CorpusRecord 176643

School Board Workshop - Part III - Feb 11, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Granicus / BROWARD
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Broward County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,334 words · about 36 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001(Meeting adjourned). thank you, we are back to our discussion about the building department. MS. Rupert, did you have any more questions or are you done? I'm good. . Er MS. Leonardi? I will be quick on this one. Thank you. It was mentioned before the need to build the bench so to say, to have a plan for staffing in the future, so I'm wondering what initiatives or nabs mrab -- plans are in place now or if the board needs to take action on something like has to help you build capacity for the future for the building department. so, I think the struggle is real in terms of trying to find qualified people that will come and work for us at the price point that we currently pay. Part of the challenge too, it's not just the

002building department but it's just in this area of work that we do. I am working -- communicating with the superintendent, one of the things I want to be very careful about is making sure that we have the right balance of staff for supporting the capital program and then having that expertise as down the road we go into a bond program, so I'm very intentional about how we staff, the worst thing we can do the have a very heavy staff and not be effective in terms of the work, so I'm working with MS. Prk erla -- perla as well as my other drek reporters to see this. We had a person that we wanted to hire that was really qualified by the price point was 160k and that is totally out of our area and so

003just kind of bridging that gap, I'm very grateful to some of our -- to cap who is the group of people that we use to help us -- our contracted services but that is expensive, so part of the initiative is we really have to figure out how to grow our own. We have a lot of technical schools here, sheridan and at tant I can -- atlantic, so we need to form a good relationship and a pathway so they can work in the district when they graduate. We have several examples of that within the division already of people that came in as apprentices and work in real estate and under chris and just various examples and we need to really emphasize that because if we get them young, you know, choose bcps, choose bcps, so we

004need to live that, so again, it's not just one solution, it's a combination, so to make a long story short, we need an aggressive apprenticeship program, we need to hire these young people that will stay with the district for another 30 years, 40 years, so it's a process that we have to continue to mine and prosper going forward. I'm hearing a few different things, one, you're working on an analysis of your staffing to see -- to make sure you're most efficient. When would be a realistic timeline for that analysis to be done? so, I really want to take advantage of the superintendent's reorg that he's going to do in the spring so a certain extent and try to see -- I should have enough information by that time to see exactly how many more would

005be effective to hire into the department. okay. So, would it be realistic then to ask for you to share that analysis with the board before the reorg happens? yes, yes, and I like the word that you used, sharing, I'm going to share a lot with the board going forward and we're going to share a lot with the public by posting as much information as we can on the website so, yes, ma'am. and then I also heard the need for an aggressive apprenticeship program and I'm wondering what a realistic timeline would be for that to implement that? our work with the academic side, DR. Fulton and her team, to plan it out, I know that many districts especially large districts had really good apprenticeship programs and it could be as simple as re-establishing it. We have

006a lot of models arn florida nror -- around florida that work well, around the country that work well, I don't think we have to reinvent the wheel on this one, we have to do it. I'll work with the academic side to see how we can do that better. I know there are current apprenticeship programs in our house but also in the private sector and I'm wondering if we can recruit more aggressively or partner more aggressively with those programs as well. yes. what would -- I'm trying to think of a dip le mat I -- diplomatic way to ask this. In terms of a chief officer, would having that position be beneficial to the building department or would it be redundant? I don't think it's redundant. I had the vapg of when I was chief of

007facilities to have a deputy chief that I hired from palm beach county, he's currently the chief of facilities at palm beach now. His name is dave dolan, that's a success plan, we really need to focus on that going forward, not just in my position but in other positions. We were one deep in many of the departments and that is a real concern. Some of our employees, you know, I have one that has 40 years that's a key employee and so we have to build a plan going forward. yes, so I would like you to share that plan, and what I keep drilling down to, I know we have to make all these plans and do lots of analysis, but from the board's perspective, in order to maintain accountability throughout the system, I would like to

008know what that succession plan is and all of that and just one last piece, on pages 9 and 10, I'm curious -- so, like and maybe I'm missing something, how were these specific -- explain to me these two slides, why these specific schools are listed here. I'll answer one part and then I'll turn it over to MS. Perla to answer the other part. So, again, part of the criticism is of the building department and I know there's a lot of history I'm not privy too in many respects throughout this program, but oftentimes what perked my ear is that many times when we had a problem or had a project we were looking at, it will be oh it's in the build building department or the building department didn't do this and those kind of things,

