CorpusRecord 179269

Muscogee County School Board Meeting January 13, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Muscogee County School District Board of Education
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Muscogee County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,236 words · about 80 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e [Music] welcome to the Mogi County School District creating we and empowering Futures together this year we're building stronger connections between our students families and Community ensuring every child has the tools to thrive in a rapidly evolving World Cutting Edge technology and Hands-On experiences to prepare students for tomorrow's challenges every voice matters our diverse and supportive environment Fosters belonging in collaboration our mission is to inspire and equip all students to achieve unlimited Potential from stem to the Arts we're equipping students with critical thinking creativity and Leadership skills for Life Beyond School the musi county school district is a beacon of educational Excellence where all are known valued and inspired we are proud to be named one of for's 2024 best employers for women inv best in state employers this recognition highlights our commitment

002to fostering an inclusive Equitable workplace that values diversity and supports professional growth our dedicated teachers and staff are passionate about helping every student succeed we encourage you to get involved stay informed and help us continue making the Mogi County School District a place where students don't just dream they succeed n [Music] good afternoon afterno and happy New Year to everyone this is our January 13 2025 regularly scheduled board work session but we do have a couple of things that we need to do first um the members who are reelected in districts 135 and 7 will be sworn in by our probate court judge Mark deantonio and we're just going to go right down here and take our oath I can speak pretty loudly I think let's see if I can go U well thank you

003all and it's an honor to be part of this o ceremony um if you all are ready let me have you raise your right hands do you state your name um citizens of the state of Georgia Mogi County and being employees of the Mogi County School District in the recipient of public funds for services rendered as such employee do you hereby solemnly swear and affirm that you'll support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of Georgia do you further swear or affirm that you will truly and Faithfully discharge all duties required of You by law as members of the Board of Education of Mogi County to the best of your ability do you further somly swear or affirm that you're not the holder of any unaccounted for public money due this state or

004any political subdivision or authority thereof that you're not the holder of any office of trust under the government of the United States nor either of the several States nor any foreign State and that your otherwise qualified to head so said office according to the Constitution and laws of Georgia and that you'll support the Constitution of the United States and of this state and that you have met the residency requirement uh of this office do you further Sly swear or affirm that you're citizens of the state of Georgia Mogi County and being employees of the Mogi County school district and the recipient of public funds for services rendered as such employee hereby somly swear and affirm that you'll support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of Georgia so help you God [Applause] congratulations

005give the mic back to somebody all right thank you so much for bearing with us on that also at 5 o'clock we are um hosting or conducting the mcog County Board of Education public hearing January 13 2025 in response to the rising values of property in the state of Georgia the legislators in April 2024 signed into law House Bill 581 Statewide floating homestead exemption also known as floss which was approved by voters in the November 20124 election this law provided for property tax procedural changes new local option sales tax and local sales tax limit revisions and Statewide floating homestead exemption this law allowed for an opt out provision to the portion related to the Statewide floating homestead exemption the Mogi County Board of Education intends to opt out of the Statewide adjusted base year at

006vorm homestead exemption for Mogi County School District the district is having this public hearing to hear from concerned citizens on this matter all concerned citizens are invited to the additional public hearings to be held at the public education center this building 2960 making Road Columbus Georgia on January 21st 2025 at 6 PM which is next Tuesday the third one February 10 2025 at 5:00 p.m. and February 18 2025 6 pm. so that's both our January meetings and both our February meetings among the reasons that the board intends to opt out of the Statewide adjusted base year adorm homestead exemption is that the msco county school district is already impacted by a countywide freeze on the assessed fair market values of Homestead Property and affirms that with the opt out all existing local Homestead exemptions including

007the local Frozen assessment Homestead will remain unchanged the intent to opt out follows a thorough review of the potential long-term impact on local taxpayers school district revenues retention of local control and provides flexibility for future for the future that is not afforded by the state exemption due to our local Frozen assessment Homestead the Statewide floating Homestead is of no benefit to the vast majority of our homeowners and will be confusing and potentially costly to implement with zero benefit to the majority of taxpayers opting out keeps control locally so that we can always add a floating Homestead similar to this in the future where the inflationary index would set locally not by the state however by not opting out now we foreclose that possibility forever and that's because the a part of that law the state

008only gives um one opportunity for municipalities to opt out and with that we will address anyone who's here from the public who have any questions or concerns step to the podium over here so that we can hear from you my name is I live at 13830 upto Lane thank you for inviting me it was kind of alarming when I was on Facebook and Charmaine Krab who's a city councelor basically was saying that you guys were going to take away the heste exemption for the school and I think everybody panicked and was going crazy there and then I started looking at your comprehensive annual financial report and uh you guys look pretty well uh like I talked to the uh Finance uh officer that you have and uh you just recently passed a 2024 East blast

009and it was a tune to 290 million and it was kind of you know doing Simple Math you you only have it for five years 5 years in the 290 basically gives you 58 million a year and I asked her I said how much do you Garner right now and historically and she said 4 million 4 million a month you know four time 12 is 48 million so you're 10 million shortfall each and every year so at the end of five years you're $50 million short the problem is since 1997 which is about 27 years ago basically you've garnered at least $1.5 billion from the taxpayers for East Bloss in the past and each time you always set a higher Mark and you know you can't reach it so in in essence it's not a

010very honest way of trying to get money from the citizens if you know just simple math okay the other thing that I have a problem with is that uh uh you uh the uh the number of students I remember a decade ago was about 32,800 and now in according to your comprehensive annual financial report is 29818 down 3 ,000 and what's really disturbing in that respect is the state according to your financial report they provide 58% of the revenue based on enrollment so whenever you guys lose 3,000 people in enrollment it dramatically affects you and I can understand that what I also am troubled is that you have 78 days on your fund balance and you're only required to have 60 days and that's 18 days over and based on $82 million and 5 years

011ago you only had 40 million and you had for 50 days and now it's 78 and since 18 18 days more so that gives you $19 million more than what you're actually required to have to keep a a a rating of your credit so that's kind of disturbing because I've dealt with the city across there and they've actually co-mingled money taken out of the olos sales tax and sent 20 million which was basically supposed to be devoted towards the uh Public Safety and in essence they were complicit of the crime that we had because we were not hiring enough police officers so I kicked up enough dirt and said this is going into the Senova account then I talked to the finance department and they likewise it's going into uh sovis and what you don't

012understand to average people out there 40 million from the city 82 million from the school board that's 122 million in deposit cbnt covis gets a loan out fractional banking 10 times that so they get the loan at out at 1.2 billion and the thing is the credit cards charge 20% sometimes even 25 to 30% okay let's say it's 20 that's $240 million they're getting all proceeds off of money in your deposits off of your fund balance so they're becoming very super rich off of us ladies and gentlemen what's also disturbing is the fact that there's been tax abatements given out into hundreds of millions that I've talked to the uh the tax assessor offer officer Miss White House or ven house however you want to pronounce it German and anyway uh she said there a

013moratorium but every time you give out millions of that you're taking that off of the the tax payment and lastly the district Tad 8 which is adjacent to the $50 million baseball field that we did not authorize them to have there should have been a referendum adjacent to it is going to be a development of $350 million and in that $350 million they said that it's going to be 18 years that they don't pay any property taxes at all that's very disturbing because the people who are players in that thing is Uptown Columbus Inc and Jim lanard is a registered agent I've been down that road before I've done my homework and he's CB&T sova's former president you got WC Bradley again sovis and then you got Kathy Williams who used to be the former

014chairman she's neighbor works CEO neighborworks okay and then if you take a look at her board of directors you got covis written all over that too some of the board members sovus they're becoming very rich off of us and they plan on bringing a gambling uh casino here to Columbus which will do nothing but exacerbate the crime wave that we're experiencing now and if you look at your own stats in your comprehensive eval financial report you'll see that 21.8% of the people in Columbus are let make less than the poverty level so that's one out of five people that you look at is at below poverty level we've got to start thinking about the poor people and we got to think about how we're taxing them to death we have the highest sales tax at

0159% and if you put the 23.3 21 of your property taxes along with the 17.62 that's 41 plus the state is 42 Mills we have the highest property tax and sales tax in the state of out of 159 counties in Georgia and then what really is disturbing is the credit report that I see on what we're getting on return and we've got for the average student we're paying for the taxpayers 11,686 then I looked at pelli and it's 11,900 for tuition there so in essence you can get a probably a better education there than you can here and the reason why is that it says mcco County School District average test ranking is 3/10 or the bottom 50% of the 159 counties so it's the 30 percentile okay that's we're of the 159 we're 50

