CorpusRecord 1745

Superintendent's Workshop 12 p.m. 1-13-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Indian River County School Board
Date
2025-01-13
Location
Indian River County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,839 words · about 155 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e Workshop to order the time is 12: noon I wish to welcome you to the superintendent's workshop being held at the Joe and Idol at Jr Tec I ask that out of respect for everyone please silence all electronic devices also if you have any material you wish to share with any board member please give that to our executive assistant Miss Mor we'll take a break every two hours board members and if you need one before them please let me know and just reminder board members we are in a workshop but please wait to be recognize before speaking and before we begin this meeting Dr B I just like to congratulate you and this district for wonderful graduation rates let's give them a round of applause everybody about that um it is so great

002to see that and um our high schools did a great job and you know that's a K12 working system when we do that so thank you to everybody and um I think we'll go ahead and get going going so Dr Moore please explain the purpose of this workshop and then start with our items thank you madam chair the intent of this Workshop is to present items and receive feedback from the board um specifically items that will be coming before the board at an upcoming business meeting as just discussed by Dr Jones graduation rates were released last Thursday afternoon um we didn't get a lot of notice that they were going to be released this early typically it would be probably this Friday but we were excited to receive them and as you can see from

003the screen here the state's overall graduation rate is 90 up from 89 so congratulations to us as a state but when you look specifically here local Indian River county is a grad uation rate of 96% and Sebastian Senior High School Leading The Way with a graduation rate of 98 and viral Beach uh hanging in at a very solid 97% um and I hit the wrong button as you were saying Dr Jones graduation rate is a great indicator of the strength of a system typically high schools have the graduation rate associated with them because that's ultimately where kids are graduating but it is a K12 approach in order to ensure every single child has the opportunity to walk across that stage it's just not what happens in the classroom is it extremely important 100% but it

004is extracurricular activities it is coaches it is relationships it is the clubs it is the experience that someone ex uh engages in over the course of 12 Years so to go from 89 in 1819 to a graduate uation rate of 96 is something we all should be proud of that is the fourth highest graduation rate in the State of Florida The Three Counties that are in front of us are extremely small matter of fact if you added all of their graduating classes up it doesn't equal to to our graduating class so we're we're very very proud of that 96 was the graduation rate last year maintaining 96% is extremely hard and difficult to do so we are glad that we actually did when you look at at 18119 going into the end of last school

005year 11 percentage increase in Black graduation rate Hispanic a 14% Improvement White plus five students with disabilities plus4 and economically disadvantage students plus 11 so continuing to see minor improvements when you're at 96 it's hard to see improvements it's about maintaining the area where where you're at and we are happy to produce those outcomes so now we jump in ensuring these graduation rates stay exactly where they need to be in in the coming years and continue ultimately to grow as we engage in the initial conversation kind of the kickoff of what will be our upcoming strategic plan so as a reminder we are in the closing year of a five-year strategic plan so we created this initial uh strategic plan in the midst of the pandemic it is in my mind find one of our

006Innovative keys to Our Success one of the Innovative things that we're doing when creating that strategic plan I wanted to be very intentional because I was new to the system of modeling accountability when I say modeling accountability uh making sure I was giving or showing to our principles that I'm going to hold myself accountable to what's absolutely the most important so we created a unique connection between my evaluation in the district strategic plan my evaluation in large part is the annual outcomes that is approved by this board which is very very bold and courageous we could have gone with a strategic plan that says conduct X number of professional developments attend X number of community events though this is an outcome driven strategic plan and it's 100% linked to my progress or evaluation areas that

007we have already engaged in this creation of our upcoming strategic plan is to take additional looks at early childhood education uh Slash interventions focus on Innovation and Leadership which is an ongoing conversation that we have collectively put per pushed forward over the last several months I've been talking a lot about Innovation and redesigning what public education looks like in our last Workshop we had a conversation with the board and looking at moving much faster and I say much faster when we look at data we probably do that faster than anybody else we make decisions as close to kids and as fast faster than any other system probably in the state if not the nation but I challenged principles during our December meeting based on the conversation we had at this meeting every month I have

008the opportunity to engage with principles where it's just the principles and myself and I challenged our elementary principles to look at their facilities look at their space if you can figure out a way to move to a k uh 8 school a middle school which as you all know we lose kids from 5th to six the data is extremely clear and if we know that now we shouldn't create a plan to address it in two years if we can in fact address it going into next school year so we have a number of schools who are proposing to me to propose to you and this probably will come in our January board meeting to sh shift them from a Elementary K5 space to a K8 school over the course of the next three years phasing

009in sixth grade seventh grade and then eighth grade these schools are engaging with us now to validate these plans in order to ensure it is feasible it doesn't come at a cost to the district we can use current facilities uh across our system in order to accommodate this so this is very very exciting FS Elementary School is in this to to win it they want to offer sixth grade next year and then transition 7th and eth in the following years um Pelican Island as you know we we've already approved to move into sixth grade the feedback from the staff as they're going and engaging in their training around the classical model is hey we don't need to wait a year we we can add sixth grade next year so we'll be coming in saying can

010we add sixth grade to Pelican next year as well um Oola U magnet school also believes that they can move to a 68 space over the course of the next three years and then Rosewood as well is putting together a plan or a proposal to consider to make that AKA so in my mind this is extremely exciting it causes us to identify some known unknowns because we'd have to in the up coming school year evaluate the impact of our Middle School spaces we don't know what the impact would be if we offer a 68 in each of these four schools what is going to be the overall impact in our Middle School spaces our sixth grade space because obviously if sixth graders are staying in their elementary school they're not going to a middle school

011it would all but that would allow us the time to evaluate that and then create create a plan with staff to make recommendations to you early next school year to ensure that we have a solid plan in place in terms of Elementary School K8 spaces Middle School offerings as well as high school offerings keeping in mind we have that Boutique high school so that is information specifically or focusing that conversation around um identifying elementary schools we think we would start with the those four specifically uh and bringing recommendation to provide the choice the opportunity for a parent to say I would like my son to have the choice of remaining at a elementary school transitioning to a Ka or I would like for them to have the choice to attend a traditional Middle School experience

012and then vetting out what the curriculum what the design would look like so it's very clear so that we are in the exploration of that as as well additionally um continuing to look at our technical education some of our plans that we have created to ensure that we have a true programs of study that take students through and to our technical centers maximizing Career Technical education opportunities and maximizing opportunities for school choice and programming um through a very specific and articulated process um the Botique High School which we just kind of referenced would be embedded into our upcoming strategic plan and then retention of students and families also all areas that our strategic plan should address in the upcoming year when you look at the overall planning timeline as I've met individually with all board

013members this isn't a oneandone process this isn't just a workshop process this is an ongoing conversation with the board uh each of oh every month until this plan is is ultimately created ultimately creating this feedback loop or we'll be doing specific things uh as staff going out and conducting workshops getting feedback from teachers uh from staff from Community from parents uh will begin drafting in April and March but as as staff receives that feedback we'll be able to bring that information back to the board and let them know any shifts or changes or considerations the board would like us to to evaluate as we move through so we're creating a feedback loop between each of the steps of the creation of the Strategic plan with the board so we're excited about doing this over the

014course of the month uh over the course of every month and then additionally ensuring that as we have this conversation we're also talking about the financing of this plan you can create the world's greatest strategic plan but ultimately you need to be able to fund it so the alignment of our budget process you'll see similar conversations taking place with our budget as we move forward ensuring that we're kind of Shifting or changing our behaviors to ensure that we're financing a plan based in the reality of public education that ensures we are a being aggressive and going after and marketing for our students But ultimately ensuring that we maintain our high Financial um accolades that we received over the last several years our current areas of focus and I'm going to transition over to Dr Jacobs

015who will go over some of this information and I'll pass the the clicker down to you but these this is the four areas the five areas that we agreed upon in our current strategic plan academic success safety culture and climate communication and engagement talent development and support as well as organizational and fiscal responsibility it's important to note before I give it over to Dr Jacobs everything is flexible within our strategic plan even some of these areas have changed in title and grouping over the course of The Last 5 Years based on the reality of the system feedback from our community and most importantly feedback from our board so as we agree upon something at the end of this process over the summer doesn't mean that it will be solidified or put in you know we

016may change based on our reality or we may push ourselves to go even farther or move faster based on what we've accomplished in a shorter time time period than we anticipated okay Dr Jacobs so essentially the information that I'm about to present is a first step in taking a deep look at our the current structure of our district strategic plan in anticipation of creating our next cycle of our strategic plan from 2025 to 2030 so as you can see we have the Five Focus areas that is really serves as one of the an ERS within our district strategic plan to align our strategies and targets and to have very clear communication of what our strategic priorities are um that we have collectively decided upon so in previous sessions we talked a lot about Innovation and

017Leadership and how incredibly important both of these areas are going to be as we move forward through the next five years and so as we're looking at this I think we um it's important that we really consider how are we going to integrate both in Innovation and Leadership into our un upcoming cycle of the district strategic plan in thinking about this Innovation can be aligned to academic success so a lot of the Innovation work that has been discussed at workshops and board briefings is related directly to the academic success of our students and the school models that we offer across our district Continuum the next area that we see really aligned to this is that if we are going to be organizationally and fiscally responsible we're going to need to innovate we're going to need

018to learn faster we're going to need to use our fiscal resources more efficiently and so those two areas seem to clearly align to the area of innovation so your your student experience what learning Solutions you're offering as well as how we reimagine teaching within the classroom to increase student engagement and interest in in our curricular offerings the next area leadership we're really looking at Talent sourcing how do we most effectively draw high potential talent to the school district of Indian River County if we're going to sustain uh the outcomes that we have realized over the last few years we have to have a strong leadership bench who can carry on the systems and processes that have been de developed in order to drive continuous Improvement that next piece is leadership pipeline so the leaders that

019we already have here how are we cultivating their Knowledge and Skills so that they can continue to move forward in various leadership positions and then finally executive stewardship so by that I really mean that those leaders that we have in cabinet and senior level positions how are they mentoring and really investing in the leaders and teachers that we have here in order to ensure that we have healthy succession planning so when you look at leadership really talent development and support obviously is is very clearly aligned to that area and then also academic success so again going back to whether we're going to be able um not whether that we are going to sustain the progress that we um have been making so um in thinking through this I also wanted to share another kind of

020conceptualization of how we could align it so we could either stick uh move Innovation under academic success and organizational and fiscal responsibility into the existing Focus areas and then leadership under talent development and support and academic success or another way to look at this is really if we say that Innovation and leadership are our priorities wouldn't it be important to have all of the different areas fall under Innovation so not only are we innovating in academic success but but our safety our culture and climate we're finding the very best technology in order to keep our our students in our school campuses safe and communication and engagement we are using the latest technology in order to reach the broadest number of people talent development and support really equipping our teachers staff and Leaders with the skills

021and knowledge that they're going to need in order to prepare our students for the future jobs that don't exist yet and then organizational and fiscal respons responsibility what are the tools what are the processes that we need to use in order to maximize our fiscal and our staff resources and then the same kind of thought about leadership so leadership is important to all these different areas academic success whether you're talking about safety whether you're telling the story about the district um whether you're providing professional learning and then finally leadership for organizational and fiscal responsibility so with that um we wanted to get some initial feedback from board members on number one the Five Focus areas that we already have established in our current District strategic plan and then thoughts about how to integrate Innovation and

022Leadership into our upcoming District strategic plan all right thank you very much um I'm going to go to uh Miss barenborg and Dr PCA first um so I don't forget you so miss barenborg any comments on the presentation with our strategic plan or um any ideas on what Dr Jacobs just asked uh yeah sorry um I you know I look forward to the fact that we're being so Innovative and um creative with everything and I look forward to Future conversations about this we've had some initial conversations but um I'd like to hear from other board members as to what they think um as far as the initial thoughts of how to move forward with this plan so thank you for this thank thank you Dr PCA no I I appreciate the uh presentation and um

023you know obviously it sounds like there's a lot of room for flexibility based on how things go um Innovation is kind of the Cornerstone of what we're going to be working with here um so I'm interested to see you know how quickly we can develop some of these K through eights that's uh and just kind of see where this goes and follow up over the next couple months thank you Dr PCA Miss Rosario okay um so thank you for the um initial beginnings of this discussion um I really like uh Dr Moore that we are going to have a placeholder for strategic planning in all of our meetings moving forward I think that's incredibly important for us as a board because the Strategic plan is the board plan the Strategic plan is not the superintendent

024plan it is the board plan that's why I think the board should take this very seriously because it is through that plan that we then um have the superintendent um um work you know day-to-day uh to reach the goals that are within the plan clearly we're working together on this effort so I think it's really really important I also like the idea that you mentioned uh budget alignment with the Strategic plan um now that we are just beginning and I know that Mr green is probably just also beginning the process of um uh working on our budget for the next year um I would like to see a little bit more of that I would love to see part of let me say take back like I would love to see um a placeholder for

