CorpusRecord 179075

December Board Meeting 12 10 24 1

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CCS -TV
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Coweta County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,611 words · about 54 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001our call to order this meeting of the K County Board of Education agenda 824 6:30 p.m. December 10th 2024 please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance followed by a Moment of Silence thank you you may be seated is there a motion to approve the agenda so move second any discussion all those in favor motion carries s to zero recognitions DR Horton thank you Mr chair at this time I'll call on Public Information officer Dean Jackson to bring us our recognitions of which we have several tonight Mr Jackson thank you DR Horton board members we do have several recognitions tonight and our very first one is our Core Business we have the Nunan High School chorus who are here tonight to kind of get us into the spirit of the season and I'm going to call

002on newon high school principal Jamal KMP to recognize good evening everyone I'm Dr Jamal KMP principal of Nan High School what a great way to start the the board meeting as we get to hear some wonderful voices of non and high school the 5-year kawi County School System strategic plan emphasizes and measures Advanced opportunities for all students that encourage creativity Innovation and the collaborative problem solving we at nun and high school have identified using cross-curricular approaches to build community and to enhance student performance in math Ela as a point of emphasis in our school Improvement plan for the 20242 school year as part of our focus in this area we are highlighting the Nan high school performing arts department as we understand that a course program can help students with cognitive development through improved memory

003pattern recognition and language skills as well as support critical thinking through interpreting music additionally applying team problem solvings through collaborative efforts and resolving harmonies and perfecting Dynamics in a group setting parallel problem solving activities in all content areas even our core areas of math and Ela Miss Robbins newon High School Core Music director is here with her students this evening to share one example of the work that is being produced at nonon high school hello we are delighted to be here this evening and grateful for the opportunity to share with you the exciting achievements of the Performing Arts students at Nan high school over the past six weeks we have celebrated a number of milestones in our brand new Auditorium the theater program presented the first play A Wrinkle in Time on the new stage

004our band held its very first concert of the year the chorus produced the first musical The Adams Family and most recently we hosted Nan sings an Acappella Festival involving nearly 200 singers from Nan high school and Evans madress and Smoky Road Middle School choirs the motto of the Nan chorus is building community Through music the chorus students and I were thrilled that our first concert in the new Auditorium reflected that mission and included so many singers from across the nonon community I am honored to introduce one of our chorus members Emil Brown a is a member of tonality our Advanced treble chorus Viva our treble Acappella quartet and also serves as an officer in the Nunan Coral Council this past summer Emil represented kawia County as a participant in the governor's honors program earlier this

005fall she was selected by her peers as the 2024 Nan High School homecoming queen in October Emil was featured in the principal role of mortia Adams in our production of The Adams Family she is here to share with you her experiences and Reflections as a member of the Nunan chorus Emil singing is a transformative power each moment that I have sung in chorus whether that have been at one of our fall musical rehearsals or even at our first vocal concert this year n and sings I have truly come to treasure growing and working with my peers from collectively working to build our musicality to fostering new connections with those around me the community that I have worked to build within my program has been such a highlight in my life to dare to make people

006more understanding through singing to take on being the Storyteller in a musical and to see life from a different perspective these are the strengths and opportunities that I've been given as a part of N and chorus so through music not only have I had the privilege of welcoming new people into my circle every year but I can also say that because of it I have been changed for good music has changed me for good Miss Robins has changed me for good and my peers my friends have changed me for good thank you very much on behalf of all the Performing Arts students and my colleagues at Nan high school I'd like to express my sincere gratitude and thanks to DR Horton the kaita County School Board the Nunan High School administration led by Dr Kemp

007and the entire Nunan family for their support of the Performing Arts the new Auditorium is an incredible facility that will support the growth and showcase the achievements of kaita County students for decades to come tonight we have a few chorus students who would like to share a brief performance with you from their upcoming Christmas show The Most Wonderful Time of the Year thank you again for the opportunity to be here this evening [Music] on an open [Music] Knows turkey and [Music] know [Music] know how to fly and soer this [Music] praise2 [Music] Al many many Merry Christmas Merry Christmas Merry Christmas to [Music] [Applause] thank you nun in high school for our next presentation tonight speaking of uh seasonal um uh Traditions that we've had for sometime we have a visit from the kawia county

00848 tonight I'm going to call on Bill Hammond for uh County Extension agent to talk about our longstanding partnership with them and with 4 in our community thank you for coming tonight thank you uh and as always we come bearing treats um a as a as a thank you for your support for the kawia county 4 um kawi County 4 of course we go into all of the fifth grade classes um every month to teach science and English language arts lessons um for the past couple months we have been working on public speaking that's part of uh part of one of our competitions called project achievement so in Project achievement um students learn to uh to compile thoughts do research um create visual aids and then give presentations uh this starts of course in in

009fifth grade for most of our students um they can do it again in sixth grade when they get to seventh grade there's an added component of a uh portfolio which is a compilation of all of their accomplishments in their chosen project for the year um when they go to high school I tell them the stakes get bigger because if they win at District level they can move on to state congress in Atlanta this past year we had four high schoolers go to state congress and three of them actually advance to National Congress so they won at the state level um today I have with me Ryder who's one of our fifth graders at anco Sergeant uh one of Miss brightman's students um um this past month we listened to a lot of fifth grade presentations

010and writers was one that that stood out to me so I invited Ryder to come with me this evening so I'd like to turn the time over to Ryder to give his wonderful presentations on chickens hi my name is Ryder Moore and today I will be talking to you about chickens did you know there are 2656 billion chickens in the world crazy right but today I'll be talking to you about chickens on how to house them what to feed them and what's the difference between free ranged and pasturised chickens where to house them chickens need a warm well ventilated house they need a big enough entrance to pass through for their space chickens need to exercise stretch their wings and Carry Out normal chicken behavior and for their covered flooring it should be covered with

011dry materials such as wood shavings or straw and a purge so the chickens can Roost comfortably they also need a nest box for the hens to lay their eggs in a closed box with comfortable nesting material what to feed your chicken H what to feed your chickens high quality feed you can purchase at many pet stores other treats are seeds fruits and vegetables they can also eat grass weeds and grubs and some stuff you shouldn't feed your chickens like onions chocolate or processed food what's the difference between free ranged and pasture raised chickens free R chickens are outdoor part of the day and in their cop the other half pasture R chickens are out out outside all day which they have more space to forage and a better diet and their eggs may have higher

