001all right at 6:00 we'll go ahead and start the meeting welcome everyone please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all be seated I do need a motion to approve tonight's agenda so move second Motion in a second all in favor say I I I any opposed hearing none the motion carries um I would like to let everyone know that uh truste Jones is out tonight um he's sorry he's not able to be here um he is uh has some health issues so if you could all just keep them in your prayers that would be great um we're going to go ahead and enter into the
002work session we've asked for the um what are they the building principles and any directors to come forward and sit at the table with us if anybody has any comments questions suggestions anything of that nature we would just ask that you go to the standing microphones so that you can give us your input um we would love to hear from you as well but we are not going to run around with microphone and try and get that to everyone so we can hear but anytime you have something you'd like to offer uh for this work session please feel free to go to the stands um the microphones and maybe if we're not if NE none of us are looking if you wave your hand that'll catch our attention and we'll be able to give you
003an opportunity to speak on that we will open with the uh we've been given a plethora of information but we will start um with item D1 budget information and the first item being the spreadsheet that we were given for the levy um budget information for 2425 top one so just to give the board some context in the last few um discussions after the levy failed and workshops there has been um questions about what the levy has funded where the 6 million specific to Staffing just over the course of the last six years what we have increased where the dollars have gone so everything listed here with explanations trying to provide the most transparent picture of what our district has done over the course of the last um actually nine years with the um Levy that's
004the first category here so we have listed everything here's Athletics co-curricular Safety and Security Transportation certified staff classified staff this is a whole picture of Levy dollars and how the levy dollars have been spent you go to the next all right thank you so you're telling uh me the L the levy budget information the spreadsheet is uh what the levy dollars cover in those categories okay yes each of the line items um if there's a staff member attached to it or position it is salary and benefits so again it's the entire picture of what the impact of the general fund is so it's not just their salaries it's benefits included under certified staff there's the additional special specialists at the elementary schools um with a total amount of 613730 is that the additional or is
005that the total for all of the that's total for this is just for at the elementary schools it says all elementaries have one librarian and one lab technician and then it as the one certified for so it is the total for those stock members that are listed by building there um it's only for the ones that are listed by building where it says elementaries have one library and one lab technician lab technicians are actually on a separate line and we did not includ Library it's on that L it's literally just a specialist R building it's a certified specialist certified special so for six individuals we're paying $63,750 salary salary and benefits there's eight total positions there um and that is salaries and benefit for all of them you're looking at okay gotcha okay the average
006benefit package for a district employee is 9,555 for medical um our certificated staff have a 13.48% Percy rate you have Medicare you have F you have um p and United Heritage which is the district L insurance that place into that so what is the benefit package per employee 9,000 well just for medical so medical General Envision the average benefit package that's elected is $ 9,555 um if an employee elects everything up to what the District covers which is $860 per month it's $1,320 a month for benefits that the District covers or excuse me a year $1,320 a year that the District covers for benefits if employee selects everything that they could up to what the District covers they do cover the difference they cover the difference of what oh so for example I can use
007myself um I have family medical uh the district portion is $860 a month I pay a to on top of that about $950 a month to have medical for all of my family and that's just medical so the state reimburses or gives us $860 per employe allow we allow up to $860 per employee I would be happy to share with the board the report that I sent every year to the state that shows how we're using the money that they provide for health benefits that shows that we are actually covering more than what the state provides us for that line item okay how much does the state provide us I would be happy to look that up I don't have it with be at the moment okay my next question on the Athletics and co-curriculars
008the amounts you've listed here is what the levy dollars um would be applied towards are you telling us that this is what the expenses are for Athletics and co-curriculars or is this just what Levy dollars went to and there's actually more that needs to be involved so it is a combination um the contracted coaching siens because we don't have everything CU spring Sports haven't been played yet we use 23 24 numbers to reflect that um but for example the athletic trainer line item they're not currently charged at nurse clastics they're actually being charged to um guidance and health which is an accounting fun function um they're not in that athletic number that 1.4 million that we spent last year on Athletics but those aren't included in there but they are part of our Athletic program
009if we were not to have Athletics at the district we would have no need for athletic trainers unfortunately so we did include that in the L item um so it's a combination we used last year's expenses because we had a full year of expenses to provide to you but we did include some of the pieces that are not being charged currently to that energ plastic line okay so if I were to add all of this up Mark it up 10% just for Giggles would that fall in line with what we would anticipate needing for the 2425 school year if we coded everything there yes to appoint but we don't always know what teams are going to state so they fluctuate year by year but yes I I appreciate that input but here's the thing I
010mean we keep getting inundated rerun the levy rerun the levy rerun the levy um from my perspective if we should choose to rerun a reduced Levy it's going to have to be for athletics and co-curriculars and for Safety and Security because those we do not receive any dollars specific to but I also know that I want to make sure that we're covering the that those programs for 2 years which means we should have a baseline of this is what we were projecting for the year the next school year and then we need to increase that by roughly 5 to 10% for the year after that to come up with a dollar amount it's not going to be the 1.4 that we told everybody from before because we just chose that number without factual knowledge of
011hey we're missing the mark and if you total the number for this um what we present here for you it's a over 1.8 million right I saw that we do I think we've done our level best to include everything in there do you have anything you want add to that link one of the reasons that this is quite a bit this is higher is because of those athletic trainers not being coded originally to the um athletic budget as well as the athletic director so we do have so both of the athletic directors are not coded to this function and the athletic trainers are not C with this function so changes the amount well respectfully we also just signed an mou that 80 or 85% is being reimbursed back to the district however if anything happens
012to theou we are on the hook for the salary of that employee so respectfully I mean I please don't don't think that you have to justify why you know this that or the other by saying coding coding coding we need to know the dollars and and that's just our reality right now so this would cover like I said everything that's listed there um it doesn't give them much for uniforms um we did reduce their uniform budget quite a bit um they have no uniform budget this year um so there are things that I think that 10% would help cover because we did reduce line items this year to try to keep them within what the levy covered we Lev 1.3 million with the current 9 9.52 it's cost it as you can see it costs
013us more than 1.3 million no I understand that and but the the problem is is when the Public's coming at us saying what are we covering and we can't even answer that because nobody seems to have it a LED item that is challenging and now we're being asked uh to go back to the public rerun a levy if we were to choose to do that we need to know that we know that those dollars are going to cover what we're asking for not guessing I I would say again this is a very fair estimate of what Athletics and extracurricular co-curriculars cost the district m i i the only piece I I would add is inflation is impacting everybody so you have officials you have gas you have all of that so taking that into consideration
014that is something that is out of our control we can't additionals has gone up every single year so then there has to be some discussion and a little bit of loal room specific to that because everything has cost more each year that's just a part of our reality right now I hear you and when I observe the high schools being responsible and doing their best to navigate and reduce we do need to walk beside them so that they're not being stripped down to nothing and hoping to make it work and I don't want to lose the momentum that we've gained I mean specifically I mean historically what I've observed is Timberlake's just kind of been on this Rolling Hill going upwards Lakeland has actually fought and turned their programs around and is going upwards and
015we can't lose that momentum it's detrimental to the school culture and climate and it's detrimental to both communities but that being said I don't want to go ask the public for money if we're like well we hope it's going to cover everything this is enough yeah that that's not good fiscal management whatsoever say this is a deep dive everything that you see here is a deep dive to provide that transparency to exactly what the money is being spent on okay thank you well I have a question on this Transportation double routing you're saying $50,0 $3,036 is all that ly dollars was to cover this one's a little bit more difficult um without having everything maed out and knowing all the particulars are we going to a 4-day school week are we including both uh elementary
016middle school high school there's a lot of parameters that have to go into mapping out an actual total for you so the $50,0 36 here is going it's the difference between increasing 21 FTE from the fulltime equivalent sta in 2016 17 to now and decreasing 39 part-time positions it's just the difference between those two so it costs us $50,000 more to have 21 fulltime sta versus 39 part-time sta that's what that's showing there again it without knowing every single parameter it's hard to give you a concrete related to single routing or double routing I can tell you exactly what double routing costs CU that's what we're doing right now but I need to be able to sit down with Jessica have her map out every single thing is it resoning is it what kids are
017on the bus how many drivers we need how many hours they're working how many miles we're covering on the road every day to be able to give you a concrete number of what single routing could save the district there's other decisions that Happ have to be made for us to calculate exactly what that's going to be have oh I was just wondering is there a way that we could follow the numbers of what you guys are looking at on your screen too I don't know if that's possible we will see what we can make work thank you for bringing that up I thought we were on it and we're on line 29 line 29 it's all here okay perfect want to do it whoa don't do thaty could run the numbers I suppose the struggle
018that I have with this is we ask the public for $1 million of supplemental Levy to go into transportation and now we're coming back to the table saying you know if we uh decreased to 39 part-time employees from 21 full-time it's only going to impact us $50,0 336 more a great way to say we probably should have provided a little bit more detail in this box of what we were doing we only calculated the difference between the positions I can tell you when I put a million dollars in the board recommendation for the levy ballot this time that's what it actually cost us last year year above and beyond what we got from the state for the transportation reimbursement I know exactly that's the dollar amount I did increase it a tiny bit for inflation
