CorpusRecord 179073

Public Hearing #2_ HB 581 Amendement 1/ 1 28 25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CCS -TV
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Coweta County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,267 words · about 41 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening welcome to the kaita County Board of Education agenda 829 public hearing on intent to opt out of homestead exemption 6:30 p.m. January 28th 2025 please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance in a moment of silence Al of the United States of America and to the repic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all seated have ation to approve agenda just speak so I seconded it all right I'll talk uh talk loudly until we get the mics going know they were working a little bit first off board members good evening um pleasure to be here with you again tonight to have our second public hearing on uh House Bill 581 um Mike if you'll go to the next slide just a reminder to everyone this is a state

002required process you can see um we're at January the 28th which is now our second public hearing after we had to reschedule one last week uh due to inclement weather and let's hope we avoid any more inclement weather uh for a very long time uh if you go to the next one there Mike uh you see the ad language there board members once again I'll call your attention to the ad language States the intent to opt out this language was provided to us by the state uh it is language that is required um the fact that it states that you intend to opt out doesn't mean that you have decided to do anything and once again I'll remind you there will be no vote taken tonight okay um this is a consideration process um the

003wording is what the wording is and it was provided to us we had no discretion in that Mike if you'll go the next one you can see the summary here of House Bill 581 uh it was designated as a Statewide uh homestead exemption however it has been um since related to us from the state that this is now considered a local uh exemption I'll get into a little bit later on what that means for us but it does have special meaning meaning for school districts ballot language there is verbatim from the actual ballot um that was voted on back on November 5th uh you'll notice there it calls for a Statewide exemption again they've clarified that that's now a local exemption It also says um that it serves to limit increases in the assess value

004of homesteads but which any County Consolidated Government municipality or local school system May opt out of upon the completion of certain procedures uh board members as we consider this we have to consider the entire language of the ballot not just a portion of that uh this was the actual language from the ballot uh that does allow for this process of consideration uh that we currently find ourselves in some other Provisions there uh it authorizes a special sales and use tax uh aimed at providing property tax relief uh that sometimes is referred to as a local option sales tax uh under this legislation uh that is uh provided to municipalities cities and counties school districts may not uh participate in the additional local option sales tax uh it actually revises some of the appeal process and

005requires that there be an economic analysis uh every couple of years um on any income tax credits so that is that is something else that's included in the legislation Mike did you go to the next one important dates of course I've already mentioned November 5th uh none of this process could start until January the 1st of 2025 and you can see there March 1st of 25 is the deadline uh for a school district or municipality um to opt out of the floating homestead exemption if they choose not to participate order to do that you have to have three hearings uh and you have to uh pass a resolution and get it to the Secretary of State's office process starts January 1 three hearings a public notice all of the Public Notices that you have seen

006uh that have run in the paper they are all prescribed uh under this legislation has to be 30 by 30 in has to run a certain period of time uh before uh the hearing itself and that has all been prescribed to us um by the state and by the legislation you can see a language there about issuing a press release simultaneously with the ads uh We've complied with all of that and then the filing of that resolution once again by March the 1st looking at potentially opting out if you were to choose to do so uh there are some potential outcomes of that maintaining local control over tax policy right now uh the Board of Education sets a millage rate for educational purposes uh in CWI County um it would maintain flexibility for future boards

007what I mean by that is uh school districts are different school districts have a cap on the number of Mills that they can Levy for educational purposes that cap is 20 you can you can move that millage rate either way and over the past 5 years you've lowered the millage rate uh to the lowest rate in 43 years here in caly County it's 15.41% cannot raise the rate any higher than that so it could uh create an outcome down the road where there is a expenses are going to keep going up they have revenues could um tighten down if you reach the mill cap down the road that's another interesting difference between school districts and cities and counties uh we have a cap on the number of Mills we can Levy cities and counties do

008not have that um a potential outcome of of opting out is um acknowledging the uniqueness of cwia County um business industry or parents they often come to us asking for uh specific programs um with specific needs uh and we have the flexibility under the current model uh to be able to adapt to uh whatever the circumstances here are uh in CWI County uh opting out allows you flexibility uh and greater long-term fiscal stability and sustainability I don't know that a more limited system um that restricts revenues would would necessarily do that for you uh and you have the ability to respond to local needs and local crises um that that's just a few outcomes of of opting out if you look at opting in there's the potential that the millage rate would need to go

009up um we don't know exactly what indicator they're going to use what inflationary indicator will be used uh to determine revenues uh down the road uh but it could lead to the millage rate needing to go up to be able to meet uh the the the demands that we have from an extense expense standpoint um if the cap is reached or once it's reached down the road the flexibility would would be severely limited uh and it would be very difficult to innovate and meet needs in times of Crisis um want to stop well go go the next one Mike we really don't know there's a lot that we don't know about the long-term impact uh if we were to opt in to 581 what we do know is based on this past Year's number uh

