001our Board of Education freeor session the board chair James Heen cannot be present today so as a vice chair I will be presiding Dr Whitaker please introduce the first presentation our board meeting Cadence allows board members to prepare for upcoming regular meetings through pre-work sessions the sessions are typically more casual and primarily for information gathering no formal votes will be taken we will begin our pre-work session with our book study for the year the governance core Sophie Sophie De Elena will facilitate chapter four on boarding and welcoming new trustees thank you Sophie for um so chapter four is um onboarding welcoming new trustees um I am a un trusty as student board representative so I felt like this was a good chapter for me but on the first page um there is a claim made
002that one new trustee a new board and I guess my first question is um do you guys agree with this and if so why do you guys agree with I mean you make it so difficult for us to operate under our normal procedures that yes we've had to make huge adjustments to have you on this board no no no I so I do I the point that's made is yes we have to accommodate new people that are on the board I think that that every new perspective means that you think about things in a different way and actually to be totally honest having a student representative on the board has actually forced us to consider things in ways that we maybe haven't thought of before but that's I think a very positive positive aspect of
003of that change yeah I think I agree with the statement in the book I think a new trustee does create a new board um you bring New Perspective um new energy and we have two uh new trustees and so um you know it's a new Administration and uh and I think um these have been uh our new trustees have been great additions um with your the perspectives and the questions that you bring learning opport well I'm the new one um I love I love asking questions I love learning from people and I think it's just because when you do share things I think it helps contextualize or add something um so thank you um somewhere in the book it talks about um how sometimes new board members have you know preconceived ideas about what a
004board is or how a board functions but then when you know they're they've been elected and they're on the board it's surprising or um it's something it's unexpected so I guess my second question is when you were elected is there anything that was surprising about being on a board that you just before yes I mean that the answer to that is a profound yes my primary experience prior to being on a school board with elected bodies were uh City commissions uh uh council members for example and those are legislators that are elected by a specific constituency and that they are responsible to the interests of that specific constituency uh very often defined by what they ran on and it was um jarring to join a school board and find out that actually I don't represent
005any adults in this district and I don't have an adult constituent uh but that actually the students of the district are my constituents and in fact all of the students not just the students that are in my particular district and so that mental shift where where oh wait this is a different job this isn't a group of five individuals representing different constituencies this is or six now actually this is a body of one acting in concert to the benefit of the students of the district that's actually but I'm not sure I'm still there yet it's it's a constant learning process so coming from the classroom it was a huge learning process for me um there was so much about the business side of a school system that I just really didn't know a lot about
006and I was elected in November U 2019 and I was started right away because we had a Schoolboard member who had stepped down and then the pandemic hit a few months later and so I learned a lot really quickly as as you know things were happening with nutrition and we were you know less student you know students Wen in the building so they weren't getting lunches and and you know I just learned so much uh really quickly um and it was quite a learning experience during the pandemic um uh so yeah there was a lot that I had to learn I think um how quickly I think two things the first thing is how quickly you have to learn a lot of information um there's you know multiple areas that make a school board functions
007um some of it is the team team Dynamic some of it is the operations Dynamic even simple things is or um that you I think take for granted like uh how seamlessly the buses run um or that the uh that the lunch lines function seamlessly we take those things for granted but now we have uh insight into how those things run as school board members um so but I think in the first year or so and Tasha white told me this the first year or so you spend understanding how the school board functions and how their school system functions but a year actually is a pretty rapid Pace I think um and I think the other thing is that although we all have individual opinions thoughts strengths weaknesses um we uh we're a a voice
008in a governing body of one um so um I think if you've been in other leadership positions or if we serve in other boards or in other um governing capacities that can feel a little different um and um when you are in this capacity you're uh one you have to do one unifying voice which um I think is is a different type of leadership skill that that you have to learn fored I think like Dr Johnson the um classroom experience and I think being a teacher really has helped understand that I'm working for students so that's not an issue um and I feel like I paid a lot of attention to school district things before but definitely making decisions and looking at things from a kind of long range systemwide is definitely different from even
009planning the school year and looking what are the outcomes at the end so I think paying attention to that and reprogramming some of that while still paying attention in the classroom um was probably the biggest leing ship for me um and then the chapter also speaks about governance culture um so my last question is with the addition of a board of education student Representatives um do you guys think that governance culture has changed at all I think that really good question actually so I'm going to be brainstorming it as I speak out loud so bear with me but I think the the biggest shift from my perspective culturally is that um while we are uh in theory always focused on and our role is really focused on on serving the students it can be extremely
010easy to get distracted by you know the latest nutrition report or the you know bus schedule from Transportation or you know some of the operational details that get presented to us and not necessarily be thinking absolutely at the student level and I think having you on this board like constantly reinforces how does this impact a student how would I think about this to best impact a student and how is uh whatever the information being presented how does this ultimately Drive successful outcomes for students it is very uh in a way focusing and so I think that's in my mind probably the one of the biggest benefits of having you I think essentially the government does not change but having your perspective on the board just um increases our efficacy um um but I think you
011know we have you know policies that we you know agree on we have these board Norms that we agree on most things that you know are our guard rails um and those things ultimately stay the same um but I think your your you know the perspective of a student representative and a new board member you know just increases um you know the opportunities to to be even better I agree with that I think it's um it's perspective um I am an Inquirer by Nature um I like to ask questions I like your storing that sometimes bothers people namely Hans because question but also I'm I have four kids and having kids in the school system where you know when I feel like I've made a decision and I don't really quite understand what how that
012decision has landed or how it's going to be implemented or how it hit I would go back and I ask I asked them um well you know what did what happened with you know with the school lunch policy are people talking about this you know and I think having a somebody that's not my own advisory Council I my own children um I think is is also helpful for perspective I think it's been a couple of times that I've met with Dr Whitaker who's made a decision I'm like did somebody ask Sophie what she knows um or did somebody ask Sophie what she thinks and um I think having not always looking through something or our decision making through an adult lens because that's all we know at this point we only know what we see
013or feel or through our own perspective but having that um alternative perspective um about how the decisions we make actually directly impact our our constituents which is our children um I think it's helpful and then having somebody who can give us direct direct you asked about change I didn't really see it but I think the discussion one of the first discussions we had about how um for our norms for you right and what was acceptable in terms of asking you a question in spee I hope exemplifies how we work as a board so that you know this person asked a question this person provides this Contex someone else asked a question and so I think just through that there are natural changes that take place so um does anyone else have any about the chapter
014in this book I could I ask the two new board members a question CH uh and actually uh board member Anderson I'm going to ask you to answer first so that we we give board member Dela a moment to think about it yeah how could we do better on boarding yall next time if there were to be one you know I've been thinking about that um sh I know I know you know it's the nature of me as a teacher I'm always like what could I have done differently and better not that it's better just what could be improved on um and I don't know how to answer it directly yet because I've been thinking about it a lot um I think the orientation that I had was phenomenal right um I really appreciate it
015and I know y'all were so patient because I ask questions probably of each of you because I like to think I know what I'm doing even if I'm still learning as I'm doing it um but I have to get back to you with the other stuff because I think it is something we should talk about sure um I would say probably familiarizing myself with the Strategic plan because I know like on the slide shows when it goes on and you know all there's all it's everything is driven with the Strategic plan um so if I was if I knew a little bit more about you know the end goal or you know the different areas of the Strategic plan and how everything fits under it I think that would make understanding for the board board
016decision thank you I okay anyway I had a question um this was on well page starts on page 83 then page 84 um about having a full discussion with the board and going through the governance handbook and so I was like did we do that um I know that we had and and so then I got confused on time I know we had gsba training at the beginning of the year but then I don't think you were here yet so so I don't know and I read that as well when it talks about the governance handbook I said I think we can say yes we have Norms but that there is a governance handbook discussed in chapter eight so what that meant for me at the top of 84 I said oh well I guess
017when we get to chapter8 maybe that will be some of the things that we can do to work to improve the board maybe it is to create their handbook I know at the retreat last week or not last week you know couple weeks ago what was also stated that um we should have maybe job descriptions for chair and vice chair so that could be like the first step and then we can really cify all of it into a handbook so I thought about that and it giv us some samples in chapter eight I didn't like go read ahead but I was curious about it that's definitely not not that I'm going to suggest we add meetings to our December schedule so I'll just be very clear the breathing a time of relief there but I
018think in having a conversation as a board about the Strategic plan where it came from what are perspectives on each of initiatives are uh that you know killing two birds with one stone really basically what what board member of Atlanta just suggested and and as a part of the onboarding process just really kind of touching base with our the moral imperative and our core purpose over the next number of years I think that would be a beneficial conversation yeah because I think I didn't share like you some of you were so helpful in prepping me like individually and then I think what I remember is in January we had a discussion of our Norms right and so what I was thinking is maybe there is another meeting but no way do we want a meeting
019but um there were lots of things that worked really well so um not to take away from what Dr sulon was about to say but next month we will start out with the self assessment again in January because it'll be a year since we've taken the self assessment and then um and then also in February at the February board retreat it is taking a look at our kpis and also the kpis come from the Strategic plan because there is to be a quarterly discussion on it so I know that is on the February agenda for our Retreat to the extent that any of that is executive session I would request of the board that we wave the um requirement that or that we permit uh board members Elena to attend Those portions of the session
020yeah if it if it I don't know if it is but the Strategic plan is is not an executive session item the board our evaluation of ourselves good that is all for the discussion thank you thank you Sophie for facilitating today next month as we mentioned we will not engage in a chapter of the governance core instead we will complete a gsba board self assessment board members please complete the board self assessment assembly prior to the meeting and we will discuss it in January Dr Whitaker please introduce the next item thank you Vice chair sulon I would like to call on Mrs Amanda Lynch Chief of Staff to seek your feedback on three personnel policy drafts good afternoon acting chair sulon Este members of the board student representative Delena and superintendent Dr J Whitaker in
021accordance with the 2024 2025 policy calendar Personnel is scheduled for pre-work in the month of December today we have three policies on this pre-work agenda from these area g ma drug-free workplace which is a revision to an existing policy GB step political activities and GC responsibility to report criminal charges to employers as a reminder to the public policies that are presented during pre-work are new business on which we are speaking board input these policies are being presented as initial draft they are being shared to gather board input and feedback that can be reflected in drafting or revising future versions I will also invite Adena Walker chief of Human Resources to join me upfront so that she can be available that help answer any questions on these Personnel policies that may come up during discussion first
022policy G is an existing policy it was already in place and was adopted by the Board of Education in November of 2022 a need to add additional language around Reasonable Suspicion was identified which is what is being presented for feedback tonight as an existing policy an environmental scan of other District policies was not provided to the board rather the proposed additional language was shared we have provided the Gama policies for D Cab County and Clayton County for board members at their seats tonight as other District samples however for our revised draft the added language defines Reasonable Suspicion and allows for drug and or alcohol testing when Reasonable Suspicion exists that an employee is under the influence of a controlled substance or alcohol while performing their duties on behalf of the district the new language indicates
023the superintendent shall develop procedures for conducting Reasonable Suspicion drugs and alcohol testing and states that refusal to participate in Reasonable Suspicion testing will res will result in termination at this time I welcome any board input or feedback for policy Gama drug-free workplace if someone has has a legal prescription for medical marijuana how do we know and how are we able to right so I understand they cannot use it while in the workplace but if they test for it and they haven't used it you know over a period of time it's still going to show up positive how do we how do we manage that difference well depending on what their their actions are if you were buing them in the workplace then that would be something that would disclose to us and then we would
024take that into consideration of what why we are testing it if theyr or anything like that then that's when we have to work through but if they have their their ediction then that's something that we need to [Music] be is that that something that's managed in regulations or it's not obviously a policy but if the next tear down is that that what I'm hearing that would be that would be explained in and is reasonable suspicions based on the discretion of the principal or do they have to have some kind of second check by an administrator or how do you how does that exactly normally if something comes to our um attention it may be a coworker that that's reporting it but of course as a supervisor they will have to be the one to observe
025um observe their actions within the workplace is it in altering their ability to do their job and then they will just contact see meaning H yes okay thank you this is just kind of toy backing on hans's question so I understand you know we're governance and we Pro the policy but the policy allowing process and so I think to hans's question I just I'm still unclear in the event that someone is behaving suspiciously and they don't want to take that like what is there a particular metric like I know for alcohol there's like a blood alcohol level I don't I should know nothing about what the testing would reveal who I guess I'm still asking your question well the development of the procedure because this is changing the policy so very similar to how when
026we approve the uh policy on demonstration and Strikes you first you approve the policy and then we write the regulation that goes to the policy and go on and then we to our department to exactly what the legal um amounts are and then we but as proposed it's adding that reasonable suspicion piece to it that allows for testing when Reasonable Suspicion finds it allows for the testing and Bor I want you and board I want you to know that we have dealt with this on more than one occasion in my ERS which is why there that is being suggested as a CH as a change to the policy I have a question does the teacher get to if there's reasonable suspicion does the teacher get removed like up until the 10 I don't know I