019because costs go up wages go up we don't ever know exactly how many routes we're going to have that kind of thing we've had some overtime things like that so I know comfortably I can tell you dollar Penny to Penny that a million dollars for transportation if they right on ask for transportation if we continue operating the way that we are right but when we have full-time bus drivers that are you know full-time because they're transporting kids to and from schools on their double routes and then we have the Athletics portion we've got all those people into overtime right and that's challenging given the fact that did anybody budget for that and who are we hitting up for that money because if you had the part-time staff we wouldn't be Crossing that line into overtime
020so significant I get it we need Transportation Etc but we also need to be reasonable about it and the fact that we had to go ask for another million dollars for transportation I think is it's not appropriate and it's not a good use of taxpayer dollars I will say um what was not highlighted and what was an oversight on our heart at the last meeting when we provided um documentation related to Transportation I failed to pull in the revenue that the buildings pay to transportation okay um we know on the financials you'll see it that it's Transportation Revenue um on our monthly Financial reports that offsets that too um so there was about $184,000 in transfer revenue for yellow buses last year for athletics so our buildings do pay for that yellow bus service does
021it cover the total cost of it no but it does help offset the cost of it okay but I guess we're I'm challenged is if we have funding for athletics and we're including yellow bus travel in the Athletics funding why are our buildings having to pay more funding for yellow bus travel they're not that is the it's the same thing so what you're seeing in there for yellow bus travel is essentially the transfer to cover Transportation cost so okay um the other thing that I want to point out in this that is not reflect in the Box um for the 50, $36 if we were to go to single rout were asting we would need 36 routes um 93 special education so that would be 43 buses total we don't have enough buses currently to
022do that if we were to purchase the 12 buses that we need to be able to run single routes I estimate that's going to cost the district about $1.65 million in order to get enough buses is to run single routes based on what we're currently how we're currently running how we're currently zoned okay four years ago we were running single routes what happened to the buses um I will defer that Jessica had to answer that there's a little bit of a difference between what we're asking them to do now and what we did in 2016 17 so when we had single routing before that was when I first started we still transported elementary students separately from from high school so what you guys are asking us to do with the kindergarten through 12th grade is
023different so I don't think we're comparing Apples to Apples it's going to be you know like out in Hower for instance we can't just send one bus out there and pick up all the kids there's too many kids out there so we're still going to have to we're going to have to send two so in our calculations with trying to estimate putting kindergarten through 12th grade on the same bus it's it's an ask that we haven't done before so these are all estimates and like Jessica was saying unless I actually go through and build all these routes specific to what you guys are asking for which is a huge time you know and we're still running the department so I mean we've been all working a lot of crazy hours to try to get you
024all this information um so it it's a hard estimate you know it's it's not going to be perfect and then with needing that many special needs buses is we're still estimating that we're going to have to haul those elementary kids separate from the high schoolers because there's just not room on the bus to hold that many kids and keep all the ones separate that need to be separated okay so let's say we say okay we're doing single routing and we need to order 12 buses and we know the turnaround time is 1 2 3 5 years mhm what do we do exactly and that's the thing no that's what I'm asking you what do we do so I think that we can run double routing in a more efficient way and I've estimated that we
025can absorb some routes you know we can make some non-transportation zones and since I've been the director the last 3 years that's what we've been doing as people have been retiring we've been bringing you guys the non-transportation zones you know trying to bring more of the stops out to the you know main roads instead of going kind of off on some of the side roads and that's in one of the spreadsheets I went through and estimated about how many miles we could save on each of the routes but I also want to point out um let me just bring up that spreadsheet here really quick that one is the budget recommendations it's this um it's Transportation building building department and then go to the second page of the transportation or the transportation yeah so Transportation
026page two you can go to that one right so this shows for each Elementary School what we're estimating we could potentially cut um so with the mile save per day you know for the first section is 44 so we've estimated that our maintenance and fuel cost is 80 cents per mile so we could save $35.20 and then multiply that times 173 a day school year mhm that's only a $6,000 savings so what I did not have done before I submitted this was what we get reimbursed so from the state reimbursement we get $46 $46 per mile reimburse so when you calculate that we get paid to drive these roads so putting these families out is reducing what we get for reimbursement too not saying some of these Cuts wouldn't be a good idea if we
027can absorb a route you know and haul all those kids on two buses instead of three and cut one of the drivers that's retiring I think that that would be a cost savings to the district but these little ones where we'd make families come out a mile mile and a half we aren't going to see those miles on our reimbursement claim so we're going to get less money from the state we're already getting less money from the state when we have to go to the taxpayers and ask for a million dollar so that's a problem I hear what you're saying I mean we've been told for quite some time that our transportation just gets reimbursed we we don't need taxpayer dollars but now we're asking for a million from the taxpayers we have a problem
028in in our transportation department in the sense that we are spending too much money somehow we've gone from uh part-time employees to full-time employees obviously when that transition occurred I don't think anyone counted the cost to the district from all these full employees Plus benefits and all of that to what we're looking at we're looking at an extra million dollars we have to figure out how to fund and I get that we get reimbursed but not enough so that is the problem I mean you're right we do get money back from the state but we're not getting enough so we have to reasonably look at this and figure out how do we make it work for both sides MH on on on this this is and go ahead Jess and um there is some change
029in state legisl that's happen enough being proposed to increase the reimbursement rates currently our drivers are only reimbursed at 50% that reimbursement would go up to 85% but the legislature moves slow our transportation reimbursement is always a year behind so we would not realize that increase until FY 2028 that's if it passes if it happens right right so I just want to speak um on the reimbursable miles versus non-reimbursable miles so for our state reimbursement our total miles that our buses drove was 57,7 38 reimbursable miles so this is to and from school and then graded field trips we drove 52080 Mi for athletics activity routes and non-graded field trips those are non-reimbursable Miles by the state so if when they calculate our state reimbursement they take that 570,000 Mi they multiply that times our
030406 a mile and that's our big state reimbursement and then we get docked for driving the non-reimbursable miles so that 52080 they multiply that times our 406 and then we get dock that right off the top from our reimbursement so that was $211,000 that we got docked okay so then if you count the average salary for all of those trip drivers for all just the non-reimbursable miles that was about 98,000 so half of that would be the 49,000 okay and then the maintenance and fuel for all the miles that we drove non-reimbursable trips it was about 36,000 so if you add up the deduction that we took from state for driving the non-reimbursable miles 50% of the salaries cuz that's what we get reimbursed for the maintenance and fuel cost that's $296,800 that it costs
031the district to transport non-reimbursable miles we build the schools just for the non-reimbursable trips $163,700 th000 that it's costing you know and that's being more absorbed by the general fund right so well if the the problem is is if if the buildings are paying it we're still pay the district is paying it it's still coming out of general f it's just part of their dollars that they're having to spend it doesn't cost us as a district any less it just where that money traveled through to get back to be being paid there but it's about $300,000 for non-reimbursable trips so just throwing that out there well is that included in the Athletics that we should be funding cuz we we have to fund Athletics and co-curriculars through something other than the State dollars that we
032receive we can't use our state funding we have to go it in a different area if that's what the community wants to support us for a portion of it is covered out of there not every non-reimbursable Den is related to Athletics orators okay if you have field trips things like that okay which we don't have a field trip budget this year other than for the fourth grade culum but yes those are I think great field trips are covered yes but if there's other things that we're doing okay that so it's not just Athletics there are other things that we do that are non reimb okay it would be good to know what they are I mean toing I can email that to you too if You' like it sooner okay did anybody uh figure out
033where our buses we going to pick up step kids were we getting for that I have a request that we I should be able to hit some tomorrow morning that shows what we built some for those trips um so we don't have insurance or nobody even knew that we were doing that it was a I think uh superintendent Arnold addressed us a little bit that it was something that carried over from previous administration yes none of us really knew that it was happening we do not have an mou in place the practice has stopped until we can either have anou in place at the board's discuss or until we just stop and yeah but it just opens your eyes to to say what other things do we not know about exctly right it just our
034work really has been to try to uncover some of those things as decisions were made and there has been change in superintendent so um as those things are when we first found found out about that um we're bringing it to light and trying to get all the information so that you guys have a full picture of everything that's happening in our district okay I never got an answer to where those 12 buses went did we not have them did we not lose them them and I believe no we sold them on a surplus we sold them on a surplus I apologize but we um did some of the purchases in 2022 21 I think it was last two years ago 2020 some of them were treated in through that Surplus process during during that those
035previous bus purchases okay so yes they're all accounted for they've all been fold okay go ahead so I just did a quick research on how much a new bus costs and it's somewhere between $15 and $150,000 so for 12 you're looking at 1 500,000 for 12 buses the district is exempt so there is no on the purchase but the school district can still go out and get Surplus buses for free would you like to address we just have to provide transportation oh hey yeah since the uh last meeting you mentioned looking up Surplus I've been online I've been talking to GSA I've been talking to a couple other um whatever Chad hooked me up on today Public Surplus the what is it Public Surplus Public Surplus there are all also uh GSA programs out there
036that can you can get your name in the Hat for surplus vehicles and things like that so I am looking into that right now we have somebody over here too oh yes I I think that there's a pretty simple solution to part of this Transportation issue one thing is if we just cut out these nonenal trips and at the risk of being booted out of here because most of them are Athletics I say it anyway I'm a strong supportive High School athletics and I'm not saying do away with it but I am saying do away with the nonenal trip 2,444 is a lot of money that's in non Reimers month and there is no reason in God's green earth to send a school bus to frch toown Montana to play a basketball game or one
