001few minutes. What it was going to entail. maz batista. any other board member. yes, I'm confused on robert's here. We had an item that MR. Holness, brought. We had an amendment to the item and now we have a substitute motion. We cannot have three things on the floor at the same time, where is this going to we can land the plane? there is two substitute motions. no, absolutely cannot have two situations. we just did that before. we get perfected through amendments but one competes against the other, you cannot have three. MS. Batista? you can have two motions to the motion and that's not substitute motions. that's what we have. We have DR. Holness's motion, my original change. yeah, there is like four now. If you really want them owl. So my suggestion is that, without
002the, you know without objection, that you know, one of the motion be withdrawn since basically the one just made by MS. Bulman is very similar to the prior one. So I don't know which one, honestly I lost track. This one here is yours and the first one was DR. Holness. right. physician MAY, chair. MS. Bulman's option is an easy to add after your substitute motion which was amended by folks. so if you voted on your amendment, then MS. Bulman can then enter that with she's willing withdrawal without objection. I'll withdrawal. since we left on there, did we vote on DR. Holness's amendment? we didn't vote on anything. let's vote on DR. Holness's amendment to my motion. How is that? So DR. Holness's amendment was to say additionally direct the superintendent to explore all options including
003partnerships and possible cost for internet access for all students at home. All those in favor say aye. aye. all those. aye. all those opposed say no. no. roll call. school board members, zeman. nope. alhadeff. no. bulman. no. fam. yes. hixon. yes. holness. yes. leonardi? no. rupert. no. thompson. no. fails. 3-6. okay, thank you. And now, MS. Bulman I think you want to make a motion? I do but I don't remember exactly what that motion said. Did you happen to know. to add demonstrate need after all students, in between all students and at home. okay. is there a second. second. public comment? School board, board member comment? Okay, great. MADAM Chair. yes, DR. Holness. I'm so sorry, I did not hear the prior motion, pass. it did not. thank you. all those in favor of the
004motion to add demonstrate need after students say aye. aye. all those opposed say no. no. roll call. sorry, school board members alhadeff. yes. bulman. yes. fam. yes. hixon? yes. holness. yes. leonardi. yes. rupert? no. thompson. yes. zeman. no. 7-2, passes. so now we'll vote on the motion as a whole. the item as a whole. oh the item as amended. So all those in favor of item bb -- . chair, I'm sorry, we still have DR. Holness's motion, and then we have a substitute motion that you've written up. that's what I was thinking. We didn't vote on my it total substitute. not yet. We can. that's what I thought we were doing thank you. All those in favor of the substitute motion for item bb10 which was to direct the superintendent to ensure that all broward
005county school students have computer access at both school and home as well as internet access at home by AUGUST 11, 2025 and collaborate with partners to seek internet access to demonstrate needs through grants and programs. All those in favor say aye. aye. those opposed say no. no. two noes. okay, so the motion passes. Okay, so yes, now we have to vote on the item as amended. All those in favor of item bb10 as amended say aye. aye. all those opposed say no. wait a minute, wait a minute, MADAM Chair, we need to read the motion as amended back into the record. I just did. I'm sorry I didn't hear you. We voted on one which passed and you said there is an amended motion. right, that is the amended motion. according to robert's rules, we
006have to read the motion. the idea is amended because that motion passed. So we have to vote on the item altogether. okay. so the item now reads the direct the superintendent to ensure that all broward county school students have computer access ated both school and home as well as internet access at school by AUGUST 11th, 2025 additionally collaborate with all students at home through various grants and access programs. All those in favor of the item as amended say aye. aye. those opposed say no. no. two descending votes. thank you, motion carries. The next items we're going to bring together, bb6 and bb7. Can I have a motion to bring them to the floor. so moved. it's been moved by MS. Leonardi, second by MS. Rupert. any public comment? no ma'am. board member. MS. Alhadeff. in
007regard to these bb items, I want to throw out the conversation something that we can discuss for next year. It's very very expensive for all of us to go to up for broward days. Just putting it out there, like maybe we have the chair and the vice chair go next year to represent the school board, because it would be more cost affective. I do want to see for this year, that there is a stronger plan with our legislative platform and using our lobbyist up in tallahassee to help us as school board members have meetingings with elected officials to speak on legislative platform. I mean, I've been for the last two or three school years, I cannot go this year, I'll be in las vegas for public safety. But if we have a more of a
008strategic plan and the lobbyist that we pay a lot of money for help school board members get key meetings to help lobby for our legislative platform. I know we spend the day with our students which is amazing, I just think there would be a stronger plan. board discussion, DR. Zeman. I appreciate that. I'm not sure, I don't share my legislative adventures with school colleagues I don't want to trip my time with chair. I'm spending my time talk to go people that actually legislate and people that influence legislation and those two days have been very productive for broward county in the past. My own view, would not want to deny an elected leader to go meet another elected leader. You'll never know that with non vice chair, gets together and you get something moving that was
009not going to get moving before. I also think it's fascinating for all school members to see public hearings and go to the education on the house side and appropriations committee and watch how the sausage is made up there. On your issue with the strategic use of our lobbyist, we need to do better. We do not have an acceptable system in place for my standards. We should have fewer items. They should be broward items, that affect us, and we should engage our lobbyist when we can go up there and make calls and do things otherwise. But I think part of the item of having fewer people, maybe based on the fact that not everybody knows what everybody else is doing on the board and what affect did they did have through the legislatures that they know
010from in area. I won be in favor of restricting but I think that we can use our lobbyist far more effectively than we have in the past two years. thank you, anybody else? MS. Rupert? I think there should be a conversation about helping us get the message across up there. I think our team does a good job but we can always do better as a school board and speaking up for our students and our community. I do like it when the legislatures are brought to us, I think that's better use of our time. So it's a rotating come around, we're here, we stay there and they're all coming to see us, that's the power of having really good lobbyist. We do that with the greater florida consortium, I won really want to limit an elected
