001[ NO AUDIO ] Then we'll post it. And the posting must be out there for 45 days. I will reconvene the Trumbo Housing Task Force Force to set up the next few steps on their end. And that's it. That's where we are with it. So we hope that that is a good resolution to all the things that we had discussed about the Live Local act and the former RFP and the ending of that RFP or that interim agreement that dissolved on December 12th. We think this is a good way to start fresh. Board members, is that Live Local act still up the agenda for the city of Key West? Yeah, it hasn't passed yet. It hasn't gotten through anyway. Has to go through whatever the Alphabet soup in Tallahassee is likely called. But, yeah, it's.
002We're not getting it before February or March, so It'll still be 25 by the time this comes back out. We're writing it that way. So my only suggestion, slash request, and I spoke to Jayke about this already, is I think it's important, important that we attach the lease that we want so that prospective responders to the RFP know the type of lease that we're looking for and the kinds of things that we want in it. And that's not to say that we wouldn't be flexible in agreeing on a lease with them, but at least let them see what, in our perfect world, we want for the agreement. Okay, that sounds good. Thank you so much. Thanks for your input. And so now I'm going to turn this workshop over to our visitors, and I'm going
003to turn it over to Mr. Harry Russell, who's going to have the easy part. Superintendent Oxford, it's my pleasure to introduce Mike and Deborah from Florida School Board Association. They're going to work with you, lead you through the workshop today. As you can see on your agenda, there's several items that they'll work through with you concerning the superintendent search. And then later down in the agenda, there's a few other items related as well that are out for either public reading or possibly action. So with that, I turn it over to Mike. Welcome. Thank you, Mr. Russell, and thank you to the board members for having us here today. I have to admit, driving into the Keys was one of the most wonderful experiences I've ever had. I've only been here once, so now I've been
004here twice. We're going to go over several items today and with the hopes that at the board meeting after this workshop, you will be approving some of those items so that we can get the portal up and running. And I'm going to talk a little bit about the portal first. First, I'm going to make sure you know who's with us. Mr. Wessel, introduced. This is Dr. Deborah Pace. She may be working my mouse because I'm going to be honest with you, I cannot read any of those things at the bottom from here. So I panicked a little bit and asked her to be my mouse person. Also virtually, we have Andrea Messina. Andrea, if you're there. And Dr. I'm here. Yep. Okay. And Dr. Demetrius Rice is also virtually. I want to talk a little
005bit about the portal before I move on to the timeline. The portal is an essential piece to the superintendent search because it's a one stop place for all community members and potential candidates actually to look and see what is going on with the Monroe county superintendent search. And it will have items such as the community forum information, the community. I'm sorry, the applications from the candidates. And if a candidate applies, their application is posted on the search portal. If they decide to withdraw, we keep the application on the search portal because in Florida law, that's a public record and some candidates decide they don't want to be a part of a search and they want their name withdrawn. But we keep it on the search portal. The online surveys will be linked to the superintendent's
006search portal and we're hoping that we can get that going also, if they approve later on in the school board meeting, the semifinalists, when we get to that point, they will be posted on the search portal so anyone can go in and see who the semifinalists are from Monroe County Superintendent. And then of course, when we get to the finalist selections, those will also be posted. When we get to the finalist selections, the finalists will do written question responses and video question responses. And both of those responses, each type, will be posted to the search portal. So you can see there's a lot of information that will be contained in the search portal. And working with Mr. Russell and Mr. LaFeare, we're hoping to get that up and running as soon as you approve the
007timeline and some of the other information like the online surveys. Are there any questions about the search portal before we talk about the timeline? Okay, good. So I want to talk A little bit about the timeline and where we're at and some information that we need clarified and some commitments we need from the board for when we get to the on site interviews, which of course will be towards the end of the process. I'm not grabbing the mouse. Sorry. Can you pull the timeline up for us, please? Oh, there it is. Sorry. Thank you. That's not the timeline. Yeah, it should say timeline. Monroe County 2024. That's it. That's it. Thank you. So, as you can see, we're at today, which is the 28th. We met on the 10th and reviewed many of the things
008that we're going to talk about again today. Today we're going to review this timeline with the hopes that at the board meeting later it will get approved. We're also going to talk about the online surveys which I know you've reviewed. We're hoping to get those approved also so that we can get those up and running on the search portal. I'm going to talk about the community forums and the student focus group and I've worked with Mr. Russell to get some dates and locations. And with the board's approval, we'll move forward on those also. We're going to also talk about the on site interviews at the end of the search process because we will need commitments from the board with those dates to make sure your calendars are clear. Next thing that will happen is the
009online surveys will actually go live. And if they are approved, they will go live on February 3rd. And those surveys will allow anybody that wants to click on it. It could be a community member, it could be somebody that's not a community member to give input into the qualities and qualifications that they want to see in the next superintendent from Monroe County. If you look at February 11th through 13th on the timeline, that's something I want to take a little bit of time to go over with you. The board mentioned on December 10th that you wanted to do three community forums in the upper, lower and middle keys. And in working with Mr. Russell, we kind of found a solution to that. We believe that we hope the board will approve. We were looking at
010doing it a February 11th, 12th and 13th community forum. The first one on the 11th would be at Coral Shores High School, 6pm the second one on the 12th would be Marathon High School at 6pm and then the third community forum would be at Key west high school on 13th. At 6pm so we have a school board board meeting on the 11th in Key West. So I'd like to either reverse that so that we're all going to be in the place. Can we start February 11th in Key West? Is that so the board could attend the community forums? Is that one of the things you don't want? Correct? Yeah. Okay. It just really helps with the transparency of the process. Okay, so then that doesn't matter. Okay, thank you. Thank you for bringing that up,
011though. One of the things that we also put into the timeline, and it's not listed here because Mr. Russell and I kind of discussed it on the side. The board wanted to do a student forum and you have a group, I believe they're called the Mags group meeting on February 12th. And what we would do is do that meeting virtually that way students from up and down the keys could all participate. And it fits within the timeline of our community forums. So to kind of recap, the 11th would be a 6pm Community forum in Coral Shores. On the 12th, we would do a virtual teams meeting for students to do a focus group. On the 12th at 6pm we would do a community forum at Marathon high school at 6pm and then on the 13th,
012we would do a community forum in Key west high school at 6pm so before we move any further, I wanted to kind of discuss that and see if that kind of fits into what the board was thinking as far as getting face to face input. Remember, you still have the online surveys, which is going to outnumber usually the numbers. As far as the community face to face meetings, the online surveys usually you get in a county like Monroe county, you would probably get between 1500-2500, maybe even 3000 surveys. I can tell you you're not going to get 1500 people probably come to the community forum. But I want to make sure that timeline and those community forums kind of fit with what you were thinking. And the student Mags group meeting kind of fits with
013what you were thinking. So any comments or any thoughts on that or any issues possibly with that? Do mags go down to middle school or do you just have high school kids at that? At your request, I contacted the middle School principals and asked them each for a representative and they are going to Send those names to Mr. Russell. So middle school students and middle school Leaders will be involved. All right. I think the timeline is fine for me. And I have a question about the forums. Can I ask that now? Yes. So we don't want the school board or administration to be there, but what defines an administrator? So how within the local school administration, who do you expect to participate and not participate? Well, actually, administrators can go to the community forums. They
014just have to realize that when they go to the community forums, they're acting as a community member when they go to the forums. The main reason for the school board members is because this body is selecting the superintendent. We want to make sure that we keep you guys above reproach, that nobody says, well, they were at the meeting, and, you know, I couldn't say what I wanted to say. Even though that's not the case, some people will, you know, say that. But as far as administrators, administrators can go to the community forums. So it would be okay for vice principals or principals to attend. Anybody in the community is welcome to attend, whether they're an employee, a parent, a business member in the community. And we will share all of the data back with the
015board. Okay. When that's done, there will be an executive summary, and then we will provide. All of the data. We don't screen it. The same is true for the survey responses. We provide all of the data, including comments that may be added back to the board. Although there will be an executive summary. And just for reference, as of right now, Ms. Messina was just sharing with us that Monroe. I mean, I'm sorry, St. John's county has had their survey live for a week, and they already have 3,000 responses. Respondents on the survey. So it typically does provide pretty rich information. At the forums and the focus group, we ask very similar questions. What do you see as the strengths of the district that you would not want a new superintendent to change? What do you
016think are identif. Are areas of need or things that you think we could improve? And then we'll ask at the focus. At the forums, not the folks. Excuse me, necessarily with students. But what qualities do you think are important for your next superintendent to have? As I said, then you'll see all of that information, and we'll provide that data back to you. Okay, thank you. And all of that information will be accessible through the portal. So do you surveys identify what you are? If you're a community member or a staff person, do you have any way of knowing whether or not you're getting multiple surveys from the same spot? It's linked to an IP address, so you can only do one from an IP address. But we all know that they can use somebody's phone
017or something like that. But when you get a large number, it's. That's fine. Yeah, I was waiting for the announcement. I'm trained to hear the other thing. If we're using our properties, we have to have an administrator in the. In the building at the time or in the audience, so. Correct. And that's absolutely appropriate. That's fine. We do. And we've already worked with Ms. Axford and Mr. Russell in communicating to individuals who may be interested in applying for the position. We always recommend that they keep a distance from the search process so that it's, you know, objective in that regard. But it is a very public, open forum that allows for a trust, tremendous amount of community input from all stakeholders. Correct. We would work with administrator because we would need access to the buildings
018and such. And you think the right way forward is to have a description before we talk to anybody. That typically becomes a part of our advertisement. Okay. That's one of the things that I will be talking with the board in a little bit about. But once we have all of the data from all of these different sources, the survey, the focus groups, the forums, we'll bring that back to the board with a draft list of qualities and qualifications. For example, do you want someone who's from an educational background or do you want to leave it open for someone from a business background? Mr. Russell will be going over the current job description as well as some changes that we recommend, because FSBA recommends that you cast a wide net. Right. And certainly indicate what you
019think are must haves. But keep it pretty open because then you get a wider pool of candidates from which to choose. And remember, also, Mike's going to get there in a little bit. But we do invite the board to attend our community meet and greets when the finalists are in town. That gives you an opportunity to interact with your constituents, hear their feedback directly. We'll also provide a QR code for individuals to respond and provide feedback to the board in that finalist interview process so that when you're ready to make a decision, you have a lot of data, a lot of information at your fingertips on which to make that very, very important decision. That is the full responsibility of the board. Thank you. It also gives you a chance to see the potential finalists
020interact with the community, which is an important part of being superintendent, as you know. So are we okay with the 11th, 12th and 13th, the way that's set up? Very good. Moving on to the 25th. If you look at the 25th, that's going to be an important meeting where we'll be going over the online survey information, letting the board know exactly what data we got. Also the community forums and the student focus group information. We're going to talk about the minimum qualifications and the qualities that you want in your next superintendent. So that we can get the advertisement out by March 3. If you look on the timeline, March 3 would be your advertisement date, and that would run through April 1, which is a pretty standard advertisement. Oh, I'm sorry. Pretty standard advertisement period
021for superintendents. People already know that Monroe county is looking for a superintendent, so that information is already out there. So that'll be a length of time for a great advertisement for Monroe County. And this will not be the first time that you see that information. As soon as the search, as the survey closes, Ms. Messina and Dr. Rice will process that information and get it to the board in advance of the 25th. You're going to have some discussion today about salary and contract length and those types of things so that you have an entire month to ponder those things and then come back. But we will be asking the board for a decision on the 21st, 5th about those things in order to keep the timeline and the advertisement on the third. Then on the
022eighth, we will look at the process for selecting our finalists and how we and then select our semifinalists. Now, remember, I said in the beginning, the semifinalists are going to do written questions and video questions. And so after the semifinalists are selected on the 8th, that's when we will contact them and tell them these are the questions that the board. Andrea will work with you to get board questions that they will respond to, and those will be sent to you. They will also be on the portal so the community can see them. Each board member will be asked to work with Ms. Messina on a specific question that you believe is important based on the information that you've seen from your community. So does the amount of applicants determine how many would be semi virus
023and. How many would be filers? It's actually up to the board. It's completely up to the board how many semifinalists you want and how many finalists you want. We encourage you to make it broad when you are looking at narrowing it down, because applicants do pull out. So, for example, and I'm going to be hypothetical, if you had four semifinalists and three of them pull out, you really only have one left for finalists, and so you. That's one. That's a good number. Andrew, do you want to talk about the best numbers you've seen work for semifinalists or finalists, or is there a best number? Sure. I recommend certainly more than five. And ideally, you know, it's no harm, no foul number. So just what Mike said, where we try to keep the pool open as