027guess like what when is the teacher staying and then like leaving or when can they come back so if there's Reasonable Suspicion and feel free to jump it I'm going to do my best here but you guys can see why I brought uh Miss Walker up here um but of course if it's if there's suspicion the teacher would be removed from the students because of a safety perspective this allows the testing to take place usually the testing takes place pretty immediately um and this does allow that if the teacher refused testing it could result in disciplinary action up to an including termination all right three more next up is policy gahb staff political activities this is a new policy for consideration when the policy audit was conducted last year three of our five Benchmark districts
028had this policy in place we also recognize that our Community Values Civic engagement and having a policy for staff political activity will provide important guidance for CSD employees board members were provided with sample policies from other districts as part of the environmental scan that was conducted and drafting this initial policy as drafted this policy states the Board of Education recognizes employees have the same Civic privileges as other citizens including campaigning holding office and supporting candidates in causes in the political Arena however it also states that the Boe recognizes that employees must uphold public trust in their political involvement must not interfere or conflict with job duties and responsibilities the policy provides key definitions that are addressed in the policy including employee District facilities and equipment or resources detailed guidance is provided for employee participation in
029political activity the guidance prohibits the use of District facilities or resources and employee work time to promote political candidates it states that employees shall not display political pictures signs posters which includes attire during normal business hours or while performing job duties the policy does state employees May Express opinions privately and publicly on political subjects issues and candidates but should do so as individuals outside of their capacity as a district employee when doing so employees engaging in political activity shall make it clear that they are speaking and acting as an individual and that they do not represent the city schools of decada the policy also allows for employees to be candidates for the board of education but indicate that they must not continue employment of this of the same district while serving as a Boe member
030this policy allows for disciplinary action for employees in violation of the policy finally exceptions are also included among these are allowing political activities within the instructional program such as mock elections and EXP explicitly stating that employees May Place political advertising on their personal vehicles at this time I welcome any board input for policy gahb staff political activities I wanted to get clarification on the term political are we talking about just in terms of folks running for offices are we talking about issues that um can be deemed political um how do we how are we defining political yeah so that's not one of the definitions that we currently have in there um we do talk about c a political candidate specifically so that is something that would be covered there are places in here where I
031want to get the words right but I think it says um political issues yeah issues when I saw issues I was like oh this is more than just a person let me ask an next explicit question on this point would someone advocating for Israel or Palestine fall under a political issue in this or you know um gay pride yes or abortion abortion um all of these are things that this board would need to determine I suspect that this policy is going to have to in a work session for a while there's going to there's a lot for us to figure out here sure I yeah you go ahead um one of the points says that employees shall not display any political pictures signs posters badges but like what about like Flags in the room right
032I I underlined that that was one of the things I was you know yeah you know so it's like where is the line drawn that kind I think I was thinking of two things so if I read this correctly an employee for example you know has their car they can have whatever they want on the car right um they may be a CSD employee but you within reasonable kind of behavior here so it sounds like then what we're doing is looking more specifically at in Your Capacity as a teacher in your work capacity as an administrator do we want and how do we want to Define what constitutes a political activity and therefore be displayed in a classroom what is allowable to be worn what is allowable I mean that's really what we're going to
033have to decide right correct exactly which I mean if it matters I I think we are um I like that CSC already respects employees because I know some school districts don't give employees as much um I don't know what now to use um but I appreciate that we might need to clarify a little of this not to oversimplify the matter but I kind of read this looking at that first bullet point as kind of civic duty so running for office um advocating for a candidate in office less so into the arena of um yeah political issues or um kind of that sort of or really kind of getting into the arena of your free speech um so that I read this when I was reading this over really read this as if you were running
034for office as a private citizen or if you wanted to put your political beliefs or who you were voting for on display um like what the rules work for you can't use a company copier to copy your political Flyers um that was kind of what I was reading into that um not to over simplify the issue but that was how I was reading it this is in front of us for a reason right and so what is the objective that we are trying to resolve with this in front of us now I think it's to clarify where the board stands on political staff political activity so that we can use it to inform revision so that we can work it through the through the process and it's the desire of the board to so adopt
035my second question is in the fourth bullet where it says the second phrase the use of District facilities or resources and employee work time to promote political candidates is restricted is there a reason why we limited it to candidates and not just generalized political activity so that's a great point that could be clarified I mean we do have I think elections next fall and so I can see why we do want to has um some policies governing how we're doing things so that as well so um that was something that did come up I know Miss Anderson when you were uh running for the board there was questions around some things that needed to be clarified not necessarily in G but and just it lives in G because it has to deal with politics right
036so is is it safe to say that we probably need a focused work session on this particular thing similar to as we did with uh nutrition nutrition nutrition student launch yeah perfect I would say I think we probably need to have a much larger conversation about this great well I challenge you in the meantime to manate on your thoughts and I will bring together a structured protocol for us to work through um where we stand all right we're not done yet though we still have one more our third and Fin policy for pre-work today is policy GC responsibility to report criminal charges to employer this is a new policy this policy requires employers employees to report events related to criminal charges and report them to the superintendent and the chief of human res reported within
037five days of its occurrence know that that five is a change from the previous draft that you saw that said three to allow because it's calendar days so to allow for weekend and things like that five is one adjustment that has been made to the language the policy exempts minor traffic violations such as speeding or parking tickets from reporting a failure to report any of the listed circumstances or events May result in disciplinary action the policy is drafted also includes a section on sexually inappropriate conduct explicitly stating that violations of the policy and the Georgia Code of a staff member toward a student would be grounded for disciplinary action including discharge at this time i' welcome any board feedback for policy gamc responsibility to report criminal charges to employer I forget what the term is
038but but like we're informed about something that happens to a student we're a mandated reporter does this create a mandated reporter we're already under that law anyway we already got mandated reporter this is um for employees self-reporting any kind of criminal charges or things like that um the speically so if I am a teacher and one of my co-workers takes me into confidence about a um sexual harassment or something that is egregious they've taken me into their confidence am I now mandated to report that to you only if that act is okay so so this then if I find out about something Criminal but it didn't happen to me I don't have to report it to you interaction that's not what this looks like this looks like it's saying that if I find out about
039something criminal I do have to report it to you this this is self-re self is if you're this weend you know you you're arrested for for something then you would have to let us know that that has has that first bullet is worded where it says employees to report it's really the employe any employee in the way that's written in the draft that is so on and so forth um for a crime um shall report each and all of these events so it's really the self-reporting aspect now question um okay so one I think this is kind of the the guard rails we have because you know we're certified or employeed so therefore PSC already knows for a new employee who's apply but once someone is certified before they're renewed so there's a fiveyear window
040okay I that makes perfect sense but now Hans has introduced a question that maybe it's a PSC question more than a CSD question because if we are now told of a not to say alleged okay but and I think we I don't know maybe we need Clarity on that one since he's introduced it adult so as a mandated reporter we must report anything on children but if someone tells me this is what has happened in their home I I don't have a I'm not saying that that has to be reported because we're talking about two adults that that's not our pervie me to take us way off line here but it just occurred to me um is board member of the Elena now a mandated reporter no she's not team that would be a responsibility
041that you should know that all right thank you very much so we will bring back Gama and GC uh moving forward for work session for next month GB will be a pro structured protocol um build thank you Miss Lynch we look forward to the conversation next month in our work session on these policies thank you board members for the discussion this concludes our pre-work session we return for the work session we move right into the work session okay all right thank you for joining us today for our monthly work session the board chair Dr James Jen curin cannot be present today so as the vice chair I will be presiding Dr Whitaker please introduce our first presentation thank you Vice chair Sulton I would like to call on Mrs Francis Hull assistant superintendent of student
042Support Services to Prov by the state of the division for 2024 afternoon SP Care Dr Su esteem members of the board student board representative Delena superintendent Dr Social Work wraparound Services diator student centers Section 504 School psychology esol Federal program special education behavior intervention and student code of conduct are the support areas housed within the student Support Services Division this division was created in January 2024 with a focus on aligning and enhancing existing Support Services across the district the scope is both deep and wide since there is not enough time today to give you updates on every aspect this afternoon you will hear about areas of focus associated with strategic goals and key actions that have been or are being taken to continue to strengthen support systems many of the artifacts of our comprehensive work
043align with the building and sustaining and engaging an inclusive culture accelerator however deep down we know that our division touches all areas of the Strategic plan after the September board meeting with your support we launched the design n year of a comprehensive social emotional learning seal framework I am pleased to report that we are on track with the timeline for delivering for deliverables related to the if in our seal theory of action as you know a comprehensive needs assessment was conducted to evaluate past and current seal practices in CSD key insights were obtained which help us understand successes challenges and growth areas the results of this assessment will also inform future components of our seal work as we bring the theory of action to life you have a copy of the CNA results provided as
044an addendum to this presentation the CNA results have been analyzed by various groups including all principles and all of the superintendent Council groups not surprisingly the most enlightening analysis and recommendations have come from the student reminding us that student voice is key in this process Additionally the student council group participated in informing the development of seal standards and have provided us feedback on how we can Implement a comprehensive framework by the end of this month we will have finalized the 612 CSD secl standard and we'll have a newly selected high quality evidence-based curriculum next next semester among other things we will finalize the 612 Logistics develop Scopes and sequences and select a K5 the K5 standards as you will see in my upcoming slides the launch of the secl framework could not have come soon
045enough as our discipline data continues to validate that the effective needs of our students are not yet fully met overwhelming overwhelmingly the stakeholders have told us that we need to have consistent implementation ofcl programming across schools in order to address uneven experiences for students students moments of social emotional learning instead we need momentum by ensuring that seal is Thoroughly integrated within the school day mixing with academics and providing opportunities to practice skills with a curriculum that adapts to the student developmental me at the end of last school year the total number of ISS and OSS incidents was 366 noting that we are tracking completed referrals from July 30th to November 4th 166 incidents resulted in ISS or OSS we also know that ISS for half a day or less is not included in this data
046as this data only reflect reflects State reportable ISS and assess the breakdown by school is deor high school 133 Deacon Hill Middle School 18 Upper Elementary 9 lower elementary six the key takeaway is that in comparison to last school year osss and say incidents remained overall stagnant as well as disability as shown on the graph you can see that the majority of incidents resulted in a resolution of ISS and that OS the breakdown by race shows that black students continue to be involved in greater numbers of discipline related incidents than white students however both black and white students are being suspended in greater numbers than last year this increase can be explained by how CSD like many other districts are responding firmly to serious and chronic behaviors after the tragedy in appalache at the beginning
047of this school year even so our goal is to reduce ISS and OSS combined incidents by 5% for black students and students with disabilities this continued as does our commitment to support schools in improving their school climate at the end of last year we met this goal and we were able to decrease combined incidents for black students by 133% and 5% for students with disabilities the total from the end of last year are our Baseline Baseline numbers for this year to reach another 5% reduction our goal is to have no more than 242 combined incidents for black students and 105 incidents for students with disability the actions in place to support schools with this goal include training for all School administrators on the newly Revised Code of Conduct which includes a rationale for exclusionary discipline
048and a continuation of disciplined consultation required for all out of school suspensions as well as any in school suspension Beyond two days school teams continue to examine internal practices around multier system of support and problem solving Behavior concerns with the use of evidence-based behavioral interventions to teach alternative Behavior lastly to build the capacity of school-based Staff teachers and bus drivers to understand and better respond with empathy to students who have been impacted by trauma CSD partnered with the Georgia Center for Child Advocacy and trained Select school-based Staff to be trainers in tra in the trauma informed curriculum called connections matter we are also strengthening tier one by continuing to work on creating positive School climates at each school by implementing positive behavioral interventions and support Evis each schol year the Georgia Department of Education recognizes
049districts and schools that exemplify best practices in the implementation of pvis this year six CSD schools Claremont oper Winona Park Glenwood Westchester and Beacon Hill achieved operational status being recognized as having operational status means that those schools met four out of four outcome data measures pertaining to the percentage of students at tier one for State Rep reportable office of discipline referrals or odrs the number of State reportable odrs per 100 students the number of ISS days per 100 students and the number of OSS days per 100 students as evidenced by the growth in the number of schools participating and the number of schools that have achieved the 80% staff participation rate on the self assessment survey School staff and administrators realize the importance of their input in positively influence influencing School climate additionally oakers and
050Westchester have are eligible to participate in a three-part training that teaches PBIS teams how to establish systems and data components needed to ensure that tier one classroom PBIS practices are implemented with Fidelity and finally also this year CC has worked in collabor in collaboration with the Georgia Department of Education and mria to begin planning towards Georgia mtss which is a multi-level prevention system designed to meet the needs of the whole Child by implementing a Continuum of tier supports for Behavior academics and well-being while this year is our planning year we expect to fully transition towards gtss at the beginning of next school year for the third consecutive year CSD has utilized the Third Edition of the behavior assessment system for children behavioral and emotional screening systems for the B three bets the screen for em
