001hello everybody before I start this meeting I just need to make everyone aware that this room occupancy is 80 and we left just enough chairs to an an addition to ours to have that number so anybody who does not have a chair we do have an overflow room that has been and there's three chairs up here if somebody wants to come grab them including on the floor we can't have anyone on the floor we have had fire code uh Fire Marshall called on us before so anybody who's standing we are going to ask that you um proceed to the conference room that's by the entrance and we do have staff members ready to help you find it yeah sorry we can't have anyone on the floor either up front sorry and we also need to
002keep the hallway cleared um for safety reasons thank you so much there there are um cameras in there for you to see what's going on and if you do if you submitted a public uh uh public comment card you're more than welcome to head this direction when it comes up to that is there any more public comment card they still yeah okay I will now call this meeting to order at 605 good evening and Welcome to our P Val Unified School District board meeting we have translation in Spanish if you need that support please see or Lopez um this meeting will be live streamed and recorded if somebody would like to speak to an item on the agenda they must complete a speaker card there in the back here um and hand it to EV
003anria who's at the end here um prior to the start of that agenda item I also see a lot of new faces here tonight so I want to take a moment to establish some ground rules there may be differences of opinions sometimes strong differences please give those speaking the same respect that you would like to receive when you are speaking this will allow everyone to be heard and the board to conduct its necessary business okay so now I will move us on to item two uh 3.2 and I will ask trustee D turle to lead us in the pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the rep for it stands one nation under God indivisible withy and justice for all thank you trustee Charli I will now move
004us on to item 3.3 Dr Heather conteras our superintendent of schools will make a few comments good evening and thank you for coming this evening um we have our nutrition services Personnel is there is jeie here jeie can you come up and if we can get Sylvester to play our pit oh no and I would love to have our nutrition services staff come up at this point as well [Applause] don't be shy come on all the way up so in in light of some of the um not so joyous things that we're will be discussing tonight we did want to highlight some really amazing work that's happening in our district and I wanted to personally recognize um this group of people so over break I was on a run um and I ran into Carlos
005where is Carlos I ran into Carlos who is a photographer an amazing photographer and we had a great discussion about his photography and then he proceeded to invite me and and make me aware of what was happening in nutrition services over vacation and invited me to have lunch on last this past Thursday and see what nutrition services was up to and I was completely amazed and impressed and what I learned is this group of people gave up vacation time to spend learning and you can see the the pictures about different ways and skills they could improve upon and innovate with to give the best food to our students and they made some amazing meals I got to sample them so that was really fun um you could see the pictures but what impressed me the
006most is your commitment to our students to investing in yourselves to make yourselves better employees to provide the best for um some of these young people that we even have right here and so we wanted to honor you thank you from the bottom of our hearts for your dedication to the job that you do uh it looks pretty high pressured back there in the kitchens and and it's a amazing that on time off when you're supposed to relax and you went into this High Press environment and and did all these great things so I we really just appreciate all of your effort your hard work Carlos thank you for stopping me that day on the beach to tell me about this and for inviting me to be there I think we had board members attend
007too because they were really excited Olivia Flores went Daniel Dodge went but to the wrong location but that counts that counts and his heart was in the right place so that's what matters most uh just fantastic leadership as well jeie Carlos um Carlos how this happened is he brought this um because he invested in himself during summer taking a class on his own to enhance his skills and then said oh my gosh everyone should do this so it is an honor to work with you have red and we we don't have 40 red apples but we do have one that we thought you could um showcase in a special [Applause] place thank you wow e thank you so much and before we move on to oh sorry Dr contras did you have more to speak
008or okay before we move on to item 3.4 I'm just going to make one more announcement because I see some more people have come in that weren't here when I made the announcement the first time our room capacity is 80 and that's exactly how many chairs we have available plus our chairs so if you do not have a chair we do have an overflow room set up and some more chairs have opened up so if you're standing please find a chair um we have the Overflow room down at the front conference room and we do have staff members ready to help you find your way there okay so now we will move on to um item 3 4 our governing board comments um I will now oh sorry this is the opportunity for each board
009member to make a few comments each trustee will have three minutes and we will start with trustee Medina this thing right hello test test sweet um hola everybody um I hope you are doing well um and thank you all for being here today um I just want to say for those of you who emailed me um thank you so much for that I'm doing my best to respond to y'all um because I love writing so um I will I will keep doing that um also I want to just take some big picture acknowledgements that I know that are impacting a lot of us um right now I really want to acknowledge our friends families and those that are in LA right now um who are really feeling the impact of those fires especially the um
010Altadena area where a lot of Bren a lot of black and brown families live so um if you have anybody that's down there please send them our strength and love and um we hope that they're doing okay um also um I have been hearing reports that there have been ice raids and CBP raids in karna County um which is very alarming so I'm going to keep um kind of updating everybody on that because I know that's a very big interest to us also I had a visit at Paro Middle School in December um and um what I saw there wasn't great if you saw my newsletter um you saw some of the photos which I'll be talking about later also I want to give a huge shout out to the drama class from PB High
011School who did the production of The Nightmare Before Christmas Superstars that's all I got to say get an actor's contract cuz y'all are stars all right I'm going to say that so great job shout out to Mr robetto on that also um I want to commend student trustee uh Daniel SK on his leadership and Civic engagement so um thank you for that and um we're working on something a little special and I'll let him uh save that announcement and um finally just last two things I'm also going to be submitting a policy um to the board hopefully we can get that on the agenda about local businesses and stopping purchases from corporations that harm small businesses and hopefully we can make that policy within the district also I'll be meeting with some admin um next
012week I have um got your emails about the soccer field Recreation and also about um um uh what was the other thing oh basketball as well so I'll be talking to admin early on so with that being said um thank you guys for being here and I hope we have a fruitful discussion thanks are the these are only a minute right I'm sorry are these only a minute three minutes three minutes oh okay and you had 44 seconds to spare so good job wow all right thanks okay I will now move us on to trusty Charley thank you trusty Flores we've changed the public speaking part of the agenda a little bit I know there are so many of you and with only 30 minutes allowed it's still limiting um the opportunity for everybody to
013speak and I apologize for that um I am committed and I hope that each one of my fellow trustees is committed to hearing from our students our faculty our parents community members um either in emails or phone calls or meeting in person I'm committed to doing that because I want to make sure your voices are heard and that I know uh what your concerns are and what you're dealing with um and I'd like to thank all of you for coming and caring enough about public education and about our students to take your time away from your lives to come here thank you trust trle and now trusty carasco all right hi everybody um I just want to thank everybody for being here I know that it takes time out of your day you know to
014be here and um to be civically engaged um I want to say a shout out to uh PV High who invited me on their campus in December I was able to tour um PV High um I had only been to the library and maybe the cafeteria so for me that was that was really nice and to the teachers who opened their doors to me all of the art teachers thank you I was able to go in there and to talk to a lot of art teachers um and I also want to say thank you to Bradley uh Elementary School even though that is not one of my schools I was able to go and tour and and and talk to the um to the school there as well um and then I'll be reaching out
015to my schools I know that I had um originally gone to Freedom um but I'm going to pay another visit um and if again uh communication is really important to me so if you need to email me if you need to send me an you know a a message on Instagram if that's easier for you um I'm doing my best to get to everybody as of earlier like two hours ago I have responded to all of my emails concerning to everybody right so um so just if I can't get to you within 24 hours just know that I'm also running a nonprofit and I'm a mom you know and I'm an artist um and running my own business but communication is really important to me so please reach out if I don't have the answer
016I'm one of those people that I'm going to find the answer for you because that's that's the whole reason why I'm here so thank you thank you trusty Dodge good evening everybody pack to once again and you know we're we're glad to see you here you know I know we've had some disagreements in the past but you know we're looking forward to the continuing to have this dialogue and just also briefly I just like to thank I'm not sure if it's the food division or the presentation that we had right now I I believe Carlos you know former Wildcat himself but I also wanted to recognize those classified workers who make our who make our food you know people don't always see the people that serve us they Ser you know they come in work
017hard they don't get that recognition because we take advantage oh well they're just Food Service workers but these are the people that feed us um and you know I've been here for you know only six years but the the first people that I saw during Co were the the classified workers serving food handing out food so I just want to acknowledge that and say than you classified workers and Food Service workers and and just briefly I'd like to thank the city of Wattsville and our superintendent uh Dr Heather conas um we got a flashing crosswalk by Ratcliff and so I would just like to thank the city and pbd staff um I've always sat here and talked about infrastructure whether it's crossing the streets um buses stop signs it it's important especially here in the
018city of Wattsville because it's difficult to cross the street here in Wattsville especially in downtown and so I just wanted to say thank you and this you know um the mavas the city manager City staff and thank you for helping us getting that flashing cross that R Cliff thank you thank you trusty Dodge uh student trustee Esa thank you president Flores um welcome everybody thank you for taking the time to come out today um I'm going to keep my comments pretty short for just this item but uh just considering uh students just returned from school but from a a majority of my meetings um we concluded that a majority of the schools are planning the future rallies which is super exciting and back to what trusty Medina was saying we're currently working on legislation um
019to lower the voting age in Watsonville for um students at 16 years old I believe um to yeah 16 for uh students to be able to vote in our local election so we're hoping that the board will get on board with that and then yeah and then we'll be able to present that to uh to the Watsonville city council and hopefully get approval on that and we'll be working towards um enacting that so it's super exciting you know encouraging fellow students to you know have a say in local elections and I also want to say that I plan on intending attending the Watsonville youth leadership uh mixer which I was invited to um so super exciting things and uh once again thank you for taking the time to come out thank you thank you trusty
020Esa trusty Dr Navaro so happy New Year and I hope that everybody had a happy holiday I wanted to congratulate Olivia for um being the new president of the school board so congratulations and welcome to all the new board members I look forward to working with you um congratulations to you and your endeavors with trying to lower the voting age I look forward to seeing what what happens um but that's that's exciting I I think having all the students come to these meetings and and advocating for themselves I mean this is your environment this is where you spend the majority of your time so it's great to see all the faces here um I just wanted to Echo what uh trusty Flores said about these meetings um you know I've only been on the board
021for a couple of months but one of the things that I noticed after serving on several boards is that Mee these meetings are a little bit out of control um and I think that as the adults in the room that we need to set a good example for our students about how to have respectful dialogue and differences of opinion without resorting to name calling and to have some sort of decorum and respect for each other so so I hope that going forward that we can start a new year and be able to you know have important discussions I know that we talked about uh opening up the discussion on the C and uh ethnic studies so I I've heard I know the community is very um this is a really huge issue to the community
022but I want to assure everybody in the audience that there's actually a lot of important issues and it's not the singular issue I know there's a lot of people here that want to talk about the mental health and social emotional counselors and so I would just like to ask please respectfully to the entire room that we remember that these are our meetings that we have really important decisions to make and while I 100% am so excited to see so many people here and I believe that student and community community input is so very important that we have to make sure that we are able to get our work done and not be here until 3:00 in the morning so um with that being said said uh I know that we have a lot of hard
023decisions to make tonight and it's never easy um and I know that we all feel pretty strongly that we're trying to do what's best for the district and make sure that you know we don't move into qual qualified status and that we're able to maintain control of our Schoolboard and not get taken over by the state where all of a sudden these decisions are in somebody else's hands and the input is you have less input um and then I also wanted to let people know that I've been trying to respond to everybody's emails I've been meeting with people individually thank you so much for reaching out to me I've met with um one of the Mental Health Counselors last week perhaps the week before and so I'm I'm trying to get to know all the
024issues I've met with people in regards to ethnic studies and so my please please communicate and I will try to get back to you as soon as I can I also will be doing office hours for uh once or twice a month and I'll send out a zoom information about that so thank you okay thank you so much and before I begin my comments I'm going to say again sorry because I know people have arrived since I've made the the comment our room capacity is 80 and that's how many chairs we've put in so if you do not have a chair we need you to proceed to the Overflow room which is down the hall and around the corner near the entrance and we do have staff members available to help you find your way
025there we cannot have anybody standing we do have two chairs available up front if any of you standing would like to move up front and then we also can't have people um lining the hallway because that is a safety hazard as well and the Fire Marshall will shut down our meeting if we can't um abide by the rules okay so um that being said thank you so much you guys um for the past uh few weeks I have enjoyed uh the Christmas break with my family and I hope you all enjoyed your holidays as well um we had our first agenda setting committee with our new um members uh where we all agreed that uh we hate to have to limit public comments we we all agree on that um but we also do agree
026that you know we do still have to conduct um our Board of business and we have to do it in a timely manner um so there was a suggestion made to us that we will uh try and really it's going to be up to the public if we're not going to force it we just thought you know it was made to us so we're going to let you know so the suggestion was made um that would allow we could allow all comments to be heard sorry I'm going to stick to what I wrote Would we would allow um that would allow us to hear all the comments without setting a 30 minute time limit um we could leave public comment we could leave public comment where it is on the agenda but we would still
027have to limit it to 30 minutes and if we see more than you know 15 or so comment cards we would reduce it to one minute just so that we could hear the most amount of people um or an option is we could move it to the end of the meeting and allow um everyone who would like to speak to have time for their comments now in order to do this what we would do is we would um at the beginning of the meeting have a QR code of up and when you arrive you scan it and you vote um we don't want to open the voting up to just anyone it's only for people who are here who want to participate in public comment um and so if you don't like that idea vote
028no keep it where it is and we'll proceed as as we have been um I'm sorry right now I'm speaking sorry M Miss Garrett um so that's just it was suggested to us so we're putting it out there and if we notice after a few meetings that it's it's not looking like anyone wants to do that then we'll take that away but it's just something we're going to try um we'll start that next meeting okay so now um with that we will move on to um item 3.5 our red apple Awards um I will our sorry oh we did that okay just that one okay that was I did enjoy going to food and nutrition that was fun um okay well then I will move on to item 4.1 um can I have a motion
029uh with a small change uh we on the agenda we used to allow for our um we used to allow our pbft csca CWA we used to allow five minutes and uh I did notice it was changed to two so we can um proceed with that if that's what the board would like or if someone would like to make a motion to amend the agenda to give them their five minutes back or possibly three or whatever you'd like then we can change that I think I move to ad the agenda with the one change of making it five minutes for our uh Union Partners okay and just a a point of order really quickly if we want to pull something from the consent agenda do we do that now or when we get to that
030second when we get to consent got it thank you I second the motion okay I have a first and a second all those in favor I any opposing any abstaining okay vote passes six Z one we don't count okay Z okay now I will move us on to item 5.1 can I have a motion to approve the minutes of the December 11th 24 board meeting I make a motion thank you can I have a second okay thank you I will now call for a vote all those in favor I I any opposing and any abstaining okay the uh vote passes 61 sorry 6 01 Okay I uh will now move us on to 5.2 can I have a motion to approve the minutes of the December 18th 24 board meeting so moved thank you can
031I have a second second thank you I will now call for a vote all those in favor I any opposing any abstaining thank you it carries 601 okay so now I will move us on to item 6 point1 are there any items to report out of closed session um I move to approve the C certificated Personnel report as presented by The District administration on January 15 2025 with 12 and 18 additional action items thank you can I a motion you made the motion I will second thank you and uh can I call for a vote all those in favor I I all any opposing any abstaining thank you that carries 601 next motion 2.2 I move to approve the classified Personnel report as presented by District administration on January 15th 2025 with 13 and nine
032additional action items thank you I second and now I will take a vote all those in favor I I any opposing any abstaining thank you okay so now we will move on to public comment um this is the opportunity for members of the public to address issues that are not on our agenda this evening please know that although the uh please know that through the brown act though the brown act prohibits the board from engaging in discussion of non- agendized items we are listening we recently had a brown act training session where I was reminding of the reminded of the purpose of these board meetings these board meetings are meetings of the board held in public to conduct the district's business a board meeting it is not the same as a town town hall meeting
033my role as president is to keep the board meeting on schedule and within our time period it is not in the best interest of the school district for us to be making very important decisions super late into the night at our last board meeting I allowed us to go over the time allotted for public comment and I even allowed a late comment this caused us to go over our time and unfortunately some of our trustees had to leave and miss out on the last hour of the meeting time we will do our best to try and hear every person who wants to be heard if we have to reduce the time to 1 minute to allow for more speakers we will do that I want to remind everyone that you do have our emails and
034our phone numbers to reach out to us with your concerns and although you might not get a reply with the answer to those concerns I assure you we all bring those concerns to the superintendent during our one-on ones lastly I ask that we respect each other's time when a speaker goes over their time not only are they being disrespectful of everyone's time but for every second that you go over your time a second is potentially taken away from somebody else okay so for tonight how many do we have okay that's okay yeah okay so for tonight we're going to have one minute for public each public speaker we have 20 okay you can go ahead and call those up Bobby pels okay Omar Diez Bill bet uh Bill beer Dr lordes barazza maximiliano Baraza uh
035Bobby P Watsonville High I'm here to speak on the C contract and um I'll have my opportunity to do that uh later tonight the first thing I want to address is another piece of unfinished business when I initially spoke about C I pointed out the Injustice of slandering its founder Dr Allison Tango kubalas with unproven accusations of anti-Semitism and I called that I called that board to issue uh an official apology but it never did that's not right and now the two people responsible for that slander are no longer here while I do recognize that as a step toward Justice it is not restorative we have not yet made this right so I'm calling on this board tonight to have the courage to issue an official apology to Dr ttio kubes even though none of
036you made those original comments you all now have the responsibility to restore Justice how can we look at our kids in the eyes and tell them that they need to do the right thing if we won't do the same right this wrong apologize to Dr tago kbal thank you Omar Diez I'm going to try to talk as fast as I can I got a lot of issues to talk about but first of all I'd like to welcome everybody here thank you for being here and uh I want to first talk about the uh soccer fields that we need to address with the youth that don't have a soccer field to to practice on over 60 students uh that go to poo Valley High School don't have a soccer field to practice on so I would
037like for us to look into that please the other thing I would like to talk about I would like to welcome Doug Kaplan here who is here to talk about the C contract and probably going to talk about it again let me remind you guys that Mr Doug Kaplan was here back in the 90s to segregate our students to send our students back to Watsonville when they were school bused to to apas high school the other thing we need uh talk about is the immigration problem what are we going to do if immigration shows up in our town how are we going to protect our students how are we going to make make sure that they're safe and they don't have to live in fear uh and the other thing the budget cuts why are
038we paying I I will touch base on that again sorry just quick point of order um this this item is for non agendized items so ethnic studies is on the agenda um the sustainable budgeting is on the agenda and also we do have an item regarding um immigration on the agenda so please this time is for non- agendized items good evening to the new board superintendent and staff we are faced with the worst Financial condition in 35 years we are deficit spending we took onetime stimulus money from the state and hired people attendance is dropping 4% a year will be down 40% by the end of this decade the State's Fire insurance plan is underfunded to handle the LA fires by billions and billions of dollars they're going to have to take it from somewhere
039else the state has been deficit spending for the past two years many of our schools are less than 60% utilized other than that everything's peachy together we need to make hard choices and we are capable of it do not be like the 1990 91 board who didn't make the choices the state had to come in and take over this District don't let that happen with declining enrollment and underutilized schools we need to combine classrooms reduce Staffing move charter schools into the underutilized schools decide which schools to close before you allocate measure M funds thank you yep I'm just going to read mine quickly because I can't stay for too long but good evening board I'm glad to see new faces here after a long time and I'm very hopeful for the future however I know
040it's still possible for the C contract to be discarded with the current board so for my first statement of this year I want to remind the board what liberated ethnic studies teaches and why the C contract matters liberated ethnic studies teaches students like myself to critically analyze the power structures present in our society this information allows the public to create meaningful change which can be scary for people in positions of power as this enables Everyday People to hold them accountable I'm asking this board to please be brave and see through the lies that you are being told by certain people in the community research liberated ethnic studies for yourself and make the right decision for our students thank [Applause] you okay so I'd like to start first by saying that the idea you all proposed
041of leaving public comments to the end is a horrendous idea especially for students one of the reasons the student is not going to read his comment later is because he needs to go home go to sleep so he can be ready for school tomorrow one of the issues that we have is attendance we don't want students to not sh to school because they're tired so you putting this at the end is a horrendous idea so I hope that gets deleted right away um the students do need to come and and be able to speak and practice their or exercise their their rights and by putting it at the end we cannot have students going there the other thing we're going to be talking about later on today is mental health that also contributes to their
042mental health so again another reason why not to do that so I hope that gets deleted um but my primary thing is I do want to also let the board know that we should write a letter of apology um there's been a court case that has already been um where a judge clearly stated that you know uh people who have issue with liberated ethnic cities have not actually proven anything about it they they have not said that it's that it's what they claim it is and in fact it um he said just because you're uncomfortable with it doesn't we shouldn't teach it I will talk more about that later [Applause] Exel Baraza May Guerero Rod Kirkman Elias Gonzalez and Chris web thank you if you guys can line up so that we can get through
043as many speakers as we can that'd be great uh hello my name is Isel barasa and I live in area 5 this is a new year and a new school board but I'm but I'm here with the same message bring back CR I'm taking ethnic studies in school and I plan to continue but I want my teachers and the school to leadership to be supported by experts in the field of ethnic studies not by some water down uh 700 page Mass made by people in Sacramento we need ethnic studies for the we need ethnic studies for the bajaro valley by people who understand the bajaro Valley Community bring back [Applause] SI May gerera they might be walking anyone else Rod Kirkman Elias Chris CH okay here U really quickly while they're coming up do you
044think that um we could get other Q cards so students could fill them out and we could prioritize those first I think it's a yeah yeah okay let's get a cool color and then um we'll slot those in first and then we do the adults after that yeah that's a great idea cool thank [Applause] you okay good evening trustees my name is Rody Kirkman I am the former Chief negotiator for the pbft um but I am going to speak to an agendized item because I am currently in the classroom and I need to go home um I am here to speak in regards to the proposals made by this the SBT the the school budget team um and I want to share the first core value that lists on the team's presentation that it is
045to prioritize students however when I look through all of those proposals most of them are directly impacting students if you look just at proposal B 1.5 million reduction in mental health clinicians and 2.4 million in SEC reductions social emotional counselors while this also does not provide the board any actual information on how those will be those students will be impacted there is no FTE listed there is no explanation of how that is going to affect sites 1.75 from the do and 4.5 million to positions directly impacting students does not meet that core value Elias I had to walk like two miles to get here so you're gonna have to give me that minute uh sorry about that no it's all good it's all good thank you so bues good evening board EST the board supervisors
046and staff right uh first of all I want to give a shout out to Gabriel Carol and Jessica for making it here right thank you for taking time thank you for the commitment um and now it's time to get to work right and there's a lot of work so thank you for that and thank you for take stepping away from your family CU we know what that means secondly uh student trusty I have not been in this space for a few months but let me tell you um you keep holding this up you keep holding that palabra um we talked about lastly I'll say this but you said we talked about right now to being respectful to the board doing all this doing all that I'm all for that I'm all for that M Dr
047novaro right you I heard you say that but I think what also very important that we have palab here right having palab and actually we're going to say something doing it and following through and also making sure that what we're saying is alignment with all of us right what we're doing behind doors is also happening in front of us here with the community but with that being said again I welcome you all I look forward to working with you all and I mean let's get to work cuz there's a lot of work to get done with that being said I'll just say bring back C Chris Webb I uh good evening um I know there was some some like controversy between the district and the and pvft regarding the um sustainable budget team and the
048recommendations um because of a few requests that haven't been forthcoming yet I'm I'm inclined to lean towards pvft so the ones that we're I'm talking about are the the legal expenses um related to rpn days and that whole case and then um also just like data on like you know model continuation Renaissance versus like like policies that work to encourage people to go like if we're going to compare best practices to current like how can we learn um also I think like before we cut mental health conditions and the like I think we should cut all the stiens and have like Dr conas and like everybody else like have to do mileage the same way aosa does and also the stien for SRO should be out actually we should just cut the SRO entirely my
049opinion but um we should have sight by- sight combos about what an effective use of the mental health Clin conditions look like sometimes like having good practices you can uh mitigate some of your situations thank you May Guerrero I'm GNA move on to the next one Barb uh sorry if I get this wrong Barbie marer Sal uh Shen Ellen Shen glennen sh Monica Nolan sorry last name on this one is s h EA believe that's M Marilyn Garrett Marilyn Garrett Monica no Nolan I already said and then Amy Fitzgerald and Ian Lata cool congrats all around I'll I have time for on that um I knew tonight was going to be packed I knew this was going on y'all had to also why are we in this room if you have a capacity of 80
050I don't understand honestly uh it's I've been at meetings for a long time where we've been packed out and that has not been said if it is something new for some reason fair enough but it it's hard for it there's still trust to be built back with the board and it's hard for it not to feel like more suppression of voices even if it's not the intention I recognize it may not be the intention but that's the impact and so I do question why we're in this room and not at a bigger space knowing what tonight was going to be like I do want to encourage us to lift the the minute or two minute I understand the need to get work done I understand things go late I've spent years in these meetings where
051we did not have that and it all started in the past year and a half when people came and started showing up upset about some stuff going on I agree some things have been out of control I do not condone all of the actions that have been taken from behind this at the same time I think that we also have to take responsibility as a board for what has been created get to a pace of peace and then when it's peaceful if you want to put that in place for the future maybe but now is not the time to do [Applause] it my name is Eileen Shay yeah it's a nice Irish name anyway um I'm just here to take a minute literally I just wanted to talk about a social emotional counselors and our
052mental health um interns and um and I wanted to let you know I don't know if you know this but our social emotional councilors right now up so far this year has already seen 50 they've already seen 50 students they meet in small groups they give us goals we know what these kids are doing we're we're helping them navigate and um being able to access the curriculum that's their job um our our counselors that come from our outside agencies like um pvpsa they see seven kids in a whole year and I just I don't understand that like I I I just feel like we really need to be thinking what we're doing here because our social emotional counselors our mental health clinicians they see a ton of kids and then to seven kids a year
053and they give us no information they don't want to give us names they don't talk to us about these children how are we supposed to work together when we don't even know what we're doing with the kids thank [Applause] [Music] you hi I work at the middle school level and I wanted to say that I already have many students who experience mental health challenges and without counseling support for some of those students I think it would be a lot harder for me to teach because it does impact the classroom and I have 35 students and several groups of 35 students so the other thing I want to mention is my classroom hasn't had heat or air conditioning the whole year even though there's been a work order put in can we get your name I'm
054sorry thank [Applause] you what school what school do you guys know what school what school abas junr thank you all good evening everybody I'm Ian Lata I'm English teacher at Diamond Tech and also VP of Charter for pvft I also teach ethnic studies and I was lucky enough to do the CRA training and it was excellent and you should bring it back um so that's one thing but I I'm here really I'm very concerned to hear there might be cuts for counselors mental health clinicians we're dealing with a mental heal Health crisis I think you are hopefully aware of that it's getting worse um we we are people are afraid that their families might be separated here um with the new immigration policies so it's not a good it's never a good time but especially
055right now to reduce school counselors mental health clinicians or intervention teachers teachers who provide release and academic coordinators will put additional burdens on classroom teachers and reduce support for students these Cuts will disproportionately harm the most vulnerable students we have creating an equity issue we cannot ignore so please look look thoroughly through the budget find ways to to solve this problem without cutting people who work with the kids every day thank [Applause] you Marilyn Garrett stop mandatory vaccines it's a human right to decide what goes into one's body the approximately 133% of children who are in special education are vac injured children this is from learntherisk.org in 1986 pharmaceutical companies producing vaccines were given full Federal Protection from lawsuits resulting from vaccine injury or death via the childhood vaccine Act passed by Congress if vaccines
