001[Board in recess] I want to take a point of privilege to thank both MS. Priest and mac entire for their professionalist and cooperation throughout the 8 months that it took to negotiate the I. L.A. With the county as well. And just very glad that you guys are here. thank you, very much MS. Batista. Good morning, chair and members of the school board. I want to thank you and express my appreciation for your confidence dm my agency's ability to take on the work that you have asked us to do. It shows a lot of confidence in my colleagues at the agency and in the work that we've been able to do so far. I also want to thank your staff particularly MS. Batista as counsel and other members of the school board staff who assisted us
002in our process of giting to know one another and what each of us did and negotiating the terms of this inter local agreement or ila. Which did take a while but was collegial, informative and it, it did dmens trait a generosity of time on staff. With that t I'm going to ask my colleague kathy mac entire our general counsel to present on the ila itself. good morning. yes, good morning, thank you again for having us. After the presentation, we will go ahead and take any questions you MAY have and we'll answer them to the best of your ability. I've prepared a powerpoint presentation. and I'm going to start the powerpoint presentation with a little brief overview of what we did historically and then I will go ahead and transition to what we will be doing
003with regard to the ila and our new relationship with the school board. So, let's begin with what does the org did? Or what did we do before this ila? Well overall, the best way that I described it to anyone that asked, we ask as a watchdog agency an independent watchdog for the residents of broward county. We were created by charter and we were created to basically investigate, report what we find and refer to any particular authority that we must refer to with regard to our findings. And we are specifically to look for misconduct and gross mismanagement and I'll be going into those definitions before the ila and our what our conduct will be, what we'll be looking forward to as far as conduct after the ila and also the charter that we were created under
004our broward county charter, gave us jurisdiction over county official and providers. You can find our particular section of the charter in section 10.1011 that charter provisioned was passed in NOVEMBER 2010 and like I said we were create today investigate MISS Contact and gross mismanagement. So what was misconduct and what is gross mismanagement. Misconduct is any violation, a federal state or municipal law involving fraud corruption or abuse. What is gross mismanagement, now these are definition that's you find in the charter while misconduct can be used in the general use of the word, misconduct for jurisdiction is found in the charter. Grossmanagement is a mamarial wawaor gross mismanagement. Again the jurisdiction was over county official, employees and providers and the charter also established that we were headed to be inspect or general. We were structure and organized
005in order to make sure that there was no external influence or interference with our work and we're overseeing by a committee comprised of no one na is under the oig's authority, that way the agency maintains its independence. Now again, this is a brief overview, there are definitely much more details in the charter and I welcome you to look at the actual charter for details for example the make up of our selection oversight committee. Now because our agency fits the definition of applicable agency, we have certain obligation with regard to our information. By law, the oig cannot disclose the name of any complaintants or any individual who in good faith, discloses to us any kind of information that alleges that an employment, employee or agency or independent contractor has violated or suspected of violating any particular
006laws or has committed or has engaged in gross mismanagement. So again, with regard to the name, the identity of those individuals they are forever protected by us unless there are provisions where we must disclose or can disclose the name. Now likewise, the statute also indicates that we have to keep confidential any information that we receive during our investigation while the investigation is active. Again these obligation right side statutory obligations for us. The charter directs that we are to write reports under certain circumstances, one when we are concluding a gross mismanagement investigation and two when we're completing a investigation if the report will be helpful in preventing similar misconduct in the future. The only exception is if we are working on a criminal investigation and the criminal authority has asked us to hold off on a
007report because it would be interfering with their independent investigation. The way that it works is first we issue a preliminary report. This preliminary report is issued for 30 days. That 30 days is for the purpose of giving the opportunity to respond to any entity to the entity involved as well as to my innrimations party: all response right side considered for purposes of report and we a fend the finances so that the readers, the public can see all relevant information. Now our investigation continues to be confidential until the report becomes final, thus the preliminary report is also kept confidential. The issuance of our final report is the signaling of the investigation concluding and the charter also empowers the ig to follow-up on any recommendations that we make throughout any report. With regard to our obligation to
008refer and to and refer and some cases prosecutor. If there is probable cause following an investigation, we must notify the appropriate agency charged with any enforcement. For example, if we see criminal conduct, we must refer it to to the state attorney's office and/or the united states attorney's office if we see misconduct with regard to any laws I mplicating the florida on ethics. Again with the florida ethics commission, they get florida ethics violation sxz to any jurisdiction that MAY have enforcement over the particular contact that we MAY have observed then we have probable cause. Now if there is probable cause following an investigation, however there is no particular agency that has jurisdiction over enforcement of the probable cause, that's when our duty to prosecutor kicks in. And those instances, we file a complaint and we prosecutor
009the complaint and those in the florida procedure and florida rules of evidence. The charter also obligates us to issue annual reports. It requires us to publish the annual report and that report details the activities of our office. Once the annual report is issued, the selection over convenes within 60 days. To consider the report as well as the pfs of the ig. Now I took some example from highlights from our 2023-2024 annual report, just to give you a kind of taste of the things that we've handled and we've reported on. The first one is what we, what the report, the report was called gross mismanagement within the city of ft. Lauderdale allowed waste to over build two million dollars. In that case we determined that a former direct at the city of north ft. Lauderdale engaged
010in gross mismanagement for failing to report waste services. Because of that failure to proper lehmanage the contract, waste pro who was the service provider was able to over build the residents through the city as well as commercial customers and they did not pay all of their franchise fees. In total, what we found was between JANUARY 2012 through SEPTEMBER 2021, the waste pro waste buildings amendmented to 2 million 600,000, a little under that. We found, other gross mismanagement in the city of wilt wilton manners with regard to their parking services contract. In that report, after that investigation, we found that two former city finance directors engaged in gross mismanagement in their handling of the parking management. Nobody was seeing or vetting the invoices and because of that failure to vet the invoices, we were able to
011determine that they did not, they did not engage in certain activity for example, shoeinger that the monies that the parking management provider in this case linear was collecting matched deposits that was going to the bank altogether. For instance, we saw deposits totaling 3,056,000 however they reported collecting 2,900,000. Once we started investigate anding conducting our interviews, we were able to determine that there was no oversight of the contract and because of that failure to oversee the contract, linear was able, there was questionable expenditure totaling a little over 100,000 linear had built for approximately 78,000 and been reimbursed in that money that did not have proper back up documentation and they had been reimbursed approximately 30,000 for expense that's were not even authorized by the contract. During the investigation we were also able to determine that the
012contract had called for a retainer and that retainer was suppose to be returned to the city however, it never was. We also determined that the linear was suppose to sign over a vehicle to the city and again, that had not happened as well. By the time our investigation was over, we do credit the city and lien yor because they did review those issues by the time our investigation closed. Now before I go into the contract, I also wanted discuss that there are sometimes that we go ahead and investigate a matter and we do not report it, there is a lot of behind the scenes going on as well. For instance n fiscal year 2024, we closed an inquiry after vetting allegations about elected commissioners misuse and MISS Appropriations of taxpayer funds for discretionary projects. In
013conducting the inquiry and in this case it was an inquiry, we reviewed all relevant documentation and expected the expenditure from the expense acts and determined that there were ten violations in fiscal year 2022, that were a little under $5,000. And that was under a now repealed ordinance that they were able to make those expenditures because the ordinance was no longer in affect, and because the of the did I minute mus amount involved, we found good cause for misconduct in the code violation but closed the matter without an investigation. In another matter we closed another inquiry into an allegation that a manager avoided -- had manipulated bids to favor specific vendors. We reviewed a multiple of records, such as the procurement code, the purchasing card, the purchasing, the records altogether and the invoices 50 of which,
01450 invoices which tote allege approximately $40,000. Also conducted interviews in that inquiry. Our analysis the manager conducted seven solicitations. We also analyzed aggregate spend anding found that those were in compliance as well. We found no concerns when we reviewed the 2020 purchases, we reviewed everything to make sure that everything was in the up and up and we did see that not only not was only everything proply bid and pro cured, we learned that they had spending methods and established key vendors which to us to enhance the compliance with the agency's purchasing standards. So we determined the allegations to be unfounded. Now turning to the agreement which is what we're all here for. Affective JANUARY 2, the oig, the school board of broward county and the county executed an inter local agreement whereby the oig is
015to provide services to the school board pursuant to the ila's terms. Now, what are the terms of the ila? Now this is going to be a very broad overview. Again the ila commands. Let's talk about who is included. We have included in the ila all school board elected officials and o -- appointed official and employees. And those that provide goods and services to the school board under a contract for compensation. But with regard to the vendors our jurisdiction is limited to the contract for compensation. So just because they are vendor, does not necessarily mean that we automatically have jurisdiction, we have to be looking at conduct that is relevant to the particular contract. We also have included school board or superintendent appointed members of groups that are delegated decision making authority or acting as an
016advisory member to one or more school board members or the superintendent. And we have also included all members of the competitive solicitation evaluation committees. Now, who is not included? We have specifically excluded members of groups that act to support the district's school for example, school ally groups. Now that is unless the members of those groups are otherwise included, for example, they happen to be an employee, they happen to be a vendor under a particular contractor they happen to be an official, which I don't know if there is any official that's are members of school advisory groups but unless they are specifically included, we have no jurisdiction of those members that belong to groups that are simply supporting a district school. Now what conduct is included? We are through the terms of ila, we have included
017state and federal constitution, statutes and codes, county municipal codes and ordinance sxz included applicable school board rules and regulations which I see that you guys have a lot of so we will be learning them. And we are we have limited as far as the particular subject where we have jurisdiction over specific subject such as, administrative operations and procedures construction management equipment, maintenance things of that sort. And again you can find it in the ila as far as the list. We also have jurisdiction over conduct involving fraud, corruption or abuse as well as any material waste or significant mismanagement of public resources. Now what are the financial obligations pursuant to the ila? These are the highlights. The school board is responsible for all the costs that the iog will be incurring and its provision of the
018services to the school board. The method of funding will be through the budgeting normal process. The school board, the fee of 659,000 is to be used for the cost of oig services through the rest of fiscal year 2025. That was the initial fee and to my understanding it's already been paid. Yes, and it will cover us through fiscal year 2025. The oig will provide its anticipated budget to the school board on time for the school board fiscal board and maintain documentation to back up these costs that we're asking for. We judge included in the ila a termination process. Now any of the parties can terminate the agreement with 30 days notice of the affective date. Now once the oig receives or provides notice, a wind down period is to begin by which the oig MAY
019not undertake any new services unless based on existing information, information that they received before receiving the notice or providing the notice. The period, the wind down period, the actual period will last through the notice becomes affective, through the date of the notice, through the end of the county fiscal year following the fiscal year that the termination became affective. That will afford us to wrap up any investigations that we have pending. If the school board's investigation right side not concluded by the end of the wind down period, the school will continue to fund the costs necessary to bring that particular investigation to conclusion. As far as our other obligations, as far as report anding referrals, those obligations remain that the same with the exception that the school board is now a recipient of the report on
020those matters that volve them. As well as a recipient of the oig's annual report. Now this is the time for questions. well, is, I do have some comments. I would like to speak. turn mic on. I don't do this very often, you can tell. I would like to speak to the my office and how we envision providing these services to you and a little bit of our experience so far. After which time we'll be happy to answer any of your questions. We were happy to agree to provide you with these services when we were approached a couple of years ago. But only on these two conditions, just two conditions. They were of course, adequate funding but also we had a condition that was not negotiable, which was ultimately that we remain independent and be able
021to function properly as an inspect or general. Independence is the hallmark of inspector general or any oversight of agency. And without it or without appearance of independence, we just, we don't have trust of the public to do the job b that we'r'rgaged to. We don't expect o relatishsh w with yoto be any different than our relationship with the other entities that are under our authority or that appearance of independence MAY be affected. We were pleased, I was very pleased that the ila suitably addressed these two conditions. Now in terms of how we treat agencies within our authority, we have principals that all of us in the oig agree to uphold. And that includes that they dedicate our limited we sources primarily opportunities to improve systems, our teachinging moments would have a deep or wide impact
022and/or are in the public's interest. We don't get involved with we would not add value, we don't get involved as an appeal avenue for example for decisions about matters that we see are adequate lea dressed by the school board or by another agency. As far as the treatment of subjects and of allegations and other implicated parties, we recognize that our reported findings can injure reputations. So we always solicit and we listen very carefully to explanations to our preliminary negative findings and then we consider those explanations and we also consider and mitigate unwarranted negative impacts to individuals and agencies. For example, in a published report, we myto mitt the name of the individual who was an integral part of an investigation but was not implicated and for that reason, we might indicate that individual by their
023role or by their initials to because it's not necessary to accomplish what we're trying to accomplish through our services. But at the of the day without fear or favor, we are going to report and report we're going to report and refer for enforcement as a appropriate, the misconduct and gross mismanagement that we find. I want to emphasize as MS. Mac entire has statemented to you, that our authority is very very limit by following the chart and her ila which we are bond%backer bound to do. It's only over school board officials employees and providers, period. We are not, we do not have authority nor will we engage in investigations of any other individuals or entities if they happen to have been part of a misconduct as part of an investigation that MAY be reported if it's
024pertinent or relevant to what we were investigating in the first place. We're not going to investigate anything outside of the school board, officials employees and providers. And then of course, only that gross mismanagement or misconduct as defined bit charter and ila as explained bit MS. Mac entire. I'm going to go into the subjects that the ila covers. So we have with the county and municipalities, we can base our conduct on their ordinances. And so we saw your school board policies rules and rules as kind of, you know, the equivalent to those ordinances so we expanded beyond state law and federal law in finding this conduct. Based on violations of certain of your rules and policies, not all of them. So, generally, these are subjects enumerated, they're enumerated in the ila for example regarding administration, accounting,
025building and construction, codes of conduct other than just for instructional personnel, contract manage, finance, financial management and reporting, funds management. Cybersecurity and information technology, procurement, property control, records management and of course the other enumerated policies. So for example, we will not be investigate your legislative action. What you decided, we might investigate the implementation of that, we must investigate violations of that, but we're not here to second guess your policy with a little p, policy decisions. We're not going to be investigating disciplinary issues and actions involving individual employees, unless we find that there is an indication of a pattern of some kind of system wide or systemic problem. And we're very good at tracking these individual tips and complaints overtime to see if there does appear to be some kind of repeat allegations which, you know,
026in an isolated case, MAY not be something that we want to take on but if it involves systemic mismanagement or fundamental problem, we will. We don't investigate whistleblower claims per se. You are the employer of the individuals who are designated to be whistle blowers but we're interested to know when people are retaliated against, or claim to be retaliated dense, because we believe that is additional evidence of the underlying facts that these individuals are reporting. We will not be investigate violations of our policies relative to academic, instruction, instructional material, carricula or extracurricular activities, we will not be abusive behavior or of course student conduct. We will not. So you have understanding of how much work we take on and we produce, I thought I would go some of the statistics that we compiled for our latest
027annual report which came out, you know, our fiscal year ends on september 340th so through SEPTEMBER 30th 2024, we reported in our annual report that we handle 377 tips, 6.3 of those resulted in an investigative matters. We handled an additional 40 complaints, 7.5 percent of resulted with investigative matters. We identified 2.9 million dollars in questionable expenditure. We closed nine inquiries and investigations that we reported to the public and we closed 16 others without reporting to the public. Now this was for the county and 31 municipalities. We've been operating when the service right side fully up and running, the school board will approximately for approximately 25 percent of our work. In the 2025 annual report, to be released around thanksgiving, will have a section on school board accomplishments, and we'll be distributing that annual report to
028each of you board members individually and will notice the superintendent of boards and school board chair, about when and where the annual selection oversight committee meeting will be held and that is of course, where they review the annual report examine my performance for the fiscal year. I want to turn to the ila and our very brief history, so far, what we've done so far under the ila, as you know became affective on the JANUARY 2022, as the third of the three parties to the agreement. We are now seeking to fill three positions dedicated to school board cases. And we have job ads, I should say running right now for a special agent and a special auditor and we intend to hire an investigations manager either from among those applicants or in-house. I thought you might
029be interested to hear that since our inception in 2011, between then and 2024 through the end of 2024, the oig actually received a number of complaints of the school board. And my count, it was 38 in all of those years. And since the ila, since JANUARY 2, we received 5 tips, which of which were closed and two pending follow-up. And I wanted to very briefly go over with you the tips that we closed or rather why we closed them so you have your eyes open in terms of how we're going to be moving forward. In the first tip it was received on JANUARY 13, we closed it about a week later. It alleged discrimination, harassment, denial of accommodations and false claims by your nursing department that resulted in harm to children, certain children. And the
030allegation was essentially that there was no implementation of a 504, an 504 plan since 2023. We, no action in this matter. Because there is a 504 plan it's just not one that the tipster felt was appropriate. And because it did not rise to the illegal harassment, a threat to sue is not a legal behavior. If warranted and even if not warranted, it's not a violation of law so it's not misconduct. And so without misconduct, we don't have the jurisdiction to proceed and we did not. The second tip we vaoefd was on JANUARY 23, that the department of education violated the first amendment when it passed a new curriculum that requires teacher to affirm believes they don't believe. We no-action this because the oig only has jurisdiction over school board official and providers, these allegations are
031really against state actors, right? The school board is following the curriculum therefore it's following the law, it's quite the opposite of misconduct. As school board actors were not engaged in gross mismanagement and misconduct and we no-action the tip. And third tip we received on FEBRUARY 7th, the allegation was that there was a teacher who is out on sick leave due to a medical condition while being seen in public perfectly healthly. Now the nip -- tipster thinks that they're burning through the time prior to retimer and committing fraud. These are one of those minor singular events by a single employee and not by management, as presented, right? There MAY be mismanagement of time, employees but this tip does not present that kind of bigger problem and we have referred this tipster for your hr for hr
032or appropriate department to proceed with disciplinary proceedsings but the tipster filed anonymously so we could not reach out. that's what gives you an idea what we've done for you. Before we close, we do have a couple of questions for you, and they include one which is when do you need from us our requests for next year's budget? We're going to the county with a budget request I think by the end of APRIL, but your fiscal year is a little different than ours. DR. Hepburn? I'll ask MS. Johnson to weigh in, you're right, our fiscal year is different. Go ahead MS. Johnson. we're currently billing next year now, so if you can process as soon as to our office, it will be appreciated. I'm glad I asked. And who should we direct that information to? it
033will be fine if you can direct it to me. okay, and you are? C.F.O., remenere johnson. thank you. And second and finally, we're going to need to physically expand and, you have included in your initial fee, approximately $115,000 I think to fund for us a modest build out of our existing space. So we're in plantation, we're at the corner of broward boulevard and university drive. And we're in the guess I guess in the county's government west building but we're in a separate suite, we're physically segregated from the rest of the county staff, we have our own entrance and this is, for a reason to, you know, to keep a physical and psychological separation between the county and oig and to encourage people that it's okay to come and you will not be seen by county
034administrator and managers. So, we're pretty tight as it is. What the plan is to reduce the size of our individual cubicals, stuff some additional cube tals in our file room removal of our hard files out of your file room and that kind of thing. And we're staffed for budget for 20 but we have 20 of our own staff now, we're adding three, you know with the idea that we're going to dedicate three to the school board matters. And then, I think we are going to be expanding some more because of the displacement of work that we're able to provide the county and municipalities by taking on this job. So we would like to plan for accommodating approximately 30 staff and we have this plan that was developed last year, and we're ready to implement it,
035but I was wondering, with your downsizing, with your lowered enrollment with your extra space here and there, whether there MAY be some appropriately located space that we could, you know, separate from school board, you know, somehow, separate from school board space and make accessible to the public, that maybe rent from you, of course at a discount, given the services that we're providing you. So if that's something that is feasible or desirable on your part. I know you can't work it out today, if, if somehow word with get back to me, I would not proceed on this other plan, but for now going to proceed on this other plan until I hear from you? DR. Hepburn? yes, and you said you would pay for that space, yes, my team and I will get back. We're reviewing