051social emotional and behavioral risk in students the data for this screener creates an evidence-based pathway for students to receive additional support provides information that helps schools Focus their efforts time and resources on students who have the greatest needs and Aid School in making big picture programming decisions to support students the best is a screener that helps put students on the radar of Staff who students who might not otherwise be there as we add additional grade levels to the administrations we strive to keep participation ratees at 90% or higher and as you can see we're meeting this goal the fall administration of the best just occurred from October to November for all students in grade 3 4 6 79 and 10 on this graph you can see that more students screen at at normal risk and
052fewer screen as elevated risk and extremely elevated risk in comparison to previous administrations following each Administration members of the student Support Services team at the school level follow up with students who have been rated elevated extremely elevated for risk contact families and discuss screening outcomes and make referrals as appropriate for support staff or Community Support the CSD wraparound supports team is comprised of 19 school counselors four Student Center counselors and four social workers the school counselors and Student Center counselors have tailored support by creating a pyramid of services to meet the needs of all students in an effort to better serve the CSD students and their families C the council referral process has been streamlined this year to ensure that students with the greatest needs are afforded the opportunity to meet with their counselor in
053a timely manner school counselors participate in an array of professional learning to ensure that their skill levels quit to the service needs of the student this year one such training was the applied suicide intervention skills training or assist which empowers counselors with the tools to help keep students safe one once and if they verbalized thoughts or planned action for suicide School social workers have immersed themselves in multiple aspects of student and family support but this year their focus has been primarily on school needs and providing targeted attendance support District Personnel have been working to strengthen the provision of wraparound Services across the district by creating standard operating procedures for threat assessments and B alerts revisiting a comprehensive mandated reporter protocol and offering multiple parent engagement and education opportunities two recent opportunities include a workshop on
054the bass three best and the drug awareness parent seminar which occurred during Red Ribbon Week the English to speakers of other languages esol and federal programs Department Provide support that oversees Federal funded Grant programs of Title One 2 3 4 esol and mcken vento also the department is currently managing a grant from the office of refugee settlement to support Refugee families within our community title one provides extra intervention for students identified via academic needs with Success measur Through progress monitoring monitoring and Universal screeners boards this slide shows a percentage the students receiving Title One support and meeting the map growth targets at the end of last school year in an effort to better align this with the needs of each School Title One plans were developed collaboratively with the principles and in conjunction with each
055schol Improvement goal Title One grants funds are currently allowing us to serve students at Claremont and tally in reading and or math in ESO well we have approximately 112 K2 students with the top three languages being Arabic Dari and farsy different languages but both from Afghanistan and Somali the results here indicate that 69% of students in our esol program are showing typical or high growth as compared to their peers on the access test a Georgia annually required Assessments in an effort to continue to increase quality instructure for the students in this program the department adopted the English briefy a K12 English language development program that help students build academic language in writing discourse vocabulary and communication and mcken vento which ensures enrollment and support for students experiencing homelessness also providing resources to remove educational barriers
056another area in our department recently we have updated the needs assessment to identify challenges and prioritize the needs of students and their families who are served in this program a new referral form is now available and at this point in the year we have about 50 students K12 students served under M the special education department in the city schools of deor is serving approximately 540 students at this time with top three identified disabilities being specific learning disabilities other health impairments and autism these categories represent a diverse group of students with unique needs and our department is committed to providing individualized support to ensure their academic and social success for this school year we are focusing on several key initiatives aimed at improving student outcomes first we are proud to announce that we are now in
057ACC credit a special education accredited District this distinction allows us to actively involve our students in a range of athletic abilities fostering both physical development developmental and social skills students will have the chance to participate in various Sports gain confidence and develop teamwork abilities these efforts will culminate In a districtwide Special Olympics event scheduled for March 2025 next in alignment with the science of reading the department has begun implementing decodable readers from Just Right readers these resources are aligned to improve are designed to improve foundational reading skills for students pre through seventh grade as well as being used in our adaptive curriculum classro K2 decodable readers provide structured accessible reading materials that allow the students to apply phonic skills in a meaningful way promoting reading fluency and comprehension this program is especially important for those
058students who Str reading strategies ensuring that they have access to materials that meet their developmental needs and abilities the department is also implementing the council for exceptional children's vetted life curriculum transition program this curriculum includes vocational training Independent Living skills and community- based instruction to ensure that students with the most significant disabilities are prepared for Life Beyond School whether that would be to further education employment or Independent Living we are also understanding the importance of supporting our teachers particularly in where staff turnover rates are high and can impact student progress to address this with the support of mrisa we are prior izing teacher retention by offering targeted professional development and mentorship opportunities so that Educators feel supported and confident in their role for Section 504 in school psychology CSD is currently serving about 56 students
059with 504 plans is about 9% of our student population 77% of the students are in the secondary grade 18% in Upper Elementary and 5% in lower elementary the top three areas for 504 impairments are other health impairments sorry excuse me ADHD other slmed and specific learning disabilities or dyslexia at the beginning of the school year we rolled out a new 54 module and our student information system that give schools more insight and Technical efficiency to write Implement and monitor plans as well as accommodations in the area of school psychology the district currently employs six olist because this is an area of high demand nationally CSD has maintained a partnership with Georgia State University to place school psychology interns and practicum students we currently have a doctoral level practicum student place within our department last year
060our school psychologist completed almost 200 comprehensive evaluations this is an increase of 17 from the year before and the number one disability identified is specifically learning disabilities followed by speech language impairment and other health impairments this school year the department is focused on creating uniform practices across all grade levels and schools to ensure Equitable decision making in the identification process we also continue to contract with independent school psychologists to help us manage and meet these deadlines in closing I would like to say that I'm grateful for the dedicated and hardworking team that keep students at the center I hope that this presentation has provided you with an overview of the important work being done and or supported by my division you have any questions um so first just thank you for all of the work
061on this a lot of this is fantastic and I know it's been stuff we've really wanted to see happen for quite some time so really appreciate C work on um can we quickly take a look at slide four um the one thing that stood out to me was that osss and ISS data does not include less than a full day of ISS um and so the the real metric that we care about here is really hours out of the classroom right it's non-instruction time so what can we do and I this is broadly asking everyone I think but what can we do to get to that refined piece of information that that really tracking how many hours the these kids are not in instruction due to discipline which is which is really what we're trying
062to end that on from a student information standpoint that is not necessarily tracked because for student record that we're required by by Georgia doe to report what we report um it would be hard to measure we can't measure and that's why we're trying to clean this data up because if we do that we are in violation of student record and creating errors at the state if that makes sense yeah I I would not remotely suggest that we try to record this information to also report to the state that's not that's not what I mean but from an internal standpoint if we if really what we're trying to affect is the amount of time those students are outside of the classroom we should figure out how to evaluate how long those students are outside of the
063classroom not not from a regulatory reporting standpoint but this is just for our own ability to uh improve something that we want to would the Swift system have that data the is telling us um using the pvis telling us where incidents are happening the teams can then look at that and say okay we're having a lot of incidents in the cafeteria at 8:00 in the morning um but it doesn't necessarily track how long or when a student is outside the but do we do we put the consequences in twist there there are consequences in twist but they are report to the state but so I am not looking for something that we report to the state this is for us internal if we are tracking that in Swiss can we get to that level of
064detail to be able it's not the time out the classroom is not within with so I I'll be honest in PBIS World your time out of classroom is not the key performance indicator to determine whether or not you are operational or distinguished that's not one of those that's not the the Journey or the path and I do not know of a system that says let me know how many hours a child is is out of the classroom outside of what is required for State reporting or putting in a different system so that would mean a third system for and so that's why I was like yeah I'm not actually pressing for a solution here what I am challenging the administration to do our objective as a board I don't mean to speak for the board
065so y'all step in but our objective as a board is to lessen disperate discipline outcomes and it is evident that we are actually not capturing all discipline outcomes and so what I would want to avoid is a scenario where instead of giving full ISS we do partial ISS because I know that doesn't have to be reported but actually the kids out of the classroom for the same amount of time anyway there is a need I think to close that little bit of a loop not for the state again but just internally so that we know that we're moving it in the right direction think maybe what I'm hearing is when kids get ISS and OSS maybe that that's a little bit straight more straightforward maybe we can use the code of conduct as a guideline
066to figure out how those children are ending up in the in with that as a disciplinary measure and there's truth be told there's some of them are it's the recidivism rate is high so sometimes it's you know 30% of these kids are are turning back and forth not a good thing but it is the data that shows but I'm unclear how an administrator a principal or a teacher would decide what how a kid gets a half day which those numbers fall through those cracks versus a full day um so what would be the difference and then maybe if we understood that we could figure out because you could get two half days um and then you we wouldn't know if you were in that that repeat offender kind of cohort um and we also wouldn't
067know you wouldn't get into these numbers at all so I don't know if there's a way to know how teachers or administrators are deciding whether to do a half day or a full day or if that's eded in the code of conduct that's legitimately question yeah so so I want I want to clarify one thing that half a day ISS can be reportable if it's tied to a state reportable action so that is part of the data cleanup that Dr Whitaker just spoke about and I'm working very closely with our new director for data to make sure that those things are being addressed um however in general uh administrators are looking at the time of day when the incident occurs if it's happening towards the end of the day it might be if the last
068period and student is referred to ISS then it's less than half a day right um then there there're still going through the consultation process where they right now have to call me because I have a vacancy in my department but we talk through that like what part of the day is ISS and what is tomorrow going to be and when is the student returning and what's being done when the student returns you know are they going to the Student Center or what other activities are happening to make sure that the right support team is involved so um it does depend on time of day maybe the particular class there are students that can go to is for a period and then return ACC so that is part of that um again assuming that it's not
069a state reportable incident that we we have to go ahead and report and that clean up is but but we are able to record when a less than full day ISS happens so why would we just not make it as a matter of practice to always record that even if we aren't having to send it to the state again I don't I don't want to go down that but why would we not just know that we have this number of less than all day ISS I do have that I mean we have that it's just it's not here on this slide it's not St reportable and we're just presenting on reportable got it okay so that was that okay that's healthy so we do know how many less than full day ISS okay I would
070I would um request that VRI be included going forward just because I think that's something that also want to be able to make sure I I wasn't clear on your on the question so I'm sorry I thought you okay I'm sorry do you want to see it by um the action I know we couldn't report some of this but H what are you trying to find out from getting the half day ISS that isn't reported to the state versus the half day ISS that is reported State I I want to avoid the squeeze the balloon one area and have it blow up somewhere else you track all of it so that you know I'm not moving kids that would have gotten full day ISS now into half day ISS and it looks like we've solved
071the problem what I want to make sure is we're looking at all of it when we report so we report this twice a year so well we'll bring We'll have that data in the summary data that we do in great I had uh two other real quick comments actually if that's possible on fled number five I just want to make sure as we report I know that we're saying our our metric is 5% reduction right but in reality that's 5% reduction assuming the population of students stays the same and so it really is a reduction on a percentage basis of the population right and so the scenario is if half the number of black students are in the schools next year a 5% reduction doesn't look great it's actually probably a bad thing right and
072so the the metric here I'm going to challenge us to think about this metric in terms of ratio of population not just a flat rate does that make sense I mean does matter the percentage of the total population of black students in the school would would have a different would serve as a different correct correct I understand a mathematical difference and then slide number 10 very much kind of a similar thing on on slide number 10 I just think we need to know the N um with some caveats because if it's a very low number I don't we obviously don't want to be you know making it identifiable but I suspect in some of these cases the number is so small that that changes can be a little bit misleading right like like if you
073have a very very small end being able to say that we have achieved a particular reduction we may need more data than just that one snapshot does that does that make sense the nwd go yeah like what what is the this is if this is 500 students and you have these kind of improvements that's amazing if it's five students and you have these kind of improvements it's probably noise and so that we just need to know roughly about the are we still using restorative practices we are using the whole gamut and we're adding um our seal framework which is about the foundation for it all okay and then uh What uh grades are included in the Special Olympics so it's for it's very specific criteria and the Special Olympics of Georgia is for students with
074significant disability it will be k12 and I think the reason I asked the question to you hun was because do we want to just look at numbers I know certain things aren't recordable right but we understand why certain things are being reported to State um I think the presentation started with the fact that you have most school districts now you know looking um closely differently at safety so is the um number of ISS by itself or the reduction of the percentage important are we also wanting to look at particular um patterns so you like you said in the cafeteria in the morning we might see there's a trend with the number here but if it's also what's resulting I think what I'm trying to ask is do you also want to know what's resulting in
