CorpusRecord 177802

12/17/24 - Flagler School Board Information Workshop

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Flagler Schools
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Flagler County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,843 words · about 50 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001for good afternoon I now call to order the Tuesday December 17th 2024 1 p.m School Board Workshop please rise for a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance and the national anthem please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all [Music] you see by [Music] the rock is [Music] thank you please be seated okay we'll now do roll call starting at the end of the table uh Lauren Ramirez present jie ready present Derek bar here Christy John present wurry present LaMore okay um are there any uh special announcements for this meeting no special announcements okay so uh we'll move on to uh board

002lays on updates uh would you like to start uh mrus sure all right so so matanzas high school we had sack committee on November 20th uh four faculty had many grants so we have miss aod miss kler and miss Langley and Mr reader um all were within the ace programs so think of PE um exercise equipment um Spanish courses they are will be getting novels and like children's books um to help facilitate that so it was actually pretty amazing and at matanzas since they're my liaison I like to say to Mr Andrew Douglas Miss Wanda Pitman and Miss Ashley Forest congratulations we have the rookie employe and teacher of the year and um Bel Elementary we had PTO and Sac on December 12th holiday shop was record of every single holiday shop ever of profit

003this year so way to go for volunteers teacher staff they're going to have a Polar Express movie night for VPK first and second grade to help with like graduation expenses um that'll be January 10th so if you're in those courses those grades Reach Out health fair is coming up in February math night was a super success their parade they invited all the rookies employees and teachers of the year the past 20 years for their 20 year of being open which was pretty impressive uh they're going to focus on early communication um H School Partnerships so they're going to really focus on that I thought that was a great initiative with their sack they want to engage more families science night is coming up on March 3rd um and again uh since I'm there liazon we

004have Miss Ash Ashley Deo Miss Nicole Massie and Mr Shane Kerr for the rookie teacher employee of the year a virtual town hall meeting sorry I had like the next day after I got sworn in we had the virtual town hall meeting that was my first experience and I had um Johan and Danny were representatives there it was incredible students get five hours of volunteer um learned a lot so I highly encourage any high school student to attend if you can um it was very inspiring epac meeting my other um that I'm L Laya on for the meeting will be January 8th from 6:00 to 8:00 pm on January 28th from 4: to 7: the Enrichment Center will have their grand opening so if you're available they would love to have you all we do

005have a meeting that night so may be challenging for us but um and then I am going to be in touch with Miss Debbie Newman as um the liais on for focus on Flagler youth Coalition and that is all that I have thank you great job uh so for my leaves on with uh buddy Taylor unfortunately we were at a conference the week that their SAC meeting was held but I am in contact with them to uh to catch up and I'm excited to do that um with FPC um their sack meeting is not until January 13th however they have announced I have a couple of news tidbits they have announced a student of the week um her name is Miranda Spencer and that is uh sponsored by Beaver Toyota so thank you to that

006that's very exciting um and of course fpc's uh assistant principal has been named the assistant principal of the Year miss Mandy CRA Kraus I'm sorry crab Rus yes C KRA Rus thank you uh and the African American mentorship program um uh doesn't meet until this coming Saturday so that's all I have all right thank you very much so a lot of things are about to happen in the next day or so so first DJJ meeting I'll be a part of will be tomorrow we'll have that online um so looking forward to that uh tobac of free uh partnership uh that will not be uh that'll be on the 18th as well uh ctst meeting that be a part of a traffic safety team uh led by commissioner dance uh will be in January so not

007much to report on that as of yet I have spent some time uh at the imagin school and met with principal fires and her team and the work that they're doing there and at Rimfire um they will have their um next uh meeting will be not until January the 16th we thought it was the other night uh however I got to go spend some time with the after school uh folks there uh because they actually we did not have that meeting but uh been in contact with the principal there and looking forward to spending more time with them as we move forward um and then legislative liaison been meeting with uh our legislator loc local Representatives um to continue that partnership that we will need with them as we move forward with our our legislative

008priorities um with our legislative delegate that will be on the 8th of next month um so have a lot going on in in the pipeline um I stopped at Bell Elementary's Winter Fest that was an incredible turnout uh the line was out the door so that was very great to see I think great for the community and I imagine they probably raised a lot of funds doing that the kids were all having a great time they got to tape one of the coaches to the wall it was pretty funny so yeah that that's what happened with vanel recently um the school health advisory Council that was a couple months ago so there have probably been some changes since then but at the time there was a pertusus case in Flagler and and I've kind of

009wondered if there's been an uptick in that with some of these prolonged uh coughs going on best way to prevent that is with a Tdap um and also RS there's been an uptick in that also um for adults as well so might be seeing a lot of that coughing it's not all Co or flu um they are also revising their nurses manual uh to to have some updates on best practice and for Wadsworth actually their last meeting I believe we were in a board meeting so I missed that one but I will get in touch okay thank you yeah and so the um because we have our our meeting schedule kind of moved around uh this month for the holidays some of these liaison updates are kind of sparse but um we'll be uh getting

010more robust as we go into the new year and um so I just have a couple of uh announcements for the uh Flagler Auditorium um they have upcoming show called sigh bells and the 60s with um a uh that will actually take place Thursday December 19th and um also they are offering um a show pass they call it the Holly Jolly Show Pass where you can buy for $89 you can watch uh as many shows for two for um with no exclusions all the way till April 19th so that's a be a great last minute holiday gift um and supporting our uh Auditorium and um also the Ed Foundation um they had uh last month successfully hosted another uh Josh Cruz Gala which was a really great I wasn't able to attend but I saw