036all available space sxz see if we have any spaces comparable to your needs. We'll follow-up. thank you, I appreciate that. So finally, members of the public, who MAY be watching, we are standing by. If you believe that you've seen or know of misconduct, or gross mismanagement by school board official, employee or provider, please contact us at our website broward ig.Org. We have a report misconduct page which you can find online forms very convenient. You can call us, on our anonymous hotline at 954-357-tips. You can email us at inspectorgeneral atatrorordrdrg. U can dropop by, noappoinent need tudaday throug thursday, 8:30 to 4:30 at 1 north university drive, the south suite. Or you can make an appointment to come in at another time during the week at 954-357-7873. On behalf of all of my colleagues at the
037office of the inspector general, we look forward to a long and cooperative relationship with the school board to helping you avoid and uncover mismanagement and misconduct and to improve your operations for years to come. Thank you. thank you so much. MS. Batista. yes, I just wanted to add that there is a also a link on the school board website that goes directly to the inspector general's office for anyone that would like to make a tip or complaint. thank you. Any public comment on this item? Okay. Thank you, MS. Leonardi? thank you. And thank you so much for coming and doing the presentation and thank you to my colleagues for accommodating my request for us to go through this workshop together I thought it was very informative. I just had a few questions about the presentation
038and ila. I know very early on you said that there were some circumstances in witness oig must or can disclose the name of the complaintant, what would those be? if the tipster or complaint were to waive the confidential, that can happen. if it was necessary in the course of investigation, for example if the tip had to do with the tipster and her or himself and there was only one person and we need to investigate the underlying facts, it can happen there. We have not had to trig thaer exception. And if a court would order us, we would. right. How about if an elected official was the complaintant, I know we're subject to a lot of laws. Is there a situation where? no absolutely not. The law in large part, large part protects the confidential of
039the source of the, the identity of the source of the information. You know, we can, we need the informer to help us with the investigation, we reach back, we might even have that person be a witness in our case and they would be known as a witness in our case but they won be known as the source of the information in the first place, official or not. got it, thank you. In the presentation, it identifies somebody submitting a complaint in good faith. Can you give me an example of how you determine that? If it's done in good faith? so we have not had that situation, member leonardi. But I can imagine that it could be a situation where somebody is absolutely out to get somebody else politically and ready to make statements that are not
040truthful, they know they're not truthful, et cetera, in that case, perhaps, that might be a situation where the confidencetial provisions would not apply but we have not made that determination nor has it been raised to us. got it, thank you. So mention some tips that you've already gotten about the school district. I'm wondering and maybe you answered this earlier, but would there be a report on the information, like we got these reports but guys that in the annual report. yes, we'll break down the toum tips and councilmember complaints came in. If we issued any memorandum or final reports, I doubt it I don't think we would have time between now and end of the fiscal year, but we would report the numbers for you, for sure. got t thank you. If somebody calls in and
041files a complaint and it's not something that the office chooses to investigate, is that person communicated to at all? yes. So one thing we did not reference, is we are accredited by the commission for florida law enforcement accreditation, this is a group that is set up by florida statute, that accredits law enforcement and inspect general office throughout the state. And there are a number, there is something like 49 standards by which we as an oig have to comply with in order to get and keep our accreditation, which we received in 2014, and just got reaccredited last year. One of the standard is that we must communicate with the stipulatester or complaintant within ten days of them having filed their investigation assuming they are reachable and if there is not exception to that requirement. got it,
042thank you. I had a question generally about some of your findings and the city of manner situation I thought was interesting, I believe I heard that from you all that, the park ing services vendor and the city came to an agreement like the money was recooped and all of that, is that a correct understanding of what happened? in the city of wilton manners as far as the resolution that they were able to reach were the two resolution that's were indisputable in the contract. One resolution was that dfs a deposit that city of wilton manners paid lien or and the agreement that lien or was going to be applying it to the first invoice in the contract. Here we are years later and that retainer was never returned so. When we started looking through the records,
043started looking at the contract and saw that that retainer was maintained by lien er and brought it to their attention, they immediately issued a credit, years later but they credited their account. The other resolution again, it was undisputable, in the contract they were suppose to sign over a vehicle, a particular vehicle it was never done. When we pointed it out, they went ahead and got in the department and took care of that. thank you. I'm wondering is that what is disputable in the investigation. Or do you see some cities or county then using the report to pursue legal actions against a contractor or some entity that they do business with to recoup funds? As happens in the manners case. The parties realize, oh we never did pay this, their right to ask us about it
044and they resolve those matters so we can report that they resolved the matters. at the conclusion of every report, where appropriate, we are also going to be issuing recommendations to the entities involved on how to improve their processes and their internal controls and to extent that those processes change and those controls are implemented by the time we issue our final report the entities want to get that credit and we're happy to give it to them because after all, it did result from our work. We do see, we have seen in one weighs, the old case out of west in, where a couple of landscapers had done some serious over building of the city. And the city was able to take that information, file a lawsuit and did recover several hundred thousands from the landscapers for
045that misconduct. okay, thank you for illuminating that. I think although this relationship is going to cost the school district money, it seems like perhaps it could save us money down the line and help create efficiencies so thank you for that. I just wanted to ask one more question, on the page where it says what are the terms of the ila? I just want, I was curious for who is included at the third built point, would that be, so it says the school board or superintendent appointed groups that are delegated authority or serve in one advisory role or the school board or superintendent. Would that be like our advisory committees? the way that we determine jurisdiction is if they are charged with decision-making so acting the instead of the board member so. If they're, that's one
046of the or appoint he's, but, that particular clause if they are kharnld with any kind of decision making for example, vetting through, resumes and discarding some resumes, then we go ahead and have jurisdiction. I'm wondering if our general council can speak to that. Would that be like the committee, looking at hiring and things like that? I would like some more specifics? MS. Batista? so we don't really have any committees looking at hiring other than when we talk about the superintendent, so this would not apply to regular hiring processes within the district where you have an opposition that is being advertise asked then there is a panel that interviews and vets, like the hr group vets the information. This would be more along the lines of what ms.Mac entire just alluded to where the committees where
047the board appoints members and those committees are making decisions that, you know, impact the district. For example, anything with competitive solicitation, evaluation committees all those members would be subject to the review of the inspector general. okay, so not the dac or those kind? right. thank you, thank you for clarifying that. Those are all my questions. thank you, MS. Thompson. I just had a question, you said you had some tips that would be unfounded but that would be within our jurisdiction, do you send that investigation to us, like the teacher? no, we don't send that investigation out. When we close our cases without published findings, the case is closed. We don't announce it, we don't publish it, we don't call anybody. And that's for a number of reasons including we might reopen it and any confidential
048that might be lost in the investigation any confidential that we had might be lost. It's also because there are all kinds of people with all kinds of motive who provide information to our agencies. And sometimes those motives are not great. And we understand that there are people who would file information that they knew to be sketchy, so that they can waive it around in the public against individuals who, you know, they want to attack. We are not in a position to make a decision as to whether somebody is ill-motivated or well-motivated, we're in a position to determine whether the information is true or not. And when we close the matter, we don't pass judgment on the source and we don't go out of our way to give that information to the source so that the
049source can use it for whatever reason he or she might want to. It's always available as a public record if somebody were to follow-up on the information that they have provided and they do, they can get that information or anybody, a subject if you become aware that our a subject of oig investigation that you believe is closed, you could make a public records request and we would provide all of those records to you, except for that which remains confidential which is the identity of the source of the information. so I just want to clarify why I asked, you taukds about a parent that was concerned about their 504, do you tell the stipulatester I recommend you tell the school board so make sure the students is receiving services they need. so we do inform individuals
050that we closed a matter or we followed up with it, when it comes to tips and complaints. Sometimes we're in a position where we can provide the reason why, but I don't think that is given as a matter of course. But MS. Mac entire is the ones that receives the calls and explains over the telephone the reason why something was no-action if it was no-actioned. is that something that you can start doing just direct it back to the school board? no, that's not something that we would do for you or any of the other entities within our jurisdiction. okay. okay, MS. Bulman. good morning. I just wanted follow-up, ms. leonardi kind of covered some of the things that I want today talk about, but in general, I'm getting a much better idea of what we're
051looking at here. In your experience dealing with other agencies, do you find that there is an abuse of this service? So you know, anybody can make a complaint, there is a good faith requirement that protects identity of people that are making complaints but in general, there is is there a good faith component to making the complaints? Not to disclose the identity but just to complaints themselves? Could I file infinite complaints without any real substance? And you have to investigate every single one of those? that's an excellent question. Because we, we do look at the motive of the informer, the stipulate -- tipster or the complaintant but even a person with an ill-motive could be providing and does provide good information which results in an investigation and findings of misconduct or gross mismanagement. As far as
052somebody who repeatedly provides bad information, we look at every tip and every complaint, however, if it's from the same individual and it turns to be 50 or 60 or 70 times or more and it does happen, we have a number of them, then, we take their information with a grain of salt. But we do look at every one of them. We don't close anything automatically because of where it's coming. We look to see whether or not there is still a basis for following up. that's all, thank you. DR. Zeman. thank you so much. I find this absolutely critical for our relationship with our public, earlier this year, we asked our demo graphers, we how many people were involved, 41 percent of our population directly involved and our relationship with them is predicated on trust, accountability
053and moving forward with things like this. It is nice to get this deck. Chair, I'd love to get these like a week in advance whenever we can, it's difficult to review such an important topic and in an hour come up with all the critical questions but I'm going to ask a handful. I'm going to list some people and I would like just yes or no if they're covered, are you ready? I'll do my beststr. Zeman. grereat pta. within provider no. volunteer advisors who don't have any policy obligations that would present themselves as decision makers? now you see, you're starting to get into school board have vanacular which I'm not familiar with. We're going to run it through council, and we're going to ask that lawyer, or one of our lawyers to go through the ila
054and make a determination as to whether or not they are or aren't within that definition. I totally appreciate. This is a question I would have asked a week ago if we would have had a week ago, I would have had an a-b list, it's critical for us to know tha. How much vend thaerz do before school or after school? MS. Batista. just wanted point out that you all have a copy of the ila, and on page 14 of that document, there is a list of inclusions and exclusions and specifically, you know, the school ally groups are excluded, ptsa, the pto, school advisory council all of those are excluded. thank you. Today is an opportunity to communicate to the public who does not read the ila and I want them to understand who is in and
055who is out. School -- . no. disputes with collective bargaining agreement subject to oig investigation? no. a vendor that offers before and after school board are they subject to investigation? if they're paid for by school district, yes. I'll bring, this is what we're going to be ask thed. When people say, who do we bring this to. And we need to know it. Broward ig.Org, a huge deal, we want people to understand to know how to report things that they've seen. I appreciate you sharing that today. The cases that you presented today, what were the consequences for the individuals involved besides just repayment and other kind of civil responsibilities? let me step back and explain, there MAY be expectations of what it is an inspector generals can do. And inspector general only ever have the authority
056to shine a light on a situation and let the decision-makers make their decisions. We don't recommend, discipline, we recommend procedure al changes, we recommend internal controls, but we don't recommend that somebody be suspended or fired, we don't have the authority to fire anyone, we don't have the authority to fine anyone and we don't have the authority to do anything other than to refer them for refer their cases to an enforcement authority that does have the jurisdiction to do something about it. and the cases presented there were no criminal prosecutions for behaviors? no. MR. Superintendent, how are we going to communicate the ig's ins and outs to our 3025 employees? DR. Hepburn? we have an awesome communication in marketing thing, so I'll let MR. Sullivan chime in briefly. But listening to all the information and get
057some clarity on next steps on this presentation, will help us understand what we need to communicate with the public at large. we can definitely share and come up with a plan and put it on all our channels. like MS. Batista indicated, it's already on our website. I appreciate that, I thought MS. Thompson had an interesting question, which is report to ig, you MAY click on that and if this is student services this is a number to call, if you're upset or whether or not your child has appropriate resource to see learn or things like that. To at least educate people that go through our website, it would be great to minimize the calls and inquiries that you get. So at least within our control, I'd ask to you consider doing whatever you can. In your
058deck, MADAM Ig, you MAY that info is not released while the investigation is open. I think what you said to MS. Leonardi's question, is all of that information, other than the complaintant's complaint is subject to request overtime. correct. does that include the people that participate in your inquiries? yes, sir. are they aware of that when they do it? I think people assume that the information that they're giving is public information and will become public information. terrific. Last point and I think it mate be one that we need to take into consideration overtime. You've had a number of complaints on the school board and we just got started. that's right. you've assumed three staff members and 11.3 million dollars a year for this course. We need to be prepared for that cost to go up. This
059is a group that in some sectors can be laticious, I believe it's the body that has the greatest impact on welfare of our community. And I'm not sure that three fde's is going to be sufficient to get these things done. Are there methods by which you can come back to ask for more staff and money. we plan to ask for more staff. The three that we're hiring now are get us through the end of the fiscal year. So in our budget request, we're going to be asking for funding for three additional to be hired sometime during the next fiscal year. what would that bring the cost. about 1.3 million dollars. so that's still, that's the annual that we start with. And six fde in the ballpark. that's right, plus, a percentage of those personnel within
060our staff whose work for the school board is intertwined with the rest of the work. For example, my work, MS. Mac entire's work, we're working on policies that affect all the work that we do including the school board's and you'll be a portion to part of our services as well. terrific. And I want to caution the board about one thing, we love data and we love accountability and the ig and we're tickled that it passed and we have you on board. The greatest impact of an ig will never be measured because it's people not doing the right thing. It's people who say, let me double check and I'm not sure, not that people always do wrong things with mal intent maybe they took over a job and somebody did it that way and they just
061keep doing that way. To the impact of ig a because they exist. And people know how to report things, and it's easy to report. And you quickly, kind of decide how far to go with public release of information about things that are given to you. We can never collect that data. Right? You can never find out about the good behavior that went on. But this is fundamental to us, building or rebuilding trust with our con constituents, I'm to glad we got this done. I don't think we could do it in two and that's credit to you and our general counsel for putting to together so quickly. But this is a big deal and I look forward to talking about this more often. And I also suggest that we not wait until the end of the
062year for reports, if we can modify our ila or come up with a friendly amendment where we can learn more about inquiries, the tips that are provided to you on more often than an annual basis that would be useful. Thank you for being here. Thanks for being here for us and for being an integral part of us doing our job. thank you, DR. Zeman. I just wanted to address which I failed to do in answering ms. thompson's question, and is that was that we do refer tipster sxz complaintants to other agencies on a timely basis, meaning we will refer individuals who have concern which we think is better than an another agency we will suggest. including broward county school board sdm if it includes a component of the school board, sure of an agency within
063your, within your human resources for example, the general counsel, who, you know, whoever would be responsible for handling that given situation. and I'm sure, because I think that's the opposite of what was said earlier. The opposite was if you have a tip it's not referred back to the school board. we don't refer it back to the school board. We suggest the tipster go back. yes, that's what MS. Thompson was inferring. Does that mean you MAY need amen ooh of things and menu of people that you can suggest the tipster go to? that would be helpful. do you have that yet? no. that's something that we can suggest, if you get a 504, you call student services, anything to mental health, call rebecca thompson. No? thank you, thank you for clearing that up. MS. Fam. thank
064you for coming forward and able to work with the school district, we do appreciate it and I know it's much needed. I have a few quick questions. I know you talked about keeping record and confidential, how about a complaint that is filed and withdrawn is that still part of the public record? so there is no way to withdrawal a complaint, once a complaint is filed, it's filed. A person can say, I'm withdrawing the complaint or I don't want you to act on it, we MAY act on it, without the complaintant but there is no real way to withdrawal a complaint. thank you. And another quick question, union official that's are also considered employees, on leave of absence, would they also be covered under the oig? employees and officials and providers by the charter providers but
065when we look at the conduct of employees and officials from any entity, we're looking to see whether they, whether they're alleged misconduct, or other behavior was related to their work or whether it reflects on their fitness to be somebody who who should be carrying out public business and receiving public money. For example f we were to have a city attorney get pulled over for a dui, maybe even involving an accident or injury, under the charter, we would have the jurisdiction, the authority to investigate the dui et cetera but we take it within the overall reading of the charter and overall understanding of what the public expects from us, that that is not something that we engage in. so I would say that, in the absence of more information, you know, what is the nature of
066the alleged misconduct by the union official? Would we investigate? We might. But it would have to have some nexus to their officialness. okay, thank you. thank you. MS. Rupert? and welcome. thank you. we're happy to you came here to the best and I'm going to do a shameless promo here, you chose bcps, we appreciate that. My question is is there a set daetd wlien if somebody was to report mismanagement, do they have a x-amount of time period or is there no cut off? no, there is no cut off. We will accept, we will accept old information but, with the understanding that number one, you might have a statute of limitations problem if you're looking at misconduct, number two, information that is old is often stale and as time goes on, like anyone who pursues investigations,
067civilly or criminally, evidence is lost, witness's memories fade, additional problems with oldle information. So of course we want information that is fresh but we don't, we don't have any kind of edict or rule or rule that says once the information is old, it's not considered. We don't do that. okay, and what if it was an employee that worked for us, but now has not worked for us for 7-10, 20 years, would that information still be looked at? for any providers, so we're. We're going to be concerned whether the conduct involved their work as official official or providers. But the discretionary part, the part where I get to decide whether it's something that we want to spend our resources on. That is something that we would be looking at for example. [Captioner switch] I think even
068a case against a former employee is super egregious and pretty recent, I don't think we would take it on. thank you, that's all the questions I have. Thank you to all my colleagues who asked the other questions. thank you, tr. Holness? -- DR. Holness. thank you for coming, I appreciate it. I also thank you for clarifying the concern that board member thompson had regarding if there's a tip that is not within the scope of your responsibility, you do not necessarily directly contact the school board but you encourage the tipster to do so, if the tipster doesn't follow-up for whatever reason with the school board in our case, what is the -- can we get access to the information through records request? you could, yes. The case would have to be over and then we would
069have had to -- well, I suppose you're interested in tips, just the information itself. correct. you could periodically request a report -- not the report, but you could periodically request the records involved. I understand, so the reason I'm bringing this up because of the mere fact that you don't necessarily direct us of any tip you receive but I think it would be within the district's interest to see what those tips are. If the tipster does not inform us, then as a board and I guess through the superintendent, maybe MS. Batista can respond the this, can the board periodically do a records request from the oig on any uninvestigated issues that relates to the school board so least we can have that information to determine if it's relevant for us and our departments to look into
070it? MS. Batista? thank you, MADAM Chair. So, the answer is yes, we can, if that's the will of the board, if the board would like me to proceed in that manner, I can periodically make requests from the oig's office for closed files they can can share with us. so, I would like the see if the board can give consensus for MS. Be t is -- batista can periodically -- MAY I be heard on this issue, chair? let MS. Batista -- yes, a couple of things, of course we would have to allow enough time for the ig's office to complete the investigation because those items would not be available toto -- until l their les ar closeded, that's numr r one.E. Numbertwo,rarely do we see someone that goes to the ig's office as their first path
071to a remedy. So, normally by the time that they are -- file something with the ig is because they have come to the school board, they have gone to their school, they have gone to all kinds of different places, they're unhappy on how things are proceeding and then they go to the ig. I don't know if that's normally what you see as well. Er it definitely is what we see. okay, so then I guess my other questioning is if in the rare occurrence they go to the ig before coming to us and we would not be aware of it if the tipster is directed to come back to us but did not and the irk g's office is not necessarily going to inform us of it, then the only way we could know that information
072exists is to do a request on any information issues issues with respect to the district to which we weren't privy to the information. Is that something we can do? did you want to -- yes, I did. Before you make this decision, I would caution you to appreciate that this could have a chilling effect on people coming to the ig in the first place you or someone else within the school board will be able to identify by the circumstances that they're presenting, by the nature of the information, etc., it's certainly a public record and available to you, but I would caution you to consider the fact that it might be chilling to someone who is in good faith seeking to remedy a situation that they see within the school board. DR. Hepburn wanted to chime in.