075the half day ISS or that OSS that's not just the number that's been reduced we can provide that in future so to piggyback on excuse me to piggyback on H's question yeah so providing what would be the nonstate reportable right and what offenses they are at an aggregate level that's what we're going to be doing because we do have to make sure that those things are being CED correct exactly and Bo I going to let you know um our data is only as clean as what goes in the system and to be able to establish data governance uh which is some of the work that is being done now with now having um a director in that role with that with the background not only in infinite campus but the understanding around that and those
076business roles that go with it there are going to be um some changes that we know we're we're having to make and that's even from a communication to you all uh it came a little later than it typically does because the data and the governance of it and what is in the system is not necessarily as clean as it should be let me just take a second to thank the administration for that work this has been something I've wanted to see happen for a long time it's been evidence in the data that's been presented to us the last number of years that this is an issue and I know from personal experience how hard it is to fix your data so I really appreciate what y'all are going through um and and thanks for taking
077it on it's pretty Fess until I felt like maybe thanking youate well well understand the the work around what one of the first things I said to you all is to have an interoperable data system well when you're creating an interoperable data system you then begin to see the holes in where data governance has not been in place so all of that takes time to address so um thank you so much uh you have in front of you some of the work from our work from what our students have said So based on this year we are at year zero which is in the design and so you can see here I listened to our K5 students and in The Advisory as they unpacked the comprehensive needs assessment and we talked about the definitions of
078self-awareness social awareness self-management and then ask them to draw or write what does that look like in the classroom and then even thinking to the 612 advisory where they said um the key piece around the practice of social emotional learning is the teacher and whether or not the teacher has buyin into social emotional learning so as we are building this framework I want you to know that there is a power in the adult I believe Sophie echoed that earlier when we were talking about social emotional learning as well so we are creating this environment and we are going to need our adults to help us build and sustain that engaging and inclusive culture for all of our students so Bor thank you for having that as something that we really do need to focus on
079um I just want to add one thing I would really like to see um the breakdown of like why the guy that's like the different reason for why they got ISS and then categorize them into more General categories just because I think it can make um I don't know because there was the numbers up there about like the percent they got ISS but then why it that's exactly what uh board member Anderson was alluding to as well thank you thank you Mrs Holz I want the community to know we review this data twice a year in December and may it is very important that the board implements what we are learning through our outcome data is present academic outcomes but how our students are interacting with one another and adults in our district Dr Whitaker
080please please introduce the next presentation thank you Vice chair sutan I would like to call on Mrs Jennifer B assist to provide an overview of our expansion in the early learning St good afternoon Vice chair Dr fton esteemed board members student board representative Delena and superintendent Dr GMA wher I'm excited to share an update on our plan to expand Early Childhood learning opportunities in the city schools of the cater the construction of the new Early Learning Center falls under the organizational Effectiveness and excellent strategic accelerator but we know the outcomes of the Early Learning Center will reach all strategic accelerators in 2017 the city schools of Decor purchased Land from the decor Housing Authority with the promise to use the land for public school purposes we have an opportunity an opportunity to fulfill a promise
081our promise is to provide a high quality Child Care Program that will ensure kindergarten Readiness for kindergarten on the very land that was taken from the Beacon Hill Community Beacon Hill also known as the bottom was a thriving black community established by freed enslaved people after the Civil War it was a center of Commerce educ ation and Community until the 1930s when much of the land was condemned in favor of new public housing leading to mass displacement fulfilling our educational promise is our Equity work why we believe that early childhood education is part of the solution to the significant disparities in our district the research on the efficacy of early childhood education is robust and it is clear that a high quality Early Learning Program is a key factor in ensuring Student Success in all
082areas a few things to consider our brains develop most between birth and age8 these are some of the most fertile years to learn and develop Early Learning can have a lifelong effect adults who participated in high quality Early Learning were found more likely to be employed have graduated from high school and have higher earnings than those who did not and it also makes economic sense Nobel prizewinning economy Economist James Heckman shows that every dollar invested in quality early childhood and yield returns between $4 and $16 have shown savings and later intervention costs and that's not even tackling the impact on Family Financial stability our project Vision aligns with our district Vision we all know that at city schools of theator we strive to create an Educational Foundation that empowers students to realize their full potential
083drive as productive Global Citizens ignite positive change and create a more just and Equitable world but to bring that Vision to life all CSD students have a strong Foundation starting at Birth we seek to build a best-in-class Early Learning Center to transform access to high quality Early Learning options for our families I've shared the disparity in our academic Data before but I'd like you to consider some other data a recent survey of families living at dicator Housing Authority demonstrated that child care is an impediment to Career Development for many families with 20% of respondents reporting they were unable to progress their career or education due to child care issues in 2022 48 students were not en enrolled in An Early Childhood Program and that number is growing right now we have 67 children living in
084the decor Housing Authority who are not enrolled in any early childhood education program at all and this is the beginning of our Equity Gap we also know that there are some wonderful Early Learning options indicator including with our own in our own District but there is still more need this need actually transcends our families that are economically disadvantaged this fall to gauge interest in a new early learning facility a majority of the 100 economically diverse family survey identified affordability and availability as key concerns here you'll see our current Early Learning enrollment of note is that we have weight lists at both College Heights and the Frasier Center and the birth to three classes College Heights has a total of 166 children on the weight list and Frasier has 18 our new Early Learning Center will
085bring our total early learning capacity to over 400 we plan to have a balance of children with private pay reduced pay and scholarships with a oneir oneir oneir approach the new Early Childhood Learning Center will fulfill the promise of Beacon Hill and bolster Child Care access for all CSD families the proposed Early Learning Center is expected to offer 13 classes first through prek with flexible spaces to adjust to accommodate evolving needs the building will serve between 135 to 150 students College Heights is currently a model Early Learning Center and we plan to replicate its success by using the same curriculum we'll focus on using conscious discipline Equity focused instruction and science of reading align practices the because this Early Learning Center will replace the Frasier Center this new building will be the hub for the
086high schools teaching as a profession pathway as we expand this promising and needed pathway this is a complex undertaking with the needs of our district in mind we've worked to develop a draft tour plan that will allow for the kind of high quality programming our children deserve here here is an aerial view of the conceptual design we've worked to make the footprint modest to keep the building low profile and allow for continued Greenery we envision a Sleek modern accessible environmental friendly building with a welcoming interest and a design that blends in with the surrounding buildings and fits the character of the meeting the needs of an early childhood facility this is the first iteration of a conceptual design once the conceptual design is completed and approved the architectural design firm will proceed with the schematic
087design phase addressing architectural structural mechanical and electrical components the estimated budget for this project is between 15 and $22 million this includes the construction design and consultant Services necessary site work and the FFN which is Furniture fixtures and equipment funding a building project Like An Early Childhood Learning Center requires a comprehensive approach to address both one-time Capital expenses and ongoing operational costs developing a sustainable funding strategy for a new Early Learning Center in the city school Li theator involves leveraging multiple Financial sources to ensure both the establishment and long-term operation of the facility we call this Diversified support structure a graded funding model we are exploring all funding sources including spots grants donations our general fund and partnership our Communications team has launched the new early Learning Center web page which can be found on
088the Cs de.net website under teaching and learning the community will find the information I've shared today along with frequently asked questions and a dedicated email address to share an interest in Partnership or ask questions this web page will be updated regularly after board and Community meetings also each of you has a one pager in front of you that's been included as an addendum that provides project highlights at this point in the project this gives you an overview of our next six months including Community engagement and design Benchmark in January we'll host the Board of Education Community me meeting and continue to engage focus groups by February we will finalize our schematic designs which will allow us to refine our budget estimates and we'll connect with best-in-class Early Learning centers across the country in March we'll
089come back to the board with a quarterly update as we solicit proposals for construction management at risk firm in April we will be in the preconstruction phase and host another community meeting in May we'll award the semar contract and begin planning our education plan for Early Childhood learning staff we'll come back to the board in June with another quarterly up so what's happening next so to recap here are immediate next steps focus groups are beginning this week with Early Childhood learning staff we invite our community to attend the community meeting at Glenwood on January 22nd at 5:30 p.m which will focus on the new Early Learning Center and we're continuing to uh continuing our relationship building and strategy around obtaining funding funding in February we'll be partnering to learn from some of the best Early
090Childhood learning sites across the country that align with our vision for programming and architecture by fulfilling our promise to use this land for public school purposes we also create opportunity in the space currently held by the Frasier Center at thear high school while this space won't be available for several years we are considering in athletic needs as well as the expansion of our ctae offerings we'll use our strategic plan as our guide and developing a plan for this SP when it becomes available the research and our district data tell us that this is the right work and we need everyone's help please spread the word and rally others to Champion this transformative work partner with us or help us find donors as we say in CS we are all in and we invite our decator
091community and Beyond to be all Ino This is Our Moment an opportunity to truly serve our community let's expand the great Early Learning childhood oh Early Childhood learning work that's happening across our district and make it accessible to our community that needs our support the most prepared to answer questions um so just running through the numbers really quickly we the weight list for College Heights The Frasier Center plus DHA is about 250 total students we're looking at maybe 150 incremental with this which means we'll still have weight lists when all this said is done so I just want to quickly hear from the administration how we're going to ensure the available ability to the extent possible is prefer or preserved for the highest needed students coming out of the uh D yes so uh our
092programming would be onethird of our seats would be reserved for DHA um proposed oneir of the seat will be reserved for Frasier as we're going to move Frasier over and then oneir will be for a full pay and so by that preserved reserved I also would love scholarship meaning those families would not pay to have their children to attend sure um in terms of financing I know we probably aren't in the weeds of this yet but I I don't know if if things like go bonds or other bonding mechanisms cops whatever the other Capital allocation programs might be event that is all kind of being looked at as fantastic and then the last thing I would say two things on this one can we definitely say draft here so we people freaking out whether they're
093finalized on it or not yeah and then too I think there is some value in mentioning that that we are preserving a pretty significant chunk of and just making sure that that is also reflective of The community's Wishes one question about the Le page you say there's a section where people could provide questions or feedback okay thank you what ages does the Fraser Center service they serve zero to three zero to three okay I was just wondering is it possible once this is finished there may be families wouldn't have we wouldn't have face for them on if for everybody who came from the phasing Center oh no we will have we have enough space so there are our Frasier serves about 60 children so we will take all of those 60 which will leave about
094hundred right under a hundred additional spaces for um for the new Early Learning Center but yes they will come from Fraser and and another key piece is the children who were probably going to serve maybe in utero right now so like like we don't that's the KE couple yeah so we have a couple years before we will know but yes we do we will bring Frasier will be fully engulfed into this okay so so when we say a third of the Fraser Center what do we mean by that no so the total Early Learning Center will have you know about a third will be um so a third of our Early Learning Center will be from The Frasier Center a third will be full pay and then a third will be scholarship or from the
095AJ so basically taking the 150 and dividing it by three um but that so mathematically it means that we're actually going to be lessening the number of Fraser Center available spaces right because the third is 50 spots not not the 60 yeah but with attrition and people move like when we make that move it would not be surprising that a a couple of people don't select the Early Learning Center or but then but then there's also some number of the 67 kids in DHA that are going to be Frasier Center age kids would need to be able to access that I I'm just a little bit concerned about Jan is maybe concerned about the ma I mean so the building is built for about 150 and 50 and so 50 from DHA 50 from Frasier
096and 50 from for full and because a lot of teachers use the Fraser center right that's mainly mainly right there so I'm just wondering if there is a way to I mean once the FR is gone it's gone for you know like that 50 for Fraser who are those people really but mostly teaching right may I ask a question about the numbers because we're using the existing pH oh I'm sorry so Frasier is currently staff children that's basically uses Frasier right now there are about 60 children there their enrollment you know definitely varies right but um 2027 Frasier will no longer meet over at the high school but they will be in the new facility so teachers will teachers get any type of priority to placement um there in within that Fraser yes yeah well
097that's it it would they'll be just like you're preserving oneir for DHA you would preserve one3 for what would be Frasier Center Uh current enrollment so yes it's about reserving seats and spaces for one our teachers that's a that is an added benefit you know for here in theater that our staff can have their children at the fure center I think what I wanted to ask was about the numbers so if we have 60 pressure center students right now then it's maybe we need to know how many are in since how many are three years old because in a year or two years the three-year-olds will now four-year-old so unless we're certain that the staff for example will have a consistent number of children that age and I'm not sure how we do that but
098we're talking right now about 60 students at franer Center correct those students age so as they they don't AG no no they yeah they're going to grow up so they would not come those 60 children probably wouldn't be in this building anyway because the children we will really serve are currently in utero right because they're not born yet or maybe an infant so I think to the questions that I'm hearing about the numbers and how because I think what we're realizing is we have a need for this Center um and even when we build it we're still going to have younger children in our district that will not be able to attend and I heard on NPR today I think the class of 2025 is the largest then we go down again so are we