011a lot of the pictures and everybody had rave reviews about that so it was a great benefit uh to support the foundation um and uh we just uh uh completed the um recent School tours uh just the other day where we invited um members of the community to tour our schools and were you there Lauren yeah yeah I thought I saw your picture there so that's great uh wonderful so that's all I have for liaison updates um so now we will move on to the adop option of the agenda um are there any changes to today's agenda superintendent Moore yes I do um ask that the board move item 9.01 after public comment um again 9.01 have sent sales text um citizen over um site presentation to after item 4.01 very good um okay so

012I'll need a motion to adopt uh the agenda motion adopt okay I have a motion by Mr bars second second by miss trong all in favor I hi I post passes unanimously okay so we will uh now move on to public comment do we have anybody signed up for public comment I'm I signed up okay I will close public comment and we will move on to 9.01 half cent uh oversight and uh Miss B and uh Mr de welcome good afternoon board uh superintendent Moore I have with me today uh conin bko she is the current chair of our uh half cent sales tax oversight committee and she also is the uh current president of our flagor County Education Foundation uh to give a little bit of background uh the purpose of the oversight committee

013was to um ensure the use of the half cent sales tax within the district was align with what the referendum and the ballot language AG that was proposed and approved by our community in 2022 November of 2022 at uh 70% uh positive uh response from them so we're really uh proud of of that and the support from our our community uh this report is uh set to be done annually to bring to the board and really inform the community uh about what the uh funds have been used for uh the alignment with the referendum um and to kind of highlight uh where um where we can Spotlight uh areas within uh the district um relating to the use of the house and sales tax so I'm going to turn it over to con ly thank

014you um thank you board chair board members staff um everyone for tuning in today um as of De my good friend Mr de said um the last board um put in place the hson oversight committee we've had the hson um sales tax here in Flagler County for over 20 years this is the third iteration of of this sales tax that the voters have approved um this is the first time we've included a half cent um committee most of the other counties almost every county in the state of Florida has a half cent sales tax passed by their um their constituents and they all have um a an independent citizen committee that sits and makes sure that what the voters um asked for that that this school district is spending it according to these buckets so

015our role is really to hear all the good news um that's coming out and all the good things that are are being done with um with our tax dollars for our kids and to continue the amazing infrastructure that we have here in Flagler County that really makes the Flagler County School District um the Premier Technology School District in the State of Florida but um the ballot language is here so as a as a committee we first got together we met four times this year and um we said okay well kind of the first time you meet in committee gets together you have to sort of figure out what your role is so we did go through that purpose and um and we kind of wanted to know well where are we where where were we

016before 20 the start of 2023 which is when this iteration of the tax began um so we kind of went through the things that the first tax did for 2020 2021 or 2012 um the last iteration and said okay well where um and what we're supposed to be doing um from 2023 forward um as I said it's going to continue to sustain our infrastructure our technology infrastructure and as you'll see um going forward that's the largest bucket um that this this have sales tax takes care of but it also enhances um our classroom careers makes that possible um makes it possible to meet the needs of of our Workforce and the community um and I'm sure you all are well aware of all the enhanced Safety and Security measures that have come down so um

017as a as a group we wanted to see where our starting point was can go to and we took a look at the last um five years of sales tax revenue and the fund balance um we did ask you know we're taking a look at starting a fund balance of $1 million I said well whoa you know did what are you know why is it so High um and we found out that but there were three main reasons the first one was Co um we did receive some eser dollars which were able to save some of these um half cent dollars it was also the last couple of years of this tax um I believe your school district was very and your staff very wise and conserving um that balance in case the half cent

018didn't pass you always have to to um prepare for that reality and making sure that we could preserve the digital technology until um something else could have been um determined and um it was as I said it was Co there are things as you know you have a five-year um a five-year uh plan for infrastructure Capital plan and um it was hard to get those things done in that period so those are the three main reasons that fund balance um is as high as it is but as you'll see um it will continue to be spent in the way that the that the taxpayers intended so our responsibility was to um make sure that that 10.4 million was um was spent according to the ballot language so we took a look at this in the

019different buckets of um of the ballot language and um I do have to say the um the finance staff with Patty and the technology staff were incredible um in terms of making sure that we understood um they've aligned everything according to those buckets so it is very easy um to see and follow the procurement and um understand um how those dollars are being used so the first is the districtwide technology as I uh as I said the infrastructure here is unlike anything you'll see across the state of Florida um and it's because this was started 20 years ago because of this abent so in this bucket in terms of replacing um or renewing software licenses making sure servers um are up to dat can making what the did we do an a telecommunication upgrade yeah

020phone pH to telecommunications yeah yeah here we go um and so one you'll see $1 millionar of that went to this particular bucket which is your districtwide technolog really your um nuts and bolts of the infrastructure the next piece was um you know what what we are able to actually see face to face every day when you go to these schools and that's the instructional technology piece um every student in our school district we are a on toone um County and every student in our school district um has we're able to provide them with a device if anyone here has never been to um the distribution of these I highly recommend at least just going by to see it it's um it's it's a machine it's incredible to see um from the um getting kids

021ready and and and our kids because they have um they have access to these things are I believe more ready for our Workforce when they come out of Flagler schools so here we go 20 uh the projects we worked on this year we had the um iPad update for your K through three students your teacher devices um were all updated this year and instructional software so that took up about $2.7 million the next um oh sorry there's um I think there's one slide out of place in addition to that um the school district also has technology staff at each in every school to make sure that if something goes wrong during the day I mean you basically have a tech department at every single school on top of what you have here um at our

