001good evening and welcome to tonight's meeting of the Board of Education the meeting is called to order at 4:01 p.m. in Open Session roll call please miss Armstrong Miss Centron here Mr critchfield present Mrs Garza Miss Stewart present alen do we have any cards tonight for public comment or Carri sorry no no we do not all right um tonight I would like to ask our newest Board member Miss Marina sron if she would lead us in the flag salute please thank you so much all right Mrs oo let's begin the retreat thank you good evening everyone happy New Year nice to see everyone back thank you thank you um this evening we have three presentations for the board presentations for information and uh you have individuals that have come to speak to you about three
002very important topics the first first topic first presentation for you will be from Westberg and white we are going to have an update regarding the Mayer High School athletic fields so I'd like to ask Bob bender and staff to please come up and provide us an update regarding those fields uh board members uh thank you for having us uh we welcome the opportunity to uh make you this presentation to the board bring the project up to date and ask any and answer any questions that may come up uh with regard to uh the project as it stands now the uh uh first high slide is uh just roughly the renovation features as uh the project is in inclusive now the U uh Stadium portion of the project is the primary impetus behind the entire project
003itself uh the stadium contains uh field lighting which consists of four uh large light poles with uh LED lighting on the top of them uh which uh shine on the field and the soccer field and illuminate the track and field area of the uh Stadium itself uh the most recent change that we've made to the project since it was originally a approved uh back in 20 uh 21 uh we added the 1500t uh home bleachers with a Press Box to the west side of the field and then we included a 500 squ foot or 500 seat capacity bleacher on the east side of the FI and that's the visitors bleachers uh the Synthetic Turf has changed since we originally designed the project we're going with a different manufacturer now and the areas that uh are
004inclusive are the uh soccer and the football fields and then our surrounding the soccer and football fields the running track is also a synthetic field all the grass areas inside the fence perimeter is going to be of Synthetic Turf there will be no natural grass within the stadium area itself uh the uh buildings that we have uh are the concessions restroom building uh we have two ticket booths and then uh one of the new additions to the project since it was originally approved was the 1900 foot storage facility the fuel storage facility is primarily there for uh The Grooming equipment that's required for the Synthetic Turf and storage space that is provided for the football fields uh the track and field events and all the other uh athletic equipment that's required to provide serviceability to
005the stadium itself uh it's 1900 Square ft and it's uh much larger in capacity than most of the field storage areas that we provided in some of our other projects uh the rest of the fields consist of two baseb one baseball and one softball field each has a back stop and each has a home Dugger and a visitor Dugout with additional storage space provided for each of those facilities uh there are two sets of bleachers behind the back stop and then there's also a raised scores platform with a shade structure that covers it right behind the uh uh Bullpen fence um both the uh stadium and the fields uh have scoreboards uh the main scoreboard is at the stadium area and then there's one each uh smaller scoreboards at the baseball field and at the
006soccer uh softball field itself uh as part of the original design uh we have a 300 car parking lot that covers the what is now an open flood control channel uh the flood control channel uh is being permitted as we speak uh and the uh uh rest of the Fields contain there's two practice fields one of uh practice fields is going to be of Synthetic Turf and the other is going to be of natural grass U the portion of the practice field where the Synthetic Turf occurs also includes a storm water detention Basin which is a state requirement uh it was part of the original project from the from the GetGo from the beginning uh and this is the plan uh that we have uh if if there's any questions or anything that you'd like
007me to go elaborate on further we can discuss that during in the plan do you want to continue maybe with the presentation then leave time at the end for questions that might be a little bit better okay regarding the highlights uh this project started back in December of 2014 when we uh first met with the district uh uh it was uh uh principles involved at the time um and we submitted our proposal we were authorized to proceed with a proposal um in December of 2025 2015 the major requirements of the project was to go through the city and involve the county and the state authorities having jurisdiction all of these bureaucracies have subsequent timelines which initially delayed the project in the first case they have had subsequent impact on us in processing the project through
008them again the second time and that's will show up later in these highlights the original project was scheduled to be a phase one of a two-phase project which included the steam building the sports Fields was proposed to be developed first and then the steam building would tie into that as a pH to construction based on the uh delays caused by LA County Flood Control District where they were hemming and hawing about bringing in the Army Corps of Engineers uh the steam project was authorized to go forward first uh the final project uh initially approved on May March 4 2021 uh was later put on hold um as a result of the construction the steam project at time and all the other projects that were being uh proposed for development at that time all projects were
009put on hold at the same time after that 2020 March 4 date in October uh we understand that the school board had authorized staff to move forward with the project as was originally designed based on the presentations that we had made earlier ear on we had uh back in the uh April board meeting there was a presentation made to the board where we author where we prepared three different options for the sports field project each one containing a different dollar amount and it was presented to the board at that time in October 2023 the decision apparently the decision was made by the board at that time to move forward with the project that was originally designed uh there was a caveat to that that uh it'd be reviewed with uh District staff and the site
010stakeholders to make sure all of their requirements were inclusive uh later on we were uh participating in the meeting of November one where we met with uh District personnel and site stakeholders and they outlined what their specific requirements were above and beyond what was part of the original approval uh we took that information from the November uh meeting and went back and we came up with some design options and some creative ideas as to what we could do in order to implement all of those uh criteria for uh their requirements and we presented that on December 6th in a uh meeting at the district office uh based on that uh uh meeting of December 6th uh we submitted a proposal for services and we were authorized to proceed with the proposal for services on March
0118th we orig we originally registered the project with DSA on March 13 uh but going back and forth with DSA based on some of the requirements that we were uh uh that the district was asking for one of which was the update of the uh fire hydrant flow tests we got the flyer hydrant flow test from the school district and we registered our final the registration of the project on April 15 of 2024 we got the first comments back from DSA on May 28th of 2024 uh following that we got the conceptual plan approval from the LA County Flood Control District uh for the improvements in the channel uh with that conceptual approval we were authorized to move forward with the uh processing the permits and the applications necessary to secure uh the permit applications
012and uh move forward with that work uh the response to uh our this first round of comments uh uh we got the comments back on August 14 we submitted in in March and we got the comments back on um August 14 that was the the first duration of the DSA application we responded to those comments on uh November 13 and re-uploaded our package some of the comments that were made as the initial review were as a result of the design changes that took place on the site plan DSA now required us to provide additional fire lanes and additional access for the uh fire and emergency vehicle access so we had to redesign the site plan based on that requirement which which is what we uh took to took us to November 13th to get uploaded
013and at this time we were also required to go back to CGS uh California Geological Survey for approval of the uh site improvements that were required we got the second round of comments back on December 4 which is what we are responding to currently and we're scheduled to have a in back check inperson back check on uh January 16 anticipating DSA approval at uh after this January 16 meeting we should be able to provide move the project and go out the bid late January early February for a construction start date that we need to make sure gets in started in March the window there's a moratorium for construction and flood control channel uh the county will not allow any construction to occur in the flood control Channel during the rainy season so the only opportunity
014we have to do any work in the flood control Channel itself is between April and October so we need to have all our contracts in place prior to the April start date so we can move forward immediately with the flood control Channel improvements that's going to be the longest duration of all the construction uh activities on site uh and we do not see it taking all the way to October but we cannot begin the construction of the parking lot until after we complete the flood control channel so if we complete the flood control Channel work in October we're looking at may and or October November December before we can complete the project so as a result of that we're going to miss the 2025 football season uh we were asked to update the uh project
015construction costs when we uh prepared the original uh applic or original proposal for the design the construction cost budget established back in 2014 was 6,45 uh we went through there was some additions and modifications of the project that occurred early on and the adjustments were made in April of 20209 we provided the district uh an update of the construction cost at that time as $9,250 th000 which is what we've included in the application to DSA for the construction costs uh that uh we're under application for right now uh in the last presentation we made to the board or back in the April 2023 presentation of the boort where we had three different options option one which was to move forward with the project as initially designed was given a rough order magnitude of $15 million
016we reiterated that $15 million in uh our our board approval of uh our board meeting of August 28th or August 9 I'm sorry the construction cost estimate that we had uh uh that we hired out was provided to was on um August 28th following the board meeting and the constru rough the construction cost if hard cost construction cost estimate came in at 17,9 $829,000 uh if you factor in uh soft cost and District costs and other costs that could easily put the project over the $20 million level and I think that was discussed at one other point in time I don't remember exactly what the details were but I know that has been Pro the number that's been floating around within the district uh itself one of the things that we uh got approval from
017early on was in November of 2024 we F we got CGS approval it was a requirement that of DSA that we get CGS approval before we could submit our back Checker before we could apply for our back check inperson back check appointment we got that approval on November 26th the caveat to that approval was that it was a provisional approval and we were required to provide uh what is now called Deep soil mixing to stabilize the soils for the foundation systems for all the buildings the original application that we made to CGS was where we provided a u additional soil boings and additional uh geotechnical report for the area of the new bleachers the 1500 feet bleachers there was additional boring requirements that were done there so at that time uh as a result of
018the boring requirements the geotechnical engineer had a recommend Commendation of either going with deep soil mixing for the foundation systems of the home bleachers only or using a ovx and recompaction for the entire area which was the process that was used on the steam building so we had the option of going either way now with CGS approval they've directed us to go with a deep soil mixing uh soil stabilization we have the district has sent hired a contractor a specialty contractor to go ahead and prepare the designs the calculations the specifications as necessary to include this in the bid package when we send it out but we haven't gotten an update of what their approximate costs are going to be so taking that $20 million project I could see this project now going to 22
019million we Ed the Deep soil mixing on a project over in belf or Downey Unified School District uh for the suspect Elementary School SES middle school project there were three large buildings included in that project one of which being a large science building similar to the steam project the other being a gymnasium and then there was a significant addition to the uh admin building that was made on the ssma high school or sesma high school project the estimate or the cost for the Deep soil mixing that was uh incurred over at that susman High School site was in the neighborhood of $4 million I'm seeing as being about half of that so that's why I'm saying that at this time we're looking roughly 20 20 20 to $22 million possibly for the cost any any
020questions um before I open up to my colleagues um Miss oo there's a lot of things going on with Athletics right now I would like to form a subcommittee On Athletics and I would like myself and Clark critchfield to sit on that committee so can we talk about about that later it's going to keep going yes we can all right any questions for my board members um clerk critchfield okay I have a few um so if this project would have gone forward when it was originally approved the cost would have been closer to six million right no no there as original approval was uh what we had provided to the district uh back in 2019 the estimate at that time was 9, 250,000 okay as of the what date do we have for the uh
021the April 2023 presentation made to the board where we had the three options option one to proceed with the project as designed and approved at that time was $15 million when you say designed did that include the parking structure that did that did include and so as so when the board I believe it was August 23 um August 2023 where we had the three options and we said option one plus and the plus was we wanted uh to go back to the site to to engage with the coaches and and site Administration um so that was what was the price at that point for option one that design 15 million that was the 15 million so the the additions from that is is how we got to the uh the 20 million how we got
022to the 17 million that we got the current cost estimate on okay so the 15 million based on what we submitted to DSA back in March 28 we we sent the drawings to a cost estimator we got the cost estimate estimate in on August 28th after the board meeting and that cost came in the hard cost for the construction cost was 17 m829 th000 okay and and from that point when we had the new scope of work uh it did not come back to the board for approval correct oh we hadn't we haven't talked about we got that U propos we got that estimate after the board meeting of August 9th right we got the proposal on August 2 we got that cost estimate then I've discussed it with staff but it hasn't been brought
023up to the board that I'm aware of okay um I I read the transcripts of that meeting and it was It was supposed to come back to the board after that meeting uh for more discussion uh I wish it would have um the next question you mentioned uh switching manufacturers for the synthetic field going with a different manufacturer who is selecting which synthetic field and is are our um staff involved in the actual selection absolutely yeah both Patrick and I and the groundskeeper um what was his name Patrick Vincent uh we flew back to uh Arkansas and viewed an installation of that field at at the location and the price that we got from that new supplier was equivalent to what had been provided by field Turf but field turf was going to be increasing
024their costs because of you cost escalation since their original yeah original submitt so uh yes uh Patrick was involved uh um and the rest of the staff was made aware of the change that was being made to go with uh an alternate to the Synthetic Turf okay good good uh and the scoreboard so I know the initial design was to uh kind of mirror the uh Ron yui scoreboard which is I don't know how long that scoreboard has been there um but uh I know Patrick's thinking right now he's thinking of a year um sounds about right um but the and that's what we design the the brand new stadium to have that was the program that was used at for the 2020 204 proposal that we submitted to the district it did get adjusted
025afterward but that was the initial proposal was to mirror the rer stadium okay is that the current plan well no well we're we're we're going with visitors bleachers and home bleachers we pardon score box that hasn't changed okay that's still the scoreboard that's in the project currently I have talked with staff about it pator and I have had several discussions about it and I just got a call this morning from the scoreboard supplier which is providing a CS agreement uh to Deborah purchasing uh for the scoreboards uh I talked about it with him uh we can add a video display board to the football field scoreboards the video display board alone is in the rough order of $75,000 added costs I asked him what the total cost would be for the uh football uh scoreboard
026and he was saying in the neighborhood of $250,000 less what we already have in the original Cass agreement I wasn't copied with that original Cass agreement that was sent to Deborah so I don't know what the cost of the foot post scoreboard is in CS agreement but the Delta would be from that to 200 $50 million okay my my concern $250 my only concern there is uh to kind of back dat our technology isn't probably the best way we should go uh I understand why that decision was made when the plans first came out but if we're having a a brand new stadium I I feel like that the technology needs to be current and sticking to you know we talk about our technology plan and just kind of keeping it current I think it'd
027be a very uh I think it'd be very beneficial to have that as current as we can um so I'm hoping we're looking into that I do have another question do you want me to kick it over um do you have any questions for M Sean let Brad finish and then I'll chime in okay sounds good questions are the same cool go ahead um all right next question I'm I'm happy to see you and thank you for being here uh City of Lakewood staff really appreciate it um I again I looked through the transcripts uh at one point we had said that there was no need for a traffic study and then at a a subsequent meeting we uh we said that we were going to engage with the city for a traffic study um
028I'm really familiar with the the traffic issues around that area and with that parking lot I it gives me like a my Spidey senses kind of go off because uh it's it's a pretty tight area and even getting out on the Aon is problematic have we um if we build the I know we can build the par parking lot there but in order to have those Outlets there um have we engaged in traffic study and what is our partnership and collaboration with the city at this point okay uh going back in the files I found that uh uh the civil engineer had opened a discussion with the City of Lakewood City of Lakewood contracts traffic studies and that type of uh uh steady work to the county uh public works department but that dialogue was
029opened under the original design prior to the 2019 approval so there was a a a dialogue that was established uh they do not move forward with the development of the offside Improvement plans uh to submit to the city until a a contractor is in place the project was never put out to bid therefore they never had a contractor to include in the application so an application was never made to the City of Lakewood for a off-site Improvement plan which at that time if a study was necessary would have come up so so there has been no no traffic study not to date no so uh this I've discussed this with a civil engineer they're currently moving forward with Tule to the county whom they're going to have to deal with eventually anyway uh with regard
030to options to add one or two more driveways possibly one onto Allington as an exit only another one uh down of cane Hill uh as an exit only uh from that 300 uh parking lot area uh I haven't gotten a report back from a civil engineer involved in that yet I talked with him this morning he has not heard anything back yet from the county people that he's open to discussion with okay and and you're the expert here uh I I just it I think it would be probably good to work with the city at this point uh to see if those are where those uh Outlets should be um especially going down cane Hill right there because it is a residential area uh it just seems like that and I don't know if it
031would be uh you having those conversations or or staff or or who but they would probably have some pretty good insights on how to do that in the most safe and effective way especially because that parking lot it's kind of like a oddly shaped uh uh parking lot I just I would like to see those conversations happening because I'm guessing at some point for this current plan we will need a a traffic study correct uh we're we're checking into that currently yeah I I was just going to try to go back to the site plan uh the parking area that's directly off of Allington was always part of the project the only park that is was subject uh to either disapproval on under the option two or removal entirely under option three was the improvements
032over the flood control channel right so that linear driveway along can Hill is the flood control Channel and that's the only ones that we're really concerned about uh the rest of the parking up in the corner was what was originally in part of the project from the very beginning and is still in the project well didn't you say even with that initial plan with just that that parking lot on Aon uh Allington uh there was no traffic study even with that original plan no because no application was submitted we didn't go out to bid so we don't even know if that would have really happened uh the civil engineer that I that we uh have were working with at the time had approached the city early on in the uh conceptual designs we did have
