001and we're going to get started so welcome everyone this is our final sustainable budget team meeting aside from the January 15th meeting where we will um present to the Board of Education um so for tonight I just want to run through what we'll be doing um we have prepared a PowerPoint with all the information uh that we think we would present to the Board of Education as a recommendation moving forward um we did a draft to kind of make it easier I'm going to go through the draft presentation with you um at the end what we'll do is we'll do a fista five on does this look good or not what adjustments might we make um and then following that we'll actually choose the slides every single one of us will help to present to
002the board of education on January 15th and we'll choose the slides that we would prefer um to present and then we'll have some time in which you can write the script of what you would like to say and then we'll be collecting that so that we can put that into the actual like slide prompts so that on that evening we're all well and prepared and have a total script for for what we might present to the Board of Education are there any questions about that I want to thank you for being here um when we first assembled this team and went forward with here's what we would be doing it takes a lot of courage and bravery to be a part of that and I know as we've come closer and closer to the recommendations
003um that it's hard it's really hard this is a a hard and challenging time um I want to remind the committee that when we set out on this we knew that we had some areas within our budget we needed to look at and that two things that were colliding together at the same time really were one the the sunsetting covid dollars or Esser funding that was the $100 million that we had to help mitigate the impacts of covid to remind everyone this District did engage in a process in which Community input was provided uh about what services and things do our students need um to help through this this really challenging time of Co and so that's how some of the things were um added and now it's forming a committee to look at okay
004now that we have to those dollars are sunsetting now what do we do the other thing that this committee was initially taxed with also was that at the same time that covid happened we were also experiencing severe declining enrollment and that declining enrollment continued through the pandemic and we didn't make the adjustments during that time which no District would have made those adjustments during that time that was not the right time to make those adjustments but now as we climb out of the pandemic and its impacts um and we no longer have those dollars to help us we need to look at making sure that we're right sized so those were the two tasks and so when we looked at the different options the options included were really the things that had come on board
005with the um Co dollars and the position that we hadn't done anything about in terms of right sizing all right I am going to go through the presentation now so this is a draft of the sustainable budget team presentation to the board of education for January 15 2025 we say draft in case there's any adjustments that we're going to make this evening uh you each have a hard copy in front of you and you are free to make notes as we go through the presentation of any recommended changes that you think we might um need every single slide in this presentation are slides that everyone has seen before as well as our public because these have all been posted on our website for public uh pervie so um nothing that is in this is something
006that you haven't already seen so we always at our board meetings begin our board presentations with a review of our vision and our mission uh this vision and Mission was created by our school board in July so it's a newer vision and Mission and we'll be revisiting it with the board changes that have happened we'll actually be revisiting this on January 31st and February 1st these are our Representatives who were uh who applied to be on this sustainable budget team and we want to make sure that at the board meeting we do recognize the people who volunteered the people who came for all of these meetings and donated their time uh and worked tirelessly to understand the U budgetary picture of the district we're including in this presentation to the board the team Norms that
007we developed on our very first evening together um like the School Board of Education who adopted their norms for governance we want to um demonstrate to them the Norms that we chose in um for ourselves when we were having these meetings so students are our top priority Equity of voice listen to understand don't listen to respond be brave and ask questions this is a safe space where people are empowered to use their voice and should feel comfortable sharing and honor diversity of community as well as assuming positive intent and we we thought the slide belonged in there so that the board understood how we decided to Norm ourselves um over the last eight meetings that we've had we also include the pvusd Strategic goals we actually read these uh out at each board presentation that
008we do and then we call out the specific goal that that board presentation is meeting and so in this case we're really meeting that goal of the fiscal solvency we also remind the board on this that the purpose of the sustainable budget team was to make Collective recommendations to the board of education on how we use our resources to best serve students and maintain fiscal solvency in the face of declining enrollment over the next decade and the recommendations to the Board of Education were to be made at the first board meeting in January inserted this slide so that the board would see what we went through in trying to solve this problem that we made our problem statement that we gathered and analyzed information that we looked at potential causes and root causes and that
009we tried to identifiy possible implausible solutions and then worked to make a recommendation to the board so this was the problem statement that we co-created pvusd is facing a significant challenge due to inclining declining enrollment and the loss of one-time pandemic funding to address this issue we must reprioritize and reimagine our services to scale effectively and maximize available resources our goal is to maintain high quality educational offerings while ensuring Equitable access for all students to achieve this we must Implement Solutions with transparency ultimately positioning our district for success in a sustainable manner and this aligns to our district goals it also aligns with our lcap goals and finally we aligned ourselves to what our core values were for this team in the allocation of resources so we stated on this team that we would be
010student centered that we would ensure equity and ex equity and access that we would prioritize our core educational goals and that we would consider our long-term educational Investments those were our our guiding core values for this team we also include in this slide deck the order of ranked priorities that we determined in I believe our third meeting and that was that we were going to prioritize teaching and learning first Visual and Performing Art second enrichment opportunities third third mental health fourth career in college connection fifth family resources Sixth and educational options seven we also um put what was as part of our guiding decision making is what are the responsibilities of an educational organization particularly in a K12 system so we include this slide um to help the board to understand what we were at
011as we were prioritizing um our decision- making and so as an educational system K12 our primary task that we uh exist for is to educate students in math science and El laa and that is per educational code also included in the slide deck um the data that we looked at about how our students are performing in those areas of our core responsibility and then we include this slide to help the board to understand the enormous amount of work this team went went through the meetings that we held as well as uh what we worked on on each of those meetings so that they see the scope and sequence of our work this slide outlines some of the reductions that have already been made from district office we want to um ensure the board that we're
012looking at all angles of our district and that we have already begun making reductions um starting last year in areas um for the district office governance and then we walk the board through the different plans that uh were put together for this team to consider so here was plan a that we all looked at here was Plan B that we looked at plan C Plan D plan e or options um so we want the board to see and understand the different considerations that we looked at different configurations of addressing the onetime dollars and as well as declining enrollment and right sizing of the district and this is a summary of what the sustainable budget team decided to recommend to the board so this was the revisions that were added in to option b and d