056are so safe why do they need a lob to protect from Li ability after this law vaccines became highly profitable there are almost 300 vaccines in development and mandatory vaccine laws for children and adults are being pushed in Most states stop mandatory vaccines hello I'm Monica Allin um I had a whole wonderful speech but we've been reduced which the math just so you know 30 minutes and weird there's only 20 speakers at 1 minute that's 20 minutes so hopefully somebody will get some time to extend on their comments because they deserve it um and so I am going to talk to an agenda item because that's also the first time I've ever heard this that you cannot speak to an agenda item on public comments kind of funny to me um we have a lot
057of Renaissance High staff here tonight they're not all in this room but more specifically we have our mental health clinician here Matt Merill he is an amazing friend and an amazing coworker and I could say that probably to every mental health clinician that I see in the back row over here um and also the social emotional counselors and we have our students here too that are echoing that um and I know it's a really hard decision to cut jobs and it's not you alone and it's not this group of people alone and it's not you alone um it's a horrible place to be I wouldn't want to be any of you to be honest and so um I I hope when you do consider these you consider the the faces and the hearts behind it
058when you think about it and where you can cut that doesn't impact our students like it will May Guerero did CH leave uh Hilda gazari and river or orelis [Applause] oras good evening my name is ham F and I'm a senior at par Valley High School I'm here today to talk about the budget car regarding our mental health department and I apologize for uh speaking in the public comment section but as a senior in high school it's not easy to sitay here in this room for 4 hours when I have school tomorrow let alone that I have to make it to my practice for Watson count B by 7:30 I an intern EMP power Watson and it breaks my heart to see that all our efforts and supporting the growth of the mental health programs
059at the schools will go to waste simply because of your decision I have seen close friends of mine Str uh struggle with mental health and I cannot stress enough how big of an impact our social emotional coun is made on their lives it's only a matter of second for someone to make the wrong decision a decision that would affect their whole future and without proper guidance in the time of dark darkness is impossible for people to survive I really hope you Recons your position in this decision and lastly I wanted to sorry I wanted to just wel welcome our new board members and I'm really happy that you're here on our side thank you so [Applause] much uh my name is River ones I am a senior at bajar Valley high school and I am
060here to talk about c as well as the budget cuts I was a person that was going through schizophrenic episodes and the only person that was there for me was my social emotional counselor at my high school without it I probably wouldn't be here and we need the counselors and I am so glad that we have people like Miss Gasco and Mr Medina because I was out there advocating for you guys to be on the board because I know you guys care about us and you go to our schools and you go and listen to us instead of just ignoring what we have to say additionally C needs to be reinstituted because at in ethnic studies we need teachers who teach with that teach it without bias we are finally having latinx and black stories
061and Asian stories represented and it is so necessary for students that are in a minority Community to see themselves I have seen people who would never show up to school and they would show up for ethnic St thank you M okay thank you so much that will conclude our um public comment time and just want to let uh the public know how many um just put a v it really quick how many cards do we have left how many do you have left these are all other items are those other items yes we that okay thank you all for that agenda she might have put it under did you put under 12.1 or 12.2 okay we we got through all of them I'm sorry um but we're going to move on now um but I
062did want to say that uh we were aware that we'd have a large crowd and we wanted to have it at chamber but it wasn't available we are going to work on having meetings there when when it's available to us um now uh we will move on to item eight uh this is a time that we hear our employee organizations each will have five minutes um we will start with item 8.1 pvft do we have someone from pvft here all right good evening this thing is like sliding on me so I guess I'll try to hold it um Brandon Denise negotiations chair for the pvft I'm here tonight because our president is actually on her way back from Sacramento where she attended a meeting with CFT leadership I want to point out that this environment
063is so unwelcoming like there are are people back there who can't get water because there's no cups it's late but you guys can't spare any coffee like what can we do to liven this place up make it a little more funds because we're going to be here for a while so I'd like to take a moment to thank and just welcome everybody happy New Year that kind of stuff um so I just want to say that we have a lot of work to do and it's our hope as a pvft that the community can come together and begin begin to heal from the divisiveness that has gripped our community and Ed these meetings for far too long I recognize that sometimes people get up here and they say things that aren't so nice but man
064was that last board toxic so we have a lot of healing to do um one immediate step this board can take to help the community move forward is an outright lifting of the time limit on public comments so I was proud and happy to hear that Carol brought that up because a QR code is one of the dumbest ideas I've ever heard so we're going to be excluding people whose smartphone died that day or don't even have a smartphone what's that going to look like we're all in the back huddling over a QR code like if we're only meeting every 3 weeks every voice deserves to be heard bottom line so step up and make that call um we are encouraged this thing is like bouncing on me man we are encouraged to see that
065the board will be determining a date for a special board meeting on ethnic studies but let us be specific and clear with our purpose for this meeting the previous board allowed false and slanderous statements from special interest groups to take precedent over the will of our community our administrators deserve to be trained by CR so they better so they can better support our teachers students and Community before I speak to the elephant in the room which is the action item on the sustainable budget team's recommendation I want to point out that under California government code section 54957.6 the public has the right to access the agenda and accompanying materials for a special board meeting the public still does not have access to the sustainable budget team review view slideshow that was presented during the 12924
066special board meeting it might be somewhere else on the website but when you go to board meetings and you go to that agenda item the presentation should be there and I've actually requested that I recognized that there were reasons and constraints for why that board meeting was held at the pararo dunes but the Optics of this decision are only further worsened when access to the full agenda and the presentations are still not available online on the board meeting agenda where it's can be easily accessed I also request I already said that the pvft will always stand in support of our students and our community the recommendations that will be presented to this board during the sustainable budget team presentation represent a direct attack on our students education and social emotional well-being this entire process seems
067to be nothing more than a charade to set the conditions for layoffs cutting school counselors and mental health clinicians will will remove life saving support for students dealing with social emotional challenges and Mental Health crisis our counselors at elementary schools are already split between two sites so as Rika Kirkman came up and mentioned that that we don't know the FTE we don't know the numbers we don't know the sites but we already have it so that a social emotional counselor has to split their time between two elementary schools so if little Brandon is having a meltdown and I need somebody that day but they're at the other site sorry you bet hold that in until tomorrow that doesn't work with elementary school kids we need more access to mental health support not [Applause] less I
068actually stayed at that board presentation I was like the last person there from the public it was like me and the media and we were holding down the fort um and I was there when the consultant dropped the line straight from school Services of California that goes something like do not invest in things that eat well what what about investing in the humans who have saved lives of students can we invest in them because our mental health Clin conditions are so incredibly important to lay them off could potentially result in a student not having access to the support they need during a time of Crisis the things that they address are hidden they're ghosts we can't see them as teachers we know a student's acting out or we know that something's going on but we
069need that mental health clinici that counselor to be able to build that connection so those students feel comfortable sharing what they're going through so we can get them the support we need cutting those positions would be foolish and Reckless where is the same energy from the returning board members that y'all had with regards to how the SRO save students lives I believe a board member who's not here used the term blood on our hands what's going to happen if something happens to a student and they're in a crisis and they don't have a counselor they don't have a mental health commiss so this board we're looking forward to working with you cuz you got a lot of work to do to do better [Applause] thank you I will now move on to 8.2 CSEA do
070we have anyone from CSEA here tonight okay how about um 8.3 CWA Mike okay testing all right right good evening Board of Trustees and Dr contras me get this right my name is Mike Flor and I am a steward and I'm on the negotiating team for CWA local 9423 that's the union that represents the substitutes in our district and I came to a board meeting in September of 2023 to bring up a pay discrepancy related to one of my positions and it's turned into finding out a lot of history about the CWA local and San Jose we missed a negotiation round in 2021 due to us being put into receivership from the previous administration um from back then and so there are some gaps in the substitutes being represented and there was really no Union
071Local working behind the scenes so I started coming to meetings I brought up uh elpac tester pay rates I got a pay reduction after 3 years getting paid a certain amount I didn't really understand why I definitely do now and um we have negotiations underway at the moment and we went to the close session to kind of talk about that but back in November we had our own elections and so we have a repopulated local in San Jose um 9423 that's what was going on on the 18th when you guys were having your organizational meeting we were were going through the same thing so I came to that meeting and then I jammed up to San Jose to be part of our first member meeting then we had our Christmas party but I wanted to
072introduce David Seda he is the newly elected president of CWA local 9423 it isn't just going to be me coming up here anymore we actually have an active Local Union shop that we're just getting started just like you guys are too so that's a good thing um I got elected onto their executive board so I'm an eboard member at large for that and David is the new president and I'm going to give him a little chance to talk to you all and introduce himself so thank you for your time and thank you for everything hello I'm David SATA I'm out here supporting the substitute teachers um I'm president like Mike said I'm president of uh Lo CWA local 9423 we have just come out of receivership we're kind of getting our feet back under us
073um feel like I've weighed into a lot here you guys have a lot going on here um it's great to see the community involved I mean I'm not familiar with all the issues here but it's great to see young people involved and stepping up and coming out and you know saying what they believe you know it's important whatever side you're on and I I believe the keeping we can all talk to each other in respectful ways and keep those discussions going so though I don't know the ins and outs of what you guys are going through I do understand budgetary concerns we're going through that at our local so I do hope when all this is going on though that you can remember that the substitute teachers have been left behind and some of that
074was due to our fault of our receivership not opening um reopening contract for negotiations so we we did drop the ball on that but I'm hoping now that we're here that you guys can realize that and bring them up to where they were supposed to be and uh get them a more um a more fair pay scale for what they do thank you you okay and now we have item 8.4 pavam do we have anyone here from pavam okay seeing none I will now move us on to item nine consent agenda cons consent items are routine items coming before the board um do we have any public speakers on item nine no we do not okay so are there any items that the board would wish to defer yes I would like to deferred um
075item 9.3 and item 9.4 okay do we have any other items from any other board members okay Gabe would you please make a motion oh sorry Danny oh I was going to Second his motion oh I would like uh to make a motion to um pool 9.3 and 9.4 from the consent agenda second thank you we have a first and a second wait do I need to take a vote for that okay all those in favor I I all those opposing and all is abstaining so we have six it passes 601 sorry 6 uh yes was the motion meant to approve the consent agenda with pulling that Point those two items yes okay so now we will move on to item 10.1 deferred consent agenda items we will start with item 9.3 do we have
076any comments from the board gab yeah um yeah I am curious why we are Contracting with a private Christian University that is associated with the Plymouth Brethren so I'm questioning why we are Contracting with this outside organization um from Iowa at and they're going to be from my understanding placing folks within our schools to support teachers can can you just give me more clarity on that sure good evening president Flores I got to figure out vice president Dr nabarro superintendent I'm Brian Saxton director of HR for certificated and yeah trusty Medina so this is a pretty standard umou we have a number of universities that place that place student teachers with us um Massachusetts Global San Diego State um UCSC San Jose State and we sign anou with all of them we're not paying for
077any Services they have a they have a student who is taking online courses with them who has asked to be a student teacher at McQuitty and so um we are not Contracting with them we don't have any fiscal responsibility towards them this is just an agreement that we will have a teacher who will um be the students Master teacher and fulfill their requirements via the university so my concern is I was looking at their mission statement and it sounds like a missionary mission statement where they're going to be putting people in vulnerable communities and I'm guessing that's us which these private Christian institutions tend to do and also there did are you aware that they're also related to the emis international College uh I'm not because we're again we're not um every university has its
078own mission statement its own um every university has its own mission statement right and its own thing so like again we get a number of contracts orus for student teachers the student has chosen the university she lives in this area she wants to work at one of our schools as a student teacher um teaching our curriculum she's not bringing in her own curriculum she'll be working with Debbie stenco at M or mcti um and so it's a it's again it's a pretty standard contract and I understand that my only thing is this organization is connected to the Plymouth Brethren okay which is an in Evangelical movement that was happening right and they have several allegations against them against them including the amus International College which had and they uh did something they shouldn't have and
079the reason why this certain College Chang his name to amus University which was just recent was called Emma Bible College I don't feel comfortable going into an um a contract with a private institution I get what the purpose is of that totally get that but knowing their ties what they stand for I don't feel absolutely comfortable having us with this student now if that individual person wants to come volunteer their time by all means I think that's great but why aren't we looking into CSU andb who has a great Teachers program to get more teachers in the classroom UC Santa Cruz has another great um program to get students into the classroom and San Jose as well and I bet you if you get more of those people into the classroom right those are going
080to be people that are going to convert into teachers because they're already doing the job in working with the community so I would love for us to dive a little bit deeper when we're trying to look at stuff like this because again I do not feel comfortable with a Christian private university associating with them along with their connections with the Plymouth Brethren and the Amos International College which has gotten allegations sued essentially against them okay so just to we do have student teachers from those various universities again we get student teachers from a a wide variety of universities throughout the country and how many of them are private Christian institutions I'd have to check but I would assume that we have some religious institutions because they offer online programs the student may have attended there
081for their undergraduate so they need in order to get a California credential you have to have a program that is um accredited by the CTC and so there's a wide variety of of places who have those so again this is all about perception for me and I don't like us being even in one inch of this University so um those are going to be my comments okay okay do we have any other comments from any other trustees okay um oh U I agree with my fellow truste gri Medina to take a little bit more insight with these religious universities um but this person you're saying is a local person who wants to teach at a local school correct they've they've reached out I believe they know one of the teachers at McQuitty and so they've
082reached out to that teacher to be a student teacher in their classroom um right so we currently have a number of student teachers we have one at Aptos High there's a couple at Watsonville and so all of them have those two are from UCSC but we have ones from other universities sometimes they know somebody sometimes the like CSU andb they'll reach out to us and say hey we have somebody who we need to place in your area we'll find a place for them a lot of them have happen to whether they've gone to school here they have a relative whatever it may be and so if we do not have anou with their University we do a standard mou to make sure that you know they're accredited um sometimes they do pay our teachers a
083small stien to be the student teacher and then that allows the student teacher to get their credential so that then they can come back and teach in California somewhere whether that's here or whether that's somewhere else in California so without this she will have to find another location to do her student teaching in another District I understand but like my fellow Tristy was saying maybe it's something to look at but I'm going to support this agenda item because I know this teacher wants to be here and I don't want to turn away any teachers that want to come who live in this community so U with that I'd like to make a motion that we pass this agenda I thinkk okay I have a motion do I have a second I second um so now
084we have a first and a second all those in favor I I all those against Carol I stay okay so three two one okay so I'm sorry I'm new to this I need some clarification it does not pass okay so this fails for a lack of uh enough votes okay okay okay thank you thank you okay and now we will move on to um item 9.4 did you did oh I'm sorry did you I'm the student teacher you're the student teacher I'm not I'm not sure should we allow I I would like for them to advocate for themselves yes please thank you hi so my name is Caitlyn Matt um I understand your concern with the um Rel just affiliation there I we have a connection here we've been living here for a few weeks
085now um my husband and I and I just I was here just to fulfill a course requirement I'm not here to um uh I don't know what the word is like PR proc soltize yeah I'm here like P I was trained in a teacher prep program purely education um academic purposes here um yeah I just would love to serve the community and serve the children and work under Mrs Stefan Co that's okay I yeah I'm not here to um be proing and I don't know about that EMAs International thing we changed our name just because we got a master's program recently so they thought it was more appropriate to have the word university instead of Bible college but we are still um claiming I mean the the Christian aspect of it but that's not um
086I don't think that's a like I'm not here to do anything bad yeah and I I understand that if you just look at the history of mission work that's happened in this community from private Christian institutions or priv or Christians in general it wiped up a lot of our religion here so that's why I as a native person have big concerns with Christian private institutions coming into our schools and I hope you understand that I respect that thank you I um I'm sorry I would like to just apologize on on behalf of me that you know we have failed you you know to be able to support our children um would have wholeheartedly supported this and who knows if we have an uh abstaining member who would like to choose our mind later we could
087possibly bring it back later uh is it possible to bring that vote back and make it a roll call vote can I say something real quick I'm sorry um I also want to apologize to you I you know there are several members of our community who leave and choose to go to Christian universities and you know I I assume that under Ed code we don't allow IND cination in the classrooms and I don't think we should be penalizing students who want to come or student teachers who want to come back and help out in our classrooms especially when we need all the support that we can get so so we'll have to um speak with legal counsil later to see if but I'm pretty sure that the only way we could bring it back is
088if an a dis what's a u descending member vote you know changes their mind so I'm very sorry okay so now we will move on to item 9.4 and uh trusty Medina you also pulled this item I did so we are spending 120,000 for laundry service and um I'm just curious how many pounds of laundry is that so good evening uh my name name is Jenny M I am the chief business officer um so just to give you a little bit more context um So currently um the district has been contracting with Mission uh Services I believe for the last 5 to six years U Mission um laundry services um serves multiple departments um and programs within our district including M so they launder um and repair uniforms which are um part of our collective
089bargaining unit for um uh traits such as our plumbers our custodial staff our grounds team um as well as for um our shop and uh some of our bus drivers in transportation food and nutrition as well as Laing um towels for um courses such as um uh home egg culinary um our child care uh centers as well so um my understanding looking back it's upwards of 600 pieces of uh uniforms and garments um not including things like towels they also do things like repairing um tears putting on patches um repairing buttons so looking at just the the impact to our operations if we were to do this inhouse my my belief looking at the cost analysis is it would actually cause the district more because we have to remember we would probably have to bring
090on probably more than a full-time employee because this is at every single site in our facility including our child care so they're picking up on a weekly basis Laing doing tailoring repairing delivering back to those sites um and it's not just in bulk um it's going to individual employees as well so there there's a lot of organization and then we would have to have space for a commercial or industrial set of washers dryers um also the maintenance of it okay and and I understand all that I think what I'm really trying to get at it's $120,000 I said Grandma check this out we're sending laundry to get done in Santa Barbara for $120,000 and she said Mel bring it to me right now and I'll do it for fre I'll do it for $120,000 so
091one thing I wanted to I totally understand she she knows how to make her money so looking at that if she wants to come uh apply but so one thing I want to so just in transportation um it's upwards of 90 employees 90 employees just in one one department so if we're looking at and it's not just a number of um uh employees so if we're multiplying that out by the number of departments that serves and then the number of sites so it's not just our school sites it's our and I get that I get that I think what I'm trying to get at is I'm really trying to keep our funding local as much as possible because we need to stimulate the economy here um and I think $120,000 is like I mean man
092can we create like a student job where they're learning how to do laundry and we could pay them this amount to stimulate them because we do have students who are having to choose between their education and work right now so I would love for us to be a little bit more inventive right so if we could teach them how to wash clothes fold them I'm pretty sure their moms will be happy their abas will be happy will be happy but just to get some sort of Revenue within the community so that's only reason why you know that's a great thought for sure and that is something that um is taken into consideration When developing different types of courses and Pathways I know in a lot of our CTE for example um we have sites that
093have washer dryers on sites and that is part of the um the coursework or the class um time of doing things like the laundry services um so there's we're absolutely looking into ways of integrating that um in terms of um at this time do we have the capacity of doing this in-house my recommendation would be not at this time okay yeah and I just wanted to flag this so we could start being a little bit more inventive of trying to keep more money within the community if we can okay thank you thank you trusty Charlie how often do we put contracts like that and like uh office supplies out for rebid it's usually on an annual basis thank you these types of contracts are usually about a a 12- month period thank you Jenny was
094is there anyone local that put in a bid for this uh for this uh um RFP um we only received the one bid um from Mission so so if there are local companies we would love to do business with them thank you uh trusty Navaro for bringing that um up because yes when we are a government organization as much as you know we we have rules we have to follow being uh state funded and so we do have to put things out to bid and they do have to be um Union or prevailing wage and they um we correct me if I'm wrong but I'm pretty sure we always have to go with the lowest bid um so there's you know our hands are tied in some of those situations but if there was a
095um Union shop local I mean yes and they were the lowest bid then there you would go but you unfortunately a lot of times it's it's a fight you have to take up with the state Gavin Nome I heard you heard that yes so can I um I'm still looking for a motion I'd like to support agenda item 9.4 I second okay thank you I have a first and a second all those in favor I I all those opposing all those abstaining I'll abstain okay sorry Jessica was were you a for okay thank you so that passes 501 okay so that concludes um consent agenda items so we will now move on to item uh 11.1 uh this is a public heing for lin Scott Charter School renewal petition uh the report will be presented
096by Alisia dittle administrative director and principal see if I can make this stay okay hi we're gonna see we're gonna see if you push it down and then the little knob it's the um the mic like I have a lost setup here yeah all right great uh good evening president Flores vice president Dr Navaro members of the pbsd Board of Trustees and superintendent contras my name is Elicia ditt I am the administrative director in principal at Lin Scott charter school it is my pleasure to represent the Linscott Community this evening as we bring our Charter before you for Renewal Lind Scott Charter opened its doors in August of 1994 authorized by pvusd we are one of the earliest charter schools in the state number 41 of what is now close to, 1300 Lind Scott's Service
097to the community didn't just be begin with our Charter it's important to recognize the longstanding commitment to families that the name Linscott represents in our small community since 1928 Lin Scott has had a rich history of meeting the needs of students and their families in one form or another Linscott schools have served approximately 20,000 students in the past 97 years we are humbled and proud to be part of this Legacy 32 years ago several families of the then Linscott Elementary School began discussions around converting the school into a charter school Under the brand new Charter Schools act the new legislation allowed 100 schools to provide a unique approach to public education by encouraging flexibility Innovation and choice our founding families believed deeply and how much family involvement impacted Student Success basing their school model on
098the Watsonville Cooperative Preschool they envisioned a school where highly trained teachers and families worked side by side to educate students while our program has grown and changed in the past 30 years our mission and dedication to strong family Partnerships remain steadfast I'd like this to take this opportunity to read our mission statement Linds Scott charter school is a k through eight parent participation School collaboratively governed by parents and staff dedicated teachers and supportive families provide individualized active Hands-On learning that Fosters each child's academic success encouraging Excellence students become self-motivated critical thinkers demonstrating creativity and confidence our focus on community in and out of the classroom allows students to gain social and environmental awareness although Lynn Scott is a small school with just 259 students spanning kindergarten through 8ighth grade we welcome and support the needs
099of all children the evidence of our vibrant and diverse Community is seen in our demographics as a small school we have the privilege of participating in the day-to-day life of our families as they grow and change we enjoy the benefit of building relationships with multiple children in a family in the past three years we have begun to see our first set of second generation Lind Scott charter school students this is a testament to Linds Scott's strong community and Devotion to supporting each child research consistently demonstrates that family participation in a child's education enhances acade academic achievement improves attendance increases motivation Fosters better behavior and emotional regulation boosts self-esteem and strengthens social emotional development at Linscott we bring this research to life with over 50 50 family volunteers actively supporting classrooms each week our teachers and
100instructional staff staff are data driven and appreciate the freedom and flexibility to use best practices and new and Innovative approaches to meet the needs of each of their students they design differentiated lessons remediate skills and push students to challenge themselves with a growth mindset all while building meaningful relationships we are proud of academic achievement in both math and Ela outperforming both the district and the state as a whole and in all of our subpopulations though we still have work to do we have made great strides in closing our achievement gaps this is notable specifically with our students who are socioeconomically disadvantaged which is our fastest growing population due to our ongoing achievement we have been designated in the high performance category for Renewal we are the only Charter School in Santa Cruz County to earn
101that distinction given this designation we are asking that you renew linscott's Charter for a term of seven years five minutes is not nearly enough to share all of the things that make Lins Scott a wonderful place to learn and to work I would like to extend to you an invitation to come by and get to know us better perhaps at our ka8 science fair which is coming up in a month I'd like our community to have the last word about our about Lin Scott this evening when asked on our annual survey last year about the one thing they love about ly Scott here's what they said the largest words were used the most frequently thank you for your time I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have okay thank you so much do
102we have any public speakers this item have two Alyssa KH and Allison Garen hope I that um my name is Alyssa Khan I am a member of the site management team for lindscott charter school and parent of three current and one future student um I'm here to express my strong support for the renewal of linscott's Charter over the years this school has demonstrated a consistent commitment to providing a high quality education ation to its students fostering an environment of academic Excellence personal growth and Community involvement the school's Innovative approach to education coupled with its dedicated staff and involved families has proven to be a valuable resource to the community the positive impact this charter school has had on students success social emotional development and future Readiness is evident it offers a diverse and inclusive environment
103where students are challenged supported and encouraged to reach their full potential the school's record of improving students outcomes and promoting a strong sense of personal responsibility and Leadership among its students speaks volumes about its Effectiveness for those reasons I wholeheartedly support the renewal of Lind Scott's Charter and encourage the decision makers the board to continue to allow this exceptional institution to serve the community there are a lot of difficult decisions being made tonight but this is an easy win for all of us thank you hi everyone thank you for having us my name is Alison Garen and uh I am also an smt board member and and the proud parent of two small children currently attending Lin Scott Charter School um when I first moved out to California I actually spent my first three years
104here working at Lin Scott so I have a unique perspective and I wholeheartedly agree with the charter renewal I have seen both from the perspective as an employee and then now as a parent just how instrumental this small charter school is for our community um when I first started working there was many years ago and I've seen how much the charter has changed we are working with students in our community and it is an important option for our parents to have so please consider renewing Lind Scott Charter for um everything that they're doing for the students and the families here thank you okay thank you do we have any discussions from the board trusty Turley I do have two questions um are all of the students at your school from the paru Valley Unified um
105District area they are not um we are um it's about 86% of our student population is from within the pvusd boundary um and the rest are from surrounding other districts thank you and what are the keys to your success and how can we share that with us schools I was hoping someone would ask this um uh so um that's really layered and uh anything I say here is supposition but um the the number one key to success in my opinion uh is having extremely strong Partnerships between our families and our staff almost every single staff member on our campus knows the names of every single kid on our campus we know their needs we know their families we know who is struggling with a sick grandmother at home we know who Abita is is having
106challenges with um dementia we know who walks and who needs rain boots um because they're walking and they don't have any we we meet we strive to meet the needs of all of our families that is the first thing that I believe makes us successful the second thing is our teachers they each classroom is um they work together as a team but they're individuals they have the flexibility uh to innovate have they have a student in front of them who is struggling with something our teachers will go research what's the what's new what's best what are uh what's out there to support this child and they remediate and they move kids from where they were thank you trusty Medina yeah hello so just FYI I want to go check out the school um did a
107meeting did did get that AC thing figured out we're good okay cool um it was funny I saw my home Vince teaching fourth grade I was like what home Vince he went to San Jose um wanted to get into education and I think that's kind of what Struck it for me is that you're including you know folks from my area in losos who really don't get a lot of these opportunities so the fact that there's job creation there is great now um on page 22 um it says that professional development is mentioned broadly but lacks a specific focus on strategies for teaching e especially in math and science given the increasing proportion of el students how are you equipping teachers with the tools and training necessary to deliver differentiated cultural response instruction and also just
108to communicate with parents who may not speak Spanish but an indigenous language yeah excellent um in terms of indigenous languages that's definitely an area of growth for us um currently all members of our community are either Spanish speakers or native English speakers um we are actively we actively hire and um an attract or trying to attract more Spanish-speaking members of our staff that is um part of one of our elcap goals we have done so we have um multiple members of our staff for Spanish speaking and who who will come translate if the the teacher or um member of Staff who's dealing with situation do doesn't have the language skills uh in terms of professional development great timely question we actually partnered with um the County Office of Education last year and this year to
