CorpusRecord 178917

January 13, 2025 Public Hearing

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Carroll County Schools
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Carroll County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,212 words · about 24 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I like to call to order this public hearing for the Carol County Board of Education for January the 13th 2025 like to welcome all of our visitors and guest here we thank you so much for being here tonight and for being a part of this public hearing we hope that the information will be helpful and hopefully that we'll be able to answer your questions in some kind of way so thank you so much guest for being a part of of this meeting let's all stand together and we'll have the Pledge of Allegiance I PL aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you you may be seated all right at this time I'd

002like to turn it over to our superintendent Mr Scott coward thank you Mr chair and and as Mr Turner echoed we appreciate all of you being here today for a public hearing um wanted to share that our Board of Education uh has diligently been working to study House Bill 581 uh since late in the summer uh it was first on our August uh agenda and it's been on each of our agendas each as we've moved through the fall and um we've updated the board and they've had conversation about what house bill 581 could mean uh whether to it opt out or opt in the uh if the board were to choose to opt out one of the things that we want to make clear is it does not impact any current homestead exemption if they

003were to choose to opt out it does not impact any current homestead exemption also we want to be clear that senior homeowners in Carol County already are exempt from paying school taxes and and this does not change if they opt out that our seniors would continue to be exempt from uh school taxes so those are just a couple things as we get started uh at this time I'd like to turn it over to miss delene wolf who was our assistant superintendent for business and finance uh she will share information about House Bill 581 and then we'll turn it back over to Mr Turner for public input thank you Mr House 58 one created a um new exemption and this exemption has a long name it's called the Statewide adjusted basee adorm homestead exemption this um

004new exemption adds on to the current exemptions it stacks on top of those it does not change any of the current exemptions uh as Mr coward Shar shared the opt out process only applies to the new exemption and the board has one chance to opt out the assessments made by the County Tax Assessor's office will continue to be done at fair value then um the new with the new exemption the state would then um control the amount of this exemption and cap by establishing a cap annual that would then um go next to those fair value assessments um for schools the state funding formula is designed to split the funding for schools between State funding and local funding when the fair values of properties locally increase the state funding for our schools decreases and these

005decreases um are based on the fair value and do not consider any of the local exemptions while we can't predict um with in a precise way what um the impact of this new exemption would be um going forward we can look back and see if this um new exemption had gone into effect 5 years ago and had been in place each of the Last 5 Years the aggregate impact could be as much as $21 million equate to over 200 teaching positions um due to the cap by the state that is already in place for the um millage rate um the board would not be able to offset that amount by increasing the millage rate to the cap which would mean reducing the budget and reducing services for Carol County learners for schools um there are

006there is no other way to fund the general fund other than through that state funding and the local um property tax funding cities and Counties have other um ways to generate funding for their budgets the impact um for the new homestead exemption would grow each year with the impact becoming more and more significant over time and while the uh the statute and the uh calculations may be complex the impact is simple first it would mean long-term less funding for schools and secondly less local control the next um two um hearings are scheduled for January 21st at noon and at 6:00 p.m. at this time Mr Turner I would turn it back over to you thank you Mr Wolf with appreciate that presentation and hopefully clarifying some details as uh there's been a lot of unclarity

007about this house bill as we've spent uh multiple opportunities uh trying to be educated and and and brought up to speed on what it what it is and its impact on our system couple things that I think is critically important to make sure that we highlight as a board that we're very proud of and and very grateful to be able to have the opportunity to do in the past we've we've continued to provide tax relief uh for for our public uh as a as a board of education we've had three consecutive years of millage rate cuts and then overall we've had 177% reduction in millage rates since 2016 and by having the lowest tax per learner of any local multi high school around in their districts we we feel as if we've been able to

008provide more with less uh that's something that we are very grateful for and that we are thankful F that we have the opportunity to do and we want to continue to to operate in that exact same uh Direction and that same path while providing a stellar educational opportunity here in Carol County schools and so we are grateful for our staff our leadership and for all that's been done over the last several years it's hard to ignore our our graduation rates and the things that we've been able to accomplish as a system but not as a board but as a collective system everybody working together on the same page and uh and doing that so uh thank you very much for sharing that report and uh we appreciate you guys uh sharing the highlights and Mr

