CorpusRecord 179577

Oconee County Board Of Education Public Hearing #2 • Jan. 28, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Oconee County Schools
Date
2025-01-30
Location
Oconee County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,448 words · about 20 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001call this HP 581 hearing meeting number two to order Mr Adams purpose of the hearing good evening board members of Dr Branch before we get started there is a sign-in sheet and we do have some handouts available at checkin I want to remind everybody the purpose of the hearing is to provide information on HB 581 to the board and the community and to listen to any thoughts from aone County residents what opting Out means local control customized for our community what opting in means State Control one siiz fits all the law requires the intent to opt out be advertised in the newspaper of General circulation and show evidence of public hearings the board is required to hold three hearings for the purpose of listening to the public on any thoughts they may have on this

002matter the first hearing was held on on January 23rd at 6 p.m. the second hearing is tonight January 28th at 6 p.m. and the third hearing will be February 3rd at 4 p.m. HP 581 is a floating homestead exemption that limits the annual increase in property tax assessments to the federal inflationary rate from the prior year the state will set that amount that Homestead Properties can increase at a yet to be determined inflationary rate tenants of the law school districts have one opportunity to opt out of legislation if they do not opt out the cap will begin in 2025 based on 2024 values if they do opt out they must follow an intent to opt out process OCS projected that local Revenue it would have collected could have decreased by$ 13.9 million over the last

003seven years as you can see in this chart we assume the CPI and if we use that for the inflationary rate the last threeyear average is 2.7 million or an $8.1 million decrease in our funding the changes in HB 581 could significantly impact tax revenues for aone County Schools the change could impact flexibility to meet local needs and maintain competitive salary and benefits as a reminder we are funded 54% State and 40 6% local funds property taxes that make up that 46% fund part of our district salaries as well as Transportation school supplies and curriculum HB 581 will limit the taxable values for Homestead Properties thereby reducing the amount aone County Schools receive as shown in the previous chart with the inflationary rate Capp by hb5 81 OCS may have to increase the millage rate

004to maintain the level of service we offer to okone County students the mill rate is the primary means available to school district to raise funds to ensure they can maintain educational services and resources for their students school systems are limited in the number of Mills they can Levy for fiscal year 2025 okone County School's millage rate is 14.2 5 Ms the maximum millage rate for school districts is 20 Ms for the last 10 years aone County schools has lowered or maintained the millage rate o Cony County schools has gone from 17.5 Ms in 2014 to the current 14.25 Ms a decrease of 3.25 Mills at the same time aone County schools has grown by two schools and about, 1450 50 students a current M's value is approximately 3.5 million or the equivalent of 34 teachers

005also this chart obviously shows we have not raised the millit rate aone County schools has only one chance to opt out and the process must be completed by March 1st 2025 therefore there's not another chance to opt out even if the legislation causes significant issues to alone County School's funding and cash flows this is a one-time decision with long-term Financial impact there is no Sunset to this legislation and okone County Schools funding Gap could could excuse me could continue to grow it is important to note the decision topped out will not affect any existing Homestead exemptions for aony County school districts are not authorized to assess an additional Penny Sale tax unlike cities and counties and a reminder aone County Schools Financial Obligations are continuing to increase annually we have read just recently with the

006budget that came out from the governor there's a potential increase for health insurance for our classified Personnel of about roughly $125 a month which would equate to about $600,000 annually we've also with with the increase in our TR TRS rate we're potentially looking at another $415,000 increase those two together is about a million dollar in an unfunded mandates from the state opting out all allows the board to maintain local control over property tax policies and would have the ability to tailor tax rates to our specific Community needs and fiscal conditions to best meet the needs of aone County students the HB 581 presentation FAQ document are posted in assembly with corresponding meeting dates mentioned earlier the hearing dates and times have been posted to the social District website social media accounts and general circular n

007excuse me General circulation newspapers and all advertisements have been published as required that concludes the explanation of the hearing Peter so um you said that it won't affect any other exemptions that took effect this year such as the senior exemption that automatically freezes your home's assessed value once she turned 65 is that correct that's correct and there's an additional one at uh believe it's over age 70 so so really HP 581 has no effect on anybody that's 65 or older to the extent is already Frozen yes yeah unless we raise exactly there you go thank you yeah so I just want to restate so and I think it's 75 maybe is when that additional $10,000 reduction to the sess value kicks in um for those people we're still waiting on the Tax Commission or she's