109provide professional development in um with math as a focus um specifically aimed at targeting our students who are second language Learners because that is our largest area of growth of needed growth is our is supporting those students who speak language other than English in mathematics and so we have been working with a Coe um in with uh professional development focused at that sweet okay and then just my final question is um I know at a lot of charter schools there tends to be family participation that's needed um you know and you know studies indicate that 4% of parents attend educational workshops in recent years how are you addressing barriers such as language or scheduling conflicts that disproportionately impact Cho latiner indigenous families and um have communication platforms are expanded bilingual workshops to increase engagement so
110um we our last lcaps or our lcap survey last year um we we our family survey we really spoke to the results really spoke to the need for more community events we were actually offering a lot of parent education um opportunities but we were finding that there was a a lack of um interest in the in the agendas or the topics that we were uh presenting even even when we did have we did offer child care and food um also translation was offered we were finding that that maybe the time of day wasn't right we were having because we're a small community I can just go ask people right like hey I noce that you didn't come to this like what's going on yeah people work right yeah absolutely and so you know really trying
111to find a day that or a time and a day in a venue um we offered we tried offering um parent education in the even evenings via zoom in person um lots of different variations but we we worked really hard to try and get around that but what our community told us what they wanted most was more community events so this year we have a community event every other month um and theyve been um large widely attended our very first one was our um was our 30th birthday bash um and uh it we had over 400 people there excellent yeah awesome thank you thank you thank you any other comments yeah how do you make decisions on which students do you take oh that's great I'm glad you asked that um we don't make decisions
112on which students we take um we are a a public school so just like every school in in pvusd we allow every child in however um Ed code requires charter schools to uh hold a random public Lottery if we have more interest than seats available so what we do is we make sure that the word is out in the community that our application window is open we want to make sure that we are inviting in and and welcoming to all members of our community not just the people who seek us out we we do um go to preschools we do advertise um to make um amongst those communities to make sure that we are getting a lot of um uh diverse student uh body a diverse interested body of students um and then uh so
113the application windows open from November till the end of March we hold our R random public lottery in um in early April we do have a a list of um of priorities that the lottery is drawn in the um I just want to turn to my notes so I have the accurate information here um our siblings get first priority because there's nothing worse than having multiple children and having to go from school to school to school for drop off and pickup um so uh our first Lottery preference our siblings of currently enrolled students um our second priority would be children of any um uh full-time lindscott staff member again if you have a child attending a school that you work at you're more invested and you stay and you work super hard and that's what
114we found um our next is any student uh residing in poo Valley Unified School District and then our our last um preference would be any student outside of pvusd and what we find is that siblings take up a very small percentage of our Lottery most of our students that are um that apply who enter our school are coming from within the pbd boundary what percentage of your applicants did you take I don't actually have that information what um uh off the top of my head we our largest um number number of seats available is in kindergarten because we have one class per grade level that travels up and matriculates up when and we have happy families and happy kids we end up to we end up not losing a lot of students over the years
115um and so we have I'm not I'm I'm really not sure about that we we maintain a weight list for anyone that is not uh in that does not um is not placed due to Lottery and that is a Perpetual weight list so it rolls from one year to the next and we move down it all throughout the year the reason I ask is clearly your academic numbers look fantastic um it reminds me a lot of when I had my kids at monor when they were younger and I one of the things that I stated when I applied for the board is that I believe parental involvement is so important in making sure that our students are successful and our teachers are supported and our schools are able to complete their mission so what do
116you do and I won't belabor this anymore cuz I know we have a lot to do but what do you do I mean other than requiring it to get parents involved we don't require it we do not require it um that that was something that happened um a long time ago in our history we have been around for 30 years and since then lots of things have changed um it has not been a requirement to participate we um we ask we encourage we beg we plead we smoke signal everything we can in order to get parents in we build those deep connections and it starts with our front office staff making those first connections and then it's and then it moves on to our teachers making calls home and and seeing people you know out
117waving at cars that's how well keep up the great work and Dr contras maybe we could move that over to the rest of the schools thank you okay um thank you any other comments from the board okay see done um so ly Scott is very dear to my heart for a couple reasons um I grew up just around the corner on bakia street and so Lind Scott was my playground and also um I had I think eight of my cousins are all alumni um and so uh I know it's a great school and um I do you know keep an eye on it and um other T schools just see like what can we glean from that because yeah we need to you know improve our numbers as well um so I I thank you
118for your presentation tonight um and do we is being seeing that oh did you have another make a motion no this is a dis this is just a public hearing so we don't need a vote Yes so thank you so much thank you very much for your time thank you okay um I'm now going to move us on to our action items but I do want to just ask that um we keep the disrespectful comments to yourselves I I we hear them when you guys are saying them um again we're just asking for simple respect please um so with that said we will now move on to item 2.1 the selection of a date to hold a special board meeting on ethnic studies um Dr Heather um contras our superintendent of schools will report on
119this thank you uh by popular demand most of the board if not all I believe wanted to engage in putting ethnic studies onto the agenda for a study session to have a deep dive into uh where pvusd has been with ethnic studies and uh make some considerations for where we're going and so proposing to hold a special study session uh on ethnic studies we need to agree on a date to add for that I had a couple of suggestions um but if we want to look at something El someone can Pro propose that as well uh to try to honor everyone's time our different schedules and dates that have already been uh advertised as well to the public we may be proposing March 5th or March 19th but moving our closed session up to 3:00
120starting the study session at 4 o'clock and holding the study session from 4 until 6 and then having the regular board meeting from at 6 o'clock at this special meeting or we can we could do it we can add a meeting as well I was trying to honor mainly your okay sorry before I'm sorry before we have board discussion do you are you done with your presentation okay so um do we have any public speakers to this item oh sorry wait when correction 26th the 26th is the board meeting that we had already identified not the 19th we move so we'll move it to the 2 so either the 5th or the 26th okay yeah March so next for item 12.1 we have Bobby pels Omar Diez Christine Hong Dr lordes barazza and Maria Garcia
121um before you start Bobby are we still I'm going by the one minute rule for these ones as well yes there a big stack for these yes there's a big stack for these cool I'd like to make a motion to um increase it to two minutes so people who have a prepared speech could actually um say what they need to say um no this isn't a time for motions or voting right now this is the way the agenda is going to going tonight so if I wanted to extend the meeting so we could hear them for 2 minutes I could do that there's 26 we have actually 31 we have 31 and so I will promise you that we can I there's 31 if everyone lines up and goes quickly and doesn't go over the
122time we can hear everybody I would allow us to go over a few minutes just so that we could hear everybody but we're not going to change it to two minutes I would want to AC well I mean it's um it's not there but I want to extend it to 2 minutes per person and I mean we are elected by the people this is our job we're only here every three weeks so I think we got to listen Dr contras is this something we would take a or is it just something that as board president I just say yes okay so it would be a vote okay but yeah she changed it to one minute and we didn't vote on that so wasn't that part of the approval of the agenda for this evening that
123we stick to the program no so we in our board policy if when we have a large amount of comments we are allowed to change it to one minute that in that's in our board policies but it's also in the board policy that somebody could overrule that with a motion correct make a motion I would like to make a motion to have the speaker speak for 2 minutes on this agenda item do I have a second okay all those in favor for all those opposed I abstaining okay thank youy [Applause] I already wrote it for one minute if you don't need to speak for one minute that would be great I mean for two minutes that' be great I'm prepared for one minute but thank you all right Bob P watching High uh since after
12416 months of countless comments letters emails petitions editorials articles radio shows news reports and a clean sweep of the board election C back on the agenda and I'll be speaking to it while I'm grateful to see it on the agenda I'm disappointed that it's only to schedule a special board meeting and not to approve the contract we have already spent the last 16 months proving time and time again that it was wrong to cancel this contract and C must be brought back but if you need to hear these things again and have a special board meeting we'll do it again I've already been to every single board meeting for the last 16 months month worth one more but I want to make something very very clear this is no longer about deciding if C should
125come back the community has already decided that we are going to bring back C because if you have not figured it out already we're not going anywhere support ethic studies bring back C thank you can I uh withhold my comment to the end of all the comments is that is that possible or do I need to take my comment right now just if you could speak now please okay well well I'm here to support the ethnic studies uh CR contract and I and I'm here always to support all the students that come here their voice is the most strongest voice in this whole movement and it's important that if they are here to fight for something that they believe that we support them in that and it's it's important that we we take into considerations
126what they need and want in this community they are the voice and they are the future and if they feel like they need to be supported in ethnic studies let's support and please thank you power just I'm waiting for my PowerPoint thank you my name is Christine Hong um and I'd like to speak about ethnic studies um and also the fact that the people have repeatedly come to this boardroom advocating for ethnic studies I'd like to um also state that I was chosen um I was um appointed by the University of California to serve as the co-chair of the UC um area a through GH ethnic studies implementation work group um and you can see here that UC the UC Office of the President they have an A through G articulation team they actually went
127through to see what are the key findings they did a survey back in 2025 if you go down to the last bullet point it says that the most important the the most reported types of support that were needed were professional development okay professional development was the most important and you could see here too that the look at the bottom two what the survey found is that lack of ethnic studies expertise and lack of teaching availability were the most crucial issues even outpacing the question of funding I want to go here too if you go to ab101 the law that mandates the teaching of ethnic study studies in k312 education you see that there is a restriction that a course that does not have and deliver majority ethnic studies content does not count this is also
128a budgetary issue if you're not proposing to hire an entire new Fleet of ethnic studies Educators you are dealing with teachers who are hired to be English language arts teachers um and just finally I'll speak about this later it's the fields for was that my time that's your time thank you okay this is the field framework please look at that it's in your [Applause] package um hello uh today I'm here to welcome the new Board of Trustees so far I stand correct that I can see that you guys are going to make a big difference I was voting for you guys I was rooting for you guys and I made sure to tell everybody that I knew to make sure to vote for you guys and I guess it worked so um I am here
129to support ethnic studies and I'm happy how it's going so far we got our own little segment so I'm happy that at least we got that and I'm just looking forward to of course I'm coming back I've been coming for over half a year so it's nice to come back I didn't come once because there was some stuff going on but um I like that we're going to make a change and I'm happy that all of you are here to hear me out and to hear about the problems that are here so thank you um I am a pbd graduate I attend in first grade to 12th grade and I'm a Watsonville high school graduate I also taught wats I also taught at Watsonville High School in Renaissance for 10 years during that time Mr
130Doug Kaplan was a trustee and he worked really hard to have abas seced from pvusd when the brown kids from Watsonville started to get bus there and now he's here again to deny the brown kids access to real liberated ethnic studies um for over a year the community has consistently showed up for ethnic studies in the C contract those who are against C have yet to provide any evidence that supports their lies and their slander against Dr Tango kues I do not care how other districts run their ethnic studies classes I care about pvusd since this is where my kids go because I now I am a parent of pvusd students I don't care if Scott's Valley or Santa Cruz are doing something different great for them if it works for them awesome it does
131not work for us I want real eth real liberated study for my kids I don't I don't care what they're doing so don't bring in those those comparisons earlier today we had a student River who informed the board that there are kids who specifically go to school just for that being that we have an attendance problem why would we not have actual liberated ethnic studies if that's what's actually contributing to kids going to school and it actually aligns with the research I don't know how many of you have looked at the research I know the previous board didn't bother to look at the research but the research aligns with that it says that kids that take liberated ethnic studies not water down ethnic studies but liberated ethnic studies improve academically they're more likely to go
132to college they come to school and they come back and serve their community so I don't understand why the CR contract has been an issue when again none of the lies that have been spread by Mr Gil Stein uh rosin shorstein and Mr Doug hlan have ever been proven we've consistently asked them where is your evidence they've yet to show us anything it's all opin it's all it's just what what they feel but the most important thing is they're not experts in the field why are we listening to people who are not experts in the field I want my kids to be taught by people who have been trained by experts in the field [Applause] hi I'm Nat low area 7 um I want to thank the new board for putting this special meeting um
133under agenda this is something that the students in the community have asked for for months so I appreciate that um ethnic studies in the CR contract are finally going to be discussed openly and we ask that this discussion is based on what is best for the students and is backed with facts and evidence I think that when people with no students in the district attack an existing successful two-year partnership that was already vetted already approved twice by the board and that the students and teachers benefited from the burden of proof should be on those who make the accusations we have brought you evidence and materials we've run a town hall to discuss the issue we've gone above and beyond to bring you information and evidence and we've done this in the service of the best
134interest of our students in our community all we are asking is that you listen to the ethnic studies experts that you listen to the students and you listen to the teachers and make your decisions based on their best interests thank [Applause] you Eli Davies um in area 7 here to advocate for C been coming for over a year I'm an ethnic studies major this is important to me I think it it goes all the way back to when they the previous board did not renew the ethnic studies contract consultant contract um the the person giving the presentations you know had these questions and said well yes but we need someone with an ethnic studies degree like this was uh the person who was presenting to the board and the questions they were getting eventually came
135to you know you're asking well can UCSC do it can we get it for free and it it comes down to you're going to need an expert in ethnic studies to teach ethnic studies um and we've been bringing all these resources there have been all the local professors have come here to try and talk to this board and bring on this this extra um session and allow them to speak there are very accredited experts in ethnic studies here that have been trying and I think it's it's important to note that there's no apology to Dr alago cuales and yet this you know part of this board immediately was to give an apology to a person tonight and uh I I just you know you want to talk about the way that like the this part
136of the board meeting acts like the board also needs to look at the way they act the leadership that was there created the toxic environment so it's up to you all to heal [Applause] it good evening my my name is Kelly matsua I am a staff member at Food what a local organization that focus on Community Health and food Justice and I strongly support the reinstatement of the C contract and robust and supported ethnic studies for our community each year I am lucky enough to work with dozens of incredible young people from high schools in pvusd last year our organization took youth from Watsonville to a youth Leadership Summit with youth from all over the country I got to witness the power and importance of ethnic studies in action when our youth proudly and confidently
137shared about the history and background of their Community to youth from all over the country they shared about leaders from their community events and things like the canary strike things that they had learned about in their ethnic studies curriculum here this is just one example of the ripple effect of the importance of of ethnic studies in Watsonville that goes beyond even here please listen to what our students are asking for thank [Applause] you uh good afternoon board my name is Mark Mendoza and for a year I've been coming to board meeting to speak about the renewal of CR and I'm sure our new board trustees have seen our progress and how the community has made an impact on this issue I'm here once again to keep talking about the issue I understand that the topic
138of ethnic studies and C has been added to the agenda and there have there are plans to have a special board meeting on the topic I am Overjoyed that there are plans to have a discussion and I hope the board doesn't disappoint their Community again our community has fought a lot to get where we are the community and only we can only keep looking forward please don't let us down us students and the community have dealt with a board that only let us down and wanted to be in power and didn't care about their students I'm proud that this year our community got together and brought in people people who are supporting us and not letting us down and I hope as a community to keep rising and growing thank [Applause] you good evening board
139my name is Doug Kaplan I suppose I'm the skunk in the garden party the co-founders of CR have had an opportunity to practice what they preach in 2015 they started a charter school in Oakland 5 years later Oakland trustees closed the school deeming it in their words not academically sound 83% of the schools students were not proficient in Reading 92% of the schools students after 5 years were not proficient in math the issue is not what whether or not to offer ethnic studies that decision has been made a decision all of us enthusiastically support but the decision is do you use an approach like cres or liberated ethnic studies in a standalone ethnic studies course available to students or do you adopt the CR liberated ethnic studies course or approach to the teaching of other
140academic courses throughout the curriculum so I beg you please keep cr's academic track record in mind as you struggle with that and other decisions and prepare for the meeting coming up in a few months thank you very much one question um point of order really quick this is Gabe we're in public session public comment right now so you can wait and I'm happy to return to answer any questions if that's your desire thank you Mark M okay move on sandino Gomez Eric Marilyn Garrett and tekashi Mizuno maano Muno um hello School Board welcome new members welcome old members um happy New Year I am a teacher who benefited from the c training 100% I'm a better teacher today because of the c training I think the oranges that uh Doug brought up have nothing to
141do with the apples that we're talking about here which is that we need people to train our teachers we're not asking C to teach our students we're asking them to train our students and our administrators so that they can better support the program and more accurately and honestly deliver ethnic studies content to our students that's what we're asking for the opportunity to get some of the foremost experts in the country back on our team helping us to create a better program that's what we want and the fact that this has been politicized and used to attack these scholars in slanderous in liess ways with the the weaponization of Jewish identity okay it is not anti-semitic to talk about Israel and the occupation and Palestinians and the fact that this has become this big of an
142issue and that it has taken this long for the board to addresses it is honestly a disgrace and I refer more to the old board than new I don't want to start on a bad foot here but Kim desura disgraced this board when she brought up those allegations unfounded unproven I don't know what doug gave you but I'm willing to bet it is not anything to do with the curriculum that we reviewed because we asked Temple bethl to look at it we asked leaders of the Jewish Community we asked Murray sheckman our former superintendent to look at the curriculum and to to to analyze it he found nothing he was in support of our students he was in support of our teachers please do the right thing and I like that you're doing in a
143agenda or a special board meeting that's great but put it on the agenda to renew the contract the problem was they refused to put it back on the agenda we have a new a new board a new agenda committee I really hope you can find the courage and the decency to a apologize to Dr Allison and B to bring back C enthusiastically and apologize for what we've done please do the right thing [Applause] just uh trusty Florence I just have a quick comment okay um if the public could just address the board and not address anybody else in the crowd thank you very much okay um to address the board I he should be able to call a point of order I feel like that is like a yeah somebody said back there they need
144a parliamentarian up here but anyways I'm here to speak today in support of renewing the C contract I'm an elementary school teacher here and when my kids move on I would love for them to have a curriculum that is relevant to their lives and experiences our students deserve an education that reflects their histories cultures and communities they come from and to squash that just because of some false allegations is like ridiculous um I'm really inspired by like all of my comrades up here that have like done amazing organizing the words of sandino are like very inspiring um yeah I'm just very yeah I'm sorry I'm like welling up with emotion cuz I haven't felt this way in a long time and to see so many people fire it up is amazing um so yeah uh
145teachers need consistent support and professional development to effectively teach this curriculum and guidance from the community responsive education is crucial to ensuring that educators are equipped and engaged um to engage with the diverse backgrounds in our community um so I hope you all move forward with it and renew that contract thank you [Applause] hi good evening I'm Takashi again and I was on the pbsd ethnic studies Community coll collaborative committee uh for several years and I received a letter of Professor Arison addressed to the board in O October of and after I received the letter and I started to take on this issue and I have spoken on this issue since the fall of 2023 and tonight I just I had a chance to meet with Professor Arison in the town hall meeting last year
146and I was very much impressed with uh presentation and I had a chat I had a chance to have a chat with her and at that time I told her that I have researched American Indian farmw worker families uh who immigrate to Bahar since 1840s and she said she loved to hear it so I have been blessed to have worked with local Indians and Indigenous people since I moved here about 11 years ago from New Jersey and I can work with Professor E and her team if they would like to do because I'm one of the one who have had documents and personal relationship friendship with local Indians so I'm happy to her to work with her and her te yeah thank you [Applause] I would like to give my two minutes to Christine Hong
147may I do that what she spoke already so you can go ahead and not two minutes we've never allowed that before as far as I know all right um I um Community responsive education is is critical and we live in a settler colonialist capitalist exploitation Society here and Indigenous people and people of color are exploited in many ways I want to give you just a couple examples I taught in this district for 20 years bilingual classes second grade mostly so um one thing I remember I had a little girl in my classroom who was practically blind she had a special teacher the parents worked in the field and pesticides and I looked up about methyl bromide which is applied or was in next to the schools and it says damages lungs eyes kidneys skin known
148to cause reproductive harm this is just one of the damaging effects of the kind of system we live in the other was that the parents of course wanted their children to have better lives and not have to work in the fields some people had trouble with their feet because when they were harvesting strawberries the road were very narrow so their feet wouldn't fit and they had to bend over all the time that's just a couple of points of exploitation thank you thank you do we have any other comments no okay okay um so now we will move on to um any discussion from the board Trust Medina sorry good uh I just wanted to say thank you to our agenda setting committee for putting this on the agenda I know we've had a lot of
149advocacy and that's also inspired me so I just wanted to thank everyone you know comes out repeatedly to these meetings you know every night giving up their nights their dinners um spending quality time with their family and I just wanted to um Echo that and thank the Geno heading committee once again for um listening to the community [Applause] trusty Medina yeah um thank you all for showing up um I am somebody who studied uh Cho studies when I went to UCLA and it was surprising to me that I had to spend thousands of dollars per unit just to learn about myself well people like that man that came up blocked my education because we don't want Latinos mexicos indigenous people knowing that we are being oppressed currently not only by the Americans but also by
150the Spanish when they first arrived on these Shores and let me give a fun fact the US was the one who showed the state the blue and white State over there what to do in order to commit a genocide to restrict people from their hometowns let us not forget that natives lived here first if you want to come in here and evoke Manifest Destiny all right let me tell you something that's not going to work in this day and age anymore these history books are wrong they need to be corrected these people that have been here coming for a year and you don't want to extend their time I that is amazing to me that we're going to continue to drag us on which we are not so um I have a question about this
151special session are we able to invite people in a panel that way we could have an expert come in and not people who are going to be spewing non-fact ual [Applause] information we can arrange to have experts come in and speak with us and during that time yes yeah yeah I would think I think it would be great if each um trustee could invite somebody to come in and hold down the fort so we could ask questions about ethnic studies and its curriculum similar to what they do in the United States government since we are a governing board right cool um with that being said um I hear you guys I've heard you guys right and let me say something the cool thing about running an election is you actually get to meet and talk
152to people and learn about what they want and learn about their needs their struggles and what they're going through and I can't say the same to somebody who's been appointed by three people so with that being said thank you okay do we have any other discussion from the board trusty kco I I want to take the I want to thank um board members who put this on the agenda this is really important um I am a product of ethnic studies um the reason why I wanted to become a teacher is because of ethnic studies and I'll speak more about that but I want you to also know that the statement of having kids specifically wanting to go to school because of this class is true because as a teacher who taught it they're a kids
153who literally only came to my class so that's all I'm going to say thank you any other comments trusty [Applause] chle I'm glad there was agreement with the agenda setting committee to have this planning session I look forward to learning what community responsive education is and is not I hope that through this process we develop a road map for how we deal with all controversies that may come up to us so that we're making decisions based on information from experts our own study um and not just making quick decisions on something that we only heard something about for a few minutes um moving forward kind of a related subject um at at a future time I'd like to learn more about how when we have any new curriculum how it approved and how we roll
154it out and have our teachers trained to fully understand the curriculum so that they can better serve our students Trustin novaro hi thank you um one of the things I've noticed just in my short time on the board is clearly how passionate the community feels about this which is why trusty fles and I that was one of the first things that we wanted to put back on the agenda um I'm not sure exactly what happened previously but I will apologize to Dr Allison tago kubalas I I don't know exactly what happened and transpired because that was before our time but if she was disrespect in any way then I will be the one to apologize um thank you I I think the one thing that we all agree on is that e think studies is
155really important I think that there are so many stories in Paro Valley of communities that have been marginalized and discriminated against and those stories need to be shared and taught and I believe everybody's stories are important um so I look forward to learning more about this particular curriculum and this SI my I have been meeting with individuals and you know actually got the textbook and I think Carol and I are delving into it to try to understand this more fully and I just want to assure you that I think most of us are trying to learn as much as we can about this before we make a decision I'd also like to thank the agenda committee for bringing this back and with that being said um you know we we chose dates where we have
156a lot of packed items and other upcoming items so I would like to ask the the board president the vice president if I can make a suggestion of March 27th if we could dedicate an evening I agree with you I I think packing it on to already agenda meetings and I appreciate you trying to respect my schedule but that's I have five hour board meetings mon once a month and that's I think a separate meeting would be better for all of us can I make a motion U let me I just have a couple comments to make before we um know you're before okay H you know so hopefully we could take a look at another date where we can have a a deep discussion and hopefully when we talk about ethnic studies you know
157as trusty Medina said and and and sandino the the M wat the mon Bay has a lot of history a lot of people um a lot of indigenous roots and cultures you know for example we have the Native Americans who live this land the aloney people and a lot of people don't know if we look at you know for example Lake View secondary Middle School right we look at we look at Lake View Middle School we have a monument that mentions that that was Indian land and I I think that's something that should be also included in ethnic studies the the Chinese American people who lived here in Watsonville who built the railroads who who lived off uh Maple Street B um Union that was a a Chinese Village I think that also should be
158included in ethnic studies the Filipinos who worked the fields you know who were attacked because they entered the wrong establishments and were dancing with American women and they were murdered off Mur crossing road that should be also included in ethnic studies the Japanese Americans like masimoto who were rounded up and taken to interment camps at the selenous fairgrounds when you look at where they have the rodeo when you look back towards the Stables there's a monument that says the Japanese were interned here before they were sent out to the Central Valley The mexican-americans Who harvested this land in the 1950s before they were deported under operation wet back and that's something else we need to talk about in the 1980s and in the 1990s the canary strikes were I believe some of our our relatives
159worked and um that's also something that should be mentioned and so I I wanted to dedicate a special day so everybody can have the opportunity um Everybody B is about everybody and I hopefully invite everybody who sent letters and who talked to please show up to that meeting and and tell us the history that needs to be told because some of us know that some of us know that and um you know let it be said you know this is was a meeting for everybody to talk and dedicate their stories and so this is a day and hopefully we can find a date where all of us could share those stories thank you thank you trusty Dodge um I'm glad that you mentioned uh Mr Hashimoto because I had the privilege of being in kindergarten
160with Miss Hashimoto and Mr Hashimoto at Watsonville High uh for US history and um I loved what both of them brought to their classrooms and I just want to take this time to thank um Mr uh Mizuno for the invitation to the event that's going to H be at at APS High School on the 28th um my great-grandmother is actually a Loney Indian all of her generation when they are buried uh the tribe still comes out and performs there so that I I definitely am going to be there um thank you for bringing that to our attention so now we can have the discussion um as for as far as a date and time and so uh trusty Dodge brought up doing it on a Thursday how does everyone feel about that my preference would
161be to keep it on a Wednesday because that's kind of our routine maybe the Wednesday before the 19th or the 12th so a separate Wednesday from our board meeting but still on a Wednesday okay um if if I I I would actually rather have this on a Sunday where we could have more participants um involved and students um I know a lot more people are off on a Sunday is that possible for us to do I would be okay with a Saturday but not a Sunday as as the one person who has to work every other weekend and only gets their kids twice that might be a little challenging but maybe on a Friday evening I could do Friday evening do whatever you want yeah so how does everyone feel about a Friday evening I
162could do a Friday okay so let's suggest some so we can look at our calendars 21st or 28th I'm a broke Millennial I'm free all the time so just tell me when to be there so March March so why don't we all look at March 21st or March 28th okay 21st is off the uh 28th does March 28th work okay and how about a Time Dr contaras what time should we at six o'clock like we we typically start Fray it's a Friday and is will there be a closed session since it's a special study session I don't see a need for a closed session and we'll have other meetings to do board business uh with that so I think it would just be straight study session could be a lengthier present because the study session
