001you've been able to help provide that and that's wonderful um so recently we had some go out that had some information in it that wasn't incorrect it was not incorrect information it was actually from our slide deck and on our slide deck we had looked at um what our staffing ratios were and then what recommended ratios were either by Ed code or by um like cspa and also our own U comparisons that we did between similar districts so um there was a information that went out in the paronian uh that made it maybe sound like some people interpreted it that we were already made the decision to increase class size uh so we had did not make that decision nor will we make that decision that's a negotiated item and we won't do that I
002want to thank Todd um because he was Stellar he did reach out to us prior to um that article the information he printed was not inaccurate it was right in our presentations and said that um and we didn't respond to Todd in time to to um say oh no no it's this so there was no like ill intent at all and Todd was so wonderful to actually do a reduction today to just say hey that wasn't accurate they're not looking at um reducing that so if you hear that because it caused a little bit of a stir with teachers um we are we are not looking and this group is not responsible to do that that is something that happens at the negotiations table and we are we the district has no interest in approaching
003our budget reductions by doing anything with class so just want to rest assur okay um so we are gonna skip all of the fun stuff by popular demand and now that we really know what our today we're going to start off by um some information requests from the last meeting one of the information while looking at ours dist I know everyone probably the amazings that we offer only our insurance GC actually so I think that is phenomenal um I'll be going over the next three slides um the way I have this formatted is I have um first a comparison of our benefits to all of the other districts within and then the third side is looking at some districts nearby mon and over the in Santa County what I did because benefits do uh uh
004very wildly between districts is I tried to compare light to light so what I did was um I'm looking at both certificated and classified I'm looking at each District's top tier um health plan so for most districts that's going to be their P or the HML plan and at Lake to Lake um I'm looking at uh the family plan broken out as if the employee was a full-time 12 month employee looking at the monthly employee PA per um what that means is that is the amount that comes directly out of the employees paycheck each month so it comes out of their gross pay so looking at this list we have um P at the very so we can see that our top tier plan is the Blue Shield Pop um and the employee paid amount
005each month coming out of their paycheck is $90 which is phenomenal um on the classified SI it's actually 0 and we actually offer full benefits for employees working four hours or more down below we have um the other districts we have um San lenzo City schools for Co Valley UniFi soel and I think right off the bat we can just kind of tell this is the money that our employees are able to oh thank you are able to um keep in their pay so this goes directly into the employees um uh pay uh paycheck it's pretty significant so if we go to the next slide actually I have the right here so here are the small dis small districts in our County um these four small districts um did not have the most current information
006available on their website so what I did was I searched for the most publicly available information from prior year so this is the monthly um employee paid premium cap at these districts so again we can see that PV offers the best um benefits out of every District in our County and then um this final slide what I what I did was I expanded the comparison to districts um both in North Montery County and then over the hill in um Santa Clara um I compared um a combination of lcff funded districts like ours um lcff of course is the bread and butter of how we're funded um what that means is for each student um the state guarantees a certain level of funding the two districts highlighted in yellow San Jose Unified and Pao Alto unified
007they are what's considered basic Aid or you might have heard the term excess tax or locally funded Community funded there's lots of different names for these districts um what these what sets these districts apart is they receive more property taxes because of the value of the um homes in in their district and it actually exceeds the guaranteed amount from the state so what that means is they receive money above and beyond um the per pupil funding and they're able to keep that um in their District the reason I wanted to include those districts is to show even in those districts that receive more per pupil um then lcf 500 districts uh we are still able to maintain um the best uh employee benefits package so I think that's prettyy uh pretty amazing uh any um
008questions before we move on to the second info request yes or the benefits package but the concern that the teachers are expressing is that they can't continue living here with their salary even with a great insurance package which many are actually expressing they're not super happy with so I just I know I don't have a solution here I know it's not our job to do that but I did promise that I'd raise that yeah I do want to tell the team real quick that we are having problems with liveing right now so we're recording this and it will end up up and just to let every was really loud all right so what I it's uh my name's Nelly I'm the um currently elected uh president for the um Educators Union in our district um
009and we this is one of the bargaining aspects um that we have uh it's it's something that we bargain for our unit medical benefits and um the frustration that people have isn't necessarily our medical benefits it's our dental and vision so I just want to clarify that um that it's not the medical portion that is causing frustration it is the dental and the vision um portions of the benefits um package that cause frustration I want to second that that was exactly what the teachers were saying so thank thank you for making that clear but the the point that the teachers said were saying is like well we're feeling frustrated with what we're getting and we're not able to actually live in the area to teach here and the uh second info request that we received
010was um uh the last five years of um utility expenditures um which um and um please uh correct me if I'm if I'm uh interpreting this um incorrectly but the way I interpreted this was to have a good understanding of how we project our utilities how we budget and to kind of see examples of how that looks um at the different interim periods so what I did was I went back to 2021 and I'll go through um five years including the current budget year um to show what are some um factors that we consider when we're budgeting for the amounts um so I'm starting um back in 2021 um so what I did was I took a snapshot of the budget line um for our gas and electric so um uh our vendors are pg&
011and spur and um this was also a uh it was a start of covid-19 so that was definitely a factor so we can see um at during the different budget periods um it stayed at about $2.2 U million and the actual amount um when we close out the year um came in at 1.9 million so that variance typically um what I've seen with utilities is typically between a 2 to 5% variance is considered um Within the normal range so we can see that this year there was a variance and that was likely due to the um school closures and saving on pg& and um and gas um some of the other factors that we take into account are um uh projected um increases to the electric and gas rates so uh when we create the