073no problem. I wanted to chime in because since I do agree with the oig where we don't want to dissuade anybody from providing information to the oig that would be pertinent for something that we need to address that's like some drastic issues we need to update, revise or make sure they're addressed, all the cases she referenced earlier that were submitted, we are familiar with, as MS. Batista said, that usually they're sending us information to the oig as a last resort to get a different decision for the regular knew wans we deal with, 504, ese, student discipline, things like that, I would caution the board as the public is welcome not to say we're going to pull public records from the oig because it's the larger issues that we don't want to dissuade people from submitting
074that MAY be of concern that we really need to dive in and correct that course of action moving forward. So, I know it's a delicate balance, DR. Holness, of wanting to get that informal, but many of the cases she's just referenced earlier, we're all familiar with those cases because they're e-mailing the school board too, they're copying the superintendent and in some cases, they're copying the governor, the oig's office and everybody, we're familiar with those cases, it's a delicate balance, I do not want to create an environment to have this independent arm to help us investigate and figure out what's going on so we can address them accordingly, I don't want to dissuade people from doing that, and we have the same issue with staff, we're figuring out a system so we can get anom mouse
075issues -- anonymous issues, we're trying to figure out a better way of getting anonymous information because folks feel will could be retaliation if they step forward and provide their names so we're in the same type of issue ourselves, so I would caution the board on that also. I understand that, MADAM Chair, can I finish up. I appreciate that feedback, I think it's well received. I didn't see it from that angle until you mentioned it so I will not be seek ago consensus on that but I appreciate the fact that as a board or individual board members, at any time there MAY be concern about any particular tipster, then you can do a records request but I don't based on what you said, it's not something that would be advised collectively as a board for us
076to engage in on a collective basis and I believe your advice is credible and well received. MADAM Chair, I'm good. thank you, I have two quick questions, and one is similar to MRS. Leonardi's question on what are the terms on the ila and who is included, on that third bullet, it says school board or superintendent appointed members of groups that are delegated decision-making authority which is what you said, but it also says or serve in an advisory role to one or more school board members, so we have school board appointed committees. There's 13 of them or so, so would they fall under this because they are -- they serve in an advisory role in that they have advisory committee meetings and they bring us recommendations for us to look at in terms of changing policy,
077so I read this as they would be included in who was included but that's not really what you said when we asked the question, so I just want to be really clear because I'm pretty sure the reason it was put in there is because the expectation was they were included but it's sounding to me like you're saying they're not. so, I just want to make sure I understand your question. You are asking whether we all understand about the decision-making authority. yes. the superintendent or school board member appoints somebody, not appoints but designating someone as their advisor on a particular committee, I would have to have more information with regard to which committee. there's 13 that are appointed by the school board. that's not something we struggled with but we went ahead and knew we needed
078to have more information for because we're not familiar with what each duty is, in a municipality, they have a whole plethora of boards as well, some boards have within its duties to go ahead and make decisions, some don't so it's going to be dependent on what particular person's role is, are they acting in the stead of the board member or the superintendent or is everybody purely advising, and we wouldn't know unless we know the person and the advisory board. I got you, what I'm tripping up on there is decision making 100% we understand but it says or serve in an advisory role. So, the fact you've distinguished or we have distinguished two different things, an advisory role is to give us recommendations which our school board advisory committees do, for example, the audit committee, right,
079they don't have decision-making authority but they do give recommendations to the school board about different audits or whatever that we follow through on, same thing with the ese advisory, like, we have some -- they're not decision-makers but they do provide recommendations has we act on, so, the fact that it says decision making or advisory -- this is a little unclear, so i understand you're going to look through it. Maybe you could give us a follow-up. maybe I can help, the language is in the ila, I think it is clear. It's either a decision-making body or serving an advisory capacity, if appointed by the school board or school board member or the superintendent. so, they are include. they are included. maybe we -- everyone else wasn't clear on the question because I think we were all
080added that and the answer seemed to be no, they weren't included but they are included so I want to be clear, the ones where we appoint school board or superintendent appoints someone specifically to a committee, they would be underneath the oig, you could investigate them? correct. And of course before we make any decisions, we will look will you the allegation, the person's role and the actual -- we wan to make sure we have jurisdiction before we move forward. perfect, I appreciate that, it was kind of muddled. My last question is on the termination process, it says any of the parties can terminate the xwraoement and I wonder since we have had to get a vote by the people, the residents of broward county, do they also if there's a termination process, does it have to
081go through a vote again or that's completely up to the school board and the oig's office? . Er it will be up to the parties. so, the charter amendment that the voters approved essentially says that a voluntary entity who -- so, if you are a constitutional officer of the county or the school board, you can voluntarily enter into an interlocal agreement with the county and the inspector general and if that doesn't exist, then there is no -- so, the voters just said we could come into the agreement if we wanted to, they're not saying we had to. that's right. thank you so much, we appreciate your time and explaining all of this. It is an important thing and we're very glad to have you, so welcome aboard. thank you very much for having us, we
082appreciate it and we appreciate your very thoughtful questions. thank you, and have a great day. thank you. okay, the next item up is the smartd program update. And I will now turn it over to staff for a presentation. while they're setting up, I want to be clear, is a member of the dac subject to oig? I would imagine yes because they're school board appointed based on the conversation we just had, we appoint someone to the can dac. we're going to recess the meeting for a few minutes to set up for the next presentation. (Meeting in recess). thank you, the next item is the smart program update. I now turn it over to staff for a presentation. good morning, I'll turn it over to MS. Paul and her team. good morning again, wanda paul, chief operations
083officer, to the board, MS. Hixon and superintendent hepburn, I have with me MS. Sonia coly who's our task assigned exec tier director of construction and so she will assist me in this presentation. I thank you for the opportunity to bring this information forward. Also as part of compile thirsting presentation, we have aecom and atkins realis who can help answer any specific questions. The goal is to provide the board an update on the current status and forecast of capital improvement projects, both smart and defp projects. You can see the table of contents, I won't go through that, it's structured pretty much like the previous presentations. smart by the numbers, 1.6 billion dollars, 65 billion dollars has been invested across all aspects of the smart program including safety, music, arts, athletics, technology, as you can see the
084status of the renovations, go forward. Sorry, we're having trouble with the clicker here. Let's see. Can we go back, please. The clicker's having trouble here. Denise? Okay, let's see. Okay. So, as you can see, smart by the numbers, 1.65 billion has been vested acssssall asaspectof t program including safety, sisic, art, athletics, renovations that are still in progress and technology. Next slide, please. As you can see, the focus of today's presentation is the r in smart which stands for renovations, as of DECEMBER 31, 2024, the smart program has 153 schools in act tier construction, a total of 68 media centers have been dieted to date. The 6 project ins the design phase are plantation middle school which addresses ada restrooms, athletic west, atlantic west which addresses restrooms also, lauderhill 6-er 12, steel magnet, again, ada restrooms,
085lauderhill 6-12, another project which deals with hvac, and north lauderdale elementary which also deals with ada restrooms. You can see the slides here commemorating some o the completion of the smart programs, the school choice enhancement program is complete. In addition, 230 schools received an additional 100 thousand dollars in funding as part of the school choice enhancement upgrades. Next slide, please. As you can see, this is a depiction of the smart update, the current budget of 1.55 billion. This slide provides a summary of 334 smart programs or smart projects, as you can see, DR. Zeman, we did address the scale, thank you for your input on that. Of the approximately 110 million unencumbered funds, million is pending construction contract awards and 70 million is in contingency inside the project budget. To date, we've spent 82% of
086the current budget. The next slide represents the summary of as of DECEMBER 31, 2024, for capital project that is are not part of the smart program, some of these projects are managed by the pmor and some are managed by the district staff. The breakdown of the spend, as you can see,, it shows how the smart program dollars have been spent so far for the 331 smart project and is the each of percentages each.Category represents. The program management figure improvers the program manageress, cost program control, building consult constructions since the inception tof program, design represents architect, engineers and any other consultants like geotechnical testing. Construction includes the primary contractor as well as other hard costs like furniture, it purchases or purchase orders. The economic impact of our certified emerging small veteran minority women business enterprises, you
087can see the number there I.'s reflective of 546.6 million in spend and committed funds that has been awarded to 79 district certified small business ins the tricounty market. This represents 40.71 of the program funds spent and commitment. In addition, you can see the prime and emerging payments that we've made, 1.3 billion representative it is actual spend of the smart program to date as reported, 447 million represents the total amount spent with the certified firms as reported in b2gnow, as of DECEMBER, 2024, that represents 43.39 participation. B2g just to remind you is the self-reporting system for monitoring data. it was implemented while the smart program was already under way and MAY be missing historical completed po's, the previous pmor which is hery, the data is inclusive of all activity ins the smart program, mam management design
088and construction. So, you can see the status of the renovations. These projects, a lot of discussion has been on three projects, originally it was four, we were able to move one off the list, these projects are bennett, north fork and broward estates and you can see in bennett, we have a remaining budget of 860k, north fork is 1.5 million and broward is 5.9 million, I think this was brought up at the previous discussion. The reality is that these dollars that are set aside for these three projects are not enough. These projects have been I think on the list since the inception of the program and it's not enough to take care of their needs. Two projects in process is in the process of hiring an architect which is for charles drew which deals with hvac
089and broad view which is ada restrooms, six project ares in design for ada restroom carve outs, two hvac carve outs and I can provide additional detail on these projects, the 4ada restroom carve outs for plantation middle, atlantic west elementary, north lauderdale elementary and lauderhill 6-12, the two hvac carve outs, atlantic west and lauderhill 6-12. One project is in the process of hiring a contractor, margate middle school, which deals with smart program renovations over 20 million, the school board awarded the general contracting contract at the JANUARY 2025 regular school board meeting so when you talk about a date of OCTOBER 2025 is sending the program, as you can see, these projects are still in development. And that's part of the challenge that we've had throughout this whole project. I think MS. Fam asked a question and
090it deals with the cadence of the program, so how the projects were organized and that has been a challenge along with some of the other challenges of fire devices and other things, so when we look at the complexity of what we're dealing with now, there is no simple answer to finishing the project by OCTOBER 2025, so I want to give you kind of a status of the renovations and the defp projects. These numberers are a snapshot of current will you active capital projects that are not part of the smart program so another added complexity is that you have the smart program and then you have defp projects intertwined that the pmor also manage, so it's not just a sanitized version of them dealing just with smart programs or the smart project. While they are not
091included in the board resolution as far as the completion of the smart program by OCTOBER 31, we wanted to give you the -- kind o a picture of some of the capital projects as we move towards having management of only the capital projects. So here is the big three update, we have northeast high school, you attended -- many of you attended the ribbon cutting of the new building in JANUARY. The next one is blanche ely, the primary scope of blanche ely is complete but we still have the renovations of the bus loop as well as some other items that we are working towards completing. And thep -- then a new old thing is stranahan calf tier wra, the kids are in a cafeteria, they are enjoying it, it's a beautiful building and let's be clear,
092it took way too long to get there but we're there and so we'll have a ribbon cutting, I think it's this week, so I hope you are able to attend that beautiful building. Major projects, we wanted to share two of the major projects we have in motion, parkway middle school, we have -- we're in negotiation with the design firm and that began the first week of FEBRUARY. It's going to the board in MARCH, where is DR. Holness, there you are, the solicitation to hire construction manager at risk will be continued shortly, rickards middle school, we've completed the interior of many of the buildings, it's still an active project for roofing. The gymnasium continues with duct work, insulation, and I give you detailed reports, probably too detailed. One of the challenges that I'm going to try
093to address with each board member is give you what you need so you can speak to your community in terms of where the progress is in your particular area, so we are working on that. We're also working to identify with the school administration timeframes to host community meetings to also keep the community in step with what's happening in the buildings. We do brief the principals and give them updates but I think we need to move also towards community updates as a part of the regular plan. When a construction highlights, you can see that, one of the things we have to take into account is to take those opportunities when kids are not in a building to do as much work as possible. We have 153 schools in active construction that received critical upgrades that were
094completed by the start of JANUARY the 6th, so we worked really heavily with aecom and our contractors to make sure that happened. We are still working to receive certificates of occupancy. They were finished on schedule during the winter break so that was a plus. We are also focusing on cut cal electrical and hvac related improvements. Rest ram -- restrooms and renovations as well as window replacements. Overall, this highlights the management of construction and taking advantage of those critical times, as I said before, when kids are not in the building, that's when we need to do the lion share of the work during the school year. Then have a video that we want to show you which is the highlight of the winter construction that took place. Click that. (Watching video). the next slide speaks to
095change orders and it demonstrates the five change order categories and how much we've spent over time over the life of the program. tax savings is what we get back from the general contractors through the direct owner purchase program. We don't have to pay taxes on the materials when we canting with the supplier directly for purchases over 20 thousand, so every time we have an opportunity o do that, we will, it saves us money. Owner requests are currently a net credit because they have been quite a few cases of work being removed from the project because it is no longer required. A lot of the efficiency for the program is working hand in hand with our ppo department to try to spaoem up system of the minor projects if possible and has tha has helped quite
096a bit in the 7 or 8 months I have been here. Consultant error, consultant omission are mistakes that the architect and engineer made on the plans which is common, that happens. It's impossible to have a perfect set of plans, as much as you work towards that, and the added cost is the premium for these change orders because plans were not in the original bid to the gc, so a lot of this is -- and this is kind of how the complexities of the program and kind of how the sausage is made has created some delays in the program, but again, you know, this is where we are right now, this is where we find ourselves right now and then we have this thing called unforeseen conditions and I want to talk a bit about that.
097It's like you have a project and the project is to paint the wall and when you look at the wall, you see growth or something on the wall. You have to see what that growth is, you take the wall out and then you find out that there's a leak behind the wall that to the naked eye you don't see, so that's something that was not caught, very difficult to catch in many cases, that's an unforeseen condition. You can't just paint the wall, you have to fix the problem, the root cause of the problem, it could be a pipe burst behind the wall or whatever the scenario is. That is considered an unforeseen condition, that wasn't in the contract the contractor signed so we have to go through the process and make sure we update the
098design and that we pay the contractor appropriately to repair it, not only to repair it but to paint it. So, oftentimes when you see on a time impact analysis sheet, it's not just about the whole period of time that the project took, part of that is a percentage of what the unforeseen condition is and so we've had some of that and because this is such a long program, the total amount of change orders MAY be a large number but it represents and I think omar showed it in a bond oversight 709 page book that it's under 2%. And so that is the industry standard as we've said, I think at least two other times that I briefed you is between 8 and 14 percent so we're well below that, but that is not -- that
099does not mean we lose focus on the fact that it exists. So, we will continue to monitor that. Let's look to the projected look ahead for OCTOBER 31, 2025. And DR. Zeman, my birthday is OCTOBER 30th, so, I mean, you know, you could have done that, you know, we could have had a celebration OCTOBER 30th, so let me move on. The program forecast, okay, so as you can see, you have seen this slide before. We have 35 projects active, 296 substantially completed and three schools that i mentioned before that will be rolled into the long term plan. The long term plan is the capital plan is the defp. So, I want to make that connection. The three projects being discussed, bennett, north fork and broward, when you look at complete, that means the school or
100that the students are already in the space, so we're still working towards final close-out and any warranty activities that MAY be included. Projects pending further discussion, many of you, the board members, have asked about these three projects. We removed glades middle school because as I said previously, our ppo department was able to take care of those minor activities there, so we removed that from the list and that project is being closed out. Bennett, north pork -- fork and broward estates, these buildings require a lot more, they're older r ildings,s,they rereirirlot more than was scopopedout soso ththe a a wiwi help us understand those three schools better. And in terms of what their needs are. The next slide represents projects that we project to be rolled boo the defp, currently the list contains 35 projects but
101again this is a moving target because our intent is the close out as many as possible and to be aggressive in those close-outs, so this number -- the expectation I have is that this number will go town. And I explained to you previously some of the complexities that we are dealing at the end of these projects, part of that that was talked about was the need for additional fire devices, some of that deals with not meeting the specifications that are required for us to close out the projects which deals with the building code department. We'll do a presentation of the building code department about some of their work a little bit later into today, but my expectation is that that number will continue to go down of the 35 projects but this is where we
102are right now at this moment in time. And the southbound page gives those projects too and I will do an mewing -- I will continue to talk to the board at board workshops and provide information to you on a regular basis to tell you where we are in the smart program and as we move towards the capital program. To continue to have that conversation with you as well as with the community. The next slide shows the capital projects, defp projects, we are projecting to have ten active projects by OCTOBER 31 that these projects were managed by aecom and then on the next page, you can see those ten projects. Of note, building one, james rickards middle l school and coral glades high school auditorium and the new addition at parkway middle school, so those are
103projects that were paid by capital projects that will still be ongoing. Next slide, the path forward. So, one of the things that I wanted to speak to you about were opportunities and how we move forward from this program and so there are three or two things here, enhance the relationship with the business community and proactive and thorough planning. One of the things I mentioned in the previous presentation regarding the bond oversight was planning. You know, you have to do very thorough planning at the start of the program, it's very difficult to do it on the tail end because you've already lost that time. But I wanted to highlight the business excellence program. We had during the course of the program, we had 40 guest panelists, 800 attendees and 258 graduates, so this initiative was to
104increase engagement with the community and it also creates an at mot fear of collaboration with our local business community. DECEMBER 5 we graduated 258 small businesses and aspiring business owners. This was the first year of the program and the goal of the six part training series was to elevate and empower and connect small businesses on the journey and growth and impact, so this goes back to what I said before about building a firm foundation. We need to build that foundation with our small businesses as part of how we move forward. Next slide. Strengthening business partnerships. Local is imperative that we continue to foster that relationship, having a targeted outreach and engagement communications program will help us. As part of their normal business, eddc host as monthly brunch and learn series for small businesses in training
105and access to resources. We host quarterly industry specific match maker events to broadcast specific procurement opportunities and then we have currently we have events scheduled in 2025, we will continue that program. Coaching and development helps us build capacity to do the work in a district. it provides -- we also provide certification assistance and again the coaching workshops. In a large organization, it's hard to break the code to do business and this is how we want to do it moving forward. Next slide, I'm going to turn it over to MS. Colie that is leading the facility condition assessment and give her an opportunity to speak to the board. good afternoon, good morning, sonia colie, so through proactive planning, the facility condition assessment which is currently under way is going to assess the state of the schools
106and identify areas needing repair and upgrades or replacement. With that, the long range planning and steering committee, we will have more business minded experts that will provide guidance and direction which is very essential to the development of a comprehensive plan that will address the schools' future needs. Proactive and thorough planning supported by the long range steering committee is crucial for the schools' projects. And working together, we can ensure the educational facilities meets the needs of our community. As stated, we're again as of JANUARY 30, 2025, our vendor bureau veritas has completed more than site visits on more than 85 schools, we are actively coordinating with key departments, ppo, our fire department, building department and n a collaborative effort to ensure we seek input from every one school administrator, we sent out questionnaires post and presurvey
107questionnaires for them to answer, so we can capture all that data within the fa assist condition assessment, in addition to meeting with our external consultants, our roofing assessment consultant, our structural consultant to ensure we have a comprehensive report. okay, I'll talk about vendor evaluations. They're ongoing and serves as a way to assess how architects and contractors are performing the work, so this is the accountability piece that I feel has been lacking in the program. You can see the numbers in terms of the average score. The scores are shared with the quality selection evaluation committee to provide insight on the firm's quality and capacity to take on new projects. So, the next slide deals with the management of remaining projects. So, many of you asked me how do we move forward. Once our program management team
108leaves. So, I've showed this slide before, so we have three approaches, internal, hybrid, external, you can see the strengths and weaknesses of each one. One of the things that is acutely aware to me from reading grand jury reports and other documents during the time I've been here is I think the district gave up too much control of the program. At the end of the day, the district is responsible for the success of the program and when I read certain documents and I see where projects have just sat for years. As I said before, there's really no way to recover that time. So, that will be a lesson learned and I'll dive into that with the board members in future meetings. So, we are in a situation right now whereby we have to transition away from
109the pmor and I'll come back to you with recommendations next month. Our contract with pmor ends in JULY of this year, so I'll come back to you next month with recommendations in term of our next steps. As I said previously, the approach that I would like to recommend to the board and of course to the superintendent is the hybrid approach. I think that as a district, we should not give up that kind of control. One of the weaknesses that we have internally is just staff, over the years, the construction department has been reduced and I think that in order to effectively manage a substantial capital program that we need to the look at adding additional positions. So, dwen, my recommendation is the hybrid approach. I will come back to you next month at a workshop
110and tell you kind of what that looks like. I want to make sure that as we go forward and move away from the smart program and move into the capital program, that we are not caught flat footed again. You know, the fca is a great tool but it's about the execution of what you see in an fca and how you manage the program. And so in my experience, it is unprecedented to move from one pmor to another pmor within a bond program, so, as we learn and I'll bring lessons learned back to you and I'm sure many of you have experiences that you've seen from your perspective with this bond program, I'll bring back lessons learned and how we can get better, I will ensure you we will get better, we will improve but this
111program just from its onset has been complicated throughout and so one of the things I want to do moving forward with my team is simplify it to make it understandable to our community. There were like countless missed opportunities here from the very beginning. I want to make sure we don't make those same mistakes going forward, so that's pretty much the presentation and definitely I'm open for questions and input as we go forward. thank you, thank you so much. Any public speakers on the item? Okay. Thank you, before we go to board member questions, I just wan to remind everybody, I know this is a very hot topic, we by policy and by an agreement from the board are limited to ten minutes for the board answering questions, so MR. Hill is going the make sure
112he stops the clock, we do have a time certain at 4:00 today so we want to make sure we're cognizant of the time we're spending and don't get upset when it beeps because we've agreed to the ten minutes. With that, we'll start with MRS. Rupert? thank you, and I will have it done in in ten minutes. you talked about the bond programming needing a heavy lift in the the beginning, absolutely, the information that would have been helpful for us was not available and my one question in the very beginning when conversations began was the number one question is how are we going to implement this and what I was told, don't worry about that, we need to push back and make sure that it gets past first, I said we're going to take 8 months
113doing that and it will get passed ask then what, then what happened? When staff was asked by me what was that information back, add toing the ever revolving door of facility chiefs, that would have not happened with MS. Paul. I appreciate our staff and students not being after hinged by the loud and messy projects but I wanted to highlight pages 22 and 23 in the powerpoint for item 3. And when you add up those items, I want you to look not with the eyes of somebody who has rose colored glasses but the eyes of somebody, staff, community members, children sitting in buildings dripping, moldy, those are things that happened and there were many points along the way that it could have stopped but it was not. And from my perspective and I was here, I
114was there, I felt and this page will show that time after time, it is very striking to see that the 35 projects rolled into the defp, district 1 had three of 35, district 2, zero, district 3, five of 35, district 4, five of 35, district 5, 8 of 35, district 6, one of 35 sx, -- and who was the most vocal person at the time who has a lot of the eastern communities, district 7, 13 out of 35. So, if I did my math right, it's about 37%, that's what happens when you speak up, that was before, that is not now. I have full confidence in the superintendent and my colleagues and our new staff to be able to right this ship. What I believe the failing program was for was to silence people and
115employees and honestly it was very chilling and it did happen. What I can say is it was not -- makes my hand shake talking about this, it was not pleasant to go through because we were letting our kids down, we were letting our employees down and our community down again and there's no way these projects don't get done on these new dates and I am sure MS. Paul is going to be able to grab the reigns and be able to do things right because I'm impressed so far what she's been doing with her staff, and DR. Hepburn, kudos to you, up front, accountable, transparent and honest, I'll end with that, thank you. I told ya. thank you, DR. Holness? thank you, MADAM Chair. And MS. Paul, thank you for that wonderful comment on parkway middle,
116I'm looking forward to MARCH 11 to be able to happily vote yes and moving forward with it. So, some of my concerns here has to do overall with the unfinished work before and after contract ends, the accuracy of the information and any transition plan that's in place and what that looks like. I did express concerns through a board member request regarding scope of work, the status of the work and targeted completion, I believe that's forthcoming, I haven't received that a as of yet but I'm sure that will be coming sorely. I orely -- shortly. Projts status as of DECEMBER 31, and today's FEBRUARY 11, has the projection changes regarding how many projects will remain unfinished? DR. Hepburn? MS. Paul? through the chair, so, I get a list of projects at the beginning of the month,
117middle of the month, well, every meeting every week, and I track with my team where those projects are and if they will be at substantial completion on the last day of the month and if they fall out, I work with aecom to tell me why they fail out and a lot of the reasons that I see are projects at the end. We have as was stated previously additional fire devices. If it's one or two or three or four, that's not a big deal, but when we start dealing with 20 and 30 and 40, we have to go back to design and that causes additional time. At's onene example. Ananheher exame e coulbe that the contractor put in the wrong type door, even though the plans -- these are real examples, even though the plan calls
118for a certain door, they ordered the wrong door so that adds time, is we -- so we have these one-offses that occur in our projects, another challenge has been some of our subcontractors that are not doing what they say they are supposed to do. When I first got here, we had challenges with pay and paying contractors on time, so we've improved on that but there are some things that is are in litigation. I meet with MR. Kuni every week, he h e's part of our meetings every week to talk about litigation and those things that we are calling for the bond or the surety on some of these contractors because they're not doing what they said they were going to do and what they are contractually obligated to do and that is a change that
119has not been exercised in this program over the ten years. We bring them to the table, we tell them we're serious about this and in many cases, the contractors go back to work and do the work. In some cases, it is going to be a legal issue. So, we work through these things, these challenges every single week and we look for the best path forward to complete the project. So, that's again things that happen behind the scenes that are not in the public view, but as I said before, our intent is to be very aggressive in closing out these projects and reducing the number that will carry over boo the capital plan, -- into the capital plan so that's our focus at this point. okay, MS. Paul, I appreciate that response. And how do you
120normally receive project updates and do you believe the project data is accurate in your professional judgment? And have you or your team independently verified these projections? so, I doubt everything quite honestly. We work with aecom. I think my staff has a better perspective because obviously some of them have been here a lot longer in the district. The aecom we have today is no the aecom that we had previously, so I work with mike mcintyre to -- I feel like it's like forensic study if you watch csi sometimes because you know just trying to get o the root cause of why the project isn't moving forward. We to that every week. So, in terms of trying to give you a percentage of what I think is accurate, I think the majority of the information is accurate
121but we have those moments where questions lead to why did this, why did this and then I go into the forensic mentality and sonia in many cases goes out on site, her team goes out on site, if there's a disagreement between us and aecom, the team shows up at the building, example, stranahan cafeteria, to make sure we don't accept something as a district that is below standard. okay, so would you say then that oftentimes your team independently verifies the projections? if we have questions about something and the team typically looks at this during close-out, so the team consists of nathan would've behind me, the fire code official perla, who I think is here somewhere, not yet, she'll be here in a minute, building code, they go out, so one of the things I think that
122has changed with this is that we're a lot more aggressive in questioning things and making sure that the district that the community gets what we paid for. The delay in stranahan cafeteria was because we would not -- this lady right here as well as myself would not accept that cafeteria floor the way it was and sometimes you have to draw that line in the sand and put the stick in the mud and say we're not doing this. So, we've had some cases where that just didn't happen. We worked with tom kuni, with MR. Mcintyre and his staff to make sure we're all on the sheet of music, we're going in the same direction, it's not good for us to say one thing as a district and for pmor to say another thing and for our
123inspectors to say another thing, so I have a weekly meeting that involves revenger that can involve a project. MS. Paul, can you expound on what the role of atkins is in this whole process in terms of budget and scheduling? well, so, atkins does not control the master schedule. When I bring their contract back in MARCH or APRIL but I think it's MARCH, I want them to control the master schedule. Part of my concern with this program is I don't do squishy and times those are the dates that keep changing, so that's why I want to put that in the control of atkins. Atkins in myen since I've been here and then based on my staff has done an outstanding job on the financial side of the house. I want them to control the master schedule.