010that if we were in that system the estimated loss of Revenue based on 8.11% digest growth and 4.10% CPI which is an inflation indicator that the loss of funds to the district uh would have been approximately 17 .4 million I mentioned uncertainty on the index we're using CPI to make this determination but we don't really know whether they're going to use a national Regional what what inflationary measure will be used to calculate uh revenue for the district moving forward already mentioned uh property tax relief that's available to cities and counties it cannot help school systems to offset Revenue decreases if they opt into a house bill 58 1 and then I really don't know what could happen with future Market adjustments or recessions if that were to occur do want to give you really quickly

011an example of some of the budgetary um considerations that we often get into I know that sometimes people tend to think that when a budget goes up a certain number uh that that we're just making decisions to spend more money here at the local level I know that's a common narrative sometimes give an examp example last year last year our budget for personnel 2024 was $ 21,44 4,870 and FY 25 for personnel that budget is$ 268 m960 784 it's a difference of7 m515 9914 and remember enrollment stayed fairly level from last year to this year we had a bit of an increase last year the state uh in their budget uh passed on increase in the employer contribution for employee insurance cost the district $5.6 million State also passed on well-deserved salary increases to our

012teachers $5.7 million the system's contribution to the teacher retirement system increased $1.2 million step increase was provided to all employees with the exception of central office administrators none of those decisions were made locally it's $14.1 million in addition to that locally we did increase for the first time in about 15 years money for maintenance technology operations 2.85 million I share that with you as an example of decisions made at the state level that we're having to account for every year just last week we were informed that the cost of insurance for non-certified School Employees which is funded locally will increase to $1,885 per month on July 1st of 2025 originally it was going to be phased in over several years but now if the budget remains as is um it's going to be phased in

013in one year 6.6 million above what we will receive state funding for we're going to pay that it has to come from local funding it's significant for us it's a local responsibility and it's certainly not unusual you can go back through the past several years and see that these decisions are passed on to us and that we have to account for them we originally told it was going to be a phase in it would have been 2.1 million so now we're we're approximately 4 million more we're already planning to try to account for uh in our in our budget going into next year okay so I just say that to remind you that that sometimes we're kind of along for the ride a little bit and decisions that are made um at the state level

014we're having to account for them here uh and that's a good example of that mik go the next one could become more dependent on state funding if you were to choose to opt in to 581 more vulnerable to changes in those funding sources and I'm going to show you here in just a few minutes what's happened to those funding sources uh over the last several years uh could could make it if we're more dependent on state funding and that state funding shrinks or austerity Cuts come back in in the future I don't really know what that does to us our state funding system the QBE formula is not adjusted annually for inflation uh and I I don't know what the long-term Revenue impacts uh could be uh if we're limited I do know that we

015use local Revenue every year to offset um where the QBE doesn't factor in inflationary cost no considerations in QBE for enrollment uh we have to use or excuse me in 581 for enrollment uh that would have to be accounted for uh locally our tax digest is currently 73% residential uh so it very well could be a disproportionate impact if we opt in um unfunded State mandates and obligations I mentioned those just a moment ago uh it would be very difficult down the road potentially to respond to those go the next one Mike just some just some elements here I want to make sure to talk about you can see some definitions um one point I do want to make I know there has been some discussion about either in or out of 581 what that

016means for current exemptions nothing it means nothing you have a current exemption whether it's a veterans exemption uh homestead exemption senior exemption all of those exemptions remain intact so whether the board opts in or opts out no one is losing a current exemption one one thing I will mention to you is when you look at exemptions um if you were to choose to try to increase exemptions down the road and your revenues are limited you could find it difficult to want to do that if that makes sense okay ultimate flexibility allows for you to look at those exemptions if you want to choose to look down the road to do something different with any of those go to the next one Mike substantial property changes uh they they are pretty much under this legislation considered

017like they are uh under the current model if you make a substantial increase come out assess it and it would of course be adjusted the property assessment would be adjusted once you're into this you're in it uh once once um homeowners are eligible they're automatically into this system uh and automatically renew and they keep all other exemptions once again mik go the next one our millage history I just mentioned .41 it's the lowest in the metro area it's the lowest in uh 43 years here and we can't Levy more than 20 go the next one Mike that's just a chart that shows you the millage rate and an assessed home value go the next one surrounding millage rates and you can see we're very very comparable to uh to everyone else uh locally here till