008got a new brochure coming out she hasn't got the language from the state yet I just checked her website today so she hasn't put it up yet yeah it's uh there's a lot to to work through on that I don't envy don't envy that office um also just want to talk through the the tax values when it comes to our QBE formula yes sir so and I talked about this some at our last um hearing as well um just want to make sure that um again because this is a very complex issue and I'm I'm glad to know that the homestead exemptions that were passed by the county um residents you know the house bill 581 doesn't impact that so those uh over the age of 65 their home value was Frozen um they wouldn't

009see an increase in taxes unless there was mill rate increase um and looking back over the past number of years where there were Miller rate decreases even though there was a tax increase because the assess values increased those homeowners over the age of 65 would not see a tax increase in that scenario um so when I think about the QBE value it will the way that house bill 5881 is written um the first five Mills of every homeowner in the county um goes to help fund the QBE model um and that QBE model will look at a tax role based on the actual value of the property or of that that Homestead not the inflation managed value of that Homestead over time um so that means those first five Mills will become more valuable than

010any Mill after those first five Mills meaning that a proportionate amount of dollars would be kept by the state over time to fund other districts than staying in okone County Schools that's correct they're treated as a local option that's why it wasn't includ that's why it was excluded okay and also understand in in reading the bill and then also for lack of better term attachments to it um that the state did allow local communities to review all of this um to determine what's best for its Community um which is why we're allowed to have these hearings and allowed to go through this process to help determine what's you know to help make a decision on what's best that's correct thank you you're welcome Peter I had a couple of questions and I want to see

011some clarification on a couple of things you said you mentioned from 2018 to 2024 we could have lost about $14 million if this had been in effect but in looking at that is is that the most Fair assessment of that because that would be true if it was you know this is a static model meaning the inputs if if it was a static model that would work because the inputs wouldn't change but the factors for us are changing for example our tax digest continues to grow is that is that correct correct this would not impact commercial growth or you know we have a lot of commercial infrastructure at EPS bridge that would not be impacted by the homestead exemption is that correct if you opt out or opt in if we stay if you stay

012in my understanding of the of the bill is that you shift the burden of responsibility you'll shift from homeowners to to businesses which would be beneficial to homeowners and taxpayers from that perspective and as far as resales for homes if someone were to you know if Michael bought his house for a million dollars because we know that was the case and he sold it to me for2 millionar we're still going to realize the gain from that increase in value at the the new value so once you once you sell your home the value starts at the the new sales price and if a home were to come online like Westland or Parkside when those homes are built we're not limited by that growth is that right that would also go into the tax digest it

013be included in tax digest okay so what I'm hearing is we're not necessarily limited as far as our tax digest growing if we opt into the homestead exemption tax our tax digest could continue to grow is that correct that is correct okay and as far as the local control piece of this goes we maintain the freedom to adjust the millage rate based on budgetary needs up to 20 Ms is that correct that's correct so we keep that control locally yes sir so when we talk about losing local control the biggest issue there would be you don't have an opportunity to add a penny sales tax so the only option you would have if you needed to raise funds would be to increase that millage rate but we can't we can't Levy Penny tax now beyond

014the East loss right the E loss okay um I think that answers the questions I have for now I appreciate that I want to add one thing on that so in that scenario if we did have to raise the millage rate those people over the age of 65 would see a tax increase um through that scenario where otherwise they would not if we were obligated to raise millage rates um across the board so that would be a I think an impact that would an impact that would come across our our taxpayers and our home owners any other questions thank you Mr thank you public Communications Mr cait we have anybody signed up to speak Mr Ransom we have four citizens signed up this evening uh before I invite them up I'll read this policies BC

015CBI and BCB R1 state that only okone County residents or school system employees May address the board and that members of the public shall conduct themselves in a respectful manner that is not disrupted to the conduct of the board's business the board allows three minutes for those who sign up prior to the meeting please state your name address and topic the board requests that you refrain from making any disparaging remarks about school system Personnel generally there will be no response to comments or questions posed by citizens at the meeting all comments and questions will be taken under advisement by the board however any board member shall be free to respond and make public comments if he or she elects to do so to any citizen wishing to provide documents for board members please submit them

016to the director of communications before the meeting or prior to addressing the board please remain at the podium during your public comment time our first citizen this evening is Ian Taylor Mr Taylor welcome thank you good to see you all again um I was going to since I was here last week at the last meeting I've had a chance to look at the documentation that was provided uh by Peter and I I just want to comment on on some of that um Adam I I appreciate your comments I think you were you were spot on on a bunch of them um Ryan just uh the QBE formula is complex and there's no doubt about it however it's important to know that that first five Mills doesn't leave aone County it just reduces the amount of