025Budget as well specifically regarding how it would align with our strategic plan as you mentioned before but also how it would help for board members to be engaged in the process of our budget so that come the time that we have to approve our budget in the summer we are well vered in it if we had any questions we don't have to wait until the last minute to say we haven't been a part of that process so I think it would be really really important if we could get into the habit of doing something like that um so with regard to the question um that is posed to us here um it would have been a little bit helpful if we had this presentation and knew what your questions were going to be for us

026to provide for you before today because then we would have board members prepared to have that discussion um that said I think uh one of the questions that you mentioned was where should we put should we have the areas separate and inovation separate if I understood the question or um have them underneath all innovation I think it should be the opposite and here's my thought because every area that we decide on has its own type of Innovations academic in in Innovations are going to be very different than Talent Innovations um what uh human resources does in terms of hiring and uh professional development or whatever wherever it falls under those Innovations will look different than what happens in the classroom under instruction and curriculum um I think those are two very different areas the same

027thing with facilities how facilities and organizational structures work um their Innovation would look quite different than all the others um same thing with communication and engagement so I actually think whatever the umbrella areas we select should have its own Innovations specific to that area um so maybe our focus should be just on what those umbrella areas should be first um I do think that there is a uh critical Place absolutely for academic success that shouldn't change we're our focus is always on academic success umbrella area I guess I'm using Umbrella like the the big areas um Talent develop and support development and support I think is uh critically important um safety did I say safety uh safety culture and climate also very important I don't think that should change either um community and engagement I

028don't think that should change I do have some suggestions on how to get there um because I I think that we need to do better in that area still even though we've come a long way from where we used to be um same thing with organization I I think organization and fiscal responsibility there are some areas in there that we have had conversations over the years where they're quite different they really probably shouldn't have be under the same category um but one area that I don't see here is the umbrella and this is where it gets a little I'm going to sound like I'm contradicting myself unless you want to give it another name is innovation as a separate umbrella but not separate from the individual strategies of how each of those areas will become

029Innovative does that kind of make sense so like overall Innovation might be a district what is the district doing to innovate as opposed to what is curriculum and instruction doing to innovate in the classroom and what I mean by that is what are we doing as a district to re Envision School Organization to re-envision um um maybe classical education might fall under that topic maybe creating more K8 schools as you mentioned would fall under that particular umbrella um what other area what other things are we doing um alternative school maybe reenvisioning alternative school could fall under that umbrella another area that I don't don't see here that doesn't pop out that I would like to see would be a stronger focus on Career and Technical and vocational education we we have to do better there

030we have a great College Career and Technical education College um Treasure Coast Technical um and Vocational college but I'm but we're not doing a lot of focus on that school I think we really need to focus more on that building our students academic giving them opportunities to have dual enrollment uh participation in Treasure Coast Technical and Vocational I think is incredibly important and though that might fall under that other kind of District Innovation umbrella again you can call it something else so we're not too confused um but I think those are the types of things virtual education well that might be curriculum but yeah that's still an option when you're talking about school children Choice re-envisioning what school looks like could be under that umbrella that we don't have here um and um trying to

031think of anything else that I that I and I can't think of anything else right now but yeah so I hope that you got my as I'm thinking out loud uh kind of brainstorming and thinking at the same time uh if that makes any sense and of course I'll just at this point hand it over to board members thank you Mr Dyer uh yeah could you put the slide back up that you had with the uh with the two areas Innovation and Leadership there yeah you know one of the things that I've found in doing strategic plans corporately for many many years is if you don't let me start again 20125 is much different than 2020 what was important in 2020 certainly is different today and as you said with the competition that we have

032with public with private schools and charter schools and homeschooling uh there are things that are happening in education that were not here five years ago and I think that what I have seen in a strategic plan is you don't try to fit it into neat categories you really have to identify those things that you want to do now there you have to all the issues that we have in the symbols whether it's safety or Finance or fi financial and by the way I agree with Miss Rosario that the financial should be talked about in light of the Strategic plan as we go along and not just in one great big 576 page budget package at the end I think that is an excellent point and I believe that's the way that we should do it

033but if we don't point out the things that we believe are important for our success over the next 3 years then they can get buried in all the other things that we do and so I think trying to prioritize and Innovation I think is so key for our competitiveness for Reinventing schools for uh everything that we do to be successful over the next five years we have to have the Innovation part and the talent and Leadership part how do we become schools the the school of choice for teachers how do we become the school of choice for parents or the schools of choice I should say by the options that we offer I mean to me those are some of the some of the Big Ideas uh you know the best performing uh one of

034the things with teachers the best performing District in the uh in in the state also how to have the uh most uh the best uh compensated teachers in the state and administrators and I think we ought to do things things that really support everything that we're doing and that's why I think it's important in the budget that we separate the things that are nice versus the things that are necessary and that's make sure that the budget is focused in places that are going to make a difference and really impact us so that I uh certainly believe in and I think this competitiveness uh is one of the big things you know I what I did talked about I did that study 8 10 years ago with now with Council of 100 eight years ago and

035it was well known at the time that the K through 8 model is the preferred model really for academic success I mean we only have to look at the middle school slide to see that kids come out of uh fifth grade 63% proficient they come out of sixth grade 43% proficient this was Data 18 months ago or so but you know maybe it's a little better one way or another now but it's still a 20o gap there's a middle school slide and I think that everything that you're doing with Reinventing schools with coming up with new ideas uh is uh really important and that's why to me Innovation just really pops out as its own separate category while other things are important but the Innovation what are we going to do to really change the

036direction of schools and make this the schools of choice for parents I think is the big deal and uh certainly I would uh would hope that we're going to focus on that thank you just a few comments thank you board members Dr Moore I wasn't here in 2020 when the Strategic plan was developed I know you go out and talk to people but is there a committee or parents together how do you get true feedback If the parents can't get to these meetings so in the process as we move along and kind of Benchmark this out over the course of the next seven eight months we will have Town Halls we'll have focus groups typically focus groups gives us a lot of information and allows us to focus the conversation around the Innovation and and

037clearly our initial conversation is mostly about bringing Innovation to the for to the Forefront which is absolutely exciting to hear if you just listen to the the boldness in some of the statements board members are are are making it it gets you Goosebumps if that's I don't know what y'all call them here but um it it's it's it's exciting so so clearly as we collect this information we step back and saying okay what did we hear how do we organize these ideas if we're able to come back in in a month and say all right this is the structure of the plan and these are the areas give us feedback board members um but I I I couldn't agree more Innovation is at the Forefront of this plan um and Innovation is in every area

038within the plan and just a couple couple more comments um you know being out there for choice I mean choice in the public school system can happen 100% And I think this is leading the way I really do um because if we don't do it it'll be done to us as far as losing students and and so forth not only do we have a little bit of a middle school slide we have a summer school slide so we should got maybe start looking at that too I hate to say okay we're going to do this or this but um you could see a summer school slide for sure um or summer slide I'm sorry and I like all the components in our strategic plan I've gone through this several times I like the components but

039I agree with what's been said here too somehow whether it's Innovation under each area or innovation at the top of all five areas I think is important because um you know obviously student achievement is is our priority here making sure that they're ready to go to the next level whatever it will may be and of course if we have the KH you'll be making a plan with okay that sixth grade's not going to middle school how we will adapt to that and I know that's future but um I think overall as far as the Strategic plan and its components very good but keep Innovation out there in every respect because it's important yeah and I as I digest the conversation I tend to agree there's Innovation within each area regardless of what those areas end

040up being but we're really forcing ourselves to have the conversation around school design school concept um start times those not uh groupings Bells those that might be a a separate area of innovation or School design area whatever we would call it maybe a separate area and I just appreciate I think most people will say you know um this is our community let's look at it locally how will it affect our students our parents our teachers and community members very important and I I to me that's one of our our key areas of our success is that this is a strategic plan that we want to be Innovative But ultimately we going to be Innova to create Indian River Cy public education system for its community so it's being hyperfocused in on the desire and wants

041of our community and designing that experience for them in order to ensure a we're meeting the community need our advocacy a lot of times we think of advocacy and we we think of going to legislators we need to be advocating back towards our community regarding the options and choice better job I'm sorry M Rosario yeah um so a couple of things that were said um that I had a thought um because I kept struggling in my head with Innovation Innovation Innovation and really another word for Innovation is transformation and that's part of that is our um mission right transforming education to inspire students so how about with regard and because the district's Focus focus is so different than what would happen within a school academically or within the finance how about the districts umbrella would

042be called transformation District transformation or transformation or you know something under transformation because that's what you're doing is you are establishing goals to reach our mission which is to transform education and then underneath that would be how you are innovating to reach the transforming work what are you doing to reach the transforming work of the district and I'm just talking District here you know if if we were to add another category um if you could think about that I think that would it would align certainly with our mission you're smiling why you smiling selecting a everything you said when you initially spoke regarding innovating the system right and having Innovation inside each strategic plan is kind of confusing so maybe focusing in on the district Innovation whether it's transform I mean I'd let a transformation

043office for seven years so um I like that so it is the redesign repurposing um transformation of how we go about the business of educating kids yeah so there's a lot of thinking it's exciting it's good it's good to have the conversation but I think we've made a lot of progress and for the next meeting can you please provide us with any thank you thank you Miss barenborg Dr PCA any other comments nothing right now thank you thank you okay Madam mad sorry I had one other comment the one other thing that you said that I thought was great in the beginning is that you're when you look at a strategic plan you have to have measurable results it's uh really a lot of hard accountability to achieving the plan and I think that you

044guys do a better job than I would venture to say than most districts anywhere uh of holding yourselves uh accountable for the results and I want to make sure that in that in the uh in the words we don't lose the emphasis on results and what we do in strategic plan leads to a outcome that we want 100% good point okay next item I'm sorry mrar that's okay I got a left left that's okay I just want to throw something out there and we certainly don't have to have a long drawn out conversation about it but just for a long-term thinking as a superintendent um think also about how to restructure your your evaluation uh because there are Parts in our conversations uh over the years that there are parts of your evaluation just the

045formatting of it that doesn't allow for your that doesn't allow for like other areas that we could uh provide feedback in um that are Incorporated within you know the the overall structure of communication but not communication specifically with board members like I just think I'm doing I'm doing better though right yes yes yes sir we have our abs and flows but yes definitely better no I and I don't mean it like I just mean just in the formatting of it so as we move forward it's certainly not a conversation for today's topic but um if you can kind of think about that because it would help us as board members to be able to give feedback that is both subjective and objective I agree thank you so I um if it's okay with the board

046Mr tesy is here and I don't like to have Mr tesy just sitting around uh because he is our safety uh and security individual so if it's okay we are now required as you know to have a a update from our safety specialist on a quarterly basis so Mr tesk is here to provide um that update and I'm sure he'll say it but we also have a close session coming up early February as as well so this might be a a good time to transition some C topics or conversations for that closeup session Mr tesy yes sir thank you Dr Moore good afternoon cabinet board members board chair and our board members uh remote Happy New Year to everyone it's good to see everyone again uh so according to House Bill 1473 rule 6A quarterly

047updates will be provided to the board in a public setting so here we are again uh we had our previous update back in October what a day that was cuz we were prepping of course for the storms and the hurricane so we were very busy at that time I don't think there's any storms out there today so I think we'll be able to get through this um quick and fast for you so um if you wouldn't mind please like we do in our close sessions I'm going to read through my my bulleted points to you and and then we can address questions or concerns at the end of course if we can discuss them due to confidentiality but um I'm just going to move through some talking points and some updates for us uh so

048since our last audit update back in October I have finished the door and gate exemptions at all of our schools in facilities these have been updated within the fsat uh portal and um any changes that have to be made to those exemptions have to run through me the office of safe schools gives me a year to have them done we had them done by the winter break so we're very proud of our principls and APS working with me to get that done uh the threat assessment protocol has been updated and it will continue to involve based upon changes but we have a districtwide template in place that will improve the consistency of the reporting and the recordkeeping for all threat assessment data uh all principles and assistant principles have created a resource guide with the

049help of cabinet and myself and all the fine people you see sitting here in front of you we've created what we call an office of safe schools compliance binder but I call it the battle book so it's basically Grab It Go Do Your Walk do your tour or at any time your Administration should be able to reference that battle book to answer questions when an auditor or an inspector shows up it should be easily accessible and available at all times for administration to use Protocols are in place for updating that battle book those documents weekly at a minimum monthly and corrective action for deficiencies has been addressed from the last inspection and Progressive discipline has been imposed as necessary which is a requirement happy to report all of our school administrators have completed the required

