CorpusRecord 1915

Volusia County School Board - The Volusia County School Regular Session 01⧸14⧸2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Volusia County School Board
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Volusia County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,929 words · about 106 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e [Applause] good evening at this time would you please find a seat today is Tuesday January 14th 2025 Happy New Year to to everyone the time now is 4:35 p.m. and I'm calling to order the meeting of the valuch County School Board in just a moment I'm going to ask that you please join me in standing for the Pledge of Allegiance please remain standing for the national anthem and then um following that we will have a moment of silence and reflection and today our moment of silence and ref reflection we're going to dedicate to the student from Ain Elementary the third grader who lost his life yesterday so at this time please stand and join me thank you greeetings from Spruce Creek Elementary School my name is Andrea Hall and I the very

002proud principal here I here with Nicole Hayes teacher and her wonderful kindergarten classroom and also here with us is blae the speech and language therapy dog I PL allegiance to the flag United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all see light what so broadly we held at the Twilight last gleaming proes and bright stars through the par of fight or the r parts we watch were so G streaming and rocket the boms buring in prove through the night that our flag was still there oh say does that store Spangled for the land of [Applause] the and the home of the brave [Applause] thank you you may be seated and I'd like to ask that we give one more round of

003applause to miss Jacqueline LEF who's a student at danan [Applause] College you did an Absol absolutely beautiful job and we appreciate you coming tonight to do the national anthem for us so at this time I'd like to take a moment to introduce the board members that are here with me I'm going to start on my far left we have Mrs Donna brosmer who represents District 4 Mrs Christa Goodrich who represents District 2 we have our Schoolboard attorney Dr Gilbert Evans moving over to my far right we have Mrs Celeste Gilmore our agency clerk next to her we have Mrs Jesse Thompson representing District 3 we have our vice chair Mr Ruben cologne representing District Five and then we have our superintendent immediately to my right Dr Carmen balaman I am Jamie Haynes and I represent

004district one and I'm your chair at this time items for approval on this agenda tonight are items 1.03 2.02 5.01 7.02 19.1 and 19.02 public participation times for there will be public participation for any any item that is on the consent agenda you just need to see Miss Sarah Lux who's over here on the far right and you'll fill out a green card um we also have a 6 pm time for items of general interest pertaining to public education in valuch County at that time we can allow a total of up to 15 minutes for public input time is also provided for public comment on any action item before a board vote is called on that item and finally time will be proved invited at the end of the meeting for public comment for items

005of general interest pertaining to public education in Valia County before any items from the board superintendent or attorney are up for discussion or announcement our district vision statement is to create lifelong learners for an everchanging Global society and at this time I'd like to invite any of the board members to share anything that they would like to share about what they've been doing since they returned from winter break Mrs Thompson thank you and welcome everyone thank you for being here today I just had a couple quick things um one I went to the new smna beach girls soccer five-star championship and it was against Spruce Creek and those are both my high schools very entertaining all tremendous athletes with great footwork uh but new SMA Beach was Victorious as was the boys soccer team against

006FPC so congratulations to you guys I know we'll probably touch on this because we were all there but uh we had the Teacher of the Year this past weekend and Jeremy Davies from Spruce Creek won that so congratulations to all the teachers of the year um and congratulations to our teacher of the year I know he'll make us all proud and then last but certainly certainly not least uh corado Beach Elementary participated in the state beta um convention and so you had these young kids from all over the state competing in a variety there was Art there was speaking music dance um so really talented kids and what I took away from it was all these kids none of them were on phones or tablets they were interacting with each other which is really nice

007to see all day and Coronado Beach had kids in first second third that place that are going on to State finals so congratulations to them as well as five of our teachers there were awarded the beta um State educators of excellence awards so congratulations to all of you and that's all I have for now thank you Mrs good Rich so I recently got to attend um a pre-show of our thir 36 young stomp contestants and they went over to Tampa and competed um it was an incredible show of percussion ISM so it was really fun to attend I also got to go visit Long Street um for their teacher of the year party and Long Street knows how to throw a party it was a great time so I was very excited to be there

008congrats to all of our teachers of the year just remarkable individuals I so glad I didn't have to choose the one because there were so many great people to choose from but an exceptional congratulations to our overall teacher of the year and then I did get to spend a day up in St John's County um visiting with some of their school board members some of their Administration and was able to learn a tremendous amount about what they're doing in some of their ESC programs and some things that are afforded to their ESC students both while they're through high school and then if they extend their high school for an extra period of time and we were able to take that information and are looking into what it would take to offer similar programs here in

009valua so our ESC parents out there just know there's a lot that we're working on right now um and that's basically what I have I hope everyone's having a great new year sticking with their resolutions if they made them Mrs brosmer I want to just add U with regard to the teacher of the year that it was just a blast it was like a giant pep rally and and it was great fun and the teachers were wonderful and it was it was fun to see them honored um considering the uh the Fantastic work they do uh and sort of along those same lines uh the Orman chamber um does a teacher of the quarter and they they surprise the teacher and I was invited to go along with them and that was really fun and

010at one point we went to each of the Orman each of the schools in Orman Beach um because they each had a teacher of the quarter uh but at one point in one of the fourth grade classes uh we looked up we were standing in front and getting our picture taken with the teacher of the quter and we looked up and the kids are all lined up with their iPads in front of them taking pictures of us so that was fun um and uh and then last week I attended the induction ceremony for the Junior Honor Society at Holly Hill school and that they had um about 30 kids who were inducted which was wonderful and what was really special was to see the family support they had and I want to in particular um

011extend my thanks to principal deetz for allowing me I just kind of showed up and uh she invited me to participate in the receiving line where I got to congratulate all the kids so that was really fun too and that's all I have Mr cologne so uh a little bit of an angle on the stomp presentation of course the kids were were amazing but special shout out to the teachers and the parents and the and this and our Fine Arts staff uh who supported uh getting these students to the Florida music educators conference I know I probably did not do that Justice I'm sure there's an acronym for it somewhere uh but our students had the ability to go to Tampa and present that stomp presentation in front of 10,000 uh music teachers no pressure

012and so shout out to them for that uh had the honor of uh attending the food uh brings Hope Community where as you know uh food brings hope and uh food brings Hope Community does a lot uh to support our our schools our students our teachers the Leman Center so uh that was a wonderful event shout out to Miss Victoria Seno as always who uh was awarded the Florida Orchestra Association s first annual Rising Star Award and so uh for those of you that don't know she built the program at uh Delona middle from the ground up and now their Orchestra programs just busting at the seams and so uh special shout out to her graduation rate I'm sure the superintendent has a wonderful uh report on that our teacher of the year event I

013little bit of a spin on that because yes it was a wonderful event but I want to say thank you to the Futures Foundation who uh helps us along with uh the many sponsors with Advent Health being uh the premier sponsor you heard that Miss Bernett and so uh it was she's not sitting next to me anymore so we could just and so uh and so no it was a it was a great event and as well as I want to thank uh Bob Davis the Daytona hospitality lodging and Hospitality Association who also along with uh PR D PRM hotels which they own several uh hotels in Daytona they donated uh stays for our five finalists teacher of the year uh and so that was H super exciting and last but not least we were

014at Blue Lake Elementary uh and is there a video for that um I don't think they have it for for this meeting but for the next we will so do you have that in your announcements I'll let Jamie give that one then all right I'm done thank you okay thank you all right I'll try to hit on the things that haven't already been spoken about uh Taylor Middle High School won an award from T-Mobile for $5,000 for um entering a contest they had and part of it was communicating about the positive things going on at your school especially in the Athletics and sports areas and so they um competed this year and T-Mobile came out and gave them a $5,000 check they are hoping to compete again next year because the top winner got a

015$1 million check and so they're not going to give up they're going to continue to shoot for that also um I did have the chance um for any parents that may be listening or teachers and stuff I got the chance to walk um Stark Elementary because like the walls are up and I think the roof is mostly finished it's going to be absolutely a beautiful school for that community and we're looking forward to when that opens I also attended the future Business Leaders of America event um it was held this year here in Dand for our students to compete and it's a wonderful event and and the things that they learn and the way they learn how to communicate and present themselves is just absolutely wonderful and CTE gets the credit for putting that together

016I also did something new this year and it's the first middle school that's actually ever to the best of our knowledge done this we see this a lot at the elementary schools where they will have you come in they'll invite you to come in and read because it's about one book for one school well Delan midle this year they have a wonderful coach there that decided she was going to take on we're going to do one book for one school at danan middle so there are over a thousand students there and the book they selected was the mystery of rag Cliff riddle well they reached out to the author the author came she came to the event she was there signing books and meeting all of the students she actually read in some of the

017classrooms and what was really wonderful about it is every student received a copy of her book like when we typically read at elementary schools we go in with one book and we leave that book with the teacher because the teacher's going to continue to read and do activities well at the middle school we put a book book in every student's hands and the first thing we said when we handed them out was take your pen out and write your name in it because the book now belongs to you and the teacher the ELA teachers have prepared all these activities for them to be doing each day that align with the standards and the book and they're going to have a literacy night to sum it all up and the author is coming back for the

