001testing testing one two three. Please stand by. welcome to today's school board workshop. We're happy to have you join us and thankful for your time and dedication to the school district. This meet workshop is now called to order. Please be reminded of the exit doors that are clearly marked from exiting. All attendee must occupy a seat with the exception of media. Once the board room has reached its seating capacity, attendees will be directed to a designated overflow area. Upon activation of the fire alarm system, please exit the room in an orderly fashion and remain outside until the authority that has jurisdiction that's deemed the building safe to return. Thank you for your cooperation. Board member alhadeff will now introduce her school to lead us in the "pledge of allegiance". please stand and remain standing for
002the "pledge of allegiance" with the students of broadview elementary. We want to thank the students. we are broadview elementary. Please stand for the "pledge of allegiance". I pledge allegiance to the flag uft united states of america. And to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under GOD indivisible with liberty and justice for all. great job. yes, thank you. board member leonardi has requested a moment of silence for a staff member from seagul school. thank you. She was a shining example of a teen parent she overcame various challenges and a chived remarkable success. After graduating from is seagul she gave back as a childcare assistance since 1986. This waunz a job for her. For three decades it was her life mission. Warmth and compassion left an indelable impact. She touched the lives of countless people
003offering guidance and inspiration. Please join me in a moment of silence honoring the life of MS. Carolyn span. Thank you. board member rupert has requested a moment of silence MS. Tasha wilson, north region administrative support who has recently passed away. Supporting the office of school performance and accountability in the north region office despite her bat well multiple health challenges, tasha continued to serve our schools vilantly. Please keep her family in your prayers. Please join me in a moment of silence. Thank you. I would like to request a moment of silence for a staff member from physical plant operations. Please join me in the moment of silence. Thank you. Also ask to you join me in a moment of silence for alexander rereny also a staff member from the physical plant operation who recently passed away.
004thank you. On friday, broward public schools will commemorate 7 years since an active assailant injured 7 members of community and killed 17 innocent students and staff members. This morning, the school board of broward county will paws for a moment of reflection to recognize the loved ones who were tragically killed on FEBRUARY 11, 2014. DR. Holness. aaron vice. Helena peti. alex shackter. Cara lockrin. carmen shintlop. Gina montelo. helena ramsey. Jamie gotenbergh. And my daughter, alyssa alhadeff. my husband, chris hixon. joaquin oliver. luke boyer. martin lucay. meadow poluck. nicholas doret. Peter wong. scott. And scott beagle. these remarkable individuals will never be forgotten. Thank you to the entire broward counted' schools community for participating in the day of love and service on friday and for honoring these beloved students and staff members. thank you. As we prepare
005to begin this school board workshop we are reminded that our vision is 100 percent proficiency for all our students as an a-rated school district we begin the task of achieving this achievement. Our theme this year is believe and power achieve one broward. Today's workshop will operate in accordance with school board policy 1020 and the board will review the items as advertised and presented by the superintendent. Our first item for discussion is bond oversight committee report fiscal year 25 quarter one. I now turn it over to staff for a brief presentation. good morning, I'll turn it over to MR. Shim. thank you, good morning, MADAM Chair, board members and MR. Superintendent. My name is omar shim I'm director of capitol budget. On DECEMBER 19th, we met with the bond oversight committee and we reviewed the bond
006oversight committee quarterly report for the first quarter which ended on SEPTEMBER 2024. Later on today, you will hear more update status of the program but, this is a opportunitied I have a guest with us MR. William tracy a member of the bond oversight committee to give a brief update of the meeting. Thank you. good morning, MADAM Chair, members of the board, MR. Superintendent and staff. This quick update is from the DECEMBER 19th, 2024 meeting of the bond oversight committee covering fiscal year 25, quarter one. Key take aways, the quarter one report show that over the summer of 2024, an average of 10 projects a month moved into substantial con mraoetion of what you term 21b, we remarked that by the quarter two report the number of proj thaekts were in substantial completion or completed will
007exceed the number of projects that are still on going. We also want to thank the board for revision of policy 8,000 which is stream lined the change order process and has not only tightened up the process but has really improved the way that we can move these projects forward. And we also want to thank the board for the reduced quorum requirement, we're still looking for a couple more members. It's but at least now one person can't show up, we can still have our meeting. Then, the cumulative change orders over the course of this bond, has been kept very low, state wide, bond projects, bond program, change orders are running seven to nine percent. This current bond is running at just 1.7 percent which we think is excellent. And then, the small business minority women business
