CorpusRecord 169169

Board of Education Meeting Dec. 17, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Morongo USD
Date
2024-12-23
Location
San Bernardino County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,224 words · about 63 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Veronica, Veronica Lane Coleman said, nationally recognized arts professional and arts education leader with over 30 years of experience in the field. Our career is rooted in connecting artists, organizations, schools, communities through innovating arts program. As director of Groundwork Arts, Coleman oversees a team of 22 artists who bring a variety of arts, including visual performing and music arts to elementary and secondary students. Permission is to introduce students, teachers, and families to the transformative power of art to make arts education accessible beyond traditional boundaries. Her leadership emphasizes collaboration, innovation, and the creation of new models that challenged out the work, I'm sorry, challenge outdated systems deeply inspired by our humbled upbringing. Her work reflects her belief that everyone deserves access to arts and culture Like us. To everyone to stand the pledge of allegiance, please place your

002right hand over your heart. I pledge allegiance to the flag to United States, America and the Republic, which it stands, one nation God, in with liberty and justice world. 2, 3, 2. Thank you. Thank you. So You'll not have a vote on the adoption of the agenda for, for tonight's December 17th, 2024. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Five zero. You will have an adoption of the minutes for the November 12th regular meeting minutes. Appro. Um, we're looking for approval for November 12th, 23. Four. Regular meeting. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Five zero. We'll now read, I will now read the results of the closed session. Be resolved that board the board of Education accept the stipulation agreement for immediate expulsion for student 24 dash zero five. The vote was

003four ayes and one abstention be resolved at the Board of education except panel's recommendation for December 3rd, 2024. Hearing of student 24 dash 0 0 3. The vote was four ayes and one absent chair. The resolved with the Board of Education, except the stipulation agreement for the immediate expulsion of student. 24 dash 0 0 6 4 Eyes one abstention be resolved at the Board of Education readmit student 23 dash 0 0 1 to the wrong unified school district four eyes one abstention. Lastly, be it resolved at the Board of Education. Accept the recommendation of the, of assistant superintendent of human resources that employ 10 56. Be separated for employment effective at the end of the workday. December 17th, 2024. Five Eyes zeros. Thank You. We'd like to start off, which we love to do this.

004We'd like to start off with some recognition. Thank you, Mr. President. Uh, for that I'm gonna invite Amy Woods to begin with the first one, Board President Claire Superintendent Dr. Vargas and board members, thank you for allotting time on tonight's agenda for us to recap the experiences offered to MUSD students by Groundworks Art and to celebrate the many community art partners our students have access to as a result of this partnership. Art lessons are not just lessons in creativity. They are gateways to discovering who we are and who we can become through painting and music, dance and theater. Children learn to see the world through new eyes, express what their words cannot, and feel the power of their own imagination. Please welcome the founder of Groundworks Art Rhonda Coleman. Thank you, Amy. I'm a little

005overwhelmed. I wasn't expecting that. Um, recognition of appreciation and thank you for that. I, I try to, uh, keep this brief. Round Arts' mission is to ensure that all of our TK through 12th grade students, their families and our teachers, have equitable access to the arts. We hope our goal is to bridge the gap in arts curriculum, to provide and address social and emotional learning needs. And also to guide, um, give professional development to our teachers and support who do so much for us. And we do this in three ways. We develop special artists, videos and art projects. We bring teaching artists into the classroom. And we also partner with over 30, uh, organizations in the area to make sure that we can provide once in a lifetime opportunities to our students. I heard there's

006a little, there we go. I am pleased to announce that we have received a number of very important, some of the highest recognition in our county and state. Uh, one from San Bernardino County Arts Connection As an arts champion. They have since developed an arts program as a result of ours. Uh, we also received certificate of recognition from the California Assembly. And for us in the art world, the California Arts Council Certificate of Recognition is one of the highest that we can receive, aside from the National Endowment for the Arts. And recently last week, um, the board, uh, and Dr. Vargas, Amy Woods, Danielle, were able to go to Anaheim to accept the California School Board Association Golden Medal Award, which as I understand it, is sort of like the Oscars of education and I

007couldn't be more excited to receive, uh, an award that's outstanding program in curriculum and instruction category in visual Performing arts is truly, uh, something that the district should be proud of. And I want to say that this is a group collaboration. I'm not gonna bore you with the stats, but I did have to put them up here because it means something. We currently impact more than 3,200 students each month in 131 classes at all 11 schools and over 1100 classes each year. And here's how we do it. We are unique. There is no other program like ours that we know of in the country. We, oh, I'm looking at the tongue. We have a special featured artist video where we introduce students to artists in our community. Uh, we want them to get a sneak

008peek behind the scenes and see that artists come in all shapes and sizes. They work in all mediums. They have a different process. Some work at their kitchen table, others in a garage or a fancy studio. This is an example of on your left artist, there's a seagull is a world renowned costume and set designer who does these miniature sculpty creations, these tiny worlds. So the kids learn about her work and then they make their own tiny weird worlds inside Altoid tins. So our projects are not canned. You can't find 'em on YouTube. Well, you can now. Um, but we don't, we don't get them from anyone else. We create them for ourselves. I'm gonna run through the projects really quickly. So one of the projects we did last year was influenced by Steve Colts.

009He is a well-known, uh, musician who wrote for a jewel. Uh, one of his big things is that the way that you write songs, you take it from your own experiences and you write it in art journals. So the kids developed their own art journals and they did this, uh, worked on them through the whole year. The next project, uh, influenced by Native American artists, Gerald Clark. His work is all about difficult issues that appear in his community. So the kids did an identity study about themselves, and then they created their own unique symbols out of foam and cardboard. It's one of the things we're good at is using materials that are everyday materials. James O'Keefe, well-known abstract minimalist painter. He works on board and canvas, but we use cardboard. Cardboard is one of the

010most amazing mediums that you can use. And I encourage anyone to go, go get a cardboard box and deconstruct it and see what kinds of cool shapes appear. They learned about color and how color can evoke emotion. This is probably one of the most important projects they could do. It seems simple, but typography is paramount in anything you do in life. It appears on shirts, candy wrappers, billboards cards, and we had them take a look at themselves and make their own typography based on their identity. Sherry El is right down the road. She's a singer songwriter, illustrator. She does weird art. It's illustrative, it appears on t-shirts. It comes with a message. So the kids did their own special patches. We talked about theirs that already. And our last project of the end of the

011year, uh, was by our very own Heather Sprague, who was a photographer, but she started as a painter. So this project was an experimental watercolor project that incorporated science, art, and meditation. So not only do we have the teaching artists who go into the classroom to teach these projects, but then we work with all of our partners across the basin to give them the opportunity to share their work. So this is an example. The kids that did the minimalist art paintings on cardboard, that to show their work at the 29 Palms Visitor Center. I will say it is one of the best exhibitions I've ever seen. I know I'm biased, but it was better than some adults, No offense. Here's an example of taking the quirky character patches. They made four of 'em. We retained

012one, we made it into a, uh, patchwork quilt, installed it at Joshua Tree National Park, BlackRock Art Gallery. And then we also did an installation at Corner 62, which is a local business, and it had to do with UFOs and all that fun stuff that we deal with around here in the desert. And caustic, uh, three dimensional paintings. There's a little bit here, it Doesn't wanna go to the next one. I'll keep talking. The most important project that we've dive to, oh, here we go. The most important project that we've done today is a very special project that was a year long project called Science of Courage. It was a collaborative art project between the teaching artists and the students. All the students participated, but this was specifically for the sixth graders. So the sixth

