001e [Music] pull it I would like to call the school board meeting for Tuesday February 4th 2025 for the dewine public schools to order Miss Rios could you please take the role yes Miss Alonso here miss compos present Mr dicks here miss Knox here Miss Marano here Dr Mayberry ma here miss Norris here we have Corum the first item of business is approval of the agenda may have a motion and a second to approve the agenda so moved second we have a motion by Mr dicks and a second by Miss Alonzo is there any discussion or does anyone have questions may I may I ask that we pull item E1 um we did not receive the documentation um so I would like to make a friendly amendment to approve the agenda minus E11 and to
002be clear you do you want to discuss it or do you want to pull it I would like to pull it as we did not receive the documentation in a timely manner to review okay can hold on one second we are operating under a timeline and so let's and I think an email was sent to the full board with the information answering questions and so do you want to take we could take a few minutes of a break for people to have a chance to take a look at it we can go ahead and just pull it for separate vote then okay uh all right so so a friendly Amendment uh to the agenda so uh does everybody approve the agenda with the exception of polling item e 11 um which is the uh early
003retirement thank you early retirement uh so again we'll just uh all those in favor just say I I okay hi wonderful okay here we go next we are moving to the public forum oh that's me um okay so we provide speakers at The Forum an opportunity to address the board for up to 3 minutes regarding items that are not on the board agenda and up to 5 minutes for an agenda item if anyone wishes to speak during any portion of the business meeting please email rosa. Ros dmschools.org the same speaking protocols apply to all individuals who wish to address the board speakers will be called individually and we ask that they State their name and address prior to providing comments students and minors do not have to provide their address guests of the board are
004encouraged to speak to matters relating to programs services and operations of dmps please remember that Iowa law prohibits us from discussing specific employees or their job performance we ask all speakers to avoid references to personalities or character attacks as those type of comments do not contribute to the purpose for which this public form exists the use of inappropriate language will not be tolerated and individuals choosing to do so will be gaveled out of order and asked to excuse themselves from the premises or escorted out by District security as a reminder to the board and public the board will not engage in a discussion with public forum speakers as it is Our obligation to discuss only matters posted in the public agenda for the sake of transparency and opportunity afforded to all Community stakeholders matters requiring
005attention will receive appropriate staff and or board followup at a time after the meeting thank you for your participation we appreciate your feedback and input Mr Rios do we have any speakers for the public forum yes we do first up I'll call Steve Meyer my name is Steve Mar 3317 East 9th uh my phone number is 5325 the mo public schools has failed my daughter because they don't have data she doesn't get the education that she deserves because you guys don't have data my daughter's five and autistic and special needs she has a lot of the same traits that her older brother does who is also autistic we were able to get him into a school that we knew he was safe the school that I'm talking about is better trained and better equipped to
006make sure that autistic kids and special needs kids are safe and learning in an environment that's good for them I'm going to assume that most of us here say and think and we are concerned about the safety and education of children but if I told you that that doesn't matter because you you guys don't care what parents think the first year my daughter was in school she was at mck first year there were no issues the second year that she was there she was found with a heart pill in her mouth that belonged to one of the staff my wife watched a full-grown adult male staff pick her up buy her coat and drop her then we watched the security footage of another adult cut cutting her hand open with a locker door because they
007didn't make sure that her hand was out of the way we took her out of mcke and there were no issues when we moved her to woodlon this year we enrolled her in her neighborhood School C tell because we were lied to by her special education coordinator that the school we wanted her to go to that they had contacted and said no and they never did we contacted the school and they said they'd never heard heard anything about our daughter in the 3 months that she was at catel she was bitten by another child with a known biting issue so hard that it bruised her whole upper arm for more than two weeks but you guys don't have data to keep her [Music] safe we watched sorry her the final straw was when they closed
008my daughter's hand in a door and pinched her fingers because they weren't paying attention but you guys don't have data to keep her safe to make it where she can go to the school that she needs I'm not blaming that school I'm blaming you guys because all you care about is data most kids can come home and tell their parents how the day was or if something happened or they got hurt now imagine that they can't tell you that somebody hurt them 30 seconds remaining mine can't mine my wife's daughter can't but that doesn't matter to you guys because you have to have your data as my daughter grows up there's going to be a lot of things that she may or may not be able to do and that's something that me and my
009wife have to face every day yet at De Mo Public Schools you guys took the opportunity away from her because you can't keep her safe and what we know as parents on what's best for her doesn't matter because you don't have your data our daughters not data thank you thank you thank you next speaker is Daisy Campos [Music] Gan hi my name is Daisy Kos Gan my address is 2910 50th Street and my phone number is 51524472929 um that affect my children's educational experience one of them is poor communication with parents I have encountered difficulties in reaching School staff when I have questions or concerns and opportunities to interact with teachers are limited to response received by parents uh which is me when uh myself rais concerns or inquiries responses are delayed or inadequate I
010frequently receive gener or automated replies that do not address the specific issue raised I have also observed a lack to followup and previously raise concerns and the policies and procedures for addressing parent feedback seems inconsistent third is safety I am concerned about the insufficient safety measures in place to ensure the security of students on campus uh uh the supervision during school hours uh I am worried about bowling and the school efforts to prevent and address it um there have been incorrect marking of absences and uh which had to be corrected uh this is not only causing unnecessary stress but also impacts my child's attendance record accurate and timely recording of attendance is crucial and I urge the school to address this issue promptly I hope these concerns will be taken into consideration and the steps
011will be taken to improve communication parent response safety and attendance accuracy at the school I am willing to collaborate and to provide further details if necessary thank you thank you very much thank you those are all the speakers I have the next item on our agenda is our district recognitions uh Dr Roberts are there any recognitions for today thank you madam here good evening everyone and thank you all for being here um while we do not have any impersonal recognitions uh certainly there are a number of items a number of accomplishments and celebrations of students teachers and staff that we can recognize but I want to uh Crave Your Indulgence this evening um on pivot from a recognition to acknowledge the passing of one of our teammates uh we are truly overwhelmed with sadness to
012share that last week we were informed that Doug Richardson who our Public Safety manager and had been with the mo Public Schools since November 30th of 2020 has led us our safety team through a number of really critical Transitions and quite frankly has done a remarkable job of partnering with his teammates to ensure that we continue to improve and refine our safety protocols and processes to keep 31,000 students and the adults who serve them safe Doug was a dedicated public servant he was always committed to doing what is best for people prior to coming to the mo Public Schools he was a paramedic A Firefighter and quite frankly many would say that he was a stalwart in the first responder Community since joining the mo Public Schools he was truly instrumental in enacting many of
013our safety protocols but perhaps his greater skill was that of a communicator if you've ever had an opportunity to interact with Doug you would see that he epitomizes what it means to be a first responder after the first two minutes but in the third minute you would realize that he doesn't fit any characteristic of a first responder his smile was inviting his tone was welcoming and his eyes were kind on behalf of the board and the mo Public Schools cabinet we certainly want to send our sincerest condolences to Doug's family and will continue to support his teammates who are members of our Public Safety team during this time of bereavement that concludes my remarks Madam chair thank you Dr Roberts the next item on our agenda is an update on our goal three uh from
014our superintendent and team I will turn it over to Dr Roberts I am going to make a suggestion because I believe Dr lendine stepped out Kaye would you mind just okay great thank you thank you he stepped out to address and support appearance I'm back thank you madam chair members of the board superintendent Roberts on behalf of the go 3 committee we're excited today to present some new uh research with you that we believe oh sorry thanks that we are confident is validating not only the model that has been chosen for uh diploma plus as a means of increasing our graduation rates and our rates of achievement um but also uh in uh ensuring that we are creating an achievement-based environment across all of our schools ahead of tonight's meeting you should have received not
015only a copy of the presentation uh but also a copy of the most recent work plan that shows progress and I'll be glad to answer questions about that at the close of the presentation uh if you have any um but I want to dive in to today's objectives uh for goal three we want to first take the time to illustrate the direct quantitative relationship between participation in diploma plus activities and dmps graduation rates in short there's been Val valued questions asked by this board around whether there is a direct relationship between the specific academic and extracurricular activities that are being proposed to be areas of Distinction within diploma plus and whether or not there is an a correlational relationship between that and increased graduation rates uh our Pro our group our program team has done
016uh remarkable work in analyzing that data and I'm excited to be able to share with you today what's been found next uh we want to elaborate on the external academic research that's validating the diploma plus strategy we've looked not only uh at what the research shows us anecdotally but also what it shows us in specific cities like ours where a pro a program like this with uh predictors that can be used to guide uh students toward towards the higher likelihood of graduation makes the difference uh for promoting student achievement and graduation and we want to show what that's going to look like within dmbs schools so I as I always do I bring us back to our current reality which is at 72.2% current four-year graduation rate it's a number that nobody in this room
017uh can accept as uh an acceptable status quo and one where we need to be thinking creatively not just about what we are delivering in our classrooms but how we are guiding students to be able to complete the academic and extracurricular activities that are going to increase the likelihood of those students going on to graduate in this case our ambitious aim 100% of a four-year graduation rate with distinctions tonight we're going to respond to three critical questions and they're questions that I've heard in some way shape or form uh reflected in board dialogue in some of our pre updates the first is would diploma plus represent a significant change in what our students are actually learning and doing aren't they already engaged in the proposed activities there's a healthy amount of skepticism around the fact
018that when we shared with you that these are specific activities and opportunities that are available to us within the spectrum of what's offered in dmps right now that that must mean that they're already uh part of the Lexicon of what students are doing and therefore that there wouldn't be a direct change uh in outcomes as a result of students participation tonight we'd like to rebut that argument second and uh I appreciate Miss Marano asking this question the last time of looking at whether or not the diploma plus uh framework and its specific inputs actually translates into explicit student achievement and graduation rate increase es and I'm pleased to say we've been able to show the correlational data that shows a dramatic link between the two and three how does the diploma plus approach align with
019best practices is validated by external academic research in short our goal 3 team has done the research and is more confident than ever that the introduction of diploma plus will have a direct and positive impact on our students graduation trajectories we have seen not only in what's gone on in other communities like ours but also in our own data that's been analyzed by our program evaluators that in fact we know that there's going to be a direct and positive relationship that will increase graduation and student achievement in the process that raises the first question would diploma plus represent a significant change in what our students are actually learning and doing aren't they already engaged in the proposed activities so I don't expect everyone to be squinting at the chart here but I wanted to show
020this to show the depth of analysis that's gone in to specific question of whether or not our students are engaged in the specific Enterprises and activities that diploma plus seeks to incentivize and make part of what will lead to distinctions within the program and by extension graduation our team of program evaluators and um M Mor you asked this question last time as well we do in fact have a team of program evaluators working hard on the team have analyzed multiple data sets for the classes of 22 23 and 24 to ascertain the exact levels of historical involvement in proposed diploma plus Student Activities as a result we see tremendous potential for future engagement of our students let's start with the basic question of whether or not as a whole our students are currently completing the