018literacy night because she it was she spoke and it was just adorable she's like I hear about you know people's books being selected and always thought I'd love to have my book selected and she goes when they called me I was likees I'm coming and so that was a great event and the kids were really excited about the book so if you've never read it uh you might want to check it out and then um yes Mr clone and I on Friday were over first at the warehouse where there are 168 there were 168 brand new bicycles you know Mr mcalli has a wonderful attendance in initiative going on principles you've embraced it you're doing a fabulous job sharing on social media about students being there every day parents we want to thank you for

019those of you that are getting your kids to school on time but we know still there's always some barriers that keep some of of our children from being able to get to school on time so Advent Health stepped up and they started with 168 bicycles and we took the first two over to Blue Lake Elementary and they were both given to two young ladies that are in fourth grade and what was so interesting was when we finished they both said we're going to be here by 7:30 Monday morning riding our new bikes so we'll be here in time for breakfast and we won't be late to school and there's nothing more heartwarming to know that kids can already start to take care of that piece if Mom and Dad can't because they may work and

020things like that and so a big shout out to Advent health for partnering and providing those bikes for students um I thought Miss Goodrich was going to announce this one but and I don't think you did Thursday night where we went what P Reflections oh yes oh yes yeah I did oh can I say it yes okay yes I did forget that one I'm sorry I'm sorry there's been so many things that we've been to lately um so we did Reflections PTA Reflections and it was a beautiful fantastic event thank you for letting me steal the mic on this um we have some incred incredibly talented children as everyone knows and and to see what they had created with the topic they were given it was um the topic was about imperfection and I will

021tell you that there may have been imperfection in some things but these were perfect kids in what they did so it was it was beautiful thank you for reminding me of that I'm sorry there's been just a lot no it's there's a lot going on and it's wonderful to share all the things but those students that won the awards that night there was one little girl actually that walked across the state for three different categories uh she won in three different categories and that you can just see their excitement because some of these are kids that may never compete in something else but they competed in that and to see their artwork or the stories they'd written were just beautiful one final thing um as I wrap up is we are always um the auditor

022general comes you know to audit BL County schools and most recently we were audited on operational and financial and so I had to attend um the exit meeting for that and I want to say thank you to every individual that works on collecting all of the correct information following the correct rules under operations and finance because it's a lot of work because they're here for many months with us asking for receipts for this and Co copies of contracts for that but um the auditor general um gave us a really good report there will be a final like report coming out that we'll all each receive so that we can see it you know I can't ever say that like there's never some little finding that they find because they look at even what happens on

023every school campus but there was nothing that was a surprise and it's just you have to take when they find something and say okay how are we going to correct that and have a solution for it but I do want to thank everyone that was involved in that thank you so at this time we're moving on to item 1.03 approval of the minutes we have the minutes from um the special session the workshop and the regular session that all happened on December 10th at this time I need a motion to approve the minutes a motion to approve the minutes thank you Miss goodr do we have a second I'll second that motion thank you Miss Thompson any discussion okay hearing none I'll call for the vote all of those in favor of approving the minutes

024as presented for the December 10th special session workshop and regular session please say I I I any opposed okay then it passes unanimously then we are moving on to item 2.01 agenda changes Dr balaman are there any agenda changes at this time Madam chair I would like to request that we pull it item 19.1 which is the adoption of school board policy 320 media selection of print and non-print material materials um we're going to undergo a further review as we have received recently some additional information that could further clarify our policy changes and procedures so it will be brought back at another meeting are there any other items that's the only one that I have okay so board members hearing the recommendation of the superintendent she's asking that we are going to pull item 19.0

025one and if none of you have any other things that you'd like to pull then I'd like someone to make a motion to approve the agenda as presented with the removal of item 19.1 no moved thank you Mrs brosmer do we have a second a second thank you Mrs Goodrich any discussion hearing none I'll call for the vote all those in favor please say I I any opposed it passes unanimously we're now moving down to item 3.01 Dr balaman it's time for your announcements thank you madam chair board members members of the audience so many familiar faces here in the audience today happy New Year all of you and for those of you listening at home I hope that you had a relaxing winter break and that you enjoy some quality time with family and

026friends which is what it's all about um with this new year as we know there is lots of exciting opportunities for growth Miss Miss uh Goodridge you spoke about one of them from our most recent visit but also opportunities to enhance learning and successes across all of our schools so I want to thank all of our stakeholders for being a part of that process and with that said we know that recently we've obtained as you mentioned Mr colong our 20 2324 grad rates and I will share with you that valua county has um seen an impressive 93.7% on our grad rate which is an uh increase from a 91 .6 previous year [Applause] um truly we know that this is the collective effort of a prek through 12 system but we'll talk a little bit

027more about that in a second um in addition to that um in our ranking we're looking at we're in the top 10 in the State of Florida out of 67 we're top 10 and we're the second highest in the central Florida Coalition which is all the schools in the central Florida Co Coalition were the SI second highest scores um congratulation goes out to these schools nine out of our 10 uh High Schools traditional high schools seen an impressive um um increase in their grats rate so I will call them out but if you don't mind let's wait until the end to give them a round of applause so congratulations go goes out to and I see the principal proud principal and his team is here um Atlantic High School who is in Peru from a

02893.6 to a 96.5 % the land high school that went from a 95% to a 96.5% Deltona High School that went from a 99.7% to 100% Mainland High School that went from a 91.5% to a 94.8% new samna beach high from a 94.6% to a 97.2% Pine Ridge High School went from a 93.4% to a 97 .8% C PR's high school went from a 93.7% to a 97.8% Taylor Middle High went from 89.7% to an 89.8% University High School say the principal back there with her team from a 92.6% to a 96% um we had a uh Spruce Greek high school that was a 98.6% last year and now it's a 95 . 1% so they've experienced a very slight decrease let's look at our subgroups data this is pretty impressive as well when you

029look at our English language Learners as a subgroup they experienced a 3.1% increase for that subgroup um when you look at our black Essa subgroup they've experienced a 1.9% increase and when you look at the exceptional student education they've increased a 2% increase and our Essa uh White subgroup at 2.2% so really this is the collective effort of everyone as I've stated prek through 12 but we've got our District staff that supports our school-based staff so congratulations to our district staffs congratulations to our school-based staff all of our teachers PA professionals all staff members our parents our parents supports this educational process so thank you to all of our parents and most importantly to the individuals that that that engages and does the work daily and those are our students a special congratulations to all

030of our students now with that said you will see that at the end of this month Mr malli and his team they will do a full presentation in terms of State of Florida statue what what are the graduation requirements what are the systems that we've put in place here in valua County I get often asked when I when I go to other districts they will say well Dr B your scores look really great what is it that you're doing stay tuned for the next board meeting because one of the things that I will tell you and I've stated this before is the monitoring systems and communication process that we have established here it's it's in a very granular form and you will learn about that and pretty much how how we work together with with

031all entities all stakeholders but that's coming at the end of this month in addition to that our teacher of the area absolutely right thank you to all of our board members that were there there thank you to our futures foundation for always putting on a great event very classy and great event thank you so very much and to all of the families and friends and and all of the nominees that were there I want to congratulate all of you and the five the five finalist were Katie Adams or is Katie Adams our fourth grade teacher from citus Grove Elementary Melissa SE from English language arts teacher from Greek side middle Shilpa Sharma she's an ESC teacher from Galaxy middle uh Jeremy Davis Matt teacher from Spruce Greek high and Kelly shahal A Gifted teacher from

032tamoka elementary and it was we know we proudly select celebrated all of these teachers and but we want to thank them for their dedication their dedication to students learning to their families but most importantly for choosing vucha County public schools with that said said we know that we all congratulate there's got to be one I I talked about maybe we need to consider more than one because all of these teachers are truly exceptional but Jeremy Davis um he received a 2026 teacher of the year um so congratulations Jeremy and to all of our nominees because really realistically any one of them would have been a proud representation for Teacher of the Year here for Bia County Public Schools I'm not going to elaborate a whole lot because we did talk about Advent help but I

033do want to share with you and we just received this information that not only 168 bikes but I will tell you that 168 helmets and a 168 locks that were provided also because when we made that notation to Advent that you know we want to secure these bikes immediately they went back the following morning and purchased 168 locks so I want to thank them for their partnership because I always say that it takes the village and most importantly I will always say this not everybody in the village it takes all the right people in the village to ensure that students are successful and Advent definitely they've been doing a really really good job as partners with us in addition to that we have also experienced uh we set out a 10% goal to reduce chronic