016and Below okay and in the math we're a proficiency of 24% so 24 out of 100 kids are proficient in in math and versus the average in Georgia is 37% reading proficiency is 31% and the average in Georgia is 40% that's three out of 10 kids are are reading proficiency it's an Abomination and and it's and it's sad because I come from a family seven kids I came from poverty my mom had a second grade education my dad had an eighth grade education there were seven kids in her family she was a house cleaning lady she she the Mantra was if you're born poor you die poor and I said to myself oh God no and I'm going to do everything in my power to educate myself so I did that but a lot of

017these people don't have that opportunity so what we don't need to do is suppress and oppress people and put them in a a different way so when it comes to taxation in the future if you have a chance lifting it I'd say no do don't do that because people are struggling every day just to pay bills and I'm just asking in God's name amen thank you m Olson are there any other citizens all right third time are there any other citizens I think it's just us and Mr OLS all right then we will conduct another hearing on next Tuesday at 6 o'clock and that closes our public hearing all right now we will go do we have contact information R all right good to see you Mr Olsson all right now we'll go into our

018our board work session uh what was that we don't have a public agenda but I will take this opportunity um to go ahead and read our our background and rationale for a public agenda we do offer opportunities for the public to speak at each of our meetings the work session as well as the regularly scheduled board meeting all official meetings of the Board of Education shall be open to the press and public however the board may meet in executive session speakers remarks should be directed to the board and shall be limited to five minutes citizens are encouraged to address items on the board agenda or to initiate presentations of issues appropriate to the school board for consideration if individual desires to speak they may contact the superintendent's office to be placed on the agenda the

019board meeting or the work session is not the appropriate place to address either criticisms of particular employees or individual parent complaints when such complaints have not been first addressed to the attention of the appropriate administrator for a resolution citizens are encouraged to follow the normal channels to address individual parent complaints or problems and this um this week we have none so that will move us right into our education committee School progress report Miss Buckner okay hold on here we only have one item for the education committee and I see Mrs uh Dotan get the other part of your name Doon fault uh folk coming to the uh podium it's good to see you good evening I am Stephanie Faulk and it is my pleasure to serve as the Director of schooling um District Effectiveness I

020present to you today an update on CSI and atsi School progress first I would like to start out with acknowledgements we're so excited about our schools that have exited the state designation of CSI as well as TSI we have the current schools Davis Diamond Lenny Jackson yes I can uh so it's the comprehensive support um for schools and then also targeted um support for schools um as I was saying the schools that have exited the um designations are Davis Diamond Lenny Jackson Fox and Martin Luther King in addition several of those schools have receive recognition such as the literacy leader Banner um for growth and progress also we have Diamond STEM Academy that also recertified their stem certification last week we were informed that there were several schools that were recognized for making great strides

021as a CSI School these schools increase by 5% in their ccrpi Content Mastery and a score of 80 or higher in progress closing gaps or Readiness those schools are Baker Middle School Brewer early innovation academy and Forest Road Elementary School CSI and atsi criteria we have eight identified schools comprehensive support and Improvement CSI we have Elementary and midle middle schools stage one Content Mastery the lowest 20% of all Title One schools in Content Mastery that's stage one um second is stage two for progress It's the lowest 25% of the title one schools in progress or lowest 10% of Title One schools and closing the Gap stage three Readiness 5% of the title one schools with the lowest Readiness score our mcsd identified schools for fy2 for comprehensive support and Improvement are Baker Middle School Brewer

022early innovation academy Dorothy High Elementary Eddie Middle School Forest Row Elementary School and Georgetown Elementary School in 2025 2026 school year is the next redetermination cycle throughout this presentation I will provide you with the support that we are providing as well as the state and as well as Risa before I conclude this presentation on today additional targeted support and Improvement atsi there are also three stages there is no cut score so there's no way to determine what a school could make for their Content Mastery or any of the ccrpi components in order for them not to be on this particular list stage one Content Mastery performed at or below the highest Content Mastery score among CSI lowest performing schools stage two progress and closing gaps performed at or below the highest progress score among CSI

023lowest performing schools or performed at or above the highest closing Gap score among CSI lowest performing schools stage three Readiness performed at the below the highest Readiness score among CSI lowest performing schools so as I stated earlier we have no indication of the schools that fall in these categories because it's the entire state of Georgia the mcsd identified schools F525 additional targeted support and Improvement we have Davis Elementary and Key Elementary and they qualifi based on the area of special education further in this presentation we will talk about also how the special education department is also supporting these schools School data so here is gmass 2024 Content Mastery and it's in comparison to the star winter Ela Content Mastery School it's not uncommon when you look at the star winter Ela Content Mastery scores for

024you to see that we are not where we want to be by the end of this year before the students take the gmass assessment when we really think about how much they've done from August to December is somewhat close to Mid a midpoint of part of the curriculum that they're learning so there's still a lot to learn prior to testing the score range if you look at the range for gmass 2024 for Content Mastery is any anywhere from 20% to 36% star winter Ela Content Mastery ranges anywhere from 23% to 42% and you can see some increases and some decreases but we will talk about the supports we are in embedding in these schools at this point for math if you look at the range for math as well there's a comparison of gmass 2024

025to Star winter math Content Mastery um the rain once again is anywhere from 177% to 43% and that's for gmass on the other hand for Star winter math Content Mastery you'll see that it ranges from 19 to 34% this year and last year well last school year we implemented the new math standards and so this is more of a baseline for us for math progress monitoring and supports so these schools CSI and atsi schools receive dist support gdau support and they also receive Rea support and we'll talk about each one of those entities and the support that they provide District support collaborative planning walkthroughs I've had the pleasure of working with a team and sitting in on common planning time throughout the district with the CSI and atsi schools and I'm not going to go

026through this whole checklist but just kind of let you know this is what we look for for evident or not evident and primarily we're in there just making ensure that they understand what the standards are that they're teaching the students they understand a success criteria to determine whether the students actually learn the standards um also we look at are they looking at misconceptions um that students may have when you're teaching them the standards and skills we look at how are they going to implement the opening closing um and work session for the students you know are the teachers explicitly modeling are they providing feedback to students and also are they using data to drive their instructional decisions also we've conducted standard space instruction walkthroughs um within our schools this month I know we've already completed

027three walkthroughs and we'll continue throughout this month and we also provide the faculty and staff with feedback especially the administrative team when we go into the standard space classroom we look for the instructional framework we look to make sure that the learning targets and success criteria are aligned as well as we look at engagement strategies are the teachers engaging the students in the work um eity of voice are we hearing 100% teachers are we hearing more 50% the students 50% the teachers looking for personalization of the lesson based on the needs of the students are the students actively engaged how are the teachers engaging them is it a positive learning climate for the students and that's just a few areas for look fors um District support and what I will say is I'm I've been

028impressed being in the department of teaching and learning because they're offering a lot of resources for our schools U one of the main resources that rolled out this year was our learning um Mogi County teaching and learning blueprint and through the blueprint oh my goodness there's so many resources in the blueprint um that's where you can find learning plans um as I was talking earlier about learning targets and success criteria that's already embedded in the plan so was more the teacher taking their data and determining what's best for their student based on the resources we have embedded in the plan um also there are other resources that we have you fly and we'll talk a little bit more about that through our work with the science of reading because we're really focusing in on Phonics

029and early learning for our students so that they can read so that when they are in Upper grades we feel like they'll be much more successful because we know reading is the foundation for all of the content areas yes ma'am with the um with the information being embedded for the teachers is there some support for the teachers to help them um utilize that resource yes ma'am so um I would say twice in the beginning of the summer and at the end of the summer the department of teaching and learning supported the principles and also um taught us how to use the blueprint and that included Your academic coaches who were a part of of it which are your instructional Specialists within the school as well as with these particular schools we have been out and

030we've had our content Specialists from each one of the content areas go out to help support the different departments if it's middle school and also the horizontal grade level so there's inhouse support through your administrative team including the academic coaches who have had um professional development regarding the learning plans as well as the um Department of teaching the learning they're sending out their content specialist to help support and our teacher quality specialist through our professional development department and um as we're going into the classrooms as well if we see there's a need based on our feedback we're also um giving feedback and we're looking at next steps and we're working on a continuous Improvement cycle for them so it's basically here the needs that we see U let's discuss the next steps and then we're

031bringing in our teams to help support them um based on their needs and from there we're going back to monitor again to make sure we're successful in the implementation of the blueprint um as far as the writing framework um that's been an area that I know we want to make great Improvement in is 47% in elementary school of the reading uh gmass assessment score and so we are providing writing framework courses for them and the framework courses it's basically a lesson plan laid out so that the teachers do not have to do the work it's more of just once again looking at your students needs and pacing the lesson accordingly Universal screeners and informative assessments we're using those to drive and adjust instruction School walkthroughs and feedback for standards based classroom instruction that was based