009when you drilled down as MS. Perla said, yeah, informs the building department but it wasn't done correctly. There are obvious things that are MISS, it doesn't match up with the plans and there's no way we can pass inspection with it being this way and I have said earlier in the presentation, there's a lot of pressure on the building department to get the work out as quickly as possible, evaluate it and then you can see in terms of the number of days where it's with the consultant, it's either with the architect or the engineer and so what MS. Perla tried to describe is kind of the process this thing goes through and the fact that when they look at it and they make a ruling on it, action needs to happen, right, you know, and so

010and I'll let her take the second part because this is probably one of the frustrating -- most frustrating things for me as i came into this district and into this work was because you had a lot of finger pointing, and not a lot of collaboration and not a lot of work together, and so nathan and MS. Perla worked closely together to stop the finger pointing and to move the projects forward so I'll let her take this part. so, when we started preparing the presentation, we just chose four projects that were like 2018, kind of the beginning of the program, and 2022. I became the chief building official on DECEMBER 15, 2021, so we wanted to show what impact was there before and what had happened since. It has nothing to do with -- we have

011a lot of examples like this and the next page is what we did. We show stranahan, we chose rickards, it's a large school, and what we did with it. That's why we chose it. I braoesht -- appreciate that. I think what would be helpful, well, it would be helpful for me but I think it would be helpful for the larger narrative you're trying to demonstrate which things are getting better, things are improving is a more extensive analysis so, not just four schools but all of -- like you want to pick a point in time, I think you said the mid cycle smart program, so pick all of the schools or all the projects, whatever, not just four and then fast forward to now and do the same thing. ideally, MS. Leonardi, we need to take

012a systems approach in terms of how we look at not only this process but also fire alarms and devices process. We don't really have a systems approach, in other words, what is the process, so one thing we mapped out in nathan's area was the process, why are additional fire devices being added and how long is that process from when you identify that you need new fire devices or additional fire devices to the time they're installed, and that's some of the analysis that we are working on collectively because that's kind of where we lose thehe end date, so you see on some of these where there were 213 days and the consultant, this is just an example, so we need a systems approach and that's what we're working on that we can put all projects through

013this system and have an expectation that it stays with MS. Perla, her group for fiver days when it goes to the consultants, it stays with the consultants for a period of time that's reasonable and it comes back to us for her to approve the plans so that the contractors can finish the work. So, that's what I feel we do not have that is solid, locked-in, and that's what we need to work on, more of a process -- analyzing our current processes, our systems approach to this and from the onset of this program, it's absent. It feels like we're looking at a juija board and hoping it comes up correctly and that's not how programs are ran. That's some of the discipline that we need to put into the program. and I think with the new

014program and new initiative with the plan review, it will have a lot of ways to query the data and accountability is going to be nr and we're all going to see it because we're all going the see how many days was in the building department and how many days it wasn't there. and keeping the end in mind, the goal in what you hold us accountable for is finishing the project, right, and so -- and when we look at, for example, how we have that conversation with board members and how we have that conversation with the community, we need to speak to them in terms of that process so they also understand not, you know, every -- look, ingredient you put in a sausage but how does that work and in my conversations with board members

015over the time I've been here, there's a gap, so we need to improve that and make sure that you understand when you're asking a question about something, you understand the process on a bigger level that we follow and not that -- it coulder be familiar with you and not that it's like unknown territory and that's something that I need to work on as well as my team in communicating where we are in these projects. We need to do a better job. My opinion. okay. Thank you for that. I agree that we do need a systems approach. When can we expect some of those big changes to happen? I think it's a gradual process. You don't go from 0-100 in two days. One of the things we'll look at is lessons learned from this process or

016from this experience, you know, I have months of you, some of you have 11 years of it, and we need to look at our policies and we've started on a very minuscule scale but we need to look at our policies and see if they support the new direction because that is key to set kind of the parameters and the guidelines of how we're going to do business going forward. okay, I want to come back to the information on pages 9 and 10 and if I'm playing devil's advocate which I hate doing, but this happens all the time in the community, people might be saying they picked these four or five schools out of thin air, what would be shelfful for the sake of transparency, having a more extensive list for palings 9 and 10 with