013graders addressed difficult issues that they face, body image, um, depression, grief, you name it. We dove into it. We had some deep conversations that were difficult and out of that, I guess that flipped. That's okay. Out of that, they developed their positive messages to share with their teammates, their, their, the people they go to school with. And they took every single one of those lessons they learned in the core foundation and applied it to making a sign. How do we develop our own message? How can color evoke emotion? What kind of type am I going to use? What is the symbolism? I'll use what kind of illustration? There's a six minute documentary on the entire project, uh, which you can find on the website. This is to to date the ground regard. Science of Courage

014Project has resulted in 7 25 classes at 11 school sites impacted 2,899 students each month. Employed 15 artists, produced 10 art videos, featured four artists created 509 signs, two exhibitions, and one That was, um, I'm a little teary eyed because it had, um, incredible impact on all the students. I'm gonna leave it with this. What's on the horizon? Uh, what's on the horizon is as of December, we started a new program at BlackRock, our high school called Sound Lab, where we have musicians coming in and doing an experimental lab. They are learning about music theory, um, developing their own songs and also learning about music production. And finally, um, we are currently in talks with 29 Palms City Parks and Rec and also Pac about doing a large collaborative project where we're doing permanent tile

015art installation on the Community Plaza. Uh, thing I just one more thing. I know I have my time. I'm here not only as a director of art and an educator, but as a parent. I have two kids. One at junior high and one at high school. Oops. Okay. And I am a single mom who was low income. This community is everything to me. And I feel like it's our responsibility to do everything we can to give everything we have to our students. And I wanna thank the administrators, the board, and I want to thank all of our teachers, our principals, and our admins for this incredible collaboration. This is how we get stuff done, Board of Education. And Dr. Vargas, thank you for your support of our partnership with Groundworks Art and for giving our

016students the opportunity to step beyond the ordinary and embrace the extraordinary. Thank you. Can we get a picture? Can we ring the bell? 1, 2, 3. Uh, we're gonna continue with the recognitions, uh, board President Claire and members of the board. And for this, uh, at this point, I mean as a, Sorry I the wrong. Okay. At this point, I mean, I'd like to actually, uh, extend my heartfelt gratitude to the organizations for supporting the Miranda Unified School Board and the School one, measure C. The passing of the Measure C was, uh, our work. And it took a lot of effort to have our community involvement in the trust of the community to actually do it. And, uh, at this point, I do want to recognize some people, and I do want to recognize some

017of the institutions that were behind the scenes to make this happen. And to begin with, I'd like to invite, uh, the president, uh, of the committee that led this initiative. Uh, his leadership actually was instrument to make this happen. So Mr. Christopher Claire, if you please come to the, you a couple to, uh, well, a hammer, not a, so, so we're gonna have a few people that will recognize it now. Uh, one of the things is that the, uh, our president who was leading the effort was we need support and we need to have people to support this effort. And the very first person was who's going to keep control of the money? And so that was a crucial role. So Paul Hoffman, uh, has been instru in making this happen. So Paul, if you

018could please come. And then that, now that we had somewhat of a committee together, we said, so now who's gonna be the goods of the ground? And that's when, uh, we said we need to look around. Look around. And MTA came forward. So we do have two representatives on MTA three, three representatives. Okay. Thank you. If you can please come to the front. We have, uh, Amberia, Jean, Carla, and Susan. And it took quite a few weekends, a lot of doors, and a lot of walking. So it was, it was great to join the team and actually do that. A lot of meetings. A lot of meetings. A lot of meetings. Yes. And, and food too. So that was great. And we do have to recognize CSEA as well for the contribution to, uh, is

019there any member from CSEA? I don't think so, but we'll, we'll get it to them. I mean, as well. So CSEA also me was instrumental, but now that we had our committee, we had our people, we said, now we need funds. And the funding of the, of the campaign was crucial. And, and that's how we made it happen. So I am gonna call the different, uh, people that represented, uh, organizations that supported the bank, beginning with Clark Architects, Roger Clark, and Charlie. We have from Tran Roofing and Building Maintenance Harvey, cover Rubius, we have from the California Professional Management, Mike Woods. We also have from Ledesma Mayor Chris May, and we have from class leasing. Uh, team Nicholas. Did I miss anything? No. Okay. Please give them all please. Round applause for Thank you. Thank

020you for the trust that you, that you led this effort and thank to our community for everything they're doing. And we'll take 1, 2, 3, 3, 3, 2, 1. Thank you Dr. Barque. Thank you to the community and thank you for these efforts. I know that was a lot of work for sure. We'll now move on to reports from student representatives. Probably to start with Yucca Valley High School. Hi, good afternoon. My name is JC Bradshaw and I'm the a SB Secretary at Yucca Valley High School. So for Yuin Valley High School, we recently had a Saturday school on December 7th from 8:00 AM to 12:15 PM This was a great opportunity for our students to catch up on missing work, make up absences, and get extra help for some of our students. For sports,

021our winter sports are upon us at our school and both boys and girls soccer. Boys and girls, basketball and wrestling are all happening currently. All sports are in preseason. Both girls basketball and boys basketball and wrestling have had tournaments these past few weeks and have been very successful as a team. While our girls basketball team had many highlighted moments, the Lady Georgian basketball team came up short in a second round tournament game by a score of 37 to 45 against tournament host Riverside Poly High School to fall in zero two to start the season. However, we had many star players that night. Senior Sahi Gilmore led the team with S 17 points while fellow senior Taylor Monroy added seven points and Tona Simpson shift in five Points. Sophomores, cam Meina and Kennedy Golden both added

022four points to the round and the scoring. Our library at Elli High School is showcasing the following genres of books for the month of December. In the entryway, we have books that are either based on a movie or TV show and books that have a movie or TV show based off them. In the main library area, we have two tables with various Christmas, Hanukkah and winter books. With a large break happening this upcoming month. A SB does not have any major events being hosted. However, each class, each class is working on individual projects that they have set and are preparing for. Our executive ward is working on our buff puff and the Lip Sync Battle. Our seniors are working on senior excursion and end of the year senior activities. Our junior class will continue to

023sell Trojan blankets at sport events and are also working on prom. And every 15 minutes, our sophomore class will be hosting winter formal this year the theme will be Candy Cane Lane and it is held sometime in February. Our freshman class helps out a lot by creating the monthly calendar and our weekly announcement videos. Our commissioners are planning for our Winter Sports Peb assembly before winter break starts. We will be hosting a spirit week this week to bring some holiday spirit onto campus. Yesterday was Polar Express Day where everyone wore pajamas. Today was ugly sweater day. Wednesday is holiday hats day. Thursday is dressed as your favorite Christmas character day and Friday is Christmas colors. And that concludes the presentation from Yella High School. So thank you for all of your support to making all

024of our events possible. Thank you for the report. As per our custom, you're more than welcome to believe. That also includes all donors and volunteers that are recognized. If you have other things to do, children to feed, maybe you want to go to bed. But thank every everyone of you. Next up is our legislative report. Okay. Water class. Great, thank you. We will now have the representative from the classified, no classified in attendance. Thank you. Now have certificated representative. Thank you. Good evening. Um, MTA would like to give a warm welcome to the three new board members. We look forward to working with all of you and to everyone's new positions. Congratulations. Um, MTA appreciates the work and effort that instructional services has put into developing the cell phone policies in alignment with new legislation.

