CorpusRecord 179097

House Bill 581 Public Hearing #1 1-17-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Fannin Rebel TV
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Fannin County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,862 words · about 78 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001we called our meetings to order we've had our digest turned down because the size of our ad we called our meetings to order we've had our digest turned down because the size of our ad if you have a cell phone please turn it on vibrate and it is now 601 so Mr P please stand for a prayer join me please gracious Heavenly Father we come to you at this time lord just thanking you for all that you've done for us today and all you've done for us throughout this past year as we start the new year Lord help us to once again call upon your name and ask you to be with us ask your presence to be with us ask your wisdom your guidance and your leadership Lord we're just be people but you

002are the great God of all and we just ask Lord that you would just U lead us through this difficult task and Lord we just uh know that if we put our confidence in you that you never let us down Lord thank you for again this County thank you for everyone here Lord with this uh The Testament for our people for this night to the is as bad as it is cold windy and we have a good turnout Lord because these people here are people that are interested in fanning County and that love Fanning County Lord so you bless every each and every one of them thank you again forgive us of our sins we ask in Jesus name amen flag United States of America stands one na indivisible andice gentlemen I call the meeting

003order for County Board of commission countyard of Education order for public hearing on 5 meeting call order one okay right you would turn just maybe the up here everybody see that all right so I am I'm the chice county louder okay can you hear me now okay again I'm Don Cochran I'm the chief appraiser of Fanning County um I appreciate everybody coming out and showing their interest in this it's uh something that's very important for our County and this is a good showing um letting us know that you think so too I wanted to give um kudos to an individual that I was talking to a couple of weeks back and he gave me a um small slideshow that he used in his County when he was trying to discuss house spell 581 and I

004took a little bit from him and took a little bit from the law and then I took a lot from Fanning Count's details so that um I could make it more uh local and more important to us as far as understanding the impacts directly to f County can you still hear me or do I need to hold that I can hold it so his IND his name is Blake Ellsbury um he is a previous commissioner that was in chatuga Georgia and he shared these slides with me so he helped in this and I wanted to give him credit there no I'm good I can do it um as many of you know some of you know I am not a public speaker I've never ran a presentation in front of anybody I didn't even know

005how to use PowerPoint until a couple of days ago so just bear with me um I'm a Fanning County resident I've been here for 40 years I love my job I've been at my job for 27 years almost 28 and um I want to explain to you the impact that I can see the facts of the law give you the information you need to go go back and make a call in your jurisdiction of what you think's best for our County I'm not trying to persuade anybody one way or another but I do have the information in my office that helps us get to um numbers and get to the decisions that need to be made in this County and um I kind of have found myself saying this over and over and that's many

006people don't know this about fan and County and as you guys have came to um these meetings and talked to us I'm hearing it more and more and you you're not intended on knowing that this is more my job and more um the understanding of the tax assessor's office and so I want to convey that information over to you guys as properly as I can and having that said most people do not understand that Fanning County actually has some of the best exemptions in the state of Georgia and um we have a multi-level exemption and those exemptions date all the way back to 1999 they were voted in and then they were even made a little better in 20 or 2004 so this little uh slideshow here shows you that if you had a piece

007a property that was valued $100,000 and then with Market increases I increased your value to $ 110 the next year Fanning County's current local free will float that $110,000 exemption that I added to you and you'll still only pay on $100,000 on the county side of the portion of the tax there's no rate of inflation there's no CPI index it doesn't change from that local lockin value now Fanning County's local homestead exemption covers your home one home and up to 10 acres of land okay now another tier of that exemption is if you're 70 and older and your income qualifies then you get that same same exemption off of the school tax okay as values increased from 1999 at a home that was probably 180,000 for the house in 10 acres and we pull ourselves

008up to 2024 and that now is 480 100,000 that float that exemption just floated right on up as increased value now anybody less than 70 does not get a local freeze off the school you guys are only feeling that pressure from the 70 and older okay the cities do not see it at all you guys do not have anything really more than a disabled veteran and along that line State exemption with the exception of Morgan and morgon sees an exemption that come from the state in the form of a $2,000 exemption for everyone in their City no matter age or no matter income okay so that is an explanation a quick basic explanation of how these local freezes work and how they grow and over time they really make an impact this is hard hard

009to see um but I tried to show that we have multi levels in Fanon County and it starts with anybody that's my age and um got an exemption it's considered a S1 but I also get the local Freeze from the date I locked in off of the county portion at 70 if I'm you know income qualifies then I can start getting it off the school tax side we have an exemption that starts at 62 years of age there's two income bra brackets for it and then we have an exemption for 65 there's two income brackets for it and 70 and there's income brackets for it the cities are exactly what I said earlier and that's this is showing that we're showing they're they're covering only disabled veteran type exemptions and then Morganson has that extra

0102,000 exemption Exon mill rate in fanning County um some of you guys have seen this and heard about this basically we have been able to with a combination of the city and the school I mean the well City County and schools really um I only have County and schools on here but we've been able to go from in 2003 our total millage rate for the county and the schools alone was 20 and as we've increased values and as Market has grown and as the Commissioners have been willing to not tax gouge and roll back these millit rates when they could they've been able to manage this tax system and roll it all the way back from a 20 mil rate to currently a 9165 that is second or third lowest in the state of Georgia

011um I don't know exactly cuz some people don't update their millage rates annually on the system so I can't really tell on that one um and then if we flip over and we take it even tighter down to our surrounding counties I pulled this from the Department revenues website and this is 2023 so not 24 but you can see Fanning County had a county portion of 2 . 757 and a School portion of 7.43 n Gilmer had a 5.5 for the county portion and their school had a 9.74 four Union had a 4.28 with their School portion being 7.52 three Pickin had a 7.39 with their School portion being a 12.40 towns had a 4339 with their School portion being a 5995 and then Fanning County even rolled it back even further in 24 um

012we had a large increase of value uh took place in 24 and they rolled the millage rate back all the way to a 2.46 5 and the School Road there's all the way back to a 6.7 from a 7.43 n this and M my small mind shows Equalization of Taxation we should not be taken and having counties out there that I say here's you another $200 million and they say thank you and they hold that mill rate they should not be doing that because that's not how it was intended that's when the taxpayers start getting choked okay so I give kudos to our commissioners for being able to do this because the only people that have the authority to do this is the elected officials through the city the counties and the school and they

013make a choice on this every single year whether to roll back or whether to hold where they're at or whether they go somewhere in between and I know for a fact that Jamie even rolled back further than the said roll back great this right here is just to give you guys a a rough count for my 24 values that the couny part of their digest has basically 15,8 12 types and counts of exemptions that top number the 619 2 92515 that's a total of every one of their exemptions here's the school and the cities school has 12,000 I'm sorry these numbers are blurry for me I can't see it on this one 12655 for a total of 41,9 58550 worth of exemptions that come right off the B from their digest values the these are

014not taxable dollars they've been Exempted off and they don't see a revenue from these you drop down to Blue Ridge right now they got 212 mcville has got 50 and morgon's got 68 there's a few other factors that um I would like to put out there so that we get our mind wrapped around that this isn't all about House Bill 581 we've got to consider the other factors going on in fanning County and the very first one is our parcel account is 29,500 we have grown significantly in our parcel count in the last 10 years out of those we have 1364 that are exempt Parcels okay then when you drop down to that middle piece right in the center you can see that residential Parcels is 82% of Fanning Cy's but or digest so out

015of 3.8 billion 3.1 billion belongs residential that is not normal across the state of Georgia most people have a good amount of commercial good amount of industrial they have a little bit of everything that shares the burden with us this is one of the things that makes it so hard for Fanning County to get a digest pass through the state because we're so heavily residential and that's where all the sales are and that's where things have gone Hog Wild that it is a numbers game trying to balance that out if you drop down in the next category you're going to see House Bill 808 that is another uh um referendum that was on the ballot and they said hey you know do you want an exemption instead of 77,500 do you want a $20,000 exemption

016this year and everybody's like yeah that sounds good well what that really meant in fanning County language is personal property if you own a boat or if you own a cabin rental business or a small business here in Blue Ridge then if you if your value was less than 7500 you weren't getting a tax bill and everybody that was 751 and up were we just took that Statewide and we took it from $7,500 threshold to 20,000 and in fanning County alone that immediately dropped $12 million off of our digest and that's only count counting from 751 to $1 19999 that's not anything less than 75 cuz we had already lost that and we weren't counting on it well when you take $12 million of value and you adjust that and you do your millage rate

