001to this meeting of the governing board of the seoa Union High School District um so I called this meeting to order at 4: p.m. uh and then we'll take public comment on closed session agenda items okay with that um we'll recess to close session good evening and welcome back to our meeting of the governing board of the SEO Union High School District um we'll start with item three which is our public protocol um members of the public who wish to provide or remotely provide comment during the meeting can use the raise hand feature on Zoom during their agenda item speakers must raise their hand during agenda item 8.1 the public comment portion of the meeting in order to comment on topics that are not included on the approved agenda and to speak about an item
002on the agenda in person please fill out a speaker card indicate the agenda item and hand the card to Laura at the dis um when the requested agenda item comes before the board the speaker will be called forward um okay next we have item or 3 point or four which is the roll call trusty Chris here trusty Thompson here truste gin here vice president coup here president Nori here acquirement present great um next is item number five which is approval of the agenda so can I get a motion to approve the agenda so moved can I get a second seconded all in favor I I no that motion carries um next is um report out of closed session um the board does not have we do not have anything to report out of closed session
003um and then now is item number seven special recognition so I'll turn it over to superintendent leech thank you so tonight we are recognizing the East pal Alto Academy Pride club and neighborhood environmental advocacy and Technology also known as meet Garden Care Club I want to welcome epa's interim principal uh Veronica Miranda pink Pinkley to the podium to share more details about these outstanding club members and their advisors good evening I'm honored to recognize our first and newest Club neat has revitalized the garden at epaa growing carrots brussels sprouts strawberries and leafy greens members have collected censor data about Gardens to develop data literacy skills um JoJo Flores and Benji presented at a keyote talk at the 2024 Sam County climate Summit on youth involvement and Melanie Kimberly Jojo and Allen presented to community members
004and organizations to get feedback on the garden we are excited to have this new club on campus their advisers are Benji Maria and hongi our student leaders are JoJo Flores Daphne kidos Kimberly Delgado Natalie Chavez Alan sandal and Melanie Melendez do we have them come up here or at the end okay so if you can come on up our neat Club come on up [Applause] yeah so as as you're getting those we'll continue with our pride club that promotes awareness of the lgbtq plus community and history through daily announcements to honor various lgbtq plus awareness days weeks and months lesana and Inc participated in the April 2024 San Francisco Gman choir performance and celebration to support an inclusive and welcoming School Community by presenting this choir to the entire school on March 4th members will
005attend the youth advocacy social Summit being held at the San matelo County Office of of Education a huge thank you to our advisers Phillip Wong Mo Hayes and our student leaders lesana Ingram and Inc DW come on up [Applause] please for e thank you um next we have item 8.1 which is public comment um the board does not act upon any matter that has not been agendized except under very limited circumstances as permitted by law it is the policy of the board to refer matters raised in this forum to staff for investigation and or action where appropriate board policy ordinarily limits the time to be devoted to any single agenda topic to 10 minutes and individual speakers are ordinarily limited to 3 minutes if the board decides to expand the amount of time to be
006allocated to a particular agenda item because many speakers wish to address that item the board May reduce the time allocated to individual speakers to two minutes or to one minute as appropriate in order to permit more speakers to comment the board will announce the amount of time to be allocated to each speaker before public comment on each particular agenda item we ask all speakers to keep within the time limit so this is public comment on items that are not on the agenda um well have one in person and I see one hand up on Zoom so two okay so um last call but if so we can give them three minutes each okay we can start with in person all right we have Dan maleri good evening board um first of all congratulations to the
007two new board members I don't know which of you actually are um I've seen all your faces but um congratulations I hope that you two have come in are going to correct the mistakes that have been happening with the other three I'm to start with you Mr Nory you still owe Shay Codwell an apology and just so you understand on the record so the Public's up to speed you defame that little African-American kid and so we're for sure are coming to name you so you board members have a little problem you guys got two doors the two new ones don't put yourselves in a bad position and get yourself into a mess that is not going to lead you to anywhere but disaster and drag down your names and put yourself in liability this ball
008game's over you got multiple lawsuits and your close system that you told these people out here does not exist it does exist you've got at least three more law suits one of which is my client my brother Mike molier who's going to sue you miss leech and you Mr Beal you guys have targeted him you targeted OFA you target multiple people a federal judge at you guys up to speed since you didn't do it you guys with your attorneys that you spent over now three million are doing a sance it's called to try to separate the district from the police department that's going to fail you guys are ready I will let you know in March 3rd look for that in the newspaper in March you'll be served with another lawsuit for Mike molier we're
009waiting for office then that'll hit the news you'll be named leech you'll be named deal so you board members you started to do correc thing because it's come to our attention I get reports every single day of what you guys are doing you guys are doing some great things you're finally do you are dealing with some special educational issues you're making changes you're you're realizing you can't alter records you can't get because you're going to get caught eventually that's what happens with corruption but you board members cannot allow federal crimes to be occurring your next step it's my understanding leeches I mean field leaving supposedly for for transportation yeah right you're leaving because he caused a huge big of your problem your next best move fire leech we're going to go to the judge and
010we're going to ask for certain things now you guys can keep spending money but like John bur just put out in his document we just this isn't about money for us this is about making sure people's rights are protected make sure you guys don't hurt people so please you two board members don't fall into this trap avoid it please we beg you I got 20 second left hurry up and interview my brother Miss leech because we would love to keep telling the story we've complained and we already know you're dirty we already know you guys are committed it's in the police report we got filmed but there's nothing for us that we're afraid of so please board don't fall into that trap avoid it thank you next Jeremy aray Jeremy are you there yes I'm
011here hello yeah we can hear you go ahead for quite some time the board has read in emails or listened to employees say that they have needed to be hospitalized that they were forced into therapy that they have suffered mental and physical effects during their time and that they have become suicidal because of the Hostile retaliatory environment you've allowed to persist you've heard students say that their rights were violated that they have seen their classmates harmed that they're losing trusted mentors services and educational opportunities you've seen people cry break down in front of you and struggle to put into words what they've endured and yet you continue to pretend that you can't do a thing about it that is negligence gaslighting and manipulation you do have the power to communicate and to act you do
012have the ability to completely change your board meeting format and policy to something more Innovative you have the ability to create major forms and Outlets where people can actually share their stories and you have the power to swiftly remove people who are causing major harms or allowing them to exist and ruin the culture instead just like the last board meeting you hide behind procedural excuses in silence in a way that insults people's intelligence we know our rights Crystal instead of being compelled to completely change this culture around and stop the facade you've allowed and successfully facilitated a culture where students and Staff feel like it's useless to stand up for themselves anymore they feel like they won't be heard across all of the schools in this District over the years where you've been in charge
013alongside Todd Beal and others in the click hundreds of people have suffered silently and that is not an exaggeration fortunately the truth does not just disappear because it's ignored with public records requests and documentation a clear picture will emerge of how this district has reacted or failed to respond to serious issues over time as I've told you before resources are being created to provide information to the community that will rewrite the history of this District to be more accurate and it will not look good when everything is put together under Crystal leech and Todd be's tenure people in this District have learned not to trust HR or expect validation when they raise concerns about harm or retaliation just for doing their jobs there have been numerous complaints about how HR processes are mishandled under Todd
014Beal through email public comment and in the media with employees describing policies being misused weaponized applied inconsistently whistleblowers left being left unprotected and even being denied access to critical evidence in their email and yet instead of investigating these serious issues by genuinely following up with those who have come forward and making sure that no matter what they get a resolution the only people who have appeared to suffer consequences are those who have stood up for what's right thank you that concludes public comments on non- agendized items all right thank you Laura um next we have item number nine which is student trustee comments hello my name is Caitlyn and presenting with me is May we're both sa representatives of kont high school and today we're here to share some updates regarding our school sites and
015a couple others um on a positive note we really like the involvement in participation in clubs at our school many clubs like competitive speech and debate Robotics and Mark trial are doing amazing things and winning many competitions for example our speech and debate team um went to Stanford Invitational last weekend and brought home a lot of awards and several students in our Deca chapter also competed in District and brought home Awards and they're also going to compete in two weeks um clubs are also finding ways to get students involved in outside programs like pets in need the Ronald McDonald Foundation various Key Club related activities saf Etc which shows that students are really committed to the school and are comfortable and feel safe to start clubs many students also want to take on leadership roles
016and join our school's Associated student body which shows that they feel belong to the school so we think that's really great that this culture is being promoted moving on to the negatives um some comments were brought up from previous SA meetings um regarding the water fountain sanitation issue um this is the main reason why I joined the student trustees but um I believe that it can be a safety hazard to students and it also deters students from drinking water during the day I know I personally don't drink any water and I don't leave class at all to um get water because when I pass by I can see that there's dirt on the water fountains there's hair and generally it just doesn't taste good um I see several students carrying multiple water plastic water bottles
017in their backpacks but they don't refill them even though they could um and so this situation generally leads to littering at the school um people were talking about how there's trash can everywhere but if you look inside there's mix trash there's recyclables and compost Al together um and Raquel is going to touch more on this hi I'm Rael I go to Woodside and I've seen similar things with um uh water fountains and trash cans but um in our bathrooms and a lot of other school's bathrooms it's been very dirty and for Woodside the trash cans for like anything inside of the stall have been closed so they haven't been able to like throw away their feminine products and in general it's just really dirty and not a good environment to actually be clean for using
018the bathroom so thank you thank you so much for your comments um next we have item number 10 comments from the seoa district Teachers Association and American Federation of state county and Municipal Employees good evening um we are going into the midwinter break having done some good work with our counseling committees um having a draft of um evaluation rubric language to address the new California standards for the teaching profession that will come online next year and um having done a good check-in about um the changes the district office has implemented to address um the inordinate number of initial assessments for special education that our psychologists and case managers have been dealing with since we returned um to inperson learning um and I would call your attention that on your consent um agenda that you're going
019to vote on in just a moment are two contracts one that includes uh contracted psychi psychologist another that is Contracting for psychological assessments what this means is that the psychologists that we employ in the district District are not capable of doing the work that is required to serve the students in our district there is too much work for them the recognition comes through these peac mail um uh contracts when we have to contract out rather than um in a systematic attempt to at the beginning of the year staff at a livable ratio and this does not affect just our psychologists we see the psychologists represented here but we have four program Specialists for the district we have transition Specialists for the district each of these individuals ends up working with all of these cases every
020time there's an initial assessment that has to have an IEP meeting a program specialist has to be there we have not increased the number of program Specialists to keep up with this they are burning out our transition Specialists are burning out we need to really look at how we are creating systems that can that can address the problem and we need to look at establishing ratios so that we can hire and get the best people inhouse doing the work for our students so that we don't have to continue to peace mail Higher by contract um employees outside of the bargaining unit thank you thank you um is I I don't think there's anyone from okay okay next is item number 11 Board of Trustees correspondents yes I do have a correspondence and because this is
021regarding our board and an appreciation Proclamation for our board I thought it would be odd to have President Nori read his own appreciation Proclamation so I thought that I would highlight it um for you all so we so you all received a Board of Trustees appreciation Proclamation from Avid and so Avid believes that re recognizes the importance of the educational leadership and governance of you all at the local level directly affecting the development of College and Career Readiness for all students um they also acknowledge your vital role that you play in the development of student agency uh rigorous academic preparedness and opportunity to uh opportunity knowledge for all students they also appreciate the partnership um of you and fostering a culture of academic achievement and personal growth um in conjunction with Schoolboard members you are
022committed to continuous Improvement of our education system to better prepare every child for challenges of their future so they commend you for your efforts in shaping our educational system and their unwavering commitment to developing student agency they want to acknowledge your invaluable contributions in transforming our students into leaders of tomorrow so thank you all thank [Applause] you okay next is item number 12 approval of the consent agenda board action to approve the following items is taken simultaneously with one motion which is not debatable and requires a unanimous roll call vote for passage the actions indicated on each item is deemed to have been considered in full and action taken as worded therein only members of the board and the superintendent May remove items from the consent agenda members of the public May provide comment at
