001e here here want to thank everyone who showed up even though you're not here but you're probably watching on YouTube everyone who showed up to discuss cell phones in our schools and our high school students for sharing their wisdom with us tonight e e hi hi great so typically about a week before we come and join you all I start jotting down notes and I was like have two things on my list and now I have seven things on my list so I will keep it brief but um the main thing tonight was for you all to get an opportunity to meet the amazing Jackie Carol Jackie has worked for CMC cida for the past two plus years as our Enrollment Services coordinator when bnal stepped out of her role as the concurrent enrollment coordinator
002a few months ago uh we went through a search process and have hired Jackie into that role she is doing an exceptional job and I have heard that consistently from our friends the counselors over there and Jesse and Abigail and most importantly students so I just wanted you all to get a chance to get to know her a little bit and hear about her background and so you can tell them whatever you want to awesome hi um I'm kind of newer to the area my husband and I bought a plot in coldale in October of 2021 and just recently finished building our house this past July and now we've got our first baby on the way and it's due end of March so that's real exciting um I really love it here I love working
003for CMC and I was really excited to take this particular position because I love working more closely with the students um our traditional students that are not SEO students um tend to interact a lot more via email they don't need as much from me um I like kind of helping the students figure out their Pathways and what they're interested in and delving into what the possibilities are with CMC um I have a bachelor's of Science in human biology and I'm working on an MBA through CSU Global right now so that's fun too and uh have a lot of pets I do have a lot of pets yeah we've got a little Homestead going we've got goats and chickens and dogs and cats and um yeah we absolutely love settling into our lives here we feel
004really lucky to be here and um yeah very excited for this journey this was my first got through my first semester in this position um it was definitely chaotic but nothing too crazy and I'm excited to kind of get it more streamlined and get to know the students um trying to remember student names right now is very hard for me but I'm really trying hard and I'm hoping I've been told the pregnancy braid never actually goes away but I'm optimistic so we'll see but yeah it's very nice to meet all of you and um I encourage you to if you're around um CMC please feel free to chat with me and would love to get to know you Jackie's office is at the high school so she's there four days a week either 8 to
005noon or noon to 5 um her office is right across from Mary and Dawn and so um one of the things that this trans transition afforded US is an opportunity to sort of Hit the pause button and make sure that we were really clear about what the purpose and focus of her role was so I just want to read you one thing um that we kind of collectively put together and I won't go through all of these bullets but um I think it was a helpful exercise for me in conversation with Jesse and Abigail and the counselors and this is this is number one it says the first priority is to provide exceptional academic advising and counsel for students this should be a given but I think at times it's gotten lost in the details
006of meetings committee assignments emails Etc every student at Salat high school should know who you are and see you as a resource for information and guidance on career Pathways both those that include Colorado Mountain College as a postgraduate option and those that are headed elsewhere so um hopefully that gives you all a sense of of the number one priority for Jackie and her role over high school so um anything else any questions you all want to ask Jackie before we transition to other stuff great uh I want to give a brief Ascent update um and then I want to share a quick story about a student so I think most of you know that the criteria by the state is sort of an Ever moving Target they fixed the number at the number that we
007have this year so right now we're looking at seven or eight students uh next year David recently committed to funding 10 I have that in writing Jesse has it in writing um so if he walks that back we'll we'll make sure to revisit that with him um I want to share a story about an individual student that um and I might get teary when I share this story but a student that two years ago we funded um to go take Colorado history class through CMC lead bill in the summer that that class was Grant funded I believe it was the first college course that this individual took this is an individual from a pretty impoverished background that there was like zero chance the student was on a college pathway came back from that experience had
008a really positive experience took a couple of more college classes so that they were Ascent eligible um with a ton of support from our colleagues in the swap um office which is in our building uh that individual is now up at the CMC Steamboat campus this fall um I got word last week that they received a 3.6 GPA this semester and um I again like this is a g gigantic win for us as a community when I think about what the purpose of ascent is and the target student like this is the target student of the fact that this individual went to a residential campus a long ways from his home required a ton of financial resources and just support systems and network like every single person in our office knows this student like everyone
009has been involved in some way in helping get them across the Finish Line um and so that's been a huge win for us with ascent and that's that's one student this year um so anyways if you want to ask me more about that I'd love to share more about that um one of the big successes this year and I think and Abigail and hopefully the counselors would agree if you all remember the past couple of years CMC has helped write this grant for the school district that concurrent enrollment expansion and Innovation Grant it's the grant that paid for Josh Beckle to get his graduate degree which is why he's able to Now teach classes like calculus and college trig and stats at at the college level when we were looking at that Grant last year
010we knew that there were two teachers in the pipeline uh Brady Hines and lug walney and so we knew that if we it there was going to be some extra money left in that funding so we pitched a pretty crazy idea at that time to to create three new stien positions the first was around supporting Ascent students the second was around supporting work-based learning credentials and the third was to work directly with Fred Maxwell on a four-year work-based learning curriculum at the high school we H hired Abigail cookie with one of those stiens to work on industry recognized credentials we hired Paul Brockman to work on Ascent support and then we hired Josh Beckle to work with Fred Maxwell on fouryear learning uh four-year work-based learning curriculum all three of those individuals have absolutely hit
011grand slams in my opinion like the return on investment from those three $8,000 stiens has far in a way exceeded what we have spent um cookie can you remind me what the number of C dips was last year and when it's going to be this year is 50 the number that we're anticipating this year anticipating we had 11 last year um yeah so I I could probably spend the whole evening talking about the success of those three siphons but I've just been really pleased with getting to work with those three individuals and the work that they've done uh new courses that are just for the first semester happening this semester art appreciations a new course interpers comms a new course US history since the Civil War is a new class intro to Sociology Ensemble and
012audition choir so that's six brand new college courses this semester alone uh art appreciation interpersonal Comm US history and intro toos are all guaranteed transfer courses so that means if a student is attending any instate institution those are part of their General Ed transferable requirements um couple of fun anecdotal stories had a meeting with a student last week that graduated from Salata High School last spring that's currently at Montana State in Boseman we were just hanging out catching up and at the end of the um our conversation I said hey what happened with your transfer credits and if some of you have been around long enough to remember this some of you haven't but three years ago there was all this discussion around how to transfer credits work for students and do CMC credits actually
013mean anything in the real world and are they going to transfer and there was this whole AP conversation versus concurrent enrollment blah blah blah student said ontana State accepted all 40 of my transfer credits I started day one of my freshman year as a sophomore so that's student number one again out of state institution texted another student today that's at Arizona State because I had heard through the gra Vine that Arizona State may or may not be accepting transfer credits I'm going to pull up the email and read it to hear the text that I got back from the student and read it to you if I can find it I can't find it there it is um ASU took all of my credits I'm set up as a sophomore right now and I'm planning
014on graduating in 2027 because of it so that's two students both attending different outof state public institutions and both of them accepted all of their College transfer credits um that's about it what else do you all want to know gave you a one pager that's something that we put together for our planning strategic planning retreat with our team at the end of every Academic Year so that's a few months old now but that'll give you kind of a snapshot of what cmc's up to that includes lots of uh data points around concurrent enrollment but uh the larger conversation around what else is happening with CMC and one of my questions um that I mentioned to David the other day is with now that we have the pathways and there's a lot of courses listed on
015there of these are the courses you should take are we going to be able to be offering all of those courses on the different Pathways not next year but I think we're pretty conscious of of courses in each of those Pathways and trying to actively work towards adding those so so you will be able to at least take something from the pathway probably every semester like if you pulled out the pathway document right now I would bet that probably half of the courses on there are currently being offered there's some more like Nuance specialized courses that we're just going to have to find adjin faculty or credential teachers at seleta high school over the course of the next couple years to build those out and are most of those going to be are most of
016those at kzar or at the high school or does it depend probably half probably half and half yeah I was gonna say about half and half and then some online options as well um we have some students taking online courses to to fit better into their schedule if especially if they're trying to finish with an Associates or something like that Jody you had a question yesterday um kind of looking at the current number of concurrent enrollment students and whether it's I think the way you articulate was there a lot of students taking a lot of courses or a few students taking a lot um so we had 208 discreet students taking concurrent enrollment classes at least one course in the fall typically that drops off significantly in the spring we have 210 this semester um
01711 71 credits which according to my back of the napkin math equals out to 5.29 credits per student so that means most students are taking around two college courses you're gonna have a few that are taking like one you know one credit auto or construction or two credit auto construction course and then others that are taking nine 10 12 credits Jesse was able to share with me freshman 5% and that it steadily increases exponentially actually for the seniors so it's exactly what you want yeah I probably could have said it earlier but in the student section conversations we talked about the block schedule a little and the ab schedule and very excited at least at my table of like how much better that works with CMC in the classes that they would take through the
018pathways and concur enrollment and everything else so that move as it's kind of forthcoming is beneficial so from a bigger picture CMC thing and you may not be able to tell me yet but have we found a slida board member is it have found a slide slid board member and I apologize that we hadn't we haven't issued apparently a press release yet I um Beth Helm key uh is the new board of trustee representative for the uh Southern section of CMC many of you know Beth as the deputy director for chaffy County um and she is as we speak going through her first day of CMC Board of trustee training and I believe today is her first day on the job as a CMC board trustee I'd encourage you to get to know Beth if