033a the parking lot lot along the flood control Channel continued all the way to the west and was going to access that drive uh I don't remember the name of the street there but that residential driveway there that was reviewed with the city and that was turned down okay so the city was aware of the project moving forward they they would not approve the project with an exit on onto that a those residential street yeah well the reason why I I think it's a it's worth discussing is because I mean that was so long ago I mean that's you over 10 years ago uh you know maybe though you know with you know different staff a a different number of students that would be using that like you that study would probably change if we
034were to do one and developing this plan maybe out on that cane Hill you know maybe it would have been better to go down to the bottom or or uh to have that exit off the cane Hill but I think like for the the experts working with uh the safety and traffic people in the city probably be really helpful so I last thing I'll say I want to see that collaboration happening and maybe that'll help guide us because I don't want us to go down a rout where we're planning on having these outlets and then we can't do it okay uh well as I mentioned I'm currently working with the civil engineer uh they are taking the plan as presented there we're showing where there's two possible options the one down near the corner of
035the intersection between uh Allington and Cane Hill and then the other Outlet uh up toward the turnaround um access onto cane Hill from that parking lot those two areas are are dashed in on that site plan as you can see them that is what is being presented to Public Works LA County public works for the City of Lakewood for their re and I haven't gotten a report back on that this is just something that's just transpired recently so we're still in the process of following up on that activity we are moving forward with the project as it's designed now with DSA processing and stamp out if we add those driveways in it'll have to be something that will be done as part of the off-site Improvement plans which I State AR don't get prepared and
036submitted to the county or the City of Lake liid until we have a Contractor on board which we can include in the application and the contractor is the one who essentially pays the fee great so what I hear you saying is that it won't uh it won't happen until we for with the put it out the bid we can do that later okay yeah it will not be part of the DSA approval for those uh additional driveways okay great um in regard to the technology that he's talking about with the scoreboard is it possible to get a price difference and just have that submitted to us on a Friday memo of what that price difference would be if we wanted to use that technology yes once we're provided the information from the architect yes yes
037uh well as I mentioned uh the the just the digital board itself all by itself is a $775,000 increase the pluses are that we have to add structure we have additional footings we have additional columns there's added structure there's added electrical costs and there's also other incidentals the quote that was given to me for $250,000 for a to for the football field scoreboard itself is just a at this point a um rough order magnitude he will provide us with a final cost because he has to modify the Cass agreements that he originally had sent to Deborah because we're now going to be including those uh digital scoreboards in that Cass agreement okay thank you and then my next question quickly is for Miss arus because we're starting this so late and we do know that
038that bond has passed is there any way that we can apply for matching bonds for any of these projects uh we're definitely going to look into any matches however um most matches come from bond funds and bond you know projects and so we're going to try to see what we can do out there but we are have to go under the assumption that we will not get a match to proceed with the project okay okay do we have any other questions um Bard member sron thank you um one thing that I didn't see is a timeline of the project once the bids so we want I heard that we're hoping to get the bids and everything approved by hopefully April just because of the bills because of the moratorium in the flight control channel right
039so once the timeline like once you get started what is the timeline looking like assuming you know it's been projected it's it's going to take nine months for the work in the flood control Channel just just in that area just in that area alone so the project itself the the while the working the flood control channel is is proceeding we will be moving forward with all the other works uh we we will the the stadiums will be fabricated the stadiums uh the bleachers will be installed and and and developed we will move forward with all the underground work for the buildings so we had figured the entire project C total uh had we not had many so many delays that we've encountered with it the bureaucracies involved uh we were originally looking at a a
04012-month pro project nine months for the uh flight control work and an additional three months because you couldn't do the parking lot until the flight control work is completed okay so is that the timeline that we're still looking at 12 months from whatever start time it is 12 months from there yeah that's why if we uh get the the bid we we go out to bid late January through the month of February we can award contract uh or the board can award contract in March for a construction start date prior to that April deadline or the April authorization to proceed so we can get everything in place and ready to go for immediately starting in the flight control channel in the inum all the other work can be starting as well so what I hear
041is where the assumption would be if everything goes right right that our 2026 grads would graduate at their no I'm getting 2026 yeah you would have the stadium available we would would be a 12-month turnaround so we get so our class of 2026 would have their first graduation on the if we move forward in March theoretically we complete the project the following March which would be 2026 okay cool um I think I don't know who to address this there's s it's it's a side question two side questions you can direct it to staff okay great um so one of the things that I was thinking about as the presentation was going on is where are all of our Sports students going to practice um while this work is being done like where their practice their
042games obviously we won't be hosting any at that field at all um so we have football soccer track and field our tennis courts are not going to be touched but would it still be safe for them to practice there um so I like that is more of the general like where are our students going to go and then um this does not pertain to the field itself but also so were they going to get a shiny new field but are they going to get shiny new equipment our students at this um campus on this campus so whatever that looks like um you know like if there's anything necessary for like we glamorize a lot of our sports teams that are outside and and in my mind I think about the boys sports but I also
043want to keep in mind the girl Sports the track and Fields um I would like to see or possibly know if we're going to give them or have the budget for equipment for the field to be used on the field let me work with staff and get back to you on both those questions thank you and that's all for me thank you just as a preliminary discussion that we've had uh acknowledging that uh we we this subject was brought up by staff we've talked about uh creating a uh a lane along the residental Residential Properties to the east or to the South rather on this project and and creating a crosswalk over to where they can uh go to uh what is it Lindstrom over there eser Lindstrom yes that was discussed prior as well
044so that's where the football field would be or football teams would be practicing I can't speak to the rest of the other practice teams yeah and I think I heard that and I read that somewhere and we were only talking about football but there's so many other teams that need to be addressed and also catered to as well so that that's where that question came from as well as our PE classes and I think we know that um I have a question are we still planning on doing the kind of under construction Banner along the side so that people know that this is up and coming are we planning on doing that or no we are planning to do that sometime this year yes okay um vice president Garza did you have any questions sorry
045no not not at this time thank you are there any other questions uh clerk critchfield uh one more question the so those lights being so close to the residential could you speak on that for a second what's the uh is there an approval process we need with the the city is it going to be a nuisance uh what kind of study have we done so far we have not done any study on the the uh lighting uh at the at the previous board meeting I outlined that uh there is a definite cut off for the field lighting uh and the uh foot candles along the property lines at both streets is less less than one or a a parking lot a minimal Li for a parking lot is is one foot candle so it's less
046than a parking lot lighting that you're going to get on the street on the street side of the campus the street side of the school the parking lot the parking lots will have Lighting on them but that's all cut off and the the parking lot lighting shines into the parking lot and won't go out won't spill out onto the street at all so uh yeah there was a a a foot candle study that was made by musco lighting the supplier of the uh Sports porch lighting uh poles and packages uh where they they did a a photometric study of the entire area around the stadium and around the entire campus so uh well uh thank you for I 10 years is a long time to be talking about the same project I'm sure so I
047appreciate you answering all these questions uh I will say I think it was a disservice for uh previous Sports to not move forward with this when it was supposed to happen because it's costing us significantly more to do it now because of costs and everything I am glad we're moving forward with it um but I I think it's really important that uh the information whether it be about the lighting or the or the traffic we need to be able to communicate that uh with the people that live in that area because even though I think the community has been waiting for this for a very long time and they're very excited and a lot of them to be frankly are doubting it's going to happen until they see a shovel uh in the ground which
048I'm excited about uh but I think it's really important that we communicate uh that there are going to be lights because people might be concerned the people that live you know 30 feet from them uh you know sound from the stadium I know you had mentioned you there's been some studies on that sound and the lighting so I just want to make sure we get that information out to the residents and collaborate with the city so their constituents aren't worried or blowing up our phones about what the heck's going on yeah I recall that there was a brief comment about an Outreach that we do we we could do and you we could participate in that if the district would want us to I think that'd be great thank you so much are there any
049other questions thank you so much we appreciate that thank you for having us thank you so moving along to item 3.2 supplementary Employee Retirement plan Mrs oo yes so our next topic um this evening we have uh Dennis Yu the Executive Vice President from public agency retirement service or better known as pars uh Mr U will provide the board information regarding the possibility of offering an early supplementary retirement program all right good afternoon Madam board president uh members of the board again my name is Dennis U Executive Vice President with pars I'm pleased this afternoon to present information regarding a potential early retirement incentive program for your certificated non-management employees I do have a quick presentation to review and then I be available to answer whatever questions uh the board may have um just a
050quick background on our company or company has been in existence for more than 40 years now or company was actually founded on providing early retirement plan services for school districts uh throughout the state um we've done probably over a thousand of these early retirement programs uh since our founding um we're headquartered in Orange County right near John Wayne Airport where um we provide all the of the administrative services for our programs um on the next slide just shows a quick sampling of some of the 350 plus school districts in California that have done early retirement programs um with our company um so that also includes your District um which we successfully implemented a plan approximately 30 years ago back in 1994 and I was actually there um when that plan was actually um adopted um
051in addition we've done work with about 2third of the school districts um in Los Angeles County um including some locally including uh Downey Unified and Paramount unified which we've uh um offered programs um in recent times as well so the goal of an early retirement incentive program is to Simply offer a one-time Financial incentive to your employees to retire a little bit earlier than they otherwise would have and so um uh through this early retirement program the goal is to try to incentivize that senior employee who's typically at the top of the salary schedule again to retire a little bit early and allow you to replace that employee with a um a lower cost or person who's lower on the salary schedule thereby trying to create some salary differential Savings in order to help pay
052for the cost of the program and also to generate some savings over and above that of natural attrition so at your district for your certificated non-management employees we're seeing about a $35,000 salary differential between those at the top of the salary schedule compared to your new hired employees so again that's the salary differential savings that will help pay for the cost of the program um when we looked at the salary differential savings for other employee groups not the certific non management employees but rather your classified employees and your management employees we simply we're not seeing that large of a salary differential and therefore those type of plans that involve those employee groups generally do not pencil out um so in general what we're trying to do is to try a triple or quadruple um natural
053attrition which is the normal rate of retirement that you would normally get in a given year so again in the year you offer an early retirement incentive program you'll see many more people um retire in that given year and um throughout the years or programs have been very um effective to help um reduce the need for layoffs during tough fiscal times so back during the Great Recession era of 20 200920 we had offered a lot of these early retirement programs to help avert um many layoffs throughout the state so how these early retirement programs work is that the board would um um authorize the offering of what we call a conditional early retirement incentive program so that um employees who might be interested in taking advantage of the early retirement program would be provided about
054a 45 to 60-day enrollment period to decide whether or not they want to take advantage of it and I do mention the word conditional because um the the program would need to meet certain fiscal and operational objectives of the district in order for the plan to move forward so during that 45 to 60-day period employees who are interested in taking advantage of the early retirement program would submit an irrevocable letter of resignation and so at the end of the enrollment period pars would then gather the list of those employees who would be interested in taking advantage of the plan and um provide a calculation to the district to deter to determine whether or not a plan would make you know sense for the district from a financial and operational standpoint So based on the results
055of how many people enroll in the plan and the actual savings the board can determine whether or not to proceed with the program or could actually cancel the program so historically pars has had a very successful rate as far as approximately 95% of the programs that we do offer are in fact approved but unfortunately about 5% of the programs um that are offered by districts are ultimately canceled because they don't meet those um fiscal and operational needs so the bottom line is that your district has the hindsite of 2020 Vision as far as if you do offer a program um we want to make sure that it's a program that ultimately works for your district and if it doesn't the district can again resend that program and if a program is rescinded anybody who submitted
056a resignation letter during that time frame um th that resignation letter would actually automatically be rescinded so with respect to the proposed retirement incentive offer um we've developed two different um retirement incentive offers that your District could consider um these are just simply based on retirement offers that some of your local nearby districts have offered to their um certificated non-management employees in the recent past so one program scenario one is called 70% of final pay scenario two is called 60 65% of final pay so what that simply means is that represents the cost to the district of a particular program based on the employee salary so to to make the math simple let's say one of your employees is making $100,000 per year in salary if you offered the 70% of final pay plan you
057would take 70% multiply that by the salary so that would be $70,000 in that case and that ultim ultimately represents the cost to the district to provide that retirement incentive for that particular employee so again that $70,000 employee I'm sorry that $100,000 employee the district's cost for the incentive would be $70,000 the district does not pay that in one lump sum amount the district can spread out that cost over a 5year time frame to to provide some um additional budgetary savings for the district and with that uh contribution of $770,000 the district would actually purchase a tax qualified um annuity on behalf of the employee and that also that serves as the retirement incentive offer that the district is making and by purchasing the annuity um that provides certain tax favored advantages for the employee
058to participate in the program so the way to think about it is that when an employee retires they would be eligible for Ker's benefit whatever they were originally entitled to plus the pars benefit so in retirement they would basically collect two retirement checks and so again the pars incentive is really what motivates people to retire in that given year so the employee if given the opportunity to accept this um annuity program um to participate in this pars program they would then be able to select among 14 different annuity payout options so these would be 14 different types of monthly payout options that the employee can select from so pars would be um notifying and educating employees exactly what the option are and what the amounts potentially would be with if they were to accept this
059early retirement plan offer from the part standpoint what we wanted to try to do is to provide as many as much um options to employees from a financial standpoint to help to assist them with respect to you know providing a financial incentive that makes the most sense for the employee from the district standpoint Point um the district doesn't really care which option the employee chooses because your cost is going to be fixed at that either 70% or 65% amount but from the employee they can then select the financial payout option again that makes the most sense financially so we do offer three different types of Lifetime benefit options 11 different types of fixed term payout options which would be higher um in nature in addition there's also going to be the ability to do what's
060called an IRA rollover on some of those benefit options so that allows employees to even tax defer a portion of their pars uh monthly retirement benefit so again we're trying to provide as much retirement flexibility for the employee um through this um incentive program so the next part of this presentation I did want to get into a little bit of the potential design potential design that your District could consider and some of the assumptions that were're actually we factored into or or model to help determine whether or not a a plan would make fiscal sense for your District So the plan for your certificated non-management employees that we're looking at is a plan that um inv involves employees who are at least age 55 with five years of District service um so they would have
061to meet that Milestone as of June 30th of 2025 um and in order to participate in this program they would need to actually resign from district employment by the end of the 24 25 school year and one thing to note is that usually with pars programs we don't require employees to actually retire they would simply just need to resign from district employment and they would actually have the ability if they wanted to to work at another district and continue to acrew additional s service credit at another District but from your District standpoint they've um you know you're able to um have one of your top um of the salary schedule employees depart the district and so that's what really generates a financial savings for your District so um from that standpoint there is a lot
062of flexibility even for the employee to not even have to retire but simply they would just need to resign from district employment um what we do find is that most will actually they retire under the their respective retirement system so this plan um we are um um looking at either two different types of program either 70% of final pay 65% of final pay so we've modeled calculations looking at both um with respect to replacement employees we're looking at um we looked at approximately who your District hired last year in a certificated non-management role at approximately 87,00 so that's if an employee retires they would be replaced by an employee making that um salary amount um in addition we've also factored in retirement health care costs um retirement plan costs because those factors also impact directly
063the amount of savings that would happen if somebody were to retire early and so like for example with retire healthcare costs there is actually an additional cost to the district for people to retire early because if somebody retires early there's potentially more years you have to fund for their their retire Healthcare benefits so we do also factor in that cost into our model So within our program um so we looked at your demographics um for your certificated non- management employees and there are is a total of 123 employees at your District that do meet that um requirement of 55 years of age with five years of District service um on average their salary is in excess of $120,000 um they are on average about 60 years of age with 24 years of experience so these
064are folks that have been with your district for for many years um so with respect to um these two different retirement incentive um offerings 70% and 65% um we don't have a crystal ball but what we do have is a lot of statistics on how many people would take these retirement incentive programs so we're we're forecasting that approximately 26 of your employees would retire if offered the 70% of final pay plan and if a slightly lower incentive offer um were offered at 65% we would fact we would project about 24 employees would retire under um that particular model and one thing to note is that our our model generally what we try to do is try to be a little bit more conservative upfront in our projections um we could expect anywhere usually we would