023the start of the consent agenda item which may convince a board member or the superintendent to remove an item for further disc discussion and the motion is to wave the reading of the consent agenda accept the reports adopt the resolutions and approve other items so do we have any public comment on the consent agenda I have none okay seeing none on Zoom um do any board members or superintendent wish to pull any items no if not um could I get a motion to approve the consent agenda so moved second a roll call student truste Lynn yes yes truste Figo yes student chusty bedos yes chusty Cruz yes chuste Thompson yes chusty gin yes vice president coup yes president Nory yes motion pass 5- Z great um okay now now we're on to our informational item
024so item 13.1 presentation on construction delivery methods and I think I'll turn it over to assistant superintendent G good evening so tonight we have D sake from Dan danis wber and Kelly who will present on the various um construction delivery methods that our district maybe may use for our measure W project hi good evening I'm here to talk about construction conts tonight very exciting topic I know I am very excited to talk about it I might talk a little quickly tell me if I if I am because I get um this is what I do every day all day so um I'm here to talk about three different project delivery methods let's see if it Ms forth okay so the road map for today is um we're going to talk about design bid build first
025this the traditional method we're also going to talk about lease lease bath and design build okay and generally what we're looking for is which deliver delivery system fits best um there's no one size fits-all sort of thing depending on your project you may want to use a different kind of project delivery method they all have their strengths and weaknesses and it's just a matter of considering your project and thinking about what you would like to do with your project um things that you should consider in doing project delivery is um to assess the district resources um design changes or conflicts construction and coordination issues materials and schedule impacts and potential delays so um the first type of project delivery method I'm talking about is the traditional design bid build model so what happens in this
026model is that an architect will design your project they'll bring it through DSA which is division estate architect they are your building department once DSA approves your plans and specifications it goes out to bid um there will be one general contractor and the general contractor will give you a lump sum um bid and then all other subcontractors come under them the um the arrows indicate the contractual relationships between people um you knowe that there's no contractual relationship between the architect and the general contractor and we can also have a construction manager that helps um act as the owners the district's agent you notice they don't have any contract relationship with either the general contractor or the architect and that the district doesn't have a contractual relationship with any of the subcontractors so for this type
027of um delivery method like I said before you can enter into the Construction contract before DSA approves the plans and specifications um so that means there's no early Builder involvement so sometimes when the Contra uh the designers are designing the plans if they have input from the contractor there's ways that they could either um eliminate an error that they might have missed or um use different types of products or um materials that could uh better the price but we don't get that information until after the contractor com comes in um for this uh project delivery method it's based on price only so the assumption is that it doesn't matter who builds it for you you're going to get the same product you just get it at different prices now I don't know that that's really
028this um a realistic assumption but that is what this is based on um and that's why we use the term that the contracts are awarded to the lowest responsive responsible bidder so that means that um sometimes if a bid is missing a portion of it so you ask them for for example a bid Bond or security for their contract price if it's missing it and they were the lowest price they're still not considered because their bid wasn't complete okay and um something of this project delivery method is it's kind of rigid so bidders cannot change any of the terms of the agreement it's it's what it is so whatever the project plans and specifications are that's what we're working off of it and for us sort of um we can't make any changes either so
029it's kind of rigid so that means that this project delivery method could end up with more change orders because everything that's in the contract up front is that's that's our base Point okay this is the most common delivery method so you won't get a lot of people challenging the procurement like you go through it and whoever is the lowest price wins the contract so there's not a lot of um about whether or not the way that the contractor was selected is proper um the risk is primarily with the contractor after bidding because they have a lumpsum price that they have to keep within unless the district adds additional things to the pro um to the project or something is discovered that we didn't see before like underground the risk of the design errors is with
030the district because if we go back up here to the top the district is on a team with the architect engineer so if there's any um error in the district I mean in the plans then the district is uh responsible to the contractor to pay any difference so that's where another way where um change orders can come out um and then we have prequalification and pre-qualification is a way to try and see that we have um more equal contractors in in the quality of the contractors but it's it doesn't it's not a panace it doesn't it's not a solve all situ ation it's only required for contracts over a million dollars where using state general funds or state bond funds um you can do it if it's less than that um and otherwise you don't
031need to do pre-qualification and this type of pre-qualification that I'm talking about we call it mandatory it's not just the bidder but any first tier mechanical electrical Plumbing subcontractor would also be pre-qualified and then this project delivery method is best used for for um a tough economic client small projects simple projects things that are wrote that again it's sort of like um machine you know it's it's classrooms that you do all the time things that are that require a lot of different um thoughts to it like maybe a Performing Arts Theater may not be the kind of project you want to use design B build for okay before I go on to Le these back any questions okay so the next um project project delivery method I'm talking about is the lease leaseback project delivery
032method if you note it's very similar to traditional designed to build where the architect and the engineer um they're they're in a relationship with the district and if there's any problems with the plans and specifications um the district is responsible to the contractor um we call the contractor in at leas backc either a lease leas back entity or developer because the contract vehicle we're using is called a lease and it's a genuine lease that we go into um but the leas Le back entity or developer they have subcontractors the same way that a traditional design B build does okay um when we say lease lease back I always feel compelled to explain what we mean by that so you start out by leasing this unimproved site to a developer and they come in and they
033build tenant improvements onto the site and then they lease the site back to you it's because the origination of this project delivery method was for districts who didn't have the money upfront to pay for their construction projects and therefore the people who were building it helped them Finance it now today we have bonds so we don't really have that in the same way but then there is a portion of the project that's financed it's not financed 100% anymore through the developer and then um I guess my last point is that financing is not require I mean re back it doesn't invalidate the contract but there's this thing called validation action where you can't um challenge the contract after 60 days with if there's no objection filed to it um that type of quick validation occurs
034if you have financing your relas lease back contract therefore when we work with the district we always make sure there is financing in it um okay one other thing before I move on some of you may have heard about this case called um Davis versus frone Unified School District it's been 10 years since it's been around I I can't believe that it's been 10 years like it seems as though it just happened a while ago but what happened in is that um the leas leas back statute used to allow that you don't have to bid you could just enter into contract with anybody you want as long as you have um you lease it to the to the developer for a dollar they give it to you back you can use the same contractor over
035and over again and there were a lot of lawsuits that people said that that wasn't right and um most of them found that no you don't have to bid it except for Davis versus first un Unified School District and we went into a series of things where um there's a lot of back and forth on it but um at the end of the day what happened as a result of it is they ISS they amended the the um the leas eback statute so it's no longer you just pay them a dollar and they come out and you choose whoever you want now you have to do an RFP you have to advertise it um the subcontractor bids are are advertised as well so there's a lot more structure to the procurement process than there used
036to be before and I have to say that since the statute's been changed there's a lot less litigation over it when you read articles that say like hey the Supreme Court said that um Le these back is illegal that is not correct what the last Supreme Court decision all it said was that if you don't have financing in your contract it doesn't validate it doesn't mean that it's not valid it means that the contract doesn't validate under the validation statute contract still fine okay elements of a lease lease back so the developer is responsible for the delivery of the project and the archit tech is responsible for the design of the project like we said before there are two different teams on that we're allowed now to enter into a contract before DSA approves the
037plans um before this we used to have a preliminary Services agreement and what it happened is that people were saying that that was a conflict of interest now when we enter into the agreement we can enter into before DSA approves the plans so there's no conflict because there's just one contract whoever does the preconstruction constructability value engineering they don't have any say in the next contract because there's no next contract um so that means that when you enter into this contract you only enter into it usually with the pre-construction cost only so preconstruction is doing the constructibility review um the value engineering and bidding of the general maximum price guaranteed maximum price I'm sorry and um that's usually determin that is determined after subcontractor bidding and it can be done around or after DSA approves
038the plant remember before I told you that in design bid bill there's no early contractor involvement in this case there is like to pay them a fee to go and come in and look to see if there could be any change orders so therefore when we're negotiating the guaranteed maximum price we're able to get some of those cost out because um early because if you do it when it's still competitive you get a better price than doing it in a change order when there's no competition um what it what there is though for leas leback is there a skilled and trained Workforce requirements unless your district has entered into project labor agreement which you haven't but the Skilling chain Workforce agreement I mean for I'm sorry the skill and Workforce requirements I'm trying to summarize
039it because it's a little um it's a little complex but for every occupation that has um that has a uh competitive bargaining agreement you have to um award uh sorry apprentices and journey persons have to be used on the project um for the journey persons there's two ways that you can get your license as a journey person you can either um attend an apprenticeship program and graduate from it or you can get it based on your past experience what the skill machain Workforce requirements are is they put on certain types of occupations 60% of your Workforce has to be graduated from a from a um from an apprentice program as opposed to or some of them are 30 and for teamers is zero but um in order to do that I mean for some some
040of the occupations They Don't Really always have the number of people to do that so they also have the option of doing it by number of hours it's not just people um selection for lease lease back is different because it's not just based on um price only unless you wanted to you can still do little bid on a um Le leas back but people don't do that because you have the opportunity to B to pick based on um qualifications as well you can put together the um the different uh criteria that you want to have and it could be like how long they've worked together the technical expertise um sometimes you have it their safety record um what they want in their contract those sorts of things those are all things that can go into
041your um selection process and then at the end of the day you have what's called a best value and that's how they're selected based on best value um like I said before an a request for proposals is required a request for qualifications is optional what we propose to do in our documents is we have the request for qualifications and proposals together so there's not a two set process it's just a one set process um and then another thing that is I remember I told you for traditional um design B build we can't mess with the contracts or the plans but in this one we have to negotiate it so there is some time lead in time for that also to like when you award a lease lease back contract I think most people think that
042oh we awarded the contract we're going to see construction like in a couple of you know within a month but that doesn't occur with lease lease back because they have to finish the design and they have to bid it out first you're looking at anywhere from a month or three months generally um it depends also too on how long it takes to get the plans back from DSA and how soon you bring in the contractor so I'm sorry and I did jump ahead when I talked about the legal challenges but this is the slide that talks about the legal challenges regarding um validation and including things that weren't required under the statute like financing that it's the genuine lease and conflicts of interestes um I think that since Davis versus Fresno people have come to
043uh to deal with these issues and know how to take care of it so that it's no longer a problem and like I said since they change the statute very few people have tried to challenge selection to lease lease back okay so um again when we talk about risk once the uh guaranteed maximum price the the risk is generally with the leas leas back entity unless there's qualification for change orders with leas Le back there's supposed to be less chance of having change orders but I'm not going to say there's no change orders because there's still the opportunity for um if you're digging in the ground you find something you didn't expect like a storage tank underground storage tank or um something that you didn't expect or um you dig you open the wall and
044all of a sudden there's things that you didn't think were going to be there um so there you could have a change order but probably not as much and you certainly you can go back to the person who did the preconstruction services and say Hey you know you had a chance to look at all of this and do a preconstruction constructibility review why are you asking for changer now um the relationship with the district and the contractor is a little different for that it's more of a partnering relationship than an adversarial relationship but I got to say going into the contract your price may be a little higher because you found a lot of those change orders up front um let's see the dis the risk for design errors is still with the district like
045I said the architect is still on the owner's team versus the contractor and um um and one of I mean I guess you could call it a con but there's financing leas requirements following the completion of the construction so when you're done with the construction you may still be paying off the contract depending on what you've um negotiated so uh lease leaseback is best used in a healthy economic climate complex projects elaborate design projects where the Builder or Builder input is beneficial um some people will say you have more control over the project schedule because if you get out some of the potential change order things before um DSA is signed off and the whole thing you don't have to wait for DSA if something was found later on and in that way also too
