CorpusRecord 167973

Board of Education Meeting - December 12, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bellflower Unified School District
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Los Angeles County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,224 words · about 152 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everybody uh welcome to tonight's regular meeting of the board this meeting is called to order at 4:01 p.m roll call please student member o Jose Miss Armstrong present Dr Al hessen present Mrs Garza Miss Stewart present Mr critchfield present tonight we do have request addressing Clos the session agenda items I'm going to read a little Spiel while meetings of the governing board are not public meetings they are open to the public individual speakers will be allowed three minutes to address the board on each agenda or non-agenda item and the board will limit the total time for public input to 21 minutes uh so three minutes each per board bylaw 93222 may I have Dr Robinson to the podium welcome Dr Robinson I didn't do it too uh the right button no just touch

002it yeah just one little the little green little I don't think so I could try but it's it's not going to work board and cabinet I really and and superintendent I really appreciate the opportunity to address you tonight I want to thank you for the changes that have been made they've been slow Plato said the beginning is the most important part of the work but it's how you end that matters and obviously we're not at the end yet we have a lot of work ahead of us when we had our last two superintendents one of the things we were working for as a bargaining unit was to move us to common interest bargaining that's really what we thought we were moving toward in fact um your chair of your bargaining team has on his website

003that that's one of his priorities and that students are his priorities however we're challenged by some of the decisions that are being made regarding what we're doing moving forward for kids and so tonight myself and all of those who are assembled behind me and those who are not in this room currently who also share the same views would like to articulate to the board that we want the interests of our children represented our children deserve the best that's why any of us get up every morning and stand in a classroom that's why I believe that you sit on the dicese and that's why I believe that they sit behind those tables to inflate class sizes does not make any sense historically when we've had problems we have always come together and born it on our

004backs this isn't about teachers and what's hard for teachers we do hard things every single day but what's best for children is to not cram them into a room and heard them right now postco we have long covid not just physically but for our kids academically and educationally stacking kids in a room doesn't make any sense anymore than putting all of you up there makes any sense the reality is that when we look at instructional decisions we're asked to look at data when you make decisions maybe you could produce some of that as well but it can't be a Hardline this is what we want and this is what we need and this is how we're moving forward when we come to the table our interest is the children when you sit behind that Das

005your interest is in the children historically our district office has not had that same interest I do not want us to start pummeling down a hill that takes us back to where we started we worked too hard to get here and we put someone in a position to move us forward not backward and now our superintendent our current superintendent is going to be stepping away we need her to be replaced by someone who carries that same kind of mindset and the cabinet that you work so hard to change has to also have that same mindset this isn't pointing any fingers but when the people who just got here decide what we're doing moving forward that has to factor in what's already been happening here all along and what we have as an interest for our

006children our children in belflower un un ified School District deserve the best 30 of them 35 of them 38 of them 40 of them in the classroom that is not the best thank you Dr Robinson I may have um Mara Ros did I butcher it PR welcome and thank you for being here good afternoon everyone um real briefly my name is n roas sites and I'm a bilingual instructional assistant and a retired teacher so um I'm coming on behalf of classified and certified and um five years here with belflower I have worked with the ELD students and um working with them we have had a big influx in the past year a few years of many students coming in and we have had even right now 30 students that not just me and our teacher

007can work with we need more help and we need less students in the classroom they deserve that attention we have a wide variety of students coming from Vietnam Philippines Egypt and different locations of Latin America and we are to address all that amount with the High quantity of students and it's unfair to them we cannot give them the attention they need when the classes are maxed out we really need that to be paid attention because then they also they get discouraged with their other classes because they're not learning we do need those classes to be much smaller thank you thank you m Jones to the podium please welcome and thank you for being here Aon okay um I'm trying to remember how to address don't start me yet okay um hello um president um board

008and um superintendent um I just want to say that I've my um back to school night this year I was very proud because I got to tell the parents that we now had a theater class we had music there were no combos um you know talk about PE we've had all these great movements and so I felt like starting of the year I felt like oh my gosh I'm finally feeling good because there's been a lot of jaded feelings in the last few years um just as far as the district and and what's been going on for what's best for children um and so you know we do have a lot of issues you know the behavior every element campus we have kids that are running out of classrooms that are um hitting kicking um

009both adults and children which is actually something that I wanted to come and just talk about at some point anyway it's just the behavior maybe um problem solving finding ways to deal with these kids because one student can take over your entire class um and a lot of these students are having problems with self-regulation as well and then obviously with laws passed um through California with the students not having as many consequences it's just been and with the Mental Health crisis that the kid that um children are experiencing and the things that we have to now do with students in class um I was really shocked to hear that then we're going to increase because I feel like we have so many issues just within our contained classes um the behavior is not the same

010as it was when I started teaching 24 years ago um the mindset the work ethic all of it and I know it's generationally changing but I mean there's a lot of issues in I don't see where having more students in classes will be beneficial at all um and if you've been to the elementary schools I know you have um children in there I don't even know where 38 kids would fit in the classrooms um and you know and also what if I'm a parent and I like for some reason my grade level cohort has 38 every year fourth fifth and sixth meanwhile the other grades alongside of it with those averages have 30 I don't think I would be very um Angry as a parent to see that and say why does my child have

011classes that are so much higher than others so that's something to think about when we're coming to this average and um numbers um and I know that um we care about our students but you know there's like when you go on a um trip and they always say you have to put your oxygen mask on first before you help your children I mean our our mental health also matters and so when we are already dealing with a lot of um like adversity right now um it just seems like this is we we I mean I love my students I love my job but it's hard and it's way harder than it was 10 years ago or 15 years ago and so we know I also have to make sure that what's going on with me

012that I'm able to stay healthy mentally so that's another thing to think about thank you so much you're very welcome M have Shannon slagger to the podium please welcome and thank you thank you you got a pre- Applause on that one pardon my vocal nodules here I go um yeah my name is Shannon slager currently a third grade teacher at Ramona Elementary and this is my 25th year as an educator in this District I have a passion for this job and people who know me would say I'm fired up uh throughout my BD career I've served on many district committees held various leadership roles along with the amazing teachers here I I represent what you would consider highly qualified teachers who have devoted our hearts and souls to our students families and the administration here

013in this District I've taught in every grade K through six and this year I requested to move from sixth grade down to third when I'm asked why I made that choice my first response is simply I can I can make a greater impact if I go from teaching 34 kids down to 24 I do not feel equipped to successfully facilitate learning for that many humans in one room all day with no Aid support minimal breaks and no individual planning time this fired up teacher I hate to say it her flame is dwindling I understand that budget is a motiv motivating factor for your reasoning to consider increasing class sizes and we're facing many undisputable issues that we all want to solve but I implore you to ask yourselves this question How Will adding more students

014to already crowded classrooms solve our issues and benefit teachers and students here are a few concerns to consider when you make the decision number one student enrollment is decreasing as families are opting to go to private schools with smaller class sizes and homeschooling How Will adding more students to classrooms solve this problem two student achievement in all academic areas is at an all-time low in this District with around 30% Proficiency in ela and even lower in math how well adding more students to classrooms solve this issue and benefit teachers and students three the special needs of students academically emotional and behavioral they're steadily increasing the spectrum of dis diverse needs in our classrooms is beyond overwhelming and nearly impossible to tackle with the limited resources and student numbers that we currently have how will more

015adding more students to the classroom solve this issue and benefit teachers and students and finally I have 37 seconds teacher efficacy across this district has severely diminished and this is so important we need to we need to Define it it's teachers confidence and their ability to help students learn and succeed we want to see positive change and unfortunately we we need your help we are in a battle to overcome many challenges and become a thriving District we want you to help us Empower us work with us to brainstorm ways to utilize funds creatively and continue to try to solve Solutions our motto is we build Futures it is represented by a flame and a torch please do not snuff our torch thank you Miss leer uh may have Amy Mustafa please to the podium welcome

016Amy hi thank you good afternoon president critchfield interim superintendent Lisa zedo Schoolboard members um cabinet audience um one of the amazing things that BD has to offer is high quality education with lower class size class sizes than the surrounding districts we need to do a better job of advertising all of the positive things that bu USD has to offer the smaller class exer sizes the no combos these are things that should be all over social media after Co students have different needs we're still recovering from the learning loss and students have a greater need for social emotional learning increasing class sizes does not serve vusd students the district just implemented the No No combo classes this year those smaller class sizes are an intervention in itself we haven't given this the opportunity to be successful

017let's wait and see let's get the data on that and see if those programs the no combo classes and the lower class sizes are successful if the goal is keeping students and families together let's brainstorm other ways to accomplish this we have increased class sizes in the past to allow families to stay together and it was not successful it just moved the bar the class sizes were higher and guess what once we reached that higher number we still had to separate families it didn't work now those families are still being separated let's brainstorm other ways to solve this problem instead of raising class sizes last school year BTA CSEA admin and the Schoolboard got together through the alliance and devised a plan to implement to limit separating families through the reorganization process did we implement

018this plan let's be more proactive instead of reactive if the purpose of increasing class sizes is financial I urge you to look at different ways to save money how many admin do we have in our district what is the ratio of admin to students has this ratio increased are the admin directly serving students when planning the secondary schedules are the admin getting teacher input these are just things to think about I urge you to consider other Alternatives than increasing class sizes B USD needs to do what is best for students solving problems on the backs of the students is not the answer thank you have Robin B to the to the podium all right sorry we're negotiating now that we have only a little bit of time okay so um good afternoon hi if you

019don't know me my name is Robin bog I think I know all of you um thank you for all that you have done to shape our school district and BSD uh we have been plagued for years with an apathetic board a dysfunctional and poorly staffed district office High turnover and Administration which leads to broken systems in schools with the Staffing changes that you have made such as a new superintendent who listens and cares about the community and teachers uh new Staffing in the district office with fresh ideas and a new CBO with years of experience and a different way of thinking and looking at our finances things have been slowly improving thank you to the board for all that you do to be available to your community for responding and looking into concerns and reach

020reaching out for the betterment of everyone I believe that because of the change in leadership under the direction of this board we're finally moving in the right direction and would that would not be possible without your support I'm sure that everyone in this room understands how different education is in the current climate all of us are here to make sure that our students and Community are properly served and given the best education possible class size is an intrical part of a student's success adding students to a classroom is never a way to improve education test scores or School climate smaller class sizes are important to help form relationships reduce behavior issues and increase engagement with so many students struggling with learning loss mental health issues and competition with technology the best thing we can do

021is try to limit our class sizes responsibly I understand that certain circumstances there needs to be flexibility in order for us to add students with without adding another classroom I believe that we can work together to find a solution that is both fiscally responsible and us being good stewards of our students when we look at our student numbers Bud along with many other districts has lost a large number of students over 2005 years however our staffing ratio does not reflect this loss we have a student to teacher ratio of 17 to1 where most districts sit at 20 or 20 1 to1 we're overstaffed with teachers that are not directly tied to students we do also have an increase in admin which uh Amy represented so this is another uh area that we could look at

022that might have a significant fin fiscal impact uh thank you for all you do to help support our teachers students and families in this District I hope that we can work together to find a solution that will help maintain smaller class sizes while continuing to work and move in in the right direction thanks you guys thank you Robin M A and Marie sharp come on down welcome and thank you for being here tonight I guess I was at the end good afternoon president Chris critchfield members of the board superintendent oo members of cabinet and guests my name is anarie sharp adapted physical education specialist for belflower Unified School District this is my 25th year in education and 23rd year here at B USD I'm a dedicated passionate energetic sometimes misunderstood advocate for children with special

023needs 15 years ago general education teacher Mrs Boss and myself were joining our classes on a weekly basis before co- teing existed at least in our district I vividly remember a girl standing very far from my students and Mrs Boss also noticed this after class Mrs boss asked her what's wrong and she would eventually tell us that she was afraid of my students she was afraid that she was going to catch something from my students this was very difficult for me to understand I quickly realized this was an opportunity and a sign that we needed to educate both students and staff about students with different abilities this is a very small portion of my story of why I became so passionate about teaching students of all abilities in an inclusive physical education environment my two

024areas of specialty are physical education and special education I work best with my students who are the best around this afternoon I'm here to advocate for my students BTA has has proposed maintaining the longstanding one teacher to 55 students in the physical education environment it's my understanding the district is proposing to remove that one to 55 and that's really disheartening we've had this understanding that for band and Mr Phillips and the incredible programs that he runs it's been an understanding that he can improve that and your and your asking to remove that language our facilities can barely support the class sizes we currently have as everyone knows and as heard we brought to the attention the state of our facilities the locker rooms cannot support larger class sizes we see all over the um Facebook

025parrent page all the issues in the in the locker rooms and a larger class size would not help that there's a big difference in teaching versus babysitting we're hired to teach I'm not going to get through all my stuff so if you need more where do I go from now if you need a little bit more time we're happy to you're going to give it to me thank you can we extend it uh is an extra two minutes okay I think that should do it cool as a former BTA board member standing committee member for four years I have to share that I'm shocked and disbelief about what we are reading regarding special education negotiations for years B USD has employed a legal team not now but before they charge outrageous fees would not settle

026cases and continued to allow leaders in this District to not follow laws when it was brought to their attention time after time we finally have a level of expertise in this special education leadership which we've not seen in many many years we have made improvements and now BSD is suggesting taking away some of that collaboration away on May 30th BD and BTA agreed to have RSP itinerant teachers teachers at Travel like myself but I'm not RSP only at two sites say we had an RSP teacher at five sites last year that is not in the best interest of kids whatsoever so we had agreed to two and now the proposal is to remove that language we went through H double hockey sticks during covid our students across the board my daughter's calling lost a heck

027of a lot and our students in in special education suffered immensely I got to know families on a different level because of covid and that's the only thing that I am thankful for because without my parents showing up with their students there was no education going on the adult transition Center which educates our students with the most um needs from 18 to 22 uh we have a current case load of 10 and the proposal is to remove that or it may have been an oversight so I do did want to bring that to the attention fiscal responsibility is what we need and what we have always needed for too long District leaders have not listened and made poor financial decisions our students should not have to suffer at expense of adult decisions we should be

028celebrating the many successes of this District over the last year and a half and instead we are called to share our frustrations with what has being proposed at the bargaining table My Hope hope really is we can turn it around and work collaboratively to meet the needs of our students our district and get back to celebrating and expressing our gratitude because that has been an awesome expression this week thank you so much thank you Miss sharp and thank you everybody for being so respectful of the time and uh all your comments you are you are heard and we value you um at this time we will be adjourning to close session uh Open Session will resume at approximately 6 p.m. have a good night good evening everybody we will now reconvene Open session at p.m.

