001and for um a moment of silence IED allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you you may be seated the first item on our Workshop agenda today are policy updates Dr Balaban thank you madam chair um members of the audience good afternoon to all of you and those of you listening at home at this time I would like to ask our board attorneysgeneral counsel Dr Evans to present to you there are several as you know uh Madame chair and board members we have started updating our policies about two years um ago and Dr Evans and and staff has worked on some of the policies he's here to Shar uh those policies with
002you obtain input and go back and craft and get it ready for the next step so Dr Evans thank you um board chair members of the board uh superintendent balaman as uh the superintendent stated we're here to look at a few of our policies as she stated the uh departments and myself have gone through these policies looked at them and we're offering or recommended suggested changes and we're going to also ask for your input during this Workshop to see if there are anything things you would like to add or to delete regarding the policies that we have listed the first policy is policy 610 and it's naming school facilities and uh the one change that we are recommending and would like to discuss is adding to the paragraph or approval of contracts and it reads
003specifically the names of those persons in office at the time of the school board's approval of the building plan or approval of contracts shall be included on the dedication plaque unless otherwise determined by the school board and this uh recommendation is coming from Miss Patty core is there any discussion or any suggestions regarding this particular policy Mr colog so the only thing that I would add to this that we have learned in the past is uh rather than uh delegated authority I think the superintendent should be the one to sign off on the final plaque typically the vendor will send it to uh the uh construction department and uh for approvable and so I I'd like to uh propose that you know I mean the plaque is forever and in one of our schools we
004ended up having to get it redone uh because it was not as though the construction Department I had followed every rule that we had it wasn't necessarily uh accurate and we didn't catch that until later so um you know the plaque is forever and so i' I'd like to see something in there added where the superintendent will provide the final approval for uh the the plaque language thank you Mr cologne that that is noted here and again at no fault of the construction Department I just think it was just you know varying opinions on what should and shouldn't be on there at the time all right thank you uh we'll move on to policy 702 which is our purchasing policy and we're try we're recommending to rename that to procurement um there are several changes
005that that we are suggesting uh here in this particular policy uh the superintendent designate Authority and limits um for purchasing those things are highlighted there in red along with some other items regarding um prices and increase solicit competitive solicitation amounts increases as all as as well so in essence we're really trying to up the threshold for a lot of these amounts due to inflation and for efficiency with Schoolboard um Administration and staff and if you have any questions regarding policy 702 we do have Dietra wittenberger here uh who is in charge of our finance department speaking for Mr Todd CE any questions yes there are Miss brosme um I just had if I may sorry I'm GNA ask uh derer if she would come to the podium and en yes [Applause] both hi um I
006just have a couple of questions um on Section D first of all I greatly understand and agree with the need to expand the spending Authority because it hasn't been updated and everything costs more and and you need that level of flexibility the only thing that concerned me was that these numbers can add up pretty quickly and I wondered if um and and I would be interested in anybody else's thoughts about this um I wondered if there's a point not where you need to ask for permission but just to report back like if if we start to get a cumulative amount of a million dollars that has been spent with this um expanded Authority uh is there a point where it wouldn't be a bad idea for the board to be aware of of those expenditures
007since they were offline or off budget anyway um just as a point of information that's one question okay I'm happy to answer so we actually look at things cumulatively and that is referred to in the policy um we also look at that when we're looking at competitive solicitations so the thresholds that we're proposing will allow us to align with some of our neighboring counties as well as um we are looking at them cumulatively by Vendor by fiscal year so the the numbers that you're seeing they are the superintendent if we were to have say multiple contracts that now exceed her Authority limit we would bring them forward to the board I I do understand that and I I appreciate that explanation uh what I'm thinking is that um there are a number of categories with
008expanded uh authorizations and and when those are pulled together that can add up pretty quickly so that's why I wondered if there's a point where it wouldn't be a bad idea to to just update the board as as an information item U to to let us know that there have has been um additional money spent um past a certain point and I don't know a million dollar sticks in my head but that it doesn't have to be that um I'm just wondering if there's a point where we should know that more than we anticipated is being spent for whatever reason are you referring to if it goes over a certain budgeted item not necessarily the vendor as a whole like if I say we budgeted a million dollars for this product and it was only
009being increased by a certain amount but now we're going over that line item in the budget I'm not sure I'm just trying to answer and that's why we're here today so it's awesome question if yes would that would that go along with what we when we discuss change orders when there's a change order right so if the item has already come forward to the board because the current amount 50,000 right now we're bringing forward any change to that contract um we would continue that process we have added in a potential um change to the policy that would allow our superintendent to approve 10% or 25,000 to a contract change order um and if it were to ceed that then we would bring it forward to the board again another example of what I think you
010might be asking for is actually HR so HR has designated Authority for you to sign however they still bring forward a spreadsheet to the board as a notification of these are all of the contract contracts and expected spend and I I would be happy for us to provide that to you it' be in conjunction with um our planning and fac facilities team since they handle some of their own um competitive solicitations but we definitely would be happy to keep the board informed whether that be like on a quarterly basis or an annual basis okay that sounds like what I mean y um and uh the difficulty for me was I I was trying to figure out if if the expanded authorities applied to uh budgeted items or were these over and above what was already
011budgeted and that's probably um a distinction that that would make a difference for your reporting purposes but what you're describing uh that you do with HR sounds like what I'm aiming for so thank you for that I I appreciate that very much um my only other question um is on section g where it says unless waved uh that strikes me as unless we have criteria for waivers uh that strikes me as um potential a a potential problem um or it could raise potential problems so I wondered if there's a criteria for waivers and there is so um The Authority would be given to me to make that waiver however I would only use that if the item is exempt per the Florida administrative code from the competitive bid solicitation and some of those examples are
012uh Professional Services which which list out several items including auditing Services um Legal Services then you have educational materials and copyrighted materials and then um we already have an emergency um purchase process in place but that is also exempt from the bid process because we don't want something to cause further damage or financial strain on the district um also grants sometimes specify the V that we have to use and then the last couple of items are technology items which um the Florida statute 282.30 I have more questions than Donna does and so you know we we reviewed this this policy a year ago and uh updated it unlike many of our other policies and so in this policy we're adding coordinators and supervisors with a limit up to $5,000 that may be extended with a
013Cabinet member or the superintendent can you give me an example of why we need to add that layer uh and the hardship that a direct that these folks may have to get to their directors to sign in other words we're we're delegating an authority up to 5,000 um without that so so why why is this necessary and what kind of expenses would be a part of this ask so one example would be the CTE Department currently that is a coordinator barely hear you you got be loud sorry all right one example would be we have certain departments that do not have a director over them and they report to an executive director or a cabinet um level member and it's really just to expedite some of the purchases for our students so CTE purchases a
014lot of equipment for a and student needs and right now they do not have the authority to approve even up to $5,000 for that purchase so we're delaying and getting some items to students and we just want to make sure we're utilizing our funds so this is just increase adding somebody who does not have authority right now and to a very small level but so that we can get resources anything under 5,000 is usually a material in Supply so it doesn't normally have to be inventoried or tracked it's not a large purchase it's not a capital or non-c Capital Equipment okay now the second line number two D2 uh UPS the amount for the principles and So currently uh the directors have a ex uh executive directors have can go up to currently executive directors
015don't have any Authority so it goes from Cabinet member to superintendent so the executive executive director is an addition uh similar to the coordinators and supervisors so can you give me an example of a time that a principal has had an amount that they could not get the approval I'm I'm trying to figure out what the Catalyst for the ask is and what the burden would be to not expand it you know what is it that's causing the difficulty right now uh and so from a at the principal level uh what are an examples of uh times where this is an issue yes so um events is a big one so field trips and proms has been probably our largest area sometimes the hotel will sell that space out underneath you if the contract's not
016signed in a very timely manner field trips um if tickets aren't bought in a timely manner and so having to go those additional steps to either a Cabinet member or to the board or superintendent has caused delays and ultimately changed their event programs um some other additional um discussions we've had with principles have expressed uh music and theater purchases being delayed um which may uh change their on-site school programs um and then Athletics is another big area so sometimes you don't you don't know till the end of the season that you may be going to the playoffs or something like that and so uh booking your your um charter buses and hotel stays and things of that nature ultimately are last minute um the other example I think is a big one is Grants um
017sometimes you get your Grant approved and you have a short amount of time to spend that money and you have to actually receive the item in order for the grant to cover that expense and so there by having to do a competitive solicitation and or obtain additional approvals can delay the spending and then ultimately we're giving that money back you mentioned grants is that exclusive just to us or does that include Charters private all of uh the grant deadline are exclusive to everybody that the grant covers so private schools Charter Schools anybody who is a stakeholder and have we had any delays in serving those folks because we've had to wait to get signatures from the next level up delays yes to my knowledge we have never not purchased an item that they have requested
018but maybe they did not get it in a timely manner where they could really Implement to with Fidelity so we really want to make sure we're implementing our federal f specifically with Fidelity which means getting the resources in the hands of students as quickly as possible so um an extra site license for a student that was not budgeted we do a grant Amendment they approve it but now we have to wait for it to go to the board because it's an increase so this would help expedite that so at the ex so number three we're adding executive directors which we just talked about so cabinet members going up to 50,000 what can you give me examples of why this is necessary so in our previous um processes if you will we had um area superintendence
