001[Music] all right good evening everybody cold evening at that um sorry we don't have the heat warmers on and your uh seat warmers on uh but I would like to call this meeting to order on January 21st 2025 the school board of man County um I'm going to go to miss spray for our reading of the district Vision thank you chair the school district of manate County will be anary student focused school system that develops lifelong Learners to be globally competitive and um I'm gonna we should do invocation first and then bring in the color guard okay I think it's a little bit out of order normally yeah so we'll go invocation next I don't know if not see uh Pastor Stevens from St Mary's Missionary Baptist from Parish I'm imagining it could be traffic
002related so I will defer to Mr Tatum if he would be so gracious to do so sure you guys will rise invation and then we'll bring in the color guard and do the pledge after as well let us pray Lord we are gathered here this evening under your grace to do many things to celebrate great members of our school system and our community we are also gathered here today to discuss expenditures of the hard earned money of the taxpayers and we are also here tonight to make decisions about Personnel within our school system so Lord we just ask that your blessing be upon all of us this evening for our heads and our hearts and our minds and our Spirits as we go forth and make these decisions that we can have dialogues that are
003Frank and honest with civility so may the Lord bless and keep us may he make his face to shine upon us and may He bring us prosperity and peace God bless us and God bless this greatest country on God's green earth the United States of America amen amen amen right at the MHS gec will come on in they are Commander Ashley cholette Cadet Brian bernabi Cadet Joselyn novice and Cadet Abigail Fus AR you'll join me in the pledge I pledge allegiance to the of the United States of America and to the repblic stand one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all [Music] arm right AR thank you you may be seated all right that brings us to item number six which is the approval of the agenda uh the chair has found
004good cause to amend the agenda to include all items listed under agenda amendments on the January 21st 2025 agenda updated January 17th and posted to the district website an [Music] schools.net we have a motion to approve the agenda item don't move second so we have a motion in a second did youall do that in granicus I am oh sorry but I don't have any options perfect did you did you sign out sign back in I'm going we had a motion by m Bray second by Mr Kennedy what is or got it go ahead oh there it is there we go okay okay here we go and that passes five to zero uh moving on to item number seven approval of the minutes superintendent weissa good evening chair Cho and board members I recommend approval of
005the minutes from the December 10th 2024 Schoolboard Workshop as well as the minutes from the December 10 2024 school board meeting so moved second we have a motion to Second any sorry uh minute fixes no from the board all right let's go and vote on the approval of the minutes for December 10th Workshop December 10th school board meeting that passes 5 to zero all right next item is student celebrations recognitions Mr Barber come on down for our Sunshine State Scholars lot of hes out on my friend thank you Mr board chair board members and Dr weong going to get set up here okay uh you know it's always great to start the board meeting with the uh color guards here and uh uh it's I get the pleasure of watching them get here early and
006getting set up and and doing their walkthroughs and everything so uh like I said it's it's just special to do that and then to follow that with uh you know student celebrations and then celebration some of our uh employees uh that that makes the uh school board meetings to me you know very special so uh tonight we've got two amazing uh recognitions I think you'll be extremely impressed by the students that we have here and the people that are here to speak on their behalf so the first person I want to introduce is Erin Chapman she's our coordinator of instructional projects so a good evening good evening so I am here because I get to introduce these wonderful Sunshine State Scholars um but I want to give you a little bit of information about the
007program and what it is the Sunshine State Scholars Program was created in 2011 to encourage Florida's strongest science technology engineering and math students to attend one of Florida's postsecondary institutions and hopefully to continue into careers in stem within the State of Florida each district can select a designated number of 11th grade students who represent dedication to and excitement for a variety of stem Fields Manatee County selected two Scholars and one alternate to represent our district at the Sunshine State Scholars Symposium this April at the Symposium our student Representatives will have a variety of networking opportunities to educate their decisions about postsecondary options and career pathways colle and University representatives from around the state as well as notable employers from the stem sector will present research and Innovations while educating students about future opportunities students will
008also work with their peers to develop solutions to real world problems currently impacting our state so I'm going to hand it over to our high school Representatives who are going to introduce our Scholars hi my name is Jenny MCN and I'm a math teacher at bra River High School I'm here to support Tina um Tina is an exceptional combination of determination Drive curiosity and heart she has excelled in all of her coursework while asking thought-provoking questions helping her peers and brightening all of our days she has plans to work in the medical field and has already been involved in medical research I know her dedication Keen mind and kind heart will lead her to be a strong advocate for the practice of humanitarian science for the people I'm so excited for what she has in
009store for the future and I'm proud that she's part of the pirate [Applause] nation good evening I'm Tina d as long as I could held a pen in my hand the pursuit of knowledge is something that I've been very dedicated to the fact that I have the privilege to be able to to what I want and quench my thirst for Education through academic schooling is something I'm very grateful for thus through the recognition of this award I'm glad that I have the ability to stay in school for as long as I can and further my education um with this award excuse me I plan on getting my undergraduate degree and hopefully and hopefully attend graduate school where I get my PhD and medical school for my MD thank you so much Ginger Collins principal Southeast
010High School it is my honor to recognize militia a truly remarkable young woman whose dedication achievements have set a standard for excellence for other students at Southeast High School milisha not only excels in her rigorous IB coursework but Embraces all challenges with resilience and Grace she represents the essence of what stem is all about milisha we are so very proud of you and cannot wait to see the impact you make in stem and the medical field as you preserve are your dreams of becoming a neurosurgeon [Applause] oh hello I'm Misha and I first of all want to thank God for this great opportunity and great recognition that he has allowed me to have and I want to thank my parents because they have always been my support and have shown me that unconditional love and
011without them I wouldn't be here today I also want to t uh thank the school district of manate County and all of the the teachers and staff that have worked with me and have supported me along my journey and my education I feel like the programs that are offered in this County are so great and the connections that you can establish here are amazing as well I love the clubs that I'm allowed to work on with um do and pursue all the STEM related activities I can do at my school and I'm so excited to also pursue my education here in the State of Florida and uh pursue a career in neurosurgery thank you very much thank did we did we record that make sure we recorded that first marketing off good evening Dustin dolus
012I'm the principal at Lakewood Ranch High School and I'm going to introduce Julia vendramini uh every day students like Julia Inspire us um I'm sure that would be echoed by the Educators up here they make our job so much worth so worth it and so much better and so much easier uh but I had the pleasure of of having Julia come down to the office when I informed her that that you all had invited invited her down here and I looked at her academic record and I'm just shocked I mean she's taken six AP classes in our anatomy and physiology honors class which would which is like a college level class and I'm sure all of these students are are taking that same level so we heard I heard the word dedication and you have
013to be dedicated in order to take that level of class especially at Lakewood Ranch High School and so I'm I also heard from Julia she she is going to make Nationals in FCCLA and uh her and her sister have a project about the importance of civics education in our schools so I look forward to hearing more about that project and I'm going to introduce Julie good evening everyone my name is Julia benjamini thank you Mr doist for the wonderful introduction and first of all um I would just like to thank everyone that's here um the superintendent and um the State of Florida for allowing me to have this opportunity to allow me to thrive academically not only in the stem field but with all the electives my school has offered um my future plans is
014to major in economics and hopefully go to graduate school and become an actuary because I really like that kind of risk-taking side and knowing that um the people around me had the um Faith to nominate me is just a perfect example of a risk that I'd be willing to take in the future for others so I would just like to once again thank everyone here thank my parents especially thank Mr doll quis for taking me here and um yeah that's it thank you thank you they're only Juniors it's amazing they're going to be around for another year we're very uh you know happy about that uh but these are three of the top uh stem students in the State uh for that are Juniors so it's great to have them I also want to make
015sure that you know that Tiffany Spradley director of secondary curriculum and instruction is here so so um we'd like to get a picture with theard in the background and I believe we do have some we have parents here [Applause] should we get all the parents in yeah come on parents can we get all the parents in yeah parents come on parents I'll be posting onalia Julia get in there Julia get in there [Applause] thank thanks thanks DUS that's great couns all right okay we always have to wait for Kevin to get things yeah wait all right uh I love these evenings when uh we get to celebrate students and then we get to celebrate employees and this is a very uh uh special recognition it's uh uh it's in coordinate with National School counseling week
016which is February 3rd through 7th this year and uh we have two uh uh employees from our district that are Statewide uh nominees uh the first is uh Cassandra Cassie uh I'm sorry uh Dio Dio Dio from Rogers guarden bulock Elementary and I'm going to ask principal Michael escorcia to come say some put my glasses on okay okay um it is my honor to have Miss di be part of our school Community um in the two years that she has been at Rogers she's changed the way our students and staff treat each other they are more self-aware and able to manage emotions which you know that age is very hard for the staff too um and behaviors in a safe and respectful way they also continue to develop positive relationships with each other with staff
017and and have an understanding of empathy for others Miss Theo has taught everyone out our school how to be kind to each other and that they have the power to make good choices so that they will grow in their educational journey and make any goals they want for the future that's what she does and she does this to everybody that she encounters I just want to say congratulations for this a amazing and well-deserved honor yes you're [Applause] here good evening everyone Dr wison good evening I am so honored and excited to represent school counselors in Manatee County and school counselors across the State of Florida um my mission is to continue to um advocate for our professional identity with the goal that 80% of school counselors day is spent dedicated to providing direct services to
018our students services that are vital for academic development social growth and the development of lifelong Learners that are globally competitive every student deserves access to a comprehensive School counseling program I am deeply grateful to my current and past administrators Mr escoria and Miss bench for recognizing the transformative impact of such programs when students have access to well implemented School counseling programs throughout their educational Journey we see measurable results improved academic performance mitigated behavioral challenges and increased graduation rates with the unwavering support of my administrators we have achieved the highest recognition in School counseling the ramp designation for our program first time ever in Manatee County and our goal is to position Manatee County school counselors as leaders in Florida by securing additional ramp designation this upcoming year together we are setting the standard for excellence
019in school counseling programs thank you for your time and your dedication to support our students and of course our school counselors in our district thank [Applause] you um again Cassie Dio is the Florida school counselor of the year uh named by the Florida school counselor Association uh next we have Lissa Bennett uh district coordinator of school counsil Ing and she received the school counselor Advocate District leader award at the Florida school counselor Association conference in November and here to say a few words about her is Dr Lorie Breslin executive director of student support and family engagement thank you good evening good evening it is my honor to introduce Lissa Bennett um in recognition of this award she has received to give you a few facts about uh Lissa she's she's been an employee in the
020district for 23 years and a school counselor for 17 of those years the past 5 years she's been doing tremendous work in the district office she currently serves on the FC fsca board of directors to support school counselors across the entire state in 2017 she was recognized as the Florida school counselor of the year which puts Manatee County as one of four districts in the state to have two or more school counselor of the Year recognitions the other districts are Brower Duval and Palm Beach which are quite large districts so we believe statistically that makes us number one Lissa is a constant support to staff and students and um it's an honor to be able to work and see um what she's able to achieve for our district Lissa thank you good evening board Dr
021we song um I stand here and I'm an empath true and true so um I get emotional every time I hear Cassie and the work that she's done because the work that I have done as a school counselor I had to leave my students to take a job at the district and that was a hard shift for me but being able to advocate for people like Cassie to do the work that they're doing for our students makes me really emotional and I'm so proud to work with a whole host of school counselors in our district to to be an advocate um in School counseling is a hard is a hard task in the State of Florida it makes it even harder for us because we are a little bit behind the times all of you
022probably went to school with guidance counselors in 2013 the state changed our language to school counselors and that was to catch up with the fact that our roles changed significantly in the 90s no longer are we just academic advisers but school counselors work to meet the social behavioral academic and post-secondary needs of our students and as you know our students need us more than ever so it's been an honor to continue to support our counselors like Cassie National School counseling week is coming so if you know a school counselor or you want to stop by a school and say happy National School counseling week it's their week to celebrate what they do on behalf of our students and we continue our work to create School counseling programs in our schools so that all of our
023students can access what they're accessing as Cassie is we have a lot of work to do our counselors have aot lot of extra responsibilities and we're working to create programs that allow them to be able to do their work so thank you very much I'm honored that my colleagues recognize me but more importantly I am super excited for Cassie to be our Florida school counselor of the year I I believe our superintendent has good evening board members um I I just want to U note that uh it's very rare to have the state counselor of the year and the state supervisor of the Year from the same district I I had an opportunity to um sneak out uh of here the day uh that uh these awards were announced up in Tampa and made it
024just in time to hear the announcement and and celebrate with Cassie and Lissa and um it was it did not go unnoticed by the crowd that um Manatee had won both of these distinctions and um uh to see uh the the respect uh that both of these women have with their colleagues around the state uh was uh was uh really special um when I uh arrived in Manatee um uh Miss benett was one of the first people that I really heard about uh and I heard that she was wearing about four hats at the same time right and uh uh uh talked with um my team and we decided that we really wanted her to just get to focus on School counseling services and um I know that our our counseling teams are are getting
025stronger every week because of that and uh we uh we appreciate Miss Bennett she's also been leading the effort on um uh our portrait of a graduate work uh that I know the chairman had an opportunity to participate in last summer and that work continues to evolve and um uh I believe it will be a a centerpiece of our next strategic plan um as we roll it out to more Community stakeholders and so um appreciate uh Miss Bennett for all your leadership in the district um I uh first met uh Cassie uh I believe last February um I made a trip to Rogers Garden because she had sent me uh notes from two Rogers Garden second graders um who wrote to me uh during kindness week and I wanted to meet them and so um
026Cassie uh made that happen and when I went up to her office which is um office isn't really the right word it's a it's a welcoming place and you walk in that room and and you know that that uh um that you're you're in for for something special I know Vice chair spray you got to um uh visit that room as well and and and you just know walking in even even before uh someone meets you um the um uh the work that you put into your job and uh it's a a a really remarkable opportunity for the students at Rogers Garden so uh thank you both um for for your leadership and what you do every day to take care of kids in this District [Applause] she does a great job out there L
027great things happening in The District employees to students and I agree with uh Mr Barber I love starting meetings off with with our recognitions and celebrations of our students and our staff all right moving on to item number nine public comment we do have one public comment general public comment um and that is Joe Roberts so if you want to come on down uh screen above you will show the three minute clock and you're good to go okay I want to thank the board Mr chair for giving me the opportunity to come in here and speak tonight about an injustice that I am seeing in this District my name is Joe Roberts I'm recently retired after 35 years in this District I was a teacher uh principal or assistant principal at the middle school level
028and a uh administrator at the ESC Department uh with the county office I've got a good grasp on how the district Works internally Dr Skip Wilhoit who I'm before uh who will come before you later on this evening is dedicated 26 years of his life to the Mante County School System I know Skip as a teacher as a coach uh as a worker at the County office for safe and drug free schools Dropout prevention uh he has put on countless trainings he has facilitated numerous committees his work on the code of conduct committee is legendary it's the best committee I've ever been on in my life he's worked on Champs he's worked on uh he is basically the face of the anti-bully movement in Manatee County he mans the bully hotline he uh has given
029hundreds of presentations to elementary school students who Among Us has a letter from a student that says you saved their life Dr wilhoit's got one of those I could go on 504 procedures for discipline this work on the Champs program it's endless he has dedicated his life to this District the Injustice that I am here to talk to you about tonight is the target intimidation that he has had from our superintendent ever since of all things he had an interview he has an interviewed to advance his position in the district he gets the job go on go on the uh HR Portal sign in you've got the job congratulations he goes in he accepts the position it's not approved by the superintendent he interview the job gets reposted he interviews again and I will leave
030it at that right there but I hope you dig in and find out what happened to him it's unacceptable what happened to him in that interview process it's pathetic what happened to him in that interview process and that was the Catalyst when he reapplied for that position that was the Catalyst for this super inant to use targeted intimidation against him what did he do what happened removed from his that code of conduct committee that was the best I've ever been on gone out of that responsibilities gone taken away from them so what happens he gets assigned to schools to help with truancy and attendance okay he goes there he Embraces that something happens at a school and he's escorting a student to the office and he is attacked by this student it gets broken up
