001good evening I would like to call the school board meeting for Tuesday February 18th for the de Mo public schools to order it's really good to see all of you tonight it's so cold out uh Miss Rios could you take the role yes Miss Alonso Miss compos Mr dicks here miss Knox miss martron here Dr Mayberry ma here miss Norris here we have quum is Miss Lonzo on line um she has opted out she's not feeling well so uh we have Quorum uh the first item of business business is approval of the agenda may have a motion and a second to approve the agenda Marano so moved dick second we have a motion by Miss martarano and a second by Mr dicks is there any discussion or does anyone have any questions uh I just
002want to make a kind of a friendly Amendment or note we are going to pass policy 218 which is within the consent agenda but I've asked Dr Roberts to provide an update at the next board meeting if that works for you Dr yes thats so um just so people are aware it's the Sak it's the board policy on Sak uh okay any other discussion questions board members please cast your votes the agenda is approved uh 6 to zero next on the agenda is the public forum do we have any readers of the public forum tonight or is that good evening we provide speakers at The Forum and opportunity to address the board for up to three minutes regarding items that are not on the board agenda and up to five minutes for an agenda item
003if anyone wishes to speak during any portion of the business meeting please email rosa. Ros dmschools.org the same speaking protocols apply to all individuals who wish to address the board speakers will be called on individually and we will ask ask that you state your name and address prior to providing comments students and minors do not have to provide their addresses guests of the board are encouraged to speak to matters relating to programs services and operations of De Moine Public Schools please remember that Iowa law prohibits us from discussing specific employees or their job performance we ask all speakers to avoid references to personalities or character attacks as those types of comments do not contribute to the purpose for which this public for exists we you the use of inappropriate language will not be tolerated and
004individuals choosing to do so will be GED out of order and asked to excuse themselves from the premises or escorted out by District security as a reminder to the board and public the board will not engage in discussion with public forum speakers as it is Our obligation to discuss only matters that are posted in the public agenda for the sake of transparency and opportunity afforded to all Community stakeholders matters requiring attention will receive appropriate staff Andor board followup at a time after the meeting thank you all for your participation we appreciate your feedback and input M Rios do we have any speakers yes we do first up I'll call RJ Miller Next speaker is Lyle Crome good evening Lyle cron 3 2006 east Cutler in De Moine uh good evening board of directors and superintendent
005Dr Roberts my name is Lyle cron I also have Sharon Beller vice president in the back I'm honored to serve as the at large representative for asme local 2048 and also a school bus driver here in the district asme local 248 represents those in transportation Food Service custodial security and Logistics I'm reaching out to formally introduce myself and express my commitment to fostering a stronger and more collaborative relationship between the board superintendent and our Union I want to strongly emphasize that our Union is not the problem however we are a vital part of the solution we are dedicated professionals who care deeply about the success of this organization and student outcomes we want to be active participants and sharing its future however to do that effectively we need more engagement open dialogue transparency and a
006seat at the table when discussions or decisions that impact our respective departments are being made I firmly believe that by working together we can address challenges more effectively and create an environment that benefits students employees and the organization as a whole I would welcome the opportunity to discuss how we can increase collaboration and ensure that our voices of our members are heard and valued with the outrageous attacks on public education and unions it is time to join forces and move in a positive direction I appreciate your time this evening and we are hopeful for your consideration and look forward to working with you in the future nice to meet you thank you thank you those are all the speakers I have signed up the next item on our agenda is our district recognitions superintendent Roberts
007would you please introduce those recognitions certainly Madam chair good evening everyone as we continue to bring forth recognitions at every school board meeting honoring and recognizing the outstanding accomplishments and actions happening in and out of classrooms by students and adults who serve them we also find time and take the opportunity to recognize some of our what I like to describe as stalwart Community Partners who are champions of public education and without them we will not be able to achieve an accomplish the things that we do this evening I am pleased to share with you that we have had an ongoing partnership with our uh po County Board of Supervisors and prayer Meadows each year I want to I come to the board with an expression of gratitude and this year is no different I want
008to express sincere gratitude to Julie St and our pedal team and Angela Connelly and our poke count Board of Supervisors for your continued generosity and commitment to not only children in the central Iowa region but your commitment and support to public education your generosity sometimes is measured not only in terms of your finances but your commitment to time and thought leadership and we thank you for that this year your financial contribution of more than 569 th000 will help us to enhance educational opportunities support our Educators invest in the future of our schools and make a meaningful difference in the lives of 3,826 brilliant Scholars who knock on our doors every day depending not only on us but in generous committed and dedicated Partners like you when I ask that you come forward and be [Applause]
009recognized thank you uh Bor and uh Dr Roberts this is one of my favorite things to do obviously as I serve on the board our partnership with Prairie Meadows has been for decades and we are pleased to be able to provide this money for de Public Schools more than ever uh with everything going on you need it we're happy to do it and all the support that we can give you as you say not only financially but anything that we can do to help de Point Public Schools we are here for you no matter what and as you you move forward in your strategy and your reimagined Mo we're happy that to move forward to help your students and when you say reimagine the world is your oyster so I I'm so excited for what