012nutrient value today I talk to you about how to house them how to house your chickens what to feed them and what's the difference between Freer ranged and pastor rased chickens so did you know there are 2656 billion chickens in the world so here's a tip if you get any chickens make sure to give them space to Forest room to room and and ex room to room to exercise and good [Applause] food so on behalf of um of our Cy County 4ers thank you for your support um I've got a box of cookies I also have a card that's been decorated by uh Journey dukes and Audrey cubon from cubison from Willis Road Elementary Rider I have listened to a lot of presentations and judged a lot of presentations and you did an excellent job

013so thank you be proud of [Applause] it thank you Ryder Mr Hammond thank you 4 we appreciate that we have uh for our next uh recognition tonight we're going to call on East kaita High School to recognize the Georgia class 6A Georgia softball championships the East Gita High School lady Indians we have principal Steve Allen coach Franklin D delach members of his staff ask them to come on down and introduce and PR BL if you don't mind could you also recognize Haley while you're here too yeah goe do that let me do that before we start guys guys we uh we have young lady Haley f is and I think maybe most of you have met Haley who hasn't Haley's one of our exceptional students uh at East CWI high school she has been named

014to the uh uh super State superintendent uh advisory uh Council now she she couldn't be here tonight she is dancing at the ball game um and so she wanted I we just want to make sure we recognized her uh for her accomplishments she's awesome 11th grader all right moving on eight years three three run uh three runner up and four state championships these people sitting behind me it's an amazing feat proud to be a principal of East kaita High School known Franklin Deo for 25 years uh this is is his 25 uh 25th season uh at the helm the coach I'm going to I want everybody just to please uh it's it's really um great feat uh what these young ladies have done over the past few years and what these coaches have put into

015them uh over these past few years so uh with further Ado I want to introduce coach Franklin dut school superintendent Dr Evan Horton um Dr Mark gu school board thank you so much for having us here tonight it's just really an honor and a privilege and before we get started the girls if you guys we have something small GI for you guys for having us here tonight and just want to say thank you and we'll go ahead and get those to you want to also send a sincere thank you to our school board um for an awesome facility we have you know um we're so proud of it and uh I was just telling someone just last week I was at a meeting in make and and uh how I feel like we might have

016just we might just have the best high school softball locker room in the state and um and we're so thankful for that in the Press Box and and and and everything and and it's uh we're so we're so thankful for that um going to introduce some of the girl or the girls here um and girls I think we just want them to walk up and um we went 37-1 like uh Mr Allen said won the state championship in 6A um overcoming the University of Buford which is Quite a feat um and so we're and it was it was awesome I think the three games we played them there in Columbus uh was a two to nothing win uh a one to nothing loss in the bottom of the seventh and then the third game we

017we beat them four to three so we're very proud of these young ladies uh first one uh freshman Payton Wilson uh pton was our starting left fielder pton also as a freshman uh just uh received the honor for second team also state which is quite an honor for a freshman uh senior Madison duffel Madison uh is assigned to go play softball next year at Georgia Tech uh she's First Team all state um Junior McKenna Holmes mcken is one of our pitchers went five and0 on uh during the year in the circle for us uh junior Kate Miller starting centerfielder um made that last awesome catch that final out of the Season that uh we we're still talking about that catch uh junior Addie jiner our starting catcher uh she's already committed to play softball at

018the next level at Mercer University uh also uh second Team all state Andy Joiner uh senior Lizzie alustin starting right fielder uh Lizzie has already signed to go play softball next year and continue her education at the University of West Alabama uh junior Gabby gpy Gabby was our was our starting third baseman um Gabby had a wonderful season for us we have some freshman here um that helped help helped us out a lot gave us some debt key Gardner um Izzy kellerer could not be with us tonight kayn Bowen we also have a junior Cameron Horton one of our pitchers she went 5-0 uh during the season in the circle Forest we have a senior couldn't be with us tonight um Riley Gordy um we have another fresh uh sophomore Excuse Me Avery Batton senior

019mattye weathers uh Mattie has already signed to play uh softball next year continue her education at Jacksonville University uh Maddie was our starting first baseman who also second Team all state um Junior Payton Robertson uh pton uh First Team all state um has already committed to continue her education and play softball as well At Mercer University um Junior Addie Hal Addie is uh gives us gave us a lot of depth uh around the roster senior Jenna Hamley Jenna platooned a lot with us for us out out in the Outfield had a great season for us and Junior Jada Savage uh Jada was uh state of Georgia highest classification pitcher of the year uh um voted on by the coaches across our state J's already committ committed to play softball After High School and continue her

020education at Old Miss and yeah and Senior uh greatest manager I've ever had and I mean it 20 28 years baseball and softball Lany Blair so proud of Lanny so again just want to thank you guys for having us tonight and also would like to introduce our coaches couldn't do it without him uh coach Brandon Blair coach you guys stand up for us here please coach Kyle Bowman and Coach Blake Summers and Coach Tyler Ridgeway as well as coach Mark BS right here thank you guys so much for having us tonight stand [Applause] all right thank youall for coming and congratulations coaches and players thank y'all very much uh our next recognition Mr Jackson I'll take this one uh to get us kicked off here our next recognition tonight uh is to recognize the first

021cohort uh of our Georgia's best uh graduates from the University of West Georgia uh the caly County school system and the University of West Georgia entered into a partnership um almost two years ago uh where we would um take staff members and and assist them with getting Advanced degrees in exchange for um them uh committing to work for the school system for an additional 5 years in order to shore up some of our high need areas I'm proud to recognize uh the first uh group of of graduates tonight um this group's a little bit off schedule they're a little bit ahead of schedule the biggest group will come in the spring uh but along with that want to make sure I introduce uh some great some great partners of ours uh Dr David Buckman associate

022Dean for Partnerships at the University of West Georgia Dr Logan Arrington uh he's the interim chair of the education technology and Foundations Department of over there Dr Kathy green uh who's interim chair of the special education department Miss Anita Williams uh who uh assists Dr Buckman she's the coordinator of strategic Innovation and external uh Partnerships uh and then my good friend uh dean of the College of Education Dr Mike Dishman I'd like to recognize them have them uh come down we're going to ask Dr Karen Barker assistant superintendent uh for curriculum instruction to come down introduce our our graduates and board members if you would we're all going to go down so we can uh shake their hand so let's go down as the board members are coming down graduates as I call your name