012adopted budget um we are typically creating that in April May of the of the prior year so in this year in 2021 um the adopted budget was created um by May of 2020 um and that's typically right around when we start to hear projected rates um and those rates can change throughout the year so that can also account for some variances so we can see in 2122 um the actuals actually came in um higher than what was initially budgeted and I imagine that's because that's when um business was starting to return to normal schools were probably starting to reopen um I wasn't here at that time but my um assumption is when it was initially budgeted um it was budgeted without possibly knowing kind of what the what the rest of the year was going
013to look like in 2223 um we can see that the actual schs came in um sorry I can't see about uh 2.8% higher than the prior period estimated actuals um but it did come in significantly higher than when it was initially budgeted um again I'm assuming that because this was a year with a lot of change um the this was also the year that we had um I believe some uh wildfires um some flooding in our district which I'm sure impacted um um what happened so this was the most recent prior year 23 24 um so in this year um we did come in um above the norm at 7% um uh under the last budget revision at estimated actuals um this was an interesting year um because this was the first year that we
014were implementing a lot of new Energy Management project upgrades through phase one and phase two of the climate Tech project so those projects included new LED lighting at U most of our sites upgrade at thermostats including here at the do HVAC upgrades at many of our sites um and more um PG and E rates were also initially uh projected to be um increasing up to 16% they actually came in a little lower closer to 12% um and then a portion of that increase was actually offset by those energy projects so that's a really great sign um we will continue to see those um offset savings um um for the duration of of the LIF span of of these projects which is great so if we go actually back to the prior year we can kind
015of see where we ended um close to 3.2 million in actuals um and we can see even with that 12% rate increase um it it didn't come in that much higher so that was great sign so this year um uh we had haven't uh presented first in term to board yet that will be tomorrow um but we can see um we're projecting a little bit um uh more on the lower side and the reason for that is because the rate increase has um steadied out a little bit so we're we're expecting a 1.6% increase um in 2025 and also the Solar projects at Calabasas and here at the district office is slated to be completed um in the early part of next year so we are expecting to see savings from those projects as well
016um the actual amount is um yet to be known we're hearing estimates of uh possibly between 300 to 400,000 um so that will be pretty significant okay any questions on um on the utilities thank you okay so we're going to jump right into what we've been uh tasked with as a team uh which is to look at the different options for recommendations to the school board we built these options based on the priorities a few different things one the priorities this team set up in the very that we've been referring to time and time again so we won't refer to them again um so we built five different options to look at we also looked at what were the one-time funding strategies that we added with Sr dollar so we added positions and we added
017programs that were designed to help and support our students through the difficult impacts that covid created um there's a Golden Rule in finance and that is that you don't add positions with onetime dollars because eventually you have to recognize that you cannot continue to afford that without making changes somewhere um I believe thoroughly that our district made the right decisions when we put strategies in place to help our students and I don't think any District would have recommended doing it differently but now and that's why we're here gathered as a team we have to look at those and say we can't afford all these things we can afford anything but we can't afford everything um so we put this package together by here's the things we added so now here would be the things we
018would might naturally reduce we also looked at how declining enrollment has impacted us and what things we need to do to address our declining enrollment uh during covid and the subsequent years as we recuperate ated from um the impacts of covid we did not address declining enrollment we weren't rightsizing that was not a time to right size uh but now we need to do that so that we can be fiscally solid so the options that you're looking at that you're going to see shortly are going to be addressing the things we added or else declining enrollment impacts that we haven't addressed okay um so I'm going to go through the different options after I go through the options and we're not going to stop and ask questions at that point after we go through the
019options you'll break out into your small groups we have district office Personnel who will be with each small group so that if you have questions or you want to get more clarification in your small group you can your task as a small group is going to be to choose the two that you think should be recommended to the board for their decision when everyone gets there to then we'll come to consensus on what that is by the end of tonight we'd like to have the two recommendations that we can all agree to um ready for the next meeting when we meet on the 16th so that we can prepare for the presentation that we'll give on January 15th okay Karen do the two recommendations have to Total million no you're going to see that there's
020a little bit of a difference what the two what the recommendations can't do is go less than that because we really do need to reduce by at least 5 million but we do have some recommendations where you might want to consider a greater amount I don't know we just put together some options okay okay all right so here we go um well with that I do want to say this these are very hard decisions and I I opened um that in the beginning these are very very hard decis decisions to make they impact people they impact our community um so one thing that was important to all of us as we looked at this is is how can we help people to retain positions what can we do where can we what can we offer
021and what things can we do and so we've done a lot of research to see uh what we're looking at so that we can make those determinations so when you look at positions uh we feel pretty confident that we can address reductions through attrition um so we're going to look at how now first of all I want to call attention to district office reductions that were made this year so uh the district office has had selected at the beginning of the year not to rehire a supervisor of Transportation uh when that position was unfilled uh we also didn't rehire a classified technology position we did not we have a coordinator of counseling position that person moved into a different position this year and we closed that position uh we did the same with an admin
022secretary 2 uh that happened this year in our district office a person took another position within our district and we are closing that position uh we have three full-time equivalents of parent education Specialists uh that we replaced from a in a different area consolidating them down to only two positions and then we had a secretary in Sela that we collapsed as well as a coordinator in El services so those positions are all ones that this year as they became open for different reasons we closed them so there's already a savings for this year and dollars that we save this year are like more more for next year so so those were some some things we were able to do by just being strategic we also took a look like if we are looking at positions