008enterprise participation is running at 44.98 percent currently which is almost statistically identical to our goal of 45 percent and acome is confident that they'll be able to reach that 45 percent before this closed out and many of the reasons why many of these projects are being delayed has to do with final fire inspections for alarms and sprinklers. Apparently in the review process, projects are approved and then, when it comes to the final inspection and the walk through, the inspectors are finding instances where they need to say change a detector from smoke to heat or add an enunciater, it really gums up the process because it has to go back to design and go out to bid, you have to fight over change orders. Another is a fire marshal and I'm a building official and our
009process is we have our plan examiner also go out and perform inspections. It makes them better plan examiners and also improves the entire process. Apparently due to changeover and staffing shortages, many times and I've seen this happen in other situations where the plan examiner, they just don't go out in the field anymore. So they look at something and then three years later, it's built and an inspect or goes out and sees things that, were either missed or perhaps a scope of work changed and it didn't become apparent that that also changed other things. And it's what we, we term a cascade affect. But, and of the projects that are fighting to reach substantial completion, the number one thing is done, updating the fire alarm system fire sprinkler system and that's my report. go ahead. I
010also wanted to recognize the chair stopped by for a little bit and thank her for that. Thank you, we'll take questions from the board. okay, are there any public speakers on this item? no ma'am. okay, thank you. board members? MS. Alhadeff? question on page 19. In regards to the 25 projects that will not be completed by OCTOBER 2025 and then specifically it speaks to four projects for further discussion, can you elaborate on that? DR. Hepburn? MR. Shim? DR. Hepburn if I MAY. go ahead, paul. mac entire can you speak to that, this is dated information it's no longer on the list, so mac entire, can you speak to that? mic please. hello, this one should be. Yeah. check, one two. Good morning, MADAM Chair. Board members, superintendent, michael mac entire e a com program director.
011When this was issued it was on data, the four projects was there that had not been on design. They were on hold for various reasons by the district. I believe it's now down to three projects that are determination has not been made on what will happen with those three projects. They have not been assigned project numbers yet. So the scope is unknown. The depth of the project is unknown. and what schools are those three projects at? MS. Alhadeff, we will provide that information in the next presentation on the smart update but the three schools are bennett, north fork and broward estates. Broward estate s is part of the redefining initiative but we will brief this afternoon on the smart update. can somebody speak on the projects not being completed by the 2025. there are a
012number of projects that will not abstain substantial completion 110b by the end of OCTOBER. That number is constantly influx. It is fluid, it's based on issues that are arised during a project such as you heard about fire alarms, we have a number of projects that have been extended out because additional fire alarm devices have been added. That requires us in essence to go into design, argue with the contract and/or engineer at the time regarding a change order. Once approved, abstain the equipment and install the equipment. So we have a number of projects ex tenlded out due to firearms and we have a number of projects, I believe it's 26 now that are in limbo due to legal issues. Claims or litigation have been filed where work has slowed down and architects have stopped working. That
013just drives the end date, so they have now slipped past the OCTOBER date. and I don't know if the information, what I'm going to ask is the in the 120-page document but what I would like to know from the 15 projects what is the issue why this will not be completed by the OCTOBER of 2025? and by your comments I feel like you're also saying from the 304 projects that are going to be completed that you possibly think that there might be issues in some of those 304 projects and if so, I would like to also know what school and what the issue is? DR. Hepburn? staff? we will provide a follow-up of that but what I would ask is let us do the smart update and that will provide some additional detail. okay, thank
014you. And then in regards to this fire alarm issue, I would like to understand that a little bit better, peel back the layers on that. Is it an issue from our fire chief? From an outside fire chief? Why are we I guess, going down this path where we think we are doing a correctly and then, there is a I got you at the end from the fire chief. So can we, can you explain that, DR. Hepburn? DR. Hepburn? staff. so there are mult able reasons. Part of is when the project starts, that's when the architect makes the design, and correct me if I'm not saying exactly correctly. But the architect makes the design if they MISS The detectors in the original design, all the contractor knows is to build it at the design. And they're
015there is various inspections along the way. And at the end of the project, if it's not cocompliant, the fire official cannot sign off on it. We have to go back and put those detectors in there, based on code. So it really starts at the projects. And many of these projects as you know, went over, span over years. And so that's what I have seen. In my time here. is it our fire official? That is making this determination? yes, based on code. Because if the fire official were to approve the building and something happened later on, the district would be liable. So the fire official similar to the building official is required to approve based on the code at the time of the design. okay, so I guess, how do we prevent further delays? Do we