017that means 82,000 is going to be off the school taxes and 30,000 is coming off of the County taxes before you guys ever even start figuring milit rates so that's something that we voted in as a state and that's going to be for us to deal with as well this right here is a copy of consolidation sheets and that basically Scotty can you get this bigger I can't see any of these I'm sorry I've been straining trying to use my 46y old eyes and I'm not able to see this this right here is small can you make that larger oh wonderful now I can see um and so if you take a look at the breakdown of this you're basically going to see on this side you're going to see a gross digest total countywide

018does everybody see that L can you point up there like right above o exemption amount all the way up one more up to the on up one more up there that right there that yes that right there is where the county starts at before any exemptions and anything happens in the schools well if you see if we drop down to the county portion they immediately lose $644 million in exemption and then if I go over to the schools in the city you're going to see the school loses 428 million and then you're going to see Blue Ridge loses 1.5 million mville loses 1.2 million Morganson loses 853 th000 before we ever consider changing this house bill 581 so going in to explain House Bill 581 it took place January 1st of 2025 House of 581

019implements a float homestead exemption for all local governments that right now we have it whether you voted on it or not the cities have this exemption the county has this exemption and the school has it it passed we have it a floating Homestead is a type of of exemption designed to offset inflationary increases in values it works by increasing the value of exemptions to offset the tax dollars this is going to require the taxpayers to vote for or against a 1% floss that is called a floating local option sales tax if that passes the additional Revenue coming in on that will have to be used for tax relief only and it's going to used be used in a manner to roll back millit trates if it fails you try try try again you decide when

020you have an extra $440,000 to hold another exemption and see if you can get them to vote for it again but you will always have the exemption with no money coming in to offset the exemption if you can't get it passed the earliest Fanning County can even have an election is going to be likely mid November 20125 this will cost us about $38 to $40,000 the soonest that we'll see a return on the floss will be we'll know kind of what numbers look like in 2026 but you really will not see true numbers coming in to where we can put them on the PT 32s and start comparing numbers until 2027 this is a 5year floss so that means every five years our taxpayers are going to be burdened with a new election and it

021can't be attached or booked on to any other type of Elections going on it has to be its own special election just like the splot for homes that are receiving this for the first time if they come in and they apply with for 2025 their 2024 value is where their base is going to lock in the value will be reset anytime it's sold these these values can be adjusted based off substantial property changes additions new houses garages remodels things like that we can up the value on those the floating homestead exemption in House Bill 581 is an addition to but not in the place of existing homesteads so for communities like ours that have existing local exemptions the taxpayer will receive whichever the two actually benefits them if Fanning county has been locked in since

0221999 and we've got longterm Homestead folks that's lived here for years this exemption will never help them because is what we have to offer this exemption can't beat But as time builds as values change and as this plays out down the road we could see a shift in that because everybody that locked in knew and let's say maybe they are in Morganson in Nelson's area well because Morganson didn't have a local freeze by when we lock them in for our local freeze all of a sudden anybody and everybody in a city limit is going to probably lean more to a house bill 581 because mine doesn't give them that but the new one would does that make sense this includes any local float and Homestead exemptions that are added to our future as well so

023this is an expl an explanation of 581 floating exemption that was set up in fanning County so remember we had $100,000 value We reappraised Them $10,000 that float went up$ 10,000 they still paid on $100,000 if we go with House Bill 581 then we have that same $100,000 value they give us this first year let's say they do a 2% CPI and that's cons considered a consumer price index that number comes from the state revenue commissioner annually the following year their 100,000 is increased by 2% and they're taxed on 102,000 we were at 100,000 and locked in with no increase tax burdens don't disappear they shift in fanning County we do do not have many commercial and Industrial properties to shift this burden to we have a majority of Residential Properties so we cap values

024or increase exemptions one so if we cap values or if we increase exemptions one of the three things is going to have to take place and this is going to be in each City each County and the school you have one option of budget cuts you have number two option mill rate increases from all three entities or a combination of the two cut the budgets as far as you can and then roll the mill rate up to make the checkbook balance with one of the lowest millage rates in the state of Georgia the history of Fanning County shows that our taxation system is working well I contribute that to the property being assessed at market value efficient collection of of our taxes elected officials rolling back millage rate when they can and a complicated balance

025of our property taxes coming in and the multiple local auction sales tax that we have coming in I feel like that in looking at these numbers and understanding where this has been building in Fanon County all the way since 1999 and Lind been here through this whole thing she came over on the art this is a delicate balance that takes the school doing what they're supposed to because if they were being money greedy and they didn't roll back we wouldn't be here if the cities didn't do what they were supposed to do by rolling back and keeping budgets cut as far as they can if the counties didn't do their part and everybody didn't work together we would not be here saying maybe this isn't for us maybe it is but either way you guys

026have a challenge of making the best educated decision you can make voting it and standing behind what you did and said may I be excused to go home [Applause] okay I'll the cor no I'm GNA St here I'm all right ladies and gentlemen what we'll do is we'll open it up for comments suggestions um anything you got to say like uh M said please come up here and state your name and uh yes sir you in the back yeah I want to say something sure in Blue Ridge was 80 years old when I came in here I think I'm 81 now this was government at its best we get a long one-sided explanation um your point of view but there's nobody up here to tell us about this other point of view I don't know

027whether the numbers are right or wrong what it is but you know I've been up here for eight or 10 years and I don't get any exemptions but I'm not Po and broke enough to do it if I was you know maybe I get the exemption but I hear that the government wants to um be able to tax us more and have a like a almost a slave audience to be able to tax for the property tax and you can't pay the property tax you take the property C compensate the home and then you're homeless America has a whole problem with government turning into an aristocracy the average government employee makes almost twice what the taxpayers make I get no paid vacation nobody's paying my pension nobody pays my health care you know I pay

028for it all I'm the private sector I'm the one that saves money invests money opens up a business provides jobs I'm the one who supports all of this and government just Jimmy gimy K so that's my I don't know whether it's right or wrong that but the other side is not presented so trust me I'm the government no thank [Applause] you anyone else yes sir well the whole purpose of hom what's your name sorry Julian black got you the whole purpose of homestead exemption anyway is to give Financial relief for people over 65 that's the whole purpose of it okay in the state of Georgia overall 62.9% voted J on this meiss 37.8% voted no in B County 66.8% voted yes so I don't see why we're having this meeting the majority of the people

029in F County have already spoken so why are you even having this meeting why are you even attempting to go against the Constitution that majority of people County already want amen I think it's ridiculous and y'all took the H to uphold the Constitution of the United States and of the state it seems to me like this is the treason thank you sir Mr my name is Charles Donaldson and uh what I'm going to say will address what you just mentioned I work in the election office um as a volunteer and uh I worked this last election and I stand there behind the machines or behind the the voters and assist them in their voting make sure they don't have any issues any problems with the machines or with their their uh manipulation of those screens

030and make sure they print out their ballot and it gets into The Ballot Box um some of you guys may have seen me in there we had um so many people asked what does this mean what do these words mean on the different uh uh bills that they were that was on the ballots I think we had real I'm not allowed to explain it um and I understand that I may explain it one way and I may shift the vote one way just by the words I choose so um I just uh I had to tell I can't tell you anything I can't explain it you have problems with the machines then I can help you but other than that I can't do anything so over and over and over again we were asked I

031don't understand these and they would turn and try to get help and it's unfortunate the the bills were worded uh house bill uh 581 was worded so that it was um aing whoever was reading it it it was actually worded to get you to answer yes and uh the word the words that they used not everybody understood so over and over again for three weeks we had people ask what does this mean I'm sorry the only thing I can tell you is to vote yes no or just byass the question and go ahead and go to your next U place there to vote so that addresses what you what you said what you were talking about we had 66% of the Count's already selected this and I'm saying that they didn't understand fully understand what