024wide as we can, as long as we can. So it depends On I heard somebody ask about the number of applications. But people who you believe you'd like to see continue in the process, you see their application materials, you find the applicant compelling, you would like to see them continue. That's how many semifinalists I would say. You know, typically we've not had more than 10, but we've certainly had between five and 10 on most searches. Okay. If you look at April 14, that's when we would receive the responses that we talked about, the written in video responses and actually disseminate those to the board. So you would have all of that information. And then on April 22nd, we're going to identify the finalists. And Andrea walks you through a process to identify the finalists. We
025don't rank them, we don't say this is number one, this is number two and so on. But she walks you through a process to try to get some kind of consensus on who do you think is the group that should move forward as possible candidates for the superintendency, Monroe County. And then one of the things that we need to discuss a little bit is the on site interviews which is scheduled for the week of April 28th. Because at the December 10th board meeting there was a desire for the board to have meet and greets in the upper, lower and middle keys. Three different ones. We normally do one at a central location. We certainly understand that. And working with Mr. Russell, we're going to, we're going to try to accommodate, accommodate that, see if it'll
026work for the board. So if you'll pull up the on site interview schedule for me, please. Can I ask you a question going back on April 14th. Input opportunity means that members of the community who see the results can be. Can respond to questions from. To the questions into the videos. Yes, that's absolutely correct. Thank you. Thank you. So this is a sample schedule. This would not be the exact schedule you would follow because we don't know the number of finalists you're going to have. The most important thing I want to talk about right now is the dates because you would have to clear your calendars and make sure the dates would work for you. And what we are looking at is a Tuesday, April 29 through Friday, May 2 calendar. The first day would
027not involve the board. That would be a travel day for any of the candidates who are out of town to be able to get into the keys. So the main dates you're going to have to be available are Wednesday, April 30, Thursday, May 1 and Friday, May 2. And I'll walk you through the schedule. But I just want to throw that out first to make sure that you get that on your calendars. Mike has worked really hard with Harry to work around things like Easter and Mother's Day, those types of things that could impact a candidate's ability to travel. So let me walk you through what the calendar, or I'm sorry, what the on site interviews may look like that week, if the board thinks this would work. So day one of the of the
028actual interviews and meet and greets would be Wednesday, April 30, with the day before being a travel day for any out of area candidates. We would have a meet and greet at or about Coral Shores High School. I'll work with Mr. Russell to see if there's a better location than the high school to do something like that in that area. At 6pm the board would be there, community would come, and it is exactly what it sounds like. It is a meet and greet where the superintendents will have time to interact with the community members and you get to kind of see how they can portray themselves in front of a community event. There will also be QR codes to have more community input on how they feel the superintendent did in those situations. That night
029after the meet and greet, they would actually travel to Marathon and stay in Marathon that night. They would get up the next day and they would actually have the full board interviews on Thursday, which is open to the public, and they would rotate through. One candidate would come into the full board member. The other candidates would do tours of schools or whatever the board's pleasure is. We usually set them up with a host so that they can go see some of the interventions out at the schools or any other things you want them to see. That night there would be a meet and greet, another meet and greet and Marathon at 6pm after the meet and greet on that Thursday, they would drive to Key West. The morning of the second, which would be Friday,
030they would do their individual interviews with the board. And the schedule is similar to what we have up here and that you have in your laptops. Of course, it depends on how many candidates you have. We would adjust it some, but basically we would rotate the candidates through to each board member to do the individual board meetings. That night at 6pm we would do a meet and greet in Key West. So one of the thoughts that we had was traveling after the meet and greet might be the best thing to do because they can get to their hotel, stay in the hotel that night, get up in the morning and get ready for their interviews, rather than traveling early in the morning to get to an interview if there's traffic or something, you know, you
031hate to put you in that situation. We would hate to put the candidates in that situation. So there's a lot, lot to this. I know, but I kind of want to hear your thoughts and will it work? Are there some things that need to be changed? Keep in mind this is going to. See if I understand. So you're expecting that they would say, fly into Miami. Yeah. Tuesday. Correct. That probably makes sense. Their first event would be Wednesday night at the Upper Keys. Correct. And Thursday you would get to the board interview and the tours and Friday. And do a meet and greet later that day. Yeah. So the only thing I would do is perhaps figure out a way to add in to have the event for them start before the meet and greet
032so that they could tour the upper key schools on the day they arrive, get ready for the meet and greet and come down so that when they're presumably in marathon for the board interview, they would be touring the marathon schools. And then before the meet and greet or during the interviews with the individuals, they would be down in Key west and get to see those schools. Because there's really a different kind of culture climate on each the upper, middle and lower keys. And some group is going to feel left out if the superintendent candidates didn't actually come go visit a school in their area. So what if we added on the first day that they were actually doing stuff? Because they arrive on Tuesday, the day before, and we don't know what time they're going
033to arrive on the first day. The meet and greet is at 6pm and we could arrange for tours that day with the candidates and they would still have the meet and greet because right now there's nothing really scheduled that day. So they can see the Upper Keys and talk to people from the upper keys. What that allows also is that before they go to their meet and greet, they've had a look at some of the schools in the area. So it's better for them to be able to respond to people as oh yeah, I was over at Key West High today and I saw that as well. And that kind of keeps it consistent because on day two they would be able to do that before they got to the meet and greet and day
034three they would do that. So that keeps it consistent. I think that's a good idea. Any other thoughts on that? Are the dates the. The 430-5152, are those problematic for anyone? Once those dates are determined tonight, then those are things that we add to the portal. Those are things that applicants will plan around if they are interested in flying. They're going to need know that that week of time, they're going to be busy and they're going to be in the keys and they're going to have to, you know, forestall other obligations that might be there. So we really work hard to try to. While certainly the timeline will have to adjust if things happen once we set those dates, we really work hard to keep them solid as best we can. God forbid a hurricane
035or anything, but it's not hurricane season, so we're going to hope for the best. So the board member interview, they will take place each day with different candidates. So on day two, how is that actually working? Well, let's talk about day two first. Day two is a full board. So it'll be one person sitting and the full board interviews. Okay. That's where Andrea will help work on the questions that you will ask. That way you don't get caught asking the same questions. The second day of interviews, which is actually the last day on Friday, May. May 2, or individual board interviews. So, for example, Chair Khan, you. You would have a time set for you to interview. Let's suppose there's four candidates. A, B, C, D. At different times in an office. If you have
036offices in Key West. Okay. And. And we would rotate the candidates through each board member at different times that he's setting up a schedule similar. Similar to that. Okay. Yeah. And if it's not filmed, it's one on one. Yeah. I'm just trying to figure out how the board member or not the board members, the candidates in each area, is that coordinating with interviews or is like sue gonna interview up in the upper keys and. No. So we're all going to interview everybody in Marathon in Key West. So the full board meeting interviews, full board will be in Marathon. That's the day two. Okay. When they drive to Key west the next day or that night. I'm sorry. And wake up in Key West. That's going to be the individuals in Key West. So it is
037going to involve. I was going to mention this. This is a lot of movement for. For the board also. Right. In tech personnel, you know. Well, that's why I'm trying to figure out what that all looks like. Yeah. Thank. Thank you to Mr. Russell because we went round and round about this one, trying to see what. What would make sense and what would work. So the full board interview, though, is filmed and broadcast. Yeah. And if the community comes, we give QR codes so they can actually give live input also. Okay, thank you. Do you think they'd be more like suitable to have open conversations at our offices or at district offices? Your offices are not in the district building or. No, I mean, I have my own law firm, so would it be more
038accommodating for them to come to me at my office or do you think that kind of a little bit standoff. It would be better if it was at the district office? Yeah. That way they're not traveling from location to location location for those individual interviews. And it keeps some consistency among board members. So to that regard, though, maybe we do that in the office at City hall so that we're not doing it in front of the entire district staff. Wherever they do it, I want to make sure they're comfortable in the atmosphere. They're not feeling kind of uptight and tense the last time. And we just were in different places around the building. Well, it's not something we have to decide tonight anyway. It is not. And I'll work with Mr. Russell on that. The
039main thing was getting the dates and if you felt like the format would work. And one thing I'll remind you, if they're applying for superintendency, they're going to be anticipating this type of situation. Oh, we're on your birthday, huh? And members of our staff will be helping to guide the applicants from one office to the other office. We give them and you a 10 minute break in between because you'll all be tired after, you know, that length of time and they're going to be tired. But. But that's part of the process and it really gives you ample opportunity to get to know them both as a group, but also then one on one. And then do you think they'll need downtime by themselves at the lunch or is that something that would be sort of
040like an administrative meet and greet when it's at. There have been times when, for example, your teachers union may want to host breakfast or lunch for the candidates. We do like to give them a little bit of time to catch their breath in between and throughout this process. But you know, we'll look at that with Mr. Russell and the staff and if you have specific suggestions about that, you can contact Mike, me or, you know, Ms. Messina and we'll be happy to. To work with you. I think meet and greet with the teachers union would be awesome. Yes. And just so you understand the timeline, not this on site interview schedule, but the previous timeline we were showing, we will update that periodically like now that I know these dates work, the timeline will be
041specific and it doesn't have to come back for your approval because the dates were already in there. They were just the wide range. But now, now we can make it more specific on exactly what's happening, where it's happening, and it helps the community because now they're going to start being able to see that at some point in late April, early May, I may be able to go to whatever the location will be to see a board interview with the candidates. Are there any other questions on the timeline or the on site interview schedule? Okay. Mr. Russell, are you up next with the job description? Okay. We had other items on the agenda. Yes, I apologize, Ms. Messina and Dr. Rice. We're going to go over the superintendent search survey with you all. Yes. And I
042don't know if I share my screen, if you're able to see it or not. So I just know that the three versions of the survey have been provided and what you'll see on there is exactly what we discussed previously. The survey is already set up, ready to go. We have it in three languages. We have it in English, we have. It in Spanish, we have it in Haitian Creole. As somebody previously mentioned on the survey, they will identify whether they're a parent or guardian, community member, school board employee, current or former business leader, student or other. And as Dr. Pace mentioned, we will provide the survey results in, in totality. So I say that just because sometimes people maybe write a comment that has maybe foul language or something, but we don't screen anything because
043it's a public record. And when they put it in there, a lot of times, especially if they have maybe a critical comment, they want to go in and make sure that their critical comment actually appears. And so we just don't filter anything. We do provide an executive summary where we find, we look for common themes. And then as Dr. Pace mentioned, we take the common themes in with the input from the forums and the focus groups and that's how we draft some recommended qualities, qualifications, the things that you would put in your job description. So we have these ready to go. I've also prepared and I don't, I'm not sure, I don't think you guys can see, but I'm going to try to share my screen. Anyway. We've prepared some social media notifications and again,
044we've got it in three languages. We've got the French, Haitian Creole, Spanish and English sort of promoting taking the survey. And then we've also got some language to share with your team. If you guys want to send out text messaging or email messaging to encourage people to participate in the survey, we have all that as soon as we get approval for the survey tonight after the board meeting. Your team can expect those first thing in the morning. We just like to make sure everything is completely approved before we release it. So any questions on that? If there are no questions, then we'll move on to the next item on the agenda. Do we have anything that asks people if they are a resident of Monroe County? I mean, you said that you don't. That anyone
045could answer this. Can we add that to the check. All state holder groups you represent? Sure. But when you say resident, I want to be clear because some people might. Do you live or work in Monroe County? Okay. Live or work in. Is that. Yeah, live or work in Monroe County. And also if somebody maybe lived there two months out of the year but was there, would you consider that living or working in Monroe County? That would be up to them. Okay. I just want to make sure that we're not going to try to specify. I can certainly add that right after the check. Your. The group that you represent. District. I mean, it wouldn't make me disregard their input, but I would just be. If we end up having 40% of the people not
046living or working in Monroe County. But why would they ever do the servlet. I'm just saying that we had people from Asia voting on the Bubbas. Right. I guess my point is though. Correct. If they did, they're still going to check. I live or work in Monroe county, but you know. Yeah, I would recommend putting it on there. Just they may lie about it, but still, it doesn't hurt to have it on there. Well, and I would add, as Andrea mentioned, you know, St. John's already has 3,000 respondents. If we do our best work, which we intend to do in working with your team to disseminate it to your internal stakeholders and get a wide number of respondents, the data is going to trickle down and be something I think the board can rely on.