099looking out three five years to see what we're looking at we'll always have some staff that'll have young children and we'll always have some young children here and that might answer maybe to some of the other questions regarding Fraser Center children my followup question would be does the Fraser Center have pre right now no so it looks like this model is going to incorporate prek like College Heights has um I'm not sure how many prek classes you're thinking about you don't you don't have to answer but I wondered if maybe we thought about what that pre- model looks like especially um going into um kind of future years I guess like we were talking about as the enrollment numbers look differently and maybe where where those pread are house if they potentially went back to
100their home schools if that offloaded some space um for some of those weight list it's just it's don't kill me it's just a it's just a thought but um now you're looking at absorbing the Fraser Center Plus adding PRK which yeah which they didn't have before um and but um it's just a just another and you know the yeah the ability to have a prek you know that it's dependent upon you know other agencies so we have to go through all of those processes so that's where it's very high level of a third a third a third because you have a we have a lot of work to do to be able to say how many prek classrooms we can actually have because we have to apply with them for through other agencies and this
101is where I think I would be a lot more comfortable if I saw some of those forecasts over time just because now is the time for us to say well if we need 175 students instead of 150 now's the time for us to be talking about it if we want this to be instead of you know 15 to 22 if we're talking about it 18 to 7 like that's like this is the time to be talking about it I just don't want us to bake in it being too small but then also I don't want to be much l because I mean the reality is enrollment is declining across the board right it is declining across the board and so um just a little bit of sophistication behind those forecasts would go a long way
102and yes it's so to provide what would be birth rate and things of that nature because that is really what informs M enrollment projection for the school system K12 but at the same time obviously would inform the birth through five so yeah yeah um I have a question about the 13 to 13 to 13 ratio could that ratio potentially fluctuate based on how many DHA apartment um children need the be in the um in the preschool just because I mean right now there are 67 I think that aren't enroll because they can't AFF it or they can't have trans they can't get their kids there um which means that if that school is built right now so 17 kids wouldn't be able to go if that one3 to one3 to one3 ratio is like don't
103Sol it yeah um nothing would be set in stone um so it wouldn't be you know this is it really comes down to need and funding so it it's it's complicated um but uh we definitely want to serve the kids that that need it um and the important pieces are then we have to find the funding for it so um but that has been our priority in this project I I would like to just start the public conversation about general fund subsidies for some of this because I do absolutely believe the one to four to 16 return the amount of money that we spend now in the general fund to try to close some of the issues that have been created because these children have not had these programs is catastrophic I view it as
104fiscally responsible to fund some of this out of the general fund so I just want to set that out there so the public hears it and we can begin talking about this publicly it's going to require an investment on the front end but I think it pays dividends thank you so we are hopeful that continued quarterly updates on funding construction and engagement will keep you well informed regarding this project the project is envisioned as an evidence-based model demonstrating the power of what would be public private Partnerships highlight while highlighting our Collective investment in Early Education and it would address systemic inequities I am appreciative to have Danielle gray associate director of the Ze Foundation present today Ze has been very impactful in supporting Student Success in neighboring districts and also indicator I believe this early
105learning initi ative approach will inspire Partnerships and other communities to rep replicate its future success ensuring a lasting imprint and impact here incer and Beyond thank you Mrs Burton for the presentation we look forward to the quarterly engagement on the topic of the new Early Learning Center also I invite the community to engage in a two-way dialogue with the Board of Education on Wednesday January 22nd at 6:30 p.m. at Glennwood elementary school regarding the project Dr Whitaker please introduce the next presentation Vice chair Assan I would like to call on Mrs Amanda Lynch excuse me Chief of Staff to review our governance team policy for first read good afternoon Dr sulon team members of the board student representative Delena superintendent Dr J Whitaker today we have one policy on the for work session this is
106policy bbfb governance team this policy was discussed in pre-work last month it is being presented for first read if approved for first read this policy will be available for public comment through assembly stakeholders can access any policies open for public comment on the right hand side of the simply homepage simply is linked on our CSC website under the board for policy bbfb governance teams there were just a few minor boarding revisions that were made to the draft that was discussed last month this includes adding the word strategic plan as requested by the board during last month's discussion this draft was then shared again with the SLT when the superintendent met with the SLT which resulted in the addition of one additional word the word Mission so that the policy reads that slts are responsible for
107complying and carrying out the mission and provisions of the district Charter that's the only feedback that they had it was also shared with them that it would be shared tonight and shared with all SLT members at their annual governance training that it would be available for public comment through assembly if approved for first read tonight may I read the recommendation yes please the recommendation being made is that City schools of the cater Board of Education accept policy bbfb governance teams for first read have a motion to approve the recommendation to accept policy bbfb governance teams for first read some moves any board member can to second the motion second any discussion all right all those in favor the motion carries unanimously thank you Mrs Lynch and thank you Dr Whitaker we encourage the public to
108review this policy which is posted on assembly and we will will recess and return for our regular board meeting in 5 minutes 450 450 which is e good afternoon our board chair James Heen cannot be present today so as Vice chair I will be presiding we will now call this meeting to order at Cor 50 p.m. we ask that you silence all cell phones we'll begin with a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance at this time I ask that everyone join me in a moment of Silent thank you now I ask all who are able to please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic stand one nation under God individual with liy and justice for all our
109mission is to inspire and enable student growth through meaningful and engaging learning experiences supported by highly qualified and caring Educators in a safe and inviting environment first on the agenda is approval of the meeting agenda for this meeting December 2024 board members are there any revisions to the agenda this evening no yes okay do I have a motion to approve today's agenda they moved board member us approve the motion have a second all right board member Anderson makes the second any discussion motion Carri unanimously our next agenda item is the approval of minutes from previous board meetings do I have a motion to approve November board member make the motion have a second second board member Johnson Davis second the motion any discussion no discussion all those in favor by the motion carries unanimously all
110right Dr Whit garthy we have some guests who have joined us do we have recognition tonight yes Vice chair Sulton to facilitate tonight's recognitions I would like to call upon Deputy superintendent Karen mut Scott thank you Vice chair so steam members of I have the pleasure of making several presentations this evening for college early childhood Learning Center T uper Elementary Deacon Hill and two cicada high school graduates as we honor each group please do not take your seat instead we'd like you to Stage along the wall to my left your right for a photo opportunity with our board members at this time I was going to invite Sarah Garland principal of The Early Childhood Learning Center to the front but she is checking her head not um her honores have not made it here this
111evening for unforeseen reasons but we will still read them by honoring the highlights College Heights proudly recognizes the dedicated individuals who form their instructional leadership team these dedicated Educators selected by their peers embody the heart and soul of our school Community they serve as the powerful voice of our staff and AC L shaping our vision setting ambitious goals and driving transformative improvements in instructional practices the instructional leadership team is committed to fostering a positive and Equitable learning environment for all students they collaborate with their colleagues creating a culture of open dialogue and shared responsibility by actively seeking feedback and valuing diverse perspectives they ensure that every voice is heard and acknowledged from participating in critical hiring decisions to welcoming visitors into their classrooms the EC team members exemplify high standards of professionalism and dedication they
112facilitate meaningful staff meetings inspiring and empowering their colleagues and peers to reach New Heights we thank the outstanding Educators for their invaluable contributions that would be Annie Phillips and Maris Ren as well as Aaron Matthew Davis Ava Deo Stella sodat tayor tapes and Denise Stapleton thank them all we thank them all for their commitment to Excellence and efforts to make College Heights an exceptional place for our students to learn and grow let's give them a round of applause in their accent knowing the fundamental importance of literacy and the impact of students reading ability on their entire educational career the Georgia Department of Education has recognized schools with exceptional achievement or growth in Reading as literacy leaders schools were recognized for achievement or growth in the percentage of students reading at or above grade level the
113criteria for the literacy leader Awards recognized The crucial importance of great level reading and third and sixth grade and require higher growth from schools with lower achievement levels awards were given at the elementary middle and high school levels a total of 324 schools met the qualification to be recognized as literacy leaders and our very own tally Upper Elementary School was one of them so we invite principal Heaton to receive recognition as the Georgia literacy leader School in CSC thank you Billy and your team for moving the needle on literacy and changing the lives of the students you serve additionally this award was given for math recognizing the fundamental importance of mathematics and students education and future careers the Georgia doe recognized schools with exceptional achievement or growth in math as math leaders schools were recognized
114for achievement or growth in the percentage of students scoring at proficient learning level or above in mathematics the 2023 math leader award criteria recognized The crucial importance of numeracy numerous excuse me skills and S an A grades and require higher growth from schools and lower achievement levels as well this award was given again at the elementary middle and high school levels and a total of 624 schools met the qualifications to be recognized as math leaders and our very own Beacon Hill Middle School was among those receiving this recognition we invite principal Thomas Dr Julie MCB Angela profit and Sarah Homan to see at 2024 Georgia M school we applaud the hard work that has resulted in these accomplishments recognized by these prestigious designations now for our decer graduates I'd like to invite Wes Hatfield assistant
115principal of Decor High School idy Watley director of the virtual Jones our lead school counselor to the front being that way okay for recognition of our decator high school graduates graduating high school is a significant milestone in life tonight we have the honor of recognizing two exceptional students who will graduate at the end of December and transition to the next phase of their lives they have reached this moment through hard work dedication and perseverance and we are are thrilled to celebrate their achievements as they walk upon their new Journeys let us take a moment to honor all that they have accomplished and wish them continued success in their exciting Adventures first we will honor Caleb Alexander lanir come on up [Music] front Caleb your teacher have shared that working with you over the past year
116and a half at decada Virtual Academy has been a true pleasure your positive attitude and active contributions to the online community have made a lasting impression they've also been impressed with how well you've balance academics and Athletics today you stand before us having met all the requirements for graduation with honors and ready to pursue your dream of playing college football at Duke University congratulations not yet Caleb I'm still working on still honoring you congratulations on your athletic scholarship and may you achieve all your dreams we know you will be successful at Duke okay and our second graduate is Madison Davis he is TR okay we will read Madison's recognition and um if she makes it before we're done then we'll make sure to call her up and and get her picture and all of those
117things Okay Madison Decor High School is proud of your dedication to earning your high school diploma through both Decor high school and Elizabeth Andrews High School you have demonstrated remarkable resilience and the ability to stay focused on goals during Madison's time at Elizabeth Andrews High School last year she earned 10 and a half credits in work-based learning English math science and social studies an achievement that is truly outstanding we look forward to Madison's continu success in the automotive field and we are here to support her as she transitions to the next exciting phase of her life if one of her family [Music] members her information we give you a round of applause thank [Applause] you at this time I'd like to invite our board members and Dr W to join us for photos with our
118honor yeah congratulations congratulations congratulations congratulations thank you congratulations congratulations you want your cap on do you want your cap on no no no it look so gorgeous thank you congratulations congratulations congratulations you're gonna get you're gonna get in the middle I thought you were by me we don't we don't we don't buy we really don't we really don't yeah of course we have to widen a little bit sprad out a bit a little bit we can put you want to get in the middle midle all right back in that basketball a congrats guys congratulations [Music] here you mean [Music] like's lookit Dr whiter do you have a report tonight yes Vice chair of saltan I do on Friday the Georgia Department of Education released the College and Career Readiness performance index under the federal federal
119every student succeeds act otherwise known as Essa each US state is required to have a Statewide accountability system that compiles with Federal complies with Federal requirements providing information on how well schools are performing the ccrpi meets the requirement in Georgia and satisfies requirements for school accountability in state law the Board of Education in collaboration with the community excuse me has developed the Strategic plan all indicator many of the key performance indicators of students success in all areas are measured using components of ccrpi there therefore this present this presentation is a true reflection of progress made towards fulfilling the objectives of the Strategic plan the ccpi measures school district and state performance on five components the first is Content Mastery which includes student scores on Statewide assessments and English language arts mathematics science and social studies
120the second component progress measures how much growth students demonstrate in English language arts and Mathematics and how well English Learners are progressing toward English language proficiency the closing gaps component measures how well schools meet annual Improvement targets for subgroups the fourth is Readiness which is includes literacy scores student attendance and percentage of students succeed for instruction accelerated enrollment pathway completion and College and Career Readiness measures and then there is the graduation rate which is a high school component including both the fourth and fifth year graduation rates the ccrpi no longer includes an overall 0 to 100 score for schools districts or the state each component still has a score of 0 to 100 though the Department of Education has communicated that this change has made was made to increase transparency and provide a more complete
121picture of school performance ensuring that challenges and opportunities are not hidden behind a single score State legislation passed in 2024 requires the governor's office of student achieve M otherwise known as Gosa to calculate a single score for schools and districts and for the Georgia Department of Education and the local school district to publish these scores online CSD will publish ghost's single score for our district and schools as soon as they are made available so let's dive into the components Content Mastery addresses whether students are achieving at the level necessary to be prepared for the next grade college or career for Content Mastery City schools of decada is number two in the state and number one in the Metro for both elementary and middle schools the high school's Content Mastery score has also increased from last