023that we hired and that we added during the covid time what impacts will that have for our teaching staff we love our teaching staff we don't want anyone to lose positions we do have 45 and I hate the title of this this is just what the legal title is is unqualified classroom teachers what that means is those are teachers who are not fully credentialed they're working uh maybe they're working towards a credential sometimes they're teacher they're people who are like I might try teaching uh while I work towards this other thing and in fact I talk to a teacher who's doing that and is working to own his own restaurant that's really what he wants to do and right now has a love of teaching but has other goals um and doesn't have the full
024qualifications we we love these teachers they help us they help us with positions um that that we need to fill um however these teachers are always because of their qualifications working on a a temporary contract they're not guaranteed employment the following year and they know this um so that that's kind of a um a good understanding to have as opposed to if I'm a third-year teacher I'm thinking I'm going to come back okay so we have 45 of those teachers um that exceeds the number of teachers that we would be looking at um that we hired in for during the covid times we have 13 intern teachers intern teachers are teachers who are actively working to complete their credential they're enrolled in classes and um they also are not guaranteed that employment for next year
025it's contingent on their ability to complete the classes but it's also contingent upon if we still have a position available so there is that understanding that they may not return the next year and then we have 22 potential retirements this does not mean people are going to retire that 22 people are going to retire but it does mean that in our district we have 22 people who have the right age to retire and the right number of service years to retire so that they would retire uh with their full salary in place okay so um knowing this at least gives me soless because I know we have places for if we are right sizing that teachers will have um a position it doesn't mean they're going to have the position they have right now um
026but they would have a position in PB USD um can I ask a question of these positions um do we know how many of them are like the impact of losing them I guess like what do youan I'm not sure um so I I put in like kind of cold terms are like are they being used slash needed like what is the impact on the students if we lost these positions there would not be an impact because we would be able to fill positions with our current employees yeah okay okay we also wanted to look so that's certificated that's talking teachers we also wanted to look on our classified side we added many positions in the social emotional health realm from classified also some firm certificated and we're going to talk about that um and
027so we had concerns like okay if we hired all these um different positions in mental health where where do we help people to continue in mment if not with us in other places and so we did reach out to our nonprofit Partnerships as well as County Behavioral Health um and some other entities that do hire clinicians there's a huge need in our County there's actually a shortage in those different places and so we feel assured in those conversations that if we reduce any of those positions that there are positions available in this County actually in this town uh for people and we would make the commitment to working with people towards a Next Step so we'll take a look at that so there is a high need for mental health clinicians across Santa Cruz and
028monter County through nonprofit organizations and County Behavioral Health additionally we have counselors that were added and are funded through onetime Esser dollars and those are certificated positions but counseling just as we've seen an increase in Need for um Counseling Services counseling is in need uh people have a lot of different options for counseling services they're actually in high demand um some of our counselors have recently left our our district to open private practices um so there's private practice there's nonprofit organizations and then there's also higher education um that requires counseling as well for students so we feel a little bit of soless in in that commitment to helping people to find next steps so before I go to the first plan so that's just kind of what we're looking at we do want to be
029um helpful these are hard decisions um but they are decisions like we said we we need to um make these decisions so that we can be fiscally solvent all right so this is plan a in plan a we look at a total of $5 M50 th000 the approach in plan a is what we're calling a right sizing approach this approach would be right sizing uh based on our declining enrollment so district office would make a uh reductions of $750,000 above what I we have already done this year so there would be more reductions in the district office um we look at we've already made this um 600,000 contribution and that's what by rightsizing and looking at our staffing ratios for our academic coordinator positions our academic coordinator positions are the positions at the elementary schools
030um that assist the principle so they administrative positions they require administrative credential what we did is and you can see the the ratios that we are following they're in our previous sustainable budget team we worked with our ad administrators to say if you have this many students you get a full-time if you have this many you're going to get a part-time and if you have this many you would not have an AC uh this year we reduced three of those positions already because we had a hard time hiring um and saw an opportunity well if we're having a hard time hiring we also know that we need to uh right size ourselves uh for next year it would be three more positions we also look at our elementary release ratios and right sizing those our
031elementary release we talked about um during these meetings that's a release program that we provide for our teachers so that our very hardworking teachers has have time within their school day uh without students so they can attend to the very huge demands of teaching like grading papers entering grades phone calls home lesson planning um so we did not address declining enrollment in in terms of we need so many teachers to be able to provide that release time and so if we right size we would be eliminating an additional 1.3 million we also added intervention teachers um during covid with onetime dollars we added intervention teachers because the learning loss from from covid was significant and our students needed extra support and so we added many positions there if we reduced those positions this is not
032eliminating it is reducing um we could reduce by $2.4 million so this plan a gets us to $ 5,50 th000 let me get through them and then what we'll do we'll talk about in our small GR and then I'll come over to you unless you want them for record can I get through all them and we can go back just to make sure we end up pacing ourselves okay ex so plan B is a reduction in the programs that were are completely funded by onetime monies so it' be just looking at those saying okay that we're not doing anything else except uh addressing those programs completely with onetime dollars not any kind of right sizing uh so this would be looking at the mental health clinicians that we added during covid the social emotional counselors
033that are paid from one-time funding reducing the pvpsa contract by 500,000 that would bring us back to a prepandemic level and we still want to provide counseling services for our students just not necessarily through us um reducing eliminating the coordinator of counil position and then still continuing with the district office reductions the district office reductions that are called out there is actually not onetime funding but district office has committed to these reductions so they're going to see that come up on every single plan option C is what we call a combination plan so it's looking at a combination of ways to get to that $5 million so we look at mental health clinician reductions uh right sizing the elementary release ratio looking at a academic coordinator positions continuing to right siize those we continue to
