CorpusRecord 169168

Board of Education Meeting Jan. 14, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Morongo USD
Date
2025-01-16
Location
San Bernardino County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,531 words · about 42 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Reconvene to 6 0 6. Tonight we're gonna start with pledge allegiance, but we'd like to recognize An individual. It's kind of where he wasn't here anyways. Uh, David Daniels has played a key role in raising the standards of the district's facilities. He has been the driving force behind numerous successful projects, and his contribution was instrumental to passing the bond. Measure C, this achievement among many others, highlights state's ability to manage complex projects and deliver outstanding results. David's innovative approach to operations has streamlined processes resulting in increased efficiency and productivity. Additionally, he's exceptional problem solving skills and dedication to excellence have not only improved our operations, but also fostered a culture of continuous improvement and teamwork within the department. Graduation state. Thank you very much for your words. I'd like ask everyone to stand allegiance and

002please Right hand over your heart pledge allegiance, United, United States, America, and Republic. Extend one nation under God with liberty and justice for all the video on 2, 3, 1, 2, 3. We'll now have, You'll now request a motion for the adoption of two minutes Agenda. So moved. All in favor. A I The zero Also have a, a motion for the, the adoption of the minutes for the December 17th meeting. So moved. All in favor. A Actions from the result of the closed session be resolved at the Board of Education Readmit dated 23 dash 15 two MUSE. This has been passed and adopted as of today, the 14th of January with a vote of five ayes and zero mays. Now we will go to our superstars from the different schools. We'll start with Tony Palms

003High School representative. Good evening, everyone. My name is Williams Sump and I am here representing Tony Palms High School. And I have some very exciting news for you this evening. The second semester is underway and we are excited to now have the California Cadet Core classes being offered to continue the program that begins at junior high. As you may know, our school-wide focus this year is on promoting academic success within our freshman class. But first semester grade reporting data is in and is very promising with the help and support of our high school success classes and teachers. While cath ninth graders are off to a great start, we saw significant increases in the passage rate for several core freshman courses, um, including a 9% increase in English, a 6% increase in biology, and a walking

00421% increase in integrated math one. We are also very excited about our ninth graders that are part of the early college initiative cohort who have already started their college grant college transcripts by taking CMCs Dual Enrollment College and Personal Success classes this fall and will let, are now taking dual enrollment, public speaking and athletic news. Winters sports sports are in full spring. Our DVL seasons having become our athletic director Coach Art is happy to report the first time since the pandemic. We now have varsity and JV teams for all four winter sport programs. The Wildcats, um, are, Sorry, the Wildcats are taking on Yucca Valley Valley in both basketball and soccer this evening, and we'll battle Coachella Valley on Thursday. As you may have read in the Desert Trail in December, Wildcat Senior and Reigning

005athlete the year Jen Silvas, who recently accepted a full ride scholarship, a soccer or f Cal State Fullerton, was selected to represent Mexico in the Women's National Softball Team, um, in an international term in Puerto Rico, where she played in every game. This opportunity may lead to Jenica, traveling to Tokyo, Japan with the team later this year. We also want to, uh, celebrate Wildcat football standout, Zach Arwin, Jay Macte, and aid Ildy, who were chosen to play an annual desert, elite showcase, east versus West game in Indio on December 21st. This is also Winter Sports Weekend. TPHS with theme day is all week, culminating in our Winter Sports Assembly this Friday. Finally, TPHS is excited to announce that the first time ever we'll be sending a group of wildcat leaders to serve on San Bernard

006Bernardino County Superintendent of School Student Advisory Panel. Six Wildcatters are bring all grade levels, will be traveling to the four advisory panel sessions throughout February and March, and we'll proudly, uh, represent TPHS and give voice to our high desert community at the county level. That's all I have for now. I'm William Sum, and I'd like to thank you for the opportunity to speak with you here tonight. Do you guys have any questions? I do not have a tremendous job. Thank you. Thank you. You does not appear. You have Ellie representative. You I hear. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. No worries. I just thought maybe you'd sit next to each other, but I get the rivalry so I was in the back and couldn't Bring Her in and I apologize. No worries. Okay. Well, hello. I'm Jada

007Watson, a SB President at Yucca Valley High School, and I'll be seeking on behalf of a SB today. Yucca Valley High School will have our first senior parent meeting on February 25th at 6:00 PM in our electrical. We, we will have a few vendors there that are available to purchase senior belongings and parents and students will obtain the final timeline for the detailed information on senior things. Winter formal is in the process of being completed by our sophomore class, and it'll be held in the gym on February 1st. Take around sale now they months of this Monday and it's $20 without a SB and $10 with a SB, the theme is gonna be candidly themed and it'll be from seven to 10 on the Friday before there will be a PIP assembly for the winter

008sports and the winter portal. Our winter sports are working on building routine with signups and tryouts. With our, with this, we're excited to see how their seasons progress, progress and how they continue to work and improve as a whole. For winter sports. We have both JB and varsity boys and girls soccer, basketball, and wrestling. All of them are doing well within their very first few games. Trojan Golf is holding open practices on Wednesday's ad Hocs Landing Golf Club, and for any interested freshman and sophomore underclass, our Yucca Valley High School cheer team will be hosting a cheer clinic for anyone interested in being a future cheerleader for our Trojan team, their are flyers available in our front office, or please look at our social media page. The clinic will be Saturday, January 25th at Ya

