CorpusRecord 178957

January 22, 2025, Board of Education Community Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / City Schools of Decatur
Date
2025-01-29
Location
DeKalb County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,863 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001well good evening City schools of the cater families I'm Dr Jima Whitaker I serve as your superintendent and I would love to welcome you to the January 22nd community meeting at this time I'm going to turn it over to our board memb Sophie De Elena to continue with today's meeting EST she might need some help unmuting herself Sophie you there she said her mic won't unmute in the chat Dr Whitaker do you want me to get started and then Sophie can raise a hand if she's able to unmute her mic and then I can stop yes yes you can all right I'll do that Sophie if you are able to get your mic to unmute just wave a hand and then or you can just unmute yourself and yell that'll work too all right um

002I want to welcome everyone and thank you for joining us virtually tonight my name is Dr Carmen Sulton and I'm the current chair of the of the city schools of decater uh Board of Education uh before I share tonight's agenda I want to ground us in our strategic accelerators the Board of Education adopted the Strategic plan in March of 2023 and identified these four critical strategic accelerators which guide our work uh Student Success in all areas building and sustaining and engaging and inclusive culture cultivating and retaining high quality professionals and organ organizational Effectiveness and Excellence our community meetings are designed to Foster two-way communication with the community we will start with board member presentations on several agenda topics I will review these agenda topics ICS in a moment then there will be question a question

003and answer period for the Q&A portion of the meeting we ask that you have a if you have a comment to share use the raise hand feature in Zoom um I will call on you in the order in which your hand was raised once called please unmute yourself um to allow maximum participation we ask that speakers limit their time to 3 minutes um and please let us know your first and last name if you're able tonight's agenda includes the Georgia Vision project was which was facilit Ed by a newly elected uh board chair myself as well as board member Tracy Anderson uh the Early Learning update which will be facilitated by a newly elected board Vice chair uh Mr Hans UTS and board member Dr Jana Johnson Davis fiscal year 26 budget development which will

004be facilitated by board member Mr James hearnen and last it will be time for community members to engage in a question answer session with the board now um I will start with uh myself and board member Anderson and we will talk about the Georgia Vision project so uh board member Anderson if you want to go ahead and get started hey all glad to see so many people here and please bear with me if my Wi-Fi goes out or something happens with the camera I am here um so first this Georgia Vision project has helped guide us in both creating as well as implementing our strategic plan it's a Statewide initiative that aims to provide all children with an equitable and excellent education that should prepare them for Life a career and college uh it sets

005world-class educational standards as you can see on the slide establishes viable directives creates sustainable framework and organizes contemporary networks so you can see that the initiative is working with lots of Partners school districts the Georgia SCH Schoolboard Association and uh I'm excited to be a part of it so if we can move to the next slide please um and this is a question that I like to ask a lot you know why and why now and ideally one of the things we're doing tonight is exemplifying that building trust and support for public education ensuring meaningful engagement and communication with Public Schools creating a single Vision to change the education culture culture in our state providing a rewarding educational experience for all Georgia students ensuring our students are competitive in a global economy increasing significantly the

006high school graduation rate ensuring appropriate curricula for a new generation of Learners making learning more rigorous more relevant and more real and being more responsive to students individual needs uh the state believes this vision project is important and Urgent for several reasons that I've outlined here and it aims to set a bold standard for what public education across the state should aspire to be for all Georgia Learners and I think one thing we could do is look at the various things we uh aim to accomplish and consider which ones resonate most with CSD um and I'd like to think again this meeting um can definitely help pave the way for these meaningful um engagements between the board and uh all of you we can move to the next slide and there are seven areas of

007impact so I'll um finish this slide and I think then Dr Sulton I can hand it back over to you uh focuses on seven key areas Early Learning and Student Success teaching and learning human and organizational Capital governance leadership and accountability culture climate and organizational efficacy teaching and learning resources and Financial Resources as a board of education we desire to operate in excellence and are on track to seek exemplary status for City schools of Decay as you reflect on key components of Georgia's Vision you'll notice direct alignment with the four strategic accelerators of CSD strategic plan which offers evidence that our district is committed to taking actionable steps that help to realize this vision for our students thank you all right next um so what are our next steps um finally we encourage you to

008join us in this effort um you can learn more about what the Georgia Vision project is by visiting the website or scanning the QR code to access the summary overview which is in the slide there we welcome your influence and input in Sharing CSD success to stretch our goals and our strategic alignment with the Georg Vision project we also ask for your active support as CSD aims to meet and exceed standards for public education in Georgia our district is grateful to have Community stakeholders like all of you who bolster our efforts to provide the absolute best education experience we can for all of our students within the city schools of decar and now we will go on to uh our presentation on Early Childhood learning with h board member Hans UTS and Dr Jana Johnson