046you cut down and maybe delays in that in that matter and maybe cost um when people compare um traditional design bid build and leas these back um like I said initially the cost for traditional design bid build will be lower but some people are um concerned about having um orders and claims that come at the end and if you end up in litigation are the costs really that different there's been a lot of studies by a lot of different uh universities to say whether whether or not leas lease back would be or would not be more expensive one way or another depending on what school you look at the results are different one says it's more expensive one says it's less expensive um it's just I think for some people a big draw is being
047able to choose your contractor not based on price only okay um design build is our last project delivery method that we're talking about today so um I think if you notice here in the middle the design build entity team is the designer and the Builder so instead of having um the risk be with the district because the plans have problems in this delivery method it's it's not separate but I mean if there's a problem with the design it's with a one there's a One-Stop shop for responsibility if you notice I have a extra um arrow for bridging or criteria architect um basically when we're doing the RFP we want to have some kind of performance specifications about what we're looking for and in order to do that if we're going to do performance specifications we
048need to have a licensed professional do it they're usually referred to as a bridging or criteria architect bridging architect is um create bridging documents which are usually a little far further along in the process criteria Architects um create criteria documents and um I've heard it described as sort of something on the back of a cocktail napkin it's not quite that um rough but criteria documents are are a little they're definitely not as polished as bridging documents are you can still have a construction manager to help you with the design build project process so the design build process it's it's um kind of more complex is really not a good process if you're just trying to do it for the first time especially without professional help on it um the district will need to make decisions
049faster because it's sort of a turnkey thing you tell them I want 10 classrooms and it has to meet the um DSA specifications and they come to you um they design it and they build it for the price that they tell you and that's supposed to be how it's supposed to work they use all their Ingenuity um and experience in order to bring you a process a project that does not involve you that much however I don't know that school districts like to not be involved in their projects so we do tend to um put more conditions and we do have them check in with us more than like the traditional design built um so let's see I I talked about the first bullet point and then a lot of the constru like leely spat
050um we're allowed to enter into the Construction contract before DSA approves the pans the specifications so again we're not approving a contract with a whole price unless you have a notic seed number um sometimes you have a stipulated sum and that could be that but for some types of design build you enter with a design cost only and the markups for insurance and bonds and stuff but other than that you're waiting for the contractor subcontractor's prices in order to create a guaranteed maximum price um let's see but because they're a team together you have early Builder involvement and it could help mitigate change orders by having the contractor involved early um there's a little note here see okay so last year as of January 1st 2023 um the legislature adopted something called alternate um design
051build so we had design build as it was before you had a minimum $1 million threshold your project has to be at least a million dollar and you uh um you'd have to have skill nutrition Workforce but other than that there wasn't a lot of other um uh what's restrictions on it because you're giving you're giving um space to your design Builder to work these these things out um but last year they started something called Progressive well it's based on the Progressive design build model where you enter into it with design only you create your price through open book um and then once you create your uh your first GMP your um guaranteed maximum price then there is actually a change order limit of 10% uh of the GMP so that's something I really I
052didn't discuss on the change orders for traditional design build there is a limitation on the change orders it's not to say that you can have change orders more than that but if you have change orders more than 10% you have to bid it okay I talked about that skild anding Workforce okay selection for design build um what you do it's a two-step process it's not like you get to make your choice about it it is a two-step process you do an RFQ to short list um potential design buil entities and you'd have at least three and you would do an RFQ uh P which is a request or proposal and you could have a design competition and then you negotiate the contractor before the the contract before the award um I talked to you about
053okay so the bridging architect that I talked about earlier they cannot be and any of the design build teams so you have two contracts where you have a design I mean a bridging architect contract but they can't be part of any of the design teams that's by Statute um it's by Statute but you also need to have a board policy that says that and um I talked with you about TurnKey projects before and what they're supposed to be so um as I said the risk for design and construction is with the design build entity for design build but you have to pick you have to decide early that you're going to use design build because um you're going to have a bridging architect and they can only go so far your architect of record for
054the project wants to get in and put their stamp on the project so you can't wait too long to decide because or your architect's going to go pretty far ahead um there's also a risk in using this if the design being the design built team members don't have a good relationship like if they're fighting with each other um you try to you try to Suess that out during the selection process to ask them how many projects they've done together hopefully these projects are successful and you'd have that information um so for traditional type of design build where it's a stipulated some the risk for the prices with the design build entity um the risk for the price is mitigated by setting a guaranteed maximum price after selection where the contractor gets more idea of what
055the cost can be instead of just off of a criteria documents or bridging documents so I mean people I know that there are people who prefer um alternate alternative for that reason um and I did say that the minimum threshold for alternative is $5 million but I don't know any building you can build for less than five Bill $5 million so you know it's not really a big um hurdle to have to do like I said there is a steep learning curve to using design build um I think when you start out it's good to start out with a consultant to help you through it the first time and have you know to be able to give that experience to staff too so it's well suited for specialty projects we use it for pools Performing
056Arts Theaters that sort of stuff um it's best suited used in healthy economic climate complex projects projects that need a quick start or projects where design and scope is not rigid um you know I mean frankly school districts tend to like to use these lease back more than design build it has been especially because of the Davis versus fral case where um Le back was questioned um it became more popular but it I do far more leas leback projects than I do design build projects um but you know honestly I do all of them because they fit I mean there's different fits for different projects so any questions I'm sorry again I went really quickly also ask I assume since you talked about all four that we may with our bond funds be looking at
057some of each of these in the coming years yes and um you know and luckily for school districts I mean they're all open to the district it doesn't matter like if you're using State bond funds either because for community colleges is a little different I don't want to go into it that much but design build you can always use State monies for um twinity colleges but there's no such restrictions for school districts thank you are there any other board questions if not um I forgot to take public comment on this item so are there any public comments requesting to speak about item 13.1 not for this item now okay thank you once again for the presentation um next is item 13.2 presentation on the facilities master plan and measure W projects are there any public
058comment uh I just saw one hand go up so I'm not sure if it was for the last one I for this one but so we have one on zoom and any in person no okay so turn it over to three minutes on Zoom okay on Zoom first is Laura hi good evening board members uh my name is Laura Nunes and I've been a teacher at East paot Academy for over 12 years I am also East PA out Academy's athletic director a district coach working with teachers across School sites and an elected um Ravenswood School Board member and longtime East paa resident I grew up here uh for years epaa staff and admin have been asking for additional classroom space and we've received nothing uh teachers are sharing classrooms and have no dedicated prep spaces
059uh during covid I had nowhere to prep and I had to wear a mask the entire school day because I had to share my class room at all hours um this year I can't I I don't have no other place to prep because again I'm sharing my classroom and our therapists who come in and work with our students have been forced to use our locker rooms like we had to convert our locker rooms to so that they can have their counseling sessions in the presentation that's going to come up you're going to hear about the facilities plan and other schools are receiving hundreds of millions of dollars in projects for new classroom Wings some Stadium lights a new baseball field and epaa request for Portables that are just 1.7 million in the grand scheme of
060things remain remains unmet and part of the last phase of the plan I understand the need for some of the updates but classrooms should be coming first some District projects won't be finished until 2030 and are we expected to wait that long to get a portable um my questions are like how were the items in each phase prioritized who was in those meetings and making these decisions because from where I stand it's clear that epaa was not part of the conversation we serve some of the most vulnerable students in the district and they deserve better Portables are a cost-effective solution that should be prioritized immediately thank you for your time thank you okay um I'll now turn it over to assistance return gone Nayan n do our chief facilities officer will provide an update on
061the measure W or construction uh projects including high level uh summary of the projects the budgets and timelines good evening everyone major major W Bond program was approved in 2022 and the amount was $491 Million and it was it has received an overwhelming 62.99 98% yes vote so that the success began there today I'm going to I'm going to share or an overview of the total program the bond program which is aligned with the master plan which was developed between 2024 and sorry 2021 and uh the the areas which we are going to cover today is uh basically the schedule the budget and the scope uh these are the key elements or components of any prog project or program management because it it develops that control system which we have to be we have have
062to have in place to manage such a big program and the reconcile budgets have been updated from the facilities master plan uh to escalate to a midpoint of construction based on the current master schedule so first the schedule was developed and based on the schedule the mid points were all calculated and then the ex escalation rate of 5% per year was added to it firstly the program schedule schedule the program the the Bor program is uh scheduled in phases because it is very difficult to get all these projects done at one time they won't if you allow that all the projects to be done at one time the resources will not sustain it the site will not be able to accommodate that and there will be a lot of disturbances to the actual activities going
063in every School site so it's impossible so we have to Stager it up in such a way so that it's well scheduled and it's feasible to execute Construction in a timely manner so phase one projects are we have taken in consideration the projects are phased based on the size the scope and also the impact it'll have on the campus in terms of the footprint which it'll occupy in the campus in terms of construction so because the construction it may be a building but the construction area will be much much bigger than the actual building where is the size of the building which will be constructed so so the first one is Roofing at calmont which is the first and foremost it's the easiest one so far out of all the projects because it's non DSA
064and we want to get on to that as soon as possible and it it'll be starting this summer and we have planned for this summer this year next summer 20 2025 and then in 2026 and the major projects for phase ones are kmon new twing the kickoff has been been done for design it's it's at design level at the moment on the programming phase and by the time it gets constructed it'll be in 2029 hopefully earlier because as you heard from D DSA is a dependent variable which you have to depend on because it takes longer at DSA times and it takes shorter at DSA times at DSA so it all depends if it's shorter the the scope will be shrinked and it'll become shorter and we can the the final completion could be much
065earlier so that applies to all these projects and the projects ahead of this slide and the second one is cant swing space Portables the Portables and the T new T Construction are basically one project because we have to relocate the students to uh temporary classrooms while we demo them existing T TV building and then build a new one and man string space Portables that's also part of the man and new classroom building because we have to displace the students or relocate the students to the temporary housing and then manow atan bleaches that has been kicked off it's in design phase it'll be going to DSA this year and we expect that to be completed by the end of this year or early next year the next one is sea Union sea new classroom building we
066have already kicked of the design portion of it it's in design at the moment and uh that is a standalone building so there's not so much of logistics involved it's not there's no demolition taking place it's on a new space so that'll be much quicker probably head of 2028 it should be done or much earlier if DSA approves it earlier outside new classroom building is the same situation as the Carmon new teing building and Men new classroom building it all depends on DSA if the purple portion of the schedule bars you see there if it shrinks the schedule become shorter and then there'll be earlier finish and the same applies to the outside swing space phase two projects are carmount baseball field which will be kicked off this year M Lo weight room building SE
067locer room renovation sea string space for locer room if needed it all depends after the new building analization of the new building Scopes are all done and then outside baseball field will also be kicked off this year as I said earlier Roofing at calmont Menan squ and side will be continuous for the next three years phase three projects are common Terrace building meno EET and beinging renovation sequia main building renovation Woodside deing renovation these are modernization projects and uh there is a lot of work involved in that in terms of getting the sqa done also modernization has requires a lot of due diligence lot of assessment and testing so that no unforeseen uh situations Prevail during construction now to the program budget the program we have the the the columns the master what was in
068the master plan and then what is current base on the midpoint of construction uh it was estimated by a third party so there's a comparison you'll see the column there the difference column is the difference between the master plane and the current or the one we are proposing at the moment uh Carm from 53 went to 57 twing building baseball 10 to 19 manlo aeton de building 56 to 80 and then Stadium at manlo at turn 44 to 4 is remains almost the same of $4,000 difference sequa classroom building 33 to 35 WS side 45 to 53 now rounded up so the difference is shown on the right hand side the next one is a project budget for phase two calmon Terrace building N9 Remains the Same Manon there's a difference of 1 million plus