034have the district office reductions and then we look at a reduction of intervention not just taking um all the positions we added during Co but just reducing them and I do want to note that intervention teachers we would we are still committing to having one intervention teacher per elementary site yeah so that doesn't just we're not ever in any of these plans do we just take all of the intervention teachers we we are leaving intervention in place at all of our sites one intervention teacher option D looks at our social emotional counselors our mental health clinicians and right sizing Elementary release time not noted on there is this does include continuing the reduction of district office that's again that is not going away that's staying in place um so just kind of know that and
035option e this this plan goes for the Gusto we put this in here because we wanted to have kind of a call out to here's here's all the things that we added we've talked about our reductions needing the same team well maybe not the same team but the same format happening again next year because we will still have next year another $5 million however the dollars we trim now um would add it would reduce what we trim next year so sometimes districts do do like a rip off the Band-Aid approach do it all at one time um so we put this up here in case anyone had questions about what that would look like so you notice a larger reduction number of 8.8 million um that would reduce the level of reductions in the next
036year likely to reduce the level sometimes things happen that you can't anticipate yet so I don't want to make guarantees but that's what we would think would happen so in option e we have the district office reductions right sizing the elementary release ratios um intervention reductions all all still leaveing one intact for each site uh mental health reduction and we have 4.4 million because that would be eliminating everything that was added for mental health uh with a one-time funding and that's what boosts that number so those are our options um I know Nelly has some questions and then after that we're going to break into our small group so you can have some small group not some you can have a lot of small group we're leaving most of tonight for small group discussion and
037then come back for the consensus piece okay Nelly Jenny might need to answer as well um so the first question I have is what is the average um cost that you're using for the teachers that you're um speaking of like Elementary release um or any intervention what is the average cost for each one so uh typically uh for budgeting purposes um we look at kind of the factors that are going into what the hiring is looking like so right now um what we're seeing is we're seeing um more teachers starting at um not on the first step they're coming in maybe a little bit higher so right now we're budgeting um averaging around 120,000 um including all of the statuto statuto okay yes um and so just for people watching that don't understand that it
038doesn't mean that the the um employee is receiving $120,000 a year in salary that is probably a salary of like 60 something thousand that's what they're taking home in the for the year and then that is their health plan which is inclusive of medical and dental um retirement so stirs or purs whatever they chose um what to pay into and um taxes so just for the public to understand that um and uh thank you because that helps me then do the math on like how many positions is that um the other and so our counselors while they their salary schedule is based actually off of the teacher um salary schedule they just work more days um are you also using the same is that the average am amount that you're even using using for the
039social emotional counselors what are what is the cost so for the social emotional counselors um and what I did was I took an average of the current um payroll that we have um in our system so the current staff that we have and their placement on the salary schedules I don't know the exact amount off the top of my head but I can get that to you okay great um and how many mental health clinicians does the district have employed we have we have 22 uh the mental but there are 15 for um no sorry we have 15 okay seven of those are special education and eight are general education okay um we have 2 to social emotional counselors that was probably going be your next questions yes um I would get I since their
040salary was based on or then this amount is based on their average or there's it's based on the payroll how many sc's do we have counselors 2 22 okay um and are they so we have 16 Elementary sites where are the other our social emotional counselors are at all K2 so they're split part-time between each Elementary so you they have a share two sites um then we have two per middle school and then the rest are dispersed through our high schools a little bit different at each High School based on their the size of the high school Watsonville is much bigger okay um and then in um one of your options sorry I didn't yeah um so with the with option e this one um while it looks like this super reduction you have this
041little caveat of this option would likely reduce the level of reductions in phase three that word likely is scary and untrustworthy I I agree Nelly but we don't want to make guarantees for fiscal year we're not I understand um I'm just saying that out loud I know and then um for because I heard you say at when you were as you began to present that you've made and I and I acknowledge you have made some um positions adjustments and I think that's great um because there there doesn't need to be up and and if we're topheavy so for option C the combination plan um so you had stated that these numbers so some of these numbers were items or the they're on top of so our academic coordinators are already you've been right sizing them
042and so are you going to continue you haven't all the way uh we have on the plan a I kind of explained we could not hire three positions this year and so we just held them we didn't you know I wasn't going to pull teachers from classrooms and that's usually where those positions come from or get filled by and so um as we delved into our right sizing plan for management uh we set the Staffing ratios for how we would be Staffing um our our schools all of our schools in terms of management and so our staffing ratios which are in a previous um sustainable budget team we're following those so this year we didn't hire three next year it will be an additional three for a total of six over two years um and
043then uh pvpsa contract reduction so our district contributes $1.8 million to pvpsa um and I so I see that you're only willing to reduce half a million of that yeah the the reason for that is that if we are not having Mental Health clinicians we do need to have counseling services for our students um we we think we leave options open um that us supervising mental health clinicians as Educators is a challenge um and that we're and we added that during covid when the needs were so great and it was hard to get that those services and so in this look it returned that service to this the people who are most skilled for overseeing that and so we we only reduce it by that 500,000 bringing us back to the 2019 level of service
044uh because we have seen our needs lessen for our students since the as we've gone through the years of covid so that that's the rationale there okay and so when a student is referred to pvpsa it's because there has been a need an identified need greater need for um counseling services at at a which our mental health clinicians in our district can do but now would just they also go to pvpsa but a social emotional counselor could also lay some foundational uh social emotional groundwork for our students and we are looking at reducing potentially reducing various counseling positions and also a reduction to pvpsa in cost and where are our students going to receive that social emotional guidance when you're taking those people away away from them at school sites that are a valuable resource
