001as one exit only another in the street as an exit parking only 300 they haven't given a return report from the engineer I spoke with him this morning, and he didn't Nothing has gone from the County to the people who He wanted to talk to them and you are the expert Here I think it would be working with the city at this point to see Where could those exits be? especially going down by K because it is an area Residential, I don't know if it would be. you have those conversations or staff or whoever but they would have good information on how to do that in the safer and more effective way because that Parking is in a way that not very unusual I would like those parking spaces The talks will take place because
002I guess some points for this plan. Currently we will need a study of transit That's correct, we're confirming it. verifying returning to the site plan parking that is directly from Allington was always part of the project the only parking lot that was subject to disapproval under the option number two or that they withdraw it completely in option three was the improvement of the canal Floods in the Flood Canal is what The only thing that worries us is the parking. What was on the corner was part of the project from the beginning originally And it's still in the The project stated that with the initial plan, it is parking in Atherton Allington There was no traffic study in that original plan because they didn't present it We do not accept any offers. we don't know if
003that's actually the case The civil engineer we are working with him had approached the school to the city before in the conceptual designs Yes, we have a parking near the canal flood control in the west and I was going to be there, I don't remember the name of The street is there, but that driveway... Residential, that was reviewed with the city and that They denied that the city was aware of the project that was going to They were not approving to continue. project with an exit in those areas residential and the reason why I think it's worth it. It's a shame to talk about it because that was a while ago. so long ago, more than 10 years ago once with different staff or number of students who are going to use that study Perhaps
004things would change if we did that and developing this plan perhaps in that K Hill street might be better to go until the background or that have the exit in Kel but that the experts with the safe transit of the city would be very useful the last thing I would say, 'I want to see that collaboration' that it happens and maybe that will allow us guide because I don't want to go down a path that we are planning to have these departures and then we can't Do as I mentioned. I am currently working with a civil engineer are Taking the plan as it is presented there We are doing where there are two options Possible one, the one in the corner The light between Allington and Keel and the other exit where the roundabout the
005K access of parking, those two areas are there in the site plan what is what They can do what we are telling them. presenting the county of the to jobs public by the city of Lak so that They reviewed it and I haven't received it. return report, that's something that just If it happened recently, we are in the process to follow up with that activity We will continue with the project as it is currently designed with the processing if we add the inputs or The departures will be like the plan outside site of I need to prepare better and to present to the county until we have a contractor that we can include in the The request and the contractor is the one who pays. he The fee won't happen until We are moving forward
006with the project and We can do more It won't be late on his part DSA approval. For entries of car additional information regarding technology that I was mentioning with the marker It's possible they'll give us the difference in the price and that it presents us in the Friday memorandum What would the price difference If we want to use the technology if when they give us the information to architect as I only mentioned the digital scoreboard itself alone is an increase of 75000 when we have to add is that we need to add the structure we need to put columns structures we have costs electrical things to add and also things incidental the budget that me They gave me 00,000 for the scoreboard from the football pitch American, that's one possible order will give us the
007cost possible because it has to modify the Sas agreements that He originally sent Debra because we will be including the digital markers in the agreement The following question is for the Mrs. Ares, because we are just starting This is so late, and if we know that bond has happened, we can apply so that we give the bonds that match for these projects we are indeed going to investigate the one we give to equality of We're going to try to look at those projects. We can do with that, but let's... to have with the presumption that they are not going to Oh, we're not going to give you the amount. to coincide with the We have another project. board member questions focus Thanks, one thing I haven't seen is a project timeline when we Give us
008the offers, I want them to give us the We anticipate offers and everything approved. in April only for the construction because not They can when we have the timeline When they start, what is the chronology assuming that There aren't many issues being projected which will take 9 months the control the control channel of floods while they are working on the We'll be on the Drios control channel. continuing with the other work but The stadiums will be manufacturing the stands will be built and developed. And if we are going to do all the underground work by the I think the project in the buildings If only we hadn't had so many delays that we have faced the bureaucracies involved Originally we want a project of 12 9 months months after the flood control and then Three
009months because we couldn't be in parking until they do the Flood control is the chronology that We're still seeing 12 months After they start, yes. And that's why it's that if we maintain this Offer from the end of January until the month In February we can work on the contract may grant the board may grant the contract so that it can begin construction before that date of April expiration or authorization in April so that everything is in place and ready to start immediately in the control channel of floods, what the Assumption would be like if Everything goes well for the grads who go They will graduate in 2026 Graduating in 2026 will take 12 months So the class of 2026 is going to have the first graduation in the field if We will complete the
010following in March next March, which would be the 2026 Okay Father, I don't know who to approach with that. one separate question two questions Apart from one of the things that was thinking while they were giving it to me making the presentation where they are going to train students in sports while they are doing this work where the games will be held obviously not We're going to have it on that court for We're not going to have Facebook. American races the tennis courts They won't be ready yet, but they can train That's where the students are going to go and This is not on the court. Yes, then they'll have a good court and new, but they're also going to have to give new players to this team Schoolgirl How it looks That's if there's
011anything. necessary because, as a clamor, we zaed the the sports teams that are out And in my mind I think of those of the guys and I also want to keep in mind the girls the I want to see races or possibly if we are going to give it to them or have it budget for the team so that I'm going to be able to use it on the court I'll work with the staff and I'm going to... to return with the questions for a discussion, a conversation preliminary recognizing that this topic arose from the We have to create a staff Line One lane of the properties residential areas to the south in this project and create a pedestrian crossing Where can they go to Esther Lindstrom? that's what we talked about Previously, there it
012would be. they would be practicing the teams of football, and I think I did hear that. But we were only talking about Facebook and There are so many other teams that we have that address and also attend to them and also the classes of physical education and I know we already know that I have a question, are we still... planning to do the the sign that says we're going to have instruction yes we are planning to do this at some point this Vice President Garza had some ask No, no, not at this moment. Thank you. Is there any... another actuarial question clf one question plus those lights that are so close to the Residential area. What is there a process? approval with the city or what kind of study we've done, right? we have done
013nothing study of the action at the meeting, previous meeting, highlight that there is a deadline for the lighting of the court and the lights along the lines of property in Las dos are less than one when a parking lot the Minimal laughter is of a light one foot is less light in the parking that they will get in the street on the side of the school grounds school or of the school the parking lot or parking lots They're going to have the lights but or but it only illuminates the parking lot and It's not going to light up the street for nothing, if there was one they did a study of the lighting that they part of the people who provide the poles of the lights were used in a photometric study of the entire
014area around the stadium and beyond the entire squad 10 years of schooling is a long time for talking about the same project I appreciate that you are answering all the questions I'm going to say It was for the previous meetings that didn't They continued with this project because we It's costing significantly more because The costs and everything, I'm glad we're going to keep going with this but it's very The information is important if it is from lighting or traffic we have to to be able to communicate That with the people who live there area because although the communities are They've been waiting for this for a long time and are They're excited, and many are wondering if so Or it won't happen that they see one shovel, but it's very important that Let's announce that
015there will be lights. because maybe the people who live They'll be worried about 30 feet. That's why I think there's so much noise in the stadium. We have conducted some noise studies and I want us to give them lighting residents information and let's collaborate with the city with its citizens so that that they are busy, that they are not I think calling was a comment a brief one that we can try to Talking to people, I think, would be very good Great, is there anything else? Thank you for your question. We appreciate everything. Thank you. for having us Continuing with article 3.2, the plan of supplementary retirement, ma'am, the next topic This afternoon we have J the president executive of pars The gentleman and he's going to provide the board with information on the offering
016a retirement program supplementary early retirement Good afternoons, Chairman of the Board, members My name is from the board I am the CEO of Par here to present you with information to encourage early retirement employees who are not managers I'm going to be able to answer any question that have the background meeting our company Our company has been in existence. For over 40 years our company was founded in provide early retirement services to be for all states We have made thousands of these programs of retirement early we are by John Wayne eer in Orange County, where we give all the administrative services for our programs on the next slide dream of the 350 most school districts in California that have done programs of early retirement with our company That also includes your district, which with We
017successfully implemented a plan a while ago 30 years old in 1994 and I was actually there When they tried, they adopted that plan as well. We have worked with two-thirds of the school districts in Los Angeles County Angels including some local parm and Downy unified that we have offered programs in recent times also the goal of a early retirement is to give them a information a an incentive for employees to retire earlier than They would normally have done it for this early retirement program is from try to incentivize them to the employees who have the most salary that allows them to retire earlier and that they replace that employee with a person with a lower salary like that create salary savings so that you can help pay for the cost of the program and to
018generate savings beyond for jobs that are not Managers, we are seeing a difference even from the people who are on top of the salary of those we hire Again, that's going to be the savings that They will help pay for the program When they see the savings differentials for other groups of employment but its classified employees and We administrators are not seeing that salary difference then Those plans that normally don't work in In general, what we are trying to do is for increasing four times what they give him in a year, the year they offer him early retirement program will seeing that many people are going to retire in that year and during that year our programs have been very effective for help reduce that they have to leave unemployed people when the reaction occurred
019from 2009 In 2010 we offered many of these programs retirement so they don't have to to leave people How do these programs work? Early retirement is that board authorizes the offer that a retirement conditional for the jobs that have are interested in taking The advantage of the plan is that they will give you a 45-day break. or 60 days to register. For if They want to take advantage of the program and are conditionals because the program is going to have to meet certain requirements of district for the plan to continue during those 45 to 60 day periods the employees who want to take advantage of early retirement will be presented a resignation letter irrevocable when they are going to grab the list of your jobs that interest you who are interested in the plan and
020give a calculation to the District for determine if the plan has sense of a point of operations and economic results-based who enroll in the plan and the You save the board can decide if continue with the program or can cancel program previously it has had a lot success success 95% are approved but unfortunately 5% of the programs that the districts offer cancel them because they do not meet the economic requirements and Ultimately, the operation is that district has How are they seeing the future? They want to see if it's a program that finally work for the District and Otherwise, the district can indicate that. program And if the program is terminated the people who submitted the letter of resignation during that period would automatically be terminated with respect to the incentive We have two different
021offers incentives that you may consider Districts are simply based on the retirement offers that their districts nearby businesses have offered to non-certified employees administrative scenario one is 70 of final payment scenario 2 is 65% of the payment Ultimately, what it means is that represents the cost to the district of a program in particular based on the employee's salary for doing the math if one of your employees gets 000 in If I offered you 75 million, you would take 5% of your salary. and I would multiply it by the salary and It would be 7,000 in that case, representing the cost to the District to provide that retirement incentive for that that particular employee 100,000 would be the cost, the district no pay that in a lump sum, you can divide by 5 years to give
022some savings to the district budget but with that contribution of 0.000 the District would buy a qualifying nesting the taxes for that employer. And that. It also functions as an incentive for the retirement offer and when buying the This gives the employee advantages. taxes when an employee retires They are going to meet the requirements benefits of casters what what they had the right plus the benefit of pars Then they would give him two checks of retirement incentive for pars is what that encourages people to retire in that the employee if given the opportunity. by accepting this audacity, the program of nested in the program of pars they go to be able to have the options of 14 different nesting options 14 different from monthly payments than the employee can the Which employees to notify? These