019and you'll actually see that uh listed in our policy so they're replacing that role and we felt that it was necessary to give them some Authority level when it came to purchases um and ultimately ultimately we have tried to line this up with some of our neighboring districts who allow different levels of authority so as an example simol County actually allows their principles to sign up to 25,000 so we're we're still trying to be restrictive and not open the gates up too much but to allow uh those that are in a position of authority to have the appropriate signature level as well so we don't really have an example for what you're asking about a Cabinet member level not having a signature um but just making sure they're included in the approval process and a
020lot of it is as it goes up higher we want to make sure all of the correct and appropriate members are also reviewing it before it gets to the next level so including them in those conversations as well as far as the funding okay and then uh number five superintendent so we're talking about going to $100,000 and I I want to point out this is not about people this is about policy policy uh soon we may not be all sitting here and so this is uh no reflection on on the individual but my question is uh have we ever had a time that the $50,000 Uh current amount now mind you if if we were to approve this as presented it would make absolute sense just because we're going from 5 to 20 to 50
021and so to if we decide that we want to implement cabinet members uh to have approval up to 50,000 then it would make sense that the superintendent subsequently could go to a 100 that kind of makes sense but I want to understand um what examples do we have of times when that amount has been difficult and may have caused a delay because they have to wait for the next board meeting in order to get something approved so we have some current examples happening with CTE um in Dr V's area uh par uh particularly with industry certifications so one example would be our col culinary students and teachers have to have annual um certifications and because the expected spend districtwide as 880,000 we've had to tell them we cannot make those purchases right now until we
022bring that agreement forth to the board um they have a list of nine different certifications that were're in that same boat currently so that would give the superintendent the ability to to approve that uh consultants and I understand that that's just consistency uh construction up to $325,000 and so that one was very hard for me to to to understand and so um just for continuity I would suggest if you know and of course I'm throwing this out at my colleagues that we just keep that superintendent amount at $100,000 and then everything else come before us exceeding that 100,000 because then that um will even that so that's just my suggestion um now the change orders I'm almost done I promise change orders uh up to 10% and 20 $25,000 whichever is less is that cumulatively
023or is that by change order that would be independently per change order per change order so if you have lots of change orders on an amount um then that would not fall under that that would fall under that so you could exceed it just because like your point it would add up and we would never know um I can't think of a time in the six years where change orders have been of issue uh do we have examples and I guess I guess construction would probably be uh Patty if you're listening um we're on change orders I think construction is probably the largest part of that uh change order because that's what the most change orders that we see um do we have examples of a time when uh this has become an issue to
024get before the board seeing that all change orders are positive and negative and that's the irony too is even the positive ones uh where we are making money because we did an owner purchase that has to come to us too um and so I guess my second question so first question is examples of when this has become an issue and second question is um can we if we don't consider that can we just make where the superintendent can approve the positive change orders although I do like seeing them to be honest with you because I like to see that we made $440,000 instead of you know because otherwise we wouldn't never get that excitement but so I take that back so it it just you see it and it's positive you know we save money
025I like saving money change orders aren't generally a problem for us because we bring them all to the board positive or negative um I think one of the things this these changes could help the most would be in the maintenance area um to change we don't have very many schools that are DX systems anymore most of them are chillers but the schools that do have DX systems a small DX can cost $36,000 just for one classroom for one DX system and with their current limits they can't they can't do it so without getting permission from somebody so if we take cabinet members which would be Patty she could go up to $50,000 that's correct and so help me understand why that is necessary the change order one like what's the barrier I'm trying to understand
026why we're why you're asking for this may I add something for a moment if you don't mind no no so I talked to them also about this section and so when they're saying that one of those cost $36,000 typically when the chiller goes down it takes a whole building down it doesn't take a single classroom down so what he's saying is one classroom they would need 36 but if You' got 10 classrooms in that building and you've got to get them back up with air immediately because you can't have kids we know for most of our school year sitting in a room they don't have the authority to be able to bring in what they need but the other thing because we were talking about Stark yesterday is Stark is slightly behind on their schedule
027and I kept asking why I went out and toured the facility trying to figure out why they were behind and then I find out it had to do with dirt and we lost we had secured dirt that was needed to bring in to level Stark out and while they were waiting to get the process to us to approve we lost the dirt and so then they had to go back through the process and find another way in which to get the dirt and and so that's what put that school behind that's a very good example and we end up paying more for the the dirt the second time okay I'm sold Dr hold on I don't I I don't want to cut Dr short he does have an example that he would like to provide
028since you were asking for examples I'm sorry guys I it's f a lot of questions could provide quite a few I'll give you one last little example here uh you know often we're criticized as government for not being quick and efficient as much as business can be and it's often because of these slowdowns in our decision-making process there's often windows that we need to get into so I'll give you one of those windows for instance uh last spring we were approved for Title One funding for installations of interactive flat panels we obviously want to do those installations when kids are not in the classroom so we were scheduled to do that during the summertime but of course the cost went over the threshold and you guys don't meet a lot during the summertime so we
029lost the window of Summer installations for interactive flat panels when kids would not have been disrupted now we are paying overtime on weekends uh to install those when we could have done it during the summer and that's just one example of where often we miss a window because of a Slowdown in the improval process okay I'm sold and I oh informal quote so we're taking it where we don't need a contract explain that to me where we don't need a contract if it's less than $20,000 yes so our current process is anything from 10,000 to 20,000 essentially the department or school has the authority to go get their own quotes they must provide those quotes to procurement and then we vet those to make sure they're Apples to Apples essentially that one didn't forget maybe
030installation or delivery um and then we move forward with the purchase process um we are um suggesting an increase to that again we've given promp and some other examples as uh it's essentially impossible to for some of our larger schools to host those types of events for under the $10,000 Mark um so we are suggesting raising that from um 20,000 to 35,000 which is actually still less than the state statute requires they require uh competitive formal bids at 50,000 um so we still want to have some brackets underneath the 50,000 where procurement has over oversight of those purchases and so um I don't know quite sure if you're also referring to the waver that U Miss brosme also discussed but we don't require a contract for those lower Dollar in our eyes lower dollar purchases
031um so again unless it's waved from the competitive process we would still require the informal process to be done anything over 35,000 would come through the procurement office where we post the bid online for a set amount of days and then we get proposals submitted through that process what are examples where this would apply to um prom is a good one so the the hotels um really it can apply to anything though if our expected annual spend with that vendor would be less than the the new value of 35,000 would this include software textbooks software is from the bid process per Florida statute so we don't have to bid those but often you'll find like with our new Erp system Focus we wanted to see what the market had to offer and get competitive pricing
032on those all the questions I have good Rich yeah I just had a question to follow up on Mr cologne so he asked us on d5c um to take the construction amount of 325,000 and reduce it to 100,000 so my question is is there a reason it was 325,000 and not 100 I would imagine there was yes so a Florida statute 2 87.0 five5 goes over the CNA CCNA process and that outlines that a competitive solicitation is not required for construction unless it meets that $325,000 threshold so we were just trying to align with Florida statue um I also believe and I'd rely on Dr Evans that one of our construction policies has a different value as well there so we are just trying to get all of our policies aligned internally as well and
033we're going to update that policy to make sure it's one price anything else that's it that's all I had so how we got here on some of these items um Mr clone and I were on the board when the tornadoes went through to land and did a lot of um destruction and they had to immediately bring people in because individuals couldn't get out um they couldn't get out of the parking lots and things like that so that's why under e um well actually it goes down there and it says you know for the Emergency purchases that are consistent we can you know do that because there was no time like when the tornadoes went through that you could call a board meeting and say we need to spend and and it was a large amount
034of money that needed to be spent to remove those trees to get people that were trapped out of that piece but we also came onto this board during a time when they had updated the new policies on purchasing um for and and the contract Amendment pieces because there was a time when there was no oversight on that piece and I agree with you I like seeing when we're saving the money as well you know on a contract Amendment as well as when sometimes we have to put out a little bit more because the cost has gone up or we've lost the ability to purchase it from that person so having worked where Dedra just recently worked in federal programs this process has been in place for a long time I mean when I was there
035I was the first signature on any of those things and it went to the next level and aidra knows and you take it all the way up through all of the levels until it gets to the board I personally because I know what the costs have happened and they've gone up and we have kept people where they've lost things and then it costs us more money I personally don't have a problem with this as long as it's followed and the right signatures are on there but I do believe as a board member I will say on the one line I wish you would go back down to on number four for cabinet members which is new I think you need to put back in the 49,999 which shows up on all of the forms that
036have to be signed since $50,000 as the threshold for when it comes here I just want to be kept informed when you're spending over that amount and that it come to the board so that we know what is happening and we see it and we give approval but if we follow the rules that are already given to us and the updates each year I don't have a problem with any of this and I know it took a lot of work for you to figure it out and how we can move forward and so thank you and thank you for all the examples that you brought because there's been a lot of times where we've been the barrier not because we chose to be the barrier but we've kept schools from being able to move forward
037with what they need to do for students so thank you so again for that for cabinet members you want it changeed back to $499.99 is that the consensus the minute you hit 50 it the rules are it's board appr approval except for in those unique situations doll difference it would then go to the it would go to the superintendent after that right and the proposed changes um the cabinet member would be able to sign up to 50,000 and now from 50 50 to 100,000 our superintendent can sign going forward if we accept these changes the board would see contracts with a value of a 100,000 now now an example of where maybe we had an initial contract at 80,000 that the superintendent has signed and now we need to add 50,000 to it we're bringing