065expect anywhere from maybe 20 to 30% of the population to retire in a given year but um right now we're using you know what we would consider considered to be a little bit lower on the lower end of the spectrum but generally speaking if we get more people to participate in the plan we'd actually see more savings to to the district right um on the next page um next couple pages so this is again some of the forecasting that we've done with respect to what we could what the district might expect if um a retirement incentive were to occur and the one thing to note is that again these are just projections the actual savings won't be known until we actually see who actually wants to participate in the program so this just gives you
066kind of an a rough idea of what might actually happen but the real calculation is done at the end of the enrollment period when again we know the names numbers salary of the employees that are actually participating in this program so um the way to interpret this chart is that um again at assuming the 70% of final pay um and we get 26 employees to participate in this program um we would expect over a 5year period slightly more than $140,000 savings um over and above that of what we call Natural attrition so we we think that again this type of program at 70% would make fiscal sense um for the district assuming that we can get approximately 26 employees to participate in this program the next slide is a projection using that slightly lower benefit
067formula at 65% again we're going to see again statistically slightly less overall participation at 24 but again over a 5year period we're projecting slightly more than $200,000 of savings over a 5year period so again what we do view this is a a a fiscally positive program for your District on the last slide I wanted to cover the uh potential timeline for your District um what it would actually look like when we um have to factor in it that 45-day enrollment period um fore employees so assuming this is a a concept or program that your District would be interested in there would have to be a resolution that your that this board would have to adopt to move forward with that contingent offer so um hypothetically you could bring this to your next board meeting I
068believe next Thursday and that would open up that 45-day enrollment period so during that time period pars would then immediately start um communicating with those eligible employees providing them with retirement packets about what they could expect from a early retirement incentive offer we would come out to your District site in late January and host what we call a group orientation meeting so that all the employees who are eligible for the plan would um again get um idea about what pars is and what some of the options that would be available and what's the um terms of participation would require um in late February we would do what we call individualized counseling again come out to your District site meet with your employees oneon-one to provide again any last minute assurances about the program help fill
069out paperwork and then on Fe febrary 28th the pars enrollment window would actually close so anybody who wants to participate in this program has to submit that irrevocable letter of resignation um to the part's office onor before that date and so the evening of February 28th or analysis team will be fiercely crunching the numbers um figure out again who part who's eligible for or who actually participated in the program what the actual savings would be and then we would submit that information to The District staff to um to help determine again whether or not this plan makes fiscal and operational sense for your district and then uh that information would be B brought back to this board on March 13th and then the board would have the final say of whether or not to move
070forward with the program or again the ability to cancel the program assuming you do move forward with the program um employees would have to resign from District service no later than June 30th um your District would make the first of those five payments on in July on July 10th and then on August the 1st employees would receive their first pars um benefit um check in addition and then they would also receive what other benefit checks they were eligible for eligible for from the other Retirement Systems so basically that wraps up my presentation for today and um I'll be happy to answer whatever questions the board may have thank you so much Mr U um colleagues do you have any questions I actually have one um okay so let's say that we decided to go under
071the 70% and and I know it says that it takes about 26 what if we've got 24 or something like that could you go back and change the percentage or when we make the decision for 70 or 65 are we locked into that yeah so generally speaking once you make that decision UPF front you would be locked in at that point okay and technically speaking even if we were to let's say get 24 employees when we were maybe hoping for 26 you know sometimes again depending on the type of employee who accepts that offer it could make um you know there could be some benefit if for example one of the higher paid employees of the district accepted that offer so we could even see more savings with 24 if they were the right 24
072gotcha um I I think it's a great idea I think we should do it I'm a little confused on the percentage you're the expert what would you recommend and why um so it what I've included is just two different options meaning two viable options um and ultimately it I think it depends on what your District's objectives are is as far as if you want to try to achieve a certain number or of employees um we think that the 70% offer would be a good choice that's again what a neighboring District um offered their employees a couple of years ago and that resulted in a su very successful offering um one of your other neighboring districts is offering the 65% um currently right now right I know that District very well but um but we don't
073know the and result of that offering I know and I wish I was 55 but um but but so I generally speaking um I would feel very comfortable with the 70% offering um because I think that's a more common you know 65 is a little bit of a you know not a round number so to speak whereas you know 70% um I think historically we've had from the or company standpoint we've had great success with that level of offering so there's not a huge difference from what I'm hearing it's really just the incentive of getting people to do this so that our can save money correct absolutely correct okay right um vice president Gara yes thank you um I think most of my questions will be directed to staff but maybe perhaps you can chime
074in in case you have any extra information um I did we already um request some information prior to um looking into this into the early retirement and years passed with our unions I thought I had I was um I was not part of that in the past to my understanding verbally was that it was looked at and reviewed and it was determined not to be a um Financial savings for the district at that time but my understanding is that was looked at in years past okay so um would we go out then and ask our unions how many people they foresee have um taking advantage of this or no that's part of this process as he described so if the board elects to move forward with this um it will come to you next week
075as a board item for approval and then pars will then jump in and it's their yes okay perfect thank you and um I also heard that there are some extra benefits um that the district would have to pay on behalf of the um our employees that do decide to take this U plan for benefits after retirement um are we able to meet those um responsib ities yeah those responsibilities would be ours for any and um I think this one is just a small clarification um you said that by the end of June um on June 30 2025 that any of those employees who would decide to take this plan have to present their resignation notice um with that but then over at the other um timeline you gave a February 28 pars enrollment window closes
076right right so the resignation letter itself would would have to be submitted on or before um February 28th but the actual resignation effective date would not occur until the end of the 2425 school year not to go past June 30th so I'm not sure what the last day of your um school calendar is on the 2425 school year but that would be the date that the vast majority of your employees would submit a resignation letter for that the last day of the school year okay so then to make sure that they're in the program they have to um abide by the February 28th deadline yes as far as submitting an irrevocable letter of resignation so if they want to be a part of this program they would submit that letter on the 28th and then
077on the March 13th the date that the board would review whether or not to approve or reject the program assuming you want to approve the plan then all those resignation letters become binding effective on the 13 and then the resignations actually take effect again usually on the last day of the school year okay thank you and then um I guess this one would be to staff does our do our principles and do our campuses request teachers to give them an update on what their future year plans would be is that still in effect I thought what we did that whether they're staying on with us moving on to a different District so at science teachers are given a tentative assignment that usually happens in the month of May this would be happening before that would
078take place okay um and it's not necessary for us to move that date correct no okay um I think those are all my questions as of right now thank you so much thank you I have another question just being transparent for our teachers or employees is there a difference between a teacher if they're taking this resigning versus retiring because I know that when you're in a district you're locked into your health benefits so would that be a difference that we need to talk to our employees about correct yes so um from the par standpoint from this incentive standpoint all we're simply looking for is resignation from employment and that qualifies them to receive this monthly pars benefit um for your District you do offer continuation of healthc care benefits into retirement which would probably require
079or necessitate retirement under stirs or purs you know depending on which retirement system the employee belong to so yes it would need to be clear that if employee does want to actually retire and also receive Healthcare benefits they would need to also then concurrently retire under either the stirs or Pur system if an employee simply wanted to go let's say work for Downy unified for example and and just simply resigned afterwards then they would actually forgo or forfeit their continuing retire Health um continuation of retire health care benefits at that point in time if they chose to not retire and continue work at another District so that's why we do see most employees would probably um resign and concurrently retire but that's not 100% always the case right um clerk critchfield great thank you for
080being here um so just for clarification we did you did do a study on uh classified and admin as well to see if it would be uh beneficial for the district right so usually when we at pars when we look at um demographics we look at all employees including um classified management teachers and so forth just to look at demographics hiring Trends all that and other employee groups were determined to not make you know did not have any fiscal savings like we saw on the teacher side okay um and I I I get it with declining enrollment uh and needing to adjust uh Staffing um but if we're talking about what percentage to go for to see how many people we can get what's the number that we want like what is our if we
081were to adjust Staffing to our current enrollment what we need how many for this particular plan you're looking at a financial goal so the financial goal is the recommendation of hoping to have 26 individuals retire or resign and then at that point once those individuals are in the system and if the board were to move forward then you look at your enrollment numbers and figure out of those 26 let's just say there are 26 of those 26 what do you have to hire back and that's why you see on the spreadsheets well what does it look like if you only have to hire back 75% of the people what does it look like if you only hire back 50% of the positions right I think that's the part that i' like because when you look
082at what the actual savings is if you hire back 100% it's really not that much of savings at all so I feel like that's an important estimate of like what it is we would be hiring back because that'll determine how much this would even save us our estimate is 50% 50 okay um and I'm so sorry let me correct that 75% is that correct Miss Arcus that's correct our estimate is it between 75 and 80% is what we're anticipating we're just starting right now to look at the role of the enrollment for next year a look at the loss of um students that we've been experiencing in the past few years and we'll take into account what teachers that we will need for next year and so as these kind of Two Worlds Collide and
083we get the information from um pars if we should move forward we'll also have what we anticipate needing in teachers and we'll be able to utilize both those thank you for their correction so it' be like a net reduction of a like four or five teachers net that would I mean that that's about 75 you're looking at roughly 75% so it' be five to six teachers on 20 six teachers on 24 would be that we wouldn't need to bring back six of the 24 teachers just picking the number that's easier to do mouth on so again if we look at our Trends and we determined that we will need less teachers than that that would result in more savings okay so we're giving the conservative 75% range which on the 24 teachers would be six
084teachers we wouldn't need to higher back and that's where we'll start and then as like I said these are kind of running concurrent as to when we look at enrollment Trends and we're starting um you know to look at classrooms for next year okay no that's helpful because it rookie uh if we were to do like it's a difference of like projected Savings of 2 million over five years as opposed to closer to six million so that that's really helpful um one more question but if it's 75% just really quickly to jump in then we're looking at about a three million savings on either one of these right am I reading that right Coles yes yes over five years okay go ahead okay um okay if we go forward uh with at least the discovery
085and seeing how many people would be willing and want to do this and then the board decides uh that the numbers just aren't there uh what's the cost of doing the study and like what's our cost for like going down this route company would assess the District of $3,500 3500 if you were to cancel it correct thank you any other questions so I think what we need now is we kind of need some direction on whether we want to do this and at what percentage so maybe if we want to kind of just each one kind of say how you feel about it I'm going to put vice president gar on the spot and have her start I deserve that I was late um I think that the 70% will be enticed into our staff
086and hopefully they will initiate that um project and we can move forward I would go with the 7% board member Centon I think this is a good idea to at least assess and see what like going down the road would even look like I think more benefits are always better um especially like I just think like how hard our teachers work they should have extra bonuses in some sort way form or fashion that they can take advantage of um so I would like to at least get the assessment done what do you say assessment what do you mean like at least start the ball rolling on this okay what percentage do you think we should start at 65 or 70 want to think about it more and I come back to you yeah I think
087I want to I'm looking at the numbers so give me a second I'll tell you clerk critchfield um I I'd feel comfortable uh going out and seeing how many people would uh want to do it I mean the the concern that that comes I feel like hiring teachers is is a struggle sometimes so I just I I worry about that if we do need uh but outside of that as far as it's concerned I'm I'm fine with the 70% and seeing how many uh would be willing to do it um I'm definitely for it the percentage wise I would go for either 70 sounds good but I do think we need to ask you Mr sarcus because you are our CBO what your opinion is I think given the fact that we have the ability
088to look at the program look at the dollars when they come through I think the the probably the start would be the 70% model as suggested so you would be okay with that I would be okay with that thanks for asking okay thank you um so it sounds like we have a a consensus of oh back to misson yeah let's do 70 um so no but also to kind of piggy back with Brad cuz that was one of the thoughts while the presentation is like so how many teachers would take advantage of this and then what are we looking at to hire and for me goes back to my original comment of like I love the bonus situation and I think with the bonus situation when we're trying to recruit for more teachers to have
089this extra thing there would probably have them come but this is only for retiring and they will come this is only for people that are retiring it's not for our regular teachers but you're just saying because we'll have extra money to be able to maybe and it would be something that they can potentially enroll in down the line when they get yeah absolutely absolutely because I know Paramount did it I think two years ago and they're doing it again this year so they've actually done it twice because it's so beneficial um any other comments okay so it sounds like you have your direction is we do want to go forward and we'll look at that 70% understood so we'll have a board item brought to you next week at your next board meeting thank you
090okay thank you thank you so much for your presentation we appreciate you thank you all right so moving along do we need a break are we good we want to keep going Brad okay we're going to keep going you yes okay we are going to take a 5 to 10 minute break really quickly we'll be back and we will resume at 5:30 go ahead my watch is telling me to stand up anyways sorry my mic is not on um we are now back in session at 5:32 p.m. and we're moving on to our last item item 3.3 Transportation program review Mrs oo yes Timothy FIS is here with us this evening from Pupil Transportation information LLC he's going to provide the board with an overview of a report that was completed regarding our transportation services
091um Tim pis again with people Transportation information and Madame President of the board it's a pleasure to be here I wanted to also let you know um before we entered into the current uh contract under the scope for the project we're about to present here I was able to get familiar with the district for about a year a year and a half under prior business leadership understanding um the current situation with your service provider just for some backdrop on that um the report is um thank you the report is um heavy and data so I don't want to move too quickly so just please slow me up uh if you want me to slow down I have done some references on uh for the report for your your convenience as we're uh going through but
092essentially uh the study background in October of 2024 the district approached PTI and asked for um not just alternative delivery system option assessment but also if we were to bring the model back inside to the district what would it look like what would be the challenges what would be the pros the cons the cost uh Etc so in doing so we concentrated heavily on those services that the district does perform internally and that's vehicle maintenance so there's about six of the deck slides in here dedicated um to those steps uh the report is uh set up into about five sections for reference the first being the executive summary please read further than the executive summary though it's really hard to put those together and the report is heavy in detail uh two the current Pupil
093Transportation Services and cost uh I feel that's important for the board to understand also every District of of 1021 in the state is different in Pupil Transportation funding and it's uh sometimes a challenge to figure out why my neighbor might be getting so much more under the local control funding formula than I am so it's important to kind of read that history there three the analysis of the current contractual agreements that you have with your current external services provider which is also another nonprofit Lea and that's the him at Unified School District for the potential alternative Service delivery models which you're probably most interested in the assessment and the cost of those and then we were asked to provide an opinion on those assessments as well so current Pupil Transportation Services and costs as a
094starting point uh the district receives about a million and a half dollars um historically that comes and funded it's buried within your local control funding formula but it's tagged for Pupil Transportation essentially has a maintenance of effort uh an on it essentially that if you don't spend at least that much in the current year you won't receive or you'll only receive what your proportion is uh the following year and it's hard to explain why that is that's a historical funding formula from the state that dates back to about the 20s and the Ed code um I've been in the industry 42 years the new legislation um which brought about 60% Revenue enhancement not in addition to your current state revenue but in total is probably the largest adrenaline shot in the arm we've had that
095I know of I suspect it's probably the largest revenue enhancement for people transportation in California's history from what school services and fmac have shared uh with us uh those costs must be identified must be identified under your function 3600 or they don't count so let me share with you why that's so important as a side note here is we spent the 1990s and the 2000s into this Century going up and down the state helping to protect non uh required Transportation that's General Ed so what many districts did is they spread out per a fuel cost so an example of such would be an instructional Aid in the classroom who also is assigned to be a school bus attendant perhaps and uh those costs would get buried or that percentage of that salary benefits Etc would
096not be tracked under function 3600 and we did not do a detailed dive in this scope of um your expenses um I didn't see anything glaring that stood out I would I probably would have captured that but it's just a reminder to the district and to the board for understanding expenses for the 2223 uh school year were reported as a little over three million do we use that as the base Factor year because that's the last year on actuals from the state reporting because remember you always receive your funding the year following and it takes two years for that to kind of catch up so we use that as a very objective uh Criterion because it's it's a fixed figure sort of speak um approximate funding the district can expect to receive is a mil