023are the options and what are they? amounts potentially if they accepted the offer of early retirement what what we want to do is to give employees more options an economic point of how help them by providing them with an incentive financial that makes the most sense for the employee and from the point of view of district the district doesn't matter that The employee chooses because the cost goes to be 65.7% but for the employee You can choose the option that has more sense financialmentor the taxes of pars We are trying to provide the retirement flexibility for the employer for this incentive program the following incentive part wanted of the potential design that your District may consider some of the presumptions that we invoice in our model to determine if a plan would be would make
024economic sense, or the plan that We have for the sides that are not administrators who are at least from 55 years old with 5 years of service The District had to comply with that milestone for June 30, 2025 to be able to participate in this program They would have to resign from their jobs. district by the end of 2024-2025 with the plan of programs don't have to retire alone He has to resign from his job. district and have the ability to work in another district and accumulate more credit services in another district but from their views of the district they already They were able to reach the top of the salary scale. to leave the District. And that can providing you with salary savings has a lot of flexibility for employment who doesn't have to
025retire but only has to resign from the job with the district What we did determine is that Yes, they will retire under the system of respective retirement this We are looking at two different plans. programs 70% or 65% of your final payment We have modeled the calculations based in both with respect to replacement of We've seen who hired the jobs district last year in non-administrative jobs if a would be replaced Furthermore, we have factored in the costs of Health. Retirement costs because That also directly impacts the savings that would occur if someone retire early on, for example, with the costs There are more costs for the District in healthcare. Because if someone leaves early It has to be older than they have that you pay for health benefits retirement so within our program We look
026at demographic data to There are a total of their certified employees of 123 employees in their District that They meet the criteria of being 55 years old and 5 years of service with the district on average their salary in excess of 0.000 of them have an average of 60 years old. Like at 24 years old experience with people who have state with its District for many years So with respect to those two different offers of retirement incentives 65 7% no We have this data. But we have Statistics on how many people have done it We think they accept about 26 employees His people would accept the 70 percent plan final payment and is slightly less than 65 We project that as many as 24 employees will They would withdraw under that particular model And one
027thing to note is that in our model that we want to be further conservative at first in our projections We can usually expect We expect up to 20 to 30% of the population He should retire in a year, but now We are using what we consider a slightly lower numbers on the spectrum But generally speaking, if more people We'll see if they participate in the savings plan. more savings District on the next page next couple of pages again est These are the anticipations we have as to what the district expects if These withdrawals and retirements happen What needs to be noted are projections. The actual savings won't be known until Let's see who really wants to Participating in this program only allows you to It gives a general idea of what It would probably happen,
028but the calculations real ones occur after the registrations when we already know the Name the salaries of the employees who participate in the program So the The way to interpret this table is to assuming a 7% final payment 26 employees who participate in the program We expect a little more in a period of 5 years of $10,000 in savings beyond what We call this natural wear and tear. We think that type of program at 70 because it makes fiscal sense for the District assuming that councils We got 26 employees to participate in the program The following sheet gives a slightly smaller projection giving data from 65, statistically less participation with 24 but in a period Over the next 5 years, we project more than 200,000 savings over a period of 5 years So We do
029this because it's a program. positive is fiscally positive for your District in the following I want to give a slide projection of timeline of what it will look like district applying the 45-day factor employee registration assuming it is a concept program that your District has an interest in having There must be a resolution from this board. must adopt to move forward with that contingency offer hypothetically that it may bring present this topic the following Thursday for the board and that opens the period of 45-day registration period time would immediately begin communicate with those employees eligible by sending them packages retirement so they know what they can do expect a retirement offer anticipated at the end of January we can to have a meeting guidance for all employees eligible to receive an idea What What are
030the options? available to them and the terms to participate and that require end of February We will hold counseling sessions. individualize go out to the place talk one individually with their employees help them fill out documents and February 28 closes the window the inscription Thus that whoever wants to participate has to submit the resignation letter to the Paris office before that date of February 28th. So we're going to be... Honestly looking at the numbers to see who is Who is eligible? Which ones? These are the possible savings and We present the information to the staff from the district to help determine if Does this case have this economically for the District that information is returned to This meeting on March 13th and the meeting us It says if we continue with the program and has
031the capacity to Cancel it, but if they continue from now on the employees would have to resign district service no later than On June 30, your District makes the first of its five pages of payments in July 10th and in August the first employees receive their first pars benefit check in addition to any benefit check which makes them eligible from the others retirement systems, that's basically it. That concludes my presentation today. I'll answer any question you have. Thank you very much, sir and colleagues. do you have I have a question like this. that we look at what if we use the 70 one He says there are about 26. And if there are 24, they can be changed. percentage or When we make the decision For 70 65 we commit not eh to Making that
032decision at the beginning is already... She remains committed to that decision. technically speaking, what does it mean if We got 24 employees when We wanted maybe 26 sometimes, depending. the type of employee who accepts that The offer may make there some benefit if one of the employees of The district accepts higher payments. We can see even more savings with this offer 24 if they are the 4 depend on the 24 the 24 I think it's a good idea for my employees. We have to do it. I'm confused about that. What percentage are you the expert on? recommend and why that Well, what I've included are two different two possible options this Ultimately, they depend on what the objectives of your District if they want try to achieve a certain number of This offer of 70
033employees would be a Good option again with a District This close friend decided that and it was a very successful offer another District offers 65% now I know I know the East district well, but not We still don't know the final result, yo yo I wish it were 55 but Generally speaking, I feel comfortable with The offer of 70 for Because I think it is A more common 65 is a little not a A round number. Let's say like 70. I think that historically we have had of the company quite successful, there is no great I think the difference is there, but it's only the incentive for people to do it so that the district can save money Absolutely correct, vice president. Yes, thank you. I think I have a few questions. The following questions
034are for the staff But if you have information Additionally, we already requested this. information previously to Let's investigate this: early retirement In previous years with the unions I thought that I wasn't part of that in the past But as I understand it verbally, it is that He looked. It was checked and it was determined that it was not. It was a cost saving for the District at that time, but as I understand it, that's looked in years Previously, we would go out and ask How many people anticipate unions Whether they take advantage of this or not, no. It's part of the process, as he put it. described if the board chooses to continue Go ahead, this will happen to you. as a topic for approval and Pars enters and they do that well Perfect, thank
035you. And I also heard of... that there are additional benefits that the The district would have to pay part of our employees who decide take this plan for benefits after the withdrawal we can fulfill those responsibilities if those responsibilities would be ours by anyone who is withdraw by offering this program or not that profits may increase well-being at this moment at the beginning But we are very confident about it. other other post-benefit account We have the funds for retirement. support all employees who can withdraw or retire in that way Well, thank you, I think that's one small clarification You said which is good for the end of June 30th 2025 that any of those employees Those who decide to take this plan would have to submit your notice of resignation but Then in the other
036timeline, it gave a one that closes the registration date April 28th, well, the letter was sorry before February 28, sorry, this has to submit the resignation letter But the the true date of the resignation is on the last day of the school calendar, uh, I think that's it the date shown on the letter resignation to be the last day of the year The last day of the school year is June 30th. So to make sure To be in the program, they have to comply with the deadline of the 28th February, yes, to enter a letter of irrevocable resignation that is part of that The program presents the letter on the 28th. February and on March 13 the date that the board makes decision to approve or reject the program assuming it wants approve the plan
037that all those letters resignations are made effectively legal this and the resignation itself takes place last day of the school year is for our directors and the staff fields Schoolchildren ask teachers to give them This information about your year about His future plans are indeed that S They're going to stay with us, they're going to move on to a different district, good in Science, this gives them an agreement tentative that happens at the end of May It would happen before Tom takes his place That's not necessary, we don't need to move that date then correct No, those are all the questions I have. From this moment on, many Thank you, I have one more question, just for... be transparent to teachers and employees, is there any difference between a teacher, if you're taking this as
038a... retire instead withdraw if I know that when I am in This district has bordering the health benefits we are talking about with the teachers about this in the program of pars the only thing we are looking for We are looking for a job resignation and that This gives them eligibility to receive this monthly benefit of pars for the District, we offer the continuation of health benefits until it retire completely, whether with Stars or pers It depends on which plan it belongs to. employee So yes, of course. Do you want to continue if you want to retire and receiving health benefits still has that resign under the program or system sts or pers if you want to go to work for the Down District and simply resign then then this No. So they no longer
039follow or they discard it. obtain your retirement benefits from Health if they want to move to another job District, so that's why we see that the most of the employees, most of the employees retire and They remove them completely, they cover them completely, but that is not always the case bufi Thank you for being here for We made this clarification an employee benefits survey classified and administrative Yes when We look at each one. employees including classified management teachers all administration demographic This hiring trends and others employment groups had none Tax savings as we saw by the I see and understand the teachers' side. with the registrations that are lowering the staff adjustment that We have to do it, but if we talk about the percentage by which one to decide to see how many people
040uh, do they accept this one? Which number? We are looking for what, how many, so that Let's go for this plan looking towards an economic goal, eh with the wish that 26 individuals retire, resign, but point that those individuals are in the system and if the board decides To approve this, we look at the numbers of registration and I see that I know of those 26 Of those 26, how many more do you have? that's why we looked at the sheet to hire What do you see if... How does it look if you only have that hire 75 percent of people that Which ones are coming out this week or 15? What are they? numbers, but if you look at the numbers for See the savings if you have to hire We're not saving much
041at all. I believe it's an important estimate of what would we be hiring for after the retirees leave to determine the estimated savings what we have is of 50% and sorry, let me correct myself, 75% correct lady That's correct, our estimate is We anticipate between 75 and 80%. we are starting to see now the role that registrations have This next year the loss that students that we have been having in these last few years and we take into account How many teachers do we need this year? that comes. And it is that when the two are put together information from and and and and grab the information from pars we can follow go ahead and we will also have the information on how much we anticipate having in terms of the number of teachers and
042we can use the factors to determine Well, thank you, there is a reduction of About four or five teachers then in In total, yes, that's how we are. Seeing as 75, so it would be like 5 six out of 24 teachers that we wouldn't have that this contact again cu cco six teachers So again if we look our trends and determine that that we need, we would need less teachers, that results in more savings. So We are giving the range of 75 per So out of 24 teachers, six don't We would have to contact them again, and there We started and as I said, these are... simultaneous when we look at the trends this registrations this salons for next year, that aid because if we see a difference savings of 2 million in 5 years
043plus CCA That makes the difference if it is Closer to 6 million. But if it's 75 We are looking at a savings of 3 millions in either of these two plans as you are reading correctly Yes in In a period of 5 years. Yes, well, this one is. We're moving forward with at least the investigation of How many people want are willing want to do and the board decides that they are not there numbers What is the cost of doing the Study: What is the cost to start? this way The company would charge him $500 the District if you cancel it Well Thanks, any other thanks? So I think that's what What we need now is a little bit of direction that if we want to do this and at what percentage if each of
044Let us express our opinions on the topic I Vice President gars la I'll put it in everyone's sights and let it begin Well, I think 70% This would be more appealing to the staff Hopefully they'll start the project and we can then move on. I think that the 70 per member centron I think it's a good idea that at least evaluate and see This is the beginning of the journey to see how it will be The more benefits you look at, the more they will always be. better [Music] I especially think about how hard Teachers should receive bonuses. additional in some way and style to cu to take advantage and and So I would at least like to receive to do the evaluation when it is an evaluation So what does that mean, at least?