021activities and prerequisites associated with diploma plus right now based on the data analysis conducted by the program evaluation team roughly half of our graduates and even less of our total student population have historically completed the requirements for at least one de plus distinction over the last 3 years we've seen bits and pieces of those activities being completed but not necessarily to the fullest where the point of them eventually earning a distinction that would align with their graduation has been produced as noted here we then went through eight of those indicators to reflect how much of our graph graduate and our current student body are actually uh have actually shown over the last three years that they've accured those uh achievements the first one completion of one year of college or 24 college credit hours you
022can see the numbers are quite small roughly 1% we've got work to do to increase our students inclination to complete that one year of college credit uh in order to set them up for success in the enroll comp component of enrolled employe and enlist next we looked at the college readiness in our national exams and whether students would be meeting college readiness benchmarks on the act or the SAT as noted in the scores here and as you can see here in our current 22 through 24 statistics we have roughly 5 to 6% of our graduates and 3 to 5% of our students overall currently achieving that number what we've term the CTE concentrator well we've got students completing four or more semester long courses in a single CTE program area with an A or a
023B we can see that in the classes of 22 through 24 that our numbers range from 8 to roughly 11% with our student numbers uh overall between 6 and 8% the Seal of biliteracy you can see that similar range roughly between uh 2022 and 4% up to roughly 9% in 2024 among our graduates and a lower percentage among our students silver cord with the completion of 160 hours of volunteer service you can see again roughly similar statistics of students currently completing these achievements in uh within our current structure and then on the multidisciplinary pathway and this is one that was a complex set of analysis here you can see that among the students who were meeting at least two of the four unique criteria this is a slightly higher percentage among the graduates uh from
02422 to 24 it's roughly 30 to 35% and among our students between 23 and 26% same with our performance Excellence of four years of participation in the same sport jrc or Performing Arts you can see that among the graduates roughly 15% to 19.9% of graduates were completing that achievement and then 11 to 15 uh doing so among students as a whole so what is the conclusion about this looking at these stats the question may be well why are these stats so low in the first place well in part it's because we haven't had a cohesive message that's align students activities and involvement in both the academic and the extracurricular space so that they would have that coherent Pathway to complete those achievements I find great encouragement in these numbers because they show that if we
025explicitly offer students those clear Pathways by which they can acre these achievements that not only are there a great number of students who have uh had the potential to do so before but haven't done so up until this point but that those students would uh that are currently missing out on those major opportunities would then have an incredibly strong correlation between their approval acral of those diploma plus distinctions and their rates of graduation which leads us to question two does diploma plus actually translate into higher graduation and achievement rates earning a distinction means very little to us if it doesn't come in hand with the increase in that four-year graduation rate and so we looked long and hard across all of those different indicators to see what the correlational relationship would be between a student
026actually achieving one or more of the diploma plus distinctions and their likelihood of graduating in a four-year time frame and the results boggled our minds oops the answer there was that our team of program evaluators conducted that analysis and found a significant relationship between those students who would have accured at least one diploma plus distinction and their respective rates of graduation here's the big picture headline for you and let me decode what this graph means for those who uh maybe haven't been as familiar with the conversation we had you'll notice here listed is the total earned percentage earned and graduation rate over that same three-year total 2022 to 2024 what the data shows us here is for students who earned based on the criteria that we've established at least one diploma plus distinction 93.2% of
027them graduated in that four-year timeline that number increased to 98.8% for those with two or more and 100% for those with three or more we actually found one student who we affectionately termed winning high school because she had six diploma plus distinctions she's new now doing quite well at the four-year University of her choice but even if it's just one that likelihood of the student achieving that diploma plus distinction and them going on to grad graduate from our high schools with a 93% rate of reliability is remarkable we then took that apart even further and sought to break it down across each of the areas of Distinction that we've highlighted for you in our previous presentations now first statistic I want to clarify there uh it says one plus diploma plus so one or more
028diploma plus distinctions had a gr graduation rate of 96.8% you'll notice that's slightly different than the previous statistic where it was either one or two this is the Amal of both but as you can see in the statistics reflected here whether it would be in the one year of college the CTE act the silver cord performance Excellence JC Athletics the numbers are all in the 90 percentile or above that students who completed these specific areas of achievement went on to graduate from our high schools that in short setting up the right Cadence of activities and experiences for students dramatically increases the likelihood that they are going to graduate with our diploma in hand at the end of their four-year Journey so that leads us to a conclusion and a theory of action if we guide
029middle and high school students through a rigorous academic advising model and build system capacity to provide students these opportunities then students will achieve one or more diplom and plus distinctions which will lead to increased graduation rates I would be feeling like I was going out on a limb if this wasn't backed up by the research which we'll talk about in a bit as well but the research shows us that this use of pre graduation indicators has been shown to serve as a powerful Catalyst for increasing graduation and achievement rates not only in our respective context but Nationwide as well so to give you a comparison one example we've shared with you before was that of Kansas City Kansas Public Schools which launched its own diploma plus program roughly 10 years ago right now now the
030goal that diploma plus has been set for in Kansas City Kansas having a few years under their belt which they are Unapologetic in setting is that by 2031 100% of KPS students will graduate with a diploma plus credential with no disparities in race or gender subgroups while meeting or exceeding the average graduation rate of the state members of our committee engaged at length with senior leadership from Kansas City Kansas to gauge how they went about getting to the point where they could set an ambitious goal like this with confidence and in short it is a similar Pathway to what we are working on doing right here in De Mo you can see here in some of the slides that have been presented uh by Kansas City that in not just middle and high school but
031now in the case of Kansas City Kansas and the early childhood and Elementary sector the frontloading of students specific academic and extracurricular opportunities that they know will lead to the likelihood of diploma plus acrs that will internally hire graduation rates is front-loaded throughout every part of the student experience in Kansas City Kansas and you'll see in the section on the right some of the specific distinctions that using what uh we hope to have in our signature schools will be able to launch as early as elementary school so that students will be able to be on that track for greater graduation rates and achievement at an even earlier stage than Middle School this is historical data from Kansas city that has shown how from the start in 2015 it has been a gradual but significant increase
032over time based on the continuous integration of the diploma plus criteria and uh academic advising model that we have recommended here and where they're at today and where they're looking to get to you can see that in about 2018 they started to truly integrate about four years in into some of the earlier grades as well and then were able to create cohorts where those cohorts will ultimately by 2031 lead to a rate of acral of 100% right now for 2425 they're seeing an initial trajectory of 66% that's already been revised to 70% with seven years under their belt in short by incubating the program early with these the models that we've already established and shared with you and then continuing to expand it across the elementary middle and high school Spectrum the data shows that
033the graduation rate and the achievement rate of the students involved has increased dramatically and will continue to do so going into the next few years we envision a similar trajectory here in De Mo where we look not only at setting up our initial cohorts starting with our first batch of ninth graders receiving that academic advising we're working with our middle schools now to be able to set up the those future cohorts of students to be able to be on track to increase the likelihood of them of receiving those distinctions and then continuing to build that out in both directions so that we get cohorts of students uh in earlier grades who are gradually introduced to more and more opportunities to frontload the experiences and opportunities that will lead to their ultimate high levels of graduation
034one other thing that I think is important to note in the example of Kansas City Kansas is the recognition that they can differentiate what their goals are looking like by school and based on the unique context when we talked with uh KCK they have a combination as we are aspiring to do of traditional comprehensive schools and signature schools and so as you can see within the rates though all of the schools are looking to have rates of at least 70% of students receiving diploma plus endorsements with 70% 78% or more doing so in this coming year it's gone on a slightly different uh rate of increase within their signature schools that as with their comprehensive schools but no school has been left behind in being able to show a positive trajectory of students receiving these
035kind of distinctions and ultimately leading to high higher graduation rates that leads us to the third question which is how does the diploma plus approach align with best practices as validated by external academic research we've done our homework when it comes to what Academia has shown us Works in this space and though we didn't want to bore you with every article we wanted to give you a couple of the high points that show that this specific model that of using pre high school and high school indicators as a means of almost incentivizing the likelihood of a student going on to graduate in a timely manner works and is in alignment with what we see for not only postsecondary success in the uh enrollment in a four-year college or university space but also doing so in
036the uh employment and enlistment space as well so in short research has validated the power that the Strategic selection of specific postsecondary Readiness indicators can have on the rates of graduation and long-term success of our students we started looking at a study from 2024 entitled knocking at the college door projections of high school graduates and what it showed us was at the timing of our introduction of diploma plus is very appropriate given that high school graduation rates across the country are expected to Peak in 2025 but will then be followed by a steady decline through 2041 we need to be proactive in recognizing that if National Trends are moving in a direction of decline graduation rates for a number of reasons that we need to be moving proactively now to counteract that Trend and increase
037those graduation rates within De Moine and reverse that Trend locally I would next refer you to a study that's been conducted by the University of Chicago Consortium on Chicago School research on selecting effective indicators specifically the indicators that we've shared with you all those uh 11 different criteria that we presented to you several months ago there was a method to the mess in selecting which ones of them made sense for being likely to be triggers for greater graduation rates the findings of the study showed that diploma plus mirrors that of other effective urban districts in which a portfolio of postsecondary success indicators is identified and or Advanced as specific aims for students within the article the University of Chicago identifies four key qualities that car characterize the effect of selection and implementation of such indicators
038that they're valid for the intended purpose that they're actionable by schools that they're meaningful and easily understood by practitioners and that they're aligned with the priorities of the district and schools and I think I can say with great certainty that if you look at the 11 uh categories that we presented to you each one of the fulfills all of those four functions we specifically cross referenced each of those categories with the diploma plus uh excuse me the diploma plus categories with these four criteria one the valid for the intended purpose the diploma plus options reflect the body of research that identifies the Readiness indicators for college career and life as students are choosing which diploma plus options they wish to pursue they're developing Knowledge and Skills that have been correlated with postsecondary success I I
039the example that comes to mind more than any was at our last board meeting when the young lady who was part of JC was describing her advancement onto the university there was no coincidence that her involvement in that jrc over the course of those four years put her on a path where she would be set up for post-secondary Success along the way there's stories like that across each of those 11 categories and the research has shown us that they are the likely indicators of what's going to set up those students for not just graduation but achievement along the way second is that each of the categories in place now are actionable by schools when we first presented this concept this board asked a very valid question of what new programs were going to be created
040Here and Now for diploma plus and what we shared with you at the time was we wanted to use what we had in our existing infrastructure to start the process by which we increased this graduation rate using the diploma plus model and so each of those 11 categories are actionable right now so that our class of 2030 can graduate with them and hopefully Advance at a greater graduation rate than their predecessors have in the past third that they're meaningful and easily understood by practitioners we wanted categories and uh postsecondary indicators that would be likely to be able to be engaged with families in a conversation around why they were strong uh predictors of Student Success and what it would take for students to be involved in them those conversations have now moved not only from
