CorpusRecord 179576

Oconee County Board Of Education Public Hearing #3 • Feb. 3, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Oconee County Schools
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Oconee County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,283 words · about 24 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I call this HB 581 number three hearing to order Mr Adams purpose of the hearing uh good afternoon board members and Dr Branch uh before we get started want to let everybody know there's a signin sheet and we do have some handouts in the back of the room for those here in attendance I want to remind everybody the purpose of the hearing is to provide information on HB 581 to the board and the community and to listen to any thoughts from aone County residents what opting Out means local control customized for our community what opting in means State control a one-size fits-all on November 5th 2024 house resolution 1022 was on the Statewide ballot it read shall the constitution of Georgia be amended so as to authorize the general assembly to provide for Gen by

002General law for a Statewide homestead exemption that serves to limit the increases in the assessed value of homesteads by which any County Consolidated Government M municipality or local school system May opt out of upon completion of certain procedures the measure that PASS gives the state the authority to offer property tax relief through a Statewide homestead exemption but also allows local school districts to decide if they want to participate the law requires the intent to opt out be advertised in the newspaper of General circulation and show evidence of public hearings the board is required to hold three hearings for the purpose of listening to the public public on any thoughts they have on this matter the first hearing was on January 23rd at 6 p.m. the second hearing was January 28th at 6 p.m. and the

003third and final hearing is today February 3rd at 4m. what is HB 581 HB 581 is a floating homestead exemption that limits the annual increase in property tax assessments to the federal inflationary rate from the prior year the state will set that amount of Homestead Properties can increase at a yet to be determined inflationary rate some tenants of the law school districts have one opportunity to opt out of the legislation if they do not opt out the cap will begin in 2025 based on the 2024 values if they do opt out they must follow an opt out process projected impact aone County Schools projected the local Revenue it would have collected over over the last seven years would have decreased by $1 13.9 million as you can see in this chart we assume the CPI

004and if we use that for the inflationary rate the last three-year average is $2.7 million or an 8.1 million decrease in our funding the changes in HB 581 could significantly impact property taxes revenues for a cone County School System the change would impact flexibility to meet local needs and maintain competitive salary and benefits and as a reminder we are funded 54% by the state and 46% by local funds and property taxes that make up the 46% fund part of our district salaries as well as Transportation school supplies and curriculum HB 581 would limit the taxable values for Homestead Properties thereby reducing the amount Cony County Schools receives as shown in the previous chart with the inflationary rate cap by HB 581 aone County Schools may have to increase the millage rate to maintain the level

005of service we offer to okone County students the mill rate is the primary means available to school districts to raise funds to ensure they can maintain educational services and resources for their students school districts are limited in the number of Mills they can Levy each year for fiscal year 25 okone County School's Mill rate is 14.25 Ms the maximum millage rate for schools districts is 20 Ms and for the last 10 years aone County schools has lowered or maintained the millage rate aone County schools has gone from a 17.5 Ms in 2014 to the current 14.25 Ms a decrease of 3.25 Ms at the same time we County County schools has grown by two schools and about 1,450 students a current mail is approximately 3.5 million or the equivalent of 34 teachers also this chart

006obviously shows we have not raised the millage rate aone County schools has only one chance to opt out the process must be completed by March 1st 2025 therefore there is not another chance to opt out even if the legislation causes significant issues to aone County School funding a cash flow this is a one-time decision with the long-term Financial impact there is no Sunset to this legislation and OCS is funding Gap could continue to grow is it important to note that this decision to opt out will not affect any existing Homestead exemptions school districts are not authorized to assess an additional Penny sales tax okone County's Financial Obligations are continuing to increase annually ually as I mentioned in our last two meetings we've heard that our Healthcare premiums are going to go up for for classified

007staff uh that's going to be around 600,000 a year that'll average out to we also have just read that our TRS is going to go up that's estimated 400,000 so those two figures alone are unfunded State mandates that are coming for us about a million dollars opting out also allows the board to maintain local control to best meet the needs of aone County students the HB 581 presentation frequently Asked question document are posted in assembly with the corresponding meeting dates mentioned earlier the hearing dates and times have been posted on the school district website social media accounts and in general circulation newspapers and all advertisements have been published as required that concludes my explanation of the hearing thank you Mr Adams any comments or questions hey Mr ad I do have a couple of questions