069mu is squa difference of 830,000 sea locer rooms difference of 55,000 WS side Baseball 5 million there three projects M Ean beinging modernization 4 million to 10 million difference of 5 million sequa main building 5 53 million to 53 remains this difference of 990 sea Stadium lights uh difference of $500 outside deing modernized ation a difference of 2 million 2.7 million then for phase four Adult School renovation uh difference of 3 million Terrace difference of 4.1 EPA 5.6 uh 56,000 Oxford green new Portables 2.3 Redwood retaining wall 1.3 program budget summary phase one two and three the difference is 61,800 infrastructure projects uh the difference is 46,000 46,8 73,000 other campuses 11,894 interum housing no changes escalation allows master plan in the master plan CW presented 142,5 79,000 this was this was very this was
070very well done actually CW did a very good job of the master plan we have this uh they had this contingency 142. 279 which was is all spreaded out when the estimation was done for the midpoint of construction and uh it's now it's all accommodated by project which which is another document which is in the board talk for to review there a lot of details regarding all the project details on that and the program expenses 20 million Remains the Same program contingency went down with by 2 .6 million now current Pro coming up current and coming up projects by site the first and foremost carot High School the program allocation this is a graphic uh exhibition of how much the portion of the budget how is distributed infrastructure new construction solar andp Athletics now the
071schedule for common tving uh design kickoff has been done programming is in progress and bidding will take place in 2026 construction will begin in June 2027 that is during summer break could be in May and uh it will finish by 2029 and if BC approves earlier it'll be earlier car more new baseball field design will be kicked off probably by within the next three or four weeks and then bidding is expected to be in 2026 next year early next year so that construction can take place during summer of 2026 and completed by 2027 uh come on Terrace building uh design will begin in 2026 and then bidding will take place in 2028 construction 2029 completion 2030 Carm Roofing replacement is on will be ongoing phase one this year phase two next year phase three following
072year it is phased in it's it's done in phases because you cannot change all these roofs at one time because there's Summer Schools going on and then there's uh there'll be problem with the uh resources regarding having contractors on site probably the we will not be able to get a contractor we can beat the whole campus at once and then there'll be three campuses which will be done on almost four campuses will be done uh with this roofing project and it has to be done in phases because of the limited resources this is a picture of the kickoff meeting we had at carmont high school and the next one is manal e and high school and this is the distribution of uh Financial Resources for the projects biding again 2024 uh sorry design 2024 already
073kicked off 2025 will be bidding 2026 construction 2026 by the end of 2026 it will be completed M classroom building uh design is ongoing at the moment bidding 2026 construction 2027 completion by June 2029 man Lo weight room uh design 2025 it'll be kicked off within a few months biding will take place on 2027 construction 2027 April close out 2028 it's a simple building so it'll be much a shorter scope uh schedule sorry M Roofing replacement ongoing I mean it'll be in three phases as I said earlier for the carmont high school the same uh schedule applies to these two that's a picture of a k of meeting at Manon the next one one is sequa High School uh this is the financial distribution the same applies here design has been kicked off uh bidding
074has to be taken place in 2026 construction 2027 and then completion by 2028 and that is the reason why the modernization of the admin building for sequa will take place later because we'll have the new building in place and the administration and the counseling departments all can be moved there so allows the building to be empty to be modernized with very few Portables uh Stadium lights we want we we'll get that soon this year and then by June it to should be bid Out Construction this year and closed out by end of December this year or ear January next year local room renovations uh design this year to be kicked off building 2027 construction 2027 completion 2027 we'll try not to have this uh non DSA project so it may be quicker than that u
075m at sequa design 2026 bid 2027 construction 2028 close out 2020 main building Improvement this is a this is one of the most difficult projects what we foresee at the moment because of the sensitivity of the site being a historical building uh that so that we will try to do it as as soon as the new building is constructed and then after that construction will begin as I said earlier for we may use the new building as a swing space for the classrooms Roofing replacement same as the other Pi of meeting picture outside High School this is the distribution of resources Financial Resources for projects new classroom building already kicked off is in the programming phase buing 2026 construction 2027 close out 2029 baseball field at outside design 2025 that's being will be kicked off
076in a few months building will be 2026 construction 2026 close out early March 2027 the same applies with the diving modernization once the new building is done because it'll be a three-story building uh we are hopeful that we will not need a sink space or temporary housing for students occupying deep diving at the moment uh where where the they will be requiring temporary spaces but we will will try to accommodate as much as we can in the new building which we'll be constructing well before this project goes on in construction replacement Remains the Same but we will be this there's a difference here phase one for good side will be taking place next year not like not this year like other sites because at the moment there's a HVAC project going on at the site
077and the units are being mounted on the roof so it'll be very difficult to get that done in the summer KCK off meeting for programming at put side ready for construction so as I said earlier ready for construction now is Roofing and these were these are the few pictures for the conditions of the roof we have 25 2025 carot High these are the buildings will be re roofed this is for M Eon this is for squ and this is then following year these are the phases which will take place 2026 man Eon squ high school hotside high school and then 2027 it'll be kmot high school and square and outside after that any question um oh I I just had a question about um some of the um costs kind of went up against the
078budget especially like at at Ma I noticed it went up quite a bit and what was the reason for that the reason the first and foremost reason is the bidding uh the the midpoint of the construction part of the schedule that's how the escalation took place basically adding 5% each year and also the complexity of the project certain projects are not that simple because demolition will also cost a lot of money there'll be demolition abatement and disposable this abatement demolition and disposal of materials and none of the schools are similar the terrain is different there there are many other factors accessibility and all these all these factors were considered so basically it's not just playing on on the estimation was not done Plain on Plain paper but theoretically it was also there were a lot
079of site visits we had to work the sites to assess the site more of a buildability approach than uh just looking at the figures so that's why there's a bit of a difference I said 5% but 5% behind 5% there a lot of other subjective efforts which have been taking place so also another point of clarification during the facility master plan process there there is a lot of estimating going on but these um these new numbers that we have is the work of kitchell who we hired which is focused and as nian mentioned there's a lot more detail going into the estimates of these project costs um just a a lot more detail in the calculations which is also posted on this agenda item so I'm just wondering you're using 5% as projected escalation what
080has been actual escalation in the last few years last Fe few years it has been volatile sometimes goes to 15 went down to 8% and uh so the average what you see within the next 3 years was 5% that's the that's the figure we used that's the industry figure we used but as it is I must remind I must just inform you all that it may vary it may go down may go higher uh we have uh 47 projects to complete within this bone program they there were 73 total in the master plan the priority list was 47 and we are aing to complete all these 47 in this Bond program me W but uh we have to be mindful that the escalation could be much higher or much lower it all depends as it
081is now uh just recently there was a bid opening at one of the other districts because of the steel price hike uh the bid which came out the variance from the initial S was about almost 10% so which is pretty much unacceptable Al comment I've been involved in other Bond projects and every time the increases were higher than projected and yes 5% I'd be willing to bet that it will go up higher than that so that's that's what we are personally I look at a variance of less than 5% or less than 3% is acceptable uh that is where the cost is and that's why as uh the superintendent has stated that we are very getting into very nitive details of things so estimation will take in different phases as I said that we kicked
082off design design uh we talked about scope budget and schedule but the schedule itself is very detailed like in during programming there are lot of details with programming which is Project assessment same as Pro programming is the same it depends on who uses it and then we have schematic design then design development then construction documents so at every phase there will be estimation going on and as so all the budgets which you see here now are called the fixed budget limits and all estimation will be done so that we don't go over the fixed budget limits So based on that there'll be continuous value engineering being done so that we remain within that threshold of the f fbl uh not compromising with scope not Des scoping but trying to find out other avenues in terms
083of material compromise maintaining the standard use and all this kind of stuff I am worried about the steel cost yes and that potentially could change the design and how we look at some of our future projects because we are building some big buildings so we will be working through that I also concerned there might be a lot of building going on LA area in the coming years which could impact prices of everything another area of question and this would require I guess board input if if you're interested in this but my perception is that we well I we there's about $20 million of solar in the plan yes and I think clean energy is great but I think our our options are to buy solar panels and generate our own clean energy or to buy
084from Peninsula clean energy who makes clean energy that they sell to us and I'd want to make sure that the value of the electricity that we believe we would generate would pencil out with reasonable assumptions to the cost of the solar project is that an analysis that has been done and can be shared uh it hasn't been done yet but at the moment we are installing uh uh control systems at all our all the sites which is solar panels at the moment uh to gauge that and then we'll be seeking reports for regarding that whether how we threw up with the PGN cost and all this so we haven't I haven't got any data on that yet but the solar is included there so there's a kavat by DSA regarding solar because this is to
085for The Architects to fulfill the Kel green requirements that's why it is a project can you say it again uh the Solar projects are listed here and allocated funds for that because solar is a requirement we have to have that this the roofs have to be sustainable enough to accommodate solar panels because that's a requirement by D per K green requirements you have to be able to accommodate them but do you have to put them on uh I don't think so okay so I'd just be interested to make sure that the cost of them is worth as long as DC we don't have we will absolutely be doing that assessment on the en regarding solar yes and there's some other things that are listed in there that um you can see towards the later phases
086that potentially um I mean it's it's a plan right things cost this this Bond was passed with the focus on the four main campuses and the focus on classrooms so market conditions can change what we end up building how much we end up building um and so as we continue to work through these projects design is completed we are constantly evaluating those and making necessary adjustments so there is still a lot of um opportunity for the board to weigh in about our projects anym okay next is item 13 thank you yeah sorry next is item 13.3 the annual presentation on the SEO Union High School district attendance we got one public comment and person okay do we have any online please raise your hand now this is for item 13.3 okay just the one um
087like to welcome kit waffle good evening um I was here a few weeks ago regarding the quality the Stars therapeutic program and I'm here tonight as a desperate parent to address the district's plan to increase in attendance in the in the attendance presentation you're about to see the focus is justifiably on English language Learners 39% of whom were classified as chronically absent um in 2324 school year however students with disabilities fall just behind this at 34% and deserve your attention too my son is one of them this is the third year that my child has not been able to attend school full-time because of his disabilities every year we receive attendance warning letters and treny notices every year we ask for help and nothing changes my son's had an IEP since the beginning and I
088send him to school every day but seoa high school has never figured out how to provide the right support to keep him from having to leave campus in mental health distress autistic meltdown or atic problems caused by the stress of being at school he's not alone autistic children experience a six times higher rate of anxiety and Studies have estimated 40 to 60% of autistic students experience School avoidance from the overwhelming environment and experiences of school trauma we've tried to find Solutions um but the district has stopped us at every turn when he was almost completely unable to attend this fall we scrambled to find online classes that he could engage in from home to keep his education going while we waited for assessments and IEP meetings that hadn't been completed in time for his Tri
089trienal last spring despite the district offering no Solutions every solution we propose has been denied smaller classes a plan for a graduated return to full days independent study Home Hospital a hybrid schedule a shortened day to provide access to one toone classes outside seoa even an MPS placement with the board's decision to reject concurrent enrollment credits from non-w schools he hasn't even been allowed to continue in the two general Ed classes that he passed first semester online The District's only offer is to continue as we have for the last two and a half years of being unable to attend full day school in a placement that has never worked I have begged and begged for changes and been denied at every turn I am truly at a loss on what else to do to help
090my son attend full-time and access his education as you review the ensuing attendance presentation I ask you to consider a few actions you as a board can take to make a difference number one postpone the narrowing of accreditation standards from any Regional body to only was schools so that students across the district who were successful first semester can complete their courses of the year I'm sorry time's up sorry your time's up I'm sorry your time's [Music] thank you that's all um good evening board trustees and members of the audience uh I am introducing this evening for our presentation executive director Jarrett dly uh to present on attendance thank you good evening uh president Nori superintendant leech trustees staff and public guests have the pleasure tonight of providing an overview of attendance efforts within the seoa
