CorpusRecord 169421

SUHSD Board Meeting Dec 18, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Sequoia Union High School District Communications
Date
2024-12-19
Location
San Mateo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,376 words · about 130 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Wednesday December 18th meeting of the governing board of the Sequoia Union High School District um we have some exciting agenda items start off with first of all um swearing in our new trustees but I think before we start with that um can we have public comment for item number two point1 I have uh yes I have two public comment cards in person first is Carrie DUIs away let's go how quickly you forget we can arrange hold on second Laura we'll call Laura Let's uh let's do another random draw okay first up is shaie Stevenson so I'll do it for the two returning people I'm shie Stevenson um it's nice to be on the other end Carrie you can't tell people what to do so we have to do what the genda says so I'll just

002do two right now when she comes I'll I'll repeat it when she gets sworn in um I wanted to just welcome Rich back nice to see you don't look any different um I'm excited that you are back so from Carrie and I I'm giving you a welcome back gift not sure if you want it here you go and then um Dr Maria Elena Cruz you've seen me everywhere so I'm just coming again um just to welcome you to the board um from the from area e as a representative of area e because I live here um and so excited that you are on board I'm excited for the new board and the diversity of the board when I say that um having a student's perspective having a business perspective having a current parent um and

003experienced board member who's been a delegate and so many other things um for board so you have your own board expert on here and having a great superintendent in the cabinet and Leadership and and parents and kids and you'll be bringing um we we it's different being saying you're in education versus you work at a college District so you get to tell tell us what our kids are look like on that end and help us figure out how to get them there because you have the experience of being in the system um and that's a gift within itself but also being a woman of color um and um being married to a born and raised he's Paulo alalon mow Atherton graduate um and so that's really exciting um to to have alumni in so many

004other ways as well as being a parent of the district and welcome um to Maria Beth um I'm excited that you are on board um because you're you're a potential parent because you have a little one that's so cute at home and so you're also creating a district in which you want your child to come to but better more than that like you're an educator um and so we don't have to wonder what educators are thinking we have one at the table so anytime I've done early intervention we always say you bring everyone to the table and you do something cold design um and different perspectives and only way to do that is have different perspectives on the table um and so I will end my statement as saying I look forward to this board

005um and what you guys are going to do um and I'm okay with not being on there because I don't think I was the right person I think Dr Mari Elena Cruz is the right person um for the next stage of our district um and working wonderfully with our superintendent and so many others who work with us um so congratulations welcome to Sequoia Union High School District board it's a lot of colorful things happening on our board and it'll be a great great great great great um roller coaster ride and you'll love it um so thank you all very much and wanted to make sure you all receive it thank you next we have Carrie deah this is so weird being on the other side um here too anyway I'm also here to welcome the

006two new board members um when I decided not to run I had a vision and that Vision was to hand flowers to somebody I would be excited about um and that Vision came true I have strong Vision sometimes so I am really really thrilled that this Vision came came true so welcome um to both of you um when I was thinking about who should take my seat um I knew I couldn't get everything because there's nobody like me and that's not I'm not saying that in a good way it's a it's a weird way there's my husband would agree there's nobody exactly like me but if I could only have one thing I decided I wanted to educat her and it's before I met Mary Beth I am thrilled we have two because I think

007um the most important thing um there's a lot of there's a lot of work work it's a hard job but the most important one of the most important things is to take care of our Educators and that's at the district office it's in the classroom if our educators are well taken care of and all the staff members that support them that is what's best for kids um so I'm thrilled to welcome both of you and I'm going to complete my vision thank you that concludes public comments so next we have um the administration of the Oaths so yeah I think first we'll have our reelect trustee front and center um please please raise your right hand and repeat after me I state your name I Richard gin do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I

008will support and defend that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies against all enemies foreign and domestic foreign and domestic that I will bear that I will bear true faith and Allegiance true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of California and the constitution of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion or purpose of evasion and that it will well and Faithfully and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter discharge the duties upon which

009I'm about to enter congratulations thank [Applause] you uh next is Dr Maria please raise your right hand M after me I Dr Maria E Cruz do oh sorry I Dr Maria E Cruz do swear do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I will support and defend that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of California and the constitution of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation really without

010any mental reservation or purpose of evasion without any meal mental reservation purpose purpose of evasion and that I will well and faithfully and I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter discharge the duties which I'm about to enter congratulations oh my gosh thank you thank [Applause] you and last but definitely not least um please raise your right hand I state your name I am Mary Elizabeth Thompson do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I will support and defend that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance that I will bear

011true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of California and to the constitution of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion without any mental reservation or purpose of invasion and that I will well and Faithfully that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter discharge the duties which I'm upon to about to enter congratulations thank you so now if any of the newly sworn in trustees would like to make any first comments we welcome that I just want to say thank you shanies thank you for the flowers thank you for acknowledging us thank you and thank you for the saring in and

012thank you to my family for being here thank you I just wanted to say that my heart is completely full of gratitude to I wanted to say particularly thank you to my husband and family because their love and wavering support has been my foundation and I wanted to thank my neighbor and former colleagues and the passionate Educators who shape this community thank you for your belief in me and to all who believe in what is possible for every student in our district when we come together with Open Hearts ask what is best for our children roll up on sleeves to do the work this is the journey for all of us and I am so honored to serve and together we can make a difference so thank you so first I like to thank uh

013my family for their understanding and support when my service in this role has impacted us uh since I ran una opposed for this term I did not have a campaign during which I explained how I would Advocate if elected for another four years so I'll take this opportunity to say what I would have said I believe that we should strive for our district schools to be the first choice for All Families in our district this is a stretch goal as we compete with private schools and charter schools and some families will prefer those schools I've heard some people suggest that we should not worry about the competition as there are not additional spots open in them so it's okay if parents and middle school students in our district would prefer their students to attend one

014of our competitors because they can't all get in I disagree with this mindset and will continue to advocate for what I believe will move our district schools in the direction of being the first choice for district families there are two areas of change in recent years that I believe have negatively impacted the Public's perception of our schools I have been advocating to address these and I will continue to do so uh one of them is course options I believe that parents of middle school students prefer to send their students to a high school that offers a broad range of course offerings from which their incoming freshmen can select a path that is right for them versus a school that has more limited options ization our local University Stanford recently selected Jonathan Levan as a new

015president in his inaugural speech he stated the University's purpose is not political action or social justice its purpose is Discovery and learning to create and share knowledge and to prepare students to be curious to think critically to flourish and to contribute to the world I see strong parallels to the SE High School District and what is not the purpose of our district our Northstar is our newly adopted strategic plan on which we should focus our efforts teachers can and should bring their own flare and experience es into classes to augment and supplement curriculum at the same time the district has board policy 6144 about remaining neutral on controversial topics which reads in part in leading or guiding class discussions about issues that may be controversial a teacher may not Advocate their personal opinion or Viewpoint

016the district has had some issues with this in the recent past I support our existing board policy and will continue to advocate for this policy to be followed and enforced the district has had discussions about how certain words should be defined I believe this is a distraction from our focus and that rather than trying to come up with definitions of words that mean different things to different people we should demonstrate commitment to our strategic plan and the promised statement therein all sequan high school students will belong expand the world view through diverse connections and graduate ready to pursue their dreams in addition to seeking to improve course choices and to follow our board policy about controversial topics I'm looking forward to the district's substantial upcoming facility upgrades thanks to our recently approved Bond authorization two

017years ago District voters approved a bond authorization and I'm really glad they did school buildings age and eventually become outdated or in need of renovation schools need to keep operating every year to balance these schools need to rebuild or renovate some portion of their schools every decade or so if school buildings have 80-year lives that means one8 of every school needs to be renovated every 10 years uh and if we do that the schools will continue to be in good shape for our community I appreciate the community support of the bond authorization and the upcoming improvements that will be coming to FR over the next couple years I think we have a great governance team and I'm looking forward to my upcoming years of service as we work together to govern our schools to balance

018competing interests to make judgments and together as a group to best serve our district thank you okay so now we'll take a short break to celebrate our new trustees with members of the audience 2.2 um election of officers um do we have any public comment we have none okay uh I nominate sopic nor to be president okay um do we all in favor or do we have to do a roll call vote trusty again yes trusty Thompson yes truste Cruz yes trusty C yes president norie yes motion thank you before the next one I just want to ask Amy if she's interested in serving as the vice president oh yes so could I get a nomination for the vice president Clerk of the Board of Trustees I name nominate Amy coup for the position could

019I get a second I second um let's do another roll call vote try again yes yes truste Thompson yes truste Cruz yes vice president C yes uh president nor yes motion passed okay much cleaner um the the so the last last agenda um nomination is for the representative to the Sano County committee on School District organization um I served in this role last year I'm happy to do it again um there's not much if anyone else want though they not much agenda items I think I shared with the previous board but they kind of said that they don't foresee any real agenda items it's mainly dealing with District boundary changes or other you know bigger ticket items like that and they don't foresee anything at least on the next two years so is there one

020at least one meeting there's one meeting a year and it just happened so it wouldn't be again until next like early December 2025 I don't think unless something comes up I'm interested to try it out as oh yeah okay then I think you should take it over so um I'll nominate um trusty G we need to vote on the rest I think yeah I think this one no just this one just this one the other ones we don't so I'll nominate um trusty gin to be the representative of Sano County committee on School District organization and I second trusty G yes trusty Thompson yes trusty Cruz yes vice president cou yes president Nory yes motion pass okay um so that's that agenda item then the next agenda item is 2.3 district and community meeting board

021participation list of 2025 so are there any public comments for this agenda item there are none I'm just checking Zoom there are none if not um I think all the trustees should have a list of committees and oh you can you put it on the um oh do you want us to pull up the computers for this I mean if you could put it on the screen [Music] oh is that print out here somewhere is it in the packet it is in yes host is gonna put it on the screen in just one second it's here is it in the I I don't know if I did you print it separate okay I think it's on the screen so we can all follow okay so why don't we go we can go down each one

022and returning board members can share how much of a time commitment it is and the new board members can decide who we want to put on so the first one's the Belmont Redwood Shores District SEO Union High School District 2 by two which I think meets quarterly and before is Trusty du and trusty coup who are on it so I think trusty coup you want to stay on it yeah I'd like to stay on it okay and then and I would like to Poli carry okay so that that works perfectly um next is the budget committee so that was trusty gin and trusty cou and that meets quarterly so I don't know if those two trusty would like to remain yeah I'm I'm good continuing okay um that's great um next is the Meno Park

023District um SEO Union High School District 2 by two this actually didn't meet that often but you never know when it might start up again I'm happy to remain on it because that's a big part of my district I don't know if anyone else is interested in joining yeah I'm interested in joining one okay so trusty Cruz will join with me um next is the 2 by two by two that with the city too it probably makes sense to keep the same too for that one too but that one also rely if ever actually meets unless something comes up so I think we can just keep me and trusty Cruz for that too okay and then next one is the mtss Task Force so that was me and trusty du um I'm happy to come

024off if someone else would want to join I'm happy to join okay how often does that mean that's quarterly the meetings are during the day though that's I think that's the only thing they do occur so if you have topic if you're coming off you need two new people yeah yeah yeah so that's what I was saying I think the meetings are during work hours if that's a problem I'm happy to stay on if no one else has the time to okay so that we that that works it can be I just have a lot of later ones so feel like we need okay so I think that works it around so point of clarification Thompson and then next is the Ravenswood School District 2 by two so I think that met once last year

025so um and both the trustees are new ones I'm happy to be one I don't know if any if trusty Cruz be on that one yes okay so that's twoo and then I think we can keep the same ones for the 2 by two by two unless anyone has any objection um next is a strategic plan implementation committee I don't know if the superintendent has any recommendations for that one so my recommendations for that one is Trusty gin and trusty C oh does that work for the board okay and then oh yeah okay and then next is the wellness advisory committee so this one actually does meet in the evening so it's not um they do meet it's student run or wait actually that might be something else s that's a sustainability committee this one

026um this during during the work day oh okay so um right now it's trusty cou and I don't know if anyone else wants to I've actually never actually never been invited to one so well in that case I can probably join we uh we haven't started I think we start um the first of the year oh okay okay of this of the New Year okay so would trusty Thompson like to I I can do that okay perfect so trustey Thompson trust and vice president coup um ccso we already figured out and then the last two is the Redwood City School District and City Redwood City and SSD 2 by two by two I don't know if that met but I assume trusty again wants to stay those meet frequently and I I should definitely stay

027on Roy together I think that trusty Thompson is up for joining me point of clarification just real quick point of clarification this is the 2 by two by two I think it should be the same for both in my opinion yeah that makes sense okay so the also Redwood City together will be truste gin and trusty Thompson and then the student L sustainability committee um right now it's it was trusty du and trusty C so that one is the one that meets after school or in the evening the student run meets so I don't know if anyone else is interested in joining it is a little bit more of a time commitment then and is primarily Carlmont students and I would say that I I haven't consistently been joining the meetings but it is helpful

028to see the report out if if I I feel bad because I joined it for a bit but I didn't have the time to show up consistently to the meetings so you don't have to and I think it might be fine if we just have one trustee for that too because I think it's more of a leaon role it's not necessarily as much of a bring action or very rarely so if it's just trusty C I think that works too for that one okay and then are there any other board committees we'd like to propose or if if not then I think um could I get a motion to approve the 2025 district and community meeting board participation list I moved I so move um can I get a second a second okay um roll

029call voter just all in favor okay so all in favor I I I okay so that motion carries and then um um next is okay yeah so that's the end so um we'll now um recess to close session before that do we have any public comments for our Clos session agenda items 3.1 through 33 I have none in person and no hands on Zoom so with that um we'll be back at six o'clock thank you welcome back to this meeting of the governing board of seoa Union High School District um we'll now proceed with the Open Session part of our agenda starting with um item 4.1 which is um public protocol just to go over this briefly members of the public who wish to remotely provide comment during the meeting can use the raise hand

030feature during the agenda item they're interested in speakers must raise their hand during agenda item 8.1 the public comment portion of the meeting in order to comment on topics not included on the approved agenda to speak about an item on the agenda in person you can fill out a speaker card and indicate the agenda item and hand that card to Laura at the dis and when the requested agenda item comes before the board the speaker will be called forward so after that we can proceed with item five which is the roll call try Cruz here trusty Thompson here trusty gin here vice president coup here president Nori here the Quorum is present great okay so item number six is approval of the agenda um I have one change after talking about superintendent leech um since