037to eure Montana to play a volleyball game or whatever else doing so that's that's a lot of money and that's a huge portion of what you're short already right so I I just think that's something should be considered thank you Mr NE can you please um talk to the topic of transporting Athletics Beyond just like local competitions why we do it or how that's done state tournaments no beside state tournaments like going over to Frenchtown Montana or going well we didn't s so I can't speak we did send boys and girls basketball we fundraised for that we paid for that from businesses and the boys and girls raised that money um the reason you travel for athletics and anything that's been out of the area we've fundraised this year we also got 80,000 cut from
038Athletics so we've been fundraising like crazy to make up for the difference um the last few years of both high schools I speak Tober but as far as traveling if you don't travel you have no opportunity with your strength of schedule when it comes to State rankings so I'll use our girls basketball team for example they're 10 and0 probably the best team in the state but they're ranked number three because their strength of schedule playing North Idaho teams just can't get to number one so you go to Frenchtown because they have several division one girls on their team they're going to have a good season we fundrais for that doesn't come from the Le com from the parents and the coaches fundraising so that specifically is how we handle that thank you and currently at
039lik high school any nonstate trip where they go you know further than 100 miles our program is self funded so the levy dollars are not paying for that cuz they don't they don't cover it's not there so we we're in the same boat we make some pets this year [Applause] so thank you both I I knew that to be the case I just wanted to hear it from the mouth of B it's green on the front trust I see that we've got to hang on just one second I have a question do we know what the overall all uh budget is for transportation what we actually spend what that number is while she's looking that up can I ask them question no okay go ahead go ahead sir so I I have three kids in
040the district and they've gone on different trips and my question is is so there's a difference between graded trips and non-graded trips and reimbursement um and maybe this correct question for the principles but why aren't all the trips graded in some fashion okay why are we sending our kids somewhere to learn something and not grading what they learn good question Jessica can you answer to that about graded and non-graded so there's a flow chart from the uh State Department of Education the transportation department and um you go through and I can read it if you want you want me to read it I just like an understanding of what um so pretty much if it's based on curriculum from a classroom and a student gets a grade from the trip then we can reimbursement reimburse
041the miles so I think that it would be easy for a teacher to add a grade to the field trips to make it a reimbursable trip okay can we he that was SP no I'm sorry I don't know student athletes right they are student athletes they are learning stuff yeah don't they get a PE credit so can't we we we do only allow graded field trips the things that aren't graded our BPA fcla FFA all those things count against us that we pay out of our Levy funds for nastic so those are non-graded trips we don't take any trips at the high school level that for like an academic class that aren't graded does that make sense so like a band goes to Nic that's a non-graded field trip even though that's that's that's how
042we get marked it's been a conversation with us so their Scholastics um those have counted against us and not being reimbursed so okay and that's so frustrating because fa and FCCLA those are co-curricular so how can we not call them graded we'd have to go through the and I haven't had a chance to sit down with the principles for those specific trips we that's not what our when I ask the other director yep yeah go ahead just good evening um I would just like to bring up the I think you said that the extracurricular um transportation the non-reimbursable non-reimbursable transportation was like 200 roughly $50,000 um talking about sports specifically I mean I can't imagine a group of 16 15 17 18y old student athletes from Timber Lake driving up to Bonner's ferry in the
043middle of winter on their own self transporting themselves to play a basketball game at 7:00 at night and then expecting those people to come back or those student athletes to drive back be responsible to drive back on their own um on a school night um to play a leak basketball game or Lakeland you know group of student athletes to drive down to to Moscow on a Thursday night um I just think it's very very dangerous for our student athletes to that and expect them to do that and I think that $250,000 investment and our student safety is very valuable and I hope that we find a way to keep that in place thank you [Applause] as far Elementary goes for our non-graded we have things like the crop swim which is an opportunity for all
044their thir graders to learn to swim but all of the again the bodies of water around us we find we feel that's a necessary um trip they do that that's a 5day trip we get to get into the lottery for possible reimbursement for it so sometimes we get it reimbursed sometimes we don't it's just dependent on the number of students it's a c County thing that the cson offers we also have the opportunity for Farm the table which is not graded because we don't have anything particularly tied to it um for our fifth graders and all of our fifth graders go to the food County BRS and spend the entire day learning how the food gets on the table so those are important those is non graded for um Elementary the only one that is
045graded is they trip out to Galo for the fourth graders live on Idaho um so the lottery for re reimbursement that's through the county that's through the C Center there scholar it's a scholarship reimbursement for busing and we all submit our papor as soon as we get it to be considered that we're competing with every other Elementry in the county but how is it that we can't find an opportunity to make that graded I mean you've got participation exposure to water what they're learning about water I mean how how is it that we can't create a learn do right now could not speak to the PE standards of third grade elementary in regards swimming but we could certainly look at that well and I would have the same argument with Farm to Table because if
046they're learning that's the purpose of being in school education they're learning there there should be some way to create um a reimbursable because you should be able to grade them on what they're learning just is there a criteria from the state that requires as long as long as they get a grade that's all I need to hear is that they get a grade and we'll mark it as a code to we all we all six of us agree they're all going to be graded from now on okay great trusty at the previous Workshop we provided a document called like longitudinal budget I can't talk longitudinal budget history um on that document we show that we spent 2.78 Million last year for transportation okay thank you that's what I was trying to find out so the
047state gave us 1731 million what I'm trying to understand is the overall budget foro that we approved was 33,8 270,000 plus another 75,000 or so so far from the state from the state funding we've been right now so far they still owe payment so far we're at 33 million 459,000 is outside of sports and and all of these things we we need to look at what the state specifically is paying us to have I can't imagine that we're required to have all of this sped that we saw on here behavior interventionist and all that requirement and there's no reimbursement for the state the levy has to pay that that's an un non-funded mandate fed mandate um if you read I apologize trusty them down below on it's down on the line um it apologize we
048try to it real quick 75 so for example the speech and language Pathologists occupational therapists uh things like that those can be covered with the funds that we get from Medicaid reimbursement um our title Consulting feacher is partially covered this year out of title funds we plan to cover that position 100% out of title 2 funds which doesn't take anything away from the students um we can cover our uh right and that that's what I'm saying is all of this was given to us as though we need the levy dollars to do it and this I don't think is is accurate or it was just an additional impact to the general fund um so those could be it's not specific to the levy but there expenses that are partially coming out of the general fund
049yeah the goal is to give you a full picture of general fund but back to the buses with special ed if there is an IEP and the team has decided that there needs to be special transportation we are legally obligated to provide it so some years that could be potentially four buses depending on the amount of that what I'm saying is what we've got from the state what we budgeted is almost to the penny correct what we're being given showing what the levy covers I don't think is accurate because how can we be using Levy dollars to cover state funded items Beyond Transportation that's all I'm trying to reconcile here is we have all of this listing on Levy dollars when in theory is part of I mean if you look at what the state's
050given us so far and what our actual approved budget was um I think we were two units they ended up giving us 213 units and we thought we were at 215 or something like that I still don't think we have an accurate picture of what the state is paying for I know with their formula and with aappa rules they look at our population they look at the needs of the district and they say you must have these many teachers these many librarians these many blah blah blah and that's what they fund correct we don't have that information and all of this information is not an unfunded mandate so therefore it should not be coming out of Levy dollars and it shouldn't be uh given you know the the perspective that it is ly dollars um
051and the transportation the reason I ask because now I see where the million dollar deficit is because they only gave us almost 1.8 but we need 2.8 okay so we need to figure out if the other million dollars I know uh I I believe you know if we did uh cut the amount to go back to the public with I know that there's already been people in our community that have stood up and said hey we will I don't want to say fully back but they were pretty adamant that they would help take care of sports um and I don't I don't think anybody's advocating to get rid of them we're trying to figure out how we're going to pay for it right so I think we need to have a better understanding of exactly
052what we're paid for and where it's being spent I know we got all of this information but it doesn't reconcile to what we budgeted and what the state is PID so I'm just going to remind you the question that um was posed to me and was requested from me was to bring you what the levy has covered over the course of the last nine years so not this isn't just 2324 there has been questions about how many staff we have added in the course of the last nine years where that money has been spent when we bought beacons when we've bought so you know security so I wanted you give to give you a full picture of where those Levy dollars have gone this isn't saying that this is what we spent for 23 24
053or what we're spending currently I'm trying to give you the full picture of what the last nine years has looked like and what we have added based on from the start of 2016 to now okay all right well that was nowhere in here explained all the documentation so there again if we go forward um you know looking at those at those dollars from this year to the to the next year what does that look like right so the again the goal for me was to provide you information um there's been lots of conversations about not providing you with numbers so anything and everything that you guys asked me for I tried to provide for you so the goal was to provide you a comprehensive list of what the levy has covered Additionally the next column
054is these are the line items that have a direct impact to the general fund so that you're getting to see the whole scope of the picture not just the levy pieces but everything so moving forward you guys can make the most educated decisions with all the information so if you like this in a different [Applause] format but the goal of this was to provide you what the levy has funded over the course of the last 9 years for n for 9 years not the last year okay so out of um cruising on down to just a couple of questions under the certified staff we use 471 $168 of Levy funds for full day Kinder Staffing is that correct so for this SL item that's the average of six of our kindergarten teacher salaries we currently
055have 12 kindergarten teachers um we're currently using literacy funds for half of those so half of 12 um is covered by literacy funds which is 44% of the literacy funds the rest of the literacy funds are used for first and second grade teachers um we cover all of our first grade and a couple of our second grade just because that's where the money caps out so I was trying to give you the average of six full-time kindergarten teachers with Benefits um that we could potentially not use literacy funds if we went back to amm kindergarten um you're still going to have to have teachers to teach amm kindergarten right um but this does not reflect the additional cost of transportation to run those routes to take those kiddos home during the middle of the day