045to begin, to begin this program and Okay. And what percentage do you think that...? We must begin at 65 70 I want to think about it a little more and I'll come back With you, I do believe I'm looking at the numbers So give me a second I'll I say Kitfield, I feel comfortable watching How many people want to do this? me The concern is that hiring teachers is a That sometimes makes me worried. Sometimes we do need them, but outside of that I'm fine with 70 and... We see how many people decide to do it I definitely want to do it now. Whatever 70 sounds good, but We need to ask you, sir. This varas. Which one are you? Is the CPO which one? That's your opinion of me, given the fact that We
046have the ability to look at the program Look at the dollars when it is already I think they reveal that starting with the model of 70 as suggested would be fine So you with that? Then yes, thank you for Asking "Well, thank you" sounds like... We have a good consensus, we'll return with The lady centr Yes let's do the 70 but no also for This recap of what it says is one of The facts this How many teachers They would take advantage of this. What are we? looking at new hiring and for me, my return to my I like the original comment situation of the Bond the situation of the Bonuses when we try to recruit more teachers, well, have this thing additional there for Hey probably Well, it makes people come. that they are
047retiring alone. Yes, I know, no. It's for regular teachers, but... There will be enough additional money to be able to Accessing it wouldn't be something that perhaps they possibly uh, could they decide to have this too registering is that per lo did it ago two years and they have done it, they are doing this year also twice because it is quite beneficial some Another good comment sounds like... We have your address, we want to follow it. We'll look ahead, uh, at them with the 70 Well, it will be an agenda item. next week Thank you very much for your We greatly appreciate the presentation. we need a break we want go ahead Brad, we'll keep going Okay, let's go. take 5 minutes of quick break, we'll be back this We will meet again at 5:30
048The session is adjourned and we will continue to our latest article 3.3 the transport verification program Timothy F is here with us from Student transportation LLC is going to give the report to the board of a scheme that was completed with the transportation services Transportation information sir president and the school board is a It's a pleasure to be here, I also wanted to say to you. give notice before we start current contract under the scope of project that we are going to present if I could familiarize myself with the district for a a year and a half under the leadership of business understanding the understanding of The one who portions the servants report This is quite data-driven So I don't want to review too quickly if He wants me to go further if I have
049more space. I have references for your convenience references while we are but essentially the background study On October 24, the district brought closer to pti and requested a delivery of a system of alternative delivery an evaluation but If we brought the model to the district, how We would look at what the challenges and the pros would be. the cons, the cost, and so on when doing it we focus heavily on nuos services that it does carry out district internment and is maintenance There are six vehicles. devices dedicated to those steps the report It has five sections for its reference the first being the summary executive Please read it, and it's heavy on the details the services of transportation to students It is important that the board knows about current events also all districts in the
050state is different and the transportation of the Students, it's a challenge to know how my neighbor... It has lower control funds. It's important to read the background information there. analysis of current contracts with its external services which are also a non-profit foundation and the alternative models of evaluation and The costs and also an opinion on those evaluations also the current services of Students and services and costs as a reference point it receives 1 one and a half million dollars history people who come from backgrounds are buried under local funds but It has a transportation label It requires maintenance effort if not spend even that much in the current year He will only receive what is his portion The following year is difficult to explain Why is that? historical state funds that is up to age
05120 and the educational code I have been in the business for 42 years new laws that brought a 60 percent increase income not in addition to the total state it has been more the I think it's the injection increase that they have shared with us those costs have to be 36,000 identified or not counted I'd like to share with you why it's so important. important as a separate thing in the 90s and in the 2000s until the century going up going down through the state protect General Education transport that many districts did is They split the costs like an assistant instructional that is also assigned to be a truck assistant Those costs are buried, or the percentage That salary's benefits cannot be traced We didn't do function 36,000. in-depth research in this area I didn't
052see anything that stood out about their expenses. would have captured it but it's a reminder to the district and the board so that they understand the expenses for the The year 2022-23 was reported as slightly more $3 billion. That's the a point of reference because it was the year of current reports from the state He always receives the funds the year he does. It continues and takes two years to update them. We use that as a very important criterion. objective because it is a fixed sum. restio can receive is 1,162 per year 2324 and continuing with the expenses be in function 3600 the district has not anticipated a budget for the year current of almost 4 million dollars a A little more than an increase, but not us Our opinion and our The calculations are
053a little further down. of the state average in controlling Those costs, that's the reason why and the increased labor costs and the constant supplies and the continuous list and costs of the transportation district is something to hold here for the meeting is around 7702 per student is a little more Since we are using the figures from 2000 2023 and 2024 are in the average of status per student by transportation if we have the assistance We make the anilis for them we use the same equation to calculate that as well And school services, that's very much a a very competitive figure in its current form good transport done their services is hem unified School District is a service a very unique and one service provider that they took quite a bit of advantage of The reason
054is because they are a contract. cooperative with you and the rate and the costs and everything are current similar to yours If they were operating a system when They want to do jobs or Cooperatives are not done aggressively by the state but most districts get Take advantage of that arrangement because they they can come and have to compete better than a external contractor for profit It's not a topic for discussion today because Hem informed the District in the last years that they have to leave Withdrawing that support seems very likely. very much finished by the current year understanding a little more about their current services hem reports that they are operating 12 truck routes and leading to carry out activities and they're programmed for that thing if not They are using the HMET Unifier on
055the truck. the district is providing transport to 263 students that Data It was reported to us from contract provider is not confirmed with data from the District because there was a 15% difference they can There are many reasons for that, but it's because in the field of Special Education we were with the highest figure approximately 139 of the students are from Education general and 124 of those receive transportation as a service under the Individualized Education Plan in Hemet, a subcontract that I will explain later or a TNC vehicle that is another contract or by parents or different contracts that we will address later in he report as I said that helmet increases the district to use St which is a contract for the purpose of I believe the profits are national, but because They're not
056even on the west coast They are well known and do a good job And hem is doing that, they're doing for increase and in an effort to help District to carry out the transportation for this year and next year past because they have been in the middle to decide if they could continue the service or not they continued continuing with the districts to the TNC company has one in the district and it is not Hemet It is Bellflower that contracts with the network which is called TNC, is Hops Drive, is a of a Lots of good companies to work for The companies themselves are expensive, and the reason why That means he doesn't want them to be a alternative permanent but they do fit a good option for students who are isolated outside the district
057to the location of your program Or perhaps inside the district but the children They have needs that bring them out the numbers of the normal truck Students who have hsp Drive are not alarming, we use a figure of 5% if It's exceeding 5% of the TNC, they're going to want to investigate it because the cost of Transportation is quite expensive, isn't it? one negative thing does take place in the Entrego system also the district Internally hiring, this is quite impressive with 62 parents and guardians to give for there transport under the educational code in see the refund of Instead of transporting u, there may be any background with that or what The parents pay, I know it's more than the one Figure per mile Beyond what it gives IRS, however, we would share with you
058who the more contracts that they can arrange with The parents were the most transportation competitive depending on what it is That figure is quite high. the number of students they have hem notified the District in 202223 that go to stop their services obviously continued for that year and the year and this current year I think which is well understood that we sit in the It's very clear to me that the table with Hemet is very clear that They will need to suspend the services at the end of the school year no I was clear about who I spoke to, whether yes or no. The extended school year could help. for this summer it would be Enjoy your meal if you can continue with that service PT could not identify specifically the contract formula for hamet
059and I don't necessarily want They're alarmed, but it's not a service. competitive that sets a daily rate weekly rate other things they formulate the cost of an external contract is a cooperative contract I imagine that in the time the contract was held me I imagine there's a document, a service a 3 to 6% climber in that, although not We were able to find it and substantiate the figure that we are projecting of 900 million is from invoices we saw which were identical each month we simply multiply them by 12 12 years no 12 years 12 months that will probably be 2.9 a A little high because the services are going to volume drop in both hands summer due to the extended school year fewer students on the routes School buses have to be inspected every
06045 days or every 3000 million vehicle maintenance we are going to Start with this because they are the criteria objective for evaluation and are the best business practices business practices This is a legal requirement that it has for the trucks and no, no, that would be good practice but not requirement legally the district has a satisfactory type to the board is it satisfactory or unsatisfactory It has the highest rating that they can offer and have had it for the recent years 98 for others vehicles and equipment that are not of district I have to use approximately quite a lot for the upcoming devices Because we don't have electronic data. or to drag to the school trucks to give an example of the maintenance team What the district is supporting I think having 32 school buses
061We have 33, one is not operating, maybe to be more than that the district lacks the robust programs to use for tracking and perform preventable maintenance and repair orders, things that I'm going to They're going to talk, they'll come back for the technology to track the costs of district operational costs we prefer to make our recommendation to understand What is the vehicle operating cost? and not a total cost, which is what it is increasing the cost of your supplier of external or internal services of the Truck drivers It's a bit difficult the figure I showed him 11,700 per student, that was taking the sum of the entire budget of transportation And dividing it, yes, there is a program that they do have in the department that explained it to us Historically they haven't used it
062and it has certain shortcomings for the need of department and staff and we are from agreement with We cannot identify parts of that. inventories or maintenance system preventive or if a list if a vehicle no It's working, I'm going to take some pictures. These things, because it's not that they have less important things, but why? understand the importance under the code educational title 13 certain requirements my examples will be specific to a school bus Because that's what we're talking about here when we don't see evidence of a list that are out of service that an operator He has a truck that doesn't work because has a critical defect or something security. Or it could be something about not. security that Ne is paying attention and is It points to what an inspection report indicates. inspection
063or Preview the chip they'll want to see No necessarily during your annual review of the school trucks but if Is there a truck incident or if There is a catastrophic incident that It involves a student; there is proof. that there was a missing component in They're going to check if a school bus was there. Known When was the last Preventive maintenance was and if not You can find it there, you'll see number 45 day the inspection of 45 days or 3000 molas and if they didn't write it down And if they did, why What if it happened on the way, they're going to see the The driver's TV is looking for a for to trace from the operator's point He claimed there was a problem with the truck and during the inspection that a The
064district mechanic had a problem They documented it with the truck and They scheduled it to be repaired later They will see a work order if one exists. What part did they fix it for? What materials did they use to repair it? And what did they use? The mechanic did the repair and it They present that again, they communicate it. I somehow return to the supplier Truck Driver Services They're going to notify. So, it's possible. trace with documents that they did make I'm not going to go over all the repairs. Unless you ask me about things But I want to give you some examples. district does not have a process for replacing tires of the truck vehicle the district It has enough, it won't wear one out tire in the mileage that puts it but however
065such as operating our own vehicles But he doesn't want a tire there that has more than 5 years, I'm not saying yes or It doesn't have it, but it doesn't have the evidence of to be able to inform you that there is a current program that they are reviewing This is easy to fix. I gave him repair records An example of that, and I want them to... people understand that because it's a This is a very, very serious matter; he wants it in everything. your district fleet to protect your investment, I'm going to get ahead of myself a little and put it in terms of your own car You buy a new vehicle. You have a factory recommendation Prevention requires maintaining Preventive measures separated by repairs in The toor camera would perhaps be the first
066service at 10,000 or 20,000 miles such This time it has its second maintenance prevention at the 40-mile third to 75,000 miles and another around 100 or 120 miles if you see the recommendations of manufacturer By the way, service I would recommend that certain things have that performing certain services will cost plus certain services are going to be more to take more time and the parties and That's why we can't track things in the moment in the district in the best practices that are we cannot find current ones there evidence of useful vehicles such as golf carts, we're looking at everything What do we do, PTI, when we... We're talking about transportations, but We are looking at all the maintenance of vehicle programs also support vehicles and other things like golf carts and whatnot I'm not
067going to spend much time on that. because it is not directly related with the thing in We cannot determine the tank CNG for school buses, that's it. legally required depending on the of the mileage that the vehicles have Those tanks have to be inspected every year or every TR years the labels have to be we can see that the label did indeed point towards down and not Hidden is fairly regulated Normally, CHP would be looking at that. also several visual inspections and vehicle inspections quite a few You can see, I think there are about 30 36 the happy facilities to the District I'm usually in a tent on The district has a building that is very well updated, very well equipped The workshop has five spaces for the vehicle and has a rotary for the
068in the floor or flat work surfaces due to the size of the workshop operational and accessible is quite enough for the size of the district's fleet We know that the inspections of the the elevators were inspected But I think they were a few days late. months of disorganization, there are many photos You can see them in the report; those are Easily addressed is organizing the parts the inventory what they have Using technology will help a lot In this area I want to give you a for example, because we do a great thing in the report to control the costs to the District if you have five oil filters for certain Certain things can to be in a small truck, a truck It's great when the mechanic brings that vehicle and is doing 45 days or
