CorpusRecord 1758

Superintendent's Workshop 12 p.m. 12-9-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Indian River County School Board
Date
2024-12-09
Location
Indian River County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
37,967 words · about 211 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e this Workshop to order the time is 12 noon I would like to welcome you to the superintendent's workshop being held in the Joe and idlet Junior Tec I ask out of respect to everyone please silence all electronic devices at this time also if you have any material you wish to share with a board member please give that to our assistant Miss Moray and we take a break every two hours um as needed before that um board members if you need a break let me know and uh at this time I'm going to turn the meeting over to Dr Moore thank you madam chair the purpose of this meeting is to present items that will eventually all bride updates and provide items that'll eventually come for approval for the board uh the first

002item on the agenda is a our strategic Plan update as well and the second item is the Ed fund um we thought it was timely to bring an update to the board so I'm going to combine those two items and run through them together so this time I'll bring up the presentation um to provide it this is as a reminder this is the last year of a five-year strategic plan upon my arrival this was the very first thing that we began to engage in and working with the board as well as the community to create a strategic plan we've had a tremendous level of success with this strategic plan and as we come back in January we're very excited to engage the board and Community with what will be our 26 through 30 strategic plan

003so uh the focus of this plans going into this last year and I think it's important to note this plan evolves over time uh this is a plan that was set in place five years ago but the theory of action behind the plan was to continually reflect within our current reality and make modification uh in changes in real time keeping our Five Focus areas the same but modifying uh our behaviors create habits based on what we see across the organization uh this year's three key areas to support our five areas of our strategic plan uh Innovative practices to uh optimize outcomes increase collaborative cultures that promote the growth of all students and engage in problem solving at every level of the organization when you look at um the those three areas key key key focuses

004instructional and prog programmatic Innovations are are this year really trying to ensure the success that we've had uh we're continuing to grow that success by not staying the same but drastically uh improving what an experience in a Indian River School District school actually is like sustained instructional improvements ensuring that the level of oversight in management from a district perspective becomes less because the behaviors and habits at school sites around instructional improvements uh have sustained they are in fact habits uh in each and every single school and then creating a culture of service three areas that we're focusing in on this specific year so when you look at instructional program Innovations that's Innovation at at the heart of this work uh we all know about the Dodger Town significant amount of work in creating a steam

005Park we've had the opportunity to to kick that off about a month ago pelican Island classical magnet school that is off and running very excited about that as is the community and School staff there uh capturing the work that's being done at g gford Middle School and the advanced studies academics that was a program that was thriving many years ago it is once again thriving again and then very specific job embedded professional learning to support Innovation and we'll talk a little bit more about that in the coming slides if you look here this is some of the bringing to life Dodger Town very excited to have that opening ceremony on a Saturday about three or four Saturday Saturdays ago and this was a truly truly at the school site Innovation uh with the team this

006isn't a model that's being replicated it was thought up here it was dreamed up here and it's coming to life here at Dodgertown uh and very excited about the attraction the Steam Park is going to have Pelican Island is continuing to recruit extremely well uh we have Partnerships across the state uh to ensure that we do this right that it does have a solid instructional program that is grounded in the classical model so we are very excited about that uh and just looking to continue to innovate across our system um and then job embedded professional learning if you were to look uh across our system this has been one of the key ingredients to our district success uh being the most approved School District in the State of Florida isn't something that just happens it's

007not the work of one person it is the work of many people and we have been very focused on empowering leaders and empowering teachers to make the right decisions uh and supporting them as they make those decisions and we are creating habits across the organization in order to ensure the continued success of our system uh sustained instructional improvements these are some very focused things that we're working on shift from teachers on assignment to content Specialists that's Miss B's team we really wanted to empower them as problem solvers they are all content experts in their field and we want to take the authority in decision making um that those individuals should have and need to have to support principles and teachers uh so uh shifting them to content specialist has really really honored them for the

008work that they've already been doing uh E2 empowering educ and math very succinct in specific programming in our mathematics in seventh grade those are students who are potentially going to be algebra students going into the next year U micr credentialing for algebra teachers we have to continue to work in algebra in middle school as well as geometry uh we have extremely high passing rates for those students in those scores and we're continuing to expose more students to algebra uh as in seventh grade when they hit that level three so we got to continue to hit them in seventh grade because we know in eighth grade they're going to be in algebra uh Civics job embedded professional learning for our teachers this is a crossed uh Middle School collaboration we're working with our teachers and Civics

009as you know I said earlier in the year Civics is a key area for Success um for us in this specific year in the art of problem solving which is a guide that we use to drive professional learning for our principles very transparent putting all of the required information in one space for them uh to allow ow them not just to have information but to use information to problem solve so really is facilitating a streamlined approach to give principles the information and content that they need in one space so they can problem solve extremely extremely quickly uh the implementation of this work and this is just I'm going to throw the slide in wherever I can um has been significant so each of the last three years we have outpaced all other districts in the

010State of Florida in terms of our academic growth um so this is a slide that we're very very proud of and we can we want to continue on that projectory as we close out this school year um sustained instruction improvements also come at in the cost of finances uh we have created a very comprehensive long range plan to ensure that we are fiscally responsible with the dollars that we have we just don't balance our dollars from year to year we're making forecast on enrollment we're aligning the enrollment uh our our staffing needs to our enrollment needs in order to ensure that we continue to be stable financially we've had two upgradings of our financial rating since I've been here uh just about two weeks ago Mr Green released that we are uh had our received

011our second uh improvement in our Fitch rating from uh to stable from negative to stable to positive over the course of 5 years takes about two years to get a increase so the fact that we've had two and five years is absolutely outstanding uh this takes you a little bit deeper into the art of problem solving this lays out all of the information gives principles and this is a continuous Improvement cycle uh that we condense into a grading period whereas the state um puts it over the course of a year so when you look at why are our results U growing faster than other systems uh they go through problem solving over the course of the year we go through it each and every single uh nine weeks ensuring that we are moving faster thinking

012faster and responding faster we've also have done a lot of work with our walkthroughs ensuring our principles are in fact instructional leaders uh this looks at some of the success that we have um in our math programs um just great work there and you're capturing our rate of improvement in each of the assessed areas culture of service has been something that we as a system have been very very strategic on because within this specific year uh we are competing for the right to educate this community's children and we know uh one bad experience could turn off a family and we want to ensure that there are no bad experiences we know things are going to happen we know that there's this is hard complex work but we want to create a positive experience just not

013here at the district office everywhere in the school system so we're excited about what we are seeing um this is just another example of our customer service one of the things that we're really problem solving on um is transportation making sure that we're 95% on time and dismissal we created an App of the leadership of Dr McMahon which allows us to problem solve why buses may be late at certain times uh and looking at the all of the trips that they're taking when they're stopping when they're going in we're able to track every single time a bus pulls into a school and then make modification or changes so we're doing significantly work here I think there we're had 84 87 drivers when I got here the same number of students still use Transportation today enrollment

014may have declined but students participating in transportation has not um and we are down to uh about 12 13 different routes and increased the number of time that we're getting kids uh to school and back home so proud about proud of that work and then service this was a day uh just prior to Thanksgiving where we had the opportunity to get out into the community and give back to organizations that support our community it was just a day of learning for for us so we as a system want to continue to outpace outperform and preserve when we say preserve preserve is making sure we capture all of the great things that make Indian River County Indian River County uh we're not trying to walk away from those things we're trying to embrace those things while

015at the same time continuing to outperform all other districts in the State of Florida and outpace and we know outpacing is looking at how we're going to innovate and transform education um as we begin um feedback two specific areas um that we're focusing in on and this is where I'm going to kind of transition into the Education Foundation as you know uh our Foundation was incorporated about six months ago and just last week we received the the superintend I received the superintendent shining award um for the State of Florida by the Consortium of foundations for the State of Florida and initially I was like well that that is absolutely crazy that we've only been around for six months and we we have the opportunity this Ed fund to represent the State of Florida and the

016reality is there's been a significant amount amount of work that's been done in the last six months to support um public education and we made a a conscious decision to create Our Own Foundation because what was currently in place wasn't going to meet our needs and if we wanted to move as fast as we deserve to move for our children we need to take the matters into our own hands so we were able to recruit Miss kup who was the founding executive director for Chicago public schools Foundation uh and it was a model Across the Nation in terms of f foundation so we are excited to put that in our key area is around two specific areas Innovation and Leadership over the last six months we've been able to create and organize um with Mission

017and a very very driven specific process we've created the bylaws uh we've gone out recruit recruited a board that is topnotch uh we have Piper the CEO of Piper uh Marine Bank and Northern Trust CEOs all wellestablished individuals in our community uh who were going to be able to support um this board strategic plan uh this organization although it was in its empy stages did support us in making sure that we are communicating the importance of our millage which as you know passed at a 75% pass rate which is absolutely a vote of confidence for our community and as we move forward with this organization um almost $700,000 raised in in its six months to support public education I think that's absolutely outstanding uh we are doing a number of projects and Innovative things to

018build Innovation uh and leadership in our community and that's my presentation i' be happy to answer any questions uh board members may have sure thank you and board members yes Mr I just have one thing David first congratulations on all the accolades I know that having met the team that it really is a team effort I mean that just from the teachers to the Administration has just been terrific so congratulations on that but second you know one of the things that's really near and dear to my heart is Early Education and I I heard something uh the other day from uh miss basuro about uh third grade reading and third grade with a goal of 75% achievement which is up about 12 points and and I think that's fantastic and when we achieve that it

019is really going to make a difference in our community so one of the things that I would ask that I would really like to see is you know I know we just measure third grade but it really is kind of a k through three discussion so at some point in one of your future presentations could you guys go deep into kind of like the way this is Flowing from kindergarten Readiness all the way through third grade because we can't just do it in third grade we have to have the whole progression so I really would appreciate an update on that when you get a chance coming up and get the midterm data so I so just to typically I would like to have more meat on the bone in this presentation we are in the

020middle of our pm2 assessments right now right so our schools starting tomorrow will dig into math some will do Ela this week and math next week and then we'll spend the back half of next week not easing into the break but each school will be working in creating a plan that is comprehensive to ensure they have every stone unturned to make sure that they hit the goal uh I'll shend out that data prior to the break for the board but as we come back I I would be more than happy to share you here's where we are in K1 and two we have a very specific approach I think one of the things that we have done strategically um even upon my arrival is to say that we're not going to be you know solely

021focused in on the District grade or school grades which you know are account third through fifth that makes up the entire grade but we're really going to solve the problem um so some of the work that we've done in K1 and two we reap the benefits now uh in terms of really growing solid solid students I'd be excited to share that as well as more more data as this year uh this calendar year closes that's good oh doc thank you very much for the presentation and congrat congratulations to you and Miss kup on that Ed Foundation Award very very proud of the fact and I think it was so important for you to change to make sure we had Innovation as our goal because when we talk about this again we're fighting for our students

022we think we're the best in town and we want them to succeed so I think that's important you know public education in the state and Nation where it's going you know I certainly want to protect in River County to make sure our kids are good question if you don't mind on the uh micr credential in the algebra I did talk um to miss Hiller about that what percentage of eighth graders are in algebra now do we have that anywhere miss baser or Dr Mo okay we but we can get it real quick at oh that's okay no I just wondered because probably around I'm going to I'm going to make a guess it's going to be around 45% okay and you basically look at the level three that's okay you can give it to me

023later I think you're very close but through the I will double check on that uh the the big difference around the micr credentialing for algebra is that all students who are eligible and eligibility is a level three or higher yes are enrolled in it okay all right um and I agree with Mr Dyer what he just said about um Early Education I know getting more of our um preschools in our schools this year and making sure that they're getting ready for kindergarten I think is number one a great recruiting tool and number two it just helps the students that adjust and just get ready for kindergarten so um I'm anxious to get going on the next strategic plan I think the two components Innovation leadership are spot on thank you P yeah um first excuse

024my my voice in my cough I'm a little under the weather today um but yeah definitely I want to Echo the the congratulations and thank yous to the team um who obviously due to um State recognitions and are school performance and everything you guys have been performing outstandingly and I would extend that obviously to the prior cabinet members who um have sense left us um so big thank you um and you know job well done um and you know the I think the biggest thing uh it was obviously an extensive presentation that covered a lot of things but um there's there's obviously still more work to be done with Student Success and uh improving testing scores ultimately um and then as well as uh monitoring and looking for improvement and the percentage of students who

025go on to get either a college education or a technical degree um and then what their Dropout rates are so just ultimately Student Success um there's there's always more work to be done there's a lot of work to be done there um and then corollary to that is um student and I would say really parent retention is obviously something we need to um look closely at and just uh TR trying to reduce and mitigate I guess the consistent loss of of students from the district um not only to um protect the district and the way it's functioning because if if you do see a significant drop over the next five years um the district and you know the number of schools we and all that uh could change substantially um so it's difficult to plan

026and project a system out with a moving uh Target really with budgeting and students so um just working on student retention as as well is is going to be a big factor and and I 100% spot on and I think as we come back in January that's going to be a a major focus of our conversation the creation of our next strategic plan and I've said uh sitting at this table before we we know where we're losing students and we lose them from fifth to six and we lose them not as as severe but from 8th to 9th so we have created a plan that was very specific and increase K8 over the course of time we may need to be more aggressive in terms of looking at k8s and I say k8s there's additional

027research to do but at face value in the conversations across the community um it is relatively clear that parents want a environment that may be different from our current middle schools in the uh midyear evaluation with our principles uh principles and our magnet schools uh in Beachland specifically uh talk explicitly to me about the number of applications or letters of recommendation that they're writing to go to a private school that costs a whole bunch of money and it's not because they're not satisfied with the product that they received in the first six years of educating their children it's because they don't choose Middle School that structure so I may be coming back to the board I'm want to engage in the conversation with the board first but we we may collectively need to be need

028to be more aggressive in our timeline of accelerating the creation of k8s which is a humongous statement to make because there's so many different barriers and obstacles that would need to be um resolved you just can't say hey you're going to become a middle school there there's significant amount of work in terms of seating and enrollment uh and shifts and boundaries that need to be done um but we we you are right you know you know we are a two-time a district we are the most improved District in the State of Florida uh We've improved or outperformed the state in every single assessed area but at the end of the day um that's not enough apparently it's it's it's the it's all great it's not enough we we need to do more uh to keep

029kids uh to make us as the number one choice I'm confident you can do that thank you big tall word thank you Rosario um yeah so congratulations on all of the awards given to you it was uh really nice to uh be there and to be able to celebrate that with you and your entire team who showed up so I'm very very excited um that we were able to see everyone at at uh the Florida school boards Association um this week uh that was really special um with with regard to um K8 I will say um you won't get an argument from me I have always been in favor of k8s I have always um said that that should be the way to go um in fact you know I've said it before you know

030I felme is a perfect opportunity to create a ka8 um it's no secret that I have been a proponent of or a supporter of that idea especially with what they have created in terms of their choice the Dual language I've spoken with multiple te parents who have said you know we're spending so much time teaching our children uh the children their dual language from K through six uh from K through five and then in sixth grade they're off to a middle school that's not going to pay attention to the Dual language Focus they would rather keep their kids there and do dual language all the way through K K through 8 um it just it it makes sense whereas if there was a steam Elementary they could probably find an middle school that has steam

031um but this particular school is so um is so unique in their you in their choice uh in their attractor program um that I think it would be a great beginning uh if there were a beginning to have plus you know that Community uh many parents want to keep their kids in their own Community rather than bust them elsewhere um so yeah you'll you'll you'll have my full support on on that um the other thing that I was going to uh talk about was the Ed foundation so with the Ed Foundation well let me just um follow up also on enrollment it's funny that you mentioned enrollment Dr PCA because I just had a conversation with uh M Dr Moore about this earlier did I say Mr PCA Dr PCA yeah whatever it's good I

032don't have a chip on my it's good um and so it I literally have the screens up from powerbi I went on this this weekend to take a look at it and when I looked at it I was pretty shocked and then even more shocked after we talked earlier today so the enrollment on powerbi as of December 2425 shows us non-charter shows us at 14,545 Dr Moore actually confirmed that that's not correct that we're actually at 13,097 70 which is that's tremendous as far as I'm concerned when I started here 6 years ago um we were at 17,500 so the amount of the decline in enrollment is so critical as far as I'm concerned I know Dr Moore says he's not concerned about it um too much but um but I share your concern um

033that that that that retention of students is critical uh and that's one of the reasons why the classical model is so important so that we can actually build um the interest of parents in the community to say okay I'm going to put my my children back in because this is what they want something different something new something out of the box yes you want to say something yeah I you were correct and I think I I sat here probably six seven months ago and I said uh in a budget conversation that we're going to be under 14,000 students um so it was a forecasted projection um I was hoping I would be wrong but I but I was not um and I think the reality is keep in mind I think of when I think