032on the walkthrough form that I just displayed professional development and the coaching cycle provided to schools by content and teacher quality Specialists and alongside them are the school's academic coaches Department of exceptional student students they're providing assistive technology training they're conducting the school walkthroughs and they provide feedback as well also they're providing evidence-based professional development based on the school needs my job my role director of school and District Effectiveness so for me right now um I'm working with the regional Chiefs um my academic office Chief academic officer Dr Lewis and um the other goodd do Effectiveness specialist um we attend monthly formal continuous Improvement team meetings where we discuss the data based on the walkthroughs and we look at next steps and it's Collective because we also receive input from those schools and from um

033the the state as well as our district we participate in classroom walkthroughs and we provide feedback we meet with all departments and divisions on behalf of the CSI and TSI identified schools which the cabinet members have been wonderful anytime we have a request I know that since I've been in the position it's been less than 24 hours that it's like okay Miss faul it's a CSI TSI School here's what you need let me know if you need anything else updates and School progress monitoring workbooks to create gmass score projections and to revise and refine School Improvement efforts we do have workbooks where we can look at the categories of the students and we can kind of plug them into this worksheet and it will tell us like a like a projected score so once again

034it helps Drive everything we do to decide on if we need to make adjustments to our next steps for growth um also we revisit School concerns with gdo Risa um Chief academic officers and Regional Chiefs those updates on School progress those U individuals the updates on the school progress are those individual schools and you you do the individuals and you uh gather all that information to compile it for so for each individual school we still go out and share that data yes so um for example I had a zoom meeting last Friday so we went out to the school we shared uh feedback from our walkthroughs we created the next steps and then also when we're in the CIT meetings which they have formal CIT meetings with just their um School specialist from the state

035and the regional Chiefs my chief and myself and administrative team they're all present and then we go over those workbook we look at the workbook in the data as well and we make changes because once again with the school improvement process it's forever changing because if we say hey at this point we met our goal then let's what's next and then we just kind of continue to look at the data so yes ma'am and it's individualized personalized to the school um for the cabinet members the Chiefs actively work side by side with the principles for Progress monitoring purposes they're constantly inside of the schools and they're also there with me as well when I'm meeting and working with the schools um they make sure the data workbooks are updated they collaborate uh with the the

036administrative team in the school and then also they are part of the leadership teams and they visit very frequently um all good do identified schools participate in two live meetings um with the superintendent and the cabinet to review progress adding needs and we use what we call an atlas protocol this year and through that protocol we looked at and reviewed data and we had a conversation with them and what I will say is my superintendent pretty much he kind of he he led it he facilitated it and they had a conversation with him and they were able to really look at next steps as well and what their needs were for the school this is the administration yes so it could be the leadership team the leaders all aart and then all of the cabinet

037members here also were on the meetings they were either live or um they were in person as guests as a part of the live meetings um all the district departments divisions provide Priority Services to CSI schools and other state identified schools once again when they tell us a need the cabinet members are readily available to help meet that need GD do um provides us with good do inspired it also has resources and documents and if you look at the list as some of the things that they provide as well for the teachers and it's easily accessible this year um we've opened up Brewer early innovation academy and that is one of our prek-2 literacy and numeracy initiatives and it serves our prek through second grade students from Brewer Davis MLK and Dorothy Height and it

038offers personalized learning experiences in small groups the um student to teacher ratio is 14 to1 and in some classes is less than that um we implement the science of reading framework with support from the Rollin Center uh for language and literacy we execute the continuous Improvement cycle to improve in um instruction and increase student learning outcomes we also are implementing the multi-tier system of support you may have heard of it as mtss as the framework to provide immediate extensive and intensive interventions to accelerate learning as well as to close achievement gaps among that student population we also provide ongoing professional development to teachers to improve their understanding of the reading processes and executive function as well as to refine their instructional practices uh we also offer wraparound services and support for families through the community

039um schools United strategy there is an emphasis on the development of key foundational literacy and numeracy abilities setting the stage for continued academic achievement as as well as to assist the students with transitioning to the next stage of their educational Journey when we look at feeder patterns we also noticed that with the students from Brewer early innovation academy they will be equipped with strong a strong foundation in essential reading and math skills ensuring they are fully prepared for Success at Baker and Eddie or any Middle School in our school district science reading initiative progress all elementary students are or will be participating in the science of reading initiative 21 out of the 30 elementary schools comprise cohorts one and two of the Rollins Center professional development and coaching series cohort 3 will begin in August

0402025 with the remaining elementary schools that are now part of cohort 1 and two implementation of the science of reading framework provides systematic explicit instruction to support the development of oral and written language for all students targeting early Learners and struggling Learners in our schools our professional development plan has been tailored to provide instructional guidance and coaching to teachers in the areas of phic awareness phonics fluency vocabulary writing and comprehensive I mean comprehension based on State Standards curriculum resources are also in line with our state law HB 538 professional development is offered through cot campus courses and iners and inperson sessions facilitated by the Rollins Center the mcsd ele content specialist for literacy and mcsd literacy leaders also supporting this work learning walks coaching cycles and feedback sessions are also conducted by these same leaders

041School data chats are also facilitated by the Rollins Center and our mcsd leaders gdau support so in these CSI schools we do have school Effectiveness Specialists from the state who come in and they're here at least three days out of the week and they facilitate the continuous Improvement team meetings they also are part and participants in the leadership team meetings and the collaborative planning meetings for atsi schools they provide professional development opportunities as needed gdau also supports us with the district effective specialist and she assists with also the CIT meetings um that she facilitates monthly she assists with data collection and reviews and she also helps with monitoring the district support to CSI schools Risa support we have res support in our building School Improvement Specialists and um I've had the opportunity to meet them

042not only do we have the school Improvement specialist in the building we also have the school Improvement content specialist in the building and they're in the schools weekly as well and they assist with collaborative planning and also they assist with classroom walkthroughs and if atsi schools need support they're willing to support them as well and that concludes my presentation are there any questions I I have a question um so do is there any indication from gdau that they will develop a cut score to to just have it open-ended like that has has been quite frustrating um even in sports I mean you got to have some kind of goal some kind of Target some kind of measurement um because if you just create a list of everybody on it without a cut score there's always

043going to be somebody at the top and always going to be someone at the bottom but you have to have a cut score I mean even with the act the SAT you know what your score has to be in order order to meet certain criteria um one principal did give a a really good analogy about not having a cut score it's like in a football game moving the the goal post in the middle of kicking kicking the field goal not knowing if it's that you have 10 yards in order to have a first down is there any indication from the state that they're going to develop some kind of cut score they're just going to keep creating a list list of all of the schools I mean there's I just need to know if there's

044um any indication so this is all directed and guided by the federal department of education US Department of Education their parameters set how each state has to calculate these particular lists um the testing is left up pretty much to the individual states to determine but they the state the US Department of Education has said based on those uh top or bottom 25% bottom 10% bottom 5% whatever the case may be that is the parameter they set how the state does it within that that's up to the state but we've all said it'd be much better to set some kind of a threshold let us know where that threshold is to work toward that but as it is it's a sliding scale so uh for example one of the schools on the list improved in every

045category and because in one category they improve as much as they felt like they should have that's where they fell below is that the best way to explain that M Mr KN okay yeah one one of the assessed areas but they improved in all of them but not enough in that one to put them on the list so we would definitely concur we'd love to have a threshold I've always said you know set the bars high as you want to set it but just set a star a bar at some point that we can work to reach and it's frustrating when schools work very hard and get this much improvement in virtually every category but because they didn't meet the mark in one category because others did it pushes them down so it's just a

046very difficult and challenging situation especially since you don't know along the way how you're doing there's no way to really or what you're or what you're what you're monitoring what you're progressing towards there's I mean I that's I don't understand that me either because even as I um anything I attempt to do I like to know the rules I like to know what the score is how I'm going to pass what what grade am I going to make so the first thing I do even before I'm in any kind of class or have any kind of situation I study the rules see what the scores are and then try to figure out how to get there but in this situation there is no way to figure out how to get there you know you just

047gota work along I mean we're always going to do our best anyway you know we're still going to do our best and work hard try to do your best try to make sure we don't um wind up on a list however um you know it's uh when people are working towards something they need to know what they're working toward and um it's it's a Advantage for these schools to be working and just working hard and and like and to be on the slide and scale and not know where wind up so and depending on the list and again Mr KN you could corroborate this I suppose depending on the list some schools are taken out not even considered in the calculation some of the state Charter Schools yeah are not even considered in the calculation

048wow just for full transparency are these understand State Charters I just have a couple of questions if I can so that I can get a um a clear picture of where we are as a district um so we have several schools that are considered to be CSI and there are several criteria in order for them to get on that list one of them is being in the lowest 5% of Title One schools is that how these schools got on the list are we in the lowest 5% of Title One schools or is is there another criteria that put these schools on the list so it starts with that stage and then also you have to qualify through stage stage two and stage three and so I can go back to that slide so we can