031we have a packed meeting we're thinking of moving um item number 10 to the end of our meeting so that we can proceed with some of the more important agenda items quicker so if there's no objection could I get a motion to approve the agenda with that change the move approval is amended second all in favor I okay so that motion passes um next we have report out of closed session so by a vote of five board members in favor zero against the Board of Trustees approved the settlement agreement for case number 2024 d225 D3 and then by a vote of also five board members in favor zero against the Board of Trustees approved the settlement agreement for case number 2024 d225 D4 okay so next um that's item number seven so next on the

032agenda is item number eight which is public comment so um Laura how many speakers or cards do we have I have two speakers ERS in person and for those who are online please raise your hand now if you'd like to um public comment on any agenda items not on the agenda okay so I think we have five now or do we have another one in person actually three in person now and so six all together three online three in person three online okay so we can either three minutes or switch it down to two so we can be within our time more close Okay so I think we can do two minutes per speaker and we can start with the ones on Zoom start with the ones on Zoom okay we're going to start with

033zoom first first up is Isaac sto if you can unmute yeah yes thank you very much good evening members of the Sequoia Union High School District School Board superintendent leech and community members my name is Isaac sto I am a student at Carlmont High School I'm part of the California youth climate policy leadership program which supports students across California who are advocating for environmental and climate action in their school Community today I am here to introduce an important Integrated Waste Management policy that I believe will help position our district as a leader in environmental sustainability and climate action while benefiting our school students schools and broader Community The Proposal will aim to reduce the school district's generation of waste a which in a goal which aligns with the broader California commitment to environmental stewardship and

034will support our or our District's goal of preparing students for success in College and Career Pathways in addition to being responsible citizens who care for our planet and it not only and it as our environment as globally only 15% of waste is recycled IED and 25% of what ends up in landfill is food waste it food waste which when that decomposes in an anerobic environment it turns into ironment it produces a high amount of methane though one positive amount is thing is that recycling has increased from 10% in 1960 to 32% in 2018 let's make a let's take another step step in addition to the many steps steps are School board has taken that are well appreciated apprciated by our community and we would love to to provide you with a policy with C draft

035at a future meeting thank you all very much thank you next we have Jeremy aray hello can you hear me yes hi me so let me get started um I just wanted to take this time to call out attention to an article in Almanac news.com it's titled former seoa staffers accused District of discrimination and the reporter Jennifer Yoshi Koshi She interviewed at least eight different people and there's more people I think that are coming forward and they talk about the hostile work environment and the Discrimination they faced in this district and I know a number of employees myself including myself who have put forward uniform complaints that were never properly investigated because if they were the evidence is overwhelming and they would have been sustained but somehow all of them come back unsustained and people

036have been to board meetings every month this year and when I look at the board meeting notes there's legal counsil before almost every meeting except in November so there's definitely some issues going on in the district with discrimination and with the way complaints have been handled and the lack of leadership around that um so I wanted to call attention to that article and make sure the community can look at that and also look into how much legal uh how much funds are being spent on legal defenses and also in the article there's a mention of a social media channel called investigating SSD and a website has fraed out of that as well where the district is being looked into so I'd like the community to be aware of that um there's a history of racism

037there's a history of complaints Todd Beal the head of HR hasn't handled those complaints properly or professionally um and he didn't do real investigations and it's kind of an issue when you have five six seven complaints and all of them are referencing similar things and people aren't being interviewed properly or their evidence isn't being looked at properly and they all come back unsustained not everybody could be lying so just look at the legal issues this district is going through and the articles that are coming out and you'll be able to paint uh see the picture that's being painted okay thank you looks like we only have the two now so I'm going to switch to the inperson comments first up is lean strip just to confirm this is for non- agendized items this I think

038it is agendized this is um regarding the um study yeah so this is for a different an item so should I come later yes all right next we have Isabelle Ling okay um hello everyone this is my first time speaking at a school board meeting so I'm very excited I'm Isabelle Ling from carmont high school and I'd first like to give a warm welcome to the newest trustees um I'm very confident you guys will represent our wonderful Bay Area Community well and today me and a couple other students want to talk about something that is really important to us the sustainability in our schools especially having tribin for trash recycling compost in our classrooms in campus environmental responsibility is not just about addressing immediate issues it's about setting a standard and to me it's not

039just trash samon couny already a very sustainable place so I'd like to see our school policies reflect this and if school is a place to learn that I would hope that our sustainable practices of sorting waste will be taught and ingrained in our system like giving easy access for this practice and when paper is one of the largest sources of waste in classrooms but in some Karma classrooms for right now for example there isn't option for recycling let alone compost and so what is this teaching to students like me sorting trash is an excellent way for sustainability and according to project draw down it is maybe the most efficient way to start sustainable policies also make Financial sense which I know you guys are concerned about so according to the National waste Associates waste reduction

040can reduce long-term cost for the district as trustees you guys hold the power to encourage policies like this and it is my greatest hope that we can see these ideas reflected like seeing agenda items for inter implementing triing and campuses um thank you for your time and I'm very excited to see what you guys will do with your term thank you thank you so one of the common cards moved to 14.1 but the hand we lost earlier is now up in Zoom okay this will be the last comment for8 Point item 8.1 Daniel L good even members of the seoa Union High School District School Board superintendent Crystal leech and community members my name is Daniel Levy and I am a student at Carlmont High School I am part of the California youth climate policy

041leadership program which supports students across California who are advocating for environmental and climate action in their school Community I am here to introduce the important Integrated Waste Management uh board policy 351 11.1 that I believe will help position our district as a leader in environmental sustainability and climate action while benefiting our students schools and broader Community the proposed resolution aims to reduce the district's waste management issue this initiative aligns with California's broader commitment to environmental stewardship and climate mitigation and supports our District's mission of preparing students for increased climate awareness and nurturing new leaders who actively advocate for lessening environmental issues the key points supporting the resolution are the lack of an integrated waste management system has led to low sanitary standards regarding the cleaniness of areas such as the school walkways in the SSD

042schools poor Waste Management continues to be a pervasive issue that has had lasting negative effects on the environment by advocating for Integrated Waste Management plans most importantly the incorporation of the tribin system on campus we will be able to address the issue of poor disposal practices in this District in addition each trib bin should come with corresponding labels and image that are large and clear to eliminate any unnecessary confusion this resolution demonstrates our commitment to keeping our schools cleaner and setting an example for other districts across the state thank you for considering this important policy action and for your leadership in advancing opportunities that support our students and Community I hope to be included on a board meeting agenda to discuss this policy more in depth thank you thank you this concludes public comments okay

043so thank you so um item number nine I don't think we have any Board of trustee correspondents and then item number 10 is moved so next is um item number 11 which we haven't had in a while but um we have some new student trustees who I think it'd be great if they could start by introducing themselves and then share whatever comment they might have for the board hi I'm alisandra harwig I'm a junior at Menlo Atherton High School hello everybody my name is Walkin borha I'm a freshman at SEO High School you want me to go first um so I got in touch with some of the organizations around seoa but there doesn't seem to be much that uh many of the organizations want to bring to the DI tonight so I don't have

044any comment and at our Sac meetings I don't think that there's been anything that we want to officially announce here can I just get a thumbs up for finals thank you one more tomorrow and then I'm done okay so great to have you and I'm sure we'll look forward to hearing more from our student trustees and student advisory commissions throughout the year um next after that is item number 12 comments from the sdta and American Federation of State County Municipal Employees um I think we start with sdta um good evening I first want to apologize I was not here at four o'clock for the official swearing in um you things happen and adjust your schedule um but I am very pleased to um welcome both Dr Cruz and um Miss Thompson to the board and

045to congratulate you on your new organization um it has been a difficult year in many ways and um I'm very much looking forward to it being behind us and moving on to a more uh successful and collaborative and uh smooth hopefully 2025 um I wanted to reflect that uh while students were taking finals this week I have been in meetings at the district office working to um get our uh counselors into better uh uh working conditions collaboratively with the district I will be here tomorrow morning working with uh some of our administrators who are with me here tonight to uh update our rubrics for Teacher eval classroom teacher evaluation so they reflect the new standards um there is no rest for the wicked or otherwise I won't cast dispersions on Simone and gay um I'll

046take them for me um and we are I think all very much looking forward to 3:45 on Friday and not hearing from anyone for the next two weeks I also want to really thank everyone in the room for the support that they showed me personally in the last um month and a half I am still not operating at 100% but I will get there hopefully in that new year thank you so much thank you and is there anyone from the American Federation for State okay um if not next is item number 13 the consent agenda so board action to approve the following items is taken simultaneously with one motion which is not debatable and requires a unanimous roll call vote for passage the action indicated on each item is deemed to have been considered in

047full and action taken as worded therein only members of the board and the superintendent May remove items from the consent agenda members of the public May provide comments at the start of the consent agenda item which may convince a board member or the superintendent to remove an item for further discussion so do we have any public comment on the items on the consent agenda there are none and then do any board members want or superintendent want to remove any items from the consent agenda okay if not the motion would be to wave the reading of the consent agenda accept the reports adopt the resolutions and approve other items I move approval of the consent agenda second roll call student truste Bor you can vote okay this is yes or no yes stuna chuste Hartwig yes

048chuste Cruz yes trustee Thompson yes trustee gen yes vice president cou yes president Nori yes motion pass 5 Z great okay so next is um item 14.1 streamlining course offering data analysis prepared for SEO Union High School District by Hanover Research Institute um before we hear the board presentation why don't we start with public comments for this agenda item so if you're on Zoom you can raise your hand and if you're in person you can turn in so I do have two um actually I have yeah I have three in person and it looks like there's two on zoom four in person and two on Zoom okay I'll give it another second because this is your last chance if you don't raise your hand now you won't have an opportunity to comment on this item

049but seeing that so we have six public comments or seven now okay so we have seven people wanting to comment um I'm fine with two minutes for this one or we can also do a minute and a half whatever people prefer okay two is fine so I think we can start which in person or resum whichever one is easier for you just had oh yeah no that was seven that's included yeah yeah seven I have four I have seven yeah okay let's start oh maybe we consider three minutes each because of the meanness of the topic or do you want to stick with the shorter time can B on I'm I'm fine with whatever the board wants I think we did public comment for the regular agenda item for two minutes it might be better

050to keep everything for two minutes but um okay if that's fine with the board I'm also happy to change it if people prefer but okay so let's yeah let's start with zoom okay first up is Sheila can you hear me now yes we can perfect thank you uh thanks for the opportunity to speak um I appreciate it very much as a community member and taxpayer I'd like to strongly encourage the union to get rid of the policy of streamlining the course offerings while I haven't seen an analysis of the 2024 test scores I'd like to know note that there seems to be a relationship and and in fact an inverse relationship between the Casp scores and absenteeism in the schools in fact again the there's an inverse relationship there so the higher the um absenteeism

051the lower the scores uh have been and we've seen that in Sequoia uh we've seen um in uh Menlo Atherton actually uh lower absenteeism and higher uh Casp scores if um given this uh I think that uh a closer look at these statistics are warranted and rather than detracking or staying on the current course I would strongly encourage the board to look at statistics further and also focus on improve on uh making improvements to the attendance rather than taking away uh courses for students thanks for the opportunity thank you next we have concerned [Music] citizen hello hello go ahead great I'm just reading a comment that someone emailed earlier um from a parent group um and this is a parent who had uh four learning disability children um in the district uh the youngest one

052graduated from ma last year and the comment is not providing honors classes for learning disability students is discriminatory the leap to AP and pacing of AP classes is too hard for learning disability kids it is magical thinking that a high achieving child with processing differences can handle the pacing of AP Physics or APM Etc sometimes they can but many times they cannot because I am a person of privilege I was able to pay for my children to go to lydian academy but how many people can truly afford that the district should allow many Pathways for students to qualify to get into uc's in polych state universities by not offering learning disability kids and other honors classes students can't show colleges that they can handle harder classes and can't compete with those students who are taking

053nothing but AP classes you are essentially taking them out of the running I believe not having honors has little to do with the want for all students to Excel or tracking but more to do with funding to have honors course teachers administrators need to create the curriculum this is a tremendous amount of work for the district that is already strapped with the AP um curriculum is offloaded to the College Board they created the content tests and grading scale uh I sorry um the district can Outsource curriculum managing test creating to the college I'm sorry your time was up thank you our last speaker on Zoom is satiz hello can you hear me yes go ahead yes okay uh I just wanted to highlight uh again that Carlmont provides as English one but Ma Woodside and

054seoa do not Carlmont staff wrote a letter staff I mean the chair of social studies the chair of English and a lot of the teachers clearly stating their opposition to removing honors English is foundational we want our public schools to do a great job of teaching our kids math and English hopefully that's not a controversial statement and what we're doing by only providing that in Carlmont is essentially educational redlining you heard some claims of discrimination earlier this to me is appropo here as well um we are only providing as English one in places where the population is predominantly white and Asian at Ma Woodside and seoa that opportunity is simply not available like that's what we're doing that's the reality so I would really appreciate if all five of you could please address this topic

055and if you're going to rely on S as a pretext that in of itself is a problem the p s kids probably need as English one as much as anybody they rely on our public education system to provide these opportunities they they don't have the opportunity to go to lydian or to have all this extra uh help that uh some of these other U districts do uh Mary Beth Thompson you put Facebook ads that said 100% for honors I would like you to clarify that please tonight and did you really mean 100% for honors for white people only or is there something else because I saw those misleading ads and I found them disturbing thank you when I'll shf to the inperson comments I'd like to welcome to the podium lean strub thank you for

056the opportunity to address the board and to welcome our new trustees my intended audience tonight however is broader encompassing the students we teach and their parents my goal is simple I want to remind everyone that teachers entered this profession for just two reasons because we love young people and we love our subject matter five years ago when a group of teachers in my department set out to create Multicultural literature and voice those two motivations were what drove them first they loved their incoming ninth graders and saw that the system we had in place was not advancing their intellectual social and emotional development there is no magic hat to sort students in middle school students were placed in as English one or English one based on an arbitrary Judgment of their potential to succeed and dividing

057students into two tiers imprinted a permanent image on those students Minds in terms of where they belonged academically creating a class in which all students would have the same opportunity to learn and to show their aptitude for Reading Writing and speaking opened the door for students to choose their paths in high school rather than have it chosen for them my hope is that the board recognizes both the impulse to create MV and the success uccess of its implementation in the last few days my seniors who started High School in mclv have been pulling me aside to share joyous News Miss troo I got into NYU Colombia Barnard Harvard their Joy is my joy as I've been privileged to share their academic Journey for a few years we are honored to call teaching our profession sorry