017the purpose of reflecting on what went wrong and moving forward, what can we do better and demonstrating to the public how much things have apparently improved. So, that's what I'm asking for, for a follow-up and then on page 12 r a foll-u-up, someofof the new w initiatives, I would really like to see some of the data that might be b tied to them. So, I understand that maybe like for the simultaneous reviews, you're not going to be able to really show me any data around that but improve turn around times, I'm curious to see what some concrete examples of enhanced collaboration between stakeholders and quicker plan review submissions, I would like to see the data around that. Thank you. thank you. MRS. Alhadeff, you're next. so, one of the recommendations of the grand jury report

018was to outsource the building department. To we know what the financial impact would be to do that? yes, we provided that on one of the slides. Let me get the slide number. Student: 7. 7. the building department, yeah, it's 6 million dollars, our current building department budget is 2.5 million. Rebeer outsource or contract out 75% of the work. what is the 75% equal? I don't have it in front of me? we would have to do a follow-up on that to give you that number of what we're currently -- that's a really important number because if you're telling me it is completely outsourced, we have to weigh whatever cost of what we're already paying and what are the pros and cons. so, I have the information for years 22, 23 and 24, we paid two vendors

019which their names are cap and nova usa, we paid them 7.3 million dollars. is that per year or total for all those years? that's total, 22, we paid them 1.7 million, 23, 1.8 million, algt bit over, 24, 2 million, so each year and we can provide this information, each year, it has gone up. right, I'm just going to make my point. I understand that the cross is a little bit higher but I think we also have to look at the back end of the costs we're losing as far as getting projects completed in a timely manner. I don't think we're weighing that to any capacity which I think you definitely need to do. My other suggestion is I think we should do a field trip to the building department. should do what? field trip. absolutely,

020rock island, any time you want to come. no, I'm saying as a school board, I would like to -- all of us go. . Er absolutely, we would love that. thank you very much, thank you, MADAM Chair. and before I move to DR. Zeman's next, MS. Batista, can you weigh in, if we went to the building department which I've done, it's interesting because it's a very small space for the things they do, but would that be a sunshine violation? so, there are some concerns about traveling together and potentially doing a visit together, if there is going to be discussion of items that potentially could come before the board as an item to be voted on, so yes, that is a concern. thank you, and DR. Hepburn wanted to weigh in. just to weigh in to

021provide an example, we just had probably about five of the palm beach county school board members visit atlantic tech to learn more about our technical college programs, what they did, they came in one after each other so we would have one board member for 45 minutes to an hour, tour him around, really dive deep into what they wanted to see, then they chased a a time certain when they left, another board member came after him, so you didn't have to were ri about the sunshine issues, fyi. DR. Zeman? there's a couple really huge items here we have to think about and I want to ask MS. Leonardi to go even further because I think what we wan to know is how much do we want to spend on the building department so we get schools

022built. That's missing here. I don't care if it's 6 million or 27 million dollars, I want schools built, I want them built now. Chair, do how much money we're sit ining our capital budget for building new buildings or facility modernization? MS. Johnson, if you have that data available. we don't have it now, we can make it available to you. it's 800 million dollars, aisle give it to you. Do you know how much money million tlars is, DR. Holness, this is a workshop, 800 million dollars to spend. How big of a building department do you want know? That's the type of systems analysis MS. Leonardi is talking about which is how big of a building department and I don't sksh excuse my french, I don't care whether the contractor is government, I love the hybrid approach

023for this model, this is the hybrid model you staged about but wi want lot of it. We want lots of pm, we want planners, we want planners like an iq related to construction by the way, not just planners that can run software. But what we want is to spend 800 million dollars and by the way, I don't know the exact number, so let me can ask you, chair, part of our capital budget is paying breast off on debt. Do you know which year we stopped paying interest off on debt? no, I don't, but I can get that information to you. 2027, the magnitude of that is almost 200 million dollars a year of capital money we will get for capital and not have to pay on interest, so regardless of wlorn the bond goes through