047It's been really cold in St. John's recently, so they've all been indoors. As long as the board's. You know, as long as the board's okay with it. I'm happy to add. Just a simple question. It'll be yes. No. Do you live or work in Monroe County? Yes. No, that's fine. All right, then we'll add it. All right then. Moving on to the next item on our agenda, it's a generic discussion about salaries and qualifications as we've said when we come back to you on February 28th, we're going to be bringing draft qualifications qualities for your next superintendent based on the data that's come out of the survey, the forums and information that you all may have shared. Another part of your decision making process that's going to be very, very important is determining the salary
048range that you want to offer for this particular position. Mrs. Messina has shared with you a wide variety of data and I'm not going to go over all of it with you. I'll just point out a few important things for you to look at. One of those documents was the salary study that was done of employees in Monroe county. In particular, I would suggest that you look at page 38. That is actually the salary table for chief executives of your public entities in Monroe. So for example, the City of Key West, City Manager, the Clerk of the Court, the Aqueduct Authority, I believe it is Executive Mesquite Control, Keys Energy and the College of the Keys are all represented in that table. As a reference point, I would also suggest that you remember that your
049superintendent is often supervising a large number of employees. In this case, I believe the school district is the second largest employer in the Keys beyond the Armed services, if my research is correct. And while your student body is not quite as large as some other districts, there are certainly complexities here in terms of operational logistics that other superintendents with a more dense student population may not have to lead, so to speak. So those are some things to keep in mind. In that reference, she's also provided for you the latest table from the state in terms of the salary table for elected officials. It looks just like this. As you may know, 38 superintendents in Florida are elected instead of appointed. I will tell you that typically elected superintendent salaries have lagged behind what appointed superintendent
050salaries are. But the salary table for superintendents had not been updated in decades. And this last legislative session, the legislature did approve a change in that calculation. So it did raise what that elected salary base would be. Currently, for Monroe, the minimum for an elected superintendent would be 173,701. Just in reference, St. John's is 203 and your current superintendent's salary is at 175. The other piece that we've also shared with you is a salary table of the most recent searches that we've done and some other superintendents to give you another just frame of reference point. And you can see Monroe is second on this particular page with 8,066 employees. I mean students. That was from 2122. In looking at this last FTE forecast, you're forecasted to have 8,886 students in Monroe for the 2425 school
051year. I don't know exactly where you are now, but it's typically very, very close to that. It shows the number of employees as well as the annual revenue, which is, you know, close to $150 million, and then the current salary with it historically. So this gives you some reference points for which you to start framing your frame of reference. We will ask the board to consider a salary range because you'll have candidates with varying levels of experience depending on the qualifications that you have as you bring forward. And something else that you'll want to think about is contract length. Do you want to do a three year contract, a five year contract, options to renew? Those are all things that you'll discuss with your attorney. As you know, you're in that negotiation phase once you
052have a finalist and you want to move forward with contract negotiations. But these are all things that we want to include in our advertisement, which again is scheduled to post on March 3rd to keep with our timeline of getting your new superintendent in place or at least chosen in May to allow time for contract negotiations, movement, those types of things for a July 1 start. That would allow them also some overlap with Ms. Axford, which you know, is always helpful if you are bringing someone in. So I've been thinking a lot about this and actually, Dirk, I might need your input because I don't even know if we as a board or allowed to do something like this, but we want to give the superintendent the highest possible salary and in order to do so
053we may need to restructure the district top level staff. So the first question I have, Dirk, is that something that we as a school board could choose to do so, for instance, and this isn't a surprise to our deputy superintendent, but if we got rid of that position and used some of that money towards the superintendent job, or restructured in a way that we don't have executive team and directors in order to save some some money and put money in different places, it seems like a really good opportunity for the district to change and fine tune finances and salaries and condense it in a way that we're offering better salaries for our most important jobs and sort of adjusting how much we pay commensurate with what some new responsibilities may or may not be. Yeah,
054you approve the salary schedule. It's your province, it's part of policy. And you also approve all the Job descriptions and you approve the, you know, elimination of positions is within your discretion. Creation of positions obviously is within your discretion. So it is a board issue. I've been through some of my other clients where they do a study to. And then they get feedback from you on what you might want to eliminate and consolidate, you know, So, I mean, it's not necessarily something you need an expert for, but it's certainly something within your province. So, Andrea, like I said, I've been thinking about a restructuring and I'm wondering if this is something we need to get done or at least in the process of doing prior to hiring somebody new. So, for instance, I would love
055to see the district run more of a business model with a CEO, superintendent and a cfo, finance director, a lawyer, and then even have somebody doing internal auditing. And in order to pay for those positions and still save money for the district, we would then get rid of things like a deputy superintendent, maybe not have executive and director and change to just director. So I guess my question is that's something we need to accomplish now. In a sense we do, because I want to be able to pay the new superintendent the highest possible salary. Right? I mean, that's the way to get probably the best candidate. So I guess I'm just looking to you for timing and then obviously board input. I mean, for instance, John is always looking to save money at district, so
056this would work with him in terms of cutting top level, some top level positions, paying other top level positions a little bit more. You know what I'm saying? Like just moving the money around and then saving in the long run some money. I'm sorry, turn your mic on. All right, let me. My point. Yes, that's something I've always looked at. However, I don't believe the board should be the driver of it. My plan on this is that's a question I would have been asking every one of the candidates is how can you. Do you think you can restructure this and trim down bureaucracy if there is excess there? If in their opinion, there is this point, I don't believe we as a board should put that on whoever we pick. As a superintendent, I would
057hope that that person would want to do that kind of stuff, but I don't think it's. I think we're handcuffing. Well, that's why I asked. We're taking the job away from them and we are not the superintendent. But I agree with the premise of it. I agree with the outcome of it. I just don't think the Board should be the ones doing. Doing it. Yeah, I think that you're offering more money and handcuffing a new individual. You know, when Mr. Porter came in, he brought in staff of his and had and structured the district the way he wanted it structured. And I think we should. And Mrs. Axford has done the same thing. She made adjustments to leadership in the way that she wanted to lead the district. And I think we can offer. If
058we offer money and then tell them, but. But we're cutting staff, like experienced staff, or you can't bring in your people. I'm with John. I think that it should be that every superintendent should be looking at how they can be the most streamlined administrative machine. But I think we need to give them the flexibility to bring their ideas to us. So where are you getting the money from then? To pay the superintendent more? Or are you just going to leave it at what Terry's current salary is? Where you find your money? We're going to discuss that. But the money has to come from somewhere, correct? Well, you know, just like we give, we have to talk with the CFO about what kind of flexibility there is and we have to talk with the staff about,
059you know, what, financially, what it's looking like moving forward and what we could conceivably offer. I, I don't think it's a. And or situation because if you have a superintendent that comes in and then immediately cuts people's jobs for their own financial gain, then you have a bigger issue. So I think this is a conversation we need to have sooner rather than later to say maybe there are jobs that we need to consider, you know, relocating at this point, but not making a blanket across the board cut of everything because we don't want a superintendent coming in and saying, okay, I'm going to limit this job because if I limit this job, then my salary goes up this much more because that becomes a self serving purpose and there's nothing. To stop any superintendent from
060hiring whoever they want and bringing that person in. That's not limited. But I do see both sides of the coin. But I do think that maybe one or two positions need to be looked at right now just to make sure we have a high paying superintendent salary that we can potentially put out there, which is more than what's offered right now. I don't think we should. Do you have any input, Andrea? Yeah, I was letting the board speak first. Was that another board voice I started hearing? It's all right, go ahead. That was John again. Oh, okay. Now what I was going to say. Is I understand all of the angles that have been discussed. I would say that the structure of staff typically is, if you're going to hold a superintendent responsible for student
061achievement and for the goals in your strategic plan, and then you're going to set up the structure that they have to work with, it's almost not fair to hold them responsible for those goals. It is fair to hold them responsible for goals for a structure that they create. And they say, this is the structure I need to work within to achieve the goals you all have set in front of me. So my inclination would be to ask current staff to go to the budget and look for some ways to get some money and bring that back to the board if you're looking for some extra dollars. But then let the new superintendent. And while you're interviewing, you make it clear that you're not necessarily tied to the current structure that exists. So there is some
062room for some restructuring. But I think if you create that structure without the executive's input and then hold the executive responsible for achieving goals under a structure that that executive didn't create, I think that there's some problems there. Thank you. So we're not deciding salary today, though. We don't have to have a decision on salary today. But it is important that over the next couple of weeks before we come back together on the 28th, that you've really given that a lot of thought as individuals, obviously, you can't talk to one another about it. You can have individual conversations with staff. One of the things that I know from my experience is that they're often vacant positions. And, you know, those are dollars sometimes that could be allocated differently, as opposed to automatically saying, we're going
063to eliminate a position that has someone sitting in it until the superintendent comes in and has an opportunity to really look at the organization and think about what that structure should be in order to really move the work of the board forward, as Andrea mentioned. Thank you. So one of the things, I think that the. What you call the Monroe salary schedule is the Key west chamber salary schedule, which may not be the same as Monroe County. It may be more money in Key West. Now, granted, that's where you expect the superintendent is likely going to live. But, you know, I'm just making that clear that that's not necessarily what people in the rest of Monroe are being paid. Well, and thank you for that clarification. We provided as much information as we had in
064terms of what the county's current situation could be, and certainly you bring up a good point, because the cost of housing is something that a new superintendent, if you hire from without, will also have to contend with. Depending on what you decide with salary, there are other opportunities. You could provide a housing allowance or a moving allowance to help with that kind of a transition, if that's the direction that the board goes. And those, again, are not decisions that you have to make today. And that's not even something that you have to make on the February 28, because depending on who that candidate is, you know, it could be an internal candidate who you know for that, for whom that's not an issue. Those are things that during the contract negotiation process in May and
065June, you're working with your school board attorney, you're working with staff. That could be decided. But we will need to determine a salary range before the 28th. I don't know if the board would prefer to have a workshop before the board meeting like we have today before that decision is brought forward for action, either that afternoon or even on another date. That is something for the board to think about because it's a very, very important discussion for the board to have. And we want to make sure you have an opportunity to look at all the data, look at what other current superintendents are making, particularly those that have recently been appointed, and see what you want to offer to be competitive. And we'll be bringing. I'm sorry, we'll be bringing a recommendation, but we want
066to kind of look at this community input to see sort of what the expectations are and how we're going to write up that job description. But Dr. Woltanski, I do have a question. Are you. Is there a study or a. No, I'm not aware of that. I do know that United Way has a cost of living, you know, for these salaries on this list, it might be interesting to find out what the median income is for a range of these superintendents or what the, you know, cost of living index is for these counties. So that we could say, well, you know, I know it's expensive in Flagler as well. It's expensive everywhere. But you know, that we're talking about a small school district with, you know, where are the other places that have similarly high
067cost of living? Because the cost of living affects everybody, even the internal candidates. Right? We'll pull some of that. That's the kind of. That's exactly the kind of project that Dr. Rice looks for. He's laughing in the background. So can you give us a general salary range now? So that conversations with our financial. Our. Chief financial officer Will be looking at a range until we actually come up with a number. And then besides that, I'd love a workshop with her in order to see what we need to do or how we need to do it to get where we want to be. Can you share what the St. John's range is? They haven't said it yet because they haven't started advertising yet. Okay, thanks. But I could share if I had it because it's public
068information, but they have not said it yet. That's going to be one of their next steps as well. Although they will be setting it before you guys do. So I will have it at that next step meeting. What are you thinking? And I know this isn't a hard number. This could change up, down, in between. I just want to get a feel for. I would say you certainly are going to want to. I would think you're going to want to prepare for. Right now you're at. Hold on a second. I'm looking in the wrong place. I was thinking 300. That's not what I meant. I knew that that was wrong. Collier is currently paying 305. Okay. And Collier, as you know, is one of those high cost of living areas. You're currently at 175. So
069I. I would say. I mean, if I'm just ballparking it, I would try to have maybe 250 for sure because of the cost of living. But I do want to run some of that data to kind of compare. That's a very good point that Dr. Wotanski made. Looking at cost of living compared to the superintendent's salary and seeing how that works. But Sarasota's at 255, for example. So I think if you. If you in your mind at least thought 250 as far as trying to find something in the budget, that's what I would. I guess that's a starting point for the conversation. Thank you. That's the question you were asking, right? Yes. So how do we all feel as a board about having Charlene workshop what money we have available and where it's coming from
070at our next board meeting? Because ultimately, that's what the question is, whether we restructure or not as a board and leave things open to the superintendent. Money's got to come from somewhere, so we need to see what we have and where we're going to get it from if we don't have it. I would love to know what kind of flexibility we have in the budget for this sort of thing. Is that much more that you have to go working all around to look and they can come up with that kind of money. It's over a hundred grand more or just 75. It's 75. It's one position. 175 right now. Right. So 250 is 75,000 more. Right. It's less than one teacher. It's not something that they, you know, they can find that. If they can't,
071we need to get new people in there with the whole. No pressure, but. But on the point, though, you know, this is the same board that wants to do that but refuses to give the current superintendent race. It's a little bit of a, you know, position that you put us all in. I guess the easiest spot to look is try to find some positions that there's overlap and maybe say, you know, we could probably eliminate this one because this one always doing this job or something similar to it. This. We have a fun balance every year, and we've been adding to it every year. So that's my point. $75,000 is. Yeah, I think we can find it. We just need the assurance of the CFO that we can find it. And. And we can do
072that in a workshop and we can talk about cost of living. Yeah, I agree. Dr. White, what do you suggest? Well, we're fixing to start going through the budget process again for next year. So it's one of those items that we would need to put on the list and fit into the process. My concern, especially for next year, is enrollment. I think we're going to have an extremely tight budget because enrollment is down right now, FES is up, and what's going to happen with immigration students here in this area. We potentially have a huge impact on budget right now. But again, it's one of those things that it's my job to figure out the budget and make it work based on what we need. I'm here to support the board. And. As the superintendent and
073staff work through that budget process this spring, that will obviously be one of the first things that the new superintendent has to understand and tackle. And then bring forward a recommendation to the board because you will approve the budget in September. Any other discussion from the board on this particular topic or any specific information that you want our team to bring back to you before we meet again. We will look into the cost of living in those counties. We'll definitely bring a comparative. We'll add a little column on our chart. All right, Dr. Rice, I'm on it already. Thank you. I think now we're to the superintendent's job description. Correct, Harry? Yes. So attached in the workshop as an item is the superintendent job description with recommendations from the Florida School Board association team. It's
074also later on in the agenda as a first reading public hearing for job description, like we would do with any other job description. If you open up the attachment and go to page five is where the edits begin, the red lined items. And truthfully, it's not a lot of recommended change and there's one small item on page six of it and that's really it. So pages five and six, if you have any questions or need any rationale, our wonderful FSBA folks are here and can help provide some insight on why that language is being recommended. But I think it's pretty straightforward, personally. But again, we're here to answer any questions on the job description, if you have any. And if not, I believe is that it for you guys? So that would conclude this part