034absenteeism by 10% and as we review our data for the first half of the year the first semester we've noticed that we have already seen a 5% decrease so Mr Malla and the entire team and all of our school-based team and everyone that's doing this work thank you so very much and we also received an invitation where we will be presenting for other school districts at fats on what we're doing in terms of chronic absen ISM and that's going to be in February okay another thing to be very proud of we know that we're one of those few districts that has an AI policy in place right and we said that with AI it's not going to go away guys it's there but how do we utilize and leverage this tool to enhance learning experiences

035for students so you're going to see that we're going to be presenting I believe and we're attending a conference in April that we've been invited to to attend but you're going to see that there is this program called reading progress and how that program is working with AI to provide real time feedback to students to differentiate their reading experiences and we have a short video that we will show you at the end but this was filmed actually at Timber um Crest yeah Elementary but our principles went back with our AI policy and devised systems in place so that their teachers could truly Implement these policies after training so Kudos and congratulations to all of our principles and their staff right for taking this policy and saying how do we use Ai and leverage it with

036other tools to enhance learning experiences for students so you're going to see that short video one minute and 56 seconds in a little bit and also some important dates to remember January is National mentoring month and School Board appreciation month and I've always said this I work with Schoolboard members I've been in this business for 26 years there there's a lot of work that our Schoolboard members do behind the scene this is not it these folks are constantly working with me behind the scene and our team to ensure that our mission is accomplished and for that I want you guys to know that the governance is truly important along with leadership for students to experience success and from the bottom of my heart and my entire team I want to say congratulations and thank you

037for the work that you do on stage but most importantly work that you do behind the stage to ensure that our students are successful so thank you very much um also January the 16th it's the Eide uh school choice fair and it's going to be at the news journal again this year from 5:30 to 7 so we know that the State of Florida is a choice State and we know that valua county is a choice District so parents if you're shopping around uh you want to see what what programs and what what special features our schools are offering when it comes to the educational needs of your children and you live on the east side please attend the fair um also January 20th which is the same date as my late um father who passed

038it's MLK's Jr his his birthday and my late father's birthday as well so because it's MLK's birthday and my late father all of you take the day off stay home keep your children safe we'll see you the following day and January 27th um Westside school choice Fair that's also going to be from 5:30 to 7 and that's going to be at the center for at Deltona and uh January 27th through the 31st is we're going to be celebrating literacy week and I will have more information for you upcoming we do have a short video because I did short Change you guys at the last board meeting so 1 minute 54 seconds this is on AI and that uh reading tool called reading progress part of this program is that thei is going to help listen

039to your words and help you improve by telling you what words you need to improve on Lily's heart raced with excitement as she reads to not the AI then analyzes a recording of that reading and in real time corrects the student on any word they mispronounced or weren't able to read breaks it up into syllables it pronounces for them it gives them a nonlinguistic representations so that real time correction makes sure that they're uh reinforced in their reading right then before they develop any bad habits in their reading after you finish reading it getes you a choice like oh would you like this happen or this it gives you options it gives you options and you like options you can choose yeah it goes into the language that they're going to speak and then at

040the end that the teacher has the option to also have comprehension questions whether they be in English or in the foreign language that they're learning look at that great practicing it also gives them ownership of it it gives them more opportunity to practice which increases their fluency if I want to add on comprehension questions I can use the AI to generate it it gives me different levels of questions I can do open response I can do multiple choice and then on top of that the computer grades it too you're a prime example how we have used this to enhance your experience and not take away skills from you but to add more skill set we're using the AI to uh create a culture of students who want to be here who want to learn and

041giving them tools to enhance that process to help them be the most successful that they can be next chapter A or [Music] [Applause] B and that's it Madam chair thank you Dr pman we're moving right along to item 4.01 Florida Council for instructional technology leaders the nominee for inov Innovative principle of the Year yes and I think he's here in the audience sitting right in the front row right there uh chair and board members and those of you in the audience I'm pleased to share with you that n other than our very own Mr Jason Watson is the principle as we all know the principal of Atlantic high school he has been named vucha County nominee for the 2025 Innovative principle of the Year by the Florida Council of instructional technology leaders so Mr Watson

042has been a part of the impactful initiative Atlantic like the student Tech assistant program you've heard of that Miss Haynes where trained students assist teachers with tech troubling troubleshooting and he has helped Atlantic also pioneered districtwide distance learning events for ELA students he has expanded that partnership program with also with Embry Riddle offering students real world experiences in flight and airplane digital maintenance so we want to say a special congratulations to Mr Jason Watson our very own for this very well-deserved recognition and for representing Bela County with excellence and Jason we have something for you it's not a check but we do have something for you so um if you would please come up with Matt Dr we would like to recognize you and take a picture with you star I think do you have

043someone you have folks from your school here also my wife is here join you get off thank you [Music] [Applause] now we are moving on to item 5 01 administrative appointments and transfers Dr Balaban yes thank you madam chair and I do have three items here um I would like to ask Mr Benjamin Carter to join us so I will share with you a little bit about Mr Carter he's obtained a bachelor's degree from the University of North Florida a master's degree from ston University he holds certification in the following are areas Ed leadership English speakers of other languages esol um English for grades 6 through 12 he started as a teacher at Edward white high in Duval County he's been with Valia County since 2015 where he started as a teacher at Delan High

044went on to become a teacher and assignment at University High then becoming an assistant principal at University high today board I'm recommending that Mr Benjamin Carter becomes a manager of Professional Standards and if approved his effective date will be January 15 2025 board members you've heard the recommendation of the superintendant do I have anyone that would like to make a motion I will gladly make that motion I'll second thank you Mr cologne thank you Mrs brosmer any discussion oh I'm sorry we're not um any discussion go ahead I'll let you and so uh you know we don't like giving anybody up on the west side but we are excited at the opportunity and and seeing you grow in to this position it's not an easy one it's not one folks that you know nobody calls

045Professional Standards just to say hi and so uh I want to thank you for stepping up I mean it's not it's not not an easy one you know to deal with your colleagues and all that comes along with it so again thank you and we look forward to uh seeing the good work so thank you it is hard when we lose someone especially someone from one of the schools and you've done you did a great job when you taught at dant high but then you went to University and look at all the things that you did there a lot I know anytime I was there you were there with your hand in the middle of everything making sure it happened and all of that and we so appreciate that but at the same time you

046are entering a job that doesn't actually give you a lot of friends at times and the fact that you stepped up and applied for the position and you've done the work to be there and I truly believe you'll do a great job in that position so thank you for agreeing to do that anyone else all right then we need to call for a vote all those in favor of Mr Benjamin Carter being um the manager for Professional Standards please say I I I any opposed it passes unanimously [Applause] congratulations so old school I use paper that's okay um good evening Dr balamin and members of the board uh when I first became an assistant principle at University High School my principal Dr Julian Jones gave me a great piece of professional advice he said Ben

047you are going to come to a point in your position where you'll have to make a choice you can either do your job the easy way or you can do it the right way I knew the answer and from that moment on the right way would always dictate my approach to situations on our campus I'm excited for the opportunity to share this message as the new manager of Professional Standards uh making the jump to Professional Standards was not an easy decision but it was the right one after spending the last seven years at University High School I cannot thank our Titan faculty staff students and families for providing the opportunities for me to grow as a professional you all contributed to who I am and how I forever approach working with people I will strive

048to maintain the personality that you've enjoyed working with over that same time you've taught a Delan High alumni how to follow the Creed and bleed orange and gray I'd also like to quickly thank my family here and watching online for always supporting me on my professional Journey my wife and two daughters always find ways to brighten up the toughest days and although my parents tried to talk me out of Education they never wavered in their support of the path I've taken to get here I'm thankful for the team that is in place at the office of Professional Standards as I also uh excuse me as I know they bring a ton of experience to the office from which I can grow thank you Dr balabin Mr Cash and uh Miss Workman for entrusting me with

049this responsibility I'm ready for the challenge [Applause] you can return but don't leave yes Madam chair thank you our second appointment I would like to ask Miss Charles Bennett to join us I will share with you a little bit about Mr Bennett he has obtained his bachelor's degree from Illinois States University master's degree from St Stetson University certifications in the following area leadership English speakers of other languages elementary Ed k6 started as a teacher in um in 2002 in Illinois and became a teacher for wickl Elementary in Sanford Lake Orient Elementary Alon Springs Forest City Elementary Alon Springs went on to be a Dean at Teague middle Timon Springs currently serving as the assistant principal at Markham Woods middle in Lake Mary if approved by this board I would like to recommend that Mr Mr

050Charles Bennett becomes the assistant principal for T small Elementary and his effective date will be January 21st 2025 dictated by his principal who's here at this audience the time the reporting time board members you've heard the recommendation of the superintendent do I have someone that would like to make a motion that Mr Charles Bennett become the assistant principal for T small Elementary I'd like to make the motion thank you good thank you m brosmer any discussion Mrs good I just want to say congratulations and I look forward to learning more about you thank you yes after reviewing your um resume and all the things that you've done thank you so very much and you'll understand this for crossing over the bridge and coming into vucha County because some times we see people go over the

