CorpusRecord 167972

Board of Education Meeting - December 12, 2024 (Spanish)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bellflower Unified School District
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Los Angeles County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,652 words · about 71 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al testing one two three testing one two three testing one two three al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al Good afternoon. We are going to begin. We are now beginning the open session. The 6:00 PM Vice President will provide an update on actions and also staff discipline. No action was taken during the closed session. Thank you, Vice President. The replacement pages for topics 13.2, 13.8, and 13.1 are on the back table. We also have requests not to address certain topics on the agenda. The

002request to address the cell phone policy will be addressed later when we get to this matter. Members of the Board, even though this is a board session, will be able to have 3 minutes to speak with the board, a total of 21 minutes, going down to Rule 99 3.1, unless the board decides otherwise. First of all, I have Sonia Casada come to the podium to make the public comment. Excuse me. I completely misspoke, but welcome. Let's begin. Press the button to turn on the microphone. Good afternoon, everyone. I am here tonight to express our appreciation and gratitude to Dr. Hen Hassen for her service to the students and parents of the Bellflower School District. I have two children who attend the Bellflower School District. Both of my children are permanently disabled. All parents want their

003children to be treated and provided for. There are many barriers in society that prevent them from participating. Our son experienced discrimination in many areas of his public life, including the school environment. This school year, the district refused to give my son reasonable accommodations to participate in a before- and after-school program. We advocated for our son passionately, but the administrators ignored us and did not recognize that they were engaging in discrimination. When Dr. Hassen learned of our son's situation, she contacted us immediately and listened to his story. She advocated for our son and made sure his needs were met. After Dr. Hassen became involved, our son was able to participate in the program before... The school with his classmates. Now our son is happy, thriving, and participating in the before- school program. The school is slowly

004accepting his disability and is becoming an inclusive environment. Dr., we appreciate your dedication to ensuring that students with disabilities are included and have the same opportunities offered to General Education students. Please know that it is fully appreciated, and your efforts have had a great impact on our son's trajectory. Thank you. Thank you. I also passed by Marlen. Marla, where are you? Are these comments open? Yes, uh, those that are on the agenda. Not on the agenda. Are you going to talk about the cell phone policy and you are going to talk about the digital policy, and I also have another topic, so that's it. Right now, you can carry out the other topic, and when the cell phone policy comes up, you can come back. I'm Marla Bruens, and I'm involved in various ways within

005the School District. I've seen several things that have been happening in the schools where I am. Things after COVID. Student needs have increased significantly, and I know that the contract negotiations are on the agenda. I wasn't prepared. Excuse me, my concern is that we are possibly increasing the The number of students in the classroom... I don't know how they're going to fit so many people in. I see the classrooms we currently have... the children only have this much space to work in. And if they want the children to be creative and able to move around and do what they need to do, they should n't have to worry about bumping into their neighbor or catching a cold. Because of this, the teacher needs to be able to move around the classroom to help a student

006if someone has an emergency for any reason. We sadly had a case at another school where there was a medical emergency. If you can't physically move around the classroom and you 're not equipped, you don't have any kind of boot or anything that's preventing you, and you can still teach the students... I don't know how you're going to be able to help all the students. This will help the teachers go when the students have a question and say, "I don't need help with this," especially in kindergarten. If they put more desks in the classroom, it will also help the children. Being able to take the children out to help them individually, to separate them, is what the children need, especially with COVID. Since they are facing many challenges, I know there are many things involved,

007but it's something I want you to consider if you want to help children do their best. It's not about putting more children in the classroom so they ignore the child who actually needs help. And unfortunately, and I know this is also true, there are children who are doing well; the teacher knows their names, sees their documents. But if you add eight more to the classroom, there's less attention the student can get because a teacher is just one teacher. You can divide your time between 32 or 36 students, but when you get to 40, you definitely can't give as much as a parent who is watching things and helping at school. Yes, adding four more people per classroom per school year will affect lunch, recess, it will affect all of that. But if you truly want

008the children to have the best education and feel comfortable where they are getting their education and feel safe, you have to consider how this will affect the classroom because otherwise, it will cost more and they will finish late. Well, thank you, Miss Maya. Please come in. I like it. Your little hat is very welcome. Good afternoon, Mr. President, members of the board, cabinet, and the people in the back. Excuse me. I'm seeing that Aisa and I started here together, and I know that things are very complicated, but I want to talk about the proposed size of the teacher- student ratio. I've been co- ruling, uh, 6 per student. This allows me, as co-ruler, to move around and meet the needs of all the students in the classroom. It's a small classroom; it wasn't designed for

009this stage in our lives. But, you understand. But our children are big, and so are their backpacks, and the only space I have in the classroom for backpacks is downstairs. Often, because they are children, the backpacks end up in the middle of the classroom. If we add five more desks to my classroom, the desks for the aide have to be removed. Because if I have one aide, I'm also going to have to get rid of a station. A center station has access to all their papers and pencils, and then we add five more and put 40 because the proposal would be the maximum. I'm 42, and now everything is restricted. I can't reach my students in a timely way to help them when they need it. I feel that right now, if we add more

010seats to my classroom, it would be dangerous. Because of safety, moving around wouldn't be possible. I wouldn't be able to carry out station rotations carefully, and I would n't be able to manage distracting behaviors and everything that happens. Because yes, we sometimes have to move students away from each other, and right now I have the space to do it. My IP numbers are about 41 in two of my classes and 50 in the other. So if they put more kids in, I won't be able to provide the same level of service as I did this year. And I know that academic grades increased thanks to the construction. Right now, it's perfect; there's no need to change it. I've been here for 30 years, and we've worked so hard to make things better for these kids.

011We don't have to go back to the 90s when we had to fight to prevent this from happening again. My experience, because I was a combination teacher from five to seven, and there's no need to... Going back there wasn't... Well, thank you for your time this afternoon, and first of all, thank you to everyone who came to advocate for our children and for us, for yourselves as teachers. We heard you, we value you, and I want to respect the negotiation process that is taking place and the conversation that I know is happening, but we're going to have a little more clarification as we move forward. But I'm confident that we're going to continue in the direction we've been working so hard to achieve. So again, thank you. Next time I have an event, or if

012I'm going to have free pizza, because it does work. We have any corrections to tonight's agenda. Yes, we have corrections tonight. 12.2, first of all, is the interim economic statements on the action recommendations page. It's the second interim report, it was corrected to be the first interim report. And then the second correction is 12.3, the members of the Belflower School District Foundation. We're going to set this aside and bring it back at a future date. A motion to approve amendments to the agenda regarding the information issue It has to be done, it's necessary or not. It's something, it's a replacement, it's up. Thank you. A motion to approve the changes. A motion to approve it. Someone second it. I second it. We'll take roll, please. Um. Student Member José, Miss Armstrong, Dr. Mr. Dio, Mr.

013Kingfield, yes. Um. Moving on to the acknowledgments, we have... Excuse me. Almost, almost. Well, let's move on now to the Pledge of Allegiance. I want to ask Ester Istn, the assistant principal, and Josh St. to come to the podium. Thank you for being here. Please stand and turn to face the flag, right hand over heart. Begin. I do pledge allegiance to the flag, to the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. You may be seated. President Quickfield, members of the board of directors, Dr. Sedo, executive leadership. Thank you for inviting me. I was given instructions, but I was also able to deliver the inspirational message, and I was told to be brief. So I will. In fact, you're going

014to spend a moment... something happened to us just before... I'm leaving. Well, no, no, that's not true. No, no, no, there's no pizza. Stay. Stay, but we have some awards. We'll move on to that, miss. You have an award tonight. Yes, we have awards. May I ask the board to please come forward? Please come down and come to the front. Tonight we're going to recognize Dr. Hassen for her service as a member of the School District Board of Trustees. Right now, the board, the superintendent, the office staff, and the cabinet would like to present something here to show our appreciation and gratitude for her term as a board member. She was elected to the board in 2013 and served in 2018. She was elected for a second term in 2020 and finishes her service tonight.