018the next one Mike this is a line graph that shows you the millage rate over uh the better part of the last uh 43 44 years or so and you can see it's at its lowest rate that red line at the bottom uh is debt we have zero debt as a school system and haven't since approximately 2000 FY 2004 go ahead Mike once again shows you the the millage rate shows you when senior tax exemptions went in um and and just a good a good graph that shows you kind of where we are comparably uh over time go the next one there Mike austerity funding something I mentioned briefly earlier um state of Georgia uh from time to time will reduce uh education funding you can see there 2003 a couple million dollars uh that

019were taken out of QBE funding uh around FYI 200920 you can see those numbers uh tick up uh to over 15 million a year at one point that was in the height of the Great Recession uh so the state of course was squeezed at that time QBE was squeezed uh and local districts of course uh lost Revenue uh one one point to make here if you were to choose to opt in to 581 we just need to think about if if similar circumstance were to happen again uh what we would need to do to to account for those lost revenues without the flexibility locally to do so uh to your credit or to the former board's credit not all of you have been on that long um but during the Great Recession uh you held

020the rate uh we fured employees uh we did some things that need to do to be able to maintain 180 instructional days uh for our students in light of uh these these reductions in state funding millage rate again cap 20 you cannot have more than 15% uh of reserves in state law I've always found that interesting I read an article yesterday I believe the state has over 16 billion in reserve right now they don't have a reserve limit we do um you know small businesses my wife owns a small business they recommend three to six months I believe uh in reserve in a small business um are reserved about 6 to8 weeks and we're capped by law at that uh the Local 5 m share which I'll talk about a little bit more in depth

021here in a minute we pay that Local 5 mil share each year the equivalent of five Mills to participate in state funding that funding is used um to provide equalizations to other districts throughout the the state uh so so you take money from kawia in the form of 5 Ms uh and you send it to other districts in order for us to participate in state funding uh cities counties municipalities don't have to do that there is no local five share for them uh which for I think House Bill 581 purposes makes us different uh than them it's a very different conversation you see the number there that 5 mil share as the digest grows and the 5 mil share grows I mentioned earlier the distinction between uh a Statewide exemption and a local exemption now

022that they have come back and clarify that even though a Statewide exemption was voted on it's a local exemption the that means that the state gets that 5 mil share off of the gross digest before any local exemptions are applied okay so they're going to get the state money first local exemptions would be applied and then the school district get get it gets its funding you can see a couple years ago um our 5 mil share was 20 27.7 million uh it's now 46.7 million and we've seen a a three-year decrease in funding to The District in the form of 5 mil share uh it's 18.9 million Mr copelan uh sound like you're in a cave man I know is just turn it off and yell at me speak I know I asked a few

023weeks ago now did we ever get any Clarity on how the state was able to change the language from the ballot that we all voted on that state to local no sir I haven't haven't received any further Clarity on how that change could be made um from the ballot to to now um nobody seems to understand or no yes sir go the next one Mike and you can see this just a line graph from 93 uh until now and see see what our local fair share has done as as a digest grows that number uh will certainly continue to grow State funding I mentioned earlier you can see I think this is about uh 20 years ago I can't see the bottom there but State funding was 60.7% of our budget that's in 99200 you

024go to the next one you can see State funding uh what 20145 was 51. 36% of our budget and locals making up of course uh where state um reduces so 51.3 six local there is 38 give or take if you go to the next one Mike and you can see now State funding uh for this year is 46.2 two% of our budget so you can see where that number has been gradually squeezing or trending downward a little bit uh go the next one Mike just an article um our neighbor District fet they've had a 3% cap I think for the last three years I think they may be in year four now um and and there's an article there that references U some of the some of the revenue um considerations that or impacts that

025they have seen uh reduced positions uh I do think this this you know today we or right now we're having to have the conversation of opting in or out of 581 I think there is a separate conversation uh of of funding in general how schools in Georgia are funded in general um that's not a question we're going to be able to answer tonight um but it is um there are some real considerations or conversations that I think may need to be had down the road especially looking at um our own property here too I understand just like all of you do um and what we need to do to make sure that we can meet our obligations to our students uh and also be be responsible um to to our community quite frankly let's go

026to the next one there Mike millage rate is the to that you have uh to manage school system finances um you've heard this presentation I think three times now this is when I will say again you do not assess property you do not determine property value Boards of Education don't do that that's a job for the tax assessor um they determine property value you have no control over it um your only job from a system Finance perspective well two of them are to set the millage rate that is needed uh to be able to to um fund the operation of the school system and adequately uh educate our students and to set a budget those are the two Financial Obligations that you have again I'll say I don't know the long-term implications of of the