051bridge the other way so we appreciate that you are willing to come over and you're going to a wonderful school you're going to a school where children are there to learn every day and I appreciate that you are coming across the bridge if there's no further discussion we'll call for the vote all those in favor of Mr Charles Bennett becoming the assistant principal for CH T small Elementary please say I I any opposed nay it passes unanimously [Music] [Applause] congratulations good afternoon I want to start by thanking the vucha County school board members Miss Hayes Mr cologne Miss Thompson Miss brosme Miss Goodrich also want to thank superintendent Miss uh Dr babon Babin Dr V miss castalano and miss Boyd Walker for this opportunity your dedication to education and support that you provides students and

052staff is inspiring and I'm excited to become part of the vucha County Public Schools Community I'm also deep deeply grateful to my family for their constant support to my wife Trisha without you none of this would be possible thank you for always being there and for understanding through the challenges and long hours to my daughter Olivia who attends new samna Beach High School thanking for keep thank you for keeping me grounded and up to date on the current slang to my son jack who attends Reed patillo thank you for always reminding me to count my blessings and always finding the positive in life and lastly my mother-in-law who showed up last minute today thank you for always picking up the pieces I love you all lastly I want to thank all my colleagues in seminal

053County who encouraged me to pursue my dreams to never give up and continue to do the work I care so deeply about I've spent the last 23 years in education in both in Chicago and seminal County I've taught kindergarten third grade fifth grade six seventh and eighth grade social studies and my leadership career began as a dean and it progressed to an assistant principal for the last 11 years in both middle and elementary school I'm extremely I'm extremely excited about the opportunity to make a difference in the county I live in I look forward to fostering young minds and supporting the teachers at T T small Elementary as an assistant principal I've learned the importance of building strong relationships with students families and colleagues I've seen firsthand how a posit positive inclusive School culture helps

054everyone succeed leadership is about empowering others and I'm excited to continue my work here in vucha county and create an environment where our students and Educators can Thrive thank you again for this opportunity I can't wait to get started together we'll make a positive impact in on the lives of students in valua County thank you [Applause] aome also please don't don't leave all right you're next this is my last chair um I would like to ask Mr Ronald Washington to join us and here he comes I will share with you a little bit that about Mr Washington he has obtained his bachelor's degree from LR College uh master's degree from National us Lewis University holds certifications in the following areas at leadership English speakers of other languages elementary K through six middle grade social studies

0555 through 9 and he started as a teacher in 2008 he served as a team success a school of excellence in Bradington Saddler Elementary I'm familiar with that school very very well Orlando lockart middle familiar with that one as well Orlando and Midway Elementary Sanford uh went on to be a lead administra of Dean at met Brook Middle also Orlando then the assistant principal at Wolf Lake Middle also wow and currently serving as a teacher an assignment at cample Middle School what a small world I'm I'm familiar with one two three four five of the schools that you were at I'm recommending today that Mr Ronald Washington becomes the assistant principal for cample middle school and if approved by this board his effective start date will be January 15 2025 and I see the Spartan

056family back there all right board members you've heard the recommendation of the superintendent do I have someone that would like to make a motion that Mr Ronald Washington serve as the assistant principal for Campbell Middle School I'd like to make the motion thank you Mrs Goodrich do I have a second second thank you Mrs brosmer any discussion so it's not often you get a while from Dr balabin so those schools must be uh wonderful schools that prepared you for the journey in which you're about to Embark in and thankfully already there and so uh thank you for choosing bushia County schools and and for choosing to serve our students and and I'm sure that Campbell they're excited to have you especially you have already built relationship with the kids so that's amazing so thank you

057good rich just want to say congratulations and I'm also looking forward to getting to know you better as well yes we appreciate um everything you've done and we love that you left Orange County headed over to Vala County and I and I'm assuming if you accept since you stepped up to accept this position you're happy here in Valia County and so that's what we like to hear and we hope that you will stay but at this time we have to call for a vote all those in favor of Mr Ronald Washington being the assistant principal at Campbell Middle School please say I I I any opposed okay it passes unanimously congratulations [Applause] yes good evening to the school board member Haynes good Rich cologne brosme and Thompson to superintendent balaman and her esteemed cabinet it

058is with profound gratitude and a humble heart that I stand before you today honored to embrace the role of assistant principal at Campbell Middle School this opportunity represents not only a professional Milestone but also a personal commitment to the ideals of Education leadership and Community Building I extend my deepest thanks to Dr valer Dr Drayton and principal Owens for entrusting me with this responsibility your confidence and my ability to serve students and staff inspires me to strive for excellence every day to my mentors past and present your guidance has been a beacon of light along my journey your wisdom encouragement and unwavering belief and my potential have not only shaped my professional path but have instilled within me the values of integrity resilience and vision thank you for Paving the way with your examples of

059dedication and Leadership to my family your enduring love and encouragement have been My Sanctuary you have been my constant cheerleaders reminding me of the importance of balance and purpose and to my incredible wife your steadfast support patience and belief in my dreams have been the foundation upon which I have built every success you inspire me daily to become the best version of myself and for that I am eternally grateful as I embark on this new chapter I pledge to serve with diligence empathy and a Resolute commitment to fostering an environment where students and Educators alike can Thrive together we will continue to build a community that uplifts empowers and inspires thank you all for your trust support and encouragement I am truly honored and excited for this opportunity thank you thank you [Applause] at this

060time we'd like to ask Mr Carter Mr Bennett and Mr Washington to come forward and bring anyone you may have here with you for photos we'll start with Mr Carter that's okay I don't feel like I I brought the fashion these look at that such a Gorge [Music] all right thank you [Applause] carer thank you is there anyone else from else here you [Applause] doing congratulations okay ready to he said something about he want to come [Music] up congats there's the entire team you guys musty [Applause] [Laughter] love it he gradu I know right you want to go around [Music] that [Music] you [Laughter] good let me call Stephanie to do the transfers to okay all right Dr bin yes Madam chair moving right along I would like to ask Miss Stephanie Workman our D

061executive director for human resources she will share with you two transfers good evening board Dr Balaban um this evening I'd like to present uh two transfers of assistant principles the first being Buffy Snipes currently assistant principal at Discovery Elementary to assistant principal at Sugar Mill Elementary and the second Shannon Van slik currently assistant principal at sugarm Mill Elementary to assistant principal at Discovery Elementary both with a start date of January 21st thank you thank you Miss Warman any questions I have no questions board members do you have any questions thank you thank you Miss Warman so we're now moving along to item 6.01 which is public participation concerning any items on the consent agenda slux do you have any green cards okay so at this time then we're moving into the consent agenda Dr baman

062are there any items requiring removal on the consent agenda no Madam chair I have none at this time board members are there any items on the consent agenda that you would like to remove for further discussion okay hearing none Madam chair I had a I want to I had a procedural question uh we have a uh bid rejection and then we have a bid approval it just seems weird that we would be rejecting and approving at the same time and so um my question is can we vote on the rejection independently as then after that then we can approve the new uh contract for milk and dairy so would you like to leave the bid rejection as part of the consent agenda and just which is item item 11.01 and pull item 11.02 which is

063the piggyback contract the other way around I'd rather reject the bid first and then uh and then accept the new it just seems weird that we're rejecting and and approving and the same bam all right so um I'd like to pull 1101 01 yes okay so you want to pull 1101 to vote on separate and you want to leave 1102 in the consent agenda okay so at this time board members um we're going to pull 11.01 as a separate item and is there any discussion you would like for the ladies to share it just seemed weird to do that in that same one fail swoop and so is there any is there anything you guys would like to share I think good afternoon Patty Chief Operating Officer I'm sorry I don't have the numbers in

064front of me but you want to keep on uh consent the rejection and then vote separately on no he wants to P the rejection do the rejection first and then approve the new contract as part of consent as part of as part consent okay thank you for the clarification okay any questions no I just wanted to clarify so we're pulling the bid rejection out to vote separately first before the r and then we're going to do 1102 in the kinson with everything else yes ma'am okay thank you okay so then I need someone to make a motion um to vote separately on just item 11.01 which is the bid rejection for the delivery of milk juice and dairy products to school cafeteras do I have a motion so I will make the motion okay I

065need a second I'll second that motion thank you Mr cologne and Miss Thompson any further discussion Miss Goodridge I may need to recuse myself from this particular vote okay so miss Goodrich is recusing herself uh my husband and I um may be associated with some of the players involved wonderful thank you for doing that so Mrs Goodrich will not be voting any other discussion okay hearing none at this time I'll call for the vote we are voting separately on item 11.01 the bid re bid rejection for the Direct Delivery of milk jues and dairy products to school cafeteria all those in favor of rejecting the bid please say I I I anyone opposed okay so it does pass unanimously but it's a four to zero because Mrs goodr is removed so then moving on I