029uh vice president Stewart will provide an update on closed session agenda good evening everyone the topics discussed in closed session student matters pending litigation labor negotiations and Public Employee discipline dismissal release no action was taken in close session thank you vice president Stuart uh replacement Pages for items 13.2 13.8 and 15.1 are on the back table um tonight we do have request addressing agenda and non-agenda items the uh request to address the cell phone policy will happen a little bit later when we address that uh agenda item um while meetings of the governing board are not public meetings they are open to the public individual speakers will be allowed three minutes to address the board and the board will limit the total time for public input to 21 minutes as per board bylaw 9322 point2

030unless otherwise waved by the board all right first up uh have Sonia pasadas to the to the podium you're giving me that look like I totally butchered your name I apologize welcome I was going to push that I think it's the button to the right perfect good evening everyone I am here today to express our appreciation and gratitude to Dr suel hessen for her service to the students and parents of belflower Unified School District I have two children that attend belflower unified and one of my two children is per permanently disabled every parent wants to treat their children equally and provide for them equally but sadly there are many barriers in society that prevent that our son experienced discrimination in many areas of public life including the school setting earlier this school year the district

031refused to provide our son reasonable accommodations to participate in a before school program we advocated for our son passionately but local administrators dismissed our concerns and failed to rec recognized that they were engaging in discrimination when Dr Sue learned about our son's situation she quickly reached out and listened to our son story Dr Sue advocated for our son and ensured his needs were met soon after Dr Sue got involved our son was able to participate in the before school program with his peers today our son is Happy thriving and participating in the before school program his school is slowly learning to accept his disability and become an inclusive environment Dr Sue we appreciate your dedication and ensuring that students with disabilities are included and have the same opportunities that are offered to the general education

032students please know that you are truly appreciated and your efforts made a huge impact on our Sun's Journey thank you thank you very much thank you sodia I have Marla Bruins to the podium where's Mara at I'm here where you at is this just open comment uh you yep uh non agenda agenda yeah or are you thinking I speaking on the cell phone policy I was going to see speak on the cell phone or the digital policy and then I had another topic so that's right now so you could do the other topic now and then when the cell phone policy comes up you can come back up again okay I didn't know if I needed a thing for that hello I'm Mara Bruins um I have been involved in several ways within the school

033district um see several things happening in the CL in the schools I'm at um things have with postco the student needs have greatly increased um and I know that there is on the agenda the um contract negotiations sorry I wasn't prepared for this now my concern is if we are increasing potentially increasing the student numbers in the classroom I don't know how you're legitimately going to fit that many people in the room I currently see some of the upper grade classrooms that we have now with people the kids just are have this much room to work first of all and if you want kids to be creative and expand and be able to do what they need to do they don't need to be worried about bumping their neighbors all the time or catching the

034cold because you touch hands or whatever the case may be and the teacher needs to be able to get around the room to help a student should someone have an emergency for whatever reason we had the case sadly at another school this year where there's a medical emergency if you can't legally or you can't physically get through the classroom and you are able-bodied you don't have a boot on your foot you don't have something that's hindering you but you can still teach I don't know how you can help all the students it kind of prohibits teachers from going back there when they have a question and saying hey I need help with this you especially in the kindergarten areas you're if you put more desks in the room you're going to limit centers you're going

035to limit pulling kids aside to help individually at that table the way they're set up now that's stuff kids need and especially postco when they're struggling I know you there's lots of things involved but that's something I want you to consider if you want to help the kids do their best it's not putting more kids in the room so that the kid who needs help gets ignored and unfortunately and I know this to be true too I mean those kids who are doing well the teacher does know their name the teacher does see their paper but if you add eight more people in the room that's that much less attention that student can get because one teacher is only one teacher you can be divided in 32 or 36 but by you know by the

036time you're getting to 40 you get you're definitely watered down so from a parent observing things and a helper at the school observing things that makes a huge difference adding four more people per classroom per grade yes it'll affect lunch it'll affect recess it'll affect all of that but if you really want the kids to get the best education and to feel comfortable where they're getting their education and to be safe I think you need to consider what doing that will how that will affect the classroom because otherwise you're going to renovate and that's going to cost more thank you Miss Mara I okay Maran foot come on down love the hat there you go welcome thank you sorry all right good evening president Crutchfield Board of members cabinet and people behind me I'm sorry

037I'm just looking at Lisa Lisa and I started together here in the school district and so I know she's passionate about things as I am um I'm here to talk about the proposed um size of the student to teacher ratio I right now I'm a third-year Cod teer um I have at most 29 students in my classroom I have a seating arrangement of 6 by5 and this allows me and my co- teer to have two teacher desks and the flexibility to move around and meet the needs of all of our students in the classroom it's a small classroom it was is n designed for this day and age and we understand that our children are large and their backpacks are large too the only space I have in the classroom for their backpacks is underneath

038often because they're kids the backpacks end up in the middle of the classroom if we were to add five more desks in my classroom the desk for the oneon-one aid has to be removed cuz I do have oneon-one [Music] I'm also going to have to remove a station Center where I have kids have access to all of their paper goods and and and pencils now you add five more and you put 40 in there because the proposed maximum is 40 students I am now restricted I cannot get to my students in a timely manner to help them when they need help I feel at this time if we were to add more seats in my classroom it becomes a safety hazard for me and being able to move around I would not be able to

039do the station rotations carefully and I wouldn't be able to manage the distracting behaviors and the disruption that occurs because we do have to move students away from each other sometimes I have that space now to do that my IEP numbers are about 41% in two of my classes and 50% in the other okay you put more kids in there I'm not going to be able to serve them as well as we are this year and I know my our academic grades are up this year with our co- teing okay it's perfect right now let's not change that been here for 30 years and we've worked so hard to make things better for these kids let's not go back to the 90s when we had to fight so that this didn't happen again also my

040experience I have been a um a a combo teacher I taught a 56 combo and a 78 combo not good let's not go to back that either thank you for your time this evening thank you man and before we move on to the the agenda I want to say thank you to everybody who came out to advocate for our our kids um and each other as teachers we value you we hear you and uh um I I want to respect the bargaining process and I know the conversations are still happening but I'm sure we'll be able to get some more clarity on some things as we go forward but I'm still very confident in the direction uh that we've worked so hard to create in this District um so I again thank you uh next

041time I throw an event I'm definitely going to have free pizza because it works uh thank you all for being here tonight all right do we have any corrections for this evening's agenda we do have two Corrections this evening item 12.2 first interim financial statements under the recommended action on page one it states that it's the second interim report it's been corrected to read the first interim report and then correction number two is item 12.3 belfar Unified School District Foundation members this item will be tabled and brought back at a later date great thank you Miss aavo do I have a motion to approve the amendments to the agenda is the amendment to the informational item is that necessary or no you handed us a paper on that as well that's a replacement page sorry

042was listed at the top thank you sorry do I have a motion to approve the changes motion to approve do I have a second I second right roll call please student member o Jose I miss Armstrong I Dr Al hessen I Miss Stewart I Mr critchfield I I will be moving on to recognitions uh do we have any recogn oh wait no I almost edit edit the edit the tape all right well now move on to the Pledge of Allegiance I would like to call Esther Lindstrom assistant principal Mr Josh Stern to the podium thank you for being here thank you please stand face the flag put your right hand over your heart ready begin I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands

043one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all you may be seated uh board president critchfield board members Dr oo executive leadership uh thank you for having me here um I was given some instructions that I also got to do the inspirational message and I was told to keep it brief so I will do that and um I was actually you're gonna come up in just one minute we have one more thing right before I'm out of here you got you got a two for no stick around there's Pizza stick around uh we we have we have some recognitions then we're going to jump right back to you um Miss as do we have any recognitions this evening we do have recognitions can I ask the board to please come down from the

044dis up up to the front this evening we will be recognizing Dr suel hessen for her service as a belflower Unified School District Board member at this time the board the superintendent the office staff and cabinet would like to present you with a token of appreciation as a thank you for your term as a board member we have two things for you Sue was elected to board in 2013 and served through 2018 18 she was elected for a second term in 2020 and is completing her term of service tonight Dr sah Hassen has worked with multiple board members staff Administration and superintendents during her time of service we thank her for her time and have a video to share with everyone so we could if we can get everyone to turn their attention to the

045screen we have a short video [Music] if we can get a quick picture one more thank you and then I understand that we may have a guest or two um here this evening so if we do if you'd like to come up to the podium you're welcome to do so right now actually maybe just for a minute good even evening everyone good um good evening board members cabinet community members I would like to present um I call her Dr Sue but I would like to present Dr Sue El hessen with the certificate of appreciation from seros college um my name is Dawn green and I represent the Board of Trustees and in grateful appreciation for your dedication service and leadership as board member of the belflower Unified School District Board of Education and your partnership

046in education with cito's college we thank you Sero College Board of Trustees our um president is Mariana Pacha thank you thank [Applause] you and then Dr Sue thank you uh for being a strong supporter of the cops program during uh my time of service as the CEO and we wish you well okay it looks like we have one more two more come on up good evening it's a pleasure to be here on behalf of supervisor Janice Han to join um our superintended board and community members tonight as you recognize Dr Sue El husen and Dr Sue we want to recognize your tireless efforts they have not gone unnotice and I would like to present you with a scroll from the supervisor Han and it reads on behalf of the Board of Supervisors of the County

047of Los Angeles I danis Han supervisor fourth district commend you for your leadership and dedicated Service as a board member of belflower Unified School District As you move forward we we really want to wholeheartedly thank you for your nine years of service and wish you all the best as you move forward so congratulations and thank you again okay we have one more all right good evening um BTA would just like to thank Dr Sue for her many years of service to the students teachers and community of the belfar Unified School District we know that being on the board is a big dedication of time and a commitment that often goes unnoticed so thank you for your service [Applause] one two three and that concludes our recognitions for this evening thank you absolutely you have someone

048that wants to come and take a picture e going to say let's get a picture e should I warn Mr Stern that he needs to get ready pretty soon no I'm I'm building up the anticipation because he knows it's coming up next okay all right uh now we'll do presentations from staff students and Community Mr Stern will highlight this month's student Spotlight for real this time welcome all right thank you uh I thought I was gonna do the inspirational message before and I um looked up uh one of my favorites um my wife calls her his uh her boyfriend Simon cynic um he's got a lot of great inspirational um information out there and he um he spoke about the difference between optimism and positivity and inspiration versus motivation and um I just wanted to

049share that with you before I uh did my student Spotlight um because motivation is something that we all strive to have uh we we get you know some people have this natural intrinsic motivation uh some people get motivated by the carrot that's out there their parents that threaten to take something away if they don't uh get the grades and that's motivating to them um the motivation for just um acknowledgement but that comes and goes the um inspiration is it's that flame up there um that we see it's an internal flame that light that goes on and it it burns inside of us and that's what pushes us to dream and to see the light um through the darkness of the tunnel uh there are times when uh someone says stay positive and you just can't

050um but the inspiration that we have helps us remain our optimism around those dark times when we're in those dark tunnels when there's differing sides of things and it's difficult to see through it but we realize that um inspiration that's inside of us that flame that exists with within um the bell flower um logo that we have right there that flame inside of us keeps moving towards that light and seeing it no matter what the darkness is that surrounds us and when I um when I saw this um this message about inspiration and optimism it really was a natural segue for me to introduce Michael Lopez that guy right there come on up so [Applause] uh Michael is joined by his uh mothers Erica and Vanessa and his brother Jacob and um when the idea

051of a um student Spotlight came up who who are we going to choose the the choice was pretty simple because everybody was Ro roaring if you will about Michael Lopez about what a great kid he is his uh first grade teachers let's see if this works next there we go he's a man of many activities um he has a lot of things that he loves to do can I get the next slide Michael uh from his first grade teacher Miss kber says it was a joy having Michael in my first grade class he was a hard worker always wanted to help others he thrived on responsibility and it was so wonderful to see the wonderful young man that he is growing up to be you're welcome Miss Moses is third great teacher said Michael was

052in my third grade classroom I remember a polite friendly boy with a great smile and a positive attitude he was willing to dive into any project with enthusiasm and love to learn next slide he demonstrated a love of technology and helped keep our Chromebooks in order each day I might have to hire you for that one I recommended him as a Friday morning assembly techie with Mr Tim because I knew Michael would be responsible as well as proficient in the skills Mr Tim would be teaching him I'm also so proud of Michael's accomplishments moving up to uh one of our intervention teachers Mr hedgpeth who helps Mr Tim Michael has been a vital part of our Lindstrom sound crew for years he learned these complex skills under the tul toage of Mr Tim Tula his

053older brother Jacob um he has been an inval invaluable to our school site making sure we have sound and microphones ready for every event he does this without complaint he takes the job seriously and does it extremely well our school is beyond lucky to have such a talented intelligent helpful young man who makes good things happen at our school way to go Michael I had teachers coming up to me saying do you have enough information can I do you want me to give you something else because they kept on talking about how much they loved you and how much how proud they were of you and I'm going to cap it off with your sixth grade teacher Miss McQuade he is a gift to any classroom school and or community he is reliable and always

054first to volunteer with a smile he is first to be the new kid's friend and spends the entire day escorting that student around Michael notices the details in the classroom environment and acts accordingly Michael is an Engaged learner and advocates for his own education he's not afraid to stop the teacher and ask questions his positive disposition is contagious to those around him on the playground he is inclusive to all that want to join in play his leadership skills are natural and flow with ease Michael's confidence is supported with humility it is no wonder that his vote his peers voted him as the ASB President Michael when I think about that flame and I think about the inspiration inside you're the type of person that provides inspiration for others because you set such a great example

055for us at lenstrom and everybody in belflower unified thank you you're welcome thank you so uh but before you go too far Michael why don't you hop on the mic there for a second uh tell tell me what's your favorite thing about going to Lindstrom helping other kids there we go all right is this your first time ever attending a board meeting yes is it is it exciting yes yeah uh and there's free pizza so thank you for being here Michael we really appreciate you keep up the good work okay thank you tell tour I said say hi I will thanks oh wait we we need a we we need a picture so I could I I can show Tori so once you come on up all of you if you will we'll take a

056group picture with the board e yes please if you're a Michael's teacher come up to the front for a picture e all right and at this time I would like to welcome our student board reporters representing belflower High School is Stephen Martinez welcome Stephen good evening board president critchfield members of the board interim superintendent Miss asito guest and fellow students I'm s Martinez I will be um this will be belflowers December board report so starting off we're going to be talking um we will be covering our gingerbread house building event that was actually this Tuesday where PT PTSA hosted this event where students and members of the community can come out and build a free gingerbread house um so you can see that there was students and families um that came out and built some

057gingerbread houses all those who participated who um were entered into a raffle to win multiple prizes such as that movie bucket in the top left um and now I'd like to cover Ensemble which started off their holiday season on December 4th by at their holiday coffee house which is an annual event to Showcase their program in a holiday style um those who went were able to get desserts hot chocolate and obviously listen to them sing they also performed at the bular street lighting ceremony on the six alongside May and sorry I didn't mean it in that way I didn't mean it in that way I was trying to go on to the next line um on December 7th they they participated in the Disney candle light Pro processional event um along with their alumni alongside

058the rest of the vocal department they will be performing tonight at the wi at Winterfest concert um yeah and Oh So currently our penny wars has raised over $200 for the local belflower community which helps families in need and we also have students who at belf which do receive this funding that does go to the city um this is event is a Twist to the traditional money or can food drives which which specifically this event helps students engage more um in our upcoming events our holiday parade and our winter snack Riley our holiday parade is an annual parade which we host inside the school throughout the hallways where students come out of the class to watch on LA to watch this parade on the last day before winter break um in the parade there are

059organizations such as cheer band um our classes they they come out performer in the parade just to Showcase um everything for the first semester and then for the winter snack rally uh different groups perform at this rally and we also play games such as musical chairs um I also like to showcase our 605 band belflower belflowers marching band is proud to be a part of the 605 band for this for this New Year's Rose Parade earlier this month they um they had their practice parade uh starting at roner stadium and going all the way to Mayfair Park which seen on the left and then they were also able to participate in South Gates parade where they showcase their new uniforms as seen on the right the band also received third place receiving bronze at the

0603A championships in Long Beach City College on November 25th um I would also like to congratulate current board clerk Mrs Garza on winning re-election and welcoming Miss syron to belflower unified I also want to congratulate Dr Sue El hen for the years of service to belflower unified thank [Applause] you thank you Stephen and representing Mayfair High School Gil frean uh good evening president critchfield interim superintendent Miss A SEO board members and District colleagues all right so starting off with academics Mr Keanu Lambert was awarded the every student succeeds award he you know he was at a low point he was going through a lot but he still prevailed and he was awarded a $250 scholarship and a Chromebook first quarter honoral uh that began today and we had more than 1300 student students with the

0613.0 GPA and higher which is super awesome and final exams are kicking off next week the 18th through the 20th all right for athletics we wanted to highlight the unified TS the unified program and unified cheer they had the Hoops tournament on December 6th it was a great event Good Times lots of schools came out and played uh and we're going to update uh the winter CIF Sports in January but I wanted to highlight Courtney Cummings she was the first player to be nominated to play on the LA County Allstar team at the Chargers Stadium so that was super cool for the Arts we wanted to highlight the 605 band parade which was throughout the community of Bulow and Lakewood they had their practice parade and and it was super cool I mean it was

062a great opportunity so awesome to see the communities come out and watch that walk was rough and I'm glad that I'm not doing that again in the actual parade but here's a little video on that High School bands are gearing up for the big one KCAL news photographer Assad Khalil a day shows us the practice routine in belflower as students get ready for the Tournament of Roses Parade today it's kind of like a test drive one of my goals in my in my career was to always take a band for the Rose Parade to do the Rose Parade you have to be pretty big I invited uh seven friends out to dinner and uh and said hey I want to do the Rose Parade would you partner with us and let's put a band [Music]

063together it's important that we acknowledge the efforts of our local Southern Californians and this was such a unique concept a composite band of eight area local area high schools that otherwise wouldn't have the opportunity to march on the parade we were absolutely intrigued we're so excited learning how to take 540 kids and merge them into being a marching band who have never existed before so that's the challenge it's definitely more of a culture culture shock per se all these bands have their own cultures you know they they have their own way of doing things we're still learning who the kids are I mean I know my kids but I don't know the others and so we're going to get to know each other over this next month and hopefully build a great relationship and uh