041high school and middle school School principles to counselors as well and we'll eventually be part of conversations with our success workers our community schools coordinators and another school-based Personnel so that that conversation between uh those involved in academic advising students and families is one that is Meaningful and easily understood by the practitioners doing the work and fourth that they're aligned with the priorities of the district and the school I don't need to tell you that the diploma plus and goal three uh goal three uh objective directly aligns with not only pillar one but objective one of our strategic plan that goal of having 100% of students graduate with one or more diploma plus credentials is aligned to the new strategic plan and current graduation rate data third i' refer you to work that's been done
042by the research education laboratory College and Career Readiness work group just as last year and within their work they seek to define the indicators that can be identified through high school and early college Years that predict enrollment persistence and success in college courses the presenters also provide examples of methodologies that can be used to conduct such investigation and as you can see here in the bold print on the screen we've directly aligned each of the categories that have been selected for the initial batch of diploma plus uh uh characteristics over uh these first few years with the qualities that are going to be needed to succeed in post-secondary coursework or Workforce training there's about five more articles that I was tempted to present to you but I recognize this is not a research Symposium and
043you have a lot more on your agenda than just this but the links are all active and can show you pretty much the same recurring theme that uh we've been sharing previously namely that the Strategic selection of the indicators in the diploma plus program have been set up in a way where if we cue them up early for students and families show them the value of what those opportunities are for their success not just in middle and high school but beyond that and then have a robust program of academic advising in which students are continually ruid towards achieving those goals that it has a significant correlation and hopefully predictive indicator of graduation increasing significantly across our schools so that leads us to our next step and I know that Rosie's also provided you with our
044most recent edition of our work chart and our progress and as you can see on the chart significant work has been conducted across all of the various areas ranging from working with uh our counseling and support team to familiarize them with what it's going to take to ratchet up the degree of academic advising that's going on in our program continued Gap analysis of what additional opportunities are still needed in our high schools to interaction with key constituencies both within and outside of schools in order to get them vested in diploma plus being the vehicle by which students uh are going to be able to achieve at greater levels one of the biggest areas that we're focused on as we go into this next quarter is alignment of diploma Plus data tracking systems with high schools
045we want to make it easy through either Infinite Campus or other platforms to be able to systematically track students achievement of each of these progress indicators so that at any time not only uh a advisory teacher or an academic adviser can look at student progress and integrate that into the counseling and support that they're providing to students we don't want to have to have a team of very gifted program evaluators but program evaluators dissecting all this data for us to have a clear sense of whether or not students on track we're looking to infuse diploma plus content into the newly adopted high school first year advisory program and ensuring that the messaging aligns clearly with that of um diploma plus next the coordination of our IAP expansion with Middle School leaders I had the privilege
046of speaking with our Middle School principal several weeks ago and giving them a broad overview of what this would look like in practice and how they particularly in seventh and eth grade would be playing a vital role in queuing students up for a successful uh transition into high school and of uh student pursuit of these specific achievements I was incredibly encouraged by the reception and look forward to continuing that conversation not just with our Middle School leaders but with our teachers and with those that are leading academic advising as well next comes the development of student and family facing Communications content designed to inform key constituencies about the components of diploma plus one of the things that's going to be very important is that there is a buzz around the idea that something different is
047happening in our high schools when it comes to graduation and also advertising some of these opportunities that students and families may not otherwise know about but that can get them to the the point where they earn special distinction in their own uh Graduate Studies so we're going to be working closely with Phil Raider and our Communications team in developing that content that can get shared out to families hopefully within the next quarter and then finally continued coordination with the reimagining Education team on prospective future academic Pathways and diploma plus distinctions we do not see these 11 initial uh categories as the limit for what diploma plus can offer Us in terms of a catalyst for improving graduation and achievement rates we see that as just the beginning so with that I thank you for your
048patience and your Indulgence we hope that you share our enthusiasm about the prospects of this initiative and that as is evidenced by the data that you see the possibilities that we see in utilizing this platform to to dramatically increase graduation and achievement across our schools with that I welcome any questions you might have great thanks Dr lundine and Josie and Tasha and all the individuals who've been part of this board members I think we'll just um open it up for questions uh that people would like to ask I don't have really any questions but I just want to thank you guys so much for this um I know this has been really tedious probably sometimes cuz we have put a lot of stuff that we wanted out here and on this and I just want
049to thank you guys for for doing this for us you're very welcome I did have a question around um it was towards the beginning of the presentation you had shared kind of the sample sizes from 22 to 24 um and just they were all kind of between the 7 to 900 population how and which students are participating in diploma plus currently well currently they aren't but what we did is we took it as a hypothetical that if they were to be in diploma plus would they have completed the activities by which they would have accured the the distinctions okay and then I have a follow-up question with that just now realizing this is H that that was hypothetical I heard a lot about the correlation between the two which I'm excited to hear um would
050you mind also just sharing a little bit about analysis for causation as well and how diploma plus is the is the cause of the increased graduation rates versus just it being correlated and that's where we we really look to the external research because we haven't had the the program in place to be able to show direct causation but the AC the external academic research was was vital for us in being able to uh show us the link to causation thank you just a point of clarification were you asking Dr Mayberry Ms who are the kids that are currently meeting the diploma plus distinctions were you kind of asking about what that sample size looked like no I I thought there was an actual population that had piloted or do not just to follow up though
051I think you did though um it was like when you said these there's a group of students who are doing this could overlay they they would qualif for diploma yes and so I think the question is do you know that when you look at that group are there demographics or other uh qualifiers that you can share about that group they're doing it now and it's not called diploma plus but those who are doing it is there a particular demographic are they coming from a certain School certain I can get that break down for you I don't have it on here okay thank you yeah AB thank you yeah we' be happy to provide that dat I think that's excellent as we think about how we're going to bring to the board and community that there
052are already examples of where um causation um is is likely to happen but again we using some hypothetical and just examining some of the students because this is a very new Initiative for us board members I too have uh questions regarding the data um you you talked about that correlation and you said um that think this is translating to higher rates of graduation you said this is dramatically increasing the likelihood but no nowhere in this presentation did you show us percentages of students that were not in one of those diploma plus programs am I mistaken that were not in the program so you gave us from slides um eight on you gave us that three-year hypothetical if a student um met this criteria then they met um you know by Literacy for example Le one
053of those programs um but there's nothing to compare it to to show the students that are not participating so you just gave us one set of data not the set that says students that didn't did not fall into this yeah and we can run that c sorry we can run that calculation but just from kind of a a math perspective right if we're looking at the students who do have diploma plus are graduating at 95 98 100% rate then the the students who aren't graduating are going to be falling into that category of students who aren't I can run the calculation on what it actually is but that's the like if they're not falling into this diploma plus category they're falling into the other so that that tells us that that graduation rate of those
054students who aren't doing it is actually going to be lower than the average so another question regarding the graduation rate that's 72.2% is that state calculated graduation rate yes did you use the same logic when calculating these graduation rates with the diploma plus yes and I can get I can get you more specifics about it but the and my program evaluator who is running this actually just sent me a text so she's watching at home um uh the so yep the students not completing so to answer your first question the students not completing diploma plus graduation rate is about 65% um so compared to that 72% um and then the graduation rate the percent of graduates and the count of graduates the total graduate number we're using from the school performance profile so from that
055state-based calculation okay um and then on slide 20 when you present you've presented everything before slide 20 in annual data 20 2 23 24 and then on slide 20 you gave us three years worth of data and I heard in your presentation that you had an N value of one student that is in my opinion not a sample size that I would report out and I wondered what are the end values of the others and why did you um compile that into or present it in three separate years and then compile it into one in that slide 20 we'd be glad to break that down for you as well um I think for ease of an analysis there we simply just consolidate it into a three-year total okay so I I'm hoping to hear that
056the other end values are higher than one student correct so yeah those the one diploma plus two diploma plus three diploma plus those are all significantly higher it's just it was once you get up into that four five six that's where you get into small end counts um okay yeah so so if you look kind of above that's where you'll see that comp I'm sorry I'm looking at a different spreadsheet um so in uh the slide if you're looking at the slide deck um on slide eight it's kind of small um but that completed at least diplom one diploma plus um that you'll see at the top of slide eight that's that broken out bye in both the count and the percent of graduates so you can see we're looking at 22 about 880 23
057836 24 about 874 so that's where the that's the the summarization was just for to make it easy to to see them kind of all in one place aggregated um when we were looking at those those multiple collections of diploma plus as opposed to the singular um but I can get you the counts on those um only if it's already run I wouldn't yeah no I I have them I just there uh so for just kind of at a snapshot um for kind of the the two for cohort 22 we were looking at 255 um for cohort 23 249 cohort 24 is 260 for those multiple um and then it kind of decreases from there okay thank you Mr JS just um because we're supposed to be thinking about resources and resource allocation on this
058board um my question was it seems to me the key to all of this is the early counseling that you're talking about in junior high how many more counselors are going to are we going to need and do you know how much more time uh students are going to need with a counselor in order to come up with these plans or to be aware of the pathways ahead of them because experience would tell me that right now we don't have a lot of counseling time focused on this in junior high so I think a big part of ensuring that we can maximize the amount of of counseling time was the shift towards the IAP model that we talked about previously and uh Aon Krueger kavasa are are um head of counseling has been working with
059our immediate team of uh counselors and academic advisers to be able to Prime them there uh as we grow out the program I think we're going to need to map out what that looks like in terms of a higher level of academic advisement we're also looking in the ninth grade level at the creation of basically high school style houses that would blend themselves more immediately towards teachers being able to provide that sort of academic advice as well and looking to hopefully adopt that for the next academic year uh so in answer to your question there is not an expectation of addition of more counselors for the coming year but it's something we need to be looking at long term you started to answer my second question talk about that first year advisory program are you
060talking about advisories that students would keep through high school or are you talking about simply a firste uh advisory House program call it what you want would students stay with their advisories through high school or would they uh would that simply be a freshman year program I don't want to get ahead of the high school team because they're working on that right now but I know when I come back with the next update we'll have an update for you Mr Lono uh I just have one question um on your slide of our next steps bullet number four um in Communications uh family engagement is so important so vital um I'd like to know what strategies are you employing to ensure all families have this knowledge in a timely manner so that's where we're going to
061be working uh with uh not only our Communications team for the development of content but also uh on the ground with our parent associations with our bilingual family Liaisons with uh our uh teams on the ground uh to ensure that there is uh a robust set of opportunities for families to be informed and uh students to be able to ask direct questions about that um I would also hope that we can be using uh our technological platforms uh Facebook and Facebook and espanol um as well as uh some of the tools that our Communications team has at their disposal to be able to get the word out through multiple platforms Miss Knox so I'm not a data person I leave that up to Kim um but what I do agree with just from my personal