025Um, we do believe that a real effort was made to hear from all impacted groups, including students, families, and staff. Um, and we look forward to working with MUSD to do what's best for our students once a new policies finally in place. I shouldn't say finally, but in place. Um, with regards to bargaining MTA held two very successful bargaining input sessions in November and December that were attended by over 60 of our members in January. Our executive board and bargaining team members will visit each site to reach as many members as possible and get as much input from our members as we possibly can. And we will then utilize this information to help tailor bargaining to what our members feel is necessary for our students and our educators to be successful. And we hope that

026you all have a very safe, relaxing and happy holiday season. Thank you very much. You and I have reports from superintendent and staff members Here. I have no report. We spoke before. Just to clarify, I'm sorry. I really apologize. It my first meeting or something. Thank you very much. And we gotta get the new board members out to see you Right board do another tour, I think. Absolutely. Alright, Next up this time is the reports from superintendent staff members. Uh, thank you President Clerk. Uh, we do have, uh, Dr. Danielle Snyder. Dr. Snyder, me is gonna be here to help us and walk us through the dashboard data. Good evening, President Claire, Dr. Marga and board members, thank you for giving me this opportunity to speak to you about the data from Moraga Unified School

027District that's been recently released on the California dashboard. But before we get to the da, I wanna talk a little bit about my sister, my sister's, the Lake uc up there in that corner. From the time I was in elementary school, her, my dad and I would run and compete in 10 Ks. This was an activity that we did continuing my dad working two, three jobs and able to support the family. It was something that he had to do for his job as a marine that we were able to do together. So it was something we were very passionate about. My sister ran marathons in 2019. I got to see her run the Salt Lake Marathon. This was a big marathon for her at this point. She was ready to qualify for the Boston Marathon.

028She was running a seven, just over seven a minute mile for 26 and a half miles. She was seven until she hit miles 13. And then she injured her hip. She ended up finishing the race without qualified to Boston. She figured the dream was over between that qualifying and the injury. What was she going to do? She got herself backed up together and she realized that all she had to do was get 1% better every day. And she was going to meet her goal. She took every race she ran, she looked at those at that data, she looked at her final score. She looked at her case during, during that run and judged the performance for each branch she ran after she ran it. This we call live death. During each practice she ran, she

029looked at her pace, she looked at her heart rate, she looked at her effort pace in order to determine whether she was continuing to grow and improve and make that 1% growth every single time. This we call lead data because this allowed her to continue making that growth as she was moving forward towards that goal and response. She has now ran five of the six major marathons throughout the world with only one left Boston. She would be running Boston in 2025 with the high, with the lowest mild pace required since post pandemic. This year. She did qualify for Boston and she will be in Boston 2025. It's through using lead and lag data that she was able to make this goal. Now how does this apply to Morgo Unified and our goal, our vision? Like

030her? We know that we need to be committed to the process and we can need to continue to move forward. We need to look at our lag data, our cas and our dashboard. So let's take a minute and look at our dashboard that just recently came out right before Thanksgiving. When you open up the state dashboard site, this is what you will see. These are 20, 24 measurements. The first seven of those measurements are ones that the state uses to measure us. The last five are measurements that we do and we reflect on ourself. This is done in committees with stakeholders in or and through parent surveys in order to be able to get this information and report to the state, I'm gonna go a little bit over those indicators. One of the things I

031want everybody to be aware is we are sending out individual student reports. These are are in the process and they're also in the process of being put onto synergy. So everybody has them both available digitally and in paper. So the first set of data points that we look at is academic data. And we have our 2023 academic indicators, which is our English language arts, our math, and our English Language Learner progress indicator. This is our 2024 data shown an improvement in both ELA and math. In student engagement, we have chronic absenteeism and graduation. These are the indicator colors that you would see in 2023. We were very, very concerned this year because we see, did see that problem in graduation due to some policy changes. It's revamping on how we want to envision BlackRock High

032School. It was expected, but it did cause us a concern. It 2024, look at that color. Yes, that is green. Great work by our, by our high schools, our administrations, and our teachers to be able to make this happen for our students. We saw that growth that we had anticipated And school climate and suspension in 2023 and in 2024. The other indicator we're looking at is broad course of study. Study. Notice this one looks a little bit different with the cell phone that we saw right as we returned back from from Covid. The reason it looked this way is because this was the baseline year. This was the year to determine where everybody was at. So then we can measure growth from that. And you'll see in 2024 that we grew over 5% in college

033and career. So how do we get those colors? So you saw all those colors for each of the indicators. How is that created? It's created by our placement on a five by five grid. We look at this grid in two different ways to be able to determine where each school and the district as a whole falls. You will see in the corner where it says English language arts. That is on the California dashboard. We take the top number, that 39.9 points below standard and we look at the vertical access and we say, where in what range does that difference from standard fall? And we place us place the school or the district in that row. The next thing we do is we look at the horizontal axis to determine blood column. And this is the

034growth from year to year. We see that we grew 3.5 points in ELA from 2023 to 2024. And that would determine the call up that we found ourselves in this year. So let's look a little closer. How does this look for our schools and how does it look for our district? Are you ready from 2023? Yes. This is 2023. Now the object of this is to move up and to the right. If we're in the last three columns of the three columns furthest to the right, we are doing better. And the higher we are, the better we are. So I want to go to watch the movement of the district and the movement of the individual sites to see this growth. So we are down to only one school in the bottom low range. And

035you saw that movement to the right and some schools moving up. This shows that tremendous work from our teachers and our site administrators to be able to make this happen. Again, we look at math with the five by five grid. The square in the bottom is the spread that you would see on the California dashboard. And the vertical access is different with standards. With the 79.7 points below standard would determine the row that we're in. And then on the horizontal access, looking at the comparison from year to year with a 3.4 points growth. So what does this look like in 2023? Well, this is what it looked like. And notice the schools that again, we have in the low range and the schools that are in the the far left two columns. We wanna move

036to the right three columns and up. And you will see that in we that shift more to the right and the shift up, we have fewer schools that are in that flow range. Chronic absenteeism 2023 done the same way with the vertical and horizontal access. This was an area where we saw a huge problem since, since the pandemic. And we saw improvements every, every year. Look at the difference between 2023 and 2024. Notice the schools and the and the placements. Every single school and the district declining chronic absenteeism and many to, to the level of significant decline of chronic absenteeism. This growth is amazing. Now the star of our show, 2023 conviction. Little cringe. It's okay. And look at that in 2024. Impressive. This is the pro, this is, this is the projection we are

037moving, this is the growth we will be seeing. So How does this compare to schools of similar size and how does this compare to the state and the county? So we're gonna look a little bit at growth here. We agree 3.5 far exceeding the growth of what you saw in California average and San Bernardino County average. And in math we grew 3.4 points closer to standard. Again, over doubling what you saw from the state and the county average. But let's look at our data just a little bit closer. I wanna point out a couple things before we actually look at the scores. The first one is, is that dark line going down the screen? That is where standard is met. That is the goal point. Anything moving to the right back is amazing. That's where

038we're headed. Then you have the student groups along the side. Those student groups are indicated by the state as ones that Mongo Unified needs to attend to due to the number of students that we serve. There's your 2223 data and our 2324 there in yellow. And you see large improvement in in some of our student groups. But we see growth in almost every single one of them. Again in math with a dark line showing standard 22, 23 and 23, 24 growth in most of the students groups. And very large growth in some of them closing that achievement gap. But this is rating what happened last year. And our teachers and our principals did amazing jobs and we saw that growth. My sister used black data, which is what you just saw her pass perform, but

039you also did lead data. Do we have lead data? The answer to that is yes. In the fall we gave the iReady assessment or kindergarten through eighth grade. This is the results for ELA. This measures where the students are compared to where they need to be at the end of the year. So this will be moving as they learn more and more material through the year. And this is the math. The reason this is lead data and not live data, even though we just gave it in the fall, is because the teachers are able to go through this data and look at it real down. The principals, the teachers district office staff can look all the way down from school sites to teacher to the individual students to the individual concepts and skills and then

040mind resource from the same platform in order to target those schools, start target those students and move them forward. But do we have it for high school? Absolutely. We have NWA, which offers the same type of data for the high school teachers for both ELA and math. And they are able to use this to be able to get the concepts that their students need down to a student level to move forward and make small changes. And we make big differences. The changes that we saw Over the last year is we have gone from being 18 separate islands, each individual school sites working alone, each teacher working behind closed doors. We took off those doors, we combined our schools and we're working together in the same directions. We have aligned the L, the strategic plan to