011official just because especially the broward days part, maybe the only place you get to visit other broward elected officials and how you can work together as a team. We're all broward, then we're all team here for here for the kids and community. That would be a conversation that I'll be willing to have but I do want to say that our team does a great job and I do enjoy coming having the legislatures come to us and I know they're busy and last-minute changes but that five-ten minutes, you really have 100 percent of their attention and I wholehearted especially when we're there with our students, there is nothing better that ignites their faces and honestly those kids are super happy to go. I'm lacking forward to it, thank you for bringing thaup, MS. Alhadeff. okay, anybody
012else? All those in favor of bb6 and 7 say aye. aye. any opposed? Says no. Thank you, item passes. The next item up is bb11. MAY I have a motion and a second on bb11. so moved. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Alhadeff. Any public comment? no ma'am. okay, MS. Alhadeff. thank you, so I'm bringing this forward asking the board to approve the eagle's act of 2025 to our federal legislative plat forms. This honors the 17 victims at the margely stillman douglas tragedy. It helps through k through 12 students threat assessments and reauthorizes the expansion of the national threat assessment center of the department of homeland security. thank you, any other? Suggestions? I don't think we don't need a second, it's an item. Thank you for bringing it forward. It's important we,
013I think lead the nation in threat assessments and we do that because we have a relationship with entack and they have shared information with us so to make sure that it's codified and to continue to have fupding, I appreciate you bringing this forward. All those in favor say aye. aye. any opposed? Motion carries, thank you. Next item is bb12 can I have a motion and a second on bb12. so moved. moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Leonardi. Any public comment? no ma'am. public school board comment. I'm going to start this time because I brought the item forward and just kind of explain it and then there is an action that we have to take. So, the chair of the new solid waste authority of broward county it's a brand new commit other that the
014county instilled because as we know solid waste is a hot topic and there is a lot of issues on how we're running out of places to store and take care of our waste. So they've asked us to to its a formal request for the broward county school board to appoint a liason to the solid waste authority of broward county executive committee. It's a non voting position because it's already been defined. The purposes of request is to enhance collaboration between the school board and this committee about critical topics, sustainability and solid waste management and since the school board plays a vital role on that, they would like to have somebody there to give their input. I don't see it in here when it meets. The meetings are held on the third friday of each month, scheduled
015from 9 to 11 and prior to materials will be provided. So what action that we're asking for is to appoint somebody so I guess, it's just like when we do committee. Is there anyone thatatisis intetested in servrvinon ts cocommtee?E? I I am. okay, so MS. Bulman and I heard I am MS. Fam. brenda fam. okay, I'm not sure if there is a alternate, so I don't know what we do when two people want to be on. you're the chair make something up. So MS. Bulman, I know that MS. Bulman is working with this committee and people working on it already on a project that looking for, that's what I've been told, MS. Fam would you mind if MS. Bulman is in this right since she's in it. her for sure. it will be in the
016committee going forward then you can have the opportunity if you're still interested in NOVEMBER to voice that interest then. okay. so thank you so much. Okay. MS. Bulman? thank you. I mean, this is a great opportunity for the school board been work withing DR. Hepburn and I think it's a great way to further allow us to be a leader in making initiatives to deal with the solid waste issue and we'll have support from the rest of the county, I have a representation on this task force. So happy for the opportunity. okay, thank you so much. So all those in favor of bb12, say aye. aye. any opposed say no. motion carries. Thanks so much. The next item is bb13. Can I have a motion and a second on bb13. so moved. moved by DR. Zeman,
017seconded by MS. Rupert, somebody over there said it but I don't know who. Any public comment on bb13? Okay. Board member comment? Board member thompson? I just had a question for staff about teacher feedback related to losing their early release days this year. Can we have collected that? DR. Hepburn? no, we haven't collected unless the team has any other antidotal data on teacher feedback about the lack of early release days this year? go ahead MS. Holings worth. good afternoon or good evening, we don't have anything in the qualitative sense, but there is a mix bag I can tell you from our end, it's been a struggle with those release days, we want to make sure that people get their certification and recertify. and then, so I guess as a parent, I am in favor of
018not having release daze, I think -- proposes a childcare issue however I'm concerned about we're requesting more and more of our teacher and we went them to have mental health train anding tech train anding all of these things and we're taking more and more opportunities to learn this. So I am, in favor of this item if it includes, a proposal of how teachers are going to meet these professional development requirement that's we're asking of them? DR. Hepburn? that's noted, I expressed the same concern that we need to be provide quality pd to our teachers we do demand out of them and with new standards and newman dates, new challenges, so as long as we can work with btu to come to a good resolution of how we provide quality and pd opportunities and leverage d
019ask on this item, I'm fine with this as long as we can get to that outcome. thank you, that's it. thank you, all those in favor of item bb13 a tsai. -- aye. aye. all those opposed, say no. no. I have one did I sended vote, we'll roll call if you want, MADAM Chair. okay. school board members, bulman. yes. fam? MS. Fam? Hixon? no. holness. DR. Holness? Leonardi? yes. rupert? no. thompson? yes. zeman. yes. alhadeff. yes. motion passes 5-2. thank you. I'm going to take the next two items together so dd3 and dd4, can I have a motion to bring them to the floor. so moved. moved by MS. Leonardi and seconded by DR. Zeman. Any public comment on dd3 and dd4. no ma'am. so I'm the only one that had a question and I
020have already said this with DR. Lozano but I just want him to say out loud to every one so on dd3 my comment is when you look at it, it shows that monitoring actually the failure rate increased so there was, there is continues to be a bigger problem in monitoring students that are identified and this is frustrating to me. So I know you're going to speak to that and on d4, it should not be even a thought that somebody that knows the student is not part of the threat assessment, that's how you truly get a base line of that, so you can briefly speak to both of those things. MR. Lozano or DR. Lozano. through the chair, security officer, so we'll start with dd3. What you saw is we have robust student support management plans