023you will come down this aisle and then receive your stole and pin and shake hands really quickly Dr Barker while while everybody's getting organized if you are a spouse other family member coworker of any of these graduates that supported them along the way stand up for us make sure we recognize thank youall very much and the pen right all right Kay Brewer is Kaye here Jimmy Brown you're first next Emily Bine next Kylie Cody Adrien Colton I'm sorry I went too Felicia Dunson congratulations Delaney Frank yat Aaron Hill Courtney Kawa k L kite Ashley paa Julia Powell Jennifer power Jennifer Reed Nicholas Tinky conratulations Dorian Venable and Aaron wol Phil I don't think she can make it I think that's it congratulations to our graduates [Applause] so two years ago um at the recommendation of

024Dr Horton and I stood before this board and asked you to make a commitment to your teachers that was truly historic in scope and you all were one of the first Two school boards in the state of Georgia to make the commitment to its teachers and this is a wonderful thing that we have with George's best but it would be impossible it would be nothing but a vision except for the courage and the support of your school board thank you for all you do for your teachers is there a motion to approve the minutes of November 12th 2024 so moov second any discussion all those in favor motion carries 7 to zero action item group one Dr Orton thank you Mr chair the first item I have for you in group one is to approve

0252025 Board of Education meeting dates times and locations uh the Cy County Board of Education regular meetings will be held on the dates listed below at 6:30 p.m. at the central office located at 167 wors Industrial Boulevard noon 30263 January 14th of 2025 February the 11th 2025 March the 11th 2025 April 1st of 2025 and please note everyone that we Chang that date to the 1 Tuesday in April uh due to the spring break which is the second Tuesday uh May 13th of 2025 June 10th 2025 July 8th 2025 August 12th 2025 September 9th 2025 October 14th 2025 November 11th and December 9th 2025 Mr chair I recommend approval of these dates for regular Board of Education meetings thank you Dr Orton uh you've heard the recommendation of the superintendent to approve the 2025 Board

026of Education meeting dates times and locations is there a motion for approval so move second is there any discussion all those in favor motion carries 7 to zero the next item I have for you in group one is to appoint Cy County's 2025 Georgia School Board Association legislative liaison we need to identify and appoint a member of the board to serve on gsp's legislative liaison network uh as Cy County's representative for the 2025 session of the Georgia General Assembly uh the appointee will attend gsba annual 2025 Summer Conference in Savannah uh in next June uh Mr chair with that I'll open it up for nominations I'd like to nominate Mr Buzz Glover is there second on that nomination second um any discussion or any other nominations excuse me all right all those in favor motion

027carries 7 to zero all right now uh I need to M do I need to approve it again okay all right thank you next item I have for you in group one is to approve uh system applications to the Georgia Department of Education for the establishment of two locally developed career Pathways in audio sound technology uh it's recommended that the Cy County Board of Education approved the c local CTA pathway applications uh to the Georgia Department of Education for the creation of audio technology post production pathway and the audio technology live production pathway this approval is required to submit the locally developed CTA pathway applications to the Georgia Board of Education for the the development of these two career Pathways uh this approval allows the school system in the state to meet Regional and Statewide

028industry career needs and audio sound technology career Fields similar to the existing audiovisual film and TV Pathways that we already have at C uh these Pathways also allow our school system to continue to grow both academic and Technical dual enrollment options uh with our postsecondary partners as well as work based learning learning and career exploration opportunities uh here in CWI County uh Mr chair I recommend approval of these applications to the Georgia Board of Education you've heard the recommendation of the superintendent to approve the system applications to the GD G dooe for the establishment of two locally developed career Pathways in audio sound technology is there a motion for approval so move second any discussion DR Horton do we have a teacher set up for that we do have teachers and it will not require

029additional staff M Dr Pucket reminded me to say that he's shaking his head back there there go all those in favor motion carries 7 to zero the last item I have for you in group one is to approve the addition of three new English language arts courses Georgia Department of Education has approved new course options for 9th through 12th English language arts graduation requirements beginning with the 25 26 school year uh new courses that we're recommending we're recommending the additional of three new Ela courses to continue to provide Advanced opportunities for students these new courses will better prepare uh students for success in advanced classes advanced placement and dual enrollment English and Humanities courses and will be taught using existing staff allotments uh with board approval students will have the opportunity to take preap English

030lit and comp one preap English lit and comp two uh there is no AP exam association with these courses uh with board approval students will also be able to meet Ela course graduation requirements by completing as one of the third or fourth core Ela options uh an AP seminar additional High School Ela course information there's no board action needed on this piece all students completing the four standard core Ela courses to meet graduation requirements will take Linton comp one Linton comp to American lit in composition and British lit in composition on the accelerated career diploma students will take one state funded core English course and literature and composition two for the third enforc course options there will be an AP language AP Literature college readiness dramatic writing dual enrollment core Ela classes or ctae Plus

031Credit through CT AE pathway completion board members that's a lot of information to share with you that the that the state is changing uh the names of the ELA courses and some of the content there standards are not changing that's why I have to bring this action to item to you for approval tonight so I recommend approval should I reread it you can reread the whole thing I'm not doing it again is there a motion to approve the addition of three new Ela courses so second is there any discuss discussion all those in favor motion carries 7 to zero move on there are no action items in group two bids nor three trips two superintendent reports this time I'll call on Mr Chapman to bring your budget report sales tax Mr Chapman Finance report we've

032completed 41.67% of the year we've expended 4.68% of the budget so right at a percent under sales tax continue to see good collections there just over $3.4 million increase year-over-year is right at 1 half per. thank you Mr Chapman this time I'll call on Dr Mark guy to bring your staff and student attendance Dr guy thank you DR Horton for the fourth attendance period of the school year the highest staff attendance uh was Northside Elementary School highest student attendance in the program area was Central Educational Center highest student attendance for Elementary School uh Thomas Crossroads highest Middle School student attendance was madress middle school and the highest High School attendance home of the Vikings Northgate High School thank you Dr guy northgate's on quite the run there board members for your board goal report this