009d good evening um our next presentation shares exciting progress towards expanding access to Early Learning in city schools of decada next slide oh yep the construction of the new Early Learning Center falls under the organizational Effectiveness and excellent strategic accelerator but we know the outcomes of this early learning Central will reach all strategic accelerators in 2017 the city schools of decada purchase land from the decada Housing Authority with a commitment to use the land for public school purposes CSD has an opportunity to provide a high quality Child Care Program that will ensure kindergarten Readiness for CD's largest undeserved community at the decada Housing Authority while also supporting families across the district why do we believe that early childhood is a part of the solution to the significant dispar ities in our district the research on

010the efficacy of early childhood education is robust and it is clear that a high quality Early Learning Program is a key factor in ensuring Student Success in all areas a few things to consider our brains develop most between birth and age8 these are some of the most fertile years to learn and develop Early Learning can have a lifelong effect adults who participated in high quality Early Learning were found to be more likely to be employed have graduated from high school and have higher earnings than those who did not it also makes economic sense Nobel prizewinning Economist James Heckman shows that every dollar invested in quality Early Childhood can yield returns between $4 and $16 Studies have shown savings and later intervention cost that's not even tax tackling the impact of family financial stability next slide

011please the disparity in our academic data is often shared but I'd like you to consider some other data a recent survey of families living at Decor decator Housing Authority demonstrated that child care is an impediment to Career Development for many families with 20% of respondents reporting that they were unable to progress their career or education due to childcare issues that is the beginning of our Equity Gap right now we have 67 children who are not enrolled in a early childhood education program at all we also know that while there are some wonderful Early Learning opportunities and Decor including within our own district there is still more need this need also actually transcends our families that are economically disadvantaged in a survey done this fall to gauge interest in a new early learning facility a majority

012of the 100 economically diverse family surveyed identifi affordability and accessibility as key concerns the proposed Early Learning Center is expected to offer 13 birth through prek classes with flexible spaces to adjust to accommodate evolving needs the building will serve between 135 to 150 students College Heights is currently a model Early Learning Center and we plan to replicate it it success by using the same curriculum we will focus on using conscious discipline Equity focused instruction and science of reading aligned practices because this Early Learning Center will replace the Frasier Center this new building will be the hub for the high school's teaching as a profession pathway as we expand this promising and needed pathway now our will turn things over to board member Hans UTS uh thank you Dr Johnson Davis uh so as yall might

013imagine this is a complex undertaking so what we see here is an aerial view of a conceptual design and I want to emphasize the word conceptual this is not the final design um we are in process of working on bringing forward um uh a number of uh design documents and we should expect I Believe by the end of February uh beginning of March to have these plans finalized but what we wanted to do was put some Concepts in front of the community so the community can understand uh one what some of the limitations are that we're operating under and two how we are thinking about and looking at solving some of the complicated um uh designs and desires for use on this property one of the things that we are committed to is ensuring that

014as much green space as possible is left remaining on this particular lot uh that has been very clear to us as a community desire one of the other things that we've been very focused on is ensuring that we have this built as a familyfriendly uh camp campus and we have been uh very focused on exploring the use of mass Timber which is a very strong Sustainable Building Material made of wood as opposed to concrete or steel just to lessen the economic or I mean to lessen the environmental impact of the um of the property if we could move to the next slide and again this is a first iteration of the conceptual design once this design uh the iterations of this design are uh completed and approved the architectural firm will move forward with the

015schematic design phase which will address a number of the uh architectural structural and uh mechanical and electrical components uh ultimately that'll be followed by the actual design phase preparation of preconstruction documents and then the solicitation of uh proposals for the construction management at risk um after the contract the administration phase will begin during which the selected construction management risk firm will begin all of the preconstruction phase services so uh this is a uh expensive project as I think no one would be surprised to understand um we have a number of funding sources uh the fact that this is a large capital expenditure means that spast funding is available grants and donations are available uh but ultimately we will look at uh uh general fund sources of revenue as required in order to bring this this

016project to completion excuse me uh it will involve building building this funding strategy will involve uh multiple Financial sources to ensure that not just the cap capit outlay to build it is uh supported but also the Run rate and operating costs of of having the facility um uh in and that is uh a part of um what we will be ensuring that we we solve for if we go to the next the next slide uh our next key steps uh uh include taking uh or receiving I should say additional stakeholder feedback obviously any comments from the community tonight uh will be something that we document and and uh bring into the plan uh we ensure that there's additional communication that is uh going to be going out regarding the state of the project and where

017we are in the project uh and we will be providing uh we be exploring additional funding options and communicating that uh as I mentioned earlier we will expect towards the end of February beginning of March to have some of the final documentation around what the plan looks like uh and what the the site map will look like which will allow us to begin putting together more precise estimates on the overall calls next slide please so if there are any questions or in in any way feedback that the community wants to provide please uh take a look at this QR code or send an email to Early Learning at CS at.net uh this is the phase of work where we are actively s seeking Community input and feedback on not just the conceptual designs but but

018still wanting to hear from the community about the priorities and ensuring that what we do finally bring forward towards March is going to be reflective of the best compromises between all of the constituent uh requirements that we hear so uh you know as as we continue to engage one of the things that we would ask for is your continued advocacy uh here in this slide you see us saying continuing to Champion uh the work that we need to do uh in order to serve the the children in our community but we would also ask for your ADV advocacy around what you want to ensure the plan entails uh if if uh you know this is one of the things that you saw on that on that drawing was the amount of green space that we

