CorpusRecord 178958

January 14, 2025, Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / City Schools of Decatur
Date
2025-01-15
Location
DeKalb County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,575 words · about 154 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001right thank you everyone for joining us for today's Board of Education pre-work session our board meeting Cadence allows board members to prepare for upcoming regular meetings through these pre-work sessions these sessions are more casual primarily for information gathering no votes will be taken I will begin our pre-work session with our gsba board self assessment so ually the board completes the gsba self assessment this year we have individually completed an assembly and calibrate uh to determine the ratings are the standard level also both Sophie and Mia have completed and uh encourage them to chime in as they arrive that sort of stuff um as well so we'll move on the facilitate the rankings you have them in your red folder in front of you give you an idea of the standard on the left where it

002was ranked in terms of totals on the satisfactory needs Improvement won't know and have highlighted the two areas that uh a majority of the board thought we needed Improvement upon so we can make sure that we talk about those um but then just wanted to open it up to the board for any comment about any any of them broadly or we can go sort of item by item okay so let's kind of quickly run through these and I'll open up for conversation so domain 1 a uh which is domain one refers to governance structure do we exist and do we follow it so a standard is the government leadership governance leadership teams comprise local Board of Education to appropriate roles and responsibilities as defined by the law all six of us thought we were meeting

003that standard I I consider this one the the minimum you can do as a board as it is following the legal laws that that that are outlined there two we had one needs Improvement under B and B if you will is a standard of uh executing our duties as defined in the state constitution laws consistent with local board policy accredit as a accreditation standards procedures ethical standards which control our conduct um um and so somebody thought we needed Improvement there um you can see the comments I think a COI policy should be written into the board Norms someone else comment I'd like to understand norms and policies for the 2025 election do what [Music] [Laughter] quick point of clarification we actually do have a conflict of interest policy written to our policy I mean so

004we are bound by a conflict of interest policy correct we're Bound by one you're bound by one at the state level when you run for office and then you're bound by one when you sign into a board and that sort of stuff and I I would disagree that we need to add it to the board Norms I just feel like we already we have it well documented and the boards are already I think complicated okay so hearing no I mean po norms and policies for the 25 election anyone want to discuss that further I'm not but maybe I'm wrong I thought there was okay so and I think Dr whiter at the last meeting were we looking at a policy regarding I think it was regarding political actions and then I thought maybe I'm just

005too tired to remember clearly that we moved into the fact that an election would be coming up next fall uh that was talking about staff political activities not the election of this board the election of this board is something that is really outside of the board's perview it's more the policy of elections in Georgia I think I conflated the two are looking at policies and so sorry my mistake no it's good you're thorough I appreciate it um you can see that yeah absolutely okay so we're we're fine with satisfactory there um number 1 C is the area where where like I said a majority thought we needed Improvement and one is the board acts the policymaking body separate from the roles and responsibilities authorized to the superintendent probably the the most common refrain and then

006that we'll see as we move down into the comments um I'll read a couple of those I think we have struggled this year with getting involved in operations namely too much in investigations and then as we manage as changes in funding laws and amounts we might need to consider how operations budget matters intersect and consider the one high school one Middle School feature of our small District calls another intersection of governance and operations um I did not write either of those comments I think both of them are well stated that um we do we I mean it's it's hard as a board member to not want to be involved in all parts of running the school particularly things that we do we can as a board constantly be reminded to to improve upon that and

007then number two and consider well maybe I'm a little lost there if that comment is just meant to say like um you know the middle school and the high school and how we have some sort of unique interactions there but I think what I was talking about and I feel like Dr whiton talked about this once or rather I brought it up so Dr W you a larger School District with multiple high schools a larger School District with multiple middle schools you'll have like a policy and then it's implemented perhaps differently in different high schools middle schools depending on the needs so that's what I was talking about our small scill school district is I think at times unique because when we make a policy it's one high school that's implementing it the schools polic

008because we're talking about board we're talking about board policies right so these policies would apply to all schools yes yes yeah yes and I think with to Tracy's point it often becomes awkward when we're writing a policy about the middle schools we're really just talking about one set of kids one people and just being cognizant of that I don't know but we don't have any policy specific to uh schools no but in and I apologize I do want to but there have been times where the board has I I think of I can think of two instances last year where the principal made a decision and then like it it sort of from a community perspective it was the board making the decision because um it it's like oh yeah that obviously the board is

009responsible and the superintendent is responsible for that because there's only one Middle School there's only one high school I don't think that that's really relevant to the policymaking aspect of it I I don't think it's relev to the Misunderstood this one too dress code right the dress code policy that we talked about really clearly impacts that a middle school or a high school right but it does apply to all of the system right to J's point so I yeah I think yeah what what our conversation was is that there are things that are local school governance and then there are things that are board policy District governance and there is a definitely a separation of the two and because we are just one high school um that does not mean we then become local school

010governance we just still remain as total District government I'm happy with satisfactory this I think that these are that that getting involved in oversight of the superintendent is a is a constant issue um but I did list it as S as fact I think I may have listed as need Improvement because honestly I was looking for areas where in this we we might you know I was had my teacher hat on to train you you know you're looking for the area of an improvement this is probably the only one that I thought we could all be better at and I think I'll just clarify one thing I think this came up in the context of curriculum right so you know a larger district is adopting a curriculum like Georgia be is changing some of the

011pathways right now and so ultimately that's where this stem from so that if you had a curriculum change and you had multiple high schools that might be implemented or look different that's where I got the question so sorry if my feedback seems to be conflating two different things you're all good okay moving on to 1D then hearing nothing further so what is this satisfactory I think we had we had a a tie for majority and then a couple people talking about I think to my right pointing out that while those are valid complaints are not really relevant to the question of policy creation 1D governance leadership team demonstrates a unified approach to govern the school system in order to ensure effective fulfillment of roles and responsibilities um we had one needs Improvement but a majority

012were they was satisfactory a couple of comments about wanting uh specialized training to continue and then of course questions about student involvement and what they are included in and not questioned about the specialized training I just I haven't received any specialized training and so I was curious is that are we actually offering that it was news to me that we were offering that it sounded to me from the the elements that we ought to be offering that example would be um the Excellence training that is being offered is for for board members specifically another one could be um and so that's an example of specialized training ume a present that we offer is a specialized training no you no for the gsba um GP offering so it's like how do we want to kind of

013do something separate or different it's something we can do all of the Retreats kind of speak to that too when we have uh topics that are tied to what we've done in the past so this I understand I I understand that we as a board might receive additional or differential training than other boards but I read number two as individuals on this board might receive differential or specialized training if I if I misread that but but but you know like like like a great example would be you know somebody that's coming on the board that doesn't have any Finance or budget experience would I would assume interested in some training on how a budget Works versus GSB a offers specific training on that type of information so they they offer it now whether or not

014you as an individual board member participate goes on the school board you to take some of those things I don't think we do that very well right I guess is my my point because I think that there's probably an opportunity I personally would be very interested in understanding a lot more about Teaching Standards as an area that I am ignorant of or has become slowly and familiar with on the seat but there's obviously some training that can go there and I would does that make sense okay so Point well taken and a note for but it's satisfactory was seven of the votes there um domain two sove away from policy into strategic planning um we had one for each of these in the needs Improvement so I'll list them the governance leadership team provides input

015to and adopts the systems strategic plan uh we had a couple of comments here yes may I say one thing yeah um I think I wrote too much so I don't expect much you feel if you have to um so just putting that out there gotcha um I I had um done needs Improvement and maybe I should have ready don't know but we don't uh and do we have we annually reviewed the and reopt the Strategic plan it was adopted in March of 2023 and then we set the kpi for it in at the retreat was it May's retreat the May of annually so annually yeah it was May of 2024 is when we uh went through it again and changed some of the initiatives in addition to setting the key performance indicators and on

016every month we are speaking to some of those yeah and then and then we do another version of it again at The Retreat on an annual basis at the end of the year okay because I um I know that you know we are always it's always at the Forefront um but I didn't know if there was a a process where you sat down and went through the whole strategic plan to review it and then reopt it and so the way that it was worded that was what was um yeah it was it was in May I think the May Retreat when we went through it again in totality and then set the key kpis we uploaded them in the in assembly and then we do it again next month so we do it annually at

017our Retreat to to Dr Johnson Davis's point I do think just let's be explicit on the day that we do that that this is the the adoption of the plan because I miss that I didn't I mean I get that that's what we're doing doing but like maybe we the public would benefit from knowing that we adding it to the B right so a point of improvement but overall satisfactory please might takeway uh b um and oh man I'm GNA want to hear from my my student contributors here as well so B is annually and as needed utilizing the adopted strategic planning process the government's leadership team monitors and reports progress on performance measures got a couple of comments there what what do we want to hear specifically from our student memb well we we

018had some one of them said and I'm not I'm not going to call them out they're welcome to come in but uh some needs Improvement there from uh from them and [Music] uh and maybe not that's okay I I I I comment I thought this was the best written standard by gsba it's like clearly Define what you need to do and you Monitor and report it and anticipate PD and self assesses we're doing that literally it's like are we doing the thing that we're voting on giving ourselves a satisfactory for doing yes we are doing it so clearly definable steps okay let's move on to domain three that is board and community relations so for leadership team develops a process for creating a culture where input is salt herd and value including uh Community culture

019um seeking that out collaborative review have a couple of comments here I can synthesize onee I love the community meetings I think I've said this before I do think we can do more to go from meeting if that's step a to use of what we get from the meeting that's Ste be sorry if I was um long winded in what I said here but that's you know I think the community meetings are great and I'm glad we're having them but thank you for organizing point point while taken we don't often see the part at the end of every public comment where like and someone from the admin team will reach out and take care of this I really saying and this is what we did and how we reached out but it would probably the

020culture of community feedback would probably improve if people saw other people getting answers to their questions well and I think a moveel and then we talk about this a bit so you know a lot of times and correct me if I'm presenting anything kind of incorrectly uh someone from the community may have a question that is inevitably an operations question yeah and so as we've talked about if they contact the board and the superintendent it's really not the board's job um nor would it be appropriate to respond but at the community meeting it is the governance team so what is the expectation of our feedback but you know I understand like at the last community meeting there may have been a question that seemed like operations right and I think James you answered that it

021was like you gave an anecdote I believe about the lights over the field but then I guess I want to know more about what is my role here I'm here to listen right I'm here because I want to hear you and then is there anything else we do in the community meetings yeah or with what's shared the community meetings but the last one was particularly I liked because we had you we have an agenda which is nice to respect people's time or Preparation but then we had a Q&A session at the end and so I liked that kind of interaction where people um were asking questions some of which you know were more kind of organically driven by another question someone asked it is is that how I mean I in when I think about

022our community meetings that's how all of them have gone it's ended with a Q&A and we take direct questions from the community and have a conversation right I think this one Hans I don't know if you were there there was specifically Dr whiter kit come you outow for one session that was yeah it was just fre for the next next uh community meeting on the 22nd we'll talk about the Georgia Vision project we'll talk give an update on early learning and then we'll talk about budget development and then there's a session for Q&A and so the reason why we put Q&A at the end in separate was so that we can hopefully get to all the information and so it was a reor reorganization of the time what I can say is that we've iterated

023on the best ways you know every time you start something new you have to iterate and make it better and I think that's what that's why that Q&A was at the end and we'll do that again this upcoming one and and then typically Dr Whitaker you and your team will take to will address some of the questions because typically not because it's typically the question about operations so we're Limited in how much we can do as a board and that's why the staff member um subject matter expert if you will is there um with you as you're presenting because you're presenting from a government governance perspective and how from a governance perspective on that topic but if it's going way down in the weed or below the line whatever the case may be that person's

024there to help you're right right I think to trac's point I think the where the community gets frustrated is when they don't hear anything um and I can see where that is um where that's from a Comm just a basic communication standpoint that's frustrating um if you ask question or send an email or send a text and then nobody replies at all even if you know you're reaching out to the wrong person if the person doesn't take the time to redirect you that um that that can feel maligning um so maybe that's why people like those Community meetings even if we say we don't know or we say you know this is the right person at least we saying something so um I think maybe that's where we could figure out a a way outside

025of this particular I think this has been a good example of how to engage the community in a way where there's a back and forth dialogue even if we don't have the answer um because I think that that does about 51% of the battle is just where they feel engaged um and heard and then it's not us it's really you know Adina they need to talk to we can redirect them to that person but at least there's some interaction and I think that's what we get criticized a lot is that there's just they send an email or they call or test something say nothing that maybe that's a point of improvement which I think that one is probably find satisfactory but as we move into B the Board needs to develop ensure effective communication engagement

026of stakeholders which supports the treaty pay culture Improvement this is the one where a majority had needs Improvement you can read the comments there um as a place we do need Improvement I will I will share that um yeah that is a that is a point of frustration for me um just we get lots of emails we get things it's hard to know uh who to respond to how to resp when should it be passed off um and that's tough it is uh is also been sometimes overwhelming to know who you need to respond to in terms of emails and then you know you get 74 plus was the one time I counted of the exact same email like do we have obligation to respond to them I do think this is the place for

027the board could use a more clearly defined plan that we follow with emails with Community feedback um looks like a majority of the the board kind of agreed with me there so I'll open that up for what am I missing yeah I wasn't clear on if we had a if the board has a communication plan I think and I this is where I also get confused is within that communication plan what do we do when it's clearly an email letter writing campaign like when you get like 75 of the same email it's impossible to respond to those in a timely fashion and it's impossible to know how to respond because it's the same email over versus you know I think we've gotten one or two in the past 24 hours that we're clearly somebody reaching

028out on their own behalf not a letter writing campaign I get I get very confused about how to respond to those when it's a hundred that come at once um you know are these people that are actually looking for a response are they just looking to you know get our you know to put an issue out there neither are bad but it does become confusing there I you know seemed like I I thought our board Norm was that there was autogenerated response to something that comes and then we know that typically there you know so recently I've gotten um emails that I have said you know I'm going to um I'm looping in the board for our for our board Norm so that they're all aware of this issue and uh Dr Whitaker so that

029she can she and one of her staff can address it so that's been our board Norm but I wasn't sure what a board communication plan was supposed to look like cuz this was so limited in what we can say because it's almost always about operations and and when when you do that uh when you do um Dr Johnson Davis you Loop me in and then typically I Loop in the you know the staff member that helps to support that specific area um but you know to Dr sulton's point of when it is a letter writing campaign um things of that nature how does this board want to respond I mean I think if there's a letter writing campaign where one individual is written a form letter that a thousand then individuals forward on to us

030so think it's perfectly reasonable for us to have a form response right and so I would I would look at it's hard to can that response in advance because sometimes it requires responding to the specifics of whatever that email is saying but that's where I would look to the Communications Department to help us right this comes in 75 people have written in you agree with this response send it to us as a board not our heads and then that becomes the official board from our board that respon will come from the the board chair correct yes so that we're not all responding correct the you know was feedb okay okay so we it sounds like we're addressing one issue when it's a um discernible letter writing campaign it's a form but and I hear is

031saying and rightfully so that often these communications can be in the operations Lane but I still don't okay so then what we've addressed the letter writing campaign part right what's the so then we would typically so when I was a chair I would um you know respond on behalf of the board and forward it to I mean because we're all getting even if we're typically off typic we're all copied in both even if it's not a um a form letter typically we've all been copied in the same email and then I guess my second question is now that we have resolved CSC are we using like are those intersecting in any way or because I know that you know people still like the email um but are we using then those emails if CSD is

032tracking right um the areas of communication um the number of people that are contacting the school district for these various areas so do these emails ever go into CSD um resolve CSD or are they two separate no you're contacting the board that's a separate entity than contacting the school system and so that's that's the kind of different and so if you're contacting the school system it's going through resolve CS and all of what you saw in that presentation then happened and you know we will provide an update when we do the date of I think it may later on in the school year I don't know month off hand um on where we are with resolve CSD and how many the frequency and areas all of that's part of that update so one thing I

033am wondering now then I I think we've talked about this before like when someone emails the board it is also going to you right and then there are times when someone may email an individual okay so then in that regard is there a form email that also says hey you know thanks for emailing and please use resolve csb as well or anything that we want to so that that would be an update because when we created form email was all CSD didn't exist not currently no not currently but is that that could be you like just add to the yeah I yes I you know when when it's things most things around I'll be Hest is curriculum questions all of those that come in we we we pretty much handle in letter writing campaigns which

034is kind of I think what we were talking about before um we can follow up with this is the response have that approved and move from there and we can update the autogenerated to say resolve CSD I I'm hearing lots of good ideas and definitely an area for the board to focus on in terms of needs Improvement for 3B um and the point about 3C that someone makes it I I feel like we're definitely in the need of improvement in writing it which is board Norm to we're probably fine in terms of following it because we just don't have a whole lot written down that we need to follow so 3B is do you have a a communication plan and then and I read 3C is a you know implementing the plan and so at

035least me I put that one is satisfactory because we're following the rules we just probably need to update our rules that a fair assessment there because even the ones the comments here I think are all good but they are all of them commenting on the need for a policy as opposed to following policy anything else on domain three okay let's move to domain four policy development um everyone put this as an area of improvement I wrote the comment that this is probably in my opinion the biggest area what four a 4 a is a satis satisfactory what did I say oh I apologize that was just a brain skip I apologize there we all said that that was an area we are working on policy it is part of our map um someone commented that