0693,000 pots, an inspection or changing the seven he or she would identify the parties in the order They work and are taken out of the District electronically controlled and is keeping the necessary parts and replace the oldest parts with the new ones so they can put them in the shelves when we don't have that, it's not different than you and I looking for that can of corn if we don't have it we'll Buying another can of corn is the... The best way I can explain it is a bigger thing than if we see disorganization or that the inventory It has quite a few different ones parts of the workshop They can do it Clean up for a few months and they can address that But that's the importance of what I want Make a comment
070about where they charge the batteries when charging the batteries batteries inside because they have a frame of The metal batteries are charging can someone Harming the supplier can give you the Free is better practices the structures to give DJ gasoline The monitoring system of C has one called casasp for monitoring the levels of thiazole and of gasoline, we understand that the tanks that They are not buried, perhaps they were That's why they didn't have license plates, if you see that the one with gasoline is also It needs to have the labels and the Yellow things can't smoke in the area is one thing of ordering the best practices the the The district works so hard and strives as harsh as in the South districts Coast in the 90s became the most that they could do
071almost everything with Natural Gas I did in my own organization in Power UniFi requires a lot of money and effort. And now essentially everything is going to be going to go out but in doing that there are many Best practices are difficult to maintain items such as electric vehicles They have to give gasoline at the tower or at The parking lot needs to be very... be careful with the lines of c&g without the protection or the thing re is not working, it has to have the fire suppression system proper labeling and turning off He has to give attention. Ne This area is good for best practices We again identified this compliance environmental waste requirements This is girly stuff, this is too needs attention can We cannot identify that we can fix it. He had a
072system, this system of environmental reports suggest that They have one but during our time at the place The staff were unaware. that we weren't talking to the individual correct in terms of maintenance vehicles and recommendations from I put recommendations for vehicle fleets I put the slide up for you to see. may Find good ones now in models of delivery option I created three options for you to consider. district but there are like four option one It has two pieces depending on how you look at it. Look, option one is internal services internal and external resources that are provided with or without vehicle maintenance from the district doesn't mean it's going to Paying for system maintenance is not the that we recommend but the fleet of buses, this has very little to do with it with
073the best business practices that What we report has more to do with what He's doing this in the district with uh Replacing their vehicles and the costs that this system uses the This proportion is the transport plan external It is according to using a bidding process external maintaining the buses the district or that the contractor us provide a fleet of buses in consideration of this model the district if You Choose using an internal system they offer maintenance: pay close attention the replacement needs and the associated costs conal project expenses for option one is an external provider but using the That district's fleet is another one service provider which illicit This is the budget with budget without You might get some bonuses but we don't know how much but we are seeing how $6.2 million and
074you pay those buses this with the budget of The district has to be done within a year. Well, no, but we suggest to the District that are way behind on those in apply for those vehicle vouchers The electrical district shares With this account, there are many factors that They are calculated when those bonds are taken. But they are either requested. But the more bonuses are requested, the better. you can request you can get up to 100% 25% of the cost but we hit the worst of the reported cases of that type service provider expenses supervisory district as 2.2 to 2.7 millions cost for a district of your heat of Despite their size, they maintain their fleet of of vehicles giving this minimal maintenance and personnel minimum. And that's what it is. He thinks he can
075spend this... Total expenses for option one of 8.5 to 9 million dollars, huh, when the district takes care of the system internally projected expenses for This one with the contractor with the buses of them maintenance team for maintain those buses the alternative service model external is from 4.7 to 5.5 million with personal administrative assistant of district 54000 service provider and district support expenses 2.2 to 2.7 million in expenses, a total expenditure from 8.5 to 9 million adding the 43 benefits per uh that are like 24,000 this health and wellness as 18,000 for district staff total cost of option one with external fleet provided from 48 4.8 to 5.6 millions option two is one of authority of joint transport powers for There are no schools with nearby districts We don't have this projected expense idea of
076knowing who they might be those partners, but we gave it to him nonetheless. very detailed instruction on the legal preparations for that, uh, I know is creating a GPA by participating in GPA has already done it, JPA, but there's still time. deadline for submitting applications and There are formal ways to do it; it's cooperative. It's not like Hemet's, but it's more... more important because it is formal We recommend the most successful Ah It Is when There are two or What else can I see in the state we don't have none in Southern California large were they from Merch Insurance or uh this the El Monte Preparatory School and Elementary School Monterrey Rosm District in its services this they identified their contractor and hamet is because they historically they do things well in where this were
077in their place one The cooperative was 45 years old and is now being undone. 2 years ago due to an incident tragically they decided to scatter Freso is JPA with 17 schools and there are another group of small jpa of 3 cu districts mainly in the area of the Bay and a couple of areas south of it premises of educational plans but none projected cost for those options 3 This part of the district is internally the owner of the transportation program and operates in this bellflower model This makes the transition to a program operated entirely by the district fleet fleet maintenance vehicles personnel using the drivers to management district instructor dispatchers Everything is in the district report I would have to hire services from transport in our opinion up to the time for the district
078to have the routes appropriately designated This is a great topic, I want to talking about this to get to the conclusion project spending for a internal district program salary 150 for supervisor an assistant payroll administrator 54,000 route planner dispatcher Two individuals. Why 14 routes? 147000 The route starts earlier and ends Then the transport routes. So We put two people on the payroll. of 147000 combined this 14 drivers of buses like 70 7523 drivers who are replacing as 161,000 benefit from salaries as well as like 5 75000 and other health services and well-being of others 396000 the figure comes out at 6 million pun2 for replacement and purchase without bonds that We believe it is the one for the District as the That's what "elephant in the corner" means. replacing this program internally handled transport this
079opinion that best interests of East district in terms of costs I support the time and ease of manage the system a program of This transport has responsibility for to maintain with all due consideration and requirements in having seen for 42 years These issues carry a lot of responsibility. Federal, that's why we talk a lot about it The workshop requires attention that needs to be given put in place to support and replace that fleet do what the resources board environmental California is against you This one with all the costs, this one that there are for the maintenance team this We assume they can decide any either way, but either stay in the condition they are looking for this external provider that they no longer have With unified h they can do that. Search for a arrangement
080that when they go out Elicitar, looking for a supplier that puts buses and drivers or Search that tender in such a way that the district continues to maintain the fleet But if you can't handle the replacement for the the district will then have a fleet They could have a contractor who a contract that allows you to have the supplier increase it with the fleet of It doesn't mean he has to stay. In that position you can also achieve some bonds or grants for buses withdraw from that contract and maintain the balance with whichever is more Comfortable, but what I want to tell you here read them word for word, points two and point 2.3 in the response to the goal of to have zero carbon emissions after 2025 is the requirement that there should not
081be This impacts the fleet from you and to me and to you. So that the fleet replacement challenge This has the requirements of c zb electric vehicles that, starting from January 1st of this year 2024 has to be 2027 Sorry, it has to be 50% of the The vehicles they buy must be electrical and January 1, 2027 Sorry are 100% Ah, maybe look at that and say Maybe It's not fair, he just said 20 35 but it's There is one more set of requirements such as Public fleet to ensure that you reach the zero emissions rate. If he's looking for something now, it has to be a bus that is zero missions or electric and without knowing if the district will succeed in obtaining vouchers and subsidies enough to modernize electric vehicles and the infrastructure
082related to maintaining a program and a fleet like that district did not participate in the most recent this grants for these funds and there will be another chance and I'm confident that he will get some buses but not him I can say that it will be successful to achieve 100% Compensating for those buses could be 40 50% of state bonds but you're going to have to But pay the maintenance for the rest can also group grants with money for electric buses now maybe five that they can get now and increase the number of electric buses that enter the Yardage can accumulate them, but not we have a way of this project that but and no way of project it in a early quear with the the contractors with the trucks the other Something that worries
083us a lot is the transition the transition time if it goes independent, we are in a shortage of truck drivers When I was in P for 33 today we offered we had very lucrative contracts fairly high-end feature packages and it didn't have more than 5% we're noticing Ah a year or two before the pandemic that we were increasing as around of 15% and what had to do with those with More strict regulations recruitment, what it had to fulfill with that driver in the Federal standard Drugs and alcohol, it's all a bit sad But everything had to be done; we had 10 drivers and We were lucky if we got 10. then with the pandemic and going out The pandemic is affecting us like contracts. that we are currently submitting because of the The first time
084they have to be like a external provider to create the model shared service or by districts very small is moving the trucks which are called passenger vehicles, no formed but regulated no they are not We wouldn't recommend it for such small children. That would be one option for education. students with special educational needs certain code requirements but not We think it's an option they can to confront in order to move the numbers of students who are facing We want that recruitment of drivers we cannot say for sure with the Hemet drivers would love to come and take the position in Bellflower nor We know if those drivers who perhaps They have employment with Bellflower, which they Are they compensating in hamet or how many of their drivers, what we understand of hamet They are increasing
085with several drivers not many, but several drivers who are coming from the region of Hamet. Up to here because historically it has not I don't know if this complete time is in the the district's forecast we have a lot There's concern there, but the big thing is that the fleet and what I think it would be the basis of managing your perspective I think this is my last device. everything I have and I'm going to answer I asked you. Thank you before. Let's open this one for questions I have one, we have three options: one, two and three, but we haven't spoken to two of them. no partner this nad with naden has Spoken is not an option. So if it is Speaking of JPA, we need quite a lot time to go out and
086communicate with others entities and find out if they are interested partner with us either as a JPA as mentioned or another District for in your opinion, to create a JPA from scratch I'm not sure how I'm an expert because she's... in the presentation if it is not an option how long does it take to do That's in the presentation because it was in the staff's interest when We were previously involved. And yes we consider it as an option This is reasonable, but we cannot Showing the costs is important. We want to direct staff to do that. How long does it take to make one? an evaluation can however, getting information quickly We view this as a situation of emergency that needs a provider for this coming year, one way or another JP can take from
087TR to 5 years West Sonom JPA hired the executive manager 4 years and a half before opening the doors county this Southwest Transportation this me He said today that they were in talks with Ya They've been in talks for 6 years already. I can are joining one two three four 5 business partners near you no They must be adjacent to their physical limits but they have to to be in a position where they will benefit one another with that association with common need. So size with the eh and common needs there are savings if the It's a very viable option if they can But there are others, the problem is... that there are five boards and superintendents And now someone is telling them what to do. hours The bell rings some want leave at 8:00
088or 8:30 this different time In those steps everyone can to cope, but that's the reason why which price this isn't there because It has a very involved evaluation profound and we will have to conclude the same Even if we did what I'm saying saying already if he decides to go internal to decide internal needs an external provider to help him from one to five years old, just like me That's quite worrying if the district wants to do it internally so find an external supplier who comes and is interested in bidding on a one, two, or three-year contract is not Impossible, but I work with two. Your neighbors right now it's something nearby and are looking in terms long and one already backed out that There is one bidder left, I appreciate this, I know This
089started in October 2024 but This conversation is already many years old. In our district, it's something that... We should have been more like that prepared but I'm going to open it to my Colleagues, regarding kfi questions Well, I have quite a few Thank you for being here. Here's a very comprehensive report. I was pleased. Reading it was very Impressive, awesome. Sorry, this wanna begin I have quite a few notes So there was I asked information on previous personnel any criticism of the record of These are the ones, nobody is here for them Yes, but who was giving that information that the board was given pretty bad when it started comparison so much of this is This board is new. For example, we don't know. He said we have 600 students this transporting in buses at
090a meeting I think there are more educational options. near 263 I can tell you that there is some variation in those 263 but not in routes But this one makes more sense, God. 263 189 general education and 124 of education special we didn't say I don't think we said Who uses the Hub skip Drive system, I think? I don't have that in the report. I don't know, maybe, I'm not sure. I saw it. If it's not there, I'll find out. That's the most expensive one. I don't apologize if we didn't put it in the report, but it wasn't a number alarming, I mean not everything, but we looked at the 5% of the total, close to That's why we have 62 parents who opted or who They transport and uh, the costs of G, I'll
091tell you Do a little. Have a little bit of smallness. We'll be with you very briefly. talking about how Gemen can no longer continue with services we We left them, not the other way around. I know they are small things but That contract started to increase quite a bit and Questions arose and suddenly there are saying they can't do it anymore but it's From the costs I understand the President Stuart says there's plenty history on this topic and the way that This whole conversation started. How was it? which is that we did everything internally Yes, that's correct, many years ago. Yes, I requested information about our cost when we did it internally and We moved away from that, and the reason why which was to save costs in that regard. hire with Hemet and look
092at this table We saved money for two years over the course of 7 years. then we're spending more money on Hemet, yes, when he was an intern. So that I have that information or ha Lost if you ask me, we'll investigate a little bit of that, what I don't We have the costs increasing in terms of maintenance drivers' wage increase and I will try to find the benefits document to which it refers and I will try to retro Well, I'll do my best. to obtain retroactive information there is examples you can look at in the state This is not an unusual program size. I have some information about that program. But that contact started in 2011 or 2012, something like that. So I think that with H's contact He began. I want to say a
