CorpusRecord 177700

School Board Meeting @ KW 02-11-2025 @ 4:30 pm - Feb 11, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Granicus / MONROE
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Monroe County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,845 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001We're heading into our closed session for safety and security. [CLOSED SESSION] We're going to go ahead and get ready for the workshop. So, Mrs. Conn, I want to start our. Are we ready, everybody? Our 4:45 discussion here of the rebid process for Trumbo affordable housing. And first off, I spoke to him today. I want to say thank you to Hunter O'Connor for his outstanding work on this RFP, especially for including Mrs. Talbott's interest in parking under the building as part of this art rfp. And so is there board feedback on. Has everybody had an opportunity to read it? And Mrs. Conn, maybe you can call for feedback on from the different board members. Dr. Woltanski? I think it looks good. I don't have any concerns. I'm excited. Excited to get it going again. Mr. Horan?

002Good to go. Ms. Talbott, ready to move forward? Mr. Dick? Okay, let's move forward. I'm fine with the phase one and the phase two, but if somebody wants to do it all at once, I certainly wouldn't object to that. So Hunter's with us today and Mr. LeFere's with us as well. Is there any way that we can state that in it, Hunter? Yeah, I think the main reason it was broken up like that is because phase two is talking about the development of the administration building, which I don't believe the board has an exact timeline. As to when, you know, that building. Will be vacated and be available for development. So I think that's kind of what the main reason why it's split up like that. Okay. And because it's a request for proposal, if

003somebody wants to propose something different, they certainly can, correct? Sure, yeah, I can. I'll double check the language in there and, you know, make sure it reflects that. And Hunter, we talked today, you and I, about the time frame for posting the RFP on our new system. Were you able to get an answer about that? Yeah. So when this was originally posted the first time around, it was out there. For about two months. You know, looking at the board's policies, you know, the statute, I don't see any minimum timeline that it has to be out there for, you know, but. Given the scope of this project, I would say, you know, probably 45 days at the minimum order to, you know, give everybody sufficient time to put a good proposal together. You know, given that

004they want, you know, it calls for, you know, design documents and things of that sort. Does the board have any recommendations about that? 45 minimum 60, possibly. Anybody, 60 days. Can we do 60 days, Hunter. Certainly. Alrighty, so 60 it is. And I think that's what's stated in the RFP right now in the timeline. Am I correct, Hunter? Yeah, let me scroll down to that real quick. Remind me what the date for the lot is again. When do we get that back? Which date now? Oh, the abrogation lot. That is summer 2026, I believe. Okay, so one more year. Thanks. Yep. And yeah, so the current timeline contemplates a release date of tomorrow, February 12th. And a due date of April 2nd So we can adjust that out a. Bit more to be 60 days.

005Thank you. All righty, so tomorrow then. It will be posted. Thank you so much. Thank you, Hunter. Once again, anytime. So, Mrs. Conn, we have five minutes before the regular meeting begins. It's time approximate. So let's open the regular business meeting. And do we have someone for the pledge? Mrs. Rebecca Palomino, will you lead us in the pledge, please? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Mrs. Conn, I have one correction to the agenda, and that is to remove item 11, which is the roofing repairs for Poinciana Elementary. And it's not that we. That somebody has waved a magic wand and we don't have to do them, but it's a new

006contractor that we're dealing with, and so they were not able to get in all their paperwork in the time frame necessary to present those contracts to the board. So we will revisit this, but tonight, we're going to remove that from the consent agenda. Can I get a motion to amend the agenda to remove consent item number 11? Move. I'll second. Motion by Mr. Horan. Second by Mr. Dick. Any discussion? Any no votes? Hearing? None. The motion passes. Thank you very much. And I recommend approval of the January 28th school board minutes as presented. So moved. I'll second. Motion by Mrs. Talbott. Second by Mr. Dick. Any discussion? Any no votes? Hearing None. The motion passes. And gems. So we're going to move on now to an amazing GEMS presentation and then some other recognitions this

007evening as well. Thank you, Superintendent. If you and Chair Conn will join me down here for our gems presentation, I'd like to first call up Mr. Jack Bridger from Key West High School. So, Jack Bridger has accomplished a phenomenal feat, not once, but twice. He has scored a perfect math score on his psat, not just this year, but he did so last year, which is Absolutely amazing. In addition to his prowess in the classroom, he is a leader in school. He's a quiet leader and he spent a lot of time focusing on his academics as evident of his weighted 4.34 GPA, which includes a lot of Advanced placement classes for a sophomore, including advanced Pre calc, which I'm not sure even I could do these days. So as a sophomore he is always looking to

008explore and learn more. This summary has his sights set on attending special sessions on economics for leaders and program in mathematics for young scientists. As he likes the STEM field, he leads with quiet confidence on the school campus. He was a founder of Reviving the Chess Club and his classmates really enjoy not only his academic outstanding academic accomplishments, but the accomplishments that he does on a daily basis as a classmate and overall the contributions to his school. So for all the great educational moments that Jack has created, especially Those Wow. Perfect PSATs, which by the way puts him in the top.07% of all students taking the PSAT. We want to award him with this gems. Congratulations, Jack. [APPLAUSE] And next we have special recognition. Key West High has accomplished an amazing thing and I'd like

009to call up Andy Martinez from the Cognia Group along with Principal Rebecca Palomino to join the chair and Superintendent Lieutenant Axford for this amazing presentation. [APPLAUSE] Good afternoon everyone. Good afternoon. Distinguished board, Superintendent Axford, Principal Palomino and community members. Congratulations on this wonderful accomplishment. I am honored to be here with all of you to celebrate this momentous occasion. Cognia is very proud of the wonderful partnership it has with Monroe County Public Schools dating back to 1924 when Key West High School received accreditation for the very first time. I'm here to present the 100 year milestone award. This award is presented to schools that have had a continuing accreditation for an entire century. We applaud and celebrate your 100 year commitment to your learners, to your community, and to the continuous improvement that you are undergoing.