019are attempting to preserve uh that is because we heard that loud and clear from the community as as we built these plans continue to partner uh with us uh and and ensure you know the expertise of this community around so many of the questions that have to be answered uh through a project like this is is crucial to helping us be successful and then to the extent that uh you have contacts with donors or individuals who can support work like this to support early childhood education please do share those with us and work with us to ensure that we can uh uh identify and Source the funding for this project as much as possible outside of the tax supported general fund next slide excuse me uh to ensure all CSD students have a strong Foundation

020starting at Birth this is uh this early learning Childhood Center has been identified as one of the crucial building blocks of the system that we need to ensure uh that we can meet these particular requirements um uh there are additional considerations that that we are uh looking into around athletic space and other ctae offerings to ensure the community is served um uh as uh to the best of our extent possible next slide please thank you so at this point I will turn this back over uh to discuss the fiscal year budget development great thank you Hans Dr johnon Davis for all that want to talk about James heren uh wanted to talk about some of the budget stuff FY 26 budget development it applies to and impacts all of our strategic accelerators U but a

021specific focus on number four that we want to effectively organize an excellent uh school system as you can see here it's kind of the calendar it's it's ongoing conversations about the board and our budget we have budget feedback link it's on the finance department's website continually seeking input feedback on the budget FY 26 budget development process began in September uh and with the development of the budget timeline the adoption of that timeline occurred in October and the board has followed that and discussed various subjects including the school allotment guideline which determines uh lets the principles and the slts of the group determine how they're going to fund the positions at the school and as well as establish the parameters and priorities reviewed the FY 24 budget and compared salaries with all of the metro area

022and and how we're doing keeping competitive in December the board looked at midterm budget amendments adopted the school allotment guideline um and this month's board meeting the board took a second look at compensation and we were also presented with a a clean audit for FY 24 as well as the budget book that came out for the last calendar was given a rating of excellent for transparency and and including all of the information that's out there for the public we will continue to follow this budget timeline we're tally scheduled to approve the FY 26 Budget on April 15th uh final approval our goal is that May 13th Schoolboard meeting um you can see there with millage hearings in June if they're required as well as the printing and availability of the budget book as we close

023out the fiscal year so FY 26 budget parameters and priorities these are sort of the guidelines for building the budget ensuring Equitable allocations of funds based on the district's priorities um my use of equity there is a reference to making sure that it's uh fairly distributed amongst each of the schools that it meets the priorities of the board and that it's focused on Equity initiatives themselves the budget parameters and priorities are one under strategic accelerator four uh organizational Effectiveness and Excellence uh we want to present a balanced budget uh where Revenue is equal to or greater than expenditures we're not deficit spending third we want to seek alternative funding sources such as grants rebates tuition to come to the gator U those are gone over every month in the area of alternative funding sources we

024want to maintain a fund balance per our policy that fund balance should always lie between four and 15% of projected expenditures we want to develop a revenue neutral budget that will not require any tax increases it's a goal of the board develop uh and ensure that the budget is aligned with the the district's four strategic accelerators that are our strategic plan invest in an Erp an enterprise resource planning system that will help us uh financial and in terms of HR manage the day-to-day business activities such as accounting position control payroll procurement accounts payable and Human Resources we want to ensure a transparent modified zerob based budgeting process I've heard Dr Whitaker say that many times essentially means that there was no floating thousand budget for this thing and the person running the system knew that

025they had $1,000 to spend and wanted to get make sure it got spent by the end of the year instead each department each project is zerob based so they have to submit uh justification for any operational request and then finally identifying opportunities for cost efficiencies and places where we can make the changes and become the system we want to be here you see that under accelerator 3 cultivating and retaining high quality professionals the FY 26 draft budget parameters and priorities are maintaining a competitive structure for all employees two funding State mandated increases for the health benefits told us we had to pay more for health care but weren't going to give us any money to help us do that third maximizing revenue from the QB e by carefully monitoring students attendance and class sizes accurately

026classifying students programs and special needs and just generally optimizing the way teacher assignments exist based on student needs in the buildings under strategic accelerator to building and sustaining and engage of inclusive culture uh for FY 26 the parameters include supporting the launch of a comprehensive seel framework to help uh cultivate skills and environment to advance all students learning and their mental development invest in Safety and Security for all students and staff in our buildings including putting the resources there and finally for Student Success in all a in all areas that includes closing the educational Gap the achievement Gap Strategic Staffing early college readiness Insight via the PSAT for eth and nth graders which measures skills and knowledge to show our College and Career ready and investing in the eclc center to equip children early with

027the tools and skills that will need throughout their academic journey and skills life honestly at the cater and Beyond the parameters and priorities are not presented or listed in any particular ranking or order just sort of what we consider when we set the parameters for the budget now practically we know the community has raised plenty of questions and concerns about the Staffing administrators and there's a lot of information here as detailed in our timeline the school allotment guidelines they are an integral part of the budget process at CSD they've been addressed at multiple board meetings Retreats the slts will then get that information and make decisions about Staffing in their individual schools and I just wanted to take a second to provide some clarity over some of the things that I've heard the most in