093little more. after but we continue services with PTI because This type of investigation. So that's it. Definitely something we can... Well that We've done about 300 this year evaluations in 25-30 years in the state We saw quite a few districts moving around Labor costs. We have to be honest. It affected Ada's student services and the districts were closing these things No demanded not because they save taste but because There were transport mandates That's why they started to rise. costs, so I'd be interested in that information and also when we talk about the expenses to internalize for to do the program internally I know internally that there is a larger number because it includes the replacement of buses but the buses would not currently be By 2035 we have to get rid of them and get
094new ones, good when we're looking at the general costs, a couple of questions Regarding this, I'm talking about bus replacements. You mentioned it's a great thing we have I think two to four electric buses that there are five electric in the next 10 years we could Replace those. Search this funds. This We are looking for someone who knows Get funding and grants, that's good. It's the biggest cost I see and This is true, but 6 million is for buses in the current 10 years of 10 years that we have done some Investments in this direction We're going to the beginning of the Last year we made a hire for transport transportation say it again sorry what not We pretended not to contact someone additional transportation costs transportation to talk about this topic To address this
095issue, I think we have a staff member who was there but in another classification perhaps we are identifying the classification but this person of staff the staff has not increased in terms of trans good transportation Uh, regarding the workshop that's there How many, how much have we, how much are we How many bus drivers are there? I know that there are staff who are using Drivers? Well, there are mechanics who know. This driving mechanics They drive, they are mechanical drivers mechanical drivers as I understand there are zero Bus driver jobs yes That's correct, those employees can drive. the buses but then they don't go We consider working on vehicles that those employees are Ours are replacements because as support but they are not this drivers there is a front that the district pays 50% because
096he is a data technician who I believe and 50% Hemet pays But The budget currently does not identify Specifically, some other, uh, staff dedicated transportation but it is not It's not unusual because everything is There are some conglomerates assigned and there is one that looks like a mechanic which Pero drives and another driver of buses that it does operate But there are precautions to that, but a administrative assistant is someone already The employee would be a new hire. The people who have it now are not part of our task but I think it classifies as a somewhat technical data technician It's strange for us, but those people I think if you want to compare, it's closer to the administrative assistant in payroll the route planner despiser the The person who is doing the work is
097Who is he referring to there, if he wants to See 67,000 before uh before the benefits of the costs and benefits of health and welfare are already being paid, we have a person we are paying for that So, well, I am what I am Looking at it, what is the cost? current so that it is internal already factoring in what we are already paying and long-term investment with the 10-year-old buses and I think so You return to option one costs Thanks a long way back projected spending there I think this can to be what you are asking the service provider plus the following cost That might help answer that. The assistant has a question. administrative staff of the district person we are talking and then he has Well, if you're asking which one, I would
098have to. That's the cost, I'd say from 4.8 to 5.6 millions this brings up a piece of data Very important about the fleet is a a very important thing that needs to be Considering this, the district has a full CNG fleet if something happens now this very, very big and these costs are no longer There are those parts. The costs I have are 40%. of 200 buses and prematurely We had to replace about 60 with because we simply can't get it There is no such support in California. that it will receive some subsidies subsidies of 100% 75% 50% 25% But the district is going to have to have... It's going to be a big blow, what's going to happen I imagine it depends on the mileage of that gas fleet this is going to having
099to put in some dollars to maintain that fleet because we are in 4 4.8 5.6 as a cost reference Because those external services without including in The external fleet went up, maybe it's not the The best example to use, but the cost of The contractor kept raising the price. contractor because he no longer brings the driver but also the bus and They are supposedly going to require that keep the bus that the 2.7 is not 4.8 Okay, well, the cost In general, for us it would be like what we are paying Now without the good fleet replacement dealing with the buses with that timeline and President Stu and I We went to the yard yesterday It seems that what I observed was that still We can get parts up to 20-35 This comings is not
100the only manufacturer CNG engines in the country coming to It stopped a year and a half ago. treat to take the engine to California because of the reduction of emissions that had as requirement in California. So no They could win. So if they can find diesel or compression buses natural gas, that's why I tell you to buy it the plus the highest number of buses gasoline because after 20-35 they can continue operating what you have in place but he won't be able to replace it with the same type of fuel so For example, if it has, if here it has you a sum of money PTI asks what we should buy, not him We now say that it should be 100% vehicle electric but rather like 80% for a Unified district 20-30% by bus fossil
101fuel fuel because has to students that have to take 150 miles from the place. So this The scenario does change, I think, depending on the the time we are in and the costs of electric buses to replace Now, regarding the cost of electricity in the 20 35 can be significantly this The cost is different. So one ask plus the cost if we put the factor We're going to keep those buses Let's say we hire someone who is write to write to get subsidies if we add, uh, if we remove the cost of replacing the buses how much you would say that is as soon as to have suppliers like we have I've been doing this, I'm going to pay between the 15th and 18th. for more with the supplier that we do in our analyses
102and that is the The answer to the question depends on how bellflower Look, that brings, takes away responsibility of classified personnel that needs to be maintained initially not n more recruiting drivers and it's not That task is easy, we have 20-30 clients which are those that have contractors and I think that only one has all the There are staffed routes and programs available. that are needed has a of General Education that takes a lot It's very heavy, you shouldn't give it to him service to that to that to that population of But you can get the students from students drivers there but in the others districts that are doing this will use to support staff who are also drivers and other maintenance personnel I'm going to tell him that you can't do that. with the
103maintenance program of vehicles Now there is a lot of information about which one he has to pay attention to The topic can be addressed, but it's a The problem is that he doesn't want those individuals They're driving when they have buses. that do not have inspection 45 days 3000 miles don't want that mechanic who drives driving When you have that other one I want to give you that precaution as a requirement. Thank you for clarifying that, sir. He asked if we're hiring anyone that knows how to write This is not for getting grants We're hiring, I don't want to, it's not that We're going to hire him, I understand. limited quantity situation bus drivers but I am Wanting to understand, we have the fleet either our own or we have partners, there is one lack
104of bus drivers of all ways yes the only challenge that has changed post-pandemic don't ask me Why is it after the pandemic? Private contractors may or may not They are typically paying the amount typically so typically that they can can receive To offer someone like Hemet this larger contracts as if you leave to tender the contacts that will enter They're going to be the most competitive. one by one. This is what it has. Floating St this t a local yard the others who also want to keep their employed personnel and wages of They, the tall ones, have more money, let's say. to hire drivers also I can point you to contractors who have This is also a reduction in drivers. with one of the clients and a reason why which hem is changing its model
105a Little is due to associations that could not This has the drivers enough because there are needs of special education and as a result They wanted to take more risks than the safest option So it's not one, but two outside contractors in case someone doesn't It works, they can use the other one. That's it. It's better to manage, or rather, have two contractors in order to fulfill the requirement some This question is for the staff seems to be approximately We are transporting 139 students from General education And I've probably already mentioned it. previously, but what are the reasons that we are transporting to a general education to different groups Basically, it's about the distance from the... where they live to the school they are attending, I see that I see that he means There was
106also an offer of program when we close a program in a school and we transferred to the program other school that had a great impact The distance to schools is when We have to put them in other schools Because we don't have the space in a current school that, as you know, is based in the registrations that are decreasing That's what we are One could say that doing so as well We need to figure out how to do this. pending school year or be a little better organized We're going to be organized. But we have fairly small schools that These things require the offer of the I think we're going to have transportation that see more the requirement for him What they offer is what we have to offer. investigate Thank you for answering my
107question. The next question is, do we have a plan this summer for the school year prolonged and the transport lines Chim brought up the topic but didn't give the Yes, I spoke with the CBO in Hemet. If summer could end It could be a possibility, we'll continue move forward with a contractor without which to see due to the time frame of summer and the year We're going to have to do it quite a bit again. quickly. And if that contractor... I can provide those summer services I preferred to do what that working with that new ot contractor within the summer period when School routes are smaller and the number of students we are transporting are smaller so that can give us a good sense Where are we going to have to have that? before the
108board in order to be able to give those services without going to have the bidding process quite quickly. That would be the process from 8 weeks with the meeting As soon as we can they give us laec They can guide us, we'll go with the bidding and we'll be back with the granting and that's when I would use pti for figure out the best way to move forward with that contractor we are looking at as ensuring that we have a service hired for the summer around March, March or April, I'd like to make sure that summer and the coming school year To be sure, and next time ask We have that it seems that the district are Billing, which seems to be my We are concerned about all those bills entering correctly and in a
109way In time. Maybe it was like I said, we like it. view a contract and analyze the I would like to say that the contract pays one daily rate and every hour and when it goes that rate basis pays that payment we don't have We have that type of contract as a service a limited cooperative that does not It doesn't talk about the cost to us without However, we see the invoices, I think. we saw October and November simply I took that, multiplied it by 12, and told him that it's a little bit The more space there is, the more space because the It's summer and I suppose a leaf of rate of the rate that the costs will increase There is something that is increasing by 5 or 8% And if We could have
110four clients now in Los Angeles and in the Orange County and External contracts have risen from 16 and Med by a high of 27 by 3 4% and I said that's the answer to that internal organizations we were comparing that to what the districts the amens that have paid around the time leaving COVID with the costs of materials gasoline and it was almost the same and for what I'm not trying to advocate for the minutes that it be an external or internal program that be the best so that it is for the children Bellflower's and what has been proven I just want to highlight those factors because costs have increased significantly and I imagine they've seen that with the staff classified in general Thanks regarding the program to the fleet vehicles replacement the ballot check
111system We are close to seeing a system of organization that It works, we're starting the process. I think Patrick brought us in August the report to you of the process of maintenance use system one of The things that have emerged are: Which These are other systems that are there. report thanks to pti we requested it was to the board in October and they returned him in two months and many days passed in the school staff investigating spoke with the directors and the staff of transportation and personnel physical when they returned the report to us It was very useful, but we just received it. In December and January we're going to start seeing the recommendations and let's hope we anticipate advancing the programs and inventories, that kind of thing It's definitely on the list and probably
112the things we have the most that prioritize first perfect and These are also certain photographs, it seems I'm seeing the My son's bedroom is a teenagers we are all working on That's because I agree, it's something easy to fix wants to come and say something. A lot. Thank you, board members and president from the Sánchez board the transportation that are out of service I am the administrator, one of the mechanics. I've been here with the district for 21 years I started as a mechanic, now I Senior mechanic and I'm still I have also been managing them working on a school truck because we hired a new mechanic fortunately in October when They arrived because we had a shortage of personal and we have been since the pandemic our senior mechanic retired in December 2019, 3
113months before the pandemic and we had a staff shortages since then and with regard to the articles of I took a class on ordering with chem a case study for the principal maintenance transportation leadership with CASW and I paid for it myself because I wanted to increase my knowledge to to be prepared for this position if it became available and I learned I learned a great deal that he provided this service by pti and I also gave him a call and started That's so they'll come and see. the department of transportation and see our room as a teenager we are working and To answer your question, yes, we are. By doing that we have many things in the workshop that have to be cleaned and I'm also ordering. viewing the maintenance program of the fleet
114inventories are things that We definitely have to We just hired to implement a technician who is very good with the diagnoses, that's what we I've been missing it since I've been all alone. with the other technicians we've had that They are drivers and mechanics. And we have monkeys. a mechanic, a technician's position from the mechanic who is helping us certain trucks that had seen that They were out of service because I didn't had the time to properly diagnose them and get them walking again Mr. Carrillo is here again working since October has been able to that all three or four work CHP certified champions since Chim has arrived, we are working on That's true, but with the work we have What to do? I'm glad I have the I have all the photos in the
115report, and it's something that I'll be reviewing with my staff so that we can address these things and approach it and invite them to Look, and hopefully we'll clean it up. and that we didn't put everything in the closet sometime ask a question more is indicating that the system that we currently have to It's Mr. Sanchez, we had bought before Mark, who was ours We had been looking for the senior mechanic Dolphin program fleet We didn't want to spend a lot of money It didn't cost much then. No, it didn't connect. Great, I'm in the process of looking into something. stronger formula that is easier of using a software package for the maintenance of the fleet vehicles, not just trucks but That's going to be white too. It's also a challenge because we have to
116some older gentlemen who didn't They are good with technology. accustomed to writing orders in paper they're now going to have to put in The computer is going to be... There's going to be a lot growth, but definitely something What can we do? Thank you for mentioning. That. Maybe we'll give it time when I... Give them those budgets and present them to him to the board because many of those things Software packages are not cheap Everything is cloud-based, so no The main thing is the packages of the programs will also They will have to renew annually in order to use those programs that the most software packages use I think I'm done with my current ones questions ma'am Membra wanted to make some comments on Mr. Sanchez First, many of my questions have already been answered.