058the time's up thank you next we have Lisa G hello thank you for letting me speak this evening my name is Lisa jangel I am a parent of a seoa high school grad and also have a grader in the district currently so um I am not speaking as a parent this evening now I'm actually speaking as someone with a Masters in Education and 20 plus years working in admissions for a highly selective University I am very concerned about removing honors opportunities streamlining um because I think there are a lot of um unintended impacts that I see on the admission side that others might not have privy um to seeing institutions absolutely look at the academic rigor of courses even from your first year in High School freshman year on they do look at that have

059you pushed yourself have you challenged yourself they're taking a look at that including the uc's look at how hard it is to get into a UC school these days right many students in particular from lower socioeconomic um backgrounds um including a lot of our DACA students really talk about how it was being able to leverage the resources in their public high schools in other public institutions that made the difference for them because they did not have the luxury of additional learning opportunities outside of school or the additional tutoring or maybe taking a summer school class that would allow them to test out of something because they needed to work during the summer to contribute to rent and such for their family and so I really worry um given how the Supreme Court ruled last year

060that there are certain parts of people's identity that we can no longer look at that you're just putting an additional barrier um for students who really want want to prove themselves to change not only their future but also really the trajectory for their families as well and I've seen it now for 20 plus years in Admissions and it does make a difference thank you thank you Rachel Richards good evening my name is Dr Rachel Richards and I've had the privilege of teaching science at men Aon for the past 12 years over this time I have taught Advanced regular and heterogeneous classes in both biology and chemistry and this has given me a broad perspective on how different instructional approaches impact student learning when my department first introduced the idea of heterogeneous classes about eight years

061ago I was skeptical as someone who grew up taking advanced classes I did first believe that separating students by ability was the best way to challenge gifted Learners however my experience in the classroom has changed my perspective completely I have witnessed firsthand how all students regardless of their starting point benefit from learning together in diverse groupings tonight I speak not just for myself but as a voice of many of my colleagues who couldn't be here this evening the majority of us agree that heterogenous classes have been a success and we urge the board to take the time necessary to fully understand this very complex issue I understand why some might feel uneasy about heterogenous classes from the outside it can be difficult to Envision how such classes work in practice but this approach wasn't introduced

062on a whim around a decade ago when the next Generation science standards were implemented science departments like ours began transitioning to a more Hands-On inquiry based project uh driven learning as we aligned our curriculum we realized that the content for regular and advanced classes were largely the same the only real difference was pacing combining these classes into heterogenous groups simply made sense in Project based based learning all students whether they are performing at a high or low level can succeed in meeting the standards Advanced Learners will naturally take their projects to a deeper level while those who need more support can achieve success at their own pace over the years my colleagues have worked tirelessly to design and refine this curriculum and the results speak for themselves our sback scores have improved and our students

063are scoring higher on AP exams I love this community our students sorry your time is up thank you uh next is shaie Stevenson hello everyone that I do not know I am Shaunie Stevenson from East paloalto and an alumni parent of Menlo Atherton um and I say that jokingly I'm not jokingly so I'm supposed to be somewh else right now I am a parent I wanted to thank you all for the report it sounds like we are moving in the right direction um of all children doing well um and still wanting to do more studies around long-term um outcomes um and I just want to continue to think about when I came here when my child from eth grade was assigned to Milo Atherton it was the first courageous decision coming out of East Palo

064Alto and at that time um there were some things that they were trying to undo which is systematic um discrimination and access right and so one of the things that they looked at is you put your money where you value and if you value all kids doing well then you'll support the report and I support that the AP preparation classes especially for children who I am a parent of child with special needs and learning disabilities that you have AP courses not only for kids and Avid andmy but kids who are not in the emies um so and how can we do that more so that we can also get kids access when you think about children um who are have all different types of backgrounds what I have heard directly from students is that the

065AP classes is really what support them but also being able to support them about the culture of college which I'm very excited that we have new board members who have different experiences um and they can share more about what that looks like um the other thing is that I really want to name that mow Aon has been named a couple of times sorry Carl um and nothing against you but I just wonder if there's something there around the culture of the school and the individuals and the adults there um and that maybe that's where we need to start because I do think there's a misunderstanding as I have been in many of the classes there um and see the teachers really sorry the time is up thank you um the last is we had one

066late comment but same item um next up is Linda thank you for squeezing me I appreciate it uh my name is Linda I'm a parent and Community member and I've been involved in this issue for the past two years um I think the top questions this board should be answering related to honors are three-fold first did elimination of honors a aieve its goal of increasing the percentage of underrepresented student groups progressing to subsequent Advanced coursework that's something that we all want sadly the answer to that question is no neither this report nor the staff report last September showed that result second is elimination of honors aligned to the new strategic plan the answer to that question is no the number two signature strategy of the Strategic plan is quote participation in an advanced coursework that's

067the the header participation in advanced cours work expand availability of and enrollment in rigorous coursework with options aligned to student needs interests and Readiness these eliminated courses removed options aligned to student needs interests and Readiness thirdly is elimination of honors what our customers I.E the students and their parents want the answer is no you've received over 1,200 signatures and over 400 comments to that effect the request to restore these eliminated courses was raised by the community over two years ago you now have two non-coal reports showing no results to goal you now have an initiative misaligned to the new strategic plan you still have dissatisfied customers in your students and parents please come up with a better alternative to help underrepresented students thank you thank [Music] you thank you so um after that I think

068we have the actual report so we turn it over Miss Hansen will introduce uh good evening members of the board superintendent leech cabinet principls sdta former board members and community members so we are grateful to all of you for being here tonight Lara Gil your son is adorable um I am really grateful to have this opportunity to make this presentation of a speaker and part of the reason I'm grateful is because last year a report was given on the work that's happened um in streamlining some course offerings primarily in the early years that students are with us before they get to apib level classes and a great deal of work went into that report but it was done by people who are employed by the district so um kudos to Dr Wilmont who has more

069um titles than I can possibly name she is a Northwestern and Cal PhD data Guru um but we really were asked to get another set of eyes on what was happening with streamlining courses some courses in our district and so um as the board approved last spring we hired Handover research and we gave them last year's report we gave them the all of our data and then we gave them an additional year of data as well as anything else that they asked to look at and then we said go nuts and we answered questions when um titles of courses didn't make sense or it was hard to understand something but they really took it and um and gave us an Outsiders lens on how it's going and here after a long flight to give handovers

070research findings to you um both to talk about uh the Val validity of the process used for last year's study um as well as what they found this year as far as areas of achievement and areas of growth um it is my pleasure to introduce to you Dr Matt Roni thank you it's nice to meet everybody thank you for having me um I'm going to use can I control this slide deck okay just arrows or should I just tell you when to arrow down okay got it thank you okay thanks so uh thank you and good evening and um as Bonnie said my name is Matt regon I'm the senior director of K12 content at Handover research um it was uh my team that conducted this study uh and I thank you for your time

071and allowing me to present the findings to you um on their behalf uh this is a lot to present uh I hope it's okay with you if we save questions to the end I'll do my best to address the questions um as my staff isn't here uh or my team isn't here uh some of these questions may have to be uh submitted to them uh for clarification I have think people in the room that could help uh clarify situational contextual questions as well so uh This research project represents uh months of uh work and collaboration uh with seoa staff to collect data and understand very complex uh events that have occurred around core streamlining over these several years uh I want to thank the uh seoa Union High School District staff for their help and

072support to educate my staff my my team on the content of all that uh we needed to study it's not easy to come from an outside situation and understand a very complex situation so the discussions that we've had really have been for them to educate us on on the conditions uh or or the situations that have happened and of course share the data uh sharing the data is technical process as well that um uh that we need clarification on you know what does this data mean what is this data set what is that data set can you provide this clarifications for this uh however I want to um uh stress that Hanover's conclusions and interpretations of the data were not influenced in any way by seoa staff uh they allowed us to be independent um

073third-party objective research team uh that we needed to be uh and that they asked us to do it uh that way um the research questions that you see here are not changed in in substance I edited them for a little bit of grammatical Clarity the the same questions that the 2023 report uh used and it's the same research questions we uh Endeavor to address in our study uh essentially we want to know what changed as a result of streamlining did it create less opportunities for advanced students which is the first research question in brief and did it create more Equitable access for other students which is the second question abbreviated uh in this report we highlight which student groups have been impacted uh and which students uh may still need additional support to take advantage

074of the additional opportunities that were provided by streamlining so our directive was to evaluate the 2023 Sequoia study and to try to replicate that study in order to validate or IND invalidate its results uh the the main report that you all should have that went out has many more details it's a very extensive report and it looks at uh these subjects in uh great detail uh and I won't have time to share all of that with you today uh but tonight I'll take you through this a summary of the full report starting with uh a meth methodological review uh of the 2023 study uh A Brief Review of Hanover's methodological um uh uh process including the data we had available and the limitations of our study the bulk of the presentation I'll go through the

075impacts of streamlining on student outcomes in ela science math and uh AP courses I'll say also when you PDF the presentation it looks a little different some of the it's not going to look as pretty is the one that I'm looking at so so you now okay first the 2023 study so in Hanover's judgment this study was a sound study we did not see methodological problems that would have biased their results in any way uh while all research has some bias mostly int unintentional bias think factors that we have to look at uh seo's research uh strategy eliminated intentional bias uh through careful PL planning starting with uh well- constructed research questions and the use of highquality data in short they really let the data speak for itself specifically we find that examining outcomes of

076high performing students who have uh and they Define High performing student students as three 3.5 GPA or higher which is an appropriate way to define that uh subset of students answers the first question or uh attempts to answer the first first question uh additionally looking at AP and IB exam scores uh course enrollment future course enrollment uh and all the ways that we assess student performance uh that are that are listed here in the bullet points uh are uh important outcomes that we would want to examine to see if students were impacted or Not by streamlining so we thought the data set was uh legitimate and appropriate uh any research study has limit limitations as we probably all know the main limitation of the 202 23 study is pretty much the same limitation that we

077have in in the Handover study and that is it we're not looking at a cause and effect relationship we're looking at a descriptive analysis uh the uh subsequent um uh Handover report is is in the same vein so both are descriptive studies and in that we want to know what is happening we can't necessarily explain why it is happening but both in both the 2023 study and in the Handover study uh this is intended we want to be able to describe the situation so that we can carry out additional research or so that additional research questions May um May reveal themselves and even though we don't intend to show cause and cause and effect the various circumstances in which these changes happened over different times different places uh and situations different schools makes assumptions of

078the impact quite credible because we can see the single change of streamlining taking a course away combining courses happening in several different scenarios so we can look at and make plausible hypotheses uh of cause and effect so one of the ways to do this and one of the things that we suggest as a Handover research team uh we're always looking for additional ways to study the problem so recommend recommendations for future research uh include s I'm trying to work two PowerPoints here so uh there's several additional methods that we can use to study this uh cause and effect relationship a little bit more deeply uh there's propensity score matching there's regression analyses uh that we can control um for which we can control a lot of all the all of the different variables that are

079that could be count uh confounding um the the situations that we're looking at U we want to be able to isolate the streamlining situation and see what the impact is so those two more quantitative data analyses might be uh strategies that you could look at in the future um notably most of what controls a student's success or failure in school happens outside the classroom and most of what happens inside the classroom is determined by the teacher none of these Studies address the 80% of what happens in a kid's life outside the classroom or outside the school and none of it addesses teachers teacher quality these kinds of things should be looked at as future um studies studies that examine those additional variables uh could provide a more clear picture of what's Happening hover also recommen

080recommends continuing descriptive analyses so continuing to describe the situation as it develops and and as it changes over time as uh student outcomes uh uh reveal themselves with uh additional data every year uh that situation should be um should continue to um uh be part of the research um uh sequence further we recommend uh collecting more qualitative data through interviews or focus groups really understanding from the people that are directly involved with what's happening in the schools and in the classrooms is an effective way to round out the research and to complete a picture uh the principles the instructional leaders have a much firmer understanding of what's happening and can help hypothesize about cause and effect about why the data is the way it is uh they can help help with the why part of

081the what we've done which is again just the what so I'm not going to spend a whole lot of time on the data overview this is in the report it's kind of pretty straightforward um but uh these next couple of slides just show you the data that we collected and all the information that we gathered with the help of Sequoia staff it's listed in two different ways and defined um those definitions are important to look at but not really important to dwell on at this point uh hover did uh a few things differently so I'm moving on from the methodology or the or the evaluation of the 2023 report really want to describe uh the differences in in how Hanover approached this uh this analysis we did do a few things differently first of all

082we had another year of data to work with obviously the 2023 uh data didn't have 2024 outcomes or 2023 2024 student outcomes um but these are pretty minimal and what you're seeing there on the screen now the methodology uh have uh really not a lot of significant changes uh with the methodology that we used there's no research um uh there's um again no research study without flaws so we do our best to interpret the data to create key findings and recommendations on the data and on the data alone our research team tried very hard not to include value statements and the narratives of report sometimes that happens just sort of spontaneously and uh subconsciously but we really look at what the data is telling us and and try to report on what the data is

083telling us con contextually it is also important to note that all districts Across the Nation have data showing lower achieving um uh scores student outcomes for certain student for certain groups special education English language Learners socioeconomically disadvantage advantaged students you call them SE uh s here uh and also by race and ethnicity these disparities happen in every District uh we work with hundreds of districts Across the Nation uh and those groups are um uh what we call traditionally marginalized or traditionally uh underperforming uh groups uh otherwise known as the achievement Gap right so the factors that keep these student outcomes lower are beyond the control of most school districts although that doesn't mean that we don't have responsibility to uh to um create factors that that counter U that counteract that that achievement Gap so

084that's the methodology that we're looking at we have some data handling decisions again this is sort of um Technical and really not that significant but it's important to note how we handled some of the data so that's in the main report as well um so I want to get to the EA results and start looking at student outcomes so this is a Chron chronological list of the changes that were made since 2019 so as you can see here seoa first merged uh several English courses into an uh an upper honors track uh the following year they created the English one IAP P course and finally uh an English 2 IAP P course that follows the um uh logical sequence for the students that in the from the previous year menow Atherton created an entirely new

085course uh Multicultural lit uh and voice um out of the As and English IP courses Woodside merged as with uh English IP or English 1p some of these changes uh is is that more students have access to higher levels of learning within those classes theoretically and students in in these classes have more diverse students so what we're looking at here is uh the uh key findings for the grade nine Ela EA courses uh generally what uh Hanover does is develop these key findings from from each school from the data set uh cohorts uh just so everybody understands are single sets of students uh from the same graduate ating class uh whose data were followed to track uh their performance over time uh so from this data we can conclude uh about the impact of the