021and we put a lot of interventions in place for our students in need of intervention sxz particular for this audit so what would happen is, maybe a substitute was teaching the class that day and didn't mark the student as absent. So in the pen cal database shows the student as present so in the log there was not a signature even though that student was absent so because the auditor could not verify that the student was absent, that was marked as a exception. Those with fidelity so out of 1830 days of school year if they MISS Aid day and had one-day of unattendance discrepancy. So we work with our schools and their bta monthly meetings to review those logs. So it really was, even though it looks like an increase, it's, it's a minor detail of
022our overall program and implementing student support management plans. okay, and my suggestion to that so moving forward is that if a teacher is absent, and there isn't somebody to sign it if you can have an assistant principal make sure so that is not, that's low hanging fruit, it's a signature. So I hope that moving forward there is some kind of something in place so that there is a signature and we don't get dinged on that again. duelly noted. And then on, -- . I was going to suggest to maybe make a motion to direct the superintendent to what you said. okay. Do you want to make the motion. so I would like to make a motion to direct the superintendent to put in place the procedure that if a teach cer absent and there is
023a necessity for a signature on a student attendance based on the threat assessment that somebody in administration has to make sure that they've signed off on that. second. okay. Any public comment on the motion? Any board comment on the motion? sorry, I have a process question, if you don't mind chair. To the general counsel is this a legitimate motion to pass the legal review to direct the superintendent to do something inside the school. MS. Batista. it's a motion to put it in place a procedure. I'll ask this begin, that's operational issue, is that something the board can direct the superintendent to do? I think you can direct the superintendent that would you like changes so that the findings are not what they are and then, I think the superintendent through his operational procedures has to
024figure out how to best implement that. okay action but the motion stated sounds like they're telling him how to do that rather than set the goal. yes. I won did if we can restate to set the goal. to put in place the procedure to ensure that the signature is done regardless if the teacher is present or not. second. okay. any other board comment? All those in favor of the motion say aye. aye. any opposed say no. Motion carries, great. And then for dd4. so on dd4, the ability regarding the person with personal knowledge of the student, the whole states switch to the new general model JANUARY first, 2024 in the middle of the school year and as there were new requirements put in for the new model, the ed plan plat fellower didn't have a
025space for administrators to log that individual who served as the individual with personal knowledge. So they were teams were inviting the individual to the meetings, we our plan waunz at the level because they had flipped the whole system and to make that one change for broward, they weren't, that wasn't a high priority for them when they were getting the new platform up and running across the state. So, through mid-FEBRUARY, we had actually in the platform so schools can actually identify who that individual was in FEBRUARY 24. And so moving forward, it was rectified. So, the schools all include an individual currently who has personal knowledge of the stutd enter, so that way we can look at the students base line behavior and make the appropriate decisions. thank you for clarifying that. All those in favor
026of item dd3 and 4 say aye. aye. any opposed say no. Motion carries. Next item is ffi, I have a motion and a motion to bring it to the floor. so moved. second. moved and second. Any public comment. no MADAM Chair. I pulled this one, as I often do thanks so much to the grants department this month, we brought in 597,974.50 in grants but the best part is that in district one, there were seven schools that received the grant so congratulations to all those schools. Any other board members? thanks for recognizing that. I agree it's awesome and keep up the good work, grant department. thank you, all those in favor of f f1 say aye. aye. any opposed say no. F f1 passes, thank you. Gg2? Can I have a motion and a second. so
027moved. it's been moved by DR. Zeman seconded by MS. Rupert. Any public comment? no MADAM Chair. DR. Holness had pulled it but said he didn't need it after all. All in favor say aye. aye. those opposed say no. Motion carries. So the next item is item jj5, and I have a motion and a second. so moved. second. it's been moved by DR. Zeman seconded by MS. Leonardi for jj5 is there any public comment on jj5? no ma'am. okay. Board member comment that's me. So I just want to point out and have a huge concern here and I will say, that we did not do very well on our consultant omissions and errors this month, we have 727,807.71 and point out that lloyd estates, this is a changes order which is the consultant omission for almost
028$100,000. So I, it's dis heartening to me so I don't know if staff can staff can explain why this is considered a consultant omission and that's a pretty big change order. the sektd item on this, that the installation of the roof top units required a structure reinforcements. So this is something that we would need to do either way to complete the project. The project at this time. Is nearing substantial, actually it's 82 percent complete. This is something that we have to do to move the project forward. I'm not contesting that, the problem is that it's a consultant omission. What did they omit? How did the end of this, now? keep in mind that this project started in 2022. Again, whatever occured in terms of the fca this was not included in the designs. So this
029was missed at the beginning of the project. We do not have a policy that addresses this. last week we got a report that said we're significantly lower on errors omission on construction. Can I get those statistics again. What percentage versus the national standard. is would have to give that to you. I remember 1.8. yes, it's very low. and 5.8 percent. errors and omissions happen. It's ugly, like construction is hard, you know, you look' site and you think you're going to need seven supporting pillars and you need 19. Sometimes the geo thermo reports are wrong and that comes through as an error and omission. But our system actually worked very well in terms of errors and omissions. Our ame firms do better than national averages. And where we have agrecious errors, we go after to recruit
030when we can. yes, sir. I just, it's, it's not an issue in broward county, there is an omission. We got, we got to recognize the things that are slowing us down. yes, sir. And I understand, that we are across national average doing a whole lot better than most. But understand part of the discipline that we knee is when we start a project that we need to make sure that we design it appropriately. I would much rather spanned 2022 dollars or 2023 than spend 2025 dollars. Even though we have a low rate and I appreciate you bringing that up and providing that data, I think we still have room in terms of how we manage our programs to improve and that's our goal. thank you. Okay. All those in favor of item jj5 say aye. aye.