032they were reading it sounds good but it was designed to sound good it was worded to sound good somebody wrote to sound good just because 66% of the county voted for it doesn't uh actually it should not reflect it's actually best for the county and that was the point that I want to make it may be good for other counties but it may not be best panning count I think the figures that we just saw will tell us that it may not be the best for us [Applause] here my name is Bill whey and I'm speaking as an individual um I I have the Good Fortune to have a number of lobbyists and politicians and Schoolboard members in other counties that are part of my practice in Atlanta I have asked three lobbyists who are

033very well known in the city in the state one in health care one in transportation and one in utilities if there's anybody that ought to know what a bill says it's a lobbyist all three of them said I feel like Nancy Pelosi you have to pass the bill to know what's in it um I have a feeling that uh to Echo the last speaker that we knew who we were voting for when we voted for President and we knew who we were voting for when we voted for the house and the Senate we had plenty of ads we had plenty of Education we had zero for this interestingly enough I contacted after that the heads of Two school boards in huge counties we have our Schoolboard people here neither one of them knew anything about

034this bill when the election came up and then atted the head of the County Commission in another County he didn't know anything about it when he went to the election so the fact that the voters voted for it is uh to me means nothing secondly if we pass this then we are handicapping our future County Commission school boards and City councils and taking their ability to react to the conditions that are going on away from them and my old dad said don't burn your Bridges boy so I would say that we were have to pass the Bill know what's in it is exactly what we are in here today that if we do this we are going to be living with it for decades and I don't feel comfortable handicapping the people that come after

035me and come after them because of the misunderstandings that we may have over this bill I am not saying that it's not good for some people in some County but I'm saying I can find nobody and this audience proves it who had thorough knowledge of what this bill meant when they went to the polls and cast their vat [Applause] Brian Pritchard I live here in the county you know I I listen to the tax assessor first of all thank thank you guys I'm only going to actually address the school board and the County Commissioners I don't have a vote in the cities have a vote for school board and County Commissioners so that where I'll address that and uh because I don't have any vote in the city and uh but I want to First

036say thank all of you for this past week all the First Responders all the people and out there on the road Cruise all night long getting people out of ditches each and every one of you I want to thank all of you because that's why we live in Fon County and God bless Fon County okay so I think we can have an open honest discussion here and not be offended I'm just a tad offended I might be a tad offended with 9,762 other people that I just heard had no idea what the hell they was doing the day they pushed yes I pushed yes I pushed yes at the same time I pushed yes for three school board members I pushed yes for the same I pushed yes for Johnny Cersei I pushed yes and

037so did 9,762 people so I think if anything here going to say that just everybody and nobody understood anything they were doing that day uh may be something we want to rethink for the citizens family County this man here I respect the Daylights out of him anytime you come to vote he helps you every way you can and I respect everything you said today about being helpful but let me tell you what they did do you're 100% right they probably asked you said what does this mean what does this proposition mean and you said I can't can't help you with that but you know what they did they went ahead and voted okay they went ahead and voted they could have said I don't want to vote I don't understand it but they did okay

038that's called the will of the people the democracy now and that being said every one of you have an association every city I study it you have City associations County you got County ass Association represents all the counties okay School Board you got your Association that represents all school boards now if you this concerned tonight why didn't all of you associations get together and run a real hard campaign against this before election day why didn't they why didn't whoever runs the school I know who they are who runs the School Association that were all members of come to you and say look we need to get out here and campaign against this to get people V know what signs up put no but you didn't why didn't the county uh commission Association say fell us

039we need to get out here and get us some no signs because if this thing Creeps in we might have a problem but you didn't same thing with all you cities you didn't and the reason I bring that up reason I bring that up is because I've lived here when all of your associations came to you and said you better get out there and put a sign up to vote Yes for Splash or you better get out there and put a sign up to vote for this yes or you better push back against this bill down at the house right you don't have to nod your head yes or no you know I'm right all of your Association come to you say you better get down to Capital and fight this bill it's bad you

040better get out there put this sign up and get Splash revoted now I'm not here to debate the value in in in 581 100% but I'm just saying now now you tell me that 9,762 people now let me just let me just say this all right we heard the tax assessor we probably have the best tax assessor office in the state of Georgia and I'm going to tell you what there's many of you here to know tonight the what they have to go through to satisfy the State Revenue Department of Revenue would dawned them have to go through to satisfy the Department of Revenue but let me tell you something folks the nice lady that stood up there tonight she's your tax assessor okay but she has no taxing Authority this is your taxing Authority

041not your tax assessor right and you know what your tax assessor kept saying if if these good people I like most of you some of you like me many of you don't but let me just say it like this they're good people they roll back they roll back but if they didn't if this board next year said no we're not going to I tell you something I hurt if it comes the day that they need to raise the millage rate to balance the checkbook you know who the checkbook is that's me that's you that's you we're the on a balance the checkbook I like each and every one of them I voted for them I don't know about you but I'd say we'd go about 82% Republican in here all right now here's all I'm

042going to say and I'm going to get out of the way 2/3 now I don't know if you know this I followed this bill last year and the state senate your state senate had this bill passed and ready to go but the Georgia state house would not pass it John Burns would not pass it without giving the lobbyist the option for you to opt out they wouldn't pass it unless they put a riter on there saying you could opt out but this was never intended for you to opt out but that's the only way they could get it past and I'm not here to argue the merits of it I could get into it on a different time because I have studied it all right and I'm not saying it's the best thing in the

043world the only thing is if if on that given day you know we got 82y old people that don't know how to come over and and do a challenge on their tax assessment they don't know how to go to the Board of Equalization and fight that and all these people have to do and follows I voted for all three of you Glenn write that down I voted for all three of you legally okay I'll vote for you again I better think that now voted for all three of you all right but next year you three have the authority to take that up to mil and you know you do no I saying you will you have that Authority school board over here you have that Authority all right and we all know what's happen to

044assessments the only thing I'll say is a super majority 23 is a super majority that's not just a majority folks that's a super majority and the sit here tonight and assess make an assessment on 9,762 people that they didn't know what they did that's just not accurate okay that's called for the will of the people and here's here's the way I think about it as as this gentleman stated earlier 62% of the state voted yes okay 62% of the state right wrong or indiffer F County 66% as 9,7 62 votes the only thing I want to ask you tonight every one of you that has stood for office and ask the citizens to go vote for you have any of you ever received 97,000 9,762 votes and one of you here tonight got that many

045votes to get into this office I don't think one of you got that many votes I looked it up all right maybe close Jamie don't make that face you be over, 9,000 did you get that money yeah I'll raise my hand I'll see if check I was checking it joh but the point being is you respected every one of those voters to get your seat and I know that I know Johnny I know you I don't know all the school board members I don't know all the members of Blue Ridge and all the members of that but this this commission here I know you guys and I know you respected every one of them voters I've seen all of you go out and ask for the votes so respect them voters tonight and just say

046the will of the people said this is what they voted for amen God bless you thank thank you for your service I [Applause] appreciate he Rogers I just wanted to start off by saying I know this is a tough decision for everybody everybody body um I think when the state put this in Motion in my mind anyway what they were trying to do was offer some stability for people that are homesteaders within the state of Georgia the people and I don't care whether they're 18 whether they're 50 whether they're 80 if they move into your community to put their Roots down and to become part of your community I think the state was trying to say that these people maybe deserve a little bit of extra benefit right our County being the way we are

047um and believe me I'm one of them we're getting older and older and older our population is is Agent tremendously and so we have kind of a weird situation going on where you know we we we have a different population than probably a lot of other places too but I read in the paper you know I mean I I did I did my best to study this bill before I voted on it and I voted yes and I'll tell you why probably like a lot of other people I read we're going to cap your taxable rate and I said Count Me In you know the cap sounded good to me and but I went back and I tried to look at it again I thought you know did I make a bad decision to try

048to vote Yes for this and I still feel confident in the decision that I made and I know that you guys you know you got money to spend you got revenue to collect and you're you're trying to keep the millage rates low which is understandable and helpful but keep in mind I've got the fiveyear tax digest in front of me for the county you've rolled back millit rates every year but yet the collectible property taxes that continue to go up right because Mill rates are only one side of the tax equation it's the property value so what and School Board same way you know and what it gets down to is this um let's say that you have a 25 year old or a 75 year old that came across piece of property in Fon