050ces.org training those certificates are on hand emergency drill compliance has been addressed with uh a mandatory schedule being programmed and noted within the Raptor drill manager platform basically reminders are being set um myself the school safety specialist I have conducted as of this morning 62 official audits to our schools and Facilities public and Charter 62 since August um and specific plain language protocol has been put in place for completing after Action reviews we had a wonderful training last Tuesday with all of our srds and SRO here in the Tec um and I myself updated them on the new house bill language for the after action review requirements so the official Quarter Two update as follows uh we had one school that had an real world AED incident and Raptor alert was not activated uh the

051after action review was updated afterwards we reestablished Proto call with the school office office staff and administration and Progressive discipline was imposed we found one open classroom door at one of our charter schools in November uh this was documented in fsap by me uh I conducted the reinspection that was completed and Progressive discipline was imposed from the Charter School administration to their employee overall districtwide I I was Finding hard Corners in safe areas were lacking uh deep labeling or signage uh postings I've met with every school administrator and done a safety walk at every single school to ensure that these are rectified and corrected so hard corners and safe areas are also now being referred to as of last week safe spaces safe space so not to confuse anyone out there but um some of

052our state inspectors may be referring to them as safe spaces on top of what uh we've already had in place we had some food and nutrition cafeteria staff um located at a charter school not participating in a live scheduled drill that was observed by myself during the active as salent drill the FNS staff was just continuing to work and as we all know by code that is required for all employees into in the school to participate and assist so um Progressive discipline was imposed uh since those Food Service employees do work for us and push out to the charter schools and I will be reinspect them next week at their next drill to ensure that that staff are doing it correctly now two of our schools uh were not complying in completing their emergency drills

053on time within the 30 to 45 day window for November and December so I met with both School administration met with the persons who are in charge of drill manager we've created assignments for them in canvas to ensure that they do not miss their deadlines and Progressive discipline was imposed uh for both of those schools as mentioned before with our school resource deputies and officers after action review forms are very um have have become very detailed and are audited and inspected and color codes uh need to disappear and we need specificity with drill language so we can no longer just simply put a code yellow or a code red we must actually name the specific drill on the after action review so we buil bu new protocol in place with each principal and we are

054reviewing each form uh before they are submitted to the state and put into the binder I would like to end with quar or two noted improvements so we have seen an improvement with increased Raptor alert whether it's on the phone or the desktop we're seeing uh increased uses of the Raptor kiosks at the front offices everyone is being Raptor in I'm sure you as board members if you're visiting the schools they holding you in place until you are Raptor in so we're seeing an excellent Improvement uh it is required by law but it is a best practice as far as the after action review forms um our law enforcement agencies are doing an outstanding job capturing details and documenting them to a very high level uh so I wanted to give a nice shout out

055to all of our three law enforcement agencies who are completing those evaluations for us uh so we're seeing a reduction in the number of schools not meeting drill timelines so remembering back back to October's quarterly update I gave you the 2223 data and we had seven schools who were tardy with their drills remembering that they completed them but the timeline the office of State schools was not pleased with so we're down to two now the two that I just mentioned so we're seeing uh an improvement there but we still have work to do until we get to zero none of our schools and uh our work order system has just been Stellar it's been outstanding I have to give a shout out to the physical plant director Michael and Bob Dunton uh whether it's tree

056trimming repairing Gates doors locks um outstanding uh response from the physical plant to ensure that these areas are repaired and in place properly before we we become inspected from an auditor at this time I'll take any questions but just remembering I can't be too detailed this is open to the public we will be meeting um February 10th for the close session here but I will stand by for any questions or comments thank you board thank thank you Mr tesky Dr PCA we'll start with you thank you for the update uh Mr tesy um and I I would just start by saying that I don't I mean I don't feel that the um current state of affairs in this country is really business as usual right now I think there's an increased threat um really across

057the country obviously there's no real specific threats to our area but I think this is a a good reminder that we need to take Safety and Security very seriously VI ly at all times um and to put that into practice uh and obviously um we can't go into detail about specific projects or things that we may want to do um but I'll say generically as we do pretty much whenever we discuss Safety and Security behind closed doors or in private meetings um that you know we have several years of plans of upgrades and you know my mind these are all things that have to be done um and and the sooner we do them the better off our our children and our community is going to be and and safer um so I would recommend

058moving up the timelines for really any Safety and Security project we can try to fit into the budget potentially move other things down the line that could that could wait um and then finally just to add on uh as a followup to our prior conversation continuing to look at um I would say maybe a in our protocol to how we handle drones getting ahead of uh what I would identify as a known threat that eventually we're going to be facing here um so instead of just allowing drones to watch us in airspace that they're not supposed to be in um to have effective and relatively safe ways to uh eliminate them thank you Dr PCA Miss barenborg yes thank you I agree with um moving safety as a priority always as a priority and um

059the concern I still have is prop doors and I like the fact that we're talking about Progressive discipline it's important that people know that we take this very seriously um they need to take it seriously our our kids need to be protected and so that's the part where you know when you hear about all the delayed um you know fire drills or whatever drills that they're delayed I I have concerns about that because you know having been a principal I knew exactly how to do that and it's real easy so um I don't know why we're not doing that um just priority needs to be keeping the kids safe thank you Miss barenborg Miss Rosario um yeah I just uh I'm going to reiterate what Dr PCA mentioned it just so happens that we were

060talking about Dr drones not long ago um uh I don't know maybe about a month or two ago and lo and behold here you have this drone issue Nationwide um so I think it's really important and as the news was sharing obviously what what everybody else is hearing over the news um who is in control of our airspace is so important so I know you mentioned that it is up to the Sheriff's Department um to handle local airspace um if there are any uh unapproved drones that are over our games specifically or over our schools um can you talk a little bit whatever you can say publicly about that and what the plan is moving forward on that I think that is really really important nowadays yes ma'am um I do already have that on

061the Clos session in February to have an in-depth discussion with law enforcement they will be briefing you as well as us on on their protocol that they can share with us okay um there's a part of that that I think needs to be public as well especially with what is going on in the new news so we need to kind of figure out maybe that's something for our attorney um to to kind of help guide because we haven't decided anything yay or nay on either side so I think having a full discussion of it is not going to violate any of our current policies or safety protocols especially since we haven't established it yet um so I just think that in order for us as board members to be able to make the best decision

062how do we approach our constituents with this topic we need to be able to say hey here are all of the issues that we're facing I understand that we're going to get a debrief from the sheriff and local law enforcement um which um I encourage uh but at some point there has to be a broader discussion about this we can have all of the policies in the world even if we have policies now um that establish what the protocol would be moving forward regarding drones over our schools and our Sports Arenas but if our community is not aware of it then how can anybody you know move forward or tread lightly under those policies it's kind of like we don't want to set someone up for failure even if it's some someone innocent wanting to

063take pictures or something you know I think those are some of the things that we need to kind of bring to light publicly without divulging whatever policy we eventually enact if that makes any sense thank you Mr Dyer yeah thank you for the uh update uh I uh was impressed that uh when you did find people in non-compliance that you're taking action I think that's one way to get compliance certainly uh drills uh although they may seem uh to people involved in them at times frivolous it is unbelievably important when something actually happen so uh I'm I'm pleased that you're doing that I just uh uh need to be uh updated a little bit and perhaps we could get together before the February 8th so I could find out some of the things that uh

064will be discussed and get into it uh before that with you but uh I am all for uh anything we do to keep the kids safe and I think that you know when we look at again budget priorities that always has got to be at the top so thank you for the update thank you um Mr tesy how many more schools that are in need of the single point entry to date they all have a single point of entry but the Harden vestibule so our last count was nine okay and how many I'm sorry um are being worked on this summer or or as the school year begins yes ma'am uh two two okay all right yes go ahead Mr Dyer is that true with Charter School too yes sir yes they all have a

065single point of entry required now Harden vestibule is separate from a single point of entry which I can go into detail in February okay right yes sir different criteria and regarding the progressive discipline I also agree with that um how many steps are there in Progressive discipline it's changed since I was a princi so we depending on the situation in general Progressive discipline starts with a warning and then it goes to a documented verbal warning a written it can go to suspension with or without pay and following that termination okay I remember in the information I think you said Mr tusy said this in October some were late but some something with the timeline and they didn't get it in in time as far as the number of schools that had those um I guess

066not following the protocol for our code red code yell and so forth but for the most part they're all up to date on that right as far as how many drills they need yeah yes ma'am the the number of drills have been met the state and the office of safe schools have 30 to 45 day requirements and those schools although they did the drills they were out of those days that's right they moved outside the window which we need out of the original seven two as of this December we still out of compliant so we've built those mechanisms in place to where they can't miss it now okay thank you very much any other board member any comment on on this area thank you Mr tesky for all that you do y all right now

067get back to it um next is Dr Jacobs followed by Mr Green the next item is a request to authorize to accept Grant Awards um for three programs these are mid-year entitlement grants it this is a standard item that comes to the board two times a year around January as well as around June the mid year entitlement grants that come in January there are much fewer of them to approve and just to give you an overview of those grants we've um briefed all of board members on these particular entitlement grants the first one is the office of safe schools Safety and Security of school buildings that's just a little bit over $4 million and those funds are used to improve the Safety and Security of school buildings as well as to support School hardening efforts

068the next one is title three enhanced instructional opportunities for recently arrived immigrant children this is about 23 um, and that's just to help transition children who are entering um US public schools and then the final one is Title 9 part A that's the education of homeless children and youth and this is approximately $889,000 and that's to facilitate the enrollment attendance as well as success of students who are homeless in our schools thank you board members I just have one question before we begin do we have the count on homeless students I know we had it in Fall what is it now yes so as of January we have 471 homeless students thank you miss barenborg any comments questions yeah um thank you for doing that I know it's a lot of Hoops that have to

069jump through and a lot of paperwork so I appreciate whoever's doing the paperwork because I know what is like it's it's a lot so we appreciate it thank you thank you Dr PCA I have nothing to add thank you thank you Miss Rosario uh no nothing nothing we Mr Dyer okay good to go thank you thank you Dr Moore um through the chair the next item is a review of the proposed 2526 instructional calendar as you're aware there's an instructional calendar committee um I have to thank Dr David Ericson for continuing to lead that effort um that committee consists of representatives from District staff school-based leadership parents um representation from our CWA and irca um organization s and that work is always happening a year year and a half in advance so last year this

070time this calendar was out um just for the public to be able to view for six months all through the summer then in August the committee starts meeting they have a series and it's an iterative process that they go through looking at the calendar making adjustments so what you have before you in the backup is a proposed 2526 instructional calendar um very very very similar to the current 2425 calendar um the start of school and the end of school being just one day off because of a different um calendar year but in that beginning week um the two optional days for teachers and then going into a week of professional learning for teachers at the school level at the district level and orientations and having time to work in their classrooms and then with students

071starting on Monday the 11th of August which one of the um consistent feedbacks the committee got from that parent online um information was start on a Monday when you can instead of in the middle of the week so another year starting on a Monday as we go through the months the calendar is identical to um this year's calendar with three um differences on on in March spring break this year was the third week of March and that has been pushed back two weeks that week then encompasses Good Friday into April that day um is moved to November 10th um in honor of Veterans Day and there is a day September 22nd which is a Monday that added a day that was a long period from having off on September 1st which is Labor Day all

072the way through the 24th of October so moving through the traditional holidays at the end of the year in May you will see similar to this year the high school graduations on the back actually list the high school graduations and between now and any feedback we get um and coming forth to the board on the 20 7th we will be adding those graduations to the front but those are on Thursday and Friday now for the communities this year with um Sebastian River High School being on a Thursday evening ver Beach High School being on a Friday evening rather than a Friday evening and a Saturday morning the 2526 calendar replicates that with ver Beach High School going first on a Thursday evening and Sebastian River High School on 5:15 going on a Friday evening um

073everything else is uh very much identical to the current calendar and again it is the proposed calendar that'll be coming um forward for the board's approval on the 27th and with that I'll open it up for any questions thank you Miss barenborg yes um there was a teacher that sent us an email concerning the first couple of days did you see that Mr Green um I saw that today this morning actually it had to do with um orientations I believe so um I did look at that a little bit in the in the current 2425 school year calendar ele uh Middle School and High School orientations were on the same day on a Wednesday and then Elementary was on a Thursday and we got some feedback the calendar committee got some feedback about um people

074not having the opportunity having middle and high school both on the same day causing some issues for parents to be able to attend both and some scheduling and transportation issues so the committee did respond to that and broke out High School on a Wednesday Middle School on a Thursday Elementary School on a Friday so they're each on a separate day um and I think the feedback from the teacher um email was having that orientation for elementary school on a Friday and the start of school on a Monday um but that was the rationale for why that was divided up into a Wednesday Thursday Friday was to each each grade ban and grouping their own independent day for orientation for um parents and transportation issues so is it possible to switch um Elementary with middle school

