001items to be added to the [Inaudible]. (No audio available). welcome to today's regular school board meeting. We are happy to have you join us and we're thankful for your time and dedication to our district. This regular meeting the school board of broward county, florida is now called to order. Our primary focus is to create a safe and productive environment for all participants, please be reminded the exit doors that are clearly marked for emergency exiting. While many the board room, refrain from obstructing if doors, once the room has reached its capacity, you will be directed to an overflow area. Upon activation of the fire alarm system, exit from the room in an orderly fashion and ko rpt to exit the building and remain outside until the authority that has jurisdiction has deemed the building safe to
002return. Thank you for your cooperation. Board member leonardi will introduce her school to lead us in the pledge of allegiance to the flag. MS. Leonardi? thank you, it is my pride to introduce the stranahan marine corps jrtc led by marine instructors master montgomery, sergeant filiat and aponte is the stephanie rivas pass. Please remain standing. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands one nation under GOD, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [Applause]. thank you so much. Board member holness has requested a moment of silence from parkway middle school, DR. Holness? thank you, MADAM Chair. Please join me in a moment of silence to honor the life of tajay cooper, a 7th grade student at parkway mimilele hool, her r ile had the
003poweweto light upup any omom and d her rsrsalaly leleft a lalasting impact on all who knew her. It caner ajay's presence brought joy and energy to those around her and she will be deeply missed. Her manly will remain cherished by everyone at parkway middle school. Thank you. boebdbacker board member rupert has requested a moment of silence from coconut high school. more mekie al MAY from coconut high school who passed away, please keep all our students and community in our thoughts and prayers. Thank you. T superintendent released a revised agenda and published it on the school's district website. DR. Hepburn, beyond the changes online, are there any additional changes? yes, MADAM Chair, imd like to withdraw items j1 and j4. the chair finds pursuant of florida statutes that good cause exists for such changes and accepts
004the revised agenda. MAY the chair have a motion and a second to close the agenda. so moved. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MRS. Rupert. All in favor of closing the agenda, say aye. . Er aye. those posed, say no. MAY I have a motion to approve the minutes, NOVEMBER 13, regular school board meeting, NOVEMBER 19, 2024 annual organizational meeting, DECEMBER 10, 2024 special school board meeting, JANUARY 22, 2025 special expulsions. so moved. second. moved by rupert, seconded by DR. Zeman, is there any discussion? All in favor of approve thing minutes as listed, say aye. aye. those posed, say no. The minutes are approved. As we prepare to begin our regular school board meet, we are reminded our vision is 100% proficiency for all our student x as an a rated school district,
005our vital task is to sustain this achievement. We will continue educating all student tos reach their highest potential, our theme is believe and power achieve one broward. The chief communications and legislative officer polled the board of the members of items we wish to address. MAY I have a motion and a second to pass the consent items which includes h1, h3, a1, a-2, a3, c4, j1, j2, j3 and o3, those are pulled. so moved with the exclusion of j1, it's been pulled. sorry. Let me read that again. So, the consent items that have not been pulled for discussion ao are h1, h3, a1, a-2, a3, c4, j2, j3 and o3. so moved. second. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, seconds by MS. Leonardi. At this time, we will have public discussion on any consent items that
006were not pulled -- we'll have public speakers for any consent items that were not pulled for discussion. there are no registered speakers, MADAM Chair. thank you, all in favor of approve thing consent agenda items that have not been pulled for discussion, say aye. those opposed, say no. Motion carries. Okay. So, at this time, we will take remarks from the superintendent and board members on any of those agenda items that were not pulled. Anybody have -- I just wanted to say for h1, congratulate the 20 retirees that we have, congratulations, thank you for your service to the district and we wish you all the best in your journey moving forward. Do you have anything, DR. Hepburn? yes, I would like to congratulate our new appointees and ask our new principal from northside elementary, marylin grand to
007say a couple of remarks and also MS. Carla heart, new principal at james heart elementary. Did I jump ahead? yes. I pulled h2 but I think that was on the list. I didn't know, I said h1, h3. okay. you were supposed to say something before this happens. one second, new appointees, the chair would like to take a moment to recognize the new staff appointees, we would like to congratulate each of you for your career advancement with broward county public schools. we value you and your families. If we could please give all the appointees a round of applause. [Applause]. Thank you. We've already done this part, but DR. Hepburn, can you please introduce the new leaders. happy to do so, we'll start with the new principal of northside elementary, MS. Maryland grand and follow up with
008carla heart at james heart elementary. good morning, my name is maryland grant, I want to say thank you to the board member and is the superintendent and the cabinet for allowing me to be the next principal at northside elementary school. This is a full circle moment for me. I started my career in broward county schools as an sbrern from fau, student teaching at northside, then I got hired at northside, I spent ten years of my career at broward county schools serving as many capacities, so this is going back home. This is really an honor to be serving such an amazing school with a wonderful staff and an amazing community. I am truly honored to have that title to lead northside. I just want to say thank you to everyone who made me who I am
009today, a special thank you to my family members that are here today watching me, you have been a tremendous support, thank you for your love and continuous support. Definitely thank you to all my former principals, ap's, directors for believing in me, because of you, I am who I am today. I cannot wait to get northside to an a-rated school. Thank you. [Applause]. good morning, my name is carla heart, I am the former principal, a proud principal of lark dale elementary, I have served there for ten years, we moved lark dale from an f rated school to a b rated school and we're on our way to an a school, so I wanted to start out by just saying kudos to lark dale elementary. This is my 28th year here in broward county school, I've had
010every position from a substitute teacher to a classroom teacher to a reading coach and assist tan principal, a principal, you name it, I've done it with pride, so today I come to you humbly just appreciative of this opportunity to take myal talent tos james hunt elementary and I'm excited to get started and meet the new staff, the community, my scholars, my babies, and just to continue my love and my passion for leading and shaping young minds at james hunt elementary, so thank you, thank you, thank you, and I am ready. It's a bittersweet transition from lark dale to james hunt elementary, but I can assure must f you my love and passion will continue in whatever seat I sit in, so thank you. [Applause]. thank you so much, at this time, we will now recess
011the regular school board meeting for a board photo with all the new staff appointments. (Taking photograph). this regular school board meeting is now reconvened. Next we are going to pull -- do the consent items that were pulled. We will start with h2, can I have a motion and a second to bring these two to the floor. Moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Thompson. Any pub -- public comment on item h2? No? Okay, MRS. Fam? thank you, I went through the folder very thoroughly and I noticed there are several ten day suspensions which were warranted because they involved some physical contact with the student but I do have concerns and I wanted to bring to the board as we have also ten day suspensions for an ese student, I think when ese students are involved
012that our professional staff should recognize that there's already issues present and that might be one of the issues that the student actually has -- needs assistance with, and more patience when being addressed so what I would like to do is to put on the record now and bring up at a future date that there is -- when there is some kind of physical contact with an ese student, we put in place where there is a probationary period to monitor when there is physical contact, the person who is coming into canting with the student either doesn't recognize they're going the need extraordinary care with this student or they lack the patience to provide it. So, I'm going to recommend a probationary period and also some kind of follow-up with either monitoring or counseling, so to make
013sure it doesn't happen again because the ese students don't have the ability, sol of -- some of them to communicate on their own so we are their first line of defense or their protectors, if this happens one time, it's one time too many. i would like the board to get on board with that and tightening this loophole when it come tos an ese student, you are not going to hurt and touch our students, we are serious. So, thank you so much and I will be bringing that up in the future. thank you, MRS. Rupert? thank you. I've already spoken to the superintendent about my concerns for h2 but I do want to go on the record with the ideas that I brought forth. While looking at the items, you can definitely see a difference that
014there were two different kinds, there was correction action report which is usually the building centered or the school if it's a school, and then you have the psc, professional standards committee gets some, I think we need to educate board members and the public about what is taken for each one of these particular areas. There needs to be a missed list, so you know the corrective actions for instance inappropriate anything, conversations, texts, slapping, neck restraints concerning our students and psc corrective actions. I think it would behoove to us to make sure that there's a direct line from the time of the incident to something that the the superintendent would take care of to make sure it goes either to a car or to psc, but reading through it, it didn't seem like there was a rhyme
015or reason in there. And I do agree with MS. Fam especially unprofessional behavior, inappropriate touching within physical aspects of ese students or any student in broward county. This needs to be looked at, so thank you so much and, sir, superintendent, thank you for having that conversation with me and I look forward to some changes, thanks. thank you. Any other board members? Okay, all those in favor of h2, say aye. aye. any opposed? H2 passes. The next item is c-1, can I have a motion and a second for c-1? So moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Rupert. Any public comments on c-1? Okay. DR. Holness? thank you, MADAM Chair. So, I just have -- and I'm not sure to what extent I can question this item but this particular assistant principal I believe, MS. Neeson,
016is being recommended that she gets a three day suspension and I looked at the background and I looked at the information that we have and the question that I have is according to the background, it says that MS. Neeson was on cafeteria duty and that there were apparently two the students who seem to have expressed possibility of fighting that was conveyed to MS. Neeson, then she indicated -- it indicates she went over to the student, one of them, and then she said, you want to fight, go ahead and fight, you'll get 9 days. MS. Batista, I just want to understand the context to which she's being suspended because some people MAY interpret that as discouraging the kids from fighting as opposed to encouraging them to fight because she makes reference to what the consequences would
017be if they did fight. Maybe it was a poor choice of words but there could be different interpretations of what she meant, so with the consequences that are given n and I don't kn w wha tent can esesonon th t t my interpretati of what occurred with the same words MAY be completely different from another person's interpretation of what occurred with the same words. The reason I say that, because in her comments, the latter part of it, she said go ahead and fight, you'll get 9 days, right, so in one sense, that could be her way of expressing that there are consequences if you do fight. I know the cafeteria is a challenging environment to work sometimes as an ap, and I've done it before when I was a designee back in -- as a
018teacher and filling that role as an ap designee, so could you clarify what is the punishment for, is the punishment is because this was interpreted, that this particular staff was encouraging the kids to fight and if so, can you expound on what her words -- how her words could be interpreted differently different individuals? MS. Batista? thank you, MADAM Chair, so the complaint, yes, the complaint is asking for the three days suspension based upon the the superintendent's review of the facts and the belief of the superintendent and hr, that that's what the principal, she was basically egging on the kids to fight. That's their take on what happened. When we get here at this point o the board is for you to look at the complaint and take everything in the complaint as if it were
019true. If based upon those facts that are given, those alleged facts that are given in the complaint you feel the discipline is appropriate, then you would have to vote that up because as you know, the next step would be the principal -- the assistant principal would get the ability to challenge that and good o to the division of administrative hearings and go there to present the evidence, whether it be other witnesses, whatever it is, and then the alj, the administrative law judge will make a determination based upon the facts and the witnesses presented as to whether the lack waj means what you, DR. Holness, thinks the language MAY mean or something else. okay, so it says here that her deadline for requesting a hearing will expire prior to the board meeting, has this ap requested
020a hearing? the assistant principal, did -- yes, they requested the hearing. I want to make one more comment, thank you, MS. Batista, for clarifying. Every time these come before us, I understand what my role is but if something comes before us and we accept what's given to us as factual, for example, it is factual that she said you want to fight, go ahead and fight, go ahead and fight, you'll get nine days, that's factual, right. How you interpret the facts differs with individuals, right. And I'm not saying I'm in a position of the administrative law judge but for me, that could also mean discouraging them from fighting. If you do, these are the consequences, it was a poor choice of words. If I don't believe the facts warrant the punishment, am I not allowed to
021vote no? MS. Batista? because I'm accepting the facts as facts but my interpretation of the facts differs from the recommendation of the punishment, so as a board member, I can't disagree with their facts? so, that's an excellent question. You could vote no, however, as I said, you have to take the facts as expressed and I would really go further to say that you have to take the facts as they are written and accept the superintendent's take on the facts, right, because they have not come to that lightly. There has been an investigation that took place before this complaint, before the charges were made, so there is some due diligence that was done prior to writing the facts as this they appear here. So, while you could say no, I believe that based upon what is
022written here, the only time that you would be able to say no would be if you feel that the discipline is not appropriate, so in other words if you wanted the superintendent to take another look at it and then bring back either less discipline or more discipline based on the facts. okay, so from this point when it could goes to the administrative law judge, what happens next? so, what happens next is that there will be a bench trial before the administrative law judge, both the superintendent through his counsel and the principal through her counsel will be able to present evidence, witnesses and whatever documentation they have. The alj will take that into consideration, both sides write a proposed order to -- that is submitted to the judge and then the judge writes a recommended order
023that comes to the board for final determination. okay, so my vote today is -- is my vote today simply to allow this to move forward to the administrative law judge and then it comes back to us to which I can then vote yes or no? correct. So, if -- once the recommendation from the judge comes, then both sides have an opportunity to file exceptions which is what you sometimes will hear here if you recall, you will have a hearing before -- usually before board meetings and both sides argue the exceptions, one side will say, no, the exceptions should not be taken into consideration and the other side agrees obviously with whatever their exceptions are and then the board makes a ruling based on the evidence on the whole -- on all the evidence as presented.
024At that point, you will have all the evidence that was presented at the trial, you will have it before you. I understand, so that will give me a lot more information to which I can make a decision so this is simply moving it forward to the administrative law judge. So I have a question for DR. Hepburn, for this particular case, is the consequence suggested and recommended here based on the interpretation that this particular ap was egging the students on to fight? Was that what led to the consequence as opposed to her suggesting that they do not fight. DR. Hepburn? yes, I will have MR. Azzarito and MR. Lozano present. if I told two kids to go ahead and fight they fight, I'm in trouble because I allowed it so I think the matter here is
025one of our school base administrators not acting in the proper manner as we expect our school base admin to work and so the fact that she's telling kids go ahead and fight, you'll get nine days, that's the inappropriateness of it, it's not necessarily that they didn't fight but what could happen if they did. so, the question is on the intent of the statement. Do you believe the intent of the statement to which the consequence is being recommended is based upon one's interpretation that the ap was encouraging them to fight. you want to fight, go ahead and fight. Go ahead and fight and you'll get nine days. She wasn't saying -- I hear you but -- we within there, we're taking what she said, to me it's not necessarily the intent of what she said, she
026was tell thing kid fight. that was your interpretation of the statement. yes. and so I will support this moving forward to the law judge but my interpretation of it could be there's room for doubt as to what it meant. And just to be on record, it is a poor choice of words but i'm looking beyond the words, what was the sben of -- intent of the ap and it could be to discourage them from fighting because you'll get nine day ifs you do, I think it's matter of interpretation, it was a poor choice of words si aoem going to support it going to the administrative law judge but when it comes back, I'm going take a greater look at the evidence that's there. Thank you. thank you, DR. Zeman? chair, thanks very much. We've had
027these kinds of items before, I have asked before for a timeline, they would really help us understand these tenses, where we are in the step. There's something like nine step ins our discipline process f we could get timelines put on these items, we would know exactly where we were, DR. Holness and we would know what decision we're making and that would be helpful for the public and for the board. Toipt make a couple of comments, one, these items seem to take a long time to get here. This one's only nine months but we get routinely things that take up to a year to get here. My concern with that is when there is appropriate discipline to be made out, it's better to come sooner rather than almost a year later. I have participated as an
028observer on some of these items before where people were accused of things, and it isn't just the punishment, it's waiting to hear about the punishment, wait tog get counsel, waiting to get to an administrative law judge, waiting for that to then come back to the board and now you're two years after an event and we're not giving appropriate feedback if it takes forever to get there. I have an opposite upon of DR. Holness for this matter. My perception of this is a school leader was humiliating a student and that's never okay in broward county. So whether this is two days or 7 days or whatever the judge and us decide to do in the long run, I'm going to continue to comment about these items and make people understand we have standards in broward county
029public schools, when you're an ap or a principal, your contribution to our schools are that much greater and teach and he iser staff are watching you, if you say go ahead and fight as a leader of a school, if in fact that was the intent of what she said, that's not within broward county standards and i look forward to this going forward to the administrative law judge and hearing back. Thank you very mup. thank you. MS. Thompson? thank you. How long is the timeline generally? Because I know you guys do a very thorough investigation, you have to probably get witness supports, so is this within the normal timeline? MR. Azzarito or DR. Lozano? this was a site based discussion, we're working on that right now, one second. So, psc is 84 day MISS The invest
030fwaition and it goes through the process there, this was handled at the school site. so, does that mean the process is different? it should be quicker. so, was this within the normal process of on-site? yes. perfect. So, I think I really -- I think we need to respect the investigation and it would be helpful to have a timeline but I also feel like these things take a lot of time to make sure we are getting all the evidence. It's not a biased report, it's the facts. I think -- I don't want to weigh in too much because personally I don't like that's my role. The fact that the student said they don't want to fight and the person who was supposed to be a school leader is encourage toing do that, it's an inappropriate response.