066go back to the consent agenda is there any other items that anyone wants to have discussion about before we approve the consent agen I consent agenda I would like to just I just want to make a statement about one thing um which I kind of alluded to earlier if you go down um and it's item and I lost it item 14.01 request for Schoolboard acceptance of donations to Valia County Schools I read these every time when they come up on the board docs and I want thank Celeste for all the work she does to get the information in from the schools but December was a short month and yet we still had almost $46,000 in donations made to our schools from individuals churches business community members and including parent organizations and so I want to

067thank everyone that each month in some way or other supports our schools and especially through donations that are needed for some of the different activities that take place so thank you to everyone that has donated this year but especially in December for a nice that was a nice amount of money for a short period of time so at this time the only change to the consent agenda as originally presented is we pulled item 11.01 and we voted on it separately so at this time I'm asking for a motion to approve the agenda as presented minus item 11.01 do I have a motion Madam chair I have a question for Miss Goodridge do you have a conflict on 11.02 as well or no just want to make sure uh possibly so yeah myself from that as

068well so okay so let's pull 11.02 as well separate we're now going to pull 11.02 do I have someone to make a motion to to approve 11.02 no Moe thank you Mrs brosmer do I have someone who will make a second second thank you Mr cologne Mrs Goodrich is going to recuse herself from this vote so we're now voting on 11.02 which is for the piggyback contract for milk and dairy products which my understanding is we're we've been doing a lot of piggybacks lately um and we're doing them because other districts have gotten cheaper prices and we're piggybacking off of them to get cheaper prices and so when a district has already done that work and we can save the money versus the bid that we receive it's to the best interest so at this

069time we have a motion in a second to approve 11.02 piggyback contract for milk and dairy products all those in favor please say I I any opposed okay so it passes unanimously on a 4 Z because Mrs Goodrich has withdrawn herself now let's go back to the regular consent agenda I need an approval a motion to accept the approval of the consent agenda as presented to us minus the items 11.01 and 11.02 do I have a motion so moved thank you Mrs brosmer do I have a second I'll second that motion thank you Mrs Thompson everyone can vote on this part because we've removed items 11.01 or 11.02 any further discussion Madam chair I just want to shout out to our construction department and and uh operation Services facilities we have a whole page of

070projects that are going on in our schools so thank you thank you thank you thank you uh for the your hard work because every one of these represents a project that is going to make a difference for our students so thank you okay any other discussion then I'm going to call for the vote we are voting to approve the consent agenda at presented minus the items 11.01 and 11.02 which were voted on as Standalone items and Madam chair I know we have our our uh Charter School audits I want to acknowledge the presence of I know Mr LEF was here who is from uh from uh Ivy Han as well as uh from Mr Smith Mr Smith is here so thank you for coming today all right do we have any other Charter School members

071here this evening recognize all right okay we have a mo we have a motion in a second all those in favor of approving the consent agenda as presented minus items 11.01 and 11.02 please signify by saying I I any opposed okay it passes unanimously we are now moving on um well we will be moving on in just a moment to public participation so we're going to take a short recess and we will be back here in the boardroom at 6: PM for public participation if you wish to fill out a card you can go over to the far side and fill out a card thank you e e e welcome back it is now 6:03 pm and we are going to move into public participation which is item 17.01 on the agenda I will name

072the first two speakers the first speaker will come forward the second speaker will be ready to go next we're going to start with Jean Miley you're the first speaker for this evening followed by Christine sirer welcome Miss Smiley my name is Jean Miley and I'm speaking on behalf of Miss Jessie I seen on the news and it kind of really bothered me or the reason that you all dismissed her and what I heard I'm only going by what I heard on the news that she said something about the school and that she not plus some some kids she didn't I didn't hear no name calling or anything I heard the word some and I was a bus attendant for 25 years with valua County and I know some kids can be give you body language

073and I assume that's what she was looking at and she probably held what she held in her heart for some time and she may was a little fanatical in how she expressed herself but I don't think she said anything wrong or out of place or out of term because I have five kids and I have to put two of my sons in place that I did not couldn't trust them at one point in time until they got themselves in order and I think that's all she was saying and in this world today is some kids sends off body language and they give and you read that body language and you got to express yourself to them and talk to them to get them in the place where they need to be and help them through

074education and a lot of my students I did that on the bus even a parent came on the bus and I went to her house that afternoon and let her know she was wrong later on that lady saw me she said something about you touched my heart she said and I went and got myself in the church and I'm saved and every I see her every now and then and that's the same thing she tell me how she turned her life around some of the kids that I had on the bus they said Miss Miley you don't think we was listening at what you was saying she said but we did and she said I really appreciate you and I'm like well KS still know me don't remember them and they and when I when

075they comes up to me I I it makes me happy it touches my heart that I did do something that somebody did hear me when I talk to them I have five children they all graduated they not on drugs they're in the church my daughter went to the military she's a hairdresser Evelyn I heard y'all talking about Advent that's what she's working at she's a nurse and she said Mom we got valuch kind School Board people coming in I said oh okay my husband is Mr Arthur Mary that's so God sent me to be a bus attendant I was his bus attendant I became his wife 31st of this month will be 27 years we'll be married he's the supervisor for area one for valua county school transportation and I'm always talking and telling him

076I I I I missed it because they made me retire but I thank God that that that it just bothered me when they heard it that lady when they took her down thank you Mrs Smiley we appreciate you you're welcome thank you so next up is M Christine serrier followed by Kathy noes welcome for superintendent Balaban I want to thank you for pulling policy 320 from the agenda um I do want to ask as you revisit that policy um please prioritize inclusive language make sure there's safeguards in place to prevent potential abuse of the system um because it's very very important that we have a thorough fair and transparent review process thank you thank you next up is Miss Kathy nolles followed by Miss Heather Bendle welcome hi I'm Kathy noes former employee just ones

077here that don't the few that don't know me so I want to address a few things to about the last Schoolboard meeting first I want to thank y'all for finally giving the bus drivers the raise that they deserve that we've all you know as they can say in negotiation the raises that we've tried to give them so I guess now we've established if there's not a union we're willing to give people more money so with that being said as the representative for schway Cafe in the negotiating we've always been held back for the 13 years that I work here of giving our employees the raises that we can afford to give because in our budget we have it cuz we're separate budget from the school board so whatever we give them if we give them

078$10 an hour it's not going to affect y'all's budget whatsoever so I'm hoping to see the next school board meeting that we address schoolway Cafe and finally give those people the raises that they also deserve because we have the funding to do it that they've had for 13 years but I'm glad y'all finally did transportate all of transport it wasn't just bus drivers it was mechanics and everybody so the second thing I want to address was a Schoolboard member that wanted to wait and vote on the contract and because she wanted to investigate more I agree with that because the one that said that she knew it all if you knew it all I wouldn't have left here as unhappy employee I wouldn't have quit because that man can tell you sitting right over there

079there was not another manager that loved her job more than I did and I left here because the way the place was being run and things that was going down the lady over there can tell you that and there's other managers that are doing the same thing other assistants are going to the same way so now let's address the safety I don't care what Miss bagman drives her car okay so we don't have to him haul around we did last schol boy meeting about why we going to let her take her car as a cafeteria manager I've opened the gates every morning for 13 years by myself nobody else on campus if my freezer alarm went off and I had to go down and check my freezer 12 o'clock at night I went by myself

080nobody else then I would do a report and see if maintenance needs to come out so if we're going to talk about safety let's talk about safety for all employees and not just one and then so then I'm gonna tell you as you can tell I was at Delton Ohio and I I'm going to ask you is keep my babies out of your out of your conversations and I hope you don't need your gas pumped thank you you thank you Miss SNES next up is Heather Bendle followed by Miss Jennifer Kelly good evening my name is Heather Bendle uh this this what I'm going to read are two emails that I sent on December 13th and December 17th to quite a few people but specifically our superintendent superintendent bgin you and I need to have

081a serious chat about what I have been dealing with as a mother of four children at Mainland Campbell and Palm Terrace as well as what I have been subjected to by Becky Porter at nsbms and her students please reach out to me today to schedule a meeting I will also be at the board meeting January 14th so the public is aware of what is happening to my children as well as myself at BCS since Monday December 2nd as a seventh grade science teacher at msbs I've been spat on had my life threatened had my dog's life threatened had my job threatened by students and their father had worksheets I was told the hand out to the students crumpled up and thrown at me while they all laugh been sworn at had my property stolen the

082list goes on by 121 students in room 9913 when I brought all of these concerns to Becky Porter as my boss she Shrugged off and then proceeded to bully me out of my own job she told me I'm just not cut out to be a middle school teacher I am being treated like this at nsbms by students and the principal in less than 10 school days what are my four children dealing with at a larger school just up the road mandate reporters are not doing their job regarding regarding my own children and my deep concerns at Mainland Campbell and no one bother to do their job and is just a title and a paycheck your schools are illegally blocking blocking me from my own children email uh dated 1217 four days later as a followup