028terms of talking points that are out there the first is about the K through two assist assistant principles good friend said I heard you were getting rid of assistant principles in the city schools of decada and that is not true um city schools of the caters continues to have a significantly higher number of locally funded staff over the state recommended ratios and fundings so specifically the state provides CSD with funds for 8.94 assistant principles so almost four principles to cover all of our schools CSD has taken that and in La this current school year we are funding 16 assistant principal's positions which means that those additional are coming from local General funds to cover uh what's happening according to the new approved CSD School allotment guidelines the all allocation formula for APS starts at 501

029students and any higher additional enrollments when we look at our k2s all of the assistant principles have been there for less than two years uh and currently we're at 43 in Claremont 162 in Glennwood 197 in Oakhurst 139 at Westchester and 238 at Winona Park we use that instead of instead of deciding that everyone gets an assistant principal it's a certain allotments the state help funds that's the school of learning guid guideline where the principles and the slts can choose what they want to fund each fiscal year we'll continue to develop those allotment formulas and guidelines for schools last year was made available for the public in time for those meetings for increased transparency in District Operations following the outline of the parameters the development by that buz budget the enrollment for AP positions is

030an efficiency we had to look at this year the SAG was discussed as the October board meetings was mentioned in the November and December and as part of our ongoing FY 2026 board discussion another talking point we've heard about is the disproportionality and sporting Equitable outcomes I want to make it very clear and share that CSD is not under any sort of Investigation by the Georgia Department of Education CSD did receive targeted support from the Georgia doe because we have been in significant disproportionality status and special education for seven years now in the 23 24 school year the Georgia doe FTE and student data revealed a troubling trend for nearly a decade there's been a disproportionate identification of our black students for special education particularly in the categories of learning disabilities this means that a

031higher proportion of black students in CSD are placed in specific special education compared to other racial or ethnic groups the doe has conducted a site visit to conduct an in-depth root root cause analysis and are awaiting feedback on how we can target support we will receive this work needs to be done we are all in on deor to make sure that we are Equitable treated equally the all indicator strategic plan calls for Equity to be interwoven in everything we do that's part of our commitment to equity another talking point that I've heard is well I see all these new people that have been hired at the central office we went over in our previous meeting that there are fewer people currently working in central office less money being spent on those people than there were

032when Dr Whitaker was hired and brought on board one of the things that happens particularly in school systems is when you let someone go and you see a new face replacing them we often don't remember that the new person is replacing them we just see a new face and we get worried the zerob based budgeting however means that we are able to have those Justified as part of the discussion that concludes mine I will pass it on to Sophia who will um we'll open it up for some q&as yes um I got my microphone to work so we're good to go um so for this um question and answer period just press the raise hand button and I will call on the um attendee in the order in which um the hands are raised um

033Miss Kelly Brooks hi I'm I was just wondering if you would speak to the one bullet that was on a previous slide about considerations for athletic space I'm happy to address that um it's Dr Whitaker's intention once we are able to move the Fraser Center once we're able to um integrate the Fraser Center into the Early Childhood Learning Center that would allow that Fraser Center space to possibly be used as additional athletic space um are there any other comments or questions Dr Dr Whitter can I ask a just so it's publicly asked if a member of the community or a group of a community wants more athletic space to be included in planning or part of what would be the best way for them to go about um and I think we've already answered this

034question but I just want to be clear what would be the best way about going back letting that desire be known uh I'm actually meeting with the the cater booster on Friday um it was a meeting uh that was requested and so uh if anyone and I would assume that's where how when I will find out officially what it would be but um I am eager and able to meet with um the the booster so that we can talk about athletic space And as far as anything else they would want to discuss okay that's helpful um Miss Brooks I was just wondering um for the Frasier Center does that mean um The Frasier Center would have to be reconfigured to accommodate some of that athletic SP space like a auxiliary gym perhaps um it seems

035that maybe if we're starting from scratch with a new building that we could incorporate some kind of auxiliary gem which is really needed um and could use the space for the Frasier Center for all types of activities including club sports decater performs um I think it would be great with the location of the eclc to incorporate other needs um that also you know that could also serve the students of the eclc as well as the high school and the middle school I can perhaps speak to this Dr Whitaker step in if if you think that's necessary the the the one challenge with the eclc that doesn't necessarily exist uh to the same extent with the other schools is that with the little little kids uh security and ensuring that uh nobody is on that campus

036that should not be on that campus is is critical and so the ability to have other kids coming into and out of the building or coming into and out of the facility uh is just is is probably not going to be something that we can do particularly with the eclc uh and so um it is it is UN unlikely that we would be able to build a uh publicly accessible or even just a school accessible facility into the same campus where we have the the small kids and that would be accurate board member sorry can I ask a question then is I I may be confused but the Frasier Center that is currently serving young children is based at the high school right so I'm not sure how answerable this is but is there something