049look at it just originally how did they ID how did they identify these eight schools I'm what I'm trying to see is um the state that we're in as a district so how did we get eight schools on this CSI list from what I understand from talking to the state um and asking questions since I'm in this new role is that when they look at all the scores across the state then they look at the lowest 25% and the schools that fit in that range they look at that first through Content Mastery and then next they look at whether those same Schools fall in the lowest 25% as far as progress or the lowest 10% and then they move down to 5% um as far as the title one schools with the lowest score for

050Readiness score so that's why we don't have a cut score because it just depends on what those schools their performance is the way it was explained to me when I asked so we don't necessarily these schools are not necessarily in the bottom 5% for Ty one schools no it could be in we're looking at different categories eight total schools in either CSI TSI or atsi the list that you all gave us that's all comprehensive the eight schools are all inclusive of all those categories right okay and so the other thing that you mentioned um throughout the presentation was science of reading initiative you mentioned the Roland Center and then you mentioned teaching and learning blueprint can you um just walk through for me how are the teachers able to access this information because it just

051seems like a massive amount of information yes what role how do they category categorize what they're supposed to be doing for SS of reading initiative what they're doing with the rolling Center what they're doing with teaching and learning Blueprints and then looking at the state standards okay so that's that's a lot of resources the blueprint I know you fre can talk about it but I just want to add that that was the uh best part that was the best part of the presentation those uh District blueprints I had no idea you know those were that you know I know we we were supported District State and um District State Rea but the district support I found to be the best support because of those uh those uh blueprints okay sorry that's okay and I have

052a follow-up question about the blueprint once you sort of put into perspective see as a as a former teacher I'm thinking about me how would I keep all of that um in the back of my mind while I'm doing my lesson plans I got to consider the science of reading I got to consider what's going on with the rolling Center I got to consider the blueprint and then first and foremost I look at the Jord standards because that's what I'm going to be my my teach my um students are going to be testing on so how are they keeping all of this just give me a um you know map it out for me so I can visualize it so we are building the blueprint to be a One-Stop shop for teachers meaning it will

053have lesson plans in there it'll have Assessments in there um many of the courses are there we're still building out some other courses and we're still um improving the ones that are already built um the point is for teachers not to have to plan for them to be able to go in have a plan that they can start from and then make adjustments as needed based on their classroom um to to help streamline that streamline that planning process for them so that's the the bigger picture of it where the Rollins is is a small component within the instructional piece so we're looking at um you know phics phic awareness those different things that are needed for um just improving literacy with our students um those are components that are built into our lesson plans within

054a blueprint um within also within hmh our um our primary curriculum resource um so it's it's kind of like a subset of the the blueprint so the blueprint is a 10,000 foot view of everything all together they can go in Access those things they can plan with other teachers um do the assessment piece and all that where the ring Center work is very specific to the components of literacy and and how we get those kids um stronger in reading and what about the science of reading initiative that's the Rollins that's the Rollins oh so they're not two separate things it's one Rollins is the entity with whom we are working that is embedding the uh science of reading in our schools to have consistent methodology throughout the district okay and so this blueprint you guys

055have already taken into consideration the resources that the Rollin Center is bringing in and then the science of reading initiatives and the state standards yes all of that is intertwined so the teacher is not pulling from these several resources all of them are really in one place is that what you're telling me the idea was to have One-Stop shop when I charged this to teaching and learning a couple years ago I wanted one place especially in light of the fact that we're going we're having more and more teachers coming in not necessarily having the pedagog would you have traditional training right to make sure you could have one place where you could go to find your standards you could find your pacing guides your resources all of it's right there and tells you when and

056where to put the to utilize these particular resources for this particular standard um I don't know how else to explain other than it's kind of like the the bies everything's there bies everything's there yes understandable okay that makes me feel a lot better also we're in the process and some courses are further along than others in terms of development but we're also trying to build in their formative assessments along the way too so we can tell to inform the instruction going forward where are you now in the fifth week of school or the eighth week or nth week of school so we can make adjustments informed adjustments to the instruction and personalized for individual students based on their need likewise we have canvas uh that teachers can or parents can access at home to help

057supplement and support their children with what they're learning throughout the day as well right and the teacher has the autonomy if they if they find out that their students don't need this par particular lesson that's on the pacing guide they can alter or do something different yes to to a degree we're not we're not we can't get off the reservation you know we've got to keep people focused on what we're doing but in terms of not everybody gets the same thing if we if we do a formative assessment and some students are demonstrating Mastery early on they can move on it's I liken it to like an accordion you can expand and contract the the curriculum as you need to based on the needs of your students right and the intent is our our new

058teachers in their first three years they stick closely to it and then as they get more proficient they can start you know experimenting more doing different things from that um the bottom line is are we getting the the student growth from that classroom and if if we're getting the growth from that classroom that teacher can do what they need to do from their perspective to continue getting that growth and I'm a big believer in performance grants autonomy if you're getting good performance you have a little more autonomy and we're not talking about growth as far as um you know magnet class where they're coming in proficient we're talking about growing kids period no where they are absolutely and so I'm assuming that the teachers are then working with um you and also working with uh

059testing to sort of analyze that data and to see where we can fill in those gaps with those students okay yes okay sounds good and my last question um well maybe not my last question but my next question is about the walkthroughs um when you're conducting the walkthroughs who's um on that team is it a team of people going through doing the walk throughs and um are there any teachers a part of that group um giv that feedback sort of peer peer walk through also not with what we're doing um with our teams it's the district team of course from dtl or Department of teaching and learning as well as we have our state um Lea for school Effectiveness the regional Chiefs and myself and then also the academic coaches or Deans as well yes

060from that school because we try to calibrate um and meaning that as we look at the objectives for the different criteria we try to talk about it to make sure that we're you know because we want to give them the same message and not that they're hearing something different from the principal versus what they're hearing from the team that comes out um I actually reduced the number of um team members because I want us to collabor um collab calibrate better and make sure we're collaborating I should say it that way way um so that once again there's one message and that we're not overwhelming the administrator where I'm saying something and then someone else is saying something else and then also when you have the coaches involved they're the ones that are also supporting the

061instruction and so it's easier for them to go back to the teachers and say you know this is what we need to do recently um for a walk through at one of the schools well two of the schools the uh Department of teaching and learning we did it side by side we looked at the walkth through form that um you just saw in the presentation and then they actually um looked at the content so they were able to give more information and we look more at the instructional framework so that was very helpful to the and before the lessons ever taught one of the things that we do is collaborate of planning get the third grade team together go in there and look at the standard and the idea behind that is because it's all

062laid out it's no longer thought about as planning it's more like preparation the planning's been done for you all you have to do is figure how to implement um in terms of quality of instruction and often times they will come back the expectations will come back and debrief that lesson as a team how' that go what could have gone better and as we start using our in-classroom cameras the hope is that we planed our strategy is to start getting them to use that in classroom camera to debrief the lessons as are actually being conducted let the teachers come back look at the lesson the way it was taught what suggestions might there be to improve the lesson for everyone are there any more questions I I had a couple of things and again I'm probably

063gonna show my ignorance in this so when we talk about our frustration with these lists it is and and the idea of the moving Target it is because it is based on your percentage as ranked against other schools not as saying okay if you achieve this score on your Mastery you will get off of the list okay so because again if you made but I mean again if you were 35 and then all of a sudden everybody else was 35 you could drop so okay but it is still based on these scores and then how you rank on that okay so I was trying to which I mean I get that and I understand you know that you don't like to have them categorized but it was interesting to me I did not realize that

064we had um good employees actually in our schools you know offering assistance which is another resource and a help to those schools and recent that are um that are struggling to where you know help is at least they are sending help where it is needed but again I was just trying to kind of understand that and then I guess and this might not be a question for today but looking at the schools that we did take from in made Brewer innovation academy um you know how going to kind of see their performance going forward one I know like Brewer showed up but I didn't know how we had like now the Brewer school now how are we comparing it stats is that from like the beginning of the year till now because it wasn't from

065last year because it would be we talked about the universal screener we give those at beginning of the year mid year end of the year and then of course of gmass scores which are tightly correlated we've used matter of fact you may have seen emails I've sent to you all about our our screeners and our resources for teaching reading have all been approved by the state in terms of what they require uh and they're at the highest level of efficacy so we feel like we got really good resources in there so at this point then what we want to try and do is continue using those resources and then in these schools for for Brewer what we'll see because again their assessment they don't get assessed in SE through prek through second grade but as

066those students move on into third grade we've been talking about this our next step is to make sure that as these students matriculate through second grade when they're close to being on grade level we can't just remove all the supports that got them where they are so we've got to make sure we have that same kind of support wherever they go to their partner School whether it's MLK whether it's Dorothy Height uh whatever it might be we want to make sure we have a class or two that continue to support those students so that when they go into third grade they continue to be successful now again obviously this is our first year Brewer so the students who matriculate on to third grade at our partner schools say this next year will not be necessarily