019you don't know her she is a fantastic addition she came and met with our staff team last week and um yeah I think it's going to be exceptional in that way GL you ask that thank you I heard that rumor so you confirmed it what else you guys excited about your new home permanent we are excited about our new home yes the lift has been working for more than a month now that's a bonus yeah the lift has been spreading awesome well thank you for being here tonight yeah not sure if you're sticking around through Jesse presentation but we're appreciate you guys did I Ste any of your stuff J one more thing that I'll just say to you rob um is that all the students tonight talking about what's going well at the high
020school like CMC and the opportunities that they feel like they're getting through CMC was the main thing they kept saying over and over again I mean they it was their amazing teachers and then all of our opportunities through CMC so definitely the students feel really pleased with what you guys are doing and you in particular your name was strongly mentioned and truly the words I believe were this is the best thing that could have happened to CID High School cool yeah they actually said that at my T yeah yeah all right big fans thank you thank you guys appreciate getting to spend time with you please feel free to pick up the phone anytime if you ever have questions I'm always happy to do some digging if you need to dig down into the data
021weeds so to speak thank you for being here Peace Out friends thanks for the pizza take more sure there's plenty uh campus reports we jumping straight into Jesse yep I think it should go over our head okay okay well um before I go into the presentation I I think uh just just reflecting back on uh my three years here and uh watching board members talk to students um how do I put this it's it's it's a distinct pleasure with you a board uh I've I've been in this game for a long time now since the 90 and have worked with various boards over the years and um soid high school when I came here was a great School uh with with areas to grow in which we are continuing to grow in those areas but
022um I think it's important to recognize a lot of the work that we have done at the high school we needed board support and and we truly appreciate your your support um there's there's been a lot of growing pains over the last three years and uh we're we're starting to see results right I I told the staff that I was I was super excited to come in front of the board and and talk about the the great things we've done over the last few years and how we've grown and where we're continue we're going to continue to grow but I I truly mean it when I say it's it's really hard to do this work and if you don't have board support it's even harder to do that work so I we truly appreciate uh
023what you've you've done to support us so thank you um so with that um some of the stuff I want to brag about maybe so Blank Slate oh there we go you gotcha uh Mission this hasn't changed over the last years we take care of kids at the high school Al socially emotionally uh by providing quality academics College and Career prep durable skills and belonging if you look at those uh those things at the bottom those are the things that we do in advisory that's where we focus advisory advisory driven are we there yet no we're we're getting close uh as you talk to students uh probably heard some inconsist consistency in in what advisor is like depending on their advisor uh but we're continuing to grow uh we talk about this Mission all the
024time at the high school love that go back for a second cookie uh that picture of olly under physically that's soccer when they they won a they run runner up I don't know why he had the trophy but it's a cool picture Vision uh you'll hear David say this a lot I say it a lot also we need we need to know every student by name need and strength and uh also every student can verbalize and articulate uh a postsecondary pathway you know uh the goal was 75 % of kids if you ask them what their pathway is they could tell you we're there we've achieved that um or kid hopefully they could tell I'll go back for a second too I just wantan there's uh our fearless leader at uh career day interviewing kids
025some artwork and uh our our great state championship cross country team Mandy that looks like Monument Valley Park is it yeah successes uh I'll talk a little bit about the the first one I am super proud of uh the gold goal was to reach 60% matriculation this year which means it would have grown by 12% from last year we knocked it out of the water 70% you know 70% of our our our kids are going on uh to a postsecondary program growing from 48% a year ago so that is awesome uh we have advisers working with kid kids on individual plans pathways are published uh satps this hasn't changed average for how long long time um concurrent enrollment you heard in credits uh saving families over half a million dollars Athletics activities cross country state
026champions this year the boys soccer Runners up uh The Adams Family was an incredible hit we've created Esports they're in a a pilot mode right now for the next three years an Esports team which is chassa recognized uh we know about thisal framework a Counseling Center with two counselors uh a Sol Vista social worker Jackie Carrol from CMC and uh Jessica Bennett school psychologist all in one place to support kids so just a few of the great successes we've had goad cooksie I was too excited uh goals every year you know like anybody we we write down a bunch of goals these goals are written on my whiteboard they're in the action plan uh that we share with staff uh and develop with the building leadership team uh at the beginning of the year um
027you know we had a retreat with CMC and uh the leadership team from the high school and I remember David uh sliding a piece of paper to me a scrap piece of paper and saying these are the must things we must have and I looked at the list and I was like how in the world are we going to achieve all these things halfway through the school year we've accomplished almost all of them right um in progress uh we're working on it shs is advisory driven we're getting there it's been an arduous process um and and getting everybody on board and Rowing in the right direction has been a challenge uh but uh you know super proud of the Improvement we've had there um and 90% of courses have a clearly defined scope and sequence
028I think we're close to that also individual academic plans uh did any students share those with board members today no uh well each student should have an individual academic four-year plan where they've identified their career pathway uh um advisers are working with kids individually uh they should meeting be meeting with them on a quarterly basis and what they go through is what their courses will look like for the next four years according to their um career pathway uh first Tuesdays where where we present career Pathways for students that are interested in those career Pathways support this um the master schedule is based on student requests and needs for uh students that need these courses in their career pathway um a work in progress um but those are the conversations advisers are having with kids right
029now career Pathways uh talked a little bit about this in a prior board meeting I think October November we have seven clearly defined find Pathways uh with with a number of recommended courses and required courses um each each student should pick one of these Pathways that's of interest to them does that mean necessarily they have to stay in that pathway the whole four years no they can they can move from Pathway to pathway um but this is the first year I hear students using this vernacular right they know what a career pathway is a lot of them know know what interests them and I think we'll continue to build on this goals for advisory uh four buckets college career Readiness belonging durable skills and academic support So career Readiness this is where they're talking about
030their individual pathways uh on Thursdays belonging we have Club day where each teacher has a club uh clubs are anything from uh Jody deas makes Crepes right uh where yeah that's awesome uh there's a reading club Dr brackman does a work War II uh film club uh they're all over the board uh with that for for kids that are interested in a certain thing durable skills that's our social emotional learning uh curriculum through wayfinder where they do a wayfinder um lesson plan each week um academic support we use navian for that and also individual c coun academic counseling Within advis uh so advisory serves many different purposes uh next year when we change the schedule another piece of advisory will be students being able to go to other teachers to get extra support on classes
031they may have missed because they were sick or because they missed uh a class because of a sport uh so that's one of the the reasons behind find extending advisory another 10 minutes uh with all the stuff that we need to do in advisory it makes sense for us to extend it another 10 minutes The Challenge and I'm just being quite Frank with you is getting every single staff member on the same page into to Be an Effective advisor right um when you've been doing things for a long time as a teacher sometimes it's hard to change especially if it's outside of your content area uh so really giving those uh advisors that need support the support uh to move them along to become a better advisor is that it yeah that's right uh block
032schedule I had a few questions from board members on on the Block schedule uh we put a big document together on the rationale of why we're changing by from a 4x4 to an alternating block I think one of them well there's a couple really big benefits to the alternating block one is they have math and English all year as opposed to the semester it's very concerning that we have kids in our building that take a math course and then do not take another Math course for an entire year right and that and when they have that Gap also they're testing for college board right so have lost a lot of skills we have some data that we we dug into on that that really showed uh the gaps that kids have when they missed math
033or or language arts uh for a period of time uh also the alternating block enables us to um create more opportunities for kids in registration it matches up with with cmc's schedule uh also where a kid could take you know a CMC class on Monday and Wednesday and then that block on Tuesday and Thursday they can take another CMC class class or a high school class as opposed to having an open hour uh which is what they have now um um teachers will have kids the entire year I think that's going to improve relationships uh also kids have have more time to get through the content um so we're super excited about it um another piece of this is the block will be reduced to 90 minutes from 100 minutes 100 minutes is too long
034for kids uh especially freshmen right sitting in an algebra one class um it doesn't matter how much you break up the class it's still a 100 minutes of algebra which is a long time 90 minutes is more workable uh for for kids and I think teachers any questions on the Block schedule before I move on well I guess I should talk about challenges too it's going to be an adjustment period uh as far as planning for teachers as far as pacing for kids uh we're going to have to do some professional development with that uh longer time between Class meetings you know a kid misses a class on Monday day he's only going to have that class once that week on a Wednesday so that's that's kind of a challenge right questions yeah J Jesse
035um with regard to the adjustment period well first let me say i' I've read what was put together by the team that made that choice re recommendation and it was fascinating it was so informative and it was complete and so it was really really helpful a lot of some of the scheduling problems and scoring Pro test scores and stuff like that are be are on the back of this modified block what how long will that adjustment period be do you think before you see some of the hopes realized you know I'm just talking from experience yeah um when I worked in in manitu we did the same thing we were on a 4x4 block okay and we moved to this exact schedule in AB block um the first year was definitely an adjustment period for
036for the teachers and the kids I would say more for the teachers than the kids uh as far as pacing and workload and and one of the things that we screwed up in was not providing professional development for the teachers right and being deliberate and talking through what it looks like now students have eight classes as opposed to four classes and they have twice the time uh teachers giving students the appropriate workload um you know as far as like scores we we saw a bouncing scores the following year so I gota be patient any other questions on schedule data uh Athletics activities part participation is through the roof um I I like that feedback that I heard from from your group Matt about um almost too many kids in certain activities right and and maybe