091Union High School District this will include our system overview key Data Insights the role of our bilingual Community liaison and SEF and our future plans to improve student attendance our approach to attendance has evolved significantly over the years is demonstrated on this timeline uh pre-2020 we built monitoring systems setting attendance goals 2020 to 2022 we all know what happened with covid-19 pandemic uh extremely disrupting attendance requiring extensive re-engagement efforts and multiple modifications to attendance taking measures 22 to 24 focused on tiered interventions implementation of multi-tiered systems of supports as well as hiring six bilingual Community Liaisons to support student engagement we have navigated the many changes to attendance within the state in response to the pandemic the implications of these many changes on attendance data are outlined here including the recent focused effort through the
092district's elcap this includes the full implementation of the district sarb uh process and hiring staff through the lcap to focus on individualized and targeted student attendant supports directly tied to students needs across multiple tiers of interventions as we proceed further into our system overview it's important to identify and celebrate uh the diligent work of our School site and District staff members our bilingual Community Liaisons are identified here on the left I'd like to ask them that are present with us to stand up so we can acknowledge all their hard work have Mar soul is Isabel Alexis zardo and Pedro thanks for joining us in addition to the other school site staff that support our attendants work uh additionally our district office team as listed uh want to acknowledge their role in developing tiers of intervention
093training and professional development and the ongoing support of our site sta our School site staff this should look familiar because our District's tiered approach is an effort to ensure that all students uh receive the support that they need and the staff identified in tier one schoolwide universal strategies to promote attendance from all staff members in tier two early intervention for students showing warning signs community lons and our intervention teams tier three intensive support including mental health uh our mental health case worker and our District staff as our tiered approach to attendance interventions illustrates and supports district has shifted from punitive approaches the historical punitive approaches to a restorative trauma informed model to address attendance barriers this is also seen in our District's award-winning model soled process which includes required interventions by law like our treny
094notifications as well as additional key supports students that continue to struggle with improving attendance and end up in conferences where Community Liaisons attempt to find the root cause to not attending regularly students that continue through the intervention system may receive third letter of treny resulting in the student attendance review team otherwise known as sart convening to provide an individualized higher tier of interventions some students may be referred to the district SAR sarb team to again explore higher interventions and supports this also applies to the connection of our model to that of the county which they just released in the last few months that's the County Office of Education their sarb and SAR guidance built off the work here in our district so we have a seamless transition to the highest level of support if needed
095as a reviewed at the last uh board meeting elcap has goal one action 1.1 just a reminder here focusing on chronic absenteeism and its reduction with English Learners the data presented here also was provided at our last meeting just a reminder here uh that while we promised while promised several years ago the state still does not include chronic absenteeism as an indicator on the state's dashboard for grades 9 through 12 uh as it does for TK through 8 this is the main reason we built out a2a which is now called School status attend which you'll hear more about here in a minute because we wanted a better way to analyze the root causes of non-attendance for various subgroups we still hope the state dashboard will eventually incorporate chronic absenteeism for high school students onto our
096data review uh first I wanted to have a little disclaimer as pointed out chronic ente ism not represented on the dashboard so we have collaborated with school status attend partner for the data presented tonight this data differ slightly from that which uh you might find on data quest which is from the state of California this is largely due to the fact that the state includes all students that have been enrolled for more than 30 days and calculates based on all day absences attend only counts active students and calculates on a day equivalent historically they uh seem to be quite similar but in order for our data to align and have longitudal longitudinal analyses and a level of detail that the state does not and cannot provide we consistently present from our attend data our attend
097partner distributed close to 20,000 mailed and emailed Communications last school year with a 50% save rate what this means is 50% of students receiving treny notification one or excessive excuse absence letter one did not need a letter two to positively improve attendance saying in another way they've changed their attendance behavior and don't require further intervention attendance conference data shows a significant increase over the previous year doubling from 25% address rate to 49% last year largely attributed to the increase in our staff our community Liaisons who take that uh resp responsibility on while a few larger School sites may have a low lower rate it's important to point out their total conferences are substantially uh lower but conferences held they comparable sorry their conferences are substantially higher uh conferences continue to demonstrate Effectiveness as an early
098intervention within our model data shows students Miss almost one less day a week on average after a conference is held Within Improvement rate about 10% which is demonstrated on a weekly basis in the graph looking at our attend attendance categories uh sorry this is the three-year snapshot of attendance rate highlights an increase of about 05% and a near one day reduction of the average number of absences per student and looking at the attendant attend attendance categories over 3 years we can see the reduction in chronic absenteeism for all district students note that these are inclusive of all absences excused and unexcused excellent considers uh Missing less than 1% satisfactory ranges from 1 to 5% manageable from 5 to 10% and chronic is missing 10% or more of all school days team's efforts have consistently been
099on identifying and supporting students in the manageable category this is in the reduction of chronic and manageable with the surge in the satisfactory group here's chronic absenteeism by grade level which also includes a trend line the trend line represents all 9 through 12th grade students that attend contracts with in the state of California you can see by grade level uh chronic absenteeism is substantially lower than the attended overall average in reviewing student subgroup attendance categories over the past two years are teams have significantly impacted Hispanic Pacific Islander and Native American reducing chronic absenteeism rates by four three and 2% respectively this also illustrates we have work to do as we see an increase of 1% in our Filipino black and multiple ethnicity student groups an additional uh view of student subgroups represented here by a
10010 category the data demonstrates the need for increased and ongoing support to reduce absenteeism for these students group uh student groups uh unfortunately in our attend data we just started tracking all of these categories so we don't have longitudinal data uh we will for next year and we'll bring those forward in future updates looking at our attendance categories for English learners while The Chronic rate is still high at 39% we have to acknowledge the amount of positive engagement strategies that the teams have leveraged and reducing the rate by 4% over the last three years we can see boosts in all other categories which is impressive and we hope to see that Trend continue in summary the overall attendance rate increased by 0.5% over two years chronic absenteeism decreased by just under 3% overall and by
1014% for Els 2% for Native Americans 3% for Pacific Islanders and 3% for Hispanic students chronic absenteeism Still Remains a significant challenge as various other subgroups saw slight increases and attendance conference has doubled in the past year leading it uh to an increase in attendance by about 10 to 11% our six bilingual Community Le leasons play a crucial role in student engagement offering day-to-day interactions to identify tenance barriers and patterns we just started recently tracking home visits and our sorts for interventions and you can see a data table as additional data we will be measuring uh currently resulting in a 4 to 9% attendance increase after interventions completed they also complete attendance monitoring parent engagement and support in multiple languages and so much more additionally our mental health caseworker works very closely with our team
102of Liaisons and here you can see a list of site resources they develop by each School site helping to educate students and families about the importance of attending school regularly districtwide we've made attempts to strengthen mental health behavioral support and Community Resources to address root cause uh root causes of absenteeism this accomplished with our mental health caseworker and in collaboration with our district teams additional support includes tier three re-engagement strategies which we're making an effort to get back to uh this school year future plans have us looking ahead to 2025 and Beyond as we expect an influx of students in the next several years with significant attendance issues as we know as you can see on this graph substantial amount of elementary students with severe absenteeism issues we need to make sure our model and
103our system is prepared to absorb the incoming uh students also will include the expansion of our intervention planning across all tiers as you can see here are our current plans that's just a little screenshot there's a link uh as well as in our resources to look at those in Greater detail the district will also look to continue to strengthen our sart action plans and continue proactive communication to re-engage students and families maintaining consistent attendance is the number one predictor for Student Success and we're committed to ensuring every student has the support they need to stay engaged our teams will continue honing data skills to identify students in need increase in improve home visits and intervention strategies and Leverage The lcap to provide these resources additionally our team will be presenting on this very Topic at
104the upcoming casual conference in April 2025 to celebrate the work of this team uh in closing we know attendance matters and our district is making great strides and reducing chronic absenteeism some additional resources were included on the previous side and through our datadriven interventions community and school Partnerships and our targeted support we hope to create School culture where every student can be present and engaged thank you thank you so much for that presentation um I have a couple questions so I'll kick things off first um one of the things that happened right before I got on the board was I know we made some policy changes around second semester seniors and their abs um like their absen ISM policy regarding how many absences they could have and get a certain grade I'm curious like if
105you have the breakdown among grade level like specifically for seniors if you see an increase in chronic absenteeism among second semester seniors uh we could pull that data and provide it in a future update that's definitely worth noting one one thing I'll also explain is there's a lot of data this is just a little bit so if we have interest in pursuing some other request just like that it's something that we absolutely can provide uh this is like a very very scal down version of our end of thee report as you can imagine um our state data that we get focus on chronic absenteeism but we're we're able to do much more within uh the attendance system oh yeah yeah thank you and I think um a lot of what I see here is really
106promising so I'm glad our District's taking this approach that seems to be at least initially paying off on results so I'll turn to any of my colleagues if they have questions or comments trusty Thompson first I want to say thank you to our community liaison um it's so cool that you're in the room tonight because you are not this is not the only time that praise for you has come up um as I've been associating with different board presentations so thank you and and with that being said you know when when something is working that's a bright spot how do we mimic it and and make that happen for others and so um correspondents that we've received um comments that we received on the board I'm wondering our community L Lon just working with our
107English language learner families in terms of like the lcap or is this something that we can broad into to our other most vulnerable subgroups as mentioned from our community or or or by that data yeah thanks for asking that trusty Thompson uh real important question um the through the lcap and the hiring of staff that was the primary goal to support our English Learners and families through reduction of chronic absenteeism and increasing re-engagement that's basically the goal uh our goal in leveraging the hiring of staff to support the school sites is to implement the tiers of intervention as a system which is applicable and can be applied to all students now we started rolling out first uh I mean we have it's it's our team of bilingual liaison right so they are working in multiple
108langu languages with our English uh learner and uh newcomer families so that is the primary focus but operating within the system and the tears of intervention it is good for all students and when we proposed that and we started to write the data that we wanted to examine for the lcap you know was cross your fingers let's hope this works and the data really does support that it's not just we're not just seeing gains in one subgroup we are seeing it across uh multiple subgroups and I think that's obviously attributable to the team but also to the school sites for um harnessing that and welcoming those conversations more and more into the um School sites and the and really the intervention team so it's much more talked about widespread any other trustees with comments okay
109um so I I noted that um I think I understand that the absences are all absences uh it would be helpful to see the absence type um in in some of these charts and then also um can we track or do we track the root causes of the absences if they're identified as part of those parent um conferences two-parter so yes we can we can look at some additional data based on um absent type absence type um tied to a root cause we do not have a a system in place where we can globally respond to that um we have some ideas that we're currently working through in collaboration uh with research and evaluation um department and trying to see if we can actually create that um what we have in place right now uh
110would be very difficult and cumbersome to come up with that data uh but it is on the list because that's how we are able to identify interventions and tie them to student need by looking at a root cause and and trying to uh solve that root cause just right now we don't have an easy uh system in place to collate that and then report based on that it's in the works best way I can answer that okay yeah that I think that would be really helpful when you see the trends and then you can actually attack it more holistically um and then I guess going back to the attendance conferences can you help me understand why the um total number of conferences has an impact on the address rate because shouldn't we be targeting a
111high number regardless is there some limitation that I'm not seeing um that was back on slide 14 because you said the total conferences held was similar but the total conferences was more um yeah I think I might have misspoke okay let me get this one right here right yes so conference address rate is conferences held divided by total conferences um so our four large high schools you can see from Sequoia ma carmont Woodside the total conferences column uh specifically for seoa and Ma being significantly higher um you know upwards in the 500 to carmont Woodside being 189 and 269 um I just wanted to point out that when you convert to a rate even though the rate is slightly lower for COA and ma um if you look at the conferences held the conferences held
112or comfortable actually exceed the number at Carlmont even though the rate is doubled at Carlmont so it's just making sure to point out that you know no no pointing fingers everyone is doing the conferences and holding the work um just wanted to point out that even though rate could like we could have just displayed the rate but without then the calculation you kind of don't understand and are unable to compare the school sites to each other but I guess I'm curious then are the total conferences related to different students or is it like yes those are unique students okay unique student conferences yes you um per our our sarb process uh the third intervention is a conference after the second letter which one important point to note is if the conference doesn't happen the next