031thank you, MRS. Fam? thank you, MADAM Chair. I just want the board to recognize that there's prior discipline in this where now we're looking at a 3 day suspension but just in a prior incident, not even less than a year prior, there's video footage of the same teacher showing her yelling at a student over the microphone, grabbing yanking a second student by the shirt and grabbing the third student by the hair and pushing that student, obviously we have anger management issues going on here and I think this should be looked into. This is what I'm talking about, monitoring the situations, possible following up with counseling, 101 counseling because we can't let this repetitive activity continue because it's only detrimental to our students, so in my particular circumstance, we have a proven track record here that
032this person is aggressive and harming our students and now she's encouraging them to fight. It doesn't pass the snip test to me, people. Thank you. thank you. Okay. all those in favor of item c-1, say aye. aye. all those opposed, say no. no. I'm voting no as far as the three day discipline. okay. I don't think it's sufficient, thank you. okay, thank you. So the motion passes 8-1 I think. Next item is c-2, can I have a motion and a second on c-2? so moved. Er moved by MS. Rupert, second by DR. Zeman, any pub lig comment on c12 -- c-2? no registered comments. MR. Holness? I have the opposite concern on this particular item. We have an ese student it appears that exited a classroom unnoticeably by the person in charge and was gone
033for quite some time. I have a couple of questions. What is the normal consequence for a teacher or staff not properly supervising students, especially an ese child that exited the building or the classroom for a prolonged period of time? Is this consequence given, the standard recommendation for something of this sort because I think this is significantly consequential to a child, especially an ese child to not be properly monitored. MR. Azzarito? good morning, I'll start and I'll pass it to charlene manzo, yes t student was unaccounted for, if they left campus, it would have been another issue. I'm pass it off. good morning, everyone, good morning, MADAM Chair, board members, my naum is charlene manzo, the director of professional standards, and to respond to your question, normally the historically, we have issued a three day suspension
034in a situation that if someone leaves a child unsupervised, so that has been the practice since I've been here. okay so, this particular classroom, what percentage of the students were ese? Was this a primary ese classroom or was this a class -- classroom that had ese students as part of the mainstream group? I would have to look into it a bit more and get back to you to tell you specifically what the percentage rate of ese and the other children. okay, so DR. Hepburn, for this particular item, it is very concerning that this was an ese child as well. I don't know necessarily what the disabilities are but I think getting information on the number of ese students that this particular staff is supervising is also important. i would recommend -- I would suggest --
035it's hard for me to think of a staff member supervising a high percentage of ese students and not properly monitoring them because this kid left for almost 30 minutes and no one noticed so the information of getting know thing the ese students and particular staff supervising them is important, and I think it's particularly posht to look at this staff and whether or not this person should be supervising students that MAY not necessarily follow the normal classroom routine is very concerning. I mean, what will be next? So, DR. Hepburn, I don't know if you can look into that because I would hate to just leave this as it is and then this person now supervises an ese classroom or a classroom with a high percent of ese student and is we end up with greater circumstances
036where a student wanders off campus, you know, anything else can happen. So, I just think it's important to look into the job responsibilities of this individual as it pertains to kids that have a propensity to wanderer ofor kids with certrtain arning challelenges that MAY not conform toto the normal classroom behavior. So, is that something that is possible? absolutely, the noted, the team will follow up. okay, thank you very much. thank you. All those in favor of item c-2, say aye. aye. all those opposed, say no. Item c-2 passes. Next item is c-3, can I have a motion and a second? so moved. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, second by MS. Leonardi, any public comment on item c-3? no registered speakers. MRS. Fam? c-3. is it okay -- go ahead. thank you, I'm going through
037my notes here. I reviewed the administrative complaint and in my opinion, I thought the discipline appeared excessive. I didn't see anything there unless I missed something about the hostility and it appeared there was inadvertent contact to try to recover the ball that a student refused to put away but I didn't see anything that indicated hostility or any type of aggression. So, that was my take on in reviewing the complaint. I don't know if others had the same opinion or if they feel that there was hostility but I would love to hear input. Thank you. DR. Hepburn? nothing to add, MADAM Chair. thank you. DR. Holness? MADAM Chair, are we on the item with MS. Ruper? It indicated MS. Ruper snatched the ball and so f -- shoved him. Was there contact by MS. Ruper with
038the student? yes, according to the investigation, yes. so, the investigation said she shoved the student. I just want to validate that this information is correct. DR. Hepburn? that's correct. okay. So, my questions are a little different. You know, there will be students within our schools that MAY be defiant, that MAY not take instructions well and so the response of our staff is important. So, this particular teacher, MS. Ruper, seemed to have responded in what would rather seem an aggressive manner if the shoving took place. Which it says it did here and she snatched the ball. I was looking at the broader picture. Is there train hating the district offers, and what does it look like when a student refused to follow directions or requests from staff? What would be the protocol for this teacher to
039follow? And the reason I ask these questions are not just for me, it's those for our staff and teachers who are listening to understand because this teacher basically had asked the student to turn over the ball, the student refused and the teacher snatched the ball and shoved the student. That's obviously an inappropriate response. So, when a student is not complying to your request as a staff, what is the normal protocol for the schools for the teach and he iser our staff to follow, so this can be a learning lesson for anyone else who's paying attention. DR. Hepburn? yes, so I'm going to throw this to MS. Hollingsworth, I know this is in DR. Washington's shop for specific training, in situations like that if you don't know how to deescalculate, you call for additional support with
040an administrator. in the case where a student didn't follow any direction from a teacher within a school, what's the first step that that teacher should take? calling the administrator, assistant principal, principal, if they have some form of a position like a dean, additional support. okay. And in this case that obviously did not happen and it resulted in the teacher getting aggressive and shoving the student. correct. okay, so those are -- one more question and I'm done. It says her deadline for requesting a hearing will expire prior to board meeting. Has she requested a hashing? MR. Azzarito? yes. you said yes? yes. okay, that's it for me, thank you. MRS. Alhadeff? thank you. I'm sitting here and a little bit frustrated to be honest. I've always known we are not supposed to be investigators on these
041issues so it's frustrating. What I would recommend possibly to my colleagues that if you have a motion to make, whether you want to increase something or decrease something to make the motion, but I would be cautious that we sit up here and try to investigate and pick at each of these cases. Thank you. thank you. All those if -- in favor of c-3, say aye. aye. any opposed? Motion carries. The next item is c4, can I have a motion and a second? so moved. second. I'm sorry, not c4. F1. the next item up is f1, can I have a motion and a second? second. so, moved by MRS. Rupert, second by MRS. Leonardi. Any public comment on f1? no, ma'am. MRS. Alhadeff?Frjts on f1, my question is in regards to the net book value. There
042is a few with actual values. My question is what are we doing with the lenovo computers but more specifically in regards to the robin air recovery machines, each valued about 3 thousand 490 dollars. DR. Hepburn? MR. Davis? good morning, board, trey davis, chief information officer, regard thing technology that is aged out through the depreciation process, those values that you see on the right hand side naturally or typically are smaller values and it doesn't really rep -- represent the usable life, beyond economical repair in this case, so attempt tog repair a screen would cost more than that value that you see, so now what do we e do with the ones that do have some useful life left? In cases where we're waiting on an rfp to get new equipment to replenish, we're going to haul
043those back if they have useful life so we can use potentially with one on one backup stock, at this point, we will work with an e-psych -- e-recycler. can you speak specifically to the machines two of them valued at that? can you repeat the item. it's page 11, the last two, it's the robin air ac recovery machine. okay, so I don't have the exact information response, but I think MS. Johnson does. good morning, board members, ramineer johnson, chief financial officer, that is pr the prance oration department, they are liquid pumps, they can be fixed, they were sent out several times to be fixed, some of the parts are obsolete and they can't repair those objects, if you can't repair it televising's no more useful life for the machine even though we have a book value
044for it. so, what are we going o -- to do with them? they will be disposed. okay, thank you. thank you. All those in favor of f1, say aye. any opposed? F1 passes unanimously. The next item is f2, can I have a motion and a second? so moved. it's been moved by DR. Zeman seconded by MS. Alhadeff. Any public comments on f2? no, ma'am. MRS. Fam? yes, ma'am, thank you so much. Okay. I have some severe concerns about this and I've been contacted, it's my understanding that initially the three cpa's in the audit committee were not in favor of this and that they still have some objection and concerns about this. One of the things that has been brought to my attention is school board policy 3150 and broader rule administrative code, rule 6a-1008 require
045us to do certain things and it's in the opinion of some of these professionals we have not done these thing and is we're not in compliance and the question is the ending fund balance, sit in compliance with the state requirement, administrative code 6a-1.008 and does it comport with the school board policy 3510. And if so, what is the general fund as listed in the fund balances for policy 3510? DR. Hepburn? MS. Johnson? we are in compliance, the cpa, there is no way to [Inaudible] Our fund balance if it is going up and down, we identify y wah the fund balance is and a assign it and we have no budget amendments so the fund balance is still in tact versus [Inaudible] Budget amendments. my second question, I have multiple, that the board isn't receiving budget
046amendments. They're not going through the board, so how can the board possibly make recommendations when we're not receiving these amendments in advance to be reviewed and considered? MS. Johnson? since I've been here, we have been through all the budget amendments through DECEMBER and you have DECEMBER in your packet now, so if the board has been hah received the budget amendments, if there is any questions, you can feel free to reach out to myself and my staff. All the budget amendments have been fulfilled for the fiscal year up to date. You are going to be expecting JANUARY next month. . Inger and I'm continuing on, I'm documenting this for the record if n case dls a budget issue in the future, the estimated 3% we're required by law, I want to make sure I thoroughly question
047staff about this because I want to make sure that someone is held accountable. On here, they say detail ares omitted on assigned and assigned portions to show how the district comply widths the state required 3%. can you point out to where the public can find that. well, the actual expenditure and is revenue received, you have not received any amendments, we haven't amended the budget yet, when we do an amendment, that affects the fund balance if the amendment ill pacts the fund ball l -- balance, a lot of the amendments do not impact the fund balance, therefore you have not received any amendments. the circular argument that is made here is the board is not receiving these amendments so how can we possibly know we haven't done them yet or bring them forth so how can
048you make an accurate assessment on incomplete data. Wefrjt have not amended the budget, when we amend the budget, you will sao e receive the amended budget and then when we have questions op the impact on the fund balance, we will bripg it forward. The actual revenue was received to date and expenditure tos date. When there is an amendment by my department, we will go through that if it impact it is fund balance, we will go through the details anyway, if it doesn't impact the fund balance, when it does websinger will let you guys know. are you saying that the funding has not been change tog the schools and the state funding that we have not received one budget amendment, there haven't been any changes, that's why we haven't been presented with anything or we have
049been presented -- we have not received the third calculation from state websinger ear waiting for that third calculation which impacts the budget in a major way due to enrollment. We will receive that third calculation which has not been received by our area yet, that will be the first budget amendment you receive. and one of the final things I want to bring forward too is that the public at least from phone calls I've received, they don't -- they're not assured that the district's financially stable with the current budget reports esspshlly in light of some things have not been recorded as far as interest payments that were made and they're not being reflected in the way they're being made, so I would like to know too, what can we say to the public now to make them
050comfortable that the district is financially stable and we're not going to be falling below the 3% we're required to keep by law? well, based on the information we received, we record expenditure and is funds we receive, there has not been an entry that has not been roared r -- recorded improperly and we're on track to be fiscally solvent for this year. that makes me feel so much bet and her say we are finance -- financially stable and the public doesn't have anything to worry about. I hope we avoid an unrocky future especially among raises coming up with teachers but I appreciate you telling everyone that you're confident in the way things are proceeding. Thank you. you're welcome. Thank you. thank you very much. DR. Zeman? I spent a few years budgeting, chair, and I'm going
051counter the narrative that just came out. Broward county schools is excellent at budgeting, there's 18 page that is have just been entered in the public record that go down to detail revenue and expenditures. It's broken out this year in a way that is easy to understand and uses plain english. it says things like here's a line that we pass money through to the charter schools so why do we track it? Never should have. You MAY not know this, our old financial records used to do projections versus actual, that doesn't follow generally acceptable accounting procedures, we do now. Broward county schools with this superintendent and this cfo make sure that government money is being spent in a way that is fully transparent. There is no nobody, nobody in the community that thinks we are not acting
052in a responsible or stable manner. If you do, I will give you 18 pages, you can call me, you can call the superintendent and we'll walk you through it because it's crystal clear. Our fund balance is growing, our budgetbacker budget amendments, five of them came before this board last month. We reviewed them in detail. We continue to review these things and in other meetings, we are tracking other items that need to be done otherwise. But I am not going to sit here while the narrative is presented that somebody out of the 2 million people that live in broward county that think our money is not being spent wisely or we are unstable websinger are stable and watch thing budget and being thoughtful about what is being spent. I want to say thank you to the
053superintendent, I appreciate it very much, things like the charter schools being pulled out is important, things like showing actual versus actual versus projections versus actual, nobody's family dwo wo do that f you're sitting at home and think k about money, you're not thinking about what your projected income s you're looking at your actual income and those things are important. I have a couple of points that I think are incredibly important, today I just added up real quick the amount of federal money that comes to broward county schools. I'm happy to share that number even though I don't have it in the report separately, 868 million dollars either comes from the federal directly to broward county or through the state to us. That's 41% of the amount of money we have on the operating side. When
054the federal government passes rules that say if you done do x, we'll withdraw your money, it's a lot of money. And it's money that goes often to our most vulnerable students through title 1, ese funding for therapies and other things like bus systems and lunches so, it is a lot of money if f the federal government is going to pass mandates on local government execution of school districts, we have to pay attention because it is a lot of our money. Thanks again for pulling this stuff together, thank youerer for leading this district in our roughly 6 billion dodoars of total revenue e and total expepeitures per year.. I have one suggeseson t thoh and is tharard that has asked this in the past, it's confusing to us to get fund balance numbers throughout the year.
055The state's law about fund balance is only about the total amount of unassigned money that we have compared to total revenue on JUNE 30, is that correct, chair? DR. Hepburn? that's correct. so, getting interim reports along the way confuses us. We're laser focused as MS. Fam pointed out on fund balance, we're painfully aware of the 3% limit, we love to follow our policy which says 5% to the extent we can, but fund balance throughout the year could easily be con viewed as great, with ear at 8.6 or 5.6 when the flow of funds that come into government make us borrow money tat beginning tof year because we don't have enough in, allow us to pay those things back. The funds we don't accumulate or execute on, we get to earn back, it's stable and wise
056decision that we do that but I would not -- either I would ask if we could call them something else or follow the board's direction which please don't report fund balance unless it's an end of year fund balance so that way we're tracking the same number all around. all those in favor of f2, say aye. aye. any opposed? F2 passes unanimously. Next item is o1, can I have a motion and a second? so moved. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Rupert, any public comment on o1? no registered speakers. thank you, MRS. Fam? hold on. yes, thank you. In looking at -- I have the chart right here. In looking at precertification or prequalification as you want to call it, I noticed one of it is super low and I'm wondering what we're
057doing about that. We have veterans, business enterprises now, veterans business enterprises female at 1%, just one term for the female and is one for the males, others we have over and then the lowest even close to that is 11. I'm wondering what are we doing to make sure our veterans are getting precertified and/or recruiting veterans especially in light we know they're offering to do volunteer work now for the district but ak hull it's been a little bit poo pooed and it's going come -- coming out in the press this week, we have a veterans organization that has volunteer today do some work on [Inaudible] Behind one of our schools that is grossly needing some work and is an eye sore and is in danger, they were supposed to begin the project or they thought they
058had a green light for the project but instead some individuals called the school and said they didn't like the [Inaudible] Which is let make [Inaudible] So instead of accepting 100 thousand dollars in free services, it looks like the district might go out and purchase or put out their bids for another organization and pay for that out of their pocket. It's my understanding we're trying to keep costs down. Why you would do this at this point in time, to me, I can make the analogy that it's similar to when fema went out and refused to assist people from north carolina because they had trump signs on their property. MS. Fam, this is about prequalification. I understand, and this is about veterans that are prequalified and precertified and I'm telling you that they have come forward, in
059fact, DR. Hepburn, I have asked him to go out and even inspect the area but they're getting push-back, and is that from -- I don't know if they're employees, parents or whatever, what kind of county are we, do we turn away people that volunteer to do services and are veterans on our list because of a logo they have of let's make america clean again? thank you, I will address two things, I will ask MS. Paul to weigh in, the first one to straighten the record, there is the organization that's providing volunteer support for piper high school to clean up some overgrown areas that was introduced to me by MS. Rupert probably a week or two ago. That's still on so we don't turn volunteers away when they're doing something to help the betterment of our
060schools and our community, so I don't know what we're hearing about turning a volunteer away for work like that. And MS. Paul, if you can follow up on the question that MS. Fam had about acquiring more veteran businesses or contractors for our contracts. thank you, DR. Hepburn, for following up on that, it was very disturbing, so I hope that situation can be rectified. Thank you. to the board chair, superintendent hepburn, board members, we definitely have a very aggressive program in bringing volunteers into the district under DR. Hepburn's leadership as well as the different categories of small businesses and so forth. As a veteran, I will not turn away veteran organizations, I encourage them to be involve ined our district especially when they come as volunteers so I'm not sure where that came from, but I
061would tell you it has not reached me and we deaf -- definitely need more veteran participation. That's all I have to say about that. and I would like to mover this into the record show thing 1% being the lowest in our protected categories, thank you. thank you, MRS. Alhadeff. DR. Hepburn, can you speak to veteran priority. yes, we have veteran priority in many aspects of the district including hr for hiring individuals, they get additional points with veteran status and I know in procurement for contracts, there is a lot of outreach for veterans on that side too. We put a lot of effort into making sure that we're caoe cratereating an environment where our veterans feel welcome and can do business with us and provide for our district. Er all those in favor, say aye. yao
062I. motion carries unanimously. Er next item is o2, can I have a motion and a second. It's been moved by DR. Zeman, second by MS. Rupert. Any pub luck comment on o2? no, ma'am. I have DR. Zeman?Frjt thank you very much, chair, iped to take a minute and recognize that there are certainly folks who will look at this chart on page 3 and wish that we did more, you know. Our non-certified spend, we'll continue to do better but one indication of doing bet ser looking at the number of firms we have outreached to and talked to and that consistently grows over time. The bigger question I have is , chair, maybe for our general counsel, what does the outlook look like for having minority owned firms be recruited to bid on work for broward county
063schools? MS. Batista? thank you, MADAM Chair. DR. Zeman, are you speaking about based upon the executive orders and other colleague letters and so on? I am. so, those items have not touched upon businesses as of yet, so we are certainly very aware of what is happening and how those executive orders and other material is affecting pupils and student admissions for example and so on, but so far there hasn't been anything that has percolated to that level. and while we're op that topic stl, anything in broward county schools has seems to be violating the new executive orders in relation to race and orders? no, not so far to my knowledge. thank you. all those in favor of o2, say aye. aye. any opposed, motion carries unanimously. At this time, DR. Holness has an additional moment of
064silence. one moment, MADAM Chair. I am so sorry. I got it, it's on my phone. please join me in a moment of silence to honor the life of tanasha, a ninth grade student at board anderson high school, tanasha loved dance, love for dabs, brought joy to all who knew her, her vibrant spirit and passion sfr life will be deeply missed by her family, friends and the entire board anderson high school community. MAY her memory inspire us to embrace every moment with the same energy and enthusiasm she shared with others. Thank you. thank you, this is the time of the agenda where we have split the general public speakers to incorporate a morning session. Each registered speaker is reminded to present their agenda comments in accordance with policy 1020. First speaker? mayra and trudy jermanovich. my
065name is mayra, city of pembroke pines, I'm here to represent myself and my colleagues. We are a group of owners of private children transportation company that is operate on the west broward county, specifically in the air y of the west pembroke pines, we service charter schools and public schools and our job is to transport children from their house to the school and from the school to their house. All of a sudden inspectors of broward county consumer department appear in one of our schools, sparkly summer set academy requires us to change our liability insurance of 100 thousand dollars to thousand without any notice in advance. We are supposed to take the rules by the statutes of the state of florida and also by the department of children and family. Gives us citations of 1 -- thousand
066dollars to 25 thousand dollars, we did not comply with them, making us cut routes, stop businesses and even closing down. According to the board county commissioners, broward county florida human services department, public school transportation should follow the ordinance on section 2298, subsection 7, and the liability insurance as specified on section 316614 and section 324021 of the state of florida statutes and constitution says that all buses and motor vehicles covered by subsections 1 and must be covered by single limit liability insurance to protect pupils being transported from their house to the school and the following amount, 5 thousand dollars multiplied by the carried amount of children and the maximum amount of children we carry is 14 children which make it 70 thousand dollars or 100 thousand dollars, whichever one is greater, so our question is, why
067are the inspectors of the consumer department going against the statutes and the constitution and making us pay a 500 thousand dollars liability insurance. Their answer is because they consider limos, taxis or vehicle for hire. Their job is to pick up tourists, to pick up executives and pick up people from the port, the hotels and from the airport, while we pick up children from school that come home dirty, sweaty and hungry. They charge $300 for their inspections which is only a cosmetic inspection. We cannot be cosmetic all the time inside because we carry children that are dirty that are in the mud and on the play ground, so all of the other counties which are 67 county ins the state of florida, they do not charge that, another county charges $90, ao tl 's another county
068that doesn't have inspections, in the broward schools, we're the only ones that get citations. that was your three minutes. go back to the 300 thousand dollars insurance that we're supposed paying. thank you, DR. Hepburn, can you address this. thank you for sharing the concern. The broward county public schools is not our lane sparse issuing citations or addressing any concerns from the inspectors, all the entities that you m ef mentioned in your comments, those are the people that you're going the need to talk to to address that concern. We have absolutely nothing to do with that facet, I can reference them, I went through this two years ago in the county o the north where individuals were transporting students just like yourselves and they went through the same thing and they had to go get those
069certification and is those licenses because of the amount of students you're transporting but not our lane, you have to communicate with the entities you listed but thank you for what you do for our kids and our communities. Thank you. next up we have DR. Trudy jermanovich and then we have MS. Greaves after. I'm going to read what's on the broward county website for how to access the sex ed program, the disease prevention curriculum for the 2024-25 school year is under revision and will be posted upon approval. I would like this board to have a discussion on why this revision is happening so late in the school year but it must happen in a board meeting or workshop in the very near future. Is broward county the only district which has nod had their sex ed
070curriculum approved tat state level? I see many others have had this approved. Why is this happening? Why has this happened for the last three years since the district could have looked at other approved programs. If I don't bring this up, I'm fearful our students will be denied this important component for all public schools. Next on the agenda, there is an item regarding how many students do not have internet access on a computer or a tablet. The only way to get some baseline data for this issue would be to do an anonymous survey where painterbacker parents could fill out the sur va I online or return a hard copy survey to the school to be add today the data. It would be a big task, if you want to analyze the problem, you need this information.
071The only way to truly transform the way students use textbooks online is to make sure each student has a tablet. They would have access to educational programs as well as the ability to type and submit their written assignments and their textbooks. I know this MAY seem like an overwhelming task, if you con strait on student who is don't have access at home, it's a step in the right direction. I also believe this would be the time to partner with broward ed foundation to have a fund where people or businesses could donate money to make this happen. Perhaps access could begin next school year, I applaud DR. Holness for bringing this important equity issue forward. The policy on public speaking and committee reports is not ready to be approved. It appears that you're silencing the public.