015Dr. Hassen has worked with several board members, administrative staff, and superintendents during her service. We thank her for her service, and we have a video to show and share with everyone. So, if everyone can turn to the screen to watch the short video, and if we can take a quick picture, one more. Thank you. And I understand we have maybe two others here. So, if you'd also like to come up to the podium, you can do so. This moment, maybe just for a minute, good evening everyone. Good evening, members of the board, cabinet, and community members. I would like to introduce you to Dr. Su, but I would like to introduce Dr. Su El Gensen with a certificate of appreciation from Covadonga College. I am Mr. Green, and I am representing the Board of Trustees

016and expressing my deep appreciation for her dedication, service, and leadership as a member of the Bellflower Unified School District Board of Trustees and also for her partnership in education at Covadonga College. We thank Covadonga College, Board of Trustees, and the Chairwoman is Mariana Pacheco. Thank you, Dr. Su. Thank you for your strong support. Thank you. We send you our best wishes. It seems we have one more, two more. Have a good night. It is a pleasure to be here on behalf of Supervisor Janes Han to be here with the Board of Trustees and community members to recognize Dr. Su El Gensen. We want to give Dr. Aul recognition for her tireless efforts. We have not ignored them. And I would like to introduce you here. On behalf of the supervisors of the Los Angeles County

017District, we thank you for your leadership and service in the BFL School District. We truly want to thank you from the bottom of our hearts for your years of service and wish you all the best in your future. So congratulations and thank you again. We are doing things thanks to them, so it's a great achievement. Our Maritime Choir has its first concert on December 18th and 19th. Go if you can. And for the activities, our choir not only went to Bellflower Tree Riding, but also to the [unclear - possibly "the one in the original text]"—they sounded very good—but next week we are going to do it again, so go to those concerts. We also took pictures with Santa Claus, and as you can see there in the corner, we had the Snowfest, which is the

018high school dance. They said the atmosphere was very good. And tomorrow they are going to show [unclear - possibly "The Grinch" or "The Grinch"]. So if you are available, go. Also, a special thank you to President Quef for his service on the board. It's always a pleasure to be with the district. I met him a few years ago at the opening of our STEAM building, and he gave me some great advice for my first campaign to be president. For my first presidency in my class, so thank you for that. And don't forget to stay connected. You can follow us on Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook. And thank you for your time. Thank you. And representing Summerset, we have J. Taures. Good evening, President CI and board members, Suente Acevedo and guests. I'm J. Taures, and I'm

019in my senior year at Summerset High School. I'm going to present tonight our most recent activities and upcoming events. I want to introduce some of the new staff members at Summerset. We have Lauren D., who is the new Wellness Advisor, who is here to help you at the Student Wellness Center. We also have a community service worker, Stefan Garcia, who is here to help students and families with community resources. We're excited to have them both here tonight. Thank you to everyone who came to the turkey day. The community donated $505 for the student scholarship fund and also donated cans for people in the community. The ESPB students were happy to serve them and spend time with each other. They applied to be a Modern Continuation High School and were selected for a verification visit. The

020team came last week and spent two days observing the classrooms, instruction, and activities. They also spent a lot of time talking with the students, teachers, parents, and district office leadership. They said they were impressed by what they saw in Summerset. The report they sent to the Department of Education determines if we will continue to have recognition as a Modern School. We will know in the spring if we have the recognition. We also had the Air Force presentation about taking the Assault B-level course to have a military career after high school. Before we take our winter break, we are going to have some fun activities and we are going to have dress- up days. It's already Wear Your Pajamas Day. We are planning to hold musical chairs on Tuesday. We are going to bring Santa hats

021and we are going to have hot chocolate. On Wednesday, there will be a competition between students. On Thursday We're going to bring ugly sweaters, and on Friday we'll have cookies. And finally, we're going to collect food. If you want, you can drop it off during school hours between now and December 19th. Thank you for supporting us, and we wish you happy holidays and hope to see you again in 2025. Thank you again, Gil. And remember, you can stay for the whole meeting, but if you want to return to your schoolwork right now, you're free to do so. A round of applause for the student reports! Now it's time for stakeholder communications. PTA President Carl McDaniel, please come to the podium. Thank you for being here. Welcome, President Kenel, President Acevedo, and members of the community

022and cabinet. I want to talk about the importance of having documented behaviors. I receive quite a few emails; this is one of them. Some schools have access to documentation of student behaviors, but most students and teachers don't. Why do some have access and others don't? I've received emails asking what to do after I've given a warning. Having a written conference, talking to the administrator, and it doesn't change the behavior that continues. They also receive emails from teachers saying, "If we don't create the Google Form and document the behavior, there's no record because otherwise it never gets to [the point]. This has been a problem for several years, and if there's a concern about what kind of things teachers use, we need to train them. Undocumented documents seem to be a problem; we shouldn't be afraid

023of what they report, of what's in the dashboard reports. And if we do need to have [something], and for the teachers to know that from 1 to 10, that's where the behavior falls, that's where it's [something]. That's the consequence. I suggest you investigate this and create a plan. The open forum regarding cell phones is very important. I know that studies have shown that humans have been distracted by them. And support the teachers who want to take away their cell phones and complain. Teachers, students, a media society, and we can say it's an emergency. We're going to be using the phone. Cell phones have caused quite a few problems. Nobody can see your tone or see your facial expressions; it's easy to say things that [are] The best thing someone does n't usually say is that

024because they're not in front of you, the students need to be talking to each other during recess and lunch, not sitting in a corner staring at a screen. Create a policy that addresses the instructional environment and teaches responsibility. Or a conversation the other day with a teacher, and we were talking about the importance of libraries. We have so many students who are having trouble with reading. We're promoting reading at a young age. The libraries are open all the time, at all hours, so students can come and see a room full of books and embrace this love of reading. When they get to high school, it's hard to teach them this. They've spent six years just reading for information and not for pleasure. Libraries are important, and I urge everyone to go and visit our libraries

025and ask for what they're offering. The students are finally getting involved in the negotiations. As president of the BTA, representing over 500 teachers here, I'm not new to this negotiation business, but I have to rely on what I'm told. We're relying on the team to do what needs to be done for everyone. I want to emphasize this on sensitive issues. I encourage you to come into the classrooms. Don't tell them you're coming; just see what's happening in the classrooms in the district every day. I think maybe you'll get a better idea of ​​what's going on. Facing the teachers, and maybe the district can understand why it's not best to increase the number of students in classrooms. I hope everyone has a very good holiday season and that 2025 is a good year for everyone. Thank

026you and have a good night. BT President Linda. Excuse me, follow-up regarding the libraries to know if they are open all day and the questions you asked, please. Yes, one more, Linda Morgan, please. Have a good night everyone. President Grefi, members of the interim board, Acevedo, the cabinet. We have here a room full of people. I didn't come to the meeting last month, please excuse me, but I do have some positive things to share, and I'm going to briefly share some of the photos I have with you. So, these were the numbers for BT last month: more than 2,100 members, parents, students, and teachers. And on the right, we see those who actually have 100% teacher membership. So, speaking of teachers, thank you all for being here tonight and for advocating for our students and

027sharing your concerns. Thank you to the board and staff for this. meeting and hopefully we can continue the collaboration and arrive at the best solutions that provide the best services to our students and uh was this Thanksgiving and we are continuing the season of gratitude. So thank you to everyone who came to PT, your continued support is truly appreciated. We also had Red Ribbon Week and the campaign. Uh, those are photos from each of the sites. Miss Garza was part of the group that visited all the campuses and was able to see everything the campuses did. Uh, yes, I took quite a few photos. It was an incredible week, an incredible day to be able to visit, and I want to thank all the volunteers for all their great work and dedication to all the

028PTs and PT students, whether it was the Turn of Treats, a breakfast for everyone, or providing a safe space for families to come, for the community to gather and celebrate the season. They also had events for Veterans Day and the Arts and Reflections program. Uh, they recognized students at each school campus. And well, that was last month. I hope you enjoyed it. Their Thanksgiving break is over, but we're almost halfway through the school year. Supporting students and enriching the school community just takes a moment to acknowledge the great work being done on behalf of students and families. Every event we organize, every fundraiser we have, every meeting we hold brings us one step closer to creating a school environment where children can thrive. And thank you for your passion and commitment to the students. Last

029week we had Red Ribbon Week, school site visits, and feedback. All of this was considered, and we can recognize our schools for all their great work based on awareness, community involvement, and posters. The top three were, in fact, Linstrom and Franky Woodroof Elementary PTA won. This month we're at about 2,200 members. We had additional schools where 100% of the teachers joined the PTA. So those you're actually seeing are Craig Williams Wood, Stephen Foster, Thomas Jefferson, Washington Elementary, and Albert Baxter. I realize that not everyone you see there sees all of them. The photos and slides. So I wanted to acknowledge you. So, 2,200 members. This year's goal is 3,000. So, please join us so we can reach our goal. But last year we had 2,400. So I think we can do it. We're already at