033morning I want or this evening I want to bring you some information uh regarding uh the requirements of Senate Bill 23 3 uh the promise act on December 2nd 2024 the governor's office of student achievement released a list of schools that have been designated as low performing under the requirements of Senate Bill 233 which is the promise act these schools are glanton Elementary Jefferson Parkway Elementary AR Co Sergeant Elementary Ruth Hill Elementary Smoky Road Middle School schools are good schools who have hardworking teachers and students in them in fact just last month Jefferson Parkway was named a math leader school by the Department of Education AR Arco Sergeant was named A literacy Leader by the Department of Education for gains in those content areas I want to be clear that one list doesn't determine a

034school's success or failure with this this Senate Bill 233 list we haven't even been made aware of the metrics used by the state that would cause a school to be included in fact I almost pulled this item tonight because of the fact uh that the state has pulled the list off of the Georgia um website um governor's office of student achievement website twice now for revalidation and recalculation and we still can get no Clarity on what metrics were used to compile this list system staff are already working to determine how we can better support these schools we're also trying to find out what metrics were used to put the schools on the list we're going to work with these schools to continue to provide targeted supports through our embedded School Improvement processes to help our

035students to be successful we'll continue to provide these supports as needed as we do at all schools from time to time based on their needs throughout the history of our school system various Cita schools have been designated by the state from time to time as needing targeted supports for one reason or the other our teachers leaders and staff members have always made any adjustments necessary to ensure that our students are successful those targeted supports and accompanying adjustments have proven to be successful for our students I'm confident that this time will be no different I hope that we learn more over the next couple of days while we're all together at our gsba conference about how this list was devised about how revalidating of this information and what we can expect going forward I wanted to

036bring that to you as information tonight uh it's all pretty confusing uh but we will continue to work with these schools uh to to help them to be the best that they can possibly be for our students DR Horton do you and you may not but do you know who is comprise like who's on this committee is it is it local superintendent is it just some of State the what I read today was they had um State analyst that data analyst that were looking at the list I don't know I'm not aware of any committee that was devised to to come up with this list um when I get more information I will certainly share it with you um I don't take us being on any list lightly uh and if in fact um we

037should be on it we will work like crazy to not be on it the next time you got that commitment for me but these are these are good schools with good people working in them a list doesn't Define a school I encourage you you go walk into any of these schools and you have I know you have these are good schools and they're not going to be defined by a list you can tell I'm a little bent out of the frame about that last item I have for you um I've got two items left actually facility and construction report and then I have a presentation for you on House Bill 581 uh facilities and construction report you can see softball field houses are still there we're just waiting to close those those projects out actually

038Final close out documents were submitted last week new and high school will be there for a while for us uh you can see there on bp3 still got some work that we have to complete on the sound system in the auditorium still working on that one handrail um um but we're uh we're getting there on all of our punch list items there at newon high school see Central Educational Center the addition Renovations and modifications Southern a& working on conceptual design drawings and they actually have a design review meeting scheduled uh for the early part of next week I mentioned turf fields to you last month uh they're renovating um those turf fields at no cost uh to the system over the course of the next few weeks um going to improve the longevity of the

039turf so there's no no cost on any of that Shield projects design is underway to install Shield at madis Smoky Road Arnold East Cita and Lee Middle Schools uh we're planning for project completion uh next summer on those then we do have two sewer upgrades that we're working on for this summer uh East Side Elementary and Arco Sergeant Elementary uh both have uh some dated dated is a good way to put it I guess Ronnie some dated sewer infrastructure uh that we need to uh we need to work to improve out there this summer and that's on the docket for this summer so we're right at 7:15 and this evening um and actually every evening we do set aside 45 minutes for public comment I'd like to go ahead and uh to do that as

040long as the board's fine with that um so we were just going to jump for a quick moment and I'm just going to read this um so in order to improve communication between the Board of Education and the citizens of K County the Board of Education encourages citizens to attend regularly scheduled board meetings and speak on matters of general public concerns 45 minutes will be set aside for this purpose at each board meeting um to guarantee an orderly meeting and to ensure that as many people as possible have an opportunity to speak the board of education has implemented the following rules regarding public comment each speaker will be limited to five minutes the Board of Education will listen to each presentation without comment after the presentation is made each board member May respond if he

041or she wishes to for a period no longer than one minute only residents of Coward County or employees of the Coward County School System may speak in the public comment portion of the meeting no grievances will be heard concerning any specific Personnel action or any specific County employee except through the grievance Pro procedure set forth in the board's Personnel policy no one will be allowed to discuss any matter involving threatened or pending litigation with the Board of Education during the public comment portion of the meeting in the need to preserve order in the meeting no person attending the meeting will be allowed to boo hiss cheer clap or otherwise show approval or disapproval for any speaker in any manner whatsoever no signs or placards advocating any action or position will be allowed at the meeting

042no personal attacks on any person will be allowed I as the chairman of the board and responsible for enforcing these rules no citizen or system employ employee will be retaliated against in any manner whatsoever for speaking in matters of public concern at the Board of Education meeting any person not recognized with theot within the allotted time period for public comment will be scheduled at the next meeting this evening we have four speakers first uh John Moody good evening Mr superintendent and board members I am the proud father of a very excellent third grade student at Norths Side Elementary School we are in our fifth year enrolled in the kawii County public school system and my student my child has exceeded standards in every area since we've been enrolled in the County School System until this

043year when we first saw our spelling scores begin to go down as an inquisitive father I immediately requested a parent teacher conference with my child's teacher during that conference two apparent deficiencies were brought to my attention which I believe warrant the board's attention as well I am not here to criticize my child's teacher nor the school they are both very good good I am only here to discuss the adopted methodologies in which things are being done the first issue I have is the way the manner in which spelling is being taught in the school system before this year every student got a word list of 10 words on a Monday you studied them all week you test it on a Friday that's the way I learned it and I'm pretty sure I can wager that's

044how the board members have learned it and every member in this audience learned it and it worked today we are teaching the students the rules of the English language and at the end of the week the students are being asked to spell words that they have never seen before never attempted to try before to spell and having to Simply guess which vow pairing consonant pairing long or short vow rule applies to that word though admirable I will say in teaching this method it has obvious and inherent flaws and that is simply that the English language has too many violations and exceptions to its own rules during that meeting with the teacher we were given an example of a spelling test my child gave was given the word was boast B my child wrote B and