024and I pay that it does, I pray we win people over and we get 6 blt dollars to rebuild our schools but even if we don't get it, we're going to go from 100 to 150 million of capital, so 350, that's already -- and remember, people, our smart bond was only 800 million dollars of new money, we took 14 years to spend it, I'm sorry, is that right? If we end in -- 11 years, we had about 80 million dollars a year, we're abto get another 200 million dollars a year because we don't have interest to pay off on the capital side, we're about to become like seriously involved in it. Chair, do you know how much more expensive construction is in 2024 than it was in 2014? DR. Hepburn? I think DR. Zeman has

025has answer. it costs exactly $2 for every $1 you would spend in 2014, if you're renovating your house and you want to spend 250, it's 300 this year, what happened whether the cost of construction went up, it attracted thousands of people boo program management, construction management, building departments all over the country wesh have twice as many people working in the trades. I'm work witching county commissioner steve gellar to integrate all of these trades programs, it is a demand signal that will not stop. What I don't want us to do is be cheap and the second thing I don't want us to do chair and I'm loose in my cool on this is to go slow and say we'll do it next and then we'll do it later and I'm sorry we can't change because the

026students done care that you're only here 7 months, and the students done care, MR. Superintendent, that you're here less than a year, they want their schools built. The community wants their schools built and it doesn't matter how long our leaders have been here. We want action, we want things to get done and we want thinking that is outside the box, if we have to pay contractor rates for government people, I'm in. If you need 12 million a year, not 6 because that's what will get 800 million dollars through the process, call us. Like we'd love -- I don't want to speak for us, this is a broad philosophical statement, I think we would like to see options absenting more if we can burn through the 800 million dollars and show people we can do construction

027and modernization. I think we have a lot of work to do to build them up. I will tell you a personal story because these contractors call me all the time, I don't know why. But they used to call me and say MS. Perla is stopping me, I can't get my roof through MS. Perla and I'm like good luck, I'm not a roofer, and they f now they say MS. Perla approved my roof in two days, I am getting so many calls from the building department. The system isn't set up for them to like you, you're holding them up from getting work done you, ear saying in tend it's good -- if it's good enough there bro urbacker broward county schools and they dig what you're doing, so thank you for allowing me to get good

028phone calls, there two years, I have gotten nothing, it has turned around lately. What we want to know is how much money do we need to spend between the building department, between MS. Paul's construction department, between the c -- cfo, staff in general and I'm not concerned about the average salary, if construction has gotten more expensive and the trades have changed, we have lekt tries in the county, they were making 40 thousand dollars a year and they're running wire. Not the owner, not the manager, the guy running wires is making 240 thousand a year, I don't know how much we have to pay, there are compensation studies that maybe MR. Azzarito can run for us and we'd know what the median is f you don't pay market salary you, ear depending on the nobility of

029the agency to get people in. If you can pull off a miracle, that's great. At the end of the day, we need a system that works. That's building department, it aos all of the construction management under the chief of facilities officer and that's what I hope to see and my view is I would like to see that in a month and I can't take anymore of this we condition do it. We've got the figure out how to do it. Do our best effort, take some risks if we have to. Manage risk but I can't stand to have 800 million dollars in the bank account which is the same size as the bond program, sit ining the bank and people are going to ask us, why were you sitting on the monday and I -- money

030and I want to say because we did our best, the burn rate we have in broward county schools is too low and I think we need wholesale change in terms of staffing and thinking about this in a way that makes the community excited about us having their money. thank you, DR. Holness? thank you, MADAM Chair. Thank you, DR. Zeman, for such a passionate expression of your concern. I see your hand movement kind of -- board member moving to the side so she doesn't get hit, that's commendable, board member bulman. I have heard concerns as well regard thing building department that it tends to be slow moving and I've heard that multiple times since I've been here and I praoesh the feedback today and your presentation. I've heard here where the building department, well, I've heard

031where the building departments revues are considered to be taking too long but at the same time I've heard here that it's not necessarily the building department fault, that it's the things that are missing and it has to be kicked back to engineers and whoever that's causing delays, and I remember finger pointing, and it seems they're finger pointing in both directions so I'm not sure exactly where the issue of efficiency lies but certainly I think the board would like to see greater efficiency so I guess my question is through the superintendent, have you addressed the -- assessed the performance of the building department in term of considering measures the improve its efficiency and I know you mentioned some of that earlier but has there been intentional assessment to look at the overall performance to improve efficiency