027new model there's there's a lot of unknown of the new model I've done as much research as I can do on it but I still don't have all the answers to the questions uh so so that's why I say there is concern about what it may mean uh for future boards and superintendent uh if you meet the millage rate cap local fair share continues to grow up school systems are not immune from inflation uh we are seeing Rising expenses we we are um a lot of them passed on to us through through no local Choice um I do think there's some concern if those expenses continue to rise as they have uh and and and we have to answer the question can we do um the things that we've we've done uh to have the

028type of school system that we want for our students in our community uh if we don't have the flexibility to meet the needs I think that is the ultimate the ultimate question I wish I had a better answer to the question a better answer to more question or to more questions about 581 um but but I don't last thing I'll say um is whatever another another concern with this whatever decision ision you make in the coming weeks under this legislation it is forever you opt in there's no other alternative if you maintain the current system there's been no other alternative provided it's a one-time deal to make this decision to opt in or to opt out and that's the way it that's the way it's written there is no come back down the road and

029we want to opt in later um there is no come back down the road if we opt in and we want to opt out later so it it's something we have to consider and it's a it's a momentous decision for you to consider uh over the course of the next several weeks and we have to have to have a decision have it to the Secretary of State by March the 1st uh with that board members I'll be happy to take any questions that you may have I do have a question uh Dr the Georgia promise scholarship that has just taken effect is that for 2025 or 2026 is it immediately now or do we know it will applications opened I think January and they will be enrolled after July 1 of 2025 so would be

030for next school year so we don't know what that does our budget right now no thank you don't all right thank you for your time all right thank you we'll move on now to the uh public comment portion of this meeting those Desiring to speak shall indicate whether they are for or against the issue involved and shall be limited to 3 minutes each first speaker is vason Smith members of the kawi County school system board I rise today to speak against the opt out because frankly I'll just make my first point known Defiance of the will of the people of the state of Georgia and of kawi County undermines our democracy we've heard a lot in recent months and years about protecting our democracy trying to preserve our democracy because it's so unique and wonderful

031but your actions can undermine our democracy if you do not adhere to the will of the people of kawi County and of the state of Georgia we vote for you to represent us on this board and we voted for Amendment one to make sure that we have full accountability of the funds and full accountability of the actions of the school board you refusing to adhere to our will is in defiance of our trust that we put in you my second point you work for us we don't work for you we elected you to this board to work for us on behalf of the kawi County School System opting out is in defiance of what we have given the Mandate that we have given to you thirdly opting out breeds mistrust in our local government systems

032and it breeds mistrust in our community Proverbs 29:2 when the righteous are in Authority the people Rejoice but when the wicked beareth rule the people mourn the board's decision to disregard again the will of the people who elected you will hurt our community it will breed mistrust in local governments and frankly I don't think anyone wants that you can do something amazing here you could set a president for integrity in the school board you can align yourselves with the voters you can align yourselves with the will of the people who employ you and you can do what's right you should respect the Democratic authority of the will of the people you should respect your voters and your fellow citizens in kawi county and you should not optt out my conclusion our democracy cannot function when

033our leaders defy the will of the people the board must must honor the vote and build trust in its community Through integrity and not undermine it through Defiance I yield my time Nathan Burns evening my name is Nathan Burns uh speaking against the motion to opt out uh ladies and gentlemen of the board you only sit here tonight because God has ordained it and because the citizens of the districts that you represent elected you and uh they did so hoping that you would do so in good faith your Covenant with those citizens if you will is to act according to their interests rather than your own a move to opt out of amendment one would be a violation of the trust that these people have placed in your leadership uh let's back up a bit

034and set the stage um so we can fully understand the shift that's occurred over the past few months um if you'll remember in August of last year U when both this board and the Board of Commissioners proposed a drastic millage rate increase you were met with pretty firm opposition uh the taxpayers of this County made it crystal clear that they were fed up with the the spending the bloat uh and the government of kaed County treating their bank accounts as their their own uh and then in November they sealed the deal with Amendment one in The Ballot Box in an effort to curb the theft occurring at every level of local government from the assessors all the way up to the board in short the citizens of your districts have made themselves abundantly clear and

035now you find yourselves at a Crossroads you could choose to govern honorably and respect the covenant made with those who elected you complying with their will rather than your own this is what um superintendent uh who introduced us this evening so tactfully put is restricting our revenues AKA the money that you steal from us or you could choose greed over honor and steal more and more from the very people who trust you to represent them justly this decision sets a precedent for how this board will govern how do you want to be remembered as greedy bureaucrats who defi the will of the people uh and who view our hard-earned dollars as your personal revenues or honorable representatives and neighbors who stewarded our resources wisely and placed our well-being and will above the County's coffers I