009Valley High School, where they will learn skills and materials to perform at a high school basketball game with a large break that happened in December. A SB does not have any major events being hosted. However, each class is working on individual projects that they'll have set and are being prepared for. As executive board, we are on moving. Dates to rebut have been. We're working on Lips and Battle. Senior class is working on senior excursion as well as Brad May and end of the year activities. Our junior class will continue to start blanket at each sports event and is also working on prom in every 15 minutes that is being hosted at Yucca Valley High School. Our sophomore class is hosting winter formal this year in the Candy Link theme. Our freshman class helps out with

010creating our monthly calendar and putting important dates on there. And our commissioners are planning our winter support, prep assembly as well as future preemies. Thank you for giving me the time and support in making every event possible. I cannot wait to continue our student and committees and get more involved with our school project. Thank you. Do you guys have any questions? Thank You. That was a good report. Thank you. Um, however, I failed to, uh, write down the date of the Parent meeting. I think it will be, um, lemme see. It's February 25th at 6:00 PM 6:00 PM Yes. Thank You. Thank you. Request. You do not have to sit through this torturous meeting. If you do want to, you're more than welcome to to see the process. Thank you very much. Have a good

011evening. You'll now, I believe it's Carol Lee, the legislative report. No report tonight. Thank you classified representative. Thank you. Thank you. Not Tonight. Not tonight. Okay. You know, your honor. Next up certificated representative. Thank you. Alrighty. So MTAs executive board and negotiations team started our site bargaining visits today. By the end of January, we will have visited every site to provide all members easy access to voice their insights, concerns, and ideas so that we may focus our bargaining on what our members feel are the most important issues. Uh, we'd like to thank each site in advance for welcoming us and finding us a little spot, uh, for which to converse with the individual members privately during the day and time to meet as a group after school. And also thank you for extending the report

012card window to this Friday, uh, after the loss of power for two days. Thank you. Thank you. I will not forget the Marine Corps representative this month. As usual, like Very much. Thank you. That leads us to the reports by the superintendent and staff members. Uh, Mr. President, We have the honor report presented by Oscar Gonzalez on Good afternoon everyone. Um, today we're here to present the results of the 2324 Your Honor report for the district. Um, usually like to highlight before I present is I usually don't touch base on those, me at this point or all of the sub. Let's remove at this point. But of course you guys ever have questions, the district can always email us and we can gladly respond to that stuff. Um, I'll keep it short, just a moment.

013We kind of running our time. Um, what you like to do is kind of give a background in terms of how the audit takes place. Usually around February and March, we'll visit a sample of your guys' school sites and we'll build out 30 tests, third return controls as it relates to attendance and a b Tech controls. Um, we'll subsequently have a visit to the district where we'll test internal controls as pertaining to cash receipts, payroll, cash disbursements. We also will start testing state compliance on federal compliance, and we'll have one visit at year end where we'll wrap up our state compliance areas, any thorough compliance, as well as focus may most our time on the financial audit, making sure that the amount of actuals are fairly stated as of June 30th. Um, what everybody's kind

014of worried about is actually the results. Um, so in terms of the financial statements, we actually, um, issued an unmodified opinion, which is a clean passing rate basis for the district. Um, for federal compliance. This issue, we test their Title one part A and federal impact a again, in that aspect we give a unmodified opinion to clean opinion. And then lastly, for state compliance, we also give the district clean opinion on that aspect. But there was one finding it was related to immunizations. We identified two students that didn't have the required immunizations within the specific time to make in the school year. I will highlight though, that district has taken steps to implement monetary precision, um, monetary procedure procedures to identify those students and subsequently reach out to the parents and guardians, making sure that

015hey, we can provide you communication, what information that they need to ensure that those students receive those vaccinations within the time manner. Um, other than that, do you guys have any questions? I did, I was gonna ask you about the immunization. So, um, it said two out of 10 students. Was that a sample size or did we have 10 students within the District? No. So it's at the time of the sample size. Sample size, there was two. Yes. Okay. And we following your recommendation on how to have a better process in place for that? Correct. Okay. And the second piece was, and I don't, I don't know who could answer this necessarily, but a SD it sounded like it was, um, a little wild wooly, like the record keeping wasn't spectacular. Um, You just put

016that one second comment indicated. I think it was just one Ifferent schools. I believe they had that. Yeah, I was just mentioning something about the record keeping within the a sb and like what sort of recommendations you have so that we have better controls. Because I know that's outside of the district office, but I'm assuming the district office would kind of keep their eye on that. Yeah, I'm sure. I'm assume the district providing training to them if they need to. Um, it kind of would follow the same kind of record keeping a division internally for their business end of the district. So they're probably kind of communicating with the schools guidance to them in terms of, Hey, this is what the Ottawa see, you know, the purchase position, the approvals, the invoice at slip, you

017know, that those, those Did you also, uh, audit the a DA? We did. I I thought that was really good. How close did Those two figures, um, match? So I guess there was no real problem with that at all. Uh, not based on what I see to the audit report. Again, I was kind of the auditor in charge of this audit, but based on the audit report doesn't look like there was any issues. Okay. Good. Anyone else on the board? Thank you Very much. Thank you. And next we have the citizen committee involves their responsibilities and Sheriff is presenting. This is Don Fields from work. This is Don Fields for Moore. Good evening board members and cabinet members. Uh, first I'd like to congratulate you on the passage of the, the bond measure. It's fantastic.

