001(Meeting in recess). welcome to the public hearing of the school board of broward county, florida, for public comment on instructional materials recommended for adoption in 2025-26, this public hearing is now called to order. Our primary focus is to create a safe and productive environment for all participants, please be reminded of the exit doors that are clearly marked for emergency exiting. While in the board room, refrin from obstructing the doors, once the board room has reached its seating capacity, attendees will be directed to a designated overflow area. Upon activation of the fire alarm system, please exit from the room in an orderly fashion and continue to exit the building and remain outside until the authority that tha has jurisdiction has derailed the building safe to return. Thank you for your cooperation. All please rise for the
002pledge of allegiance to the flag of the united states of america. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands one nation under GOD, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. thank you, are there any changes fo the agenda, DR. Hepburn? there are no changes. thank you. MAY the chair have a motion and a second to close the agenda. moved. second. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, second by MRS. Rupert. All those in favor of close thing agenda, say yes. yes. any opposed, say no. Motion cairns. MAY the chair have a motion and a second to move the items to the floor. yes. so moved. sek. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Rupert to move the item to the floor. As
003we prepare to begin our public hearing wre, reminded our vision is 100% proficiency for all of students, our vital task is to sustain this achievement. We will continue educating all students to reach their highest potential, our theme is believe empower achieve broward, this is to keep the public and school board fully identified as to the whether the district is using sound policies and pranks and warrant public confidence in the district's operation. The law require it is public be given the opportunity to provide input to the adoption of instructional and digital materials. This is the public hearing to hear public comment for the 25-26 instructional and digital materials adoption for k-12 science. Is there anyone in the audience would wants to address the item? You must register at back of this room. I mean call on
004each of you after the superintendent's presentation. Each listed speaker will be given three minutes to address the board. This will allow for each person to be heard and for the business before the board to be handled in the most expedient manner. We thank you for your support of the broward county school district and for your attendance at this public meeting. DR. Hepburn will now give a brief overview of the instructional and digital materials recommended for adoption in 2025-26. thank you, MADAM Chair, I'm pleased to submit the instructional and digital materials planned recommended for the k-12 science adoption in 25-26 for the school board's consideration and adoption, florida statute 1006 .40 requires public access to the recommended digital materials and a school board hear tog receive public comment. Broward county public skol has the duty and
005responsibility to provide instructional and digital materials to support instruction. The materials selected must be align today the academic standards and reflect the most current information. Each year based on the state adoption cycle, district staff and teachers review instructional and digital materials for designated subjects and select the best suited materials for use. The subject area reviewed rotates each year allowing for materials, they are generally used for five years, for the 25-26 school year, the designated subject area for review was science for k-12, recommended titles include continually components and interactive features, district staff from innovative learning will provide a brief presentation of the reck edged instructional and digital materials for the k-12 science adoption for the 25-26 school year, following the presentation, staff will be available to answer any questions. thank you. Good afternoon, once again, we
006are here to present on the public hearing for the science adoption and an agreement with all things previously stated, our process is in alignment with the broward county schools strategic plan supporting the goal of early literacy, the goal of science proficiency, the goal of college and career readiness. Additionally all statute has been filed in relationship to our process so it is an equitable process that has transparency as far as the review of all instructional materials. As of JULY 1, 2024, there was a definition changed to what adequate instruction materials are defined as and broward county public schools is in alignment with that process and our purchasing experience is inclusive of digital materials and paper based materials and we have the flexibility to buy accordingly so we can fiscally sound. If we can go to slide
007number 4, so with the process in order to maintain our transparency sh we use the ed credible tool which houses all the responses from all teachers that participate in the review process, it goes through a rating scale as well where that data is kept so we are selecting the highest quality of curriculum for our students but the subject matter experts from various departments including sekt dare, elementary and content area practitioners participate in this review to ensure we are in alignment with all state standards so that our materials align. Additionally we did have a revision in our statute in 2019 to make sure we were in alignment with the commitment to eliminating the common core and we are following within that tradition. Just for a point of clarification, the science can k-12 adoption, the list of
008approved materials on slide 6 was approved on 7/2, 2024 and up tainted 12/12/2024 and all of the titles listed in this presentation are adopted and approved by the state. You will see on slide 7 through 9, you will have a robust list of all of the core courses that we are covering within science, additionally, these -- all vendors are inclusive of having print and digital content as previously mentioned. Again, we want to highlight that when it comes the our ap courses, the instructional materials advanced placement courses are not purchased by the district, they are purchased by individual schools and that is dictated by what those schools offer based on their master schedule, so I wanted to make sure that that was clear that those dollars are not included in the overall request for the instructional
009materials adoption because that particular line item is absorbed at the school level for ap courses only, all other courses that are in the curriculum that all students have to go through k-12 na are general education are outlined in this presentation and that would conclude our presentation but for your edificationfinger we do have a robust section with appendices where you would be able to click the hyperlinks for every single textbook so you could go through in detail what the courses offer within that text, additionally, these links are available in the broward county school's calendar on today's public hearing date and that would be available to the public through the duration of this process until we come to an adoption and we also did the appropriate legally public notice where the link was also offered along with
010the list of materials and that would conclude our initial presentation and we would be open for any questions you MAY have. thank you. Speakers will now be called to the floor by name and are requested to state their name and address, I think just the city you live in before beginning their comment, each speaker will be allowed three minutes to address the board. MADAM Chair, we have one registered speaker, DR. Trudy jermanovich. my name is trudy jermanovich and I'm pleased to represent the public. In adoption and purchase of the digital materials for teaching science, I'm reminded we must follow these purchases carefully to make sure there is equitable distribution of resources to all schools. It appears that both the digital versions and paper versions are included in this purchase. As I've discussed before, it is
011very difficult to read any book on a computer, tablets are necessary for individuals to read comfortably, teachers should are the electronic versions of the textbooks and a tablet before the end of this school year so they can better plan for this transition to using the new textbooks next school yardmen I sent out my comments to groups of parent and is teachers sometimes the schools will go out and buy their own books, the high schools purchase their own books for cambridge and ap because they receive that extra fte when a student assess a test, so the books has the money to pass their courses, when it comes to middle elementary schools, my office purchases the books for cambridge courses. and it's not in this particular presentation, are you fully funded to buy every middle school student
012that signs up for the kale bridge class, the books that they need, like a class set at least? I haven't done the fuel math yet, DR. Zeman, to see if I'm fully funded for every school does. I've had funds to buy books that every school has needed. if we say it offers cambridge courses, we better have cambridge books, if we push that into the school budget, I don't think so, this comes of the central budget. We can't say kim bridge and not do the cambridge books. that's noted, just some clarify kayingsinger, every student a MAY not be in that cambridge course, when you say all middle school students, that MAY not apply, we'll make sure it gets budgeted and funded appropriately. I don't want to go through what we went through this past year, lessons
013learned and monitoring that to make sure we purchase those books. any other board members have comments? Okay, thank you so much for your presentation. thank you. [Applause]. the scheduled order of business for this public hearing of the school board of broward county, florida, has been completed. Seeing no objection, I now adjourn the meeting.