0302,200. And to celebrate the winter holidays, our schools are having events: dances, festivals, movie nights, dress-up days. They're holding food and toy drives, and also an event where students can buy gifts for their families. So please go. And we're a little short, but I showed you the arts and reflection program that the schools did. The Council has compiled all the winning entries. We're holding our own awards night in 2025. So everyone is invited. And lastly, I wanted to share the appreciation on behalf of the Parent-Teacher Association for your years of service to the Board of Education and the service you have provided to our students. And that's basically it. Very much so. Grateful to everyone and wishing you happy holidays with your families and I'll see you next year. Thank you, beautiful, and we have

031a communications agent here, Anthony Rivera. Welcome. Thank you for being here, President Craig Field, Board Members, Superintendent Acevedo, and Cabinet Members. Welcome. Happy holidays to all. A few brief notes for the CACA this month: President Michelle and the Ordering Labor Representative met with Superintendent Acevedo and Assistant Superintendent Dr. Smith regarding nutrition service hours and sick leave. They also met with the Ascended Superintendent and Dr. Smith about some very important staffing and special education aide issues. We are continuing that dialogue. The President attended Comprehensive Security Plan meetings at Washington and Forest. These were all very informative, but we couldn't attend many more because of scheduling conflicts. She also met with Board Member Craig Field and Ms. Garza. We are pleased to continue this dialogue. Negotiations will resume in December, and we will have the next Alliance

032meeting in January. We also went To the staff committee meeting where they announced the new chief executive officer of staff, and we are very excited to work with him. During this holiday season, classified employees in the district helped almost every school put on their holiday shows, and they helped everyone. We are happy that everyone is involved at the schools. Speaking of another topic, I have a few points for the public hearing you're going to have, and I just wanted to say this: there is a very compelling interest regarding how each policy will be implemented. We want to see standardized training and instruction for all relevant employees who have to directly or indirectly enforce any policy or report any violations. We want a clear and consistent mandate that is communicated at the school level and across

033all schools. Also, if you would like to have clear assurance that all employees who have to enforce any type of policy have the full support of the district administration. If you are aware that some of your families and students may not be completely in agreement with the use of cell phones, but there is a In any crisis or emergency, we do n't want members, classified employees, to be subject to anger or public discontent. What kind of accountability do we want? Some kind of assurance that the district and the board are backing us up. When we enforce something that you decided to do, that's my report. And happy holidays to everyone. Right now, we're going to take a 5-minute break for our well -being and resume at 7:15. [Music] Ah, al ... By email that we

034have to read when it's ready. Good evening, Mr. President, members of the board, interim cabinet members, guests on CAM, and I'm the behavioral specialist. Today I'm talking about possible cell phone policies. I want to start with the appalling fact that an American spends 11 hours a day with digital devices. We check our phones 150 times a day. How do our brains learn to be human and passionate? It takes human connection, interacting and engaging with others. It has a physiological effect. We learn to regulate our emotions through social connection. Basically, we're cheating ourselves when we use a device. We lose the ability to regulate ourselves. If we do it 150 times a day, that's why we're having behavioral problems. Students aren't learning to regulate their emotions because they're facing digital devices all day. I hope your

035job is made easier by providing you with data. I have the benefit of being in the classrooms every day. I support all the campuses and have been in most of the classrooms. I'm in the back of the class, observing and collecting data. I tell you that I love my job, I really love it, so whatever they said I'd do, I'll be here for it. I'm going to prepare myself so I can enforce it. But the hardest part of my job is seeing the students' faces when they're ready, they want to learn, they want to participate, and it only takes one person to cause a distraction because they can't control their technology. It breaks my heart when I see the teachers' faces asking for help, not knowing what to do. So we have to have efforts

036because we're going to need more security. Part of my job includes responding to crisis calls for those students who have lost control. If the student is destroying the classroom or attacking the teacher, I'm called in, or one of the other 22 behavior assistants. There are evaluations by students, and most of our high school students I was called in to have their behavior evaluated had a primary concern: technology use. I 'm here to advocate for and abolish cell phone use, and I feel that consistency is going to be key. We already have this in the classrooms, and it's following us. I received an email this week from one of my high school students, a high school student, who was asked to put away his cell phone. And then he added that he wasn't going to comply

037with putting away his cell phone because it was his private property. I was told that his grandparents are afraid of him and don't support this. He said, "If my grandparents take my phone, they're going to... Well, I don't want to ask him to continue because he's running out of time, but okay, two minutes, yes, go ahead." The student said, "They're going to pay for it," and I believe him. So the answer I want, the question I want you to answer, is who is going to take the phone away if the family is afraid of us too? All the training and crisis interventions that I have, which I think should be mandatory, in this training we learn what to do when we are being physically attacked by a student. One of the last things I tell

038everyone who comes to my training is that under no circumstances should you take a student's cell phone because it's a quick way to be assaulted. I did a Google search for "student assaults teacher" and I got almost 3,000 examples. Teachers are equipped and shouldn't be expected to confiscate students' property. My training indicates that they shouldn't touch the... Students' phones. But if we have a policy that says they can be confiscated, I think the problem isn't the phone itself, but the social media platforms that use it to capture attention. These are advanced psychological platforms, and security is a paramount concern for parents and teachers. While phones provide a way to connect by phone in an emergency, giving us the ability to communicate, which can save lives, they can also be transformative. Translation apps help students learn

039English. These devices can be powerful tools for inclusion and accessibility, but cell phones aren't just communication devices; they are also attention-grabbing and sophisticated machines that divert attention from the student. The mental health implications are also dangerous. Bullying and inattention are damaging social skills, reducing face-to-face interactions, and also reducing social interaction. There are very compelling points on both sides of the coin, but what would be best is not just an approach that is either banning them or not banning them, but something that controls social media. And these active policies recognize the possibility that technology can help with instruction, mental health, and also teach how to use technology responsibly. Thank you. Anyone else who wants to speak, please go ahead. Good evening. I want to change things up a bit and talk about this a little differently.

040We're dealing with a situation that has been expanding, and it's difficult, of course, and it's going to be complex to resolve. Jonathan H is the one who wrote *The Anxious Generation*, and I think his book has probably inspired people to do this kind of work. One of the things to keep in mind is that he talked about why so many children have cell phones now. He talks about how in 1988 cell phones started to enter children's hands, and in 2005, when those cell phones were created, they became smartphones. So, a recommendation on how children could have a cell phone that is something for children, one that isn't a smartphone but that only has some applications for communication between parents and children. In his research, in the research that he summarizes, he says that most parents

041buy cell phones for their children when they are young because they are afraid, they fear for their safety. The security he's talking about had to do with issues like how things were in the 90s, for example, the Nike Stocker serial killer and all that. But moving on to the present day, what he mentions ironically in his book is that it has created a very anxious generation, and more than anything, it's because we've given children cell phones that make them see the world as more violent than it actually is. So, he has suggestions for dealing with them. I know that taking away their phones is a curriculum that says, " Let them grow up," and I could talk to the board members about this. But the idea is to teach children how to do things for

042themselves, on their own, and at the same time, encourage parents to know that while they can be aware of their child's safety, they do n't have to create this sense of constant fear, because that's what parents are reacting to very frequently when we use these devices. And I would love to talk to you more about this. Thank you. Anyone else who wants to talk about this topic is welcome again. Thank you. Um, I'm a teacher here tonight, but you only found one to compare. Um, last year the seventh graders had a really hard time getting their cell phones out of their hands and out of their backpacks. Um, it was really hard to get them to hand them over. There was a group of teachers at the high school, and we organized ourselves and created

043a plan of what we were going to do. And I, honestly, was very reluctant to implement it this year because I said, "We're going to struggle with these kids because there's this phone addiction." But because our administrative advisory team supported the plan, and it was communicated very well, the parents and students understood that this is how things are going to be done. So this year, the seventh graders put their cell phones in their little boxes and it's returned at the end of class. We do it again, and it goes to the office, etc. The consequences are working because we're doing it faithfully. So talk to us here at Mayfer, and we'll let you know how the plan is working. Thank you. Okay, anyone else? Now, if anyone wants to come up to the podium and