031any opposed say no. Motion carries. Next item is jj7 I have a motion and a second. so moved. second. moved by DR. Zeman seconded by MS. Leonardi. Any public comment? no ma'am. MS. Leonardi. I'm good thanks. all those in favor of jj7 say aye. aye. any opposed say no. Motion carries. The next item is jj11. so moved. sorry. i need a motion and a second, moved moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Rupert. Any public comment on jj11? no ma'am. MS. Bulman. my constituents were contacting me about this and I just wanted to thank MS. Paul for being on it and figuring out what the delay was and why there was no work being done on this and moving the project moving in a very quick meaner, so thank you. thank you, I was the
032other question. So I just have a quick question. Why it seems, reading in there, that they took the wall out and they found a window and some other stuff, s so why isisthisis considering g coululta omisisonon and t unforereseen? DR. Hepburn? looks like mike mac entire, go ahead MS. Paul and then I'll swing over to mike. again, this is not unforeseen, it should have been caught in the design with the ash -- architects walks, I don't know if mike wants it say anything else. Unforeseen, everything is behind the wall. that's the way I read it that these windows were behind the wall when they took the wall down, they found the windows. mike mac entire. This is an error and omission because it was shown, the condition was shown on the as-builts. The condition con
033be visually seen because it was hidden but it was on the as-builts. thank you that just read iting, I wouldn't have known that. I just didn't want somebody to get in trouble if it was wasn't their fault. Thank you for that. All those in favor of jj11 say aye. any opposed say no. Next item is oo1. so moved. moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Thompson. Any public comment. no ma'am. one of our speakers stepped away, in case you want to bring a different item. item, well I'll go, and come back. DR. Holness? Is he on the line? If not, we'll let. Okay, DR. Zeman. ma'am, I didn't ask for this. it has -- . -- did I, oo1 and I was not ready. I tell you, my apologies. I don't have the item in
034front of me but I think there is 10.5FTEs if I'm right, that's 10 million per FTs. DR. Hepburn? MS. Paul. yes. Basically, we're going to add additional people to the contract we want to, add additional an additional scheduler. if you can pull the mic closer to you, MS. Paul. sorry. This contract is a little different and includes a contingency of 230,000 in case we need additional services that gives us a little bit more flexibility. In addition, we're adding additional scheduler, affective 1 JULY. An additional person to help coordinate some of the information that goes to the board. And one of the things that I want to assure you base on the, the vote of the board in terms of whether we continue our contract with acome or we go with other options, I want to
035make sure shah you understand that we're not going to double dip. We're not going to pay adkins and pay a con for the same thing. terrific and the point that I want today make is sim wlar to what MS. Balls pointed out, we pay significantly more on than we do on the government side. If we have man je,z the price of having them come in when we can't find them is significantly lower, plenty of good reasons to have adkins and a con particularly for their domain knowledge, that's critical to make sure that we continue to accelerate construction. Thanks chair. thank you. MS. Leonardi? thank you. I have a lot of questions on this. As it pertains to the also the services that we are currently getting. In and I emailed MS. Paul some of these
036questions but I do want them in the public record as well. So under the current contract and the original solicitation documents which I went and looked up from 2021, it indicated that adkin or the c pc m is expected to use software and maintaining schedules. Is that currently what adkins is doing? no ma'am. okay. Can somebody explain why? I'll let ashley carpenter speak to that. But as I understand t the master schedule was decided at some point that acon would be in charge. MS. Carpenter if you want to speak further on that. ashley ar pender with adkins, the contract that you're referencing from that was approved in early 2021, was approved just after the a econ contract ehcon contract they're responsible for the master schedule. And the way it was explained to me through the
037district staff, was that adkins rule, there is another that says report actual program progress and performance as measured against the base line master project schedule. So that and the base line was developed by acom. We've continued to do feedback to ensure its accuracy welcomely with regards to things that have happened to make sure that all of the reporting to the committee and to the board and public is you know, accurate in that way. But it was not in our contract to develop that. but we do f6 to providing feedback to the pmor. thank you. Who is responsible for preparing tia's honors over 25,000. aecom? okay. It says differently in the the solicitation documents can somebody explain the dis creme en see. I'll go back to mike mac entire to explain na I can explain that.