036we would like to as the map calls for it continue to move policy towards areas of curriculum um but I've been very pleased with the the Cadence and the way we've been addressing it five uh domain V board meeting was also all satisfactory 5A or just board meetings in general um there's a comment here about the new student board member being included in agenda prep I think that is a good point making sure that the student rep and the even the student official title Apprentice that's a cool title um The Apprentice has a role in in that sort of board meeting aend in the prep I I they do so I meet with uh The Apprentice and the board um student board rep on a monthly basis a a question this is maybe for us

037for consideration later but I I I do think the principal way that the the student rep and The Apprentice interact with the board is on the de and if there are opportunities for us to interact more way that the rest of the board kind of organically operates and interacts together I I would encourage or or be um supportive of that what would that look like well I mean we have uh Beyond just exec session we have other meetings that we have you know conversations or emails that get circulated I just I I think that I I understand why there's some levels of structure that are necessary and I'm not trying to blow that up but um uh I think more interaction between the board and the student reps would be I would find that I

038agree I was the one who wrote about the student rep in the comment so thank you what can I ask what the student rep I'll be honest with when I met with the student reps and we were done prep they said I have to go because I have to work on my scholarship essays and I need to do xline Z so um that's yeah I don't want to make yeah I would say the main I think with the emails sometimes I I feel like I'm out of the loop a little bit so then it's kind of like at the board meeting kind catch up but um because the only meetings that they don't typically attend are the um exective session they've been at all Retreats all trainings all board meetings right it's your individual conversations

039with one another that they're not a part and I am not going to weigh in on whether or not they should be a part of those because I'm not necessarily in a mean to them and to that point I think it is it certainly would be weird to make it a a board Norm about something that's organic and your point and Tracy to try to make an effort to include figure out how to student boards in coffee and ketchups and seeing where their brain is when they're not sitting on a des in front of the community would be well served well and I it's probably too much operational detail to get into right now but but to think in terms of how we can be they can be more included on email chains per um

040rep dillan's point I think would be helpful I recognize again that with that there has to be some boundaries but um I would be interested in seeing how to allow a little bit more access is there any policy that's written on where the line is drawn what member can know and particip in is that like a solidified thing yes yes so anything that would be gered to something of executive session so that would be land legal or personnel and so um if it's uh in any of those areas student board members would not be able to be a everything else though yes so that's where state of the city if you would like to come we said attend uh the yes I can Awards I mean a a lot of I what I send to

041you is really what I send to all the board as far as opportunities to engage in the public training um all all of those sorts of things correct me if I'm if I'm wrong but right now when emails come to us from the public we default to the student reps not being a part of that and have to choose to make them a part of that exact can we invert that and default why not no because you can never control what a public entity would email yes but we can control whether they get continued to be included on that email chain yeah I would that would put the district at risk could we though yeah I understand that um you know I'm thinking along the lines of the things that I learn from all of

042you in our conversation but also at times in our emails and so I understand why the district needs to be protected from those kind of emails but then do we have built into our process and maybe we don't want to fite this but you we have a pretty I think extensive way in which we prepare for meetings right and I think I heard you say that I feel sometimes out of the loop there but wouldn't it be easy for us as a group to decide how to synthesize some of that or throw some of those questions out y okay yeah you can talk with um you know your fellow board member the the students actually come to the office about once a week sometimes twice a week and so they're they're present in in learning

043but they're they're still learning they're not necessarily governing and we add a step when the email comes in where we look at it and say this is fine for student C consumption and then include them on that even because I think what I'm what I'm hearing is there are still a number of conversations that continue to happen that they ought to or could be a part of but that they aren't and then that is an impact in their preparation for the public conversation and I I I that's a legitimate term so I think the legal council has I just want to exercise caution about this even in that step you're going to have to have someone who has an eye for okay this is you know confidential oh this includes the student name it's got

044to be redacted first you know those kind of things so well I I would argue if anything has to be redacted then by Nature that it doesn't get shared right it's more that the the when I think of the bulk of emails that we get the bulk are not problematic I get that we have to protect against the few that are but the bulk aren't and so it it would strike me that that there ought to be a way to be inclusive to allow the student reps to perform their task as effectively as possible where we aren't adding risk for the system I mean I recognize all the concerns that we're having here but I feel like that can be accommodated I think though is a pra is maybe more practical than legal you have

045to have someone who can say this can't be shared and here's why yep because other things can slip through the cracks and so the district so I just want to okay so can we have that validation check my first thought is that that might require a lot more um work and then I'm hearing the eyes I I'm still landing on something that is addressing what I think you and I are talking about H but maybe starts with some communication that we're sending to the student members if it's the board members saying we want to know if you have any commentary on this right because obviously we're not emailing about Personnel matters and we're not so I'm thinking it's something along those lines to start with but I don't know how anyone else feel um um

046I was my initial thought was maybe Dr Whitaker when in her oneon-one with the apprentice and the student um member could kind of give a summary of the you know the email in her in her oneone um think like that would be the safest thing because I'm I'm even hesitant I think it should be one person on the board and not I don't know it could be the board chair um but it feels like maybe the superintendent because she's in constant communication with legal person deliver that information in the 101 yeah I agree I think it's I think it is most of the emails I feel like are the latest operations that could Beed as anoculus I can think of one that I got just about two or three days ago that was seemingly innocuous

047but did have a student name in it and we could have easily just missed that if we hadn't been paying attention um so maybe it is maybe that is a good creative solution is um when you guys meet together um you go over whatever are the um the uh kind of flow of emails and and some are going to come up in the meeting and then some are just not you know some are just going to be handled kind of externally and they may not be worth your mental energy or time um you know because they're just going to be handled by the cabinet members yeah um I think I also want to just bring up as well um that I would imagine that the student board members can add agenda items so if there

048you know if there was something that you guys went over that was not on the agenda or you know something that you would like to add then know you solicit another board member um to support you it comes to the chair and then we can add it and so we should that also as a vehicle to Eng for members and to um to make sure that your voices are heard as well um but I think the email portion may be best handled through the superintendent or throughand well said think we're satisfacted here but there's definitely student role is a whole ball we've opened up we need to be attentive making sure we're doing it right um moving on to six A and B are you know hiring evaluating the superintendent where we're doing it um

049there's obviously a majority think they're satisfactory I want to give a second see if anyone wants to add things we need to work on I think the I did not write it but uh if continuing to emphasize that it's confidential and working on the instrument process is definitely something as a board we need to work on any comments about that uh and then C was the board adopts Personnel policy implemented by the superintendent um there's one comment and obviously one needs Improvement there I I didn't actually make this comment but I agree with it so with matters of we need yeah I didn't either but I agree with it mid adjustment oh oh oh y'all are on B oh were we not on B I made the adustment I do not see a midyear adjustments

050comment where am I where am I lost moved on to page no no no I went to seven I'm sorry sorry okay got it go to no we're still talking about Personnel matters we're good those are those that that whole category can be satisfactory I think the general takeway from the board is communicating the superintendent valuation tool and Contin training people on it all right Hans now You' got your wish we're on the seven Financial gut look at you want to talk about Finance surprise surprise um sorry you're good uh so a we had one needs Improvement and B we had all status Factory a is the board upon recommendation the superintendent adopts a budget that ads to strategic plan and then B is adop sound fiscal management and and implementation of the budget in

051accordance with state laws and regulations so both of these are just we adopt a a a budget that is legal and ethical and and we make sure that it we're following all regulations what comment did you it was um under uh B okay where the comment was want to see if few amid your adjustments went appropriate okay oh yeah I both of the comments there I think I think are are well while receive fewer adjustments and then also just continuing to work on community and stakeholder impact on on school budgets it is uh a very complicated area but as far as passing legal budgets we are satisfactorily doing that uh and then the last one is eight there's one standard for a this is the government scene aderes to adopts and practices a code of

052ethics avoids conflicts of interest and annual reviews ethical standards to ensure government structure and organizational Effectiveness we were all in agreement that we have been legal for kudos to you all any closing comments yeah thank you all for working with the structure I want to do a special shout out to Miss Amanda Lynch for facilitating uh fair is that fair Dr wher to give a little shout out yes including reminders to several board members to get it done um and and have this conversation publicly and acknowledge there are definitely some areas we need to improve even in areas where we're satisfactory there's some places we can get better I want to thank the government's team as well for helping it do it and and a lot of those will inform the Retreats for the remainder

053of the year um next month though I want to remind everyone we will be back to the book we're skipping this one to chapter five which will be facilitated by me governing coherence and Synergy uh Dr wh I'll move it over to you for the next agenda item yes and I would like to call on Mrs Amanda Lynch Chief of Staff to facilitate a policy draft protocol with the board I'm also taking notes so I'm gonna sit okay as just for my purposes know everyone here will attest to that you're right good afternoon today your computer I'm going to I'm going to I'm going to negotiate get started okay okay so up in front of you you have a blue folder um which contains some of the resources that we're going to be using today

054today we heard the board's request last month and estimat you'll go on to the next slide um there was a request for time to have a discussion around policy gahb which is Staff political activities um which came up just a little bit ago as well and so initially a draft was presented last month and there was disc we recognize that we need some additional time um for you as a board to kind of mle and have some discussion around what is it that we truly believe um and so we're I'm going to take you through a little protocol today um where we're going to take some time in just a moment I'm going to ask Carrie to kind of give us a little bit of a legal landscape some legal guard rails that we need

055to consider particularly in response to um this particular um policy and then I'm going to give you a couple of minutes to silently reflect you do have a graphic organizer there um to help you capture your individual thoughts on four different questions basically a chance to think about what is it that we're aspiring to with this policy what is that we believe that we want to really capture um where you agree with the policy is drafted something that you're unsure about that we might want to talk through and discuss and something that you want to argue with or things that you might want to argue with and what applicable and then we'll talk about it so I'll take you through that discussion and then we'll stamp agreement the next steps and based on how it

056goes um so I will ask Carrie to come forward and just provide you all with some um basic legal guard rails to consider for this so on this policy the guard rails are very wide because um unlike federal law unlike federal law state of Georgia does not have a statute that specifically sets out each of these prohibitions federal law does the Hatch Act um which we can look to and take from but it does not apply to you all as a local board um but Georgia does have code of ethics for government employees in general which requires you to work a full day give a full day's work or staff members to give a full day's work for a full day's pay there is your obvious code of ethics that you have adopted um and

057there is the um code of ethics for educators cerated Educators it also applies to our staff members who are not certificated through our employee handbook so in between there is what you all get to decide um but I want to be specific about what the policy is intended to deal with which is political activities of Staff or board members and how do we want to Define that I think the policy is pretty specific that it is dealing with advocating for a candidate promoting a candidate running as a candidate yourself or a staff member running as a candidate um but I looked at the hash act to get a definition what does political activities mean under that act and it would activity directed toward the success or failure of a political party candidate for a partisan

058political office or a partisan political group so I wanted to just put that out in front of you to keep in mind as you're discussing this policy because what is political can become very um vague and turn it back over great thank you so much Carrie all right go ahead yeah attorney where could you just it it was a party a a person what was the third political it was um activity directed toward the success or failure of a political party a candidate for partisan political office or a partisan political group now that again is not Georgia law right but I'm using that that's from federal law but that is to help you kind of get an understanding of what is intended by political activity or any other question thank you I do I do

059have a question how do we part of what has inspired this I think is political advocacy or I'm not going to even use the word political I am going to use advocacy for particular points of [Music] view that I mean prior to that definition that you just gave us I would have said are political but that aren't necessarily under that particular budet if I am advocating for example in the classroom for the Israeli state or if I am advocating for the Palestinian state in my mind that is political advocacy it does not it does not at least to me sound like it meets the definition of what you're describing as political activity dealing with basically using work time or work resources to advocate for a candidate or a particular group so um some examples would

060be you know if at a pep rally that a staff member is handing out pamplets related to a political candidate or they are wearing a shirt that says a political that's advocating for a political candidate or group it does not least as written currently I would have to be broadening this too much but it is not getting into social issues having to divide between what is political and what is the social issue so by this policy we would not have an issue with a teacher handing out anti-abortion literature at AEP rally for students so that is a different policy that's is that something that is against a different policy of the board this deals with political activity so the abortion is yes it is there are different perspectives held by different politicians but you're not

061advocating for a specific politician so the my understanding with the point of us examining and introducing and looking at a policy like this was to try to prevent some of that advocacy from happening so if that's the case then I think that the language is going to have to be broadened for example District facilities or resources may not be used to promote an employee who is a political candidate time during normal working hours may not be used for campaigning over the promotion of political candidates the use of District resources or the use of individuals in their capacities as employees um it's number seven that's most concerning number seven is a little broader than most of these shall not display any political billboards pictures signs posters badges buttons or any other political advertisements at any school

062facility or on their person during normal business hours or while performing job duties because it does not define political in this policy correct correct it does not so it's up to you how broad or narrow you want this to be I think that's the starting point that we need to decide we want this to be a policy that just looks as political activity as she just described it so political parties candidates what happened if an employee is running for an office themselves themselves and does not hint at the social activities that may be driving said political activities but very black and white you know if you are if if you if it a political candidate that you support you cannot come to school with that particular t-shirt on doesn't matter what what that person stands

063for but then what I'm hearing is that if we wanted to brush more broadly to include some some of the social drivers that drive some of these political act we know that they're out there then we need to define the language when I read this it seems more like the first interpretation what happens if you are running for office how do you handle political paraphernalia pamphlet that sort of thing what you cannot use the company copier to copy you cannot use your planning period for political activities um or campaigning it seems more of that but if we want it to be something else we need to have that discussion probably first which is like 2A what do we want it to look like first questions for me before the and just so you know the

064original Inception of this was really back in I want to it like last school year and there were a lot of questions around what people can and cannot wear um regarding truly it was around the election that we just experienced that's where this this came up originally um it was that and and our our ele four right right number yes 2024 um with a question that that actually board member Anderson had when she was in the process of campaigning that that is that is where this original conversation came from now we've experienced a lot of life you know because that was November 23 actually I think it was like September October 23 cuz it was really interesting for me to research it started from the conversations were when defined in the more traditional sense of

065you know politics and political also as part of the policy audit three of the surrounding counties which is kind of our tier two also this year um had this in place as well so it was on our radar as a potential um policy to work on development for just based on the benchmarking and so then when it's like oh yes and is relevant so that's how it kind of came to fruition up here so you know my I I I understand why um to me some of the campaigning stuff that um Dr sulon outlined makes sense I think you know what I put in I went ahead like you know what do we aspire to with this policy I said to protect the school district and students and so where I'm struggling is I understand

066most of this but I I think and correct me if I'm wrong that we have a great community and you I'm thinking of a bumper sticker on a car now um you I think there's so many of the finer details that we'd have to consider I think that it is allowed on a personal vehicle but in the park you know a backpack that has you know pins or stickers or whatever this isn't inhabiting students this is just oh no no no I understand that I think those teachers we said season hell so I think that's a good place and I think Dr Sulton probably said it correct it sounds like one place of clarity that will help us in um understanding the will of the board to draft the policy would be how do we

067want to Define that political piece do we want it to include more social drivers or closer to the definition that Carrie provided from the Hatcher act hatch keeping in mind I'm sorry just keeping in mind that as you stray into social issues you now start stepping into First Amendment here you go so I just want to put that caution out there now in the meantime though and maybe you answer to this you know with the employee code of conduct you know my job as a teacher is not to walk in and teach you my political position so if you're writing argument as is it may allow for the facilitation of different views so that's where I'm I guess I'm sorry I'm getting kind of confused myself now because it makes perfect sense to me I'm

068here to teach you English in this case not politics about politics we may choose to use the inauguration or a campaign dry already isn't it every American government teacher that is in America faces that I mean as a high school as especially in middle and high school you face that just in the curriculum itself this is more so around um you know your advertising advertising it's not it's not the thought in the classroom because the I mean the standards and the learning targets call for that level of thought and Analysis I I just so I agree at a minimum we are political advocacy as it's defined in the doc I I again not suggesting anybody's willing to do this but I would have a great problem if a teacher was directly advocating for particular social

069issues in the classroom as well I I don't think that belongs in the classroom either I I 100% agree from in an instructional standpoint yes we make all the accommodations we possibly can if I have a teacher in the classroom for example telling my children that abortion is bad example that is not appropriate does not belong in the classroom and so how do we accommodate that well that I mean there I mean that's like outside the standards like right so I mean this all of this is outside of the standard well I'm talking in terms of instruction this is about like what you're wearing what you display how you're using your time how using your time things like that resources exactly Ian agree and you're you're you're you're referencing using your classroom as a bul

070pull pit to push appropriate for reasons trying to be outlined by this policy in this not in this policy substitute political like candidate and take on political issue and it holds I think if I'm using classroom resources if I am showing up in the classroom with you know uh whatever I'm trying to think what the buttons with it coife I guess whatever it may be but if you're if you are taking a political issue and and doing all of the things as we've allowed outlined here for a political candidate how is it any different like why would we want to allow that's what think K is saying that we need to be careful about substituting political issues here yeah I think my thought is for the purpose of this policy I would leave social issues

