001e e e everyone it is 6:45 p.m. on January 27th 2027 2025 excuse me I would like to call to order the finance meeting uh finance committee meeting for ly Community School District 202 uh is there any public comment no I don't believe so okay uh next up are the minutes from the November 2024 finance committee meeting has everyone had a chance to review that we all agree it reflects the November 25th meeting and on a side note there was no December meeting so we're not looking at those all right so moving on item number number four are the transport agreement extensions that information can be found under item four of the finance committee packet Mr Wilkinson uh thank you so I just wanted to give um the finance committee an update a little bit
002on where we are with our transportation agreements and kind of what to expect over the next month or two uh first of all there was I touched on this last year there was a a recent public act that changed the laws for transportation agreements where you're now allowed to um extend them for up to 10 years inclusive of renewals under the previous uh law extensions were limited to you kind of had your first three-year uh contract and then you could do up to two additional years and then it was year to year after that unless another provider said hey I want you to go out to bid so uh that law is no longer in place and now you're allowed to enter into whatever length you want as a board of education but it can't
003extend more than 10 years and so when we look at our regular transportation services with Westway coach we're actually finishing up our 11th year with them right now last year we extended for this 11th year after talking with our attorney who said you know what this law is new it's a little bit gray a little bit of a gray area you can go ahead and extend for one more year but you really need to think about bidding that out the following year and so that's what we chose to do last year we extended for that 11th year with Westway coach but now based on our feedback it's time to go out and go through the bid process so I'm in the process right now of putting that bid together it's going to be um out
004on the street here within the next week or so and then the plan is to bring that bid uh for approval depending on how many responses we get and who's interested we'll um go through the process of evaluating those biders evaluating those bids and that would be approved at the March meeting that's the timeline for our regular Transportation as far as our special ed Transportation we're currently with um a part of our SD Cooperative with some other member districts and we're in our seventh year with sunrise for special ed Transportation um over the last few years the the members have been um very satisfied with the services that Sunrise has provided they've been able to get the drivers they've been able to provide good services and so uh we initiate discussions with them about an
005extension and they proposed three options they said if you want to do a one-year extension it would be a 6 and half% increase for a 2-year extension would be a 5% increase each year and if we wanted to extend it three years to get to that 10-year Max uh they offered us 4 and a half% each year for those three years after some back and forth some conversations with a few of the member districts in Sunrise they ended up coming down to 4% which is what they're asking for for a three-year extension uh in general the the the member districts would like to go for that full three years again they've been happy with the services they'd like to um continue that partnership continue that relationship for the next three years and so that's what
006the group is moving forward with um we I just wanted to get kind of the committee's approval here to move in that direction um staying with the other districts is extremely important because we benefit from sharing some of those routes a lot of our students go to the same locations and so by being a part of this Cooperative being a part of this joint bid we end up getting those routes for half the cost of if we had to do it ourselves so that's why it's important to stay with those other member districts um so I guess I guess I'll finish out here with the other Transportation provider last year we went through the bidding process for kind of our as needed Transportation so this is our mckin vento students our students in transition some
007of the smaller groups and um we went through the bidding process we entered into an agreement with Rich Lee Vans it's a three-year contract we've been pleased with their services so far this year and so we will continue under that contract uh for next year and those rates are already part of the previous bid so uh I guess I just need I guess verb approval that we can continue to work with Sunrise pursue that three-year extension of 4% with the other member districts and so I don't know if anybody has any questions or any other thoughts regarding uh that contract no no does anyone have any questions no no it makes it makes sense to it does seem like an efficient way to deal with things thank you very much okay so we we will
008um move in that direction and then we will also work on the regular Transportation bid uh for the March meeting thank you all right so the next item is the resolution authorizing the sale of personal property that information can be found under the regular board meeting packets uh item 7 A6 Mr Wilkinson so with the Elementary uh the refresh of the elementary computers for the staff uh we've had some laptops about 20 that have come aail ailable um that we'd like to try something a little bit different uh this time around historically our current practice has been to you know when we do a a staff refresh of laptops we retain some of those devices and we kind of use those as spares and things like that if if one breaks or someone else need
009ones we we we retain those for that purposes and then kind of the rest or the ones that aren't as as good a condition we go ahead and recycle those but we've never received any money for recycling those and so um we have had a few staff members who've kind of mentioned hey are you selling any of those is there an opportunity for us to purchase some of those old laptops and so um it's only been a few people here and there it hasn't been a lot but it's something uh in talking with the IT department we thought maybe it's worth kind of giving it a try and see how it goes and so uh again we have 20 laptops all those devices would be wiped they'd be restored to their factory defaults they'd go