038Again with the impact, the general tone is that adkins is suppose to support the as needed throughout the years particularly when they first started. I reached out quite a bit to district staff and pmor related to I guess offering our service to see help with tia's because they were very backed up at the time. And they didn't take me up on that. But now, with the way that they've, you know, they've caught up on their tia's and keeping up with the demand of that document, so, yeah, we've never since aecom started we have not done any tia's for any project that they've managed. thank you for reaching out and offering your assistance, I appreciate that. It is concerning to me that that that was not taken up either by the district staff or aecom and
039I would like follow-up on on whether or not, how much we've been billed for tia's on exchange orders exceeding at that,000 and I would like confirmation that adkins and aecom's never did tia's on the same change orders. I'm concerned that we are not as a district, we're not being diligent in monitoring who is providing what services. Wire asking people to do what is in their contract. It appears that adkins has reached out multiple things about multiple things that was in their solicitation documents to you and they were rebuffed to us, that is extremely concerning to me. So I look forward to getting that follow-up. Thank you. thank you. Anybody else? Okay. MS. Bulman. I agree with MS. Leonardi, I'm glad you brought that up and so, I support her direction. Thank you. thank you. All
040those in favor of item oo1 say aye. aye. any opposed say no? Motion carries. Next item up is item oo3. I'm sorry, o o-2, any public comment? Oh I need a motion examine a second on o o-2. so moved. second. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, second by MS. Rupert. Any public comment? no ma'am. okay, MS. Alhadeff. thank you. In my comment in the future with sro agreement if there could be something with regards to law enforcement complying with audit request pertain to go safety and security, also law enforcement having current valid certificates on file on their schools and that they follow our protocols. DR. Hepburn? that is definitely noted for our upcoming contract negotiations. okay, thank you. can I ask a question about that. MS. Alhadeff, the audit procedures of broward county schools that
041they should submit data or their own city police force. no audit with safety and security at broward county schools. terrific, thank you. tubsinger all those in favor of item oo2 say aye. aye. any opposed no. Motion carries, the next is oo3, can I have a motion and a second. so moved. second. moved by DR. Zeman. those opposed? DR. Holness is not on the line. sees the one that pulled the item. So the next item is oo12. so moved. Moved by DR. Zeman and seconded by alhadeff. MS. Fam is not on the line. yes. All those in favor, say aye. aye. any opposed say no. item next oo14. so moved. second. moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by ms.Ly nard. no this is also pulled by MS. Fam. all those in favor. Say eye . Say aye.
042aye. those opposed, say no. MADAM Chair, we have a question on gg1. We need confirmation. I have a motion and a second for gg11. so moved. second. moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Alhadeff. any public comment. no ma'am. any board comment. All those in favor for gg1 say aye. any opposed no. the last item is pp2, I have a motion and a second. so moved. moved by DR. Zeman seconded by MS. Leonardi. Any comment on pp2. no ma'am. I think I'm the other only one, since the other two is not here. DR. Zeman is here. I have not missed a meeting in two years. I even learned how to say it the right way. you go ahead. this is important, I cannot explain to my neighbors why buses drive past kids that need a
043ride to school with empty seats, I don't think anybody on this school board can. It cost no more for kids to not fill the seats than it does to fill the seats. Reduce car lines around schools, reduce time for parents or guardians to get their kids to school. More students go to school when they ride to bus than when their parents takes them. It shows the community that we recognize that an empty seat is a wasted opportunity. Here's the image I have in my mind, a kid that is two miles away, they ged a ride but if if a child is one mile they don't get the bus. With empty seats. What we proposed months ago because to say any empty seat can be signed up by people. I've talked to senior staff. They recognized
044that ATMs have been in the ufm states since 1969, why is that issue? That people have 11-second memory mentality. And uber can be in seconds. Atm and uber. Soy talked to people about bruber. You push a button and see if you get a seat in the bus and it MAY be that you get a seat for two weeks, if they sign up on wednesday of the first day of school you've got to give them a seat, so somebody who did sign on MAY get kicked off. But I cannot imagine the pollution, the car line, the absently and watch a 85-seat bus go by with 45 empty seats. I don't think the policy reflects these ideas if they don't support the bruber, if they don't want the people to take the seats on day one, you
045should support this policy. If you believe that the community deserves to use the empty seats, that kids that are at 1.9, 1.8, 1.77, I've got a mayor in pem brooke that has yelled at me 50 times, and i have nothing to say. You've got 50 empty seats and I've got kids that need a ride. And I said, we don't get paid. And he says it does not cost me more, you got me. I think it's time that we take a bold step and work with the cio to develop an app not application, not a paper base application that goes through principals which is reflected. But just a central policy where people can use the resources that we already pay for at a more affective way. So, I don't want to go through 43 changes, I
046think it ought to be back for being rewritten but I'm curious if the board is happy with making modest changes or if they want to respond to mayor anglo's cast at castillo and the 4400 parents that would like to use the extra seats in the bus. chair, we have to extend the meeting, we're about to pass the 15-minute park. Mark. 15 sounded good. all those in favor of extending no longer than half an hour say aye. aye. any opposed, motion carries. Thank you. Next is MS. Alhadeff. thank you, so I'm always happy when people think outside the box with the bruber. Uber. bruber. however I would like to know in regards to line one if this would and I don't know, I didn't do my homework as far as if we were to two change
047the two miles to 11.5 or 1.8, what would do that. DR. Hepburn? MS. Paul? MR. Alvarez has a dollar amount for that. So if you can provide that information. alvarez. rolando executive director student transportation fleet services. So I do have 3450 kids live between 1.9 and 1.99. That is equivalent to 5.5 million dollars to put those kids on buses. Between 1.5 and 1.99, is approximately 1600 kids which is 2.4 million dollars. So we've got two numbers, between 1.5 and 1.99 and we have 11.9 and 1.99. wait a minute. can you break that. I'm sorry, 9 to 1.99 isis 3,450 kids. if he can just start at 1.99 what is the cost is and the next level and next level. so I have two ranges, one way from 1.90 to 1.99. That is approximately 3458 students.