009Cowart uh also your information so at this time is there anyone that would like to speak in this public hearing for the board yes sir if you will just state your name and uh and and where you live pleas sir my name is j Bennett I live at 2015 old Columbus Road Bowden I've been in Carol County Rural car County for 48 years I'm a homeowner and a land owner um normally for such an occasion I would have prepared a little uh more detailed but I didn't have that opportunity I've had a family member in the hospital the last seven days so I've been in two different hospitals so I'm going to have to speak in Broad strokes and to begin with I'd like to congratulate you uh recently Carol County School System moved into

010the top 10 in the state and that's outstanding and I believe that is directly towards your leadership as a board and specifically to Mr coward congratulations and thank you and I have great confidence that this board will do that going to the future but the way I see this issue it is an issue of how we are going to fund our government and I believe that our state legislature is signaling to us all and specifically to our school boards with HB 58 1 that they're moving away from a wealth-based or a property tax based method of Taxation and moving towards more of a consumption-based series of Taxation which is where we get our spos funds and our other uh other monies from to that end it wasn't just a victory that HB 581 achieved in

011the in the general assembly it was a 164 to2 and in the Senate it was 52 to Z that our Senators and our legislators were pointing to this direction and I think that is a strong mandate that they really wish that this would be carried forward and carried forward into the future your voters in the recent election voted almost 2 to one your constituents in favor of this action we do not not want going forward and I speak for myself but I bet there are a lot of like-minded individuals in this audience we do not want our government to under threat of losing your property that be our tax base we want it to be a consumption based tax initiative moving forward that is what our state government is telling us that they're wanting to

012do that's how they're signaling us and I fear that if we opt out of this then we are making a signal to our state government and we are making a signal to the homeowners and the land owners in this in this County that we're not going to go that direction as a county that's not who we think we are as a people I don't agree with that I definitely do not believe you should opt out and one of the consequences of opting out of this system might be a loss of faith in this board and our superintendent I don't want that to happen I have tremendous respect for this entire board I really really do and the job that Mr Cowart has done has been nothing short of exemplary but I don't want to see

013the t- spast or any spast that supports our education system fail because our population is angry because of what they perceive has occurred that our government in in this case our government is this board is unable to take a reduction in their uh budget of one or two per. I have tremendous faith that you guys can absorb that today and that our state government is not going to leave that as a whole for you building as it would in the future you're looking at these numbers through the Last 5 Years what some of the greatest inflation in land prices that Carol County has ever achieved that is not a great lens to look through in my opinion this 5year window that we're looking at is not a great place to say oh it's going to

014be this massive number year in and year out it will mitigate it will not continue to we will not continue to grow by 100% over 5 years again and again and again it will not happen so so I want you to recognize that the people that are going to stand up here tonight they're not not Anarchist all right they just believe that low taxes are essential and they believe in good schools and they believe in well-funded schools but we have to change the methods by how we fund our governments and that includes our schools and HB 581 is a step in that direction and that's why I hope that this board and their wisdom will not opt out of this Homestead uh exemption law thank you thank you benett anyone else that like to address

015the board yes sir Brian Hager 2314 Pleasant Ridge Road um thank you very much for holding this hearing thank you to all the people who are attending and showing interest in this we're all here because we recognize that public education is one of the greatest Innovations technologies that we have developed providing um public education that is free to children to access is not a universal service applied around the world it has been the foundation of our um democracy and our economy having people who can read write well can participate in this um information economy that is being created right now is very important and I think we all recognize that so this debate is how we fund that this bill is part of a long-term effort by many in the general assembly to limit your

016ability to fund schools let's be clear on that and it's a one-way trip when this bill was passed it got the broad support it did because of the opt out provision that was in there because that was the demand by the people who wanted to retain the right of local school boards to manage their money and to be able to fund their schools in the best way possible now if as a gentleman who preceded me um if he is correct and the state does come up with some additional funding you can go back the other direction you can choose to opt in in the future however if you don't opt opt out now you cannot opt out in the future that's in the law and so this gives you the flexibility to respond to if