075I will defer that to miss basur a little bit from a curricular standpoint I don't know if there's any issue that I can't foresee any through the chair I do not see any issues and I would actually recommend that that's preferable all right let's do it okay I just I I saw the one email and I do know how tough it is for parents to you know gather all the supplies all that but they should be paying attention to that in the summer and see the supply list and you know kind of what the preparation is for school so okay thank you we'll certainly take that feedback into consideration prior to coming forward thank you no no no no what I think if if you have consensus we can make the change right now especially

076since Miss basur is certainly sorry that's okay chair especially since Miss basur says that that's recommended on her part to flip those um as far as I'm concerned I can certainly agree I think that we should do it um any other board members want to support um this item this is the time to say it so there aren't any confusions later on Dr pasca um yeah I would support that change I think it makes sense and otherwise the calendar looks good thank you thank you Mr Dyer yeah I read the email and agree with the change for elementary but does that put middle schools in the same position that the elementary school was in would be my only question would that put middle schools in with an issue on a date is what's what's the

077difference or why I think the the difference just standing in the hallways in each of the gray configurations during these events the most attended event is is the elementary event so um maybe it would be less of a burden somebody's got to go on Friday um the less of a burden would be the high school um more than likely the design is significantly different in high school it's more of a student L process where I'm making sure I'm getting my my syllabus for each of my different courses I know where the classes are if you're a freshman maybe it's a little bit more intensive where your parents are walking making sure you can get to class to class but Elementary it is ultimately get to know the teacher um concerns are a little bit different

078in Elementary from a parent from a high school so it's seems to be an easy change and I agree with the change also and since um you can get your schedule online you don't see many high school kids there I mean you you you we have the orientation for the ninth grade but they know they know but anyway um welcome like a high school friend should elementary change with the high school and they go on Friday if that's the least concern and just do Elementary Middle High School versus versus the other way yeah no we were going to flop Middle School which was in in elementary so oh she did yeah okay can you tell us what you yeah what is's the [Laughter] final Elementary Middle High yay and nothing against high school kids but

079they just know you know they're coming in they're going okay they come in that first day all right I'm sorry next item unless we have any other questions Miss Rosario yeah I just want to um kind of make a comment here and say that this is one of those situations where you have a recommendation from a committee and you have you know PE well intentioned people who um you know make these recommendations based on the information that they're given and clearly there are concerns that come to us from from community members and this is just a wonderful opportunity for us to be able to respond um and in our workshops you know decisions that are made and we just clearly made a decision that um as long as there is consensus they've got to do

080the work so that's why it's so important for us to be prepared for our meetings and be able to give you a yay and nay or sometimes right then and there this just happened to be a good one so I'm glad we were able to make that change thank you m Rosario thank you through the chair the next item is the review of the Surplus property and is that's a standing item as well oh I'm sorry Miss bar I'm sorry that's okay I want I just wanted to say one thing um think about the fact that elementary schools kids uh this is their first time you know experiencing School in kindergarten and middle school and high school they kind of know the ropes by now they've been learning it for years um so that's just

081to that's why I really like that point that that teacher made you know for kindergarteners especially um it's tougher for coming into school and turning around and starting on Monday and I know from being an elementary principal uh that half the kids aren't prepared until a week or two later so it helps if we can get the information out earlier I'm just going to say that two cents thank you good point thank you yes Mr AR yeah sorry I did have another question on the calendar item um I requested some information um on Veterans Day um did we have that the his the history on that um so on the Veterans Day it has gone sometimes we are in school on Veterans Day sometimes we are not and then the times that it falls on

082the weekends it's either a Friday or a Monday to correspond with that um but there's not a historical pattern just in the way that it falls throughout the week so we have had school on Veterans Day we have been off on Veterans Day um regard regardless each of those events and Dr Ericson has done a great job we actually were on with the executive director again this morning with the veterans Council um Dr Erikson and myself ensuring that whatever we do we align with their programs and we um offer them opportunities to come into the schools throughout that week and that we make sure that our programs even if we are off on a Tuesday our bands and our programs are supporting those events at Round Island and the Sebastian Park and um those types

083of things so we stay in constant commity communication with them um so that whatever happens um both of us are supporting each other on that uh week yeah I I am a a believer that Veterans Day was is the uh day in which the nation celebrates and honors our veterans I think our schools should do the same thing uh a few years ago we had some concerns because we were not taking off on Veterans Day um and then we had um you know things may have changed since but um I I would be certainly um a a full supporter of moving it to the 11th which would only be one day um there's really no Rhyme or Reason here um and but except for the fact that Veterans Day is on the 11th not the

08410th um so that would be my recommendation I would love for the board to provide you know yay or nay on that as well I I do see the benefit of having the one small benefit of having the day off on Monday and that would be that on that actual day students can engage in some lessons on that day to support veterans in their classrooms on that day however you could still do the same thing on Monday and then on that day those students have an opportunity to spend quality time with their parents go visit grandparents who might be in a uh you know in uh Veterans Administration nursing home you know be able to actually go into the community and volunteer um have our students you know able on that day um have off

085so that they the bands can prepare and you know plan appropriately without having to worry about missing first or second period um so I am in favor of the 11th not the 10th board members Madam chair he um any input Dr PCA forget that I have nothing else to add thank you okay thank you Miss Miss Borg yeah the one thing I want to say is this is this comes up almost every year and um you know we've checked with the veterans Council and our local veterans Council to see what they would prefer and I believe that they have gone back and forth too but recently they have been really enjoying the fact that kids are um doing so many veterans uh celebrations in the classrooms that week and that that Monday is the day

086that we take off um to celebrate so um they you know I would go with whatever the veterans Council wants this year hey Mr Dyer yeah I concur I would go with what the veterans Council wishes uh to do with this one thank you I have a little bit of a mixed feeling on this one I'm the wife of a veteran and the daughter of one and I've seen it in the high school um when we're off Veterans Day but when we are in classes on Veterans Day we really have pushed um through social studies and and a lot of other subjects um you know the value of our veterans so I see that and then if they're off on Veterans Day our band does perform we've done that for over 20 years that I

087know of both Sebastian and Vero and it's great for them to be at those ceremonies it really is um but I think um I would go with what the veterans say but I think when they are in school and I've seen the plans I think the students learn quite a bit during that time so I think I'd stick with what it is right now so just just a little bit so this year they were actually off on Veterans Day not on the Monday um and in previous year I think last year this past Monday they I'm sorry this past November they were off on Veterans Day the previous year they were also off on Veterans Day I think um I believe it was a weekend the previous year so we were we did that Monday

088yeah so Monday happened to be Veterans Day this past time and then the other time it was a weekend right a Saturday and then the year before was actually on Veterans Day so we have had a history of having off on Veterans Day with the exception of being on a weekend not the other way around so we haven't had Mondays other than the fact that it was a weekend you know it fell on a weekend um and I do believe that the Veterans Administration is in support of whatever the school district would choose so that would fall on us to make that decision what did you hear that's right Mr Dyer thank you excuse me what did you hear from your conversation with the so um just echoing Miss Rosario's comment they are in support

089of what we uh do and they will collaborate with us on either one of those days um so they don't have a stance one way or the other they understand we have great programs when we're in school on that day and and there's other things um we do there are um the one of the feedback I just share from the committee along the way was um a lot of our um CWA Maintenance and Facilities are veterans and one of the reasons that that proposal came through that group was to be able to travel to visit those relatives that aren't here and have a 3-day weekend to be able to travel that was the feedback that initially got got it on to a Monday on the committee I just wanted to share that okay any other

090comments yes sir just just one other question in terms of academics when you have a holiday midweek is there any really disruption to what goes on academics I mean is it does it matter academically uh whether it's a Monday or a Tuesday you come for a day and then I mean historically the data is extremely clear the the Monday attendance would be abysmal because you take one day off both for staff and students you have a a 4-day weekend so typically having the Monday being in school Monday and then off Tuesday means you're going to lose a lot of students and staff on that Monday okay okay thank you for the discussion Madam chair remember that comment when we get to the last week of uh school it is Mr Green is laughing because that

091abysmal was the quite when you have that in the the this you know one day off in the middle it's abysmal remember that I'm gonna remember that word tou all right our next one is I'm sorry Mr Green Surplus property thank you um so the Surplus property for this month that you have before you the vast majority of items are 18 to 22 years old and those are TVs or computers um you will notice as you uh remember you approve the purchase of some school buses which were in your Capital plan which will we will be leveraging a um energy grant to get some reimbursements so you do have some school buses on here I can tell you that these school buses one of them has no engine one of them has a bad transmission

092and no turbo um there is actually one propane bus on here that U particular bus has an engine and a transmission problem but Mr kroer has stripped that entire bus to use it for spare parts for all of the other propane buses so we're aaging everything we can do within those um and then you go on to a lot of 10 and 12 year old um you you'll see brightlink projectors interactive projectors that's kind of like what we have on the wall where the students can see in the classroom a large majority of um battery backups in the closets that are 8 years old and really the only items of value were three um security cameras that were newer they were only 3 years old they still have some residual value but they were struck

093by lightning um didn't reach our deductible but there's still some value we don't like to get rid of stuff that have a has a residual value unless it's just in such poor condition we can't use it and that's basically what you have for the Surplus okay Mr Dyer is there any value of these at all I mean how do you dispose of them do you put them in the dumpster or is there somebody that buys them and pays you something um all of the above we try to anything we can auction for whatever value that we have we also have a recycling company that works with on on the computers some of the computers that are so old it would actually cost us to get rid of them in a proper way to dispose of

094them um so sometimes they take them at no cost just to as a cost avoidance measure if it's such uh and then other times we put them out on gov deals um to see if we can get any value of out of it that way M Rosario have we ever considered um donating some of those to our current um Tech teachers so students have an opportunity to break open a system and put it back together oh we've done um even when I was here before we have taken and a lot of times we'll do that before it even gets to you um but we have definitely done that um I will tell you one of our maintenance workers who is very creative um just hung a clock this morning in the finance department and the

095clock Center is a hard drive and it's got components before they were IP based so they weren't in internet they didn't have an internet plugin but he's made us a historical clock that's built out of some of the parts of one that was so old it's I'll U you have to stop byy and Seed it's in the finance just as a little bit of a legacy to it so we appreciated um him that's really cool that's incredible all right anyone else on our Surplus property okay Mr and the last item for me um as we have discussed during um hurricane Milton the vast majority of damage we had were two things um opening shelters and Staffing those shelters and then debris so the last count I had for Mr Michael is 275,000 lbs of debris

096that was um removed he has one of the best systems in the state where we follow those trucks we take pictures all along the way when they pick it up when they get to the dump when they get the pay ticket because we are dealing with three and four years old hurricanes now and they're asking us on this particular day did that truck stop to pick up any other debris how can you prove its weigh so he's got a um between finance and a physical plant we have some really strong procedures in there this is through the Department of Homeland Security and FEMA they have a subgrant to the Florida Division of Emergency Management and then we are the subrecipient of that basically we need to fill out this application so that we can claim

097our reimbursement which will be about $875,000 for those expenses about half of that in debris half of that in salary and um it designates Dr Moore as the authorized agent to be able to fill out all the necessary forms through that step and then we will find determine a reimbursement rate which usually ranges between 75 and 80% of those costs that um would be reimbursed to us within 6 to 18 months um or longer if they're questioning any of the items thank you um Dr POS see thank you I have nothing to add you're good okay thank you Miss barenborg I'm good thank you Mr Dyer I'm good Miss Rosario all good okay thumbs up all good m b good afternoon through the chair I am excited uh to bring to you some of the

098feedback and the committee recommendations for the instruct materials adoption for science um would be remiss if I did not thank Miss Anne Bieber Becky tesky Carrie Mitten Kristen Brookner and Wendy hack for their support with this committee and also the committee itself these are uh this is a committee made up of teachers parents residents administrators and anytime you go through an instructional materials adoption it's a a pretty heavy lift and a lot of time commitment so we're just really apprecia of those folks who committed their time to go through this process with us there we go so what I'm going to do with you today is just review the timeline in the process I'll review the rank ordered list of reviewed materials um and then we'll talk about the next steps oops it went faster

099there we go so August 21st the committee was formed and that initial email went to the board members the superintendent cabinet and principles uh that was also shared with all of our stakeholders faculty staff parents via the principes and the public information officer communicated all of that information via messenger call to all the district stakeholders as well um a committee was made up of folks who were willing to volunteer and participate in this process and an initial email went to all members of the committee on September 4th September 10th was the first meeting and during this first meeting we reviewed the timeline we conducted Sunshine Law training uh we completed part four of the Florida Department of Education library media and instructional materials training that's mouthful um September 17th we used that as an opportunity