072Thank you. thank you. DR. Hepburn, can you address the sex education part. yes, MR. Sullivan? yes, so our team, john sullivan, chief legislative communications affairs officer, they have to approve it before we're able to offer it, we're in constant contact to try to get it approved from them websinger have the opportunity to offer it to our students before the conclusion tof school year. thank you, next public speaker? good morning, MADAM Chair, vice chair, superintendent, board members, I stand before you to give you an update in regards to the broward estates elementary school that I have concerns. The board basically directed the staff to give concierge service to the parents at the last meeting as well as make sure that everything is done properly, perception versus reality. The reality is as they did with the school
073choice, they did not follow your instructions. I basically went to the school with the parents and there was about 6-8 parent there is, and what staff did was asking parents their name and just highlightingngthe children's me withouout having a one one conversaon with h th. Ththere were parent thatis was there that did not speak english, there was no translation there. So, those parents didn't quite understand what was going on. The few that was there. I went there, the next morning as well and there was about two to three parents at that particular meeting and the conversation went with two of them, they came back because they still would not clue in as to what was going on. There was a text message that was sent out to the parents saying that on JANUARY 22, 2025,
074that the school board was going to consolidate, basically most of the parents that was there consolidated said broward estate to martin luther king, they do not want to go to martin luther kin, they signed up to go to plantation middle school. There are concerns that I'm aware of that plantation does not want lauderhill schools, plantation was in the backup on the last meeting but none of those parents want their kids going to martin luther king. District did confirm at the parent's meeting to them that is not a true montessori school, they have pockets of it so that's mislead tog the parents and they're confused, hurt and lost. Their safety concerns of the parents, I told the parents they need transportation that they need to contact the principal, that not concierge service, these parents are lost,
075upset, they're hurt, you speak about mission statement providing all students with necessary social and emotional academic and career skill tos effectively succeed, that's not going happen with this going on. So, I ask you to please bring it back and reconsider it. There's buildings at the school, we asked for a model, you have four schools that had the model we asked for, charles drew elementary, mayor bethune, pete and he iser eastwood, you -- west radioed, you don't have to reinvent the we'll, you have empty buildings being used for storage. Thank you. thank you, I'll give DR. Wanza and her team and also the regional office team the opportunity to clarify any misconceptions. valerie wanza, chief strategy and innovation officer, thank you for the opportunity, skol board members, the viewing as well as attending public, so the
076district staff did exactly as the board directed us to do, so we did go out, we had an evening meeting as well as a morning meeting the next day, so that is true. But we also realized what we did probably a week ago is we put an actual personalized letter in each one of the student's backpacks to go home that was sent to the parents that gave them some information because we do recognize that some of the parents work different kinds of hours and those hours that we would have a meeting at 7:00 MAY not be good for some or 7:00 in the evening or 7:30 in the morning, that's one phase we did. We also worked with the principal and asked her to please identify a saturday that we would come out because some
077parents MAY need a saturday option, we would come out on saturday from 8-12 and set up at the school to work with the families if that was the desired option for them. We are going to the school on FEBRUARY 27th, I believe is the date where they are having an actual coolidge event where we will be there to meet with families on that day as well. Coupled with the fact we did actually work with the central regional office which plantation elementary school is under as well as the school transformation office which is the office that broward estates is under and we do have more personalized things because what we found was when we did go to the meeting that night that was scheduled for parents, many of the community members thought it was a community
078meeting and it was not a community meeting, it was a meeting to meet specifically with parents so we could discuss their individual needs. One of the things I will say is that it was a more powerful experience that we did not have the district translators a the meeting that evening. The actual prainsbacker principal of martin luther king elementary school, MS. Parent, is very nraoun in the language that parents needed translation nr and she was able to provide a more intimate touch with them explaining processes, procedures. We have worked with the transportation department and we have always made it known that if families wanted to continue in the the stem magnet, that plantation elementary school would be the option for them and depending on where they live, we've also worked -- MS. Paul's team is die
079nam nick what they do, we know there MAY be concerns as it relates to hazardous walking conditions but the good thing is that with plantation elementary school, they do have a transportation boundary, a transportation zone but depending on where the shunts live, there will be transportation provided for them and we did explain tla to parents as well. I think that one of the things that some of our colleagues in the community MAY not appreciate is the fact that these are meetings with families and these are not community meetings and there are times that we're not going to discuss family issues in an open meeting. That is why we did go out to the school with personalized letters for the children to take home so that we can talk individually with their families, so those are
080just some of the things. We also told the principal if there are other ideas that she would like us to incorporate that would better meet the needs, we would certainly do those things but we are definitely committed to ensuring that we meet the needs of all the families but one of the things we know is even when when we make every attempt, if a family -- it comes to them that it's now JUNE and they need to make a decision, we're going to work with them then, so there is no cut off, there is no deadline, we will continue to work with each family until we have taken care of each family. MADAM Chair? DR. Holness? I was trying to present but DR. Hepburn and DR. Holness, we were able to solidify dates on their
081calendar on friday, there's a flyer that will probably go out later today for the initial community meeting. We've already been in conversation with the city staff and the elected officials so they know so that meeting will take place on MARCH 3 at 6:00 at broward estates elementary school and that meeting is to do what the board also directed us because it was in the board item for us to meet with the community to talk about the transition, the services, the resources that will be incorporated in the early learning center. Sorry, DR. Holness, I didn't mean to cut you off. DR. Hepburn, I believe when we had discussed this item, we had mentioned that every single student, I believe it's 116 inbound students, that every single one of them will be aware of their options, will
082be aware of the process that's taken place and I also believe we talk about plantation elementary, seeing that you have to cross state road 7 to get to it, that transportation would be provided for those families who elect to go to plantation elementary. Just want to confirm that we are on the same page. we're on the same page 100% so, thank infuser the opportunity to clear up the misconception, they are getting concierge services, we're starting for a group strategy first, those who are not participating in that group strategy websinger will address those individually. that was going to be my next question, the approach we currently have is a group strategy as you termed it and we will still MISS Student sos the question I have is how are we tracking the students we're gaining contact
083with so that we can have a more individualized approach to those who are not getting those to those arranged meetings. we know every student we have contacted, DR. Wanza's team is doing a great job and to keep an attendance roll to see which student wes have not contacted yet. there was a contact from the speaker that plantation elementary intends to be implied that there's some reluctance to take student from lauderhill to plantation elementary, have you heard of that and if that's the case, how do we -- I have not heard anything like that. Our doors -- every door in our district is open to receive student from all of our marketing efforts, our showcase efforts, our continuous engagement with community, parents and the like just to increase enrollment, period, so that is not the case
084and surely I did not want to create that type of rumor or misconception right here in this public meet sog the public's out there, that's not something that we're hearing, that's not something we're proffering, we're doing the total opposite to make sure both of those schools have welcoming environments for those students coming from broward es tates. so, plantation elementary and mlk, those principals are fully aware of the process and of accepting these students in the most embracing manner I would say so, they're comfortable, the parents are comfortable and they understand the transition? absolutely. Both principal ares excited about the opportunity and I would warn the public not to participate in any rumors like that either. We know how things can spread quickly when one person says something and another person spreads that wild firefinger our
085doors are open for all our kids, period. and MADAM Chair, I will be done in one second. DR. Hepburn, can you assure the public, I heard the concerns and I want to make sure the community understands because this is important to them, can you assure the public that every single inpoundbacker bound student will be contacted and will be aware of their copses and how to transition to these two schools? absolutely can confirm that. and have you exhausted all options or do you intend to exhaust all options to reach every single student? absolutely. and were you intending on the alternative options beyond the group to be what would that look like, is that letters, is that e-mails, is that phone calls? it's all of the above, we're starting with a group dynamic and as we find
086out the amount of families are tha aren't engaging in that process websinger eel move to an individual process to make sure every family has an opportunity to discover the choices they have with the transition. thank you, sir. thank you. thank you, next public speaker. yes, we have debra lamas and marks e -- mae smith. my name is debra, I've lived in broward county for o ifr 27 year, I was a liaison from my son's time in the public schools, I will read from my notes, I volunteered after I retired as well for several years in the broward county public school system. What I witnessed was disturbing at best the waste of food in our school's cafeterias, my numbers MAY be off, according to the latest data I could find websinger have approximately 254 thousand students
087in our schools, 42.6% of those students are economically disvaked which obviously lends to food poverty. So, that MAY e a quait to over or approximately 108 thousand children that are receiving free or reduced breakfast and lunches. Teacher student ratio is approximately 20 to 1, it is clear these same teachers are not afforded time to police the cafeteria, however someone must because the amount of waste is beyond comprehension. We are demonstrating every single day in our cafeterias that it is okay to throw away perfectly good food, unopen milk contain and he iser such. A first grader which is what I witnessed because I would go to the cafeterias with them and similar ages having only 30 minutes to eat cannot consume a slice of pizza and a mill and can a juice and a cookie and
088dessert of their choosing, the pizza is half eaten, the unopened milk contain and her the fruit and the other remains go into the garbage. These children many of who MAY not gate proper meal at dinner, we're focusing more on academics and that sort of thing. I realize there is or was a pilot program or initiative to reduce food waste broward county public school food recovery program, I don't know if this is still in effect, I have made many phone calls to various schools and most of whom I spoke with were unaware of this program which basically tells me that the food is still going on these trays and going on the conveyer belt and going into the garbage. There's a tremendous amount of food being wasted. I recognize sharing is not permit and had removal
089of said item is not allowed either. If they had the where with all to take the fruit back to the classroom and place it into their book bags for late ner the day, they are not allowed. I suggest having someone there at the front of the line or the end of the line to keep an eye on what their trays hold so perhaps not allowing them to put so much food on their tray to begin with will eliminate a lot of this food waste and sending them a horrible message because they're monkeying ri at night and they wasted part of their lunch. Thank you. thank you, next public speaker. unless mae smith is not here, we can go to the wait list. mae smith is there. I'm here, good afternoon, board members and staff, my
090name is mae smith, I'm standing before you today to plead at your hearts to rethink item number m m-1 to bring it back, to give our children the best option and that is the community met last week on monday actually and talked about a better way to keep our school, keep broward estates as an elementary school, add a learning center and change the boundaries so that more students are bound for the school. Several schools throughout the district as you all know are understood enrolled. There were 33 schools on the chopping block or repurposing as we call it, but only broward estate elementary is forced to accept something. The other schools had options and they brought forth what they wanted for their neighborhoods. We're asking the same thing for broward estates. Let's talk about the numbers
091of the school because I keep hearing everyone saying we're so underenrolled and I heard that the number is supposed to be 695 students in that school. However, we have 216 seats, yet we have 222 students there, half of that 695 is all storage. Why are we considering that part of the number of underenrollment? That's not right. 7 million dollars was allocated to broward estates elementary since 2014 yet 5 million went for the roof and mechanical issue and is other things to make that school bet and her more accepting. Not one dollar has been spent on that school in those areas, where we continue wally try today make the school to be change ined the future, is that why we didn't put any dollars in it that we should. I'm a taxpayer, a lot of the
092budget on my taxes go to the school board for those reasons. I voted for it and I push people, it's not fair that we can't do it. I just learned on monday night our boundaries, you guys look at our boundary, it's only about 8-9 blocks to broward estates elementary sx, you say people are not having babies, if you picked a chunk of our neighborhood out which has seniors, 80 year o els aren't having babies anymore f you stretch that boundary out, you will able to receive more students then and you will see the our school will come up nr the numbers. MS. Hixon, you spoke about having the parents come, our neighborhoods don't afford us to maybe have those parents come or maybe they're like I was back in the day when I didn't know
093how to speak for my children or other folks' children that I was raising so therefore we're coming out and being the voice. we're going o do petitions because that MAY work better for the parents to be able because some people are not comfortable with this microphone or been able to come so I'm asking you guys, revisit this thing, any one of you can bring this item back and allow a better process. I'm not like the people you hired to come out, I'm not a diplomatic speak ner the way they can to make it seem that -- thank you so much. Okay. Next we'll be going to committee reports and our first two reports are going to be virtual because the committee chair was not able to attend and let us know ahead of time. So
094we'll have the audit and district advisory council committee reports. hello. DR. Lynch-walsh, can you hear us, you're okay to start. okay. I wasn't quite sure what we were doing. Alright, thank you. So, first up I guess is the audit committee report. The audit committee on FEBRUARY 13th and one aof the reports that we transmitted was the audited acfr which surprisingly is on today's agenda as ff2. So, and we had some concerns, it was not a unanimous vote to transmsm. We so first t read a tion ababt t techchnological devivis s and the tionon was toto recommend the audit committee be provided with a technological device that includes the necessary software, security and ability to update agenda information automatically torx reduce the financial and personnel costs associated with transporting and transmitting paper. We also transmitted the
095bernl funds audit report that followed a heated debate of sorts between the director of the business support center and the chief auditor's staff regarding a problem and how they were categorizing and what they were using internal funds for. It seems that the business support center was allowing a school to move funds into a trust account to purchase a conference table and office chairs which are not appropriate uses per chapter of the red book and basically chapter 8 says you can't use this no matter what funds you put it in so we're going to follow up on that. Property and inventory, there were a couple of fun items there, a golf cart that was picked up for repair in 2014, we're following up on how it got missed or if it was missed in semi-annual inventories
096or prior oud diets. There was also a pallet that was meant for surplusing, that was surplused by the custodian, so just some interesting things but the semi-annual inventories, that's supposed to be happening and then you're also supposed to track whether the semi-annual inventories are happening. There is a report for schools but none for administrative offices xh -- which has been a problem prior. But most of our time was spent on the annual comprehensive financial report, there were general -- the discussion centered around the accrued issue around the charter school settle. , there was significant discussion on whether it was properly recorded and recorded in the district's fund financials, yes, everything is on the districtwide and the reason for it being on the districtwide versus fund financials is when you put it in districtwide, it doesn't
097impact the fund balance meaning it wouldn't drop below 3%. This was something that was discuss witched the cfo where she stated on DECEMBER 12th at has special meeting that had they booked it the way that the accountants on the audit committee would have expected to have it booked, it would have dropped the fund balance to below 3%. The other issue that some of our members had as far as those that voted against transmitting it because three of us were not in agreement, also had to do with the next year budget appropriations, the 54.6 million which is on page 88 of the acfr, we're looking for clarification on that amount. There were conflicting explanations at previous meetings and we wanted to see -- wanted to know if this amount includes fund set aside for the charter
098school settlement and other referendum related spen hurst. This report as far as our concerns, I pulled from co-pilot, so that will be sent to you because this was a pretty significant discussion. We also talked about the budget reports because one is related to the other. You have item ff2, they're claiming you would be out of compliance but mer 31 is the deadline. And then florida statute 1011.041 is pr wr the policy comes from and speak toser your projected fund balance so we'll be discussing that in the future and I think -- I'm not sure if I'm at five minutes. . Er you have 20 seconds. 20? And the superintendent has been -- the superintendent and the cfo have been invite today the next audit committee meeting. the chief financial officer was not there in person
099or virtually and we're having these types of discussions, it would be helpful for them to be there but I'll be forwarding you that report. next is the district advisory council report. okay. so, let's see, at our last meeting, we did not pass any motions but we did have a robust discussion related to syllabi, canvas, pacing guides and what's included or not included in the teacher contract. There was staff present which included the chief of hr, it wasn't clear what his role there was to the group but essentially we talked about having templates for syllabi and having a reporting mechanism like a dashboard and to help track whether grades were being input as per the contract because grades are in the teacher contract. So, thereafter representative from it and actually MR. [Inaudible] Was helpful in looking
100for solutions but at the end of the conversation and again this will be forwarded to you, at the end of the conversation, everyone in the room could agree on next steps but we don't have senior management at the meeting. So, people expressed concern about that and one of my follow-up items is to officially the invite the superintendent, the deputy superintendent of teaching and learning and the chief academic officer to hopefully the next dac meeting, so with that, we can talk about next steps. For example, we had a conversation that not all students have access to the internet and to computers, but -- and I see that we'll be talking about bb10 and looking forward to what comes out of that discussion, one question might be AUGUST 11th of what year, but we can't move anything
101forward if we don't have senior staff attending to help in these discussions. So, I guess I'll send a follow-up e-mail so that the invite is official. We also had passed a motion that is on today's agenda regarding the school board implement the U.S. Department of education planning together a play book for student personal device policies. There's a response that it will be provide today the group of fau researchers but the question remains, does the district plan to follow it. And then also as a member of the long range dac has a seat on the long range facility master plan steering committee. There's a memo that we were not sent but it appears we were supposed to be sent that memo regarding the future of the committee and the question is should we be -- will
102there be a meeting in ma rp because the thing being sunsetted does not appear to be the amongbacker long range facility master plan steering committee. There's a lot of confusion as far as that goes. I'm not sure where I am on my minutes. you're about a minute and 53 seconds. okay. just checking for any other dac. Dac had also passed a motion about having the long range facility master plan steering committee report directly to the school board. What made it into the memo seemed saliently different from what was said because it mentions codifying it with a resolution, so I'm not quite sure what -- if we could get some clarity, so that dac and the other members of the steering committee know what's going on there, that would be great. And we done know what
103to take back on 1020, there's a lot of procedural things in 1020 that are not in 1070 and that's going to be the next policy up and the problem when you put too many procedures in a policy is you MAY have to change them. so, I'm not sure where today's discussion is going to go but we've talked about the committees have not been in favor of all of those procedural requirements for the advisories that are currently in 1020 that they need to be listed in a procedural manual or in 1070, so that's some feedback on that. Thank you. thank you so much. The next committee report is broward county association of student council and is student advisory to the board. good morning, landyn, advisor to the school board websinger have been making good progress on
104our speak up, speak out sessions and have received good feedback from students and having productive conversations we caner are on track to complete 36 sessions by the end of MARCH, so we're really excited about that, excuse me, and onebacker want to thank the administration at the various schools we've conducted these sessions at for welcoming us and also taking the feedback that we've shared with them. We have heard from some students about some improvements being made and we're grateful for the support of our high school principals. On the speak out, speak up sessionsser we were able to have a discussion with DR. Hepburn abd guidance in school counseling regarding a recurring theme at a lot of our speak up, speak out sessions about students having access to school counseling so we appreciate the support from DR.
105Hepburn and staff in that area and making some improvements so I wanted to recognize that. On wednesday MARCH 12, board chair hixon will host the student town hall, please stay tuned to social media and parent link for the lin tombing attend that town hall, we are excited about another opportunity for students to provide feedback, if any of you would like to conduct a virtual or in-person journal, please feel free to reach out websinger would love to accommodate that. The superintendent student advisory committee met last week along with school board member bulman to have a great discussion on ecofriendly initiatives the strict can implement in line with the resolution that was passed about being ecofriendly. We had a discussion on food waste, student involvement for composting and various way that is the district can support green
106initiatives for our students. This weekend, thousands of students from across the state will attend the florida association of student council's conference in orlando, broward county will have the largest presence out of any county attending so we're excited for students to have the opportunity to participate in this workshop. Again this year we're excited to announce mascot mania, a competition of all of our various school mascots who will come together to determine the best mascot of the year for a fundraiser for the south florida leadership training camp, south florida leadership fund t money we raise will fund students to attend a life changing opportunity at the south florida leadership training camp, we're excited about mascot mania, as well happening in MARCH, we will have student advisor elections for the 2025-26 school year which will be held on
107MARCH 13th, we are excited about hosting elections for next year's student advisors. As aus, if students have any concerns, they can contact us at student.Advisor @ broward schools.Com or on one of our social media channels, we're grateful for the sup frort the board as well as DR. Hepburn in the work we're doing and look forward to continuing from students across the district. Thank you very much. thank you. Broward county council ptasptsas. broward education foundation. Diversity committee. alright. So it's not morning anymore, good afternoon, board members, DR. Superintendent, staff, [Inaudible] Grant for diversity committee. And the chair, common things observed d before I start that, for the non-black people, happy plaque history month for you all, we hope you're using this mother productively and for my non-blacks -- my my blacks, not the non-blacks, black history
108mother, show the non-blacks the grace if you want to ask questions so you can be black google today. So, common things observed, our facility issues, standard of service and consistency and is safety and security issues, several schools visitor or experienced major facilities issues, work orders are at the all time high, there's project managers being transient, safety protocol, assessments and guidelines are inconsistent, all schools visitor have blind spots, s erl schools have inoperable security cameras, single point of entry is you yahoos, schools do -- have pa issues. Some schools have those issues. I did get to speak to MR. Lozano after the meeting last month and I forwarded him my specific things that we observed. He responded back with an e-mail saying they were going to follow up. However I'm not sure if the board got
109any updates from MR. Lozano because we didn't and I don't know if it ao assist safety issue, just a general response would be great to let us know that you have addressed some of these issues. The superintendent was present at our meeting last month, thank you so much, DR. Superintendent, for coming, the committee was please today have him. Committee members were able to ask the superintendent some important questions about sdrigt accountability, ice raids, school performance, maximum updates. DR. Superintendent recognized there needs to be better training and oversight. The superintendent stated he and his staff are doing climate surveys, coaching and support with development teams, they do cabinet meetings to observe gap and is to help understand school tos help navigate through those gaps. The student performance are monitored year round, the superintendent stated there would
110be information sent out to parents about ice raids, our student reps were present, there were three of them there, they requested these superintendents send out communications that are also student centered about ice, the superintendent agreed and said he would reach out to our student advisors. It is currently undergoing a facility condition assessment, that should be conclude ined MAY and be present today the board in JUNE and our final item we mentioned at our meeting was DR. Zeman's request for general counsel about changing and/or updating the settlement conditions, I received the response to DR. Zeman's query t the committee had an opportunity to look it over and we came to a a consensus, the committee considers the them to be [Inaudible] In nature, it will lose the original stand ining the intention of the lawsuit. Our
111motion reads, I mover the school board of broward county rerecollectbacker jesting any consideration for revision tos the ccc settlement conditions as the indicator for said conditions are modernized where necessary by the diversity committee on a yearly basis. I will concludes and say I will always end my report with a phrase power is with the people, not the people in perceived power, we work better together than apart. I want to emphasize community in putting in collaboration, this district could not thrive without volunteer and is non-profit organizations who believe it takes a village. You guys have a great day. thank you so much. MADAM Chair? yes, MS. Alhadeff? yes, thank you. If we could just be mindful to respectfully not call out names of schools with specific school safety vulnerabilities, thank you. okay, thank you. next committee
112report, btu. Bpaa. [Inaudible]. Copa? I'll keep going, if someone -- who's coming? Okay. Copa was next. Okay. good afternoon, MADAM Chair, board members, superintendent hepburn, I'm dorothy davis smith and I represent the confidential office personnel association which is known as copa. For the newer board members who I have not had the pleasure of addressing before, copa is a non-bargaining heat and confer group that represents the school based office managers and the district based employ eyes that have ---- backer employees who have been deemed confidential who work in various positions. At the top, the highest pay grade of our salary schedule is where all of the board secretaries and the superintendent secretaries have been placed. Our interest in being here today is to address the salary increases for the 24-25 school year. We've had several meetings
113with hr regarding raises for this group of clerical employees and we have been advised that the board intends to increase the salary bucket for this group by 2.5%5%. While we arare alalwaysgrefeful toto receive salary increases, we find ourselves in a situation that we can only hope was a non-intended consequence resulting from the board's decision on increases during the 23-24 school year. Of the district's approximately 28 thousand employees, all were given permanent salary increases last year except for approximately 1500 employees. 400 of them were confidential employees, while the others who were not given salary increases are administrators, confidential employees or clerical. In comparison, fope clericals were given a 2.5% increase last year along with other non-instructional bargaining groups. confidential employees received only a 2.2% one-time non-recurring, non-frs eligible bonus. We were told). Now to be clear,
114we have no bone of contention about you providing increases to these confidential employees. What we have a problem with is what you did not provide for the rest of the unit who would have been grateful for the 2.5% increase that the majority of school board employees received. As you can imagine, that decision has led to some division and a sense of being devalued within the confidential unit. The bigger issue as we see is, is if the rest of the non-instructional employees are receiving another 2.5% increase this year, it will be on top of their increased salaries from last year. For example, that would give fope clericals, our counterpart, a 5% increase over the last two years and the confidential only half of that amount during the same time period. This would not only cause a
115loss of salary again this year but it also affects having neg the tif impact rather on the future retirement income since no additional increase was reported to our fras last year, we are asking the board to show that you valued the rest of the hardworking confidential employees, they need to know they are recognized for their work and support they provide to management. This can be done by you approving a greater salary increase for the 24-25 school year. Although these confidential employees will not have recovered from no increases on the salary schedule last year, a higher increase this year will be a gesture that says they are appreciated. thank you so much. thank you. thank you, btu? how are you doing, anna fusco, I hope you heard everything she said and have some fruitful conversations to
116make everyone in this district whole which is what your commitment has been said and promised and we know you guys are trying, so have some real great conversations to -- how about groups that might have been forgotten, not purposeful, we're getting ready to go back to negotiations for my other group, the technical support professionals or tsp's, we're hoping that there's going to be great conversation on moving towards an increase for them and then we are hoping from the conversations I've had with various school board members and superintendent hepburn that we're looking to start sooner than later, so we can have an understanding of negotiations and possible increases for when people come back into the next school year and as always, we're asking you to all have real strong conversations, real conversations about what's going on
117with the insurance, there's an insurance committee that meets -- try tos meet monthly if there's business. We have real great conversation there. It's public because it is transcribed, you are allowed to know what happen ins that meeting so feel free to read what happens so you can hear the conversations of the direction that we go in and go back and forth of how our insurance is used and the money cost and so forth, so I think you would get a fruitful understanding that you do not have to come on the backs of the employees of broward county public schools. I'm telling you now that it's a benefit that is needed and it's a benefit that is way more deserved than you can imagine and they deserve amazing health insurance that under certain circumstances got forbid
118when people get gravely ill, the insurance is so great they're taken care of. On another note, I would like you guys to take a look on the impact that our educators are having with this -- we know we want to be -- continue to be an a rated district. I love that we are. I always felt we always have been. I don't believe in the stupid tests tla you think tla's what defines our students, what defines our students is when we have great schools, they're taken care of, the educator that is are in there, the admin that are in there, all of that community in there that wants to nourish our students wh, tle ear able to get their reading block done, their math and science block done, their social studies done, get some recess,
119get some physical actinviter, get their full lunch to be nowhere bushed to, to get that extra piece, before school, academic activity or after school activity, or maybe sports or any other type of academic fun club, not all the schools are getting that. They're being impacted that they're told only work on getting those tests to mover your school to an a. It is happening. Trust me, it's happening. Either visit your schools yourself and go check it out or get some real date since we have a lot of schools that are real big on data chats which also overtake our plc's which I'm going to tie into what our ten day early release day that is I knower there's a line item for school board member zeman, I did have a conversation, we're always open to have
120fruitful negotiations on what the needs are and&the wants are. We know our children need great education but if we're not teaching in the schools because we're busy test, testing, testing and they're not get thing well rounded ps of getting outside recess, getting the foundation of having fruitful centers and able to do specials, music, art, physical education, whether it MAY be a stem, something, but all day they're sitting in their classroom just doing reading and math to pass those tests. It's like we're prepping them to go to prison, they'll go out to have lunch, that's not what we're supposed to be doing in broward county public schools. I know you guy ares looking at me like I'm having five heads, I'm not standing up here saying something that's not happening. Well roundedness is going to make
121us grow and make us well wroundbacker rounded, not passing tests, I never believed in test, it doesn't define our students and it doesn't define our studentbacker schools, our staff and our educators do. pba? Ese advisory council? good morning, everyone, jackie lusckinein, ese advisory, we had a discussion and presentation on student behavior last week, disabilities related behavior, how it's managed in schools, whether it's managed appropriately, sometimes mistaken for misbehavior where it's misunderstood disabilities related behavior, behavior management, expectation and is strategies, but we do -- one tof school board members mentioned earlier assaults on students with disabilities because staff aren't necessarily plain trained or knowledgeable about how to interact with them and how to expect behaviors and how to -- there is a difference in the behavior management that you need. There is widespread concern in our
122xhaoubtbacker community about repeatedly parents being asked to come and take their child home or suspensions happening for disabilities related bela ifr and that was not taken into account and I think these discussions are rich ones that we need to move the needle on or we think. And meaningful inclusion meeting next thursday, this is around our subcommittee having virtual parent education session led by two new diverse college students talking at how they advocate for their unique needs, the downs syndrome met last week, helping parents with those and end of school year -- extended year updates, ese advisory meeting tonight, an 11th grader is going to be sharing his story about the importance of every child being seen for their abilities, not their disabilities, and they're rising above challenges such as discrimination and injustice. His own journey
123with disabilities haves led to great things including award winning accomplishment ins the artistes, he's representing the district in state and is we're proud of him. We are also going to be talking at ese advisory about customer service. I am at every meeting absolutely swamped, swamped by a tidal wave of parents have been difficulties that they cannot get resolved with broward schools through the channels availablefinger they either don't know the chanel channels available, they're not able to advocate, we are having concerns as well about parent who is exercise their right to advocate for their kids being retaliated against and yet their advocacy is protected by law. We want bcps to have our kids' backs and I can bring you so many afros of wonderful things that go on in our district that need to be celebrated
124and talked up and applauded. And we're grateful for all of that, but when things go wrong, there are no processes or procedure that is are working for parents to seen our parents being retaliated against, being sanctioned, being found guilty of bullying and harassment without any kind of process, without any documentation, without any right of appeal, without even being notified they have been. This is cause for concern, we need to be able to bring community issues forward, individual issues where things are going wrong at school as well as things that are going right and to be listened to. I took part in the best prakt and is inclusive education self-assessment district level 1, that was a wonderful meeting we had assessing the district's progress towards inclusive practices in schools. i also brought forward to you folk
125and is to the superintendent and various department chiefs about the progress reports for iep's and ep's not having gone out when they were due with the general progress reports. I have now asked a number of questions, I know you folks then asked questions, you got my questions answered but I did not. I have separately had a nice discussion with the executive director for it who has opened some die wlog me but when you folks go to memo answering some of the questions that I brought forward, I still got no reply to my repeated e-mails. And I do think again we don't stand here just bringing up things for fun. Those progress report ares so important. And what doles I have for you, nursing is another issue that's going to be coming up tonight. I am
126hearing reports from parents of their one on one nurses for medically fragile students being removed and their jobs go to paraprofessionals, I have been texting a parent, they have kept their kid off school because they are ter aniseed. e zal leadership council. Facilities task force? Gifted advisory council? Green advisory committee? Human relations committee? good afternoon, nancy fry, chair of the maou man relations committee. I don't have much of a report because our meeting's today, but I do want to cover a few thick that is I was not able to cover in my last report because my last report covered two meetings, so five minutes only gives you so much time. First we wanted to thank the board for revising the calendar option that is were put forward for the next school year to make sure
127that there was a date that coincided request d diwali, we are the only day off that coincides with diwali, I know our community appreciates that consideration with the calendar. The think before you post program, we wanted to thank the superintendent for ensuring all of our equity, diversity and equity climate stuff, every student and staff will be taking part in that program. We also are proud to say no place for hate is currently in 170 schools, but we would like to see that program be more consistent with how it's get tog the students. We also discussed that we would love to see in the school board meetings to bring back presentations by students, for example, this was supposed to be from a january report, JANUARY was mentorship month so we were wondering why couldn't you bring
128in students from 5 thousand role models or mentoring tomorrow's leaders, to come in and acknowledge some of these observances and make the students more of a part of the meeting because I know that's something we did I believe it was pre-covid, so we would love to see that come back. Going back to all the various programs we have in the school, we're looking into feedback mechanisms for all of those programs to find out what's resonating with the students, if they're understanding the material, if it's impacting their school climate and so on and so forth. Sorry, that's a repeat. And we also wanted to congratulate the rise program graduates for those that are not familiar with the program, rise is for students that have been retained at least two times before fifth grade and they go
129to an off-site school for one semester to get really focused education and support to be able to get them promoted and then in the second half of the school year, just at the beginning of this last semester, they were promoted to 7th grade and they are given a mentor and peer support sxit's an amazing success stories we have in broward schools. And I wanted to spopd -- respond to one thing that was meption ined my report at the last meet, we talked about the feedback mechanism for students that had issue widths any type of discrimination, mistreatment by peers or by adults and specifically in reference to some of the islamophobic attacks that have been happening along with other issues with not physical threats but any kind of threat to a student's emotional safety and feeling
130that they can access their school. It was discussed that we have the safer watch app and while that is great, that is meant for physical safety measures, to my understanding, and this is something that's meant to be more for students that have issues with something in the curriculum that is big -- bigoted towards their particular demographic or teachers saying thing that is are not particularly good to students. That was the feedback we got. And I just also want to highlight that while we're promoting apps, we specifically have a cell phone ban in our schools, so to expect student tos give feedback through an app that they're not allowed to use during the school day seems a bit counterintuitive and also we should not expect that every student even has a cell phone to begin with.