017the state does in fact increase funding now we've seen the struggle that they've had to fully fund the quality basic education act and um the cumulative deficit that the local school systems have had to deal with over the last decade due to that has put a real strength on your ability to do your work of providing good education so while we can hope that the state will actually step up and take some of the burden off of local Property Owners until they do that I think it would be a real disservice to the students um of this County for you to bank on that given the track record that we've seen and the difficulty it is to do that at the State Legislative record so I ask you to take the opt out this time

018and if the state comes up with some additional funding mechanisms as a gentleman before me suggested you have the opportunity to change you don't have the opportunity to change if you allow this to proceed and give the state more control over how you fund our County Schools thank you very much thank you Mr Hager all right anyone else yes sir good afternoon my name is Jim Stevenson I live at 7257 Confederate Lane V reca one of the first thing I want to ask is will you entertain a question and that question being uh what is the current budget for this this year I suppose if you've come up with one if not what was last year's budget do do we to I think I saw information say in the neighborhood about $194 million am I

019close you you can I mean it's it's public it's public knowledge for sure I mean just usually in public yes sir it's public knowledge but we want we want to provide that information for you Norm it's reason we're trying to question is because normally public input you you know we don't but we we can get you that number pretty quick and Miss uh Delan can share that round number for you there was one other question I live in Fairfield Plantation yes sir because we play D out there and one of the things that we pay for is a effectively a contingency fund rainy day fund whatever you want to call it does the school board have a similar fund yes we have it's called a reserve fund equity and we keep a certain amount of

020money back how much that would be she could tell you yes um all of that information is available on our website um but to specifically answer um the questions as requested the um general fund budget is um 198 million for this fiscal year and the reserve fund is um what the target is is approximately two months of payroll how much is that that is um roughly um 25 million you said that's the target uh do you have that much in your reserve fund now or you're still shooting for it I would be happy to set up a time to meet with you and um go through um all the details all right thank you absolutely as you can tell I'm a senior so I don't don't pay school tax anymore I paid it for a

021long time yes sir uh but I have children and grandchildren that live in Carol County that do so I'm really concerned about their interest and I'm in a sense standing here speaking on their behalf uh the current millage rate that was on my tax bill for school tax was 16 point I think a quarter thereabouts and the state capts it at 20 Mills so you've got uh about 3.75 Mills that you could increase it if you come short of your budget so I'm concerned about opting out of what the state has mandated because they've tied Theirs to the CPI and CPI has been roughly over the last at least 20 years running about 3% you ever take a tenth or two so if they allow you to increase your exemption and and get an additional

0223% of roughly $200 million it seems like that would be sufficient without coming back to the taxpayers but even if they do you have that option to increase your millage rate you also have a t blast not t blast and East blast excuse me uh which I believe you're going to be asking for a vote on that again is this year yes so you're wanting an additional 1% of tax revenue which uh I actually voted for because I'd rather fund government in just eneral through a consumption type tax as opposed to having my property always leveraged I never Own It none of you own your property well you technically have title you never own it as long as the government has a lean against it and I'm like Mr Bennett said ready to get rid

023of that lean and go to something like a consumption tax so I would much prefer to vote for a East blst and give you additional funds that way rather than you opting out and then having the the option to increase the homestead exemption you know I've been in Carol County 20 years i' much prefer to have my children in school here than where I came from which happened to be Cobb County their schools in my opinion have degraded I guess this as good a word as any uh every report I get from Carol County is is positive so I commend you in that regard but by the same token I also want to keep government's hands out of my pocketbook if I voluntarily buy something and I'm paying taxes as a part of that purchase

024that's my option to purchase or not purchase but I do not have an option when you come back to me and send me a tax bill which I happen to have a copy of Mind here and say you owe this much and if I don't pay now you got to lean on my property so please take that in consideration I am opposed to opting out let's take what the state legislature has passed and then put it to good use thank you g thank you sirar yeah I I think that I think it would be appropriate to address the consumption tax just a moment hopefully provide some more clarity to that I think you know some really good comments have been made about I think all of us in this room would love to go to