017money that the state provides and make sure that we're Equitable across you know all all counties so you know it's not like we're giving away that five Ms to go back to uh use the documentation that you provided I think it was page five and page nine of the uh of the I'm going to use your numbers so yeah the millage rate if you go back 10 years um the first seven years of that the millage rate stayed essentially constant at about 17 between 16.5 and 17 Ms which is fine it's only in the last 3 years that that millage rate has continued to drop what's left out conveniently out of that is during that time the taxes have gone up significantly um if we take from this from 2018 your tax uh that you

018were getting from the millage rate was 23.3 Million to this year 36 .9 million which is a 58% increase in taxes so you know the millage rate it's to me it's a political expediency right it Mill rates mean nothing to me it's the amount of money that I got to go and ink the check with at the at the at the courthouse it's important I me even in the last three years where we've seen that significant drop in the millage rate even then the uh the taxes have gone up from 28.6 million to 36.9 million so you know it's one thing saying that you know we can put out the the the the press release it's the lowest Mill rate this Century well whoopy do but it's also the highest amount of tax that we've

019ever taken from this from the citizens of this County at the same time only got a minute left here but just going back to your question and answer thing um the unpredict Adam you spoke to this bunch of the unpredictable Revenue loss you don't know what your tax digest is going to be one year to the next anyway so it is somewhat unpredictable there non the the the the concept that you don't receive any local fair share well that's because we're more affluent than most counties so we never have received the local fair share this bill doesn't change any of that reducing the the revenue by 2.7 million over the last on average over the last C year that's less than 2% of your budget assuming that you don't change your millage rate to go

020back to you this is a very you know um um fluid needs to be a fluid model so you know you're saying a 2% decrease is going to cause doom and destruction in the school system I don't I don't I don't buy it um opting out ensures that the district can better manage long-term Financial Health no it just simply states that that you can't raise the the property tax values more than the rate of inflation I'm out of time here I guess we'll speak next time but um yeah you got plenty of local control okay there's no there's no there's no local control that you're losing it just you might be docking your allowance a little thank you thank you Mr Taylor the next citizen is Charles Hunt welcome Mr Charles I I go by

021Chuck hunt I'm from uh 1080 Sam Cooper Road and I've been in the county for uh since 1991 I came here and the job that I S was a teaching position so I got certified as a Georgia science teacher and math teacher with gifted at re uh specialization and I've taught in classrooms from fourth grade to 12th grade o over a period of 12 Years that I had to homeschool my own daughter because of learning difficulties that I couldn't uh find a a solution for I returned to the classroom didn't have the energy to continue to help with K12 programs so I uh subbed for a while in our Cony County schools and later on I decided to be a bus driver and did that for 11 years I'm asking you to opt out don't

022uh do not opt out excuse me uh a lot of confusion about the Homestead uh exemptions I understand because they were all on the ballot this year and it gets confusing but this is about owner occupied homes not commercial property not all the other things we've added to the digest uh while we've seen uh the audience of gray hairs complaining about it it is owner occupied homes with your students in them that will be affected by this stabilization of the uh uh tax uh intake and it's you guys trying to say that you know how to spend those few dollars that the homeowners will save for those kids better than their parents do and that's a bad message I would encourage you not to go there um you're electing uh to cause a possible strain

023on the parents as the inflation uh rates affect their house and cause buz is issues in their own home just for the comfort of creating your budget which is not a good message for a K12 program so uh over the last few years we've seen quite a lot of uh commercial growth and that was on purpose because we were promised would take these businesses in and when I got here 30 years ago it was pretty much a homeowners uh that you guys had to rely upon for your taxes we have plenty of commercial uh property coming online now and more in the planning we have 3,000 on home sites that haven't had a house house built on them yet and that's not talking about Parkside and others that are on a more extended hold I

024know these sort of things because I'm on the board of uh Planning Commission and I've been there since 2009 and I'm not getting in the way of commercial growth because the homeowners don't need to be the only taxpayers and this is one opportunity that you guys have to show that the homeowners are important whether we're 65 or older or whether we had a young family in there and we're trying to do the best for the kids just like you guys do on a daily basis thank you thank you H Mr the next citizen is Victoria Cruz Cruz welcome hi good good evening board um Victoria Cruz 1151 Lake W Brook Drive Athens okone County uh I pretty much agree with uh the comments that were made by the previous citizens I did not come to