097162 uh for the 23 24 and ongoing depending on what those expenses are as tracked under function 3600 as I indicated the district has an anticipated planned operating budget for the current year of almost four million uh dollars uh little bit of a jump there not surprising I you know in our opinion in our calculations you're still a little bit under the Statewide average there and controlling those costs the reason for that are the escalating cost in Labor uh uh costs associated with uh contracts supplies fuel the list goes on and on and the district's cost to Transportation this is something to celebrate here uh for the board is about 11,773 it's probably a little over 12,500 right now because remember we're using that 22 23 school year you're falling right within the state average
098on per pupil for uh Transportation so if we had the fiscal crisis management assistance team we do their transportation analysis for them we'd be using the same you know equation to calculate that as well as uh School services so that's a a very competitive figure under your current form of transportation so good job your uh current service provider as you know is the HT Unified School District that's a very unique service provider and one that you've benefited from um substantially the the reason being is there a Cooperative contract with you um and their rates their costs Etc are set in place similar to your own if you were operating a system so as they reach out to do Cooperative work it's a very unique Pro uh program not done aggressively throughout the state um most
099uh you know districts are benefiting um from that Arrangement because they can come in and compete uh a little bit better so than a for-profit external contractor I can unfortunately that's not a topic necessarily for discussion here because HT has informed the district over the last couple of years that they need to cease that support and it sounds like it's pretty final for the current uh school year um understanding a little bit about your current Services uh himt reports that they're operating 12 school bus routes and they perform activity trips for you Andor schedule or arrange for such if they're not using a a himt unified bus the district is providing transportation to approximately 263 students please understand that that data is reported to us from the contract provider it's not necessarily confirmed against District
100data because there was a greater than 15% difference there there could be many reasons from that for that usually in the arena of special ed um so we went with a higher figure here approximately 139 of those students are general education students and approximately 124 of those students are receiving Transportation as a necessary related service under the I programs either in a HT uh bus a subcontracted bus Which I'll explain later or a TNC uh vehicle another for higher non-bus vehicle or through parent and L contracts which we'll cover later in the uh report and um as I alluded to himt augments um the district um by using us transportation of America sta that's a for-profit external contractor um they're I I believe they're National but at least they're on the western coast uh anyhow
101they're widely known they do they do a good job um and himt is doing that it's my understanding they're doing that to augment and it was also in a in an effort to assist the district by carrying transportation for both this year and last year as they've been in the middle of deciding whether or not they could continue service for you or not so this is how they continued um moving on um with himit the district contracts of Transport the TNC company um you have one in the district and then it's not himt sorry it's the it's the belflower that contracts with the network company it's referred to as a TNC in this case it's hop skip Drive they're one of a handful uh a great company to work with TNC companies are costly though
102and and the reason for that you don't want them to become a permanent alternative provider but they fit a very good Niche for those students that are in isolated programs going outside of the district to their program location or maybe inside the district too but the child has needs that takes some out of the normal yellow school bus um the numbers of students that you have on Hop skip Drive are not necessar alarming we we use the figure of 5% if a district is exceeding 5% in TNC type provid you might want to look at it because the cost of transportation is costly again that's not a negative though it has a spot within the delivery system um the uh District also turnley contracts with and this is pretty impressive folks 62 parents Guardians to
103provide transportation under uh the California Ed code referred to commonly as inlo Transportation reimbursement um there could be um you know a story behind that and whatever the district's reimbursement to the parent is we understand it's greater than the standard IRS standard reimbursement per mile and that could be one reason that figure is is as high as it is nonetheless you know we would share with you that um as many parent and L contracts as you can arrange that is your most competitive Transportation depending on what you're compensating of course um back at that figure is high though for the total number of students that you have um himt notified The District in 2223s I'm sure you're aware of that the S the the service would need to support at the end of that school
104year obviously they continued for that year U last year and currently this year I think it's pretty well understood we set at the table with him it it's very clear to me that that they will need to cease the service here at the end of the school year I was unclear um and who I spoke with though whether or not they could help through the esy extended school year Services through this summer it obviously would be a huge benefactor if they could continue that service um PTI could not identify specifically a contractual formula for him and I don't want that to necessarily alarm you because it's not a competitive service where they put in a daily rate a base rate a weekly rate or the other multitude areas of how you formulate the cost from
105an external contractor it was a Cooperative contract I'm sure at the time that that um contract was let there probably is a document um service and they probably had an escalator of anywhere from 3 to 6% on that although we could not find in substantial apprciate that so the figure that we're projecting the $2 m93 million is based really on three months worth of invoices that we looked at that were identical for each month so we simply multiplied that by 12 years or 12 years not quite uh 12 months which um is probably going to make that 2.9 a little high because Services would fall in volume during the two summer months for esy there's fewer students there's fewer routes uh on Road school buses are required to be inspected uh every 45 days or
1063,000 miles we we kick off in the vehicle maintenance program with this because there's what we call objective criteria for assessment and then there's business best practices so I always like to share that this is a legal requirement that you have for your yellow bus that you do not have for any other piece of equipment in the bus not suggesting it wouldn't be a good practice we're just saying it's not IL legally required um um requirement um the district has a current CHP Motor Carrier inspection rating of satisfactory sometimes that sounds negative to a board it's not you're either unsatisfactory or you're satisfactory therefore you have the highest rating by CHP that they can can offer and uh you have for the recent years approximately 98 other non-district support vehicles and equipment I have to
107use approximately a lot through the next several slides just because of we don't have um electronic or hard data um um to to track the district's Fleet from um but just to give you a size for the breath and feel of the program and what those folks in your vehicle maintenance teamot are supporting the district ports having 32 school buses which we validated 33 um I think one is non-operational um might be more than that the district lacks a current robust Software System usable for Fleet inventory tracking preventive maintenance repair orders we I I brought this up UPF front because because um a lot of things that I'll talk to in the next few slides will tie back to that need to use technology to track District cost get at actual operational cost um we
108would much prefer to have been making our recommendations from understanding what a vehicle operational cost was versus a total operational cost which is just bringing the cost of your supplier your operator whether you had internal bus drivers or external bus drivers operating um it's it's a little bit hard for do to do that so that figure I showed you up front of 11,700 per per student that was just taking the conglomerate of your whole Transportation budget and doing the division um on it there is um a software noted in the department um it was explained to us it just historically has not been used and has some shortcomings for the needs of the department staff and we would concur um with that um the um we not identify any type of internal parts inventory or
109preventive maintenance system is indicated in the shop had no evidence of an accurate updated vehicle out of service list I'm going to pull some of these items out because um um not not that they would hold any less importance to you but so that you understand the importance under California Ed code title 13 um Etc and requirements so it's they're going to my examples are going to be specific to a school bus because that's what we're talking about here so when we see no evidence of an out of service list what this means is that you know an operator has downed a bus in any given morning afternoon because there's a critical defect or safety sensitive defect or it could be a non-safety sensitive defect of which uh needs attention and it's noted on what
110we call a dvir driver vehicle inspection report or pre-trip is commonly asked CHP will want to see maybe not necessarily during their annual review of The District Fleet but should there be a school bus incident and should there be a catastrophic incident involving a student there if there's uh proof to show that there was a failure on of a component on a school bus they're going to look to see if it was known when that last preventive maintenance schedule was and if they can't find it there they'll look back to the um 45 day 3000 mile inspection to see if it was noted if it wasn't why did it occur you know out on the road which it could have so they look at the driver's dvir for such they're looking for a trail to
111show that from the point the operator claimed there was an issue with the bus or during inspection a district vehicle mechanic saw an issue with a bus it was documented and scheduled for repair from there they'll look at a work order if it exists to show that it was repaired what part was repaired what supplies were used what mechanic made the repair and they file that back that then um get communicated back in some fashion to uh the service provider in your case or if it were a school bus driver here they're notified so there's a paper trail on that to show the evidence of the repair being made so I I won't go through each bullet and explain it like that unless you ask me to but I want I'm going to give you
112a couple examples of such the district does not have an established replacement program for Fleet vehical tires now in all honesty the district has a very small footprint the district probably probably is not going to wear out a tire um in the span of the mileage that it puts on but nonetheless um we do as operating our own vehicles too but on school bus you don't want a tire on there that's more than five years old we're not saying the district does or does not have such we just don't have the evidence to be able to communicate to you that there's a program in place where this is being being checked it's an it's an easy fix um the repair record keeping is insufficient I gave you an example of that and I really want
113folks to understand that because it's a very very serious matter you want it on your whole District Fleet so that you protect the investment um I'll jump head of here a little bit and put it in terms of your own automobile you buy a new vehicle there's a a manufacturer's recommended um preventative maintenance so let's make sure we keep preventative maintenance separate from a repair and that preventative maintenance on that Toyota Camry may be the first servicing at 10,000 15 or 20,000 um it may have its second preventative maintenance at 20 to 40,000 it's third somewhere around 75,000 and another around 100 to 120,000 if you looked at the manufacturer's recommendation for um service it would recommend that certain things be done some of those services are going to cost more some of those services
114are going to be more involved in time and um the parts and everything that's used for that's what we cannot track at the current time in the district's um um best practices um in place over there um we cannot find evidence of um utility vehicles for golf carts and everything we were looking at everything as this kind of what PTI does when we go in it's a transportation specific to school bus but we're looking at your full vehicle maintenance program so we brought in the support vehicles um and other things like golf carts and and what have you I'm not going to spend a lot of time on that because it's not directly related to um the item at hand um we cannot ascertain the CNG tank inspections for school buses this is legally required
115depending on the mileage that goes on the vehicle those tanks are going to need to be inspected every every year or I think it's every three years label showing and um the label um pointing down um not hidden um it's highly regulated um normally CHP would be looking for that as well uh numerous vehicle inspection record and school bus visual inspection findings are noted in the report on the pages as noted you can read through them I believe there's around 33 to 36 or so facility um congratulations to the district um I'm used to being in a tent sometimes or under a quanset hunt the district has a state-of-the-art um um building out there um um very well equipped the shop includes five vehicle maintenance bays and is outfitted with either an inground rotary or
116above ground rotary or flat work surfaces which uh the size of the shop The Bays um if operational and accessible are are plenty for the size of the current District Fleet uh we noted that lift inspections however are currently outdated they must be inspected each each year they were inspected but I think they're a few months out as we recall uh just general housekeeping and decluttering there's a lot of uh pictures in the report just take a look at those those are easily addressed that's just getting in and organizing the parts inventory and what have you the use of Technology will help um quite a bit uh in this area I'd like to give you one example though as to why you know we make it a big deal in the report and this is
117why I'm controlling costs for the district if you have five oil filters of a certain type for a certain engine sitting on the shelf that engine could be in a district support vehicle it could be in a short chassis yellow school bus it could be in a large chassis school bus when the mechanic brings that vehicle in and he's doing a 45 day 3,000 M safety inspection or preventative Lou oil filter what have you he or she would go identify the parts on the work order they'd be pulled from The District's electronically controlled inventory and you're maintaining X number of parts by the volume you need in your replenishing the oldest Parts with the newest Parts you're buying to go on the Shelf when we don't have that it's no different than you and I
118in our own home looking for that can of corn and if it's not readily in front of us in the face what do we do we just go buy another can of corn that's the best analy I can give you on that so it you know it's a big deal to us if we see some disorganization or we see that inventory spread across several areas in the shop again couple months of cleanup you you can address that but that's the important of such uh let's move oh I let me comment on the battery charging area um because you're probably thinking well you just store batteries inside what's what's the big deal well the batteries are on a metal framed rack you got conduit you're charging batteries someone could get hurt so you set those batteries
119the the vendor will supply you the rack probably at no charge they're happy to do so if you're buying their batteries but again it's just a best practice model uh fueling infrastructure you're you're generally state-of-the-art again there um we identified um oh I jumped over let me back up one if I may I think I hit it and you're trying to help me there sorry uh the CG monitoring system uh is up to date the district has an industry standard Hardware software called gas boy that monitors your liquid fuel levels of diesel and gasoline um we understand that the above ground tanks were recently painted and that could be why the placarding uh was not on there but just like you see the truck going down the road hauling the fuel you got to have
120the triangle placering on there you have the yellow ballards to protect which you do uh fire suppression no smoking in the area all of this so again it's just a housekeeping best practice issue we're pointing out there um and um on the uh CNG the district worked so hard and it's like so many in the South Coast Air Quality Management District in the '90s and going forth you converted as much as you could nearly everything over to compressed natural gas I did it in my own organization in Poway Unified and there's a lot of money and time and effort setting there and now essentially that's all going to go out out the door but in doing that there's a lot of best practices it's hard to keep up the items because like electric vehicles those
121buses are fueled at the Tower or fueled in the parking spot so you want to be very careful about having CG gas lines laying on the ground the protective covering off the retractable is not working need to make sure you have the needed fire suppression system appropriately labeled shut off Etc so attention needs to be given in that area I'm gonna stop moving this and let you do that um best practices again um we identified Environmental Compliance and hazardous waste required in best business practice discrepancy again reference page 25 this one is pretty serious and needs some attention again completely fixable and um we could not um identify that the district had an established required environmental reporting system or a seror account we suspect there probably is one but during our um time on site
122staff we talked to just were not aware and it could be that we were not talking to the correct individuals um vehicle maintenance and Fleet recommendations I put the slide in there just so you know that you can quickly go and um identify them on that page okay um delivery models here's probably your highest interest option one we we created three options for the district to consider but it's kind of built into four um option one has two pieces to it depending on how you look at it so option one is the internal external Services provided with or without the district supported vehicle maintenance that does not mean shutting down your vehicle maintenance program here that's not what PTI is suggesting we're talking about bus fleet this actually has very little to do with the
123best business practices we just reported it's going to have to do with what the district is facing in their Fleet replacement and a way to offset that so please keep that in the Forefront of your mind the model continues the practice of utilizing the external a uh external Transportation um provider solicited through a competitive bid process which we would highly encourage the district can choose to either continue to maintain its own Fleet of school buses or have that contractor provide um a fleet of buses in consideration of the model the district um if the CH District chooses to utilize um a um internal the model for maintenance um pay close attention as we talk about the replacement needs and the cost associated with that uh project expense for Option One external service provider but using
124the district's Fleet so in essence what you have right now just another service provider solicited for um the uh District replacement bus purchase no grants are calculated into this you surely would be able to get some grants but we don't have that Crystal Ball but you're looking at about $6.2 million if you were paying for those buses um out of the district's budget does that need to be done in one year no but it you we would suggest to the district that you're a bit behind and aggressively applying for those EV electric vehicle grants um um the district will probably Faire very well with this unduplicated count there's a lot of factors that are calculated when those grants are being weighed but the more grants you get the further down the line you fall the
125grants could be 100% it could be as low as 25% so it's just not known so we gave the worst case Factor there service provider and District supervisor support expense would be be approximately 2.2 to 2.7 million very comfortable with that figure we had a client in the last 60 days that has a district EUR size they maintain their Fleet so that service provider for profit is um just providing the drivers essentially and minimal and Staffing um and that organization and that is their current uh budget for such the total expense would be approximately $8.5 to9 million for option one with the district maintaining its own Fleet uh projected expense external provider um including um external Fleet in other words the contractor comes along with their buses and maintenance team to support those buses the
126service provider Fleet would be about four point would move up to about 4.7 to 5.5 million I've padded that by about 5% Administrative Assistant District personnel there would be about 54 55,000 service provider and District supervisor support expense between 2.2 2.7 million for total uh expense of 8.5 to 9.0 but then we add on the salary D benefits based at 43% for about 24,000 Health and Welfare for that one District Personnel of 18,000 for a total expense of option one with an external Fleet being provided of 4.8 to 5.6 um million option two is a joint Powers Authority for uh Pupil Transportation uh with interest in surrounding school districts you do not have a a projected expense there because we have no way of doing that without identifying who those Partners um might be however
127we gave you uh very detailed um um instructions as to the legal setups for that essentially with a jpa you're creating another Lea uh you participate in uh jpa now I'm sure uh there has to be time for that filing though and what have you but it's a formal it's not a Cooperative Arrangement like you have with hemt right now it's a formal Arrangement it's it's a big deal um and we would recommend that you know most successful when there's two or more um I um can call out across the state we don't have any in Southern California large outside of the merge insurance and risk jpa for the El Monte High School El Monte Elementary um Mountain View and um rosem meat Elementary School District and their Charter of services they identified Transportation as