045the teacher simply informed us my child does not understand the rules of the English language to which I simply replied what if the word had been most or host or post by my child's Logic the singular o would have applied a Moment of clarity was the expression on our teacher's face simply put this methodology leaves these children lost another OST word with a different pronunciation rules words that even rhyme can be confusing as in please cheese and sneeze obviously different words obviously different spellings and how is a child who has never seen a word before but simply goes by the rules know the difference between words that sound exactly the same as in the heel of your foot and to heal a wound simply put this does not work I will spare you the full

046rendition of the late comedian Gallaghers skit on the English language however for students to learn how to spell they need first need to see the word hear the word and write the word when you combine those three methodologies together it locks it into a child's brain for life that's how we all did it is worked for Generations it has worked for hundreds of years some people may still remember a great leg Legend in this County a barbar Andrews I knew her as Barbara landrith and she used to tell me it is not practice that makes perfect it is perfect practice that makes perfect these children need dedicated lists to learn and see and read they don't need to play a guessing game there is no reason that we need to reinvent the wheel and Cy

047County and when I say wheel that's w l not we apostrophe LL I hope and I think I made my point the second deficiency I'd like to address is the lack of textbooks and homework that's coming home for these Elementary School students I remember back when I was in grade school back when dinosaurs roam the earth I came home with a textbook for every major subject that I had to study whether it be reading math science history social studies and I had a one to three page assignment to do it every night this had two folds of a of a purpose number one it was good review for the students but most importantly it allowed the parents to engage and assess how their child was comprehending the information thank you Mr Moody y appreciate sorry

048my time thank you so much thank you so much Alan Brady good evening ladies and gentlemen it's good to see you all again thank you for the opportunity to speak as you may recall I've always brought what I consider to be moral issues to your attention and asked to you to do the right thing I've mentioned Financial issues in the past but generally moved on quickly from those saying it's not about the money and it's not for me but now we have an intersection of the moral and financial last month the people of Georgia overwhelmingly voted to change the way property taxes included those used to fund public schools are determined these people did not vote for an opt out they voted for the property value assessments for their homes to track the rate of

049inflation for as long as they own their homes whenever they sold their home and realized their gain or loss which is always a possibility it happened to my wife and me when we lived in grette County many years ago then the next owner would begin their assessments that whatever the home was sold for which is always a true measure of the value of a thing what can you sell it for now as I understand that you're are considering opting out of this assessment increase limitation I assume the rationale for this would be a continued windfall of property tax increases while being able to reduce the millage rate leading the UN underinformative family my taxes went up 38% despite the roll backs because of another large increase in assess value and the state did not reduce

050it with another large special exemption like they did last year it was painful to have to scrape up all that money again just ahead of Christmas considering the Dismal economic conditions we're still suffering under but I know I don't have it nearly as bad as many do others were hit with even larger increases I can only imagine what it's like for long time property owners who just barely getting by who get hit with these large increases they're eventually going to be forced out of their homes the homes they own because they can't afford what the government requires them to pay to continue living in them I recognize that both the County government and school system require funding to operate but any tax increases need to be presented through the front door with millage increases that

051are sold to the public honestly and out in the open not not by back door based on unreasonable assessment increases while claiming we reduce the mill rate again I also recognize that you're up against some limitations like the 20 mil limit at the current limit of 15.41% cushion before you reach that you'll just have to make the case to the taxpayers for a tax increase directly rather than relying primarily on valuation increases to take care to take care of it for you I've observed the County government struggle with air budget trying to keep the cost under control and tax increases down in the face of complaints by an angry public who are sometimes not all that well informed this body does not seem to have this problem at least not I've seen decisions are made

052quickly and with little discussion in fact I saw more discussion and controversy of your decision to begin paying yourselves a salary than I've seen over anything else at least since the lockdown and masking era wasn't my intention to get off in the weeds with this there's a lot of very interesting financial information that needs to be brought to light especially if you decide to go forward with the opt out and the required hearings are held to discuss it hopefully there will be an opportunity to to discuss this later I just want to ask you tonight please do the right thing recognize that the people have spoken on this issue let's avoid all the time and controversy respect what the voter said don't consider opting out and learn to live with the situation as it is

053thank you Maxwell Britain uh good evening School staff board members and fellow taxpayers of C County uh tonight I want to talk about HB 581 and its Offspring Amendment one the homestead exemption you voted for in the last election this was supposed to bring relief to taxpayers but here we are again staring down the possibility of losing what we worked so hard to secure if the school board opts out of amendment one they're not not just cutting off significant tax savings they're taking away your vote and your voice this decision would undermine the will of the taxpayers forcing us to shoulder the financial burden while leaving the school system's spending habits unchecked follow the money let's talk numbers from 2018 to 2023 the kaeda County School Systems budget jumped over 36 million up 26% from

054138 million to 175 million what's driving this explosion salaries not just for teachers or directly for our kids but for administrators principles and other staff here's a few examples superintendent Dr Evan Horton earns more than 300,000 I think it's 340,000 annually that's nearly as much as the President of the United States of America and over 570 per higher than the average employee in the C to County Schools it's also 70% higher than the average superintendent salary in Georgia other top earners include Keith Chapman at 190,000 Mark guy at 187,000 Karen Barker at 167,000 Marcus Whitlock at 163,000 and Steve Allen a principal earns $126,000 180% higher than than the average employee this isn't school system struggling to make in Meet it's a system that's ballooning at the top while taxpayers foot the bill and it

055doesn't stop there not too long ago School Board school board members who once volunteered their time voted themselves salaries they jumped right on the money train joining the top tier administrators on this ride Mill rates and more taxes the school board might say that they need to raise the millage rate to make up for lost Revenue if Amendment stays if Amendment one stays in place they can do that up to the state cap of 20 Ms or they can put yet another local referendum on the ballot to exceed the cap what happened to working within a budget if the private sector can work within a budget why can't the school system is a 26% budget increase in 5 years reasonable where is the money really going it's certainly not all going to the classroom or