022district facility um so this half actually funds those technology departments including the people and the staff that are there that's another $2.7 million I believe if I can remember off the top of my head there we go 2.3 sorry it's off a little bit and next bucket so those were the largest buckets um that we took a look at oh sorry districtwide classroom Renovations so these would be um any kind of everything from your Furnishings to um flipping those classrooms those classroom careers um programs so if we if we need new medical equipment for medical programs um this is where uh this bucket would come into and I'm pretty sure in the next few years we're going to see more more coming out of this area than we did this year this year we spent

023about 45 million on um the new spaces at metanis so Furnishing that and then the upgrade to classroom displays um and FPC gets uh audio upgrades um and as I said earlier the districtwide Safety and Security measures so the um the automatic lock psylock systems that are in all over our schools now um your new bus safety routing system that actually covers a couple of different buckets but um and uh the 800 mahz radios which the sheriff's department has said um helps them in communication and making sure that we're um that our kids are safe and this is the list uh and that one was a little less than a million dollars this year this year we didn't do any um HVAC or energy management um but again that's this is another um area that

024if it's needed um it can come from the hset and it has in the past uh bus of procurement maintenance um bus has cost us a lot of money so it's going to be very helpful as um as we need to refresh our buses U we have an amazing routing software um sometimes it doesn't feel amazing on certain days but um for the most part it's an incredible um system that uh I think any parent who's interacted with it um and our kids can attest to um knowing where your kid is and when that bus is coming it's it's it's incredible and uh we do have a bucket this year for the charter school allocation um before this pass this tax was passed um this the state legislature said that school districts must share um

025pretta the half cense or Mills any referendums um with Charter Schools and this year they received about six um $650,000 a little less than $650,000 un for um we did we did reach out to see if they would provide some information as to how those dollars were spent but they are not required to so um they don't kind of live in the same area I guess but it doesn't mean that it hasn't been a friendly relationship I say that so um we just haven't had the time to go and say how that money was spent did I miss one oh sorry okay Y and then um looking forward to again so that leaves about $3 million out of this year's $10 million which was added to the fund balance which you saw was 14 million

026at the end of this year and the things that we're getting ready to do are um the Salto system for your exterior doors uh another refresh of iPads and MacBooks and um the smart room the smart classroom updates um and this year flagor counties was recognized as an apple distinguished School District um this is a big deal it's a really big deal it's a wonderful and it would not be possible without the half cent um the trust that our that our community plac in our school district um and allowing this to pass and allowing our school district to do the amazing things that they do so again I was very happy to be able to come here and share good news with you and if you have any questions I'm happy to board any question

027Miss B on that presentation pretty pretty well said right pres as presented thank you I know you two years ago you worked very hard to campaign for this so appreciate yeah I and also you know looking at the members who are on your board it's a good cross-section of those who have um connection to the schools but also the community interactive and I just want to share for those of you who are it's one of those things that you don't know what you have until it's gone the impact on our students in terms of Readiness for um careers in college just having an LMS system makes that transition to college so much easier having access to like 3D printers and CAD design and PowerPoint and Excel or Google Sheets far B Beyond um you know

028before you step into that um job is just a massive amount of Education that our students are getting and it's the Envy of many counties around us so thank you for advocating and thank the board for um their judicious expenditures and it allows a lot more freedom than our state budget allows um and we would be I don't know where we would be without this so I also thank the public who voted in and essentially share and their um well hard earnings with the school just a quick comment to uh the members that are on the board I think I'd asked you yesterday um so how do they rotate in and out just a real quick uh of how that happens and then is there people that will be coming in new for the coming

029year um so the way that it was uh workshopped and set up uh through through the board initially there was the three-month uh give or take three Monon where it was an open invitation for folks to apply there were I think um 11 total applicants in the course of that time and there were 11 slots so we brought everyone who had said that they were interested forward um the board took action and uh approved that that slate um there's a caveat in there that the committee must have at least seven no more than 11 and it's on the um it's been set up so that the committee itself makes recommendations to the board for the replacement folks so they have opportunity folks want to continue to serve they have that opportunity if there are folks

030that are interested in serving on the committee they would come to the the committee as one of the um one of the members either the chair or the vice Chair say hey I would be interested in in serving on this committee and then um the initial set is with three two years and three years uh just to stagger them so that we didn't have potentially you know several folks coming at so it gives the opportunity for folks to be able to come in and come out but the recommendation for additional folks the way that it was set up would come actually through the uh committee itself to recommend to the board um for new members okay I just value the work that they do uh sat on the half cent sales tax in St John's

031for a period of time and it's it's a lot of work so and uh I appreciate what you all have uh what y'all have done and what you've done for this District so thank you very much for that and and the team that uh that you represent yeah and I just have to thank con Lin for for all the work and and really taking uh in in leading with this the the first first year of this so as we continue to go I think we'll our relationship with the committee will continue to uh bring some some great opportunities for the students here in flago school yeah thank you very much yeah and I just Echo the the same comments from my colleagues here really grateful for all the time and effort you put into make

032this happen here and we're truly grateful for the community for passing this and allowing us to have access to these funds so thank you very much for a great presentation I do want to say as president of the blacker County Education Foundation want to thank you all for your support and it was wonderful to see some of you at our event and I hope to see you next year as well so Merry Christmas holiday was a highlight of my month getting to do the the shopping the the little Tes it was wonderful thank you for organizing that thank you thank you very much okay so now um we're going to move on to um item 6.01 instructional calendar Dr O'Brien and Miss boser B welcome good afternoon good afternoon board um before you'll see the