031CPS is called they come in they do an investigation nothing to see here our district sends Mr will Dr will ho home for four months on paid leave isolated at home can't speak to anybody calls in every day to some number nobody picks up the phone nobody tells them this is the way we treat a 26-year veteran in this District that brings us here tonight I want to talk to you about communication and I'm almost over but it this superintendent is leading through fear and intimidation it shuts communication down 10 or 15 people I've talked to principles assistant principles wanted to come up here and talk about Dr will Hoy tonight but they couldn't I asking you to really take your time and look at this situation this is this is you're talking about his
032livelihood his quality of life he has put too much into this District to be thrown away like a piece of trash on the side of the road it's terrible what has happened to him thank you sir thank you all right that concludes uh our general public comment for the evening uh we'll move to item number 10 um reports and presentations um I know it's the graduation rate initiatives in 23 24 data uh Dr Wong you wanted to introduce this item as we get the tables prepared thank you chairman uh we're excited to uh make this uh presentation to you uh this evening ing the results of the uh graduation rate for the class of 2024 um those who were on the board uh may remember uh that at the end of my um first hundred
033days here uh I made a presentation regarding um the entry plan and and a series of observations about potential next steps and at at the top of the um academic Services list um was uh work on our graduation rate um I was um uh trained uh uh uh for this work uh in a in a district where the graduation rate um was an indicator of the overall health uh of the organization and um uh uh the the graduation rate is um uh measured in grades 9 through 12 but it's really a reflection of how the entire system operates uh and so um we've been um working on this for some time and um there was an announcement uh last week and uh very positive news um a lot of um hard deliberate work uh and
034uh positive outcomes and so uh we uh celebrated uh briefly and then got right back to it because although we've made good progress uh uh we have um we have further to travel uh I want to um thank uh the individuals that you're going to um hear from tonight uh they uh have been involved uh in uh leading the effort uh and there are um others as well um but they represent uh the group uh and so U Miss scarbro uh became our executive director for secondary schools last February and has done very targeted work uh supporting each High School principal in um realigning systems uh to make progress uh Dr bresin uh in her role uh as uh executive director for student supports and family engagement um uh realigning uh systems in those departments
035uh to be sure um that um we're taking advantage of the latest uh research-based practices and program options for students um and then uh Lisa lion uh joined us uh last summer as interim director um for uh student services uh and um H has a um history of working with schools on on grad rate and um the board members uh the the three who were here at the time U may remember I called you and said uh I've got an opportunity to pick up um Talent uh and um we don't know exactly where that all fits yet but um we will figure it out and then uh we needed a director for student services and uh Mrs lion dropped right in uh and um has been working really student by student um and she'll talk
036about some of that work tonight uh and then um representing uh our high school principal core uh is ginger Collins uh principal at Southeast um Southeast had the largest uh gain in grad rate and so she's going to talk about some of the specific practices that are underway to to get that uh work going again there are lots of others um both at the district level and the school level contributing and of course Mr Jensen needs this team as Deputy superintendent and then um our uh director of research uh and accountability Evan McCarthy is also in the audience uh and um always gives us lots of interesting ways to slice and dice the data so that we can better serve students so uh excited to turn it over to the panel uh and uh share
037both the progress we've made and our next steps um so that we can serve students even better thank you thank you thank you Dr weong and thank you board members for having us tonight um we're excited to present this information to you um and so without further delay we will head right into the presentation and so first we're giving you the snapshot of where we are um for our graduation rate giving you this view um of what we've accomplished here in the district over the past three years so in January 9th um of this year that should say January 9th 2025 I've already caught my first mistake here um the Florida Department of Education released graduation data that confirmed the graduation rate Rose um from 82.3% in 2223 to 85.7% in 2324 um this confirmed
038which of course Evan McCarthy and his team had already told us um because they they're running the data constantly and gave us every indication that this would be where where we would land um we're going to dive into um what this number means and how each school did and um as Dr weong pointed out here from um our principal who is boots on the ground doing the work with the teachers and the students well we wanted to start with some common language so here are some terms that we're going to be using tonight the first one is a cohort so we are talking about the 2024 cohort and what that means is they started 9th grade four years ago go and then we'll also be talking about dropouts and a Dropout is a student that's
039been withdrawn for a number of reasons but they are not continuing on with their education and that's very different than a non-grad so you would think a Dropout in a non-grad are the same thing but they are very different a non-grad would be a student who is continuing on into some other type of education they could be moving on to a GED or into adult education or maybe they're looking at a fifth year of school so for example ESC students they're allowed to go to school up until they're 22 but the state still expects us to graduate them within those four years of when they started nth grade and then lastly on here we have a transfer and transfer is really important because that would be a student who is enrolled at Southeast High School
040uh leaves Southeast and then enrolls at manate high school or same thing outside of the county outside of the state so those are students that are coming in and out of our schools they impact our graduation rate so when we're talking specifically about the number that we that we are accountable for that graduation percentage we're looking at all of the students who graduated with a standard diploma within their cohort year or even before so we're looking back to when they started 9th grade and expecting them to graduate those four years later so there's adjustments made to this cohort so students um let's say they moved to Florida moved to Manatee County in 10th Grade that student now becomes part of the cohort so they're now in the numerator and the denominator and the same way
041say a student is in 11th grade and they move to P County so that student would come out of the cohort for Manatee County and once they enroll in PT County they would they would be absorbed into that cohort and then uh lastly um each student student gets a classification as a graduate a Dropout or a non-graduate based on the coding that's entered for that student so your next chart shows our historical graduation rate hold on one second I'm sorry uh would you all like let the Pres presentation go and then ask questions or ask questions as presentation goes we can certainly we can certainly answer questions as we go whatever whatever the board prefer okay yeah thank you Chad um I do have one to on what L you said on the on the
042ESC question is that where you're going okay um So Lisa you just said that um an ESC student can stay until they're 22 years old like until their 22nd birthday or through their i' to give back to you on that I was just curious It's not that important if they turn 22 on August 20 I'll be happy to answer that question I'd be happy to answer thank you Mr Roberts I'd be happy to the year of their 22nd birthday would be their last year is what our our um district has has typically done oh the school year in which they turn 22 yes sir okay so does the when the when the state publishes these numbers obviously generally this is a massive generalization so take it for what it's worth but generally speaking ESC students
043are going to have a harder time to graduate in four years so does the state I mean I know they're not including that e percentage of es students into our graduation rate but even when it's reported out along with this graduation rate date do they report each District's percentage of es students because some districts in Florida don't really have that many ESC students which naturally is going to benefit their benefit their graduation rate potentially it could and you're you're probably thinking the fifth year graduates a lot of time are our students in our IND units who typically stay with us through those years they are considered a non-graduate and well if they're going for a standard diploma type of a thing but but yes they're a non-grad if they choose that they're counted as a
044non-graduate okay but um that's a perfect example like um you know a district that has a large indd population that's naturally going to hamper their graduation rate by the state so is I guess my question is is there any accounting for that ESC population when they publish graduation rates right go so we do have a a deferred diploma so one of the diploma options we're able to award students that may be on access points would be a standard diploma um that they would get on their fourth year like when they meet graduate uation requirements but then they're allowed to continue on until they're 22 if they meet requirements for certain programming okay so we also have students that are on a traditional program with an IEP um that graduate on time very often in fact
045I I don't know the numbers right off the top of my head but um they are also increasing along with our our general education graduation rates they're included within that right oh so those numbers are you can separate the state separates them out for in another column so speak c yeah okay great thanks Jad thanks L ume did you have a question yeah get okay just to tell on to that so you're saying a ESC student gets basically a modified diploma correct so the state offers multiple options for diplomas right so not just an ESC student we have um I don't know eight or 10 different diploma options we can offer students okay but this graduation rate that we're looking at today that includes any type of diploma the state issued a standard diploma yes
046a standard diploma versus a ESC diploma or whatever categorical that they would put that graduate in correct correct that would be all standard diplomas all standard okay Define standard then I can I can give you the specific codes if you would like but it's going to take a few minutes no that's all right I I've looked at the doe website and there are a number of types of diplomas so my question is in this 85.7 I'm not going to rip our record to shred here but of that percentage um do we know how many ESC graduates there were in that I don't know the number off the top of my head but assessment can pull those numbers we okay we do have that data that we could provide if the board wishes to review that
047data absolutely and it is included in our a in our 85.7 yes and so we have it broken down um you know by by all subgroups as the state does they do provide um that data by District as well um and in saying you know you don't look across the state and see districts at 100% because there are always various reasons why a student may not graduate in the four years I mean yes it's a number that we hope to rise to the highest level but we also as a school district work to meet the needs of each individual student and 100% may not graduate in four years yes we do get knocked down off that 100% because of that but if the end result that student earns their degree and it might take them
048a little longer then that still is a celebration it's just not going to be captured here in that number and no and that's why you don't see 100% in school districts you just don't um so this number could include a student that took five years so it it could right because we don't it it it was published just this year we could have a student that didn't graduate last year that's still working on requirements for graduation whether they be a student with disability or just a student that is still trying to master their assessments they may still be working on it and we do have pass for students who are still working towards a diploma and trying to meet some requirements um and then we don't later get that quote unquote credit they're not going
049to go back and add that into our graduation rate but still important for that student of course to earn that degree okay all right okay that's all thanks so my question was um as we were talking about like transfers and students obviously moving from a district school to District school is one thing right um but if if a student is has been three years in another District name it doesn't matter instate outstate whatever and they come here into their fourth year their senior year here minity County and they're already behind we are now going to be subject to that requirement whether they make it or not I don't care if they're if they're ESC or not whatever that goes on our record of whether they graduated or not and we only get them for x
050amount of months you know that one year let's say correct absolutely and and so and I only say that because obviously we're in a area of growth so we have families moving from other places right um standards may not be the same um we have migrant families we have immigrant I mean you don't know where so I guess my my my real question is and I don't know if this is going to be something that um every work on or not just another tat write down um like do we have that data broken down and maybe we do in this presentation later on but like do we have a broken down of like out of this 80 this percentage you know x amount of percent was in man County Schools all four years the ones
051that missed you know these nine this 9% only were here for a year like do we have capability of breaking that down to see it just being not that the state's going to say oh then you don't have to wor about those but I just I think it'd be interesting to see how much are we having to um replac from what they may have lost or maybe never were given and maybe never got that chance to learn Etc right what's the recovery right and I don't want to um speak for Mr McCarthy's work but he absolutely could um pull that information together if that's something the board would like to see um and I know that our principles and you'll hear um from Mrs Collins here shortly um they they go through every senior on
052their sheet if they did not graduate they know why um and so that work is done so I'm I'm imagining the principles could go to their spreadsheet and tell you well that student came in um in August of their senior year severely credit deficient um and and they have that information because we do try everything we can to still have that student reach their goal of graduation um and so they need to know that information which is why we really look at data as a whole but if we don't bring it down to each individual student level as as she'll get into um then you're not able to make the gains that you see happening at Southeast and some of our other high schools okay thank you chairman I I'll just add that U Mr
053McCarthy pulled that data at my request on the class of um 23 um and uh the data showed um that yes uh some of our non-graduates are recent arrivals to the district um but we also have non-graduates who are with us four years right which tells you that you have work to do and some of that influen some of the programming decisions we've made we haven't run that data uh on the um uh on the on the recent uh group um but certainly can okay thank you um Miss pH um I just wanted to point out also that have having sat in that classroom myself uh with those kids that this remember as we go through the year and we hear feedback on our testing the same thing holds true there um students that we
054may have not have had in our class quarter 1 we now have them Quarter Two they could have come from Michigan but now we are now responsible for their testing scores as well so um this is across the board it's not just High School it it affects your scored starting off with the the earliest times we do testing in elementary school um so this is something that we always have in our mix uh as we go forward as teachers and as as schools and the district um and so um I I know it does affect things but for for me looking at the big picture it's not really that much of an effect because as the superintendent said we have kids that have been with us since kindergarten who are still not able to graduate
055so um while it is I think interesting to see the numbers um I don't think it really has that much bearing on our results thank you um so I'm going to speak to our next uh graph that we have so um in looking at each cohort year sometimes the requirements are different so just wanted to point out um you can see our 24 um year and that's where we have our number of graduates non-g grads and dropouts and you can see the the increase we had in population as well um and a lot of that could have been that um postco time not the way everyone talk about it all the time but this was the year of those kids that were freshmen um during 20 when we sent everybody home for a little bit
056so that's that was in there but in 1920 and 2021 both of those years of graduation and graduation rates the state assessment was waved so while students had to have their credits and had to have their GPA they did not have any state Assessments in order to receive their diploma so the last year that was really similar in terms of what the requirements were was 1819 so you can see our increase in our number of grads in that range so just something to give you some perspective as we're looking at our rates and then the next state comparison shows again the years with the state assessment and where um we are achieving and closing that Gap with the state and you can see where the state was achieving where we were achieving um and as
057we continue to close that gap between where the state is at and where we are at uh and that was one of the challenges having U Been at very recently a high school principal were those students that we went to spring break and then we didn't come back and then we came back the next fall we had a several different modalities but any of those students who started with us are in our cohort and if we don't know where they may have gone they could have been counted for us as a drop out because we don't have them transferring somewhere else as Miss lion talked about or in another school so then they're a Dropout so when we sent students home if they didn't come back this is that graduating class so we're very proud
058of the students that we did find to get them across the stage question that's really interesting what you just said I didn't know that so if a student left either during covid or anytime correct and we as a school district don't capture where they're going if they move and they don't tell us where they went or maybe they went to work and found another path that's a Dropout so that's some of the hard work that our principes and our staffs did was trying to find those students and bring them back to graduate so of that part I'm really proud of our schools because that was a lot of hard work of finding because many of them did go and work for the family or they had to relocate based on things that occurred at that
059time this is that class I didn't know that thank you hold on M yeah um when a when a student leaves say Christmas break good example they're gone we come back to class and they're nowhere to be found they could have moved or whatever how long does it take maybe the school that they went to ask for records and get records cuz that would give us we could say okay they transfer but what percentage do you think of students don't ask for records I don't think I could guess to that we could potentially look at that usually our records between schools is pretty quick because a lot of is electronic if they do register to another school they'll reach out we be able to do that proper withdraw code of attri somewhere yes ma'am it's
060just a matter of coding them from one District to another correct so that would then count for that District so say they here and then they moved up to Tallahassee once we get those records They are withdrawn and they become part of that cohort of that school okay and part of their graduation rate yes ma'am okay and vice versa okay can I just add to that so um when there's records requests that's wonderful but sometimes there's not records requests because the child has not gone anywhere right so we've added some systems we' built some new systems this year to make sure that we're catching those students that they have been withdrawn or withdrawn themselves and haven't showed up anywhere else so that we can get them connected to their next place be back to their
061high school or back to something another option that we have here so our district reaches out to that student that didn't show up yes whether it's a phone call or probably multiple times many different ways if you can find might even be a knock on the door right I was going to say that even going to their residents okay absolutely all right absolutely so our next chart is um shows all of our schools and our changes over time of percentages and as you can see all of our schools made it a jump this year um I do want to point out while Lakewood Ranch and Parish um stayed very consistent as we spoke about earlier once you get above that 95 into that 97 Range that last percentage are those students like you spoke about