037about the Frasier Center and its proximity to high school older kids that would be different from eclc yes I yes uh Miss Anderson I think that's exactly the intent by by putting the kids that are in the current High School located Frasier Center by locating that on the facility for the eclc then it opens up the space that the current Frasier Center on the high school is in and allows us to recondition or reposition that space for something that all of the high school students or that any of the other students frankly in the community might be able to access or use and so it it is accomplishing that it's just I wanted to address the specifics of the of the community member's question who is asking whether or not we can build additional space

038within the new constructed eclc to allow for similar things like that which we would not be able to do um Rodney yes thank you U first of all I wanted to say thank you to Dr Whitaker for being willing to meet with dbb we really appreciate that um and secondly to that point about the gym being located at the same facility would it matter if you know it was only accessed after school hours because what we're running into with Athletics is that it's really hard um to do well with what we have and it's very difficult to grow Athletics and other clubs and um extracurricular activities at the middle school and high school just because of the space requirements there's kids in the Halls there's kids kind of everywhere um just to meet the standards

039that they have now and there's more kids wanting to join these things and it's just making it really difficult so having the space close by even if it's after hours would be really helpful so that's kind of why that's coming up and if it's possible to kind of split the day in two you know that would be a good thing so I'll jump in um to help address um some of these questions hi everyone I'm Jennifer Burton I'm the assistant superintendent for teaching and learning um and uh one of the cabinet members that's overseeing this project and what makes the Early Learning Center different from a typical school is that we would open up earlier um and we would close later so think more in terms of almost daycare hours um so it really is

040a stretch for the whole day versus kind of what you would see at an elementary school um the other thing that we have to be mindful of is all of the credentialing that comes from the state and other agencies so when we're talking about building a birth to four um or 5-year-old Center we are bound in our construction um and safety requirements um kind of connecting to what um Vice chair Utz was talking about and so um um it does make it very very difficult to have um part of the facility that would be accessible or appropriate for a middle or high schooler also be appropriate for our zero to four um and so that really is a barrier um but um you know as to what was shared earlier is that we do know

041that because the Frasier Center is moving and would be vacated there is a possibility for the high school in the district expanding and using that space for a variety of things um one of which could be Athletics um there are many needs we know um that our our district um is is looking to fill and so we will be fortunate that we have that space and when that becomes available able um that we want to work with our our community and all departments to see what needs we need to fill Miss Brooks um I just I have a question um just about to that point the um like reconfiguring the costs associated with reconfiguring a space like the Frasier Center for our needs um it seems like I mean according to the slide before it

042says it was you know upwards of 22 million for this new facility that I believe the number it said 135 to 15 students um and it just seems that you know maybe you know thinking about other ways that we can creatively use this space that serves these students um you know this age group um and also capitalizing on just the issue that we don't have accessible land indicator um and you know thinking creatively how can we creatively problem solve for the you know the security where you know students don't have access to other parts of the building but there is its own separate entrance perhaps on the basement floor or just other ways that we can think creatively to kind of also improve the ROI on this building too where it serves you know more

043than just 150 students are there any other questions as do you see any other hands raised sometimes uh Sophie and I can't see everybody I think that um Miss Mike's has her handras okay yes uh just a quick question um with the uh the lower enrollment in the lower elementary schools has there been any any consideration in maybe creating some eclc classes in the lower elementaries versus building a new center where we could potentially leverage that land for other needs yes that has been considered the issue around accessibility to the community by which it's a part of a DE um we cannot put babies Z to three on buses to transport them to any other schools and that's what would be required based upon proximity of the decator Housing Authority one of the uh one

044just to make it clear to the community we are bound by a legal agreement with DHA a part of the deed when it was transferred requires that we build and use that land and to build an early childhood Learning Center it isn't permitted for us to uh develop it to a athletic field for example it's just it's not allowed and so some of the questions that have come up regarding other uses of the facilities um there there good suggestions with the caveat that we can't obviously violate any of the requirements that the the state puts Upon Us in in terms of uh joint use um but in any scenario the principal use of the land as required by the deed transfer is to build that early childhood Learning Center there as as opposed to any

045other use so it's it's not arbitrary that we're deciding to do this this is actually a part of the legal requirement for us taking ownership of the land on top of that I I do want to emphasize what Dr Whitaker just said we are dealing with some of the numbers that you saw in these slides you know 67 kids for example that are eligible for Early Childhood learning that are not attending it because they lack the ability to get to other locations for example College Heights where those services are offered that is the core problem we're trying to address the proximity really really matters and so that is uh exactly what um our intent is in in developing this early childhood Learning Center um Miss gin hi can you hear me yes we can hear

046you okay thanks I'm wondering just to the um point that Vice chair has just made um was the Frasier Center at any point an option for parents at the decer Housing Authority in terms of enrolling their children there because it seems like if that if that proximity didn't work for them then I'm not sure how the new one will work either I'm just curious if that if that study has been done no actually there is a weight weight list actually at the Fraser Center as well and the Fraser Center is serves our currently serves our staff and there's a weight list there as well as a weight list at College Heights to to that point though it's a great question one of the things that we're very clear on resolving is ensuring that uh of

