CorpusRecord 177051

OCPS | 2025-01-14 School Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / OCPS Boardmeetings
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Orange County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,200 words · about 63 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001it is 25 this meeting is called to order um I believe we have we have all of our school board members in attend no Vicki she she's coming okay so I'll let the who's taking notes by the way thank you make a note of who is not here and uh add them to the minutes when they arrive okay thank you so I just wanted to take a minute and I'm going to call on the chair of the AUD audit advisory committee to make a few comments but I really appreciate this opportunity it's the first time that since I've been here maybe the first time ever that we've had this opportunity to convene together and I'm not sure we why we haven't done it sooner but I I would think it would be a good idea

002for us to do this if not once a year at least every other year um so I took a minute to thank the members that are here and I know the board feels the same way the value that they bring to Orange County Public Schools is um beyond words and so but I also after um we hear from Miss Campbell I was going to talk about how I see us operating through this meetings and this Camp thank you for having the audit committee here and involving Us in this decision and this process and forward to providing whatever feedback we can from our various fin fincial backgrounds and our work with the current School Board internal auditor and provide insight and help you through the process as well okay um we're going to rely on Miss

003Lindsay to run the meeting she's going to go through the presentation um she did share with me uh we've each of us has seen the presentation individually if you have a question and you know it's going to be answered in upcoming slides obviously hold it but if you do have something that comes to mind on a on a particular Slide by all means um we'll stop there pause there and address that she is going to call on each of us um when we get to the point where we're having discussion and so what I suggested was we I'm sure you all have been to meetings where you use this rather than keeping your hand up forever and feeling like you're back in grade school um some fond memories some not so fond memories for me

004on that account so everybody good with this when you want to be Rec ni okay and if you have it up for a long time and you're getting passed over you can always resort to rock ring up a piece of paper and throwing head L back to grade school sorry okay with that Miss ly you recognized thank you very much Madam chair of the board and Madam chair of the audit committee and various board members and committee members and staff thank you very much for uh having us here today uh the purpose of this afternoon's meeting is to talk about uh the process by which we want to accomplish the search and hiring of a new school board internal auditor but before we move forward with that discussion I'd like to introduce the members of

005the audit Committee just a little bit more uh than you have at this point um as chair Jacobs pointed out Tammy Campbell to her left uh is our uh chair of the audit advisory committee Tammy is a CPA and a partner at dermit Davis and Company CPAs she is the practice leader of that office and she specializes in state and local government auditing so that is uh definitely an asset to our work step Bowman you yeah thank you is uh a certified Information Systems auditor and he serves as the it audit manager with Darden Restaurants and is a new member of our committee but I will say that Darden being an excellent part partner with the district has provided a member to our audit committee almost since its very Inception the very first chair of

006the audit committee was the senior VP for audit with um Darden Restaurants his name was Jim ingersol so darden's been great in providing talent and expertise to this work uh missing from us today sadly uh she woke up this morning feeling well unwell is Lynn mole Lynn is a CPA and she is the chief audit executive and director of in of internal audit with the Institute of internal Auditors also with us today is Brian Paulson Brian is director Disney Cruise Line finance and planning with Walt Disney World Resorts and lastly but not least Santa Patel is a certified Information Systems auditor and he is the director for it internal audit and financial advisory services with Pro ity here in town additionally serving in a nonvoting ex official capacity our own School Board chair and our

007general counsel are part of the audit advisory committee so with those introductions we'll jump into our meeting objectives I apologize but I should have oversight but I should have recognized I know the superintendent but you want to offer a few words put you on the spot there didn't it's okay used to it I've had great practice speaking on spot so um yeah thank you uh Linda first and foremost I I want to say thank you for um uh your your service to our district um no you're not but I think yesterday you said that your husband keeps asking when U but uh really you provided such a valuable service to our district uh in this area um and and uh we are so appreciative of it you're you are very skilled um have a great

008attention to detail um and have always had the district's best interest at heart so we're we're so thankful um but we know that you you you deserve this next up phase of your life and so I'm excited that we are able to participate in this process getting a better understanding of you know the functions and then looking at the description in the timeline uh so that we can have the very best candidates um in the pool uh and do it in a manner that um doesn't have your husband Contin to ask when so so I didn't realize that had been an issue tell him November 2026 it's going to be a very thoughtful delibery all right then thank you yeah yes all right well I thought I thought that it would be a good idea

009to set out in a bit more detail the objectives of today's meeting just to help keep us on Focus because um as I've said to many of you in our briefings today's meeting I hope is going to build the track and establish the stopping points and who's going to get on and off of this train uh so that once the meeting concludes we can drive the train down the track that you've built and execute the procedures that need to be done so firstly we're going to just briefly review the audit and internal control Charters um the audit committee has done an annual review of that do those documents they did that in November and recommended some changes to you but we held those until um after today's meeting just in case something else came along

010this isn't really a meeting about revising Charters but I felt it appropriate just to wait until we had this discussion before they were brought to the board for its approval uh we're going to talk about the job description for this position and that will take a little bit more time and we're going to talk about the search and hiring process for a new school board internal auditor and so without Much Ado let's Jump Ahead our outline is going to uh consist of talking about things in four parts uh the first part is just for review for some of you that have been around but for the newer board members it might be somewhat newer but it's good I think to set the context and the table for the discussion so everybody starts from the same

011place so we're going to briefly review uh best practices of an effective internal audit governance and Reporting relationships that support it we're going to talk about the key parts of the charter I mentioned earlier that are pertinent to the to today's discussion uh we're going to talk about the internal Auditors position the job description the reporting uh lines and so forth and then we're going to hopefully decide upon a process by which we can go forth and start this effort so firstly let's talk about the internal audit governance and Reporting relationship this slide may be familiar to those of you who were on the board when we had a work session last August but for refresher professional internal auditing at ocps has been in place at least since before 25 years ago and when I

012say professional internal auditing relationship I'm mostly report referring to the reporting relationship certainly the internal audit department at ocps has been around probably for 75 or 100 years I don't know but sometime further back than 25 years ago the audit Department was taken out from under management and reported began reporting independently so that there was no question of its objectivity and oversight so um you will notice that the audit advisory committee was established by the school board in 2003 and that was deliberate in order to help with overseeing the internal function since it was no longer under management and then we also had I want to point out to you that our department follows the Professional Standards that are prated by The Institute of internal Auditors The Institute of internal Auditors is a global organization

013that provides Professional Standards and support and guidance to internal Auditors throughout the world and we follow those Professional Standards as do many many many internal audit shops and lastly as I tell most of you even the auditors get audited uh we do have external peer reviews of our department every 5 years in order to be able to site that we follow the Professional Standards and the last one of those was in 2021 so my successor will have to make sure that we keep that going with a an external peer review in the fall next year now just as a quick review the purpose of internal audit is of course to provide all of you folks as well as District stakeholders and taxpayers in the community with Assurance about the risk management and internal controls and