049County whether it was left to them in their family or whether they got got it at a good deal or however they came into possession of it they put their Roots down here right here homestead exemption so you've got the 70y old person that owns 25 acres out in cashes Valley and you could get an accountant that came to that person and said on paper ma'am you're worth $1.2 million because of your property value but yet she can't buy groceries she can't pay her light bill because she's got $50 in her checking account that increase in the value of your property means zero to you until and unless you want to sell it you being worth $1.2 million on paper is not going to pay for your grocery Tri State's not going to accept it

050as a form of payment these are the people that if you give them the peace of mind that no matter what the crazy real estate market does and says their property bagged at this or that or the other this gives them breathing room that yes I can keep my home these are not frivolous things this is not a RV for fun or a boat or Mercedes this is somebody's home that you're protecting by keeping those rates down there's other ways to raise revenue and I've spoken to the um Commissioners about this before if you need to raise revenue you got the authority and the ability to raise millage rates that might be a political landline but you know taxes go up one way or the other either you raise the value of the property and

051lower the millage rates or do the absolute opposite they're still going up everybody's paying more and we expect to pay more things go up but I still say that if you Bring the actual property values within this County to what the actual purchase pric has been of those properties you will raise revenue and be able to leave the homestead people alone I'm just going to give you a couple of examples and I know there's always problems but we have a I'm just looking at random things a property that sold for $2.2 million 20 21 and the tax value of it is 1.6 in 2024 why why why is our fair market value for tax purposes so much lower than what it actually sold for and then you take the 40% value of that and reduce

052it even further I've got another one sold in 20122 for 2 million current value according to the tax sessor 1.58 those if you get those properties in line because I'm assuming somebody bought this without a gun in their head so that's a fair market day if you get those more in line it's not going to be such a tremendous burden on the people they don't want to say it they don't want to sell they want to stay here they want to be uh part of the community and I just hope that you guys will uh everybody morgon M blidge will consider that U As you move [Applause] forward so Jinger I'd like to reply to that as the chief appraiser um your suggestion is called sales chasing it is totally illegal in the state of

053Georgia my job would be so easy if that's all I had to do that is not able to be done in the state of Georgia and when you look at sales as a whole across the county or you look at them divided by um homogeneous groups like Lake Properties or view a river these one1 and $2 million sales have to be investigated thoroughly because a $2 million sale may have a $30,000 boat it may have $40,000 worth of black bear decorations on the inside it may be a 2year proven rental cabin and they're buying into a line of income so just when you see something that you think may work there's reasons behind that that doesn't allow tax accessors all over the state of joria sales Chase and we are required our number one rule

054is uniformity and if we can't achieve uniformity we can't get a digest passed if we can't get a digest passed we can't collect tax bills and that's why that method would not work it would be so nice if that's all we had to do because what you're saying is if Ginger was willing to pay $2 million she shouldn't be have a problem paying on $2 million worth of taxes but that's not how it works in the state of Georgia we we're not allowed to do that can I respond to that please well maybe so I don't know but there is a place on C public that you can put that it was a suspicious sale or it was inventory included with a sale to to give you a reasoning for what you've got the property

055valued at but I would say say this is that there's a universally uh accepted term on what fair market value is and it's a willing buyer and a willing seller and no gun to anybody's head right I'm sorry that the state won't allow y'all to use what somebody actually paid for the property as a fair market value maybe that's something that since this SP 581 has come into existence maybe you need to talk to them about it say give us more leverage on how we can assess these properties going forward cuz some of them change hands two and three times a year for two and $ 300,000 more dollars each time they change hands you know but what I'm saying is I mean if you had to choose on who you wanted to put the

056burden on is it going to be the people that are Homestead or the Casual [Applause] buyer go ahead hi everybody my name is is Aaron seol and I'm just wanting to ask who does this help and who does this hurt at the end of the day I am a local born Blue Ridge resident lived here my entire life and all of a sudden we are changing how this works when in this presentation we were shown which I took a photo of the slide we have we have the lowest millage rate in the state of Georgia in the history of Fanning County that shows our taxation system is working well this was off of the presentation we all just watched so if it's working well why make this change okay who does this help who does

057this hurt this hurts the lowincome homeowners in the area the tax credit may not seem like much but to a lowincome family $2,000 can make a huge huge difference when inflation is as bad as it is if we make this change we are charging the poorest and the most people that have been here the longest likely and punishing them with the responsibility of our County I don't agree with that that in fact is really frustrating that that's the plan you admit we have a great system right now that's working well lowest millage best in the state and yet you want more and let me let me ask this what is to stop the lines on the map drawn for where this aerial effect what's to change it from expanding spreading on and on further you

058disenfranchise lowincome homes you push them out and you bring in outside business I can't see this as anything other than gentrification and it's frustrating to see that that's what what's becoming of our town thank you thank [Applause] you can I talk loud enough to speak in here I'm a big dude uh my name is Josh Paris I wasn't I hate public speaking I wasn't going to speak but I just want to say that I went in there and voted yes for this and feel dup because when I looked at it I thought hey you're going to cut my taxes is like I'm all for that like doing it Statewide that just makes sense to me um what's crazy is after a little bit of just digging into it the state kind of knew this we

059can leave us at a deficit I believe because they want us to pass a floss so they're automatically so we we had voters that voted yes for this because they wanted a tax cut but then they're going to turn around and charge us we're going to pay $40,000 to hold an election so that people can vote in a tax increase to come up with the deficit doesn't make sense to me so I feel duped as a voter that I didn't understand what it was really telling me I feel like to get props to Manny County and where we're at I feel like the school board the Commissioners all the cities have done a great job and I feel like you're ahead of the time I feel like the other people in the state aren't as

060fortunate to have the leadership that we've had over the years to get us to where we're at where the lowest no R pretty much in the state I think we're what second or third somewhere right in there um that's a that's to be commended um so I think this is kind of Taken we're taking a step back and and I voted for it and didn't even realize it so that's why I feel like I should probably stand up and say hey I had no idea that what I just did um until after I did it now I feel really back anyway that's all I got say [Music] [Applause] anyone else I got one short comment if you don't mind this lady made a point she said if the meal rate is low are you going

061up on the propit taxes value and lower the me R cooking the books is that's what's happening is that how you manage keep low I go home look at my records and see if mine been going this and I probably said I was going to speak out just let everybody have their voice and everything two things Mr Black first of all you accus us of treason basically is what you've done that's not the truth one second I so secondly you everything we do is open records you're more than welcome to come in anytime we've talked about this before you're more than than welcome me anytime I'll sit down get Miss coner here and we'll explain everything to you if you think we're cooking the numbers you're more than welcome to come in and take a

062look at it that way we have a better understanding I just say she made a point she did make a please do that's all because I do know this I've had people call after the last several of rollbacks and talk about how their taxes actually went down I've had that in this count now mine unfortunately have went up a little bit and and it is but yeah I know you didn't fig that because you figured that I figured that you would say that I just don't pay my taxes I'm this guy I'm the elected official and I'm a treasonous person and all that other that's the farest from first of all hang on I don't like politics I'll be the first one to tell you I don't like politics I signed up for this job

063to do the best I could for the people of this you next election please put your name on the ballot and see if you can do better now I'm not trying to be a smart voted for you I I understand I understand but what I'm trying to say is the accusations have been just not good here and only the only thing the only reason that I wanted to have these right here okay I'll just be honest with you this is Jamie I can't speak for anybody else here the only reason I wanted to have these public hearings is to find out if the majority of the people people actually knew actually knew like Mr Richard said if they actually knew what they voted for cuz I didn't and and Mr BR we we asked questions

064to our state officials and accg and they couldn't give us solid answers there's still unanswered questions about this that they can't tell us so so that's what I'm saying when when this thing was handed to us obviously we start asking questions well there there're still and I think you can agree with us on that there's still some unanswered questions about this house bill this is an amendment just like you said this is an amendment to the state constitution the state constitution think about that this don't come around every 30 days this is a historic event with Antion with an option but this is historic event regardless and for for this to be hey we're going to opt in or we're going to opt out well you're in automatically passes PID fine that's fine I wanted