045not only for the for the teachers and the student but the parents yeah yeah I um completely hear you and what we did on our um options like I spoke of at the very beginning is we tried to align reduction recommendations to the prioritization that the spt came up with and the prioritization ended up with mental health um down lower so that's what so that's what we did um I I hear you and I think it goes back again to we can do anything but we can't do everything and we do have to there is no way to get away from making $5 million in reductions this year and and continue to be fiscally solvent okay and then there is one other question that we had asked as the pbft um to Human Resources it
046wasn't here at this table but it was what is the cost of this District uh not no longer continuing with the Save the Music agreement we have amazing music teachers in our district because of it but again save the music does not provide money and never has for the teacher that is teaching music they've only ever just provided instruments to a school site but there are aspects of that agreement with that program that um are overwhelming is overwhelming for the music teacher and it is untenable really um so I'm curious how much that would cost the district to just separate from that contract and what's that's I know it's it's going to a cost as opposed to a savings yeah but we we we are exploring that um what we've been told by the company
047is that they wouldn't not honor us severing the contract uh but we're still having discussions about that okay yeah and and I believe that our save the music teachers are also offering release time at some of our schools so that was and that was one of the that was the initial agreement that when that program came into this District that our save the music teachers are not release teachers we have contract language for what a release teacher is thank you um okay can you just remind me what the ratio for the AC like because I maybe I I know we discussed it it was a recommendation from the budget person who came in and presented what what are our numbers again so 500 students or above above 500 I guess the threshold would be 500
048would be fulltime principal full-time AC 300 I believe is part-time yeah three three or 350 is a 0.5 and a less than 300 is no AC okay and then one of the opportunities though that our um sites have is that if there are additional funding that they have at a site such as title dollars uh that they could choose to use their title dollars to offset um the district contribution or the general fund contribution based on our ratios okay and we're not looking at APS at middle schools or high school because of the number of students we looking at ring school students uh what we discovered so we tried to align our staffing ratios to what's recommended or what best practices are um and so we're currently staffed appropriately at our schools and at our
049middle schools okay um and then district office reductions it's trick it's just it's tricky to be able to make a decision on that not knowing what the positions are do we have list so we we have identified a variety of different ways to reduce that we have not had the discussions with others yet um and so no matter what we know we we are going to guarantee that amount that's our um our guarantee but we're we're not ready to publicize that um I I know we went over it um but I was asked to ask again about our teachers on special assignment do does anybody remember how much yeah we we do have I think 18 teachers on special assignment three or four are within our Tech world so they help and assist teachers with
050technology use technology implementation um as well as doing other uh other technological supports uh like trainings tonight they're putting on an amazing um event at Watsonville High School uh then we have 15 teachers on special assignment um in from district office in curricular areas so in English or math science uh art that ratio is very consistent with most districts our size I believe we're one over on what um other districts have in terms of teachers on special assignment tied to district office so um one idea that was presented um by a group I of a group meeting I had with a few teachers um at different sites in the district was um a frustration a a displeasing attitude with their tosa um at their site and they felt like they could their classroom would benefit
051more from um assistance greater assistance in the classroom so I just want to bring that forward I'm not sure how much we're spending on the TOA program as well so I just I'm going to so toa's um teachers on special assignment they make what they would be making if they worked in the classroom okay so they that's not a pay increase I just want to make sure that that's clear for the public is that it's we're on the teacher salary schedule and we make what we would what we would be making if we were in the classroom yeah just to clarify teacher tosa is the lovingly called name for teacher on special assignment and they are truly teachers who just do not have a roster uh set of students who are assisting other teachers uh
052in curriculum or coaching um those types of activities Claudia was just saying do she was mentioning we do have um site based tosas like our reading literacy coaches those are Grant funded positions the district received a grant because our students are underperforming in English language arts and so that Grant specifically calls for having literacy coaches at sites and those are teachers on special assignment uh why we would not be engaging in talking about those positions and a reduction is because it's Grant funded so when the grant ends those teachers will return back to the classroom unless they find other kind of job that they are interested in and that comes from the 15 so we have you said three to four are in the tech world and 15 are in general is that 15 plus
053the three to four or so 15 are tied to our curriculum and instruction Department the three or four I'm not sure on the number are I think it might be three are tied to the tech department and then there are additional teachers on special assignment who are Grant funded so they're not from the general fund back when we first started all this discussion we did talk a little bit about the funding sources that we're looking at the funding sources we're looking at are from our general fund so those are not grants they're District dollars that is how we pay for our salaries some positions where you might go well why aren't we talking about that position it's most likely a grant funded position so for instance we have Community School specialists at sites that's from
054a grant it's a five-year Grant so in four and a half more years those positions tied to the grant will be ending so that we we do have a lot of that and sometimes it's hard for people to understand like how come this school has so many blah but it's because that school's chosen to allocate their title dollars uh which are meant for specific use at the site to doing a special strategy that they believe that their school Community believes will help students so I understand the need for the reduction in the 5 million that's the priority right now but at all of the meetings that we've had so far we have had a lot further discussion on the big picture right like what's going to happen after next year so I'm just wondering in
055our presentation and our recommendations so board are we only recommending around this 5 million and then is there going to be another study like this next year for so yes um so this year we're just looking at this year's budget and what we need to do in preparation for next year well I guess we're really looking at next year's budget what are the reductions that we need to make to be fiscally solvent um but we know that we have another year that we'll go through that as well uh and we will probably um engage in this same process but because we want to evalue and expand our community input to reach you know more people we'll probably just have the whole application process do everything the same from start to finish and um and the
