CorpusRecord 1916

Volusia County School Board - The Volusia County School Regular Session 01⧸28⧸2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Volusia County School Board
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Volusia County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
36,682 words · about 204 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e yes ma'am good afternoon at this time welcome to the vucha County school board meeting today is Tuesday January 28th 2025 and it is now 4:35 p.m. in just a moment I'm going to ask that you stand with us for the Pledge of Allegiance in the national anthem today the pledge of allegion will be on video with Timber crust elementary students the an the national anthem is going to be sung by the lovely group of young men and young women standing behind me from Pine Ridge High chorus and their name is acapocalypse and I actually got it right right so um following them singing the National Anthem we will then have a moment of silence I would like to ask tonight for the moment of silence and reflection if you would please keep

002Mrs Cuthbert in your thoughts her husband passed away just after our last board meeting and this past Saturday they did a celebration of life at newer Beach High where the auditorium was packed because believe it or not he started his career back in the 1960s and people came from any school he had ever worked at to share stories and our former superintendent uh Mr Hall was even there and spoke so there were a lot of people that were there that day to honor him and to share a lot of things that I didn't even know and so just please keep her in your thoughts and prayers at this time so if you'll please stand for the pledge good evening I'm Mrs kin and this is Mrs jackz and we are representing the timber Crest kindness

003Squad and our morning news announcers with Timber I PL Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God invisible with liberty and justice for [Music] all what sooud we at the Twilight lastes and star through the fight the so [Music] rock Pro through night still there do that starled [Applause] of [Applause] [Music] [Applause] thank you you may be seated excellent excellent awesome it's so nice when we have students that come in and perform the national anthem so at this time I'd like to take a moment and introduce those of that are here at the front with me on my far left I have Mrs brosmer representing District 4 Mrs Christa Goodrich representing District 2 is online with us today so she is

004um virtual then we have Dr Gilbert Evans he is our Schoolboard attorney over on my far right we have Mrs Celeste Gilmore she's our agency clerk then we have Mrs Jesse Thompson representing District 3 next to her is Mr Ruben cologne our vice chair representing District 5 and then I have Dr balaman our super intendent and I am Jamie Haynes the chair at this time representing district one items for approval on this agenda this evening are items 1.03 2.02 5.01 7.02 and 15.01 public participation times we have public participation time for any item that is on the consent agenda if darling will you raise your hand just see her and she will give you a card to fill out also we have a 6 pm time for items of general interest pertaining to public education

005in Valia County a total of up to 15 minutes will be provided for public comment at that time then time will be provided for public comment on any action item before a board vote is called on that item and finally time will be provided at the end of the meeting for public comment for items of general interest pertaining to public education in valuch County before items from the board superintendent or attorney or up for discussion or announcement our district vision statement is to create lifelong Learners prepared for an everchanging Global Society at this time I invite any of the board members to share any comments brosmer uh thank you I um this is not something I would have expected to to be talking about but um after I was sworn in I had been contacted

006by the tax collector's office wanting to meet with me and I couldn't imagine why because all I know about him is that I have to write him checks but um we finally got our our calendars coordinated and his staff told me about a program that I understand is familiar to some of you um here in the district but I'm not sure is as broadly um familiar to the public so uh I wanted to mention it and and see if maybe at some point they could do a presentation about this this program it's um it's oh I always forget the name of it um kids tag art which is a program for fourth and fifth graders where they design uh the vanity plates that go on our cars that some of us buy uh and and

007they are absolutely remarkable um the their talent is is wonderful and and they are able to sell these and raise some money um the uh the tax collectors the state tax collectors have adopted this program as as one of their uh priorities and in County they uh they target the title one schools uh so I understand that uh we've been doing this for two years and we had one school participate the first year and now we've had 10 and um even um I guess it was governor Scott adopted a resolution and I think the the most important line in it to me is whereas it has has been proven that Arts experiences boost creative problem solving and critical thinking skills as in students and raise student awareness of different people places and ideas to help

008them appreciate the differences in the world so I wanted to mention that program and I know there's a process that that we need to follow in order to get something added to the agenda for um a presentation but I would like to somebody tell me after the meeting what that process is and and I would hope that we could have them come in and do a presentation thank you Mrs Thompson thank you so a couple things one it I think we all know it's literacy week at uh our schools and so I wanted to thank all the teachers who have invited us in to come read to the students it's always so much fun to be in the classrooms especially the elementary schools the kids just love it and they're so fun to interact with

009so thank you for inviting us in there also Thursdays I've been told the 100th day of school and so I know not every participates but hats off to everyone who does the little dressing up as old people or I know some do 101 Dalmations for the 101st day so just thank you to everyone who's making these days really special and memorable and just a little bit different for everyone that's all Mr colog so I had the honor of uh going to the east side Choice Fair which was held at the both Eastside and Westside one was held at the news journal Center the other one was at the center in Deltona and so special shout out to all of our schools who went above and beyond to uh represent their choices to the community and

010so uh both of those events were uh really really great shout out to our Panthers who had their uh health and career uh expo at pineridge so that was really really exciting Deltona High so our Deltona High cheerleaders went on to the state competition as did our cheerleaders or they're going uh so they went to the Regionals and now they're going to States uh both Delona high and pin Ridge so shout out to both of those uh schools for their programs uh of course last week in MLK week was very very busy with lots of activities one specifically in the Dand area another one in the Delona area and so the Delona one they uh award scholarships and and uh have different sa contest winners so that was a great event our high schools have

011had their uh welcome nights uh both Deltona High and pin Ridge where the students had the opportunity to uh come and learn more about the school it was a little chilly at Pine Ridge that night uh but a great time was had by all um and I know that our middle schools are also doing that and I think it's a great opportunity because it allows the parents to see what's offered uh and be able to come make those connections which we know are uh very important shout out to our amazing teacher at our uh teacher at uh pineridge who was the CTE teacher of the year she's our FFA uh Mentor teacher and so she is amazing I'm almost done oh how about all those spelling bees I had a spelling be at Galaxy spelling

012be this morning at Spirit spelling B at friendship I'm not smarter than a fifth grader and so uh it's amazing the words these kids spell that you're like I've never even heard that word before in my life and so that was really exciting uh we had a great meeting with our parents at Enterprise to uh update them on what's going on in our in our schools and that replacement school so I will stop right there it's just been extremely busy since the last board meeting thank you Mr cologne Mrs Goodrich um yeah so I just want to thank all of the principles for continuing to give me tours of their schools show me everything that they're working on um it's really exciting to see how excited and great the principles um in District 2 are

013so continue doing a great job and then it I was honored to get to go to Congressman Walt's um service Academy nomination ceremony where we were able to see all of our students that get got appointments and recommendations to the various military acmy so congrats to them excellent job and then I would also like to say I also went to the tax collector's office and that is a phenomenal program that they're doing with the license plates so I think it's a great idea to have them come and give a presentation so the community at large knows what's going on there and that's all I got thank you there are a lot of wonderful things going out on out our schools I too did a few spelling bees um it doesn't take very long sometimes before

014you figure out which children possibly are going to end up there at the end because even as fourth and fifth graders they have confidence like they walk up there and the word is said and they are ready to own it and spell it and that's what happened when I was at manate Cove last week and I've also been out reading um one of the schools that I read up this week instead of doing fiction they did nonfiction it's the first time they've ever done non-fiction books for um one school or one book one school and the kids were really interested in it because they were studying about all the national parks and so there was one book for the younger students and one for the older students and they had tied it into their curriculum

015um I also had the privilege to attend the exit interview for dant Thai for their renewal of their IB certification every five years they have to go through an IB certification and they are doing a great job and we are very appreciative of everyone at Dand high that um ensures that our students that are in IB are prepared and ready and it was nice to hear from the experts the great job that they're doing there um last night um I know Mrs brosmer and I attended the 13 th celebration of the dant and greater West fuia Chamber it's hard to believe that the chamber here on the West side of the county actually started in 1890 but one of the highlights of that chamber is that 20 years ago they actually started with Stu the

016student government piece of that and Mrs Brinkman who teaches over at dantai was there last night with a few of the student government students but I also want to share we have a teacher at University High who was the mayor of Orange City up until this last election because at that time he chose to step down because he's getting close to retiring from teaching after all these years at University High and he had no idea they were going to do this we didn't either but they called him up on stage and I can't think of anything better it's a legacy that they created that he will be able to leave for students for years to come and they are naming a scholarship in his name and that's Mr Gary Blair and it's hard to not

017say mayor any longer but Mr Gary Blair was recognized last night for all the years he's served our students in valouch county and also as the mayor of Orange City and um they're going to give a they're going to give a scholarship out each year to someone in the law and government piece and um It's a Wonderful opportunity so if any students or parents are listening you want to go ahead and apply for the first one that's coming up but I will say there's just a lot going on and we are we are very blessed I love literacy week or month I love the schools that even turn it into a month and I will be out continuing to read as the week goes on but thank you very much and we will now move

018on to item 1.03 approval of the minutes board members you had a opportunity to read the minutes do I have someone that would like to make a motion to approve the presented minutes the minutes are from the organizational meeting the leasing Court meeting the workshop minutes the regular session minutes from the last meeting which was January 14 2025 motion to approve thank you Mr clone do we have a second I'll second that motion thank you Mrs Thompson any discussion hearing none I'll call for the vote all those in favor of approving the minutes as presented please say I I I is there anyone opposed okay then it passes unanimously we are now moving on to item 2.01 agenda changes Dr Balaban are there any agenda changes before the agenda is presented to the board for

019approval Madam chair I do have it item 15.01 which is administrative appointments we do not have any appointments this evening also item 15 point Sorry the first was 5.01 administrative appointments and the second is 15.01 which is the um uh 15.01 is the response to un unsolicited letter of intent to purchase a property that will be brought up to the next board meeting okay board members you've heard heard the recommendation of the superintendent she'd like to remove item 5.01 administrative appointments because there are no administrative appointments for this evening and she would like to remove item 15.01 the response to the unsolicited letter of intent to purchase property do I have a board member that would like to make a motion to approve the agenda removing items 5.01 and 15.01 so moved thank you Mrs

020brosmer second thank you Mr cologne any discussion yeah I just want to thank the superon I think it's important that um folks understand there was a lot of misconceptions on that uh item when it was put on the agenda and so uh as we continue to work with our Municipal partners and and making the school a reality in De um I think it's very prudent to not consider this today so thank you for uh pulling that um as we continue to work with our Municipal Pro Partners so thank you I too would like to State something about that item because um I have heard that it's been misconstrued out there we actually um it's my understanding received this prior to the winter break an us unsolicited letter of someone wanting to purchase property and this

021item actually tonight was only going to open up the ability for District staff which that is what their job is to do um to meet with the person who sent the unsolicited letter or the company and go into negotiations and or at the same time open up the piece of property to anyone else that may want to look at it this did not give District staff approval to sell the property it only gave them approval to negotiate the possibility of selling it would never be sold until it would come back before the board and we would have to vote on that and approve the sale of the property so I want to clarify that because I too have heard a lot of different information out there and when people are putting out misinformation it is

022our responsibility to correct that information is there any other discussion okay hearing none all those in favor of approving the agenda as it is now written with the removal of items 5.01 and 15.01 please say I I I any opposed okay it passes unanimously we are now moving on to item 3.01 announcements by Dr balaman thank you madam chair board members members of the audience so many familiar faces in here I always love to see our students here in the audience so thank you for being here today um along with everyone who is listening parents that are listening from home students members from the community thank you for tuning in we would like to celebrate and first let's start with our volunteers and mentors of the year we do have a short video but I

023would like to recognize our outstanding senior volunteer of the year which is Miss Rachel curtain from Spruce Creek Elementary um outstanding adult volunteer of the year Eugene Perino from Citrus Grove Elementary outstanding youth volunteer of the Year Sophia hazelbaker from valua online learning and our mentor of the Year miss marleene maruo from new samna Beach Middle School we have a short video we're going to highlight all of our mentors and the incredible work that they do and the amount of hours that they invest in in in the work that we do here when it comes to teaching and learning in our students overall so I'd like to thank them but also this video is going to once again recognize them team volunteering is something that not only means something to me but I think it

024means something to the kids and I think the kids get something out of it they have that extra attention they get that extra love from the volunteers and I think it's very important to be involved I love doing this I love being here for the kids I I just get so much out of it I just it means a lot uh I was surprised not going to lie caught me off guard I was just coming in to help the teacher do some some busy work get caught up and uh next thing I know there's a bunch of people at the door so I was definitely caught off guard little bit sense of happiness joy a little bit um it's it's fun to see them having fun I think is the biggest thing you know I

025I try to leave the teaching to the teachers you know I hope if I can um but I'm just try to there to you know make the day enjoyable if at all possible when I can I guess appreciated um and it was nice to see all my like teachers and administration have nice things to say about me say if you've never volunteered you wouldn't know like how like fulfilling it is or if you've never volunteered in something and you're interested in cuz like not everything is for everybody like not everyone's going to like doing the same stuff but I'm sure everyone can find something that they'll be able to be passionate about and give back certainly not alone in this because I've gotten um help from other mentors and from being on the uh Mentor

026board and it really is a a collaborative um Endeavor that we all um should get the award together I don't think I've done anything special I've been fortunate and I've uh had good kids and uh there's wonderful uh mentors and [Music] training so in my book in our book we see these individuals truly as Heroes right because really I'm going to get a little bit philosophical here but if you look at really the meaning of life life is all about time and energy that's what it is what is life it's time and energy and when you utilize your time to really create an impact either for yourself and others and to leave meaningful trails in this world that is what it's all about and I think that's a team that really resonates as we met

027with these individuals how fulfilling these acts were to them so I would like to encourage any of you out there that are looking to make a difference because I know all of us wants to make a a positive impact in our world please consider vucha County public schools because we do need very good mentors here for our students and and also to work with with with the folks in our community so reach out to Denise Rivera because we are always um in need of of mentors for the work that we do so I encourage you to do so also it was one early morning that I was attending a conference and I got a call very early in the morning and I was toldo Dr Balman you're vucha County and you guys are going to

028be receiving an award um immediately I text my team because it's called the 2025 resilience award by The District administration which is a leading resource for K through2 leadership nationally and basically what this this group has done is that they've studied and looked at districts they've looked in terms of how when it comes to leadership in Hurricane preparedness when it comes to student safety when it comes to educational continuity and vucha county is the recipient of that award so I I contacted Patty and the entire team because as you know for every hurricane season you can always count on Florida right Florida is one of those states that you better be ready in the summer and even beyond the summer we have to be ready and one thing I will tell you is that we

029have a division here comprised of teaching and learning but also oper ation that 24/7 they're working and a lot of folks don't know that they they think well you know what school is you know we don't have schools in session so we're just waiting this out and that's not how it works these folks when it comes to attending the meetings being briefed five six times during the day briefing others organizing what needs to happen really studying the forecast executing the work going back revising it's a 247 and our team has been recognized for this so I would like to ask Miss Patty core because these are some of the folks behind the scenes that we don't get to see every day but when it comes to educating our children there are so many pillars and

030so much that needs to happen in such an order for for that to take to take really truly take place Patty if you will share a little bit about what happens behind the scene and if we can recognize some of the folks from our operation division here because they really they are the ones who have earned this so go ahead Miss core thank you superintendent Dr balgan shair Haynes and esteemed board members thank you for this opportunity to recognize um the people who make my job easy every single day uh our Operations Division and some others as you know uh it's a heavy lift um when there is a a major storm coming especially not knowing the category and um people needing to shelter and being able to house them while at the same time

031ensuring that our facilities are still safe um that we're able to accommodate these people but knowing the first thought after we get shelters up and running is how do we get them closed and get people out safely so we get our kids back um back to school in a timely fashion um and and have as minimal Interruption to the educational learning process as possible um so with me here tonight um I have a team I'll introduce in a minute but this work started you know back in Jan a year ago we'll start again in the spring prepping for Hurricane Season trainings we've attended team members have attended trainings and they presented to all of our administrators um who who do Man our shelters for us in conjunction with I have to give a shout out

032to the county of alucha Emergency Management my partner in this work is Clint meum um he's an amazing director of Emergency Management and we work very well together in his team and if you've never seen their Command Center in the middle of something like this it is something to be in awe of because you walk in and it's a huge war room and there are representatives from every possible municipality law enforcement um Waste Management St John's uh Votran busing you name it they're all in the room and so for our on our team I and if I when I say your name if you're here stand up please we have uh Dr Drew Olson our director of transportation and Chris Boer um our assistant director of transportation and he might not have made it um