065to have this to make sure that everybody understood exactly what fan County offered what F County did you have any idea of every every option that we had as far as Homestead exemptions and everything if you don't we'll go over it again but that's what I'm saying I wanted to make sure everybody understood what Fanny County had already haltered how this would affect us moving forward and if we still wanted to go with it we would take a survey at the end of these public hearings and we would we would hold that again cuz I want to make sure cuz this is a historical it it is something that will affect us once you're in you're in after March 1st you can't get out once you're out you can't get in I want to make

066sure that 25,000 people or 30,000 parcone of Sharon FY County understand what we're fixing to do and I want to hear from you that's the worst thing I want to do is go against the will of the people but I want to make sure that the will of the people understand exactly what's going on and you can believe that or not I got none of the against you brother honest with what politician do you vote for when he gets in office you know what You' already got what you got is what he presented to people I'm not changing can I say something please can I help you so I'm D at the tor's office I I didn't catch your name can you tell me again handsome devil okay handsome devil I want to offer you

067to come to my office and I will pull up your accounts for The Last 5 Years I'll show you what your value changed cuz I promise you I raised your value I promise you I will show you the mill rate roll back and I will show you what would have happened if the mill rate had not rolled back I'll give you those numbers because when you said a while ago did you to raise values and then lower the meal rate I have never one time in my entire profession had any of the Fanning County Commissioners or the school board members come to me and say we need money go up we need relief it's tax or it's election season go down I do not work like that but what I do have to do is

068stay as close to market value as I can so when I went up every one of these guys had two options three really they could have took that tax increase and had to advertised it as a tax increase on their face in the paper or they could have rolled it back a little bit and took a little tax increase and advertised it as a tax increase or they could have rolled all the way back to that set magic number that's called a non- tax increase and it's a equalized mill rate roll back okay they don't have a choice in this when I start throwing these numbers out there at them and they knew for 2024 they were fixing to be faced with some serious decisions because the values that took place in that year so

069it's not really fair to judge or to think that you're being unfairly treated when they did exactly what they should have done well that's for myself I'm I'm getting up in age and I'm in the category yes but I I want to go over number one make sure you're getting every exemption that a handsome devil deserves and and I want to make sure you understand the the transluc see of our office because I don't work like that and um you know I want to help you understand I can't convert you and I'm not into converting anybody um but I did want you to understand that part of it don't really work like that um and I want to say one more thing I'm not saying anything else no matter what y'all say I want to

070know of a show of hands in here including the elected officials Jesus is watching you who knew knew when they were voting that they were going to be turned around and given the opportunity to have to vote on a sales tax increase potential mill rate increases hold an election and all of this Who Knew by that question that that that when you voted yes or you voted no you knew that nobody nobody put I'll put my hand up on that yeah well you I think you're doing an unfair unfair question to like to get the the vote that you want just like some people are saying that the written uh vote when we voted on that was but I think you're doing the same thing so wellon say yeah I did it good you knew

071more than anybody the truth um the thing the reason I asked that is is I knew I knew when we opened early voting and people educated educated taxpayers were stopping in the office saying what does this mean is it yes yes yes no or is it no no no yes what in the world does this mean and I'll be honest with you at that point of the game I had had no education from the state I had not had any clarification I had been studying trying to figure out what this meant and I couldn't properly answer that well Don is not true there's not even a program for this year no they're working on it extensively but it's not done by majority the vity people County voted majority the state has given us an opportunity

072yes they told us either opt in or opt out in their wisdom or you want to call it because they knew I like that better whatever you want to call it see that's that's another thing you could ask people is when I voted I was not aware that the county could op out yes a lot of things have evolved a lot of things have evolved and they're still evolving we need to be able to debate this thing all right let me ask just a couple questions can't 20 30 let me ask a couple questions if you don't mind because some things have come up and I appreciate that the the the floss which I I I've about had it with E and spast and flost and not I'm not I didn't I'm not negative tonight

073okay I'm just saying every time I turn around there's something with a loss and at the end of it it's called tax right that's all I'm saying that's all I'm saying I'm not here debating that but let me ask you something if I'm right or wrong now when you get an East flast okay now stay with me on this when you get an East blast and that Revenue comes in from the East floss from the one pin right that increases Revenue to the school board that does not decrease it passes well if it no no no if it passes let's let's assume it passed that's big let me yeah but let me go back to that you wouldn't vote for another I didn't say that no I never said that I don't believe in taxes

074period if you want to go there now you go good well yeah you know I don't all right let me stay focused if you vote in in East blast right it's it's increased Revenue to the Board of Education it's not decreased Revenue correct so when you pass your millage rate that's property tax that's the money you bring in through the property tax your East loss increases your Revenue correct okay if you have a spast your SPL increases your Revenue correct right but the floss the floss doesn't increase your Revenue wait doesn't increase your Revenue your e flos increases your Revenue your spast increases your Revenue if the county would to vote in a floss if you would go this option and you vote that in and I'm not here advocating and debating the merits all

075right so it's not I'm just wanting you to know but when you talk about being confused about it don't take it wrong that's not being disrespectful but what the floss would do if you voted in in if you vote the floss in then that one cent if it brought in two million it would decrease the property tax revenue correct right coresponding exactly see the floss the reason the reason in my opinion this where my opinion the reason nobody is is pounding the door for a floss is that doesn't increase Revenue in any of the municipalities or the counties so I don't think that's all right no wait that's my opinion I said I start out my opinion I'll start I start out I just said it's my opinion I was clear all right but that's

076my opinion why so when you when you start talking about you got to go back to you got to go back to and I I respect the young man that changed his mind and I respect the young man that says uh we have a system that appears to be working but you can't change the fact now with with this right here it does not alter and I want to be clear on that it does not alter their ability to raise taxes if you keep this in place it doesn't mean they can't raise taxes they there can't be a fear of well we only got $20 million and we only got $18 million and we only got $10 million you can raise taxes tomorrow this will not change that it doesn't change that one bit so

077if they feel and and I really don't want misunderstood I'm not saying these gentlemen are going to raise taxes you always have to come and look at these seats as empty along to you because they may not be there one day I mean I I go all the way back to you know uh I going to tell you how far back but none of these three guys was here the first time I ever came over here I think Dr bth was here the first time I came in this building or this building when it was built all right Dr B first time okay Bill Simons let's goes on so you got you got to sit here you got to look at these chairs and think of all the people in past and all the people

078in the future they can alter in what they can do when you say no to this so I'm not telling I'm not telling you to push back against it I'm just saying you got 9700 people that said yes you can debate I mean you want me to believe 81 million people didn't know what they was doing when they voted for Joe Biden yeah I might have went the wrong direction on that right no I I I I actually unlike him I knew what I was doing but you see what I'm saying so you can't you can't go away thinking well if if you don't put this in place and and you guys opt out they can race a village now they don't want to because here's what they don't want to do they don't want

079to go the next time and go out there and call themselves uh Republicans and call themselves conservatives and raise the military up three Mills but that's actually what they would have to do if this goes in place they'd have to change the Millers rate to meet the budget that they want in place so it can get very confusing but there is a cautionary side of the future is that not a good point right there what you just made highlight that if I made a good point okay you just said that we' have to raise taxes this did not me no I didn't say you have to you can they know that we'd have to Would we not I mean cut the budget huh cut the budget now we going down the road going down different

080road going down different Road what what I what I at the current time at the current time tax assessment which again I want to reiterate can I call the minute limit you you're the one calling a 3 minute limit I sit okay but the the tax assessment right now through your military you have you set what you're bringing in Revenue if this goes in place obviously the assessment there'd be some changes there on what you would be able to put in place you'd have to raise the mill is what I'm saying you understand so but you get what I'm saying you cut me off doc wh called The Whistle you used Don mentioned that she had the option of the existing system versus the the FB 581 whichever was beneficial of choosing that so what

081is the disadvantage of just leaving it the way it is that's my first question because if she still has the choice of choosing which is the most beneficial okay my second question is is it is it the old system if we accept HB 581 things St like they were if we don't then you vote for a floss you have to do a floss and what if that floss fails that's okay so I'm saying if if you leave 581 like it is does that give her the option of choosing which is more beneficial I think that's where the confusion is coming I'm it's Denise Smith um I just there questions that that I don't think really everybody understand so to answer that um the state says that the taxpayer automatically gets the one that's most beneficial