044is against the policy... I know it's kind of weird how we marked it, but anyway, Miss St, I just wanted to clarify. I would like feedback because I appreciate all these comments, but it's not helping me answer the question I have. I'm allowed to ask a question and then ask for comments from the audience. It's a public hearing, which means you can have a dialogue or ask questions and answer them. The question I have is, the policy currently states that we're not supposed to have cell phones in the classroom. So basically, from bell to bell, it's no cell phones. But if we stick to this, we need the administrators to address this. At my school, we have a policy where they're in their backpacks and are simply stored away. They can only be used right

045before entering the school, and then it says they can't be used during recess or breaks. That's what's difficult for me because I'm hearing that they don't want them. The classrooms have Chromebooks, I understand, but for me, as a member of the board, I need feedback on limiting recess and lunch because, again, I'm a teacher. I see the things they do: they take pictures of me when I'm walking, they post them, they jump off buildings, and I show the Secondary school is quite different from high school; a two-year program isn't the same as an eighteen-year one. But what I want to know is the opinion of the community, both outside the classroom and outside the school grounds. to leave the school grounds. Can someone tell me what they think because that's what I need to approve

046this policy? Please, someone, please. Hello again, a quick response. I do think that children need to have communication access with their parents during the school day. As long as it's not during my classroom time, I understand that parents need that connection and children need that connection with their parents too. So, as an individual teacher, I do agree with that. Thanks. Anyone else? Hi Tony, my daughter has a cell phone. I had to get her one basically when she entered fifth grade because she started in the dance program. They transported her from Steven Foster to Washington. We had an approximate pickup time, and sometimes the buses would arrive late, I think once 45 minutes late, and I had to know where my daughter was. There was no communication about when they would return. We just went

047to the school, waited, and they arrived when they arrived. So, I have to talk to my daughter today. Her cheerleading practice was canceled. So, she was at school with her backpack. I went to drop her off at 8:30. My other child, who is the one who... Of course, it's inconvenient to go to school for everyone, but it works for us, and she called me immediately. I do n't have to take this second backpack; she has to take two backpacks because she's small. And immediately I went to... to go get... so you can't call me, then she's going to be stuck with that all day, and I suppose she's going to leave around 5:30 because I need to communicate with my daughter too. I see her location. I have a responsible student; she simply has to

048communicate with the parents. What are the expectations with the phones? But I have to communicate with her, and if she can't reach me... it's at the cheerleader... they're waiting... they go by bus... we're talking about weekends, during the school day, at night... it's different times, like the schedule... the 1:58 would have been at 5:30, at approximately 1:16, 3:30 in the morning, 6:00 at night... I have to talk to her, and it's difficult; it's already dark when she goes and leaves at different times. It's an approximation, but I can see her; I can see she's walking; that's where... It's located, you guys drop it off at lunch, and I didn't even know. Basically, I made a call, and then the parents got a message saying, "Yes, they can leave lunch. Our kids can go to lunch

049and do whatever in the neighborhood, and then we come to pick them up because we assume the school has them there at lunch, but they have the freedom to leave at different times, and they think, and you don't know they can leave. We have to be able to follow the kids, and I have a responsible kid who's responsible with his phone. All his teachers, when I go to his classroom, as it says, they have policies. They take away their phones, put them on something, discipline the kids, and it starts in elementary school, and for her, it was mandatory due to the discipline problems there were in middle school. So yes, we have to have some communication with the kids, okay? But to clarify [Music] est al al al al al al al al al al

050al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al al teachers teachers teachers need we're talking, I was saying students, we're going to record the things that can be for the parents. Ani use culars in many schools, especially est acting a Tom communicates, I breathe technology, we're on screens all the time, so screen time is all the time, not being on the phone at night, and again, we've had enough. We're here for you, this highlights what policy we should all use, implement it, whatever it is, so that students and parents are also taken care of, whatever they need, whatever the bags have. Man, fast, it's talked about, there are many ways we can. Well, more comments before we close the public hearing. You're going to allow it. Once

051we close the public hearing, then the board will talk about it. At 1:00, at 2:00, and I declare the public hearing closed. Some comments from the board regarding the cell phone policy: For me, as I'm in my senior year, I'm not 100% opposed to banning them, but for me, I think that cell phones should be put away during instructional time, especially if someone can't do that, putting their phone away. I feel like it's a problem; there should be more consequences in their education. But for example, I use my phone when I have to check in or go to school or leave; it's called a "minga." It's a school-level app that helps students with their pass, so they can leave, and it shows how long they've been in the bathroom. So, the staff and teachers use

052it a lot, but I feel like some students are going to try to get around the cell phone policy. For example, I feel like some students are going to bring, I do n't know, maybe a fake phone and have the real one in their pocket. I feel like a lot of students are going to try to get around this issue, but if they can't keep it hidden, they're going to have problems. Like I said, there need to be more consequences and security. So, thank you, student vice president. I have a question. She's talking about whether it will be usable if they don't have their cell phones. [Music] There. So, it would just disappear if they don't have their cell phones? No, it 's not like that. The policy actually states that, with the exception of

053digital IDs, they are allowed to use their devices to access their digital IDs, which would require identification. But the question isn't that, because they have to use digital IDs. But we're saying they ca n't use cell phones. No, we can't say... Well, yes. They can, but they can use it for schoolwork. It doesn't work, so what I'm asking is, if we say they can't have their phones, then the program disappears. What I understand would be a problem because the students use them for passes to leave the classroom. They use the digital ID for lunch and breakfast; it's how they get their meals, and it seems like a conflict of interest. We have a problem, but it seems like they have things they have to use on their cell phones when they go to the bathroom

054and all that. If I may, I was wondering about the fact that... [Music] here. Sorry. Sorry, it's that they can use the ID; they don't have to use the phone. That's correct. That's correct. They can do it the old-fashioned way, but that's a different answer. Yes, they can use it without their phones. I'm not sure how they would use their ID for the pass to leave school. That's something that will be determined by each school. Well, obviously, the information is correct so that decisions can be made. So, thank you for that. Well, I was wondering what the exception was for digital IDs, and we're saying that in the proposed policy, they're still going to have their phones; they just have to keep them between... Students could still use their digital IDs to enter the school,

055but it says they have to store them because it's policy. It indicates they can have them at lunch, during break, but why do we have an exception for them? Because they never use the IDs in class. Is there a reason why? So why should there be an exception? It doesn't make sense. It's a question for you, Ren. The exception was put in the draft policy for the board to consider. Because there is a very broad use of digital IDs, and not only for purposes like the ones we mentioned, but there are also many notices that are also used in class. So that exception is in the draft policy specifically because high schools are using that technology quite a lot. So there's an occasion where the student has to use their phone to access their ID

056to do something on campus, whether they're in class or not. If we're using phone-accessible digital IDs, it makes sense to me to have some kind of exception, but again, that's the board's policy, and that's the policy. You can do it however you choose, but typically they don't use it in class. I mean, we 're not allowing them to use it. Cell phones for that in class, I don't know if I can talk about that specifically because there might be a time when an ID is needed in the classroom and they're signing up for something. I don't know, I imagine that at some point, something has already come up where students need access to ID, something in class, definitely outside of class, but maybe the principals would know. The teachers, going around, student IDs, we use

057them. The only time I've used it is when I need to create a pass to leave, when I have to go to the nurse or the bathroom. I can make a pass and the teacher doesn't have to do it for me, but that's the only time. It also shows them their ID, the ID number. So if they're filling something out in class, you can just go in. It has all your information, and then besides that, it shows notices and things that are happening around the school, not just during the week but daily. So maybe not during class so much, but definitely outside to see or check things. In fact, we can get more information about Minga because I'm a little confused. Again, it's not so much to say that the kids are going to do

058bad things, but I imagine that They can make their own passes and leave the room whenever they want. So maybe I don't fully understand the system. So could you give us a little bit of information on how it works? Yes, I will provide it. Thank you, President St. Member Stuart. I also have a senior, and like the parents here, my daughter needs her phone for unforeseen things that can happen. I agree with Dr. Robinson; we simply have to do it in phases, and we have to educate our children because we're not going to hear about technology; we're going to keep moving forward with it. So we have to teach them the acceptable use of it, of cell phones. And these smartphones have everything; I mean, everyone is inside them. So I don't have a problem.