131We have plenty of students that either their parents don't want them to have a cell phone, they cannot ain order a cell phone or for whatever reason, anything we're offer tog the students, that it's accessible to all of our students. So, that was all I have for that and we will have a more robust report next month after our meeting today. Thank you very much. thank you. Next isis multililgual advisory y cocommtee.E. Okay parent mmununity involvement task force. good afternoon, the parent community involvement task force met FEBRUARY 3, we discussed the community partners forum also referred to as the non-profit forum, determining the format content, the forum will be held in this room next week, one week from today, FEBRUARY 26 with registration from 11 to 11:30 and the conversation lunch will be held from
13211:30 to 1:30, on the evening of FEBRUARY 25, we will host a parent university welcome to kindergarten, this program was successful last year, we appreciate the opportunity to work with DR. Cannoning, her department and other staff member tos introduce parent tos the many program and is opportunities at broward county public schools. In keeping with our goal have shorter more targeted programs, we're planning a 60 minute program to assist parents as they take this important step in their khiel's educational journey. Policy 1020 was discussed at the meeting, a recommendation was posted, was passed which I shared at the public rule making meeting a few days later. I will take this opportunity to share it now and probably speak la later. I will share this recommendation t parent community involvement task force believes that policy 1020 should
133be registered and looped throughout all district committees whose members could be impacted and are concerned about the impact on parent and community participation. There is concern that the amendments to policy 1020 will stifle parent and community input and participation to time where we are trying to build community involvement and attract student tos our district. Finally we're continuing to work, our task force is continuing to work on our podcasting program that we're planning, we're excited about this and we hope to have some more information for you later and last month I mentioned that our longtime committee member, natalie moffett passed away, many of you reached out to me, I wanted to share with you that there will be a celebration at life next friday at o 1:30 P.M. At the life center. small f technology advisory
134committee? Okay. At this tile, we're fwieng the have a superintendent's report. thank you, MADAM Chair, please play the video, we lad a lot going on this past month and I know I speak for the superintendent, he continues to be proud of not only our students but our staff. Becon? (Playing video). thank you. This will be the part of the meeting where we will consider all the open agenda items. At this time, MAY the chair have a motion and a second to pass the open items that have not been pulled for discussion which include items bb1, bb2, bb3, bb5, bb8, bb9, dd2, gg1, jj1-4, jj6, jj8, jj9, jj10, jj12-19, oo4, oo5, oo6, oo7, oo8, oo9, oo10, oo11 and oo13. Sofrjts moved. . er second. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Alhadeff, all those
135in favor? Sorry. I wanted to make a motion to remove bb6 and bb7 or add them to this list since the changes were made prior to. so, you want to pull bb6 and bb7? no, they're already pulled now, I want -- you didn't say the name, so I would -- because they're not pulled. What I read were the ie steps that are not pulled because we're going to approve them all now. no, the problem was fixed. you don't want to pull them anymore. Thank you, we'll add bb6 and bb7 to the list. is there a second? add them to the list of things to pass. MS. Batista? She cannot pull l the items, right? right. okay. MRS. Alhadeff, did you want to keep those items pulled? I do. so we'll leave them pulled. Thank you,
136you didn't mention that. Okay. Alright, so it's been moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MRS. Alhadeff. Is there any public comments on any of the pulled items? we're good. no public comments on these? all in favor of approve thing open agenda item that is have not been pulled for discussion, say aye. aye. all those oppose, say no. Items pass, so next we will be -- we have a time certain for dd1, we're going to call dd1 to the floor, can I have a motion and a second on dd1? Sofrjts moved. moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Thompson. Any public comments on dd1? no, MADAM Chair. okay, DR. Zeman? thank you so much, chair. I have a handful of questions about this but I want to make it clear that while there's things in this
137that I wish had been done differently, audits play an incredible role in ensuring that all organizations follow the appropriate rules and guidance. It is this board's responsibility to direct audits and to approve audit plans and it's too easy to say, oh, look, here's an audit with 27 findings or recommendations. This in fact shows that while the audit costs x dollars, it saves us y dollars, saving y dollars in an audit is -- happens because you have an audit team and you respect that audit team and people watch the rules because there are schools that get audited for internal funds, there are contracts that get audited and the like and our audit team is a strong and capable team. But I have some questions abthis particular audit, it's going to take algt bit of time today,
138chair. Was this audit part of our annual plan for 24-25? DR. Hepburn? MS. Arce? good afternoon, ally acc e, audit director, I'm the designee for MR. Rhodes, the chief auditor, so through the chair, I will say yes, it was part of our plan, it was something that had been requested from the board as well when the first follow-up was requested, so yes. I'm sorry, chair, I just am a little confused, it was in the board approved annual plan and it wass requested by our board? when the last report was brought forward which was the first follow-up, it was requested that an additional follow-up be done for the next next school year. I was just making sure it was this board, it's one of our favorite words. How much did it cost to conduct this audit?Frjts
139DR. Hepburn? MS. Arces,? I have to look that up, with us today is MS. Harpalani and MR. Kin kaid who were the lead for this audit, so i will see if they e can thanes. good afternoon, this is jennifer harpalani for, the cost for the audit is not to exceed 45 thousand dollars. what was the roi for this audit? I don't have that number, I would have to follow up. okay. On page 2 of the audit report, items 8 and 10 appear to be the same finding, this is important. As someone who spent a couple of decades in government service and now significant amount of time working for the government as a contractor, I've always known it was the contractor's responsibility to submit reports, why is there a material finding for the government not unhinging
140this quarterly report in? I will ask MR. Kin caved -- kin kaid to elaborate. ben kin kaid, we separated out these findings consistent with our prior report from one respect, it is the vendor's fault for not providing the quarterly reports as required by the contract, from a secondary issue because of the historical issues that have arisen in relation too the apses and gowns contract, we had a recommendation in place previously that the school district follow up in relation to quarterly report that is were being required and mandated for vendors to provide, so the secondary finding you're referencing there, item number 10 was in this case pws did not adequately track and ensure that the vendor timely submitted those reports back to them. okay, I appreciate the opinion on that. I just disagree with that, it's
141in the contract, the vendor is require today do everything that's in the contract. If they don't, I don't believe it is the government's secondary issue that they can't do what the contractor was required to do, so we'll just have a difference of opinion on that. The audit report also says that the spend authority is exceeded. I've worked a long time in government and you get in a whopper of trouble if you exceed spend authority. But on page 26, it says that the amounts from the last audit which were added in which were coded incorrectly is what allowed there to happen. So, is this really an issue? yes, sir. So, if we were to go back and take a look at the various spend authority that was provided, whether you include the prior findings from the
142first follow-up or just the issues within the second follow-up, it was still exceeded the spend authority that was approved by the board. okay. On page 27, item 16, some of the purchase orders for caps and gowns included shipping. That was not appropriate. It was never paid by broward county schools for shipping which I think is the contract requirement and the issue. Why is this a finding that there was something on a piece of paper that was never paid that represents one third of 1% of all the purchase orders. it's an issue from the standpoint that it could have been paid and in the past, again, this has been a historical issue particularly in relation to these contracts here that there has been items that were not approved by the contract that were being paid so
143in this particular case, it had bypassed the internal control system in terms of that it was allowed to be put on to a purchase requisition and ult malty turned into a purchase order, so had the vendor in this case not submitted that as part of their invoice, then it very likely would have been paid which has existed in the historical timeframes. okay. Again, one set of eyes can look at this and find a problem. Another set of eyes could say, looker they didn't pay it and they're not supposed to pay it. So, I'm -- I continue to be curious about that. On page 32, we talk about exceptions, findings, effects and reck m dashing. Could you provide a definition for these four terms? certainly, the findings that you see there listed on 32 and continuing
144through 34 relate to the specific issues has we identified through the course of our procedures. The effects is what would potentially occur or did occur in relation to those findings and then the recommendation is of course what we would ask or the district in this case to consider to improve the internal controls to address those issue that is were identified through the kour of our procedures. and how would you define an exception? in terms of a finding is an issue that we identify through the course of our procedures that was not in compliance with the district's policies and procedures or within terms of compliance with the contract that existed with this particular vendor. terrific. The reason I ask about that is there's not a lot of discussion items included in this report or what I
145would do is not a sufficient one. The public's perception when they walk away from this report is that we're again not in compliance with a substantive way with state or statutes or broward county policies. I don't think that's true. Out of the 21 observations, the primary finding or exception is really about using internal funds to purchase cap and gowns, tla's also a no-no, it's nice to observe that, it's easy to correct, we do a lot of training about how to spend internal controls and the like. I just feel like if there's going to be audit reports released to us and audit reports that go out to the public, I would like them to be balanced and I would like them to be fair and have clear kind of severity of what the implications are. I
146think if other people look at this and say shipping put on a form that was never paid, is that really a violation or is that an issue that might not have been a find -- finding in a report, I think that's great. Audits by theses are wonderful things, they make sure good people do good things and I appreciate them. This audit as a repeat audit got a starting point from the first audit. i hope that the findings are not a reflection of looking for things that MAY or MAY not exist and trying to fill up a table of things so there's a long report. I don't have any evidence of that. I just disagree with sol of naoez findings as to whether or not they're worth running down and I do think for things like
147contractor behavior, it's difficult to point to a government employee and say you should have encouraged the contractor to do what's said in their contract. If it's in their contract, that's pretty much a great motivation for them to get it done and there's consequences for missing turning those things in, so I would appreciate it if there wass more discussion in audit reports, so that whoever reads this would kind of see that a lot of the things that were looked at turned out to be great and some of the thing that is were looked at did not but the severity of these thing ins my own opinion is inflated. One third of 1% or something on a form that never got paid I think just needs to be clearly explained to this board and clearly explained to
148the public so they can understand kind of the severity of what you looked . Ank you very much, chair. t tnknkyou.U. Okayalalthosose in favor of dd1, say aye. aye. any opposed? Motion carries. The next item to the floor is item ll1, can I have a motion and a second. so moved. second. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, second by MRS. Alhadeff , I'm trying to say it right, I'm sorry, any public comment? yes, we have two speakers, one's not here, natalie lynch wall-walsh, the next one is mary furdic. this is the motions. we're good. first up is board member bulman. thank you, chair. I actually pulled this, I wanted some clarification. Will we be voting on accept thing recommendations today, is that part of -- yes, we vote on the item -- we don't vote
149on it unless somebody bring as motion doing anything but we vote on accepting or we're receiving the recommendation. we're receiving it but not necessarily accepting the recommendation? correct. okay, that's all. Thank you. alright, MRS. Rupert? thank you, was it ll1 and ll2 or just ll1? just ll1. thank you, ited to -- hinted to weigh -- I wanted to weigh in on the particular motion that is were there, long range plan, I agree with that, adopt aecom's framework, yes. The audit committee, first item, yes. Audit recommendation number 2, yes. Human relations question, yes. Ftf, long range plan, yes. okay, thank you. I also pulled this item. So, DR. Hepburn, there were two recommendations, one from the diversity committee and one from the facilities task force that spoke to the steering committee and long range facility plans,
150so can you just one more time explain what's happening with that so that we know that it's been addressed? yes, absolutely. First of all, just clarifying nomenclature, there's been several names other the past few year that is's been used for this group, but right now we're calling it the long range facilities master plan steering committee, that committee will be formally sunsetted immediately and creating the superintendent's long range facilities and steering committee which will be made up of industry professionals, so we can start moving the work forward with input from industry professionals in construction, engineering, finance, a resolution will be coming forward also to codify that with the board. And we sent a memo out or I sent a memo out last week just to update the board on my intentions of formalizing this new steering
151committee so we can move this work forward as we have a lot of facilities work to perform in the near future. thank you, so just to be clear, the steering committee, whatever it was called, that will cease to exist and a new committee is being formed that is not necessarily made up of the same -- that is correct. okay. yes. I wanted to clarify that. I also just wanted to point out the district advisory council had a question about the cell phone policy, so I appreciate that there's a study being done, so that we can have some data. Human relations also asked about a required course that trains participants to develop a positive cultural school environment and the answer was there is a course being created, so I appreciate that it looks like most of
152these recommendations have been addressed in some way. Anybody else? MRS. Rupert again? yes, to DR. Hepburn's statement about sunsetting this committee and then bring it back with industry standards. I think that's great. You should be doing that, I'm not comfortable with cutting out the part from my standpoint of our community's voice. I don't know where that would be, so could you walk me through that a little bit. DR. Hepburn? if you can give me some specifics, as you're talking about make-up of the committee? yes. yes, so for the most part t majority of the make-up of the committee will be folks that have industry knowledge and expertise so they can provide the best feedback possible so we can move this work forward fast, efficient and actually complete projects. After we recruit and set the specific
153people who are going to be on na group, we can start looking at community members that can provide some additional value to that committee also. okay. I would prefer as one board member that there is concurrently the same time the public's conversation in this aspect. I feel, yes, we need industry standards, yes, we need their expertise and the construction aspect part but we also need our community. Sometimes we say we're listening and we think we're doing everything that's expected of us for the voice to be able to be heard at this level and sometimes we sometimes close doors. So, for me, this appears like a closing door to the public and I know that's not your intent and it's certainly not something I'm comfortable with. I guess I would like to see after you put
154your committee together, how we will incorporate the public's community stakeholder people that are the absolute foundation of our district quite honestly. yes, of course. I don't know if other board members wanted to baying in on that. Er and we wouldn't be closing our doors, it would be a public forum where it's transparent and in sunshine, so it won't be something done behind closed doors. MRS. Alhadeff? thank you. So, I know DR. Hepburn, you sent your memo. Was there communication to the people that are in the committee that's being disbanded, that they are being disbanded? we are formalize hating communication now and we'll have a face to face meeting with them too o to go over all the change that is will happen. I suggest in the future there could be something simultaneously being done because
155I think it's hurtful to the committee member that is are in there now to find out whether from this memo or from this board member but that we appreciate them and d yes, absolutely. There was no intention to hurt anybody. I wasn't aware that memo was going to be sent out tha,'s why I sent it specifically to the board to update you first and then we were going to circle back and communicate with the other stakeholders in the current committee. thank you. All those in favor of item ll1, say aye. aye. any opposed? Motion -- so, it passes 8-1. The next item is ll2, can I have a motion and a second to bring ll2 to the floor? so moved. second. it's been moved by DR. Zeman, seconded by MS. Leonardi. Any public comment on
156ll2? Wefrjt have mary furdi and DR. Trudy jermanovich. Sofrjts, since we both found out that they're going to hold up our social securities check, I guess that's why we -- alright. My name is DR. Trudy jermanovich, I believe you recollected have another workshop item on policy 1020. Most of the committees are not in favor of all the requirements which are put upon them in the proposed policy. Also the way that the rule for public speakers is written is very confusing and will be detrimental for people trying to speak on an item. Follow what's been done in the past and give a total number of minutes a speaker can speak during a meeting, period. These are only some of the topics which were discussed by participants at the evening rule development meeting which provide the public
157a choice of being able to speak on agenda items either on public comment time at the start of a meeting or when the itemm ititlf I is on the f floor. Cuenently your job policy prohibits limiting all public comment to the start of the meeting. I feel it removes the immediacy. Between us speaking at the beginning of a meeting and you then getting to the item that we provided input on, another 20 items MAY have gone by and I think having the immediacy of thought and being able to speak would be helpful. Splitting the time is too complicated. I don't think most members of the public will understand that and I think it's restrictive. It was my that started the debate about defamatory. I did it because I have -- concerns that it's not a
158legally defendable position you're putting forward in your policy. It's important to protect dequorum but school -- defamation is a judicial-only determination. That's why I suggested putting the word "derogatory" in there. We within the to see you protecting public decorum and protecting it but you have the wore in there and it will get you in a pickle. Committees produce publicly available minutes. I feel the forms reveal a misunderstanding of how committees function and provide them to it limit their ability to report immediately to the board. Committees and advisories don't form to make policies. We need to be able to peek to all aspects of our committees a work. Weed he be happy to craft forms that meet with your requirements and ours to make a better appendix. Thank you. next speaker. Drl furtig is next. I
159lost five seconds, john. Public input at board meetings has been diminished over the years. There was a time that there was not a time limit. They limited it further the amount of time an individual could speak and they limited furd the time a individual speaking and now we're here today where, trust me, you know nobody comes to speak on your public items. I would encourage to you do what we've asked and bring this back to we can fine-tune some of the language before you pass it. The policy revision is further lilting our time by requiring input of a meeting. You're disenfranchising people taking children to school and various other things would not be able to be here. Last week uld a ribbon cutting in stranahan high school. That began -- that began with the community
160with three minutes in this room. Noria, you were here, you know that's the case. I will tell you that ended up with a beautiful now cafeteria. 1987 and 1988 trudy and I were here and we had our three minutes, the committee and now the advisory board spoke out about the dmorable condition of eastern schools. It resulted that more money, hundreds of millions of dollars passed on a bond issue. I did demonstrate but I've never spoken at a school board meeting before that. I didn't know what I was doing but it made a difference. Please don't take away ourability to speak on an item when it comes up. The meetings are now longer that ever ever so it's not the public speaking that does it. There is nothing more important than public education. Send us back
161as the parent community involvement taskers task force and others, let us work with you to craft a system that will work for your neeghts make them orderly and also gift board meaningful input. Thank you. p I'm DR. Treudy jermanovich. That's wa why you dot the new middle school. Because of those kinds of meetings. We need these meetings to be open. What you're doing is closing off the public. Because not change this and make it so complex. All you have to do, it appears that you're still trying to split the time, as they said, that's just silly. What you've done is you've I cut down time. Already. And now you're going to cut it in half because most people don't speak on those consent items. You're limiting all kinds of things within this policy instead of
162opening it up. It would be simple to say, if you don't want to make it 15 minutes, make it 12 minutes. Then it's dwibl by three and they don't have to figure out how many minutes to speak on an item. That's dumb. Also, I think that you have to start listening to your committee people. You've going to not have committee meme is what is going to happen. They're going to leave and when these people leave, who would want to come back to the mess that you're creating by this policy. So unless you're going to change this policy today and put in the things we've asked for, i suggest that you go back and pause -- whatever you want to call it, have another workshop after you've spoken to the committee chair people. That's the only
163solution that you have here. Please don't do this. Thank you. next public speaker. I'm erin goal and I'm here to express deep concerns regarding the proposed changes to this policy. Several changes significantly limit opportunities for community engagement at a time when strengthening these connections should be a priority. Over past year, we have seen firsthand how vital community input is to ensuring that school board decisions reflect the realities, perspectives and needs of families, schools and educators. We support increasing and expanding not restricting opportunities for meaningful engagement should be the goal. Capping public comments restricts impacted individuals and community leaders from providing critical input to the board and broader public. Separating public comment from the board discussion dleuts the impact that has on decision making. Limiting opinion reduces public access to the insights of informed and committed
164volunteers and down grades the value of these committees to the school district. It sends a discouraging message that community input is not valued by this school board. Those that take the time to attend meetings, serve on committees or provide expertise and lived experiences should not be sidelined. This is a vital point of transparency, viability and trust in our school system. I appreciate the intent behind several of these proposed changes, however, respect for the community must also mean welcoming its input in a meaningful and accessible way. Thank you. thank you and our last plirk speak. nicole marks. I disagree with cutting any public speaking time. I understand that general speaking time is not included in the 10 minutes, if you don't use that time, you're losing time and only five people per session can use public
165speaking time. I disagree with some of your time being taken for motions can. Some items MAY have six or seven motions and it's unfair that the public be force to ration our time to speak on issues that affect us and our children. In a sometime of grit decline in our district, we should not limit anyone willing to participate. We want to participate. Thank you. thank you so much. board members, I'm advised that the general public would like an attorney client session. I'm requesting that all persons not attending the attorney/client session, please leave the room. the first session is luna kohn group ink versus the school board broward county 24-006018. also 24006021, 24006025, 24006026 and 24006970 pending before the 17th judicial circuit in and for broward county floored. School board members, leonardi, al, ald hef, pham,
166jeff hoalness. Rupert, thompson. Zeeman, DR. Howard pep burn. Oscar e. Societier, thomas keuny expire. The second session is burt construction, inc. Verses broward county 24006568 cace pending before the 17th judicial circuit in and for broward county floored. Attending debra hixon k7 sarah leonardi, ald hef. Bowman, pham, holeness. Rupert, zeeman, hepburn, thomas kuehney ex-choir and mayoral batista esquire. These were properly noticedded for today -- 1:45. The purpose of the attorney client sessions are discuss settlement negotiations and/or strategy relative to the pending litigation. A certified court reporter will record the sessions. Only those noted in the advertisement will be permitted to attend. People to get here in the morning, especially when they're driving their kids to school. To come down to fort fort lauderdale, it could be challenging to get mere toe speak on -- in the