100to hold a makeup meeting for any folks who could not attend the first one uh September 24th that was the overview of the Florida Florida Science nextg standards um we wanted to make sure that all committee members had a had a purpose for reviewing this work and understood the standards they were reviewing um September 25th through October 30th is the timeline when all of the members of the committee reviewed and evaluated the instructional materials using Ed credible which is an online platform um we use that now to uh capture everything that we do for this Committee in addition to that we are committed to this process at such a high level that we actually use the state's rubric for review so our work uh will always align with the state work and what I failed

101to mention at the beginning is that when the committee met to review curriculum all of the curriculum that was reviewed was already approved by the state um there used to be a process where we might be on a parallel track where the state's reviewing while we're reviewing and we run the risk of choosing or ranking high on the process curriculum that doesn't make the state's list so a couple of years ago along with uh staff uh we we talked with community members and parents about this as well we decided that it was in our best interest to wait until the state's bid list came out and their approved list was was factual and then we would ask the committee to commit their time time to do this process um November 6th the committee met to

102review the data from these rubric submissions and um at that time the committee said they wanted one additional meeting that was not scheduled originally they wanted that for K through five and 6 through eight just to review any additional information so the way the timeline continues is we'll pre I'm presenting to you obviously here today January 1 13th January 17th a notice of public hearing will go out in the form of the agenda the public hearing will take place on January 27th at the board meeting um the school board will vote to approve on February 25th and at that time uh the material must be must sit for 30 days for petitioners cont to contest any of the materials and that will go from February 25th to March 26th what I'm going to do is

103review a a handful of slides and some of this information will be redundant but I'll just show it to you in different ways um this is the rank ordered list of the committee reviewed materials Elementary K through 5 Discovery Ed ranked the highest savis learning second highest McGraw Hill and Then followed by STEM Scopes um and as I just mentioned all of the materials reviewed already made the state's bid list and we reviewed everything that was on the state's bid list so we did not choose certain Publishers to review at that time Middle School 6 through 8 Discovery Ed ranked highest followed by savis McCraw Hill and stem Scopes a very uh similar path to the elementary elementary review biology 9 through 12 and I'm going to put a pin in this moment of time

104I'm going to review the rest of the slides if it's at the board's will board's will and then come back back to a biology discussion at the end if that's okay yeah I'd like to go through it and then we have all our questions for you thank you so biology um Savas learning was highest ranked followed by mcra hill national Nat Geo and stem Scopes and then environmental 9 through 12 that was also savis learning McGraw Hill and Nat Geo for Marines we have a few we have three um science electives up here Marine forensics and Anatomy those all chose Nat Geo as their highest ranked followed by mcgall Hill as their second highest ranked and then chemistry and um physics highest ranked was savis followed by McGraw Hill this is where the redundancy comes

105in this is the same information it just gives you a breakdown of the the average scores and so for elementary the average score for savis was 125 followed by or I'm sorry Discovery Ed was 125 followed by savis at 120 so you can just see the the variations in the average scores this is the information from that additional meeting uh that the committee wanted to just have one final review of different components of the top two they felt like the top two were close enough 125 to 120 that there was an opportunity just to look at this one other uh one other time time and so our team took notes the committee just spoke and shared idea shared their feedback so these are really the raw notes from that committee meeting and then just like

106in the elementary it was pretty close in the Middle School it's also fairly close with Discovery at at 116 Savas at 113 so the committee also recommended that the Middle School curriculum be reviewed just through the notes as well and there we have that so high school biology uh savis at 124 followed by McGraw Hill 106 right behind that Nat Geo and 91 stem Scopes and I'm going to go through these a little faster because they speak for themselves and you've had these slides to really review where there's quite a bit of discrepancy in the average for um I'll pause and answer questions along the way but um this is the the final outcome from the committee's perspective High School Marine Science chemistry forensic science physics anatomy and physiology and this takes us to what

107our next steps are so at after the final committee meeting which was November 21st the 20 calendar day public review commenced uh so November 22nd uh that information is actually still up there so if folks would still like to go review those materials they're welcome to do so we did not take it down after the 20 days um January 13th today we're going through this process as I mentioned the notice of public hearing will happen on January 17th the business meeting uh for February 24th is when board members will be asked to approve materials and that then starts February 25th through March 26 the 30-day calendar period of time where petitioners May contest the the curriculum um and I just one more shout out to the committee members who committed their time uh volunteered a

108tremendous amount of effort and time to go through this process for us and so at this time if I can go back to the biology slide I just have a few uh we did have some comments about biology and I wanted to go back to the rank ordered list oh there we go so we had some comments uh and they were really around the first second and third choice around biology and they were specific to um viruses and vaccines and so what we went back back through Savas I believe there were seven pages that had quite a bit of factual information about viruses and vaccines and there were some belief system beliefs that there might be uh opinions or viewpoints that were also integrated into that uh curriculum and that was the same situation for

109McGraw Hill and Nat goo as well so I do know there is some conversation happening with the Department of Education to see if they have any further information or supplemental um resources that they would like included in this what I would like to add is that in addition to our team doing a balance a review of the curriculum prior to implementation uh our curriculum Specialists meet with the teachers they confer with other school districts they map out and Pace out all of the curriculum that is also the time where anything that's supplemental or additional information would get added um so we are we are positioned where there is an additional standard that we are considering and it's um it's a standard the essence of the standard is identify an instance from History of Science in

110which scientific knowledge has changed when new evidence or new interpretation are in interpretations are encountered and so I say all of that because I know the the Genesis of some of the comments was specifically around Co and the vaccines and this information was developed a few years ago so there is obviously new information out and new reports out and new data sets out so as we go through and we write the curricular maps and the pacing guides anything that's important to be added to that is when we would add that to um con to add competing or considerations other considerations as well all right going to open this up to board members Dr PCA we'll start with you questions concerns comments um yeah so I saw some of the comments uh in the emails uh

111and I looked at the materials and mcra and SAS related to some of the comments um so I'm interested to see if you know there's any uh interest from Florida Department of Education in uh maybe altering the recommendations or seeing if these Publishers are interested in uh giving us an updated publishing and and maybe either adding and subtracting some information um I don't want to go on a very long Exposition about a bunch of different things um but I think it's important to understand uh that when we're talking about this this is obviously a publishing company that gets paid um to publish these books and you know in order to understand basically the pharmaceutical industrial complex you got to look at it's few different pieces you have um you have pharmaceutical companies obviously you have

112Federal regulators and agencies like FDA um CDC NIH and niad um and then you have media and Publishing corporations which would include journalists um and and metap journals actually like J and Newland Journal um and you know the problem that we have in the pharmaceutical industrial complex is really Decades of ingrained and uh corruption and that that's come up come on into these industries and interconnected and I'm not going to spend a long time about this but I want to give a few examples so people understand that it is actually um a real problem that persists today and it's probably the most corrupt industry um even worse than the dod and military industrial complex in uh fraud and waste and backro Deals um so just just to give some some examples you know uh in

113about a 10year period if you looked at the drugs the FDA approved from 2000 to 2011 uh they approved 220 new drugs and of those drugs that went through clinical trials and were approved um they had to add to about a third of those 77 blackbox warnings for severe adverse effects including death associated with the drugs so these are the drugs they approved over a 10year period almost a third of them um we find out that the FDA was basically a complete failure at assessing their safety data um and this is not a new problem this has been going on and that's why doctors generally don't use new drugs when they come out um they use the tri and true drugs and they wait about a decade to collect more data and they might use

114them on patients basically that have um adverse effects to the the first or second or maybe even third line drugs for that class whatever that disease may be um so the FDA is approving drugs that are unsafe consistently regularly for decades um the FDA does something where sometimes they award uh what's called an expedited approval um in these there stipulations that the pharmaceutical companies since they're getting their drug to Market faster they have to continue uh safety and data analysis and provide studies to prove it actually is safe um and a review that was done of those expedited approvals found that the stipulated studies are only conducted about 38% of the time so just over a third of the time these pharmaceutical companies are actually confirming that these drugs are safe they're they're really just

115not looking at they're taking their expedited approval and the FDA is not doing anything about it um and you know combine that with the fact that you know this is not a a meme it turns out it's very true uh nine of the last 10 um commissioners of the FDA went to go work for a pharmaceutical company uh usually on the board of that company after they left and that represents over 40 years of leadership of FDA to present time um so they give sweetheart deals and pass unsafe drugs and then after 10 years at a government agency they go work for fizer or Mna most of the time and they they make massive amounts of money and they they maybe get their payoffs after they leave their government agency is what it looks like

116um and that you know so that's on the drug side that's part of it but there's also there's also cancer causing chemicals that are consist L found in our drugs that are contaminants that are not even supposed to be there um so I'm sure some of you have read studies about these but one example is uh nitrosamine compounds one of them being n Nitros dimethylamine or ndma um you guys probably read a few years back that was found in over-the-counter Zantac a heartburn medicine um you know it was also found in dozens and dozens of other medications that are commonly prescribed for blood pressure and heart disease so this chemical causes cancer um we weren't looking for it we weren't testing for it um and eventually it was found it's probably been there for a

117while in many drugs and you go back and you look retrospectively where did this enter the supply chain in the manufacturing and distribution process it primarily comes from reagents that are bought cheaply from China um so we now we have our our biggest foreign competitor who objectively wants Americans dead uh selling us the chemicals we need to make our drugs and in it there are contaminants that will kill us um and this has been going on for a number of years under the fda's uh guidance or lack thereof um you know and just to show how they really don't follow any protocols or procedures there was a drug a couple years ago Adu Helm that was approved by the FDA even after the committee That was supposed to look at all the data and the

118trials um the 11 person expert panel all unanimously voted against it and so did the biostatician that was uh counseling the expert panel and they voted against it because it actually showed zero efficy at improving Alzheimer's um but it was associated with fatal side effects including inal Hemorrhage so zero benefit and proven to be dangerous but the FDA says hey let's do it anyway um so this is what's been going on and you know this is really a small small fraction of it you know there's tons of stuff in the foods Food and Drug um you know I'm not going to go through the thousands of compounds and chemicals that are in our foods that cause cancer diabetes autoimmune diseases hypertension and other problems and are many of which are legal almost most developed places

119in the world um but we'll we'll talk about just one of them and that's glyphosate or Roundup that we spray on our grains and as in uh bread and cereal and oatmeal kids are eating it multiple times a day and what we've known about glyphosate is glyphosate is metabolized into another chemical called ampa or aminomethyl phosphonic acid um both of the glyphosate and the ampa uh are toxic uh they're specifically because of the compound's ability to go through plasma membranes and the nuclear membrane it can enter a cell enter the nucleus and cause direct DNA damage and once you damage the DNA and it does it through a few different Pathways um it can cause single stranded DNA breaks double stranded DNA breaks it can oxidize uh base modification and it can cause DNA adducts

120um all of which lead to mutations in DNA um especially over repeated exposure so even lowd dose exposures over long per periods of times you're G to have an innumerable number of damage to the DNA and then you have all these molecular processes that are supposed to go back in and repair it but over time these build up and you get mutations and when you mutate certain parts of your DNA you it leads to cancer um so you know the the glyphosate we knew from the beginning was never safe um once again the FDA decides let's spray it on almost every meal you eat you're eating glyphosate in it let's put it that way it's in almost everything um and this is clearly unsafe there's no way at any dose it's unsafe or any parent

121would want to give it to their children yet somehow FDA leadership says this is safe um and and it should be in your diet um so what we see from federal regulators and CDC ni um FDA and IAD is they they don't really have standards they do not care about safety in the same way a parent would care about safety um and there there appears to be intense uh longstanding corruption and collusion between the agencies pharmaceutical companies as well as uh I'll call it the media and Publishing um and and part of that is just because there's so much money um fiser alone spent U 3.6 billion in advertising uh many of that money goes to uh Publishing Company media corporations and scientific journals um and because of that the media doesn't publish concerns about

122drugs potentially um and they get uh different kind of treatment and this is a long-standing relationship between this pharmaceutical company as well as many many other pharmaceutical companies like they didn't start giving billions of dollars in 2023 it's been going on for a very long time um so you know at the end of the day when you look at all of this um what's in some of these science and bi curriculums and this is we're talking about elementary middle school high school I tell you it is far far worse in the medical industry doctors everywhere know this that half of our board exam are actually really uh they questions that were put on there ultimately by the pharmaceutical company that should not even be on our board exams that's how bad and invasive this corruption