013ended up being the identical plan both ways so we really came up with instead of two plans one and so this slide then explains how we arrived at at the recommendation that we would be providing to the board and then the presentation ends with public comment and then a Q&A for the board to engage in and discussion and in the end it is the Board of Education that takes action on the recommendations um so we're just a recommending body and um and that's that so any questions or comments about what was presented or what may have been left out or the approach of the presentation yes sorry if I made a couple your questions first of all just for continuity on the Sor there's no slide numbers but when we say the for the district
014office reductions completed total is approximately $1 million and then we go to refer to it through all the options is 750,000 which which is it that is a good question we had a debate about this so if we include some of the reductions that were made the previous year it ends up totaling a million dollars okay so we can make that distinction that might be if it's unclear to you then it'll be unclear to them too and my next question probably should have come a lot earlier but on these different options we settle anything between five and 8 and a half million my my question is there there is nothing in this document at all at the beginning that states what we're aiming for we've just settled on 5.6 why it' be my question yeah
015why if if if option A at 5 million was acceptable then why are we pushing for 5.6 so we can absolutely that's a good suggestion we can include that on there if you'll remember um what we thought we needed to be fiscally solvent in this year would be to accomplish a $5 million reduction however we know that next year we will be needing to make a similar reduction amount another $5 million so any amount beyond the 5 million just makes it for a little easier potentially reduction for next year we can include a slide that explains that yeah I that that' be that'd be useful my my word of caution to that is the general rule Cuts is don't give more than you have to because um I know there when we looked through some
016work last week there are other projects are ongoing in terms of cost-saving measures um introduction of new solar systems in different places a lot of things going on we haven't yet seen the benefits of or can't forecast what the benefits are I would you know I would just say be cautious of putting too many cards on the table at this point and because it may not be a problem next year but or it may may be more of a problem try not to solve next year's problem now would probably be want and I just wanted to say that is a really really excellent point and when we came up with the the goal of the minimum of the five million um we were very very we tried to make sure that the cuts that we
017were recommending with the reductions would not be Draconian in nature so the Von is more on the conservative side and that's why we wanted to have a phase a phase one a phase two and then a phase three for the 26 27 school year because you're absolutely right there could be things that change at the state and federal levels at the local levels and we do have that time to have the phase three that we're building in so we also didn't want this to be too much of a shock to our system so we're implementing this phase of reductions focusing on the onetime Esser um and then the right sizing that should have been done during Co and then it'll give us another year to look at what are the next round um so I
018spent this last week listening to a lot of counselors and teachers and parents and students and like the consensus with all of us at this table is like we don't want to cut all of these positions for mental he like that's super super clear and I want to reiterate that literally nobody wants that one thing that was interesting to me was one counselor had said that they were just in had started to learn how to bill to insurance as a team and then when their Supervisor was like changed positions they were kind of like their senses their sense was that they were left like on their own to figure it out and so like it sounds like there was these shifts to try and figure out alternative ways to keep the positions alive even if
019it wasn't under the employment of the district or at least to continue getting that like ongoing revenue from insurance so I'm just wondering like what happened with that and how do we like and I I know that like what talked about last week was the district was trying to figure out how to be able to Bill but you like what happened that the counselors were learning how to be able to submit claims and Bill to some sort of insurance and why can't we still do that or like Rush that a little bit like as we're transitioning for them to have a different employee they're in the process um as I explained last time of receiving a grant a subgrant from the county office of Ed to build out our um capacity for the fee schedule
020implementation we actually are not technically able to build yet we haven't activated the system um and what we're seeing is that at the same time we have been doing this work to build up our billable system a lot of the nonprofits are also leaning in through the um what is it called the ECM I don't know what that stands for I apologize learning more about you know because you're yeah um so they're leaning in to do that work as well and I think um what I've heard uh folks here saying is that there are expertise in the community in community- based organ organizations in medical service organizations clinical service organizations who are learning to do that it will take us some time to build up our capacity to Bill and our rates are so much
021lower as a school district when we compare them to like ferally qualified health clinics and other other s that we will never recoup the actual cost of a staff member um with that b scheduled program it supplements a bit and we're still understanding how much by position and by service type so we're not it's going to take us a while so we're not at a point where we could rush it in two months and have new information we're talking about probably a year or two at least curiosity question from I don't know if this pertains to you sorry Andre um but uh just I I'm passing through a question curiosity question it's not directly from myself but is there another organization or agency or entity that could employ these social emotional counselors that is not
022the school district and possibly not pvpsa through some of our grant funding in the um student services department uh we have uh been working with Encompass Services um and we also are working with a company called I think it's educational student services ESS um so we're looking at different models and but it takes time for us to see how much the billing for ESS will return back to the district for Encompass they get the service directly but we're we're engaging in return on investment conversations and Analysis and again it's going to take us some time um to accomplish that and do it well right there are other oh yeah besides pvpsa there there are quite a few um piggy backing on what Richard suggested about not you know not taking away things before we absolutely
023have to take away things if we know we need to have that $5 million Mark $650,000 were over that that 5 million how many social emotional counselors were looking at having going back to pre-pandemic numbers going from 202 to 12ish roughly um how many more could we afford to add back in with the 650,000 K that that part we really don't want to get into speaking positions because there's a whole thing with that okay um so we're just kind of looking at estimates and even the 5.6 is an estimate if you'll remember at our last meeting Jenny talked about using in average to kind of come up with a number okay so these are estimates okay yeah just trying to honor the feedback received from and that that of the suggested cuts that was the
024one that I received the most feedback around I was hoping I can kind of just clarify too um at the last meeting um we discussed and I know there's we're not discussing specific positions however there was a change at the middle schools which I think um wasn't communicated clearly and so I'm hoping tonight we can clarify um the Middle School counseling positions because there are a school counselor then there's academic counselors at the high school and a social emotional counselor at the high school and then there's social emotional counselors that are split across the elementaries but there's no social social emotional counselor as of now at the middle school so we the middle schools just need a little bit of clarity about what that means in terms of counselors for the middle schools Katie those
025will be things that we're working through with our labor partners thank you and I don't know a whole lot about it but um I believe that they bill out to Medical they take medic like um students with medical and then they bill out so if they're getting paid for their services through medical um why is it that that PB pays them such an absorbent amount of money just because I don't know yeah I I think what happens with that is when you contract with the company the company does their portion of what they need to do to run their company but we're also paying for a portion to partner with them that's how Partnerships work so um that's that's the model for pvpsa and for any of our other uh mental health clinician services so