014uh other operations of the district uh this is part of being transparent and accountable to our constituents and although we are independent of management I want to assure you as I think you all know we are all in on supporting the district's strategic plan and objectives uh that's the beauty of being an internal auditor we do work for ocps for the board but uh we want to make sure the work we do is absolutely in support of the district's mission statement goals and objectives and is signed to help management manage risks that would interfere with the achievement of those objectives our work in auditing governance risk management and control processes is focused on the risks that might jeopardize achievement of those objectives and the work of our excuse me the results of our work do

015support the board and management in decision making and in protecting the district's reputation and the assurance that its many stakeholders expect and we operate pursuant to a mandate uh that in our case is uh put forth in two documents one being the school approved audit Charter which we'll talk in depth about later and the other being Florida Statutes I would also um believe that best practices are are a mandate for us any organization worth it salt is going to have a robust internal audit function to help provide that Assurance that's necessary for stakeholders and constituents um according to the statutes we have the same Authority and access to records documents personnel and so forth as the state auditor general does Now The Institute of internal Auditors has put forth these essential conditions on this slide

016that they have stated are essential for an infective internal Control Function um certainly I think it's pretty obvious that it would be necessary for Effectiveness but I wanted to put this slide in for two reasons one is to stand in front of you and say that in my opinion all of these essential conditions are present here at ocps which is a very positive thing but secondly I want us to be able to uh emphasize and promote this when we post the position because candidates of quality will also want to know that indeed all of these essential conditions are present uh they're going to want to know that is Senior Management and School Board support of the audit function they're going to want to know that there is an independent reporting relationship and so forth and

017so on so this is an important factor that we want to make note of now briefly how is Independence achieved also from The Institute uh accountability to either the board and or an independent audit committee is the key to Independence um uh having access to all areas is critical having the necessary and appropriate resources having effective audit and board oversight and having administrative reporting to a senior executive level is okay in other words Independence is not object uh is not impaired if for administrative matters the audit function has some type of management oversight as long as the function the function of internal auditing is answerable to the board and for the audit committee so at Orange County Public Schools the school board did establish the audit committee as I mentioned earlier in 2003 as a

018committee of independent qualified individuals who will oversee the internal audit function on its behalf knowing they possess the knowledge and expertise that's necessary for this this is a working group of experts who actively perform their respons dis abilities and on the next two slides we're going to review some of the actual work that they do for and be on behalf of the school board up to this point in time the administrative types of things such as if I want to go to a conference for example have been handled through the chief excuse me through the general counsel so this is the first of the two slides I said that describe the audit committee's responsibilities uh you can see there's there's some real roll up your shirt sleeves and get the work type done here uh

019they do review the plans activities Staffing and structure of our department uh they review and approve our risk assessment and our audit plans they monitor our performance against the plan throughout the year they do monitor manages Management's responses to open audit findings they help to ensure there are no restrictions on internal audit and they do review the effectiveness of both internal and external audit functions meeting with external Auditors twice a year once before the audit work is significantly entered into and once at the end of the audit process additionally uh they assess and evaluate their own performance once a year every November they use an evaluation instrument and talk about how effective are they as an audit Committee in performing their duties and resp responsibilities to the school board and whether there are opportunities for

020improvement they do review the charters I mentioned earlier and we'll talk a bit about those in the next section of our presentation uh they meet annually with the Chief Information officer to talk about it issues and they of course conduct annual performance appraisal of the auditor and annually they come before you usually it has been in January to formally in a in a structured environment report to you on their work and some of the other necessary things that are going along with following Professional Standards now previously that report was in January uh at their November meeting the committee discussed the timing of this knowing we had just had a work session in August and we had this one which is not really technically about the business of the audit committee but it's a a a

021focus and because our plan runs on a fiscal year basis from July 1 to June 30 so in their November meeting the committee recommended that they change that annual report to the board from a January date to a July date and that is our plan we will request time with you in July to make the annual report from the audit committee to the board and just for those of you who like to see it in a graphic way this is how the reporting relationship works this is how it's been working ever since the audit committee came into existence uh the auditor reports to the school board through the audit advisory committee so it's uh this is exactly what's going on now all right so moving along to the charters now as I noted earlier as

022part of its responsibilities did I do something oh I'm sorry no you didn't do anything I don't think it's change something I think they is it okay I apologize um as part of its responsibilities and in accordance with the Professional Standards the audit committee reviews the charters of its committee and of our internal audit Department annually to determine whether revisions are needed often there aren't revisions needed but the desire is to build in a discipline so that in their annual program of work they do look at those Charters instead of just putting them on a shelf to get Dusty and when revisions are necessary they evaluate those and recommend them to the board for approval this year well last year now uh there were new standards put out by The Institute of internal Auditors that

023was the sum and substance of what we talked about in that August work session and the new standards called for they didn't call for it but because the new standards were here we needed to make some changes in the charters to conform some language and some um Clarity around the charter Provisions so that we were clearly in Conformity with the new standards so that process concluded in November and you've been provided with red lines of the two charters that reflect those revisions so today we're not going to go through the recommended revisions of the charters per se but we're going to briefly review what is in each Charter and then focus on the part of each Charter that specifically deals with today's key business so first starting with the audit committee um the audit Charter

024for their for the committee has this content in it it talks about what the uh establishment was uh what term limits or the terms of the uh members are it does prohibit conflicts of interest by the audit committee members they they cannot they and their companies can't be uh doing anything with the district in the terms of business that would be a conflict it describes their roles and responsibilities and talks about their reporting relationship but what I want to emphasize to you today is this paragraph from the charter of the audit committee which deals deal specifically with why we are gathering and it talks about the that they are charged by the board through the charter to provide input and recommendations to the school board in the performance appointment replacement or dismissal of the Schoolboard

025internal auditor including participation by designated audit advisory committee members in any interview or selection process so what we're getting ready to do is consistent with the charter that you folus have U adopted the internal audit Department Charter like previously contains basic things you would expect to be in a charter the purpose of the department the scope of work that they are charged with performing The Professional Standards and practices that they must meet uh the Mandate and responsibility and so forth for purposes of today's discussion we want to focus on this last bullet Independence organizational structure and Reporting relationships because um that is something we want to make very clear before we post the position this is the language from the current and proposed there's no changes in this provision that is in the charter for

026the department and again this is the way it operates now and the way it's been operating since the existence of the audit committee began so the school board internal auditor reports to the school board of Orange County through its audit advisory committee the school board internal auditor reports administratively to the district General Council for routine administrative matters I mentioned that earlier the school board internal Auditors annual performance evaluation is prepared by the audit advisory committee and signed by both the chair of the committee and the district General Council so again this is what the charter reflects at the present time now when we get into the next section which is the job description we're going to find some inconsistent inconsistency currently and before we leave the meeting we want to have the charters and the