038it forward to the board because we've both exceeded the 10% or 25,000 and the 100,000 cumulative huh cumulative cumulative and just as information 100,000 on everything for the superintendent number five correct so we're changing the 325 to 100,000 is that the consensus I don't think it's a consensus yet I don't think no guys can we discuss it want your input so I was satisfied with the reason of why it's 325 to be in line with Florida State statutes um so I would say we' leave it at the 325 what I thought okay but if you look at letter e under the part that we've been looking at with just the numbers it says all purchases of Commodities and contractual services with a value of 50,000 or more per fiscal year shall be authorized by the
039school board with the following exception and the only exception and we did put this exception in there after the tornadoes went through was for the Emergency purchases where are you Jamie no yes huh where are you where are you I'm okay it starts on the bottom of page three letter e and I would like to add I believe this is a oversight on our part where that dollar amount of 50,000 should have also been changed to 100,000 to match section D number five okay CU see when I read all of it that should be stricken through released I still was like well we're still okay because we're going with letter e so even when these things have to happen up above and that's what I was referencing why I thought the cabinet member should read
040like it's always read for the superintendent which was $49,999 so you're now saying under Section e you want to change that to the value of 100,000 correct which would match section D number five we wouldn't see anything under we wouldn't see anything under 100,000 that I struggle with personally so let me share this with you this is your policy this is your wheelhouse right here so whatever the staff has prepared it's it's it's just sharing with you and you provide your input because you have to feel good about this Mr clone can we add to this a mechanism of notification so I mean trying to find the happy medium here because you know $100,000 at a time can add up to a million can add up to two million and and while I you know
041obviously we don't have money sitting in the bottom drawer so it's got to be budgeted it's got to be allocated it's got to be you know for the most part under normal circumstan es uh so where we would not stop the approval of the purchase is there a mechanism where we could be informed of it in other words just out of what's the word I'd use courtesy out of courtesy uh and which gives us the ability to ask questions not because we don't approve of it because we're extending to 100,000 but at least we would be aware of the expenditure that exceeds 50,000 in other words between 50 and 100,000 I don't know how much work that would add is that I think that's what uh Miss bowmore was asking as well so perhaps I
042thought we were going to do something monthly or quarterly to bring those things to the board for informational purposes only I'm 100% in agreement that sounds like a great idea to me and it doesn't even have to be formally brought on agenda or any of that it's just the the the SOP part of it not necessarily the policy side of it I'll also um want to give uh Vice chair Haynes the information that we did chair chair haes um we did survey other districts here in the state and you have uh two of our neighboring uh simol is at 100,000 and Lake county is now at 200,000 um and then within the state we have two other examples of a 100,00 that's Clay County and Bay District County schools and then Palm Beach county is
043at 250,000 so we're aligning if you will with other districts but still not meeting the cap that some other districts have made for themselves miss good Rich so when was the last time these numbers were updated I know we said it's been a while but let's look at that date because cost of change um as we're not even at the state levels are sounds like even close so I I know $100,000 sounds like a lot because to individuals it's a lot of money but I don't know that an organization this size I feel like it's really that that large of a number that we can't stay on top of it with a quarterly reporting of coming and letting us know hey this is what was spent so if it's being Mis spent for any reason
044then we can review the policy again and um but at the same time we're cutting a lot of red tape which is what tends to slow down things from happening in government I think this policy was updated um in June of 2024 but I don't think the thresholds were addressed at that time the only piece updated was the emergency piece because do we know when the thresholds were updated last and there's a history here but right 1902 I can I can I can tell you well the last change prior to that was um 2015 uh April of 2015 but I cannot confirm thresholds were changed at that time so it's been at least at Le 2015 so at least a decade and so I think that the world in general is very well aware of
045the cost of living for all of us and everything we purchase everything we do and I I would love to still be purchasing things at 2015 prices but that's not a reality so I can tell you 15 years ago these were the amounts because I was I had to sign off on them in federal programs and grants and so these amounts 15 years ago these were the amounts but the eggs are going to get cheaper so it's okay there's hope hopefully you sure about that insurance isn't Miss brm at the risk of sounding like a real here um are we still on five or are we on E well five and a five 5 a b and c okay uh good cuz that's where where I was aiming um to Mr cologne's concern I if
046I understood you correctly you're still looking at the 325 and feeling like that is more than it needs to be and and I'm inclined to agree with that um only because the statute has to be written to accommodate districts that are a lot bigger than ours and a lot better funded than ours and so I think there's a happy medium in there somewhere uh maybe 175 instead of 325 or something like that um where where we're not at the highest level but we're trying to um trying to authorize enough flexibility that's appropriate for this size District uh and also um I completely agree with the updates as as you know because I already argued for that but I think quarterly should be often enough not certainly not monthly and and I do think it should
047be an agenda item at least on the consent agenda so that the public is notified um in the same way that we are that's all miss good rich I would just say if we're going to consider changing that $325,000 number I would like some knowledge as to why we're changing it to what number and not just an arbitrary because it sounds big to us so I'd like to if we're going to change it let's do some research as to why we're changing it and to what number we're changing it to Miss Bros Meer I would only suggest that the 325 may have been arbitrary too um it's it's hard to know where that came from if it's in statute um it may have been the product of of um research that that legislative staff did
048but I'm not sure that that any figure we come up with is going to have a solid basis we're trying to figure out what is reasonable in our own budgetary flexibility and so um I'm I'm not sure that there is research that that will uh validate any particular number any more than Palm Beach County can validate their their 250,000 I don't know um do Dr Evans would like to say something is it okay oh you're good I took my just a point of clarification Mr cologne did you say 325 or did you want to do 100,000 across the board for number five I proposed 100,000 across the board for number I Believe Miss Goodrich was the one who said that she 325 it should stay at 325 and I think the reason for the 325
049because that's the statutory limitation when it comes to contracts construction competitive solicitations for cont uh construction Donna said 175 on the prices right I hate to bother Patty again but since this is on construction how often has it come up that it exceeds 325 or gets around there okay because construction is where we spend a lot of our money and that's where these costs do arise Ron wants Ron wants 325 come on that's I just want the reason that's easy come on it's rare that anything comes across that's less than a million wow that was a good answer yeah no it's the truth I'm I'm okay so I need to ask this on E you're going to change that to 100,000 so that was an error that that part was left at 50 okay I'm
050fine on construction I wouldn't be with the other two but I'm fine on construction with 325 cuz everything in construction is priced out and we have missed out on savings them waiting to get it to us in order to approve it and with when they're having to replace repair renovate and build I don't want to be the reason why a project gets off schedule while they're waiting for us that's my personal opinion Miss brosme no I'm sorry I thought I had taken myself Mr colog so I can support the 325 that was a good answer Ron we 325 325 good with 325 325 and a dollar good you're good all right we're good there 325 but you will make the correction under e all right correction under E from 50 to 100, 325 is what
051we're going to uh consensus for 5C and we're going to also do quarterly uh updates to the board on the consent agenda regarding um the expenditures expenditures okay I have one thing because of what Dr brought up because it is true um his department has to do a a lot of their work during the summer when the kids aren't on campuses just like a lot of the construction big projects are done during the summer when the kids are not on campuses because you can take an entire building's air system down to replace it when the kids aren't there uh because we're not impacting them but his group they do a lot of Technology things during the summer to bring in new technology update the technology and all of that is there anything we can do
052so so that he does not fall into the same issue that they fell into this past summer because we do that last meeting in July and then we don't come I mean in June and then we don't come back for a meeting till the end of July because that's also when a lot of people are taking their summer vacation and you know 12-month employees so is there anything that we can do because I don't want to see that happen because now we're paying overtime to employees to come in and work on the weekends to install equipment that had they' been able to install it during the summer it would have been installed and been ready on day one for kids to use also so here we are and kids are not able to use the
053technology so how does anybody feel about that and what could we do with that Mr cologne I understand in this policy and we I don't know which section it is but there is a an area for emergencies which is what we had to utilize during the Hurricanes where we thought we had to meet and we didn't because there was a delegated authority to the superintendent to notify the board meeting we were going to spend this much because we needed to right now the superintendent mind you she was capped at 50 now we're going to 100 uh could approve it and then bring it to the next board meeting so there was no need to have everybody come in for a hurricane and so um in the case of one of the conversations that I had
054with the team was I you know lack of planning doesn't constitute a state of emergency and so if it's because someone forgot to submit something on time and they knew it was coming that's a different thing but would that provision cover that so that the superint I mean we just doubled the superintendent arguably and so would that if we were in that scenario could Dr not reach out to Dr balabin at which point do you know I don't know that it would exceed $100,000 because now we've taken it up but then Dr balabin uh rightfully could make the decision and of course you'd notify us you know and I know Dr B is good for that so that's not even you know I don't need to spell that out uh but would that cover that
055kind of expenditure under Dr B's will our policy cover it if we have something that urgent that's specific project that was referenced um was a $100,000 project and we're budgeting it multiple years to try to get updated technology into the title one schools um so the change for that specific incident would have now been fixed where we would not have delayed because it was a matter of timing with our title one roll forward when it was released by the state getting the funds and then getting to the board but with the new Provisions we should be fine as long as we stay in that $100,000 threshold and spending that much time with federal funds in a very limited time um looks better on us that we can get it implemented right away like I said
056implementing with Fidelity our funds so because it's a change that falls into that change provision which is 25% yes or was it 10% % 10% 10% that only gives you $10,000 on a $100,000 project but does that really Sol that wouldn't really have solved that problem I mean you said it was at 100,000 you already had the TV project pre-board approved I don't remember no you're fine you're fine you're fine you're fine I don't remember when but um this was an increase just specifically to the tital one schools um in this example so if doc so if we ran into this and Dr in our under our current policy if we ran into this and Dr needed to go to Dr B is there a provision that would allow her to approve it conditionally to
