CorpusRecord 169148

Modesto Board of Education 2/11/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / MCS Board of Education
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Stanislaus County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,503 words · about 109 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e okay okay prior to us coming back to order I'd like to refer anybody who needs translator services to miss Paula Valena at the podium thank you [Music] links thank you missena welcome everybody to the Modesto City schools regular board meeting of February 11th 2025 this meeting is now called to order in closed session board gave direction to staff we'll have roll call trusty Brown I'm here trusty Dy present trusty irin present trusty Lopez present trusty marks pres vice president Mahia pres president myis I am here student board representative Ahmad dagger and here and student board representative kavari Gupta they are both at Mock Trial so um they're going to be lawyers okay all right so let the record reflect we do have a all members are present except for our student board

002reps um can you please stand and join me in a moment of silence thank you well good evening everyone this Open session meeting of the Board of Trustees is being live streamed at the direction of the board the live stream is available on the district's website and the recordings will be available the next view uh for viewing after the board meeting MCS has provided an opportunity for the public to provide comments it is out outlined on the agenda the public has G been given an opportunity to call in and leave a voicemail send us a comment via email or appear in person before the board any public comments received via email or voicemail following the posting of the board agenda and prior to noon of the day of the board meeting will not be read

003aloud but have been transcribed and printed with copies provided to each board member prior to the start of the meeting and available to the public the voice and email public comments will be attached to future board meeting minutes for approval this practice will continue until further notice for members of the public that are interested in commenting in the future we welcome your comments if you wish to address the board During the period for public comment tonight on a subject that is not on the agenda you must complete a Public Presentation request card they look like this and submit it to um to the board president myself prior to the period for public comment if you you need assistance from our translator please indicate so on the request card every person who wishes to address the

004board please fill out one of these cards you'll find the cards in the lobby and you can hand those comment cards to miss Chambers in the back she's going to wait for everyone there she is hi Miss Chambers I also want to remind you if you wish to make a complaint against a specific District employee you should follow the district's Personnel complaint procedure copies of that procedure are available in the lobby as our agenda copies which outline the procedures we will observe During the period for public comment the right to address the board does not exempt any speaker from any potential liability for defamation if you plan to speak on a topic please fill out the card now as no cards will be accepted after the period for public comment has begun the maximum time

005for anyone speaker is 3 minutes for total of 30 minutes for those of you requesting translation services an extra minute will be added to your comment time okay well we are very pleased to welcome two musicians I hear from Garrison Elementary School to lead us in the flag salute um first we have Melanie asil Melanie is fifth grader Melanie is aad dedicated student and a leader on campus she makes a positive impact on campus by serving on the Guerilla Council and actively participating in safety patrol she's been recognized as safety patroller of the month and she also maintains perfect attendance Melanie plays the trumpet in school band just like my son does so go Melanie trumpet and enjoys exploring her love of Art and performance in through expanded learning opportunities program passionate about music she

006hopes to continue playing the trumpet while learning the violin multiple instruments wow After High School Melanie plans to attend college to further her education so we are missing someone else Angie Jimenez was also going to be here um but I'm going to allow right now Melanie to lead us in our pledge ready be I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God and indivisible with liberty and justice for all than all right we'll move on to um Dr nuchi you're welcome and announcements good evening everyone it's great to see everyone out here in the audience and also welcome those that are at home listening to us um from the Comforts of their home um I'm going to keep it

007really short because I'm going to spend a little more time talking um in the presentation um in two presentations from now the mid year review but I do want to send a couple acknowled ments first to the MCS team um who is here tonight um to share their midyear goals and their progress um um towards their goals and also areas for growth moving forward so I want to thank you for your time and also your commitment for continuing the that the work on those goals between now and the end of the year next I'd like to thank synergistics who is here um to Prov provide a recognition to some of our schools um for original board members from seven years ago it was seven years ago that we made a commitment to sustainability and synergistics

008was the first step towards that um towards those goals and from that time we have greatly expanded but it truly was synergistics um our partnership with them in energy management um that started us on this journey so thank you for coming and thank you for the recognition for those School sites that um have um made it to this award so thank you with that I'll turn it back over to you all right thank you so much okay next Mrs sherina Shams with our recognitions well good evening uh president mys board trustees superintendent Dr nuchi and of course our family staff and community members here tonight I hope you all had a great uh three-day weekend before we begin tonight's recognitions I want to take a moment to highlight a proclamation that's on your consent agenda

009tonight and it's honoring February as Black History Month this year's Nationwide theme African-Americans and labor recognizes the profound leadership and enduring Legacy of black Americans in the workforce and in the labor movement and to celebrate you may have noticed we are highlighting impactful black American icons who have inspired our own black leaders within Modesto City schools so the community is invited to follow our Facebook and Instagram posts um and um follow that those highlights there so uh now we're going to move on to one of the most rewarding parts of our board meetings and tonight we have the opportunity to celebrate a couple of really special recognitions these are individuals who exemplify the values that make our community stronger the exceptional students and staff of Modesto City schools and we're going to start with our

010character education award and our character Ed recipient is sitting in our front row tonight this acknowledges not only his efforts but also how he inspires other students to uphold the values that strengthen our school Community um tonight's um or rather the month of February's trait is compassion and we're recognizing latu Vega an eighth grade student at Loma Junior High School so here to tell us more about his nomination um is student services administrator Lindsey dryer why don't we have you both come up to the front so miss dryer can say a few words about lotu and then we'll take your picture here by the [Applause] board good evening everyone tonight I have the privilege of recognizing an exceptional student latu Vega whose actions speak volumes about the power of compassion he makes a genuine effort

011to uplift those around him every single day as a safe School Ambassador at Loma latu is a champion for inclusion ensuring that every student feels welcome valued and heard he has a remarkable ability to sense when someone needs support and offers encouragement with a quiet strength that makes a world of difference he takes great pride in his Heritage as you can see tonight and he celebrates the diverse backgrounds that enrich our school community Community Lau your deep care for others and your commitment for creating an inclusive compassionate environment inspire all of us you lead with empathy and in doing so you make Loma a better place we're so proud of you thank you so [Applause] much you set a high standard for connection um and compassion at Loma congratulations next we are proud to present

012our MCS hero award and tonight we recognize a staff member who goes above and beyond to support our students and families tonight's honor is Myra roas a student Family Support administrator at Orville Wright Elementary School she was nominated by Katrina Van waltrop Orville Wright music teacher we'd like to invite you both to come up to the front so miss van Walter Rob can say a few words about maida good evening board Dr naguchi I don't know how Myra does it because she does so much for our over right Community before the school year started she was posting on social media to get backpacks and supplies for our students which she distributed for them at Roundup in October she had Family Day in the park and she organized the second annual override Trunk or Treat so

013we have a trunk or treat in the parking lot of our school for our families and she gets donations of healthy snacks and candy and it's a really fabulous event for our community then in November she makes sure she has always has food distribution she has art Cricket's Cricket's house comes to her building to does art with our kids she is always there to help families who need anything then came December Myra in December did the whole month she was doing 13-hour days we have this incredible uh airport neighborhood parade which board member daily participates in and we do this with Brad Hart and the Johanson band and lots of community support and normally we all meet on a zoom call it didn't happen this year but Myra kept sending emails saying this is we

014got to make sure this is happening does everybody do their job we did so then she said we normally have a reception and Myra said to me I don't know what we're gonna do because last year we had a really big reception well she had she made a 100 treat bags for the kids and we invite our community and all the parade participants in and she had um Puch Pand donated from viva and then I told her I know she was going to make poule and I said no you can't do that so I went to Costco and got water and cookies but the next day that same week she took kids to Don's mobile glass and they go shopping and they have Christmas cheer and then this day after our parade she had an

015event at Gallow glass they take 50 of our families go there and have a Christmas special adventure and Myra personally invites them all so I said okay I'm going to come help you this is two sessions it was like a 13-hour day for her she did like whole month of 13-hour days but she's just amazing and I appreciate what she does for our family and I know the back half of the year she does so much more so thank you Myra for being our hero and thank you for choosing her [Applause] thank you so much Miss van Walter up for bringing that forward tonight thank you so much to you Andra and so moving on tonight we do want to um make note of a special recognition um as well and this is um special

016because we know that our district is deeply committed to sustainability and to environmental responsibility across all of our sites Modesto City schools works hard to create healthier more sustainable learning environments for our students and staff so tonight we're honored to receive the Energy Star Building certification and with that part of our program I want to toss it to my colleague um our associate superintendent Tim zley thank you sherina good evening uh as Dr naguchi mentioned earlier synergistic has been provide has been a partner uh providing energy specialist and consultant support to Modesto City school since 2019 tonight we celebrate our continued progress with synergistic by recognizing 26 schools awarded the energy star certification this represents building energy performance for the top 25% Nationwide in Energy Efficiency and ventilation standards there'll be a short video presentation

017for the 26 School awards or for the 26 schools receiving the certification Awards and then synergistic will come up say a few words about the program and uh present the district um with the plaque honoring um the energy star certification congratulations to Modesto City schools on three years of energy star building certifications in 2022 there were 19 buildings certified in 2023 Modesto received 24 Awards as 2024 concluded applications were submitted for a record recognitions on average energy star certified buildings use 35% less energy cause 35% fewer greenhouse gas emissions and are less expensive to operate than their peers all without sacrifices in performance or Comfort to earn energy star certification buildings are verified to perform in the top 25% Nationwide for Energy Efficiency and meet strict ventilation standards the following schools have earned energy star

018certification Beard Elementary School Bret har Elementary School Burbank Elementary School Catherine Everett elementary school elista elementary school enlin elementary school Evelyn hanshaw Middle School Franklin Elementary School Grace Davis High School Harriet kersen Elementary School James C Eno High School James Marshall Elementary School John Fremont Elementary School John mure Elementary School Joseph and orori High School Loma Junior High School Lakewood Elementary School Mark Twain Junior High School Modesto High School Orville Wright Elementary School Robertson Road Elementary School Roosevelt Junior High School Rose Avenue Elementary School Shackleford Elementary School tallamy tk8 school William Garrison Elementary School and Wilson Elementary School [Applause] it's right here congratulations oops uh so first just want to thank you for the the more than six years of partnership um we're very delighted I think I would just leave you with two things

019uh one is that the award for energy star is a bar that keeps Rising every year so it's scoring against all the schools in the United States and you're staying in that top cortile so every year it gets harder as new schools as new energy programs come out so congratulations to your team and and Gilbert and the folks that are in the buildings every day second is uh most school districts don't have even one building that's energy STAR certified the fact that three qus of all your buildings are is a testament to your guys uh commitment to sustainability so again thank you for the partnership and uh present this Ward to over here I guess [Applause] thank you president my as that concludes tonight's recognitions all right I can't take this home I'm not energy

020certified right our schools are thank you so much for that um I know the hard work that we've been putting in the last seven years on on this is very special all right um so we'll move on to our Board of Education reports so do we have any board members that have reports tonight all right trusty marks thank you um just a few things we've been doing these last few weeks we've all been very active uh Vis went to the CTA dinner uh all of us were able to go to that so appreciate our president inviting us to the dinner to meet the and then to see trustees from all around the county that night it was a really great speech and it was uh it was very well attended I visited the gregori open

021house this last week which I know lots of us were probably at open houses it was standing room only in the um the multi-purpose room and wow so many eighth grade parents and um eighth graders in the room it was it was exciting and Phil did such a great job of of announcing all of the fun things that were at the school that night and then we got to go over to the gym and then see what was available for the students and lots of Hands-On things to to for these eth grade students to see if this is something they want to do in their future so that was very special we also I visited the um I had I went to ethnic studies and viewed the we got to view the online curriculum and

022start that process so we're viewing two different curriculums so this time we did it and um mike always does a great job of just giving us that information and then helping us walk through it and try to you know learn how to do it on the computer just like the students are so it was it was really good it was a really good night I know um trusty Maho was there as well so we got to go um try out that information and then I also uh wanted to I visited the clergy Council today and they talked about the youth Summit there's going to we're going to host a youth Summit with them or we're participating our students are participating 80 students will be going on April 11th to the sheriff's department and it helps