034of students I think of FTE there's number of students that are in buildings and this is what you get funded for uh so when I say 13900 whatever that's what we're getting funded for so that's the truth that's that's the money that we're getting for for students um our design in terms of budget puts us in a we are fiscally responsible with the dollars that we have based on the projections that we have I think one of the important things that I'm I'm gleaning from what Mr Rosario is is saying is that we do need to be more aggressive in looking at different concepts uh and thinking completely outside of the box and it could be very very small schools that don't feel like a public school but in fact are a public school I

035think we have the ability between this board and obviously yes this staff um really to challenge the the reality it's just not steam it's not going to be enough K8 um I yeah I think that is a good step in the right direction but it's not going to be enough it's not going to be enough um when you're competing with micro schooling which is going to explode uh when you're competing with private schools uh who can have access to public dollars you use the example of and it's the best example that I can give um as to why we need to think differently valmir would be a great place to have a Ka we need the space and we've been struggling with the space and and pretty much every Elementary principle is going to come

036in here and the end and Miss Christoph only can tell you they end every eval every uh midyear evaluation with I want to be a Ka they all want to be Ka because they they know um it's good like where am I going to put them um but a private school went into felsmere and what were they Marketing in their very first year they're in a portable I haven't been in I can't speak to the quality of because I just don't know yet but they are established they are there and they're going to continue they're starting in Middle School the Dual language program and they're going to work backwards to add a Ka so people are looking um to meet a need that we're not meeting that we need to meet and I'm all about

037competition but the guarantee this board gives is quality and accountability because if there's not quality you're going to ensure accountability so that's why I think we need to kind of put us our reform on the FasTrack but I just want to reinforce it just isn't eight it may be schools within schools it may be um little boutiques in certain aspects of the school uh we really need to challenge ourselves not to recreate something that's being done but we need to look at who's taking our kids and those may be opportunities to create programming we'll always have to do accountability we're always going to have to follow State Statute um as we should but we're going to be accountable to the end I think there's aggressive thinking and the relationships are right for us to have

038a those conversations yeah I mean it's you all know I homeschool it's not a secret also um and one of the reasons why homeschool is so effective is because of the smaller environment because they have these co-ops or the like you said the micro and the mini schools are also in in homeschool environments um but yeah I mean if if and one of the other things that is unique in homeschools for homeschoolers is that they're not t to grade level curriculum so you can combine a six and a seven and have a curriculum that actually teaches sixth and seventh graders in the same classroom if you combine those you might be able to create less need for space you know where there where whereas if you had three classes six seven and eight here if

039you combine you might I don't know just thinking out there you might be able to um come up with some something where you don't need as much space um but anyway so uh I trust that you all are going to have those conversations and come to us at the at the right time um so let me just um switch a little bit to the Ed fund so on Thursday I don't know if you all um have been able I I know I talked to Miss uh kup about this on Thursday I think it was Wednesday on my way up to fsba I heard a commercial on one of the local um radio stations and it was it was an ed Foundation commercial it literally said Ed Foundation it was Indian River County Ed Foundation even

040though I know we're Ed fund and um and it mentioned everything that we do all of the after school activities the before school and at the end of the commercial said we even partner with the Learning Alliance and like you know commercials are only just what less than 60 30 seconds 60 seconds so it was so quick and when I heard the Learning Alliance I'm like oh that must be us and and it turns out it may not have been us because we didn't really have anything to do with that so I don't know who that was I mean if there were if somebody had something out there that was you know plugging our Ed funds somehow and we get the benefit of it financially then great but um if we didn't do it I

041think that we should have commercials right because it was so effective and it really caught my eye it caught my ear rather to the things that the Ed Foundation what it was and what it did um and of course if you wanted to donate to it so um I don't know whose Ed Foundation that was I don't think anyone actually found out I didn't even remember to look at the which station it was I'm gonna say it was Christian FM but I'm not sure so it was the local one yeah I'll I'll find out I know staff is like it wasn't us but um I'll give some info yeah um and then the other thing uh with regard to uh the Ed funds so it's not $700,000 that was donated it was actually SE so

042far $764,000 cents I don't know where the 23 cents comes from but um so that's fantastic it's wonderful it's great um I just want to reiterate though that the purpose of the Ed found the Ed fund the Indian River education fund according to the bylaws is to operate exclusively for educational purposes in alignment with our district priorities so I just want to make sure that we are going to do exactly that I do not personally think that the political advertisement that was sent out um which costs the the fund $51,000 more than $51,000 um at Ironside press That's to me not for educational purposes even though I know you're going to argue well it's for $60 million um yeah I get that but we didn't have that money before if we did not have this

043fund where would where would that come from that would come from someone in the community who'd be able to pay for the political advertising I'd like to see these funds and we've we've talked about this literally directly impact classrooms that's what the purpose of the Ed fund was supposed to be for not for some of this other stuff not for posters not for some of the things that are have nothing to do with classroom activity this fund was supposed to supplement everything else that we're not that we can't in those buckets of of funding that we receive that we can't use and so I just want us to be reminded of the purpose of the fund and you are not as superintendent even though you sit on the board you are not a voting member

044on that board so I just want to be careful to protect you and not to have a a v a vote on that you have a voice but you don't have a vote so I just want to make sure that you're not directing the fund to use their funds the way that they're using it um the other thing that I wanted to bring up is um so I went on the website um and we've talked about this and it still hasn't been um taken care of so um here it is at a public meeting the June 20 so the Ed fund um for the purpose of of the public who are who's listening um they function according to sunsh Sunshine Law and according to Sunshine Law any uh meeting that happens has to be publicly

045noticed and the agendas have to be public and minutes have to be posted for those so the June 20th meeting there is no minutes still so I don't know when the minutes will will be posted for it but there are no minutes still I'll follow okay September 4th meeting um the agenda is there but there's no documents and no meeting I mean no minutes sorry okay September 4th um on the September 4th agenda there were three things that were on there that I had questions of and it said discussed gift acceptance policy uh admin fee policy and investment policy what are those policies and why aren't they posted under the documents tab so we can see those just recalling the conversation wasn't necessarily policies it was discussion or theory of action as the board is

046is be is initially forming itself so there was no policies in which to review but conversation and dialogue to have in consideration do we have to look at those specific areas so if a product is created I'll I'll I'll share okay but that could have been captured in the minutes which there are no minutes so that's where the question comes from if there were minutes it would kind of we'd be able to see that they aren't actually policies um the other thing November 13th November 13th agenda uh There Is No Agenda the November 13th meeting has the December agenda posted on it not the November agenda so even though there is a no November 13th meeting There's No Agenda I know she's shaking her head she's listening so that's okay all right um the December

047and no minutes so no agenda for that one and no minutes December thir December 10th there is an agenda no documents no minutes so when I go back on this you know and I look at these so the agenda you know I look at the agenda if I look at the minutes I'll be able to see when this political advertisement was discussed and when it was voted on who voted on it when when did it show up on some on the agenda it there's no indication on any of the posted agendas that this was even discussed to spend $51,000 it it was discussed and and it is captured in in the minutes the minutes are are available um the board that board approved $225,000 and the rest of the funds to come through donations so

048as you just referenced yes uh that money would have came from somewhere that's exactly what happened uh went out and donate individual donations came in to cover the cost cost of that so it wasn't um money being taken from kids it was money specifically being given uh to support that specific initiative which is the village but you do understand that without the minutes and without this item on the agenda there's cause for question and and that that's absolutely fine and I think that's part of your your your role um but at the end of the day it is completely transparent minutes will always be be available um now if it's the posting of agendas I think it's important to to note this is a a onew woman show and the volume of work that has

049been done in six months is astronomical uh we are at a point that no one thought we would be at because of the around the clock work that has to happen so uh I'll give a little bit of Grace and some clerical Mis mishaps to be very very honest with you um but the quality of work the quality of th those individuals is really above reproach approach and we'll make sure that we WE Post those things well the I I agree you know which is one of the reasons why you and I have been talking about this now for I think two months and but still I mean as of June a June meeting there are no minutes that are posted so um it needs to be posted minutes need to be available um in

050terms of some of the the content of conversations that they're having they're going to be talking about uh individuals money finances um they'll always be available always be provided but I I'll I'll have that conversation uh with the board Mr Dyer is the representative for the board um so as you're listening to this conversation any information you would like to take back to them to represent the board I think would be a fruitful conversation for them to have as well well let's again there's they're subject to Sunshine so according to Sunshine minutes have to be posted in a timely fashion okay um the other thing is um the dis the district found now we have a pol interesting when we approved this policy which is 9215 the district support uh foundations organization policy what what

051what I found just recently um maybe about a month or two ago was that we have a district Foundation policy called 6670 you got what we have two we have two What policies go ahead I'm sorry separate from that one yeah 6671 yeah what's the other one 9215 no that's the one that I just mentioned okay so we approved 9215 9215 was for the direct support organization that's the one that yes that's the one that we have that we know that we approved I me bylaw all that good stuff but there's another one that we have too called policy 6671 and it is titled District Foundation I don't know why it wasn't brought up or why you know we it must have skipped skipped us somehow all of us everybody uh but it is there

052um there's not too much that it's a a short um policy there's not too much that contradicts our current one but I'd like you to pull both of those up and if we need to just you know uh repeal the 6671 we don't need right I mean we just we're just policy heavy we don't need all those policies so if we could take a look at that and if you can bring back to us um a report I think there's like one or two things in the district Foundation one that I like um that I don't think is in the 9215 but yeah if you you can bring that back to us um that would be so um with that said I think that's all I have on the foundation and again congratulations on All

053the Monies that have been raised thus far okay um first of all Janet congratulations on all your hard work and um I was there all the way until Friday for the fsba conference and she extended a wonderful offer because I was there on Friday to go to um the consortium's meeting and they had a tour of the facility where they were so I drove all the way west it was a long drive home um but I was so thankful I did and I'm going to talk a little bit more about that tonight I'm going to add a discussion item about it because it was something that I had studied when I was working on my Master's Degree it's very similar to micro society which is what I gave to Imagine Schools and when they opened

054but what they have done there is just phenomenal and um thank you for all the money that you've helped raise Janet and um and for the award that was wonderful and it was really nice that they were so thankful that some board members actually came to that meeting so that was nice um one of the things that you have on the Strategic plan is innovation for Math and for civics and interestingly enough what I saw there is the Innovation for Math and Civics so so I can't wait to kind of share with you what we what we saw there which was amazing um so it's it's kind of the future it's the focus and they're doing doing it already in pelis one of the other things that they do there um is they prek focus

055so they have a very strong prek their kindergarten scores their Readiness scores are through the roof so that's a really nice thing to look at as well um you mentioned multi-age classes U Mr Rosario my son was in a multi-age class at Dodgertown and so that was years ago because he's in his 30s and uh we had several multi-age classes at Dodger toown I have taught a fourth fifth class so it's possible it happens and it was really nice there were two teachers that paired together and taught multi-age and uh it it worked out great so thinking outside the box is always great another thing to think about is adding sixth grade to the to the elementary and possibly making a boutique High School 712 so that's another possible and you know how I feel

056about Cades yes um we are losing a lot of kids from that fifth grade to sixth grade and parents are scared they hear stories about you know these big middle schools and how scary they are so either looking at Boutique middle schools or looking at um doing something Innovation or even Boutique k8s you know that's a possibility I like I like all those ideas um thinking outside the box for all kinds of parents and surveying parents to say you know why why aren't you in the public schools you know tell us what we need to do do to help and and be a better um you know forecaster of what we want to project to do not just think we we are understand what parents want but listening to parents and getting what they want

057so I think those are things that we need to start doing so thank you for all that thank you now the next items is going to turn it over to Mr Green and he is going to present C all the way up to uh through K as that says Dr Jacobs but I'm going to ask Mr Green to present that um just as a reminder we do have policy review which typically when we do policy review we put it at the front of the agenda so we do got a a big Hefty item uh towards the end of the agenda so just saying that as a reminder go ahead Mr GRE thank you Dr Moore through the chair so item C on the agenda as we have briefed previously is a semar or a construction

058management at risk agreement with Remnant construction as you're all very familiar we had the Jimmy Graves Community complex and there were two phases to that a 1 a and a 1B the 1A was the track with the shot put and all the various things that are there that's already in place this portion um we had to go through some St John's permitting some retention Pond stuff some other um things that we have gone through this is Phase 1B which will be the site work which will allow the inclusive playground to be installed we already have that equipment that was purchased um and then the the stands the seating the concession stands and the restrooms so this will allow us to move forward and complete that part um so the track will be functional the um

059inclusive playground can be installed um as we've talked about before this is funded through um really a a three-prong effort and that's a fixed Capital outlay that we were granted around 3.4 million um of around a million dollar from the city of Beach and then private donations that came through for those um so this is to approve a Construction contract with Remnant construction to do the remainder of that work CH bar all right just one question so what is the final date of the part two going to be finished so the final final date because it's probably a 10-month project would be probably September of next year but you know we are looking at getting site work done getting stands in as you remember you approved GT Grand stands at a previous meeting so we

060could move quicker so that the goal is to hopefully host some type of a smaller event later um in this spring we might have to bring some restrooms in to do that and food trucks or whatnot but um to be able to celebrate that in some way this spring and then the final completion final final should be around September thank you anyone else yeah got one question uh on that I I noticed that the budget was four million and the contract is for three and a half and it's a fixed rate so just out of curiosity since this is phase two did the contractor perform without lots of change orders and were we happy with the work in the first phase and uh did he perform on budget and on time yes absolutely and um

061what you're approving this evening which will go is also a um a guaranteed Max price for this evening of the 3.4 million so yeah we wouldn't be moving forward with them if they didn't come in on budget and on time terrific anyone else okay the next item on the agenda which should be D is the approval of the renewal of the um Contracting and Consulting agreement with Aon Aon is a global um they help mitigate risk through insurances and other um Financial advising um they help us with our self-insured health insurance fund our employee Wellness Center they do all of our reporting our 112 reporting our financial statements there's a list of things that they do to support the district and they attend our high our um health insurance advisory task force in 2010 the

062board approved a three-year contract that had three one-year annual renewals this is the third and final annual renewal of that contract and staff recommends approval there is no direct cost to the district meaning it's not um a per pay they are reimbursed through commissions of vendors who they use and leverage and support um so it's a more of a commission base through those vendors that pay them directly anyone have a question good on that one the next item e is the review of the charter school annual financial report so as a component unit of the school district meaning their financial statements um are relevant since we pass funds through to them they are required as we are each year to conduct Financial audits so they go out and retain the services of an independent auditor

063or um CPA they go through their books and they report their financial statements so um what'll be on the agenda this evening are those from those PA firms and those independent Auditors the results of those audits um overall I can tell you so similar to audits we get as well there are three kind of levels there are deficiencies so a deficiency would be something that in the normal course of a business if you didn't address this through internal controls something might slip by you a deficiency if those deficiencies are um to such a level level that there is a probability that a financial misstatement would occur because of it that would be a material weakness um I can tell you that none of the charter schools had any material weaknesses or sufficient deficiencies reported in

064their audits um their ending general fund balance reserves Indian River Charter High was 87% fund balance St Peters was 4% fund balance North County Charter was 83 3% Sebastian Jor Charter High 47% and imagine 45% um and and no no fraud or material misstatements reported in any of the the findings and it's an annual requirement for charter schools to submit Mr Dyer yeah I had just a comment uh on uh Indian River uh Charter High School they had a very robust uh management discussion in that one that really told you a lot about the school and having visited that school and seeing their arts program and their Cambridge programs uh I think that they are doing a really terrific job and it ought to be uh noted for that again no material deficiencies and I

065know that they are looking forward to some Capital that uh will be coming their way I also would note that North County Charter did have a deficiency in control uh that was corrected from the year prior that was from the year prior that had to do with their reporting so other than that looked like a pretty good bill of health but wanted to call out uh Indian uh River Charter High for their discussion and for the work they do thank you and and North County Charter did have their board addressed some policies to address saw that yeah great yes um Mr Green did you say 4% fund balance for St Peters yes is believe it was a $37,000 fund balance and it's around a million general fund budget so okay it's law says you have

066to have at least four right for our school district yeah I'm wondering individual schools okay that's interesting okay anyone else all righty item F similar since we're on audits are are in internal audits so um just to be clear that um this is not the same as the budget you approved on September 9th these are the internal accounts within the schools money's collected through Athletics for yearbooks for various issues go into um specific bank accounts some of that's invested through Florida Prime each school has their own bank account they then manage the collections of those the reason that we do internal accounts audit is to um you know make sure the financial statements are are presented properly but also they pull samples to test internal controls we have an internal control manual that they follow

067so they pull samples to say are they following the internal controls So within those audits those are all of the schools as well as the um district and you got a memo on that this year there were three schools to apartments with only one audit finding that was the district office Sebastian Elementary and Pelican Island Elementary and there were five schools with no audit findings Treasure Coast Technical College Oslo Middle School Treasure Coast Elementary which happen to be their second consecutive year in a row Citrus Elementary which was also their second consecutive year in a row and Indian River Academy uh Liz G Offrey this is your shout out by the way um which was their third consecutive year in a row um and we I might get a shirt next um but we leverage