018Um, with the passage of a Proposition 39 bond measure, there are a number of accountability measures, um, including that you'll have, uh, performance and financial audits, but also that you'll have a systems oversight committee. And so once, uh, the action tonight, uh, that's a little bit later in the agenda to declare, officially declare the results of the election occurs. Uh, the board has 60 days to put a systems oversight committee in place, um, along with, uh, action to declare the results. You'll, uh, you're going to approve some bylaws for the committee, and that will give them some guidance on, on their operations. But essentially, the provisions relating to the citizens of oversight committee are set forth in the education code, um, in the area where the bond provisions are set forth. Uh, now the purpose

019of the committee is to make sure that the items on the bond project list, um, that bond bond press proceeds are only spent on those projects. Um, and so the, the city, the the committee will review the expenditures as the district makes 'em, and ensure that all of those expenditures apply to one of the projects. Um, the committee can review other materials relating to the bond measure, including the performance and financial audits in connection with their duties. Um, now there is a little bit of confusion typically on the role of the committee versus the role of, of you as the Board of Education. Um, the committee again, is to review the expenditures as the district makes. And us, uh, board members, um, are elected and are empowered to make the decisions related to which projects

020go first. Um, how those projects are, are constructed and completed, um, and the overall timing of those projects. And so even if, if you wished you could not delegate that authority, that's vested in you to the committee. Um, the committee has an important purpose, but it's not to, to select projects or how they're designed. Um, they are to make sure that the projects that you do spend money on are spent only on the projects that are listed in the law mission. Um, so the committee is, is operated similar to how your board meetings are operated. They're subject to the Brown Act. So they will have a posted agenda and, and it'll be open to the, the public. Um, they must have a, uh, annual report. Um, and they are required to have at least one

021meeting a year. But typically they are more like a quarter in the meeting Meeting. One other thing is the district is to make a website a page on your website available to the committee so that it can, its activities can be recorded to the public. So the committee has to have seven members. Um, and five of 'em are specific members, um, that you, they have to have some kind of affiliation, like a business organization, a member and a citizen, a senior citizens organization, a unify taxpayers organization, um, in a member in the business community. The other two, uh, I'm sorry, in a, a member that is a parent or guardian of a child in the school district. Um, and then a member that is a parent in a Guardian, both a parent in a Guardian,

022um, or, and a member of a parent teacher organization. The other two members are just at large. And so there's no specific requirements for those two. Uh, one, one thing to note about the committee, I've mentioned that you have 60 days to put it in place. Um, if for some reason a school district, uh, is willfully not putting their committee in place, uh, any citizen could come forward with a lawsuit to prevent you from spending bond proceeds until it's in place. Um, so it's an independent citizens oversight committee. So that means that no, uh, current board members or employees or vendors can be on the committee. Um, now the committee members will serve for two year terms, um, and you could, uh, have three consecutive terms as a maximum. Um, that seems like a lot,

023but usually bond programs go several years. And so, um, there's oftentimes where committee members will turn that. Um, so I mentioned earlier the, the systems oversight committee provisions are in the education code. Um, that sets forth all of the, the, uh, requirements for members, um, the annual report, um, independence. Um, and so most of the provisions govern that, govern the committee are there, um, the Citizens Oversight Committee bylaws that will be before you and later in the agenda tonight, set forth those provisions, but also give a little extra guidance on operations on how to, to, uh, select, uh, members, um, and puts forth the process for putting that together. Um, the other important document, of course, is your full text of your bond measure as part of Prop 39. You have to have a specific

024project list. And so that project list is gonna be very important for the committee members. Um, 'cause that's what they're gonna be comparing your expenditures to and according to the public that the expenditures were all made and consistent with that project list. I'm happy to answer any questions I have. I I have just one. Um, we have 60 days from here. I didn't quite catch That one. Oh, sorry. 60 days from tonight when, assuming that you, uh, adopt the resolution to claiming the results later on in the agenda, Is the, uh, is the district responsible for facilities for those meetings? Or how, how would that work? The district is, uh, responsible for the cost of helping administer the committee. And so providing a place would be Included. But can those take place on a school

025property? Is that Yes, that's what, okay. And then, um, I'm Assuming they typically do, And I'm assuming that they would apply through our District Life website typically helps handle the oversight committee. Uh, we provided a, a sample application. And so how you advertise that will be up to you as school districts typically do, to have, uh, in accordance with how you advertise for other positions or committees. Thank you. Thank you. And congratulations again. Appreciate it. That brings us to the public conduct section. Individuals, individuals may address the board on issues within the district of the NUSD Board of Education that are not on this agenda. There is a time limit of three minutes per person and 20 minutes per topic during public comment. Please refrain from applause or side commentary to ensure the board members

026can properly hear all public speakers. Members of the public are expected to maintain a professional, courteous to quorum during their comments. Inappropriate behavior, which disrupts, disturbs or otherwise impedes, the orderly conduct of the meeting will resort forfeiture of your public comment privileges. The board is prohibited by state law from taking action or discussing items not on the printed agenda. Public comments on specific agenda items will be deferred until consideration of the item on the agenda. With that being said, first up would be Melissa Bond. Good evening. But that was good. I'm, I'm Melissa Bond. I'm a retired teacher, 36 years. 36 plus year two, the district, I think my main concern, and, and I'm looking at something that was right up to my attention just today, um, is the lack of fact that we have