064and it's just going to be fun along the way the 605 band is one of the largest to ever play in the Rose Parade today's practice stretch from belflower to Lakewood Over a Four Mile route [Applause] yeah so congratulations to them for that uh our choir our Maritime our Maritime our show choirs have our first concerts December 18th and 19th next week at the Bulow Civic Center so check that out if you can all right so for activities our choirs not only did we go to Bellflower tree lighting we also did liquid tree lighting and I think they sounded terrific but we will redeem ourselves next week so check out those concerts you're going to love it we also had pictures with Santa you can see him in that bottom corner snowfest which was the

065middle school dance looked they said pretty lit and movie night tomorrow night they're showcasing the Grinch so if you're available come out free all right a special thank you to president critchfield for your service on the board you're always a light to the district I remember meeting you a couple years back at the opening of our steam building and you gave me some pretty good advice on my first campaign for class presidency so thank you for that and thank you for everything you've done all right don't don't forget to stay connected you can follow us on Twitter Instagram and Facebook at Mayfair buusd thank you for your [Applause] time thank you Gil um and representing sumerset High School is Jay Torres take it away good even good evening president Crestfield members of the board superintendent

066aavo and guests my name is Jay Torres and I am a senior in ASB and the student board board reporter for Somerset High School this evening I will be sharing with you our latest activities at Somerset and up and cominging events too I would like to introduce some of new staff members at Somerset High School we have a new Wellness counselor Miss Lauren Dillard who is with us on Mondays and Fridays to support students in the wellness center we also have a new community service worker Miss Stephanie Garcia she is here to help students and families with Community Resources we are excited to have them both here to help thank you to thank you to everyone who made it to Turkey Day at the Kias Hall the community donated $55 for a student scholarship fund

067and plenty of donated canned goods for people in the community the ASB students enjoyed serving you and spending time celebrating with one another sum Somerset applied to be a model continuation High School back in September and we were selected for a verification visit the team came to our school last week week and spent two days observing classroom instruction and extracurricular activities they also spent a lot of time talking with students teachers parents and district office leadership they said they were impressed by what they saw at Somerset the report they sent to the Department of Education determines whether we will continue to be recognized as a model school we will find out in the spring if we earn the award this week students got to hear a presentation from the Air Force uh Air Force about

068t taking the ASVAB and the value that one can earn from a military career After High School before we head off for our winter break we are looking forward to some fun activities the ASB is planning dress up days and fun events Monday is PJ day PJ day and we plan to play musical chairs Tuesday we are wearing to we are wearing Santa hats and drinking hot cocoa Wednesday there will be a kickball competition between the teachers and students Thursday we will be wearing our ugly holiday sweaters and Friday we are making Christmas cookies finally we are wrapping up the year with a food drive if you would like to contribute any items you can drop drop them off during school hours any day between now and December 19th thank you for Sumer uh supporting

069Somerset High School and we wish you a happy holiday season and we will see you back on January 7th 2025 for Block 5 [Applause] Steph Gil J thank you again very much and uh remember you can stay for the whole meeting but at this time if you'd like to get back to your school obligations you're free you're free to go but thank you guys for your reports one more round of applause for our student reporter all right it is now time for stakeholder Communications may I have btaa President Miss Carrie McDaniel come on down to the podium thank you for being here Carrie that one okay good evening president critchfield interm superintendent Mrs aavo Board cabinet members of the community um tonight I want to talk about the importance of documented Studio behaviors in Aries

070there are a few things I get emails about a lot and this is one of them the high schools have access to adding documentation on student Behavior but most of the elementary teachers do not and I don't understand why that is we are professional teachers why does one group have access when the others do not I have received emails from teachers who ask what do I do after I've written the student up held a parent conference talk to the admin and the behavior doesn't change what is next I've gotten emails from teachers who say if we don't create our own Google form and document student behaviors there would be no record because what is written on paper or referrals never make it into Aries this has been an issue for several years um if there's

071worry about what kinds of things or words we want teachers to use let's train them but not documenting behaviors ever makes it look like there are no issues we shouldn't be afraid of what the dashboard reports or if we are then we need better interventions in place in a system that teachers know that from 1 to 10 this is where the behavior Falls this is what the wording goes in Aries and this is the consequence I urge you to look into this and come up with a plan tonight's open Forum on cell phones is very important Studies have shown that humans are distracted by their phones I know I am I urge you to create a policy that supports the teachers who take phones away if that's their policy and supports the administration to stand

072up for the teacher if the parents complain we have become a society of immediacy and I think that we can all admit that if there's an emergency we're going to be on our phones over the years cell phones have cause a lot of issues no one can tell your tell your tone they can't see your facial expressions and it makes it easy to say things that one might not normally say because they're not directly in front of you our students need to talk to each other at snack at lunch not take up a corn do take up in a corner and put their eyes on a screen create a cell phone policy that addresses the learning environment and teaches responsibility I was having a conversation the other day with a teacher and we were talking

073about the importance of libraries we have so many students struggling with reading are we promoting the love of reading at an early age are our libraries open all day with staff for students to come in and choose a book see a book full of rooms sorry a room full of books and embrace the love of reading when the get to Middle School it's hard to instill the love of reading if they have spent six years only reading for information and not for pleasure libraries are important I urge you to take a visit to visit I take I urge you all to take a visit to our site libraries and ask what are they offering our students finally I will close on negotiations as BTA president I represent over 500 teachers in this District I am

074not in the room during bargaining and I have to rely on what the people in that room tell me BTA relies on our bargaining team to to do what is right for all of our members I would just like to say that increasing class size at any level is a sensitive topic I encourage all of you to make some time to visit our classrooms don't tell anyone you're coming just show up see what is going on in classrooms across the district on a daily basis I think you might get a better picture of what teachers are facing and maybe then the district can understand why increasing class size is not what best for students or teachers on a side note I know that everyone um I hope that everyone has a wonderful winter break and

075I hope that 2025 is good for all of us thank you and have a good evening thank you Carrie can I have PTA president Linda Mor I'm sorry can we follow up on the libraries to find out if they're open all day and the questions that she asked please yes can I one more time uh Linda Morgan come on up okay can I have that one awesome love it good evening everybody board president critchfield board members uh interim superintendent ASO cabinet um and a room full of people not used to that um I missed last month's meeting and I apologize um I kept some of the slides and I will briefly share some of those photos that I had collected with you guys um and so okay so this was last month's membership numbers our

076PTA members um over 2100 members and the breakdown from parents uh students teachers um and then on the right it shows you those that have actually had 100% teacher members um they all joined um so speaking of our teachers um got to go there right um thank you everyone uh for being here tonight and um advocating for her students and sharing your concerns and I want to thank the board and staff for listening and um hopefully continue the collaboration and come up with the best solution that serves our students best um sorry had to um and um just it was Thanksgiving you know and and we're continuing the uh season of gratitude so I wanted to share those that joined all 12 of our ptas um your continued support is really appreciated um we had

077Red Ribbon Week um The anti-drug Campaign and so these are pictures of each of our sites um Mrs Gara was part of our group that toured all the sites um got to see everything that our uh sites did our PTA said there we go sorry um I know it's a long meeting so I'm trying to go through them but I I mean I collected a bunch of pictures it was an awesome week um an awesome day to be able to visit them um and I want to thank all our volunteers for all their hard work and dedication um fall all of our ptas and PTSA hosted a fall event uh whether it was a trunk Retreat a fall festival um U you know providing a safe space for uh families to come together or Community

078come together um and celebrate the season where am I clicking um they also had um Veterans Day events and our Reflections are program celebrations students were recognized at each School site for their artwork that they submitted um okay so did May sent last month so I hope you all enjoyed the Thanksgiving break with your loved ones and then as we're um almost halfway into the school year of supporting our students and enriching our school Community I just wanted to take a moment and recognize the incredible work being done all around on behalf of our students and families um as every event that we organize every fundraiser we run every meeting we hold gets us one step closer to creating a school environment where our kids can Thrive and thank you all for your passion and

079commitment to our students um we held our this week last week we held our Red Ribbon Week recognitions um so the site visits and the um the judges comments took those all in consideration and were're able to recognize um our sites for all the hard work um based on you know student awareness Ness Community involvement uh their posters um and then our top three uh schools were actually um ilc Esther Lindstrom and the overall winner uh was Frankie Wood Elementary PTA um and I will just continue um so this month we are at about 2200 members um we had additional schools where uh 100% of the teachers joined our PTA um so for those that are actually watching it's Craig Williams PTA Woodruff PTA Steven Foster Thomas Jefferson Washington Elementary and Albert Baxter PTA um

080I realized that not everybody watching gets to see all the photos and the slides so want to get the shout out um so yes like I said 2200 uh members our goal for this year is 3,000 so if you haven't joined uh Join one or join Jo all please help us reach our goal um just as a comparison last year we had 2400 so um I think we can do it we're already at 22 and then to celebrate the winter holidays a lot of our sites um are having their events whether it's the Winter Dance uh Festival um movie night pajama dress up days um they are hosting food drives toy drives and doing the holiday to shop where the students can shop for their families um but it's different at each site so please

081check it out and then a little ways away but I shared some pictures on the reflections art program that they did at the school sites our Council will has collected um all the winning entries and we are doing our own uh Reflections Awards night on March 4th of 20125 everyone's invited and then um quickly wanted to share our our appreciation on behalf of belflower council ptas for your continued support all these years and for all your service and dedication to our students in belflower Unified School District and that is it um again lots of gratitude to everyone wishing you a wonderful holiday season with your family and I'll see you all next year [Applause] thank you Linda and now we have CA Communications officer Anthony Ramirez come on down welcome and thank you for being

082here and board president chrisfield board members interim superintendent House of v on cabinet members welcome happy holidays everyone couple of U brief notes for the csca update this month uh this month CA chapter president Michelle quer and CSA labor rep uh dotu olones have met with superintendent oo and deputies super superintendent Dr Smith concerning nutrition service hours sick leave Bank retirement issues and some Personnel issues uh our chapter President also met with assistant superintendent Alma woa and Dr Ryan regarding some Personnel issues and some very serious special education Aid issues so we're happy to that um we continuing that dialogue uh president quer attended public comprehens of school safety plan meetings at Thomas Jefferson uh Washington and Los Flor schools all of those were very informative uh we were unable to attend too many more

083but there were some scheduling conflicts um she also met with board president chrisfield and had conversations with board members Stewart and and mcgara and we're happy that those are continuing to express some ongoing dialogue as well cfca scheduled to resume bargaining negotiations on on December 18th we look forward to the next Alliance committee meeting that is scheduled in January and uh we have we also attended the recent Personnel commission meeting where they announced the new classified Personnel executive director and we are very much looking forward to working with him during this holiday season classified employees across the district helped almost all of our schools set up for their holiday shows and a lot of them personally assisted the students with their performances so we're happy that classified employees are are demonstrating engagement across every campus

084here um I want to Sidetrack a little bit here and have a couple of notes for the upcoming public hearing that you're going to have and I just wanted to get these out ahead of that um csca has a very compelling interest in exactly how and when any board policy is enforced we would like to see uniform standardized training and instruction for all relevant employees who may have to directly or indirectly enforce any policy and or report any violations we would expect a clear and consistent mandate to be communicated at the district level and across every site in addition csca would like to have some clear reassurances that all employees being directed to enforce any part of this policy to have the full backing and support of the District administration CSAA is aware that some

085families and students may not fully agree with any enforced limits on student cell phone use but if a serious safety crisis or an emergency were to occur you know we want we don't want classified employes ways to be personally subjected to whatever it is public outcry unhappiness um any type of liability right we we would uh like some reassurances that the District administration and the board have have our backs as we enforce something that you decide to craft that's a brief report for me happy holidays everybody thank you thank you Anthony at this time the board will be taking a five minute Wellness break and we will rejer J at uh 7:15 all right we will now rejourn for Open session at 719 p.m. and we will be moving on to our superintendent report Mrs

086aavo thank you the 2024 school year is coming to an end rapidly before us our students have six more days until winter break which just seems so fast we're approaching the end of the fall semester so I encourage all of our students to stay focused and finish strong as the holiday season brings our community together I want to take a moment to celebrate the diversity of our bflow family and the many Traditions that make this time so special whether you're observing Christmas Hanukkah Quanza laspadas or another celebration this season reminds us of the joy peace and friendship we share may your holidays be filled with warmth laughter and love alongside friends and family and before I conclude my comments this evening I'd like to address the messages that we've been receiving regarding negotiations with the

087bellfire Teachers Association I'd like to remind everyone in our community that on August 13th I spoke about bosd being known for its family feel I shared how we celebrate together and sometimes we disagree with each other but I also spoke about coming back together to support one another negotiations are often a time where groups May disagree for a period of time but the goal of negotiations is to work together to come back and support one another through an agreement between both parties this Con this continues to be my expectation for this District moving forward and my expectation is that we'll continue to move through this process in a collaborative manner in conclusion I look forward to a bright and promising New Year in 2025 and I wish you all a merry Christmas thank you miss

088alabo all right it's now time for the public hearing on agenda item 11.1 board policy 51 31.8 mobile communication devices while meetings of the governing board are not public meetings they are open to the public individual speakers will be allowed 3 minutes to address the board on each agenda item or or on the item and the board will limit the total time actually no don't do that part um okay uh all in if anybody's in favor of the policy now it be the time where you can come up to the podium and feel free to speak you don't need a card for this one if you're in favor of the policy now is the time you can come up and speak it's after after Mr critchfield can I back you up just for a second

089did we declare the public hearing open oh you're right got to do the power of the Gabel yeah you have to do that we got to rewind the whole thing uh I declare this public hearing now open so formal Dan thank you for being here thanks for declaring good evening president critchfield School Board superintendent oo District staff and community members thank you for dedicating the time to address this critical topic of cell phone usage during the school day Dr Smith presented data last meeting that phone usage in elementary schools is less problematic as fewer students own phones and family restrictions are greater however in secondary schools most students have phones with very little restrictions this increased access combined with the developmental stage of secondary school students creates significant challenges with that in mind on Monday

090December 9th we surveyed mayfair's teachers about cell phone usage 68 teachers responded which is 57% of Mayfair staff and roughly one-third of all secondary teachers in the district the data is clear 98.5% of respondents believe that cell phone usage during instructional time time negative negatively infects academic performance the survey also highlighted specific concerns about student cell phone usage during the day 100% of those 68 teachers agree that cell phones increase inappropriate activities such as meetups for fights romantic hookups gambling and even vaping and drug use 98% agree that cell phone use contributes to cyber bullying including social media posts about student and teachers or taking unsolicited photos and videos 94% agree that cell phones uh use negatively affects student mental health and decreases in-person social interaction when ask about potential Solutions respondents expressed deferring preferences

09153% support limiting cell phone use to non-instructional time 42% favor an even stronger approach restricting phones to only before or after school and that's 95% of respondents if students are permitted to use phones at break times 58% of respondents suggest requiring students to use their phones only in designated areas to decrease cyber bullying and video taping of fights beyond the numbers the additional comments reveal a common theme Educators need support to implement and enforce a cohesive policy many emphasize the importance of a uniform districtwide approach one that is both feasible and consistent across all schools with everyone from District admin to principles to classified to teachers all being held accountable to do their individual Parts moving forward it is critical that we develop a modern comprehensive and enforceable District policy that prioritizes not only student

092learning but also student well-being while offering practical tools for implementation with your guide and support we are ready to do our part thank you thank you Dan would anybody else like to speak I'm a parent of two teenagers one in Long Beach Unified and one in belflower unified and what I can tell you is when cell phones came into existence I think it was one of the most dangerous things that we gave to children it's probably more dangerous than other kind of weapons because they weaponize it I've watched my own children go into the bathroom where a teacher can't go and there's a fight going on where they videotape the fight they meet up and do it and then they post it the things that are happening on the campus is that these children are

093taping they aren't just doing it in secret they're then posting it to something that's going to follow them for the rest of their lives I think it's I I applaud the board I know this is going to be very difficult to impact because right now the inmates have taken over the Asylum and they're not going to go quietly and they're not going to give the phones up very easily I think they're going to be very Savvy they're probably more they're more stute with how to handle technology than we are and so it's going to be difficult to get that wrangled in but it's very important that we do that because they're children lest we forget their children and we put something into their hands and into their pockets that's given them access to adult material

094adult content adult adult communication and they aren't ready for it my own children includeed and I can take things away from them they can wipe their whole history on things it's it's it's this has been a problem for a long time we were remiss to allow them to just come into our schools in the first place it's going to be very difficult to get them back out of the schools but I would really like our district to be very mindful of how we go about doing that the messaging forward and how how we're going to handle I don't want to say confiscating but putting those things into a safe space so that they don't get stolen from other children and so that they're not they're not putting them in hiding them in other places it