122year moving them from second and moving them to second in the Metro and seventh in the state our teachers are continuing to focus on the teaching of the Georgia standards of excellence both Elementary and both elementary schools met all Targets where you see a green flag the target was met if there is a yellow star in the flag the subgroup met the Improvement Target if a flag is not present there are two use students in the school to actually calculate that score Content Mastery in our secondary schools also indicates that we have met our accountability targets for our subgroups for Middle School the Georgia Milestones assessment test as well as the 2024 Georgia alternative assessments for students as gaas are included in the Content Mastery score for high school Content Mastery score 2023 middle school
123algebra end of course 2024 high school end of course and retest as well as the 2024 the 2023 24 um also IB AP and I history are included and you you can see their Flags there progress progress measures how much growth students demonstrate in English language arts and Mathematics and how well English Learners are progressing toward English language proficiency students obtain growth percentiles which indicate how their current achievement Compares with that of Statewide academic peers who had similar histories all schools increased in student growth for ELA three out of the four schools increased in student growth in math and kudos to the staff and the students at Beacon Hill Middle for ELA growth at 11.25 percentage points and at Decor High School for Math for 8.53 percentage points and at tally for English language Learners
124at 14 percentage points closing gaps sets the expectation that all students and all student subgroups make improvements in achievement rates this component is based on ccrpi Improvement targets for academic achievement which are also represented by Improvement flags and it provides an opportunity for schools to demonstrate the progress made in improving student performance among all subgroups mathematically the amount of improvement stays constant and is added to the previous year's subgroup score to determine the target score each year so we will not rest on these scores and continue to improve as indicated on this slide all schools met subgroup Targets in closing gaps in ela closing gaps is the only ccrpi component that is not comparable this year to last year that is because we have new K12 Mass standards and targets are in the process of
125being established this year using the 2324 as the Baseline elementary schools achieved a score of 100% however there is opportunity for growth in the content of science for economic disadvantage and English language Learners mathematically the amount of improvement stays constant and is added to the previous year group to determine that Target score for each year so once again we will not rest on these scores but continue to improve our secondary schools show a bit more variety and therefor at the middle school are with with Hispanic students and once again economically disadvantaged students in science I am sing a pattern the red flag in US history is not a surprise when we presented the Georgia Milestone results earlier this year we knew US History needed to be addressed we have put systems of support in place
126through plc's and pacing to address the root causes of the flag finally Improvement targets without Stars coincide with the need to bolster our mcss processes as on trck and off trck data assists us with drilling down to the student and the need Readiness measures whether students are participating in activities that prepare them for and demonstrate Readiness for the next level college or career the indicators for elementary and middle schools include at or above grade level reading student attendance and Beyond the core for our elementary student 88.9 3% are reading at or above grade level that is an increase from last year from 1.43 percentage points and yes the aggregate math the subgroup performance where black students are reading at 65.5 5% but that is an increase from 55% last year economically disadvantaged students percentages are
127up from 43% to 57% is this where we want to be no but there is Improvement and that is significant likewise for Middle School black students reading at or above grade level increase from 62% to 68% in economically disadvantaged students reading at or above grade level increased from 52% to 63% High School Readiness indicators include at or above grade level reading student attendance accelerated completion and College and Career Readiness if for if board members remember I asked what it would mean for us not to have only 38% of our economically disadvantaged students reading at or above grade level last year now 54.9 five% of economically disadvantaged students are reading at or above grade level this year once again not where we want to be especially since these students will graduate in a year and a
128half but we are making strides finally our graduation rate measures whether students are graduating from high school with a regular diploma in four or 5 years last year's graduation rate was 95.1% and now it is 95.4% this indicator is only at the high school level but is a part of ccrpi in conclusion I want to remind the board and the public CSD will publish ghost's single score for our district and schools as soon as they are available each ccpi component has a 0 to 100 score for schools and districts there is an addendum to this presentation which presents all ccrpi scores in 2023 and 2024 out of the 13 components all but two are now over 90 I must thank our dedicated teachers and staff for their commitment to academic excellence and Student Success this
129year's College and Career Readiness measurements reflect the progress DSD is making in narrowing the achievement Gap and preparing students for Life Beyond High School finally I'm going to actually pass something I am thrilled to close my remarks and the first semester of this school year with an exciting announcement about four months into my tenure as superintendent I met with the leadership of the chickfila foundation and submitted a proposal that you have in front of you that would assist us in taking CSD from a good school district for most students to a great school district for all students The Proposal emphasized that CSD shared the Chick-fil-A values of adapting and Reinventing how we do things to achieve great outcomes the necessity and the urgency for finding new ways to ensure equity in student achievement for every
130student and a belief that we will achieve the greatest and fastest outcomes by investing in the development of our school leaders and District leaders the The Proposal was requesting funding for the professional development of leaders through the University of Virginia's Partnerships for leaders in education program UVA the UVA combine combines the most Innovative leadership advancement practical exper expertise and The Proven methodologies from both business and education The Darden School of Business and the curry School of Education the worldclass organization emboldens education leaders to cultivate systemic change to enhance the conditions where School communities achieve remarkable results UVA ple also emboldens and equips leadership teams to create and Implement shifts critical to addressing inequities and fostering remarkable student and school adva advancements the ultimate effect is more Equitable inclusive and an excellent school system on Friday
131I received an email from the Chick-fil-A Foundation notifying me that CSD has been awarded a grant of $200,000 to advance our efforts the leadership development will be focused on our four UVA schools Fifth Avenue Upper Elementary School T Street Upper Elementary School Beacon Hill Middle School and decada High School and if you realize those are also the four schools that I just presented on we are tremendously grateful to the Chick-fil-A foundation for their generosity and partnership in developing strong leaders who cater to the unique needs of every student together we will ensure Equitable outcomes for all students providing a Beacon of Hope for the students who need most Vice chair Sultan that completes my report and I wish everyone an enjoyable and restful winter break thank you Dr Whitaker good evening on behalf of the
132city schools of decator of Education thank you for joining us in person and virtually your engagement in the success of our students is appreciated it's December which means this will be our last Board of Education meeting until next year during today's pre-work we continued our book study on the governance Corp School Board superintendent and schools working together a revision of to the drug-free workplace policy where it's presented for board feedback along with initial draft of policies on staff political activities ities and staff responsibilities to report criminal charges to employers there were two presentations during the work session the first was an update on the state of the student Support Services the second presentation the board and public got an update on the planning underway for a new Early Childhood Learning Center including a programming plan
133the the projected budget and a first look at conceptual design we also accepted a policy on school governance team for the first read the presentations for all board meetings are available on the district's website and assembly while you're there I invite you to listen to the October and November board meetings for discussions on Direct fiscal impact of house bills 581 on CSD which creates a Statewide floating homestead exemption as an inflation C on property tax assessments more than 55% of Voters in the city of the Ator approved HB 581 as a constitutional amendment in November however the bill allows cities counties and school districts a one-time option to opt out of the property tax cap the city schools educator Board of Education will follow the legal procedures to opt out of the exemption including holding
134three virtual public hearings two on January 14 one in the morning and one in the evening and one in the evening of January 21st recognitions have become a highlight of monthly meetings the board looks forward to celebrating our schools and the achievements of our students and staff this evening we had the pleasure of hearing about the invaluable contributions of two teachers at College Heights Early Childhood Learning Center celebrated the recognitions of T Street and Beacon Hill by the Jordan Department of Education at the Statewide literacy and math leaders and the accomplishments of two decater high school students who will graduate early at the end of this month we wish them well in their postsecondary Pursuits and congratulate all student and staff on their achievements over the next two weeks I know our schools will be
135ringing with cheer from incredible winter performances and various celebrations enjoy the upcoming break everyone we look forward to W welcoming you back in a New Year finally our next board meeting will be Tuesday January 14 2025 and that concludes my remarks for this evening board members do you have any thoughts that you wish to share I may yes please um so this is in regards to uh Dr Whitaker's uh superintendence report on ccpi um and I just want to acknowledge at the beginning of this that I recognize we are not done we have a long way to go uh but I want to commend the superintendent and I want to commend the entire team uh for the work that has been done to date um this is the first time since I've been on this
136board and frankly probably since I've been paying attention and I marked that around 2017 but I feel like we're watching the right things that we have a grip on the data and that we're taking the right steps to see changes and this is the first time I've seen systemic Improvement across the board on all of the metrics that we're trying to track so I just finally feel like we're actually making meaningful change to help the students that for so long in this system have not received the support that they should have there's plenty more to do but I uh I do feel it's important to acknowledge that so thank you very much second that and say thank you to Dr Whitaker um everyone that I'm looking at and uh all the teachers and administrators I
137understand it takes everyone so I appreciate it thank you Dr Whitaker please introduce the next presentation thank you Vice chair Sultan I would like to call on Dr Lita broom Chief Financial Officer to present the midyear budget adjustment good evening Vice sherff Dr Clon to members of the board student representative Delena and superintendent Dr W the district has been in operation for 6 months and we have had an opportunity to analyze Current financial operations and Trend based on the analysis it has been determined that there is a need to amend the current cical year 25 general fund budget the fiscal year 25 budget amendment has an impact on all four strategic accelerators with a specific focus on organizational Effectiveness and Excellence through financial equity and transpar of District funds the operation division is requesting approximately
138$2 million in midyear budget request the 2 million request includes increased cost for energy custodian usage and supplies modular rentals and funds for the maintenance of buses that are no longer on contract or warranty additionally nutrition revenue is coming in less than projected and it is estimated that the general fund may have supplement the school nutrition program by approximately $520,000 with the acception of the request for two maintenance technician for the Legacy Park Track and Field will be funded by reallocating funds save from Personnel vacancies to operation the request for the two maintenance technician which is inclusive of salary and benefits for legacy part track and field will satisfy the requirements of the district District to provide routine and preventive maintenance as specified in the intergovernmental agreement between the district and the city the $4,365
139will be funded by deducting funds from the district fund balance human resources and information services division are requesting a combined total of approximately $27,000 Human Resources request in clude a system to digitize Human Resources record to allow quicker access to data Consultants or compensation and Professional Services a position upgrade and an exit survey terminated and for technology request includes the adoption of a cyber security framework a Safety and Security consultant and increased funding for Safety and Security maintenance and repair again we are proposing that funds from vacant positions pement be reallocated to cover these requests Finance the superintendent's office student support and the district are requesting a combined total of approximately $483,000 Finance is requesting a return on investment system to identify efficiencies and areas of opportunity to reduce cost for programs and an upgrading
140a position in the finance department to ensure Equity among positions in the finance department there's no physical impact for the upgrade superintendent request is for an increase in attorney fees due to increased services for audits investigation and other services student Support Services request is for additional funds to cover the increased interest from teachers for esol endorsement the district requests include various employee changes throughout the year that impact the budget this includes teachers obtaining certifications completion of advanced educational degrees and new hires coming in with higher salaries than the average projected Sal the total midterm general fund budget request equates to 2,571 34 the fund is source for 2,456 671 is to reallocate funds from general fund personnel the funding s for $1 14,36 3,000 which is the two maintenance technician for legacy part track and
141field is the general fund is to be deducted from the general fund fund balance on numerous occasions the board has expressed their concerns with surplus funds left at the end of the year reallocating funds at the midterm will will reduce the Surplus that is traditionally left at the end of the year in The Last 5 Years the Surplus for the general fund has averaged approximately $2 billion the budget will be closely monitored and if necessary a second budget amendment will be presented to the board after me the fiscal impact of midterm Bud of fiscal year 25 midterm budget amendment one is $4,365 as shown in the small box top right the fiscal year 25 beginning audited fund balance is approximately 19 million the amount that will now be deducted from the fund balance has increased
142by $4,365 the end fund balance has also decreased by this amount and is now $6,279 and8 the fund balance percentage is within the 4 to 15% for policy this year I'm happy to respond to any questions you may have or provide uh Dr Broom um one mil is about what about 2.9 about $2.9 million right now um in general I am not hugely concerned about $2 and5 million adjustment on7 million budget what might about a 2% adjustment overall uh but that's actually not what we're presented with here this is a $1.9 million adjustment for operations alone and a very very small adjustment for the entirety of the rest of the budget and so even if we subtract the $114,000 and I'll even rant the $520,000 from nutrition I appreciate that beginning to try to be
143transparent about the subsidy the general fund pays into nutrition we're still talking about 1.3 of an adjustment in a single Department that has to get tightened up that's a half a mill basically that's wrapped up in a single department and if we think about it that's what a n to1 million Department we're really talking about a 15% adjustment in one area um this is numbers that impact our ability to provide raises this is numbers that impact our ability to staff at different levels this is uh this is material and so I just I want to make sure that when we are back here this time next year we're not talking about uh 15% adjustment in one area yes sir but now I do have a question sorry H every time you say something it makes
144me think of something and I think I asked something like this last year so if we're looking at slide six and it says reallocation from general fund Personnel savings so that means that we had budgeted for personnel that we um ended up either not getting because there may not have been staff to fill that or not needed they indicates that if we anticipate at the end of the year from vacancy Y and from like employees being on Le that we'll have about that much left this budg I guess to speak back off of Han's Point looking at the M adjustment she's asking for I mean how much of these could she really have anticipated like some of them are inflation costs and then some are related to Legacy Park so I mean is there anything
145she really could have done can we put the slide it's your slide three yeah a very common estimate right 3% inflation is a pretty typical number so I don't know if this means that we underestimated inflation and need to add an additional 3% or if it means we didn't estimate inflation but inflation is actually down this year it's not up and so it concerns me that we aren't appropriately accounting for inflation is something that should just automatically have an inflationary budget estimate built into it um additional I mean every one of these other things in my experience are see to anticipate as a part of the budget process the one exception is the 114,000 through the Legacy Park because those are new positions that we did not have for contract at that particular point in