124so, what is their current role in the whole process? they do the financials and ashley, if you want to speak to that, you MAY. Not to put you on spot. ashley carpenter with atkins realis, the role that my company company is performing here for the sdrik ask the way we serve the program is in the cost and program control, so as MS. Paul said, related to budgeting, forecasting and risk assessment related to the financials of the program overall and as well as the capital program, and then also in terms of administering the program management software, so e-builder, it's changed names, it's now trainable unit construct, but e-builder is the software by which all of the work flowers for the program so really helping the program to move forward by streamlining and automate ago lot of
125the various processes, so most everything in construction and design and now goes through these different work flows which have helped to really increase the volume of things that can happen in a month, right, so when receiving happening electronically and it's -- nothing's in paper anymore, it's easier for everybody to process more items so that's also helped. Then I have cost estimators as well, not just budgeting and forecasting for the company but estimating projects when they're in design, doing change order review that is are over 25 thousand dollars, trying to think what else the team does, but yeah, it's mostly in those three areas. okay, I appreciate that, and MS. Paul, you mentioned that atkins doesn't have access to the master schedule and based on your response that you feel that this would be relevant to
126their responsibilities in the future, is that what you mentioned? yes, but also I think -- I don't want to mislead the board, we wounding in concert with atkins with aecom, we all work together but one of the things that I think going forward that would improve the program is to put the master schedule under atkins. okay. And I have some more questions. What is the total cost for the 45 projects that are projected to remain active and this is past OCTOBER of 2025, correct? yes. Do you have that number, the 35 projects, I think it's on the slide though. Give us just a moment. sorry, a lot of slides, so on slide 24, the project budget is the first column with the cost, so those 35 projects add up to a total project budget of
127255 million, but that's why we added the second column just to kind of say most of that money -- well, about 80% of that money will be spent, we're rioting that about 88% of that money will already be spen so there would be a remaining balance to spend in those projects of about 58 million. Tla's just based on a formula, it's not super scientific but just to give you an idea that a will the of those projects particularly where you see projects with the projected completion of DECEMBER 2025, we're looking at a project that's almost done, so most of the money will already be spent. okay. Thank you very much, I have some additional questions, MS. Paul. I know that aecom's contract will be expiring in JULY and I know that there were conversations regarding
128an extension to OCTOBER, so will aecom be proposing an extension to OCTOBER, are we to expect that forthcoming or where are we as a board so we're not taken off guard ta tha there's no extension being proposed and then we end up with having to figure it out going forward. so what I'll bring to you is three options, one is to do it external, one is to do it internal and one is to do it a hybrid approach. The external would be to do an rfp for another pmor, internal would be to staff up and if I were to try to staff up internally to that amount, then I would have to more than likely extend aecom's contract by at least three months but no more than six months to do that. And again the
129-- I think I mentioned staff augmentation which is my preference which is the hybrid approach, I would piggyback off of an existing contract on a crack, due value has an existing contract, I would pick gi back off of them for three months and then do the rfp for either staff -- for staff augmentation and for another pmor, so I want to be able to give you different options so that you don't feel like you're boxed in a corner of it, but again my recommendation is to do a hybrid approach where we staff up as we need those particular skill sets, if we're not using those skill sets, we don't pay for them. So, one of the things when you look at project management, you look at the staffing part of it and at certain times,
130you need more than others, and what I've looked at throughout this contract is where I have not seen that movement where, you know, it's been kind of a flat number throughout and I take pause with that and so I want to be able to control the number of people that we have on the project as opposed to being fully staffed when there are less things in the queue for work, so we need that flexibility is what I'm saying. so, MS. Paul, you mentioned those three options and my impression was those three options would be upon aecom leaving, correct? yes. well, yes. and my impression on that was that should aecom request an extension to OCTOBER as we had originally talked about, then the three options that you are proposing and being in favor of the
131hybrid option x that would come subsequent to aecom leavening, whether it's JULY or OCTOBER, so my question is regarding -- does aecom intend to provide a proposal for extension to OCTOBER or they're not. And if so, if they made a decision, I think it would be important for the board to know in time because JULY is around the corner, so I guess my real question first of all and I praoesh information you shared but are they intending on having a proposal, if they're not, that's when your suggestion of the three options and choose thing hybrid would come into effect, so we don't know whether that's JULY or OCTOBER. I think they're interested in an extension based on a meeting and let me tell you what the process is, I'm sorry I haven't done it yet,
132we have started transition meetings with aecom, so, basically detailing the process of aecom transitioning out. So, that has already started. i think wre ear -- we're into the third pelting of that part of that transition out, if they were to transition out is whether they would -- whether there would be an extension for three months or an extension for six months, right, that's part of that plan. I think it's important that we look at doing an rfp that addresses whether we have staff augmentation or/and another pmor. The piggybacking off of the duvall prakt would allow us a transition time too, we could use that contract to continue the work. One of the issues that I'm concerned about is the summer is the best time to do a lot of the work so I don't want
133us to jeopardize the summer. And so that is why we started the talks already and the conversations and the meetings for transition. okay, and I appreciate that but as a board member, one of my major concerns and I appreciate the conversation taking place, we're in FEBRUARY, at some point, I believe we would need definitive information that aecom is going to extend or not extend and -- well, that is really up to us as a board or you as a board in terms of if you would be receptive to aecom extending, and I need to bring that to you so you can have that conversation. okay, so I know we had the conversation, MS. Paul, before, I remember, I don't remember how long ago, but we know the contract expires in JULY. We had a conversation
134I believe DR. Zeman mentioned we need all the work done by OCTOBER, 2025, we talk abit -- abit -- about it as a board, I think the expectation would be there would be some proposal for extension that would be forthcoming by aecom, if not, we need to have a plan of action in place that would take us to our OCTOBER completion deadline and I'm a bit confused because I am not -- it seems very gray where we are at this time because we don't know if aecom is going to present a proposal for extension and if they're not, I am not sure I'm clear of a transition plan and if they are, I think we still need a transition plan beyond OCTOBER, so where I feel like we're in sort of a gray area that
135I'm not comfortable with because we have the deadline of the contract, the expiration of the contract coming up in JULY, so, when can we receive a definitive answer as to whether or not there will be a proposal coming forth from aecom for an extension because this board has already had the discussion that we would like to have an OCTOBER completion timeline and I know you mentioned 35 projects might be beyond that, it could be less as you mentioned, so we had the discussion as a board and now my concern is, is aecom coming forth with a proposal and if they intend to, when can that be worked out so we can have it? Jts I believe we have mike mcintyre here, if you can address that, mike. board members, superintendent, mike mak tire, we are
136in discussion widths our partners presently on what the options and opportunities are, as soon as the partners in aecom make a determination, we will let the board know, hopefully we'll be finalizing something in the next couple of weeks but we do have ongoing discussions. so, I am hoping that information will come forth soon because we're looking at a JULY contract expiration and I think as a board, it's responsible on us to really have a plan of action in place should there not be a proposal for extension and should there be, then that would be great, then we have more time to determine a plan of action beyond OCTOBER but we don't have a lot of time if aecom should decide not to prprenena proposal for extension and d so I am hoping, .. Ininty,, thathahat
137foformation will be forthcoming very soon because I think it would enable the board to move forward in a responsible way. understood, we are working through it, aecom and its process, it will be a group decision on what we believe is in the best interest of everybody. Hopefully within the next couple of weaklings, -- weeks, we will have a proposal put forward. okay, thank you very much, and my last concern and I still have two minutes, board member hixon, I have ten minutes, correct, okay, thank you so much, so where the concerns that I have, I think it's important for our superintendent to have a transition plan to include aecom's involvement in the transition, whether that's JULY or OCTOBER, and so I would like to direct the superintendent to present a transition plan hopefully sooner than
138later to include aecom's involvement in the transition moving forward. DR. Hepburn? I just want to -- for clarification, MS. Paul, I know you're bringing an item next month, correct, and this is going to speak to the transition to give the board options about to come to consensus about specific next steps, so that could include aecom or a piggyback pmor, so I would suggest we wait until the next workshop that we have planned for all that information abhow we transition and what's the best option to move forward. and DR. Hepburn, based on your best judgment, do you think that the time we will have information pertaining to aecom's intention beyond JULY? we're hopeful. Right, mike? we're hopeful. yes, we'll xlaoun kate with MR. Mcintyre. thank you, that's all my questions. thank you. Next is MRS. Alhadeff.
139thank you. Where do I begin? I guess I'll begin from the beginning. 2014, this is when the smart bond started, it was supposed to be 8 million dollars, as we are aware, there was core planning, lack of a planning needs assessment, alright, now fast forward, 11 years later, we're at 12.9 billion, is that correct? I'm sorry? for the smart bond. 1.6 billion. I need my glasses. I would have appreciated 12.9 billion. [Laughter]. alright, and we have an amazing superintendent with amazing staff getting us moving in the right direction. So, I think it's a great idea to come up with a transition plan. You know, we're paying aecom millions of dollars throughout these many year and is I'm sure in the next cup ofl weeks before we workshop, they can come to you, DR. Hepburn, with
140a plan, but then ultimately you're going to make the best decision to propose to us the school board what that plan looks like. The other thing is on page 29, the path forward, I thought this was a crucial piece. As we know our enrollment projections are decreasing and we are trying to redefine broward county public schools. I know we are trying to live up to the promise of 2014 but I do believe that this board needs to figure out in an aggressive manner, when we were supposed to be closing five schools or more and now that got morphed into something different, we need to -- so this says on page 29, the comprehensive identification of facility needs, the facilities condition assessment, so that assessment is supposed to be our guiding light in the sense of
141how we as a board figure out what is the best way to redefine broward county public schools. And I think it's very difficult -- like, I don't want to see us putting millions of dollars in a school where we're going to decide to hypothetically lease that space or we're going to close that school and demolish that school. Again, and I know it's very difficult but -- and these are difficult decisions the board has to make, we have to be aggressive in our plan of action. I know there's a phase 2, probably phase 3 of redefining broward county public schools, and I just again don't want to make another bad decision and I don't want to waste millions of dollars of taxpayers money, so I guess what I'm saying, DR. Hepburn, is that I would tliek
142see something to come to this board in the MARCH meeting as far as what that transition plan looks like because to DR. Holness' point, JULY will be here before you know it and when these things get legal, things get wrapped for month and is months and months goipg back and forth with lawyers and there's delays, right, but ultimately, JULY's going to be here and we need to have a plan, plan of action, and if we don't, again, we're going to waste millions and millions of dollars and who's ultimately going to be affected is our students and our schools, so I think the board really needs to vote on something in MARCH, in the MARCH meeting but also again this needs taob comprehensive approach with our redefining plan, this cannot be in silos, meaning we cannot
143just try to fix 2014 decisions here in 2025 when so much has changed and I'm optimistic with superintendent hepburn leading this district in a positive way and doing our best for broward county schools. great feedback, you're in the right vain of the thinking we have, the fca completion of that comes at an opportune time for and you say we will share wit the board which will be in the initial phases of redefining phase 2 that will help us assist with some decision making that we'll have to make around our schools and where do we go from there. And the MARCH meeting is about providing as much comprehensive information to the board so we can make the best decision possible before a vote on how we mao f forward if it's hybrid, if it's not a
144hybrid solution. More to come. okay, thank you, and just to clarify, if the board can weigh in on my comment, I would like the see something in the MARCH meeting for the board to vote on. DR. Hepburn, was that what -- vote on specifically on the different -- no, I was -- I want to clarify on the vote. on what you're already bringing to us. so, if I MAY, the intent is to have a workshop and then a board meeting to vote. will both of those happen in MARCH? that is the intent, yes, ma'am. MS. Alhadeff x does that satisfy? as long as we execute something in an agenda item in a school board meet ining MARCH. DR. Zeman? did you want consensus on that? it sounds like they're already bridging it forward. I want
145to come back to your comment that you made because it kind of gets back to I think is like a massive issue that we as a board need to think about. Can anybody on this board provide me any evidence right now that we do a better job in construction and facility management that we did in 2014? No evidence. Evidence that we have. It's critical we know that, it's critical we're able to talk to people about that. What we get in presentations is incredibly useful, it's far better organized we've seen in a long time but I keep asking about this critical board presentation that we get that gives us the evidence and the facts that we can go back to our community and our constituents and our county commissioners who have to approve a bond overly
146and everyone else you want to talk to and say we're getting better. Here's the projects getting done, going to a ribbon cutting, we have gone to ribbon cuttings, whether the project takes three years or six years, there's a ribbon cut x on critical construction metrics, can we get a board format that comes back to us that says there's the everyday, now I can talk to my neighbor and to the mayor and talk to people in the county commission, leaders in our community and say give us some time, we've already turned the tide and we're getting better, that'sing what I'm looking for, we had it 20 years ago when I ran a construction project, I know we can do it, it's something that I think we need those fatsoes as school board members so we can
147fulfill our obligations. I wanted to thank DR. Holness for asking for the data you asked for. I'm going the ask an extension of that question. How many active questions will be between JULY 1 and the end of the smart project on OCTOBER 30th maybe or 31st of 2025? DR. Hepburn?Frnlts MS. Paul? what we have now is 35, that's the number as we stand right now. So, I really am thinking somewhere, you know, maybe ten less. I meant projects, defp and smart. The reason is we're talking about organizations and pmo resigner's, how many project wills we have between JULY 1 and the end of 2025? DR. Hepburn? I don't have a number because we're going to have a lot because we have ppo that are doing projects, we have the 10 that are in the defp,
148plus we have the predicted anywhere from 25-35, so we're goipg have quite a large number of projects that will be ongoing throughout the defp. speaking of defp and capital pros, how many of them are under pmor? I believe there were 10. and to help my colloguing think about pmor, how are these projects assigned to the pmor? so, my understanding is that the enormity of the project that is too much for our ppo to handle so the large dollar projects that could be more efficiently handled under pmor. so, if I can characterize your answer, pmor get it is more complicated projects that can go beyond. rickards, would's responsible for managing those? those are under the pmor. thank you, and just to clarify what you said, you think even though there's 25 on the list that will
149extend beyond the smart deadline, you think some of those might come back in before the deadline and that number will go down. it's 35 projects that as we stand today that are on the list, of those 35, some have moved in and out, so it's a constant flow based on what's required based on inspections, based on just the complexity of the project, so it's 35 now. I in concert with aecom and my staff think it will be a few less but it won't be zero. terrific, just so my colleagues know this well, what percentage of the overall pmro contract is awarded to aecom for their services? I'm going to go to ashley. Give us a moment. Yeah, sure. mike mcintyre with aecom through the chair, the aecom contract we are one of five and our
150contract value last year was 20%, our contract if we were to have another year, it would be 25% and the rest is split between our partners, so in the end, we are in the middle of those that collect fee on our contract. terrific, but that other 75%, 80% minority owned, women owned local firms and the like, so just when we say aecom to DR. Holness' point, they are 20% or so or 25% of the overall contract, there's 75% or 80% that are other firms. I want to take a break too though and compliment DR. Hepburn, MS. Paul, there's one small thing that you did that is important to this board which is you have made it very clear that you need experienced construction and building experts to be involved in our long term plan. Thank
151you for that, it's a see change in broward county to make that citifying and I look forward to see who will participate on that effort going forward. Chair, I really don't know how to make sure this gets done, so I'm going the ask whether or not you have consensus or you would like the gain consensus on that dashboard for the school board, so that we can talk to people and say we've already turned the tide, we're going to keep turning the tide ask that we keep that going roughly on a quarterly basis from now until we go ask for the next bond, until we get the next bond, until we have not just confidence because I have great confidence in our leaders but now I need evidence and I need the pact tos carry forward
152and make sure I'm persuasive. Can we get consensus or do you think we have on a quarterly school board dashboard that we have the facts and figures to move forward. yes, absolutely, we utilize the dashboard right now in our [Inaudible] 101's websinger can get what we have and make it public facing so it's easy understood. I appreciate that. on the organizational issues, I think there's more, I think there's two decisions, one, what is the future construction and renovation management system look like and the second is when do we transition to it. Like DR. Holness, I'm nervous about anything between now and OCTOBER 30, 31, OCTOBER 30, we have to change the resolution, on her 29th birthday, we're going to have this done, I'm nervous about changing because of domain knowledge, I'm scared to death because
153there are not enough construction managers in the united states right now. Right now, chair, MAY I ask what percentage of the aecom/pmor team is staffed today, if you have x positions, which positions of those are filled? DR. Hepburn? MS. Paul? aisle refer to MR. Mcintyre. . Er michael mak tire, aecom, through the chair, we are down 14 right now and we have two more expected departures in the next couple of weeks. We are at that moment in the program where people are looking at their personal lives and their profession and if the future's unsure here, if they're good at what they do, they have five job offers right now. so, that's the world we're living in is -- and we're talking about companies that are big players in this market that they are struggling to
154keep staff because of programs winding down. thank you. And to me that's why MS. Alhadeff's point of MARCH is so important, just by saying we won't have aecom, four more people resigned today, 8 more people resigned today, they got tons of job offers, atkins has 20 job offers for every person on their team, their team is talented, they are domain knowledge about bro urt county construction and renovation and have to be careful about when that transition is, what does the landing look like, when can we feel like the risk profile is appropriate to make those decisions. I also think there's a big issue with our own government staffing. I've been asking for a year to figure out why we don't have enough people inside broward county public schools to do planning, to do construction management,
155to do project management, to do skenbacker scheduling and risk, we just don't have enough, I know there eventually will be a plan but I know a year ago we didn't have enough time. if we look at the size of our capital budget, our government staff is dramatically too small websinger split twaoep a chief facilities avenue, a piece of which is facilities, but most large urban districts have two people in those roles and I'm anxious to see what the org chart changes will look like this summer. Thank you for the dashboard, I cannot wait to have that like in school board vernacular so that in just plain english we can talk to people at publix, talk to people at kiwanis club and showed them we've turned the tide, if they trust us with more of their
156money websinger eel continue to deliver big things. Why is that important to me, because charter schools condition do that. They get a piece of what we do but we go to the public and say we need this done and they ride our coat tails but we really need that long term facilities w e are billions of dollars in the deficit in term of delivering facilities that our kids deserve. Thank you, chair. thank you so much, next is MRS. Mccarthy bulman? thank you, chair, thank you for the presentation and I'm not going to keep you long because I think my fellow board members have hit on a lot of the points that I wanted to make, so I'll just say again just to kind of in support of what DR. Holness, MS. Alhadeff and DR. Zeman
157have said, I think that with the timing and just knowing how the titi slips awaway d d bruary isis not r r from totor r or lylyth it's incumbt t on us to to -- we're gaining the trust of the public to make sure we have a tight transition plan. We wfrnt here when some of these mistakes were made but we're here now and it's our responsibility to make sure we're doing it right moving forward. I agree with MS. Alhadeff about make drk making a comprehensive plan of redefining, otherwise we would be negligent in our duties so I think it's extremely important. I'm just wondering contractually with aecom what the responsibility is moving forward. Ideally we're going to have a seamless transition to what we're going to do next, if we're going to do a
158hybrid approach or whatever we do next month but when we transition, what is the responsibility of aecom to assist us with that? Is there -- are we getting a bunch of boxes of files for the successor or is there a contractual obligation in there to make sure we are maip staining functionality at all times? so, one of the things -- . Er go ahead, MS. Paul? sorry. One of the things we're doing, we're having a transition meeting with aecom, mike and the team have been very forthcoming with that, mike attends the meeting with mike's staff, kuni is also in the room, we're compile ago list of everything we need from them going forward. If they choose not to present a proposal to extend and that has -- one of the great things we have is
159that we have e-builder which is the system we use which gives us a historical depiction of all of our projects and everything that's happened along the way, so that has helped a lot, so we are just continuing to work with aecom, they are a partner to make sure that if they are not successful in the extension that we have everything we need to protect the district and to move the projects forward. In addition, it's very important that we have this transition plan so that any kind of litigation or future litigation, we are in a position to work with aecom through those issues so MR. Kuni has been instrumental in those meetings. and could you just give -- I'm asking how this goes -- I appreciate that your recommendation for the hybrid format for moving forward
160and when you're talking about -- to DR. Zeman's point, do we have or what do you envision in terms of having in-house knowledge and talent that we maintain here so we have a certain level of capacity internally and then juxtaposed with the personnel flexibility you're talking about, how does that -- I think we need both quite honestly. As DR. Zeman alluded to, we don't have adequate construction staff but we have to make informed and meaningful decisions on who we add to the team. That's number one. Number two, we have incredible subs out there that are responsible for the projects and I can't see moving forward without having them as part of our team and so the ones that are the subs to aecom, it's my expectation that we will continue to keep them and many
161of them have worked with the district for many, many years, so we do have that historical knowledge that will help. Quite honestly, part of my responsibilityies as I see them based on speaking with DR. Hepburn, before I even came here is building the bench. We need to have qualified individuals that are waiting to move up within the district and that's part of the succession planning we need the have, so there are a number of fronts that we need to improve on but we have many contractors that have worked here for many years that are very good and we need to keep them as part of our team. That is the expectation. Part of the technicality of it and I wish I had tom here to speak to it, but if aecom chooses not to propose