059I'm also a teacher, but I don't have a problem with my students. They don't have cell phones, but they do know how to use them, and they better not find out their passwords if they have them. But we have to make sure that we teach the children and start early and teach them the acceptable use of technology. We have artificial intelligence. Well, we already have it, so we have We need to teach children what integrity and virtue mean because we have students who do use phones the way they're supposed to. So, if we have this in policy, this balance... Yes, I know a teacher who has a box to store phones where they put them directly because they're teaching, they have a lesson, they don't have time for cell phones. So, if the teacher is

060teaching a lesson and the phone isn't required, it shouldn't be a problem. I mean, it shouldn't be. However, if the children have them, and there are some, it depends on what's happening with mental health. Remember, we're in a mental health crisis too. Not only the children, we need to possibly figure out a way to store these phones in the classroom and allow children to have their phones when it's not time for instruction, and also the parents have to agree. One person said they're afraid of their own child. So, all these things have to be taken into account, but we have to get the parents and guardians to agree. Thank you. Um, member... uh, Einstein, minga, can't be used on your Chromebooks? Question. I'm hearing... Yes, in the audience. So that also makes a difference to

061me. And another comment, another comment on the second page of the policy, below it says collaborative policy development, that the designated principal at each school will work collaboratively with the staff to develop policy. I agree with many of the things the public said. We have to have a policy for the District, and it should be for all principals and all schools. I do n't think the sites should do it individually. That's something I would change in the policy. And then above, promoting digital citizenship. This says that we should do it, and we should do it, and I would love to know what we are doing each year to promote this digital citizenship with all students because I feel it is necessary. Thank you, Vice President Stuart. In 3216, it says that we have to create

062a policy that limits cell phone use by June 2026. This is what they are indicating to us. We are taking the initiative; we are talking about it now, but policies are going to change over time. And I honestly, we talk, but I don't think it's something that is very good for our children. Period. In a perfect world, we would agree that they shouldn't have them at all, but it's not. A perfect world, and if you have legitimate concerns, I also have things like the AirTag. And for my daughters, I have the Apple Watch; it's kind of weird if they're not wearing it. So, that's one of the things. Thank you for posting the survey. We asked about Apple Watches, also about Apple Watches, because I don't know who said it, but that technology isn't just

063about phones, and no, it won't be like that. In two or three years, I'm excited to buy the new Apple Glasses, but technology is always going to keep advancing. So, I feel we need to address the problems here, the root of the problems. And for me, with all the policies—we've talked a lot about policies this year—whatever the policy is, we have to back it. We have to know what's in it, and we have to support the people who are focusing the policy. And if we're not going to enforce the policy, it's better not to have it at all. And if you do have a policy and you know you're not going to implement it, then that diminishes the value of all the other policies. So, whatever is decided has to be something we can back,

064and we can either financially or with personnel. That's what I think about it, and I know There will be more talks about this, Vice President. There will be a discussion about personnel policies. Board comments: I just have one question. Although they work one or two hours a month, number four says that it's being added that they will be entitled to the same health insurance plan. Our people on the personnel committee have some other regular jobs, or need it because they only work one or two hours a month. I don't know specifically which committee members have that or not, but the intent of the policy is that it be available to them if they need it. It's a common thing that boards extend to personnel committees, but I can't speak for the personnel commissioners in this

065particular case. But it is important to note that the commissioners have been eligible and have received—I don't know that, but they do have the eligibility to receive it, but it hasn't been memorialized by the board. I see that it's being added, but it's always been there. Well, okay, again, it's at the board's discretion ultimately because we want to ensure that... It solidifies the written policy that if the board wants that to continue as a benefit or not, I think that's how it's been; they've been receiving benefits for it, but it's never been in the policy. That's what we're going to do. If we do that, we're going to put it in the policy. I mean, it's the board's decision. Any other comments from the board? It's a topic of discussion that a director brought up,

066which is that the staff should set a limit, take the 250 and limit it to 150 or 200. What does the board think? Will they ever meet more than three times a month? I said no, 200, 200 is fine. This would be a bit excessive; five meetings. Excuse me, any other direction from the board on this policy before I go back for reading? Well, let's move on to the main action. Let's start with item 12.1, acceptance of the auditorium, audit year 23. 2. We have a speaker, Mr. Chef, from Black & Black Audit. Good evening. You saw my presentations in the past; I'm not going to bore you with all the background information I usually do. I think this is the third time I've spoken about this. What you hear is... I'm talking about this,

067the third year we've done the district audit, but briefly, let me review the school year, fiscal year 2023-2024. It normally comes out in January, but we're doing it earlier this year. We're finishing all the audits in all the districts; Monday is the deadline. I think there's a finding we found here, and I have another client, 14 of them, that we want to resolve. But it's a comparative note. The audit report has an unmodified opinion on the financial statements. The financial statements here, referring to the financial statements that were adopted in September, we do the audit, we give an unmodified opinion to see if they comply with generally accepted accounting principles. The report has quite a bit of information. It hasn't changed in format year after year, so there's nothing new in terms of format. But

068briefly, to remind you, later in our opinion there's a section called Management's Discussion and Analysis. If you're not into numbers, if you don't want to read the whole audit report, you want a summary. That's the section to look at; it gives you all the comparative data on how the district has performed year after year and what the... Financial audits, but if you like numbers, start on page 11, financial statements followed by notes that talk about the important details about the different aspects of government accounting. As I said, if you want to know about pension plans, proportions, and discounts, you want to read it all; it's all there. It's glorious for those who like numbers. There's a section after this, several sections after that, a required supplemental section. This is a standard GASP requirement that you

069submit more information about personnel and retirement benefits, retirement plans, and other information required by the state controller or their office. This has other summary information, other information about the requirements of federal programs, things like that. And then it goes to the next-to- last section, independent audit reports. There we put in our statements that we follow all the standards that have to be followed. When we do your audit, we don't just look at your financial statements. Internal controls, compliance with federal programs, compliance with state programs—we also look at state programs that we must audit are listed on pages 79 and 80. It's a large menu, and it gets longer and more tedious every year as we add more and more programs with more and more requirements. So it's very important. That's why I said at the

070beginning, a great achievement that we only found one problem. Most clients have problems with this program, and it's very good that this District didn't have any errors in those areas. That leads to the last part of the report, which can be defined as a finding. A finding is a result of several things: deficiencies in internal control or noncompliance with a state or federal program. So the results are at the back; that's where most people go because they want to see what we caught them with, what we looked at wrong. Pages 83 and 84 say that there are no errors in the internal controls, the federal program that we looked at, and there is one in state compliance, but no problems in the previous audit report. Finally, at the back, there's a letter where we talk

071about the problems that arose during the tests we did on ASB funds at school sites, but no They weren't considered significant enough to be found as errors because there weren't any requirements, but we must include that communication and show it to management in the audit report. Can you also explain what the finding was? Yes, I can explain. There's a requirement that's been in place for several years called the CA form. It's a... what does the acronym stand for? I don't remember exactly, but it's to calculate the percentage of the district's total expenses that goes toward teacher salaries. There was an error in the calculations that caused the district to fail to meet the requirement. And how do we do the audit? We look at the error, and we're required to put it in the audit

072report. I think there's a way around that problem through the LEICO (Law of International Cooperation). We recommend that the district find a way around that report. And what happens when that error occurs? Well, if they receive a pardon, the district will work on correcting it because it's an annual requirement. We'll audit every year, but if it's an ongoing problem, they won't give a pardon. They only do it once, and the district eventually has to correct it. And the goal of that requirement... Why do they have that? Because... An interesting question. I believe this arose years ago through communication with ETA and the state legislature. It was an effort on their part to require the district to spend a certain percentage of its annual budget on teacher salaries. They made it a requirement that the district

073report this in its financial statements each year. There were no problems found with classified employees. There is no similar requirement for classified employees. Well, I have two questions. My first question is, on what page can I find that error finding that we didn't comply with? To read page 85, it's on page 85 and it's also in the reports they adopted in September, the CEA form that the district adopted in September. Second question: page 87 says 5 out of deposits, as an example of ASB, lack supporting documentation. What documentation did we need? Well, it's not a simple answer. It depends on the type of issue. ASB does various types of fundraising activities and events. Typically, we look for documentation that shows where the money came from. If it was a fundraiser, is there a sales record?