010can happen for our Deo public school so thank you thank you um thank you for um recognizing us tonight I'd like to first of all I'd like to um recognize Brian oroko he will be our president and CE o starting January 1st of 2026 so um on behalf of PR Meadows and um in Poke County we're happy to present that this year we're giving back to poke County students $1.3 million and since we've started this partnership with Poke County we've given back more than $20 million to poke County um students so we can't think of a better investment is investing in the future and investing in our kids so thank you for recogniz us recognizing us tonight thank you thank you a cap a moment Manda where sure maybe she want where do you want
011us to go back inle what do you think you tell us okay you're the pro how about we do um in the front here sure is right yep um begin with the logo the for those of you watching this process um one of the things that was really interesting that I shared was and can get in um to see these kids uh and feel that c medow Co county is investing in them when they walk on new turf or they have new uniforms it's a really big deal for our young people and so um we're really lucky that we have this partnership week I I really appreciate it I need so much to thank everybody ready two thank work with you guys yes than thank you thank you oh you're so welcome do we have
012any other recognitions um yeah we're going to do that every week right very hopeful thank you um additionally this evening I would like to take the opportunity to do somewhat of a general recognition uh last week many would describe as uh a hectic but celebratory week in the mo public schools with a series of monumental events um the state of the schools event uh which was kicked off by our uh Team frostbite students from um North High School followed by our board share the feedack back we've gotten thus far has been nothing short of exemplary and outstanding um but behind the scenes they are groups of incredible individuals who are doing good work and so I want to just say thank you and recognize um the members who are part of our uh superintendence uh
013committee the remag education committee both our parents um students staff certainly our leaders who are part of that committee also want to recognize individuals who are part of our uh Communications team Phil Rider and his team for doing an outstanding job um for having not only our av and S system up but just just the presence and the atmosphere um certainly outstanding though last but not least our leadership and faculty and staff and students at North High School thank you for being such gracious host um go polar bears uh we looking forward to building in this bigger and better next year and um finally as we think about recognition some last week two days later we had the de Mo uh Public Schools foundations event and I know that that would likely come up later
014on today in recognitions but I have to say thank you all to the foundations for and for the the foundations Gala outstanding event and we're looking forward to continuing building on both of those events in future years Madam chair that concludes my recognitions this evening great thank you we are now going to move to the consent agenda as a reminder to the board in public the board will not engage in discussion or deliberation with a speaker regarding comments made to agenda items discussion and deliberation will remain among board members at the board table with speaker comments informing the board's discussion deliberation and determinations as deemed necessary Miss Rios do we have any speakers no speakers Miss Marano I believe you have the consent motion I move that the board approve the consent items in accordance
015with the recommend recommended action for each item on the consent agenda including bills previously authorized certified and approved for payment by the board secretary in the amount of 5,262 22444 and peard transactions in the amount of $ 366,924 79 is there a second dick second we have a motion by Miss Marano and a second by Mr dicks is there any discussion or does anyone have any questions board members please cast your vote the vote is approved 620 we will now move on to other business we have one item E1 Personnel recommendation receive and file action Dr Roberts would you like to introduce the matter certainly Madam chair I recommend that the board receive the file and approve the termination of the contracts for reasons stated forth in the superintendent's notice may I have a motion
016and a second to approve this item Marano so moved Campo second we have a motion by Miss Marano and is second by Miss Campos is there any discussion or does anyone have questions board members please cast your vote the vote is approved 6 to zero next we move to items of privilege this is a quick one I love it uh who would like to go first I can go first I want to oh thank you all right I want to give a special acknowledgement and uh appreciation for the schools that I've had the pleasure of visiting in these first few weeks in February um South Union weeks middle school and then Morris Elementary and I see principal Amos in the audience so shout out to you um there are some really exciting things happening in
017our schools so I would certainly encourage our board and our community and our families to get back into the schools I mean it it's fun that we have the big events that go on on the weekends and things as well but uh the teachers the Frontline the building leaders they are really doing some impressive things to make sure that all students feel included and that all students feel like they belong during these critical times so I wanted to give a special shout out to those three schools being led by principal Burke principal Amos and principal Dr Johnson so thank you thanks well I've just got to get in there and talk about the wonderful hoot hoot nny of the gala uh what a great event I mean you walk in and you're applauded and cheered
018by cheerleaders um Abe Lincoln you had uh wonderful music uh it was just all around such great um dmps pride and it was wonderful to see alumni coming and to listen to the beautiful gospel music I just I can't say enough about how wonderful the event was I'm going to let Miss Knox actually talk to you about some of the really important outcomes that came out of it but um I just I want to say thank you to kayy thank you to Jenna uh I know there's a huge team behind you but you have really uh embraced this and seen this vision and it's keeping it's growing and growing and I just want to say thank you so much for your leadership uh and all of your hard work we really appreciate it we appreciate