128a matter of fact heet was their provider it's one reason they could reach out and service you historically so well um the Whittier Transportation Cooperative you may have heard of them they were in place for about 25 years and just unfortunately disbanded about two years ago due to a a tragic incident and they decided to disband however Northern California West Sonoma County schools has 18 districts belonging to a jpa uh the Southwest Transportation agency in Fresno County is a jpa with around 17 or so schools and then there's another handful of smaller jpas of two three and four districts um mainly up in the um Bay Area and a couple Sela special education local planning areas have jpa for transportation but again no costs projected with that uh option three um District internally owned and
129operated Transportation program uh under this model uh belflower unified would transition transition to a fully staffed uh District operated transportation system this would involve assuming full internal responsibility for all transportation services including fleet Fleet Maintenance Fleet replacement um uh employing drivers employing the manager employing dispatchers employing the um State Certified instructor which is all Spilled Out in the report the district will need to contract for transportation services and our opinion until such time the district has the designated routes and is staffed appropriately I'm going to talk why that's a pretty big deal here when we get to um the conclusion next projected expense for an internal District program is we're basing a district base salary at 150,000 an admin assistant payroll 55,000 roou planner dispatcher that's two individuals if you're wondering why for 14 routes
130it's because the transportation day starts a lot earlier than when most come to work and it ends a lot later after people so they can overlap so we built in two individuals there for a base salary of 147 a State Certified instructor at 72 14 certified school bus drivers to match currently what the level of service is at 7 about 52,000 three cover drivers that brings you up a little bit above the 10% % uh we typically recommend in all agencies for 161,000 salary uh driven benefits at 43% 575,000 health and well welfare for District staff approximately 396,000 and that figure comes back in again there of 6.2 for replacement and purchase We Believe on the team that that's the elephant in the corner for the district on this decision is the bus replacement issue
131but we'll have a suggestion here for you on that than um it's our opinion that in the best interest of the district we're we're we're driven by the fiscal dollar and the long-term support of the system and the ease of which to manage that system running a transportation department I'm not going to say it's any more complicated than food nutrition or maintenance and operations or it Etc but having sat in the seat for 42 years um there's a tremendous amount of federal on local liability that's why I I I discuss we discussed so much about the shop there I think there's some attention that would need to be given to support and replace that Fleet and and do what you're being forced to do by the California air resources board um and option one the
132external uh services provider with or without the support of the vehicle maintenance team so the selection we propose that you could go either way but we suppose you kind of stay in the same situation in now and you just look for an external service provider to replace what you no longer will have with him at unified you could do that or you could look for an arrangement where when you go out to bid you one you go out to bid looking for the provider to provide the buses along with the drivers or you could write that bid such where the district continues to support the fleet but if the district cannot keep up with the replacement of the fleet you have you know a a contract article that'll allow you to have the provider augment
133with their Fleet doesn't mean you have to stay in that position the district's able to get some bus grants and get more buses then you can back out of that and and keep that balance you know that you're most comfortable with but what I do want to read here almost word for word for you is point two sub point two and three and that's the looming challenge of the fleet replacement in response to the carb zero Mission goal which mandates that all new vehicles purchase after 2035 will be emission free that impacts you and I as much as it does your school bus fleet out here but additionally for your Fleet the looming challenge of the fleet replacement is affected by the Advanced Clean Fleet ACF requiring state and local governments to phase in zero
134emission Vehicles as of now as of January 1 anything you go out to buy or grants you go after must be 50% or more zero and by Janu jary 1 or excuse me um my other date there January 1 2027 100% you might be looking at that and go that's not quite Fair because you just said 2035 well there's additional layer of Regulation put on you as a public Fleet to make sure you achieve that zero um rating so right now if you go out to replace there's really nothing you can buy unless it's a gasoline engine bus or a zero emission um electric bus and the uncertainty of knowing the district would be successful achieving enough Grant Awards to significantly offset the need for the fleet to modernized to EVs and the related infrastructure
135uh unfortunately the district did not participate in the most recent Grant Award of this nature there's another opportunity here and I could say with pretty good confidence you'll get some buses out of that what we can't say to you is will you be successful at getting 100% compensation for those buses it could be a state voucher system where you're getting about 40 50% of the cost of the bus sharing in that but you're picking up the full infrastructure or you can stack grants that's commonly done I did it for years you go out with your local utility that will gladly bring the electric which they've done in part to you now for the I believe you have five electric buses now on you're going to need to increase the the um amount of electric coming
136into the yard though um and you could stack those we just do not have a way of projecting that and projecting it soon enough um for you that's why I talked about that other option and and uh um with the district going out to contract and setting a clause in place that they could augment with the dis the uh contractors um buses the other item we're very concerned about is the transition time if you go Standalone you're in the middle of a national school bus short or a North American school bus driver shortage so when I set at the desk at powerway for 33 years and during that we offered very lucrative contracts and we had above average benefit package and I usually ran at no more than 5% opening we started noting about a
137year or two before the pandemic that we were increasing up to about 15 um percent and a lot of that just had to do with the more stringent regulations placed on recruiting what that driver must meet the federal standard drug and alcohol ET Etc this is all kind of sad but it all played into the T we would bring in 10 drivers and we'd be lucky if we got 10 out of that the uh the pandemic hit and coming out of it we're just being blown out of the water the contracts we're going under now to help districts are for the first time looking at moving them to an external provider doing a shared uh model of service are actually for very small districts moving them out of school buses and moving him into what
138we call non-conforming but regulated passenger vehicles you're not small we would never recommend that here that might be an option for a few special ed students done correctly under the requirements of sb88 which came into place this past January but we don't think it's a an option that you can face to move the number of students that you're looking at so we think that recruitment of drivers we can't say for certain if the drivers with himt will just love to jump and come over and take the positions at Bellflower we don't even know those drivers that may have been employed by belflower what they're being compensated at himt or how many of those drivers but we understand from himt they're augmenting with a lot of D several drivers now not a lot several drivers that
139are commuting from the Hemet region out here so I I for a position that historically isn't full-time don't know if that would or would not be in the district's you know perview um we have a lot of of concern there but again the elephant in the corner is that Fleet and that's what I think probably should be at the base of driving you know know your your perspective going forth so with that said I think that's my last slide um that's all I have and I'll answer questions for you thank you thank you before we open up for questions I have one question so I we have three options one two and three but two we haven't looked to partner with anybody or spoken anybody so that's not really an option correct if you're discussing
140the jpa that would be we would need quite a bit of time to go out and actually communicate with other entities to find out would they be interested in partnering with this whether that be a jpa as mentioned or another District to form a jpa from scratch so in your expert opinion because I don't I'm not even sure why that's in the presentation if it's not an option how long would that take to be able to do that it's in the presentation because it was a uh a staff interest when we were previously involved and we do consider it a viable option we just couldn't price it out for you without to answer your question specifically important though and I'm like if we wanted to direct staff to do that how long would be well
141to do to do an assessment we it could be turned around very quickly however um we looked at this somewhat in an emergency situation that you need a provider by next year one way or another a typical jpa will take anywhere from three to five years the West Sonoma County jpa took they hired the executive manager four and a half years before the doors ever opened the West County uh or excuse me the um Southwest Transportation agency told me uh today um they were in discussions for about six years what um if I may um you're pulling together one two three four five business partners from around you they might not need to be contiguous with your boundary but they need to be regionally located because you're all joining into a service to benefit one
142another and you think well okay but there's a common need and scale and size will save and it will it would potentially be the best option on there if you could pull it and put it together however then come the more challenging items and that's when you have five superintendents and five School boards that are sitting down and now having their Bell schedules dictated to them because they all want to have 8:00 or 8:15 or 8:30 dismissals this has been compounded by the secondary later start time so those steps can all be overcome but that's the reason there's no price there because it would take a deep assessment and if we were up here presenting that to you right now we'd also be concluding with saying you need to have kind of what I'm already
143telling you here too if you decided to go internal you're still going to need another external provider to assist you for one to five years um as is I'm very concerned about that if the district would decide to go internal let's say to find a um external provider that will come in and have interest a bid a one two or threeyear contract is not impossible but I'm working with two of your neighbors right now somewhat close neighbors and they're looking at the long term and one backed out even bidding so I left them with one one bidder right and I appreciate that um and I know you started this in October 2024 but this conversation's been going on for many years in our district so this is something that in a way I feel like
144we should have been prepared on okay so I'm going to open it up to my colleagues question questions um clerk critchfield all right I have a lot thank you for being here uh very thorough report uh I enjoyed reading it um is very impressive um so I want to start with um the let me see I have a lot of notes [Music] um the so I had there was a a I had requested information from previous staff and it any any criticism of of the history of this is uh nobody's here anymore um who was giving this information but the board was given some pretty bad information when this conversation first started so some of this is new for instance this board was told that we had 600 students uh riding our buses uh at
145a board meeting uh which now we're saying it's closer to the 263 yeah I I can tell you that there'll be some flux in that 263 but just and sheer routes alone right yeah yeah this never makes more sense now out of that 263 you said 139 were General add and 124 are sped um how many I don't think we said how many are using uh The Hop skip Drive oh we have um I think that's in the report I don't have it or I or we may not know I'm not sure okay I didn't see it okay if it's not I can I can find that out for you but that's the more expensive of the the it wasn't um I apologize if we did not put that in the report it wasn't a
146staggering number um I mean it didn't stand up like I said we look at 5% of the total and it wasn't anywhere close to that okay um and it was we have 62 parents that opt to okay um and hemet's cost all right I'm gonna be Petty for a second sure just a moment yeah very very briefly worries I know we keep saying that hamet's unable to continue Services we broke up with them they didn't break up with us I'm just I'm being petty but the the the contracts started going up pretty significantly and questions started coming up then all of a sudden they're saying they can't do it but it's a cost thing understood and and uh uh Madam president Stuart mentioned it but there is a lot of history here and I think
147that the way this whole conversation started or how it was uh they used we used to do it all internally that's correct is that correct many years ago yes and I had asked uh for information on our cost when we did it internally and then we we moved away from that um the reason that I was told was to save cost to to contract with Hemet and I I was looking at this uh like aess seven-year chart and we did save money for two years but then we were spending more money going with Hemet than we were paying when it was internal um so I I I do we have that information or is that Austin if you're asking we can look into some of that what we don't have is the you know rising
148cost of had we maintain the bus drivers and such and the you know salary increases the benefit cost increases and stuff like that so I can try to find the document that you're referring to and and try to kind of backtrack that that'd be helpful I'll I'll give it my best shot thank you you there are examples you could turn to in the state this is not an unusual sized program we could might have some of that on record myself also did that contract start in 2011 12 is that right I believe the hmet contract started I I I want to say a little later but yeah and I think um we we continued services with PTI for these kind of inquiries so that's definitely something that that look to help them put out that
149year because there was a we've done about 300 assessments over 25 30 years in the state we saw a lot of districts begin to move because of escalating labor cost and Driver shortage to be honest with you it was affecting student services and Ada and also districts were shutting down their genad non-mandated not because they wanted to but because safe cost it was really to put those drivers into sped so where there's mandated Transportation I just offer that up as one reason cost started to go up quickly okay um so I would be interested in that and also uh in when we talk about the expense for uh internalizing uh the internal yeah I I know we have the uh the the bigger number of that includes the bus uh replacement um but those the
150buses currently would be uh we just have to phase them up by 2035 if you can back up yeah right there right so like when we we talk about the overall cost couple questions on this so the replacement of the buses obviously you mentioned it's a big deal and we have I think two or four electric buses currently I think there's five five electric and over over the next 10 years we we could replace uh those and go for Grants and I I I think I think were we moving forward on getting a grant riter we are okay um I think that that would be really beneficial but that cost I mean that's the biggest number out of all of them and it it uh has like some sticker shock to it but that six
151million of that would be for those those buses over the course of the 10 years right so the and and we have made some investments in this direction correct we had made a hire uh earlier in the year for uh transport right when we started talking about this I'm sorry can you say that one more time didn't we make an additional Transportation higher to start going in this direction not that I'm aware of I think we have a staff member over there that was under a different classification maybe we were identifying the classification but there's the the staffing has not um increased in transportation okay and so out of that that shopping list there uh what do we currently already pay for because I know we have how many bus drivers do we already employ
152because I know we have staff that are bus drivers as well right you have mechanics that are able to drive some of them are drivers mechanics and some are mechanics drivers if I understand that correctly okay so we currently have uh zero bus drivers that are employed that's that's correct those those employees can drive the buses but then they won't be working on the vehicles okay so we consider those employees our backup but our mechan they're there to work on the buses maybe I can help you have one FTE that the district is paying I believe 50% for it's it's a data technician I believe that um and 50% um him is paying for that currently the budget doesn't identify specific Al um any other dedicated um transportation staff that's not so unusual in anot
153model because it's all kind of conglomerated you do have someone on interim assignment and you do have I guess a bus driver that could drive we we would really caution against that though okay and so like the admin Administrative Assistant um that that wouldn't be somebody that's already employed that would be an additional hire yeah it's the the person that's out there now I mean this is not part of our task but I think I believe they're um classified as a u a data technician which is a little bit odd to us um so that person I guess if you're trying to compare would be closest to the administrative assistant that we're calling payroll the route planner dispatcher which is the work that that person is doing out there um is kind of what you're
154you're referencing there so you know you would look at you know uh 60 70,000 before uh salary driven benefits and health so we we already have one person that does that currently yeah that you're paying 50% for I believe I'm right there correct yeah so what I'm trying to get at is I wonder like what the actual price tag would be to have it uh internal if we were to factor in what we're already paying for and the the longer term investment in the buses over the 10 years yeah I think you could if you go back to um go back to option one cost thank you and too far back it's option one then go one one more I think okay go there um so projected expense there and I think this might be
155kind of Mr crfi what your you're asking there is and that service provider um that's not a good one go one more go to the next cost for that one sorry right there um that might help answer that question there because you have the administrative assistant District personnel which is the person we're talking about okay MH and then you have um well you would have if you're asking for that cost then I would go with the 4.8 to 5.6 million you're bringing up an interesting fact regarding the fleet though and I just want that's an elephant in the corner that you need to be really careful with because as the SE the the district has a the full CNG Fleet right if something major goes down on that Fleet right now you're not going to
156be able to get the the part for it matter of fact I think that's why we saw the number of vehicles rout so we think that's going to escalate on you um quickly there is my guess I I had 40% of powerway Fleet of 200 buses and we had to prematurely replace about 60% because we simply couldn't get the support for those they're not being supported in California so yes you're going to get some grants yes you're going to get some grants that are 100% 75% 50% 25% but the district is going to have a substantial hit there what's going to happen is I would imagine depending on the mileage of that CNG Fleet Etc you may end up having to kick in some dollars to move that along a little bit more quickly you
157know but why where are we at the 4.8 5.6 uh as a reference as a as a total because that's the um external service provided um without um including the um external Fleet it went up that might not been the best example to use the contractor cost went up there and the reason the contractor cost went up there is because they're not only bringing the driver they're bringing the bus and presumably they're going to require that they maintain the bus so you're saying that that 2.7 would probably be the not the 4.8 okay so the the general cost for us would probably be about what we're paying right now without Fleet replacement with without with dealing with the buses uh with that timeline and and actually uh president Stuart and I went to the the
158yard was that yesterday um and and the what I gathered was that we could still get parts for those until 2035 no um cumins is the only CG engine manufacturer now in the country as of two a year and a half ago seed Ste an attempt to bring the engine into California because of the ratcheted up effect of the uh emissions reduction not zero just emission reduction they simply felt they couldn't make a dollar so for instance could make a fortune if I could go find diesel buses or compressed natural buses for clients right now all around you we can't so we're telling everyone to buy and buy quickly as many gasoline buses as you can because to your point after 35 you can continue operating what you have in place but you're not going
159to be able to replace it with the same type of fuel or what have you so for instance if you were sitting here on a pot of money and you were asking PTI you know what should we buy what have you we would not tell you right now to do 100% EV we would tell you for a unified district do about 80% you're going to save 20 or 30% on a fossil fueled bus because you have athletic teams that you have to take 15 50 miles down the road won't be able to get them home so this is a changing scenario right I know it's it's really nuanced and when you factor in time it because also the the cost of the the EV buses to replace now compared to what the EV might be
160in 2035 is going to be significantly different absolutely you're correct pH it out just one more quick question I'll throw it back um so the the the cost if we were to factor that in with the buses we're gonna you know maintain those and uh hire a grant Rider and go that route and see what we can get um if we were to do apples to apples as far as taking out the the replacement cost of the buses uh what would you say that is compared to uh vendoring out like we have been doing uh you're going to pay about 15 to 18% more for the vendor we do that analysis all the time so you might say well that's the answer to my question here it all depends on how at that you bring