067as well U inoculated if you want to use that word or whatever as will be the students who have been there for four years four years from now they'll have the benefit because again what we're talking about now is when teachers receive a group of students in kindergarten or first grade they're going to keep those in Loop up with them they know who the students are they've got the personality they understand everything about them when they go to summer school they're not going to go to a different teacher like we do in some other Schools they're going to have the same teacher we're that's one of the reasons we're paying our teachers more at that school and they'll actually have that group of students all the way through to then move on so I think

068the the merits of it will be seen down the road three or four years from now but we are already seeing uh Mr Bell has shown how the growth in those School in in Brewer is been pretty impressive thus far just in one semester I think was about a what was the had 43% typical or high growth which that top 10 in the district very good okay thank the um our Universal screener is that is that star reading and star math okay did I hear you say that they are very highly correlated to G the star test okay I think somebody said that they had um improve the star test because yeah thank you miss you take you've taken the Miss green position okay thank you um the uh star you know I see I

069see a STAR test I see I gave it for several years but it was um it it used to didn't have the the complexity as the gmk so the star test now is more difficult it's uh it's a different star test I like to see that star test is there any way I can see huh I don't want to take I just want I just want to see it because it doesn't take but a few minutes to take anyway it's it's about about five minutes to take for any student but yeah I do want to see is there any way I can see those tests then probably just give it to because I'll give it to somebody because I I I just want to see the correlation the correlation between that gmass is hard the

070star test is U something thank you I I do appreciate that uh and what else was that the star test and the um okay I don't see it right now any more questions anybody thank you so much Stephanie I couldn't remember your last name so we appreciate it good job thank you Miss Buckner um next is our policy committee Miss chillery thank you madam president 6.01 we're going to discuss the 2025 legislative priorities on December 16th 2024 the board um of Education approved a riority Iz list of legislative priorities for 2025 as recommended by the local legislation um delegation the Board of Education will review and discuss priority number five as it pertains to when a vacancy occurs on the school board so do youall want me to read it I thought we did that

071too but I can read it again if you need me to had to be on the for 30 days is that right no we um we asked them to consider the language all right so here it is and we also they also asked us to put it in a priority okay yeah I thought we did oh okay that's I came this afternoon in case there were questions and I certainly wanted to be part of this discussion so we don't have Mis understanding going forward but what we need to do what I think I think it's time for you all to do is to all get on the same page about exactly what language you want to submit to our legislators to have them consider to adopt to replace the language that was adopted last year

072because it did not accomplish what you all have indicated you want to have done which is to give you all the ability to appoint somebody as a board to ser in the vacant spot until a an election can be conducted that would not cost you any money to conduct not a special election but to have an election conducted um to fill that vacancy for the remainder of that term so there's some ways to to do that um it turns out that what you all have described uh wanting in this year's legislative agenda appears to me to be very similar to what the state law is for filling vacancies on Boards of Education there actually is a state statute on that I have conferred with Nancy Boren the elections superintendent to make sure I understand how

073it would work in practice and she indicates to me that it does appear to fit the Des descrition of what you all have said in this year's legislative priority so I don't know if everybody has been given a copy of that statute but we can certainly do that so you can read it for yourself but but basically the the concept is you have to have at least 90 days advance runup to an election because somebody has to qualify so that puts in place at least a 90day advance window and what the state law is is operating is if you have more than 90 days before the next ele the next nonpartisan election which typically is in May every two years then the vacancy would be filled in an election which you wouldn't have to pay

074for it if you don't have 90 days in advance of that date or it's you know it's in June that the vacancy becomes available or comes open then you all would appoint somebody until that next nonpartisan primary election which would be in that instance you know um would be different amounts of time you know depending on where we are in the count between elections but that's what the state law already calls for and my only question is the wording and I could just be reading it wrong um it just says you know Revis HB 1280 such that when a vacancy occurs on the school board the vacancy is filled by a majority of the school board should it be like a vote by the majority of the school board instead of just filled by a

075majority of the school board only until a new board member you know then it goes into that right I just didn't know if that verbiage was just a little off right there and again I could be reading it incorrectly but it just feels like maybe vote yes that's right but I I think we need we need to be more specific in the language that we actually send to them than just the legislative priority that you all adopted in October November whenever was soon that we can all vote on I guess next Monday we can see soon I I know I've seen something but I think we need to all and I'm guess I'm hearing are youing that we should tie it to the existing state um rule or should we and then keep for ourselves

076the ability to change it if the overall state law ever got changed to something we didn't like or do we just take the language from that state Lo law and put into our own law that is now ours both I think your first concern that you all want to maintain the autonomy to control how you fill these vacancies I agree with that being a an objective and I think the way to do it is just if if everybody reads the state law and agrees that it meets your needs then I think we can just submit that language to them and say we would like for you to adopt this as our local act on filling a vacancy on our board and then if the state ever changes the state law and you like what you

077have and works for you you're not bound by whatever happens in Atlanta five six seven years down the road because in my understanding and I remember when I researched this is the state law is kind of a default it's saying if a school district or a governmental agency I don't remember if it's just school districts if they don't have their own law then this is what happens they have their own then that's controlled correct um no I think that sounds good I was clear just something you said I mean either way the board will have to appoint somebody to fill out a term it just might only be for you know four months five mon you know whatever so just I wanted to clar for that they'll still need to app point it just hopefully

078will be for a shorter amount of time under this revision that's correct sounds good Greg yes going from this into the part of an appointment of the board to somebody how do we go about all of us picking somebody if this should ever happen and you know that's the whole thing has only happened twice and 40 50 years now so it's not something that's going to happen all the time but if it did how does the board come and do we all pick a person that we might like and then we vote on that person I mean this is just something I see what's the next stage of what we're talking about tonight um how do we go about that you know what I'm saying don't you Greg yeah I do I I understand the

079question I believe so y'all did discuss sort of a mechanism that would be in place to go through the steps where an a committee is appointed where a committee is appointed uh and then comes back with a recommendation which this board could then either accept or not the board wouldn't be bound by the recommendation of the committee but but we had those discussions back in you know June July what if somebody had a you know a board member because that's where it's coming from what if a board member had somebody they want to recommend but they're not on the committee yeah I I think that the um procedure that we already sort of work through takes that scenario into account and that there would be an opportunity for somebody to do that to make a

080recommendation to the committee and then you know and then the committee Works through it does background you know searches checks to make sure the person is actually qualified lives in the district doesn't have any issues um that would prohibit them from serving uh but this is a great opportunity to look at that again and make sure that it will work the way that you all want it to work so so I think we've I think we've addressed that but it's not too late to look at it again to make sure that everybody's on the same that's what I was looking for great appreciate it yes sir the reason it was only going to be a three member committee is so that it didn't have to be made public since we're kind of talking about individual

081people I mean or is there any kind of exception for that kind of meeting that we could have you know four or five people on the committee and it still not have to be it would have to be public I I'm not aware of an exception matter how many people are on the committee I think if but just as a reminder the current way we had it the board chair would pick would have three people to serve on the committee everybody can give a name to the committee the committee then will take steps to make sure that they're qualified the way it does read now the committee then makes a recommendation for a person and so if you that person that you put up did not get recommended by the committee you'd have you have

082the opportunity to bring them back at the table I guess one variation could be that the committee could just only vet them and not make a recommendation and at that point the whole Board gets to look at all the people that qualified that were put up and get to make their own decision from there I like that I you know when I looked some in the other state laws most of them didn't get that much into the we I think most of them really had the committee type stuff probably in their policies so I didn't really see a lot about how that worked I had not really seen language that did it the way ours the language from last year said it but um I think we can think through that or that might be

083something that I don't know if I'm off course here but if in the new legislation we don't say that and we just handle that within our own policy I agree with that because really we should set policy the policy should be set at the school board level so I think that we definitely decide on this language for number five but then the process is handled in our policy um for the school board so that it's not necessarily state law but this is the way that way if we want to make a change we can make it here locally at the school district level instead of making it at the state level that was never an issue I didn't think I trying to make sure there waser any reason I didn't think that was an issue

084but Lori too uh I want um I think what U what has become an issue is um the way the committee making the rec uh the recommendation uh uh as opposed to coming to the table with no recommendation um it seems to me that that would be um you know [Music] um it would take uh there might be a b whole lot of um discussion or maybe disorder without actually a recommendation I mean I'm just saying uh is I I think the if if if the school board members want access to I think they should if they want to have access to the backgrounds of the people that's fine but I do think should come with a recommendation all we have to do is vote it down or vote vote it uh up or vote