071out of it I think that what's going to end up happening is um we're going to quickly get into somebody's First Amendment right um and it's going to be too easy to or it's going to be too M Mucky or gray between what is political and what's social it's going to be an argu an arguable Point um and everybody has a First Amendment right not just the First Amendment right of your opinion um and everybody likes the First Amendment until they say something that somebody does agree with so I think it's I think if we keep it with political activity as she has defined it I think it's going to be much more clean otherwise if we try to get into the social Dynamic of it I think it's going to going to be very

072difficult to enforce um and it's going to I think it's going to be it might be it's going to be Lev difficult I have two questions I'm not trying to be pedantic but board members aren't partisan so we're using the Hatch Act solely as a kind of starting point right yeah yes does not apply to okay often in the law when there is not a specific definition you look to other similar laws so that was so then like is The Tick Tock ban a political activity by what we're talking we just talking about candidates okay so we are ling it because I think I'm sorry I was trying to make sure that we were kind of raining it in because I thought originally when we heard that the description it was um success or failure

073for a partisan party a group or an activity I I think this law is vote for Bob should not be on a t-shirt yeah okay vote for Carmen should not be your screen saver if you're a math teacher whatsoever where it gets iy is I you make me take down my vote for Bob poster and I put up an NRA poster but then now we've got first amendment issues now we've got all classrooms you know all that sort of stuff but in terms of a policy vote for Bob has no place in the classroom when it comes to resources Etc and if that's what we mean I think to my original point we just need to Define that clearly in terms of election and if we want to get involved in things Hans was like

074do or do not talk about abortion gun right you know we could list off at infinum hotly cont I mean out of the game let's not let's not pretend this is anything other than what it is this is a policy that curtails First Amendment rights we are telling people that they cannot advocate for a person or for a group or for a whatever but that's but that's why the hatchet we telling them you may not use government resources or government time to do that when you go home so then I fail to understand the difference when we say something like let's take abortion as an issue we would be saying you can't cannot use government resources and you cannot use government time you could do whatever you want to do at home agreed but that

075activity within the classroom is we're we're we're curtailing that precisely or I am suggesting that we curtail that precisely the same as we do for a candidate and I I'm not understanding the differences between those two things how is a person running for office different than advocacy for a particular political position because by saying you may not advocate for any political person that is very clearly defined Bob is defined you may not advocate for a candidate you may not advocate for a partisan political group social issues get very mky and what becomes a social issue versus a you know is this a moral issue is this a religious issue and you start getting into First Amendment ter suggestion would be if that is where you all want to go you address it through a different

076policy through the lens of these are the standards this is the instruction anything that goes beyond the instruction or that type or advocating in the classroom for one position over but that's a different policy not advocating for a political party or using government resources can we can we start with this policy yes so what I've heard so far is that um we do we want to make sure that we kind of Define a little bit maybe using that definition from the Hatch Act um to understand political activities to keep it focused on political office so is there any part in here that as it currently exists we are either unsure about or want to argue against Jana and I have a problem with seven she's already said it out loud ni it well if is

077if we if we Define political in here then I'm I'm fine with seven but as written it literally just says like you can't have any political advertising so that's why you got to Define right because otherwise it's like oh my gosh you wore a baseball cap with yes a Chick-fil-A baseball cap and that's very political to some people in our community and makes a statement I don't want to write a policy that excludes that and if I do I don't want it to be this policy and to the followup point I think that Dr wer brought up in many uh government classes it's common place for them to have political buttons posters as a part of their curriculum so we may want to make sure that it's at least pointed out as detail that instructional

078and I believe we have that as an exception So within the instructional number exceptions number one political activities within the instructional program are not for into this policy the last thing we would want to do also is like limit our Board election we have student representative and Apprentice right so that is a that is something that happening in the in the school building at the high school level as well so love that but I again to the extent that this relates to teachers and staff and not students correct because I I don't actually think I would want teachers advocating for a particular student rep either right like I all let yel chime in because a question came up about that last year about where they could post their posters and things like that and could

079they ask a teacher to post it and so there was some rich conversations that happened that we're continuing to work with so I mean I know that when I was running um I was able to put my poster up in teachers classroom I would ask I would ask them to put it on their intro slide some um if they were willing to and I know that you know if I ask teachers with support and there were limits on the number of posters the number of things so um I'll give all credit here to miss Courtney Bernett and what's Happ over at the high school worked very closely on these procedures Courtney is working with the students now to do the refinement as we're getting ready this spring to do the next set of Elections um

080but yes I think those are you know those are the types of conversations that are happening and what an awesome learning experience that sound like that if students are excluded then student based election should be excluded that should from this policy that should fall under the of the principle agreed and it sounds like it's already at a regulation level anyway being worked on so there's not a need to pop it up at this well any other pieces that we'll consider and we'll we'll try again we'll draft another one and and send it to you for feedback and and work from there as we have in the back quick quick question actually I mean so I know Stacy Abrams has come in St at elementary school at the you probably knowed Elementary times before I know

081other folks have come through and so we have call outs for that are there exceptions for when like like so what's the how do we manage a situation like that yeah I think that's a good question is I've heard a lot about an instruction and then I'm more familiar with optional attendance right so it's not like Stacy abrs is coming to school and you all have to come into the but when she I just want to clarify when she came she was reading a book yeah yeah it was doing there was a literacy activity she wasn't campaigning I you know and and that I would say typically when an elected official is coming to see students that's that's what they're there to do only probably singers can actually vote meaning singers in in high school

082as far as the age limit of who their level of influence would be or direct influence of of voting I'm watching time too okay excellent thank you so much thank you look forward to the conversation of the next work session for that one thank you for board members uh I think we have we feedback on two general public relations policies though before we close out yeah hey is that you hey good afternoon board chair her Vice chair sulon let St members of the board student representative Delena and superintendent Dr Diva Whitaker all right in accordance with the 2024 2025 policy calendar policy code K which is general public relations is scheduled for pre-work here in the month of January today we have two policies on our pre-work agenda from these areas the first is Ka

083public relations goals and objectives the second is kmb possession of weapons by visitors as a reminder to the public policies that are presented during pre-work are new businesss on which we are speaking board input these policies are being presented as initial drafts they are being shared together board input and feedback that can be reflected in drafting um or revising future versions first up is policy Ka public relations goals and objectives this was identified for development based on the board's desire to professionalize communication and develop a strong relationship of trust and transparency and Community engagement with all stakeholders AA lays the foundation for public relations and would codify the board's belief that our schools are made Stronger by the support of the community it indicates that the board shall make every attempt to one keep the

084public informed about the policies administrative operations objectives educational programs and all pertinent and public information pertaining to the schools and two provide the means for Furnishing transparent timely and accurate information along with interpretation and explanation of school plans and programs at this time I welcome any board input to be considered for policy Ka public relations goals and objectives my my only comment is that this is a very vague policy very much just like a hey we're going to be transparent we want it it doesn't Define it we want to be timely it doesn't Define it we want to do it accurate and so to me it it's a fine policy I actually have no edit to it whatsoever I'm just not sure how it contrains or changes Behavior which in theory should be the point

085of a policy my feedback point I think that if the policy called for or assigned someone as responsible for creating those regulations or those set of Standards it might be a more useful policy all right is it something that the board would like to have brought back and look at adopt or is it something that you don't want to pursue at this time would that being like the regulation of it I right like it just says like let's just take this furnish transparent timely and accurate information along with interpretation explanation of school plans and programs okay so it's like I hear I hear Tracy in my head right now right like she is such a advocate for being transparent to her credit but then often we're like What does it mean to be transparent have

086we hit this policy are we in violation of that policy whose job is it to say that well a good policy would tell you whose job it is to say and check that and be transparent or not as opposed to just sort of like that last standard that I don't like in the gsba Norms they're like are you being ethical and legal it's like good job we're being ethical and legal great policy everybody what is the problem we're solving go it is it looks be more as a way to kind of codify again some of the things that were in the current strategic plan the board um charged superent would occur obviously when she first came one of the things was to professionalize communication um as well as you know to have that trust and

087transparency with stakeholders so this is a way at the policy level to kind of acknowledge that and say this is what we believe and this is what you know as a board we want to see we know that having that Community um we value our community and we are and we really aspire to do these things so it was in response to that man one question is relevant I thought you said there was comment public comment to one of these yeah no this is brand so just one point for clarification by law do we have to let the public comment or are we opting to do that we have a policy in place um that that allows for that public comment period on policies before they're adopted I don't know Carrie if it's a larger

088law just our current policy to allow I think it's just our policy okay so I think I should have recognized that in our board assessment because that is a specific way in which we get the so thank you I mean so to the extent that not having a policy that states were going to be transparent they were going to be quick to respond to the like that's probably bad so I I prefer us to have a policy around it I do think James is probably right that it feels a little bit like you know patting ourselves on the back for something anyway but um I don't mind putting a policy in place and then having this be one of the main ones that we kind of routinely revisit to evolve as we go along to

089give it a little bit more teeth and Direction excellent I think I'm going to be told this would be the implementation part but I remember when we were in Savannah in June we were talking about our website I think right and I think James you were comparing or sharing examples of others so we probably wouldn't be delineating some of those features in the policy but would that be something we could connect to the policy that's a lot more operation okay thank you yeah because and that's that's my problem with the policy like who is the check on whether we're being transparent we could look websites we can look at budget we yeah think like as I read number two provide the means for Furnishing transparent timely and accurate information you know there's there's room in

090the budget for you know the types of technologies that we have to provide that communication we're doing it but but I'm hearing a call to continue forward with it great all right next up is policy kmb possession of weapons by visitors this is a new policy for consideration intended to support our culture of Safety and Security as drafted this policy for ribits possession of weapons at schools or properties except for persons authorized by law it includes a definition section which defines key terms such as school function school safety zone and weapons it acknowledges the existing General prohibition against carrying weapons in school safety zone so there is law around that but it encourages School visitors including parents not to bring weapons on any school district policy it does allow for lawful possession of weapons in

091a locked motor vehicle in accordance with Georgia law it does not prohibit lawful search of the vehicles with sufficient cause and to prevent any immediate threats so this again was kind of risen based on um the culture of Safety and Security and just again alignment with law and things like that so I'd welcome any board input for policy K and B possession I'll have K listening closely to this one question may a question for Carrie does this allow parents who are off duty um police officers to carry a weapon on full property like if they're there to pick their kid up and they're an off duty officer and they have to have a weapon are they do they they have to leave it in the car still Yes okay thank you and the second question

092is would there be signage in front of the school that makes it clear to visitors that they cannot they cannot carry it's not in the policy but but can you create said sign yeah I have seen signus like that across the years of being an educator in Georgia okay thank so the last bullet allows for searches of vehicles with sufficient cause and to prevent immediate threat so I will always refer people back to the actual language of the policy which is attached in simply just um we learned last time ianda tries to summarize for you all in the public some of the bullets here of the highlights in there what it says is that nothing in the policy shall preclude the right of school officials or Law Enforcement Officers to search a privately owned or

093School District vehicle when necessary to prevent an immediate threat to human health life or safety or when there's sufficient cause so was just calling out specifically that if there's an immediate threat that can still occur that's so because it's efficient cause is defined as if there is an immediate threat or so there are different standards under the law for when you can search and standards apply differently so could be probable cause it could be reasonable suspens suspicion depending on the circumstances if it's student it's going to be reasonable suspicion if it's an adult you're probably going to have to have probable cause with the police officer um so and I'm not going to be able to go through every single circumstances standing here but sufficient cause would mean under the circumstances what is the appropriate

094level of cause you have to have in order to be able to but just to be clear this policy is just saying we're not changing anything that already is expent in the law largely so yes yeah you can't we can't change law right we always have to fall under the law anyway so essentially the weapons prohibited section like ocga provides it shall be unlawful really this policy is like hey this state law applies to the city school it's applied and it's and we're making a statement that this is important and especially in our current culture of Safety and Security um I'll be honest we had a couple of schools even reach out out and ask questions about um I've had slts question me about arming teachers and their rights to do that as a governing

095body we clarify that um so there's just been some some talk and chatter around um weapons on campus and so to just make sure that it's codified at even the policy level because not everyone might be looking at state stuff and this is slightly more accessible to some public to have that in place and then my only comment is I have sort of like a pedantic question that first sentence because it says the board prohibits the possession of weapons at any school or any of its property great only person's all thread by law and then we got claws out May possess a weapon on school property um almost reads to me like unless you've got a uh permission to carry a gun you may not do it I wish that that sentence was a little

096less vague or if I'm wrong and it's not legally vague I'm fine to hear that as well when I authorized by law May possess weapon on school property I got a permit yes some people may interpret it that way okay it just seems like we could fix that with like only purpose persons authorized to have a gun at school got it are allowed to do it great recommendation we'll do that for your next draft right thank you okay okay thank you Miss Lynch uh we look forward to conversation next month and work speci on those policies as well as news policies thank you board members for the discussion this concludes pre-work we will return at it is 3:23 now so we'll let's try to be back at 3:30 um to get started with our e

097recommendations that Happ at home oh no all all right gonna call the monthly work session to order thank you for joining us Jump Right In Dr Whitaker if you don't mind introducing our first presentation thank you chair hearen I would like to call on Mr El EST Melton chief of safety and Technology services to provide the annual update of the division good afternoon everyone good afternoon board chair hearnen Vice chair Dr Sultan esteemed members of the board Bron and Dr Whitaker it's a pleasure to bring most of our team um to you with an annual update on state of the divic so like every other support team our division exists to help realize Student Success in areas as you've heard before the support of student outcomes is what differentiates a school it department or District

098security team from itm security at Delta cacota but on a day-to-day basis our work happens in the space of organizational effectiveness of Excellence the most significant change for our work this year revolved around Staffing and organization in July the information services and Safety and Security departments merged into a single safety and Technology service division safety today leans heavily on technology resources furthermore it work and safety work often involve change management and Readiness for the entire organization not just teachers and principles but also bus drivers Administrative Assistant par professionals the whole spectrum of employees and often the whole spectrum of students for example our successful project last year to implements multiactor authentication as a cyber security measure for all staff and further coupling Safety and Security with the IT team gives us additional School level staff

099directly in the reporting structure to support the technology side of safety initiatives our school-based technology Specialists just as they were the Lynch pin for change management around multiactor authentication they've already proved hugely valuable in cgic rad units and they will play a bigger role in the crisis go roll out coming second semester I'll talk about those projects in a minute the safety and Technology Services branding for the group isn't all the way out yet that will come um in large part with uh District website relaunch the step one for the new division was of Safety and Security which we did before school started you all have met director James Brown several times he's rapidly established himself as a goto resource and a high level strategist for how we modernize our Safety and Security program step

100two this summer was to hire a new Shepherd for Infinite Campus and our data tools and we were fortunate to have Carol Gibson join our organization one thing both James and Carol bring to their roles is since we first met them in everyday sense they connect their highly technical often behind the scenes work to Student Success and student outcomes they are here for the kids and of note these are two Wilson sensor employees but they are not additional headcounts and the majority of the division is still assigned to schools and furthermore everyone on that left side of the screen with the desk at the Wilson Center is also virtually every single day working with often physically with even in the digital world they are with our teachers from media Specialists administrators and other school-based staff

101this is a very School heavy team now for the next little while I'm going to focus on some of the work that our new directors are undertaking and then I'll zoom out a bit and share more broadly about the other list that the rest was te two of our biggest lists this year have been strategics crisis alert system standard response protocols um cix is a one button uh crisis alert system employees wear around their neck I'm right here I'm hoping some folks over my right shoulder might be showing you their C bad and if you haven't had a chance to push the button I've got a demo here during the break you can press it you won't set anything off um employees click it click his button three times to indicate I need help immediately

102notifying building administrators and front office staff on their computer District cell phone whose badge went off where they are in a building now staff have had their cic badges for a few months and they've used them to ask for medical assistance help break up fights or to alert to a student who's possibly run off additionally any staff member can click their badge eight times to put their building in a lock down if there is an immediate danger to the School such as a shooter armed Intruder or someone violently trying to get into the building in those cases not only are front office staff alerted but so are district leaders strobe lights throughout the campus will illuminate and very soon testing's been going on uh today in fact um automated messages will play over the intercom

103letting occupants know they need to lock down also very powerfully eight press alerts immediately notify the city of decar 911 Center and we want to thank the city of the city police department for their partnership in implementing this integration this system does give us some Assurance even as we think about the horror that would necessitate using it we recall from appalache high school in Barrow County the cic system is credited with saving lives on September as a system though just because we've gone live doesn't mean the project is done we have in fact had four eight press alerts in our schools three of them in Inver one of them was an accident from a box bouncing on an employees badge moving other was an inadvertent escalation of what should have been a three button I

104need help and the third triggered um at two schools as an employee was commuting into work and they had something pressing on their badge as they were driving through deer we consider these to be in instructional speak assessments for learning what not to do and from an Adar perspective a change management perspective a kind of reinforcement of how best for example to take care of our badges the effective campus has also got a demonstration that the syic system actually works but as a community and as Leaders though we need to expect that we will have more false alarms as the tool becomes part of the system of wearing the badge and making decisions about when and how often to press it every school district working through a cix implementation has gone through this we got