068her um so as you go through there you will find various recommendations and findings of um when following you know deposit things within the five business days or how they handle and cash two people counting um no material weaknesses or deficiencies but things cited around internal controls that can be strengthened to ensure that you know monies aren't disappearing or fraud happens since that time we've conducted two um large scale sessions with all of the bookkeepers trainings we use Liz geofrey as a trainer um now um to help other people we have also U met with all of the principles and gone over their last three years of findings for each because some of them may had a different bookkeeper some of them may have been in a different school so we've met individually with every

069principal and gone through those and then um myself and Miss chrisa Foley and Miss Copan have worked with every school and every bank because every year it's not a finding but it is a recommendation that says your bookkeepers do some things such as collecting monies and depositing and using and their check signers on the accounts so we have been working to remove those as check signers on the accounts through those Banks we are down to two schools I'm glad to to tell you it's One Bank um and that bank requires everyone involved um to show up at the same same time on the same day with their licenses so we are scheduling that meeting but all other schools besides these two have um had their bookkeepers removed and that will um occur before the first

070of the year and we will not have that finding in the future anyone on this I got just a real quick one I mean those those accounts are 3.6 million when you look at all the clubs and everything so it's not you know inm material you know a small school one and I'm glad that she found the deficiencies but it kind of raised raed a question for me that I don't know the answer to and we can discuss it later but is there an in internal audit function for the district that we have our own internal Auditors uh you know $400 million budget it's uh I'm wondering if we're getting to the size that we need to consider something like that just for future we take it off but it just kind of jogged my

071memory on that yeah that's something we certainly can yeah look into anyone else okay I have one um two months ago I asked you for the individual athletic um budgets I still haven't seen them you deferred that to me yeah and the reason why is because I had some parents call and say you know they're they're wondering why certain Sports get so much money other sports don't get as much money there is a Title Nine that says you know we need to distribute funds evenly so um just like to double check and make sure we're doing that absolutely could we could all the board please get those budgets MH for both high schools yeah and just to be clear that you know comes out of their discretionary budgets and then they're able to use their

072internal accounts or other athletic funds for various things as well what what we want to know what I think I want to know is um you know how much each sports team is getting and then look at it per student allocation type thing um are we being fair that's what we want to know I want to know and the parents want to want to know and then um can we do it for middle schools too since we have Middle School athletics thank you can I can I add that um just a little bit of um you can do with it as as you as you wish um I'm not in disagreement with what Mrs barenborg is asking for um there was a concern um and I know and I have a feeling what's going to

073come back to us is well you know individual schools get to choose how much to give each individual sports depending on how many students are in it I get that that's going to be obvious that's going to be I mean clearly if you have a sport that has four students versus something that has you know 40 students that's going to be quite different in terms of budgeting um what I'm interested in and maybe you can add this to to the request is not just the budget portion of it but I'd like to understand the decisions that are made so a bowling team for example who is required to have those students travel not just locally but out of the out of out of our County for competitions um was is not provided uh a bus

074is not provided transportation and where parents have to be responsible for doing the driving of those students um that's a safety issue especially when it is a school sponsored event uh yet th those students were denied that opportunity and of course a parent was very concerned about it um it has since been resolved um but that shouldn't have been the place and I think budgeting had a lot to do with the reasoning before it was before the issue was fixed so those are the things that I'm interested in so if you want to however way you want to present you know collect the information and present that um I think what is what is fair is fair I understand the numbers that's not the issue but when it is a school sponsored event I think

075it is incumbent upon the schools to ensure that they're budgeting properly so that those kids get the transportation to and possibly from I don't understand the from I think a lot of parents come pick them up but um at at least two um and if possible from the sports sporting events so through the jar what we'll provide the information but um Kelly's gon to give me a number you all just I don't know you need to be reminded but the commitment that you all make in your budget to extracurricular activities with the dollars that we are provided um I'm going out on a limb here but I kind of live out on the limb um is significant I I think it's more than any other District uh Middle School athletics in a lot of counties

076just does not even exist if you look at the bands if you look at uh the volume of dollars that we commit to making sure we have that overall experience for our students and that's when I talk about preserve that's one of the things that we need to preserve because it's not the norm anymore but we'll provide we'll provide that information but I think you should be proud of the the commitment we all have collectively made uh to provide those experiences to our kids Mr yes go ahead all right uh thank you Miss Rosario and Miss barenborg for mentioning this I think you'll see when you look at budgets especially internal that the activities are getting money and whether it's football tickets volleyball tickets and so forth um pretty fluid and then it makes a

077difference is who's getting uniforms this year I mean what you're going to put your money in and I think I think I'm still sure that the principal and AD work together on that but I will tell you the the um the budget that really hurts them is transportation so if we can get a little bit more money there so we don't have our parents driving or we don't have that kind of things because first thing I think of is liability if something happens so but these these budgets are very fluid depending on fall winter and spring Sports and from what I recall um they are Body by Title 9 and uh I believe that is true but again these are fluid and I think most of us know that um football will support a lot

078of the other teams I mean you don't make money in track you don't make money in Bowling you don't make money you might make a little bit of money in volleyball but then you pay your refs so you could see it's we have done a great job in in River County with helping with that because I think all of us know whether it's band Athletics chorus keep our kids in healthy activi so whatever we can do to help um there through the chair the next item is item G contracted surfaces for roof replacement projects so we have two large roof replacement projects coming up um this is through a uh intergovernmental Cooperative purchasing agreement it is a full roof replacement at Oola magnet so that's take down the type of membrane they have seal it

079you're talking about making sure you're building envelope that cre keeps moisture in and out that has to be replaced as well as all that metal fascia that you see around that's colored on those schools those type of schools that is included and that's roughly $2.4 million and we have the ver Beach High School boys and girls um the gym and the locker room area those two projects will be um starting soon after approval for a multiple of reasons and those those will be done in the evening number one there's not enough time to do it just in the summer when school opens we have summer school going on number two Now's the Time to do it from temperature and weather standpoint um the summer is the rainy season so those will be um evening projects

080that will be managed from now through the spring for those two roof Ro uh projects and those are funded out of your Capital plan and that was approved anyone else um one thing I've noticed uh one of the projects that was going on I think it was Glendale um there was a temporary gate their issue so just make sure that we don't have any security issues okay through the chair the next item is H and this is a construction management at risk contract with Bill Bryant so at Treasure Coast Elementary you'll um you'll be aware that is our special needs shelter um although we have a generator there that doesn't run the entire School the county also brings in a separate generator for people on life support so it's a it's a fragile center with

081a lot of infrastructure one of the things that this board was granted through the division of Emergency Management was um just over a $500,000 Grant to harden that building so if you go by Treasure Coast Elementary and you look up on kind of the mauve color area you see those small windows and what is it I don't know um red M they uh they they keep the clear plastic shutters because you have to have a lift to get up there to put those shutters on and off all the time so those windows will be replaced with impact window so that we won't have to do that everything on the ground floor will be the accordion type um hurricane be able to close them up and lock them except for the retunda area which would be

082replaced with impact resistant uh material as well this is funded through a grant and since it's involving Windows it will be done over the summer um the cost is a guaranteed Max not to exceed $528,500 43 and is funded through that um GR through the division of Emergency Services anyone on this I have one comment and that is um did you know that Bard schools does not use any of their schools for shelters Bard uses all their County facilities for their shelters so when an emergency happens they don't have to delay school coming back in because they don't have to clean up the schools and and come back have we had conversation with the county about you know now they have this Administration Building that they didn't have years ago they have the IG Center

083I'm not sure if that's Arcane proof um but they do have some other facilities that are we starting can we ask them at least to share some of this responsibility so we don't have like our flick um you know being used as that shelter that it takes a long time to clean it up so just sitting in those Emergency Management meetings I don't think they're they have the ability to to staff them nor do I think they have the facilities across the County that that would meet that need and as big of a burden as it is for us I I think you sound like a Few Good Men uh you want us uh running those shelters for our community the the work that our principles do and doing it now I don't know I

084think the IG Center is I think that's the only one that they would they would they would have um but how they would staff them I I I honestly don't I don't I don't know but it's a partnership that we have with them right have Poss staff it I'm thinking I'm thinking of our facilities and how long it takes to clean them up and then we Delay school a day or two so we we do a really good job that was and Mr tesky knows how I am uh we're going to open up schools immediately as soon as we possibly can the one variance we're always going to have uh which is the school we're referencing Treasure Coast because it takes an extra day for them to get out but we created a protocol for

085that as well so we will move all of the materials and equipment to one specific place in the school because they have to come and pick it up so we can continue to have school so we will not as this district has done in the past let the entire District sit home for an extra day because they have to clean uh or remove materials or resources that are spread across Treasure Coast so we have a plan in place so we won't miss in any additional time other than the traditional cleaning I understand but I think it's worth a conversation IG CER at least so you know at least we have another facility like the flick I'm thinking the flick because that that one I've been in that shelter and done shelter Duty in that shelter

086yeah no and and a piece of that falls on on me as well or as a team is is that the most appropriate place to to have a shelter are there other locations Oslo is right down the street um so we do an after action review which we haven't had this year yet because you know is hurricane season really over yet um but when when we do that those are the conversations that we do have okay because I I'd like to at least throw that out there that we need to talk about that um especially when I find out that other districts don't use their schools at all thank you through the chair the next item I is um a form agreement contracted services for replacing the stadium ligh lighting at the Citrus bow at

087ver Beach High School as we've discussed um the lighting there is aged it is in a um a coastal environment and has been found to have corroded the cross beams and the connectors as a precautionary event we have already um provided cabling to each of the lights just to ensure that um no additional lights would fall it's a life safety issue um so this is a contract for um $346,500 to replace the poles will stay the concrete poles but this replaces the metal the infrastructure the beams the lights the wiring and the control boxes um and will'll replace them with LED lights which are much more um energy efficient to operate on a consistent basis anyone about lights yes doc um I'm sorry is that going to replace all the lights of ver Beach High

088School at the state the ones at the stadium yes the four I believe the four main grouping okay um in the band thanks you yes I know it was in the isn't that where it felt it was a clear inet section I was more in the trumpet section um through the chair the next item is J um as we have researched additional um mechanisms and uh for purchasing some of the items we have found um are more coste effective through Cooperative agreements and and you have a board policy 6440 which encourages the use of Cooperative purchasing agreements when uh that benefits the district so this is an agreement with by board interlocal um who is a group of governmental agencies who gather together um as a Consortium if you will a Cooperative to leverage volume

089pricing and um this agreement just allows us to piggyback and purchase at the prices they negotiate iate through that um cooperative and it's just an annual automatic renewal with a 30-day uh cancellation if for some reason we didn't want to use them um we had been using other ones however the New York hires contract which gave us even more competitive pricing has raised their threshold so that our volume of purchasing doesn't meet their threshold so this gives us um additional um Cooperative buying agreements that we can leverage um for cost savings anybody Mr RAR yeah um how many how many contracts do we um engage in through by board do you I mean this is a renewal this is new this is um I heard you say renewal oh I'm sorry um this is a

090uh it's a Cooperative agreement we would be entering into we would be one of the Cooperative members so that um we can then purchase at that volume price okay there is no cost to it it's just joining their membership if you will so what so again if there's no cost there's no cost for the district no if there's no cost then how does it how does it work what's the benefit to so buy board yeah and I think they started in 2010 if I'm not mistaken out of Texas so their benefit is through vendors that's how kind of like Aon they going to get paid to vendors and the vendors benefit is I've got 75 school districts who are going to buy metal detectors open gate because that's the you know example and I can

091bring all those to you um in volume so it's volume purchase pricing so um an example let's say open gate if we were I mean how would that work for us how would that work for you all if we were thinking about Open Gate um what would you do you would go on to like their Marketplace or something exactly okay and so we are um purchasing our procurement person would reach out to multiple so we have some of these are the roofing is a piggyback on a um on a contract so we we have something online where we keep those various contracts we join them and then we price bid them we put them out and see what the price is um when we purchased the open gate originally we were able to leverage the

092New York hires contract and we were able to see about a $66,000 saving per unit over buying them direct from the manufacturer and we priced out like five or six different bids and we can also leverage any bid any other governmental agency is um competitively negotiated so if Oola County went out and did their own bid for open gate and they got a cheaper price than the Consortium we could leverage that so we leverage any governmental bid we can leverage this just gives us a wet it's you're right it's like a Marketplace we have an online site and we can shop their products and add them into into our cost analysis before purchasing I I've seen the logo I've seen um uh by board I just didn't know obviously what what it was for um

093my question though I don't know if you've done some research prior to this um do do we have any local vendors I mean are there any local vendors that are a part of it or are these more like National Vendor yeah I see a shaking head they're like National Vendors I I would want to say however not being a member I haven't gone under their Marketplace I don't have access to that so I haven't looked at their vendor pool okay um but I would assume since they're out of Texas and they're a n they're an international type um Cooperative that it's probably larger vendors okay thank you anyone else all right this is one of those times where you know at conferences we go and talk to the vendors that support conferences and there one

094of the big vendor supporters for fsba so I've talked to them several times so thank you Bruce for taking the card that I gave you and following up on it after speaking to them several times at fsba I thought why are we not using them because the cost that you know that they can get us for something that we're already purchasing already was amazing and with no extra cost to us so why not so thank you for following up on that I appreciate it thank you the next item through the chair the next item is actually K review a purchase of school buses for per Florida doe ITB which is an invitation to bid 2302 um so in every year in your Capital outlay plan that you must Post in the newspaper one of the

095items that you must um notify the community a line item it's one of the few line items is the number of school buses that you'll be purchasing so in that Capital ad you posted 10 school buses that does not mean you need have to PO purchase 10 school buses in fact last year I think you only purchased five of the 10 um if if I'm not mistaken however you can purchase up to that 10 so going back away and this was um before me even being involved with most of it I know there was a board who had come up with a commitment to move to um a cleaner um instead of the diesel buses sitting at the overhangs of the schools I remember the conversation the kids are all sitting on the benches and

096the diesel is running in the smell um to a more clean running um bus um move towards uh propane buses currently you have 109 bus fleet you have 16 diesel buses left out of that 109 um the average miles on those buses are 215,000 Miles and they are the oldest ones are 14 to 16 years old of those buses you have two that are unusable because the turbo is bad you have one that is unusable the engine is out and one that's unusable with the transmission um as well I know Transportation has been trying for a particular clean energy Grant which they were finally awarded this year so with the purchase of these buses if we are to take our diesel bus for every 1: one we were approved up to 14 buses where we

097could basically poke a hole in the motor you have to disable the bus so it can't you can't sell it and they use it for a food truck on the summertime it can't be on the road remove the emission um and purchase either electric or propane a clean energy bus there's a $25,000 rebate per bus we were approved to 14 buses however your Capital add limits you to 12 uh 10 buses without read advertising so um in your Capital plan is is um money to purchase 10 school buses this would be purchasing 10 propane school buses and removing 10 diesel buses applying them to the grant at $25,000 each so you would have a $250,000 rebate coming back you purchase them up front the total cost in the agenda is uh 1.5 [Music] million one

0981,513 ,850 um the buses used to be on a 10year um rotation you've extended that um these are 16-year-old buses and just a goal to try to get them on a 12 or 14year refresh cycle and to leverage um as many of the um rebates as possible um which eliminates um having diesel mechanics and propane mechanics um um some of the parts and the emissions that that have to be maintained on an older diesel bus that a propane bus does not have he anyone on buses just one yes um Mr Greener Dr Moore I know Mr idet talked about this a year or so ago about being able to gas up at the compound and there were some questions on that yeah so you actually have an item in your Capital 5year plan for a

099refueling Center that's been pushed out a little bit um Mr westenberger and I have had some conversations about that and we're going to be meeting with some vendors to see about instead of building a capital investment of $3.4 million for a fueling station um I know when I was in the Private Industry we did this at a um at a company you can have them come in they'll do the infrastructure cost there might be a small um up charge on the fuel but you pay for that over the life of it and then if you ever change to electric buses you're not stuck with that capital investment so we're are going to be meeting with some vendors to look at possible ways of having the vendor install that unit um they support it they maintain

100it they do the warranty we leverage being able to fuel up propane at the particular site at Transportation North or South County but we aren't um out that capital investment and that maintenance issue it would be um just through the fuel they there's a charge that you would have to calculate that uh return on investment um to to not have that long-term investment in a propane Center so we are re-evaluating that before we bring anything back to the board thank you anyone else yeah that was what I was going to ask about the fuel station it did seem you know $3.4 million uh I think that being green is great but my question is is what's the premium you know at some point over doing Diesel with fuel probably going down and you know maybe

101if you don't do the capital investment the other thing going up propane can be pretty expensive so I I don't know if it's a a wash green is great as long as it's uh the premium is manageable yeah so um our our propane cost now is about $1.70 per BTU gallon we're Diesel and we get it on a different contract so it's different than you might see in your Marketplace if you just went to a maragas or something where diesel has been ranging 280 to 310 a gallon now it's not the same footprint miles per gallon per BTU to diesel but um most of the research studies show that you can save some fuel with propane but bigger than that are the maintenance costs longterm just the maintenance of changing the oil and stuff the