085it down and uh and even if the school board member wants to come to the table that night and say um there's a recommend I like another person added to be voted on at Schoolboard members we can do that you know uh we can do that at the table you know and what I was just saying is I do think with the three committee we should come at least with the recommendation it would be more orderly to me but one I don't really have a strong preference you know either way I just think it might be neater if we put in in policy so that way if we do ever somebody has an issue with that part we don't have to go back to the legislature to get them to change so just just for

086a clarification the the things that we're talking about now about how this committee would operate those are things that you all took under advisement and voted on as policy local policy is not part of the local act yeah but we also did do it in policy when we had a law that said we had to have that committee so I mean the law said it first we then because I I said plenty of times we have to do it now because it's the law and we've got to add we could add a little to it I think the better thing going forward would be for that part just not to be in the law and let that part be a procedure that we but in our policy understood good all right any other questions so

087FYI the legislative session began today we don't have anything so we need to get it done because the legislative session began today well so what I intend to do is Sir is is circulate the state law which I think covers what you all are asking for okay thank you there are no more questions I will move on to 6.02 Board of Education meeting schedule for 2025 um It's usually the second and third Monday um but there are a few exceptions Monday February 17th that's um President's Day so that will be on a Tuesday and um oops sorry I think I just logged out you're welcome um um Monday June 23r and then Monday July 21st is going to be a com a combination of work session and board meeting m December 15th It's a combination

088of work session and board meeting and then Monday January 19th is Martin Luther King Jr holiday so it will be move to the Tuesday are there any questions no mark your calendars accordingly yeah okay if there's nothing else I will turn it back over to you madam chair thank you so much Miss tiller discipline committee there are no items um submitted this month and then next Pat fry with our property committee thank you madam chair um first we have 8.01 which is the proposed sale of the Rose Hill school property it's being uh the board's being asked to approve uh or consider for approval at our next meeting uh the sale of approximately 1.9 Acres of property at 433 21st Street formerly Rose Hill School to include structure and all improvements the purchaser is Olympia

089Development LLC and it's for residential development the purchaser will be responsible for all closing costs associated with the sale of the property the approval of the sale includes the approval of commission payment of $7,000 equal to 7% of the total sale price to calwell bank or kbd k commercial KPD the district's approved realtor the commission payment will be processed from the proceeds of the sale which of course will believe uh after the $100,000 sale 7,000 commission would leave a net revenue for the uh school district of $93,000 any comments questions can we throw can we get them to throw into 7,000 closing cost for where we clear at least 100 Grand on that I mean I know the property very well and I know it's maybe a CD part but it's still that's a wonderful

090prize for it because we had done a full remodel on that school several years ago now I think it's probably been broke into since that time but I'm just saying can we ask them to pay everything where we clear a 100 Grand on the steel I'm going to reach ask somebody else to to be able to address that I know nobody could probably answer that but I think in executive in executive session we kind of said we were okay with including I don't remember the 7,000 I thought it was 100,000 we was making on the on the building typical I mean you know when we we have when we say we're willing to accept a certain price that's with the understanding that there will be a realtor Fe yeah but when you go from 300,000

091down to $100,000 that's a $200,000 drop there from the asking price that's a big drop in anybody's book that's a big drop so that's I'm just bringing I'm not saying that's a Make It or Break It but I would like to clear 100 Grand on the property I mean just seem like it'd be by far worth that and it's never been on the market for 100 grand also remember it was that 300,000 this company came in and made a 100 th they made that and decided not to do it then they made 100,000 well that sort of eliminates everybody else making a bid on now that it's dropped so low we might have several people come in and say I'll give you more than that for it I don't know I'm just saying I'm just

092going to say with as much as long as it sat there and as many people but it's 300,000 too it said that but we did have an agreement um comment to make please but that was my only comment thank you L okay Mark I think that's a a great comment and a great idea but as a realtor the commission percentage is decided on the front end and that would be in our agreement with the listing agent when and if we've already sort of agree that no matter what the purchase price is that they get a certain commission I don't think it's I don't think we can go back at the end and do it now asking the buyer perhaps to pay that Fe maybe we could have yeah maybe we could have done that on

093the front end but I think once we gave them the okay for this purchase price if they've already signed it we're sort of like locked in and I would hate to sort of go back on our word at this point but definitely put a pen in that and remember that for the next time that that's just my two cents I'm for it don't get me wrong I'm for it I was just trying to clear 100 for us absolutely I was just gon to say it says supporting documents pending so will we get those soon yes you will have them it's just the final contract to sign we're waiting for that to come in okay thank you there's nothing else move on to 8.02 a land swap uh we're being asked to consider approving the land

094swap on the site at Forest Road Elementary School um to the company of wiser home builders LLC which will receive area one of 0.56 Acres currently owned by MCO County School District MCO County School District will receive area two which is 79 Acres currently owned by wiser home builders the land swap provides each party with land that is more suited for their needs uh the land swap transaction um would be just a like I said just a transaction of with nothing other than the property changing Yeah question so on the land swap swap is that suitable for each other's needs okay so what are our needs for the swap War do you want to address that please good evening the land that we'll be providing them will be suitable for a retention Pond and the

095land they'll be providing us would be suitable for a plague area or a land that the students can use oh okay all right thanks thank you thank you sir for that clarification any others okay moving right along 8.03 the uh board is asked uh to look at the and approve the appointment of new board I'm sorry Library board members um in accord with the 2010 I'm sorry 2010 memorandum of understanding between M County School District M County Library board in section 4 the school board the msco county library board in December approved the following list of applicants to be recommended to be appointed by the msco County School District to the msco county library board to fill three slots coming bacon in January of 2025 approval of these individuals will complete the library board approval

096process uh Shannon Reynolds Sharon Charles Jameson and David E Fox no questions concerns moving right along to our Museum report uh wonderful report uh Maryann but I want to say everybody needs to congratulate the library are on being nominated and um awarded best new library Museum yeah the museum yep um best new museum for [Applause] yeah that way to go Y and um we'll go ahead and move on to the library report one thing I thought was really cool in here was the was the officer contining to come and speak to the neighborhood uh about neighborhood safety and speaking at the library but the uh the partnership between Valley Health Care and um the South Columbus branch that starts this month to bring Health Care access to those who uh don't have it because of

097Transportation issues or access to health insurance or whatever so way to go thank you Davis to come speak the 23rd okay thank you and that concludes thank you thank you thank you so much Miss Freight uh Dr Lewis Madam chair board member Madam chair board members want to make you aware I received a time sensitive request today uh for a uh to adjust an easement that we approved back in 2019 for indemnification purposes uh it's been looked at there are no objections from legal and so on I'll send that information for you but is time sensitive from the standpoint that the U people who are requesting need it done by the end of January if at all possible so I will send that to you so you can look through it but it's nothing significant

098other than just the indemnification Clause okay so yes yes yes ma'am I just want to make it put it on record today thank you want to say I I even with uh Allan U the library and the museum I so appreciate your library and uh and Museum reports you do them so enthusiastically I love toar you give there your reports on the library and the museum person all right that concludes our property committee up next is our Personnel committee Miss Jackson okay um Madam chair we have um one item 9.01 which is the Personnel report there's four attachments are there any questions hearing none back to you madam chair thank you M Jackson uh Mr K Trail our construction committee thank you madam chair moving on to 10.01 construction manager HV vac various schools on

099October 21st 24 the board approved Peach engineering to design the heating ventilation and air conditioning equipment for Diamond Elementary School Fox Elementary School and Richards Middle School and rild Middle School the board also approved the construction manager at risk project delivery method the MCO County School District construction Department advertised for a CM following the standard State procurement process an evaluation team comprised of five evaluators review the responses provided by the construction companies five construction companies attended the mandatory site visit three of the five companies completed the bid process by the pro request by proposal uh Carlile construction carrier commercial service Freeman and associations River City Construction Sheridan Construction ruction the evaluation team has recommended River City Construction as the CM to work with peach engineering on this profit on this project any questions ladies gentlemen

100and gentlemen you superintendent no questions move to the next one 10.02 construction manager HVAC on October 21st 24 the board approved Peach engineering to design the heating ventilation air conditioning for Blackman Middle School School the board also approved the construction manager at risk the mcsd construction Department advertised for a CM three companies attended a mandatory site visit and all three companies completed the bid process by response to request by proposal Apex facility Service Group Carlow construction Freeman in association the El the Evolution team is recommending Carlow Construction as to CM work on peach peach engineering on this project any questions if Now we move to the next one 10.03 construction manager KET Stadium during the October 24 board meeting the board approved architect LLC to design the KET Stadium upgrades the board also approved a