075of the workshop, if there's no other questions. All right, Madam Superintendent, Back to you. [ NO AUDIO ] 5:00 start time. Yes, thank you. [ RECESS ] All right, thank you so much, Mrs. Cotton. I believe we have some students who would be willing to lead us in the pledge. Dr. White? I pledge allegiance to the pledge allegiance Flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all Thank you so much. And we're going to be recognizing these students as well tonight. Yes. So Mrs. Kahn and I discussed this earlier. We're going to ask you to bow your heads for a moment of silence for the Decimi family in Key west who suffered losses in the tragic fire on
076Friday evening. Thank you. Thank you everybody. And our hearts prayers go out to the family. All right. In terms of the agenda, Mrs. Khan, I do have one change to make. We are going to not give the report on the Department of Justice grant, basically because as you know, today there has been a temporary pause of agency grant and loan and financial programs by executive order of the President. And we don't know what the status of that grant is going to be at this time. It was a Department of justice grant. So we are going to delay report on that until we can understand exactly what's going on with that in the future. So can we just move that to pending? Certainly. Excellent suggestion. And with that said, I recommend approval of the agenda as
077presented. Dirk, do we need to do an amendment of the agenda? Are we good to just go? She can recommend it up that change and you can approve it with that change. Okay, so do I have a motion for the agenda with the recommended change by the superintendent. So move. Second motion by Mr. Haran. Second by Mr. Dick. Any discussion? Any no votes? Hearing none. The agenda passes. Next, I recommend approval of the December 10th school board meeting minutes as presented. I'll second motion by Mr. Dick. Second by Dr. Woltanski. Any discussion? I would like to mention the correction to the minutes. I was in attendance at the December 10 meeting in Mr. Griffith was not. And a correction to chair and co chair that were. Thank you. So any further discussion? Any no votes
078with those edits to the minutes. The minutes pass. Good evening, everyone. It is my pleasure at this time to do some recognition. We have several layers of recognition this evening. First, I'd like to call up Josiah Ellison from sugarlove school. Josiah, I'd also like to invite the chair and superintendent up to assist with the presentation of the awards. We have Mr. Tyler from Sugarloaf here as well. Josiah Ellison. Some of you may recognize his face because right before the holidays he got very popular on social media because of the kindness of his heart. He took his trumpet. He is in the band at Sugarloaf school. And he went to the bus stop where he waits and parents wait and children wait. And he started playing holiday music. And he might have thought of doing that
079just once, but everyone enjoyed it so much that I think he got a lot of requests. So he continued to play his music. Through the holiday, really cheer up, lift people's spirits. And it was just such a uniquely kind gesture. Nobody asked him. It was just something he found in his heart to do. And after asking a little bit more about Josiah, I did find out that his trumpet skills are expanding at leaps and bounds. Mr. Dallas has high hopes for the trumpet player he'll be by the time he leaves Sugarloaf. And he's definitely looking forward to Josiah's growth and continue working with him and his classmates and his past. Anybody who heard him play, his teachers all say that that kind hearted young man is who Josiah is all the time. So, Josiah, for
080creating great educational moments for so many people, we want to award you with this gems award. Head for the paradise. Scoot on in for a picture. Congratulations again, Josiah. Next, I would like to call up Landry Sayre from Stanley switlake elementary along with her principal, Ms. Linda Diaz. So Landry is now a fourth grader at Stanley Switlake elementary. However, when she was in first grade, she would take walks around the town in her neighborhood, and she kind of noticed things looked a little trashy. And so she got the Idea that there needed to be a cleanup. Now, remember, she was in the first grade, so she went to see then mayor Mr. Lewis Vidalis, who is here tonight, actually, and talked to him about having a neighborhood cleanup. Well, that was four years ago. And
081just recently, they completed the fourth annual Landry Sayre cleanup. They got everyone involved. The city council was behind them. The sheriff's department helped. She really not only initiated the cleanup, but she really raised awareness on the thought that everyone should be proud, everyone should keep their town clean, not just on cleanup day, but all year long. And so it has made a huge difference. And all with the efforts of a first grader who has had the perseverance to continue with this cleanup. And in addition to that, she is a student who displays leadership in the school, serves as a Christmas cadet for Safety Patrol. She earns straight A's. She is one of the top fundraisers on the annual Jogathon fundraiser. And she's always looking for ways to grow. And for that, we're so proud of
082you. And you have created some fabulous educational moments by educating people on how to help keep our community clean and doing it yourself. So showing them exactly what a good role model is. So congratulations to you, Landry, on earning this gems. Do you guys want to join her for the picture? Congratulations again, Landry. We look forward to the fifth, sixth, seventh. All right, we have several. These are the two students. Next, I'd like to call up trio Alex Chavala and Cindy Augustin, students here at Marathon High, and their coach, Kathy Warner. Would you please come up? So, Cindy and Alex, as you can tell, come on up. Step up front. By the clanking sounds, they have earned a gold medal. Here. Come right over here. They have earned a gold medal at the state meet
083in weightlifting. And I want to recognize their coach, Kathy Warner, who coaches them in weightlifting, but does so much more for Special Olympics and unified sports here. This was the first time they competed in weightlifting. And it was through determination, commitment, and true perseverance that both Alex and Cindy practiced, really worked hard, showed their teammates just what could be done if they really put their mind to it. They never let the idea of they. Couldn'T do it get in the way. It's their commitment that helped them make it all the way to state. And then after going against people who were twice their weight, there's a big fancy formula they use. They both emerged taking home top honors with the gold medal. So we want to first award them with the gems. And I want
084to go on to continue and tell you a Little bit more about coach Cathy Warner. Coach Cathy Warner has really been a driving force in getting the special Olympics and Unified Olympics here in Marathon and expanding it. Bocce soccer cornhole. She just is out there. If people want to do it, she is in there to help make it happen. And she really believes in that principle of if the kids play together and their teammates together, then it helps everyone to get along and furthers our work and inclusion. And again, it takes a lot of extra time, but she finds joy in every moment. So she is the coach of gold medals, but she has expanded the program so much more. And before we award her gems, I'd like to invite Mr. Mike Pudo up to
085say a closing word because he is also so very proud of this crew. And we also honored them at the city council meeting for Marathon. And after we do with the school board, we're going to the county commission. So everybody will know. These are good kids. Alex and Cindy, you are extraordinary athletes that deserve the recognition of your school and all of us here in the city of Marathon and the Monroe county school system. Great performances. Alex and Cindy, you are outstanding student athletes, and you are truly Olympic champions. All right, thank you. And again, congratulations. And now I'm going to turn the microphone over to Superintendent Axford, who has some certificates of appreciation. That's great. So, as everyone knows, we had a historic referendum which we passed in November, and we had to put
086together a committee to support that whole process. We called ourselves the mcsd. I don't think I can include myself, really. We called it the MCSD Best Committee. And we did a lot of things in terms of fundraising, and we also created advertisements for the radio. And we were all really out there making sure that everybody in Monroe county knew how important it was to support the schools. So we did historic work. 82% for the half mill, 72% for the half cent. And so I want to thank these people. So, first of all, Mr. Mike Pudo. We know him as Mr. Marathon. He was the president of the best committee. Thank you. And his radio ad was really exceptional. When we went over to tape them, I was wondering how he was going to do, but
087actually, he far outshone both myself and Mr. Dick. They never played our ads. But I want to bring the Next person up, Mr. John Bartas. All of the advertisements were done at his studio, and he has the most mellifluous voice I have ever heard on the radio. I don't think anyone could deny him and not do what he asked. So thank you so much, John, for Helping us and for recording all those ads and making it happen. Remember that mellifluous. And lastly, our former mayor here and supporter of Marathon High School extraordinaire who was also on our committee. And when I kind of asked them and tried to pull them together, they were right there at the table talking about who they could get money from and how we were going to make this happen.
088So, Louie Gonzalez, thank you. Thank you all so much. So it's people like these that made it all happen. And I'm so happy that we could recognize them tonight. And John, of course, you know, come. On, put you on the spot. No, I'm not going to do that. It was a tie between John and Mike. Yeah, I'll get in the picture. It definitely wasn't you or me. I didn't do one. I didn't. You did one. I didn't. That's right. Well, then it definitely wasn't me. Thank you again. To. Thank you again. It's the support that we get, as superintendent said, and it is those same supporters that help these kids get to. State and so forth. So while I take all of the award recipients just outside, I'm going to call Mr. Russell up. He
089is going to. He has a reflectional moment he would like to share. I guess everybody's going to hang out. I thought that considering that we were in Marathon for this particular meeting, it would be appropriate to say a few words about a pioneer and I feel, a legend in the city of Marathon who unfortunately passed away in November 26th at the age of 77. I'm talking about Mr. Frank Greenman. Just real quick. Frank graduated from the University of Tennessee in 1969. He returned to teach history at Marathon High School for four years. Upon graduating from the University of Tennessee, he would leave to attend law school at Florida State University and return to Marathon to practice law. In 1980, Frank was a member of Marathon's inaugural city council, serving two terms. Frank was a visionary
090and a true public servant for the city of Marathon. He was a hard working, compassionate leader who worked tirelessly to ensure progress for the city. On a personal note, when I was hired to become principal of Marathon high school in 2007 at the young age of 35, green as can be. And it was Frank and his wife in that summer, I think it was in June, inviting me to his home and had a welcoming party, I guess you can call it, at his house. Food, drinks and I guess key players of the community attended. And it was my first good in depth introduction to the community. And I was always very thankful of that opportunity to speak with the group to meet those individuals. His kindness and his welcome in nature will be sorely missed.
091I know my wife and I periodically to this day still bring up that night and that event. Let's please keep Judy, his three daughters, Susie, Kelly and KG in your thoughts and prayers. And at this time I would ask if we could have a moment of silence in Frank's honor. So please, if you would bow your head with me. So Harry, just so you know, I guess both of us cut our teeth with Frank Greenman. My first ever civil trial, I was sitting opposite of Mr. Greenman up here at Marathon. Small world. Thanks for sharing that. And he went to Florida State. That's what I really like about him. Citizen input. Do we have anybody today for citizen input? Maran? At this time we have nobody registered to speak. Then Back to you, Mrs. Hagsburg.
092That brings us to the consent agenda. All items listed as consent agenda items are considered routine and non controversial by the school board and will be approved by a single motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items prior to this meeting. Board members have had the opportunity to review each of these items and may request that any item be moved to an action item for individual consideration. I recommend approval of the consent agenda as as presented. So moved. I'll second Motion by Mr. Haran. Second by Mr. Dick. Any discussion? I have a question. So the Ajax, the renewal is no longer on this. Is there an action that we're going to take on that? So I believe that will be something moved forward. There was a request from the board, two board members
093to remove the Ajax contracts from the agenda at this time. Okay. All right. And Mr. Mr. Schmitz advised us to proceed in that manner. And then is there a plan to put it back? It's gonna be on for Key West. Okay, thank you. Any other discussion? Well, I would just say that, you know, when things. When the new. When the agendas get amended. If we could get notification of what those amendments are. Because I had reviewed contact the consent agenda before Friday. I didn't think I needed to go back into review to see if things were still on there. I apologize for that, Dr. Wotanski. That was an error. I believe the agenda was resent, if I'm not mistaken. But there was no clarification as to why it was resent. Okay, thank you. Should we
094move on to reports? Yes. So as I mentioned earlier, we have eliminated that one report and we're going to proceed then with the Reynolds School conceptual design. Oops, I'm sorry. Maria said she didn't get a vote. What do you need the vote on Maria? Motion by Mr. Haran. Second by Mr. Dick. Discussion and done. Pat, Is this the same one from last time? Madam Chair, board members, Madam Superintendent, good evening. Afternoon. At the last meeting, you'll recall, we took a look at a couple of very conceptual site plans for the Reynolds School renovation. That includes the move from the maintenance staff from Bruce hall over to Reynolds Street. And we discussed a little bit the option of including some classroom space in front of the historic portion of the building. And since then, we have
095also held, as I told you at the last meeting, a community meeting. Some of the board members were at the community meeting in attendance there. But for those who were not or have not heard, we did get a couple of the neighbors to show up for that community meeting. And so we went through the. We had our architects Row architect and Bill Horn go through the couple of options just to see if they had any thoughts or any ideas or questions, concerns. And they did nothing of. What they brought up was really substantial, I think it was. They were things that we could address as we move further along in the design process. But it was good to. It was good to hear their input because they were actually very supportive of the project in
096general because it will improve the neighborhood compared to how those old back buildings look right now. So we thought that was good, and we look forward to kind of continuing to include them in the process as we move through the various phase of development, phase of design. I should say we just go through them again real quick. Pat, before you go through, did we have a consensus on whether or not we need the extra classroom space? We're gonna. So yes, Madam Chair, the classroom conversation is going to happen right now, essentially. So I'll just show you the two. Two conceptuals that you've already seen and then we can continue to have conversation. The first one is the one with the classroom space. We just think that it would be easy to divide the two operations
097because you're going to have an instructional side of the kind of the campus and then an operational side of the campus. So we just kind of cut it right down the middle and provide space. Now, if we were to go down this path, we would probably come back to you with more options for doing not just a wide open. Because those are really large classrooms. We would probably do maybe two classrooms in each of those space or some type of iteration like that, depending on what the adult ed program or whatever program we determined to move into those spaces once. This is just kind of a, again, first step in the conceptual plan. If we do decide to move forward, then we would apply a little more rigor to what exactly those spaces would look
098like. Hey, Pat, Excuse me. Does this meet the single entry? I mean, I know we're talking adult Ed, but does it need a wall there where it says office reception? So that becomes a controlled. Or, you know, so that becomes a controlled entry. We'll. We'll have to look at that as we go through the design process with the adult Ed program. I don't know that there's a requirement for a controlled single point entry. We probably want one anyway because. Because it gives you more flexibility if. We end up doing something different down the road. I mean, classroom space. Space is classroom space and we certainly need more of it. So that would be addressed later. Similarly, here at the barrier between the two operations, we would want to have some place to some ability to
099transit, but not freely, you know, it would have to be controlled. Again, very, very initial stages of conceptual planning. The additional buffering that the neighbors requested is out in the rural street side. Mm. So the. This was part of our plan all along, was to put along the parking lot area either a wall, you know, a concrete, 4 foot, 6 foot concrete wall with some nice vegetation kind of in front of it, hiding it to make it look good in the neighborhood. But those conversations are what we're going to have to have with the neighborhood. Some talked about maybe more like a picket fence type of thing, which is a little bit more akin to what the neighborhood has now. That would apply less with regard to noise deadening and that kind of stuff. Obviously,
100the more substantial you build that buffer, the more it's going to kind of deflect or absorb the noise. So those conversations will be coming, but they were appreciative to the fact that we were considering them when talking about putting the trucks inside the parking lot there. And again, this is the non classroom, the advantage there, if you will. You just don't have to build as much additional space, new space, which again, opens up the area for more parking. So that's kind of the two options we're looking for, we believe, based on kind of the academic programmatic needs that we've discussed with the board before in the Lower Keys, specifically in Key West. We think this is an opportunity to add classroom space and we would like to move forward with that particular site plan and
101look at more options on how to actually build that space out. What part do you Want to see. I want to see the South Street. So I walked by there the other day and there's a lot of parking for people who would be coming to adult ed. I know most of them come by bicycle or walk is what I'm told. Yes, but there is a lot of parking along South Street. That's not resident restricted. Right. That can be used there. South street and Royal Street. All right. It's all right of way parking. So it's not, it's not school district property. So we would have to work with the city on how to. How to. And we can. But it's already marked, marked for parking there. And so is the. Do you think the plan will
102be to lock those gates at night? Absolutely. Yeah. And so then there will still be enough parking for evening classes with adult ed, I think on the street. Right. Any other questions, comments, concerns? Mrs. Kahn, you asked about last time about a one classroom option. I've got a very initial draft on that to see what that looks like. It's interesting. It's going to be very close with regard to providing enough space for adult ed. But as you, you know, the point you made last time was the less new construction we do, the less cost on the project. So we'll take a look at that too. And if that, if it, if we can make it work, the one classroom option, the other issue is you put some operational stuff up front and then it just
103makes it a little bit more difficult to isolate the operational functions. But we just really kind of started looking at that. So unless I hear any significant objection, we're going to continue to move forward with. With some type of instructional space in the front of the plan. Awesome. Moving on to the next report. While we were at the community meeting, we got into some conversation with our architect, Bill Horn on the upgrades at Rex Leach. And, and Bill mentioned that we had new plans coming forward that we took to the design team last Tuesday and Mrs. Kahn asked if we could bring it to the board just so we could show you the. Essentially the 3D renderings is what was requested. So I will show those. We did have a discussion with the design team.