161on the responsibility of the classified staff um the need to maintain ongoing not just initially but the recruitment of those drivers and and I truly want to stress with you that's not an easy task right now I know very few we have 20 or so clients under contract right now and I can only think of one that has their routes fully filled so you could be taking on the issue of instructional minutes kids not meeting the program programs what have you most of those organizations have already deleted you have a general Ed population in there and that weigh heavily on us M you don't have to provide services to that population so maybe you grab those drivers the other handful of small districts doing that and and please don't do this it's the safety of
162the students they're going to use all support staff their licensed drivers they're going to use vehicle maintenance staff that are licensed drivers and I'm I'm going to walk out on a limb here and tell you you cannot afford to do that in your vehicle maintenance program right now there's a lot of information here that you need to give some attention to it can be addressed it's not a problem but you do not want those individuals out there driving you know when you have buses that aren't being inspected every 45 days 3,000 miles you don't want to have that mechanic driving a route so I just caution you on that can I clarify one thing thank you so much for explaining that I know a couple times um Mr kitfield you've asked if we're hiring a
163grant writer I just want to clarify we're Contracting out with a grant writer we're not hiring an internal person I just want to clarify that I I have a question really quickly I understand the lack of bus drivers like you've we've talked about this you're not the only one that's told us that but I guess what I'm not understanding is whether we have our own Fleet or we partner out isn't there a lack of bus drivers either way yeah the only um challenge I would say that's changed since post pandemic and don't ask me why it's post pandemic I don't have that answer is that um the uh private contractors are able they're not paying as much as you frankly typically I don't know about him it um typically um but they can offer large
164contracts because they have multiple providers so for instance if belflower were to go out to bid right now those contracts that are going to come in that are going to be most competitive are going to be well I know one it's already in your Fleet right now and that's sta because they have local yard here um I know of two others that have local yards they're trying to keep their staff busy to keep their salaries up so they have they have deeper Pockets sort of speak with with the drivers I can also point out contractors that have a shortage in drivers as well we dealt with it with a client um um one of the main reasons himt is changing their Model A little bit is due to merge um they weren't able to fulfill
165because of a shortage of drivers it became a service issue and it's all special Ed children there as a result um they decided to um play it safe and we awarded not to one but to two outside contractors so when one Falls in staff the other one picks up and it does this and it's worked beautiful doing that you're managing two contractors of course in that Arrangement okay um any questions any other questions yes um this one is directed to staff um it's a here we're approximately transporting 139 General students um and you probably have said this before but exactly what are the reasons we're transporting General students to different schools typically it's based on the distance that they live from the school that they're attending okay um so I see you want to say
166something there was also a program offer when we closed a program at one school and transferred the program to another school um that that is pretty impactful and that's um the distance to the schools is is when we have to place them at other schools because we don't have the space in a current school which as you know based on the dropping enrollment and the number of classrooms we can offer and the students that's that's what we're doing so is it safe to say that we would need to also look at um our how we do that this upcoming school year and maybe um being a little bit more organized yeah we will be organized we we just have incredibly small schools that require some of these things the offering of the transportation is what
167I feel like we're going to need to look at more what's required to be offered is is what we need to look at more okay um and then thank you for answering that question um I my next question is um do we have a plan for um this upcoming summer for esy and their transportation needs so um that's what kind of uh Tim touched on I um he didn't get quite the answer I did talk to the CBO at hemt and asked if there was a need to finish out the summer if that was a possibility um we're going to need to move forward with um a a contractor regardless given the time frame of Summer and the new year so we're going to have to do that fairly quickly and if that contractor can
168provide those summer Services that's what I'd prefer to kind of make that movement work with that new contractor in that time frame of the summer when the bus routes are smaller and the number of students were transporting are smaller um so that we can get a good feel so around when would we need to have that forward to the board to be able to provide those services without any lack of um we're going to need to go out with a bid fairly quickly and then that would be the six to eight we process we've talked about with the board so um as soon as we can get that direction we'll go out with the bid and then we'll come back with an award and that's when I would probably use PTI and uh to figure
169out the best mechanism for kind of moving forward with that contractor so we're looking at somewhere um making sure that we have a contracted service for summer by around March i' like March or April I'd like to make sure that summer and the and the next school year yes just to be safe okay um and then my next question have we ever found um it says here that it appears that the district is being invoiced my concern is the word appears so are we having um all those invoices come in correctly a timely manner might be a choice of words on my part we like to go in and see a contract and analyze the contract I'm very uncomfortable with that I would have liked to have told you you're paying a b daily base
170rate of this and this many hours and when you go over your base rate you pay an inflated price of this we don't have that type of contract we have a a limited Services Cooperative contract that really doesn't talk necessarily what we were provided cost at all um however we looked at invoices so I think we looked at October and November so I simply took that times it times 12 and told you that's probably padded a little bit because of the summer months um in there now I suspect somewhere at some time a rate sheet um you reference the um cost going up so some somewhere something exists that shows we're increasing you know 58% and if I may in the weed a moment I'm so sorry um we have about four clients right now
171within the LA Basin and Orange County and their external contract costs have gone up at a minimum of 16 and a half percent to a high of 27 up on the Great Vine a high of 27 and 3/4 percent and I thought well this answer is that you know inside organizations we started comparing that to districts have um the increases districts have paid over about the time um coming out of covid and um with Supply expense fuel Etc and it almost was on par um with another one and for the record I'm not here to Advocate whether it be an internal program an external we want the best for what's good for the kids of Bellflower here and what's prudent I just want to point those factors out here because costs have risen tremendously and
172I'm sure you're seeing that with classified staff across the board okay thank you um with regards to uh the program fleet vehicles um Replacements um the ticket system are we anywhere near looking at a organizational system that works we're we're starting that process I think in um August Patrick brought a report to you guys that talked about the maintenance process of utilizing a system so one of the things that's come up is you know what are some other systems out there so again this report thank you to PTI was asked for went to board in October and turned around within two months and they spent many days on our campus looking they talk to principes they talk to um transportation staff they talk to fiscal staff so the turnaround on the detail of this report
173is super helpful but we did just receive it over the December January time frame so we're going to start looking at the recommendations and and likely start bringing forward those um you know the needs for the software and the needs for the inventories those kind of things is definitely on the docket and probably some of the most prioritized things that we need to do first okay perfect and also um some of these pictures um I'm sorry it looks almost like I'm looking at my my son's bedroom um he's a teenager so uh our we already working on that I mean I it I agree it's an easy fix so okay do would you like to come up and say something I see you nodding please thank you so much yes board members board president Rick
174Sanchez the transportation out of service outof class Transportation manager I'm one of the mechanics I've been here for with the district for 21 years started off as a mechanic and then lead mechanic and I'm still handling lead mechanic duties as well as I was just working on the floor this morning on a school bus because we just got a new mechanic hired fortunately in October right before they showed up because we were short staffed and we had been since the the pandemic our previous uh lead mechanic retire retired in December of 2019 three months before the pandemic hit and we were just running short staff since then um so as far as uh the the housekeeping I I I took a class with Tim with the uh a Caso class for a director of Maintenance
175uh what it called Transportation Leadership Academy with casbo paid for out of my pocket because I wanted to increase my knowledge to be able to uh be prepared for this position had it come available and I learned a lot and i' learned that he provided this service uh through PTI and I actually gave them a call and kind of got the ball rolling for them to come down and to look at our transportation department and see our teenager room that we're working on and as as an answer to your question yes we are currently working on it we have a lot of things in the shop that do need to get cleaned up and put away I am looking at additional uh Fleet Maintenance software inventory software these are all things that definitely need to
176be implemented um again we just hired a new uh technician who was very good at Diagnostics which we lacked since uh I had been pretty much by myself uh with the other uh technicians that we have that are mechanic bus drivers or bus drivers service mechanics so now we actually have a true mechanic position technician who is actually really helping to get some of these buses that uh Tim had seen that were out of service CU I just didn't have the time to uh properly diagnose and get it back on the road uh this guy Mr CIO uh who's working for us now since October uh has able to get three or four of these buses backup certified and inspected by CHP since Tim has been here so we are working on that um but
177as far as uh getting the the work that needs to be done I'm glad I have the report I have all the pictures and this is something I'm going to be going over with my staff so we can go through and address these and get it taken care of and invite you down to take a look and hopefully you'll see that we cleaned it up and we didn't just shove everything in the closet any questions thank you one more question um so you're saying that the system that we currently have which are um Mr uh Sanchez um we had purchased before uh Mark who was our lead mechanic previously had purchased uh we had looked at a dolphin Fleet software very limited very inexpensive because we weren't looking at spending a lot of money and
178it was just didn't integrate very well um so we would want to and I'm in the process of that right now looking at a little bit more robust uh user interface friendly software package for our uh Transportation vehicle Fleet Maintenance not just uh the bus fleet but also the White Fleet as well and it's and that's going to be a challenge too because we got older guys who aren't very technologically savvy and they're used to handwriting uh repair orders rather than they're going to have to input all of this on a computer now so a little bit different so but definitely a lot of growing but definitely something we can do for sure okay thank you for mentioning that problem that way we can also you know give that allow for that typ so be
179be prepared for when I get those estimates and present them to the board because uh a lot of that stuff is not cheap those software packages and like with everything now everything is cloud-based now so there's not only just the the initial outlay for for the software package there's also going to be an annual an annual renewal to to use that software which most uh software packages use now okay thank you um I believe I'm I'm done with my questions thank you so much thank you board member sron I just wanted to make a a a few comments to Mr Sanchez first um a lot of my questions have already been answered um or asked and answered but Mr Sanchez I wanted to give you kudos for spending and investing in your education to be
180able to rise and get the work that needs to get done done so I really appreciate it and I know that looking at a report usually beats us up yes um but also gives us an opportunity to fix what actually needs to be fixed especially if there's an outside person looking in right um and I'd like to make a comment about when you're presenting things for us to look at for software and things like that I would also suggest to include training of that software for your staff for you and your staff um because I'm sure there's going to be upgrades there's going to be training for those upgrades as well so um please keep that in mind cuz I definitely feel like you know we're everyday students so I really really appreciate you and
181thank you so much for willing to come up and answer our questions sure thank you very much I appreciate absolutely I'm going to get back to you I know you have a few I just want to say a few things honestly in my mind I don't think we have an option I think the option is number one because basically we have no choice I believe that we should have our own internal Fleet you just said that costs are going up 16 27% we already have the buses we have this huge beautiful maintenance that we've seen that's what I believe I should I believe we should be running our own like we used to in the past before it was brought back but I also understand that it's not feasible right now we can't do that
182so it sounds like we're going to have to contract for outside for esy anyways I would just love to maybe look at a contract that's not super long so that we do have time to look at option two and talk to different people or we do have time to look at Grants to get buses or things like that so for me I would be in favor of just going with someone outside obviously um and still looking at the other options because I do believe that we should have it within as far as the other things I'm going to be honest I'm pretty frustrated with this report because there's a lot of problems with this I mean I'm just going back to like number one we're supposed to be inspecting every you know 45 3,000 and
183we're not doing that um I'm sorry oh sorry Brad's talking when he's not supposed to and it's distracting me um um the shop had no evidence of accurate and updated vehicle lists there do not have established standards of replacing programs of fleets or flat tires the maintenance repair I mean this is a lot of stuff that we're not doing I'm so kind of glad our legal council's not here because he'd probably be flipping out and we probably should be providing him with this because this is opening us up to a lot of lawsuits a lot of things that could be happening because we're not I mean these are like it's like not following an IEP in my mind these are things that the state is requiring that we're not doing and I do understand and
184I do want to say again the people that are in place right now have not been in place so it's not on them so please everyone know that I'm not talking about you guys but it's disappointing to see this report and how out of compliance we are in so many areas I mean so many areas that's disappointing so I understand we're going to start cleaning that up I get like the tidying up and things like that but we need a system to document this and I understand the where we're looking at but can we get some type of report or who I guess it probably would be the superintendent who is overlooking to make sure this happens and when these things almost like our fig matat report can we get a 1 two 3 4
185five this is done this is done this is done do you know what I'm asking Mrs Alo yes we can provide you an update along the way absolutely thank you and I don't mean to be critical but again this is litigation this is safety of our children this is safety of our employees there's a lot to this so this is a little bit frustrating I'll take it back to Mr critchfield thank you madam president um what one quick question uh the GPS system that we had uh gotten how much was that how much did we invest in that because I I believe that was one of the things that we talked about if we were to do it internally we'd need that GPS system for all of our buses to track them but um how
186much was that I'll look into that and get back to you okay um um thank you um I agree fully uh with President Stewart um again I think the history of this situation matters and again the report is great the all good information I'm sure staff is going to take it uh and it's only going to help us uh grow but you know when the the way it was done with our our classified staff in the beginning was terrible I ended up in law it it became a legal matter and it just wasn't good I think it it it hurt the culture of our district I think one of the things that we've been working really hard is restoring that culture and and just me like I think uh you know I'm sure that the
187hmet bus drivers they're great and I would really be curious to see if we were to ask like how many because a lot of them live here but they're working for hemt Unified School District bus like how many of them would just stay here and hire on with us I mean it seems like a no-brainer if they're already doing the job um but I also think it's important to have stability for our kids when they get on the bus to see the same person have that anchor person who they want to see every day I think it it it it speaks to safety of our district it speaks to the culture of our district and I would be uh that would be my ideal is to have an inro and I understand that it's more
188work there's there's a lot of things that come with that and I agree with Miss D if we need to find something in the interim to give us time to make this work but the facility is great our staff are more than capable and able to make meet those recommendations uh I think we have a lot of great stuff going on over in that Transportation yard and I I think it would be awesome to have it be ours and and take some pride and ownership in it but again if if going a different direction for a a limited and uh Set time uh I would be I'd be okay with that as well may I offer a suggestion um hearing and I concur um first of all um do not feel isolated or alone I
189would say about 30% of our assessments identify our heaviest areas vehicle maintenance even over operations believe it or not what is very different here is the attitude of the Personnel we worked with when we walked in here was Superior it was excellent it was transparent took us everywhere um honored it and I'll say owned it okay and there's a plan you have a checklist start start with that but what I I think um you're in a very serious situation because I don't if we have a special ed person in the in the audience here but those esy esy class lists and promotions are going to be happening in April or May you need to have that contractor in place I might suggest that you go out and you openly advertise for a one-year contract with
190four years renew up for Renewal um it's a kind of a standard you know to get to that fiveyear um we want to be honest and transparent business partners I'm not suggesting that but that gives you the flexibility to take the time to make the decision you ultimately want to make for your program also it gives you that opportunity I don't know maybe Rick has a treasure chest of CNG Parts I don't know but if some if he doesn't and something goes Haywire right into that contract a segment where you can augment with the district's Fleet something I didn't point out very well is for those routes are not being done by himt or the district's Fleet I believe they're being done by sta yes so it's important to note that okay just a suggestion
191right could you could you repeat that again so four of the routes are done by 12 routes being performed um Hemet is augmenting with a subcontract to student transportation of America to do four and they're using their four buses st's buses okay it's a subcontract so the it's coming out of what we're already paying H they're paying or are we paying that separately I understand is they're paying they're so it's not a separate bill it's not a separate bill but it shows to the usage of hemt not being able to staff their staff to support our schools and therefore they're subing Contracting out their work at least four of the routes and those buses as Tim mentioned are using their buses their Fleet so they contracted out with the intention for them to use their
192Fleet okay I have a question really quick just it might be a silly question but I know we're saying there's 14 routes typically and I'm not sure if you can answer that or maybe you guys can't answer but how many buses are being used at one time in a day cuz it's more than 14 routes I'm assuming there's field trips or things like typically how many buses do we use in a day excess take the field trips out for a second so those um it's terminology I'm sorry we should start you know a route is usually made up of many runs think of a run matching a school so ideally for a unified district it's hard right now with the secondary late start times but you would build a route with two runs in the
193morning and two runs in the afternoon we didn't do a deep routing analysis here but if you're doing that you're probably going as as efficient as you could I looked at your ratio of student load and what have you and you were right in the norm generally for special ed General Ed we didn't calculate because we understand a lot of those General ed students are coming from a special not a specific program but there's a reason a boundary issue so it doesn't really matter what the number is there so based on the number of students you have have the and that's why you didn't see in the proposals we stayed right with the 12 routes um because the reason I'm asking I might just ask it a bit I me I need to ask it