123is in education so I'm not surprised there's problems in these biology and science textbooks um as it relates to you know these curriculums and if we should buy them there may not be a specific curriculum that doesn't have some of this in fact you know of the major Publishers um but I I would like to see is maybe they could pull some of this stuff out that is just unnecessary you know there's a lot these kids need to learn um you know in there there I think it was page 129 of mcra they' said the best treatment for a virus is a vaccine um and you know the reality is uh many viruses you cannot make a vaccine for in fact they've been trying for uh 50 years to try to make a vaccine for

124uh Corona viruses and Rhino viruses they've been unsuccessful because there's so many different strains and variations in fact as soon as you make a vacine and and give it to people all you've done is caused a different strain to circulate um so it actually has almost no effect so that that's scientifically just a a p a poor statement um and then you know the statements on the covid vaccine itself and the messenger RNA technology I'm not going to go into that in detail but the covid vaccine was the first major drug brought to Market using messenger RNA um it's extremely dangerous technology that specifically my background in molecular biology is an expert in um and the problem with this is that a it's in uh a lipid bilayer driver and just to give an example

125we used to have fungal infections in the brain and we needed to get an antifungal into the brain because it was a fatal fungal infection of the brain and what we found is uh certain preparations that were early on such as otter andb in the wrong lipid bilayer driver were actually more fatal than the fungal infection in your brain um so it took many years to find a driver that would actually even lower the mortality if he had an active fungal infection in your brain um and the lipid bilayer drivers that were used for this drug for the messenger RNA vaccine um they've never been used in another drug before um that's the driver alone so that driver can you know it can incorporate into plasma membranes it allows the drug to reach the nucleus

126additionally um you know there's been a lot of misinformation from once again these government agencies they said that the co vacine cannot get into the nucleus this was one of them um that is in fact wrong there are ports that allow messenger RNA transfer r rnas or RNA in G to reach the nucleus once it gains entry to the cytoplasm which it obviously is designed to make it into the cytoplasm um so it can reach the nucleus and the biggest issue is whenever you put in RNA that's foreign into a nucleus there is absolutely no way to know what's going to happen in that specific individual in fact some of the side effects will specifically be genetic um specific to that person so a different genetic code wouldn't experience the side effect this person with

127their genetic code May um and there's no way to actually study it because of that um you know additionally we talk about gay as one example of things in our environment that are constantly causing DNA damage if this mRNA foreign mRNA is in a nucleus with DNA that does have damage and there's repair processes going on it can inadvertently um be incorporated through various means or contaminate the repair process um also you know and this is getting it a little bit into the weeds but there whenever you're transcribing and translating um DNA and RNA there's all these proteins involved in process there's regulatory proteins um there's the proteins that are actively doing the process um and they are actually driven by RNA themselves so the RNA controls those proteins and it will change depending on

128the type of Gene sequence you're looking at and what the process is it could literally alter how much protein of a certain thing you're making uh from that specific cell um so in general I would just say the mess RNA technology is extremely unsafe um it is not ready to prevent disease and it probably never will be um it probably has uses in terminal illnesses but it should never be used to prevent a disease in my opinion um in my medical opinion I would not recomend anyone take a messenger RNA drug unless they had a terminal condition um but I guess the elementary Biology book um probably knows better than me so they they they had a different opinion thank you very much Dr PCA uh Miss barenborg yeah I'm not surprised that biology gets

129dinged because it usually gets dinged for lots of reasons um I was surprised it didn't get dinged for other reasons um I agree with a lot of What U Dr Bosa said as far as Roundup um in our food things like that um but it comes down to what is it as a board we're going to do about this um I do know I spoke to the superintend tenant about you know his um calls into Manny Diaz's office and what is their suggestion because they approved all these materials so um what is their suggestion then because a lot of times these Publishers write it three to five years ahead and so um when the book comes out it's really hard to remove something because it's printed so what we have to do instead is um

130that's when our team goes in there and says okay we're going to work on uh the curriculum map and say you know we're going to skip this chapter we're going to do this chapter and so on um the other thing is parents always have the right to opt out of something that's being taught and the question I have is how will parents know when um things are being taught that are controversial thank you Miss Rosario um okay so I don't even know where to begin on this thank you for that uh extreme um review uh the thorough review rather and I I always I'm like fascinated whenever I hear Dr PCA talk because he's just to me he's brilliant at his craft and um he knows so much about it and I honor his opinion

131um so I'm glad that he went into detail about some of those things as he was talking um he mentioned um DNA and so it just kind of triggered a question in my mind about where that remains that and the topic of covid and vaccines and all this other kind of stuff which seems to be uh the main controversy in much of the science curriculum um just in general and there are what's interesting is when I pull up the standards there's really no standard that actually talks about covid or um vaccines but there is um curriculum I mean not curriculum there is there are standards that address how um your genetic code is made how organisms affect the genetic code or the genetic code affecting um organisms and then there is one here which was

132interesting describe how viruses and bacteria transfer genetic m material between cells and the role in the process of biotechnology and I think that's really the one that might be the one to focus on because that's obviously where we're going to talk about viruses clearly no one is going to deny that covid-19 is a virus and that it did exist I don't think anyone would deny that um but it's certainly along the line I think the question is along the lines of um what information are we then giving regard in that virus and that's really where the controversy is it's making sure that the information that came out after the virus you know after the pandemic that's the part that concerns me the most and I think in in taking you know a little bit of

133what Dr PCA said and what Mrs barenborg said is just leaning on you miss basora to make sure that we just don't teach some of those things that are not not 100% um certified I suppose to be real and true rather than those things that might be opinions not rooted in science I things that are not rooted in science and or things that are not factual and I think those are that's really where the rubber meets the road for me as a board member I don't want to teach um or or have our teachers be in a position of saying well so many people whatever that might be so many people died um of covid so many people died because of covid or so many people during this time period died because they took the

134vaccine that's something that I think is very um unsure and it's not just my opinion science now says the you know the the the powers that be the doctors the um even the Department of Health is even admitting nowadays that we don't really know those numbers right those numbers are pretty up in the and those are the little pieces within the curriculum that cause pause for me um certainly isn't that we shouldn't teach you know that covid-19 um existed it's the other things and so I I think that if we could put a button on some of those things that are not we don't see both sides um then we should put a pause on those and I think it would be right for us to do it especially since we don't have a standard

135that talks specifically to that particular topic if that makes any sense um I don't know I think Dr Moore should um and and I'll mention something just to another support for what Dr PCA said and what I'm saying now is the fact that he says you know he said one of the one of the recommended curriculum I think or or one of the ones that were reviewed actually indicated that the viruses um that viruses are cured by a vaccine and when in fact we have a Doctor Who's actually saying no that's not true there are some viruses that can't be those are the kinds of little things little strands of information that I don't think that we should be responsible for imparting upon kids um and I and I think that's really the Crux of

136it the other thing is I had a question for you with regard to the the um standards I don't see biology here under 9 through 12 I only see that for 9 through 12 there's uh life science physical science earth science nature of science and computer science but I don't see biology you looking and I'm on C sea PMS by the way so if you want to so the many of the standards uh fall into different areas there is actually a standard that does address um the human immune system including specific and non-specific immune responses vaccines and antibiotics and that is sc. 912 DOL .1 14.52 and so that's that's the standard we we believe that this particular these seven pages in savis and I think 13 pages in McGraw Hill and a handful of

137pages in Nat Geo as well um is really addressing um but what I would say is that we are committed to anytime we we add new curriculum the Specialists the teachers they spend enormous amount of time reviewing that curriculum creating pacing guides and Curriculum maps much to Mrs Baron Borg's point and they they lay out uh the plan for teaching that curriculum and so we're committed to working with not only our own internal Specialists and stakeholders but also with other districts there are currently 17 other districts that are already implementing this curriculum because as I was describing at the beginning of this session we do it now a year later and so there are already 17 who did this last year and currently in it so between some conversations with the Department of Education and

138conversations with our colleagues around the state um we'll find ways to add supplemental resources and curriculum that addresses any new or updated or uh information or evolving information okay um um so let's go back to the biology right just I guess that title would did you say that would fall under life science instead of biology yeah let me pull them up and also was that L4 that one was l14 14 52 52 okay so that would be explain the evidence supporting the scientific theory of the origin of some cells that I can't pronounce that name so the the standard that I explain the basic functions of the human immune system including specific and non-specific immune response vaccines and antibiotics oh that's not what I'm looking at at all but okay so um I I think

139I'm I had another question like why are we I guess why are we still labeling biology biology instead of life because it falls under the life science why don't we change that because we don't have a standard called biology anymore the standard is life science so if we're in this process now why not why aren't aren't we aligning that course to life science instead of biology that would be a great Department of Education question well no it's ours the Department of Education has it down as by as as life science and then they also have course codes that relate to biology oh I see what you're saying so you're going you you're saying it's a course code but then they also have a course code for um life science no oh gosh you're to because

140challenging my memory now there are mil course codes all right don't worry don't worry but yeah I mean if we could go ahead and look into that yes it might be something minor for us to do but if we could better align with the stamp whatever this so I I hear what you're saying so the course is biology but the standard is life science well that's a little weird that we definitely need to bring up okay then the other um question that I had um would be for Dr oh no it's on theories so we talked about theories just now and I there is a standard let me bring it up The Benchmark and Miss Bieber my trusty phona friend uh as you're looking at the standards on C poems you can look at it

141by standard or you can look at it by course code okay and if you look at it by biology it'll give you all of the standards okay CU I'm in standards so I'd have to go back but okay so let me come back I'm still in standard um The Benchmark for standard I don't know if you want the number it doesn't it's it's in nature of science it's under the nature of science section um still Grade 9 through 12 explain that a scientific theory is the culmination of many scientific investigations drawing together all of the current evidence concerning a substantial range of phenomena and there's a little bit more there so I think when you mention theory that would also be a part of the whole idea of theories and I get very worried when

142it comes to theories because theories as far as I mean when I grew up the theory of evolution was the theory that we were supposed to believe was real and it wasn't a theory it was real I mean we every year had a trip this is in New York of course to the science the museum uh of natural history and you had this entire view of EV of of an evolution from whatever it was you know ape all the way to human um and that's actually still standing today it's probably been there for 100 years but I worry about Theory because I would rather us focus on and I get this standard which says that it's important for students because there's another one it's important for students to understand how theories are made and where

143theories come from and that entire process of developing a theory that's incredibly important but to actually teach a theory as real is not TR is not accurate and so that's why I worry about theories if we're going to teach theories then we need to teach all theories and I don't think that we are in general so coming back to the whole covid-19 controversies and all that other that's part of where I am filtering my information just to make sure that we are accurate and when we're not accurate we're sure to show all of the sides and then you decide right that's really what education should be not teaching you what you should know but giving you the ability um to see all sides and then you you come up with the decision you know whatever

144that decision might be um so I will leave it right there I with my comments and questions Dr Moore there was a question um that Dr that Miss um Baron Borg mentioned about you having conversations with the Department of Education um you want to talk a little bit about that and fill us in on what that or followup or something you were supposed to do so no followup yet um I haven't had any conversations other than some quick Communications um and I'm going to point of of standby so if anything evolves ultimately we will let the board know I I I think we'll have a little bit of track or Clarity um based on meetings that I'm not involved in okay but we'll see where that goes okay thank you Mr Dyer yeah I I

145just have a uh point of clarification if I could ask is we have to use state approved curriculum is that correct all of these were approved and yet from what I heard we have the ability to not teach what's in the curriculum and we have the ability to supplement what's in the curriculum which sounds like that you're not teaching State curriculum so I mean state approved curriculum so I'm a little confused because it seems like you have the latitude to do something different than what the state has approved although I thought that was the what we had to teach so you got to educate me a little bit about why and if we have that that l attitude I guess we have it everywhere we can teach what we want to teach is that what

146it's saying through the chair uh districts do have the authority to go outside of the scope of the state approved curriculum uh when it comes to our Core Curriculum we try very hard to stay in line with the state approved curriculum because it's been vetted at multiple levels um but to your point about changing or adapting or adding supplemental um in terms of those question questions there are actually science standards that address that because sometimes a curricul we've had our current science curriculum for eight years and there are things that are different now than they were eight years ago so some of these science standards uh there the wording around them identify an instance from History of Science in which scientific knowledge has changed when new evidence or new interpretations are encountered that's a science

147standard um another science standard along that same level of thinking is scientific knowledge is durable and robust but open to change um another one is identify sources of information and assess reliability according to strict standards of scientific investigation so in terms of science curriculum um it may science may move faster than our next adoption so there might be opportunities where we have to add new things um for example I believe there was a White House report uh that came out in December of 2024 addressing covid I have not read it it's 500 and some pages long but some of the statistics yes some of the statistics that are cited in the textbooks may have actually already changed and I I just don't know if they have or they haven't then may I suggest that we