027practice and the job description all aligned so that they clearly and and consistently describe how this works the audit committee also I have to give credit in this next section has been terrific in providing really good insights into how this works in the private sector and suggestions from their experience and knowledge of audit positions and audit Executives at other organizations and it's been very valuable to me in preparing this presentation for you folks now firstly the key features of the current job description and they're on this slide and the next one uh the title is as you see it uh the educational requirement and the professional certifications um nothing really uh proposed to be changed there except possibly there's been some discussion about the title and we'll talk more about that in a moment we

028do believe the board might consider a different title when posting the position because the phrase School Board internal auditor doesn't really sound like the chief executive uh Chief audit executive of one of the largest school districts in the nation and when I show you some comparable data from other school districts you'll see uh what I'm talking about all right continuing with the current job description oops it didn't Advance uh the years and type of experience is listed here uh right now the job description says this position reports to the general counsil it end of sentence this this part right here oops I'm so sorry I can't highlight on the screen um the second part there is a recommendation and that is we do recommend that job description be changed to reflect the reporting relationship as

029it's working and as is stated in the charters before this is posted because a quality applicant is going to look at the job description probably first and if they see that it doesn't report to the board of the audit committee as is expected in consistent with Professional Standards they might be hesitant to apply and here's the salary range um and I I will note that it is in group two on the district's salary schedule and we would recommend that it be moved either to group one or the executive management salary schedule all right because I have worked with you people for so long I know that you always or at least often ask me well what do other districts do so I surveyed some of my colleagues at other school districts in the Council of

030great City Schools internal Auditors group I know on the screen this is probably too small but I think you all have a version that you can look at more closely um and these are um some a couple of Florida districts as well as several from around the country uh large urban districts and you can see how their uh titles uh their bachelor or their degrees and years of experience and professional certifications line up and um and this is also highlighting I think some of the differences in the way they title the chief auditor or the um lead audit position in their various districts I'm just presenting this to you as information at this point uh with the idea that you will digest it and decide what if any you want to do uh about Job

031titles and or other matters but I think we line up very Nic nicely terms of the degree the years of experience and the certifications required it looks like everybody's pretty consistent and and also as we advance into the process I'll add um I know all of these Auditors professionally through the council and they also sent me their job descriptions so if that becomes useful as we move forward I have those available work at HR or whatever all right now we've come to the heart of today's discussion uh we intend to post the position to the district's website of course uh and to the association of local governments uh Auditors job board and we'll post it with the Council of great City Schools internal Auditors Network it's not really an official job board but we have

032a a group chat and some group emails and we can share it that way as well as through the Institute of internal Auditors possibly one or two other locations as well will evaluate what audiences those places reach and what the cost of those uh additional postings might be in the posting We want to emphasize in addition to how wonderful it is to work at Orange County Public Schools and and how great our our department is uh we'll want to emphasize that we do have the correct reporting relationship in place uh we do have the essential conditions that the Institute of internal Auditors has identified for an effective audit function in place and we do follow the IIA standards people will want to know this when they're applying now this is a an a a draft

033of a process that we might follow moving forward in putting this together we contemplated two rounds of interview views uh an initial screening that would be conducted by staff just to weed out anyone who mistakenly applied it clearly didn't fit the requirements but a short list of applicants to be developed for interview from that by perhaps the audit advisory committee or some subset of that group uh with possible input from Senior Management if you remember when we met in August management can provide in put that's not going to infringe on uh Independence but it's not required uh and then interview questions and a round of interviews with possible recommendations of candidates for a second round and then conducting second round interviews and so forth what we need to decide today is this is just my

034preliminary thoughts but we we need to really talk through who's going to be involved in each of these steps so that we can proceed from this point forward to just Implement that plan keep in mind that both the audit advisory committee and the school board are Sunshine committees Sunshine boards uh any meetings will have to be posted and the more people we get involved the greater input but also the more difficult scheduling will be because the audit committee members are very very busy and they have day jobs and the school board members are very very busy and have many things going on so as you deliberate and and consider what the different choices are today let's try to find the right balance between getting everyone's involvement and input but not encumbering the process unnecessarily um

035I'm going to go to the next slide and then I'm going to come back to this one and ask for uh if I may uh Madam chairs uh ask for some discussion um but the next slide is a proposed very very tentative timeline that is built off of the process that was described in the previous slide so and it's aggressive okay it's an aggressive timeline but we we got to get something out there to start figuring out and as you're also deliberating who might be involved in what phases of this effort you will have some idea of the time frame when we might do the work so that if your your other commitments and your calendars are such that you have greater availability or lesser availability that can be factored in as we're evaluating who

036does what when um additionally we have a little bit of a constraint because in March there's only one school board meeting due to spring break so whatever we can't uh to the the extent it needs full board approval uh whatever we can't get completed by March 11th uh we'll need to defer at least to April 1st so um that's that's another consideration as well but this is this is really the meat and potatoes of today's meeting um we are respectfully requesting um discussion guidance direction from the the 13 of you um here or I guess Len could make it 12 of you here um as to how you see this moving forward and how excuse me how we are going to proceed so following your uh suggestion chair Jacobs I see uh Melissa Bird's tag

037is upright correct all right thank you um I when looking at your uh suggestions for the first round of um to cre get the short list the second section there um I agree that I think the initial screening um I'm fine with s with HR or in the internal auditor now doing that um no go back there you go on the next one though I feel like um I think the audit committee definitely I want to have their input or at least the subcommittee of the audit committee if if there's just maybe you know a small group of them that can meet to do that to look at the look at those and um create a short list um I don't really know that Senior Management at that point needs to be involved because I

038feel like we might want their input once you get narrowed down to like two or three candidates um but at this point I want to really know from the professionals I want to know from the Auditors I would also really like to have the internal Auditor's opinion I'd like to have your opinion about um the applicants that we get I want to I want to see like the first short list group of applicants to know that they are approved have the seal of approval from the people that know what they're looking for um as far as auditing goes that would be my opinion at least that way from there then I feel like you can get you know Senior Management involved you know if it's a matter of who they feel most comfortable working with

039um you know those kinds of things but at that point I really want to know that these applicants are qualified have the skills that we're looking for um in the background and all of that and I think the audit committee and the internal auditor are the best people to be able to do that that's my op and member foron um so I definitely agree I think that's a great um great input from numberb bird and I think um maybe even having that Senior Management be down more where we um when it's the fourth one down where it's conducting the first interviews that's where they would sit in on those or um they may even have some interview questions that things that they were wanting to know so maybe even number three where they've got uh