162and to stay, then we would ask aecom to release the subs and either we as a district would contract directly with them, so that's another option. The piggyback on the duvall contract will give us additional time too for the transition plan if aecom chooses not to propose for three months or sick months -- six months or whatever they choose to do, I want to make sure all of our bases are covered and that we're not just doing emotion right now, just that one thing. Ask sonia has been instrumental in working through that and helping us move forward. contractually, when do we have to have a final decision from aecom, what's the timeline on that? their contract ends in JULY, so, my expectation is that they'll work up until JULY, but the sooner, the better. I
163think as we spoke previously, if they can fwet the proposal in within the next two weeks, then that's something I can present to you at the MARCH board. we would definitely praoesh that. thank you. and then if they -- when you're talking about releasing the subs, if they decide not to go forward, are there also non-compete in any other kind of issues that would be -- that is with their contract. that would be something -- is that a problem we have to also address? I think that's something we would work with tom and aecom on, the specifics of it. okay, thank you. thank you. Next is MS. Thompson? Rjt I'll just keep it really brief because I know we're behind and I don't want to belabor the points that have already been made. I appreciate
164MS. Paul that you are trying to right this ship. I know there's been a lot of issues with the smart bond f we -- let learn from the mistakes and let's move forward. Two comments I want to v i think it's important to have comprehensive options. I was not here on the board when they decided that maybe they would expect with aecom and I think it's important that we have that opportunity as a board to reconsider all of our options, whether we want to go any sort of way, whether we propose or not, it's still on us to accept their proposal, I want to make that very clear. And then along with when you bring it back in MARCH, if you could give a comparison to how the other larger districts are working their building
165department, I think that would be really helpful to see like how miami-dade, how they're working with contractors, if they have everything in-house, is that clear? Perfect. And then I also just want to make a comment when we're as a board talking about redefining schools, we don't have a facilities assessment yet and I don't want us to jump ahead on making decisions abredefining when we don't know the conditions of al -- all of our buildings, since that won't be until JUNE, just something to continue reminding yourself of in MARCH, that's it, thank you. thank you, MS. Leonardi? thank you. I will not be quick, I'm sorry. I have a lot of questions, comments. To something that DR. Holness was asking about earlier, why wasn't the master schedule under atkins already? MS. Paul? . Inger I do
166not know. Mike, can you address that? michael mcintyre at aecom, the master schedule is held within the aecom contract because that's how the scope was written, understanding how a master schedule is developed is important. The master schedule is developed on what projections were at the time and thep it is informed by actual live contractor schedules. So, an initial master schedule that's agreed to, there's a theoretical projection of what should happen at the beginning of a program and that master schedule just happened to have been within the aecom scope. Like MRS. Paul, and most of you, I wasen here then, so that's where the master schedule lives. The basis of the master schedule is just that projection, how should it be.Everything worses properly, what does the schedule look like for program, what does the skembacker schedule
167look like for individual projects? Then it's informed because then it becomes live. The master schedule is static, it's chiseled in granite, it doesn't move. The progress schedule which is the work, that's free-flowing. That changes based on the day a contract is issued if it's is dewed tle months later, the schedule is busted. We know the first three years were sort of wasted in the project. There's no way if a structure, nothing got to the street, so the program was off kilter, it was off tilt at the beginning and then the master schedule had it compressed. Where should it live? It could live in a future pmor, it could live in atkins, both would do the same thing, collect the data from actual projects and would inform the master schedule. It's really about building a master
168schedule that's honest, that's true, that's factual, it's based on real world projections of what should happen if it's done properly. So, we're looking back now at water that's gone under the bridge and it's hit the ocean. Was it done properly, probably not. Was it fag khul, probably not. Was it realistic? Definitely not. so that should inform the board on what it lives in the future if that helps. thank you. So, I know there was a recommendation earlier that the master schedule live under atkins so I'm wondering what does the board need to do to ensure that that happens? we will bring a contract to the board for approval for atkins and the it will be in their contract to renew. when -- up for renewal, we'll include that or they will include that as part
169of their responsibilities. when can we can expect that to happen? it's coming to the next board meeting I think. next week, thank you. Is aecom or is atkins doing the tia's on the projects and the program or is it a combination of both? I think atkins provides the financial piece to it but -- am I correct? Aecom, okay. Go ahead, mike. mike mcintyre, through the chair, the tia reviewers are ja us time analysis so there's no financial side to it. So, aecom does the time analysis, there's specific information that must be supplied by the contractor, multiple schedule types and then we need the narrative of what happened, what happened and what do the schedules tell us happened, whether or not a contractor gets additional time, whether it's awarded to them or whether they're held liable
170to it. is that in the contract that aecom would be doing that? we do the change order analysis, a a time analysis is considered part of a change order. got it, thank you. I believe the question was raised earlier, you know, how confident are you in the validity of the information that was presented to us so I won't ask that question again for a response but I think that is a question for many of us. And to that point, I believe that we have now 270 million dollars to spend by OCTOBER, from AUGUST to DECEMBER, we spent 85 million dollars which is about 4 million -- 14 million dollars a month, so I'm not sure how we're going to be able to spend that money by OCTOBER, are you confident we're going to be able
171to? no. okay. I mean, because we still have ongoing projects and we mentioned parkway and some of the bigger projects so, no, we're not going to expend all of that by OCTOBER, but keep in mind too that in terms of the smart bond money, that's already expended, so no, we're not going to expend all of that by OCTOBER. okay. Can which brings me back to the validity of the information in this presentation. On page 12, I asked for a follow-up of the 169 projects in close-out, how many of these were still in close-out in AUGUST and the response was 147 of them were in close-out in AUGUST, they're still in close-out now, so 147 of them have not progressed beyond close-out, which is -- there is -- [Inaudible]. sorry, ashley carpenter with atkins, I wanted
172to clarify, the 147 that showed in that construction close-out box from the AUGUST presentation includes projects that are fully closed, financially closed out, nobody's looked at them anymore, they're done, done, as does the 169, the reason we continue to show them here is just because with the smart program, we want to always make sure with ear showing the full amount of the funding and the full amount of the scope and not just being we don't talk tabt 100 projects anymore because they're done, so that 169, 102 of them, somewhere twaoeb 99 and 102, I don't want to say the wrong number, are completely finished, phase 9 closed, finance financially closed out and the rest are in those vase spaces, somewhere they received a substantial completion and they're fully, fully closed out. got it, thank you
173for clarifying that. When we're talking about projects, are we talking about schools or individual buildings, individual projects at schools? that is an excellent question and thank you for that. We're talking about individual projects, so if it's a roofing project, if it's an hvac project, we're talking about individual projects. One of the things that I want to do in the future is I have always managed by school and so I want to be able to give you a holistic view by school as opposed to carving them up and getting you into the roof counting business kind of thing. So we have several things we're going to recommend going forward as a better way to not only communicate with the board but with the community because the it is very confusing. We can't expect a community member
174to understand wra wah a roof carve out is. we're looking at that as a better way to communicate. thank you, I appreciate that. On page 14 highlight thing big 3, I just want to point out from a community standpoint from AUGUST to DECEMBER, it says the exact same thing for northeast high school and tran hanh high school, the roof repair and is ungrades are in progress, demolition of old buildings is you should way for for northeast, and it says the same thing as it did in AUGUST for stranahan, so I think it's important to point that out, that that can be frustrating for some. I think and I understand we completed the stranahan cafeteria, that's not the whole stranahan project, so again, it is in many cases very respective, literally what I want to bring
175to you is done, done and done. But we still have certain aspects of the project like in blanche ely, the bus loop and so farther but I don't want to -- because these were major items as a par sdsh part of the bond, I don't want to take them out. I want to make sure they're at the forefront that the big three, she tried to explain the big three to me several times, the big three stay ins the forefront, but yes, I understand, we can take some of that verbiage out and give more of a status of we are 95% complete and -- or a better way to describe the project. that is positive, I guess my frustration is around -- and I think it's more of a -- like a more abstract issue of
176these are the big three, they are taking longer than they should and I know that that is not your fault but things have not seemingly progressed that much from AUGUST to now for some of these projects at those schools. And I want to go to the stranahan cafeteria for a second. I'm readadinthe e supentendede's's ne d notes from t 7 7th and it says the issue concerning the nrorbacker floor slope and kitchen areas, you have alluded to the issue with the flooring in the cafeteria multiple times today. The consultant has identified multiple pareses in the kitchen where the floor slope was not installed per code and I'm wondering how does that happen, was that approved by anyone in our building department or in our staff, that slope, or did the consultant just do it and
177we realized after the fact that we were incorrect. I'm going the let MS. Colie go through the different gyrations, the floor in the cafeteria was not acceptable, we would not approve it, that's why they had to go back and replace it, that added time. The floor in the kitchen was not functioning properly whereas the equipment was tilting. That wasn't acceptable. They're going to replace that this summer, so part of the tension we have especially with not only around the fire code but also around the building department is we're just not going to accept substandard work and so the building department, the fire code -- or the fire department or fire official, I look at them as our front line of defense so that -- they have to question and they have to make sure we
178follow code. So, with stranahan cafeteria, I understand that it's taken longer than it should have but I look at these buildings that are constructed that we're going to live with them for year and is if the floor is popping up and they're waive have doctor -- wavy before they turn it over, we have a couple of examples, like rickards is one too, we have to be clear in terms of doing that because you go to prototype tos save time but just in my short experience here, it really hasn't saved us time, so that's my opinion but sonia can speak to the specifics a little bit more detail like going down to miami to look at the kitchen floor. Nlt sonia colie, the kitchen floor is per code, it's quality control quality assurance issue, so the
179kitchen is much smaller than our normal kitchens we have in high schools, well, not much smaller but the faolt print, so and the contractor being able to slope the floor, they missed the mark, so that is the issue. It is code compliant, it's just the quality -- a quality issue and it's -- really our requirements. and functional. So, mary mulder, who is our invaluable person over at child and nutrition program, even though it MAY look right nao term of code, if it's not functional, we're back in the same spot. That is why we have to replace the floor. And I know that brings other questions but if -- even though it MAY look correct on the plans, when you put the equipment in there and it's sloping and tilting, then that's not functional and it
180becomes a safety issue so we're making them go back and replace the floor. okay. and there are other spots, not just there. yeah, I feel like I'm hearing multiple different things about this, so I want to come back to the slope in the kitchen. Is it not per code, was it installed not per code? it's installed per code, it passed inspection, it's a quality issue. So, the floor in some areas are just not sloped correctly. And it wasn't noticed until the furniture came in. The contractor did go back and correct some of the areas, they repaired some of the areas, however some of the areas still need to be repaired which are larger which they can do until over the summer, again, it is installed per code but our specifications call for something and the
181architect did not pick it up within our specs. thank you for helping me get to the bottom of that. On page 15, we're talking about rickards and the superintendent sends out -- I'm sure you are right, a portion of the news and notes every week about rickards. You know, for months, we were told that there was a delay about a year ago, I was told there was an additional delay and that the contractor plan today recoup the time we've lost. That has now changed and I'm wondering why has that changed and when -- has the community been told about this, has the school community been told about this and if not, when can they expect an update on this? I'm going to bring mike mcintyre up. michael mcintyre, through the chair, as many of you
182know, rickards had a structural floor that was identified when thereafter partial collapse of its sister school in miami. At that time, we stopped the work, we had a third party engineer do a structural review. Structural review found faults or redesign was required and we lost plus/minus three months, the contractor did attempt to adjust their work flow. The phasing of the work with the intent of picking up that three months. The change in work flow did not capture the time they had lost. In many ways I call it they worked their way into a dead end that they could not capture the time. The problem in the business, it takes a week to lose a month, it takes a month to gain a week back. So, they could not get that three months back. They're still
183piecemealing it to try to get some of it back but I'm not sure with my experience that we can find three months with what's left for the work. The window is just too short the gain that much time. But they did make a valiant attempt, they changed the work flow, they just could not get there, the loss wasn't theirs, the loss was the engineer's and they worked out of the box to try to recapture that time but it could not be recaptured. okay. I appreciate that explanation. So, to my other questions, has this been communicated to the school community and if not, when will that be happening? so, the reports that we put out have captured the accurate date as of today, the schedule is still NOVEMBER. We've asked again for an update of that
184change, we will notify the community. So, the information that's being reported currently, the NOVEMBER date is accurate. the other thing that I believe I spoke to you about is the need to have a community meeting there and so we do need to schedule that. We will send you that date once we finalize it but I think that's important, that's part of the additional enhanced communications we need to do on the remaining projects. thank you, I appreciate that and I will just say and I know that this does not take into account all of the complexity and nuance that you all just described about rickards but I drive by rickards almost every single day, I don't live far from the school, tiets school that I'm zoned for and I've seen apartment buildings go up, be occupied
185in the time that the roof collapsed and I mean I think even to last year, so as a community member and then as a school board member, watching children go to school on a portable campus while people are able to build apartment buildings and have people occupying them is infuriating, and so I understand that these problems come up but it is unacceptable for our students and our families and when we talk about redefining and repurposing our schools and the concern around enrollment, I can tell you as someone who lives in that community, it certainly doesn't help enrollment for that school even though they have amazing principals and amazing teachers that have been there for decades. I would be remiss if I didn't express extreme frustration over this situation at rickards. On page 18 of the
186presentation, does this -- tarn change orders, does this include change orders that are in dispute, do we ever talk abchange orders that are in -- about change orders that are in dispute? ashley carpenter, through the chair, it's a good question. We have not included any open change orders in these reports and we typically don't. This is really just reflecting approved change orders but I did run the reports this morning because I wanted to answer this question if it came up and obviously we need o do a better job of representing what's in the pipeline since the question has arisen. Currently for construction, all the change orders added up together that are in the pipeline are 7.6 million dollars. As is referenced somewhere in the presentation, there's about 70 million dollars in contingencies in the project
187budgets. Now some projects have no budget left, they've had a lot of change orders and we've used up all the budgets, you'll see when we bring change orders to the meetings, lots of projects have plenty of money and contingencies still remaining for change orders because they've been dpujt budgeted from the beginning, it's normal, it's a normal part of construction. We have changes that are being reviewed and processed for designers. Those represent about 5 million dollars of open additional service requests. Now, some of these both on the construction and the design side are probably not going to be approved. They'll be rejected and sent back or they'll be negotiated and the amount will be less but equally there will continue to be new change orders that come up as we progress through these projects, so that
188number will fluctuate. thank you. And thank you for being prepared with those numbers, I appreciate that. The concerns about a transition plan, you know, have mentioned by my colleagues so I won't reiterate that. I do have two asks though that if we do -- if the board does decide to go external to bring on another pmor, that that contract be tied to more deliverables and this is something that MRS. Paul has talked about many times but also I think like we need as a district to do some very serious reflection about what's worked with our two previous pmor's and what has not, if that is the direction we go in, and I don't know if that looses like a workshop or what, but I don't want to -- i do not wan to keep making
189the same mistakes and that is what continues to happen and I appreciate that we are fixing some of the smaller problem and is the progress has been made but when you look at someone's experience in their community with the projects at their cool and I'll go back to rickards or go back to stranahan cafeteria, there's delay after delay after delay, so we need to do some -- again, a reflection on what worked, what did not moving forward. Thank you, I will finish within my time. thank you, very good. I believe MRS. Fam is on the poen. yes, ma'am, I would like to speak. I'll try to make it quick, I know we're running way behind. My question is when will the board be presented with a written synopsis of the backup plan in the event
190that aecom does not extend their contract and we need to retain -- we really need to gain an alternative way of getting to the finish line, so I would like that to come to the board and I would j like to know when that can come o the board so we know what we're going to do in the event this doesn't come to fruition. DR. Full fulton? MS. Paul? MARCH. did you hear that, MRS. Fam? yes, thank you, so the next school board meeting in MARCH, we'll have that backup plan? yes, ma'am. thank you. do you have anything else? no, thank you. okay, thank you. MRS. Alhadeff had a brief thing to add and then I'll end the discussion. yes, thank you. On page 13, the construction close-out, I know I've been constantly asking about
191the financial close-out, like that's the final, final and I was like why are we putting that on here, so I know MS. Leonardi brought it up, why don't we put it on here or make any notation towards it? DR. agreed, -- fulton? I agree we can add it in. Since you brought it up a couple of years ago, it has been in bond oversight committee so we do have a separate page in the bond oversight committee on which phase they're at and which projects are at those close-out phases, so you need another slide to break down what's in each of the different closed-out phases but yes, it's in the aecom monthly report, it's also in the atkins monthly report which are currently being housed on the bcps smart futures.Com website, so anybody from the public
192or board members can go to see those reports as well but we will keep that in mind for presentations to the board for the future. thank you, and DR. Fulton, so to the superintendent, I know we kind of changed it in some documents, if we could just make sure it's consistent so we're just extremely transparent throughout the continuity of all of our documents. absolutely, thank you for that feedback. thank you, and I also will be fairly brief. I just want to make a comment and I understand that it's mushy because we're moving things from smart to defp but I think it's really confusing when the workshop is on the smart bond and we're adding all this information about the defp because they're separate and I think that's what happens is the public mushes them together
193because we're showing them that way, so my preference is to not highlight it as much on here when we're -- not that it's not important, but maybe have it like as a back enor in the appendix or something because that's what's happening is we're conflating the two together and I don't think the public understands the difference between what's smart and what's the defp, just my personal opinion. I think part of that confusion is the fact that aecom is managing ten of those projects, so I think that's where the confusion comes in because the public doesn't know what's paid for with smart and what's paid for with capital, thank you for that feedback. I have a cup ofl quick questions, they focus on page 22 and 23, so first of all, page 23, and I believe
194it was part of the smart program but I'm not sure where it fits now, but we -- before you got here and before this was the board, we as a school board had a whole workshop on dania and I thought we agreed on something about how that was going to move forward and we've never seen it again. So, now it's rolled boo the defp but it was something like when I first -- I think 2020, 2021, it was something that was brought to the board, we had a long discussion websinger were in the process of figuring out which one of the plans, I think there was a, b and c, something along those lines, I just am not sure where that sits and it looks like we're not even -- it says project completion JANUARY
19526, but we've never had that come back to us again so can someone just briefly say where this is at? ashley carpenter, through the chair, you are the chair, dania has a couple of projects, this is again that messy part we talked about, 334 projects, that's more than the schools, so dania has a couple of projects, the one that's on the list for completing after OCTOBER 2025 is the demolition of building 2, so dania right now is under construction, it is -- I can tell you about 80% complete in construction and that's for the regular smart program renovation so it had music, media center, electrical improvements, safety security upgrades, some of our regular smart program scopes and then the demolition of building 2 is separate from that and is happening g subsbsuent to that, so
196at's w w thth's onthe liststor after octor.R. therwas a whole discussion about the play court and whether there was going to be a whole separate building for the music and all of that and it never came back to us, so I don't want to harper on this, I'll have the discussion with MS. Paul. we can do a follow-up on that. mccart thur high school is that project that's on page 22, is that the science building? It says renovations. Is that included? mccarthur has the smart program renovations and has the stem labs building, the stem labs has always been on the defp list, this project, smart program renovations is being handled I be the same contractor and it's part of smart, so that's why they're on separate lists. okay. Thank you. Since we're on mccarthur and
197because we've put defp in here, there was a discussion at our last defp meeting, MR. Foganholi brought up about a pool at mccarthur so I don't need an answer right now, I don't see it on the list on the defp and I thought it was added or at least we had a discussion about it. I think it was a discussion and we looked boo -- into the pool, basically my memory as I think able to, I think the pool has to be replaced and it wasn't in the scope of the work. no, it was a separate defp request but I don't see it on here, will that come to us as a discussion in the next defp? so, it would have to be included in the next defp if that were to happen. thank you,
198there are 13 projects that are projected to be done in DECEMBER of 2025. I just would like to say I would love to see them completed by OCTOBER 31st of 2025. I don't know how much I would love that too and we'll work towards that. yes. i'm not sure if DR. Fulton will have this answered, DR. Hepburn was going to answer it but the long range planning committee, they're supposed to be a resolution that's combining to us so we can understand what the make-up of that is. and I believe the draft or we're working on a draft letter to the board to tell or to infer you of the process so yes, that should come this week to you. perfect, thank you, and the last thing I'll close out with, the vendor evaluations, I appreciate
199that, I think it's been a question a number of people have asked and nothing you can do about it but I will just say these scores are horrible. They're 50%, a little over 50%, 4.3 out of 8 average, 4.26 out of 8 average, that's -- that's out of 8 and not 10. I know, but that's still half. they're horrible, yes. it speaks to a lot of what my colleagues have said so I don't know what we do with these evaluations but I hope that they are part of the conversation when we look at rfp's moving forward. that definitely is part of the after action report or lessons learned to look at some of our endorses -- vendors that have disappointed us, so we have to have that real conversation. and I'll end with I agree