023build collaboration between the police department and the students and there's some students coming from Turlock and also calaris this year so it'll be a really special event they hold it every year and it's a very it's a really great um collaboration with the well law enforcement with law enforcement um it's with the police I think it's the sheriff's department the MPD and the CHP so it's a it's just a great opportunity for our students and then lastly I wanted to invite you all to the parents leading change on February 27th it's on a Thursday night 5:30 to 7:30 for um students and parents to come it's the Martin Luther King we're going to have Martin Luther King reading literacy uh Fair we're going to have an overview of our Modesto City School's reading curriculum and

024then also Stannis County Library is coming to give a presentation and so I think it'll be a really awesome it's going to be held in this room 5:30 um on February 27th so thank you very much thank you trusty marks trusty Brown yes trusty marks already mentioned the uh dinner that we had the CTA dinner and I was uh very impressed with the presentation that was made that evening uh and grateful for the reminder of the great uh partnership that we as a board have with our our teachers and all of our employees but uh particularly we were some attention was brought to some issues that uh we need to look at in oncoming legislation that uh we uh can use to help help uh support teachers Statewide so it was it was a very

025good event and glad to be there with all trustees and Dr naguchi and uh members of uh our MTA Union there that evening thank you thank you trusty Brown trusty dy I had a few things definitely the CTA dinner that was really a good event I also had the privilege of joining Johansen High up in Sacramento where they had the music teachers for the state got together and Joe Hansen High along with students in our special ed program called the scald program were able to perform up there and there was a lot of people that attended our own assemblyman Juan Alan was also there so that was a nice event to go to we had our first meeting for the family life the fifth grade um health education curriculum we had that first meeting and

026I think it went really well everybody around the table really seemed to be on the same page of wanting to provide the right education for those students we had um I joined the El consilio for a mingle to meet the elected officials one evening there was several of us that were there as well and then had the privilege of going to Jo Hansen High to do their open house and um like trusty marks I was able to play with some robotics um VPN so the visual oh oh I forget what the name of it is the Johansen High where they do all the videos wonderful videos that we see his table probably was the most um the Viking production Network yes Viking production Network thank you so it was really exciting to see all the

027students enjoying thank you thank you trusty Dy trusty Irvin yes uh again been mentioned several times CTA dinner um I was there as well and got a chance to meet a lot of other board members and staff from other districts throughout our County uh so I really appreciated that um I was quite busy with uh something else as I was um directing co-directing and acting in the play over at the yallow so with rehearsals and things like that time was was limited um I also went to the um the rotary career day uh at the uh Martin Peterson Center all of our uh CTE programs were there they were making presentations about the programs that they were involved in in all of our um our high schools and it was good to hear about all

028of the different CTE programs there and and the students as they talked about what they learned um and their experience in those programs and then that was followed by mock uh uh interviews that there at the tables when they set at our tables uh they um we gave them advice I was there as an observer but um I got pulled into to giving advice since I am a business owner and have employees and so it was good to to give advice to our students as they prepare to uh enter the workforce eventually you know whatever their pathway is they're eventually going to enter the workforce so was good to participate in that so rotary did a really excellent job of providing the materials and the guidance and the um rotarians who were there to support

029the event so it was it was really great to see all of that happen on that day and that was it thank you thank you trusty irin uh vice president Mia yeah it seems like a broken record we've been all to all those um those those events together so I'll just say CTA dinner the ca recognition employees that some of our employees were recognized here but also recognized there uh shout out to them for all the great work that they do but recognized on a on a countywide stage definitely the ethnic studies I've really fell in love with the way we're looking at two um through systems that we'll be using for online curriculum we got lost in there there's so much so much good things and and potentially more other things that could be

030added there so that was pretty pretty incredible um we also went to the consilia for parents leading lead uh for newly elected officials uh we we were they were there all also hosted by consilio and the Latino pact of Santas County so it was it was for all the people that were newly elected um and everybody else was invited as well but mostly was focused on them uh and then also I just want to thank for the partnership that I know in the last few weeks uh lots of families have reach out to us what's going on around our country around immigration so I just want to recognize the partnership that our district is doing it's such an incredible job partnering with with organizations providing information and um H in our community and um again

031we're here standing with you uh with our our families and communities and anything they they might need in this in this situation that's happening thank you very much and that concludes my report thank you vice president Mia um I have a few things to report on again CTA dinner I um it was really nice being in the room with all the other board members in the county and being able to to talk talk with all of them and and just network was it was fun to do that uh I went to the eighth grade paranid and open house for Enoch and uh both as a board member and as a parent of an eighth grader that will be going there next year so it was really cool to to hear what some updates were and

032um to see the students that were representing the um uh the biotech Academy as well as the um s is it SSD pathway I believe it it is the cyber security um pathway so they were there um promoting um what they were doing so that was really great I enjoyed that um went to a strings and band performance at Lakewood Elementary School they had to it was really their Christmas performance but the uh instructor was sick during the first one so they rescheduled till after so but it was funny because they still played their Christmas music after afterwards but um wonderful scene seeing them all perform and then on a bigger stage uh I was at the county honor band performances which Spann two days three different performances at MJC Friday was the uh choir

033the so it was the all count choirs and then the Saturday in the afternoon was the all honor County County honor strings and then uh the county honor band was in the evening that Saturday so it was really cool seeing our students uh represent our schools they were some of them were in their choir um robes and so it was really cool to see them all there and it was a it was phenomenal amazing if you ever get a chance to do that it was packed but it was so cool standing room only only on that Saturday night and it was it was amazing amazing so I really enjoyed that and then last meeting we did uh we recognized our employees making a difference and the following day was it the next I it was

034either the day or two days afterwards there was the county celebration of our of employees making a difference and one of our employees was sent to the state level right and it was super it was just super cool to see them recognized um all of our our um awardees recognized that that evening but it was great to be there in support of the work that they do every day for our kids so um yes that's my report okay we're going to move on to the approval of our consent agenda are there any comments regarding the consent agenda items okay sorry teacher wait time I tend to go a little longer than normal uh do I hear to approve the consent item agenda uh move by truste marks second by um trusty Lopez sorry he he

035was faster all in favor say I I any opposed see none motion passes unanimously do I hear a motion to approve the order of the discussion action items so mooved by vice president Mahia second by trusty Brown all those in favor say I I any opposed see none motion passes unanimously this takes us to our period for present uh public presentations thank you again for attending tonight's meeting and showing interest in our schools I have one card this evening and so I'll ask this no this is not this something else so but thanks um so I do have one card so I'll ask the speaker to come up and and address the board come to the podium you'll have 3 minutes to speak and if you need uh translation services you'll get an additional minute

036so miss uh Latricia Beasley day thank you good evening thank you good evening board members superintendent and community members my name is Pastor Latricia be lead day and I'm here tonight to advocate for the classified and management employees whose livelihoods are now at risk due to the current negotiations these are real people parents caregivers and vital contributors to our community who could soon find themselves struggling to keep a roof over their heads feed their families and provide stability for their children during the pandemic we saw teachers classified staff and managers go above and Beyond to meet the unprecedented needs of our students and schools their sacrifices and dedication kept our education system running in a time of Crisis and yet here we are again facing another crisis one that could result in devastating job losses

037pushing families toward homelessness and deeper Financial Security I believe there is a way forward that does not pit one group of employees against another this is not about me it's about we a school district is a team every member of that team plays a critical role especially in our education system for our students success and the success of parents from teachers in the classroom to the classified staff who keep our schools functioning no one should be seen as just a number I urge all parties involved unions school districts leadership and the broader Community to work together in good faith negotiations should not be about who can demand the most but about how we can protect as many jobs as possible because when employees are laid off it's not just a budget adjustment it's families losing

038their sense of security parents struggling to provide and ultimately students who suffer the consequences I am a community organizer with faith in the valley and let me be clear no one should be thrown under the bus for financial gain the idea that some would seek more even While others face losing everything is deeply concerning me and the community that I represent what happens when the tables turn when the same hardliner Cutthroat negotiations come for any one of us we must reject reject the crabs in the barrel mentally instead let's focus on solutions that uphold fairness collaboration and shared sacrifice the goal should not be about who wins but how we all move forward together with the least harm done because in the end what goes around comes around thank you for your time and let

039them who have an ear to hear hear what the spirit of the people and the community are saying thank you for your time thank you again although we cannot engage in discussion or take formal action on items not on the agenda we do thank you for following the protocol and addressing the board this evening um and taking your time to come share your views with us all right so one of our students made it back from mock trial and so we're ready to hear uh your report student representative cupta okay is it working yes okay I have to say first of all that second semester is going by way way faster than first semester like it's already it's already February it's been a month since break ended which is crazy to me um and I

040know seniors have finished college applications by now um so it's much more relaxing for the class of 2025 and now it's time to focus on graduation besides that many other student events have also taken place recently across the district first up I know you've already mentioned this but just to touch up a bit a bunch of talented students from our district performed at the stanisa county music educators Association or scma festival at MJC two weeks ago they participated in honors ensembles for choir band and Orchestra the performances were absolutely breathtaking and every student did amazing side note I was also in the band next up on January 25th many students participated in the county academic cathlon a rigorous academic competition involving 10 academic subjects I attended the award ceremony and can say with a matter

041of fact that every competitor did really well also many schools competed in the future Business Leaders of America Regional competition this last Saturday including gregori Downey and Davis High School many students qualified for the state competition in April in Anaheim and we're looking forward to seeing what they accomplish next next up many high schools also competed in the county Mock Trial Competition past month the final round literally just wrapped up right before I got here the award ceremony is actually going on right now and just for context the final round was between migh and gregoryi which but we both did really good so I think despite the outcome the team will do well at State moving on most if not old schools have successfully completed their winter homecomings and winter formals I'd also like to

042mention that it was a great honor to attend this CTA dinner last Monday and sign note like originally before I came to MCS I was actually in Stan Union so it was really cool to reconnect with some of their board members and teachers so that was really cool from my perspective um in January I also attended the ethnic studies guidance council meeting where I got to preview some of the new piloted curriculum on new Zella it was really cool to see like a different perspective because you know as students you can only see the reading and the questions but then I could also see the teachers pers ECT of all the lesson plans and everything and it was really cool to be able to have a different lens on the curriculum um and then lastly

043a mod I will be meeting with the junior high leadership teachers and Inter High Council tomorrow to continue building our vision for an inter Junior High Council thank you that concludes my report awesome thank you I saw you you were wonderful all right um do we have a report from MTA no report and um for for csse at California Schools Employees Association Monique Fernandez good evening president maestas Board of Trustees superintendent nuchi and cabinet my name is Monique Fernandez I'm an executive board member of CCA Modesto chapter7 I'm here to provide an update on several important matters that directly impact the well-being of our members and the future of Modesto City schools we believe it is crucial to remain transparent and collaborative as we move forward together this past week we've met with HR to

044discuss the proposed layoffs affecting our members we want to express our unwavering commitment to supporting our members during this difficult time while we understand that the district faces significant challenges our top priority remains protecting the livelihoods and well-being of its employees our members provide vital services that keep the district running smoothly including in-class support with direct student contact and we still believe that every possible Avenue should be explored to prevent any unnecessary layoffs moving forward um next our local chapter Modesto 7 was established on February 5th 1955 uh it's important to reflect on the hard work and dedication that has shaped our Organization for seven decades we have diligently represented our members right rights and needs as employees of Modesto City schools we are proud of the advocacy we have provided and the collective progress

045we have made in ensuring that our members have a voice in the decisions that affect their professional lives this anniversary represents not only our longevity but also the strength and resilience of the relationship between our organization and Modesta City Schools we look forward to continuing this partnership and advocating for the best interests of our members in the years ahead with that said I'd also like to point out the importance of our classified positions here at medesa City Schools our classified positions play a critical role in the day-today operations from maintenance staff custodial clerical par professionals bus operators campus supervisors and many other staff we are essential in maintaining the infrastructure and educational environment for students and staff alike these positions May often go unnoticed but they are indispensable to the smooth functioning of our district

046it is vital that the district continues to recognize the value these employees bring and ensure that they are supported as key contributors to the educational missions of MCS and finally we would like to express our interest in being an active part of the selection process for the new superintendent as labor Partners we believe that our participation in the process is essential for ensuring that the needs of our members are considered in this important decision collab oration early in the process will not only help Foster a positive relationship with the incoming superintendent but will also ensure that labor considerations are integrated into the decision-making process we are eager to work alongside the board and superintendent to identify a leader who will be dedicated to the success of MCS and the well-being of our entire staff as