101construction manager at risk for project delivery method the mcsd constru construction Department advertised for a CM following a standard State procurement process an evolution team if I'm saying that right I might not be uh comprised of five elevator evaluators review the responses provided by the construction companies y'all need to put a couple more long words in there so I can see six companies attended the mandatory site visit five of the six companies completed the bid process Bailey Harris Construction kylo Construction Freeman and Associates River City Construction Sheridan construction the BR construction the evaluation team is recommending Freeman and Association as to cm to work with the architect LLC on this project any questions ladies move to the next one 10.04 the construction status report and we have somebody here to talk about it don't we

102sir you got it buddy yeah waiting for the okay there we go thank you War yes sir so we got the uh construction January construction update slideshow two months ago I took y'all through a tour of the Kendrick project uh tonight we're going to tour Hardway even though we're about three weeks away uh from the actual completion with the punch list and and outside we close enough to show I wish this was three weeks down the road but uh we have the rendering here of what the school was going to look like uh this is a picture from the outside where we currently are so really it's just Landscaping pretty much is is what's left uh kind of a side view so you can get the elevation of the building uh is what it looks

103like um this is standing inside looking back out to where we just came from uh so that's uh the inside component of the building uh to the left picture is the again the inside and then kind of like you're standing in the center looking towards the uh doors in the on the right picture which is the original School in the very back coming down the hallway so this is the admin offices up front you see the new lighting very similar to the lighting that was in Jordan as y'all Tor it over there uh this is the uh front office or the secure vesu the reception area very updated very beautiful uh here you have a corridor that's in the main office and what a typical office looks like in this Suite here uh and through

104that door is actually uh principal madri's office in the back there so that's up front so they love that uh we have a work space here with the copier and then a construction I mean a conference table uh you can see that the furniture is obviously new um and then the conference table that they have there so these are our remaining projects and like I said we'll be finished about three weeks with that um we have uh remaining projects here Blackman Road uh Middle School HVAC the cop 26 uh HVAC which was just mentioned a few months ago with the diamond Fox Richard Rothchild double Church's Elementary upgrade the downtown Elementary HVAC cooling tower uh the Georgetown Elementary HVAC which is already underway and scheduled for completion of fall 25 uh the conet stadium upgrade

105uh which we just got the um construction manager or or will approved next week and then the secure vules that we're working on phase one being completed winter of 2425 so what I'm going to move to next is uh three additional slides it's going to have some some words on here want to talk about available East Bloss funds uh that we have and this it's a little bit more words than I usually have so I will provide this to y'all we're just going to go through it right this uh this evening to talk about the 15 East PL funds that are available I just want to remind everybody that the referendum on that was I'm going to use the word approximately so I won't have to give them exactly about around 192 million uh we

106had the collection shortfall back in 15 of the of the approximately $15 million which put a total East plus proceeds of the 1777 million uh we had other other funds that we uh put in and other funds are are items like uh the interest income the capital outlay reimbursements the e- rates the bond premiums the Bus Sales so we added that in which brought us up to $194 million or total expended out of that was 193 uh which leaves a, 400,000 left to spend and of course if you look down below we're over the winter break where actually those projects are underway so all we got to do is actually pay the bill and that money is completely gone so that's that's fixing be cleared out so that's where we were with the 2015 East

107Bloss the available 2020 East Bloss funds and again this was as the data of 11:30 uh the referendum was 189 million uh through what law allows to the collections up through November and then December and January the last quarter we're able to collect another roim 22 million which brings us up to 211 million uh the addition of the 25 million which is just the same stuff they just talked about Capital outlay reimbursements Income uh interest income bond premium stuff like that uh and then the um other funds that were received is part of that then the estimated addition of the 5 million which was some of the Arnold e rate and reimbursement put us up to $241 million and then we have 173 that we've expended so far which leaves us approximately $68 million left

108in the 2020 East plus and this is the buckets that'll be going in obviously the steam center that was 2 million uh North Columbus library was the 3 million technology 13 million left athletic Improvement 65 uh then you have the renovation and modification which is the 5year facility plan and to remind yall it's like HVAC roof stuff like that in that component campus Safety and Security of 5 million up playgrounds a half a million there left uh we have furniture fixtures just 116,000 uh buses or the white and White Fleet or other vehicles approximately 3 million and then the finance and bond 2 million which account for the 68 million that we have left so there's a projects associated with this in the future uh but I just want to kind of give a quick

109update of where we are with the where the funds on the 2020 East plus questions I don't have a question I was just going to say that I I watch so much um HGTV that when when I was at the basketball game at Hardaway I noticed that the ceiling outside continued on the inside that was so it looks very nice it's very neat and that would be a great um asset and upgrade for the parents in the community absolutely and and as always we thank the community for the East Bloss for whichone of these projects could wouldn't be done so thank you ward thank you good yes wait a minute any questions yes trying to get it on hold on oh laori I'm sorry I don't think mine's really for Mr other than I thought

110the 2020 paid out at the end of June so what was the additional money that comes in no because is that part of when did we start the 204 we won't start the 2024 until February we will get our first um money for that in February we started the the stores are now collecting for it in January we will get that money in um February why did I think that the 2020 because it was moving ahead of schedule I thought it kind of shut down at a certain point and when early okay so it would have run till next June yes okay it's just interesting how we ended up with so much more than what we had said I thought that that was the pointment shutting down sorry oh just leave leave your mic on

111Janice all right leave me on um yes that um we had anticipated reaching that limit in August um with the anticipation of the collection's ending however when we got the information from the state it um they continued that the um the collections until the end of December so it was a little bit farther than what we had anticipated okay any more questions so comment still was we still wanted we went early so that we would not have the Gap we would have the continuation that's why we went early yes and it it continued December stopped the old one January starting the new one with money the first money getting in February thank you Janice thank you ladies Madame chair that's all for the construction committee thank you Mr kantrail next is our finance committee Mrs

112Chambers okay 11.01 is the allocation for the 2020 eash funding and I think we just um saw most of that in the presentation but are there any questions or Janice would you like to go over that um I wasn't going to go over it in detail but yes you're correct it is um just the kind of the board agenda item where we are um allocating those additional funds that we received to the various projects and also did some um reallocation of funding and that is on the attachment y yes yes yes all of it were um part of the referendum okay any questions on board members about the allocations okay okay thank you Janice hearing no questions I'll move on to 11.02 which is purchase exception F this is um for virtucom it's a purchase

113request attached $4,240 superintendent is recommend that we approve this any questions all right 11.03 is for um Professional Services if you see there is an attachment for the Coca-Cola science um Center for $20,000 this is for our elementary math and science program for fiscal year 25 hearing no questions I'll move on to 11.04 these are budget adjustments and they are all attached um I did have a question about number two the $3.2 million out of the general fund um Janice can you go over that and just give us some detail on um the 3.2 million I know you said it's no it wasn't budgeted but explain that a little bit it is mostly the um money that I was moving around and uh for the uh sipen that we gave in December um and that

114was it was actually close to a $5 million um cost for us and it's just moving the funds around to accommodate um that with some other um cleanup that is in there as well okay so most of it is um the bonuses for the teachers yes okay it was actually all staff but yes teachers included okay sounds good all righty any other questions about the budget adjustments okay hearing none 11.02 are the purchase order increases and they are attached there are two of them any questions board members I have a question about um the $2 million one for exceptional students um if you look at the current contract can you explain that um Janis just a little bit the current contract is 1.2 million roughly but then you're moving two million can you explain as

115we have had vacancies in um the um the services that these companies provide for us in Staffing we have had to um and then the needs of the students we've had to increase those uh the services for that we are um purchasing from these different companies so are we um increasing the amount by the $1.2 million or by $2 million or are you just putting a cushion in there the total contract um is right now is the 1.2 we're adding $2 million on top of that to get us to the 3 million so we have one already this is an increase of two million to get us to three okay and the two million will it's not being spent yet you're not asking us to approve an expenditure no this is what we project through

116the end of June okay so we're just moving this $2 million in the category of exceptional students well we're asking for the price to be able to increase the POS for these individual companies um in order and we don't know because we'll be varying those we didn't know exactly how much we were going to be increasing each vendor so that's why it's coming as a group to allow us to um to use that $2 million as we need to across these companies but you'll bring it back to us individually no that this is this is what we're asking that um overall we would not increase these companies more than $2 million so we really don't know what you're spending with each vendor good afternoon Dr St Crystal poris executive director for programs for exceptional students

117um to answer your question what we did is we went through and looked at the number of hours that we had for each of our vendors and calculated when we calculated we were at about $1.5 million we broke it down um on for each vendor and if you would like for us to share that we can share that information with you um but we looked at it to just try to make sure that we weren't having to bring the information back to the board multiple times so we did add a cushion I think for us it would be better if we have a breakdown because I'm a little leery of just approving a $2 million spend and not knowing where it's going that's a lot to just blanketly say okay it's going between one of