036pray you'll choose the honorable path thank you brt Frost good evening board and good evening everyone I would like to address and I speak in opposition to the opt out as you might well have imagined the Practical consequences of opting out of this in terms of some of the more vulnerable members of the community as the superintendent was so kind enough to point out we have been experiencing for lack of better term back lack of a better term a flatlining in enrollment and as a result we can look to National Trends to anticipate that continuing as you all are well aware for decades now the birth rate has been falling and so with each succeeding generation fewer and fewer students are entering our student population and our population is going to get older it's going

037to have more retirees and the populations that are most negatively impacted by property taxes as you well know are the retired and the young specifically young couples I dare say many if not most of the members of this board have children or even grandchildren who are at that time of life when they're trying to buy their first home and I don't need to tell you about housing prices in this County if we are going to continue to be a place that is welcoming to the very people whom we are enjoying the blessing of their revenue I.E the retirees we ought to be very conscious of the fact that this program of continuously Rising property taxes and real dollars not talking about the military and real dollars will potentially drive them into other counties I dare

038say everyone here tonight on and off the stage has a friend who has moved to herd Merryweather Spalding County or some other County because it's getting too crowded here and the cost of living is going up in Cita County at some point you got to draw the line and remember retirees don't put their kids in school but everything they contribute to the school system is a net benefit to the school system if we continue to be a community which is welcoming to them we need to be cognizant of that also kawia county has one of the largest populations of private and homeschooling constituents again people who do not cont who do not partake of this government service yet they pay the tax if we are going to drive away populations that do not partake of

039the service yet they pay into it we are going to be left with more and more loss again how do we justify a flatlining population continually raising taxes and revenue off of a population which is needing the service less and less of course at the end of the day it's up to you to decide but remember the same voters who elected you voted for this so if the voters as I assume all of you would agree you would all say that the voters were intelligent they chose you if they were intelligent when they chose you surely they were also intelligent enough to vote and mean what they said when they voted against for this reduction in the ability to raise taxes thank you Thomas countis good evening ladies and gentlemen thank you for your time

040I am speaking in opposition of the opt out this uh this evening I do want to just provide a simple call back to the responsibility that's been given to you and to some biblical stewardship as many of other speakers have mentioned the positions you guys have been put in is ordained by God governing bodies including this school board here are divinely appointed to serve the good of the people that have put them in those positions this role is as a steward and not as a sovereign ruler this person is supposed to be a caretaker and prioritize the needs of the people that have put them in this position if this governing body were to ignore the will of the people that was voted on it disregards the Divine Purpose of the authority that's been given

041to you opting out of amendment one would destroy as many of the other speakers have said would destroy the trust that has been placed in you a call to stewardship this evening as well is in order in Luke chapter 14 the scriptures say for which of you Desiring to build a tower does not first sit down and count the cost wise stewardship requires careful planning and evaluation of resources ensuring that financial decisions are prudent and sustainable the decision to preserve unchecked budgets without considering the financial strain that it puts on families in this community in my mind shows poor stewardship the rich rules over the poor and the borrower is the slave of the lender excessive taxation by which in any other ages we would all say we are under burdens the families in this

042community it leads to increased debt and financial instability by raising these property taxes or providing the opportunity to to preserve the revenue as it's sometimes put puts the board in the position to put families in financial bondage undermining the ability ability for the families to thrive and for new families to want to come into our community this school board's task is not simply to fund the programs but to figure out a way to do so that respects the will of the people and prioritizes the dollars that we've entrusted to you prioritizing excess Revenue over careful management shows a failure in the stewardship Department I've mentioned families several times the families are the Cornerstone of both the church and our community here and the families have been ordained by God to nurture their children and raise

043them up in the fear and admonition of the Lord the families and their children are one day the future voters and future council members future citizens of kawi County the home again that I mentioned is being threatened by some of these increased taxes is a sanctuary where children are raised and families are built by increasing these taxes and pumping revenues up again this board threatens the stability of the home I yield my time thank you Barry Roland I came to speak because I heard two points made in a previous board meeting that concerned me the first point of concern is that you are 1% under the budget this year when reporting the budget it seemed the board was happy to be only 1% under the budget if you are you certainly should not be I

044suspect none of you spend 99% of your income in save only 1% any good financial planner or business will tell you to have at least 6 months worth of income saved for un unexpected expenses or downshifts in the economy this should be easy given the windfalls of East BL and now tax on liquor sales personally I believe your job just like a business or the military is to provide an excellent service or in your case excellent education at the least cost not spending every dollar that you take in the second point of concern is that opting in is forever opting in is not forever I repeat opting in is not forever there are no laws that can't be changed by the will of the people the taxpayers of this County are smart and will know