095just then becomes Contraband so I would really value that I have a tutor for my children who teaches in a classroom in Long Beach and when they came in to observe her they said you're not teaching these kids and she said they're all on their phones you have literally no policy so I have no Authority in the classroom so when they come in if they're interested in learning then they then I can teach them but at this point those devices need to be put away it was hard enough having computers in our classroom because they can navigate away from that I'm grateful that Mayfair at least now has goguardian where there's some eyes on them but we should be controlling the media that they have in front of them and we should be controlling what

096we allow them to see and when they have their phones that is absolutely impossible so moving forward this is going to be a difficult task but it's really really a necessary one and while you're at it we have agency AIDS who apparently just like our children think that their phones are an appendage that's very difficult for us to have them not put them away because the safety of our kids then comes gets called into question when the people who are supposed to be super supervising them are like this it's fine if they're doing it on their break but their break is not any time that the children are within ey shot and then out of ey shot and then their phone beeps or Rings or whatever so it's not just a kid problem this is

097a problem that's a little bit larger than that and it needs to be addressed as well thank you Dr Robinson Mara ruins come on down so I guess I have sorry Mara real quick sir the comments can you keep them to yourself if you're going to be disruptive I'm gonna have you leave the room thank you keep going Mary I have a um a several different perspectives on this first of all I would like clear implementation like the CSA said um and to outside agencies the district needs to communicate to them what the cell phone policies are how they are supposed to um Implement those I actually work for an outside agency in the district does that make sense and that information doesn't always get relay to us I find it through my principles because

098I have a really good working relationship but my boss at the agency doesn't tell me does that make sense so we need to make sure that communication is happening as well um if we get to that point where we have to need clear guidelines so that when whoever is interacting with this child we don't get our Authority taken away if that makes sense by someone else saying oh no you did that incorrectly I need clear guidelines on how that's happening from a parent perspective yes I think they need to be put up in the classroom so the that the kids can learn they're not being distracted by their neighbor on whatever it is um keeping them safe so that there is an emergency one thing I didn't notice in this report that I printed out

099is dealing with those who have mental health issues some of those students who have panic attacks or anxiety levels have something with them on their phone so does is that covered under Health um number three students Health as determined um because it just says licensed physician I don't know if a psychiatrist would be covered in that so that's something I wanted to note um yes we all feel like their appendant is that's our like our security blanket that less used to carry around so we have to address that as well but my my request is clear guidelines yes I would like to see them out of the classroom so that all students can learn learn because if you have ADHD whatever's going on in the corner is going to be catching your attention and please

100speak with outside agencies so we have clear direction as well whether it's the AIDS coming in to help with the students or those supervising the children during the day thank you Mara I saw you jumping up earlier come on down welcome thank you whoa hold on a second here I have that problem all the time can I there we go hi my name is Rob camstra and I'm currently teaching at Washington Elementary School third grade uh I believe cell phones have a place especially in an area whereby agent uh emergencies need immediate attention however students do not need the cell phone during this time at Washington school we have a caring staff who can notify parents and Guardians in the case of emergencies the student should not have this privilege please consider a platform which

101turns off all cell phones of students as they enter in each bu us school or require students to deposit them somewhere so they are not able to use them while they are on the school campus thank you very much thank you is there anybody else who' like to speak on this one oh yeah you can yeah come on over welcome and thank you for being here thank you to the board and the president I teach English and El at Bor high school I have a very strict cell phone policy I also have 48 kids or 38 kids in my 12th grade senior class I take phones away um but it's a war of attrition I use go Guardian religiously but they can thwart go Guardian uh by simply using their phone so in comparison to

102that I have El classes that average about 25 and there's no cell phones out in those classes their performance outperforms the seniors by at least double digits so it really when I think about uh increasing class sizes the cell phone equation comes in there's no way I have a co- teer as well we constantly are taking phones away we cannot constantly monitor um and there is a part of personal responsib um it's frustrating because I love technology I'm pretty adapt at it I like to stay one step in front of the kids um I love it it's a tool and and I've used it in the classroom uh but again it comes down to sheer numbers um and the other consideration is um consistent and fair enforcement of cell phone compensation I have witnessed administrators

103giving phones back to kids have them out during State Testing while other kids are harsh and require their parents to come pick up their phone so fair enforcement across the board IEP considerations you have to live with that law so if it's in the I AP um as a classroom teacher I can live with that um I can enforce cell phone policy in my classroom and keep it as uh sellf free as much as I can but when there are serious violations or continual violations an Administration doesn't have the spine to do anything about it and hold people accountable they say consequences don't work consequences get me to come to my job every day because poverty is not an option I don't drive my motorcycle down the 91 doing 100 miles an hour I could

104but consequences keep me from doing you know so there's a lot of things to take into consideration it's easy to say no cell phones in the classroom but without the support of the administration it's really it's sort of a moood point Thank you for time thank you sir would anybody else like to speak and all right welcome just to let you know we have one um that's submitted via email that we need to read to you when you're ready okay thank you good evening Mr President board members Madam interim superintendent cabinet and guests my name is Caroline Thompson and I'm the district behavior intervention specialist tonight I am speaking on the potential cell phone policy I want to start with the scary fact the typical American spends 11 hours per day interacting with digital devices

105and not fleshy objects we check our phones 150 times per day how our brains learn to be human and compassionate it takes human connection for that interacting and socializing with others have a physiological impact we learn to regulate our emotions via social connection we are essentially shooting ourselves in the foot every time we wake away from a human being to attend to a device we are losing the ability to regulate and we do this 150 times per day it's no wonder our schools are experiencing a massive explosion of behavioral problems our students are not learning to regulate themselves because their faces are in digital devices all day I hope to make your job a little easier and not harder by providing data like this I have the lovely benefit of being in classrooms all day

106I support every School site and I've been in most classrooms I stand at the back of the class I just watch and I'm collecting data and when I say I love my job it's an understatement so whatever our district decides to do I'm here for it I'm going to gear up and I'll be the first in the line to enforce but the hardest part of my job it's seen the look of defeat and some of the students who are coming to school prepared these students want to be there they want to alarn they want to engage and all it takes is one peer to cause major disruptions because they can't control themselves around technology it breaks my heart to see the look on teachers faces they look at me and they're like saying help me

107please what do I do if we are going to do this we have to if we're going to do this and have a ban we need to call in the reinforcements because we're going to need more security part of my job includes responding to crisis calls for students who have lost control if a student is eloping the campus destroying the classroom or attacking their teacher I get called or one of our 22 hardworking Behavior assistants sometimes I conduct assessments for these students and the majority of our secondary students that I was called to assess the primary behavior of concern inappropriate cell phone use I'm here tonight to advocate for a balanced approach to cell phone use I firmly believe whatever policy we put in place consistency will be key we already have a pseudo ban

108in effect for classrooms and it is not being followed this week I received an email about a secondary student who refused to put his phone away he stated it is my property and I do not have to comply he later added I will never comply with putting my phone away when asked how his parents felt I was told the grandparents are not supportive and they're afraid of him the student then stated if my grandparents take my phone away it will be hell so my question is who is going to take this student's phone away I have a lot more but no more time I make a motion to allow her to continue that's fine can I get a second uh it's uh about two minutes sure okay cool thank you so the student said it

109will be hell and I believe him so the question I like answered is who's going to take the student's phone away if we have a ban if the family is scared of him and so should we every year I host crisis management trainings and physical Crisis Intervention which in a side note I think we need to make mandatory by the way um in this training we learn what to do when you are being physically attacked by a student one of the first and last things I tell And I stress to everybody who goes to my trainings is under no circumstances do you ever take a student's phone away why because it's a quick way to get assaulted earlier today I Googled student assaults teacher I got almost three million hits when it comes down to

110enforce in this policy who will be the enforcers teachers are not equipped nor should they be expected to confiscate student property again my trainings are going to tell staff to not touch student phones but we will have a ban in place that is telling them to confiscate phones it's going to contradict each other I believe the core issue isn't the phone itself but the social media ecosystem designed to capture and monetize attention phones are simply the delivery mechanism for these psychologically sophisticated platforms safety is a critical concern for parents and Educators alike cell phones do provide an immediate lifeline emergency situations um they provide the the quick ability to communicate which can be a lifesaver for students with special needs cell phones can be transform transformative translation apps assist ESL students these devices can be

111powerful tools of inclusion and accessibility however cell phones are not just communication devices they are sophisticated attention stealing machines a single notification will derail a student's concentration breaking the thread of learning that teachers work so hard to achieve the mental health implications are equally alarming cyberbullying social media anxiety and digital addiction are ravaging our students psychological well-being these devices create constant social pressure reducing face-to-face interactions and genuine human connections that are crucial for adolescent development the reality is that there are valid compelling points on both side of this debate ultimately the most effective approach likely is in a total ban or complete freedom but a balanced approach that addresses both the potential benefits and risk of cell phones and more importantly social media these adaptive policies should one recognize the potential educational benefits of Technology

112two address legitimate concerns about distraction and mental health and three teach responsible digital citizenship thank you thank you very much would anybody else like to speak yeah yeah come on down welcome thank you good evening John Young um I'm going to Pivot a little bit and talk about this um um a little differently um you guys are dealing with a situation that is has been growing and is daunting and no doubt um it's going to be a complex one to to solve um Jonathan height is the one who wrote uh the anxious generation and I think his book has probably prompted a lot of people to uh start doing this kind of work um one of the things I think to keep in mind is that he talked about um you know why many children

113do have cell phones today um he talks about in 1998 is when cell phones started getting into kids hands and then they changed in 2005 when those phones became uh smartphones so he has a recommendation for example for how children could have a cell phone that's um suitable for kids one that is a flip phone and only has a couple of apps for simple notification between say a parent and a child um in his research and the research that he summarizes he says that most parents will buy their child a foam when they're young because they are uh fearful of their safety um that uh safety that he's that he's discussing had to do with the State of Affairs in the late 90s when things like um say the nightstalker Norwalk had grabbed everyone's attention

114so you you fast forward today and the ironies that he's that he's pointing out in his book is these cell phones have created a very anxious generation and it's partly because we've given children a cell phone that is making their environment even more scary than reality really is so he does have a suggestion for how to uh deal with it when you do take the phone away and that is uh a curriculum that he has supported it's called let grow um I'm happy to talk to any of the scho U school board members about it that the idea is to um teach children how to uh do things for themselves and on their own and at the same time encourages parents to know that while you can be conscious of your child's safety you don't

115have to create a sense of constant fear because that's oftentimes what the parents are reacting to when they're giving them these devices so it's called let grow I'm happy to talk to anybody about it some more thank you thank you is there anybody else who would like to speak on this welcome back welcome thank you uh Red Hat teacher here tonight thank you um just a quick compare and contrast so last year um the seventh graders were very very it was very difficult to get the cell phones out of their hands and have them keep it in their backpack and they had a very difficult time handing it over to us um as a group of Middle School teachers we organized ourselves and we came up with the plan of what we were going to

116do and I was very apprehensive implementing that this year for the fear of we're going to go to battle with these kids because there is that addiction to the phone but because our um admin team and counselor supported our plan and was very well communicated parents and and students understood this is how it's going to go so this year's seventh um graders um cell phone have put in the box fill it slip boom they get it back at the end of the class they do it again it goes to the office but anyway consequences are working because we're working it to Fidelity so talk to us at Mayfair Middle School we will let you know what how our plan is working for us thank you thank you all right uh anyone else so now it'd

117be if you uh anybody would like to come to the podium uh who would be against the policy I know it's kind of a weird delineation there but no all right uh Miss Stewart so I just wanted to clarify I would love some feedback because I appreciate appreciate all of these comments but it's not helping me answer the question that I have am I allowed to ask ask a question and elicit feedback from the audience yeah so it's a a public hearing which means it is agendized you can engage in dialogue with uh the speakers or ask questions and have them respond as well okay so my question is this we actually our policy states right now that we're not supposed to have um cell phones in the class so it's basically a bell tobell

118no sell right now but obviously if that's the way we stick with it then we need for our administrators to enforce that um at my school we have a policy where they're in their backpacks and they're just put away and they can only use them when they right before they enter campus and when they leave campus so they're not allowed to use them at lunch or breaks that's what I'm struggling with I think I'm hearing from everyone that people don't want them in the classrooms you have Chromebooks they can use I get that for me as a board member I need feedback on do we limit them at lunch and recess because again I'm a teacher I see the things that they do they take pictures of me walking through the quad sometimes and post

119them they jump off buildings so they can go viral I teach middle school so it's a little different than high school and I get it um a 12-year-old is not the same as an 18y old but what I would like to know is what is our community's opinion on keep them out of the classrooms or keep them off campus entirely until they leave campus can some of you please come and give me your thoughts because that's what I need for this policy for me to approve this somebody please so if any would like to come back to the podium hi Marin foot again I'll I'll give a quick response I do believe that kids do need to have that communication access to their parents throughout the school day as long as it's not done during

120my class time so I do understand that parents need that connection and kids need that connection with their parents so I as an individual teacher I'm okay with that thank you would anyone else like to brief response hi my name is Tony Woods my daughter has had a cell phone I had to get her a cell phone basically when she got into fifth grade because she got into Ensemble Dance Program you guys transported my daughter from Steven Foster Elementary to Washington Elementary we got a pickup time that was in approximate pickup time I need and sometimes the buses were late at one time the bus was even late like 45 minutes I needed to know where my daughter is there was no communication as to when they're coming back we just went to the school

121waited and they got there when they got there so I have I have to track my daughter just today her um chair practice was cancelled so she was at school with her backpack I dropped her off at 8:30 dropped her off at 8:30 my other child which the times of the you know going to school is also inconvenient for everyone but I make it work and Ella immediately called me and said I I don't need to carry this second backpack which is what she has to carry two backpacks she's very petite girl so I immediately left Steven Foster drove all the way back to mayford to get it if she can't call me then she's going to have to be stuck with that all day and I would assume my daughter was getting out at

122approximately 5:30 because there's still not a time for that I need to be able to communicate with my daughter I track her on that I have a responsible student I think you just need to communicate with the parents what the expectation is with these phones but I need to communicate with her and as far as you know enrollment going down I would 100% pull my daughter if she wasn't able to communicate with me she's in cheer she's in ASB she leaves on buses we're talking about weekend we're talking about during school we're talking about at night it's all varying times just like the schedules she's out at 158 today could have been 5:30 she's out at 1116 next week 3:35 tomorrow 6:30 this day I need to talk to her and and it's dark when

123we're going there and she comes out all varying times it's very much approximate but I can look and track her okay she's walking this is where she's at you guys let them go at lunchtime and I didn't even no I I basically made a phone call and then the parents got a message saying oh yes they're able to leave for lunch we could have our kids just leaving for lunch doing God knows what in the neighborhood and we come back to pick them up because we're assuming the school is keeping them during lunch but they're free to leave so they're free to leave at a different time than we were thinking they're free to leave so we need to be able to follow our kids and I have a a a responsible child who's responsible

124with her phone all of her teachers when I go in their classrooms just like she said they have policies they take their phone they put it in a thing discipline the kids and it starts in elementary school and in hers it was they were they were bad coming into maer from the the discipline issues that were coming from the elementary school and it just proceeded to get worse so they need we do not have some communication with our kids so just to clarify um what I'm talking about is they have their phones I'm not saying they're not allowed to bring their phones but they have their phones and they're in their backpack so they can keep them on silent in their backpack all day long locations and just you guys know there's four um four

125times where they can actually use their phones um one is they can ask for permission I do it all the time with my students I'm in the locker room so they can't have their phones in the lock room but they will come in my office and say can I call my mom absolutely so there are those builtin so knowing that do you still think that they should be able to use their phones at recess and lunch sometimes she does have to communicate with me at that time but I I get it if they're taking videos of stuff but also if my kid was in the bathroom and was a fight I do appreciate if there's a video because it's going to happen and then they're just going to be be silent so I get it

126that they're posting this but give them discipline action as far as the children that are posting and doing inappropriate things with that but we do need to see who is in there and what is going on because kids will stay silent and then we'll have somebody bullied and tortured and then you know things happen thank you for your opinion I appreciate it thank you um president creville can we please read the written one that was submitted via email too yes let's do that one then I'll come back to you sir thank you wait do I have it oh no Bon I have it the email States so many schools are using their position of authority to enforce a policy of bell-to-bell no cell phones powered off and in backpacks all day snack and lunch too

127it's in writing and on many schools websites as a schoolwide policy M Bud it is left up to the individual teachers or explained verbally by administrators using phrases like the majority of teachers agree and never stated as an actual policy districtwide in writing I feel this piece is so important I'm finding many schools are holding the line there also as a school in writing when we used to have a discipline Matrix It stated clearly no cell phones in view Andor powered on during the school day or during participation in school activities it said that right here at BD and that was not the 1950s it was just a few years ago why are we choosing to ignore rules that so many people have already spent so much effort to enact we behave instead as if