083with subject line why have I not heard from anyone at all superintendent Bal gabin surely by now you've received and read my multiple emails regarding what Becky Porter did to me regarding my seventh grade Science teaching position at msbs Ms at VCS surely by now you've received and read my two emails regarding my own two children in VCS that are failing with a 1.0 GPA my son is 17 with an eighth grade education in BL County schools at Mainland why have I not heard from anyone in blch County HR or you why have I not heard from my children's principles at Mainland or Campbell why are taxpayers in the state of Florida paying all of you to do what are they paying you to do I need answers on What Becky Porter did to me

084and I need answers as to why my children are completely drowning in your school district the silence is deafening and speaks volumes of everyone involved in all of this as of today's date I have not heard from any of my children's schools or human resources thank you thank you next up is M Jennifer Kelly welcome good evening board members chair superintendent last August at the moms for liity Summit Miss toson spoke during one of the breakout sessions entitled how to work with your school board this was a national Summit with members from across the country who attended to gain knowledge to empower themselves on productive ways to engage their local school boards to improve their districts I personally did not attend the last Summit because I it was scheduled around the due date of my

085first grandbaby a few months later mom's for Liberty posted all the breakout sessions to their website for those of us who could not attend to view when I got to the session where Miss toson participated let me just say I was completely astonished and mortified I was shocked to hear her call her colleagues names put students down even going as far as to say they were not intelligent and that she would not trust some of them to pump her gas and most shocking to me was the admitted lying she lied to all of you because you were all too lazy to read contracts she fed you all false information because she didn't like you and wanted to get under your skin in an attempt to make magical changes for Safety and Security with the contract

086with the sheriff's department did we ever find out what that lie was this is not how to productively work with your school board it's an it's the exact opposite and if you can't tell the difference Miss Thompson you don't just need to step down as chair you need to step down from the board completely if you choose not to do the right thing for the students in vucha county and step down there are other ways to have you removed one by the governor two by recall the criteria for both are the same and they are as follows Mal feent Mis feent neglect of Duty habitual drunkenness incompetence permanent inability to perform duties arrests for felony and misdemeanor related to office and duties the first two definitely fit the criteria and possibly a third I request

087you step down tonight if not I will start the other two processes first thing tomorrow thank you thank you at this time we have no further public input we are moving on to item 18.01 which is a a presentation readers to leaders Dr Balaban thank you madam chair I would like to ask Miss Christy castalano our executive director for elementary Ed also we're joined with some fabulous partners that are here uh in our in our boardroom Dr Michelle Goldies where are you okay there you are if you will join us please as you know Miss goalies is the associate vice president for Enrollment Services for day State College a very good partner with VCS along with Devin Miller employee benefits consultant for Brown and Brown Insurance our very own Ken Phelps vice president for resource

088development from Theona Regional Chamber of Commerce and they will be sharing with you some some information as it pertains to this program readers to leaders partnership all right good evening board superintendent I am excited tonight to introduce this readers to leaders program with all of you with the readers the leaders program is an exciting collaboration between Valia County Schools The Early Learning Coalition and our dedicated business partners together we are committed to fostering early literacy and creating a strong Foundation of lifelong learning this partnership brings together resources expertise and shared passion to support young readers and ensure their success in school and Beyond we'll make do with the production challenges of short cords yeah members of the board Dr bamman thank you it's exciting to be here tonight to share a little bit about this

089program uh the readers to leaders initiative uh has Origins going back a couple of years uh it has roots in the Daytona Regional Chambers leadership development program leadership Daytona uh it has roots in the Florida scorecard which is an information resource of the Florida chamber of commerce Foundation uh and it has roots in the passion of Nelly leoi from ICI homes who was our 2023 chair of the board uh and it was uh her interest in having a positive impact in the community that led to this challenge uh so I don't want to steal the Thunder of our uh of our participants who kind of created this idea uh that we' we've run with but uh it's my pleasure to pass the mic to two members of that 43rd class of leadership Daytona who helped

090uh kind of get this ball rolling thank you Ken and thank you School Board uh my name is Devin Miller and I'm sitting alongside Michelle goldens we are proud graduates of leadership Daytona class 43 from the year 2023 and we're excited to talk to you about the readers to leaders program so the leadership Daytona program is is a leadership development program and at the beginning of that 12we Journey that Michelle and I went through together um we were given a challenge from the sitting chair Nelly lupoi and our challenge that was given to us was to come up with an awareness campaign to illuminate the fact that only 53% of third grade readers were reading on grade level at that time so as a member of the business Community um that was shocking to me

091that was shocking news to me it may not be to all of you who who focus on this every single day for our students um but for someone who sits in in the private sector that that was stunning so throughout the 12we program uh Michelle and I and our classmates work together to put together an awareness campaign and what we learned was that there are a ton of great resources in our community that are already out there um however as business partners we think it's our role to uh to be the Bridge connect resources um which Michelle is going to share some more about so as Devon mentioned our goal was not to solve this problem but to shine a light and to raise awareness so our Focus has been working with our within our

092leadership class as well sorry there's within our leadership class and also within our leadership uh Daytona alumni Council to talk about how we as a community can share our time talent and treasures whatever that means to each of us to our employers and the network and the community that we're all a part of uh most recently recently we met with our leadership Daytona alumni Council and we've surveyed our own members to highlight some of the resources you all should have a handout in front of you with a QR code that takes you to this digital uh brochure that you see on the screen sorry there is a bug in my face um uh this brochure is going to be maintained digitally to allow us to update it in real time and be able to Showcase

093it um in various Community participation events and make sure that we can send this out highlighting some of these programs like the Early Learning Coalition things like the Dolly Parton Imagination Library which you're if you're not aware of is a free opportunity for your child to receive books every single month until they turned five my daughter was a recipient it was amazing um and one of the things I learned throughout this process is that uh the cost of that is increasing that's not a free program and so we've learned the cost that the Early Learning Coalition uh coordinates and raises funds to continue offering that because it is not free the community does have to have an organization that's supporting that uh the cost used to be $30 per child per year and now or

094sorry per lifetime in the program I think uh and it has increased to 40 so that's something that you know we've learned as an individual I learned we could donate and then actually during this month Brown and Brown is matching the amount so if you donate $40 it sponsors not only one but two children which is an amazing opportunity um but learning just little tidbits like that uh as we were in the leadership Daytona program I had a child that is now in third grade at Spruce Creek Elementary amazing principal thank you so much um but I have a third grader so these these these assessments are very real they're in my world right now and part of what we've talked about is making sure we know about these opportunities about the VPK opportunities and

095spreading the word to anyone we know to make sure that parents are taking advantage of VPK um and surveying our colleagues and friends to find out what opportunities they're willing to support in the community whether that means stocking the little free libraries or volunteering to read in the Elementary School classrooms um again supporting the Dolly Parton Imagination Library and just really making sure that we talk about what time talent and treasures we or our colleagues are willing to support I'm going to step in uh Allison Miller was supposed to join us tonight she's the chief program officer for the Early Learning Coalition and unfortunately had to attend a celebration of life this evening but uh she shared with me some some notes on the impact that this program uh can have and is already having

096uh on on our earliest Learners through the Early Learning Coalition um Michelle mentioned the the funding you know we want people to be able to direct their resources there is currently not enough funding for the dolly partner Imagination Library for every student in valuch County to be able to participate in that program and I think that's unfortunate maybe we'll be able to get there to a dollar a dollar amount where that is uh is feasible for them uh but here's the reason it's so critically important we the challenge focused on third grade reading scores in blushia County but you can't solve third grade reading scores by going in and reading third grade classes it's got to start much earlier than that the the early learning folks have already seen traction from this program in terms

097of the number of uh volunteer inquiries that they've had specific to youth literacy uh Allison shared with me the other day that they've had 18 inquiries like that in the last month the average month that was one to two so I think we're already seeing the the ability to bring this together what a positive impact this can have because a program like the dpil will prepare students for when they arrive at kindergarten or in VPK that they are ready to learn and that the goal will be that that supports the work that you're doing here on the board so I'll pass it to Christie and then that's the partnership with the Early Learning Coalition then once the students are here in our schools in kindergarten and you know we're teaching them to read right we're

098we're working with them and so we have the superintendent um summer or the reading challenges that happen multiple times throughout the year and we know that our children love to read but you know what they love even more is they love winning prizes so that keeps them reading so this is it's a great way for business partners to be able to donate some of their Treasures um so we can keep you you know giving our kids these wonderful gifts like the um you know gift cards that um to the water parks and and different prizes that they can win so um it's just a great partnership and we're really excited uh to bring this to fuchia County and I just want to close briefly and thank you for the time tonight uh to to share

099this program with all of you and with the the community at large uh one thing we often say at the Daytona Regional Chamber is we we don't we don't necessarily have the answer but we likely know somebody who does because our business Community is incredibly resourceful they're incredibly supportive uh as as Devon and Michelle brought this forward on behalf of their class and we we said let's convene the stakeholders to see what is already happening and what we very quickly realize is we don't need another program there's already too many programs maybe out there what we need to do is make the community aware of all the opportunities that they can support whether it's time whether it's Talent whether it's treasure and and sometimes it's one of the three sometimes it's two of the three