037it's time to expand uh which needs to be very deliberate right we've been working through a policy on how we we bad sports right that makes sense um but we have incredible participation within within our events um so and Jesse I wanted to share what one of our students said also they said no more sports or activities because they're already spread too thin that right and that it's a small school somewhere in four Sports and if more is offered it's going to be those same students being spread even thinner so I hear what your student was saying but on the flip side we heard and the challenge is cannibalizing the sports that you do have so right um which I've seen happen in small schools before and we don't want to go down that road
038but I think it's important to look at students that are for lack of a better term disenfranchised right now and how do we hook those kids that are not involved in anything so like right now I'm super excited about Esports which I can't believe I'm saying right um I had to change my thinking a little bit about gaming being an actual sport but it is right and and there's a a population of students that are super excited about that and they're not involved in anything else now they're in Mr Long's class after school duking it out on um Mario Kart right and and participating in something so it's great yeah as long as we get mountain biking chassa right yeah yeah two separate students our only sport where we have like BB kids on our
039team um tennis tennis that's right which was a concern that was expressed because they're already at 40 kids and allowing BB kids to come well that's what I was curious too because your numbers were super high like how many of those kids are out of our district that are participating in our programs there's 40 kids in District to be clear on the P team already okay according to the girls yeah I think that those are the only two NY that's same yeah let me think about that yeah this is just swim does yeah and golf does um there's some overlap there yeah mean yeah we could drill down into that data for sure um if you look at well that's winter and and fall for sports so Jody so so from my limited knowledge and
040you're asking me about orts so um I'm definitely not an expert um I can barely this but um from my understanding there's the way it works is there's there's two games that they pick each year for a season so it's so it's Mario Kart and I want to say smash smash smash BRS right and it it's like two divisions so I would compare it to like Freestyle swimming and the Butterfly like there's some folks that are yeah yeah yeah and and they game against other teams right so there's a team score and then there's individual schols yeah you do not what else about Athletics have we just had an offer for mock trial um a proposal for mock trial but it's one of those things right do we offer it because those kids are already
041involved in 18 other things do we have the capacity for it it's a great activity but do we have the capacity uh AP tests uh here's some of the data number of fives up there um which is five is the top square you can get on an AP test uh the one outlier is language usage uh and and that data right there is not great and that's because we had three teachers last year for um uh but you know the the other scores are are quite exceptional PSAT sat data again above State national average it's been like that for a long time all right now we consistently perform higher this is the Focus right this is the thorn in our side our growth is low um we took a different approach this year and looking
042forward to seeing what our scores are like in the spring uh each department is being very deliberate about practicing for PSAT and sat uh with with time devoted within the classes to to practice uh PSAT and SAT test questions or work on claim evidence reasoning and science um you know um English is working on a program uh computer program called quill which has practice sat questions um so we're doing a number of things where where teachers are being very deliberate about practicing for the PSAT and sat I think that has has been one of the issues is we've always recognized that ah we're above the state average we good right we don't need to focus on it right so it's never really talked about or addressed um this year we're being more deliberate about focusing
043on all right how can our kids do well on these skills and practice for this test um so we'll see and matriculation um I can tell you when this came out on December 20th it was a great Christmas present we we knocked it out of the park you our goal was 60% Le 70% and the thing that's even more exciting is um the gender gap has closed right boys are matriculating as much as girls now and the socioeconomic Gap is closing also right Jody you brought up a great question that I did not see in the data uh which we're drilling down into is why are our kids 50% of our kids going out of state and uh you know rouie was brought up I don't know if that's the case um but we're going
044to drill down into that b yeah that's that's different than previous right didn't most of our kids used to stay in state yeah I think it's it's like a 10% difference from from last year so that was just the last year students who graduated 50% of them went out of state or it's like an out yeah totally exactly it may not be a bad thing and especially if you know like Rob said they're taking all the all the credits still yeah is there a reason that would be a bad thing that I just don't know yeah for college right there's nothing bad or good about it it's just a it's a brand new piece of change in our student body and so want to make sure that we' thought through and understand the implications of
045are we really supporting the kids that's why it's great to hear that they're accepting what we've already designed because that wasn't working then we'd be like oh no we're we're out of sync with what our students need want so I think there's just going to have to be some investigation to make sure there's no un intended consequences of what we're trying to do support kids actually yields what we intend so right now it is but I think there's it's worth asking more questions and see if that change is a oneof or if that change is something that's really going there because I think it'll help us understand how to keep on improving our support of the kids of or so some could just be a cultural difference in our town and our town is changing
046and maybe more people coming from other states and other cities maybe want their kids or encourage their kids to go a little further field yeah yeah well it's amazing if our system can support them no matter where they go you know the the thing I worry about with out of state kids too is uh when you talk to seniors a lot of times they don't think about price tag right and and and um student loans right and going out of state and busting the bank and then realizing wow I I could have went to a CSU or Fort Lewis for 25% of the price I just paid so I I think that's important when we have conversations an advisory to to talk about things like student loans and college debt it is not on a
047consistent basis though that's what we're we're trying to do yeah so that's all I have there is oh yeah go Spartans I'd say we're close yeah yeah and you know why I say we're close to 90% is some folks have a scope in sequence but it needs work yes right right yeah well and I mean my question picky backs on that because you mentioned with changing the schedule so I would imagine that will change their scope and sequence in some way or no it would just stretching it out like you mentioned giving the wrong amount of workload to a student in the beginning initially so that would maybe be kind of the professional development piece is making sure they're knowing how to stretch it out appropriately sure yeah yeah it would be the same scope
048and sequence but as far as recognizing workload and timing and timing yeah um because you know it's it's not like you're going to sign work for a kid every single day because you're only going to meet him twice a week um so that that definitely needs to be deliberate okay very good thank you thank you appreciate it appreciate you getting those kids here earlier and absolutely all the good things they said are attributed to you and your team so appreciate all you guys do for us um nobody else from campus reports except Evelyn is here I feel like we should just have to ask Evelyn a question but I got nothing for so well I think first we should say thanks to Evelyn from the appreciation uh kind of committee or sometimes is Evelyn um
049and full Committee of one and the food was amazing thanks for taking care of us tonight yes thank you um my I know that William you so a couple of things starting February the bus month dri to Hype it up we're short we're gonna be short on drivers uh the other thing on my report uh that I'm adding staff appreciation because I hate to see I hate to see when nobody gets recognized that is my to me so next month for the bus driver Quick Clip come March I'm going to highlight all the rest of actually see them doing their jobs we're going to highlight them in March and then April will start the rest of the staff appreciation where I'll start figuring out building by building so other than that that's about it did
050you have any other questions you have uh anything I mean February is next month that's my big month so now I'm focusing on February so if you guys want to bring any day is fine because I try to make every day something special for the dver okay so just contact me any questions no all right then Aon can do the money uhhuh Nots oh the new fleet vehicle no it's a new small vehicle small it it's not a small I'm not buying no bar um those things are my ,000 I'm just buying another Suburban we have a call for Suburban suburb Toyota and Suburban 4 are both 2011 when I took this over Suburbans were just handed out for whatever and [Music] to, mil I think it and sub 201 run almost, so they're starting
051to get up there um I'm not going to buy a new Suburban or new vehicle you're looking any a Expedition Expedition yeah it's a Ford Expedition it's it's got everything it's got the screen it's got the maps it's got everything so yeah don't listen to I got I get there next year I'll buy people like to I'll buyed about team and take that he needs so right okay have a good night I'm glad you guys enjoyed your dinner yes thanks Evelyn you're welcome hold it down oh just hold it District rep reports Dr Blackburn uh I don't think I think you've got lots of great information I will pass two directions this the only feedback we have from the for policy that was talked about tonight um some people it's out there for public review
052so I'll send it both ways there's not a lot there it's supportive of where you guys are intending to go but I thought I'd print that off that'll be out there for another uh another month and we'll bring that back to you next month so but that's what's out there and there's no other feedback um from anything else that we've been uh allowed for public comments I don't think there's anything else you need for me unless you have questions respons yes staff um there's three responses it over also have a petition that was started online for Banning cell phones next year unfortunately it doesn't say how many people it's a lot but when I looked this afternoon online I think it said like 130 okay um so just another sort of indication all for Banning
053next yeah so just another indication that the community themselves mobilized this petition and wants us to go phone free so it's great that's awesome if you know whoever's loading that petition out there' be great to know who they are and how we would get access to the petition so that they were at my they were here tonight so actually Susie Hines started it um so she was here tonight actually several of the people's names that I see on here were here tonight makes sense um if you just go change.org cida cell phones you can find it okay um but we can pass this around in a second so I just was reading the names that's fabulous okay so initially the way the petition was listed it had me as the decision maker and it was
054like Lobby Mandy and none of the rest of you and then it said that there was no response from me so right but they fixed it when it was pointed out to them fix and they took that off and were realized that I didn't need to be singled out on the petition um I don't think I'll sign this petition because it's very particular like like it specifically says that they want the cell phones in the bags in the pockets um so it is a little specific I mean I think it's good like it's good support but I I mean I think for me as a board member I'm not going to sign it because I don't know it was asking for very specific policy that we haven't yet been able to finalize with our admin