102the maintenance that needs to be done is cheaper they average about like $45 versus $150 for one component the turbos the emissions there are no emission controls the EGR the turbos and all of the emission components those are what typically start going bad on a diesel engine later on so the overall maintenance costs um the research shows is lower there's a little bit um like $3,000 upfront cost for it but over the life of it is um cheaper okay according to those it's still an internal combustion engine though right with because it's just the fuel is propane versus it's more like a gas engine that's converted to use propane instead of a diesel engine but no emissions right anyone else and the wonderful world buses no I I have a question about it um how

103many um drivers do we have right now um I think say we have 71 to 74 drivers currently right now probably about four or five openings okay and okay so about 80 total and then we have a you said 109 in the fleet so why would we need 10 more buses well actually what we're going to be doing is reducing 16 buses so six of them are obsolete will reduce the 16 so we'll reduce those 16 we'll buy 10 new however those buses are they're also some are used you know for specific things there's handicap lift some are used for various trips field trips and then there is a percentage and I want to say 30% of spare buses that are needed and used at each of those sites on a day-to-day basis to keep

104the fleet running those are okay so we won't have a bunch just sitting around no um there are constantly buses in um I actually called Mr kroor today we had one of our mechanics out and he was actually um up to his arms in Greece he was on the lift with one of our wheelchair buses but they had three buses in the bay and um so those are accounted for in this Bayer so actually we will um eliminate our diesel buses the 16 that we have um six of them just are not functioning and we can reduce the efficiencies and then the 10 we will replace with um propane okay and then the other question I have is um I have heard that we use the diesel buses for long trips right when go across

105the state with a team or something so and most of that is because the refueling you know you have to stop at a place that actually can give them propane and I'm sure you do um agreements with other school districts when you go places right so will that be a problem then if we're right we um I think we had the sence sphere Awards or something that was out of the range and we um just coordinated for a bobtail so while the bus was parked Americas or whoever came and serviced and filled the bus up at that location so they could come back okay so you've got that figured out then we don't have to worry about keeping diesel buses around for that yes okay and through the chair those are all of my items

106okay thank you Dr shafty item L on today's Workshop continues to demonstrate our commitment to compliance with library media purchases today two schools are bringing forth purchase lists that are new acquisitions to the district We are following our same procedure that we have for the past two years as well as uh the information individually briefed with you the two schools are Oola and uh ver Beach Elementary you will also notice that their Sac approval minutes which are their committees who review the books are attached to the backup documentation for the item and each Sac committee um approved the purchases unanimously after reviewing peer reviews and then the last piece of information is upon receipt pending board approval each of these materials will be read cover to cover before being placed on the shelf for Access

107by our students happy to answer any questions questions board members no question I do have a comment um I'm just glad that we're in a place now um I talk with other um districts who are still struggling as if it was day one with all of the book issues um I I'm just I'm really grateful that I get to breathe when I have those conversations with them and I'm like not us um so I I'm happy where we are I'm happy that you know we have that system going we understand our policy is a great policy I've always said that um it took a while to get there but we were um I I want to say the first to develop a really good policy um I hope to be able to share to continue

108to share that policies because we do have several policies regarding um the books and um and this is just one of those so thank you for the work that you're doing on that um and I'm glad that the books are going to be read now I understand that nothing is fullprof um but um we haven't had any issues so far and I'm I'm extremely grateful for that so thank you thank you likewise anyone else all right Madam chair the last item is the review of policies and just to set this up and I'll defer to you madam chair is each Cabinet member will follow first if you can hold that up we're going to follow the chart and present each item so if you were wanted to follow along the policies so we'll be jumping

109around uh as in the past this may take a significant amount of time I don't know if you wanted to take a break now or maybe you say you take it every two hours but that's up to you and does anybody need a break right now good all right we'll ask again at twoo all right that's the case I will turn it over to Dr Jacobs uh who will facilitate um this linky process all right um good afternoon through the chair I'm going to be reviewing over the policies from the office of the superintendent Dr shafty will be co-presenting some of these policies along with me but we will follow the order that you find in your agenda materials um regarding each one of those policies so the first policy is policy legislative the revision

110to this policy is the addition of language related to the board adopting a policy prior to a statute becoming effective so this just allows the board to get ahead of a statute um and the implementation of a statute the next policy wait do you have a do you have a question s i i i don't have a question um I had a conversation though um this uh week when at fsba about this um and really about how long it takes um um Neola to get their changes to us uh and even though we have the so it it's interesting and we can enact a law that has been pass and most of them um are effective as of July 1st um if it is effective July 1st we can go ahead and begin enacting it

111in order for us to be able to enact it though we'd have to create a policy for that but then niola may come to us 6 months later with their recommended changes their recommended um policies for that so there's this gap of time in between when we are legally um allowed to begin the changes according to the legislator's changes blah blah blah and then I just I don't know if this would be a conversation for U Miss shadic I guess the question is how do we do that you know do we just go ahead and create let's say there was a policy that we wanted to create do we go ahead and do that and then wait for some recommended changes and I know that you're going to say we're going to be legally sound

112it would be legally sound for us to do that because policy is up to the board but there just seems to be such a disconnect with that time you know with that lag um yes through the chair so um in terms of creating policy policy um especially when you're talking about a legislative session and you may have 30 policies you need to change whether you have a contracted company like Neola or you have staff doing it it's going to take a while to be able to go through all of the policies and make those corresponding changes um you'd have to look but I mean one of the reasons that school districts contract with companies like Neola is to make the lag shorter even though there's still a lag because it you know what I mean

113would take staff even longer to try to make all of those changes by themselves um so that's one of the services they provide but in terms of compliance you know you can comply with the law before you know while you were in the good faith process of making those changes it's understood that that is going to you know take some time and not just the changes in terms of you know making the changes to the policies themselves but also we have that process we have to go through our elves with rule making um which is your bylaw 0131 I believe so you know we have to do that whole process where we publish our notice of Ru making and we have the 28 days and then we have our hearing on it and so and

114even before that things like bringing it to workshop and you know making any changes if um if the board has suggested changes so we had we've we've had opportunity we've had times in the past especially with the parental Bill of Rights where we just went ahead and we just started um the process I think we we drafted our first um policy so that it could begin July 1 or maybe shortly thereafter um which was no big deal and this was a few years ago um so we could do that obviously I just don't understand why this change here I'm not I'm not against it I just don't understand why it needed to be captured it's not a bad thing um because we were able to do it anyway um so this is I guess it's

115a rhetorical statement here but um just so that I understand the full scope of what happens behind the scenes do you have anything to add to that or to help us understand okay yes I see I agree with you and I think you know sometimes even when things are already true you know we may still put them in our policy it just reinforces it so I would agree with you on that point okay thank you thanks anyone else um yeah there's something I want to U mention about this I I went to the session about Neola and uh it's interesting that Scott bass was there and he's now working with niola so that's interesting um but I agree it takes too long after a law is enacted for us to finally get the policy that

116we need to put in place here it is tonight where we're going to be doing a lot of that um but I also heard very very clearly that they said they have a team of law lawyers and they look it over for legal sufficiency and that they back it so if we are um challenged on any of our policies it doesn't come out of our board pocket to defend that it comes out of their pocket so they defend their policies when we get um somebody that disagrees with something in our policy and challenges us so but if we change one word of that policy that's negated so that's just something for the board to understand that we pay Neola and their I don't even know how many attorneys they have that work on this but

117a bunch and um we pay all these attorneys to look it over and make sure they do a good job but if we change one word of it we've now negated what that policy's defenses so we now are on the hook for defending the policy if we change a word so I'm just letting you know that I heard that very clearly in um my session I went to over in Tampa so thank you the next policy is policy 1010 board superintendent relationship there is one revision to this policy in which they identified that whenever the board formulates their position on the superintendent's performance evaluation that objective information should be used in lie of subjective opinions Mr Rosario yeah it's not not in lie it's not in Li of it's actually um oh I'm on the

118wrong one hold on let me get there um it's whenever possible so that's a big difference I apologies for using the wrong ter no that's okay and it it makes a difference because um we're we there are so many there's evaluating the superintendent is so vast there's so many things um that go into evaluating him um and there are um obviously things that are are going to be subjective because it's it's based on the experience that we have with him right Communications for example is one of those areas of evaluation for the superintendent if the superintendent fails to communicate with the board um that would be something subjective that each individual board member would have to provide their evaluation on him for um and clearly as a subjective matter um it is a part of

119his evaluation so I take this here this change um even though I do understand where it's coming from I I don't think it's necessary um and it's not by um statute we don't necessarily have to have it in there um I just want to make sure I'm glad that it says whenever possible and not in lie of because of the variance uh of his of his work the scope of it um and board members need to be able to know that especially Mr Dyer who's new when you give your evaluation it will be primarily based on obviously you have the the objective the state the the the academic part of it where you're going to get the data and you'll be able to evaluate him on that but then you have all the other things

120um and that's the part that comes that this subjective part comes into play yes doc M Borg um I've done hundreds of evaluations and U yes we have the data um with Dr War's cabinet and how we are doing but I do believe subjective in some manner is good because we have this all the time with people doing what they need to do and then the relationships they establish through that and I think it's important that we have the objective 100% And if we do subjective we give you a reason why um you know you can have the best math teacher in the world and they're not connecting with kids you know so they're not doing the learning that should happen so I'm just going to ask Dr Moore did you put this in here

121and why were you thinking about this this is not Neola this was actually a a recommendation so what as it came to me for re review I I think it's just solidifies um what a good board superintendent relationship would be and it is a combination of of absolute both thank you very much I like I said I I think that we all do something subjective as as to how you know you're relating to our principles our schools our community and um you do an exceptional job okay I yes I would like um um through the board for to hear from other board members on this I mean Terry and I were the only one Mrs barenborg and I were the only ones who were here when we had the the pre the previous superintendent um

122um if we were to go on just objective outcomes that entire ending would be completely different and in fact we it was based a lot of it was based on subjective information um and we don't need to Hash that up but that's important so I appreciate Dr Jones uh what you just said right now because it is incredibly important so I'd like to hear from other board members my recommendation is that we just not put this in there it's not necessary it's not needed that's the only thing that's being recommended by Neola again it's not by Statute there's no requirement for it um I just think it muddies it not just for for us because obviously we're here but future boards to come uh we know that we're looking at both we know we're going

123to be looking at both or we can even say both objective and subjective um but anyway uh through the board I'd like to hear from other board members to see Dr b um I I mean I don't think this is going to really change anything I mean I also my observations are objective so um either way I'm just going to going to review however I feel like at the end of the day so that's your subjective no I mean leg legally your my observations are objective all day long every day at my job so it is what it is um I have a question was this a Neola Rec recommendation yes okay so I just finished saying that if we change a word from a Neola policy then we're on the hook for it and

124it says whenever possible I agree that I do put subjective things in there because I tout um your accomplishments in that way however I understand why probably Neola is doing this because I have seen some very inappropriate unprofessional comments that are written and they're public and I think that people really need to consider the fact that we need to be more professional when you sit on this board in our speaking and in our writing and I think that's probably why it's there um but I'm fine with it because um it says whenever possible and it's a Neola recommendation so I'm fine with it I'm fine with it too uh I I would say while new to this board I have done numerous CEO evaluations uh for probably uh the last 30 years I I understand

125subjective and objective I have done the evaluations and I've been evaluated as a CEO so I'm well vered in evaluations and I think that this is just fine okay thank you next the next one is policy 1210 standards of ethical conduct we align this policy to the principles of professional conduct so that when you see the red strike through it's not actually strikethrough of removal it's strikethrough of realignment to where it falls s with the state statute and then the addition is based on the Florida Administrative Code that has new expectations for principles as certificate holders as it pertains to instructional materials anyone M Rosario so um just for purposes of clarification those items that were were stricken are placed in another policy the strike through on on page one is referenced later on in

126the order that it falls in the principles of professional conduct and then the page two uh page two and a citation again on page three with the statute okay questions on that one okay the next three I will present as one because they affect they're the same update but affect different books of niola so 1242 3242 and 4242 are the Admin Professional staff and support staff updates for professional development which we shifted a couple years ago we updated the language now to professional learning as well as the state's uh expectations for the professional learning catalog which the board approved in August so we are on track with everything as a technical update in these existing policies anyone have a question on any of those okay looks like we're good next one is policy 2440 summer

127programs this is related to our voluntary pre kindergarten programs during the summer it indicates that the board May um fulfill the requirement to have a summer VPK program by Contracting with private providers additionally there's timelines added um within the language that indicates when students have to be assessed during that summer program um both at the beginning and end of that program Mr Rosario um what what is it can you talk a little bit more about contract Contracting with private um facilities so um the I'm sorry I'm sorry this is 2440 right yes okay yes so each district is required to have a summer pre kindergarten program The District May operate their own program or may choose to contract with private facilities for those programs to implement that program so for the summer yes who's paying

128for it we are we receive money for a voluntary prek program okay but we had an issue last year was it last year we had an issue one year and I I I'm just asking for clarification here um that we were going previously to seesac this was years ago we were going to seesac asking for funds for voluntary prek I think it was and then um that was no longer the case because the law changed legislation changed and then we other organizations were paying for it and then last year we weren't approved I mean I don't know what was going on but we are we is this that through the through the chair this is that these it wasn't a law that changed it was their ordinance for the city the ordinance Chang that two

129tax receiving uh organizations that receive tax dollars which obviously the county is as is the school district that we couldn't receive those um those funds so what they came up with is to Outsource the program so an organization hosts the program that they hire our teachers most in most cases they hire the teachers and then ultimately they run they run the program so that's that's how it's currently that's how it was done last school year uh and then we're looking at how we're going to do it this specific year but this is saying that we would contract with them yeah you it's saying you can contract with an outside entity not necessarily the the county itself it's just how we've done it locally in Indian River County to do step and Decay yeah but Contracting

130with a private prek provider there's no language here that says that we are funding it if we're funding it if we didn't have the funds for it last year and the previous year and the previous year how are we going to fund it again moving forward if we're putting it in policy I know we've got to find the money but we've never been able to do it before so where is the clarity on that what does the contract mean I think we need to clarify what contract means you could contract as a part there are a number of prek programs um that function we could have contracted with one of them and pay them to run that specific program so um I don't know I think on your way home all of you will pass

131a a prek facility this allows us to contract with them to meet this specific requirement it's an option it's not how we've met it have no intention of of moving in that direction I think we have a model program when it comes to steping Decay yeah um um but I'm sure there are districts who who say you know what there's we don't have the the Manpower teachers aren't willing to work over the summer it provides an option that I think the the board would want to have the option um God forbid yes go ahead now obviously in our summer programs we have step into K and then we have ese prek did we have can you tell me how many pre-s we had through our system through Miss flood this summer can provide that information

132to the board It's relatively it's an extensive program we're very busy during the summer I know um on our priorities for legislation and then with the state we're looking for more money for prek because it's not 100% as we all know so I think it's a key the next policy is 2522 that is an update based on House Bill 1285 which limits a resident of the county to challenge one material per month so that ex exact language was lifted from the house bill and added to our policy anyone on that one policy 2700 is academically High performing school districts this is a new policy to us in addition to that we were recently um named an academically High performing School District this policy indicates the eligibility of academically High um performing school districts to be

133exempt from certain requirements it also outlines the eligibility requirements to be named as such anyone on this one this one yes Dr jaes can you give me an example of what we could be exempt from so one of the most clear examples that I could find was that we are able to do up to I believe it's 2 days virtually instead of having inperson instruction so that that is one of the um indicators the other in or one of the eligibility exemptions and the one of the other exemptions is the start date for the school year thank you interesting the next one is 3130 appointment assignment transfer and promotion of instructional staff Senate Bill 7002 replaced the term temporary certified with inexperienced teacher and it kept the definition the same meaning one who has been

134teaching for three years or less so we normed the policy language with the Senate Bill questions the next one is 5780 student parent rights a combination of house bills resulted in an additional rate for families dealing with short acting Bronco dilator use so our policy has been updated to reflect that rate can you tell me what tab that's under because you just went out of order so it's not under the superintendence tab anymore it's probably in uh probably under um Student Affairs Advocacy and access okaycome we'll do that one again order we'll do that again we it's like three policies ahead of where we left off yeah okay I see it thank you and policy 7548 is artificial intelligence and we are suggesting uh the recommendation to go with nea's language we reviewed it with

135our teams and made sure every citation in this policy to an existing policy is one that we actually have in place anyone want to mention AI M Rosario I I do let me I have a here with me because I had a screen here see if I can find it here it is so this was the academic honesty policy no that was the artificial intelligence policy I'd like if we can can we pull up 5505 does that fall under you it's the student student services let me is that yours yeah oh sorry all right let me pull that one up 5505 there it is all right I'm waiting here as I pull it up um so while I do you have it up do you need it on the screen yes through the chair yes