062experience and that of my daughter who's you know in this Middle School age is that how important it is to have opportunities outside of academics and how important it is to have rigorous um academic advising so I love that that is I agree with your conclusion even though I don't know if the data is right or not and leads us there um but my logic says that that this makes a lot of sense I and I really want to see it properly funded um and I would love to see us I you know capacity um to have more opportunities for students I think is is what I want to see at the end of the day from this thank you Miss Knox I think that's that that really leads to um one of the future
063updates that we're going to come to the board with and that is is really the critical nature of resource allocation or resource reallocation right as we think about how do we um deliver on the promise that is grounded in our strategic plan um in this case diploma uh plus the questions you've asked are anchored one in pillar one right cultivating excellence and equity in high quality teaching and learning then to uh Miss um Alonzo's question right we think about pillar five right cultivating Community collaboration and how do we make sure that we are being thoughtful to have a comprehens approach to achieve the desired outcomes here so um working with our Chief Financial Officer we are going to come to the board at least with a first year look at um what resources are we
064considering to make some pivots around Dr line I have a few questions the first one you know I I noticed as I look at this one of the things that stands out is that kids who work um don't have an opportunity to actually participate potentially in diploma plus can you um refute that right so if you are if you work after school and so um Athletics activities things like that are hard to achieve can you address a pathway forward for um those students who have to work absolutely so uh take for example our multidisciplinary pathway that includes AP classes CTE pathway courses uh or or college credits or four semesters of Fine Arts or participation in speech and debate or annual theater uh same holds true can you go back though for a minute I
065just just to push a little bit so theater and speech and debate those are those take place during the day during class time there are classes during the day yes okay thank you um silver cord uh volunteer service during the high school can occur uh both after school and uh within School times as well seala by literacy is one where uh the conditions by which students earn that would be occurring during the school day as well CTE concentrator completing four more semester long courses in a single CTE program with an A or a B the answer is yes exclamation mark we have Pathways right thank you for that um second uh thing that I would ask um I think there's a big bold Vision that students could graduate with their associates degree and I noticed
066that you are not holding up uh you hold up one year of college not two years of college and I'm wondering if there's a reason why uh I think I wouldn't I I would love for us to be moving forward with an associates degree I think it's a question of getting to the point where we get that first year uh as a habit under the belt first and then expanding out yeah and I would build on that Madam chair certainly that is a big part of our vision and it has to be we have a a growing Partnership if you may um with our uh Community College with dmac and some of our local universities um as we think about um just creating a a more sort of sophisticated diploma plus program ultimately and we
067don't have a timeline and we probably will build that in eventually we have to move towards um dual enrollment where students are going to graduate with a high school diploma and an associates degree we have a ple of models that we can pull from and build on um and I believe that we have right now if you ask me I I would say that we have uh teachers and leaders who are in place that can facilitate that we do not yet have the infrastructure and that will come as a result of getting diploma plus to a place where we can do that okay and my only ask is because there is there there are success stories of young people that have done it um last year I think I saw one uh that was able
068to achieve that and so I just hope but it only works if you get to them like in eighth grade and so I just hope we don't um I get we need the infrastructure but for those that are motivated I hope we're just making sure that that pathway is available you have a Believer here okay um the next one was you presented this I think to staff uh in some form or fashion or whether it's building leaders I think you've you've taken a little bit of a road show and I'm wondering what kind of feedback you've actually gotten from your colleagues so the High School principles it was incredibly gratifying um because they were excited by both the vision of what it could mean for their graduation rates but also the clarity of which uh
069you they felt like they could articulate to their students and families what those specific Pathways would look like I was equally gratified by the reception that we got with our Middle School principles our Middle School principles want to feel like they're part of the ultimate solution of our students getting on to graduate and go on to future success and they saw in uh what they were Hearing in the presentation uh exactly how they can play a vital role in queuing those students up for that success because all too often the conversation about what you expect when you get to high school often feels like the extent of the dialogue between that eth and nth Grand transition when instead that conversation can be about why don't we start making some strategic choices now that once when
070you get to high school you're going to be able to be queued up to have success in this way so I I have been enormously gratified by the reception that these uh presentations have received from those audiences great what do you think is the the one like the biggest challenge that you heard about in terms of implementation I think the biggest challenge is just making sure that we have Clarity of messaging among all of our stakeholders around what the what diploma plus is and what it isn't um and making sure that whether it is the success worker whether it's the principal whether it's the academic advisor whether it's the teacher that we've got universality in terms of being able to have a common language when it comes to uh not only what this is but
071how is it it is accessible to your point to multiple student audiences great and I think just to follow up and then I'll end which is I was looking at the Strategic plan because in it there's words there's life college career there's enroll employe inlist yes and I and I I would say it's been interesting I think I've gotten uh more feedback from people on the word enlist yes and so I just hope uh you know wondering to service national service count is part of enlist um I just hope as you're thinking about messages and communication that you'll um kind of come up with the themes that are clear for the general public to understand as a former Amor Corps participant myself that idea of service is something that is near and dear to me
072and yes we will work to make sure that we have Clarity around that messaging great thank you board members other questions great thank you so much thank you and Josie is it kayy that's online uh Bridget Bridget okay thank you Bridget as well let's see we are now going to move to the consent agenda and uh for our colleagues as a reminder there was a friendly Amendment on the consent agenda and that is that E1 is moving to other as a reminder to the board and public the board will not engage in discussion or deliberation with a speaker regarding comments made to agenda items discussion and deliberation will remain among board members at the board table with speakers comments informing the board's discussion deliberation and determinations as deemed necessary Miss Rios do we have any
073speakers no speakers Miss I believe you have the consent motion I sure do I move that the board approve the consent items in accordance with the recommended action for each item on the consent agenda including bills previously authorized certified and approved for payment by the board secretary in the amount of 2,980 n185 is there a second Marano second we have a motion by Miss Knox and a second by misss martarano any discussion or questions board members please cast your votes the consent items are approved 7 to0 we will move on to our other business the first item is E11 the early retirement program superintendent Roberts would you like to introduce the matter certainly thank you madam chair as a district uh one of the most important uh sort of aspects of the business that we
074take care of are uh includes how we support and value our people uh we are currently in a phase of um strategic planning and strategic plan and especially as I think about uh pillar number three of our strateg fiveyear strategic plan which is to uh cultivate uh uh sort of um transformational um Personnel um we realize that are a number of teammates who have over the years added tremendous value towards the accomplishment of the mission and the vision of the school system and um what is on top of mind for us is uh the consideration that while some of our teammates um have given years of service and are considering retirement uh we know that a big decision around retirement sometimes involves um people's uh Financial reality and um having consulted with some of uh
075my cabinet members I thought it that it would behoove us to consider um sort of offering an opportunity that allows many of our teammates um to sort of not only um exit the district if they so choose to retire with dignity but for us to show them how much we value them and while this comes at an additional cost to the district I thought it's it's prudent for us to offer this option historically we've offered this option of an early retirement incentive um to many of our teammates in ut positions at lower ranks and I think you know this is somewhat unprecedented that it we offer this uh retirement incentive to teammates who are in positions of leadership and so with that said I know that we also have a timeline within which uh we
076would have um those teammates who so choose to indicate that they want to take advantage of this and hence the reason for us bringing it forth to the board today for consideration um and quite frankly in the spirit of transparency that timeline is just about 45 days um we have until April 1st backwards map into 45 days and so if if the board so chooses uh uh we would come to you with just tremendous thanks and appreciation if we can have action on this item this evening great thank you prior to discussion may I have a motion and a second to approve this item KNX move second Mayberry Mays we have a motion by Miss Knox and a second by uh Dr Barry May any discussion or questions at this point I know that we
077um approved this is the revised version We approved the um previous version at our last meeting and the reason for me pulling it is I just didn't I was not able to review um the revised version prior to tonight's meeting because of the um upload so um I appreciate you thinking uh mentioning the financial um I didn't I didn't know what changes were made but the financial impact and sustainability of this um Miss Marano do you want uh Shashank just to take you quickly through the changes please great so the basic changes were under the benefit section which I had send as an email uh the the Bas the things that had changed was one of the offerings that was done was that whoever opts for the uh plan will be paid in two equal
078installments through the TSA and all these positions are already getting TSA at this point in time and they would be on the roles of the district till end of June so two equal installments was not feasible because then we pay them a portion for the last 6 months of this year equivalent there's a cap as per IRS and then that same amount the amount that will be paid next year will be much larger plus some of them we will not been able to pay them just in 2 years it'll be in 25 p 25 which is a smaller portion 26 and 27 so we wanted that option to be included the second thing was the policy was not very clear whether it was just health or was it health vision and dental so we wanted
079the clarity for the participants so they knew what they were going into here the Third change that we had done was in the form which the applicant had to sign there was a cash option whereas in the plan itself we had not mentioned anything about cash option the reason why we decided to eliminate it ex completely from the plan is because there'll be a tax cost both to the participant and to the district if you went with the cash option and historically we' have never given a cash option to to the staff so those are some of the major changes thank you thank board colleagues are other questions board members please cast your votes the the vote is approved 6 to Z next item is F1 school budget review committee sbrc requests for modified supplemental
080amount for abatement projects Dr Roberts please introduce the matter thank you madam chair most certainly I recommend that the board approve the requests and Exhibits as presented for a hearing with the S BRC for modified supplemental amount of 8,555 187 for as bestos basement abatement projects During the period of July 1 2023 through June 30 2024 that were paid for using general fund dollars may I have a motion and a second to approve this item Ranos so moved KNX second we have a motion by Miss Marano and a second by Miss Knox any discussion or questions board members please cast your votes the vote is approved 6 to zero next item is F2 by the way I should have clarified on E11 the vote was 6 to zero with one exstension thank you uh next
081item on F2 request for school budget Review Committee for special education administrative costs so superintendent Roberts would you please introduce the matter yes Madam chair I recommend that the board approve the application to the school budget Review Committee in the am in the amount of $379,800 for special education administrative cost Associated for the 2025 2026 school year may have a motion and a second to approve this item martarano so moved than we have a motion by Miss martarano and a second by Mr dicks any discussion or questions board members please cast your votes it's not working there we go the vote is approved 6 to zero next item is F3 requests to the school budget Review Committee for modified allowable growth for special education administrative costs superintendant Roberts would you please introduce the matter yes
082Madam chair I recommend that the board approve the request to the school board Review Committee for modified allowable growth in the amount of $2,229 58 cents for special education administrative costs associated with River Hills Consortium program for fiscal year 2025 may have a motion and a second to approve this item martarano move Dix second we have a motion by Miss martarano and a second by Mr Dix is there any discussion or questions board members please cast your votes the vote is is approved 6 to0 next item is F4 Personnel recommendation receive and file an action Dr Roberts would you please introduce the matter certainly Madam chair I recommend that the board receive file and approve the termination of the contracts for reasons stated forth in the superintendent's notices may have a motion and a second