016need to get our fire official into the school sooner to try to figure out where these gaps of fire alarm systems are? I mean, we have to be more proactive I feel like because reer now going beyond OCTOBER of 2025 and not to say that this is an excuse but I feel like we need to have a stronger plan of action to figure out how we can fix this. so one of the things if I MAY, and as you understand that this bond program has been going on for ten years. And we've had a change in the fire official, but one of the improvement is that the fire official is at our weekly meeting and we talk through some of these things. So the number of required has gone down but still in all good
017conscience, you know, we have to follow code and we have to make sure that before the fire official approves the proj thaekt it's done by code to law for the safety of our kids. So we are, we have drilled down quite a bit on the number of fire devices that are required. But the operative word is, they are required. So if you missed a project at the beginning, MS. Alhadeff, if you missed the design, if you missed a project, that causes a lot of delays. If the contractor installs them incorrectly and puts a screw out of place whatever, that causes delays. What I've experienced dm my seven months here, is that, when they do the various walk throughs and stuff, that's when you identify and I think it's been kind of in the past, you
018get all of these fire devices and requirements at the end of the project. That's what we've put under a microscope and examined. Some of is due to contractor error some is due to designerors so there are various discusses. But the reality is some of these projects are four and five years old, you know. And there is really no excuse for this. But what I wanted to say is basically, each project is different, some requires three devices. I've had some as much as 80 dwiesz which is concerning. and so our objective is to get the project as closed out as quickly as possible. But when you have a four-year delay on a project and then say, you know, three years later, I want to close out in OCTOBER, sometimes that's not realistic just bayeds on the
019various issues that have plagued this program throughout. yep. Yeah, I hear you and obviously we're going to be in compliance with the flor fire code. However, I guess what I'm trying to say is with I would like to see a more aggressive approach to figure out how we can make this more efficient, maybe it means, we need to have a consultant of an additional fire chief person to be able to analyze to go into school to analyze it, because at the end of the day, if we can puted more manpower on the job, we're going to save more time and money, remember the longer we keep extending this the longer this smart project just expands. I would love, DR. Hepburn, for to you come up with a more aggressive plan of action to figure out
020the fire alarms and if it means coming back to the board and asking us for, you know, to implement something additional with the fire chief or some type of consultant, that's my ask. Thank you. thank you, DR. Zeman? thanks, chair. I wonder to preface my comment that's will be repeated over and over today. Can you look at the resolution that we passed, I think it's on page two or three of the original page three. Chair, if you go down to the 9th whereas, would you mind sharing that with the rest of the board? hold on a second. Sorry, I seem ton be on the right page. Rere is, soy. The h h erereas. Whereas all smart projects will be completed and being utilized for the intended purpose as designed. terrific. And, I'd be curious if
021what we're seeing on slide 19 is consistent with the resolution of the broward school board? DR. Hepburn? no, this is not consistent with the expected close out of all of the project. I'm just going to follow-up to MS. Alhadeff's comments. This board has been repeatedly, not while we've been on it, but in the past, formerly investigated and come up wanting in our supervisor of the construction project. And we do things like pass resolution nz 2023 that suggest, not suggest but say, we want to get through financial close out not substantial completion, not intended use, not 110b, but through and even with the lower standard, we continue to say we're going to get fewer and fewer projects done. Scott travis article in the sunset was castigating and telling the community that we promised a lot toward
022the end of the smart deadline 2025, but we're over promising and under delivering on construction in broward county schools. this report, has more news that is disappointing. Chair, do you know how many fire inspection right side in the length of generational project? DR. Hepburn? staff? I will refer to acom,Mac mac entire. michael mac entire, acon, through the chair, typical project would have two reviews and multiple what we call in-progress inspection and then the final inspection. The two drivers of issues are the initial plan review, which is which is plan review is a initial approval process of the design. The second review is what we call shock on fire alarms particularly where the contractor has basically resubmitted the design concept but with much more detail information as far as the equipment to be used. That is
023reviewed and also approved. And then, during the project, as work is on going, there is what we call either rough inspections or in progress inspections. And during those inspections, it's eyes on from the inspect or, meaning they're walking the building, and they're look at the work that fits into their scope and their checking it for code compliance and doesn't meet the requirements of the design. We have multiple of those inspections then the final inspection is when the work is done and that's where approval is received. we have to receive approval on all scopes of work before we can get a building permit which moves into 1-10b, and that's beneficial use and then there are theoretically there are two final completions where the contractor gets paid out, the paid out financial project close and then the