010And we would also like to mention that the system's commitment to continuous improvement extended in 2014 as well when Cognia first introduced System accreditation. And in that year when Cognia introduced the system accreditation, Monroe county also became an accredited district. On top of becoming an accredited district in 2024, Monroe county also became a Cognia STEM certified school district. Incredible accomplishment. As you may know, accreditation from Cogna is a valuable mark of distinction recognized around the country and around the globe. Cognia, this year we are celebrating our 130th year of existence and we are now in 95 countries around the world. Cognia accreditation is not a checklist or a quick endeavor. Accreditation is a continuous improvement journey. That Key West High School began their journey last year, but it is not an easy one. It is

011a rigorous external audit of all of their systems and procedures and they started well, advanced well in advance of the time they spent putting it together. So it's a hats off to all of the individuals, the staff, the board, specifically the teachers at the school which I had the pleasure of speaking to earlier today because we know that nothing happens without them in the classroom. So it's incredible. Hats off to all of these accomplishments again as this great accomplishment emphasizes the importance of the student first approach and collaborative leadership skills of the entire board and your leadership team. During Monroe County School District's most recent accreditation review which happened this past year in 2024, the evaluation team identified noteworthy practices that reflect significant areas of strength in the institution's works. Although there are many and

012numerous examples of the institution's level of quality, the recognition of noteworthy practices reflects the one that truly stood out. Noteworthy practice that stood out for Monroe county schools was your take. Stock in children approach program helps learners strive towards individual achievement and self efficacy. The systems program implementation has resulted in over 1000 scholarships and over 750 college graduates. I am humbled and honored to be here to present this 100 year milestone award on behalf of Cognia, which is the largest school accreditation and improvement organization in the world. So again, congratulations to the school board member, the schools, the teachers, the entire community of Key West High School. This is an incredible accomplishment and we truly say congratulations to all of you. [APPLAUSE] Thank you. Thank you so much for doing the double tv. Of course,

013it's my pleasure. And now I have the distinct honor of calling up Captain Beth Rogoli and her team, along with asking Ms. Palomino to step on up, Mr. Trevor Tyler, Mr. Brian DeSalitz to come up for a special presentation for our Purple Star schools. Hi, how are you doing? Good. All right. Good afternoon. It is my honor today to present the Purple Star School campus flags to three of our Monroe county schools. HOB, Sugarloaf and Key West High School. These schools are among 176 schools in Florida that have earned the Purple Star School of distinguished distinction through the 2027 school year. The Purple Star program acknowledges those schools that support our military families. And while the service members make sacrifices when they deploy away from their families, those families also make significant sacrifices at the

014same time. So we like to recognize and honor those schools that are vital in supporting our children of our military families. So I, along with the Executive officer, Commander Steve Smith, as well as the Command Master Chief Josh Joiner, are honored to be able to present these schools with these awards. [APPLAUSE] Captain Rigoli, we're going to have you back again because we want to become a Purple Star district and we don't want to forget that our school, Sigsbee School, has already received that Purple Star designation. I see the principal back there. We're now going to move on to citizen input. Do we have anyone signed up? Yes, we do. We have Mr. Ralph Henriquez requesting three minutes. Thank you. Ralph Enrique's 3613 Northside Court. Good evening board members. I would like to begin by expressing

015my gratitude for your support of the Rex Weech project. A special thank goes to Ed and Joan Knight foundation along with Claude Gardner. Their generous donation will help cover the cost of our professionally designed trained hitting center which will be named the Ed and Joan Knight Foundation Training Center. I also want to acknowledge Bill Horn, a local design architect who is collaborating with MSG Group from Ohio as a consultant. MSG has an impressive track record in designing batting cages, concessions, trophy rooms for colleges and professional teams. Together, Bill Horn and MSG will deliver a world class facility for our current players and future athletes. The baseball community is incredibly excited about this project as I have shared this information with many and many of our future players and parents. Our Little league program recently held

016its opening day ceremony this past Saturday boasting an incredible 560 players participating in baseball. This highlights the significance of baseball in our community. As a coach, we have started this discussion on Rexwich Field dating back to 1995. And I thank you that we are getting to the finish line with this project and it has been, you know, great working with our team, our board members, in getting this project done. So I thank you wholeheartedly. However, I must address a concerning situation with the outfield at Tommy Roberts. The condition is problematic for everyone, not just baseball. Last month in January, we experienced 1.5 inches of rain which resulted in a loss of six practice days for the team, preventing them from taking batting practice, defensive drills and being able to do communication drills which prevents safety.