008and just to to affirm um if the system were to opt out of this legislation it does not impact any of the homestead exemption changes that the local voters voted on in 2024 and subsequently passed that's correct okay and then I did see on slide seven um um how you were showing the the millage rate uh the um accumulation of funds over time for lack of a better term so the first five Mills of property taxes that are paid by our local taxpayers are exempt from the um inflationary cap and those first five Mills are then used um to reduce State allocated monies that come to okone County um because okone County does not receive any fair share allocation that's correct okay um but there are other systems that do receive fair share allocations that

009are funded by those in part by those first five Mills that is correct sir okay any other comments I have a clarifying question it may be also about slide seven when it comes to that graph where we saw over the past 10 years we went from 17.5 Ms down to 14.25 m that's a steady decrease which I think we could all agree is a great thing is it fair to say the tax revenue during that time steadily increased or stayed the same what do we see with that I'd have to go back and look at all the historic to go back and look at it but I know that the the digest has gone up okay so despite the fact that we lowered the mill it consistently went up because of values that had been

010a big help with that so with this issue whether we were to opt out or opt in as the voters have asked us to do our tax digest is still not limited from growing is that correct whether it's from new development that comes online commercial um property tax that comes in commercial development all of that is still fair game and also value that is um realized in a home sale we could still realize an increase in tax revenue because of that correct okay thank you thank you Mr Adams thank you public Communications Mr CIT Mr ROM excuse me we have eight citizens sign up to address the board before I invite them up I'll read this policies bcbi and BCB R1 state that only okone County residents or school system employees May address the board

011and that members of the public shall conduct themselves in a respectful manner that is not disruptive to the conduct of the board's business the board allows three minutes for those who sign up uh prior to the meeting please state your name address and topic the board requests that you are framed for making any disparaging remarks about school system Personnel generally there will be no response to comments or questions posed by citizens at the meeting all comments and questions will be taken under advisement by the board however any board member shall be free to respond and make public comments if he or she elects to do so to any citizen wishing to provide documents for board members please submit them to the the director of communications before the meeting or prior to addressing the board please

012remain at the podium during your public comment time our first citizen is Robert roric thank you Robert welcome thank you I go by Ed by the way Ed uh I'm Ed weor I live at 1460 Cooper genen Road Stadium up in dark corner I been a resident of okone County this time for almost 11 years however I've been closely associated with this County and many of his residents for more than 50 years I choose to live here and pay school taxes even though my wife and I have no children we do enjoy the activities associated with the excellent schools here and are happy to call this home my wife was raised here and graduated from okone County High School and says that she remembers when the County School's administrative staff consisted of the superintendent and

013his secretary relative to the issue under discussion it appears to me that the initial absurdity was when lawmakers put an issue to the voters and included an opportunity for as few as three people to overturn over overturn the voter's choice now you have been presented with the opportunity to go against the will of almost 65% of the voters in this County and I've only heard one of you indicate the willingness to side with the voters last year the okone County Commissioners held several Town Hall sessions where this bill was discussed explained and promoted I don't know about all voters but I voted with some level of confidence that I understood the issue and made an informed decision I admit that I was either not aware of the opt out provision or that I mistakenly assume

014that those who would eventually face that decision would do so with their constituents preference in mind what I do not understand is why if the okone County Board of Education members at the time were not in favor of the bill you did not do more to explain your position to the voters and or encourage opposition to the bill instead the perception is that your plan if the voters approved the bill was to exercise your opt out provision your major concerning factors appear to be that income will be significantly reduced I don't see that happening with the continuing growth in okone county and new families continuing to locate here add that to the commercial growth and the future looks very bright however in the unlike unlikely situation where revenues were to decline you would simply be

015put in the same situation many of us face every day how to do the same or more with less we can't budget based on our wants but try to get by with our most urgent needs as you should be aware there's also a movement in this country towards government efficiency I think we need to get ahead of the curve and start looking at how to be more efficient it appears to me that this approach would better prepare the board for future potential fluctuations and income I think the real problem here is a perception the bottom line is voters will perceive that you're going against their wishes I understand the school board doesn't hold the authority to implement a special option tax as the County Commission does but you do have the authority to raise the

016millage rate to a certain predetermined level I can't speak for everyone but I'm not impressed by the continuing claim to not raise the millage rate when the revenue from taxes continues to increase every year to answer Mr Hammond's request it has increased for the last seven years the information you provided also the last two years the percentage increase has been higher under the projected Revenue after the cap as compared the current Revenue also the total for the past seven years under the current Revenue the increase was 36.83 per under the projected Revenue under the cap 37.4% so I don't think reduced income is a concern thank you can can I ask a clarifying question I think maybe of uh Dr Branch or maybe Ryan as our legislative Le is on has there there been any