136we do have it up okay mine is taking forever to open so as soon as that opens I'll be able to you know talk specifically to it but um until then so the academic honest Y and artificial intelligence there's some parts of art artificial intelligence clearly that talk about academic honesty um and so I'm just wondering if we can just combine obviously we so many policies just saying the same thing uh through the chair yes we uh Mrs Holden did brief the board on that and um that will be under consideration I see that most those two part policies do you know share pretty much the same information so I can see that happening well that that was when I brought artificial intelligence months ago um there was a policy that I recommended months ago

137I kind of Incorporated some of the academic honesty in it so that we didn't have five different policies saying basically the same thing um and so here we have a brand new one of AC I mean yeah a new we have academic honesty here it says new but it's really not new and then you have artificial intelligence that's the new one so through the chair just something for consideration is your 7,000 NE work is property and your 5,000 policies are students so while it may seem redundant if you have something driven for your students you would more than likely want it to stay in your 5000s which would be your academic um honesty and what I'm sorry what would be the difference it's still addressing students teaching and learning but the 7 thou it's the

138numbering system in Neola 7,000 has to deal with property and gifts and just the way the organization of the policies if they we were familiar and consistent with policies like the other Neola districts they would look for certain things in the 5,000 book versus the 7,000 book so academic honesty makes sense in the 5,000 book because it's directly related to students where artificial intelligence impacts a broader space of property which would keep this one in the 7 thousands of property and not students you're good keep going okay I disagree but okay so this policy there are a lot of language changes within the policy to align the verbiage with USDA requirements additionally there are USDA smart snacks nutritional standards that we must abide by so you'll see that there also has been language added related

139to comp what they call competitive Foods so there's limitations on when competitive foods can be sold um and what can be sold uh as competitive Foods anyone have a comment about this one stay tuned with Mr Kennedy it's probably going to change again so yeah um I have a comment about this I I was uh went over to see what was going on at Dodgertown on Saturday I missed Santa um but um there were a bunch of cars there because of the bikeathon that was going on in gford so I saw a group of kids that are the Explorers troop I think 551 and they were wonderful and they were on their downtime so one of them recognized me and they came over and I was surprised they knew what a board member was um

140but they were telling me about um their schools and how proud they were of their schools and they were from all different schools even some in Port St lcy some Charter some private and um the one thing I heard over and over again is this food one kid stood up for Vero Beach High School and said no our food is good we really like our food everybody else said the food is like cardboard and I was really taken back by I I wasn't taken back by that because I've actually walked through and seen some some of the meals sometimes and go but I know that they they follow nutrition standards and they do all that I just want you to know what the kids are saying and it was a group of probably 15 20

141kids all said the same exact thing it was pretty interesting except for ver Beach High School he went on and on about their food is really good so he defended his school but the rest of them said they love their school a lot of the things they did mention a couple other little things I'll talk to you about um but they um mentioned overall the food and that's why they don't buy it because they said they don't they don't think it's tasty and and delicious y so I'm just letting you know that that was from coming from the kids next policy is 8600 Transportation the major change here or addition relates to bus infraction detection systems um and the cameras essentially that we place on buses to detect any um traffic infractions so essentially this

142revision says that that those detection systems can only be used to enforce traffic infractions and can't be used for just general surveillance and that came from on one of the statutes that was passed this past year correct okay any comment on that all right could we take a break um because it's too to we do one more for her and then if we do one more then one one more can you hold my office is done all right one more I have the last one it is policy 9700 very quick update House Bill 13117 defines patriotic organizations and their roles in schools and this policy simply updates it from that house bill any comments All right we shall take a 10-minute break e e e okay we're going to resume our Workshop it is 211

143and uh Dr Moore Mr Greens book of policies thank you Dr Moore through the chair so we are going to skip to some financial and business services policy starting with three policies together that are related and if you notice on the spreadsheet as we go through you'll see red markings where it says 1281 3281 and 4281 are related as you know 1281 will be an administrative 3,000 of be instructional 4,000 in support so um 3281 and 4281 simply add the statutory reference to the policy nothing else they add the statute number that was missing for all three of those policies the next two are related 13 hold on one second anybody have a question on those okay all right the next two were related um around anti-harassment actually three 3362 and 4362 as you know

144we talk about bullying and harassment with students often but this statute also says we can't bully or harass other employees so what they have added is a reference to um speak to employes bullying and harassment you will see a lot of green addition and red strike through that is simply a formatting issue there are not substantial changes in any content here it's just the way they're formatted so the entire section is struck out and is Rewritten in green what it adds is the fact that you can't harass or bully employees you can investigate on an anonymous complaint but you cannot discipline solely on an anonymous complaint and someone could be um disciplined up to termination for falsely or wrongly um intentionally accusing someone of harassment or bullying those three policies all have those three similar

145changes to them around employees you good there yeah I oh mrar yeah I I just I know that um when that is fully implemented I trust that the um procedure of establishing or trying to um investigate whether an accusation was intentional or not would be um priority would be you know taken seriously because even that in that alone we don't want to accuse someone of intentionally doing something um without actually having the proof of it so I don't know you we don't need to get into what the proof is now I just hope moving forward that that would be um carefully I I suppose screened in the process of however way that's going to happen if it's through human resources or some other manner appreciate the feedback um through the chair the next two items

146go together that's 1410 and 3410 and they're around um they're around Advanced degree supplements and there was language and statute that prior to 2011 a degree supplement had to be a supplement not part of the base and they struck that and it can be part of the base salary it's simply saying for administrators and for um instructional staff a supplement can be included in the salary schedule as part of the base salary and not a supplement uh supplemental pay I I have a question about that cuz that I got my Master's Degree I think it was in the summer and I didn't get paid for my Master's even though I submitted everything on time and everything for like three months later so what is it now and when an employee gets a an advanced degree

147um it still does take about 60 I mean it depends on the processing but it still does take a little bit before that kicks in okay I just want to make sure that that's that people understand that because that was not made oh someone just went through that and said it's back to the day you submitted your transcript it should be it's what so it should be okay thank you um through the chair the next item actually is in the 5000s which is student as we just discussed earlier but um it's bullying harassment and all it does is says remember those three we just did around employees when you're reading the student section if you come across employee bullying or harass it adds a reference say go see these three St uh board policies if

148it's an employ employee issue so it's a cross reference added to that policy to the three we just discussed 6210 fiscal planning that basically just says that uh summary of your tenative budget and proposed millages are now required to be posted on the district website you're already in compliance with that we post it on our website we post it on our agenda we post it in the newspaper um moving forward there's some options that we can U maybe not put that in the paper and only put it online but we still put it in in the paper to meet all of the space and size um requirements that are required for that I have a comment on that I specifically asked that question when I went to Tampa and I was told you don't have

149to worry about the fact that somebody's receiving it on a different device so I would check on that because I think we're spending money that we don't need to spend um because they pass the law for that reason that we have to do what the law says not what the receiver is looking on okay okay because a lot of districts are are not advertising in the papers anymore they're doing on the websites um the next item 6322 construction Contracting and bidding so Senate Bill 70002 amended Forida statute 101345 basically and increase the day labor amount of a contract or a contract using day labor from 280,000 to 600,000 so it's just following that statutory change 6330 is your um acquisition of professional and Technical Services House Bill 149 increased the not to exceed from 4

150million to 7.5 million or some number based on the Bureau of Labor Statistics of the United States website as it changes from the June to June CPI for all Urban consumers um we've uh we've already discussed that and the board implemented that change already and this is codifying that anyone we good okay 7100 facilities planning so the board can adopt no earlier than 5:00 p.m. through a resolution to modify some facilities to to be hurricane shelters as we had a discussion earlier and modify some of the building requirements if necessary they've taken all that detail language out and said you have the flexibility of a charter school so when making those modifications you follow the charter school statute where they are some exceptions to srf the school facilities um codification so it simplifies the language

151that says you have the flexibility of a charter school when doing those design criterias as long as you meet local emergency management criteria the next one is 8330 student records and again there's a lot of um formatting in this one but really two substantive changes one is around um threat doc doents or documentations of threat or harm and it just redefines that instead of a long list of stuff it redefines that under the um Florida harm prevention and threat management instrument and that safety team must keep those documents as long as they are deemed relevant and under the transfer of Records there was a long list of details about um how to transfer those records and now it references Florida administrative code code 6A and says because those change frequently and that way we're just

152following the Florida Administrative Code instead of constantly updating the policy to try to keep up with all of those minor changes me me ask a question about that as a principal getting a student in from a different um State you know it would take forever to get records and sometimes you know my kids would come and go so by the time they got into our school and we got the record they were already gone and when we had have a feeling like something's wrong there something's going on with that family um we had no ability to kind of follow through with it quickly because they're already gone to another state if you know what I mean um those are the kids that are being lost in the cracks is there any sort of Interstate student

153record thing going on now that we can improve that not that I'm aware of gosh you know when you're talking about child trafficking and I'm going to be real honest I I there were a couple times that I suspected that's what was going on and you can't follow through with it by the time the record comes they're already gone they know what you're doing they're gone and it's really really sad if we're going to address child trafficking somebody maybe a legislator needs to start looking at what can we do across state lines to get these records faster just saying my two cents good point um through the chair the next item 9200 is volunteers and it simply States states that volunteers are State mandated reporters every citizen in Florida is a mandatory reporter for child

154abuse but um I think it's just saying for those people in care of students volunteers when you're coming on so that you see that and you understand that and it's made clear to you that you're a mandatory reporter for um sexual abuse in the State of Florida the next item 9211 booster clubs and actually 9700 do11 the next two have a similar change and it's changes in the red book and that's our um Financial book and it basically says we've discussed this and it's already in the red book that um schools cannot conduct games of chance or gambling or raffling on a school campus and the only people who can conduct something like that would be a charitable or nonprofit who has a tax exempt status who is not on campus and does not allow

155minor children to particip ipate so those basically just add the language around not allowing minors to participate in gambling and Raffles I know I brought it up to you but I'm going to bring it up on camera um booster clubs doing 50/50 Raffles they can't do those on school property correct correct they can they can do it maybe in a golf tournament um that's a fundraiser but they have to have that status correct yes okay tax exemp y all right just making sure that they they know that we have made that very clear correct yes okay oh yeah absolutely and we we do training on our red book frequently U Madam chair those are all the items out of financial absance services it was this last one is that yours the um advertising commercial activities

156um yeah and that's a staff edit basically it added that same raffle language to it okay I think it was um SAA was next Mr Seymour uh through the chair as I stated I did not uh brief on these but I do have my team here Mrs Holden and Mr tesy however there are policies that are very um similar and uh just a few changes and this is in reference to Athletics and I'll go ahead and cover those first uh policy 3120.4 [Music] 41203 and 41 20.08 uh one of the similarities here is that all of these individuals uh must be certified in CPR first aid and the use of AD AED train individuals in order to be a part of the um athletic programs in addition to that based on the Florida High School

157sports athletic association all sanctioned events must have coaches that are certified in those areas so each of these coaches any coach that coaches our students must be trained and certified and that's a course that's online okay the difference is for two of these um and that would be 31208 and 41208 is that these individuals primarily are paid through the school budget however uh there is an option for coaches now outside of the school budget which is normally I think 5123 to be paid from the school district so the school pays them supplements but the school district has the option to hire them for those positions that's it for me so I okay you got a mic all right anybody question on that hold on one second oh okay anybody have a question about that we're

158good okay okay next we'll start with uh Miss Holden she'll start at 2260 so 2260 is a non-discrimination and access to equal education opportunity that cross out right there is due to the repeal of Florida statute 102. 311 so there are still some exemptions for human reproduction lessons um contact sports that sort of thing but that cross out is strictly in um compliance with that Florida State Statute repeal and then the only other one is the addition of um breaking down exactly which title in our district is in charge of adult Title 9 versus student Title 9 versus ese Title 9 that's all that's to that so questions anybody yeah I do have one um the way it's written it says that the cross out in accordance with Florida statute the board May establish and

159maintain a single gender non-vocational class extracurricular activity or school for elementary middle school or high school would an extracurricular activity be um considered the sports or is that so there are exceptions um per Neola or Sports depending on whether like the how much contact is involved in the sport okay because we do have some mixed um gender Sports yes you're allowed to yeah okay the next one anybody else is Hope Scholarship and again these are also just based on um the Florida state statute change um it looks like they're Crossing out a couple of different things but they're just simplifying the notification process um in here so that way as the state changes rules and procedures the policy can stay in compliance people are still eligible for Hope scholarships for any substantiated or unsubstantiated bullying

160harassment or sexual harassment so this is just saying go see the rule so that every time the rule changes we don't have to get a new policy questions about that okay all right then 2455 is Dropout prevention and again all pretty much all of mine are based on changes in State Statute so um the two that are next this one and the withdrawal are all about adding in that programming for the new gate programming that Miss Bieber is working on in cni for us to be able to implement so it's mainly vocabulary leading to us being able to implement that new process both in the 2455 Dropout and the withdrawal from school in 5130 we good okay okay and then my next one is I think might have already been said the 5330 where they're

161changing it to the short acting um Bronco dilators um in one in 53 30.01 they're changing the title from meter dose inhaler and short acting Bronco dilators if you have any questions you're going to ask him of Dr PCA because he'll know that better than me and then the other right just to say it is I deserve credit and then the next one is just adding a policy whereby if we choose if a principal were to request to be able to hold short acting Bronco dilators um on campus for students in emergencies so that would create that possibility that we currently do not have questions questions for Dr PCA anybody what is the difference AED I know a basically the meter dose inhaler is a type of administrative method so you put different drugs in

162it there they're all going to be inhaled drugs but um Savas or short acting Bronco dilators is a very specific one that would be used in an emergency um so this is actually narrowing and restricting it to you should really you should have this it's more specified language rather than MDI mados inhaler could be any number of chronic maintenance drugs for COPD emphysema chronic bronchitis Etc so just for emergencies really it's really just making it more specific right yeah would asthma be a part of that too yeah and of course our schools are already trained the first thing you do if somebody's having trouble breathing is you call 911 and then you call the parent tell them you've called 911 because we want our children breathing um academic honesty 5505 is our next one and

163it does have the reference to the artificial intelligence that covers both adult and children and any kind of use the district might have um we also do have an artificial intelligence page in our um code of student conduct that you all voted on last spring and we'll be voting on again again this spring um but these are all just us picking um updated options based on changes in uh the adding in the wording to include the artificial intelligence yes go ahead which it didn't include that last year uh Dr Mo Miss Holden um what's the situation at our schools with AI are we having a lot of issues with any kind of plagiarism all that information the kids can now get through the chair and and Kelly can respond as well or anybody else um

164I I think it's it's emerging right now not a major concern but we we have done a lot of training make sure our our teachers are up in front we do a lot of work in the classroom so it's not necessarily something that you can just plug in a lot of the devices uh when appropriate are our block so you can have access to them so I I think in the upper grades is more of an issue when you do your essay or your homework and you bring it back in um then we have to verify and make make sure it's it's not plagiar not not even plagiarized anymore uh that someone else didn't write it we do not have a significant number of referrals from that so far this school year good thank you

165so one thing I was going to bring up because this this um policy was brought up earlier with the AI policy and and you know Neola just focuses on one Topic at a time so I understand why these are two separate and a lot of times Neer refers to one that's um related like it does here with the artificial intelligence it says C policy and that's why they do that but the other thing they do is at the end of the policies they reference the statute but that one doesn't have a statute referenced you notice in the next one there are several statutes referenced I'm just curious why that one didn't have one it did not give me a reason for why there's not a state statute I think that's because Neola sometimes um creates

166policy based on feedback that they receive from the community so Community can email and say you know XYZ District doesn't have a policy in academic um honesty and if they get enough feedback on that they might create one that has nothing to do with statute those are the ones that I worry about uh with regard to um the recommendations from Neola uh few times they have recommended policies that this board outright uh rejected and and rightfully so not this board the previous board um because they were just crazy but um and they didn't have anything to do with statute but that's one of those and this one here in the beginning chart you know at the at on the let me pull it up so I know it says the two policies are new policies

167offered based on the continued growth in the use of artificial intelligence and natural language processing yeah it says new but when you look at the actual policy itself it's not new says revised at the top so I agree because if it was new it would all be in green so it kind of threw me off even when I'm looking at both of them trying to figure out what that's why before when I said one was new and one wasn't it's a little cooky there um but yeah I I mean but everything in this policy is pretty much what's in our code of student conduct about student behavior in terms of academic honesty and artificial intelligence there's nothing egregious at all no I there's nothing egregious I agree with you um I just think that I

168just wish we would have less policies to pull from because then you know you go to edit one or revise one you know you have to make sure that you're looking for all the other policies by keywords you know if you can't remember where they are you're in trouble right any other questions on that one and my last one is about removal out of school suspension if you look on the second page they literally are just giving us this opportunity when um we suspend a student we must formally tell the parent that we have done so which is a good thing um but it's just giving us a or other method agreed upon by the parent if you have a parent who can't like US mail is going to take too long or maybe they're