055team if that's what we're doing I will say for what it's worth some of the people involved in this were at my table and said oh well I really thought it needed to be done this way but now that we've spoken and I've heard from people I realized that maybe the way you're thinking would be just fine so I don't know that they were that rigid ultimately but that's how it looks when you sign your name that's There's an opportunity because it's an action item that will be discussed so we can rehash some of the conversations at that point so than just also I have a um letter from heart of the Rockies uh Health Center slide of Health Center recommending what we're proposing also so I'll pass that around interesting okay um we need
056a break we good keep powering through powering through all right can I make one more just District comment yes uh Mr woodell is not with us um he he went home uh but he did officially retire that's in your board packets and you're taking action on that here in a second and um I'm sure there'll be a lot more to say about it I just want don't want to bypass somebody who gave their life um and Faithfully we had a few other uh retirements people who spent 30 years or decades with us serving our kids that came in today I'm not sure if they'll be on this board packet or if they'll be on next board packet but we're always super grateful to the people like Mr wedell and others um who give us their
057whole life their whole career um to loving our kids and just want to lift that up and say thanks and uh we're excited about those transitions for those people as they go on to the next thing that they're they need to okay um moving into consent agenda looking for a motion to approve consent agenda and Jen questions comments needed clarifications okay ready for a vote Dr be P hi Dr Hill hi Mr HW hi Mrs Lumberg hi Mrs Pas hi M shman hi and Mr Smith all right okay moving into discussion items uh collaborative bargaining interest for 2526 David Aaron take it away this is me I'm actually as I told the administrative team pretty excited about this year's uh kind of sitting down and problem solving I think we've got some good people on
058the team as people are volunteering and it's just important we have this conversation in a public Manner and so wanted to bring it to you to get there um the interest that I understand us bringing forward this is an opportunity for you guys to say I'd like you to add this or consider this and maybe Talk Amongst yourselves uh first off is how do we help pay for insurance premium increases at the moment we are looking at somewhere in the magnitude of a 24% increase to health insurance premiums to our our people at this time like last year you and we have in the past years the board has continually picked up those premium increases this will this is probably going to be big enough that it causes some decision making so we have an
059interest as a district to continue to give the very best benefits we can I think that's one of the things just a name that I would recommend that we I'm go into the room with when we do a market analysis we do that every year we look at six districts bigger than us six districts smaller than us we include BV because 90% of revenue for school districts is based on size how many students you have so you look at the same districts with the same revenue streams that includes districts like Aspen and manitu um as well as other districts right um so it is a very good thing it looks at other districts that are in Mountain Resort communities um so it's pretty good when we look at our classified staff we're in a very
060good shape in many places we're paying over 20% more than districts our size to classified staff when we look we made changes um at Christmas to step and levels for classified made changes to certified steps increased that we also gave more experience for some of our veterans who transferred in um to help us continue to attract new people those yielded good benefits um the main group that's still behind when we look at the others would be teachers and I think we can dial in so my recommendation is um or interest to go in and say how can we get more money to the teacher whe that's base salary um they may have other ways to spend that but I think we have a strong interest in just focusing in on teacher pay and seeing what
061we can do with any new revenues that we'll have so those would be the two big Financial things I do not have uh from my knowledge any other big Financial asks that I know of so I'm going to pause there before we get on policy but from the compensation side um I think we got a pretty clear um set of interest to see if we can really do better for teachers and whatever money we have anybody want to talk about that CB if teachers would rather have monies that we have put in base pay or insurance premiums okay appreciate that and it may be both and and a little of this and a little of that I think that'll be a really good conversation that I'm expecting anyone else on the compensation side uh I
062was just trying to find it but I couldn't the the the the information from Tracy at Colorado School of Finance I thought was super helpful and it shows we're still behind State average is teacher pay pretty substantially um looks like like we're we're starting to close the gap and make that up so that's super encouraging but but we we we do need to continually lean into that space as much as we can um because I think the numbers where the average teacher pay was somewhere around 63 I'm kind of recalling from memory again but and ours was 53 so we're about 10,000 behind is my recollection and my question would be do we have a number about what 24% increase would look like Aaron you want to take a shot at that one okay okay
063yeah I'd be curious Matt with just kind of that data set that came out like how all-encompassing is it to do they have a bigger base but pay their premiums I was just curious in those components um yeah and I guess I'm going a different direction sorry but in terms of the uh um the payments on um oh there it is uh health insurance when we're when we're doing market analysis yeah how how many districts are paying 100% of you know and I can't answer that we do not because it's so hard you get into such um hard to make apples and apples comparisons um we do really well by what we do for staff it's um but I also haven't done a deep dive so I wouldn't want to speak publicly and make a
064guess that's incorrect also is that I mean I haven't read the report yet but is that like comparable districts to us is that what no that' be Statewide so I asked here we came out yesterday uh Colorado school Finance project gave us kind of a profile of the State versus Salida so you're going to mix in Boulder Valley and you're going to mix in mix in Lun and you're going to put the whole mix together to get that aggregate data uh that piece and I think when we come into it I think though I'd still recommend I think teacher salary and I would say base pay is kind of where i' initiated but other people may have other ways to spend the money and make it more beneficial but I think that's where we need
065to spend our energy um for any money that we're not putting into new Staffing or anything like that it's definitely helpful to know Statewide versus comparable districts obviously yeah and so I think we can get you both those pictures as we get into it um but we just got that yesterday and I know we haven't really analyzed to tear it apart and do really good sense making there's also where our rate of change has been much higher than the rest of the average of the state we've been more aggressive with making changes in the last five years um and we're about approximately um 425 42,500 for your very very basic starting point I'd love to see us get to 45 and keep on chasing in the $50,000 base that' be the what an interest I
066would recommend depending on the monies right depending on the student count depending on all lots of things this is really quick Pro right not based on perfect numbers but you're probably talking 300,000 for a 24% increase yeah I would say my three interests and maybe one of them is not necessarily the interest for cl barging but be um as we talk about kind of some of the restructure with Will's official retirement and what admin Staffing we need to kind of take the next step okay um we talked about curriculum advisors and teachers and coaches and all those things just there may be the additional need for more admin which no to get gutted for saying that but that's okay but that component um I always struggled with insurance because if you're an individual like you
067get your full premium paid correct me if I'm wrong but if you're on a family plan you're getting that same dollar amount versus like the percentage correct so if we went to a system where they are paying their premium I would be more in favor of everybody's paying 20% of their premium and it's not that inequitable for an individual versus singles or spouse or family coverage and then the last thing would just be to Echo what everybody has said yes like follow the financial plan put as much in the base salaries for all staff that we can okay anyone else on compensation they'll move us into policy yes Ben I have a question on the insurance are there are there different deductible levels that the teachers can pay that influence uh how much it costs
068um the way we have our design program there's kind of two options most people almost I think everyone now chooses what we would call a high deductible plan and then we're unique where the board's been able to set aside some monies and there's a health reimbursement account basically the district helped pick up the high deductible so Aon correct me if I say this poorly but it's a $6,000 dedu poorly what's that that's poorly it's a $5,000 Aaron please answer the question correctly no problem before you just sorry that was rude um yeah no it's a $5,000 max max out of pocket for individuals and the deductible max out of pocket match and then we cover 3,000 of your of that with an HRA um so you basically pay the first 2,000 and then we cover
069the next 3,000 so for an individual it's basically a $2,000 deductible but we're already on a high deductible plan and we're on the plan that's the highest deductible that we can get um we're shopping it I'll tell you that when they called me with the this rate I said that's 50% over three years we're shopping um the problem is our usage is crazy high and so even this year there's a lot of companies that are like you you're smart to shop you should wait until some of your big claims start to come off over the next year so I think we're GNA have a big Bill no matter what in terms of going up um but we did take it we changed the deductible last year and we actually picked up another thousand because we
070did have a $4,000 max out of pocket and we covered 2,000 we changed the deductible to 5,000 with the HRA picking up the extra thousand this year that's been working um we've got about 18 months left in the H usually we get a big um chunk of different insurance premiums or different insurance basically paybacks and for having really good premiums when on like Pinnacle for example and that money rolls into the HRA so usually it self- sustains it but we haven't seen those yet this year so we have about 18 months that we can guarantee that that's gonna last okay so can I just have a little recap so if you're on the district's Health Plan and you're for example one person the district pays 100% of the monthly premium for Health Vision dental and
071life yes and life life's mandatory with CB okay and then the deductible is the same for everyone yep which is what it's a $5,000 max out of pocket we're calling that high that's considered a high deductible plan yeah okay great and then um but there but the individual employees risk is 2,000 okay and so they pay the first 2,000 and then the district pays the rest of the high deductible and it's it's done without the way we run it it's not the employee never SE in yeah the employee never sees it um which is confusing for employees because they read their 5,000 but unless you are educated and we try to continue educating them you don't really understand that until all of a sudden you go over $2,000 and you never get another bill so
072some people maybe get that extra $3,000 benefit because they have more health care costs and some people don't yes or does everyone no it's I mean everybody has access to the benefit it just depends on if you use it throughout the course of the year yeah absolutely that's going to be variable so it's not that it's an incentive after you hit the 2,000 but no you don't get cash like it's not like it's we're just we're basically making the insurance plan better it's cutting down the out of pocket yep okay and I've had an H before yeah it's just nice because you pay your deductible usually I paid my full deductible and then got a check back for whatever the max HR would be but we don't do that no it's done in Billing we're
073able to manage it in Billing so the so it's user lose kind of no just it's the only way you could sustain it because your percentage probabilities are most people aren't going to need that f 5,000 yeah right and so or the 3,000 that's the second third or half of it it's it's not the high common thing and so your HRA can be self- sustaining um and continue to keep that risk low for all the staff and for the few people who need it who have a really difficult year then yeah right use benefit there so that's kind of how we've designed the system cool I know enough about insurance to be dangerous okay are there other like plan options I know not of better term that we should explore where we don't have an