017discussion among the legislature about allowing the school districts to add a uh any kind of spast or anything like that because it seems like you know schools hands are tied a little more than counties when it comes to that ability to generate more revenue is that something that ever comes up no sir okay thank you next is Ian Taylor Mr Taylor welcome last time I promise Adam to go to answer your question uh 2018 went from 23.3 million in Revenue to 2024 was 36.9 million in Revenue so yes it has gone up um as I was saying last time um just move on here I'm talking about your uh frequency asked questions note here teacher salaries technology and infrastructure uh won't be won't be covered nothing is ever mentioned about potentially decreasing Administration costs that's

018a big one for me down here says opting out ensures the district can better manage its long-term financial needs no opting out simply just says that you won't limit your uh increases to the inflationary uh rates preserving local Authority I will submit to you that the voters are the local Authority and the shifts controll tax revenues to State guidelines and that's inaccurate there are already State guidelines in place maintaining the current tax system ensures a customized approach to revenue generation that aligns with District priorities again it's misleading you're just reducing the base potentially point four by retaining local control over property tax revenues District can continue to prioritize long-term success of its students and Community you still main control still maintain the control you just might have just a little bit less money to do

019it with potentially opting out empowers a school dist IC to retain local control you again you still have local control point five significant Revenue loss 2% Revenue loss is hardly uh significant it's 2% and again you can up the milage rate to get that limited flexibility I don't understand why you would have limited flexibility reductions in Staffing extracurricular activities and essential programs again no mention of potential Cuts in administration costs delayed infrastru structure improvements well that's normally funded with El lost and spast money so I don't think this registration affects it at all I've only got a minute but the point I've been trying to make these last few meetings is that it was clear from the that you intended to opt out from the very beginning and the comments that I heard and the

020numbers I've be giv were essentially a repeat of the Georgia School Board Association and the Georgia school superintendent Association talking points the financial information provided to you by the school system was I believe overly simplistic and very one-sided at no time have I heard anyone say this is the will of the voters and here is how we can accommodate this it was we simply went to we need to control the money while it is understandable that aone County Schools may be concerned about Revenue HP 581 does not eliminate property tax revenue growth it simply moderates it schools will still receive increased funding from new construction business properties and continued residential growth the exemption provides a more predictable and gradual increase in tax revenue rather than sudden surges that can burden homeowners the millage rate will

021more accurately reflect the taxation of the folks uh the reduction in the tax revenue was not a bug in the legislation it was a feature I've got some more but I think you I think I've made my point thank you all thank you next is Roy burn welcome I'm back again also Roy burn 27 44 wild Indi crossing state of Georgia uh good afternoon ladies and gentlemen of the board this is final meeting of uh opting in or opting out of this house bill 581 you know I've everybody I've heard speak here there's no one in favor of opt opting out and I think that you know The Young and the old voted for this bill because we all thought we was going to get tax relief and we need tax relief but you know

022my wife and I we were coming out Hog Mountain Road the other day from Butler Crossing to 441 and we saw a lot of grading going on and we wondering what in the world is this so we get a little further out and we see Paving going on and pavement already done and I get to checking on it and it's a multi-use trail now to me I know you don't have anything to do with that but our local government our County uh councilman not councilman but uh Commissioners to me that's a waste of money totally waste of money no telling how many millions of dollars they're spending on these trails that they're talking about building and that could help us a Rel us with tax uh taxes on on the schools I mean that money

023could go to the schools if you really need it and I I just I just don't agree with what they're doing and I'm going to be a uh against that I'm going to start going to the commissioner's meetings anyway and what my opinion on that but anyway uh and uh salaries I agree with everything that's been said here so far today but I see where you all have been giving 5% salaries salary increases you know we get us uh senior people we get 2 and a half% raise on Social Security I haven't seen a 5% increase in probably 40 years but I worked at a manufacturing facility in Athens for 38 years in 1991 we took a pay cut I mean a tremendous pay cut because they said they were going to close the business

024if we didn't and we did now I don't believe in pay cuts but I do believe in freezing salaries so I think if you're in need we can free some salaries here and none of us wants to deprive any kid of a good education but we do need to get back to Common Sense without our spending and all Departments of government in this County and in oh I'm out anyway and I want to add this I think it's time I'm speaking in behalf on behalf of the seniors I think it's time to give the seniors a relief exempt status on these school taxes like other counties has done in around the state thank you thank you next is Charles Hunt Mr Hunt welcome Charles Hunt 1080 Sam Cooper Road and again I'm also revisiting you