056no I understand that I just we came up with a dollar number that we're pulling from Levy funds to cover full day kindergarten because the other portion is covered we're funding it through literacy dollars which those dollars technically could be utilized one through three correct okay um I do want to say that those features are part of our salary based abortion calculations that that half that's in the general fund that they are part of our salary based proportionate calculation so taking them out would potentially increase reduce it would depending on which teachers are taken out it could impact our average weighted salary for teachers which could impact our reimbursement in the state we get into uh if we get to a certain point that we're not fully utilizing the money that the state gives us
057we have we use it or lose it right we have to keep an eye on as well no I understand that and I don't know that everyone fully comprehends the fact that we have to budget in AAR meaning we have no idea we create this budget without any kind of understanding of what we're actually going to be receiving until the school year actually starts and we can give a body count to the state to say these are the students we actually have body count by how many were sitting in seats correct for the whole day but and and that's where this whole budgeting process getss um challenging is the fact that it is best guesstimation um but with that being said it's really challenging when we're asking questions and the response back is well you
058know we just don't know not that you've said that tonight not that you've said that tonight in the past um we're we're still trying to figure things out um the funding for two additional nurses how many nurses do we have on staff today we currently have six okay see I think that's where my confusion comes in that we're paying for two additional nurses and that amount is I assume what the 172 is but then when we talk about the additional Specialists we just put the full amount of all of the Specialists that we have like one one we're presenting the difference and one we're presenting the full amount just the certified it's not everybody we didn't include the Librarians and the lab teexs are in different line item but part of the reason why we
059gave you the full amount is in talking with the elementary team again this is something we would we want to do our Specialists provide our kids with opportunities and experiences but if we had to go down to three which is what we used to have that would be the dollar amount that we be saved nurses were added specifically because of our diabetic students we have more at risk kids coming in with more health issues and so the nurses were added based on need um and so they're serving I mean our nurses are all over the buildings running around that we have so many kids comparatively to 2016 who need those nursing supports in all of our buildings so the 600 I just I I'm still confused as and I apologize the 613 is what we
060could save by reducing it down to three but you're saying that there's only one at some schools I don't I'm not understanding that is the full amount of all of the specialists at those schools um I think there's just a line it's just the top where it says AE one certified PE music BK one certified PE one certified music it's just those people that were reflecting the item we didn't average three per we could us reer building for the Librarians and the technicians and things like that we didn't we just gave you the true cost of the specialist for that line that's all that's reflected there it's not all of the specialist it's not all of the specialists at each building it is the Specialists that were added with lyll so that's one or like
061apple Elementary is one certified PE half I think she does half PE half music so that's just we have just the cost of that specialist in there not all the specialists at Apple but we have three other Specialists besides this one we have two others so there's a total of three at AEL there's actually four at Betty kefir three at Spirit Lake no this is saying we could reduce to three so if we reduce to three does well no all all elementaries have a librarian and a lab tech so if you take those two positions and add it to the certified that is three so two buildings have four as opposed to three if I can clarify just one so that looks like cutting two positions because that would just these two outer positions here
062that's not going to save us $613,000 correct that so that what I'm being told what I'm looking at and like it that doesn't make sense one thing that I don't think we're accounting for in this single line item is our Al position that's reflected elsewhere and so there are more specialists at the elementary level that are in this spreadsheet but they are categorized differently because they're technically attached to Advanced learning programs which is its own separate line item I believe still funded byy and that's 5467 N7 line 36 the alternative Middle School um it's funded 12 students to one teacher ratio it's costing us 8,230 or is that just the funds from the levy that are being allocated into that category do we know again this was a program that was added withy so trying
063to the cost of what the added program the okay so it's just the salary and benefits of the indiv alternative middle school again we're just trying to show you the question of the last meeting was what did the levy cover um so there was a lot of work to go back and look at all of the different documentation that was prepared over the last 9 years to try and give you our our best of this is what we use this money for right and I absolutely appreciate all the time and effort everyone has put in to creating all information um respectfully being inundated with demands to know what we're cutting right now right now right now is challenging because for quite a while we haven't had the information on this much detail so I commend
064you all for being able to come together and put some numbers down what we need to understand is these are Levy dollars that being taken and used for this funding what is apologies the tricky thing is once you add a program it just becomes part of what the district does so it may have been something that we asked for in 2016 but now it's just part of what the district does and so yes doesn't help offset it to a point you can say it helps offset everybody's salaries because we don't get funding person by person we get an average salary for the salary base so really truly unless we said J's position is covered by The Levy and we track it that way and if the levy goes away my position goes away we don't
065do that it just becomes part of the district's po of what we're doing I understand that but and I get that this is just what the district has done but we have got to figure out what this District needs to do to be able to educate our students because that's the focus that we have to do and making sure that our kiddos that are coming up from K through 12 are being educated and being educated with funding that were given so that we're not strapping teachers to classrooms of 30 plus kids because that's just crowd control that's not education and being able to do what we need to do to make sure that everybody's educational experience is benefiting that student I guess I would say the difficulty of that is if we just provided what
066the state funds we take away lots of opportunities and experiences for our kids so all of these decisions were not made arbitrarily we added Al because we wanted a K2 through through second grade program that um targeted our Advanced Learners all of the Specialists was because we wanted music offered to our elementary kids we wanted PE we wanted art so all of these decisions so that we were really addressing the whole child and providing experiences that's what the levy has funded and whether it started in 2016 or it started in 2018 or it started in 2020 that's what we now have so I mean I think every single person here could defend why we need to keep Alp why we need to keep every single specialist as a literacy person I would tell you I
067know you haven't asked my recommendation but the last last last thing would be to cut Kinder like huge impact to our families and overall reading and literature that's the hard part is if if we just go off of what the state funds we have to pull a lot of this away and that's the hard part and I you guys are tasked with that with that you know decision I understand that but this is really hard because this provides our kids experiences and our families and our communities we have people who can't we pay extra Transportation because we have families that would not be able to go to these State um deals without it we we are providing our kids the opportunities that for some families they would not be able to have so to say
068like let's just go off of what the state funds that's really difficult because we just don't have enough none of our Athletics none of our co-curricular we have teachers that are writing grants constantly to enrich and experience this for our kids they do it on their own dime on their own terms off you know outside school hours um but that's what we're doing and you heard Mr everin talk about you know all the grants that he's writing and they're trying to fund raise and I mean it it's hard when the state doesn't fully fund the programs that make us competitive and offer our kids experiences I agree with you can I have some understanding of what building lab techs do because we have 14 of them so we don't have 14 building laptops so we
069have six um we have 14 technology employees in the whole District uh the building labex is a program that uh is Levy funded and started in 2017 previous to that we had three techs uh splitting two L metrics so each Tech would go to two elementaries for six elementaries and then we added the building lab tech program and what they do is their halftime Technology support and they're halftime technology teacher so they're actually one of the specialists in the building they're teaching coding uh typing uh digital literacy uh you know digital they're teaching uh those 21st technology skills Elementary level okay so we have the information we have says that the building lab text we have 14 no it says it says we had nine total technology Personnel in 2015 and currently we have 14
070it's not just lab tech specific it's technology Personnel correct as 14 is my network administrator you know you have your uh small device uh specialist you have your admin ass okay hold on all oury based on the information we were given added building lab text is 297 250 and the notes state that we have 14 then we have added technology admin system at 5818 then we have Tech integration specialist at the district office um handling all state testing and diagnostic setups training PD and best practices um then we have uh a Chrome OS G suite and small device specialist at $ 67,341 676 so I guess what I'm trying to ask you is these extra positions I kind of heard you say no that's part of the 14 is it or is it noton I
071apologize we worked really long to hard on this document and we went over it a million times the description on that line is not accurate that should just say that we have six buildon lab Texs I apologize that we didn't catch this we I don't know how many times we okay so six building lab texts cost us $297,200 okay all right nobody yell at me CU I'm going to say some stuff that's going to hurt um you know we spend $600,000 in statements and nobody's addressing that we have uh teachers and admins with their hands out all the time if you're a teacher you're a leader in the building you don't get a SED or going to a meeting okay period we got to cut them away don't get a mentor s nobody in the
072real world gets these things no they don't no they don't nobody does I was in the military for 33 years I never got a stien I got my pay and I had 50 additional duties okay this is this is ridiculous we're spending all this money you know why do we have crossing guards at this school when the other schools listen the other schools have teachers doing it that's part of their Duty okay okay we got to stop with this hands out I'm not going to do anything unless I get a stien okay pick up trash clean up your buildings we got to get back to the basics like Michelle said we're here to teach okay and yeah you can you can chatter all you want okay chatter I'm I'm tired we had we had over
073how many we had $2 million in stiens going out when we started this boorder 2 million you think that was paid by taxpayers yeah it was okay and it's just it's it's getting old you know I mean it's taxpayer funded you can say whatever we want about Transportation but that's taxpayer dollar too yeah we get reimbursed where does the state get their money from us the taxpayer okay so if we're not fiscally responsible we're going to be behind you know and we just we have just if you're a teacher in a building and you have to go to a meeting once a month okay go trusty yeah we don't get stiens for going to meetings and almost anything that's paid outside of our contracted time that we do or let's for example our master's stiens