148to that we add supplemental uh material based on current science I think that a lot of the points that were made were were were valid and that we you know move on I mean the science does evolve that's one of the things that that uh I was going to say is science does evolve and there are different opinions and uh you know you never know I mean I'm sure I remember as a kid taking uh the polio vaccine on a sugar cube a live virus uh who knew but you knew there were a lot of people that were in Iron lungs and uh we tend to wipe out polio so some work and some don't that's science right and I guess that uh you know if there are things that uh are U science will

149always move forward some things are going to work and some are not but when you get the knowledge that they're not working you you need to uh fail quickly yep Mr rarl then I'll make my comments yeah um I I I agree with regard to um what science what some science has been able to accomplish um personally I am I'm okay with vaccines I think everybody personally I think everyone should be able to make their own decision that's that's my stance I just don't believe personally in mandating you know vaccinations but um that aside um something that with your regard to your question curriculum uh the things that we present to students even though it's approved by the Department of Education it's not 100% um even some of the curriculum that has come to us

150is pretty inaccurate um and not worthy we've had I'm sure that you know Miss basur can attach to some curriculum that has been approved by the doe that just doesn't she wouldn't recommend to put in front of kids um but that said curriculum can change and we do have the ability to do that it's the standards that we can't change it's the you know those benchmarks of what learning is supposed to be what kind of learning they're supposed to receive it's how that we give it to them that that can change and so if we had an issue a couple of years ago um with the um um the English was it English or reading and there were some I guess some chapters or something that just that were inside of the books that just

151weren't appropriate and didn't align with the standards and of course as a a district under the superintendent supervision you we can make adjustments there they can make adjustments there um but overall it's really the the standards that shouldn't that are not allowed to be changed sounds like the Department of Education has some work cut out for them to yes to review a little more thoroughly yes exactly hopefully they have as good a process as you did looking at curriculum I think the process that you went through to look at these seem very robust and uh and and thoughtful so thank Youk and finally we don't have to choose any of these right yeah we could choose curriculum that comes from a private you know um U curriculum writer somewhere else it doesn't have to be

152the ones that the Department of Education um approves or you know recommends rather um we could always do that and I hope that we can do that process for classical education because clearly the traditional uh recommended curriculum is not classical related so we have to start looking into that for a classical school um but the law is very clear that we can actually adopt those that are recommended by the Department of Education or come up with our own in some other way okay just a few comments thank you board members um I did this adoption in 2017 18 adoptions take a lot of time and work it looks like your committee as Mr Dyer and Miss Rosario said really put put effort toward it question what book does biotech use I'm sorry if I missed

153it Miss baser do you remember if they're using any of what does biotech use for biotech uses the CTE standards okay all right I was wondering about that for biotechnology okay so but do they take a can't remember if they use a textbook at all I need to double check with them okay I don't think they use but any looking at some of that um I agree with a lot of what's been said today um you know these books were probably printed two years ago to get everything ready we don't have to do state approved and as Miss barenborg said you know if you don't agree with something you can exempt your child but I think the key for us here is stick to the standards you know public education what we need to do

154what what is the desired outcome some people may agree with some things some people may disagree but sticking to the standards make sure our our teachers have the support they need in teaching the standards will be the key for us in biology or in any any subject so but it was a good discussion but stick to the standards and keep moving forward board members any other thoughts okay we done M um does anyone need a break before my last two items they're going to be about two hours I'm just no no no whoa whoa whoa whoa I'm just whoa I'm sorry sorry Miss Borg go ahead sorry okay I just wanted to make a comment about theories um I teach a lot of theories in in my science classes and um for example cell theory

155and um things start out as you know a hypothesis then they become a theory and then when many many many scientists have tested it and all agree then it's law so there are not that many laws um that weren't as a matter of fact they were theories first so a theory is important but when we teach it we say this is a theory and there's lots of others but we can't start talking about other theories because then teachers are going to get off on a tangent and get in trouble they need to stick like you said to the standards and teach exactly what it says to teach there and not teach something different because that's when they can actually get in trouble I agree and I think that's a agree too safe anybody need a

156break we good good okay so I have um the next two and then miss barenborg okay um mine on public records request I just had a question when we received the public records request for the last year I noticed a board member did public records requests about a couple years ago we put in our protocols that um if a board member requests something it goes to the all other board members and with two new board members on here Dr moris it just that we go through you and then all the information comes to board members because I did one last week with Dr MCB and I think he'll get it to me this week at the end of my text I said please share with all board members I wanted to get an up dat

157on bullying so how does that go so just for informational purposes any request board members would like if you can send it to me and I will facilitate with the appropriate staff or myself I think the board protocol references uh if it's over an hour's worth of work typically if that's ever been the case I'll Circle back with that particular board member and clarify in terms of what the actual request is and then when I provide that information I provide it to all board members and I just want to make sure I was correct so cuz when I usually just go through you and then it goes back to all board members okay any questions on that yeah it it depends as well because if anything is communicated through the superintendent when he receives that

158information he's supposed to share it with everybody but if an individual board member requests a public record as a citizen or separately from going directly to the superintendent whatever that information is he's not responsible for sharing with anyone because it hasn't uh it hasn't developed into official action what is what is public record is official action um if nothing has developed from that point there's nothing to share because he may not even know what what is being requested so it all depends on how that information is being communicated um again if something is directly communicated to the superintendent of please give me the data on discipline or whatever it is then when he starts to work on that it is now part of official action and something that he should share with you all but

159if an individual board member is asking public records not through the superintendent something else no one you know you don't even know what that's for it's not even official act it could be anything as a citizen it doesn't really matter I not that it doesn't matter but it won't be public through the superintendent until it's then action is taken so if I look and I'm doing research if any one of you is doing research and you receive information through public records and you decide I'm not going to move forward with this it doesn't develop into official action nothing happens from it if from that point I have a conversation with Dr Moore and say you know I've been doing this research I really you know this needs to be on the next Workshop this is

160going to develop into something you know we need to talk about this at that point it has now become part of official action and of course we have a new attorney here with us miss envil so I'm so excited to have you I'd love to kind of um toss this your way if you can follow up with uh what I'm saying clearly if there's anything that I'm saying wrong um but I I I'll just hand it over to you I'm notar with your protocol I'd have to take a look look at that first but I'll be happy to take a look at it okay but just in general if an individual board member requests public records through the public records department or office and it has not developed into any official action in any way

161shape or form it's it's all open to the public anyway I mean you know we need to know that but I don't know what your protocol says if your protocol says I don't think it delineates it probably doesn't delineate whether you're as a public official or not but the board has established some sort of protocols that say anytime a board member makes a public records request it goes to everybody that's that's I don't know what your protocol says it doesn't say that it only says anything that we communicate through the superintendent should be shared with board members um just a question on that now Dr Moore you just said that if we have a question it comes to you and it comes back to all the Schoolboard members and I remember getting several of those

162like when I asked Mr Fagan a question please share with all board members why would we do a public correct C your question this is just discussion instead of asking our superintendent and I understand official action I don't know that state statute or that law I've never heard of that but why would we do that when here we are trying to get information as those in the district who are responsible for the education why would we do a public record instead of just asking him I mean forget the official review every situation is different you never know I don't know if I AG you can't you can't you can't assume every situation is exactly the same well and even and on the ones you requested I like to have the answers because about call them

163call them up ask for the the documents it's public records okay I'm just sorry I got where am I oh yeah I know the protocol yeah um requesting board members should ask the superintendent fulfilling the request if it goes over one hour superintendent will work with the board member to narrow the request if it does not exceed 1 hour so it doesn't if the request cannot be crafted to take less than one hour or is required an expend expenditure of funds the board member will present the request of a board meeting or Workshop a cons consensus of the school board is necessary to move forward such requests information that was requested by the board member will be provided to all board members now I know that's protocol but I just think as a um you

164know unified board if we're wanting to know something like I requested bullying last time that should go to all board members I want to get an update on that every semester I don't know I just don't think we need to go through public records requests and that's what the superintendent said so do you want I'm sorry Mr Dyer you had a question or comment I guess just a comment it just appears to me that is if a board member requests public records from the board or from the school district which they are a board member it seems to me that that should is is uh should be available to all board members I mean it just doesn't make sense because you have the ability to go right to you correct and to get any answer

165that you want so if there's something that and it is public it's public records uh and especially it is board business if you're asking something that you're about the board that you're on or about the district that you uh are uh a board member of so I I mean there's something in here that doesn't make sense and perhaps we need to address the protocol and and fix it there I just think we're all um talk about transparency all the time so if the information's out there let's just get it to everybody yeah Dr Moore do you have a final comment I think through the chairs some of this and listening to what everyone says part of the the issues on me my staff was who typically sends the public record information on a weekly basis

166uh was was out so there was a number of weeks in which it unfortunately wasn't sent I understand the issue and and I'm I'm I'll fine with it I I'll take it um but if that information was flowing as it typically was then all board members were able to see it through public records and and ask any questions they may have but ultimately I would encourage board members to reach out to me and I could facilitate um the request regardless of what that request is okay alrighty um I have the last item and this is on school start times check there are two attachments on the agenda one was a survey done in 2017 about 78 Pages Dr Fritz um I read through that survey and a lot of good some of you might have

167been on the committee I can't remember you were lot of good information um I notice the uh parameter set up you know you're all going to have disagreements elementary middle and high school parents but really was was good at the end they decided no time changes okay um about 330 parents replied there good information shared and know we've talked about communication and parent input right now uh the state says the high school start at 8:30 Middle School at 8 starting in the 26 27 school year and my only intent in bringing this is to make sure our parents are aware and they can respond um those two items and then just this morning from Chris Duan uh the small schools are asking for a survey and how this will affect them and what are they

168going to do and I also put on the legislative platforms for the fsba one of them said let the local school boards decide so just a few comments you know High School start too early at 7:05 absolutely and they're done that and just a little bit of institutional knowledge uh when I was principal G for Middle 6 not g for Middle we were the last drop off about 8:45 there then we went to 8:00 a.m. start up with the schools which we are now with the middle schools high schools at that time were around 7:20 and Elementary 8:45 and again when you look at this it's just saying let's hear from our parents uh I represented chair barenborg at the treasur coast Council of local government last Thursday at Marshall Andy the school board member

169from uh St Lucy said they're going to start with committees and one of them is going to be a student committee how this will affect everybody um um you know we're a high performing District I think that we could certainly talk about it um I did email our representative um bracket and Senator Gro just to let them know I was bringing up this topic because fsba said just be sure to let them know so I'm thinking could we at least start with a survey or a committee uh you know right off they may say we like it 8 Middle School 8:30 and Elementary I think you were thinking before eight right Dr Moore I mean just when you looked at it in general correct correct okay all right and if you look at the times

170now there's about 45 minute difference between drop offs of our schools if you look at all the times um but no matter what when this comes about parents will have to make adjustments and I want them to be aware through Dr Morrow last week I asked and I also put in there this will be shared with all board members through the High School principles you look at I'm starting to get that data back and it'll be shared Athletics band those watching siblings those getting home before them dual enrollment those who work when all information is in how will this affect our students and more importantly how will it affect our parents I just want to get a scenario out there with a committee or a survey and after that survey we could say okay done

171there we don't need it anymore but I just want it to be discussed and I started thinking what if Elementary does start at 7:40 or 7:30 I'll use 7:30 um their time now is 8:50 to 3 30 6 hours and 40 minutes if Elementary starts early they'd be around 7:30 to 2:10 those who whose parents cannot pick them up they'll be in after school care about three hours so I mean we really just need to look at it um I think there are so many variables and I just wanted to yes it's a law but I'm telling you districts are looking at it they're going to present it they said to email your representative and Senator I haven't heard back from them I'll double check um and I just think it's something we should talk

172about with our with our community you know seven years ago eight years ago now maybe after a very very intensive study they said we don't want changes so hey I know High School start too early I mean as a parent who had three children in the system and as a middle school and high school principal understand that 705 was too early but but I just think we need to get input as from our community and take a look at it so just wanted to open that up for discussion Miss barenborg are you still there Dr P I am um I do want to talk about sorry I can't see the I'm sorry go ahead Miss Barbor sorry okay so um this is a platform for fsba too yeah and um there is some discussion going

173around on the um Hill in Tallahassee about this particular topic because they I don't think the writers of this legislation realize how expensive it would be for districts to put this into place so quickly um and that's the part is you know what's the cost going to be so we are we also did a survey back on my first year on the board um for this and uh we got to find it but it I think it was in year 2018 or 19 somewhere in there and um that that was very telling parents did not want to change um the times so um you know when people get used to certain things they are used to certain things but it could be good um but you know I think just the cost of it is