118these people will receive part of this $2 million so if we could get a breakdown of how much because according to policy anything over 50 ,000 is supposed to be brought back to the board so if you pay a vendor more than 15,000 we're supposed to approve it so it would be great to have a breakdown of exactly how this $2 million will be spent yes and what you're really asking us to approve yes ma'am and I can provide that to you I don't know if you want me to share some information with you tonight regarding the conf well you can just email it um out or or one of you can just email it to Miss Jones and miss Jones will make sure that all of the board members receive it in time for

119us to to vote for for the record what we'll do is just add we'll have the breakout readjust the it the agenda items so be on the record okay that'll be fine and it'll be in time enough for us to review it right yes yes okay already okay yes yes and it is to make sure that we have the vendors paid through the end of June so we won't have to come back understandable yeah we just want to see which vendors are getting how much right sure she has that thank you so much I appreciate it thank you I just I have a question so these are vendors and and not um did we not have a contra a contract with these yes ma yes ma'am we do have contracts with all of the vendors

120that are um that are on there like Sant we have contracts with each one of those what we're asking to do is to be able to increase the purchase order amounts for those when we made the projections um last year we made we made our projections for this year off of what we had for last year and there's some um differing things like the Tim in which some of the people were employed the hourly rates they are varying uh factors that have increased the amount of u money that we're having to pay out we've had some vendors who've had Stark increases in their um hourly rates so we're having to to make adjustments for that as well wait they up the rate from the contract we contracted them with no from the previous year for

121FY 24 fiscal year 24 we had some start increases for that when we sat in the spring and looked at that information based on what we had we thought that we would be where we needed to be but now that we've had some additional um some additional vacancies that we're having to feel through contractors contractors us okay yeah okay well okay I got a couple questions one if they went up on I get it from one year to year at what point do we Reid it out if we gave them the contract based on a certain hourly rate and how much we were going to pay them and then and I get some of these there might not really be another option out there and that's a whole another issue but you know it concerns

122me that we're being asked to authorize some pretty big jumps in some categories because either it's one thing if there's more need it's another thing possibly the vendor that we have not rebid is asking us for more money per you know unit so your qu I'm sorry I didn't your question is when do we decide to rebid for those um we always are looking for vendors that going to be able to provide us with what we need unfortunately there's a lot of like for some of the things that we're need or positions that we need not a lot of vendors have that they don't have the people that we need but um as we move forward and go into the next year we'll start looking at some other places that may be able to provide

123more um competitive rates cuz like AC what is academic Staffing academic Staffing is a subsidiary of ESS um and so they um have worked with us to provide um School SL speech language Pathologists and they do a pretty good job of providing those speech language Pathologists in person for us I guess again I guess my concern was just making sure that if we contract with us I mean they bid it and then if they're going up on us and anyway just making sure we're asking if they ask more my other question was just like it says Gina B Cox 14,500 board approval was not required I get that that was because it was under 15,000 but I guess that's saying that she may now get above 15 and that's why she's on in this list

124yes ma'am I I just need some clarity because I'm processing very slowly these are vendors who are providing Staffing which is why you don't know because of the vacancies right okay I'm thinking it was some services for students I'm I was just getting ready to say as as Miss McCrae is saying if we've done a contract why is it changing so it's changing because this is a staffing vendor right and we did not we had no way of anticipating we were going to have these this vacancy correct well well but she also said that some of them their hourly charges have changed right because so there's two pieces right we need more but some of them are I I was thinking it was services for students I I was and I guess confusing to me

125thing here with the gina B Cox I think that one should have probably been out on its own instead of lped in there with these big time vendors just from a tracking mechanism I think I think too though that a lot of these questions can be answered if you would just when you provide the breakdown so that we all know um go ahead Miss Buckner uh yes uh except for this question which is uh an extension of lores so as we uh year to year we go to the next year and we see a a substantial hour hourly increase do we kind of reflect and say wow this is a big increase I do try to negotiate with them to make sure that our prices don't don't go up and I think I do a

126pretty good job with that but I think there was something that was um a mandate that came down that made the nursing because this is for nursing the nursing prices went up for hourly rates see that's this is what I'm trying to say the nursing in overall this is what I'm saying is there any reflection so in these increases uh for this year the nurses in general the prices was a lot okay all right so thanks a lot okay thank you so much we appreciate you um providing that clarification for us I think we feel better about it and we'll feel even better when you provide us with the update thank you yes ma'am thank you all right hearing no more questions I'll move on to 11.06 these are our normal financial statements that we

127receive each month and um you also have the uh Splash actual versus the forecast for 2024 and and they are all attached any questions board members the last thing from Finance is 11.07 these are our donations and they are attached and we want to take the opportunity to say thank you to everyone who thought it not robbery to make a donation to our students and to our schools and as uh Dr Lewis always says um schools can't do it alone right so we thank you for your contributions and um if there are no questions then I'll turn it back over to miss green thank you so much Miss Chambers um anything else other than we kind of ask for what we need for next Tuesday but anything other than what we've already requested Miss Buckner

128I know Dr Lewis is fixing to give some kind of review but I wanted to um ask a question not for now but I want something added to our agenda on what month is it February on the February work session AG agenda of discussion um prior to Dr Lewis's tenure um we used to rotate our banks every five years our banks every five years our banks our banks are our banks banking we should rotate it every five years okay so now we we don't we've kind of stopped and we only have one thing so I want to know um the advantage of that while we just locked in to One Bank year after year after year and if it's uh possible to resume our services for different banks uh every five years or if another

129bank can request uh serving the school district I want that discussion that discussion on Friday okay thank you y yep that's fine sure thank you so much M aware that I was not made aware of any of that so that's news to me yeah well I've been here 22 years and we that's we used to do that yeah well we just have discussion but uh we used to do it I I think what Miss Buckner is referring to is not all of the accounts they're used there have been some banking considerations for certain aspects um with school dist we used to have a Sun Trust five years then we used to have I don't know about a time period but we do she was she here we did we we would put it out for

130bid and whoever came back with the best um service and what for banking for banking services so like the cost you know there's a cost to um uh uh for processing the transactions and so we would put that out for bid and whoever would come back with that best cost versus and and service you know there would be an RFP so there was a service component to that as well as a cost component and um we would make that determination from there I remember the bidding I just didn't remember a time period was it I don't remember the time frame I I I wasn't here we've always had Sova since I've been here I thought it was I thought it was five five years or three years I just said five years I think electonic

131and all the stuff we do online now it might have not been as cumbersome to change Banks but it would be a major a lot EAS major ordeal for us to change I still would like to have that discussion but it seems like because of all the technology it may not be that difficult it just seems to me that because of us to you know people would just issue a check and then you went and cast your check somewhere now they direct deposited into your account so for them to change that that would for all of our employees that would be a lot more complicated than it used to be well it still seems to me that so so we would have one Bank forever it I mean we Chang all our services for different

132um vendors we we B them out so does that mean that for the rest of the whole school district we just will have sovas I mean I'm just saying One Bank you mean just one Bank yeah so if it's One Bank well then at this time can we at least be it out and maybe get another bank I'm I'm just saying I don't see I think that is why we B out stuff like bonds I think I don't I get that man said what he did but I and I've been out of the banking business for a while now but I I don't think they make that much money off of handling our checking account stuff versus or or charge us a whole lot different than what any other bank would do well they make

133a lot if you talking about $192 million but well that's what he said right but that but that's but that's that number off but that's a that's a wait a minute that's the record that that uh he just brought up here for our construction he just brought up $192 million probably more but he just brought um Ward I'm sorry instead of just he Ward just brought us a document explaining what all we do and that figure was on the document but I'm saying when we look at it we have to look at what expense and what it it charges us to have one Bank versus another that's not saying that the bank doesn't get a benefit from using us but I'm not sure that the expenses change I mean but again I we can look

134at it but I don't think the expenses change a lot for us as to which bank we have and I do think there is value in consistency I think there is value in the fact that it is very much a local bank that supports our school system a lot and that we need to be careful of how much we do based on you know just thinking we got to move things around except we don't have local banks anymore they've all gone big top but Naomi is this a local it seems like to me this discussion probably should be like I said we having it right now this as I said I think this discussion should be be on next month's uh work session right and then we can see where we are where we are

135all right thank you so very much Dr Lewis okay um thank you uh I think since the last time we met Carver High School has won a state championship in football so be recogniz them we recognize them in our upcoming meetings and then also uh this past Saturday we had the Academic Decathlon and I'm pleased to announce that Columbus High School plays first Kendrick high school plays second and Carver High School play three Place third congratulations to all their students and their sponsors I know they all work really hard to prepare for that event and I I particularly want to thank uh dtl for supporting that and coordinating it takes a lot of planning and and uh preparation for that so thanks to everyone for that as well that ends my report thank you for

136that thank you Dr Lewis thank you for the reminder and next week we elect our board leadership Tuesday Tuesday Tuesday night all right anything else all right we are journ see y'all Tuesday [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.