024project close takes one year from the date of substantial completion, that's the warranty period. That's the process across all scopes whether it comes to inspection sxz reviews. thank you very much. And chair, I think I heard our much appreciated member of the bond oversight committee and thank you for taking the time to come and present this news today. Suggest, that in his career, there was an opportunity for the people who did it at the beginning, the planners to be informed bit inspexz along the way and I think we just heard acon, 8 or 10 moments, how much more money did we have to spend? How long were these buildings not ready to go? Which is what the standard set resolution is, I think that the public and this board would be you know, frustrated, outraged
025maybe that another issue kind of comes up and it's fire alarms this time, it's been roofs, it's been airconditioners. One of the big challenge, chair that we have as a board, is our ability to oversee a project when we get is a 709 page report. If I was a member of grand jury and any investigative group and say here's all the data with no key performance indicators that say this project is late this MAY not be moving forward. It's nl the kind of oversight document that would allow us to feel good about it. 20 years ago, I was responsible for ave large project and 20 years ago, we had indicators that went to our board and said this is where we're behind at the pentagon. And if we can do that 20 years ago with
02680-86 processes and lap tops that had a crank side on the side, in 2025, we need to do a better job so that things like fire alarms become apparent early on and we fulfill our obligation on this budget. What I'm superly concerned about at this point, is 2028 which has not been a subject of our board yet to this board yet. But 2028 is the earliest where they can ask another commission to go out for a bond. And at the last time we checked, we need between 24 million no matter how many schools remain open in the future and we're going to be highly dependent on the bond passing so we can make progress. I hope that overtime we can keep this on the agenda. I don't think that we should have a workshop where
027we don't talk about construction. I hope we shift our focus from air-conditioners and roofs and fire alarms to very large issues like are we going to be able to go back to the public and ask for more of their money? And I think right now, I don't want this to be the first school bond to fail in broward county history. they've been very generalous for construction, teacher pay, for mental health and safety and security but I'm really worried about 2028 and I would like us and MR. Superintendent, this is just a recommendation from me, to come up with a different way to communicate to the board about the risks that are implicit in all of our projects rather than a 7 19-page three-ring binder. I can pour through that and I can read it and
028I can find individual projects but I cannot tell whether the capitol program which is what we're moving to is operating in a way that we're going to win the trust of the vote wherz we're just a little bit down the road. Thank you, chair. thank you. MS. Leonardi? just real quick since this is the beginning of the workshop, I was wondering and because I've noticed that this is maybe more pertinent to the kind of questions that we ask the smart program. Board members ask a lot of questions in our workshops and in our -- board meeting or the next day if the board is provided with the list and tracking number of all the follow-up requested or promised? DR. Hepburn? noted. We keep track of a one page, we can send that out after the
029meeting. thank you. MS. Fam? thank you. I agree a lot with what zeman said. I just want to point out in the resolution, number 7 and 8 state, that we are committed the board is requiring this program be completed by OCTOBER 31, 2035. I remember when we discussed this, we were very clear that if this was not a reasonable date we wanted to be aware of that. This was in stone, this day was going to be, met and we could rely on this with the community in make thising public. In addition, it says, that this includes, the expectation of financial close out in full expenditure on the general obligations of the bond funds, again, we're failing on those. We're not living up to our word and frankly, tired of losing credibility and I low a
030lot of people are too that sit on this board. So I have several questions, I have three that I'm going to ask. Number one, I'm going to give you all three and you can answer them. What should we as a board have done or or what should the district or board have done to avoid these delays. Number two, how can we move these projects forward, the 25 and then the other three so we can meet that OCTOBER 2025, or OCTOBER 31 deadline. And actually on number three, are we identifying and red flagging, the designers and contract thaerz are causing these delays so we can move them out of the system? Because if we cannot rely on them, they don't bring a lot to the table, we need to be able to trust these contractors that
031they're going to live up to their commitment because the community is dependent on them. I would like answers to those questions? DR. Hepburn. if we can go one by one. what should the district and the board have done to avoid these delays? What can we have done to avoid these delays? that's an excellent question as far as how this program was initialed in the beginning, and I guess that time was 2014, 2013, I'll let MS. Paul answer that based on her plethora of experience talk about how a program should be initialed to move forward and be in completion in four or five years. do we have penalties in place when this happens? When it's an omission by a contractor? I'm going to have her answer the first question and we can go to the rest.