019you do you want to tell us do you want to give a little drum roll um yes thank you to everyone who attended the de Moy Public School school's Foundation dinner on Thursday uh the second annual event and uh it's sort of like I guess having your second child you're like I don't know if it's going to be as good as the first one and then it is it's even better you know so um it was awesome we raised over 147,000 is that right Kaye um the generosity in the room was just overwhelming and the energy and um Dr Roberts thank you for just your comments of um inspir I received so many kind notes from everyone who was there who just left feeling energized and believing and and motivated and inspired and so we're
020fortunate to have such a generous and engaged Community um and looking forward to the third annual event next year of looking at Kaylee uh I just want to say thank you so much to Kaylee Becker uh for her vision and tenacity and hard work and um we are so fortunate to have you on this team and thank you to the foundation board um and again I said at the event we had 100% board attendance and I really think that I choked up actually speaking about this because looking around the room at all of you which you know I I feel honored to serve with you all but I just think that's a testament to our community about how much the school board uh is in it for the right reasons and will show up um
021for all of the things including the foundation so thank you all for being there for for this event meant a lot other items of privilege unfortunate unfortunately we had to postpone the clap meeting on Saturday due to the weather that uh never came but um please stay tuned for a reschedule date for our legislative action team meeting where we will be focusing on informing our community as well as legislators about our preschool um initiatives at the state house and in hopes that our legislators vote to properly fund uh preschool education and public education uh so stay tuned for that um there's also another event this week if you would like to support our Public Schools the maroon and gold Gala is Thursday evening and welcome every every Community member to attend and um support our
022our Lincoln High School and pattern this is personal privilege and I promise I'm really going to try not to do this very personal stuff uh very often but I can't hold back tonight just because of the night it falls on I became a dad 16 years ago today uh so I have two drivers you've been warned public there are two new drivers on the road um but I'm incredibly proud of my boys and uh just they get to they get to have a happy birthday from the school board tonight so happy birthday boys where do do attend they attend school Patrick yeah they are sophomores at Roosevelt High School oh thank you and here at central campus and Central Academy okay all right so can't be late to school tomorrow morning they're already gonna be
023late to school tomorrow uh I'll go last before Dr Roberts but I don't know if you're going to mention this you probably will because it seems like every time I mention something Dr Roberts mentions it in his um little thing but I'm super excited and so thankful for the district for expanding more preschool Transportation um that is something big for our students and our families that uh have working parents and want to get their kids off to preschool and I've send many to preschool and that's something that's really good for our community so I just want to thank the district and appreciate that Dr Roberts up to you thank you madam chair um I certainly uh in my brief remarks this evening it's one that again is just grunged in so much gratitude for the
024work that we embarked upon this year a journey that every single person on each of our leadership teams understand will take an incredible amount of effort um some of which has been unprecedented but what is sident and encouraging is that everyone continues to raise both hands and say yes we're in and so we're excited about that and even as I think about um our legislative priority while we are going to continue to partner um with the governor and the Department of Education to make this compelling case that if we are going to achieve strong outcomes for all of our students not only in the mo Public Schools but across the state um if we're going to get back to the place of preeminence that Iowa K12 public education once had when we were known as
025the place to come to see where good quality education was then we will have to certainly double down on making the right strategic moves and taking the right strategic actions to achieve not only our goals but the governor and Department of education's goals of improving literacy so we are strongly aligned with that being a desired outcome I think where we are going to have to find place to increase our alignment is in how to get there and there's no doubt in our minds based on the research that we've looked at and the current credible and reliable data that says students who are given opportunities to attend preschool are more than 10 times likely to outperform those who did not and so as our legislators in both sides of the aisle are contemplating reviewing and looking
026at a current bill around preschool um we want to continue to encourage them um to come back to the mo Public Schools who is in partnership with many other districts across the state and even some private and parochial schools that says that investing in preschool is going to be the most worthwhile educational investment we can make as a state and so we continue to engage in those conversations with our parts in the hill um with uh Governor Reynolds and certainly with director snow because I know that they are truly invested in increasing and advancing literacy but I want to offer them that we're not going to be able to do that if we do not invest in School Madam chair that concludes my comments this evening well said Dr Roberts uh thank all of you
027for coming tonight and being a part of this board meeting uh we are going to adjourn at 5 who wants to help me out 54 and uh board members we are not going to take a break we are going to move straight into our work session to discuss board governance and it will be time limited so it will be 1 hour and no more so with that uh let's take a moment to switch out I think Rosie's got some things to to share with us that we'll discuss [Music] thanks hi are we in a break or we're not no is that okay I just want to power through so board members we had the conversation uh was it two weeks ago now about board governance and we just got a sense of where where everybody