033they were our boots on the ground at the vucha County emergency command center I was in and out there for meetings but they lived there and slept there and the beauty of that process is when we call them and there's an issue we don't have to wait for a call back they run to the table because all the tables are manned by these different groups and so we needed some assistance in busing and the vot tram people were s were employees were sitting right across from them and they were able to work it out very quickly um shout out to of course the sheriff's department and our law enforcement Partners who helped man our shelters to make sure that they were orderly um yeah thank you all again all of our municipalities I was on

034meetings two or three times a day with the county and then membership uh city managers from all of the municipalities we're on there doing a roll call um you know talking about safe roads what's not safe for our schools so we shared in that responsibility and um we definitely you know learned some things that we would like to improve on um but for my first experience and with the team it was it went very well I will tell you um running our shelters we opened six this last big storm uh Dr castelli at Mainland Mr damoo at Delan High Mr Jackson at Creekside Middle Mr dunigan at Henson Middle Miss Wes is here tonight from University High and Dr valz from Galaxy they ran with their teams our shelter and I'll give you uh one

035of the things we learned in our a after action well we learned it during the event we were able to thanks um to Dr V for this but miss WS called and said guess what we don't have a bilingual person at our shelter didn't even yes I know Mr cologne lento lento we learned it will not happen again um but we got Dr V and he got three different Spanish speakers available on the phone and we were able to do that remotely but we do want to make sure we Rectify that in the future that we'll have someone there that can speak to um those who who maybe only speak one language um so that's an example that I can say that came out of our after actions and uh this isn't a point to

036brag but just I'm not surprised that we were recognized because one of the things we learned through our trainings with our administrators we had multiple meetings with them leading up to the event especially the shelter managers and their teams what to expect during the event our deployment during the event and then we had an after action with them and I believe they mentioned it to Dr balaman that this was the smoothest operation for opening shelters that they that these particular principles had experienced and that's because of this team I mean yeah so I have to thank okay so also we have um Ron young he's our director he's in the back because he's a back of the room kind of guy uh Rod Smith director of Maintenance Rod two of our coordinators are here from

037maintenance department Sean kman and Rick Domin in addition to going to the county management Command Center we have a command center at Olsen that we set up that's where we all slept and um we have Ken Mitchell our coordinator for fire health and safety and he set that up for us and has done this for many years and had a wealth of knowledge um that team also set the whole Command Center and did a whole dry run in advance we used a uh 800 megahertz radio wanted to make sure everything was working and we were up and running um also who helped at the command center two assistant directors from Transportation Betsy burus and Madson [Applause] Ki and of course at the sites and for us at Olsen we have Heather deola and members of

038her team helped us with schoolway Cafe to make sure people were fed did complement the food um you know you got to keep them happy we don't want them displaced and also hungry and grumpy and then Debbie Fischer from Health Services our [Applause] coordinator with our um Health Department Services from the county as well and especially at our two special needs shelters we had plenty of of help there um to assist our students who are medically fragile um we did receive several um letters of thank you from C from some of our um community members who availed themselves of our facilities and one we presented at a principal meeting to Dr castelli someone who had never sheltered before and came and said how uh she was very apprehensive about it she was older she was

039nervous about leaving her home but when she got there she felt so safe and so glad that she came and utilized our facility during that that time did I miss anybody from our team I don't want to miss leave anybody up I said cman and Domin did I not did he not stand up when he was supposed he he I said Ron I did say Ron Don oh Rick and so Rick Dominique also runs our special projects team and I have to give them a shout out so Freedom Elementary had one building that had uh carpet um that water got in it didn't damage anything else but the carpet they turned over and luckily we did have a teacher Duty day so that storm ended I'm not sure if you remember then we had a

040teacher Duty day gave us an additional day without students to fix as much as we possibly could but these guys were working around the clock and their teams many many other people um they turned over that building at Freedom in one day 16 classrooms 16 classrooms they turned over one day so teachers could come back and kids could come back and teach and they didn't have to double up at other classrooms or be displaced um and what I miss Chuck back there um another school that did take on some flooding with Sugar Mill Elementary um they thought that was going to take longer you guys had Sugar Mill up and running before winter break by around Thanksgiving break yeah so amazing work and that's team members of the team that maybe do other jobs they

041all just went as a team pitched in they had to redo floors there they had to cut out drywall replace I mean there's just that's the behind the scenes things that unless you're there at or you were affected by that you would maybe not know um but I just can't say enough and I'm not telling you they they came in what do you need where do we need to go what's next we're getting calls kman was out there with his team at um also by freedom where our retention Pond there there was a fail in the pump or in the piping you know I don't know all the words but needless to say they came out and they brought pumps out and they were able to remedy that pretty quickly the neighbors were happy about

042that so thank you I know I took probably longer than I should but they deserve this recognition and so much more so thank you for having [Applause] us please just sit with the team for a little bit I have three more quick announcements and then we'll take a picture I want them to hold this up this is about them thank you Miss core the aspiring leaders academy uh this year we would like to welcome and congratulate 16 applicants that were um welcomed to this Academy so they are going to be spending an entire year where they're going to be learning collaborating and building skills for that next steps and these are the 16 uh 16 um uh applicants that has been inducted into our aspiring leaders Academy congratulations to all 16 of these aspiring leaders

043also Carnegie Hall I think uh board members and members of the audience you heard a little bit about there were seven districts Nationwide that were um selected for the Carnegie Hall musical explorers program and this is actually I do have a short video about this because this is a curriculum that's in every single one of our elementary schools so I'm not going to tell you a whole lot about it I want you to watch the video because one of our teachers from Pathways as all the other teachers from the elementary schools have been implementing the curriculum and I want you to get the takeaways from so far from the teachers and the students who are experienced this wonderful curriculum and it's going to be a full year fully funded by Carnegie Hall for all of

044our elementary schools again we're we are very honored to be selected for this and last but not least uncf are that uh campaign we've Bean that campaign and as you know for 35 years we've had this partnership and I want to thank you and CF for again their partnership with fuchia County public schools because they they they utilize this you know the funding that's received through these campaigns really to help prepare our students for fulfilling careers and meaningful lives so I want to thank them for that partnership and I want to encourage encourage all of our staff members to continue continue to contribute to a very very good cause and I have do have a short video of the Carnegie Hall and then we will take the the picture Miss Miss core musical explorers is

045a curriculum uh born out of the very famous Carnegie Hall in New York City and it was crafted by their education department and by musical artists from around the world and so this curriculum really targets the elementary level and music classrooms around the nation so we're very very lucky to be one of only seven districts as you as you said for the nation theyve only selected seven districts right in the nation this program in particular which you start working with the musical explorers program how is it really crafting and helping our students develop those skill sets for that overall educational experience in the area of music yeah I think that it's just opening up it's broadening their Horizons because often times we get caught in just our own world and of course this is expanding

046what they what they know as far as the world music is concerned um I think that it's it's um going to help our students be more empathetic I think it's going to help our students be more compassionate and I of course that's something that I think that we need in our world probably more now than ever and and to me I've always been about The Human Experience right and just being a good human and I think that this program can really offer that to our our students of L County so can you share with us a little bit what is your favorite Parts all let's let's start with you what is your favorite part of the music class when you're doing this musical expor program what's your favorite part about it getting to learn like

047new dances from other cultures or other parts of the world so you know what precisely I heard today that you experien a dance called the Garba yes okay can you tell us a little bit about that what you learn it's an Indian dance where you have to clap along to get with the rhythm of the song to get with the rhythm of the song and I'm sure there is a whole lot more and you were sharing with with me earlier also that you had an an experience today as well right with the freedom song yeah can you tell us a little bit about that and what you Le learning about freedom in a song and learning how they can know how to sing [Applause] and some important dates to remember we know that January 27

048through the 31st is celebrate literacy week and we know how important when it comes to reading that's the foundation for every other subject area so we're celebrating that on on January the 30th the 100th day of school so we're going to be celebrating that as well and we know Dr Seuss has quite a bit out there about the 100 day of school um Black History Month in February Career and Technical aded month love the bus month um February 3rd through the 7th is National counseling week and February the 7th is Florida school crossing guards day and that's it for announcement but we do have a picture that we would like to take with the operational division [Applause] guys hold [Applause] the proba need proba need two lines guys you guys line up and a semc

049two lines that would be awesome all right everybody [Applause] ahead for [Laughter] yeah thank you at this time we're moving on to item 4.01 recognition of students for safety awareness contest Dr V Madam chair I have one recognition at this time I would like to ask our wonderful Captain one of the best uh Captain Smith he's going to do the presentation for the safety awareness contest good evening superintendent Madame chair esteemed Schoolboard members thank you for allowing us the opportunity to recognize some outstanding students this evening the volucia sheriff's Youth Foundation recently sponsored a contest focused on promoting the safety of riders Walkers and bicyc list tonight we celebrate the creativity and talent of the students who have captured our attention with their impressive work these students will each receive cash Awards sponsored by the

050valua sheriff's Youth Foundation in recognition of their excellence and illustrating this year's theme safely rolling to my destination we'll start with poster recognition third place is Kyra Clayton from Deltona High School with her poster titled look both ways before crossing a street receiving a $50 [Applause] award second place is Caroline hanania from manate Cove Elementary School with her poster titled ways to stay [Applause] safe receiving a $150 award and first place is anaki shei from Deltona Middle School with her poster titled safety rolling into my destination receiving a $300 award [Applause] and then we also have our PSA winner and first place is Christine glim Haley Beck Juliana Santana and Sophia Nan from University High School for their Public Service Announcement safely roll into my destination receiving a $500 award [Applause] woohoo total not not

051each um congratulations to all our winners for their exceptional work and dedication to promoting [Applause] safety I think some of the yes could we do the three could we do the three with their families okay and then we'll do the University High group congratulations you guys are some rich kids you know congratulations wow very nice very so you guys come over here you can stand right in the middle let me see your everybody pleas that [Laughter] wow she is good I'm her art teer we've met before your [Music] that was smart ibody go one and let me one more with your okay okay [Applause] you got a lot of money and you want to cash those checks before because it's coming from the sheriff I just not guys go ahe and come over this way

052friends and family and principles everybody's welcome congratulations conratulations sweetheart conat Fant congratulations thank you it's nice meeting either way you want to go doesn't [Music] matter I'm a little taller that I got all right guys let's do two lines get nice and close let's do two lines I to do this everybody but can we take one step this way we got a bunch of phon just bear with you ready we go three two one be with me I told you this a lot one last one ready [Applause] this [Applause] one there go oh yeah that help thank you so much did a good job d just keep doing what you're doing okay at this time we're moving on to item 7.01 removal of any items from the consent agenda board members are there any items

053on the consent agenda that you would like to remove for further discussion or as a standalone item okay all right then we'll move forward with the approval I need someone to make a motion to approve the consent agenda as it's presented motion to approve the consent agenda as written thank you Mrs second thank you Mrs brosmer any discussion okay hearing none I'll call for the vote all those in favor of approving the consent agenda as presented this evening please say I I I any opposed okay it passes unanimously we are now moving on await I apologize that's cuz they buried it in the yellow we have a cons we have a card on the consent agenda we'll retract the Motions we'll retract the motions and Mrs Albert please come forward Mrs Albert you're here to

054speak on item 12.05 R yes Jerry a good evening Madam chair members of the board superintendent Dr balabin members of the audience first I want to thank you for fixing that I would have been really sad had I not had the opportunity to ask my questions so I'm speaking about the consent agenda item 12.05 which is the resolution of the school board to wave the impact fees for the single family homes on Fulton Street I understand the intention of this action and I recognize that it is great it is a it's something great that's going to happen for my for the community but I just have a few questions about the waving of the school impact fees first and foremost is vola County School Board as an entity legally allowed to wave School impact fees

055um typically School impact fee waivers are for developments that are 55 plus communities where they do not have children attending our Public Schools uh will these homes be available to parents of school AG children and we know that the school impact fees actually pay pay for financial um costs that are incurred by having children attend our Public Schools so um how will those uh Financial impacts if children are going to be living in these homes be covered uh is that something that valua County Schools will then cover or will some other source do that um we know that um even as uh recent as today our school funding is always um in Jeopardy we know that we are um obligated but um we receive our funding because people make decisions outside of those who are

056the practitioners in our school so I just am asking these questions to make sure that fiscally we are setting ourselves up in the best position thank you thank you Mr cologne yeah so uh to this point and I actually had a meeting with uh staff this is deferral of impact fees so the we do not have the ability not to collect the impact fees what we do have the ability to do is to defer them for a later date and so these impact fees will be collected they're just deferred which is what allows the homeowner to be able to purchase the house because of all the initial costs so we will be collecting the the fees we don't have the ability to wave them it's just deferred for 10 years years uh so we will

057be collecting that money uh which is often done it's you know municipalities do that sometimes Within impact fees as well uh and so uh usually it's you know based on you know as their phases go out so I had many of the same questions uh with that and so uh at first I thought we were giving a 10-year waiver to never collect and I'm like wait a second whoa but no that's not the case and the other thing is that's this is particular particular to only four Lots which are the four lots that we uh had gifted them earlier uh in the year for these homes and and my understanding is that preferential treatment is given to first of all folks in the community I think one of the I I don't know specifically who's

058going into these homes uh but they are working together with our schools to I know one of the families because I was at the uh event was uh uh from Bon cookman and so again I could see just as another educational institution the advantage of that so um again many of the same questions I had thank you this prar uh you're I this is unfamiliar to me and and your comments uh just brought a question to mind uh about the process uh not everybody owns their home for 10 years so how does does that waiver um follow the property we have also placed uh lean on the property it becomes a lean then on the property that runs with the land that after 10 years those impact fees will be due okay and and the

059lean doesn't interfere with their ability to sell the the property um I would guess they would have to satisfy that lean in order to buy it think the lean would have to be satisfied before a new fee simple owner is able to take possession of the property okay thank you I just wondered what the process is yes ma'am any other questions okay so we're going to go back I need someone to make a motion to approve the agenda because I have no more green cards um the consent agenda as presented I motion to approve the consent agenda as presented thank second thank you Mrs brosme okay we'll call for the vote again all those in favor of approving the consent agenda as presented please say I I any opposed it passes unanimously we are now

060moving on to item 14.01 this item is on graduation Readiness Dr Balaban thank you madam chair as you know recently we've received our graduation rates from the state of Florida and during that time what we do is that we we present we do a presentation and the presentation is not just to highlight the schools and the work that they've done but also to acknowledge the work that our parents do behind the scenes when it comes to working with their children the work that our students do daily in the classrooms and when they get home every day right what you would consider their homework and so do and also the work that that our teachers are doing and our principls and our District staff so I would like to ask Mr Mike malli who is our

061executive director for grad assurance and student services I see we have two High School principls in the audience so I will ask them to come up in the front please and sit here because you had something directly to do with this work as well best huh the two best yes both of them all 10 of them Mr colog um and we also have with us here today um Dr Baker Dron who is our executive director for secondary and Mr Bill reer but I will tell you soon to be Dr reer [Music] okay and they're going to do a presentation I've shared with you in the last board meeting that a lot lot of folks say what is it that that H you know I remember four and a half years ago and I remember something

062that you stated Mr cologne when we were talking about our grad rates and where we were and you said think of of the number of students on an annual basis that's not walking across the stage you remember that conversation oh yeah and I will share with folks that when they ask about what we're doing in volia county and I said we have really taken and created a systemized approach for identifying and allocating resources so we can meet the differentiated needs of of students is so the team is going to give you a full-blown presentation what that looks like but also they're going to be sharing with us what are the state statutes and requirements for graduation um Readiness and how here in vucha County we have systemized an approach to meeting the differentiated needs of

063our students so take your away team all righty thank you thank you Dr B chair Haynes school board members Dr bman thank you guys for having us and allowing us the opportunity to share a wealth of knowledge with you guys we have a very very thorough uh presentation for you that we went in depth about graduation requirements and what it kind of takes um and I want to start off by providing you guys some accurate information too um just to have a clear understanding about what it takes and what it goes into talking about a school district grade where graduation kind of falls into that with a high school grade A District grade um and then talk about some other components so um please understand when we're doing this that the requirements have multiple Pathways

064that we're going to talk about with the graduation um as we do this based on the Florida State statues as Dr Babin stated as Educators directly involved in this work we want to ensure that the board and the community understand the following graduation rates represent one of 12 components of our school district grade at the school level graduation rates represent one of 10 components of our high school grade third grade reading carries double weight in a district grade which is our district grade has 12 components just so you guys know when we're doing our school grade an elementary school would also carries double weight in their eight components counted both on an average component of ela for a district is grades 3 through 10 so that would be a culmination of grades three through 10

065average um and grades three through five for elementary and then it's also a standalone metric is that double that it takes for um to go across when we're talking about third grade carrying double the weight I want to give you guys some clarification on that and I bring that up because I know there's been a lot of misconceptions out there but of the 66 districts of only seven schools performed higher on their third grade Standalone proficiency metric than they did on their overall District average of grades three through 10 um across the board of seven of those districts of the 66 so I know there's been a lot of things saying our third third grade scores aren't matching our graduation rates that's not right so I'm going to get into a little bit more about