074And for a sporting event, was there ticket tracking? We are looking for example, sheets of these amounts. Some point-of-sale documentation to see where the money comes from so that everything accounts. They did Bellflower High School, Bellflower, also Mayflower, Mayfair. Well, in both schools, Mayfair and Bellflower, we noticed that problem regarding staffing. Can we find out what's going on? How can we improve in that aspect? Yes, well, thank you very much. Can I ask about the error finding on page 85? We already applied for forgiveness. We need the audit report with the error finding. We've gathered the documentation from all the school districts. As this gentleman can testify, he has problems with this calculation, and we have all the documents needed for forgiveness, but we need the audit report to finalize it. But when that was

075completed, we made some amendments that we submitted, but the auditor saw that we can make different amendments or do it differently. So when we look at the upcoming fiscal year, we can see those amendments and submit the correct information. Thank you. Let's move on to other questions. Is there anything else from your presentation? No, no, that's all. That concludes the report. Any other questions from the board? No, thank you very much for being here. I appreciate it. Well, my pleasure. Good evening, everyone. This will require a motion to accept the audit report. I have a motion to do so. I second the motion. Does anyone second it? I second it. Student Member: Yes, ma'am. Member Armstrong: Yes, Stuart. Yes, President Kitfield. Okay, we move the motion. Next item: 12.2 Interim Financial Statements. I'm going to

076move on to the Chief Executive Officer and Ms. Venegas. I'm going to move on to the presentation. We're going to move on to the presentation on the screen. Just a moment, almost there. Thank you for your patience. Good evening, Mr. President. My cabinet, my community. Here I have the pleasure of presenting our first report, which will be the first District budget cycle. In June 2024, we provided a presentation of the 2024-2025 budget. As a starting point in the budget cycle, we can anticipate the fiscal year. The 45-day review gives the District the opportunity to make changes. Many budgets are based on this. In June of this year, we didn't have anything to comply with. We moved on to the finances in September for the year 2024. Before this presentation, I provided the details of these

077files tonight. To say that we have closed the books of Fiscal 24, at least fiscally, this is not the first complete report as you see here on the date. We have two more to alter the finances in the school year. It is the best protection we have to begin the deduction process for the next budget. We are going to start collecting information from the Governor's budget, which we will use to develop the next fiscal budget. We will continue monitoring the current projections to have the most current figures. That is what indicates to us that the fiscal year development is a year-round activity that our financial staff has. This is the report that is presented. The anticipated cases in fiscal technical data from June 2025. Two-year fiscal year projections for 2025-2026. I present this to you

078so that it means we can meet the financial obligations for the next two years, to be able to project the income and expenses for so many years. Fiscal staff use the data points to calculate certain areas in this There are three data points on the slide: housing cost, or the state, also attendance, and the largest revenues are based on these topics and more. The collaborators have a significant positive impact when we are converting costs into expenses. We are also experiencing a decrease in revenue. Here I will show you the cause with respect to retirement benefits with an increased cost, but we also have increased costs with health and welfare, also for employees, supplies, contracts, more costs with respect to utilities. All the things that are happening are currently. So we have to look at the

079general funds, the operating fund, the majority of the revenues and expenses for unrestricted and restricted areas. I'm going to focus on unrestricted revenues since it is the largest fund. Here you can see an improvement in projected revenues from 149 million to 1.4 million. A major change is the local formula, which has improved as an adjustment. It's an adjustment. Attendance in recent years could fall. Another change is that we are awaiting approval of our student count. We also realized that there was a Changes in Prados' spending in unrestricted funds. The budget adoption showed approved spending of $142.5 million, and now we are projecting cases of $ 1.4 million out of a distribution of about $ 8.2 million. This is a reflection of the collaboration between the fiscal department and the program departments. We need to review

080planned spending to see the accuracy of the resources. We need to be fully and partially review to see if there are more opportunities. This allows us time to review spending now and for the future so we can report on the budgeting process. The requirements I spoke about regarding submitting a multi-year PR for this year and the next two are also relevant. This is a look at the general restricted funds. One of the differences in revenue is the decrease between this year and last year. Last year's figures, including what we finished and the TR years that are included in the first interim period, show a loss of $ 8.3 million due to lower revenue and also lower student enrollment, as you can see on the slide here in the current figures. 9.7 million this year, next

081year, and the change in the enrollment and registration system, we are anticipating 1.4 million in used funds over the next 2 years. We see a small increase due to the increased cost of inventory and use, but there have already been some requirements that are providing districts with less, as state revenues and expenditures become clearer. So going back to the slide of the percentages that were used, we are waiting for the budget to know about it. Multi-year expenditures are anticipated to increase year over year with the inclusion of new projects, improvements to fire alarms, and also improvements to the countryside. Here is a broader picture of our specific general funds, including the used resources. This includes the money allocated to special education, after the schools, and one of the other things you can see here are

082the federal resources. So if you look at the federal revenues, you can see that last year we had 21.6 million, this year we are using 10.5 million. These are used resources, but the biggest decrease between the two years has to be Seeing with the completion of the money received for COVID, seeing its future with this federal money, the restricted revenues look more like the ones before the limited ones, as seen, how it is done with local, state, and federal restrictions, here is one of the components we have, the budget approved by the board, it first represents where we were in the budget adopted in June 2024 and now the time of its first interim report, since we are close in the place with the resources to be able to reserve funds and with the anticipation

083of the needs and the gas, preparing for our future is our priority. All this information leads us to a list of several years of the general fund balances including 2022, 2023, 2024 and also the projected years in 2024, 2025, 2026, 2027. This shows an improvement of about 25.5 million from the budget adopted in June and at the same time continues to show us a decrease in state revenues and more expenses for costs such as retirement. Um, funds, supplies, contracts, public services, and also decreased the District's resources, which will continue to strain the District's finances. But we have time to navigate this, continue reviewing the finances, and look for ways to improve, which leads me to the next steps. In January 2025, the government will release its 2025-26 budget. I anticipate that we will have a

084local control plan reading. From there, we will work with the board to prepare a report, and that is the second option to provide more details of the results. Right now, we are looking at the current budgets, but in the meantime, it gives us the best way to see the current budgets up to January and the projected resources. In May 2025, the government will release its revised budget. In June, we will have the same public hearing for the local account control and reduction plan, and they will approve these two items at the board meeting. We will return in September for the board to approve it, along with the current budgets, and from there it will be presented to the County Board of Education. Thank you for the presentation. I'll take questions from the members. The first

085question is, why can't you give us all the pages in the presentations? The page I 'm talking about is the one that deals with the summary of unrestricted expenses. You have a question about indirect cost transfers. What are indirect costs? Examples? Indirect costs are something we allow, we charge restricted programs, Title I programs. Maybe they're not—I'm not going to make up numbers—maybe there isn't a million dollars to run a program in our district. And when we get to the actual numbers, what are the administrative costs? We figure that out in that program, and it comes down to a percentage. So we're here at a rate of 6 or 7%, and the program that's on the restricted side can be charged 7% to cover the unrestricted costs. For example, the payroll department issuing checks to manage

086the program and handling all the benefits and allowances in the program. So indirect costs are charged to the restricted programs, and they cover all the expenses we incur. Under the residuals. Thank you, member. I have a question. On this page, at the end, are the total cases? I'm wondering if there's something that has been reported because we approved a certain amount, but then the actual totals are less. That's where I spoke with the staff and program staff about using available resources. We realized that it was n't something we were going to do this year, or that we could do. What are we going to do? That was an opportunity for all the interim reports, like the budget, that we're going to prepare, and all the money we have available for the protections, how much are

087we thinking we're going to spend? So, we've made some modifications about how we're going to spend money, if we're going to use resources. I have another question. If I look at a page and it has the total projected to date, I mean the part where they're projecting that we're going to spend more, those are sources of income. So that's income, it's income that's going to come to us, so we're going to receive more, we're right, we're going to receive more income. Well, thank you, thank you, sir. I have a question. The auditor mentioned the... Finding that figure here I see is salary, wages would be low, but we 're at 95, so it shows that we're projecting to have the same next year. Or how does it affect the projections? So the CEA takes into

088account all the expenses that are seen as such in the economic report, the money we're spending on salaries compared to the entire district. So there's no figure in this presentation, nor are they in last year's figures. We have a problem, I don't think we're going to be okay. What happened last year is that we had a lot of expenses for non-instructional things that created a salary. So if you like math, the master's degree grew, but since we do n't have this money in our system, we're trying not to have a problem with the CEA and things we thought were appropriate back then, but they said no. So we'll see about that. And then close the books to see that we're in line with what the CEA asks for. So, construction, or does that affect the