047the space that is being set aside in the early childhood Learning Center that the the students from DHA will have access to that that we are not trying to set up uh a new facility that then ALS o ends up on a wait list and the same 67 kids literally right next door are are shut out we are going to be making sure those seats in those spaces are reserved for the kids that are that are that are needing it Miss Sims yes hello can you hear me yes okay so I'm so glad you spoke to the um point about priority making sure those children have priority because I know there is an extensive weight list my other question is about affordability um what are we doing to make sure it's also affordable um we

048were at College Heights for quite a few years and every year the costs went up um significantly and so I'm just curious what we're doing to make sure it's affordable to the people who need it most I can jump in um so we have we are looking at a 13 one3 one3 uh model so a third of our students at the new Early Learning Center would um be at no cost so a scholarship one3 would be at a reduced rate and then uh our last third would be at full pay Miss Ashley um I am Ashley long I'm a teacher at tally um and as well as a parent at the Fraser Center and soon to be a parented two at the frasure center I wanted to start off by saying thank you to the

049board for prioritizing the safety of our youngest children um you might hear one of them in the background sorry um my question was uh and the concern I wanted to bring was about capacity also um when we're looking at that top capacity being 150 students with a and that's assuming the max um with a third being the pseudo Frasier Center employee reduced rate a third being um scholarship and a third being full price that assumes 50 at each level um and with 67 kids not getting child care in DHA right now that would be 13 kids on the weight list and I know that current the Fraser Center has 60 children and and there's a weight list so we're cutting that down to 50 also so I'm just wondering if there's any wiggle room in

050increasing the capacity so that we can not start off with the wait list and start off making sure we're meeting the needs of um families and employees in the district yeah thank you for bringing that forward um yes we certainly are going to ensure that our staff um and our students at the Frasier Center um will have a spot and and move over um and while we're we will have a capacity you know a limit um our our priority is our DHA students and our Frasier Center students and so if that means that there are not as many full pay spots um we that's a priority for us and so while I put forward this oneir 1/3 1/3 understand that you know our priority and the board's priority is around ensuring that the students that

051need it the most um have that along with our staff um we really do believe that this is an important um benefit to our staff and then and then we moov to our our full pay thank you for raising that that point Dr Burton one one of the other things that I I want to talk a little bit about is uh the trade-off that we have to make when we're building a building is recognizing that that's a 50-year uh uh building right it's there for the long term and anybody that has tracked enrollment numbers indicator knows that we are flat or slightly down in terms of enrollment and so uh I think that there is the avenue to flex on that third third third that you just heard from Dr Burton to ensure that the

052folks you know to ensure that our our current employees as well as the students that or the potential students that needed the most out of DHA have access even if that means lessening the number of of full- paid students I also think it means that within several years uh and and not many like five we're going to start seeing enrollment numbers at a place where the capacity in that building is going to be the right capacity for everyone that needs a spot and so um just keeping that in mind as well uh we are looking at what five 10 and 15 year projections on enrollment look like within the district um Robert hi yeah I was just curious um if a third of the positions are fully funded um at $2,000 a month that's about

053$1.2 million a year that's going to have to be funded from somewhere and I know Hans mentioned that we want to have sort of the operating and ongoing expenses figured out before we start building anything um so I was wondering where is that money going to come from and is that going to come from the general funds or an outside Source we are looking at a true braided approach and by braided approach it would be things such as general fund such as philanthropy F such as the state um there are multiple funding sources that would need to be put into place uh and that is what we are thinking about and we'll come back to the board actually on a quarterly basis to provide an update on where we are uh correct me if I'm

054if I'm wrong Dr Whitaker was it the no maybe it was October but there was a a board meeting in the fall where a number of uh experts in this space and individuals who are you know the executive directors for example of foundations that fund work like this uh came and presented to us and talked about what some of the funding opportunities are and and what the you know what the approach is to ensure that we're able to receive um not tax dollars out of the general fund to fund this can can you speak a minute to that yes um I can speak to that and as well as uh Jennifer she can speak as well and we did have members of um the a couple of different foundations um the Zeiss Foundation was just

055with us at the December board meeting we also have had members of the whad foundation and we also had um the Beverly I forget the last name Foundation but um multiple foundations we are having those conversations with them this is something that is a model that would be a little bit of a prototype for the Atlanta metro area in the early learning space so the appetite for funding is great and that it is a different in the way in which we are prioritizing the need of our community to serve so um I mentioned to the board and to the community I should say that the board will be going to um in no in February will'll be going to see a facility in Grand Rapids well just found out yesterday that the United Way wants

056to accompany us on that Journey because they are looking to talk about and help us bring this to a reality for Decor so this is something that is um really has the ear of many Beyond deer from a philanthropic standpoint Fitzgerald Betty Fitzgerald I mean I mean it's beli is Fitch Dar is the last name I was like it's GNA come to me but uh yeah um Miss gin hi I am am just wondering if since this is such a large project it's such a long um planning period and fail and so much things there was any thought given to up a task force to help um answer resolve address some of the questions that have come up here and that I'm sure have been raised before there seems like a lot of things that