194better um is we have 32 buses and we're saying it's very important that we replace the buses but are we using 32 every day I guess that's where I'm going with that no no no no and our our um replacement plan is not suggesting that you replace 32 buses so there's some things we don't address in here one is you in our opinion Rick Rick I you see what I'm saying if we're only using we probably have more buses than you need to have but our replacement was based on the bus and the bus type with a few extra models and we padded that we didn't plan that 6.2 million based on uh replacing 32 33 buses and I think um Rick and Patrick can probably tell you better than I many of the numerous
195buses are not oper operational at this time I believe I thought there was 32 operational and one that was not I okay so I don't know who can get that answer but I'm just curious as to how many buses do we use in a day I know we have 32 or you know what I mean how many do we use in a day I'm going to go ahead and pass it on to uh vice president Gara um how long does it take to train a bus driver recruiting is the is the thing let me walk you through this so you're recruiting for a commercial Drive there's very stringent background Criterion um for them so for a typical School District in a typical HR fashion you're recruiting and you don't want to run the class because
196the state mandated class is a minimum of 20 hours behind the wheel 20 hours um in classroom then you do District protocol specialized train what have you when I was a sitting director at a 65h hour class so it would take us approximately if our instructors weren't out driving a bus it would take us approximately six weeks was what what I expected and we considered ourselves doing a pretty darn good job if we yielded anywhere from 50 to 65% meaning driving a bus isn't a job for everyone and that's okay A lot of times those people phase out during the behind the- wheel portion um we were seeing percentages as high sadly as 12 to 15% that didn't meet distri Criterion meaning a host of things drug alcohol Etc once you do that you on
197board them you really need to spend some time with them heading in that bus all too often I don't think any of us do that well enough but we're suggesting a couple of months then the driver needs a minimum of 10 hours annually in retraining offered by a State Certified instructor on the presence of such and then fifth year year renewal of their commercial certificate they need to have what's a test here 15 of those hours I believe um done in renewal specific um classroom so it's it's a daunting task when you're yielding often half of what you set out to do so specifically if I had a driver three months after I hired him thought I was doing good Okay the reason I'm asking this question staff is because I'm thinking perhaps we have
198some students who are you know looking to go into maybe not perhaps bus driving but you know some type of training right out of high school um and maybe this is maybe something that we can look into with Cal it can I so uh that that's actually was uh looked into actually by that our former uh cab CEO Miss elabo she actually uh spearheaded that and did a lot of research and I think at the time that we found that it wasn't uh feasible uh with our our kids can't going that route um but it was something that was you could speak to it well I think one of the things that we all need to consider when you're looking at that is do you want an 18-year-old a 19-year-old driving a bus full of
199students so there's a maturity level that we all need to have right and some life experiences dealing with younger children and you really need to think about maybe what could that person do in between to gain some life experience before they're actually behind the wheel well said all right um and just thinking outside the box here as well um for um maybe you'll shoot this one down too and it'll be okay um maybe looking uh to partner up with some unions I'm not sure if they ever have I didn't hear the question unions partnering with unions yeah is that something that maybe we can look at there is one company in Northern California I know of a Mike Michaels transportation and that's the only company I've seen be able to pull together a union partnership
200and and be able to supply drivers um um they've made it where all the others have kind of failed I think it's kind of hard because you got I don't want to share mine when I have them because I never have enough in San Diego County I created a Cooperative trust for bus drivers and vehicle maintenance and I found out it was great as long as I was helping my neighbor now we were a big District but boy when I needed help just wasn't there you not because they didn't want to no I I I see what saying I just had to ask just for the one year you know time Gap that we need to fulfill this service for but thank you so much for your answer cler critchfield um so I I'll be
201I've been thinking about it here s sitting in the chair and we out of our 14 bus driers we for that we've endered through Hemet two of them drive from Hemet to here to drive to right I think I'm not aware of that so I don't know uh Patrick says all of them live local they eight Hemet bus drivers right because four being with p with the other vendor so the eight drivers for Hemet live local so I I'll be honest I don't even know where hemet's at how far away is Hemet oh it's long ways I drove it an hour okay so I'm I'm going to I don't know like say how many of the our bus drivers that live local are going to go back and drive for Hemet over there because do
202they have other contracts out this way they historically did and um you know as a side note my work with merge when merge left and himt went away that tremendously impacted you because they were using those resources they had they did some work for a district to the west of you here but I don't know if they still are it's my understanding though they have uh tremendously reduced what they call their ENT I think it's their Enterprise program um I picked up on that when I interviewed them but I don't know if that means they don't have any you know so so my my thought process is uh if they have reduced in hemts you know over an hour away they probably don't have the routes to give if if they don't have our contract
203are they going to have routes to give the bus drivers that are working currently and my thought is I I bet I bet we just already have our drivers and this is you you may I was not told they were all locally local to be honest with you they told me they were supplying about 10% from there so I guess those were backup drivers I don't know they told you 10% yeah so I'm Rick's saying no and I would trust Rick there so um but but remember there's eight drivers really you're talking about if they had some loyalty to himt and they don't want to stay local if they do that's good because I would think they'd want to but if they don't I assure you himt needs them in their own organization that's a
204very large Organization for transportation of well over 125 routes without all their uh support service contracts so because four of those drivers are sta remember that so okay well i' i' bet money that they're not going to drive an hour to uh but I I just think that that's a really good if there's a way to find out if they would just stay with us I mean it sounds like the only the the big difference between Contracting with Hemet and and not because we do all the maintenance and do everything ourselves anyway is just who's driving the buses so I I feel like the solution's like right in our face and the people are probably there and hiring is probably very difficult but I think that the the bulk of people would would be there
205and again I don't know you you guys are the experts but uh I I I feel I feel pretty good about that MH how many bus drivers do we need for ES why is it the same amount or is it a lower amount because it's not as many kids I don't know the exact number but is a significantly smaller amount because we're transporting a lot less students during ES1 can you kind of just give us maybe on Friday like an idea it doesn't even have to be exact but some you know obviously yeah I can definitely pull that number for you across the state it's onethird of your normal one3 okay yeah I I wouldn't expect in a in a a footprint that you have have here that would differ you know and based on
206your numbers too that you have so board member crfi um the we talked a lot about uh the uh the bus routes that we have and uh I mean is there some efficiency there that we could do as far as figuring out our bus routes and how to B like if we do have less drivers to like make it still work like are we looking into that I I would hope I gave you a percentage on the special ed side and that percentage Falls within the straight state number it's going to seem odd to you but if you're if you're transporting on average average not per one but on average in a unit 10 to 15 students you're hitting the Statewide average it's because of ride times most IEPs have Curb to curb pickup Etc
207there's many reasons for that the distance the kids are going Etc so it didn't fall out of line here's my educated guess though I'd like to believe in my heart I've I've been in a lot of organizations where himit has been that they would want to run as optimally as they could especially when they didn't have the Staffing themselves over the last couple of years that typically internally like it or not even if the boss of a for-profit contractor may be saying more buses more buses more buses isn't going to happen because that dispatcher is condensing if that dispatcher can continuously condense five days a week four weeks a month Etc you probably have stumbled on an efficiency that can be permanently put in into place the number of students you're transporting for the number
208of routes doesn't seem too totally out of line so is it possible yeah it is it would take a routing analysis but one other thing you guys are doing it right that data technician that's in place out there that individual is creating the route you're not handing it over to the person that's selling you the bus or to use to also tell you how many buses you need your District person and she's very sharp we were very impressed with her she's creating that route and handing it over to your service provider that's why you saw our projections set up the way they are that if you continued and if even on the short term you continue you continue to do that routing and oversee it with your M uh leadership team and that individual out
209there doing the routing don't change that okay so last thing I I'll say uh just a couple things uh it sounds like we're already doing a lot of stuff uh that puts us in a good position um and I know timing is still an issue uh we've already made some Investments uh in the GPS and and certain uh changes but uh the the routes seem to be a problem it sounds like that's a another just another one on the list of issues of running so many small schools and as we talk in committee about uh facilities and what we're going to do I think this is another thing to consider as far as efficiency and finance and as far as a lot of the stuff in the report when it comes to the facilities I
210think it's another good reason why we should we should have went for a bond in 24 and why we need to get one in 26 um so I think that it there's a lot of work that we can do even outside this issue that's going to support this issue but uh yeah thank you just to clarify uh Mr Sanchez we are creating our own routes here in the district himit is not creating them no Hammet is still creating uh the routes and they were okay they were we had created these routes these these 12 routes plus well 13 um before Mark had retired and he was actually the last year of us having our own transportation manager before that he was 30 plus years as a lead mechanic the last year they made him Transportation
211manager but it was just too late with what was already in place as far as get moving to uh to contractor Hemet and um we had actually had a lot more routes than the 1213 and it was kind of bloated and he he paired it down and really worked on that and one of the things hemt sold as part of their service was they would do a route analysis and the software that they have that they purchase and they pay for this certain amount uh I forget what the the amount is but the dollar but what they did was they leveraged that dollar amount that they invested in their routing software and were able to contract that to different school districts and say we will do a route analysis for you give us all of
212your student database they would put it into their computer system and then they would put out these routes and before they did a route analysis for us they immediately said well we're definitely should be able to to reduce the number of routes by two or three routes and at the end of it uh Mark had did an excellent job it was already streamlined as good as it could get they could not fine-tune it any better so that's what we've been for the last since H has been doing our transportation to those 12 13 routes so I know we talked about looking at our routes do we work then with well we won't have him at now but who are we going to be working with to create our routes and change our routes staff well
213it sounds like the routes were created internally so I think and that's what's been using is what PTI is saying and nor is continuing with those routes so we'll continue the same pattern and that's what we'll look at when we look to get that external contractor is to maintain the routes that are working for us wait I'm confused I'm sorry you said they're not being made internally that hemet's creating them right yes Hemet does still create them so you are in what you're alluding to is that if we were to have our take our own transportation department no no no I'm alluding to we need routes redone pretty soon in the next six months and we need contracts and bu who is going to then do the routes whoever we work with externally or how
214does that work and if you guys don't know can you guys let us know that in the maybe Friday memo go ahead well we we would actually have to purchase our own routing software okay so and is that the software that we've been talking about that's part of the software we have we're talking it's a whole transportation software that we're looking at and that routing um would be inclusive gotcha okay yeah those two positions I call router dispatcher um those are the positions that do exactly what you're asking there they not only run the two-way radio but their their expertise and routing there and the position you have out there despite what you call it now my understanding was she managed those routes and himt told me they did so I don't know if there's
215just a history of she manages them but she didn't create them is that what I'm understanding yes corre okay can I share a little bit just from the cops experience about routing because we had to go through the same thing okay so my experience and I understand that that's a much smaller program in comparison to the entire District but what we would do in the cops program is we tried to determine the route we sent that information to Hemet hemt would then confirm it or make changes after they probably used the routing software and then sent it back to us and said well actually here's your route and it may have been the same or it may have been different so that's just an experience that I've been through with a very small program in
216comparison to the district I know we've talked about the software and that we need to purchase some of this software is that coming on next week or is that something we're looking to in the future it won't be on next week's board but we it is something that we're looking into okay um colleagues any other questions comments I just want some you mentioned the esy you you recommended to get a oneye with like a fiveyear option yeah so the partner knows that if you're not prepared to do whatever alternative you want in year two or year three or you year four they have the option to either back out themselves if they wish but two they have their escalators how you would normally do a five-year bid you really are only awarding it for one
217or two years we're doing it with a neighbor of yours right now with an option at five years you always best practice rebid but can I ask that that's the extended year service that's oh it would include include that but that's um is that it's close I mean you need to be moving on that we normally are building a bid for a client in the fall awarding it either right before the holidays or right now um and we do that just in case your existing provider doesn't Prevail they have to have time to move out and the new one move in and they're getting those class lists in April or May but what I'm curious is say if if we were to go the route of uh bringing it internal we wouldn't have like that
218extended year more than just this time around because you always have it yeah it says your summer routing your summer program but I would highly advise you I just do not think I'm a conservative individual I do not think that you can have the components in place and the expertise in place to put routing together here in the next couple of months have it efficient have the drivers in place and be ready to organize those routes and if you don't you're in violation of Fate now it's a serious serious situation we would sounds like a challenge we can do it no but but it sounds like other than just the the drivers which are mostly local anyway we already have the routes and well if I'm hearing correctly I mean your student numbers are relatively
219low overall um but they're appropriate for a district your size so that makes sense but so you could man a person knowing what they're doing and experienc in that job could manually route those students but here's what you're lacking and I'm still unclear as to if the district's building the rout or if him building I think that him's verifying the route and their routing system probably and it might come back with different rights and lefts if I'm following okay sounds good so that's the case that means that there's one person here probably and that's that data technician that has the history in their head that could take that on and and to some degree may already be doing it or may be doing very little of it and and get it in place but I
220um that is just a challenge to be very honest with you at this time of year and for the nature of those students the volatility of those students the legal requirement of those students I would not gamble with okay so it sounds like we should go for a contract for the esy and then can I point out one thing that we're not spending a lot of time talking about and I'm sorry I need to bring this back up but it was mentioned earlier in the report that we have a concern about the maintenance of our current vehicles and making sure that they're all meeting the current requirements so I know we're focusing a lot of time on the drivers behind the wheel but I think we also need to focus on the wheels that we
221have on the road and I'm wondering you know my concern is we have a lot in this report to address there are pages of it do we need to focus some time on that because if you're asking if you're thinking that we're going to get our own Department up and running you also have a lot of cleanup to do with the wheels that are on the road possibly I know some of it's minor we talked about some of it's minor but he also alluded to a couple of things that were major and one of them's a software to track what we're doing with those vehicles and as we had mentioned the training for the staff because I think it was mentioned that we're used to doing things paper pencil um so I just don't want
222to forget that component of it I know we're focusing a lot on the driver if CHP were CHP no fault of them great organization they're your objective Criterion um looking at it once a year they came in so you're satisfactory that's great um we came in Lu of the draw and there's um two to three buses I forget the number that exceed the 3,000 mile 45 day if that had in CHP that day with my team on board that bus would have been taken out of service on the spot if the particular investigating officer had chosen to look to see that there's a preventative maintenance program in place and staff could not have convinced them that there was be it electronically or manually that individual been over here talking to you as Ed code States
223and could have given an unsat terminal rating and shut it down immediately I'm giving you the worst case scenario there but I'm just telling you you had two at least two units that did not meet the 345 day inspection and excuse me Rick and Patrick but it wasn't known by staff until our team member found that so it it's very serious I concur with your superintendent I I would not rush this this is why we're saying a minimum of one year to turn we're talking about children's safety right we're talking about children on the bus I got you I got you I I I think we understand completely but I'm going to go back to something I wrote down that you said you said that our contract with him it was a g great contract
224and it was beneficial why because similar to your own cost if you were operating a system on your own and so I think that's where we're at with that I think we all I'm going to speak for myself and I think most of my colleagues I think that we understand we need something now we need a contract now we're not going to say like let's have our own maintenance right now but I do think that many of us want to explore that in the future and I think that's where we're at with this and that's what we're talking about is we want to look to that in the future we used to have it the cost we saw started to go up and then we're also talking about you said that there's a 16 to
22527% rise so I'm going to let you go ahead but I think that's kind of what you were going to say that's where I was going with it because with the obviously we all care about safety and that's the most important thing but the the they're using our buses right now so there's no real difference in we still have to do everything you just mentioned whether or not we do it internal or keep using Hemet drivers the reason why I think we're focusing so much on the drivers is because it sounds like uh with the exception of who's actually making the routes and it sounds like there's a debate there uh with the exception of that that is the only difference right now that I can see but the vehicles are the same and it
226sounds like we have a lot more Vehicles than we have routes and it sounds like uh like they're they're not on safe the ones that are being driven right now and there's a lot of work that we need to do on those but we have to do that anyway because hemet's not fixing our buses um board member sorry go ahead go ahead board member do you mind if she goes board member Gara oh or board member Centron C go ahead go go ahead because mine is um I'm looking more um a timeline there are a lot of things that we have to get done before we are ready and compliant with eyi um I think I think esy I'm sorry um so can we please have ASAP as fast as we can a timeline to
227the for to the board as to when are we going to be able to um you know have these routes for these kids a plan of pickup um drivers like all of it in excruciating detail please as as much as possible um so that way we understand where you're headed and we can then give you the better maybe the best support that we can as a board um because there seems to be a lot of things going on here that we need to address now at the same time so maybe prioritizing that list would be the best way to start taking some action or remember cars are you talking about if we were to go to that what it would look like in the future right now I'm talking about just now the present which