032MS. Paul? so part of, and I'm just going to be extremely honest on this. Part of it is, I think the district was caught flat footed before the bond. The bond is more than just engaging in the community and getting the support. That is extremely important but, you need to have a lot of preparation on operational logitic side of the house, right? So once that vote is passed in NOVEMBER, you have to already have a plan of execution. You need to have your architects are willed red before the board all of that preparation happens well before the voters even cast their vote. And if it doesn't pass, then you don't have to do anything but at least you have your vendors and all of that stuff lined up. did we do that? my experience is,
033you have to have your architects ready and based on the timeline that you went out for the bond, there is more than just broward that is going out for bonds. So you're competing for the same resources, the same contractors so, the prep work is extremely extremely important post passing or getting the voters, getting the voters approval of the bond. So I think that if it takes you three to four years, to actually start or see construction then you've already lost that battle, you cannot make up that time and in many of the projects that's what I saw where they didn't get started, like started in a very aggressive manner. You don't get aggressive at the end of a bond program you're aggressive at the beginning. You've got to get, we talk often times about speed
034to market, that's what it's about. Because the longer you wait to get the projects on the street, the more money it costs you. So you know, just totally missed the boat, missed the plane at the very beginning for three years. maz fam. and what was the second question. how can we -- -- . maz fam. -- MS. Fam. Can you read those questions and when we come back to the smart bond which is the third item, we'll start with you and MS. Rupert. she disappeared, I'll ask her when she comes back. If you read the questions so they'll be ready to answer them so we can move along. sure, how can we move those 25 projects and the other three that are delayed. What we can do to move them at a faster pace. Number
035three, are we identifying and red flagging and holders designers and contractors accountable if they diverted the project and working somewhere else, whatever the reason for the delay. We need some accountability and we need something in place that says we're going to do dh and get this done. This is those are my questions. MS. Rupert are your questions can we get through them in ten minutes or hold them until we get to the smart bond. I'll be more than happy to hold them. It's a little comingled. thank you. Yes, sir. thank you, MADAM Chair. Just for the record, I know na it says here on one of the whereas as pointed out, about financial close out and full expenditure about the bond, although we will not close out some of these projects by the time in
036OCTOBER 2025, I just wanted the board to know that we have fully expanded the bond funds and let you know that that part of it is done. thank you, I was going to point that out and I'll end this so we can move on to the oin. I have a question for, you did mention that in your plan xler do inspection to see improve the process. So hearing what you heard from aecom, do you feel like we're doing that? Or what is the difference? If we have them involved in all of these steps, it does not make sense to me how we're failing inspections at the end? I would doubt that the plan examiners that reviewed the fire systems actually went out in the field normally, that's a job for inspectors and a lot of
037times when people become a plan examiner, they never go outback on the field. That's something that I've been trying to change in, in our building official association here in broward county. Another disconnect is, buyer inspect or often don't talk with building inspectors, they enforce the florida protect code, we enforce the florida building code. And there are some mismatches where the fire code MAY require one thing and the building code requires something else. And our, we've been working together, we've been having workshops the past couple of years, every quarter for their fire marshals and building officials meet. And the standard is, if you have two completing requirements, the most restrictive is the one that applies. So something MAY pass building inspection but fire inspection does not. And then another, another issue was with regard to the
038bond, a lot of the projects were assessed based on the 2014fca, the facilities condition assessment. And it seems that some of those assessments of facilities were done in a manner that that hidden problems, did not come about. So that's one of the issues with the roof problems that ended up costing double or triple because you take the roof off and you find, there is termites, and we have to tent the building and we have to replace the proof treses on the wood structure. That the roof MAY seem fine if you do a core on the roof but if you get underneath, you would have to take out the hard ceiling inside to see the condition of the underlying structure is bad. There are in the past ten years, there is been tremendous improvement in detecting
039tools that can give a much more accurate assessment of condition of the existing facilities. And then, one last thing, a key popoint mrmac entire from acom mentioned there are rough inpexes one key point is what we call a framing walk through before they start covering up all the walls. If a building inspector and fire inspector walked through together and did a joint inspection, there would be better opportunity to catch issues, you're going to need paolt station here because of the use of this room. Get those things corrected before you cover things up. It's a lot cheaper plus you're also at typically, the 60 percent point in a project so you have more time to make that up. Instead of coming through the final inspection. Usually the final is when everything is done. great. Thank you.