163will include presentations yeah I'm looking at Claudia because she's going to be responsible for that cloudia what how much of presentation time are you envisioning oh goody um yay I get to have input on this uh I would like to be able to have a good solid hour um I mean perfect world scenario maybe a little even more than that especially if we're bringing experts in um so if we could go an hour hour and a half and then that would be able to give us time to have public or comments about it because we still have to do public comment so we would have be able to have comment and then a nice sizable time to do discussion so I I'm wondering if since it's a Friday if we do five o'clock five o'clock
164start time just so we don't I don't know how many people want to stay super late on Friday if I could get a quick survey of people would Friday at 5: work raise your hand if that's cool like I don't people at 5:30 that's a good 5:30 is good my grandma said she wants to come she's free after 5:30 so okay I need a mo after noas right I'll make a motion 5:30 on March 28th special board meeting and can I have a second I'll second okay all those in favor I all those opposing any in okay motion carries 601 thank [Applause] you okay and now I will move us on to item 12.2 the sustainable budget team um this will be presented by Dr Heather Conta superintendent of schools and the sustainable budget team
165thank you so our sustainable budget team is a assembling themselves I can see some people coming up um so as they get ready for the presentation I just want to brief the board in and do a reminder of the process behind this there's a couple things I want to note also um for you to be aware of and think about uh this process I believe is one of the most transparent processes a district has engaged in with the most opportunity for Community input um that I'm aware of in looking at budget reductions and all of California is in this position we are pvusd is not alone in having to look at this we received Millions hundred million dollars in one-time monies that were allocated in a variety of ways um but we did choose as
166a district to allocate one-time spending to positions that money has sunsetted and so we need to look at how how do we address um that funding when we have positions that we added with dollars that we no longer have um so we put together this team all of the meetings were recorded live streamed and then any documents were posted um my team put together what we thought was the really the pertinent information and we chose to look at just what did we do as a district with one-time dollars covid money or otherwise known as Esser funds you'll hear hear those interchangeably today in the presentation um that what did we do how did we allocate that spending and then what what might we do now uh the team was asked many many questions and requested
167much information from us so if you look through those different meetings you'll see different things like at one point we had a request to see our electric bills um so we shared everything that was requested of us and we also shared a lot of documents that we did um I know earlier pvft talked about positions um and not sharing those we we did not talk positions we talked overall funding sources um positions and the approval of positions that might be impacted by this would come at the February 17th board meeting um additionally so tonight the action that we're seeking from the board is to give approval for my team to move forward in preparation for next steps that would have to happen um additionally I know the mental health clinicians are impacted in one of
168the recommendations from the sustainable budget team I do want to note that that does not include mental health clinicians that are paired with our SRO and that's because that the SRO pairing with the mental health clinicians is a program that we have um said goes together to our public so so the that is not one of the positions that would be left additionally I want to note that we are the what the sustainable budget team recommended was to return to prepandemic funding levels so things that were in place in 2019 remain intact and so in none of the proposals I think except for maybe yeah no in actually in none of the proposals is uh there just a total um removal of like Mental Health Services or a total removal of social emotional counselors or
169a total removal of intervention programs um or or Partnerships that we do have so that I I do want to point that out because we are remaining Pro you know programs intact so um the sustainable budget team worked through many hours to um make the recommendation to the board knowing that what they are putting before you is a recommendation uh and it is ultimately the board's decision so uh with that I think they are ready to present we like need to bump bad Bunny's new album while the silence is happening or something because I think that's appropriate right thank you I do actually have one more comment that I'd like to make and that's to the sustainable budget team um so this team of 24 people applied to be part of the sustainable budget team
170uh we had more applicants to the team than um we had spots because we were looking at what's a team that could be really functional and have deep discussions over the course of these actions uh I want to thank this team uh personally from the bottom of my heart you showed up you showed up every single time you were thoughtful you asked questions you went back out into the community and brought things back in uh and I know that this is a very hard and difficult presentation to make but we do value community and Community input and when we're looking at budget reductions it is important to consider those things so thank you very much hello everyone here and at home my name is Nora yurena I'm a mother of six all students here within
171our school district um I'm a certified family educator and I'm the founding director of Raa zarino a Family Resource Center I was fortunate um if that's the right word uh to serve on this budget committee um we're actually in incredibly beautiful diverse group um those who were able to speak tonight um may not all necessarily represent the diversity but um it it was fantastic I really appreciate the work that went into that um we were tasked with the impossible um really to know that we we aren't experts in anything that we were presented with where many of us are regular old parents um all members like uh Dr Conta said were chosen by Lottery they include parents Educators labor union Representatives Administration and communitybased organizations like that I represent we spent more than 16 hours
172learning the intricacies of our District's budget this committee has no voting power so everybody listening we do not have any voting power whatsoever and again it's ultimately up to you all and I I really want to reiterate that because the sense I'm getting from public comment from stakeholders is that this budget committee is kind of being viewed as a scapegoat for making this really crummy decision that has to be made um I don't know are you guys doing slides that we have oh I have a fancy button hey um I don't think we necessarily need to read these over but this is the school district's vision and Mission these are the members of the committee we pull together some Norms to lean on um our work was Guided by these core principles that students are
173our top priority Equity of voice for all of us on the committee and including Equity of voice for those that we represent from the community at large listen to understand not listening to just respond be brave enough to ask the questions create a safe space for open dialogue and honor the diversity of our community and then also to assume positive intent our recommendations align with the district's strategic goals um these were presented in a board meeting in November of last year with the first goal being academic Excellence professional learning climate culture and Community fiscal responsibility and human resour sources and then our purpose so the budget committee's purpose was to make Collective recommendations to the board on how we use our resources to best serve students and maintain fiscal solvency in the face of declining
174enrollment over the next decade right so that was the other piece is this wasn't just deciding making a recommendation and understanding what's going to happen next year but over the next decade and then also understanding what was happening long before covid and that is part of these intricacies that were you know tremendously confusing but I thought the community did a really great job of bringing in experts to help us understand in a deeper level um the committee faces a difficult task identifying potential cost-saving measures to address a projected budget def defit let me be clear no one on the committee wants these Cuts not a single person on this committee not miss contras here not anyone not anyone in the community not any student no one wants these cuts for those at home those behind
175me I urge you to engage with the school board on these critical budget decisions I also hope the district considers establishing ongoing budget committees to Foster continued Community involvement in the decision-making process I also feel like we as a committee did not have all the information and I don't feel like that's necessarily the fault of any particular person but feeling as I said like a scapegoat for these really crummy decisions that have to be made I also feel like and I I share that as a collective that we didn't have all the information there were there were questions that we asked that didn't get answers to that there is a misunderstanding of the the intricacies of just the mental health professionals that support our students as well so in that as I propose and request
176ongoing budget committees that it bring in our community that we do in fact give all the ins and outs of everything involved even if it's a little too complicated even if we go beyond 16 hours and we pull 20 hours those who signed up to win this Lottery to be part of the committee we're invested in our students in our children and in our community thank you [Applause] thank you so much good evening good evening president Flores vice president Dr Navaro and Dr contas members and cabinet my name is Katie Chris cunis and I am the proud principal of Lake View Middle School my pronouns are she her and I am also a parent in our committee our in our community excuse me Dr Conta has provide provided our team with a seven-step problem solving
177model as a process for conducting our work our team worked collaboratively to identify the problem in early work together and for many of our meetings as we analyzed data and reimagined possible and plausible Solutions knowing that this challenge is something that we will be working through in the next few years on December 13th our team completed step five which we are recommending to the board this evening our team co-created a problem statement to clarify the problem we were tasked with addressing the problem statement was our guide for this important work pvusd is facing a significant challenge due to declining enrollment and the loss of one-time pandemic funding to address this issue we must rep prioritize and reimagine our services to scale effectively and maximize available resources our goal is to maintain high quality educational offerings
178while ensuring Equitable access for all students to achieve this we must Implement Solutions with transparency ultimately position positioning our district for success in a sustainable manner to ensure that we are able to address possible and plausible Solutions aligned with our district and our our team reviewed our district goals I think it's important to review these goals here this evening and I do understand you can read them but I I do think that what helps me to ensure that I'm achieving the goals at my site is to constantly revisit those with all the stakeholders in our community so that we can make sure we stay focused at what we're trying to achieve goal one engage and sustain the trust involvement and responsibility of all parents and Community to promote collaborative programs which result in high levels
179of success for all students goal two attract hire develop and retain an excellent professional staff throughout the district goal three provide academic challenges for all students support and maintain programs that are successful and help build new opportunities so we keep all students engaged in their learning goal four maintain a balanced budget while effectively maximizing all resources to fulfill educational priorities goal five ensure that all schools provide a safe healthy and positive School environment for students and staff goal six provide a consist consistent and strategic program to achieve the goal of English acquisition pardon me our district goals are aligned to the local control accountability plan commonly referred to as the lcap for our community members the lcap goals were collaboratively developed with stakeholders in our community last year and they were they describe the goals
180which align to our actions and expenditures to support positive student outcomes so goal one is focused on College and Career Readiness and academic success goal two positive School culture including family engagement goal three supporting Foster youth goal four supporting students who receive special services and such as students with disabilities goal five supporting multilingual Learners and the site specific goals 6 through eight which is an equity multiplier funds focus on our um new school Community Day School Renaissance continuation school and virtual Academy Additionally the team was presented with the district's core values for allocating resources our first value as a district is to be student centered we maintained that through these challenging discussions we want to make sure that the decisions that we're bringing or the recommendation that we're bringing you here today um focuses on
181putting students first we must re must prioritize students best interest in all decision making and consider the impact of sunsetting funds on student well-being student learning student outcomes and parent engagement in support of increased student outcomes our second core value is to ensure equity and access as we make decisions with realigning our program we commit to maintain Equitable access to educational opportunities and supports for all students this includes a focus on student groups who have historically underperformed our third value is to preserve the programs and services that directly support District goals and lcap goals while our fourth value is to consider programs that are currently in place that need additional years to show progress towards improving student outcomes when considering programs that require more time to exhibit progress we will ensure evidence-based datadriven decisions are
182made regarding program Effectiveness and with that said I want to thank you all this evening for representing our community um not only um our schools but also as a parent in this community um my own children's um needs so thank you and with that I'd like to introduce Mike [Applause] Flor good evening again board and I'm Dr contras here we are ever use one of these you just use the right there we go um so the very first thing we did in the first of the eight meetings was to prioritize what the budget is spent on these are the seven areas that the budget is used for and we spent the entire meeting sitting down and prioritizing there were five groups of small groups we all had our own ideas in the consensus base and
183all those groups turned into this list of priorities the first being teaching and learning um that's the teachers and the core educational programs as defined by the Ed code that's the first priority that's kind of to be untouched the second was Visual and Performing Arts music art drama choir don't want to take that away from the kids again that happened 20 years ago so that's not going to happen again the third is enrichment opportunities field trips outdoor activities Athletics those programs can't be cut either so those three things we deliberated for two hours and um those three were pretty pretty much unanimous with all the groups then we get into the controversy mental health was the fourth priority there's an array of services there career and college connection um college visits College and Career Centers
184we spend money on Family Resources medical socio emotional informational and food security and then educational options the uh basically Virtual Academy and Pacific Coast Charter those schools need to be there they exist because of Co we opened up a a second one and so that is the ranking of the priority that the entire committee um deemed priority this is the core classes the core subject areas that our district uses this model it's a nice Vin diagram um Math and Science and English language arts have their own individual components but then they cross-pollinate and in the middle there you could see that they support analysis of a range of grade level complex texts with evidence because you have to read in all of those so it's kind of how they're all folded together that's the district
185model and then this is um the 23 24 school year um how we rank with some neighboring districts as far as meeting the base um uh expectations for the learning that happens that year um these are similar districts demographically to ours in California and as you can see the numbers there we're not the worst but we're definitely not the best um there's a lot of Need for improvement there if you look at for English language arts we scored lower than we did the year before and in mathematics just a small Improvement so there's a lot of room for improvement there um from what's what we did in the 23 24 school year and then these are the meetings that we had you can look at those the one I'm talking about was on September 18th
186where we uh basically broke down and created those priorities we had a two-hour presentation on how to read the budget at our second meeting an outside consultant came in and spent the entire time breaking down the budget to us none of us are experts so it was a big time learning experience for all of us us and a lot of eyes were open like oh okay learned some terms there's a lot more than I think most of us mastered but we got a working understanding of how the budget works then the following week um we broke up in groups and we dialed in more to the tough decisions that were oncoming so we're looking at six hours of meetings before we even talked about what we were going to do any cuts um where we
187had to make adjustments on uh the day before Halloween um we continued what we were doing the week before the the fifth meeting on the 6th of November we talked about Site Staffing and ratios so we could understand what that meant because some of the cuts that we kind of need to make are right sizing the ratios at certain schools which is going to seem like we're filling classes more and having less people do it so it's going to be more work for the people that are already doing it and then when we came back two weeks later we talked about how to attract students I mean teachers to our are and keep them so we didn't really talk about what we were going to do cuts until the seventh meeting on December 10th and
188of the seven things where do you cut what we needed to cut I mean none of it was pleasant so we talked about bringing things back to preco because the co money enabled us to hire new things but that's not a sustainable amount moving forward so we didn't know what to do we didn't like it that was the least fun meeting and if you watch that we went over so all the meetings credit to Dr contras we we ended at 8 o00 so this one we went till almost 8:25 because it was very uncomfortable and um we were given a homework ass assignment right before Thanksgiving on November 20th to try to come up with innovative ideas to save some money and we posted those all over the board um so we did a lot
189to try to figure out creative ways but the reality of it is the recommendations that we came up with that we're going to present to you that we're doing right now is the the the lesser of all the evils according to the 24 of us that collaborated on this and then the last board meeting we we put it all together and I think those are my five pages so thank you for listening I appreciate it I'm going to present Sue grty to continue thank you did I go the wrong way no okay uh good evening Board of Trustees and Dr contras my name is Su gry and I've been uh an employee in pvusd since 2010 I started as a teacher at new school and then became the coordinator of baa and gate for 6
190years and then now I have the honor of being the principal at New School Community Day School the best school in the whole District um I've also had the opportunity to work in several different states in several different um areas around the country so um California is new to me the budgeting in California is very new to me and um I mean if I could change anything I'd go way High um but that's above my pay grade um but I do want to say that I believe that all these varied positions over the years have given me um a good idea of how different districts run and and what what you need the process of being um part of this sustainable budget team was really interesting because going from the district well from a teacher
191to a district office I was I was also a laundry monitor at one point in my career that was my stting gig um anyway um it it really gave me another view of things that I didn't know about the district so I was really really grateful for that I thought the meetings were extremely well run um I think that um all of our voices were honored it's it's a tough thing to do anytime you have to cut I also um my family owns a music store back in Chicago area so I understand what it's like when you have to cut employees it's never fun and um it it's just a horrible thing so during our sustainable budget team we explored several options we had a lot of out of the box box thinking and we
192did float some really amazing ideas which are still memorialized so you guys can everybody can look back at them you can look at all the meetings I mean it's just it's really really hard excuse me thank you um teacher voice sorry um uh information was brought to us at every um meeting with and follow-up questions for me personally were always answered either before the meeting or um at the next meeting um the slides I'm pres presenting to you are not were not easy to come through um I will be quite transparent I was not there on the 10th where the 15th I was with my mother fell broke her hip dancing at ' 89 and so I was back with her um and uh so that's my goal 89 swing dancing teaching um but this
193was there has been a lot of information brought to us as this at the sustainable budget team both informal and formal and very hard to hear and nobody ever wants to have to make a judgment on somebody else's livelihood so without further Ado um here are the slides that I was asked to present and it is very hard to do so and I come humbly to you so right sizing um slide a so right sizing um is was would take us back to prepandemic um uh budget so um reducing the district office which has already been done academic coordinator right sizing so when we were presented to that am I supposed to talk this much about at all okay um sorry um I also was asked to speak this afternoon so um uh so the
194academic coordinator position right sizing Elementary re release ratios um right sizing 1.3 million I can go on forever about academic or Elementary release intervention reductions of 2.4 so obviously we found after the pandemic our students were very far behind uh things were brought in using onetime monies that and that was not a transparent process with a lot of people um reductions funded oh and then B is uh one time all onetime monies so the ele um a part of it is due to um the declining enrollment right so we don't have as many students we don't have as much money you don't need as many teachers Etc um okay then we have C oh gosh I'm sorry you guys we I did a and I didn't do B oh and you guys couldn't read what
195I was thinking sorry here's b um the mental health clinicians um which we all know that we needed and yeah anyway um so there's B like I said none of these were easy C we have again the element um mental health reduction Elementary um teacher uh release teacher right sizing academic coordinator position right sizing district office reductions and intervention so it's kind of a little bit of everything um option D social emotional counsel reduction mental health clinician reduction Elementary release time district office reduction and academic coordinator right sizing option e um was uh district office reductions which have already taken place elementary release right sizing intervention reductions mental health reductions um and that would be the total cost of the pvusd onetime mental health funding um and option e uh would go in for the
196next round um so like I said none of these options are great um I wish that I could become the governor and change everything in California but that's not going to happen anytime soon so um it is without further I'm going to introduce you to Richard who I had the opportunity to work side by side with through most the thank you good evening me sorry can you hear me good evening members of the board and most importantly ladies and gentlem behind me and those uh joining us uh online uh my name is Richie gray and I guess you all wondering why is there an English guy stood here well it's um I have a daughter who started uh TK uh this year we recently from San Diego where I retired from 25 years in the
197military sorry I made a lot of difficult decisions during my career but um non really amounted to the the pressure that we felt when we were looking at the uh concerns of um the community and the options that are sort of on the table now will stress within this that decisions made were based on the facts that we had available at the time and although you may look at and S 16 hours probably not doing due diligence but I can assure you that all those members of the board felt that it was an honor to serve on the board and then now some of us stood here me particularly at the end doing uh talking through the uh awful options um with a heavy heart because it's not something any of us wanted to do
198and I think echoing a lot of the team members it's um you know we were given a task and that to remind you all was to look towards a saving of 5 million ion over the next year with a warning that there'll be more the following year due to the reduction in uh enroll uh students Etc keep that's right okay so like most plans um we all went away having looked at options a through e and um you know we thought we don't really like those we let's play around with them if we can and um look at a hybrid options as such so we came back together on December 10th just P Christmas um we reviewed those options and a lot of the team members had had engaged in the community and their jobs
199that they do whether it be at school um where the students are Etc and it we were already starting to see the interest in this sustainable budget committee sort of being talked about and the sort of of what we're being asked to do um so after these meaningful discussions we looked at some sort of other type of options and uh those revisions as such and um I'm not going to read them out line by line I will give you a few seconds to look at them some you'll already see that are standard across all um options but then those at the top where you will see the sort of the variations as we look at what's possible or not possible to achieve so moving on really to the final recommendations again we came back then
200a week later almost a week later with more ideas having engaged with the community more having been spoke to in the playground or wherever it might be and you know there's obviously a lot of concern about this and when I turned up here tonight early and felt the passion in the room I thought fette Rich you going last what what's going to happen so you know when we look at all the options that address the the services and the support that the community needs and you know it needs them all but given the the way that things were funded and the needs to save money there was no choice but to look at difficult options so when we looked at these uh three options based on the sort of restrictions that we had we have
201these three recommendations as our final recommendations and you know I know there's a great concern about the mental health um sort of potential cuts that we're talking about and one thing that the team was certainly clear of is that all means possible should be investigated into what is available in mental health um more was added to the schools during the period of the pandemic and post pandemic because it was a recognized need but as I say the way it was funded unfortunately that can't continue but we know that perhaps some children may have health insurance some don't so you know let's make sure that those that do that we're getting that money back because there's not yet a process in place that as we understood it that was facilitating that and that's where a lot
202of this money could be recouped now as I say I'm not going to line by line this but one of the key areas that we all agreed on was regarding the pvpsa contract and it was agreed across the team that we should look to reduce that as much as possible with Shifting the money to the district uh hired mental health conditions um obviously the caveat in that is we didn't see the contract we don't know the contract and so there are Bounty of contractor imp implications in that but ultimately that was that was the piece where we thought we could do most with if allowed to do so and you know that would mean that we keep as many mental health conditions we can in schools H by the districts maintain the level or pandem
203pre-pandemic level of the uh social emotional C counselors you know and try to um already accepting the cuts that they're doing in the district office you know and I appreciate this you know we're playing with numbers and there's detail missing this there's no sort of you know what does one and a half million a equ in terms of number of positions and unfortunately team that's going to be down to you to really Pat out but um that is where we sort of landed difficult but it was great to form such a good team and um for me I've learned so much about the American education system in the last six months um I think there are things that could be done I don't understand if the target for 100 the target is 180 days that
204as a minimum well done we've made the minimum in terms of number of school days and and I looked at this because I'm like I never used to have two months off school when I was growing up we had six weeks so I think he used to refer to it as all all year school all arounds so um it's a case of you know do we look could we look at Shifting the calendar so that you know and we discussed this as a team there the students are in school when the air conditioning doesn't need to be used so rather than coming back in June and working through August where the hottest months they they go on holiday in July till the end of August and start in the fall in September so the the
205heating and cooling costs come down which would take time to see and there's the contractual issues with teachers etc etc but that's the sort of ideas we were asked to throw at a wall and see what sticks the time limit obviously of what you're faced with imminently is that that's where we land um for those that you know had the opportunity it's likely to happen again yesterday I commend it to you because it it's it certainly put me in touch with the community and it it's a great thing to learn about and then you will also understand the difficult decisions that people make you know I did hear in early comments of arriving early that you know it was a sort of bit of a Showboat you know bit of a scapegoat I can assure
206you I'm willing to talk with anybody Offline that i' take definite umbrage um for any member of the team that that is the case because it's not we're here presenting something that's extremely difficult and I do not envy your role so with that I hand over to the comments thank you [Applause] thank you very much um we will now move on to our public comments uh Trustin novaro will call you up in fives first up we have Bobby pels uh Omar Diez Christine Hong Dr lordes barazza and beton Court Corbin I'm sure there's like 30 s is it one minute one okay two it is two okay um [Music] two uh Bobby P wat High I'm here to speak on the propos cuts and mental health um you know reminded me of a debate we
207had uh earlier in the year about SRO and I remember that there was an argument that was made that that eliminating the SRO would put our students lives at risk and that was why the board insisted we have to keep SRO because God forbid we cut SRO and then something happens and a kid dies and you know that made me think of this and it made me think of you know well isn't this the same thing I mean it can't you make the same argument and because you know the CDC list the lead the second leading cause of death among young people is suicide and and and I think that you know uh cutting or funding to mental health will absolutely put our students lives at risk um even more so than than cutting uh
208uh sros I mean if you were to ask me I would say if you need funding from if you need to cut funding from our budget cut the SRO and redirect that funding to mental health support I mean we have lots and lots of research it says the return on investment in mental health is way much much much greater than uh uh any return you would get from having SOS on campus and I think it sends the wrong message that we would rather invest in control than invest in support um and and and personally I think that um uh uh cutting Mental Health Services is not just concerning and difficult it's also dangerous and and and you know we really would put students lives uh risk and I understand you know trying to right size
209and go back to pre- pandemic levels but the problem is is that the anxiety and the stress and the trauma that kids feel are not going back to pre pandemic level and so we can't reduce funding uh for something that's becoming even more of a problem than it was uh in the past in fact we really should be increasing the funding uh for mental health support but you know at the very least let's keep it where it is thank you [Applause] omz B needles why are we paying police to do a job that they were sworn in by the Constitution to Serve and Protect why are they double dipping why are we paying them for something they already swore to to do to protect the community uh if we were to cut the sro's that
210funding could go to to the elementary schools where I know the the uh mental health uh counselors are needed I work with juveniles I work with juveniles and and and what I'm coming to see and and I'm working with them in juvenile Halls I'm working with them in the streets in the community and what I'm coming to find out is that they have a lot of trauma behind what's going on in their lives I work for example with these two brothers right now that are dealing with uh not having a mother that's in prison their D their dad is dead and they have a lot of anger in them and they need healing so we need to keep our our our our mental health to to deal with these kind of cases to help them
211heal that's what we need to do is we need to heal our community we need to have healing for our for our youth it's important that we that we provide that uh and and we need to uh make sure you know these these contracts with these uh SRO are only in the high schools you know who's protecting our our our elementary students they don't get that protection the high schools do why don't they get it you know let's cut those SRO let's re redirect that money to bring more mental health uh into all our schools to help the schools and the students heal thank [Applause] you uh hello my name is Corbin xang bort I am a senior student student at opas high school and ask somebody who has had depression and nearly tried suicide
212I find it insulting disrespectful and infuriating that you would even suggest taking away Mental Health Services from my school and those who need it the mental health professionals at my school helped me a lot in fact if not for them I would be dead I would have committed suicide if not for their services so I demand you take mental health off the budget cut for their services will be an even higher demand especially from the lgbq plus community in the coming years As Trump takes office over 40% of trans adults and 30% of trans youth commit suicide and these numbers or have tried committing suicide and these numbers only climb higher if they are denied gender affirming care I mentioned these sta statistics as a Republican government will try Banning gender affirming care Nationwide and
213drive suicide rates up thus it is imperative that the mental health department stays funded if you wanted to fund something try the six figure salaries of those in the district office [Applause] instead I want to thank the committee who did this hard work um because it sounds like a lot of work so I want to thank them and I know that it's difficult um but I think it's really important to remember that for a child to succeed in school they need to have they need to be well mentally um and I noticed that the SRO were not on that list um I know some of the board members um especially on the previous board were really supporters of that but when you look at um you know it's like we had asked for what is
214the evidence that they're working we still haven't gotten that evidence it's an opinion it's a false sense of security that people get we have no evidence that it actually secures anything but we do know that when SRO gets paid $1 14045 an hour whereas a clinician a licensed clinician gets paid $44 an hour um so we can have three SRO I mean we can have three clinicians for one SRO so I would vote for that to get to get eliminated um and some of you have heard my title doctor I'm a clinical psychologist by the way this is why this is important to me um I actually work in crisis and I have seen an increase in kids with suicide depression and anxiety are so high and anxiety can drive people to suicide by the
215way um it is those are the two most common things that I've seen I've been working in mental health for almost 20 years after I became a teacher went back to school got my doctorate in Psychology in that time I have worked with um tons and tons of kids and families and the thing that I see consistently is anxiety and depression that just does not go away um so as those things increase um I I think we need to really think about other ways to cut um I was also thinking about a lot of the schools got money for Community Schools Maybe maybe you know they do have a lot of schools are working on having a social emotional Center maybe having some social workers and having families come to that they can that many