086changing of courses had on on students who took that class predictably enrollment for S students at seoa and honors uh English um Rose after streamlining so as we're looking at um the SEO high high school results you guys know this but it's in my notes to remind you that because SEO is an IB School not an AP School uh typically when student groups H grow and become more diverse in ability uh that that class that class becomes more diverse in ability we expect those student outcomes to drop um like test scores you know as you expand um uh AP data set for example and include students with with lower abilities of course we expect as uh data matrician that that those student outcomes are going to drop there's just more opportunity for lower scores to

087be included in that data set in sequoia's case credit achievement um pretty much stayed the same and then uh the class of 2023 uh did much better than expected sorry 2025 did much better than expected so even though the data set grows uh we don't see that intend that expected drop in scores uh precipitously sometimes we see nothing uh and sometimes we see slight improvements academic import performance in general uh for grade n students was better post streamlining for white and Hispanic High performers again High performers sometimes referred to as High Flyers are 3.5 GPA and higher uh and better for um at first for Hispanic students but followed by a little bit of a decline um so in grade 10 El Ela courses in seoa high school uh again predictably enrollment for SED and

088Hispanic students Rose sharply uh as opportunities opened up and more than uh what happened in grade nine academic performance improved post streamlining uh the ONG grade level uh students uh earning A's and more students uh earned uh sorry Ong grade level students earned more A's and more students earned uh their B uh B credit requirement in IB English the class of 2025 is notable here for its high achieving uh achievement um above other classes uh remember we're not really sure about why we're just talking about what we see in the data SED versus non-ed enrollment for example is sign significantly different uh but this is not a different this is not a new trend uh it's not different after streamlining um it's it's just something that persists the difference between SED and uh non-ed enrollment

089um and academic success is uh is something that's a theme throughout the report that I'll keep highlighting uh it's important to understand that these as I had said before these gaps existed before streamlining uh academic performance improved over overall more A's and B's in IB English 11 even though the participation went up uh scores on the IB English exam declined a bit but that's because participation increased as as I said that's a factor uh we expect wider distribution of abilities um therefore lower scores failure rates also declined however in IB English year one the hang of this now overall in summary uh sequoi High School enrollment and uh in advanced opportunities Rose sharply for traditionally under represented groups and academic act uh outcomes either were maintained or improved uh there are still challenges with SD

090student performance and opportunities moving on to Menlo Atherton High School in grade9 ela courses uh the new Multicultural lit and voice course included all students who were on grade level or above uh therefore the enrollment of advanced opportunities row sharply for S students post streamlining saw improvements in many uh areas of academic performance all groups improved uh this is notable Ford and Hispanic students uh who we don't see uh in the Improvement category often uh in this report uh but more of them earned the B credit requirement Mano Aon grade 10 not much change here again we're not sure why enrollment Trends didn't change significantly for S students um or uh and grades scores B credit requirement pretty much remained High uh for all students one possible theory is when you get to that high

091level when you're getting to uh you know 95% of the class of 2025 96 and 2026 there's not much room to grow so it could be one theory for the lack of change here Menlo Aon High School grade 11 uh outcomes more than half of English 3p uh is made up of uh s students however streamling shrunk those classes uh as enrollment in AP English row so academic performance here is strong for grade 11 English almost all students met B requirements consistent with historical Trends so we're not sure if streamlining had an impact on that certainly didn't hurt it AP scores increased as well and more grade nine high performance uh High performing students um took AP English comp and more past it's important to note that data is limited for this grade level uh

092as the first class to be impacted um in this uh uh in this particular situation is the class of 2025 five AP English participation exam all of these uh metrics went up for Menlo Aon and AP English again more data needs so this is you know we have a summary slide at at the end of each one uh pretty much repeats the same uh just in summary so I'm not going to dwell on these overall slides in the interest of time uh but just to reiterate the point the more data needs to be collected on Menlo Aon uh but generally all the data is positive positive Trends I should say moving on to uh key findings for Woodside High School grade n Ela courses with streamlining Woodside reversed a trend of declining honors track enrollment

093uh in a race in uh the race and ethnicity pattern of honors students versus non- honors students um those were negative patterns that that uh were different after streamlining most s students um were also non-honors students prior to streamlining post streamlining the same number of grade n students met B requirements but there were less course failures uh and more A's especially for nons white students would Woodside grade 10 English a significant finding here is that Hispanic enrollment in the honors classes increased up by 13 percentage points in one year uh we see some attrition from 9th to 10th grade uh but that's in line with uh historic Trends academic performance is also consistent with historic Trends B credit requirements were met by 81% of advanced students Pass rates on an upward were're on upward Trend

094uh to streamlining prior to streamlining and that Trend continues apparently um not negatively impacting that Trend though overall Woodside J generally positive student outcomes are stable or up post streamlining uh non-ed White students in grade 10 Hispanic students saw the strongest improvements so at the end of every section we have in the final in the big report and in the presentation we have a set of recommendations I want to um preface this first set of recommendations uh to stress that Handover develops these recommendations and all the reports that we do we base it on the data that that we are exploring but we also are adding our own experience as K12 practitioners I myself was a high school principal for 10 years uh before getting my PhD in doing research uh but we also work

095with um and and a lot of my staff have uh K12 uh practical experien as teachers as principles and assistant principles um but we also work with hundreds of school systems Across the Nation and from that we learn a lot uh we learn a lot about Exemplar strategies exemplary strategies uh that we believe as researchers and Educators have the potential to address challenges uh that might be described in in situations like this so kind of keep that in mind as we go through some of these recommendations some of them you know can can kind of feel a little generic um but uh and as researchers all the recommendations include further research so um so the the first recommendations is keep keep studying these situations uh as mentioned earlier the the additional studies that focus on

096on traditionally underrepresented and underperforming student groups um s Hispanic Etc can uh only create a more complete picture if you study those specific student groups in um in specificity um then use the data to drive decisions on how to support those students best practice research is a plethora of best practice research on how to support those uh students in these situations our second recommendation is to continue the path to expand access to higher levels of learning um and add supports for those students uh who are getting uh the benefit of that expansion uh research suggests that providing students with expanding opportunities is the First Essential step um or else they don't have it but you can't just provide them opportunities for for uh higher expectations you have to support those opportunities with with um additional

097resources so increasing access alone doesn't guarantee success for students um who might be new to honors AP or IB courses uh increasing or a bolstering parent and Community engagement is maybe be another good idea as a way to coordinate uh resources uh that can support these students uh sense of belonging uh is also very important uh students who students who don't feel like they belong in an AP or an IB course uh tend not to succeed there uh so creating climates that are welcoming um that make them feel like they along there uh is essential to to this um to this working and then finally implementing uh comprehensive systems of support uh to monitor remediate enhance the learning uh of struggling students is key uh to any Academic Program uh mtss is a really good

098framework to implement at any level at any school all right going on to Science Now science is really difficult um the hisory here's a history of changes for streamlining of science courses science is always uh pretty complicated because it's not as linear as English uh as you know you there's lots of different paths already in science uh so the variety of pass uh and corresponding math requirements uh make the changes and the analysis of these changes very challenging to study so there's lots of situations in this part of the report where I'm going to say we don't really know why but this is what's happening uh the uh context uh at different high schools is particularly important to understand so um admittedly we can't account for all of the contextual factors that are happening in

099every single High School uh so it's important to continue that examination by collecting additional data talking with principles and instructional leaders and teachers and really understanding what's happening and what they think uh is the reason for what is happening so let's start with at carmont with with chemistry so enrollment Trends uh grade 10 uh students are taking chemistry at carmont um in much higher uh levels after streamlining uh it came back down a little bit over time in conjunction with an increase probably in physics enrollment streamlining did not negatively impact D requirement credit uh as students maintain high levels in this area uh throughout the study the number of students getting A's though did increase streamlining also impacted course enrollment on future grades uh in future grade levels not course grades uh so if you

100took chemistry in the 10th grade uh for example you were more likely to take an AP science any AP science course in the 11th grade uh that's post streamlining this is not true for S students however again a theme in this report uh who are more likely to take physics uh P or or no science at all AP science courses uh in um at Carlmont High School as noted in the previous slide there is an a noted increase almost 100 more students are taking AP science courses if they took chemistry in the 10th grade um that's more true so it provides them a a path to AP the additional opportunity uh to take AP environmental science was a contributing factor for this for this rise which apparently didn't take away um enrollment from other AP

101courses at the same time AP course uh Pass rates went up as well um which is a little surprising more than doubling uh the percentage Point increase so we went from 22 to 46% AP chem exam participation um uh 22 to 40 uh 22 to 46% um increase uh in in AP course Pass rates AP cem exam participation uh did go down uh but uh uh Pass rates on that four and five level uh went up AP Bio at um at Carlmont uh in exam participation and Pass rates uh both went up AP environmental science is doing well since its introduction uh post streamlining in these two measures as well the data shows uh that streamlining at carmont carmont has enhanced uh student enrollment and academic performance uh students are more likely to take chemistry

102in grade 10 and do generally uh very well s students performance is still weak however students participate in and perform very well in in AP science uh courses at carmont but again um low s participation persists think I said that twice so sorry uh Atherton uh chemistry so access to chemistry provides additional access to the a through requirements s students benefit from uh s students benefit benefited from this at men Menlo Atherton um streamlining also reversed a large drop in advanced chemistry uh and in environmental chemistry enrollment between 2014 and 2021 a trend that still still exists where uh s students are taking less Advanced courses after streamlining more students are taking chemistry in grade 10 and most are meeting the D requirement also more 10th grade students are getting A's in Geometry Menlo Aon

103AP Chemistry AP course uh AP chem enrollment has increased overall uh but still s students aren't taking it so streamling hasn't hasn't um hasn't reversed that Trend APM uh exam scores for grade 11 students Rose uh since streamlining overall rates did did go down slightly uh but more students more students are taking the exam we need to wait to see how the other course cohorts do in the situation uh but the 20232 24 cohort had more fours and fives on the chem exam uh than in the past six years three are higher uh scores was the highest in the last eight years okay so physics uh Menlo Aon streamlining allowed more students to go from chemistry uh in grade 10 uh to apys physics in uh grade 11 more than half of the students who

104took chem at p as uh oh sorry um KMP as 10th graders went into AP Physics let me say that again because I messed it up more than half of the students who took KMP as 10th graders went into AP Physics previously less than 8% followed this path previous to streamlining this increase included a small number of SE these students um more than before but still pretty small so there's a there is though a slight decline in overall enrollment physics likely because other courses like AP environmental science uh are are now available uh AP pass rates in physics Rose significantly we went from 43 to 91% in five years fours and fives went up 32 to 78% uh physics mechanics stayed even so this all the physics scores really are about AP Physics one I

105should also note sometimes the N size for the students that are taking these classes are are a factor um the the full report will show you the details of that some of those uh some of these Trends especially if there's slight Rises or slight decreases should be taken with a grain of salt nobody should conclude uh anything from a slight rise or a slight um de increase uh again more study more look more looks um at the data need to need to happen uh additional course enrollments at Med Menlo Atherton the data shows shows more students uh going from chem in grade 10 uh to some any AP science course in grade 11 so the impact on AP Bio HP is minimal although a little lower uh but the trade-off is that more students are

106taking AP environmental science so the data shows opportunities for students are increased uh post streamlining and academic performance has improved as well s versus non participation and performance is still a challenge in this area as well so further the uh the path from chemistry uh in grade 10 to any science in grade 11 appears to have um uh the path is appears to have been cleared for many students I'm not sure why that's highlighted there well I know why but it shouldn't be there um seoa chemistry seoa as you know is a little different because they offer IB courses uh their unique situation is a good example of how we might um uh look at this uh study in a different way on on kind of why the data is what it is uh there

107are multiple factors here that provide a a various suggestion for hypothesis so for Sequoia students taking p uh chemistry p in grade 10 increased sharply as expected uh and decreased in biology enrollment in physics p uh went up slightly as well streamlining did not appear to change the trends that have uh that have S students taking fewer Advanced courses uh like biology um but the data shows credit achievement for for the D requirement has taken a small downturn getting a c or better in chemistry for 10th graders is down by about 11 percentage points again the study doesn't explain why however there appears to be some siphoning off of these students in this particular situation who might otherwise be getting that credit somewhere else uh there is some evidence for this because 10th graders are

108are taking um physics uh or biology so post post streamlining uh we also see uh high performance students in this situation earning A's uh in grade 10 almost every student earned at least uh a b post streamlining of the high performing um data set so uh in Sequoia grade 11 science enrollment uh the uh more students are taking science in grade 11 uh they seem to be taking IB environmental uh systems instead of IB Biology this was also an increase in the there was also an increase in the percentage of s students taking biology p in grade 11 and chemistry in grade 10 uh this is uh this is probably due to repeaters overall at AOA the addition of opportunities provide students uh the uh provided to students are shifting enrollment patterns uh these shifts

109uh need to be studied more the impact on the the academic achievement is not necessarily negative for example we see we see fewer 10th grade students getting that D physical science credit from chemistry but it's possible they're getting that requirement somewhere else so generally it appears that they act performance is still strong as Mo as most uh every High performing student has at least a be in science uh as with most of the trends that we've seen um in this study so far s students seem to be reluctant to try uh an advanced course so uh districtwide so this is a summary of of uh all that's happening districtwide opportunities at um uh seoa School District uh uh to take science and meet those D requirements as early as grade nine is significant uh almost

110all grade n students have been enrolled in a d requirement course uh for the last four years uh of those not taking a science uh in grade nine most are SED students uh this was uh the trend prior to streamlining improved academic performance uh is also evident in that most uh of the cords have had the highest past course rates and the same or better rates of C or better the latter gives those students the first uh year D requirement of particular note prior to streamlining s students were more likely to enroll in a nonre non non D requirement course so regardless of their performance they now have that opportunity um to satisfy that requirement uh in grade nine um that they didn't have a the grade n science uh uh data also shows increases

111in uh SED participation in D requirement classes uh did not result in lower academic performance so um uh on the contrary the the percentage of students meeting D requirements for Life Sciences uh in earning A's were much more improved uh not just with SD but with the whole data set so when you look at um the lower and the higher ends of the grading scale it's also significant uh there are significant improvements as well there were fewer failing grades uh in grade n science uh fewer than any other year measured uh and there were also more A's for both s and non-ed students so at both ends of the the grading scale so notably the uh District uh eliminated AIS more s students are meeting the d d requirements overall because so districtwide in AP

112and I uh biology uh we're looking at uh increased enrollment over time but this is already started this was this trend was already started before streamlining um as discussed the IB bio enrollment uh is down a bit but probably not because of streamlining uh Instead This is likely because uh students are taking IB IB environmental science um and uh still s students are not taking AP or IB in large numbers the data shows the streamlining did not negatively impact AP Bio course grades uh as those scores improved after grade nine streamlining and upper class grades 11 and 12 uh earned more A's in AP biology ology AP biology exam participation declined uh but scores improved uh this is typical because it reflects the smaller more skilled data set and ab uh IB exam scores are