113intervention can't happen so everything stops which which makes the conference super important and as you can see our 2223 data on the bottom that was pre Community Lis on team members and those conferences were just absorbed as additional work between Administrative Vice principls some counselors some intervention counselors just other staff and that was why when we developed the action uh or the goal in the lcap we knew we had to bring people to do specifically this and that was echoed largely by the um the ABP teams I guess I mean if it's Unique uh students that are involved um is it just the limiting factor of the number of resources we have at the site to be able to address the high number of total conferences time and resources okay it so it's not so
114much that the parents are not accepting the invitation I'm sure it's a Litany of of things yeah yeah because that's what I'm driving timing communication scheduling and not attending there's a there's a long list of reasons am I yes he's raising his hand pick me because I just want to make sure it's not something that's a limiting factor on our side right yeah yeah okay um any other no I just want to say thank you to Liaisons and I was just curious like how many hours do they spend a week in make in in you know helping the numbers here that's one of the questions I know it's a lot of work so I'm just curious as to how many hours I'm supposed to say the hours that they're compensated for yeah but I mean
115I know it's more but I'm just thinking like wow that's amazing thank you for the work you're doing and I know it takes a lot of energy and effort and extra hours but just incredible work appreciate that okay thank you so much for that presentation um why don't we take a 10-minute break and come back at 805 for our next agenda item thank you why don't we start returning to the Das trusty yeah okay next is item 14.1 um I'll I'll let trusty gin introduce this item briefly and then we'll take public comment on it okay uh thank you um so the PE waiver allowed in Ed code and that I'm bringing forward for discussion today uh only applies to ninth grade students who participate in a school sponsored athletic Endeavor some of the emails
116we received people seem to think it would apply to more students than that um I just want to clarify that uh this is the area of difference between our board policy and the California Ed code and the discussions about having our policy potentially be the same uh as what's currently Allowed by the board policies of both Sano Union and pal to our two neighboring districts so our board policy has a additional words in there that both of our neighboring districts do not have and so the discussion is just for us to match them I believe that our district should offer a broad range of course offerings and let students choose the path that is right for them I do not believe that nth grade students should have a common or shared nth grade experience some
117people who wrote to us about this agenda item suggest that having a common nth grade experience was a District goal I'm not aware that this District ever had such a goal our Northstar is our strategic plan which does not have a common ninth grade experience as a goal physical activity is very important one of my often repeated reminders to my own kids is sleep exercise nutrition as a three building blocks of self-care on which everything else rests I agree with every person who wrote to us about the importance of physical activity I believe that the board should determine what information or experiences we think all students should have and we should require students to take relevant classes however all circumstances are not the same and we should have reasonable policies about waving requirements when it
118makes sense to do so and I believe this PE waiver discussion touches on one such area in order to wave both pe1 and pe2 a student would need to complete at least six seasons which would require at least two sports were we to move forward with permitting a waiver of pe1 I believe it would only apply to students who were on a team in the fall and plan to participate on at least one other team during nth grade that is this is a proposal to have students continue to satisfy the pe1 requirement by ninth grade physical activity at school um some people seem to think it would imply being able to take PE offsite or some other thing which is not which is not what the change to the policy would would change PE is
119very important and should be required for ninth grade and we should be reasonable about when to wave it students participating on two or three sports teams during nth grade get plenty of exercise and enabling those students the option to explore an elective could enable those students to have an experience that makes more sense for them given their already high level of physical activity be would remain available for our two and three season nth grade athletes but they could have the option to explore something else again the discussion today is about having our board policy provide the same flexibility as the board policies of both Sano Union and Pa Alto which exactly match the Ed code section in currently 7eventh and 8th grade who will be at our schools when this change could take effect I'd
120bet that a vast majority of families who have students who will likely participate in two or three sports during nth grade would prefer their student to have a choice about PE or another elective versus requiring PE with no option to select anything else the school board is here to represent our constituents I asked to have this agenda item today thinking that acting today could provide options for current e8th grade ERS I've since learned that the schools would be would need more time to prepare elective capacity and that the current seventh graders are the first who could even possibly be affected if we made any change uh so my goal with this discussion tonight is to determine whether this board has an interest in exploring what we might be able to offer to multiport ninth grade
121student athletes given the greater flexibilities our schools would have if we matched the policies of our neighboring districts so I'm not asking to change the policy tonight but I'm asking if uh it's something that the board wants to get the information that we would need to look at such a decision in the future okay thanks for the introduction um why don't we start with public comment now all right we have four in person and if you would like to comment online please raise your hand okay we see one on okay why start with the iners in three minutes okay all right first up is Lauren Cornell good evening in my email to the board earlier this week I touched on the fact that offering a pe1 waiver to students directly contradicts both board policy and
122District programs aimed at equity and wellness for all students tonight however I want to speak on the importance of physical education in nth grade it is a class that students have the opportunity to work with their peers of differing ability levels languages and socioeconomic statuses to accomplish various goals it doesn't matter whether they have a job after school to provide rent money for their family or they are the captain of the football team as a freshman they engage in a rigorous curriculum taught by passionate credentialed Educators that aim to improve their physical health and well-being creating a universal experience for nth graders topic discussed at nauseum during a 2023 board meeting there are no haves or Have Nots there are simply students working together to be a better version of themselves this is not merely
123physical activity this is a physical education that allows the students to find activities that can engage in well into adulthood it is not about refining a specific set of skills to make them successful in one specific setting or two or three rather it is a health curriculum that allows them to be more informed and make smarter and healthier choices it is a swim unit that provides many students their first exposure to being in water the list really goes on and on by allowing students to opt out of this class you will be creating a situation that only further caters to the students who can afford to play after school sports to sum it up by allowing a pe1 waiver you as the board would be furthering the inequity that so many of our students face
124on a daily basis you as a board would be destroying the Integrity of after school sports and most importantly you as a board would be undermining the value of physical education in our district thank you thank you next we have Janet kin evening um I'm a mother I have three kids two of them already graduated from seoa they both the oldest two were very athletic my daughter did dance my daughter did water polo and she did swim never once did she complain never about PE it was the time she was with friends they were laughing they're doing games they were introduced to other games my other son who did football he did baseball and he did soccer he did three Sports and he did Club but he never complained about PE I talked to my
125children last night this is ridiculous this is mental health one of my sons even said it helped me if I had a class constantly I needed to move I needed to get blood going to my brain if I just was class class class and he goes mom to me if a parent thinks it's okay to skip PE he's not thinking of his kids mental health mental health is very big right now kids need to move I know I have a child with it I have a child who's now a senior talked to him about it last night he goes to Sequoia football and track he's doing track because a great track coach here's dad said hey I know it's your senior year I know you don't want to do it but just come um he
126loves it he goes Mom it's not killing me it's not he goes I have fun I see all my friends again I just didn't want to do it because I was just lazy comes home he does homework he's got the blood in the brain he's moving I get it I mean my daughter made so many friends so many different sports that she never would have tried and had a blast and you're not judged because it's PE so many of the after school sports you have to make the team or you just sit on the bench the only Sports is swimming is where everybody could do and track you gotta be good at everything it could make you feel really stupid doesn't what is our number one thing everybody's getting out of shape you look in
127the future P's going to teach you something that you're going to like to do it's going to be you're not looking at PE as education you're looking at i' rather put my kid in AI class i' rather put my kid in this i' rather push my child and that's how as a parent I'm looking at it where PE is so important freshman year they need to meet kids they need to make more friends you know they get set with certain classes but then they make so many more friends please think of it a different way they do one after school sport then they got two seasons still to go and what is it going to do for you know the credits just do me a favor and think about it think of the blood going
128to the brain and mental health because be does not destroy you it helps you it stops you from looking at your phone thank you next we have Adrien Dilly uh good evening um I actually have a uh response from Dr Taja Henderson to read tonight uh she's a seoa Union High School District instructional coach I'm a PE teacher at seoa high school but um I felt this would be a little bit more appropriate um being that it um came from Taja someone outside of our department and a former co-worker and ex Co former coach as well at sequa uh this is taja's words uh PE in the nth grade represents more than physical activity it increases essential skills like teamwork coordination and wellness while Building Bridges across the many diverse communities that feed into the
129SEO Union High School District adopting a policy that provides a PE waiver for nth graders exacerbates the soci socioeconomic divide in the district sent student athletes from families with access to financial resources to pay for expensive sport club sports and private coaches will ultimately be the ninth graders who seek the waiver the waiver will inherently inherently build walls increase social tensions and perpetuate biases rather than create an inclusive opportunity for every ninth grader regardless of athletic ability across the district to access a structured and thriving PE program that supports the universal n9th grade experience this policy could also taint the reputation of our school district which promotes itself as being committed to providing equal opportunities for every student not just the elite I urge the board to vote no on adopting a PE waiver for
130ninth grade students thank you thank you our last speaker in person is Eda Salvatore good evening I was pleased to hear trustee again say that he won't call for a vote today even though that is indicated in the agenda it was I was very upset to see that in the agenda as it's a departure from the past practice of this board that has always clearly demonstrated that if action is going to be taken it is to be taken in the action portion of the agenda and not slipped in in the background of an online agenda um I'd also like to address the contention about the Sano Union High School District at um board policy yes the board policy lists any number of reasons that exemptions may be granted in special circumstances but the truth is
131that in Sano Union High School District nth graders take PE 10th graders take PE and if they are involved in an inter Scholastic sport they may participate in an athletic study hall during their PE period during their Sports season they do not get wavers they do not skip PE but I want to talk about my family you may know my kids are in eighth grade they're looking at high school my daughter hates PE right now she's 14 a lot of 14 year old girls do should she be able to team up with her best friend next year and sign up for a couple of non-cut sports so they can hang out together on the bleachers and giggle until it's their turn to do whatever that Sport and tals with 80 people on a non-cut team
132and never participate in a PE class never learn how to manage your stress never learn how to maintain a healthy body and not find a path to lifelong activity I took that path I told my counselors 35 years ago that I was going to try out for sports teams they put me in PE for athletes I never made a team you can look at me I clearly could have benefited from the type of PE education that Lauren described to you but what about my other kids what about my son what if he decides he doesn't like English but he really likes being on the speech and debate team he's doing a lot of rhetoric why should he have to take English class what about my other son who's going to run for class office when
133he gets to be a senior why should he have to take government class he's participated in student government he's done a lot of work just because the Ed code says that something is possible does not mean it is something we should consider or that is good for our students and on top of that it is disrespectful to the work that our PE colleague thank you our last speaker is online concerned [Music] Community hi there um I want to Echo everything that's already been said and I'm a little worried because I'm wondering if this is kind of a back way into discussing waivers for classes in general um are we trying to get waivers just for PE or are we trying to do things like get waivers for ethnic studies um trusty gin has brought these
134sorts of things up multiple times and I do feel like it's a waste of time and really not anybody's priority thank you thank you okay why don't we go to board discussion thank you yeah I guess one of my questions was about sort of not everybody plays Sports and not everybody gets into sports right they just you get cut um and I think one of my questions was in regards to mental health but it was also um a lot of the students in East paloalto do not have the opportunities to actually go into these Sports and pay for these Sports even if they do get in right and then um those that don't need PE for mental health and wellness I think it's really important for mental health and wellness for all students but especially
135in EPA right there's a lot of students that don't have those opportunities to be able to go to after school sports or try to get in they have other um obligations and I think about those kids who have obligations to take care of family members at home having a babysit younger for siblings and not um having that opportunity right to exercise so I think about them in regards to mental health wellness and being able to have that PE class to do that right because they won't yeah I know but I'm just thinking about all these kids that don't have the opportunity to be in football or don't have the opportunity to be in other sports right and need PE for mental health and not just EPA I mean all students right it's it's it's I