027to cut people with the cut positions. Um, I see several that they, I get that, but I think you guys are having trouble keeping people because of course I'm looking here and these are all three, three and a half hour people. One six hour person, one five hour news supervisor. But people can't live on that, guys. I mean, you know that as well as I do. Secondly, um, we're concerned about funding. This district has more money for those of you that are new to our board than any district around us does in our monies. I know this for a fact. We were a laughing stock about 10 years ago. Our districts down below, because we had at that time, I believe, approximately $25 million in our funds. Well, I know we have double if not

028tripled that now, and we're still growing about funding. My biggest concern for you board members is I really would like for you to take a look. We have fewer students now than we have had in years. Fewer. And we're losing students. Okay? We need to look at where the money is being spent. We have more people in our district office than we've ever had before. And these people are making six figures. They aren't just making minimal wage, three hours, three and a half hour. A, they're making six figures. And we've got tons of positions with directors under the assistants with an assistant and the director, what have you. I know of two people that were let go that did a job, two people, and now there's 15 people with different parts to this job that's

029being done. And I just think we need to take a look at where our monies are being really spent. Because I know as a teacher, I worked my tail off. I didn't have time to breathe. I still do. I back subbing out for you because I know that we're in dire need for socks and I'm working. I mean, I just started and I'm working. So my deal is, I think we need to look at where monies are. I think we need to start addressing where we need the money. We need instructional assistance. We are in a situation right now where we don't have kids that are the same now from when I started teaching to now when I finished teaching. We have kids that have really severe need. And I think you guys all know

030that if you've been in the classroom, if you haven't, I would suggest you take a visit and go walk through some classrooms and see what's actually going on there and what these teachers are dealing with. I'm gonna be working in a classroom tomorrow that's dealing, or excuse me, Thursday, that's dealing with a real rough situation. I've been in there several different times, just assisting and helping out, and it's not an easy room to come to. So thank you. Thank you. We will now have Mr. Alam. Good evening. This is, I think, my first time addressing you as csca a's labor rep relations representative. And maybe my first time in the 20 years I've worked for Unified, uh, up until now at least. Um, I'm here to talk to you about action item number 10. The,

031the layoff, uh, as Missy just spoke on, as you'll notice, they're all part-time positions. They're all three hours except for one, one position is a six hour ia. Uh, behaviors. Uh, by laying off these positions, the message you're sending to the community is, everything's okay. Special ed's getting enough help in the classrooms, behaviors satisfactory. Everybody's getting fed on time. And the reality is that's just not the case. I remember about a year ago, you had a one of CSA member come and speak to you about how they're being overwhelmed, overworked, just in the office. That's not even in the classroom. Uh, this is an ongoing problem. Um, and as Missy, uh said, just said, nobody wants to work for three hours. And back 15 years ago when I was on the negotiations team as a

032classified employee working two hours a day, that wasn't paying the bills, I guarantee it back then. And three hours right now is not paying anybody's bills. Thank you. You'll now move on to the adoption of the consent Agenda. Do we have a motion? Second. All in favor? I need to pull Some stuff. Oh, you're pull. I'm sorry. Oh, I thought you Put on my I did. I seconded. It didn't be full stuff. Gotcha. Okay. All right. So starting with, uh, district sponsored social media, if we can pull that for discussion. Uh, item seven, uh, superintendent's contract. Told that for discussion. Those are mine too. I dunno if anybody else needs that to pull Anything. What was the item number on the first? Uh, five. Okay. Five and seven. Okay. We will now take a vote

033on the adoption of the consent agenda, excluding item five and seven. All in favor A. Aye. Okay. Carrie, It with the board policy 1 1 4 district sponsored social media. Who's responsible for writing this? It's our PA CS B. A Cs BA. Oh yeah. Policy. Okay. So CSBA did this policy? Yes. Okay. Um, when I compared this policy to other districts, when there's a paragraph, they're also quoting. So for instance, if it says, you know, the district is looking at our social media to promote inclusion, whatever, it would go to that policy and have that as a tag underneath so that parents could then say, okay, it falls into the philosophy, or it falls into the mission statement, and so on. So this policy just kind of reads as an essay. And I'm wondering why

034we didn't add those parts in every other district, every other district in Southern California. And I went, I won't say every other, I went through what, 12 or 13, including friends who are on the board and their policies are all very nice looking when ours looks like an Essay. So this is a brand new policy to MUSD. We've never had a social media district policy before. This is the exactly what We have not made any edits to it. We can do that. That's perfectly fine. Um, it does reference in it like in a laws and things like that, which we do have separate things for. So that would be, that's, I mean, I mean it's, uh, there's, um, so it doesn't include, that doesn't mention, um, one thing that spoke out to me before I

035was on the school board, I had put a comment on Morongo Unified's Facebook page. Well, they didn't like it, so they removed it. Uh, so I just wanna make sure that's not going to happen to our folks who may have a comment that they want to put on there. As long as it's not slandering. And of course liable Part of this is actually detailing that we can't do that. And that, again, that's kind of one of those things of the issues of not having a board policy for social media is not having a reference document for this. Um, currently I'm training some communications site level. We have a guiding document that moving forward at all district sponsored social media accounts, including site level. Right? That was my question. So I'm good with that one. Uh,