128it's some giant monster of an undertaking to solve this as if it's some new problem when in fact it was settled 10 years ago why do we insist on spending year after year acting like we need to start from scratch what is the fascination with starting everything from square one as adults we must stop this destructive problem we can no longer allow this experiment to go on Larry Tannis sorry I was on my phone uh thank you for that uh sir you're up next thanks for letting me speak again I guess it rounds out the comments yes in the classroom absolutely you know as I already stated you know Bell to Bell no cell phones and I really do try to practice that but I am kind of in the um I'm kind of more

129utilitarian and that uh to think that you're going to have a moratorium on cell phones during lunch snack and everything outside the classroom and all the quads we don't have the resources don't have the funds the disruption that would cause um among the community meaning the students they will I believe that they would Rebel silent Rebellion refuse to go to class refuse to work um and it's going to it would affect them so there has to be kind of a give and take um I try to find a compromise in things when it's reasonable and not immoral um and so allowing them to be on campus to use their phones I mean there has to be something where the parents have to do um we have to respect parent rights but we also have to

130have parent expectations that they're going to be in charge of their child's mental health and not leave it to the state um as a worker of the state so um but I really think a balanced approach and I just think it's really unrealistic to think that you're going to put the the toothpaste back into the tube for a lack of a better metaphor thank you can I ask a clarifying question because we do do it at my school and it does work so I know it works but again I'm teaching sixth seventh and eth do you think the policy should be different with Elementary versus high school it's a campus size I think it should be more predicated on the size of the student body you know I think U you know it it's a

131powerful tool I mean it should the teacher should have some discretion I know some Math teachers you know it it's very useful for them I think Somerset being a smaller you know environment um it may work to allow cell phones to just encourage engagement um I have found that technology is very engaging but as a teacher I have to teach them when it's appropriate to use it um I use AI in half for the last couple years but I teach the students how to use it as a tool and I try that do that with cell phones but as term as on lunch I mean it gets in the whole issues of just basic human rights and parental rights and legal issues and but comes down to really money and resources and time and personnel

132and if you just don't have the resources and time and personnel and that money could be spent uh for interventions uh you know for a lot of our struggling students in this district with Linguistics and Mathematics um that money that you would spend to try and enforce a Draconian cell phone policy on the outside of the classroom that's money taken away for like my ELD students and I'm a bit protective of of them so thank you I appreciate hopefully that answered no that helps thank you okay thank it's very helpful um I hear what we're saying Miss Stewart I don't know if I'm going to be helpful but I'm going to try I think if if the world was ideal and we're in a Mary Poppins movie cell phones need to be out they need

133to be out of schools it needs to be a total ban but we are not there when when that lunch bell rings at Mayfair and I'm out there thousands of phones they're everywhere so how we are going to control that I I can't even wrap my brain around how we would do that then we got to consider the watches the earbuds and now there's Rings these days that two techy stuff I just I think most experts would agree that social media is rotting our brains it needs to go away but how so yeah thank you no thank you I appreciate it I need all the perspectives yeah I know how I feel I need you guys all to give me thank you I really appreciate it too because i' I've kind of gone 360 on

134this whole thing because I'm I'm techie but uh when we were first talking about uh this policy when I learned that we already had a policy that said was a complete uh you know you can't have your phone on in class at all when I started going to the sites and hearing from the teachers of what the issues are I think no matter what we decide as a board and some of you have spoken on it this evening it has to be enforced and we have to give you the tools and the training to enforce it but also the backing uh to where you don't feel like you're G to confiscate a phone and all of a sudden it's given right back and now you're the bad guy and you know it that's a you

135know you're going to you're going to lose a lot of energy for nothing when you do that so whatever we decide uh it it has to be enforced and we have to have that discussion of how we get that enforcement because we were looking at uh some schools have gone full band some have gone those Yonder bags and made that investment and we're going to have a lot of data uh this year as those schools start rolling some things out but the Staffing the enforcement the security uh putting this extra Duty on everybody is going to be uh I've had to learn a lot at the SES of what that would really look like and what that would take um so I really appreciate all the comments tonight uh but it's a it's a massive

136Hill uh for sure um yeah get up there it is possible that rather than we go all or nothing we F we grandfather in and we phase out so if you make a policy we I don't have a problem in TK and they don't have a problem in Kinder and they don't have a problem in first or second third maybe fourth fifth and sixth we start having a problem so once you decide what you do maybe we start rolling it out and I think it's underestimating the Integrity of our children as Citizens to assume that they are just going to make poor choices I mean some of it I think has to land in the expectations that we have on them we're preparing them to be Global Citizens I'm sorry this is like telling my

137kids they can have sex in my bedroom because they're going to do it anyway and they have access to the liquor in the closet because they're going to do it anyway and bring your friends over and you can do the drugs here where I can monitor it that's a little like what I hear us saying like well they're going to do it anyway I think at some point uh we have to be the adults and take back the job of being the teachers and the parents and yeah we're going to have differing opinions but most of the people in this room didn't have phones in high school so I mean and we're educated and competent and we can use use those now we're preparing them to be Global Citizens and to work they can't go

138to their job and sit on their phone all day they will not stay employable we're talking about Futures we're building all of our future I think maybe it's not all or nothing right now maybe that won't be successful but maybe it's build out the policy and we phase it in and unlucky them who don't get the better policy I mean it's really we're doing a disservice to them by letting them just do whatever they want so I I think the most important thing I think you said it is we have to have a policy one of the things we've lacked in this district for decades is clear policy procedure and protocol it kind of comes down to you're going to have to make a decision you're going to have to implement it you're going to

139have to be consistent the language has to be the same on every single site what we do we all have to do essentially we're a family somebody's going to have to be the parent tell us how we're going to run things and we're going to have to do it and I think if you look at the data of what other people are doing you can model some of that but at some point this is belflower Unified School District District make a decision for us as a board and that's what we move forward and do and then the hill we die on is the one that we find out doesn't work I mean you implement something and what it where it doesn't work then you course correct it as you go thank you Dr Robinson and

140I think that's that's the last part said I think that's exactly what we're doing like the uh so AB 3216 is actually what prompted a lot of this conversation and the board was very proactive in sending out the survey to the community um and also having this public hearing the board wanted to hear from everybody directly and then even you know policies can change over time uh but what I think the board had a very big interest in is knowing that we had a policy that was supposed to address the issue but didn't seem to be working so we wanted to make sure we put some sunshine on it and make sure that we're all on the same page so we can have uh give the support that we need to on the the policy

141and yeah uh anybody else like to speak before we move on and close the public hearing anybody but Dan F I'm just all right oh yeah Miss Stuart just to address your question and the survey that we did 42% were in favor of a beginning of school till end of school ban this was teachers correct teachers correct um no just telling you the data get I I completely agree with Miss Wood that we need to know where our students are um I think you heard it a little bit but teachers are all the time I get Mr Fong I forgot my PE close can I text my mom no problem turn on that phone it's not a big deal you know if there are emergencies if there are issues I think the majority of teachers

142I'm not going to say all most of them in this room uh would do do that they would allow their the student to do it if it's an emergency or if there's a need um I get phone calls from the office all the time hey Grandma just called so and so needs to come to the office so there still is that communication piece even with the phones put away uh realistically you know if we're talking about complete B the Yonder bag is probably the way to go it's an investment uh but it allows for the quick enforcement and if there's an emergency they can always be torn apart and I would be happy to reimburse my entire class if that is ever necessary so that the district doesn't even have to pay for that uh

143bag um but but those are accessible put that on public record you can you can put it on public record absolutely uh it's it's absolutely worth it I think on both ends um and to miss Thompson's point it's a great point that as soon as that Bell Rings everyone's on their phones I think we could say that might be a problem for some of us you know and we see the parent data that Dr Smith presented at the last meeting and I think a lot of parents don't understand the prevalence of cell phone usage in our in our schools and especially during free time when they should be interacting learning how to communicate uh taking a breath from the technology which we put them on Chromebooks all the time so they are getting plenty of

144screen time as Miss Thompson told us as well uh even without them being on their phone phones during lunch and snack but uh I again like we've heard a lot we just need a to Sunshine you know whatever policy we come up with and we need it to be across the board everyone is enforcing it whatever we decide but I certainly want to make sure that our students and our parents are taken care of at the same time um which no matter what and again those y bags it's a quick magnet open it up you can text it or I've given students you know I said to students hey what's your parents number I'll text them even if even if they don't have a phone or phone is broken so there are ways I think

145where you know we need to explore all the options and uh come up with the compromise and think about all all sides of the issue because I appreciate everything that was said by a lot of people tonight only get up here like two or three more times thanks see you soon thank you Dan all right any more uh comments before we close the before we close the public hearing portion are you going to allow the board for discussion before you close it so after we close the public hearing then we'll the board will discuss going once going twice all right now to clear that public hearing closed is there any discussion from the board um sorry so um about the cell phone policy um um for me as a senior um I'm not 100% like

146opposed to the band but for me I believe that um you know cell phones they should be put away during instructional time um especially um you know if somebody can't do that or put away their cell phone I feel like and that is a problem I feel like there should be further consequences and you know further extrication um but for example um me I use my phone when I have to sign in or when I have to go into school or go out of school it's called MinGa it's um a schoolwide um app and this helps people or students go around with the hall pass and it shows how long you're in the restroom for so teachers and staff they utilize it a lot um but I feel like with the cell phone policy some

147people or some students might work their way around it for example like Yonder pouches I feel like some students might bring a fake phone and have their real phone in their pocket you know I'm just saying like a lot of students might just you know to a point you know work their way around it um so that's like I said not a total ban but more consequences and if they can't put it away and if they are having problems then like I said further um consequences and um security so yeah thank you student board member OA uh vice president Stuart I have a question so she brings up MinGa is MinGa going to be able to be used if they don't have their cell phones is there if I if I so that would just

148go away completely if they don't have their no that's not right so in in the policy it actually says um the with the exception of uh where did it go the exception for digital ID cards if applicable students are permitted to use the devices on school premises for accessing their digital ID cards and I add had a question about this too which may require for identification no but my question isn't that I get that that they need to use the mobile IDs to use MinGa but if we're saying no mobile phones then you can't really say well you can't have phones but you can use them for MinGa that doesn't really work so I'm asking if we said that they couldn't have their phones would that program go away my understanding is that would be

149a problem your students do use those for things like hall passes they also for example use that digital ID for lunch and for breakfast that's how they're getting their meals so it's a bit of a problem and it sounds like a bit of conflict of interest we're talking about how phones are a problem but then we have these things that they have to use their phones all the time when they're out of class going to the bathroom I don't know I'm so confused and if I can and I'll go right back to you in just a second um I was wondering why for that being in here because sorry but he's saying that you can use your IDs you don't have to use your phone is that correct that's correct they can go old school

150They can they have them now is that what we're saying okay so that's a different answer then they can use that without their phones yeah I'm not sure how they would use their ID for a hall pass and I'm thinking that's something that would have to be worked out at the site hey Dan thank you well I obviously I need the right information thank you president kville but I need the accurate information for me to make decisions so thank you for thank you so uh so I was wondering with the exception for that dig ID cards if we're saying even in the the current proposed policy that uh they would still have their phones on them they just have to be put away Bell to Bell um they would still be able to use their

151digital ID cards to get in the school right so is this for if they have to be put away because this policy says that they for for secondary that they can have them out in lunch and break so why do we have an exception for ID cards because they don't you what I'm saying is they don't use the ID cards in class ever right is there ever a reason to have them in class so then why would there need to be an exception that makes sense so that's a question for you Ryan the exception was written into the draft policy for the board's consideration mainly because there is widespread usage of digital ID cards and MinGa not just for Hall Pass purposes but for identification purposes of obviously but also there's quite a few notifications

152that are going through MinGa as well so that exception was included in the draft policy specifically because high schools to my understanding are using that technology pretty frequently and so if there's an occasion where a student would need to use their phone to access their ID card to do something on campus regard whether it's in class or not if we're using digital ID cards that are accessible via phone it makes sense to have some kind makes sense to me to have some kind of um exception for that however again this is the board's policy this this is the board's policy draft it can go any way the board would choose so but they don't typically use like that in CL like we're not allowing them cell phone use in class for that it's I I

153don't know if I would speak specifically to that because there could be an occasion where an ID card is needed to be in class you're registering for something okay I don't know I'm sure there's probably a time that's come up where students have needed access to an ID card to do something in class um certainly out of class class but our teachers would know our principles probably would know as well I appreciate that let me go down to student board member Jo say um to use MinGa in class the only time I've ever like using it is when I need to um make a haul pass like let's say I need to go to the nurse or the bathroom I can make myself a pass and the teacher doesn't need to do it for me

154um but that's like the only time um you can also it shows your ID and your ID number so let's say you're filling something out in class you can just go on MinGa and it has all your information and then on top of that it shows um you know notifications and you know stuff that is going on around the school not only through the week but let's say per day so I not maybe not during class as much but definitely like outside usage maybe to check in somewhere great I appreciate that vice president Stuart okay so first off on our next Friday memo can we get some information on MinGa cuz I'm a little confused right now again I'm not trying to say that kids are going to do bad things but I can't imagine

155that they can just make their own hall passes and just leave class whenever they want so maybe I'm not totally understanding the system so can you just kind of give us a little bit of information on how that works we can we'll provide that to you okay thank you thank you vice president Stewart board member Armstrong well as you guys know I do have a I have a senior also and um you know I'm like these parents here my child needs her phone for unexpected things that could happen um I do agree with Dr Robinson we just need to find we we need to roll it out and we need to educate our children because we're not getting away from technology we're moving forward so we have to teach them acceptable use of the of

156the of of cell phones and I'm telling you this these smartphones are it's everything is on there the world the whole world is open so we I I don't have any problems I'm I'm also a teacher but I don't have any problems with my students my students don't have cell phones but they sure know how to work them and they better not find your your they better not figure out your passcode if you have one but I think we need to make sure that we we teach our children and we start young and teach them the acceptable use you know how we have the acceptable use of Technology I'm sorry we have ai coming up I mean well AI is here so we we we have to teach and and and and and and teach

157to teach our children what Integrity is and and virtue is because we do we have we have students who use the phones the way they're supposed to be used so as long as we have in the power policy that balance now I do know a teacher that has um she has a little storage box to where the phones go right in there because she's teaching she has a lesson she has no time for a cell phone so if the if the teacher is teaching and has that lesson and it the the the phone is not required it should not be a problem I said it should not be a problem however if you have those children when we some children depends on what's going on in their mental Heir you guys got to remember we're

158in a mental health crisis also and it's not just for the children we we we need to possibly figure out a way to store those phones in the classroom allow the children to have their phones when they're not in instructional time so I don't know we have and and we have to get our parents on board I heard one person say you know that they're afraid of our their their own child so all these things need to be considered but we have to get the parents and the Guardians on board and we have to find that balance approach thank you board member Armstrong vice president Stuart um sorry I have one more question on MinGa can that MinGa can it be used on their Chromebooks I'm hearing yes in the audience okay that that makes

159a difference for me um and then another just comment it's okay I just want him to hear um another comment on page two of the policy down at the very bottom it says collaborative policy development it says the principal or a design at each School site will work collaboratively with staff to develop clear policies I disagree with that I agree with a lot of things that we heard from our public where we should have one policy for the district and it should be for all principles and all Sites I don't think we should let sites do this individually so that is something that I would change in this policy um and then the next one at top um promote digital citizenship I would love to know this policy says that we should do that and

160we should do that and I would love to know what we are doing each year to promote the digital citizenship amongst all of our students because I think that's necessary thank you vice president Stuart um yeah so uh ab3 3216 it says we have to create a policy that limits cell phone uses by uh June 2026 right so that's like what what they're saying this is uh you know we took initiative we're talking about it now but I think policies will change over time I think honestly I I was kind of Dan and I talked for I I don't think that they're doing much good for our kids period and I and I think in a perfect world some of us would agree that they shouldn't have them at all but it's not a perfect

161world and people have legitimate concerns um I even myself I I track uh you know the little air tag where like the Apple watches like for my daughters it's a must you know I'd feel weird if they didn't have them on and that's one that and thank you for putting that uh in the survey again Ryan like you know we asked about Apple watches as well because uh I think I forgot who said it but the technology isn't just about phones and it won't be in two three years I can't wait to buy the new Apple glasses I mean like then we have to have a separate policy like the technolog is going to it's going to keep moving the goal po so I think we we need to um we need to uh address