057the next board meeting correct the emergency process that um was addressed under e and we've also in the last year formalize that process by having forms that go through a series of approval processes so it starts with the director uh requesting it and then it goes to your cabinet member superintendent and if necessary then goes to the Bo beautiful I'm good with that all right because I just don't want to see that happen again um because it it cost us more money I'll also add to that that I've um gotten meetings now with most of the Departments and I'm working towards making that all of the departments on regular basis is so that projects they're working on don't fall through the cracks thank you anything else all right thank you we'll move on to policies
058707 our fundraising appreciate it sorry thank you sorry Mr col you're good I'm just thanking them thank you thank you guys we'll move on to policy 707 this is the fundraising policy since this policy uh was submitted in your board packet we did make a couple of other suggest changes for you to consider Sarah Lux is going to come up um and talk to you about this particular policy fundraising and we're adding sponsorships to this thank you good afternoon board thank you for taking a look at the policy this is a simple revision to a current policy uh schools already do fundraising and various other events and this is just simply making it so that the district Falls in line with that policy as you can see from the policy in front of you I'm
059giving you guys a second to read it but as you can see from the policy in front of you it's just added the words the district and sponsorships into that policy so really no substantial changes other than making sure the district Falls in line that's it because I believe the original policy was for schools it was for schools specifically and uh left out the district as a whole for sponsorship events and things of that nature I think we have a couple of questions okay M brosme I just want to thank you for this change um it came up recently and um and I asked questions and Dr Balaban was very responsive I appreciated that and this change is a reflection of that conversation and it's very appropriate and I'm very grateful so thank you absolutely
060happy to Mr clone so colleagues one of the things that I shared with the team is I think this policy is missing a big component and it is uh the increased use of things like donors choose uh we've got sometimes we have uh folks who are very well-intentioned who create gofund Mees for projects who uh may possibly use their cash app to get monies for projects and I want to preface this with you know we want to continue to encourage it we want to encourage folks to uh find ways that we could that others can bless our students I think the challenge is that sometimes there's no accountability for any of that a teacher very well-intentioned teacher staff member Etc may say I would like to buy this for so I'll give you an old
061example and it was from many years ago they fundraised to get a water fountain for their portable the water fountain showed up and we didn't necessarily have the infrastructure to support that water fountain and so it became a problem and so I think that at the very least any fundraising that is done and again I realize we may not have the answer to this today and and I I'm sure there are other districts but I think it's important that for the sake of protecting our employees because fundraising is something that the Auditors from the state come and or are independent Auditors and we have to report back to the state that usually hits internal funds but if I create a GoFundMe nobody really knows what money I've received now unfortunately we don't really have an
062easy way to do a lot of this we've had instances and I'll use a different example where someone has created an Amazon wish list and I support Amazon wish list that's great um the teacher has left one school and taken all the things that were given for that school to their new school because that was cons considered I guess personal property at that point although it was raised with the intent of that school where they were at and so I think as we think about the the times and and like I said I I we have to find a happy medium because what we have right now we don't have a point of sales system we don't have but at the very least the principal should in my opinion be signing off on what someone
063is asking for for their classrooms so that there is that sort of oversight of that because right now it's sort of every man's world and um I think that there's an opportunity to address that because you know don't get me wrong I don't want to see it go away but at the same time it's skirting the whole state like nobody really knows it's happening although we all know it's happening uh and so I think there's an opportunity there I don't expect anybody to have the answer to that I'm hoping there's another District that addresses that and has the perfect language uh but I think that that's something that's important um to protect not only our staff but to ensure that we are in compliance with the law thank you yes sir I actually I I
064get really happy when I can give you good news and today I have good news for that so as part of the background of this m Dr Evans and I have been working on a procedure that would go along with this because we agree with you part of that procedure would include an application that does involve signatures from designes from appropriate designes descriptions of what is being donated and things of that nature so that is already in the works that's something that I can bring to the board at a later time uh in addition to that a procedure in terms of who is asked and when they are asked to donate um which organizations and through which means they are asked to donate is also being developed so both of those things are being developed
065in kind alongside this policy and I think that may suede some of those concerns this good Rich so are we asking a teacher to get approval if they say hey we want to have a celebration day of if one learned all their spelling words or whatever and so we want if everyone donates $5 we want that to be reported is that what you're saying so if they do a GoFundMe and they're collecting funds I mean it's however they collect it I mean it's a fundraiser at the end of the day and so that I think that's the piece we need to work on because we don't have I give you an example so right now we use focus and this is something that um Dr CE is working on Todd Todd's working on uh right
066now we have Focus so when my special needs students at Deltona High are selling uh sweatshirts you when FFA alumni which is not school system they're independent they have a point of sales system I can come up here double tap boom done but the school doesn't have that and so I have to put my name address phone number the $15 for the shirt plus the merchant fee because it's built into it to buy a sweatshirt so my point is that right now we really don't have a system to support that how how to make it easy but at the very least yes I think the principal should know that this teacher is out there collecting for because otherwise I could collect for whatever I want and never send a dollar to the cause so that
067would I mean it's fundraising at the end of the day the law says that we need to audit internal and external accounts they need to report the earn ings of of whatever within a certain time period I I don't know what the answer is and what I encourage them to do was we've got some folks who are real big uh collectors and let's get them together and that's what and I encourage you know the team let's get these folks together and they can best come up with what is the happy medium to bring us a suggestion on this policy that would cover everybody and there was a suggestion um that we have an official form for all fundraising done at the school site where the principal would sign so the school the school base would
068know that fundraising is going on and and somebody even mentioned in in the meeting I was in that sometimes this set ends up in Professional Standards and it's not because the person meant to I mean it was well-intentioned but you know I had an example of one school where the teacher asked asked for headphones and so when she went to her next school she took the headphones with her well a parent was concerned because we bought that for our school and so we had to say please hand them over because you know everybody starts their requests with we're a tital one school and you know it's well intentioned so I'd like to add something there if you don't mind under Federal program laws when we did use money to purchase things for specific Title One
069schools like one year we bought scientific probes for all of the seventh grade science teachers but we bought them specific to the school based on the size of the school and how many teachers were going to need to use them well we had a teacher leave one school and she thought and and they were $6,000 okay and she was like well that's mine and I'm taking it now over to this school well we had to say to her no because it was actually bought for this school to be used and even though you received the training on how to use it you don't get to move it to another school I mean this is something we have been dealing with and at times teachers have ended up in Professional Standards because some have even left
070valua County and tried to take items with them BEC but when we walk a fine line here when you use your school's name that you you are raising money you know based on I teach at you know ABC school and it bring and you bring those items in when you leave that doesn't mean that they personally belong to you that's where we've run into the issues with it um I am happy to hear that you're working on developing some type of a form because I think there needs to be a form with approvals and things like that but I know that you know we have faced this before in federal programs and it's just it's just this thought of the minute you put something in someone's room they think I mean people have tried to
071take furniture even it it just makes no sense but that's what we have faced and then it becomes a huge issue so I Bell to what Miss Goodrich said there are teachers throughout the year that hold things in their room as a reward or a celebration or things like that there there's a big thing out there that a lot of ele elementary schools do where they do like Mother's Day tea events and they do ask for donations for that but that money comes in and most of those schools it has to go in to the bookkeeper to go into the account so that then the when it's spent the receipts are turned in for what was spent so anyone that donated to it could come in and see yes it was spent on the Mother's
072Day tea um and that is the best thing I mean it used to be years ago ago they let us send home Flyers where we could collect money as teachers for children to buy books from Scholastic and then sometimes people didn't pay the bills so everything typically at at thee I'm not as worried about elementary schools I'll be honest with you it's more middle and high that this gets messy but Elementary a school that's running correctly for their auditing they have the money turned into the bookkeeper it goes into like the second grade account or whatever where the cour us account and then they use the card to purchase with and turn the receipts in we're safe on those cases but this this whole GoFundMe out there and cash app and all that I don't
073know how to control it and I'm not a big person on the cash app I'm being honest with you I think anybody sending a teacher cash could be misconstrued in many ways go ahead Krist yeah I just so last Friday I was at South Daytona and they had no day which was amazing and um there were students that didn't have money to buy U the ice cream and there were teachers that were giving the money how far do we take it where we do we need to be documenting that a teacher donated the money because that's still a donation of A Sort so how far do we take it I guess I I I like the idea of coming up with how that looks and I'm glad you guys are working on it but it
074just I don't want to stop um people from trying to raise money for our kids in our schools and I'm just worried that if we make it too difficult and this doesn't sound like it's too difficult I'm just expressing concerns I'm not disagreeing um that I don't want to take that away because we already hear that schools are feeling more uh institutionalized and I don't you know I just get a little uncomfortable when I hear that we're heading in that direction Miss Bros I'm inclined to agree with Mrs Goodrich um and and my instinct is that maybe we're better off separating uh the the structure for the larger events from the individual schools and classrooms because that sounds like it gets very detailed and and um and very location specific where the larger events um
075maybe like proms I I suppose we could include those um in District events um um the larger events can be in their own category and then the classroom specific rules would be tailored to to that um because they are so detailed I would just be inclined to separate this into two different sections it it sounds like we can make some uh definitions that may help and I know one of the things that we're looking at doing as part of the procedure is to set a base amount so if something is $20 is that different than something that's $1,500 and we don't want to set that amount arbitrarily so part of the research we're doing is looking at other counties to determine what a good number and a standard number is for that and I think