074HRA but maybe we convert to HSA which we can contribute some to but the employee contributes mostly to their when we shop we look at those and we'll look at them again yeah yep yeah we're in the we're in the to shopping because one of the things you're in a trust right now with CBT So in theory you're getting the benefits of the trust then being able to go out negotiate rates the problem to that is the last three years we've been at the highest rate that the trust increases because the trust takes you as a population your your district and says okay you're at this usage rate which is the highest of everyone in the trust and the TR the max the trust is letting everyone go up is by 24% this year so
075you're getting that bill last year it was 17 the year before that it was 11 and we've been the highest every single year of that trust and so that's good except for if you're a small district and you're at a high usage and you're at the farthest end of the trust you're not actually getting any the benefit of the trust at that point you're actually getting the negative impacts of the Trust In some instances so we're shopping that to try to figure out can we do an individual plan that would be more effective um the problem is all of our data shows that we're really expensive right now whether that's for a variety of reasons but right some lovely things like babies and then some sad things like cancer yeah and also you know we
076live in a rural community where coverage is high yeah cost of coverage is high and so that's another another thing that's constantly working working through our we're mean with our local hospital to talk about billing we're going to explore everything um but from a CBT um just because I know it's getting late I want to keep us moving that's our interest right you got health insurance that's going to be a big thing how does how do we support our staff in compensation um and get the best solution and how do you balance that also with I think teacher pay is the area I think I'd really recommend us um to continue to invest in you did it again in January and we do it again and I think do it again um I think that's
077the one area that's got an area for growth it's also I think a good time to remember that we have a lot of really H wonderful hidden benefits that are not in that base pit yes covering the three the next $3,000 for the deductible 75% off your daycare for your children at the Early Childhood Center the great protections that we give for those serious medical issues ETC but again that's not for all right not everybody has a child at the early child's Care Center or uses their deductible right so right but where a p would right not everyone uses those every single year but we retained a leader because of the Early Childhood Center right Etc you don't you know you're not going to have cancer every year and your Early Childhood Center but there's
078a lot of really nice benefits and care that we give everybody it's nice package so let's move so policy would be the other area you've got those we've kind of referred to them as the blue policies because we had them colorcoded last year those policies we did not finish those will be up on the docket I see no reason why those won't be addressed and move through I feel pretty confident about that one of those that is left out there is that uh sabatical um and so if you have strong firm opinions you can of that space then we can make those things known um so those are some of them and our lawyers is really recommending we look at some of uh just our professionalism policy their lawyers recommending high so I'm going to
079be taking the lawyers recommendations back to that team but there aren't too many other policies there'll be some small tweaks and changes around our PTO we're like oh that phrase isn't as clear as we need to we'll be making some recommendations around some of those pieces but um definitely seems like PTO was a big success from the initial data um so we're excited about that and it's been well received and being managed successfully um so lots to celebrate but when I look at a policy I think cleaning up some of the kind of ragged edges we weren't able to finish up last season and I think I don't have any suspicion or concern that we won't be able to finish them up and so I think we'll be able to do that piece sabatical might
080be the only one um that's obviously had a lot of conversation around it so if you want to is there any other policies you want to be concerned um with the professionalism policies is that where we would put something regarding staff use of cell phones that's where we're considering or I'm going to be considering to put for instance if we're saying staff can't have cell or students can't have cell phones we need to say something that says staff if you're supervising students unless it is a emergency or work rated there's some clear exceptions then you shouldn't be on your phone um if you're supervising kids so and currently with how sabatical stands because I just haven't read it for like a year was it that they were requesting it to be paid still yes they
081were still requesting it um I need to go back and read it Mandy because I because I think that's kind of maybe just a pertinent abuse to throw into the health insurance premium and base pay is pangra spaical might not be as high of a priority anymore that's good to know I'm just saying like looking at a paid sabatical policy like if we're looking at a 25% increase in premiums and wanting to increase base pay maybe paying for sabatical is becoming a lower priority it's a great great thought to put that into the conversation appreciate that is there any other policy you guys like hey we really need to look at this piece think we did a lot of deep hard work and I think it's paying off yeah I would say my stance on
082sabatical hasn't changed I don't think we should offer it and if we do I don't think it should be paid and then keep it out of the board okay so all right is there anything else uh that's negotiated policy that you guys want to make sure that um I address with the bargaining team or anything around compensation those will be the two areas that they speak to um it is a week and a half away and that's the training and then the next week we kind of start into interest and then it's not until April we get a little more into the deeper uh like compensation so there's there is um there's time because there's so many variables right now we don't even have a really a good guest on the state budget which is
083around a billion dollar shortfall um as it's currently drafted there's just a lot of pieces and parts so we're going to be working on policy on the front just four meetings I don't expect us to need more than four meetings assuming the budget from the state and all that stuff comes in an orderly manner that's understandable and lets us all make commitments I don't have any reason to suspect we will need more than the four meetings which I know is a strong value of many board members to limit those conversations you have a full team uh there's one or two spots we're still trying to fill but we're getting there yep a lot of new faces and some of the same will be still there so I think it should be a good cross good
084cross-section of sites and um people from different working classifications be to represent I think it's going to be a good representative team um and I'm meeting regularly with CA we meet about once a month just talking to things trying to make sure we're have a good pace and there's no surprises as we head into those conversations it's not the only thing we talk about um but that'll be in the mix as well okay we'll move into the next discussion item board policy management platform yeah you Kim this is probably me Kim and I because so what we've recommended we're finishing up our audit of comprehensive I will be doing inj with Karen um and you should expect that in your February board report some first reading kind of stuff from that last two books of
085audits that's the Hope um with that being said where do we want to publish it how do we want to manage it um there's some companies like bardocks there's some other ones I think my key question here it's not a big conversation am I being asked to go bring back bids or do you want me to not go down that road and just stay with the staff stat quo like that's kind of the question we needed to publicly make sure we talk through I really enjoyed the prods for keeping things in a little nicer more accessible I support that personally yeah yeah to me the the price point seemed pretty minimal for for board dogs was it like $5,000 I forget and was in that range I haven't we don't have a bid so and
086then you know the amount we're GNA save in terms of Kim's time and freeing up that and um additional features that it brings in terms of communication with the public which is always a strong priority you know to to me it's kind of a no-brainer that we should be moving in that direction I mean if there's other options out there and you guys want to explore and bring those back uh that'd be great but I haven't seen any um maybe there are well and I I mean I think like you mentioned the public involvement like I think one of the best things about his presentation was that people can opt in to have the agendas emailed to them every month and then they can be more informed because clearly tonight when there was a topic
087that people were invested in we had a lot of people show up so if people are more aware of seeing agendas and what we're talking about then we might have more Community engagement of people showing up when they see things on the agenda okay and I really liked the ease of finding policies and was just very well organized just want to make sure we had that you know some conversation at the Colorado Association School boards conference and I just want to make sure that some public moment to make sure that's processed What I Hear pretty clearly is we should go ahead and pursue getting some bids and what that would look like so we can unpack that and bring that back to you that'd be February or March so I don't think I need any
088more guidance unless someone wants to add something you feel that's a implementation onboard usage beginning next school year uh let me go give me 30 60 days and I'll come back and answer those questions okay now we need a break I'm told so 5 to 10 minute break Mike's e e e welcome back moving into action items looking for a motion to approve action out of a approve on second reading policies all we have is the stien policy so thank you Ben thank you Ben questions comments further discussion I guess I don't really know what my comment should be about it I feel like like hearing Jesse talk about the Esports program and being in a pilot but then that policy says like you have to have the three years before you're paid and you
089have to have a minimum of 10 students so I guess I'm just confused where is the pilot that they're doing with orts outside of our policy and if so do we need to have some sort of bridge policy where like I don't believe the teacher doing the Eastport shouldn't be getting paid but current but per that policy it seems as if you have to have a three-year period before they would get paid and you have to have 10 students so my concern is just like what we're doing with that pilot is not matching our policy we're trying to make it match the policy okay so they're jumping there and I'm saying no you got policy you need to stay within this okay so you are aware so you have already disc so we're trying to
090stay within that and the board would have to say oh we're going to accelerate this this or that because if you don't um it'll backfire it'll open up a can of worms that we don't want to because somebody else have a passion point that may not support kids who don't have something right now may do more of what they talked about we stealing from an current program but it's their passion point so I think we're looking for consistency so I mean what is our thought process then on how you pilot something where you're very unlikely to have more than 10 kids if you're just starting this out I think what it's the what what way we set it up was so someone just doesn't get a a whim and a passion for that year they
091have to have the structures of of those you know boards and the extra volunteers having ni I don't think we'll have a problem having 10 kids on that yeah I wouldn't think so either I think it'll meet a niche Niche excuse me um but you got to give it a some leeway some testing to make sure it's not one person shows up oh do this and then we put all this infrastructure in place and then that person disappears and it all disappears with them um so I I think it's still the right policy and I think that's what we're going to try and follow with Esports in addition trying to use Title 9 surveys um and also trying to really dig deeper in that policy to say what else do we need was mentioned with