162the root uh problems um and and for me with all of our policies we've talked a lot about policies this year is whatever our policy is we have to stand behind it we should know what's in our policy and uh we need to support people that are enforcing the policy and we can't if if we're not going to enforce a policy might might as well not even have one uh and if you have a policy and you know you're not going to do it well it degrades the uh the value of all your other policies so whatever we decide on it it has to be something that we can stand behind and we can do uh and you know whether that's financially Staffing so that those are my thoughts on it um I know there's

163going to be still some more discussion on this going uh further uh vice president Stuart I um am wondering if teachers are watching a video at the beginning of the school year and filling out Google Docs and if that's monitored by the district um probably not since you guys can you clarify your question my question is I was told that teachers actually do watch a video on digital citizenship and they fill out a Google form does the district monitor that form to make sure all teachers are doing that and if so what grades are they being done all of them and yes it is being monitored and there's a deadline for it okay so I would love if you guys if you know that and we're talking about this please chime in and let us

164know these things so that they're not answering our questions because we all should know this right I mean we should know this and if you guys know it please tell us because we need your advice when we're talking about creating policy thank you vice president Stewart um before we close public hearing again thank everyone who spoke about this I I don't think any not many people think they have like the right answer this is a very difficult uh issue that we all kind of handle in our own houses and then to do it for a school district is very difficult I'm not going to pretend like I have all the right answers but I'm glad that we're spending the time discussing it and I thank you for being a part of that uh do I

165have a motion to close the public hearing you have that motion second thank I have a motion second roll call please you told me that's how you already closed the public hearing you just move on from the item oh okay so I don't know you don't have to do anything just move on to the next it I'm I'm just going above and beyond Andrew all right we will now move on to discussion items uh Mrs asabo yes sir we have two discussion items this evening let's begin with item 11.1 board policy y 51 31.8 mobile communication devices I'll turn it back over to you you just discussed would anybody like to talk about cell phones now no all right uh do I have any questions or comments from the board regarding uh policy 513 1.8

166it was just a discussion so we're bringing it back for an actual reading correct you are this is your first reading this is your first reading of that draft it'll come back for a second okay so then if that is the first reading then I suggest that on that page that I talked about we make it a cross the district uniformed policy that it's not up to the principle or the sites to figure it out I think it should be a district policy that all the sites follow what do you guys think I agree with that um president chrisfield do you sit sitting with me and we go through this you know like little president creville one thing we can do is revise this draft bring it back to you again based on the feedback

167that you received this evening we can go back and listen to the recording and maybe there's some updates to this draft you're looking at that needs to be made uh who was on the the subcommittee for the cell phone policy we didn't have a a subgroup for that you didn't have an ad hoc for that we did have meetings with the secondary principles to discuss it but it wasn't a formal committee okay um we've had those we've had those meetings I over here what were you you asking do you want do you want to make correction and go back do um I would be open to uh as because there's a lot of Fe back tonight I want to make sure that uh you know things are are correct in it I uh I can

168give you my uh my feedback as well but I think a subcommittee and meeting with a couple of the board members to just make sure next time it comes up it has all those things accounted for it' be good uh would anybody on the board like to be a part of that subcommittee before uh this comes back to the board I'm just and obviously Rita wants to be on it but again not that I'm I'm on like a million committees but there's two people that might want to be on it I'm wondering if we wait and talk with our other board members yes unless you'd like to be on it can we table it table it can you can you reach out to the the board members and you can form that uh committee and

169just include a couple board members uh to be a part of that maybe put out uh ask who would like to be a part of I know Miss Armstrong would like to be a part of that maybe reach out to the two others yes and just to clarify that would be to work on a draft to bring back to the board another draft and updated yeah maybe um even uh going through some of the feedback we got tonight and uh coming up uh with that with all of our input that'd be great okay um just a point of clarification uh whatever comes back would come back as a first reading that the board would then vote on and then would come back to the subsequent meeting as second reading board vote and then it become

170POS so this isn't a first reading no this is just a discussion okay so maybe we can make the we can make committees at at the at the next meeting is fine next time this comes up I thought this was a first reading um so that's fine but I think given some of the feedback tonight would be helpful uh Mr arong you want to say something no I'm good with that okay um that anything else from the board no all right um moving moving on to item 11.2 board policy 42103 relationship to the Personnel commission I'll turn it back over to board president critchfield to open up the discussion I just read your line didn't I all right do we have any questions or comments on this no questions I I have a few comments

171um if you turn to the second page I first I want to say I talked with Mrs Alo about this and I want to say that I appreciate our Personnel commission I appreciate everything they do I think they're amazing but looking at item number two at the very bottom um where we're talking about their compensation 250 per month I guess my question is how long are their meetings um and how often are their meetings because although I do appreciate that $250 a month is actually more than us as board members make and I just feel like again I don't want to be Petty or anything but we do a lot of work we have six-hour meetings and for them to make more than us um I feel like maybe it should at least be equal

172but I don't believe that they should make more than us when they only have one or two meetings a month and they're an hourlong meeting and I know that might not sound good but that's the way I feel so I'm going to be honest because that's who I am so I I think uh so I think that's a maximum of $250 but it's $50 per meeting so they'd have to have five meetings to I mean I guess they could schedule five meetings but that's just a Max correct that is correct they typically have one meeting per month uh every once a while they may have two Dr Smith may have more information about that for you yes thank you for the question uh their regular meetings are once a month and then on occasion they

173may need to call a special meeting so for example the last couple months I believe they've had two as they've gone through their uh process to identify an executive director but uh president Richfield your reading is correct it's $50 per meeting not to exceed so for example if they had 10 meetings in a month for some reason the most that they would be paid is 250 I'd also like to point out that those figures represent maximum figures that are specified in Education Code um it's actually up to the board to decide what amount if any um it would choose to compensate Personnel commission members for their service at the moment uh existing board policy as you can see uh defines that as $15 per month an existing board policy technically doesn't extend uh access to

174the same benefits Health and Welfare benefits program or health benefits uh that other classified employee or that classified employees get thank you Mr Smith uh and just for thank you for for finding these things I think one of the things on this board we've done uh you we put a lot of work into uh finding past practices that maybe weren't reflected in policy and correcting those things and I think this is one of those things where our past practice with in dealing with the Personnel commission hasn't been updated in uh their policies nor reflected in ours so this is kind of part of the cleanup uh so I appreciate bringing the yeah uh vice president Stuart I think I would be okay with the $50 a meeting but if you're saying they only have one

175meeting a month then I would like to cap it maybe at like $200 and kind of just force the issue of they're not going to have 10 meetings a month I mean we definitely don't want to incentivize more meetings I mean they're fun and everyone loves them but we don't want to like say Hey you could do five I mean so could we uh cap at 150 because Ed code is uh up to 250 right that's correct what you see reflected is the Ed code maximum so again it's the board's prerogative if it chooses to compensate at all so long as it doesn't go beyond what's defined at Ed code right is there an ed code maximum for board members or is it just the lay code that they give us on what we're allowed

176to make there's an So currently there's some discussion at the state level to adjust the stiens or compensation to school board members because that has not been looked at right and I know for City Council Members it was just revised uh by the state uh assembly and Senate so yeah that would be something to consider maybe uh discussing with state representatives and seeing if they would be willing to take up a bill to modify the compensation for school board members which at this time it is far below other elected officials uh it's just a coincidence it's just uh no I didn't do it like get my back up over here all right that'll uh conclude tonight's I know I'm kidding what is it pardon the technical difficulties folks your regular program will resume shortly hey

177by the way tonight's the first meeting that we're uh doing translation in Spanish live translation like tonight's the first one so give it up to our Tech team killing it we'll uh we we don't want to rush you um we're going to take a five minute break and we're going to get these mics fixed and uh the show will continue thank you all right we'll now rejourn in Open session at 8:38 p.m. um so we were on discussion of the Personnel policy um were there any other comments from the board I just had I just had a question so even if they do work one or two hours per month number four says guys so it's added that they're going to be entitled the same health insurance plan so do our people and the uh

178Personnel commission do they have other regular jobs do they have regular jobs to where they or do they need because they're only working one or two hours a month uh I I don't know specifically which members of the commission um have have that or not I I don't the intention of the polic is to make it available to them should they need it that's something that is common for boards to extend to Personnel commissions but I can't speak to the specific Commissioners in this particular case I do think it's important to note that our commissioners have been eligible and they have to verify if they've been receiving them but they've been eligible to receive benefits for some time now it just hasn't been memorialized in board policy as it should okay that's all I wanted

179to know because it looks like it's being added but if it's already if it's always been there then it's great um it's great and again it's up to the discretion of the board ultimately that's why we wanted to make sure one way or the other it's solidified in policy whether the board chooses to continue to extend that as a benefit or not right so I I believe the the how it has been they have been getting benefits for as long as it was just never in our policy and that's what we're trying to do is okay if that's what we're doing then we're going to put it in our policy so it's like you said memorialized that's absolutely correct and if the board wants to continue to provide that that again it's up to the

180board right thank you any other comments from the board all right so this is a discussion item so I think I heard One Direction uh for staff was to uh I I would say cap like take that 250 and and cap it at say like what 150 or 200 what does the board think are they ever going to do more than three meetings a month I would say 200 200's fine yeah 200's fine yeah five just seems a little excessive yeah yeah 200 five meetings sorry um was there any other direction from the the board regarding this policy before it comes back for a reading all right okay uh we will now move on to uh major action uh let's begin with item 12.1 review and acceptance of the 2324 audit report we have a

181report presentation you do you have Mr Jeff Nigro partner of Nigro and Nigro who's going to be sharing with the board our audit report report good evening thank you um I think you've all heard my audit report presentations in the past so I won't bore you with all of the background and stuff that I usually do I think this is your uh probably your uh third time hearing me talk about this I think it's our third year doing the district's audit um but just to briefly go over it um it's for the 23 24 fiscal year I think normally come out in January so we're a little ahead of schedu this year um that's a good sign always a good sign I was just telling them that we're still in the process of wrapping up

182several School District audits because the deadline's on Monday and uh one audit finding that's a pretty rare thing in our office I I was just telling them I have another client that's got 14 audit findings that were still trying to wrap up so uh it's kind of a comparative note there anyway um the audit report has a unmodified clean opinion on the financial statements so that means that the financial statements here uh referring back to the financials that you adopted back in September the unaudited actuals um we've audited them and we give a clean opinion which means the financial statements are prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles now the report in front of you has a lot of information um it really hasn't changed format year-over-year so there's not much new in terms

183of the format but just briefly to remind you after our opinion there is a section called Management's discussion and Analysis and for those of you who aren't numbers people if you don't want to read the whole audit report you just want to kind of get a overview of it that's the section you can look through and it gives you a lot of comparative data how the district did year-over-year in in various areas and what the different financial statements mean now if you're a real numbers nerd and you really want to get into the numbers uh they start on page 11 the actual financial statements and then those are followed by notes which really get into the Gory details defining different aspects of governmental accounting and uh like I said if you really want to know

184about pension plans and discount rates things like that it's all in there but uh most people you know are going to just Breeze right past that stuff but it's all in there um and all of its number nerd Glory there's a a section after that there's a few sections after that there's the required supplementary information section in the audit which is stuff that the gby governmental Accounting Standards Board requires to be uh presented which has a lot more information about purs and stirs and your retiree benefits plans then there's some other information that the state controller's office requires uh that's your other supp information so stuff about the district's Ada and your instructional time uh requirements your federal programs things like that then you get to the next to last section the other independent Auditors

185reports and this is where we put in our letters that say we followed all the standards that we were supposed to follow when we did your audit um not only do we look at your financial statements we look at your internal controls we look at compliance with Federal programs and we look at compliance with State programs and the state programs that we have to audit are all listed out on pages 79 and 80 you'll see it's quite the menu it gets longer and more tedious every year as they add more and more programs with more and more uh gotcha type requirements in them um that's why I was saying in the beginning that it's quite the achievement to only have one on it finding because uh majority majority of our district clients is here has

186had findings at least in TK or the ELO program elop program offerings so it's pretty good that the district managed to not get any findings in those areas that takes us to the last section of the report which is the findings which is real quick could you define finding for me sure findings are the results can be the result of a few things usually it's either uh internal control deficiency or it's a non-com liance with a state or federal program requirement okay so the findings are in the back and that's usually like I say where most people are going to go first because they want to see what did we catch you on um page 83 and 84 you'll see that we had no findings in relation to the financial statements uh or internal controls

187there were no findings in the federal programs we tested and there was one finding in all the state compliance areas and then there were no finding in the previous audit report and then finally in the back there's a letter where we discuss some of the issues noted during our testing of ASB funds at the school sites but those were not deemed significant enough to be findings per se because they weren't what we would call significant problems but the state requires us to put any Communications to management uh in the audit report as well so that's back there could could you EXP explain the one finding can I explain it yes there is a requirement that's been in place for a few years now um and it has it's called form CA it's actually part of

188the UN audited actuals it stands for the classroom I forget exactly what the acronym stands for but essentially it's calculating the percentage of total expenditures in the district that go towards classroom teacher salaries and and there was an error in the calculation that caused the district to miss the requirement and so we're required because we have to audit that we're required to put it in the audit report and I believe that there's a waiver for that from Leo available so our recommendation was for the district to seek a waiver for that requirement for the year so what happens when you have a finding like that in an audit report well in this case if they apply for the waiver and they get the waiver nothing happens the district will work to correct that in the

189current year because it's an annual Auto requirement so we'll audit it every year if it becomes a continual finding then they they won't Grant a waiver continually they'll do it one time and then the district would eventually have to correct that so and what is the requirement what is the goal of that requirement like why do they have that why well that's an interesting question um I believe that came out years ago as a result of uh communication with CTA and the state legislature and it was an effort by them to require that districts spend a certain percentage of their annual general fund Budget on classroom teacher salaries okay so they made a requirement that the district report that in their financial statements every year and what there was no finding with our our classified

190employees there's no similar requirement uh for class if employees really yeah vice president Stuart I have two questions um my first question is on what page can I find that finding that we did not meet so that I could read up on that 85 and then my yeah it's on 85 it's also in the district's un audited actuals that you adop in September it's listed in in form CA okay and then my second question was on page 87 um it says five out of 10 deposits sampled for our ASB um lacked sufficient supporting documentation what documentation would we have needed that's not a simple answer but it depends on the type of item T um for asbs they they do all sorts of different fundraising activities and events so we're typically looking for some sort

191of documentation that shows uh where the money came from if it was a fundraiser uh is there a record of sales if it was for a an athletic event was there some tracking of tickets done um and so there's uh you know we're looking for for example tally sheets individual prenumbered receipts basically some sort of point of sale documentation that shows where the money came from and that it's all accounted for and did you only do Bulow high school or did you do mayfer as well and was that only a problem at one of the schools no we noted that issue at both Mayfair and belflower so as far as staff can we find out like what's happening or how we can improve in that [Music] area yes okay thank you so much can I

192can I ask with the finding on page 85 so did we apply for the waiver so we have not applied for the waiver we need the finding in the audit report to apply for the waiver we've gathered all the documentation many school districts I think um Mr Nigro can attest to have um trouble with this calculation it's an old calculation and um we have all the documents we need to apply for the waiver but needed the audit report to finalize okay thank you and when um when we completed the unod actuals we had made some amendments to that we passed however the Auditors saw that we needed to make different amendments or do it in a different manner so as we look to close the fiscal year for next year we'll look at those same

193kind of amendments and ensure that we um pass along the appropriate lines thank you you're welcome so I know I gotta jump to questions pretty quick was there anything else uh for the presentation oh no no no that's that's it that's the end of the report all right any other questions from the board no okay thank you very much for being here appreciate it my pleasure have a good night you too all right so this will require a motion to accept the uh to accept the audit report do I have a motion to accept so moved do I have a second a second all right roll call please student member o Jose I miss Armstrong I Miss Stewart I Mr critchfield I all right the motion passes uh next major action item is 12.2 first

194interim financial statements we have a presentation Miss ASO yes I'm going to turn it over to our chief business officer Miss Rene Arcus we are looking to get the presentation up on the screen give us one moment we are almost back in working order thank you for your patience all right good evening president chrisfield vice president Stewart board members fellow cabinet members and members of staff and Community here and at home tonight I have the pleasure of presenting to you tonight our first report which is our first glimpse into our district financials for the Year let me first begin by walking us through the budget reporting cycle in June of 2024 we provided a 24 25 budget presentation as a starting point for our budget cycle this is our first and best understanding of what