083to approve this item alono moved we have a go ahead second dick second we have a motion by Miss Alonzo and a second by Mr dicks is there any discussion questions board members please cast your votes next on the agenda is information only the dmps foundation minute meeting minutes from January 2025 are provided we now move to items of privilege uh I would like to ask if our board members would like to share anything I would like to invite everyone to participate in the community legislative action team meeting on February 15th it'll be held at Mitchell Early Learning Center um Kristen roor our director of Early Childhood um education will be there along with Ian Roberts and many of our legislators to discuss um our preschool initiatives and legislative action or Focus for this year
084and that is at 9 a.m. yes I'd like to invite everyone to the build Lincoln higher 8th Annual maroon and gold Gaya this is a fundraiser for Lincoln High School that happens each year and uh tickets are still available in the Gaya will take place on Saturday February 22nd and they are excited to bring people to the South side and get excited about Lincoln High School um I would like to say thank you uh to all staff um admin everyone working in the district um who have been so supportive um of families um immigrant and Refugee families in our community um that are being very much affect Ed by Uh current recent and current events um know that your wordss are very impactful and so thank you for thank you for that this is the
085last call for tickets for the dmps foundation dinner and Kaye informed me we're $750 away away from $100,000 so come on people um it's going to be a fantastic night again it is February 13th um please go to the dmps foundation website to learn more we're excited to celebrate our entire district and our talented students um and we would love everyone to join us so thank you I think I'll just close by actually saying thank you to all of my board members my board colleagues and superintendent as I look around the country and I look around the state and I think about the rhetoric uh the partisan rhetoric uh that is all around us I want to say how grateful I am that we are um able to have civilized conversations we don't always agree
086but our disagreements are more on process than they are on anything else and so thank you very much I think uh I hope that um we should continue to hold ourselves up as a model for the rest of the State uh to have um civil productive Forward Thinking conversations so thank you for that uh Dr Roberts I'm going to turn it over to you for your report thank you madam shair uh card G Woodson is noted to have proposed that those of us who occupy the soils in the United States of America acknowled and celebrate the amazing accomplishments of individuals who are descendants of slaves who are black who are afro-americans whove often gone overlooked and negro history week certainly was the impetus for eventual 1976 I believe approval by President Ford the first African
087American History Month there is no question that one month is never enough to celebrate the outstanding and amazing and often underlook accomplishments of those of us from the diaspora whose descendants and ancestors did not come to these lands willingly but were brought here in enslavement and while every single day and every week every month and every year there are moments and opportunities for us to celebrate no more than ever given our current political climate where so much has been removed discontinued and ignored with the strike of a pen I want to encourage you to join us in celebrating the 2025 Black History Month there are a number of outstanding activities happening in all of our schools our elementary schools our students are honoring and celebrating so many individuals of African descent who have done great
088work and many of whom are residing in this city today and so I want to encourage you to find where there are moments and opportunities in our schools to celebrate with our young people go read with them to them and show them your support additionally February is an important month as well for this board in the school system thank you board member kns for highlighting and sharing the soon the upcoming uh Foundation dinner on February 13th looking forward to that and certainly on February 11th two days prior we will have our annual state of the schools address where uh our board share will share remarks which includes a celebration of so many outstanding accomplishments in the district that will be followed by remarks and sharing as well from yours truly as I talk about the
089vision that we have for de Mo public schools that will be anchored in our 5-year strategic plan at this year state of the schools address we are going to roll out out in detail and add some granularity to our remagine education plan where we will talk about the vision for the district over the next 10 years you don't want to miss it you want to be there our Communications and marketing team will also have some goodies and treats for you that you will want to have it's a Once in a-lifetime opportunity to have some of the trinkets I say that because it includes a hard copy of our strategic plan but we welcome you to come and join us we looking forward to that so two really big and important events February 11th at North
090High School go polar beers thank you for your hospitality and then on the 13 the foundation dinner thank you madam shair that conclud Dr Roberts just to clarify U it will be online uh the the the February 11th event if people can't make it in person and uh you'll ALS be rolling out a series of community sessions where the community can listen to the presentation and learn more is that right that is accurate Madam thank you for that REM reminder yes great well thank you everybody for joining this evening we really appreciate you being here the meeting is adjourned at 657 uh the board will take a brief break and move into a open work session to discuss governance board governance followed by a closed session on Personnel uh board colleagues if we can re
091reconvene no later than 705 that would be great thank you e e e on your uh board colleagues we are going to get started with the work session I do I have 10 can you add I have 10 nobody wants it nobody wants what no wants it you get 10 other people that you can add when you have the card you pay the annual fee oh yeah other people to go uh all right Miss Alonzo to get my credit C yes you get this is why now I remember why we didn't do it for people who are that's totally one okay all right you two you chit Chatters you can you can cover that afterwards uh so uh it is 707 and uh I think um you know I think the time limit is an
092hour Max and what I want to do is first of all call your attention Rosie has given you two handouts one is an agenda and one is uh an Excel spreadsheet that looks like this that is the feedback that was uh provided by all of you uh just the other um day it's also emailed to you so for those of you that would rather just see it thank you so much see it um on your computer you can do that as well so uh as Skylar and I talked about this and um Kim and I had a brief conversation about this as well uh I I tried to think about how we can continue to advance our conversation about board governance uh which is something that people have EXP rest interest in and I identifi
093these goals uh one of the goals is we do have uh our current partnership with Council of great City Schools there are two contracts that are going to be coming up for approval by the board and I think there's a little bit of history as well that all board members may not have and so I thought it would be a good time just to talk about the contracts uh and the resources available um the second thing was um we also heard in our last uh you know Retreat that we wanted to talk a little bit about how the governance model might better align Theory with board intent the third was identify the support we need uh whether it's Council of great City Schools or other support needs and then the final was uh to discuss
094the goals and guard rails in the context of the Strategic plan this is the first time we've had a strategic plan and so it's a it's just a really interesting question about um what is what what do goals in guardrail look like in the context of a strategic plan and I think it was great that um Josie and others showed how the goals and guardrails aligned with the the Strategic plan so how do people feel about those goals and does anybody want to add any goals to the to the list okay so uh just a little bit of background and I'm actually going to ask us to crowdsource this one uh and Miss Marano may put some pressure on you because of your history uh longest history on the board um but just so people
095understand there are two uh contracts uh that we have with Council of great City Schools one is membership and one is coaching and so uh the membership uh I'd love for you miss Morano if you're comfortable just talking a little bit about the membership uh and at a high level what and then I'll also share what we've heard from Dr Roberts and Shashank and others about the benefits of membership De Moine has been a member of the Council of the great City Schools um and is a member of the council because of um we are the largest school district in the state um so there are different ways that you can qualify to be a member of the council it's either based on you being the largest distri in your state or having a student
096population of 35,000 students or higher um and the council provides to us resources that are very specific to school districts of uh large Urban Public Schools um we have unique challenges that many of our um fellow Iowa school districts do not face and so it really gives a Consortium of of just incredible knowledge and talent not only at the superintendent level but um CEO level uh technology level curriculum and instruction uh we have we have um task force task forces I guess um that focus on um black and Latino male achievement and we have another task force that focuses on black and Latino female uh achievement we have task force that focus on um governance policy and legislation um I'm missing another one but um the the focuses that um the council offer is really
097um helping provide the largest school districts in the country the resources that they need in order to improve student outcome across the country um and I believe that it that our membership is invaluable that was a great overview and I think I speak for Dr Roberts and Shashank and Josie and there's a few others who've said that they really appreciate the peer Network that this brings and the data comparisons um which I think are I don't know if you can um access them online but they're provided annually so you're able to look at other districts and make comparisons as well so yes that is correct um the other task force that I forgot to mention were our English multilingual Learners um and focusing on their achievement as well um so yeah anything else with that
098just high level you did and and so now what I'm going to try and do is also then talk about the oh thank you um is the so the second contract is a coaching contract and um the the coaching contract and the membership are linked but they are separate contracts and so uh Miss Marano can you because you took the board through the history can you talk about the linkage between the two um the Professional Services agreement that we've entered into um is to receive governance coaching specifically and it was a 2-year contract we we pay uh an annual membership to be um members of the Council of great City Schools um and but this professional service agreement that we have entered into is to receive that um coaching regarding our student outcomes Focus governance
099so we are at the end of that two years um the council do you want me to go into the voting and thing okay um the professional service agreement that the council provides um has a different price if it is a unanimous vote versus uh a non-unanimous vote by the board um so if we vote 70 to accept the Professional Services agreement which we did when we accepted it it is at a lower um more affordable cost to the district to enter into that contract whereas if um we are not in agreement as a board um but do have majority toenter enter into that contract the cost does increase I um do not have those exact costs in front of me but it is something to be aware of that um the the council and
100the coaching teams recognize that if all Bo board member board members are wanting to engage in coaching that the process looks different than if some board members want to engage in coaching and others do not or are not willing to engage in that coaching so that is the reason for that that price difference the resources that are allocated to boards um that don't have a unanimous vote looks different than those that have a unanimous vote great thank you for representing that and um if you want to see the contracts um I mean obviously they'll be on consent but we can circulate them ahead of time if people want to read it and and I just share that so you have some context um into into this um and and Kim doesn't know I'm going to
101ask her this but I'm going to put you on the spot can you just maybe talk about the the history of dmps and Council of great City Schools meaning the evolution to the point with which we signed on to the contract oh oh well where do I begin um I at a very high level there was um a team of individuals that came together to to engage in research and creation of what is now the student outcomes Focus government governance sorry um process we had a previous board member that was on that team um and we affectionately referred to it as team Rogue um so a previous board member was is a a founding um member of Team Rogue and helped create student outcomes focused governance so in 2018 when the De Moine um School
102Board started to engage in this governance model um we did not enter into a contract contract because we were one of the first districts um in the country to do so so the coaching that we received was all pro bono per se from the council um and AJ and team so we have only entered into this contract I believe one time okay um so we've only paid for services um for for one length of the contract so we've been receiving Services since 2018 I believe I I would have to go to a historian no um I believe 201 18 but um have only been been um have entered into a contract with the council since 2023 but have been receiving coaching Services since 2018 and and pay for but we have paid expenses we've paid
103travel expenses for coaches to be here on site yes that is correct um so in 2019 the board engaged in their first Community engagement in Outreach process they wrote their first goals um or student expectations as they were called then and um management limitations um and I will say the board prior to that engaged in policy governance so it it's a little bit different but um um so yes the we engaged in the council work back in 2018 uh 2019 great thank you for doing that does anybody have questions Miss campus um I do um going back to the task force that you're talking about we're paying into that are we actively using that we are um and maybe Dr Roberts can speak more to this um um with regards to what team members are