076that'll help as well what constitute an official fundraising event what constitute an official fundraising event exactly absolutely or a sponsorship because recently one of the middle schools received a $1,000 check for culinary and so I reminded them would they please fill out the form and send it over to miss Gilmore because even tonight on our board docks we had were're voting to accept the donations that came into schools well when $1,000 comes in for culinary we we need to recognize that and it needs to be on there but we are still struggling with some of the schools not filling out the forms and getting them to miss Gilmore so that they can be posted I I've heard quite a bit of conversation about property belonging to the school or the school district is that something
077that we think we might want to add to the policy any property that's purchased through fundraising or sponsorships belong to that particular school or the Valia County School District to get away from teachers thinking that they can take things along with them when they leave the district just question for the group yes yes thank you Mr G Mr G and so again I encourage Dr B and the team I think we could find a happy medium you know we know who the folks are and if you have questions let me know because I think getting their feedback and what would be allow them to accomplish their goal yet not be intrusive enough to not to to deter people from wanting to give us because I'm guilty I said send money all the time when somebody
078wants up for their class and I and they're good I I no question in my mind that these are good people I just sometimes worry what if somebody says well they didn't turn it all in they put themselves at risk and so I would love to give them an a mechanism to be covered so miss Lux what I would like for you to do look at what constitute an official fundraising event look at some um you know neighboring districts look at their policies but also let's include a group of teachers elementary middle and high along with the office staff and administrators so we can once we have a tenative plan of this is what we're going to be proposing to the board have them review it with them and obtain their input because that plan
079could always be tailored before brought here to the board M I think that's a wonderful idea yes ma'am thank you uh the next policy is policy 717 travel expense reimburse urement policy um there was only one change that was recommended uh on this travel policy and that's under number four where it says all reimbursement claims for travel shall be submitted within 60 days of return from that particular travel event um there was some discussion I believe where we were getting asked for reimbursement five or six months after the trip had been taken so we want to try to limit that to no more than 60 days after the trip to um you must submit your reimbursement claim and Dietra is here if you have any questions regarding this travel policy I think that's a generous
080amount of time okay all right we're we're I think we're she turned around very quick and the last policy is policy 801 public participation and school board meetings this had already come before the board uh a few months ago but we had to uh change it or pull this policy back because there was a new case out there that's relevant to E1 uh where now you can address individual board members and our policy stated that you cannot address an individual board member so we had to pull it the last time to make it comply with the new with the new law and everything else Remains the Same Mr clone and so as I stated before when we had this discussion I was not in favor of this change from board attorney to from the chair
081to the board attorney and so uh I will maintain my position if nothing else is changed on that thank you good Rich there a reason they feel that way so just I have a better understanding so you know as elected officials it's our job to deal with the public and to address the public and to take The Good The Bad The Facts of Life yes and so um I feel that it's very impersonal and very unfair you know as you know sometimes public comment is beautiful and happy and sometimes it's not and so I think that is a duty of the chair uh it's we're what we're elected to do and so to delegate that just doesn't seem like it's in the flow of the meeting and in good interest again we've lived through the
082hardest times ever during covid when it was easy when we've had times when it was hard we've had times where it was impossible and so I don't know that putting Mr Evans in that position versus us just owning it because it's what we signed up to do is the right thing to do so that's just my opinion thank you I agree with what you're saying what what was the reason that we decided to make this change would you like to share Dr Evans I think it it's to make it as impartial as possible well the chair there there have been times as Mr clone said we live through really tough times there were times when people were stopped there were times when people were not stopped when the buzzer went off we watched as it
083depended on who was speaking and that's whether whoever was sitting in this chair realized it are not you can't show favoritism to one speaker over another like you need to hold everybody to the same criteria and when we live through Co this thing got banged a lot for some and some it never got banged and so when Dr Evans was hired and he was hired to come in house to be a school board attorney for us instead of us having you know a consultant person coming in to be the attorney he brought this up that at the University and college level where he had served as the attorney for the Board of Trustees that that is how they run it and if you look at a lot of your city councils and things like that
084that is also how they run it and so we just because he's impartial you know he's he's not looking at well that person's my friend or I agree with them or I disagree with them or whatever so I'm going to hold some to I'm stopping you immediately or I'm going to let you continue on and I think if you even talked to a lot of the people that have attended the board meetings that's what they saw over the years you know and it's like they knew how the feelings were quite frankly of where the chair stood on things by who they allowed to speak longer or they stopped from speaking totally and so we were trying to bring some piece of he's an impartial party he's the attorney and when he says stop they need
085to stop because we've had people ignore when we have also said to stop they have kept reading or speaking and then you find yourself you know and then then they immediately turned around that we're being rude and unprofessional asking them to stop from speaking Mr CL you want to say something again I I do and so in the same policy we have the board attorney May notify or warn speakers that their comments have gone beyond and and I don't know that that's the board attorney's job that's the chair's job I mean at the end of the day if they go over that's the chair's job and I don't know that I want to put the attorney in a position where he's now saying stop stop stop turn off the microphone that's what we do and
086thankfully again we've lived through the anything that could happen that was terrible and we survived and fortunately we're very blessed that despite the differing opinions 99.9% of the folks who come to our meeting are cordial and are they passionate sometimes absolutely but so are we and so um I don't know what this is fixing I think it's more impersonal I think it's I I I I I don't like creating drama and so I I think that this it's not broken don't fix it that's my thought Miss brm I agree uh I was not on the board at the time that this policy was adopted um but I agree that it is the responsib ility of the chair and if the chair is showing favoritism I think that is a discussion that the board should have
087with with the chair um but I I'm inclined unless unless there's a reason to invoke some legal um standard because of the behavior of of someone who's participating or doing public comment um I do think it's the responsibility of the chair and I realize that's not the the change the policy change that we're here to discuss but I just figured since Mr cologne had raised it I would weigh in too Miss Thompson thank you I will say that and I know you've handled this a lot and I handled it last time it it would have been easier if Dr Evans had done it not because of the comments but because if someone's speaking to you I like to write everything down that they're saying so I can look back on it and if it's discussed
088later or if someone else emails about it I have a reference point and when you're trying to look at the time and make sure that they're getting the time and like it's getting close it adds an extra layer to where you're not able to listen as well because you do have those extra responsibilities so that's just another piece of that puzzle R I can understand that uh we try to make sure that we that we make notes of of the things that we want to try to remember but I've also found that it's been very helpful when I have not not been able to to fully take notes to go back and look at the video and and especially in public comment um to make sure that I that I my notes were accurate or
089whatever it was uh so I think that's a good backup system for when we're not able to fully um make the notes that we want to make while we're also actively listening okay so we need to give Dr Evans Direction on this policy comment Miss goodr sorry if it's not imminently pressing could we review this could we push this back to the next meeting so that we have a little more time to review and discuss it because there's more information I have now than I had before and so I'd like a little more time to think get through and so we would move it then into February for to bring it back at a workshop because we like to Workshop everything and know that for the most part we're settled with it before we bring
090it on for a vote since it's going to be a policy so you've heard um the rec or suggestion M good Rich has made is everyone in agreement with that I agree with that I agree with that okay Dr Evans so we'll hold this in a b until the February 2024 meeting we'll bring it back at that time those are all the policy updates that I have thus far chair Madam chair thank you very much so it is 1:54 and we're going to take a short recess and then come back in for item 2.02 our way of work presentation so if everyone could be back in the boardroom at 2:15 please thank you e e e I'm gonna be I'm gonna be Jesse sorry time good afternoon and welcome back our next item on the
091agenda is 2.02 our way of work presentation Dr Babin Madame chair thank you very much I would like to ask Mr Tom Gonzalez who is an attorney with gray Robinson to come forward and share with us information and a presentation on our way of work as you know um gray Robinson also happens to be the firm and the the body of work that we do with them for legislative affairs and so it's it's it's a team of individuals that's well known to vucha County um Mr Gonzalez has worked with valua County for probably more than four decades at this point in time and throughout the State of Florida well-respected attorney he represents management clients throughout the State of Florida in matters of Labor Relations equal opportunity law wage and hourly law and also all employment
092and Personnel related matters so we want to welcome you back it's only been what the last time you were here during Co I believe right in this about 1:30 2 o'clock in the morning yep so welcome back and we're glad to have you here and Madam chair as you know we we also are going through our recertification process for um Master board so thank you again for being here Mr Gonzalez the floor is all yours thank you and thank you for for having me and and uh by way of full disclosure I've been the Schoolboard attorney for Hillsboro County and also have worked with a number of uh School boards so I don't I don't come to this presentation with a with a lack of of experience and personal opinions but I've been asked to
093talk about our way of work and it was it was nice to be sitting here watching the board do what I'm going to tell you and that is that the way of work is whatever a majority of this board wants it to be subject to a really really specifically defined system of government that's unique to school boards and uh that system that I'm going to talk about and and its origin is is I think what makes you all and that's why I wanted to do the full disclosure because I have that that that prejudice is that I think that being a school board member is the hardest legislative job in the state government system and I want to tell you why and and I want to start with the 1968 Constitution which has a couple
094of Articles one of which is entitled local government and in the local government article the Constitution provides that there can be counties and that the governing body of the County will be the board of County Commissioners there's no mention of a chief executive whatsoever it's left entirely up to the board and the board operates under the Constitution the way they want to operate but they do it as a body and there's also provision with respect to municipalities and municipalities it says again that they'll have the powers that are given to it by the charter and there's no mention of a of a mayor or any other kind of chief executive now I'll tell you and and you while we're talking about it the the way government has gone and the need to act quickly both