040some questions but I agree I think um you know really getting it narrowed down to these are any of these three four people that we have before us any of those would be amazing they've got the qualifications they've got everything that you need and now uh we get a little more nitty-gritty on some of the questions that we have to ask um and as far as like working with them and feeling connected in that sense uh so I agree I think um moving that down um and really kind of keeping it as like a smaller group um because I think the Auditors you all know more of what you're looking for and what it takes um than you know some of us who are not in the auditing World chair Jacobs thank you I I

041just have a followup to Vice chair I may have Mis heard you but I thought on number two you had said the audit advisory committee and a school board or a school board member but not Senior Management were you thanking school board at that level or School Board representative I I did not include a school board representative I I I said the school board auditor I meant the internal auditor okay I just I wanted to make sure if that's what you meant that we considered that I I heard what you said that it was the audit committee and the auditor okay which I agree uh yes um I know that you probably want to stay focused on the process because you want to get out of your ASAP but um but I just wanted to

042go back to the job description um if we could I was going to take us back there yes okay let's do that um just because I know that we can't really do anything until we feel good ab about that um just looking at the information you provided from the cgcf um I I and understanding that we want get the highest you know High highly qualified high quality candidates um I I think you you had some good recommendations about possibly changing the title um and um I also have also the reporting I think we should talk about the reporting whether that should be directly to the school board um so it's consistent with the charter which I think makes sense um and then the third thing would to look at the salary um and I guess

043my question to you with respect to salary is do you think we'll be able to get the highest quality candidates with a salary range uh I think we probably need to bump it I don't know how much um I I deliberately didn't get information from like La New York Boston Chicago because those are vastly different markets in terms of salaries and so forth from us uh but even the the ones that we did select um we we don't always compare as favorably as we could uh ultimately I think the HR department's compensation manager would need to uh weigh in on that I did not do a an actual salary study uh there is a lot of data out there uh from outside agencies as well about salaries um several you know uh a um like

044Robert Half and others that put out scales uh for chief audit executives and things of that sort but uh I don't have a specific recommended salary range I think we could possibly you know ask us to work with HR to come up with an appropriate salary range before it's posted if we can decide today what the reporting relationship is and what the job title is I think we're fine with the qualifications and experience and the professional certifications Lind if I can take us back I'm sorry that's okay can I take us back to um the slide we were on yes so the one question yes the one question um maybe more than one the interview questions we've got down there um input from the school board and I'm not given the tight time frame I'm

045not sure you're referring to the board as a whole and being okay so so to be clear you're looking for input from school board members and that would be I'm assuming you having oneon-one com conversation we have several ways we could do it this is a thank you for going to the next one because this was really spongy right um I think we could do it where I could do one on ones or we could just send a I know you can't talk to each other but send the same information to all of you by email and have you respond individually not collectively uh with comments on proposed questions and be or maybe just designate you know some subset of each group to work on this on this particular tax um I don't think we

046need to have a formal vote oh excuse me a formal vote and approval I think we can just get feedback and input because some of the questions are going to be basic I don't I really don't anticipate a problem but I think we should be prepared that we could have say one board member has a question that they really want asked but nobody else has raised that as a question does it automatically become a question that gets asked because I say it's me because I don't want to single anybody up and I really feel like this needs to be addressed nobody else brought it up and you guys decide not to bring it up and I'm over here like feeling like this really important thing has been glossed over so that's the reason I I

047want to delve a little bit more into I know what you're saying that you don't think that the board has to approve it but I do think it's important that if there's a question that doesn't make it on that there is an opportunity why don't we develop a draft list of questions and circulate it uh in individually as I set so as to not run a foul of sunshine requirements um and get feedback that way and then find out if there are uh a question or more uh that some just really feels strongly must be in there no matter what and then get get a consensus that way if that's acceptable well let me ask um our general counsel are remembering that W suit that the school district boss um with violating the Sunshine Law

048and the superintendent went to so my thought in you saying that except for the fact it could be a sunshine violation you could send out your initial question you all have come up with you can send that to us and then if one of us feel like something's missing we provide it to you you could send out a revised version right and then you would know if everybody is okay with the revised not the revised would come back to the board now to John have we just tripped the no okay the process the chair just described yeah and that was that was what we were envisioning so that we wouldn't run a foul of the sunshine laws so yes we'll we'll we can do that yeah so the one thing that obviously the time frame

049would change because we need to get that back to a regular board meeting or a special board meeting again I highly doubt it happens but just rather be prepared um um and then on the um interviews I think it would be good for the board probably at this point to make a decision on whether or not we want it to be a representative of the school board the whole school board if it's a representative or more than one representative I'm assuming the board would vote on that subcommittee if you will but I'm not suggesting we identify who it is but are we okay with it being one person that we um choose or are we okay with we'll decide when it gets to that point whether it's a person or a subcommittee anybody have a

050problem point of clarification you're talking about the first round of interviews yes yeah where it says representatives of the school board so not suggesting that we identify who that is but that would be that would have to take place at a board meeting in order for us to identify those individuals and it might be one person or a group of people do we have it scheduled as could we get that determination this evening at your board meeting if it has to be decided in a formal meeting rather than in a work session because scheduling these things and and beginning to work on the process would be helped if we could um I I didn't I confess I didn't think that picking a person or persons would require formal voted board action in a in a

051regular meeting I think if you want to point a person here yeah I think you can do it here by consensus I don't think you that yeah but we need to do it in this forum not outside of a public meeting yes yes yes for a second I thought you said think I can do it I I didn't if if the board is ready we can choose that person if you all feel like you need a little more time then we would have to wait and do it this evening what let's pick let's pick somebody okay anybody I have a nomination I have a nomination to I bet it's yours yes don't say you're not willing to Salam yes I just did external audit pick so you know I'm I'm my my wheels are G

052nicely I'm happy to be there well let's do it let me do it this way also is there somebody who would like to I don't know if there's a subset in addition it's a lot of fun Vicky no it will be a different process member Salomon it will be it will be I interview rather than but I do think we need to do it quickly because D yeah okay I've got two NOS I've got a yes number Quan absolutely you mean like to have her no whe like a like a second we need a second I no we don't need to we can just trust put all of our trust incredible knowledge but if for some reason you need a second person or no I just want to offer that we can have a backup

053the way we always have backups backup I don't mind being a backup person yeah the backup would be a good idea because people's all you know people's lives have other things going on and it might not there might be a time when we need to get folks together and there's a a conflict so that might be a good idea remember douas did you have an interest on no not at all all right you guys I I support member Sala and backup as okay thanks all right that's resolved okay um were you finished chair yes I'm okay I saw the superintendent turned her flag up I did thank you I have a I think a basic question so um the board has three employees um I'm trying to figure out who the point person is for