082to the taxpayer so starting out it's always going to be our local one for anybody that's been locked in over a year but then after that it really can change and you don't really know what their standard are going to be and how much that 581 bill is going to change because it's already changing right now so the system when it's written properly will run numbers and we'll say hey this group of folk are going to stay under your local exemption and this group right here are not hey I've got my phone number for you no no no no come back here you go sir hey hey [Applause] so basically when they if they oped into this or we stay in it there'll be a portion of taxpayers that are taxed one way with a

083cap and there'll be a portion that are taxed without a cap and all your numbers I'll keep up with all of those with this system and at the end of the year before we start sending out assessment notice type things it'll start kind of saying okay who's going to go with this group of exemption who's going to go with this group and each year it's going to change because as values increase or values decrease or as things are removed moved as people buy in the city or get um annexed out the annexed out annexed in there's a whole bunch of things that are going to change all those numbers and that's why right now I cannot no one in the state of Georgia can go into our system and especially the ones with local exemptions

084and say this is going to cost the county $ 1010 million or it's going to cost the school $5 million and as long as I've been here they can tell you I've never not give them the numbers that they've asked for but we can't produce them because there's too many things up in the air and the knowledge of things that are still changing so if they vote this in and I may be speaking wrong when I say this Jamie correct me if I'm wrong but Jamie wants to know he wants to do the will of the taxpayers and if the will of the taxpayers is the fact that he knows they knew what they were voting for and they are all going to promise to come out and vote in that extra sales tax that

085seals the deal and he's not going to be hung with an exemption that he can't make up the deficit without being every one of them being the bad person in the bunch when they never asked for this to begin with none of us did and then House Bill 581 has not been heard of in two years and nobody really cares and I will be so glad when I never hear that again but all of a sudden Jamie is raising the mill rate two points Robert and Ashley are raising the mill rate three points the cities are raising the mill rate two points well if you're a city homeowner that lives in Morganson they raise and school raise and County raises you we've got problems we really have taxpayers that cannot pay that tax bill and

086when I run the numb when Jamie started saying I might be giving out too many much information Lo slips when Jamie started saying I'm concerned that if we ask them for another tax another sales tax on top of what we're already getting and then what if they say hey we're not voting in that that wasn't what I agreed to I asked for an exemption and I'm being punished and I'm being asked for now another tax well we got a floss and a lost and a lost and yeah all this stuff and what happens when the taxpayers get tired of this and they're going to and so right back three years to to each other we're going to say okay six years On The Floss let's vote that in again then we're going to say hey

087I know you didn't know this was coming but now we need to renew on the 5year lost well everybody in fanning county says I'm tired of getting lost they're going to stop voting for it because the lost only had 7% voters in 2023 then my question is why would you take that risk why would you that's why he's afraid to do this that's why we're here that's why we're here is to make sure that everybody understands the pros and cons of going in this that we're already op me it isn't worth the risk but I I I don't know you know and and we respect the the will of the people but the thing about it is is that they didn't really I didn't even understand it then all this here is like a nightmare

088I me complex I mean because why would you want to change something that works that's good for the people and then they're asking us to do this and like she said I hate taxes too but that Splash it does so much and thank God for it and thank God for the people that come out and support it cuz we couldn't do what we do for the people without it and because we' have to raise taxes and I ain't about raising taxes I hate them but you got to have we got a a school system one of the best in the state these cities they've got so much they've got to provide for and and there's a cost in government and and it's getting I'm hoping it pans out a little bit but I do take

089the the the voters what they did they voted it in and I respect that that's the hardest thing for me to have to do is think about going against that but I've got to do what I feel is right for my people in my county and these cities because we have that responsibility if it takes hey if it takes losing it's that's it I mean but I'm going to do what I think's right in my [Music] heart and and and that that's another out there Sonia is right here let me tell you something let me tell you something you know we get out here and and they can tell you L can tell you too they always have to vote for Splash something that's very important to this County and these cities you realize with

090what how many would you say there's 30 20 something th000 or 30,000 reg voters and 1,500 comes out and supports it oh my Lord man that's that's cutting the cheese stand right there now I mean you I mean people it's just there's so much here and there's another thing they wouldn't have gave you an option out clause if they did not know this thing wasn't right now I'm telling you I've been in law a long time and I studied it too and I've seen a lot of laws come through and it's like oh there's a word always in there they give you an option to op out if it was so great then why are you giving us an option to get out out of this and and we had both elected officials stand right

091here did not know what than and thank God for the people like Ally from the Commissioners we used to have that Brian mentioned they built this program we're just fortunate to add to it they they laid the foundation for this and what we're doing right now is that why would you take what you've got that's working great and giving our people what they need to uh I don't know what's going to happen next year why would you do that I mean it's a lot to think about but why would you go against the will of the people and then that's just something that we have to study and pray about it is tough it's a tough situation what's going to happen at the end of here are you going to be asking for a countywide

092vote or are you guys going to be making the decision or what happens after these three hearings PRI we're doing that anyway but I'm just saying I'm might to cut another yard I mean try to get another p on hey is this is this truly so you're trying to get a a feel from the thing we had if we were going to op out we had to have three meetings regardless right okay um I wanted to have these like I said earlier this is just for me I can't speak for anybody else in here I wanted to have these to find out if this is truly and and I understand what the V said I understand that and I respect that I swear to do but I didn't know 100% I'm the chairman of the

093command of of this County and I I'm ashamed to say it but I didn't know what it all went when I asked I didn't get good answers I didn't get hardly any answers when acccg guys how do we go with this they didn't even know you know and and that's that's my RI that I'm talking to and you know for me it was it's just hard I mean this is that's why we make the big bucks I guess you know decision but but the thing about it is this just a a old County one way or another is going to affect this whole Cy and and this is for me I mean we got a lot of decisions don't be wrong but this is the first one that truly 10 years down the road could

094be the determining factor of of good or not good you know and and like we said you know my my concern is and just like Mr brard I'll say like this you know we're tired of all the osts sp sp La T SP all that stuff we're tired of I understand it but what if we do get tired of spost and lost you know and and yeah everybody wants to do budget cuts well guess what that means services are good ambulance services we're trying to put on to to better suit we we cut them out our our law enforcement we we would have to cut shoot off with we get somebody here makes 30,000 I don't care you know what I'm saying but my point is there's a lot of unknowns at this time and

095and just like you said if there's a lot that's the biggest twetter word in the dictionary in my mind if yeah if everything goes smooth shoot yeah let's run with Jamie is there anything in the uh that HB 581 that puts a limit on uh the county or Schoolboard or cities over their control over the millage rate I mean did they say that you can only raise it to this or you can only cut it back soate a Statewide of but we're way lower than that so I mean do you do you think it will be a problem let's just say like you know you're putting your budget together for 2026 or whatever in June of this year and you see that for whatever reason things are going to be way more you know you've

096got some projects or whatever are you concerned that you won't be able to raise the millage rate to a rate where you can collect that revenue is that is that cons I mean see I don't know so but is that a concern for for me we we we put the project s that we can P I try not to live me but I but I mean can you do you feel like you'll still be able to collect the revenue that the county needs by tinkering with the military going up we just leave it down we would have that's our goal we we would have to go up on a lot of permits we'd have to look at something I mean honestly if we just have to see honestly we don't have numbers to run to

097even um to do that like she said there there's no this is a this is truly a a different time in life for all of us to move forward and I don't have that answer I'm sorry you been waiting and M you anything I would say and this would really be helpful and I know it's impossible for you to do this I'm Sonia Smith by the way I serve on the board of elections and it'd be nice if you could come once in a while and sit and see the people that come in to early vote three weeks of early voting okay this particular election first of all this 78 page bill by the way 78 page I has anybody here read it has anybody oh have you collected oh you ought to be up

098here well when you read it did you understand it there's too it's too absolutely one always questions why it takes 78 pages to say a certain thing the number of people that came in to vote early personally that I knew and some that like um Mr Donson as asked he didn't know wanted to know what is this what are we voting on there was nothing that I noticed any lengthy editorials in the paper preparing us for this thing that appeared on the ballot well we all knew that Mr Trump was running and the other lady was running the the lady was running because we had nothing but advertisement about it we knew everything good about him and bad about him we knew nothing about this bill the average guy the average worker got off work