066that no not to mention no third grade reading Standalone metric or District's Ela proficiency grades three through 10 even came close to any school district's graduation rate not even closer comparison so I want to make sure we're comparing Apples to Apples when we're talking about that so when you're looking at proficiency and you're looking at third grade and when you're looking at Ela there is a huge discrepancy when you're looking at those numbers and then the graduation rate there is is and we're going to talk about what we talk about progression of learning when we go there we're going to talk about multiple Pathways available for students to graduate in four years or less how these Pathways prepare students to be college career and service ready we're also going to explain how data-driven strategies for

067supporting students entering high school at various achievement levels and progress Progressive learning and approaches for students uh to be successful our goal this evening is to clarify any misconceptions and demonstrate how we're meeting state requirements by serving our diverse population this presentation will cover the key policies related on our students performance and uh progression along with some graduation requirements for a district next slide we will also focus on the district's strategic goal around our optimizing learning conditions and operation efficiencies to support student learning all aimed at ensuring high levels of learning for all students we're going to get started here by talking about what is high school graduation Florida has established three main requirements for high school students to graduate based on the Florida State statue 13428 to it's based off of credit requirements grade

068point average and state assessments First Credit requirements students need to complete either a standard 24 credit diploma or 18 credit option I call that as a high school principal you have flexibility or you have speed and I'll get into that a little bit more these credits must be distributed across specific required subject areas to ensure all well-rounded education is required the GPA standard to graduate students must maintain at least a 2.0 grade point average this isn't just for core classes this factors in every class including electives giving a complete picture of the overall academic performance of the student State Testing there are two crucial State testings that must pass a student must pass the 10th grade ELA language arts test and the algebra one end of the course exam this ensures the student has mastered

069fundamental skills in writing reading and ma uh mathematics and this requirement works together to prepare students for their next steps whether it's college career or being service ready we talked about the different paths and different types there's technically seven different types of diplomas that a student can earn um a high school diploma with and we're going to cover all of those with the team up here for you today the main diploma types are your standard traditional high school diploma which we talked about is your 24 credits and then we have your accelerated 18 credit option which stands for just so you guys are aware academically challenging curriculum to enhance learning which is 18 credits and then we also have our International recognitions those are our two IB and our Ace Cambridge that we'll discuss a

070little bit more in in-depth um later on in this presentation and then we also have career Pathways our CTE diploma option we have two other alternative options and that's our C certificate of completion and our access for standard diploma to ensure every student has the opportunity to to graduate based on their individual circumstances we'll review a couple special designations the students that enhance their diplomas when they graduate just not with a normal high school diploma but also additional recognitions these include Merit scholar designations for academic excellence and special seals for biliteracy of Fine Arts so the next slide is just kind of an overview just so you guys can kind of see what it is I'm not going to kind of go into it because we're going to break it down um in the next

071couple slides so it's just an overview of the options of what the credits look like what the designations are the team up here will go into each one of those in depth for all of you guys so you guys are aware let me highlight some crucial distinctions between standard diploma and a certificate of completion a standard diploma represents full completion of All State statue and all standards it's including assessments 2.0 college gpa and you've fulfilled all your credits this opens the door to colleges military service and employment opportunities to be productive members of our society in contrast pass certificate of completions mean a student has completed coursework but did not pass State assessments which means they have graduated with a 2.0 they've condone they've earned their credits but they were not able to pass the

072two state required State assessments either math or Ela while this shows educational e effort it also carries significant limitations for that student you could look at this as a participation certificate they get a normal certificate just like they would these students are allowed to walk at graduation they get a cap and gown some parents depending on where they are they think their kid received a high school diploma because they receive a diploma cover with a certificate of completion and all that and it states right there it looks only thing different from a high school diploma it says certificate of completion on it and not standard high school diploma the limitations of a certificate of completion are substantial it affects colleges admission military enlistments federal aid ability and of course career opportunities federal law does not

073recognize this as a standard high school diploma this is why we're encouraging our students to work towards a standard diploma at all cost and demonstrate what both options we have for skill and Mastery the next is the 24 standard and 18 credit options the differences here in the commonalities between the standard and accelerated options are as follows both paths maintain the same core academic values 2.0 pass required State assessments and GPA core subjects like math English science and social studies the key differences are the 24 credit program offers electives includes PE and online courses provides the full year experience the 18 credit accelerated option removes these additional requirements for those students allowing a more motivated student to graduate in three years and focus on a more academic path if they want to go dual enrollment

074route this is that flexibility verse speed so knowing what the student kind of wants does the student want a true four years Traditional High School experience do they want to be involved with all kinds of stuff Sports academics extracurricular activities and really take in that full four years or does a student already have their plan mapped out when they walk in their ninth grade year saying this is what I want to do I want to start my dual enrollment some have already started in in middle school and their parents have it mapped out for them to where they're finished their sophomore junior year and they're strictly do enrollment after that so that would be that flexib or that would be that speed plan with the 18 credit Excel option so which path fits for goals

075and circumstances it's all about what's best for the kids the parents know and what the students know I'll be very honest with you they decide we have counselors that they meet with um they're incoming year they sit them down they go over the plan they they each school is different and unique each uh student is different and unique we have to decide what the kid is good at what their interests are and then we will then kind of build the programs and the schedule around those students just so you're aware um the 24 credit program suits students wanting to full that High School experience while the 18 credit works well for those academically strong and post-career graduate students next slide and then I'm going to turn it over over to Mr Reeser here and he's

076going to talk about our Ace diploma very happy to speak with you all about opportunities that are most accelerated students have opportunities to pursue Advanced diplomas while here as a student in vucha County Schools the first of those is the Cambridge Advanced International diploma otherwise known as Ace or Cambridge you can see the schools represented there that have this program available Belia County schools has a very high success rate of a students earning the ace diploma the Cambridge Ace Program is an internationally recognized curriculum that must be completed within 25 months of starting students start on the 24 credits and must pass seven Ace exams that's a critical component for the ace diploma is the passage of those seven Advanced exams the program requires 100 community service hours while meeting standard diploma requirements this rigorous

077program is offered at the select schools that you see pictured the Wolves of Deltona the Panthers of Pine Ridge the sand crafts I know what they say once is sand crab always is uh the cudas uh as well as University Titans the sharks at Atlantic high school and uh Buck Pride Never Dies this a rigorous program uh is offered at these schools this path combines International academic standards with local graduation requirements preparing students for Global opportunities I do want to highlight that these students do participate in our valua schools progress monitoring assessments these progress monitoring assessments as are administered to all of our students are also administered to our Advanced students with the purpose being that no student is Left Behind no student falls into a crack they do participate in those progress monitoring assessments

078next slide refers to the IB program that is hosted at Dand high school as well as Creek High School the district also enjoys a very high success rate of IB diploma success the IB program is an advanced pre-university curriculum available at Spruce Creek in Delan students must complete six IB subject exams a theory of knowledge course an extended essay and Cas hours community service while maintaining standard diploma requirements this comprehensive program combines academic with creative and service components preparing students for higher education globally as shown by the mascots this program is offered both at danan and Spruce Creek High School moving to the next page are the CTE Pathways available for graduates in valua County Schools the CTE pathway combines standard diploma requirements with career focused preparation we celebrate our CTE programs and the opportunities

079that they provide our students for work Readiness upon graduation from high school students take two credits of call Career and Technical courses while pursuing industry certifications like all Pathways this diploma pathway requires a 2.0 GPA and passing of and of course assessments ensuring students maintain academic standards while gaining practical employment skills this option prepares students for immediate career entry while maintaining educational Excellence if you've ever heard me talk about the job placement for HVAC Academy and the immediate wages earned upon that employment that's what we're talking about next would be the access standard diploma the access standard diploma provides a modified curriculum for students with significant cognitive disabilities this path uses the Florida standards alternate assessment to measure achievement in course subjects at an adjusted complexity level students must demonstrate employment compet competencies and daily

080living skills while aligned with the Florida standards this program emphasizes practical skills and very importantly meets individual student IEP goals I'm happy to pass this now to Dr Tamara Baker Dron good evening everyone so in addition to our achievement in addition to a standard diploma students can obtain additional achievements that can be added to their diploma such as the Merit designation so the Merit designation recognizes students who Excel beyond the standard diploma requirements students must earn uh industry certification and complete Advanced coursework at least one credit in AP IB Ace or dual enrollment while me meeting the standard diploma requirements this designation demonstrates both academic excellence and Real World skills enhancing college and career opportunities another added achievement could be the scholar designation The Scholar designation is a recognition of advanced academic achievement this are

081this is honors outstanding academic achievement through rigorous coursework and assessments beyond the standard requirement students must pass the exams in Geometry biology and US History additional credits needed in advanced math science foreign language and AP IB Ace and dual enrollment courses another achievement could be the Florida seal of biliteracy designation the Florida SE the Florida seal of biliteracy offers two level of biliteracy recognition either the Gold and Silver Seal the difference between the two the gold seal requires level four or more on the ELA FSA and advanced foreign language proficiency through AP IB Ace exams or completion of four years with a 3.0 GPA the Silver Seal requires a level three or higher on the ELA FSA and intermediate High foreign language proficiency through similar Pathways at slightly lower thresholds this recognition demonstrates Mastery of

082both English and foreign language valuable for college and career opportunities another academic achievement added to the standard diploma could be the Florida seal of Fine Arts the Florida Fine Arts seal recognizes exemplary achievement in dance music theater and Visual Arts students must earn a standard diploma and complete three credits with an a grade in one fine arts program they also need to fulfill two additional requirements from a menu of options these include Advanced coursework um jury through comp um competition um participation Arts related service portfolio completion or recognition for the original artwork all right and I'm gonna now start and we're going to talk about the EOC assessments um and first we're going to start with the algebra one this is a required State assessment that all students have to pass starting from 22 to

08323 that the best uh started that's when it started with us participation is mandatory in the performance levels range from level one which is a 325 all the way up to a level five which is a 475 students must achieve a level three that you can see highlighted in blue which is a 400 is the minimum score a student must reach to show proficiency to meet that graduation requirement or hire to to do that so it's a level three four or five learning gains will show student growth on state assessments year-over-year and how they can be achieved in three different ways moving up from one achievement level to another from a level one to a level two a level two to a level three and a level three to a level four a level four

084to a level five maintaining a level five status or a level one or level two student who increases their specified points within the same level such as 1.1 moving to a 1.2 a 2.1 one moving to a 2.2 this allows the shows that learning has been taking place which shows that that student is able to earn a learning game the system recognizes both examples and shows learning is taking place and progress is being being made towards closing those achievement gaps we talked about like Progressive learning and what we do so when we when we see a kid is not getting it in third grade that's not the end of the story that's the beginning of the story is how we should really look at it it's then we start doing the testing what are VBA

085is showing us what are the kid needs what we we kind of break it down like there when we look at the assessment value truly we should be looking at it in like four different ways does it promote deeper learning rather than surface level memorization um you know are the results useful for improving teaching and learning is it fair and accessible for all Learners and then most likely is it important and does it measure the growth and development of our students I think if you look at those four things that we're doing and when we do our uh valua um VB and our PMS that we do and we assess our students off of those are what we're look forward we're trying to do we're trying to dig and really find out what those students

086need what the skills are needing so we can help them Reach their goal of at least making learning grains or learning gains or growth to show achievement here is our Algebra 1 concordance scores students that don't earn a level three or higher this is where this is where we come into play so a majority a lot of our students will earn their graduation requirement off of right here this algebra 1 concordance score so I will tell you guys that right now student who pass who don't pass the Algebra 1 EOC can meet it through these ways we have the PSAT the msqt which is the preliminary uh or the National Merit Scholarship for qualifying tests for for everyone to know you need to have a 430 on that uh the SAT Math is 420 they

087need it 16 on the SAT math geometry they can also take it and score it three or higher so even though they failed the algebra 1 they did not get a three or higher they go to algebra if they get a three or higher in algebra or a three or higher in Geometry they would meet the concordant score to get their their um graduation just so everybody is aware also CLT is a new one which is the classic learning test which came out last year um with the governor and they need 11 on that for the mathematics piece in 11 so elig eligib eligibility varies when students enter ninth grade um schools offer all different types of things I'll be honest with you as principles we do after school boot camps we do SAT and

088C uh camps uh we do practice tests uh during lunch we do online study resources uh math tutoring programs uh we hit the district up for all kinds of stuff and use our Title One funding I know as principles and uh everybody up here can tell you um we also work on targeted remediation with our students so we would know who these students are uh just not seniors but we look at them as as every cohort so if they're ninth grader sitting in there and they failed their Algebra 1 we know who those sophomores are we still know who those juniors are who don't haven't met their graduation requirement we have those all situated in like different cohorts and maps and we're trying to how do we provide these students every opportunity that we can

089give them and we'll get into to show you about every opportunity because that's what it takes to get these kids to truly graduate in four years or less you have to provide these kids opportunity and it truly comes down to doing that and finding someone who believes them so and we'll we'll get into that as well so when we're looking at the fast Ela uh Ela uh Ela reading assessment I apologize olog the key points here are pm3 that's the last uh PM that they have to test and that's for 10th graders so all Ela 10th graders regardless of a concordant score whatever you score on any other score you have to get a level three of a 247 or higher on the pm3 to meet your graduation requirement for 10th grade ELA doesn't matter

090what you score in ninth grade you can score four or five um we hope you score four or five on your 10th grade but 10th grade is the one that counts that's the graduation requirement not your ninth grade um your achievement level like I said goes from a 179 a level one all the way up to a level five which is a 308 and of course a level three or higher meets uh your graduation requirements with it same thing as what we talked about before with the math you can show achievement levels based off of going from a one to a two a two to a three a three to a four and a four to a five your level fives maintain a five it shows that they've made learning gains because they're maintaining where

091they're at and they came in with a five and they've maintained a five um if they also do show Point increase within the same level which means it would be a 1.1 to a 1.2 that would be a learning gain a 1.2 to a two would be a learning gain 2.1 to a 2.2 would be a learning gain as well um we do all types of learning when it comes to this uh we have students in all different levels I would say with tier one tier two interventions all the way to tier three with our intensive readings with our ninth and 10th grade students because that's really the core of it where we really have to hit it we also are strategic about where we place our Juniors and seniors that still really haven't that

092passed this to where we're cohorting those students when we're when we're scheduling like we're just not scheduling them put them wherever the scheduler puts them like we're being strategic and putting them with the right teacher with the right with the right group so they're all together so the class and the peers they're sitting with they know they're all in there because they've got a pass they're all looking around it's not like we're here to have fun they know the job that they're asked to do um the comprehensive skills in all subjects that they have to do that's where we do cross-curriculum in literacy reading strategies um in science social studies math electives and everything just not Ela classes we got to give the kids the exposure everywhere we can targeted interventions for uh struggling readers

093we do text complex complexity um we do regular progress monitoring for all VB like I said in PMS those are you know that's that's really how we move the needle when you look at everything I know people will look at it but I mean that's that's our diagnostic right there when that's how we're going to know where these kids are at what they need with the Rea Department pretty much will hand deliver everything that you need to know about a student and what that student is struggling with and we'll give it right to you on a plate and all you have to do is take it read it get the kid and give the support and it's there I mean that's that's how good our department is for Rea that is is so granular that

094they've G you everything you possibly need to know what a student needs they've taking all the work out of it for principls teachers and all of that so shout out to them when you look at our concordant scores this is another thing when students don't pass the ELA 10 this is where we go again just like we do our algebra so current scores what we need sat we need reading and writing to have a 480 um act English and uh reading combination you need to have an 18 CLT verbal and grammar you need to have a 36 so we support this we do the same thing we do boot camps we do Saturday schools uh we do after school tutoring we can do any and everything that we can to give Target tared intervention support

095for these kids for ACT prep CLT prep any kind of boot camps that we possibly can think of to get these kids motivated and ready to test just so you guys are aware because they know they have to take this the concordant score is where a majority of our kids will get their graduation requirements just so you know and it's about opportunities and we weren't always exhausting all opportunities and I'll get into that in a little bit when we talk about testing waiver options just so everybody knows this is provides an alternative path for students with disabilities when standards assessments can't accurately measure their abilities so key points to know about this the I AP team determines their eligibility all accommodations must be considered first the student must pass the course and also must sit

096for the exam to be a a waiver eligible so they have to pass the course and they must sit for the EOC exam before a waiver is issued once that waiver is issued that student is then able to check that box for a graduation requirement and that is for the algebra EOC and for the ELA 10 when we get into this Esau students testing waiver options we do have a little wiggle room here if a student comes to us and is labeled Esau within less than two years we have a portfolio option that they're able to meet um which is great for these students because coming from Deltona you know that's that's our population that we deal with we get a lot of kids that come and that's that's the population that we get caught