045when we are hurting our children children and the school system just like you the voters have spoken to opt in and I hope you will honor our wishes Linda mink thank you um love the comments that have come before me and I agree with every one of them and Mr superintendent I got to say something I've never heard the phrases could be maybe perhaps I don't know your entire presentation was full of unknowns what I do know is that the children belong to the parents they do not belong to the government they do not belong to the school system the school system has their enrollment full-time student enrollment has been stagnant for 12 years while the population growth full-time student enrollment in homeschooling classical education in private schools it has consistently gone up it has

046not gone down your job board is to supervise him and tell him what to do he doesn't tell you what to do you tell him get your roles clear because he's not your boss these people out here we're the boss we decide whether or not you get elected to your position and how you do your duties and we're judging you right now the other thing I'd like to point out you want to cut your budget start with central office cut the Staffing by 50 % taste the rest of you and cut their salaries by 25% you talk about budgets what do you think the families of these children are going through they're they're balancing a lot more than this school board and this school system ever has they're balancing Transportation time clothing shoes after school

047care utilities mortgages rent food everything that goes with it a lot more than you've got on your plate and those are just single family households or senior citizens that are on fixed incomes listen to the voters we have given you a mandate we've given you that mandate we voted for it you need to listen to us thank you Lori Nome uh my name is Lori Nome and I'm vot I'm speaking against the measure the kawia County Board of Education Works at the pleasure of the kawia county school superintendent that is not how it is supposed to be the a county school superintendent is supposed to work at the pleasure of the kawia County Board of Education but that is not how it is done in kawi County perhaps you're not familiar with other counties and

048their Boards of Education the superintendant Do not sit with the board during the board meetings board meetings yes he has things he must talk about things he must present if you will to the board but the superintendent normally do that from a seat somewhere else in the room so they can be called on when needed this is a board meeting yet we have the superintendent right up there with the board as though he is a part of them he is not they are elected we can do something about that he is not the kawi County Board of Education really doesn't work they do what they are told by our school school superintendent have you ever seen any of our board members vote no vote against something the superintendent asked them to vote for I cannot

049remember a time have you ever seen any of them ask a question that really matters I cannot remember a time yet they voted themselves a salary a year or so ago for doing basically nothing but attending a meeting once a month sometimes more often and for doing what they are told to do by the superintendent when they ran for those offices it was a voluntary position and now we come to this the superintendent cannot abide what 51,000 kaita county voters said they wanted he is asking our board actually he is telling our board to vote to withdraw from what 51,00 voters said they wanted he doesn't care he doesn't want the measure that we the taxpayers voted on and approved now it is law yet he is telling the board to withdraw from what the

050kawi counter kawia County voters wanted and they will do it because he told them to they always do watch [Applause] next name is Carrie and I apologize I can't read the last name we have a Carrie okay yes good evening Carrie sunvold I am against opting out so when I think about Community what I think about is being helpful to a neighbor being welcoming to a new neighbor what I do not feel welcoming is increasing the tax burden on uh the community members um we have people in the community who do well we have people in the community who get by we have people in the community who struggle I know from a healthc care standpoint I hear stories all the time it's heartbreaking about the struggle as taxes have gone up or inflation excuse

051me has gone up more and more people are moving into that struggle I hear stories of patients excuse me who do not feel their prescriptions or delay filling their prescriptions because they need to pay a bill I hear stories of patients choosing less nutritious food affecting their health because they need to pay a bill I hear stories of people avoiding going to see a doctor because there's a co-pay because they need to pay a bill these are struggling individuals increasing the burden on these people do not help the community members it does not help the community it is a bad look on Cita County people may choose to move to another County they will take their revenue with them when you buy into a community you spend your money in that Community you buy groceries

052sure you going to travel you're going to buy gas somewhere else but the majority of your stuff is in C County that produces revenue for the county if they move somewhere else they take their Revenue with them I am heartbroken for these people who struggle I feel a burden for them I have a grandmother she's not in this state but I feel she struggles all the time I send her money to help her I don't know how many people can send money to help their family members because that has become more and more of a burden on People based off of food gas etc etc I ask that you listen to my words as coming from my heart I have a passion for people in the healthcare field that's why I'm here and I yield

053my time thank you Bruce draber thank you for the opportunity to speak I appreciate that and uh I honestly signed on the sheet up front because I didn't know what to expect uh this was a kind of a placeholder uh in case I did want to participate and speak in front of y'all the folks that came in front of me said it more eloquently than I ever could um I didn't have a speech planned for this this was just as I said kind of a placeholder so I'm going to yield the rest of my time to the folks that are prepared and are going to better convey our thoughts to you than I could so thank you for the opportunity I Yi my time Jimmy deuk my name is jimy debuk I'm opposed to opting