099came in and voted looked you know what I think he looked at he saw that it was going to raise an exemption for 7500 to what was it 20,000 oh that sounds like a good thing I'll vote Yes how did I vote I didn't vote at all because I didn't have a clue what I was voting on not a clue and I couldn't tell any of the voters that asked me what does it say couldn't tell you now if I have it toothache we usually go to the dentist right so what I did after the election I went to see Miss Dawn and I asked her what does this thing mean and she gave me a very good explanation not that it answered all of my questions it didn't I I don't think you can

100possibly answer anybody's questions all I say to you is that Miss Dawn and these people up ahead of you that you've elected to run the county of taxpayers here most of them are born and raised here and they mean the best for the county so I'm going to rely on them for their for their advice and I'm going to advise I'm going to rely on L Dawn because she's also a taxpayer here lives here all of her life for many years and I'm going to rely on what they believe is going to do I thank God that we have these hearings that we can opt out all that Glitters Is Not Gold okay as you've heard that before and I'm just saying to you we've done very well as a county in taxes for years

101as long as I can remember and I've been here since 19 76 we have almost the lowest millage rate in the whole state why would we opt in for this that's what I say to you I'm not telling you how to do it but I'm just saying think about this why would we fix what doesn't need fixing that's all I got to [Applause] say been here since 1964 so I'm uh I've been here a while but I'm uh i' like Miss dwn to tell me the metric that they're going to use to establish that percentage CPI you thr that out there do you know what they're going to use they don't that's what I'm saying I'm just a common sense guy but why would I vote for something that ain't even ain't even written down

102yet I don't even I don't even know the percentage of what they're going to put in there and what Val it's going to bring my grandpa said don't grab a pig and a poke and that's what that is and we are we are good stewards of that of that Fanning County money that to our school system we these guys y'all vote on it but you don't get to collect it you know who the Schoolboard gets to set the millage collect the millage spend the millage and I think we're doing a darn good job of the monies that's been brought into vanning County if you can't tell I'm a little bit passionate about that but I can't vote for something and I voted no and I saw in August I was at a gsba conference and

103I was a delegate there and they brought this bill up and I thought that's crazy I'm looking at it but you know what people saw a cap and immediately they voted yes for the cap the same people that in the school board that voted for that I just saw the numbers and more than half are opting out they didn't opt out in August but they opting out now I saw the list going down where they they've already said my superintendent had one and and I apologize I didn't plan on speaking either and I don't have any numbers up here but when you look at 22,000 voters in the state in the county and only 9,000 voted for it that tells me it's less than half because I'm I'm under obligation not to just for the

104voter but for every citizen of the County I'm supposed to represent and that's what I got to [Applause] say I'm just speaking as Cen as well and I wasn't around when the last um get in or get out thing was voted on but from my understanding it was Social Security and um I don't know how well that's doing us now um we got in for it for life or got out for life we voted in and I can say it's not working out too well I'll never see any of that but I'm paying the I'm paying the bill on it and I'm not saying that against any of the folks that collected here because I've got family that you know that depends on that but what I'm saying is is if you get in for

105something for life Social Security was a great thing when they voted it in because that guaranteed somebody to have something when they got older but look what they've done they got your in for life and they Twisted it around they wanted to use it and that's my concern on this is if you opt in something you're throwing everybody in this County into it and what are they going to do with it on down the road they don't like something and that concerns me as a citizen you know and uh it puts us in a different position as they've already said is that we've already got a good exemption in this County we're trying to take care of the people in this County and I as a citizen appreciate that nobody dislikes taxes more than I

106do and uh you know I voted yes for it because I was like heck yeah I don't like paying taxes and I voted for it you know what I'm saying but um I'm thankful now that they give us an option to sit down and discuss this and op out if we want to and I'm just saying we need to think real hard about whether we bind ourselves to something for life before we figured out all the details on it so as a citizen I'm appreciative of this meeting and I hope we all think it real well once you're in you're in it's going to limit you limit your control too and that's what I was going to say when you do that you're giving up local control to state to the state I like keep

107local control [Applause] they're saying if you opt in it's for life but if you opt out it's also for life so it's not a either one is for life that's not the issue but you got local versus State who do you want answer is if you're offing out and down the road your spot gets it's refused by the voters what happen you can always the and what if the floss fails that floss fails even the first time Jamie and I did the numbers on that I didn't realize that was what you were asking I'm sorry so if we lose SPO and lost and we don't get floss then we will be to make ends meet with 24 values and 24 budget the county mill rate would be 22% without the school without the school cut

108budgets you cut budgets a little do you can cut but you can get you can do away with the services that are provided yeah but and you don't want to do that but think about it this way I mean I'm not trying to be argumented but I'm just looking at it on the F side if you got a elderly personal fixed income and their electric bill goes up their taxes go up their insurance goes up they can't call and say uh hey uh Donald Trump or Joe Biden or whatever I'm GNA be a little bit short this year I need an extra $400 on my sub so what I'm saying is I don't think that you guys are going to go hog wild with the mill rate you know and bring it up 30 or

10940% that's not what I'm worried about I'm just saying that a little bit of control for the most vulnerable people in our County would be a s of relief for them because they don't have a way to raise their income anymore based on the whim of whatever real estate market students and their taxes so it I know it would be transferring more of the burden to the people that don't have a homestead exemption you know they would be paying a bigger share of what we need but I'm okay with that I mean I think most people will be okay with that so I you know I I'm glad we're having these meetings I know everybody got different uh ideas there's no point in any of us getting mad at each other it's just you're looking

110you're coming at it with a different mindset right you guys are in charge you're setting the milit rate you're you know you're you're having to do the hard work and we're just out here as consumers and taxpayers but we see things too we run into people that I mean it makes an impression on you I don't know how many times I've been at the grocery store in the past two years where I've had to see people put their groceries back and and and and we and it makes us hurt you know we all go those cats if those cats are in place like I said I don't care if for people are 70 or 17 but if they're Homestead I would love to see those restrictions in place where their taxes didn't have to go

111any TA EXs are by what we have for all the people that are currently homesteaded in fanning County I've owned my home since 2000 my home is and I have Homestead on it and it is C at what my value was in 2000 now if I go and sell that house the next person is not locked in John am I not saying that right yes see that's that's what I don't think people are understanding so here's the thing though ly if we're already doing that or going above and beyond that why are we worried that they're putting it on paper and saying we're going to cap it at this if we're already doing it it's going to be continue on like we're doing right but our intentions are better than the state but the bill

112if I'm not mistaken now somebody correct me if I'm wrong the bill says if your current exensions with your County are better you get to keep on that is correct the problem is that to make it up you're relying on a floss which may or may not pass and as Brian so eloquently put it most of us are tired of additional taxes so at some point in time you run the risk of losing one of the three that we have and that would or all three and that would be detrimental just as the folks but the other thing is if here under the system we have now I don't get to vote up here with these folks with any one of the two groups I work with I don't get to vote so if they

113screw it up if our taxes suddenly go way up you get we all get to vote I vote we get to go vote them out but what and I voted no and I will tell you I voted no on every one of because since I took political science in college it became abundantly clear those measures are always written in a means that entice you to vote Yes I don't care whichever one it is they're enticing you to vote Yes some of them might be great but that's just lit as an individual but the I think we all need to consider and I think that's why we're having these is whether or not if you don't like the outcome you get to control it by the people that you vote for every two or four years

114depending on the seats or whether or not it's controlled by somebody they put something out with very little public information in it well what did our dist how did our district people vote Johnny and when we had a meeting that had the Quorum of all these organizations early on U right after the first year right at the end of last year um and both gu and Mr Chastain were here they were very open to questions and there were a lot of questions that neither one of them could ask but did they vote for it I mean were were they in support of it yes they voted for it down at Gold but then they that was in March and April and or end of end of March and when we were here end of December

115they said there's still things that have to be fixed and there's still things that we don't have the answer to and they don't understand and they they didn't know the they know exemptions that was already explain right so is there anybody can I ask a question as a home as a taxpayer with a homestead exemption if for some reason your software decides that I'm better off on the HB 581 side for this year and then next year things go crazy over here can I go black it will atically flip you you'll have no control if there is an exemption in your name with an application in my office it will automatically run the numbers and it will flip you to one side or the other so when it goes to the HB 581 side and