056board is aware of that so does can the board just decide to cut other things without input yes from us so they could just decide to cut more say we don't like this plan we we aren't good to vote they could also do a vote where it's a no decision vote uh which when we make this recommendation we will have six members on the board so okay um yeah so so they can they can do that um yeah that would be an interesting choice okay yeah it's not I mean as uncomfort as we all feel right now we're making recommendations the board is making the decisions and that's really hard that that is a very hard thing to do no one likes this I don't like recommending this I don't like being part of this
057um but that is the job um and what I've tried to do what we've tried to do is really think through what's a process that we could all at least um give input too and and have an understanding of to me that was like only the the one thing I could give in a tough time is to at least make it transparent okay so what we're going to do now is your groups that you've been a part of for all these weeks you're going to go to your Corners that you've now established your spaces you're going to go to your group and you you are going to discuss your thoughts your feelings your concerns but in the end there needs to be two recommendations that your group feels like okay we can we can do
058this we can recommend this a first and a second and that's what we're going to put to the board is a first and a second I I guess maybe just to give everyone the next steps for me with the board is um I'll be working with them on here's all the information that we've been Gathering and talking about inbt and then here were the um recommendations so that they have an understanding of what it was and then um on January 15th all of us will present here's the work and here's our recommendations and then it will be the board's decision okay all right let's go let's give it 45 minutes and if we need more time we'll do more time okay it is almost 7:40 sit oh 7:46 now we're one minute late all right
059so everyone was able to have have a lengthy discussion about the different options and I think we had some thinking around maybe some changes that might be good changes that we can do in a a better approach so what I'd like to do first is Jenny is going to record each groups number one and number two just do your number one and two without any of the changes let's see how close we are there and then we can talk about okay we can accept this piece but we want this part changed okay because we may have I already know of two groups that have the same recommendations okay so let's start with Katie's group all right so just sharing the options option b and option e okay B and E and let's go to Karen's
060group okay um who's our next group Nelly your group just get as close without the extra recommendations oh you don't want me to speak not yet no no no you're going to we're going to I know Nelly um option so plan B although I we want to make it incredibly clear that it's also very misleading um and there needs to be changes made okay so we can we'll go we'll go to those don't worry okay we had we have another group who because I'm really holding it back thank you not for holding it back thank you for being here and C with also a lot same yeah okay so a b and a c so it looks like B is a popular option at the moment okay and then who's our last group who's the
061representative is that your group all right Nora okay uh B and D B and D add we also have strong recommendations for changes as well okay so it looks like B would be the first recommendation however everyone has said with changes so we can look at those changes so B and then our next recom recommendation would be D however I believe I also heard with recommendations so we're going to take the other things off the table for now and we're just going to talk about okay what are the recommended changes in B that we could accommodate okay Karen okay so we want 600,000 added to it for since we were told that AC reductions are happening no matter what and we don't see that listed there so that saves an additional $600,000 we also want
062to add Elementary release time right sizing to option b because it's not taking away release time from teachers it's just right sizing the over Staffing at this point which adds another 1.3 million in savings so option option b we want to add 600,000 for the AC reduction because you had mentioned that that's happening regardless J Wasing to okay and then we wanted to add the elementary release time right sizing to option b because that was it's not taking away release time from anybody it's just right sizing the issue which gives us another 1.3 million in savings and then it says social emotional couns to reductions but what we were just told is that that 2.4 million that takes away all of them so we actually want to keep that a true reduction and make that
0631.2 million instead of 2.4 million so that we're we're back to then we have 11 we're reducing it by half okay okay right removing the coordinator of counseling right because that was already taken on already so if we do that that takes us with option b a savings of 5,700 th000 it should okay we just discussing one option does anyone have a um disagreement with that approach would everyone still so everyone's number one was B if we change change number one in the way that Karen just said is everyone amendable to that so that means we keep half of our social emotional counselors intact we can we add in AC's which should have been in there because that's going to be in there anyway we right siiz the elementary release and that brings us to
0645.7 we take off the 150,000 coordinator already pulled out because that was already pulled out yeah okay anyone have a like no that we will not accept B with those changes okay instead of since we're at 5.7 million just reduce the soci emotional by a million instead of 1.2 okay just to give us a little bit more support there 5.5 million okay so reduce ion just 1 million that would take us to a savings of 5.5 okay million and that takes us to a okay okay we have a question on this yes I have a question what's the logic on your I see the Math logic what's the number of people Logic on that so we said split cut by half and so I read down to 11 current currently we have 22 too so
065if we do by half it would be 11 and if we do it a little more than half I think then we end up maybe 12 yeah to that as well yeah so the title of this portion here is the reduction in programs funded by one-time monies prior and the onetime monies came in because of covid prior to 2019 or up to 2019 prior to the closure we had 12 social emotional counselors in our district do we want to and we would never ask for our social emotional people to be on the chopping block entirely um I know that this committee uh did not prioritize mental health for our students um really high because we all know that you know yes the academics are really important but so is mental health for our students and
066we have major behavior issues so social emotional counselors are critical in as support at our sites um so it is I don't think that cutting any kind of service that we employ directly in this District that helps our students is healthy um and when it comes to right sizing uh positions uh like our intervention or even classroom we already have a procedure in contract that um that encompasses this and we do that every April April and that is when the district is responsible for making sure their stuff is in order and we have that ugly conversation with the people who are impacted what this committee is doing is presenting to the board a a footprint for layoffs so I just want to make that clear um and we have again a process in our contract