048and the dollar value? the dollar value is 5.5 million dollars. The other range that I have which is, is 1.5 to 1.99. Which is 1600 students. That is 2.4 million dollars. okay, what do you have at 1.99? I don't have a single number for kids that live around 1.99. I have a range. you don't have a financial cost. for not 1.99 only. that's important numbers because if we're trying to get more kids on the bus, but financially, be mindful, we need to know those numbers. so we can provide you a follow-up on specific numbers and without the ranges if that would be easier to understand? But you know, the issue I think is and I think the problem we're trying to solve for is when, when we have empty seats on the bus, we want
049to put kids in those empty seats. So I think that's what we're trying to solve for. The issue is, that where the greatest demand for transportation is, based on historical knowledge is in those areas where the buses are overcrowd. The first day of school kids don't ride the bus. The first week a lot of kids don't ride the bus. The, concern is, that we would put a kid on a bus that we get reimbursed for and when they registered and they go through the process of registering for transportation, so we hold that seat for them. So if, we put a kid that is not under the current policy, not authorized to ride the bus then we're taking away that reimbursement that we get. It potentially, potentially, that is the concern. But, in terms of having
050a bruber concept, I think that's a great idea but we're not there yet. You know, we're just not there yet. and MS., alhadeff, the idea that I'm talking about is using unused seats only, which costs us nothing. I'm not talking about changing the radius, I'm just talking about the 844-school bus that pulls up and has 44 kids in it. I would like to our system to go to the last stop and take up an unused seat. We have ten thousands of thousands of kids that can take the unused seats and we can do a good for our broward and performance because they do better if they show up to school. I skill would like to know those numbers because I think it's important for me to you know, if I could possibly be making a
051motion right now but I can't because I don't know what the numbers are. and I'm just to clarify, and I'll, get MR. Alvarez who has his hands up, and chime in, we have students that register bus when we tell them to register in the summer. And those students will typically, not ride the bus in the first week, and the requests are normally, additional requests are areas where there is overcrowd. So if we let the kids ride the bus within the two miles, they take the seats of the kid that registered. So now you have a bus that can't accommodate all the needs of the kids who are outside of the house. Is that what I'm? that is absolutely correct. So -- yes, I think worth mentioning is when students register to ride, those kids are
052assigned a seat on the bus for the first day of school. Every school, every school bus has a total number of kids that is assigned to those seats on the bus. we run the risk if we put any kids for empty seats on the bus, two things MAY happen, we're going to overload the bus immediately. If every one rides the first day of school and we put empty seat riders, we're going to overload the bus. that's not true. number one. Number two, we route buses according to the number of kids that we have registered to ride. With the kids that we got ready to ride are the number of bus that's are allowed to work with that number of students. So it is very important to understand that every seats on that bus, based on
053the number is they are based on the number of kids that registered to ride. can I clarify something for the board. sure. so after the first couple of weeks have settled and kids are riding the bus who registered, what take place then? For the empty seats? okay, so the first week of school, the second week of school then we begin to see which number of students that do not ride the bus. Now those seats becomes available for any students that is under 2 miles to then apply to be on the bus. so they come to a specific stop t.Sounds like we don't change our route. They come to on existing stop board the bus, yes. are you done? I just want to make sure. MS. Leonardi? thank you, and I have to give kudos to
054MR. Alvarez, i r&b my first year on the board when AUGUST would roll around, we got so many emails and now we barely get any. So thank you for the work that you and your team do and all of our transportation personnel. I'm curious I think, DR. Zeman made a very compelling pitch minus the name, I would hope that we can use a different name. me too. I'm curious about it. Is the suggestion then that we vote down this policy in the hopes of you know, the cio and staff developing something for exciting and efficient? Is that the suggestion, DR. Zeman? it is, the policy that is put before us is being predicated the doing things that we've always done them. It's only out of the box in a sense of using ann unused resource,
055it would not push anybody off the bus. It would just use up seats that right now are being unused and I cannot justify that. There is a kid that wants a ride, and we have an empty seat. So yes, I think we would need to just draft a policy based on day one approach that is about to the community good. so I have two sets of questions then. Cause what I'm hearing from superintendent and MR. Alvarez is maybe I'm just, maybe I'm not fully understanding the concept that we do open up seats for students within that boundary, so help me, I guess DR. Zeman understand the disdes here. so the idea that costs us nothing but uses up the resources that we're already paying for is to run the exact same routes that we've always
056run on buses and for the children at one point, they get to look at the children at 2.0 and get a ride, and they don't. If there is 20 seats, of even, not even looking at the people that ride or not but 64 people that wanted a seat that means 20 seats left over, you back up from the two-mile by distance and allow 20 people to en roll. If in fact somebody else comes in and asked for a risk they're at-risk they know they're getting a seat has somebody who does not have a guaranteed ride. But what happens in general, is not the case. And all that I'm suggesting that is we pay significant money of our and federal dollars to run a bus system and we ought to do it in a fashable way.