146time um but all of these others I would expect to be able anticipate as a budget as a part of a budget process and what concerns me is even if we didn't anticipate this as a part of a budget process we did anticipate this going somewhere else in the budget that we are now saying we don't need in the budget and so even if these weren't the things that we needed why were these in the budget then in the first place let Mr per so he can exp well I'm I'm not sure that I'm necessarily needing a defensive it right now I'm just saying that I I want this tighter next year that's my statement last question and I think is what you just asked maybe is what I was thinking so did I tell
147me if I misheard you but so there are two things here anticipate but the second part was then why are we allocating funds for this Personnel if it turns out we know we're not going to need them we don't know that we're not going to need it because we don't know what positions will be we don't know what employes will be or what emploees will go out but we know that it's not 15% in one department and zero in the rest thank you so Vice sherff Sultan and the board we will use a modified zerob based budgeting approach to build FY 26's budget as well staff's capacity is increasing in this area of work and I look forward to decreasing the need for adjustments in the future thank you Dr Broom and thank you Dr
148Whitaker please introduce the next presentation Vice chair sson I would like to call on Mrs Amanda Lynch Chief of Staff to present the 2026 2027 academic calendar good evening once again acting chair Sulton and St members of the board student representative Delena and superintendent Dr JMA Whitaker today I'm bringing to you a recommendation for the 2026 2027 academic calendar first I will provide you with a results of the stakeholder survey and how it informed the calendar being proposed for the development of the academic calendar aligns with our strategic accelerator focus on organizational Effectiveness and activ last month I presented to you a proposed draft of the 2026 2027 academic calendar this draft remains similar to past Year's calendars the current year calendar and next year's already adopted calendar I highlighted District priorities in last year's
149extensive survey results and also related that we had heard a desire from teachers for a teacher workday to be embedded in the school year rather than just at the start or end of semester to gather feedback on the draft calendar and specifically on the teacher-driven proposal to explore teacher workday options a survey was made available to all stakehold to complete from November 18th through December 4th the survey was featured prominently on our website communicated through the district newsletter and shared with our superintendent Council overall we heard from 580 survey respondents our were our CSC parents and families which made up 62% of our respondents next were CSD employees at 33% which can be further broken down into 21 teachers and 12% being other school or District staff 4% of survey respondents were students now let's
150look at some of the data we collected we analyzed the data we gathered overall and by stakeholder group we looked at both the quantitative ratings of satisfaction as well as qualitative feedback overall respondents from each CSD stakeholder group indicated high levels of satisfaction with the proposed 2026 2027 academic calendar Approximately 80% of respondents were satisfied or very satisfied with the placement of the first and last days of school the weekl long breaks in September November February and April as well as the semester break the majority of respondents were satisfied or very satis today as a digital learning day and the frequency of the early release days there's a decrease in the frequency of early release dates from our current school year beginning next school year with it moving from being other month in the comments
151we still saw some misconceptions around that there was less satisfaction with the placement of the early release days qualitative feedback shows a desire by some for early release days to occur on Friday while we hear this feedback we must also balance it with the intent of the early release days which is professional learning for teachers we've heard similar feedback in the past and in last year's extensive survey Wednesdays were red as the second highest preferred day for the best interest of teachers professional learning the release days ever made on Wednesdays in addition to asking about overall Impressions and general feedback on the calendar we also F sought specific feedback about the inclusion and placement of a teacher workday within the semester if you remember this came out of our teacher advisory Council one proposal was
152to shift an existing teacher workday to October 12th which is the indigenous people's day federal holiday approximately 79% of survey respondents indicated support for this shift this included 82% of our teacher respondents and 84% of our student respondents therefore in the calendar being recommended for adoption tonight you will see the October 12th day designated as a teacher work day rather than both staff and students are scheduled to be in school with this October 12th change an additional shift was needed to maintain the 180 student instructional days and 190 teacher days respondents were provided a number of possible scenarios including the ability to provide their own Solutions overall the highest rank option was making Friday December 18th the last day of the semester for students and also making it an early release day this was preferred
153by nearly 40% of teachers this is a change you will see from the draft calendar that previously had Thursday December 17th being the last day the last student day of the semester in the qualitative feedback families commented they preferred not having to find full day child care for the single Friday teachers indicated that working December 18th was preferable especially to the option of Shifting the January 4th teacher workday January 4th was seen as a vital day for teachers to return refresh and a day to plan to prepare to receive students at the beginning of the second semester the preliminary survey data and calendar recommendations were shared with Dr Whitaker's teacher advisory Council for any additional insights I'm happy to report that these teachers appreciated understanding the complexities of calendar development and also supported the recommended
154shift I just described made and so the calendar being recommended tonight reflects two changes to the draft presented to the board last month and shared for stakeholder feedback first it adds that October 12th as a teacher workday second it makes December 18th the last day of the semester for students and teachers note that that's also an early we are so grateful to the stakeholders who took time to provide their feedback to the calendar survey we feel this calendar reflects our community values and prioritizes the needs of our students STA and family there are any questions before I read the recommendation of course I will be happy toer one thank you so much for the teacher workday um and I think I'm just trying to figure out like with the December 18th it may have been
155you know the most number of the best of you couldn't have a January 4th work dat if you didn't we have a certain number of days that have to be met right for employment for teaching and so therefore when you see something like 36% it's also because well then January 4th is that great day where the teachers can prep while the students are not there so everyone comes back ready to go on in the in the survey design Hall it was only the 30 you know I think 9% it was a lot of different rankings for it to be distributed upon and so that was the highest and then also reading through the qualita feedback as well it helped substantiate that that was significant L the highest rated one thank you for that I'm pleased
156that we have settled on one calendar prior to the break winter break and I'm certain families appreciate the knowledge for future planning additionally I appreciate the feedback from my teachers advisory Council on the way the calendar would reduce teacher burnout through the addition of the work day that teacher work may I read the recommendation yes please I recommend the city school indicator Board of Education approve the 2026 2027 student academic calendar do I have a motion to approve the 2026 2027 academic calendar so move board member Johnson Davis approves the motion we have a second second board member Anderson any discussion all those in favor I motion carries unanimously thank you Mrs Lynch for working through all these processes with all stakeholders next we have items for Action information or discussion board we will now
157move on on to consent agenda items which include monthly items such as Financial nutrition and Personnel reports as well as overnight and out of State student travel I will solicit comments from the board on each item after the item has been discussed it will be moved to consent there will be a motion to accept the consent agenda at the end of discussion for all items Dr Whitaker do we have a monthly financial report yes Vice chair Salton Dr Lita broom chief of financial officer will present the monthly financial report good evening the October 2024 Financial reports and definition of function codes are located in assembly of the finance department operates strategic accelerator with a specific focus on acceler for organizational Effectiveness and Excellence through financial equity and transparency the general fund budget is $16,814.23 today
158which is in line with the percentage that was collected this time last year approximately $4 million for the month of October which is 2% less than the amount of Revenue collected for September due primarily to a small decrease in property tax collection from September to October all other revenue is trending as anticipated expenditures are normal for this time of the year the district has suspended 29% of the overall budget are approximately $28 million year today for the month of October itens is equated to approximately $9 million this is slightly higher than what was expended last year du primarily to salary and benefit increases the majority of October expenditures are for salaries and benefits which make up 87% of the budget for the month of October that was a deficit of approximately $5 million which means
159the district expenditures for the month were $5 million more than the monthly Revenue last year at this time the deficit was $4 million the approximately $5 million has been deducted from the fund balance which is normal for this time of the year overall year to date there's a surplus of approximately $8 million du primarily to the large receipt of property tax collection posted in July last year this time that was a surplus of $1 million the surplus of Revenue is normal at this time of the year in account for the healthy fund balance of approximately $27 million which includes the UN audited beginning fund balance of approximately $19 million the fund balance last year at this time was also $27 please note that the fund balance will continue to decrease as expenditures in October revenue
160for capital in Deb funds consisted of $ for this time of the year and the $655,000 deficit was deducted from the fund balance which was approximately $6 million in October just the year 25 anticipated expenditures for capital is approximately $12.7 million special Revenue funds are Grant funds including federal and state Grant not budget in the general fund we have closed out all of the fiscal year 24 Grant and as of October 31st 2024 have been awarded approximately $2.8 million in Grant F nutrition revenue is coming in less than projected and expenditures are trly within the same range as previous years the school nutrition budget is being analyzed and will most likely need financial support from the general fund the $135,200 Surplus for October increased SCH nutrition fund balance to approximately $2 million last year this
161time food nutrition fund balance was $1.8 Million I will be happy to respond to any questions or provide clarification thank you Dr Broom any questions or comments from the board y thank you thank you this item can be moved to consent consent agenda item number two is the SCH nutrition report are there any comments from the board all right this item can also be moved to consent consent agenda item number three is the Personnel report are there any comments or questions from the board this item can also be moved to consent consent agenda item number four is overnight and out of state travel um are there any comments or questions from the board this item can also be moved to consent consent agenda item number five is fesal year 26 budget priorities and parameters which
162were discussed in the work session last month are there any comments from the board does this include the school allotment guidelines or is that the next item okay well it's any other questions this item can also be moved to consent consent agenda item number six is fiscal year 26 School allotment guidelines which were discussed at the board retreat last month are there any comments or questions from the board go ahead so uh Sophie you asked earlier I think about what we learned and um what was difficult and this would be one of them so when I came today I didn't think I had any questions about this um but after reading multiple questions from people I do and that so I guess my first question procedurally is we are taking items and putting them on
163the consent agenda um especially since James isn't here is there um an opportunity to take this school allotment guideline and move it until the next board meeting that may interrupt Dr Whitaker's plans and that may not be something the rest of the board wants but I think that would be my first um request because I feel like I need more time now to look at some of the questions that people are asking and understand a little bit more about what I'd be approving so procedurally we'd have to make a move motion to move it off the consent and then vote to move it off consent and I think turns out to be what everyone else want I also think you know we' we've gotten a number of questions about about a particular portion of the
164school allotment guidelines so are there some specific questions that maybe we want to ask of um of Miss Walker who's here or Dr Whitaker maybe we should rather than moving it which we can we can make a motion and then move it know is it worth it to ask some of the questions out loud okay so my first question I know we've gotten a lot of communications um emails and questions about the AP position about the AP positions um there are three AP there um five AP positions and three Equitable outcome positions would the aps have first divs at those Equitable outcome positions yes yes so as we begin to staff for next year we would have a full with a process that's called a reduction and force process where those individuals who were impacted
165by reduction and force would be able to have first priority for interviewing for any of those position and and then the remaining two okay because this it's an HR proc it's a it's a standard HR process it's very it's similar to like a surplus process when you have multiple uh more teachers in a building than you do uh the needs for it and you need to move people around so that that is the what would be the reduction of course process so they would they would interview first then you make decisions it's possible that one could be picked out of that and then you go and start holding more interviews for those positions or is it possible that 3 APS could take those positions right off the after interviewing we look at the program need
166we qualifications and replace you uh with the affected employees where they need to be and they will be definitely have firsts as far as vac within the district maybe maybe if if I I could ask the superintendent to I know we talked about this in the uh Retreat as to why we were looking at meeting um the Equitable outcomes positions but maybe if you could just take a second and talk about why this change is necessary and what uh we're going to accomplish with it yes so currently the city schools of theer is um underst State oversight for our disproportionate identification of black students specifically for special education there are a couple of different violations that could that are really processes that we're not doing with Fidelity one would be childb um and so these
167individuals will help um oversee and key have the key conversations that need to be had from an equity standpoint around students and the it it's some support that is necessary um and because I from an equity standpoint you should not have the overidentification of special um special education students specifically black students so when you talk about Equitable outcomes you need really need some some people who are versed in what's consider the Georgia mtss process which is that including of child find it's the understanding that it is about the academics it is about the behavior it is about the attendance it is about the curriculum it is about the on track off track and the ways in which we are supporting students and I have said consistently since the end of my 90 days that we
168need a lot of work in that area and now to be with Georgia Department of Education oversight due to that I think it is incumbent upon this board to make the decision to really do something about that and is it is it would it be correct to characterize this as because I know a number of the comments that I've seen from the community and and from some of the emails that we've received has been really around the mtss process and how critical the aps are in supporting that process and and so what appe feels a bit to me is that we're broadly recognizing the ntss process needs support that we actually really do need Focus on some of those um uh cered support structures and and some some uh uh instead of a uh position
169that is Broad and general across the entire school really ensuring that we double down and focus on that specific need that has brought us to a point where the state is engaging with us this is actually a better way to address that specific uh requirement yes it is And to clarify would this position be in the school so would this be somebody who was like house atw in the school so I think that some some folks are thinking that this is a central office position but so can you clarify that this would be somebody that would be living in the school okay yes they are in schools they are not central office positions but they are iner right yes they'll be yes yeah yes because you're we're not bringing on uh seven we're only bring