067for displacements we have also the opportunity to know what the ratios are the projections are for this next school year and have those conversations not at this table but where we can have a collaborative conversation as labor stakeholders with our district employer um so it is a I'm going to be graceful with my words it puts us in a position where the where it might be the trustees are making this decision and you can say well this is what the trustees agreed to but this is what we are taking to the trustees and again we have a process when it comes to right sizing for the types of positions like intervention teachers like release teachers um which is correct and I just want to remind everyone that we did not right size during the pandemic
068because it was not appropriate because our students needed the additional services and we also didn't want to harm employees during a very challenging time so we we had not right sized you are correct there is a process which we will be following we will follow all of that um this is just so that we analyze and understand the situation that we're in and that we do need to make reductions that we didn't make you're correct and we didn't look at that process and said you know we may have looked at it but had agreements that we're not going to address this because the need is too great I'm sorry I may have misspoken what well I was actually getting towards the that we've on top of that 5 million there you've got quite a bit
069of fat on the bone and we immediately said 50% to 11 and then you're telling me that we were at 12 so my point would be well why why don't do we not go back to 12 not and because we we're making Logic on math as opposed to numbers and that's my question is it based on one per site I don't know so if you're telling me I need one per one per site then what is that number and can we afford for that it's but just to play on on math is just not a logic yeah so we had 12 employed in the district and then during um during what after we received Esser funds and we were um bringing in social emotional or counselors uh we negotiated that our elementary sites um that
070our social emotional counselors used to be um just spread very thin uh across many many sites we were able to negotiate that social emotional counselors would be at no more than two Elementary sites so that's eight social emotional for elementary schools and they're still going to two sites so my perspective 19 years teaching in the district is prior to co we didn't have nearly enough support for soci emotional counseling once we got that money and we were able to add those positions it helped tremendously but those needs are not going away my other I just want to bring this up to if we're talking about cutting a million dollars from social emotional counselors is that on the Staffing ratio formulas the recommended by the state is 250 students to one counselor I know this is
071all counselor this is not just that one's actually that that recommendation is inherent to academic counseling only only so is there not a recommended ratio for soci counselors and I think the reason why there's not a recommended for socio emotional is because that's usually a tier two and three strategy and so then that's really inherent upon just circumstances it's very circumstantial so I think that might be why where as opposed to academic counseling academic counselors engage in very specific work and so that's just what um ASA is which is the um administ the counseling kind of like group is who puts out those recommendations and it's based all academic counseling and then the other thing about the um suggestions and changes from Karen's plan is that it doesn't have any reductions from Intervention teaching services
072and so we could potentially you know modify bring down the reduction from soci emotional again maybe not have no reductions but have a small reduction and then have a small reduction intervention CH does the rest of the group want to so so what Emily was saying is that in Plan B there wasn't any reduction to intervention and that's because Plan B was predicated upon what was added in social emotional for one time Sesser funding I was really looking at that social emotional chunk um but we could do plan B but add in some intervention teachers which we added a lot of intervention teachers through onetime funding um and reduce those currently there are two and a half intervention teachers per site we could reduce that not a your maybe at some our num the Baseline
073is every site has at least 1.5 okay some sites have more than that but every site has at least 1.5 so we can look at reducing that and add and then allowing for more social emotional counselors that could be something so I have a question on that the um intervention is purely brought into improve an academic standard is that correct yes intervention was brought in intervention teachers were brought in to give assistance to students who are not able to access the court curriculum in either math or reading or others usually it's typically math and reading um we we spoke as this is a group and GRE Charming group if I miss anything but there was a question over is there any data to support the the success of the intervention uh teaching and the reason
074we asked that is our number one as a greed group was you know the academic performance of our students now I would have to personally question quite firmly taking that away when one in four or one in five students in this District don't make the great from math or English rage and those are our sort of group initial thoughts yeah yeah to Echo what he's saying is we felt really strongly we should not cut we should not make reductions to intervention support can I so I'm going to speak to the data question that was asked our our data has not shown great Improvement um in fact we're in District assistance it's hard this is a very challenging time in education to be able to say like we should be seeing great improvement from Intervention because
075what we may have seen is even more reduction if we didn't have that so it's kind of hard to to tell that because of the impacts from covid uh but the but current data doesn't really show big but that's an a that's an average data yes that's not teacher B has been working with student a on Intervention and actually student a is an individual it's gone on loops and Bounds that's not hand for across the the state average or the district average students groups of students that intervention teachers have particularly worked with demonstrating growth I just think it's important to say I know that the group discussed the importance of academic supports right but it is very important to say we can't compartmentalize and look at things individually if a student comes to school and
076they have an emotional issue or a need they're not going to learn anyway their academics are going to take the back seat so until you address the problems happening that are causing them stress anxiety depression all of these things by providing them counseling they're not going to succeed academically anyway does that make sense so I I my belief is the soci emotional counselors are the most important because it's the foundation that you need for the learning to happen in the first place I absolutely hear what you're saying and and agree with that my C to question would be are these Services provided in any other fashion to any sort of medical insurance care you know I get I absolutely agree with you that do is there is nothing here that shouldn't exist or be funded
077nothing you know it it should all be there and we should all be able to pay for it but we can't so I I agree with you but it's like if if that service is available elsewhere in some sort of format then do we have to consider that as an OP can I also sorry just add no no to build upon that um and it could be more clarification for the next time we come back just recognizing the time would be the credential that our academic counselors hold and our social emotional counselors hold um that those credentials are they the same because if they're the same then that service can be provided by multiple individuals um if they're slightly different um then I would just think that would be helpful for the community to know