026they still they may be billing out but they're servicing our students so we're paying for them to do that parents can also just go into pvpsa and have their students SE in that way too okay I don't want to get too far off topic from that but um I've had a lot of thoughts over the past week about the process of what was presed to us in the options um it was difficult for me to process it and articulate it at the last meeting but um one thing that I'm struggling a little bit with is you know we had six meetings where we went through a lot of work in small groups and we came up with a lot of ideas that never made it to those options that were presented to us last week
027and it it feels like to me like those five options were sort of just variation of the same Cuts different dollar amounts but all coming from the same place whereas like there were other places that never really were presented as options and just one example of that is like in our order of ranked priorities we listed mental health as number four and just as an example to throw out there not that I'm advocating for any types of cuts but we put educational options online learning and interventions is number seven and when we discussed last week and we looked at like changing up the option b and the option D we specifically people specifically said let's not touch intervention let's go with social emotional but if we ranked educational options as our least important of the
028priorities that we came up with at the beginning of this program or this process we didn't talk about the Virtual Academy there's a whole bunch of other things that I think that were like up on the walls that we talked about that just never were presented as an option for this $5 million um so a lot of the things that were up on the wall that made it were actually additions they weren't really going to be reductions they were wonderful and great ideas and I hope ideas that we'll see fruition for because they were great and we have them all saved and categorized and all that but there were really no reductions being offered in there uh Virtual Academy is an area where we can see any reductions it's driven by the number of students
029in the program and the number of Stu teachers indicated to teach those students so there wasn't really um Virtual Academy did have a full-time principal and it no longer has a principal the the Renaissance High School principal overseas Virtual Academy so I I'm on topic for uh pvpsa I would like to know how many students of PB pvpsa mental health clinician can serve in a day whereas our mental health clinicians employed in our district um like thinking about the hours that they work in a day which is probably eight hours we don't represent the mental health clinicians um but they're so they're probably eight hour a day worker and I'm just thinking about the number of students they can sered and I would like to know what um pvpsa has as a standard for the
030in number of students that one that one clinician can see in a day also the amount of money that we contribute to pvpsa is over two times than what we had um what this District had contributed uh in 1920 um and the contracts back then actually also had wording where there was some other some monies out of the funds of the district contributed that then they also had to they were responsible of taking money from that amount to pay for another I can't some another agency but now the contracts read where it is on top of what the district gives them every year they give them an additional amount or they pay or the district pays that an amount to this other agency um so I'm sorry I can't remember all that wording because that
031was from this last week when I was looking at that but this district is contributing actually closer to 2 million this year um and that uh uh just only cutting half a million if we're like talking about you know pre pandemic and then now uh that's a lot and that is a good number of positions that we can maintain in our district who are serving our students Nelly we have some of that information Jenny just pulled it up so we can share that she's going to um share I think with syester so we can put that slide up so we're looking at sustainable budget team meeting number four this was a slide that was shared that um outlines pvpsa their contract uh the number of students served the number of visits each student had the
032the potential cost per student over the course of the year and the cost per visit we also share that information with Encompass and effective School Solutions can you help me understand what the nearly 2 million is spent on I mean I see these numbers here I see the the number served um but I this was also shared with many parents and folks across the district and they still feeling really confused and so I'm wondering if like you guys could maybe explain it how you would explain it to a second grader uh I I'm not sure what so we contract with pvpsa to provide mental health services to our students so the contract we're paying for is for them to have those clinicians available to the students that are being referred for services so that's the
033contracted amount that's the agreement that we entered into uh that agreement grew with the pandemic and the pandemic needs and that um contract is being reduced for this upcoming year beyond the reduction of the 500,000 that we're talking about here no that's the amount that is being reduced that had already been negotiated as part of just what was some of the ongoing work could we think about maybe since we're we keep talking about pvpsa and soci missal counselors can we think about doing like a fist of five type thing at this table to see who would be in favor of potentially cutting more from pvpsa and fewer soci emotional counselor positions or fewer dollars from this like swapping this I really so I we can do that absolutely and if that is the direction that
034the team wants to go in I I complet completely understand I do want to caution everyone that we don't really have the expertise to oversee some of these programs our focus is educating our students and we usually most districts do partner alongside like a pvpsa center for Human Services is another one that's popular in areas uh to provide those Services because they can provide the clinical supervision necessary and we we don't provide that and that that definitely is the feedback too of like that at least that I am hearing um is having that skilled reflective supervision um but what I'm also hearing is from the counselors is that they're overworked and they have just too much of a case load because the need is so great still so it's you know like just trying to
035figure this out and then you know like yeah and I think just like looking at like I I'm just my site that's all I can speak to but my pbsa counselor sees serves five students which I'm super grateful for but my social social counselor probably sees eight to 10 students a day and she's there two and a half days a week so I think about how many kids she can serve versus how many are served through and and there are limits and very specific requirements associated with pvpsa and I know it's a different level you know of of support but if we're talking about just meeting student need you know that's where I would be in support of looking at perhaps an option where we could keep a little bit more uh social emotional counselor
036support I mean I think if we think about what Richard said at the beginning which is super good feedback and I think we should consider just keeping it at 5 million because there is going to be that discussion again next year of making more cuts and I just in my experience like having worked for this district for a long time usually like even if cuts are made now they're still going to say we have to make a bunch of cuts next year anyway right so if we keep it at 5 million that's 650,000 that can go back into the to make the reduction to soci emotional counsel is only 350 and then you could add on that three you could eliminate that line completely and you could say we're going to reduce pvpsa by 850
037and that still gives them over half of what they had last year and or this year and back to what it was still more than what it was in 1920 as Melly pointed out and if we did that maybe we can buy some time while the district figures out how to build so if the reason it sounds like the only reason we're not really billing to insurance is because we haven't figured out that whole system you like that part hasn't been the whole system hasn't been it's not us haven't figured it out no no no I know system itself hasn't been established like it has not been figured out but like I wonder what we could do with some time yeah I I don't so our understanding of that is although we will be able