216can go to some of that as well um and let's see um on a side note uh well actually I would encourage everybody to write to the state let me finish this really quick I would encourage everybody to write to to the governor to the person who do does a and remind them as Mr Pelt said that while Co is gone the things that Co caused are not gone and we still need that funding and as my last note I know um president Flores and um trusty Dodge mentioned that you didn't like people mentioning names but I think that when people cause certain situations they need to be called out and that's the reason why I name people because three people have consistently created this as a problem and that's why I felt they needed
217to be called out [Applause] tekashi Mizuno sorry Maria Garcia Mark M tekashi Mizuno Christina Souza and Emily com Comet comedy hi me again um I wanted to I wanted to know why we have to take away money from the mental health um service section um it helps students like many other people said and um ages from 10 to 18 years old commit suicide as Mr pel said and it's the second most common reason why people are dying they're committing suicide and they're ending their lives and I think it's a big problem in our lives because it's not fair for students to just feel like they need to end their lives just because they're feeling this way and they just not feeling like they're being enough or they and I also heard that in Watsonville High
218School got two were in PB and Watsonville High School got two new golf carts I don't know where they got that money from but it sounds like we got money so it it's kind of confusing we have four golf carts we had two already and they're brand new we got them like what like a year ago and now we have two more it's a little confusing I don't know if they got some adap toss or something but um that's what really confuses me I so if that if we have new golf carts where's all this money coming from if you guys could answer that question if you guys have any sort of ideas or if they got it from their own money or something it has their logo on it so I'm guessing it's from
219the school um and I don't think it's fair for you to take away our health department just because of that like take it from something else instead of that because we we have four golf carts they don't they don't use they use it to go around the school they don't actually use it for like helping people like when somebody's getting into a fight they run they don't like go in a golf cart and like go over there they run they go running and they're like they separate them they don't go in a golf and then they you know like I I just think it's not really fair for you guys to take it away thank you [Applause] I have recently been informed by teachers and counselors that there has been a new budget that is
220being discussed this budget is concerning because it will risk schools losing their Wellness Center that helps many students who struggle with mental health as a student who has struggled with mental health for most of their lives this is difficult for me to hear put yourself in my shoes imagine you go to school after feeling horrible at home because you have been dealing with your mental health you can't reach out for your family for help to your family because you come from a family who doesn't believe in such a thing as mental health your only home can help you so you remember you have a social emotional counselor at home you need the help so you ask for help only to find out due to the recent budget that was approved by District the help you
221need is Gone without the help you need without the help you thought you had you feel helpless imagine students who struggle like me or denied the only help because the district decided to cut the only resources you needed are we trying to raise the suicide rate if you are then get out of the board because your mission statement is to support students in learning how can students learn when their mental health is worsening because they don't have a SA safe place to go please don't approve this budget as a student who struggles a student who knows the struggle and is still trying is still is currently trying to get hope and grow thank you hello board thank you for hearing us today and thank you everyone for being here and supporting and coming out and
222staying long um this is so important I don't even know what I'm going to say anymore cuz I threw my speech away after I got those numbers I am my name is Christina Souza I'm social emotional counselor this is my 10th year in that position at PB USD I was so proud to um come to a school come to a school district that actually had the foresight to create these positions of social emotional counselors and realize we were at the Forefront this was before anyone knew what seal was I was just coming from getting my master and my Master's thesis was on sustainable seel K12 the research is overpowering on the impacts that a sustainable K12 secl program a comprehensive program has on academics on College goinging on test scores it goes on and on
223if a student is not well they cannot learn if they don't feel safe they cannot learn if they don't have a person a community somebody at the school that they know will be there for them they can't learn and that's not really the worst thing that can happen them not learning right we all understand that it is not the worst thing that can happen serious things happen students do take action on wanting to end their lives they share that with us they we've made space for them there's been space made by the social emotional counselors and the mental health clinicians especially the gened mental health clinicians there's being space made at this current time for these students who are seriously concerned about their mental health and don't know who to go to or who is
224safe right now we have those positions and they are in place please don't take them away I know these are hard budget decisions but our students cannot learn if they are not well thank [Applause] you hi good evening my name is Emily cmet I'm a social emotional counselor at two Elementary sites I was also previously a teacher I've been in the district for 15 years and I'm also a parent of a student in the district I'm here here tonight cuz I'm highly concerned about the recommendations by the sustainable budget committee first off obviously with the amount of support here the number one priority is students we provide access so they can access their learning and curriculum if they are disregulated suicidal thoughts trauma grief we provide the supports so that they can be in school
225so that they can attend and so that they can access their learning they cannot do that if they do not have these types of services one reason I'm very concerned about the sustainable budget committee recommendation is in one of the meetings on December 16th they said that the children's youth behavioral initiative the fee schedule they weren't ready to do that pbsd is one of the first of 47 local education agencies that in January 2004 became and got access to these fees to be able to charge for all of the services that social emotional counselors and mental health PS provide it was also noted that the fee schedule would not recoup the same money or we would not get the same amount of dollars and on the fee schedule it is exactly comparable to what medical
226billing is in the health industry so I'm very confused about that information that was provided on the December 16th meeting additionally sorry number four was mental health and their priorities there were three underneath that and yet mental health is in cuts to all of the options that's a huge concern pbsa lastly pvpsa has a $2 million contract we service I service about 30 to 50 students a week I have one intern at each site they see five students a week the same five students for the entire school year I'm very concerned about these Cuts I feel that we provide necessary services to our students and I want to encourage the board to reject the sustainable budget committee recommendations thank [Applause] you can you understand what I said K it's in Japanese good evening I I
227tested you anyway oh first of all yeah I'd like to say thank you very much to miss Olia Flores you said you oron that's amazing yeah thank you very much and I be through my research I was amazed that there have been so many people in pahar who have American Indian DNA not onlyon but Cher so many people it's amazing yeah and you are also indigenious and I'm also indigenous from Japan yeah Japanese has about 10 or 30% of the any indigenous people that's what I learn recently and culturally I have become more and more indigenous these days and one of the things which I have learned from American Indians that when we make decisions we need to think about seven generations back and seven generations forward this is important this is wisdom so and
228I also mentioned in one of both meetings that we need to consider think about generational trauma there are so many people have suffered from generational trauma so we really need counselors so please think about it thank [Applause] you is Mark m still here Mark next that okay um Bobby maresal Carrie Goodwin Matt Merill Susanna lstaff and Nat L hello board uh yeah I just I'll start by acknowledging we got a it's it's a really tough position and so oh hello um yes um it's a hard decision we're we're in a horrible spot you are in and we are in um and I want to thank all those who are on the team because that's a lot of time they put in I appreciate all their work I am a teacher of a what I consider
229a core subject who Happ to provide release and I'm also a parent in our district and um I watch some of the Full meetings not all unfortunately it's a lot of time maybe I'll eventually get to it I'm gon to try um but I don't know how you do this without considering some of the FTE and I I hear what you're saying there but but I that's a struggle for me uh I have questions that I hope will be asked about right sizing release teachers $1.3 million there um we talked about the top priorities being teaching and learning and then second was vapa and I don't know how you do that first of all without cutting vapa teachers and your release are music art PE and science which are all not only valuable because they
230provide release but they're valuable important subjects and so I think to just call it release really doesn't give it the weight that it deserves and like what are we actually cutting if we do that um I understand Esser is sunsetting as it's been said many times the effects of Co are not um and just going back to 2019 isn't the best way because it's not 2019 okay we need more mental health support has been talked about um I Echo why have why were sro's not presented how did we decide what was presented to the team why was that not a discussion and in the same way uh we're we're making hard decisions we know that I don't want to see any schools closed any more than anybody else that being said why was this not
231part of the conversation because there are questions about weighing that against getting rid of mental health clinicians right like if we have to do that but it gives our students what they need I I don't like that decision but why was that not part of the conversation I think those questions uh need to be asked um I uh you know there's a tension within me cuz I do appreciate a lot of our admin in in in the towers and at the same time I know we have some great teachers who if we just got out of their way they'd kick some butt and and so I I think 1.7 million there when we've got 2.5 and mental health is not enough we got to look at more positions there as hard as that is to
232say good luck thanks I do I do just want to clarify that the reason why the positions that were discussed and the programs that were discussed is because all we looked at were things that were added with onetime funding dollars and so the sro's were not added with one-time funding Sr dollars that came out of general fund in the past actually came from a grant good evening my name is Carrie Goodwin I am a social emotional counselor teachers and parents will tell tell you we are an intrical component of a functioning school we know our students are coming to us with a level of need never seen before and as such the budget team prioritized mental health as fourth most important out of seven yet the choices provided them were swayed towards these very Cuts
233these very supports we social emotional counselors are accessible in real time without barriers to serve students our district spends my understanding is 2.4 million on how social emotional counselors I provide Direct Services to 28% of my site students if we use that data as a basis it means SE counselors are costing the district $489 per student served my understanding is PV psa's contract is 1.5 million working with 2% of our students this essentially means we are paying $4,285 per student served by pvpsa 10 times more expensive in addition we spend hours on each student we attempt to refer often resulting in a failed handoff my most recent referral of a second grader took two months to complete despite the fact that the intern had space our mtss team deemed the student appropriate for the support
234and the parent was in agreement the parent states she returned the agency phone calls three times and still could not get a hold of the proper person to complete the family intake when I informed pvpsa of this their reply was that they had have been super busy and have not had time to check voice messages in days again we SE counes are accessible in real time without barriers to serve students at on10th of the cost per student served finally I call out the decades long practice of our superintendent serving on the pvpsa board while simultaneously giving fiscal recommendations to the pvusd board in the best interest in the best interest of our students I ask you to eliminate the pvpsa contract and continue your investment in social emotional [Applause] [Music] counselors good evening pvusd board
235my name is Matt Merill I'm the mental health clinician at Renaissance High School um I was hired in 2019 as was the first nons mental health clinician Ms is a mental health clinician for our special ed students um like Christina said um I've been so proud of our district for valuing and recognizing the importance of mental health and it's hard to come up here and not sound over dramatic about what we do but what we do is very serious and I'm not going to come up here and tell you stories of how serious it is but I promise you it's a big deal um to the budget committee I want to say personally thank you for all the the time you put in all the work you put in I wish we could have been
236there for them to provide accurate information we came to one of the public meetings and we were not allowed in the room so we were there to provide you information and I'm sorry that you couldn't get it um this is a big decision please think of the students when you make it thank [Applause] you my name is Susanna lstaff I'm a special ed teacher at appas Junior High School and I just want to emphasize that our social emotional counseling team they're the heart of our school with our wonderful admin they have a collaborative relationship they have relationships with students like they're available whenever they're needed and they also have relationships with staff and so I learned so much from my communications with them my my problem solving with them I'm a better special education teacher
237because of our wonderful social emotional team and um so please I'm glad that the budgeting team is reduce considering redu ction in in the contract with pvpsa because I see that the relationship between our social emotional on-site counselors is just so important um and and thank you again for your work and these hard deliberations that you're doing for students for our community and for us as district and school thank [Applause] you hi um net L area SE I just want to affirm that mental health clinicians and counselors need to be prioritized even amid the Steep budget cuts that need to be made teaching and learning was listed as the first priority of the committee and I want to say that education and learning is something that can only be done when students other basic needs
238are met so just like a hungry student will struggle to will struggle to learn students who are housing insecure will struggle to learn students whose basic mental health and social emotional needs are that are not supported will also struggle to learn um you've heard the students talk about how you know their school counselors and clinicians are crucial for saving lives and for students to learn they have to be alive we need to make mental and social emotional health a priority on the same level as other basic needs so even as we have to figure out other budget cuts I hope that you do your very best to keep as many of these critical supports as possible and I heard that um the sustainable budget committee was only given the option of cutting items that had
239one-time funding um but the school finances were already going under before the pandemic um finances came into save them so why was the committee not given the option of scrutinizing the budget practices from before that time in this process um I also want to you know Echo um the calls for like the cost effectiveness of SRO and like wonder if we can also be building stronger community supports and relationships with Community mentors to supplement some of those social most needs like you know organizations like baros unidos and Mila who are already in our communities already supporting our students um so let's figure out together as a community how to prioritize this thank you uh Laura zaro kayn Wright Eli Davies Selena V Mary Helen Orga Montero can I can I ask if you guys can
240call she the last student here which oh I'm sorry yes of course [Applause] yes apologies there's no indication of which ones are students uh no it's okay I just hope my phone doesn't die because it's at 10% um well I'm going to leave soon so um hi good evening my name is yeli Garcia I'd like to speak about how you guys are trying to cut people's jobs jobs and what hurts me more trying to cut mental clinicians jobs everyone here can agree that there has been a lot of suicides in our community not only in our community but in the world most of the times is because they are not diagnosed in time and that is with mental clinicians on campus just imagine how many suicides there could and will be without mental clinicians on
241campus we all have our ups and our Downs most Downs are in school for me most Downs are in school due sorry due to many reasons but one of them being bullying why because you guys can't stop bullying bullying according to you guys wait according to you guys um our community is a safe space but is it really bullying has happens in every grade but in my case in every grade literally every grade for me um and I won't get into detail about my personal life but I will say mental health clinicians have to be here for me for our students and for many other people in our future you guys expose us to sorry you guys expose us to people we shouldn't have to be dealing with such as child Predators I won't say
242names nor anything else but I will say say you I will tell you guys the first persons that were there to help me with the people I had to be with and the Predator I had to deal with with my mental health clinicians all I'm saying now is that if it wasn't because my mental health clinicians in my school I would not be standing here [Applause] if you guys are willing if you guys are willing to expose us to that type of people I expect you guys to be willing to give us the support that we need which is by your mental health clinicians thank [Applause] you you recogniz me are there any other students here thank you so much for your words have a good night good luck at school okay so oh sorry
243go that's okay good Laura hi thank you um I'm really visual is it possible to get the slide up with the um number 28 okay great thank you um yeah and I I'm Laura aaro I'm a um Elementary School educator at ha Height Elementary uh I've taught third and fourth grade and now I'm a reading intervention teacher but that was that's funded through something different prior to covid um and I do want to I've been on other boards before but I've never had to make decisions like this before um and I want to thank the the whole committee and and the district because I've been working in this District for 30 years it's never been this transparent ever and I just really really appreciate that um that a committee was formed and they've gone through
244so many hours and um I'm just reminding you as a board first of all just thank you for being here I do appreciate it and I did email all of you um a letter about keeping the AC's and um and I wasn't I had questions about the release time um right sizing and I did get a response from Gabriel and Olivia but and and Jessica for some reason your email just didn't go through I don't know if you I'm saying this just as information not to throw you under the bus or anything but um it got kicked back and it's a pvusd email and I'm not sure if it's it's obviously not correct cuz I had two people check it so just to let you know cuz I know you want to be very accessible
245and I don't have Instagram but um I just want you to know that the this isn't a hard stop this is a part of a Continuum and um you're almost there I mean we're almost at the at the end of the road and I appreciate the process immensely but the AC's and the I knew this was going to happen dang it um the academic coordinators have been around since school started like back in the 1900s I mean I'm exaggerating but um they've been around forever way before Co and they've absorbed just read my letter okay just read it um it's detailed and it's not melodramatic but try to it feels like a hunger game right now but really try to get the social emotional counselors and the AC's and the I I don't know what
246right sizing release ratio means okay thank you um but if you didn't get my email I'm at ha Hyde Laura aaro at PB usd.net thank you thank you very much for [Applause] your hi good evening my name is kayin Wright I'm a mental health clinician over at Watsonville High School um thank you all for being here um thank you to the um the committee that was put together as well I know that it's a really difficult decision also thank you to the board members that took the time to um meet with us to communicate with us via email um to hold Town Halls um all of those things don't go unnoticed and so we really appreciate it um I recall close to 10 years now um graduate school Professor telling me that he believed that
247the future of Mental Health Services was going to be in schools and at the time um I had never worked in schools despite my mom being a um School administrator um but I didn't really know what he meant at the time but after working for the district for the P past three years I know exactly what I meant what he meant and that the closer we are to the potential people that we're going to serve the higher likelihood that they're going to receive the services that they need and anybody in this room that works in mental health or Works in our district knows that a significant portion of the referrals that go out to Community Partners never get taken up they get lost in transition they don't get calls that go through to them they
248get passed on to National agencies for telea health and this happens on a regular basis and I don't mean this to throw any of our Community Partners out of the bus they are absolutely needed the reality is the need is huge it's huge and it's more than can be met with our Community Partners and with the people that are working for our schools in fact my wife is currently a um a intern at one of those agencies I respect immensely what they do and of the four referrals that I put into outside agencies um not one of them received services and this was in the fall not one of them received services within a two-month period of time and students were regularly coming to me and asking me like what do I do and I
249would communicate with them like Reach Out call and so that's a major concern for me is that um the reality is that if we cut these positions there will be students that will not receive Mental Health Services as a result thank you [Applause] Eli thanks Eli area 7 uh looking at the question of oh well we need to get back to like 2019 money if you Google cost of living 2019 versus 2024 cost of living has increased by 25% like the the dollar of 2019 cannot live in the dollar of today I understand that there are things you're working with you know actual California Nome whatever I mean we are dealing with the of capitalism uh right here and the the needs that cannot be met um but I do want to advocate for mental
250health uh reiterate what we heard about um High suicide rates suicidality amongst queer and trans kids um and and of course all all the kids and all their mental health matters and we're looking at a very specific political moment going into 2025 going into the presidency of trump going into uh uh policies that in greatly increase the um lack of quality of life of queer kids uh of trans kids and uh we can't I mean I just want to say I looked up pvpsa the board of directors and and I do see some familiar faces um but the president of that board uh I saw uh you know being very close with former trustee SoDo who on his last day said you know stop the woke agenda so we need to look at how there
251is a conservative like push to remove social emotional learning how it coincides with this moment what uh you know organizations are taking up funding which you know what counselors are getting pushed out um in if we're if this is just the onetime money from Co um yeah and it does feel like the sustainable budget people are being thrown under the bus I will see [Applause] that um good evening uh thank you for everybody who's stuck around for this but I'm just going to go ahead and start with this you can't achieve your dream if you don't show up to chase them some of these kids don't bother to show up to school because they're not in the right mental state to show up to school in the first place and that's simply it I work
252with two elementary schools and I have kids who refuse to come to school I work with them I've refer them over and it's just not the same Capa to the same capacity um I have been at my sites for 3 years and in those three years I have built Community there pvpsa comes in um with interns different interns every single year they like my colleagues have mentioned they only see five kids and that can be the same five kids in a school year that's ridiculous because us as social emotional um counselors and mental clinicians um we do so much more than just oneon-one we do whole group whole um small group whole classroom uh whole school sometimes right but um I'm coming to you today as one of your counselors but I'm also here to
253remind you of your your District mission statement right which is that you are committed to cultivating and nurturing environment where every student thrives a nurturing uh academically socially and emotionally empowering them to flourish in a dynamic and evolving world so how is that going to happen if our positions are reduced or in the case of our mental conditions they're practically going to be gone thank [Applause] you sorry I needed a minute thank you hello everyone good evening my name is Mary Helen Orga Montero I'm a social emotional counselor for the school district at the elementary level and I concur with all of my colleagues at the High School level and at the elementary level as well as other supporters uh to the social emotional counselor position the mental health district employed mental health employees um
254I'm one of the oldest in the group of social emotional counselors I was one of the first hired 10 years ago at the elementary level so I believe I've earned my stripes to say what I need to say to the board today and with all due respect I offer it to you to consider um it seems there has been some misunderstanding as to the work responsibilities and the extremely vital role of the social emotional counselor I will attempt to clarify the details to fill them in several years uh pre pandemic or preco I have 10 years of seniority as one of the first Elementary level social emotional counselors in The District 12 years in the district and it has been a blessing in several ways to be employed by the school district to clarify um
255a student cannot perform in any subject core or extracurricular if the student has a mental health or social emotional block we all know that again a student cannot perform in the extracurricular or academic classroom if they have a social emotional block and I don't think that any of us can do that as well I would like to kindly clarify the responsibilities of the social emotional counselor at the elementary level 2. five days at each site when I first started we had one day for four sites we had a balance four schools and one week now it's been two and a half days for two sites so we still need one counselor at each site there's enough demand there um also I'd like to say that unfortunately many of our Community Partners do not provide bilingual
256Services many of our social emotional counselors are bilingual we reflect the student population we address their concerns not only with the students but with the parents thank you so much I'm sorry that's been two minutes thank you I appreciate your time Chris Webb Eric s Tatiana Cerna Monica Nolan Nelly vaka Brandon Y and Marilyn Garrett um I want to thank the sustainable budget team for all their work um I thought the caring members of that team brought great ideas and I hope the committee um continues to meet and follow up on those ideas I feel like the the their part their the things they generated didn't get enough um attention and also the things that they brought up could have mitigated the need to make some painful Cuts cuts that are you know left kids
257crying in the hallway here um also I in addition to like the whole money thing I keep thinking back to like when um Sheriff Hart promised that for SRO it wouldn't be an issue right that he would pay that that they would pay for at least the EPS one so I feel like we should get um like a reimbursement check on that a cut on the sros entirely um also um another thing is like in terms of out of the boox thinking um have we considered you know I one thing I felt over the over time is like that the value of like good principles and then um I'm a big believer at like being in the classroom like helps that so you know there's there's times when principles are out or or assistant principles
258are out is it possible that maybe maybe we have like a somebody who has a position that's like uh Point 2 teaching and then the rest is like you know administrator of some kind some type of AC type position U have we thought of that also um I know in the in when you're coming St th us you were said we don't really have the expertise to oversee some of these programs and the counselors and and that one kind of hit me in that um like Renaissance had some major restructuring be because of one of the one of the persons who was overseeing the counselors and who's not even there anymore and so when you said that I was like man we like have hurt and um it's and in in a way the the
259hurting caused like some inefficiencies where we're not where there was like more redundancy than there had to be so I feel like we need to like really get at the ground level what what really works at each site thank [Applause] you uh hi like others here I want to express my concern about the proposed cuts to school school counselors mental health clinicians and release teachers as well as the broader allocation of resources in our district these positions are crucial for our supporting our students well-being and educational success and I urge you to reconsider any reductions school counselors and mental health clinicians provide vital social emotional support especially in a time when our students are facing significant mental health challenges and I'm sure if you were to talk to anybody around you they're probably generally not
260having a good time most of my colleagues are really struggling as well students have a hard time especially my elementary school students have a hard time advocating for themselves it's really on us to be able to like identify when they need some support and I want to give a shout out to ignasio Alvarez who is the social emotional counselor at my school site um he's scrapping every day over two sites um just spread thin and doing his best and leading um Talk circles really helping our students and it would just be a disservice to all of them if like his position were to be cut and I'm sure it's the same across other sites um also important are those released teachers who support classroom Educators by ensuring they have time needed for lesson planning and
261effective classroom management these roles are not luxuries they're necessary for sustaining high quality instruction and preventing teacher burnout also ask that you look closely at other areas in the district where funds may be misallocated or overly inflated specifically I'd urge you to consider reducing high administrative costs including the excessive stiens for directors and other high level administrators who take a disproportionate share of the budget additionally I'm deeply concerned about the continued funding for school resource officers the cost of these officers is significant but there's little evidence to suggest they improve student safety or contribute meaningfully to educational environment these funds could be better spent on initiatives that directly address student needs thank you thank [Applause] you hi my name is Tatiana CNA I am a a resource parent a foster parent in this County and
262I work with neurodiverse children in this community um in this school district social emotional counselors are one of the very few supports that are available to youth with trauma it is extremely significant that this trauma is addressed because it impacts not only the students who who have experienced the trauma but also their peers in their classroom who can be disrupted or put in danger if these traumas are not addressed um children who have experienced trauma include many Foster Youth and neurodiverse students um according to this presentation the district lcap goals include number three supporting Foster Youth and number four supporting students with special needs in my my experience the schools in this district will deny access to an IEP and increased accommodations on the grounds that trauma is causing these behavioral issues um as a
263result of that the soci emotional counselors are one of the only supports available to these children who receive trauma I've also experienced that schools will insist that parents or caregivers pick up their children early daily or stay in the classroom daily because they're not equipped to handle these special needs or traumas that are experienced and I mean this is not a oneoff I have had four encounters with this kind of thing where students are sent home early or they're just not supported and soci emotional counseling is one of the only things that they receive consistently um one of the very few supports available to neurodiverse and traumatized youth in this district is at risk of being eliminated I personally had a six-year-old oh okay thank you for your [Applause] time is okay I thought I
264was last I'm usually last interesting so what a breath of fresh air you new trustees are the whole feeling of the meeting is so much more pleasant I it's just unbelievable and the testimony of the social mental counselors what gems what professional care earning Personnel that are really required I can think of money that is not providing for a safe healthy and positive School environment like all the wifi microwave radiation Broadband um all the fences around the schools that make them look like prisons the SRO money you talk about evidencebased data look into the adverse effects of the microwave radiation depression learning disability fatigue headaches this room's difficult to be in for me and what are causing suicides there are many factors here's an article Japanese researchers say side effects of covid vaccines linked to
265200 1 types of diseases just to read a little Professor Fukushima said there were so many brain related adverse effects his researchers probably hadn't found all of them yet mental disorders psychiatric symptoms depression Mania anxiety came up in abundance but it's endless he said check out globalresearch.ca Michelle chowski this article is by Lee Harding of January 2024 thank [Applause] you okay Brandon Denise negotiations chair for the pvft I want to start off with a couple literal Hot Tips the first hatot tip is to the board and specifically to Olivia Flores for the way this meeting is being conducted I recognize that none of us want to be here super late but I think by allowing the community to speak you can just feel the tension toned down and it makes a difference when the board
266president isn't banging the gavel left and right so thank you for that and I also want to tip my cap to the sustainable budget team members um I was the one who came up and said that it felt like a charade and that's not any targeting to those specific members it's speaking to the data that they were presented sometimes I come up here and I talk in nu I talk in talking points and the Nuance is often lost in that previous board member actually called me a prick because of that so I just wanted to point out that I feel the data that was presented to the team could have been better we have a contract with a group titled fiscal crisis and management assistant team fmat so I would like the board to discuss
267amongst yourself and ask the question were any recommendations from fmat involved in this process at all I know this semester they're going to be looking into the Sela but if we have a contract with the fiscal crisis management team we should really take their input into consideration I also would urge the board to postpone any decisions until the vacant board seat is filled so that we can have true representation from all of our trustee areas this is too important to make a decision now um our district has a healthy budget Reserve I recognize that we cannot continue deficit spending because somewhere down the road we will hit rock bottom but we don't need to make a decision today so I encourage you to not make a decision in haste and prioritize our students mental health
268support so much has been said about that that I'm not going to harp on on that but we our students are looking to us to make decisions to benefit their future and let's make the right choices so thank [Applause] you oh Monica Allan sorry can you pull up slide 10 I was going to ask you in advance but I'm all over the place um I was going to leave which is why I made comments earlier but I am so involved tonight um and so I just want us to look at slide 10 as a group right we're talking about the goals the pre previous young lady that was somewhere in here beautiful hair um she was commenting on Foster youth is on here but I think we can all agree right anyway I was like