200with all of my colleagues, we have to know what the facilities assessment is before we look at phase 2 of repurposinging because we don't want to put money in a place where we MAY not be housing students. It dun make -- doesn't make sense, I don't want to stop the process of repurposing but I think it's important we're able to put those together, thank you, and thank you so much for the presentation and for everybody on staff that came today, we appreciate it so much. The next item is rule development workshop, 6 ssep policies, I will turn it over to staff for a very, very brief presentation. and I'll defer to you if you prefer we not do a presentation and just take questions. take questions, yes. DR. Lozano, I would hate for you to
201all be here, if you could just maybe briefly introduce what it is we're going to do and we'll move on from there. again, as part of the policy review project, it's the safety and security and emergency preparedness looked at six policies that needed to be either updated or repealed could come up to 2025 standards, so the team worked with cowar and cowar and reviewed these six policies so we would like to get feedback from these six policy from the board and the public. They were 2302, facility incident reporting procedures, policy 2.4, bomb threat procedures, policy 3.7, safety devices for safety patrols, policy 1160, safety devices, school zones, policy 4017, assaulting personnel and policy 4017.1, broward county police, and the changes were either changing the name from siu to broward county schools. is there any public
202comment on the policies? Okay, board member comment? Anybody? yes, I do. go ahead, MRS. Fam. hello? go ahead, MRS. Fam. my comment is you had those words in where appropriate which is a vague and ambiguous term as far as referring to law enforcement and I make the recommendation and I'll bring this motion when this comes forward that it's the police that are expert ins the law, the police should be making the decision on what amounts to a crime and what doesn't and we should take the subjectivity out of it because we don't want our principals that have relationships with teachers to have to factor in those relationships and the relationships they have with their students so that is one recommendation I would make is that we don't want to put that onus on the teachers
203to be experts in law other than judges and attorneys I think police officers are probably the third most familiar group with what is legal and what is not. Thank you. okay. Thank you. Staff, did you capture that? we captured that, thank you. okay, anybody else? Alright. Well, that was easy. Thank you so much. That's it, thank you. You're done. you recommended no change, it's easy to do no change. okay, the next item, thank you very much, the next item for discussion is the office of safe schools quarterly report, quarter 2, I now turn it over to staff for again a fairly brief presentation. so, on this one, we have a short presentation, you like us to do the presentation to bring context and take questions? yes. it seems like -- a short one. a short
204one? yes. sorry, so welcome, everybody, I'm ernie lossan know, chief safety security officer, I'm joined by two ladies I don't like very well, but the rest of you will like, our two compliance specialists here in broward county public schools they hold me accountable every day, they're really good at the work they do so without further adieu, if we can have the powerpoint up, MS. Nakiel is going the take you through the powerpoint quickly. thank you, chief lossan know, if we can start, this is for our office of safe schools quarterly report, this will cover OCTOBER through DECEMBER of the 24-25 school year, it's quarter 2, so we can move on to the first slide. This first slide gives us some context for the statute requirement for presenting this information to the board in a public
205session and the table that you can see that's on this slide is the full quarterly report that we are provided by the state and the department of education. It does describe the number of compliance visitors that were conducted so for second quarter websinger have 46. And then of course what percentage of our total scoots, that is 42.7%, the number of inspected schools with no deficiencies this quarter were 18 which is 39.13% of those conducted visits, what they mean by that is that had 0 deficiencies, nothing was found to have a follow-up and oversight there. What we did was taking this data broke it down for you between our traditional public and our charter public schools, this first slide goes over those same exact numbers but just gives that to you in the context of the
206tradition public schools, so we had 24 inspected traditional public schools and those schools without any compliance deficiencies found are 9 which is about 37.5% of that total. We also added on this slide the superintendent objective for a minimum of 95% of deficiency -- excuse me, compliance so that means those 18 items that they are looking at, at a school, this is the average percentage between all of those public schools that were visitor, both the quarter 2 as well as the year to date so we can keep an eye on that overall percentage as we are working our way towards that goal for the superintendent and so as you can see right now websinger are at 93.7% compliance year to date with 93.14 for the quarter. Our next slide is going to give you those same
207numbers for our charter schools of the 22 visits, we had nine found without any deficiencies and we are at -- the superintendent objective does not encompass these charter public schools but we tried to present you that information so that is 89.6% compliance in quaert 2 and 89.3% for the year to date. So, to kind of on our last slide to give you a wrap up of some of these information, if we can can move on to number 5. So, we wanted to give you some takeaways here, for our first quarter, we did have 22.22% of compliance schools from that quarterly report from the office of safe schools, so we have increased that compliance to 39.13% which we are very pleased to see. We definitely have expectation and desire to have that significantly increased. We have
208some areas for continued improvement of our items of documentation, gate and door locks as well as save or space markings, those number ins parentheses are the number of sites we did see during the quarter with those deficiency and is I broke it among the table among private and charter schools. The actions we've been taking to address these deficiencies are a multitude through different processes and with different departments within our division. We have the bta department as well as our emergency security managers, they have been going out to site and is checking documentation but they are conducting our district compliance inspection and is wrapping out -- ramping up those number of visits, we have changed some procedural aspects like making sure all of our media centers are closed ask locked as that is instructional space and
209instead of allowing that decision of when it's instructional space used and when it's not, we want all of those k us tetley closed and locked for the safety of our students and staff and then we also have not just the review of the documentation by our security managers but they're checking those safe markers, we see things MAY have been put up with paper and students have pulled them down wre, encouraging our security staff and our instructional staff to be monitoring those things as well and make sure serology up with that. The last item therefinger we wanted to make sure the board knew all of these deficiencies were done within the three day timeframe from the state of florida. okay, thank you very much. I believe there are no public comments. So, we'll go straight to
210board comments, we'll saturday with MRS. Alhadeff. -- start with MRS. Alhadeff. thank you, I'm going to focus on page 5 in regards to the continued improvement. When you say there was documentation 22, was does that mean? so, that means 22 of those school that is were visited during this quarter, the 46 schools had a deficiency related to documentation, so near the beginning of the school year, they started out by just giving a citation if one of documents they were checking for was not available, now they have I took the certificates, it wasn't in the actual folder when the state showed up, so if it's in the in the folder, the school gets cited as being deficient and then they have day tos produce the folder, so the documentation is the certificates of required training threw
211state statute that staff is supposed to complete. And for us, it's not that they didn't complete train, it's that the certificate wasn't in the fabler during that surprise visit from the state. so we are currently building a digital database so that we can monitor it dally and put all the certificates into a digital database by school to ensure going into next school year, we're at 100% compliance prior to and we done have to send someone to a site, we can monitor it digitally. when it come tos the documentation items they are check, it is [Inaudible] Manage m, training certificates, it is emergency drill logs for lock downs, severe weathers as well as our bta monthly meeting documentation, so anything related to documentation which there are things they are checking associated with having that documentation. One
212of the deficiencies is they did not have the documentation and there are associated ones where they verify, did they conduct the drills as he f they should, that could be cited if they don't have the documentation to prove that. so, is the state requiring us to have printed out folder of the documentation or is it an online access folder. they're growing and evolving,, so the expectation was a printed folder but they are now starting to accept digital folders and allowing us to have -- but again the digital folder needs to be all in one place and they have to be in there and available when they show up. okay. Perfect. So, definitely this is low hanging fruit. This is something that is not negotiable as far as also like I'm assuming this is locking of
213doors and gates. so, let me just clarify and put your mind as ease, again in the beginning when house bill 1473, there was confusion across the state about what is an instructional space, so schools were allowed to exempt and she talked about the media center, because schools don't actively teach all day in the media center, students MAY go and check out bookers but it's not an instructional space, in broward, we didn't want to liver any gray, when we saw that miscommon kaition, all media sent reser locked so it wasn't like there was preponderance of open gate and is doors, it was learning the language of what could be an sxeption and whatnot and as we worked through the process, we cleaned up our processes and protocols to make sure schools were not getting cited for
214exemptions. okay. So, the area security managers, they're conducting site visits, they're checking all these things and I'm very happy the board tied the superintendent's evaluation into this compliance piece of it. I think that's goipg to really help but this is low hanging fruit, safer space markings, come on, and documentation, locking doors, gates, we know what we need to do and I just think that it's so important to make sure that every single person is doing their job, right. It's -- we're a team, so we want to make sure that no one's propping open doors with a pencil or putting all this stuff in the safer space area and our asm's, I know they're conducting their site visits, I don't know if we can -- the board can see, I would love to see what their
215data is because they're going more frequently to our schools and their date will show another picture into this, this was just from the office of state schools, the schools they visited so I don't know if that's something we can bring to a workshop or that's a closed door meeting but I think that is also really important for the board to be aware of what is happening on a weekly basis at our schools. and we can absolutely bring that data to a closed door session for you to see. We continue to evolve with expectations on asm's, we also because after the state does a visit t principal has to to do that follow-up corrective action report, we now require that from our asm's when the schools get smart with the deficiency to go over their protocols
216and is process of how did that happen and meet with director la rosa to ensure that we are minimizing and d havivingo o deficiencicies we nt evy school to t t a a perfecsesemement. Cocould tell you last week, we were at 86% of our schools and last week's visitors that had perfect assessments, that's where we need to be, that's the superintendent's expectation on our division that we're at 100% in compliance and that's the expectation we set in our department. and just my last question, the area security managers, if like let's say I'm an asm in district 4, do I go to a different district to inspect the schools? good afternoon, ma'am, yes, so the asm's are assigned by innovation zones, that's been a recent adjustment to our alignment in the past year or so, so
217each asm is responsible for two innovation zones, so those -- typically they are geographically approximate to each other but they might be separate. There are cases where asm's go out and conduct inspections outside of their zones, in the spring and since the new year that we're doing these state level oss inspections, so yes. so, DR. Hepburn, I would be mindful that I just wan to make sure that you're having different eyes look at different schools across the district because you might have someone that can come and say, yeah, I know they have this, ask they're already checking boxes so they're looking to see whether that security is in place. so, that's been specified specifically by me that these -- especially these inspections we're doing, so we've been doing inspections for a long time, we've put
218app ins place, mechanism ins place and asm's have been doing these nor years t state has picked up on what we're doing and they're having them do it as well. Now we are using the state's mechanism, so nros playing around with that, so -- I don't mean in regards to the mechanism, I didn't mean -- the person that is actually going into the school and looking, I want to make sure that we're not just checking boxes because I have a relationship with the principal or I already know the school, I want to make sure there's fresh eyes looking at different schools so that we're making sure that those -- that whatever is in that compliance standard, that we're making sure it's legitimately, we are in compliance with that school safety standard. and I can tell
219you direct already la rosa and I meet met yesterday and we're going the start on a weekly schedule where we're doing surprise visitors across the school district so we can calibrate to your point. thank you. okay, DR. Holness? thank you, MADAM Chair, so I do agree with board member alhadeff, there appears to be items here that are low hanging fruits that should easily be resolved and I guess my question is how is school leadership involved in terms of training and bringing awareness to the factors that are being assessed in order to be in compliance. Can you describe that process of how leadership is involved and ongoing training or awareness that one needs to look out for the staff and so on to be in compliance and I believe there are 18 factors, am I right,
220that are measured. So, can you respond to that question so we can kind of understand. MR. Lozano, DR. Lozano, sorry. so, it is mandatory my team is at every motherly principal level meeting and they go over the protocols, MS. Nagiel and MS. Howard has prepared a one pager with all the expectation and is it's reviewed with school administrators as the asm's visit campuses, they're also meeting with the school administrators and talking through those compliance assessments. Again, this has been a transition year in terms of learning for everybody across the state as house bill 1473 was just passed last spring and we can expect a probably a few changes in this session as they continue to update and pass stronger legislation in terms of school safety. So, we constantly -- it's something we have to be
221just as vigilant, DR. Fulton brings fire in teaching and learning, wanda paul brings fire in operational, we have to bring that same fire in safety and security and bring that same commitment to safety and it's an every day conversation, it has to be. so, DR. Lozano, and I am happy to be able to say that sir, congratulations. thank you. so, you mentioned that your team meetings with the school administration, how are they reporting back to you in terms of getting some sort of qualitative feedback as to their efforts and ensuring compliance with these 18 factors. So, when their schools are visited, they can be among the schools with no deficiencies because I'm looking at the numbers and we look at traditional schools, what I see here is 32.5% had no deficiencies, right. And then --
222or 37.5 I think it is, therefore 62.5% would have some level of deficiencies from the 24 schools, that would be about 15 schools if I'm correct. So, how do we ensure there's this sort of continual ongoing exchange with leadership and your department that they're looking out for these 18 factors and reporting back own their success in doing so, so, the goal here can be achieved in reducing the schools with deficiencies because I appreciate the data showing we're trending in the right direction but still 62.5% having some deficiency is not necessarily a good number, would love to see that shrink down. So, describe the -- besides just meet witching the school administration, what is the ongoing effort in terms of them responding back to you or giving you feedback and so on and so forth so
223we can make sure that we're at a better number. so, I meet with these two ladies almost daily or weekly, we're in conversations, so I don't know if you want to talk about your process with schools. Nosing absolutely, not only are we pounding presentations, there's a lot of information but I believe a lot of these one on one visits, that we are mirroring that state visit so they're going to be having those dialogues and is those one on one conversations as well, specifically op all of these key tinsels, subpoenas we tried to mirror that over the years, it is exactly those items weser ear following along that same visit structure. Additionally, we've been able expand what we're doing in our review of documentation and trying to get in front of a lot of any deficiencies
224we MAY find. So, of course we've had our bta team that goes in and is looking at these -- the certificate and training requirements, also expanding our review of our drill log documentation because there is even some minutia of documents the fact of law enforcement was informed 24 hour ins advance of a lock down drill, so we have those built into our drill logs, if there is something like a clerical error in documentation, that can end up being a citation websinger ever been working hard and we have a secondary compliance coordinator to expand all of those documentation item for 350 schools almost, so that has been helping to progress with where we're going to improving that and ensuring that everyone is getting that communication because additionally we know that a lot of our ap's enup
225doing a lot of our security requirements and a lot of them are put in charge of those security measure sos we're having more dialogue dlektbacker deftly with them to make sure that all of the information is being filtered and filtered properly and so it's all a team effort so with all of those different dialogue options, we hope that's going to continue to improve that. I understand, and I appreciate having those dialogue options, but DR. Hepburn, how do we -- and i believe DR. Will recollect ozano and his team and the others are doing a great job, how do we hold the school leadership accountable because they might be given the information that this is what we're looking for but how do we hold them accountable that they're carrying these out? DR. Lozano? we now include
226also like we include the asm's now on the visits, we include all the drill information to the principals, supervisors, the director tor of teaching and learning so they can monitor the trails na take place, the safe spaces in the classrooms and those safety checks as they visit schools and they enter a campus is did someone greet them at the gate, was it locked, was there somebody there, those protocols too, so when we receiver -- receive the state report, it's cc'd to the principal supervisor as well for specific follow-up. so, as we aoefr discussing safety and I appreciate all of that, I think that not just school leadership but those who report to school leadership that everyone has a role the play and that everyone has some level of accountability in order to keep our schools
227safe. The other question I have and then I'll be done, I know has we have some data here on charter schools as well. What is our role with charter school compliance? I'm glad you asked that question, sir. So, your role as the corporate board because you as the board are directly responsible and it's your responsibility as board corporate to hold the charter schools o the same standard we do tradition schools in these visitess and we don't differentiate from charter to public in our department. There's kids in those buildings and we have to ensure the same safety compliance, so we hold the charter school tos the same accountability standards that we hold our traditional sites to. so, how do we enforce compliance in charter schools and how do we get corporation from them because their data
228is not that much different from ours? So, as a district and in light of the safety of our students, whether they're in charter schools or traditional public schools, how do we enforce their compliance and how to we get their cooperation? first it's statute driven as well, our asm's are assigned to charter schools as well and they have to go out to the charter schools and do the same state compliance checklist that we do with our traditional sites. MS. Nikiel has two dedicated staff on her team that monitor all the charter compliance, there's certificates, there are drills, everything that we hold our traditional schools accountable for, charter schools under dante collins team on school choice and dra. Wanza's team work with us, we send non-compliance letters websinger have sent non-compliance letters to charter schools. We followed
229up to ensure that the go frping board when there is a compliance issue that they follow up and we ask the same questions you're asking me, did you provide corrective action to that school administrator who was not compliant or did something that wasn't in alignment with the safety practice, so we hold all charter schools to the same standard and we follow the same cadence as we do with our traditional sites. and I appreciate that, if there's a particular charter school that's reluck tan to adhering to the requirements as shown here with the 18 factors, what are the conesbacker consequences or what kind of consequence would that particular entity face should there be reluctance to adhere to the 18 factors of compliance? so, we would work with their governing board and what we would do is
230we would have to bring the is yao to you, the board, and you could look at based on the severity of the infraction, would you as a board wan to revoke their charter, right. So, that's the power you have as a board to look at whatever safety infractions, if you as a board would find it egregious, you as a board would leverage your power as a school board the ensure they took the appropriate actions that they need to take to come into compliance. okay, I appreciate that response because I know that some of our board members are new and I think that information is relevant should we run into an issue, the safety of children, when you're charter or traditional schools cannot be compromises w -- we must be diligent in our efforts to make
231sure kids are safe. Thank you, sir. . Er you're welcome. DR. Zeman? DR. Holness, thanks for bring thirsting up because charter schools are competimates, we want to offer a good product, at the same time, we need charter school tos go to hall has see with -- hall -- tallahassee and lobby, we want thel to lobby on what safety compliance really means including measures safety and security rather than measuring a piece of paper that shows that somebody completed training. Even participating in training by itself doesn't make you safer. I don't view that as a particularly good thing, what bothers me and we kind of look at things like a scale for construction vendors here and we joke they're at 50% and we're at 40. Which means 60% of our schools have something they were deficient in,
232right, a lot of that is documentation. I hope that it's not an indication of safety and security but it's a measure of paying attention to the details and I'm just not particularly happy with these results. I love the fact we're doing well. On page 3, we don't show the quarter 1 results, what were those? DR. Hepburn? MS. Nakiel,? from quarter 1, we had 18 site visits conducted, which was 5.77% of our total schools. Four of those were what were found to not have deficiencies, we had 22.22% compliance. I appreciate that. I'm looking for the -- on the bottom of page 3, we say quarter 2 is 93.1% compliance which is taking those 18 elements over the 24 school and is doing that, what is the equivalent number for quarter 1? so, I I can fwet
233that for you, what I do have with the follow-up, we had started track hating in DECEMBER when that was created as the object tier, I have that amount but it was from AUGUST through DECEMBER and adding the last two weeks of DECEMBER, so I do apologize, I don't have it. quarter 2 was 93.1, which is great, that's a good solid score but since our year to date average is 93.7 high ier than that, I suspect quarter was higher than quarter 2 which means with ear not going up in a key metric of safety and security. I think we are, I think the total number of schools assessed in quarter 2 was a lot more in quarter 1. We had 18 schools. from 18 to 46 that were visited. sample size in quarter 2 with was
234a lot higher than quarter 1. so we didn't weight that by quarters, we weighted it by sample size of schools. Put me down as somebody that's upset. I'm not going to be happy that 60% of our schools are non-compliant. I view this, chair sx, MR. Superintendent, as an easy fix. And why wouldn't we wan to make sure we're 100% compliant. I mean, this is as MS. Alhadeff pointed out clearly, this is not a difficult thing to have papers in a file and if you're not putting papers in a file, what else are you not doing? Like, hello, like, we don't want to go relitigate everything that's happened in security on school site ins the united states but why aren't we having all of our pieces of paper in a file when an inspector walks in
235when we know they're coming. we're on the same page. thank you, let's fix this and next quarter, let's be 100%. thank you. I don't -- nobody else raised their hand, so I'll just finish us up. You said everything, DR. Zeman, I was thinking same as MRS. Alhadeff, it seems simple enough to be able to lock the doors, have safe spaces marked and to have documentation, we should be the bee -- becon of what the right thing to do is in light of what has happened here and to see that we're only at 39 -- 37% and the charter is at 40% to have no deficiencies is disheartening, although the other compliance part looks like a good number, it should be 100%. And I think until we hold leadership accountable, whatever that looks like, I don't
236know what accountability piece looks like here, but we know it's true of students, if we don't hold them accountable, whether it's with a grade or yesterday the teacher said she was going to call the student's parent and the student was crying and she fixed her behavior, so it doesn't have to be a crazy thing for accountability but until we start holding people accountable, and as school board members, as we go to school visits, it's part of my checklist, it's things -- and if I see something, I let DR. Hepburn know, hey, I was here and someone should check it, so I think we also play a role in making sure every time we go somewhere, making sure we're looking at those same things, is the gate locked, is there someone there r the doors locked,