095the counties and the cities have ended up having Chief Executives either as a mayor or a County administrator or city manager but that's by decision of the board and it wasn't something that was imposed by the Constitution in the case of school boards there is a specific provision in article nine and it's section four which says that each County shall constitute a school district and then it says that in each School District there shall be a school board composed of five or more members chosen by vote of the electors in a nonpartisan election for appropriately staggered terms of four years is provided by law and then B and we're going to be talking about verbs because I think verbs I hope I won't be boring you but it's important to talk about the verbs the
096legislature has used in the context of school boards but five 4B says the school board shall operate control and supervise all public schools within the school district and determine the rate of school district taxes within the limits prescribed herein two or more school districts May operate and finance joint educational programs but then in section five and unlike counties municipalities and Special Districts The Constitution the State of Florida says there's going to be a office called the superintendent of schools and when you read section five it says in each School District there shall be a superintendent of schools who shall be elected at the general election in each year the number of which is a multiple of four for a term of four years or when provided by resolution of the vote of the electors the
097district school superintendent in any school district shall be employed by The District School Board as provided by General law and that makes school districts and school governance the only instrument of government in the State of Florida that has a chief executive named in the Constitution and and what's important is what the legislature did with that because regardless of whether the superintendent is elected or or hired it's still the same it's still an office that's created by the Constitution and it resulted in what's now 101.32 which is the management control operation Administration and supervision now you notice there's some more verbs in there than there are in the Constitution and and so you have control operation and supervision but now you have management and administration and here's what the legislature did with respect to the District
098School System it'll be considered as part of the state system because you know all know that that part of your obligation is the state Florida is is committed to providing a uniform system of public education with with uniform funding and everything else and part of that will be in section two the district school board that says in accordance with the provisions of 4B of the State Constitution District school boards shall operate control and supervise those same three verbs all free public schools in their respective districts and may exercise any power except as expressly Pro prohibited by the state constitution of General law and then it goes to the district school superintendent and you have different verbs than you have for the district school board and these are verbs that were given by and imposed by
099the legislature but it says responsibility for the administration and management of the schools and for the supervision of instruction in the district shall be vested in the district school superintendent as the secretary an executive officer of the district school board as provided by law only school districts have that system of governance and and with respect to the the the mention of the executive officer this is the only executive officer that's created for a school district and again it's it makes it unlike counties and cities that that have to go their own way in terms of what kind of administration and and day-to-day operation they want to have and this system has been around a long time it's been the subject of a number of opinions of the Attorney General and and basically what it's come
100down to is what's in the 1996 opinion that I've included in in the uh in the printouts that that basically talks about the question in that case was is a District School Board member precluded from making recommendations to the school board regarding those manners specifically reserved for the superintendent of schools by section 23032 and 23033 those 230 numbers are simply the same statutes that got renumbered as the thousands in in the current school code but the provisions are exactly the same and and what this deals with is the operation of a school district in the context of a system that was provided going back to 1939 with in my opinion the imposition of government in the sunshine and the public records law which made what you all do so hard in my opinion but basically
101the upshot of this opinion was on what I've got on the next page and this is the the conclusion was that the statutes relating to the powers of the superintendent parallel those discussed above regarding the school board section 23032 is a broad statute providing that the superintendent has General oversight over the district school system for the purpose of determining problems and recommending improvements the superintendent is charged with under this statute with recommending policies rules and regulations and standards for the operations of the district system and executing them once they are adopted by the school board this general power is tempered by the requirement that the superintendent quote advise and counsel with the school board on all educational matters and recommend to the school board for actions such matters as should be acted upon goes on
102to say the district school board is statutorily required to adopt these recommendations by the superintendent if in their opinion the actions are warranted however nothing in sections 23022 or 23023 precludes a Schoolboard member from making suggestions to the superintendent in areas in which the board member may think appropriate for comment if the superintendent feels that these are deserving of incorporation his or her recommendation to be presented to the board for final action he or she may do so if this informal suggestion process is utilized caution should be exercised by the Schoolboard members and the superintendent to ensure that no violation of the Sunshine Law occurs and that's where the the the job that you all do in terms of legislating comes into this and that is to say that the constitution the school go code
103is real real clear that individual Schoolboard members aren't given the authority that you all may think you need to to get done the things you want to do because all the powers that we're going to be talking about are given to the school board acting as a board which gets me to what I was saying is that the way of work is whatever the majority of this board wants it to be and that's up to you in terms of how you want to handle this thing and what you want to get done and it's talking about the school code and this is the last of that opinion where it says the the statutes prescribe the powers and duties of the superintendent responsibilities described therein exclusively assigned to the superintendent the superintendent directed however to accomplish
104those responsibilities with the advice and counsel of the school board whose suggestion the super superintendent May adopt as a recommendation for approval that's different than what happens when the recommendation comes before the whole board in which case that's when your powers are really the best and the highest they're going to be because as I said a majority of the school board determines whether that recommendation is going to be in your best judgment adopted with one exception and that's personnel and we're going to be talking about that specifically now we're going to go through these quick and I'm not going to go through these long lists that's in the statutes about the powers of the school board because I think what's most important is that they begin with some some form of what's in this statute
105which is the 1,141 which is the general powers and it says the district school board after considering recommendations submitted by the district school superintendent shall exercise the following General po and then it goes on to say determine policies adopt rules prescribe and adopt standards contract Su and and be sued and then that goes down to the general Powers which is they are to perform the duties and exercise those responsibilities that are assigned to it by law assign students enter into agreements and and and do those things that it does as a board which is made clear by 101 42 which says the powers and duties of the district school board is the district school board acting as a board shall exercise all powers and perform all duties listed below there are no duties for an
106individual Schoolboard member that that's where you're free to have your opinion and express your opinion but in terms of exercising The Authority The Authority is exercised by a majority of the board which gets us into the legislative function that's carried through all the way through that 1 1.43 they they put it it says the school board May exercise the following supplemental powers and duties as authorized by this code or State Board of Education Rule now there's also statutory pronouncements with respect to what the superintendent does and in 1.48 it says the district school superintendent shall be the secretary and executive officer of the district school board provided that when the district school superintend is required to be absent on account of etc etc there is a provision that'll be made to that but with respect
107to the the the duties of secretary and and the ex official membership on the board that is again something to prescribe by off as is the executive officer of the School's district because that's what the system entails the uh the general Powers again which is 1,149 the general powers of the district tool superintendent are again put together in a law that that makes you pay attention to the to the uh the verbs that are used in the statute and number one is the general ex oversight which is exercise General oversight over the district school system in order to determine problems and needs and recommend improvements advise counsel and recommend to The District School Board recommend policies recommend and execute rules recommend and execute minimum standards and perform recommend and execute rules recommend and execute minimum
108standards and perform duties and responsibilities as are assigned to the district school superintendent by law and by rules of the State Board of Education so you have this system that has the over and over statement of the provisions of the statute that that put the superintendent in a position where the superintendent is the one who brings recommendations and and you have a right to require those recommendations as a board you have a right to consider those recommendations as a board and you have a right to to to when there's reason to do so to reject those recommendations but the the system doesn't encounter doesn't include a way by which an individual Schoolboard member acting alone can can get any of these things done the again 1,151 is is another statute that deals with the district
109school superintendent and the powers and duties and and they're the verbs are again that in that she's to assist in the organization she's to attend all school board members she's to keep minutes she's to act for The District's School Board as custodian of school property she's to supervise the assembling of data she's to recommend the establishment organization and operation of such schools classes and services as are needed to provide adequate educational and importantly be responsible as required herein for directing the work of the Personnel subject to the requirements of chapter 1012 and again again in in the in the context of the school code the school board has only one employee that they're required and that is the the superintendent and then two others that are by choice which is a the is number of
110attorneys that you all want to have and also the the general auditor the auditor if you want to have that all the other employees are employed in positions that this board board determines as a majority of the board because there can't be something to hire a position into until this board decides they want to do it acting on a recommendation but with respect to the hiring and the directing of supervision that's not the job of an individual Schoolboard member and it's not job even of the school district except acting through the school board I should say acting through the superintendent and the long list of of powers which is the same verbs that are used over and over again all come down to the same thing and and I said that we wanted to talk