054out I want to thank y'all for the job y'all have done you're smart people I know you're smart go the citizens voted you in please be smart enough to give the will of the people what they want I was looking around and I seen some folks here Whitehead just like me we live in a county that we at 70 still pay school taxes even though it's elevated other counties clayon County at 65 you're exempt the other gentleman said that we're going to be exempt are or nothing's going to change as far as if you opt out as far as Social Security not Social Security the senior citizen discount or the homestead it may not change getting it but the percentage you pay is not it's going to change so please do the right thing and

055give the will of the people thank [Applause] you believe it's Chris Petri yeah I'm Chris Petri uh just by a show of hands how many people are opposed to this just curious okay uh and three minutes um I think everybody else has pretty much said what I wanted to say um I've lived in this County since uh bought property here in 2015 and my property taxes already overd doubled since 2015 uh I don't quite understand everything with the pro and and the cons of this but if 60% of the people voted to uh you know keep the homestead exemption the way it is or I guess the on the state level the way that they're doing it now uh I suppose that's that's the will of the people and that's the way we should go

056um I heard the superintendent say you know teachers deserve more when he was up here talking and uh you know it sounds good when when people say that but uh I'm not really quite sure what deserves more means and when you take from all of us to give to them there's got to be some kind of a balance uh the coy County school system and school systems in general they are they're socialist programs and so I like to see them kept down to as low as we can and and if that means you know doing what 60% of the county said and that helps keep our taxes lower let's do that you know between federal state sales tax all these different taxes that we have uh it ends up being about 50% of what I

057make every year and when somebody takes everything you make you're a slave so what do we call somebody who loses 50% of what they make that means if I got to work 300 plus days out of the Year roughly 150 60 of those days are to the state and to the federal government and so you know if there's a way to keep these taxes lower uh you know do more with less I was a marine I I had to train with gear from Vietnam when I went in uh for um operation Iraqi Freedom we trained with with gear from Vietnam uh because uh we had to do more with less we didn't want to go back to the taxpayer and say we need more money for fancier gear that may have been the Army Air

058Force and all them I don't know but as a marine we did more with less so I'm going to ask the county county school system to do more with less thank you Alan Brady good evening ladies and gentlemen thank you for the opportunity to speak I'm against opt out in the last couple of weeks I've seen and heard a lot of discussion regarding optin versus opt out some of the most interesting was what several Georgia legislators that were involved in getting HB 581 passed and Amendment one on the ballot had to say about it what they said sounds a lot like what a lot of people around here are saying including this in this room they describ the current campaign to opt out mostly by school system as Scare Tactics one of the common ones

059is that money will be lost by the system if they opt in and a number in millions of dollars that would have been lost had the assessment rate increased limits been in place previously is given number I heard here was 17.4 Million for last year a more accurate and honest way of describing these losses would be how much less the increase would would be but even if it resulted in less property tax revenue than the prior year how much do you really need the County government has decided to opt in as of all the local municipalities I saw where the city of New n was considering a freeze on property taxes maybe even setting their millage rate at zero and replacing that Revenue with a sales tax fet has a freeze as have over 30

060other Georgia counties including a number of our large neighbors to the north somehow these count ioun are getting by maybe a more thorough examination of the school system budget and some belt tightening is in order just like the C's done something interesting about the comments from these uh state legislators in their description of how the opt out option came to be in the first place the original bill that came out of the Senate did not include an opt out option in the house some arm twisting was applied by various associations and Wella an opt out provision appeared but the legislators legislators who supported the original Bill still have something left up their sleeves they're saying that if school systems opt out they will apply legislation that will force a freeze on homeowner values in their

061District maybe something like that could happen here too The Winds of Change are a blowing these days rather than all this Con contentious scorched Earth stuff there is another way school board can recognize both CWI County and state of Georgia over overwhelmingly voted for reasonable limit to assessment increases for homeowners only for only as long as they live in their homes ask the school board to be reasonable also recognize the voice of the people and vote to opt in not opt out thank [Applause] you next name I can't really read perhaps it's Rose it's the last name we get to the end Maxwell Britain uh good evening I'm against opt out um let's talk facts not excuses you the kaeda County School Board are on the verge of betraying 51,000 voters who overwhelmingly approved Amendment