057um that could still be considered before we make a move on something this big and um I would love to be a part of such Task Force if that is in consideration um Miss Jackson Sophie um could I jump in really quick Miss gerin um I will definitely make note um of um of your name and um you know would love to get your contact information um so we are doing um focus groups and um are you know have many more opportunities for collaboration um and so anyone that is um would like to be more involved in this process please email the um the email address that was up before uh I believe it's early learning at CS de.net um because uh you know we we want to continue this this is an open um

058process um and you know we'll also be having more Community meetings with our Architects um so but would love to really if you're really passionate about it I want to make sure that I get your information and get that captured and uh for the board members and Community wanted to let you know that our Architects actually are on the line and could answer any questions about the conceptual design or anything like that if needed and just for context Jennifer we did have some focus groups in the past right where we looked at I mean there were some some I think you tapped some Community leaders some um you know there were some parent group so um it might be you know you could add to some existing um kind of groups along but we did

059we did kind of look to look to folks for some insight yeah absolutely we've had the path sessions um where we had um you know know two or three sessions there um where we really got to Envision and dream about what this uh design could look like we have had um focus groups we've done um surveys as well um and uh Dr Whitaker had a listening session and uh Early Learning was a focus there um but it doesn't end and so we we want to to continue um you know collaborating um and so that was the beginning and so uh but yes please please email and we'll be sure to capture your information um and include you in kind of future two-way communication opportunities Miss Jackson Hi how are you um my name is Pisha

060I work at tally and I also am a parent of a three-year-old um so my question is well background I've been here since 2010 um both my kids have gone through College Heights um but they were able to start at the age of two um due to Head Start I know Head Start start is not currently at College heghts hence why my son is there because it's not affordable um for single working parents is there a way to kind of bring that partnership back or is there other or Easter Seals I believe they go by now um is there a way to bring that partnership back into the school so that it can be more affordable and that um taxpayers aren't putting the bill for those scholarships and those partial payments thank you for your

061question I actually have a meeting with Easter Seals tomorrow um and that is you know that would be one of our um kind of scholarship and funding opportunities is our relationship and and partnership with Easter Seals and Head Start um and so that that is that is a priority that we're we're looking at um Head Start does have very specific requirements around programming um and building design as well um and so we want to make sure that we any building that we design um that we stay in line with any kind of requirements um and that would leave leave us open to that partnership with Easter Seals and Head Start and also I want to couple that with head start funding is something that um really does change based often times based upon the national

062perspective so that's just something I also want to bring to to mind so that people are aware um sometimes funding is cut at a national level that ultimately impacts us at a state in local level yeah Miss Miss Jackson thanks for the question and and all you do for our kids um that as a board we don't often we often will have ask questions and get them answered before the rest of the conversation has so that meeting where Dr rer put four or five funding sources both National and state and then um also had a conversation with our state representatives there's a lot of appetite for funding this stuff because and as a board we said listen if we're going to do this and we're going to say we're solving it let's make sure that

063we do set aside a number of seats review quarterly you know is that sufficient I mean if we build to someone else's previous question 150 person seat and we've got 70 kids who need and qualify for free stuff the board would not sit there and say oh well to 20 I think we have a superintendent in place in a school that said we would go out there to find the funding sources to make sure that that happens because the whole point of the center is you know to help make sure children are ready to learn when they enter kindergarten if we're not doing that that's that's defeats the purpose um Miss Jackson um hey me again um so I will say that I used to live in um Alan Wilson and so me and duck

064F worked a lot together on different initiatives and I was actually on um one of his committees to actually try to bring ELC eclc closer to um the community so if you guys need any help again I'm willing to join part of the task and I also will say that I coach girls JB basketball so I can kind of guide like um I'm able to wear multiple hats is what I want to say because I I would love to advocate for both sides Athletics and our little babies Miss Jackson thank you for that and um I have already written your name down so look you know look for an email from me um it doesn't look like there are any more hands up but if anyone else has any questions may I um I have

065two things I'd like to talk about one is a question regarding building the conceptual design this might be more for the Architects and how you build knowing the children grow but before we get there I think this is for um Dr Whitaker and my fellow board members I'm hearing a lot of people ask about planning in addition to planning for the Early Child Learning Center and I know that we're talking about taking students who are currently being served at the Frasier Center and moving them to the Early Child Learning Center and I was looking back at our eclc timeline so for example I think in March we're supposed to be starting the development of the design so I wonder if there's an opportunity then to build in how those future considerations of the Frasier Center

066are actually being planned because what I'm hearing is we're building the Early Child Learning Center but we're also then building an opportunity for a new space so that's just kind of throwing that out there and then for the question for The Architects I think I asked this at our city meeting you know as a teacher who taught for many years before Chromebooks and then going into a classroom where now you have heaps of Chromebooks that need to be plugged in that's like an easy adjustment I am curious how we're building this in a way that recognizes the possible need for adaptability if the younger children grow and then we're serving older younger children or you know I don't know how we even determine that we will have a consistent flow of babies for the next