038to Bill it will not cover the cost of providing what the level that we're providing now even under another agency like if it was under Encompass or under PB just like Andrea explained they're able to bill because they are in that business and they have the licensing to do that they are able to collect more for the billing than we are able to I I don't I didn't write the fee structure so I'm not quite sure why it's like that but it is like that I guess like my thought process is that like a shift of not an elimination of the positions but a shift of who their employer is like it wouldn't can I say something yeah is it possible to just cut the pvpsa contract Al together cuz pbsa literally only takes children
039that have medical right and so I'm saying this because it's all about money for this company we can still still send our children that need PVS pvpsa to pvpsa for their services after school or before school we would save $2 million if we cut the contract now it's like a Band-Aid solution rip the Band-Aid off now and we would be able to ensure that the schools that need the counseling services on site like Valencia they'd get their um social emotional counselor maybe five days a week right instead of having somebody only two days a week she might well she she she might get somebody 5 days right um because that's the need that's the need of the children Sela might look at that and say hey you know what we need to put we need
040to put somebody here five days five days a week that's the need um I'm saying this because pvpsa is bleeding us dry right now and it's not about the kids you guys billing is medical billing isn't the problem our job at pvpsa for me as a High School parent I'm here representing High School parents right now is education in children right and what I want to see at our schools middle schools high schools elementary schools is that our children are being serviced in education okay pvpsa is not servicing our children in education they can get those services off site PV uh pvusd is doing a tremendous job meeting the social emotional needs of our children because they've shown that in who they hire as District employees we need to make hard decisions and I'm telling
041you this sorry I'm I'm still like under the weather right now we need to make these hard decisions and I know that people are going to be upset and I know it's hard to make hard decisions but I'm telling you this as a mother as a district employee as a human being from every fiber in my body that this is the easiest cut that we can make this is the easiest cut we can make without even thinking twice about it because this is not going to hurt our kids what will hurt our kids is not cutting pvpsa I'm telling you right now so one thing Jenny and I are looking at is the length of time of the contract because we do enter into contracts with them and so we're unclear right now on if
042the total amount can be reduced we we know 100% of the fact that we can reduce it by 500,000 and we have that paperwork here M we're looking at it right now I just want to say one more thing as far as the intervention piece I know interventions listed under priority 7 but when I was advocating last week I see it as a critical part of teaching and learning which is our first priority so that's why I advocated that we don't cut intervention so just clarifying that and when talking with parents the many many parents are very concerned and frustrated and overwhelmed with their children who have disabilities and learning disabilities physical and learning disabilities those kids are having a really hard time so I said we can control where we can cut we're a
043little top heav at Salpa maybe we need to relook at Sala and yeah actually Sala is going going through what we call the fmat process where we are um having a deep study done to help us to understand um how to be more effective uh with our s that uh study was approved by the board in December or November and will not commence though until February of this year just there's a a large they have a waiting list I think knowing that too it does underscore Richard's Point earlier that we cut we only cut what we have to cut because we know that once that comes out there's going to be more cuts that can be made next year okay so this is a little different than what I thought would happen tonight uh last
044week I thought we we actually had 24 people come to consensus about the recommendations and so the PowerPoint we prepared was based on the recommendations and the work that we've done up until this point um it sounds like the sustainable budget team is changing their minds about recommendations that we had already previously agreed on so that changes things a little bit uh we do have timelines that we have to reach in this process uh because of the recommendations and and how the budget development process begins so I'm hearing then that I'm not quite sure what I'm hearing we go going are have we wavered completely from our recommendations and we're moving back to a different scenario or solution are we moving forward with the presentation as we had reached consensus last week I'm unsure what
045to do next to be honest um could with regarding the timeline that we're working with we have a lot more Folks at home watching tonight than there were before could you guys just give like a reminder of the timeline that we're working with yes so uh when school districts need to look at the different reductions that they're making there's considerations for personnel and laws that have to be met as well as contracts that have to be renewed through budget development or contracts that need to be let go and we also always want to give the earliest warning to anyone we might not be partnering with anymore or also to employees and so those timelines uh for employees is March 15th and for our Consultants is pretty much uh in that area as well because Jenny
046and her team begin the budget development process right at that same time if I may at this point I think my feeling now within this room that I'm getting is that due diligence is something we have to put to this and in my mind now I feel there are more questions than answers when I look through the proposal and I absolutely agree with saying last week we seemed like we got a way ahead I think when we look at the bottom three district office reductions um the AC reduction and the elementary release ratios I don't think there's any argument there it's right sizing and it's puts that have already been made it's just the the mental health bubble that we we're talking about and I'm sat here thinking well I didn't understand the whole pvpsa
047and the Medicaid so thank you for that education if there isn't an offsho to that one would say well why why wouldn't we just stop it if it is available elsewhere and so I guess a lot of words there I said what I'm leading to the fact is there there's some more expanded information that I think I would want before I would sign my name to anything like this bear in mind we know it's just a recommendation is that you know what is the pvpsa uh contract requirements what can we do with that and then we weigh that off against the other the social emotional counselors and their General head and we aim for 5 million and see where we land with that and that's something I would then feel I like that I was
048to say I'd like to reduce um our first and second um or or maybe even also um yeah reduce our first and second um points of General Ed and social emotional down to um meet our total uh more closer to 4.9 or five million so then that way that it just seems it don't sit well with me at my core that we're cutting District off office reductions and we're cutting General Ed and Mental Health social emotional at 1.5 and 1 million and um district office reductions is uh sitting pretty at 750 it hurts my soul just want to call out there that there's less people employed in the district office than it when you look at all the sites so those other numbers are like all the sites combined and then versus district and then
049one thing I wanted to call out is the 750 is on top of the close to $1 million in reductions we've already done um and in the district office we have many many departments that are almost ful either fully funded by restricted Grant monies or mostly funded by restricted grant money so I know it seems like we have a lot of people here at the district office but for example food and nutrition that entire department is funded out of restricted dollars um U migrant e small Head Start um early early childhood so um we have uh yes so one thing I wanted to um um talk about in terms of how we're thinking about the reductions also is how are these getting funded so we talked about when the one time Esser dollars um went
050away um a lot of what Esser was funding and before that yellow um G it got moved into our district unrestricted and that's where we have to really we start reducing so in our restricted right now that is um supporting our pvpsa contract and we we do already have um ideas in mind about reducing that going forward so that's already included in our multi-year projections but where we want to focus is really on the unrestricted side so out of Esser all of those uh supports that we brought on because of the pandemic and to mitigate the learning loss post Pandemic those were absorbed by the unrestricted so as a team I think one thing we have to think about is anything that we keep on from the S doll and unrestricted then that probably means