028was as it relates to um the current governance uh model where we were struggling a little bit um things that we enjoyed uh we really liked about our governance model things we felt needed to be improved and uh and so I um believe that I task board leadership to put together a set of next steps um this is a recommendation um and I I think it's really important just to have a starting point to work from and then discuss how people feel about it so um as as I started to think about what our objective was both for this meeting and also for how we move forward as a board with some clear goal on where we're going um I think our goal today is to make sure we have consensus on a structured strategic
029approach to board governance in 2025 uh I'm very intentionally saying 2025 because there are elections at the end of 2025 and so with that could be new board colleagues um or it could be the same lot uh but that's always an inflection point to reflect on board governance so um everybody should have this this one-page handout um that starts with objective action plan and timeline and so as I thought about how we might use our time today um what we could do is review the actual plan and timeline that I've laid out um there are two small breakout groups there's actually three questions that I thought we could noodle on in small groups to discuss um our thoughts whether it relates to the monitoring process uh it's how board gave feedback on the governance manual
030and uh topics that weren't in the governance manual that we might want to move forward so the thinking would be that um today we could accomplish uh as much as we can and I think we could probably even do it in 45 minutes um in March at the next agenda that we approve the Council of great City Schools membership contract I think we've heard from staff they really value it uh and I think as Skyler and I were talking there's probably more ways that the full board can harness and access the learnings from this network of District that maybe we haven't um necessarily tapped into and then Kim is our representative and so asking Kim to just provide more she's been great about you know plug-in conferences but if there's emails or action alerts or
031things that you're getting sharing it so we can learn more about um the benefits of being a member uh to Council of great City Schools not just for staff but also for the board um then the thought process would be in March and April what what I think we all walked away from was we need to talk about our monitoring process it's just not feeling we're not there yet um and then the second thing was our governance manual is out of date right so we have a document that actually is not um aligned with current practice and so in thinking about this I thought March and April could be used to get us to a monitoring process that we think works for both the U board and the superintendent along with um along with Josie
032and the team uh and then our goal would be to execute an updated monitoring process at the April 15th board meeting because we do have um I think uh some items for monitoring at the same time March and April we could review the board governance manual and we could uh revise that no later than May 1 um I think you know I'll share with you Kim did a great job of kind of showing like where are items of consensus where are items that we need to dig into um and so we a strategy to be strategic in in looking at the board governance manual um at the same time you know thinking ahead to to the Future um you know we have goals in guardrails uh I think we're all consistently wanting to keep those
033I think there's been some discussion about whether or not we need to add guard rails um and I also think an important conversation will be in May and June with Dr Roberts on the Strategic plan you know he's made a commitment to monitor ing it on a regular basis uh and so how does that factor into the whole monitoring conversation and what does that look like so I think by by then um Dr Roberts you'll have a better sense of the cascading metrics and things like that so we can I think our goal is we've got to make sure that we're all super clear with interims no later than June 30th so there's a clear plan of action um so I I kind of push those conversations for for May and June uh and then
034you know thinking about where we are with regards to how many things we're looking to accomplish um what I thought was in November um that might be the time for us to discuss and look around and see if we want to move forward with uh Council of great City Schools board coaching um or if there's a a different type of coaching we might want to seek out but as I thought about all of the things that we have coming up between now and uh November it feels very hard for us to feel like we can dedicate a lot of time to um potentially a new coach and a new round of of coaching um which is why I I put that in November this is a recommendation so I I want to this is a
035starting point do people have thoughts on the timeline or questions no I feel the timeline's good and strong and it will help us for what we want to accomplish this year thank you and I will point out we have uh an April a Sunday April insert the date held as a board um so that's a that'll be a full day of work that we can move I think the the two buckets forward the monitoring process and the governance manual some work can be done outside of it and then some work could be done during that day uh to to to push that forward other questions or thoughts at this point um I appreciate you putting this together and I think it's a a good jumping off point and identifies a lot of the areas that
036we do need to focus on um and areas that have been outstanding for quite some time um one item that Jenna and I have been working on is um scheduling a meeting with Josie to discuss monitoring processes and we have that scheduled for this Friday so um wanted to add that onto the board's radar um or just a question a clarifying question are you reflecting the input and feedback of the board or are you coming to the board with recommendations and suggestions um this was something that you tasked Jenna and I with doing um and some we've scheduled some times and they've gotten pushed and and rescheduled um so it was an initial conversation to discuss what's working what um where our areas are opportunities for improvement to bring um current board feedback that we
037had up until that point to Josie and team to discuss not only the reports being um updated I don't want to use the word more robust but to meet the needs of the board um at the board table during those monitoring sessions and then we were going to visit the conversation once we had the conversation with Josie visit um with a board regarding um how could we as a board how as a governing body um make this work for us so it it felt like our um it felt it feels as though we are not being reprimanded at the board table we're able to ask the questions that we want to ask at the appropriate time we're getting the answers that give us the information that we need as a board to understand that we