105canned messages from cix knowing that is what happened and they were great to be able to not start with not start with a blank page um and we've got messaging ready to go the next time we do have an an ver Cress um short of an armed Intruder though cic also has the ability to send other types of Campus alerts in a crisis we might need to evacuate the building due to the smelt of a fart spray or shelter in place if there's a train derailment or hold students um where they are to clear the Halls if you need to evacuate someone during a sensitive um medical EV EV evacuation administrators can trigger these types of alerts using their CICS F2 again lighting strobes of a particular color and sending an intercom message now although

106we often indicator like our Boutique deater way solution these colors and these labels align with terminology and procedures developed by the I love you guys Foundation um I want to give credit to director Brown who brought his expertise with this framework to us here indicator this framework is the foundation for our new standard response protocol SRP School leaders were exposed to SRP in October November and December SRP training was part of each school's back to school regimen with staff our very first day back on January 6 last month we shared the srps with Dr Whitaker's PT Council yesterday SRP posters for classrooms and comment spaces went out to each and every school this month we'll get the SRP post to the district website we'll begin supporting School leaders and educating students on what each of

107these colors and Associated intercom messages mean and there'll be a topic of conversation at the January 27th safety Summit conducted jointly with the city the SRP is meant to clarify our vocabulary during the crisis might note for example it's just lockdown on the top line there's no linguistically ambiguous soft lockdown versus hard lockdown we also want to empower our families to know what these labels mean so so that if they get a text in the middle of the day saying your child's school is securing those Guardians not only know a little bit more in the moment about what that actually means but it also can be the basis to have a conversation with that child when they come home from school that day to check in and you see there's some of those connections between

108Safety and Security regimen and those conversations and that emotional well-being that we rely on um with our kids to so that's a lot for the first few months and we have a lot more in store in St in store theix is helpful in telling folks that something has happened but not and it tells us where but not what and for that we need a dedicated communication system and that for us is Crisis go crisis go also contains modules for unification in a crisis but we're starting off with basic Communications superintendent Suite have used it for a few events and we soon be expanding it outs of principles prices go will eventually roll out to all employees this year so that Educators can take account of students during a crisis additionally this month we're continuing to

109develop procedures and will begin testing cic's visitor management system starting with a pilot at Westchester elementary this will involve significant communication and change management for not only sta but also our families and our vendors visitor management system will require visitors including parents to scan a state issued ID that checked against the sex offender registry Positive Hits against that system are folks we don't want around our students they'll be not granted further access to the campus it is new to our families to ask them to show ID on campus Building family members not only awareness but also desire to interact with such a system is critical part of the Readiness and the pilot will also involve ensuring that we have plans and language to address for example false positive um where a family member or instances

110where a family member doesn't have a state issued ID uh we would would not accept security coming at the expense of any Community numbers likewise we'll be working on parameters for heal front office staff address situations um pardon there are school events where we do not anticipate this system being used for example Community Circle where guests are constantly monitored by staff Limited in their building access and not directly interacting with students and again it's not only families who will undergo these checks it applies to vendors too and will ensure they're aware one additional benefit to the system is that authorized visitors will receive a special badge that will show that bad's location on a map of the building so we know where our guests are at any given time and an administrator's request and third

111will soon begin installation of the aidil on camera security system paid for by Grant from the Department of Education at the high school DHS is our most complicated site and has the greatest need for thorough robust and reliable security C coverage we are working with net planner a longtime partner on the it side of the house to engineer solution to bring a 21st century security camera system to that campus the new system will allow administrators to access and share footage from their phone backtrack folks movement throughout the building across multiple cameras and quite simply to have confidence they can promptly lay eyes from anywhere on any part of the building on a moment's notti last month we issued an RFP for design build firm to design and price out security vest to bues and the

112significant portion of the $1.4 million allocated in the budget to Safety and Security this fall go toward this work five firms submitted proposals The Proposal evaluations began last week and a recommendation to award the contract will come to the board for approval next month work on all four of these is underway we expect the first three to be concluded by the end of the semester and at least for vable design the pricing to be concluded this this semester pricing and design complexity will determine the timeline for actual construction we also have some updates on the digital side of security and other operations you received an update on our cyber security posture with the largest recommendation for CSD be to implement multiactor authentication for all employees so last year we implemented multiactor authentication for all employees

113as a reminder multi Factor authentication also known as two-factor authentication is a system by which a password or a pass rate uh isn't enough to access uh any users account um we also use the increase in security to expand single sign on for staff computers and Infinite Campus it's rare that an organization can increase both security and ease of use um and we were eager to take advantage of the opportunity uh last year and we appreciate the Bo's support on the security side our environment remains monitored by a Georgia Department of Education provided resource which continues to identify us as performing and an advanced level for a K12 organization and we receive regular reports too from the federal cyber security and infrastructure Security Agency scanning our Network render this work though is never ending thanks

114to the board support during the regular session we hope of a midyear adjustment um we'll partner with one of our cyber security vendors to document and validate our progress toward reaching CIS uh critical security controls level one the cyber security framework that the Georgia Department of Education encourages school districts to make progress toward reaching and we anticipate completing most of that work semester presentation talking about physical safety which director BR manages on a daily basis with expertise and fluency now let's talk about some of the data Work Director Gibson has undertaken this summer we launched the district's first public data dashboards using the power of Enterprise grade Tableau Data buiz tool we updated them to include late relased map data and ccpi will be posted soon there's still troves though of information we want to

115get out there for our community we've begun the work to add additional public visas including profiles on our school demographics additional assessment data and they'll be up by the spring we're also working on another series of improvements to internal dashboards for school operations and in particular granular information on student Renaissance assessment performance worth noting that a lot of our work is similar to and we learning and sharing with other districts Carterville City Schools came to us and asked how we got our public dashboards made and around the same time we turned to our friends in Rockdale County with every teacher likes to do we adapted um some of their work for us to modify and provide to our own teachers to start bringing that to them at last month's board meeting there was a conversation

116between several of you and assistant superintendent H about suspension days and what suspension durations went to State reporting and what CSD should measure and at the end of it Miss Hol mentioned our work around data governance board member us took a moment to name both the necessity and the challenges of undertaking data governance and so we're doing last month cabinet approved a project Charter to begin CD's formal work toward data governance including standard data governance a standing data governance team with group Charter and initial deliverables focusing on role and process documentation early evidence of successful shifts and practice reflected in our initial data submission to the state for our upcoming State reporting Windows this group will help Drive accountability by documenting data roles and responsibilities to the job title and data system level it will

117help establish consistent definitions and processes when it comes to data consumption and maintenance another way to think about this work is that data governance makes a succession ready or succession proof so that Essential Knowledge and shared understandings don't evaporate when someone hires moves on to the next thing and new leaders aren't having to redefine basic concepts when they step into their role the third piece around our data work is simply around maximizing our use of the infinite campus student data system director Gibson came to us from the soulle infinite campus implementation partner in Georgia who's already begun the work to better leverage features that were underutilized for example we were able to use campus payments to register close to 1300 Guardians to sit for Thanksgiving lunch with their children and I'd like to tell you

118how large an improvement over the previous year that was with the manual cash and check process couldn't track the data more recently we've worked with our counselors to implement the graduation planner module letting Scholars and their parents explore further ahead the multiple Pathways open to them over the course of their secondary education career and this can help extend the on-ramp for families to backward plan how to get their child ready for and access to our District's growing and robust Advanced academic offerings that plan of begins rolling out this month speaking of data I have a few data points to share with you despite a 3 and a half% increase in year-over-year ticket volume we've had an even higher customer statisfaction rate from staff what we don't see captured in the staff but what we hear

119from principles that our teams communication and visibility remain critical ways the it side of the shop support staff supporting colleagues with their Tech is our major role in cultivating and retaining highly qualified professionals team also included nine major multi-site projects this year including copier Fleet replacement wireless access point life cycle refresh Elementary student device refresh ensuring access for all employees to powerful generative AI tools and the department of education's new District employee resource portal on the safety side we've conducted 24 school security walkthroughs using a tool provided by the Georgia school boards Association and we look forward to showcasing that tool and building awareness and desire tomorrow as I shared before we've had over 40 I need help strategics alerts three of them inadvertent both the intended and the unintended alerts are opportunities for us

120to refine our practice and become more fluent in using crial resource there's a lot more work this division has completed and anticipates undertaking it's the right work it's the right people many of whom are here this afternoon supporting students and staff um on it in a daily basis everything we do we do for kids for the grown-ups who are there for kids out of this team and conf we continue to deliver I'm happy to take any questions did one quick question about um the I forget what the term was but uh for when there's things like tornadoes hurricanes whatever it was standard response protocol yes is that in any way link uh siren system that uh is able to identify our alert when there are funnel clouds or Touchstone I don't know that's a great

121question to ask about like we hear that every second Wednesday at 5:00 pm right that's something we can explore with them I don't have an answer for you but I'll get you one yeah what I mean it I recall prior to this Administration that there was a one day release where we released directly into the mall of a really severe storm and um yeah people were on buses kids were on buses when the alarm started going off and so we have in my office the national weather service radio um and now I am as well as many members of cabinet very much tied into the cab Emergency Man management association we are on all national weather service calls um so we're in Dima we're in FMA we're in National Weather Service and we have the

122radio in my office and the radio was already there I'm not sure how that came about but we just and I don't remember all the particulars in the play by day play byplay of the day but I remember the day you're talking about one thing that comes to mind is even if we can't tie in with the city or the county alarm system between both strategics and crisis go what these tools allow us to do is to get the word out systematically and fast you probably heard I know everyone on this side of the room has heard Dr W talk about when a message comes through I need to to make a noise other than the happy birthday message for like General employee chat crisis go the mechanism to do if we're on the C

123of dismissal at p and Fifth Avenue the kids are right about to go out the door we can literally make our own siren sounds to capture the attention of building leaders front office staff even all teachers if we have to get the word out to say hold P for a second um and that's like that's a very narrow there there's a broader question about systems and procedures around pending weather and Readiness and we've gotten growing into our maturity around that over the last uh couple of days last year or so but in terms of that technical specific question we'll follow up and get your on answer and I will say um the students actually uh on their advisory team both K5 and 612 they have the smaller cards that were issued to them and we

124took them through the SRP and help them to understand its importance and then to talk to their families about it so just one question about cic I'm familiar with it and I think I hope it's impressive that we've had so few inadvertent ones but in the event there is an inadvertent lockdown because the apple pies are you know bouncing on it will the school get a communication or the parents saying hey sorry there was an inadvertent absolutely let me tell you about what happened the first time it happened one of our elementary schools almost a perfect storm it was Friday during Community Circle the strobes were active and I think the staff member was helping to get ready for a book fair otherwise helping to do things around and just lots of books you're an

125English teacher you know L got do some heavy stuff and so the Press happen and so the intercom integration wasn't live them we still had families and and uh but the app notification alerted so principal wisman gets the alert it doesn't sound like his Google chat message he knows this is something different I need to step away immediately he did exactly what the principal was supposed to do he saw who the employee was he saw where it was and within moments he was up he was up there within moments director Brown Dr Whitaker myself checking with the school ascertained nothing is wrong and slly thereafter messages went out to the internal Community to of Staff because they saw the STP and also to the parents to let them know certainly we know that some parents

126in fact one of them did ask Mr wisman later on hey what was that red light that was happening so yeah I mean and and so just as Mr Melton said CICS provides caned if you will responses to those things but we know that communication has been something that we have taken on in this Administration so um know that our Communications team responds immediately when um any of those things happen and it's one it's one of the great things about having this growing Communications team office M Mr wisman was able to go principal his school director Brown Chief Hart they took on the onus let's take this SC report make it custom to us and have it ready so the principal s to be on it way that's the resource that that team provides in

127that so the safy technology division has completed significant lists this school year and they will continue to do so I want to Echo to um his invitation to the community to come to the school Safety and Security Summit Mr M Melton mentioned earlier it will be held on January the 27th from 5:30 to 7:30 at decar High School in the perform Performing Arts Center we look forward to sharing with our partners from the cater Police Department as well as the cater fire keeping all students and staff safe not only will will there be a panel discussion but we will also have breakout sessions for families to attend and our students from The Advisory Council once again had influenced some of the um topics that will be discussed or even questions that will be asked so

128I'm really looking forward to that event later this month very timely thank you Mr Melton thank you to your team those projects are incredibly important to CSD being effective and safe and excellent and one of my neighbors works for p Alto and and shared the ticket and then he's like wow that was his only response was wow like no one is hitting those numbers so kudos to you all for responding quick and effectively Dr Whitaker next presentation yes I would like to call on Mrs Adena Walker chief of Human Resources to provide uh the FY 26 compensation content good afternoon chair Vice chair Del consultan other exem members of the board board uh student representative Delena and superintendent Dr G today's presentation marks the next phase of our compensation reform Journey building on the foundation

129laid during the Board of Education retreat in November this step ensures our commitment to providing competitive compensation for all St our work is always grounded in Allin strategic plan with competitive compensation aligned with the Strategic accelerator cultivating and retaining high quality professionals to illustrate our intentionality behind our compensation reform let's take a historical look at entry level salaries T4 and Master's T5 degrees over the past seven academic years annual salaries for both categories have increased by over $177,000 annually at the November Retreat we we shared the district where we are now current rankings Bas so basically on a salar and year two of strategic plan CSD ranked seventh out of nine in The Benchmark comparison with eight other Metro Atlanta districts as requested by the board the goals of this position the D is in

130the top portel for total teacher compensation by the conclusion of Sy y28 total compensation includes District contributions to healthcare PRS F and this is providing a comprehensive view of the compensation package currently CSD ranks third out of nine in total compensation this is a look at our total at our current teacher ing solely based on salary for entry level teachers coming in with zero experience we rank seventh out of nine for bachelor five out of nine for Masters six out of nine for Specialists and seven out of nine for doctorates when we look at teachers with 12 years of credible experience which is the average years of experience in our district we rank seventh out of nine for teachers who hold a bachelor and Masters six out of nine for teachers who hold a special

131and a doctorate degree in all of these categories we did rank uh increased one rank last from last year when we look at the top of the scale which are teachers with 25 years of predal years of experience and higher we rank eight out of nine for all levels which is an increase from nine out of nine for fy2 FY 24 here are the current rankings for our goal criteria which is total comp compensation for entry level teachers we rank three out of nine for all certificate levels Bachelors through doctorate for teachers with 12 years of experience we ranked three out of nine for Bachelors and Masters and four out of nine for Specialists and doctors of the scale we ranked four out of nine for bachelor and doctorate and five out of nine for

132Masters and specialist to provide a greater insight into the distribution of Staff across the certificate levels and years of experience as we explore various compensation Concepts the numbers in the middle of each box represent the total staff and procedure scale meanwhile the numbers on the top of each box indicate how many individuals fall within specific years of experience at the conclusion of the November Retreat the board agreed on the following compensation priorities that would guide the work of this next phase of presenting proposed Concepts these priorities are give all staff a minimum of 3% C A 3% Cola a increase give all eligible staff a cola and step increase to look at specific positions in the lowest ranking to prioritize how to inas their compensation [Music] ranking increase par professional hourly rates to a minimum

133of $18 an hour to smooth out teacher salary scale to have equal increments between steps to minimize salary comp uh compression with administrative scales and lastly address scales to ensure Market competitiveness while supporting internal equity for compensation part two these rankings give pertinent information from different perspectives the salary only rankings of course are rank solely based on salar however total compensation rankings incorporate this the employee perspective showing the employees salary after Social Security deductions before but before individual taxes and benefit premiums are applied this perspective is essential it helps employees understand their potential take-home pay even with the district's contributions to their retirement as inflation Rises take-home pay directly affects employees quality of life and daily living expenses a continuous factor in this Pro process is the need to remain aware and mindful of how

134aggressively other districts May adjust their salaries in the upcoming fiscal years for our teachers the initial proposed concept includes a 3% cost of living adjustment which is the cola appli to the current salary scales this analysis assumes no changes to salary scales in other districts as it is too early to determine their potential adjustments at the entry level we ranked four out of nine Bachelor and doctorates three out of nine for Masters and Specialists for 12 years six out of nine Bachelors Masters and Specialists and four out of nine for doctorate for the top of the scale we rank five out of nine for Bachelors and six out of nine for Masters Specialists and doctors can I ask one clarify I just want to make sure that I'm reading that chart correctly yes that's just

135how does our how does a 3% increase only compare with the status quo of other districts that is correct okay thank you our total compensation our rankings uh improved significantly across all stages of the teacher's career notably rankings increase substantially for 12 years of experience and at the top of this pay scale this is reflecting the majority of our current teachy staff have achieved the desired top tier rankings for entry level rankings we are that three out of nine for bachelor Specialists and doctorates and one out of nine for Master's level for 12 years of credible experience we increased to three out of nine for all certificate levels Bachelor through doctorate and top of the scale two out of nine for Bachelors and three out of nine for Masters through doctorate now we will look

136at the estimated cost for the salary only for this concept increases the entry salary to $ 59,4 31 and it applies the uniform increase to each step of the scale for bachelor's level 900 would be the the amount between the steps for Masters 1,50 for specialist 1,200 and for doctorate 1350 the estimated cost is approximately just shy of uh right under $1.3 million for concept 3B the entry level again is $ 59,4 31 this also incorporates a uh the it equal step steps on the scale but this is slightly a little bit more at 1100 for Bachelors 1,00 Masters for specialist level and 1,400 for doctorate level this estimated cost is approximately $2.2 million sorry I like clarifying these things when we're on the slide and I apologize for this yeah bachelor's degree 900 3A