054this in the past it hasn't been the person in the position and I don't think we do that as um an organization so is it going to be a board member is it going to be the chief of staff are you going to have Linda be the point person that's running the interview process and all of that can she do it I'm not saying if she can or she can't is that typically you don't have the person who's in that position who's leaving overseeing the interview of the next person coming in yeah I don't I don't really want to participate I don't think it's appropriate to participate in interviews I'm happy to do sort of the behind the scenes logistical stuff and I would be delighted to get support or or to have it otherwise

055handled by someone else because it's just me I don't have administrative support in my department yeah no I wasn't saying that you didn't participate in the interviews because that made bring value since you know the district I'm just talking about like you had you've had a firm or or Bridget when you were looking at um our general counil I'm just clarifying that's all because that hasn't been it could be a school board member I mean I'm just that hasn't been brought up well I think it ought to be Schoolboard services for the chief of staff either one of those um I do see maybe there's confusion here I I do see value in having yeah and I doubt that the board cares whether it's um the head of school board Services is she not here

056um bridg right brid right okay I'm sorry I was I was thinking Rebecca no I was anybody have a problem with Richard handling it bridg like I I don't know next I believe is next it up what are you talking about we got it it was me she just put it oh my gosh you guys she's running her meeting is that it Dr Vasquez yeah that was my that good so so we will work with um Dr Williams 10ig yep we together excellent excellent oh thank you y thank you okay Rob and okay all right I believed uh that member bird was next she's had her sign up for a little bit um on the uh well first of all for the title I and looking over the um all of our titles we're basically

057all chiefs the Senior Management so it seems to me it makes sense to change it to Chief internal auditor um so I would be in favor of that and then as far as the salaries on this list that you provided um where you have number years experience is that what they required when they hired them or how many how many years of experience they have these actual Auditors have that are making this money no that is what's on their job posting so to speak if they put out their their Chief auditor what they require as a minimum okay and these are their ranges for what they advertised they were yes or what's from their version of the salary schedule if you will the only one that's different um is the Miami Dade and Broward uh

058caes those those are actual contracted rates cuz they one just renegotiated his contract and the other one was just appointed so that's do you happen to know how about how long they've been with their uh in the case of Miami D he he is a career um auditor he's been with Miami Dade for probably 20 some odd years he was the deputy auditor before he became Chief and I think he worked at Broward before that the um the Broward auditor had been a um specialty auditor many many years back and then he left and went to another entity in Broward County and forget I don't remember what it was but he got uh more experience there and then came back over as the chief auditor just this past fall okay so our our range obviously

059is is you know now we near most of these except for L clar County it looks like but um so yeah I'm definitely in favor I don't know if you where we left it you said you were going to have have a check or see what we could do with HR I I have not done a salary study or anything that would be uh true data on which to base a recommendation and that's really not my forte I mean I can certainly I these are I can tell you what people make um but uh I think we have a compensation manager in our HR department who's well versed in this and if I'm going to be working with Dr Williams and Mr Bixler then we can certainly tap into that resource for some additional support

060and see what they recommend but it will be probably you know a negotiation type of thing once a range is established anyway could I just comment on that so you know we did compensation study for cabinet we also did it for our our system principles and our principles I think John did some comparables as well um and so just with we were looking at Miami day and Broward those were excluded because like the cost of living and um some of the other elements were not comparable to Orange County so we looked at Hillsboro um we did look at Charlotte um uh dval some that had more and and that what we got from a firm so we could go back and look at the ones yes that were done for um for those two studies

061um Rob has has headed up the one for the assistant principal and the principles and that that's what we did for those positions okay if I may though in looking at this position you're going to find more variation because for example Duval hasn't had a board auditor except since the 2019 School accountability Act passed and um that they don't really have a full fullblown yet uh audit function that's up and running and likewise Hillsboro has um some situations that even though the district is very comparable to Orange the audit function I don't think is is comparable and we can talk more about that separately um but but there are other comparables and I think that makes sense I would support that because again it needs to be done and it's not my expertise thank you

062okay so now I'm not sure whether member salamona or member Gallow was next I confess I didn't see the moment paper SC so we'll let Maria go first she's adamant I promise I'll be quick kind of okay so um I agree on the title I think let's at least have the title match the chief whatever one of the chief internal aitor is what I heard so keep me honest here okay yeah yeah I think that's right so I definitely support that um I think on the salary it would be great to have some comps U that are some combination of comparable districts in the standard of living as well as I especially I think experience will be really important to understand um one of the questions I had for you was who from Senior Management

063do you interact the most with because I know in part of the process there's a pending question on kind of Senior Management having some visibility into the process so I'm just like who would be have a better sense of if someone is the right fit or not because they're working with them more often than not are you talking to CFO I don't know that I work with anyone more than anyone else uh we we audit the whole dist District I interact with all of the Chiefs and with uh the superintendent and the deputies as well as directors and Senior directors and others so I don't know that there's you know we we audit in facilities we audit in operations we audit in f i i don't have a strong feeling on and does the superintendent

064have a like no I don't Senior Management and who you'd want to be representing part of the interview process I think it's on there right so um honestly I probably would um defer to either or even Roberto they have the most number of of audits they're Chiefs and so Rob you know I would say Chief of Staff but he's going to be involved in this process but Maurice or Roberto have the most number of um of audits so I would recommend either one of them yeah I think because can you talk about the interview process yeah yeah having input in that so I uh knowing how much it is involved in all this I would recommend mauce as the one that has some of the was part of the process so um either the COO

065or the cioo is that what I'm hearing yeah but I sometimes when you turn away I I can't hear Maurice my recommendation was for oh it would be Maurice okay cuz there is a lot of it component when it comes to and he's great in an interiew too uh before he was in his current position I had him on interview panels for my IT Auditor position and uh it was very valuable U so that that would be great so that's for the um you're talking now about that first round of interviews correct yeah can you go back to the project I think that oh yes I'm sorry let me do that okay so I should have numbered these but you're talking about conduct first interviews and recommend candidates for second interview so we haven't decided

066so we know it's going to be uh member salamona with member Fant as a backup from the school board and we're going to have um the CIO as a management representative participating and then do we want the audit committee as a body of the whole or some subset of the audit Committee involved I think subset I don't know I think a subset the problem people schedule so if you had subset you still have somebody I think so I think so what do you think Madam audit committee chair two three what what do you think I think probably two is sufficient uh I'm sorry member salamona were you finished um no so I think that was the last thing I did have was um I I definitely absolutely want your uh input into this process as

067part of the interviews and recommendation of candidates you know what it takes to do the job and so on the dayto day I think it's it's really important for you to like we definitely want your input in the analysis of each of these candidates so definitely feels and then member Gallow you had your yeah yes thank you sorry so it usually when we hire somebody especially somebody as important as an auditor do we not have HR like shouldn't we have an HR person person that is also on the interview process yeah they'll run it they'll run it oh you'll run okay so HR will be running it okay and then it but the interviewers would be U Mr Dragon and then people from the audit committee with member salanka yeah okay I just want to