047always we thank you for your attention to these matters and for your continued support thank you M fernandz for that report all right we'll move on to our report on the 2025 26 Governor's budget proposal Mr zly thank you president my Estus good evening again trustees quick um on January 21st Deputy superintendent gdau and I joined representatives from the Modesto Teachers Association and California School Employees Association to hear School Services of California present the governor's budget proposal for 226 the governor's budget is just the beginning of the budget development process for for us um but it allows us to estimate the types and amounts of revenues to project for the 25 26 school year school Services graciously allows us to use their slides uh for a board presentation uh so you'll notice uh in upcoming

048slides they're different from the look of the slide that you see on the screen which is our traditional uh PowerPoint theme slide for our presentations in order for our vision to be successful our budget priorities um need to support um the Modesto City School's Vision which you see um here on the screen the pandemic budgets we have seen in the past are gone uh and education funding appears to be stabilized however concerns are currently being raised on how the governor proposes to fund uh proposition 98 in the current year as the governor provides a proposal that could under appropriate the the current year 2425 minimum guarantee by $1.6 billion for 2526 the governor proposes an education budget that contains a respectable cost of living adjustment uh and strengthens core instruction and learning we'll be Clos

049closely monitoring the economy to see if there will be any necessary changes needed at the May revision while the financial impacts of what could be the most devastating natural disaster in the US History are unknown uh the governor had to meet the Constitutional obligation of releasing the state budget uh just a few days after the Los Angeles area fires the governor's budget presents tenants of stability and resilience uh but persistent inflation potential impacts of tariffs and changes in immigration policy could make the proposed budget vulner vulnerable as we move farther into the spring at this time last year for comparison the state was facing a 38 to 68 billion deficit uh however this year's proposal projects an operating surplus of $7 billion proposition 98 funding remains strong in the governor's budget proposal and fully funds

050an estimated 2.43% Cola increasing the local control funding formula based funding rates and provide significant one-time discretionary funding to address unspecified Rising costs uh student support and professional development this chart illustrates that proposition 98 continues to be the majority share of the state budget averaging 55% since 2015 while there are fewer built-in risk to proposition 98 this year than previous years uh enrollment and attendance declines continue to be a concern across the state in addition the 2024 tax filing deadline for Los Angeles County has been extended due to the recent natural disasters LA County makes up 25% of the total state population and is home to 14 Fortune 500 companies so the tax collection for the May revision will be an estimate until personal and corporate income tax returns are filed later this year 2021

051in the middle of this chart reflects the pandemic school year and you'll notice um that there is a zero there on on top of that for annual Investments that was a year we got stable funding um because of the pandemic um but subsequent years show significant investments in the local control funding formula coming out of the pandemic with the high year being 2223 um you'll notice that the orange or yellowish um piece of that particular bar on top um those are annual Investments That year to the local control funding formula um and then um last year or this current year 2425 um a much smaller um annual investment from the prior year um that was due to um concerns with the economy um that we are currently in right now here you can see the

052impact of the proposed 2.43% Cola on the local control funding formula base rates um per grade level as well as the add-on for transitional kindergarten and supplemental and concentration Grant amounts both the supplemental and concentration Grant amounts are maximums uh and must be multiplied by our unduplicated pupil and average daily attendance percentages to get the funded amount uh per pupil um those um the the supplemental Grant and concentration Grant amounts that you see um that would be if we had 100% attendance and 100% unduplicated pupil percentage uh population we have neither of those so you have to multiply it um by those factors to get the actual funded rates this chart shows that um recent statutory Cola increases do not always translate um to real dollar increases um using Statewide averages so this chart reflects

053um all the districts in the state of California Statewide averages um the yellow is the statutory Cola um the amount on the right the the lines in in the blue um that is Statewide averages um for actual cola this is due to declining enrollment um in expiration of covid-19 hold harmless attendance Protections in 2526 the coming budget year the 2122 attendance percentage will be gone from the three prior year average calculation um and then the question marks you see for 2425 and 2526 that will remain until those years are certified um this chart shows the differences in financial accounting for federal and state covid funding U Federal Esser funds um which is gray uh in on this chart were recorded by school districts including us uh in the year that they were spent beginning in

0542020 21 um and fully expired on September 30th of 24 so you'll notice that um in this this is Statewide data um 6.5 6.1 and 6.4 so districts seem to spend the the the equalent amount of money each year um these were Federal Esser funds um while the majority of State funds which is the blue the dark blue on this this graph were recorded in 2223 the year they were received um that's the difference between Federal accounting rules and state accounting rules and these will be fully uh expired in the year 2728 in 2223 nearly 6% of all School District Workforce was funded across the state of California with one-time funds um as we have already done twice um the Staffing from onetime funding needs to be addressed either with reductions or identification of an

055ongoing funding source uh for those positions that were added in 201223 um with one-time funds our existing covid funds reduction plan includes a third year of reductions uh to be identified in 2526 and implemented in 26 27 school year there so you can see we're not unlike all the other districts in state of California um in utilizing um the pandemic funds um for Staffing uh Personnel this is the school Services California Financial projection dart board um we use these percentages in building the budget um not only for the budget year but projection years um I've highlighted some things of interest uh you can see uh the planning Cola um for from the Department of Finance um it it appears to be stabilized or stabilizing um current year of 1.07% 2.43% um in the budget year

056and then around three and a half% for the projection years uh of the multi-year projection however the the line immediately below it is the California Consumer Price Index um this shows how much um uh consumer prices are expected to increase year-over-year um um and that puts a burden not only on the district but that puts a burden on our employees as well um when we're talking about uh cost Del living adjustments to our Revenue um in in two and a half to three and a half percent um and the Consumer Price Index for the State of California um is in the high tw's almost 3% so it's a challenge um we're fortunate to be stabilizing where we have projected colas in a multi-year projection um however as mentioned earlier the continued um cost pressure of

057price increases is going to remain not only for our employees um but for the district as well and then calper employer rate um that is um the retirement plan for um the majority of our classified members uh 27.5% in the current year um that rises to 28.2% um in the third year of the projection year 28 29 fortunately uh Cal sters which is the majority of our certificated members um that is flat uh 19.1% no increases um in the budget year um nor the three projection years this is the state budget process from the release of the governor's budget proposal in January um to adoption of the state budget um by June 15th that's the statutory deadline um for state legislators to pass a budget um so you can see um what's going on in

058Sacramento uh up to that point um and this is our district um Financial uh reporting cycle it is a continuous cycle of planning updating reporting um revisions are made um to the initial budget monthly and are officially approved at first and second interm reporting periods uh so you can see next month um there will be for the current year there will be another inter reporting uh period coming up um and then um as mentioned last time uh at first interim our reporting Cycles has been revised to include uh quarterly internal monitoring views um those are outlined in red there on the screen that will help us better align with first interim second interim and estimated actuals uh to ensure that we are appropriately progressing uh with our planned expenditures for the year next steps for

059budget development um we are currently holding budget meetings with school sites and individual uh District departments as previously mentioned on the last slide our second entering report for the current year um will be updated to include um Governor's budget proposal in our multi-year projection we're awaiting the governor's May revision um as mentioned though um that there's a large amount in the state of California that's not going to have to file their taxes by April 15th um so this is going to be an estimate um estimating tax collections that will come um later in the year and then in June we will have our public hearing uh to adopt the 2526 local control accountability plan and the proposed budget you president my Estus all right thank you so much are there any comments from the public

060on this agenda item all right seeing none are there any comments or questions from the board all right seeing none this was just a report so thank you very much for that um we've got a very long review coming up and I've been asked for a break so if we can we're going to take a short five minute break right before the review okay okay we got another one but we're going to still take a short break so five minutes go e and in the meantime I'm going to ask all central office folks that are presenting to come to the front as opposed to hanging out in the back e e e okay all right we're missing one so that presentation up right all right I think we are ready for uh for all of

061you to shine right are you ready to shine right okay see here we go okay um Media review superintendent a Gucci wonderful thank you thank you president maestas so tonight I have the privilege of kicking off the year review presentation um it will go over the progress that we've made thus far this year but also highlight some areas uh that is areas of challenging and areas that we need to do continued work on um the purpose of this presentation is to provide the Board of Trustees with a clear understanding of how the district is performing in relationship to key performance indicators as well as where we continue to face those challenges everything we disc discuss tonight is aligned with our strategic goals which serve as the foundation to our lcap or the local control accountability

062plan our goals are directly tied to our vision and you see this in each presentation that we do all the decisions that we make relative to our goals work towards ensuring that every student graduates with the skills the knowledge and the character traits to thrive and contribute to society while we have made progress over this past year and in some cases some significant progress there is still work ahead something to consider and you hear me say this often systemic sustained change in education in a district our size takes time it doesn't happen overnight it requires intentional effort and it's guided through thoughtful planning reflection and presentations like the one we're doing tonight I strongly believe that our continued alignment to the Strategic goals that you see each and every um board presentation coupled with intentional

063professional learning which has been developed through our cipd department for everyone in the system is paying off it is through this professional development that we are supporting our teachers in enhancing instructional practices empowering our site administrators to strengthen their instructional leadership equip our essential staff that we heard from earlier to better support our individual students and engage our parents who are essential to our Student Success this Collective effort is making a meaningful impact on our district I want to take a moment and express my gratitude to the team thank you for moving up instead of hanging out in the back there um for their continued um support in preparing this report and this presentation I know it was a lot of hard work and I'm sure that they lost a few minutes of sleep last

064night as they were thinking through and going over in their heads what they were going to say but more importantly a thank you and a thank you to go forward and that is continuing your urgency as we move forward this year to the end of the year we don't need to miss a beat we need to continue to have the urgency that I continue to talk about that cabinet continues to talk about so to frame tonight's presentation um first off six years ago um actually need to go here um six years ago in an effort to create an accountability system for the central office six years ago we were building an organizational structure and you will we will talk about that February 24th we were building a structure but as we were building a central

065office structure of support you all the board at the time said they wanted to see an accountability system to what we were building so our accountability system for um our central office staff we built around what we call a network structure and you see the networks up here each Network consists of cross-sectional departments because we recognize in order to be able to do work you have to work with different elements of the district so we've strategically put indiv different departments together to burn a collect a collective effort at the end of each year we take a look at where we were the year before where what goals we need to have as it aligns to our strategic goal we identify specific metrics and throughout the year we report through our networks where we are in

066this process so this will be the third time that the net networks net that the networks have presented on their progress or lack thereof earlier this month all the networks came together for a full day review and everybody reviews the different goals looks at the progress provides feedback and input for areas where we see barriers so we continue to move forward so that frames our Network structure which you we see tonight so a little bit of logistics and I am finishing up I know it's a long one um each network will report out through the network lead however the entire network is here so if you have questions that the network lead can't answer they are here to be able to provide feedback when the board has an opportunity to ask questions each network will

067re will report out in four areas one what is their goal secondly what is their key performance cator third what actions have been taken thus far and then what's the next steps if there's barriers what what do we need to do differently as we move forward to the end of the year additionally you're going to see some color coding I'm big on the color coding green is great right and red is not so great two years ago I really challenged the district to not just grow but to do double digit growth so if you're seeing green that means that's double digit growth or they met the target of that P specific goal if if you see yellow it's not bad it's just growth it just hasn't it's just not at the level of where we

068want it to see because we are really pushing um pushing the envelope there and lastly you'll see red there's there is some red up there and and that's work that needs to be done so there's the color coding next um you're going to see an acronym handout you all have that um to help you navigate the educational terminology that all of our teams are well versed in while I have asked to have fewer acronyms recognize this is just part of the language we use we have a different language in education and not everyone can follow the bouncing ball so we've provided you them support something that you're going to see in almost every single slide is boy beginning of year M oy middle of year and eoy end of year we should be comparing the

069beginning to the middle for the most part but if we don't have a middle of the Year Benchmark we will do last year to this year um in in few cases I'm down to my last three bullets there is one deviation to this presentation and that is Business Services um Business Services um is going to add in just a short little blurb on um facility updates that was not a network goal but I do know that it's it is of interest um where we are relative to um a lot of our bond work and the and the work that we're doing around our bond around our facilities so we deviate a little bit and Mr zley is going to start out and and get that deviation over with in the middle of the presentation we