062one this isn't just a policy decision it's a blatant slap in the face to the people you were elected to serve in a betrayal of public trust Amendment one wasn't ambiguous it was a clear Mand mandate to cap property taxes and protect families and retirees from skyrocketing costs every County in Georgia supported it because homeowners are tired of being taxed out of their homes yet now you're considering undoing their vote scrapping their relief and shielding a bloated budget let's be honest this isn't about the kids it's about protecting the cash here's the truth you don't want to face property tax revenue has skyrocketed 64% in just six years from 86.4 million in 2018 to 142 million in 2024 enrollment is flat test scores are stagnant and Teachers Pay has barely budged so where's all the

063money going superintendent Horton earns $340,000 annually one of the highest salaries in the state and will collect $888,000 every year for life in retirement with that number increasing the longer he stays senior administrators take home six figure salaries with perks and even you the school board now pay yourselves and here's the ticking Time Bomb if just 10 administrators retire with Horton level benefits taxpayers will be on the hook for 2.5 million annually money that will never touch a classroom talk about unsustainable when salaries and pens pensions grow this large it creates a conflict of Interest decisions that should prioritize students in schools instead prioritize personal gain that's unacceptable we've heard you claim that Amendment one will cause lost Revenue translation you'll lose automatic tax hikes from rising property values and might actually have to justify

064your spending heaven forbid that you make your budget decisions public let's be real opposing your opt out of amendment one doesn't mean voters hate highquality Public Schools that's absurd as saying Farmers hate rain we don't hate good schools we hate wasteful priorities voters want tax relief because they're fed up with a bloated bureaucratic system that punishes homeowners especially fixed income seniors with endless tax increases respecting the voters isn't an anti-education it's anti- waste if you vote to opt out of amendment one you're telling this community loud and clear we don't care about your vote um be at the meetings on Fe February 4th and February 11th coming up um demand that the school board honor our vote no opt outs share this message with every homeowner retire and voter in kawia County this is our

065community our money and our future if you think the people of kawia County will forget this by election time you're dead wrong let's remind you who holds the power not the superintendent not the board Mr Britton thank you but we the people Nicholas Snider good evening I'm speaking I'm Nicholas Snider and I'm speaking against the intent to opt out and I appreciate the presentation earlier and the and I really appreciate the balanced budget the physical responsibility that has been kept here by the school board that is appreciated um and having lived here in Quita County since 2003 I have witnessed an increase of population Home Building liquor stores indust you name it it's all come in increasing uh revenues uh for the school board and the county uh I heard in the presentation that uh

066there's rises in inflation there's possible crisises that could occur uh that could raise the cost for the school system uh which likely means that in some cases uh that's also occurring for a lot of the folks here in this room and for the citizens of the county and if that's the case will the school system will just need to cut cost just like the folks here in this room and in the county now the chart that was presented also showed that uh that compared K County the other counties that surround us and show that we have a low millage rate and that's good and K County should be a benchmark for doing it better than the surrounding counties that other counties should aspire to be more like K County uh not that we should raise

067the rate to be the same as the surrounding counties it was also shown in the presentation that fet had to cut cost and positions I don't know have the actual numbers but I think that F county has seen a reduction in public school enrollment which again shows that when that occurs the school system is forced to reflect the district as a whole so the school district has the largest budget and handles the most money from the property taxes that are collected for the entire County you guys handle the most of our money so that's a huge responsibility and I pray that uh that you'll continue to hold the line on cost and cap your ability to increase Revenue more than 3% a year thank you Eve Olen hi I am against opting out um I

068don't want a certain group thinking that this is any way an alliance between me and them but when you see me and Linda mink come together at um against uh a uh an issue I think you should pay attention um and because Linda mink would know that these seats are what we want um you guys represent us and uh I'm glad um that Mr Horton brought up uh Personnel because I want um you to know that the many citizens um that are in this room and in this County our property taxes increased during an inflation and now we're struggling to pay for food utilities and even our housing homelessness is on the rise and some here recently gave themselves a raise it's very important that you guys listen to who put you here and I

069I leave these things Neil Sullivan Neil Sullivan not here okay do we have somebody that signed up that the one that I couldn't read the name Rose that wanted to speak no okay just thank you for coming out and speaking tonight we appreciate it do we have any board comments no okay action will be taken yeah two more hearings yeah we're going to have two more hearings we're going to have uh February 4th and February 11th we have a school board meeting the regular scheduled meeting on uh February 11th Tuesday we'll have some more comments by then thank you that evening correct yeah we have a meeting at 12: p.m. February February the 4th at 6: p.m y uh February the 11th at noon and then the regular board meeting for February will be held

070at 6:30 p.m. uh on that night if we decide to move forward one way or the other one way or the other just need a motion to adjourn we have a motion to adjourn we have a second you have a second I'll second all any discussion any discussion no all right vote six to nothing all right

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.