174really kind of alarming too okay thank you thank you Dr PCA he had a medical Emer oh I'm sorry okay I remember um like to address one he didn't have one I understand the um the sleep that our high school kids I understand that but if they could even start at 8 vers 8:30 again that goes to the parents but um I just think a lot of districts are looking at this and would I think and I think our state would look at this too say you know the local people should decide you know and then and then we go from there miss Rosario any comments yeah um so this is not um a new conversation we had this conversation in January of 2024 in fact I put it on a workshop and it was

175uh brought to the board on January 22nd 2024 as a charge for the superintendent um in that meeting it was to authorize the superintendent to develop a timeline regarding the potential impact of the new um start times um and with that he was supposed to present to the board in February um uh and uh that would have been that next month uh and the items that he was also supposed to present to us was um what he was going to do to move forward and uh in process of communication engaging the community um the operational impact and so on um the followup from that from the superintendent was not in February it was March 11th of which he presented um to the board his plan in a pretty comprehensive um strategic planning timeline it is

176uh his recommendations for the timeline moving forward basically what he's going to do it included our current start times it included the communication in which he was going to take um towards this um these changes which is really not I mean we don't have a choice right now it is the law I mean it is based on legislation so we have to follow what the law says um and that would uh require actually that uh the middle schools cannot begin earlier than 8:00 a.m. and the high schools cannot begin earlier than 8:30 a.m. beginning um by July 1st 2026 um so at least by July 1st 2026 we have to have that in place so in his presentation he said that he would communicate with uh uh social Med through social media posts parent uh

177notices gather stakeholder feedback engage Community Partners provide board updates which we haven't received updates so um there's quite a few things in here in this timeline uh plan that you presented to the board Dr Moore that hasn't been done um that is true communication defined um there it says here that by April or May of 2024 you would have stakeholder feedback in the form of survey to parents survey I'm sorry survey to parents regarding enrollment impact Elementary writers ship extended day services that you would meet with irca and CWA and then Analyze That feedback as a district leadership team the other thing that it um included was that you would meet with youth activity groups Community Partners Parks and Recreation um IRSC regarding dual enrollment tctc um FHSAA County officials regarding signage traffic patterns lights

178Transportation conferences analyze the feedback um and with regard to operational impact um you said the adjustments would be would would uh extend to extended day hours transport ation of Staff hours current routing for buses courtesy stops staff hours uh contract language uh security measures marketing materials practice runs explore uh instructional time options and then continue study with other districts the financial impacts were also included um and it is provided here it it I we don't have a full you know uh Financial impact uh but there was there were estimated costs here for school signage changes um Athletics Transportation routing marketing materials and transportation costs then of course there are um costs for marketing or rather the plan for marketing that were included in the in these in this strategic planning timeline so bringing this up

179is not new this was something that was addressed by us as a board and we charged the superintendent with it the followup though I would agree has not been had um and I think it it it would be about time I know you would say we have a year and a half left for that to happen but uh year and a half goes by super quick and a lot of this stuff was supposed to be done last year according to your timelines so we are far behind the timeline that you presented to us um I do believe that it is very um important as I've shared even from that January meeting um that we needed to get on surveys and because there's a lot of different surveys here that are supposed to be had and

180if they're not done with time enough for the team to actually analyze them and then come up with a plan moving forward um it would just work out to be a disservice you know to the operation and and to to what we need to do to actually get this changed um and then at that point it would be the focus would then be well these are the recommendations High School would start at 9:00 a.m. I mean either 8:30 9:00 a.m. and 10: a.m. just an example if we had those three examples then we can present to parents what are your three best choices and we can get that feedback but right now we're not there because we haven't gotten all of the other pieces of information that the board that the superintendent was required to

181submit to us or at least present to us um so I would just ask the superintendent to do give us a little followup on that okay thank you I'm gonna let Mr Dyer speak and then I I'll do another speaking if it's okay in Dr Moore Mr Dyer uh you know I I I worry in this too about the uh elementary school kids coming at 710 I wonder what what that does to their parents to uh to Transportation I mean I gu a staint bandid so we at this point we have to we have to follow it but it does create quite a lot of uh of issues um you know you could go later with a high school as as uh Mr Rosario suggested however then that affects Sports if you've got uh any

182extracurricular activities so I mean there's it's a it is something that that needs to be addressed uh I would say uh sooner rather than than later and hopefully the uh Florida legislature will come to their senses and give you more latitude and let the communities decide thank you um Mr rarel Mr Dyer and Miss barenborg I understand that's a law and that we have talked about it I really do but districts are truly having issues with this and if fsba made it a platform I asked her why she put that on there she said so many districts said they're having issues and it just said please let the districts have local control um and I do think you know if a lot of districts have issues if we give feedback to the state they might

183listen for local control and like I said I know high school started a little early but there's so many variables so many variables you know like I said in high schools it's just not kids in athletics band drama like I said I'm starting to get those percentages but um those going home and watching siblings those working those um having responsibilities after school so I'm just asking that we maybe sent out a survey and see what parents think because I know listen a parent with three kids I'm not thinking a year and a half down the line I'm just not so just getting them feedback so as as everyone has here said like then we could present that to our representatives and and our into um Department of Education because when I saw that this morning

184with uh Chris duelan how small school districts were saying we want you to do a survey now what is how is this going to affect your communities I just think it's important we've talked many times today about parent input and um you know I don't have children in the system anymore um but most of our parents work and this could shift a lot of things for them that's all that's all Dr Mo any final [Music] comments the I think the Board needs to clar if the if the board is choosing to Advocate our legislators for a shift in time I think that's a a conversation or to Advocate to change current law to give us the flexibility to determine that is a a conversation to be had as it stands now it is the beginning

185of the 26 27 school year um and surveying parents regarding options the various options um is is something that we staff has looked at and said all right if there are districts who are advocating um I'm not sure which specific districts are but but there's a number of them um based on your research that are advocating to change that through the legislative process I think Miss barenborg has has referenced that that as as well and and when I was at the meeting um Thursday for Miss barenborg St louy was starting the process and with that survey going out to small school districts I don't know some may say 8:30 is fine um one last thing I'll say my daughter-in-law in Texas their High School start at 8:30 but their practices begin at 6:30 so you

186know you know High School in sports yep 50% of the kids basically so I don't know I just want to hear from these parents I from my perspective writing an update to to the board absolutely fine um surveying parents regarding the various start times um because as you all have said this is something that is in fact happening so in terms of saying these are options A and B in terms of being able to to shift to the 8:30 High School 8:00 Middle School start times and this is what we intend to do based on the feedback the community provides now if that in turn promotes feedback from the community that we don't want this at all then that's information the board can have right but I I don't want to tell the community that

187we're you know do you want this yes or no cuz the reality is the answer is yes you you are going to to have it unless there's change in legislation I don't sure I'm not sure I understood what you just said I don't I don't want to miscommunicate to our community this is happening this is this what's Happ and this is a law we know that's what we're going now I mean maybe some of you else have heard a little bit about this but this is the law this is where we're going but just to let them know that number one because I I don't think they have a clue as far as most parents because they're not looking to that year but we've just got to get feedback if if the districts can have

188local control what would be your scenario I I'll try to email Senator bra and um representative bracket again just to let them know I mean fsba said and I'm on the legislative team on fsba said just let your representatives know you're talking about it I said okay and I will I will do the same and circle back with the State Association to see if there's any traction or an organized effort in that local in that things that just went out for small schools I'd be interested in seeing that to speaker Chris M Rosario yeah um Dr Moore do you need um to I think you need to revise this timeline um so that we can have a new plan please if you can bring it back to us um if you need it to be

189an action item it could be an action item as well but if you can bring it back to us this way um I think as a board I don't think that we followed up appropriately with you on this as well so we have to take ownership as that on that um but there were some clear dates and deadlines in here that have not been um adhered to so I think we we need to follow up on that no wholeheartedly and I think just not the the presentation that you're holding up the the entire scenario whether there is in fact a a movement whether it's just small districts or other associations uh this is the number of districts that are pursuing or Desiring a shift in advocating for State Statute we can't control that and we'll

190we will probably know within the next month the level of traction that will or will not receive and that will give us a a clear timeline that that we can create and and at the end of the day we're going to look at what's established fulfilling it and making sure we're going to keep the main thing to Main thing at the same time doing work once and doing it the right way here's why I have an issue with that I have an issue with that because even though we're hoping to have conversation that maybe local control can be returned to to us in this particular area right now as it stands we need to keep planning right so I don't think that we should stop our planning just in hopes of what a conversation may

191result in I think that we should con we we need this revised and we need you know what what the what what you all are going to do to get us to the endgame and the other thing that I was going to mention is we keep talking about by 2026 but many districts have made their changes already so it's by that date not as of that date we can make these changes tomorrow if we you know had all the information um so I just want to make that clear for the public as well that the deadline is July 1st of 2026 but we can make those changes anytime before that deadline yeah and those districts are going to feel really odd if it it switches and it made that change that no one really wanted

192well a lot of them a lot of them that a lot of board members that I've spoken to who already made the change and in our last um fsba session there was it might have been the the June one that I went to the June or July the summer one that I went to there was a session on time changes um and it was very helpful and the the panel that presented were all Schoolboard members who actually made those changes and superintendents as well who said it's working great um it works out fine for them and they actually like it so I think you know there's a part where people can be worrisome about these changes but then I think on the other hand we've got to look at the positives I mean what if

193it works out great and it turns out to be something we didn't expect last any other comments I just want to say how was your interview in Washington DC it was a very cold but fun experience to have the opportunity on at a national stage to tell Indian River County's story of success so my sole and intent was to go there and brag about the transformation using that word intentionally of our school system highlighting that we are the one district and I've said this at board meetings multiple times that has seen drastic improvements in our outcomes over the course of the last 5 years and it is the process that we follow and that if Indian River County can serve as a Beacon of Hope for all other counties on how to we engage in

194public education and have meaningful conversation that is respectful of everybody's uh diverse ways of thinking to create public education for its Community advocating down to the community listening and creating that school system um that would be great too but I I just had a great time left extremely proud of being able to tell our community story and is the winner announc in March March yes March so we'll just forget about it like it ever happened move on to board members anything else I'm sorry yes Dr Jones had an item Oh Oh I thought Dr Mor said you were taking that off did you what do you have an item Miss barenberg I'm sorry I have the Cleveland Clinic agreements and what I want to say about that is I've been in touch with um the

195CEO that is um current CEO of Cleveland Clinic Dr Rothman and out of respect to the negotiations that are going on between his team and Bruce's team I'm going to hold this off till next month but I want to bring up a um a concern and something positive that happened from my experience with this and so I'm going to wait one month and bring it up at the next Workshop thank you my apologies Miss Rosario um I was just going to talk about um Dr Moore's experience and I hope that um obviously I hope that you do get it because that would be pretty neat um and I I we don't get to hear the interviews with all of the candidates that were there um but I will say it brought me um to really

196think about something that I had been thinking about all along which is the the point of um meritocracy right you the work that you put into something would be the work that you get out of it and clearly there's been a lot of work that you've put into um the this position um moving our district forward a and you know having a merit-based system this is a perfect example of I'm going to assume that you won hopefully uh it would be based on Merit right all of the things that you have done all the things um to get you to this particular place place um and I I would like us as a district to start thinking about what it looks like to be in a merit-based system not just for you know from the

197human resources perspective of hiring those who are most qualified because clearly you were the most qualified of all of the panel panelists um in this context but from the standpoint of a classroom you you know perspective like I started thinking how does that work for students right how how would it in the classroom experience benefit the student to learn what it means to be to be in a merit-based system um where you're working hard to accomplish and at the end of that working hard process there is something that is a benefit for that student um I love that I love that idea I think our entire system should be Merit based I'd love to see that a part of somehow woven into our um strategic plan moving forward I know that we say uh that

198we only hire the best and that are high you know the most qualified um but at the same time I would like to see us memorialize that somehow uh you know if we can just start thinking about what that would look like um ultimately as a system not just from the district and you District standpoint but from the school based you know even in sports you know it really affects Sports too because the students who work hard on the field um they get to reap the benefits and the rewards on the other end and that's really all about merit-based system I think anyway thank you anyone else okay I'd like to adjourn this oh sorry I was just going to say I think that the workshop today I'm excited about what's going on in the

199school system I think that this Indian River School District is on the verge of really doing something great not only in Florida but really being a beacon the idea of transforming the school district and coming up with all the innovative ideas to drive us to to the Future to be competitive I think is really exciting and I really can't wait to get back into things that matter in education and get this strategic plan uh into the Strategic plan and and actually watch you guys execute it over the next few years because I think it's an exciting time for all of us thank you very well said Thank You board members everyone Jour 252 for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.