051that there has to be a cut somewhere else if we're reprioritizing mental health as we did as a team um then it might mean that there has to be a cut in another program so all of this it's not just in the general fund as a total we're really looking at it how much of it is coming out of the unrestricted which is the important funding source so question um maintenance and operations isn't on this list because we got that beautiful M correct so actually for measure M um that's a great question um thank you community for voting that in so measure m is uh very very restricted money um State Facility Bond money is one of the most restricted forms of money um that schools can get it can only be spent on approved
052capital projects meaning construction projects and very very few types of um positions specifically to support um the program Administration so we are not able to use that just for any um M position um it can really be used for measure M projects and then a very very small amount on um uh positions to support making that project or bringing it to fruition so m is um pretty much fully supported by our general fund yes and just to add on to that um in the sustainable budget uh team meeting where we looked at our staffing and our staffing ratios one discovery that we had is that our maintenance and operations department is actually severely under St so that's why we wouldn't see that on and and to Echo and just underscore what Jenny said is a
053lot of what we're looking at is what was added during the pandemic to mitigate the conditions that the pandemic created and so these were things that were added and you've heard me say before we can do anything but we can't do everything and so when those dollars sunset as well as students um were not enrolling at to the level that we had them we find ourselves having to make the difficult decisions of what can we what do we still continue forward with and what can't we and these were things what we discussed through this team were purely the things that were added through onetime funding so the um outside the box ideas where we got to think and imagine life and education as if we were in Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory will those
054ideas be able to maybe come to life when we think about how we cut the budget next year most of the ideas that were shared were amazing and wonderful and and like I said we have categorized them and kept them uh but they were all additions like that was spending more money rather than looking at ways to um reduce so my idea was not an addition well I and I don't know whose idea was what we didn't have I had an idea to shift our school calendar and in in hopes to cut the HVAC uh yeah the HVAC and so that might be something but that is a negotiated item and so we would have to be working with our bargaining Partners on that and that um calendar has we haven't negotiated that I have
055an idea so we got together and we worked the first six meetings we took step bystep approaches we prioritized we brainstormed we got uh a lesson on how to read a budget it was all theoretical we did the massive brainstorming willly won in the Chocolate Factory that was kind of fun the homework assignment we were told on day one that this would be hard that we're going to have to cut something you're not going to get everything you want on your Christmas list after last meeting it got personal positions being cut people watched the stream they started talking I was just approached coming in here by a couple counselors that I see at sites with like fire and hurt in their eyes like we're doing something to hurt their livelihood this isn't what this is
056about we're making tough decisions people are involved D now that it's getting more personal we're all feeling it tonight has turned into kind of a retread a reassess of our ideas that were theoretical now they're becoming real so I propose I make a motion um to meet our timeline since tonight we were just going to kind of do our dress rehearsal for the presentation what if we use the rest of the meeting tonight to kind of readdress and amend some of the numbers and Cuts all these ideas that I've heard tonight are fantastic I've been pretty quiet on this Committee just because there's so many good thoughts by people closer to the problem than me as a substitute and a tester um I even thought tonight what if we just cut substitutes and let the
057teachers cover the classes would that save five million I don't want to cut my job I'm just saying trying to think as fairly as possible so if we have a ninth meeting January 12th or 13th during the SBC days like the night before school starts that's closer to the presentation two days later is that an agreeable thing we don't necessarily need dinner doesn't have to cost anything just our time so we can kind of do a rough draft Amendment we're not ready for the final draft yet is that something that's possible so we have to upload uh documents into our board documents prior to the board meeting so we have a board meeting January 15th um and then I also have a special study session with our board on December 19th um but if we
058did it like January 12th or 13th I think the 13th is Monday the 14th is Tuesday the 15th is Wednesday what if we did it the board has to review it on the 19th she's just kindly saying no because she's a sweetheart but if we're presenting on the 15th so they would review this what next in two days on the 18th December 19th gotcha so there yeah there what if we met Thursday then I'm just trying to think of an option to get out of our sinking feeling the consensus that I'm s sensing right now now we not really going to have a lot of passion in our present let's work through the hard feelings you guys let's work let's work through it and come up with some numbers this is tough stuff and I'm
059sorry I wasn't here last week you guys I was going through it but so I I'm going to just remind the team that we're a Rec we're recommending we're making just recommendations uh to the board to help the board in the very challenging work that you now see this is because they are going to have to make decisions and um that's unavoidable so maybe recomendation doesn't mean that these numbers are going to be the numbers you know like it's a rough estimate yeah correct so maybe what we can do is instead of recommending an option we look at the we present the options to the board that through our discussions and I want to remind everyone the options that were put together were put together by the core values that the team prioritized on our
060second meeting so maybe what we can do instead is bring the PowerPoint in its totality take out the recommendation of anything just B and D just here's some five ways that we thought we could move forward in making these difficult decisions and leave it there would that work can we add a slide of you know to represent our conversation tonight what would that side look like I we can add whatever absolutely but I don't know what like I I heard some pretty specific stuff tonight and I just wonder what that would look like in a SL yeah we can do that I mean what absolutely and I'm sure the board is watching this meeting too it is live stream and recorded and that helps you know to see and then the one thing that we'll
061have to consider as we're creating um the last option is looking at the impact to the unrestricted versus the restricted because like the pvpsa right now that's getting um funded out of a restricted Grant it moved from eser which was restricted into another restricted block grant so if we're reducing the um pvpsa even more it's going to impact on the restricted side which is not so much of a concern for our District it's more of the ongoing unrestricted side so as we're kind of thinking about those things um um if you give me a little time I can I can start to separate out how much of it is truly going to um be the change that that we need to create a sustainable budget so thank you Jenny for that um but I also
062want to ask then like this District contributes out of our G general fund our unrestricted dollars about what close to $40 million somewhere between 30 and $40 million to the restricted fund so I'm curious um if then if we're talking about how money shift from one account to another it's really not impacting the um the uh limiting it like oh we're only reding ing then in the restricted area when we are taking unrestricted monies every year to contribute to the restricted fund and we do do an unrestricted to restricted it's called a contribution in school Finance but it's really only for very specific programs so here at PB USD um we do contributions from our uned fund into special education to fund our special education program and then to fund um it's called the uh