033calendar that the calendar committee has uh put forth the calendar committee is comprised of 10 people two fesa Representatives two uh fcea representatives for uh District level Personnel appointed by the superintendent and two parents one appointed by our jointly by the FCA and fesa presidents and one by our superintendent so collectively we came together to put together this calendar for the 25 26 school year we took into consideration a lot of the feedback that we heard last year so um last year we brought a calendar before the board and there was some current concerns about alignment of spring breaks and days that St John's Valia and Flagler all have off so we really try to make sure that we reconcile the three calendars to try to have as much commonality as possible because we do

034understand that we have employees who work here who have children in other districts and vice versa so um we put together this calendar and you'll notice that the start date is for August 11th by Statute we cannot start any earlier than August 10th and since the 10th is on a Sunday our earliest date would be the 11th um you'll notice a colorcoded key at the bottom it's just a the color is a little bit uh brighter than last year because we had some people say that some of the colors were too closely related so it was a little bit um we gave it a little bit more pop um but I do want to point out some of those major concerns that we had last year was the spring break time uh valua St John's

035and flaggler all have a common spring break for the 2526 school year and that does align with dual enrollment uh DSC spring break uh where the bulk of our dual enrollment students participate so that is a nice change um we have looked at where St John's has the and valua have their end of quarters and the teacher work days that fall after that and for the most part they align um there are two dates in September that none of us uh we don't have a day off in September but St John's does and valua does on two different dates um but everything else pretty much lines up uh you will notice that we have allocated another major change is that previously during the August uh pre- pre-planning and professional learning week it used to have

036dates that were Loosely designated as these are the pl days and these are the pre-planning dates we've just designated as these five days are for pre-planning and professional learning to be determined based on uh professional learning calendars that are available um that come up throughout the year as our teaching and learning department works with the schools for their PL needs do you have any questions about specifics so I'm seeing just two days for professional learning for teachers so those two days uh the the two that the January 6th and the April 3rd those are the ones that are specifically tagged as PL so no one can decide to do anything otherwise the week of August 4th through 8th two of those days are professional learning and three of those days are pre-planning and that's where

037it can be decided like a school principal might say this the Tuesday will be our professional learning day because we have this specific need and a different principal I say it's the Thursday okay and those um January and April are those District professional learning days or they uh also left up to the schools to decide we kind of uh we didn't establish that during the calendar committee meeting that would be something that the teaching and learning Department would kind of work with the schools to determine what their professional learning needs are okay um so there are many districts in the state that have a recurring half day on the calendar for professional learning for teachers how do we stack up with the availability of professional learning time compared to those those schools and how does

038that essentially impact also the number of learning hours throughout the year for students so if you look at our student our teacher contract day and our student the length of the student day we have a shorter length of time in the day which is part of the reason why this year we had a little bit of a challenge with some of our hurricanes and which is why we also don't have the early release days that other Counties have um in terms of professional learning days that have been allocated while we don't have those early release days that some of the other districts have we have a I think we upped we dropped to 179 day calendar from a 180 day student calendar to allocate an additional professional learning day for our teachers in lie of

039those so if you assume that most of these districts they're doing an hour early release for those we've almost gained 7 days worth of 6 to 7 Days of those early releases by adding that day and dropping off the the typical is it's an hour it's not necessarily a half day or anything they no it's usually an hour okay so it's pretty comparable it's just concentrated yes okay thank you you're welcome okay are there any uh additional questions or comments on this agenda item I I would just make a comment that I am I'm glad to hear the coordinat between uh other districts um you know looks like a best practice but just kind of working and keeping in mind for parents and also staff as well so I appreciate the uh the effort to

040make sure you go outside the box I'll add to that too because a lot of parents that's a big con I mean they work different places and um that's really great that you guys did that so thank you all right thank you very much thank you okay we're now going to move on to operational Services 8.01 school safety quarterly compliance report Mr wahan good afternoon chair School Board member superintendent Moore I'm here to present our quarter 1 compliance report um uh as a school safety specialist in pursuant to Florida Administrative Code 6 A- 1.18 and Florida State Statute 10001 212 the school safety specialist must report quarterly uh to the superintendent and the school board on district non-compliance with the school safety laws or rules and present each quarterly uh to a public um school

041board meeting um also annually as as we did in in September uh they are school safety Specialists also must report on the number of schools inspected to the from the prior year um and the compliance rates um so our our quarter 1 report uh came from the office of safe schools in in November on November 18th um at that time uh the number of schools inspected or reinspected were zero uh which means our percentage of schools inspected or reinspected were zero the number of schools with no school safety requirement deficiencies zero and the percentage of schools with no school safety requirements deficiencies zero um so that was our quarter one numbers that were reported on November 18th um as we know we are in Quarter Two And so uh when we when we receive those

042numbers from the office of safe schools um from the from the results of quarter two I will come to before you with those numbers as well so any questions regarding our quarter 1 data um from the office of stfe schools no questions all right thank you for the update very good thank you okay so uh now um we'll move on to 8.02 Mr vsh good afternoon chair furry board member superintendent Moore I'm here to present the project priority list um and the funds that used to do that were the capital outlay and debit Services the C and DS funds um and just giving you a little definition the funds must be used to acquire build construct alter remodel improve enlarge furnish equipped maintain renovate or repair School District capital outlay projects that have been prioritized