113down a little bit over over three years again the study does not conclude why uh but a notable pattern to explore um in the future two core two corts impacted by streamlining grade nine science both had of the two core horts impacted by streamlining grade n science both had higher AP Bio exam scores as compared to the six previous cohorts so overall District overall is that where I am uh the data the data shows that streamlining uh grade n science uh the district likely um uh likely led to improvements in science academic performance both in enrollment and Achieve and in achievement um those metrics are both up as noted earlier almost all grade N stence grade n students have had the opportunity to enroll in a course that gives them the de credit uh and

114it's also um notable that this is a rare instance where the SE students uh had higher Pass rates uh and meeting D requirements for life science something that's working for the S students so again uh our recommendations similar to uh to the English recommendations we're we're looking at the next sort of logical step in opening up uh after opening up opportunities is to uh engage the students in higher levels of learning um uh with support uh and uh enhanced differentiated instruction uh that can lead to even higher exam scores or to um better exam stores in the S situation so again what we want to stress is to keep studying each particular situation uh by school by course and by student groups uh the technical nature of science makes it really even more imperative to

115start students early so one of our recommendations is to partner with the middle schools uh and in preparing uh students for building this this particular skill set and the knowledge base that they that they need to be successful at the high school level Partnerships with um the middle school is probably a little bit harder in your District than it is in regular K12 12 District but it's just as important um promoting diverse science course offerings and ensuring they all satisfy the D requirement is also vital a diverse science curriculum um can offer students with many different career paths uh and build on their uh existing interests also similar to our requirements for English creating welcoming climates uh for students to take Advanced courses uh like IB and and AP um they have to feel like

116they belong there this is critical for students who have traditionally been closed off from these opportunities okay I'm going to move on to math I'm going to try to pick up the pace a little bit because I know it's been a long um is it okay so the right there it is so the math courses were streamlined in The District in 2020 2021 to create more div diverse student groups in these classes so uh all the schools merged Al Readiness with algebra 1 um algebra Readiness did not count for the C Credit uh so opportunities for the SE credits going to rise here in this data set uh analysis for math is much shorter because all the changes took place kind of all at once at all all at the same time um so the

117only the first and only impacted cohort is the class of 2024 so you could probably guess what one of our recommendations is going to be which is to keep studying this this um this change a key difference between the Handover study and sequoia's 2023 report is that Handover included uh additional data here in this situation with grade 10 courses so all the courses that you see on the right side of this graph or this chart um we studied we studied those additional courses so our data sets a little bit bigger this me doesn't really Chang the analysis or the conclusions of either rep of of the 2023 report it's just one more thing to look at it adds a different level of analysis and addition uh additional uh condition to describe so when we're looking

118at math findings we want to look at um uh first and and this is not by school because it's uh because it's um a districtwide uh condition that we're trying to describe um the lowest level of algebra uh below algebra or Readiness algebra was removed it stands to reason that more grade nine students are taking algebra right so and that in fact did happened 56 to 60% of all grade nine students are now taking or uh were taking in this data set algebra one the change had an impact on grade nine students taking geometry as well um it went up to 31% um of grade nine students who took uh geometry um uh sorry 31% of those nth grade students that took geometry so or taking geometry and Algebra 2 two trig is also up

119uh so those same students um uh 14% um uh that that Algebra 2 trig course enrollment went up 14% which is the highest percentage since 2018 pre-cal and above also saw High enrollment numbers uh in the most recent cohort so the data is showing that more s students are taking ODS one and geometry and Algebra 2 uh in grade nine um uh for that grade nine um group so SC students are taking higher levels of math um is the highest uh since 2014 2015 so the opportunities are there so so let's talk about the performance along with the increased opportunities for all students to take higher levels of math uh academic performance seems to be increasing as well so after the initial increase um in fail rates so there's a little spike in fail rates

120uh initially fail rates over time uh for Algebra 1 for those grade nine students algebra one is the lowest uh for the affected cohort which is the class of 2024 so this includes drop um in s student failures as well the one thing to look at is what's happening there why did they go up and then they go down so we want to look at grade 10 math enrollment as well algebra retakes are important um it's an important factor uh to look at because we uh they often act as a prerequisite for other courses science courses in particular so post streamlining only 16 to 18% of grade n Algebra 1 students had to retake the course this is way down from 32% pre- streamlining so in two which um uh the 32% is from a

121specific Year from 2014 so students are also moving on to Geometry at a higher rate so enrollment in grade 10 is uh in grade 10 um geometry is up to 65% SD students have to retake algebra 1 of um more than non students there are more s students taking no math as well than non student than S students so the other significant finding is that more students are getting to Algebra 2 quicker so in the class of 2026 uh grade 10 Algebra 2 students is highest among other cohorts uh but only for non-ed students there's a quick note there at the bottom that uh just reminds people that we're not literally looking at um a typical pattern when you go from Algebra 1 to Algebra 2 there are other things there's a geometry in there

122so there's other things that are um that are uh creating a situation where students can jump either it's a remedial program or maybe there are students coming from outside the district and they got their geometry credit somewhere else so the data shows that math streamlining did not appear to impact C requirements the percentage of students meeting requirements has been relatively stable since 2015 uh there's uh there continues to be a gap uh between non SED and uh and S students meeting this requirement with more students enrolling in Algebra 1 and grade nine opportunities to meet C requirements increases however so it's too early to see the impact of the the streamlining uh here because the students who start grade n in Geometry or higher are most likely to meet C requirements IB and AP math

123post streamlining more students enroll in AP and IB math courses uh it's notable that this is for S and non students s student enrollment AP and IB uh in fact R faster than the non-ed enrollment um of course the non SED enrollment was already pretty high so there's no really no where to go for them so when the non when the SED students are enrolling it's always going to be faster the important thing is that the Gap is closing here though so uh in the class of 2024 the first and only class to be impacted by this streamlining uh uh took more AP exams uh across uh the AP high schools and more IB exams were taken at Sequoia uh as we said typically we see scores drop as population mixed uh mixability Rises this

124didn't happen here Pass rates were fairly stable even Rising a little bit uh to 30% of the class of classic 20 2024 at the same time IB maath uh scores uh rebounded for the class of 2024 after declining the previous two years so our recommendations for for math streamlining uh in this situation continued study of the math streamlining is really important here because there's only been really one cohort to be impacted additionally similar uh to science and English Hanover suggests that uh implementing or enhancing existing support for sad students in math remedial enrichment opportunities uh will uh help continue to lower failure rates for these students again we suggest enhanced Partnerships with middle schools and creating more diverse Pathways in the math curriculum that can provide students uh with even more opportunities to take courses

125like pre-calculate uh pre-cal or hire examining the impact of prerequisites um might be a useful exercise often prerequisites uh put barriers kind of like blanket barriers on students uh and that leaves a lot of students that might have abilities that uh uh and ready to take these higher level classes um albeit with more support but it kind of leaves them out um those blanket prerequisites um is you know we understand why we have them we don't want to set students up for failure uh but to have a blanket prerequisite is sort of like those barrier tests that we used to have uh for APS so something to look at okay the last section we wanted to look at um uh take a closer look at the AP scores as reported by college board uh to

126add some perspective uh on the student achievement here the report gives uh the College Board um U findings in in pretty good detail uh I wanted to highlight uh two ways to compare this a national comparison and an annual comparison just for some perspective so soqu high school district uh consistently outperforms districts I don't know if you guys know that I'm sure you do um Across the Nation in most important English math I mean some of the the toughest courses that that the College Board gives out you guys pretty much rock it so um for example AP Cal AB uh scores are 23 percentage points higher um on that test than the national average AP English Language and comp exam scores Higher by 35 percentage points um 38 for physics um for physics one uh

127so also in 2020 um Menlo Aon call woodside's course enrollment has increased um as well so the the data sets and there's a there's a compar comparison there's a national data set chart in the final report that's pretty interesting that shows you course by course how you guys are doing by national comparison so um recommendations here should probably be keep doing what you're doing right um with ap and AP and IB prep uh it's got to be working to some extent however keep in mind more students Avail themselves of these opportunities more supports are going to have to come online so uh the skill levels become more diverse uh bolstering preparation um with like Bridge programs or summer programs uh have to be more important part of the plan moving forward uh because you can't

128just open up the opportunities you have to provide the support So further aligning the course curriculum to students interests and possible career paths could be something to take a look at in terms of AP and IB course enrollment um it makes it more meaningful student for students when they see that the IB course or the AP course is attached to something that they're interested in or to some to some career that they want to do yeah nobody ever told me what calculus was for when I was taking calculus which is probably why I did pretty badly in it and became a history teacher so having that understanding that context uh is really important I did see what I did I just blamed my my teachers for that um targeted Support also has uh proven track

129record so uh addressing any disparities uh in AP uh exam Pass rates uh among student groups courses or course uh or schools really targeting those those um specific student groups or specific situations uh those strategies including mentorship programs peer study groups practice tests regular review sessions for each course in each grade level uh is vital to to um uh closing those achievement gaps in these higher level courses often we call this the Excellence Gap uh more students um of white and Asian um ethnicities and races uh Avail themselves of these opportunities uh and uh other races are um feel like they don't belong in that um so uh again and that sense of belonging is is another factor to take a look at educator collaboration is also really something that is probably happening uh based

130on your scores but something to always uh remind ourselves as an important factor because AP uh teaching strategies can be unique and that coordination and collaboration of these supports um are proven strategies uh to help um uh AP scores across the board not just not just with the you know the greatest AP History teacher so um sharing those understandings is important so that's the presentation I want to go back to um uh our research questions and uh address that real quick to make sure that you all know that we've addressed them so did changes in course offerings in which more diverse student groups learn together create less opportunities for advanced students uh to succeed in that course and Future higher level courses um we do not find that these changes um uh created less opportunity

131uh we um find that opportunity is opened up for all students um and that uh success in those classes um was certainly not hurt by uh by the streamlining of courses did changes in course offerings in which more diverse student groups learn together create more Equitable access for students who historically have had barriers to accessing courses this clearly is the case especially when you look at the a through G requirements they have more opportunities to Avail themselves of those requirements and it is clearly the opportunity for them to uh be part of those mixed groupings um and Avail themselves within those classes uh of higher um uh uh higher opportunities to learn with higher expectations um there are certain situations that we need to continue to look at some some of the data um begs

132more questions uh so uh my final plug for additional research um can conclude this report so thank you for your time one questions thank you um I think I'll turn it to our board now for questions so who wants to go first order perhaps Le I'll start with a few questions um what does uh more Equitable access mean so I mean in this situation we're looking at uh eliminating barriers to choice so availing uh allowing students to Avail themselves of whatever courses that they want to take was what what I heard over and over again was that the as soon as there was differentiated offerings the S uh percentage of s students or number of s students taking the harder of the two options was unchanged from prior to the streamlining which sounds to me

133like there was no change but yet you're answering yes to the question um so to me that's if the number of SED students taking the higher level class once there is one is unchanged it seems to me that there was no change in the access so I'm wondering if you could I see clear that up so yeah I I I guess the the situation to look at is what's happening within that within that choice so looking at um heterogeneous grouping mixed ability grouping is the access um with in that classroom um Can s students Avail themselves of those higher expectations within that classroom right so clearly the the S student Gap non s student Gap is is still there right when they make that choice to take that class or you uh kind of force

134that that grouping to happen um you give them the opportunity to do that but the results aren't there yet in every situation does that clear that up maybe I mean I sort of understood the effort the initia the purpose behind this whole initiative was to increase the number of SED students taking the advanced classes in the later years my understanding of the results is that that simply has not happened not in every situation right at all in any what I understand so I'm just kind of so it seems to me that the answer to question is no but yet you're answering it yes so I just want to clear up because I hear that a lot that the objective was to get more underrepresented student groups into AP and IB courses that was definitely an

135objective and we definitely have not arrived in any sort of a meaningful way there were other objectives that was not the only objective there was also the objective of more students meeting UCA through G requirements and more student students passing classes and we have met those objectives even if our only objective had been to get more students into AP and IB classes which it was not that was one of the hopes but it was only one of them just targeting you didn't get very many more kids who are socioeconomically disadvantaged taking apib classes and ignoring the fact that we have more kids meeting UCA through requirements and getting good grades in UCA through G classes without harming the results of students who were in higher level classes before is like saying I stopped eating bread

136because I had diabetes and it didn't hurt it didn't make my diabetes any better when I stopped eating bread and it didn't make my diabetes any worse when I stopped eating bread but I lost 40 pounds but because my diabetes is no better I'm going to go back to eating bread even though these other fabulous things happened again I want to say one of the objectives was to get students more students represented by our demographics in AP through IB classes but it was only one of the targets but even if it had been the only target I think that the rise in a through G and in uh graduation meaning graduation requirements without harming students who were doing well before um is is more important um so I actually had a follow on on that

137one um in terms of um more s students taking honors or Advanced tracks um are is there research on you know if if students were placed automatically based on objective criteria area in the advanced class and had to opt out instead of opting in um would that help to close because I think the opportunity may be there for them but they may be reluctant to sign up for some of these classes so is an opt out approach something that you've researched yeah that's a fascinating question I haven't come across any research around opt out or opin um choices and how they might impact those situations um not that that it doesn't exist um but we haven't looked at any of that just to add on and I might be wrong but I think we have

138tried stuff like that before at our district and I don't know if it's actually been that [Music] successful I think uh are you shaking your head when um I think we need to look into that I don't remember ever having done that but I don't it doesn't mean we haven't I just don't remember it [Music] um I had an additional question too uh which was General um is there because you're looking at uh trying to identify confounding factors as a future research item and I was always wondering like how often are students utilizing outside organizations to supplement their public education learning whether it's tutoring extra classes College counselors just whatever resource and are they private services or are they free community services um so I I don't know how you might recommend approaching that because

139when we try and figure that out it seems daunting yeah I we have some research and I share with the with staff about uh creating Community Partnerships we've done a lot of research on that collecting best practices for those kinds of Endeavors so um I can share that with with staff and they can pass it along to you all um you know some of the the um Common Sense kind of things uh that come out in these reports are uh not always applicable um to your context so um they they may or may not apply uh but it's certainly a starting something to think about um my reference to community one of the recommendations with Community Partnerships and parent programs is really to get more resources not to actually do uh the remediation or the