269let's talk and dive into how every single one of these mental health would be impacted we know this um and so I like closed my eyes and took a deep breath and was like where did I learn to even close my eyes and take a deep breath from a mental health clinician that I worked with at APS high when I was an office manager um or sorry social emotional it's actually Christina in the back and Christina um I was the office manager at appas high for five years and now I'm the academic counselor at New School actually the three schools listed at the bottom there um and so and I work hand inand with you know when I worked at AAS High I didn't know anything about mental health because I came from a small
270town that didn't understand how to deal with a loud mixed race woman and and then I came to abas and bajaro and Watsonville and I was like wow I found my place and I could only imagine our kids that get to have that and then it's removed and I'm a 35-year-old woman sitting up here crying because I I feel so much for them and I know what it feels like to be marginalized and um to not have the people there again very small town Turlock California look it up it's not a great place to be um and my friends are still there though I love them anywh who so you I'm saying it because maybe we've all seen a therapist maybe some of us in this room we've had the privilege to pay for that
271our kids their families they don't always they're not educated on this culturally my dad would never have said go see a therapist so we need these people cuz they're for free they're in the room they want to do it and they're amazing so thank you [Applause] all good evening board um sorry I'm really tired I'm burned out I was in Sacramento and drove here so um my name is Nell vetta president pbft uh and I was on the sustainable budget Comm committee um and frustrated throughout all of it and and if you watch those committee meetings you heard me um and and I don't need to reiterate what our professional all the professionals behind me who came up and spoke um uh you know to the role of being a social emotional counselor or mental
272health clinician um one of the things that I spoke about at the sustainable budget committee meetings is that this district is deciding to um make austerity measures on the backs of our students on the mental health of our students um and pvpsa doesn't serve all of our students you could ask any teacher who has uh worked in our district for years and had to experience referring students to pvpsa and there is a struggle story our social emotional counselors and mental health clinicians are here today every day for all of the students at the sites that they're serving in 2019 2020 this District contributed to pvpsa just about half a million dollars so we want to use the argument of well pre pandemic no no right because pre pandemic oh pre- pandemic for social emotional mental
273health clinicians employed in this District ble let's give close to $3 million to pvpsa so this year pvpsa is um set to receive like about $2.5 million so a $2 million increase so this is inclusive of there used to be monies that was given to pvpsa and from that money they had to pay out other resources now the district gives them the money and additional Monies to pay those other resources you as trustees we have an additional 3% Reserve in our ending Reserve balance that's um like it's an addition you as trustees can make a motion to take some of that money and set it aside for social emotional and mental health clinicians for like another year or two while we look at what's happening to our budget here in California part of my conversation
274today was um talking about the budget and it's yes we have I I want to acknowledge all of our not only our brothers and sisters in the c um CFT that are affected impacted in Los Angeles by these um traumatizing fires but all the families um impacted and schools there are schools that are closed um so yes there's going to be some impact but there's still a promise to fund public education as best they can and this decision what is presented we the pbft are not we don't stand for that this is horrible and and there is another way you are being taxed with giving this this District based on we gave everybody time to talk about it this committee and we had wonderful conversations and they're and they're tough but then here's the menu
275of choices we're going to make you choose from thank you Nelly yeah but you have other means but this is what you're being asked as a blueprint for layoffs [Applause] thanks okay I believe that is our last public comment so now we will move on to our board discussion I am going I know we all want to speak so I'm just going to start with trusty Daniel Esa and then move down the board uh skipping myself CU I'll go at the end thank you thank you president Flor and I just wanted to thank the sustainable budget team for all their work um that they did but with that being said I will have a list of questions for them so who's ever welcome to come up here and you know if they have any answers
276to the questions because they will be directed yeah okay um some of them were just to the team but um I was disappointed that mental health was ranked fourth and I think that completely contradicts the team Norms um about assuming positive intent and I just wanted to ask ask what is the intention of you know how would there be a positive intent about cutting these services I don't know if there is anyone in the mental come toting okay I'll answer for everyone uh so the the Norms that were created by the sustainable budget team were norms for Behavior within the meeting so that when someone was speaking we wanted to make sure that we were always listening to anyone thoughts or um the way their approaches with that they were coming at it with a
277positive intent so that that's what that was okay and then another thing going back to the October 16th presentation um there was a list of um I don't know if it's possible to pull that up but there was a list of Sr funding programs that um such as LC stma food what um the Latino youth Film Institute LIF lab um parent engagement Wellness Center Virtual Academy and all those were Sr fundings but none of them are included in the recommendations so I was just curious about that if you know any of them that that is a good question uh part of what we were doing during each of those sustainable budget team meetings was to educate um the sustainable budget committee and anyone who was tuning into the meetings on here's here's what we chose
278the services the contracts just everything that we chose to do with our one-time funding uh even including we have had many um projects at schools and things like that so in that particular meeting we were looking at our different consultant contracts that we had through one-time funding and all of those are contracts that are sunsetting naturally because they were like a one-year contract that was not being renewed or a three-year contract that has one year left and so those were ones that were um not a topic really for discussion in terms of is this something we want to continue or not continue because they're naturally sunsetting themselves but it's just to educate people on here are the things we engaged in um additionally some of those do continue to be contracts in our district however
279they move from being funded through Esser dollars into other funding sources mainly through our Extended Learning programs because it fits the mission of the Extended Learning programs and a lot of those supports are like um not academics so are things that we want to engage students in but outside of the school day okay thank you for that and um another thing I know was said in the beginning of the presentation was um we're not experts and I know this was the first run of the sustainable budget team but I think moving forward it would be helpful if we would have more experts you know just at the table um whether that's you know more mental health clinicians at the um out the table or basically just you know expanding and giving more seats to the
280people and stakeholders who um are affected by these um it's obviously extremely unfortunate yeah that we're dealing with this um but I think collectively as a board we're going to work together to do what's best for students but I just don't think cutting the mental health services that as a district we've strived um for in the last recent years it would negatively impact all of us and I can speak this for the students that I've met with and they're deeply alarmed by all these and I know at school um a lot of teachers are concerned we have teachers here from AP House High also representing and teachers from you know just all over the district um and yeah I just hope that you know I have trust in the board to make the right decision
281but um I think that's all for now thank [Applause] you so I have to say that I spent about two hours with Dr contus talking about this because it's actually something I feel pretty strongly about because of what I do for a living um the needs of our pediatric mental health are not met by the community at any by any of the outside Services um I'm on the physician board for ccah and one of the biggest struggles that they have is finding mental health for Pediatric patients I've had suicidal ped pediatric patients in my department for over a week because there were no impatient beds um there is a stigma in the in the next Community um it's a generalization but for receiving mental health uh I think that meeting kids where they are which
282they spend most of their day at school is actually probably the best place to do this and I understand that we're in the education business and not in the mental health business but you I agree with a lot of the support in the room that states that you can't really learn if you're not addressing the mental health um we have a lot of traumatized students not just from covid but just intergenerational trauma as somebody brought up um you know parents who are in other you know still in other countries uh living with family or friends um you know parents that are incarcerated uh living in cars you know I see I hear terrible stories every day um I wish growing up that something like this would have been available to me um and you know
283it's not it's not 2019 anymore and I understand that you know trying to find ways to cut budgets is is really tough and these are some really really hard decisions um you know unfortunately we as people when we're making a budget for our house have to decide you know sometimes do we pay the electricity bill or you know are we laid on the rent and so we are going to have to make hard decisions and I want to just thank the sustainable budget committee for all the hard work that you did I'm a little disappointed to hear that you felt like you didn't have all the information that you needed um I would beg ask if maybe we can try to give this another stab because unfortunately all three options have cutting mental health which
284doesn't really give me much of a choice in this um one of the things that I had mentioned to Dr contras is because I'm on the CCH board you know what I was trying to get a better handle on how we build for these Services um you know I've met with one of the mental health clinicians and found that basically the person that oversees is not a mental health clinician because that's we're we're not in the mental health business we're in the education business and it's just kind of how the school district works and I think you know some Creative Solutions about maybe partnering with CCH to try to find something on that I just feel like we need a little bit more time to explore other options rather than making a decision on cutting
285mental health because I agree with most of the speakers in the room that it's probably one of the number one most important issues for our students post pandemic and just with the world with social media with you know politics with you know what with the unknown in our community um I would I don't know what one question I have for you Dr contras is what is our contractual obligation with pvps say and when does it sunset Jenny do you have that can you pull that up so we make sure we give that accurate yes so for pvpsa our current contract um goes through the end of this school year until June 30th uh 2025 and what is our total budget for pvpsa for the 2425 budget it's just under $2 million okay so you know
286I I would like to see I mean everything that I've heard from emails to stories in this room is that Community partner in particular does not seem to be meeting the needs of our students and I would personally like to see more Cuts there over cutting the people that are seeing our students every day um and then I would also like to maybe see some work on improving the reimbursement um making sure that I what I learned from the mental health clinician was they don't really have much training on timely documentation and how to code and how to build and that's actually my expertise and so you know bringing somebody in that can maybe help our mental health clinicians and social emotional counselors actually get reimbursed for their services and you know everything life's negotiation
287CCH currently is unable to meet the obligation for Pediatric mental health and if you already have the systems in place I think there's a negotiation there to be had to improve the funding so that perhaps we don't have to make as drastic Cuts going forward thank [Applause] you trusty Dodge um I also too would like to thank the budget team you know you guys were put in a in a difficult situation um you know Mrs yena I know you didn't do this lightly because you are from this community and I know the love you have for this community you know I I always tell people like who is this Mrs Adena who is this Mrs yena and I I tell people during the floods when the people were sent to the fairgrounds for some reason
288monter County turned away a lot of stuff and they they turned around they turned away food water clothes I know because I was there and I saw it and trusty Olivia Flora is there and uh you know we need to made the decision just give everything to the people and for some reason when Moder County said we can't have this people sent all the the extra materials to your private business and I just wanted to acknowledge you and thank you for being on the budget team um also to you know hearing a lot of we're not sure about this item we're not sure about this type of information um at this time I don't think I could support any of these options you know we hear about we hear about pvpsa but we're not seeing
289that on any of these options so I would like to see if we can get that option I mean you know they say there's $2 million I mean we need an option where you know they provide services but we got to at least try to keep these people here that in our schools every day I do want to note that the board is free to make their own recommendations as well so I just you know hearing that not everybody got the information I think we need to go back one more time and whether to looking at the contract um looking at other positions in management I know if I've sent you recommendations um one of the main reasons why I sit here is because I've always pointed and saying we can't cut our our people
290we can't cut our neighbors um and so I'm going to I'm going to stick with that so hopefully there's other ideas hopefully there's other positions trustees can make recommendations and hopefully at another time you know all these questions all these comments that you heard today you can give us answers to and also too you know if we can't make a decision is there default is there default Cuts I mean is there a list of if none of us can make the decision or majority what's going to be like a trigger like right away these are going to be cut oh so what happens is we do need to reduce our budget uh it is not recommended to deficit spend you can only do that for so long um districts are recommended to keep a very
291healthy Reserve so that if the state in times like this defer payment to us that we have money to be able to pay our bills um so that that's why those recommendations are are in place and it's not recommended to spend from your reserve uh if we can't make a decision we will be deficit spending we will most likely and Jenny can chime in have what we would call a a qualified budget meaning uh we were unable to make the decisions to have a sound budget um once you're qualified now you still have even more cuts to make because we didn't make the decision uh if we still are unable to address our budget correctly the state comes in and they will make the decisions for us so there will not be a discussion and
292Community input at that point it will be um no longer a community decision so that that's uh probably if we're not doing anything today um um or you know this year or whatever um that would most likely be like a two-year process so qualified uh going into this next budget cycle hopefully able to make adjustments in the next year which would be much steeper than what what would happen now um and then you know so so that's what what happens if we can't make a decision I'll just talk there's no like U Tri you know I mean I guess the next thing that could happen is instead of all the community input we could come with a resolution and say okay here's what a new recommendation but at that point it would have to be
293a resolution so that uh we're making the timelines that we would have to uh and then if that I would think that with lacking you know a lot of input that I don't know I was just talking specifically this meeting you know because I feel like we only have half the information and I would like all these people's you know question and comments to be considered and then also too I mean give us you know a presentation what if we can't make a decision and we do default what what are the consequences of us as a board like hey if you guys can't make a decision you know if he could give us a presentation cuz I'm not sure how these other trustees feel so we had that presentation on December 19th but as you
294know all these people are saying you know look at all other alternatives let's just give them all other Alternatives and you know we have to make a decision so there so like I said there were other alternatives to that this was the the recommendation there are some other Alternatives that were added with Esser dollars that didn't that weren't part of the recommendations so there are other Alternatives but so thank you all colleag speak all right um I would just want to say thank you to the budget team um because I I understand we signed up for this right as well um and I didn't realize either how big um debt that the district had right and coming on and seeing these numbers so don't feel bad don't feel you know this is these are this
295is what we signed up for and I just want to say thank you for um putting time aside to being part of that conversation and I also want to thank uh superintendent Heather contz for doing this because essentially you are providing um the community a space to the table to see the numbers instead of us not being transparent and this way you get a little taste of the numbers that we see and realize that these are hard decisions right and I have some questions um could we have more time to explore the possibility to create either a program or a place for social emotional counselors in programs like expanded learning right would that be a choice um because these programs are self-funded um or can we create a program just for them right because technically
296it's not academics but without you those academics we can't get to it either right um my other question is can we sit down with um Santa Cruz County sheriff in wson bille py and have the conversation of them taking over the salaries and benefits of the sro's um I'm trying to meet yall halfway you know and this is something that when I ran my campaign and I knocked on doors there's a lot of people who felt very strong and I said you know what let me meet you half place right what if we ask them to pay for their salaries and their benefits right um I I looked up and other school districts do the same thing where there's the police departments um that pay for those salaries and that can give us some wiggle
297room right um my other question is um can we look at funding that was not one-time funding to balance the the budget um there are different issues that we are facing today that we were not facing then um I'm also thinking of all of the students we have in our district who are going to be really scared to go to school because they're scared that ice is going to come for their families and that is a big you know group of our our kiddos and how are we going to get the funding if they're not in school if they don't feel safe right um and then the other question is if we remove social emotional counselors who's going to do their work are counselors ready for that is administrators ready to take that on that's
298more work for them right and I I can't vote on these these choices because I ran a campaign on empowering students and I don't see these choices doing that and I'm someone that if I if I give you my pal I'm going to follow through so I would like more time um and I would like us to explore um outside like stuff that we did in fun with covid money um to balance it and I know it's going to be hard but if we have to have special meetings I got my calendar and this is what we signed up for thank you trusty Turley trusty Navaro I agree so much with the comments that you made I really appreciate your perspective as a healthc care professional and I would be in alignment with making a
299change if I felt like there was a viable alternative in our community but there does not seem to be at this time but I'm also very well aware that we need to be fiscally responsible to the sustainable budget committee this is a crappy job thank you so much for doing it and and putting in those hours and coming up the recommendations and I I sincerely hope you don't feel disrespected if we come up with an alternative none of these choices are great choices [Music] um we need during the the next six months we really need to be digging deep into our budget we need to focus on streamlining we need to focus on our declining um attendance are declining enrollment um superintendent contras has some ideas about increasing that but the trends are still going
300down we still have many schools that are only 60% occupied and we need to focus on those areas we have some schools that are in horrible condition and do we want to spend some of the $318 million from the bond fixing schools that are falling apart or do we want to focus that money on viable schools and fixing them up so the air conditioning and the heaters work right um when trust when uh president Flores is ready for a motion I have an alternative that I'd like to propose when it's um when it's that time this is freaking painful Carol you you might want to just propose what you're thinking now because it might be further discussion or it might lend to someone else's comments okay and this is painful too there are no easy
301solutions but I think the first three and maybe the first four items are are kind of agreed upon and not as horrible as the others the first one the district office cuts of 750,000 the right sizing of academic coordinators for 600 the right sizing of Elementary release ratios of 1,300,000 and the coordinator of of counseling of 150,000 that gets us to 2,800 that's a little bit more than half the task the last part is really painful um one of the options in or one of the elements of one of these options was reducing intervention reductions and I know that's a horrible thing to do but a million2 200 and then reducing the PV PSA contract by a million dollars that gets you to five it's yes can I get your number again El releas um
302Elementary release ratio is 1,300 and then intervention um coordinator of counseling 150 intervention reduction 1 M200 pvpsa 1 million and I know there may be a contract issue with that but I'm yes yeah well I was just going to ask if we do return to pre-co numbers because 2019 to 2020 pbsa was 400,000 right um and cutting that 1 million would put us at 999,000 so it is yeah yeah I think that's good and healthy but there is a current contract and I don't know if that can be renegotiated I'm hoping it can I'm sorry if I could um provide some information so one of the really challenging things as we were looking at the um different options um was looking at um what is getting funded out of our unrestricted general fund and what
303is getting funded out of onetime or Grant funded um um funding sources so the pvpsa contract it was getting paid from one time uh pandemic dollars um as of this year as of 2425 that's been moved into another restricted funding source um so even if we eliminate the pvpsa contract or increase the reduction to that that is not going to really get us to the goal of rate sizing it's mainly our unrestricted side of the budget that is seeing the um structural deficit spending that will lead us into a qualified budget potentially next year so I think what I hear you saying is even though there was a time when either covid money or unrestricted money was used for pvpsa that's not necessarily the case anymore there's some other funding that's come in that's going
304to handle some of that contract and it's can only exclusively be used for that contract and not for other alternatives for mental health um it could potentially be used for other Alternatives it's not specifically for the pvpsa contract um however um the funding source it's moved into it's called The Learning recovery uh block grant um it runs through uh I believe it's 27 28 school year um and it is tied to evidence-based practices so there are some restrictions around that um so we could look at um you know what are some possibilities but right now one of the challenges that our district is facing um so I just to give everyone a little bit of History um I started about a year and a half ago in the director of fiscal position um my heart
305definitely goes out to everyone on the on the board and with a sustainable budget team one of the things I've and it's not unique to our district this is something because we're all humans every single District every single board struggles with this um since I've started I have seen efforts by the district to try to right siize um when there have been grants that have ended or um program areas that needed to be right sized so in the year and a half um just off the top of my head I can remember workability grant that was um severely reduced there was a position that could no long longer be funded um it was moved into the general fund um at the beginning of I believe it was the 23 24 school year the district tried
306to rightsize um release teachers at that time because they saw that it had not been right sized in many many years um based on community input it was not right siiz at that time so one of the struggles and my heart definitely goes out is there has been a pattern because we're human and it's hard to make these kinds of decisions where no decision has been made to right size when we had the opportunity and that all gets absorbed by the general fund so our district during Co has received over a million dollars in onetime pandemic funding to bring on these supports those dollars U mostly it's called the federal Esser dollars they are gone as of September of this past year so many of those Services were absorbed by your unrestricted general fund or
307any other um restricted Grant we can we were able to get um one thing we have to remember is because of declining enrollment we're projected to lose um just in our lcf funding that's our bread and butter $10 million next year and it's not just a one-year loss the next year after that that's 10 million plus an additional I believe it's a two or three million in that year so as we thinking about what we're right sizing those are things to factor factor into so so I am so sorry to the community that we have to make this decision but um my fear is that we are going to continue down the cycle of not making decisions um and I believe I read an article um with the Live Oak School District Board member and
308he I don't don't quote me exactly but he was quoted as saying that that was his biggest regret as a board member that they did not make decisions when they had the chance so I just wanted to um put that comment out there um so one of the options or one of the line items in a couple of the options was reducing the pvpsa by 500,000 if we did that does that um interfere with the grant money that's come in that's been using for PV pvpsa um so it would um so if you're asking if it would impact the amount of Grant dollars we would um receive um no it what would likely happen is as we reduce pvpsa and that was already a plan that had been in place um so when we entered
309into the contract for 2425 we had reduced it from the year prior um and the plan was to continually step it down um so that was already in place and um factored into the learning recovery block grant multi-year plan okay so if we reduced District office academic coordinator um resizing Elementary release ratio resizing coordinator of counseling intervention reduction by 1.2 and pvpsa by 500 that gets us to 4,500 do you see any issues with those reductions those were all things that were included in several of the options a b CDE e and in the um academic coordinator position um I apologize if you're seeing that on one of the slides so that was part of the $1 million in um district office uh Staffing reductions that we've already made and that will be in addition
310to the 750 on all of the options so maybe um so I know right now let me see what slide it was um I apologize so it was the slide that had the three recommendations on it um it was the last one before the public comments oh sorry side sorry sorry [Music] s oh that one M sorry if you could go back to the one before yeah thank you and I wonder um so I also wanted to maybe provide some information that would be helpful so we did um I I heard some questions from um some of the comments about the fee schedule so I wanted to provide a little bit more information so currently um for many years our district like many other school districts we participate in a program called the uh local
311educational agency billing option program um acronym um Lea Bob I apologize for the acronyms um so this program enables school districts and local colleges um to uh bill for certain types of services um where the uh student um um is part of medical so through that the district does um on average um receive about 500,000 in revenue and um those funds have been used to support um special education positions such as a psychologist position a nurse position um and a um instructional Aid position um the program that we were hearing about the fee schedule program um that is a new program that the state State of California has implemented um pvusd we are one of the very first districts within the state that has been invited to be part of the cohort one pilot program
312so that started in January 2024 um we also received um some special grant money to help implement this brand new program um so starting in January 2024 um we did have District administration start looking into building the capacity what that means is work with um our current building provider um Paradigm to start building uh building out not only the system the software system to handle this but building out policies working with our staff and training um we my understanding is um we have had uh um a billing started to uh being entered into the system but it's really to start building up the training and the capacity and to start being able to get an estimate and a projection of what the revenues could look like so at this point this program is still in
313the implementation phase and we have not actually received um funding for this new fee schedule it's still um in the pilot program and we are actually ahead of all of the other districts within our County so I'm very thankful to um chrisy McAn who had been spearheading um that development for a long time before she promoted into a different uh position so that is still actually in development at this time it is very difficult to get an accurate projection of what we will be um able to bring in um based on some initial um analysis we're thinking at the when we're at full capacity and that is still years down the road it's likely to be about maybe 750,000 um for the for uh for our district um and that is through being able to
314build through insurance carriers so that is still about probably maybe two year two three years out the road to get to that full capacity okay I'm I need to pause one moment I'm sorry uh partially because I'm new to this position but also I'm so enthralled in this discussion I need a motion to extend our meeting because we are beyond our time oh boy I'm I'll make the motion for what time do we think 1 3:00 a.m. cool awesome I'm in so 1 a let's start with 1 a.m. okay I have a first do I have a second second okay all those in favor thank you I got call my grandma real quick proceed proceed truste Charlie yeah it was so it was on option b in the number on the sustainable budget um package
315number eight where it had the 150,000 for the coordinator of counseling and we um we realized during the spt meeting that that was um not removed it should have been removed because it had already been part of the district office reduction so so that's already included in the 750 not on top in the uh the 1 million of reductions we've already taken so that's not part of the coming 750,000 so I apologize for that yes we may need to go back to that slide because I think when that slide was being presented about the million dollar reduction from district office it didn't really get explained um so last year district office through um unfilled position like someone left vacated a position um they just closed the position we've continued that practice through this year so
316last year a million dollars was reduced from district office staff this year $750,000 additional dollars will be reduced but that coordinator of counseling position we've already factored in yeah and not not towards the 750,000 that was incorporated into the 1 million yeah yeah if we drop PV psa's reduction to 500 and eliminate the 150 that means we're at about 4 million math 350 yeah well I just learned that if I was going to take my health insurance that the District offers that would save $42,000 but I'm not going to so that helps a little anybody anybody else hey could we not have meals at any of our meetings you know all those little things can add up I know I'm sounding silly right now but I agree with you the hard part is it's the
317the onetime expenses are the are the things I think what Jenny is trying to explain is one onetime things that have an end date a contract end date um aren't really going to help us too much not not to the extent of I mean when I I think $100 million to add into a budget is a lot of money to then exit a budget not for films okay um does that complete your comments for now trusty Charlie yes okay yes and we'll come back to that motion um and uh trusty Medina yeah so um when I was listening to all everybody coming out here and speak especially the students I remember I experienced grief for the very first time my senior year in high school and I did not know how to process grief I
318isolated myself I didn't want to speak to anybody because the the person that gave me that space was no longer there and when you come from a Mexicano household where we're not very open about our feelings because us men have to be very maesal right we can't show our emotions that's hard growing up with and if you don't have those support systems in place at home how are you going to grieve who's going to teach you about that why aren't we doing that at a younger age so that way we're not CAU in with these feelings senior year high school that year my great grandpa I was going to be his first Grands to go to UCLA and he was excited we were excited he didn't make it but he was still there right but
319it took for me to have to speak to somebody at school who wasn't um trained therapist they were just somebody that listened and that's all I needed in that moment and I think that's what we're missing in education right now I hear so many adults talking about what they think students need when we should be talking directly to the students and getting their needs not a consultant who's going to come in from out of state and tell us this is what's going on when we could clearly see it ourselves so with that being said our students and families have faced crisis after crisis covid-19 the devastating poo floods caused by Montery Cy negligence and now wildfires in Los Angeles that have displaced so many of our friends and families at this the Trum of mass
320deportations looming while the Trump Administration comes in and the current political landscape targeting people that look like me people that look like our students these realities show a Cru how crucial it is to protect social emotional support services for our students who are already caring their weight their parents rate their great grandparents weight and they don't even know that well I appreciate the work done and I really do um by the sustainable budget committee by the way if this was a film the pro um the line producer would give me what you gave me hey this is how much we need to shavee down me as a producer I don't stop the discussion there and say hey director we got to cut this I do my D diligence as a producer and I go look
321for that money and I think that's the piece that is missing in this we need to look for the money we need to get the money here and I love these proposals but you know what I think big corporations in Watsonville need to step up and I think Montery County especially Glenn church needs to step up because guess what we got 20 million in FEMA funding for Paro half the people left half of them still can't access their funding the same man raiseed taxes on the community Paro by 1% people who are already struggling bringing in 29 million so they could cover their 26 million deficit that the country has putting that on the backs of compos workers from pararo students so I think we need our restitutions from Montery County I think this could
322be covered by corporations driscolls brought in $3.5 billion dollar billion granted construction $3 billion in 2023 why is it that we're over here infighting when we need to be going to these corporations and saying hey guess what dris sklls you poisoned a lot of our community back then where are our restitutions where are our reparations right because dyslexia autism ADHD are factors of the poison that was injected into our grandparents and we're living with that and now we're having to make up those cost because these people didn't know that they were poisoning our community and now we need social emotional support counselors to make up for that so I say where's the camera at by the way is it right here hi Driscoll hi Granite Construction and Glenn church if you love our students so