043and approved by the school board pursuant to the most recent educational plant survey and in this particular um project prior to this that'll be survey 5.1 um this is the second step of the first step was the service the second step is the project priority list um that goes through doe for their approval then the board for your approval as well um this project priority list is um consists of matanzas high school um buildings 125 and six uh redoing the carpet in th those buildings and then the 30 Portables at belter elementary school that we're going to be replacing the carpet there as well and we are planning to start that around March 1st of 20 25 are there any questions um so the carpeting obviously you guys probably make decisions about Floor Covering um

044to last the traffic and Longevity that that our students beat this flooring up with why carpeting why are we replacing carpeting with well why do we choose that over more of a like tile or hard hard we look at l VP if and if we go with VCT that can you help me out with the the lvp are the planks where you there's a lot less maintenance to that but it does the final saying L um the you've got the tile that they have to have buffed and waxed that is what you would see in a lot of in kitchen cafeteria area and some of the older schools correct but that also in uh requires custodial to do a lot of work on their end with stripping and waxing and different things you've done that

045analysis and determining correct so it it and it depends on the usage um you know it carpet also is a sound buffer so in classrooms such as the Portables where they're it's just one space if we were to do an lvp or even tile we the noise level would increase some I mean it would so um carpet and carpet's easier here to keep clean um what we're doing now in the district um is using uh square tiles so when there is a spill or something yes ma'am they're two by two foot by two foot so when they're when the custodial maybe cannot get a stain out or something like that then we can go in there and replace it a lot easier than when it's rolled Goods then obviously it's a lot more difficult to

046do that fabulous so I see a I mean a lot of this is metanis um so I'm guessing this is even though it's a small dollar amount there are a lot of rooms that you're covering um in that yes ma'am uh so when it's uh these codes that you have on there how do I determine what those items when it says like um lighting all this is what is the 1758 NSF what are those what does that mean that's the square footage of the room so in the survey thank you um with doe that the best the easiest way I can explain it if we do a survey that we do it's it's a big list of essentially all the things that we we may want to be able to use the co and DS

047funds for so it's a big it's a large blanket of saying that we want to do just about anything when we break that down and have on our 5year plan and have specific such as in this carpet we don't have to do a survey just specifically for that carpet because we've already done that in that large survey and the project priority list just breaks that down to being more specific that's why you see those estimated costs that I wish we had that much money in our in our CS funds but that is the estimated cost if we were to do all of that um but we don't have that we're roughly this this year we have about a little over 500,000 so um I've year marked approximately 300 50 towards the matanzas project and 150

048um for Bel okay thank you so you're snipping away at this is what that's correct yes ma'am just plugging away a little at a time okay where we can and this was approved by the doe 2020 so this is the fiveyear survey so there'll be another one you have to submit next year um we actually when they were just here a couple um weeks ago um we had actually um surveys from 5.1 1 through 5.6 we went through all of those because we can roll them into a new um it'll be survey 6.1 so over the projects or um that we hadn't done in all of those previous surveys were rolling into the 6.1 survey that'll allow us to continue um to use these funds uh on projects that we set forth on our five-year

049Capital plan that's on there as well yeah okay thanks so much yes absolutely the um for Bel Elementary those you said those are Portables we're putting the carpet in yes sir okay are these Portables we own yes sir okay yes they been they actually got put in shortly after we built that facility there's a total of 30 of them we have 30 on there I believe there's two or three of them that have already been replaced um during the Hurricanes where we had some damage in there um I think it's three but anyways we're when we get done with it they will all have brand new car and we're replacing all the doors the secondary doors because they're really rusted as part of not as part of this we're using other funds for that okay

050any other question for Mr Bush all right thank you very much thank you sir okay that moves us on to um 11.01 this is the uh our Weiss and serto agreement for our um uh Council and um so we've already appr approve this agreement um that was brought back for some question um at the reorg meeting um M Ramirez did bring this up the board did approve it um because it was tied to that that's what is listed at um as um from M Ramirez at that time Miss Ruddy also brought up the the desire to um talk about the structure that has been approved by the previous board to have two separate Council for the district and the board so it really is a conversation um that was brought up um by those two

051board members okay so is there anything more to add to that to the to the agreement or well I think that one of the items that I'm concerned about is that uh the cost increase from the last contract to this contract right there's what they're charging per hour uh I don't know was it what is the increase like a 30% increase so if we continue down this with two separate councils um you know every day we're hearing about doing more with less money but we're I'm concerned about that level of expense and uh that dual representation and understanding why and do we need that and is that the model we're going forward with um there advantage with having somebody who is employed directly with the district um those were the reasons that I brought for

052the only thing first thing I just want to address is where where where are you getting the 30% increase uh what was the amount per hour from last year on the last contract are we talking about the last attorney or the firm on uh from this whichever it was right the history is long and Rocky here right so how much per hour in the previous agreement were we spending for Council well are you are you saying with r and soda or anybody well it's it's it's a little hard to say exactly because there we we had a staff attorney and then we went to two separate um contract attorneys okay so much so we could look at the spend uh overall spend as a comparison and and also the the spend in as it is

053um directly related because there is some um expenditures in there that are for out outside Council that we would have whether no matter which scenario get but it all is based upon how much you're getting charged per hour so 310 is the new agreement what is the amount per hour on the previous agreements with any organization that we've uh broker agree agents with for Council sure um prior to that the agreement with our firm was $300 an hour 300 and it was for all attorney time so this was split out to have a lower rate for associates and essentially a okay 3% so then before this organization what was it but the thing is that you you made a claim that that we're paying 30% more I just want to know where you got that