017During this period when we were not practicing all the fields along Kennedy Drive, Poinciana School, George Myra Facility were fully operational. After waiting this time and years of seeing and being proud of this complex, I cannot wonder how is this happening to a $21 million facility. A couple of weeks ago, a group of soccer representatives visited the stadium to discuss the possibility of bringing a professional team to play soccer in an exhibition game in Key West. They walked up and asked, can we examine the field? Of course. They quickly left, stating that conditions were unacceptable for play. Prior to that visit, a supervisor from Brightview commented that the field was poorly graded and suggested that the only solution would be to tear it up. She also recommended considering artificial turf due to the tropical conditions

018we experience. With this frustration. Last week I consulted a professional sodmaster who echoed similar concerns, adding that the current SOD has little to no root system and that the ground is so hard and compacted that the water has nowhere to drain. He likened it as an example as to laying sod on a parking lot. When this field was being prepared, a 5050 sand mix was used. A 5050 sand mix is a lot of materials torn up from roads mixed with sand and then they use it to lay in preparing the field before the sod is put on top of this sometimes backfires and in this case it greatly backfired and the surface where the grass is the sod is it's hard as concrete. That's why it goes the ball rolls so fast. It rolls all

019over the place and we have tried, and credit to you, we have tried aerating the field, putting holes in the field, putting sand, and this was done in December and here we are in February and the same holes remain and the same sand remains. After three or four days those holes and sand should not be visible, but they still do and sand flies up in the air when balls roll. He also commented that it is compacted too late and this prevents the roots from growing and you have nothing there. We see it every day. The grass does not grow when it is cut. There's no blades of grass being laid out. I sincerely hope that Rexwich Field does not experience any rains during midweek as cancellation of a weekend series would be significantly a disaster

020for us in many ways. Not only do we lose revenue, but more importantly we prevent kids from playing a game they love this weekend. Rex Huich Field was awesome. It was full of people, young kids wearing conch baseball jerseys. It was awesome. The time has come, I feel to make a decision to resode with the appropriate materials, install drainage systems, regrade the field and Engage in professional companies experienced in athletic fields, or invest in quality artificial turf that won't harm our children. Once again, you know, this is our showcase. A big part of our community. We have spent tremendous dollars in this project, and we need to get it right. And I hope and pray that we could come up with some kind of solution to make this be right for our community, for our

021kids and the dollars that were spent in this project with the companies that we used. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you. Do we have any other speakers? Thank you. So, moving on to the consent agenda. Right? Yes. Thank you, Mrs. Conn. All items listed as consent agenda items are considered routine and non controversial by the board and will be approved by a single motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items prior to this meeting. Board members have had an opportunity to review each and may request that an item be moved. And as we discussed earlier, the only change to the consent agenda is the removal of the roof repairs for Poinciana, which will appear at a later date. I recommend approval of the consent agenda as amended. So moved. Seconded.

022Motion by Dr. Woltanski. Madam Chair. I'm sorry, just. Is that out of county? Field trip. I wanted to make sure. Or is that on action? It's on action. Okay, never mind. Motion by Dr. Woltanski. Second by Ms. Talbott. Any discussion? Any? No votes? Hearing? None. The motion passes with the amended agenda. And we go on to our reports. Mrs. Conn and I just want to say prior to this report that it's been in the hands of Jennifer Barrios for a few years now. And as everybody knows, the calendar committee can be extremely contentious. But with her skillful handling of the committee and her involvement of so many people, we have a successful draft calendar for 25, 26 and a draft calendar for 26, 27. And Mrs. Barrios is going to go over those calendars with

023you now. Good evening, board members. Superintendent Axford. Tonight I'm here to talk with you about the school calendar review and the 25, 26, 26, 27 school year draft calendars. Are you going to introduce your guest there? I am. I'm waiting to that next slide that keeps leaving me. Yep, there we go. So, as you can see, the calendar committee was quite extensive, and we met on January 23rd at Marathon High School. And tonight I am very fortunate that I have Ms. Katie Katina with me representing the union. And she's also a parent of two students currently at Key West High School. But the calendar committee is composed of six members from the union and six members from the district, two parents on each side, and then a student representative, usually from Marathon, because that's where

024we end up meeting. We like to choose either a sophomore or junior because they have a vested stake in the calendar. So very fortunate to work with a terrific group this year. It went exceedingly well. And that is why we're very happy to present to you a couple of the draft calendars. I'm not even touching it. Maria, I'm going to let you so some of the calendar constraints that were dealt with with the state of Florida, they give us some statutes that we have to abide by. And one of the main statutes is that it says that we have to have 180 calendar days or a seat time of 900 hours for grades 4 through 12 and 720 hours for grades K through 3. We have way more hours than that. Right now we're at

025about 1,060 hours. So as you can see, we're well over the seat time. So where we may not meet the 180 student days, we have the seat time to do what we've done this past year and with our professional learning days, and I think it's been very successful. And on my next slide, I'll talk a little bit about some of the stakeholder feedback. The other constraint that we have with the statute is that Florida says you cannot start school any earlier than August 10th. So that's something that we work with. And one thing that our committee always likes to do, because it seems to be so popular with parents, teachers, students, everybody is have that midweek start. So we try to do that. And you're going to see where these two calendars that we're going

026to propose to you do meet that criteria. So last year we did something a little bit different. We did away with our six early release days, and we did three full professional learning days. We've already had one which was October 31st, and we've got one coming up Friday which is going to be February 14th, and the next one is in April, and I think it's the 16th or 17th, I'm not quite sure. But we've got three professional learning days instead of the early release. So when we brought the committee together, we needed to have stakeholder feedback. What did people say about doing this? Overwhelmingly, the parents were very happy about getting rid of the early release. They were too difficult to track. They'd forget. And overwhelmingly they were thrilled with having the three professional learning