041the lcap, to the S at the school sites. We have collaborate collaboration time for our principals and we have collaboration time for our teachers so that they can look at that data, they can dive deep, they can get the professional development they need and they want in order to better their practice and continue moving forward. The differences this makes Differentiate Assistance is, is the measurement the state uses when they're looking at each of our student groups and determining whether they're moving forward. When a student group qualifies for differentiated assistance, they have two or more indicators in the red, red. In 20 21, 22, we had 11 student groups that were in the red bringing forward the coherence model. We immediately saw a decline in the number of student groups that were in red leading us

042with four student groups qualifying for differentiated assistance. And again, last year we saw this decrease down to two. We met, we recently met with the county and the state. They said this is unheard of, this is remarkable work. And they said we should go do a road show and help other districts. But there's another way to measure this. We look at the comprehensive support and improvement, which you call CSI, which is when a school site has all or all but one indicator. So academic student engagement, school culture, all all but one in the rep for all students. They would qualify for CSI. Then we have additional target support improvement, which is A TSI. This is the same thing as CSI, except for it's for the student groups. So where CSI looks at all population at

043a school or A TSI looks at those student groups Now they added this year target support and improvement. So every time you write a new L cap, Schools Are able to qualify for CSI or A TSI the two years why we're reviewing those L caps. So this year and next year schools can only qualify for TSI. And so that's a new thing that they brought in this year. So let's look at what this looked like a few years ago. In 2022 we had three schools that qualified for CSI and 11 for A TSI. In 2023 we had one school that qualified for CSI and eight schools for A TSI. Are you ready for this? Yes. Because this just came out at the end of last, end of last week, 2024. We have no schools in

044CSI. We only have four schools. Yes. Dropped in half and A TSI and only one school for one student group in TSI. This is again a amazing work that our, our teachers and our principals have done because it has been the sum of our efforts that has allowed us to reach our goals and continue to move forward to a bigger and brighter and more glamorous goal of every student achieving and crossing that goal point that we saw on that screen. Thank you. Do you have any questions? Okay. First I've missed your presentations. It is so great. Wonderful. I love the passion. It just shows, you know, why you're here. Um, congratulations to instructional services. I mean really you blew it out of the park. Probably was help from Rhonda and her art and getting kids

045to school for something fun. So kudos to all that. Uh, question about the i-Ready for seventh and eighth grade. Yes. So I have subbed with these children and i-Ready, is there something we can look at in the future that would be not as kitty and cartoony for the middle schoolers that they might actually be engaged in with regards to collecting that benchmark data? I actually appreciate that, that question very much because I'm very proud to be able to say that we have given that same feedback to iReady. And iReady has and will continue to reformat for sixth, seventh, and eighth grade to make it more mature. So they, they have already made some adjustments and are continued to make those adjustments because of the feedback they have received from our districts and others like us

046because it's, I don't know, the kids have been, they're very, very smart. These children. Yes, they have manipulated it to get the minutes and we're not getting, because I know they know more than one plus one. Right? But we're just not seeing it and I don't know if it's just too kitty for them. So that was my only thing noticing, uh, what can we do to help you with those last two subgroups? SPED is always very difficult. I know it's very hard to meet that because their testing is a little bit different with regards to maybe they would say, which one's red and a student can pick this or which is a circle. It, it's hard to really get that data. What could we do to bring up those other two subgroups? Well, some of

047the things we're working on currently and we would love to have the word support with is the implementation of UDL. Um, we're trying to be 20 time Palm Junior High School a model UDL school in order, especially for our, uh, student groups, uh, targeting, uh, students with disabilities as well. Uh, good strategies help all students. And so working on that with having that professional development throughout the district in order to make that practices not just at a single school but at all schools as we have been doing with other things. Uh, another thing is, is we're, we are working first with which, with Sharon to be able to get the furniture and professional development in order to have our classrooms designed to make it easy for our teachers to be able to do collaborative learning

048inside the classrooms and then providing that professional development to follow up with that. Okay. Alright. Uh, do you wanna explain UDL? Just because, oh, I'm sorry. I think with starting up as a new board with some of the acronyms, I love UDL, it's the greatest thing. But any teacher can use it for any child and it works fantastic. UDL is universal designed for learning. So it is meeting the students where they're at, giving them the ability to show their learning in the way that they can show it best. So we're actually measuring their learning instead of giving 'em just multiple choice. They may be doing project based learning where they're creating a project. They may be doing group presentations. They can use different modes of mediums to be able to learn and display their learning.

049Thank you. Um, I had a couple of quick questions. I don't know if it was an oversight or maybe I didn't read it correctly, but the chronics ab absenteeism, um, I didn't see the high schools input in that data. Was it an oversight or we don't have that data or It's one of the most unique things about the dashboard is, uh, there are actually five grade levels that are not included in chronic absenteeism. That's kindergarten and ninth through 12th grade. So they are not there. Uh, student engagement is not measured through chronic absenteeism. It is measured through the graduation rate. Okay, thank you. Um, I agree that it's just like military, all these, I mean, I tell my wife it's unbelievable. But, um, as a cast, um, ELA and math, the, the area that sticks

050out, we talked about the students with disabilities, but what sticks out to me, and I'd really like to know what the district's doing about this, um, I'm trying to say it harshly, but our English learners and our long-term English learners are struggling in this district with their peers. So what sort of programs, what sort of things are we doing to help these students? We have had extremely large classification rates over the last couple years. So our students that are exiting that program are higher performers performing English language learners because they're being reclassified. And when we reclassify, we are seeing that shift. And so we have students that are struggling more with building English language development and so said we have a little drop for that. And then on top of that, we realize, uh, the

051continual need, regardless whether they're performing or not, to be able to make those programs strong. We are holding monthly, uh, meetings with our bilingual ias to be able to support that. We are working on, uh, professional development for both integrated, which means supports that are occurred during regular class instruction and designated supports for English language learn, which means times that they are just getting that instruction about the English language precisely to be able to develop that. And so working from those ends to be able to get their scores to meet, uh, those of their peers. Okay. I'll take somebody else's. Sorry. Um, the, the last thing would be the high school, well lemme see here. Yeah. The ELA, the NEW benchmark. I was curious, I noticed that for some reason our percentages go down from

052ninth, 10th, 11th grade. Do we have any idea what that would be like? We have more red further they progressed to the school and you would hope that would kind of go the other way. Actually, The, uh, high school scores, when, when you're looking at those test scores as they, as they go, it is, we have motivation issues with, with high school students who are getting them more motivated to be able to take those assessments as well as the skill sets they're looking at are higher level skills. So when you're looking at a a freshman, it looks a little different than when you're looking at a senior. So trying to get that build rigor and when we're talking in the beginning of the year, ready for the end of the year. So the rigor for

05312th grade is harder than let's say for ninth grade. So trying to build that up. Mr. Claire, if I could say something about, um, for the high school program, Um, What Dr. Snyder is saying is, is very true about the incentive, the incentives for the students to show you what they know from the ninth to the 11th grade and also the courses that they're taking, sometimes that the testing that they're doing, um, for instance, like I I know you talked about the ELA and the math, but the cast, uh, which is the science test and it's trying to find the right grade to give that in the 11th graders are tested out and of course there's only one bite of the apple for the, you know, for the high school inside of the cast. Um,