104Just a couple of minor changes. I'll talk to when I get to the. The particular slide that we're looking at and we should be pretty good to go with design development here. And we're meeting that again I think next week with the design team to finalize those changes. Obviously this is kind of the 30,000 foot level. Just seeing where looking at the whole complex, the area that's Being improved is down here in the corner and we can start looking at getting a little specific on that. So these are the bleachers that are existing, the fields up here. And what we've got here is a multi use training facility that's got four tunnels with individual mesh fence dividers in between them that can either be opened or closed, depending on what you're going to do, pitching,
105batting, whatever it is, or open the whole space up for some type of other type of work. So that's the, that's the training area. You've got a new sort of covering. On the training area. Yep. We'll be able to see it here in just a little bit. Yeah, yeah. The old concession stand will be. Will be removed and this is the new concession stand that will be built up to finish grade so we don't have to. So when we do raise the field, ultimately we'll be able to just keep that there. Inside the concession stand is also the, the requested memorabilia, memorabilia room or museum for the, for the baseball program. And then this is kind of the existing weight area that they have right now that there might. There might be an alternative to
106make some improvements there too. So here's the indication, Mrs. Kahn. That's the roof of the training area tilted away from the field. So the rain goes towards away from the field. This is what their first shot at kind of an entryway. And the team seemed to be pretty happy with that. Still again, more development that needs to be included in that. But it's a starting point and it looks pretty good and it was pretty well received by the team. Globes on the top of the entryway or are they baseballs? We don't know yet. I think they're just a decorative like pedestal type type of thing. I don't think they were baseballs. Has there been a discussion about where the Ed Knight plaque will be? Let's more than just discussion. They actually got some graphic depiction
107of it, so. Which is another reason we wanted to bring it to you because obviously we're very happy that we got support of the foundation. That's not the one. Okay, so this is the. These, these are the 3D images. And since you just asked that one, Madam Chair, we'll go right to that. This is looking kind of from the street at the training center. The proposal would be to put this verbiage or something that the board thought was more appropriate on the training center and have the training center be named after Ed and Joan Knight. This is kind of the, again, street level view of the Museum, cafe with the appropriate labels, kind of looking from over towards, like, the bleacher area or towards the road down the line there at the facility. Again, cafe,
108museum, training center. Some ramping. I said that there was some areas that we're looking at based on questions or concerns from the design team. The ramping, whether to have two ramps or one is one thing they're going back and taking a look at. And then how much sidewalk to have around it and where you exit and enter from into the sidewalk are something they're taking a look at. The only other one was whether to put the air conditioning unit on the roof, on the ceiling, on the roof, or down on the ground. We initially said the roof. Now we're thinking maybe there might be room on the ground. And from a maintenance perspective, we prefer to have it on the ground so it's a little bit more easily circle serviceable. The other two, the last
109two slides that are in the deck, if you looked at them at all, were just different iterations of the roof. And neither one of them. I'll show them to you. Neither one of them were particularly appealing to the group, so they elected to stick with the first one, and that's kind of the way we're going. Any questions on this one? So this is beautiful. What are we thinking the cost here will be? We had Mr. Horn go back and scrub it. I haven't got the numbers back yet. We're. You know, our initial estimates was right around 4.5 for the whole thing, and that's what we kind of think it will end up at, especially as we see it's kind of turned out to be pretty nice, especially that training area. So we think there'll be
110some cost, and we'll continue to look for options on finding that money, too. We've got. The superintendent's got some engagement with the TDC coming up here pretty quick that we hope can be productive for us. So what, we have what, 3 million right now? We had the 2. We got the million from the knife foundation. 500 and 500. 500, yeah. Right. So we're at 3 right now. So equaling 100. So we can get another 1.5 or 2 from TDC. That would be. That would be good. Right? All right, thanks so much, Pat. Where are we on. Where are we in the process for Founders Park, Coral Shores? The RFQ has just been. We're in the negotiations with the contractor who's been recommended for the. Who's been recommended for the project. So that's getting ready to
111get Started again by coming up here and talking to people. Have we seen the plans for it? No, we're starting back at the design build. Is that what you're doing? So at what point do we just sit there and go, all right, time is kind of up on this? I mean, I know this, and I know the founders. Yeah. I know that the, you know, city alumni is in turmoil. And that's kind of what I'm. Yeah, I. We will engage with the. The village staff and see what type of reception we got. Last. Last time it was, you know, it was a bit reserved. I'm hearing there's more support now based on the makeup of the. The village council. And if that's true and. And that reflects through the. Our conversations with staff, then I'll
112be. We'll be full. Full court press. If not, then we regroup and talk about taking that money and doing. Moving to the backyard. Moving to the Coral Shores backyard. The. They are in the process. They may have just finished doing a community input on what people want to see in Founders Park. Like, you know, what you would like to see there and the baseball diamond, the field is in. In that list that you can rank what you would like to use that for. And. Yeah, and. And it's in. You know, I've now seen the, you know, PKs and KLs now have better baseball facilities than the high school does. So, you know, it is getting to be pretty dire. It's definitely a dire situation. Unfortunately, it's one we don't have control over. So hopefully, moving
113forward, we will get that in our hands to move forward. So thanks for all the work you're doing trying to get us there. Absolutely. I would like to see some photos of KLs and PKs at the key west meeting because I haven't had a chance to see them, but if you have some, I'd like to see them. I've heard KLS for sure. Thursday. Absolutely. No, they're changing it to March 8th. Oh, never mind. They are going. They are going to have a grand opening. They are going to have a grand opening. They changed it to March 8th because they wanted to ensure that all of the board was able to plan ahead. It will be a Saturday at 10:30 and the invites are getting ready to go out, and that way people involved with the
114project and the board could be invited to attend. So March 8th is the first home opener. Any other questions? Great job, Mr. Lafair. Very excited. Anyone who wants to see what wonderful. To see that come to fruition. So I see that Dr. White is coming up. She's going to introduce our folks who are going to talk to us about our new property and casualty renewal package which is being presented today. And the vote comes at the next meeting. So, Dr. White. Yes, ma'am. Thank you so much. Thank you to the board members for meeting with us individually. Good discussions and greatly appreciate your time. I would like to introduce Eileena Bella that's going to do the presentation. And there were a couple of questions throughout the meetings though, that I'd like to kind of discuss
115at the beginning, just to give everybody kind of an update. This bid was completed, was approved by the board in February of 23, about every four years. The last time it was done pretty was 2019. So about every four years this goes out for RFP and their commission rate is 7.25% in the bid, it asks for a maximum of 12.5%. They came in at 7.25% and actually had been 8.8% the previous contract. So just some background information with the company and under the current contract we are with them. Anything else? Good. Everybody should have a printed copy at their desk. Did everybody get one? Good afternoon, Eileena Bella with Arthur JJ. Gallagher and company. Thank you, madam Chairperson and Madam Superintendent. I am here to present the 2025 property and casualty insurance renewal. So within
116this. Let's see, go down. There we go with this presentation. We were just going to briefly go through the current insurance marketplace, the district's current insurance program, and then the renewal results for the 2025, 2026 insurance insurance renewal renews on March 1st of 2025. So looking at the state of the market, we are fortunately finally in a much improving insurance market, which is quite a relief to everybody. We had started to see a moderation of rates last year. While the property rates at the beginning of the year were still going up, they were going up by a smaller percentage than they were the year before. By the end of the year, we were finally seeing property rate reductions, which has really helped the insurance market. And the two things that haven't really been taken into
117complete consideration, which we'll talk about a little bit, is that we still don't know how the 2024 hurricane season and the recent wildfires are going to affect the insurance market. But as of now, there's no indication that either the recent hurricanes of Hurricane Helene or the recent wildfires out in California are going to substantially change the momentum that we're seeing with an employee improved property market. We are still seeing some stress in the casualty Lines. This is due to a few different reasons. One of the main reasons is due to social inflation and we've spoken about this in the past, but this is just the consequence of jury verdicts being outsized compared to what they were 10 years ago. Juries are looking to award more money. There's a lot more litigation. There's something new on
118the horizon called third party litigation funding, where we have third parties that aren't related to plaintiffs that are going out and actually finding cases and then going out finding plaintiffs and funding that litigation. Fortunately, we haven't seen a lot of that in, in our world, but in certain parts of the country it is growing and we would expect that at some point that could filter down into, into Florida. It's unlikely to affect us as a school district because it's more often than not funding larger class action lawsuits. And so that's not really something that we would be dealing with. So where we may be seeing some of the pressure with it is going to be for the non Florida sovereign immunity cap type claims. So we'd be seeing it more with like ADA issues. One
119of the things that I know a lot of efforts have gone into is in making websites ADA compliant and things like that. So a lot of times that's where we're seeing some of that class actions and stuff is really with some of those groups looking at different types of environments. And you're absolutely right, Florida has a very good sovereign immunity that's held up very well. There's always a push for increased sovereign immunity caps. You know, to date it hasn't increased very much. You know, the Lakeland shooting is one of those areas where. But that's exactly what a claims bill in my opinion is for. For these black swan events, things that aren't your everyday type of litigation and claims against. Do you review our ADA compliance or is that something we as district do? And
120if we as a district do it, Superintendent, which section of our district would handle that? That is not something that we as your insurance broker look at. I'm not sure where within the district. Operations and facilities, but we are, we are ADA compliant in the district. Are you asking about the website or. Okay, that's what I thought. Yes. Our blackboard system currently and the apogee that we're moving to, they. It's part of their contract to make sure that we are compliant with that. Yeah. So again, these are things that are affecting the casualty market as a whole, not necessarily the school district here. This is just the general overview of the insurance market. So if you look at this next slide, this is the 2024 year end graphic of the billion dollar events throughout the
121country related to weather and climate disasters. And just a couple of comments regarding this graphic and I, I believe most of you have seen this in years past. We tried to go ahead and share this with you. There are some interesting phenomenons with this year. So if you take a look at it, we have five different hurricanes you'll see along the southeast here that have hit the United States. Typically, and this is part of the issue that insurance companies have had in recent years is most of those billion dollar events historically over a long period of time, have historically been due to hurricanes. And now we're seeing, as you look at this, most of the events aren't hurricane events, right? So these are other types of storms, whether they're winter storms or hail flooding events.
122The other thing that's interesting, unlike the past few years where we've seen a lot of wildfires out west, there was actually in 2024, only one wildfire. Obviously now we've had the January California wildfires, which are going to be one of the deadliest and most costly wildfires that we've had. Like I said right now, the indications are that this isn't going to be a market changing event. Unfortunately for those in California, a lot of those homes and businesses were uninsured or insured by the state insurer, which is kind of like our citizens. Interestingly, a lot of where the insurance claims are going to come in is due to a lot of these fine arts, very expensive fine arts collections, wine collections, jewelry that was lost during the fire in some of these very large estates out
123on the west coast. So that's really. Most of those collections are more, a lot of them are more expensive than the home to rebuild that they were actually in. So it's very unfortunate. But again, we do not expect as of today, while the total costs are still coming in, we're not seeing that this will make a huge impact on the market going forward. So this is just a quick overview of that casualty market and more as it applies to the school district versus the general market as a whole. So in the general liability market, this is your third party, your trips and falls on campus, things like that. We're still seeing some moderate rate increases, but fairly stable. And in the auto liability, this is an area that we continue to see increased costs, increased
124litigation when it comes to auto accidents. We also have the phenomenon of the fact that it is more expensive to find used parts and used cars. A Lot of this is getting a little bit better, but it really started with COVID when there was just a huge shortage of both cars and replacement parts. Sexual abuse and molestation is obviously an issue around the country. The court cases and the litigation that we see is much worse in other parts of the country. Florida is not as bad as many other areas, but it is still something that's of concern and especially when you're buying large limits of insurance within the market. Got the school leaders errors and omissions which covers the board as well as administrators and your employment practices liability which are your discrimination, your wrongful
125termination, those types of claims Workers compensation While the state rates are going down, these are the NCCI published rates for if you were to have a small business that you bought first dollar workers compensation. Those rates have been pushed down by the Florida insurance commissioner. Unfortunately medical costs and cost of care has gone up. So this is an area where we're still seeing some pressure on rates. But with the district's self insured retention and their ability to control those claims, we've been in a very good position on the excess workers compensation. Cyber liability continues to be a topic of conversation within the insurance market and within the within the realm of insurance. If you look at the next page, this is just an overview of the district's current insurance program and their current structure. The
126green boxes on the bottom being the amount of either self insured retention or deductible that the district retains prior to any insurance. And then you can see the various insurance coverage lines and limits and carriers within the current program. This is just a quick snapshot and a reminder for those who were here last year and for those who weren't to be able to see what the insurance renewal looked like this time last year. So back in 2024, as I said, we were still we were seeing improving property rates, but we were still in a market where rates were going up this time last year. So the for example on the property you had a 1.3% increase in values and a 4.2% rate increase. Your overall premiums went up by 6% last year. So if you
127look at this next page, this is just a risk update and taking a look at the district's exposures year over year. So even when we are in a good rating environment and even if you were to get no rate increase, this is the amount by which we would expect your insurance to go up simply because your payroll has gone up or the number of vehicles have gone up or you've built a new school or a new property. So the really big ones here and most notable affecting your insurance premiums, obviously your property values up 3.6%. It's actually up 2% after the addition of Tommy Roberts Stadium. That was added after last year's renewal date. Your payroll is up 8% and your vehicle count is up 7.7%. The one area that we've reported to the insurance
128carriers that you're down is in the number of students enrolled. Looking at this next page, this and you know we won't go through all of this, but this is just we always like to present to you a list of the markets approach. Every year we look at your insurance program and look at ways to go ahead and rework it and make sure that we are getting the best possible program and the best possible price. And so this year we went to about 57 different insurance companies to obtain your renewal. So this slide is the casualty package. So we package together the third party liability, the auto liability that errors in omissions, employment practices, a small amount of crime and a small amount of workers compensation in between this and your main workers compensation policy. Again,
129if you look at the bottom rows, this is showing how the increase was in your exposures versus the increase in premium. So this premium is going up about $20,000 or 9.7%. The majority of this is due to the increase in exposures. There is a small rate increase which is what we're finding in this casualty market. But it is in line and on the smaller side when you take your increased exposures into account, what is our. Law enforcement liability coverage cover any SROs. On campus and security. So Pat, I thought at the last time we talked about this, those people were covered by the sheriff's department and qspd. So this is if the district were to get drawn into a lawsuit from theirs, from their activities on your campus. So I don't know what the contract