062Mr Cho who show up senior year and don't have all the credits who may have been a deferred diploma so once you get into those numbers we want to stick with those consistent numbers um so credit to them for the students that they maintained that high level and then you can see each school as they increased uh which was really fantastic for them question Miss Caro actually related more to the last slide but potentially this one too so did I understand correctly that if a student drops out of high school and then we don't know where they went that they we have to count them kind of in our records so apparently there's not a a rule that says look if a child doesn't show up for school for 30 days they've essentially they're considered
063to be with drawn they just stay on the books until until somehow we track them down or something that's correct and then there a Dropout for us if we don't locate where they are so they could show up halfway through their freshman year drop out at Christmas or their freshman year we never hear from them see and some and then we have to carry them all the way and they count as a as a what as a as a drop out a drop out yes sir and that counts against our grad raid is that right there must be somebody up there there there must be is there a like well the reason for that is have you ever heard of it I mean you've been around the game long enough you know that's where we
064have teams at our school that try and find where those students are whether they they call their house knock on a door find an aunt and uncle somebody to get some kind of tracking of where they are so we can find an end result of did they enroll somewhere were they successful did they go private school did they you know move or or did they choose to go a GED and even a GED um is considered a non for us even though they did get their general education diploma I mean there's probably somebody sitting in the office of High School graduation rate calculation At Doe right and somebody wrote a rule and it said a student drops out and you never hear from them again you still have to count them like somebody called that
065person and said this is a crazy rule why I I know I'm being a little fous but it's so bizarre and I've been around bureaucracies long enough to know that well there probably is a reason right that seems like a a ridiculous rule but somebody wrote it because at one time in the past there was a reason maybe for instance it forces you all to try and track them down and so the state doesn't want to let you off the hook and like well we'll force them to try but any thought on they ever heard ever I think exactly what you say the reason is we don't that all of our kids count from the day they start till the day they're done they all count and and we don't want them to get lost
066along the way so if we can find them and get them on a path and it may not be graduating from us but it could be getting them in a different opportunity then that's part of it you know we can't forget those kids that may have had something happen I think it's to make sure that we do keep track of every kid along the way and give them the best opportunity you would think after a semester or six months like we have not we've tried we've called we email went to their previous residents after 180 days you are now allowed to drop this person from the roles of your school system yeah anyway we're going up to Tallahassee right to talk to people I might have to bring that one up the second yeah the
067second question I had let me think I had another one too it was about graduation rates I'll it'll come up again I'm sorry can I tell goad um with regards to just to to uh tail on to what Mr Tatum said the district does have Dropout prevention specialists at most of our schools and I was wondering if you could give me an idea of what the number of those persons are and about what their case loads are so I I think um to to touch on it's a little bit broader so we do have graduation enhancement Texs we call them gets from elementary up a lot of our title schools um in secondary will'll have it but not everyone um but it really is a shared responsibility um we do bring in um the work
068of our school counselors our social workers um our school leaders are heavily involved in the process um so that when you do tap because when you're talking about um the size of a high school and looking at because the work doesn't start the senior year you're looking at student performance 9th 10th 11th and 12th grade and then figuring out how to um Target your at risk students who might be showing deficiency in credit GPA or attendance and then breaking those students up into manageable pieces to give to your school team so really the entire team then um comes into play to try to do Outreach for those students and then that school teams need extra support the social workers at the district level um can help do some of the knocking on the door and
069those types of of things to um try to re-engage the student and their family um Traditional High School isn't working we do have other options and having those conversations so it really is um we would not have been able to see the over three-point gain had the whole teams not not been engaged um in the process it's a it's a it's a large number to to re-engage some of the students did you have your thought I remember my question yes so of all the reports hundreds of them that we send up to FD FLD dooe I'm surprised there's not like a a Statewide or maybe there is but Statewide student database where if you know Johnny Jones withdraws or just leaves Manatee County but he shows up in I don't know Broward County that we
070can ping the database and go oh yeah he's over there is does such a thing exist or does it that is part of our teamwork with our data collection between our um reporting with our state reporting that is part of the work that our schools do and our registrars and our student information system they do review student by student to make sure we have the accurate codes with what the state may have to see did we have a student register that somewhere fell through those cracks so that's part of that fine tooth comb that we do with our students so yes sir what I'm saying is K let's say Johnny Smith withdraws or just leaves and we don't hear from him and can we put his name into a database or his whatever student some
071some type of identification go oh yeah he's over there in Broward County like is there a you would think that there would be a state database like that for this type of reason with all the reports we apparently such a thing does not exist You Know M student yes so there is a file that we can review once a year once a year so we take a look at those students we look for those children but I mean the name of the game is looking for children here so we are always looking to find where our children are when when we can hand them off nicely with a records request or something else then we can rest easy but uh I'm sure all the principles will tell you it's the ones that we don't know
072where they went that keep us up at night and we look for these children in many different ways and many different levels and one of those places is the state file that we see annually okay great okay to that's all I have thank you student doesn't show up for how long to the end of the school year you have to keep that record open to the end of the school year to you can code them has Dropout we have we have a treny process that we follow for our students that goes along with our attendance policies right so if a student is just not attending any longer that's different than than you're trying to find the student well it's actually pretty similar okay when they stop showing up for I you know Miss Miss con
073can speak more specifically to it um but when they stop coming for an amount of time when we start worrying about them right they've been gone for two weeks a month now you you've not been able you you've reached out at what point you go to the landlord oh they moved out a month ago can you code them as a drop out then or a well withdrawn from your District that's the hypothetical I guess I'm looking for is you can but they still count as a as a Dropout for you until you change the code of where they may have then re-enrolled or re-engaged and you wait till the end of the year to do that we can do it at we we look at it all the time once okay and say they show
074up you can go back in and change the record they're back in attendance we would them we would re or we would change the code that now they transferred somewhere else all right so we could accurately depict where they are because they may have left here couldn't find housing for a month lived with somebody may not even got registered out of school yet because they didn't know where they're going to go so all right that all right that helps me understand yeah they're not once they withdraw and drop out they're done if we can re-engage them we can change their code and bring them back in absolutely perfect but if you never find them they count right there's no drop out drop and it counts against our graduation rate right yes okay okay so some
075of the um contributions to growth and um Dr weong spoke about this when we talked about realigning some of our systems systems um so we focused on of course clar Clarity and consistency alignment and student focused initiatives um within that really the heartbeat of all of this work takes place with our teachers the work um that our teachers do and our school leaders our principls assistant principles and all that support staff that I was mentioning they are the heart of all of this work um our job in District teams is to support them um and we do that by having clear expectations and Communications our alignment of resources um which we um support you see written in the um sdmc strategic plan and then our student Focus initiatives if everything we're doing has that student
076focus and we believe will positively impact students whether it be graduation rate um learning college career Readiness um if we stay on that Focus then we'll um support what we believe is the heartbeat of our organization and a little more detail um and we spoke about this earlier is really looking at a plan for every students so our assessment team which is vital um Evan McCarthy and his team um to give us accurate data sheets to monitor individual uh progress towards graduation and I know that um student services um director lion and our principles rely on this and they have a systematic way to review it um repeatedly throughout the year and will'll talk about that as well um of course our assessment schedules and um how we really look how can students achieve I
077mean Evan and his team Evan McCarthy and his team go through um Student Success on each time we give any sort of assessment and if it's not meeting students need then we have conversations about what we could do better either in preparing the students for it or offering a different type of assessment um of course multiple diploma options um individual student and family engagement really um helping families understand and there's been a lot more um Outreach to families and trying to re-engage their students um in some sort of path towards a diploma um professional learning we've increased professional learning both with um um all student needs but especially with students with disabilities and our elll students and we've seen growth in both areas um for the 23 24 graduation rate um Recruitment and Retention of
078Highly Effective teachers again that's your heartbeat that is research shows it um that is your um strongest strongest effect on student achievement and monitoring of credit recover opportunities and learning outside the traditional high school schedule and Mrs gar will speak a little bit more about that we're really looking um into students the traditional day is not working for them what else can we offer them um and we've created additional Pathways um within our own district with contracted with a charter site um to really meet individual student needs so to speak to that and and concert with uh Miss lion we do monthly data monitoring on our with our schools with where their data is those files you talk about with each individual student who's on track who's not on track what can we do individually
079for those and each of the schools have a team with doing that and pulling together with what our um best objective is for that student uh graduation tracker we can we're already monitoring obviously this year for next year's graduation rate we can see where we are and we're already closing gaps there we're really excited even about this next class and what we're able to do um and we're looking at increased opportunities for credit recovery um all of you know that high school's been about the same for many many years but maybe our society has changed a little bit so we're looking outside of the box thinking we have some of our students who may need to work and they may need different hours to go to school so we've been piloting a program at bashore
080High um and as well as some smaller venues at our other high schools and meeting with the High School principles of okay do we need to adjust and the student come in this period and work certain periods or work after hours based on their schedule and uh Contracting with some of our teachers to work those different hours to better um facilitate our students and what they need you know the 7:30 to 2:30 day may not work for every student we may need to look at things differently so we've tried to be very creative while still giving them that full academic experience of what they're doing and so I know Lisa you can talk to that a little bit as well as some of the alternative systems that we have quick question from yeah Sharon if
081you could could you talk about what's going on at bore how long it's been going on what their schedule that's a really exciting idea it yeah so it is exciting we're excited about it and so um this this year we started that at bashore so what they're actually doing and Mr Cooper speaks to it as like kind of a a Chinese menu so to speak where I'm going to pick one from this column and one from this column or like a morgas board you know so they get each individually and see what they need and they have contracted Beyond a longer day so they go into like an eighth nth period of the day even sometimes 10 so student may come in fourth period and then they stay through that ninth period or maybe they're
082coming to us credit deficient from somewhere else and so they're there their full day but then an additional two three hours afterward for the periods that they need so it's individualized to each student with that they've got teachers that are staying or either working those extra hours or working in additional period that they'll do that and we're doing similar at other high schools we've initiated some of those um at our high schools the second semester where they'll take those classes that they need to go into that and we're reporting what periods they are there but it's just a different day um that is more successful and and we did this at vasher we brought in some of the students individually and what do we need to do and just gave them I think at the
083end of day hope um they see that if they see too many things they have to reach they may drop out or give up because they don't think they're going to get there so we're able to meet with them individually and give them hope of like here's your path you do these things and this is where you'll be able to get at the end of the year and it has brought in quite a few students as well so it's been very exciting it's just this year we started it in the fall we we launched it second quarter and how many kids roughly are taking advantage of it oh I'd have to check specifically I can get that for you that's okay um chat if I may um Lori you know that for many years I've
084been banging the drum for start school later um and that you know all that adolescent brain science about the changes their brain is going through and that's and that's why they have to that's why their sleep cycle changes it's not that they're lazy and they're sleeping all day it's because they need their biological Cloud maybe that's not the right term but their circadian rhythm is changing there you go and so yeah um but uh that's I mean to have the opportunity to come in perod or something they work they may work the circum some of that is their their when their job is or they have to care for younger children or something like that so we've just tried to be um looking at and some of them need a longer day or more periods
085where they can be engaged the I'm sorry me do cut you off um do they have to have a mitigating reason to switch their daily schedule or they can just choose it on their own they do um we are looking at this more for our students that are that credit deficient that we're trying to get them before we expand it that's why we're piloting it because you don't want to just go in so full force and not really vet it to make sure that is the the right pathway for them so that's why we've started at one place just with some this to see how it how it grows okay yeah I'm sure if you throw the all the kids at b or high like you have 500 kids like yeah I want to come
086in at 10 a.m. not 7:30 um yeah so got to take we're very specific with with where that's at and what it is no it's it's a huge step in the right direction that's really exciting to hear about thank you thanks J yeah did you well really just to add to that I think we've said it multiple times today and we'll keep saying it is we have to look at the individual child we have to look for that one specific student and make sure that what we're offering them is something that they're able to receive so instead of building programming and saying this has to work for all of our children we look at each individual child and say how can we work this out how can we meet your needs and still keep our
087rigorous standards so that they can meet the requirements that are necessary to graduate Mrs Collins if you would share some of your huge success that you've seen at South so the work has been very rewarding for all the high schools I can speak to Southeast success but I want to also congratulate all of my high school colleagues who have done an amazing job with the graduation rate first of all we never underestimate the power of the public school teacher uh The Human Side of these numbers that you see in fact is that every student at Southeast has an advocate on campus who sees in the student what they sometimes can't see in themselves um having Advocates is very important I have one teacher who just showed up tonight she is my Dropout prevention teacher and
088she came because she wanted to see if there's anything she can add to her pgp plan for the year so that she can grow as a teacher even though she's a huge part of this plot chart going all the way up to 89% which is so exciting for us um secondly different Pathways so according to my student principal leadership group who are my seniors that I call in to get advice from um I spoke to them when the press released came out and I said what do you think the difference is you've been here for 4 years you've seen this Arrow go up what's the difference and 2025 senior David told me Miss Collins the messaging is the same from one teacher to the school counselor to the graduation coach the same for me and
089my friends we going to graduate the pay pathway may be different but the diploma is the same so the adults on campus let students students know that there are many Pathways if it's extended day tassel bound program remediation with core teachers or 18 credit option we will put each student on the best path for him or herself and then third um the testing Florida is still one of six states that requires the reading and Algebra test to graduate and so we have prioritized the opportunities for concordance scores from CLT to sat to act to fast reach takes all classes for seniors have the dates posted so that the students can see and it's visible to all students uh one teacher even has a signature wall so that when a senior gets the score they sign
090their name and when that happens a senior sees another senior's name and says if he can do it she can do it I can do it as well so overall that's the message to every Southeast seminal you can too our systems are in place for future cohorts and we expect to only go up from here that's awesome can I just say go NOS as always as always gos did you have a question again or were you just got off um no I'm I'm still on but I I have um I do um Jinger if you could you had an acronym in there I don't know the CLT CLT is a classical learning test it's another way to get a concordant score conord score okay I just didn't know that one a new one um yeah
091I'm I'm new I got new things to learn I'm back um real quick I'm on this I'm on this graph right here yes if um I think there's a really like important data point on here y um anytime we look at data whether it's assessment or graduation rate I think it's important that we look at not just did Manatee County go up or down but it's important like what is the state doing so for example like um I'll do the whole District Top Line um graduation rate on the chart is 86% that's a in a one year that's a 4% bump positive 4% um the state average in the same time period is 1.7% so we are outpacing the State of Florida so I I think that's really important context and then when you think
092of that the state went up 1.7% and Southeast High went up 12% that's just really amazing work by we had a Long Way to Grow I will tell you so when you see the amazing also because I want to point out Parish my child is a senior at Parish an early grad who the school counselor gave him his own pathway so I want to congratulate all schools but um yes we we had a long way to grow at Southeast High School dropping in the 70s um you know again after covid and I don't want to bring that up but I do because we had to find those children we had to look for them and some of them it doesn't take the 15 days that we can withdraw a child but it's still hurts us
093as a Dropout um it can be a year it can be two years before we finally make contact and we did bring students back to school to graduate if they're on my campus with my teachers they're going to graduate it's when we don't know where they are and getting them back to school or back to be the best path for them and I will tell you we were at 89.6 we ended up at 89.2 with the state because one child they had marked as a graduate was not but that child did go and get their GED so even though they didn't count as aad uate for me that child made a difference in their life so looking at these numbers I know the board meeting you really look at the data I also want you