054and you've got, um, the ninth grade having had no science. So, you know, try to figure out where is the best time to test 'em. When you're looking at the NWEA and you're looking at where they're starting and where they're ending the implementation of programs at the high school level for freshmen is going to bear fruit into and up to the 11th grade. So we have the high school success program that's using the exact path, um, assessments that gives the teachers more ability to dive to, um, dive deeper into their skill sets and their skill gaps. So there's lots of programs that we're actually trying to target for the ninth grade so that it will bear fruit up into the 11th grade. It almost appears they're taking a test they're not prepared for like, um,

055so is that tied to our curriculum? Is that tied to the book? I mean, we're gonna make a 3 million investment in math books. I hope that's really tied and we get staff to buy into the curriculum and it's closer to how we're being tested and how we're being viewed publicly. I hope I as a decision, as a board of helping really, really look at this because that's concerning. I mean, I understand what you're saying, but, And that's one of the biggest change with our new math books coming up and is it, is it's going along with the new framework and our math books are old not due to our negligence and not buying them, but just because it took forever for the state to be able to develop that framework and get the skill

056sets in the right places. With the new math book, we will be able to have the, a curriculum that guides the learning, the a manner that will reach those level levels of regular and, uh, the, the social intellect that is necessary in, in order to solve the math problems that are being asked to be solved. Uh, we in, at the district level are also working with the county, uh, to be able to develop a series of professional development to guide both the adoption and the implementation of the new math curriculum. And I'm hoping that's gonna be supported by training for the teachers. Yes. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Thank you Mr. David Daniels. Is now your turn? Sure. Thank you. Good evening. I'm just gonna, so you should have a copy of the developer fee report.

057That'll be very brief. This is just a statutory requirement to record out. It's essentially just a internal line process as part of the requirement, we collect and develop fees for our district. So for those of you are new to the board, just briefly develop fees, our fees that we collect, um, from developers, builders in the area, whether it's commercial, residential, et cetera, to, um, offset the impact that it has on schools, usually in the form of growth, but it can be connected in any other district. Looking at page two or some of the highlights, like to just read through more briefly. Our beginning balance on 7 1 23. So we report out six months after the end of the, uh, recording period as the requirement and it encapsulates the previous fiscal year. So on that

058July 1st, 2023, we have 2.3 million. And our account here in the district 1 25, we have any balance in 6 32 0.7 on that one year period, we 65 and fees and prove 61,000 roughly interest four, schedule A, uh, this is illustrates b level of fees that we collect, which is level one. Uh, we do not qualify for level two or level three. So we collect the minimum, uh, statutory li for our district. And that's at 3 3 6 per square foot residential and 5 6 4 commercial industrial. That also includes for COR et. Yeah. Schedule B is a listing of the county of where the funds were spent during this quarter period. Totaling is 20,000 and you can see the list of the projects there in the college to the left. Um, sub,

059uh, final fees that DSA for, uh, Wildcat Stadium, also for Wildcat Stadium. So, uh, final fees to the architect on that. And then we have some, uh, development for the new 20 Palms junior high kitchen for that, uh, $9,000 there. And then here is the money that we spent for our facilities master development as well because reliable expenditures also under these collective fees. And then we have a small amount of fees that were charged for, uh, the agencies that collect these fees on our behalf and report to the district. That is it. Thank you David. Real quick. Yes. Um, thank you for that. Mm-hmm. Um, are these restricted any way or do you have wide discretion on where we can spend these funds? They don't have real wide discretion. They're restricted. They're, they're restricted to

060the intent for which they were collected. Okay. Thank you. Oh, you're very welcome. Oh, one more question. Yes, I, I'm just curious 'cause I've been gone for four years. Okay, no problem. Hey, has this gone up? Have we seen more building, have we seen more fees come in since I've been gone? Or has it been kind of the same as it was? It's in 2021. It's, it's fluctuated a little bit. A little bit, yeah. I mean, some years we get a little more, some years we get a little less. There was a period of time where we got very little, um, somewhere around $150,000 a year, which takes you a long time to save for a project at that rate. Um, 500,000, we seem to be in that pocket for a little bit. This is

061a little, probably a little bit higher than normal. Um, I don't know if it'll be sustainable or not, it's just, it just depends on the economy and how much interest there is in our area. So are we working with the city, Yucca, Yucca Valley, the city of 29 to see kind of where their building plans are working with their planning commission to see kind of where they are to kind of give us a better idea of the fees going forward? Do we know any of that? We used to do that. We used to kind of see, well, we've got a hundred houses, you know, that we might see pop up here. We've got a new development over here, so are we working with the, They give me a heads up on any kind of, uh,

062growth or development that's taking place in the area. Usually review the plans, et cetera. They assess how many, uh, fees are, or I'm sorry they assess it for permits and valuation, et cetera. Then we of course have the, um, levy that's placed on that at these rates that you see in here. So we have little control over what we collect or any, any impact on that as far as forecasting you're seeing fees collected on development that has already taken place or is in planning permits that have already been issued, et cetera. I'm Just curious if we looking towards the, out, I mean if we're, we had a budget thing that went on earlier, you know, with of course declining enrollment, which we hear every year, but just trying to see where we match up with

063working with all the different entities to kind of see, oh, they're looking at building a, a, I don't know, new teacher housing we learned about at the conference or something. Right? So we're, I, I kind of wanna see more working together with the, I don't know, maybe Dr. Vargas does that. So over the years we have worked with Curtis and, and Frank when they were in there when Frank was, uh, in 29, we don't get the fees until it's built. So I don't know how many, um, housing tracks David and I have driven around to look to see if they were being built because they, they didn't, they never materialized, you know, and so we can't plan on those type of promises because historically the majority of them, majority of them have not come to

064fruition. The majority of our developer fees lately have been on the new construction of the, the, the Airbnbs and you know, those units. Right. And so we see a slowing of that now. And so, um, have we worked with the agencies before? Yes, but do we budget based on them? We do not. Yeah. Yeah. No, I'm not saying budget. I'm just thinking as a forecast of, uh, I, I, I kind of wanna see all of us work more together as a whole community. We work with CCMC, so I didn't know maybe Dr. Eson doing that with James Stone and, And actually working for both, I mean city managers to, in the projects that they have outcome. And we do have to give the, okay, if we have any, any pushback or anything, we have to

065actually stay that. And I signed those off. But I would say in the past year we have had maybe four, three or four projects coming up. But like Sharon said, until they come to fruition, it's just a project. Now. I wish we can, uh, do something magically to attract businesses and people to come to the desert, which we are now saying, putting around the map, we say, Hey, you should come. So maybe more people will come. But that's, that's the work that we do. Okay, Cool. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you David. You'll now open a public hearing for the statutory school facilities fees report. Any public comment. Okay. We will close the public hearing on the statutory school facilities fees report. Next up, public comment. Individuals may address the board on issues within the

066jurisdiction of NUSD court education. We have to vote. Oh, I'm sorry. My apologies. We have to vote on closing of the public hearing for the statutory school facilities making a motion. So move to All in favor. Five zero. Thank you. Back to public comment. Individuals may address the board on issues within the jurisdiction of any USD Board of Education that are not on this agenda. There is a time limitation of three minutes per person and 20 minutes per topic during public comment. Please refrain from applause or recite commentary to ensure that board members can properly hear all public speakers. Members of the public are expected to maintain a professional cur courteous decorum during these comments, inappropriate behavior which disrupts, disturbs or otherwise impedes. The orally conduct of this meeting will resort the forfeiture of Republic

067comment privileges. The board is prohibited by state law from taking action or discussing items not included on the printed agenda. Public comments on specific agenda items will be deferred until consideration of the item on the agenda. We'd like to start with Mr. Jeff Hor, please. Still in intent, Mr. Horton. Okay. We know this guy. How about Mr. Jeff Bramo. Good, good evening. Congratulations President Claire. Uh, I thank the board for the opportunity to speak again, the item. I'm Jeff, the corporate chair of Lascon Well Arts Flying Doctors. We provide mobile, medical, dental, and vision clinics in such areas as Mexico, El Salvador, Guatemala, uh, Haiti, and other places where healthcare is difficult or financially or politically impossible to obtain. Uh, this also includes areas of California. All the services that we offer are free to