111about Personnel in particular because I think it's it's it's it's one of the the most unique aspects of a of a unique system and it's 10222 and it's called Public School personnel powers and duties of the school board and the district school board shall designate positions to be filled prescribe qualifications for those positions and provide for the appointment compensation promotion suspension and dismissal of employees as follows subject to the requirements of this chapter and then when you go down to a positions qualifications and appointments it begins with the district school board shall act upon written recommendations submitted by the school board superintendent for positions to be filled for minimum qualifications for personnel for the various positions and for the persons nominated to fill such positions number two is the district school board May reject for
112good cause any employee nominated and and we'll get into the next slide is going to be the uh a a statement of of what we're talking about with good cause and then it goes on to say if the third nomination by the district school superintendent for any position is rejected for good cause if the district school superintendent fails to submit a nomination for initial employment within a reasonable time as prescribed by the district school board or if the district school superintendent fails to submit a nomination for Reemployment within the time prescribed by law The District School Board May proceed on its own motion to fill a such position but those are the only times so so with respect to Personnel the the school code envisions a system where it does doesn't begin until the school
113board decides that there is a position the school board decides that the position is to be filled and the school board decides when that position is to be filled but with respect to the filling of it that's when you get into the superintendant who has to submit a written recommendation and and again this is the only statute I know of in in the entire Florida statute book that that talks about the governing body needing good cause to reject a recommendation on personnel and and needing to reject it three times before they can act and and like uh the uh other things we've been talking about the uh the attorney general has consistently read that and and read that the way it's written and I've given you a 2001 opinion which uh involved a situation as
114to whether the role of the superintendent of the school board was different on something like a transfer and and did did did there have to be good cause to the recommendation and and the board and the Attorney General came down again reading the unique system we have in Florida as saying that in the absence of a showing a good cause the school board must accept employment recommendations including transfers made by the superintendent the case that was involved in that or the question that was involved in that attorney general's opinion was was one where the superintendent had suspended an employee under emergency circumstances until the next regular special meeting and and the the question came up as to who had the power and and again the system dictated that what happened was is the superintendent can
115only suspend an employee until the next Schoolboard meeting because now we're not talking about hiring now we're talking about about taking that person out of the position and so the superintendent only has the power to suspend that person until the next school board meeting and then at that Schoolboard meeting the Schoolboard has to decide whether or not they want to suspend that person Andor terminate that person and that's an exclusive authority of the school board at that point acting as a board and that's not subject to the good cause requirement that's something where it's a matter of governance where the Schoolboard has to decide that but but the situation sort of I think illustrates the division that the that the legislature envisioned in terms of who has the power to do what and when and
116under what circumstances I think that it's important that uh you consider when you're talking about your way of work and and the policies that that you want to develop 10142 5 is entitled individuals authorized to visit schools and it says an individual member and this is like one of the few times when an individual School Board member is mentioned but it says an individual member of a district school board May on any day and at any time of his or her pleasure visit any school district in his or her school district and then it goes on to say an individual visiting a school must sign in and sign out at the school's main office and wear his or her identification badge while present on school premises and the the board the school or any other
117person including but not limited to the principal of the school may not require an individual visiting the school pursuant to this section to provide notice and the school may offer but may not require an escort to accompany an individual visiting the school pursuant to the section during the visit what's important in that in that statute is that it's it's interpreted in the context of all the other things we've been talking about so there is no question that a that a individual Schoolboard member has the right to visit a school whenever he or she thinks it's appropriate to visit that school and the person is there not to supervise not to direct the work but to observe and and of course it's all consistent with the with the the school board member or the legislator T
118who also had to be given the permission in terms of what's going on is that they don't have the power to interfere with the operation of the school or to question particular people or or to to do whatever they want to do in terms of fact finding they're there to observe and and they're there to observe without any kind of limitation whatsoever but they're there to observe as opposed to manage and direct and the same kind of thinking I think goes into this next Attorney General's opinion which is in 2006 which talks about a school board member requesting member records and again it it focuses on the difference between the power of the of the school board versus the power of an individual Schoolboard member and what what this attorney general opinion says is is
119that as an individual member the school board member has a right to request records but only to the same extent that a citizen has which is to say you do it at your own expense and and you do it with respect to those documents that are that are there with respect to already in the context of already being in existence as opposed to creating and the the opinion says that an individual Schoolboard member can't require the creation of public records because again it is but the thing I want to leave you all is is that acting as a board with respect to the majority of the board in terms of adopting ways of work this board by a majority vote has the ability to set those confines they can't restrict the right of an individual
120board member as a as a citizen but they can certainly provide for a way of having things done in a way they want to have it done by the vote and again the March 28th 20 12 opinion is the uh is one involving a a situation where an individual Schoolboard member wanted to have a town hall question and answer session on school facilities and and the Attorney General found that in that context the individual had no right to use the Schoolboard property for for those purposes in terms of what's going on and again it was going back to the power of the superintendent to control access subject to the way of work that the that the majority of this board wants to have with respect to those kinds of events and and it goes over
121into uh situations where the uh where the the individual Schoolboard member on any number of occasions you know gets asked to to speak in terms of this kind of stuff and to discuss matters and and the two things I leave you with is number one it it's it's most important so that you don't get in trouble with the government of Sunshine Law is that whenever two of you all are in the same place and and and the discussion that you're involved in involves things that are to be coming from the board then that conversation is subject to government of sunshine and it can't be done without prior notice without the agenda requirements that you have with respect to this kind of stuff and and when you're speaking as an individual board member It's always important
122to remember that you're not speaking for the board because no one and and frankly not even the chair has any authority to speak for the school board in terms of what's going on because the the the things that are being taken are going to be taken by majority vote of what's going on in terms of the the situation that's involved and and lastly the the uh the thing I wanted to talk about because I think it's it's really important is that in in light of the the relative powers and Authority that you all have is is that this 1997 attorney general opinion makes real real clear that individual board members don't have an attorney client privilege when they're talking with the Schoolboard attorney or with a general counsel because the The General Counsel and the
123Schoolboard attorney only answers to the board which by the way the board is the only the only entity that has the authority to hire legal counsel in terms of what's going on but it's the the board's attorney it's the board's general counsel and an individual talking with them doesn't have any kind of attorney client privilege with respect to those people and uh that in a nutshell I hope is basically what the uh the legislature has has given us for good or ill and and I again I I I just can't emphasize enough how much I think things got changed by the imposition of government in the sunshine and I'm not saying that those are bad laws I'm just saying that those things made it more difficult and I think that it's worth noting that the
124legislature made sure that they're not subject to government in the sunshine in terms of what's going on but it's a it's a difficult situation where you have a a scheme that's that's very very clear that that individual members of a of a governing body they can get in trouble for violating the the government of the sunshine but they can't do anything individually either and so I I commend you as I do all Schoolboard members for your service because it it is really really a tough job and I thank you for the invitation thank you Miss brosme I have one question about the um the the ability to use to hold public meetings or you know um Community chats uh using school facilities uh do we have a policy that addresses that I guess that's my
125first question um that addresses the ability of um of the board or the need for the board to approve or disapprove the use the reason I'm asking is because I I have um last night for instance I attended a a town hall that was held by my district commissioner uh dis I'm sorry a district um County council member and I have to assume that the other County council members know not to show up at his meeting because of sunshine and and he wouldn't be able to to necessarily hold that meeting do we have a policy that addresses uh the ability of a school board member to hold any kind of a meeting town hall meeting like that in a school facility not that I'm a go ahead Dr Evans we have a pro a process
126but go ahead Dr Evans I don't think we we have a specific policy on that but we do have a process by which you have to follow in order to okay well I can check with you about that um I was just when I read this I was just curious to know whether we already had addressed it or have a structure for it so if we have a process then that kind of answers my question thank you Mr clone and so I want to thank you Mr Gonzalez that was a great presentation and and though I think we get bits and pieces of that at FS SBA um definitely you know sometimes when you're in the big room with lots of people and you know it's late in the day and you're tired or it's
127early in the morning and you're tired or whatever the case may be it's easy for some of this so again I appreciated it's definitely uh complicated um and I think for not only our benefit for that of the public to realize that you know we are who we are not as individuals but as a board and and that as individuals we have it sounds really bad but there is based on the law we have no power as individuals and so that's where the strength of us working together as you were able to witness this morning I mean we you know our meetings do last a little did let me take that back our meetings did last a little bit longer than other folks but it's because we really truly do beat some of this up
128um here as we should and so I want to thank you for that um I want to go to the section where you talked about visiting schools and so uh my question uh to the superintendent you know we're we're very blessed in that we have an amazing superintendent and we have an amazing board and um you know in some instances you know we're we're too blessed I don't know if that's a thing if you can be too blessed because you know there are no limitations on you know I could say to a principal hey I'm in the neighborhood I'm stopping in but as I hear what the law says I guess my question for the superintendent is is there a way that we can make this better I don't think I've ever heard of anybody
129say Ruben stopped in and I wasn't expecting them they stopped rolling out the red carpet a long time ago so that's not an an issue but as we talk about our way of work which you know as you use the term the verb many many times is there a way that we can optimize uh that for your staff and your team to not be I mean again I've never heard anybody complain but maybe they're just not telling me to my face Mr mcalli okay went R and just shows up so I'm I'm curious if there's a way we can uh optimize that so I will share with you as as you know Mr colong and those of you on the board I meet I have my principal counsel that I meet with on a monthly