036do you want me to go onto the next Yes. The superintendent contract? Yes, please. Alright. It has striked out in it that the board may consult an attorney with regards to the contract. Why did we strike that out, Dr. Vargas? I actually didn't revise that policy because it was a contract of Interest. So Stacey, okay, perfect. Yeah, whoever did that policy, I wasn't sure who did it. So, uh, similar to what Janae just said, this, um, policy came to it. This is the exact way that CSVA is to come to us. We didn't make to that provision. So this is how the, um, CSB sent it to us with that strike out. So there's a, there can be a discussion. I don't see anything in the guidance that, um, that says that it's now that

037that change cohesive, I just think that that's a problem to strike out. The board may consult with the district legal counsel prior to holding a closed session with the designated representative to discuss compensation to be paid to the current or prospective superintendent. I don't like taking away the fact that we should always be able to have attorneys or lawyers at our discretion, especially with contracts. And just to follow up, the only, um, some of the CSBA reasoning behind some of the changes in this specifically said that they just made those changes because the material exists in other policy materials. So that's just a potential reason behind that change. The CSBA, That's my, that's my issue is before I was on the board, we took away having rights as a board to have attorneys. Now we're

038taking it away. Again, that's, that's my concern with this. I'd like to see if we could put it back in. We don't ever have to use it, but don't take away the rights of, of the board. So my understanding was based on a previous board policy was that it wasn't taken by the board, um, their ability to get legal counsel with it. But those, um, references to legal counsel, and correct me if I'm wrong, had to go through the board president and the board president could still, um, on your behalf seek that legal advice? Didn't I know? No. In the past, if we wanted to have, uh, legal involved, I could go to the board or the board president or the superintendent and say, I need to speak with legal. This might be a conflict

039of interest. I could speak to legal directly all the time. I can't speak to that as anybody else can speak To that. I think everybody here is new, uh, except for, you know, well, Sharon's been in the position and, and Amy, but that's how it was back in the day. So that policy's gone. Bye-bye. That's over. You missed that shot. But this one, I wouldn't take away rights as a board when this is our only employee, our only employee that we do all of this for, to take away any, any legal counsel. And if I understand correctly, Stacy, this has been stated, uh, in other places, they, they access to that. Well, what are imparting is is that CSBA simply said that some of this language is cleanup because those items are addressed in other

040board policies. And that the reasoning for some of the changes that are not specific legal changes. Listen, CSBA can give us templates all day long. We sold the authority to write a policy. However, warrant, uh, while they're a great baseline, we can add anything into this. We can take it out and even if it's in a different policy, I, I've been on a month and, and I would still not give away my rights as a board member to be able to. So I would ask that it come back in that we would, I would ask that we let that come back in. And uns strike it. It's in number 12 on the agenda. I just think we need more information about it, About Why they struck it, I mean, before we make a decision as

041to whether or not. So Maybe pull it for now and find out. That's what I was gonna recommend that we pull it for now and then we can get supporting, uh, policy. The CSBA is, is everybody good with that? Supportive. Okay. Okay. We will now vote on item five on the consent agenda. I get a motion Verdict. All in favor? Aye. I'm gonna abstain. So you're gonna abstain. Okay. Four one. And we will pull the superintendent contract. Uh, item number seven. Okay. That gets us to the action items. Okay. Resolution 25 dash 11 proclaiming January, 2025 as school board recognition month adoption resolution dash 25 dash 11 from claimant 2025 at school recognition month from BIE Unified School District and go to Dr. Vargas. Uh, the Morongo Unified School District proudly joins over a thousand

042local educational agencies across California in celebrating the school board recognition month. This annual observances highlights the critical role of the school board members in shaping the policies, priorities, and vision that support the success. Uh, we like to read the resolution for this month, whereas an excellent public education system is vital to the quality of life for all California citizens and communities. And whereas Board of Education members are committed to children believe that all children can be successful learners and that the best education is tailored to the individual needs of the child. And whereas Board of Education members continue to advocate to best serve the children in our community each and every day. And where our public education system has faced unprecedented circumstances that past four years as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and resulting

043learning loss. And whereas our local board of education continues to act to ensure children's academic, social, emotional, physical and mental health needs are met so they can become their best selves. And whereas Board of Education members work closely with parents, school staff, educational professionals, and other community members to create the healthiest environment as possible where all students can thrive. And whereas Board of Education members are responsible for building and maintaining the structure that provides a solid foundation for our school system. And whereas Board of Education members as strong advocates for public education and are responsible for communicating the needs of the school district to the public and the public's expectations to the district. And whereas the mission of public schools to meet the divers educational needs of all children and to empower them to become

044competent, productive contributors to our democratic society in an ever-changing world is more poignant than ever before. Now, therefore, I Dr. Patricia Varga, superintendent do Herby declare my appreciation to the members of the Board of Education and proclaim the month of January, 2025 as a School Board of Recognition Month in the Morongo Unified School District. I urge all community members to join me in recognizing the dedication and hard work of local school board members and in working with them to create an education system that meets the needs of our children. And with that, I'd like to present you with certificate appreciation. Thank you very much. Asking for a motion for resolution 25 dash 11. Second. Second. All in favor? A Aye. Thank you. Next up, resolution 25 0 9. This is declaring the results of the