097up the most it's it's that second language I don't care what people say it's that's that's the hardest thing for them to understand and really sit for a test to try to see not in their native language and say how can we get these kids to pass it um but when they're not less than two year when they're less than two years they have a portfolio option that they can demonstrate Ela proficiency through formative assessments and completed the portfolio that we send to the Esau office they take control of it they gu grade it they guide it if all the criteria is met they let us know they check off the Box the unfortunate piece is if the kid is over two years there is no Esau waiver so kids three or more years labeled

098Esau there is no waiver the kid has to pass standard high school diploma by Ela or get a concorded score uh for algebra one or the ELA piece that's where you come into a lot of your certificate of completions back in the day um and I'll talk about just some stories with that when we get there when we talk about options these are some options that I want to show you this is what we gave all principles I gave at the beginning of the year here's your test dates for ACT SAT and CLT all your counselors should have these it's the test prep guides that were hyperlink to them so it took the students right to the test prep guides there's no reason why students shouldn't be able to have these and signed up for

099them so this was all Saturdays not counting the two um in school CLT days that we're paying for as a district as well for our Juniors and seniors that's new this year that we have never done so we're doing that to break the cycle because I know how important is and early it is to start that on the left you will see what's highlighted here these are your retake days so retake days normally happen in September December and uh May is when you're going to retake your algebra 1 eoc's and your elas in between there that's highlighted you will see is your act school days your sat school days and your act ncrs not there you will not see the February 20th CLT school day that's not on there because we just got it added

100on to so that's that's that one is not on there so but we as a district are providing that to our students and all of our schools free of cost to all of our Juniors and all of our seniors that still have not met their graduation requirement because we know the importance of it so it's about exhausting every effort and opportunity that we have for our students just so you guys are aware um kind of went over all of that so you can see that piece so District level support when we're talking about it um Rea myself um Dr teron I kind of work hand inand with his team and try not to bug him too much but monitoring in data is is is key if you want to get these kids across the stage

101you have to know them and you got to know everything about them um that's first and foremost and it starts with the relationships it really does um if you don't have relationships with these kids and they don't know that you like them they don't know you believe in them and they don't know you trust them you don't have a shot with them I'll be very honest um and I'm coming from that from I'm an Orman boy but they love me in Deltona you know and it was there for eight years and it worked out great you know and it's just one of those things to where you know the Dynamics the culture but it's knowing the students it's getting them to understand that you're part of them and you're part of you're part of that

102community and once they see that and the families believe that you can do anything you truly can in a community um so Rea department and data dashboard is huge we'll get into a little bit about that we do bi-weekly project 10 reports which will show you a little bit of that as well it's pretty much an update and it codes all your uh your graduation seniors by color green shows they they've met all graduation requirements light green means missing one component it could be a GPA it could be a credit behind in or they could be missing a testing and then what we do is monthly graduation Trend and analytics so this is where you would be right now this is where you're trending if we don't see this this is what we're doing as

103well so what we do is have regular meetings with those principles and we talk about what's their plan and it's just not with their principles it's we have them bring in their graduation teams so that's a new thing that we started with them as well to make sure that it's just not the principal doing the work because you can't do the work you've got to have a full team behind you doing the work each and every day and literally you build as long a table as you can possibly get um financial aid support you know we look to cover act and sat waivers whenever we can um you know and we're collaborating as much as we can with all staff and regular principles as well I'm gonna turn it over to Mr rer now talking

104about identifying atrisk students and Mr mcalli was speaking about exhausting every effort and at times what has worked in the most cases for students doesn't work for certain students in certain situations and obstacles present themselves that put at risk the pathway to a graduation diploma for a student he talked about the devotion of the principles and their staff to not give up and exhaust every option an option that became available for us in this past year is the new graduation acms that are housed on each of our campuses and and staff by our staff the graduation Academy you may have previously heard of e-learning is essentially a new and expanded version of e-learning by which we have expanded flexibility and options for families for atrisk graduates students who are considering at that time potential Dropout

105options potential GED options one of the final efforts that we make prior to that would be be invitation to the graduation Academy it begins with early identification and initial assessment if a student has two or more course failures their attendance is below 90% they're below grade level in reading and math and their credit deficient this creates an immediate priority for students needing intervention the project 10 report that Rea creates that Mr mallof spoke of is that early identification as early as 10th grade where you begin to identify those non-graduate risk factors the second step is the support team that he spoke of building the support team with the counselor The Mentor in a Student Success contract to bring awareness to the student and their family that the pathway has obstacles that must be mitigated step

106three is the personalized success plan creating a onepage plan credit check for each student that includes the specific credits that they need to graduate quarterly Credit Recovery goals and required State testing requirements as well as daily and weekly check-ins it is flexibility options that have support provided and finally implementing daily support structure monitoring that's attendance contracts and grad Academy placement review of daily and weekly progress and a progress check with the mentor uh as well as uh required Credit Recovery work time step five is that credit recovery and great Improvement to establish the required GPA and eighth period credit recovery options online course access for flexible completion and we have coupled this with access to the programs that otherwise exist on our brick and mortar campuses thereby giving those graduation Academy students access to all

107of the great things accessible to their grade level peers monthly progress review meeting also include the counselor student and the parent so that the student and the parent understand that pathway to the diploma to create that sense of urgency to complete the diploma within the four-year period step seven is the College and Career Connection linking the coursework to their career interests and connecting them potentially through our CTE programs and with local businesses for job shadowing exploring vocational job certifications and potential College visits if that's the goal and then finally quarterly evaluation and adjustment to flex as the students needs continue to change these are our most at risk High need students at the high school level that require the most flexibility in our remediation plans you have to love the picture that you see before

108you because that's where it all comes together uh this picture tells you a story a student uh that's wearing that cap uh indicative of their graduation welding indicative of their industry CT that they've earned through Career Tech uh the Technical Training and in connection to the employer uh and that happens to be uh military uh uniform as well uh ready to serve uh following High School potentially in the armed forces of our great nation this represents one of the many postgraduation Pathways combining education with the skill trades the visual emphasizes how vocational and Technical Training can lead to immediate career opportunities while continuing education and not to be outdone or our dual enrollment students we are so proud of the success that we have had in cooperation with Daytona estate and the graduates that you

109see there our students are achieving remarkable Milestones Beyond High School completion they're earning college credentials alongside of their High School diplomas Associates degrees with high honor rates over 80 of them each year having one student not only graduate with a diploma but also their bachelor degree while in high school the 2023 student who graduated with their bachelor's degree was a Deltona High School graduate last year as well as growing vocational certifications from two to eight as well as a combination of academic and Technical achievements this demonstrates how our students maximize their high school years leaving with both a diploma college credentials and giving them a significant Head Start over their peers same age this is a further breakdown of our dual enrollment numbers you can see the tremendous numbers fall semester 1500 students consistently enrolled

110with nearly 25% of them uh representing each High School saving families thousands of dollars in college costs as well students earning college credits and building that college gpa while still in high school additionally the vocational track fall semester shows the greatest enrollment in our vocational track students gaining industry Sears and a direct path to Workforce Readiness these numbers represent accelerated academic progress college readiness college career preparation opportunities and as we mentioned that cost savings for families our students aren't just attending high school they're actively pursuing Advanced education and Career Training simultaneously I would like to Echo as a former principal our job was to make sure that our kids had every opportunity um to graduate whether they were going into the workforce whether they were going military or within the traditional pack of College and

111Career which leads me to our career in technical education because as we know not all kids um want to go to college they want to enter into the workforce and so we I want to illustrate that one of our strategic expansion and success U of our district CT CTE programs is emphasizing the critical role in preparing our students for the workforce and higher education by offering programs across 15 career clusters and integrating industry certifications belua is ensuring that students gain both academic and technical skills relevant to in demand careers we have Partnerships with institutions like Daytona State College and Emory riddle Aeronautical University through dual enrollment programs not only to enhance access to advance learning but also create a seamless transition to postsecondary education we have now built our CTE programs amongst our middle to

112high school Pathways um which reflects Dr Bam's commitment to providing students with early exposure to Career options and equipping them with the tools needed for Success upon graduation our work-based learning initiatives such as internships job shadowing and pre-apprenticeship bridge the gap between education and employment so our kids are able to get out into the real world early before even graduating allowing them to gain that Real World experience while still in school Additionally the extensive Community Partnerships reflect a collaborative effort between the district and local businesses to build a talent pipeline that benefits both students and our local economy overall our commitment to CTE is fostering a future ready Workforce while aligning with regional economic needs creating opportunities for our students to thrive in high skill High wage and high demand careers continuing that strategic growth

113ensures the expansion which we have aligned to our district goals Community needs and Workforce demands our CTE has grown tremendously here in Valia County programs of courses our programs we have increased from 48 to 56 our honors courses from 74 to 100 our career acmy from 19 to 37 and our career Pathways from 23 to 64 our industry certifications we offer um our offerings have increased from 32 to 120 and students testing doubled between um from 4,784 to 10,476 this shows a dramatic expansion in both opportunities and student participation from since TW um 2021 this also allows for our resources to be allocated effectively avoids oversaturation or duplication of programs and ensures high quality outcomes for our students by growing we can maximize impact build sustainable programs and provide students with relevant meaningful opportunities that

114lead to success in high school and high demand careers so once again if we look at our CTE program integration and why industry certification matters it's because one we've aligned it to our district goals we're looking at our community needs as well as meeting the demands of our Workforce so this allows us one to um as stated before um look at our allocation and making sure that we're not duplicating programs so that we can ensure high quality outcomes from our students so some key benefits to this our industry recognition of Competency this accelerates career entry and advancement we match employer needs and expectations and we lead to higher wage opportunities so um once again we can maximize impact build sustainable programs and provide students with relevant meaningful opportunities that lead to high success in careers

115when we're looking at our college level um experience and opportunities as we stated earlier they have to take certain tests and those energy certification tests as well as our um our our our accelerated tests so our AP performance we have increased over 1,500 tests passed annually this shows Mastery of col level content our International programs our Ace has dramatically grown from 140 to 2,45 pass exams our IB showing um growth with 1,000 over 1,000 um exams being passed our dual enrollment success between 6,000 and 8,000 courses passed annually which is a significant college credits earned while in high school enery certification has more than doubled from 1326 to 2775 this shows a growing career Readiness and these numbers distri excuse me demonstrate our commitment to challenging students academically so this is important because while we

116are preparing our students for college and careers students aren't just participating but they are excelling at our Advanced courses here in valua and then the last for me military pathway as we know we do have some students that aspire to go into our military services so in order to um the requirements to go into the military they must have a standard diploma not a COC which is the certificate of completion they must have a standard diploma they must have taken the ASVAB testing measuring the academic skills um a physical examination is required and a minimum afqt score by Branch for Army is 31 for Navy is 35 and for Air Force it is 36 so so a strong academic performance open doors to even our specialized military roles early preparation through rigorous coursework helps achieve

117those required scores all right this slide we're going to go over our historical graduation rate as you guys can see valua is the blue uh 201829 of where we started to 23 24 of where we we are trending uh we are trending in the right Direction I will say when you're looking at that 2018 2019 that 84% there think of all of those kids of that certificate of completion or those kids that got a GED um that probably don't have a high school diploma so when you're looking at that TR trajectory think about the students that are walking across the stage with a true high school diploma um and meeting what they need to meet by the Florida State statues to read receive a high school diploma so it's a great thing for graduation for

118valua County Schools we've risen to 93.7% up 2.1% from our previous year um of the 67 school districts across the state we ranked in the top 10 for graduation rate for the second consecutive year our district have seen an increase in graduation rates nine of our 10 Traditional High Schools showed Improvement Deltona High School reached a perfect graduation rate of 100% Pine Ridge School Pine Ridge High School had a largest one-year increase at a 4.4% Belia graduation rate has shown steadily increasing Trends rising from 84.5 to a 93.7 as you can see consistency year-over-year Improvement volution graduation rate suggests these students are being empowered to maximize the potential and the achievement that each one of them have while the Statewide Florida rates provide helpful context the key story here is the significant progress valua students

119have made demonstrating that success looks different in every individual student the data highlights valia's commitment to supporting all students not just any student but all students and helping them overcome challenges to re their reach the graduation goal at all cost this slide is very this looks at our Central Florida Coalition as you can see here vucha County School ranks second among the districts within the central Florida Coalition with our graduation rates these numbers just aren't numbers they represent our students from our backgrounds with real dreams and real aspirations as a former principal I know the complexity and the the work that goes into supporting students day in and day out multiple Pathways multiple graduations that students need and to have the support people may question the work but until you actually walk what we do

120day by day in our shoes as a high school principal a high school teacher high school office staff you'll never truly fully understand because it truly takes a team or a village to do what we do valua steady rate has climbed outpacing the state shows an unwavering commitment to empowering students lives and giving everybody an opportunity to succeed metrics matter of course they do but a reflection of the meaningful work for our staff and the students that they put in Daily that matters as well these results speak from the heart of the work that our staff does daily and the schools that they put in for 180 days that we ask them to do that here's our VCS data dashboard that our Rea Department develops this is how we progress Monitor and track our students

121so on the left you will see our data dashboard this is our project 10 that that I was showing you guys this will let you guys see kind of where we're at with our graduation if we were to graduate right now with our dark green dark green would mean we wouldd have a 311 students graduate today at this certain School light green we would have 51 that means they're either low in credits they're under a GPA or they need one testing if they were yellow that means they need two components of graduation still so what graduation teams are doing is coming up with individualized plans for those 51 students those 15 students those four students and those one and that one student every one of those kids I promise you has an individualized plan on

122every one of those campuses um and I'll show you with that right here is something new and this is the individual student this is actually the baseball card here to where you can pull up on your phone you can pull it up on your laptop but this will show any school counselor any High School principal actually what the student needs if they met their graduation requirement if it was through uh the ELA if it was through their Algebra test it shows their GP and then also it shows if they met their concordant score for graduation and it tells you what test and when they took it so when I say we have one of the best Rea departments in the game we truly do I mean they give you any and everything if I call

123them and say I want this and I want a principles to be able to see this so they can monitor and track let me get back to you and within an hour it's built with a program and it's this is this what you wanted same thing I mean it's it they're absolutely amazing when I say they put everything on a plate with what you just have to look at it and you have to analyze it and that's how you know your students because if you put in the time to do that you're going to know your students and you're going to see success and you're going to see results so just to kind of touch that piece of it that's the that's the the the data empowers our Educators to closely monitor our students so

124just so everybody understands that piece of it um next this is what we developed at Deltona High School it's the Playbook to senior success love this very proud of it um once I got into this role I worked with the school counselors um and then got into the school counseling Playbook because you got to have a blueprint you got to know where to start and you got to know what to do so what we started to do here when my first year as being a principal is we mapped out month by month what we do how we do it and why and then once that month was over we would go back and we would reflect on it what worked what didn't work what do we got to change and what do we got to

125add we kept a running tally of that my first Year's principal my first Year's principal was Co by the way so that wasn't that fun so you know we we had a lot of tweaking to do that second year but once we got it down we knew what we had to do so we keep this Playbook and it it's it's an ongoing it's a live document not every Year's the same you add new things into it like the CLT testing was added last year that was never an option but it's a game changer for a lot of schools right now um so it's the blueprint of our strategic intern or intentional and systematic executed plan to ensure seniors graduate in four years or less it outlines the non-negotiables that I always had as a principal

126it gives my month-by-month actions of my expectations of my graduation teams of my APS um of my school counselors my expectations of when they meet with those seniors or those Juniors because we're not just meeting with seniors we're meeting with every cohort and I would want to know the expectations of where we're at and what was going done um and then also the data curriculum and uh data AP and curriculum AP they would be the ones that would spearhead a lot of this because they oversee that Duty and responsibility it was Key to Our Success it was it was empowering us to holistically support students toward their goals for graduation um it leveraged our resources it did um with students so they can navigate their High School experience and we put them in positions to

127uh have a positive post-secondary outcome for most of our students as I said the school counseling Playbook it was developed to individualized plans for our students and their cohorts so we didn't want any student to fall between the cracks so coming from a school-based level principal and then coming into this side of the house I knew the importance of we got to have systems in place because we've never had it before so we wanted to make sure that our counselors knew the importance of having a Playbook and a blueprint and this ensures that students when they enter their ninth grade year their counselors are knowing what to look for each month what they should be doing how they should be targeting their kid when they're doing their uh credit um reviews when they're meeting with