070will pause um to ask to allow the board to ask questions and comments get questions and comments or U Get comments from the public and then we can take a break if you need it or not depending upon where the board is at that time so with that I am going to turn it over to Brad gdau um he's going to um support Steve Hurst who is unable to be here tonight um in really framing the work around the elcap EXC me excuse me and I'm going to turn it over to Mr G okay Dr oh perfect so good evening board uh a key aspect of our work is not just communicating to our crucial education or educational Partners but to engage with them on a meaningful level uh this slide showcases the various efforts

071led by District staff to engage with many of our educational Partners as part of the local control accountability plan process aka the lcap the feedback from our education Partners is a crucial part of the process as we work to develop our lcap goals actions and services so our Focus remains steadfast in monitoring and reviewing the 2024 through 2027 lcap plan to ensure we are meeting our goals and addressing the needs of our students staff and Community for a comprehensive overview of our progress with regard to actions metrics and and midyear expenditures I refer you to the 2025 lcap midyear monitoring report which has been included in today's or tonight's agenda additionally we will bring the 2526 lcap for Board review input and approval in June now I'd like to introduce associate superintendent of Business Services

072Tim zley thank you Brad um our business services Network League lead is Chris Atwell senior director of nutrition services um Chris couldn't be here tonight but I was going to do the presentation anyway on behalf uh of Business Services um and our Network goal is to improve quality customer service through efficient operations and Communications to support our students staff and Community the key performance indicators to support our customer service goal are nutrition services uh elementary schools to be offered a special lunch option uh this will help promote perfect attendance positive student behaviors and student outcomes for students selected by the site Administration while providing students with an exceptional dining experience uh Financial Services uh provide meaningful and collaborative Financial Training to principles administrative assistants and bookkeepers driven by their individual site needs uh Transportation prepare

073for and Implement special education transportation services for our adult students with disabilities um those are 18 to 22 year olds uh in the transitions program sustainability uh increase our School site participation in school sustainability projects risk management uh in particular workers compensation offer meaningful temporary work opportunities for work related injured employees uh that will provide doctor approved productive work during their recovery period um and school safety improve the school safety safety officer incident response time from currently 10 minutes uh to eight minutes uh that is the time call is received uh to arrival at the school site actions taken to date to per to um for each one of those key performance indicators um first semester we held six American Graffiti themed meal celebrations to support positive School culture and attendance awareness um senior director

074Chris Atwell has committed um for a second semester doing this weekly um if the demand is there um in order for us to get to all of our elementary school sites um all of our new principal 6 uh received one to one individual budget training um by November of 2024 um we held four uh monthly Administrative Assistant bookkeeper meetings um there'll be another set um regularly scheduled already on the calendar for second semester um we've increased our site sustainability coordinator participation from 24 schools to 31 one um that means we have three School sites that currently do not have a site sustainability coordinator this is in addition to um the work around the 26 energy star certifications uh we received uh earlier uh tonight um implementation of the first phase special education Transportation program uh

075this will begin February 18th so a week from today um will be the first time we're Prov we're um transporting our students with disabilities the adults uh in the transition program program and we are currently planning for the second phase that will begin in 2526 for all of our non-ambulatory students uh we have launched a new website um with workers compensation resources for our injured employees and we have participated with local agencies to receive daily information on road work enclosures if you travel around Modesto enough you know it's challenging it's even more challenging um when there's a road closure or work being done this will help us respond if we know um what's going on um ahead of time you won't see and you didn't see um color codes as as mentioned earlier um by

076Dr nuchi in our presentation um but these Smiles you see here from the students um really represent the um how much they enjoyed uh at this particular time um the American themed greedy uh graffiti meals that were were um shared at their school sites uh also mention in addition to our Network goal we're excited to share um facility construction updates that will also benefit our students our staff and the community our current elementary projects our uh M Elementary is cafeteria multi-purpose room um that should be completed hopefully before the end of the school year probably in May um so we we'll plan a ribbon cutting ceremony for that overwrite cafeteria multi-purpose room uh Franklin cafeteria multi-purpose room and improved drop off and pickup area front of the school will be moved to along ma Avenue

077um with a new front office um Roosevelt Junior High classrooms will begin modernization in June this summer and our first planned measure X that's the most recent um Elementary uh Bond measure um will be a multi-purpose room uh at Marshall Elementary uh and that is currently uh underway for planning for that our current high school projects Modesto High classroom addition uh phase one that will begin um later this spring uh swimming pool construction at Davis and gregoryi will begin uh in June science classroom modernizations for Downey and buyer will begin this summer um Library Renovations that all of our high schools with the exception of gregoryi um have been completed uh were completed over winter break students came back um to Freshly renovated libraries um at each of our high schools gregoria is currently being

078planned so that that will be next um synthetic track and Fields at berer and enox the fields are complete um the track uh portion I believe is scheduled to begin this week uh today at at Enoch weather permitting uh and then once that's done the track will be completed at buer hopefully in time for um uh our our track season which began uh two weeks ago it's a it's a Spring sport um so those are those are on the way and then planning for the Davis athletic complex that will be a Stadium baseball and softball fields on the Davis Campus um will begin later this summer I'm pleased uh to introduce employee retention Network lead valon Ferris all right thank you Tim so our employee retention Network team primary goal is to increase new hire

079retention to 95% during their first year with Modesto City schools a strong retention rate directly benefits our students by ensuring consistency in the classroom fostering stable learning environments and allowing Educators to build meaningful connections with their students High retention also reflects our district commitment to understanding and addressing employee needs creating a supportive workplace environment where where staff not only feel valued but also empowered to succeed to achieve this goal we have identified three key Focus areas diverse new hires par professionals and probationary staff several concrete steps we have taken thus far to enhance retention are we've taken a close look at our post onboarding practices for classified employees identify in gaps in areas where we can improve we've also enhanced our data collection and monitoring systems to better track employee feedback and we're continuously collecting

080monitoring and analyzing this data to guide our strategies when it comes to recruitment on boarding and retention we've made sure to strengthen our supports for our probationary staff working closely with both SES and department leaders to offer more proactive assistance and right now we're in the process of expanding resources for newly hired prayer professionals who've historically faced the lowest retention rates and this includes things like a new pair professional training hand manual as well as digital training options to ensure increased accessibility some of the kpis the key performance indicators we are tracking to measure our retention efforts are the number of employees separated during their probationary period to identify Trends and areas needing intervention on the screen you'll see these numbers of our year-over-year trend from 2022 to 23 and then 23 to 24 along

081with our current midyear data of our current school year and we're seeing positive movement with reduced attrition across all three employee groups year-to date on this slide you'll see a comparison of the number of employees separated during their probationary period from last year's midyear data to the current midyear data notably the separation rate for our classified staff has decreased by nearly 50% while the certificated staff separations were remain consistent with last year's figures we've also been closely tracking the retention rates of our tk12 instructional pair professionals and autism pair professionals as these groups have historically had the lowest retention rates and as of mid year we're seeing strong results with a 97% retention rate for instructional Paras and 96% % retention rate for our autism Paris moving forward we'll continue refining our approach by strengthening

082new hire and employee feedback systems to proactively address concerns we're working towards incorporating focus groups to better understand our needs of our diverse employees establishing formalized post High onboarding practices across all MCS departments and sites sharing new hire and exit survey data with site and department leaders to guide our retention efforts and then obtain comparable District retention data to Benchmark our progress and identify best practices from similar districts these next steps will help us sustain and improve our retention rates ensuring all employees feel supported and engaged at Modesto City schools and next I would like to introduce senior director of school leadership Mr Ernesto Calderone thought to heard some claps back there I felt special uh good evening uh now we will shift our Focus to our goal on uh Universal preschool through grade six

083instructional core although the instructional core in prek 6 has many components uh the goal tonight will focus primarily on achievement in English language arts and Mathematics our goal is to increase student achievement performance and English language arts and math on the Casp by 10% overall and identify student groups of English Learners and students with disabilities our most current Baseline data is 31% of our students meeting or exceeding standards in English language arts and 23% of our students meeting or exceeding standards in mathematics again that's in grades three through six in grades 3 through six actions taken to date include holding data Dives in ela on Dibbles hegerty and iabs which are assessments that help guide instruction in literacy specifically ongoing professional development for staff in targeted areas aligned with year one of the instructional core

084road map uh refining uh what we do with our mtss time Block in kindergarten uh with at Target sites to maximize opportunities for firsttime instruction for kindergarteners our continued effort in adding certificated math support teachers at 12 sites identified as having the largest need and the implementation of the classroom Mosaic platform to to provide strategic instructional feedback to teachers while conducting classroom walkthroughs now moving to the key performance indicators which serve as checkpoints to help us determine if we are on track to meet our goals the following six SL slides will contain data indicating progress in English language arts and math the first chart indicates how students performed on the Integrity assessment this assessment measures critical pheic awareness and early literacy skills and all transitional kindergarteners or TK students take this assessment the chart shows

085how students perform during the beginning of the year or Boi uh when compared to middle of the year or Moi values in green indicate a growth of 10% or more in students who scored at or above Benchmark on the middle of the Year assessment when compared to beginning of the year and as you can see we are on track to meet our goal by the end of the year and then please note that TK students do not take the lpac and therefore there's no data available for the English learner student group in this chart so the next chart indicates how students performed on the Dibbles assessment Dibbles which stands for dynamic in indicators for basic early literacy skills measure student progress on basic early literacy skills including phonemic awareness phonics and reading comprehension this chart

086shows how students perform during the beginning of the year when compared to middle of the Year again values and green indicate a growth of 10% or more on students who scored at or above Benchmark on the middle of the Year assessment when compared to beginning of the year yellow indicate students that have made growth on the assessment but not not 10% or more and red indicate a decline from the beginning of the school year so please note again that this that this assessment has cut points that increase throughout the year and because the expectation is for all of our students to naturally develop those skills as they progress throughout the year therefore Benchmark for proficient performance should also increase to reflect those growing abilities this next chart indicates how students performed on the Casp IAB

087assessment so the IAB which stands for interim assessment block measures student uh progress on the English language arts grade level standards this chart shows how students performed during the 23 24 school year when compared to this year and as you can see this is an area of focus that we've begun to address and will continue to address moving forward for example since this assessment took place all teachers in grades 3 through six have participated in constructed response trainings which was required as this is the area that most negatively impacts student scores when taking the IAB or the C assessments next we now will look at Swan Benchmark data which is our math assessments as you can see most grade levels and student groups have made an increase in this math assessment when compared to last

088year we are making progress towards meeting our goal by the end of the school year as well uh we also wanted to include a year-over-year comparison on how students performed on the same SW Swan Benchmark assessment uh mentioned in the prior slide but only for the 12 sites who have certifi certificated math support teachers that I mentioned at the beginning of the presentation the 12 sites were identified as the lowest performing sites in mathematics on last year's cast assessments the purpose of adding these math support teachers uh to these particular sites was to provide uh the classroom teacher an opportunity to work with strategic small groups while the remainder of the class continues to receive math instruction by the certificated U math substitute teacher or guest teacher uh so this slide uh was not originally

089included in your presentation so I just want to make you aware of that but this data was honestly too exciting uh not to share with you tonight so last year Dr nuchi challenged a district uh for double digit growth for English Learners or double double the growth of English Learners who will met the criteria to be reclassified and students parents teachers coaches staff and administrators we all met the school together this year we have already exceeded the last year's number as well we are grateful truly grateful for the hard work everyone uh involved has made in towards making sure our students a master the English language so moving forward some of our next steps include continued intentional professional development in line with the instructional core road map for year one in the prek through sixth

090grade and also since we're getting to the um you know second half of the year uh beginning to plan and move into the year two of the road map as well uh we're also going to continue to monitor how the certificated math support teachers are being utilized at sites identifying best practices and sharing those best practices uh with other sites who also have this this additional math support we also want to expand our Cas preparation initiatives uh that would be uniquely tailored uh to uh individual School sites and refining our data di protocols to have a greater emphasis on instructional decisionmaking by the teacher uh so now to report on 712 instructional core road map is Dr Sarah olon senior director CPD good evening tonight I will be sharing about our 712 instructional core Network