025the previous meeting but I had Mr hammock came and spoke at the GOP last night and so I had an opportunity to hear what was going on I have to admit this this house bill was it the the thing on the on the ballot was very confusing a lot of people didn't understand it I I looked at it I personally did not vote for this because I am over 65 and I will benefit from the home homestead exemption the tax the the tax Bas freeze uh but I I look at the I'm pretty sure most of the citizens didn't know what they were voting for but they did vote for you to opt out I mean to opt in they didn't they did not vote for you to opt out they probably didn't even realize

026that you could opt out they wanted to see some sort of control on their home taxes and I don't I I don't blame them and to say here that it's not going to affect 65 we're not that selfish that we're only concerned about ourselves we are concerned about the younger families the families who want to move in here they're going to have to pay more for the houses the ones who move in here houses are not going to get less expensive very fast certainly not as fast as they got very expensive your tax base grew tremendously over the last few years you benefited from the inflation we've had the last four years well that that's hopefully going to end but it's going to end at the hopefully coming from the federal level but they're going

027to cut costs too they are overspending they have been just using up taxpayer money as fast as they can and that's what I see happening here at the school board uh just the cost overruns you had on this building people never never imagined that this building would be as expensive and I believe you're still Furnishing it so the costs are not stopping the problem is you're going to opt out of saving people money you're going to try to keep your revenues as high as possible and you're not going to give the citizens any input on how you spend that money you know I I haven't seen it I haven't seen where citizens have an input on how you spend the money so I just think this was kind of a bait switch to the voters

028and um I'm I'm sorry that more of them aren't here to speak out against it but we do need to tighten our belts all the way around from the federal down and um so you're unsure of what your Revenue was going to be so are a lot of people so are a lot of people so just take that into consideration and I appreciate your remarks Mr Hammond very much thank you thank Mr bru the next citizen is Roy burn good evening ladies and gentlemen my name is Roy burn my address is 2744 wild Indo Crossing and I live in okone county and uh I want to start tonight with uh a hypothetically speech let's say the superintendent of the school system is an elected officer and John Doe is the president superintendent and now we

029have an election coming up and Jason branch is running for the office along with John Doe the election is held and Jason Branch wins the election by receiving 64% of the vote but the school board has the option of whether to accept the election results or to keep John Doe as superintendent and they decided to keep John Doe is this the will of the people no I thought we lived in a democracy where 51% is the majority the citizens of this county has spoken with a 64% majority on House Bill 581 and you should accept the will of the people one of the citizens that was here last week and spoke was told by a county official that the county that o con County was a senior retirement County if that's so why are we

030H bu having to build more schools and employ more teachers bus drivers Etc there are approximately 100 65 homes in our neighborhood where we live and I can count on one hand the seniors in our neighborhood there are from one to six kids in every home excluding the senior retirees now to speak on behalf of seniors I think it's time for seniors to be exempt from school taxes I have been paying school taxes for 57 years my wife and I we don't even have a kid in school we don't have a grandkid in school a great great grandkids in in any school system I have checked on counties where seniors are exempt from these taxes and we have many in in the state close to us are guette fton Hall fory Henry and right next

031door to us is Walton County they don't pay any school taxes they exempt completely starting and they start at 65 years old and even some are at 70 years old when they are when they uh are not required to pay taxes most of we seniors are on fixed income we get a little 2.59% increase in cost of living for our social security that has not come close to the expenses that we have like Medicare insurance deductibles uh increases in supplemental insurance or drug cost increases let alone the cost cost of groceries and Etc am I through kind to continue few more seconds go ahead you know I haven't seen in any form of government where there's not waste and maybe I'll get into that at the next meeting I REM I recommend you as the

032board and superintendent maybe you need to tighten the purse strings and follow the voter's wishes thank you thank you for your time and I look forward to seeing you next week and speaking thank thank you m burn Mr C do we have any more speakers that concludes Public Communication before we end Public Communication I just want to say something to the speakers thank you for coming here for your thoughtful comments and for really sharing your feedback I know this is a very complex issue and there's a lot of passion around it so thank you for that and a big thank you to Peter as well for breaking down a complex issue for us so that we can make a decision about this because at the end of the day as a board member we have

033to make a decision that is best for students in the schools and best for everybody associated with our school community and to me a big part of that is a financial well-being of a household I think that's a big part of this and the Cornerstone of my decision when it comes to voting for this will be the vote as you all said we can't deny the fact that 64% of the public voted to be in this homestead exemption tax and I think that's something that I'm going to keep in mind as we treat this hearing process with an open mind so thank you all for being here comments we have no further business we're adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.