094to see The Human Side of this from a School principal's Viewpoint because we look at that child no matter how it impacts our numbers and um really finding those kids and bring them back on campus is where you see that growth great thank you good work relationship relationships Great lead in from the first time I toured Southeast when I I first got there way what two years ago you was telling me about a student that was having a difficult time was ready to drop out and you just kept saying to them nope you're going to graduate you're going to graduate and anytime I visited the campus after that I try to make it a point to remember to see him you're going to graduate you're going to graduate and it is about just that one
095touch Point might make a difference and that was the student I kept looking for at the graduation for 22 23 is when that was and he graduated so it's not just about the data it is about the student and I when I saw the numbers come out I'm like yep I can see how Southeast has made such a drastic change and I get the CO but just from my first year there to my second year there just the attitude and staff and students the relationship between staff and students is is way different so I think you're doing great things there I want to personally congratulate you and yeah go NS and it could be the turf too you got a new Turf the whole new outlook all of it is going up uh I'm just
096saying do matter something like that can make a difference in in the attitude of a student you know that football player is going to say I can get to that end zone I can get to that you know make that touchdown because that one thing made them motivated them more so I just want to say congratulations to you and to all of your staff because that's what helped I think Propel our numbers absolutely I mean we all did good but that 11 12 points is a huge uh uptick in our overall data so I just want to say thank you m CH M Collins congratulations excellent work and all of you really but right you get the number on your chart there man so and your staff whoever that is they there so if you
097could address something for me real quick this actually the these numbers when they came out publicly seem to circulate through the community pretty quickly and I got kind of a cynical text message from someone and they said well all you got to do is inflate those grades that's really easy and I thought that's kind of cynical but could you address that and just to help the some people at least in the community that might be have thinking along those lines that well the reason we did so well as we just inflate grades and we I don't think that that's true but help us understand what some of the things that what what would you what would you tell the public let's put it that way if someone came to you and said well miss colins
098you just inflated your kids' grades and you made that happen I mean how would you address the the public in that way I would tell them that neighboring districts um are having celebr ations for their schools that have made these gains so I'm waiting for the celebration but of course I'm willing to take the Heat and and talk about any criticism like that um GPA is just one piece of graduation so there's no way to inflate um Quick Fix whatever that criticism may be there is no one way to fix that or else every school would be at 100% graduation so that is hard work you see the numbers I see the faces um and then I could show you absolutely how they made those gains and plus they have to pass the English test
099and the math there's many requirements there's lots of checks and balances there absolutely so thanks for addressing that I don't want to take away in any way shape or form your accomplishment I just if one person texted it to me I'm sure there might be others in the community that are thinking that and that's just absolutely not the case you the staff the members of the school system and all these High School Employees have have made this happen in a fair and just way and they should all be congratulated for their effort so thanks for taking a moment to address that and student grit if I don't talk about student grit um I will tell you my students at Southeast are tough I had a uh you know that I came from middle school as
100a principal and so when I went to Southeast High School my eighth graders followed me and one of my young ladies lost her brother who was a senior at Southeast um this Summer that she was to become a freshman at Southeast she started her first semester nth grade with a 0.0 GPA she failed every course she had all A's and Bs in middle school because I knew her and because I could keep track of her um she is going to be an early grad she's our goalie for soccer and she's doing amazing things because we would not let her fail so my student grit at Southeast High School is very very strong and so that's the reason along with the advocating for our students along with the um making sure they have hope in their
101testing and also the different pathway so that they all earn the diploma but maybe a little bit different way um that's the reason that we made those gains thank you you miss um having worked with ginger at Southeast High School I was a teacher there for six years I worked with Miss Spencer who's hiding out in the back uh and did she's she shushing me um and and did drop out prevention with her after school one day a week for for a semester and worked with those kids my myself um and having taught Juniors and seniors and having to drag them across the Finish Line to graduation anybody who says that they're inflating their numbers needs to to maybe take a step back and pay a little bit of attention to how hard the staff
102works and how hard as Mrs Colin said how hard those kids work they work so hard um I had Juniors and seniors who still at the end of their High School career had not passed State Testing so that they could walk they had everything else but they didn't have that State Testing and every day we did test prep for SAT and ACT so that they could pass one of those tests and then to stand there and to be able to tell them guess what you passed the test and to have them burst into tears and fall on you and cry on your shoulder because they are so happy that they are literally crying having passed this stupid stupid test stupid test so that they could walk although they did everything else that is incredible as
103both a teacher as a staff person um anybody who has worked with kids to see that is incredible and anyone who you know come see me I'll tell you all about it anybody who has complaints and doesn't know because I have seen them do it and it's amazing and I am so proud of every single kid at Southeast High School and all of our schools for their hard work in in doing this because that is absolutely amazing thank you and bore was plus nine too I mean you did great second place go to bore so that was great too thank you and um Lisa line will go through um what we're doing to continue success build success so we're as Mrs Garo said earlier we're not done um we worked really hard already this fall
104and and hope to come back to you this time next year with even um stronger numbers as we continue um to refine what we do for every student right so we're continuing our work and uh some of the things that we have in place and plans moving forward um we're not just monitoring the senior cohort we're not just looking at those seniors right now we're looking at all four years all the time so that's one of the big things that we've implemented is really looking at our freshmen our freshmen now have a GPA so we can see which ones are in trouble and which ones are on track so if we can start early interventions in ninth grade and get those kids corrected and back on track then we're going to have less less work
105to do their senior year they might be more willing to stay engaged throughout their high school so looking at all four cohorts is very important and I I really believe that it starts with the transition from eighth grade into nth grade so I was previously a middle School assistant principal and I could tell you in sixth grade who was going to have a hard time in ninth grade so we want to make sure that those conversations are happening between our eighth grade uh administrators and support staff to our ninth grade teams rece receiving those students to make sure that their schedule is on point and they have someone that they're connected to before they even set foot on that campus to set them up for Success from day one or day negative one um we're
106looking at summer programming for those students and then Main maintaining that monitoring for those freshmen throughout the entire school year um we are growing our zel program in elementary and in secondary schools uh this is our College and Career um platform that we are using uh if we can help students see that an education is is benefiting them for their life and not just what they're doing in the moment we can get more Buy in on what they're doing more participation better programming for those students so they can get what they need we're going to continue to review concorded score opportunities we work very closely with our assessment Department um and our concordance scores change um next year I think we have some different tests that we'll be able to use um so staying up
107with those and making sure that students have every opportunity to meet those concordant requirements we're utilizing branching Minds in the mtss process to build those academic needs um for our students and again looking at each individual student throughout their whole time in high school but also all the way back into kindergarten making sure this is just the culminating event that high school gets but this is really about our students education from the moment they start with us um we're making sure that our students have access to Credit Recovery coursework um so not waiting until their senior year if they need it sooner than that we want to make sure that students have access to to uh course correct and then get right back on track and into their programming and then of course we talked
108about our alternative scheduling opportunities and our extended day programming and um We are continuing to meet with our schools so we meet very regularly with our schools and we review our tracking sheets we look at at ways to support our our students throughout the school year based on what's going on at that time thank you did you have I just need to stand correctly that Horizon's actually took second place with 11% yeah and then we have I mean everybody did well awesome but there we go all right before before we let you go just a couple things real quick I I'd say number one um that ex into this side right here that extended day alternative scheduling and opportunities I know we just we're we're just piloting it we're just doing it right um but
109we're seeing um Charter Schools come in and different with these different Avenues and things like that and be successful and and this is something I do think that we have to start um rethinking education and so kudos to the staff be able to say hey look this is something we need um and it's not for every child right it's not going to be for every student um and like Mr K said I don't think it's for anybody just say I don't want to wake up at 7:30 give me at 10: I don't I don't think that's necessarily the way that we do it but I think giving that option for students that really do need it um is extremely important and and I'll say as it as a and I know we're not necessarily probably
110doing this now because we're still piloting it um but probably for next year this is a this potentially could be a choice comp opponent right like hey I'm at Parish high school but I really need to do this or whatever they don't offer this alternative schooling can I Choice the bore because this is what you know to be able to move myself forward for family reasons or whatever right so I think this is something that that um uh is extremely exciting for in the future and I want to say this for for a second um Miss Felton you know brought up the the help helping after school and doing the part of that and and I just want to say um the success teams that are there and I'm sure miss Collins can Kudo this
111but um as a coach um and there's other coaches in the room and past coaches um they make a huge difference in in the students lives athletically put on one thing but you got to have the right GPA to play you got to have the right GPA to be in in your your bands etc etc um and so I don't know if they get as much credit um as as they are but we monitored kids we we we sat on on hot summer days and and made sure they were on FLVS or whatever right um and and so um you know I think that's that's still part of the success teams right there's a lot of individuals there's a lot of people but I want to give the the kudos to to to our coaches
112to our extracurricular people out there that because they're pushing these these kids no doubt and um and I don't think sometimes you know we just think oh that's just a basketball coach just a football coach or soccer coach whatever but um but they're pushing kids and they're changing kids' lives so numbers are great and um like like they're saying the vestment world to the Moon right like that's what we want to do right to the moon so anybody else I don't see anyone else lit up to see other than to your point the cynical person I'll bet that person hasn't been hasn't walked a school hall and because I I'm probably the same persons that been yeah I would almost say um and that's what I would say to the public if you haven't walked
113the halls or read to a student or coached a student in at forever and some that have commented don't even have children so that's the truth um go to a school one day a week or once one month one day a month even and see these are kids um just like the uh good news moments here those kids are going to be our future brain surgeons you know seriously think about that when I was just astonished I mean we just did this thing this week with uh well I'll talk about Bor comments but this is what we invest our dollars in and this is how we cultivate our community because a lot of people never leave Florida they end up being our professionals here in our County in our state so yeah I'd say to
114the cynical to go walk a school sometime anyway Amen to that thank you all very much appreciate it than you so much we are hour and a half in so we're going to take our mandatory bathroom break [Music] there we go we're back we're back all right um thank you for obliging me in that uh recess so item number uh moving on to item number uh 11 uh consent item superintendent thank you chairman I recommend approving of the consent agenda for the January 21st 2025 school board meeting so moved second doesn't matter doesn't matter uh so we got a motion and a second are you granis did you do the mo motion there we go oh wow I'm way I'm back on the minutes all you have to do is hit motion yeah think you
115just got the bottom if you hit there you go all right so we got our motion second in granicus thank you Laura so let's go ahead and vote on these consent items and that passes five to zero I real quickly I just want everybody to know and I know Dr weong will bring this up and maybe other board members um but before we move on to new business you know consent typically past things that are in large um quantities things like that but I want everybody to know that um in that consent agenda right there um as a board we sat here and talked about Mill and safety is going to be a part of that Etc um and we've we've expanded our safety in this District um by purchasing the the new uh evolved
116systems more evolved systems for middle schools so um we absolutely that's what we set out to do the voters passed that for us um and we made sure that that it happened um and and to keep our kids and our faculty as safe as possible um is an utmost goal for the district so I just want I don't want that to go by too quick as we as we move for board through the meeting so thank you to the voters um thank you to staff thank you for board we approved um more safety for our students so moving on item number 14 new business nonconsent items um item number one approval of budget amendments for November 2024 uh superintendent thank you chairman I recommend approval of the budget amendments for November 2024 so moves second
117second got motion second uh Miss it's yours I got go ahead for a second I I can hear you but I don't know if the volume's actually on but okay all right well the month of November uh the for the district we had 468 budget amendments that was related to approximately 2200 chart strings and out of that four of those chart strings were over $1 million these were all related uh to um transactions in the general fund uh the uh they were related to recognizing the revenues and expenses of the education development grant for the MTC Hangar and there was also movement between the uh reserved budget for the AP and Ace and we those were pushed out to the schools thank you I know you you went over those with us at the at
118our board briefings um I don't see any questions uh for the Amendments for November 2024 we have a motion a second so let's go and vote on the approval of the budget amendments for November 2024 and that passes 5 to zero item number two Dr R thank you chairman I recommend approval of the annual comprehensive financial report and all official Parts thereof for the fiscal year ended June 30th 2024 so moves I like do a second Mo second we'll go back and forth and and I can go ahead and speak to this one as well too so this audit report was um uh uh discussed uh with the audit committee Cherry Becker performed the audit for the district um this was for fiscal year end June 30 2024 uh this particular report uh was a
119clean report uh and so uh there were no audit adjustments and there were no findings the two Federal programs that were audited this year was one the um the s or the um stabilization uh Grant and or Grant and then also the special education cluster uh program as well so both those were the two Federal programs audit to this year great thank you all right so we have our motion our second I don't see any questions let's go ahead and vote on the approval of the act for and it passes 5 to zero thank you um moving on to item number three uh Dr we thank you I recommend approval of the district's School internal accounts audit report for the year ended June 30th 2024 so moved second all right and Miss sers to you
120again I can speak to this report as well too so this audit report was on the schools internal accounts uh this is um separately done and required um by a state rule to be audited separately it is actually show shows up in the column in inside of the annual comprehensive report underneath one of the special Revenue funds U that's uh presented in that particular statement so this is just a separate report report on those schools additionally there were were no audit adjustments related to this report and um it was a clean of opinion as well too so no findings right reportable findings no reportable findings I'll put it that way gotcha thank you um seeing no one lit up to speak again we we've gone over this in our board briefings and appreciate all the
121work that that's done from your staff so thank you very much Miss seller so let's go ahead and vote on the approval of the district's internal accounts audit report that passes five to zero uh moving on to item number four uh Dr we thank you chairman I recommend that the board select a campus name for the Barbara a harvey K through 8 campus that will serve grades K through3 beginning in 201226 I'll make the motion I discussion yeah well there'll be a discussion yeah we got a motion and second for the discussion motion and second by Miss Felton um I'll say I'll I'll say by on the board docs attached you know we sat as a board and said we want the staff and the input from the the the stakeholders there um and on
122the board docs it it has the names and the results barbar a harvey K great primary campus um is was the number one vote getter um and so Miss spray you had a a comment and then yeah Miss at the time um I failed to bring up what I thought would be a good name for that campus and it was Barbara Harvey core because that is the core uh function of Education instead of primary I was going to say core I think primary is a little three syllable Barbara Harvey uh what is it Barbara Harvey K through a k through3 primary I was just going to recommend maybe saying it Barbara Harvey K through K through3 cor instead of primary but I understand it didn't go out to the public and I see that they
123did do the votes but I wanted to get the board's perspective on maybe doing just Prim the core instead of primarying okay you sorry y so although I think it's my opinion I think it's I I don't think that's a bad name I think that we've got to stick with what we what we asked we asked them to come up with it right um and so my my my uh choice would be to go with what the stakeholders put out there right so sure I don't know if anybody else no um fine if not it's it's you okay say I still have my hand up yeah all right so um when we first discussed this um and I'm sure everybody remembers I argued against uh naming the uh upper campus after the development in which
124it's located uh because the stakeholders called it the upper school and the primary school um and I wanted them to have an opinion in this um if you look at the comments that have come along with this as well they still are calling at the upper school and Primary School um in the comments is that a lot of them are referencing it um in the uh the suggestions that were compiled uh on this forum they have uh again 152 respondents uh asking for it to be called the primary campus 70 for moccas wallow Road at moccasin wallow road 65 for at Copperstone and then an assortment of other things um myself I uh actually was very interested in one of the comments in here in which uh one of the respondents said that copper to