104utilizing what um services that the council provides I know that Shashank engages um with the council work I know that Josie engages with the council work I think Ian does as well but um I don't know if our elll team um is engaging in that research thank you board M moano yes uh certain to Echo um the information that you just shared um the some of our executive tactical cabinet members see value in the RO alike convenience and so um our CFO convenience I know that that's one that he utilizes um our director of data assessment evaluation uh she also finds value in and participates in that and of course I have attended uh the annual fall conference where many of my superintendent peers and I have seen value in just um engaging I think
105that's the extent to which I would say that um I have committed some time and engagement Y is that responsive uh okay so with that background uh I think what as Skyler and I talked what we wanted to do was based on some earlier feedback you gave which is a little bit of exploration around a conversation around our board governance model and so the four questions that we laid out um the first one was what information gaps do you have with student outcomes Focus governance what do you still need to learn about the model the second was uh what do you appreciate about student outcomes Focus governance the third what do you struggle with with in the student outcomes Focus governance model and then the last if you could make two changes to improve the
106governance model what would they be so those are the four questions that we laid out I'm wondering if it would benefit us to just take five minutes of quiet reading time because I just shared this this afternoon would that be valuable to everybody I've read it already you've read it already have people read it okay um so I guess uh you know um I want to be careful not to summarize um so maybe with this first question right so information gaps maybe the question I want to ask is do you see any themes are there any themes you're identifying in information gaps that you'd want to call out and as a reminder there's two pages I I do think in a point was brought up that I did not make myself but that I would
107support in that is that I I do think it's appropriate for this board to ask for um and to get a sense of where this model is being used and its success rate and so um every district is different um but to what extent is it being used successfully I think is a question that I would that I would have that I still don't understand yeah I appreciate you calling that as a theme because I think that came up multiple times um what other themes did people see in information gaps that they might want to call out I think the other one contrary is uh that it seems like people understand the model which is good U but understanding it and recognizing the success of it are very different M chair I would just ask
108like just for a a discussion Point even from my colleagues I think all of many of us have said we understand it I would add to that that I believe that this model's heart is in the right place so I don't I don't think anybody thinks that this is a bad uh idea um so our struggles with it I don't think I I guess I would just call out that I I see the benefit um not only understand it but see the benefit I'm going to uh play contrarian just so it doesn't always have to be one person at the board table which is there's a couple people that have said I understand the model and um I was one and I read the book okay thank you so um and yet I I've heard
109some feedback that you know board has not sat through a two-day training that um you know we we haven't been open into the coaching uh Etc so I just I want to share that because I do think that um understanding of the model uh maybe um there's different depths of what it means to understand the model so we'll just kind of keep moving forward unless people have things to say let's talk about what we appreciate and and Patrick I really appreciate you saying that because there were a lot of people who I think really talked about the idea of goals the idea that they're measurable the idea that there's uh boundaries that there's accountability um that it's Public public facing uh monitoring transparency I mean those those are a lot of themes uh and I
110I think that's really good because what what that says is kind of what you said Patrick which is like people respect the structure respect having having some form of policy governance in place other other themes or things that people would want to call out in terms of what they appreciate well it is a governance model and so I think we all believe governance is important I I would also say I think um it made me appreciate the Strategic plan a lot more cuz it feels like the thing that was the light bulb didn't go on for me until we had a strategic plan that articulated something that we could center around this was at least something that this board could center around um in a specific way uh and so we'll get to the what
111do you struggle with later but I think that's the thing that this this did for me was going back to the so what you know like what what are we going to do what are we going to Center our conversations around and so the outcomes focused of the the governance model is um I think really admirable I would add to that and say maybe it's duplicative but I think sofg gave us a North star to look towards um and I think at the time before having a strategic plan like you mentioned you don't know what the North Star is until it's defined so this gave us three North Stars and to say these are the things we're aspiring for as a district um and like I say that pre- strategic plan and I think it
112was also commented that the appreciation is that it's focused and grounded in students I don't think there was consensus that that's all it should be but the idea that was called out that this is about students and their student goals was also mentioned here let's move to struggles uh and again I'm just trying to kind of bring us through the summary so we can have a conversation I want to elaborate on my governance comment cuz I feel like that was shallow but honestly it is important and what I think I think it did set good it does set good boundaries for us and I think um that is important and not everyone follows that you know as to the level of which we attempt we have attempted over the years to hold ourselves accountable and
113really live um modeling uh positive good adult behaviors for our district and I so I do appreciate and think that's a benefit that should be recognized in what we've been able to do so far in this model yeah and if you ever watch um really old Schoolboard meetings let me tell you you really appreciate um governance okay because I do that for fun on Friday nights I guess I don't know um okay so um what do you struggle with you should do it together yes exactly and have like a like a a bingo like a drinking bingo game okay moving on the thing I struggle with not in a strategic plan yes no the thing I struggle with is um and I always have with this model is I feel like this is where we
114want to be is discussing going from 89% of kids being able to read to 95% of kids being able to read and really focusing down in on that where I feel like there are some very structural cultural struggles and hurdles that we have as a district right now that the um specific nature of sof FG doesn't allow the board the freedom to get at in a in a um more strategic way and be a thought leader with with the superintendent and so um I think this is a great model for when you have to go from when you have to go a small distance we have a larger distance to go as a district and um and so I that's where I struggle is and that's where I feel like we are held back I
115appreciate the specific nature of only talking about a very small group of students and understand the the reasoning behind it I feel like it leaves so much on the table that our community looks at us and goes what are you doing there's all this other stuff it's like uh the building is on fire and we're worried about the chair you know and and I think that's that's really where I have always struggled with this is that it's a good model it just um it's not where we are right now and and um I think this board can in particular get to the larger struct larger structural systemic issues um in our district to improve it and set it on a better path other themes people saw in the struggle column I have two U one
116is it not not being able to tell the broader story of successes um I think it and I know we've pivoted a bit away from it even when when goals are on track we put them on a consent agenda and just approve it and we've kind of gotten to a point where we're saying no we want to start highlighting the fact that we're actually doing things well and we're pulling it from consenter we're talking about it but it's not necessarily and I'm someone who probably does not fully understand sofg but from what it seems like is that is not what we should be doing it should be on cons we should be approving it and moving forward not spending a lot of time on it and I I do think there's value in talking about
117the things that are going well um we have to control The Narrative of the district as well and and share our story about what's going well in this district and this model has not organically allowed for that other themes I see words like rigidity um I'm trying to way too rigid uh responsibility should be broader and I think Patrick this is a little bit like you know this is Corporate but um ensuring accountability to shareholders so just say the community um setting values exercising accountability focus on Direction and oversight of strategy risk opportunity management sustainability talent management so more of the typical some of the more typical uh board uh corporate board governance um issues U other I didn't write this but I I want to say it I think I said it in front
118of Dr Roberts and Skyler once which is I actually find the monitoring reports incredibly intimidating because I actually don't feel I have any expertise to offer to the conversation uh I um sure I taught right I mean I'm a parent but the idea that I would be able to ask questions of Dr Roberts it just feels off for me and that's just a personal feeling um because you know I'm not shy and I'm comfortable to say I'm holding it back yeah so I'm I'm not you know I'm pretty comfortable uh but I find that very uncomfortable so um and and I don't know how you change that but that's just my just my personal struggle um on sometimes the monitoring I think Jackie to that point uh I think that was shared by one of
119the coaches in the past that you know the the monitoring report should be delivered in a sixth grade comprehensive man comprehensive manner U so I know that's kind of the intent behind it but the things that we're measuring are not sixth grade conversations or sixth grade topics to measure so talking about something in a sixth grade manner that um most people wouldn't even I mean I had to go and look up what the ISS exam even was you can't imagine a sixth grader to know that um so even the way in which we deliver it I think even if we were getting to a point where it's the expectation through the coaching um it would still be a bit of a struggle our sixth graders know what ice ASP is yeah which sixth graders they're
120familiar with it all of [Laughter] them I have um I'm so glad we're having this conversation so glad um I think it might have been the second year and it was at the East Auditorium I believe remember that and that was Dr Robert's first I I was just concerned with the rigidity and I was one of the people that indicated um that's one of the things that I think I struggle with the most uh it feels rigid it doesn't feel natural uh it it and I expressed at that meeting that it it seemed it felt like it was a framework that was meant to quiet people down and I remember stating that and I remember our facilitator kind of going away from my comment and it was almost like a confirmation to me that I
121was not um wrong um and I I definitely see I also comment Ed that I appreciate that it serves as an anchor for us it gives us truly uh a sense of direction the North Star right which is soon outcomes but nowadays in 2025 student outcomes I think it just encompasses so much and it feels like the framework quiets down um a piece that is so vital in student outcomes which is family people um it seems very it it does feel intimidating and so I I value personally um people being able to understand what we're talking about but I also think it's so important for us to allow ourselves to ask questions even though they might not be stated maybe correctly and not feel ashamed because I have felt ashamed of asking questions and and
122then I'm like I'm just going to look down because I don't even know that I said that right but I I already said it and like shame on Maria because she did it again and it just it takes away from what we're really doing um what the focus should be and so I believe that it's a it's a good framework if we use it to do what we know is right in our district in 2025 um considering all things that are going on today you know how does the framework um allow for us to be able to talk about these things because even mentioning was going on today feels like it shouldn't really be discussed because it's not student focused and so redefining finding ways to utilize the framework to our benefit and to the
123benefit of our students and families is what I would like to see happen I really appreciate your comments thank you Maria I also want to be sure that we're being true to sofg and and potentially also saying out loud maybe we're not doing it right and so um at the risk of putting you on the spot Miss Marano um if you're comfortable do you have any I just want to make sure that we are you know really being thoughtful about the conversation to understand is it possible Right to to have what we want and what we're asking for in the context of as of sofg and then the last thing I was going to say is Dr Roberts if you want to participate you know you're welcome to participate but Kim should we have Kim
124go first that's okay um I have so much to say student outcomes Focus governance is a framework it is a framework that was developed based on research um it is a framework that was developed based on what we know works this framework is a lot like our guard rails where um it is it was created with that research in mind this research tells us by engaging in a b and c you have the highest likelihood as a board of achieving improved outcomes so that's that's at a very high level what this is if the board does this all of the research and the data from boards before us that have done this um if you do all of these things based on best practice recommendations based on the research based on the data you will
125have a higher likelihood of achieving student your the goals that you have set forth Kim can I that framework sorry I was just going to ask on that point because a couple of people brought out like where is it working and wanting examples and you talked about research so can you just at some point address that piece like where our examples where it's working or I thought we were the first right didn't you say we were the first to have this framework in 2018 we were one of the first districts that um engaged in this um there were districts that were doing it so this this particular framework um is not the first of its kind it was Lone Star governance is a a form of student outcomes Focus governance um Lone Star governance has