06710 20 years Etc so how do you build it in a way that it may grow with the children as they age or the children's needes um so part of that I can I can answer um that that the design of the building has to be has to be able to accommodate all of the ages of the children that are going to be in that building at one time in other words it's not going to be just babies that start and then they grow in it'll be everyone from age 0 to five all of the kids from 0er to 5 basically right before kindergarten and so built into the design is the intent to have all children of those ages able to be served in the same building which I think then answers the question

068what happens when those babies grow they just grow into the slots that the children that have moved into kindergarten uh were previously occupied um I so what just want to take a second to make sure that that answered the the question you have about the the growing in um can you repeat the other portion of the of the question I got a tiny bit lost in the uh in the beginning of it well sir you talk about the Frasier Center um and building kind of that use into the timeline with the eclc or the conceptual design of the eclc well the The Frasier Center is going to be a part of the eclc so the the Fraser Center as it exists now is moving off the high school and the new building that is being

069built in the space is going to have the all the children from zero to five so what exists as the current Frasier Center all the way through that part I understand and so I'm hearing a lot of people ask about um athletic space as one and so I wondered as we're looking at a timeline that is mapping out the specific actions for the building of the eclc will we be giving a Time line that is also examining how the space that was housing The Frasier Center children that are now going to the EC is being planned and used I I certainly think that that's the intent I don't I don't want to speak for the administration on this one but I think I think those comments that were in the slide saying that uh we

070will be putting forward a plan around what the ecl or I'm I'm sorry what the Fraser Center current SPI for the Fraser Center could be used as I do believe that Dr Dr Whitaker yes yes that is the case so my first conversation will be with the booster on Friday but then also want to just make the community aware there is also a lot of conversation at in our state around our high demand career Fields um and that too is a part of our strategic plan and strategic accelerator so uh there are a lot of priorities for a school system that is locked in by land um and so the first step on this uh strategic plan is to get this part going um and also I know board member you did ask me I

071think at one time of about do you think we would have to go for a bond for the this new EC well if we are going to add in multiple activities and activities such as buildings um it is a possibility and so that's where we need to be comprehensive and it would actually align once again with an election cycle um and so those are the things that we are um working towards and and just so we're clear for the community what we are not saying we are going to do a b we are saying that we're at the very first phases of beginning to explore what the options are and uh Capital financing uh debt financing would be one of those options that would obviously be evaluated yes if if there weren't any other questions

072I wanted to maybe take just a second to talk about um the opt out provis Vision that um the house bill 581 opt out that the schools are going through I I know we have heard a fair bit of um perspectives and in some cases some Mis misinformation uh about what that provision is and I just wanted to quickly address um some of the issues associated with it so for those folks that aren't familiar uh Georgia is uh Georgia just voted to um cap the growth of the digest at uh what is being settled on as CPI Consumer Price Index um and the intent of that is obviously to prevent uh very very high uh year- on-year growth in digest value the there's a couple of challenges um particularly as it relates to using CPI

073as the growth limiter um the first and and I think probably most obvious thing is none of the major expenses associated with running a school system comport to the Consumer Price Index uh a great example um Mr hearnden mentioned it earlier in the conversation uh the state just passed along a series of um required increases in health insurance costs associated for our teachers those costs on a single year are two and a half times the rate of CPI uh and so just on that element alone if we were capped at CPI we would not be able to pay those increases and because we are also capped on millage rate when those caps hit the only thing we can do to meet those costs is to cut and when those are the size of the costs

074that are we're discussing the only thing that can be cut that is of sufficient size within the budget is actually our instructional staff and because we are adant that that's not going to be the approach that we take we are one of the reasons this is one of the reasons why we're going to be opting out one of the other things to point out is that of the hund I'm going to say 179 systems somebody keep me honest here but of the 179 systems something like 150 to 160 of them are also opting out largely because the economics that I'm describing here hold for every uh educational system so it would be uh extraordinarily irresponsible of us to allow our millage to be capped and to cap the growth of the digest it would fundamentally

075require that we begin radically altering the way we think of providing Educational Services indicator and since that's not something that any one of us can countenance we are instead moving forward with with opting out I just wanted to make that clear to the community I have heard on a couple of occasions well why why not just let it grow with the rate of inflation well it's because one it's not any inflation Consumer Price Index is very specifically unrelated to the costs that Educational Systems experience so um hopefully that's a little bit of additional information that might be help for some of the folks on the call are there any last comments or questions um well I guess that ends the Q&A portion of the [Music] meeting all right thank you so much Sophie you did

076a great job thank Dr Whitaker do you have any other uh question or any other comments uh before we close out no I just wanted to also Echo she did a great job and she's not feeling her best as well so thank you so much for uh facilitating and everyone thank you so much for joining the call I agree thank you so much thank you everyone for for joining us uh have a great evening and we'll see you at the next community meeting have a great day

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.