027days. The student was very happy as well with the elimination they seem to feel that early release days weren't very productive in school, so they were happy to get rid of that as well. The teachers, the district admin that was on the committee also were very happy about elimination of that one. Professional learning, really at the end of the day, not many people want to go through three hours of professional learning after you've taught in the morning. So it was kind of hard to get that buy in. And as successful as it was, especially when we did regional professional learnings, it was a lot to ask for. So these three professional learning days have been much better use of our time, of the teacher's time, and I think overwhelmingly it's been positive. The other thing

028that it's helped with is absenteeism, which we'll kind of see this week. But we tried to target those professional learning days where they're days of high absenteeism. So if we know there's going to be high absenteeism, those were kind of the days that we looked at when we did the calendar. So some of the highlights from the 2526 calendar and to start, you already proved this in the draft version last year. So now it's just making it official. And some of the highlights is the start date midweek. Everybody loves that midweek start date. So it would be August 13th. The other, you know, fan favorite is Thanksgiving break is still a week long. Don't want to touch. Thanksgiving spring break will be March 16th through the 20th. Looking at the last day for students is

029going to be May 29th. That also seems to be something that the students, the parents, the teachers all kind of like that May end date next year. Our professional learning days are listed there. October 13th will be the end of the first nine weeks. October 10th will be our professional learning day. January 5th is the end of the semester and it's a teacher work day. February 13 will be another professional learning day. March 13 is the end of the third nine weeks. And April 17 will be a professional learning day. Quick question. January 5 is the end of the semester, but exams are still going to happen before the break? Absolutely. Okay, thank you. And that is another. I should have mentioned that. That is another thing. The testing calendars. When we do our midterms,

030all of this definitely goes in. And even the students. Please give us our midterms before break. Nobody wants to come back and do midterms. Also, special consideration is given when you see the calendars and there are versions for you all to take a look at before we bring them back for approval. Next time you all meet, which I think is February 25th. The hurricane makeup days, they are all of the professional learning days. So we've identified all of them. So that way, you know, it's very clear if we have to make up hurricane days, they are indicated on that calendar that, once approved, will be posted on the website for everyone to see. There's the two calendars. Like I said, 25, 26, you all have already approved and draft. We made no changes to that.

03126, 27 will come back to you all on February 25th to be approved in draft version next year. They'll tackle that calendar, make it official, present it to you, and then present to you 27, 28 in the draft. Any questions? Any questions for Katie? No questions. I just want to say thank you because the feedback I get from family is that not having the half days is enormous for their work schedules. And the feedback I get from teachers is they really like the full professional day. So it's great that we're able to work that out and make people happy. Yes. I think it was a win overall. Absolutely. So thank you and the team for the work that you did on the calendar. Well, thank you. Anything else? No. Well, that's great. Good night, everyone.

032Thank you. Thank you, Jennifer. So our next report, Mrs. Conn, is about our federal E Rate program. And I'm really happy to present Pat Leffere, but also our new IT director, Dr. Marlene College. And I don't know if she's been formally presented to the board, but I'm happy that she's with us tonight. Madam Chair, board members, Madam Superintendent, good afternoon. Good evening. We're coming to the school board tonight because next meeting we're going to bring to you one, maybe as many as three purchases to consider, and we're on a tight timeline to improve that because of the federal E Rate program. This is a program that we participate in every year, have been for a long, long time, that provides discounts on certain IT infrastructure and equipment. We typically see about a 70 to 80%

033discount on whatever it is we're purchasing. So that's significant. And we're just previewing these three purchases today because those at least one of those will come back to you on the 25th, if not all three of them. The filing deadline for E Rate is always very, very tight. And this year is a little bit better than last year. Last year we had to get your approval before we actually had the final numbers. This year we're going to get it the day before. So we've got a file by the 26th will bring you all the details on the 25th for approval on at least one, if not all three. So we've purchased our Internet service through E Rate for a number of years and that's kind of been our go to with regard to the E

034Rate program. We've linked the last contract for that to the board agenda, just so you can take a look at it and be familiar what we have purchased in the past or what we have brought you in the past, because it'll be likely very similar to that in the last couple of years. We've also purchased some equipment, a lot of, you may recall some of the routers and some of the switches that we've bought here in the last couple of years, which has saved us even more money. This year we'll once again be renewing our wide area network, which is shown on the slide there. That's just a renewal, so that shouldn't be too much of an issue to bring to you for approval. But we're also going to be looking at a couple potential

035new services that you can get through E Rate that I'm going to let Dr. Khalegy share with you. Thank you very much. Thank you to the board and to Mrs. Axford for the opportunity to speak to you today. So the second one is our dedicated Internet service. We have a dedicated Internet service today. That service provides our connectivity up and down the keys externally to the schools. Our wan, which is the renewal, connects all the schools. This one gives us outbound access. We're adding a second Internet connection that's going to be based up in Key Largo, which gives us a connection elsewhere out to the Internet. So we'll retain our Key west to Miami connection. And this one will be designed to be Key Largo to Tallahassee with an additional Internet connection. The managed internal

036broadband services is our opportunity through the E Rate program to have our wide area network, our access points, our wireless access points, which went into were renewed last year, really this year, finished up, as well as our 24x7 monitoring and the care and feeding of all of our switches and routers to have an additional outside vendor or company manage that for us in terms of what we like to call eyes on glass, means that someone, while we're sleeping, is watching our services. But what this program also does is provide an additional opportunity for this vendor to look at the services that we have and make sure that we're getting the best use of our technology across the entire school system. So for us, it's a real opportunity to not only manage and monitor, but to