063restricted routine maintenance account so because we are a district that receives State Facility funding um we are we are required by law to contribute 3% of our actual expenditures every year so that 3% goes into um what we call the restricted routine maintenance account to keep up with our facilities um requirements so those are really the only two um restricted programs have received the contribution um and all the other uh restricted programs so for example pbsa has shifted from onetime Esser into the onetime learning recovery block grant um so that program does not receive any sort of unrestricted um support or contribution it is all very complex School Finance has many many many rules it's not like your savings account to your checking account it there are many um rules and regulations that that govern
064how you can move that and so none of our are any of our mental health clinicians or social emotional counselors none of those are funded out of the same source that pvpsa has funded out of is that correct or are some funded out of there right I just want to make sure that that we're understanding that correctly yeah so currently our social emotional counselor are vended out of our unrestricted our mental health clinicians we have our uh mental health clinicians that are uh serving our gen I students um so those um mental health clinicians right now let's see are funded out of um unrestricted and then we have Sala mental conditions and they're funded out of the restricted special education for that in writing you can look at the sustainable budget team session number four
065and in on Slide by 26 it has how those are funded yeah so I just that's I just wanted to clarify that if we were to try and flip some of these numbers within it doesn't really help us save any more positions because it's two different funding sources yes and then the other thing about the learning recovery block grant that right now is supporting PB PSA is its onetime dollars um we have a multi-year strategic plan tied to it but it's um it's lated to to end um at some point in the future as well uh don't quote me on this I want to say 2728 is the year that it ends and it's already tied to um um some uh uh strategies and priorities that the district has already established so if we as
066we're thinking about what we have to reduce that's another complexity that adds to it um our Focus really is on the unrestricted because that's where we're deficit spending um that is what we're consider in um the finance where we call that a structural deficit because it's built in its salaries it's um it's our own people that we're employing so those are costs year-over-year they're not one time like a contract that that we would be able to end but just to clarify I'm I don't know if Nellie's question was completely answered if we're giving if we're contributing money from the general unrestricted into restricted and we want to make a cut from restricted why can't we just contribute less money from the unrestricted to the restricted restricted to offset that and that's a great question so
067because right now the two programs that are taking contributions one for the um restricted routine maintenance it's a required 3% so we have to maintain that mandate um each year and then the other program is special education um and we um have invited um fmat to come in um and to give us some best practices and guidance around looking at that program um but we're not quite there yet so we imagine looking at special education in Phase um in the next phase um of uh possible uh restructuring um by reducing the pvpsa contract by 500 or more what then does that help us do because if it doesn't help us save other things you know then I'm not sure I just I'd like to understand the purpose behind it like what how does eliminating that
068help us so if we were to reduce uh pvpsa even more than the 500,000 what it would do is it would open up um some funding in the learning recovery block grant um and then what we could do is we could evaluate the allowable uses within that block grant um to see if we can um maybe transition something and unrestricted over but one thing we have to keep in mind is that the source of funding does end in 2728 so essentially it's kind of what um the district had been doing during Co which was kind of kicking um a little bit down the road so can I ask one more clarifying question okay so it says general head gent General Ed mental health clinician reductions non-sa so that means we can't touch any of the
069mental health clinicians that are Sala correct um it does not mean that necessarily but we have to that's a lot of analysis that has to be done which we will be doing um but there are Services tied to students through special education individualized educational plans and so it's not as simple to just um say we're not providing those Services yeah I so we have to look at where at what do we have in IEPs how are we making sure we're meeting the legal um guarantees of the IEPs so it says reductions but what I just want to understand is is the 1.5 million actually eliminating all General Ed mental health clinicians will there be any General Ed mental health clinicians left yes there will still be general education mental health clinici there will be even
070even if we take that okay thank you so I think the the point is now 55 minutes sorry 54 minutes how do we drive concurrence for the deadline that isn't January it's tonight um I think we just want to talk like re ret talk a couple numbers I or do we have to stay with these numbers no we can we can look at that okay I what I'm hearing from from my amazing peeps at the table five different people have said that they feel more comfortable with staying around five million is that something that we can configure again I'm yes but I'm going to say it is an estimate and I don't want anyone coming back and it's you know 5.1 and will you so it could come in a little more and a little
071bit less but we can look at that I'm wondering if um just thinking through what you had shared Dr contras which is all of the options and then just having an honest kind of conversation with the challenges because they will have to make it's we're coming forward with a recommendation regardless they don't have to accept our recommendation but we share the process and we share the challenges from tonight and they're probably watching but um we I just think that perhaps it does come down to these were the options we were given it was challenging here's where we landed still weren't sure we were ready for that land and here's the conversation that we had as a result of that land and we appreciate you having to make the difficult decision yeah that can definitely be
072the approach so what I would then look at is going back to here were the different plans and again these plans came together through positions and services added during with onetime dollars as well as the declining enrollment that we do have to right sizee so these are the plans that all of you looked at and then really ultimately what we can say is you did devise your own plan which was fine that was great that was really really great um and that in the end this was the best work that we could do um to represent the community and the community feelings around what actions um the board might take and then if we want to um have a slide created that Nora recommended we can put a final slide right after this one um
073kind of showcasing and then here's the conversation that happened here's what the main points are maybe what we do then is some bullet points on what we discussed and then um and then that's that is everyone okay with that approach that's do we've created another option what if we were to break into our small groups for 20 minutes and Rec crunch these numbers it seems doable we're looking at the areas like if we reduce as much as we can from pvpsa and then add to General Ed to the the counselors that are employed by us and shift that 1.5 million to 500 shift the pvpsa to 1.5 million so one thing I do want that's just an example yeah that's a thank you Mike I appreciate that one thing I do want to um State
074around how the plans were developed is it was like Jenny said the approach of making sure we were looking at the restricted and the unrestricted because as Jenny described if we do everything from one it's not really solving um what we need to solve and so each so each of the plans uh reflect what we know uh help to solve the problem that we were working to solve we could though a different combination for instance like just taking this might not have that restricted to unrestricted match that we need we could though from the 5, 650,000 pull 500,000 out of that and we could lower the number to million for mental health conditions or we could lower the social emotional counselor cut to 500,000 and that's still keeps us over a $5 million cut yeah
075okay yes and um and like um Dr K said because we're working with estimates um it it if it seems like it's coming in a little under we might have to bump up um one of the areas um when we're finalizing everything but I do feel like we do have that flexibility especially with all the feedback that we're getting from this team and the community and we really want to honor um kind of this the spirit of why we put the team together um so we can absolutely look at that Richard that's a great idea breaking out into the smaller groups um maybe looking at the different options now that we have a little bit more information um the one thing I did want to point out um is yes we have to find that