137first year teacher fifth year teacher the fifth year teacher will be $4500 more that is correct because it would it would it would be 900 each and then the B that same teacher would be $5500 more and I just do that across the board 20 years of doctorate 1,400 each year I can do the simple math that's what we mean by smoothing thank for the next C up it's a little bit more aggressive with a 4% Cola increase the salary rankings on this uh option is very similar to the 3% colon with some notable changes for entry level Bachelors moved up one rank to three out of nine for 12 years of experience Specialists moved up one rank to six out of nine and for Topo scale doctorate level moves up two rank from 6

138out of n to four out of n with total compensation these rankings uh maintain the rankings very similar again to the 3% to increases however this concept does increase the base entry level salary for teachers significantly and shows the aggressiveness of maintaining in the top cortile particular usually in the mid to end of your teachers where most of our current teachers live for concept 4 a this increases the entry level to 60,000 and it also applies the same amount between the steps for Teacher skills the approximate cost for this concept is 1.6 million for the concept 4B this also increases it to a little over 60,000 and again the amounts between the the steps are the same for Bachelors 1100 Masters 12200 specialist 1300 and do, 1400 the estimated cost is approximately 2.5 million for

139this concept now we will look at our targeted non-teaching support staff position the five specific job categories are targeted for increased salary competitiveness for Care Professionals nurses directors non-administrative Specialists and coordinators as these groups did not receive an adjusted level level set for FY 25 first we will look at our par professional the budget priorities specifically called out increasing par professional pay to a minimum of $18 per hour currently PA professionals rank seven out of n in total compensation the proposed level set is 10% to increase to $18 an hour before the district col perc increase it this increases the pair professions to five out of Nine the estimated cost for this concept is 200 we do have two concepts for this for this estimated cost on the first concept is $218,000 um for approximately

14074 parents for concept two this is $334,000 I'm sorry $334,800 [Music] day calendar Day schedule I'm sorry and compare the par hours are split 5050 with half still working 7.5 hours and the other half still are working eight hour shifts next we will look at nurses currently nurses rank seven out of nine in total compensation the proposed level set is 7% uh before the district Cola increase percentage increase this concept increases the base salary and total compensation but maintain the overall nurse ranking of seven out of Nine the Georgia Department of Education recommends nurse to student ratio 1 to 750 students for elementary schools and one to 1500 for middle and high school currently we have fully licensed registered nurses in all schools the the decision to adjust nurses SC salaries would be at the

141discretion of the board as nurses was one of the specific job categories identified to review if necessary we could start with the proposed salary increase and work on improving competitiveness throughout the remaining of the Strategic the estimated cost for salary only for nurses is 37,7 $27 for directors currently directors in our district rank four out of nine in total compensation the proposed level set is 3% increased before the district Cola percentage increase this increased the total compensation reing to two out of Nine the estimated cost for salary only is 43,000 $77 for 16 District directors for our non-administrative specialist which is our business office and Technology professionals on the specialist scale currently our Specialists rank four out of nine in total compensations the proposed level set is 4% before the district Cola percentage increase this

142increased the base salary and total compensation but maintained like the nurses specialist ranking four out of Nine the estimated cost for salary only is $6,550 for approximately 15 Specialists on these scills and finally uh coordinators the coordinators are a little bit more challenging category to assess as their duties vary depending on on whether their position is instructional or operational however overall the overall 12mth cator salary is fairly competitive with other districts to enhance competitiveness a proposed 2% level set increase is recommended before applying the district Cola percentage increase the estimated cost for salary only is 41,8 $4 for 19 coordinators on these skills here's a summary of all the teacher proposed Concepts both Concepts offer overall percentage increase and smoothing out step on all teacher scills that will eliminate random step increases here's a summary

143of the non- teing positions that we specifically pulled out to review their their selling competitiveness with others Metro District and last but not least here's the proposed annual supplement for our adapted special education teachers and peer professionals and the estimated cost associated with those supplements for approximately 12 special education adapted teachers a $2,000 annual supplement is 24,000 and for approximately 20 adapted PA professionals a 1,500 annual supplement is 30,000 here the next steps in the process during the January work session we are assessing the compensation concepts for teachers non-teacher positions specific administrative job job categories differentiated compensation for special education teachers and parent professionals and assessing the affordability and sustainability for all proposed Concepts going forward in in February we will pass the pon to finance to price out each option with the benefit determine

144which FY 26 compensation recommendation that is in the best interest of the district financially estimate the financial impact of achieving the district's goal of being or suing a teacher compan total compensation by fy2 thank you and at this time I will answer any questions you may so when you um are presenting non-teacher uh changes you presented it as a certain percentage plus a yet to be determined Ru up yeah but we did not show it that way with the teachers are we assuming that the 3% or the 4% option is itself Cola and so we're not providing the teachers AR raay we're just providing a cola or are I was confused by why we're not showing a cola for the teachers or we are only showing a cola for the teachers and then showing a

145raise and a potential Cola for other categories exactly but the cola that I am putting the the the percentages that would be the cost of living increase and then we would have to factor in the step um that will be built into those steps as well so whatever uh the 4% or the 3% is is the raise for for theut and the sorry okay so concept three is essentially a cola time step four is a cola plus one when you're looking at the other positions it's because those positions did not get any uh level set if you will last year so that's why they were um pulled out this year for assessment for that and so then it sounds like we're generally considering 3% to be a cola anything beyond that 3% is the raise

146for everybody that is not a teacher there is a differing set of adjustments but they would then also get the 3% Cola that we're talking about applying okay because there's no steps not yeah yeah yeah yeah to clarify your question for the pairs the nurses the cola we should assume is three% it will be whatever your your whatever we deci we're saying your priority minimum of few questions confused slide 21 and slide 27 so I'm sorry if I'm misreading these percentages but on slide 21 what I'm seeing is apply a 3% increase and apply the proposed Cola on top but then when I move to apply 27 I'm reading that it's a sorry 6% increase and the cola so where did we go from slide 21 it said apply 3% and cola but slide 27

147says 6% and cola I'm misreading that July 21 is for n non teaching the slide 27 is for teaching no no no I'm looking slide 27 the director right there it says level set 6% increase before proposed Cola percent but on slide 21 is it not saying directors the same so I'm using the director's ter exactly that original slide and that that isn't an error right there the original F had the that in the uh P 3% we backed it out and that in the clarify so then the other thing I think James asked this but I want to make sure I understand when we're using the term level set we are saying that we are implementing um consistent increases for each step is that what of understanding so x amount for the bachelor's okay

148understand that but then I think I heard you say James there are no steps for directors but I thought that directors coordinators various positions have have uh it's like a 15-year versus the teacher with a 30 year so are those not considered steps like leadership year one leadership year two leadership year three but those are just years of experience okay that's is not based upon certificate level or any grade area like that but with those and I'm sorry if I'm mixing and mingling things here so a teacher earns their salary based on their certification and their years of experience so then when you move these directors coordinators Physicians I don't know if it applies to nurses or parents it's they're in this position and then each year is The increased salary amount that is correct

149okay so we are still going to offer looking at their leadership years of experience so each year would have an increase just like with the teachers they okay um yes but the the steps are just written into they're based off the state data um one big point of contention for me that I've had privately is like during Co and and particularly during furos we're going back a decade a lot of school districts skipped steps which is a very common thing and so when I asked Adena Miss Walker to put together that list one of the things was like if I had been teaching indicator for the past 20 years I would not I just did this map I would not be third out of nine I would actually be much higher than if I had

150stated Fon because fton had been skipping steps and so that's what we as a board as we agree do steps and that's not a guarantee in the Atlanta metro and it is certainly not a guarantee outside of the Atlanta metro for teachers as opposed to the leadership things where we can modify those those aren't tied to anything and then I guess the other thing so I tried to I think James you were clarifying it when we're looking so we look at salary rankings and then we look at compensation ranking and so we tend to go higher with the compensation rankings pretty much across the board correctly um and then so I was like well okay so we're looking at the ranking assuming there's a status quo I did go back to try to compare last

151year when we had this presentation and so I was pleased that we largely did move up right in some cases you know for those um entry level in all degrees they moved up I me I think from like 7 to four six to three um I'm just going to say that I'd like to see the teachers be at that second ranking when possible and I don't know if that it's into any of the possibilities we have well if I if I could add I know that Miss Anderson has raised a couple of times the fact that we don't necessarily know what other districts are going to do but we are clear on our terminology around what part is a raise which we would not necessarily expect other districts to offer versus which part is a

152cola which we would in fact expect other districts to offer right so the the point being if we offer if we say that that the cola is 3% that is because we're presuming across the board there's a cost of living adjustment necessary for 3% and we're probably going to see multiple uh competitive districts offer a similar dollar amount which means that that then can't really be used to assess our change in the rankings because that's kind of the amount that everybody's going to get just for inflation and so then when we say the raise is then what is on top of that Cola that is what we adjust ourselves based in the ranking right so that that I think clarification can go a long way when we start talking about what is it that we're

153doing that is just driven by inflation versus what is it that we're doing that's exceeded by inflation probably put your mindset into the four instead of the 3% because that includes a rate is what I'm saying yes effectively no I mean I actually think 3% is a pretty high Cola to be totally honest I don't know that inflation is going that direction this year so let's be precise in that terminology and I'm I'm sure miss Dr Broom will have a perspective on on where inflation is coming out but but but nonetheless that I think is the right way for us to be thinking about it great great so what I'm hearing is definitely a a concept of a four um is there a preference on the increment between stats if you could go to 2

154slide 27 all the way I know you went you just went all the way to other sorry yep so were increments between Steps A or B I'm gonna ask a question that so on slide 28 right we talked about this at The Retreat um again still in anything that I'm inaccurately describing but I believe we've had a problem trying to get say the I think we have two skyp or extra amounts that we're doing so along those lines we're getting to see the number of teachers we have in each kind of first 10 years 12 to 20 20 to 30 in addition to degrees so I guess the question I have is while the leveling seems where those step increases reasonable to equity um is there anything that we need to consider in terms of

155um keeping teachers the same way that we are looking at needs over here did I articulate that clearly can you can you so we get to see inide I think it's 20 something you all put and thank you for that um the number of teachers that we have in each category in each category correct right and so the fewest number we have in total I think or the newer teachers right I think I counted 120 something so now when I am and I in people leave and retire so you need new teachers um we did a nice job of incentivizing entry level salaries last year and I think you showed us that presentation historically so I guess my question is when we are looking at these step increases am I correct in saying right now

156they are treated equally equally by degree so 900 per year for each teacher as a bachelor's um 1050 or 1,200 per year for each teach you mean the current scales well what's being proposed yes so this is right now this is because if you look at our sales now it's very random and so when we say when we're trying to make sure that this is equable whenever someone is increasing their stuff because one year you can be 400 know you know and then the next year you could give you know 1400 and so and then at the end of the steps our steps are double so once you get get Beyond 25 years you're not getting a an increase a step increase but every other year so this right here is really it's going to

157correct that and to your point uh Mr H uh whenever we're looking at the raises from that come from the state if you really look historically in the last couple years they have been giving dollar amounts instead a percentage amount so that TI into your conversation as far as the Rays versus the cola out and then giving our Cola on top of that that would be the decision and so going forward whenever we do get that that amount from the state it has to be and going on our on top of our skills that way thank you I don't think I asked my question clearly but you answered the fact that so a teacher at 25 now is going to get the stepas it's going to get them step increases and they will know exactly

158so the the reason why I brought the question of the ramaa versus the raise is those percentages are are pretty impactful especially when we start looking elsewhere right so if it's 2 and a half% cola as opposed to a 3% or a 2% Cola as opposed to a 3% we just want that to be soon as we can have that clarified I would be more comfortable I'm sorry could you ask what you wanted again oh how we're going to the delineation between what is the cola versus what is the raise because the cola is getting applied to everyone else and the raay is getting applied specifically to teachers and so if it is a two and a half% colot then that means proportionately more of what we're doing here is going to a teacher raise

159as opposed to just for everyone and so I just want us to be as soon as we can get that tightened up I'll be but for clarification it's not everybody who's just getting the cola there's certain other groups that were eligible for a raise on top of the cola right these well those level sets and all the adjustments we're talking and all the other departments you know the directors 528 I think I'm the thing that is yes those are going to be adjustments beyond the cola okay the the bigger change is the a versus B that's answering your question I mean just very quickly 1% is $400,000 right but an extra what $200 for every step of that's almost a million dollars for I mean that's a we're talking a massive raise so my question

160is I would love to see the sustainability of 4B I think everyone on the board agrees and that first chart than you put together shows that we have been making progress some we teachers um so I think we all would would take 4B sounds great I love to do it but um just the sustainability of of committing to that um so my question the B the bulk of it is you're just looking at the math you're talking about one between one and 1.2 million a year consistent growth per year going forward based on the difference between a and b exactly yeah it's the sustainability it it um you know that's what what it wouldn't be 1.2 every year though yes because every year every person that's in that step gets that step change and the

161difference in that that that doesn't account for turnover doesn't account the way that the budget does it attrition for every teacher you have you retire you have a new teacher it's also teachers are more whatever that's yeah so yeah don't don't mistake my top of my head calculations for an Excel sprit but but yes it is though ballpark you're talking about on the order of a million dollars you're not talking about a couple hundred, so so so um it sounds like this board has more of an appetite for 4A I'd like that with the c two budget draft I'm leing towards 4 a without open to seeing what what's the sustainability so that means we're going to do budget draft one and budget draft two versus one one budget dra budget I mean I think

162if we're going to talk about this then I want to look at all of it because I think to hans's point the difference between a coal and AR Rays is significant because the cola 3% is being applied across the board did I understand you correctly there not so it seems difficult to say take 4 a or 4 B now until we get the information about the cola versus R both have four% okay yeah A and B the only difference is St no no no but the but if it's a 2 and a half% cola or a 2% Cola versus a 3% Cola that has a pretty dramatic impact on everybody else that's within the budget right that's I think the point and so I would lean towards that I think James's question about what does

163the B cost over time matters tremendously right and so what is that ratio of change over time and and I I think we're talking about at least 40% 30% of what the base cost is but even but even still if you go back and look at the numbers themselves the the the bulk of where the numbers are going to be different is between that 4 a and 4B if you have a 2.5 or a 4% Cola or or 2.5 Cola or 2.5 plus a 1.5 raay and you make that differentiation in the Specialists versus the nurses or whatever except they're a smaller number the bulk of your money is and the the teacher so I think that's really where I think that's really where the differentiation is going to be is whether we want the

1644 a or the 4 B I do agree totally probably need to decide what she said several minutes ago do we want the co what we want the colon number to be do you want it to be three do you want it to be four do you want it to be 2.5 um but I don't think you're going to see the needle move as much in that realm as you're going to see between 4 a and 4 B not absolutely below this all up but I mean to the extent that if we are offering a lower Co Cola and a higher raise that does free Capital up for us to consider even more raise for teachers um if if that was something that was interested I think a 3% cola this is just 3% Cola

165standard is reasonable I agree I think the only thing I would like to see I um really appre itive of the salary or compensation rankings moving but for example coordinators are rank second in both categories but I think when we look at the teachers some are still in the third so we made some improvements so you know I appreciate talking about but I believe we' been also using ranking as a benchmark coordinators second I'd like to see then the teacher second too well this the same it's be the same con because if you do that then you're talking about a much larger population of people that are going to be moving so again the nurses and the coordinators you're I mean if you look at this share volume of numbers you're talking about 2.5 million

166versus 1.6 million and down in the coordinators there at a cost of 42,000 so it's just a smaller bucket it is but I think when I'm looking and maybe I'm misreading this slide 13 with the rankings or we go to the number of teachers in those positions are teachers with the most experience and the uh most or degrees in experience I believe we have fewer of them I may have misread that but do you mind going up I have it at 13 I think it's 12 on years okay uh no it's the one before that yeah I'm trying to find the one number I was looking for comp part two teacher rankings total comp 4% increase okay than Cy to your point I was excited about the master's degree is the bulk of our te

167it's more than it's almost 55% of our teachers and one of nine three of nine three and nine that's pretty solid do we love work to do sure that's what that's the one that I wrote a bunch of numbers down here for and a key piece is it's a 5e strategic plan so [Music] incremental and I know that that's it's an incremental growth in rank and change um but it's a fiveyear strategic plan you you don't have to do it all in your what would be now two the key sustainability yeah would does that I think I know the answer but I want to ask you 12 years of credible experience Masters three out of nine that does not assume the scale fix that just assumes a 4% correct okay so the scale smoothening would

168we actually don't know but it will I think I'm at a three or a 4 a I think that my concerns with the exponential growth that happen with the larger scale steps is a concern uh and it's not necessarily in the one year that I'm concerned it's in the aggregate over multi-year that that that's a I think it's going to start constraining our ability to make additional salary adjustments in the future to continue to push the numbers up here so for clarification that's saying a 3% Cola and a 1% raise that's the way that we should document that with the smaller step adjustment smoing so then all the other would get a 3% Co yeah okay I think he's wrong but I'd like to see I when we go to the scale that has the