045school board election, excuse me, school bond election and establishing a citizen oversight committee for the bond. We're approving resolution 25 0 9, therefore entering the election results in the board minutes, certifying the election proceedings, having premises of the board of supervisors of the county, and approving the bylaws for the Citizens and Oversight Committee. I get a motion. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. We don't have a Can you make a comment real quick? Yes, please. I see Mr. Hawkins. Mr. Hoffman, did you want to talk about this or are you just here for this? Mr. Hopman was on the Measure O Bond committee and he was super helpful. Did you want to talk about this or anything? I don't know how much You want to hear you. You Were so helpful to us

046with Measure O that I wanted to acknowledge And uh, and the last time I served as the chair of the oversight committee was for the college in 2011 when we had to do the expansions and the upgrades to the college. And I was the chair for that until it was terminated at some point in time. I also served as a member of the Yucca Valley Oversight Committee, uh, for similar reasons. So I'm familiar with the process and I'm a dog when it comes to doing what's right. Thank you. Thank you for helping. Yes. Thank you for everything. Paul. I know you've done a lot for the community in general. You've been a great asset to our community. And I just have a comment, I just wanna make sure that when we are looking for citizens

047for this, that, uh, the district office or we are not handpicking folks, that this is super open to everyone. Uh, I want to make sure that it's out in every school. It is out to anyone who wants to be part of it. Um, especially I'm hoping Mr. Hoffman can come back, uh, because of all your knowledge, but that's my only concern is making sure it's out there everywhere. Thank you, Carolyn. Next up hourly class of, oh yeah, we have to voting. I'm sorry. Um, um, all in favor? Aye. Aye. Five zero. Accept the hour hourly classified substitute rate of pay will increase the hourly rate of pay for classified substitutes to 17.50. Um, Bitner, excuse me. Motion. All in favor? Aye. I keep asking questions, but that's kind of what I do. Uh, before we

048vote on this, so increase the hourly rate of pay for classified to 1750. And I know that says we're a dollar ahead. We're trying to stay ahead of California. Do you think that we could bring this up a little bit more because of how bad we need substitutes per hour? Hear me out. 1750 an hour for a substitute, but people are making 20, 21, 20 $2 at fast food joints. Has it, was it discussed to raise it more to maybe make this more attractive per hour? So the, um, intention of staying above minimum wage for a dollar came, we started that about a year, or I'm sorry, about two years ago when we did our CSEA negotiations. We raised the CSEA negotiate, uh, salary schedule by a dollar per sale. Um, so the only, we

049could be open to increasing it more or having those discussions, but I would, um, just kind of caution and concern with you probably want to talk with CSA. We do not want it to get to a point where it's encroaching on, um, our, our CSA salary. So we're balancing those two things out. The CSC of course would be involved, please. Adam, keep up on that one. Alright, that's all I have. Okay. We'll have another vote. All in favor a aye five zero. We now have a discussion around the classified layoffs. Um, we did, yeah. We will make a motion. Can I get a motion for the, gimme a second. Any discussion around this particular item? Sure. I do. This one's hard because of a custodian position. I know for a fact at 29 Palms High

050School, when I was, uh, talking with, uh, Mr. Kyle corny, he had mentioned it would be nice to have another three hour position. So when I saw this on here, but I mean, we can't give 'em a, a person, maybe a giant machine to do the floors. I don't know what they're called, scrub machines. I don't know. Um, and then with the nutritional services I get that's based on enrollment. Uh, but still, and especially the noon supervisor to bant positions, how if you roll up to 29 junior during the blockout, um, you had Sarah Smith from district office, Ms. Amy Woods from district office over there to help watch the students because there isn't enough noon sups on a daily basis. Uh, so that's my concern with this. Um, I, I've seen this before where

051they come to us as a board and they say, we need to get rid of this. It helps clean it up. Eh, it doesn't, if we really don't need 'em, they would just sit there vacant. So it, it's just kind of a, an issue for me when I know we need especially noon soups, behavior positions. But again, you know, if they are vacant, it's probably 'cause they're three hours. No one can make money, no one can pay their bills. That is the biggest issue is why would you want to do it if you can't pay your bills. Yeah. And the board, um, is requesting that Steve, uh, Stacy gives a little more clarity as to the decision. Yeah, I I can definitely do that. Thank you very much. Um, and some of these positions as

052we see on there, we've discussed several of the vacant ones. Um, they, some of these vacant positions are position control cleanup in that they may have not been filled, not just for this year. So in other words, what they're not a vacancy that we're currently flying in looking for position, they are position control cleanup. Um, as Carly stated, they could sit in our physician control vacant. Um, the concern with doing that is that sometimes when, um, we are budgeting for our positions, sometimes fiscal services, budgets, those positions, which then makes our budget look like we are over expending and staff, that's, that we're not really intending to hire for. So that's one of the intentions for doing a position control cleanup. And some of these positions that we see here, um, that are part-time positions,

053the, the position itself is being eliminated because, and we've done several over the last year, we've done several increases of position hours to full-time positions. But what that leaves is a, a part-time position, um, hanging vacant that. So some of these are an, an attempt to take those positions where we, where we determined that there was need, um, in that regard. So there's a, there's a variety of reasons for these. And I know a lot of the special ed ones, um, situations, Heidi met with, um, fiscal department and my department to really look through them and to make sure that we cleaned them up and we were, um, leading off the vacant positions where there truly is no need versus positions that we do need to continue to hire For. So to clarify, that sounded