126been in place much longer than student outcomes focused governance so there are districts in Texas and the state of Texas actually requires that um school districts engage in this work um I I do have districts where this is successful and I can share those I have not shared those in the past um because I am not this District's coach um our coach should be providing those to you um but I have those and can certainly share those with you um a framework is not a you have to do this and you cannot do this a framework is a here are things that are proven to show success make it and do with it what you want there's a self- evaluation that looks at the six different portions of this framework where the board engages in
127a an evaluation of what is it that we are doing to actually move the needle forward on behalf of the students that we serve um we as a board have historically scored um below 30 points out of 100 and I know that many of us have sat in those self- evaluation conversations and have felt frustrated and demoralized because we're getting zeros we're getting one we're getting a zero we're getting a one we're getting zero points but ultimately um you know we have chosen as a board to not engage in what the framework best practice recommendations are we don't have to we don't have to engage in those things as they're written they are in fact just you know recommendations that are going to move the the needle forward for our students so um is there
128a place where we can engage in student outcomes Focus governance and also do the things that we want um Miss Morano um AJ texted Rosie and said that he's on oh um AJ I think I think I want to make sure we stay to our time limit so but AJ do you w to maybe speak to this question I think yeah question Madam chair well you just texted Rosie the current questions aren't fair for Miss Marano to answer so maybe that that what's working yeah what she was saying is she yeah she was saying she's not the board coach and I would certainly agree that more helpful to have someone not on the board try to answer those questions um and so if the board is interested um in connecting with some of your colleagues
129who have been doing this work uh for a while in other districts um and asking for them their opinion I think you probably find more valuable visiting with value visiting with some of your colleagues um than hearing it forb and so I'm happy to uh connect those guys for folks to have that conversation yeah I just just a followup on that I think it's it's actually just like demonstrated results right so I don't even know if it's the conversations with sofg Schoolboard members it's more just like where's the evidence that it works AJ I'm just trying to I'm looking at head nods and so I think that's that's what's being looked for specifically in the the feedback so and that's what I'm saying is there are districts who um the board members they're you can
130ask them for yourselves but they would say we deployed this and this helped us move the needle for our students and so uh I'm happy to connect you with however many U different districts in the council that you're interested in uh to have that conversation but um it's it is not for I I can't speak for them it' be stronger for you um if you heard it from them directly to say this is exactly what our board did and this is the result we got and yes I'm very happy to connect you with um is bidy different boards in the council that or outside of the council even um that you all would be interested in yeah AJ just to follow up this is Jenna there and I think one of the other question was
131around data and having data just curious is there data that exists within um Council of great City schools on the impact of this governance model to achieving goals um with the council no uh with this framework yes and that's in the Texas is that the Texas model yes it would be really helpful to see that I think the same way we hold ourselves accountable in the monitoring sessions um qualitative data certainly is beneficial but I'd love to see the the quantitative data as well on the successes of this um yes and I'm I'm with you on that I'm happy to connect you all with your colleagues but I'm I'm certainly typically more persuaded by data and evidence um and so there are multiple districts where the growth in student performance they've had is um very
132compelling um the analysis from districts across Tex as it did this uh the short version of it and I'll gladly um email you the uh study though it's also in the manual in the research section of the manual uh you'll find it in there as well um but the the study that points to um essentially boards that were doing this work um and uh with Fidelity um actually we're more likely to see their students grow twice as fast as student as the boards who are not doing this work is it simply what the research B out thanks AJ sorry S one more comic because I I feel like I continue to hear even from the board sometimes just you know it's a framework we we use the parts it that work for us and my
133question is if if you're only using parts of something that work for you why stay committed to the entirety we can come up with our own governance model for taking parts that work why why so a I'd love to maybe just your thoughts on that if you're only if we're only going to use parts that work and maybe the parts that work are we want to have guard rails for example or the parts that work are we want to have a public monitoring progress or process and and maybe I should clarify I think think when I was saying we can we can make it work for us I think if we want to monitor um additional guard rails if we want to monitor um the effectiveness of HR like let's write a guard rail that
134that allows us to monitor it and the superintendent knows that he'll be evaluated on it and we know at the Cadence at which it's going to be monitored so I probably when I did not I'm probably mincing my words a little bit but I'm not saying take take goals and let's keep that because it's working and not do any of the other things I'm saying let's let's not abide strictly by only having five guard rails let's have the number of guard rails that is going to give us the Comfort or the um the ability to monitor the things that we're worried about that are more operational or um when it comes to monitoring and asking the questions can we ask any question we want we can um during monitoring um and I'm I'm disheartened to
135hear and I hear and I recognize that that the feelings of feeling um I'm sorry Maria I don't recall the word that you scolded or um umam maybe ashamed was the word that you used and that that um that hit hard when you said that and that this is not this this governance model is is about continuous Improvement and is about never having anyone feel ashamed so I'm I hear that you have felt that way and I think that we need to do everything in our power as a board to never have any anyone at this table feel that way um can I because I think there's two things that I love to get feedback on one is something that can just surface which is about evolving goals and guardrails right so so that's one
136thing that I think is really important um the second thing is we've talked a lot about the monitoring process and how it feels and it feels intimidating or you know restrictive um Dr arbert I'm going to put you on the spot if you don't mind as it relates to the monitoring process potentially maybe that's a just to give some feedback on how it feels for you the monitoring process or um really quite honestly I should just say are there things you want to say I'll just make it more broad uh so you can say what you want to say just with some brevity thank you um I appreciate what appears to be um the spirit of the the model and that is for us to um anchor what 100% of our approach to to governance
137in student outcomes um it offers um somewhat of a very strong guard rail to ensure that um the the board uh right continues to at the risk of an oversimplification to keep the main thing the main thing right why are you here and the board is here uh to ensure that we are relentlessly focused on student outcomes um the during my time uh uh certainly leading a district that is a part of um that is utilized in the framework um I I I continue to have a little bit of an appetite for there to be some flexibility in how monitoring happens um and I can be certainly specific one I don't know if it's the framework or the execution of um I struggle with uh uh what appears to be my direct report uh uh
138feeling uh deflated beaten down um heavily criticized on a very narrow scope of work or scope of items that being monit monitored when while I recognize that we are so far away from our our desired outcome of getting um to 100% of our students achieving proficiency um I go back to the district on many occasions after monitoring uh board meetings and um throughout the district folks are feeling just deflated right when what is not being highlighted there's so many amazing things happening in the district and again I I say say that in this place of acknowledging this duality of yes we're now where we need to be but there's so much happening I mean you walk into classrooms and you're seeing the work and other thing for us to consider is um where are there
139opportunities for flexibility with a model but that keeps the spirit of the the framework but that keeps the spirit of the framework um so that's the question where are the opportunities for flexibility but you maintaining the spirit of the framework y Dr robers if you don't mind I think something you just said which is the first comment I'd love for um AJ to address which is I mean these are all urban districts clearly struggling with some really big issues and student outcomes um is there a form of monitoring that actually um doesn't leave you know sta staff feeling deflated uh maybe just talk a little bit about um where execution maybe looks different um or if the point is to be that yeah I'll just stop there yeah thank you for the question the intention
140of monitoring is certainly to make sure that the board is at all times clear about how the school system is performing and that's both on the um student learning side with the goals and the operational side with the guard rils uh the board as the community's representative should never be without information about this school systems performance and that information needs to be grounded in what the board has said are the priorities um and there needs to be firm data that everyone is coming back to um and so that is the expectation and we're fairly Unapologetic about that but we also don't see that as being synonymous with folks feeling beaten down in fact as I watch other districts having monitoring um it's much more Sal you know one of the comments that was made earlier
141was that um you all were told to put um goals on the consent agenda uh we literally never uh want people to put their goals on the consent agenda uh we always want the board to discuss its goals and to have celebration around what's happening with him in other districts um they've leaned into a practice um that I certainly encourage you all to lean into very heavily which is for every goal monitoring session bring out your students who are showing growth in those areas this doesn't have to be a durge where we're just focused on on what's not working it can also be a celebration of here where students are growing in this area and certainly we have more path to go um but but we lift up what's working and we rally around that
142and so that's the energy that I see in monitoring in other places and that I I would I wish for you all as well I want to keep the conversation going um I don't I don't want to cut it short but I'm I'm trying to think through where to go next and and yeah go ahead so so maybe as as I'm thinking about this conversation um I don't think anyone on the board would say that um they think that we execute this perfectly so we we know that we're not doing it right for um use of a better term how ever um it occurs to me that with a better strategic plan that's anchored in data and that really does follow the the community feedback that we got uh with preschool with um um the
143change in the junior high uh structure and with our career focused outcomes we are we then have some specific goals that are sort of subsets of those and guard rails that are subsets of those and so I wonder with um a better strategic plan articulated will we now have the language to better monitor ourselves not just on those very specific goals but on the concepts around them and moving the resources to where they need to be because now I feel like I've got the bigger macro pieces preschol school to go along with reading third grade and connecting the dots in a bigger way so that we can be a little bit more strategic so I don't know Dr Roberts maybe does the does the Strategic plan help you think about it differently it certainly it
144certainly does and cert you know Madam chair and I had just a quick sidebar um around now that we have the Strategic plan in place when will we have Matrix that speaks to or in the case if I use a language of the plan um when will we have those key results that sort of shows how are we doing on a specific strategic action or how do we make sure we're aligning those strategic actions to our strategic objectives which then again if you're backwards mapping shoots up to the the big pillar um one of the things that I know we are going to do and the team is starting to work in this is to make sure that we are aligning or doing a crosswalk between our goals and guard rails um to our actions
145that are and and key results with the Strategic plan so that it will certainly provide us with a lot more clarity right um around daily actions so just I want to ask AJ a followup so when if if if I said to you we've got a strategic plan there's annual Target set why it was it was presented by the superintendent but the board established the kind of vision the mission and I think because because we were interviewed you could say like kind of outlined what we thought were some key priorities uh what would you say if we said why don't we just use the Strategic plan with some monitoring like what what would be the argument I don't say against that but what would you say to that because I'm sure other schools have strategic
146plans yeah so the the the point you're making is well made that the single most important thing that a lot of the research around this is trying to accomplish is organizational alignment so when you really dig into the research behind this work and uh and similar governance researchers across the country one of the things they're lifting up is when organizations get really clear about what are the outcomes really clear about which outputs measure those and really clear about which inputs will accomplish those and and everyone's in the canoe rowing the same direction that you're vastly more likely get results for students and so the biggest thing that uh we would hope any board is accomplishing is creating that organizational alignment so um but the but it does have to be grounded in a clear Northstar
147and that North Star needs to be the Community Vision and values uh first and foremost it's the Community Schools Community children um and so the community's voice has to be preeminent and so as long as you can find a way to accomplish the community's voice saying what has to be true for our school system and what would be unacceptable because it be a violation of our values and then you create a system of alignment the Cascades down from that then you are really in good stead with what the research literature suggest so the challenge with many strategic plans is that if they aren't grounded in the board's leadership of saying here's what the vision of values of our community is then they aren't starting from the Bedrock um and so it is ABS this is