089ratio, for example, N ratio? Or if it can, if an example, for example, calculus takes things that sound like, for example, the logical construction of calculus, but general and low Deitos are going to see. Many, many constructions, other things that I didn't take into account were, uh, the income from ESAC funds for technology, other things that raised the figure, and the PID, you were looking for where we could lie down with you, that we are not alone, many enrollees have been going through this and have been having extensions. This is the first extension we requested, and have confidence that we have recovered the data to show that we believe we are going to receive this exception from the ECO, and we are going to be... good question, this president, my present question is about the

090report itself, the page... tell me when it arrives there, we are there already... well, I was talking last night about these... we were looking at expenses, number four, books and supplies. We budgeted about 7 million dollars and we have spent 746,000. It seems that we are going to over- budget. We have an over- budget of about more than 6 million dollars. We lowered the projection to 2.3 million. We budgeted 7 million, we have plans to spend 3.8 million, and column D is the reduction we made. We put that we don't believe we are going to spend the 7 million. That's not it. The current one, but the current one is really the direction of what we are now in the present difference that we are seeing now according to the adoption of the budget, that

091is, 3.3 million. So yes, that's correct. Next, we are seeing that we are in the negative by 70 percent. We are under- budgeted. We are going to spend 3 million dollars more. The budget increase with the total for the fire alarm budget. That is an opportunity, but an opportunity to look at the budget again. I wasn't here in the development of the budget. Look at the budget and say, well, look, let's... Yes, we are going to use those funds. We have a contract approved by the board to carry out that project, and we are going to reflect those dollars with the adjustment. In the same way, we are not going to do the same on utilities. We will do the same on that issue as well. Fire alarm systems. Most of the numbers in that...

092in that fire alarm project are for the four schools that we started. The other question is line eight of the budget, indirect costs. Is that what you were talking about? But it's on this page. We would also like to meet with you to review this with you and understand it more. Yes. I'd be happy to support you on that. The more support I have for these documents, the better for all of us. Thank you for offering. Thank you very much, Vice President Stuart. How confident are you in these multi-year projections? I can tell you this: our projections, like the first one, are based on what we assume are impacts that we monitor. What I can tell you is that it's the best information I have at this time. Also, it's only the moment we started

093developing this. TR months, this from the beginning of the year, or 4 months to October 31 and 2 months within You can imagine how intense it is when we look at documents like this, looking at two months out of ten months of school expenses. Putting that data together and looking at things gets intense, but it's the best information I have right now. My goal is to come back to you at every board meeting with the best information I have, and if that means changing the numbers, I'll explain the changes to you. That's why I'm here. The second interim deadline is in March. We're already in January, seven months into the calendar year, five months into the school year. It's a much better picture of what we're seeing: how much we're spending, what kind of employees

094we have on record, and how much we've been doing in services or in CPOS. All of that will be a factor in what I bring to you in future determinations, but right now it's the best information I can give you. Any changes I make, I'll let you know at that time. There won't be any $ 40 million offer, right? No, I don't have anything of that nature. I appreciate you being here. I have complete confidence in you. I appreciate the perspective and experience you bring, but I think As a board member at BUSD, I've seen numbers where we try to... well, we receive these projections, they're very murky, and we can't do this or that because of the money. But at the end of the year, we say, "Well, yeah, kind of." And I look

095at all my books from previous boards, the last two years, and they're very consistent. I think that with the staff we have now, I'm very optimistic about where we're going, and I think all projections... it seems there's a reason for that. And the money sometimes comes in, sometimes more comes in, and really, I think that's part of the projections. But if you, as an accountant, never want to assume you're going to receive something you don't have, then I understand being conservative with the accounting. But I've realized in my time here on that board that as long as we can close that gap in what we project, we'll be fine. We're going to close the gap with more than you think, I assure you, Member Armstrong. Yes, I want to continue working with the budget. You'll

096give us realizations about how you're trying to stabilize it and move things around. Absolutely, I can continue doing that. I will at every meeting, March, June, certainly. If there are... Big changes between that time, we're going to communicate that too. I want to know if there's anything dark you see in the future. Well, I mean... Well, you already asked, right? Look, I do n't see it as something dark, I see it as an opportunity to improve. This is what we're showing. We lost about 8 million in revenue this year. Balances are going down. We have plans for some projects where we're going to use restricted funds. I'm not here to give you some dark information about the future, but rather to ask you how we're going to address all these declines. I don't want to

097project dark times, but I want to project what might happen, and I'll adjust it when I can give you more, better numbers with more information. The last thing I want to ask you is, as I'm thinking about the past, how might this affect staff in the future? Well, absolutely. Like many districts, 85% of the district is made up of staff. The dollars are for benefits for classified and certified staff. Every decision we make will be made for the students and staff, for the betterment of our district. Well, up to this point, we don't have to cut any programs. This reflection is what we have. Now there are no shortfalls to programs approved by the board. Thank you, Board Member Armstrong. I do appreciate a little bit of dark projections, that's why I know, I know,

098I'm telling you, uh, I understand, it's better to ensure that we are solvent, responsible, and 100% secure. You have seen the projections in the past, and they are... How are they going to operate? It's difficult to make decisions if you think about it. In the past, two years ago, the prions we had... now we should be at 35 million, and we are... worse off with the numbers. I appreciate the conservative accounting. I know you are on top of that. I have a lot of faith in you. Any other questions from the board? No. Well, thank you very much, Renée. We appreciate you very much. There is a motion to approve item 12.2. I make the motion. Second, well, list, Student Member: Yes, sir. Yes, Stuart. Yes, sir. Yes, well, let's move to the next item

099on the agenda. I have one on 13.7 and 13.21. Board Member Armstrong, there is a motion to approve the consent agenda and postpone items 13.1 and 13.7. There is a... Motion seconded. Yes. Student member list. Yes, Mr. Armstrong. Yes, Stuart. Yes, Mr. CRFI. Yes, one second. Let's move on to the first item. 13.7 Annual Contract Amendment. Agreements. And lists. Any comments from the board? I have a question. I think the consultation report says that it provides after-school activities. There's quite a bit of what this is. My question is, how does it compare to this Think Together and One-on-One program? Because this is different. Can you give me a little background on this, please? So, it's a service that we're providing in the district. It's part of our outreach program where there are STEM services during

100the Think Together program. We have the additional one for the spring. We did the early one in the fall, and we're going to increase it for the spring. But we mentioned the One-on-One Academic Counseling Service program. This is another one where there are people who come in to give STEM lessons with the students. They come in and work collaboratively with Think Together to do these things with them. They absolutely do that, and then school sites can also hire them to come in during the school day or for other events that can effect something. You can do something. That can be individual, they have this separate, they can work together, yes, absolutely. Either way, either way, perhaps. The question is, what are the advantages? Because we have so many after-school programs, and this is different, and

101I understand that, but if they're working with Together, we're paying so much for Think Together, I think these other ones are a million dollars more, but what are the advantages of this? Well, I'll answer that in a couple of ways. One is that it's important that we remember that we have to spend the money from STEM programs. It's 9 million dollars, and we had funds remaining that we have to use. These current programs... Another explanation is that the STEM program is providing more classes that other individuals can't provide because they bring with them materials and personnel that the Think staff can't give. It's a program that enriches the after-school programs. Well, thank you very much. There's a motion to approve 13.17. My motion is seconded. Roll call, please. Student Member Jos: Yes, Mrs. Armstrong. Yes,

102Mrs. Stuart. Yes, Mr. Richfield. Yes, we're going to move on to the next item held: 13.21, year budget review School 2425, that was my next question. I'm looking at the opportunity, seeing that... It's like 2.6 million that they subtracted from the budget. 11.7 million was the budget already with its revision. I'm thinking about the money we have left. How can it be used? Give me an idea where we're spending most of the money in LOP. I know every district is different. Ours is clubs, then schools, sports, and field trips. What are we spending the money on? We're spending it specifically on our Think Together program. It's the most popular. We do that at every school site, and the high schools too. We also have Marx. What we're looking at is stacked services and enrichment programs.