054really loud. Um, these positions are vacant and we're not looking to hire. That is why we're trying to eliminate them For full transparency. Yes. All the four of them. Correct? Yes. Any further Questions or comments? Yeah. Yes, comments. Is it because we're not hiring them because of the lack of progression in, uh, HR that we're not out there adamantly looking for folks for these positions that we're not making them attainable for them? Um, you say you don't need them. I just cannot understand why we don't need a custodian position or nude supervisor position. That doesn't make any sense. Same with budgeting. They're gonna budget that way anyways. I've seen that game before. Uh, so that's a, that's a good one. Um, I guess I need more information on where CSEA would stand on this. Uh,

055we heard from Mr. L who represented him and he didn't seem too keen on this, but also wanted six hour positions. When you're looking at this, when it says IAMM, that's an instructional assistant for a mild or moderate kid, The what, the reason there's so many is because the district does not want to pay someone six hours. Example. My son who went through here had 21 different instructional assistants. Can you imagine if he would've had one, how great his education would've been one that would've stayed with him throughout the course? So with this, this is where I have a, a, a big problem because nobody can do three hours. They have to do three hours here, then maybe go somewhere else and somewhere else working two or three jobs to pay it. But when you

056see all of these, that's for one student guaranteed two, each position is one student. So those students may be gone. You can still think about the future special needs students that can benefit from having a six hour all day aid. So if that idea is the student graduates or they leave the district, um, that position can always be re if there's a need, we can always post that again Correctly. Let me, let me hit this because I know how this works too. Uh, it's up to the parents. If the parents come to the district and say, my son needs an instructional assistant, needs an ia, the district can say, well, we don't see where they need it. And guess what? Oh, we don't have any positions open for that. They can kind of get around

057it without giving the parent an ia unless that parent really knows their rights, really has inland regional really is involved in all of this. That's how they would get it. Taking this away. You may have some more special need kids that come in and need that, then what the parent's supposed to fight for it. And the district could turn around and say, we don't have that. We can't find that person for that position. Okay, Let's, let's go to Stacy on that. So these are specific positions in position control. They're, um, we have position members. So the positions that we, that are vacant that we're actively hiring for, for students and classrooms and needs, they're, they are out being actively hired for. These are additional redundant positions. Okay. Thank you. I have one more. Is there

058a list then of current, uh, vacancies that we are hiring for? We have that in our office. Yes. Okay. Just so we can see how it compares. Because I would hate to think, um, and the public to think that we are not hiring anybody with these positions. There are positions open. Yes. These are the redundant ones that we're eliminating from your system in hr. Yes. So they don't get budgeted for in the future, for the next school year. Yes. And I'm happy to provide a report of the vacancies that we currently involved. Thank you. Yeah, I like that. Heidi, this is, uh, near and dear to your heart, which like, comment Absolutely. Is. I, I would like to share how we went through this process to get that I sat down with faith and with

059Yeah, please come up. Okay. Good evening. I wanted to share the process of how we got to this list. Um, I sat down with Faith and Carly from the HR office. I have a list of staffing that I have per classroom. All of the level of needs for the number of students that are in that classroom. And, um, one-on-ones and the positions. And I know if they're filled or not. I don't have access to epics with, with position codes. So when we do, the three of us have different pieces of information we communicate to get it all together to make sure it's all cleaned. And so when we were looking for certain position codes that were vacant in the system that were not in mind, we could go through and say there's not a need

060for this position. So at this point you go vacant. Some of these we had done before and for whatever reason they never made it to the board. This was a couple of years ago when we had that declining in enrollment with Covid. So that's why the list is so large, um, with that piece. So that's how we got to that. And then did you guys Just do this last year? Didn't we go through a classified layoff last year? Okay. Didn't we go through this last year? I did when I, I remember being out in the audience and there was another classified layoff last year's. That wouldn't be for you, I don't think. Ms. Forget, but that would be for Stacy. Yeah, I was Gonna say we only do this every other year to look at

061mine. So it's The last year. We also did a position control cleanup. Heidi is correct. Her positions when she met with Faith and Carly were not included in that one. Um, and since the, um, classified, um, education code changed in regards to layoffs and they have, the laws now have the same protection as their certificated employees, um, we have discontinued the practice of sending abolishments monthly to the board. So it does look like one large group versus few positions, um, every month. That might have come for Abolishments in previous years, prior to two years ago. Thank you Ida. That's very valuable. You're appreciate it. We'll now take the vote. All in favor. A aye No Four one items for review. Second, read and review temporary substitute personnel bullying, remu nation reimbursement and other benefits. We

062also have first read review temporary athletic team coaches under information items. We have cash receipts, the budget transfer transactional report. Next up, future agenda items. We have nothing to list. I, I need some clarification on the ethics training that we're supposed to be taking. Is, has there been any open dates for that? So Has it I like any openings. 'cause I remember like, yeah, I'd like to try to get that ethics training over With. Um, I'd like to bring up the board study session. A Yeah, that's next up. Thank you very much. So that's on the next one. Got it. Yeah. So next up would be the board and District Honor. Originally we were gonna have a board study session January 21st. Um, so that's fairly What sort of comment did you have around I,

063I have a comment that I sat up here and when I mentioned having the second board meeting, I was told over and over and, and more or less I left feeling a little bit put down that how important it was. And now I'm being asked to change the date to February 4th. Um, when I had January 21st and I supported doing the board governance, you know, session. So I wanted to know why we cannot do it on the 21st. I will not be here on the 21st. And I believe, uh, Roberta also has a, I won't be able to be maybe to day, Well, is there a way that we can like take this? I don't know, maybe more seriously since the date was on there. And especially since Ms. Myers, you were very hard