170on three right so they'll be they'll be moving between the different elementary schools and one upper El yes and we're focusing there because the the violations of child find or potential violations of child find or the monitoring of implementation of child find really is occurring in that K2 space in three5 not as much in the 612 I wanted to ask Tracy what what other information um would you want to consider you know I I hear about the need and I I mean I guess I need to contextualize this because I keep thinking ironically at the discussion we had earlier about new trustees right and what you learn and what you don't know and so you know I I look at a lot of things through a teacher lens I know how I feel philosophically I
171know what my responsibility is as far as governance team and I look at the ccrpi right phenomenal job that I know couldn't have happened Without You Dr Whitaker without your team and without teachers and right now I just don't feel like I know enough to explain to people I know the need I hear that right I understand that we're going to move this to here but I just don't know if I have enough to really explain that I know how it's happening and why it's happening and so I think one I just appreciate um public questions because this help me and so I think I just I need more time to look at this and think about it I know we talked about it in November but I also know at the board retreat I
172talk specifically about um staff working face tace with students and so I'm I'm encouraged to hear that this new staff would be in the school building um but I think I still need to understand more um and I I think the bigger thing we also have to do is make sure that the community understands what we're doing um I think sometimes we have questions because people don't understand and so what I learned today is just a lot of people are confused whether it's false information that people are sharing they didn't know that these staff wouldn't be at the Wilson Center and that's really why I just have more questions than I thought I did does that answer it this is a good yeah this is a really good time though for us to focus on
173that right so this is the opportunity right now to be clear with the community about this information right so these are going to be in school positions not central office positions that correct the individuals are going to be prioritized and have first ISS I guess is the word that we said around these positions this is definitively needed because we are actually under the offices of the state due to gaps that we have in this particular process it is not actually inhibiting our ability to respond to ntss that was a comment that I heard in fact this is enhancing our ability to address that in fact because we have been needing to ask assist principles to support ncss this is what's driving us to a position where we need to beef this capability up within the
174schools um I think we've seen some concerns or comments about riffing a bunch of par professionals or something like that which is not what we're talking about that is not this process so so right now in my mind this is the opportunity to make things clear to the public about what this is and what we're trying to accomplish with it additionally I think what I'm I'm hearing this also came up during the board retreat is that we also have to address the fact that some of the K to2 schools are overstaffed is that also what I'm hearing is that some of why we look here as opposed to looking elsewhere um to i i i Illustrated that what we get from the state is as far as funding and how much over we are with
175um our school administration especially in at and so when we were looking at the achieve the student achievement Gap that was one of the the areas that we could really benefit from kind making sure that these positions are in direct proximity to our students and making the difference in closing that achievement Gap so and And to clarify so state funds 8.94 assistant principles at a total salary of $468,000 the district currently funds 16 assistant principles at a total salary of approximately $1.7 million and approximately of that 1.2 is funded locally so to make that plain our schools in the K2 do not earn an assistant principal because for some of them their enrollment is under 200 children and an assistant princi for a school that is that is that small is a very very costly
176price to pay for a small school model so that is where the board has to understand to keep a small school you still have over overhead and that overhead of a principal and assistant principal to the tune of what we are what we are um putting in our budget is very costly I think that and maybe this is a a follow-up question to that maybe more so for the superintendent is some of the concern from I think staff and other community members is if you if we pull the aps from the K2 schools we talked about how MPS and some of those things would be redistributed into that position but some of their other day-to-day operations um how do we anticipate that those will be handled every thinking that those will fall on the principal
177or and you may not have the answer now that may have to be long-term projection but I think that's also some of the concern is that you know ultimately when those positions are not there is it going to be more is it going to be unmanageable for the principles a school a traditional school has a grade level of 150 children 200 children most K5 schools have schools that are that large across the Metro there are multiple districts that are facing potential closures of schools because board is is combatting the fact that you cannot stand up a building with that children with all the overhead it takes to run the school now I am not suggesting that that is what we need to do but we do need to make a decision because we are locally
178funding 1.2 million and if you think about that for each and every K2 school where the probably Max enrollment is not even 250 children where most schools themselves a grade level is there well I mean I think that an alternative way to address this that you are not suggesting would be to close one of the elementary schools and reconsolidate I am not suggesting that you are not but the public should be aware that there is a set of decisions that we have to make about allocation of resources and where uh critical needs are highest and it sounds like our critical needs are highest around mtss and Equitable support for our students is a big part of what some of these APS are doing anyway we're repositioning around that and we're choosing to do that to
179continue to support I believe the community's wishes to maintain small local schools yes as opposed to closing a school which would involve you know basically riing all of the staff in that particular school and reconsolidating the students yeah how does this work procedurally because I mean I have a few other ideas and you know I realize we have an agenda and so how does this work procedurally then in terms of moving this item so if I am not comfortable approving it tonight what's the next upep make a motion so we can I think we can make a motion to move this one item I guess to be to next month if she if she gets a second yeah but then we would but she has to have a second then you have to have a
180second and would vote and so your legal council is providing there is a second take a vote if there is no second it fails for a second okay am I hearing this correctly and I'm sorry this is I'm learning this is the first time this will happen so if I say you know I would like to move this and someone else on the board says I too would like to move this and then we vote on it if I am the only one that wants to do that no one else does then it simply moves to consent agenda and we live on okay is there a preference if you want to make the motion you make it okay um well I'd like to move the uh student allotment guidelines to the January meeting that's my
181before we take that I do want to let you know the implications of moving that that means the School principles will not have their January meetings for their school allotments they won't get their allotments until February so that means your impact for your budget approval will move not from first draft in February but first draft in March so all of it's a domino effect because your school allotment guideline is presented for approval in now so that work can be done in January to give it the allotments to the school so that you can have a budget in February draft one draft two and so just want to make sure you all know that moves your entire hiring timeline down a month and so there is no other way to revisit the stuffel the guidelines after
182I've had time to consider all the questions without affecting those timelines that that that's the that's the impact or are there any other specific questions that you would like us to answer now yeah I mean I think what I'm hearing is we're funding our elementary schools and these at positions largely through local funds right you know I understand QBE but I think the question that I'm seeing in some of the communications has been a bigger question of how we're using local funds and QBE funds and so again I just am not comfortable approving this for the sake that we need to move on that timeline and at the same time I don't like holding up principles and hiring and I'm sorry for the quandry so would you like to proceed with your motion if so
183can you receive it sure I would like to revisit the staff allotment guidelines in January and I'm going to add something to the motion even if it inconvenience so that we can timeline that we need in the hiring process timeline we need okay so board member Anderson has a motion to move um consent a agenda item number six which is the fiscal year 26 School allotment guidelines off of consent agenda and move it to Jan January um is there second all right hearing none I believe the motion fails and this item will be moved to consent do I have that right legal thank you all right moving on to consent agenda item number seven intergovernmental agreement thank you inter governmental agreement for Legacy Park has been reached are there any comments or questions from the
184Board hearing none this item can be moved to consent agenda item number eight which is ground lease agreement for Legacy Park are there any questions or comments from the board I just want to make make it clear to the public that this was an executive session item do we need to be clear about that just so folks know that this has been reviewed under offices of exact session yes yeah we it was already on the agenda first it was in the publish agenda in the beginning because uh it was already published at the city so we just published the city's exact document so okay thank you any other comments or discussion from the board on consent agenda item number eight right hearing none this item can be moveed to consent yes uh Vice chair c
185may have you the recommendation yes please excuse me I recommend the city schools of the cater Board of Education approve the consent agenda items 1 through eight do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda which includes consent agenda items 1 through eight board member us make the motion do I have a second second or member John Davis makes a second are there any or questions hearing none all in favor motion carries unanimously uh moving on to Poli Dr Whitaker thank you Vice chair solson I would like to call on Mrs Amanda Lynch Chief of Staff to present four policies for second read action good evening again all tonight we have three policies for second read action each of these policies were presented last month for first read and have been available for public
186comment through assembly first we have policy jceb student hearing procedures we did receive one public comment through assembly the comment is itself did not address or provide suggestions to the actual policy have been shared with the board and appropriate staff members therefore no changes have been made to the version that was presented last month may I read the recommendations yes please I recommend the city schools at the cater Board of Education approved policy jceb student hearing procedures for Action thank you do I have a motion to approve the recommendation to approve policy jceb student hearing for procedures for Action so move board member Johnson Davis makes the motion do I have a second second uh board member us seconds the motion is there any discussion hearing none all those in favor I the motion carries
187unanimously second we have policy jqk exchange students no feedback was received through public comment and no changes have been made to the version presented last month may I read the recommendation yes please I recommend the city school to Ator Board of Education approve policy jqk exchange students for Action I have a motion to approve the recommendation to approve policy jqk exchange students for actions move for member us makes the motion do I have a second board member Anderson seconds the motion is there any discussion hearing none all those in favor I I uh the motion approved uh carries unanimously and and third we have policy J GSG student accents no feedback was received through public comment and no changes have been made to the version presented to the board last month may I read the
188recommendation yes please I recommend the city schools of decator Board of Education approve policy J GSG student accident for Action I have a motion to approve the recommendation to approve policy J gfg student accidents for action for member us make the motion do I have a second second Bo member Anderson second are there is there any discussion hearing none all those in favor Carri unanimously all right uh moving on to parliamentary procedure uh before we move to public comment we'll have a brief discussion regarding our parliamentary procedure for public comment during board meeting at our last board retreat we learned the phrase while this is a public meeting we are holding it it is a meeting of the board while this is a public meeting we are holding a meeting of the board in public
189therefore we must consistently Implement guidelines for audience members and those who seek to address the body as a whole regarding issues related to the city school ofor as a board we have outlined the following areas of improvement time limits sign up procedures maintaining order rules of the Corum and Personnel matters time limits time limits will be strictly enforced sign up for procedures planate procedures will be open until 1 hour before the start of the regular board meeting maintaining order the chair must ensure order is maintained the chair must enforce the board's established meeting rules to manage the public rules of the Quorum all public comment is directed to the chair not the audience all participants participants must adhere to proper meeting etiquette for example we rining from cheers Applause shouts from the floor Personnel matters
190Personnel matters shall not be discussed the board will not use will the board will use a broad def definition of personnel matters so no individual employee shall be named identified nor discussed um I would like to open it up to the board for comments and discussion I want to make sure that we're clear when we say broad definition and when we say no employee shall be named discussed or anything of those lines what we also mean is no invest no situation that exists that might be able to individually identify an employee we're going to be fairly strict about ensuring that if you're even getting close to that line we're going to be needing to close this down and I also want to clarify that community members are welcome to discuss their own experiences but they
191cannot mention ongoing Personnel issues so last month we had students that talked about their experiences here in the district um and if community members want to come and and um share those experiences and concerns with the board we are still open to hearing those um that commentary um but they cannot discuss Personnel if if I may Dr J Davis I would say more than open we are we welcome them coming to share those perspec I also think um we realized that we had some work to do in this area it was confusing for the public because public comage looked and felt differently based on different meetings sometimes we didn't enforce these rules the way that we should have uh they are in policy and our goal is to make it look consistent um by making
192sure that the details are there on respons the responsibility is ours to make sure that we are working consistently and sure the details are there that doesn't mean that we don't want to hear from the public but I think to this current topic when it comes to Personnel issues investigations um CC employees um I think it we want to be clear that it's not that we don't want to hear about employes what public comments is for and we're going to also be more intentional about being consistent with the time as uh community members are um sharing their commentary um we may we've just discuss different ways to do that to make sure that we are consistent perhaps the sound also going off when the clock ends um and then possibly the mic going mute um
193to make sure that we are being fair to everyone I think it's important to note that that we're doing sure we are fair to everyone we recognize that we haven't been great about that I think our default has been to try to be a accomodating and to try to be nice and to allow people to finish what they're trying to say and etc etc etc the outcome of some of these decisions is going to look and feel different in public comment we're going to be considerably stricter we're going to be considerably more concise and we're going to be considerably more consistent when folks are up here I just want to make the public aware that that that is going to be a little bit of the changes that you can anticipate seeing during public comments
194any other thoughts all right well we have five minutes until public comment Dr W do we have anybody signed up for public comments no uh Dr Sulton we do not okay we will move on to future date the next board meeting is scheduled for January 14th 2025 at the Wilson Center additionally on that day there will be a virtual uh househ 581 opt out resolution hearing at 10:00 a.m. and 6:45 p.m. the final final virtual hearing will be held January 21st 2025 at 6:45 p.m. there will be a community meeting at Glenwood Elementary School on January 22nd 2025 at 6:30 p.m. we where we want to engage with the community regarding the new Early Learning Childhood Center there being no further business this meeting is adjourned at 6:31 p.m.