037be able to tell us, are we using our services that serves the community and the school system the best way possible? Are there any questions on either one of those? Why do we need dedicated Internet service from Miami to Tallahassee? So the first service that we have today is from Key west to Miami and that's then out to the Internet. This is a second service that's Key Largo to Tallahassee and out to the Internet. So it balances our traffic across the entire keys as we go to the Internet. And how much will the dedicated Internet service cost us under the E Rate program? We will pay 20% of it. The other 80% is covered by the E Rate program. And we'll come back with all the contracts and all the information based on the bidders

038that we have coming in. So we'll see those bidders over the next few weeks as they come in. So right now Key Largo doesn't have good Internet service. Key Largo school because we don't have something from Key Largo to Tallahassee. Key Largo has to traverse our connection from Key Largo down to Key west and then back out. And this is an efficient way for us to provide services from basically Marathon to Key Largo, out to the Internet in a single direction versus a bi directional solution. And we've never had the managed internal broadband service before. Why are you suggesting that we get it now? Because it provides us the opportunity to. It's two reasons. One is 24, seven monitoring of all of our switches and routers up and down at every location, up and down

039the keys 24 by 7. But in addition, the second part of that is to look at our entire solution and to ensure that we're as efficient and as effective as possible in terms of our spend and what we're putting in place already and then what we plan for the future. So is that a one time thing we do? So we do that this year, they figure it all out and then we don't need to pay for it in the future. This would be a yearly contract. I mean we can certainly terminate the contract at any time. And we want to evaluate what the proposals are coming back to ensure that it's in our best interest to obtain this service. Okay, thank you so much. Any other questions? Thank you for your presentation. I want to

040ask because I still why from Key Largo to Tallahassee? Why not Key Largo to Miami? Because there's not an Internet connection today from Key Largo to Miami. We can Certainly go that route. But since we're already going from Key west to Miami, we're taking a different Internet provider to provide that service. Okay. And we'll be able to answer more specific questions if we, in fact, bring both of these new services back to you on the 25th. And if we decide, if the board decides that's not something we want to invest in, that's fine. But Dr. Kolagy has, since she's been here, brought a whole new set of eyes onto all things that we do within the school district's IT infrastructure. And she comes with an incredible amount of experience from the corporate world that she's

041been able to apply to us and make some of these recommendations. Again, not something we have to do. So we'll bring it all back to you on the 25th, at least, whatever we get a final solution on, and then we can have further conversation then. For me, it would be a question on the managed services as to whether or not they're saving us enough to make them worth paying for. And bring more details, since you all had questions on that, and more detail on the technology behind the routing and what potential flexibility we may have by doing another dedicated one. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Dr. Collegi, for being with us tonight. Thank you. Mr. Lephere, I'm going to ask you to remain where you are because you are going to talk to

042us about another topic which has everybody's interest, and it's the background of the school marquee replacement project. Right. So we've got an item on the action agenda, item number six, up for consideration tonight. It's a contract to replace the existing marquees at Key Largo, Marathon and Poinciana. Separately, last October, the board approved the purchase of the replacement panels at the Coral Shores High School marquee. That project actually started this week and should be complete this week. So we'll have our first marquee replacement. But that one was a little easier in the long run because we found a way to just replace the panels where most of these other three are, having to get completely new structures which needed a design architect, and then that had to bring back and be bid out. And there were

043just multiple hurdles for each one. And so it's been, I think, at least three years in the making with the starts and stops that we've had along the way. The. There's been a significant amount of effort to get them here. So we hope that we can get the board's approval to move forward. But we wanted to do a report on them tonight just to give you the opportunity to ask any questions that you have. So we passed this last board meeting because I had obviously some concerns with Ajax. Those concerns are going to be alleviated for the time being because I understand. The significance of the time crunch that we're into. So they can go ahead and put those marquees. I'm going to vote in favor of. Their contract, but I am withholding any. Future

044contracts with them pending a resolution of what happens at Tommy Roberts because that is still an ongoing concern for me. Well, you know, I really am perturbed that they haven't corrected the problem at Tommy Roberts. And can we, I guess the schools want this and you want to go forward with it, but I'm wondering, can we make some sort of condition with them? I mean, I got to tell you, I look at this, if I was doing something, spending money, to me from the school district, I want to do it like it was my own, like it's my personal money. And I have to tell you, if I had a small company or a little contractor doing some work around my house, doing my garden, and after he finished the work, my garden flooded. And

045it didn't never flooded before in a rain, and it's flooding now. But thinking that I gave that contractor, he previously, before doing my house, he built my, before doing my garden, he built my house, he built my brother's house, he built my grandmother's house. And we spent all this money with him. And he doesn't come the minute we have that problem, he doesn't show up and fix it or at least attempt to fix it, do something about it. I've got an update on that tonight, too. Mr. All right. Well, you know, I think that's more important because I got to tell you, I would not be giving that guy the job to let him change a door in my house or anything else until he fixed that first problem. To me, that's very serious. So

046now the situation you have here is the schools want this, we have the parts, we have to get it done. How about making a deal with them? We withhold payment of it to them till they fix the problem that they created. We're going to speak to the issues at Diamond Roberts, but these are completely unrelated projects. I know that it's unrelated, but it's school district funding going to the same place that took an awful lot of funding from us. And basically the opinion I get from them is they realize that we're winding down. We don't have any more houses to build, and they don't care about us anymore. So, you know, I was planning to vote no on it, but if the board's pleasure is to go forward for the school's sake. But I'd like