195we are expecting for the fiscal year the 45-day revise provides the district with an opportunity to adjust any major changes made by to the state budget parameters after our June adoption this year we did not have anything that met this requirement in September we brought to the board the final financials called the UN audited actuals for fiscal year 2324 just before this presentation our audit Forum provided the details of the finalization of those records tonight we can say we have officially closed the books on fiscal year 2324 at least fiscally tonight I'm presenting the first in room report as represented by the green arrow on the cycle we will have two more opportunities to refine our finances with additional information throughout the year this is our first and best projection for 2425 very soon we

196will start the planning process for next year's budget 2526 you can see from the slide that we will start to Garner information from the governor's January budget and utilize it to start the development of our next fiscal Year's budget while continuing to monitor our current year projections to provide the most up-to-date numbers what this tells us is that fiscal year monitoring and development is a yearround activity that keeps our fiscal staff on our toes all year long so here we are at our first stop the first interim this is the actuals reported through October 31st of 2024 and the estimated expenditures reported through the fiscal year end June 30th 2025 the first interim also provides an additional two years look at the district financials for fiscal years 2526 and 2627 I'm bringing this to the

197board tonight for approval the financials show that our district can meet its Financial Obligations for the current and the next two years in order to project revenue and expenditures for so many years our fiscal staff utilized data points to calculate in certain areas on this slide there are three different data points for Revenue cost of living or Cola which is provided by the state funded average daily attendance or Ada and enrollment the district's largest source of Revenue our local control funding formula or lcff revenue is based on these items and more the unfortunate loss of cola and students attending school have impacted belflower greatly as I will show you in the next few slides while we are combating the costs in areas of expenditures we are also in um experiencing decreased revenues on this slide

198I point out that cost associated with our retirement benefits for employees as a decreased as an increased cost but keep in mind we have increased costs associated with Health and Welfare for our employees increased cost for supplies contracts increased costs with associated with utilities all things that many of us are feeling in our own homes right now so let's take a look the general fund is our largest operating fund and houses the majority of the revenue and expenditures for belflower unified it is split into two areas unrestricted and restricted funds I will concentrate on our unrestricted general fund Revenue as is as it is the largest funding that is the least restrictive here you see an improvement in our projected revenues from 100 49 million to 151.jpg [Music] this can be here seen here on

199this slide at budget adoption we had expenditures approved in the amount of 142. 6 million and we are now projecting expenditures at $ 134.4 million a decrease of about 8.2 million this is a reflection reflection of collaboration between the fiscal departments and our program departments we were able to review planned expenditures to determine the accuracy of the expenditure review restricted resources that are state federal and local provided to determine if there were better options for utilizing these dollars the resulting savings to the unrestricted General funds allows us to some time to review our expenditures now and for the future so we can make informed decisions regarding the budget process as for the requirements that I spoke of regarding Ed code we will be submitting a multi-year projection for the current in the next two years

200here's a glimpse of the unrestricted general fund one of the mark Market differences in the revenue decline between this year and last year so I've included last year's ending and the ne and the three years that are included in the um first inum is an estimated loss of $8.3 million due to a decreased Cola and our loss of enrolled students and decreased attendance so you can see that on the slide under the uned actuals which is the first column last year we were anticipating receiving we did receive 159.000 million this year with the change in Cola and the decreased attendance of students we and and enrollment we are expecting about 1514 million in unrestricted Revenue over the next two years show a slight increase due to some more favorable cost of living increases from the

201state however there's also already been some Rumblings in the legislature that the colas that have been provided to the districts may be lower as state revenue and expenditure projections become more clear so back to the cola slide and the am percentages were used we're waiting for the Governor's budget to hear some more about those things our multi-year expenditures are also expected to increase year-over-year with some inclusion of District projects including upgrades to our fire and alarm systems and some Mayfair field Field improvements here's a broader picture of our entire general fund including our restricted resources this includes dollars devoted in areas such as special education title programs our after school programs CTE programs and many others one of the largest changes that you can see here is the ending of our federal Sr resources so

202if you look on the federal revenues line you can see last year we had 21.6 million this year we're expecting about 10.5 that's all federal resources but the largest decrease between the two years has to do with the finalization of our Co Federal dollar as we move towards the future with those extra Federal and State dollars your restricted revenues start to look more like a pre-pandemic level and will be limited to the programs as assigned by fa federal state and local restrictions here's a picture of our components of ending fund balance as per our board approved budget the First Column represents where we were in a board approved budget in June of 2024 and now at the time of our first in room while we have landed quite close to the same place we have

203made some adjustments to committed balance to prever preserve funding in anticipation of deferred facilities needs and our future spending deficits preparing for our future is our top priority all of this information brings me to a multi-year Outlook of our general fund balances starting with with the fir final reported balances in 2223 23 24 and then our projected balances for 2425 through 2627 this multi-year Outlook shows an overall general fund Improvement of about $25 million from our adopted budget in June at the same time it continues to show that decreased State revenues and increased expenditures for ongoing costs such as Retirement Health and Welfare costs supplies utilities and contracts show a steady March downward of District resources that will continue to weigh on District finances what we have available to us is some time to navigate

204these Waters continue to review finances and look for AA of improvements which brings me to our next steps in January 2025 the governor will release his 2526 proposed budget and we'll also have a mid-year review local control accountability plan review in March of 25 we will come back to the board for our second second interim reporting this is our second option to provide some more detailed results right now as first in room closes we were looking at actuals through October but the second inter room gives us a much better option to look at actuals through January and project those resources in May of 20125 the governors will re release their May budget revise and in June we will have the same public hearing for local control and accountability plan and budget and the board will

205have approval of those two items as well and then I'll bring us back to September for the board approval of the unated actuals and our unau actuals will be turned into our Los Angeles County Department of Education thank you thank you for that presentation I'll open up for questions from the board vice president Stewart um my first question is can we get these in all of our presentations the pages numbered yes okay so I'm going to just tell you the page I'm talking about is the unrestricted expenditure summary and I just had a question on the other outgo transfers of indirect costs what are examples of indirect costs what is that so indirect cost is the um is in Ed code and it's allowed that we charge to our restricted programs so to run a

206title one program they may give us and I'm going to use just made up numbers for this for this part they may give us a million dollars to run a program in our district we at at every unid actuals we figure out what our cost for administrative of that program cost and it's it's it comes out in a percentage rate so right now we're in the six or 7% rate so our our program that's on the restricted side can be charged 7% to cover the unrestricted costs such as the payroll department cutting the checks or the AP department writing checks to vendors to manage the program managing the benefits for all of the people in the program so transfers are indirect cost get charged to the restricted side and we get a credit because all

207of the charges that we do to make those programs happen happen to be on the unrestricted side okay thank you you're welcome thank you vice president Stuart member Armstrong yeah I have a a question on that same page um at the end the for the total expenditures I'm sorry um I'm wondering are what are you has anything's been cut to make the because we we approved so much but then the projected totals come out less so that was where I talked about in concert with talking with staff and program staff about things that we could use either we utilized restricted resources or we found that that was not um something that we were going to to do this year or that we were able to do without so that's the change and that's the actual

208opportunity for all of the interims is as a budget we're going to prepare our most options or the most dollars that we have available but the projections are what we're actually planning on spending so there's been some modifications made to um how we're going to spend money if we're going to utilize other resources to do that okay and then I have another one if you just go back one page I think it's back one page and you have the um projected totals to the actual date are we like um I'm I'm referring to the yellow the 151 are we do you project that we're going to be overspending those are Revenue sources so that's Revenue that's money that we're going to take in so we so we're going to be getting more we're we anticipate

209at this time that we're going to get more Revenue okay thank you thank you board member Armstrong um so I I have a a question for your um so on that on the audit report we just got they mentioned that finding um where would I find that number on here I see certificated salaries on here uh but would it be under the on so in that audit finding it it said uh that we're uh at 95 million so where does that show up here are we projected to do the have the same finding next year or how does that affect projections okay so that particular um the cea takes in account all expenditures that are labeled as such in the financials so it can be found all throughout money that we're spending on um teacher

210salaries compared to the entire um District and so there's not a number in this presentation and remember that was on last year's numbers too so there's not a number in this presentation do we anticipate having the same problem no I I think we're going to be okay what we had last year was a lot of expenditures for non-instructional items that built up a balance so if you're a math if you're into math our denominator got bigger once we don't have those dollars in our systems we anticipate not having a problem with the ca um we made adjustments that we thought were appropriate at the time um the oddler one list said those weren't the proper adjustments so we're going to look at that and before we close the books ensure that we're in alignment with

211what the cea requests so that's interesting so say if there's a construction project or there's something like that does that affect the ratio so where it actually like messes with that percentage so it's that's a really good example the the calculation takes out known things that are really clear like construction right it takes it out of the equation and it also has to be in the general fund which under most um districts you won't find a ton of construction in the general fund other things that didn't take into account is the influx of the Esser funds in which we use them for technology and other items that kind of raised that Bottom bar and had to have us looking for areas that we could adjust that um when I say we're not alone I know

212a lot of districts have been experiencing it so and have been requesting waivers this will be our first waiver we have the most confident that we've collected the data to show that we we believe that we'll get that that waiver from Leo and we definitely will report back if there's any concerns about that um but looking at this year's numbers we're going to keep close tabs on that and before we close the books ensure that we can meet that okay thank you thank you good question vice president Stewart um I my next question is from the actual report itself okay and it's page one okay um I'm GNA let you get there tell me when you get there I appreciate it I appreciate that okay I'm there okay so um I was actually talking with

213board member Garza last night about these and we were looking at the expenditures so looking at number four books and supplies I know we budgeted about $7 million and we've only spent 746,000 so it's looking like we are going to over budget about $3.3 million in books and supplies correct the way that reads is we've changed our projection down by 3.2 million so the way it reads across the board is we budgeted 7 million we're planning on spending 3.8 and the column e is the difference and the the reduction that we've made to our financials to reflect that we don't believe that we will be spending the 7 million at that particular column doesn't have to do with the actuals the actual is more of a guideline to see how we're doing so far so

214the difference is just on what we projected at first the difference is what we're projecting now at first in room from our budget adoption and that difference is about $3.3 million that's correct okay so then the next line we were looking at six Capital outlay it looks like we are negative 70% so we under budgeted and that one is we are going to spend $3 million more correct uh yes at the time of budget the entire budget for the fire and alarm F systems project was not included okay and so this is an opportunity this is one of those great examples of an opportunity to relook at our budget again I wasn't here during budget development right um to look at our budget and say hey we are going to utilize those funds we have

215a contract that was board approved to do that project and now we should adjust our first interim to reflect those dollars in the same way hey we might not be doing the same things in supplies and so we should adjust ours in the same manner but the majority of that is for the fire and alarm systems that we're doing correct yes the majority of that number that's a a capital expenditure line and so yes the majority of that is for the fire and alarm project for the four schools that we've started and then the last question I had was on line8 that is what you described in this when you talk about the indirect cost that's just that on this page correct that is correct okay I know Bard member Garza had that and then

216board member Gars and I would like to meet with you and go over this so we can understand better and I'll get with you on I would love to support you in that the more support I have in understanding these very complex documents the better it will be for all of us so thank you for offering thank you vice president Stewart um how confident are you Renee in these projections the multi-year so here's what I can tell you is our projections as with the first is based on assumptions and impacts that we monitor what I can tell you is that this is the best information that I have at this time it's also only at the time we started developing this three months into the school or three months into the year or four months

217in the year October 31st and two months into the school year so you can imagine when we're looking at documents such as this and we're looking at two months out of the 10 months of school expenditures extrapolating that data and looking at things can get quite intense so this is the best information that I have at this time my goal is to come back to you at each board meeting with the best information that I have and if that means changing the numbers and explaining to you the changes that's what I'm here to do so second inter room will come with the March deadline it's actuals through January we're now seven months into the calendar year and about what would that be five months into the school year that's a much better picture for what

218we're looking at how we're spending what kind of employees um we have on our records and and how much we've been doing of extra service or how much we've been spending in regards to POS all of those things will factor into what I will bring you at each of those determinations so this is the best information that I have at this time to to give to you and any changes that I make I'll bring at that time but there won't be like 40 million off or anything right I do not plan to have anything of that nature and I I appreciate that you're here and I have all the confidence in the world uh in you and I I appreciate the perspective and the the experience that you bring to the table um I think

219just as a board member here in BD I've seen numbers that uh we tend to like we get like these projections and then like they're very Doom and Gloom and we can't do this we can't do that because of this money but then you know at the end of the year it's like oh yeah we're too up or and it's and and I went through all I I save all my board books I've I went through like two the past two years of it and it's it's very consist consistent um I think having uh the staff that we have right now I'm I'm very uh I I'm very optimistic about where we're going and I know that these are all assumptions I just feel like there there seems to be like some you reason for

220that and like sometimes the the money we're getting in we actually get a lot more in um but I would almost feel like that would be built into the assumption but I'm sure if you're an accountant and you never want to assume that you're going to get something than not right so I get get being conservative with the accounting um but that's just something that I've noticed through my time here on the board and uh yeah I I as as long as we can clo close that gap on our assumptions I think it'll be good we will be closing the Gap by more than that thank you I appreciate it um uh board member Armstrong yes I just want to um so as you bring as you continue to work with the budget and you

221will you just give us updates on how you're trying to really stay ize it and move things around absolutely I can continue to do that I will do that in public sessions in the March and the and the June time frames for sure if there's been any major changes between that we can we can communicate that as well okay well I do want to know do you for foresee any Doom and Gloom well if I if if I were to refer to let me oh you asked right I don't call it Doom and Gloom I call it an opportunity for improvement right and this is what we're showing we lost about $8 million in Revenue this year so our ending fund balances are going down we're also planning on some projects and some other items

222that will be utilizing general fund unrestricted so I'm not here to Doom and Gloom I'm here to work with you the board with my fellow cabinet members um and to to come up with how we're going to address any of these declines and so am I I'm not trying to project glue and dune I'm trying to project what I really do think that we're going to experience and I'll adjust it when I know more information that I can provide better numbers okay and the last thing I'm going to ask about is because I you know I'm thinking about staff are we are we thinking about how this may or may not affect staff in the future absolutely as um most districts uh 85% of their district is is made up of Staff the dollars and

223cents go around classified certificated and benefits for those staff so every decision that we're making is going to be made around staff and our students for the betterment of our district okay all right so so far we don't have to cut any programs this reflection is what what we have at the time okay with no board approved cuts to programs all right thank you thank you board memb Armstrong and I'm fine with a little Doom in I I I appreciate the conservative accounting is what I'll say that's why I brought this back up and so I really appreciate you saying that it's not that I don't think I I get it it's it's better to to you know make sure we're safe and solvent and responsible and I 100% I just you've seen the projections

224of the past understand they are just it's how do you operate you it's just very hard to make decisions when you think that that's I think the projections two years ago put us like I think right now we're supposed to be at 35 million just they're really off so do gloom's cool I guess but I appreciate the conservative accounting and I know you're on top of it and I have a lot of faith in you I appreciate that thank you um any other questions from the board no thank you very much Renee we appreciate you thank you very much all right uh do I have a motion to approve item 12 point two so moved second do I have a second yeah I second all right roll call please student member o Jose I miss

225Armstrong I Miss Stewart I Mr critchfield I we now move on to the consent agenda any items to withhold from the consent agenda board colleagues I have two all right um 13.17 and 13.2 one all right any others board member Armstrong no I don't have any all right uh do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda and withhold items 13.17 and 1321 so moved do I have a second second roll call please student member o Jose I miss Armstrong i m Stewart I Mr critchfield I give me one second here Oh no I got it all right we will go on to the first withheld item 13.7 Amendment to the annual contract listings and agreements 2425 fiscal year uh any comments or questions from the board I had one question um I think

226it's going to be for Bonnie but the guap Consulting it says that it provides steam activities um um after school and I I see that it's quite a bit my question is what is this and how is it comparing to our after school think together and the one-on-one programs that we've been talking about why is this different and can you just give me a little background on this please okay there's my voice all right so gu is um stem netics and that's a layered on service that we're providing at in our district it is part of our expanded learning program so they are providing stem Services um during the think together program so we've got the additional here was for spring so we had done the earlier fall and now we're um increasing for spring

227um but we mentioned the one-on-one tutoring Services that's feev tutoring and so this is different this is um people coming in to do stem lessons with our students so if they're coming in um did I hear correct if they're coming in it's like they're working or collaborating with think together to do some of these things with them absolutely so they'll do that or the school sites can also uh contract for them to come in either um during after the school day or other events that they might do so it could also be something that's more individual so you have thing together you have this and they're separate or they can work together absolutely we could have it either way okay I guess my question is just what are the advantages is because we have so