130basis and you guys have been really good I think for the most part you're visiting a school you'll you'll let the principal know that you're visiting the school what was brought up it's if we can consistently do that and here's the reason why sometimes principles may not be at their school that that day they they're planing and I mean I've shown up honestly and I'm guilty of it where I didn't tell them in advance and I showed up and they're not there so they they said you know in situations like that they would like to be able to know if someone is planning to visit so that they can at least talk to their AP or someone else and know to kind of expect that person that that person will be there and whatever time
131that it would be or if they need to tell you you know what you may not want to come today because we're going to have a field day or whatever the case may be they'll let you know but at least that that communication is established and I think I like to and and actually this is I'm glad you're asking me because this was just last month just before the break that this was one of the this the recommendations or suggestions that they share with me if we can consistently do that moving forward just notify them that you are going to be visiting their school so that they're aware and it could be via text or an email but just let them know wonder if we can come up with Dr and his fancy a process
132folks have an app or something that we could quickly just say and and you know sometimes it's and I could see where that would be helpful like sometimes like for example I want to speak to the Food Service person regarding food service and so typically we just call Patty and Patty makes the connection Etc but if if there was a way that I could say hey I've got some questions for schoolway Cafe you know I'd like to request a meeting a call whatever the case may be I wonder if there's a way because you know sometimes things come up as you think about them and you know also calling someone in the middle of the day and you know they may be in a meeting cabinet I know I always get I'm in cabinet and
133so you know if if I think that would make it work I think that would make it easier for us if we knew what department we wanted maybe and again I'm thinking in the world of rainbows and unicorns but maybe a Google form or something that we could just and then that can be linked to the people who need to know that we've requested ested to visit Deltona High specifically their football now I don't think that applies to football games because that's a public event or any you know those things are public I mean let's be real but um I I could see that as something that may be able that we may be able to optimize that'll be good for everybody and actually that to your point Miss brosmer actually that would that would
134to make sure to ensure that we're not violating sunshine I think having a process like that would would really be very fitting to what you were discussing earlier and and i would support the ability to do that and and the rule with Sunshine is it has to be publicly noticed and minutes need to be taken so something like a town hall you just have to make sure somebody's taking minutes and it's publicly noticed and then I could be there now I can't speak or let me take it back you shouldn't speak so normally you're there to listen and support the the person who's doing their Town Hall um which you know we have when we did public meetings for uh the the Zoning for example myself and Miss Haynes were there and we ensured we
135said make sure somebody writes down minutes so that we because it does constitute a me a meeting at that point but I I would be supportive of of that and so I don't think that's an issue and so if that's something we want to bring forth going back to we just got schooled it would have to come before the board to uh create that process by which we you know say I think that's a great idea let's all do that or whoever wants to do it for that matter and I would be supportive of that so again go ahead if I if I could just because it's it's on that topic because I think it's worth telling you all because it it shows the lengths that that the the government in Florida have gone with
136respect to government of sunshine but there was a school district that wanted to have a tour of schools an architectural tour and so they arranged for a bus and they got the Schoolboard members to make sure they sat five rows apart and they had members of the press there and it didn't do them any good it was found to be a violation of the government's Sunshine so it's just unfortunately unfortunately you know the law doesn't presume yall's good intention and good faith and and when they got when there are two or more of God's children in the same place and they're public officials then then somebody's going to suggest that you're you're doing stuff in violation of the government of the sunshine and again which is you know know I I don't I hate and
137I've told this to legislators but I mean just the the fact that the that the legislature understands that that's a really tough way to operate a government I think tells you all you need to know about about how hard it is the job you all have to do and and to add I think there are also violations um there are consequences for violating the Sunshine Law that are specifically outlined in Florida statute and it might be good as Mr cologne and a superintendent recommended so if you know you're going to be speaking somewhere um it might be good to let the district know and maybe we can go over those kind of things with you because sometimes we have good intent but it could still be a violation but it could be where more than
138one individual is invited from the board and the other individual doesn't know doesn't know it's a challenges when you're speaking example we do the mar Martin Luther King event and so that's we're not necessar I mean we're congratulating kids on their scholarship so that is not a you know that it it I don't think it goes that far I think but it's it's that speaking component and so um in fact there was ones that uh I think I even walked out of the room or something at one point when somebody was speaking just to not give that you know but uh yeah so but I think again I think even that fancy Google form or whatever we decide to use may be good because that's a way that we can communicate and then those can
139be routed to you know if you select this box it goes to I'm just thinking fancy what can make it easy so I'll ask Dr to something that's not cumbersome that's very simplistic in nature and then we will share with each board member to to get their thoughts does that work for all of you and that's all I had so I yeah so what I wanted to say to that is it well I think we have um in general we give a a courtesy of letting a school know when we come to visit them I think if we created um a document that was even insinuated to be required to fill out that would actually violate the statute here can you help with some clarification on that because the state statute says that any individual
140member of District School Board at any time at his or her pleasure visit any District school so if we then created something that you had to fill out while I think we're following that in general and I think that that's a great courtesy that we should continue to follow I don't see how we could Implement something when the state statute says that so I don't want to waste any time creating something we can't Implement anyway as a requirement you mean yeah yes yes ma'am I agree with that yeah if it was a requirement if if it just a courtesy yeah if it's something that's written into a way of work to saying that you know that they're you're asked to do it but as as long as it's real clear that the statute says what
141the statute says and a school board member can visit that school I would say there's people that are going to show the courtesy or not so creating a form maybe just to let someone know but I don't know that I want to have staff do a tremendous amount of work of something that's not even enforcable miss brosmer I um I want to go back to the town hall thing for just a minute um in addition to the County council member who the the one I Know Who Holds these meetings I don't know if anybody else does I know of several Mayors who do as as well so I know that it's okay to do it and as I said presumably other board members would know not to attend uh but I I just want to
142make sure that I understand correctly that um if if I'm holding a meeting like that for purposes of not of speaking for the board but of getting input from from constituents from voters uh from parents then I have to assume that I'm not violating anything or stepping on any inappropriate Toes or anything like that um which would be the primary purpose for having a a town hall it's like H doing a a public comment section that that is just a little more in depth than 3 minutes so anyway I just wanted to be clear about you're you're absolutely right as long as long as you you you absolutely have the right to listen to anybody that wants to talk to you at your choosing and and there's no violation and in fact I've go so
143far as you know you can you can have two public officials if if I come up to two public officials and start ranning and raving you can both listen to me and stand silent you haven't violated anything talks you know as long as as long as you don't discuss as long as you don't turn to the other public official and say gez what I you know I think we ought to do this that's when you run into it but no ma'am you can you absolutely that's that's you know you have a lot of a lot of maybe restrictions on what you can do but with respect to obligations absolutely you listen to your constituents in terms of what's going on and I think you have to be very meticulous even in listening to make sure
144that you don't respond and start talking about things that are being discussed at board meetings because once you begin to discuss those things that could be a violation especially if there is another board member there but listening think as he said that's perfectly okay but we it's human nature to start trying to explain and then when you start explaining and talking that could potentially be a violation and the the permutations are are endless in in in the context you're talking about if if the public official knows that whatever she says to Tom he's going to tell another Hey I was talking to the Schoolboard member this other school board member and she's for it then that's that's a violation of the of the of the public government sunshine when you're conveying those those conversations to
145an intermediator good rich just some clarification so if I'm going to a fundraiser that's not Schoolboard related and another Schoolboard member is there I don't know what everyone's going to at all given moments What's the protocol what do we do in that scenario don't go off in a corner together yeah deal corit to him across the room you know okay we don't have to announce that obviously because absolutely not because I mean theoretically theoretically if you wanted to if you wanted to to get with them and and talk about anything other than something that's going to come to the board that's not a violation the problems in the perception and the fact that there are people out there who are just looking for something to say about about what you're violating thank you Mr Gonzalez
146and I would like to clarify um um one thing for all of you so Sarah and her team each week ask Karen Karen is our executive secretary here um to give them a list of where we're going to be and what we're going to be doing so that they actually post it on the website noticing it especially in the event two three all five of us are going to be at the same location so it's very important that when um we receive receive you know calendar invites to things that we go ahead and if we're going to be there accept them because they get that information a week like they get it for on Friday for the next week so that they can post it and it can be posted for the time that we
147have to post it so the community can see where we're going to be together because there have been over the years um especially during Co where public records requests were made of our calendars to so people could see where were we where were we not were we together here well if we were together at this event what were we doing there and things like that and so I would just like to encourage each of you I know sometimes when you first get it you may not know if you're going and it or you may know immediately I'm not going to attend and you decline it or you may put the maybe on there but please to help better help them because they're trying to follow the law on behalf of us please accept your invite
148so that they can know and they can publish them and that way we don't end up in any kind of Sunshine Law violation but thank you thank you thank you Mr Gonzalez you have a question no oh okay all right then if there's no further discussion about this topic it is now 3:06 pm we are adjourned and we will be back in the boardroom at 4:30 p.m. for the school board meeting thank you