056directly benefiting the kids Frank farmer once said the school system is a financial engine what happened to the kids Frank we're spending more than ever yet we're consistently being asked for more it's time to get off this Runway runaway train and demand answers to the school board honor the will of the taxpayers don't opt out of amendment one be transparent show us where the money's going and how it directly benefits our students cut the bloat operate within a reasonable budget like every private sector business does and to my fellow fellow taxpayers this is our community our money and our future let's not let this slide attend the meetings ask the tough questions and hold the school board accountable thank you and let's stand together to ensure our voices are heard thank you good night Linda

057mink good evening two of the mantras that I have repeatedly heard over the last 10 or 11 years years coming from a number of you on the school board is that one is it's all about the children no it's not let's be honest it's all about the money you just can't get enough of it the voters in this County made a decision and it was a resounding decision with regard to Taxation and yet here we are today with an understanding that you're considering opting out as Mr Moody was walking through the dissertation on what he's actually experienced with his child and the failure in reading comprehension and proficiency you have all the money you need to correct that problem and DR Horton you're talking about looking at the metrics because you had six schools in

058the system that you question how they were rated you've got the money to fix the problem you don't need more and the other Mantra that we heard repeatedly was that we're all in this together no we're not we are not all in this together I'm looking at mothers and fathers across this County some of them working two and three jobs some of them own a home they have a mortgage some of them pay rent and renters do pay taxes trust me the owners of the property pass the taxes own through rent increases to the renter so they're paying taxes I've got the numbers I can prove it I'm concerned about the average median income in this county is $9,300 th000 and Mr Britain just outlined the outlandish salaries that y'all are paying yourselves in the

059school system it's ridiculous Mr Horton you make 400 times more than the average a area median income resident in this County that's despicable I'm concerned about the area median income family that's working jobs paying for gas paying their mortgage paying their rent paying the utilities making sure that their children go to the doctor that their prescriptions are f bu and everything stays on Target and you guys are considering opting out grow up you have a budget stick to it stop sticking it to the taxpayers okay there are no uh board responses this evening to public comment um but we do appreciate all of you for being here we really do so we're going to go back to superintendent reports uh Dr Orton and we'll then we'll go to board comments perfect board members if I

060may I'm going to walk down to the podium uh and bring you an informational presentation on House Bill 581 figured it might be a little bit easier for me to come down here instead of trying to talk to both ends of the table there um board members want to want to start off by saying um tonight is about bringing you information so that you can make informed decisions uh moving forward we'll get into the timeline about what may need to happen should you choose uh to opt out of of House Bill 581 or Amendment one down the road but this is all about me um doing what I think is my job and that's bringing you information related to what your options are uh with with a piece of legislation uh that that quite frankly

061uh will be one way or the other it's going to be very consequential uh for the school system there is no vote tonight I understand that some groups in the community uh had led though some in the the community to believe that you would be taking some sort of action tonight uh there's no action being taken in fact uh the earliest you could take action on this uh would be at your regular February board meeting and we'll get into the timeline on that here in just a few minutes Mike if you'll go to the next slide just a little bit about the ballot language uh and what this is um it there was a Statewide floating home homestead exemption uh that was passed by referendum uh with over 60% a local and Statewide approval uh

062it's interesting on the ballot it was listed as a Statewide homestead exemption uh We've since gotten clarification from the state uh that it is now considered a local exemption and that has some implications for you related to things like local fair share and we'll get into that more in a minute uh I will say the exact ballot language is there on the screen for you uh and you can see uh that it it it mentions the question of whether the Constitution should be amended and it also at the very bottom uh says which any County Consolidated Government municipality or local school system May opt out upon the completion of certain procedures it was right there on the ballot uh so let's be clear about what was there um you can go the next one Mike

063some other Provisions that authorizes a special sales and use tax that is aimed at providing property tax relief uh and it's subject to local referendum approval um there it revises the assessment uh and appeals process and it requires the department of audits and accounts to conduct uh economic analyses on any income tax credit um within two years and it revises the notice to taxpayers that they get uh typically in the summertime and it now would include an estimated uh roll back definition uh on on their assessment that they would get or their notice in the summer some dates of course November 5th uh it was approved by the voters uh January 1st is the first day that you could do anything related to this referendum or related to this piece of legislation The Way It

064Was Written it does not allow anyone to take any action before January 1st of 2025 and you can see there uh if a municipality or a school district uh were to to consider opting out um that's the deadline March the 1st there has to be done by March the 1st uh you must pass a resolution and you must complete the required public hearings by this date a board members is very similar to uh the millage hearing process that you already have in place during the summer the process would begin with with an intent uh basically to opt out you have to run ads in the paper uh we'll get to those in a minute but everything has to be done by March the 1st and has to be filed with the secretary of state so

065you can see their process start and then March 1st deadline the public hearings uh must hold at least three before passing a resolution so it begins with those hearings one of them must take place between 6:00 and 700 p.m. on a business weekday uh to accommodate public participation and then you must publish notice of your intent uh in the the newspaper of General General circulation and on your website so in this case it'll be the noon and times heral and on the Cy County website the law even prescribes the size of the public notice that you have to put it's 30 square in and it has to be placed prominently uh in the paper and it has to be a week before each hearing also have to include a press release to local media has

066to be simultaneous uh when when you make that notice and then again that resolution would have to be filed uh by or with the Secretary of State's office no later than March the 1st of 2025 Mike if you'll go the next one there's some potential outcomes of opting in or opting out I want to take you through what some of those are uh one outcome if you were to choose to opt out that means you would maintain local control over tax policy if you opt in the state Now controls um tax policy for the local Board of Education and I'll get into that a little bit more if you opt out it would maintain flexibility for future boards related to millage rate the ability ability to maintain a lower millage rate and you have the

067lowest millage rate for education in the metro area I'll show that to you here a little while opting out if you were to choose to do so acknowledges the uniqueness of Cita County if you opt in to a Statewide solution you may lose the ability to um respond to things that may may occur here locally just need to know that going in there's a chance that will provide greater long-term fiscal stability and sustainability and I'll get into that here more in a minute would maintain our ability to respond to crises locally things come up and you need to respond to those if you have that local control and flexibility related to your finances uh you're able to do that and you still uh maintain a local ability to respond to Rising property values uh and