068make sure that at some point that HR was gonna okay going to be involved um the other comment that I had I know that we've got to like look the job description before we can even listed and I know that we had this conversation when we did our call but um I really would like the reporting of the auditor to go back to the school board I know that right now our general Council handles administrative but our vice chair does all the administrative for the general counsel and for the superintendent so I don't know why the vice chair can't do that as well versus splitting it out since the auditor isn't direct report or should be a direct report to the board there kind of in statute that is a direct report to the board

069I feel like that should come back to the board and the board should do the approval versus general counsel I don't think it's going to be a lot more time on the vice chair to click a couple more buttons for the auditor than she already does or is required to do for the general counsel or the superintendent okay so um so then we would just leave it the way it's described and the way it's practicing except deleting the reference to the general councel doing administrative approvals and we that would just probably just disappear from the job description we don't need to get that granular yeah yeah we would just mimic what we do for the superintendent and the general Council like that to me makes sense why are we breaking off a process that's different

070than how we handle other direct reports to the board okay and then I saw the chair Jacobs um yeah I want to make sure that I understand what the expectations are of that administrative function so let me let me turn to John for a minute to make sure I'm I'm clear I know I sign a ton of things but because I sign a ton of things doesn't mean that I should be the person that decid that ton of things and so when things come to the board for the internal audit I'm not sure if you fully understand what might happen so the administrator is just her leave and her time off that's it that's what what and travel and travel which is what as Vice chair I already did like Vice chair has always handle

071that for the general Council and the superintendent I did for two years memb yeah so so still approving his stuff so so from my perspective the only thing I do with Linda is proove her lead I prove her travel you know and I haven't been obviously in the position where she's been evaluated before my understanding is general counsel signs off on the evaluation but it's well the valuation we need to have a whole separate conversation no I got that I'm just saying my understanding is the general counsil nominally participated in it and a lot of this and Linda can tell you this goes back to when it was originally created I think general counsel back at that point was much more active in managing the day-to-day functionality of the audit Department than it has been

072in the past few years obviously so I think what blend is talking about and what what um remember Gall was talking about more comports with how it's evolved over the years than what it used to because I've looked at the job description too and a lot of the stuff that's in the job description had me setting you know or my position excuse me setting you know audit um priorities etc etc in a way that this position has not done in many many years so I don't have any issue with the very limited administrative stuff going away from my function because so leave you then are looking at how much leave do they have have and make I don't know so the way so the way so compter yeah so how it works is you get

073like the vice chair when you're the vice chair you get an email that either says one of two things it either says you have a work list that needs to be approved which is any travel expenditures or any leave um or vacation now I used to have the PE card too like I used to have to go into Bank America and approve the PE card but I believe that Bridget does the PE card now so all the vice chair is responsible for doing is approving and it tells you like when you go you see how much time they have you can't approve it if there's not enough time there so it's you're just basically approving travel and approving leave and I did it for two years for Dr Vasquez and for Mr pomerini and before

074him um Miss um well it again I've never been the vice chair I will't be the vice chair um but coming into this my think thinking was that if we're going to move it it would be under School Board Services um and so I was thinking that that would be something that Bridget would handle because I didn't even know coming into this that the vice chair was handling it I think that so the way that and this this was done prior to any of us being on the board because I don't think there's yeah none of us were here um so it was decided to take some of the workload off the chair that the administrative stuff would fall to the vice chair and they would approve it um and it it's been like that

075since I've been on the board and so they approve it and I think that that's appropriate I don't and love me some Bridget but I think when you're when you're approving stuff from your people that report to you I think it's more appropriate that someone on the board approves it versus somebody in the district so and this is Linda's uh and please correct me from all okay and I don't I don't have who does the all that but one of the concerns that Linda brought to me a while ago so we have cabinet right and so then each Chief then shares with their direct reports what's going on because she yes she's your employee but she report she's also at no CPS employee so the functions like we did the pilot for remote work so

076if there isn't someone it's not a school board member that's attach that that is attached to her or you could just um determine who that's going to be that would meet with her or him to be able to make sure they are also aware of the things that are going on in the district especially things that are coming like the Strategic plan that wouldn't come just from so couldn't we couldn't we put that in the job description like we could put in the job description or the job yeah like we'll work with cabinet blah blah blah blah blah the the reporting to the board should be much like John and yours whereas we approve the administrative stuff the evaluation comes to the board for the board to look at have input in mostly from the

077the subcommittee and and then we we approve it but that like the evaluation system should be a function of the board after it goes through the committee um and then anything else that needs to happen in order for the auditor to do their job should really be in the job description per detailing what it what their their job is yeah I'm I just I just know that was a concern and then I think Bridget started I don't remember how it was resolved so just wherever you put it or however that is determined I think that's a key aspect so that they're not in the dark when it comes to things that are happening in the district and I and I don't know that um I don't know if this would be appropriate so if it

078isn't because this is is different please I'm my feelings don't get hurt um because the auditor does work with the school board on so much there needs to be like the audit committee would need that information like because their job's not just about doing the audit it's about how you work well with others um how you interact with ocp PS and do those so there's got to be a component of that to the evaluation and so maybe then Bridget or the superintendent or somebody would like take a little piece of the evaluation and hand that over to the audit committee to um to review and add to their evaluation to give to the board John have as part of um yeah yeah if I may just to to respond to what Dr Vasquez said I

079think the the issue she articul is more one of communication than anything else uh just to cut to the heart of the matter what happens is most all of this information is disseminated to cabinet members and I'm not on cabinet and so if nobody needs to change who reports to whom or or change processes dramatically if we can find a way to send Communications that are necessary for any top level of management to know about like the pilot remote work program like the strategic planning thing all of that stuff to Cabinet plus the auditor something like that because it's really truly truly um not this problem it's it's a communication problem and I think we can find a way to figure that out yeah and well that should go through Bridget as a deputy of

080school board Services yeah I agree but the chair has had her her thing up for a while so I'll Circle back to her you do this you got to do this when I look at you you got to go not it I didn't see that uh chair Jacobs we are um going to have to work on um Angie's seating arrangement initially I thought she couldn't sit next remember bird then I decided it was Salamanca now she can't sit across so really what you're saying is problems me you're the problem G um actually I'm glad to actually I'm really glad you clarified kind of the why behind what you were suggesting I completely agree I think the position from that St point should operate just the way um the other two positions that looking for so

081really on board with that and I also think that I don't know what the thing is with that it's a teacher thing that might be a the teacher always go okay I was going to say that better not be like sign Lang which you're start using with other board members brid okay so I'm good with that bridg out of the room we just everything else over to yes she left all right we resolve that I I believe I think so I I believe so so um essentially we're talking about the reporting Rel relationship being as it is practiced now which is the position reports to the school board through the audit advisory committee but that includes all oversight uh no dotted line side thing for administrative matters administrative matters will be handled through this chain