074that we get paid those for our master's degree that's considered a stip in but I should be compensated for that the eight money the advanced placement for I'm sorry the advanced professional educator stien that's considered a stien so please do not minimize what we're doing when we call certain things s i do do my boards I do wi down my Des all so that we can help our maintenance staff so please do not minimize what we do as hardworking professionals [Applause] talk about contract hours if you want us to work our contract hours meetings are out pay us for what we work you want to write the curriculum you write the curriculum because we don't have time for D in our contract hours contract hours that's fine above and beyond that's not hands out asking
075for more that's getting paid for what they work for exactly talk about a mentor typing okay you get 500 bucks for a mentor no don't get okay just let me talk please any job I've ever had in a civilian world I do not get a mentor St I have to train newly Airmen or Marines or whatever to do their jobs that's part of my duty okay I didn't get a I don't want to hear about pay because a lot of people in this room would make way more than any guy in the military way more yeah what okay yeah you didn't have to get shipped overseas at at any time NE day okay if you'd like to have a conversation with the board please come up to the microphone don't shout from the audience this
076isn't going to be productive if you guys start attacking us based on our frustrations that have been built up over the years so we are trying to get to the bottom of this 9.52 million everyone keeps saying just rerun the levy but I'm here to tell you if it doesn't pass what are we going to do then so we need to know where we're at and what dollars we need to look at where we can cut back everybody has put a lot of time and effort into this and I appreciate that all of you that are paid have done your due diligence in trying to give us the best information possible we are all elected officials and we are trying to work through this together with all of you side by side we don't just
077want to take a machete and whack everything off because that's not going to help the children the children are here to be educated that's our first first priority we have built the the high schools and the middle schools have created additional programs that require funding unfortunately the State dollars don't cover that so we need to look at that and how we're going to do that go ahead hi so I'm just I'm really worried about how this meeting is going um I like how you said you're elected officials when I vote for a school board member I'm voting for someone who will represent the best interest of my children in my zone and I love trusty Bane and I appreciate everything that she does I when I came to this meeting as I think a lot
078of people here did we were here to hopefully come together as a team and work for our school district to figure out how we best can deal with this situation right now if we're over halfway through I don't feel like we've done any of that we've just sat and nitpicked through each line item and and picked it apart and I don't think that's anyone's intention I think everyone's coming in here kind of guarded up we all have to take the armor off and figure out how we're going to show up and do what's best for our kids so what's on here the leadership in this district has worked tirelessly well outside of their contract time with no hands out asking for absolutely anything to come together and put a list of what this Levy has
079paid for full day kindergarten Alp all of these programs I believe all of the children in this District's need I am capable of enriching my children at home not every family is without these programs I taught first grade I can teach my kids how to read I did teach my kids how to read before they got to kindergarten I taught kindergarten half day it's not okay when when full day kindergarten was on the levy I was door too knocking getting people every time there's a levy I'm door too knocking talking about our school riing tirelessly I mean I just am hoping everyone can take the armor off look at this don't pick it apart if you have questions ask the question respectfully but maybe it's a detailed question about $200,000 we're looking at $9.52 million
080[Applause] wa I might apologize I didn't mean to offend anybody with serious I didn't I I understand the H Ty and the the ba L 24 and all those I you earn those you should get those I'm just talking about like building leadership and you know we have 1,000 bucks here 1,000 bucks here it all adds up you know if you don't want to do it that's fine you know people step up and do it I just I'm just trying to think of different ways to cut money and you know I know people are going to get mad Crossing yards at other schools they the the teachers do it you know we're paying $95,000 for crossing cars um and we got what bones we got bones we got uh phones for admin which I mean
081how many people actually use the phones it all adds up and if we just start cutting a little at a time you know I know it's not going to all add up to 9.5 but if we can show the taxpayer that we're trying to cut money then they'll be more apt to vote a in right you know it's just like Transportation leaving buses up at Spirit Lake you know it took us how long to do that couple years you know it shows the taxpayer we're trying to be responsible with the money we have you know so but I apologize if I offended any teachers I do believe that the hope I do believe the hope for the people here though is that we start providing some solutions and start talking about some of these things
082so again if there are line items where you don't fully understand I mean we have 40 minutes left if if you want to email us some of that but are there things that I mean we so we can give our patrons some of that transparency about next steps are there things that there's been a lot of ideas thrown out like what what are some areas where you guys are comfortable saying that's something that we could potentially cut I think people want to hear some solutions um can I pick you back can I pick you back off that absolutely my worry and my fear as the building principal here at L High School is I just got a report from the corland school district and we've already lost U 70 to 80 students in our school
083district to the Coran School District that's only the C School District but I have those numbers four February 1st is the uh deadline for prior for open enrollment students to be your first priority I fear if we don't make some decisions and give some some parents some answers soon specifically U on extracurriculars I think we're going to Mo a lot more I don't know who was first I just I have to agree with what was said it seems like we're not really getting to where we need to get to and I don't know if it would maybe be beneficial if we potentially look at this from a backward design type model where we look at okay we need this many teachers next year this is uh what we should budget for them if we go
084along with the negotiated agreement as is and how many students are projected along with administration every program that we have I mean is that anywhere I'm not seeing it anywhere and then from there looking at where do we need to trim some things down what is possible for us to trim because it just seems like we're nitpicking little things like $500 here and couple hundred, or not well not even aund couple hundred thousand it just seems like we're not really getting anywhere and uh like Jimmy just said parents myself included I have them come to some decisions here as to what to even do with my own children as as far as where they're going to go to school next year along with those of us wondering what's going to happen with our jobs and
085obviously you guys are in a really tough spot but I'm not as I'm looking at this this is really difficult to follow I where are we going to cut 95 million um if we re Levy what's that going to look like I mean there's just all these questions that I feel like we're not getting the problem is that the election doesn't happen until May we have to have a budget to the state before that election happens so we have to create a budget without the 9.52 million and then work on figuring out what we can add back in that's my questions is understanding what makes up these dollar amounts so I know what I'm comfortable saying okay this is really important to me to add back in this nice to have but we can't afford
086it so that's my questions right now is understanding what makes up these dollar amounts so that I understand what we absolutely have to have and what that Levy pays for and what we can add back in if we were to rerun a levy maybe at a reduced amount or to see where we're asking the right questions from uh the people that are providing the budgets I mean is maybe we're not communica it seems like we're not all on the same page as far as what should be communicated and what's being asked of everyone at least that's my perspective I don't know if anybody else feels this way but it feels like you guys are asking for one thing and then different things are being delivered and we're kind of talking stres around this whole I
087was just getting an understanding of what made up the dollar amounts that those were my questions go ahead um trusty Clum I will say thank you for the apology I will also transparen play with you always know that you'll have to build that back with the teachers but also more importantly in those one-on-one conversations with the community cuz as you serve that Community I will tell you that they tirelessly support us as well so just like that'll take a little bit of time um from some of those to be totally transparent um coming here tonight one of I guess more than one question but the things that I would ask that coming as a community member as a parent and as a staff member some very specific things that I'd like to hear from our
088board members one and I think that I've heard this that I would like to know we're in support of rerunning a levy to support some of these things in our district um and then I do think we're at a point where it's what do we believe that that needs to look like is that a million dollar off is that we're at a 4.5 million because that is going to be a decision that needs to be made and I know it can't be made tonight necessarily but I would like to hear from each board member where you are possibly at with that I know that some may not want to or may not be there yet but we need to have an answer that we can vote on on that in January to be prepared to
089put that language on the ballot so I just think myself and many that came probably would like to [Applause] know thank you for that information oh hello go for it I I was born in ROM my wife was born in R my mom was born in R 83 years ago and and we've never had an issue with blin having money to to have a nice school system going and now I can go over here to Super One and it's packed all the time and I walk in there and I don't know anybody right and I think the problem we have is we need to educate the people moving in here because they don't understand the Idaho education the funding that we get cuz they come from different places and they don't have the help fund
090right and I think if we don't if we don't pass this Levy and we make it through next year what are we going to do the year after that and if we don't pass this Levy next year our taxes are going to go down right now is the best opportunity to get it because your taxes aren't going to go up as much if it doesn't pass and you try it 2 years from now it's going to make your taxes a lot more and it isn't going to work I understand [Applause] I went through and if I had to pay $1,800 to get them through their their athletic sport I'd take them to another school and I think that's what's going to happen here I agree with you and you start loading these classes up and
091teachers are going to have a lot more problems right and it's not going to work we need money we can't we can't cut this stuff when you're talking not much money I don't care how you look at it if we go to single about single rout busing our bus driers going to quit because they aren't going to get [Applause] their I think you need to figure out I don't know if you need that much but you need to figure out how much we need and Lear it again and educate the people in the dist [Applause] oh sorry good evening I completely agree and W to dtail on that because um I think there's many facets going on and one of them is educating the community it seems like there's um a lot of different things