068decreases and an opportunity if you choose to look at other potential exemptions if you were to choose to do so if you opt in there's a potential higher property tax burden for homeowners there's there's a point where um millage rates most likely would need to go up they would they would most likely need to and it could mean that down the road there are potential um higher rates once the rate cap is reached there is no flexibility there it's greatly dimin finished once you get to the 20 mil cap and I'll talk in just a minute about the difference between school systems and other local entities once you reach the cap um certainly would would would have an adverse effect potentially on future boards ability to uh innovate or respond to those local crises the

069actual long-term incap of consequence or long-term impact is is undetermined and we have run the numbers if the cap had been in place during this year it would have been an estimated loss for our school district based on 8.11% growth and a 4.10 CPI would have been an estimated loss of up to $7.4 million for us this year it's just what it would have meant for us um there's uncertainty even I even asked again yesterday there's uncertainty on what index will actually be used uh in order um to to determine what what inflationary measure is it going to be a regional measure is it going to be a national measure we still don't know one thing I will mention to you um in this particular piece of legislation school districts cannot participate uh in property

070tax relief local option sales tax that's available to cities it's available to counties it is not available in this legislation school districts were specifically excluded uh from the the opportunity uh to to go to the voters on a referendum for for an additional local option sales tax under this and it could impair the district's ability to recover uh from future recessions or uh from other Market adjustments down the road if you look at um where we are and I'm going to talk a little bit more about Revenue here in just a minute opting in it could make us more dependent on state and federal revenue and I'll be honest with you I don't really know what to make of that right now um federally I don't know what's going to happen there it's been a

071lot of discussion uh even as as recently as today I saw an article about Federal Department of Education could go away and that goes to the states so I don't know what that could mean for us um it's possible uh that opting in could cause us to be more con concerned even then we already are about local fair share um opting out could mitigate that I'm going to show you in just a minute our local fair share that's five Mills that we pay to participate in state funding uh it was over $40 million this year I'm going to show you the trends of what that's done uh our QBE formula uh that we use the quality basic education formula in the state of Georgia uh it is not adjusted annually for inflation so there when

072the formula is not adjusted the local fair share goes up State funding goes down or the percentage of State funding goes down the money to run the school system comes from local funds and I'm going to show you in just a minute what those Trends have done over the last 25 years no considerations in House Bill 581 for enrollment growth there's nothing there for enrollment growth could have a disproportionate impact on our school system because 7 73% of our tax digest approximately is residential here in CWI County we are very heavy re residential um tax base here in Cita and it could also add to the already disproportionate impact of unfunded State mandates and indirect obligations I'll give you an example of one just last year the legislature decided um that employe insurance cost we're

073going to be we're going to be solely the responsibility of the school system I think it was $5.2 Million last year based on that decision that we had to come up with during the budgeting process our percentage our employer contribution to the teacher retirement system last year Rose by 1.2 million that had to come from uh local funds another example of that is when raises are given and we're grateful when they are for our employees when those raises are given by the state not all employees are covered we' have this conversation many times those funds have to come uh from us locally and I'll I'll show you a little bit about how some of those Trends have gone over the last few years here in just a minute just some key elements there um the

074exemption does allow the property value to increase it's just adjusted on that inflationary rate and I'll remind you once again we don't know what what rate they're going to use they still haven't told us um the exemption does reduce the amount of property taxes paid it ensures that the assessed value of a home does not increase dur dramatically due to Market fluctuations this is the point I'll remind you board members you do not assess the value of a home your sole responsibility is to Levy a millage rate for educational purposes here in kawii County you do not assess home value the assessed value for property tax calculation would be calculated on a base year it's either going to be 2024 or the year immediately preceding when the exemptions first granted so in this case it

075would be uh 202 4 it's cap by inflationary rate to be determined by the state Mike if you'll go to the next one major improvements or reductions uh are included into the calculation but they're they're treated separately uh it's automatically renewed it is automatically renewed and then people keep other uh Homestead exemptions either senior veteran whatever other exemptions they have if the local taxing jurisdiction has a more favorable exemp exemption the taxpayer does keep the more favorable the two for them Mike if you go to the next one austerity reductions which is something we've talked about this is this is State funding you can see here beginning in fy2003 uh the state began to um reduce funding uh for Cita schools you can see the trend lines there and back in 2018 uh austerity ended

076over the life of austerity I believe it was 119 million do between FY 23 and FY 20108 State funding was reduced for the Cy County system school system $119 million the decision whether to opt out or opt in is a big one just need to know that's why I'm I typically don't come to you with 20 six slide presentations this is a big one it's a big one because once you do it either opt in or opt out the way this is written it is forever I liken this decision uh to the decision to create the school system back in the late 60s a group of people made a decision that they didn't want to have a City County School System anymore they wanted to have one and it set our school system on a

077trajectory uh to be able to to do the things that we've done uh over the course of the last 60 years quite honestly this decision is a very similar decision you get one shot that's why I want to make sure to bring you as much information as I can austerity to 119 million a lot of that was due to the recession the Great Recession that we had you can see where those Trends really bump up that's during that time of the housing crisis and the Great Recession the question we really need to answer is is if we had another similar situation and we didn't have local flexibility how would we how would we handle things I think that will that will be a guide for you uh as you begin to look at whether or

078not you want to opt in or opt out do we have the local control to be able to do the things that we need to do Mike if you go the next one I mentioned State funding this is the year 2000 I believe you can see the yellow there is our state funding the year 2000 our state funding represented almost 61% of the Cy County School Systems budget it's in the year 2000 Mike if you go the next one five years later State funding represented 51.3 6% of the budget and you can see the local amount begin to creep up there 38.369899 now the state is at 46.2 two that's their percentage of our funding and the school district locally there is over 42% so you can see the trajectory that we've been on uh

079over over the past 25 or so years one of the questions you're going to have to answer as we decide whether to opt in or opt out is is it a good thing to become more dependent on state funding uh when when those numbers are shifting on us Mike if you're go to the next one you've seen this before this our historic millage rate data uh 15.41% that's 43 years ago lowest rate for education in 43 years also you've lowered it for the last five um and you increase senior tax exemptions uh in 2020 just a reminder here once again um the school systems operate uh I call it kind of a financial box so to speak the State caps um the number of Mills you can Levy at 20 the State caps uh your