064up about how important this was to you. So I'm curious to know why I should change my date to, to the date fit in With it. The date wasn't important. It's the meeting that's important. So I can't make it. I have a standing appointment I've had for eight months. I cannot cancel. It would've been nice to have that information at the last board meeting. So could've come up at a different day to been perfect about it. It would've Been, it would've, but I didn't have it on my calendar. All right. So now we need a new date. So what is the new dates that you're proposing? Okay, so let's, let's not make this personal, let's just get a date. This is a very, very valuable session. The 21st was not doable and we, I really

065would like all five of us to be in attendance. I think this a very critical one because it deals with how we operate as a board, especially with three new board members. Um, originally we had discussed doing February 4th, so would February 4th work. I already told Dr. Vargas I can't do February 4th. Okay. So I don't know if everybody needs a regular calendar. Do we find a different date or Is there, Is there another day of the week besides Tuesday that would work that week or the pre or the last week of January for everybody? Mm-hmm. One of the considerations also, we would have to coordinate with consultant self. So we'll have to, if you Gimme a couple of days that check, So maybe we'll just table this until we can get a better

066idea from the consultant. We, no, If you, if you guys agree on a date, then I can check that. Gimme a couple of days or Sixth. Okay, so you want a couple dates? Yeah. Okay. Uh, January 30th. That's a Thursday. Does that work for everybody? Uh, How about the 6th of February, Thursday Hard Thursdays. Is there a way we could do it at night? Is that the problem? That is during the day? No. No. Not, not, it wasn't the time. Okay. Not this particular month though. Alright. I'm open to evenings afternoon. It doesn't matter to me. Yeah, evenings are fine as well. I How about the fifth? Wednesday the fifth Or Monday the third? Wednesday the fifth works for me. Wednesday the fifth works For, I can do the fifth as well. Alright, so can

067we give you two dates? Can we give you the third and the fifth? Do both of those dates work for us in the evening? The Third we have the Annual week. Oh, that's right. I'm sorry, But I'll, I'll keep the fifth. The Fifth, Yeah. In case it doesn't work that we can arrange everybody do it. Is there any way to see another date just in case I 4 5, 6? I could do six. I can do the sixth. Okay. Fifth or six. So, so either the fifth or the sixth. I'll check In the evening. In the evening, No. What, what time? Uh, the time. Uh, I check with the, uh, with the consultant and he needs, uh, a good amount of time to have the discussions. So when would we, do we keep it as

068we have planned already at four. Oh, that's what you, right? Yeah, that's what we have scheduled. Four. Is that okay? That way we have enough time for the discussion? Yes. Okay. I'm okay with That. Okay. So timely. Look at February 36th, then get back. I'll be about two years soon as I get those. Okay. Next up we have the C-V-S-C-V-A annual meeting. February 3rd, 2025 from five 30 to eight at the Dorothy in Grim Learning Center in San Bernardino. The next board meeting will be February 11th, 2025. Next up also is the coast to coast federal advocacy trip. April 28th to the 30th and Washington DC Um, that one I want you to have the discussion to see if you want to go, if the go participate and will do it so that we can

069proceed with the paper. So we're opening this up to the board to have an opportunity to attend this advocacy trip. And we'd like to see which of the five would like to attend. I, I would like to go to DC but It's, it's not just for DC It's like a lot of learning and, and advocate, but days, no, I want to tour. Oh, I mean, it is intense. I'm here to let you know, this kind of stuff is intense. Like we used to go up and do a day in Sacramento and it was super intense. I lost Hillary somewhere and I was down on the assembly floor having fun. But, uh, meeting everybody can be super, super intense. Carol, is that something you're interested In? No, I'm good. No, no. Thank you. Pete. Roberta? No.

070And I'll say yes for myself, So No, we have two. Okay. Thank you very much. That was not A four. A four. So two Right. And seven board, uh, board comments. We will start with beyond. I have no comments Roberta, No comments from me Either. Carol. I, I just wanna give a shout out to all the schools and how great they did during the blackout. Um, I dropped by 29 high and 29 Junior while I was out working. And, uh, they had it together at one time. Mike said, hurry up and get to your dark classrooms. You know, trying to make it fun and enjoyable for the kids. Um, so they did a really, really good job on that one. So just shout out to, to everybody, the teachers, everyone. Um, and I just want

071this noted, uh, the voicemail kind of hit me a little bit wrong when it said that, um, parents depend on the schools were food and childcare. And I just want everyone to know, um, we do not think of you as childcare workers who are working professionals, teachers, educators, site support staff, and um, so I just want to have that noted. Thank you, Pete. No Comment. Okay. That was, uh, care. Hold my thunder a little bit. Yeah. Thank you to all the staff. I know that that was trying, it's not easy to be put in that situation. It was kind of spur of the moment. Um, but I appreciate everybody's efforts. I appreciate the parents' patience, the students patience with the process. Um, I'd also like to extend a heartfelt sym, uh, sympathy toward all the

072impacted areas with the fires. There were several schools that were burned down. It's really gonna impact those communities for a number of years. And I'm getting chills is thinking about it's very sad situation. Such a beautiful place. And, uh, it's putting a lot of people on very hard times. So I just want to express my sympathy to those folks. We will now adjourn to an additional closed session.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.