091goal which is to increase student achievement in ela and math for sth 8th and 11th grade students and in identified student groups by 10% as measured by the Casp our Baseline data is from the 2324 Casp assessment you will notice that 12th grade is not included in this data tonight our goals are specific to secondary students in the Casp testing range which does not include 12th grade before we look at a few data points let's first review the high leverage actions that have been implemented so far this year to support our goal the action steps are broken down into three core areas of focus implementation of the instructional core professional development and collaboration and meetings in the area of implementation of the instructional core we continue to support sites with instructional coaching and engage teachers

092in instructional Cycles all of our instructional coaches are certified in cognitive coaching classroom visits are conducted on a regular basis by site and District level administrators these visits focus on the components of the 712 instructional core framework for learning road map statements feedback is provided primarily through the classroom Mosaic platform classroom Mosaic offers the ability for feedback to be given in the moment and sent immediately to teachers data Dives also continue to be conducted at the school sites these are facilitated by instructional coaches in partnership with site administrators to review current data points and identify areas of strength and growth for students and determine next steps for instruction professional development is ongoing throughout the school year in the area of ela 9th through 12th grade teachers and parallel teachers were trained in the new curriculum

093and an overview was provided to 9th through 12th administrators genre writing training was provided for seventh and e8th grade teachers and writable was offered to all 9th through 12th grade teachers in the area of math 7th and e8th grade teachers are participating in quarterly math tasks professional development and 7th through 12th grade grade special education parallel Math teachers were trained on the general education curriculum and how to embed special education supports while using the general education curriculum in the area of collaboration and meetings graduation rate intervention team or grit meetings are held four times a year these meetings are facilitated by school leadership with a focus on looking at current data such as grade data Benchmark data and College and Career indicators setting goals and identifying next steps additionally instructional coaches attend collaboration meetings on

094planning days to support the PLC process with various grade level or content teams moving on to our key performance indicators we will start with Ela as a reminder our overall goal is to increase by 10% the percent of students met and exceeding on the Casp this is also the goal of our key performance indicators on the benchmark assessments first we have data for ELA Benchmark 1 comparing the 23 24 and 24 25 school years as you can see the overall data for grades 7 8 and 11 shows an increase from the previous year as reflected by the yellow highlights it is important to note that 9th and 10th grades are not included in this data with the adoption of the new Ela curriculum the 2425 school year is a baseline year highlights in this data

095data include an increase for seventh and 11th grade africanamerican student groups and 11th grade English Learners as represented by the green highlights looking at math benchmark 2 for grades 7 through 11 you will notice that we have the overall goal to increase by 10% grades 7 through 11 students scoring at the Met and exceeds level on the math benchmark 2 assessment from the previous year a review of math ass assessment data reveals promising Trends but also highlights areas of concern before we get into the data I would like to provide some background on our current math benchmark assessments it is important to note that the rigor of 7th through 11th grade math benchmark assessment ments was increased this year to better align with the expectations of the academic standards this change was based on recommendations

096from an external audit of the benchmarks additionally math pacing guides were realigned to more accurately reflect the content assessed on these benchmarks The increased rigor in the revised benchmarks resulted in an initial decrease in student achievement highlights in this data include an increase for seventh and e8th grade African-American student groups geometry shows significant Improvement in three of the four reporting areas it is worth noting that the geometry Benchmark required very few revisions to meet the level of rigor the content standards expect although growth was not observed year-over-year it is expected that student achievement will improve as students have more opportunities to engage with math content at the level required by the standards the data for the algebra code teaching model is displayed in this graph this represents the comparison of code teaching groups to traditional

097groups of students for math 8 Algebra 1 and geometry for math benchmark 1 and Benchmark 2 as requested by the board last year we are also monitoring the students who were in The co- teing model for algebra last year and are enrolled in Geometry this year the blue bars show the data for Benchmark 1 for both groups of students in each of the courses while the orange bars represent the data for Benchmark 2 while both co- te and traditional classes show significant growth from Benchmark 1 to Benchmark 2 the traditional class proficiency rates in Algebra 1 and geometry are slightly higher than the code proficiency rates we also see the Gap closing between the two groups of students in algebra and geometry math 8 proficiency rates are significantly higher for the traditional classes compared to

098the Cod te classes and as a reminder code teaching was expanded to math 8 this year and is offered at two of our four for junior highs we are now going to take a look at the school level analysis for Benchmark 2 Proficiency in Algebra 1 the chart displays proficiency levels for each High School broken down by students enrolled in a co- te course or a traditional course we see that three high schools gregori Byer and Johansson have co- te proficiency levels at or above the proficiency levels for the traditional algebra course while Enoch's Coe students didn't outperform their peers in traditional algebra classes they have high proficiency rates on Benchmark 2 for co- te and traditional classes compared to other sites looking at the overall range from Benchmark 1 to Benchmark 2 met or

099exceeded for this school year we see that seventh and eighth grades had decreases while the high school level shows significant growth for all three courses as a reminder we have increased the rigor this year for the math benchmarks which has had an impact on year-over-year comparisons we anticipate that this data will continue to improve as students are provided more opportunities to engage with math content at the level required by the standards in the area of grade data the goal is to decrease dnf grades by 5% for grades 7 through 11 in ela and math this table shows the year-over-year data for semester 1 in the 23 24 and 2425 school years for seventh and eth grades in ela we see a decrease in dnf grades for all areas with the student groups of students with

100disabilities and English Learners meeting the 5% goal in math we see a decrease in the dnf grades for the student groups of English Learners and African-American students here we have the year-over-year data for semester 1 again in the 23 24 and 24 25 school years for 99th through 11th grades for ELA and math in ela we see a decrease of dnf grades for the student groups of students with disabilities English Learners and African-American the English learner student group met the 5% goal in math we see a decrease in dnf grades for all areas with student groups of with the student groups of students with disabilities and English Learners meeting the 5% goal classroom Mosaic was implemented this year as a tool that administrators use to monitor teachers implementation of components of the instructional core and

101provide feedback to teachers during classroom visits this app captures data for various areas aligned to the instructional core including the use of board adopted curriculum instructional strategies and student engagement when feedback is entered administrators can send communication directly to a teacher with this being the first year of implementation of classroom Mosaic data is being gathered to establish a baseline current classroom Mosaic data shows the following the implementation of board adopted curriculum was observed in 84% of classrooms the most commonly observed instructional strategies are Focus notetaking and partner collaboration and student engagement was noted as 79% of classes having most or all of their students engaged looking ahead to our next steps we will continue to focus and monitor the work that is being done in the following areas math tasks PD at the junior high

102level lesson studies Algebra 1 instructional Cycles continuing our work with California education education partnership implementation of Casp practice items supporting the implementation of the new Ela curriculum utilizing classroom Mosaic for classroom visits focusing data Dives on instructional decision making and providing a 712 math Summit in April we'll now turn it back to president Maas and the school board thank you very much um all right we're half almost halfway there and so we're going to pause for a second to take any um comments so do we have any public comments on what we've heard so far in this report all right seeing none um any comments or questions from the board all right trusty Irvin um I wanted to see um especially in areas where we're needing to improve in all the areas um got a

103question with the the HR presentation um is there in order to monitor uh what's going on and with the retention and things like that is there um continuous improvement process model that's being used or how do we how are we understanding how things are evolving uh within that um retention process see yeah so that's great question so that's one reason on the next steps we have that we want to obtain some comparable data of other districts their retention rates it's not necessarily something that we have to send out to the state but um as a as a data metric but we want to see where other districts in our comparable size currently stand in regards to their retention rates to see where we kind of are in in that same regard as well does that

104kind of answer your question yes and but add to that the the the process in which you know how do you monitor how are you monitoring the steps and the the processes in terms of that you know in terms of that like now just use for example continuous improvement process model there may be other models that are being used within the district but how do you know how do you get from um say okay the retention rate we got from you know we increased in attention rate to you know 85% so to speak you know okay what was the process to get to that you know so when you come back for that 10% to get it to 90% you know um say you know 90% you're continuously improving so capturing how you're doing that

105is what I'm like the steps that were taken I definitely I I know there's been a lot of different steps that they've been taken over the past last couple years too that we've taken this year is it okay to add a like board report after on or not a board report what is that called the board communication thank you after with some of those identified steps that we've taken so far right right yes yes yes yeah I would add to that that U as uh Miss Ferris mentioned that prior a lot of our efforts were geared toward Recruitment and so we haven't dug into uh retention Baseline data to the level that we are this year uh you know until now so we're trying to set some really solid baselines and then what I think

106you're referring to is more of a cause and effect which which actions that we're taking are achieving the the outcomes of changing the data and so we're we're doing a lot of deep diving into that this year to um identify what we think would be uh actionable items that can uh effectuate a change in the retention rat for par Professionals for example looking at things like support um pree effective date training those those types of things and and then monitoring the data uh on a regular basis kind of taking a builder's approach to the data we want to see the data all the time and so um there are some increments where we can only see it at certain periods of time like the midar uh but other times we're trying to to uh grasp

107it U as frequently as we can to see are there changes um that we can we can see causing a trend okay yeah thanks and I'm going to you know actually utilize that for all the uh presentations we've had you know how do we you know we are pro improving but how do we maintain that you know so we have a um a footprint for you know when things you know new people come on you know we have this continuous improvement process model that we utilize in order to monitor how we're improving on our our data because you can you know you can do something and then all the nuts and bolts in between that get lost and then you got the outcomes but then you can't really assess or pinpoint how you got those

108those outcomes and so that's what I was you know I'm getting that and I would say that for you know the other presentations as well rather than me going through each one of them we know where the reds are we know where we did well at you know did we capture how we do well how we did well within those so we can apply those same principles um to where we were challenged at and so that's what I was looking to get you know get to in terms of that you know how do we Monitor and said okay we did this this this this and this and this led to this outcome you know uh versus we did this and then here at the end you know are we're beginning year and mid year and

109but we can't really pinpoint how we got that increase or how that decrease uh impacted if that makes sense I'm just going to leave it there thank you be okay any other or I have a couple um one just on facilities um I have to say thank you for the water bottle refilling stations that are going into some places um it's a thank you from my daughter so she's really happy about that um the there's a lot of data here so of course I'm going to ask a question or comment here the Dibbles scores indicators this is some amazing growth by our African-American students like I just have to highlight that 26 to 55% Kinder 14 to 59% 23 to 6% um it's phenomenal so teachers out there that are working hard to get our

110students um reading amazing work I'm concerned about mathematics um as of course I would be um you know I guess our Baseline is is 18% in the high school 133% in 8th and 21% in 7th yeah there's a lot of uh of chatter out there about um you know students really have to be able to read a bunch in order to do well on this math but if you look 47% of our students are meeting or exceeding standards in ela yet we still only have 18% meeting standards or exceeding standards in math so that is not aligning something's not aligning there um I do appreciate that the there was a an audit on the benchmarks I I do appreciate that so I'm looking forward to seeing what our growth is going to be after this

111year using the aligned benchmarks that align to our standards um but I on that though um I want to highlight one that I thought was very interesting with the more rigorous and aligned standard Benchmark there is still a 12% growth in AFC afcan American students in grade seven there's still a 6% growth in African-American students in grade 8 only a 3% drop in Algebra 1 almost 30% what 20 24% growth in Geometry there there's something going on there so I I really applaud um our teachers for working working on that um that was some impressive growth um I do have a question what's my question uh on the next steps there's a mention of a 712 math Summit in April I'm interested to know more about that I don't have to talk about it right

112now but if you can send in a board communication or something I'd just be interested in knowing a little bit more about that Summit um yeah and then I had one more thing I wrote down um the decrease in in dnf grades looks great so um thank you for that first half okay trusty marks thank you so much I I forgot to ask this but I wanted to find out on the key performance indicators on the Cod teaching versus the regular classes uh just the quite the discrepancy on some of them where the regular class did so much better especially on the um Benchmark one two so what was the plan are we planning to continue with the co- teing I know in the um algebra gregori Brier and Johan well Johansson was even but

113they did a little better with the Cod teing but just wondering what the plan is for those classes on co- teing versus regular I don't know how many are teaching it I don't know how many classes are doing it so for each of the high schools the co- teing model has um one pair of co- teers so it's five sections in a school day of co- teing so five groups of students of about 35 students each um moving forward for the rest of this year we're continuing with some specific co- teing professional development for the teachers we actually have our third of the year coming up uh February 18th and then we are taking some of our sites that are demonstrated a little bit of a need for growth in the co- teing instruction to