125name it uh at Copperstone because the land was donated versus uh Pat Neil making you pay for the other land which is actually not quite accurate I believe the land for the upper campus came from a different developer is that or did it come from Mr Neil okay all right so I wasn't quite sure where that was um so um at the recommendation of the um that I'm would be in favor of either at moccas wallow Road or at Copperstone um I believe that the the campus family will continue to call it the upper school and lower school regardless of what name we give the building um but uh if we it needs a building name uh as I had requested so uh either of those I would be fine with but not primary so
126you're wavering from primary uh no not primary okay right so okay so Miss Felton you're you don't you would prefer not to go with primary even though that was a top vote getter right and um I believe they're going to call it that anyway so uh but for directional purposes in terms of somebody driving around um Mox and wallow road is where the school is so which is why I would support that most um but what going to call it is what they're going to call it yeah as far as cor is spr I'm not when I hear that word I doesn't it's a afterthought don't Ponder on it very long I I wanted to address it I it was an afterthought and I talked to the superintendent about that you know so it's all
127right is copper Stone the name of the development right there is that the Housing Development correct it's um if you go out of the school entrance and turn left there's the gate for Copperstone so why not if we really want to make it spec which I like the idea of tying it to neighborhoods because moxon Hollow Road's a big long road why not why not use copper Stone as you have is there a reason no I'm fine with that I am too okay do we make a motion on what we we have no have we're in discussion we're in discussion yeah yeah as far as it naked okay I would go to Copper with Copperstone just because it ties it I mean if you know where the Copperstone neighborhood is and you know where that
128school is just like if you know where North River Ranch is you know where the school is but if that's the idea is to tie it to some geographic location that would be the most specific but these are not follow my swords issues for me I'll go with the flow so to speak you know make a motion for yeah you want to make a motion he does or do you have some I do I would like to make one comment I'm say um just like Mr Tatum said I'm you know I'm I'm pretty uh flexible here but I do want to take a moment to highlight the creativity of our respondents oh my goodness those were fabulous I really do want to I you know these are always so good like Heather said it's you
129know it's just like you go straight to the comments you know like look at the results first straight to the comments and I don't think it's gonna get three votes but Barbara a harvey OG yeah I me that is one my name right there she is an OG perhaps to Barbara Harvey uh no but I um I kind I like primary because that's what people are using but excuse me but the uh rational around around Copperstone makes sense to me too so um I could support either one of those if I can't get three votes for Barbara Harvey make so you want to make a motion so I will go ahead and make a motion that we uh name the car current uh original Campus of Barbara Harvey K8 as uh Barbara Harvey K8 at
130Copperstone a second we have a motion in a second I don't see any other further discussion so uh Miss Cox you have that are you doing your motion on okay I clicked it the request of speaker you should oh I'm sorry I didn't see it up there I don't it's just yeah take I would throw in the K through three K3 well it's no it's still Barbara Harvey K8 the K through3 campus which is the current campus but I would just make sure that's in there that the K right and i' take out the second campus we have Barbara Harvey K8 we we chose to name it Barbara Harvey K8 at North River Ranch so this should be Barbara Harve K8 at Copper to be consistent right that looks good take out the second campus
131it doesn't say second after K8 take campus out so it just says at Copperstone there you go perfect all right we good y yes all right thank you Miss Cox just vote on the motion to name the current Campus of Barbara Harvey the Barbara Harvey K8 at Copper that passes five to zero get a all right uh item number five Dr weisson thank you chairman I recommend approval of revisions to the job description for director of purchasing so moved second do a motion a second uh Dr W you want to explain did you okay for folks uh what this entails uh thank you chairman um this is a U update uh to a job description that is currently vacant uh we're in the process of uh searching for our next director of purchasing uh and
132as I've done on prior occasions when we have a vacancy it's a good time to take a look at the job description and um sometimes there's little cleanups sometimes there are uh changes to job duties and um various titles uh there's no Financial impact here the salary schedule Remains the Same thank you so moved second yeah we so ready to we're ready to go ahead and vote I'm behind oh sorry on the approval revisions to job description director purchasing oh do that and that passes five to zero item number six uh superintendent why thank you chairman I recommend approval of the revision of the job description uh of director Communications family and Community engagement to director Communications so moved I'll second so we have motion and a second um Dr W you want to explain
133this one too yes chairman thank you um uh board members as you're aware uh our current uh director of communications uh and uh community and family engagement Mike Barber has announced to the leadership team that he uh intends to retire uh on June 30th uh as scheduled that that was always his plan was to finish up um we uh want to um update this job description uh to get it ready for um posting later this week I want a long lead time uh to search for uh the right candidate um upon uh reflection we did narrow the title to director of communications there was a time when uh some school districts operated without this type of function uh just the communications part is more than a full-time job with with so many different um communication
134channels now and the changing school choice landscape and so we really want to focus on um on finding the best Communications professional to come in and represent our school district so uh these uh changes um I think position us well uh to advertise this position and and attract great candidates uh and again there's no Financial impact there's no change to the salary schedule right thank you yeah um Mr Barber's done a great job in the district and uh but I look forward to uh to seeing the candidates that come into this um and uh to to to replace him so let's go and vote we got our nobody's up uh to speak let's go and vote on the revision of the director of communications and that passes five to zero uh brings us on to
135item number seven we do have a public comment and that is uh Dr Wood thank you Mr chairman fellow board members my name is Dr Skip will Hoy I'm a 26 year veteran of the school district my tenure with the district actually goes back 30 years to when I was hired as a Dean at Manatee High School it really goes all the way back to 1972 when I first stepped foot into Miss bucks kindergarten classroom of b elementary school I'll go back along way with the district I'm here this evening because the superintendent is recommending my termination because I've chosen to fight this decision he's recommending that I go on unpaid leave petting the outcome of a hearing by the state that I've been forced to file regarding the allegation of excessive force that is
136the impetus for the superintendent's recommendation I disagree with those terms or disagree with those terms in the strongest possible way I was attacked and threatened by a student with an extensive violent history uh doing the same to school staff and even law enforcement at no time did I use excessive force with this student and I think that's clear based on the video I broke no law and committed no Act of abuse as evidenced by the refusal of DCF and local law enforcement to even investigate this situation I broke no District policy according to the district's own investigative conclusions I find that the superintendent's recommendation for my termination is nothing more than a malicious and unjustified attempt to finally remove me following a long line of of targeted Behavior Uh by both himself and our former
137superintendent and I intend to provide primacia evidence to support this at a more appropriate time deciding that uh this is not the strongest case the superintendant decided to pile on my entire disciplinary history I can only assure you that these cases are all involving situations of of of of ridiculous and absurd and false allegations uh incompetent investigating by our HR staff and multiple violations of my civil rights I have contemporaneous rebuttal statements for each one of these incidents and can provide Witnesses who will test to the veracity of those rebuttal and whose own statements of the time were either never considered or were taken so that's one thing to consider about that as well so as far as my past history there's a lot to be uh to be taken in there throughout my entire
138employment uh history uh I have dedicated I my life to this District I've served this district with distinction and our community with distinction over those 26 years uh I have received nothing but the highest possible evaluation on my personel evaluation every single year in my more than 20 years at the district level I brought millions of dollars to this District through grants that I've written and I've worked hundreds of hours every summer off the clock to ensure that our district remained Mission ready throughout the entire school year I'm a 247 guy and I've been that way for a long time I consider myself to be well-liked by the vast majority of my colleagues I also am well respected by those same colleagues and more importantly I've uh made a difference in the lives of thousands
139of families and children and over the years through my work I have dedicated my life to this organization and to my serving my own Hometown Community I find it both unconscionable and reprehensible that I would be faced after 30 years nearly 30 years of dedicated service and a lifetime of affiliation that I would be faced with the manner of termination that I'm facing right now without even a single conversation to agree with the superintendent's recommendation not only breathes life into these faulty allegations but it will create a financial hardship enduring one for me as this is my only source of income and I'll be forced into an immediate and early retirement such a decision Also may greatly jeopardize and may even eliminate my ability to seek Justice in this manner I want to thank you
140guys for the opportunity to be up here this evening thank you thank thank you that was our only uh public comment for item number seven um so I send it over to you Dr weong thank you chairman I recommend approval to place employee VW on unpaid administrative leave pending a hearing on the merits well I'll make the motion so that we can have a discussion about it it doesn't mean that I'll second for the same reason but I'm in favor of it necessarily but okay so we have a motion and a second um Mr D yes thank you chair I just want to remind the board the the uh action before you the motion is limited to just voting on the superintendent's request to place uh the employee on unpaid administratively pending a hearing on
141the merits and the the hearing is with doah also you should not be discussing the merits of the case because as you know from earlier today uh these cases end up back with the school board or can end up back with the school board so you have to remain neutral in that regard um so the so the motion is just placing the employee on unpaid administrative leave pending the DOA hearing and that's been the practice of the school district for forever and pretty much around the state otherwise people would be getting paid and as you know these things can go on in a while um I just wanted to clarify that thank you all right um I don't see any board members that to speak unless we just haven't hit our Gran yet I'm up
142yeah go ahead I just had a couple of questions for the lawyers um U Mr D you were saying that this is this is a regular procedure to place a an employee pending leave or on unpaid leave pending their hearing is that correct that's correct and uh typically how long do it does it take between now say and when the um subject is able to receive their hearing guess Mr chairman yes it is difficult to give you an estimate in all cases on how long it takes DOA to hear what of these a rough estimate is 90 to 120 days I say are you done or you have more I'm sorry I'm Rel logging in to granted so um I'm I'm done at the moment okay you sure oh sorry yeah okay we can always
143come back yep go ahead uh thanks Chad um no in answer to that question having been through multiple DOA issues during previous board service and hey sorry I'm sorry real quick granus died nobody can log into granus oh okay oldfashioned way put your hand up if you need something I'm sorry no that's okay that's from previous experience and statute may have changed since I had one last but I believe it's by Statute 60 days from I could be wrong it may have changed but I thought it was 60 can you clarify 60 days from I don't know if it's by the time of the filing or by the time we take this action but there is um again I I I didn't realize this question was going to come up I would have looked it
144up but I I thought it was 60 days like it must by Statute it must happen within 60 days oh that go a hearing you mean that do a hearing in front of an officer must happen within 60 days oh to check that I haven't had one of these hearings no one has requested yeah and what I'm saying may be old information so I want to give that caveat but other areas it takes a while for do it to set the hearing everybody to agree on mutually agreeable dates get it back get an order from the alj that's a recommended order that then comes back to the board for Action okay like we had earlier today exactly like we had earlier today that was over a two and a half year period I believe yeah
145right well that one had exua other issues yeah wasua um nobody else no that's okay I'll keep going I wanted to answer that but I I have more but if somebody else wants to go first it's fine finish up Mr pen okay thank you you're floor yeah um well first I want to I want to um this was originally on consent I want to thank the superintendent for Pulling this immediately as soon as I asked and the reason I wanted it moved um to new business because I think any employee let alone a 20 plus year employee in a situation like this when their career is being put in Jeopardy deserves um you know like Dr will just did a chance to at least address the board before we make a decision like this because
146we're we're putting him on the path toward possible termination and you know I just think when you take an action like this this is um this is this is a very strong action I've said this many times before in previous board service like we have a lot of power here and I think we need to be careful with it and I think we also need to be transparent um so it's a it's about transparency and about uh you know Fair due process to any employee um when such a strong action as this is taken I um I know we're only to speak on the on the motion itself so I won't speak to the evidence um contained uh in the agenda board work or the Ops report but uh I'm not going to support this
147but I do have a question um if this motion does fail attorney Dy or attorney penley if this motion does fail um that would only mean correct me if I'm wrong that would only mean that Dr willhoit remains on paid leave while he awaits a DOA hearing is that correct that's correct okay and so there's really no other outcome here it's either um motion fails and he remains unpaid leave or the motion is supported and he goes on unpaid leave correct that's correct okay um that's all I got thank you okay or I'm sorry did you have something no I'm listening I'm listening so for one of the attorneys we we can't really speak to the merits of the case at this point is that what you're you're telling us or yes and you shouldn't
148talk to anybody about the merits of the case either okay individually individually yeah so obviously not amongst ourselves because that's a sunshine issue but when you say anyone like anyone yes like like my mom or you know my day you need to remain neutral and then you'll have the benefit of the record to look at the entire record and then when you have your your final hearing like you had today in the other manner because if if I were to talk to somebody what are the legal ramif not that I'm going to go do it I'm just trying to understand because I I I would like to address the circumstances of the case but apparently at this point it's not a good idea legally to do that so what are the consequences of well it's
149kind of like you're the judge right and you're talking to one of the litigants on the side yeah so you but I but I mean members of the community you're saying don't talk to members of the community don't talk if someone comes up to me and says I'd like to talk to you about this case or sends me an email I should just tell them I'm sorry I I can't discuss the case with you or or well your your understanding the case will be built on your review of the record right in the in the hearing before the uh division administrative hear what I'm asking for is is legally you're people may come up like who knows I may be I mean you need a bowling alley and someone says hey I'm a really good
150friend of the person in question here and they say I want to speak to you about this case or I have some information I'd like you to know should I my my response should be what at that point that you're not allowed to talk about it okay finally agree with that yeah in in these cases the board sits in what is known as a quazi Judicial manner meaning that just like a judge you have to maintain impartiality until you hear all the evidence since the this is a case that doesn't come directly before the board it's a a request has been made by the employee to refer this matter to the division of administrative hearings DOA and they will assign an a excuse me an alj to hear the case and that record will then
151be compiled and the alj will issue a recommended order based on the evidence in the law that he sees that then comes back to the board in in those cases for you to enter a final order so once you're placed in that quazi judicial position of being the ultimate determination you you must maintain neutrality until that record is presented to you and maintaining neut neutrality means not providing any public opinion on the on the case that yes sir correct that's that means so uh if he were not to be put on unpa leave are there legal preced that we set when when a similar case comes before us and and we make a different we this person we put on unpaid leave this person we we leave unpaid leave do we open ourselves up to
152some type of legal hey you did it for this person but you didn't do it for that person and my circumstances are the same or is that just kind of our judgment to make up here or what are your what are your thoughts on that it it would be precedent setting in fact to the to the contrary of past practice of the district that has always placed employees who request hearings on unpaid administratively pining the outcome of that hearing that has always been the practice of the district and it is the practice of districts all across the state that you let that administrative proceeding play out and then it comes back to the board otherwise you're going to be paying all of any employee who is subject to a termination review you will have to
153pay them through the remainder of that that process it would set a precedent of of having those employees remain unpaid administratively pending the outcome of the hearing and those can take some time so are you I think I heard you just say was that if we were to leave uh person at question here on paid leave that that would in your mind set a legal president where everybody else from this point forward could say well you you did it for that person do it for me or or absolutely and so that's a concern of yours or it is a concern and then if someone wanted to sue us and say well you did it for person X now you have to do it for me it wouldn't be we can't use our judgment up here
154to say well we think this person should be on PID leave while they're going through the do process and this other person should not be unpaid leave it would take away our ability to make those kind but go ahead it it it would so you think it's precedent setting I do Mr Dy yes I agree I would actually encourage people to always request a hearing and at least get pay till that process and then if you drag the hearing out you continue to get paid and not have to work but actually would encourage that behavior so we're that's the concern at this point I'm really not allowed to make any comments on the case correct just the decision just the motion that's before you I'll just make one last comment and that is it it
155pains me to to not be able to as as a leadership educator and like an executive coach I I would just it just pains me that we've gotten to this point with someone who obviously has been a lot of service to the community but but my point is is that when it when it crosses the line from I'm trying to work things out with the administration or my supervisors or my bosses to now we're at a legal we're in a legal position that kind of changes the rues of the game what I'm trying to say is that I I I would have liked to have SE when I say I would have I'm not criticizing anybody that didn't go down the way that it should I'm just saying that it's a shame that we couldn't
156when I say we I mean not again I'm not pointing the fingers at anybody that that the everybody involved and I've seen this in my leadership work and I've been involved in it sometimes right where we just we all take a step back and go how am I how am I contributing to being part of the problem here right both sides and could we have worked this out somehow where we didn't have to get to a point where now we're we're in this really kind of very restrictive legal box where we might have to take some very negative action against someone who in many ways uh you know obviously has been an asset to the school system but now we face this kind of situation I'll just end it that without because I can't talk