047to see something else done. I want to ask a question about Marquis. So these are easy for anyone to. I know we already purchased them, but I just want to be sure that you don't need any special training to be able to program this marquee. Right. Because that has been the problem at Coral Shores for so long. There's only, like, one person who knows how to change what's on the marquee. And this is a kind of thing that we can. We're going to be so much better after we upgrade. But the other ones, like at pks, is stuff that anyone can do. Those screens. Okay. Yes. All right. I think. I mean, I hear the concerns about Ajax. I'm a little concerned that we don't have a noticed discussion of the field at Tommy Roberts,

048if that's what we're doing right now with this marquee installation. If we're discussing our concerns about that, I'm not sure that really follows the open meeting, the heart of the open meeting law. So I'm a little. I mean, I hear what people are saying. I'm concerned that we need to keep these conversations separate. I would just like to echo what Mr. Horan and Mr. Dick said as A new member of this board. But I'm also a very involved community. Member, and I've been concerned with ajax. And as Mr. Dick said, if it was my personal project, I would not hire them. But I do understand that these schools have waited a long time for this marquee, and I don't think it's fair To penalize them because Ajax has not Completed Tommy Roberts to our satisfaction.

049And like him, I had planned to vote no today. But I given this a lot of Thought, and I don't think it's fair to hold schools hostage because we're upset with the outcome of Tommy Roberts. And I begrudgingly, will vote in favor Of the marquee today for the kids in the schools that deserve that. But I do believe that Ajax need to be held accountable, and it isn't right that we've spent that much money of taxpayers money, and they have taken so long to answer our request. So thank you for your report, Mr. Lapheere, as referenced. Excuse me for a second, please. Oh, absolutely. Sorry. After the project was completed, I kept repeating myself about finishing payment when we were happy with the field and we went ahead and we paid in full anyway. And

050now here's where we sit, right? We hold no money. We have nothing other than the hope of their good faith. I will vote to have our schools get their marquees. My concern is the bottom of the action item that says continuing contract renewal. So I just want to make sure that that renewal is only to allow these marquees to get put up and not a continuing contract renewal. So they're an automatic go to for future projects. That contract, ma'am, is the existing contract with Ajax Building that was renewed by this school board back on October 8th. It was the first renewal. Thank you. And when I so inappropriately interrupted Mrs. Conn, I was going to say that to advance that discussion and I'd have to confer with Mr. Schmitz. We could do a short workshop

051before the next board meeting. The topic being our relationship and expectations of Ajax going forward. It seems like all of the board wants to address that. Absolutely. We can do a workshop anytime we want or a retreat or whatever is you feel appropriate. So you would. Mrs. Conn, you're recommending a retreat? I'm recommending a retreat simply because the next meeting is an in Key West. And I believe if we're going to discuss in a workshop the fields that that meeting retreat should occur here where it involved community coaches, et cetera, have the ability to hear us input, so on and so forth. So I will come back to you with the appropriate schedule for that. Can I just suggest we always have workshops at the same time as board meetings, but we could just have

052a workshop in Key west on this. You know, the difference with the retreat has to do. You can say better than that. But if we really want the community coming and giving public comment that aligns itself, I think, better to a workshop than it does to a retreat. So we may want to have, just for words, a workshop in Key west about the field and not a retreat. So if we're going to do that, maybe we can possibly change the schedule and make our next school board meeting in Key West. Even if we can't have it here at the city, we can do it over at the district and flip flop another meeting with whichever school we're supposed to be at next. Well, I think the next meeting is at Coral Shores. And since that

053has, you know, we've got Founders park issues that those folks may want to express themselves on. So I think we just need to look for a date. I'll get with you, Mrs. Conn, and we can Propose it to the board. Okay, thank you. I was suggesting that we just have a freestanding workshop. Oh, without a board meeting? Without a board meeting. Ah. Is that doable? Is that agreeable to the board? Okay, so instead of calling it a retreat, we can absolutely call it a workshop, and we'll still come up with a date. All right, that sounds good. We can work on that. Thank you. And to echo the chair's comments, I Would like to have make sure our AD is there, as well as the principal at this workshop, because, again, we don't use that

054field regularly. They do. They know what's wrong with it. They know it should be in certain places. I've personally been there. I've seen things that I scratch my head. I go on. How is this even possible? So if it is timely for the other board members, I would suggest prior To any workshop, if you can, please. Go visit Tommy Roberts yourself. See all the shortfalls that I have seen, and then you have a better understanding as to what we're actually getting involved with. Yeah, I actually went and took a look yesterday. Again, the field was dry. Happily, we've had no rain, but you can clearly see a gully. I was made aware that there is drainage right next to the cement bleachers on the Tommy Roberts side, but nothing else anywhere. And so, really, if

055you take a look, you can see the grading is not as it needs to be, as well as other issues. So I, too, would encourage everybody to go see and take the walk with somebody who knows the field, whether it's the football coach, the baseball coach, or somebody else who's familiar, like Andrew or Rebecca. It's really important that everybody understands why the flooding's happening, what the flooding looks like, so on and so forth. So if board members are interested, we will be glad to facilitate those visits. If there's nothing else. So was it in my conversation with you that you like. Should we be getting someone to come in? Should we get an evaluation of the field, a professional evaluation of the field before we have the workshop or, you. Know, Madam Superintendent, you want

056me to provide my update with regard to the efforts we've made with the contract? Yes, we were going to do that. Save that for the workshop, please, because that's not. Do you want to hear it noticed? It's not noticed on the meeting. So let's not have that now and wait for the workshop. And then, Mr. Smitz, if you can tell us, moving forward, is it okay? Should we have the board members look at the field? What should be next steps? I Believe all board members are invited to work to look at the field. If you don't feel you need to, that's one thing. But of course it's very relevant to the discussion for the workshop. So I do encourage that. As a secondary matter, what Dr. Wotanski brings up, it doesn't hurt to have a