114visit um other sites co- teing classes so that they can do some observations and have get some ideas and support that way our instructional coaches are also working um with the plc's and doing instructional Cycles with those teachers to help them reflect on their practices and deepen their um knowledge base and build their toolbox of strategies and supports okay that's helpful I it yeah I was totally with the president um my Estus on just the concern about the math in the especially in the higher well in seventh and eth and 11th grade because our students I know they're capable of of doing better so I'm like what is going on and and it just gives us concern glad we're keeping track glad we're making some progress on some of these other um benchmarks but the

115Casp is just discouraging so I don't know and I'm glad we're aligning it so when we say we're aligning The Benchmark we're aligning it to the CP now is that correct we're aligning to the level of rigor that the standards expect so build increasing the level of rigor to align to the standards which is what the Casp assesses where also um encouraging the use of Casp released items um a team of instructional Cod coaches work to pull together a resource for our high school teachers Math teachers um so that they can Infuse those into their daily lessons that are correlated to the content of the lesson so that students are getting multiple opportunities for exposure to Casp like questions at that same level of rigor okay that helps that helps to understand that a little

116bit better because I just I look at it and say how can our students be not doing very well this cast but then doing you know making such great progress on our benchmarks and yet it's lagging so but I want them I just want them to have the knowledge so they can do whatever the next level of Education they go to they're going to be able to do it and if that means I don't know if Casp is the best form of assessing our students on their ability to perform in a college level um area or career that they go into so I don't know if our benchmarks are something that we're measuring that is going to be something better than what the Casp is measuring so I just it's it's discouraging to see the

117numbers on the cast but I don't know if that's the best measurement for how much our students already know because if they're doing something that's ju that we're teaching them something that they have use of that's going to help them in the next level of Education with like geometry or Algebra 2 and cast isn't measuring those kinds of skills then I'm proud of our teachers and what we're doing I just don't know I'm just looking at these and going I'm comparing apples to oranges and I'm not sure which one is the best measurement for our students so it just helps to see it trusty Brown so seems like we have a lot of focus on math I'm pleased looking districtwide at what progress making and I I'm wondering where we see that the growth is

118uh slower in the S 12 uh category for math than it is in the uh tk6 I'm I'm hopeful and hoping that there's a way that we can track the progress that we're seeing in tk6 carrying forward as our students are more prepared to enter into High School so is there anything that uh we can start to look at to see if we're seeing that Improvement carry forward so that that's a great point over the last six years we've spent a significant amount of time working with our uh tk6 math program specifically around the content the level of rigor the coaching involved the the review of data we spent a lot of effort uh kind of emphasizing that system to be better with the intentional purpose of exactly what you're saying right how do we

119then see them coming back excuse me coming or matriculating into the seventh grade with those numeracy facts and those things that we've said they they've lacked over time so that is our hope I think there are some other things that we probably need to address at the 712 level and that's really what the math Summit is about we're just I'll give you a sneak peek we're going to call in two separate days junior high on one day high school on the other we're going to call in every single math teacher and we're going to review kind of some of this data we're going to look at the urgency for it and we're going to identify hey what are things in our control what are things out of our control that we can really do to

120emphasize uh a systematic way to approaching this and the anticipation would be it's not a it's not a onee we fixed it and moving on it's going to be a multi-year plan to really help us uh see the growth we want to uh remember at the high school level we only test in the 11th grade so anything we Implement at the n9th grade level we don't actually see on that Casp assessment we can see it within internal benchmarks but we don't see that for three years so it'll it'll be a little bit of work on that but yes to to your question our absolute hope is that we're seeing students coming in better prepared to at least to our junior high schools from our elementaries and then at the high school level you know we're

121fed from multiple districts so that we don't necessarily have control over that but uh that that is our goal that we would see them better prepared to be successful at the higher level math so I I just want to point out how grateful I am to see that we have the data that's helping us track this and helps us really focus our efforts on that uh 78 or 7 to2 math need that we have in our district so thank you for that uh Deep dive into those numbers that allow us to have this uh uh math Focus thanks um on on a couple of those notes I don't I personally don't believe Casp is the Casp is like a one day few days in the life of a kid and I'm not quite sure about

122the indicator quite yet of what it what it does tell us so it's a snapshot um but I am hopeful for the new mathematic California mathema framework in that it specifically addresses what the students need to be capable mathematics Learners in their Futures so that's coming and my I was going to ask a question about uh curriculum in our framework um as it starts to happen in our in our map in our road map and how we're going to take a look at curriculum for the new math framework which happens in a couple years so I'm hopeful that that is and then on the other point um our co- teing students for the very first Co cohort have not taken the Casp yet those those students take the Casp this year so it' be interesting

123to see how those students do on the Casp as they move along all right um do we need a break okay we're pressing on to the next piece um and Christino Romero good evening I am so excited and Incredibly proud to present tonight on our inclusion Network goal as a district team we have been diligently working to improve our inclusive practices throughout Modesto City schools and this collaborative effort has been an area of focus for not only our Sela leadership but a focus for our entire general education counterpart um across the district as we began this work an outside analysis of our inclusive practices was completed and in review of the findings of that analysis um and in support of the larger goal to increase and improve inclusive practices in our district we have committed

124to the following areas of focus for our work to increase the number of offerings and the attendance of Educators in inclusion-based professional development opportunities to increase the number of students with disabilities participating in the general education environment and to support our inclusion specialists in providing increased coaching and professional development in inclusive practices for site staff in working with students with disabilities in their classrooms while our district m message this year regarding inclusion area practices is not new we've made incredible gains in increasing the collective ownership of this goal across the district this was established in both Dr nuch's beginning of the year address and our start of the Year administrative trainings as well as the active involvement of our school leadership team in reviewing supporting and and continuing the work of the implementation of the

125site inclusion plans additionally collaborative efforts in this work have included the inclusion and differentiation components Within all professional development offerings through cipd our inclusive practices based 05% offerings through the PD catalog and the alignment of our inclusion efforts applying this Focus to all marginalized students groups as opposed to just students with disabilities we have expanded successful inclusionary practices across our district which we will look at in terms of data momentarily but moreover we have ensured the inclusion of leaders across departments in our work not only to expand ownership of this message but also to increase understand understand of the most important piece of our work which is the why this Collective ownership has allowed us to properly begin supporting our site administrators our certificated and our classified staff as I mentioned the success in inclusivity

126requires the ongoing support and development of our staff last year we offered 56 varied professional development sessions on inclusionary practices reaching 829 Modesto City schools employees this was offered primarily through the special education office specifically from Sala leadership K12 special education instructional coaches our mild to moderate inclusion specialist and our district inclusion coordinator this year we are not only on track to reach our goal but we have already exceeded last year's first semester offerings and have already exceeded the total number of participants reached all of last school year we are incredibly proud of this achievement as we recognize that understand in the why for our work is critical in its continued expansion and success while supporting our staff in this work is is critical the ultimate goal is obviously to increase access to and the

127participation of students with disabilities in the general education environment within this work we are implementing pieces to increase access for our entire student group in this area regardless of disability or the level of service through varied supports that they require but there are some very specific spe ific and targeted trainings and adjustments that we are currently putting in place to Target two very specific data bands in each of the districts in our in Modesto City schools this overall goal being growth in inclusionary practices and general education access for students with disabilities in elementary this targeted population focuses on our students in special day classroom environments at present these students are typically included in our unstructured portions of the school day um these are lunch recess prep provider time computer literacy assemblies um library and PE

128the focus for this student group moving forward is how those inclusionary practices can be implemented during academic time providing students with access to peers during socialization but also through academic conversations in the in their rooms this includes investing in small intervals of time where students can be included to participate in related activities and ongoing socialization for our secondary students we are targeting our students with more mild moderate disabilities within the school oop sorry this data set demonstrates positive growth in both of these areas and has focused at the secondary level on co- teing which you've heard a little bit about earlier we are able to see however um we would be remiss not to have pointed out a dip in our Junior highs while they have absolutely made tremendous progress and had huge growth we

129recognize that there's a scheduling difference between Elementary and Junior High with regard to some of our um our more unstructured activities the ones I mentioned earlier there is not an opportunity uh for um necessarily Library time uh some of those additional things prep provider time CLT time at the Junior High um but they are working diligently to include students with all of our focus on increasing inclusionary practices the goal before you of decreasing inclusion Services uh for students may seem counterintuitive however I want to take a moment to just explain this uh we're not suggesting that we should not be providing inclusion services to our students but instead we are looking at focusing those inclusion Services um on a Less Direct model that's specific with students and a more coaching or supportive model that allows

130us to build capacity of our providers in working with students on a daily break basis to increase accommodations modifications and supports in the general education environment where students with disabilities are um placed in classrooms throughout uh throughout the day the purpose of this goal is is then to provide that instructional support ongoing uh across our our district so while we've done a great job you may be asking what's next moving forward the foundation of our work needs to be grounded in the further development of our mindset regarding inclusive practices this includes the understanding that students with disabilities are eneral education students first and that special education is a service not a place we send students this collaborative effort and ownership of this work also needs to expand into our communication with our feeder districts as

131students matriculate into our secondary sites established IEPs and practices move with them ensuring we are all of One mindset and that we are involved in the conver conversation surrounding transition into our high schools is a critical piece to ensuring increased access for for our students as well the implementation of our site inclusion plans has been a success that we are working to refine those plans and the process to include all marginalized student populations and to continue to better align our communication and focus this will include addressing the needs previously identified uh surrounding culture mindset and professional development within both the plan itself and our ongoing conversations with leadership and collaborations throughout the year we're looking forward to continuing expanding not only our work but the meaningful access that our students have to general education not

132just coursework but their peers with that I'd like to um welcome Amanda shreer senior director of school leadership okay good evening I'm excited to share as I click I'm excited to share our midyear updates on graduation College and Career Readiness um highlighting our progress key achievements and strategic steps we're taking to reach our goals our three key goals provide a clear road map to ensure every student graduates prepared with the skills knowledge and character traits needed to thrive and contribute to society we aim to strengthen College and Career Readiness by increasing the percentage of graduates meeting the College and Career indicators on the California dashboard from 33% to to 43% to support student retention we're working to reduce Dropout rates in our 2025 Co cohort from 73 to 60 additionally we strive to raise graduation

133rates from 91% to 96% for the class of 2025 with these focused objectives we remain committed to providing every student with the resources opportunity and support needed for Success our three-year College and Career plan serves as our foundation for achieving our goals and ensuring long-term success built around key key excuse me around five key areas it provides students with the support guidance and opportunities needed to graduate prepared for College and Career Pathways the implementation of the College and Career campaign empowers students to take ownership of their educational journey by setting clear graduation career and career goals through targeted Outreach personalized advising engagement strategies and through engagement strategies students will gain a clearer understanding of the steps needed for Success refining a through G requirements grading practices and transitions ensures academic expectations are clear Equitable and

134aligned with post-secondary success efforts include strengthening a through G course alignment to maximize College eligibility launching a grading task force to improve grading policies and enhancing student transitions for a seamless academic experience additionally six schools are participating in the California educational partners collaborative focusing on keeping students on track for all postsecondary opportunities expanding School links provide students with personalized tools to explore career and college Pathways set goals track progress features such as a career assessment resume building tools and scholarship searches have helped students navigate their postsecondary Journey expanding du enrollment to all to all high school sites allows students to take college level courses during the school day this provides a head start on earning credits reduces future educational costs and builds confidence in their academic abilities expanded credit recovery options ensure students have a

135clear pathway to graduation e-learning programs offer flexible self-paced course work during the school day with teachers support while extended summer school Services provide in-person sessions before and after school through these initiatives we're building a strong Foundation to support students success in long-term academic achievement I am very excited to share this data or our kpis it highlights many opportunities our students have to achieve success dual enrollment has increased by 487 students this year expanding access to college level courses during the school day a through G completion rates have increased slightly to 32% indicating some progress to four-year College eligibility while this is a step in the right direction uh there's still significant room for growth in this area School links adoption has been highly effective with 99% of our high school students completing their four-year plans