167beginning of a meeting. But it I could just verify page 7 number 1 with regards to the red line, specifically what that means. MR. Hill. thank you. through the chair. Number one, what it does is two things. It reduces the 15 minutes down to 10 minutes for the cumulative time for public speakers to engage with the board during school board meetings. That does not include their speaking time as well as it does not include their written public comments. Later on in the policy, it also addresses -- it splits it between consensus and open agenda items. what I'm understanding what it's saying is they're only allowed to speak in the beginning of the meeting and not when the item is pulled. the only time -- sorry. go ahead. the only time when they can speaken the
168agenda itself is during motions. So the one minute there for the unused time, they are still allowed to do that. Otherwise they have it speak either before the item is taken in the bulk, any agenda items that were not pulled, they could speak at that time before the board moves forward with the open agenda. O the beginning of the the actual agenda itself. timing wise, what do you think the time be would be that those would occur? the consent agenda is first. I would say if the meeting startedded at 8:45, around 9:00 is when they would speak for the consent items. For the open agenda items, maybe about 11:00 11 o'clock or noon latest 11:00 or 11:30. I think timing-wise, it's way too early. Also for me as a board member, I like to hear
169what the public has to say when that item comes forward to the board as brought to the floor. I have a motion prepared and so, I'll just come out with it and then we can go from there. So, I move to amend page 7 of 16-a-1. A single speaker MAY not exceed 12 minutes in total per m meeting including their general public comments. If any substitute motion is introduced, the speaker is allowed one additional minute to speak on that motion and time spent delivering committee reports does not count towards the 12-minute total. it's been moved and seconded. Any public comment on the motion? trudy german vimp. Vich, I like -- german jermanovich. I like those changes but you don't include the public speaker time. Question you asked was referring to this particular motion as I
170understood it, it was a little bit confusing because it didn't sound like that's what you were asking, thank you. thank you jackie. 12 minutes is better than 10 minutes. I would like to get back to the 15, but thank you for the offer of compromise plus the 1 minute for motions. And yes to chair reports. That's not specified. That's a good catch. It's not even specified anywhere in the draft. I could see that chair reports are protected five minutes on top of the other time. I agree, I don't think your question was -- I'm sorry -- are you -- thank you. I don't think your question that you asked was actually answered. Thank you. thank you. Any board discussion on the motion? DR. Holman. Just to clarify your motion. For the 12 minutes, this would
171include open or consent, it doesn't matter, correct? correct. I like the motion except that I would prefer that it does not include the general speak and sign-up. So, I will go ahead and listen to everyone, but I would like to make a substitute motion. Is that a substitute motion to add? no stud. what is the term? Amendment. Okay. So I would like to make an amendment to the motion, but maybe the amendment would still keep board mem alhadeff's motion on the floor. It's been amended and she would have to accept it? Is that how it works? I just want to make sure. So make the motion? had there is a motion on the floor, if you second it, then belongs to the assembly so MRS. Alhadeff would not have to approve. so I make a
172motion to amend correct? if that's what you wish to do. I would like to make a motion to amend the current motion to include three minutes of general public sign-up. Public speak ask sign-up which happens in the morning and arch, correct? The motion is to add an additional three minutes for those who sign up for general public speaking. But every other part of the motion I agree with. I'm going to second it, but I have a suggestion. Instead of -- I think the way it's written, if you said not including the general public comments, it would say what you want that to say. but I want to limit it to three minutes. it is limited to three minutes. The motion is to say a speak is not to exceed 12 minutes not including 9 public
173comment. I accept that. Public comment on the motion. trudy german o jermanovich. To have it split like it's consent and in the consent, it should be for the whole meeting. And so, maybe you need to put that in. MRS. Alhadeff, can you explain. You want this to replace what's in red? right. This is on page 7-a-1. It would replace what is in red. And the motion ask a single speaker MAY not exceed 12 minutes in total per meeting. And then DR. Holness said "not" including their general public comments. if any substitute motion is introduced, the speaker will have one additional time to speak on the motion. The public speaking on does not include the 12 minutes. thank you. It still doesn't address the consent versus non-consent. You know your intentions but you have a page
174and a half of feedback from the community of points the community wanted to address and suggested. It's not clear if they're going to address those or if these are the sole proposals. If they say we support a motion and that's it and move on. This is why alternatives to this process were suggested. It's messy not been design process here. You have a clock ticking on a time certain at 3:00. I'm not certain how you're he going to doll this in a methodical manner. I do believe this is just saying a single speaker can speak for is 12 minutes in ray piano meeting. It's separating out the time. that's correct. Any time during the meeting just like we normally do now and I we ask for public speaker. just for the sake of the olympic, MAY
175MISS Batista say we pass this motion that's what assess saying? yes, the motion is to replace the language in red font on page 7 which talks about five minutes to address items on the consent and five minutes to address items on open items with the motion that is on the floor. MR. Hill. thank you MADAM Chair. I want to remind the board if they make this motion, they will have to amend the language on page 10 of the red line on the bottom. It breaks down that open and consent section at well. right, page 7, 4-b. If this is in any place it has the time. okay. MISS Thompson. For clarification, this woation would take it back to where we have it now where you get to speak on the motion but only for 12
176minutes, correct? 12 minutes total. I'm in favor of that. DR. Zeman. on potential wording issue on the primary motion, I'm happy to talk about the amendment. On the second bullet it says if any substitute motion is introduced. What about an amendment like this is introduced. Would people still be able to speak? MISS Baa. no, the languages is any substitute motion. If the intent is to have the speaker speak as to any motion that word should not be there. The substitute part should be taken out. could, if any motion is made, it might be an alternative to come back to that later. I'm not in favor of this. I'm not in favor of voting on this policy at all today. I like to spend school board meeting having good productive, sitive discuions abo inings. i t
177think the community has made some points, but the staff has not presented where those points could go in and the pros and cons about these different things. I'm very worried about piecemealing this policy and ending up with a frankenstein. It's one of the most important policies we have as a school board. It's a reflection of the school board and therefore the school system in terms of how we conduct mites. My view is that while this amendment I don't support and this motion I don't support because I worry actually about the people he don't come to our meetings any more. I worry about the people -- people I appointed to advisory meetings and quit after one meeting because of the conduct of the advisory meeting. We need change. We need to have positive, engaging, thoughtful discussions
178at school board peteings and I don't see this getting us there. I would prefer to table this and come back when we have alternatives that come out of page 2. Where the community has said there are things we'd like different. I would like to know where the staff thinks that fits. Would I like to come up with a general policy on how to conduct meetings in a way that we're does things efficiently and effectively for the students of our district. I worry that we'll end up told with a frankenstein policy after we debate it for hours when instead what we could use are alternates based on community input, pros and cons cons and decisions that go through and end up with something we all agree on. I would like the top three decisions to come
179up at 1:00 clock. Say we'll do these toip five issues at 1:00. There are chaiks that changes we could make to our meeting to make them more engaging to the public and transparent. I think we conduct business to the best of our ability and get criticizedder in not being accountable because of the time of day it comes up. We cannot allow people to speak inif I natalie. We have to come up with a -- infinitely. We had l we need to have more people come to the meetings. People I appoint said somebody had an agenda, they ran around with it, I was not allowed to talk. It wasn't the type of engagement that we want and that destroys our relationship with the community. I don't support this amendment or motion. Eventually if we spend too
180much time on this, I hope wie table this and do thoughtful discussion next month and have alternatives laid out for the board. I haven't gone yet. MAY I speak on this point? sheur. L-2 that we just had was approve the denial of the request to basically workshop policy 1020. through the chair, what was the vote on that? 5-4. So DR. Zeman. You were on the yes, side. I'm confused why you didn't want to workshop it if you're saying now, I think you're saying you want to workshop it. I want the staff to bring us pros and cons for the options so we have yes or no votes on those things and we have cohesive alternatives for what we want to do at a school board meeting. My view is if we table this and get
181the staff work done, we can make a much better policy at the end of the day. That's my opinion. thank you. I was going to make a similar suggestionses a motion, but I will just repeat why I thought it made sense to split it into the open and consent. Many times people will e-mail me or they see me in the grocery store or wherever and say why do I have to wait all day to talk to an item? I want to come to the school board meeting but your meetings are 8 hours and I can't come. The purpose of doing it this way is to allow them to speak at the beginning of the consent and beginning of the open items so they didn't feel the need. They were welcome to stay because again, motions
182come up as we're discussing it and obviously they'll have their comments on motions as we're going through that. So I still feel strongly about having time right before each so that people know. And I think if we -- some suggestions were to allow who wanted to talk then and have others right before the item, I think that's just too confusing. But I was going to ask and make a motion to change it to 12 minutes. And I'm okay with whether it's 12 minutes all at one time or six for each of them. I would still like to see they need to dress the items before consent and open items. I do agree with the timing. So thank you. anybody else? address to DR. Zeman's point. We workshopped this two times and we have the feedback
183from the community to work with. I support his idea of going become ot staff and seeing if we can work this a little better. One point -- a couple of good points were made during the comments. We do not want to close out the public. It's important that we're hearing from them. I like the motion and putting it together. Another thing that was brought up was the forms for the committee report. It sounds like the committee members would like to have input to resize the forms if we accept the rule as it is right now that includes the exhibit which is incorporated so I don't know what the procedure is but I would like to see the advisory committees be able to get some feedback for that before we incorporate it into the policy. and
184I'll just let MR. Sullivan addresses that. But I will say that the forms were not new. the requirements did not change. If you look at the red line, there are no real changes in there. That was in policy before. They're the same fomples that have been there for a while. We had community members saying the forms could be tweaked. I thought they were going to make it those memberses at the meeting we had. That was a discussion that we had and I say yes, bring them ydz. If we were to pass this today with the idea that the forms could look different, would we have to come back and revote on this? Or can the appendix of the form -- like the form itself look different even though it's the same title of the form?
185The form is part of the motion. If you change the form, you would have to bring back the motion. And MR. Sullivan you wanted to add something. this policy is how school board meetings are governed. This is a superintendent recommendation. The reason we didn't provide pros and cons is because it wouldn't have been appropriate to do so. It's how the board governs themselves in meets. We provide a way for account board to react if they so choose. thank you. I agree disagree with our general counsel. I suggest a member of this board would make a motion to delete those forms and reference forms that are provided and ask then those forms could be updated. I don't think pom si needs to include forms. Forms are forms. They are documents to gather data and get things
186done. If there was an option to refer to these by name, we could host those on a website and people could use that. Is that fair? MISS Batista. I would love to say yes, but the answer is no. Whatever forms are part of this policy, they are by reference part of the policy. Whether you name it and not attach the form, the point of policy would be incomplete and you cannot make changes to the form because they are part of the policy. again, I fill out so many forms every week that are the result of policies is of this board. And the board policy says you must fill out a form to go on a field trip and those forms are not in the policy. Why couldn't we have this form outside of the policy
187and like thousands of other forms that we do in broward county schools that are called out in policy but not codified. I believe those forms are in policy and if they're not, they should be. wow. Well we'll continue to disagree on that. I have one more point of order. I believe that community contribution those things that this we're considering ought to be staffed by this staff. they are advisers to us on what is good or bad or in conflict with what is written in the policy. That's why I talked about having the staff do this. They're all school board policies but I need to need to know more about the pros and cons about what the professional staff feels about how we conduct meetings. anybody else about the motion which is to amend page 7
188a-1 a single speaker MAY not exceed 12 minutes per meeting not including their general comments. Speakers are allowed one editional minutes. point of order, I think we're going to vote on the amendment first. that's where we're at. All those in favor of the amendment say aye. aye. any opposed say no. no. school board bowman. yes. fam. yes. hixon. yes. honas. [Indiscernible] em len yrdy. no. zeman. yes. no. [Indiscernible] no. we have to make the same changes on letter b it's the same paragraph. I don't know if you have to vote on that. roll call. okay. I'll make a motion to delete the section and replace it with this on -- I believe all you have you have do is delete the red portion. Offer section b and a. Section a and b of page 10.
189okay. Both a and b? yes. second. wait. Just b unless MISS Batista thinks it's different. I think it's just b. right, it would be b in the two different places on b. Two different areas. on page 10. so just delete b al together. of the red. right, the red line. yes. okay. So I move that we delete the red on the red line version, the things in red on page 104-b. second -- 10 4-b. second. any comment on the motion? count us confused. Can you clarify what we're doing, what you're proposing. it's a repeat of whafs just changed. So it has to be changed in both places. The -- what was just changed? It needs clarification. This is so important. Not just to those of us who still managed to survive sitting here. But all
190of your community. We've brought up so many constructive, sensible suggestions that you haven't even brought up and you're going to move on and strike out some wording and we're not going to clarify what it is and why? I'll repeat it again. What was changessed on page 7 of 16 a-1 is that it will now read a single speaker MAY not exceed 12 minutes in total per meeting not including their general public comments. If any motion is introduced, the speaker is allowed one additional minute to speak on that motion and the time spent delivering committee reports does not count towards the 12 minutes total. That was passed. Now we have to make the same motion on page 10, letter 4-b because it was the same wording so it has to be changed in both places. what
191happens to all the other things we suggested? we're only on one motion p. we've done it already. If you're saying it linked to what you've already decided, you're saying you're squaring off language too concur with what you passed. for this one motion, that's correct. I apologize because I ran out quickly when you you had the closed door. Are you making it that a speak to one item? yes. and you said the red sos so not the things with the black lines in it. correct. and you're allowing one minute to speak on an amendment which could be a sub stan tifer change to a motion. yes, which is what I think it is now. thank you. Now we're back to speaking on an item, now we'll go to the next. all those in favor of the
192motion for making the same amendment to major 10 a 4 b say aye eye pos pos say no. 2340. MISS Leonardi, are you still on? yes. And your vote was. no. MRS. Alhadeff. my other comment was with regards to the attachments for the committees. There seems to be possibly some confusion in regards to these specifics and these reports. So the way it is now, it would be required to submit these reports. That's how I'm undersing it. I think it should just be a recommendation. MR. Sul vann. Would you like -- sullivan, would you like to seek to that? it's already in the policy. The point ever the forms is to make it easier for the committees to organize themselves and make the information of the meetings adjustable to the board so they can react to
193it. is it required in the policy? it would be required under the recommendation, yes. okay. And what page is that on? page 9. it's only required if you don't intend to give a report in person. That's attach. A and b which is d as in dog. 37 I move b and d to make those reports -- make them as a recommendation. it's been moved and seconded. Public comment on the motion. : I see several places where you would have to do this and just by way of saying this, I said it earlier, I was on an activist in 1987 but by the early 90s, I was sitting in numerous district committees including chairing. So I would like to say, that yes, for some people it's great to have these. You use the word, shall, you
194shall do a report. What are you going to do to enforce some of these. Optimal great? Providing resources, wonderful. Your staff resources great. Just be careful what you require because that brings up another issue. There are a lot of things that you'll have to change here that I think you'll have to stop here for your 3:00 P.M. Time. What you're requiring by all of this verbiage, I mean, a policy shouldn't be soum pages? This is crazy. No one can figure out what you're doing and you still, I don't believe you addressed the original point which was do I have to come and speak for five minutes for on a consent agenda? Or and then on the other side, so you're missing all kinds of things and that's why, this is not the place to be
195doing it. You should be doing it at a workshop. MS. Alhadeff wanted to address something then we're going to go to our 3:00 o'clock time certain, so we'll pause this. my question MS. Batista, if I MISS Shall to MAY and then on d, shall to MAY, will that show that it's option al to do the forms? yes. ?A. Will be my motion, must to MAY and in d, shall to MAY. second. okay. okay, we're going to pause this conversation to bring ss1, since we have a time then and we'll come back to it. Can I have a motion and a second to bring ss1 to the floor. s-1. sorry, s1. Moved by MS. Rupert seconded by MS. Thompson. Any public comment on s1? yes, MR. Haouda. I'm michael I'm the district commissioner which is where
196the aquatic center is, and I can of anybody more deserving than to have this aquatic center named after my friend peggy. I'm going to make any comments short so we can get moving. Thank you. okay, we're going to move this, MS. Rupert. I'm going to say this, I get choked up. Peggy knowland wears her heart on her sleeve. She spear headed the aquatic center for the dearfield community and she is a tour de france force and in honor here to receive this and to vote to change the name of the aquatic center to the peggy noland aquatic center, congratulations to peggy for this honor, I'm glad to call you a friend and a former commissioner of mine. Thank you. okay, thank you. Any other board comment? All those in favor of s11 say aye. any
197opposed? Motion carries unanimously. [Cheers and applause] we're going to recess for a quick meeting to take a photo. We're going to recess the meeting for three minutes. thank you and welcome back again. We were on alhadeff's motion on page 10, right? 9, sorry. To say MAY as opposed to must or shall. And we were on board discussion. MR. Zeman. it seems like MAY is too harsh but we do want to recommend for advisory committees to make a report to write things down and send these to us. I like these forms although I disagree that policy should have forms. But I just feel like, MAY do something is, like you know, if you're going to get around to do it. It's recommended good for the board and good for the staff for people to have a
198record of things. If you can't come to the meeting, we recommend that you get it on paip and her get it done to the extent of the time and effort that will allow. MAY is something that we have no value in. I propose an amendment to say we recommend rather than they MAY do this. is there a second. second. okay. public comment on the motion? Okay. Board member discussion? MS. Alhadeff? thank you, DR. Zeman, so can you be specific in b and d where you would add that language? so, if I understand, the motion, the original motion on the floor it would replace must in the second line of b, where can, is that correct? MAY. I apologize, thank you. MAY, and then on d, shall on the first line also replace with MAY? yes.
199So what I'm proposing is an amendment would say is recommended to in place of MAY? And also on d instead of MAY would be is recommended to the written reports of the committee are recommended to be typed and b, and the first one would be verbal committee reports shall represent an account of respective meeting and minutes are recommended to include specs reference and attachment a, so it's a swap of a small word change recommended rather than MAY. DR. Holness. yes, so if MS. Batista recommend if it changes any meaning to the language and the intent of the policy? well in practice it MAY not change a lot. And practice, I think as a statement of what the board is trying to say, it does make a difference. MAY, it sounds like a ambivalent, you really
200don't have a preference one way or the other, when you're recommending something you prefer that it's done this way but you're not mandating it. got it, that clarifies both. Thank you. thank you. I'll make a comment. So on page 9 of 16-b where it says all verbal committee reports shall represent in account of committee respective meeting minutes and recommended must MAY, whatever, it says now must include the specifications. It's not saying that they have to fill out attachment a, it just says whatever the report is, must include these things. I think must is important there because we want them to include in what they're telling us so we have a uniform committee report that, that they know what it is we want them to at least tell us these things. We've had a lot of
201newer committee chairs saying, please give us some guidance here. We're not sure what we're suppose to be doing and they're a little nervous about coming to us. So it's not saying that they have to fill out attachment a, it just says that they have to keep attachment a in mind when they're giving that verbal report. So in d, if maybe we can change at that to add those words which says include the specification and not necessarily require them to fill out attachment b. But whatever report they're sending to us, has at the minimum have those things because I know one of our committee chairs said, if we do so much more with that. So we used that as a guide this is your guide how you're going to report out to us, we want this
202at the minimum, that was really the intent of b and d. So we can tweak that wordings but I still think it should say must include specifications, references or however must use as a guideline or something that there, they know that that's the way we as a board, this is the information at minimum we would like to know when you come to report to us, MR. Sullivan, you're flagging me there. sorry to distract you with the flag. A is not the form it's when it applies to the reports it's what it should include so the board can react to the information that they're meant to advise the verbal report. So it's not a form, they don't have to fill out a, they only have to fill out b if they're giving the report in-person. that's
203fair. yeah, so I would make another motion, I guess, is to say in letter d, the written report of the committee must be typed to include the specifications referenced in attachment b because then it would say that they don't have to do the attach but the report would have to include those things. ?A. Dam chair. DR. Holness. I thought DR. Zeman has an motion which is an amendment. and I'm making an amendment to that. so this is the second amendment. yes. so if there is an amendment on the floor already, wouldn't he have to accept? no. just replaces. it goes back. if there is a second. There might not be a second. That was my motion to keep b the way it is and to change the wordings on d. second. okay. It's been moved
204and seconded any public comment on the motion? Speaker: my fear is that as you're changing word byword, the many pages of this document today, we're just going to see it back here again because something didn't get changed that could have. Wouldn't it be better at this point to table this. It's very confuse to go sit here and hope we can follow all of these amendments. I know you've got other, you've got technology and other things that we're not sitting here with. So I would just request that we not bring this back in sixth time in six years and you got some great things in here. You're rally doing some great work, but just get it complete and bring it back so there is an opportunity for everybody to weigh in on it. Thank you. remind
205what the amendment is. the amendment is to leave b the way it is. b? page 9 of 16 on the red line. so b says all verbal committee reports should recommend and must include the specifications reference. So it says you must give those reports and I'm sorry, d, my motion is to say the written reports of the committee must be typed to include the specifications referenced in attachment b. So to echo the wordings in b to d. I just want to make the point that the, the previous item that you voted down wasn't voting down a workshop it was voting against a request for a hearing. I just want to put that out there. Thank you. chair if you can help me, what happens if this motion happens to the original motion made by MS.