130is. And ultimately they would probably assume that there's some type of indemnification agreement. But this would allow, we put this in all of our policies so that if the district is sued, they're, you know, they're not really rating this as a separate. This is really just something that's added in for your protection so that if the district were to be sued and brought into something that you would have coverage for any legal expenses or anything that did ultimately come against the district. So there's no way for you to cost that out for us. We could, but it would be minimal because they are aware that they're not Your, you're not, you're not like Miami Dade who has their own police for, you know, their own school police force. So that's taken into account. So this
131next slide is the excess workers compensation for those of you who were here or I spoke to one on one back in 2023, we went ahead and changed insurance companies and in doing so, we achieved a 17.6% rate decrease that year over the carrier that you had at the time. When we did that, we went back to the insurance company and we negotiated a three year rate commitment in order to ensure that they weren't just cutting the rate to go ahead and entice the district to move insurance carriers that this was going to be a long term partnership and that those rates would not just go up the following years. So they did agree in 2023 to a three year rate commitment to be no greater than 2.5% per year. In 2024, that rate was
132last year they agreed to a 1% rate increase. So below that 2.5 this year, they've agreed to keep that rate flat. So over that three year term, that allowed for 2.5% per year, we've only increased our rate 1% and this year is flat for 2025, they're agreeing to now do another two year rate commitment and it would be for no more than 1% rate increase for next year. So the only increase in premium here is based on your payroll, which is auditable. We go ahead and get all of the information of the actual payrolls at the end of the year and it's reported to the carrier and then it's adjusted as needed up or down this. Next slide, we sat down and talked. We spent a lot of time going over social engineering and the
133double coverage. So I'm just going to ask that if you didn't meet with all of us that you talk a little bit about how we have that coverage in two places and why we may or may want. Okay, sure. So this is the crime that she's talking about. And we do have some social engineering coverage. So social engineering, for those who aren't familiar with it, is the use of deception to manipulate individuals to either divulge personal information or transfer money. So I'll give you two examples. And these are examples of actual clients of mine that have occurred with these types of claims. And you know, unfortunately you'll see, as I tell you, that none of these have anything to do with hackers getting into your system. In both cases, they had the procedures in place,
134but somebody failed for whatever reason to follow the procedure. So I'll give you two quick examples. One was it was somebody who sent over some purported to be a vendor of this organization and they told them that they had change in banking information and they convinced and they did not. The organization did not go through the proper protocol to double check and verify through another means to double check that that banking information had actually occurred. So the regular true invoices came in from this vendor and when they went to pay them, it went to a fraudulent bank account. As soon as those funds meet get to that bank account, it gets transferred from bank to bank and it's very hard to get back after the fact. In this case, I think there were three or
135four different invoices. And it wasn't until. Until the vendor finally followed up and said, hey, you're really past due on your payment that they realized that the payment had gone to fraudulent funds. The other one that was also, they caught it the second they clicked and it was still too late. What we think happened was we had an employee in finance who was using a hotel computer. We don't know if they didn't sign off properly or if they just somehow got into the system. But they then sent a message to somebody within the organization and they thought it was coming from finance to go ahead and make a transfer. And as soon as she clicked it, she went and called them and said, did you send me this? And it was too late. They couldn't
136get the funds back. So this is something that does happen. Hopefully it will never happen to the district. But one of the things, and as you can see here, it typically has a much lower sub limit than the rest of your than the rest of the limits offered by the insurer. Which is sometimes why we go ahead and buy it under two different policies in order to build up those limits. Because there's. You usually can't buy what you would necessarily want to buy just through one of the insurance providers. So with that. So what we're looking at here is the column all the way on the left is how you currently purchase your crime coverage. It is the first 400,000 excess of your 100,000 retention is within your package. So that's that package that's covering
137that general liability and auto liability and whatnot. And then you do buy another $500,000 on top of that just for employee dishonesty. So employee theft that's discovered over a period of time that there has been a incident or a series of incidents. So we went ahead and decided to look at this year. Once again, I think it's been looked at before in the past, but we were looking at what happens if we go ahead and take this out of the package in order to improve coverage and or deductibles and what would that look like? And we looked at two different options here. So the two different options there, you're looking at less than $6,000 difference. And the difference is the $25,000 deductible versus a $50,000 deductible. So we were looking at those three options. Those
138are all available to the board to look at when we get to the last page here with the premium summary, what we were tasked with was what can we do to improve our program, improve our limits and deductibles? Or what would be your recommendation to make the most improvements to our program now that we're in a better insurance market, keeping our spend about the same. Obviously, some of these options that we're going through have lower cost and higher cost. So when we wrap this up at the end, we're looking at a program that's a similar spend to what you have and we'll talk about the enhancements. So when we get to that, we're showing this last option, which is with the $50,000 deductible, just so that you know but that can be changed to either
139of these others. So here is our bright spot this year, the property insurance. Finally. So if you look up the far left, look at going back a number of years, the district had $5 million worth of coverage for their name Storm, Flood and Storm Surge. As the market got increasingly more expensive, this board decided to offset those increased premiums by taking a lower named Storm and Flood Sublimit. So this year, if you look at the first two columns, you'll see you have the same $2.5 million named Storm and Flood Storm Surge supplements. And it resulted in a 9.7% premium decrease. So this is on top of the 3.7% or 2%, depending on whether or not you want to consider the new stadium within that increase in value. So when you look at the rate increase
140is actually higher than that on. The property insurance renewal, which is your suggestion. So I will. The suggestion to keep your spend around the same would be to go ahead and take advantage of the $3 million option would keep your insurance spend around where it was this year when we wrap up all of the coverages together. So the other thing in addition. I'm sorry, go ahead. You're thinking when you don't keep it at the 2.5 which gives us a 9.7% decrease. So again that is what we originally came to the district with that this is what it would cost to do a year over year type program. And and I will always, you know the board and the district make their own decisions regarding. I'll always recommend that you avail yourself to higher limits for
141these things just because one you. There's always that risk and two there's also concerns regarding the future of some of the public assistance assistance and that is a very low amount of insurance compared to most of your. Most of your peers. So Pat, the last year when we discussed this we came to the conclusion that we almost never get any money after storms from insurance companies. So I guess my question to you is based on that. Is it worth us taking the savings on the insurance or having the higher coverage limit? I'm not familiar Mrs. Kahn on where we are with regard to our self kind of our hurricane fund if I guess the better question would be what kind of flooding do we sustain in Wilma or Irma? Significantly more in. In Wilma because
142we have since raised four different campuses but we didn't get paid for Wilma or Irma. Correct. Which is why in my opinion it doesn't pay for us to spend the extra money just to keep our spending the same. Why not save some money since we typically don't collect anything on our property insurance claims and have a lower spend than last year on our insurance. That is absolutely an option to continue to purchase what you had been purchasing over the last few years all just sit like this. So that's. But if we don't collect, we don't collect and if everything is gone, everything is gone and nothing is coming back. And there's no amount of money we could collect from insurance that will ultimately replace an entire district of buildings. We could save $75,000. Yeah. Are
143you going to continue to be rude? $75,000. We saving money then. I do want to point out even if you choose the two and a half million dollar option we have improved on the named windstorm deductible from 10 million. It's going down to $5 million. So that is. So you know that that is even with the two and a half million at that premium. Just so you know. I just wanted to point that out that that is going to be an improvement over the program. Even if you whichever option you take we have negotiated that minimum deductible down to $5 million for you. Thank you. You're welcome. Any Other questions on that. So this next line of coverage is the equipment breakdown. I'm sorry, I do have a question. Of course, because there is a
144$75,000 difference between those two. But is the same money that we would spend on insurance able to be used for salaries? Yes. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Exactly. Thank you. So the equipment breakdown, it, you know, we're talking about less than $1,000 increase, and that's just due to the increase in values. Just so that for those of you who don't know, equipment breakdown, that's really covering the accidental and sudden breakdown of any type of equipment, mainly air conditioning units, your elevators, any type of electrical arcing type events would be covered under this equipment breakdown policy. And as you can see, it's got a very low deductible and low premium. This next page is your workplace violence. So this is covering, hopefully we will just put this aside and never have to use this. But this
145would include any type of active shooter events, any workplace violence of any sort, any stalking threats. And not only does this cover liability, but it also brings a plethora of resources to the district. Anything from psychological counseling for your students, families and staff and teachers should something happen, public relations, taking a look at, you know, what they can do to assist at that time. And so it's a turnkey product. And like I said, hopefully we file this away and never need it. But risk management and the district have the numbers that they need to call should an event occur. So finally this just wraps it up. And again, we're just showing one option. And if the board so wants, we can change this premium summary for the next board meeting so you can see it
146all wrapped up based on whichever options you'd like to see to have in this wrapped up premium summary. But this is the program that we would recommend should the district decide that they want to improve their coverage within the amount of insurance premium that they were spending. So I don't know if there's any questions, but this just kind of wraps up what we were talking about here. Any questions? Do you guys all want a minute to look at stuff before we close it out? I'd like you to bring back both the options of what you have here and the option of. With the two and a half million. Yeah, so really we're talking on this one and I'll bring it back in a nicer presentation format, but we're talking about $75,000 less. And then the
147other, the other option is if you wanted to go back down to the smaller crime policy without the social engineering or without, I would say, meaningful, because the retention was so high on that. And keep it at that hundred thousand if you want that to also be in there. We're talking about, you know, not. Not a big premium saves, but like you said, I mean, this money goes through the teachers, so it's about $6,000 more or less to go from one to the other. So. So you want me to keep it with the lower deductible and the additional coverage on the crime, but have an option page like this with the two and a half million for the property? I would say. Does that work for everybody? So those will be the two premium summaries
148for the presentation and for your voting at the next board meeting. Okay. And at that point, the property won't be a question mark, correct? Okay, correct. And I will tell you exactly which insurance companies we're recommending that you go with. Now that you've. We've pinpointed down to those two options, we'll go ahead and it will be. It will be finalized to the. Hopefully to the dollar. Great. Thank you. Madam Chair, may I interject? We used to get a letter that said we would get FEMA money. We used to have to have a certain amount of insurance to make sure. We would get FEMA money. So I'm just asking that question because that's. Thank you for bringing that up. So Gallagher started. It was actually with one of our large county clients. The. The Stafford act
149states that FEMA can't require you to purchase insurance more than what is deemed reasonable by the Florida Insurance Commissioner. So many years ago, we went to the state and we asked them to opine on whether or not our client's insurance program was reasonable, because what does that mean? And there's really no definition of what is reasonable. And for many years, we were able to get the Department of Emergency Management and the insurance Commissioner's office to go ahead at no Pine. Once we renewed our program, that, yes, this indeed was a reasonable insurance program based on the insurance market, the amount of money you're spending, etc. There's a lot of different things that they. That we presented to them to make that determination. And we would get a letter back from the state basically saying that
150this was a reasonable insurance program. And we felt that should there be a hurricane, that we could show these letters to FEMA and say our insurance commissioner has deemed our program reasonable and that we should get full reimbursement. A number of years ago, the state decided that they would no longer provide reasonableness. Letters. A few years ago, this ' same client did some work and met many times up in Tallahassee to try to have the state come back with a process by which you could go ahead and apply and get that determination. The gentleman who came to do it was actually from Louisiana and they actually have a very good system. I haven't looked into it recently, but it actually had broken down by type of entity, whether you're a school district or a city.
151And it actually said that what percent of your operating budget needed to be spent on these type of insurances to be considered reasonable? And what percent is that? It was, I want to say it was between depend and this was many years ago, but between the different types of entities, they were like, between like one and a half, 3.5% of the operating. So it was an interesting exercise. So we thought that they would do something similar. They did come up with an application process, but the state decided that they were not going to at least publish any parameters of what would be determined. We have for two or three years submitted this entity's insurance program and we have yet to receive a determination year after year. So most of our public entity and school district
152clients were kind of waiting for this first test to see what they got back and then go through the process. And so like I said, we've now submitted either two or three different insurance programs and we have not, we've sent follow ups, but we have not yet received, received a response. And that, you know, unfortunately leaves districts like you in this uncanny situation that we don't know if it's deemed reasonable, will be deemed reasonable or not. Charlene, I know this is a totally offended question, but do you have any idea what our operating budget is off the top of your head? It's a 310 million dollar operating budget. So we include both operations and capital when we figure the 1 to 3%. Or is it just operation? You know what I mean? Like we have
153two sides of our budget, right? We have capital projects and we have our operating expenses. So I'm wondering which half of that budget, or is it the whole budget that we're trying to figure reasonableness on? Because it doesn't make sense for us to include the whole budget. Because the whole budget, you know what I mean, it doesn't affect our property. I believe it is the actual operating budget, not the entire budget. So about half. So what would 3% of that be? 3 million ish. Right. So we're looking at 1 to 3 million. And 2 and a half actually falls right in between not of your. It's not a math right or not the property limit. It's the insurance spend for the property coverages. So you're buying a two and a half million dollar limit. They're
154not using that as a gauge to what limit you should be buying. It's a gauge as to how much you should be spending on your property insurance. Your property insurances. So let's go by that instead. What is our, what's the property spend on the. Oh, is it up here already? No. Yeah, A million. The property page. But it's, it says a line item here. It's a million two and then. So that's roughly a million two 1%. Right. One and change percent. Yeah. Okay. So again, you know, if the district wishes to go ahead and submit an application, we can assist you. We, you know, that's up to you. Most haven't wanted to until they know. That we're getting it an application. I just, if reasonable in Louisiana back. In the day was approximately, then our
155lawyer could certainly make the argument that the insurance we have is reasonable. Yeah, so that's, it's, I think, I. Think you're below that. Just, just FYI, I think you're below that number because it's 4 million, isn't it, Charlie? At point three, it's 4 million. That's the high end. So it's a big number. Yeah. 5.3 million. Dr. That's what I have too. We could take 179 million operating budget. 3% of that is 5.3 million. So we are, we would be unreasonable even at 3 million in that case. If that was the test. But you're talking about Louisiana, which is low lying, you know, older buildings. We've built everything to Cat 5. So we have a lot more going for us in terms of things that you can mitigate to make the word reasonable more reasonable. Right.