136ensuring they have a clear Road mapap for their future additionally 534 more students are on track to complete a Career Technical education pathway equipping them with the skills needed for Workforce success Junior reserves office Officers Training Corps enrollment also known as JROTC has also grown to 44 students providing an additional pathway for leadership development and personal growth these achievements demonstrate our commitment to expanding opportunities and preparing students for Success Beyond High School our progress in reducing Dropout rates is a powerful indicator of student engagement and success over the past several years we've achieved a clear and significant downward Trend with Dropout rates dropping from 7.7% in 2018 to an impressive 1.8% in 24 so far this year with 34 dropouts districtwide we are on track to maintain this progress additionally our current rate is more

137than 4% lower than the state average highlighting the effectiveness of our targeted interventions this achievement is a result of our dedicated efforts across the district with classified staff counseling teams teachers and site administrators working closely with the district office to identify and support atrisk students a key driver in in the success is our grit process our graduation rate intervention team process which provides personalized interventions proactive monitoring and re-engagement strategies to support students at risk for dropping out by addressing individual challenges and ensuring tailored support we're keeping more students on track to graduate these collaborative efforts reinforce our deep commitment to Student Success as reflected in the continued reduction of Dropout rates across the district our next steps focus on maintaining momentum and expanding our impact across seven key areas we're committed to expanding early college

138and dual enrollment opportunities with a focus on increasing participation and ensuring Equitable access for all students particularly our students with disabilities and our English Learners strengthening Partnerships with col with colleges and providing tailored support will help remove barriers and create more Pathways for Success the map your mission Campaign Will engage all educational Partners including inner High Council student board Representatives uh to prepare for full implementation in the 2025 2026 school year in transitions a through G and Grading practices we will continue to engage in California education Partners to spread and scale effective strategies launch a grading task force to Pilot and Implement grading policy changes and strengthen the grit process while improving articulation Pathways from our Junior High to high school to enhance college and care career Readiness we will expand School links to junior

139high students creating a six-year Readiness Plan while integrating Career Technical education and work-based experiences into that platform additionally counseling professional development will be a priority with districtwide training focused on multi-tiered systems of support College and Career indicators and effective use of School links for Dropout prevention we will continue to refine potential Dropout procedures to improve site level monitoring and intervention efforts lastly we will continue strategic credit recovery options as needed to ensure every student has a pathway to success through these targeted efforts we will continue to strengthen our our progress uh close the gaps and create opportunities for students to achieve success thank you I'd now like to introduce uh Dave hul senior director child welfare and attendance I get the clicker right tonight so I'm going to be talking tonight about I what I

140believe is the foundation of everything that we do it's interesting as I sit here this evening I listen to all of my colleagues speak each thing is interrelated that we've talked about tonight and what I'm going to be speaking about is attendance and enrollment that's attendance for students and staff it really is the foundation for the success of everything we do our attendant enrollment goals are for student attendant to reach 9 96% across all sites if a site has 96% it's to increase by 1% to increase our student enrollment by 2% and to approve staff attendance by 1% for our actions taken to date for our student attendance is to strengthen support for School attendance review team that stands for assort it's one another one of those acronyms Dr nuchi spoke about promote our attendance

141campaign share best practices for attendance Improvement published a revised 20-day drop procedure boost participation in Saturday school programs to recruit to recruit attendance losses and identify students with chronic absenteeism early to provide supports and remove barriers for our enrollment actions taken to date we prioritize consistent advertising across all platforms if you'll remember several years ago we didn't start enrolling kindergarteners until March March we now begin that the day we come back from break and that advertising campaign starts before we go to break launch Junior and highman en highight enrollment campaign promote the toam steam program highlight Career Technical education opportunities and Inspire youth Inspire dreams events boost awareness of expanded learning programs and explore possible opportunities for dual Language Academy expansion for our staff staff attendance actions taken staff attendance actions track and incentivize attendance

142at the site level previously I don't think some of our side administrators were aware of the leverage that they could use or that they had uh to discuss with teachers that were suffering from poor tenants uh and other staff members we're working on that collaborate with iets to streamline data processes provide monthly data updates and compile annual comparative data expand data reporting to key departments and provide training to site and department managers on attendance processes staff attendance and all others our student attendance Trends we have seen continual growth over the last three years at all grade levels right so our goal again was 96% for the for all schools we currently have one site that is exceeding that I'm going give them a shout out that's Franklin Elementary they currently as of today 97.1 attendance

143we have several schools that currently have close to 96% at 95 that's Shackleford insulin and Lakewood are all above 95% our districtwide our attendance rate is 92.9% we continue to see year-over-year growth and our English Learners again we see year-over-year growth it's up across all grade levels we see a bit of a Slowdown this year but it's it's hard to continue to grow at 6.7% as our elementary did in 2223 we still continue to see growth within our African-American group we do see uh growth overall over a three-year period but we do see that there's some work to be done with our elementary and Junior highs with a 7 and a02 decrease for elementary and Junior High African-American students we need to identify those students and remove barriers and provide supports for students with disabilities

144again green across the board at all grade levels currently 91.22 per with a three-year growth across the board student enrollment Trends now I know some of you know that in California we're seeing declining enrollment Medesto City schools has not experienced that as of today our current enrollment year-over-year to date is plus 305 right a good indicator for growth and possible growth is our TK and Kinder enrollment that has been a concerted effort this year for next year our projected enrollment is plus 163 in TK and K alone so those are good numbers uh one of the goals this year for our HR department has been an employee uh absence comparison and to promote good attendance for our employees that includes all employees so we have on this chart you have all staff absences all staff

145absences for specific reasons site only all absences and site only by specific reasons you might ask what specific reasons are specific reasons include illness personal necessity sick leave Reserve unauthorized illness in family and personal Le in this category if we take a look at all staff absences we have seen a decrease in staff absences year-over-year of 912 this is one I'm really proud of it's been a career um for me working with student suspensions working with student discipline there's this is um unbelievable data when I when I pulled this it yeah so what I wrote was I'm excited I'm not excited I'm ecstatic okay um if you take a look at this data you see year-over-year decreases at our tk8 grade level for our suspension rates and what you will see is they are coming

146close to level there has been some disparities in the past and which we're seeing now now is a decrease over a three-year period in our black or African-American suspension rate for tk8 at 4.39% if you what you'll notice is though is that those levels are now almost level across the board right which is what we're looking for we're looking for parity in our 9912 hold your seats for African-American students 912 our three-year change in suspension rate is 9.42% again we're getting back to almost being level across the board for those suspension rates this is not something that has come easily this has been a concerted effort by students by staff by parents by campus supervisors by yard duties by every person that has touches that kid's life throughout the day I'm really proud of that

147work I I believe it's due to uh our work in PBIS in restorative practices but most importantly in just building good relationships with kids for our next steps we'll refine TKA kindergarten advertising we'll monitor enrollment data and adjust Outreach strategies of accordingly strengthen restorative practices and PBIS continue training staff to support positive School culture will enhance our African American success plan working with Mr William Patterson to collaborate with equity and inclusion Specialists and special education teams to improve student discipline outcomes so up next is Miss M Herrera dor director of parent engagement and Outreach paper I to take with me sorry thank you sir good evening Le the short one good evening here I'm here tonight to discuss our parent and student engagement our first Network goal is to maintain a minimum of 95% of

148parents and in person they attended back to school nights community of events shared internal and external resources and helped parents receive food through the through our distribution and pantries we monitored these four questions with the surveys collected we asked parents overall how satisfied were they with the information being pres presented and was it helpful in supporting student education and well-being overall satisfaction during this time last last year was 96% of parents were either very satisfied or satisfied and to date it is 98% and support your child's Education and Care was at 98% last year and to date 98% as well where we have maintained a minimum of 95% where parents were very satisfied or satisfied in responding to both these questions we also ask parents if parents um feel recognized as an essential partner and

149feel connected to the school and District during this time last year we utilized the Handover survey and collected around 700 responses and it was at 54% and this year through collaboration and developing new surveys with thought exchange asking that same question we are at 98% with over 1100 responses and our final survey question does a district site engage you in the decision-making process this time last year also utilizing Handover survey it was at 46% and this year with thought exchange we are at 96% where we have increased more than the 10% for both these goals I would like to point out that we have had continued growth with our efforts to provide parents on how the district works through our districtwide parents make a differences however on how to navigate our district but what we

150really feel contributed to does the district site engage you in the decision making was through our parents make a difference at the site level we held 26 site-based parent forums and during these events principal shared all the resources available at their school sites including all the Committees that provide a platform for parents for parent voice and how to be part of the decision-making process at the site and District level further a postevent survey was given and parents could select if they were interested in any of the of the site or District committees we then turned around and shared the survey results with principles so they could contact any parents that had any interest for more information or interest in participating on the various committees ultimately the collaborative efforts and feedback has helped us to not

151only provide support to administrators and and their schools but to meet the needs of our parents by hearing directly from them and for total par parent participation attendance during the various events offered I am pleased to say that during this time last year we were at 2862 and currently we are at 3,686 we also promoted student advocacy through various groups such as student advisory Council black student unions Hispanic youth Leadership Council and the Stannis LA County National Alliance on Mental Illness to date we implemented 15 surveys and received over 2500 responses on various topics that included consequences for racial slurs student Wellness student engagement feedback on Equity High School expanded learning program potential opportunities fueling passion and student safety we also offered 13 student forums through various College opportunities and conferences for growth for example

152the africanamerican education conference Hispanic youth leadership conference the Fresno State College Tour and other related opportunities we are pleased pleased by the completed student surveys that students are engaged and want their voices to be heard um for our next steps parent and student engagement will continue to collect survey responses at all parent and student engagement presentations conduct the student climate survey parent engagement survey the new staff engagement survey and the alcap survey using the new thought exchange process evaluate feedback related to specific topics trainings to continue to tailor offerings and continue to support sites and efforts and efforts to increase engagement I want to thank you and i' at this time I'd like to turn it back over to board president maestas there we go thank you so much appreciate this wonderful report um we'll

153open it up to public comments now do you have anybody in the public would like to comment okay guys for everything that you do I really appreciate it I know that you work really hard okay as far as the parent engagement goes I am myself for a couple two three years except for this one I went to the first meeting sort of um to the is it the parent Pac parent advisory Council to the superintendent never once did I see a superintendent number one and when I represented Johansson in the prior years two prior years in fact on the uh parent advisory committee um we were advised as parents on what we were going to discuss not the parents feelings or the parents thoughts it was here's what we're doing here's your outline and how

154can we fit this within this and let's break down into these little subgroups and you're going to get this section you're going to get this section you're going to get this section and by the way we have somebody that's either a school teacher or um an office staff a school staff member overseeing your subgroups to help you rewrite the ideas that you guys have in your given advice on what you're supposed to engage about um that that didn't include the parents at all as far as I'm considered as parent engagement that was engaging as you the district wanted us to engage in discussion of topics that you wanted us to engage in so as far as Outreach to parents and parent feedback parents are giving feedback on what you're telling us to give them in

155your committies you're not asking us for anything and so I think that that's really important um and a lot of this growth that you're seeing engagement students attendance I noticed that you're only talking about the past seeing it over the past two or three years is that since 2020 or has that been I'd like to know the data prior to that as far as if it's continued increasing over multiple years prior to the 2020 or if it's just over the past three years because of course you're going to see growth and Improvement so mainly just about your parent engagement that's my thoughts on that I didn't even finish out this year for the superintendence committee don't plan on going to their second meeting because I don't need to be told what I'm there to advise

156or talk about it we're supposed to be there to engage in what the parents are feeling right to hear our feedback and not on discussions that you want us to have thank you you um do you have any other um comments from the public all right questions or comments from the board trustee da sorry about that uh first of all thank you all so much for this um wow it was a lot of information but really good information I have to agree I love love love the decrease in the suspension rates wonderful job to all the schools and the administrative staff and obviously the students I have questions about um School links in the grading system so it appears that parents are learning that I am a mental health provider and I'm being contacted by

157parents who are concerned about or asking questions as to whether or not they can turn off the um when the when the student receives notifications saying what their grades are and it's like in real time and there are parents with anxious students that want to know if they can turn those off talk about specifically for School links yes um I don't know the answer to that but I can find out for you I'm sure there's a way in that system to turn off notifications um and so if we need that information more public we can definitely work on that yeah that'd be great I I referred them back to teachers and staff and things along that lines but it would be nice if the questions are the continue for me to know the answer to