032of the building department? DR. Hepburn? MS. Paul? I believe that's similar to the question you asked me on my first meeting. I think the building department having an internal staff is essential to this district going forward. I think as I said before, we need more of a systems approach and that does not just lie with the building department, it lies with the whole interconnect ift between everyone that touches that project, that is PRESIDENT Of having a systems approach that we need to work on. MS. Perla has really been allowed to -- and I say that respectfully -- been allowed to do her work and do the job since I've been here. I agree with DR. Zeman in terms of it doesn't matter how long I've been here or not, I agree with that, but part

033of what I recognize esspshlly coming in new is constraints that have been placed on certain things and I need -- and I have given them the freedom to do their job and do their work and to say when something is not working, when there is a problem and do it in a professional and collaborative way across the division. We have worked really hard to get away from silos and the finger pointing and I want to add aecom to that list too. We have changed how we do business in a very short period of time. It's not perfect and we know we have work to do going forward but one of the things I will not do is hide the deficiencies and hide the things that we need to work on. I appreciate the input from

034the board because you've been here for a while and you've seen a lot of things and I've read a lot of things, so, we are work a work in progress, we're not po -- perfect, one thing we have done is recognize our weaknesses and where we need to improve, so with that, DR. Holness, I'll say again the building department se essential to the operation of this district and future capital programs and future bonds. And so I want to be careful not to throw the baby out with the bath water and I think that again I put my confidence in MS. Perla, she's an honest person who does the work with integrity. That MAY not have been the practice before but that is where we are right now. We have a lot of challenge and is

035every part this bond program is messy, and we have focused on all the bad stuff that has happened over the years, we're moving to the part of the program where we're going the focus on the good stuff as we close out these projects but there is a lot of work to do, I'm not going to underestimate that, it takes work with our contractors, holding them accountable for the work and many of them, let me be clear, many of them have stepped up, so this is a work in progress, it's not going to be perfect from one day to the next. So, I recognize the challenge, that's one of the reasons I came here, so I don't -- you know, we don't expect easy, what we expect is a system that will get these kids, get

036our kids and these buildings as soon as we can and safe and secure buildings. That's soliloquy, I apologize. I didn't use my hands. in the biggest thing that I took away from that process is that the collaboration piece. As a result of not talking to each other gaining efficiency and providing accurate information. We will continue to approve to each with to make sure that when we come to the table we're able to come to the table with the right attitude. So we've gone through several transformations in a short period of time so I think as a team. A year from now we'll be so much better so we're getting the work do get us there. thank you, MS. Paul, we're looking toward great improvement going forward. I appreciate it. thank you, MS. Mccarthy bulman. thank

037you. In to not repeat erg. -- also keeping a core group in the building department which is what it seems like we need. And I think, and I don't, I would love to see an analysis of the the costs of paying people at a competitive rate given the, the difficulty of finding and maintaining good people right now given the market and the construction market, versus how much money we have I don't think if we lose by paying people competent qualified people what they would be getting in the private sector or something, you know, reasonably similar. It's in our best interest to have those kinds of professionals on our staff. Because if we're always going to be, the, you know, not competitive we're not going to get the people that we need to actually get the

038result that every one clearly wants in having the projects closed on time. And I also appreciate the opportunity to get into an apprenticeship program I think that's something that we at broward schools can offer that nobody else can do and we should be a pioneer frontrunner for that, I think that's really attractive for our students and I also think it's very good for the community to have that kind of training, both with the private sector, contractor and then in-house. So I would love to see some kind of you know, major effort for that and also the numbers, I think that we would probably be very happy to fund something when you show that paying somebody a competitive salary, is going to safe us because we're getting the work done. thank you, and I'll close us

039out. I appreciate this coming forward as you know, when you first started, and I've said it, it's no secret that I want. Mainly because in a number of grand jury reports that's where the holdup was and it didn't make sense for us to continue down that path if it was not a successful department. You asked me to give you a year, so I'm very happy to see smft changes. but I will say what doesn't seem to be different is how many reviews the building department is requiring on some of that work, it's still six reviews, five reviews, when I'm looking at the chart. So that's concerning because I wonder if there is not enough effort in the beginning of the contractors koj, soy feel -- . so if I MAY in the review, so the