076balance between not making too many cuts unnecessarily not being Draconian but then also savings today are savings going forward so if we save 500,000 in 2526 then in 26 27 that's compounded to a million dollars in savings so as we're as we know as a community we're going into another phase of reductions um it's not going to be a 500,000 added on in that year it's having been compounded so that's just one thing I wanted to just have the team also think about for the next group that has to be doing this work and we might have a really big Kinder group that comes in next year in the fall like oh actually um they're massive actually I wish I I um the Kinder Round Up was amazing I'm you know that would be amazing
077but um the Department of Finance actually just released their 2024 enrollment projections um we Santa Cruz County we used to be number one on that list meaning we were the number one County in the entire State projected to lose the most amount of uh enrollment over the next decade um thankfully we are now number five but it's still really really high so as a district we've lost um 18% of our enrollment in the last decade and according to the projections from the Department of Finance um and they're using um things factors like birth rate um from the Department of um human services so they're projecting for our County another 18% decline um by 2033 34 so that's one thing I'm going to strongly strongly urge um our team is um you know right sizing and
078not continuing to kick kind of these really really hard decisions down the road um because that's kind of why we are in the spot that we are in um and it's not putting the next team in a harder harder spot so and I know that this is um an impossible impossible decision so I was just kind of reflecting on our norms and like the top one being students are our top priority in decision- making and I still think with the exception of like the 750,000 from the district office almost every cut is coming from a service or something that directly touches or impacts a child and so when you talk about 18% of our enrollment um hit I I recognize that you've cut from the district office already and that we're looking at cutting a
079little bit more but the the cut should potentially be like proportional to that 18% enrollment drop if we're looking to keep Services directly impacting the children so maybe we could look at increasing that 750 to a higher number for district right even yeah I I don't know just cutting away from the classroom and um I just wanted to point out that it will actually be closer to 2 million because we've already reduced um 1 million already to the state um so the 750 is actually going to be on top of the 1 million that we've already did this year so it'll be um uh 1 Point closer closer to $1.8 million from the district office to because I know that you know a lot of positions in the district office cost more money than positions
080that are directly interacting with students right so it's hard to like look at the cut the number the dollar amount of $2 million and see like what does that represent in the district office compared to what could that represent in terms of you know adults that are actually interacting with children okay so why don't we it's 7:16 why don't we break into our small groups to take a look at if there's a different way or something else to think about which I want to note we did do that last meeting as well and then everyone came up with the exact same plan um so some consensus there so um maybe we look at another yet another way uh so let's spend the next 20 minutes in your small groups uh looking to see what we
081can do and then we'll come back and take another look okay I'm noticing uh a couple of our groups formed into Super groups all right it ended up being like two super groups I don't know what they're flexible grouping okay so we we broke out back into our small groups as we wrestled with the difficult recommendation and the request was can we take a look at it and what might we do um differently and have a a different approach or different idea so Jenny's taking notes on what recommendations come from that and then we still have the task at hand of the presentation just kind of keep everyone on uh line with what we need to do and so do we have a group who wants to come forth with a new Option did the
082hold on one second did this group decide to stay as is or no make a change oh s we we did decide to go with a smaller number okay we had a oh you thought it was no no no no it was four it was four to three okay go ahead K all right so our group um felt you know we last week we were we felt okay with our proposal I mean we didn't nobody loved it but we felt okay but we also felt it was really important to honor the feedback received from the people we are representing so we therefore would like to move forward with reducing the 5 million 650,000 we have we have two options our first choice would be to take reduce that number to 5 million take that 650,000
083and give 325,000 Less in reductions to the General Ed mental health clinicians and 325,000 to the social emotional counsel reduction we are happy with we're not happy sorry that's horrible wording we are we are fine with keeping the the bottom three in the proposal as is it's just the the top two really that we want to split that that money between so that would take us to um a cut of 1,175 th000 for General Ed mental health clinicians and a cut uh a cut of 675,000 for social emotional counselors that being said if we wanted to uh have the total Cuts being 5,1 100,000 then we would be okay with that too so basically taking 500,000 of that and splitting it 250,000 to um in savings well or less of a 250,000 less of a
084cut to General Ed um mental health clinicians and 250,000 less of a cut to social emotional counselors which would take us to 1,250,000 as a um total cut for the general mental health conditions and 750,000 for the social emotional counselors so that is our okay and we're fine we're fine with either of those options um depending on you know what the other groups say okay yeah Jenny has taken note of that we will go to this group over here no I was get that to you I'm well we spoke about continue to speak about pvpsa contract reduction um but we do I do like what um the other end came up with on um on wanting to put that investment into our mental health clinicians and social emotional counselors because that's what uh is best
085for our students as these are people who are on our campuses and are readily available in um the event of an emergency as opposed to oh let's see if we can get you in and go going through that whole referral process but we think that um you can cut more from the pbsa contract like another half a million and then put that towards your mental health clinicians um and social emotional again splitting that between the two okay and this group over here okay so we had some discussion um s the group thought we should just stay as we are and S the group thought we're with the 250,000 of the top L items so the same yeah once again normed okay can can we speak I one of our members thought it was really important
086for us to speak to the fact that this discussion was very very long very difficult and that we wanted to acknowledge the hard and very important work that the mental health conditions and social emotional counselors do for our students every single day we value you we see you you are not just a number at pvusd um the work that you do for our students and our community is invaluable and there is no number so we appreciate your work and having to have this discussion is gut-wrenching agreed okay so Jenny has recorded that she will start to put that into slide options a question that I have is are we taking these new proposals forward as a recommendation or are we recommending all the options and saying here you go we want to go with the
087merger the merger of the merger please okay okay so our next I'm sorry but quick I didn't if we managed to expand the pvpsa to 750 Now by five is that what I say 500 so okay the pvpsa contract reduction on the paper in front of me is 500,000 have we managed to just increase that yeah yeah we I think as a group we'd absolutely agree but I thought we'd drawn a line on the fact that the contract couldn't be moved that much otherwise we'd it's over here Nelly we have it if you'd like to look at it I I think what he's referring to is not the contract which now we've looked at you can look at it as well uh but rather the restricted versus unrestricted I think that's what the reference is
088to not so much the contract well also I mean going back to that comment of where you you are recouping I mean our 3% of our expenses is what 10 million somewhere around there whatever we have one of one of we have an account like that in our reserves so that means that there's like 32 million going somewhere else in the restricted so I we still think that there I'm sure with some Financial savviness being able to uh recoup some um for our unrestricted and that's why we are um engaging with fmat because there are only two programs that receive contributions from our unrestricted the restricted routine maintenance and then special education okay so there are two four six eight 10 12 14 14 of us and I believe we have 20 I think we'll