169in the homeless camp or they don't have a focus account because they don't have access to Internet so this is giving us a we can agree upon by the parent and of course the schools would be trained to document that and focus of what was the agreement so that we are all aware I have a question about the expulsion team um how many people sit on that team M Christof fer so um we have Miss Holden myself Jess kohas from ese um Dr Hardy and then depending on the case there maybe other people brought in depending what the topic of the suspension was okay um because I know and yes and the principals from the two schools so I know that in some some districts believe it or not I heard this when I was

170over in Tampa that some board members sit on it and I thought wow I'm glad we don't because we're the ones that have the final vote so we shouldn't sit on it right but I I was shocked to see that happen bar they're just the appeal as well they're not the initial yeah and it's you know you said expulsion but it's suspension expulsion so it's you know we're we're looking at each case separately to see whether it's just a alternative placement at IR prep or if it's a recommendation to the superintendent for yeah because as a principal I used to have to go to those once in a while thank goodness not too many um but yeah it's intimidating for the principal even to go in to sit in on that so um the parent

171is invited to that one okay the parents are invited it's actually on the letter that they receive that they can forward or bring any uh documents or concerns letter through uh an email that's given to them from the school if they would like to State their case or provide anything thing and it doesn't happen a lot but when that does happen we do communicate with them ahead of the CT so when is the parent allowed to make any comment about their child and what happened only when it comes to us two different things one if it's an expulsion hearing they are sitting in an expulsion hearing that's what I wanted to know yes okay if it's just sir they are not so if it gets recommended and approved by the super intend to go to

172expulsion yes and the student we recommend highly the student is present as well yes and during the time of the initial infraction at the school level before it even gets to CT okay I want to make sure parents have a say before it comes all the way here absolutely okay thank you oh sorry Mr Zario um 2260 can we go back to that one is that under you okay so this is the one that the strikeout was based on a a repeal of Florida State Statute and then just the addition of the student Title Nine okay I'm sorry that's not it it's 2271 that's 371 2271 I don't think that's you that's curriculum and instruction we haven't gotten there yet okay thank you John good afternoon uh board so we have some uh Safety and

173Security updates here we'll be uh starting with 7440 revisions to uh the operations of drones on campuses um luckily we've had a good policy in place we followed FHSAA guidelines for years but now the Neola policy sa has caught up with that uh just giving some language uh allowing law enforcement access to drones um you've probably seen and heard fpnl will come out and assess the power lines on campuses but um we've really firmed this up where we now work with a facility use agreement with risk management to ensure there's a checklist permissions and we're checking licenses for the Drone operators that are approved and allowed to be on campus um that also would include our athletic events any yeah I did see a drone at one of the I think it was football game

174who approves those so that small one we see buzzing around is under investigation at this time because we had our video uh classrooms we had our uh programs the students were doing it for years and we told them they weren't permitted to do that so we've been working to try and find that small one that's been buzzing around over the games this past season so we're we're working on that but that would be either the athletic director and the principal coming to myself or risk management to ensure that the facility use agreement and the checklist is is completed and filled out and we can verify the licenses on it so that one we don't know who is flying around it pops in and out throughout the game as as we are watching it so in

175that case you do know there's a device that can bring the those down a lot of them yeah we don't have one though but okay but does our Sheriff's Department have it I'm sure they do I'm sure they do so if we know that this keeps coming to our games we can maybe ask them to bring it we could okay because I've seen it and it's annoying y but they don't have permission to film everybody and I don't know what they're doing with that film they do not that's correct I don't know what we're doing with that film either we don't know if it's a student or a staff or a f prute the individual so we we we'll jump right on that okay can yes ma'am can you um just explain a little bit

176I know you went over the um the policy but the law regarding unmanned drones Federal Aviation requirements uh license for a temporary pilot or a pilot would be the licensed person who would be allowed it would dictate the height the weight the classification of the Drone so FAA requirements is what we would be looking at and the rules on school property would be there would be exceptions made in this policy to allow law enforcement to use it a vendor we had one uh this past summer assessing the rooftops at Sebastian River High School for the roof damage or the roof improvements contractors um the Drone programs at Sebastian River High School were inside so they met the requirement for their drone programs because they weren't outside so that would be part of the uh application

177policy whether it's a vendor or a club or a person that wants to use the Drone the permission would start with the principal and then work its way to myself or risk management for that so I'm just wondering what what the process would be um because I don't I don't think they're just going to I don't I don't know if the sheriff's department is just going to go in and just start shooting down these drones um I don't know I'm not disagreeing that it would be needed I'm just I mean necessary I'm just saying I don't know if they could just kind of willy-nilly do that um I don't know if there needs to be cause for concern do they have to investigate first like what that process is do we have to make it

178clear what our policy is um when it comes to um School sponsored events and drone activity I mean I'm not sure what that is is um is it media maybe media is taking pictures um obviously we don't know but if that's the case would that be um would we be chilling the First Amendment would that be considered first amendment in terms of you know a media saying well I'm just trying to access to take pictures um I I'm not sure so the Florida statute covers Government properties and state facilities which is not allowed so whether we're a school or not it wouldn't be allowed of the sheriff's department or any government type of building so uh the sheriff's department we would work in cooperation with them if it was a school uh before we took

179action against that drone it would have to be their equipment we would have to have some type of agreement that uh does it land safely you have to have clear line of sight you have to understand the wind direction are there kids at PE in recess so there would be a lot of factors in place before we wouldn't just let them come in and zap it and it would fall there would be a process to it uh that we would we would follow which are in the FAA guidelines under but in this particular case if we don't know who it is or where it's coming from it poses a safety concern so correct during a football game we would be we wouldn't be doing that during the game we would have to hopefully find them

180before or after as they land follow it just to ensure safety would happen well I mean but what if it's too late I'm I'm going to play devil's advocate here and I and I don't want to but what if it's a serious you know what if it's a there's I don't want to say the the b word um but what if that's what it is and it it's too late for us to wait you know damage will already be done if we're just going to wait for it to land and then follow it wherever it lands yes ma'am I understand your concern too um we deal with this in the military all the time so you have to assess the Drone if it's equipped with any type of weapon system so that dictates how you

181respond to it um there's protocol you follow to ensure the safety of the people beneath it and below it so this is a new era it's a new way of fighting it's a new tactic that we're all learning this policy is trying to keep up with uh what fhsa has known for a while just for student safety but now I see your point we we're dealing with civilian safety and uh this under the FAA guidelines it does cover a portion of this under like a terrorist attack so the language is written in there for us to review with law enforcement it's there I reviewed it before we came up here I didn't want to go through you know I'm sure that's a different Workshop Topic at a different time but got it thank you appreciate

182it go ahead um I think this is a good discussion um and it's it's probably a discussion that needs to be happening all over the country there's a lot of um concern that due to the prolific success of drones overseas what whether it be Ukraine or the Middle East and how cheap easy they are to operate um there is a certain expectation that we will start seeing drone attacks in the United States um that's just a realistic expectation um and given the evolving nature of the threat um clearly we have to evolve our protocols to deal with it this is mostly a sheriff's office issue and Police Issue um clearly you know drones could either have a bomb you you know the other issue is you can have large drones that um can deploy fentanyl

183over a stadium um and you know so there's a lot of different ways the Drone can be used it could be used to surveil so they know which way to come in you know there could be no weapon on it but they're using it as um surveillance to know which way they should come in or what building they should get on Etc to gain access um so I think that um in general we should probably hey do what we're doing now have this conversation but continue discussions and evolving this policy and how we would deal with um these drone threats with our sheriff's department and um and that includes having the um materials that we would need or assets on site I think during certain types of events especially if we know that we've had

184drones come um so I I would hope that we start having something to deal with a drone um at any event whether it's a large Gathering um I think that would be appropriate risk management um and you know as things continue to develop we continue to develop how we would deal with it I don't know what resources the sheriff's department have um obviously we wouldn't discuss what what they specifically have here um but in general there's area denial through jamming you can just Jam the general vicinity and that's going to affect every everyone um you there's targeted jamming with basically a rifle like object where you can Target the Drone um and then there's mechanical things you can do to the Drone whether it be Nets uh devices or bullets or of varying types um

185including even long range uh basically computer Optics on a long range scope um with a rifle to shoot a drone from 800 yards away with one bullet um so there's different systems in place depending on you know what you would need to deal with um but clearly this is something we need to evaluate behind closed doors with the sheriff's department yes sir I'm I'm meeting with the school resource leadership tomorrow so I will put this on our topic of discussion I am proud to say that our district has had a EMP EAP in place for 15 years in Fallen aircraft has been one of the scenarios although this is an maned aircraft we have protocol already in place that we've trained upon we we all saw the news of the glider that went down here

186over the weekend this is a real realistic uh threat to us being so close to the airport so we're we're in good shape with having a policy that we annually update and we will modify this summer for drone uh response with that so um couple things on that my son's a drone pilot and I know he had to go through FAA tests pass all those tests and and it's it's tough to get your commercial drone license um and that looked like a commercial drone that I was looking at that was flying over the stadium um small drones you know anybody can buy one of those and and fly that and but they have to they don't go as far um but to catch something like that you know that person when they take all those

187tests and do all that they know what the law is they have to get permission of the owner for where they're flying over before they can do it so they know so we can we can take it down without you know anybody going oh that I didn't know no they know so um I think this is a subject to bring up in a next safety meeting sure yes um Mr tesky when I see drones at graduation are they ours because you'll see them at graduation Dr Jones I'm I'm not sure who they belong to um I don't know if they're sponsored by the high school or if it's a club but we'll have to look into that okay now the football season's done we can start leaning forward to graduations and seeing who they belong

188to now that this policy is in place and we have a procedure in place I'm just thinking because both of our schools have the CCTV and sebastia has the Drone um program which is pretty cool but I uh at graduation which is a large large crowd obviously probably for pictures but I don't know we will find out and could the board be notified when we're at something like that that that drone is legal and and can do what it's doing because that does make me nervous when I see those flying around for for me and saw I work with the uh the teachers for the science camps and the course recovery at Sebastian High School like I work with them for their drone program so from a structured standpoint those are the only people I've

189been working with for approval so for the athletic events we'll continue to investigate and for the graduations we'll have have an update for everyone before May with that if not sooner okay didn't think that policy was going to have that long it's it's ever evolving and growing it's going to continue to grow uh 8405 Safety and Security this basically is stating that um December of 23 moving into January of 24 we ended the SE stag model for threat assessments we have moved into the Florida model uh this policy revision has changed some language um removing labels and titles of students and and address the uh threat levels um it's also assigned specific timelines to students this is a good good revision it's it was needed it was unfortunate it just came Midway through the year

190so a little confusing for schools uh which leads to uh when I brief the board quarterly on safety uh infractions or deficiencies I I had briefed you all a month or two back uh that the this this was a cause of some of the minor deficiencies it's paperwork it's labeling and it's uh using the proper forms to accommodate this new language and uh the addition of timelines and and just verbage with with that policy 8406 is uh what we've all known for many years or fortifyfl it is a tool used for the community in the public so we can speak openly about it here fortifyfl is the uh suspicious Anonymous report reporting tool uh you'll see posters and visuals everywhere um the new office of safe schools mandate under the house bill dictated that we

191do student instruction the first five days of school which we successfully did at every public and private school every school had to teach a lesson whether it was a guest speaker over the PA system a PowerPoint of the proper use of fortifyfl and the consequences leading to it uh for a student who uh used it inappropriately by November 18th an amendment to rule 68 came out which we have completed I'm happy to say we did another great job we had to provide instruction to parents so you may have heard the school messenger call that went out uh we posted it on the school district website um the Pio Department did an excellent job working with Mr Heiser to complete the video and the training so we are compliant with that we are we've documented and

192we're ready for the inspectors to come in and ask us if we've done that so that is complete 84 407 safe schools officers um the new requirements there are really leaning uh forward on um charter schools around the state to ensure that their safe schools officers their law enforcement officers are present physically present for the drills they're physically there completing the after action review reports uh we we we know this that some districts Pro use Guardians some use hired law enforcement and some used details so this is just uh strengthening the policies that the districts understand the reporting and all the requirements that are needed if you have a safe schools officer uh physically present on your campus signing in attendance reporting misconduct drills after Action reviews everything uh continuing to work with districts who

193cannot afford Law Enforcement Officers but do have to use Guardians so we are compliant in every aspect of 8407 8415 is new emergency and crisis management we have talked about this twice already about using our schools and our facilities um I did send uh certain cabinet members as I was in the back the interlocal shelter agreement that we have had in place since I was in my position since 2017 um I did send that to Mr Green so it does state that uh we are in partnership with the county uh for them to be able to utilize our facilities and times of need for reunification uh crisis not just storms but but any type of event event that they would need to be able to use that um so we we do have a great

194partnership with with the county uh I hope to continue with that I do Echo with what Dr Moore said larger districts have more facilities that are Cod and compliant um Miss Barbor just to your point certain parts of the IG could be used but high pitch roofs gymnasiums are not compliant so yes certain parts of the IG could be used but um that is why they really lean on the school District because of our codes and and our building codes for that as well as the Staffing and the transportation so I don't feel the uh the county will be coming at us saying that we're not compliant with that policy because we do have a anou in place with them to cover the emergency and crisis management requirements in the plan that's in place 84

195you off a second yes ma'am sorry a question have we I mean we we talk a lot about partnership with the county I don't I think we've ever talked about um partnering with uh Indian River State College their facilities they have you know obviously they have multiple buildings there here at the Mueller campus um just wondering has that ever come up um if so what's what is that like um through the chair Mr RAR the only agreement I do think they do have they do have it with Indian River Charter High School they are their one of their reunification locations so they have a uh whether it's an agreement or anou with the high school there to be able to respond for that I I I did learn that working with them but um it's

196something to think about but we don't have anything in place uh academically of course we do but from a a safety standpoint I think they have a very large Auditorium there yeah that's right we did um and so I think they they also might have I'm just throwing it out there not saying that we should go ahead and change our whole plan but maybe as a plan C or D or X you know that let's just remember they are still there in case there's a need I would just um remind the board to your point Mr sario we have a great relationship with GAC V Beach Museum of Art um the IG certain churches in the community uh that service our schools for times of need for reunification or uh Evac uation so um I'm

197always open to finding new places that would also help I have no problem stopping by there even if it's busting students it doesn't have to just be a hurricane to assist us but um we have six um reunification locations that are in place uh that we um would utilize with the sheriff's department if the time came so thank you I have that in my notes but thank you which one is which number was I on emergency 8475 yes yes Jessica Lunsford that's what that is that's absolutely been in place uh criminal background screening contractor access Mr Green Mr Michael Mr westenberger we all work daily on uh Raptor screening Jessica Lunsford and uh risk management so um adding language to that to keep people safe is what that is more requirements anybody on that um

198I have have one comment um you know when we go over to the fsba conference different people use CICS you know those the cards that they the teachers have in front of them I've always asked them you know do are you happy with it you know do you think it's worth it and I've had this time I had a lot of board members say no we're going to FL fortify Florida it's expensive um there are a lot of false things that come up because of it and um they had some problems with some of them working but um they said fortify Florida is available on any device you know you you can put it on anybody's phone and it's a lot more um easily accessed so I found that interesting yes ma'am and fortify once

199again is open to the public but um anyone can access and use it at any time and once again uh we always go back to cell phone service and cell phone uh being able to send and receive if you're using your phone if we're all sitting in front of a computer is not a problem but that's really not realistic so I I understand can always call 911 too that is correct Mr tusky I'm sorry yes ma'am uh with fortify how many of our how many are false information how many are just not what they said they are so I'll have an exact number for you in January when when we have our close session and I think we were at 438 total tips since its Inception since 2019 I I'll give you the exact number

200probably closer to 500 now um out of those I can actually count through them and tell you we get them weekly that uh maybe somebody was testing it and it's blank or it's Anonymous so once again that the new law states if it's a a premeditated misuse you were trying to cause a campus disruption it's an arrestable offense are we going to have students and people play with it get nervous and it goes off yes and that's what happens so um but I can give you an exact number in January okay of which ones didn't need a response to because they would be false thank you yes ma'am m m okay through the chair my turn yay appreciate your patience today my first policy that I'll be bringing is policy 2210 and it is some

201revised language around the comprehensive evidence-based reading plan otherwise known as the Ser uh the language in here really includes it it is to include all district schools and some changed language around the updated approval and submission requirements um that's it for that one the next one is policy 2271 uh this is around the articulation and access to the Florida college system institutions so it's essentially our dual enrollment agreements the only part of this that is really the biggest part of this I should say is around our requirements now that if we have a student who is in enrolled in a dual enrollment program and that student has been arrested we have one day to let the dual enrollment Institute know of that arrest okay I this was the one that I had a question yes

202ma'am yeah go ahead um so this is the one that I had a question on before um one of the what is highlighted here it says for students who are dual enrolled in a postsecondary institution the superintendent shall notify the inst no not that one sorry oh maybe it's not this one there was one with had something to do with parental consent is that the one I don't think it's in this one oh goodness there was one where it said um students oh here yes that's right underneath what is highlighted I was right underneath what's highlighted in that same uh policy it says no minor student May participate without the written consent of their parent and or legal guardian so the parent or the legal guardian has to sign to give permission for that student