169numbers on it Tracy scale I'm calling it can we go up a few it's actually on page six I just found it we have 30 teachers who have a doctorate but then when I look at the right column I've counted 87 teachers in the last range of what is it years that we have identified here wa am I reading that correctly you add the five with the bachelor 47 with the Masters 29 with the specialist and six with the doctorate those are the ones that have the most years experience that correct that is correct okay so to answer the sustainability question I'm am correct that we could look at where this scale is as a percentage and then look back five years and 10 years like are we getting older are we getting more expensive

170or has attrition and retirement and and growth has this pretty much been where we are I I would assume that would be kind of possible May it's the CFO question um yeah because Hans is correct if that 47 five years ago was 30 but if 5 years ago that 47 was 47 percentage wise then this 2.5 we committing to this year is actually not a sustainability problem at all no that's if you're assuming that those 47 are a different 47 I am yeah but that's not you know knew that like that's the concern right but it's 5 years ago the same 47 out of 585 I didn't 525 was we're still just 47 out of 525 this means attrition means there's not actually that much growth in the scales this every five years right this

171is what and so what what is changing as we go across the top is uh what each row right let me make sure we're looking at represents each degree right and then each bucket represents years of experience years of experience correct so so in theory 547 29 and six will have retired five 10 years from now 6399 16 and 7 will have moved to the right but what happens and and what I would like to have the data on before we commit 4 a versus 4B is there's a lot of attrition in all as we've discussed in all occupations and including in teachers and if ultimately the reason the step program exists is to incentivize teachers to stick around but realize that as a budget you're not really committing to more money because of turnover

172because of the way the system works yeah I'm not I'm not convinced of that I mean I I you're you're right in the sense that folks are going to atrip out right but we're looking at 12 to 15 year Windows we're not looking at fiveyear window okay so Is it feasible to Is it feasible to give us the projections for both Dr Broom so essentially that would be creating two two budget in the system and that's system have may I ask you a question because I think I heard you asking James not for two but for more information about the existing pool of teachers and then looking back I felt like you weren't asking for two budgets you wanted more clarity to make an informed decision about that sustainable budget here's a maybe a thing

173that'll help James and I what is the average length of tenure of those Master's teachers right that's our largest slug of teachers and that is the one that's going to be the largest amount of expense in these steps if those teachers are here for 15 years then it's much more expensive the way I'm picking if those teachers are here for five years then it's much less expensive the way James is Mak and I don't know that we need the precise numbers but we're going to actually know roughly depending on what those 10 years look like and is is that going to make you ultimately think that if there are say fewer if it looks like over time the because it's there is a little bit of a SK few in the middle towards the Masters

174but have some of a lower population in the higher higher higher year bachelors and then the lower year doctor and it but it may always have some variation and at the end of the day it may all balance out so you may have some years where that lower population is a little higher and then the master is a little lower so it may be some variation that at the end of the day may not make a h I'm looking for how much what are you looking for I still think that between A and B there's probably going to be a million dollar or so difference maybe it'll be 900,000 to or maybe it be 1.1 what are you looking for in terms of that skew that's going to change your mind because if those if

175those if that middle slug of teachers that are going to get I forget what the number is 1,200 a year or something like that a step 1,200 a year step if those teachers are with us typically for 15 years and not five then what we're doing right now is we're signing ourselves up for 15 years of $1,200 increases per person that's in that slug as opposed to every five years you see what I'm saying or nutrition yeah I totally understand but they could easily be replaced by a doctorate that comes in that with five years of experience it hangs on for 10 there's no it could be balanced that's why an aggregate is what we're talking about not not kind of like at the at the um at an individual level you guys are right

176but you have to look at it in AG I'm saying it's it probably will make a difference I don't know if it's going to be a hugely significant dollar amount the it's not going to be a $2.6 million increase every year no um and it's not going to be a Zer increase every year and it is a very difficult I don't need two budgets but if it's closer to us signing up for a $2 million increase in the budget just built into the way we scale every year then I think we're all against it I think it's more like million dollar increment a year between the A and the B well but I I still like James's question and I'm not sure if I understand you know it's kind of like James you brought about

177that the policy question because if you look at the middle category right teachers have to have 10 years or tenure right to be invested in our retirement system so right now no matter what the degree is I believe what I'm reading is the most number of teachers are in that middle category yeah so it does feel to me like it should be fairly easy for us to get some kind of historical data and projection but that's not saying that all 139 those those teachers have been with her no of course not yeah no that one I get and then two I just want to make sure I'm clear about this so those teachers in that third column to the right those are the ones when they hit 25 would not have been received step increases

178is that correct every of so you're putting yeah okay putting a larger amount in youred I'm hearing a lot of support 4 a I would just like academically like to know when we talk about fixing a scale what's the sustainability of that what do we how do we expect the scale our average scale position as a system how does it change year for year are we getting older I thought we heard last year that were trending younger that they're becoming fewer and fewer in the right column in the education system which may be an argument for us going to 4B because at the end of the day we're trying to incentivize people sticking around and be accomplishes that better but if it's not physically sustainable we can't do another way to describe this is for

179each dollar change in those steps how much every year is that added to the budget going so more work okay so while this presentation was primarily Human Resources it is a part of the larger FY 26 budget development timeline so we look forward to bringing the first draft of the general fund budget FY 26 next month also we will hear Commissioner's Office the city of decator city manager and CSC staff regarding the use of federal state and SPO funds all of this including the decisions or requests made regarding compensation Concepts will assist us in developing the FY 26 budget thank you Mrs wer look forward to learning fiscal impact of these Concepts next month uh next presentation yes chair Heron I'd like to call on Mrs Amanda Lynch Chief of Staff to present three policies

180for first read good afternoon again board chair hen Vice chair Sulton Este members of the board student representative Delena and superintendent Dr G Whitaker today we have three policies on the agenda for work session g ma drug free workplace which is a revision to an existing policy GC responsibility to report criminal charges to employer which is a new policy and bcbi public participation in board meetings which is a revision to an existing policy these policies are being presented for first read if approved for first read they will be available for public comment through assembly stakeholders can access any policies open for public comment on the right hand side of the assembly homepage simply is linked on our CSC website under the board first is policy G g ma Gama is a revision to an existing

181policy and was discussed in pre-work last month the original policy was adopted by the board in November of 2022 last month we introduced language around Reasonable Suspicion testing to the policy in response to an additional round of legal feedback there have been some additional being presented today specifically language was added that employees subject to testing as a result of reasonable suspicion shall not be permitted to trans support themselves to test students that's a safety feature there may I read the recommendation yes please the recommendation being made is that City education accept policy g ma drug-free workplace for first read excellent do I have a motion to approve the recommendation to accept policy g ma drug free workplace for first read thank Mr do I have a second second oh we're going to give it to

182Dr in there uh any discussion hearing none all those in favor please say I I Mo carries n the gamc responsibility to report criminal charges to employer this policy was introduced as a new policy during pre-work last month there have been a few minor changes made to the version of the draft presented last month these changes are in response to an additional round of legal feedback specifically it was added that speeding violations that result and arrest are not exempt from report the language was clarified for employees unavailable for work as a result of the institution of criminal charges by clarifying it with the term job abandonment may I read the recommendation yes please the recommendation being made is that City schools of secator Board of Education accept policy GC responsibility to report criminal charges to

183employer for first read excellent do have a motion to approve the recommendation to accept policy gamc uh for first read so move thank you Doctor uh makes the motion do I have a second second Mr second motion any discussion it also got modified for five days instead of three didn't it yes we talked about it last time but it wasn't reflected in the initial correct okay excellent um any other discussion all right all those in favor please say I I I motion carries unanimously L the third policy being presented for first read today is policy dcbi public participation in board meetings this is a revision to an existing policy in response to board discussion last month during the regular board meeting that focused on Clarity and consistency of enforcing policy and regulation related to public

184comments specifically the current version of bcbi indicates that procedure shall include a requirement that notice for public comment be given at least 24 hours in advance of the meeting this was not consistent with Georgia law nor our practice therefore the proposed revision eliminates this language may I read the recommendation yes please the recommendation being made is that City schools of the cater Board of Education accept policy bcbi public participation in board meetings for first reading do I have a motion to approve the recommendation to accept policy bcbi for first gr thank Mr H do have a second second thank Anderson second motion any discussion hearing none all those in favor please say I I I carries unanimously relatedly I would like to take a moment to inform the board and the public that staff has

185reviewed an updated regulation BCB R1 which outlines procedures and rules of conduct for public participation in board meetings specifically it was added that prospective speakers are required to sign up at least one hour before the period of public comment is scheduled to begin in practice this would mean that prospective speakers would need to sign up by 5:30 tonight for the 6:30 scheduled start of public comment this evening additionally while the previous version indicated that Personnel individual students and pending litigation are not subject for public participation verbiage was added for added Clarity on Personnel matters the regulation now states that specifically no individual employee shall be named identified or discussed the Redlin version reflecting updates to the regulation is available as an attachment to this agenda item assembly the clean updated regulation is available with all

186other updated or all other adopted policies and regulations in the online policy manual inst simply thank you thank you Miss Lynch and as a point of clarification these become available for comment if anyone the public listening have thoughts or comments on these public comments they will be able to do so in assembly on the policy and assembly for bcbi note that the regulation was updated by staff that does not require public comment because it's a regulation and not a policy awesome we encourage the public review the policies as posted on assembly that concludes our work session and we will return at 5:00 to begin our regular board meeting we are adjourned all right we will now call this meeting to order at 5:00 p.m. we ask that you science your cell phones at this time

187we'll begin with a moment's silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance at this time I ask that everyone join me in a moment of Silent reflection thank you now I ask all who are able to please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America to the stands na indivisible andice for all thank you our mission is to inspire and enable student growth through meaningful and engaging learning experiences supported by highly qualified and caring Educators in a safe and inviting environment uh next item is at this time I will seed control of the meeting to Dr Whitaker to accept nominations for board chair for 2025 thank you chair hearnen are there any motions and um board members you have have ballots in front of you yellow for

188board chair and white for board Vice chair are there any motions from the board for the board chair for 2025 yes I nominate Dr Carmen Sulton for board chair okay board member Dr Carmen Sultan has been nominated for board chair is there a second to that motion second thank you uh board members please complete your ballots this one I am pleased to announce that Dr K Carmen sulon has been elected board chair effective today January the 14 2025 at 5 uh 03 pm. through the upcoming year with a vote of five Z I will now seed the meeting to chair Dr Carmen Falon to accept nominations for vice chair all right are there any nominations for vice chair I nominate Hans SZ for vice chair is there a second I second that motion all right

189board members please complete your ballot what if I wanted to nominate someone else too okay I am pleased to announce that Hans has been elected board Vice chair effective today January 14th 2025 at 5:04 p.m. through the upcoming year with a vote of 520 we will pause for a moment to shift our seats actually so with an odd number now uh I was moved to the middle all righty ready ready board members are there any revisions to the agenda this evening anybody hearing none do I have a motion to approve today's agenda to approve today's agenda all right board member hearen makes the motion do I have a second second uh board member up seconds a motion any discussion hearing none all those in favor motion carries unanimously our next agenda item is the approval

190of the minutes from the previous board meeting do I have a motion to approve December's regular board M minutes do move uh board member us makes the motion do I have a second second board member Johnson Davis seconds the motion is there any discussion right hearing none all those in favor I all right uh Dr Whitaker I see we have some people that have joined us today do we have any recognitions this evening yes chair of Sultan to facilitate tonight's recognitions I would like a call upon Deputy superintendent Karen Newton Scott thank you board chair thank you board chair fers Vice chair SS esteemed members of the board and Dr Whitaker I have the pleasure of making two presentations this evening for fth Avenue Upper Elementary School and deor High School athletics as we honor

191students and staff from each school please do not your seats after instead we'd like you to Stage along the wall to my left and your right for a photo opportunity with our board members at the conclusion of all recognitions first we'd like to invite Dr spru principal of Decor High School Mr Rodney Thomas Decor High School athletics director and Coach William Felton to the front this evening we are excited to football player Evan Fitcher Evan was selected as an Allstate specialist pter for his exceptional performance on the football field being named an all state punter means that Evan is recognized as one of the top punters in the entire State an impressive achievement that reflects his skill consistency and impact on the game what makes this even more remarkable is that Evans has only been

192playing football for two years is that accurate coach yes all right his dedication hard work and Relentless pursuit of improvement combined with the guidance and support of his coaches have made him the only puner in all of five a to earn this distinction Evan is not only a standout athlete but ALS also a great student here at theor high school he truly embodies what it is meant to be a thear bulldog hardworking driven and proud of his school and Community he has made our team our school and our community incredibly proud most of all Evan has made his family proud and we are honored to recognize him tonight please come forward Evan fer next we would like to invite Miss Lyn Hansen principal of fth Avenue Upper Elementary to the front tonight we are highlighting

193a program that was started this year by Miss Edwin Ellis A Links teacher at fa Miss Ellis please join principal Hansen up front Miss Ellis has proudly worked at Bay for 10 years and during this time she observed countless positive interactions between administrators teachers custodians and students with no hesitation the adults at Fai come to the aid of students who might have fallen on the playground had a tough morning and needed some motivation to make it through the day or simply needed help resolving a conflict after seeing this so often Miss Ellis thought why not make it official she and her team launched Falcon friends at face this mentorship program aims to Foster positive relationships between School staff members and students School mentors volunteer their time during the school day to meet with their assigned

194mentees mentors receive weekly guidance and detailed discussion topics to use during M meetups they focus on topics like communication making and maintaining friendships and accountability for ourselves in our action we are so excited about the response to this to this program we also have here tonight mentors within the spous and Friends program and if I miss your name just let me know we won't say wise so we have Sarah guest come up front please Megan Ferguson Courtney Bishop Natasha Kane Ronda Edwards and artia chain I miss you I'm I'm getting to you you're a m right all right here here's your part all right so we also have some of the student mines here tonight please join us up front as I read your experience up first we have Everett Everett is a fourth grader

195and here's what he says about F and Friends [Music] thank you so much children taking it don't let him [Music] you can't come up with descriptions when I speak I never come up with subcriptions really sad but yeah like we come up to like times and fact we had started my group with you had done a puzzle where it was it took us a long time and we were even remember how much but yeah that's really what we do um thank you so much every please stay please stay and also shared that he likes thousand friends because if you have anxiety this is a perfect this is perfect to help solve it if you are ever having a bad day you can be asked to be pulled out forever and maybe others this helps the

196day be better next we have um Clark fifth grade min Clark says that one thing that she loves the most about Baff friends is that she gets to play games with her Mentor Dr McKenzie next up we have Mia Mia is not here but she says What She Likes about Falcon friends is meeting with Miss Sanchez and spending time with her and others in class she also wants to highlight how much Miss Sanchez understands her next we have Val Valentine fifth grade Valentine says that F Falcon friends is great because it helps express feelings students can express their feelings to their mentor and they do so through so many fun activities together and last but not least LEL fourth grade L'Oreal says that she likes sou and friends because it gets you you a chance

197to talk whenever you want or whenever you need to we would like to thank our teachers for their time and effort with the students and also students for honoring your teachers for spending that extra time with you as well at this time we'd like to Round of Applause I'm sorry to [Applause] PA at this time we'd like to inite our board members and Dr whiter down for a photo e e e find on the district's website the third event is for information members of the Board of Education and I will be visiting the Grand Rapids Community College Early Learning laboratory in February to inform our planning design and programming of the new Early Childhood Learning Center while planning to expand our early learning strategy is a long range strategy to achieving Equitable outcomes for all

198students I must clarify what we are required to do now the individ uals with disabilities Education Act Ida requires states to make annual determinations of districts identifying as having disproportionality on January the 26 2024 the state notified the city schools of decator of our FY 24 disproportionality determination the Georgia Department of Education reviews policies procedures and practices for all districts identified as having a disproportionality determination during fy2 24 the city schools of deada receiv received a disproportionality level of being compliant for our review however due to having having seven or more years of significant disproportionality the city schools of the cada re received an onsite visit by the Georgia Department of Education otherwise known as gdau October 30th and 31st of this year it included interviews observations review of lesson plans and surveys out of

199181 school districts you may wonder how many the state is providing targeted assistance to due to this designation that answer is three so how did we get here the city schools of decada Board of Education adopted a fiveyear strategic plan in March of 2023 called all indicator each presentation made by staff includes the alignment to the pillars of the Strategic plan known as strategic accelerators the accelerators are captured on the back of the Strategic plan last year we refined some of the initiatives beneath each of the accelerators and gave the document a facelift but one thing we did not change was the first page the first page is the foundation this slide highlights the five things this board and the community wanted everyone to know about this plan number one it recenters the school district's

200focus on students my question when first reading that was well what were we focused on if not students number two weave Equity into the fabric of everything we do not just discipline not just curriculum but also funding as an example number three reimagine what school looks like to meet the needs of all students oh that sounds like all means all create a space where every student feels included not just belongings and that this strategic plan that was created should incorporate the feedback from all stakeholders throughout deor the five things remained unchanged and underg this strategic plan also in March of 2023 the Board of Education announced me as the sole finalist for superintendent walking into the district I was asked to look into three things instructionally e e e and then after not being in