136think about mental health and I think about students who are on their phones and I think about especially my kid right like they they're on their phones a lot and that's one time when well there's a lot of times in classrooms where they're not on the phone but that's one time when I think all students are not on their phones and they're like focusing on just doing what they're doing right whatever it is that the the the um the task is at hand for that day as far as move movement right I think it's really important for students to have movement and so that's where I'm at that's that was one of my comments and thinking about this yeah [Music] yeah yeah yeah why don't we try um just a reminder speaking the mic Ser
137everyone can hear us um I'm happy to go next if any anyone else wants to go first okay so um you know I I took p as a freshman and I enjoyed it I thought it was a worthwhile experience for sure and I think um I do wonder if there are a lot of logistic concerns about how exactly this might be implemented in a way that might ensure you know that students aren't like you know shooting themselves in the foot by like planning on playing a sport and not doing it um but more importantly I think I generally agree with the principle that it is tricky for ninth graders that it seems like you know you're kind of very much set on a select path and there's no opportunity to deviate and I wonder you
138know because it is a discussion we've always had if maybe this isn't the place to do it but I do agree in general there's got to be something we can do to give ninth graders more options to take electives because you know even when we go back to that last presentation about chronic absenteeism I'm sure there are a lot of people you know who don't like not liking your courses really doesn't give you a reason to show up to school to begin with and if you know you're taking a bunch of courses where you don't feel like you had any choice like yeah I get I you know it's a terrible thing but people might feel not feel the need to actually show up so I wonder if maybe not through PE but there's some
139way we could give students some options to have sort of more you know control over what they're taking because I think we did look at this in the past and when students were able to pick courses that they liked you know that did help with chronic absenteeism and even you know they might only show up for the class that they really enjoyed that they picked but that and those do tend to be be electives I know that was something that our former trustee duah would talk a lot about about when students you know were able to pick some of their electives it gave them a reason to come to school for people who otherwise wouldn't because they you know they love their cooking class or they Lov wood shop so maybe PE might this might
140not be the way to do it but what I'd be more broadly interested in is is there some way to give ninth graders an easy opportunity to take electives cuz I think the current way isn't exactly that Equitable EAS either to say you know if you want an elective you have to take a seventh period because you know people have other commitments after school so like that's also kind of skewed as to who exactly is going to be able to stick around to take an elective that they want for seventh period so I wonder there's got to be a way of doing what I'd really be interested in is kind of understanding what can we do because I know other districts have solutions to this so what can we do to give nth graders least
141opportunity to take one elective and still be on a path for College and Career Readiness okay so I'm trying to take in everything that you all said as well as everything from the emails and the comments um and I want to say the first the first thing is as as you all know I have my history credential and when I was getting that say 18 years ago whatever it was everyone was like be a m teacher we need Math teachers we don't need another history teacher and I was like I don't want to teach math you don't want me teaching math I love history and I think we really need to pay attention to the fact that our teachers don't just choose a random subject our PE teachers chose PE because that's their passion and
142they chose it and they developed it like any other teacher would develop that curriculum so one of the things I really want to put out there is the fact that Sports don't have a curriculum PE has a curriculum taught by a credential teacher who went to school for that so I I don't want us to underestimate that speaking of trusty cou and I went to the wellness meeting the other day that was reconvened and in the wellness board policy talks about how important nutrition is how important mental health is how important um oh now I'm blinking what was the other one nutrition no what was the other one in there no it was like the whole document was like 50 anyway doesn't matter I can pull up the board policy physical oh duh physical yes
143exactly it was like this wellness policy board policy 5030 half of it is about nutrition and half of it is about physical activity where are they getting this nutritional curriculum but in PE um I think the other thing that I'm thinking about too is I was a nth grade teacher for many years I'm not saying that ninth graders don't need electives and choice and and that could help but I also am also know that there are other things that bring students to campus that isn't about a specific class but rather about the Friendship they made or the relationship they have and not all students particularly ones that really struggle in traditional academics can make that connection with their adult in a history classroom but they can on the field and so that could be that
144adult that is bringing that teacher or that student to campus not to mention the friends that they're hanging out with um I was talking to a bunch of parents in my zone um about this and talking about how you know kids who go to colmont who like what sports are they playing and what are who are they interacting with across the field and so I think you're right we don't talk about necessarily um you know that everything has to be that the same for nth grade we want them to have choice but our strategic action plan does talk about sense of belonging and we can get that from this this PE class that all nth graders have to take regardless of if they're whatever middle school they're coming from and I think the last thing
145that I want to bring up and this then we'll we'll second what you're saying um president Nory in regarding of and also what you're saying too sort of like what then what do we do like what is the Compromise Where Do We Go From Here one I I think that following another District's policy does not make it the right choice for us we we competitive districts prioritize student health competitive schools in this area prioritize student health and so I think what we what I would like to do though is you know yes state law requires PE yes districts are not um that 9th grade is specifically designated for PE and they allow for flexibility doesn't mean that we are required to offer that exemptions so what I would like to look at then and this
146is what I would potentially propose is let's not narrow this to ninth grade and to PE Let's we let's look at this in terms of all the all the grad requirements that we have in regards to our strategic action plan like we now have that do our grad requir ments match what we're asking in our strategic action plan and so what I would propose is actually like let's slow down a second let's take let's do a study session on that and that is my spel yeah I'll I'll add some oh yeah so I'll add some comments to um I think in terms of like I I think what uh president nor is talking about is giving students agency in ninth grade because if they get choices then they'll feel a stronger sense of belonging but
147it doesn't necessarily have to happen with the classes because when you arrive as a freshman um there's a lot of stuff that's new so there's all these different clubs and organizations that you could get involved with um so that already is some sense of agency just trying to explore different clubs and figuring out what you want to join um and then there's other ways to try and introduce different things like there's school dances there might be volunteers opportunities like there's a lot of different things to choose from um and I I do feel that the ninth grade PE is is covering a lot of Wellness topics and introducing new types of sports and and just exposing kids to different things and as well as people different from themselves um and I think the other thing
148too is I I agree with um trustee Thompson and looking a little bit more holistically and not just graduation requirements and how it fits in with the Strategic plan but also to look at waivers holistically because right now the discussion is just on Ninth Grade PE like that is so narrow and it's not that I want to like allow all sorts of waivers but what we've seen is uh issues with students transferring in from other school districts or private schools or charter schools and if their uh District that they transferred from didn't have the same graduation requirements as we did then there's no uh builtin out for them and so they have to either take those classes um or we we try to throw in a waiver at the last second so I think we
149just need to look holistically at that because there are going to be differences in requirements from uh School District to school district and different schools and just have something more proactive so that um students and parents are not left an alert and having anxiety especially if a student comes in in the senior year I mean that's that's very stressful um at least if you come in 10th Grade there's a little longer Runway to make up what you missed in 9th grade um but we have a lot of n9th grade requirements and so how do how do students make them up so I I want to look holistically at grad requirements and and waivers just one comment back to Edith that about someone sitting on the fence or whatever in the bleachers that our policy says
150has to be comparable amount of physical activity for the waiver to count so if it was exactly described it wouldn't count for the waiver um but I've heard two of my colleagues suggest study of graduation requirements and and waivers and I would third that um I think that that's looking holistically at the whole the whole system uh makes sense and maybe this particular graduation requirement would or would not be something that we chose maybe we chose choose to change nothing but um having it as part of an entire package one thing that came up in the discussion um or in my uh exploration this topic was you know if we did free up a period what would students take and that there aren't currently elective offerings available and that would be something that would require
151some amount of thinking as well like if if we did we make any change somewhere there's going to be other things to adjust and it's a whole thing to to understand and I I I will third the idea of having a study session on graduation requirements waivers and in course offerings um I think in well in particular the okay okay so the two that I would mean when I say those words the ones I would refer to would be um what I mean is digital literacy and financial literacy which are potential future graduation requirements so I'd include those in current graduation requirements and those two which have been talked about as near-term possible graduation requirements that that I at least personally believe align with our goal of producing successful people or people ever navigate the
152world successfully I forget exactly how we word it in the Strategic plan but I think that some of those things could be directly related to our strategic plan but that was what I meant by that particular word yes son of Maria and savic if you also agree that you want this or different thoughts so I'm very interested in this because you know like I think some of the conversation is a little unfair because it's not just PE you know the we waivers like tons of students including myself don't take Goin econ in school you know we take it online maybe because they don't offer a AP go or AP Eon which people are interested in taking or you know it just doesn't fit with your schedule and you want to take something else in fact
153you know we do allow people to take up to 20 units of um courses to replace grad requirements outside of school and you know personally I I mean I don't know if like is 20 the right number could it be higher if students are interested and we also you know we do cap the number of courses you can take outside of school that show up on your transcript even if they they're not replacing a grad requirement to 40 units so you know if if you're taking courses outside that you're interested in that are not even trying to replace a grad requirement like do we need to have a cap should should we like encourage people to say hey if you want to go take more courses outside of school yeah you know you're putting in
154the work will let you keep it on your transcript so I think there's a lot of stuff when it comes to these kind of like waivers and like current restrictions to talk about so I think it would be good to do it more broadly so that's why I think this is a great idea to have a study session on and maybe you know the only thing um I want to focus on I think sometimes when we do this we stick a little too broad and it kind of comes off with like you know we all agree that something needs to be done but we don't come up with like concrete actionable steps so one of the things I'd like is to kind of say you know we are looking at holistically and broadly but try
155to n narrow down on some actual actions that we can take so you know we can kind of address this issue instead of talking more in the abstracts that's what I'd hope would come out of the study session but I'm fully in support I am 100% in support too of the study session for sure yes and I like the idea of financial literacy for sure because you're going into college and you need to know about financial I mean it'd be great for them to know about financial literacy as they get into or they're going into college right or trying to get into college think that's huge and life skills thank you okay I need some clarification so we went from here to here um so I heard grad required ments which is pretty focused I
156heard um an understanding of all of our waivers and then I heard a clarification of course offerings but then I heard you expand it to a class that I've heard you talk about frequently on apgov and so and then and then I'm I'm kind of I'm to us to be a for staff to be able to pre bring information to present to be able to answer questions that the board may have it's not clear to me what we are actually doing a study session on why don't we do this because I think we could like talk about this ad nauseum I'm fine if um trusty Thompson trusty gin work with superintendent leech to figure out what exactly wants to go in for this study session yeah you're okay I mean I I I can do
157that but I also I'm also I'm a little bit concerned because like for me waivers was not something that I was necessarily thinking about when I first was talking about this it was really just about grad requirements and then this concept of of you know what's potentially coming down the pipeline with AI or not AI digital literacy financial literacy as just being those time things so um I don't want to I don't want to not hear everybody's voice that's the only thing I'm concerned about is I don't I think trusty coup actually brought up waivers so I don't know if you would be Are there specific ones is was it the one that we've heard about a few times that you were or there other on just just looking at the experience of transfer students
158that's all yeah I almost wonder if that's a separate I mean it could be a separate piece from graduation requirements but some of it is because what is required here to graduate doesn't align with the graduation requirements or class offerings that from the schools and school districts that they came from and it and although you can make up the credits it's just an extra thing that the kids have to coordinate and so that's why I'm saying like we just need to look at that experience because if they come in in 10th Grade yeah there's a longer Runway but if they come in in senior year and you still have to make up all those same requirements that creates a different level of stress so it's just really looking at the transfer experience I just want