237do we see safe spaces? Those are easy enough things we could play a part in as we go to school visitors. so, if I could close this out, we are getting recognized nationally, I was invited to speak in APRIL at the national student safety and security conference and we're bringing the team and we're going to talk about all the great things we do here in broward county public schools for safety and security. I could tell you schools are livivi organism too,o,right,t, so it ses sisimpleenenough, certificesessasafe space, we got cited because one of the classrooms had been painted and they pointed over the safest space and the next day the office of safe schools showed up, that's going to show up for that school as non-deficient but that helps us get better because we know as
238a team and the schools, we've got to account for those kind of things so all of those little things help us, the school, sro retired, they hired a new sro, they didn't change that certificate, right, even though both were trained so now those processes get put to broward schools chief of police when someone's changeesed sh we have to make sure certificates, so again we're constantly trying to get better. None of us are happen hay with -- lap pi with not being at 100% and the comments that I can clip and play at principal meetings will go a long way to help, set the tone for expectation, so I appreciate it. thank you, and I appreciate that we are -- I know we are looked at in that light, people come to us, but when we're
239getting a presentation and the presentation isn't 100%, it looks like are we really there, so it's just important. But thank you so much for what you do, thank you for the presentation. I'm sorry, thank you so much. Next up is the exceptional student education policies. I will turn it over to staff for a brief presentation. And I will just say since you sent the policy to us, you don't have to go through it, if you just want to introduce it for a quick second and then we'll go to public comment. I'm going to take a two minute recess so staff can come and get situated. (Meeting in brief recess). thank you, again, the next item up is the exceptional student education policy, and I will now turn it over to staff for a very brief
240presentation. good afternoon, saemone hollingsworth, chief academic officer together with dianne egen, stephanie acosta is our director of compliance with ac, [Inaudible], general counsel, as well as members of the it team so, we're here to share with you a high level of the state mandated policies and procedures that are in your document as well as the cameras in classroom, we can go straight to questions if you like. before you do that, I know we have some pertinent information from our legislators, I want MR. Sullivan to give us an update. broward county schools was the only district if the pilot as it relates to certain cameras in classrooms, that pilot project that not come into existence, it niece longer in statute, however there is legislation moving in tallahassee, I expect other bills to be filed as well,
241so point is whatever the board decides today on a policy through rule making MAY be impacted and MAY have to come back once the legislative session is over because we do anticipate the potential for legislation that would impact the policy, thank you. thank you, okay, public comment? steve moyer and jackie lovsco. MADAM Chair, members, MR. Superintendent, congratulations, new members. My name's steve moyer, I live in cooper city t state pilot camera program which will sullivan mentioned is now sunset, it was carefully crafted, it was based on a similar statute in texas georgia, west virginia, they've had those cameras for over five years, there's ten states with similar camera lasers. Draft policy 4900 which is before us says parental review of the video of the ips dent will be limited solely to the incident. If no
242ins department was captured no review shall occur. The district is proposing to deny a parent access to view video of their own klirn in their own public school classroom when nothing happened. Earlier I heard talk of trust. In the powerpoint which is in the agenda regarding policy 4900, there's no mention of the recommendation by the ese advisory to delete this language, if a parent is denied access to view a camera, the camera, professional standards would handle the appeal. Was this really the board's intent on how to handle this? To tell parents no, you can't see the video and go balk to professional standards? Pass what you like and call it what it is, draft policy does not protect students, it protects staff at the speps of students. There's documentation of our public schools denying access
243to video because there was no ins den when indeed there was. There's documented cases of video being supplied without audio completely change thing context of any incident and in my opinion to protect staff. The vast majority of our district, our sdrekt instruction and support staff do an outstanding job under difficult circumstances but in an organization this big, there MAY just be a few that should have perhaps found another profession. These are our public schools staffed by our public employees, the only reason this district exist iss to educate our children, the cameras in question are paid for by our tax dollars, they will be videotaping our children in their class rao p and is you will tell us no video for you. We won't let them see the video of your child in your school because
244nothing happened. This is not how we build trust. The district's history of protecting staff and student expense is not particularly good and I would hope that you willed pass something that would protect student and is not be a sham. Thank you. thank you. Next, jackie luscum. thank you, I have a question first if I MAY, there's two policies and one item here, so do we get three minutes to speak to each item, it's two policies? It's not being mentioned what's happening with 4800 and why it's there. MS. Batista? since there are two policies, you can give her the two minutes per policy. thank you, so because there's two things and one item going on in here, so to address policy 48 00 policy first, it came to you for approval AUGUST 3 -- 21, it's
245been worked on since MAY since the state department has asked for and there was a tight timeline for any amendments to be made and submitted back to the state. There was an ese advisory meet ining the meantime but they weren't presented there and I did come to your AUGUST 21 meeting and pointed that out, they weren't looped or presented back to us in that part of things was lacking. The answer was given that because of that ticking timeline to resubmit tweak tos the state, that was rye and then I invited staff to come back and paren to -- present to us after the fact as to the tweaks that had been made. I don't want it misconstrued from the power point that you have had that there has been some presentation of the ese policies
246and procedures to ese advisory and that we've done any kind of review, we have not, we simply were presented with the few minor tweaks to that 200 odd page document at that SEPTEMBER meeting, so I'm not entirely clear sxit's not being presented on the powerpoint as to why it's being brought back here but I just wanted that corrected. I just then I'm going to hop over to the -- to policy 4900, each of you should have -- board members a document from me that sets out the matrix, a policy matrix, the left hand column is the proposed policy 4900 and then paragraph by paragraph sets out the feedback the ese advisory and district advisory policy subcommittee which was later ratified by the the full district advisory committee gave during the looping process. None of us
247I think were aware that then in DECEMBER after we had provided feedback there was going to be a staff internal meeting which would determine how much of that feedback would come back to you and how much of it would be or not be represented in the powerpoint before you. So, there are some crucial elements of feedback that we gave and we're the folks that have been on the other end of this that want to collaborate with you in shaping up a really good policy. MR. Moyer was instrumental in this pilot program come ining and keeping monitoring on it and indeed in the legislation now coming before the state to possibly renew it districtwide so I think getting it right here is really important fm we did provide really valid collaborative feedback and I don't know
248why it hadn't been passed on to you, so in the three or whatever minutes I have got to do, tla's what I've bp reduced to do it, we would like to be a partner at the table, so providing to you this document and I have highlighted in yellow the particular element that is are crucial to address today in our humble opinion which includes a part that MR. Moyer just mentioned but also other critical elements such as when there are reviews of camera footage, if there has been a determination that there might be reasonable suspicion if there hasn't been an incident. In your draft poll osier it says parental review of the video will be limited to sew olely the incident, and we added in discussion with staff and provided our rationale why this needs to
249say and to a period of 30 minutes before and 30 minutes after the incident, anybody would works with students with disabilities, it knows that following factors play into the reasons for a student's behavior and the interactions a student might have particularly when we talk about non-verbal students with complex learning difficulties and very different ways of communicating, it is crucial that you're reviewing what went on before an incident, what interactions there were, whether there was escalating triggering factors to certain incidents so we didn't bring their feedback to be awkward, we brought it to be klab rat I ever, we had wonderful discussion at our DECEMBER meeting and I wonted why that hasn't been brought back to you, I ask you to address that. I know some parts of poll -- some things go in policy and
250some things go in procedure, we urge there be collaborative work to draw up this manual by which policy is implemented. I know from experience often we'll have a policy brought in but we don't have a framework for its implementation and the protocols and procedures around that and we have a lot of feedback from knowledge of the parents and ways to help implement that smoothly if there is to be a site implement ation manual where there doesn't need to be, we need involvement in that and on the back page I have highlighted the whole of the page where we had submitted feedback that might be useful for that manual, for example t the frequency for which letters go out to parents letting them know they can request a camera in an ese classroom. I urge you
251to please work through these items of feedback we've given you, I'm here for the duration of the item if I'm allowed to come back to the mic., I would love to explain our rationale for some of these things because it is important, thank you. thank you. Any other public comment? Okay. Board member comment? Seeing none, I have a lot, so I'll just go through -- okay. So, if we look at the policy, well, first I guess my first question would be can you explain to us what the changes are -- the powerpoint's not very clear about 4800. It says -- it has a blip here, can you tell us what the changes are for 4800, is it just what's in the green box on page 4? It has timelines and actions but I'm not sure
252what we're doing with policy 4800. MS. Hollingsworth? thank you, MS. Costa castro can address that. for policy 4800, what we wanted to explain with this slide wauz historical of how it ended up back at a board workshop. This policy is a state driven process, it is the exceptional student education policies and procedures, this item was reviewed and discussed at the AUGUST board meeting and during that time, we -- the state has to give its final approval. Once the state has provided its final approval following the board approval, we then bring it back to provide it with a local policy configuration for broward county public schools. So, that when we speak about this locally, we're able to refer to it formally as [Inaudible] So 4800 would be the policy, this was a timeline of when the
253state gave us timeline when is we brought it to the board and when the state gave us the final approval. okay, so we're not making any changes? we're not making any changes since it came to your approval in AUGUST, that is correct. perfect, I wanted to clear that up. MS. Hixon, the document itself for the stat mandated p and p is like the sac bilaws, there's small amounts of items that can be edited or adjusted just for some comparison. I remember that conversation, thank you. Okay, now to policy 4900, and I appreciate this coming to us. I asked about this policy, was hoping that we would start the year with something but we're here now, so I'm glad to see it. And as MR. Sullivan mentioned and MS. Batista did a great job also of
254comparing what the proposed bill is as compared to what the policy we have is and it looks like most of the changes are adding charter schools to public schools and the policy moving forward although it MAY change. That looked like what most of the changes were in the original pilot policy that the state had for us. So, I just have a few things I would like to suggest based on the ese advisory recommendations that they had. So, on number 1a, where it says a parent must complete and it says and I think you meant to put submit but the word submit is not in the redlined version here. So, they must complete and submit, so I would ask that we add the word submit there. I have a question on one of the suggestions that
255they had, so on letter b where it says after receipt of the request from a parent, the suggestion from the ese advisory was to put within 30 days after receipt so I would like the ask staff if that is a reasonable request, whether it's it or staff, that we would baibl within 30 day tos put a camera in a classroom because I don't want to put something in policy that we can't do, we don't believe we can do. DR. Hepbpbn? . Er ye wel l ask k.. Davis and MR. Lozano, I know both of them do installation of cameras. And probably MS. Paul and some of it's it, some of it is facility, depending on the scope. I can speak to that, my name is rob zimmerman, I manage video project and is I manage
256the hp149 project, the implementation of those cameras for three years. We feel we can install up to 300 cameras a month if that -- now if more cameras are needed, we could increase the number of people that we would bring on but ideally based on hp149, the pace was not near that. So, initially I think we've had about 700 parents interested so that would be an initial load, but after that, probably with every month base on the past of hp149, we could easily handle it, yeah. so, my question is if we were to add a policy within days of receipt with the request o a pandering, i guess just y or no, would that be something we would be able to fulfill, I don juan to put it if policy if when we ear not
257going to be able to make that happen. well, if we could have time to look at those metrics algt more. I think that for the initial installation, we'd -- we should try to keep to 300 a month, two months but once we get up to speed, in hp149, we never failed to meet the 30 day installation I'm fra im ever. if that's the case, I would like staff to look into adding in the within 30 days. Whatever time you decide is a doable time, if you don't have a timeline in there, it could be open ended like we see a lot of our work orders so I think it's important that we're very clear with the parents, what the expectation is, you request a camera, here's when you can expect it to be in. I
258won't necessarily say 30 days, I think you should go back. thank you very much, great. and letter d, under 1, it's crossed out, so I would like to ask staff why they crossed that out. MS. Hollingsworth? MS. Acosta castro? it is important to note when we first brought this policy forward, there was a consideration on instead of having a pairn make a request, we brought forward the maximum dollar amounts to outfit every classroom with a camera meeting eligibility wesinger -- e felt in f a camera was being installed in an eligible classroom, we would not have to remind a person to -- remind a parent to request. because I think right now we don't have it in every single classroom, so I think it would be important to keep that not redline it for that
259one, so thank you. On page 2 and the pages are kind of messed up but it goes to number 3, so before -- it says before -- I can't find where it is here. Sorry. Before a video camera is placed and the suggestion was to add the word activated but for some reason I can't find where that roman numeral is, located down here? I don't see it. Sorry. Roman fumarole 3, where a video camera is placed, the suggestion was to add the word activated x placed and activated in a self-contained classroom. I think that's also an important word because you could have a camera in there for a month and it's not actually working. So, I think that that was a good suggestion, so if you could add the word activated on there, thank you.
260On number 1a on page 2 after d, so letter d, number 1a, a school shall -- it says retain video recording, so ours is 30, they're asking for 45, so I'm -- I mean, they're asking for 90, I was wonder ifing we could compromise and make it 45 days so, retain a video record framing a video camera placed pursuant to this section for 45 days after the date the video was recorded instead of just 30. A question would be to it, is it possible to keep that longer than 30 days? rob zimmerman again t servers have a retention setting of 30 days, 90 days, I think we can go to six months, a year, so 45 days would require a manual intervention that would not really be feasible. so it's either 30 or 90. yes.
261I guess I leave it to my board members, I don't see -- is there a problem with keeping it for 90 days? it would be the amount of server space would be significantly greater. With the servers that were purchased for hp149, they could support 900 cameras with 30 day retention but if you increased it to 90, those same service load support the third, 300 cameras. which is what we have right now is 300 but it's possible we have 700 requests, right. right. so, we would have -- that would say require about 150 thousand dollars more in servers. we can leave it at 30 for right now. On roman numeral 4, letter b, it says the principal must protect -- so let me go back up to 1a, 1at school district shall conceal the identity of
262any student who appear ins a video recording but is not involved in the alleged incident and then it says the faces of staff are not to be -- I'm sorry, it just ends there but this is somewhere else, so can we add the faces of staff are not to be concealed or blurred and aud yes shall not be modified or muted because if I'm not mistaken, that's part of the state law. I can answer that question, I think the language you oar thinking about is potentially in the new statute and we don't know if that language is goipg the make it or not. so, my preference is if it's -- I know we're going to have to change things if the state law will include that, I don't see why we wouldn't be proactive in
263the policy we're writing. We done -- there's somewhere else that I read though that we don't conceal the faces of staff like when we're showing things, so I mean I guess I can have people weigh in on that but I would like to add the faces of staff are not to be concealed or blurred and audio shall not be modified or muted because there's -- you can't tell a whole story on a video if you can't hear the audio part of it. If nothing else, I think the audio should definitely be that part of that sentence should be included. And we can -- sure. So, the faces of staff are not to be concealed or blurred and audio shall not be modified or muted. Okay. And you can weigh in after if people want to
264weigh in. Then on letter b, I would suggest changing the sentence to say the confidentiality of all student records contained in a video recording must be protected. It's not just the principal, it says the principal must protect the confidentiality, that's a heavy lift on just a principal, I think it's on the system that's supposed to do it, so the confidentiality of all student records contain ined a video recording must be protected, so you just cross out the principal must protect the and add in must be protected after recording. I'm already -- almost done. Okay. On page -- let's see here, sorry, my paper looses different than this paper does, letter 4, no, letter 5. 3, so number 3 under b, so number 5, this is on page 2, letter b, number 3, parental review of
265a video of the incident will be limited to solely the incident. We should I think and it was requested to add and to a period of 30 minutes before and 30 minute after the incident because sometimes if you're only looking at one snippet and you don't see the whole picture of what happened, it's very hard to assess what really happened in that incident. So, you would add to that sentence and to a period of minutes before and 30 minutes after the incident. And to add a number 4 which is in your powerpoint to say that this is something that's actually, -- we are going to do, it's not a big ask, the video record made available to the parent will become an educational record of the student because we say that on page 12 of
266the powerpoint, it says that if the footage is pulled within 30 days of the footage, it is retained as an educational record so it's already in something that your response was, I know, and that is actually good timing because that was the end. The last thing I'll say is that I would also ask the superintendent to do a manual procedure -- a procedural manual that indicates how all of this is going to work along where the policy, so thank you. MS. Thompson? I just wanted to weigh in. I think keeping the retaining of the recordings for po -- 30 days, more cost effective, so I think 30 day iss a substantial amount of time. And then as far as blurring our concealing staff, I think I would rather wait for the state statute to pass
267before we include that in ours, that's it. thank you, anybody else? MS. Bulman? I'm curious about the timing of the statutes potentially going to be passed in the next couple of months if we're just going to be doing the same thing again twice and we should be waiting until we're following the actual statute to make sure we're doing that correctly. And then let's see, I just had a couple of questions for you guys. Having this policy in place as we have in the pilot program, have you seen any negative effects on our able to hire and retain ese teachers and aids as a result of them being video monitored constantly all day long? staff? I was trying to be appropriate. Good afternoon, so certainly, we did not because that was state legislation as well, that
268was something that was obviously the teachers union was in agreement with, so we prior to this new legislation that's on the floor, we did meet with the union about that and that wasn't at that point a concern. that was reassuring. So, yeah, my only comment would be to maybe b wait until we see what the statute is, so before we finalize this. Thank you. MRS. Rupert? thank you, MS. Fulton, for giving us the phase of implementation foecus update last night, I was trying to work on it as we were speaking. I just have to be brought back to when focus came up into a conversation before we purchased it and I among other people could see that there are vast problems with it and especially about migrating sx efrg we were truly assured there would
269not be a major problem that we'd be able to go forward and, I don't know, maybe I'm continually naive but I'm closeting alt bit of that, my naivety is weaning, when you have one person pop forregard and say this is what's happening with me and another person and that then it's group and then a huge number of groups, for me, that -- we needed something like this beforehand. I appreciate that it came out last night but I know they've been asking for these things forever especially having to do with their updates, you know. As a mom of three kids who were under the ese umbrella -- I'm just confused because we're op the camera, this is about the cameras, I'm not sure why you're talking about focus. well, because I wanted to. okay, but we
270have to stay on the cameras, so there will be a time when you can come back to the focus but we're very short on time and this is specifically about the cameras. then I'll comment on the cameras. As a mom of three kids under the ese umbrella, I would want to have access. I understand that it's not going to be a pilot program moving forward and should we wait or not, I say no. Let's be a leader, let's change the policy so we're ready to go from our perspective, so I would support all the changes that MS. Hixon has recommended and also the ese committees, so I'm definitely in agreement with that and that was a little less than two minutes, thank you. i'll come back to focus. DR. Zeman?Frjts chair, how many other districts
271in mror da have cameras in every eligible classroom? DR. Fulton? MS. Hol x -- hollingsworth? sere raoe. We're the only district in the state that was selected three and a half years ago as the pilot. It was zero. I'm concerned about racing through this and I'm usually the go fast guy but I cane stand to do this and then wait four or six weeks and we get directed by the legislature to do things differently. I'm not sure that being identified as an unfunded target for a pilot guarantees that following that pilot and expand hating pilot, you know, three-fold, is what we want to do. I'm really concerned about the 30 minutes, though, chair, and I'm curious buy f why the staff did not add that recommendation because there's a balance here between needs of the
272parents and the exposure of an extra 60 minutes of instructional time in a classroom. The staff clearly did not wap to include the 30 before x the 30 after and I'm curious why. DR. Fulton? staff, go ahead and address that. MS. Acosta castro. I don't want to say it was omitted, when we brought the policy in OCTOBER, we were tasked to go back to three of the advisory groups, what we brought back today was trends that we came across, we brought back trends and what was said across those three areas, we haven't made any adjustments to the draft policy that was submitted in OCTOBER to the draft policy that's posted today wre, looking for guidance and direction from our school board on how they want that policy to be prebtbacker presented to them at a
273regular school board meeting for when it's time to vote on it. alright. I'm now very confused. We don't have advisory committees to sit around and imitate house plants. You went to three advisory committees and then brought the same document back? we were bringing back the information through the board workshop because this is not to vote on so we could then make the adjustments base on the guyed dance pr the board to be able to bring it forward at a regular school board meeting with the input you had from the community and is the policy that was presented at the workshop would include or exclude on what the board wanted to see in that policy. . Er and through the chair to our acting superintendent, is this what you understand looping to be? DR. Fulton? let
274me re-ask the question, this policy twoent three advisory boards who all made I'm assuming they followed suit with ese and they had ideas and thoughts, and then the staff might have made change tos the policy on their own, none of the changes of the advisory board are not include ined the redline, they're not present today the school board because we're coming to another workshop, this is where we would like to hear what the looping comment is so we can talk about it in an open forum and give direction back so I'm confused because that's been the practice of the looping up to this point and I think we just stepped right past advisory committees, are we waiting until the next step and then use their input before we come back to the board? DR. Fulton?