010through a quality check and and all the software um would not be on there other than the original default operating system that came with the machine terms of the pricing uh we'd sell them for uh basically fair market value my plan was to look at eBay see what they're selling for probably take off the seller fees that we wouldn't incur and then also the shipping costs and that would arrive at a selling price so I think for these it would be around $60 is what we were thinking and um B basically we'd we'd uh make the the staff aware that they're available we'd give it a period of time and we'd collect all those people who are interested in potentially purchasing one if there's uh more than 20 that are interested we would do some
011kind of Lottery system um and then based on who gets them this time around they'd be kind of at the end of the line for the the next round of of laptop sales if this goes well and so we think it's a good thing it'll it'll bring in some extra money for the district maybe around 12 $200 of Revenue give staff an option to kind of get an affordable laptop maybe for their kids or just to have an extra one at the at the house and then obviously it at least for the time being reduces kind of electronic waste um and we get something for it other than just sending it to a recycler and so uh we're asking for approval to dispose of those laptops and then I will work with the IT department
012to um actually offer those for sale and collect the money and um we'll see how the program goes Dave I have a quick question do we have a par level that we would set on ones we would need want to keep like a certain quantity we want to have in case students move in or we have I'm sure they get damaged and lost over the course of the year yeah so these are for the staff as opposed to students um yeah so we obviously have uh a a inventory of Chromebooks for students as they come in and things like that but we will do the same as well here I'm sorry if I wasn't clear we still have spares and things like that this is the inventory above what we need basically oh so the
01320 is over over correct yeah so he already has Trent Our IT specialist already has um laptops set aside as spares in case that need would arise okay thank you and dve there's no warranty or anything it's just you're getting a $60 laptop that's what about four or five years old so yeah and so the bill of sale clearly says Asis no warranty condition you get it in we don't service it that's all very clear on the bill of sale that anybody who purchases one would have to sign off on not refundable not not refundable if it breaks tomorrow but the ones that are in really poor condition we will not be putting into the pool those will be recycled great thank you any further questions okay excellent thank you very much uh next up
014uh item seven is the quarterly Financial update which can be found under item seven of the finance committee packet oh wait wait wait wait I skipped one I'm sorry uh it's student fees item six student fees for 2025 2026 it appears if I skip one month I forget how to do this that can be found under item six of the finance committee packet Mr Wilkinson uh so the write up in your packet starts with a little bit of a history as far as our fees go they've actually been waved annually since 2020 uh when we were in covid we waved the fees and that that um practice has continued um historically kind of before we started waving fees the district's revenues were about $185,000 uh for those fees uh again this is just the books
015and supplies fees we'll get into the usage fees here in a second um but that's really less than 1% of the district's revenues and so uh that was part of the reason for continuing this practice to to continue to wave those student fees we do still have usage fees for things like sports and clubs and some of the uh classes at the high school that that require some additional fees for the the classroom um those we have continued to um to charge uh the students and the athletes and the people participating in the clubs those historically have been increased by CPI and this particular uh for next school year those would be tied to the 2024 CPI which saw an increase of 2.9% um and then I guess I'm looking for feedback we're not approving
016anything this evening just wanted some feedback to uh better understand if uh for next month when those fees come for approval if we want to continue to wave that books and supplies fee and then continue to charge the usage fees with that CPI increase of 2.9% that would be the administration's recommendation uh but we just wanted to give the the committee an opportunity to discuss that before formal approval next month oh one one other piece uh I did get a question about those usage fees for economically disadvantaged students and yes there is a provision to wave those fees uh if they have um shown a need where they they need some financial assistance they would not be charged those fees good any other questions I have one question if we were to reinstate those would
017that alleviate any of the other tax increases that we've done would we be able to moving forward would that be able to supplement so we wouldn't have to increase a tax levy as much I don't believe so um again it's I the the the tax levy is 80 85% of our revenues and so it's just such a large portion of our revenues where this is less than 1% so I don't think that they would be an equivalent amount where they could offset one another maybe not the whole amount but a partial offset um it I I mean I guess it would be $200,000 I don't I don't know how significant an impact that would have on someone's tax levy I think it would be very small but it could be something that's considered I think
018when we talked about this years ago um some of the challenge was the fact that people feel like they pay property taxes for the education of their students that should cover things like books why am I paying property taxes and having to pay for things like the fees you have Associated so the board at that time decided yes your property taxes will be used for those types of items in until we can't financially do it then we'll look at adding those fees but I think the board had decided if it's a payto playay or something above and beyond that's where we would have a fee but if it's just part of your regular curriculum not to be adding all of these additional things that should be paid for as part of paying property taxes and