159to ask a question iic you mentioned trying to have a goal and narrow it down uh a possible goal would be for a ninth grade student to be able to have an elective without needing a seventh period I don't know if that would align with what you're thinking or that's not at all what you're thinking I mean yeah I think I was I didn't necessarily have any specifics but I felt like because I feel like you know we have discussed this before we had a presentation but I wondered if it was too a little too abstract not focus on concrete items I think that is a concrete item that I don't know if the rest of the board agrees I personally do would agree with that is like one of the goals that you know
160we could focus on but mainly in general I was like like one of the takeaways from the study session would be I would prefer if there are some concrete things we could do you know that we as a board agree on and with staff input and with our teachers and parents and students you know can you know we as five can make a decision say this is something we do believe that's in the best interest of our students that's kind it was more of a general point but um yeah I'm not sure if I can commit to that particular goal because it's specific and It ultimately then pushing a class to still go out somehow and I'm not committed I'm not I not okay I'm I'm not ready to do that so process question um
161so it so when I um we would have a study session we would um bring this information to the study session to study um but there could come additional questions or you know slight bird walks right like on what potentially we could do that we would then have to revisit so I just want to be able to manage expectations um because we as as president Nory did say I mean we do tend to study stuff and then we don't really have a direct thing because like right now I just kind of hear requests for information but not an end goal I think where I'm thinking about in regard sorry were you about to go where I'm thinking about in terms of an end goal we have this beautiful strategic action plan we have our district
162requires more credits to grad more classes credits to graduate than the state of California not saying an opinion good or bad but does that now reflect what our strategic action plan is and and maybe the goal is literally just to say yeah actually it does we're good or maybe the goal is know there's some there's some things we need to start looking at so that that's my goal does the Strategic action plan match our current grad requirements thinking into the future particularly what was the one you just said no no no that how like students prepared for out there want our students to be successful in successful after they leave yes does does our grad requirements match that so that that would be something that would be interested in now that we have the Strategic
163action plan no I was just thinking about um uh going back to looking at the transfers and looking at to see what what what can what is applicable what can we help the transfers with in regards to what you were saying uh in regards to the the units right and how many units they have to make up and hitting the ground running and what can be waved and what is not waved in that kind of stuff so that's what I want to look at yeah I'd be really interested in that too because just that starting there right and then also looking at our strategic plan and seeing line I don't know if those are two separate items or can combine them one because I think I think they are related separate but then they're also
164related but I do I do think that is something that you know we talk about and I feel like we've made like you know ad hoc exemptions for certain things or another but I think having a standardized policy would be good because I do do think like you know we have a lot of um grad requirements that other districts don't have or like people could come here and like as you can think you know as we talk about as nauseum like who would actually you know be able to make those up versus who could not so I'd be totally interested in that because I do think it's a real problem that a lot of our students who come to our district not in their ninth grade year doe face so so clarifica clarification then for
165um superintendent leech and perhaps cabinet then is this two separate sessions or is this one I'm looking at cabinet on that well it depend I mean depends on how long you want the study session to be I don't think we need a study session about trans I I have a proposal on the the transfer ones which would be if we were to say that if you followed if you're at an accredited school where you were before and you took everything you were required to take and then you come to our school if there's a requirement we have that's above state requirements you haven't met that we wave it because because you you did everything you supposed to do wherever you were and now you've transferred here we're not going to penalize you that wherever you
166were didn't have the same thing if we just looked at that policy and said what would be the problems with it and that could be what we look at I'm not saying that we would adopt the policy but just look at like where would the problems be I think we're getting into Brown act violation because what is on the agenda is looking at the ninth grade PE requirement so I think we need to be a little bit cautious about that and then I would ask that these be two separate studies sessions because even if you said yes we'll sit down for as long as this takes there are so many intricacies um you could go you could go on forever so I mean my advice would be look at UCA through G District graduation requirement
167State graduation requirements so that you have a a thorough understanding of what you guys are talking about where we are asking students to take things that either UC UC or the state is not asking them to take or both are not there um because then you'll know you'll have a really good idea where your wiggle room is and then where there isn't wiggle room before you start talking about what might we wave um what might we let kids take in other places Etc but that's just my suggestion um to be fair just quickly I I do think the study session where we talk about in general you know how do we align our grad requirement strategic plan but I do think that at least the um transfer student situation could just be a regular board
168presentation I don't know if we need a whole study session because it seems a little simpler of a topic that we don't may not necessarily dedicate a whole study session to it but like we had a presentation on attendance we could have a presentation on transfer students and the requirements surrounding that but those are just my thoughts yeah I mean I I brought up the transfer students thing I mean it doesn't necessarily have to be a study session it could be a regular agenda item but I also feel it's not as simple as you guys make it seem because because we choose to teach ethnic studies in ninth grade there's other districts that could choose to teach it at different times so you know it's uh it's really a timing thing and so there's a
169lot of different nuances of how we want to approach that um and so it may not be as simple as just waving everything why don't we um move on for now and I'll follow up with superintendent leech about trying to figure out what best steps forward are in some of these things is that fine I have concerns that we're all going to be walking away with different Impressions on what's going to be on the study session I would move because I like to follow rules too um anything transfer waiver regarding that let's stop that conversation right now and then put it into future agenda items so talk about it in five minutes so then go back to the original thing which is what's here proposing this this waiver again I'm going to reiterate not proposing
170like broadening this study session on grad requirements aligned with strategic action plan and we'll finish the discussion future agenda items in a few minutes to be on topic yeah that's that's fine um do we want two people to help plan like what it because it still Seasons with little I'm oh I was talking about the first study session about the oh okay okay yeah let's do that okay moving on now on to the action item portion of our meeting um 15.1 adoption of resol of resolution directing preparation of the 2025 2026 Engineers report for SSD maintenance assessment District are there any public comments there are none um okay and I'll turn this over to assistant superintendent gong so this item is an annual resolution that authorizes seci Consulting to prepare the engineer report for the
171district's maintenance assessment District uh the final report will be brought forth for for uh approval at the June meeting I request that the board um adopt the resolution okay sorry just to clarify so we'll have an we'll vote on this again in June or it's the same thing this one is asking SEI to do the services okay okay any board comment otherwise I move approval of item 151 I got a second I second um roll call trusty Cruz yes trusty Thompson yes trusty gen yes vice president C yes president nor yes motion pass um 5 Z next um adoption of resolution number six resolution authorizing filing of applications for State allocation board administrative programs for SSD um are there any public comments for this item there are none there okay turning it back to Super
172or assistant superintendent gong so prop two of the California ballot in 2024 requires school districts to submit a 5-year facilities master plan as a condition of applying for State bond funds um this resolution is new is certifying that the board acknowledges this new requirement any board comment or if not could I get a motion to approve I move approval of 152 second roll call trusty Cruz yes juste Thompson yes trusty gin yes vice president C yes president Nori yes motion pass 5 Z thank you and then um lastly we have 15.3 consideration of selection of csba assembly delegates on ballot for Sano County subregion 5B um have you start I know all three of these individuals and I think they're all make great candidates for this position I agree and at three vote for three
173so I think yeah we have no real [Laughter] [Music] choice so could I get a motion to approve I move approval of 153 seconded um all in favor I I okay that motion carries um next we have 16 um item number 16 Board of Trustees superintendent comments and committee reports um are there anything from the board or okay um well just wanted to say happy Lunar New Year and Black History Month yay um and I did want to um share just a couple of things that happened since the last board meeting um so truste Thompson and I did go to the Sequoia Adult scho School Community advisory committee meeting and it was really great to see the um every all the community stakeholders involved and um learning about what's been happening at seoa adult school
174and uh it was great to see the rise in interest in ESL classes that seems to be super popular so people are trying to learn English so that they can get jobs and be productive members of our Society um because without language skills it's really hard to navigate this um the the world that we live in and then there was also a lot of positive feedback from students who have already graduated and that's a real great Testament to what we're offering at the adult school um and then last week I had a chance to join the ra Ravenswood promise walk at Caesar Chavez Middle School um a little earlier I'd gone to a an elementary School uh unfortunately it was on Monday so it was not a typical day so there were fewer students than
175usual because of the day of immigrants walk out but I was still able to get a good sense of the school and and it was great to be able to provide feedback on on classroom observations along with other community members um and so I really recommend uh they're they're planning to do these on a regular basis so uh other Trust should take advantage of that opportunity if you can because um you're really it's not just uh visiting and talking to one person but you actually get to observe three classrooms and the there's a lot that you can learn through observation and then sharing out afterwards um what's working well and what could be improved and opportunities and one of the things that I started asking questions about is that actually Ravenswood has a Spanish Immersion
176program that continues through Middle School um but none of us are quite sure what the path is as kids go to high school um and and I'm kind of curious right um it would be helpful to understand what immersion programs are available in the feeder districts and how their paths continue in our various high schools so that's just a general question out there that I left um that day and then as trusty Thompson mentioned we were at the wellness committee meeting and it was great to see the passion of all the stakeholders in the room and many had been involved in previous iterations of the wellness committee and so there's I think a lot that we could do to upgrade our current policies um and then I I had a chance to watch some uh
177csba webinar on ethical Ai and education and it was uh very much information overload but it also compared AI with previous Tech Innovations like radio TV and computers so at one time or other those were all considered transformational potentially scary technology that would detract from education but now it's used regularly to educate people so uh it seems like AI is here to stay so uh something we might have to consider is having some sort of AI task force who can study it and actually make recommendations on on some sort of AI policy um I know our neighbor paloalto already kind of went through this exercise and probably others have as well um so it's something to keep in mind all right that's it anyone else two I went to she already mentioned so we're good
178um okay if not um we can move on to item number 17 future agenda items what were you going to say about the study question before uh uh kind of forgot but um oh I think oh I was just saying like do we want to have two trustees who are going to plan with superintendent leech what they want to shape it or if does anyone have any who'd want to volunteer trusty again and would either like trusty coup or trusty Thompson or trusty Cruz want to do it too I think I mean trusty Thompson had a much more clear idea of the grad requirements versus I mean I think I didn't I was trying to step up step back so yes I will step up yeah yeah so I think my my interest was more
179in the uh transfer experience and if we can kind of take a closer look at that and and just see see what what their experience is like the type of transfer students coming in and um what they have to navigate through in terms of graduation requirements so are you seeing that part of the same study session that trusty Thompson and I would be working with superintendent Leon or as a different something I think it's I think it's different yeah and potentially it could start out as a Friday update just to see what what's going on and and then we can potentially have a board board agenda item after that if there's things that we need to make decisions on okay is that it for a future agenda item okay um okay before we end the
180meeting um one last thing and um pardon me but um two weeks ago the men outon community in our district at large suffered a horrible tragedy with the passing of one of our history teachers Mr Harris Mr Harris was actually the first teacher I I had as a ninth grader when I started at Ma and right from the start his passions commitments and snarks set the tone for what was otherwise a great great year even after I graduated I was lucky enough to keep in touch um with Mr Harris and learn so much from him and also listen to his um advice about what to do uh the Schoolboard meeting and you know before we end our meeting one things I want to share was Mr Harris once told me that he never really liked
181school board meetings and he said when I asked him why he said because his mom was actually a trust on the Fresno Unified School District and he told me that you know his memory of school board meetings were one of Chaos in Rain Court where students were you know par adults were fighting teachers Schoolboard members and he said he never really liked it he never felt the need to you know attend attend these meetings but um I I wanted toj our meeting today in his honor because um it was really tough to to not be able to say goodbye to him but um more more than anything I think his passing kind of reminded me of the importance of when we have these meetings to ensure that you know um our ranker and discourse doesn't
182subtract away from our aim of caring for students and that that's one thing I always saw Mr Harris really try try to do in all his actions and you you know he when I'd asked him for advice about things to do in the Schoolboard meeting one thing that always stuck with me was his his constant you know reminder that we can never give up and no matter how tough things are we always have to keep keep going and you know I think it's appropriate and i' like our board if possible to adjourn our meeting today in his honor and reminder of the impact he's made on his students and you know the lessons that I and hopefully our district will continue to take away from this tragedy so sorry but i' I'd like to return
183our meeting today in his a second adjournment in his honor all favor wa