157about anything else at this point so it's just a shame M BR sorry I'll come yes I'm trying to find a policy number for paid and unpaid administrative leave do we have a policy number that I could find real quick here I personally don't know of any policy been looking procedural stuff in my but I have no CL right um I know we can't talk merits up this particular case but in other cases I was able to review documents as early as today to base my opinion on um and I understand if we you got to do it for one you do it for all I hate that mentality to be honest with you I think it should be a case by case basis in my opinion um I wish I could find a policy
158because I'd like to know what policy it is that that you said it was a Statewide policy no ma'am I'm sorry if you understood that that's a m statement that a Statewide practice practice it is the practice of all School boards that I'm aware of that when a employee termination hearing is invoked that the employees placed on placed on unpaid administrative leave pinning the outcome of that hearing unfortunately in my short term being here we've had this too often for one reason or another I'm having difficulty with this um for a couple of reasons I'm G to let somebody else finish I'm going to try to find this particular policy that we have just in case go ahead Miss Felton or Mr Kennedy if you go ahead Charlie if you'd like whoever wants to you
159can go first oh okay I'm still um okay now first um from the Florida bar uh proceedings at do move more rapidly than civil cases and circuit courts most hearings are scheduled 60 to 90 day pardon 60 to 90 days after a petition for hearing is filed with an agency um so that's not in statute but says typically I I need to um push back um on a couple things we heard from legal because I respectfully I disagree um I don't believe our quasi judicial role starts until DOA has issued an opinion so to say to an elected official you are not allowed to speak to a constituent on an issue I I just I don't I don't think that's constitutional nor fair to elected official officials um and then I get it once that
160once that alj issues an opinion in the case I agree we are in the cone of silence for lack of a better term and then when we get to DOA the only thing that we can cons when we when it comes from DOA back to us the only thing that we can consider correct me if I'm wrong please is what's in the record of the DOA hearing and then the 15 minutes each side has to present to the board correct that's correct okay so um you know we it's it's okay to disagree I Just Disagree that we are silenced as of today I just don't think that's true nor do I think it's fair um Miss Bray I agree everything is on a case-by Case basis there are no two anybody that does disciplin knows
161that situations might be similar but no two cases are alike and I think the fear of employees saying well let me go roll my dice with the board and see if they'll put me on paid leave um that's certainly a possibility but I don't think it sets a precedent it may set it may create a situation where people come and ask and then that's when we have to go look at the case and decide is this just or is this unjust I'm not going to talk about the details of the case um but I've read everything I've been given I've read the board work and um I am uncom comfortable with the superintendent's case against the employee and therefore I'm not supporting um putting him on unpaid leave on his way while he waits 60
162to 90 days for DOA frankly it's I'm sorry that we've come to this and we're hashing this out in a board meeting because I wish we could have found a solution for everybody involved that would have let everybody walk away but we didn't and so here we are um but we just had a we just had before this meeting at 3:30 today we had another employee matter that we had a decision from do we had to make a decision and and we did that based on the rules of DOA and the rules become and our quasi judicial role um and I made a decision on that one based on the facts that had pres had been presented to us um as I would do with any any of these cases so I I just don't
163think we can paint with a broad brush on any discipline matter uh like I said at the beginning I think an employee who has been with us this long and has the track record as long um any employee deserves transparency and due process um but the facts of the case and years of service those are those factors weigh on my decision here and I'm not going to support the motion um question um if and I'm not sure of the legal ease here but um if when uh our employee goes to his hearing and if the case is found to be without Merit and they don't recommend firing will he receive all of his back pay yes that's normally the order um I um I also have a a agreement that things should be taken on
164a case-by casee basis in terms of um every employee who comes before us um this is the part of the job that sucks um and I I strongly believe that everyone should be treated as innocent until proven guilty and should not be punished until there is um a final order out there um unless somebody's in a danger to themselves or others then we you know then we worry about it in terms of other things and this is not that kind of a case um and I I'm I'm struggling with this one um I just want to be very clear that this does not bind us to back pay the do officer will make a recommendation just like we had at 3:30 today and then we can make any decision we want on that decision we
165have to as we heard earlier we have to justify any changes we make to the doe officers findings of fact and application of the law but but we're not bound to pay pay if the even if the DOA Officer says You must or it's recommended that you pay back pay we are still not bound to do that so it's we're not locked into anything thanks do you have any to the attorneys do you have any comments on Mr Kennedy's rebuttal to your legal opinions and the sense of it it does seem odd that I mean at what point it's like for instance when we go to impass with when we have negotiations right there's a point where you're you know there's a cone of silence so to speak before that you can have discussions with
166people then that you really are kind of silent so are you what I'm struggling with here is that we can't because there are some comments that I would like to make and it would like I'd like to maybe influence other people about the record that I that I you know have in front of me but I'm being told that I mean what what can we discuss tonight other I mean know what about the case are we allowed to discuss and and why is it that as of this very moment I I really as Mr Kennedy said not allowed to talk about to my constituents about something that's before us I just like to understand that a little better you want to take that I'll take a stab at that the uh so the so there's
167a lot of complexity to it that that you don't have the benefit of right now that that you will after it goes through the DOA hearing process there's a lot of nuances to everything and and I think you saw that in the case you had today at 3:30 um I mean right now you have you have a very small amount of information and it and you don't have the benefit of uh the full picture of that the hearing will will bring out um including including video evidence and just everything that goes with it um so the what you what you shouldn't be doing right now is is sort of litigating the entire case right um you you should just be making a decision on uh unpaid or paid leave pending the administrative B on what
168based on what though um your review of of what you've seen with the board works so I'm not it's on any other issue on an agenda you know I talk to the public they might want to come like we if we if we decide to put him on unpaid leave tonight and and people from the community come in support of of the person in question I can talk to them I can it just is odd I I can't have a discussion with them I mean what what if somebody brought me a packet of emails and said hey look you know here are some emails that I think are very important it shows that uh certain people within I don't whatever in the school system have been taking these actions I I thought they're relevant to
169the case I I just hand them back and go no I'm not allowed to look at those I mean what that's why you get the big bucks you're not supposed to you're not supposed to no I think that's got to be presented in the DOA in in the hearing that comes back from DOA that's got to be presented is the way I look at it yeah I mean a example I can give when a when a City or County Commission board is got an application to reone property they sit Quai judicial and cannot meet with people and uh get influenced on the outcome of the final vote I have to say sorry I can't my lawyers told me I I I can't talk to you about that um so it's uh it's kind of a
170unusual legal concept but it if you think of yourselves you're you're kind of like a a court that will make the final decision so you're supposed to uh avoid being influenced until you have all the information at the end of the process okay what Mr penley what about the president setting a couple board members have made the statement of well if we do it for for person doesn't necessarily mean that that sets a precedent for Y and Z and everybody else that comes before us again and so let me go back to the the original basis of your questions what at what time in procedurally most frequently these cases come before the board on the superintendent's recommendation to terminate and it's unusual it's not the the typical course that you would have a request for
171a doah hearing normally in when I say normally typically in 8 and a half out of 10 cases you're going to see that the employee is terminated by the board at the first opportunity when an employee asks for a hearing though the board knows that it is going to sit in a quazi Judicial fashion because a hearing has been requested as it has in this particular instance where that's going to go to DOA DOA is going to complete an evidentiary record make a recommended order that would come back that's why I take the position that your quazi judicial function begins when the hearing is requested this hearing was requested last Monday so throughout this process it's it's one of procedure that you let the process work and both sides receive due process of law through
172that process um as to precedent setting it's been the past practice of this board and all school boards that I am familiar with that when a recommendation has been made for termination and the employee requests a hearing at that point they go on unpaid administrative leave so that there is not an incentive to drag out the process so that you're continuing to get paid leave not produce any work and let the hearing process take however long it takes if it's 60 days which is typical in ESC cases um it's not typical employee termination cases that I'm familiar with um but there haven't been that many so it's an unusual and can take a lengthy amount of time during which the person is continuing to get paid at taxpayer expense while there is a pending recommendation
173and hearing on termination of that employee that's why it's it's the precedent that typically occurs the employee does not request a hearing the termination occurs and it moves forward in that matter and I suppose there's no option 90 days down the road if the hearing hasn't happened and we feel like it's being drugg out or something that we can't go back and say okay well now we're going to could we could we say well now we're going to move him to I I have certainly never seen that procedure employed by any board and and you're concerned that someone would actually sue us in a future and say well you did it for X why aren't you doing it for me or or is that I mean be honest with me is that something you're really
174concerned about is I don't think a lawsuit is the appropriate forum for that but it's certainly to have a wage a campaign of public persuasion before it gets to that point yes what meaning it's it would be wrong to wage a a case of public persuasion or what yes it would okay you haven't had the benefit of having a record developed and evidence put before you you're hearing only one side of the store well we are hearing two I mean we've heard from the person in question tonight and then we've we do have a case case in front of us so to some degree we haven't we don't have all the facts but we have heard from both sides and I have received emails from people about this case I haven't responded other than saying
175thank you for your email I consider the information so just so you know that but okay I I appreciate you guys honest to the fourth right advice thanks I'm sorry are we done yeah for now um I'll just I'll give my thoughts so maybe we can push this question um I I agree with a lot of sentiments have been saying I think it's unfortunate we're here sucks we're in this position um I do believe it it it is Case by case my three years that I've been here there's not been people who have been fired coming out of the woodwork for DOA um this I mean this is not an an everyday currence um you know I think that somebody knows they did something wrong they did something wrong I I don't I don't I
176don't I don't see this necessarily all of a sudden every single person that's non-renewed or F non renewed doesn't matter fired Etc is going to now all of a sudden come up with this I'm not in support of this um so to to to have them going unpaid um too long in the district too many lives change to to to force someone to do it without the due process so I'm I'm not for it um I just got another comment other than I found the policy and it's policy 3550 and it it's very vague very I'm saying so vague I had to read it three times it's so short and then try to decipher what lawyer talk would convert that word to um I mean last time it was updated from Neola says 2013 uh
177but it's say adopted in 2017 so that's a little confusing to me there um I'm leaning toward the it's a case by case basis as well Cindy could you could you read it to us please oh can I read it I okay I didn't see that any complaint against a member of the in instructional staff which arises with the membership of the school board or which comes to the attention of the school board except through the superintendent shall be referred to to the superintendent for decision in cases for the instructional staff member or the complaint complaintant is not satisfied with the decision of the superintendent an appeal may be taken by either party to the board through the superintendent for final decision Pursuit state law a complaint of misconduct against the district administrator and all
178other all information obtained pursuant to an in investigation by the District of the complaint of misconduct conduct are confidential and exempt from inspection or copying until investigation ceases to be active or until the district provides written notice to the employee which is the subject of the complaint in the matter set forth below and if the district either either has con conduct concluded the investigation with a finding not to proceed with a disciplinary action or files uh charges or conducted an investigation with a finding to proceed with disciplinary action and or file charges the investigation results in such a finding the district shall also uh file legally sufficient complaint regarding the miscon conduct as required by the state law policy state law policy 8141 mandatory reporting of misconduct of a certified employee which is that's mandatory
179report for anyone else that would want to know what that is any material that is derogatory to an employee shall not be open to for inspection for additional 10 days after the employee has been notified either by certified mail return receipt require Reed his a her address or record or by personal delivery the employee signature a copy of materials to be filed sh the proof of such material were given to the employee with the understanding that such signatures merely signifies receipt and does not necessarily indicate agreement with his Contex employees bargaining should refer to their negotiating agreement so it's got Flor statutes underneath there but that's all I could find on it um to me it's there's okay District administration uh bargaining Union administrators it it's all to me sometimes it is a case by
180casee basis Miss Fon did you have anything else to add to that or were you just want her to read that um no I do have something else um knowing that we were going to have this and this was the only thing that we were supposed to uh speak to uh not speaking to the merits of the case uh I elected to not read any of the background information uh on the merits I wanted to just look at what was presented to us in the one document um and uh and to go from there um and it states in the the document that we were given um that you know he has a right to a hearing which of course you know he should and that also in the statement it says that uh the
181law law enforcement and DCF uh DCF uh both elect uh neither agency elected to pursue charges um and so that also makes me feel that um as as they F those agencies felt that um there wasn't a criminal act then this is something that we don't needed immediate decision on or um I guess not decision that's not the right word but um I think you're kind of following where I'm going with this um that it's not something that is probably going to result in uh or has resulted in um something that's going to require you know lawsuits from families or anything like that um and I think that we can again case-by case basis look at this and and I don't think I'm going to support it going say one more thing real quick yeah
182let me go to miss KY and then come back okay um the when the agenda when we got our copy of the draft agenda um I noticed that what was attached to the agenda to the board work was the letter received by Dr willhoit and the superintendent's statement of charges so in order to make a decision like this and I'm not going to talk about the facts of the case but in order to make the proper decision in this again and In fairness and to make sure we're making heading in the right direction I requested the Ops report around this incident I received it the next morning and I and I appreciate the the quick response um so that that way I had both sides of the story sort of both sides of the story
183at least that it that gave you know you could read witness statements you could hear from Dr will ho himself um how he reacted to it because what's on the board work is very one-sided and I believe pushes the board toward following the superintendent's recommendation but as board members as the board of directors of the school district this is our role is to oversee the superintendent and the superintendent only and in this case I disagree with the superintendent it's not um you know it's gonna it's going to happen from time to time that I disagree and if this if this motion fails that Dr will Hoy stays on paid leave um does that change circumstances with this action um I know all Dr will wants to do is go to work tomorrow um and so
184maybe that opens up an Avenue where we can find some agreement I don't know I'm just thinking through it here but um the other U well I said the other stuff already I'll let you gock we call the question if you thank you chairman uh just want to clarify a couple of points board members um I view this as a procedural recommendation it is the next step uh in the process uh the process is the same for every employee regardless of what the concern is or how long they've worked for the district or or who they've worked for it's the same process uh and uh tonight is not the night uh to U talk about the substantive facts the circumstances of the matter um my team and I will respect the process even though there's
185been lots of comments made um but to be clear the process starts with a complaint that complaint goes to the office of Professional Standards where it's investigated during the investigation the employee receives due process the report is compiled and and when there is a serious concern it goes to the discipline committee first not to the superintendent the discipline Committee in this case is for senior administrators those administrators are former classroom teachers former assistant principles and principles District administrators some in multiple districts some in multiple States the folks are also parents grandparents so they bring a variety of lenses in this case there was a unanimous recommendation for termination from those four senior administrators that then is referred to my office I review the record take my time with it to determine whether I concur or
186not and then bring that recommendation forward um as as Council has shared it has past practice in this District in many others and and I believe a best practice that when you get to the point of a hearing on the merits you make the recommendation for uh for unpaid leave U there uh there are um additional costs involved uh as the item States in preparing for DOA hearings um I believe that if a precedent is set that some employees will be able to on paid leave and others not that we may um see additional requests that doesn't just mean continuing to pay the employee it also means additional legal fees that are coming out of the general fund to prep these cases whether they actually go to a doah hearing officer or whether they're just
187stretched out and then the employee uh uh drops the case the day before the hearing um and so the board does need to consider that um if we're going to deviate from past practice um I certainly know how to count to three um so I understand where we're heading and at a later point if uh if we are going to do Case by case then perhaps the board will want to provide guidance on what that looks like um uh because at the end of the day I certainly recognize the board's uh Authority to uh to make this decision um but I'm responsible for the for the day-to-day supervision of employees um and I have to make the the recommendations and the decisions when it comes to health safety and Welfare and I I take that