140um uh enrichment programs but those um those relationships that you build uh can help um create opportunities for for additional funding or additional resources or different uh you know volunteer opportunities those are the kinds of things um that you might uh consider um adding to that list of things that that can help students um get remediation and enrichment I guess um as a clarification to that question U one one of my concerns is whether there are families who try are trying to pay for additional support um and does that lead to inequity in our classrooms right because um if that is happening I would want to see more of that support be incorporated into the school day yeah I think you know research will tell you also parents and communities of of means have more

141opportunities to um get their students uh higher levels of learning early on too right we had a speaker up here tonight talking about um how she was able to do uh different things with her students to get them uh what they need and that school the school district um and we see this not on you guys but school districts can't possibly um uh provide at that level so providing um additional levels of support uh in from the districts uh is you know debatable about whether you all take on that responsibility to to close the gap in that way so you're G to match that with uh District resources the districts that we work with um most of them don't have the funding to do that so it's uh cost prohibitive but there are strategies that

142you can work with again those Community Partnerships getting the resources getting uh different um uh ways to to um uh you know grant funding and things like that can can mitigate I don't know does that help does that answer your question somewhat um May I'll ask one more question and I'll let other people ask um so another question that I had was if there's this um increase in the number of students that are taking Algebra 2 after taking Algebra 1 in nth grade my assumption is they must be getting geometry over the summer do we do we see that I think so I you know we'd have to look at um uh at the data specifically uh our assumption is that they um they could be students that are coming in uh with a geometry

143credit either from um like transfer students or they're getting their geometry somewhere else it's you know within the district so they're doing the summer program or they're you know doing an after school program that gets on that credit but I I would probably throw it to you guys to see if you know um any specific situations like that um you need to come to the podium you know how students are getting geometry going from Algebra 1 to Algebra 2 from freshman to sophore year you have ideas so at Woodside High School yes we do offer a summer uh geometry course it is compacted um it's popular but it is um something that we are able to fund through the funding of our foundation ditto for seoa [Music] we we do not um offer a summer

144course but we do um know that several families um to speak to your point um trusty coup uh will take uh geometry through concurrent enrollment um through an outside um organization and pay for it that way and then jump to Algebra 2 so I'm happy to go next unless another I can go so learning the mic system um so I'm looking at your questions again particularly this first one um where when student groups learn together create less opportunity would they create less opportunity and then I'm looking at the college board results and I'm just curious because you have the um advantage of working with lots of different districts not that it's a competition but is are these normal results that you're seeing because this to me seems pretty fantastic that all of our students are

145scoring as high as they are and these AP and IB advanced classes or exams um I mean I can only tell you anecdotally but yeah all data counts no we don't we don't work with a lot of districts like you guys so um so no I'm not really used to saying stuff like that I think um also uh the do you guys do Pisa or uh the Pisa test you know what that is uh it's an international test and one of the things that it did the high school that I was at participated in p and we were a high very very rich zip code um and our 95% of our students were white you know we were a mile away from the CIA I mean it was just crazy and we did pza and

146we actually scored low even though our AP scores were huge comparative to the district because our socio economic status is is included in the Pisa analysis so if you look at your socioeconomic status you should be expected to be here and there's a you know a correlation line as your socioeconomic status goes up your your score should should go up I'd be curious to know where you are on that line so something to think about I just had a question about the grading like how did you account for the grading or grading scales for each school you know in regards to the grading scale grading policies in the past two years all classes like AP like math English did do account for the grading each school has different grading scenarios right so how did you

147account for the grading that's I'm just curious did you look at the grading the data we got was directly from the school district so whatever graded grades you guys reported is with the grades that we that we analyzed okay so if a if a you know a school you know gives us their a through f for each of the students that's how we that's what we took and the other question was um I know that the College Board recalibrated their numbers and how did you guys account for that in the past two years we didn't analyze the College Board data we just reported it okay so there is in the data in the report um I think an asterisk that shows the that that explanation because they did they did redefine they red the yeah

148so I was wondering how that factored in yeah thank you I'm happy to go last um I just had a quick um couple questions one was I even wondered about the last report too but both good or bad how confidently can you say that the changes we saw in performance were related to any changes we made versus just random you know High variations year by year yeah great question I mean I you know we didn't we didn't apply confidence levels to our research this again this is just a descriptive study so we're telling you what we see we're telling you we're telling you what the data says we're not showing cause and effect we cannot say that so the confidence of of the impact of streamlining is is low until you look at the other

149until you look at other studies but I will say I don't I don't know this is my my judgment it's you know it as a researcher it's it's low but anecdotally what I said at the outset when you look at this situation in so many different ways in so many different situations and contexts you can make pretty uh confident conclusion about um or at least hypotheses about what's happening and why it's happening but again I would look to the to the schools and uh get those contextual information th those contextual situations clarified because there are things that are going on in the data set that we're just not sure about not that many but there are a couple um that you'll want more information about okay and then I guess the kind of last question

150to wrap it up I saw some of your recommendations I wonder if they're just a little like vague I wonder like specifically related to this issue because this is something we've tried to deal with for a long time especially around representation in higher level honors and AP courses do you have any specific recommendations or um we could look at that for for staff we can go into those recommendations and and go a little deeper we do make our recommendations I mean like I said before they're a little generic um but we do that because we don't know we don't claim to know everything that's going on in your District or in your schools so you know to say uh you know one of these recommendations you know keep studying the problem or um get more

151uh remedial support for your s students you know those are generic um and basic but we want to we would be remiss if we didn't make those sort of basic recommendations because you got to start there um if districts and districts do do this with us they want more extensive recommendations and really more specific analysis of what they're doing and if they're doing if they're following best practices we can do that as well and align those recommendations to your existing best practices and make recommendations to further those but just to push it a little further is so we'd set aside these changes and say you know regardless of their Merit on other issues if it hasn't had an effect on increasing representation in AP courses is there something else that you recommend doing more like

152a specific thing that you say might actually lead to a change versus what we're doing right now or you just don't know right no I wouldn't again the cont context of your I mean as much as we know from this study of what you do and how you do it um I I wouldn't put myself in the position for making that decision for you guys I would say research will tell you the first step to closing achievement gaps closing Excellence gaps is opening up opportunities we did away with barrier tests in AP where I live in my district and I think over Across the Nation you know if you look at the H Escalante situ ation you know that he he said all you need is the will to do the work to the students

153right all you need is the will you don't need a test you you need to work hard I mean and he worked his kids hard and he worked himself to a heart attack so I mean th that's what you need to to to uh to eliminate the gaps is to first open up the opportunities after that comes how you do how do you support those kids to actually achieve in those with those high expectations without working yourself to a heart attack so you know that's a separate problem you have more questions oh you're gonna let it go I actually had a few more I just didn't want to ask all um I I did also um would be interested in if you break down um the Asian grouping into the subgrouping to see if there

154are any um ethnicities within the Asian umbrella that might be overlooked do we have access to the subp that's an interesting question it would depend on what how you collect your data yeah I don't know if it's broken down that way I mean most of it self-reported right so it's whatever you check on a form you don't have nationality okay um and then my other question was um I think for grade nine students that are starting with pre-cal or hire are are they taking advanced classes outside of the Standard Middle School curriculum because I'm not aware of any middle schools that offer higher than geometry well at my middle school they offered algebra too oh did they okay I mean very few people to I didn't take it but like very few but there I'm

155just curious because that seems a little I'll say it for you if you throw it out are you can you repeat the question oh for ninth graders who are um taking pre-cal or higher like where are they taking classes because I'm not aware of middle school is really offering that level of middle school math I can't speak for other high schools but at Carlmont we do have a small population of students who are in nth grade who will take uh Algebra 2 trig or pre-cal at the 9th grade level and it it is not necessarily offered at the middle schools that they're matriculating out of but those are families who have found ways to access other coursework for their students um as we discussed earlier seeming a few people made those points that some families

156can can find those resources within our community and then just one final comment I I feel like one of the benefits that I saw out of the science data was that uh non-ed students were actually benefiting quite a bit from the streamlining and I I I think my hypothesis is that maybe people who are uncertain about their um abilities in science or or maybe weren't sure if they liked it or not after they were given that opportunity to learn together with people who were really confident or really loved it that kind of brought everyone up together I don't I don't know yeah it's a great hypothesis okay yeah again we're not looking at cause effect but that's that's where you start you say okay I wonder why this is happening maybe it's that maybe it's

157the the the you know the kids that traditionally have distinguished themselves in AP courses see another level because now they have to distinguish themselves even further right they want to distinguish themselves so maybe there's another level for them too that's one hypothesis as well again that's not is not telling me that it's just a guess and then the last question I had as I noticed one of your recommendations about um increasing support or availability of AP courses I wonder if you could like um more specify kind of what you meant or like tied to like specifics about what you think we should do increasing courses or supports the which which recommendation are you referring to I think it was near the end a pretty similar so I could probably find it so you mentioned expand

158AB prep programs an increase access to AP courses growing demand offering choosing sections um introducing new AP subjects that align with student interest and career aspirations yeah so those are again um pretty typical recommendations that we would make with districts that want to expand um uh uh diversifying instruction within AP um courses so how do you get how do you get that extra levels of support you you've got to go kind of outside the classroom um and provide additional opportunities to do it I can probably work on more specific recommendations for you as I've said sorry just one more thing kind of I was like curious though like is there anything that comes to mind like specific AP courses that might be missing you think or that we should be or specific like because when

159you say like increase availability or course offer like is there something that you saw that you're were like oh no nothing specific I know no we're looking at when we making again when we make these recommendations we're looking at that things that that the research tells us are good for most districts I think what would be interesting is for and I'm sure a lot of our principles have this and we can bring this back at a at a future meeting is to really understand the classes that our students are taking outside the district to generate potential in you know the um desire to take them at your actual school if you are choosing to take a class as a single du credit um we could look at that and use that to kind of uh

160guide us as we choose to increase AP offerings yeah choose different courses no I agree because I think one that comes to the top of my mind that I know a lot of people take outside of school is APG and AP con and that's something that some of our schools offer but others just schools don't [Music] so about IB middle the middle schools offer IB Middle year programs I think one of our districts does right I mean do your middle school feeders do they yeah those those types of prep programs I think would be the way I mean you know you start other research will tell you situations or kids are selected by the third grade right into a track so getting kids early Partnerships with middle schools Partnerships with elementary schools that's what you

161need to to build build the pool build the pipeline when we were reviewing some of um these data sets in some areas of the reports over the last couple of months and I want to say even um last year as we were prepping for the study sessions I know I specific Al had this conversation with [Music] Carl um about students um who you know choose not to self- elect into the higher the higher classes and um what's what's interesting to me is that like I know what you had um mentioned president Nori about potentially us trying that before and it not producing the results my speculation is that if we did try it we tried it before we streamlined courses and so I wonder if our s s students who are um doing better in

162their later years would see themselves doing better in those courses if we did you know place them in there and and then do the opt out method so I think that it if we are able to show that we did it before my question to staff would be did it we do it before we move to streamlining because the data shows that our s students are performing better and meeting more adg requirements so the grades are there the capacity is there as our presenter said I believe the will is there we need to give them addition that additional nudge to really make what we started see it across the finish line so we have this school called tide Academy tide Academy where we opt students into dual credit college classes they have to opt out

163it could be a little experiment to see right we have some success more so with subjects depending but because they're opted in and then have to withdraw from the college course if they don't succeed we have had huge success 97.4 college career Readiness rate two graduating classes that have done remarkably well overall um so I just wonder if there's some value in looking at how we support students to right opt whatever we call it I don't know opt in opt out I get it all mixed up but um to support them like we're going to schedule you in and right support you you and yes okay if you withdraw from the college por portion of the class you still get the a through G credit right um but you're still learning the same things that

164the students who are opting for the college credit are so I just wonder and I would love to see this is my plug let's start also promoting all the college credits our students are earning right because it's not just tide it's across our school district right with dual credit and single credit and all of that and that is on the map and the radar and it is the thing that everybody is looking towards so I just wanted to mention that is one model right that we could look to and I don't think that um we know that that we're the students are not self- electing at Ma and at woodde but I believe um in the Sequoia data where the kids are being put into all students are taking IB like the grades are the

165are there I mean we all struggle at times but the data is there showing the success in that with those graduates each year I wanted to piggyback on what Simone mentioned um we've got to really expand our understanding of the College and Career indicators the CCIS and that's a whole list of eight to 10 indicators she just talked about the dual enrollment I think as a district we're behind on the dual enrollment conversation we have we yes we have AP courses and kids can earn um college credit that way but we we can also do more with our dual enrollment options and so Woodside is in its second year with offering US history with kinata college and dual enrolled um history credits and we're planning on bringing in a senior level um econ goov next

166year um but the fit has to be right but anyway the conversation needs to expand beyond the college boards offerings of the AP program yes it's probably the sexiest thing that people are aware of but earning dual High School Credit as well as college credit and competing with other students in that manner is um a really valuable and high ticket you know it it puts our kids into competition so wanted to put a plug up for that I also wanted to mention I think Amy C trusty cou you had asked something about um how are kids somebody asked about um enrollment in more AP programs or AP classes something that's important for us at Woodside is offering a variety of AP classes that ninth graders can access 10th graders can access so that could be

167the AP compai um the entry level it's a novice computer science program class you don't have to have any coding prior to it and that's very popular and we're really building that out um AP World History as a sophomore offering what we saw as a byproduct of the as um going away from the as English one class is that more students were confident after the um streamlined English one class they had we had more students and we needed to add more sections of AP World at the sophomore level because they had built this confidence that they can not only take as English too but but also AP World so um we just need time to build it out I do want to put in a caveat about the uh formerly known as duel now called

168concurrent we'll see what they call it next year um that there are also major hiccups with it um so Edith who is a rule follower and is staying in her seat barely I just said you should say something she said I can't and I thought she's so good so I do I want to say that many times how how a concurrent enrollment situation goes is dependent on the relationship between the high school teacher and the college professor and then a college professor will leave or a high school teacher will leave so it's it's it it is an awesome program when it works and Simone puts so much time into making it work um in her relationship with Foothill between her staff but it is like everything it is not the Silver Bullet yes um I'm

169Sean I think we met on Zoom I'm the principal at sequa I don't think I introduced myself I just said ditto um one thing I haven't heard uh in this report I think it's important to uh make sure that it gets on the public record in this conversation I know it wasn't necessarily Germaine to the study that was done given that it was looking at data from previous years but as of this year at uh seoa where I work and I believe the same is true the other uh large high schools in the district there are more IB classes being offered to students than ever before those classes are full we're developing new IB classes there are conversations about at least three potential IB classes one two three or four years down the road that