082of command maybe with a delegation to the vice chair but that we don't need to get that granular in in the job description it it's enough to say that it's to the school board yes m okay thank you but that will help us with the order chart as well yes our okay any all right so we've got a a a job title we've got a reporting relationship and I'm going to recap these at the end of the meeting we've got a desire to evaluate the salary schedule but that's got to be we have data need a need for data before we can resolve that circling back to the process um we're fine with the initial screening being uh myself and at HR uh I heard that the short list would be the audit advisory committee

083uh just by itself I'm not clear was that also going to be just two members or was that going to be the whole committee I think I think there'd be value in the in the whole committee laying eyes on the first round timing if timing Falls within yeah any of our meetings well we could do this without having a formal meeting just to select the short list as if we're careful about our emails like our general counsel said so that we don't violate uh if you think we need to have a meeting for open discussion then we'll just schedule one subject to people's availability so so the body as a whole for that one then for the interview questions that'll be staff but we will circulate the draft questions to all of the board members

084and we will take feedback and input and then distill that into the first round of questions and send the entire revised list out to everybody again to reach consensus possibly through that process twice possibly if it's necessary but hopefully not then the first round of interviews will be conducted by um one member of the school board that person being member monka with member forant as her backup if there's a scheduling issue and two members of the audit advisory committee and the Chief Information officer then we haven't talked about the second round of interviews yet if we could direct your attention there please chair Jacobs all right so that's a you know that's pretty much going to be person in all probability if we put the right people on that task and they recommend it to

085the board it's unlikely that the board would go in a different direction um but given how important this position is I really think that I really think that should be the whole board or at least for the final interview well that's the see that's the thing it is that is the final interview we're talking about the second round of interviews is making a recommendation to the board and the board on here is approving the recommendation so if the whole board isn't on the second round and the board is never having opportunity to interview and I I really don't feel comfortable with this level of position and the board not being able to interview that person or a subset a bigger subet or a subset yeah because it is hard to get the calendars on yeah

086so for both superintendent's position and my position when it's the last round of interviews it's everybody on board so if you're going to treat the auditor position like my position and superintendent she probably should have consistency so you could do a second round of interview and with the with the goal being to narrow that down to three people and then that comes to the board or a minimum of two people and that comes to the whole board for an interview and decision I just I want whoever we're considering to be in front of the board with an option okay don't don't come back with one recommendation so preferably three unless we only have three candidates and I don't know John you were about to say something okay that clear as M for everybody okay so

087we're talking about the possibility of a second round of interviews if the poll is very very small and there's only five people in your first round of interviews you may not need a second round because that second you might be narrowing it down to three and that's coming to the board so you know if you're interviewing 10 or 15 people we would want that first round to it down well then let me ask a point of clarification if as you said we we get only five I hope not but if we get only five applicants and clearly there are only three that the audit committee um believes are worthy of interviews do we want to essentially skip the first interview and go straight to Schoolboard interviews um because but let me clarify I I want

088to make sure that the audit committee is interviewing okay okay all right so I so they might interview three and pass three forward that is because there is also a whole lot of value in US hearing the questions that you all have and the answers you get they're going to be more valuable to us than the questions we have so I really I really think at the end where we're going to make a decision and we're going to interview potentially three people I I want as many members of the audit committee as are available to be at the table for That interview process everybody agree yes yeah I mean it would almost like if you know if we just sat the back of the room and and listen to you I I think we get

089more value out of it than we all get to ask the questions so that's my main goal okay I think the board should see and hear the candidates I think preferably we have an opportunity to ask questions but we make sure that we schedule it around the time where we I would say at least have a majority of the audit advisory members at the table everybody okay I got NS over here I I just have I have my C up I have some clarification okay yes ma'am okay uh before um Teresa uh said what she said I had did I did have concern about our uh position in terms of the interviewing because I did want the uh auditing committee to do the initial interviewing so I agree with that but I also know that

090since they're going to report to us we do need to have some understanding at least be able to see the candidates are here um will we we're not going to be asking any questions will we or we just be listening in on the questions that will be asked by the auditing committee as I understand oh I'm sorry yeah tell me what what is I understand it I mean they're a sunshine Committee just like you folks are Sunshine board so they're meeting to conduct the interviews will be posted and and available um we don't typically record all of the audit the routine audit Committee Member meetings but obviously I think these interviews would need to be recorded and if we follow normal HR interview protocols uh most those are all done virtually now anyway um the

091the first round of interviews I don't know if there would be a difference because of this position or not but we might have applicants from all over can can I I think there's confusion oh I'm sorry am I not answering the right question no so what we're talking about here is before a final decision is made we are at the table interviewing this whole board we'll be able to ask whatever questions the second ask I was trying to find out and the second round we will be we will be part of the team that's questioning and we will have the audit advisory committee also asking questions I just want to know that's what I needed to will be able to ask questions as well if you had a question you can if you don't and

092you're just want to be a part like you we would just be a part of it but you are it'd be a chance for us to be able to ask questions if we did so the board's going to have input into questions that go into first round so if there's question like we talked about that part you don't have to go to the first round interviews because that'll be a bigger CH but the second round interviews the board will do so you will have access to like impact the first round questions and then second the second round if I have question you can ask more question I just need to be clear on it thank you point of clarification please um are we envisioning the audit committee doing the first round of interviews and then

093more or less handing it off to the board for the second round of interviews or are we envisioning the audit committee remaining involved in the interview process in the second round I I need clarification matter I I'm sorry if I wasn't clear um was getting so many nods I thought okay so first round of interviews if there's if there there's 20 people that first round of interviews is going to be probably to narrow it down to a smaller pool so there could be a second round of interviews that again is the audit committee advisory committee which a whole or portion you all make that determination and um member Salam monka okay that would be and then we would when you get it down to three that might be for the third round that might be

094for the second round depending on the number we start with when we get down to that final round and there's only three it would be a meeting of the full board and the audit advisory committee yeah okay that's I like and again the only question if you have 20 candidates they're all eligible and this group meets with member Salam monka and the best that that they they don't feel like they can get it down they may do a second round oh okay thank you for that clarification I mean you may or may not they may come back and say you know what there's really only three candidates worth considering in which case depending how many uh yes uh member for um just a quick clarifying question do we feel that it's necessary to have the

095full audit board with us at that that final round of or would it could we do like represent like maybe a representative or a subset so that it's because trying to get all of us plus all of them it could be a little challenging plus they already had to do and so I know this is a little big my suggestion was it's open to all of us at at least we need a quum with regard to the audit advisory committee it doesn't have to be all of them but I did I thought it should be the majority of them but if it's if it's hand is a Schoolboard meeting and not a joint meeting then we don't have to have a quorum of the audit committee present we would desire as many as were able