038are Ming moving in the direction of continuous Improvement towards meeting or exceeding these goals and honoring our guard rails that sounds great yeah is that I think that sounds great just to reflect you know Dr Roberts I know you had some thoughts on the monitoring process and I don't know if those have been shared with Josie Skyler you know like I was thinking about the DAT to step back like just different things that had come up in the in how a monitoring process might look different so I just want to say as long as all the feedback is going to to the three of you that sounds great and if one person wants to add that add to that group not necessarily to do the meeting on Friday then it sounds like We're Off to
039the Races yes Skyler do you have interest in that this Friday won't work but I happy to contribute yet yeah great thank you so we can include you Skylar um on future conversations um my the other observation that I have is if board members will remember when we first took a survey um that produced the results that we're looking at regarding our board governance manual and we sat down in a retreat on a Saturday or Sunday morning I recall um the conversation I think and and helped me remember I would have to go back to my notes but where I'm remembering we ended was it became clear that there was perhaps an opportunity for better understanding of how the policies were initially put into place and an understanding of the why um around those policies
040so my my ask and wondering is how do you envision these edits coming to fruition are you thinking a committee will work on these and then bring recommendations back or I just worry at the Timeline that we have set for ourselves seems aggressive if there's not a baseline foundational understanding of the policies as they exist currently uh I guess I have two questions do you have a recommend I think people do I mean I I felt like at the last meeting we had this conversation and people feel like they understand the policies I think you this is going to this is going to come out the wrong way but I think you're wondering like do you really understand it or you think understand it right because we haven't had sofd training and that's com it's
041coming out the wrong way let me say it again I think people seem to feel like they understand sofg in a way that uh maybe is not the way it usually happens because of the um board training that typically members go through so I think my question is people seem to think they have a foundational knowledge of student outcomes Focus governance and so I'm not sure what else we have to do other than to work collaboratively to talk about specific so my wondering was more specifically about the our board policy manual um when we sat down and and and began to discuss those in that Retreat and again perhaps I'm not recalling accurately but there was a lot of question around um why was it written like this why was it um uh initially created
042kind of some of that historical um knowledge and so not necessarily yeah history so we can even kick that off today if that's okay if you you want to address that would you be the person to address that or I can certainly try yes I I would put it differently I would say I think we have a foundational understanding of the policies I think we all also understand that we could have a better understanding of execution of how we do things and so I think we can recognize both of those things and still feel like maybe this isn't the way for us all of those three things can be true at the same time and so um so I think that may be where I I guess I'll just speak for me that's where I'm
043coming from um and so and that's where I would want to see some of the edits that that we're talking about but we need governance and we need to have a manual and we need to have an agreed upon structure and so uh the idea of looking at some of these things and trying to get through as much as we can I think your Point's well taken we do all this work and make it last until November at which time there are four seats open on this board and so we will start all over again after that is done potentially and so I think um getting it done as quickly as possible as aggressively as possible so that we can move on to just doing it as best we can um I see the I
044see the value in that so that um we're not talking just remain out of compliance I mean really that's that's really the question I think when I think about where we are right now is we're out of compliance we don't use the manual uh that would be fine too I think I feel like as a chair it's if we're turning this over to to again it may not be a dramatically different board or it might be it feels like we have to have um we should have a an accurate or accurate enough Playbook so um that's really my reason for pushing this forward otherwise I think we have so much to do if there is not uh a desire to spend time on this just say it because I I I think that's fine too
045and that's my question was just more around how you envisioned the process if it was going to be committee work bringing back recommendations or if it was going to be whole board work um so the the question was framed around when we sat down initially to discuss this it really kind of spiderwebbed into many different conversations as I recall um so that was I'll tell you this is how I was going to approach it what I was going to do and if you look at the agenda for today small breakout groups question two we were actually going to you know find a buddy basically and look at the tier one issues that were elevated and there would be small group conversation and then bringing it back to a full group conversation that's how I intended
046to do it um this was really a warmup to then determine the work product that would have to come out of this would be making you know edits written edits I'm open to other suggestions uh that people have uh and again maybe I want to frame the first question which is I think there's agreement that we want to improve the monitoring process and it looks like Kim and Jenna and now Skyler and Josie and with Dr Roberts there's a path forward to get to that and I think to get to that in the time frame that we're seeking um do we want to go through the same exercise with the governance manual or do we want to continue the way we are uh until November Kim can I ask a question um and I I