068the individual and provided without discrimination based on race, religion, sexual orientation, color, creed, or political affiliation. On Saturday, March 8th and Sunday, March 9th, 2025, we will hold our annual clinic at Yucca Valley High School. It's sponsored by the local healthcare district and media sponsorship from Z 1 0 7 7. It is solid support from the VFW and equipment is provided by our partners HU in California. It is planned on both days that we will have up to 20 dentists, including oral surgeons, pediatric and general dentists and hygienists who will examine clean drill fill and sometimes even pull up to six. Optometrists will provide free vision exams and if the individual needs glasses, they will be, for most cases, they will be custom made onsite with our onsite fabrication unit. As always, your students are

069a big part of it with dental, medical, pharmacy, culinary, A-S-B-E-S-L, and other student groups assisting. And again, let me stress, everything we do is free to the individual Dr. Vargas, president Claire, you have my formal invitation as the corporate chair and for the organization of the Flying doctors to visit us at Dr. Bailey High School during one or both of those days. See how this event continues to showcase your students as they help the local community. Again, join us on March 8th. End on March 9th to see your career tech get programs, provide career training and immensely benefit the community. Last year we saw over 230 individuals in a single day and cut over a 200 pair of prescription glasses. We're hoping to double those figures, Come drop in and see it, or better yet,

070volunteer with us for an hour. War ii. There are students who are a big part of this and you can be too. And as usual, no appointment is necessary. Thank you. We will now look to the adoption of the consent agenda. Are there any items that the members of the board would like to pull for further discussion? Yes, I need to pull, uh, section B, human resources and certificated personnel. If we could pull that, Uh, one and two. Um, yeah, yeah. It, it, I, the second one, the first one has nothing on it. The consent. So I, yeah, when I, Um, I believe that's it. Okay. So that being said, we will, I will take a motion to adopt the, the agenda, or excuse me, the consent agenda minus the human right resources number. Were

071won. I do, I have a motion. So moved. All in favor A Aye. Five zero. Okay. Kelly, would you please lead us with that's discussion? Yeah. I, I just need to, um, be able to vote on this differently because I can't, uh, sub anymore now that I'm on the board. So principals quit calling me. No, I'm kidding. I'll still come and hang out, but I can't vote on myself. So I wanted to pull that out to abstain. Okay. So we'll take a motion to, to accept human resources. B one. Aye. Do I have a motion? I move. Second. All in favor? Aye. Okay, We have four ayes and one abstention. Alright, our action items. We will now have the 2025 board meeting calendar. The board of education is requested to adopt the calendar of regular

072board meetings for 2025. Do I have a motion? So moved. Second. All in favor? Oh, no, I have discussion. Oh, okay. Go ahead please. Um, the calendar that's actually on, and I can't pull it up 'cause I just got my, I've had tonight, uh, the dates aren't matching. So for instance, it'll have two meetings. And so it says board meeting on May 22nd, but then May 27th is highlighted. So we need some, it needs to be adjusted. It is correct. So may, May 13th is the board meeting Uhhuh, including recognition of the 22nd. So the board meeting date, See May 29th though. So you heard your dates are wrong on here. Thank you. Yeah. Um, so this is gonna have to be, uh, that adopted as amended Yes. If you wanted to do that. But

073I have some more discussion on this. This was really a long agenda to read. Um, and I'm all about doing the work, but I read every single item. I mean, I reached out to Dr. Vargas with regards to some budget questions I had on the payroll. I found typos in that. Um, it's a lot to do in one meeting. So I'm, is there a discussion we could have or come back as a board to not just only do board studies but divide this? Because this meeting only gives parents one chance to really talk to us. And that's my concern, especially rushing here at four 30 because my job is, is kind of busy and I'm literally rushing home, getting, you know, in my car to get here at four 30, which is fine. I, I'm

074good with the job, but I feel like this is our only chance to see parents and staff. Or if something comes up in the district that we need to vote on, we wait for a whole nother month. Uh, so I'm just trying to understand this new, uh, board. Or we can discuss this as a board to go back to two meetings and then put those work studies beforehand. Kind of like a presentation. Yep. Or presentation. That's a lot. And reading through all of these items for review, that's gonna be on the next one. That's a lot too. So I don't know if that's a, something we can discuss us. Well, one of the, uh, just to provide a little bit of background and explanation as, uh, the district, the reading of the items for review.

075For instance, the second read review, this one is provided three months as three readings that we do for this one. So this will have been a month, second month and a third month. So that's why we allow you the time to actually do the reading and go through those, those items. Now usually the meetings don't have these many presentations as we have today, but we have the recognitions presentations and that's what, this was a, a little heavier meeting, but uh, is not usually like that. And as far as the board study sessions, the board has requested a meantime to actually dive deeper into understanding what we do as a district, which is why we added the board study sessions. Now as a, as a district, uh, we have found that one meeting a month, uh,

076does comply and meets the needs of the district to present to the board. And the study sessions are to dive into the, uh, the data and everything. If you notice for next year, for instance, October 28th, is to do the data and safety presentation as opposed to now in December when we have the late, uh, late release of the data. So that's the reasoning behind, I mean, having the two meetings a month, but one meeting dedicated usually, uh, as a study session, unless it's required to have more votes on then like in June, uh, than we need to. So I get that that's bare minimum. Again, as a parent, as a working parent, we are only giving one option to these folks to get to these meetings. That's it today. And then guess what? If

077you have something that comes up, we'll see you next month. Or if something comes up that we need to vote on, if we have both, listen, I'm fine with the items for review reading them. I don't think they need three readings. Um, but I don't know, it just, I like being really transparent. It's hard and I, and I'm willing to go the way any of the board wants to go. That's why I wanted to have a discussion on it. I, you know, I'm very supportive of this board. We're gonna do great things, but it's worth a discussion on parents and folks in the community only giving one chance to speak public comment. Understood. So Anybody else have thoughts on that? I am a new member, so this is just me coming into this after getting

078the agenda. Uh, I, I spoke to Chris a little bit about it and I said, is this normal to have this many items on the agenda? 'cause I was kind of taken aback. I didn't have adequate time to review everything as I would've liked to. Um, I know you're saying that's not common for it to be this long. Um, and then again, I'm new, so I'm not sure how much you do cover during normal meetings, but it does seem like a lot. And there were a lot of things today that I would've liked to have had more time to review before going and, um, in front of the public and, uh, discussing items for sure. My con my thoughts are that, um, I really enjoy the workspace sessions, the board, they're open to the public.