117answered or already asked and has Answered, but Mr. Sanchez wanted to give It's worth it for investing in your own education to be able to move forward and get the work done that needs to be done and I know that Looking at a report, I don't know what sometimes It's like he gives us a beating, but It also gives us an opportunity to fix what actually needs to be fixed arranged especially if there is someone I'm looking at things from the outside and I want to make a comment about when we are presenting things for we of the programs of the I suggest you include computers in your list of computers. training and instruction for the staff for you and the staff because I'm sure it's going to have updates and it will also have
118to there be training for the updates because We are definitely students of every day. So I appreciate it a lot. And thank you so much for coming. and answer our many questions Thanks, I know it has certain Honestly, I don't think about things in my mind. I think we have an option. Option number one because basically We don't have a choice. I think that We have our own internal fleet, he said. Costs are rising 16 to 27 We have the trucks, we have the maintenance that I think we should handling our own thing as it we used to do it, but also I understand that it's not possible right now. We can do that, it looks like we're going to to make contracts for the school year I want to see a contract that is
119not prolonged. be very long so that we have time to have a look at the options talk to different people or see the subsidies to acquire trucks Things like that. I would be in favor of going with Something external and look at the other opposites Because I do think it should be internally, as with the other things, I am a I'm a little frustrated with this report because There are many problems with this, I'm Going back to number one, we should be inspecting each 453,000 miles is interrupting me Brad, the workshop, no. I had proof of vehicle lists They do not have stabilized standards of Replace the tires or the floats It's many things we're not doing. I'm so glad that our lawyers They're not here because we should... Give this because this is us
120It is opening up to many demands. Things may be happening because not It is to continue as an Education plan individualized, those are things that the The state is requiring that they not We are doing it. And yes, I understand that the people who are in their places have not Being in their places is not their fault, no. I'm talking about you, but I'm I am disappointed to see this report and compliance force that we have in I'm disappointed in so many parts I understand that we're going to organize it. We need a system for documenting I understand that the programs that We're looking into it; can you give us a report? or a report, or what would that be like? superintendent who He is assuring that these things are If this happens, they can
121give us report 1 2 3 cu we've finished this we're done Does she know what I'm asking if the We'll update when we're in I'm on the right track and I don't want to be critical of this. security may be subject to litigation our children's safety There are many parts to this, employees. So it's a little Frustrating. Thank you, ma'am. Madam President, a question the system is fast GPS, how much do we invest in that, I think? It was one of the things we had We've discussed whether we'd do it internally. We need that system for everyone. trucks to track them, how much did it cost I'm going to investigate it and I'm going to return with I completely agree with you. With President Stuart again, I think that the history of this situation The
122report is important, it's very good The staff will provide this information. Taking it will only help us to grow the way they did with the Classified personnel were terrible and were a legal matter and it wasn't a way Well, I think culture has harmed us. one of the things in the district that We are trying to work hard on restore the culture of the district I I think the drivers of Hemet Son incredible and I'm curious if he does We asked why some of them They live there but work for the District How many of H would stay here and They will contract with us if they are already there. I'm doing the work, but I think it's It's important to have stability when... our children who see when they go up to truck see
123the same person have that anchor person that everyone wants to see the days Talk about the culture of district, that would be my ideal, I understand that It's more work than there are many things that They come with that, I understand, with if we have to look for something in between to that the facilities are working The staff are amazing and very capable. and can comply with the recommendations We have many very good things in that. transportation yard and would It's incredible that it's ours and to take pride in it, but if we go in a different direction for a while I'd be fine with a fixed unlimited plan. I can give you a suggestion, and I I am First of all, they don't feel Isolated or alone, I would say 30% of Our assessments
124identify is the Vehicle maintenance Beyond the operations, which is very different This is the attitude of the staff who The work we did was superior, it was excellent. They were transparent. They took us through everywhere he is honored and they took activity what I think is in a very serious situation because I don't know if We have an Education person Special the classifieds lists in the year Extended school days will pass in April May has to have that contract in I suggest that they publish the current version. a one-year contract and up to four years of Renewal is the standard to achieve H Fifth year we want to be honest and Transparent gives us the flexibility to make the decision they finally want They also give us what we can do for their program the
125Break opportunity as he has a treasure of the parts, but if it doesn't have it and something goes badly written in the contract segment that can grow with the fleet one thing from the district that doesn't stand out Four of those routes are not making emet or the district fleet I think they're doing them because St is It's important to inform them of that. suggestion It has 12 routes H is increasing with the sub with and are using those four trucks are leaving. What he already... They are paying. Separated, it is not an invoice separated but if it proves that to put employees to support our schools and are hiring workers for those routes and those trucks As he said Tim, they are using their fleet, they did a carato from outside with the intention
126of that they would use their I have a quick question, maybe. would be a Funny question. I know he said they are four typical routes but how many trucks use the same route once a day Sometimes they are bad, there are 14 excursions Typically, how many trucks do we use? day We have to remove the excursions, one route consists of several runs like one that coincides with the school but a unified District with The one with the times starts later two bullfights in the morning and two bullfights We didn't do an analysis in the afternoon deep into routes They are working as efficiently as possible that they could see the reason and were in the Education standard We do not calculate for general education. because they are coming There is a reason why limits or
127no, it doesn't matter what the number would be based on the that's why I don't speak about the students' level We'll stick with the 12 proposals routes because the reason why I am Asking maybe I have to ask for it We have 32 trucks, that's great! It's important that we replace the trucks but we're using 32 Not at all, and the plan to replacement is not suggesting that replace 32 trucks, there are some things that don't we address in our In our opinion, we have more trucks than It needs to have, but the replacement was based on the truck and the type of truck with certain extra models and we gave more The numbers we didn't plan for are 6.2 million in replacing 32 trucks Ricky Patrick can better inform you that I know that
128several of the trucks are missing. operating in this So I thought there were 32 operating that work and one that I don't think we have three that aren't there. operating how many how many trucks do we use in it How many do we use per day? I'm going to give it to the Vice President, how long does it take for train a bus driver Recruitment is the thing, let me tell you explain to him that he is recruiting a driver commercially there is a criterion of background information that is being investigated typically for a School District Human resources is not recruiting She has to have 20 hours behind her handling it and 20 eh As training I was in a special class of 65 hours when I was an instructor, if not instructors were driving
129driving takes months weeks Sorry It's what I expected we felt we were doing a very good job work that we got 50 6% of drivers, that is, driving a bus. No. It's a job for everyone, that's for sure. Well, many people leave after the part of driving and we saw up to 12-15% that did not meet the requirement of district for many things drugs alcohol etcetera, when that happened, he... hires. But it has to be done with they This is helping them, this is Obando, the bus We don't do that much, but I suggest a couple of months 10 hours annually needs of training by a state instructor in personal presence and and they do Renew this certificate every 4 years and 15 hours is needed in This training is a task very big when
130it wants to do it unless you want to do Contact doctors, but if after A driver has been with the company for 3 months after... We're fine, I'll ask you this because I'm thinking that maybe We have some students who are seeking to be perhaps not to drive buses but maybe some kind of training after high school And perhaps it's something we can investigate. with kaps Well that's it That was already investigated by the CEO of CS Mrs. Chedo, she was the leader of that The program did a lot of research and we realized it wasn't feasible with with our students leaving because of that route but it was something that, wow, you can talk about that, well, one thing that We all need to consider when We're looking into that, it's about whether they
131want to someone who is 18 years old driving a bus full of students So There is a level of maturity that everyone We need to have some experiences There are many ways to deal with young children in life. to think about what that person could be in between to gain some experience of life before being behind the good steering wheel That said, I'm thinking about it here Maybe he won't like this one either. This idea isn't good either, and maybe it would be. looking of making associations with some unions, I don't know if any once with unions form partnerships with Unions or trade unions are something that perhaps We can investigate, there is a company in Northern California that I know Michaels Transportation is the only company that I have seen that they can join
132one association with a union and can This supplies conductors, they do it The others have failed, but it is It's difficult because I don't want to share the mine when I have them but the county From San Diego I created a one Maintenance cooperative of buses but I thought I found that It was fine if we're helping the neighbor, but when I was there, no help. There was no reason why they didn't want to, I see. who says he just wanted I'm asking, I mean, about the one year, the period of time we need to complete to the services But thank you for share kfi So I've been thinking about this seated here of our 14 drivers buses that we have through Hemet Two people from Hemet drive here, no. I'm aware of that, Patrick.