323much why don't you cover these expenses and make sure that our students are getting the social emotional support that they need that's what we need to do we shouldn't be sitting here saying where we're going to cut where we're going to pull from because we shouldn't be doing that corporations making all this money off the backs of our Community need to step up and if you love our kids Driscoll and give us just $10,000 which I know is just pennies to your pocket give us $5 million now to cover the cost so we don't have to cut the social emotional support our teachers need and this is why that I'm going to be voting no on this right because I want to see the corporations in our community step up now is the time if
324you want to see students continue to go with through the what they're going through now having high thought it's a suicide there is no need for that when we have the people right here and it's very unfair when we have these big corporations making all this damn money and not giving it to our schools so that is all I have to say and I hope these Corporation step up and help our students if you really care for them thank you thank you trusty Medina okay so um I wrote down quite a bit just cuz I have so many thoughts on this and just want to keep them as clear as possible um so again um it breaks our hearts to have to stand before you today with this important um and challenging topic um one
325that directly impacts our students teachers and Community after careful review of our financial situation it's clear that we have to make budget adjustments uh to ensure the sustainability and the future of our school district uh first I want to acknowledge how difficult this is again um our schools are not just buildings uh they're places you know where our kids' dreams take root and where our Educators um dedicate themselves to shaping young minds and um where our students you know find their passions and and potential every single program every single resource um every single position represents a piece of this intrical and vital ecosystem however as a steward of this District it is our responsibility to make sure we are operating within our means while preserving the quality of Education as much as possible um sunsetting
326covid dollars combined with declining enrollment have left us with little to no choice but to make these tough decisions um I want to give a very special thanks to all who participated in our Su sustainable budget committee you all made the choice to give up your time with your families to help this District uh during with this very difficult task you made yourselves available to the public for input and you considered all the options I watched almost every single board meeting live and if not I watched it the very next day um and now at this point I've watched most of the final ones multiple times um and I feel uh you all you know had to make a very difficult decision but thank you for Rising uh up and you know coming forward with
327that uh Nora mentioned uh earlier she was correct that nobody wants to make any of these Cuts not Dr contras not any of you not any of us um but failure to do so could be detrimental to our district um when a school district is taken over by the state the state government assumes control of the district's governance and operations um replacement of leadership we are all gone none of our input would matter and none of our you know and and with that none of our community uh members that reach out to us are going to be able to have a say um policy and decision making the state assumes control of all decisions um the duration the state can the state control can last until the district demonstrates that it is you know sustainable
328um it can range from a few years to decades um and then Community input the community impact local input is often reduced and as the state takes over decision-making authorities which can lead our community which can lead sorry the state you know does not take into consideration Our Community Voices which can lead us in lead our community into frustration so items like C items like you know I have a feeling if State came in the I I've looked at other states other districts where state has taken over you look at what they chop off the top it's all things like that the extra um their their main focus is just reading writing arithmetic you know so I I'd hate to see our district fall into that and all of our voices are now quieted um
329so like uh Jenny was saying doing nothing that's where we're going to end up um now I I heard listening to a lot of your comments I wrote down some of the questions that you guys had and I'd like to try to answer um a lot of them most of them um so golf carts was mentioned um one thing that I think a lot of people don't understand with our budget is when certain funding comes in it's allocated for specific things so Dr contas can you let us know where the funds came for for golf carts yes the golf cart funds were earmarked as safety funds through Esser dollars onetime dollars that were sunsetting and so uh we heard a need from our school um campus supervisors that they were struggling to get around the
330campus and that a students got hurt and needed to be move from one part of the campus to another that that was a concern and so uh those dollars could be expended by that in that way and they needed to be expended by September 30th and so uh that was a decision that we made most school districts do use golf carts for their campus security um as a safety measure so that's where that came from that it was one time dollars okay thank you um another um comment that I heard was you know fear of losing our wellness centers that we you know put so much time and effort into um I would hope and I'm and I'm almost positive we are not losing our wellness centers they might be manned differently um I know
331Encompass is going to be Manning some and we might be moving some of our staff members into our wellness centers those will um stay where our students can go to um seek help um another um thing I heard was about you know 2019 and um where our numbers were there so during this like all these Deep dive budget looks uh in 2019 we were headed to State receivership um if Co hadn't happened we probably would have been taken over that's scary that was really scary to think about for my children who are in our district um I don't want that um So Co managed to give us a few extra years um to really get a grasp of this now the number of students that we had in 2019 is was a lot higher than
332what we have now so um we should be able to you know decrease some positions because of just simply declining enrollment um uh another um Community member mentioned foster care so I definitely would Advocate that and I know we do have special resources specifically for that um demographic so I would hope that that's that's not going to happen um someone mentioned why aren't we looking at closing schools now um we there have been talks and and we within the year or two I'm sure we will be bringing that um out to the community that is something that it takes time that is not something you could do overnight that is a process um when I when I went to cca's um conference in San Francisco I attended a couple um sessions on closing schools and
333it's like it takes a lot they you talk to the community you you know take talk to all the stakeholders you don't just say we're closing the school um so we need to make budget decisions today that it you know we can prepare us for next year um why did we only look at onetime funding dollars was another um thing that was mentioned well trust me we are going to be looking at the budget as a whole that's what's coming next and those numbers are going to be larger and going to hurt a lot too um one of the another Community member mentioned you know the salaries for a mental health clinician versus um well sro's but in um they mentioned the salary one thing that wasn't included when those numbers were ran are benefits
334we have top-notch benefits so those numbers are going to be slight slightly if not significantly higher than what was um quoted um so when we talk about right sizing um classrooms specifically uh I've heard that we have classrooms that are sitting with you know 17 students in them um so that in the next year are things you're going to be seen where um we will be we're not going to C um go above what our um classroom size mandates are I mean I those classroom sizes are not changing can't say that enough we like those if anything I would love for those to go lower but you know um we got to do what we got to do um but yes so but 17 where we're sitting with multiple classrooms with 17 students in them
335we're going to have to start making some some move moves there um let's see I'm sorry uh someone mentioned uh Mr Denise mentioned that in that presentation on that we had at the at the dunes the presenter said that we do not invest in things that eat um that comment taken out of context because what he was talking about was the Golden Rule of onetime funding um when you are receiving onetime funding you traditionally do not want to spend that on what he said I believe was things that eat and breathe um because uh you have to lay them off eventually um and so um I'm not sure why our district when we took on these positions didn't have an end date to them um so just like when we hired a community um community
336specialist it was very clear when we hired those positions this is a 5-year contract cuz that's what the funding is for and so I'm not sure why these positions weren't um handled in the same way um the mention that the sustainable budget team is a scapegoat I I just that hurts my heart I mean I I'm sorry uh to the sustainable budget team um that was in no way what was wanting to be done by by doing it this way I it was done this way to come to this decision with weeks of time and thought and discussions you know leading up to it not just here it is tonight let's make a decision and be on our way we've had weeks PE public has had weeks to communicate with them um this was very
337transparent and it you know I I thought it was beautiful I thought it was a the a great way to handle this situation and I hope next year and the year after that when we're still having to do this we can have a very similar model maybe some tweaks to improve it um but you know next year we are going to be looking at more cuts and a larger number um we could do nothing tonight and not we we're not we're going to go into qualified we won't go into State receivership but that just means next year we're all going to come back here have $155 million cut or some you know outrageous number um I I I love trusty trly that you are you understand that we do need to make a decision um
338one one item on your on your motion does worry me a little bit and it was it's the intervention teachers um the reason the sustainable budget team did not put that on on what any of these options is because of how closely it is tied to that number one priority which is our learning um and so I mean and if we like I'm just saying if let's say we vote on this tonight it passes next meeting we're going to have a room full of intervention teachers and all those parents who you know their students utilize that um I'd like to see numbers of how many students are helped by intervention teacher teachers and how many students are helped you know with social emotional counselors um mental health clinicians um just because I do believe this
339conversation was had in our sustainable budget team um which is why they came to this conclusion um okay so that was it for what I heard from the from the public comments I do have a couple questions myself that I'm hoping Dr contras or um Miss Jenny M can um address so I know in the in the sustainable budget team the numbers were shown as far as like how many mental health clinicians we had how many social and emotional counselors we had and how many students we had in 2019 um versus now and I want everyone to Remember by making these Cuts we are not chopping every single M mental health clinician social emotional counselor we are reducing I was told we we will still have we are not okay can you clarify that for
340us we are leaving in place the special education social emotional counselors which can also service general education students but also I'm sorry you I'm sorry the public has had their time to discuss now it's it's our time to discuss and we cannot have people out um speaking out like that thank you and also the mental health clinicians tied to the sro's because that was proposed that was sold to our community as a program so that remains intact the SRO contract didn't come before this team because if you remember it went to the board one went to the board in July July and I think another didn't go until September late September so those had just been voted on decided on uh by the board they'll come again it's an annual thing so it'll come back
341again and at that time that be discussed then um but we're we leave that partnering together and what about social emotional counselors social emotional counselors would not be reduced in totality okay and then um can you tell me uh how many students do the uh mental health clinicians and social emotional counselors see on a daily basis uh we have a the a logging system and some of the use I provided that to you in a in a written thing so I can share it you could refer to that in writing I don't have the numbers completely I shared every board member received that yeah so um we do have a logging system so anything that was logged those numbers were provided to you and they reflected what has been seen from August through as of
342yesterday from what I was I was fairly surprised by the numbers um that was that was that what the um board communic um over the weekend following the board communic I had several board members request different information items and so that was sent I think two days ago okay um and it had several different things but it was it was separate and it was kind of lined out by here's the questions I received and here's the responses and then there were three attachments okay and so that included uh the information that we have that is recorded by our social emotional counselors and mental health clinicians of student served as well as what was included there was the um pvpsa number of students seen But the number of students seen from pvpsa that was included were
343simply crisis students we didn't include if you looked at the contract that I also included in that there was like Kids Corner and some things that are not tier three uh the direct numbers that I provided were all tier three like these are the crisis like um things that and I think that was troubling about that cuz how do they Define a crisis that's what I was trying to look for in their definition of when a student is going through crisis yeah and then also that 3w week weight period that a student has so if a student's parents gets deported they're going to be told they have to wait 3 weeks in order to get service from pvpsa correct because they're not in crisis at that moment I I don't I I can't speak to
344that I don't recall understanding it that way okay that's how I understood it and it sounded really weird yeah no I don't I I know there is a referral process so I I think one thing too to understand is uh pvusd has done a really nice job of tier one tier 2 and tier three supports with social emotional and some of what you heard tonight is very accurate that our district was very ahead of um providing social emotional supports most districts were jumping onto that during the pandemic because the need was so great but we did have that um in place uh many years ago because of that we have also been able to establish really wonderful tier one tier 2 and tier three supports so our tier one supports are tied into our positive
345behavior intervention systems uh we have sewn to grow where the teachers are logging like um how do you feel today they're asking the students that and doing checks like who do I need to check in with that is reporting like not feeling great they have many lessons that they deliver about things like what you talked about like how do you deal with grief and how um our tier two supports are like some of those small group work like um and restorative practices so that when students have conflict we do have a mechanism and have trained people in how do you help to resolve that conflict and how can you even do that in the classroom uh from time to time if there's a big need like happening within your class that's distracting learning yeah um
346and then our tier three those are the more intensive cases an immediate crisis would be something like suicidal ideation or reporting self harm or someone has reported um being harmed in some type of abusive way those are just immediately rise to the top and that would be yeah that would beer um but then there is a referral process so in a multi-tier system of support which is mtss uh most districts adopt that and it's the idea that you for some students you know let's try this intervention and see if it works then let's try another and let's try another and see if we can do kind of um you know that tier one supports first we then have a process for referral to uh pvpsa or any of our additional uh supports or to our
347mental health clinicians too uh and that referral process can sometimes take time as they work through that process meeting with the team meeting with the parents uh meeting with the student to get a sense of what things are but that's more for the like tier 2 level students and I know that we also have funding within the Arts correct there's a big grant that we received in terms of funding for the Arts are we also looking at the cross-section between the Arts and mental health and are there any type of grants that we could go after with that that's interesting because I was just speaking with uh Elsie stemma and they're really doing some Cutting Edge work in looking at how can we integrate mental health supports with music and and arts integration because they've
348noticed that students who have reported I'm not feeling good you know and unhappy uh have found therapy through music instruction uh we haven't really started looking at that or logging any kind of intersection there we do receive proposition $28 which is great state law we know that we will always get those dollars and that's helping to build robust arts in our schools um and then as well as the way our students um receive their art instruction is some art there's other pieces of how they receive release time teachers receive release time students go into art sometimes it's PE or science too though so got it okay and then I guess my final thought the more extreme one I guess is have we filed any lawsuits against the city of um against the county of Montery
349County for the damages that were done at poo middle school or did that have to come out of our own Pockets so in for Paro middle school and what occurred there with the floods um that was all funded through FEMA support so uh I don't don't I'm not aware that there were any specific lawsuits or anything like that nothing so but we did get federal aid we did get federal aid oh great they ruined a school and we got a little bit of Federal Aid because of their neglect but I guess what I'm trying to get at we have a lawyer that we're paying we have a school that has been completely damaged parents that are needing mental support students that are needing mental support right now and I'm pretty sure the last thing that
350this the county of Monteray is going to want to come at us for filing a lawsuit cuz they're not going to want to come after students in a school district so why don't we file a lawsuit asking for $15 million to cover the cost because guess what we're deserving and I I know this is kind of funny but as a Hollywood producer I use the out word a lot and people actually give us the money that we need when we say we're going to use it okay um trusty detina I love what where you're going but maybe this can be handled on a one-on-one because right now we're running out of time we need to focus on this item that we're on right now um and so I I believe I asked you the questions
351that I need um and so if we oh okay I'm sorry trusty Navaro has a couple more questions and then I'm going to come to you trusty trle so one of my questions would be you know I understand that cuts need to be made is there a way I notice there's a difference between the total between recommendation one two and three can we get closer to like do we have to like get to five can we get to like four and a half like and then focus on Revenue because you know I know that when you look at a budget right you got to look at expenses but you also have to look at revenue and one of the things that you know Jenny maybe you can help me with this I don't know why
352it would take two or three years to get full funding for reimbursement like most of the students in our district are ccah and like I said you know I I have a I'm on that board so like I I think that there's a way that we could FastTrack it so do we have to get to the $5 million can we consider maybe decreasing the cuts to the mental health you know perhaps we do a small cut there so like everybody's feeling a little bit of pain but not as drastic as this looks because I mean we're kind of balancing the budget on the backs of our mental health and you know so I think if we can focus on revenue and maybe not make all these decisions tonight I think most of would feel a
353lot more comfortable with that um you bring up I think really really important um point so I wanted to address first the revenue piece which is when we're making decisions for um for Budget um and we're looking at things like what we consider it's called structural spending or structural deficits so that is um spending that we can't get out of because it's year over year so things like Staffing and for us us at PV um for from the last 3 years looking at actual expenditures out of our unrestricted general fund um salaries and benefits here um are about 91 to 92% of our total expenditure budget that is higher than the Statewide average and that is linked directly to the amazing benefits package that we have so could we adjust the amount yes per um
354port per the board discretion but we also have to remember this is only phase one of reductions the reason we phase this out over multiple years is because coming to the community and saying all of a sudden we have to now make $10 million in reductions in one year that is a total shock to the system so we need to face this in so that we have time also to build capacity and to look at how is is impacting students and we have time to respond as well so if we are able to structure it in a way where this first phase we looked at supports that were brought on by the one-time funding the reason why this is heavy in the mental health programs is at the time um administrators worked with the community
355to prioritize how the community wanted to spend the covid dollars the top three were um improvements to facilities to facilitate a safe learning environment so those were improvements such as a haac um improvements Roofing improvements to maintain um you know proper ventilation proper uh breathing air for students things like that those were onetime funding the other T were intervention supports and um socio emotional and mental health support so looking at now what's been absorbed into the general fund now that those $10 were over most of what has been remaining were the additional mental health support so I apologize deeply for all of our amazing mental health professionals here um I do not want you to feel like you've been targeted um but we we were looking at what was absorbed um specifically con that is
356contributing to the ongoing deficit spending um so we could reduce but that would mean then that's additional reductions and in phase two and then there might be a phase three depending on what happens with the state budget I'm just feeling like a lot of us need a little bit more time to generate ideas because you know most of us haven't been on this board very long and it's a lot to absorb all at once to make these Cuts without even though I've been diligently studying I still don't feel like I have all the information or all the pieces and I know that we need to make a decision tonight so I guess my question is you know can we agree on a lower number in that regard to cut and focus on increasing revenue and
357because you know I met with a mental health clinician who shall remain nameless because she's a friend um and you know one of the things that she mentioned was that nobody's really checking to make sure that her notes are done and the the billing is getting submitted and that things are being coded properly and so if none of that's getting done you're just leaving money on the table so if you know like this is something I work as an ER doctor if I don't finish my charts and submit my bill I'm not going to get paid so I think you know if we had a little bit more time to focus on improving the revenue and getting more money back from the people I mean we basically are providing Mental Health Services to the medical
358patients of the Central Coast CCH should have more like an investment in that absolutely and when we um uh did our analysis of a projected revenue from the fee schedule we did actually um build in um the um the billing that has not been getting done due to exactly what you're talking about so it does have that buffer um so when I talked about the 750,000 and actually in one of the sustainable budget team presentations we had it from 750 to about a million dollar and that does have that buffer in it because we do recognize um that we aren't at 100% capacity and that there is room for improvement so um when I talked about that 750 figure it is if we are at full capacity and we do need to grow into it
359um in terms of um having present day expenditures and um maybe Revenue in the future that is um not what I would recommend as a professional when it comes to budgets um uh Tristy Medina I um appreciate you looking at out of the boox ways of bringing in revenue and we are absolutely doing that but we can't have ongoing um spending at the moment for maybe in the future so if those ideas come to fruition and we are looking at all of the ideas that we Source from not only the sustainable budget team but Dr contras almost on a daily basis is reaching out to other superintendents across the state I'm talking to other cbos we are sourcing ideas there's a lot that's actually already in the works to start bringing in more students um
360but it is not recommended um and it is not best practice and it is not something I could um ethically do of putting in budget that likely may not materialize that is the first way to get into fiscal distress okay thank you um I'm going to allow trusty kco to make one final comment and then we're going to move on to trusty Charley okay it was more of a question If today instead of taking this as option one two and three recommendations would we be able to break it down and today vote on certain things and we're we're not done right that doesn't mean that we're only going to vote on $34 million today but maybe we take the time to look at funding not onetime funding would that be an option that we have
361we we break this down and we vote on each each thing and then whatever is left we go back and we try to look at uh funding that is not onetime funding to balance it could that be an option um I think anything's an option uh the board can vote to do anything they would W like to do um the hard part is is that this is a step one that gives some direction for me and my team after this first step we have a lot of work to do um and and we have timelines that have to be met and so then we run the risk of maybe not making timelines and if you don't make the timelines then for that year you're not making the reductions and so then that puts us back
362so and we can have another special meeting of part two to make those timelines you the board would like to do that we can do that I'm I'm okay with doing that okay um trusty Turley um looking at your numbers for your um possible motion um would you be willing to adjust a little bit um I I I know you know like I like I already said we don't want to cut anything but maybe just a little bit I mean intervention teachers I just I mean I know we're going to be bombarded with um emails after that because they're going to be caught off guard for one um but I I I do agree I I do see where you came up with that because if it it shouldn't all just come out of our
363soci our social emotional counselor and mental health clinicians but maybe there's some sort of little bit little bit little bit um so we're at least being fiscally suit we're making you know a decision tonight but one that's not going to have a huge impact on our students I mean any any decision we make is going to have an impact but sure how do you feel about we start with a motion just for the district office of 750 academic coordinators of 600 Elementary release ratios of 1, 300 get that done is there any possibility of increasing I mean is there any possibility of increasing the cuts to the district office not that I think that's ideal but like is that a possibility so look at me and asking I don't know I don't like sure so
364one of the first things that we did before even starting to look at any cuts that would impact um the sites is we started at the district office so we started we already made a million dollar in Cuts we're committed to a minimum of the 750 additional one of the struggles with um centralized Services is we have many departments and programs within the building here within the district office that is actually funded um in a completely different fund so um like for example food and nutrition services they're in a completely different fund um Early Childhood for example um migrant seasonal Head Start migrant education those programs are almost fully self-sufficient and they have grants so when we're looking at centralized Services um absolutely you know we identified um those positions to start making those reductions
365um because we wanted to start here first to kind of show that we we want to also bear that burden and it's the right thing to do um we are absolutely every step of the way evaluating if there are more opportunities to to start streamlining but one of the interesting things when we were doing this study is for example our maintenance and operations Department looking at industry standards and also one thing that's very unique to our district is how wide our geographical area is how big our district is how many schools and Facilities we operate here because of that geographical area so looking at those factors we were actually seeing that we have certain departments that are centralized that are severely under staff to maintenance and operations being one of them so almost every board
366meeting I hear comments about you know it breaks my heart that we have teachers and students who don't have AC um PMS um you know you know thank you for your advocacy um we are absolutely working very very diligently on addressing some of the um things that have come up since the new build um those things it's not for a lack of trying it's that we have so many facilities we're so underst staffed um we have one director one assistant director and we're operating more schools than all of the other districts in the county combined so our um team is doing the work of maybe nine directors of mown and Facilities so those are factors to consider um in terms of reductions I my opinion looking at the analysis after we make these reductions we
367will be running lean for those centralized Services because of the number of sites and the number of employees that we have Jenny just to ask you another question um is in this budget is there anything about money being saved by attrition or retirement or cuz I'm not seeing that yes um at the first inter term budget um those are planning factors that are already included um in the multi-year projections so um I included um natural attri um um going into next year for our teaching staff usually that is um a little bit easier to project because our teachers are tied to classrooms um the classified side it's a little bit harder because it's not a ratio like that um classified side it's really for finance for example um our district because of the size of
368our district the number of Grants we actually do go out for and that is something that I'm really proud of um we have um all of our directors and we have um uh Andrea Willie um who has brought in millions and millions and millions of dollars of going after grants but each Grant then for example has reporting requirements tracking requirements implementation um uh building out capacity training so a lot of times when we are doing that cost analysis we have to then look at okay then some times we bring in a little Grant and it almost requires a whole new position just to manage that Grant um we uh part of our sustainable budget team we also looked at the number of employees we have in relation to our enrollment compared to other like siiz
369districts and the number of employees that they have what we saw is we actually have a greater number of employees um on average compared to other like siiz districts so that also then puts additional um energy time time um uh requirements and on let's say like our HR staff they have more employees they um our assistant soups have more sites more principles more teachers that they're supporting so it's kind of this ripple effect with classified it as harder to have it tied to specific ratios it's there's a lot of factors that we've been looking at and we will continue to look at that and that is a commitment that Dr contus and I are making to the school community thank you okay so I like your idea of let's get through a bit of it
370so your motion is to um I move that we eliminate from the budget $750,000 for district office $600,000 academic coordinators 1,300,000 Elementary release ratios okay I have a first do I have a second second okay all those in favor um should we do roll call or oh no let's try this all those in favor I I all those opposed no okay any abstaining so we have 1 2 3 4 5 sorry 5 1 Z okay got through a part of it okay so um for this next part I was crunching numbers here um you took care of 2,650 um, thank you very much um that leaves us with uh 2, 350,000 um if we want to just a straight 5 million um I a suggestion that I can make is um intervention uh teachers mental
371health clinicians social emotional counselors all three of those a straight 500,000 and pvpsa 850,000 you do a million for that one has a million well the thing is right now we don't we're not even spending a million of General funds correct Jenny on on that that's correct it's not out of the general f but that grant that we're using for pvpsa why can that not be used for for salaries for mental health clinicians and social emotional counselors not benefits so one of the things um for the pvpsa contract is um we do have um it's stepping down um year-over-year um so one of the things that we'll have to do is there are other things that could move in um if we moved in mental health clinicians or um social emotional counselors um it could
372extend um us being able to do that maybe by about a year I would have to run the numbers um but I can't answer that at this moment so I apologize okay and I know this is probably not a popular idea but I'm just throwing things against the wall and seeing what sticks um I know that our mental health clinicians and social emotional counselors are not in the union with the other unions um the counsel I'm just wondering if they paid some small portion of their health benefits would that save anything um so uh health benefits are tied to our collective bargaining agreement so um even if um you know and and I don't want to speak out a turn legally but my understanding is even if that was an offer um it is tied
373to the collective bargaining agreement so we would not be able to do that okay thank you okay um any other ideas or anyone want to make a motion seek donations sue the corporations good I mean I mean you're talking about a long-term strategy I that's not really realistic no it is realistic it is totally real you know how long lawsuits I mean that's not realistic do you think that they're going to want to come into litigation with us at all okay I'm sorry exactly they're not so it's a viable thing they have done a lot of damage to our students our families and displace them why aren't we leveraging the attorney that we have L is of those students and those families it's not a l to the district so thect the impact I don't
374agree with that because these students are being impacted by that right so the student that got sprayed over or their mother got sprayed over and now they have autism and ADHD we're having to make up with those with our social emotional support counselors that's why I'm saying there is money here on the table why are we being so nice to these folks that have poisoned and damaged our schools I just don't understand that I appreciate your line of thinking I do truly I love out of the box thinking and we get a lot of um things accomplished from that so we'll pursue it and we can look into okay what might that look like what and definitely I'll follow up with you let's do it all right okay did you oh no okay well I
375mean it might not pass but I'm going to make a motion um to proceed with a recommendation to um sorry okay yeah to decrease intervention um teachers by 500 uh mental health clinicians by 500,000 sorry I'll be more clear 500,000 500,000 social emotional no no they're separate separate lines um social emotional counselors by 500,000 and pvpsa by 850 I mean if you guys want to make it a million I'll make it a million but I like to make it a million all right 1 million so now we're going over our 5 million so hey um nope no I I wouldn't suggest that right now um yeah exactly it's not I mean we're we look like we're we're reducing more but we're really not um so that is my motion um MH so do I have
376a second can you state your motion sure my motion is to reduce intervention teachers by 500,000 uh mental health clinicians by 500,000 social emotional counselors by 500,000 and pvpsa by 1 million I'll second your motion okay I have a first and a second um all those in favor I I can we do roll call yes trust your can we also as a stipulation if Jenny approves if we are able to increase Revenue which I really feel like we can potentially adding back those positions I mean and just being on the record about it if we have the funding I'm just saying and being on the record about it to be transparent yes if we have the funding of course we're going to want to provide our students with everything we could provide them with um