080ability to have reserves you cannot exceed over 15% of your general fund operating budget in reserves okay you also pay a local fair share to participate in state fundings the equivalent of five Mills uh and and over 40 million this year the question you'll need to answer over the next couple of months uh is opting in potentially to 581 is that going to be the fourth side of the Box because again um there are there are constraints that may come with that uh in the face of some of those uh unfunded things that are that are passed down to us from the state uh over time Mike you go the next one it's just humility rates in the surrounding area these are 23 rates they haven't changed substantially but you can see uh in the

081Metro cowe is the lowest uh you can see Henry at 20 brockdale has a different setup there at 21 and F at 19.15 in 2023 you go the next one Mike that's just a line graph that shows you uh what our millage rate has done over the better part of the last uh 50 years or so and you can see that red line down at the bottom that's a debt and about 2,000 2 2003 you can see that red line flattens out the school system's been debt free uh since uh since that time frame it's just a chart that shows you millage rate and assessed home value what it looks like uh if with school taxes uh per 100,000 or per 25,000 there excuse me uh at 1541 Ms go the next one Mike some

082differences between us and other municipalities I've already hit on some of these uh we have to pay local fair share there's no such requirement for cities and counties we're capped at 20 Mills there's no um there's no millage rate cap uh for cities and counties that I'm aware of uh we can't request that local option sales tax I talked a little bit about that earlier uh cities and counties can we can't we're excluded from that and then we have the reserve cap that I just mentioned that's a requirement uh that that uh is specific to school systems I say that to you U just just to make sure that we we all are clear that um our our conversation has to be very different uh than maybe other conversations that may be going on locally

083uh or around the state between uh municipalities we we're playing by a different set of circumstances here I've mentioned local fair share I won't go to it again you can see fy22 was 27.7 uh it's over 40 million now and every time every time that that that local fair share goes up that represents a state funding decrease uh for the school system that's coming off the top uh I mentioned earlier um the ballot called this a Statewide exemption I mentioned earlier that we got an information from the Georgia School superintendant Association who got it from the legislature that they've now designated this a local exemption let me tell you what that means that means that the local fair share comes off the top of the digest before any exempt exion are applied there's not a

084benefit to us for it to be um called a local exemption instead of a Statewide which was what was on the ballot local fair share comes off the very top of the digest no exemptions applied there I go the next one this is an a a line graph that shows you the school systems local fair share the trend uh since 1993 and you can see what's happened and what continues to happen uh to our local fair share it's a very relevant piece of the conversation that we're going to need to have over the next month or so uh as we as we look to make decision about in or out uh it's a very relevant piece it continues to go up we don't have to look far um to see um what what happens sometimes

085uh when when school systems are put in this position especially with the funding box that I mentioned to you uh this is I think year four for fet I believe they have a 3% cap uh in fet um they are I showed you their millage rate 195 I think it was for last year it's bumped up a little bit this year so they're getting very close uh to to the mill cap there uh you can see um they're having to maneuver things around costs are not going down we're 90 73% of our budget is people mentioned insurance cost earlier there are costs that are passed down yearly from the state to us and they're not totally funded so costs are not going down you may remember last year when we did budget we had to

086increase for electricity water things of those nature just like others are having to do um this is an example I encourage you the article's linked there I encourage you when you get a chance go read the article and just see what it says about their experience uh no two districts are the same no two systems are the same um but there are some things I think we can learn as we look uh toward whether we're going to opt in or opt out uh of this legislation if you were to choose to opt out I put a tenative timeline here okay uh the process would begin it need to begin pretty quickly after the holidays because of the March 1st deadline and you can see it's just a tentative timeline um on on what you would

087need to do if you were to choose to opt out um go to the next one Mike just some some final things I'll mention to you um the one tool you have related to system finances is that millage rate it's the one thing that the board um has control over uh to be able to to to finance the school system to to to to do the things that our students and parents and Community expect of us um I I will share with you um I didn't mention the total but that local fair share amount since 1993 is $590 million is what's been paid in local fair share since 93 um did get some information from the Georgia school superintendent Association yesterday uh related to where school districts are and what they're thinking in this process

088there a survey that was done uh 76 school systems uh were considering opting out 21 opting in and 22 undecided out of 119 school systems uh that they surveyed um so it's a lot for us to consider a lot for us to consider the last thing I'll say and then I'll be happy to take any questions certainly be happy to take any questions you have over the next month is is you're trying to figure out what you want to do um the last thing I'll say is this I want to make sure that we don't that we don't get our wires crossed regarding what a vote to opt out might mean or what a vote to opt in might mean okay if you're to opt out you're not voting to raise taxes it's not what

089you're voting for for the last five years you voted to lower the millage rate again you don't assess home value okay you've done the opposite by lowering the millage a vote to opt out is a vote to retain the authority and flexibility to do what you've been doing which is to innovate to manage the school systems business to respond to crisis that's what a vote to opt out would be to maintain that local control a vote to opt in is saying we'll go with the Statewide metric and we'll opt in to State financing for the school system forever you're also saying if you opt in that if it doesn't work the way everybody thinks it might that you're asking the state to fix it and we're giving up the ability to fix our own problem

090that that's that's where you are I I again I don't want to belabor the point it's a big decision that's why I wanted to take the time and go through it for for you nothing can start for you until after the first of the year but want to make sure that I brought as much information as I could to you uh related to this it's it's huge it's a huge decision it's a huge decision for you be happy to take any questions you may have uh thank you DR Horton I think you've given us a lot to um consider a lot to uh go through and we appreciate your presentation this evening Mr Copeland can I ask I just had a quick question for Dr Horton yes ma'am did our legislative delegation give you any

091information or did get did they seek your input before this came about no ma'am okay one question for me as well ju just to make sure I understand this correctly you're saying that whatever decision is made opt in or opt out there's no going back 5 years 10 years 15 years down the road this decision has to be made by March first whatever the decision is that's the decision right it's forever okay yes sir well forever until something else comes down the PIP yes sir there is no there is no opt in down the road there is no opt out down the road you're either in or out now I apologize did any other board have any other questions or comments for Dr okay again thank you um yeah we have a lot to to

092review over the over the coming week um we'll now move to board comments right hearing none is there a motion to approve to enter into executive session to discuss Personnel uh real estate potential litigation s any discussion all those in favor motion carries 7 to zer

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.