079I know that that leaves up working people. But um, if there's something that needs to be taken care of that would happen in regular session, we can do it in that session as well. I think it's bonded us as a, um, board, previous board. We get to, um, do book studies together. We get to dive deeper into our learning of how the district, um, operates and functions. So I really enjoy the second being in the work study session. So I, I guess my question is, if there is a month like this or a month in the future, we have a lot of agenda items. Is it possible that we can have hold a second board meeting? Like we can put that on it on the calendar? You would have to do it as a special

080board meeting. Okay. And then added on, which gives no notice to folks to even show up. Same thing happens, you know, we still have to ize it and everything else, but most of the time people do those special board meetings as I've seen in past, it'd be on a Wednesday at one o'clock. Again, we're leaving out the public on, on this. And I mean, when I was on the board, we did the work study sessions no problem. Before the meeting, we had plenty of time and the staff would send it out a week prior so we could already review it and then say, okay, what are some questions that we have? Um, I don't know. I just always come back to the same thing and I'm, you're gonna hear me say it and it's gonna

081get, it'll never get old to me, what is best for kids? What is the best thing we can do for students? And is it having two meetings where we include parents and include voices of others? Or is it hanging out at a, at a board study session on governments, which is great, I get it. But I always am gonna come back to what if, what, what are our students gonna get from that? And that's, that's, that's my biggest, and I get the bonding thing, Roberta, I get it 100%. It, it's not just the bonding, it's, it's informative. We are informed about our role as a board. Um, we owe that to the students to be informed about our, our role in this whole process too. So, no, I think that those are not just a

082get together for us. We've been, um, had many, many, um, items that came up that we got clarification on and found deeper into what it really is that we're supposed to be doing. And looking at that, it gave us a lot of time to do things like that. So I'm, I'm okay with one meeting a month. I know the other one is open to the public as well. Different people could come. That's where I stand on it. Well, I've kind of had a a wait and see and I'm new too. Um, I think, so this was kind of shocked me, I must admit. But that may be 'cause I'm just not up to speed yet. And I I wanna really do a lot as you have done. We want, as all of us have done,

083we want to make sure we're getting information and we're gonna act on it the best way we can. And I, it was really difficult for me, even though I've been in the school district for a long time and, and did a lot of things. This is a totally different level. And so you just need time to, to look at these things a shorter, uh, I don't know whether the cabinet, when they prepare all this information for us, I don't know how long that takes you. I can only imagine it takes a lot of time. Uh, but then it takes a lot of time for us. I really get the fact that the, uh, prepare thing and and being able to interact with us on more occasions than just one. But I'm kind of had to

084wait, wait and see. I want to see how it goes before I really think I need to really make a decision. And this was a very unusual, um, this is not sometimes we're on and there's always a lot of as well. So that's another factor. Is it because we stopped transferring them around to different sites and including our stakeholder groups? I don't think so. No. You know, I don't, I mean, even, even as a teacher, um, I would come to board meetings and attend minutes. I mean, we had about this many people at normal, I mean attendance. And we had a lot more people here because of the presentations and the, the, um, recognition. So this is not a typical board night and it's a lot longer. And there was a lot tonight. So I

085like, um, Pete's suggestion that we wait and see, give the new lawyer a time to see if this is what you wanna do. Then you can pull back the discussion. I, I mean I'll, I'll support the board 100%. I just worry about the transparency. I don't care if there was one person in the audience. It's the fact that you have it open just in case that one mom, that one dad that guardian, that homeless student walks in and and wants to change something in the district. So I mean, if no one came, I'm glad you're all here. That's great. But if one person came, I would be okay with it too. It's the option of giving people the transparency and allowing them to come. Uh, um, and so, you know, I'm good with whatever you

086we decide to do. I don't have a lot of time to play, you know, uh, governance. I've done it. Really. You've been on the board four years. I'm not, I would like to work on that with everybody else too. Uh, but let's just not forget why we're here. It's for the students and it's to be transparent and I just worry that that takes away for me. But I will, I'm with, you know, whatever the majority wants to do. I don't know where this fits in. I'm sorry. No, I was just gonna say this board has always been very transparent since we've been on it. The meetings mark. That always the transparency part because we've had people at our work stay sessions that wanted to come and talk and be part of that as well too.

087So I'm not leaving out anybody. I'm not saying that because the tendencies great all the time that it isn't important because everyone of you here is important to me as well, and the board. So I'm not saying that at all. And I just wanna have a healthy discussion because I've been sitting on the opposite side for the past two years, not watching much discussion. So let's get back to, you know, discussing And, and you know, we have our emails out there. We can be contacted by any parent anytime, anywhere anyhow. Uh, and I really hope that occurs and, but that's, that's very key. I think if you just get to the board through an email and say, Hey, I, I need, need this or that and the other and we can intercede for our parents,

088et cetera. So that's a good avenue. It may be a better avenue or a parent that just doesn't want to come in and interact with us with the board session. So there are other avenues that we can interact with our parents. I'm also hearing a lot about transparency. Do you need more convenience for parents that having two sessions a month would be more convenient? Because I'm already looking at the calendar and we have a board meeting and a board study in January. So that's two opportunities. We have two opportunities in February, two in April, two in June, two in September. Two in October. So there are, it does seem like we are getting two opportunities to be, um, you know, addressed by the public if there are concerns most of the months of the calendar

089year coming up. But the board study is a totally different thing. So what they're doing is award study is we get together and we just talk about governance or about a budget update or this and that. There, there's no closed session items that, that are going down on that. It's open. I'm not sure it's allowed to have a public comment. Is it? Okay, so we can have the comment, alright, but it's not a meeting, it's not something where folks can come and see the ins and the outs. It's, you know, we're gonna talk about, but that might be more comfortable for some, if there isn't an agenda and we're just working as a board on something for somebody to approach. It might be even more approachable for some parents or staff to can approach us

090about things. You know, I'm willing to do, like I said, however you guys wanna go at it. I'm gonna say what I heard you say that about transparency and convenience. It seems like we are including a lot of, um, times to be addressed by the public. It doesn't seem like we are limiting that in any way, in my opinion by just looking at the calendar. Yeah, no, I mean, you're gonna never see anyone show up to the board study ever. I mean, it, it is highly rare. It is. We know that this is rare, that it's very, very rare. No one's gonna come to a board study. Uh, usually people would come based on a, you know, item for review or anything. These are kind of, I think they put 'em up at that old

091Joshua Tree school in the professional development lounge. And it is just about this in my past. No one came to the board, to the work study thing. Well then maybe that's something we can improve on. Maybe we need to get out to the public more that these are open to them and we would like their input. Maybe that's a good way to solve and, and you're comparing a work study to what you are used to and what we've, um, evolved into. And it's not just like you said, we get together and discuss. We're really digging into a lot of things that help us as board members that help students or every one of us are here for our students. So it's not, what you're saying is an entirely, um, what's really happening. So give it

092time. Caroline, I I'm giving a timely counsel some sessions with us before you decide that it's not as worthy as it word. I wasn't saying it wasn't worthy. What I was saying is I wanted to bring back meetings to meetings a month. And you're talking, you're, you see it from one perspective and I see it from other and that's totally okay. I just wanted to have a discussion. I have sat out here for four years on and off. I, IIII no discussion. That's, and that's all I'm asking for is a discussion. I love Bianca's idea about let's get people to the board studies. Let's maybe increase participate participation in that. Maybe we do more town halls. Like we were kind of talking about some. I just wanna make sure that it doesn't come off. Listen,

093I know what's going on here. Most of the folks that's does these meetings wants to get home. I get it. I'm all for it. I was just asking a simple thing on, on two meetings and I think one time we should rotate, but that's another thing. Take the meetings to the people. But that's another idea for another day. But I like, I like that idea. You, but that's a great idea. Are we kind of overlap? Yeah, I kind of, if we are wanna go back to work out, did we ever get off that? We just move on. Well, it turned into a live week Discussion, Mr. Wood. No, it is regarding the book calendar. That's why. Because, Okay, so if that's the case, if, if I may, uh, we, we have a board meeting the

094day after school starts. I, you know, I I'm just thinking why, um, why not move it for a week of the calendar? I don't know if, if the uh, uh, but it seems like it August 9th and 10th one first day of school was ninth and the second and then we were doing it on the 10th or something like that. Uh, the other way around. Yes. The first day, let's close the eighth and then we still have the board meeting of the night. We usually have the more meetings on the second Tuesday of the month. Right. And I best, however, is your, is your prerogative and is your meetings, so if you decide to move that meeting to the 16th and the board slide to the 30th, that's showing up to you. Am my own

095my only thought on that was I, I think I would like to hear from the, the, uh, district office how start up went, what's going on, what, what really happened. But that's just me. Maybe, maybe you're used to doing that, uh, and, and having a board meeting right after the start up and, and you go on with it, it seems like it might give the staff a little bit more information that the public have start, went, all those kind things. Okay. With that being said in August, we could, we also could have done that. I think that's a great point. We, we would like to push it to the 19th of the 26th. That would get as fast. The technic count is every okay. With the 19th that I like That. I like that Idea.