057professional go look at it so we know what we're dealing with. So I can make that happen in advance of the workshop because it is only fair that we have an independent evaluation. Right. And we could even have Ajax provide some responses to what they think too, once we get our independent evaluation. So I would encourage that. So do you know if the price of that evaluation would be enough that we don't have to have it on a school board agenda? It would definitely, definitely be below the superintendent's threshold to have an initial evaluation of what's wrong if they're, you know, and, and they'll be independent candidates. So. Right. We're not hiring a hired gun. We're hiring somebody to tell us what is the problem? Is there a problem? Why is there a problem? Well,

058and that's exactly, I think what we're. I think that would be useful for the workshop and that would take a couple of weeks anyway. So whenever, you know, superintendent schedules it, we can have that in hand and distributed well beforehand. I think education and on that issue is fantastic. So visiting the field, I'll obtain some sort of professional evaluation and we can go from there at the workshop. Thank you. Okay. And obviously Ajax, it's a public meeting. They can come and join it if they want. Mrs. Axford, could you arrange a tour of the stadium with someone that could tell us a little bit more about it? Yes, definitely. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Lefere. I'm assuming that's your legal advice for the evening. Yeah, let's go with that. Superintendent. Yes, and I am

059going to be brief, Mrs. Conn, but I just want to reiterate how remarkable it is that there is 100 years of continuous accreditation at Key West High School School. And this certainly shows the commitment of educational leaders in this community over a hundred years who were committed to educational excellence. And of course, school boards are definitely included in that. And I will say that over my 38 years, the three high schools have been accredited and there was a 10 year accreditation review to keep them accredited. And then as he said tonight, in 2014, they began to do a district wide accreditation. And so we went for that and we had them visit all of our schools. And so there is that standard of excellence throughout the district. And of course, in 24, we renewed our

060accreditation once again. So I think it's a wonderful thing for this community and something that should be celebrated that that's been going on for so long here, and it continues to go on. And last week, the Florida Teacher of the Year, Jamie Suarez, was here, and she met with our Monroe County Teachers of the Year, along with the cadre of teachers that have been named District Teacher of the Year over the past five years. And if you want to participate in an enlightening discussion, these teachers getting together was a wonderful opportunity. And they expressed over and over again how exciting it was to be together and talk to each other. And these are some of the topics that they covered. Can you share a little about your journey as an educator and what led you

061to being named Florida's Teacher of the Year? Which was a very interesting story from her because, you know, we want a Florida Teacher of the Year to come from Monroe County. But the other thing is, what has she seen? What practices has she seen throughout the state? Because she's visiting other districts, so she was sharing with them practices that are good in other districts, and they, in turn, were sharing the practices that we have here. So it was a great exchange. It was organized by Amber Acevedo and by Leslie Holmes, who really runs our Monroe County Teacher of the Year program. And I just want to thank them and say what a great event it was. And then lastly, and I'll say a little something later, but I want to thank you for completing my

062evaluations. I really do want to do an excellent job, and I think I speak for all of the teachers and staff here in Monroe County. We do strive to do well, and we appreciate feedback and we want to act on feedback. So thank you once again. And I've also asked Christina. We attended the funeral on Saturday for the Decimi family, and I just wanted Christina to give us an update. You know, there is one child, Seneca, in seventh grade, who is still with us. And of course, Gene is in the hospital in Miami. They're looking at skin grafts and other things for him over the next month. But this community has really come together to support them. And Christina can just give you a few details. Good evening. We're pleased to share that with the

063support of the Key West Housing Authority, Randy Sterling and Lisette Carey, the family has wonderful temporary housing until a permanent residence is established with the support of Catholic Charities. Glad Tidings tabernacle Moose Lodge, 1760. Medical professionals in our community and our very, very Generous community made sure to, Make sure that our students have a Beautifully decorated room to come home to. One student, as Mrs. Axford chairs remains in Miami and we are providing counseling services to the family. Thankfully, the other sibling returned to school. With the encouragement of Hob's fantastic school family, we visited and delivered food and donations to the home. Today I want to recognize our community's love and kindness that have wholeheartedly embraced this family in their time of tragedy. There's been a tremendous outpouring of love in our community. Thank you.

064And of course, you all were present at the Dexter Butler dedication last week, which was really beautiful and also shows our love for that family and his heritage is going to continue in the Dexter Butler court. That's it. Thank you. Board members. Mr. Dick? No, I'm fine. Ms. Talbott. I would just like to request that we receive regular updates on Tommy Roberts. Put that as a pending item so we can hear how that's moving along. Thank you. Mr. Horan. Just want to say how kind of cool it is that we're sitting in this building and this is the hundredth year accreditation and this was the original Key West High School. So it's kind of a cool thing. Yeah. Dr. Woltanski. Yeah. I've been this week spending some time in classrooms reading a book about Carter

065Woodson, who is the. He was the only child born of enslaved people who got a PhD in history and he got that from Harvard. Nonetheless. And he is the one who started Black History Month and he started it in 1926. So I'm going to encourage the social studies department and the school district to really up the game for Black History Month next year on the 100th anniversary of. Of dedicating time towards Black History. The kids have been great, by the way. And when I just show them random photos of, you know, important people from history, there's always someone in the room who knows who that is. And it's really very impressive. And they're third and fourth graders, so I think we've been doing a good job. But we should up the game and do some