206Alhadeff. this motion pass approximates, then we move on to the next thing. I'm a little worried about our sequencing, I've never seen a motion and an amendment and another motion after that, the amendment to the motion might fail in which case there is another amendment that MAY be made but when we have a motion and amendment and another motion, I don't think that's permitted under roberts. MS. Batista? so I believe that our history has been that we keep it well, that we keep it to one amendment on the floor because otherwise it gets really confusing. You know, under robert's rules, you can have two amendments up to two amendments. So I think that's where we are up to two amendments right now. if we go back to the amendment that I proposed I'm willing to
207speak against it so we can make a better one. I was advised b and d is where we need to make changes. So I'm happy to go against it and speak against it as well. okay, anybody else? so would you like to vote it down? Vote DR. Zeman's amendment down and then make your motion that's what he's proposing? sure. So we'll vote on DR. Zeman's amendment which was to change to recommend it? Right. All those in favor of the motion, the motion to change it to recommend it say aye. aye. all those opposed say no. no. motion fails. So we're back to the motion that I just made on the floor. can you make it again. okay, so the amended motion is to leave b as it is, and to chan d to say on
208page9 9 of in the e reline, the written reports of the committee must be typed to include specifications referenced in attachment b. second. okay. Any other board discussion? MS. Alhadeff. thank you. So I think that we are trying to micromanage committee members way too much. I think that I don't see, I have never seen an issue with them giving their reports in the last seven years that I've been here. I get that these are recommendations, these are volunteers, then and so now, so MS. Batista, my question to you is, if we are requiring or making strong recommendation to see volunteers, how does that impact them being a volunteer but then possibly forced to do something based on our policy? MADAM Chair? MS. Batista. so the fact that the school board has or would want to
209require certain things in the reports of volunteers, does not affect their category as a volunteer, their status as a volunteer. And you are free to do that with volunteers and their work if you prefer to see certain things or have the volunteer work in a particular way within your prerogative to do that. okay, thank you. MS. Rupert? I feel like we circled around today. To me you're not a volunteer, you're being vo told that they have to type the reports. They don't have time. I will not be supporting this part. Honestly, I think we should have taken that extra time I wanted to do a couple of hours ago. board member thompson. I would like to say that when they volunteer, there are responsibilities, if you go to volunteer, not saying that this is the
210same thing so don't misconstrue there, if you volunteer in a animal shelter, there are requirements. We're not saying this is a requirement, because all the different motions coming up, but we have a motion to change shall or MAY or recommend, we've had people reach out to our chair and ask for some guidance on what a committee report is suppose to look like, this is just providing samples and if we change the policy to recommend or MAY or whatever word that just includes the support for the ones that need it, it just covers it. But to equate having responsibility to volunteer to them being employee or employment law is not correct. That's it, thank you. and just, I'm just going to clarify something and then I'll go to MS. Bulman. Remember d the written report is
211only required which is also required if they don't come to give a report, right. If they come and give a report in-person, then, there is no written part that has to go to it. If they don't come, then how are we getting, we need to get the information from the committee, we want to know what their input is. Letter d is that written is only if they're not going to be able to show up to which is has been in policy for a while, that person, board member bulman. just, just to MS. Thompson's point. If you're a member of the pta as a volunteer, I've spent hours accounting, doing paper, that's part of the running organization, it's a volunteer position. So I don't think, I don't think that distinction is applicable here, that you can't
212have responsibility. You're suppose to come here and report some people don't do that even. So, I, I don't have a problem with having some kind of a report in front of us if you're not going to come to verbally give the report so that we know what is going on if the purpose of the advisory committee is to advise the board. If it's not, then don't do the report but how are we suppose to know what the advise is if we're not getting it from the committee? The wordings, I don't love any of the recommendations quite frankly, I don't know if should is better than must, I think there is some, some language issues with this but maybe we're just wasting a lot of time going back and forth in this forum. But, volunteers do
213have responsibilities, thank you. thank you. I couldn't mind changing my recommendation to should as oppose today what I said if that will make it easier. MS. Fam? I would like to make a motion that we table for this, we've been beating a dead horse for hours and I don't think we're going to come to consensus, we should clear our heads and really observe what we're thinking about and then instruct something already preprepared and bring it in and make some proposals. But to keep going back, this is unfair to the public and these committee members and I think this is too important of an issue to just try to wing it, so I hope somebody will second my motion. second. MS. Batista? Can you address if we were to table it, what would happen? well, I
214mean you would have to table it with some direction to do something. So that would depend ago what you're direction is. I believe that this section of the policy is actually the last section that that requires change but I could be wrong. okay, public comment on the motion? yes, please. just dwg to say it again, five times, five and a half years, you're aiming for six, you've made a lot of changes and it's hard to keep track of. I don't understand on something this important why you can't table it for a month and bring it back when all of these things have been put in writing and we can all read them together. Thank you. trudy, I would just say ditto to that but I would also say why not bring it back to the
215next workshop? And then bring it back to this thing, at least, at least you wouldn't spend the meeting next time, I'm sorry but there is so much things that are that should be taken out of here that you're going to, you're going to have the same thing happen at another meeting, just my opinion. I appreciate what's, what the plan is, but I think that you need to talk about what staff does. You can't just turn it over to staff now. If we don't understand what you want, how are they going to understand what you want? I agree with tabling it, it should have been looped. When we have policy come to north area, at least it's heavily attended. We have subcommittee, we dissect it, we staff attends, we have good conversations. At this was put
216on a night a lot of people didn't show up but we already have our calendar scheduled with our advisory meeting the night this was held. We had basketball games or whatever was going on at our schools. I hope you send it to looping, thank you. okay, board member comments, MS. Thompson. so, it's come before when you became chair and then we had to send it to a workshop, it's been a workshop, we had a community meeting, we got feedback, it's coming back, we're almost there besinger I can feel that we're almost there. We are keeping how it is now, where every one can speak to the item. This is our board policy, it's how we function as a board, and I just don't understand why we have to table it to just go back to
217workshop to have the same conversation over and over again. I'm strongly not in favor of looping it, again, it is our board policy on how we run our meetings. So I will be voting no to table it, thank you. thank you, DR. Holness. thank you, MADAM Chair. So, you know, I think this item seems to I'm not sure, how much more we are going to be discussing it if we continue, and it seems to take quite a bit of time and we do have a lot of items on that we have to finish. So just a question that I have, I wouldn't mind completing the discussion but I'm also concerned about how long we're going to be here before we get to the other items. So the question is, would this item be able to
218be placed and I'm not saying I'm advocating for this as a special school board meeting attached to the next workshop? I believe we already have a special school board meeting at the beginning of the workshop. MADAM Chair, there would not be enough time for advertisement. there you g. DR. Zeman. thank you, chair. I have three additional motions that I'll be making on this issue. With all due respect, I don't think we're at the finish line on this. My belief is that we need more understanding of what the community recommendations are. We need to know more about how those recommendations would be put into the policy, that's really great staff work. If in fact we chose to do that. And I think the board just needs more time to listen to the community and to thank
219themselves about what we really want our meetings to do. We have decades of history of listening to the community, some of our great ideas have come from the community and how we conduct our meet ising of most importance but the way we're going through this, because I think we don't know each about each paragraph and each section of this thing, and I'm happy to take responsibility for part of that, that we're not going to get this concluded in the way that we'd like. So I think tabling this is specifically asking for the staffing that I described and asking for school board members to come when we do have it on a workshop with written motion soz we can do those efficiently and effectively and we've done the research ahead of time, would make this be
220a 20-minute item on the next school board meeting rather than trying to get it right going forward. So I'm in support of MS. Fam's motion to table this until, I'm presuming until the next school board meeting in one month. Thank you. thank you, MS. Alhadeff. MADAM Chair, sorry to interrupt, I'm not sure there would be enough time for advertisement, I don't think MARCH 18th wor -- would be 28 days from now. okay, you do that. okay, I need some clarification, DR. Hepburn as far as what we did. I thought that we had, we had the meeting with the community and the community made recommendation and staff took those recommendations and put those into the policy. I don't believe that happened baseds on what is this policy. I'm trying to understand, I don't want to keep
221doing the same thing and expect a different outcome if what we did didn't get that outcome. So what are we going to change to make a difference? DR. Hepburn? MR. Sullivan. sorry, I was busy counting, it's 27 days so we will not be able to bring it to the board meeting. point of order, we notice meetings we don't add item agendas. it's rule making. We would need 28, that's how I've been trained. thank you, chair. and sorry to go back to MS. Alhadeff's point. MS. Alhadeff, do you remember the question? I was counting. what was accomplished? it was workshop where the board of directors did a community meeting, we had a community member, it was a productive meeting, even the audience, would agree, MS. Batista was there with myself and MR. Hill, we answered every
222question they had and we presented their feedback as they gave it to us as a board for board action. Again this is how the board governs itself. okay, so, so if we table this, and brings back the same document to the next school board what is changing? Besides us having more time I guess to make more motions? I don't believe, if I MAY, I don't believe there would be a lot of change. I don't believe the superintendent or staff is ready to make changes to the policy based on feedback without the board reacting with the feedback that we've already gotten and I emergency the feedback would be different because they had an opportunity to provide it. okay, thank you. thank you, that was going to be what my concern is we're just, we keep for
223a lack of a better term, kick down the road because we did have a workshop, where board members gave their input, some people were not happy some people were not. That was reflective and then there was a community meeting and board members got the form that said, how they wanted the community wanted things to be changed and that's why we're making motions, I think as we sit here today and the only way to do that is to do it at a school board meeting. So this is a long policy but I, I don't know that tabling it is going to bring this back any different at another time and we'll just rehashing everything that we just rehashed right now. MADAM Chair, before you vote on the motion, unless MS. Batista feels differently, the tabling needs
224to include the date which is advertisement requirement. MS. Batista said that's correct. I can't remember who's motion, MS. Fam, would you have to indicate that's the date you want to table it which would be APRIL 15th. we'll take the first available date, if that's the first available date, we'll take it. I'm sorry, MS. Bulman, did you have something you wanted to add? Okay, so my question to DR. Hepburn, would be if we table this to APRIL 15th, what will be done in that interim time to make when it comes back to us a more efficient way to either pass the policy or to not pass it? MR. Sullivan. we would present the motion, I mean the recommendation as is including the two motion that's passed before this. because as you mentioned, you're looking for the
225board to tell you what recommendation. that's correct. that is correct. This is how the board governs it s efl, we had a community meeting to get feedback and the board has that feedback and staff is not prepared to make any changes. it's dependent on the board, to give us direction. okay, so I'm going to ask a question to see. the board can direct us to do another community meeting. I don't think we need. I think you have the community input. So MS. Batista or DR. Hepburn, either one of you, what if dr. hepburn was to meet with each of the school board members about what those recommendations are? He gets feedback and they use that to change the policy so when it comes back to us it has what DR. Hepburn sees as the consensus
226of the board since we, wouldn't have a, does that break sunshine? we can't do that. so if I MAY, MADAM Chair. So I know the process is MAY be long and, you know, there is frustration, but, I think this is the opportunity that the board has at this meeting to make whatever motions or changes you need to make to the policy and also react to whatever it is that tt community has brought before you. So if you would like something included in the policy, this is the time for you to make a motion with the language that the community has offered and then make those changes here. okay. So let's vote on the motion of tabling the item. All those of favor of tabling pp1 say aye. aye. all those opposed say no. no. let's
227do roll call. school board members, fam. can you just the repeat the question. your motion. It's your motion to table this item until the APRIL 15th. yes. hixon. no. holness. no. leonardi? no. rupert? yes. yes, fort record? yes. thompson. no. zeman. no. alhadeff. no. I think I heard no. no. bulman. no. okay. motion fails. thank you. We'll keep going on. MS. Alhadeff do you have anything else. yes, I do have a question. The feedback frfrom the e communitit meeting, I see ththe is a a signn sheet in thbackp bubut I don't see that where is it? I saw a-line. I'm sorry you you're saying, you didn't see the feedback, it's in the idea. -- item. it's in the summary? yes. okay, thank you. so I think we're in the middle of a motion about letter
228b and d on page 9 of 16, so I'm going to, I'll mend my motion a little and go with MS. Bulman said. So in b all verbal committee reports shall represent an account of respective meeting and should include the specifications referenced and then in d the written reports of the committee should be typed to include specifications reference in attachment b. So I would like to attach those. Okay, public comment on the recommendation, on the motion? I didn't have time to look. I looked for those what came out of the meeting because, that's I didn't asked this morning how many of you had actually read, or watched the meeting because I think you would have gotten a different feel for it if you actually watched the meeting from what was given here. And but I
229think, this is at least something except I'm still worried that it makes it, and I don't know how you add something to it so it makes it feel like this is not something being put upon them which it is. And I don't care how you look at it, if you can't come to the meeting, you have to do this written report in addition to your minutes. Now is that right? This is like teachers feel when an edict from above comes down. And these people what I fear, you will not get anybody to serve on any of your committees. thank you. just for those of you that have not sat on a school board committee and most committees keep minutes, is that true? Do your committees keep minutes? Are they required to keep minutes? In the
230many years of I've done this until apparently recently those minutes were transmitted to the board which was a way for you to keep an account of what happened at a meeting, not based on what your chair came here and told you but what the committee voted on as a adopting minutes. So, do it. Do whatever your going to do in this policy. I understand you're the board, you get to do what you want, we get our three or four seconds to speak. If I sound like I'm upset. I cannot tell you how many hours collectively the people in this community donate to volunteer, because we believe in public education. And it really disturbs me to hear that this is your policy, so you get to do it and forget what we say, thank you. thank
231you. Speaker: I do see an irony that you're trying to cut down the length of meeting when we're spending this long crafting language instead of following a mechanism that would allowed the input at the community meeting but then for there would be dialogue about it, so we know that at least one of you had not seen that feedback and I can I understand that. So you're looking at our feedback for the first time and we're trying to squeeze it into policy anyway or not. It feels very messy. To the amendment, I would like to point out that the language that you're now trying to change on page 9, then you would also need to hone the language actually on the attachment to which it's referring but that says each advisory committee schmidt this report and
232it sets out the specific requirements. So is it going to be? You've got to have the language harmonized between the form and the actual policy, thank you. thank you. In light of that, I would say the motion is to include it on page 9 of 116 -- 16 and on any forms the word says shall, should be changed to should. MS. Board member bulman. thank you. To the point about the minutes, are the minutes cause I don't know so I apologize for my ignorance, are the minutes done by every committee every month and transmitted to us? DR. Hepburn? is that happening? MR. Hill or MR. Sullivan? according to 1070, yes. is it happening? depends on the committee? okay. And presumably, the same committee that is doing the minutes is the ones that would be more
233likely to do the robert and the ones not doing minutes will not be doing the report either? well I will say most of the chairs that we hear from, historically and usually are coming in-person to give the reports so the form won apply to them regardless in materials of filling out the form. All we're asking if they do show up and give a verbal report that they include certain aspects so the board can react. I don't know if that answers your question. would minutes in lieu of separate report be an acceptable alternative? that's up to the board, if that's the way they want to receive all of their minutes instead of a report, that's entirely up to this. just so we're not duplicating work or creating extra work. I understand that every one's time is
234limit especially volunteers as I view the forms, they don't seem to be extremely time consuming. That's just my personal opinion. and I would say if you look at the form, I'm going to guess most everything that they have in their minutes is what the form has. The form, I don't think if they had the minutes as long as they had everything in there which I'm going to guess it does, minutes would have the specifications so it would not have to be the form it could be the minutes. that would be up to the board if they want to receive the minutes in lieu of the form if they're not able to provide their verbal report. anybody else? DR. Holness. thank you, MADAM Chair. I want to make sure that I understand and maybe MS. Batista
235can help me. So with the word should in this context, it's taken away mandatory out of the picture? I just want to be clear on that? that's correct. Yes. so how is shall different from recommended? it really isn't. it isn't different. yeah. got it. If they're already submitting minutes and we're looking for the information, so the information is coming to us in another form, why do we need as a board member bulman mentioned that to me would be sufficient if they're not able to come to the board meeting and they submit the minutes, I can look at the minutes to see what was discussed. Why do we need to put an % additional layer of information, that they need to provide that MAY be similar to the minutes. can I clarify something? Superintendent? yes, go
236ahead MR. Sullivan. so minutes are required now, unless the board receive them and not copied, not sure where the minutes are. I don't have them, they're suppose to have minutes, maybe they have minutes, I don't want to speak for the committees. I just want to say I don't have minutes from the committees. is it mandatory that they have minutes at each of these? yes. according to current policy. And that's what I was going to clarify with the question that MS. Bulman asked, clarification, if alle committees are turning in minutes and based on what you said, the answer is no. okay, so it's quite simple, they turn in the minutes if they're not here. It's mandatory isn't it? I believe, if I MAY superintendent, policy 10770, does not matter if they have a requirement of the
237committee is to have minutes regardless of whether they show up for a report or not. MS. Batista? it's also a requirement of the sunshine law. You have to have minutes. okay, so then, if we received the minutes, why do we need, I'm just confused as to why we need a report as to why they're not here if the information is already in the minutes and we can ask for the minutes? so I'll just jump in there. They could give their minutes if they had all of the information that was on that form which it seems that they do. So this was put in there because there were a number of committee chairs that said we would like to have some guidance, what would you like to see. The newer committee chairs asked us to give
238them some guidance, so that's where theses forms came in. I understand. that's why if we change it to should it's not mandatory and if they're minutes have that information, minutes, I would guess we would all be fine with receiving the minutes if they were not here to give a verbal report. okay, thank you. call the question. okay. All those in favor of calling the question say aye. aye. can we talk about that before you go to a vote? yes or no on call the question. okay roll call. school board members, hixon? yes. holness. MADAM Chair, can you rpt motion please. we're just calling the question. yes, got it. leonardi. yes. rupert. yes. yes? yes. thompson. yes. zeman. as the guys I have three things to do for this policy? it's just on a motion. thank
239you. For the clarification, then I'm in favor. alhadeff. yes. bulman. yes. fam. yes. we have a unanimous vote. yes, all those in favor to say should as opposed must and be, and letter d, changing shall to should and adding the specifications referenced in attachment b, say aye. aye. all those opposed say? no. No. roll call. school board members, holness. yes. leonardi? yes. rupert? so changing the word, okay. yes. thompson. yes. zeman. you'll have to come back to me, john, sorry. alhadeff. no. bulman. yes. fam. no. hixon. yes. zeman. yes. 6-3, passes it. okay, great. Next, MS. Fam? MS. Fam? You're the next board member to make motions or have comments on the whole policy. I did make a motion and it was seconded but we already voted on it so I don't have anymore. okay.
240thank you though, for inquiring. going along here, DR. Holness. thank you, MADAM Chair. So my understanding is that committee chairs in order to give their report, they have to show up in-person. no. if they don't they give a written report. a written report, but I would like to understand why our why are we not allowing committee chairs if they're not able to come in-person, they give their report on zoom or by phone so we can receive it right there then and there. we did that today, a committee chair gave two reports because she was not feeling well and couldn't come. It says under extenuating circumstances and the policy so it's up to the chair. That committee chair reached out to me, and I said yes, beacon organized it. So you MAY tweak it to happen.
241Right now it says under ex extenuating circumstances. yes, so can we extend extenuating circumstances. would you like to make a motion. I would like to make a motion to include phone calls or zoom. it says virtually already, I don't think, maybe you want to take out extenuating circumstances and just say? virtually. And by phone call. it's on there. it's on there for both. right now, it's up to the chair to accept the recommendation. it's on 16 better b, it says the committee verbal report should be limited to 5 minutes, via media technology under extraordinary circumstances as determined to exist by the chair. okay, can we I'd like to make a to remove under extraordinary circumstances and have the remaining language state. I think you might want to take also as the determined to exist bit
242chair. yes. with the rest of that sentence. yes, correct. is there a second. second. public comment on the motion? Great, sorry. Board member comment? ms. Alhadeff. I think that's a great motion, I think that actually will probably have more committee members come in, speak virtually but be able to speak that gives them more flexibility so I like the motion, thank you. excellent, anyone else. is agree, it will encourage more participation and we'll probably resolve some of the issues that we've been talking about. I agree, that's why I said yes today. Anybody else? All right, all those in favor of the motion say aye. aye. any opposed? zeman. okay. So pass MS. Leonardi are you still on the line? aye. I believe it's 8-1, I believe. DR. Holness, do you have anything else? no, that's it.