128their students and doing their one touches so it's all of that stuff of really making sure we're not having kids fall through the cracks and if we do we're going to catch them early instead of their senior year so we're putting things in place to be more systematic um next like I said this is our highlights um that we we've we've kind of done that we're very proud of in valuan County Schools we've shown you more than just numbers and Trends we've shown you what transformation of lives look like I truly believe so our graduation rate has soared from 71 to a 93.7 in just six years and I think that represents thousands of additional students whose Futures were forever changed every percentage point is a story a perseverance dreams realized and families celebrating some

129possibly their first high school graduate our commitment to excellent isn't just exceeding State averages or hitting performance met we're just not graduating students as some people would like to say we're launching careers we're igniting passion and we're building workforces for tomorrow this isn't vucha County Schools doing well this is Valia County Schools doing what's right following the Florida State statue for all students social media is always filled with all kinds of opinions about public filled with various opinions about public education one truth stands undeniable the extraordinary work that our students and staff in valua County Public Schools command command is should be respect while we welcome thoughtful discussion about our approaches we will never accept disrespect towards our students our staff and the dedicated work that our Educators do each and every day our district

130has a vital Mission and we can we will continue that mission day in and day out each day we shape the future and transform our young lives and the Legacy deserves nothing less than your complete respect so thank you for being with us and we will be glad to answer any questions that you all may have thank you Team all right we will start with Mr colinton wow that was tiring W it's a lot of hard work uh first of all I want to commend you our district thank our superintendent uh because I remember campaigning when it was 71% and you said something at the end that really stuck with me is it's more than a number these are lives and Dr teron can probably correct me but we have about 4,000 or so graduates

131a year something around that number and so if you think about 71% that means that 1,00 students in 20 going back I think it goes back to 161 17 did not walk across our stage with a diploma uh now the stage is actually if I'm correct July 31st so it's not just the May graduation stage it goes all the way up to July 31st so if they're able to accomplish that um then they're considered a graduate in that time frame you mentioned a lot about opportunities and it was just one after the other after the other after the other and I remember getting here and our students who were required to pass their fsas uh fsas given twice a year was given twice a year thereabouts three times a year what that in May in

132may even worse it was once a year and so our students uh while there were concordance scores and the ability to take all kinds of different ways paths to reach those requirements they were taking their fsas their end of course exams uh how many times is end of course was that offered traditionally for retakes retakes was September it's normally September December and then may so that was three opportunities there and that was pretty much it and so if the student didn't meet that uh and so what we realized was there was lots of other ways for students to meet these concordance scores but we weren't giving them those opportunities uh it was a time when students could take the SAT sat and their families had to pay for for and they had to go on

133Saturday and take it and so we brought it into the schools we pay for it because again we want to give those students not only the opportunity but also sat sat opens your world into the college board and just lots of resources that they have there as well this is intentional work and I've seen it over the many many years where I could probably look over at Mr doer and I'm not going to do this right now but I could look over there and say how many students do you have that are in that third tier that are in trouble he could probably name them all and having been a uh slightly challenged student in high school I can tell you nobody ever said anything to me about hey where are you where you going

134how you g to get there it just it just wasn't there and while I realized that you know a lot of folks heard a lot of Assessments mentioned there the reality is to that student who's trying to walk across that stage yes they have to take as many chances as they can because otherwise they're going to graduate with that certificate of of attendance and so the work that we're doing here in vucha County the intentionality the investment because it's not cheap we pay for these SATs in school act non College act uh per gosh if we could give per again I mean there's just and you know we added the the classical test which is re re recently approved by the Florida Department of Education again just one more path and so it's an a

135nonstop path to continue to provide opportunities to our students you talked about dual enrollment and and you know having two kids have taken advantage of dual enrollment very proud of my two kids uh and every other student who does it uh but it's it's figuring out dual enrollment costs us money dual enrollment we don't make money on dual enrollment we lose money on dual enrollment but one thing I'm proud of our superintendent is she realizes that that is good for children that the only way our children are going to get out of poverty in our communities is through education the other side of that because everybody likes to praise the IB the ace and all that the other side of that which wasn't mentioned is our partnership with Richard Milburn and Richard milburn's graduation rate

136was 82 82.2 82.2 so you have a school that takes in these students not every situation is a failing one some go there by choice some go there by circumstance some go there because they' like it there it's a smaller environment there's lots of different things that go on and and different paths that they can take their students to reach that success many of which are at risk and so to hear that our graduation rate in 201617 and I can probably go back and look at the numberers so I don't get it wrong so 1617 was uh 76% that's all of valusa County all students and to hear that Richard milbourne's at 82 two that that's pretty huge that's huge but what happens in that conversation and I know that some folks listening say well

137that's the elephant in the room well guess what at some point we realize we're not the best choice for that student the same way we do for the dual enrollment students that we realize we lose money on dual enrollment it's not a winning proposition school districts don't encourage dual enrollment the way that we do they don't because you lose money but we know that it's good for students and all of these individual strategies have helped us to say you know what based on your current path maybe we're not the best for you you'll do better there because they have different resources different tools different rules and it is what it is and so our students when that student to Richard Milburn the graduation the federal graduation is based on the cohort so if they are

138able to graduate before July 31st or meet those requirements they also are counted in our cohort because they're part of that graduation cohort trust me it took me a long time to understand this all and how it worked and so the the partnership with them has been huge so much so that I have a Richard Milburn on Deltona Boulevard which is probably 12 miles 8 10 miles away from pineridge those students even if they wanted to can't get there every day so what did we do we went into an interent facility and we said hey we can give you a classroom because you know what we want to give that opportunity to that student to be successful and we realized they're not going to be able to get from pin Ridge to there or or

139from New Smyrna to there or and so we want to give those opportunities for these students and so through a through a you know facility agreement we've been able to do that as well again that's good for kids and so I want to commend I want to thank I mean it's you know the irony that the two folks that are sitting here and the two folks that were sitting there and Mr doer is still here I'm sure uh principal goodr uh goodr listen to me principal Dr lap now um uh I I saw the name up there uh you know it it's ironic that the two folks sitting here and the folks back there have carried that mantle which has been systematic and I've been really big about systems I get it we do it

140well at one school well what worked there and how can that work over here how can we create that hunger so we're not only looking at our top students the top students who are going to be successful are going to be successful no matter what it's how do we look at that one student and I noticed that on that app there's one student at that school who just chances are and so if we could focus on that one student maybe we could make that zero and so again I want to commend you the other thing that I stuck I'm almost done the other thing that stuck out to me really really interestingly was that app and I say that because when that when that staff member is with that student it may be by the

141PE field it may be by the cafeteria and that student has a question they can go this is what you're missing this is what you need that I mean who's ever heard of that I mean it wasn't when I was in school I don't think I ever even got called to the counselor's office to say I was probably at the principal's office and so you know again I I want to commend you I this is not cookie cutter work this is specific this is intent this is the work that our students deserve and uh I am very very proud because right now as you know I remember it was you know as Dr balabin alluded to it I always remembered you know if we graduate a thousand students and our graduation rate is somewhere around

14276% that's almost a thousand students that did not walk across that stage it was slightly lower in my community and so to say now now that at the end of the day in my community only about 20 between 20 and 25 students were not able to meet that requirement by July 31st or in our district so you take seven so I don't know how many that adds up to I'm not even going to try okay how many less than 20 about 19 18 1920 students that's per thousand that's huge and so we are changing lives and so thank you thank you thank you thank you because I know it's tireless work I get the rooc calls they're not rooc calls I I hear the intentionality I hear we have a biology Camp uh we have

143this I get all the calls and ironically all the calls I get say your student has been identified as one who has not please you know we have a boot camp this weekend your student it's it's very specific and that's part of that Playbook it's very specific and those efforts are what has gotten our students across the stage and across the finish line so thank you thank you thank you Mrs Thompson thank you and thank you Mr cologne for mentioning the summer cohorts because I was going to mention that because that that is something I know we see the graduations here but I know everyone else doesn't I just had had one thing to bring up and you might not have the answer you might uh misser when we were talking about the ace programs

144and I love that nine out of 10 schools have the IB or the ace and they have that opportunity it what about our students at Taylor High School do they have an opportunity to participate in either of those or is that something that's coming and it could be I know there's not as many students out there but they're also further away than anybody else to things like dual enrollment so on campus I know they do have you know the ab to go online but is there anything to that I would definitely add the success that's been experienced through the other schools has been a foundation for that to be a very worthwhile consideration uh there is a demand our tailor Wildcats are thriving under the leadership of principal Pierce uh they do deserve uh those

145equal accelerated opportunities we just added this program I believe last year to Mainland and Atlantic uh in Atlantic so so it has been incrementally added and if you followed the statistics of enrollment and passage it is profound and the beauty of the Cambridge program is the flexibility that would be very fitting uh in a smaller Community such as the Taylor Wildcat Nation uh where it would be uh potentially uh a worthwhile Endeavor that is certainly something that is being uh evaluated for further uh implementation all right thank you so much for answering that for me that's all Mrs Goodrich thank thank you so much this was fantastic um can you guys hear me yes yes yes okay so this was fantastic I've asked you about this information quite a few times and so and and

146you were able to share this information directly with me but I'm really glad to see the presentation um for the public I know that there were many years that vucha County wasn't a high performing district and we're on an incredible trajectory right now and I love to see the momentum going so thank you if I if I can I'd love to dra you guys along to some of the community events I go to so we can get all this information out to the community so they understand better how it works and how our kids are graduating and the different options that are being presented to them through valous schools so if that's an option I will drag you along as many times as I can um Mr Clen brought up Richard Milburn and that's been

147brought to my attention quite a few times so would you be willing to touch on that for just a moment or two and explain what that pathway looks like if a child um is struggling and how they end up at a school Richard Milburn and how that works so that the public has a better understanding of that yes so Richard Milburn it's it's a great question and you know Mr cologne hit on it as well when you're talking Richard Milbourne you're talking certificate of completion let's look at that that's the first one you have kids that walk out of your school with their certificate of attendance pretty much that that's all they have as a high school principal and I was a data AP for four years prior in charge of graduation it was very

148disheartening to see 30 to 40 to 5050 to 60 to 70 kids get that certificate of attendance there has to be different ways how do we think outside the box how do we help these kids and support these kids and we have to identify things that are happening earlier for these kids so it it's trying to identify those kids with what do they need and we were able to do that with working with our partnership with Richard Milburn and doing that those kids that don't get or that receive a certificate of completion they're able to come back for retake test ing the following school year and the following school year up until 21 but those kids do not do that I tell you that so those kids are pretty much they're done after that piece

149of it so when we're looking at Richard Milbourne we're identifying kids that could be behind it could not be working school's very big there's many different options for students because High School is a huge setting there's a lot of distractions the the um graduation Academy is a perfect example that's why we have that on our school setting now those kids it's too many dist ctions with 1,800 to 3,000 kids um on campus so we identify those kids we put them in a smaller setting they're working remote they're working online um as Mr colone said about why we have the partnership with them on some of our campuses it's because those are still our kids as principles those are our kids I'm not giving up on my kid I'm doing what's right for that kid because

150I'm going to provide him another opportunity that is not working well for him on my campus and like I explained to the parents we're going to do and get everything we can to get him a high school or her a high school diploma so that's why the partnership has started and has been brought unto our campuses to with Richard Milburn so we're able to still have eyes on them we're a fresh set of face they know us they can come see us they do everything and everything with us like they we check in on them it's they ride our buses they do all that kinds of stuff so it's it's one of those things that they you truly have to understand we're just not a kid goes to Richard Milbourne a principal's not saying we

151got you're out of here that's not the case with the that's still our kid that's why the kid is on our campus we want that as principles we want the ownership we're not giving up on kids we're just providing a kid another opportunity and an Avenue to earn a high school diploma that that was not working for us at our school site yep I'd like to thank Miss Goodrich for the question and I just want to make sure that the conversation includes the focus on those personalized relationships with these students that beginning nth grade and as warning signs begin to show over the years that that four-year clock is about to tick out and there's not a diploma in the foreseeable future those very personalized relationships between the school administration the support staff and the

152teachers with that individual student come to very personalized and at times very challenging conversations we sometimes talk about those as family conversations and we lead I'd like to say with a school appropriate love a power of love we're on a very individualized basis we identify and exhaust every viable option to get to that that final diploma within the four years and at times that is the most flexible option at the end of that pathway when other viable Pathways do not appear uh for that student and the alternative is non-g graduation at that point uh so I wanted to just add that relationship context thank you Miss Goodrich yeah no thank you all thank you for your attention to detail and your energy that you put into this and everything you do I've seen it firsthand

153and just continue doing what you're doing because we're headed in the right direction thank you Dr baman yeah going back to Richard Milburn I'm going to add this on also having an alternative setting such as we do here in vucha county is not exclusive to Valia County Public Schools it's in every district and one of the important distinctions to make regarding um students that might be candidates for like for a rich mbour is that they're significantly behind their credits and it could be for many reasons many reasons every child has a story we all know that um but one of the also an observation when when you're enroll into a curriculum like the Richard mbour curriculum then the student can focus exclusively on those content area classes they really don't have to like they would

154in our public setting have to enroll into all the of the electives and the other requirements so students that are significantly behind with credit that they pose a threat in not graduating they can enroll Under the Umbrella of Richard milberg which the expectations state state expectations are different and they can focus exclusively on those content area classes and again I'm going to say this that every district has an alternative such as whatever they call it right here we call them Richard mbour but whatever it is for exclusively for that group of students so that's an important distinction to make but i' like to uh give a we were talking about opportunities for students and as you know we have committed to saying when we started the CTE bus stores we talked to our partners in

155educ ation and we said guys we want to be be able to secure some paid internship opportunities for students and I'm going to share with you that about uh a week ago I believe we've received confirmation that so far we have 100 paid internship opportunities for students and I would like to thank the uh Theona Tortugas for for those 100 internship opportunities that are paid for four students uh we are established a goal of 500 so we have four more four more hundred to go so we're we're asking our we're going to be meeting with some more business partners and hopefully we can have 500 paid internship opportunities for students this summer so and again I want to thank the team because it's true dedication it's it's a true commitment in saying that no child

156will be left behind that's what it's about and understanding that every child has a story and every parent want to be able to see that their child has an opportunity to truly succeed that's when they choose valua that's our commitment to them and I want to take thank my team because this is a team here that even though we are a large District we're considered a large District in the State of Florida they have taken a very small District approach and systemized that across a long a large District as ours to say that every child we will do our very best to ensure that they achieve success and that's what public education is all about so thank you team so I last as always um I want to say thank you and I'm glad to

157hear about the graduation acmy which are formerly like our e-learning Labs because there was even a time period where we had the storefront we had storefront East and storefront West which was another and I know a lot of you may not have been here at that time but it was a lot it was another alternative but I think tonight we also should compliment um some of our other partners that take some of our students that for for whatever reason don't fit into like a normal high school setting such as our child's Academy you know the mission that they have because years ago we used to have programs on our high on not all of our high school campuses but several of them for young ladies when they got pregnant and we removed most of those

158programs and so that's how the child's Academy came to be but they are taking those young ladies and they are helping them to not only as they become mothers you know learning how to nurture their child and take care of their child but they're also doing their academic part and if you've never attended one of their graduations It's a Wonderful celebration and especially if they tell their story to hear what they went through and how they were supported in order to earn that high school diploma another one is our PACE Center for girls that's another one that for whatever reason everybody doesn't fit into the same mold and I would encourage you also to be supportive of that and then probably the one that brings tears to my eyes every year is Halifax hospital Halifax

159Hospital holds project search at all three of their locations so each year they take students that have finished the ESC curriculum here in vucha County schools and they take a specific number at each of the sites and they take them into the hospital settings and they give them experiences to work in three different areas in the hospital and basically they help them with their goal setting and you know it's a true partnership between valua County schools and Halifax Health because it's our Educators that are there and overseeing those programs and there's nothing better than to attend that graduation and you hear a student say my goal was that I could finish this and get a job at Panera and I already got a job job and I've had two paychecks or you hear another you

160hear from a parent who said I wasn't sure my child would ever get a job and they're now working in the schoolway cafe at one of our elementary schools and so there are a lot of different ways and ultimately our goal is for students to graduate the certificate of completion which used to be called the certificate of attendance it doesn't get them anything it doesn't get them into the military and what's hard for me is I've watched the pendulum you know I taught at the high school level I taught out at Pin Ridge as we were giving the high school competency exam that's what they had to pass and we switched over to FCAT you know with the first state coming down when they were going to give us report card grades and everything I'll

161never forget a young man he actually already had a daughter and he was sitting in my math classes every week I held two learning labs on Tuesdays and Thursdays after school he came to every single one of those because he was down to four months left and his time was up and he said I promised my mom I'd earn a high school diploma and see that's the stories we need to be sharing and telling because every student has a story some of them the path to get there has been much easier others hasn't you know I'll never forget the young man who was homeless and raising himself and was set on getting a high school diploma and we need to do everything possible so I thank each and every one of you it's so much