092happening that is um snowball that is creating this situation one is um misinformation um there's um people not being educated on how the state Works um but there's also uh trusty ban when you said where is this 9.3 million going this year so there was a 2023 talking point piece of paper that was put out and it listed exactly what the levy dollars are paying for currently does anybody have that information right here that we can put up there because that will tell you what it's paying for right now we give you a really good picture of what we're trying to get covered next year do do you guys know the spret that I'm talking about it's really are you talking about the spreadsheet or the flyer that was mailed out to the public I
093guess it was the flyer that was mailed out to the public it's called 2023 talking talking okay so we saw the flyer what is it that to to know what so can you repeat what trusty bane just said she said I want to know what the levy dollars are paying for they tried to give you really detailed information here and you're saying that's too much detail so I was trying to I I said I wanted specifics on what makes up some of these dollar amounts that that was my question dollar amounts for that are on this spreadsheet that we're looking at that we're working on right now I was just getting clarification on what makes up those dollar amounts I agree I don't think we're all on the same page I think there's still just
094lost in miscommunication about numbers we're trying to give you information I kind of think you guys more more time to digest this information because it is super overwhelming um but but super um assistant superintendent hasle did an incredible job with her team giving I did you guys asked and they delivered like detailed to the team so yes please take this information digest it yes none of us want the job of petting 9 million that's up to you guys um it does seem pretty clear that this Lev needs to be run pretty close to what we're asking the 9 point maybe 8 point um because this we are being ply responsible you look at this Frenchie and it's it's very clear that we are doing a very good job and so we need this money so
095please reun it please reun it for 8.3 thank you I'm going to put this out there um the school board runs on recommendations from the superintendent that's how we operate everything's supposed to come from the DL office they're supposed to tell us what they want to do and then we vote on it that's how it works okay we don't sit at home trying to figure out every day well some of us but that's how that's how it operates and people keep saying the board the board board rerun the levy well give us your plan you know that's what we need so we can say yay or n you know I mean that's how it works are you asking me my recommendation as the assistant superintendent and a mom of three boys that went through all
096of our schools I'm asking you to rerun it I [Applause] Spotlight um are there areas that we can um make some cuts for sure I think the board did their due diligence with where we pulled back all of the layers we are really trying to look at everything you guys are trying to ask clarifying questions I know that I gave you a lot of information but the idea was that I gave you a comprehensive look but any decision we make when you're there's $220,000 here $200,000 there but not 9.52 it should it doesn't exist in this budget and again I'm going to just go back to if we literally just went with the state funds we are going to decimate what we provide our kids we will have families leave because we can't be competitive
097with our local districts we our dual credit teachers all the things that they're offering our a our a our um Alp teachers all of our Specialists all of the things FFA and all the things that we provide our kids at the high school level all the experience I had a kid that my oldest needed his go-to was ban he played sports but he needed band he would have not survived high school without having band that was where he connected those were his people my middle son Sports was everything half of the the men at Timberlake High School invested in my boys and came alongside and coached them and took them to things and my youngest hopefully he doesn't hear this not the most athletic um needed BPA and needed leadership all of those things spoke
098to them so taking that away we're taking that away from a kid that that's their Outlet that's their connection I I can't recommend that I I just and I understand that we are going to have to build a budget without 9.52 we are going to have to pull things back but I I just I can't I can't recommend that we don't rerun and not give our kids these opportun ities there's no way to give it to them it's just impossible thank you go ahead I was I was to born and raised here um I gree my entire life here I worked for 30 years at Super One with this community I will tell you in the last few years I don't know if it's just been inundated from you know people moving here not being
099educated on the way that the school works our state funds I we need to put sugar coating things and saying this is what is going away this you just need to put it down on paper this is what's going to go away we don't need to try to make it sound good it this is what's going to happen because only then are people going to wake up and say oh maybe I need to like look into this a little bit more but right now they're just looking at a flyer with all these like we are right now with dollar amounts and all that it's just kind of going over their heads and they're not wanting to take any time I don't know if they're just not wanting to do it or they don't know how
100to go about doing it but with the people all the extra people that have moved here not knowing how our schools run because where they're coming from they were you know everything was being funded um it would help a lot that's just going to be my recommendation thank you go ahead hi thank you obviously this is super complex and I understand you guys have to make a case to the to the public and what you're going to do and while you're doing it but as a possible to maybe take out some low hanging Pro some places where it's obvious that we can save some money but then actually add a position maybe follow what Trump is doing at a position whose sole purpose is to look for inefficiencies and places to to make to save
101money and they can create public report so that way at least to the public you're saying like we're going to save some money and we're also going to invest in saving money make it easier for the no to say yes that's a great idea thank you are you wanting to speak yes okay uh hi I'm a Timberlake student um so I did a little bit of research and and the cost for the average cost for a home is $500,000 and for yearly for the yearly like how much the levy will cost is about 600 for for the average home and then a million value home would be about 1,200 and so even with like people in you said you represent the people but even with people in a financial crisis that that money that that
102they pay for the levy it's not going to help them they're still going to be in a financial crisis and it it just it just won't do much comparatively to what the situation might be in so you you represent the people but you also represent us at the high school so I'm asking that you take that into consideration thank you Sher Thompson yes in order to move this forward I do believe need some direction from the board as far as what to calculate if we're going to go to a 4 day school week to look at teacher retention if we're going to look at um resoning and adding more kids to a certain School those things have to happen for us to be able to calculate the cost for for the board so that we
103can come up with if we do rerun a levy if we don't rerun a levy what the cost savings are what it would look like to put on the ballot we need direction from the board which way you would like to go so that we can give you the information that you need to make a decision okay I know you can't make decisions tonight but we could no we can definitely give direction I mean there are in all fairness positions within the district office that could be removed they could be eliminated because if we are really truly going to tighten our belt then we need to look at that um within the school buildings I don't see that there is a lot of positions that should be removed um districtwide I think there's some positions
104we can look at um regardless I firmly believe that the levy has to fund Athletics so we need a solid dollar amount on that it needs to fund our Safety and Security Programs we need a solid dollar amount on that with respect to the fact that we need to be negotiating with the county what they are charging us and what we are actually able to pay we need some negotiation going on there not just accepting that this is what it is um within uh transportation that needs to get reduced so whether you all want to start looking at how can we cost make it more cost effective which it sounds like you've done that we haven't seen those dollars and what that cost gave it to us it's right here it's is it total how
105much money are we saving we can't manipulate that so bring the dollar amount to us that we are going to be saving if we choose to cut off those routes or I mean are those routes are the stops 3 miles apart from one stop to the next so that you know cuz that's what the law requires is a mile and half so if you've got a mile and a half between a door 3 m span is that what we're doing I don't know but it would be great to have that Insight you are the person that has the ability to provide that information the transportation total on this spread she is 54631 okay that she went through and said we can cut this we can cut this it's $546,000 so I think Jessica has done
106a Fant massive job at offering examples of where the transportation department can can cut it's not a million dollars like we have in the levy but that's a darn good start well and you've also found out way that these extracurricular trips that are beneficial for the students we can hopefully start getting paid for instead of just checking it off saying nope it's it's not funded because the kids aren't getting the right so that's less that's even less money than that we have to pay for transportation that that's even closer to a million go ahead so one of the things that I was going to say when we are adding bus stops student safety is always our number one priority we try not to go down the extra roads like Sienna Loop is a good example
107off of claystone and 54 that's about 2 miles total we're not going to go down that Loop but if we're already traveling on that road our state requirement is more than 200 fet away so if there's no sidewalk on claystone it's super dangerous for little kids to be walking along there we're already traveling those miles we will add stops along the route for student safety but we're not going to be adding going down the little side roads does that make sense so like it may look like we have a lot of bus stops but it's not adding a lot of mileage when we do those those types of stops okay I just want to clarify that like we add bus stops for student safety but it's not always adding mileage to our routes no I
108understand that but every stop that we make along the way how whether it's one driveway to the next driveway to the next driveway that's wear and tear on on the buses so I mean that's been part of the frustration oh you have someone Podi okay I'll be right with you that's just been part of the frustration especially um trusty Quimby stated repeatedly that you the more you stop and start that bus the more wear and tear you putting on that bus so if we can spread it out there is cost savings that is going to come that's the only Point Rod can I pass that on to you Rod is our wonderful mechanic one of two at transation that is going um could you just speak to that does that really affect wear and tear
109on buses When We're stopped I mean maybe brakes and uh that you're not getting back up to a highway spe and you're just going you know 25 30 m hour and you're stopping next you're probably not going to get a whole lot of wear and te that but if you were doing up the highway speed stop using more fi getting up speed and okay thanks yeah you can't see me my name is pigy Cutler and I have been volunteering with our school district since 1987 son Mikey uh started kindergarten went all through a Elementary came down here from middle school and high school and finished attim Lake High School I have two grandsons now that are in uh nth grade at Timberlake and seventh grade at middle school I just highlighted all of it I
110did some math I added up it wasn't the taxes that I pay out to lakland school district with our tax notices we just got and we get five we have 11 Lots in the city of Apple all together and our taxes that I pay lakan school district came to $1,110 I divided that that by 4,693 students that I looked up that said was in our district is that correct 3K through 12 I am paying we are paying Mike and I 22 cents per student that is nothing Mikey and his wife Casey have 5 Acres up behind the new super one apple with a beautiful home and garage they are paying 8 cents per student people need to do the math [Applause] our everybody needs to start working together as a team because that is not