092the student group at least one place you guys reported out that maybe we need some other activities available for females um so that I think will also be added in the mix and should go through that policy um and if the board says no we want to push this faster then it's got to come to the board and the board's going to have to say we want to do some exception here we want to make it happen and then not the policy itself but the regulation policy is that where all the amounts sit um yeah and that's the part I think we need to come back in you're talking about coaching pay in that sense yeah like all the various sens yeah because you got chassa which is its own thing um you've got these
093couple and then you got like supervising students that's a stipended um like trying to take care of ascent kids that's it's like its own academic programming thing and then you've got we want to have a mountain bike team right it's not in chassa it's so it gets its own kind of thing so we've got to go back it's one of the things I don't know if it'll be this spring but definitely next 12 months you're going to see some recommendations where we need to probably um up those amounts I don't want to add that to the CBT interest because it's not negotiated but like they're feedback regarding stiens would be would we have more staff coaching if we had better pay or is that the issue I'll probably try and ask a lot of different
094of our input things from The Faculty group like stent academic or superintendant academic Council CBT I'll SCA I'll see if I can get any feedback that helps us have a broader perspective on that space But want to get gbcb cleaned up this is part of what came out in the fall um program evaluation those kind of things and then regulation policy would to come after that so with the gbcb as it is like there's no red lines or anything on it so have we made any changes I'm looking at the board packet right now I can I can make sure for third reading and we got it 100% right I'm just I'm just trying to figure out what we've actually should be the last section there was a lot of crossed out I didn't see
095a red line but oh there is a last paragraph that just cross out it's totally because that goes more to the regulation stuff trying to okay see it yes okay any other questions about that one okay ready for a vote ready Dr P hi Dr Hill hi Mr H hi Mrs Lumber hi Mrs H hi M shman hi and Mr hi okay looking for a motion to approve on first reading policy jcj student use of cell phones thank Mandy all down in history um I would just add to it for get into discussion on that position paper there's a first draft um appreciate Matt linked in today on that position paper here's the link to ours um I think for second reading that's where we got some that's where the robust conversation needs to be
096um Chen if I remember right you kind of volunteered to help steamroll that so I don't know if there's any feedback or anything at this point but we would hope then and to bring something back in February because I don't hear anything from the community says slow down I don't know if anybody heard something different it's already pretty slow do you think um as for the policy just procedurally so we have the new policy that you're working from from d11 do we can we just get rid of our policy yeah and have the new one we don't have to like draw a bunch of headed lines and write it all again okay thanks da y just when I was trying to compare those and see what it would look like we'll just have one I
097mean one other question Jen and I were kind of going through too is we have these position papers which kind of give our why behind the policy yep is there a reason why that wouldn't just be the beginning of the policy so that it's a little bit more teeth in it like part of me feels like these position papers are sort of like I mean they don't mean anything like they're not a policy they can't be enforced it's just our opinion about something and the next board could just go on the website and wipe them all off whereas if it's a policy then there has to be discussion in a process to do away with it so is there a reason why you wouldn't want all that overview just in the policy as opposed to
098disos paper you ask can I'm gonna answer as a superintendent I'm gonna answer as a dad okay the superintendent is so helpful and you're trying to lead a system to have Clarity not just the policy and you could put those first paragraphs of the Y in there that's common in a policy but to also have the place of here's the research here's the people to contact here's the other policies you can put that on a policy and encapsulate it um so that's it is super helpful though sometimes there's not a policy um like we were looking at you know discipline data kind of as part of what we're looking at this month and to say here's toxic stress here's healthy stress and the board to take a position you can make a policy out of
099that or you can just make the public aware um and I think it's super helpful as a dad kid was my fourth kid through the system I would love a public system that stated more clearly the whole robust position on key topics um that deal with particularly in things like human development um where more Family Values can be conflicting in a governmental system that we have to run it makes me so happy as a superintendent be able to talk about it and then to also Point parents or other community members why don't you look at this it's more robust it's why I'm excited about it and what you said is also true you could go either direction but I appreciate it from like a public information outward communication standpoint and that it you know to
100me it can be I don't think there's much legal jargon in the policies in this one but it can be well this is like yes the why and everything else then here's the policy yeah future board could wipe it all out or whatever but I think with some of the stuff and the outward Communications we're working on just be helpful to a point place to say here's where it is the data uh links for like other research just but I do I don't disagree that putting some of those initial comments and policies like a bad idea Mandy onethird of my table asked for just that that you're suggesting putting that position paper before the policy so it was interesting from a community standpoint as in in the policy or just before policy included in the
101policy though and I do think it you know this is a a policy that's uncommon in some manner right this wouldn't really apply to many many of our policies and so you whether it's in it or before it like this I think with a big change and some strong opinions it is nice to be able to point to some document either in or separate from the policy saying this is how the board kind of feels so six to a half dozen if you keep the context which is the what the position paper out of it then your policy has more long-term sustainability the more you embed current like the you know this right now is something from the um youth Mental Health crisis and US Surgeon General like you put that in there like you're
102kind of dating your policy instantaneously that's another thing to think about and I was reading through the old policy like wow it just keeps going and we're not doing it so maybe it' be nice to just have a short one that just said this is the policy enjoy I will say one of the components of my student table was I feel like the distraction of text messages via a watch is still going to be persistent so not sure if just the phones would be problematic like they they felt like getting rid of it all maybe the best solu we did have students mention how hard it is to get back on track or how challenging it can be to get back on track when they just look at anything on their phone I'm not sure
103they were specific with what it was but just that it does take some time yeah and I made some comments to the policy that I I I think it should be include all technology devices and the both the policies that I link to the District 111 policy and the Boulder Valley School District they're they're they're across all devices they're not just cell phones I don't I tried to look up ason but I couldn't couldn't find it but if you're trying to limit distractions which is really what we're talking about whether it's BEC coming from social media or something else it's it's the it's the you know if you're getting pinged on your wrist um it's going to take you five 10 minutes maybe more that once that happens to you know refocus when I did
104ask um Abigail cie about airpods because I was wondering and you know also asking my kids because they do use them in class right they're compatible with their Chromebooks so when they're watching videos or doing things online in class they are using them so it's just it's hard to know how deep we want to dive into the policy how specific we want to be with enforcement like do we need to say at the high school because they're used here but then when you're outside please don't use the you know I I suggested some language just to address that issue as well in the policy that that there needs to be some exception I think for like the issue the broadcasting teacher brought up it's like well we use these until there's a technology solution and
105there there may be a class where a teacher says I want to use cell phones for this and that needs to be in the policy just like your earbuds like well we're gonna use earbuds and I think it does need to be school specific and class specific and approved by administration because I feel that many to most teachers currently feel that it is appropriate to give students a break and let them be on their phones and I certainly strongly disagree with that but I see your point about a specific class but yeah it's a slippery slope for me and what about the kids in the class that don't have the phones I don't know how it works for them but again I don't know well and even in terms of watching the videos and needing
106the airpods like I would think with this we have the opportunity to to move to just a different model in general where the teacher puts video on the screen and we're all watching it together and then talking about it like why are we watching it on our own Chromebook like so I feel like if we're looking at things like that then yeah do they really need airpods you know I can I mean my kids will come to the table sometimes and I can tell immediate because they're just a little disengaged from dinner like do you have V prods in take them out so but a teacher can't monitor 30 kids in a classro so if we just say you can't have them um I mean my table was pretty specific that they felt like all
107technology airpods watches all of it needed to be gone and making the comment that now the watches aren't distracting but they feel like if kids don't have their phone the watches will become a bigger deal because they will start texting more on their watches and they will will start being more engaged which is likely true um right and there is the equality issue and that you know not everybody can afford a smartwatch or has one and I just think strong I I truly believe that as States and Nations be you know make these rules and we all move forward with this they're the companies are going to come out with something to bypass it or something to sell to families and students which will be different so it's a whole another just same same yeah
108but a different device that we're so do we make a list or do we just have a blanket all just you know all I mean technology I mean I don't support the watch situation obviously I I think that's a lot of enforcement a lot of asking kids to push their sleeves up I don't know like personal opinion I don't know turn off the notifications if we hear it ping I I don't know although mine does vibrate um but I I don't I would be interested to hear what administration and what teachers think about that like are we are we telling everyone to pull up their sleeves are we asking if they have the internet is it just a dumb watch that looks like a smart watch I don't know yeah and I would say my
109my thought after hearing kind of conversation and timeline is like if said we're not ready for second reading until March does that issue because I I think we might need a little bit more time we have like the implementation timeline of starting it in the next school year so I I I don't know what we need more time for exactly because like you know it's great to get community feedback but it's pretty loud and clear well we I think we also need to hear from students more so than just the little the few that we had today what would you want to know from students not an opinion whether that we should do it or not just how they feel just give them a voice they haven't had that opportunity and this is affecting them