162easier at times for people to criticize than to praise but the thing of it is if they just walked in the shoes of a teacher for the day in the shoes of an assistant principal or a principal or anyone on a campus and they got to know these kids they would find out that the reason why we're here is to help them graduate so they can be productive citizens we want them to graduate and find a path we want them to be able to work we want them to go into the military we want them to be go on to college you know or a university but if they walk across with a certificate of completion all those doors have now shut for for them so we've come a long way from where we were

163in valuch county and I do appreciate everyone because it takes every individual on a campus and it also takes parent support and sometimes we don't necessarily have that and so I thank you for tonight the one thing that I would like a little bit more information about at some point is about the Merit designation piece versus the industry scholar designation piece because I know that's kind of we're like switching and the one final thing I want to say tonight because I'm surprised by the number of people but then I realize if you're not in a school setting you don't understand it um these end of course exams I think people think they're just they're in that class they're in the geometry class or they're in the biology class or they're in the algebra class and

164this is just the final test of the year in that class but that's not what it is it's a Standalone test that's been designed by the state so you can sit in you know kids can take pre-algebra they can take algebra 1A and algebra 1B or take straight Algebra 1 and they can take it all year they can take every quiz every test during that course they can do all of the homework they can participate in class they can have a you know an a even or a B in that class and they get to the end of the year and they go into a separate setting and they are handed a test that it's pass it or you don't graduate and I can tell you this none of us ever I mean I I

165took all those courses and I passed them but there was never this separate test that it was like this test makes the difference on whether or not you get a high school diploma and that is a lot of stress and that's why sometimes I worry about some of our kids that start Algebra 1 really early in middle school because the further they get away from those skills if they didn't pass it that seventh grade year or the eighth grade year it becomes harder and I know all the boot camps help I know we do some are Algebra 1 EOC you know prep where the teachers work on I mean the the teachers drill down to the specific parts of the algebra test that they have not passed and so I do appreciate all of that

166but I think the community needs to understand you know if you take biology in 10th Grade and you don't pass the biology it's not going to keep you from getting your diploma but if you want to get a higher distinction you're going to have to pass it well by the time you take it in 12th grade and you've taken other science classes lots of times you don't have right at your fingertips all of that information you have to go back and study and it makes it harder for them and so that is why I have advocated all along at the legislative level that we have other options I'm thankful for the ACT the SAT I'm now thankful for the classical test being added when they took the per test away which I still would like

167to what I said to a few of them is I'd like you to go take the perk math test and see if you can get into dual enrollment at the college level when someone said I think that test is too easy well really would you like to take it and let's see if you can pass it and so I do appreciate the other alternative paths and what I would say don't ever let us lose those paths so as you have an opportunity to speak to legislators you have to find that story to share with them about the student that walks across but does not get a diploma those are the stories they need to hear and I was very thankful two years ago our principles had a lot of our students write those letters to

168them sharing their story of every everything that they had done and how one test was holding them back from a high school diploma but thank you for everything Mr colone has something else to say and I'm gonna yeah one more thing we can close with this right now only seven states have testing that is high stakes that can keep someone from graduating seven Florida being one of them and that's our reality we live in Florida and so the diploma of someone who is in the other 47 43 States is absolutely acceptable in Florida yet our students have it a little bit harder than everybody else it was in the mid 20s in the early 2000s it was 27 actually uh but that has dwindled down so Florida Louisiana Ohio New Jersey New York Texas and

169Virginia are the only states that have high stakes testing uh as a requirement for graduation that was it thanks M brosmer just a quick question how long have we been doing that that testing which test how long has the state been doing the end of course um testing um trying to think when did Pearson come into town yeah they just keep changing the name yeah hsct FCAT and then then we went to fast but the but the algebra one I think came in to play so it was part of the original um education rewrite that was done 20 years ago no not it's No Child Left Behind I believe yeah well no the but Florida doing the Algebra 1 EOC as a standalone I could be wrong had so I graduated in 95 I had

170to do H and hsct was required or you got a certificate of of so I don't know but the high school competency test was just a test testing everything okay right similar to the California achievement test and the Iowa achievement test and the Metropolitan which are tests over the years like all states have given but I want to say it was around the time my children were right finishing high school or getting ready to graduate um and that was one graduated in 2010 and one graduated in 2011 that we came in with the algebra 1 e C so you could because I taught algebra one and one a and 1B and my students didn't take it when I taught at Pin Ridge I I had a group taking hsct and a group taking FCAT there

171was no algebra one Standalone test but the algebra one Standalone was the first one then they developed geometry and then they developed biology and at first what they were telling us as they developed each one each one was going to become a graduation requirement so I am thankful that the only one that stands right now is the algebra 1oc and instead they flipped the others over to be you know you could earn a merit designation if you passed them okay thank you and it's early 1980s was required for students to demonstrate basic skills in reading and passing the hsct well that that's yeah but that's not the Algebra 1 EOC Algebra 1 is 2011 and 2012 there you go so roughly 15 years of of doing it okay thank you yeah all right anything else

172okay we're going um to take a short break and we will be back in here at 7:20 p.m. to do public input thank you e e e welcome back if everyone can find a seat please it is 7:24 we are now moving on to item 16.01 public participation just as a reminder you'll have three minutes to speak you can see the clock from the podium please those of you in the audience there is no making sounds while people are speaking you can use jazz hands if you agree you can put a thumbs down if you disagree but we are going to respect each speaker so I do have one question as going through the cards Matt I have two for you are you speaking twice okay what I have on both of wait a minute

173okay I see it now all right thank you all right then we're going to start with I will um State the name for the first person and the second person the first person will come up the second person will be ready so the first person tonight is Chris weinrich followed by Robert is it Bryce okay so welcome Chris thank you and good evening I'm reading this on behalf of my wife Karen weinrich who cannot attend tonight's meeting because she is teaching a view professional development class that covers yet another mandate from the state this one that says that all teachers with reading and Elementary education must have 40 hours of reading and 20 hours of ESC points in order to certify and our Union has developed a class that actually covers both of the requirements

174for this one course therefore she's asked me to read this on her behalf to share the truth about testing Karen says quote once again I need to express my frustration with the amount of testing in our ele students are required to do the state has mandated the fast test given three times s a year in both Ela and math which can make up to a full day I know we can't control this test and I think most of us would agree that a test that could possibly take an 11-year-old all day is ridiculous and we all need to continue to Lobby the state to make changes to that test what we can control is to change or eliminate the VBA tests that our students are required by fuchia County to take if us school board

175members haven't seen these tests I strongly suggest that you ask to see them when you do begin by noting the sheer length of them you will find that at least for fourth grade the students have to read numerous lengthy passages and answer over 30 questions on the ELA test the math test has a similar length as I told you last month these tests are longer than they were last year again students get unlimited time so we lose two days of instruction on these VBA days I ask you to picture yourself your child or your grandchild at age nine do they really think it is appropriate to give tests that are so long that even high schoolers would have a hard time sitting for them how is all of this extra testing doing what's best for

176children spoiler alert it's not we all understand the need for good relevant data however what the vba's give us is redundant data all of the information gleaned from the VB can be gotten from the fast tests themselves by simply eliminating the standards that are not yet covered in class rather than making this simple adjustment we are torturing our children with more days of testing rather than providing important and dynamic instruction I urge you to work for the children's well-being thank you thank you Robert Bryce followed by Matt Lawrence speaking for himself good evening I come before you this evening to tell the the truth about testing and that fucha County schools are over testing our students there are currently 33 tests in middle school that are given during the school year where sometimes The fucha

177Benchmark assessment is given either a few days before or a few days after a progress monitoring test what I am wondering is why are we even giving these vvas and the PM testing so close together or even giving the bbas at all they're also coming back from winter break the PM tws were given directly the same exact week which has caused some students to just give up and not take it because they know that in fact that only the third PM test counts during the last makeup testing 15 of these students were done within five minutes of then of even starting the test this happens we're not getting an accurate score I not only as a product of fucha County school but a retired disabled veteran of the United States Air Force have not had

178to take as many assessments as these students are taking today and how many days are being wasted in the classroom for these tests why don't we go back to the good old days of the vucha away where we taught for what to make these students be successful not only in the classroom but in their Futures and lives as well I know that the district was able to pick the dates for the PM testing and the window is open for the entire month so in the future can we suggest that we don't have these PM tests immediately right after winter break or have bbas right before winter break I thank you for your time today thank you Matt Lawrence speaking on behalf of yourself and then speaking on behalf of Pamela Melton welcome hello everyone sorry

179I gotta bend over it's not made to my size um my name is Matt Lawrence I have been teaching for 12 years um across the country so I started in Philly taught in Arkansas DC um and now I've been in Valia for eight years um I currently work for volia United Educators um but I have been um at the at a high school for the last seven years um and I'm soon to be a parent that's big news for some people I don't think I told Dr castella yet um but soon to be a parent so I'm very excited about that student going to Reed patillo but I'm here to talk about testing um so last year as a high school teacher and M Mr Malla said it perfectly we give our students lots of

180opportunities um the FSA the act the ACT NCR the SAT the CLT the fast used to be the part um and then if there in 11th grade and taking these makeup exams they're also taking the VB the dasas for US History all of that to say with within those three Windows if a student continues to fail they continue to take those tests and so my question is is this castet approach the best way I had a student last year who missed 81 days of school or of my class because of testing um because he had me first period and that is a lot of school particularly when I left in April so I wasn't even there the full 180 days and so the question is does the data support this castet approach of retesting everybody

181at the high school level if I'm at a school where my pass rate is about 30% I'm having to test about 300 Juniors on that Ela or math exam if five of them pass the retest is that worth it I don't I don't know the answer to that question I just want to know what's the data what is the pass rate on these retakes I like the fact that we have these boot camps and these different things that we do for the testing and again those are great ideas but they take time again from class that student who missed 81 days wasn't 81 days of testing it was 81 days of boot camps or testing or test prep or something designed to get them to pass um Unfortunately they did not and they were moved

182to RMA in April and they did graduate they did walk which is fantastic ftic but they they were not successful on their retakes and so as a student who missed 81 days of instruction to not be successful on those retakes and that's just I'm asking is there a way that we can look at targeted data from Rea Rea is fantastic they do have great data I love data there's a way we can look at targeted data to see who do we need to retest is it the whole cast net approach or is there is there a better way to do this thank you you are now going to speak on behalf of Pamela Melton and Elizabeth Albert you'll be after Matt all right so this is um a media specialist at an ele school um

183this is just to reiterate what Robert Rice was saying uh the main problem is having VB before the State Testing students are so tired of test they do not want to take the state testing and don't do as well as they could if it was their only tests also the tests all of them are way too long and have too many passages for 8 to 11 year old students it's a lot I'm sure we could get a score with three passages and more questions per passage finally the extended time for all students is ridiculous to be sitting in front of a computer from 8:30 to 2:30 with the lunch break is torturous give them a set time and then it was included um the testing that is at fifth grade level so on December 2nd

184they had 30 minutes of I ready for ELA 30 minutes for math on that Tuesday 30 minutes of I ready for ELA 30 minutes of math same on Wednesday same on Thursday same on Friday at the end of that week they still had 27% of students not completed so they had to finish the following week the following week on the Tuesday they had the science VBA which was a 90minut session with 40 questions on the Thursday they had the ELA VBA with a 90minut session uh does not include the number of questions the following Tuesday was the math VBA with a 90minut session does not include the questions then we had break after break we came back we had the fast Ela for 90 minutes um but those said it says most students took longer

185than this 40 questions and then the following Tuesday the fast PM math 80 minutes which again students taking longer than this 35 questions so in those 21 school days students had to take five VB or PMS spend 445 minutes testing that's 7 and a half hours more than an entire day of school in those 21 days it does not account for the weekly formatives or summatives that are also given in each subject as we're approaching the end of the grading period and needed to admit the district gradeline the district guidelines for grading it also does not include transition time to the test um or any time that the test goes beyond the if you need to test beyond the time and so that is um a fifth grade class thank you all thank you next

186up is Elizabeth Albert followed by Susan Holbrook okay I only have I had the green card for you and I only have one of these and this one is for um Miss is it Grant I don't have another one for you okay so you're speaking on behalf of Miss Grant thank you you're welcome good afternoon Madam chair members of the board superintendent Dr balabin members of the audience so let's talk some more about the truth about testing Wednesday should not be a testing day there is not enough time for the students who get unlimited time to test testing on Wednesday results in one hour less and it is not fair separate class students take an extra long time to test because many of the students have to test one to one a substitute typically comes

187into the class so the teacher can test the students students are missing instruction while the substitute is there there are reasonable concerns about student growth scores that are a third of a teacher summative evaluation score because they are judged on the progress of their students yet time is taken away from instruction in order to to test over multiple days additionally here is how this I sum it up to my team the PM fast testing was split into three parts so that pm1 and pm2 would be indicators for pm3 now VCS has VB as an indicator for those pm1 and pm2 indicators so make it make sense we have VB as indicators for the PMS that were also intended as indicators oh but that's not enough data we also have to do I ready Diagnostics as

188well never mind my weekly and unit tests that provide classroom data to boot please next up is Miss Susan Holbrook followed by Mr Williams cell welcome when the state realized they were giving too many one andone test for secondary students their response was to move to progress monitoring test this was not exactly the less testing response we were hoping for but then our district doubled down with even more progress test testing in between to make sure our students would pass those tests so our districts would look good for funding then our school's response was to add boot camps to get kids ready for these tests so they would pass and we the schools would look good for bonus money the result was a never ending cycle of pullouts for test prep pull outs for testing

189pull outs to talk about testing pull outs to talk about uh tutoring for testing and then the result is that students are tired of the testing teachers are tired of the testing when I came to protest the testing last year at the school board meeting I was invited to a meeting to work on Solutions I've been to two meetings at the district office with other teachers who are concerned about the over testing both meetings had Dr nazaro Valley and Dr teron in attendance the first meeting we asked the district uh that the district testing be streamlined so it would fit into just one class period so students um can be tested by their Ela or math teacher without disruptions to the rest of the campus and or at least a block class so that the

190school could do block schedules for just two days and get the test over with this seemed to a fall on deaf ears when we went to the second meeting and the testing schedule was revealed there were not few tests they were not streamlined or shortened nor was a block schedule proposed as part of the testing in other words no changes to the quantity of tests or the length but an assurance was given that the quality had improved in fact of as of this year they've added yet another test for juniors and seniors who did not pass their FSA e in 10th Grade and that would be the CLT that you've heard about this evening again this year we've had to into the pullouts for the uh about importance of taking the tests for students the

191uh importance of tutoring for these tests and yes more pullouts for the boot camp what a waste of time talent and treasure we do not need more last hail minute Hail Mary boot camps to try to get them to pass the test the kids aren't failing because they don't know how to take the test they're failing because they lack the skills for the test we need to help them improve their skills using specialized programs that work within in the classrooms to improve our students mathematical abilities for their math exams and specialized programs within our Ela classrooms to improve students vocabulary and their reading and writing skills so they can pass the test demonstrating their skills please end the torturous wheel of over testing and use that time talent and treasure for teaching and for teachers

192and to support our students thank you thank you next up is Mr William cell followed by Miss Christine serier good evening William cell city of DeBerry thank you all for let me speak tonight I'm G to tell you a story that nobody's ever heard before and then I'll get into why I'm here so when I was uh going from sixth grade into seventh grade I went to visit my counselor for the first time and I was always a big boned boy I had friends that wanted to be truck drivers firefighters police officers and I looked at my counselor and he asked me what do you want to do for a living and I said I want to be a chi Andale and he looked me looked me straight in the eye with a straight face

193and he said I think vocational education is your path so I've worked with my hands my entire life because of vocational education and I've never ever been a day without a job so I applaud you guys for just keep pushing that vocational education we are have a huge shortage on people that can work with their hands the other reason I'm here tonight is you all own some property in DeBerry and I think if uh some of you have attended the the DeBry city council meeting you know that um we left a lot out there on the table we all said things that we probably regret or at least I hope we regret I want to tell you that that property we all at the city to Barry want to make that work we all at

194the city to Barry want another school we will bend over backwards to make it happen we currently have an A+ school when I go around and speak about the city to Barry I it's one of the first things I talk about is our A+ school look I don't have any kids and if you know me just a little bit you'd understand that it's a good thing that I never had Offspring but at the city de Barry we have about 23,000 residents and I realize quickly that I do represent children we have quite a few in the city of DeBry and I want to see them go to a school in the city of DeBry as well we are not anti- kids we are not anti- school you own a piece of property let's make it