111what I am hearing everybody is fighting against everything and we need to educate these people that are voting know what they're paying in their taxes for our kids my grandson and that's a freshman is looking so forward to going to kch he wants to do the welding course we have a logging business he works he runs skitter the last two summers he 14 15 years old now my 12-year-old grandson runs our log loader and loaded his first trucks this summer and they are so looking forward to doing stuff at ktech for mananes and Welding so thank you no matter what we've done it before we can do it again do all you have to do is highlight the section so the district office is asking for direction from us what are we telling them to
112do the only thing I can say is that we we have to we have to provide the state a a budget with without the levy so we H we have to create create that regardless I would be say it I would be ready to rerun the levy pulling two million cutting2 million so running it for 7.5 million I do want to remind the board about house 521 which is IO code 33911 that is the property tax relief bill if we did run it for 7.5 million based on the money that we received from the state if we have a levy on the books this year on our $9.52 million Levy we were able to take 2.37 off so the taxpayers are only being taxed at 7 uh4 million we would be able to use those
113funds next year if it's the same to take 7.5 down to can't M my head 5.2 that would be the tax that if we receive the same amount I just want to remind you that regardless if we have it ly on the books we will be able to use those funds to offset for property tax [Applause] relief so as you can represent we have a lot of Ls here because that was mentioned at the last board meeting that possibly a school will be closed down and I think it's important for us to find out um you're talking about posibly to R rerun that Levy but where we at with um saying schools are going to be closed or not close I think that answer well I guess was that um I don't know who said
114that because that was never determined it was proposed what was proposed was that we could create a school within school because we do have a significant amount of Behavioral uh issues within classrooms and if we could take the students with the behavioral needs and sort of house them in a school with uh general population for lack of better wording um that we would be able to do host a school within school so that the behavioral needs could be taken out of the general classrooms and that teachers could focus on working with the students um that don't have the behavioral needs because when there is one student or three students or 12 students in a classroom with behavioral needs that's a bigger impact in that classroom for that teacher and all the parents that need to
115come in to support the the behavioral needs of that classroom um we have not made a decision on whether or not we are going to go that route or not so the what was brought to us initially was let's consider John Brown because it's the closest to the district office and to put all of the special uh education staff that we have into that building it would just seem more reasonable to do that right there next to the district office one advantage of running that type of a program at Twin Lakes is we have the preschool already grounded there we've got equipment and or playground equipment and all of that so those were ideas that were being discussed but no one has made a decision that we are absolutely going in that route or going
116that route no one has said we are not going to run all of our elementary schools as of yet we are just trying to find cost-saving measures so is one of them closing an elementary school and your cost-saving that is one of the ideas that has been presented to us that is not something that this board has decided to do and are you willing to speak on whether you would no I won't no we won't so that means it's still on the table it is an idea that was brought to this board as a solution to help reduce costs so I would like to take this chance and I hate public speaking but I too have been born and raised in this area and um the conservative community that we have and the people that
117have moved into our area I do challenge you to go back to educating this community because we are a strong Community we can fight together to do what we need to do if we get the local level we would will going to do that always did like you said there's never been a problem with the levy being passed in this area but we've had a new a new group of people move in and they need to be educated and I think we do need to spend the energy on doing that and stop talking about the proposals of closing an elementary school when we have great schools I've never I've always been proud to say that my kid goes to lakland school district always and I've always wanted my kid in the Lakeland School District moved
118make sure that my kid was in the Lakeland School District so and we need to keep that strong I agree with you and on that but what's happening the Jonah that spoke behind Wonderful by the way what he said was that is what's really happening right now is that you're having people saying they're going to take their kids out of the schools that's what the proposal that was mentioned about Lakes lots of mothers already talking about homeschooling whether they're going to put their kids in private schools they're going to take them out we have to start making decisions for our kids but that's right now we want to keep them there we have a great school ofs [Applause] so I just want to add to that I think it was probably two me ago trusty
119Gris I'm actually said publicly she's not in favor of closing a school um I don't necessarily think that superintendent Arnold was providing it as a recommendation it's just we were asked to you know turn over every rock look at every day so it was because we have schools when you look at outgoing fifth grade numbers and incoming kindergarteners um we have schools for small and so that was part of the discussion the elementary team and Jessica our transportation director worked tirelessly I think two full days um in a smelly conference room just working through and I mean I think the end result came back to it I mean it is a money saver but we've never been in the business of not doing what's right for our kids and to displace 250 families was not
120anything that anybody would recommend so we are in the kid business and so when you look at solely from a budget standpoint there is money but the cost benefit is we would not recommend that because we are taking away kids communities we are taking away their families and we are displacing you're extending bus routes kids would be on the bus for longer than an hour so again it was initially suggested as an idea but I think when we started pulling back the layers and really fine tuning Jessica worked tires to look at several of those bus routes in the end of the day it's not good for kids and so if that was a decision that you guys were looking at I think the elementary team would come back and say please you know just
121like me with full day hinder they would say please no that's not an option because of the impact to our kids go ahead so I just want to kind of uh chil off what the lakes with they about my name is Britney I'm the mother of a six-year-old non-verbal autistic son his name is Nathan the Panic cannot even be described when my son began school he had had there was so many unknowns that to do with a child at the time um he ended up at Twin Lakes with an IND District transfer because of safe being alment at risks and he did the developmental preschool there the two years prior and now he's in first grade so he's been there a total of four years um with that being said you know with kids on
122the Spectrum or behavioral needs they need consistency they need routine they need schedule um to possibly close or you know the school down and take him away from all the people that know and love him that he's built this relationship on I can tell you one thing the love that has been important to my son is unlike anything I've ever experienced he has everything I give him in life and this is the one place that he can go and feel safe and loved is he's an a he's an um a regular education classroom for part of the day uh or they try to do for most of the day he's taken out for special assign like one-on-one stuff he has a 1 to1 a without could not even attend school um so I love all
123this transportation and extracurricular activities but I just want my son to be able to go to school and have all the schools stay open that's really and I didn't even know if he could attend school when we started this and now he is thriving he is Count he is learning to count he is um he has friends he plays Tad with I never even knew if he would have friends so like these people have poured their souls into my son and I just can't imagine anything changing at this point and he needs this consistency and it's not only for my son but it's for the 200 and whatever many families that would this would change their lives if the school were to close down what's the answer put more kids in each classroom that's not
124going to be beneficial in the end either right so I just would like to say that thank you thank you this will be the last person that speaks I actually also have a son who is in special education and R the and the school that he is attending is fantastic and St there has been nothing amazing to work and I absolutely love them all in this room um but that's not what I came up here for I have just a couple quick questions do you currently have a budget that does not include her Levy dollars at all um and also would you be able to provide one for the 7.5 if a rerun was able to happen and because I work well with deadlines and I'm assuming everybody else in this room does too can
125we have a due date to hold everyone at the table accountable for to have that we currently do not have a budget without 9.5 million in it um is that legally required at this point no no it's not we are presented with the budget for the next year that we approve that goes to the budget hearing and then goes down to the state um we do not have a budget for 7 point to include 7.5 million because that was just a number that trusty Bane placed on the table um and you would like us to provide you with a deadline what I have been hearing from a majority of constituents is to please give them the information before the end of January so that they can meet the February deadline if they want to choose
126to remove their student and go somewhere else I mean I I I'm really challenged by that component in the sense that people can either stand with Lakeland or move on I I don't want people to move on but we are doing everything in our power with as quickly as we're given information and as quickly as we're able to get back to the table we don't have powow with the five of us outside of any meetings that you all have seen us at this is how we have to conduct business by law so we've been given this this information our next meeting is in January we will meet again um for a second time on the workshop which I didn't ask that with the intention of ever moving on I will be in this District I
127will stay in this District that was not my intention with the question no no no what I'm telling you is we've rece we've been receiving numerous emails with parents demanding to know what's going to be cut demanding to know you know how how it's going to affect their student because they need to know if they're going to move and I can respect that but we can only go as fast as we can go because me personally I want to do what was requested earlier which is build the budget up which is what I said at the very first meeting let's figure out what the certified salary is and use that as our base and build from it I do believe we have to go back for um extracurriculars and uh Athletics and Safety and Security
128because those are unfunded that money has to come from somewhere if we're going to keep those programs going so yes we are we are moving down that pathway but to give hard specifics of dollars this that and the other we can't do that at this meeting so I'm not asking for it at this meeting I'm asking can we set a date within the foreseeable future prior to the deadline for everyone in this room to also be included within that budget to see what it would actually look like based on the pattern that we've created our regular board meeting will be January 8th and it would seem reasonable that our next Workshop would be January 22nd I would state reasonable to expect a budget with Noy dollars included on it at that meeting Jessica is that
129possible because we don't create the budget it's given to us from the district office we will work on it but again I need direction on we need to come to an agreement on what's going to be cut in order to do that it's at the board's discretion what's going to be cut we can provide recommendations But ultimately like we did last May when we cut 2.3 million from the budget that was the board's decision um so I do need that direction in order to build the budget are we closing schools are we cutting personal what what are we doing well if we're cutting out 9.52 million we're cutting a million out of Transportation we're cutting 6.5 million out of salaries and benefits we're cutting Safety and Security whatever was there but I where do you