019having a free education for your child I think one of the things that in looking at what has the most significant impact for our learning community um just looking at two students I mean these are 23 24 uh figures that in the in the comparison um but for two high school students that's 584 just in the student fees and you know looking at the uh with the impact of the levy that's 237 on a household um you know and there's families that have many more than you know two kids in that level so I think as as far as uh helping financially our our Learning Community this has a significant impact so it's it's it's helping our taxpayers who also have students in the district correct so if we would take this away it that
020it would increase the taxes effectively the cost of living for those our the families of our students I I really do think what we talked about it before the idea was you should be allowed to have a free education and so that's why people pay property taxes and it seemed like for lack of better way of describing it double dipping if you're paying property taxes and you're being asked to pay fees so it's really about feeling like you're double taxing people who have students versus those that are signing up for things above and beyond our Core Curriculum that's where we add those additional fees when I think in our fee schedule we've differentiated fees you have to do you know to attend school you have to pay versus those that are more elective I think
021we've done a good job dividing those two up so I thought we waved these I thought this was a covid wave am I remembering that correctly that this a decision was made during Co the timing was right in terms of feeling like there was a lot of financial strain on the community but I think that's where we had that deeper diap conversation as to what should a student expect to be have free and what should be charged above and Beyond and so that's where the dry line was drawn but if at some point the board wanted to have a bigger conversation about why I want to include fees again and maybe give some tax relief that definitely is a conversation that we can have with you and we'll do whatever you decide but I just
022wanted to give some historical background as to why fees came into place and Co gave us a chance to reflect whether or not we were essentially double charging people who had students when they should get a free education would we be able to calculate what the in the decrease in taxes would be on average for I think Dave well on average would we could definitely but I think in aggregate you said it was about $20 and some thousand that's correct so so you would you would take $200,000 divided by our property taxes of 35 million or whatever they might be and that's the incremental you would see for the average household so I'm I'm not saying that every dollar doesn't count I'm just trying to explain that I think the larger discussion was what should
023be free as part of your education and what makes sense to add on because of electives choices being on sports signing AIC the reason why I asked that question is because yes we'd lower the taxes by 200,000 divided by the levy but we'd be increasing households with students by I think pamu said well 584 that's that's just two high school students I mean the figures are so and that's it it's like you're going to have a what I would assume given those numbers of 200,000 over 40 something million that's that's a small percentage so it can't be decreasing people's taxes that much but we're definitely increasing the cost of living for our families that have students and then if I think if you add on the usage fees so I'm just thinking I have three
024children and so I would just keep adding that and then would I let them play football would I let them join you know the sport you have to I think make that choice as a family and I just I think the more the kids are involved and invested in school the better the community and the better for the kid um and so whatever we could do to make it more comfortable for families I think is how we should go and so I'll give my opinion this is my opinion I feel like we shouldn't charge fees to families I think it should be a free education but I think when school districts struggle that one more way for them to balance the budget M we're not there and so I feel the practice of continuing to
025charge book fees and things that are should be included as their free education is something that if we're able to financially not charge we should go back to I think the true intent of the law was when they said it was a free education so I have a question if you say District set struggle so the other ones that you gave us in the comparison like Elmhurst and Indian Prairie are they struggling is that why they're charging cuz every other district is charging fees except us they are and it's a personal choice and so you would have to ask them as to why they continue to charge fees I just again feel like we had a lengthy discussion as to what we thought was appropriate and I know I'm looping but the decision was financially
026we could afford not to charge fees and because it's less than 1% of the total revenue it's not having an impact on finan of it but I don't think that was a critical part of the decision to be able to say what should be free and what shouldn't be free got it and we don't know if these other districts ever had that discussion I mean sometimes it just becomes routine that they charge student fees but um it was something that we looked at is how could we help um families especially those that were struggling paa the two elementary students is 296 so we'll add a third one on there but that was our discussion and and we don't know if those other schools had that discussion and I think it was part of a bigger