110this is their this is a huge part of their lives and they have to make some pretty serious adjustments so I think the more like it's awesome like what you guys said to take this back I think Manda you told them the three that were with us felt very strongly that we do ban everything and they were very positive about it they felt strongly about it so Mandy said you know go back and talk to your friends about this so if we start these conversations I think it'll make that transition easier so it may be yeah another meeting or more conversation but I think they need a voice in this it's pretty huge part of their especially high schoolers I worried that no matter what they say there's not a planet where I change my
111mind no and I that's what I said I don't want to like be also no because it's not pacifying them are like great you can tell me everything you want and then you can write a book called The anxious generation that's better than the anxious generation and tells me why we can have phones and let me know in five years you know what I mean like there's nothing they can but I think if we frame it in a sense that you're not we're not going to change it because you don't want it we're going to do this but give them a voice as to how because I think there's ways and I think that's why um counselors are going to be talking here this next month around what would the communication cycle including um explaining
112things to kids engaging them what does that need to be I think we need that um let me just throw out a pro just some process not product but yes ma'am could that be um us sitting with student council and they have a student council meeting because they represent the student body could that be a Survey Monkey yeah I don't I don't have a answer to how I just think we should if I don't know I I think it was important the kids that were here today it meant a lot to them to be able to share good I think we definitely there's multiple levels there's some asking some listening and there's also some explaining and right engaging particularly need into the how the how's the tricky part on this one I think um I'm
113just looking at Jen because she's kind of the volunteer and obviously I think another board member helping is great but what if next month in the board meeting there's a discussion imagining bringing back two different policies and you can look at the pros and cons kind of side by side fleshing out kind of this strategy that's an initial one we have laid out and maybe fleshing out one that's more um aggressive on the breadth of technology that we're trying to say no to because then it have to have the and this is how we're going to say no to these things right that going to be the tricky part like how you going to manage it how you going to implement it and if we could bring that back have a discussion side by side
114that's what I would need as a thinker to be able to evaluate it and then we could and what can our process be because I I don't feel like normally when we write a policy are we looking for as much um engagement maybe from staff who is dealing with this like I I would want to hear like how do they feel about banning these things versus this thing and how does that look in their school because what I don't want to do is mess up in either direction and then we fail like we ban too much or we ban not enough right but if we could put a side by side then you could float it towards staff and get feedback you could look at it and kind of say oh I really want this
115now that I'm really evaluating it it's not coming out the way I thought I don't love it side by side because I think it just so much is the same like like that's well written I trust you and Jen and whoever else and some of the work mats put into it already to like come up with a pretty robust policy that we can review make some further edits to get some further feedback on to bring back you know whatever time prit is for second reading and then final third reading um you know I do think Mandy brought it up of like I don't know what data sets we can actually gather that's meaningful pre and post post adoption but I do think that there's some of that that we should try to do to be
116able to review the policy in X number of years and I think we've already got a lot of that I was talking to Jessica Beno that's another thing I'll be looking to that Wellness counselor team of we already have in place it's also discipline data it's also looking I mean we have a lot of the indirect like even testing data right like yeah and I you know and talking to Mrs Bena it was well I think we could maybe just do some ception data what are your hopes and ask and pre and post and because she's like we're not going to get into a deep mental health evaluation that's that's too much but it's like we could do some perception data both on the staff side and the student side well not to interrupt but
117I think it's important also to talk about intentions because even if our test scores don't go up one iota and we just don't have kids on phones in school that's fine with me I mean I I don't support a cell phone ban because I higher test score I mean yes it would be great or it would be great if there were less mental health issues but again that's not my personal intention it's the distraction right it's like let's learn at school so yeah maybe we need to talk more about intentions and and Jesse was at my table so the the median four and a half hours like I heard from him and he was like the winter was 10 hours and 11 hours a day like so that's clearly a lot um so you know
118I think just and I think the other piece someone at my table and from the community group and some of the students kind of said the same thing of like the educational pieces like you're we need to like hear it from an outside source of like the dangers of social media and why some of this is coming forward and then even some of the components of like just the distraction I think I think some of that educational piece I don't know if that's appropriate in the spring or if it's in the fall kind of when implementation happens but that was pretty loud and clear from both kind of segments of if we're doing this we need to have like education on why and the dangers you know social media and all those types of things
119and then you know the students were kind of like yeah I'd really love to know the why more than just like you don't want us on our have a book suggestion for them I mean I that's partly why I think we should stick with our current timeline of second reading next month third reading in March and then really have April and May to ideally I mean I think it would fall to Jessica and her team a lot at the high school and the counselors at the other schools of use advisory time have a school assembly like and and tell kids why we're doing this um but I also feel like we've all done a lot of research we've read a lot of policies we've read a lot of books I'm not sure we need any
120more time to come up with more ideas I think now what I would most like to see is I would like to see from each principal and team like the actual implementation do they agree with us that just keeping it in a backpack we take it we see it we take it it goes to the office a parent picks it up do they agree with that or do they think that's not going to work and they need something else like I feel like we're at that stage where we need the people on the ground to tell us if we're on track I will say as a father I recognize it to an extent I like light bulb Bly moment tonight was like how many students said like the social anxiety of hearing a text message
121and needing to respond is like such an issue that to me was like wow it's not just social media and just mindlessly it is like a social stigma of I have to respond to my friend group or I'm a bad friend who hopefully won't be texting them because they won't be on their phone okay I think I have some thoughts what I'm going to shoot for if I'm listening well there's a variet we're all on the same page but we're not all in the same paragraph um in terms of some of the nuances here and this isn't a nuanced conversation um so um Jen and I I don't know if somebody else wants to join us at that second board member we'll shoot for a second reading and then if we get into that second
122reading and it turns into discussion and we table it till March we can do our process that way um and try and look at that piece I can be very clear with you on principal sides um as the initial draft is out that's very doable makes sense I think it matches our learning from Ling other districts that just take it straight up first couple weeks and then it fades away um my middle school staff speaking through m Michelle Saab is and we really like to look at the distraction side which is what I think you just articulated Joe um of trying to reduce the distractions that's more of having somebody with like the bags and trying to look at the the watches the more uh robust way to try and address that they have an
123interest in not just the social media but also the distraction aspect um and when I will push into that space and say how and can you that's when there's like there's not a lot of solid like we know how to tackle um that more aggressive stance like who's at the door checking devices and going through that piece so it just brings up the management of it right but that's where it is let me I think I've got enough feedback to go ahead and do the next step in addition to um could you create a draft form for accommodations kids who are allowed to wear headphones and test for medical issues or diab I mean the high school implied to me that that is already under control that the high school implied to me that they've
124got that under control they know which kids they're working with and that those are so you don't that's not a a parental form then that needs to happen well have to put language in the policy that says here's how you get an exception here's the general exceptions that are allowable and here's the pathway okay and it'll point to some sort of a regulation those are legal obligations yeah correct yeah like a text to speech uh kid who needs to do text to speech is an example of that English as a second language there and then my sorry you done um my question is I'm sitting here thinking is this a budget issue also in the sense that will we need another counselor like I I'm hearing the students I'm hearing us the books we've read
125the research we've done like this is we're taking away an addiction for eight hours a day are do we have support for some of these students who it really might create more anxiety more like it may be hard I mean obviously it will be hard for many many students but are we going to have support for those students who it's truly a anxiety issue I believe so okay um and it's a question that I don't know that you we can fully predict from what I know and see I think the answer is yes there students who have the least um will be one of the profile kiddos that'll be because they may own very little and you're you're into something where they have very little Turf of their own and very little control and it
126may even be their friendship their whole but most of those kids are already getting high support from The Faculty hire for that space I think your budget constraints are going to be around if you want to be more um have a more robust thing more robust policy that addresses the distractionary side um then you are going be looking at additional staff to probably implement that there's an initial response but I think let's draft's policy let's look at it let's look at the unintended consequences let's add deeper questions yeah I mean that's what I was going to say too so one of the ladies at our table her sister teaches in d11 and they actually hired a lot of new staff at all of their buildings to essentially be cell phone police like they're the ones
127there in the morning helping check them all in they're the ones that if a cell phone's in a class clro they just call them and they come pick it up so that's another reason why we really do have to have this done by March is depending on our implementation there are budget potential budget things that we need to consider so not even just the mental health but like logistical do we need logistical staff depending on how we do this and then I would also just technology is going to be one of those things where every Board of Education every year is going to have to say do we have to take the next step you're not going to resolve any technology interface with humanity and developing humans and get it so your approach has to
128be we got this this shifted let's shift like there's going to have to be a story where every Board of educationist as we all come and go in these seats goes how is the interface the cyborg storyline rolling out um today right because it is not going to stay put and the pace of change with AI is going to rearrange so many things that have never been rearranged in human history and that's the kind of magnitude we are in light of there is a large large conversation so just to also say we may take the right Next Step you will never take the last step um so encourage yourselves of okay what can we see see what can we do take that step so that we can see the next one and take it um