025more of a consumption tax uh type funding mechanism for public schools unfortunately we've asked our legislators for several years to allow us to have a consumption tax to pay for school operations and they have refused to do that uh our current East blast we can only spend that on facilities and buses and things of that nature we cannot pay for personnel instructional needs and things out of the East blast uh they make us separate that and so what we asked them to do was to create a separate uh consumption tax that would allow us to pay our general fund which can then offset property taxes but they have refused to do that there is no mechanism in House Bill 581 for them to do that and in fact that came up again this past year

026in the legislature and they did not pass it Forward uh we will keep asking for that uh because we we like you believe that that is a more Equitable way um to fund um our public schools and and hopefully hopefully at some point in time I I hope you're right I hope that they do that Mr coward yes sir is it for further clarification though is it not true that the state legislature gave the cities and the counties the ability to raise a separate 1% sales tax if they decided not to opt out that did not allow the school systems to do that so they didn't even treat us all the same yeah Mr C makes a very very valid point cities and counties if they opt out of this have the mechanism for an

027additional if they don't opt out okay if they don't opt out yeah that's right but they would not give that to us in the school district now we we don't understand why but that's where it is currently uh and again we are constantly talking to our legislators asking them uh if they will make that change please because we we're in to we're in total agreement I think everybody at this table would would totally agree that that would be and if they would have hooked that to this yeah I wish they would and and and I appreciate the passion you know as Dr Mr Stevenson shared about there's always that opportunity on the table to raise the millage rate if after this goes down we find out you can't meet the needs or you can't make

028the cuts to do that but I think we all in this room have to be honest every one of us all being taxpayers the last thing anybody would want to hear is uh the the the not opt out and now all of a sudden we we have to raise the millage rate it would be it would be just reciprocating an issue that we feel that would be very very negative across the board for our public for our community and anyway we've now then chosen the route that that makes it difficult for him back leveraging towards property in order to make ends meet between the cuts and that so it is a very difficult place and our board has is just continued to deliberate and try to think and and no one has reached a decision

029despite you know the communications been put forth we haven't released any kind of statement to say what our option what we plan to do uh which is why we're having the hearings is to be able to have the opportunity to hear and address those concerns and understand them a little bit better and to clarify what uh Mr Turner just said the the legal notice that was put in the paper we were required to word it the way it was worded correct we had no option but to word it in that way anyone else i' like to address the board I'm sorry Dr Brooks go ahead I understand a gentleman who just spoke you said that we were adding one penny on that's not quite accurate We are continuing the one penny that you all have

030approved years on we're not adding another Penny we are just continuing the spls penny that has been in uh operation for how many 1998 since 1998 hope you don't think that we adding another one cent all right anyone else at this time i' like to address the board please please forgive me left leg here Robert pink me 4234 ESS Drive Villa since I've been I'm from New York I'm a former superintendent from Long Island since I've been here the state has failed to fund education at the level that the constitution says it should therefore I would be suspicious about this Homestead Act or this five what's the number 51 5811 act from from the house Splash money as Mr coward has indicated has nothing to do with teacher salary uh our business official said that

031had this been in place for the past five years we would have lost uh approximately 2021 million and approximately 20200 and some OD uh teachers I I realiz realiz that everything we're talking about estimate or guesstimate coming down but when you use those types of numbers I also used when I was running a school district and notion that a school district's budget reflects its commitment to the education of the children that it serving and when we are cutting back on class sizes those of us who are not in the classroom those of us who've had children and they're no longer in the classroom may not realize that 25 plus students in the classroom does provide education it provides containment and we're looking to see we're celebrating the successes of Carol County how do you expect

032those to uh to continue education cost it's as simple as that you can argue with the board left and right you can argue with the business office but the bottom line is that it's going to cost money to educate all of our children and this exemption bothers bother me greatly and I would hope that the school board in its deliberations would decide to opt out but may I ask uh darl forgive me I served on the board so if I use first names I apologize uh what does it mean when it says opt out we can opt out in one or two years do we know what the future holds on the other side of that are there any penalties assess to those who systems that do choose to opt out not that we know