027conversation where I think we Abad about $2 million over a few years of property taxes looking at our finances and trying to find a balance between what we thought was necessary and what we felt that we would be able to do to decrease not only fees but also people's property taxes there's not a right or wrong answer to answer your question Kate would we be able to decrease the levy buy the $200,000 absolutely is that a shift that we want to put back on to parents to be able to say I know it's a free education but we're reimplementing fees that's probably a larger conversation we would have to have amongst you and then probably would explain to the community why does that suggest we should put this into the agenda for further discussion later
028uh this is an annual discussion so even if we choose to you know move forward one way or the other we can re we can revisit this again this time next year uh and reverse or alter the decision what's the date for approval of the fee schedule there isn't an exact date but I think ideally we like to have the discussion now and then approve it in March so that we can start to advertise it in our student handbooks but if we needed to take one more month to be able to have those conversations we could come to a final decision in March right because normally in February is where the board approves it we normally approve it in February but we have extended it to March before um I think the only challenge is
029kindergarten potentially I think those registrations are typically earlier um but that doesn't mean we have to go through the process of billing until a future year if we decide to or down the road if we decide to reimplement it so we could wait until March if this wants to be discussed in February or or we're just looking at that one piece of information correct of how much that would impact I think that's part of it but I think bringing it back because it's coming this is coming to a board a formal board meeting for an agenda vote correct yes in February and I and you'll be able to bring back the the dollar amount to the February meeting what dollar amount exactly would you like what we would anticipate receiving if we reinstituted the fee
030schedule that we previously had in terms of if if that was not part of the levy if we reinstated the fees but then reduced the levy is that what we're asking for I'm sorry if I'm confused just how much total would come from that how much total is coming from the increase in taxes and what the the difference would be the partial offset between so I feel like it would be something to the effect of if we reinstated fees it would be at I'm using an example2 200,000 if we were to off set that to our Levy that would be a 0.0001% decrease iner Levy which would probably impact an average taxpayer by filled in the blank is that kind of the information you want for the next board meeting yeah that'd be great okay
031is that clear yes and I think we can still bring it to a vote in February then right yeah I don't see a reason why not we could probably make certain we have enough time in the finance mean to discuss it and then bring it to a regular vote okay okay any further questions discussion no all right thank you very much uh back on track uh item seven is the quarterly Financial update that is found under item seven of the finance committee packet Mr Wilson once again uh there is a uh packet included or a write up included in your Finance packet which has a um a narrative of the corly financial report as well as the uh the uh financial statements for that quarterly financial report so I'm not going to spend too long
032just touch on a few items since we uh do have kind of a tight time window here uh interest income we're halfway through the year and we've collected about 60 67% of our budgeted income it's a little bit higher than we would anticipate this time of year but we do have a uh some of those Investments that have matured earlier in the year are at a higher interest rate R because we're in a falling interest rate environment currently and so uh I still expect to get 100% of our budget income but that will taper off slightly as we work through the rest of the year because those Investments maturing are at lower interest rates State revenues uh State continues to make timely payments which is great some of you may have been on the board
033where uh there was a period of time where those were more and more delayed the only reason we're not at the 50% % is the transportation funds um ended up getting received in January versus December uh but we've already received those payments uh but those are uh some significant dollars uh that we get reimbursed from the state and they often just don't quite make that December 31st cut off on the expenditure side salaries and benefits are on track they're not at 50% just because of the timing of our payments with our 10-month staff and the acral basis of accounting um Capital outlays uh obviously that's significant expenditures related to the renovations at the junior high over the summer and then uh other objects were at 54% of our tuition budget um for both special education
034and our kind of alternative education programs terms of kind of the overall Trends uh expenditures are a little bit lower uh at this time than they were last year but that's primarily just related to the timing of when we're receiving some of our invoices in particular for SD there's some occupational and physical therapy invoices that we had received at this point last year but we have not yet received those from sasid those costs are still coming for those services but those are going to end up hitting most likely in the third quarter as opposed to the second quarter and then we also have a few Transportation invoices uh that have been received but not yet paid and so we'll most likely pay those in January and so that'll kind of catch us up uh to
035where we were at in terms of last year uh fund balances uh still remain strong and um that concludes my quarterly Financial update thank you very much are there any questions no excellent thanks for that concise summary uh so I see we are at item eight which is agenda topics for future finance committee meetings does anyone have anything they wish to add other than um the aforementioned discussion on on fees actually I should note I should note that myself all right well uh with no other agenda topics uh with uh I will entertain a motion to adjourn so moved second so that would be Pam and then miss Foster all right so the finance committee meeting is adjourned at 7:13 thank you for everyone