047just would be interested in your thoughts on this can we continue out of compliance and work on holding each other accountable um to stay in our lane so to speak um with these as a a general guideline with our with our um board policies as as they stand as a general guideline um and just have good honest conversations and some healthy conflict when it calls for it um if we're out of step is that I mean like for the and and again I'm looking at the time frame and just sort of thinking with the amount of things we have to do I'm asking is this the work that we want to engage in right now versus um maybe finding our footing through some just healthy work and then in November getting back to a governance
048uh an edit a good edit of the governance manual that's that would be an alternative I'd propose board members other thoughts Miss KN not my area of expertise for the board Jackie I would recommend moving forward as proposed with the small groups I I think there's value in doing some small groups and then coming back together collectively and if we recognize themes then I think it gets to Kim's point of how do we move forward with that does that do those decisions then become um recommendations as a larger group or is there a separate committee that maybe addresses even maybe each of the themes yeah I think it really I think this is about um capacity and ability to handle what's in front of us in the next few months right and so um there's
049nothing wrong with starting right and so uh Miss Murano I wonder if you'd be willing to kick off and give some context to the manual itself and then if there's interest we could look at the back of the the page which is in tier order these were the issues that board members said they wanted to address and so if it's tier one those four topics were the topics that people wanted to discuss the most so we could use a little bit of our time today to just do those small breakouts look at it read it have a conversation about it and see where we are so I say we just jump in then um so miss Marano do you want to provide some context uh and specifically just so everybody knows um Kim is going
050to be talking about th this this is the foundational document it's also found on our website M yeah I I feel ill prepared to provide an overview of that document in any level of detail outside of um the last time it was updated was by um committee recommendation to the full board um in 202 [Music] 2022 um what did you want maybe I misunderstood I thought it you wanted to provide context to the document I misunderstand that history and context no I think I I was referencing a lot of the questions that came up as we started to go through the individual policies in our previous Retreat and work session and was addressing that a lot of those questions s that I there's nothing that I would like to address at this time I'm certainly
051happy to answer questions if I have answers to them as they come up so so Jackie if I would offer maybe we do break out into the smaller groups there's four uh for tier one there are four areas there's seven of us pick maybe we split in half and each does two um you two decide you're both talking do two and then do two again so that we have we don't just have a one-on-one conversation we can do a four and three yes yes sorry there's only six of us here never mind three and three what are we doing yeah so if we split us us three can address the top two you three do the bottom two and come up with maybe um some some themes some concerns some recommendations at a very high
052level not that they're necess necessarily going to be implemented but for discussion okay so the assignment just to say again is that we're going to read so I'm going to use tier one 4.1 because that's what we were just assigned right which is we're going to look at 4.1 we're g to we're going to read it and we are going to discuss where uh it's it's not necessarily what questions we have what context we need where we're struggling and bring that back to the group convers yes so the anchoring so you'll have 4.1 and 3.1 and the anchoring question because on this list someone ideally in your group put modify for a reason why was modify chosen yep okay okay great and we're taking um 33 and 36 I I don't know it would me
053you were the it would make more sense guys the I think it'll work that way still because you e e e and then it should be comprehensive enough to e e e interesting that and and to find all the different policies and um policies or board policies well there seems to be a and I'll let Dr Robert speak to this maybe but a gap remember how there were all the management limitations and those management Li limitations were shifted um but it's unclear where they're reflected in I I don't know that I don't know with the sunsetting of management limitations if they were ever written as District policy when we transition from management limitations to um um guard rails it is not my belief that any of them were written or codified in District policy um
054that I am aware of thank you Kim I would say that uh the existing team probably pulled bits and pieces so a pece meal um would be one way of describing it but um we're hopeful because we have a team right now that is working on sort of creating a hub where we can actually easily access access policies board policies um admin regulations Department guidelines and a myriad of other sort of categorizations of the guidance and policies that will support the work so we we're getting that done now um since the sunsetting of those so what would be an example so goals and guardrails would be board policy polies correct um do we have other board policies this manual that we're reviewing right now is our board policies every other policy is District policy um
055but if it's not reflected in District policy like when something left here and went to let's just say to the superintendent district policy there are some things that um AR maybe board directives that and I think one of the examples was the uh collective bargaining that was in management like what we there's certain things that are um are they board policy are they District policy are they like you pass them from Schoolboard member to Schoolboard member because like that would be an example of something that would have been in management limitations telling the superintendent permissible topics or things I'm just picking on that one there's a few others so how I'm just trying to figure out how to how to reconcile some of these things yeah when the management limitation was sunsetted it was recommended