158that we'll find out thank you all right any other um trusty marks yeah it's it is it's great to get all this information in one night um um I just I had one just example of the dual enrollment that I learned at our open house that was so cool so the principal shared up in front of all these parents that he had a sub at the school that was a student a previous student at the high school who had gone and gotten he's like how are you a sub already she had gone and gotten her ba degree in two and a half years because she got dual enrollment and she was able to get it so quickly so she came back to be a sub while she's in the process of becoming a lawyer so

159it it's so cool just to just to hear that example of how it's benefiting our students already the dual enrollment and just how well our students are doing so it was so great to hear how you shared just all this information I I loved it and I love the the suspension rates because I've been here when they were really high and so it's so wonderful to see them dropping and just continuing to drop and our students being more engaged and the dropout rate only being 3 students this year um that's impressive too so just seeing those those numbers that um I know will help the public see how um just engaged our students are in their school right now absolutely um any others I've got one question um and it has to do with [Music]

160um graduation I or College and Career Readiness so I was at when I went to the open house um on the screen flash because it was a eighth grade Paran night Flash the um the pathway for math high school math and something that I noticed that stuck out to me very quickly was that um if you don't have seventh grade honors you can never get to AP Calculus because there's no way to jump back onto the like onto that train to get there um is there anything that is coming or being offered or thought about to um because I was I was that student that I took Algebra 1 my freshman year and geometry my sophomore year and I wanted to get to calculus so um I was lucky enough to have a mom that

161did the nails of the counselor and so she got me into doing a I was able to get a independent study I don't know how she finagled that but I did an independent study and I took algeb 2 in the summer and I got an A in Algebra 2 I went on to get an A in pre-calculus and a in calculus and here I am math major all those years later but it took me a while to grow into mathematics and we know there's a lot of students like that and I feel like if if we stop them and say you have to make this decision in seventh grade then we're taking a lot of of students um choices away so is there anything that we're thinking about is that is that part of the

162thought in the next steps in College and Career maap I was gonna say maybe I'll defer to Mr Richard okay Dr Olen yeah so certainly we have students that do exactly like you did and uh you know um in order to be a through G eligible you have to get through Algebra 2 and so uh I did something similar only I took Algebra 2 and geometry the same year like that's how I made that happen when I was a student so um there is ways that maybe we can look uh We've explored in regards to adding the preal AP course to offer another higher level course that's not just calculus uh that could get college credit as well as looking at how can we augment the algebra 2 curriculum maybe near the end to talk

163more about um like the difference the differential equations or the it's been a lot of years since I talk calculus but adding in some of those kind of pre-cal Standards to help with that and then providing some summer term opportunities for some of those content but it is difficult when there are four classes you know that are prerequisites if you will for that course yeah I I mean I teach a summer school Advan um course for kids to jump um into the um accelerated path to get to calculus that weren't there in that path for fresh in their freshman year so it's possible I know it's at other places I just we want that to be something we think about we also have First Look classes uh for online learning that kids can take take

164during the school day so much like you took one during the summer they could do that just during their normal school day and uh and help accelerate that way okay and during the summer all right um yeah that's all I had well I do want to thank all of you for uh your time and effort um to put this together the review process and the the presentation tonight there was a like Tristy Dy said it was a ton of information um and uh it's ton of process as well but I know that it was a ton of time and effort to put together and I also want to thank all of the people that work towards this all the uh counselors teachers classified staff everyone that works towards um the benefit of our students in

165this review thank you for all the work that you do so thank you for that all right now it's time for you to go home you don't you don't have to tell them twice right all right so we're going to move on to to uh item B6 which is the uh board Direction regarding our superintendent selection and and before we start this I just want to say that we um I think we were all a little uh shell shocked last U meeting and um we didn't really get a chance to say how much we are definitely going to um Miss Dr Dr nuchi um all of your work and inspiration that you've been able to do the years that you've been here I know my kids have benefited from being in school while you were

166here and I see the growth and I just I think the trajectory that we are on is um has a lot to do with the work that you've done so um I I even though I don't want to go through this process totally I I I respect and appreciate um your uh commitment to your family and wanting to to to move on into retirement so um we thank you for all of that and we know that now we have a difficult work to do that's going to take some time and we have to go through a process as a board as a as a uh elected board to hire a new superintendent and we look forward to that process but we also don't look forward to having you leave us um in in the coming

167months so thank you for that um during Clos session the board had an opportunity to discuss our next steps and what we might think about doing as we give direction to staff but we'd like to open this up to public comments so that we can further um take in some public comments as if there are any here and then we can have some more discussion if necessary um are there any comments from the public on this agenda item okay um are there any additional board comments um for this agenda item or questions okay truste Irvin I I don't want to cry but [Laughter] no man it's been a it's it's been a journey and you know like all of us uh really appreciate your leadership your your passion compassion um dedication and commitment um to

168um uh the students uh families staff you know teachers administrators um those of us who've been around this District a while you know myself um starting in 1998 and been through several superintendents and a layoff um I have definitely seen definitely seen um um the the elevation the elevation and um um the accomplishments you know we can actually measure it you know and you know we're we're the Talk of the Town I don't care what anybody says we're the talk of the state let me take it there and um you know without you we all wouldn't be here you know we wouldn't be singing These Praises we wouldn't be singing These successes um we wouldn't be seeing uh a actual teamwork you know um seeing that and um being a part of that um has

169made me uh proud to be um um a part of that that Journey um I'm going from literally like having the biggest hate for the district after what happened to be you know that's just a natural process you know but I got over over it yeah and you were a big part of that getting over it and so um seeing the seeing the where we are now I know that our our district is in a better place and so I just you know want to say I appreciate you and um admire you and um jealous too because you're getting ready to do some wonderful things with your grandchildren and your children and so um that's not my next step but thank you trusty Lopez yes definitely I can talk about this now a couple of

170weeks in um but still we're we're hoping for the miracle right like she says hey you know what another year um but no I uh Sarah I I want to thank you for your for your time uh with us and and the growth that we've done right uh hand in hand um with all of our staff board um the ones that are here the ones that are not here um it's all been uh due to in large part through your leadership um and so when we talk about all these improvements when we talk about uh cafeterias when we talk about about um new programs the par ambassadors um attendance rates I mean those are all uh those are all part of your leadership and but more more than anything just the the culture you created

171and as we move to this new process um and and and the process that you've been a part of it's very um has been very big on bringing everyone along and making sure that everyone even though we might have tough convers ation we might have uh disagreements that we're ultimately looking at the goals and so that's why they're there right every single time um we put up our goals so we're constantly reminded of of uh what we're doing here we're constantly reminding of our vision and so I think in the new process um that Legacy will carry on where we want to be uh Guided by Community by staff into being a part of that process in one way or another of how what what's the next step forward and so you know um but

172back to the back to what's important today or well both of them are important but um Sarah like I and I think we mentioned it earlier like today is not the day to like you know to wallow because we still have you for a little bit um and but I just want to make sure that you know that we're really appreciated for the work that you've done here losing our Super Bowl winning yes trusty Brown yeah I've gone through the process of uh stepping into retirement and I congratulate you Dr nuchi for uh daring to step there uh it's been a a tremendous uh honor to work with you through this process and and and to participate in in the Legacy that uh we've seen developed in Modesta City Schools over the past seven years

173now as I look at what we've heard tonight in this report I don't recognize an end I don't see that Dr naguchi is going to say well we did it we did exactly what we set out to do and we're finished let's just hold the norm what I see is next steps in everything that we're doing and a team that is prepared to can carry us into those next steps every category of work that we're involved in as a district is focused on continuing on the tra trajectory that we've been on for the past seven years that's part of the Legacy that you've built for us Dr nuchi and I thank you for that it's important now that we look at how we go about the process of selecting a new superintendent and as we

174as a board met earlier we uh talked about things that we could do how we select the team that's going to help us uh make these important decisions what we can do to possibly streamline the process but in the end we realize that the greatest step that we need to take forward is to make sure that all of our stakeholders are involved in that process and that we hear from everyone in the district in the community and in every uh every aspect of Education even our students what is needed in the the the role of superintendent as we move forward uh what can we do to continue in the direction that we're moving now and I'm really pleased to be part of the team that has the honor of of making this next important decision

175so I I think it's important now that we talk about who we would select and how we would go about selecting the uh the group that we would work with in the Pro process so I'm going to just open that up and see if someone else is ready to contribute there do oh yeah I I I was going to open that up but good but uh thank you I'm sorry present my my but uh I'm gonna let uh trusty marks say a couple words first and then we'll open that up yeah I was gonna suggest something so we'll see um yeah we'll go we'll go ahead and start that so um well I was going to say I wanted to continue with the progress that we've made and I know that we've had a great

176relationship with leadership Associates who's helped us through this and all of this time who helped us in the process to select Dr naguchi and who really worked with the board and has been and she knows our district really well and so as we've thought about it or I've thought about it too is I think it would be helpful if we had leadership Associates go out to go out to get a contract with them and see about working with them in this um to go through this process to find out what's the best way to do this how to get this survey how to get information from the public and how to find out what the public would like to see in a superintendent and then how to go through that process together yeah and and

177on that I believe um leadership Associates would also as we take applicants it's going to be both internal and external so we get to see the entire pool of candidates and we can um consider every option um cuz we want to honor every option that we have um okay so uh is there any other discussion on I think we've we we're thinking around the same so I want to kind of move it forward and give direction to staff are we okay with that trusty irvan I was just going to say let's let's move it forward you know we're all in agreement you know let's move it forward all right okay so um based on this discussion we the board would like to direct staff to present a contract with leadership Associates for ratification at our

178next meeting the next regular meeting the next regular meeting not our Workshop which is coming up in two weeks okay that's not really a vote that's just a Direction so we're going to go and that do that all right and with that here we go um we've got two more things here we've got uh approval for vote for no more than two candidates for the California school boards Association delegate assembly 2025 so are there any comments from the public on this agenda item all right we have uh two candidates that we can vote for we vote for at most two the two are Mary Jackson from Turlock and Ray proc Jr from Dair are there any comments from the board Tristy marks I think they'll both be good I have worked with both of them

179briefly with um Mr Croc uh on our um in our delegate assembly and so we meet as a region so there's 15 in our region and they're two of them and so I think we should just vote for both of them so I I don't and I mean we're welcome to write in a candidate it's really hard to get somebody to win this unless you've contacted all the districts in the county and said please vote for me um you know if someone wanted to do that but I think I'm fine with both of them all right trusty Irvin I take it we can vote for two yes we vote okay okay gu I've worked with Mary Mary Jackson so um yeah if we can vote for two then let's let's send them to delegate assembly

180you well I was gonna I was gonna I'm getting there oh so do I hear a motion to approve Mary Jackson from Turlock Unified School USD and Ray proc Jr from daire USD as medeso City Schools Board of Education Choice as the two candidates for the Cs SBA delegate assembly in 2025 I hear a motion from vice president Mahia second from truste Irvin all in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed see none the motion carries unanimously and I believe Whoever has the original document that was sent to us that has to be sent in because I've been on the balloting committee and if they don't send in the original it's not counted yes okay okay and with that we go to Mr Henderson Henderson please stand no it's okay all right go

181ahead okay yeah I just want to note it took until 50 for anyone to mention the Super Bowl and um I don't know how many fans we had the outcome of that but uh I happen to be one so uh it was a closer for the Chiefs and I'm glad to close the meeting uh so item B8 recommends approval of a resolution authorizing the assignment of teachers outside their credential academic major and minor uh we present this resolution for certificated staff who are credentialed in an area other than physical educ education to allow them to coach one period of Athletics for which students receive PE credit and uh that's the purpose for this uh author authorization tonight it's been determined these individuals qualify under the authorization granted through this resolution and re recommend the board

182approve this item all right thank you are there any comments from the public no you sure okay thanks any comments or questions from the board do I hear a motion to approve the resolution 20 dot dot dot 24233 authorizing credential outside the credential area Accord to Education Code for 2426 so I got a motion first by trustee Irvin and a second by vice president Mahia all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed hearing none motion carries unanimously thank you fly Eagles fight sorry are there any items to be placed on future board agendas hear none do I hear a motion to adjourn move moveed by vice president Mahia second by trustee Lopez all in favor say I I any opposed hearing none the meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.