040number of reviews depends on the quality of the work that is coming forward. Again a lot of these issues that that we are dealing with now, happened in the front end so that is something that my team is definitely looking at as we, go through, you know, the projects and that, you know, that's something that has to improve drastically and that's accountability holding architects and engineers on the front end accountable. So, again, it's the process, the system's approach that we are working on going forward. So thank you for that. right, and I don't necessarily disagree, I think it would be beneficial to work with them on the front end to make sure that they understand that was what we read in all of those grand jury reports, was that they kept having the reviews because

041they never knew what was really wrong with what was happening. We're in a new era, I don't want to go back to grand jury he's but I want to explain why that was my suggestion. So I have two quick questions and then we will wrap thup. So the 2, 508, 417 dollars that's the budget of the building department which I think is 5, 7? Does that include the money that we spend on contractors? no, that's just payroll for our current employees. okay so when it says, as it stands the costs to outsource the entire department would be six million, we're not really just paying 2.5 million we're paying 4.5 million overall? So I think it's important for us to explain that because it's a lot different in terms of how much the difference is, not

042saying whether it's good or bad I just want to be clear that the six million would be all sourced out. We have 2.5 in-house and let's say two million outsourced right now. So it could be 1.5 million difference not really three, so I just wanted to to be clear. fick clarify, chair. Just remember, fd, the cost for fringe and salary for our benefits are going to be cheaper than the costs of outsources because they charge more, right? For the same person, soz why the cost is six million instead of the four. knoxer I. I understood that, I'm just saying. That's why the total increases. no my point is what is costing us right now is not 2.5, it's 4.5, that's the point I was trying to get to. Thank you. So I just I still

043have concerns, we'll see how the board goes but I just, I agree with every one paying more to get things done faster will save us money in the long run, I'm assuming but I think it's important for us to see that. So if you could bring even as a follow-up or the next time you come, what would we save if we were doing faster and on a another point, would we be doing it faster if we outsource? I think that's important. let me be clear, the outsourcing of it deals with the inspection piece, right? The outsourcing doesn't deal with the fact that the building department will get a plan that is not suitable or that is not correct from a architect or engineer, right? So that is the, the root cause or a part of

044the system's approach that I was talking about. If the plan is defective, if the plan doesn't have the number of fire devices and fire alarms on it, it's defective, it's going to be rejected whether it's outside or inside person. Those requirements are still there. If that makes sense. So, it's just not when the plan goes into or when the inspect or goes out from the building department and looks at the plan and says, does this match? Does not all that they do. They, you want to explain more of that? it's in here. I'm sorry, I want you to see the whole picture and not the one piece of it where the plan is being reviewed in the office. yes, and I'll just repeat what MS. Leonardi said, and again, I'm not saying that that you're

045not doing your job so i don't want you to take it that way fpt but we're watching these humongous buildings going up in record time around us, what are they doing different that we are not? So that's the ultimate question, why is it? They have architects, they have to have plans. I know that we have maybe different educational standards but it, it doesn't make sense to me, it doesn't make sense to the public that we can't even renovate a building in ten years, and there are buildings going up and it's, we could talk about this all day, so I'm not really asking you for to give an answer to this, so let ne just say that. Yes, I know and we're coming close to when we have to end, so it's just concerning and I

046think that's why we're all asking this question, we see so much other stuff going up in the buildings, being built in a much quicker fashion, what is our barrier? So that's just my question and I'll end with I love the idea of apprenticeship program and I, you know, I think we're leaders in that so I appreciate that. So I know there are a couple board members that want to go, so I believe you MAY have to some time left remember we have to stay in our ten-minute time frame. MR. Hill? I'm good. MS. Bulman? I just wanted to point out, I was just thinking about this, if we get rid of the building department, that means that we're going through each individual municipality? No, okay. So then what happens? DR. Hepburn? MS. Pearla. so what

047would happen, you would have to set up a contract with broward county and you would also need to get an outside company to do the plan review and inspections. At the end of the day, because you're the owner, you're going to have to, the code requires that if you set it up with outside company you're going to have to audit the company so you're still going to have to have the building department to be able to manage all those aspects. and so, in that conversation, it's kind of like we have now, basically, because we're outsources 75 percent. When we bring the contract back we're going to ask for additional dollars to get additional inspectors in there so that 75 percent will more likely go up. so it's kind of complicated? The existing state of affairs