203to be dual enrolled correct correct okay just want to make sure that that wasn't correct okay perfect thank you know one thing about that policy change with the statute is I find it interesting that the superintendent is the one that has to do that and not the parent if we're putting parents in charge of their kids and their child has been arrested why isn't the parent then following through and doing this just a comment I know you don't have the answer Mr be sir um we notify within one business day of receiving the notification so if we don't see it correct in four days then we have one day to get it over there I mean so we've already created a procedure for this process um anytime one of our students is arrested Mr tesy

204alect alerts Miss Bieber who is AR liaison and she quickly looks to see if they are dual enrolled or not so we get arrest the day of I I don't want to speak for Mr tusky on that but that's our process for following this thank you yes I also just wanted to reiterate um for for the public who's listening um dual enrollment is not just for the 11th grader or the 12th grader um dual enrollment is for any student who is in from sixth grade to 12th grade who is capable of sitting for college level courses um and they they are more than welcome to take uh dual enrollment classes uh some classes are offered and I'm looking at you because I if I say something out of place I I I want you to

205obviously interrupt me some of those courses are offered at our high school campuses um not too many but I think a few are um but otherwise if there is anyone who is interested in dual enrollment it doesn't necessarily have to be a face-to-face class that the student would need to take um either they could take it virtually so there are a lot of opportunities for students who want to get ahead of the game still get high school credit and college credit at the same time this to me is a no-brainer I don't know why everybody's just not doing this it it's just it just it blows my mind at the opportunity for students to gain the experience of taking the same world history class in high school that you can take in college and get

206both college and high school credit right or you know geometry or algebra whatever it is not algebra because they have to take algebra before getting in but some of these opportunities are just right at the fingertips so you know know how I feel about offering these and having the opportunities for parents to know this I cannot tell you how many students I have talked to this year I've talked to you about it who have said that they want to take uh dual enrollment classes and they're told no or they're not given the opportunity there they they're they're told they they don't qualify or you know they're not of the grade level or and the parents I asked the parent did you know no I had no idea and I think we are truly doing a

207disservice to those students we have a lot of students who are gifted students who feel that they're not being challenged enough in high school I mean that's just the bottom line and so this is a great opportunity to get our gifted children into a college you know program or into at least one or two classes like why not it benefits them so you'll be happy to know thankfully outside of this policy that is a lot of the very strategic work that's occurring with our counselors and um Miss Bieber around the dual enrollment so more to come on that good so I'm gonna use this moment to just kind of throw something else in there I'm glad to hear that because I've been talking about this for years um one of the challenges that I do

208know is going to come up and I think it's important for I'm sure you'll you'll hear it um as you begin this work as you continue this work is the fact that if a student is in high school they're taking one or two classes at the high school and they want to do dual enrollment face Toof face dual enrollment their challenge is getting to the college and taking you know getting having the transportation so either they get on a public on the bus you know and they take they leave school get on the bus public bus and then they find their way there or they're driving themselves let's look at the general student the typical student whose parent Works 9 to5 parent can't come pick them up and take them to college so there you

209have a student who's stuck who feels that I really want to do this but I can't face to face not virtual I've had this conversation with Dr Moore I'm like this is a great opportunity for us to partner with local churches right organizations that have little minivans and at our two colleges at our two high schools said up like some kind of volunteer van system that can pick up the students at 11 o'clock in the morning and take some students to the college and of course getting home is up to them in the parent whatever that partnership would look like I think that would be a great opportunity the other thing um that we could look into which we haven't when we're talking about buying buses Dr Moore why not look into uh Vans at

210least one or two vans that could be used for this kind of transportation to help students I mean I I'm not suggesting that we would have 50 kids but you know a van a nice size van and that same van could be used to transport maybe a small bowling team to their to their practices or their games or those smaller athletic teams that we were talking about just before that didn't have the opportunity to do that because of funding I I that might be something else for you to kind of think about any ideas any thoughts just throwing it out there I'm hoping someone will grab hold of it no through the chair I think as we I think Miss Biser and her team is doing a significant amount of work around dual enrollment this

211year and increasing access and opportunities to take whether it's on our campus or at the actual site itself so as we identify those concerns we should be able to problem solve to provide the opportunity for students to get there how that would be we'd have the problem solved thank you okay I have a comment about that yes because when I was a coach I was a coach of a small team and I was told to take the short bus you know remember those the short buses and so I drove the short bus for a while and then they uh stay Florida said we're not allowed to use the short buses anymore because our insurance didn't cover it so and then I was told we couldn't rent a van and bring the kids because our insurance

212wouldn't cover it so yeah I'm sorry 15 passenger oh yes my husband was that was his company where we had the big 15 passenger van accident it was terrible so um that's that's one thing I think we need to look into is yes I agree you know we don't need these big yellow buses going around with six golfers in it but um we also need to make sure kidss are safe and we're following uh what our insurance is allowing us to do so I would look into that too M Bor yes um years ago sebest for high school had two Vans specifically for athletics um for our small team so again I know we have to look at the liability issue but we were covered at that time so it might be something we could

213look at so parents don't have to drive I know the 15 passenger vans are out can't use those not these are my next two policies go together 2370 and 23 7.01 these are uh revisions to align to State the language and state statute around virtual instruction um and then the second part of that is essentially saying that if you are a student who is taking virtual instruction through a different provider that you will test at your your home school unless other agreements have been mutually agreed upon okay my next one is 2423 this is merely a technical correction and it's citing uh the correct the additional Florida administrative codes in the back my next policy is policy 2432 um this is a revision to this policy and what it really does is gives this board

214flexibility to work with the County Tax Collector to administer road tests in the event that they should ever want to do that um we currently do not use this would not use this option we currently receive the Dory slosberg Grant and we we pay uh Treasure Coast driving school for that using that Grant from the Indian River um County Commissioners okay so I have a comment about that because my kids took driver's head from Greg arons yes Greg arons is a legend around driver's head and Coach will okay we'll say that anyway um it was around the back of they ran around the back of the school and every once in a while they talked them into going to McDonald's okay so um have we talked to Carol Jean Jordan though about having the tax

215collector's office do this because I I do know that when they do it over there they schedule it and I've heard from parents that it's not convenient for them and it's not fast enough we don't currently engage in this this is merely to give us the the flexibility should we deci should the board decide if the grant funding dries up that that this is an additional option and so it's just giving flexibility exactly okay okay trying to be fiscally provent uh my next policy is 2520 uh this policy includes revisions to the reporting timeline and clerical revisions around the adoption of instructional materials and it also includes the statutory amendments uh associated with House Bill 1285 1361 and Senate Bill 7004 any questions uh policy 2540 is rescinded this is duplicated in other policies this

216is regarding audiovisual AIDS or the use of audiovisual this in its entirety is Rec sended policies 5410 and 54101 go together um it is correcting some typos in the policy it is also requiring the school district to provide additional support for VPK students who show deficiencies um it also adds some retention language and the this is something that we've already started started to include the um plan must include the reason for retention and communication with the parents for input regarding that retention kindergarten through second grade um I have a question yes on um section e of that policy it says the course must be internet based why is that section e of that policy on that policy at the towards the back uh Middle School school grades promotion page five of seven there we go

217well the only correction is it the course it's correcting a typo it did say much yeah but I know but why is it why is it inter internet based it can't be a live training here it has to be something that we purchase I think I believe this I I don't know the answer to that question I will look it up to make sure but uh it is aligned to Florida statute um I find that interesting yes okay okay policy 5420 is also a technical correction and it's changing the word of to after policies 5460 and 5465 are related and this is essentially changing the language around from the for a student who is opting to leave school enrollment and take their GED uh this changes the language from underage waiver to a formal declaration

218um both of those are updated around that language okay policy 6661 this requires us to prioritize remedial instruction resources for VPK through third grade for students who show uh who exhibit a substantial deficiency in reading and it also adds math to this uh this is something we we already started to enact the wording of this at the beginning of the school year actually last year this was coming out so okay and my last policy for review is policy 9800 um this is a pretty lengthy revision it's a 24-page policy but essentially the recommendations are to revise this policy based on the frequency of those revisions um the lack of flexibility for school boards to adopt policies related to Charters and that most of of these areas and items are addressed either in statute state board

219rules or Charter agreements so the revisions that are made are essentially those that aim to identify the roles and responsibilities of our school school board rather than a regurgitation of the state statute so it condenses it and it aligns to the responsibilities of us anyone on that one so those are the policies they'll be sent to public hearing tonight with board approval um and now I turn it back to you madam chair for the items that are question off for discussion okay our first discussion item is a for a review of board protocols Dr Jones floor is yours thank you very much board members uh I did put on your um table a hard copy of our protocols M Rosario Miss bar Borg and I were on the um board when we developed these and

220also did our Master board training so obviously you have taken a look at these and um I would like to bring up some of the uh protocols and then I think if we need to make changes we need to do that for a separate time where we have a little bit more time but um one of the things that I think um uh that's very very important that I think we can improve on is making sure and and myself included that we get our information to Dr Moore 8 days ahead of time so the the public can have 7 days ahead of time you know when we add an action on at the end that could be controversial I don't think it's fair to our public that they don't know what's coming and I think

221that's very important for us to be transparent um Robert's Rules obviously uh the parliamentarian is our attorney uh Miss barenborg runs the chair and uh one thing and I'll take fault for this when I was a chair especially in workshops because it's seems a little bit more informal everything should go through the chair not the back and forth conversation again those are in Robert's Rules and I have them marked off for a certain um what page it is if anybody needs to look at that um one thing also make sure that before a meeting uh the chair and the superintendent uh knows if you're adding the action item or making an amendment I just think it's important so nobody is surprised um I think it's very very important that we do that so again people

222in the audience know what we're doing and it's not any kind of here you go I got you we're going to do this um I think the most important thing um and this has come up a little bit is to make sure that we always talk about the content not the person um not attacking a member's motives or anything like that when anybody brings up a discussion anybody brings up an amendment as a board we should all listen to that and then of course make our decision if there is a vote um one other thing I said this is in chapter 43 uh verse 23 if you will in Robert's Rules is making sure when we're on the day this is a professional uh group that we not use first names in fact Roberts rules

223even says try to avoid names so I think that's something we can all improve upon again the workshop is a little bit more informal sometimes and we want to go back and forth but everything should go through the chair um I think that again I'm just going to talk about the attorney general Sunshine State manual it's it's 03- 53 not bringing up items that could be controversial at the very end so our public doesn't even know what's coming down the pike now if it's an emergency I completely understand but um that would probably also go through the superintendent but it's just something as far as respect making sure people know what's happening because some when a board member pulls something or does something I'm going to listen to what he or she says what is

224it that's concerning you what is it that you know you think you can add a little bit to and I just want to make sure with this new board that we have that respect as we move forward um again Dr PCA and Mr Dyer were not members then so if you did take a look at these and have any questions you know you could certainly let us know or maybe we need a whole other I hate saying that Dr Jacob's a whole other meeting to look at it but I think anybody can disagree with me it comes down to active listening and that is in the protocols respect and disagreeing with respect and I just want to make sure that people take a look at those again and that we move forward Dr Moore on

225the superintendent I think the one I pulled out again I'm sorry I didn't share it with you um making of course we know our Board memb of role and Authority I don't have any question about that um chairperson Vice chairperson they have no extra power we know that um the superintendent role I think the key thing is the eight days ahead unless it's an emergency do you agree with that uh yes okay just want to make sure in the board meetings um the time frame eight days ahead once a meeting is called order the agenda does belong to us that's a given but again adding in a discussion item adding up but action item that could be controversial we should hold on that um of course we all know school board members are expected to

226model appropriate behavior including courtesy active listening and respect you know I'm looking forward to working with this board as we continue to do our best for our students in the public school system so any input or discussion or do we need another it's kind of getting late but is do we need another one just separate for that I'm I'm open for that too anybody want to comment another one separate for what for which one just doing our protocols again as a new Bo oh I see which is I understand another meeting you mean to discuss the changes possibly yeah oh okay yeah um I I'll I'll go ahead um I'll go next I don't I don't I don't think we do um I do I do see one thing that does need to change um

227let me go back to the eight days um the eight days in protocols is the reason um why that wasn't honored is because it wasn't captured in our policy but our last revision of this policy which was in November if you recall um it did pass so it was captured in there I made sure to put that in there eight days in advance um so the policy does say eight days that the board members may add items to the agenda at least eight days prior but just keep in mind that will be Sunday so if you're busy all week and you haven't had a chance to do it you got to remember your Sundays are the days to get things to him at least um to get things on the on the agenda with with

228end with backup that I think is important because sometimes board members want to add things on an agenda with no discussion or you know no uh description no backup no nothing just an item and that doesn't help us to have a um he a healthy conversation about whatever the item is nor does it give board members the opportunity to prepare in advance you know so we have to make sure that we at least put a description whatever that description is and if you have any backup to include the backup um on there the one thing that I do see that needs to be removed from here is on page five um it is the second bullet under board chairperson um the school board chairperson has the authority to individually call special meetings of the board

229that is not correct when in fact if you go to page three it says exactly what special meetings um are required and we we all know special meetings are required any one of us can call a special meeting anyone it's not just the board chair it is any one of us if you want to call a special meeting any one of us can call a special meeting but the procedure is that the attorney would call each board member and as long as the attorney can find not she can find but where two other board members are willing and able and want to have that special meeting that would be your Quorum that would be your majority then you can have the special meeting but it is not solely called only by the chairperson the statute

230says um that it is the superintendent the board chair or any of the board members so that's how special meetings are called so that bullet alone should be removed I don't even know how that got on there um I don't when again page three very clearly says individual board members other than the school board chairperson May um and that this is also wrong too may not call a special meeting without the support of at least two others I think it's just worded different ly it says the same thing but it's just worded differently so um we do need three three of us but it's not three people who are calling it's one person who has an hey I want a special meeting and then we find two others right who are of support you know

231who are in support I agree yeah Dr Jacob that that needs to change that last that bullet needs to come out on page five bullet two right Miss Rosario can can I ask page five yeah it's actually bullet three on that page but bullet two underboard chairperson can I ask the attorney to weigh in on that because I do know that that's been there for a long time I've never called a special meeting but I I do know it's been there for a long time um yes thank you um to the chair um it's also reflected in your policy 0165 meetings it says that special meetings may be called by the superintendent on the request of the chair of the school board or on the request of a school board member in which instance you

232have the attorney um call for the willingness and availability um so so it can be called by the chair um so I I would suggest keeping it in your protocol since it's in your policy no now I don't think you no one is saying the chair doesn't have the right the chair is a board member this bullet indicates the school board chairperson has the authority to individually call a special meeting of the board but that's not accurate because it's not just the Schoolboard chair every board member has that authority to call a special meeting so through the chair so the way that it's been written has been both of those are true that the superintendent can call a special meeting that the chair can call a special meeting and also that a member of the

233school board can call a special meeting using the procedure where they contact the board attorney exact can I ask a question because I've always wondered that why it's written like this um when a board member wants to call a special meeting and they're not the chair they have to have you then ask if everybody can vote the superintendent does he have to do that does the board chair have to do that to call a special meeting that's why I think it was separate because I think there's different rules for different situations through the chair uh correct so the superintendent and the chair do not have to do that but if a board member wants to call a special meeting they have to use the procedure where they contact the attorney and the attorney contacts other

234board members to assess their willingness and availability to hold a special meeting no that's what I thought no that's thank you that's not true that's well find it in the statute please and let all board members know so we know exactly what well the statute is 372 special sessions when called by the district school superintendent or by the district school superintendent on a uh request of the chair or on request of a majority of the members of The District School Board provided that actions taken at the special meeting shall have the same force and effect as if taken at a regular meeting and provided further that in the event the school superintendent uh District school superintendent should fail to call a special meeting when requested to do so as prescribed herein such a meeting may

235be called by the chair of the district school board or by a majority of the members of The District School Board um given two days and then there's some other little stuff there um the procedure and the protocol that you're referring to only happened because of what happened with um um um Mrs barenborg and myself when we were first board members way back when we as a board it was the pre previous two boards not not this one if you recall Mrs barenburg when a special meeting was called there was a huge confusion over who called it um who who which one which board member called it um it was blamed on the uh executive assistant at the time who made the phone calls to try to get the board members uh to attend the

236special meeting um and then the attorney didn't really know what was going on uh because the executive assistant was calling the meeting and the executive assistant really didn't know legally what to say and what not to say to board members so we were given different information when asked who was calling it I it was just it was it was just crazy and when we got to the dis um the board member who actually called it denied having called it it was just crazy as a result of that to not do that again when we if you recall I think um Dr Jones you you might have remembered some of the conversation about it when we created protocols that situation H came up like we want to avoid that from happening so we at the time