096Right. It would be a seven day, You want the 10 day count? I, I think seven day. You're probably good to go through my past recollection. You probably know what you do that We have. Yeah, I know. But you got a good idea. But, and if a 10 day account count impacts combos impacts the staff. Yeah. I was hoping we should push it back to the 26th. Honestly, I think we should have that full 10 day count and kind of get an idea. 'cause I know the, and the year can be very, very crazy and, um, we wanna be able to support our staff in the best way and have data by then. Are you guys good? 26th. The 26th works. It still gives us two weeks in between that and the next meeting. That's

097Fine. Okay. So we'll amend the August meeting to the 26th. Okay? Yes. Yes. First, Thank you please for taking over my possession For the thanks for Okay. To, uh, as amended the 2025 board meeting. Commer, may I get a motion? All chamber zero. Thank you. We also have a vote on the first interim financial report. The board of education is requested to certify that the MUSD can be its financial obligations for the current fiscal year 2024 and 2025. And sub subsequent two fiscal years as outlined in the first interim report. Certify that that MUSD can be his financial obligations for the current fiscal year. And uh, it repeated, sorry, I'm reading directly. Um, may I get a motion on the first interim financial report? Do we, uh, second comment now Second, Second, second. So something

098second Discussion. The, uh, information we received from our accountants, were they blessing this, That report is done by our, our our district accountants, our district led by faith con go petition. Think he's talking about No, they don't. They audit us once a year. You'll be, yeah, so I, they'll they'll audit. I mean they come all year long, but they audit, um, at the end of the school year. Okay, so that was my question. They didn't audit this. No. Right. Okay. But they will audit us at the end of the year for all to make sure that our financial reports are stated accurate. And they don't typically audit interims. No, they don't. Yeah. And they're gonna come for last year's audit in January. So you can see. Okay. And I get a motion to accept the

099first interim financial report. Oh, I'm sorry. Uh, all in favor Aye To zero as for review. Is is do we pay comments on now or do we wait for it to We Until, so we're just reading it to read it and then I would you want us to until the, to fix it when it's All started. So, so it does have, for those new, uh, board members, it does have the first week, uh, which in this case we have some board policies of the first week. And then the second week are the rest of the board policies. And now we did discuss whether we have only two weeds and then the adoption. But due to the number of board policies, uh, we, uh, we allowed three times to read the, uh, the board policies and

100then adopt them. And then the third time, that's when they open for discussion with these four adoption. Okay. Got it. Thank you. Thank you. Informational items, cash receipts by the transfer transaction report, quarterly investment report and the 2023 Williams annual report. Next up, future agenda items. Well, we don't You would like to, to discuss some items? Carol, you have an item? I, I do Only because of, uh, the, the conference we went to. I think I would like to see something on, uh, ai, maybe the AI policy where we are with, with, um, with, with all of that. Yeah, like a maybe, I don't know if that's a policy. It's like a policy coming forward or it is working on it. Okay. So I would, I would like to see something on ai. Um, I

101would like to ask if, is there any, um, sheets that HR would do on how many positions are open, what we're looking for? Do you do any data reports on We, We have a work study that for HR is gonna be in February and um, helps you handle that. Would you like us to request information or go to Dr. Vargas to request, because I had some items also that I wanted. What's easiest? If you have a specific, if you have a specific questions, you can send it to me and then we'll, we'll proceed to those such as that request. We'll include that. Would would a monthly update go on. Maybe something that tells us this is how many teachers we need. Are we doing any, I got the, you know, I got some update and

102it was just a bunch of writing about policies. I, I mean I'm reading the policy, I don't need some long paper to break down whatever that was. Um, but where are we with hr? HR Traditionally we've usually done staffing, um, updates about three times a week, a year, once been presentation and the other have been through like a Friday letter. But we do have use more. So if you're requesting that, I can gather now for the Friday letter of Monday and then we can formal presentation. I would just like to kind with that. Um, And then a future agenda items, where are we with maybe next year doing more trainings with our professional development, all of that. That would maybe that's in March though. And, and actually, so you are referring to trainings and PD

103pertaining to the board or the district? So When we were at the school board conference, we had seen that there would be more opportunities for school board members to go and legislate. And that's kind of, that used to be one of my favorite things is go up to and legislate and work on that. And the board seemed kind of keen on us working together more with our elected officials to kind of, I don't know, I was talked, how About that? I suggest, I mean that could be, if I may suggest that could be one of the agenda items for the, uh, governance session that we have in general To discuss that. Okay. Okay. That's all I have. Um, I think maybe we could look at staff housing possibility. Please start the discussion on that. Okay.

104I'd like to see that. Great. Thank you Bianca. Um, I'd like to start a discussion about, um, our hiring for arts positions, especially, um, music and theater arts since we are severely lacking those in our schools currently. And what's being done to, um, help that fill those positions? Can we add that to the work study for hr? Okay, we'll put that as part. Okay, thank you. Next up board and district calendar semester ends December 20th, Friday sure's a lot of excited people out there. Winter break the 23rd of December through January 3rd, 2025. Next regular board meeting will be January 14th, 2025 and our next board meeting will be on January 21st, 2025, 1:00 PM at the JT Professional Development Center. Last but not least, the S-B-C-S-B-A annual meeting is February 3rd, 2025 at the

105Dorothy Ingram Learning Center in in San Bernardino. Thank you. We'll leave, we'll um, start off with board comments. Let's start with one of our new folks. How about Pete? Okay, well first off, I'd like to, to express a lot of appreciation for the board up here. And I'm sorry, Bianca, you weren't able to go to that conference, but, uh, it was an extremely intensive I thought conference. I learned a lot and I'm not sure I really remember what I learned, but we've, we've discussed some things that, that we're gonna get a little more intensive on in our, uh, discussion meetings. And they were all part of the ideas that I agreed to. Also, uh, that art signed thing down in, uh, freedom Plaza 29 Palms was just outstanding. Really, really cool. I can't say enough

106about it. Um, I, I guess that's probably enough to say. Thank you very much for coming. Thank you Pete Carley. First before I start, my comment, the board study session, January 21st at 1:00 PM can we change that? I am kind of a sole provider for my family, uh, and 1:00 PM is extremely, extremely hard to make, again, back to the, and extremely hard for the parents that want to come and learn about governance. What time is Marfa favorable for you? You know, four 30 was tough, but I could pull it off of maybe four or, I mean five, I, I don't, I know it gets dark out on the roads, but 1:00 PM is extremely Hard for me. The rest of the board. Are you good with a four o'clock start versus one would

107that meeting? That works. Okay. You good? Thank you. Okay, we'll amend that to you 4:00 PM Alright. Um, alright. My turn. Oh, it's so good to be back. I had a wonderful time teaching second grade. I had the greatest class that I will ever see in my entire life and it was amazing. Um, and I did a lot of subbing, so I got to work with a lot of students still in between. And that was a, that was a blessing too. It was really fun. I became like the favorite sub, uh, the conference that we all went to. That was so great. It was, it was really great because four years ago I was on one board and now I'm on a new one and we're all vibing and, and it was just, it was

108really, really great. Dr. Barges like next year, well first we gotta get him to stop ringing that bell, but he was loving that thing. But, uh, next year, Dr. Var and, and I, the team, we want the golden, which shows that you can have.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.