156So I don't say this test has. Anything to do with us. In fact, it doesn't. But the, the fact of having a gauge. Right. Just a gauge is what you're presenting. Right. But again, we're Cat 5 schools. Right. So we don't have the same situation as Louisa, Louisiana and that entire state because I lived there for four years below water. So you know, and again, I'll also say, and I'm happy to because I'm just complete. I don't hold me to these percentages. I'm just going off of memory from a long time ago. I'm happy to go ahead and pull and see if it's still on the Louis, Louisiana publishing and change it. Yeah, there is no, they're not using any in Florida. But I will also say talked about. Reasons reasonableness last year and come
157up with the 2.5. And so I guess I'm just trying to figure out what makes 2.5 reasonable or not reasonable this year. May I? Yes, please. You could probably just take a Percentage assessment of 66 other school districts and see how much they're spending and then just fall in line with them. I mean picking your coverage whatever way you want. But I'm thinking that most school districts will be doing what we do. So. But if you're looking for another test to back your reasonableness argument, you could look at other school districts and see what percentage they're spending here in Monroe County. Or we can see what happens to these schools that were just destroyed this year if there's going to be any funding for that or if those school districts are found to be reasonable.
158And so just on that point, that's a good point. Do those other schools have Cat 5? Right. I mean, you know, so what we call reasonable is really unique to us. Just want to make that point so. Absolutely. I'll add one more thing, just that the district, we have assisted the district over the years in obtaining appraisals and undervaluation has been a huge issue and it was a huge issue with these districts, schools that were hit up in the, you know, in the recent storms and it's causing a lot of havoc within their insurance programs. The district, we assisted the district and actually paid for some appraisals because one of the things that we do is the quality of the data. So everything is computer modeled now. So they're looking at your construction, your roof,
159all different types of information. So we hired a firm to come out and obtain not only replacement cost values but also gather those what we call secondary modifies as respects hurricane for your modeling in addition to this property program and we talked about this earlier with some of you, the district also does buy which is required by FEMA National Flood Insurance Program flood policies on these. So you also do have which also would count towards your spend. In most cases they look at both the property and hurricane as well as flood premiums that you spend. So we do also buy those for the, the most vulnerable campuses and buildings. So you have that as well. All these hurricanes that we've had, we've been talking about this letter and, and that for, for all the years
160that I've been on the board, has any district been turned down by fema because they said you didn't have enough insurance. So know of any, not because they didn't have enough insurance. And this is something that we spoke about, I don't remember was last year or the year before, but there is. When you get public assistance, you sign something for an obtain and maintain agreement. Right. So an O and M that says that you will buy insurance on these properties. So what you will get turned down for is if you don't have enough insurance and those same properties were to have damage another time, they won't pay for that building if they deem that you. You didn't buy the proper insurance. But no, we haven't had for a regular, you know, aside from second claim
161on a building. We, I, I have not personally, I seen where anybody has been turned down to date because they didn't buy a large enough limit of insurance. Just generally, again, taking aside buildings and facilities that had previous damage to them. Good. And let's not forget, there might not be a FEMA in the near future. Yeah. I'll tell you, we, you know, there are some entities that are more concerned than others in building up limits because of that and others that are keeping their same philosophy and are waiting to see what happens. But that'll have to be seen. Yeah. Thank you. Absolutely. So our next report. I feel like singing a song. Do a little dance, get down tonight. Because we have never. No, we have never had a financial audit with absolutely no findings
162in my experience. And so this is something to be really excited about. Dr. White. Well, I just. Yeah, yeah, that'd be great. First, I want to thank. I mean, I've been here a year and this could not happen without the finance team and everybody on campus and at all the schools being on the same page. There's. There's just no way. You know, I think I'm the first person that knows when audit arrives and I'm the last person to know when audit finally leaves. But, you know, we have to talk about every transaction, every PO, every invoice, every PCard transaction, whatever, you know, and I'm just really proud of the team. I love the team that I work with. And these audit results show what an awesome team that has been put together in the internal
163school accounts. We had no audit findings. And so what. Aurelis and Austin have worked together. They're working with the bookkeepers. We have. Have turnover all the time, but they've got a program with them and the athletic directors to keep addressing. You know, there were suggestions that we needed to follow, but they've already met with them and working together as a team. That's what I'm trying so hard to implement, is really good communication, really good transparency. Even if you've done something wrong, let us know it can be corrected. We just want to figure out how to not do it again. So, overall, the 10 schools did a great job and clean audit on internal school accounts. I wasn't here for the CARES act funds, but Nancy and Julie and Austin, you know, there were 43 additional
164grants, over 25 million additional dollars coming through. We have done all the reporting for it. Galen was really involved in this, too. And we have no audit findings there. That is just a huge feat. It was something the government had never done before. And just lots to be proud of. In the financial audit for 23, 24, absolutely no findings. Another clean year of an audit. So, so proud of Austin. He was so tickled. He, you know, he needed to leave and go back to Vietnam to be with family. But he made sure that we completed this application for the 11th year in a row. So many congrats to that. That takes the entire team, the entire group. I could name everybody by name, help take care of them, but we did have a, you know,
165then, you know, you're just. You're so extremely proud. You get. You get another certificate in the mail that it's related to, you know, and I had never really been around the. The bonds and the things that we. The tans and things like that. But the district was just awarded a bond certificate of excellence because of all the reporting that we do and compliance with all the policies and procedures. So I just have to say thank you to everyone because this job is. Nobody's job, is an easy job, but there are a lot of policies and procedures to follow. And I try to tell everyone. I don't want finance to be a barrier. I want us to be a resource for everybody. And so that's why through budget, we're going to carry that through budget, we're
166carrying that through POS and so, you know, just please thank the team when you see them. And a lot to be proud of. This district has a lot to be proud of. Thank you for all the work that you and your team did and for incredible results. It's great when we have somebody who in their first year gets those results. Even though we know that some of your team has been very much a part of and here previously, it's still just absolutely fabulous news. Well, thank you. And it's, you know, it's been tough learning and going From Tennessee to Florida. It's a big adjustment. But I do have to say this. The superintendent, one of the first things she said to me was, we've never had audit findings, and we don't want any more audit
167findings. So it was. It's a real goal of the entire district. So thank you all. Thank you. I think we're up to reports include. That concludes our reports. Well, your report now, right? Oh, okay. Or legal can go first. Yeah, it's legal. I've already spoken to y'all. Everything's fine. So I'm sure you're all concerned about immigration enforcement as we are. So I've been speaking to Dennis Ward regularly, and we spoke the morning. And so we have in our student code of conduct a policy in place for people who come to the schools and the procedures that have to be followed. And so Dennis and I went over those this morning, and he agrees that that's where we need to keep things right now with our local school procedure. So Amber and I are working on
168getting messaging out to the schools just to remind them of what those procedures are and to give them some talking points should immigration come to the schools to interview students or whatever. Dennis said that he thought mostly people were going to be picked up right now who were criminals or were on a list. And so he didn't anticipate that the schools were going to be entered, but we've got to be prepared should that happen. So he's spoken to Immigration and Border Patrol, and he's staying on top of it. He asked us to make sure the SROs were aware of these procedures so that they could assist in the office should someone come in to speak to students. So I'm going to continue to stay in touch with him so that we can just stay abreast
169of everything as it rolls along. And he's been very supportive, the schools and of staying in touch with us. So I think that's really good. As far as other things that are happening. You know, it's Celebrate Literacy Week, so it's a really exciting time in the schools, but also the students in the upper Keys in first and second grade saw Peter and the Wolf last week on the 23rd of January, and it was just an absolutely amazing performance. And we met with a. Had a reception following the performance and met with Upper Keys parents who were interested in continuing to support the symphony program in the schools. So it was a successful day, however you look at it. And this week we've had puppy pals for third and fourth grades, and we had One performance
170yesterday at Tennessee Williams and it's just beyond. You just can't express how the kids, how much they enjoy it. And people have to leave the room because they get so excited, the screams are so loud. And so. But they do. It's an educational. You know, they talk about the five Ps, practice, persistence, patience, positive attitude. The last P is P fun. So it's 45 minutes of absolute engagement. And they invite the parents to come in the evening. So Tennessee Williams Theater was full with parents and students last night as well. And they're coming here tonight to Marathon. So Puppy Pals extends that invitation to free for all employees of Monroe County. And it was, it's wonderful. I love kids and dogs. So for me it's, you couldn't have anything better to do. And so on
171your table in front of you. As you know, I attended the legislative session here in Monroe county with Ana Maria Rodriguez and with our own Jim Mooney and all the other agencies in the Keys. But I Talked about our 14 million dollar request from the legislature. And so I worked with Amber and Charlene the last two days and we've completed a local funding initiative request for both the Senate and the house for $14 million. And so I'm sending these, you know, you know, I sent a Christmas ornament to every legislator letting them know what we need here in Monroe County. Now we're sending this for Valentine's. And the purpose is to keep our case out in front of the legislators so that when they see that request, they will understand what is all about. And
172you know, this flyer clearly delineates the complicated process of restoring Reynolds to move to or restoring Bruce hall to move so that Reynolds has to come first, then Bruce hall and then 150 units. Affordable housing. But it's a mouthful. So this really explains all of it. And Mrs. Ashford. So there is a bill up that says that excess property must be. The state can say you have excess property and you must turn it into affordable housing. So, you know, we're identifying the, the excess and we're trying to do that. And you know, so that anyone who votes for that should also vote for this. That might be our avenue this year. Dr. Woltanski, I've been talking to T.C. wolf and Senator Renee Garcia and throughout the state, this initiative is getting a lot of attention
173because we're kind of out there pushing it. And it's highly desirable to use available lands within a school district for affordable housing if there is the need that we have. So, I mean, we're really moving along with this. And, you know, I'm excited to try again to get this $14 million allocation. So this is Celebrate Literacy Week. I sent you my letter that I wrote for the UNESCO Creative City of Literature. It's a category that Mayor Henriques is doing for the city of Key West. It's quite remarkable. And so this is the United Nations Education, Scientific and Cultural Organization. That's what UNESCO is. And Mayor Henriques is. It's a tremendous initiative. And also Holly Reichstein is working on it. So our historical and cultural institutions and other community organizations are all united behind this. But
174the idea behind it is if we become a city of literature, it's going to bring international travel festivals and events and things like that. And those are things that our students can be involved in. So it would be great not only for the city, but for the schools as well. So I'm excited about that and pursuing the area that you are interested in, and so am I and that we talked about earlier tonight. I am meeting with the TDC on January 30th to go over the grant application and to find out what we need to do. And that's how we're going to fill out that 4.5 million that we need for rec. Sweet. So we hope that happens. Anyway, so that's it. Thank you. Board reports. John. You know, today I was reading in one
175school, and the book they had for me to read was about Ferris, the fellow that invented the Ferris wheel. And so I asked the students when we saw what, you know, what the book was about. And I asked them, said how many of them had been on the Ferris wheel? And almost every student raised their hand. Then I said, anybody ever get stuck on the Ferris wheel? One young man raised his hand. I said, how long were you stuck? He said, three hours. Wow. You got stuck for three hours. So we had a little chat about. That and how it handled it and whatnot. But it was. He was the star of the show for a while, you know, stuck up on the top for three hours. Wow. Anyway, but it's fun reading in the
176schools. I enjoyed it and it was good. But that's it. Thank you. Yeah. I also want to thank everyone who invited me to read. I'm reading at two more schools the rest of the week, but I've been to three so far. It's always fun. And that's how I got to see the field that kls. They're waiting on the dugouts. The roofing for the dugouts is the only thing that hasn't come in yet, but, you know, we put grass on that field and it mostly looks good. There's a few places that are challenges, but it is very, very nice. They don't have their bleachers in yet, but like I said, yeah, it looks really good. And so that was a, you know, project by Ajax and that the community has been asking for for a long
177time. Yeah, it was. It was Ajax. I also got to go to Ms. Mrs. Axford and I presented about the schools at the Business and professional Women's Organization. And it was a really great presentation. But one of the things I let them know is that, I mean, I think we all know, but Mrs. Axford has 40 years in education. She is the first female superintendent of Monroe county. She's currently one of only 14 women leading school districts. And she is now, because of all the turmoil, one of the longest serving superintendents in the state. And I think, you know, we're lucky to have her. And she got lots of applause, I'm going to just say, every time I would say, and she's the first viewer. Whoa. You know, that was all it was. It was.