100and sometimes it's all three that a program needs um but we want to be able to help our community members step into that support in whatever capacity they can some people may not have the financial ath all to write a large check but they might have an hour of volunteer time paid by their company a month that can have an incredible impact on the life of a child in the schools as you well know I know I'm preaching to the choir on that but it's important this is the role the chamber can play so some people say well why would the Chamber of Commerce be involved in this for two reasons uh one Workforce Development related one Economic Development related uh these students that are in ourc to 12 programs now they are the future

101of our Workforce at some point we need a talented pool of community members to be able to pull on to keep our economy going that's a Workforce Development piece uh I've learned through the United States Chambers business leads fellowship program the vast majority of students who are graduating our schools are going to stay here the idea that you can recruit Talent from out of the area to come and be part of your Workforce you can't do it at scale sufficient to to support Business from The Economic Development standpoint as businesses look to the Daytona Beach region vucha County as a place to land their operations that's one of they're going to ask you about two things what's your Workforce like what's your school system like every time without fail so to the extent the chamber

102can bring together these resources not duplic and support the existing work that the great educational Professionals in our region are doing we're happy to be able to do that the budget's right we're not here asking you for any money we would just love for you to be able to help uh spread the word and share about the great work that we're doing thank you um is there anyone that has a question yeah all right miss good great presentation thank you all love seeing you guys um what specifically can we do to help spread the word will be probably the biggest thing um you'll see we're we're about a month into the official roll out so this is still very much in its infancy um I you're going to start to see some social media campaigns

103you'll see emails if you need additional copies of the fly I'm happy to email a digital version of that that you can share with others uh in your in your circles um but it's just making people aware of the opportunities the nice thing about the brochure uh as as Devon mentioned we'll be able to update it digitally in a when when a new program launches whether it's through the Early Learning Coalition or through the school district we can just add that we're not going to have outdated books printed that are out there with old information it will be uh it will be current um but to be able to go to that the brochure will let people know for each program how the support is needed so it'll it has icon indicators of if it's

104time that's needed if it's Talent that's needed or if it's treasure that's needed so people can make sure they're uh getting into the right slot okay thank you Mr colog you know there are people who talk about it and there other people who make it happen and so I want to thank you all for making it happen uh I realize that though those resources are out there getting them all together in one place is not simple and so uh shout out to your uh graduating class and and and what it took to not only identify a pro a project worthy of making a difference in a child's life and children's lives in our County but also uh figuring out with from technology figuring out what the barriers were I'm sure your group was committed U

105you guys have a rock star sitting up there which I am and that's not you Mr phelp sorry said I just met you for the record I looked at Miss castalano so who Mr colum and so I'm sure he is too but miss Goldies has a real near and dear place in my heart since I'm always late registering my own kids for school she helps me so but no um you know and and I also you know following your young lady who's going to be a meteorologist she's amazing if you haven't followed her she does all the hurricane but you know again it's it's taking what other students you know you you're you're taking your struggle at home and and that opportunity and saying you know what if if this is what it's like for

106me how do I bless other students so again thank you thank you thank you thank you because again there's people who talk about it and then there's people who do it and make it happen thank you for helping us make it happen thank you and I'd like to add um you brought us these thank you very much and did I hear you have some more with you I gave everything in paper that I had to Celeste but we can get you more no no I I just want to get one to miss Shepard who's sitting back behind you because tomorrow morning she has a meeting with a lot of business and community members and I think it would be a great thing to be able to share with them and then Dr bman I'd like

107to ask can we somehow put this out on our website and on social media and things like that to share with the community Absol absolutely Sarah is G going to thank you do that thank you very much because this is so important and um I have family members that have taken advantage also of the Dolly Parton's Imagination Library and there's nothing better than to start them WR at Birth and start reading to them so thank you very much absolutely thank you and I do want to uh shout out Miss Shepard has been a part of this team so she's been a part of our meeting and collaboration and just to highlight one last thing the biggest part of this as we talk to our colleagues and our business partners is making sure they understand the

108why because I have a third grader at home so it's what I'm living but part of this has been emphasizing to others that may not have children or have grown children why do they need to care about this and and and as Ken said these are our future these are our future dual enrolled students you didn't think I'd get away without saying that word did you uh but these are our future students you know not only at Dayton state but across the district and so we want to make sure that we're emphasizing there's a reason why everyone needs to care so thank you for letting us speak about this yeah that's thank you take a picture thank you thank you everyone uh readers the leaders we would like to take a picture with you guys

109is that okay that's a good way to to put it out yeah we're back we're back to freezing I hand them this all righty guys you got me this time I'm a lot louder so ready get ready look right at the camera three two one three two one and then one more set ready three two one there we go thank you guys it's freezing over here I'm like sitting on my hair it's so yeah yeah agre agreed thank you thank you one more we are now moving on to item 19.02 Schoolboard member travel confirmation I'm introducing this so board members in December you asked that we go back and um check all of these things and we had a discussion about what we would automatically approve and what would need further or prior board approval

110in order for individuals to attend so I hope you've all had a chance to look at it but the board travel confirmation for 2025 the upcoming events that if you vote to approve this tonight will be the items listed in the first section starting with February 6 through 7th through December 2nd through 5th the middle section is if you wish to attend any additional legislative events outside of the fsba 38th annual day in the legislation event that's taking place on March 19th that will require prior board approval to attend and then the conferences listed below which are part of cosba which is now our national organization that we are part of um if you wish to attend any of those and they do actually start at the end of this week um you'll need prior

111board approval to attend so at this time I need someone to make a motion to approve the board member Conference travel for this coming school year so will someone make a motion to approve motion to approve thank you Mrs Thompson do I have a second second thank you Mr cologne any discussion Miss Goodrich for going to Tallahassee if I plan to go on my own dime does that need approval no if you're going to go and you're going to pick up your own cost we don't have to approve it this is for when um payment has to be made $500 or more huh a $500 or more we would appreciate if you are going though if you like let Karen know or share with us I intend to go with the Chamber of Commerce um

112that's fine yeah all right any other discussion okay hearing none Miss Thompson's um made the motion for approval Mr colone is seconded all those in favor of approving the board member travel for the 2025 school year please say I I I anyone opposed okay then it passes unanimously we are now at public participation are there any other cards Miss Lux okay then we are moving on to items from board members the superintendent or the Schoolboard attorney does anyone have anything they'd like to share this evening this brosmer um I'd appreciate it if everybody would come kind of bear with me there were things that came to mind as I was going through the agenda uh and so I I'll try to be quick about this um I'd really like to see more detail in our

113minutes when when we say discussion ensued it doesn't tell anybody anything about who thought what or or what the differences of opinion might have been and I know that there has been some um suggestion that minutes should be limited because of potential legal challenges and things like that but I serve on the on enra on the environmental and natural resources advisory committee and when we say u in our minutes discussion ensued it goes on and explains what the discussion entailed so I just wondered if we could expand our minutes a little bit and and allow anybody who's reading them to have some idea of the nature of the discussion so that was one thing um uh I'd love to see our board Ducks used as a library uh in researching other uh school districts they

114do they they post public documents on board docks and you can type in a search word and if you're looking for a contract you can you can pull up that contract contract we don't have anything on ours uh unless you know the date of the agenda item and then it might be attached uh which makes it difficult to find something if you're just trying to do some general research and I thought it might cut down on on uh public records requests if we were to make some of these documents a little more easily available uh tonight we had 45 um items on the consent agenda but but there were seven contracts that didn't have the contract attached some seven contract items that didn't have the contract attached and the total amount of those contracts was

1154,529 639 I thought it would be a good idea to attach contracts when they're of that size uh let's see um okay this one you know that my background is as a lobbyist so this is bound to be a um kind of a big deal for me but I attended the legislative delegation meeting last week and uh and our participation was uh kind of last minute from what I understand um I I can't stress enough how important I think it is for us to have a good personal um working relation relationship with our legislative delegation so much of what we do uh the money our policies and the money we spend or the money we take in to spend is dictated by those people and they are either our advoc Advocates or adversaries depending on

116the nature of the issue but I think we need to have an active presence with our legislative delegation at all times because legislation doesn't just happen when committee meeting starts start it happens it evolves in the off seon and those discussions are had with delegation members and that's when we tell them what our priorities are and what our concerns are and we start to develop language that we think might help to resolve that issue uh so I know that it isn't something that's of interest to everybody but I do see it as a core part of our function and I'd like to see us take a more active role in it uh so for tonight I think that's it I'll leave you alone for the rest of the evening all right thank you Miss goodr

117so it was um recently brought to my attention the significant amount of assets that we hold um in vush County Schools many assets that aren't utilized or underutilized are non-producing or losing money so I just wanted the board to be aware and in the community that I have requested a list of our assets and how um they're making money or losing money so that we can start to Deep dive into that and see what what we can do better with our taxpayer dollars thank you Mr cologne so I'm definitely interested in the uh in looking at the minutes I think that you know one of the hard things with the minutes is that you you know you can't write it word for word and and to your point earlier it is on YouTube where before