054I look at that total amounts like on some of the financial figures for what the projected cost is for um the two um representations as compared to in previous Financial um documents it's it's a large increase I don't know if 30% is accurate that's just kind of what I I I I don't think that number is accurate and I just want to add that when we went in um when the board made the decision um to not have a staff the their former Attorney at that time the district and the board saw councel the board then approved that the district could hire an in-house full-time staff attorney which is what we've worked towards um hiring at first we weren't get necessarily um many applicants um in the last couple weeks we have gotten um some

055applicants and and we have um two candidates um for consideration that actually you know um prepared to make a decision however we did not do that at that time appending this conversation um with this board I think one of the misunderstandings is also that we do have these two firms but the two firms work in different capacity so now a wife soda is serving as your Council to this board whereas in years past even before coming on has served the board or the district in different capacities and the same thing for sniffing and Spellman you see it all wrapped together for the service that they're providing to the district that the former in-house attorney would have taken care of but we also still have a contract for negotiations we also still um utilize those services

056and would have even if we had an in-house attorney for some human capital human um resources um items that um those firms would have worked with us on so when we look at um our attorney cost as a whole it you will see an increase but the increase isn't just because we have two firms the increase is really a combination of things it's a combination of some of the legal um the P the pending litigation that we worked through last year okay um which we would have had outside Council for regarding of um if we had an in-house Council or or not so there there may be an increase but the increase we haven't been a year under this this model so the increase um in my opinion is not because we have two separate

057outside the goal is to hire someone inh house for the district for the school district that would not service the board okay that was my concern is that is this a result of this new structure and so I'm also curious again because uh you know why did the change what's the pro and con of the two different models well it was the view of the previous board to go in this direction uh from my perspective here were the merits of of changing the structure um one is a conflict of interest situation we are the board we have oversight over the district right okay the district we we had an attorney that was advising both right and in my view that is a bit of conflict of interest even if it's unintentional right uh it just

058it can happen um and so that's that that's one area um one is that the the the the the needs of the board the needs of the district are different and there's I I believe there is Merit in having a a staff attorney for the district for efficiency uh accessibility those type of things but but um for advising the board it it I feel it's best to have our own Council and I don't think our demands are in need of having a full-time attorney right so better to build that as as needed um the um the other part is to have a little have more autonomy in the decision who the legal council is on both sides when you have a district attorney that's serving both if the if that attorney is not meeting the

059needs of either one of those party that creates a conflict because therefore if if if the board says you know listen I don't feel I'm getting the legal counsel that we need but the district may feel that they are then that causes A disruption within the organization if the board chooses to say hey we don't want that person anymore we want to go a different direction this allows you say it's like they have two employers because so it would be you might be at with each other so how many other districts of our similar kind of structure size have this kind of dual representation well I I know there are several but do you do you have any number on that that you're I I don't do that most districts in the state have um

060some virtually every single District in the state has some form of outside Council um because there are always going to be services that cannot be provided by an in-house staff attorney um sure I I also don't have a specific figure on this but I think that approaching half the districts in the state at least do not have an employed staff attorney they have a similar to separate for the school and the school board and their outside or well my point was they at least have outside counsil as opposed to uh an employee directly of the district serving in some capacity it tends to be the larger districts across the state who have an in-house employed general counsel okay so one of the one of the things that after this come up I began making some

061phone calls to some of the other districts and it kind of goes back to what you were saying earlier uh is that sometimes the board members that I've spoke to feel like that they don't get the representation that they that they feel like they need to get because they feel like that attorney that they only have one so they have one for the district and they feel like that uh it's whatever the superintendent wants it's not collectively looking at the totality of this particular body um so that was several calls that I had and that kind of was the sentiment of a lot of the district that just have one one uh Council compared to one for the board and then one for the superintendent um just based off of the quick cursory that I

062did in the last several weeks and even at the fsba conference I spoke with other board members about that and that kind of came up organically I wasn't actually on a fact finding Mission there but th those those topics come up amongst board members and they had um they had shared some of their challenges with having just one shared attorney um and uh and and as I shared with them that the model that we were moving forward with they they had said that is something that they they felt would be advantageous right um so and that these were just candid conversations and just from their experience um you know we are we definitely want to be good stewards of the the precious resources that we are entrusted with but um there are certain things that

063we have to um understand that we that are very valuable and legal representation um it often times comes down that you get what you pay for you know you know and um now uh with Weiss and soda um uh you know we we now have a a board certified attorney on on the board side and this allows us to have that this gives us a a a a position of uh greater oversight when it comes to legal counsel I believe um even if it if even if it wasn't uh Weiss and serona but um that this is a good position to have it's that we have somebody that that has and it's that is not an easy designation to get and there's very there's only a few I don't know that there's I don't know

064how many are board certified 50 in the state 50 in the state so we now have a a board certified uh attorney on our team sure my questioning is no reflection on weisson serota or Mr delini it's the fact that you know we have some struggles with enrollment we have struggles in where we're going to have money and so it's in my nature to go well there are luxuries items right things that are always nice to have more of or pay more of or have the top of the line but what is critical right and um you know uh that's just the perspective that I'm taking and that is a good point and just in in in my view this is something that is critical because we RI as a board if we're if we're