148not the only way to execute the research but that is the intention of the research and so if you found a way to get there um then you'd be consistent with what research says um just most strategic plans don't start with that Bedrock Foundation that's all and and I think AJ I go back to the first thing that I ever heard you say which is student outcomes don't change until adult behaviors change and and the light bulb that sort of just went on for me as I'm looking out at some of our colleagues that are still here is I think most of us walked away from our monitoring reports with good sound goals that were based on community feedback not knowing how it was all connected not knowing like I'm rowing my or over here
149but is the person up there why is their roow matter or and what are they doing I feel like the Strategic plan has connected all of that together and I can articulate a vision of a preschool through High School outcome that our community has articulated and that we are going to try to honor through our actions that's the Strategic plan but I think beforehand we do our monitoring reports and everybody it felt very disconnected they were based on all of the rules but there was not a larger Vision that went with it and and maybe that's the thing that that is sort of um revealing about this discussion for me is it's the Strategic plan that makes it work for me it's based on all the things that AJ just said it we have data
150to to Monitor and to hold people accountable and it's based off the Community Vision but more than anything it has a chance in my mind of connecting from beginning to end a better outcome for a kid who starts in preschool and wants to graduate high school in De Moine assuming there's resource alignment right and I think that's a big that's on us then yeah so um I want to I really want to stay true to time limits and so I'm going to go around the table and I'm going to ask this question where should we go next what would be a good Next Step um Dr Roberts has shared that you know I'm going to put words in your mouth but the Strategic plan is done the kpis or the the the metrics will be
151done in June and and ideally key um key priorities that need funding are going to come before the board this year like for instance the conversation that we just had about goal three potentially correct so um so where where do we go next I'm going to sound like a broken record but this Board needs to engage in two full days of professional development back to back around this model before we can even begin to make a decision on so much of what we've discussed tonight I'm just I'm hearing um questions and things that are not clear for individuals AC around this table and um I I just think that having a a clear understanding of the framework at at a very foundational level is what we need to do before making any future decisions I
152need my board colleagues to engage in that for a comment I I don't want for that to always be our excuse I feel like that's been the excuse I've heard every single time about why we're not making progress with this framework is because we're not engaging in in the governance now this is my first time on Schoolboard but I've served on a lot of boards and I've never had to do a multi-day training when we have a coach when I read the book when I sat through a training initially to be able to effectively govern I feel like we're we're being asked a lot to simply just want the best for our students so I I I I am am not okay with moving forward that way and the fact that that is often the
153response that you just need more training I'm not okay with than Skyler other feedback um the the simple question that we've asked Patrick and I from last year was like this feedback of where is it going good um and still the conversation today is like yeah we could get that information for you but that's something that we should do so uh I'll take initiative and I'll do some research myself and see what's the other school boards are doing because I feel like we're not getting that information that we're asking for and it's just a Le thing is it going well in other school districts or even even talk I think it it's it's good for us to talk to other school districts are in the same path that we are like we do communicate with
154other school members in the iow in Iowa's School System um and with this Council of Gros schools I've not really met anybody else that's in it and that's in our same you know what we're going through right now as a larger District uh so for it to be said that yeah you guys could do it on your own practically then I'm just going to take it and and look up some stuff on my own other kind of Next Step feedback I it's it's a model and I think that we all are already familiar we don't know it I don't know it by heart and I admire your brain for it Kim um because you you you have to teach it you have to know it and you have to believe in it um I I
155think that we all have been using the model enough to know whether or not it's making the difference in our district that we want to see and we as a district or as a board need a governance right we need a structure we need a framework and if we believe that this framework can give us what we need to reach what we need to reach for students to see get to their goals then I say we keep the framework but we make make it flexible we work with it and we decide what we want to do with it unless that's not doable other comments on kind of next I just want to hear from everybody on the board and and then I think we're just all gonna kind of process it a little bit but
156so and totally just to sort of clarify for Community that's watching Maria's comments and why Kim was put on the spot is Kim you do work for Council of great City schools and so I just think that in full transparency that's sort of why you're put on the spot and also why marray is talking about you having a passion for it as well and so I just want to make sure that that's noted um I think I've sat through a lot of trainings and I've read the book and um I was on the board that was like 100% committed when we sofg our heart out and um I I I don't feel like I need any more training I understand that there are people around the table that maybe don't fully understand the model um
157but um I understand it and I appreciate what it can bring I appreciate an ability for us to have clear goals for our superintendent and measurable results that we were very much lacking um prior to this governance model coming here so I value and appreciate that there has to be clear accountability and I think that's been really helpful in our conversations with the superintendent I um hate going into people's living rooms when we do monitoring reports and literally airing our dirty laundry because we monitor things that are not telling the whole story about our district and it's really it breaks my heart that um we that we do that um but you know that's that's what the sort of the structure of this governance model has lent itself to um I guess going forward I
158would be open to considering how we can pivot the model to work but I know there's also a contract that has sort of what we have to achieve um with different sort of financial levers and I guess obviously the council could obviously terminate your contract as well so I think it would be a matter of if we want to explore um changing the model from the way it worked the last two years we I think we need to get that in writing and be really clear about how that's going to work I'm pretty sure other I think the St Paul District explored trying to do a hybrid model and the council was not open to that so I I think we can come to our conclusions but it's going to be a two-way street conversation
159that I think we all just need to be very open about I also was looking at cuz on the um I know that our last contract um and invoice is on the agenda um I would really also love to know our full membership I believe we've gotten it in the past and just really understanding what you know honestly like a poll like this for your staff would be helpful to know how do we use it I know a big part when we reviewed this two years ago was the Federal lobbying benefits I don't know what that looks like moving forward I think there's just some things to maybe think about and I know we're also making an attempt this board is of getting building stronger relationships locally building stronger relationships with our suburban school districts
160our rural school districts because we really all need each other in the state to advance public education as a whole that is very different than it was two years ago and very different than it was 5 years ago and I would really love to see our board prioritize our uh relationships that we can build in those capacities um versus Federal relationships at this time I guess yeah I guess I would just uh agree with much of what's been said um already and offer up that um the reality of this is that going into a reimagining process I'm not sure that the board has the bandwidth to redo a governance structure and so I think part of this is a reality of allowing ourselves to use this model in the way that makes sense for us
161and I think one of the things that could come as a benefit of that Kim is that with bits more of Education we might be able to come up with some best practices that do allow us to be better at this and ultimately you know ultimately if we're doing right by our students and our outcomes are getting better I don't care how we govern as long as that is is happening but I think if we could keep the overall model give ourselves a little bit of Grace and flexibility Maybe um in order to have broader discussions um and and then continue to learn I I'm agreeing I'm agreeing with Skyler I I think a two-day um uh training is not something that um I feel like we're going to land back in the same place
162uh yes there are good things that we can do that are better that we will get better at this but there are some structural things about this that I just think fundamentally I have not gotten the answers to those questions and um so I I guess where I land is we are where we are and we have to stay where we are because we don't have the bandwidth to redo a model however I think it is I hear a clear consensus on the board that we give ourselves more grace and flexibility in monitoring and in use of the of the Strategic plan to help us measure our outcomes but our Focus Remains the outcomes of our students M Marano and then I'll wrap us up yeah if I may I we are we are a
163model for our for anyone watching um I believe that the way that we the way that I show up to this table sets a precedence for the way that Dr Roberts shows up to the table when he meets with his executive cabinet it and the way that the the executive directors show up Etc the way that the teachers show up for on behalf of their students every day I am I am the start of that model and if if I as a board member am not willing to engage in professional development around this very important work then I am essentially saying it is okay for our teachers to not engage in professional development in order to become experts in their craft I believe that is what I am taking from this I think that we
164need to be very careful about saying well I've read a book and I engaged in in some training and so therefore I don't need to engage in future training we would never expect our teachers to we would never give them new curriculum or a new framework The Gleam framework we would never give them the gleam framework and say Here's a book read it and figure it out we would never expect fifth grade teachers at in a PLC meeting to come together and say well I know this you're new figure it out I appreciate that perspective I think I just anything else you want to say just so we can I guess no go ahead run a time crunch well I feel like often times you push me to run efficient meetings so what else would
165you like to say I don't want to cut you short it's okay okay uh can I just interrupt and I I believe that Miss Marano's comments are uh very valid and I would love to hear more um I would love for this conversation to not turn out to feel like it's meant to quiet people down so I would love for you to continue thank you the way that we behave at this board table is the way that we allow Dr Roberts to behave and the way that we allow every single person in our organization to behave I want to be the model for everyone that walks through our doors I want to be the model for continuous Improvement and offering everyone the education that they need to be EXP experts in their craft we cannot
166expect our teachers to become experts in their craft if we're not providing them professional development no one taught us how to be board members no one taught us you know running a successful campaign did not Teach Me How to Be an Effective board member on behalf of the students in the community that I serve I believe that this board should engage in professional development as a full governing body and I I get it two days is a lot to commit but we committed to when we ran for this seat I believe we committed to a whole lot more than two full days of training and I would expect that at the very least a bare minimum of of anyone that I'm asking to represent me at a table that makes very big decisions and that
167that is impacting 31,000 plus students um so I would ask my board colleagues to reconsider I know we're not voting tonight but and I am very passionate about this um and some of that comes from me being a certified coach um I I am happy to discuss this further with each and every one of you or or I Madam chair can I just make one comment um I I I I want to apologize for my comment around because I I do think it came off that way as if I'm not interested in development I prefer development uh but what I will close with saying is at some point we too have to reimagine if the district continued to do the same thing we've always done because we are setting a model for others the district
168would go under the same way the district is reimagining we as a board have to reimagine as well and sometimes that means getting rid of old ways to get the to get the successes and to get the things that we want so I'm not opposed to being developed what I am opposed to is doing the same thing over and over and not getting the results okay okay I really appreciate everybody taking the time this is a a really good conversation and I think uh there is a lot of commonality I mean even in this conversation around what we value around structure and having a governance model uh talking about a strategic plan um and ways to measure and monitor and talk about progress um talking about getting better and thinking through the ways to do
169that so um there's a path forward I think what I'd love to do is just ask everybody to reflect on this conversation a little bit um I'm going to ask for a little time to confer with Skyler and maybe put together some potential next steps for people to consider um on on where we go I think it's super clear nobody's saying like you know turn over and come up with a completely new plan it's how would we evolve this in a way that would work for all of us and what are the tools we need to do that successfully so um with that I want to thank everybody for dedicating the time um I'm going to suggest we take a five minute break and get some food and then we will moved into Clos session
170okay thank you