116says that's better for me that year do I have the option of going back it will do it every year I'll run it every year and it'll do it for you that's what it says that's what we understand yes that is today's option it'll give it it'll do it for you and it'll settle on what it chooses is going to be the one that's the highest benefit whenever the estimate tax comes out it'll automatically say okay this exemption is greater so you you are on this classification and next year it may be something different let's say that you were just on the outside of blidge City Limits and you got um annexed in well all of a sudden you're going to be better off in bluid because now you've got a local in there that

117mine doesn't give you on the outside but either way it's going to be the highest exemp it'll be whatever's in the taxpayers benefit my C with my homestead exemption is what I lose forever right so if I go to if I'm switched to the HP 581 whatever the inflation or however they're doing whatever their is that year if that's what your computer says that I'm you know better off so do I lose this homestead exemption that that count forever so you just asked a question that I have not thought of because if you started out in 1999 and you've had an exemption locked in since then and then all of a sudden somehow or another it looked like the uh House Bill 581 is going to benefit you for next year they go up 2%

118or that's their first bow out number what we don't know a number yet from 2024 value well if I have you locked in from 89 or wherever 99 was when it started our values back then is never going to be as good as 2024's values but if for some reason your circumstances changed and it and you did benefit for House Bill 581 the way it's row is it says you'll go up 2% this year and maybe next year is 3% but if you jump back and you fall under our local where is it going to start from on the third year probably up there where the values are and that's something that's something that they really not accounted for because unfortunately a lot of the counties don't fall into place as how F and County

119can I ask you a question um no uh Mr pet you're looking over your shoulder like I'm not talking to you no I didn't know if it is you so I watched your interview with Mr douch yeah and he did a wonderful interview with you and as he went through and he was explaining all this stuff and he was covering it very transparent and very thorough like that's the best I've heard them answer stuff and you asked just the right question questions for that but in the midst of that he did take a second and he said we understand this isn't a one-sized fits all now and he said we are having to work for the state of Georgia and he said there are counties and he brought up Fanning County and I'm kind of

120paraphrasing this so you can straight me out it's not right and he said I want to give kudos to Fanny County and he said out of the seven districts or the Seven Counties in my district that I represent they've got the lowest millage rate um he said they're they're maintaining and watching their budgets and they're making it work up there and he turned right around and he said so when I say this I'm addressing because Mr pritet asked why did this happen what brought this on and he said counties that were not rolling back military and they were taking advantage of what he called a backdoor tax and he said they are taxing tax gouging however you want to say it he called it a back door tax and he said they're just taking the

121new money and they're rolling it into administrations and they're not using it like we intended it and this is going on in the schools and it's going on in the cities it's going on in the counties you took notes you didn't just watch that you took go show you's doing good and in my opinion and I'm not putting words in Mr Gucci's mouth but I've talked to him and I've dealt with him after he came to this meeting and honestly believe that not only his but Johnny's eyes were open that we are a little different than Gilmer and then Union and these counties where they're going to be more commercial and not residential they're going to have a sales tax advantage nobody comes to Fanning County to buy their school clothes for their kids they

122don't drive to Fanning County to eat they don't drive to Fanon County to have their drink no they driving here to buy up all the property and they are making my life hard that is what they're doing you're you're very accurate your state your state senator was very uh Steve fer state senator was very complimentary of good stewardship in this County now he was he was and I believe and and and that is that is not something that I Know Myself personally uh no one has challenged tonight I I haven't heard anybody challenge the good stewardship of the county well the way I took that was more like the way I took that was more like there is an opt out and there's counties that may or may not benefit from this and there's counties

123that are going to excel because if we were sitting here tonight and we didn't have a local exemption that have been in place and we had 22% military I'd be screaming for this because it would be exactly the only salvation for the county and there's counties out there that Mr gu and all of them are trying to rain in and get a little control he said that he said the word control but I don't think it's every County that they're really talking about and they they're not trying to micromanage they're saying we know we have he said said we have the evidence that they're taking 50% increases in these schools and if that's going on yeah he needs to do something this is the best thing they come up with and it's fine it works

124for some it doesn't for others but I I just feel like even at his level of what he said with you is this was their best attempt at fixing this and trying to put a cap on these values and make these people re in this behind the back door tax pricing and taking this money when we've not been doing that and Don we're not the only County that's looking all oh no no there's several counties I think the last I heard and I don't know where this even came from but 84% of the school boards in the state of Georgia are often out because the school board have a lose lose you guys cannot get the income from our floss right to make up the deficit you're going to be absorbing every bit of that

125out of your checkbook and M when we yes we can cut budgets but when a school system Cuts budgets we're taking stuff away from kids and also employees in the county we employ people in this County so we either have to take stuff from children and it usually Tak stuff away from children by removing programs which means that we have to ro people so it's a spiral and mo we are blessed in this County this County go out of it way to support system and that is not lost but this and to mention that yes we can raise millage but the ating part to me is that the state with this has tied local government's hands and they're in order to still serve their citizens at the level not even add anything at the level

126that we serve them right now then our local people that care about y'all that look in your face every day are forced to make a decision that either not raise your taxes and not provide for you all what is needed or to raise taxes and let you down by saying I need more from you and that's what frustrates me because it's hidden by letting state government look like the hero and penalizing our local people and you're right and they're already their first agenda when they went back into session I was told was 581 revision and they're already working on all that but we got a hard our deadline of March 1st so no matter what they do unless they change that no matter what they do at this point we're captive to that date well

127you know I I think as as property owner in the county and we're all Property Owners I guess is I think the challenge is is we don't want to see Revenue increased in the county based on based on assessment increase and it's it's a vicious cycle okay and this is not just F County okay or or F County so let's not get all partial but you go down to you you sit down and you say well my taxes went up and you say to me I didn't raise your taxes I don't raise taxes I have to reassess every partial you have to reassess the entire County every three years right within three years you have so what you say to me is I just have to reassess I don't do that I said the tax

128Digest so if we come down as Citizens to you you know it's not your fault our assessments are here and our taxes went up so you you don't have a you know anything we come up to these guys here and they say they say well we didn't raise you you know we didn't raise your taxes your milit R is the same I didn't make your assessment go I got nothing to do with that and it's like a vicious cycle and that's not personal to this one or you and I think that's what the state was trying to address with so many counties in the state maybe not directly discount yes so if if something happen assessments continue to go through the roof now not looking at you and saying you're doing that but if they

129do by no no fault of your own and they choose one year hey I'm not rolling back because the one thing with this and I'm not advocating to say let's stay with 581 but the one thing with this is we can't gloss over if the school board wants more revenue and this goes in place they can raise the military and that will take away from the assessment being what drives the increase in the revenue that's all I don't we need to bring this to end yeah I agree question and my first year here State come in and said you're to do the assessments if you don't do them we're going to find you and do them ourselves right so there again we have to do this every 3 years as you know based on what

130the state tells us to do so if it was up to me hey we live all what we got thankful you know um but I just want to make that clear that some people may think you know Board of ministers say you have toess every three years that's not how that works folks please understand that I own the fact that when I raise values I know what happened when I push that button I know what the impact is going to be um and whenever I do that and I I do the numbers game like you said earlier and I stay within the ratio study you know we can be a 36 to a 44 and I've been the kind of guy that tried to hang out a 36 a 30 4 36 you know 36

13138 I'm sorry um and I fell out at a line so fast and I know Ginger was kind of talking in the paper when we dropped that ratio study and everybody paper paper put me talking I just remember it came out people understood I mean they knew that I dropped overnight from a 38 to barely a 36 maybe even drop below I can't remember and that was all these sales that took place and so when you don't leave wiggle room and and go up as high as values really are and try to stay below you know some counties they'll run from a 40 to 44 um that means the increase in value that doesn't necessarily mean the increase in meal rate because they can do whatever they want my numbers are completely separate mine rely

132on sales and market and that's what I play is that game of high or low either way it's where it's got to go to stay in line so ladies and gentlemen with that and I think with that I will ask School Board you guys anything individual city city Mor anybody great meeting tonight thank you so much uh I think I've learned a lot both sides I hope everybody else has please be safe going home we have another one 10:00 10 a.m here you can make it you find something you bring it to and then uh we'll um for the commission I'll make a motion oh

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.