130want me to cut it from do you want me to just start picking people at random because that's how we build this budget by just building it at random no I need to know what positions you want me to cut to get to that 9.52 well when you brought us the other budget though you you guys already did that can't you do it in the same process you did before when you brought us that budget you guys decided who it was that was cut when it because you said we can bring that format to you again where you can pick and she was absolutely I mean that's the only that's the only 9.52 million is going to require you unfortunately to declare a financial emergency and to KN the ri I can't get to it
131just with classified employees so you're saying that we need to declare Financial emergency then there is some parameters in law around that we do have to show we have 60 days from the time that we declare Financial emergency to make all the decisions um so there there's step number one before we can even build a budget I build 9 we need to deare the emergency we can build the budget we can build the cuts for you I just need some direction are we going to AFF four days school week because that impacts our classified staff are we resoning what are we doing to get to there under the things to consider that was on that uh spreadsheet were those all the you said you know cut all these things and here's about what that was
132what was no those weren't recommendations they were just things that have been brought up that have been talked about and so I wanted to give you information um we have so for instance we have 16 um category one positions those by law go right back they have to reapply for those positions we would save a million dollars if we did not fill those positions but Elementary would tell you if we did that it impacts their class sizes we we have not officially but more than likely they haven't officially turned in their paperwork but they have verbally said we have nine retiree resignations that's close to a million dollar so those were just things I wanted you to have information about I probably shouldn't have worded it things to consider because I think it means that
133I'm recommending it again these are all things I just there have been ideas that people have talked about I felt like I needed to when some of the ideas were thrown out um there wasn't any context or any information and there weren't dollar amounts so this was our way of giving you some additional information um but again if you said you know to Jessica's point we're not doing category ones well then I mean most of those category ones are at elementary several of them are happen to be at Spirit Lake so she would have three teachers or four teachers so it it there's an impact because we can't we would have class sizes of 40 so that's I think that's her point is if you if you want us to build this and give you
134some options we can can it's just difficult if there's not a lot of big when you take out Athletics and some of that there's not um the 4-day work week I think roughly saves us what 1.5 1.5 if not two I mean well according to the numbers that are down here under things to consider the 4 day school week is uh five six 7 8 10 and some odd thousand it's not one point whatever we did not calculate classified statment um we can work on that to give you what that would look like if we go to a cut where it it's going to be on the backs of classified staff because they won't be in the building that F day correct correct okay go so my I've got two ninth graders that that that
135are here and one of them is swimming uh 4 and a half to 5 miles a day for the school and I was really surprised that it's not he's not getting a grade for that because you do grade for PE right so I guess my question is from a from a revenue standpoint and it and maybe this is just a maybe this is a legure but there are no grades for any scorts why and if they were graded how would that change how the state would provide revenue for those classes transport because that might be a way to actually bring more Revenue in because I'm sorry if he's swimming 5 miles a day he's doing way more than some kid that went to P class I agree you see what I'm saying every kid that's
136pouting grinding on the football field same thing so all those extra hours and they're they still got to go Fe but at the same time you're not you're not getting any funding for a student who's learning way more on those fields than they are in well the way the legislation is is we are not funded for extracurricular or co-curricular activities that's just the law we're funded that is a laot it is we are funded for Education based on the requirements of the state of what children need to learn and when they need to learn it and it's academics it's educational academics it's not anything with extracurricular or co-curricular activities thank you you're welcome go ahead uh so Financial emergency was just brought up which made me think in my head I was a little curious
137about if we're without 9.52 million were going to be an emergency yes then why wouldn't we reun the ly for9 need to be clear about that even though the board and the district decides to run a lby even if they do we still need the cuts we need to be clear about what the cuts are so we can educate people about what this means for our school district right so even though if we run a levy that's still only half the battle the cuts still have to be made because that's how you educate the new electorate that has moved here we can't just tell them that we spent we need a million dollars for transportation because they assume that we're buying you know 10 new buses everybody needs to understand that these are serious serious
138cuts and so far what I've only heard like I don't know 2 3 million um so I feel like we're making a little bit of progress but we're still not talking about big numbers and the big numbers and the really harsh things um the electorate needs to know about that because those are the things that are going to make them change their minds and say oh they're really not just asking for 10 new buses this is actually about your kid riding a bus for two hours a day so we still have to make the cuts even if everybody's clapping and being all excited about running another Levy that's only half the battle we still need to be able to communicate exactly what that means on that note it is 808 and we have uh this
139was slated for two hours um I have go ahead I didn't finish my thought the things to consider the reason I asked is because the total of that is right at 4.1 million which would bring a levy amount to 5.4 million and although there are things under the things to consider I didn't go through all of them um so I thought these were recommendations um I should haveed it differ the ones like the special services didn't have a dollar amount anyway so just looking at the dollar amount it's 4 mil 49,52 which means the levy amount would be 5,470 47,4 75 sorry 2:00 in the morning my brain so I guess Jessica I need clarification from you are you requiring the board to declare a financial emergency for the 25 24 school year in order
140for you to present to us a budget with a 9.52 million deficit no I'm just letting you know that I'm going to put numbers in there but I can't TI certain people to it's easier when I know what people they are so I can calculate what that's going to do to our salary based portion how is that going to change our weight at average for teachers is that going to change our weight at average for people Services it's really difficult not knowing how many students we're going to have next year because I can prepare a budget for you but if I have half the population leave my budget means nothing because I have to redo it because the revenue is not there right so there are things that we have to make decisions on and
141provide directions so we can build something knowing that we may have to redo it all over again if we don't have the enrollment I I understand that that's why our budgets are always made in AAR um which makes it that much more CH average salary we could do average salary we'll prepare a document at the board's pleasure like we did last May where you can pick and choose line items I I can build that and I can tell you what I use to build it but ultimately it's your decision to tell me exactly what we're cutting so we'll prepare it you may not like what I put in there because I it's going to be our best guess estimate to what we think is appropriate but it's ultimately your decision to tell us what you
142want us to well I think that I mean I think that the very first thing is to start with what we outlined on the original Levy just remove all those dollars and show where that was I mean that would be that's that's easy I I can tell you that's extremely easy for every single category but the Personnel because like I said at the last meeting it could be a portion of every everybody salary or it can just be a handful of people so we will prepare it I'll have something ready for you but we do need to have that hard conversation of what CS we want to make y um Can the board meet again we have a board assessment on uh Friday the 27th is it possible for the board to actually have a
143business meeting um so we can come back with I mean we just got this last night at 5:00 right so and this is the first time we've got to even look at it ask questions can we come back the board not a workshop a business meeting and sort of digest some of this ask more questions via email telephone whatever stop by the district office um so that we can okay so you want to hold a meeting on the 27th yeah since we already it looks like for an assess that December December that's next Friday would you like Jessica and I there who would you like present for that meeting yes that would be great if you could be there um I guess it would just depend on what questions we had or if they were
144you know answered ahead of time or you know that makes it so hard because they're again we can't talk until we do right so we don't really know than sending our own questions and try to get answers to those together something else she okay well yeah but I get what she's saying um so the 27th wasn't an actual physical meeting date it wasn't it was um a deadline for the sub assessment but we can hold a meeting that that's not a problem at all if that's I mean if that's conducive with everybody else I don't know if going to be out of town or the 27th makes it very difficult just but what about the following January 3rd um before our board meeting yeah the 30th or here the following uh Monday or Tuesday 30th
145and 31st I'm just trying to get in as much time as we can before because board meeting puts us back in the same pred we're not going to be able to do anything right are you here on the 30th or is that still problematic for you or the 31st I just want to make sure that you guys AR going to be gone or I would request the 27th or the 30th work for me I just was make just the 27th is right after Christmas so okay do we want to hold this in the evening or during the day what about Monday is that better Monday than Monday Monday is a little bit easier than okay all right well let's let's do the 30th then um and then I think it would probably have to be
146in the early evening afternoon um gr would you like any additional documentation for that meeting I don't have that answer yet you know um just knowing with Christmas and next week um right just trying to make sure that we have everything for you um it does take a while to calculate some of these things I think a lot of my questions most the time are asked by public documentation unless there's something like this and then we need explanation of what that meant I know I gave you a lot so sorry is there else that you would like present outside of Jessica and myself I mean obviously it's the board means people could come but is there anybody specifically I don't think so because all we're going to be we just need numbers right you how
147much something spend or cost or and that's the only thing I can okay can I make a small announcement just real quick before the release if you are interested in helping with the public education that some people talked about or supporting the district if you wouldn't mind signing on the table that way we can kind of gather ourselves as a group when we do or if we ever know forward it's just nice to have on emails phone numbers that sort of thing thank you you're [Applause] welcome what time will work for you for linge have to be fine I don't know if you're working or yes I'm working but it's it's fine you can okay it's just work it's just my day job no but I could I could I could make five work if
148I needed to yeah okay can we do five on Monday or is that yeah I 5:30 would be better 5:30 yeah perfect3 then on the 30th of December all right on that note we will go ahead and uh end the workshop it's but moving forward if we're going to team up and we have hope of educating our community I think it's really important that we're aware of how we speak about our lak district and the employees of our l l District to be aware of that language while we're 17 uh this Workshop is now over