201school for almost 2 years something in the quote unquote something's wrong with the black student if we know our black student demographic data indicator the black student is also going likely to economic disadvantaged as well so they didn't have access to two years before during or even after the so when we are asked why are we always talking about student data all those test scores and the discipline and why is that always a part of the board meeting at the subgroup level this is why we are now in the process of the um and actually conducted their site visit and we are awaiting their feedback and expect to have ongoing targeted support having been in multiple school districts where gdau provides targeted support in my career I can attest that it will look and feel

202different to the staff of the city schools of the cada I share with this with them and I told them told them it will be different this is not someone else's problem it is our problem we must look at this work as evidence of the inequity of mtss child find evaluations and determinations additional positions will be added to the K5 level two at K2 and one at Rive not at the district level not at the Wilson Center but at the school level to address this inequity at the school level these roles will report to the principal but let me be clear these positions will be filled with individuals who are knowledgeable and courageous enough to facilitate conversations with school staff to ensure that all instructional and behavioral strategies are inclusive and responsive to the needs

203of diverse student populations these positions will be posted in February and I encourage anyone and everyone who has had results in correcting disproportionate outcomes for students to apply I know this board agrees that Equitable outcomes for all students do not equal disproportionality today I've shared quite a bit about the definition of specific learning disability as these remarks transition to Star mid year data I want you to remember that the key to eliminating disproportionality and achieving oural outcomes is understanding who is making progress and at what rate with this Insight schools can strategically address students needs while continuing to support those who have already demonstrated grade level proficiency as we reach the midar mark the star assessment provides a valuable gauge of our progress the results highlight areas where we can celebrate our success and where

204we must intensify support to accelerate growth and our goal of all means all so at this time I invite Deputy superintendent Karen Scott and assistant superintendent Jennifer buron to share a midyear start assessment data and delve deeper into in soon these findings good evening board chair Dr Sulton Vice chair o esteemed board memb student board representative Delena and superintendent Dr gima Whitaker this evening Karen Newton Scott Deputy superintendent and I will provide a mid your update on our students performance across the three assessments administered in our district as you recall this is our first year administering the star assessment for k through eight students previously our students took the math assessment in December the literacy screener Advisory Group who is selected in partnership with the Sandra dunigan deals Center for early learning and literacy released

205a list of four literacy Universal screeners that was recommended one of which was star following that publication State superintendent Woods released the list of five recommended literacy screeners to the State Board of Education that list as well based on these recommendations and in accordance with Senate Bill 464 the State Board of Education released the final approved list which included star star was selected due to its strong psychometric features representative norming accessibility and ease of administrative usage math is not on the approved list the star Suite includes the star early literacy star reading and star math assessments star early literacy is read to all students and assesses foundational literacy skills such as pheic awareness phonics vocabulary and comprehension at the beginning of the school year all kindergarten through third grade students take the star early literacy

206assessment on the computer along with two curriculum based measures or cbms with which a teacher administers the Georgia literacy act requires this combination of assessments if a k through3 student scores 853 or above on the early literacy assessment the student will transition to the star reading assessment and will no longer take STAR early literacy for the remainder of the Academic Year all students in grades 4 through 12 take the star reading assessment three times per year star reading measures word recognition vocabulary and comprehension and it is not read allow students some first through third grade students may also take STAR reading during one of the administrations if they have achieved the qualifying score on the star early literacy assessment additionally all students in grades K through 12 take STAR math three times per year this

207assessment evaluates students mathematical skills across several domains including geometry numbers and operations and algeb Thinking Beyond academic achievement we can examine student growth now that we've had two administrations of the star assessment while it's essential to understand if students are achieving at high levels it is equally if not more important to know if our students are continuing to grow Deputy superintendent Newton Scott will share how star measures grow here we see two athletes one is a novice whose jump increased by 4 Ines over four months the other is an Olympian whose jump increased by one inch the question is whose growth is more impressive at first glance it might seem that athlete 8 has made more significant progress however to truly understand the significance of their achievements we must consider their performance history and peer

208groups similarly knowing the change in a score without context is not helpful in Education Without understanding the context we cannot determine if the growth was expected below expectations or exceptional each student's growth can vary by test subject grade level and prior achievement therefore knowing a student increased score is only part of the picture let's now look at two students these two students both took a fourth grade reading test and scored a 434 which for illustration purposes will consider a high score Jane began the year with a score of 31 and increased by 133 points to achieve the 434 she scored higher than 90% of of students who also started with a score of 301 placing her at the 90th percentile for growth on the other hand Don scored 434 as well but his beginning score

209was 364 he increased by 70 points but many students who started with the score of 364 just like John grew more than he did placing him at the 20th percentile for growth Jane and John are both High Achievers but Jane has shown significant growth while John's growth has been minimal this is how growth is measured on the star assessment each student is compared excuse me to their peers with similar starting scores in the and then blanked as showing low typical or high growth each teacher and principle can also view the entire class to ass to assess which growth quadrant students fall into each bubble represents where an individual student's performance Falls as you can see John is in the low growth high achievement quadrant in the middle we have typical growth to the right we

210have high achievement high growth which is where our example of James Falls and at the bottom two quadrants we have low growth low achievement to the left and high growth low achievement to the right with that in mind let's look at our early literacy assessment as mentioned earlier students who score 853 or higher on the assessment are not required to retake it the green box represents the data from the fall you will see a higher number of students taking early literacy in the fall in comparison to the winter for early literacy 707 K3 students achieved this score in the fall the 853 score and were excluded from the winter results out of a total of 1,220 K3 students 496 in both the fall and the winter for the early literacy assessment among those 496 students

211met or exceeded their growth from fall to winter and 74.7% scored at or above the 40th percentile however it is not appropriate to compare fall to winter proficiency because the number of students taking the assessment fluctuates instead we monit we monitor if students are acquiring the found growth ratees which is what we will examine next here we see the percentage of students in each racial subgroup who demonstrated low typical and high growth for example within the latinx subgroup 36.4 % which represent 16 students do high growth from fall to winter on this assessment 22.7% which represents 10 students demonstrated typical growth in 40.9 percentage which is 18 students exhibited low growth now let's look at star reading a total of 1 156 K5 students took the star reading assessment of these students 72.9% achieved typical

212or high growth from fall to winter Additionally the percentage of students scoring at proficiency increased 81.8% to 82.4% from this point on you will notice red arrows indicating increase declin or if there isn't an arrow it means the score or the percentage stay the same here we also see growth data broken down by rates you will get you will begin to notice a correlation between growth and overall achievement the higher the percentages of students demonstrating typical and high growth the more likely it is that we move the needle for the percentage of students at or above grade level proficiency this data helps us gauge whether we are on track to meet our achievement goals or the spring generally K5 students who took the star reading assessments demonstrated both high achievement and high growth however about

21330% across all subgroups were in the low growth category and that is the matter that we will address next let's examine the results for students in grades 6 through 8 a total of 1,269 students were tested approximately 70% of these students achieved typical or high growth but the overall achievement levels remained relatively the same when we break down growth by race we again see about 30% of our students in each racial subgroup experiencing low growth this suggests that while many students met their growth targets this growth was insufficient to improve achievement levels to raise achievement growth must be accelerated especially for our students in the lower achievement quadrant last but not least let's look at high school results a total of 1698 students took the reading assessment in high school of these 62.7 achieved typical

214or high growth however we did observe a slight decrease in achievement from fall to winter and if we examine our growth data at the subp level we will see slightly larger numbers of students who demonstrated low growth from fall to winter Administration this also suggests that while some students may still be progressing a portion of the student population may need additional support or targeted interventions to accelerate growth and improve overall achievement now let's turn our attention to math outcomes for all K through 12 students starting with the K5 math results a total of 2010 K5 students took the star math assessment of these 72% achieved typical or high growth from fall to winter achievement has increased from 70.8% to 74.7% of students scoring at or above sufficient level when we break down when we break

215down growth by racial groups we see that each group includes students at all three growth levels low cical and high subgroups nearing 80% of students at typical or high growth levels also show achievement for 6 through eight a total of 3.3% achieved typical or high growth achievement also increased here with 73% of student 73% of students scoring at or above the proficient level up from 67.8% in the fall again all but one subgroup of students experience 80 or more students at typical or high growth levels this trend and growth produces Higher Achievement outcomes overall but not for all the data shows us where our work continues to be and for high school grades 9 through 12 from math 1,72 were assessed and 65.7% achieved typical or high growth however the achievement level of all students

216remains unchanged this larger proportion of students in the low growth category across all subgroups which is why overall achievement levels have stay similar overall for both reading and math but overall for math 70.7% of students in CSD are at or above the proficient level in math at the midpoint of this school year additionally 70% of our students are growing at or above typical growth rates in Reading 79% of our students are reading at or above the proficient level for their grade and we're only halfway through the school year this positions us to be on track to exceed our overall reading goals by the end of the year additionally 68% of our Learners are growing at above growing at or above exper Ed rates which is commendable to summarize our mid to summarize our midyear performance

217most of our students are showing growth in reading and math compared to other districts Nationwide that also take STAR assessment we are experiencing high growth rates and high achievement however our local goals are focused on addressing the predictable performance gaps based on race and socioeconomic status while we have seen small pockets of growth we must intensify our efforts to accelerate growth and support our targeted groups of students and achieving at higher levels Mrs Burton will return to give us the next steps for addressing our areas of growth the teaching and learning team have already begun meeting with individual schools to make individual plans for students who did not make adequate growth and are below the 30th percentile as we meet with schools we are looking at each student as an individual we call this putting

218a name and need to each of these numbers that you've been looking at here you'll see up on the screen some examples of things that we've done as a team we've adjusted interventions or increased the amount of time a student is receiving support from from our reading interventionists we've moved an intervention time for a student so it doesn't interfere with their esol services at one school we're starting a Lunch Bunch to increase language skills through a natural construct where language and social skills are modeled attendance concerns have also come up for some of our students and so we're partnering with communities and schools and trying to eliminate any barriers that are preventing our students from attending school and being on time each student has an action plan that's being monitored at the district level so

219we can gather and direct resources that are found centrally our team is in the school co-creating a plan and ensuring the schools have the necessary resources and support to carry out that action the chair pan I have one additional comment the government Finance Officers Association otherwise known as gfoa announced that the city schools of deada received the gfa's distinguished budget presentation award for our FY 2425 budget book the award represents a significant achievement by CSD as it is our first budget book it also reflects the commitment of this governing body this board and staff to meeting the highest principles of governmental budgeting in order to receive the budget award CSD had to satisfy nationally recognized guidelines for effective budget presentation these guidelines are design designed to assess how well our budget serves as a policy

220document a financial plan an operations guide and a communication device budget documents must be rated proficient in all four categories and in 14 mandatory criteria within those categories to receive received the award congratulations to our CFO Dr Broom and her team Chief Communications Miss har marunga and all of the cabinet who supported the creation of our first budget book and its recognition my report Al righty good evening on behalf of the city schools of decator Board of Education I want to wish everyone a Happy New Year and thank you for joining us in person and virtually to learn about the progress of our strategic goals I want to first thank my fellow board members for electing me to chair this distinguished governing body I must also thank board member James hearen for his leadership over

221the past two years I look forward to working with each board member superintendent Dr Whitaker the administration and the CSD students staff and families to achieve positive academic and social emotional outcomes for all students this evening's meeting is our first board meeting of the New Year during the pre-work session we participated in an annual assessment using the gsba governance team assessment which is based in the Georgia state board of education standards while it is not intended to be used as an evaluation instrument this tool provides the board and the superintendent with a status review on implementing identified best governance practices additionally there was continued discussion from the December meeting on protocol regarding staff political activities along with a review of an initial draft of policies related to General Public Relations including possession of weapons by

222visitors the board heard two presentations during the work session during the first one the board and the public received an update update from the newly named safety and Technology services division as the board continues to work towards ensuring competitive compensation for staff the second presentation provided concepts for next year's School salaries the board accepted three policies on drug-free workplaces staff responsibilities to report criminal activity and public participation in board meetings for first read an update to the regulation on public participation in board meetings was also shared the presentations for all board meetings are available on the district's website and sbly every month the board looks forward to celebrating our schools and the achievements of our students and staff at tonight's meeting we recognize an all State athlete from Decor high school and the dedicated members

223of a staff initiated mentorship program at Fifth Avenue Upper Elementary January is National mentoring month so this recognition is very timely we congratulate our students and staff for their achievements now that the second semester is underway I encourage our families and the community to continue to support our students and schools check School newsletters through CSC weekly for upcoming events and activities as I conclude my remarks I have a few few dates that I want to bring to the Public's attention this month CSD will follow the legal procedures for opting out of house bill 581 establishing a Statewide floating homestead exemption and cap on property taxes three public hearings were previously publicized the first was a virtual this morning the second an in-person hybrid meeting will follow today's board meeting the third public hearing will be

224virtual on the evening of January 21st at 6:45 p.m. two additional virtual hearings have been added and publicized for January 30th at 10:00 a.m. and 6:45 p.m. please mark your calendars for the next Board of Education community meeting on January 22nd at 6:45 p.m. at Glennwood Elementary School the agenda will include a discussion on a Georgia Vision project an update on early learning fiscal year 26 budget develop M and Community questions January 30th I will the state finally the next board meeting will be Tuesday February 11th 2025 and that concludes my remarks for this evening board members do you have any thoughts you wish to share no all right Dr Whitaker please introduce this presentation Thank You Cher I would like to call on Dr lunita Broom Chief Financial Officer to introduce our auditing firm

225malen and Jenkins LLC to share the results of our FY 24 audit chair chair up team members of the board board superintendent representative Delena superintendent Dr Whitaker City and colle the district engaged a firm of Malin and Jenkins to perform the annual audit as requ quired by the official code of Georgia annotated 50- 6-6 the audit was conducted in accordance with the generally accepted governmental accounting standard and an unmodified opinion was expressed on the district's Financial St the Youth of a third party or independent auditor ensures a full financial review on an annual basis the finance department then utilizes the information learned from the audit much like schools uses their use their Improvement plans in various assessments to chart a course for improvement over future years I'm happy to say that during the fiscal year

2262024 audit the district did not receive any Finance one item was noted as a constructive recommendation fisal year 20124 fund balance exceeded 15% of the fiscal year 2025 budget by one .7 million moving forward procedures should be in place to ensure the fund balance does not exceed 15% the district has already begun working on ensuring an end ofe actual fund balance below 15% by reallocating fiscal year 2025 midyear request from vacant positions I'm pleased that City schools of Decor continue to enjoy a strong financial position we have seen positive tax dig just grow over the last few years and remain hopeful that it will continue Educational Funding from the state of Georgia is expected to remain at a but we have had an increase in funding due to an increased allocation from the state the

227district remains confident in our ability to maximize resources so that we may provide the best possible educational experience for all our students a copy of the audit report will be provided for public view of the district Finance website if there are no questions Mr Christopher meller partner at Malden and Jenkins will now provide additional details on the district fisal year 2024 Financial all right thank you for having me this evening uh Dr Broom probably took most of my presentation there she did a great job explaining that um but you should have in your uh agenda packet couple of different documents uh one of which is the presentation of the audit results the uh Splash performance audit which is a smaller document and then the thicker of the documents is the annual financial report and I'll

228stick pretty close to the uh presentation of the audit results uh it gives some financial highlights required Communications and then the audit results so on uh slide two here this is some information about Mal and Jenkins and our governmental practice as you can see there we serve over 725 governments throughout the southeast uh we provide over 156,000 hours to our governmental clients and we have 14 offices across Six States um so the audit results as you can see there uh the financial statements are the responsibility of manag man agement and our responsibility as external Auditors is to provide an opinion based on our audit in accordance with uh government auditing standards and generally set of auditing standards as Dr Broom alluded to uh we did Issue an unmodified or clean opinion which means that the

229financial statements present fairly in all material respects uh just a overview of some of the financial highlights this is the entity wide or full acral financial statements which would include Capital assets and long-term debt as opposed to your fund level financial statements as you can see there uh total assets and deferred outflows were approximately 279 million liabilities and deferred inflows were approximately 230 million uh leaving you with a net position of approximately 49 million uh to further break that down uh 9.1 million was restricted for uh certain activities and that's restricted by outside sources and then 132.5 million is net investment in capital assets which is essentially your total Capital assets less any related debt the uh net position did uh decrease by approximately 6.5 million a lot of that I believe is due to

230uh net pension and net ofb liability so nothing to be concerned about there uh we did Issue two compliance reports one of which is uh in accordance with the government auditing standards and the other in accordance with uniform guidance which is your federal expenditures neither of them had any material weaknesses or significant deficiencies so the district should be commended for that uh the management recommendation uh I'll add a little bit to what Dr Broom mentioned so gfoa recommends uh two to 3 months of fund balance U so that's you roughly 17 to 25% the district was within that range uh the state does have a a statute that requires it to be below 15% don't know that uh I would necessarily try to get that load for times where um back in 2008 when the