066big celebration for the hundreds year. I have nothing to report, so we can. Do we actually have any public hearings today? We don't. How about that? Do we want to do the Department of Justice? We are not ready with that as yet, Mrs. Conn, but we are chomping at the bit to find out if there's going to be any changes to the grant. So we're just going to move on to action items at this point. Yes, great. So action item number one. I recommend that the board consider option one and option two as it relates to approving our property and casualty insurance for policy year 2025, 2026. So perhaps if you discuss each option and take a vote, then we would know which one we want to select. Dr. Or Mrs. Dr. White, do you

067have a recommendation between option one and option two? We have had significant discussions this week in relation to the insurance. My suggestion would be option two. I would like to see our insurance be increased over time. This is just a step to increase the insurance. My personal opinion is that we are very underinsured. And what I was trying to do is just keep the insurance amount at the same amount consistent from year to year. I understand. The question of, you know, just for $500,000, is it worth $75,000? I understand. I just think if we can make progress on being more covered with insurance, then we're making good progress. Thank you. Do I have a motion? I'll make a motion for option two. Do we just want to make the motion? How do we want to

068do that? Dirk? Motion. And a second is usually followed by discussion. If you want to discuss after a second. Right, but there are two options on the motion. You can consider both at the same time for discussion. There's a motion for option two. If that motion fails, you can make another motion. Okay, so I have motion by Mr. Horan, second by Dr. Woltanski. Is there any other discussion on choosing option two for our named wind flood? Any no votes? Yes. Yes. You have a no vote? Yes. We have no. A no vote. Do we want to call the roll? [CALLING ROLL] With a vote of four to one, the motion passes. Number two, action item. I recommend approval of the superintendent's summative evaluation as presented. I'll move. Second. Motion by Mr. Dick. Second by Mr.

069Horan. Any discussion? So the only thing I'd like to discuss is the summative evaluation doesn't have the comments for each section. And in the future, I understand it won't be you, but I do believe that all of the comments should be part of the summative evaluation and not just the last comments at the end. The comments that appear in each area. You're correct. Okay. I was under the impression that those were there, but we will definitely follow up on that, Mrs. Conn. Thank you. Thank you. There or there? I didn't see the comments per section. I saw the comments for the end Maybe it was the device I was on. Okay, well, we can recheck. All good. As long as it's in there, it's all good. Any no votes? Hearing none. The motion passes. I

070recommend that we approve. Gladly recommend. That we approve the contract proposal with Performance Travel Limited. This is a Youth Music of the World program, partnership with Key West High School Band for participation in Rome, Italy, New Year's day parade in 2025-26. Point of order. Just for the record, it's. You're approving the trip, which is part of our policy. You're approving the trip. We're not agreeing to the terms of this contract. That is between the parents and the business. So for the record, if you're making a motion to approve. It's a motion to approve the trip, not the contract. So can we change the language of the motion? Yeah, that's what I'm saying. Make a motion to approve the trip. To amend. Make motion. Well, she recommended. Did we get a motion to second on it?

071Yeah. Oh, I thought we had. Oh, yeah, I jumped in. All right, so we have to take a motion. We have to put it on the floor. Right. And then we have to amend it. So I'll move. You don't have to amend it. You can just state it the way you want it. So a move to approve the trip, not the terms of the contract, as the contract is not what he said. The school board is not a party to the contract. Okay, so I'm going to move to. Approve the trip, not the contract. The Key West High School bands travel to the New Year's Day parade in Rome, Italy, and not the contract attached. Which is attached. Do I have a second? Yeah, I'll second that. Motion by Dr. Woltanski to approve the trip

072to Italy for New Year's Day and not the contract as attached. Second by Mr. Dick. Any further discussion? Any No votes? Hearing None. The motion, as amended, is passed. Action item number five. I recommend approval of the Sigsbe Charter School contract renewal for it says Gerald Adams. Number four. Oh, I'm sorry, Missed one. I recommend approval of the Gerald Adams Declaration of restrictive covenant for review and final approval by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. So moved. Second motion by Dr. Woltanski. Second by Mr. Horan. Any discussion? I'm just wondering what this is for Environmental mitigation. That has been this DRC started in 2020. Okay. So we're finally done with it. And it's ready to be approved. By the dep. So it's been a long road, so we really like to see it approved. Excellent.

073Any no votes? Hearing none. The motion passes. And now item number five. I recommend approval of the Sigsbe Charter School contract renewal for 2025 to 2040. I'll second. Motion by Mr. Horan. Second by Mr. Dick. Any discussion? Any no votes? Hearing none, the motion passes. Congratulations, Ellie, and thank you so much for being here. And lastly, I recommend approval of the Ajax construction purchase of replacement marquee installation at the three schools, which are Coral Shores High School, Marathon High School and Poinciana School. I don't think those are the schools. I think it's Key Largo School. It's Coral. It's Coral Shores High School. Marathon High School in Poinciana. Patches said, not Coral Shores. Coral Shores is ongoing. It's Key Largo. Key Largo, Marathon, Point Sienna. I misspoke. I'm wishing for it to be Coral Shores. Coral

074Shores will be by the end of the week. It's going to be done. All right. I got my wish. All right. I recommend approval of the Ajax contract construction purchase of replacement marquee installation at three schools, Key Largo School, Marathon High School and Poinciana. So moved. Second motion by Dr. Woltanski. Second by Mr. Horan. Any further discussion? Any no votes? Hearing none. The motion passes. That concludes our business. Mrs. Conn. Meeting adjourned.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.