065taking this body right here right and we're talking about you know what are the priorities of this board and what does this board need to be successful in its mission to uh to to be a custodian for these resources and an oversight for this community in in our school district we need good legal counsel and we need uh un u non-conflicted Council that is that is uh looking out on our behalf which ultimately is the entire District but it's just that the uh the superintendent and and staff their demands of of an attorney are different than ours and um although some other school boards or or districts choose to have outside Council completely they don't they don't even have one I I could see value for our size District to um to have one on

066staff as as superintendent Mo has been tasked with you know evaluating applicants for that so um you know this is the method that the previous board uh or the structure I should say the previous board willed and um you know from from my district to seat I I encourage uh the board to continue with that model um and let that play out so we're saying the current what we're trying to go forward with is keeping a a separate Council for the board and eventually going to a full-time person for the school district where the expenses would be more uh predictable okay yes and I think for me um like what I brought up on whatever it was November 18th it was um just a couple notes so the attorney that the district has just the

067differences of the hourly wage so they're getting paid $200 an hour as opposed to 310 that we're paying so my question was on that night of being sworn in was you know just getting this information less than 7 days not able to understand why and you mentioned you know this was vetted so my question is you know it's vetted was it vetted like different attorneys vetted or vetted of hey how yeah was there a bid that was done or was it like just asking oh is this a great attorney I know this person and who was the person that vetted because that's what you stated so I'm just trying to understand just cost wise like why are we paying and again this is just understanding of learning like we're paying $200 an hour for district

068attorney and our Schoolboard attorney is 310 so I'd like to understand and even the associate and then the paralal clerk is significantly higher and so I brought that up just why is there a specific reason um is it just your organization with that pay if we vetted who did we vet what other companies did we talk to attorney law firms and who was the person that talked to them was it just he say she say so that's what I brought up on November 18th so that just understanding better how I would answer that is that what what you kind of walked into is you you are inheriting uh you inhering a previous board's decision right so yes it was for you for you it was uh new but it was not a new item so

069we had been working with the firm uh prior to we did have a round where we did send out for some other attorneys and then uh we had some delays there the one thing that for school boards we don't need to put out a request for proposal for attorneys right it's not a it's not a bidding type of thing we get to choose the legal council that we feel best at any given time um and that just that that means even with our with our current attorney right so um we have a lot of control over that when it comes to our legal representation and I think that is appropriate that we do because it is an important part we are not attorneys as far as I know no one here is uh and I

070highly rely on our legal counsel and I have to make decisions and have Council that I can trust is giving me counsel that I can act on right um and so the the board had uh even uh outgoing board members had given High Praise to uh Mr Delaney and and we and Sera so the vetting was from your previous board right um and we have had legal services with Weiss and serota as a firm even before Mr Delaney came on as our uh School Board board attorney uh and I I have actually engaged him in in um uh board actions that were required even before that so there is a a longstanding relationship with the firm so from a vetting standpoint uh even from a board previous to me that they've had there's been value

071in having this long-term relation with with with this firm as a as an outside Council mind you not not an employee so I think there's history here to show that they've they've given us good service and we've gone back to them for for more service right so um and as far as the the the price you know um you if we looked at some of the the the numbers that when we did put out for a bid um the the the numbers there were even higher than some of the ones you mentioned right now so um and that was a while back that those could be a lot higher so it fortunately what I would say is that for the for the board's benefit we don't have to do that unless we want to do

072that right but now we have somebody that we've uh been working with for quite a while and the previous board was was happy with the service now we're a new board so uh but I think it just like anything um you're going to have to get acquainted with with the legal representation also and if you're if through your own vetting if you find that it's not satisfactory then we have to have another convers ation as a board on on on who represents us here right because it's it's uh it's not really you know I will say the the margin of difference between the the proposals we received are were narrower than what you what you uh shared from a different you saying sniffin and Spellman is charging less than what is the normal going rate

073no there is no going rate per se but what what I'm saying is that we put that prop out there and they did not submit to be to to fill that we put that request for proposal out there they did not submit uh a bid wa what proposal yeah I thought you said you don't have to but we did it was it was well it wasn't request for proposal a request for um qualifications qualifications yeah exactly so they they so we wanted because we were we were we had no we had no alternative at that time so we wanted to see the field right but then um we we had uh Mr Delaney as an interim and we worked well with them and we and we could have gone back those those those proposals had

074expired one of them is now working for the city so that's gone right so uh so that would be other one had a compl of Interest yeah there was a conf you mentioned that I guess like you know just when you look at the numbers and you know we want to make sure you know we're really trying to watch our spending and I know yes you get what you pay for I completely understand but from looking at the price we're paying for our district attorney and then it's it's $200 and then 310 an hour that can add up and so I'm just wondering and trying to understand is that I mean it's such a gap so is that something you know do we want to look at that or maybe this is the normal but

075we're spending 200 for a great attorney it appears for district and we have a great attorney it appears for Schoolboard but the price difference and that's what I'm just trying to understand there's some that charge 500 $1 an hour so I mean in in in essence there a firm presents itself you have to evaluate are you getting the value for the dollar you're you're paying in one side of this is that that they do serve in different Capac and there's different yeah there's different Specialties Focus because we could you know right and that's why we use outside Council for other things because not all attorneys are all-encompassing they they will charge accordingly to the type of law that they are or in the service they're providing and their access and availability you know mind you