129and I know all of us would like to get it right to get it right will be the relationship and the conversation with our staff our families and our developing humans of this tension that we're walking out because in order to make money and live independantly you must go deeper with technology in order to grow into a health the human you must find independent something internal to manage that and that is the world our children are going to walk into um so it's not a once and done so maybe let's at our first reading leave it there let's take a shot let me bring some stuff back um and I'm excited because I think our community came and spoke got Clarity and I think we can take the next step in and and continue um
130to take the steps that our kids need as we look at these issues I would say my final comment would be I saw some commentary about suspensions I don't think that would be appropriate because then they just G to go home and be on their phone bring their suspension but then also you know you mentioned it a little bit with the technology I know we're not always going to be there but um I know we're doing the best we can on constraint budgets and things but it's always a little discouraging when it's like oh my Chromebook doesn't work or it's slow or this that the other another budgetary piece that may need to come into play depending on maybe they don't need airpods because we're going to be like the airplane and just need you
131need some buds for today so connect them to your device yep okay ready for a vote all right Dr bre pit Dr h hi Mr Hobs Mrs Lumber hi Mrs Pas hi Miss shman hi and Mr Smith hi okay moving down to approve the amended 2425 budget and the associated appropriation resolution 2024 25-06 five excuse me looking for a motion thank you good David Aaron more details we need on this one any questions from the board I don't think there's necessarily more I hope hopefully you found the video helpful as we walked through that there wasn't huge changes in terms of quantity from what you saw last month there was a couple big number changes the uh the tentative agreement went up a little bit as I showed you there was about $100,000 risk based
132upon appeals and things like that we're still working through the appeals but I budgeted them all in there as if they all were accurate because that's how quickly we had to move um so that's why you saw that go up by about 80,000 and then there was a revenue stream um that I'm still a little unclear on on the state I actually think we're going to get more in state share than what they gave us in December but just to give you context of the the complication of the budget that we're working on David mentioned we have a billion dollar shortfall in the state budget next year and so in November 1st you get the governor's first budget for next year um um and then late November we get our Mill lovies for this year
133and then we get our first run of that in December then I get a December run on the budget request for the governor for next year and then in December they also said well we're also trying to review the at risk and elll population so you'll get another updated one for this year in January which is still coming but today I also got an update on the governor's budget request for next year again so we're working on constantly these multiple budgets um I I'm not concerned about that Revenue stream I TR I budgeted it where the last number they gave me but I actually think we're going to get more once they review our at risk and elll kids even if it doesn't come through though it's still within the tolerances that we built into
134the financial plan and it goes back to the strategy where we're paying off some of our PTO balance out of onetime fund balance which after the audit you saw we have enough to do that in our fund balance so I'm still not worried about it I think it meets all the goals that you've had um I think that's the big stuff I just want to be transparent AR because those are the changes from last year so for the public I think it's good to restate that maybe but if you have any more questions uh happy to go into more detail on any of that the only other thing I I would say is I think Jody you did ask a question um via email about trying to read the tea leaves on Rural and Bs
135factor and my answer going forward is until they put it in there we're operating as if it the rural the rural U money is now in the formula we're expecting to get it there is no BS Factor attached to it and we have a billion dollar short B so I don't know we're never going to know until the moment they say oh we had to fix the budget and we had to take money out of schools but for some positive note on that the run that I got literally at 7:30 tonight so it shows you CD is working as we speak um the governor's budget request has us getting more money than his last budget request so I don't know how that's functioning but we're it's I don't have an answer to that te LEF
136question but I'm just continuing to operate off the dollars they give us until they tell us they're taking away so that's where I'm back I heard the deficit was down to 750,000 million 750,000 sorry million okay yeah yeah sorry add some zero sorry it's all right you're a banker I'm a banker yeah you no I mean it's yeah I think they're updating that I did actually see something that Tracy Ry had sent out that was they had just updated that about a week ago as well um the the point is we have a lot of money that they're trying to figure out right now and yet we keep getting more money in our in our formula so I'm not sure how that's functioning so in answer to that question I'm operating off the numbers they
137give us until they tell us they're changing that number but I think that's everything if you have questions happy to answer one General budget question and I know think it kind of is erratic is there marijuana money still like coming to the district from the taxes and like does the lack of a grow facility in chaffy County make a difference to slid of school district because it's just state right yeah I not that I know of I don't see it anywhere in the formula and then locally that would be in our property T the only the only way it could change I mean I guess if we had a grow facility and they were paying dollars tax dollars on that then that would increase our M Levy a little bit as well um I just
138heard today about the metab monies the county gets and how that will yeah go away know would impact us I sit on that comme and um it has plummeted um and but that does not that's different from property tax it's from the sales tax from a former right from our former production grow facility it it's going to impact our partners very very much like 10% of what we used to have any other questions what's our current fund balance you know like current as of today or as of the last because yeah I mean I know I know it fluctuates but I'm just trying to get a sense yeah I mean the current fund balance at the end of the year to total is like 5.2 million is our projected okay um but that includes unassigned
139and all of our Taber and things like that which is a decrease of 700,000 it was 5.8 10 last year okay thanks yeah sorry no poorly worried question it's a good question ready for a vote all right Dr be P hi Dr Hill Mr hop M Lumber M Pas hi mman hi Mr hi looking for a motion to approve resolution 24 20 any 24256 authorizing the use of a portion of the beginning fund balance as authorized by Colorado statutes yeah second Jody Aon anything want out here no I mean this is just attached to that that that's this is that exact number that we're projecting a decrease I the only thing would add that I've shared with all of you and I guess again I would want to be transparent I never really think we're
140going to fully actualize that decrees I think we always budget for all of our positions and I try to do the best we can in an amended budget but even now we have a couple positions that are open so most likely it won't be that big we'll probably spend less of our fund balance than 670,000 by the end the year but I think you should always count on that being the case otherwise we're we're budgeting poorly V Dr Dr Hill Mr lber hi hi okay Kudos let's wrap this thing up board Communications committee reports Mandy anything from bosies um I just pulled up that agenda we just had that meeting there's not really much going on we're reviewing policies doing the executive director evaluation um yeah she's got a good strategic plan I feel like
141they're definitely dialing in and focusing a lot on high quality education um for sped so she yeah I I'm impressed with Susan and her what she's doing so beautiful facilities committee Karen Joe we we're talking still about the quadplex David probably sometime this month we should fire off that email to the county since the land they sworn in newbies are sworded okay copy um nothing else there for me Communications J Mt hold on oh Ben do you have something I just turn my ready Jen McKim probably should have acknowledged in BO of their comments but kudos to another great annual report yeah lots of good feedback it arrived in my mail box thank you that's the exciting thing I made a comment last month and about just like continuing to fill out content lacking the
142better as I was away my wife yelled at me because she's like I cannot find an email for anybody in the district even though there says there's a directory so just we actually this week go to the main website the directory is live I know it's coming but just continue to little little bits and pieces it's it's coming the two people still listening casby Jen no thank you Dak Ben nope policy audit nothing more no good no future business uh biggest thing Mandy sent out that email for David's evaluation trying to get that done by February 1 so she can out the data for the February board meeting whether or not we have a February second board meeting still TBD um but hope to wrap that up February March waiting on some data back from
143the survey results that we always wait for and then have those com conversations of David's contract again so and then everything else nothing much nothing much going on uh next meeting February 11th here in the crest probably back upstairs we're probably back upstairs okay anyone uh anybody ready to volunteer for a agenda review Jody um as I said special meetings Retreats we talked about the third 4ish week of February don't know if that's still needed but can't remember exactly what we're were going to use for that if you needed a second meeting in February the two key topics would be we really need to spend more time talking about I think the phone thing right clearly we see tonight still it's there's a lot of nuance there so that could take some necessary meeting time
144and then I think the other piece is kind of getting ourselves set up for for Budget season in terms of new positions and how that looks for redesigning and focusing on kind of academic issues which I think is where I'm hearing kind of for the next season is to really we get to go back um not so much operational stuff but really dig into just prick instruction and pedagogy and what's the right structure of Physicians there could be some robust dialogue that requires another meeting to have those two things so that I can keep going back and forth between different stakeholders and making that making that all come together so that would be the two topics that are it's kind of bubbling up for me right now that may require another meeting in February tues
145could do it a couple different ways or a morning meeting I don't see eight hours unless somebody else tells me something different I see you could do a morning meeting maybe 8 to 12 I think you can get through much most of anything you need to get through can you call it a retreat if it's at night um you know we violate the word Retreat all the time you say like this Call It Whatever you um we can grind here and all those things but those are be the two topics that may that may not be able to fit in the February meeting and the March meeting in and of themselves this was a very late one I really appreciate everyone giving a long night like I scheduled all these kind of talking sessions back
146in June and July and I think it was worth our time but I don't have I don't think we can be successful trying to do this three or four months in a row of going this late at night that's not what we think is best normally so it may require a second meeting for pull out those topics for the or structure stuff there's probably a component in there of Hosting for Will's position and timing for that yep so so um sell he's resigned or retired a different word um and we'll be bringing him back on for special projects next year in a real halftime setting um to kind of highlight his strengths and I'm recommending and the admin teams in the same place replacing that position with another assistant superintendent um I'll be talking with
147like the academic Council and talking to some other fa and just listening so that I would imagine is putting out a press release that has announcement of him changing as well as here's what we're looking for in Timeline okay looking for a motion to adjourn a tojn boom thank you Mandy 1020 Mike's off good job Josh you got us over there