243Thank you. okay, next is MS. Rupert? I already tried four hours ago. okay. MS. Thompson? thank you, see speeding along, like I said. I would just like to make a motion on section 3 of the agenda's item f where it says that, hold on let me find, 3 of 16. So, we're board members are required to have their questions in by friday and would I like to move it until monday a lot of times, we don't get our agendas until late tuesday and just having the weekend most of the staff aren't going to be working on our item responses over the weekend so giving us two days, sorry, of pating, I think we'll be better prepared for our meetings. second. that's my motion. thank you. okay, it's been moved and seconded, any public comment? Board
244member discussion? MS. Fam? what are we going to do when our board meetings when the school is closed on monday like this past week? Do you have an amendment you want to consider to that? it's just for our, you know how we send questions on monday. if I MAY, it's the daze before the, 10:00 o'clock the day before prior to the board meeting. So MS. Fam, to account for this holiday, the question, the polled items were not due in the yesterday 10:00 am, so we account for the holidays. this is to change when our questions to staff are due. Right now it's policy that they need to be on friday when the agenda is send to us but sometimes we have our workshop and our meeting agenda both set on the very same day and
245it's at least for me difficult to get in all my questions by friday. So I'm asking to move that to monday. so the would the appropriate language include 24 hours before the meeting. Staff was not here on monday, because it was PRESIDENT's day. it's not the polled, somebody can help me. When we have to send in questions to staff. It has to be, we get our agenda on tuesday, late tuesday, and then right now, it's in policy that it needs to be by friday the same week that the agenda was received, and so I'm asking for it our questions for staff follow-up to be moved to monday. are you sure it's letter f? yes, it's the last sentence on page three. on 16. instead of the last business day, it would be the first business
246day of the week of the meeting, MS. Ompson? if helps, ththe staff and superirintendent, wedon't have any pushack.K. okay. All those in favor. are we going to have discussion on it? yeah, go ahead. I think it's fine to change policy. I don't think it's reasonable to expect a response before the meeting. So if you turn in inquiry you're talking about the day before school board meeting. so there is two different things, there is the pulled items that are due. We ask those 24 hours to the meeting. To MS. Thompson's point, what she is trying to change, once we send the agenda, you have until friday to send questions. She said the weekend would be beneficial to the board to digest the items and give us the by the monday the following week. so that would
247be another week in a day for staff to answer the meetings. I'll give you an example for this meeting, we published the agenda this out, on a tuesday, those questions were due so we can respond in a timely manner. So what she wants to change, instead of you giving us the questions on that friday, that would deliver that tuesday is to give you that weekend and then on monday the questions would be due. which after that point there would be a whole point to answer the questions and us to ingest them. Yes. Sometimes when people understand thing, they don't communicate. I don't think I communicated right. in this case, you can choose. Now understand, it's just shifting the initial questions from monday to friday. okay, and would we still then, I seem to be the
248one that asked most of the question. so if you give us the questions by the new deadline, we would have until friday to answer the questions. okay, thank you. Board member bulman, did you have a question? no, that's an excellent idea because it is a time line and having the weekend would be very beneficial. okay, great. MS. Rupert. can you repeat it? okay. go ahead. would you like assistance? I can do it. I tried to turn off my mic by my computer. MS. Batista, help me out, so it's, letter f, and it says after receipt of a meeting or workshop agenda school board member should submit all questions and legislative affairs for the follow-up currently it's by the last business day, which would typically be friday. However, I would like to amend it into taking
249MS. Fam's concerns being a holiday, to say any inquiries to the office of communication and legislative affairs for follow-up by the first business day of the following week. Okay. so you have an extra three days. nice. Very good. great all those in favor of the motion say aye. aye. any opposed? Perfect. Anything else? Okay, DR. Zeman? thanks so much, chair. I have a similar change I think on, section 2-c which is page two of 16, c currently says, school board workshops, for the sole purpose of discussion, majority focus on student and learning center topics which is awesome, I love that sentence. The school board will take no action. And I will like to add to that paragraph, the chair will seek input from fellow board members on items if consensus is gained then the topic
250should be scheduled for a future workshop. public comment? DR. Hepburn or MS. Batista, to clarify, is that not what we already do? so to clarify that was language that was there in policy 1100-a which was the prior rendition of 1020 but it's not currently in this version of the policy and it has not been there for a while. so it's what we have done in practice but you want to put it in writing. yes. used to be there. okay, great. Okay, board discussion? Okay, all those in favor say aye. any opposed? Great. one more motion, ma'am, after that sentence, I would like to add one more sentence, at the conclusion of each workshop the agendas for the next two scheduled workshops will be presented to the board members, this would allow for collaborative topics to
251be addressed in those sessions. can you say that one more time. What page was that? it's at 2c on roman numeral two, capitol c where we just made the change by saying, we'll talk about it. I'm suggesting that we do it for two meetings because we want to layout. Sometimes we have great layout but it's full. So people could be pushed by the second one and that one we can present our best ideas to the superintendent. I'm not intending to own the meeting, I'm just saying it would be nice to collaborate about the next two so we can get together on what we want to talk about is most important and urgent. MS. Rupert? we used to have a very long calendar schedule of workshops agenda items, very much heavy weighed on the what the
252board and community wanted discuss. We've gotten by the waste side oh about 11 years or so. But it's been a ways. So I understand where you're coming from but they can do that now, because we did it before and it's very helpful instead of being a nudge, that's a technical term, I think, that you definitely know when you're agenda, when you're workshop topic is coming and then you can tell the public et cetera, et cetera. I can support that and is know that we could, I would like to see to have a even a sketch of what they're putting insofar. We want to have this this and this done and bha is the most resent one. Their apg meeting, at least we should be able to get that. So I agree. okay. Anybody else? All
253those in favor say aye. aye. any opposed? Motion carries. Go ahead? can I keep going. yes, sir. thank you. On page 5 of 16, we talked about this a little bit in the workshop but it didn't come through as clearly as I would like it. Number 10 is the list is the final item on the list of things for which school board members can add agenda to our school board meeting. I think number 10 is unnecessarily restrictive and ties our hands. It says other matters limited to statutory responsibilities of school board members, obviously at a school board meeting, school board members like to do things because we have 23 statutory number rate inside code. Instead of limited which sounds like these are the only things that we can do I would rather say related because
254it's difficult to say literally this is our statutory responsibility and I want to bring items specifically with those words. Buzz if we have things to contribute, we should be able to bring it up. So the substitute is instead of limited to be related. second. any public comment? Board member comment? MS. Rupert. I would like our gc to respond to that. yes, MS. Batista? talk about putting me on the spot, right? So, you know the only concern that I have is when you say limited to statutory responsibilities we know that's the whole world of what you can bring. You know, I don't know that is saying related necessarily, you know, makes that much of a difference other than as you know, you cannot bring an item that has the responsibilities or usurps the superintendent responsibility by
255putting so much or asking for so many different things that you're going into the operational side. So that would be the only concern that I have with changing the language. DR. Hepburn? MR. Sullivan if you can add to that? I'm just going, this MAY be a little unusual so forgive me. Going back to the previous motion, I just want to make sure that wouldn't, that would preclude the superintendent to add an item to agenda without it going to the board? that's not what it says. the previous motion regarding collaborating with the board? No, I don't see it that way. okay, just want to make sure. I don't think it was intended that way. I agree. The last sentence says it would allow for collaborative input, it's intended. I just want to make sure that the
256superintendent still had the flexible to bring items sometimes for a variety of reasons we have to add items for agenda that maybe did not go to the board I just want to make sure that his authority as it relates to school board meeting or workshop agenda was not being impacted in that way. all, any other board member comment? All those in favor say aye. aye. all those opposed say no. no. okay. So it passed, 7-2. two more chair. okay. On the next item, d, page 5 of 16, for the purpose of proper notice, school board adhere to the planning item, items on the agenda, and then it ends with items submitted by the school board member will be addressed during a rsbm, I would like to that to say rsbm, there are instances either for
257legislative or urgent matters of the community, we MAY want to do those at a special school board meeting. seconds. any board comment? Public comment? All those in favor say aye. aye. any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. last one, chair, sorry. Same letter page, b and c above, these items inclusive attachment and right now it says, shall be brought seven days, I would like that to be should be for seven days. That's part of my motion replace shall with should and also part of my motion, urgent items could be added to the if the chair deems them to be in good order. This is the same process where superintendent or cabinet member or gc comes and says I know there is five days left but I would like this added and the chair's discretion is in good
258order. any second? I'm sorry, the letter e on page 5 of 16, I'll reread it for you. School board agenda items addressed in subsection b and c above, these items, right now says shall be brought seven days in advance. I'm suggesting it say should be for the proper of notice and agenda item finish with urgent items can be added if the chair deems them in good order. second. any public comment on the motion? if I MAY, yes, MS. Batista. I was going to ask you to speak to that. the reason it says 7 days that's pursuant to chapter 120, that is the minimum amount of days that you have to have an item placed on the agenda for purposes of items. The only time that that can be altered is pursuant to 1001.371, which is
259for special school board meeting which is you only need 48 hours. That's why it says shall be and the language pursuant to statutory language in chapter 120, the language for the chair to approve additional items is for good cause. if you don't mind, chair. I'm just going to turn to the agenda that we're dealing with today, were all of these items added seven days before today's meeting? DR. Hepburn? no? Not all. so I'm confused, because we do meetings all the time and the chair says, this is so important, sorry I'm going to screw up the word. In good order, or good cause. good cause. with good cause, I believe school board members should have the same rights as the superintendent and I understand the law MS. Batista, but it seems like we're working around that
260administrative law and I think the exception is when the chair deems it as having good cause. that is correct. is that legal for us to do as school board members as well? that's not what the law provides. are we breaking the add when we add an agenda item before 7 days to the meeting? if it's so, if you're violating the law, if it's approved bit chair. The answer is, yes it because it has to be seven days in advance. It's accepted as part of the agenda if there is good cause by the chair. terrific. So if I withdrawal this motion or just do the should part at seven days, because that would comply the law. Bow but then there is urgent and we write to the chair, and say, I know there is five days
261but I would like this added. Would that be added after seven days. yes. so I would not need the second part. I pro poe pose that we vote it down and propose a change. you can withdrawal it without objection, from? I'm sorry, maze I withdrawal my motion without objection. yes. I would like to move that we replace on page yeah, I had to go to a different document. On page 5 paragraph e second sentence shall, to should. second. thank you. okay. Any public comment? Any other board member discussion? Okay. MS. Batista you're okay with that saying anything additional? I believe that putting in the word should it makes it clear that the chair can accept for good cause. if I MAY, I think the recommendation is not to have policy that violates the law. So
262we don't need to write it in policy but if we say shall and we fwhoe that we ask the chair that has good cause, we would have the same authority as the superintendent and senior staff. right and just to be clear, you cannot ask the chair ahead of time, so she would have to, you know, make that determination when the item is placed on the agenda. at the board meeting. Which has happened before. yes. okay. I have a question for clarification. Okay so if I'm, trying to put something on the agenda and I'm reading this, and all it says is should but we didn't add the other part about the discretion of the chair, we're just assuming that we know that. so the chair has discretion, as a rule, as a part of this statutory
263scheme to place any item made after the seven days. you don't recommend put thating in there just for clarification? I mean if you would like to do it but it's, I mean, I know it's happened before, I think MS. Hixon has done it before from an item from DR. Holness. yes. And I believe I was not the only one. right. any other questions? and I'm sorry, because when I said that you shouldn't put it in there I thought you were saying something else and I understood what you were trying to say. you gave us good advise on something I didn't say, I appreciate that, thank you. okay. Anybody else? board member thompson. I would like to make a motion that it get reviewed by legal counsel just to make sure that it falls in line
264with all statutory requirements. sure, we've been doing that as we go along? so I guess the idea would be that are you talking about prior school board members adding items that they be reviewed for legal sufficiency? yes. okay. just clarification is that a second motion compared to the one on the floor yet. Now. sorry, I thought we voted on the motion on the floor. I thought it was related. All those in favor of the motion say aye. aye. Those e opposesed sano. n no. do you want to? She is right in front of us. sorry, I had stepped out. she snuck back in. I believe it's just two noes, the yeas have it. that's it. I just have one motion. Real quick one, I think it's the three clean one, letter g, I'm sorry phage
265four of the clean line g, it says, it says regular and special meeting, I would like to make a motion to include and workshops. So regular, special and school board workshops meeting should have a maximum duration, so I'm not changing anything else except adding the workshop to the maximum duration of 8 hours. second. public comment? Board member comment? DR. Zeman. I have no interest of being here nine or ten hours to do these things. What I worry about though is the signal that we're sending, you know, workshops are not decision meeting, we don't vote officially, we don't pass anything, but we do have talk and we do listen. And it's a different kind of meeting, I've always appreciated the deadline which can be extended with a majority vote. But would I prefer for workshops to
266have a different length, just because we're suppose to become and talk it's our only opportunity to do that. I find a need for more workshop time and more discussion among the board members so that we can have good honest and sometimes fierce discussion among ourselves with what really matters. So I don't want to put an 8-hour limit within the workshop. In my own way of serving, I would have more time to spend with my colleagues than less but on decision-making meeting, I accept cognitive recommendations, that's I didn't always thought that was more appropriate for 8-hour meeting myself. thank you, my other board comment? Okay, MR. Sullivan. I just for MS. Batista perhaps, I just want to know how that would work because they cannot vote on a workshop so how would they vote to extend?
267I don't think if we have to word it consensus maybe? consensus, maybe. MS. Batista. yes, thank you. It would be via consensus which is the way you make the decisions at the meetings. I don't know if the motion needs that should be apart from the regular special and then maybe the next line a school board workshop is limited to 8 hours unless consensus reach to extend? that's fine, it's fine with me. yes, ma'am. MS. Rupert? I have a question. Can committee chairs give reports at either workshops or business meetings? not based on the way that the policy is written, just workshops. so currently right now. no right now, it's only at school board meetings, the change would bhof it to workshop. just to be clear. okay, we're still on this. All those in favor of
268the motion say aye. aye. all opposed say no zeman post. motion passes 8-11. I think we -- 8-1. I think we have exhausted. MS. Alhadeff. one last motion, you're going to love this one. Page 6 of 16, I did read the community input asking for school board members to limit their speaking time. So I move on b, to where it says for school board workshops, school board member have been obtain a board can speak no longer than eight minutes and everything else the same. Instead of ten minutes, eight minutes. it's page 6, number b. Sorry, letter b. correct and read my motion is to make it 8 minutes. second. public comment? board member comment? DR. Zeman. I'm curious about these limits in general. I don't know what the law is around limiting who were elected
269to office to share their representation with their people. So I'm curious general counsel, what is the law say about muzzling an elected official at the elected official's official meeting? MS. Batista. so let me answer a different question. There is nothing prohibiting you from making your speeches or debate, limiting that. There is nothing at that talks about limiting that, it's up to you if you would like to do it. yes, and we said we were going to follow robert rules of order, what does robert rules talks? robert's rules talks about ten minutes. and the second round? I believe another ten minutes. so instead of following robert's rule is 10 and 3, so we're already 10 and 3 and not 10 and 10. yes. thank you. MS. Leonardi. yeah, just to make a point about limiting the
270amount that board member speak, you know, when I first joined the board, there was seemingly unlimited amount of time that board members could speak and while I certainly welcome some limits, that have been put in place, I don't think that now is the right time to move forward with further limiting it. Yeah. thank you. Any other board member comments? Okay all those in favor of the motion say aye. aye. all those opposed say no. no. motion fails. I think it was? roll call. we'll roll call. roll call. School board members, leonardi? no. rupert? no. thompson. yes. zeman. Alhadeff. yes. bulman. yes. fam. no. hixon. no. Holness. no. fails, 3-6. okay, thank you. Now I think oh, I'm sorry board member thompson. sorry to circle back, can you reread the changes we made to DR. Zeman's
271to 5 and 14? I have it as changing shall to should on page 5, letter e. I would just like to make a motion to add that the items brought by board member be reviewed by legal council for legal consistency? okay, is there a second? I'll second it. public comment? MR. Sullivan. do you want all items for example, do you want to review travel? Is it every single b item? no. or is it only added items? added items? but we add those items? yeah, we do. bb items are added just added two weeks. all items except for travel items. that's politically not good. did anybody get that? All bb items except for travel items would be reviewed for legal sufficiency. Board member comment? MS. Leonardi? I suppose my question is that not already done in
272practice? MS. Batista so right now in granicus the way the system is set up when a board member submits a b item it goes for my review and approval, I can tell you that I don't approve or review, I submit because I don't believe it's my per view to make modifications or change a board member's item. point of clarification. I was still asking questions. So my other question is, then, if legal were to review, if legal reviews an item and the chair accepts it and legal says no this is not in order what is the resource there? MS. Batista? so the idea I guess would be that the item be reviewed before it gets placed on the agenda and before the chair says it's approved for good cause. So, the way I read or the
273way I understand the motion is that it's placing, you know, a collaboration between the board member who is bringing the item and general counsel to make sure that the item is being placed on the agenda conforms to the law. so let me ask you this, say I, submit an item you say, MS. Leonardi this is not legal, and I say well I want to submit it anyway? what happens? MS. Batista. well I suppose you can submit it and I will have to say which is no different than, it gives us an opportunity to discuss it and if you decide that you know, that's not what you want to do, because you don't want to submit an item that is not conformed with the law, then you have the choice not to put it on. got
274it. But in theory, if I wanted to be if I wanted break the laws it could go to the chair and the chair can put it on the agenda. sure. my other question is, do you -- . just for context purposes, and you know, to traditionally, the times that I've had board member cult with me regarding items that they're bringing to the board, what I try to do is just help with the language so that it does conform not try to con completely, nobody has ever brought an item that is to me other than sometimes I see them when everybody else sees them which is the majority of the time. okay. Two more questions, do you feel like they're, your office has the capacity to do this? In a timely manner? yes, if the item
275is given to me with enough time f.You're trying to put it the day before, maybe a little more difficult. got it. And with the travel piece, would there be a scenario in which, a board member might submit an item for travel that could potentially pose legal issues? Or questions? that's a good question. So normally, if you know, the items that are placed on the agenda for travel, are really for approval by the rest of the board members or not even really for approval but you're just putting it on the agenda but it's mandated for statute if you're going to be traveling outside the 50 mile radius. So I would, I would have difficult time figuring that there is something that is outside the law. so let me give you this scenario what if I submitted
276a item and I wanted to say at a hotel room that was $20,000 a night. Would that not be mismanagement of the taxpayer funds. Would there be any legal issues? [Laughter] My question is maybe we do need to include the travel items as something that you review. Not that I plan on taking a luxurious vacation on taxpayer money. There have been issues in other agencies regarding travel. So I'm wondering if we need to include that in the motion? MS. Thompson. I'm fine amending it to be all bb items and just some of my rational we have a very political ecosystem right now and it will be smart to have all board members to have legal counsel when putting something on the item. MS. Leonardi did you have a question? no, I'm good. MS. Fam, do
277you still have a point of order. yes, this is directed to general counsel. There is another rule that says $500 or over that it has to come before the board for approval. Do we have to alter that? that's a state statute. okay, I feel like we're here we're digging a whole we don't need to dig. If we're required by statute, then we got approved, thank you. board member bulman. thank you, chair. So how much time this is for MS. Batista, how much time do we need to give the general counsel's office sufficient time to review? So we're not placing an undue burden on the office? so I mean, based upon the law is now, that you're suppose to have the items on the agenda seven days in advance. I would say, you know, if you,
278if you contact my office seven days before that, that would be reasonable. If it was just one person, you know the problem is when they're, when there is nine of you and everybody comes at the same time wanting to have an item reviewed. can I, the alternative to having this particular motion pass would be on case by case that you come to the general counsel to ask before you put something on the agenda? I'm just trying to think like, you know, procedure alley if we're guming up, if we're going to be avoiding problems or creating potentially creating more problem. maybe creating more problems for me but correcting problems for you because you don't have to face the public if you have something that does not really pass legal mustard. so I don't know how to
279do this can we add the seven-day submission? do we have to put that in policy? how does that go? it would be great to have protection. okay, so great. an amendment? just an amendment. So I would like to make an amendment to add however it sounds nice that the board members need to submit their proposed bb items to counsel seven days before the submission. second. okay, any public comment on the amendment? Board member comment? MS. Alhadeff? thank you for making the motion but I think that it just restricts us as board members and if something comes up very quickly, then, we don't want to tie our hands because of the policy of the seven days. thank you, any other board member comment. MR. Zeman. I agree with MS. Alhadeff but I want to be aware
280of something when we write an item and submit it under this motion, the counsel opinion is going to be about the school's board approach. You will not have a direct personal lawyer helping you write an item. So this will be her representing the school board as she is only empowered to do giving us advise on whether this is legal. Just to make this really really clear, if an item was submitted that we want the superintendent to appoint bill smith to be a teacher at pine grove's middle school, that would be illegal. That's the operational side of things and even though we're the school board we cannot direct him to do things like that. I think, I think this would be fine, in the policy. What our authorities are but I understand why this MAY fit
281in just to make it very very clear. okay, any other board comment, all those in favor of the motion, say aye. I think they were. hers first and then yours gets vote on. all those in fafavor of e amenend d tion whwhich was s toto include seven days say aye. aye. all those opposed say no. no. do you need a roll call? Roll call. I think it failed but, school board members, rupert? no. thompson. no. zeman. no. alhadeff. no. bulman. yes. fam. no. thompson. no. fails 4-5. now vote on the actual motion which is to send all bb items. sorry, can I make all john reminded that the b items are also board items, so just all board items. So b and bb. okay. B and bb items go through legal counsel before they're put
282on the agenda all those in favor say aye. aye. any opposed say no. no. roll call. school board members thompson. yes. zeman. no. alhadeff. no. bulman. yes. no. hixon. who? Oh, sorry. No. Yes, yes, yeah. Sorry. Yes. I can put you down for a yes. thank you. holness. yes. leonardi. yes. 5-4. Rupert, I have to call rupert. no. still 5-4. I was confused with the yes and no but it passed 5-4. okay, great. Now we have to vote on the whole item as amended. So did somebody write down all the amendments as we went along. we have them. okay, so all those in favor of item, I'm sorry? Oh, yeah. All those in favor of item pp1 as amended say aye. aye. N.Any opposed say no. no. roll call again. got to get another sheet.