048that was the point? , the only poinlt I wanted to make. good. Thank you. Anybody else? Sure? Okay. At this time, do any of my colleagues have anything to bring to the board or student success to share? DR. Zeman. thank you. And I promise not to hit anybody. i asked which is what our policy says to do about adding an agenda item to today's workshop. That didn't happen but I want to make sure that we're clear about the need to talk now about redefining. It is imperative whether we make a decision ahead of the fdca, it's imperative to think about the strategy on the heels of what we did. At the end of phase one and I would like in addition to adding that to the next workshop, I would like to our workshop agenda

049that we talk about future workshops as a group and it's reflective with the superintendent. We've done that in the past, it allows all nine school board members to talk about their priorities and the things that they see that they're essential and also allows to us codify the conversations that we've had up to this point, that says oh let's get that in the workshop in the near future so the chair can do with the superintendent whatever they can with the board's highest priorities. This is a school board meeting and school board members need to be able to share their views both now and at the end of the every meeting for one or two workshops making sure that we get our priorities. So, we don't have time now to talk about redefining but I really think

050that as a board, it is our biggest item. There are people who spoke about it today and in the facilities condition assessment but we owe the superintendent some guidans on what we want on phase two and what the pace of redefining looks like. I'm going to nominate that for the next workshop. Second point, on a happy note, I want to thank directly dauj jewelers for supporting, law firm, aetna and btu, all donated money to our finalist and winners. bright star. bright star, I forgot one. I forget sometimes how nice it is for sponsors to throw money at people we can't. We don't give money to finalist for good reasons but it's awfully nice when the community does it. And miami-dade raises one million dollars with their caliber award. And when I see balances that have

051zeros to it, I wonder what we might be doing to jazz up that event and get more sponsors in the future and I'll leave that up for the superintendent and other people to work on. Thanks a lot, chair. thank you. DR. Hepburn, do you want to address the workshop question? yes. I was going to wait for the opportunity to do so. So first of all, I just want to clarify if there is consensus and if there is a question for DR. Zeman and the board, is it just an item to discuss? Is there something to bring or item to put on for discussion? my request chair, is that we have time to talk about the big broad strategy, the timing, the criteria we're going to look at, the balance between giving family notice versus the

052time that we need to do the analysises but it takes a specific amount of time. The same thing is true for budgets. Last year by this time, we had done two budget workshops, we have not touched the budget for next year yet. If we don't get budget workshops items for that, and those are structured, the budget ones clearly structured. What I'm asking for on the redefining is about the strategy for what we nt toto dodo wi phahasewowo. Okay. so, anany dada that you ne from staff to bring to provide to help with the discussion? I get the discussion point, but is there any data or anything, if you come to a consensus and want to talk off line one on one if the board talks about what that would be. my question would be for

053the ba data that we had last year and pm two, but again it would be a folder provided to people but a board just having this conversation about what our strategy about redefining is going to be imperative so you can then execute and bring us back recommendations on what is optimal timing about the phase two decisions. okay, I guess we can take a consensus on that. I just would be concerned about us making a lot of decisions ahead of staff, because we need staff ready to answer our questions. I mean that's my own personal thought. But, we'll see how every one else feels. So did you have a suggestion, a time line suggestion on that? yes, and again, this is not a decision item. I have no, I cannot imagine anybody, wanted to be a

054workshop so we cannot make decisions anyway but it's not about talking about decisions, it's talking about if we started soon, we could make decision buzz school year 26-27 by the end of this year. If we don't want to do that, we roll into the sum and her we run into the summer roll problem and. I believe that the superintendent needs to have guidance from the elected officials about what we want out of phase two and when we want t big strategy discussion not about specific schools or zones or analysis but what does phase two look like and when do we want to finish so we find the right balance between giving families time to adjust and us making the best decisions with the data that is required. okay, so we'll leave that, and I'll just