089end up with 28 slides now uh so what we would like to have is people present choose two slides that you would like to be part of presenting for the January 15th presentation so we're going to give you five minutes right now to just look over the present ation and note for yourself what slides you you might like then what we're going to do is we're going to call out who wants to slide one number one number two and then we'll give some time to um have you write a script for your slides so five minutes to look at the slides you'd like to present I think there are some of us that do not want to present so maybe we should get a number of how many people are willing to present before we
090divide up the slides that's fair okay how many presenters do we have for the January 15th board meeting four Richard volunteers as the parent oh we have two parents so raise your hand if you're presenting raise your hand very high one willing to one two three four five this side no what's your goal in how many presenters you would like to have uh what we would like to have is everyone be part of presenting um but we understand not everyone feels comfortable with that and that's fine uh we would ask that the sustainable budget team all attend the meeting which was part of the uh requirements when we asked for applicants that you would be willing to do X Y and Z so how about we do this where our presenters if every if each
091person not presenting can partner with a person presenting just to help them look at the slide be a support person to that person um so that we're still all involved in this part um now what I'd like is the so pair yourself with someone so raise your hand if you're presenting and we're going to have everyone just rearrange a little bit is it hi so people can see okay so Diana why don't you two partner and then nor Nora you're presenting right so do you want to partner with Emily and then Karen and the two of you partner and then I just need a couple people from this side to move over to the people raising their hands over here you could put your hand down because Diana's gonna okay since there's only only six
092people one two three four six people presenting can you just call out I want to present slides 1 through three 4 through six six 7 through 10 like that just count them they slide slide one is slide one is the pvusd draft sustainable hood that is actually slide one yeah I'm willing to do one through six but I'm flexible I'm willing to do one through six but I'm also willing to accommodate other folks so okay Katie has one through six thank you Katie for jumping to that yeah oh sorry okay so Nora you're doing what one through three one through six one six okay Nora went through six do I have a seven through I think that's too many then cuz it's I can do 7 through 12 okay Katie has 7 through 12 Nora
0931 through six Katie 7 through 12 okay Mike has 13 through 18 okay 18 how about you do 18 through 22 because I think it's going to get close after that bigun you are the big guns we just have 23 and 24 but we think we're going to add a couple more slides okay and we we know where to find you to help with that um so Richard I think that means did you already call a number no you iig the more yeah that's good the more presenters you have the the less a flow is going to I I I appreciate that everybody should be there but I think numbers presenting because there's nothing worse than this one hasd okay Karen you you and Richard why don't you guys decide what you want to do
094there you you basically are going to be responsible for slides 23 and 24 and any additional which Karen I almost want to say we're just going to give you the additional because we know where to find you easily I present as options that we I okay just for clarification because this is my understanding I want to make sure we're right the question is is are we presenting AB c and d and e and me and Jenny's understanding was that we were just presenting the revise that we're going to say here's what we looked at and then here was the recommendation and it's the revisions orinal so I think we do it like maybe make a so here was the plans that we looked at here was a revision that was discussed and then yes after
095some feedback from constituents that that there was um an additional recommendation discussion and then a different recommendation going forward okay so we'll be adding uh twoes two more slides so there will be final Rev rised option b and d so this everything here exists and will stay in the presentation but there will be a slide after final revised options b and d and I think what we'll say is this is the final final after the group heard from constituents and this is the next piece yeah yeah that's right okay so we will add that in okay on having that in right now to the actual side deck um however you feel comfortable presenting I think what we want to do is give the board a real walk through of the discussions that we had and
096the way our committee came together um the way our team came to our different conclusions and the considerations along the way so will this uh once we've finished or you finish the side deck is it possible to get it access to it electronically between now and January so we can make notes and decide what we how we want to e e e okay as we are organizing ourselves over here what Jenny and I determined will do is we're going to uh rework the slides to reflect the new recommendations we will slide send the slide deck to all of you everybody uh tomorrow will note in the body of the email who is doing what slides and then we'll ask that you send your talking points or any notes or script that you want uh to
097us and we will have that prepared for you and what we'll do is we'll put it in like a sheet protector and have it ready for that night so that you can just have it at the podium and then your script will be prepared for you okay um so that's that's what we'll do tomorrow once we kind of rework this uh just to make sure we have the right people for the slides Jenny can you call out what our notes are so that we don't have any confusion and if there's any mistakes you can correct us now yes so we have Nora slides 1 through six um Katie slides 7 [Music] through 12 Mike slides 13 through 17 Ashley slides [Music] through 23 and then it looks like um Karen and Richard sites 24 through
098and then the additional SES thank you so we'll ask that your your script like what you want to say and how you want to say it how you want to write it out basically the notes to yourself or even what you read out uh be sent to us by this Friday so we'll send you the Powerpoint tomorrow we'll have all the revisions we'll note what slides you're responsible for and by this Friday we'd like you to have your speaking notes when you send them put slide six I say this slide seven I say that slide eight I say this that way we can format it nicely for you so that the day of it's all just right there and you could read from it if you want or you could use it to uh just
099help prompt you okay does that sound good to clarify uh the additional slides we well we have a version that doesn't include an increased an increased reduction from pvpsa and one that does include increased reduction pvpsa or will both options so um we'll include um pretty much the final three okay revised options so we'll have the original option that we came to consensus on that total the 5.6 um and then the two revised from today okay okay so with that it is 805 and two seconds um I think that concludes our sustainable budget team uh what I do want to say is I greatly greatly appre appreciate this team uh when we knew that we needed to have a fiscally solvent budget budget and that it would require a very thoughtful process um as well
100as input from the community um we divised this plan to help get all voices and if you hadn't agreed to be here hadn't applied to be a part of the process and then Faithfully come every Wednesday that we had meetings um this process wouldn't have been representative of our community at large and so I really I can't thank all of you enough this takes courage and bravery these are not easy decisions I want to remind you all that this is a recommendation to the board ultimately it's the board's decision um but this does help because it does represent um as Karen said earlier the constituents you represented um through this process so I want to thank everyone for their time their dedication we had almost full participation every single meeting um and then for your
101commitment to being there on January 15th for the presentation I I know I thank you and I know that I've heard many many many comments from our community um with gratitude that you're representing interests so thank you all and we will I'll probably see you all before January 15th but uh if not I hope everyone has a very happy holiday season