188very very seriously and so um um I uh under again understand that there are a lot of issues involved here but again for me this is a procedural matter and if the board wants to set new precedent then certainly I I'll request guidance so that I bring you recommendations that you can support in the future thank you yeah just one response to that and um again I say this respectfully but to my board colleagues I well I want to say again we are the we represent our constituents to me I don't want to put this on you but to me we represent our employees um superintendent weong just talked about the process that this went through um the Ops report the Ops report is written by an employee of the superintendent the discipline committee is
189made up of employees of the superintendent so we have to be that counterbalance and I'm only speaking for myself when I say this the I am not comfortable with the facts of this case leading to the end of someone's career and um if I if I had read all the information that had been provided the board work plus the Ops report if I had read that and been and been satisfied with the facts of the case and the punishment I would have never asked for it to be pulled from consent but once I read it and began to consider it I like there are problems here to me there are problems here and so I stepping up in my role as that the scales of Justice you know putting some you know trying to equal
190out the the scales of justice so that we have a fair process and um and we don't you know there could be a situation Dr weong I'm not saying this is you but imagine a situation where you have a superintendent who just wants to get rid of like 20 people and so if you don't have a board of directors overseeing the superintendent those people have no hope and and a superintendent or any CEO could just get rid of a whole bunch of people and those people those employees would have no recourse and so um that is what brings me here tonight and I'm I'm and I'm voting no on this just um and I want to tell uh Dr weong that I I've listened to everything you said and and trying to look at this
191based on just what we have in front of us we're not supposed to take into account the facts of the case we're not allowed to discuss the facts of the case and while based on the facts of the case I may feel differently um I still feel that if there are no criminal charges pending that we are not looking at uh something um in in that line of of where I'm trying to figure how to phrase this but if we're just going to look at this is a recommendation this is the information that has been provided to us without looking at the facts of the case if we're just supposed to look at that one aspect of it then I feel like then we need to continue with due process as as our employee has
192asked for a hearing that you know he's able to do that um and and so that's that's where I have to go on that anybody else the Ops report that's the office of Professional Standards report yes why is why was that not included with the board work that that we were given when I say why I'm not accusatory asking why I just if it was if it was available to Mr Kennedy why wasn't it provided to the or as part of the record from press to review is that not standard practice or I don't know I I don't make those board packets so so one thing I do want to consider here is that you kind of alluded to it Mr Kennedy that if we don't go with the superintendent's recommend this is a little
193different aspect of it but I I mean under it's to some degree undermines when we overrule the superintendent on something it undermines his his authority and could lead other employees to say well you know if I if I mount a strong enough public affairs campaign or whatever it's it's it's a big deal to as the CEO of an organization who has thoroughly considered the facts and whose staff has thoroughly considered the facts to then override his recommendation who generally we have trusted with his judgment up until this point that's a big deal I'm not saying that we can't I'm just pointing that out that it it to some degree undermines his his authority one point I'd like to make is that in the future I mean I've been in a lot of leadership organizations and
194big bureaucracies and one thing that I've noticed is that you know the standard procedure and I don't know what happened in this case ultimately down over the years but the standard procedure for discipline is provide written or verbal correction uh and then document it and then see if it changes and then provide more correction and documented so that you have a legal record that if you do get to this point you can go to a do hearing or a legal court and say we we have the appropriate documentation we we followed the law one thing that I don't see happen a lot on both sides is is a sit down where three questions are asked and especially from the employees right what am I doing to make things more difficult what have I been doing
195if I have a track record and that's in that's in what we looked at today if I have a track record of some negative consequences in my file what what am I doing to make things possibly potentially maybe I'm not but I need to at least ask the question what am I doing to make things more difficult what could I do differently along the way so that I hopefully don't ever have to get to the point where we are now and how often could I check in with the PE with the people that are above me in my chain of command so that I make sure that what I thought what we what we decided was wrong and then kind of The Rehabilitation that we plann plan that we came up with is actually working
196I have noticed in organizations that have if if the organization will take that approach and the employer will take that approach this point where we're at now can often times be avoided which is a really sad sad point that we're at so I just wanted to offer that out there too that as we look at things like this in the future from both sides whether you're the boss or whether you're the employees that ask those three questions what am I doing to make things more difficult you can have this discussion with your your supervisors can we put together a mutual plan to make things better and then let's check back in with each other I don't know every week every two weeks every month and see how my plan is our plan is working out
197if we need to tweak it a little bit because I don't want to ever have to get to a point where where I am right here that this is case was kind of actually bothered me all day you saw before I forgot to vote cuz I was distracted right like I've just been up SE coming on the agenda I'm like because it is really a respected member of the community's life that we're they're dealing with here one point that Dr weong did make is that this is a procedural thing that we're dealing with here this is not a judgment on whether uh the person in question should eventually still be employed with the manity County school system or not so we could vote administratively tonight to put him on unpaid leave and then even if
198it went to DOA and the recommendation was that he not be employed we still have the opportunity to come back and say no we we're going to keep him on the payroll is that not correct right we even if like like we had earlier in the day at our previous meeting a do recommendation is just a do recommendation right and that's correct and and and but to to go against the do recommendation there has to be a finding of of fact or law we have a better legal but go ahead there is a point to be made there when you you must accept doa's findings as to fact because the the alj the administrative law judge has the ability to hear the evidence and judge The credibility of the witnesses as a board reviewing a
199recommended order you don't have that so the law provides that you have to accept the facts well stated and for which there is competent substantial evidence of the record if you're going to go against a fact you have to make specific findings as to why the evidence was you don't consider it competent or substantial um as to law you can make the determination on your own as a board that the law is otherwise applied to the facts do you understand what I'm saying there the that you kind of have to treat them a little bit separately facts are are pretty well established in the record are accepted the conclusions of law as applied to those facts is where the board and the recommendation for any punishment or the outcome that they the alj reaches is
200sub subject to board discretion on a lesser standard what laws are I mean what laws would be applicable in a case like this but policy violations of policy violation of the standard of harm to students that sort of thing so because we're not supposed to have discussions with members of the audience I won't address myself directly OB see the person's in the room but I'll just make the statement that I'm going to support the motion because at this point it's a procedural it's not deciding whether he's going to be employed with us or not there is a there is a history of and I I will read from the from the record that we have that we were given respond has been subject to P prior Progressive discipline for for previous employment related conduct respondent
201has received multiple letters of reprimand served various suspensions from work has been provided directives concerning his conduct and has been reassigned job responsibilities directly related efforts to improve his job performance previous attempts at Progressive discipline have proved unsuccessful and bringing about excuse me chair isn't this discussing the Merit of the case I'm just reading what was in the what we were given assume I can read what's given is that not true or this was this is public record I mean this was given to us today today yeah I don't have a problem with it okay I just want to make sure it's it's just in in my you know I was in the Air Force for 30 years and I I served at some pretty high levels and got to a point where people that
202have been around for 25 or 30 years and I can honestly say that at that point there were very few if any people who had you know multiple letters of reprimand multiple uh things in their in their in their record at that point and it really pains me to support this motion but it's we're not deciding on whether he should be ultimately employed with the school system or not we're deciding on should we follow the administrative procedure that is standard practice within within the system and we do open up the door to other people coming and at and wanting to do the same thing so I'm not going to sleep but I'll support last thing um I mean I guess in this yeah Rich if I may I just want to respond to a couple
203things you said number one um um you mentioned undermining the superintendent's Authority and I think if the board um let me go back to what I said what's on the board work um is is only the superintendent side of the story so to um so for us to just lay down and accept that as gospel I think that undermines our Authority and so we have a role here as oversee of the district to say I'm only speaking for myself again um there is something wrong with the facts of this case leading to a termination to me um and we sent a message to the superintendent to say don't bring us stuff like this either don't bring it or find a way to keep it out of the board meeting um and that's that's really what
204I hope we'll do I'm not I'm not accusing the superintendent of um doing anything to farious or um it's just my reading of the documents that were provided to us before this meeting tonight um and we have authority here too um because if if we let this go forward are we setting a bad precedent and then who's the next employee that's going to have you know let me just respond to what you just read there's multiple disciplines in this file but we don't know what they are because the Ops report wasn't provided in the board work it was provided to the board after the fact upon my request which is Central to making this decision tonight and why I'm making the decision I'm making so um I would just ask the board to Let's maintain
205our Authority and um and send this motion packing so let's say that Mr Gray back in the day had come to us and said the same well he did and we put him on unpaid administrative leave so you you would say that it's just all based on the facts of it because we don't get to see the facts I don't I don't necessar want to bring up someone else's old stuff I don't even know if we can legally do that I me I think we we've kind of gone round and round and round on this I think we all kind of maybe have our opinions and and I I don't know if anyone's going to be persuaded at this point um I don't think parliamentary I can are we ready to vote let me ask
206you that all right uh Mr chair I'll make a motion to call a question okay thank you there you go I don't think I can do that as chair I don't know no har rules all right chair can make motions okay I didn't know usually doesn't he or she does not but chair is a allowed to make motions so we so you're call the question I'm calling the question okay second okay so um V we don't have gr you vote on calling the question right is correct we do yeah gr should be up y should be up okay but first just vote by that's fine but wait are you is that to call the question is that the vote to call the question yes okay CU I I'm all I'm all the way out of
207GR so let's just vote um by hand all in favor of calling the question raise your hand say I five all right passes five to zero so is everybody else in griss other than me no no I'm not it was no no griss because it'll take time to right so um we had our motion we enter second so approval of uh the recommendation replace employee VW on unpaid administrative leave pinning a hearing on the merits all those in favor go and raise your hand say I so we're not we're done I can't am I am I allowed to make comments when I when I vote the question is called y yeah suppose I could make comments make public comments at the end sure so tell me so the motion is read the motion again to
208me if you would approval of recommendation to place employee VW on un paid administrative leave pending a hearing on the merits and you're and you're and what you're asking for is everybody who's in favor say I and raise right now yeah anybody who's in favor say I and raise your hand and I'll go anybody oppose this is all those in favor I know what I said before but I'm not I'm not going to support okay so um all those in in favor not supporing the motion raise your hand say I I I motion does not pass all board members um descending 0 to five uh with no votes coming from every board member mve on a new business item uh item number one approval of the travel expense for us board members to attend fsba
209February 6 to the 7th excuse me sub board members um February 6th to the 7th at the Hilton and University of Florida Conference Center Gainesville not to exceed 5,000 and this is for the school Finance Forum all right I know most everybody's going I'm not um I second so we have a motion by Mr Kennedy second by m Bray all those in favor of well any discussion on this particular item right all those in favor of the approval of the travel expense ra your hand say I hi hi hi sorry weing get back into granus oh I'm sorry I'm still is 5 to zero all right I got uh item number two uh under new business is approval of the school board members of travel to Tallahasse Florida for the new school board member part
210two and or annual day in the legislature event this is not till March 17 uh through the 21st of 2025 through the fsba not to exceed $122,000 I know I believe oh let's get a motion a second so moved second Kenny spray I know I'm going I don't know how many other people Miss I did thank you um is all are all of us going um I am not I am okay you are AR sounds good yeah I know it's still a little bit away but and I would encourage us all still reach out legislators Etc right take it up there um so we have our motion or second let's go a and vote on the approval of school board members traveling to Tallahassee for the legislative event uh all those in favor raise your
211hand and say I hi hi any pose passes 5 to zero item number three oh approval of amendment two of the contract for board legal services from die Harrison nolles Kirkland Pratt paa um estimated the amount of $225,000 annually so moved second I got the motion in Mr any discussion on the Amendments or approval board members anything Noone I'm watching it okay we'll uh we'll give you your your evaluation later on oh yeah we already did a year from now um all right so uh seeing no one to discuss on this item let's go ahead and all uh if if you voting yes on the approval of amendment to the contract Raisor and say hi hi I opposed seeing none carries 5 Z thank you um item number four approval of the school board of
212myy County's legislative priorities so moves second but I have discussion yeah okay on our legislative priorities some of those are through the greater I got my note somewhere Florida yeah thank you thank you there a lot of them mimic what we have for that group as well and they're G to have a day in legislative in April so I just want the board to think about we just motioned and approved to go up in March and then in April the very following week two weeks later is the custor shs so I don't know if everybody wants to go but I'm I'm already offered to go a your Lea on okay so I just wanted to put that out there for you all you didn't necessarily have to go liaz liaz okay I I'm I'm just
213learning so I'm coming along to learn it's about the same so yeah okay all right thank you m Bray anybody else on parties all right let's go and vote on the approval of the school board of M County legislatives are our priorities all those in favor go and raise your hand say I I opposed none that passes five to zero um item number 16 does look like we have some informational stuff I do want to let the public know especially on item number four the school safety requirements and monitoring and reports um you know due to new statutes and things that the legis legislature has passed last year we do have to get a quarterly report of any school safety uh requirements and monitoring reports we have that um and have been presented by that
214by our safety um team and we appreciate them um they do a phenomenal job yes um moving on to uh our updates um instructional update Mr good evening church CH board members um superintendent weong um just a few quick updates since we had a a long meeting already full of instructional updates we'll be bringing you in addition to the great grad rate presentation we had tonight from the instructional Services team and Miss Collins we have um we'll be giving you uh the pm2 math data presentation at Friday's workshop and really dissecting and working through that data our schools are um currently finishing the pm2 reading Administration as well and we'll be bringing that data to you in February so kind of it's that time of year where we're uh reviewing data and making instructional decisions
215and uh we'll continue that work with you over the next few weeks um I want to thank um our stem coordinator Lyn Johnson and our um curriculum team for organizing the the first of several Vex robotics competitions this past Saturday at Southeast High School um I want to congratulate the cyberchimps which was a team from Mills Elementary which was our first place um Excellence Award winner what was the name again the Cyber chimp they had princess pickles too and that award is based on a combination of different um criteria it's the team's notebook an interview of the team and the ranking and their skills and teamwork competition we'll also have a Vex competition this coming weekend at hail middle Saturday is the middle school competition and Sunday is a another round of Elementary competitions both
216days are 8 to 4 um next week is also celebrate literacy week in our schools so all schools have many literacy activities I know uh many of us are going into classrooms and reading to students throughout the week um we'll have guest readers write your own story design your own bookmark and the theme for this year is building literacy constructing the foundation for Success um and schools will participate by including books related to Workforce education and an effort to connect to Governor D San's get their Workforce education initiative um today was the first day of class for MTC for the spring semester so uh we had many new students in class today and if you know of someone who'd like to attend MTC the fall 25 semester applications open February 6 that's also when we
217begin open houses at MTC we have a February 6th open house at East Campus and then a February 13th at Maine campus um and then we're also in the uh middle of the manate county fair which I had the pleasure of experiencing the steer Showmanship on Friday night um judging is complete for beef breeding steers rabbits and chickens Dairy judging is today goats are judged Wednesday swine and dog shows are later this week um and then of course I want to congratulate all the student leaders at the Lakewood Ranch High School um FBLA district 18 award ceremony um last Friday as well thank you one quick question if I could uh MTC students started today and that was registration for the spring semester now closed or can students still register um I would have to
218get that information from Mr Wagner and uh follow up with you on that but I'd be happy to bring that okay great thanks thanks so much and I don't know if this would be a question uh you Wong Mr Chapman um last week was I believe it was last week was the Choice ni you said it MTC do we know like the number I know one was elementary was lower do we know the numbers of like how many actually tended I mean I'm not saying someone was there like with a clicker do we happen I mean do we happen to know at all how many pulling out the clicker now he's getting his clicker out did my tie sorry uh we actually had clickers uh but I don't know the click count so I should