055tell you the superintendent is in charge of the agenda it's not a collaboration that we make. So I don't get to say what goes on on the agenda and what doesn't, we do that as a board collectively and it will be up to him what workshop goes on. can you educate me then about, the superintendent has the agenda about workshops. MS. Batista, can you run in? I think we only run the agenda for special school board meetings, as a chair. so I'm not sure what you're asking me. So the way that the agenda works, is for board meetings and special board meetings the superintendent is in charge of the agenda and what goes on the agenda. For special board meetings it's a little bit different because it can be requested by a board as a

056whole or the chair or the superintendent. As far as the workshops are concerned, you're correct the way that normally done is by consensus of what items the board would like to have on the agenda and then the superintendent will place those items on the agenda. thank you. I just want to paraphrase what I think the counsel said, they con zen -- puts on the agenda when it comes to workshops. yes, so let's get a consensus, we're not voting, MS. Bulman are you okay with having a workshop with redefining phase two? okay. MS. Leonardi. I prefer to wait until we have the fca. okay, I also prefer to wait. MS. Thompson? I prefer to wait just to have that, but as soon as that comes out, I would like it. ditto. DR. Holness. I'm sorry I

057just have a quick question are we looking for this to come on a subsequent workshop immediately or the superintendent will decide which workshop it comes on? the superintendent traditionally decides where it fits. okay, so there is no time requirement here? I think DR. Zeman would like it as soon as possible. okay, so I'm going to be in support of DR. Zeman. there is no consensus. okay, thank you. Okay. Next is MS. Leonardi. thank you. And just to the point about the workshop and who determines that, I've gotten different guidans in the past. So correct me if I'm wrong, I believe I just heard that it's board consensus that determines what's on the workshop along with the superintendent, is that correct? Did I hear that correctly? MS. Batista. yes. I think traditionally again the superintendent will

058place items on the workshop agenda, I know that we have had or have seen discussions with the board where the board has asked that somebody be brought sooner to the board and also, you know, at the end of workshops to request the board members can requests items to be placed in the agenda for workshops. okay, two years ago I remember this, I really appreciate consistent guidance on these things. Two years ago, a chair unilaterally removed something from the agenda and I was told that that chair was able to do that. I just ask that we have consistent on that. to my point that I wanted to ask about for today, there was recently an issue around one of my appointees for a committee, getting calendar invites, I guess this appointee had repeatedly requested the information

059from the chair, I'm just wondering, what the process is when we appoint somebody to a committee who is responsible for sharing those dates, who is responsible for sharing the calendar insites and also what happens if a committee chair or a committee meeting changes location or time at the last minute? Is there an issue with sunshine? DR. Hepburn? MR. Sullivan. so I think it would depend on how it's being done currently, some is liason and some committee chairs it themselves. So we're going to standardize where it's just the liason so we don't run into these issues. As far as sunshine, it would pose an issue if they changed location and they did not advertise the change. thank you. I appreciate moving those to the liason, other boards do tha. That brings up another question for me,

060do when, people are appointed to these committees, do they get training on sunshine? yes. okay. So they are aware that they shouldn't be sharing ideas about policies and stuff with each other via email and things like that? it's also, they should familiarize themselves with 1070. okay, got it. Thank you. you're welcome. DR. Holness. thank you, MADAM Chair. I would like to extend my heartfelt congratulations to all the nominees considered for prestigious caliber awards. Special recognition goes to MS. Blue, principal of the year from orial elementary. And school employee of the year. And MR. Lamar, teacher of the year and MS. Rowe assistant principal of the year your contributions make a lasting impact and we're all proud of the work that you're doing. Keep shining. And lastly, plantation elementary, I would take a moment to recognize

061plantation elementary for being selected as a nation at merit schools. This reflects the dedication and commitment of the entire community. thank you. That was my sticky note about all the caliber winners. Also congratulations and a great event thank you to DR. Zeman for being my partner on the red carpet with all the finalist and for you going out to the community and getting donations. Each one of the finalist got a goodie bag that DR. Zeman was able to secure all himself. It was a pleasure doing that with you. And thank you to the staff who put that together, it was such an amazing event. The dj was perfect, he just knew the right song, he made everybody want to dance and it was such a great celebration of all of our teachers, principals assistant principals

062and school related nominees and winners. Thank you so much for everybody who put that together. Thank you. Okay. I got so excited, I turned the page. The scheduled order of business of this broward school board, seeing no other obligation, I know adjourn the meeting. Thank you and have a good

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.