283School board members, zeman. yes. alhadeff. bulman. yes. fam. no. hixon. yes. holness. yes. leonardi. yes. rupert. no. thompson. yes. 7-2 passes. thank you so much. And I apologize to the public speaker for the delay but it is now time for public speaking. So if our public speaker can come. we only have one that is here from the wait list, nicole morris. thank you. Speaker: hello nicole morris choral springs I have the concerns about the broward estates transition process. I'm concerned that a vague email went out with one date with there is two. i'm concerned that when less than two families showed up to the advertised event and two showed up the next night and that was before they showed up the night before. The parents were not aware of the meeting. I'm concerned that this
284district's idea of individualized attention is sending form home with no explanation. A parent sent me a picture of a school choice form explaining why she got it or what was being offered them. I'm concerned that it was not mentioned at the JANUARY 22 meeting where this board voted to close the florida estates. We were told on JANUARY 9th a long-range planning meeting. Only that it would be moved to the top of the priority list. I'm concerned that the useable building capacity of broward estates is being used against them after the district has neglected their facilities for decades. If you consider their useable capacity and enrollment they would be at 102 capacity. I'm concerned about head start being defunded with cuts coming from the department of education. I'm concerned that board members stated that they did
285be want to table the closure until all the unknowns were settled because staff worked really hard. This is their job. We elect you to represent we the people and advocate for our benefit not to make staff's workload any easier. I'm concerned that the staff seemed to be concerned with participation as being treated as a thorn to the staff's side rather than a partner. There were no information on the forms that went home. Parents don't understand that they will have trans poerltation to plantation. The plantation elementary principal was not at either at the community meetings. I'm discouraged as a an advisory member I'm discouraged as a parent and as a discouraged as a taxpayer. And sitting here all day and listening to how the conversation where some board members were concerned about what was going to
286happen with them and not the public speaking, I'm even further discouraged. I hope you did right, you didn't do right by the choral springs community. Parents still come to the meeting and talk about how they were fraeted during the boundary process. Thank you. thank you, we'll continue on with the agenda so the next item on the floor is hh1 can I have a motion and a second to bring hh1. second. it's been moved by MS. Thompson seconded by MS. Rupert. Any public comment on hh1? DR. Holness? thank you, MADAM Chair, just a couple of questions. For the last bulleted item, under the family counselor should carry out the responsibilities listed below on page one it says perform other duties as assigned by supervisor or des ignee, who determines extenuating circumstances? DR. Hepburn. that would be
287the school leadership or district leadership. is there a guideline provided to district leadership or leadership. This is specific to when we have an emergency such as the school being on lock down or evacuatation so folks don't hide behind the duties described in their job description. okay, so DR. Hepburn, I don't know if you recall part of the concern that we had when we brought up mental health professionals and counselors in the past, was that these individuals were taken away from their normal scope of responsibilities to do stuff like run the cafeteria and other areas that are not part of their job responsibilities and then we had to concern as to whether or not we were meeting the mental health of students because of how they're being used. So when we use the term extenuating circumstances
288we know what that means. But I don't want us to pass this and then we have a situation where it's left up to the school leadership to what circumstances are and then have the latitude to end up with the same results that we were trying to avoid in the first place so. Is there, can the description or can -- . so let me add the stuff that you just described that has been communicated to our school leadership, bus duty, lunch duty, they can only do that if the individual volunteers to do that. And we've asked that to add with security and things like that. If they volunteer to do so. So we've already sent that message many times during the school year just to ensure that our principals and leadership teams are not having, not
289students but staff that should be supporting mental health. understand. So without having it in the job description, can there be a memo or guide provided to school leadership as to what constitutes extenuating circumstances so it's not misunderstood to mean other things. absolutely. thank you, sir. I appreciate it. okay. Anybody else? Okay. All those in favor of hh1 say aye. any opposed say no. Motion carries. Okay. I'm going to hop to bb10 because MS. Alhadeff is not here and she pulled the other two items. Motion and second. moved by MR. Zeman and seconded by leonardi. Any comment? yes, DR. Trudy. And she's in the other room. you're up. my name is trudy, the only way to transform the way that students use textbooks online is to make sure that every student has a tablet. On average
290students carrying more than 50 percent of their body weight in their backpack which can results in fatigue and injuries, nearly 8,000 had to be treated for backpack related injuries. In 2017, increased use of tablets instead of print textbooks could help make students backpacks lighter. Tablets can also hold stud ept work and quiz sxz other work. It can reduce the amount instruction that is technology base can reduce the amount of time that it takes students to reach new learning objectives by as much as 80 percent. They also tend to read more books when provided electronically. A textbook publisher, provided algebra textbook to test how students scored after learning with their digital textbook versus students after learning with traditional print text bao ts books. The results showed that students used 78 scored proficient or advanced or california
291state test while just 59 percent of the students who use only use the traditional textbook scored pro proficient. And also the average textbook cost $70 a digital textbook is 45 to 55 for six years. With tablets, students would have access to education programs, school board apps as well as the ability to type up and submit their assignments preparing them for the future. They would use unique ways, there by creating instead of focusing on test scores. As we did in the past you have the opportunity to step up in the right direction. Let's partner with the broward ed foundation, if you have a fund where businesses can donate money perhaps this access can begin next school year. Other districts in the country have moved in this direction. So let's not leave any student behind. I applaud
292DR. Holness for bringing this equity issue. Thank you. thank you. Board member comments? MS. Bulman? do you want to let DR. Holness go first since it's his item? I'm sorry. Thank you board member bulman and chair hixon. I will have to call on the rest of the items thank you for allowing me to speak first. I submitted this item based on a workshop and I felt it's really important that every single student in broward county schools has access to a computer and to the internet. I know that there is a possibility that there could be a small cost to the district as well as maybe not. So the item is still to ask the superintendent to exhaust and explore all options available to provide computer and internet access to all students. Fort superintendent to bring
293that to us. When we have our students and teachers and schools that are providing grading and learning outcome for students, based upon doing assignments at home on the internet and aout liesing the internet on the computer. It would be imperative for us to provide that option to all of our students. That's really the purpose of the items. I also commend board member hixon, chair hixon rather for the request she made that she received the follow-up on the data. What I look at the data, in terms of students with no access to a internet based not survey, it looks like 3084 students in the district and they were from the responses and 84,295 bho responded. Just out of curiosity, I'm looking at the data and I'm trying to see why the numbers did not add up.
294It shows 4.9 percent, is it 3084 taken as the percentage of total response? Or how did we get to 4.9 percent under board member hixon's inquiry? DR. Hepburn. that would be out of the total responses. okay, so unlessing my xu computation, I got 3.66 percent. I'm wondering why the data did not add up? The question I question this is because we're looking at some cost factors as it relates to the number of students from this response to estimate cost to the district. So just wanted to know if that percentage which is approximately 5 percent is accurate based on the survey response and the percentage of students that they indicated they didn't have access to the internet. DR. Hepburn. yes, I'm checking the numbers myself too. Maybe decimal point off at one of the response categories.
295okay, no problem. So I am asking the board to support this item. I think it's essential especially for those kids who are poverty situation and they don't have access to computers. I cannot imagine any student not having access to the internet and not having access and then being accountable. There are some students that can't afford even a $10 internet a month access. Should this item pass that you provide internet access to all students and if there are any remaining students and I'm sure that this percentage that we have here, which is approximately 4 percent, I'm sure it's going to be lower than that as far as cost factors to the district. So I do hope that the board members will support this in the interest of our students. Thank you. thank you, board member bulman.
296thank you for bringing this, DR. Holness and chair for the question that you had submitted earlier. I think it's very important that make sure that every one has access. I would like to computer and internet at home because I don't, I think, a vas majority of the students have that benefit and so I don't know what it would look like if you're not doing it at home if you're doing homework and to start at the very least, I would say the sixth graders on because I know that's when you start using the online platform to do things if we have that as a starting point and to DR. Jermanvich's point, I would like to ex mroes the use of tablets and cost. She made a point at the last workshop and I think it's true,
297it's easier to read on a tablet than a book on a computer. DR. Hepburn. just supervised feedback on tablet, they look great, they look fine. If you talk to students that use tablet, they will tell you, they're not the best thing to do homework and do projects at home. I talked to a few students, if you go down to our students at the boys and girls club, and some go to parkway and some of the surrounding areas, I ask what do you prefer computer or tablet. And some of the things that we use are not mobile friendly, because technically the tablet is a mobile device. And my experience as a father, with kids that have been one to one since elementary school, the elementary school kids function very well on the laptops or crone chrome
298books is what they gave younger kids. For the benefit of the kids, the laptop is the best way to go we can ensure that everything shows up on that device versus the something being mobile friendly, not all of our ed tech software MAY be mobile friendly, maub some manipulation needs to happen. thank you, I would like to get our student voice on this. So landyn,, you haveve any insisideonon what ststudents MAY prefer? good afternoon, through the chair, landyn student advisor to the school board. We have seen that a lot of schools I can say my personal experience as well as visits to other schools, a lot of device that's are provided are able to be -- I'm sorry, MR. Davis, I'm going to use the wrong technological language, convertible to be flipped into a flip
299device. That's what eve sign that can be used changed vertically, I know I've done that personally, that's one part. Absolutely agree with DR. Holness's point that students that are not able to have access to this at home are not going to be able to keep up with their classmates. I think it's definitely priority that the district should have. But I do want to say that the devices that are currently distributed many are able to be converted into a tablet form. thank you so much. MS. Alhadeff. thank you. So I appreciate the back up with the financials, my question is in regards to what the superintendent is proposing for this, I would like to have a better understanding of that. DR. Hepburn. thank you for the question, so we're on our journey to be one to
300one, we had to change our strategy because we're under a bit of a protest on our current rfp which is causing delays, but our inventory, we have more computers than student and enough to replace broken. Despite the protest and acquiring the new devices MAY take loaninger than we wish. But we're already on that journey to make sure that we're one to one device. That is a priority for us especially a priority to me, we know how valuable that is beyond our classroom walls. okay, so starting next school year, every student will be issued their own computer for the year with a charger. correct. and how does it work with having a hotspot? so what we're going to do, we're going to exhaust every partner, every relationship to ensure that we can find, that we can
301match families in need with the right partners to get either low cost or free internet or wi-fi. And we will bring back to the board if that, doesn't work for all students we'll bring back that number of students those solutions didn't work for to the board so we can talk about next steps. That would mean us exhausting some funds and we need to get permission from the board to do so. so would there be an application process? we will work with some of the partners, most of the partners will have an application process. no I mean for the students? would they have to apply? so just like we did with this survey, we will identify in a similar way per school. So we'll come up with a survey, encourage as many people as possible to
302fill it out, especially those in need and match them up so that will be when we match them up, that will be a partner situation where they have to define their financial need to their partner so they can get discounted right. that's wonderful. I think this is a great idea. I think it's so important to make sure that all of our students have the tools that they need to succeed, thank you. thank you, board member thompson? hello. Thank you, chair. So I had a couple of questions to staff. So I wanted to know if we can expand, so the survey they're talking about is when you first start school, there is that little check box that says you have internet at home just in case anybody needs that clarification. But I wanted to do a
303break down and school age and how many students have checked that box? DR. Hepburn? is for this specific survey, you wonder how many students check the box? yes, I think MR. Davis and I have talked about it. MR. Daifls, if you want to provide a follow-up? good afternoon, board, so I have a break down that was in response to MS. Hixon. Out of the 84,295 responses it's broken up by elementary middle high school k through 8, 6 through 12 center and adult. Elementary out of the 84295, we had 38208 responses. Middle school, 18, 864 responses, high school 23227. Combo schools 2059 and you are correct that was a start of the school survey and it is done in focus. and I also want to talk a little bit more. As a social woker, there are
304federal programs where we can connect our students to internet access. So I'm concerned about putting that financial burden on the district and just want to emphasize that there are these resources out there that we don't have to take on that financial burden but we can be a conduit to our families and maybe it needs fob more of something. When they start school they reach out and see if they qualify for the services and that's the way we connect them more than us looking at providing these tools to students that way. How much would it be to provide every student with a hotspot if they need it. yeah, I know. That would be 629,000 per year based on the current survey. And mind you the survey sample looks like it's about a third of our students.
305if I could. go ahead. so if we look at the one-year term because you typically have two options like a ten-month and a twelve-month, we recommend the twelve-month or one year option because excuse me, twelve-month option because you might have summer programs or, you know, enrichment options during the summer and plus honestly it's more expensive than the ten-month option. 20,000 students, that just representing 10 percent so you're talking about 4.80 million dollars in a year and that's for one-year commitment and only 10 percent. Yeah, it's costly. And I also want to emphasize at least my understanding is we can't put financial requirements on the services that we provide so anyone that would have access to this free internet, even if they would not qualify under most federally provided programs, is that true? DR. Hepburn. I
306don't have that follow-up information. Unless MS. Batista is aware of that? as a general rule, that is correct. all right. So again, I want to emphasize there is already these programs out there for our community to take a part of. There is also cities looking into initiative to create hotspots throughout their municipalities and I think our purpose to the school districts should be connecting these families to connect to help bridge these gaps. That's it, thank you. thank you, DR. Zeman? chair, thank you. I know it's getting late in the day but it is probably one of the most exciting items we've had in a long time. I think about this and like a lot of things in terms of what our competitive advantage be with other people's choices for school and I think the item
307could be amended to swayed the concerns that my colleague have. But I also want to extend internet and laptop to 1100 percent availability. This is available in palm beach county, they have figured out ho to partner with conmigo, there are some technology that is showing that ai tutor is more efficient and affective than human beings and available 24-7, 365. Conmigo is an exciting one. That will cost a little bit more money. The reason we need to do that, and I'm going to promose a motion is we have to continue to have a competitive advantage when people have choice of schools to go to. And if you go to a traditional public cool and to MS. Thompson's point, public school is for everything but we're not giving it to everybody. At the end of the day,
308our special purpose is to make sure that everybody in broward county shows up at our door can get an education. I don't think a computer and internet is the end all. I think tutor in combination with that stuff is. What I would like to propose is a motion that changes the action from ensure that students have computer by AUGUST 12th because I think it's dangerous, because we don't know what the cost to that we have to bring that as a item. But to direct the superintendent to present in MARCH, the most efficient and affective plan with the resources required so all broward county school students have a computer, and internet access and access by AUGUST 12, 2025. is there a second? Okay, seeing no second, we'll move on. Did you have anything else? nope. thank
309you. Next is me. And I have a motion and they're going to bring a little paper around. So I love the idea but I have a concern similar to board member thompson's and mine not so much the money but it is holding the superintendent accountable to make sure that there is internet access for our students at home. And I'll just equate it this way, he can ensure that our students have computerrs and internet access at school. We can make sure that they have a computer but the internet access to me making sure that they have lunch, breakfast lunch and then dinner at home. It's just, I don't think that that's our place to be doing that. We want to partner so my motion is to kind of change the item a little bit. So it
310reads, the direct the superintendent to ensure all broward public schools students have computer access at both home and school as well as internet access by AUGUST 11, 2025 additionally direct the superintendent to collaborate with partners to seek internet access for all students at home through various grants and internet access programs. I think it should take the ownous off the superintendent to have the accountability for them to have access at home. If we make this motion and it we direct the superintendent it can affect him and his valuation to get all internet at home. It's been moved and seconded any public comment? Board member comment? DR. Zeman. MADAM Chair. I just prefer the aspiration of DR. Holness original motion. And I think, we're trying to distinguish broward county schools from other options that people have. I
311think, I think I would prefer to have the superintendent continue to bring back ways in which we can do this. And I just morally, believe that for students to have a chance to learn, they have to have internet access at home and if they cannot afford it and it's not available through other programs, I like us to provide it. DR. Holness. MADAM Chair, can you repeat your motion and I have a couple of comments. the motion says direct the superintendent to ensure that all broward public school students have computer access at both school and home as well as internet access at school. Additionally direct the superintendent to collaborate with partners to seek internet access for all students at home through rarous grants and internet access programs. okay, so MADAM Chair, could you explain the difference
312between your motion and the motion I had on the floor prior? so, thank you for asking. It, I did it this way because the your motion reads it holds the superintendent accountable for provide access to students at home. And I don't think that that is it should be the board should be holding accountable for something we can't really have control over and I made the relationship to we can make sure students are bed breakfast and lunch but we cannot guarantee that they're going to have dinner, although we would love to just like the internet access, we absolutely want them to have it, we'll partner and help just like we do have access to food but to hold him accountable for the way that your original motion reads, I think is just not healthy because that
313we could ding him on his evaluation for that and I want to take that off the table. okay, so MADAM Chair, I appreciate your feedback. But I believe that if you can't exactly comparison to lunches because, internet access is tied to student learning outcome. Lunches are not. And when we're asking students to be accountable for their homework and they don't have the means to afford the medium through which to do so, I think that impacts their learning outcome and that's the real concern. I appreciate your motion but I guess the question that I would have is, trying to understand the difference will your motion ensure that students have access all of them to internet and computers by AUGUST 11th or will it not guarantee that? my motion would guarantee that they have internet access and
314computers in school and computers at home if needed, just not tying it to something that we don't have the ability to control which is internet, access at home. It does direct the superintendent to work with partners as was laid out in the response that he sent to us all the different federal grants and different things where they we can help them 1100 percent you know get the internet, we can help them to reach out to resources to provide that to them but I just want to hold the superintendent accountable for internet access at home. okay, so MADAM Chair, would it, I don't know if this would be an amendment, but would it be I guess, part of what I'm trying to achieve is the superintendent bring back to us, before the start of the next
315school year, a plan where he exhausted all options and also present to us, if he believes there will be any additional cost to the district based upon, his actions? Of the determining which partners will provide access internet access to our students who can't afford it and what the cost of the district will look like? i'm not sure how that amendment would work? But what I'm trying to achieve is the superintendent exhaust all access to partners and if we have any students that is left behind that there is a cost that is brought to us to look at to determine if we would like to move ahead. But I think that it's imperative that every sud students if we're going to hold their outcome attached to homework, dependent to internet access, it's within our responsibility to
316have some measure of providing that to them. all right, DR. Hepburn? yes, so the information as stated before, that's our intentions in going out leveraging every partner, every avenue to get discounted or free internet service for families in need and being the conduit to get them to those partners so they can get the partners and we will bring back to the board the number of students and the cost for those students so the board can make a decision if they're going to financially support that need. We will not make the decision. We'll bring that information to the board. okay, MADAM Chair, I have one more xoment. I don't believe this direction to the superintendent is tying his evaluation to it. I think the focus is really getting students getting what they need to be successful
317for those that can't afford it. I don't know how this is tied to the superintendent's evaluation. this is asking him to explore all options for internet access and to bring back to us if he believes there will be a cost at some future board meeting. okay, thank you. Board member bulman. thank you, chair. So, when I look at this, if if the over arching way that we're providing education is through an online platform and you have to have a computer to do your homework, then you'rere essentialllly s en fncncsing some ofhe studts I if they don't have access at home unless we have a computer lab that is staffed until, you know, 10:00 o'clock at night, I don't know what the cost of that. I would think having home access would be more affordable but
318I don't like the idea and it's simply not fair that some students have the lux' luxury of doing their homework later at night and others can't because of their family or financial situation. Obviously, DR. Hepburn can't absolutely ensure that every kid has internet access, because you can give somebody a hot box and they don't take it out of the box. I think we need to reword it to direct DR. Hepburn to offer the opportunity for every student to have home internet access for students that q.He's not there plugging in the internet service at every single house. But we have to off ther students that qualify the opportunity. Thank you. just remember we're still speaking on the motion. i'm not saying you weren't, board member thompson. thank you, MADAM Chair. MS. Fam, you're after. oh I'm
319sorry. I was going to agree with my colleague here and back up what she said, that it is not a burden that should fall on the superintendent. He can provide as much opportunity but you can't lead a horse to water and make him drink. I just wanted to live out of davie and we're uncopeder broward and we get lightning strikes just in the last month, we lost our internet for more than a week. We get flooding really bad, where my husband and I have had our cars totaled where we got water locked where firefighters were bringing us water. There is a lot of scenarios, there is not a lot of scenario that's not talking about hurricanes. What I would suggest is that we shorten the motion and just direct the superintendent again to collaborate with
320partners and try to seek to make internet access available for students at homes through grants and internet assets programs as opposed to making a mandate for him. In addition, if need be, I know we have situations where cuds can get to the libraries but maybe you can convert some buses and make them into lab where you can park them in a certain area with youer know there is a network of children that don't have internet access, where they can pile on to the bus and make them into little computer work stations for them and that way you're going to the need as opposed to putting the ownous on parent. Like I said we couldn't even get out of our street for days at a time. So I just think that we need to look at
321the bigger picture and it's providing opportunities as opposed to getting internet in each house. I think that's unrealistic and of an unexpectation for our superintendent. thank you, board member thompson. I was going to speak to the motion. I really like chair hixon's rewriting of this. I also think it will be difficult for the superintendent to bring back the financial impact before the start of school because we need that survey, we need time to connect those families with to see if they qualify for other programs and after that, that's when he's going to know the true cost of providing internet to them. So I just think, this allows our superintendent to really have full control over the options and bring back something that is fully prepared. thank you. And I just want to point out you
322know, the ging part of it, we -- beginning part of it, we can hold the superintendent accountable. We can hold him accountable by AUGUST 11th, that's why that is in there. But the internet part at home, we don't know that we can do that by AUGUST 11th how how that will look like that's why I pulled that piece out. In the motion, is still saying, we want him to make sure that all students have computer access both school and home because we can allow him to take the computer home and make sure that there is internet access at school. So those are the things that superintendent can do by AUGUST 11th, I don't know that AUGUST 11th or that every student has the internet access at home is something that we can direct the superintendent
323to do specifically but we can ask him to collaborate with partners so was the intent. I didn't see your chair. would I like to make an amendment to your motion. hold on a second, DR. Holness. thank you, I like the motion but I also would like my colleague to possibly bring back an item in the future about tutoring. Thank you. thank you. Okay, DR. Holness. yes, I do understand your motion MADAM Chair, as far as ensuring the superintendent provide access at home. I would like to amend your motion to at least in addition to everything that you have to direct the superintendent to explore and exhaust all options including partnership for internet access at home. So this is just direct him to explore the option sxz bring that information back to us in addition to
324everything else you have in your motion. okay, so do you want to change the word explore to something? I want today change collaborate to explore? for the internet access at home part of it. right, that second sentence. yes. so instead of collaborate, so additionally direct the superintendent to explore all options? all options to provide internet access at home including partnerships, and costs possible costs to district. explore all options. we're not asking him to take action in terms of holding him act, we're simply asking him to bring information back. Okay, so if we change we're directing the superintendent to explore all option sxz bring back costs for internet access for all students at home through various grants and internet access programs? I don't think that's exactly? Sure. was to explore all options including partnerships and possibly
325costs to district because we don't know, we're not saying that the district is going to pay for anything, we're just asking superintendent to explore all access to provide internet access to home but today we're not voting on any cost to district we're just asking him to bring back all available options in addition to cost possibly cost the district. ?Fm okay. So additionally direct the superintendent to explore all options including partnerships and possible costs to seek internet access for all students at home? Is that? Does that sound right? yes. Yes, that's my amendment. okay. And it includes everything else you have in your motion. okay. Any board member comment? Oh. Well I don't think, it was amending the -- . amendments need skds too. okay, I'll second. one word I wanted. So DR. Holnesses amendment to
326the motion was to additionally direct the superintendent to explore all options including partnerships and possible costs to seek for internet access for all students at home. Is there a second? second. board member comment? Any comment. sorry DR. Zeman for stepping out of turn. I'm wondering if that is overly broad if we want to qualify for all students? I don't know what we're trying to accomplish mere, like every? where would you put the word qualify. so seek internet access to all qualified. I don't know if I would say, qualified. Maybe all. MADAM Chair. I recommend we table this item and go to the public hearing and come back to this. okay, sorry. Okay. i'm going to recess the regular school board meeting because we have 5:30 public comment and we'll come back to this item.