170we might open up um and I say this because I received an email as uh recently as last week from a parent who has students in Middle Schools asking me to explain why my school is eliminating ibap classes and how I can justify that it's patently false um it's never been the case and I um am very grateful and thank all you in advance for um making sure that that message goes to the community loud and clear that we will continue to offer rigorous robust uh program of AP and IB classes at our schools thank you all right thank you so much I think that should wrap up this agenda item but um yeah so you want to move on to the next one or take now okay yeah let's take a five minute break

171just by last comment all three of our high schools had offer AP no I just want to say one thing they all got on the honor rooll from the College Board because of their number of increased of um AP classes and tests that's all 14.2 um before we start are there any public comment for this item I 14.2 I received one in person okay so if there's no one online that's that's it for this item yes and um I'd like to call up shaie Stevenson hello everyone I don't quite know what you're discussing on the topic so I only know the subject line but I just hope that um we have the appropriate Communications with all our stakeholders including our teachers about class offerings and also that when we're discussing this we think about our

172strategic plan but also um the the bigger picture of how do we keep our school cohesive um and that we're children are having whole whole school experiences um with all types of students coming from different School District so that they're ready for the global world so that's all thank you thank you okay so I'm sure there's a lot to discuss for this item but I don't know if truste I would so I first I want to say thank you to uh president Nori and Crystal leech for allowing this uh agenda item which I requested and for those of you who are new we have item at the end called future agenda items and often if someone has an idea for a future agenda item then we end up talking about it and at some point

173we're saying oh we're talking too much about it we can't talk this much because it's not on the agenda and so and to enable us to talk about a future agenda item but to do it without being limited because it's not on the agenda that's why I asked to have it here so my hope with this agenda item is really just think of it like an early entry into the future agenda items but that we can actually say things and comment and have opinions without it being question in the brownx so again what I'm looking for here is entirely interest from if there are at least two other people ideally four other people interested in a future agenda item uh one on the top of graduation requirements and then a separate one on the topic

174of course offerings um which kind of splits into two separate ones so sort of three things but first on uh graduation requirements what I'm interested in at a high level is a review comparing the Squan High School District dist graduation requirements versus the state requirements and looking at all the ways that they are different so we can know what are all the things that we do that are different than what the state requires um and then if there are areas where they're different and we have where the board could choose to not be different such changes could create opportunities for uh students to have more flexibility in their schedule or in their High School experience because requirements create constraints and if you remove constraints you increase flexibility so we really be looking at all the

175ways where we are imply imposing more constraints and maybe we want to keep all of them maybe you want to relax some of them maybe you want to add a new constraint um but just looking at what we do and require versus what the state does so at a high level that's what I'm interested in and I for those of you who are um new to the board there's things that I've brought up in the past that I know are different don't know all the differences but there's a few that I know are different and to link back to the Strategic plan because I think we should um I think that discussing this would link to all students belong would link to increased participation and success in advanced and specialized programs would link to expanding

176availability of and enrollment in rigorous coursework with options aligned to students needs interest and Readiness and would potentially aligned with increased cohort graduation rates that said the areas that I I know are different um include what I would call the PE waiver um currently the s High School District requires all ninth grade students to take PE this the Ed code allows students to participate in the school sponsored interc Colgate sport to wave the PE requirement if we match the state code then students who participated in sports during the freshman year we'd have to work out how many seasons of sport how all the details work out but let's say someone did a full year to make it simple then they would have ability to take some other class if they want to they could still

177take P if they want to take a different class they could it would open up flexibility for additional class um there is the opportunity for the ethnic studies requirement to be met by a class um that meets another requirement I believe we have a district limitation that one class cannot currently meet two requirements and we can confirm that that's true if it's true we could choose to wave it for that if we wanted to um but that's a if it's a board imposed limitation that one course can't meet two requirements but the state allows it that's a restriction that we're imposing that we don't have to impose um on the ethnic studies one there's also the interesting potential Nuance that there's an article that we saw recently from I believe it was Ed join or

178at source that potentially uh the ethnic studies graduation requirement may not be a requirement if it's not funded um which would mean that we're different from the state requirements if it's not a state requirement at all um and then something that came up a couple times last year was uh for students who transferred to our school who who were at a school before that met state requirements but didn't meet our graduation requirements so they did everything the state said where they were before and then they transferred to our district and now we have different requirements um we currently require students in that situation to um catch up and do our requirements even though where they were they did everything they were supposed to do and that's an era we could choose to to offer flexibility

179to people who transfer or we could choose to continue to require them to catch up to our requirements versus the requirements that they had um again there may be others those are ones I'm aware of I'd be interested in a comprehensive list of just understanding where we're different we could look at these items and whatever else shows up because I don't know in what other ways we're different so that's the request would be for an agenda item to understand what do we do compare to what is required okay so why don't we see if there's board interest in that well this is discussion so I can yeah clarify yeah yeah so I I could very well be interested in sort of just especially if it means hearing more of diverse perspectives of everybody we serve

180so in terms of not just what's different between the state and what seoa but like what do people feel about it what are our teachers what our parents what our students feel about that so that's interesting to me but I I do want to make it clear particularly based on the report that we just listened to nothing that this isn't an opportunity to then also review potentially when you say course offerings and what course offerings are coming in that this is just those three things that you're potentially talking about and we're not opening this up to re introduce courses that have previously so so my hope with this specific agenda item is to talk about three potential future AG no three potential future agenda items the first potential agenda item is graduation requirements which has

181nothing to do with the prior presentation it would just be looking at and potentially we'd have an initial meeting to understand where we are different and then we could have stakeholder engagement before we made any changes like it doesn't mean we get a presentation about how we're different we don't have to make a change that day we could choose to gather information to consider a potential change but the first step would be knowing you know looking at what how are we different and why so it future items will get to Future things will be more specific to that but um this is not thank you for the clarification Okay so yes no so the way this works just you know so to have a a future agenda item be on an agenda it requires three

182board members to support it if staff has to do anything I'm on the fence right now because I'm thinking about ethnic studies I don't want to go there right now in regards to thinking about choosing and what's happening in the future of ethnic studies and sort of this debate that we're going to go into and I'm sure it's going to be a bigger debate than this stage right um so I don't I'm not really comfortable going into that kind of discussion right now and changes and making any changes for ethic studies at the moment that's where I stand in that sense but the PE I'm kind of on the fence too because I have questions about PE I mean not everybody um is in sports right not everybody I think you were talking about something

183about sports I think I was reading some of the stuff about sports and PE and people are in um some kind of sport they could take it for PE or something like that I don't know I'm not sure I'm not clear on it but yeah so what I was again interested in is a presentation about the differences between what we require and what the state requires and then we could choose after that to gather more information about anything or to just say certain things we're not going to gather information out or talk about but the initial thing is just to understand all the ways that we are different I'm interested in knowing how we are different yeah I can support looking at just where we differ from State requirements but I also agree that I

184am not signing up for opening up any curriculum or course offering changes okay so I think that's three for that so that can be a yeah I'm I'm PR two yeah four so yeah I think that's point of clarification so um trying to measure the level of potential discussion that could come from this agenda item because if the interest of the board is to just know how we differ that can be shared in a Friday update that works for me too second so then po be a future agenda item to say we know we're different in this area do we want to have an agenda item to discuss that one particular area of difference that's that's the that's where we could start um and uh I think that we could get that in a Friday

185update sooner than we would be able to find room on the agenda to have to share that information for a discussion so could potentially speed up that process okay um the second course offering related uh is course offering related and I've I have very little information on this topic but I've learned that some areas of the state districts team up together to offer CT off CTE offerings where there aren't enough students from any one school or any one District to make such an offering um and the the spirit of it is is these groups team together uh an example was that there's a like a fully functioning dental office so if students want to be certified in being able to work in a dental office that the through their public school they're able to get

186that I don't know exactly how it works I don't know what we already have through our Community College District if it's already completely robust and already meets all the needs of anybody in our County to get any sort of credentialing or certifications but I'm I I a large portion of our students do not go to college right after they leave here and to be able to have more course offerings for those students to enable them to have career opportunities potentially skilled career opportunities the extent there's not already sufficient in our local area I'm interested in exploring but we may already like it may be that there's always a super already a super robust Community College District set of offerings for any sort of field certification that anybody might possibly want or it could be that

187there's some holes and that we are we partnering I think it'd be unlikely that we would do it our it probably things because we already have offerings within the district but the the idea is to team up with other districts at least it's happening in the South I've learned about this that other places do it and when I heard it I thought that sounds pretty good it'd be nice if we have something like that but I don't know enough about the whole system to know but I'm interested in exploring what is called a CTE jpa joint power agreement where grou groups come together um and it R be just like some I don't know what level I I really know very little so it could be like it's completely already met but if there is

188a way to better meet the needs of students or career opportunities or high skilled opportunities where we could provide certifications or learnings or something like that if there's a need I'd be interested in trying to fill the need is the request then to put this on the agenda to discuss this or is the request to answer is there like inform more inform almost like another I'd be fine if it's again if someone um I I have a recommendation I'm familiar uh with a couple of districts that have this jpa um in Southern California I think that uh we can start to do a do a deeper dive and create an analysis of what we have here what they're doing like where we're missing and where potential Partnerships are and I think that that would absolutely

189be appropriate for a board presentation in a few months then I'm interested I support yes yes yes okay so that I support okay and then the the last um would be and it could be something that we follow but if we did decide uh it may make sense to just wait but or maybe it's linked if we were to relax any graduation requirement then it would free up space and student schedules to take an elective if we did that are there any new electives that we could offer that would be um more engaging for students or poent something that Carrie potentially spoke about a long time was about having an arts or music elective in freshman year that now to do it I think students have to do seven periods that they can do it

190if they do a seventh period but if there was if we made any change that freed up a period somewhere potentially students could then have an election and if there was an opportunity that then we could talk about or have a presentation about what might we be able to provide to students if we did have more flexibility so we could wait to see if there's any area where we'd want to produce flexibility but it could also be that if there were exciting areas that we could do then people might be more inclined to want to try to create the flexibility than if you don't like if you so in some way they're linked in some way it follows like okay if we create flexibility then what can we do but the other hand in some

191way it's linked because if we could offer students something that we think would drive their engagement with the school some if there were things we could add because of the extra period and frankly most freshman students in the current system have six periods and they don't have room if you're College Bound you're taking you know you're taking a foreign language is your elective and it's considered to be your elective or if you have a support class that's considered to be your elective and you don't have a chance to choose the elective you're taking is your foreign language class and that's just what I understand freshman year to be for many students so if we did make any change to the graduation requirements for freshman that affected freshman then we would be able to consider something

192available to students the freshman year so I don't know whether you'd be interested to know what we might be able to do and that link to whether you'd want flexibility or whether you see that as being completely independent I keep going first I was waiting I'm just not sure that uh maybe it's better to just get the report out of what's different between our requirements first before we jump to that question because I'm not sure what we would be discussing exactly I think to push back a little bit that's one thing when we had that presentation last time that was a focus for us was how do we expand elect ninth grade electives and you know I'm more interested too like I think one of the things we do kind of lack and I think

193it came up in the last presentation was a lot of introduction to AP or AP courses at the College Board designs that are more for you know a first introduction to what an AP course is like that you would offer in ninth and 10th grade I know there are a lot of high schools that offer some of those courses that we at seoa just for whatever reason don't have so that's kind of where in that area my interest also lies is like you know more like not necessarily just electives but what can we offer in that regard that is more of an introduction for people into AP classes so I would consider that such an AP class to be an elective like the student would be electing to take it they don't have to take

194it but they could choose to take it and currently I don't think there's room in freshman schedule to do it yeah I would be curious because I do wonder if that's a reason why maybe there's such a gap because it is kind of a jump to go from a you know some of these regular classes all the way to an AP course so maybe we had more opportunities to kind of prepare like understand what an AP course is like without necessarily all the rigor that comes with some of the harder AP courses that's something I'd be interested in exploring and again to do it we would need to find some way to create flexibility for ninth graders which I think would be have to be a graduation requirement unless there's some other way to create

195flexibility beyond that which I'm unaware of I think the sequence of events right is to first look at where we where we differ and then um what you know hearing from Woodside tonight about increased offerings for AP classes that that AP intro in nth grade like how how do they do that when we know here what we just heard about ninth grade um as president Nori stated we we did push in heavy resources to our high schools for the overall nth grade experience this is the first year that we've done that so we also need to see how our students have engaged with that ninth grade experience you know anecdotally I hearing it's good but like we we need to we need to yeah I don't know what that quite means um and I mean

196but we have made a heavy monetary um commitment to the nth grade experience increased Athletics um and then also increased into the Arts and the state does have grant money for that as well um I you know I have heard president Nori say several times about the level of interest in like AP G right and and I have visited some of these AP glove classes um and and it was one of the funnest classes I I have you know I have visited um so I could totally see the desire um to to be in that class I I do think we need some internal mechanisms to look at when we start to bring classes home when we have a large population of students going elsewhere for classes so I I've heard that now almost two

197years and so I think we need to understand that so that we can make sure that we are serving our community and that the access is equitable um and that you know if we are having students take you know uh concurrent enrollment that we're making sure that all students have access to current enrollment concurrent enrollment so what does that look like waivers transportation and so forth like that so I definitely think that there is room to explore um all of that to increase offerings whether it be AP Arts extracurricular activities for our students well that's what I'm asking for so I totally support that so how much time do you expect that analysis like I kind of I kind of feel like it's an onion not but um that that I think like like you

198know I can imagine this conversation with staff going okay and then I'm like oh but what about this what about and I become the what about and and so that's where I see these additional layers so until I have an opportunity to really digest that with staff I can what I can do is I can digest that with staff and then I can put in a Friday update like just make sure that I am understanding what you all um are trying to get the answer to and then we can follow uh that up in our two-on-one check-ins um make sure we're Target and we could maybe shoot for like springtime what I'm thinking I don't see any evil eyes so I'm probably okay with that yes I support that I don't m i second yeah

199no I think that's that's reasonable I just want to make sure that it's not an extra thing that we're throwing staff into the loop you know I really appreciate so I I do want to say this I really appreciate the the focus on tying everything that we're doing back to the Strategic plan um because for us to do that with Fidelity I do think that this fits in there I also think that the CTE fits in there as well we just we heard about this other program I definitely think it's worth exploration I am aware of what a couple neighboring districts are also doing so I think that it it does stay uh on track with what we're doing with the Strategic plan okay um I have another item too that this has been something

200I've been interested for a while but I do think AP courses at our district there is some disparity into what sites are offered and this doesn't necessarily have to be an agenda item but I am curious to understand that disparity as it exists now and if there's some recommendation from the district is like how we can standardize more of those offerings and also what you know over the next couple 4 to five years the plan is for both AP and IB offerings I'm curious about that too so I will support that sopic and as you and Amy may recall I requested something similar to that about a year ago which I called a core set of AP offerings something that we thought that each of the AP the sites that offered AP would try to