178We knew our audience, let's just say the business and professional women. But I'm disappointed that the superintendent evaluation has not been done yet. I asked Maria to send me the evaluations that were in. You know, three board members evaluated Mrs. Axford in September at the time that we were asked to, and each of those evaluations by board members had recommendations of things that they thought she could do that would be better that they wanted her to work on this year. And now we are five or almost six months past that. And now it's almost like she's so close to. To being done that it seems like, you know, it's, you know, we should proceed with those evaluations as they were submitted and just move forward. I mean, Yvette cannot evaluate her because it was for
179the previous year and a majority of the board has evaluated her. And I think we should. We should make that public to the community and just move on because I, you know, the evaluation was done. It wasn't completed by the whole board, but it was done. And I would. I move that we make those evaluations public today and that we can decide next week if we want to act or the next board meeting if we want to act on that. But, you know, or if we want to make any suggestions moving forward. But I would make a motion that we make those public, that that's the evaluation and, you know, and that we don't end Mrs. Axford's career with either no evaluation or. Or she should have. You know, the evaluation was for the previous
180year. And I think at this point, nobody, anyone who has not yet completed their evaluation cannot evaluate her on what she did up until September. As somebody that did do the evaluation, I agree. Put it out. So I will say I am one of the people that did not do the evaluation. Evaluation. I believe it's two and two. And one of the reasons my evaluation wasn't complete, and I guess you're not aware of this, is that last year's evaluation part of my issue was the way the superintendent evaluated her executive team. So my evaluation was partially going to be related to how this year's evaluation of the executive team went. That just got completed. I now have all of the documents and now I feel completely informed in a way to finish the evaluation. But
181when did they. About when do the executives get evaluated? They just got evaluated. Okay, so then that should not go in the September evaluation. The evaluation was for September last year. It should have been last year's evaluation, same time. The point being the three of us. It was three of you have a value. Three board members from that board evaluated the superintendent. It was Andy. And now we don't have Andy here anymore. Yvette cannot evaluate the superintendent on a time where she wasn't here. But the evaluation was supposed to be for the previous year. And so evaluating her now on the way she evaluated people five months later is not appropriate. It's for the previous year's evaluation. We're all talking about the same year of 2024. But if the evaluation was not available by September,
182then it was not part. Of the evaluation and it was told it was coming. It's here and now. I feel equipped to evaluate. And just because my evidence opinion is different doesn't make my opinion wrong. So now I am happy to evaluate. If you wish to go ahead with just your evaluation. No, I want to make the motion. That. I'm going to make a motion that we proceed with the evaluation from last September and. And that we move on from there. You don't have it on the agenda, so no motion have to be to add for cause. But this isn't something you need to have a vote on. You just have it on the next agenda and that you vote on the next agenda. Because right now it's kind of messy that this comes up
183during a report. Just should be the beginning of the meeting at the best. And then. But this is just direction to staff. And if all of you agree that it needs to be done in the next meeting and we'll have it on there, you know, and, and the chair and the superintendent set the agenda so, you know, we can all know if that's what you want to do. We just know right now. I am fine with having it on the next agenda. Okay, Mr. Haran. On a lighter note, I was able to attend the Marathon middle school soccer game against Basilica, my first time coming up here to watch the girls soccer team play. And I will tell you that if the middle school is a sign of what Marathon has to offer in the
184future, God help anybody playing them because those girls were tough and they are very good for their age. And I commend them on a will flop and a well deserved victory over Basilica. Yvette? Yep. I just want to say I had the first time as a school board member participating in Literacy Week and it was such an enjoyable experience. I was a little intimidated when I arrived and found out I was ready to fifth graders. I had anticipated these tiny little children are going to ooh and ahh everything I had to say, but these fifth graders were fantastic. They had such great contributions to the story and I thoroughly enjoyed it and I look forward. I wasn't sure to live today and that was fantastic, but I look forward to participating tomorrow. Gerald Adams. Great
185experience. Anyone who has the opportunity should most definitely participate. So I too had the opportunity to read during Literacy Week and I repeat this every year, but it really is my favorite time of year because I really feel like at this level on the school board, we don't get enough interaction with the kids. So it really is my favorite time. I offer to read any time of year because I love being in the classroom. So that was terrific. And I actually last night got to sit with one of our other school board members who was also in the theater and we saw Pop Pals and it was, it was just great to hear the kids go nuts. And these aren't kids in a classroom. But they were still yelling and screaming. The, the dogs were
186terrific. The show was fabulous. I had a chance to talk to a gentleman who's putting it on in the middle and upper keys and he had thanked Christina and Terry for their work in getting this here. And so it was just an overall incredible evening. Everybody had a great time. They let the kids up afterwards to take pictures with the dogs and pet them. Somebody else's little girl wanted to take one home. But it really just was a fabulous evening. And, and I love that Mrs. Axford brings a variety of programs to the keys from music to art to puppy pals. She does a lot of work in this area. Back when she was a principal, we talked about what a lot of our keys kids miss out on being on an island. And so
187bringing these programs here is really a big deal because for a lot of kids, it's their first and only opportunity to see some of these things. So a shout out for that. And I hope that we continue to bring those types of programs here because they're all very wonderful. So thank you. If there's no other board reports pending is affordable housing. We did actually sort of discuss that at our meeting. You had mentioned that one of the board members was looking at parking under the buildings, so perhaps that's something else we might want to put in the rfp. Yeah. Preference would be for parking underneath the buildings. It makes a lot of sense. And if they can't, let them tell us why. But let's at least have it in there, please. So, yeah, that's. You're
188gonna have plenty of opportunities next meeting to give feedback on the. On the rfp. You know, I didn't mention. Since we're on this affordable housing, I texted the commissioner today. And so he's still in full support of us and that 14 million request, and he said that he is going to do whatever he can do in Tallahassee to start moving that along. So, once again, you know, the commissioner understands what we're doing fully and he has offered his support. Real quick, Pat, was there anything with regard to height restrictions that close to the base? That's what we're gonna have to look at. I mean, it'll just come at an additional cost and we'll have to look at where the. I don't know that it'll be a base restriction or a city restriction, but that. That's
189clearly the concern. We can look at it, though. Okay. Going to recess our meeting and open the public hearing. So we're presenting a first reading for policies and operations and planning in internal services, in student support services and curriculum. Oh, no, sorry. That's. The first reading is just operations and planning and internal services. These are things that are NEOLA recommended. And of course, you know, the one which is an interesting topic tonight, Federal grants funds, self certification, you know, that's that $10,000 to $50,000 limit that we're changing. But as you know, based on the president's executive order order that we just got this morning, there is a moratorium on using any federal funds. So we have to. We're getting. As we sit Here tonight, orders from the state and from everybody about how to handle
190this. So I know Dr. White is thinking about it a lot. And fortunately our Payroll for the 30th, for the 15th is in place, correct? Yes, ma'am. It hit the books today. So you were supposed to stop spending by 5pm today and it hit the books. But part of this concern is that in federal programs there are a lot of salaries. So, you know, everything is put on hold. Now it's a. We hope it's a very temporary hold, but nevertheless, that was a big executive order that we got today, Madam Chair. Yeah, I just sent to everybody that a court, not sure which one, just granted a temporary injunction on the president's executive order. So we've gonna get a little breathing room. I don't know how long they're gonna give them. I haven't read the
191order yet, but it just came down while we're sitting in the meeting. I sent it to everybody. Thank you. So. Yep. Charlene, don't worry for now. Well, it has very far reaching effects, especially on an agency like a school district. Would you mind giving me an example or two of employees we have that are federally funded? Well, it. In the budget start. Yeah, Head start. Okay. Any. All the titles. Okay. Yeah. School lunch. School lunch, Yeah. A big one. Okay. So we'll keep you posted on that for sure. And then can I ask, I want. To discuss for a second the policy 131 policy making. The first part of that, where the superintendent publishes the notice of development of a proposed policy before providing notice of a proposed policy, meaning that. And then the board
192can hold workshops on those policies if they desire or anyone can before they come to us for first read. I think we skip that step. And I don't think that step would add a lot of extra time because what I'm saying right now would be said at the workshop. And then we wouldn't be wordsmithing policies on the dais. We would do it in. It would give us the list of the policies. We would read them if there's things we want to discuss. We would do that in a workshop. And then when it came to the board meetings, it would be policy readings in the public hearing and we would not be wordsmithing. We would just be listening to what the community would say. So I think we're missing that step. And I think we should
193be doing that step because we spent like the last time, you know, sometimes on second read we're trying to change the language, but the language should be set when we present it to the public. So let me paraphrase that, Dr. Woltanski. In a workshop, you would like to have a list of policies or you would like to have them preceding that workshop, and then during the workshop, review the policies. Yeah. You would say, we're going to look at these proposals, or NEOLA is working, looking at these proposals. And then you would give us, you know, for the workshop, just like we now just read all the first reads. Yes. You know, and we would discuss whether it could also be we want to create a policy of our own, like we did with the drug
194testing. All that happens in workshop. And once we come to the language that we want, which is almost always going to be what NEOLA did, then it comes to, that's what our policy says we're supposed to be doing. Then it comes to first read and second read in. And you believe that that workshopping would create less conversation here at the board. Our discussion would be at the workshop with the pol set the policy. We wouldn't be setting the policy after we had presented it to the public as what our policy is. I can certainly work that in. So, yeah, what we discussed too is that you send out the notice and send out the policies for workshop. If nobody has any questions about them, about the notice, then just move them, then you don't have
195to. You see, what I'm saying is like, unless somebody else requests, putting out the notice gives everybody an opportunity. But if no one on the board cares to comment on it and it goes through all of them, then we don't need to have the workshop. You would only just pull out the ones you want to talk about. Right. So if there's 10 and we only want to talk about one, the, the notice went out and we only need to deal with one. And if nobody has any issues, we just pull the workshop items off. I think that's what we discuss as a matter because, you know, you don't have to sit through a workshop for everything you agree upon. So then are we not doing first readings? Because it was my understanding the first reading,
196that was the point of the first reading. You've been doing it first reading, second reading. And I don't really have a problem with the way we were doing it. I know the policy reads a different way, but I don't think we were in any way outside the law. We gave plenty of opportunity to tweak these things, so I'm not concerned about that. But the strict reading of this policy is that publish a notice before you take it to first hearing, and then assuming nobody wants it during a workshop, then you don't even need to. Right. You publish a notice, and if somebody wants to talk to it, they can pick which one or all of them or whatever. But in an effort to save time, I think that's the best way to do it. If
197nobody cares about it, don't put it on the workshop. So unless a member of the public or one of you wants to talk. About it, needs to be right. Yeah. After the notice goes out, then it's put on for a workshop. And then if it's not, no need, go right to first reading. It before it comes for a first reading. Yeah, that's what he's saying. Yeah. Right. What the idea is put out the notice. If none of you care and no one from the public cares, then we go straight to first read. So in essence, we're not creating more work unless there's discussions that needs to be had. And rather than do that in a first reading, where if you change it, you got to first read it again anyway. Right. So it's kind of
198a way to avoid doing two first readings by having it on. And then if you don't have an issue, then it just goes through first and second reading. Okay. So what I'm saying is it might have result a little bit of more work, maybe not at all. That's all I have to say about that. We can try it and see how it goes. But there it also. It is. Sometimes we get those things from Neola and it says pick one or pick the other. And, you know, we could give input on or learn why it's. We picked one and not the other. So, Dr. Woltanski, I'll be mindful of organizing it that way. Thank you. Thank you, Dirk. And then we've got second reading here for student support services. Did we vote on first readings?
199Oh, that's right. I'm sorry. God, yeah. I'm sorry. I took two Benadryl. Yeah. And so some on curriculum and student services that you've already seen, that is the second reading. Also on human resources and in finance and performance, and these policies were those suggestions and updates from neola. And we have a first reading for the district superintendent and a first reading. These are job descriptions for the Threat management and Harm Prevention coordinator. This person is already in place. These updates are related to state requirements for that position going forward. There's also a first reading for the Coordinator of Reading and Language Arts, which is an update as well, a first reading for the Director of Instructional resources because AVID has been added to that position. And lastly the Director of Assessment and Accountability. All of
200these positions are in place. The job descriptions have been updated based on requirements for the position. Can we go back to second read evaluation of the appointed superintendent? We don't, I mean, we can wait till the next superintendent and workshop this or talk to them about this, but we took out that the board shall annually, no later than May 1, evaluate the performance of the superintendent. And one of the reasons that's taken out is that by May 1st we don't have any of the metrics correct. So I don't want to. And it also, I'm looking here, it also says first reading on it. Not that that necessarily matters on the policy that's in there. So I think that we should think about what the time frame is like after the eight, like what are the
201metrics that we're collecting? When are those due? We need to make sure that those all come in at around the same time and then say, you know, that no later than one month following the, you know, the release of the school grades and AP tests or something like that, whatever those, wherever those metrics are so that there's flexibility time wise. But when we have the metrics, we do the evaluation. So I don't know if we need, I don't want to change anything here because this is second read, but I'm. I agree it's, and it's awkward because I was aware of that may deadline, but I asked for an extension till we received the school grades and that's why we were working in September. Right. Well, it doesn't make any sense to do the evaluation that's
202based on metrics in a strategic plan if you don't have any of those data correct metrics. So maybe you let the next superintendent take care of the. That. Yeah. So I had actually asked Andrea about that and she was saying that we should have a policy in place for an evaluation of a superintendent prior to. Well, this, this is the policy here. But, but we don't have the date thing in there. So we, we have to be ourselves aware of when that data comes in and when those evaluations. It says annually is what it says. So that concludes the first readings of policies and second readings of policies and the job descriptions. Mrs. Cohen. So now we are going to reconvene the meeting and begin with our action items. So action item number one, I
203recommend that we accept the annual financial report. So moved. So by the way, I was at a conference that had to do with Governance. And you can have more than one second. You can. Only one person moves it. But if everyone loves this. This thing, they could all except for you. You're not allowed to second, but everyone could second it. And I'm not saying necessarily, but in situations you are not limited to whoever speaks on the microphone first. Can I be the first second though? The second. Second the second. Second motion by Dr. Woltanski. Second by Mr. Dick. Any further discussion? Any no votes. Hearing none. The motion passes. Congratulations again. Action item 2 approve. I recommend approval of the budget summary reports for November 2024. I'll move approval. Second motion by Mr. Dick. Second
204by Mr. Haran. Discussion. So this was something that Andy really wanted on our action item. I guess my question to the board is whether or not you want to continue having this on action or put it on consent and then if we want to move it to action because there's something about it that requires that movement do so. I believe it's in a policy. So we would have to. Yeah, I believe it's in a policy. It was put in a policy when the. The. As long as the general fund balance is a certain level, we get these every. On the Shouldn't. Oh, you're saying. I'm pretty sure it's in. Yeah. It's brought forward. Randy himself actually requested. Well, we should. Let's check the policies. I'm not. I'm okay with it being either place, but I.
205My understanding was a policy had been written about it. Time. Thank you. We can move on though since there are no no votes. Action item number three. I recommend approval of the board policy in student support services. So moved. Second motion by Dr. Watansky. Second by Mrs. Talbot. Any discussion? Any no votes Hearing none. The motion passes. Action item number four. I recommend of the. I recommend approval of the board policies, revisions and curriculum. So moved. I'll second. Motion by Dr. Woltanski. Second by Mr. Dick. Any discussion? Any no votes Hearing none. The motion passes. Action item number five. I recommend approval of the board policies the revisions in human resources as presented. So moved. I'll second. Motion by Dr. Woltanski. Second by Mr. Dick. Any discussion? Any no votes Hearing none. The motion passes.
206Action item 6. I recommend approval of the board policy revisions in finance and performance as presented. I'll move. Second motion by Mr. Dick. Second by Mrs. Talbot. Any discussion? Any no votes Hearing none. The motion passes. Action item 7. I recommend approval of travel requests by school board members. I'll move approval. How about a second, Darren? I was going to third second well. It'S her request so yeah. Second motion by Mr. Dick. Second by Mr. Haran. Any discussion any no votes? Hearing none. The motion passes. Action item number 8. I recommend recommend acceptance of the superintendent search timeline. So moved. Second motion by Dr. Woltanski. Second by Mrs. Talbot. Any discussion any no votes? Hearing none. The motion passes. And action item number nine, I recommend acceptance of the superintendent search survey. Move. Second motion
207by Mr. Horan. Second by Dr. Waltanski. Any discussion yeah do we have is it FSBA that's setting up the plan for how we're going to push out the survey do or are you guys I think she they did ask a question about using texting and it's going. To go out every means possible that we have to use whether it's phone messaging, website pushes, all of those, you know avenues will be utilized. Any no votes Hearing none. The motion passes. This meeting is adjourned.