057To use unused seats in the routes where they are available and MS. Paul's case where there is 84 people in the bus because there is 94 that want it and you jam 84 in there. We overload buses. we do. they would not apply for that. It's not about the over used bus. Maybe we should run a second bus there. It's about 44 kids registered less than that show up and there is a guaranteed of 40 open seats available and we tell kids, that you cannot get a ride to school even though we know it's better for them. We know it's better for their schooling and we know it's better for the community in terms of car line pollution and traffic. That's all I'm proposing so there is no cost to this. If MS. Alhadeff would
058like to roll the zone back, I'm fascinating because we MAY get the cities pay back, because they're dying with the pollution. But the idea is to try to use the ununused seats and school buses, I cannot think of a good reason to explain to people why we don't do that. DR. Hepburn? yes. So I just want to chime in. We're not dis agreeing with DR. Zeman and the need to fill seats up. I think the concern s the current policy says, what he's what he's discussing is to fill seats that current policy we wait until the bus settle and it's 35 days before we set it settle. That brings the day down to the first 20 days. I think the the concern that we need to address is that in mayor -- marilyn, I'm going
059to turn to you. If we allow kids to do what they do now, register for their ride and on day one kids who are not registered and within two miles and get on their bus and the kids that did not register, they're outside of the two miles can, a kid within two-mile bump their seat, right? MS. Batista? I'm trying to figure out if there are legal issues and another we're not getting reimbursed for the kids that are less than two miles. I have my seat. MS. Batista. yeah, so I'm looking up the statute, but basically, the statute says that you have to -- oops, sorry. register your ride is a recommendation, we are encouraging parents to do that early so we can create our routes early. But kids still have the opportunity who are outside
060of the two miles to ride our bus, correct? right, but I think your question was whether you know the legality of having a kid outside of the two miles being bumped so to the extent that we have district has to provide transportation, that MAY be a problem. so my other question about this was so say we vote this policy down, right now, does that does that impede the district's ability to provide adequate trans port-a-pottiation. -- transportation. We'll revert to the current policy which is 35 days. okay, all right, thank you. and DR. Zeman suggestion of what was the brueb r e. zoobehr. so and he's talking more about the strategies on how to make this more efficient for kids to understand that there is open seats and sign up for those open seats with efficiency
061with an app. I think what the board is being asked by colleagues is how many days should we do that? Should we do 35 or proposed in the policy which is 20. But our buses do need to settle. We have communities where traditionally kids don't ride the bus in the first days and units that where kids don't come to school after labor day. That still happens in florida, so we to make sure that they're not bumped off the bus. go ahead MS. Paul, if you want to add that. MR. Alvarez has information on the open seats when parents apply. I think that one thing that needs to be mentioned is that kids, kids that are not eligible for transportation do have a way to ride the bus. And that is that, after the proper count
062on the bus, is done, those seats become available for none and we have to, we have to be clear, non eligible transportation. In most cases, I do want it say this, in most cayses over the years -- cases, we have not had any school that has requested maybe more than 220 seats from my particular school. They are the number of kids that request empty seats are very low are of the I want to say, we have approximately 75,000 kids that are eligible for transportation, out of those that are not eligible for transportation, total number that requests MAY be empty seat policy does not exceed that thousand. So the number of kids that request empty seat policy is very low. thank you for that information. Before I go back to school board members, we seem to
063have a student who would like to chime in here, so we'll give you time to speak. yes. Hello my name is a viva I'm from hollywood and I believe that there is even just one open seat in the bus, every student should have the opportunity to be able to go to school. Some parents work multiple-jobs, it's hard you cannot always take your kid and traffic is insane and your work could cost you your job. And I understand that legally it could be difficult to get these kids on the bus, but I believe there have been some system in place that on a certain morning there have been a way to figure out how many kids are on the bus and how you can incorporate more kids to be able to be on the buses if
064there are open seats. thank you. thank you so much we always appreciate the student perspective. I'm going to chime in I have a motion. I appreciate this coming forward. I did ask about this policy coming forward because I agreed with DR. Zeman but when we had the workshop, it was obvious that day one would be very difficult for all of the reasons that have been explained here. So my motion is to change on roman numeral one letr a when it says after the first school days I would like to make a motion to change of after after the 15 schools. That gives you enough time to flush everything out if it could be less it could be great but I understand, we have ft day 10 so we know by day ten how many students
065we have so that's another week. Would I like to make a motion to change 20 days to 15 days. second. any public comment on the motion. Board comment in motion and keep in mind we have ten minutes left. Oh yes, I'm sorry, it was seconded by MS. Thompson. Okay. DR. Zeman? you know, there are very few opportunities that are so clear. And in an atm example instead of buying the atm we're going to speed up the teller at your bank so instead of waiting for four minutes on the bank, you'll wait five minutes. The reason I joined the board which is we're going to be best county in the country when we have unused bus seats, and we have kids that need a ride to school, and we know it's good for kids to get
066to school and we know that it's good for the environment and good for the families, we're going to speed up the teller at the bank. That's not why I'm here. I did not join the board so we can get one percent better every year. The importance of public education is too important. So I don't support this motion, day one is possible. We just have to do it. We have to turn to our neighbors and community members and the mayors of broward county and say, you're right, we've got empty seats and there is no reason people inside two miles can't line up and get the seats. It's really that, it's just, I can't support thth because I know thisisisfeasibib and wawaed fivevemontnthsr r thisis poli comeckck and m m justm m out ofpatience and I want
067us to do the things that we know we can do and I don't have any justification for speeding up the teller line. thank you. that's my view. thank you. All those in favor of the motion say aye. aye. any opposed say no. no. seems like. just one desending. thank you. MS. Alhadeff. thank you. Does the statute allow us to lower the two miles to say 1.9 miles? DR. Hepburn? MR. Alvarez. statute indicates that students over two miles. but, I guess MS. Batista can we lower to 1.9 miles and then we're picking up the cost? MS. Batista? so the, you know, it's two miles is what the statute provides as you know. I mean, as long as you are not denying anything that wanted to ride the bus that is over two miles by having doing
068either 1.9 or whatever less, then I think you could you would be able to do it if you picked up the cost, yes. uh-huh. see I think, it's important to have data drive our decision and not honestly we don't have any data, we have a policy with some changes but we don't know, we don't have numbers, we don't have the financials, we don't know in what, what areas how much kids are riding buses, where there is a need for more buses, we don't have that information. We're redefining broward schools and maybe if we can provide a bus that MAY be a decision maker for a family to send their kids to a broward county school. We should be weighing so much it cost to put that child on the bus, I don't have the numbers