118you didn't have YouTube so someone can go and find it on YouTube and I know I that's how I go back um as far as board dos it does have a search functionality and I don't know if how much time you've spent playing with it but you really I mean I search for things all the time using keywords so it does and it takes you to those documents can I interrupt you for one second yeah absolutely I when I was doing it it was not signing in as a board member and I think as as board members we may have a different level of access I was doing it as a never and I never log into it I always go in as public s so I think there's an opportunity there that we could

119uh because I I look for stuff all the time um I I appreciate your comment about the contracts and and my only feedback on that is um you know the time to bring that up if if you had those concerns bring it up right before we we're okay with you know saying hey you know if we got to put it off we got to put it off um and I I told totally agree with the relationships thing you know I have a great relationship with our delegation even the ones on the other side and so um you know the the delegation meeting I was going to try to make it to uh and somehow that that didn't you know I saw it on Facebook so I don't know who actually sends the invites and whether

120we ever even received the formal invite to it but um you know I'm grateful that uh Mr Evans when I was going to try to make it and then I ended up having something to do at Deltona High so that was that but um but yeah the minutes thing again you know I I've been satisfied because I realized that you know the level of I mean you really can't go word for word but having the video but I'd be curious to see how we can make that better and I think that's probably worth a conversation so I can support that so that's all I have thank you Mr Clen Miss Thompson do you have anything you'd like to add okay so um I too have done a lot of searching at times to find things

121because people have asked me when where they are and I've tended to find them the seven items though um that you stated about on the agenda item I just want to um make sure are those items 15.8 through 15.24 do you know probably I don't I I don't know um offand I just added them up I didn't write down the okay numbers so those I the only seven items I found that didn't have an attachment to them all happen to be phase three construction documents and so um Can Mrs core come up in case I speak yeah core typically when it's a phase three construction they we've already done the contract piece this is just the final piece um where we're accepting whatever it is the phase three pieces so the contracts for these we

122voted on we're just now voting approval that we're accepting the construction drawings that and and they all and I will tell you part of why they put everything back in there um is I've been very in the past as chair I was very clear that they not leave any details out because I feel like when somebody reads this they need to know exactly what everything was costing but those are the only seven items I found that didn't have a contract attached so I'm not sure if there's a way to post the original contract that we approved in that because we really would never be rev voting on that contract because we are unless they make an amendment to it and then it would say it's an amendment but these are all phase three which means

123that's the Final Phase and and if I may it's in the background and and we could always um put more information in the background but underneath the background it says that this project was established and approved by the school board on September 10th of 2024 so of course that preceded you so you wouldn't have known that um if you want us to add additional information in the background we could certainly do that Mr CL I think the challenge with that is if if you have a project that was approved then you'd have to go chase down every change if there were and so the original so I mean you'd really be digging pretty deep because if there were three changes after the original contract then that I mean and again it's it's not not a

124bad suggestion but I think that you could go back and search the title and go find the original one um I think maybe if if I'm understanding all of this correctly ly first of all uh you all have a background as as you've commented that I don't have and that the public doesn't have um I don't have it because I'm new here and the public doesn't have it because they wouldn't know any of this so if if it's not practical to post the contract itself maybe don't put it on the consent agenda put it in as an information item with just a description of what it is if it doesn't require an actual vote um I I took that from one of your comments that it does it's really not up for a vote oh

125no if we were to put the original contract back on or a contract in any amendments it would appear we're rev voting on them but okay I opened up 15.9 I just picked one and under the recommended action for this it says the superintendent recommends the approval of the final construction drawings which are phase three and specifications for exhibit a on replacing the pumps for buildings 12 at the project for Silver Sands Middle School so and and you wouldn't know and this is something we probably need to make a note of that whenever we have new board members come on that an explanation happens of what like phase three is because phase three is they've done everything they're ready now to just start the construction piece and so we've already we already approved the construction

126Andor we've approved any amendments so far and when we get to phase three we're just accepting the construction that they're moving forward whether it be drawings or whatever and it's just the final piece so that the construction can then take place and so I'm just trying to figure out how we can put it so we're not rev voting on a contract that that's what where what I'm going back to that if it doesn't really require a vote then it doesn't need to be on the consent agenda but it just needs to be um noted somehow as an information item okay it requires that we approve the acceptance so it does require a vote the final piece okay and so and that's just what happens through the year like there's never like just when it comes

127to construction there's never just a contract and then it just goes from there there's there's pieces that go through because sometimes it comes up with the architect piece yes we vote we accept a recommendation and vote on who the architect is going to be and then we finally get to the phase three of the drawings of the architect and we have to approve the acceptance of those drawings but it's not tied to another contract piece and Enid would tell you I've driven her crazy you know on but I need documents I had to like we all had to learn this oursel like yeah there's no this is a School of Hard Knocks it's everything and everything requires approval because of the dollar amount um nothing you know this particular item is one1 Point almost five

128million dollar you know for what's going to happen for the building 12 project at Silver Sands but it started off with you know a selection of who would do it we voted on that contract there's been amend and now they're to the point of we have to approve the drawings before they can then break ground and do what they need to do okay I appreciate all of this um explanation and so that will help me for future reference I I still look at the agenda from the standpoint of the public looking at it and and not having the benefit of that background so if there's some e some more explanation that can be added to C that that category I I think that would probably be enough um but because I didn't know this background

129I just looked at it as we're missing these contracts I I wonder if we can add a hyperlink okay that would Direct someone who is going to have to know if it's that that's a question because if we could add a hyperlink so that you don't have to go looking for it and that actually would be helpful for us now in the background part for this particular one it says Sebastian Engineering Group is who we selected to be the engineer for this and it says the project was established and approved by the school board on September 10th um 2024 so that is something that we have been very trans par arent about like this is who was selected this is when we approved the original contract it's just this is the piece we're to if

130we can add a hyperlink that goes back to September 10th I think that would be fabulous but I don't want to see us rev voting on a contract that we already you know voted on I I agree that that's why I I wasn't sure that the consent agenda was the right category for it makes sense so that's what I was just asking for my own clarification no and that's good because um we try I mean we've tried at times to explain things so that the public when they're looking at this knows and we've put more information and then what used to be there so you know we just need to look at how we can be even more transparent so that when someone reads it they know exactly what it is py can you give

131Miss brosmer a call tomorrow and just look at the description that box and see there's additional language that we can insert that standard moving forward okay we'll do um this here's the thing you know I will say previously when Dr Smith was here as a superintendent we not only had you know the legislators put the law into place about travel for board members and the approval that it needed but when Dr Smith was our um superintendent there was an approval piece for staff to go to conferences and everything and we did reach a point because financially where we were we could not send a lot of Staff out to conferences we found it to be cheaper sometimes to bring a consultant in and so tonight you know as we were voting on that document um

132as we've come out of covid we've started to see a lot more travel being done by staff and I'm I'm not ever opposed to that but we see sometimes on social media because there were requirements like so when I was in federal programs and grants if I was going to go to a conference I had to fill out the form listing the name of the conference the dates you know what travel expenses there were going to be for that but ultimately I had to State how did it relate to my job role and when I returned what was I going to do to share that with others to make a difference because you have to have return on investment especially when you're using federal dollars and there were several years that um we were very

133clear with that and a chart was kept looking at the travel and I know we've started to see conferences now you know it's one thing if you send five people you know and they're like from five high schools and they're coming back and they're going to conduct training and things like that but it's another thing when all of a sudden we've sent 70 people people from the district and if we've got 70 people going from the district what's the return on investment there because you know pictures are posted on social media and then you get the comment from somebody that says wow that was a lot of people you know out and I want everybody to learn and have what they need because ultimately it impacts our students in a positive way but I would

134like for us to look at possibly moving back to the system that we had years ago or something like that so that we're aware when we even see it on social media we know what the purpose is and how are they there is there going to be a return on the investment for what we're spending to send large numbers of people to conferences so I will share with you that the only large ones that I know of it's from the IT department where they have specifically written grants to cover the cost and the full expenditure like for example the fet FC conference and all these folks that Services the school they go to get the most because technology is rapidly running as we all know that those are perhaps the the the largest group but

135it's it's paid for for the grants because they submit those grants but absolutely we can look at something like that and we don't have to reinvent the wheel because we had it and it was used for many years and the rest of the board may not feel that same way I just know that when we're spending agreed great we should know how it's being spent Miss brosmer did you have another question oh I'm sorry no okay I'm the one that can clear you thank you okay it's been happening all night you you tap in and I clear you okay okay unless if you want to clear yourself and we haven't moved you to the top then just tap it it and it'll take you off well I did that and I just kept putting me

136back on okay all right um any further questions or discussion for for this evening thank thank you everyone and it is 6:56 p.m. and we are adjourned and

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.