025but I'm just wanting to clarify I want you to opt in uh I think that okone County schools are uh stand out because of the families and the faculty that you've helped collect and uh the families uh that have been attracted to the school district I am able now with more confidence than last week to to say that the digest is 60% residential and 40% commercial and other real estate so I do think that all of the commercial growth is taking a little burden off our shoulders and this opt in would take a little bit more I think the increase uh by way of the inflation rate is more realistic than the fair market value that jumps up and down and sideways in fact I guess we're obligating ourselves to continue to pay 2% or

026inflationary growth even if if this home prices drop or we have another 2008 we're sort of implying that we're willing to do that uh steady growth rather than the jumping around I think it's good for the households that have the students in it and not just the seniors that you've seen before you and therefore I encourage you to consider to opt in and uh let this tax break go into effect and that's all the time I need [Applause] next is Bob Smith Smith welcome um first I want to Accolade without my time being used up um several years ago I was looking at the budget in city of Watkinsville and seven straight years of bad audits two two identical two identical material weaknesses and so so I'm going to look at the school board and

027see what's going on at the Schoolboard and that particular year I was looking seven straight years of the same exact things I said wow it it clean it up so Schoolboard I looked at Schoolboard online and y'all had something is sort of like that then I looked back the next year it gone y'all had cleaned up your art it so I applaud you for that now uh my time ooo I ate up 20 seconds of my time with that um so when I was in the legislature in 2006 I introduced two pieces of legislation one for for senior citizens they need some help one was if you're 65 years of age and older and you made less than $40,000 and you didn't pay any taxes you had to pay the bonds but you didn't pay

028any tax but if you made if you made over that amount now it's a second piece of legislation for both the school board and the county that you your property were freezing were frozen so if you had $150,000 house in 20 2006 and it goes to $500,000 a day you're still paying taxes on 150,000 but then comes along 10 pieces of legislation I've never understood why they stripped my two pieces of legislation that was saving senior citizens money for 10 pieces of legislation that the voters vote on I still to this day don't know what the 10 were and so I'm trying to Wade through what y'all are faced with I I don't envy you whatsoever but I'm trying to Wade through what's really happening here because I've always understood as my time in the

029legislature and as an adult in the real estate world for a long time it's that the county govern has to FAL say in anything because they are constitutional they're constitutional like city of Watkinsville is a is a is a licensed City you can take the license away but you can't take the county away and so my thought is is why doesn't the County if you decide to do whatever the county has to make that final determination if not then then I I've miss the boat there um but I'm I'm I'm concerned that that I walk in this building here and when I was a kid I'd go barefoot into the okone county courthouse and you go to the end of the hall across some U Mr Adams's Grandmama's probation office or we call the ordinary

030at the time and he go into the Schoolboard office it wasn't even bigger than say here to there and I'm just amazed at this this building and and how much money is coming into this this County and how we spend it and so forth but my concern you all is that when you have 10 pieces of legislation it confuses people I'm confused today hope you do the right thing and and follow the law thank you thank you next is Pam Hendricks Miss HRI welcome thank you Pam Hendrick I live at 1151 Thornwood Drive Watkinsville um you know I've been coming to these meetings for two or three years now and I've just been amazed at the big spending I see um you know you remember you give us a onepage budget and you know we

031took a lot of time and one big thing that came out was showing that on the budget you have 50,000 as the interest income and we pointed out that it was 2 million and that wasn't corrected you're not listening to us I feel like this legislation might been a response to the fact that um the people don't feel like their rep their school board representatives are listening and the state decided to step in and you know first of all this is very odd to me um you know we're having these hearings you've announced you're opting out but then we're having these three hearings I mean I'm I'm presuming that maybe you can change your mind we're having this last hearing at 4 pm um most people are out working trying to earn the money to

032pay the taxes that you're going to assess us with one thing is we've been living through these inflationary times and you know I just read Lee Becker's blog this morning the county is getting 20 million extra dollars because of this inflation the school system's getting the same and um then we've got the we've got this dilemma now that suddenly our school enrollment in okone is going down it's declining and you know I think it was covid I think parents woke up to what's being taught in the classrooms they're not real happy about that I think they found out there were other options because they had to exercise them during Co um I don't think we know the long-term trend of whether we're our our enrollment is going to keep coming up basically I'll tell you