195work we are willing to make it work I'm here with an olive branch tonight which is stepping out a character for me I want to see this happen I need communication and I need need transparency you can't have a negotiation without those two things we need those some of you have reached out to me and it is a breath of fresh air let's keep the momentum up let's make this happen don't be so Hasty to get rid of that piece of land down there and I will leave you with one question if you couldn't build on that piece of land why has somebody come to you offering to buy it thank you thank you Miss Christine serier followed by Elizabeth Albert welcome of somebody yes you're reading on behalf of Laurel Robinson thank you in

196the interest of public transparency I am reading an email sent to the school board on January 27th 2025 on behalf of Sheila zinerman Jane bresin and Laurel Robinson co-founders of citizens for truth and Justice and education Luchia County Madam chair school board members citizens for truth and jce Justice and education is writing to you all once again to stress the importance of amendments to policy number 320 we have previously submitted what we sincerely believe are non-judgmental improvements to the existing policy for your consideration however the purpose of this communication is to stress a fundamental Omission from the existing and revised policy as a whole the document is one-sided policy 320 needs to be fair we recognize that a procedure must exist to challenge what may be an inappropriate reading material in our schools please note

197that your existing procedure has already done that successfully and swiftly in the past however just as important to the community as getting an inappropriate book removed is the ability of the community to ensure that a book vetted and approved by School District professionals gets a fair hearing to remain on the Shelf ensuring this fundamental fairness to your policy does not require any additional rewrites it is really quite straightforward you you can include appeal a decision to either remove or retain or advocating for the removal or by those opposing the removal wherever it may be appropriate these simple easy to understand words correct the lopsided guarantee of the community rights to only one position this fairness Clause will disadvantage no one but this fairness Clause will go a long way to enshrine the blushia County school

198system as one that understands what liberty and justice for all really means thank you for taking the time to consider this matter thank you and since I have a minute I did send an email if somebody could read that I sent it last week it' be great thanks this is Elizabeth Albert good evening Madam chair members of the board superintendent Dr balabin um comments this evening have been about the the truth about testing and I want to recognize the few Brave individuals who came here tonight taking time out of their personal lives to come and speak with you because they're speaking on behalf of hundreds or perhaps thousands of classroom teachers across this District who are extremely frustrated with the ongoing issue of over testing our students um you know we work to when we

199work together to solve problems that's the best work that we do and so the discussion tonight uh that focused on all the assessments that are needed for a student to obtain their high school diploma you know that's very interesting and of course we want every student to have a high school diploma we recognize the advantage that that gives an individual but I would suggest to you that there is a very big difference between earning a grade and authentic genuine learning and so uh you know I'm surprised to hear the statement that said that all of the work has been taken out of the process to get kids prepared for the test you know alluding to the fact that it is a cookie cutter uh assembly line kind of process to get the kids across the

200line I don't think that's what you meant but maybe we have to work on how that's communicated perhaps um again my question is are the children really authentic and genuinely learning so where are we are we too focused on running the system um and have we stopped to consider the needs of those who are actually doing the work to teach the students and the students themselves you know if this is the new way that we're going to do our work in Belia County Schools then some something else has to give um you know please remember that every time a student is absent from a classroom because they are testing as explained earlier that's one less class period or one less day that they have access to the highquality curriculum and content that our teachers are

201there to teach and do we want to produce test takers or do we want to produce competent creative problem solvers we're going going to go out into our communities and interact with us in the future and Mrs Haynes I want to appre I want to thank you for mentioning the service for Mr cuber uh that was heartfelt I know several of you were there uh along with past board members but this is what I want to say respective to Mr C cber Mr cubert was a true transformational leader someone who cared about each and every one of the students on the campus and every one of the employees and there was was a a resonating reoccurring theme at the service that talked about how you could go into his office crying and you came out

202with a solution um he was a man of great integrity and character and of the highest caliber and I would wonder in this moment in time if someone had come to Mr cuir and said I got students testing all day long they missed 81 class periods they still got to take this end ofourse exam I wonder what his response would be thank you I have one more card that just came in Miss Kim short welcome good evening I um I just wanted to bring to everybody's attention something that they may not be aware of in regards to properties that we own and I and I may have missed it but I haven't seen in quite some time any kind of a workshop on on all the properties that we own and one of the things

203that's concerning me is that we selling property or we're talking about buying property and as far as I know uh since 2020 when Sarah Lee Mory retired we have not had a comprehensive look at the entire County uh in regards to Building Development plans what's going on with you know student capacity and and seats in our schools and and with uh the choice environment that we have going on and every bit of change that is happening in our state I just feel like that's something that we need to go through and we need to address when I was on the hson oversight committee we were we were blessed to have had a presentation from Glenn Storch who for those of you who don't know who he is he's a real estate attorney here in the

204area and I will say it was probably one of the best presentations I've ever seen I would I would tell the board that that's somebody that I would ask that you have at that at that presentation um the other person that's known in the area is um Chris bua he is a commercial real estate um he's with a commercial real estate firm um sper vaness who you may know him also in this area but both of those individuals can give you a good look at what's going on I I I just I none of this makes any sense from somebody from um uh construction and and demolition background uh that we're doing we're doing things in regards to property Without Really knowing what's going on with our kids you know we have Micro schools popping

205up everywhere I know I just spoke to a charter school principal the other day I know that they seemed like they're leveling out and their numbers are even going down what's going on with you know where we promised the school to Enterprise and they're not getting it but we're doing it in DeBerry I mean is that the right place I don't even know I I don't know how any of you guys really know because our county is not you know one city at a time and kids don't necessarily have to be in the City to go to that school that's what school buses are for it's just seems very irresponsible that we haven't had that kind of a report for those of you who don't know what I'm talking about sahene morrisy was our director

206of planning she is to this to my knowledge the only one who's ever won a national award for it she's she did great presentations she would tell everybody by school you know area zone what was going on we knew how many kids were in the classes I mean these are so important this is so important and I haven't seen this in years and I also haven't seen any of you have a conversation about it or ask for it which is really disappointing thank you okay we are moving along we are now up to item 17.01 items from board members superintendent or Schoolboard attorney for discussion or announcement Mrs brosmer a couple of things um I'm going to kind of me to on two things that have been brought up tonight uh and since the meeting

207is a little shorter than we had originally anticipated I'm going to take a point of personal privilege um uh to explain my approach to to one of one of the issues um my I come from an army family well I'm have an army family my husband served and and my son retired after 20 years and he retired as a as a non-commissioned officer an NCO uh he had opportunities to be commissioned but he never wanted to do that because it's the commissioned the the um ncos are the ones who do the work he wanted to be on the ground doing the work and the commissioned officers very often get into they're The Political Animals they kind of have to navigate the politics of of their work and they rely on the ncos for information um

208there are two ways to become commissioned um you either uh graduate from an academy and go straight into leadership or you can advance through the ranks and go from being n a non-com to commissioned and what he noticed was that um those who graduated from theem went straight into leadership relied even more on the noncoms um and then there were the ones who had come up through the ranks and became commissioned and just kind of stopped listening to the noncoms and somewhere along the line I realized that I I kind of put myself in that setting and realized that I'm like the commissioned officers who never served because was never a teacher I was one of the ones who graduated from the academy and went straight into leadership which is the political realm of of

209leadership and um and didn't have that non-com experience in my mind the noncoms are the teachers they're the ones on the ground doing the work and and so I have found myself especially over this last year and a half when I've been immersed in these issues needing to listen to what they say and I learn a lot from public comment the two issues that were brought to me the most often over the last year and a half were over testing and classroom conduct and and when I hear that repeatedly from all over the county from a multitude of teachers who are just desperate for a solution and especially when they're willing to come here and and in public comment say please do something I really think we need to and I don't know what that

210process would be internally that's that's um not my area of expertise but I would like to encourage us to listen to what they they're telling us and and react to it respond to it uh do something that addresses these issues and don't just tell them that this is how it is and and they need to adjust to it and they need to do a better job um I I really think that that this is something that deserves our attention so that's one the other one um is um related to what Mrs short just brought up um she's approaching uh the issue of land ownership property ownership from one standpoint I I come from a background of of um a lot of uh land use and zoning and comprehensive plan uh related projects and a lot

211of concurrency issues and so I approach it from a school concurrency uh point of view and and I feel the same need to have a District overview before we sell off properties I I've noticed on on other agendas we we have uh sold off properties I haven't noticed the sizes but they never jumped out at me as being huge pieces but um and and I know that there's a reason to um get rid of properties we don't expect to use but it would be really help if we could have um a district by District overview of what the land uses are what the development patterns are what's been approved what hasn't what those timelines are and where we own property before we make any decisions about what to get rid of so I just want

212to me too on on that subject as well from a slightly different perspective but I think I think it's necessary for all of us uh to have kind of an update because development approvals go along without necessarily coming before us we don't know what the cities in our district are necessarily um approving and and what their impacts might be so um I I would request that that we might uh do a workshop that offers that information to us anything else oh no I should have told you that no thank you done Mrs Goodrich all right so um at the last meeting I had asked to receive a list of properties which I was given and I've been reviewing them and looking through what we do have um what we're continuing to look at using and

213what's considered a surplus and so kind of in line with what we've heard I guess I'd like to see some kind of um presentation about what our plan is to dispose of our source plus properties how we ended up with Surplus properties what is the process when we sell our capitalized assets what does that look like um when we're looking at selling a property like Buckley Road have we done appraisals on the property I know this was unsolicited so probably not in this case but when we're typically selling properties do we have an appraisal done do we look at if it's Wetlands a flood on a flood plane what all do we look at what are the entitlements what's the highest and best use and why in a situation like this would it be um

214prevented from being a school and I think there are reasons but I think we need better clarification of what those reasons are and how we're handling these assets so that's actually some questions I had too and then also um in the consent agenda we had um audited financial statements that had numer numerous recommendations and I would just also like to know in the future and this is not quite as pressing but it is pressing still how are these recommendations being communicated to the school and what is the process we're using to follow up on these Audits and seeing if the recommendations are working going forward um I also continue to be contacted frequently by um teachers parents talking about specifically teachers and admin actually not as much parents But continuing to talk about um how

215difficult it is when kids are arriving late to school or not coming to school at all and so I'm wondering is there are there other counties out there that have found something more effective I do know that's a national epidemic so it's not just Bia but if there's other counties or plac that have found ways to effectively get more kids to school maybe we could model that I don't know if there are but if we could start looking at that that would be fantastic so those are the things I wanted to bring up tonight and thank you all for your time okay this is good Rich if you don't mind may I ask that the things that you would like for us to have a presentation on or follow up on could you please put

216that in an email because we did struggle hearing what specifically you were saying yes I can put it in an email and I'll put all the specifics as if my people reference their background as many of you know I do have a bit of a background in real estate and so a lot of mine are very real estate specific questions um but yeah I'll send an email with all the questions I have thank you is there anything else you'd like to add and Noe that's it I'll put everything I said in an email so you can see it all all right thank you we appreciate that all right Mrs Thompson thank you so my comments are surrounding testing and uh it's something I hear about from my kids often because they're in second grade and

217fourth grade and I always ask them how the tests go and if anyone's met my daughter Charlie you know she's going to give you a very detailed analysis of whatever it is and so when we speak specifically on like the I ready tests and this just might be her perception of something it just might be the grade I'm not sure it does there are a lot of them but because there are a lot of them it doesn't matter as much because it doesn't seem as big whereas the PMs and the bbas you know they have it seems like a bigger deal so in her mind she will take it more seriously so my question is because I know we've say seen the schedules before if we could get another copy of like the schedules because

218we do have two new board members just to see like the tests that are taken um I think that would be beneficial for that but also the dates for the PMs and the VB because they were they did I and I Know It's Tricky with the different breaks but it was kind of crazy to come right back from winter vacation and they had a test like right there um I know a lot of uh parents had complained about it but I know some kids did as well and then the VB I've gone to this state repeatedly I don't like the PM testing model I I've told them that repeatedly I I know why they do it the way they do I'm not a fan of having the three tests however and we can't control that

219however the VB we can control and I know we have a group of teachers that contribute to that and I I love that because they're the ones that are teaching they're the ones that are administering these tests but I would be interested if because I know why we need the data and I love data but if there would be any way to shorten the amount of time so that we're not cutting into that classroom time so much because you know there are times where these tests do take a couple days to do and we are missing out on that time in the classroom and I'll give a plug for recess we're missing out on recess time because kids can't go on the playground so if there's any way to just kind of condense have all

220the same topics covered but just maybe less in the number of questions per topic so maybe instead of 90 minutes it's 60 minutes and that's it for me thank you Dr B yeah so actually I'm asking the team to come back because as you know we've done a few presentations with with testing and they have met with with several groups and they have made some revisions and there are some upcoming revisions that are coming but one of the ition to make here is that PM will assess the students on skills that they have learned and skills that they have not learned so that's what PM would do for you when it comes to the VBA it would clearly just assess students on skills that they have learned so that the VBA are being truly utilized

221as a method for informing instruction informing supports that needs to to be in place because once they take the pm3 that's it right I'm I'm I'm sorry FSA and the pm3 is is is the end so one of one of those some of those assessments that we would call summative assessments are consider almost like the autopsy right it's done it's over there's nothing you can do but the VB are used to like when you go to get a checkup you know from a doctor and you're going for a comprehensive checkup and it will tell you about Vital Signs and all that so that we can inform instruction we can make sure that remediations are in place that the appropriate resources that are allocated for that student those supplementary resources that it's working all part of

222that progress monitoring but I will ask the team to come back and do a presentation and share with you some of the feedback that we have obtained some adjustments that been made but some future adjustments for the upcoming year so um Mr cologne so the other thing I would encourage uh and I think would be great for all of us you know having sat here for many years and heard all of the testing presentations which some are better than others uh have been uh but until I sat down with Dr teron and actually saw the tests saw the dashboard learn learn from a principal how they use this data it really didn't come to life to me for me and so I I would encourage Dr B if we have the opportunity uh because at

223the end of the day you know one of the going back to what Miss Donna said one of the disadvantages that we have is that there's four of us here that are not Educators and so having the ability to see I mean until you know someone came and said that test is eight 18 pages but it was 10 questions 18 Pages because it was printed out on the computer it was just one after the other so when you printed it out it looked like this monster is of a test but it when we when I actually went through it and so I wanted to see different grades what what is it that the students are getting what is it and so once I was able to see it it made a little bit more sense

224to me um and also to see how they use the data you know and and I had asked one of my uh principles you know do we test too much now mind you this is uh a school that was uh probably underperforming uh and the students had probably a little bit more challenge whether it was socioeconomic or whatever the case may be and I asked her I said you know what if we took away this data we didn't do all these testing and she said then how would I know what the student needs how would I know to cater the science program which I don't know what it's called you know maybe they've mastered what did she say the art of science but not the N the natur nature of science and so what they

225do is and this was just eye opening to me she said I don't want that student working on physical science they got physical science I I could tell you right now physical science check they're in fact they've excelled in that so I need them to have this instead of that and so I when they get on the computer that's what they're working on that's in front of them so I I think that Dr B have given the opportunity I would love to sit down with the team again just to go through it understand the schedule what does it look like did we make improvements one of the challenges that was expressed the last time we were here and talked about testing was the timing of the test so I'd be curious to see you know

226have we moved it is it right before Thanksgiving right after they get back in January what what you know are these windows and so I think and then the other part of it is you know with the PM testing being new because it's only been a year we're also learning so you know maybe what we've done all along I can tell you what what we were doing before I got here wasn't working we heard that in the graduation rates and so yes it you you move people's cheese it moves people's cheese and nobody even good change is sometimes still change and I don't like change but understanding that and to hear the outcomes which is what our students rely on on what we want to see being able to see that being able to say

227show me the story of this kid here and and that teacher that principal in particular she pulled out and she said here this student did really really good on the pm1 so he did great better than everybody else almost and then pm2 for some reason he didn't do really good well what happened well she basically called the student in opened up the dashboard said how is it that you did really good over here when you didn't know the stuff and now and so they learned that they had an attendance problem and so she basically would drive and make sure that he was on his way to school I mean that that is how focused and intentional so if we could have that opportunity again Dr B I think that would be great because I can

228tell you as many presentations as we've been in until you can ask the question see the test see what they mean when they say they take a VBA what's a VBA I don't know we didn't take those when I was in school in Miami dat County probably why or at least I don't think we did and so being able to see it help me to sort of understand and don't get me wrong I think there's still opportunity and I know that uh M Dr teron and Julio they're making tweaks uh some of which I'm really really hopeful for and so um I I think that would be great another thing I wanted to ask and and it's something that you know we get really busy but budget season is coming and one of the things