237the board at the time said let's not have our executive assistant be in the middle and take that responsibility on her to call CU obviously we can't call each other um we elected we as a board elected for our s our uh attorney whomever our attorney would be to make those phone calls on our behalf so if I want to uh have a special meeting I call up the S the attorney and I say I want to have a special meeting on you know eating pizza tomorrow um please call call the board members and see who is willing to have this meeting with me that process that protocol that procedure was selected was created by the board just to avoid putting our executive assistant in the middle it's true and so that there was Clarity

238to our process you know and transparency it was safer for us to lean on our attorney for that not that that part of it was statutory or mandatory so it doesn't have to go through you we can change our protocol and say we want the superintendent to do it but at that point that's where that's a little bit of the history if you recall that was the purpose of having the attorney make those phone calls to avoid any gossip and any you know craziness bar when you have sorry so basically any board member can request it and you you have to have three board members who show up yes correct boom yes so we'll probably have to Dr James can you look at that it just I mean that's the bottom line yes because we

239can't call each other so I'd like to have a meeting they call yep three meet people can come here it is obviously through the attorney so there's an extra step in there we wrote These protocols very specifically to address the situation that Mr Ario has indicated so there it's a two-step process essentially number one the superintendent the board chair can call a special meeting or any board member can request to call a special meeting but we have to then ask the other board members are you willing to have a special meeting on this topic correct so they say are you willing to have a meeting here is the topic right then The Next Step once you have three the majority of the board so any other board members has the majority of the board that's

240willing to have that meeting then we say what date are we going to have the meeting on to ensure that we have a physical Quorum at the meeting so this is reflective fully of that conversation it is reflective of how originally that policy was written that it's the superintendent the board chair can call a special meeting or a board member with a support of two other board members so you'll see that reflected tonight because that language was redacted and when we put it in front of Staff it was very confusing of that two-step process with that redacted language in it so I'm going to read the statute the first paragraph because it does need to be um Wordsmith a little bit um it doesn't need to be removed that part about the chair not that

241I have called ever a special meeting um but it says regular and special meetings 1000 1372 The District School Board shall hold not less than one regular meeting each month for the transaction of business according to a schedule arranged by the district school board and shall convene in special sessions when called by the district school superintendent or on request sorry or on on request of the chair of the district school board by superintendent so in other words you need to add the the board chair requests the superintendent to call the meeting they don't need three people to call the meeting right and then then it says or a request to the majority of the members so it's either the superintendent that does it or the school board chair asks the superintendent to do it or

242three members when it's pull when they're pulled ask for the special Meeting those are the three situations for a special meeting that's what this says correct so what you have is correct it just needs to be maybe word Smith a little with request the superintendent probably so it's not the board chair calling the meeting it's the board chair requesting superintendent to call the meeting um again I just wanted to review a few of the points um I think overall when we did this um Master board we worked really really hard doesn't mean we can't review or revise or whatever we need to do but just appreciate you listening any other comments M Mr Dyer you haven't spoken sorry uh I I was just going to say thank you for uh updating us on the uh

243protocols I liked reading through them and I think that they're very good and I think that Dr Jacob's uh explanation of the process is what I understood the explanation of the process to be and why I was confused uh by the uh striking of the majority needs to call a a meeting so thank you Dr Jones thank you Dr P must speak I I got nothing more to add I I mean I think I it's good that we spoke about him I don't think we need to um schedule another conversation about the protocols but yeah I think we're good and um they're pretty self-explanatory you give them a read and thank you Dr BOS Mr Rosario yeah I just wanted to also um bring you to in that same uh um statute the last section

244section 4 um talks about a majority uh majority a quorum um what's what's important here and why I keep saying that even if the school board chair calls a meeting or requests for the superintendent to call me you still need a quorum you still need three at least three so it doesn't really it's not that you know the chair can call a meeting and then you're still not required to seek at least two other board members who are available you still have to seek two other board members who are available in order for there to be a quorum in order for there to be the majority um a majority shall constitute a quorum for any meeting of the district school board no business may be transacted at any meeting unless a quum is present except

245that a minority of the district school board May adjourn a meeting um so that part of it when word smithing it we have to make sure that even in that there still should be a majority even if the superintendent calls it yes so it's a quorum is a quorum a quorum is a quorum is a quorum exactly so it's not like there's a quorum for one and then not the other needed there has to be a quorum at least for all of it um anybody else just thank you um for bringing this back up and just you know no no name calling let's be professional to each other and um you know respectful and civil and all those good things and let's let's promote it for our kids to be able to see that as

246the leadership of the school district all right um we are to miss Rosario's NAACP workg group 4B all right let me get my so I wanted to bring this up um because because I there is I have let me get my my group sorry okay um I wanted to bring this up um just to kind of get us on the same page I guess whatever you want to call it um the work group meeting I'm very concerned about the work group meetings uh and that we haven't had any we've had very little this entire year we've only had three meetings the entire year we had one March 3rd March 7th October 28th and October 14th and then we have one scheduled in December that would be four if that doesn't get canceled and that one

247got canceled and rescheduled three times in 2023 there were two three four five six meetings in 2022 only one so in total there have only been 10 meetings in three years so 10 meetings in 36 months the concern is that this is not being taken seriously and this is serious stuff if we are supposed to be meeting on a monthly basis why not I know I know the district is willing I know we're available so there always seems to be a reason or an excuse and and I I don't know how else you know to um to have this conversation um safely but it is a conversation that the Board needs to have if there is a special meeting or an executive session that needs to be called I'll leave that up to the attorney

248if that has to deal with strategy um because it is you know dealing with litigation but um I'll leave that up to to miss shatak to give us that advice but this is this is not good I've mentioned this for a few months now there's no reason and no need for us not to be meeting and then we wonder and we question why we are not at unitary status yet why are we not any closer well we're not any closer because we're not meeting at the level that we should be so that's why I put it on the agenda Dr Moore I don't know if you want to speak or should we well through the chair I mean it it takes two sides to to cancel a meeting in in most scenarios so there over

249the last three years just because there's not a meeting doesn't mean there hasn't been a significant amount of work in the creation of all of the kpis that have been created a significant amount of work done between the the attorneys so there have been meetings that we have canceled that I have cancelled um and there have been meetings that they have canceled so at the end of the day it is an absolute priority in the work of this system the staff that is here the the principles um we have been pushing extremely extremely hard to to move that work forward um we we are we are scheduled um it could lead I mean this is a a legal case so maybe scheduling a a strategy session regarding pending litigation would be the most appropriate thing

250uh so the board the board can fully engage in a in a conversation anybody else Dr B yeah um when when I heard we weren't meeting within the court appointed time interval of once a month I was surprised um and then obviously through looking at it you know the idea that in a year we they met once it's it's hard to have the perception that um this issue is really trying to be resolved in good faith by all parties because if if you only meet once and the the judge said you have to meet every month in a whole year you got together once and then the next year you said there were six meetings I think and then this year we've had it'll be three or four maybe um it's just it it's hard

251for me to really have the perception that this is being done in good faith by all parties um and you know if the judge ordered that they have to meet once a month it needs to happen once a month and I I just you know I think moving forward there should be no um you know there's a lot of there's 30 days in a month so find a find a day that works um if you have to do it remote it's remote um I don't believe that you can't find a day I just don't believe it anyone else yes doc um I don't have my calendar in front of me so I'm uh assuming that all those dates were correct I do know we met one Saturday which was comprised of four meetings because we

252do two-hour meetings it was an eight hour day um and I think people are working very hard on the key performance indicators and um just have to keep pushing on Mr D yeah I just say that uh like Dr PCA I was surprised that uh we hadn't met uh the way we should have met I also was surprised this has been going on for years uh this is a topic that is uh very important to me but I come at it from the from the literacy side and the literacy is that you know we have kids that can't read and as we know what that does for you in life and I think that we have failed generation after generation of kids in this community and in this country by not having kids be able

253to read at thir gr level in third grade so I think this this is a symptom of the problem that we're willing to let kids fail I believe every kid can achieve I believe that everyone can be successful and this is a very important topic to me for African-American kids for Hispanic kids for all kids and I think we need to do better well having been an education and and close to you know the gford community I taught in Dodgertown have a lot of kids that I taught in gford my kids went there um I care deeply about that community and that and those kids in that school um you know we need to resolve this excuse me not just checkboxes but resolve it as in looking at some big big problems like you just

254mentioned Like Preschool you know if we're really going to attack this and do it why aren't we looking at all those kids that are missing the boat in third grade tracking back to see did they attend a preschool did they attend a head start what did they attend if they didn't attend why not provide that get that opportunity track that so we need to track kids from birth to five what are they doing um because I think you know that's when early literacy starts the phon names they're so important when they learn those when they're Toddlers and um they're already going to be behind if they're not getting their phone names and their um dip thongs and all the things that they need to learn by the time that they're learning all the vocabulary they

255have to learn so um it's extremely important my question is do you document you know your monthly meetings what dates they are and how they got um cancelled because I think the judge is going to ask for that the judge didn't require us to meet think so not every mon it was an agreement between the two parties okay and if the two parties agree to cancel the meeting the judge isn't going to have any issues with it um okay so what did the judge ask for when she asked for the the judge approved the uh The Joint plan The Joint Committee which said that we would that we agreed to meet monthly and there have been scenarios in which we have not been able to meet monthly that that's absolutely 100% correct um and it's

256not one side more than the other so to say that is it is the fault of the NAACP would be uh misleading to say it's the fault of the school district uh would be would be Mi misleading um so to force a a concern that you're not meeting monthly when the two parties have agreed historically not to meet as an example hey because the scheduling of all of the different people was so complex hey let's meet on a Saturday and let's do it all day long and that was a six seven eight hour meeting we were able to knock uh a whole bunch out um but I can provide the board the the the the dates I'm sure what Mr Rosario said is accurate I don't know why it wouldn't be uh the dates in

257which they've met I think we have scheduled meetings um moving forward so we did have one last month and we do have one scheduled the 18th or 19th of of this month okay thank you yes thank you oh sorry um the the makeup from the court on the workg group very clearly states frequency of meetings the work group will convene once a month until the agreement by the parties to the litigation to shift the responsibility to monitor compliance with the joint plan from the previously established Equity committee to the ircn daacp within 30 days of written notice joint agreement and then if there's a joint agreement so you just said that the the court didn't established uh monthly meeting and it was supposed it was just an agreement that's not true that is the agreement

258that the the attorneys put together and presented collectively to to the judge so it was an agreement okay between the two parts so what I was saying was I have the floor what I was saying was it was agreement between the two parts parties not a requirement of the court so we agreed to to the court that we would meet monthly and have we met monthly no but it's it's not a court requirement that you are meeting it was it was collectively agreed upon but when you collectively agree and you submit it to the court it is then filed as an agreement so the agreement still filed in the court is to meet once a month correct okay just a couple things yes go ahead um Dr Moore does a really good job of updating

259us on our data and if you remember the last one a couple months ago it still looked at our black students at being behind from anywhere from 15 to 25 points in your language arts and math so these key performance indicators are essential and what Mr Dyer said earlier getting them into a right good preschool so they're ready for kindergarten so I still think there are things we can do and I think still think if we have collaboration we can do it because our key performance indicators and each of the components of the joint plan I think have been pretty solid and um you know I open GI for Middle School very very close to the community and I know they want the same thing we want so somehow we've got to get there and

260for those who have been on the board and a few of you have and those of you who have grown up in the community um 60 years I can I can go back five years starting to say six now um the absolute debacle as to where this was six years ago oh yeah uh in terms of absolute no trust uh a agreement that was in place that wasn't supported or was heavy-handed to to say it the the easiest way an agreement that required partnership and trust correct the shifting to the work group was bold happened through mediation and it took a step back and taking a step back the goal was to create these kpis and if you want to have some fun go watch a equity meeting um where the plan that was agreed

261upon there was no criteria on how it was going to be evaluated so it called everything into question and that's that's the way it was designed uh how do I know this is true just just watch one it was a it was a mess so we collectively said we need to go to mediation to fix this and that was the amount of time Dr shafty Mr Seymour uh in and the creation of what that would look like significant those kpis even though they've haven't met every single month established the criteria to evaluate our progress at our last meeting for the very first time in six years we actually were able to present the progress within the mentoring section right so there's been a significant amount of of back and forth in exchanging of what the

262kpi is to level the playing field to get to the point where we can say yes so let me say it again I believe the school district in each of those sections has established a school district that is a one school system unified um my the 8 2018 joint plan the way we obtain unitary status which is extremely unique uh I haven't seen another situation like this anywhere in any of the cases um most of the go through Department of Justice this was given to uh the NAA the local NAACP is that we have to come to agreement on the progress that's been made right that is hard and complex and the goal has been to establish trust the kpis makes it very specific as to what we're looking at um and we are now

263at a point where we're presenting the information within each of those specific categories um so 60 years way too long six years that I've been here way too long um but the rate of progress in terms of academic performance behaviors um I'll put our black students up against anybody else in terms of their rate of improvement that that speaks for itself yes yes go ahead um and just to concur with Dr Moore just said the meetings weren't the only time obviously our group got together we would meet to plan for the meeting we would meet to look at the key performance indicators we would meet to look at you know what kind of um advancement our students are doing but and what I like about what's been happening is that we don't want to just

264say stamp unitary status we want to achieve it and I think that's important when we look at all the categories and everything within the uh uh 2018 joint plan um board in 17 or 18 I think you know they declared partial unitary status in three areas and cost us a whole bunch of money to do that and after talking with Mr Brown about that he said if you just talked to us we could say yeah you have it in facility support staff and administrators so I still think we're on the right Road uh with the key performance indicators so we have the data anyone else yeah um so so I I agree with you Dr Moore and I agree that a lot of work has been done um thus far however a lot more could

265be done if we weren't not meeting if we were meeting we could get more accomplished quicker this is just prolonging the inevitable we agreed to meet once a month that's the main that's the gist we agreed to meet once a month we're not meeting once a month it's unacceptable it's unacceptable um Miss shatak is this something that we should meet to further have the conversation is this strategy um or is this good where we are right now um yes so thank you through the chair I'm certainly going to um bring this discussion to uh Mr Matt Carson who's the attorney who's been handling the case um to see if we can get those me me ings to occur regularly monthly and I'll also discuss with him the possibility of you know a litigation session which

266allows the board to meet with the attorney and have a closed session um to discuss litigation strategy so I'll definitely be following up with him okay thank you all right that's it um we are on 4 C which is the Indian River education fund Mr Rosario I thought we did that we did that already okay well she had it as an item too I know okay and then we're to D then School Board attorney RFP process yeah P that one up okay so board members if you recall um some months ago um this was a discussion for us um and the agreement was if nothing had been done thus far um we would uh bring the RFP process to us for a vote in the December meeting that's what is the item um that is

267on on the agenda for this evening um and uh and that's where we are so I put it on the workshop if there was any other discussion that you wanted to have for it but this isn't new you know we we've had this discussion before um if we were to move forward with the RFP process and let's say for example the um um the firm and and going to defer to Dr Moore to continue what I'm saying or to correct it but if let's just just say that the firm um uh contacts us and says we have an alternative or we have another way or another route that we can go um then we wouldn't need to go through the RFP process at that point but right now this is what we agreed to so

268Dr Moore do you have any updates or do you have anything that you wanted to sh sh with through the chair I expecting to have an update this Pro well 16 seconds ago uh I do have a a call with the um lead managing partner to get information I have been in constant conversation um over the last several weeks also met with Amy envil uh who was sat sat in with us and helped us through the um a case that we had a few few months back so I am hoping to have the issue resolved this evening I do not want to go through an RFP I I think that is just um not the time to do it or the need to do it so I'm hoping to avoid that and provide the highest

269level of services from a legal standpoint to the to this board thank you I'll provide uh communication to the board so uh board members I mean that being said um you know uh barring any other kind of information that's the item that's on this evening's um agenda but of course if we hear anything before this even agenda I'd be happy to pull that item so we don't even have to then address it okay so um I have one other comment and that is that um legislature is starting up and so you'll be getting updates on legislation that's um concerning School Board soon and um the way I'm going to do it since I'm legislative chair for the uh state is um all the updates from um the legislative updates I kind of contract or pay

270attention to all of them and write up a bunch of stuff I'm going to do that with Danielle Tom Thomas at fsba and then we're going to send it out to all of the districts and I'll just make sure that um um Miss Moray also make sure that you get it so that you're aware of what's happening with school boards and then you'll hear some updates about some of the bills and where we think they're going to be going and heading and um there'll be opportunities and and I'm going to say this uh we have day in the legis lure on March 19th in Tallahassee um I I feel like all of you can go to that and come and we can speak to our legislators as a board because it's something that's already on

271our topic it's something we already voted on so if you would like to do that and when I set up uh times to meet with our legislators if you want to come as a board a lot of boards do that and it's very powerful where they all go and speak to the legislators together so if you'd like to do that then we can have her set that up and we can all go and speak on behalf of some of our priorities which I think you know we have a couple that are really important that are um pending that I think it it's a good voice to have a united front so I'd invite you all to dat in the legislature if you want to go to that and it's in Tallahassee that day so just

272see Miss Mor about it I'll get the information to herch all right with that being said it is 403 I'm going to adjourn this Workshop for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.