231financial crisis happened a lot of school districts with lower fund balances uh did have trouble making payroll so it it is uh you know guidelines to follow but gfoa does recommend uh two to three month uh we received full cooperation uh with management and staff Dr Broom and the rest of the finance department they do a great job of having everything prepared for us when we show up any questions that we have they're quick toh provide that to get us in and out just as as quick as POS went went smoothly this year there were no disagreements with Management on any accounting issues or financial reporting matters we did not have any unrecorded or passed adjustments so all adjustments have been posted to the financial statements and we are independent of the school district which

232is required by ascpa uh standards and is what you would want from your external Auditors the next few slides I have here are just some uh charts on how different balances changed but what I'd like management discussion and Analysis which Dr Broom and the finance department uh prepare and it is more of a summary of how balances change and the reasons why those change so I like to point people to that for a summary uh especially if you don't want to read all and something pages of the financial statements that's a good uh five page sum uh that gives you the Highlight uh next I'll just point out uh we we do offer governmental advisory Services as you can see there um one thing that I have seen uh different governments throughout Georgia use as

233our operational assessments uh so just wanted to point that if any of that uh if the need arises for any of that and then next is it and cyber Security Solutions uh with cyber security framework assessments uh system vulnerability and and attrition and next is there's a few slides on upcoming gby pronouncements uh I'll point out one or two of them the first one there statement number 101 with compensated absences this will uh change how compensated absences are reported and potentially will increase the compensated ab's liability it will also include uh any sick Le that may be taken over the next year so this could potentially change that liability and that'll be for fiscal year um and also statement Number 103 uh a lot of this is just it's not necessarily changing any information it's

234just changing where it's reported in the financial statements one thing that I I normally point out is with the budgetary comparison that will now uh the language surrounding any increases or decreases will now be reported in the required supplementary information whereas in the past it was a section that management discussion and anal so nothing sign significant but it will change where some things are believe that's all I have for you this evening unless there are any questions or anything specific on the presentation or uh the financial statements themselves I have one question but I don't think it's for you and I don't know if it's something we need to spend a lot of time on right now so those absences so a teacher could use those collected days retire early and then we the district

235wouldn't be paying but moving forward for 2025 yes any of those acquired sick days are becoming paid days when an employee leaves so that may be a little different if if it's applied to their TRS for early retirement that that's a little different well I want to thank you and but even more importantly I want to thank the board for funding the controller position in FY 24 this position inclusive of our entire Finance team worked diligently to ensure we had an unmodified clean opinion Additionally the budget book award mentioned during my superintendent's comment substantiates our goal of transparency in our finances and with the Early Learning expansion in the next few years St will bring a recommendation for fund balance use thank you thank you all right thank you to the finance team for your

236commitment to Excellence as demonstrated by a clean audit for fiscal year 24 all right board we will now move to the consent agenda items which will include monthly items such as Financial nutrition and Personnel reports I will solicit comments from the board on each item after the item has been discussed it will be moved to consent there will be a motion to accept the consent AG consent agenda at the end of the discussion of all it Dr wher do we have a monthly financial report yes chair saltan Dr lonita Broom Chief Financial Officer will present the monthly financial report the November 2024 Financial reports and definitions of function code are located in assembly agen the finance department operates based on the district's four strategic accelerators with a specific focus on accelerator for organizational Effectiveness and

237Excellence through Financial equity and transfer the general fund budget is 106 million 9624 the budget has increased by $1 16,752 from last month due to the award of the decab local pooling the district collected 39% are approximately $41 million of the budgeted Revenue year to date which is in line with the percentage that was collected this time last year approximately $5 million was collected for the month of November which is 40% more than the amount of Revenue collected for October due primarily to a $1.4 million increase and property tax collect November this increase in property tax is normal at this time of the year last year the increase was $1.6 Million all other revenue is trended has anticipated expenditures are normal for this time of the year the district has expended 36% of the overall

238budget are approximately $36 million year to date for the month of November expenses equated to approximately 8 million this is slightly higher than what was expended last year due primarily to salary and benef increases the majority of November expenditures are for salaries and benefits which make up 87% the budget for the month of November that was a deficit of approximately $3 million which means the district expenditures for the month were $3 million more than the monthly Revenue last year at this time the deficit was $2 million the approximately $3 million has been deducted from the fund balance which is normal for this time of the year overall year to date there's a surplus of approximately $5 million due primarily to the large receipt of property ta tax collection posted in July last year this time

239that was a surplus of approximately $10 million the surplus of Revenue is normal at this time of the year and accounts for the healthy fund balance of approximately $24 million which includes the UN audited beginning fund balance of approximately $19 million the fund balance last year at this time was approximately $25 million please note that the fund balance will continue to decrease as expenditures increase November revenue for Capital and debt funds consisted of 6825 from earnings on investments and splot six collections expenditures are normal for this time of the year and the $2 15,625 million in November fiscal year 25 anticipated expenditures or capital is approximately .7 million special Revenue funds are Grant funds including federal and state grants not budgeted in the general fund we have closed out all of the fiscal year 24

240grants and are continuing to set up the fiscal year 25 grants the district has collected 34% of the anticipated fiscal year 25 grants and expended 31% food nutrition revenue is coming in less than p jeed and expenditures are trending within the same range as previous years the school nutrition budget is being analyzed and will most likely need financial support from the general fund the $299 Surplus for November increased School nutrition fund balance to approximately $2 million last year this time School nutrition fund balance was approximately $ 1.8 million I will be happy to respond to any questions or provide clarification thank you so much Dr Brim any questions or comments from the board all right thank you thank you hearing none uh this item can be moved to consent consent a agenda item number two

241is the school nutrition report are there any comments from the board hearing none uh this item can be moved to consent consent agenda item number three is the Personnel report are there any comments from the board hearing none this item can be moved to consent consent agenda item number four is the midyear budget amendment this presentation was made last month are there any comments from the board hearing none this item can be moved to consent pinent agenda item number five is the decator high school Pac Auditorium seating are there any comments from the board hearing none this item can also be moved to consent Sheriff fton may I read the recommendation yes please I recommend the city schools of theator Board of Education approve the consent agenda items one through five do I have a

242motion to approve the consent agenda items one through five board BS makes the motion do I have a second second board member hearnen second to the motion is there any discussion hearing none all those in favor I I I the motion carries unanimously moving on to policy Dr Whitaker please thank you Sheriff ston I would like to call on Mrs Amanda Lynch Chief of Staff to present four policies for second read actually one I'm sorry not four just one good evening chair ston Vice chair members of the board student representative Delena and superintendent Dr J Whitaker tonight we have one policy for second read action this is policy bbfb governance teams this policy was presented last month for first read and has been available for public comment through assembly no feedback was received through public

243comment and no changes have been made to the version presented last month can I read the recommendation yes please I recommend the city schools of decator Board of Education approved policy bbfb B governance teams for Action I have a motion to policy bbfb governance teams for action move uh board member us makes a motion is there a second second board member Jackson Davis second the motion is there any discussion hearing none all those in favor I the motion carries unanimously we will now get 624 we'll move to public comment at 6:30 we will adjourn and return at 6:30 perfect okay all right we will now move to the public comment portion of our meeting the following information the following information is included in the board policy manual and members of the public when they sign

244up it served as as a reminder for all speakers and members of the audience the opportunity to address the board during public comment is limited to District parents students residents employees businesses and organizations persons wishing to address the board during public comment must sign and before before the public comment period begins and in doing so will be asked to State their connection to Cs and or the city of decar to allow for time for the board's other business public comment will will ordinarily be limited to one hour or 20 speakers at the board's discretion the public comment period may be extended for a specific amount of time or specific number of additional speakers the time limit for all speakers will be three minutes person speaking during public comment will not be permitted to yield the

245floor or transfer unused time to to other speakers comments during public comment should be addressed to the board as a body and not to any individual board member at the chair's Discretions persons violating this policy may be asked to step down speakers should be courteous and professionals speakers are not to list complaints about specific Personnel or individuals connected with the district in in a public session the board strictly prohibits abusive langu Che or shouts from the floor disruptive persons will be asked to leave the meeting room the chair May terminate public comments that are profane vulgar defamatory or disruptive any point speakers comments begin to Verge into areas of hate speech or defamation I will have to ask the speaker to end their comments speakers may not address confidential or Personnel matters but may submit

246such concerns to the superintendent in writing members of the board will not address persons presenting public comments or speak to the substance of any comments made during public comment instead a member of the administrative team will follow up with person speaking at the board meeting Dr Whitaker do we have anybody signed up for public comment yes chair saltan um we do have someone that signed up um a little earlier in the um time frame but they signed up in person David Messer is David Messer online okay the second person that signed up was Brendan BR and my understanding is um Brendan would like to speak actually the hearing that will begin at 6:45 is is that correct okay awesome so then no we don't have any all right can you read that thing again for

247no hor yeah please just that's okay I think you I think you got it the first time all righty well having no speakers we would all like to thank all of our speakers for taking the time to be here tonight um as board members it is important for us to hear the concerns from our communities and we take your comments into consideration um move on to future dates then okay um next Tuesday January 21st at 6:45 we will virtually hold one of three additional House Bill 581 intent to opt out public hearings the final two hearings will take place on Thursday January 30th at 10:00 a.m. and additionally at 6:45 p.m. we will engage with the community in a two-way dialogue via our community meeting on January 22nd um from 6:30 to 8:00 pm at

248Glennwood Elementary topics include our Early Learning Center and fiscal year 26 budget development strategies finally our next board meeting will be held here at the Wilson Center on February 11th there being no further business as meeting is adjourned at 6:34 p.m. we will now call this meeting to order at 6:45 p.m. any locality electing to opt out from the Statewide Homestead homestead exemption as outlined in Georgia code 48-54 4.2 shall conduct a minimum of three public hearings this hearing is similar to public comment at our monthly board meetings therefore members of the board will not address persons commenting or speaking to the substance of comments made during the house bill 581 hearing instead a member of the administrative team will work to follow up with persons commenting or asking questions Dr Broom Chief Financial Officer

249please please proceed with the house bill 581 hearing presentation although the district's intent is to opt out of house beia 581 it has an impact on all four strategic Accel there's a specific focus on organizational Effectiveness and a presentation was presented at the October board meeting which provided a summary of how to be 581 the anticipated Financial impact to the district and the district's intent to opt out of house B 581 is passed House Bill 581 passed in the November 2024 election the purpose of this bill is to amend the Constitution of Georgia to authorize the general assembly to provide by General law for a Statewide Homestead invention that serve to restrict the increases in property tax bills for Homestead Property properties to the rate of overall in inflation there are guidelines and procedures that

250allow County Consolidated Government municipalities or local school systems to opt out of the hous currently the opt out procedures are a one-time requirement and must be completed by March 1st 2025 the decision to opt out is permanent and is only required once the optout procedures include advertising the district to tent to opt out and conducting a minimum of three public hearings to ensure transparency and allow everyone an opportunity to attend and speak at a public hearing the district will conduct five public hearings for house beer 581 andt to opt out today's hearing is the second of five upon completion of the fifth hearing the Board of Education will adopt a resolution and the resolution will be filed with the Secretary of State no later that March 1st 2025 a property tax exemption is a reduction

251or elimination of property taxes on a specific property or for a particular group of property owners the city schools of decada currently offers multiple property tax exemptions for Which Resident Property Owners may qualify included are General exemptions based on ownership and osy as well as exemptions based on age income and disability a homestead exemption reduces the taxable value of your home for example if your home is a praise at $450,000 the assets value is 50% of that amount are $225,000 with a $50,000 Homestead emption you only pay taxes on $175,000 the $50,000 exemption resulted in an annual property tax Savings of $1,015 for the tax Fe currently the district has seven active Homestead exemptions based on various qualifiers consisting of disability and age exclusively and age combined with other qualifiers including income the exemption amount

252range from $110,000 to the full property value being exemp the physical impact to the district is based on the number of property owners that qualified in the exemption taken in The Last 5 Years Homestead exemptions have averaged approximately 6.4 million one is an additional exemption on top of any current exemption for property owners and will result in less revenue for the school district's primary operated budget the general fund the bill will have a large Financial impact on school districts due to school district having a property tax cap that limits their ability to raise local Revenue The Columns for fiscal year 20 through fiscal year 2023 show the actual number of Residential Properties in the city and as shown the numbers of res the number of Residential Properties has slightly increased each year Homestead Properties are

253the total number of property Parcels that are exempt for Homestead purposes the number fluctuates B B on the exemption and the number of property owners that qualify and apply for the exemption the assess value of all Residential Properties in the city of decar has increased from $1.8 million in fiscal year 2020 to$ 2.4 million in fiscal year 2023 the average assess value which is the assess value of all Residential Properties divided by the total number of Residential Properties has range from $46,490 to $314 285 the average asset value multiplied by the eligible Homestead Properties give us an estimated asset value of Homestead propit from fiscal year 24 to 29 I projected the potential Revenue loss for the district based on an estimate consumer price index of 3% please note that the Consumer Price price index

254also referred to as CPI fluctuates and have range has ranged from 1% to 8% in the last seven years I projected 5% for the actual tax digest grow in the last four years the actual tax digest growth has ranged from 5 to 133% based on those projections in a milit rate of 20.30 fisal year 25 potential Revenue loss is approximately half a million dollar and the potential Revenue loss increases each year with a projected Revenue loss of 1.7 million in the year 2029 my numbers are conservative however as shown the actual digest growth rate has traditionally exceeded the CPI rates the reduction in the general fund operational budget from the property tax cap will negatively impact the district's ability to provide adequate Educational Services and competitive salaries overall this could lead to fewer teachers larger

255class sizes deteriorating facilities fewer safety personnel and resources in a decline in overall educational resources State funds will not make up the short B the state has increased the district's Reliance on local funds with unfunded State mandates such as health care cost and increased compensation block funds will not make up a shortfall with the decline in collection of sales tax we have seen a reduction in spot funds approximately 60% of the district's general fund budget is funded through local property tax the cap introduced uncertainties especially in economic down terms if the property tax cap is infored the district may have to consider eliminating current exemptions increasing the millage rate to cover basic expenses are facing the ultimate negative impact of furlows and job cuts the quality of local schools directly impact home values poorly funded

256schools May decrease the attractiveness of a community lower home values could affect broader Community economic health not just individual homeowners while the Cap May save homeowners a small percentage per household on taxes the loss for the school district could be substantial with increases every year and projected increases of over million from fiscal year 27 forward filing to opt out of house 581 will lock the district into potentially damaging Financial constraint voters voted for house F 581 on November 5th 20124 the tenant is an aggressive timeline for action required an advertisement in the local newspaper and on the district's website of the district's intent to op about advertisements advertisement dates announcing the Board of Education intent to opt out were posted on January 9th and will be posted on the 16th 203rd and 30th although only

257three public hearings on the district intent to op out are required the Board of Education will conduct five public hearings today's hearing is the second of five the third hearing and all remaining hearings will be held virtually and the address is listed on the website and I've got resolution will be presented to the board at the February 11th board meeting for board adoption the resolution will be filed on February 13 2025 this concludes the second of five hearings for house be 58 thank you Dr Brim members of the community who would like to provide public comment on this topic May indicate their desire to do so by raising their hand here in the boardroom or by pressing the raised hand icon in Zoom we will conduct imperson public comment first and then transition to public

258comment via Zoom imperson commenters will be asked to complete a sign-in sheet Zoom commenters must ensure that their name in Zoom provides a clear first and last name all public comment participants will be limited to three minutes each chair sulan the first uh person who has signed up is Brendan thank you for allowing me to I'm a little slow on kind of where we're how we got to this point but I thought the the finance director did a great job of kind of explaining that as a taxpayer tax iser a breaking point I I get that there's a threat to the schools um I just the voters just voted for this in favor I don't have the decator numbers but in the C County 58% approved so not sure exactly what the solution is but

259I I would ask you not po out this thank you thank you [Applause] the next person we have is Barney rhods bar I'm sorry my apologies thank you I appreciate the opportunity to speak I did listen to the virtual um online this morning and heard the presentation I'm I'm very concerned concerned about the lack of participation in the one and only inperson um meeting and I wonder that the school system has made it as widely known as I think would be nice for them to know that this meeting was held I don't know what the public newspapers are if it's the champion I don't know whether it's only an online option but if you don't know something's coming up you hardly know to go look for it and also if you don't know something's coming

260out I wouldn't be drawn to look on the School Board website all of that is there but the city of Decor is a much more engaged Community than the three of us represent and I think when we voted in November and said we were in favor of it um it didn't seem to mean anything because I hear that it's already decided that we're going to opt out of it is a fol system and I find that very troubling and the other question and I know you're not going to answer me back is does the city hold a separate series of things is it two different entities that have to opt out since the school system and the city both are part of this system and it's not real clear to me how that works so

261that's thank you thank you the next person we have is Sarah Barefoot I do want to thank you for letting me speak I listened to the zoom call this morning as well and it's troubling to me that 56% of the people's indicator voted for how still 581 and I feel like you're not listening to us um and I am against the school board opting out of it thank you thank you Dr rer do we have public commenters online I do not see anyone with a raised hand there are 10 attendees online um but none of them have raised their hand okay I guess we'll move to a journ thank you for attending the second of five House Bill 581 intent to opt out hearings the board's third house 581 hearing will be held virtually on

262Tuesday January 21st at 6:45 p.m. using the zoom link on the district's website advertisement this meeting is adjourned at 7:00 p.m.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.