056that that become District policy I don't think that it was again I don't think it was codified as such okay so sounds like a healthy review of District policies I mean the team's doing it anyways to then figure out if there's certain things that got lost that need to be reflected so I have a question then did the pieces that did not get codified in District policy but were prior board policy are those going to be brought to the board for review to say do you still want these so it's up to the district to decide whether they're going to adopt them or not so I'll just go to collective bargaining because that's what we're talking about so really it will be up to the superintendent to decide what they bargain on or not he
057does not have to bring that to the board there's no more of the board oversight into that I mean I'm just you're speaking in very high level like we we would still um vote to approve the dmea contract we would still right right right but all those things that were directed by the board if they're no longer in our governance manual then that will be up to the superintendent and his team to determine whether they want to adopt them in District policy or not correct continue yeah I think we need to dive into some of that stuff it'd be good just know where that boundary perhaps existed before and what the decision was just so we're all on the same page because I do feel like often times people are saying oh this is at
058the directive of the board or you know and I don't feel like we really went down deeply because I what I remember when we went through this governance manual was everything will be codified in District policy everything that was in management limitations is going to go into District policy not that it was going away but that it was moving into District policy so I guess I'm trying to understand if it's if it's going away I just want to make sure we're transparent if things are going away why they're going away and who's making the decision so it does not come back that the board eliminated this um but that the board decided it was not going to be something that we held our superintendent to and he made that decision does that make sense yeah
059so I'm also hearing that there's an ask for us to have a very clear delineation or distinction between board policy governance policy versus superintendent and team admin regulation yeah I'm really struggling right now on the difference I have to be honest because um yeah I mean I just so District policy who directs District policy doesn't the board attendant so does the board approve District policy or do you approve District policy we just had yeah we just had we approve them but we do not monitor them for compliance we do not they are not a part of you know our you don't monitor them for compliance that's kind of crazy as a board um um well let's I I want to say true to time that I committed what maybe a good next step is trying
060to work with Josie and kayy since they've been doing a lot of the work anyways of like trying to piece things together to just ex explain what's where um or like help us understand what's guiding like what what is currently codified as a policy there are hundreds and hundreds of where would we find them there's a what on dmschools.org they're all there yes the ones that are there yeah there are hundreds and hundreds of them and most of them um our operational policies um at a high level um so it is typically not the role of the board it is the role of the it is part of the superintendent's role not the role of the board to oversee those I I'm not disagreeing but I'm actually wondering where are they all are you saying
061they're all everything that that governs everything that the superintendent has to abide by is listed on our website under District policies yeah I can okay I mean they're there so that's where we should look well except for the fact that in board policy the superintendent also has to abide by as the only employee that we monitor also has to abide by our policies or the ones that pertain to him yeah um I'm trying to think through the best way to keep forward movement and I'm wondering if yeah go ahead Skyler sorry are are we I I don't know maybe we jumped ahead are you talking about 4.1 right now or is this just no I think a question about where are the policies I mean and a good example was when I asked I think
062Skylar you asked me what does the board approve as it relates to financials yeah and I have that question where is that written um how do we know what we're getting and what we're not getting and what governs that so I I think there's just maybe a greater understanding of uh kind of like Department policy versus District policy versus you'd almost have a cross over there because in that in that very good example it is it governs what the board does and should and shouldn't be doing but it also is an operational thing that has to then be carried forward you have to have for the superintendent to bring forward to the board and the Board review and approves yeah and so would that be reflected in District policy it or it is and should
063be in board policy and should be in board policy no need to have it well it should if this is what we do then it this should reflect what we do Dr Roberts understands what he does if he's doing what he's supposed to do if we're doing what we're supposed to do both people come together but it should be written down both places I think going to save us here I I don't know if I'm going to save you but I I think I would need to to see an example it the hypotheticals are hard for me to kind of process right now um the the website is dmschools.org departments Administration policies Dand procedures and there are uh series 800 of them um yeah I think the question is I think we all know where
064they are it's whether or not the management limitations and kind of what happened to that quite specific body of work and where that went and I'm sorry madam chair I don't mean to make this more frustrating than it is to some of us but I I just want to because I don't know that history there was a piece of board policy that was chunked out and given to as as operational it move to operational was that is that what I'm hearing the board um the board updated their board governance policy manual as a part of that update there were some red lines um those red lines um were discussed in length and um the conversation was if the district um and the district leadership wanted to and felt that these were still important and wanted
065to write District policy around the these items then we as a board said yes go forth and do that that okay and if they didn't want to then that PO those policies are no longer all right well I mean I think now we kind of know what to look for Jen I think shared the management limitations just so people could understand what it with the old model used to be the policies are on the website and we'll just try and there there are some questions right so the the question about approval limits so and if that's on the website great um I don't think it is right so I think it's just helpful exercise for us to try and figure out where are the big gaps so there's Clarity um and um especially if there's