040So DR. Hepburn consider the fire inspector and building inspector, we can make it workout that they do that together t.Seems like everybody is working in a silo and the suggestion is that we should be working in tandem to make sure that we're getting these things done. I would like to suggest that we take the recommendation and make sure that is happening moving forward. if I MAY, chair, to that point, MS. Paul has made some updates to how many of these things play of course, of course we cannot change what happened in the past but many of the things that MR. Tracy is talking about, have been implemented as we close out and get MS. Paul quickly talk about that because I know we're on a time certain. so MS. Hixon, your description is exactly right
041that's what I found when I first got here. Part of the changes is we made is to have the weekly meeting with both the fire official as well as the building official who reports to me. At the meeting and we do iron out those situations where there is a question on the number of dwiesz and on that sort of thing, but this is where we find ourselves right now with many projects that are coming to a close and we sit and we work through what we can do by code to resolve these issues. One of the things that I want to say is that MS. Pearl and nathan, the building and fire official, they work very well together. Part of the challenge too is yuft just the number of inspectors, building code inspectors as well
042as fire officials as you'll see in the later presentation from the building department. We outsource about 75 percent of personnel and it's very difficult to hire these people and house. If we had to do it again, I would be a fire official because they're in high demand, I've checked with my other companions down south at palm beach and they struggle with the same thing, we cannot pay them to work within the district so we outsource a lot of that work. But in terms of what MS. Hixon alluded to working together, we're doing in my opinion, a better job. It's unfortunate that we could not do that at the beginning of the program, obviously I was not here and the people that we have in positions were not in a position to do this. So now
043we are. the objective right now to close out very aggressive about closing out these projects as acom and myself can attest to, we're dealing and sins of the past. Again, I think we all agree that the best thing we can do is close these projects out as soon as possible and prepare and build a steady foundation for the future. And that is the goal of my team and some of the decisions that we have going forward are going to be difficult decisions but they have to be made as we prepare the future. thank you, and I'll close with one other thing. When we did the resolution, I think staff was very clear to us that it would be almost impossible to finish all of the projects that we had to date and we said whatever
044is not considered smart anymore would roll into our capitol projects and we asked for, I personally asked for a list because we can be with clear with the public so we can go on that list and what would roll into the capitol projects and that's muddled and not really obvious so I appreciate that moving forward, we have some names on here and like we said, we wanted to under promise and over perform, I don't think that that's what we've been doing and we're continuing to follow behind and that was not the intent of what the resolution was, it was to be able to close the door and move forward and have the trust of the public again. As b u as a reminder we did spend all the bond money and we're now working within
045our own capitol funds. chair what is the relevance of that point? When we made this resolution, we knew. The resolution said we wanted projects financially closed out by OCTOBER 31, 2025, and my point is, that's not what is on the report. I hear you. But the question is all of the money, where did it go, expectation includes the financial close out and full expenditure of the obligation bond and the point is, we did spend the full expenditure of the actual bond money. That was my point. Thank you so much for your presentation and we're going to move on to the next item. MADAM Chair. yes. we need a recess for ten minutes, for a technical issue. okay. you need to say it. we will recess for ten minutes.