033young people can't afford okone County they can't afford a house here um you know I'm working with two young men down at my farm in Morgan County and one bought a piece of property in Green County and one's looking at toer County they can't even afford Morgan County they certainly wouldn't think of moving here um a young person can't buy a half million dollar house as their first house and yet that's what that's all we've got in okone County so we may see our enrollment go down I mean it just may become a place that only the rich people can live and it's partly because I just keep saying y'all are not being good stewards with our tax dollars you are not the the salaries are ridiculously high we you know this building doubled from

034the initial estimate of what it was supposed to cost I just see enormous spending and one thing we know in America is spending more on Ed ation doesn't increase the results thank you thank you m next is Victoria Cruz Cruz welcome Victoria Cruz 1151 Lake W Brook Drive Athens okone County I I don't have a whole lot more to add to what has already been said said my the the speakers who went before me are certainly much more well-versed on the actual finances the budget and what it what it's going to mean to the citizens as a senior citizen my husband and I both on fixed incomes Social Security now and and what we've saved I I I just look at the school board as this bottomless pit the school system is a Bott bottomless

035pit you know you say oh we've kept the the millage rate down but as Mr H Hammond pointed out the revenues have gone up and you have this amazing control over how you can raise salaries for all of your employees whereas the citizens don't have that I I can't tell them to raise Social Security and my husband's no longer employed and you know know the taxes will keep going up the revenues you take in will go up but yet there is no accountability for how you're spending it I was going to make a comment about this building and the cost over runs it seems like the more money you take in the more money you will spend everyone is now having to tighten their belts there's a great degree of uncertainty that we're facing now

036after the president IAL election uh people might think that all the problems are going to be solved immediately no there is a lot that needs to happen at the federal government it's going to trickle down to the rest of us and I think the bottom line is everybody's going to have to tighten their belts it it is just a lot of uncertainty with with Federal revenues State revenues right now we have we have a surplus plus but we don't really have a whole lot of control how that's spent so I I I just think that you need to look at a bit bigger picture do more with less like most people have to and um just look at the Optics of this nobody sees this as a good thing it's almost like all of the

037school boards almost all of the school boards in the state decided immediately they we're going to opt out that to me is sounds like collusion and uh pre-planning you were you were planning on it all the time and and just lack of far foresight so uh those are my comments thank you next is Steven alshire are welcome I'm Steven alire the same address as the previous speaker I'd like to call this the school administrator and teacher Revenue protection bill as of this last border of Commissioners meeting we now have anticipated 16 school resource officers you might say well wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute we're on HB 581 well it's related in my head um this is an example of the elasticity of expenditures which occur and suddenly we we have yet

038another hole to fill in the budget and it was anticipated at the meeting that there would actually need to be 16 instead of 12 for the school because of vacation holiday and sick and it said well you know 16 M 1.6 million sounds like a good number but I'm sure I am confident based on previous experience with budgets that this will easily go to 2 million per year so that's an example of things that are yet to be encountered in terms of mission creep and expenditure creep now um I have a background as does Victoria Cruz and medical examiner works so we know something about violence and violence in the world when you have a school resource officer at every school they're going to become buddies and the teachers pet and every student is going

039to go to them and say okay Mr Obie you know how are you doing today I suggest half the number of school resource officers and keep them rotated so that a perpetrator wouldn't know where to go if there was that kind of for forethought in addition though most based on published psychological profiles and um post uh event reviews most people could have anticipated and reported the perpetrator of things like happened over in Barrow County a year ago I'm not trying to diminish the horror of that situation I'm just saying what is reality School school shootings are rare and therefore school events like in here will be rare so why are we suddenly having 16 more SRO on the school's dime but also on the school's elastic budget I suggest half the number at roughly 23ds

040of the cost costs are never linear and rotate the SRO locations constantly in order to enhance their effectiveness and I think that's it thank you [Applause] that concludes Public Communication thank you Mr cowick any final comments I have one Michael go ahead Miss Hendrick you had said something a second ago about we'd already decided to opt out I think um that was a language we had to use in order to meet the requirement um so there was no intent to opt out we're actively discussing it uh probably more so than we'll ever let you know um but but that was the actual legal ad that had to be run that the state required us to run so there was no opt out before and I just want to thank everybody for coming in here and

041speaking because believe it or not we do listen and um we'll we'll see how it goes soon but I do want to thank youall for coming in here and voicing your opinion we have no further business for this hearing meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.