096to attend to do so but as we said everybody's calendars are busy and it's difficult even to get you know today's meeting scheduled it took us four months to get this one on the books so um so we would invite them but if it's a board meeting to which they're invited it's not the same and here I am I should be looking at our general counsel but I believe it's not the same as a joint meeting where you need a quorum of both bodies is that accurate John that's accurate the as I would Envision in a second interview that the audit advisory committee would be more of an advisory role technical assistance role there and as long as you have a quorum of a board who's having these interviews I think you're good to go

097thank you yes okay what else Sal oh thank you member salaka um my question I guess to the group is going be suggestion is that we get a set of recommended questions for that second round from that first group of people so if there's things that obvious see given time constraints or for whatever reason they didn't get to spend time with or hesitations from each candidate just a bit of that prep workor um so that when the board starts interviewing candidates we also have a starting place of questions that Advance the understanding of the candidate not just kind of start from scratch that's great and so that would be my recommendation is that yeah that whether we're taking notes in the first round or like passing on some on at least the remaining questions of

098the candidates so that the board can then start from there yeah we'll have a separate set of questions um not repetitive except well not repetitive intentionally as possible you might ask them again yeah you know some main question we just we have a big board with a lot of questions so I just want to be mindful of candidates time as well so exact exctly to scope the questions a little bit for you questions we have a lot of questions yes that's the whole board so let's so we'll have a second we'll develop the second round of qu we'll develop the questions for the second round and circulate those for approval much as we do the first round I Stu chair did you have yeah one one probably too far in the weeks but I think

099it would the meeting uh the interviews with the first round will be recorded I think it would be very helpful if a link were sent out to all the board members so that we have the opportunity to listen in to listen especially if we end up with a smaller number of members of the advisory committee that can make it those of us and I think it would be most of us would want to be able to see and hear that interview process well we wouldn't proceed with that first round of interviews without at least a quorum of the audit advisory committee I saying at the meeting with us if we end up with yes less participation because of scheduling at least we would have had the opportunity to see the the first round of course

100yes what you need from us next all right well that's what I was just going to double check we're not going to really get into the time frame now other than we'll try to move with uh deliberate uh haste but but not uh but we've got to work through the process and the schedule and then um just keeping us honest going back to our meeting objectives I think we've talked about the charters everything was basically yes that's reflecting the way things are operating and the way people want it to operate the job description we've cover oh yes ma'am what am I miss oh I'm sorry Stephen excuse just forgive me if this was clearly stated but as a point of clarification um was it decided at what round uh Senior Management would be involved in

101the interview it was the first round and Senior Management will be the Chief Information officer um we've decided on the job title and the reporting relationship on the job description with the salary range pending um HR input um I guess for point of clarification if we get a recommendation from the compensation management part of HR and and it is it it seems reasonable are we do we need to check with you folks on that or are we authorized to move forward once they have made a recommendation on uh a revised salary schedule I just want to make sure we don't step out of line from what you would like to see salary schedules once we HR would come up with a range if we ultimately change the range it still has to go through the

102board to get approval of it we we do board approval for salary schedules so okay that yeah I I mean that can be done at the same time for example on a on a consent agenda when you're getting ready to hire the um hold on it's two-step process on a consent agenda when you're getting ready to hire the auditor you can have consent for the salary range and the revised job description and then you could have on non-consent the actual decision is that no my problem is she's going to advertise a range she's post arranged I you're right you're no you're right yeah so so if we have you're right I I the salary schedule usually goes to the board so I guess it would have to go to the next board meeting because we

103need time for HR to do their analysis okay so we'll bring that to the January 28th board meeting I told you November 2026 you're working hard to make it is that all right do you think Mr Bixler yeah I've already been talking with Teresa so we'll quickly take what you've provided okay and then we'll do some analysis of surrounding districts or other large Bo districts and we'll come up with salary range and description by that board meeting wonder and I'd be happy to offer pointers to her about which ones are more comparable or less comparable okay and then um so that'll take care of the last piece of the job description and then we've got the steps in the process outlined and who's going to do the interviews and and the overall timeline is sort

104of soft but we knew that would be the case because of all of these moving parts and um and people's availability but at least we have a a path forward so I think we've covered the meeting objectives we do the job description well the job description content is just the requirements of the position and you have a red line of it in your packets the board excuse me my AP the audit committee went through it this past year twice making sure it reflected everything it needed to for the um New standards to the extent that there are references throughout it to S reporting to the audit committee and the general counsel we'll be striking all those references to general counsel in light of today's discussion but otherwise the core responsibilities are not going to be

105altered by by this discussion because the auditor still has to run the department still has to conduct you know what I'm saying yeah yes then we'll take that Redline version with the new title and clean it all up for approval at the board during the 28th okay thank you R okay I think I think you've uh brought it home is there anything else uh one thing before we adjourn we have um two members of the public that have joined us at this for this entire meeting um it's a work session which we are not required to take public input and rarely do but given the fact that they have sat with us this entire time and have had an opportunity to hear our discussion if the board doesn't object I'd like to give each one

106of them three minutes to provide their thoughts and input process okay I don't have any yeah okay he's a member of the press okay he R everything I was just an interested Observer because I was an internal auditor at one point I wanted to see what you were doing as such because I had contact with you person so for several months so I wanted to see this because it was part of what I did in said so I had some more background and experience and listening to m sort of an N versus for Prof for profit is's a very interesting Dynamic such as how your selection process which you're well aware thank you all right I would like to I did have one kind of clarifying question about the interview process is it customary for

107ocps to be to have interviews set for positions like this on uh in person or usually I I'll let our uh Chief of Staff answer a lot of times it's the will of the committee um and so we would P the committee see which they would prefer um we do there should there sometimes there can be face to face but the candidate can't make it so they'll do a virtual call to support that person depending on where they're at they may be out of state and they can't come so we we pull we pull the board the the the committee to see what they prefer good question any other we expecting throughout this process that you would have questions you would ask them I kind of a little late saying that but any other questions

108or input speak now I will say that a lot of their input was distilled into the slides um because of their expertise and and wise counsel so um they have had that input but certainly oral uh yes Brian well I sent you an email to M this meeting so oh I haven't been reading my emails it's okay I'll ask is there any training um that you would need us to go through to understand like your interview process just to make sure we don't run a foul and if so how do are you GNA that normally takes place at when the panel is seated before the interviews commence and since you are not part of ocps administration we probably would do a little bit more for you than we typically do it's handled by HR and

109uh Rob's people will facilitate the interviews uh they they don't typically Vote or or have direct input but they make sure everything is conducted uh according to process and the law and so you'll be you'll be properly instructed thank you oh great question anything else from anyone else all right with that this meeting is nowour

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.