275if I MAY, so, historically what we have done is included the feedback in the backup, not necessarily that we would include it in the redline, if that wasn't done in this case, what we'll do is provide the board the feedback before you take a vote in the xt bobod d meeting which wowoulbe the nextxtstepepin the rule make ifing g wedecide to dthat. I ow I stepped d out of th roroom when there wawas also question under the legislation , the session starts in MARCH so we would have an indication whether a bill passed sometime in MAY. I do -- so, there is a question that I think is a reasonable question whether do you want to enact the policy while legislation is moving because it would potentially impact the policy but as it relates to
276going back to your specific question on looping, it doesn't mean that staff will change the redline but we should always include the feedback for your consideration as part of the backup. So, if that didn't happen here, we'll make sure we do that going forward. If we follow the rule making for this, we would include it in the backup for the board vote. just as a suggestion, now that the board has taken its rightful place in identifying which committees ought to see something looping, it might be useful to think about a format with which their feedback could come. They have one now with advisory boards give us their recommendations, not their motions, their recommendations and there's a staff column for their reaction to the recommendation and that's great. That's kind of looping in reality rather than
277looping just to loop. So, if we have comments from our advisory committees and staff wants to say this one's great, this one's rotten, this one we can live with but probably wouldn't want to, that's fwraet. We need to have that information, we need to have that debate and we would be informed by it so some kind of format like that I could see helpful. If it doesn't need to go in the redline, there are changes that I have watched advisory committees make that did lead to read lao in changes because somebody learned something new and they said that's what focus does or something and they go in and fix it or typos or can you add the this chart, that kind of stuff, so I just want our advisory committees to be heard. we can
278include that. We did something in policy 1020, so we had a community meeting where there was an tun for the public to go ask questions and provide feedback from staff so that was conducted in the evening in this very room with myself, MS. Batista and MR. Hill so we captured all their feedback. We're not changing the recommendation for the board to take a vote on, but we did -- are including all their feedback as backup to the item. that's wonderful and I look forward to that discussion, I wish we had it today. I cannot wait to have that discussion. 1070 I think was originally for today. It was originally today. . Er he's talking about this one. oh. yes, it was. you were right, john, I was talking about -- we'll get to it when
279we get to it, but I can't wait, we really have some work to do on that and we will I'm confident figure out a way to make sure our advisory have you beening khur and input are brought forward in a productive and positive way. we're also doing a community meeting for that as well. I, chair, am it nervous of bag pilot on our own dime which makes me angry, if the legislature passes a rule and says we wan county one to do this, you have to bring a wheel barrel of money, you can't pick a district and say do it, we have to fix our lobbying but that's not cool to do an unfunded mandate for three quarters of a million dollars, I'm not sure by doing -- being the narbacker [Inaudible] For that and
280being able to do it, there are no sdrik ins florida that does that, is that right? we were the only district involved in that pilot program, we were only the district authorize today do so within statute. I'm going to wan o go back a step when this comes forward and talk about the rio of going to 300 or more. We got to 277 or something, so we didn't do what the leng -- legislature to do without any money. I don't think there was a predetermined number of, I think the parents had the request to make. there's a wonderful chart in here that mow as number of requests and video being provide and had there was one day after 30, there was one that took 35 days to do that, so the 30 days I think
281makes a lot of sense but I'm going to wan to step back one and say what's the value of doing this. now this is all our own money, 1.9 million, that's upfront cost, after that there's maintenance and replacement costs thereafter. I would do anything to protect these students and then the last point is I'm still concerned, I haven't heard the answer to my question, what is the staff's ae doctor reaction to the 30 minutes before and after. MS. "cast to? I don't think would be aposed to it, we would have to work with our appropriate committee tos put it on there and work with the terminology so you can safe 30 minutes before and after. if I MAY too, I understand the ask for it, having reviewed other documents before and during these behavior ins
282departments, while you look for that incident time, that naturally happens but understood it makes people feel more comfortable with having it written down there. if a parent asks for a video of an ins dhaen MAY have happened, school staff looks at it, largely the principal guide thirsting and finds something, that ins tent could be turned over or the 30 minutes before x the 30 minutes after, what if there's no incident, is there nothing turned over? DR. Fulton? MS. Hollingsworth? well, that would remain to be seen of how you would to reword the policy. If you want to include they see what's in the video period or if there's an incident that occurs that's made a determination by the principal. Sxfrment how is our policy written right now that's before us, would they see it or
283not see it according to the policy as drafted? tr. Pull to n? I believe they would not baibl see it unless there was an identified incident. okay. So, they've either seen incident or seen nothing according to the current policy or what the ese is recommending. I would like to see more data on ensuring this is the absolute best way to spend our money and what we're going to learn from it. I suspect there is as lot but given the fact nobody else does it and we're taking a pilot has was an unfunded mandate to us, I guess I would also like to see more on the results of the pilot. What did we hear from the parents when they did request it, how much more satisfied was it, my suspicion is it was huge, I
284would like to know more about it when we're leading the state in purchase of installation of cameras. . Er before I go to MRS. Alhadeff, my suggestion or my request was to allow parents to view the video regardless. whether there's ins den or not. yes, and there's the state legislation, a bill that's coming forward looks like it has that wording in it. If that bill goes through, every school if the state of florida would have to have this policy, so the request of bringing the policy forward was to be in front of a state bill as opposed to behind it. and maybe if that's the case, we want to get ahead of the legislature and ask for the money that comes with that mandate. Before we turn it over to my colleagues, I have to
285say happy biterbacker birthday to MRS. Alhadeff. rob zimmerman, if I wanted to correct, we installed -- we purchased 300, as the project was ending, the life of the project, I believe we had 321 installs and we've now removed 25 from classrooms at the request from principals t original concept is that any given year there MAY have been about 120, 140 active but we never removed cameras think thing district might eventually put them in all the classrooms, that was my direction, so they were put in in an active state. thank you. So, my question is in regards to the cameras, do they have the ability say there is an actual like medical emergency inside that classroom, would say the broward sheriff's office and the real time camera center sen have access to that camera? staff, please
286address. no. why not? that was not what was purchased per the legislation, so and my it friends, they're going to want to knock me out, it's -- it would be like a fish island, it would have full review of the classroom, the audio and visual but it wasn't connected to anything outside of the classroom therk were wired to the other monitor that is you would review such as your outside cameras and halfway cambering. so, do the cameras have the ability to be looped into with the broward sheriff's office real-time crime center? DR. Fulton? staff? rob zimmerman. Hp149, the cameras were on very segregated servers, no one had access other than the principal and anyone that the principal might designate in rare cases an assistant principal and what was your question? does our cameras that we
287currently already own have the capability to have like broward sheriff's sxaufs the real-time crime center, for example now, if there's an emergency situation, they can pull up the cameras based on an mou with us to have eyes on the team and better assess what's going on. that is technically possible n the past we're not permission that way. but the cameras have the capability? and again it's not just the camera, it's the server, more important to make that happen is the server. yes, the per mingling would be g -- permission would be done on the server. and just to expan on what MR. Zimmerman said, these were not designed as surveillance cameras or not connected to the surveillance network that the school uses and that is part of that mou which shares the cameras with the
288sheriff's office. Is it technically possible to make them part of the surveillance system, technically it is. I don't know if that would satisfy though the requirements of the statute to keep those cameras separate and for the purpose of just monitoring the classrooms as laid out in the original statute although the board can definitely modify the policy as it sees fit. okay, interesting. And then in regards to the financial impact and the bill that is now going to be running through legislation, is that funded or unfunded currently moving forward this year? DR. Fulton? I'm back. I'm going vote it up to MR. Sullivan. in term of the legislation, it does not include funding, it has never included fund ining the pilot program. The board has never been opposed to the legislation. What the board has always
289asked is if they were going to make us do it, they would currently fund it. . Inger is this currently on our legislative platform? I have to -- you got me good. I think it is but hold on. if it's not, it should be amended to be on our legislative platform as we go through this. So b I'm not opposed to bingeing proactive in trying to bring the language of the policy with what we believe I guess the legislation is going to propose, yeah, I would say we should really be proactively getting our lobbyists to try to attach funding to this. yeah, it's on our platform. yes, it is there. thank you so much. Thank you for your presentation. We look forward to you -- did you get what you needed from us? Okay. I
290just wan to clarify webser -- we are able to now bring back es ae, policies and procedures tos a regular school board meeting as policy as policy 4800. yes, and then once the bill passes -- I'm sorry, policy 4800. the other one, yes, I'm sorry. we'll start the paperwork to bring that back o the regular school board meeting and the same question for draft policy 4900 with the legislation penning, would you like us to go forward and bring to a regularly scheduled board meet thing policy that could be in effect and when would you want that effective date to start immediately or with the 25-26 school year ?Frjts I guess that's a good question because we can't vote today. You can bring -- right, I would say bring it forward, we will vote it up
291or down, yeah. just to be clear. it will have to be changed if the bill fwoez through. so we're bringing it back which is fine, we wan the make sure we understand what the board tr ex is, you want us to bring the policy as soon as possible before the legislation f the legislation assess, then bring it back to adjust the policy? yes. chair, can I also ask for the advisory council's comments when that comes back, please. absolutely. yes. I don't understand why it's going the change in two months, we're going to take up board time to discuss a policy where the legislature could change it again. Just being time effective. and I'll tell you my perspective on it, looking at the changes they had, most of them, that the bill is -- dun have
292as much as we do and mostly in the bill, it adds and charter schools so the bill is requiring not just public schools but charter schools to follow this policy, so what we're doing and what we've asked for in changes is more than the bill is going to ask just basted on -- other bills MAY come forward. other bills might come forward, a good compromises is give the superintendent the discretion to bring it back pending ledge slai, meaning if tlas bill that comes now and the next board meeting, if he feels this is going to be too much of a change, he would wait, allow the superintendent to make that determination. okay. I personally wanted this to be as you all know in AUGUST, so I feel like we're way behind trying to get it
293through. These are our most vulnerable students, they can't oftentimes speak for theses and the camera is a way to make sure if an incident happened, we know what really happened and how we can make sure it doesn't happen again so that's my urgency on wanting to move this forward in the best way we can. We have some limitation, we only have 300 cameras, there's 700 requests for it, where do we find the funding, all of that is part of it but to do nothing seems like a safety hazard for our vulnerable students. even tho if we passed it in the MARCH board meeting, you have a few months left in this school year. I think the best xropz is to allow the superintendent to make the determination. is that okay with everybody? well, it will
294give the chair -- it will be in AUGUST but AUGUST next year, not what we were looking for. you know, I don't think it's a good thing. MADAM Chair? no, this isn't a rule making -- yes, it is, I'm sorry, yes, it is, it's very confusing how that all works out. thank you, and I apologize for prolonging things but given that we had a loop process and all of our feedback didn't get brought to you, I think it's fair to be heard, there were pointers that were on my matrix that had been fixed, this is feedback we provided to staff, they had this matrix in NOVEMBER and you haven't gone through it. So what are we to do, stand in silence, this is a good opportunity to be discussing it. To get to the point
295abnot racing ahead, we were told in AUGUST the superintendent helped to sfe diet -- expedite this within a month. You told parents we're doing this, you didn't say we MAY or MAY not, with the state legislation, not necessarily going to pass for this year, not going to have the same format, so I think it is important to go ahead if the state brings in its own initiative with anything different, then pivot then, but this is a make or break deal for some parents who do not feel comfortable this year with their kids now in ese classrooms that done have this cover, it gave them great comfort before, there are folks who have left your district because you no longer have it or are talking about doing so, that's not to threaten, it's to provide feedback
296from our community. There was some points still to be addressed or -- if you done wish to, just say, appoint -- MR. Moyer brought forward which is on my matrix, is on page 4 of my matrix, section 4, part b, item 3 where MR. Moyer talk about parental review of the video of the incident will be limited to solely the incident. If no incident was captured, no review shall occur. We provided the feedback which was not brought to you but from ese advisory and as I say again, it was endorsed by district advisory sub policy sub b committee and then by dac generally and technology advisory also reviewed all our feedback and didn't have any objection to it so when we talk about only trends were brought back to you, that was a trend ofp
297all three buddies that had trended it. We wanted the word -- we wanted the wording reviewed, there was some other points in 30 seconds, I'm not going to be able to cover them, this is why I produced this matrix, it took a lot of hard work and we wanted every last point in it addressed. Also just to a point down here that was made on section 1, part b where the question had been asked within 30 days of receipt, a camera should be operational. A question was asked down here, you were told they can manage to inststl 300 camemes s a ntnt n nobodis lk abab otota per mont t they veveto bebeinstalled wiwiinin a certain period of request, it is not a per month affair. thank you, and I just maybe ask you, thank
298you for sharing the matrix with me, can you share it with all of the school board -- all of you have it. I didn't know that you sen it to everybody. Frj yeah, I sent it to everybody. perfect, thank you. Any other -- thank you so much. You have your marching orders. Thank you, so much, the last item is the overview of the building department, I turn it over to staff for a very brief presentation as we have a time certain at 4:00. Sxfrjts as the chair said, the time certain is at 4:00. let me ask my fellow board members, we got the presentation, do you want them to go through it or you want to go right to questions? I would like him to go through it quickly. good afternoon, MS. Hixon, superintendent hepburn
299and board members, we're going to give you a quick overview of the building department, it will take about two hours. The first slide is an introduction and it talks to the purpose of the building department, next to me I have MS. Perla, yalla, I call her MS. Perla, she's the person who I entrust to run the billing department and as you can see, the slides are very granular in terms of the services that are provided by the building department, that's page 3. In 2024, the department at a glance talks about the reviews, the plan reviews, the inspections, the portable inspections as well as the ehpa inspections. A lot of the lion share of the workload is with the smart program. So, current and internal and supplemental staff, you can see the bottom line will tl
300tla we have 7 employees, we have 7 vacant employees, we have 9 filled positions and a big number I want you to pay attention to is the 75% of the work is outsourced in the building department and you can see the different trades we have inspectors for. This is a comparison of the other surrounding school districts and all of those surrounding school districts have similar model to us, they have in-house staff plus supplemental individuals to help do the work of the district. And then the next slide talks to money and the cost analysis that the board asked us to do sometime ago and to outsource the department is in excess of 6 million dollars, our current budget is 2.5 million, and you can see the variance in the wage gap between our internal staff and
301what it would cost to outsource. And here we talk to the benefits of retaining in-house staff, as I said previously, the majority of our surrounding districts are in house staff with supplemental or augmented contracts to help with the workload. The next slide is analysis of the submittal time and I'll let MS. Perla talk to this. on this slide, what we wan -- want to say if you look at it, it's often said a project is in the building department pr the time it's in inception through permitting. A project is only in the building department for the time it's being reviewed, so like for example, the first one is seminole, it was in the building department for 125 days, however, it was with the pmor for 439 days while the architect was making the corrections, so
302it is not in the building department for 564 days. and that's something that I wanted to highlight in terms of, you know, speaking the same language. When we talk about being in the building department, it was submitted but if there are things wrong with the plans, it goes back to the ark -- architect, it doesn't sit at a desk with MS. Perla holding the plans, so as you can see, the days that it's out -- that the consultants which was the time that has elapsed, this speaks to what I think the board has asked us to do is accountability, so if it's in the building department, we should not -- or in the consultant's queue, we should not be waiting 439 days for them to turn that project back to us, so when you look
303at the time and how this relates, when you look at the time impact analysis, a lot of that time is when things have to go back to the architect, so I just want to make sure we're speaking the same language and one of the things I charge myself and tale is to make sure when we speak, we speak with sim -- sim mr is fi, not the jargon of what contractors use and what we use in the profession, we speak plainly so revenger can understand how this works, so one of the things that MS. Perla has done is streamline the process, she's part of our meetings as well as nathan behind me, I think he's still here, we all sit at the same table and work through these things to make sure that we are
304moving these projects forward. So, under the new leadership, I'll let MS. Perla talk to this. . Inger a lot of the times, the projects were having five or six resubmit, so we said let's do something, let's have a stan up review, let's get together and go over the drawings and discuss the issues, whether it's code preference, design criteria that we can fix, let's do that before we sit around again and go through the fourth, the pivoted and -- fifth and all of that, that's what we did and that's what has worked for us. That's how after like we said we were able to expedite a little bit more. the next slide MS. Perla can talk to the initiatives sx, a lot of this movement trying to improve is a lot of us sitting at the
305table talking at the challenges of the project and figuring out a way to expedite it, to mover it -- move it forward. When I got here, a lot of projects had been sitting for year, we were trying to work to accelerate them and that would be the vision as we go forward for the capital plan also, so the things we learned from the smart program of washes to improve will carry over into the capital program. so, what we did with the plan review is what I said, we now allow like 14 days for a plan review except when it's a brand new school, then we know it's more complicated, we tend to also accelerate it and prioritize it when it's a brand new school, like right now we're working on markham, we are prioritizing that
306one. We also tend to do the roofing plan reviews, they used to take like a lot of resubmittal, we've come to the point where the contractor and us as the plan reviewer have learned ask we can expedite a roofing plan review in 3-5 days. We also are doing the inspections, we are turning around inspections in 24 hours, we are doing inspections on the weekends, after hours, at 8:00 at night, on holidays, they have the supplemental staff, even though our staff participates in that, the days we don't work, they work so they are just doing inspections any time of the day. some of the initiatives, I want MS. Perla to take credit for the plan review, she already had a solution for that. she said to me, this is a lot of paper, so now we're
307going into electronic plan review, we are super excited. The staff is excited, they have tablets to add to the field, we're working with a vendor out of lee -- lee -- louisiana, the staff will have the drawings with the tablets but do the inspections right there and resolve the inspections right there and will have real-time results on everything. We also have for plan review the screens already on their desk and so we're moving pretty fast. and I want to thank tray and his technology team for helping us expedite this new system. I think it will pay dividends in the future, so thank you, trey, and your team for that. So, in conclusion, the bcps building department does other things besides code compliance, it acts as our owner representative. They perform plan reviews, inspections, to verify
308the work performed that it is to code, that buildings are safe to occupy and the district is receiving the what we paid for. The thing about this too, she has a very unpleasant job, I'm going to be honest with you because she has to be the person to push back and make sure that we as a district get what we paid for and sometimes that is extremely unpopular and -- but I would tell you I have full faith and confidence in MS. Perla and her team to get the work done and to protect the district. We have gone through an evolution in a short period of time, MS. Perla rep -- represents the new leadership in that department, she makes sure we hire professional license staff who are solution driven and not the pointing of
309the fingers and we have dedicated staff that supports her, so in conclusion, that's the building department in a very brief overview. If you want to stay afterwards, MS. Perla can go into every one of my details on these slides. Thank you for your time and attention. it also says board discussion and guidance, are you looking for us to -- what are you looking for us to give you guidance on? just the continued support of the board. I think that we have the right person heading up the building department. I think that one of our challenges going forward will be to replace staff that has -- will leave us over the next few years and these folks are very hard to hire and we have to look at our compensation for not only the building department
310but just quite honestly our whole construction, building and fire because we -- they can get paid a whole lot more on the outside, we have to find out what that sweet spot is to build the bench, get qualified people in here to carry on the work. MS. Perla has promised to be here for another 50 years so we don't have to worry about her position, just going forward, that is something that is critical not only facing us but I talked to a counterpart in palm beach, he's chief of facilities, I hired him when I was in palm beach, they have the same struggle, being competitive, getting people in here with the proper licenses ask experience -- and experience to do this work. MRS. Ruepert, I will mention, at 4:00, we have to pause the workshop
311to go to the hearing and then we'll come back to the workshop, I don't want you the feel cut off. okay. Quick as a bunny. I'll wait for the ten minutes though. Five, sorry, you're right. Okay, page 12, the initial -- hello? I'll just keep talking. Who does currently the electrical plan review, in-house or a vendor? electronic? We don't do electronic plan review, we do plan review drawings, this is where we're moving towards. Right now we have three sets of drawings submitted. Dough f we do have a program that was built in-house but it's not for electronic plan review, the plans are hard copy, we input our comments online and then he prints out a record so it is not -- I'm lost because page 12 talk about electronic plan review. that's where we're moving
312to. Now we have a manual process, this is a new program software we are moving to and in the process of implementing. and we already bought that? yes. okay. and -- just bought it. what was the cost? Frj the cost is going to be thousand dollars for two years. okay. And that includes hardware, software, the whole thing? So, none of our people are hired on this thing, we'll be hire ago vendor to do this? Ment that's what we're paying the 40 thousand dollars includes the vendor who's going to come from louisiana, train us and with the help of the it department, we'll be set. okay, and then another question I have is about the fire alarm maintenance, is that currently done in-house or is it a vendor? fire alarm maintenance? that's not part of the
313building department's responsibility, that is under the fire official and our -- I think we contract a lot of that out, nathan, can you speak to?A for regular maintenance or for erupting or inspections? -- permitting or inspections. here's the fire official. so, we have fire inspector that is do plan review and permitting just as the building department, we work closely together, we're in the building next door, we they're reviewing the plans on their discipline and we're reviewing the plans on our discipline. we already have our own people in place that are doing this currently right now, it naots a vendor? correct, the vendor is going to be for the electronic program to implement that software and guide news the direction of using it and to go into the implementation. okay. That's perfect, thank you. And when
314it talks about where we should be going with the building department, my question really will be more o to the superintendent, when the organizational chart comes back around, I don't believe that fire should be reporting to DR. Lozano, that it needs to be someone who's credentialed so we have to be prepared for when that part comes up as part of the org chart, I wanted to make sure we as a board know that's going to be part of it as well. Okay, we already talked about 75%, almost 80% of contracts are done with vendors so I've already talked about that. I would like to see the full breakdown on that as a follow-up to see where exactly our money's going, is it going to certain vendors, is it -- are they local are they out
315of state in lee waoez -- louisiana, if their people are here for a certain point for the contract duration, so that is as follow-up, thank you. so websinger are going to pause the -- recess the workshop so that we can move boo the -- into the public hearing. you think you're done with this portionfinger then we can conclude it. nice try. okay, say we recess then. we'll recess again the workshop, so that we can move boo -- into the public hearing.