377why you're doing that really quick Heather when will we be getting our test to measure how much uh contamination is uh within PB Middle School um so we have I believe the um that will be in the next board communication going out possibly tomorrow um but just to answer um so prior to the construction starting up um uh we uh contracted with a professional company to come do soil testing it was uh November of 20 uh 22 I believe um don't quote me on the exact month um so the test came back um with either insignificant or Nonet deductible levels of pollutants um petrochemicals um heavy metals things like that the only heavy metal that came back with any sort of um uh um uh range was uh chromium but it was not within any
378significant levels it was still within healthy code levels so it was deemed to not cause any health issues for um for students and because we are a school district um and we have to go through um standards like um the Department of State Architects DSA things like that we are held to a higher standard for Environmental Testing so all of the tests came back at um PMS clean and we did test um at four different locations um around the field and around the property so um you'll get a copy of the full report in the BC cool thank you thank you I understand the state has changed the level of chromium that's considered acceptable and it's a pretty significant change so if you're looking at 2022 testing it may not test well again okay um
379so now we have a first and a second on the table did are you ready to do a roll call are we okay with this no well no I know but no okay so Eva please will you do a roll call trusty D Jr your vote trusty Medina your vote trusty carasco your vote trusty Turley your vote vice president NAD you vot president Flores your vote I okay so votion passes for to zero and with very heavy hearts we apologize to anyone that this impacts and um yes especially our students okay all right now we uh I'm actually going to have trusty Navaro um do action item 12.3 so I could use the restroom hi good evening um well president Flores that's okay uh Board of Trustees and Dr contas I'm bringing forward as um
380a second read on our an action uh our board policy on school sponsored field trips so I'm not anticipating this taking as long as our previous item um I brought this forward in our uh December board meeting where I went through and highlighted the areas that had been changed um so that you guys would have some time to look at it so I am asking for approval on uh this board policy and regulation I'll make a motion our bird president so I'm I will make a motion I'll second all those in favor sweet yay thank you much next item on the agenda did she give me this page I don't think she expected us go that quickly new job description and salary schedule Child Development site program and raising a reader coordinators thank you for
381your patience and still being here at almost midnight that's all right I had plenty of work to do thank you um so good evening vice president Naro Dr contras Board of Trustees and cabinet and thank you for your time and almost hitting midnight so hopefully 1:00 a.m. we're done I am Lisa sandal I'm the director of the early childhood education Child Development Department and uh the child development department and HR have been working diligently to clean up and um make sure that all of our position positions have the appropriate job descriptions as well are placed on the salary schedule appropriately so with your approval we would like to request your approval to update the job descriptions that were brought forth to you we are requesting the removal of the coordinator for Child Development range 37
382as well that is not a position that is currently held and we don't plan on hiring for that position it is important to note that none of the changes presented and it have a financial impact on the district fund the site coordinator job description was updated to reflect the role of the site coordinator and there's no change in salary the program coordinator job description only added the word program in front of it and that's um there's no change in salary as well the raising a radar coordinator does have a reflection of change of salary and um It's been a updated to reflect the current role and the duties for the position and we are requesting a change from range 20 to range 27 on the salary schedule this position is funded 100% through anou with
383first five this mou is specific for raising a reader only so when we get this when we work with them every year and we negotiate it's strictly for this um program those of you who don't know what raising a reader is it's a national early literacy bilingual book program it's uh we started in the district with 20 centers and we now serve 141 centers we started with family 20 family family 20 family child care providers and we now serve 154 family childcare home providers we started with two School library Partnerships served 12 Library Partnerships we had one school district in the beginning and we have expanded to six school districts uh we and in those school districts we went from Zer TKS to 39 TKS as well as from zero kindergarten classes to 16 kindergarten
384classes so as you can see we've grown significantly the same coordinator who's been with the program from the implementation um of the program has been working to continue to bring in additional support services or uh supports to these classes so we're requesting that um as appropriately as things have grown that um also her duties have increased that she's placed on the correct range on the salary schedule so with that I please ask for your approval on these changes thank you so much um do we have any public speakers to this item 12.4 why did we use the word program no I'm just kidding Let's Make A I'd like to make a motion it's an overarching hold on we were checking to see if we have any public comments none okay so now do we have
385any board member comments no I'm sorry everyone's itching account thank you so much for your um presentation and uhu bringing this to us tonight so can I have a motion did you make I make a motion Gabe makes a motion to approve can I have a second second okay we have a first and a second all those in favor I any opposed any abstaining Thank you Lisa thank you good night six okay now we will move on to item 12 uh. five report will be presented by Oh by Brian today um thank you uh good evening president Flores Dr contas and Board of Trustees my name is Brian Saxon I'm the director of certificated for HR and I'm here to present the Williams uh report for Quarter Two um on a L basis Willian complaints
386must be reported to the board in the county and we need to include the number and types of complaints received uh for the quarter which spans from October 1st to December 31st of 2024 the district receiv received zero complaints related to the Williams act so um that is our report and we ask that you kindly approve it thank you thank you do we have any public comments Chris Webb uh this past fall when this uh report came up the the previous board vice president clarified that there was no upper limit on uh classroom temperatures and uh perhaps it was lingering tension over the board president blatantly denying public comments that evening but I felt that the uh the board vice president was dismissive of the lack of it seemed like it was dismissive of the
387AC situation at Watsonville high and I'm hopeful that this new board not only takes that issue more seriously but they they they do so by allocating measure funny money to um address that um in the past this board and District have at times taken a position of merely being in compliance with the law um I'm thinking about like um water quality uh standards and um regardless of of clear issues with the legal status quo I would encourage this board to be a a leader and be willing to exceed state laws and like this is somewhere this is an area where the the state laws may be insufficient um and that we should we should make it a point to like be better than the law when the law is is behind um I also feel
388compelled to note that um in that evening where there there was suppressed speech it did lead to more tensions and this is something that came up tonight that when we don't do that it makes for things a lot better also that last meeting um there were some comments made to to a community member who was suppressed and I just want to make a note of saying that all political violence and um telling people to get out in an aggressive way none of that has any place at these meetings or any other governance meeting thank you thank you any discussion from the board I have just one question of curiosity who's likely to make a complaint uh anybody can make a complaint that forms are posted in each classroom at a school site and of what
389you know there is a notice that looks like like this notice the parents and Guardians so anybody can file a complaint so it could be a parent it could be a student it could be parent student teacher a teacher okay thank you I'll make a motion can I have a second please second okay thank you I have a first and a second all those in favor I I any opposing any abstaining thank you that passes 60 60 thank you very much got we 126 okay we will now move on to item 12.6 a report will be present Ed by Christy mlan director of federal and state programs good evening um thank you president Flores superintendent contras trustees and Community I am uh happily coming forth hoping that we can approve this resolution the resolution um
390is to approve 2 42512 reaffirming the commitment of pbsd to provide all students equal access to education regarding L of immigration status um this is a timely um resolution but I want to make it clear that the that pvusd has made resolutions like this in the past we have existing board policy this resolution is really to reestablish and make sure that the community uh as well as the school sites understand our school policies and our dedication to keeping students uh safe that's our main job keeping them safe making them know that school is a safe place and we're dedicated to um uh keeping it that way and and making sure that folks are informed and um knowing our protocols so I'll read just a couple portions of the resolution it is quite long I see
391it's up here I'm going to read the the first whereas the board of education for paho Valley Unified School District is committed to the success of every student in each of our schools and to fostering a safe inclusive and welcoming environment for all students and staff regardless of immigration status cultural background or other characteristics and whereas the California Department of Education has declared California Public Schools as welcoming safe places for Learning and teaching for all students regardless of immigration status reaffirming federal regulations and state law that Pro prohibit educational agencies from disclosing personal identifiable student information to anyone including law enforcement without consent of a parent or guardian or a court order or lawful subpoena or in the case of a health emergency whereas the board is committed to the success of all students irrespective
392of their immigration status or citizenship and believes that every school school site should be a welcoming place for all stud students and their families and whereas the board believes that the physical safety and the well-being of all our children in the district and ensuring that our schools are safe and welcoming for all students and their families is Paramount to students being able to achieve in poo Valley Unified School District does not tolerate any form of discrimination harassment or bullying as outlined in board policy 513 1.2 and whereas Paro Valley Unified School District has already demonstrated a commitment to support DREAM Act and students through resolution 111220 and to support immigrant students and families through resolution 161 1725 in addition board policy 51453 outlines the pvusd response to immigration enforcement and board policy and be a
393further resolve that the board of pararo Valley Unified School District go on record in support of all immigrant students and their families as well as students from other vulnerable communities and be it finally resed that the board of poo Valley Unified School District will Advocate on behalf of the rights of all students and their families I um humbly request that you approve this resolution and reaffirm the safety as number one for our students and families in our schools thank you very much uh do we have any public speakers to this item uh thank you for putting this item on the agenda I fully support it um equal access to education is um a personal value of mine um it reminds me of a Tik Tok video you put out after the election um trusty kesco
394you raised a point about favoritism and I think that was valid but I would just point out that I think the issue is bigger than than even what you cited and I'm hopeful that this board will um focus on equal access to education is something that they can more broadly promote um with this and and other ways as well such as um perhaps making like a public working document that would detail the terms for which students um would be able to matriculate from alad schools back to their home schools if they so choose think by having that Central document making it public it's transparent and it it prevents any kind of um UNT uh denials of opportunity um another would be um with with Renaissance restoring our student produ monitoring system that system had a
395level of due process um that exceeds what I've seen um otherwise and in its absence I've seen where students have faced inequities in access to education it's something I felt so strongly about I filed a complaint about it and I I felt like my the response I got was somewhat Hollow so um that's just two two ways right there um thank you for putting this on have a good evening thank you you know earlier tonight um a student named Hilda was saying that we are in dark times and these are dark times that we that necessitate that we work across institutions that we work with Community Partners and organizations and we have to mount a really vigorous defense I'm so appreciative that we have this resolution um and I really wonder like what are the
396protocols if there is an ice raid um at any one of our campuses I want to say that I'm part of um a multicampus organ organization that is called Sanctuary campus and you know I think that we should just be having conversations about this about what we should be doing in this area more broadly I also want to say something else too you know with the um entire Fiasco around the CR contract you saw that a number of Partners universities actually pulled out of working with the district um Watsonville is in the heart which is a collaborative project between toara project and UC Santa Cruz pulled out you know and I think that it's really important at A Moment Like This Not only to have a kind of Defense in place but we actually have
397to incorporate this into our curriculum at UC Santa Cruz critical race and ethnic studies which was a department that I served as a founding chair for that department we developed a curriculum with our students an undocumented students came forward and they said it's not enough to have student services undocumented student services that are directed toward us we want to have a curriculum that studies the struggle of around immigration and links it to indigenous um sovereignty and understands it in conjunction um with um abolition and so I want to say say that just I'll close this out but we have a curriculum and that is a resource and you bring CR back and you have a partner with so many local institutions thank you very much and um I want to give trustee Dodge the first
398opportunity to comment on this and as how he was the one who reached out to agenda setting committee to make sure we get this on the agenda thank you agenda committee uh superintend superintendent herther gz and thank you Chrissy for also reading um this important this important resolution as we know ice is here they're in Bakersfield they're in Fresno um children are scared I know children at Radcliff are scared that their parents are going to be taken away so I think it's important that we highlight our support for our immigrant Community um I also kind of wanted to mention you know if next Schoolboard meeting if we could kind of bring up support of um Senate Bill 48 which was introduced by California Senate majority Lena Gonzalez um I wanted to bring this bill if
399we could support this bill because it kind of makes you know we want to support state legislation to help protect our schools I that's I thought this was an important bill because um I hope we can support this bill that's proposing um prohibition of immigrant enforcement on school grounds you know that's something we also need to take into consideration and I know that you'll be able to speak on on what the school district is doing um it also has a restriction on sharing information and also importantly establishment of safe zones sb40 proposes creating a one M radius around school sites where collaboration between California law enforcement agencies and federal immigration authorities is prohibited it so I think going back to what some of the speakers like we need to take we need to be proactive
400and in because the fear is real and it could happen here it's happened here in the past you know it's happened here in Wattsville whether they go into the fields um because they know that's where a lot of I don't want to say legal immigrants but like our our our family members you know and our relatives and I think we got to do what we can to to protect our people and our fames so hopefully uh at next next meeting we could do a resolution to support sb48 thank you yeah and I'll I'll take a minute to just speak to what we are doing um so earlier this evening on consent agenda there was a uhou outlining our connection with the PV collaborative that's a group of leaders um across many different types of agencies
401that I'm a part of Andrea Willie attends those meetings with me as well we meet every Wednesday morning at 8:15 as a way to check in about needs in the community what things are we doing to address them as different issues Ares that collaborative was formed um during the pandemic and now has been it was so effective then that now it is exists to help in moments like this so through that collaborative we've been looking at how do we Outreach into the community what are the strategies we're using what are we providing um even as early back as November to start educating um our community on their rights so we have hosted at pvusd several know your rights clinics for um parents we trained on Monday all of our leadership team about if ice were
402to come what do you do and they have protocols uh it's all in writing exactly what to follow we practiced uh what it should do we asked them to go back and please train their front office staff so that if the principal isn't there or the administrator isn't there that everyone does know exactly what to do um and so we feel like we're putting some of those things in place additionally uh starting our first day back which was Tuesday we've been closely monitoring our attendance at all of our school sites so I've asked all the schools make sure attendance in is in by 9: in the morning um and then all of the school supervisors and myself look to see if we have any spots of Rel low attendance and um the instructions have been
403you call whoever is not here and you find out why um to for a couple reasons like what has happened is there anything we should be aware of uh but also is there any fear are there are students being kept home because of fear and then how can we Outreach and alleviate alleviate that we had um really excellent attendance the last two days but we did have four sites that look to be like something with going on um and so they outreached and talked to families and everything seems to be okay at this point but we're going to continue in that practice daily um just it's a good practice so that the minute we see something we're there our principles are also ensuring to outreach and and make sure that their Community knows that the
404school is a safe haven and really our principles that is their Community they are the Hub and the leader of the their community so they're our best resource um so they're are also doing that work so thank you very much uh trusty Dr Navaro Dr Keras one of the things that we're doing at the hospital is putting up signage in both English and Spanish just letting people know are you planning on doing something like that with the school okay and I guess a followup to that is um does this also extend out to the sro's that are on our campuses yes so if they work with I we could get rid of them right what they say okay cool yeah it's not them I'm concerned about it's the people that aren't speaking up or saying
405things and you know may feel a certain way about certain law enforcement doing that so um yeah I actually can you put on my photo so I love this I appreciate it but at the same time this is what my school is going through right now this is not a safe environment for immigrant families this shows neglect this shows that I do not care when a parent shows up these are the things that they see and it does not feel Equitable for immigrant students so I guess I I I understand and I love this Proclamation but what are the repercussions when we don't meet them that's my question because we're going to approve this and we're already failing because look at how this school looks look at how damaged it is so hear you yep
406we we will do better I hope so and I I appreciate you bringing attention to the things that we need to do better and that's part of the beauty of all of you is that you help to bring our our attention to the things that need attention but that's the sad thing why do I need to bring up this attention when we know it's so bad why do I need to do that I don't think a student should be buying a lantern off Amazon because there's no light in there to use the restroom it's a staff bathroom it's in the back yeah a SE in completely open above a counselor's head right there no insulation on the doors they told me that down there on the bottom right that is card hazardous waste and it
407is within feet of a classroom what is that say to our immigrant students and parents that we have this Dumping Ground right in the only school that is the most neglected in Paro so with these proclamations I don't want them to be self-fulfilling I want them to actually mean something and I want us to address these things when they come up because this Proclamation right now we're not living up to it if this is something that's been reinstated we're not living up to it so I really urge everybody to do better right because this is very unacceptable to me and if we care so much about immigrant families and students we would not be seeing this type of stuff at our schools that's all I got to say thank you and if I could um
408just um address address this specific situation trusty Mina thank you for um advocating for PMS I absolutely agree our district needs to do better um specifically with the staff bathroom this was related to um you know I'm going to take responsibility for this there were three delays that um caused the staff bathrooms to not be unfinished um when we reopen PMS um this year so one of the things that we had talked about is and you will get more information in the BC um in order to reopen PMS um for the 2425 school year we FastTrack um not only the cleanup the remediation the planning the construction typically a project like this would be about 2 years I know there was a private school within Watsonville that was also severely impacted with similar landslides they
409are still not fully functional so we really FASTT tracked um we knew by fast tracking um by um doing this in 17 months that that first year with any new bill there will be things that pop up um this is absolutely one of them and I apologize for the school to the school Community there were three separate delays the first one was there was a last minute change that the Department of State Architects required for the layout of the bathroom um that changed not only the size of the bathroom but it changed the type of exhaust fan and the lighting that we had to install that was the first delay that caused it to be unfinished when the first day of school started the second delay was then we had to order the new type
410of exhaust fan setup and the lighting from the manufacturing company there are um manufacturing delays um uh throughout the country um still remnants from covid um and some of the delays that were happening we still experiencing that that extended it into the fall the most recent delay we were hoping to get this done over when a break is that there was um um an issue um I don't want to go into it too much just out of privacy but um with our general contractor and then the subcontractor um brought on to do this work so we were trying to get this scheduled um it was not scheduled I appreciate um your advocacy it is so important um and we have worked closely with um the principal Nicole Marsh um we started actually the work inhouse
411because we Rec recognize um the hardship this was causing for the staff so my understanding is the exhaust fans and the um lighting was installed this week because we found out it was not done over winter break um and then the rest of it which is just putting the street Rock will be done over the weekend there other little things remaining things like Outlets not working those are coming up we are addressing those in terms of the storage containers um that is related to Il legal issue that you will get more information in the board communication I can assure you that the storage containers at the moment do not have any hazardous materials or chemicals or the um most of those enclosed storage containers hold um materials Furniture supplies that were housed um that we
412thought were going to be salvageable but when we tested for things like mold spores and mildew um we felt like it was unsafe to bring back so we we are currently pursuing damage claims so that is why we cannot move those storage containers because it is evidence um so I apologize for the delay but we can not control the length of something like that thank you for that and um you know just historically this has just been a neglected community and this really just adds to it um and you know the final thing that I want to say is I um man it sucks I'm a videographer and a photographer cuz I take pictures of everything so all the site visits I'm really going to be looking out for this because I want my schools
413across that bridge to feel seen cuz a lot of students who cross that bridge over here they see the disparities and it's so normalized to them that you know what we live on this side of the bridge so this is all we're going to get and I never want them to feel like that and this just only highlights it for me which is why I was so disappointed absolutely and I think um one thing I just wanted to give a quick shout out to is I think we have the right team at the right moment Dr cont Michael Burman Claudia monadas um Nelly um our umca members um of really starting to look at this I know this year there's been a lot of work done of looking at artly Garcia high schools Dr contras
414and Michael Burman have been digging into differentiate assistance um and on the classified side um we actually have brought on some professional development to start understanding in impacts of equity to things like facilities um so that is some exciting work that we've started this year um so I absolutely agree there are a lot of opportunities to look at how um Equity it's not just in the classroom it's looking at things like how are we doing our resource allocation looking at um how are we handling facilities throughout the county so absolutely I agree and we will continue to do better awesome thank you and last thing I showed these pictures to my Abita she literally called my uncle and he said he could fix it this weekend but I told him we can't contract him so
415sorry thank you um Jenny M for we are so appreciative of you just stepping up and taking the responsibility for that um thank you herlindo I know emino is uh just overwhelmed and under staffed and um I know this we could get pictures like this across a lot of our campuses um I know hero knows when I first came on board I went to visit mine I brought him ha Hyde I mean it it it does but um thank you uh Jenny for stepping up and and taking accountability we know you guys are on it and you're just overwhelmed um but I uh would like to see if we have a motion goe um just one question and one comment um part of what you read said that we don't accept bullying which of course
416is is appropriate it's unacceptable but I want to make sure that we're not suspending students for that often there are reasons why why children act out in that way and that we have resources so we're redirecting that and not just sending them home and then the other is um I believe when I read this I didn't hear it when you said it um that we don't collect any immigration data therefore we have no immigration data that somebody could even request from us we don't require to have any immigration documents in order to enroll a student we just need to know your address from your phone bill or something like that to make sure that we're putting you in the correct school and regarding the bullying there's a very clear definition of what bullying is from
417in Ed code but at the school sites often what people might think is bullying which is actually a bit more continuous but the beginning parts of bullying that you may be thinking about we are are not suspending students for that there's a progressive process and most of it is built in relationship building and self-reflection so many of the school sites have been doing um deep work with restorative practices and the administrators and that is the heart of positive behavior interventions and supports and so that is you know we want to we know that you know people who hurt people are hurt right so the how do we support students to make different choices how do we listen to their story so their behavior changes thank you anyone else okay I will take a motion wait
418did did you make the motion oh sorry I'll move to approve I have a motion uh first and I have a second all those in favor I any opposing any abstaining nope thank you motion carries 60 and one last thing while I'm up here even though the public is probably not watching anymore I did want to remind folks that um on January 27th we're having one of our mini Mondays and the focus is know your rights for parents and caregivers we have had a successful one at Watsonville high school and the next one coming is January 27th a parent square has been sent out people from the uh Community can come staff um and it's online because we'll be doing some in person and some online just for people's Comfort level and it will be
419um this particular one will be in Spanish and English um so uh I just wanted to make sure folks knew about that and end on the the positive note of knowing that there are a lot of things that are doing uh believe me I love facilities beyond anything keeping our students and our our famili safe and that is the heart of this resolution so thank you for approving it thank you and um now I will move us on to item 12.7 this report will be presented by Claudia manaras the assistant superintendent of curriculum instruction and professional development uh good morning uh president Flores Board of Trustees and Dr curas uh I have the pleasure tonight of bringing forward our um annual resolution acknowledging black history month so um and this one hits very close to
420home considering my children um so I did want to uh kind of give a little bit of um information in terms of February 1 being uh when Black History Month begins um it's a time to celebrate culture contributions Heritage and experience of African-Americans um this year's National theme because it does change annually this year's CH theme focuses on the importance of African-Americans and Labor uh the theme underscores the diverse and significant ways in which labor whether voluntary or involuntary skilled or unskilled has been at the core of the Black American experience and then I do want to read out um three areas of the um resolution so Black History Month was originally established in 1926 by Dr Carter G Woodson an African-American author and Scholar who worked to establish a specific time of the year
421to recognize the untold underappreciated and or uncelebrated contributions of African-Americans to our Nations history pbsd recognizes that black history month is the opportunity to promote and Foster cultural relevance in our schools and enrich the educational experiences of our students to deepen their understanding of the different perspectives of American History pbsd is pleased to present this resolution and request your approval acknowledging February 20125 as Black History Month and recognizing the significance of Black History Month as an important time to acknowledge and celebrate contributions of African-Americans in our nation's history um additionally we are encouraging our pbsc Educators to celebrate honor and study the contributions of African-Americans throughout the year and to include lived experiences every month not just in February we will also be providing um resources on our district website for our teachers to access
422um so that they can have lessons and resources to use um February or really any month so yes with that I'm asking approval thank you so much do we have any speakers to this item public speakers we have two can I can I speak oh wow I said in a couple of board meetings last year that I usually go to bed between 8:00 9:00 look at that and yeah can can you believe I'm not sleepy yet W because of you anyway I I'm remembering oh know I I'm from Japan I immigrated from Japan to New Jersey and I spent I lived in New Jersey for 23 years and I had lots of opportunity to become acquainted and be friended with various kind of African-Americans and I'm remembering of several African-Americans whom I met and one
423of them is wellknown scholar Dr Vincent Harding she uh he and his uh wife worked with Dr uh Martin Luther King Jr for many years and he was the one uh that draft or wrote a draft of Dr Marin Lu King's Speech Beyond bedra and I had a chance to attend uh uh we weekend uh Workshop organized by him and his wife and I was I was amazed how beautiful his wife's hands and I took photos so beautiful and I I had a chance to talk with Dr Vincent Harding 101 and I asked his advice about how to deal with racism and he he said to me that be strong that word has be in my mind oh already so yeah this is really important to be friend Claudia Thank You For Preparing this resolution
424I wanted to say that you know last May um a number of us spoke out and we said that doing resolutions for different months you know Asian-American Pacific Islander History Month that it's an empty gesture if you don't support what actually is mentioned in this resolution which is ethnic studies and I wanted to say too that you know with black history month I think that we are sometimes tempted in this area to think that that is studying a history that is geographically not continuous with where we're at but I think that 's a really important invitation here for us to think about our local area as also a place that is a black geography which is to say that um you know part of the Great Migration from the Jim Crow South wasn't just to
425Chicago um to New York to Detroit but it was actually Westward here to this area and in fact many people who came from the Jim Crow South as agricultural labor actually moved up to Oakland afterwards so I think that in a way like when we think about this local area as if we turn this into a curriculum as a black geography we actually understand that migrant labor has always we know this played um a very important role in cultivating the wealth for um agricultural Capital that didn't actually you know I mean why is it that uh migrant black labor didn't stay locally that's a really big question that we have to ask and I think you know uh trusty Medina raised the question about the hyper exploitation of Labor locally and what does that mean
426in terms of education and the relationship with large scale corporations I you think that that's such a wonderful idea to think about their reparative obligation to education thank you do we have any discussion from the board I just got to say um I really appreciate this I have so many cousins of so many different shades and it's beautiful and um when I get to hear my um or speak with my cousins on their experiences and what they go through um I think we need to hear more of those stories um so I guess the only thing that I would um ask is if you all need video or film recommendations let me know um my class was the first class that had black and brown film producers um within our school the Peter Stark producing
427program down at USC and we all made a commitment that we wanted to make sure that we're sharing even students work um from our community so if you need any access to that let me know awesome thank you thank you trusty Dodge just to let the public know just in case you're still watching and just to let people know that on Monday for Martin Luther King Day there's a big March in Santa Cruz um I know Elaine Johnson who is head of the NAACP she's the president and um just wanted to throw out the invitation I believe it's at 11:00 in downtown Santa Cruz Martin Luther King march always a great event thousands of people so if anybody is interested please check it out thank you thank you so much uh any other comments from
428the board okay see none I will entertain a motion I need a I need a first motion I'll move to approve thank you and a second second okay thank you all those in favor I thank you motion passes 6 can I also add one more thing um so thank you Danny for bringing that up um the other one that I do want to put a plugin because I know not a lot of people are awake right now but I know a lot of people will watch tomorrow um January 30th starting doors open at 6 um convocation is going to start at 6:30 but there's actually going to be an event at the Kaiser Permanente area honoring Dr Martin Luther King so um go to the March 10 days later head on over to the convocation
429thank you so much okay so we do not need to reconvene to close session so I will move us to it item 14.1 um upcoming board meetings so our next board meeting is a 2-day special board meeting one is going to be Friday January 31st at can I get the time again please oh okay I was wondering why I didn't know okay so we will get time to be determined and then on Saturday uh February 1st okay 9 it's an early one 99 to do you know how long we should clear our schedules for it is 9 to2 okay no no not Friday okay okay so possibly like a 6 to 8 type of a thing on Friday January 31st mark your calendars and Saturday February 1st um 9-2 okay and location will to be
430to be determined yes okay thank you so with that this meeting is adjourned at 10 uh 1233