076um uh spell spelling and um Sniff and spell uh they're not making themselves available for our meetings right they're not they don't have to travel to our here to do so it's a different scope of work than what we're we're getting what we're asking of them for the district and uh ultimately that will change too when the superintendent employs a full-time attorney that's going to be a salary position and there won't be an hourly uh number pegged to that um if I could just add I um with this model being less than a year when um the board decided they were going in a different direction there were a lot of things going on a lot of things that we needed to work through um I think one of the uh things that we found

077out very quickly that it's hard when you have one person that is um handling a lot of things solely and so when that person walks away you have a lot of things that you're trying to get an understanding of where they are in the process where it it was a lot of stuff happening at one time and um I would say I'm glad that you as a board as a community member I'm glad that you as a board you're having this conversation as a staff member I think you have to give it some time to allow for some of the Dust to settle of things that we just inherited and needed to work through to really identify what is the true cost the cost is elevated um right now but I also know the things

078that we worked through last year that we should not have to deal with and work through this year it was a lot of things coming into one at one time you got a new superintendent coming on you got a new attorney that's coming on you've had this attorney for a number of years and now we're trying to make um sense of all the things that that are going on the litigation just it was so many different things um and so some of that cost is going to be the cost um but some of it was just because of the situation we were working with at that moment sort of transitional and but I I agree we have to come back and revisit these models uh but you have to give them time to work out

079uh we have testimony from other districts and that say this this works well um in theory I think it is the it's the best model for us to move forward effectively um but but it it it would behoove us to to allow this to uh to play out and uh see the model how how it works um the the because now a lot of the the the billable hours except for items that are are are are focused will be absorbed by the by the staff attorney for the district's needs and not that this needs to be stated I I will say um and um our pargal works very closely with wife soda Mr Delaney's office Mr Delaney does try to um limit the times that he has to be in the in workings of the

080day-to-day those day-to-day things in order you know one to make sure he has that clear line of work but I also think making sure that we he is too being fiscally responsible to this organization so he definitely is doing that but at the time that we made these changes there were a lot of things going on and and he had to be the one a part of those things and so when you have the attorney that's working through some litigation for the bo that comes at at an increased cost Mr what's your travel time here back there there's oh I mean I'm in the car hour and a half hour and 45 um but that's not a cost to the district no I know but I think it's just something to consider that it has

081to be worth your time too to come here if I could get back to miss ruddy's Point she she was asking about kind of pro cons one of the biggest Pros for the board when it comes to me is I'm super easy to fire if you guys aren't happy no it's right there in the contract seriously I genuinely mean um way easier to fire than an actual employ um it's 30 days vote of the board and you guys can go and you can pivot and go in a different direction if it's not working well for you um the other part is maybe a little bit to tag into what the superintendent said is I'm scalable you know as as much as you need uh I can can rearrange things and work to provide what you

082need and and if it's something that can be delivered more efficiently or I can help staff with a policy and then staff can implement it and I don't have to be you know it's my a smarter person than me said this but if you can teach somebody to fish rather than serving them fish you know that's the model I want to try to get to for the district so we can Implement some policies and we don't have to have as much uh attorney involvement um we did have a lot going on some of them were were positive I mean we did spend a lot of time on ref financing for the district our bonds which save like $800,000 so um there have been some positive projects where I feel like I've I've been a small

083part in helping have a positive impact but I wouldn't want the board to lose track of hey this is only I'm only here as long as it's working for y'all so well and I appreciate because I mean like from the you know the November meeting like the questions like and I know that's why we're here to ask those because I just needed a are understanding had no time you know less than seven days and had questions and so to bring them here so thank you for explain the vetting and then you know the pay you know um but you know that that's what I had questions on in November so all right so there are any other questions then we'll just keep moving forward as we've uh got put in place all right so um

084that closes out our last agenda item and um we now move on to public comment is anybody nobody signed up for public comment so we will close that uh do we have any board member requests okay if hearing none we will move on to closing comments uh Mr MERS do you have any closing comments just you uh thanks for everyone answering questions emails uh as a new board member um being a liaison for all the the different schools and organizations it's been great and I really feel like you know we're moving in the right direction I like it uh the communication team I do want to bring up they've been working really hard with trying to communicate all the incentive so uh yeah so looking forward to it thanks yeah it's been wonderful to see

085all of the effort that folks from our flagor schools are putting into making the season and magical uh to putting magnets and uh uh lights all over a school bus thank you Miss Henderson and um uh being part of that parade I know it's a huge effort to organize uh to down in the classrooms it's so cute you've got teachers who are doing little things like putting tiny little Footprints uh across students desks to imitate The Elf on the Shelf so they're all excited to come in the next day to school spirit um so that every child feels a little bit of magic in this uh part of the season and um I just thank you for all of that because it's the community right that makes us stronger it's uh it's it's what's special

086about bringing people together um and I can see that being built into our culture and just a really strong sense of that to make sure that every kid um in our schools is enjoying this season which can be very difficult for many thank you I'll hold most of mine till this evening I'm sure just say it again but I just want to thank uh our staff for what they do uh for us and the weekend work and parades and the things that are going on uh with communication uh with our schools I just really appreciate that and the opportunity to continue to learn the great things that our district are doing and so but I'll hold some of the rest of my comments for later the even thank you sir I'll just I'll share those

087comments and I'll save some for tonight okay yeah and uh just want to thank uh staff for all their efforts uh especially on the um on the bus for the parade that was pretty cool uh and um we um I'll I'll save the rest of my comments for tonight as well so all right uh superintendent Moore I will just say happy 78th day of school awesome this meeting is a journey thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.