229that we do as a board is we set our budget priorities what's important what's not and so I'd like to see if we could set up a workshop on uh what our budget priorities are for the upcoming year as Dr uh as Dr C and everyone is starting to work on that and the allocations uh so that each of us has the opportunity to uh share what's important to each of us and then hopefully corporately we could bring back what are our budget priorities for next year and so if that' be possible I'd appreciate that and that's all I have okay is there anyone else okay then I'm last I'll start with the testing piece and look they're lined up there staring at me so I am the one person on the board with an

230educational background I've taught everything in elementary with the exception of fourth grade and I've taught at the secondary level pre-algebra Algebra 1 A and B regular Algebra 1 and Algebra 2 and geometry I say this every time testing comes up so I think all of you know what I'm going to say Dr tron's looking at me because I don't think he really cares for what I have to say Okay so let's start with one simple thing that was said this evening by one of the teachers that as soon as they returned from winter break they immediately started by taking a test yet we had a window for the test for the entire month having taught all of those different GR levels because believe it or not high school students are just little people in bigger

231bodies and when you return from winter break there always is a transitional time to get them back onto a schedule because I will tell you most of them while they've been off for winter break there's been no schedule they've stayed up all night they've played games they've enjoyed themselves which is what every child should do they should have that opportunity but to bring them right back into the classroom I always found you not only had to bring them back in and calm them down and get them back on a schedule you had to review the rules you know the way we work together in a classroom but to bring them in and set them down and put a test in front of them and then we have to say well why did the scores dropped

232during pm2 well maybe we need to start with the scores dropped because we tested them the fir we started testing them the first week back they need a transitional time back in so I think that could be a simple fix I think that's something that we could honestly do for our teachers because even teachers need a transitional time as they come back in the door I'm being honest with you I mean they may have written plans before they left you know and laid it out but there's a transitional time for them to come back in get their students refocused on learning what needs to happen during the day how do we do this because they haven't been doing those procedures you know for the entire winter break and so that's an easy fix I've said

233this before test don't teach children and I say it all the time children are taught through well planned instruction by teachers and I would tell you the bulk of our teachers out there they know their craft they know how to teach and they know how to reach kids and they build relationships with children every day in their classroom you can't have an elementary school a child with you all day long and not build a relationship with them you can't have a student in middle or high school that you see every day you know for 45 to 50 minutes and not build a relationship with them and this is where I say there are teachers out there that their kids will be ready for the test to take if we give them the time to do

234the high quality instruction now I realize sometimes when they come in brand new I remember the year I started brand new I didn't know everything colleges and universities don't teach you everything that you need to know they teach you a lot about your content area but they don't necessarily teach you even how to build those relationships or how to run a classroom that is organized and scheduled and what do you do when things go wrong you have to learn that so that's why our mentoring program with Mentor teachers comes into place to help those newer teachers or someone that's struggling in an area but remember tests don't teach children teachers need time to instruct and then they can assess and I truly believe assessments do not have to take all day long I really would

235like to ask all of you by a show of hands how many of you set in an Elementary classroom a middle school classroom or a high school classroom and you sat in a chair all day long and you took a test where you couldn't talk to the teach teacher you couldn't talk to anyone near you you sat there all day and took a test That's not healthy it's really not a healthy thing for children so yes there are the state tests that we have to give and yes we collect data from the other tests that we give but could we look at can we collect that data in a way that it doesn't have to test children all day long and can we look at whenever they're returning from a time off that we allow

236a transitional piece for them to come back into the classroom and to get back into the order of how a classroom Works before we start assessing them I truly believe maybe if we had have started the second week after they had a week back in we would have maybe seen better scores but I also found this whenever I was giving any form of assessment to my students and it didn't matter what grade they were in I would sometimes tell them this is a pre-assessment that I'm giving you because we're moving into learning this and if you show me what you already know on this test I don't have to take time to teach that I can then focus on the things you don't know yet and when you do something like that your students buy

237into it they don't sit down there and Christmas tree it they actually will put effort into it because if they can show you they already know it they know that they're not going to have to sit and do hours of practice on it or homework so it's all about how you deliver that message to kids and that's part of what we need to do also as teachers I feel better we need to bring our kids into what we're doing why we're doing it and they need to be able to accept ownership and know that it's their opportunity to show us what they've learned because when we don't do that piece they Christmas tree the test or they don't put the effort into it and then you know what it was just a waste of time

238for everybody we don't get true data out of it and we them off from wanting to take another test so that's all I'm going to say about that piece tonight but I do want to go on to another piece for a moment based on some comments that have been made I was elected to serve on this board in November of 2018 by Spring of 2019 I sat right over there where Miss Thompson is sitting and sahene morisy sat there and she had done a presentation and even at that meeting I brought up the fact that there was only one school in DeBerry and when were they going to build another school in DeBerry and she said 'why are you asking that and I said because the city of debery just approved apartments and condos and

239they're on phase three I think at that time of Riviera Bella I live in DeBerry I've been there for 38 years so when I first moved there all the kids in DeBerry went to Enterprise Elementary along with all the kids in Deltona they all there were there were no schools in Deltona the only schools were ostein Elementary which is the third version ago Enterprise Elementary which which was at 1200 kids when I started teaching there and Orange City the old version which we're getting a new version this fall and I personally walked and got petitions signed to build an element the first and only School in DeBerry the elementary school it opened in 1996 3 years after the city of dear became a city in 1993 my students that I taught first at Enterprise They

240said why would you move to dead Berry that's what they called it the kids called it dead Berry because it started out as a retirement community just as the first area of Deltona started out as a retirement community but what I watched over the years is we built lots of schools in Deltona every year to two years we opened a new school in Deltona I actually know a young lady I think she's still working for valouch County Schools she went to four different elementary schools because she started an Enterprise and then she got rezoned when the next one open and she and when I finally caught up with her when she was in high school she said yeah I went to four different elementary schools you know Miss Haynes during my career in Deltona because

241that's what the growth was was happening there so we built one Elementary School the day we built that elementary school and opened it it didn't hold all the elementary kids into buing it held half so half of the kids were left at Enterprise the east side of 1792 stayed at Enterprise Elementary which by the way Enterprise is a little tiny blip on the map it's basically a couple roads and it's not a city or anything and then we put the kids on the west side of DeBry pretty much at DeBerry Elementary it didn't take long and guess what it became the largest Elementary School in fuchia County when that happened they went into Orange City Elementary and they built manate Cove and we shipped kids now East out of DeBerry and North out of DeBry

242still no plans for another school in DeBry it came time when people started talking about a high school in DeBerry I actually walked and got signatures for people to sign to build a high school in DeBerry there's no High School in DeBerry because when it went before the city council it was voted no so the high school's sitting in Orange City so we've now got half of the kids on one side going to Enterprise we've got kids on the North going to man it Cove we all the kids in DeBry originally went to Deltona Junior High which then turned into Deltona Middle but then we built River Springs Middle in Orange City not in DeBerry so here's where we're at DeBerry Elementary is the largest student capacity school right now in valouch County River Springs

243Middle is the largest capacity Middle School in Valia County University High depending on the day is either the largest high school or the second largest High School all of the kids from DeBerry other than the Thousand currently sitting at Deber Elementary have been and continue to be bust out of debery Elementary I mean out of Deber so when I asked Mrs morisy at that meeting she said I didn't know about those apartments they came back at I believe the next meeting and said oh some formula the apartments would only generate 8.1 children has anybody ever been to an apartment complex unless it's 55 plus in valuch County anywhere and seeing a bus pull up or parents coming out of there and only seeing eight children come out of that 8.1 yeah no so I did

244ask and I have asked repeatedly and as a mother and a teacher and a Community member in Deber this has been something that I've tackled over the years so I brought it up when I got on the board still at that time there was no land looked at or purchased and I kept asking when are we going to do something so yes the Enterprise rebuild is on The Five-Year Plan but what you need to understand is we can't rebuild on the piece of property that Enterprise is sitting on because Enterprise is the oldest school on this side of uchia County and the codes from back then are not what the codes are now today and what I can tell you after having taught it Enterprise all those years when it rains it floods the parent

245pickup Loop is nowhere on the property it's across the street and I did parent pickup years ago at Enterprise as a new teacher and I watched it and that's back when people had gun racks in their trucks and I watched a dad pull a gun on another dad one day because he pulled in front of him to pick their his children up there is no way to fix the issues we have with that property to build on that piece of property but what you also need to know is the bulk of the children sitting at Enterprise are all to bury kids because we've keep having to send more kids from DeBerry for every housing development that opens apartment that opens or condo that opens because there's we either send them to Enterprise or we bus

246them North to Orange city and that was part of why I asked when we were looking at Orange City that we do a rebuild of Orange City and we add seats to Orange city well while we were doing that guess what happened Orange City now has more developments and those developments have already taken the seats that are going to be at Orange City when it opens up in the fall the other issue we've had on the west side of the county is we built some schools in neighborhoods where we never thought about the traffic or how parents would get in and out of schools and we blocked streets and anybody that's ever been to manate Coen River Springs Middle knows that they've tried anything and everything and I do know that Ron young and them

247are working on a plan to try to pull it off the streets so this is what I did as a Schoolboard member I started asking other Schoolboard members across the state how many how do you guys handle parent pickup loops and bus Loops to keep them off the street because here's the other problem with that parents do start lining up at an elementary school at 12:30 I don't understand why you waste that gas and run your car and put the wear and tear on it we promise you we're going to give you your kid whether you're first in line or you're this 200th car in line but I started asking and so we did go and visit when um Dr Fritz was here we actually went and visited a K8 down in Orlando Mr clone

248and I went and then he took a whole another group but beyond that we found out that in PK County they were building schools in where subdivisions were and they were building them with parent pickup and bus Loops so that the traffic never backed up I made my first visit to P County to tour one of these schools being built in June on June 19th of 2023 we took we opened it up and took every board member that wanted to go and District staff back there on February 16th 2024 after they had already opened so we can now see the school in use but when I went on June 19th 2023 what I learned is they built a K8 school on 17 Acres right smack dab in the middle of a brand new subdivision going

249up with a mile and a half double lane parent pickup and drop off Loop and a Bus Loop that would stack 30 buses with five of them undercover it can be done it's a brilliant plan you know there were times said oh no we would need you know 40 acres or this or that that's not the case I've seen it in action some of the people here went in February and we toured the school we not only looked at how that worked we were looking at because the new safety bills had been passing we were looking at how they handled hardening of areas in classrooms in the event a shooter came on campus we saw how they had built that into the schools we were looking at the technology and the technology there was phenomenal

250you could have a deaf child in a classroom and across a screen lights would change colors so that they would know what was happening was it a fire drill what was happening and a message would come across the screen so they couldn't hear it they could read it I mean brilliant things at the school so fast forward we came back and to Bar Elementary we are spending a fortune busting the children out of there so we reached out to the city manager of DeBerry and we had a call with him and we asked we had researched what property was left into Berry this is what was left four pieces piece number one was on depending on which part of the road you're on Doyle durksen or debery Road that's the first piece we tried to

251get this is what was said to us by the city manager nope you can't have it we the city are buying it we said but don't you want to school yeah but we're buying that piece so we went for piece number two which is the spring Vista piece now you can't have that we've got it zoned a different way can't have it piece number three was really not an option because it's on the same road that DeBerry Elementary is built on and they're it's probably not a half a mile apart that road itself could not handle the traffic to put every kid in DeBerry going to the North End of DeBerry where did we need the school we needed it South that's why spring Vista which is on a street that has a community back

252behind it and a community North of it but not a community within the pieace would have worked the best but we were told no we were highly encouraged to go look at this piece of property called the Buckley property and we were told that's where we needed to build it and the other night I had to go to De Barry city council and we held a quasi judicial meeting there which meant we had a court reporter there and here's what every council member was delivered in advance of us going there from valua County Schools they all received this binder with all of the information in it we had all of the experts lined up because in the meantime we did our due diligence and what we learned is we couldn't build a school on the

253piece of property where they want us to build a school for a variety of reasons number one schools now have to be built as hurricane shelters we all know that and that school being built there does would the property does not lend itself that it would become a hurricane shelter and unfortunately we're required to have hurricane shelters as our schools so in addition to that we discovered part of it can't be built on because it needs to stay as Wetlands there were other things that were discovered so we received then on February hang on I've got here on February 27th 2024 actually we received it before that that's when it became before the board we received an unsolicited Pro proposal to build a new school in DeBerry by a company called building tomorrow schools and

254with that they brought the piece of land on spring Vista they had acquired the rights to purchase that land we brought it here we voted unanimously on it for the district to move forward what did we vote for we voted for the district to put it out for an RFP request for proposal we didn't vote and accept that proposal they had to go through the bid process just like everyone else does so it took some time to prepare what was needed in order for people to bid to build a school and it didn't come back to us with the approval of the district's staff after having gone through the entire request for proposal for us to vote on as an interterm agreement until October 8th of 2024 and we voted unanimously to approve the interterm

255agreement I will tell you I never thought that I'd be living in a city that I have the utmost love for that has more Parks than any other city I think in valou County we're known for the parks in DeBerry that once again would not vote to approve to build a school unless we build it where they want it and would not even allow us that evening to present expert testimony as to why the other piece would not work Violet Brown who is the head of the um Florida Department of Education facility section she and her entire team came down and they had reviewed both pieces of property she was there that night to give expert testimony and when asked this is what they said we're not here to talk about the buckly piece because

256that's where they want to force us to build and it could take 30 to 40 million extra dollars to even conceive could we do that and come to find out there was a traffic study done over three years ago more than three years ago the city approved it over three years ago because what they want to use the spring Vista site for is businesses and Industry and what was said at the end of the evening by the mayor areas well yes we approved that traffic study and that traffic study will have more traffic than what a school would have and by the way the plan we had the plans there for the school it's going to have a two and a half mile parent pickup drop off loop with Gates that close it can be

257opened as early as 12:30 because we're fencing the school itself for safety purposes so parents won't block the road and we tried to explain all that and show all of those things but what was said is well the reason why our traffic study that we approved is higher than your traffic study for school is because we're putting fast food restaurants there so it's just going to be constant traffic all day long that's why the traffic will be more so Mr cell I heard you our option at this point is if we can't build what meets the requirements by the state and what the FLD doot is telling us is the safest place for the kids to be and it meets the state legislation laws then I guess what we really are saying unless you know

258I don't know I don't even know because somebody said we build an overpass from one side of 1792 to the other and the kids can and but make it the size that'll fit a golf cart and then the parents can drive them over with a golf cart or kids can walk it was also said well just put drop your kid off at the be front of Gemini Springs and they can walk through Gemini Springs and find themselves eventually down to the piece of property to go to school so I had a friend who's a retired teacher 42 years taught for Val County take a backpack and put things in it a kid would carry and she and another person went down there and they walked from the beginning of Gemini Springs all the way to

259the Buckley property and this is what they found you walk past all the water and the Springs animal droppings there sometimes can be homeless people so do we really want our kids at 6:30 in the morning in elementary school walking through the Springs to get to the Buckley property like is that safe do we want our kids where cuz the kids we had a map there showing where the kids live that are going to go there here's a statement that was made more than once that night if we let them build the school there we lose control and they can bust the kids from Sanford to that school we don't bust across county lines I'm not saying that a teacher may live in Sanford or seol county that comes to teach for us and we

260appreciate them and they may bring their child with them which is absolutely allowable but we don't bus we have enough kids right now to fill that school without even all the continued building that is taking place right now in DeBerry and we're out of we're out of options so the options are we go to Deltona and buy property to build on and we'll bust them all or we go back into Orange City and find more property in Orange City but what I leave you with tonight is the largest Elementary the largest middle school and depending on the day the largest high school or second largest in valuch County are sitting in that area and we're already spending money every day to bust the kids out and if you don't realize this typically the state only

261funds between 40 and 50% of Transportation cost that's one of those unfunded pieces that we have to do every year that's about all the funding we get so I've done my due diligence and those children one final thing when we did the 2020 Census Data D land was only about 12,000 more people than DeBerry because that's the growth deberry's had Dand has six bu count County elementary schools two valuch County middle schools the largest or second largest valuch County High School 11 private schools and a charter school and we're even looking at property and we have some property in D land that we're going to need on the North End Because by the way both middle schools are on the south end and with the growth happening if you haven't been down 1792 or 15a

262the growth happening since Deon Springs got water which we're thankful they got water is out of control but I don't believe we'll go before the city of Dand and have any argument of building the schools that are needed because we've never had a problem yet with the city of Dand so that's where I stand on this and if you have any questions or you want to know about some of the history there's this lovely book that tells you the history of the schools in valouch county and when they were built and where they were built 38 years ago there wasn't a single School in Deltona how many elementary schools do you have in Deltona now how many middle schools and how many high schools there you go so thank you and at this time we

263are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.