228many after school programs and I know this is different and I get it but if they're working with think together and we're paying so much for thing together I'm just again this is another million dollars and I get it but what are the advantages of this um I'll I'll answer in a couple of ways um one is that it's important for us to remember that we do have to spend our expanded learning uh program monies okay and that is about $9 million and we did have carryover funding so we are making sure that we spend down that carryover funding so these layered services are part of that um the other part that I'll answer is um Stan NX is offering um more classes that are think together um individuals would not be able to provide

229because they will come in with materials and expertise that think staff would not necessarily have so it is really enriching the experience of our students and the um after school program okay thank you thank you m Stewart thank you Bonnie um do I have a motion to approve 13.17 you have that motion second roll call please student member Jose I miss Armstrong I Miss Stewart I Mr critchfield I we'll now move on to the next withheld item which is 1321 and that is revised by 24 25 fiscal year so that was exactly my next question is I'm looking at the elop opportunities and I'm seeing that we have that carryover of about 2.6 million so our revised budget has that at 11.7 I'm wondering um I know we have carryover how is the elop funding

230being used like if you could give me an idea on where we spend most of our money with elop I know every district is different ours are very into field trips you know after school clubs Sports things like that what are we primarily spending our money on as far as elop is concerned absolutely so our base and our most expensive as you've mentioned is our think together program um we do offer that at all of our school sites as well as our middle schools um we also have uh stem netics we have have young REM Brands as well so what we're looking at is we have some um layered on services and then some enrichment as well so we have uh lyt culinary stem netics nextore and that's for think and non-thinking so what we

231did this year um thinking about that carryover was we wanted to provide the schools an opportunity to develop their own um enrichment programs so we offered some of those um vendors that we're working with to the sites the sites talked with their uh communities decided what it was that they wanted to provide and they've uh We've helped them contract with them so they have fall offerings and spring offerings um there some of the other is uh spent on our summer Academy our summer school uh we do do field trips as well so spring break we tend to do field trips um and we'll do a couple during summer as well and then uh paper and Fe tutoring so are administrators are they working with our teachers and staff where they're able to do some of

232these because I know like in our district we're that I teach in we are we're getting so many opportunities to make some extra money and with Cola being so low and the fact that we probably aren't going to get salary increases this year this has been a really nice way for us to supplement our income and it's one-on-one with our students they're doing different things you know are the administrators working with our teachers to get some of them involved to be able to make a little extra money doing great things for our kids we share the opportunity with all of our school sites and our teachers have the opportunity to submit a sort of a description of what it is that they would want to do a proposal right whether it be intervention or enrichment

233um we do have 15 uh classes so that's who's opted to participate in the enrichment and our intervention and it looks like we've got nine enrichment and six intervention proposals that are happening right now but that's across the entire District it is across the entire District I'm hoping that maybe our teachers union and our president will and get some of their teachers to maybe do a little bit more I just really feel like it's really great opportunities to take field trips you can go to colleges do we have an approved list of places that they can go for field trips there's not necessarily An approved list but um typically if there's a field trip that they would like to go to and they there's a form they fill out with an educational reason they can

234submit that to their uh principal okay um I think it would be a good idea I'll talk to Carrie McDaniels about this later but I do think it would be a great idea to get more people involved so thank you welcome thank you vice president Stuart do I have a motion to approve 13 points 2 one a motion to approve I have a second a second roll call please student member of Jose I miss Armstrong I Miss Stewart I Mr critchfield I motion passes um it's now time for the Board of Education members to communicate uh and Communications and reports let's begin with uh I'm going to switch up the rule here let's start with the student board member o Jose um good evening everybody um I'd like to talk today about um the csba

235um annual student board member program um I attended it last Wednesday and it was basically just a two-day training program which um helped me a lot and you know I learned more in depth about the roles and responsibility of a student um um board member and how to utilize data from California school dashboard and more and I also networked with over 150 other student board members that are in my position and then um day two I did have the opportunity to go to Disneyland with um all the other board members so I um gained new friends and um explored Disneyland and also I went through the imagination campus I believe and I learned more about what it is to be a leader so that experience really was helpful and fun thank you and we'll move

236on to board member Armstrong I didn't go to Disneyland I wanted to though so um hello and to everyone again it's you know 9:30 and I really appreciate you for choosing to spend your this evening um I was unable to attend the November 14th meeting however I did watch it and uh I want to thank my board members for the time that they have dedicated to the detailed input into many of our new adoptions uh it's imperative that we update cautiously because this is the beginning of a new Bellflower Unified School District so um again I'm I missed the last board meeting but I am excited about uh uh the because we just had the election and I am excited about prop two passing uh because our facilities Statewide um you know it it it

237does need help I know I didn't go for the bond but I want to address once again my comments regarding placing a bond on the ballot so before placing the bond on the ballot I me I just think it should be there needs to be planning and and not just rushing I have to admit that I'm you know missing missing some things um kind of blaming myself for the lack of communication um that comes from from all of us board members from all board members and the superintendent but I still I just wanted to bring it up because because even our last Bond Mayfair utilized 75% of the funding they used a lot of it um and um I just want I really do want to see a clear plan for us to move forward

238that's going to address the district as a whole I know we have our master's facility plan as I stated before but please I really would like to see something as a whole that the whole District can benefit from um and additionally just because just because we didn't pass the bun doesn't mean that we can't use past projects to apply for funding and that has always been available and continues to be available to us so again we just need to have a clear Equitable Equitable plan that address is all of our constituents and and how we will address the shortfalls because the bond is not going to address all of our needs but at the same time it needs to be fair and Equitable throughout the the district so again um I just I stand by

239my decision but I look forward to supporting a bond when we're ready so you know let's let's get to work and let's be clear and let's involve everyone so that we can really be planned that we can really plan and be and be ready because there are a lot of things you know I can just see us having new tennis courts you know a new Surface you know I can remember uh we talked about an U an aquatic Aquatic Center before this was years ago so it's a lot of stuff that we can't have we have a band room that's been in this repair but like I said let's be Equitable in our approach with this Bond okay and again we have wonderful teachers and I do believe that they they deserve the best because

240they are working with who we value the most which is our students so let's be fair um I also attended uh I did a lot of stuff uh over the past two months but I've actually been busy also uh in my personal life with my mother so you guys you know keep me in prayer about that um but I did attend the casby conference with uh my fellow board members we had a I don't want to go into it because there a whole bunch of stuff we did I mean I got all my notes written out um but I am going to mention that I did the the the most of all the sessions the one that I really liked was this one titled fixing fixing I don't do math with critical thinking because you

241know um I think a lot of our children are struggling with math and reading and I had been wanting to go to this workshop and I finally had an opportunity to do so and the uh I brought his book because I just had to you know read in detail the his his strategies so that he was using so his name is colen Seal he's the founder and CEO of think law so think law I'm like what does that have to do with math but I don't know you probably I don't know whether you've seen it before but I do have the book I love books too um I also attended the The Well untap Network retreat in which we visited the Los Angeles Aqueduct Filtration plant uh so we went to Burbank and I don't

242know if you ever heard of the C you know you see those water things those pipes coming down out the mountain so I was up there and you know I met one of the uh policy experts and we and we discussed the the plan for using prop four monies and like what opportunities that uh might come up within our local community and you know the role water is going to play with agriculture because you know we're always supposed to be conserving water and and to see if you know we're going to be h to see if we have to be held to a long-term stability plan for water usage in California so um I did the E ethics training with my with one of my board members and uh so I'm good for another two

243years so um and um I was I felt good saving the district a little bit of money because we only paid $125 for that course and it's usually about 600 during the csba so um that's about it I have a that's good all right and csba I didn't do Disneyland but did y'all do Disneyland calfor Adventure my goodness you guys are worse than me oh oh oh before I let you go I have to my favorite thing about csba I just want to say this I told you one favorite thing about casby so I'm tell you about one favorite thing in csba my favorite I it was a keynote speaker and her name was um K Corey lean and uh this lady here she developed robots for kids with disabilities uh she's you know like

244a big thing when it comes around the virtual reality and Technology um she's created wearable sensors uh that for training surgeons and soldiers I mean she is a global leader when it comes around to technology and how uh humans can use it to enhance their performance um uh she's a social Advocate and uh she's involved in a lot of stem programs that Empower women and minorities in science and technology so again if you know me I love books I bought the book titled inventing the future so I'm enjoying the stories that um as I'm journeying through the this book so but anyway that's it you guys keep me in prayer and uh and that's it thanks for your time thank you board member Armstrong vice president Stewart good evening um first I would like to

245direct staff to start looking into a bond on our next election uh we spent many months on the bond just so everybody knows and it's not just that we didn't pass a bond we didn't give our community a chance to even vote we took your voices away and that was not right and I promise as long as I am sitting on this dis for all of you I will make sure that your voices are heard and give you the opportunity to speak for yourselves next before the break I received an email from a teacher in our district her name is Hannah Hoffman and her third grade class they completed a community service project they applied for and they got a grant and they spent the time and money creating cards and buying gifts for children

246staying at the Miller's children hospital and it was such a great idea and the students got involved and I just love the spirit and the positive energy right before Thanksgiving so I just wanted to give a shout out to miss Hoffman and her class for doing amazing things I attended the ethic training as well on Saturday December 1st president kitvi clerk Gars and myself along with masso um Miss Renee Arcus principal Diaz we took part in the 605 All-Star bands parade through belflower and Lakewood and it was just awesome um as you've heard they will be attending the Rose Parade and it's a true collaboration of so many schools and students and it was just a fun day we got to ride in the fir truck with our Cal apps family and I even got

247my daughter Taylor to attend with me I couldn't believe she went with me but she did and so I just am really excited for the students and for the opportunity of a lifetime to be in that parade so I just want to say that was a really cool event December 47th I attended the csba conference in Anaheim we started the conference by hearing from a keynote speaker her name was Dr Lori Santos she's a professor at Yale and she teaches the course the theory of well-being this is actually a free course um there's one version for adults there's one for teens I really think it would be a good idea to share that with our administrators so that if anybody wants to take the course um it's awesome I actually took the class about 5

248years ago after covid and so I was really excited to see that she was our speaker she talked about the studies and the data that they've generated and they've done a lot of different studies at universities just regarding mental health and happiness so I just want to share with you guys she had her top 10 insights to happiness and I'm not going to expand you guys pretty much get them but they were really cool number one was happiness matters for your performance number two is connect with others socially even when you're not feeling it three helping others makes us happier than we expect four make time for gratitude every single day five healthy practices matter more than we expect six be in the present moment and Savor the good things seven be in the present

249moment moment even if it feels crappy eight give yourself the gift of self-compassion nine love your job by focusing on your strengths and she had a whole list of all the different characteristics and strengths that you could choose and it didn't matter where you fell as long as you believed in them and went with them and number 10 was become wealthy in time and not in money and so I just thought that was an amazing Workshop she was a great speaker it's a free yell chorus if you guys are interested again it's the theory of well-being um the best Workshop I've ever attended was one presented by Beverly Hills unified and it was on effective communication and I'm going to sit down and talk with Miss oo I've kind of already started talking to her

250about some of the ideas I got one thing I loved was their communication guidelines for parents and Guardians it's kind of a where do I start chain of command sorry so families know who to go to and where they go to if they need help they discuss the different tools they have for communication they discussed in a crisis how they get their messages out they get a message out within 3 minutes of the start of the crisis and they update every 15 minutes until the crisis is over and I really loved that idea they discussed weekly newsletters from specific sites but each newsletter goes out at the same time every week the same day so again it's common practices across the district where everyone's receiving them at the same time they talked about how to

251craft messages some of their um emails they did did Q&A so if they kind of anticipated the questions that would be asked from parents or staff and that's the way they um they created it so it was easy to read it had bullets instead of one big long paragraph that nobody wants to read so it was really nice the way they effectively um created theirs and it just gave me a lot of ideas to talk with our staff about I attended a workshop on the superintendent evaluation I think the most important thing we can do as a board is to hire an amazing superintendent um I tell Mrs o all the time we're never going to find someone like her but I hope we find someone with her temperament and her just passion for our

252kids and the second is to create goals together and with our superintendent and show how we're progressing towards those goals so that was a really good uh session I attended as well the conference helped um our fairly new staff really get to spend some time together team building and bonding which was so much fun and I really enjoyed working with the staff that we have right now we seem to work really well together and I think we're doing doing really good things so thank you to all of you guys I really appreciate all your hard work and all your collaboration and it was really fun to just get to know you guys more as human beings at the conference instead of just our poker faces and sitting right here so that was awesome um I

253did want to say congratulations to two of our belfar high school alumni that were reelected to the belfar city council victor Sanchez and Dan coops they both went to belfar and congratulations to council member Wendy moris and just lastly I look forward to the district breakfast next week week I hope everyone has an amazing holiday and we hope that you can join us tomorrow at 6: p.m. for the celebration of outgoing president critchfield and the swearing in of clerk Garza and our new board member Centron it should be an amazing night so thank you so much for everything for all of you guys do and thank you to our teachers and our staff we really appreciate you thank you thank you vice president Stewart um I'm done writing my notes for my board report um

254so it's been busy as as always I I was able to go up to uh Sacramento for the swearing in of Jose salach who's our new assembly member I think it's really important to have uh those relationships with those electeds and finding opportunities uh so they can help us uh in Rich uh whether it's you know in facilities or just working with us is really important I also got the chance to talk with Josh lenthal who's the co-author of that cell phone bill uh that came through and get his perspective from somebody who wrote the Bill so that was a really good conversation um went to the belflower re org and swearing in uh congratulations Victor Sanchez and Dan CPS as well as Wendy Morris um actually went with uh our newest uh not sworn

255in yet remember Marina Centron was there too so that was cool uh csba was great uh I also sat in the meeting for the uh Somerset model school meeting um that was great uh the superintendent evaluation was probably my favorite breakout session um and I really did like that uh the theory of well-being one uh and then Lisa your favorite was the AI one right AI one I think that was your favorite um and uh and it's it's that one particular that the csba is always fun because we get to all be together and not only for the breakout sessions uh but also just having lunch and again that that human inside uh and I like vice president Stuart said appreciate all of you both in your professional roles but also as just human being

256so thank you for putting up with me I appreciate that um the all-star band I mean who didn't love that uh shout out to Tom Phillips I mean that's just like the uh the ultimate when he talks about how that came to be that's just manifestation like he just said like hey I'm you I have this idea and it just happens like it's for me it's like so it's so INSP operational and it's also for those kids and I got to have Tor and Brooklyn on the fire truck that was something I think we should bring it back I I think we should do more parades I don't know free pizza and more parades vote Brad grit okay um I was able to meet with uh Michelle quar CSN car MCD I always appreciate you

257guys taking the time uh to meet and talk about the issues uh cell phone policy I really like the uh public forum that was cool got to hear from everybody whoever you know fills the seat as president uh whoever that may be hopefully they they look for those opportunities to have more of that that was uh that was good I should have done more of those um live and learn um uh negotiations uh not going to touch too much on it but I do think that we as a district have worked really hard to get to a place um where uh we're going to work together we're going to collaborate and that's just that's the only thing I expect going forward is that we work together and we collaborate and we remain respectful and uh

258I think when I when I see that the unified in purpose like it's easy to say but if there's one place where the rubber meets the road it's probably in that situation if you could do it there we could do it around the district all year long but bargain I mean I think negotiating is kind of fun but I know it's very difficult it can be tentious but I I all I expect is be respectful and let's work together and let's uh keep going in the right direction um what else I got yeah that's pretty much it happy holidays everybody all right let's wrap this thing up um informational items does the board have any questions regarding the informational item items I just have I just have a a question um I'm glad you went

259to go see Jose's uh you know his his swearing in we I think we all know him in in all of that do you know when kind okay so um I didn't know you were you were going um so did did you offer all of the board members to go and see him he I mean we all love him you know we I walked the precinct with him over here where my mother lives you know told everybody hey you guys got to vote for him and Victor you know so what was it offered to all the board members in this particular event we did not so in some cases in majority of cases we send out an invitation to everyone depending on what they event is this was a um request by a board member

260and in this particular particular case I think in some instances where we know we can't send everyone it makes sense to send the president on behalf of the board if the president's unable to attend then we would need to ask the vice If the vice is unable to attend we'll go through that role there are some events that we can't all go to oh okay just not possible all right all right any other requests or questions for information items no all right uh well if there's no objection this meeting is adjourned until tomorrow uh 6 p.m Lisa it's 6 right Lisa it's 6 tomorrow right okay 6 PM uh Friday December 13 2024 have a good night everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.