133They all live locally; there are eight drivers. from Hemet because four are with him another supplier. So the eight H drivers live locally I'll be honest, I know where hem is. I don't know. Where it is is quite far already I've handled Well, I didn't I know how many of the drivers of buses that live locally go to go back to driving for him there because They have other contracts here in this... This area historically did have this This is information I have from my work. with merch when he left Merch and H moved away, we're using those resources had work west of You guys are here, but I don't know if it's still according to I understand that they have tremendously reduced its company's eh program I found out when the I learned it
134through the interview because I didn't, I didn't I knew it, but Hemer is an hour away It probably doesn't have the routes to If they don't have our contract, they'll give it. to have routes to give to the bus drivers who work My current thought is that I bet we already have the drivers Maybe so, they didn't tell me they were everyone's crazy those who lived locally say they gave like 10% of them there, so they're maybe drivers to replace said 10% You, Rick, say no. I trust Rick. But remember, there are eight drivers of those we're talking about, if have some loyalty to hem and not They want to stay local, that's fine. I think they're going to want to, but I assure you that they need them in their own It's a fairly
135large organization of transportation of more than 125 routes without all service contracts I support it because four are from St. But They've put up money they won't be able to handle. a But I think there is a way. to find out if they're staying with us They would stay with us. Because it sounds... as if the only big difference between hiring with hem and not hiring because we do the maintenance ourselves Anyway, who are they? Who is driving the buses? I feel that the solution lies in The people in front of us are already there Contacting them there is probably difficult But I think the number of people is already there. They're there again, I don't know what you are experts, I feel good about that How many bus drivers We need for is and
136s and and is are less Or maybe it's because there aren't many students, I don't know. This exact number, but it is significantly smaller eh Me It can be given as an idea, it doesn't have to be Exactly, but Yes, I can definitely tell you some. The number is one third of your normal amount, I don't I expect, based on what has been seen with you and based on the numbers that already They have no qui no I wouldn't say that it was going to We spoke to different members of Churchfield. quite of the bus routes that have and there are some way to be efficient to list the bus routes and We have fewer drivers for even if We can do it We're seeing that working, well, I I wish I had already given
137him a percentage of the special education side and this falls within the state numbers but It might seem strange to you, but if you average of average in a unit if It is transporting 10 to 15 students That's the state average, it's by the time that those from education transport special and the distance they travel Yes, but this is what I can tell you professionally in my heart I would like tell me, I've been to quite a few organizations where G has been that they're going to want run optimally as much as especially when they don't have the personal to themselves in this last A couple of years, typically that internal Internally, although the boss for a contractor for this profit this If they want more buses, it's not going to happen. They continue to
138condense this four days to the this week four times a month maybe there is efficiency that you have discovered can be put instead the number of students in As for the number of routes, it's not very Offline is possible, yes, by doing a route analysis but one more thing You are doing well, that the data technician who is in place at They are creating the routes, I don't know. is giving to the person who is selling the bus or for use telling him how many buses he needs, huh person from the district and is very very this She's cleverly creating the route and... is giving the service provider By that projection in such a way that It is that if it were to continue for a short term, if You continue, you continue doing those
139routes monitored by his Leadership team and that individual who is making the routes that's not it The last thing I'm going to say is a A couple of things sounds like we're already there doing many of the things that we Regarding the position and the times We need to make some investments. GPS certain changes But the routes seem to be a problem, but it's just one more in the problems of managing small schools facilities that we have that we have things to do that need to be considered in terms of efficiency and finance As for the facilities, a good one which is why we must also look One on the 24th and that's why we need I think I can get one at number 26. Plenty of work we can do outside of this topic
140that will provide support This topic. Yes, this one. Thank you. Well. To clarify, Mr. Sánchez, we We are creating our own routes They're not here in the Gem district creating no hem continues creating the routes They were We had created these 12 routes better 13 years before Mark retired He was in the last year, which was the transportation manager before That's over 30 years as a foreman of mechanic, they did it last year transportation manager but was only as it was already very late when I was already in its place that to change to to use the contractor Hemet we had had more than 12 or 13 routes had this had had inflated and made them more more efficient and Hemet sold as its The service is that they would do an analysis of routes
141and the computerized program that They paid a certain amount, I don't know how much it was. But what they did was... They took advantage of the number of money they invested and with the program They used a computer to perform an analysis of route with the school districts they They gave the data, they put it in the computerized system and these came out routes before doing the route analysis for us they immediately said We definitely need to be able to reduce the number of routes by two or three routes and in the end Hey, Mark did an excellent job! Everything was the best it could have been They couldn't have done it any better. We've been there since Hemel... We've been doing our transportation I know about these 12 or 13 routes. we talked about
142our routes We worked with Bueno then, no longer. We're going to have it, but with whom are we going to... work to create our routes and Changing the routes, staff... Well, it sounds... as if the routes had already been created internally So that's what has been I've been using what PTI is saying and we haven't continued with those routes We will follow the same pattern, that's what we're going to do We'll see when we get the contractor. external that maintains the routes of We say that they are not being done internally that they are creating it Yes, Gemen is creating it. So what What you're alluding to is that if we had uh our own department of transports I am alluding to the fact that in In the next 6 months we need to do
143the Routes Who is going to do the routes with who we work externally or how That works, and if you don't know, you can... Let us know that by Friday. but we would have to buy our own computerized routing program That is the programming of which We've been talking. It's part of it, it's all. a computerized program of transportation that we are looking at and that The routes are inclusive. Oh, good. I understand those two positions that I I call this route dispatcher. That person does exactly what You're asking no more of this radio intercom but they are also experts in routes the position that has Although you, despite how you told me From what I understand, she was the one who handled those calls. H routes told me that she that she s It
144seems she maintains them, she manages them But I don't believe them, that's what I'm saying. Understanding, yes, I can share a little from the cop's experience about that to make routes but we had to go through the My own experience and understanding is a a much smaller program in compared to the entire District but What we did on the ks program. We tried Upon completion of the route, we will send that information to Hemet Hemet then the confirmed or made changes after who probably used programming computerized routes and sent it to us This is your route back, and maybe... Whether it was the same or different, that's it. an experience I've had with the very small program compared to I know we talked about the computerized programming that we have Buying that is going to
145come, that's coming for next week or in the future She won't be coming next week. together, but it's something we're... This Looking at colleagues, any other questions? comments I just want to mention you mentioned that It is and he recommended a year with 5 years of option if the partner knows that if you don't is prepared to do the alternative that you like in year two 3 cu year four who would have the option of they withdraw their participation or do their scalings, how to do one 5-year authorization not only the the It grants for a year or two, it is always with one option and at 5 years old is better In practice, the elicitation is done again. with extended year this includes it but This one has to address the issue address the
146topic because normally We are seeking customer enablement as in autumn and we awarded them to them like on holidays or if the The supplier does not prevail; it must have time to leave and let the new one pass and those new classes start in May but if we choose the route of doing the internal routes we didn't T the year Extended not this time because always She'll have it, yes, it's on her summer routes the program of summer but I I recommend this: I am a person I don't think you're conservative. You can have the components in place and expert wisdom in its place to do the routes in this pair of months to make it efficient to have the drivers and if it doesn't, it's in violation of faith because it seems It's a
147challenge, yes we can do it. No But it sounds like there are no more of them The drivers are local, we already have the routes But if I'm listening correctly the student numbers They are relatively small but appropriate for a District of the size of you but a person Knowing it what is he doing with the experience in that job could be done manually Routes for these students But what They're lacking, and I'm still not clear if the district is doing the routes or Hemet I think Hemet checks the route with his routing system and maybe it comes out with different left turns right, but it seems that's the one That means there is a case The person here is probably the technician. of data that the history has in its head that can take
148to continue Doing that, and to a certain degree perhaps already does it or does very little and put it in his place but that is a challenge that to be very honest with you right now this time of year type of student legal requirements with those students I wouldn't risk it with that issue, so It looks like we should use a contractor for s and and well one thing which is not which we are not talking about enough I think I need to talk about that. new was mentioned earlier in the report that we have a concern about the maintenance of our current vehicles ensuring that all They are meeting the current requirements We are... I know we are focusing quite a bit on the drivers that lead but we have to focus on the
149wheels that move on the road I have quite a few concerns. We have in the report that we need to address are pages of it we need to focus on time on that or if they are thinking that we're going to get our own department eh functioning there is quite a bit cleaning that needs to be done with the buses that are on the road Some things are minor, but also He alluded to certain things that are big This is a computerized program for have track of their vehicles training for staff also I think it was mentioned that we are accustomed to doing things with I don't want to forget that paper pencil. component I know we are focusing on quite a lot in the driver if Patrol of roads this they are great organization
150this objectives with its criterion says they are satisfactory but we We went in, there were two or three buses, I think. that exceed 3000 miles 45 days If This would have been Highway Patrol They would have removed him from service in the moment This is the investigating officer In particular, I would have chosen to look at check if there is a maintenance program preventive measures in place and staff not doing so He could have convinced them that Ya does exist. be electronic manually that individual would have been here talking with you, this, according to what he says state code and I could have given it one this rating to Paying for the functions. That's the worst part of it. the cases had at least two units that did not comply with the 3,000-mile or 45-day
151inspection Sorry, Rck O Patrick, our staff... He knew that until he I inquired and met with his superintendent I wouldn't decide this, this, this way There is a minimum transition year. We're talking about the safety of those... those of the students' safety buses if I want to return to something that He wrote earlier that he was a great program the contract with with Hemet because similar to own costs if We operate a system on your own account. And I'm thinking that's where We're in this together, I'm going to speak for myself by myself and my colleagues We need something now, let's give a We no longer have a contract. Make our own. own treatment already but many We want to explore this further in the future and That's where we are with this. We're talking
152We want to try to do that in the future We had it before, we saw the cost It was going up, and we're also talking about that You say there is a 16.1% increase in contracts I want you to I want you to I spoke, but I think that's what I was going to say there. That's what I was going to talk about. Obviously we all care about the Safety is the most important thing, but They are using our buses now So there's not much difference in that We still have to do everything that You mentioned whether we do it or not internally or we continue using drivers of gemen the way that by We focus on the drivers because It sounds like yes, with the exception of There is debate about who makes the
153routes That topic, but what section? That's it. The only difference at this moment is that I I can see, but the vehicles are the It sounds like we have many more of them. vehicles that we have routes and this one sounds as if No, those who are being... are not unsafe. Now there's quite a bit of work to do. We have to do it, but we still have to Do it because it's not fixing our buses member of the juta G le bothers her or member sintron I'm looking more towards a line of There are quite a few things that we we have to do before we are ready and in compliance with this the transport of of this summer school we can this the most We can quickly send a line of time to
154the meeting of When are we going to to be able to have these routes for these students plan when they are lifts bus drivers all with all as much detail as possible so that we can We can understand, we can understand. For where we are going and give it the best support that we as an educational board because It seems there are quite a few things that are What we need to address is happening here. Perhaps prioritizing that list would be the best way we can start taking Gar is talking about some member action what if we move on to that How will it look in the future? Not right now. Speaking of today, the present, ensuring that we are ready for summer Once that's achieved, perhaps we can address the issue. I think it
155will look like that in the future. Please correct me if I'm wrong, we don't have We need to hire now for that, right? We have nothing, well then, a line of time with that we're going to We are now looking to go out to hire because you said March for March/April but March/April is 30 I think you told us yes. We're going to hold tenders, which is a process of 8 weeks to go to the RFP achievements if there is a president St is doing a good job, what I I wish that the direction we have all heard tonight that we all know that we're going to have to have a contact External. This coming year to cover summer and next year while We return to the information board about a process for the development
156of something It's different if that's what the board is asking for. So it needs to be done in a certain way I will speak with PTI immediately so that we can help so they go and give us a document this tender that again in March the March meeting for the awarding the tender would be better but what He said, or at least what I heard, that most districts that do that are doing this doing in the fall if we are We're going to do this today in spring Because we need to do this, what Alma tells us now that they are working on the routes with the planning of with the students and routes already that all Those factors will be taken into account But when we go out there, we're bidding. asking What are