219have had that so I I will I will find the click count and and make sure through our uh board clerk that I remember having a click be interested to see how many families are taking advantage of of going and seeing you know what what the choice is um because typically haven't we done it at the individual high schools or did we do that as well on top of that Mt well over the years we've had many different priorities right we used to have all schools at Civic Center we used to kinds of different ways uh many many of the secondary schools uh had their own open houses the next night and and and nights thereafter and then thus then the elementary ones as well uh so we'll we'll get the uh yeah count U
220it was it was a great turnout and uh appreciate all the staff too who were involved in that it's a lot of work there but uh thank you thank you anybody else all right thank you Mr Chapman thankk you Mr Jensen uh operations good evening board members Dr weong I'll give you a couple brief items uh we held an operational job fair on January 9th uh we had 82 attendees job offers were made for to three custodians uh one food service worker and 18 Transportation potential staff members uh 10 bus attendants six bus drivers and two bus drivers that already had their CDL so they were able to start training uh today so I'm moving forward there on January 7th uh we had a a dedicated nurses job fair it was kind of good news
221bad news the bad news was we only had eight attendants or attendees the good news was we hired five or we made five offers so it it was uh productive from that standpoint on January 15th uh pathways teacher certification was held we had 190 uh registrations we had about 50 individuals who came and that was for individuals that don't have the traditional route to be a teacher but they do have a bachelor's degree so working with them we hope to have them up to the point that uh the principals will be able to hire them uh in April when we do the the large job fair so it's kind of the alternate route to to being a teacher um Janu coming up January 23rd we've got another online bra Brazen virtual teacher and Pera uh
222Fair as I said online 9:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m. and then our next operational fair is on February 20th from 2:00 to 5:00 at the Wakeland Center um one brief thing uh food and nutrition services uh in the past week uh School Gardens were planted at Bayshore Moody samet and Bashaw uh elementary schools as part of the implementation of the USDA Farm to school Grant uh Mrs Beck's third grade class at Bayshore Elementary harvested their first cucumbers um the the Cucumbers were uh brought into the kitchen where the children where where they were cut up and added to ingredients to make fresh cucumber dill salad so uh the Cucumber project will continue as students are now researching pick recipes to try their next har try for their next Harvest so that's all for operations awesome
223that's fun I'm eat the pickles but not the Cucumbers same thing any questions no no uh really quick how many bus drivers do we currently have we are we are rostered with 96 but we do have four that are on on leave right now so we're at 92 so those two when they get through we've got them already assigned to routes and everything so we're still hovering in that 94 to 95 range right now and mechanics oh mechanics we're down to five at this point right now um as a matter of fact on the consent agenda number 12 was a naspo um contract that you approved and that allows us to Outsource some of our tire rotations as well as some of our roadside uh assistance to uh both the yellow Fleet and the White
224Fleet so uh transportation is looking at some alternative ways to deal with the the shortage that we have right now thank you that's all I have um legal update I know we got something Friday but go ahead just one thing um some of yall asked about the status of the asme uh impass process and uh it has uh been assigned to a special Master oh so by perk so and it's actually out of state Pennsylvania attorney I guess that's right and uh which is kind of unusual shows that they're backlogged and they actually going out of state to get wow people so anyway hopefully it'll move faster than then we first kind of were throwing out so that's good right great that's it that's good all right um moving on to superintend remarks dark thank
225you chairman I'll start where I usually do board members appreciate your approval of the consent agenda tonight there were 31 items that allow us to move the district forward in instruction operations and finance um thank you also to all of the directors executive directors Deputy superintendant who um uh do all of the prep work um as the chair noted uh tonight's consent agenda includes approval um to uh lease additional um uh machines uh from um evolve uh that does allow us to move to uh the goal of daily Universal screening uh of uh students um via touchless walkthrough uh detection systems uh again that technology rollout uh is set for August of 25 for next school year um can't go faster than that because there are Personnel implications um and uh training requirements um and
226so all of that uh has to be uh set up uh we are continuing to randomly deploy evolve uh at middle schools uh and that will continue uh for the rest of the year um next uh you uh board you approved um the start of the project uh to um put in uh turf fields at the last two high schools as part of the three-year project plan so bore and Parish Community uh will get started uh later this spring and hopefully be ready in time for uh next August so we're we're excited uh that is yet another project that Construction Services is managing on schedule uh and then uh finally uh board members you approved uh two uh out of State student uh trips this evening those are pretty routine um we usually have one
227or two each board meeting and uh I just want to um remind all of you uh and the public um that behind all of those trips are faculty members um who are willing to give up nights and weekends away from their families so that these opportunities are possible for students so thank you to all of our um Club sponsors uh and um coaches um who take on these trips because it's not required um it's done uh uh as a passion project in support of student learning and so uh grateful to all of my colleagues who take on that responsibility um uh uh Bard I'll also remind you we started the the evening uh some time ago um with uh wonderful student and employee recognitions and um I I know that you all noticed that the
228principles of those students were here uh and again they uh they love seeing their students recognized and I thank all of them they uh they had a very long day today and uh great for them to come out to the board meeting and then of course at these evening meetings we have the color guard it's great to see uh students uh performing that Duty and of course there's an instructor uh accompanying all of those students standing in the back of the boardroom or in the hallway making sure that everything is perfect um so again thank you to to those teachers uh since our last meeting in December uh I've been out um visiting schools definitely the best part of my job um uh and uh board members thank you for accompanying me on those uh
229we've been to uh Braden River Elementary Johnson K8 Lincoln uh sha Mona Jane Miller and Prim uh I was recently at mon Jane to watch uh student mock trial in seventh and 8th grade civics uh received an invitation from uh two teachers to come and watch the action and uh very much enjoyed that as a former social studies teacher um we were at Miller uh uh last week uh and had the opportunity at the end of the visit to uh walk into an art classroom and uh sat down with some first graders and uh jumped into the art activity and uh they are much better artists than me but I had a great time uh uh spending a few minutes with them uh and then um at PR Elementary uh visited uh a really G
230great uh prek uh classroom uh and the teacher in that classroom uh uh was in her uh third year of teaching after being a par professional for us for a decade and going back to school and getting that bachelor's degree and uh she told me this was she was living her dream uh of being a prek teacher for the school district of Manatee County uh and um uh again best part of the job for sure um board members on Friday we have a workshop where we'll be presenting the results of the math progress monitor 2 Data uh normally we do those in a board meeting but we wanted to get the graduation data out to you uh the other piece is that the math data in this Administration is very nuanced because of some of
231the methodology changes that we made and then also because of the way the testing rolled out we also had calendar disruptions so we really want to take our time with you on Friday uh when we walk through that presentation and that'll be one of those where we stop on each slide and say what questions do you have um so that we make sure you have all the information uh to see how our students uh are doing we went through all of that data today uh with uh our uh K through 12 principles uh and my message to them is that today was day one of a 19-day uninterrupted window of instruction 19 days from now until President's Day it's one of the last uninterrupted blocks of time that we can really make significant learning growth
232with students and uh excited for how focused our principles are and uh the decisions they're making again student by student to determine um how we help students uh grow uh uh in their learning uh so we look forward to presenting all that data to you on Friday thank you awesome thank you very much um board comments we'll go Kennedy Tatum Felton spray choke okay call me off card um I had a quick question I noticed um uh that well actually I didn't notice it Laura thank you Laura pointed it out to me when I when I asked but but Workshop requests and future agenda item requests are no longer on the board meeting agenda and um so we just should do that through board briefing yes time now yes okay which is fine yeah um
233I've got a list which includes um the south jym at manate high although I'll get an update on that from uh the superintendent soon I'm sure and I know that project is kind of already that horse is out of the barn but um anyway um I'm Reviving an idea from 2021 about a solar project um letterhead policy recognition of retirement ments um what's our practice what's our policy because we had a couple very long-term employees on our HR document tonight uh one of whom uh I didn't hear this from him himself but a friend of a friend said he didn't want to be recognized or mentioned at the meeting so I didn't say anything but we had a couple long very long term and then Employee Engagement surveys but I'll I'll talk to superintendent y
234song on those um and I do want to uh you know we had a tough conversation tonight but um but I I respect everybody involved because um you know we see things completely differently but we can have a respectful conversation and I very much appreciate that with some boards and some agencies that would have devolved into um something far worse so um I I do want to say you know I believe everybody involved here is acting out of what they think are uh the best path forward I don't think that anybody has any bad motives um I just saw that situation differently um but um I do want to thank the superintendent as he mentioned uh the the school trips I I was at Miller I was at Prime and superintendent Yong is the first
235superintendent I've worked with who has invited me to go on a campus visit and I really got a lot out of just sitting in on that conversation with the admin team and then walk in the hallway and um so I think that's a that's a a really great development um not just to help us get to know the schools and and our employees better but I I feel like it um it just kind of adds a new Dynamic to the board superintendent uh relationship which I appreciate it um that said um Well Chad you usually give thanks at the end of the meeting so I'll leave that to you but uh I do want to thank everybody that made this meeting possible tonight and everybody that uh took part in presentations and public comments so
236that's it thanks M okay I'll try to be brief seeing the time that we have my safety point for the day for the month is that it's cold out there and it's not as cold as maybe some other places people have lived but when you go camping hiking boating those type of things hypothermia can set in quickly so be prepared when you go out you know it's not Florida right now that we all know and love so don't 30 you know 31 32 degrees even 40 degrees you can be hypothermic and especially if you fall on the water or get wet or something out in the woods and you got a 5H hour hike back CU you were out hiking or something you you'll find yourself in hurt um as far as the discussion that
237we had on the per last personal election that we take I I just want to make the point that I I've worked with the people that were on the discipline committee and obviously with the superintendent for a significant number amount of time now and I I trust their judgment in the sense of I know that they're good people who are trying to make the best decision that they could and and uh and I still trust them and I and I've I think this is actually the first recomend recation from the superintendent that I've eventually gone against I guess there had to be one one day you know but I just want them to know those people to know that I I know them and I trust them and I know that they're making the best
238decision that they could and and I was very pained because what it came down to for for me was the interest of the school system and maintaining a proper procedure and and and a common procedure versus the effect that this decision was going to have on the this long-term employees life and at the very end and actually some comments that were made by at the End by some board members TI the scale where I went with the effect that it was going to have on this person's life which was very close to the interest of the school system but the point is that I I just want the people in and on the staff to know that they still have my confidence and I trust their judgment and those are the end of my comments
239thank you thank you um Miss okay I have to swap my leg so I can read um uh first I just want to reiterate congratulations again to our Sunshine Scholars they those young ladies um I am just so impressed with they the the work that some of our kids do um I wow just it's amazing the things that they are able to do I could not have done what they do when I was in high school and I'm sometimes wondering if I could do it as an adult um also um Miss diato and Miss Bennett for their wonderful work our our guidance counselors are incredible hardworking people who spent a lot of time doing other things beyond their own jobs um you know I've seen them doing testing and and running kids around to you
240know on field trips and and and so many other things that are not their job uh precisely and and they still come to work every day they're working hard for their their students uh and I I have nothing but respect for them um since we've gotten back uh this semester I have been to the SAR and for monthly event at Bishop Museum it's incredible if any of my fellow board members have not been there please go you will be wowed uh it was way bigger than I had ever anticipated I've gotten to go to FBLA competition FFA competition Elementary Vex robotics competitions um I am going on uh Wednesday to go see the pigs being judged uh at the fair so if you get bored and want to come hang out with me and see
241the pigs uh I will be there um and uh just this is Big Time competition season I'm going to try and get to everything I can um and and please keep inviting us I know all of all of us really enjoy those things um I also was one of the board members who was able to attend the MTC law enforcement graduation um it was really great to see uh these uh men and women who are uh have all come from different walks of life uh coming together to to serve our community um in in a in a thanless job um really um and then um so I've got coming up we've got I'm sure most of us are going to be if not all of us are going to be reading to Children this coming
242week I am looking forward to that um that'll be a lot of fun and uh and it's one of the many things that really make this job awesome is when we get to go spend time in the classrooms and and see our kids um in action with our teachers um and then I would also like to to state that I do absolutely um struggled with today's decision um I I absolutely respect our staff and and their viewpoints and if I had full access to the record with regards to this case and and uh I may have made a different decision but based on what we had I had to go with what I what I had in front of me um and that was really really very difficult um um but uh I I'm hoping
243we made the right decision and and as Mr Tatum said this is going to be one that that bothers me because I I I don't know um but otherwise uh I want to thank our staff I know we kept you here really late tonight uh ladies and gentlemen but thank you for all you do uh we could not do this without you thank you m okay I just want to say thank you to the staff as well and to those who are retiring uh I know some don't want their name mentioned I'm not going to mention but other than first name Kimberly 28 almost 29 years dental assistant uh and then uh Katherine 22.5 six years and then not him this one is a 35 year don't say I will not I will not uh
244thank you to your service who you are you know who you are um another uh uh teacher for 24.25 years and I did and another one for 22 years and it goes on uh but that's the biggest of it but I did notice and I talked about this with the superintendent and during my briefing about getting hire dates because if you look at our board work for HR we have a lot of turnover of teachers bus AIDS bus drivers and I see on here that we have a retirement of 1.6 years of service so to me they came decided this isn't what they wanted and they left but I would still like to have their initial hire date I don't need the In-N-Out but I'd like to I don't know what else the board thinks
245of that but I think that would give us an idea about however many people left up here um number a teacher that left Lakewood Ranch how long were they here we don't know so that was a request I made at my board work uh briefing rather um bus donation was made to the Dream Center from what I understand uh that's something I advocated for and I'm glad they got that um Christmas was busy for everybody uh for me it was packing candy cane bags 100 bags with 130 Candy cans for all of our drivers and I delivered them on Thursday I couldn't hand them out on Friday because my husband had dental surgery so I couldn't do that so I'm hoping that all of the bus drivers enjoyed passing those candy canes out to to
246their uh kids also one of the highlights of last week was attending uh ballor with Mrs Ben Carson candy who was there to dedicate a reading room which is absolutely fabulous uh the kids seemed very engaged it was an honor to even just talk to her I didn't even realize that's who I was talking to until I found out that's who she is she's just so common and and it was just a great event and I don't know who put us in for that but I'm glad we got it and it was very well received uh with the students and from what I seen the board members that were there was pretty liking it a lot too so the don't forget the fair as Miss uh Felton and uh Mr Jensen mentioned uh I saw
247Mr uh Edwards leaving and he set up a fair a booth at the fair in the veterans hall and he asked when I was coming I said when it warms up uh I spent many a day out at that fair freezing uh so I'm hoping to get out there Saturday but thank you staff for staying so long and again it was a difficult subject that we discussed and I thank the legal team for giving us a directive uh if someone comes up and says hey I want to talk to you all you can do is listen and that's all you can do is listen and that's the way I'm going to approach everything when it comes to qu judicial you can listen you don't have to comment and that's where I'm going to leave it
248thank you chair great meeting thanks done a great job uh staff thank you very much as always um we get in here we could do this for a couple hours or whatever but it takes weeks and weeks to build this um so thank you very much to everybody involved I do want to say a couple things um we we talked about a lot of stuff tonight that has to deal with relationships from uh Miss diio Miss Bennett and the relationships they have with School counseling I don't think I mean I that's unbelievable that we have the the guidance counselor and also um the uh The Advocate in the district at the same time same year I it's pretty incredible and and what they have to do um nowadays is not just oh you only have
249three social studies you need four take you know I mean they they do so much more than what it used to be and so um it's about relationships the graduation rate you know it it is a it's a lot about a relationship um and and making School making sure kids are coming to school um you know what what problems are they having and and I think we sometimes maybe take for granted at least maybe people watching the public and we're in here doing meetings and oh this and that whatever but at the end of the day it's about the relationship that our staff has with kids and um which is which is utmost important um speaking of relationships lot of lot of Dr weong and I today quas we're talking about we're already in ending
250winter sports and a lot of things are happening playoffs Etc I do know the girls um uh districts are this weekend last weekend was the the counties which every County in the school participated um every County every school in the county participated last week um and my daughter lifs so it's fun time um long but it's it's good um and so um I can't believe we're Fair season we're already almost at the end of January um seemed like Thanksgiving was yesterday tennis is coming up yeah so um Ben Carson was great again relationships how that happened by relationships somebody talking with somebody how that that's that's how that happens and so um I'm excited about that I I don't think that's going to be the last one in our um in our district I'm excited
251for that future as well um other than that um it's great seeing miss sellers at a at a hockey game uh over the break that was great uh maybe begin sometime um with that we are we'll see everybody Friday everybody had a good rest of the week we are J [Music]