069in front of me. I'll be interested in bringing this back and kind of looking at all that information. I think DR. Zeman, I think you have a good idea we have a bus app, that we already currently use, maybe that company has the ability to do what you're saying. I know, and just analogy' that I keep thinking about, if I want to sign up for a gym class, I have to go on an app and certain a spots and you have to sign up 15 hours in advance and once those spots are taken, there is no more spots or spots on the bus. So there is ability to do it and maybe that child gets a qr code that they have to have scanned when they get on the bus to know that they have
070their spot on the bus. I think there is opportunity to look at this in a more creative way. But I think it's just challenging right now at this time of the hour with the limited information and data that we don't have. MS. Leonardi? thank you. I will try to be quick. I appreciate the ethos of wanting to do things right now. That's not how government works. You support the 15 days. I don't think it's equivalent necessarily to the medicine for that was being used earlier, I think I would also like to make a motion to direct the superintendent to come up with a plan to automate and move this process online to make it more efficient if that is in line with my statutory duties. everything is already online. yes, that process is online. thank
071you. I heard differently from my colleague so, thank you for that. That's all. thank you. And just to be cognizant of the time. Board member thompson. I'm in favor of voting for this motion but it would be helpful for the board and to DR. Zeman point to have another workshop about different options for the bus also how many students or families are interested. Personallily in my elementary school a lot of families don't trust the bus system to put their kids on the bus and my first and third grader refuse to ride the bus because it's terrifying. So before we put time and energy and money I want to make sure that there is desire in the community and that's all. thank you. Okay. DR. Zeman. last point. The reason we don't have data on this
072is because we waited five months between talking about the policy and getting this policy. And that is very frustrating to me. It took a long time to, to get here. And had we done this faster, we could have asked all of those questions and found out what the answer is. To MS. Leonardi's motion we have to be care on what we mean online. sorry, I thought I withdrew the motion. you did, but you were told the bus system was online. I've registered for the bus, I would not say it's online system. I register for it every year. There is a big difference between here comes the bus being online and being able to turn in a form online. And what I'm talking about online is a student being treated with the respect and dignity that
073they deserve and their family having the ability to get to a seat that is unused to get to school. And if if that's not the will of the board, that's fine but my frustration that denied four adoration of deciding what is the trade off between attracting and or not. Some of the data we asked for byway is not there. We'll never know with certainly how many kids would come to our schools if we offered them a bus. That data does not exist right. But using up unused seats in a way that serve the community I think is a great idea and I look forward to readdress thating in the future and I hope we do it with greater speed. okay, all those in favor of item pp2 as amended as amended say aye. aye. all
074those opposed say no. no. just one descending vote. motion passes. At this time, do any of my colleagues have any discussion or student successes to bring forth to the superintendent. MADAM Chair. Before you go to that, since the policy did pass, I just wanted to I don't know that if necessarily needs an amendment but to add the to the authority section in the policy, general statue tory provisions that are not there. If we can do that, the section is 120.154, 101.41, 1,000.342 and 43 I don't think it has any affect but just wanted to add those and if there is no objection. where do you want them in the authority section of the board of the policy, excuse me. ?M anybody have objection to see that? enough you have. okay, thank you. Board member thompson.
075I just wanted to I know we're I don't think the consensus to bring this cell phone policy but I do have a concern I had two students report that they had a safety concern at their school they reported it to a parent and that student got disciplined for being on their phone at school. Aha, and I just think either that needs to be very clear to principals that they can use their cell phones for safety concerns or I think, I personally think we should revisit it but if a person is scared at school they use their phone to night fie a parent they should not get in trouble for expressing that concern. yes, thanks for letting us know about that concern if you can let us know what school so we can address it. I
076know we're going to have one off situations and so we'll gladly address that with the school leadership. but it's the same if we're expecting the students to have the safe watch they're on their phone or MS. Frye with hrc community brought up how we're expecting to and report bullying and stuff like that, if they cannot use their cell phones either we need a different mechanism or make sure that staff does not discipline students for using their phone because of fear. So. thank you. noted. MS. Alhadeff. yes, congratulations to the msd tennis team for a win today and then also, I know this is brought up earlier but I have concerns with this sexd curriculum not being approved bit state and we're waiting this is going to be probably a second year that there is nothing
077taught. So what can we do to have a more proactive plan instead of just, kind of waiting? DR. Hepburn? we submitted it months ago in the fall. So we're and I'll let MS. Sullivan chime in on the rest but we submitted months ago ample time for review. I know we've been in communication with them but they have not finalized anything as far as how we move forward. yes, excuse me. I think I don't think I know, our staff is working as hard as they can to get to a point where the state can approve it while considering what this the board expects it what is in the sex ed curriculum along with what our community expects to be taught within that curriculum so we can decide as a system to not honor what the board
078wants and what the community wants and present something that is more likely to come back in a more expeditious way. And we did teach it last year just for the record. uh-huh. so we're working through this, I think we'll get there but staff is working as quick as possible with the understanding that we're trying to honor what the board and community expects to be here. so I guess I'll ask for another weekly report but if we can ask for an update, I think it's very important so we know what is going on. superintendent, if I MAY? My recommendation is that we do update the board weekly but outside of the news. okay. thank you. And I'll end, I just want to say to the superintendent, it was very apparent with the people that were here
079today and some of the emails that we've gotten about broward estates that I think the expectation that we have as a board that they would get concierge service is not what is really happening to me, that's us calling every family and saying, you know, it sounds to me, we're saying come to the school, we'll meet you but concierge service means we're going out to them. So I would ask that we change that process a little bit. We can call them and say are you available to come to the school and if they're not, make a time that makes sense for, you know, us to meet with them whether it's going to their house or meeting on a saturday or what are but I, I don't feel the individualality that we were asking for when we
080asked about concierge service so if you can please. yes, absolutely. So like I said before, we're utilizing a group strategy we have 71 families out of 1163 families, 92 have been communicated and we have 71 left to community can. -- communicate with and we will go to different strategies to make sure every child or family gets the information to help with the transition. And I know, we have a couple of people that came up here today and I don't want that to reflect or characterize the hard work that we've been doing since JANUARY 22, which many of you said before is not representative what is going on. I appreciate that, but I will say 71 is almost half. So. absolutely. there is definitely, we're not reaching everything that was the point and we do appreciate
081staff all the work they've done but this particular community I think means more of us going to them not us expecting. and that's the plan. the scheduled order of business for this regularly school board meeting has been completed. Seeing no further obligation, I now adjourn this meeting.