157we doing now, no I talk about so many details regarding routes and all his plans and everything else when We go out to do bidding We are looking for a contractor; we have the information about what we are doing Now the routes we need, the fact we have our own buses All those details are included. Include now. So the information for transportation the summer year that comes does not stop us from going out to illicit bid and buy time for those other things options that we might have that line of time is included in the maintenance on The buses we have now are what I'm really looking forward to at least the a one-year time limit allows us They mentioned that we would do that. They hired a new mechanic in October. who is very
158skilled in that area. So We are starting to see improvements already on the buses to this point but the other components of the contract that That's what I I would like to pray to tell you these are the steps we have taken in completing the recommendations made by pti in our current service and those will be Thank you, board member. They focus on tracking so that I understand better what he's saying that the concern in the report doubts that will set priorities and make a list And that's how we'll know And I'm talking about routes apart from trucks and summer needs and I'm talking about the students. We're going to work on the report itself. update board members with the concerns in the reports and We're going to have a timeline in some Some of
159them can be fixed easily, and perhaps they're already made Others will take longer, we're going to concentrate on the most serious like any to-do list prioritize what makes the most sense for the safety of students staff safety, that sort of thing I don't have the chronology because we're going to do it in that order and we'll start I'd like to work on the list, but I'd like to. give them the L to update them frequently So that you know where we are, member Churchfield I'm just a little frustrated Because, and again, as the president Stuart said, "It's nothing that they're here." But I just want to give you that. an outline of why I'm in 2022 We have some doubts about our contract. with the contract in Hamet the staff They mentioned that we need
160more time and at that time and we approved the contract and nothing happened after that came up also the contract matrix and the board He had a conversation and We said that's the last time that We are going to approve this contract and we want explore other options and part of that The conversation is about bringing him back internally and part of the conversation It was exploring how that would work, what it is it that would entail doing that The report presentation is incredible. but when we had that conversation initially that was that I'm going to be the report on what we had to to do to bring it in internally. And it's more like a comp comparison for It's hard for me to hear that the We have the summer program, we are... Right
161now we are in positions that We have to do this right now, every time. we put ourselves in this position that we have Do this right now, or else... we will be able to provide services Then the extended school PR for right now and for next year, and that's it We were talking, my colleague. because it's the chronology because it's a bit ambiguous about when we're going to do these things because we're always in the the position we need to have back against the wall or once again me I would like to see that we take the steps necessary to internalize the transportation that our workers are driving our trucks What I'd like to see. I know it's a A very big task, but there it is. where I I know we need it right
162now and But I would like to see the same thing I am also Vice President Garza. agreement and board member centron Absolutely one more question, everything is New to me, I understand much more Thank you so much. Would it be possible? I know. that I spoke with the superintendent with the contracts We can start hiring internal staff. internally, or that wouldn't be an option. Writing in a I'll hire you for anything you want, I have plenty. experience with the writing of the proposals because nobody is going to bid if There is a clause that the extri district It must be said that 10% or if they increase or if they fall it's a ladder to renegotiate the cost because they have the staff for that. For example, I I have a client in in a
163very serious economic crisis that It will involve many layoffs and leadership not truck drivers but as a result, it has a problem tremendous with the assistance of drivers and as a result it may Seeing an organized work stoppage is not We can have one. It would be more than 100 routes. two contradictory places and the two negotiations and I've done my best I can have business relationships with them and I have helped them and sometimes I have been I've had to negotiate with my worst enemy from the district a minimum of 10 or 20-30 routes. This is a district with 170 routes, whether they use them or not, are paying and it wouldn't be possible that we have a plan that we say we're going to do 25% I think the internal one already answers
164that you can Saying next year is 75 because we can go in that direction She had her dress made by another JPA. She had a The combination has two contractors Working for them, we wrote that We guarantee each one a minimum. But One is doing more than 60 per... Because The other one can't and I want him to... Listen, but that can turn things around. That situation exists next year. Historically we have never suggested granting to more than one provider in San Diego County Riverside everyone is so big that a The contractor cannot comply with the demand must ensure that it is We are working with a neighbor on north of you who put a clause quite generous because they are in the same situation as you are in and it is I'm very scared
165because God bless her I'm not used to see the list of students up to April So how can you do the route If you don't know the IP address, where will it go? The student can negotiate that inside. But it has to be face-to-face, but you can They need to make sure that it can comply 25% internally whatever the case may be because otherwise the ladder that that entity Hemet wouldn't be for profit It costs quite a lot when it sets the contract for a 4-hour or 6-hour base hours but it takes more than 15 minutes because there is rain or traffic You're probably paying three times. plus for that extra hour they have to have I'm trying to be careful. think about the chronology and go from there. that address the drivers sign contracts
166of a A truck driver typically spends a year very unique in most of the districts schoolchildren I don't know what the story is about the districts normally list by a contract and it depends on the contract how do they negotiate that one year contract if routes are removed or service is interrupted it does not have to facilitate a reduction in the workforce, but it can indicate that next year's routes They're going to be shorter or there's less of that The driver is going to get ready again; there are many organizations that come cover that They're panicking, they're telling them We guarantee 8 hours. I understand that. But now we're not saying they want to. 8 hours plus the excursion. Then they are... paying double because not methodically They saw the collection contract collective bargaining agreements
167That's why these things scare me so much. If they hurry and try to put this valid for the extended school year Next year, if they can do it Perfect, but get a contract. right now because it's going to be quite difficult I was looking for an individual 2 years ago years that he was going to retire and the We kept it there and then he had others customers and we moved them around, that's what happened Again this past year I had a I'm a little scared, I don't know if I can get there that individual to make the offer for the District, I'm being frank, I can't say what they are going to do and what they are not going to do to do it, but I doubt they'll come knowing. that bellflowers is only
168interested in a year of service That's why I'm I'm suggesting a year with the option of Renew for 2 or 3 years, maybe not. They're going to I think I was asking about needing the reason that all those friends that H that They were ours, they are here, they are only in a one-year contract because what about If they want to return, they have to say 10 of them Their drivers want to return tomorrow What would be the recommendation in this case? then it would be discussed internally or On the contrary, he would have an external contract, it goes to take two more than two years of doing the I don't know which transition option they want. take but has the problem of the fleets and all that stuff, my experience It will take him
1696 months to board, but Right now we're using our own trucks, we're only talking about the drivers What would be the difference for Franco had two units that They have uniforms that were outside of the 45 or 3000 miles, that would be illegal. But But they weren't operating While we were here it seems that they have much progress has been made in trucks that They weren't working, but that's the screenshot. that we have, but going back to Your question about the driver in the contract They are employees classified with hem They probably have a one-year insurance policy per year per year so that they have employment because they also have drivers which they probably don't have because they don't If their contract is to have the same level of of licitation to do what you
170They are suggesting: If I were a driver, I I would say I'm coming back home. I live in bellfower Here is my resignation letter a unified hit. That's how it is. Does anyone have any further questions? Mr. Crisfield's comment for I think it will clarify everything. How many numbers do you need to present? We have trucks that are operating well I can tell you about the question. report but it seems that Rick seems to have several more than They've repaired them, if I may add to that. ask not only when they are operating but how many of They are up to the standards that are They need to be sure to be administered to comply with standards of Of the 33 trucks, we have 30 that They meet CHP standards Absolutely then there are only
171three right now. And again. that are operating and are safe based on the 45 days 3000 that It's sent via chip; there are more recommendations. because of the report we have to do But these things are going to to pass without looking at who is driving The truck and the reason why we have There are so many trucks because of the routes that They are covered by chairs Those drivers also make wheels That driver might have the excursions a wheelchair truck and a full-size transit truck That situation exists too, but we don't use it. all the trucks at the same time We definitely have to And that's because when we have than to do service to certain The safest trucks are in the path Absolutely again I think we have that hiring someone even Let's
172start that and see what we can do. in the future, but understand where We want to go and we're going to have one new research a search for the Superintendent, we want to reach that point. point, but and you can do comments, but we have to do something Now I am in favor of searching for the contract that gives us some liaci or some budgets and that he returns to us When you have a moment, Mr. CR, any comments would be greatly appreciated. shield I'm fine. That seems fine to me. Well, I'm going to have doubts and concerns if... We'll start next year and more I understand that there, for them to do the l stations and offers we'll see I want to offer, but a quick question. How many of the hem drivers who
173live Locals were employees of the state Today, by chance, two or three, but Ricky Patrick: Maybe they know that better. I think it's just one. He was one of the employees, what has happened is that the area of the mountain where it merges and Hamet had several routes, I forget. How many routes did it have? 63 routes in that area They went with h a year before that We signed the contract with him when that was removed and Merch started all the drivers or the drivers let me know that they lived here in the mountain or even in this area all They They had seniority over the others drivers then everything changed those drivers are local to this area The transition happened. How many of Our 10 employees from B were employed with h when
174they made the change one or Two people had to offer him a contract with them at a higher pay but I think that only One chose to go with them, and they didn't last. a lot and how many we had when we left of having our own drivers in At one point we had 18 drivers with routes and three drivers of I think it was before the 2011 in 15 years we had many routes in and we have far fewer students We may have currently reduced the routes in that up to that then a lot Thanks, any other comments or The question is, does it have to clarify? Does it want to clarify? that Mrs. Arques is going to do get the offers so that we can we're covered for that year. It comes with
175the intention of continuing Go ahead, I know you understand that you want a timeline to see what it would be like process of bringing it in internally We don't understand what the... tenders if they can say that they are going to That would be 6 months, that's what they had to do find them out and present them to We know what you're saying. It's going to be very difficult if you're recruiting. offer They're talking less about the driver or the I'm talking about the contract I'm very worried about you. I already... I said my thoughts, I don't know what to be I'm trying to find a good business partner Suggesting a way would be no different of what I would normally do offers a year but it is not their intention to have the the
176contract for more than a year they will wanting a longer range for Recovering your costs is a business. No. I can tell you what they're going to do if you can Requesting the tender in that way is not I don't understand what you're saying but for me, ours as members of the Boarding is good business for us too when it is indicating that in fact we can save money to do internal in the future and with the costs that they are increasing would not be good business for us to try to see that option, but I want to correct one thing. I don't know if you can be more I know they can be competitive in the long run term but his current contract and the Increases are not outside the rules of the industry
177that he was facing the negotiations and the increases they give annually and I am trying one alternative Temporary and that staff can look for the contract and that they are not going to give them no response to the lito, perhaps They're not going to say yes for 6 months or of their own choices in this presentation number one if we use we hired our own trucks The company and the drivers is 8 points. If we have the same fleet, we didn't have other option and the other part of the option is if we do it without our own fleet It would be a little less, 6.2 million than The replacement would be the worst of the cases and number three if we have All the staff recommend you. This was in this presentation I would
178be 8500 would be 500,000 less than what it says There, saying that he's not sure if... we were I don't know how much they're going to pay the driver. We saw the comparisons of the I don't have that crystal ball in the industry. In front of me I understand their interest is in an internal program I know what I think It's ideal, do it, but do it, do it. Okay, don't rush. I'm being very Franco, I am the consultant with you. pay a minimum contract for one hoop goes to have more expenses because it's going to start Hiring drivers will double those costs will train the certified instructor operators the state at best in a They'll be ready this year, I'm not, I'm not I disagree with you, but I don't want to. to be
179the consultant in front of you that he couldn't recruit or couldn't do it or it has a fleet problem I hope it doesn't misrepresent what it does. That's what I think and hope. I am requesting that we hold the litigation But let's see if we can do it in the future. do the last one ourselves that's what we want to be We want to be good at being intelligent. business But that's what I think happened When I saw the table of how much it costs Being an internal AEM, the first year is a savings significant going outside the district and I would like to obtain this information and share it with the board and then a a little less, a little less is what happens You come, they bring someone new, it's Very well, and
180then the costs increase. It's an institute, one depends on them. difficult to separate from them for a year. It usually becomes about 5 years and not me I would like to do the An error in the future is what happens, what the district happens when That's why the contractor doesn't manage it. It makes the provision of services and not It doesn't matter how good your partner is. He has to redo the litigation keeps everyone ready for something else question or a little more comment on This concludes this meeting. session H lifts the 7:47 until the Rogal meeting that will be January 16, 2025, I no longer wanted Saying thank you has been a pleasure and Thank you for being here for so long Many questions. Thank you. (The following appears to be a separate, unrelated
181question:) session and