103One is LiftCits Explore. That's for non-Think students. This year we're looking at giving schools the opportunity to develop their own enrichment programs. We offered... we were offering those vendors who work at the sites. They talked to the community, decided what they wanted to provide, and we helped them make contacts. They have their requirements and orders, and we helped them get them. Another is the academy of the program... Summer school also excursions we do excursions A couple in the summer in the summer we do and this also academic advising on paper and verbal and the students are working with staff and teachers so they can do these programs because where I teach we are given many opportunities to earn extra money and with maybe we're not getting raises this year it's a good way to increase

104our income And to do different things with the students the administration is working with the teachers to involve them also to earn extra money doing cool things for the kids opportunity a description of what they want to do no intervention proposals growth but we do have 15 classes So it's about participating in the intervention and interest of considering teachers as they submit education seren but I think it would be a good idea for people to have a motion to start the 1st. We are ready and now we are going to carry out the communications of the members of the student council. I'm going to start with student. Good evening everyone. I would like to speak with representatives from CSDA, which is an annual student program that last Wednesday had a two-day training course that helped

105me a lot and is about the Functions and responsibilities of a student account member and how to use the data from the Calia dashboard. I also created connections with more than 150 members of Histes. They also had the opportunity to connect with all the other board members. So I made new friends and experienced things. I also went to the Imagination Campus and learned what it means to do that. So it was a good experience and we spent time together. So, hello everyone. What's up with us tonight? I couldn't attend, but I want to thank everyone for all the time, comments, and detailed contributions to the advice we 've given. It's interactive, which is important because it's the beginning of the school year. I'm not coming, but I'm excited because we're going to have a great

106time, and I'm excited about the project because we have to have some resources. But I want to address the comments regarding unification. I think that unification, and not just urgency, I have to admit that some things are due to communication issues. We're all here, but because up to 6% of the funds used, and I clearly want to move forward, which will increase the overall effort we have, the teacher as... I wanted something concrete for everyone, different for everyone's benefit, and to continue simply. We have to have everyone involved and how to work because it's not going to erase all needs. It has to be fair and equitable. I have my opinion, but this world has changed when it has, so we have to work and make sure everything is clear to everyone so that we

107can, right? Because many things that I've talked about, ideas that have fallen apart, but we have ours, and I think Queen, because they are working with us, we have more than anyone else. So we have to be fair too. It's been many months, but I've been quite busy too. So there are many reasons, but yes, everyone, right? Because many of us bought the book, simply inventing their strategies, this advisor and president, also. I've heard how it is, like those who come down from the mountains, I'm one of the experts in politics, and we talked about the plan to promote this area, what opportunities could arise within the local community, and the role that agriculture will take with agriculture, because with agriculture, and if we're going to see if we need to have a long-term plan.

108For this use, I also use training, so it's good because the course is good. That's all, and it's not, no, that, but you, well, it's that I finished. I have to, the thing, my favorite thing from CS was a, uh, that she developed robots for children with disabilities. It's a huge thing in technology. I saw her virtually and she has created sensors that can be worn to train sailors and soldiers. She's a global leader regarding technology and how not to use it to improve their performance. She's a social advocate and is in science, technology, engineering, and math programs for minorities and women. And as you know, I love books. I bought the book I made, Inventing the Future, so I'm getting used to the stories that are in this book. That's all, and I have

109it in the observations, and that's all. Thank you. Thank you. Good night. I want to ask the staff to give us a vote in the next election. We passed. Thank you very much. We took away your voice, and it wasn't right. While I'm here for all of you, I'm going to make sure that your Voices are heard before the death decided a case of hann his class that complete a community service project they requested and were creating letters and gifts with the children who were in the hospital of Y it was a great idea for students to get involved, I liked spirit in energy, I know how to do amazing things F the ethics training also on Saturday Prim December the president we took part in the of the bands of the 5 and we

110are going to the parade of schools students and it was a fun day firefighters with me I can't believe that I am impressed by students and the opportunity of their stable days I think F a very amazing event on the 7 also with the conference we started to hear a speaker Santos is a video teacher and teaches a course that is actually a course for adults for teenagers and I think to share with our administrators so that if anyone wants to take this course they can. I took the class as a 5 years after covid. So I am excited to speak with the scholars who have generated and done many studies at universities regarding Mental Health and happiness that I want to share with you that I have 10 tips to expand the Happiness within

111oneself, happiness is important for connecting with others socially. If you want to do it by helping people, what we hope is that you have to take time to be, to carry out praise. Practice matters more. It's about being in the present moment and understanding things. If you're in the moment, you might feel bad. Give yourself that gift of self-care, focusing on your work and strengths that you can select. It didn't matter if it fit in, even if you believed it, and you can manage your time. So, I'm interested in a course on well-being, and I also attended one that was presented by them about effective communication. I've already started. Some of the ideas I got are things I learned from guides. Parent and guardian guides are a starting point here so that families know where

112to go if they need help. They have resources for communication about a crisis, how to distribute the message, minutes into the crisis, and update you after the crisis ends. I loved it. They talked about specific things, but each day was the same. So again, they are practical, as in everything, receiving them at the same time. We talked about how to decipher the messages, they asked and answered questions about what was happening. Personally, it's a way in which they created this. So it was easy to... And instead of a... very good way in how effectively creating... it gave me many ideas. Talking with our staff... workshop for superintendent... I think the most important thing we can do in this leadership way is to hire a credible superintendent, find a... But I hope we find one with

113their temperament, also with our children. And the second is to create goals together with our superintendent, to show how we are progressing towards those goals. Also, the conference helped us spend time together, to build group relationships and create connections. And I loved working with the staff we have so that we work well together. And I think... and to all of you for all your great work and collaboration. And it was so much fun getting to know you a little more as human beings at the conference. Only our faces here... and I also wanted to say congratulations to two of the high school alumni, Vor Sanchez, and congratulations to... And lastly, I'm excited for the next one. I hope you have... I hope you can come tomorrow at 6 pm. Thank you, Vice President Stuart. I

114already wrote my notes and my board report. I've been busy. I was able to go to Sacramento for the election of Jose San. It's very important to see all the elected people. Look for opportunities that will help us enrich our facilities and how to work with him. I also spoke with Josh, the co-author of the cell phone law. I received his perspective; he's the one who wrote the law. It was a very good conversation. I went to the reorganization meeting with Victor Sanchez. Congratulations, Wendy Mor too. And I went with our new superintendent; he hasn't been sworn in yet. He was there too. It was very cool. CSB was great too. I also sat in at the Summer School Model meeting, a meeting that was very cool. Superintendent and evaluation. That was a favorite session.

115I liked the welfare theory session quite a bit. Your favorite was the artificial intelligence one. I think that was your favorite in particular. CSB is always fun because we're all together in the sessions. Also, we're enjoying the human side. As Vice President St said, I thank all of you in your professional roles and as human beings. Thank you for putting up with me. I really appreciate the all- star band, thanks to Shan Forbes, and finally, how did he bring it all together? It was a demonstration. He said, "I have an idea," and he did it. He updated it, and it inspires me a lot, also for the youth, and also for the fire truck. We should do more parades. I don't know, free pizza, more parades. I met with Mr. Mcen, and I appreciate that

116you get together and talk and discuss the issues with us. I really liked the public forum; I was able to hear from all of you. Whoever feels that they could be the president after me, those opportunities are very good. We live and continue to learn. The negotiations, I can't, I'm not going to talk much about it, but I think that as a District, I have worked hard to get to this place where we are going to work together, collaborate. The only thing I hope for in the future is that we work together, that we collaborate, and that we remain respectful, unified with purpose. I think the coolest thing is that if we can do it there, we can do it in the District, everywhere. Prayer is fun. I know it's very tense and difficult, but

117we have to be respectful, work together, continue in the same direction, all together. I have more for you, I think that's all. Happy holidays to everyone. Well, we're finishing up these information topics. Does the board have any questions about the information topics? I have a question. I'm glad you went to see José and his unsworn brother. Do you know him, Amy? Well, I didn't know. What were you going to do? You offered to invite all the board members to see him. We all love him very much. I walked through the neighborhood where my mother lives and showed them. Look, vote for him and also for Victor. It was offered to all the board members at this particular event. In most cases, we don't send invitations to everyone, depending on the event. This was a request

118from a board member. In this particular case, I think that in some instances, we know it makes sense that we can't send everyone, but the president can. On behalf of the board, if he can't attend, I can tell him if it's not possible for the president to go, the vice president will go, but not everyone. Any other questions or requests for information? Well, then, if there's no one else, this board is meeting until tomorrow at 6 pm. We said, "Yes, that's it, Lisa, it's 6 pm tomorrow, Friday, December 13, 2024. Good night, everyone."

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.