033of this time but that that's actually would been one of the questions we've asked Dr pentney we want clarification there again goes A legislature who in my estimate all I'm not picking on Georgia's legislation New York's legislation as well uh double talk when they're trying to get legislation passed For Those whom they find of Interest as an educator a career educator I find All Children's interest necessary and needed again I repeat myself if an option was given to us we should take advantage of that option those of us who may be opposing it we do those of who are supporting it we do but the bottom line is it belongs to seven people in your discussions in your deliberations and you're listening to the community speak to you taxes are a part of our life

034I respect it I would love to pay less taxes on everything that we have but taxes are a part of our life let's modify let's research let's look at how we're assessing our monies using our monies but please do not believe in my estimation of working with in a totally different state working with legislators please do not believe that the interest of all school districts and education of all children is at their heart the choice is because I do believe there's a word here called voucher and voucher means you remove monies from if if I take my children which I don't have I have six grandchildren but if I take my six grandchildren out of uh the car County schools and they don't live here but if I were to take them out of the

035Carol County Schools am I saving anything you're going to give me a voucher the voucher is going to say x number of dollars are going to go to whatever private school I wish to attend are we not aware that currently all private schools are at maximum so if you're going to remove where are they going to go where seats are they going to have in order for it to happen let's think seriously deeply and considerately about what we're saying here and Board of Education those that I know new members welcome those that I know please let's opt out and fight the battle down the road but let's not concede to A legislature that has not since the Constitution written and in my 16 years of being here has not funded education to the level that

036it was if it had a lot of things would not have been asked for or expected and when we and I'll close on this when you say raise the millage rate I find that very interesting every school district I worked in every budget season then I put the first question that was asked to me are you going to reduce the taxes and now I just hear people saying you can increase the millage rate the board just went through a session to reduce the millage rate for the interest of the community and now we're just flippantly saying add to the millage rate to that which means add to your taxes thank you for your time I wish you the very best for my supporters to opt out thank you Dr PNE all right anyone else hi

037my name is Norma Jean Kitty I'm at 325 Rosewood Lane Carolton and I'm not an eloquent eloquent speaker in fact I get rather nervous speaking in front of people uh my son went to uh B Raa high school and um first of all I want to say that you did a very fine job although F Rica High School still has many problems and had problems while he was there um there's a lot going on in the background that people don't know about um overall you do a great job in all your schools I was a substitute teacher for a while so I saw a lot and the teachers work very hard and do a great job um also I want to tell you that if you opt out you are going against almost 63% of

038the local community that voted for this bill so that's something you should really think about the other thing is when my son was in high school he was part of the theater Pro uh crowd and they had a fine Auditorium to per do their performances in and I'm still trying to figure out why this vanity project of the Performing Art Center was built and how much it costs to best the students back and forth to that vanity project and how many teachers you could have hired instead of building that project and that's all I'd like to say thank you very much for your time thank [Applause] you all right we'll make one more call anyone else yes sir my name is Robert graph and I live in 96 o Mill Court Carolton and I have

039to say somewhat after this HB 851 came up for us to vote on it wasn't really clear it was hard to understand what they were actually wanting to do and I'm not the only one a lot of my friends and people I know I would ask them what's it mean what are we doing so I'm going to kind of tell you what I I think it means and it may not be correct so I appreciate your feedback and letting me know I get it that basically what they're doing is on a Statewide basis all the education systems the way they're going to be able to tax it if you don't opt out you have to follow the state guideline and it says you can only raise the taxes based on the inflation rate that they

040gave and that's for everybody I don't get that because not every school system has the same needs and same situations it doesn't give them flexibility I've always heard that we wanted from this state most of our legislators wanted local control so in my opinion this doesn't give us local control on the level that we're here as the people that are using using it and needing it and our children going it's being done by the state so it also telling me is is that your B ability to um you still have the ability if you don't opt out to increase tax is that not true okay but they just control how much you can do it that's basically kind of the Restriction so in my opinion I would like for you guys to have the control

041I I would recommend and support opting out thank thank you all right anyone else before we adjourn all right I need to move in second we adjourn this first public hearing I'll make that motion I'll second that motion all in favor say I all right meeting journ from our public hearing we'll take just a brief break before work session

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.