228is making sure that we're ready for the summer once we get that then maybe tackle what's going to look like in the future I think they said please correct me that we don't have we have to contract out for that we don't have anything possible yes so a timeline with that like what are we looking at right now to go out and get the contract like by because you did say March by March April but March April there's 30 days I think you guys told us that if we went to bid and to go everyone it would be about a 6 to8 week process to go to RFP bids get it please ask you're doing a really good job president Stuart yes so what I would hope is the direction that we all I I
229have heard tonight is that we all know that we're going to need to an external contract for next year yes to cover esy and the next year while we bring back to the board information regarding a process for developing something different if that's what the board's requesting so it needs to be immediate I'm going to reach out to PTI to help us uh go get a goto bid document for transportation and what I'm seeing is that it will need to be pulled together to bring back hopefully at a March this I'm guessing the March board meeting for a ward would be per would be better what I heard Tim say was that most um school districts that have done this are doing this in the fall so that's where we're at we're going to try
230to do this in the spring because we need to do this what I'm hearing from Alma is they're working on the routes now we're working on the students and the planning now so all of those factors are going to take into account what we're going to ask for but when we go out to bid we're asking asking for what we're doing now so we don't get into that much detail regarding routes and all of those plans and everything when we go out to bed we're looking for a contractor we have the information of what we're doing now the number of routes we're going to need the fact that we have our own buses be included all of those details can be included now so the the information for esy or next year aren't necessarily going
231to be the stop to us going out to bid and gaining that amount of time to look into to the other option would that timeline also include the maintenance that needs to be done on the current buses we have that's what I'm hoping that at at minimum that year timeline is allows us to do is get you know they did mention that we just hired in October a new um mechanic that is very skilled in the in that area and so we're starting to see Improvement in in the buses at this point but the other components of the contract that's what I'd like to be able to bring back to you and say these are some of the strides we've made towards completing um the recommendations made by PTI in our current service and those
232will be ongoing okay thank you B member Centon yeah so follow up just so I understand it better so you're saying that the the concerns in the report that will have that will also be like prioritized checklist and then we'll know and then I'm talking I'm talking aside from the busing routes and the summer needs and the students I'm talking about the actual we'll be working to provide the board updates with the concerns in that report as well and it and then would we have a timeline on this um some of them as you've heard tonight are easily fixed and probably already have been um and other ones are going to take longer so we're going to con entrate on the most serious ones at hand kind of like any task list that you'd probably
233take on you you'd kind of prioritize it in the way that make the most sense to safety of students safety of Staff right um those things so I don't have a timeline because we're going to put them in that order and we're going to start working on that list um but I hope to provide updates frequently so you guys will know where we're at okay thank you board member crfi so in just so I'm a little frustrated uh only because uh and again like President Stuart said it's it's nobody that's here but I just want to give you some insight to why I might be a little frustrated in 22 in our our contract Matrix I had uh brought up some concerns with the hemt contract uh staff you know said they we needed more
234time at the time and we uh approved that contract and uh nothing really happened and then it came up again in our contract Matrix in 23 and the board had a discussion and we said uh this is the last time that we're going to approve this contract and we want to explore other options and part of that conversation was to bring uh it internal and part of that conversation was exploring how that would uh work what it would take to make that work and the the presentation and the uh the report is great but when I Oh I thought when when we had had that discussion initially that it was a it was a uh report into what we needed to do to bring it internal and rather it's more of a comparing so for
235me it's uh you know a little hard to hear like okay esy we need it now it's we we get put in these positions where it's always like we have to do this now and but we've been talking about for two years so we keep getting put in this position where we have to do this now or else we're not going to be able to provide services but then I heard uh esy now and then I heard and for next year and it just feels like and I think that's why my colleagues talk about a timeline because sometimes it comes becomes a little ambiguous as to as far as when we're going to get things done because it seems like we keep getting put in the position where we're going to have our back against
236the wall at some point again so I I I think I want to I want to be clear on what I would would like to see is I would like to see us take the necessary steps to internal our transportation and bring the jobs to where there are workers driving our buses that's what I would like to see and I I know that's a a big task but that's where I'm at I'm in the same I know we need it now so I understand that I support that but I would like to see the same as well um vice president carza I agree and board member Centron absolutely and one more question this is all new well for me it is I don't I understand a lot more now thank you so much but is
237it possible I know I talked with our um intern superintendent about this but with the contracts when you have to go out do you have to name drivers could we start just trying to hire little by little internally and still use them or is that just not an option well it's always an option to write into a contract whatever you want but I have a a lot of experience with bid writing and I will tell you no because you're not going to get anyone to bid unless there's a uh a catch clause in there that if District um demands Fall by a certain percentage let's say 10% likewise if they increase it's an automatic escalator to renegotiate the cost because they've had to staff for it so for instance I have a client in a
238serious um financial crisis right now and it's going going to involve a lot of layoffs and Leadership what have you not really bus drivers but as a result they have a tremendous issue with uh driver attendance and as a result there could be an organized um work stoppage so we have put not one but two it's over a 100 routes two contractors in place and both those negotiations and I've done my best I have long business relationships with them and have helped them at times and probably been their worst enemies I had to negotiate on behalf of the district a minimum of 10 20 or 30 routes and this is 170 some odat routes but whether they use them or not you're paying for them so I would and it's not feasible to have a
239plan that goes in fact where we say okay we're going to go 25% internal out I think you just kind of answered that but you know what I mean where you could like Pace it like the next year we're going 75% or so that we could move in that direction yeah actually we have um well neighbor another jpa merge has two contractors um working for them and we wrote it where we guarantee each a minimum but one's really doing over 60% because the other one can't I want to make sure you hear me on that okay but that could flip next week so there's that situation historically we would never have suggested awarding to more than one vendor but we are suggesting that sardino County Schools um Riverside um are all of such size that
240one contractor can't even meet the need so they do that you just make sure fact we're working with a neighbor to the north of you right now where um we put a pretty generous clause in there because they they're in the exact same situation you are and esy just scares me to death here I'm crazy because God bless you but I'm not accustomed to seeing the staff the student um promotion list until April May so how do you route if you don't know the IEP and where the child's going to go but you know yeah but so those the you you can negotiate that in there but you got to be up front but you better make darn sure then that you can meet 25% internally or what whatever the case is because if not
241the escalator that that for-profit entity it's not himt you're dealing with now that for-profit entity will cost you dearly it's like when you set the contract up for a 4-Hour base minimum or a 6-hour base minimum but you go over 15 minutes or half hour because of a rainy day schedule traffic what have you you are probably paying three times more for that extra hour in there so you just got to be careful no I understand I just was trying to think of a timeline and moving in that direction at least with some of that and then one more question does do the bus drivers sign year contracts um well they're usually a bus bus drivers are very unique in most school districts I'm walking in on thin water here because I don't know the
242district's history on this but they usually bid annually for contract and then depending on how you negotiate that Collective bargain unit contract they're guaranteed that contract for one year if service Falls decline routes go away what have you it may not uh necessitate a reduction in Workforce but it could mean that the next year's routes aren't as long or shorter or there's fewer of them so that driver will be B bid again there are many organizations coming out of covid that are simply they're panicked so they're throwing up and saying we guaranteed eight hours that's fine I understand that but now we're being called and saying they want their eight hours plus um the field trip on top so they're getting double paid in there because they didn't methodically look at that collec a bargaining
243unit contract all these things these are great questions by the way all these things we're talking about is why I'm so fearful that if you rush and you try to put this in place for esy or even next year if you can great but get a contract out there now it's going to be hard enough there was one individual I was looking for you two years ago when we thought it was going away what have you and we kept them enticed out there as long as we could and then I had other clients that needed them and we moved moved them over that happened again this last year so I I'm fearful I don't know if I could even get that individual to bid for the district here I'm just being very honest with you
244here so they're not I can't speak for what they will and won't do but I doubt that are going to come in kn that belflower only is interested in one year of service that's why I'm suggesting one year with the option to Renewal two years three years more might not need them that's business that's just the way it is you know I think I was actually asking for the reason of are all these bus drivers that are himt that used to be ours that used to be here are they only onee contract because what if they all want to come back then what then what would be the recommend let's say 10 of those bus drivers wanted to come back tomorrow what would the recommendation be then then would you go internally or would you
245continue to contract out I would still I don't know if IID reach out that it's going to take you more than two years to transition because I'm not sure exactly which option you guys are leaning to but um you got the fleet issues and all those other things my experience it's going to take the staff a minimum of six months to address folks and that's but we're using our own buses right now right so we're you are we're just talking about the driver so why would that even make a difference well to be very honest with with you you had two units out there that if him at UniFi knew were outside the 3,000 mile 45 day that'd be illegal for them to operate that so I don't know what their checks and balances have
24630 that are not we have 30 and are not operational when we were here okay now it sounds like there's been a lot of progress made on the number of buses that were down from when we visited but that's our snapshot uh in in in time but back to your question the driver in the contract they're a classified employee I presume with him at unified they probably have a reasonable Assurance letter that goes out year after year after year to be employed because they need drivers too what they probably don't have but I don't know their contract is a guaranteed to have the same level bid next year that they have now so to do what you're suggesting sure if I were a bus driver I'd say Bingo I'm back home Bellflower is where I
247live here's my resignation to him at UniFi so that's how they would do it you know thank you um do you guys have any more questions com Mr crfi just just for clarification because I think some numbers got thrown out there pretty quick how many buses do we have that are operational well it's a good question I can tell you from the report what you have but it sounds like you have Rick do you want to help there it sounds like you you have several more that have been repaired in their operations may I if I could just add to that question is not only how many are operational but how many of them are up to require standard of what is needed to have them safely managed oh meet CHP standards I I don't
248want to shout but no of of the 33 buses we have 30 are up to CHP standards absolutely so there's only three that are correct right now okay so they're they're they're not only operational but they're safe correct colleague mentioned correct up on the the threeyear excuse me 45 day 3,000 M Service as mandated by CHP okay and there's probably still some more recommendations in the report that we're still going to ongoing but and and those things would happen whether or not it was regardless of who's driving the bus we still have to do those things correct and the reason why we do have so many buses is some of the routes that are covered by uh uh have wheelchair routes uh those drivers also do feel so that bus driver may have a wheelchair
249bus and a full-size Transit bus so so there's there's that as well um but they we do not use all of our buses at one time we have definitely have spares and um that's for when we pull the buses in for service okay so our safest ones are the ones on the road absolutely okay thank you okay so again I think I'm at where we need to go hire someone at least you know start getting this going um and then see what we can do in the future but you you kind of understand where we want to go and I know we are going to be starting a new superintendent search and we're going to have to discuss that with that person as well but we would like to try to move to that but
250we realize that or I realize and I'll let you guys chime in that we need to do something now so I guess I'm in favor of going out for the contract going out and getting us some bids or quotes or however we do that and coming back with with it to us um when you can any other comments Mr crfi no I'm I'm fine with that I would be uh and again I know it's I would be I would have some questions or concerns if we start going into next year even beyond that I would I get if you want them to bid you're going to want to you know offer it but uh yeah one more quick question how many of the Hemmet bus drivers that live local used to be BD employees I
251don't know that I heard casual you know um two to three but Rick and Patrick probably know that better than me one is what I'm hearing only one used to be one of the employees but they all live correct well what it happened is the uh um elonte area where merge took over where hemt had numerous routes I forget how many routes they had 63 routes in that area okay they actually went with hemt one year before we signed our contract with hemt okay so when that went away and merge took over all those Hemet drivers that live in this area El Monte or even down in this area um all those had seniority over all the drivers that had drove for us for a few years okay so they all got shifted out and
252so those drivers are are local to to this area so can I ask that when the transition happened how many of our BD employees got employed with Hemet when it when they did switch one or two they they they had to be offered a a contract with them at a higher pay but I think only one opted to to to hire on with them and I don't think they lasted very long and how many did we have when when we stopped having our own drivers at one point we had 18 drivers okay with 15 15 routes and three three sub spare drivers and what year was that 20 10 12 somewhere like that she's gonna say prior to 2011 yeah 2010 2010 20 2009 in 15 years we with uh percentage wise uh well we
253we had way too many routes at the time and we have way less students now yeah yeah we could have paired down the number of routes even then okay all right thank you I appreciate it very much not a problem that's all any other comments or questions okay so do you have the direction that you guys need so to clarify you want us to um you want Mrs arus to go out to bid to get us going so we're covered for esy and for the upcoming year with the intent of moving forward I understand that you want a timeline of what it will look like to start the process of bringing in house am I understand that correctly yes and I think I I guess we don't really understand what the bids like if they're
254going to require us to do a year if they're going to say they'll do six months I guess you guys would have to figure that out and bring it up to us bring it back to us but do you guys know what I'm saying um it's G to be very challenging for you to if you're recruiting to offer anything less than are you talking about the driver or the contractor sorry I'm talking about the contractor oh I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm very concerned about it I'm you know my thoughts on it here I I don't know what more to tell you you want to be a strong business partner and I'm trying to suggest a way that you can it's really no different than what you would do normally you offer one year but it's
255not really your intent to only have a contractor move in here for one year they're hoping for a longer range to recoup their initial cost it's business I can't speak for what they'll do yes you can solicit the bid that way I I have no idea how respons I understand what you're saying but to me I I hear you're saying it's business but our jobs as board members are its business for us as well so when you're saying that we can actually save money by being internal in the future and then with the rising costs going up isn't it business for us to try to look at that option oh absolutely but I want to correct something I I don't know that you can be more competitive I think you can in the long run
256but your your current contract and the increases in the that contract are not outside of the industry norm and I believe the district would have been faced with that through your normal negotiation processes and raises that you give annually and what what have you I'm talking though about trying to get you an interim um alternative that someone we can leave here tonight and you're directing staff to go out after that contract but they could be back here saying we got no responses to the bid that's kind of what I was alluding to they might say no in a six Monon or I'm not sure but I offer for a minimum of your own options in this this presentation number one was if we use our own buses basically hire the company and the drivers it's
2578.5 to 9 million that's maintaining our own Fleet option two we didn't have anything because you know we didn't have that um oh and the other part of the option one was if we do it without our own Fleet it could be a little bit less you take that 6.2 million out that's your replacement issue which the worst case scenario 4.8 to 5.6 million and then number three if we're fully staffed your recommendation on this PowerPoint or this presentation was it would be about 8,512 so it would actually be about 500,000 Less in what this is so to say that you're not sure if we could be I don't know what you'll pay a driver we looked at industry comparisons around you I know what I looked at there I don't have that crystal ball
258in front of me I understand your interest is in an internal program and I think that's wonderful do it don't but do it right don't rush into it I think you're going to need that I'm being very honest with you I'm just your consultant you pay that contract for a minimum of one year you're going to have some higher expenses because you're going to start um hiring drivers if that's the direction you go you're going to double those costs you can be training those drivers you can be ramping up you can beting your dispatchers hire a State Certified instructor and then in the best case scenario you know a year from now you're you're you're ready to go I do not disagree with you there okay but I don't want to be the consultant in
259front of you year from now saying you weren't able to recruit you weren't able to do it or you have a fleet issue I hope I did not miss I hope I did not misrepresent what I thought that is what I think and I hope that you guys understand that's what we're we I'm asking for is that we go out to bid but we look in the future if we can do it on our own Mr critchfield just last thing the we want to be smart uh businessman when it comes to dealing with uh but we also uh this is kind of what I I think happened when when I saw the chart of how much it costs going from our own internal to have at the first year significant savings going outside of our
260district and and I hope we can get that information and share it with the rest of the board and then the next year slightly less and then it just kind of works your way up but that's what that that's what happens you come in you bring somebody in you and it's great and then all of a sudden the cost then they become kind of institutionalized and then now you're dependent on them it's harder to break away and then the cost the costs usually come up but that you know just going up for the one year that usually turns into a fiveyear thing and it just I would hate to kick the continue to kick the can uh down the road yeah understood and your description is exactly what happens when a district doesn't manage their
261contractor that's why you go to bid for the services and regardless of how good the partnership is after the exercise of four years renewal you rebid it it keeps everyone with their pencil sharp I totally agree yeah any other questions or comments um anything else from staff no that concludes this evening thank you um if there is no objection this meeting is adjourned at 7:47 p.m. until the regular board meeting to be held on Thursday January 16th 20125 I just wanted to say thank you it's a pleasure working you so much and thank you for being up here for so long we had a lot of questions thank you all right the meeting is adjourned