201offer within the core of course if you can't fill it you can't fill it but if you try to offer it um and then there could always be extra ones that was sort of the spirit of what I was trying to do before which sounds pretty aligned with what you're saying I don't know if you're saying something a little bit different um but I still support that same idea from before if that's what you're saying okay yeah yeah that's kind of basically what I was I think I'm confused on process like what are what are you asking for are you asking for another for a third person because I think this does require staff time just to say that you know this is something that we're interested in I did bring that in that we

202need to as as part of sequencing for looking for options for students we need to we need to to understand and be able to measure how many students are trying to meet an AP class offering outside of our district because they have this high level of Interest like we know that that happens with apgov is it different at every site yes right so like we need to do that um I I see that request as what I had just ex as mentioned that's within my I feel like that's within the onion um to to do and then and then to piggyback off of what Handover was um was mentioning right like what other potential AP classes that that us old people not you um are not um you know thinking about that maybe students have

203interest and then can see themselves in that class and how awesome it would be for them to find an AP class that they can relate to and see themsel in and and I I think that we need to we need to look at we need to look at I think the sites do look at that I think we need to talk about it on a grander level yes I I support that I thought that's what we were also talking about from before I thought they were together okay yes thumbs up agree thank you yeah and just quickly one thing I think is ADD I think one of the things that makes it hard is you know we can ask ourselves like what more do we do to support teachers who teaching AP courses because it

204is work to get a certification and keep it up and stay compliant but I think it's so so important for our district and for our students so that's something kind of extra related to that you know what more might we or be able to do to support teachers or teaching these AP courses and getting certified as what they need you your course needs to be you need to take training I thought you need to get training from the College Board too yeah that's fine okay um if that's all for that item we can move on to 15.1 action items approval of first interim financial report good evening tonight's presentation is an overview of our first interim report which is a California Department of Education requirement that scho school districts are required to submit by December

20515th for the period ending October 31st so between Vita and I will'll be talking about assumptions that have changed since budget adoption an overview about the financial SU summaries of the general fund and other funds and then also an overview of the um revenues and expenses for the next two subsequent years so this is a reminder that I have every presentation of our budget cycle our Auditors have finished um reviewing our 2324 uh school year and that report has been submitted to the County Office of Education um and they will be pres presenting the result at the January board meeting for the current year the state adopted the budget in July so from October and November we work on the revisions and have the report submitted to the County Office of Ed by December 15

206the report includes a certification of whether we can meet our financial obligations for the current and the two subsequent years so what's in first inam for this reporting period we include property tax information based on the most current estimates from the assessor office uh we include carryover balances from site discretionary and local funds and any restricted programs that expire in June of 25 for position control the budget in June was built based on staff employed in Spring of 20124 so for first interam is the time that we adjust salaries and benefits based on the staff that returned in July of 24 and any new staff that filled vacancies um the financials also include the approved salary and benefit increase and the additional co-curricular styp and we also make adjustments to the base expenditures uh looking

207back at the actuals from the prior year so this is the planning factors that we use for first interim and I want to focus on the changes and what it means to us compared to the adopted budget our actual um enrollment decreased just slightly than what we had in June even with the declining enrollment it doesn't impact our lcff funding because we are are fully Community funded or basic Aid District however uh for epaa you see that their enrollment has decreased a little bit and that will impact their state funding meaning it would reduce their state funding and the general fund will need to backfill um to balance their budget for the purs rate in 2526 and 2627 um in red are the new proposed rates and that's an increase from what we had at

208budget adoption um the state has no intention to fund those dollars so that means the general fund will have to absorb the increases Lottery rates uh are higher than what was projected in June June however even with the um increase rates it doesn't mean that we get additional dollars because we are declining enrollment property tax um as of November P1 report our property tax growth was at uh 4% for the current year for 25 26 and 2627 we are maintaining the 5% growth rate we normally use a 5% um projection for future years while we see a lower projection rate for the current year we don't have enough data to adjust it in the oute so we have to um work closely with the assessor office to see um what the potential changes are and

209then we're going to re re-evaluate and make the adjustments um at second in room bito will talk about the property taxes on the next few slides thank you Christine good evening uh the next slide uh reflects property tax projection at first interim we adjusted all the lcff revenue sources and property tax and the property tax reduced by 1.49 million compared to adopted budget year-to-year dollar change is 8.29 million which is 4% growth growth in property tax as Christine mentioned for the out years we are basing our secured property taxes to increase by 5% which is which has been the historical Trend the next time that we will receive property tax estimate from county controller's office is in April of 2025 and by then it will be past a second interim timeline so we will be

210incorporating all that when we do the budget development and it'll be a part of our estimated actual update this slide shows uh Charter Andie transfers to all the charter schools at first interm one major change is the transfer to Oxford Day Academy as we are using prior year P2 Ada numbers overall the dollar change from year to year is 54,000 and the percentage change is just 1% again CDE will certify attendance in February and we will be updating this information when we bring second interim to the board for the out years the projection is that Charter and lo transfer will increase by 3% which is close to the cola percentage for the out years this slide we just want to reiterate that the property tax as we are projecting will increase by 5% in future

211years so will the transfer to Charter Schools thank you I'll hand it back to Christine now so this is a summary of our revenue and expenditures at first interim um the total ending fund balance decreased by $8.3 million and that's because the beginning fund balance increased by $8.3 million uh when we built the budget in June it was an estimated ending fund balance and when we close the books in September we bring forth that number for First inter room so that's an increase of 8 uh $1 million total revenue increased by $894,000 and our total expenditures increase by $16 million uh total transfers out is a increase of $.1 million so um the ending total ending fund balance the net increase is 8.3 million so our estimated ending fund balance will be around $43 million

212uh this reflects the major uh changes in both revenue and expenditures so for revenues the $894,000 increase is because of the decrease in property tax offset by donations and grants um federal funds and state funds um as for far as expenditures the $16 million increase is mainly from um salaries and balance fets the increase in salary and benefits site carryover from the prior year and additional um local funds so this is a visual of our revenue and expenditures uh for our Revenue 84% of our VAR revenue is from property tax 8% is from the state 7% is from local grants and donation and teeny peeny 1% from federal funds for expenditures uh the largest portion of our budget is salary and benefits which is represents about 80% of the budget and the next largest piece

213of the pi is um operating expense which is about 12% of our budget and that includes utilities and contracted Services the special ed contracts and um some of our legal fees this is um the components of ending fund balances and it's broken down as follows so 369,000 is nonspendable and that's in the revolving cash and and in our stores inventory 15 million is for our restricted programs and 4 million and for the $4 million has been assigned in vacation liability uh basic Aid uncertainty the economic uncertainty due to inflation and any settlements we have and um 20 million is our reserves using the planning factors um the previous slide we use this to build our multi-year projections and based on our assumptions we will deficit spend this year current year of uh $20 million and

214in 25 26 we also uh anticipate to deficit spend by $6.5 million in 26 27 we see a little bit of um Surplus but overall we maintain our reserves over 8% quick question what is the estimated Reserve percentage what numbers do you divide to get that number it's the um unassigned divided by total expenditures total expenditures this slide shows the other funds other than the general funds uh all our other funds have positive ending balance for the for this fiscal year with a total ending fund balance of 156 million there are different funds such as student body fund Charter School fund which is the E where we record all activities for epaa Charter Schools adulted fund which is fund 11 with an ending balance of $2.3 million cafeteria fund which is fund 13 deferred maintenance

215fund fund 14 has an ending balance of $7.9 million retiree benefit fund fund 20 building fund 21 County school facilities fund 35 fund 35 and Special Reserve fund for Capital outlay fund 40 um our first interim remains positive with a healthy Reserve however there are some budget challenges that we need to consider uh property tax we have to monitor to see where the growth is so we have to work closely with the assessor office um enrollment if epa's enrollment will decline or remain flat and with the state funding Cola next year is at 2% um the general fund will still continue to support to balance their budget uh with the expiration of onetime funds we we'll need to discuss how we can sustain the programs and initiative supported by these dollars and there's also um

216future unknown settlements when I went to the CBO Symposium School Services reminded us that prop 30 uh which was the voters approved in 2012 expires in 2030 and the state will need to consider if they can backfill the dollars or extend the taxes and for us these funds are on top of our property tax taxes uh property taxes so for us that's $1.5 million and for epaa that's about $50,000 so if we lose those funds we would have to somehow back fill for um Charter these is looking ahead in the next few months um in January the Auditors will present the results of our 2324 audit report um like I said we're going to continue monitoring our property tax and working closely with the assessor office uh January I'll V and I will be attending

217the governor's uh budget Workshop to hear about 2526 um and then we're going to February we're going to work on enrollment for 2526 and also on Staffing and then in March we will uh bring in back the bring back we will be uh presenting the 2425 second inter room budget any questions or comments sorry um is it um why don't we do public comments first for the okay if there none um do board members have any questions you know my question already um can you talk about the County's current estimate for the next academic Year's increase in Revenue I looked at it this week and it's 3% and we're using 5% in our estimate even though the county shows 3% I guess because in future years the county has estimated low and it's risen and

218we are hopeful that they're estimating low again this year and it will rise is there a is there a history of the county estimating low and then having it come in higher yeah because every week when we look at that report that it fluctuates every week the assessor role I I'd also like to note that that we put more than hope and prayer in our forecast in the future um don't forget your superintendent was the previous CBO um but uh the okay I just want to make sure um fluctuate this was a lot of conversation between uh Christine and myself on where we would settle there not other factors going on in the market to really justify this low projection from the assessor's office we have to to be very mindful um that we are

219not creating Whiplash in the district with the budget first interim second interim budget estimated actuals un audited actuals especially when the majority of our expenses are staff related however um before covid I started projecting about now the property taxes were going to be declining and we are seeing that we saw a very high correction year last year for property taxes something we have not seen since I I think it was like 12 13 14 15 where like we ended like at 10% which has allowed us to give the amount of raises of 13 a. half% over the last two years those days are gone for right now um so those were our right siiz years we dipped into reserves uh we are very much looking at Staffing uh we see this declining enrollment technically we're

220in declining enrollment but our enrollment is fairly stable so I just I want to I want to I want to state that um we we are looking at Staffing we are looking at budgets uh enrollment at our small schools is something that we very much need to pay attention to because they the Staffing calculations that we use across the district they don't work at our small schools so the per pupil expenditure tends to be higher um at our small schools they still require the same um you know an an enhanced admin team and and so forth so those are things that we need to look at um this year I think was the first year and we have been doing it successfully um with partnership uh with sdta and I think there's going to present

221um more opportunities in futur to do that where we are now now having a teacher work at two sites to meet the requirement because we don't have enough sections to offer a class at a site and so you're going to see this you we had all this previous talk about electives right seventh period those things all cost money and so those are definitely things that we just need to keep in mind um but I'm sorry I'm rambling and bird walking but to go to what uh trusty gin was saying we have not we were not able to access an accurate snapshot of this time last year to justify using the lower percentage in the out years so we will continue to monitor that um these two brilliant individuals standing before you will absolutely find the

222answers no pressure that's mostly on Bonita because I know she has the connections because we took her from the county so few months we'll get more information I'll obviously be keep keeping you guys updated great if not um could I get a motion to approve second oh make the motion sorry I make the motion to approve second um all in favor I any oppose okay so that motion passes and okay um okay why don't we go back now to item 10 which is board member comments okay yeah it's actually been a while since we last met but um I did want to mention um the Sano County School boards Association general meeting way back in November was actually really good um I I think I think truste Stevenson at the time was there were you

223I don't think anyone else was there okay um but that one um the it was focused on staff retention and so some of the the highlights were from the panel was the Sano County Office of Education you know they have a program to help uh people earn while they learn kind of approach um to getting their um credentials for becoming a teacher so that that was um highlighted as well as Jefferson Union High School District their their Housing Development uh and the progress around that um it was interesting to hear that it was a seven-year program so they're two years into that first cohort and they've got like a weight list of about you know 50 people who are trying to get into the housing um and and they've been trying to introduce um real

224to talk about the market for housing and then also mortgage brokers to talk about how you qualify um but some of the feedback was that the the folks are not saving as much as they should so there's kind of this concern when that five years is up are they going to be asking for a reprieve well there's no reprieve because there's still people on the weit list trying to get in so uh it was kind of interesting uh made me think think that you know if if High School uh financial literacy requirement is coming down the pike maybe we need to educate everyone who works in the schools too so we'll we'll see where that goes and then that was Jefferson Union High School District so they built to seven no no it's seven years

225but they've been living there for two years already so there's five years left to the uh seven years was it initially believe I believe they had a shorter initial period and then that they because of this issue they increased the period already oh okay that's what I think has happened oh interesting okay um and then the third uh program highlighted was the Ravenswood um merit-based pay and evaluation system which everyone was clamoring to understand how it was working and how how they got everyone on board uh but but actually they said that since they implemented that they haven't had any um start of school teacher shortage kind of issues because there's people who hear about that and and these teachers want to be in a system with Merit based pain and so they're flocking to

226their District so I don't know like I don't know so that was I take away from that um probably not um but yeah that that was my update for the board okay thank you so now um we have item 16.1 which is future agenda items but I don't know if anyone doesn't I I do have one thing that is not going to be scary but at some point an update on the facilities master plan because we have some new members and just at some point I don't know if that's already planned and when it would be uh it is on the um governance [Music] calendar it is attached the agenda item they I believe it's February yeah like and then I mean I had another one just and this is really out of thin air

227but oh what but I read an article actually in Ed Source I think the other day and one of the cases that's coming before The Supreme Court in January has to do with um Banning Tik Tok and he talked about its implications for educators and our schools about what would happen I don't I don't know if we actually should do this but it it was interesting because I heard other districts are considering writing um Friends of the Court briefs for the Supreme Court about the impact it would have on students mental health to not have access to this thing or to Tik Tok yeah I would or how it would help to not have access to Tik Tok it would help so that's just something I wanted to bring the attention to the board I

228don't know if we probably probably if we want to write a Friends of the Court brief but I think you should record a Tik Tok submit it but um yeah no that's something well the case is being heard Jan 14th so we a special me so just so you know that yeah okay but um that's just something I wanted to bring to the board's attention but yeah now I kind of realized that it wouldn't align up with our board meeting but okay other than that that's all so to the chair just clarification on what is future gen items is it just the CTE that you approved earlier um I have it listed all and then so these other two now are parking lot all they're all future items from the other discussion item all right

229thank you okay but um with that could I get a motion to adjourn SEC okay good SEC um all in favor so this meeting is a adjourned at 9:27 p.m.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.