078okay and so they are the same credential but academic counselors are only in secondary and our Middle School academic counselors do play both roles so they are both the social emotional and the academic counselor um it is the elementary school sites that only have social emotional counselors and those counselors are split amongst sites the curiosity question that we had was wondering if like it was possible at all to have a contract say it is pvpsa where these counselors are employed by pbsa and they can then Bill to insurance for the services and then those counselors deployed to the school sites I'm going to have Andrea answer that question because she's aware of some information that's coming about from that so yeah there are a lot of shifts taking place in um medical billing both for
079nonprofits in communities like ours and in fact also for school districts nonprofits are all getting on board to understand how they can expand and Bill for uh Services increasingly and we as a school district are uh receiving a grant to expand our Readiness to become a biller for Select Staff positions and for select type of services that we can deliver to students we're still in Discovery and building our system so we don't understand exactly what the return on investment will be but that information will be learned by us um with a threeyear grant we're about to receive can I ask you a question Andrea about that because um from what I understand I think our School nurses and speech language therapists and school psychologists already um do this billing so that is through a prior
080program called Lea Bop there is a new system coming in play called the fee schedule for California school district so that's going to be an additional layer for additional staff positions thank you yeah okay so going back to B what I have is option b is the recommended top recommended if we add in in the 600,000 from academic coordinators we rightsize Elementary release we maintain 1 1 million sorry in um social emotional counseling and we had to remove the coordinator of counseling from there and our commitment is to uh return to prepandemic levels for social emotional counselors and then there was a little talk about reducing intervention teachers as well I don't know are we adding that or no I'm I'm it it's the coordinator of counseling we put in there because that was like
081part of everything we were spending but we have actually already reduced that position and closed it so it doesn't actually count towards next year's reductions it's being included in this year um ask a clarifying question so mental health clinicians reduction 1.5 million is that all of them or is that only some of them because before it said social emotional coun reduction and it actually meant all of them yeah let me hold on I have notes let me tell you that okay I just I know remember right now um that right now the mental health clinicians we employ 15 eight of those no seven of those are for Sela and they're tied to IEPs eight are in the general education realm at the total of 1.2 million for those eight and so that would be a
082partial reduction because we wouldn't be reducing all 15 so would they come out of the Sela would they come out of so Sela is funded by our general fund it is a contribution from our general fund to fund special education students in their needs I'm just trying to figure out if with this reduction impacts the ones that are serving students with IEPs and General Ed or just one group or the other it would be general education would take the General Ed it would take the hit however the special education those are are in place because they are tied to students with IEPs but sometimes students with IEPs no longer need that service or maybe someone else comes in and there's nothing to preclude that those eight couldn't also work with a general education they don't
083have like a special I'm a mental health clinician special education it's just that they are tied to the IEPs so they could still uh provide supports to general education students okay is if we were to add intervention teachers to this is there a caveat we could put in that no site would go below the current 1.5 minimum bare minimum or are we saying that everybody would just go down to one I think what is in our elcap I think some of that would be determined by our lcap okay I and I just want to go on record to saying our top priority was student learning and so I am not on board with putting adding the intervention teachers to this plan B option so I think I don't think it matches that WEP with everything
084the way we just discussed not adding in anything with intervention okay okay so that's Plan B I when it gets to when when it gets to that point Nelly it will actually be more called out that way with the trustees we still have this is our initial recommendations we have work to do with you this doesn't circumvent that okay the next one oh where did our voting go so option b with the with the changes and then option D okay option D is that option D right there okay option D is a is the combination plan yeah we we added it in now on this one so what we're not we're not projecting um so we've changed option D you could cross that out on your papers the the changed one will be what's put
085up on our website option D is combination plan it includes a full reduction of the social emotional counselors so I have a feeling I can feel change coming on right there um a partial reduction of the mental health clinicians that we just talked about right sizing Elementary release district office reductions and the academic coordinator positions right sizing those that's option D so I would assume based on our previous discussion that nothing would have changed that we would to say we would say except complete social emotional counselor reduction we would want to have that reduction we would want to keep to the 12 positions that were pre pandemic does everyone accept that okay so option D I'm just adding in the change social emotional to 12 positions we Al our group also wanted to add in
086the pvpsa contract $500,000 to this option option D Reduce pvpsa by 500,000 okay were there any other recommended changes for option D okay yeah so what our next steps are is Jenny and I will prepare a PowerPoint presentation walking our Board of Education through the sustainable budget team although they've been able to watch this because of how we've done it as well as see all the information uh we will have that presentation ready for the December 16th meeting that SBT has scheduled we'll have our option b recommendation and our option D recommendation for the board for discussion what we would hope is at our next meeting everyone is here that we all prepare for how are we going to share the slide deck or is there are going to be a nominated speaker how are
087we going to do that um we do we will make recommendations on January 15th to the board um and we would like all of the sustainable budget team to be present at that meeting as well as at the next so we can kind of go over here's what we're bringing forward here's what it looks like are we okay okay I want to thank everyone for for their work I know this is hard work I know that we will probably all have trouble sleeping tonight um this is not the work that anyone ever wants to do but I've appreciated obviously uh the thoughts around this that this this committee this team had helped in looking at how do we accomplish the things we need to accomplish for our district in a way that is acceptable for
088our students so I appreciate that because with just the lens of the many people who helped even for prep preparing for tonight we had changes and adjustments and so thank you for your input uh I know your community that you're representing thanks you as well for being here and and working through all of this and we will see you on December 16th Andy I'm sorry I just wanted to add um one more thing um um with the revisions to option D um option b and option D are now EXA actly the same so I think we came to a really good consensus um so exact same item so