066something that really needs to be rectified that we don't even realize it's not C somewhere and I think a lot of that is the work that you'll see yeah yeah there there may not have been bad intent it may just to not have ever made it over because somebody just didn't do it you know and that did happen in between um mat yeah uh a previous superintendent um and a an interim superintendent and new um dmea transitioning dmea leadership too I felt like wasn't didn't joshh transition maybe not no yeah so anyways so the team and I will continue to again um work to sort of find create a clear space where we can look at find and distinguish between board policy versus admin regulations admin guidelines Department regulations Department guidelines and if there are
067gaps that exist based on the board's observation and there is an ask that the board has whether or not something should be uh superintendent and team's responsibility or board policy then I think we bring that to the table have a discussion and I think it's easily resolvable yeah when I was helping um kayy I what I did was like connect the board policy board governance policy to administrative policy so everything the board the superintendent has follows under 3 three which is delegation superintendent of superintendent uses you know reasonable interpretation then um uh okay thank you for another example the solvy ratio would be another example and I don't know that might have I don't think that made it in but that's another I just got on 2.6 and we've heard about that a lot that
068that's a board policy and we're like where is that so like that's another example of ones that we've heard a lot about yeah so uh we're going to end this meeting I think that um what if everybody could just write down their learnings from the conversation I have a feeling that this this the starting point is still this tension uh between student outcomes and student outcomes plus other um responsibilities of a board in broader oversight um and and I'm not sure having that conversation tonight is actually going to move us in the right direction so I wonder if the better use of time is for everybody to kind of keep their notes think about the conversation and then Skylar you and I can um try and look for more time to advance this part of
069the conversation because the monitoring conversations moving forward right so there's a group that's already so um if somebody has a very specific idea on where to go next otherwise I'm just going to look for a free hour the next time we think we can squeeze in a work session to be able to talk about it um to keep advancing the conversation um if if indeed the board wants to continue moving in this direction because I think we can make improvements I feel like we got one where we're pretty close to a good recommendation for a reasonable Improvement um and that that meets the I think the the concerns of the folks who said maybe edit and so little by little could work to The Optimist way to go I'm working on it okay um final
070comments on this process or ways to approach it better different uh more effectively yeah my wondering would just be um if this should be a an ad hoc committee that brings that discusses these items and brings forth recommendations I think that the amount of time that can be spent in a in a committee um can be much greater than what the whole board can commit to and um I think that seeing your timeline here that would be a way to try and meet some of these deadlines that you've identified yeah I mean it's up to I'm happy to be on the governance manual policy since you're on monitoring I mean I we we I'm happy to do it that way if other people want to um join that committee and be a part of it
071um yeah I I think that'd be appropriate and probably the best solution for moving forward to actually get something concrete um what I would ask from that committee and if it's you and Kim or whoever it is is that that committee is taking the feedback from the entire board and implementing that if we have it we don't have every unfortunately we don't have everybody's feedback right so but we're Gathering we're at least we're supposed to be gathering it so we could revisit this same survey that we took um previously and um ask everyone to resubmit um their feedback and if you want me to create a new survey I can so that we can compare um the previously the previous results from the survey to the new results and then um take in account all
072of the feedback how about we just focus on the first tier okay let's just start so survey the first tier all board members provide feedback on the first tier um I just think maybe we chunk it up that way it might feel more manageable so I'm going to forward the redlined version that we had from back in 2022 and the reason I say that is because like I don't think solvy ratio was anything we were thinking about when we did this I mean I think there's things that have bubbled up over time that now that you're looking back you're like oh that needs to be somewhere and I and I think that could be really helpful for everyone just to see what was eliminated to just really think through now that we've been here for
073a while and had to you know lead with a new superintendent and kind of figure out all these pieces that were sort of institutional knowledge what needs to be somewhere right and so just to just use that example would a solvency ratio be a guardrail as opposed to a like I I I I think I'm struggling to understand and that is something that the board should be able to direct the superintendent to adhere to certain Financial um Health standards right and so how how how does that happen if you have an operational excellence guard rail and a policy that says this is what operational excellence looks like in our solvency ratio you use the policy as a reason to say to the superintendent this is our ask of you an interim guard rail perhaps but
074only I don't know I would I I'd put I'd put that on policy I I think a committee would be great to figure that out okay I'm on the committee who else is on the committee me I'll join thank you okay um we are going to wrap up this work session uh just a kind of a quick announcement a couple of us have um elevated to Dr Roberts and to Matt wanting a clearer understanding of timeline and next steps and how all of the pieces are flowing together and Dr Robert said he would present that either at the next board meeting or in writing before that's correct is that right yeah okay perfect team happy birthday to the twins okay thanks everybody thanks everybody good night do you want this