CorpusRecord 1923

Volusia County School Board - The Volusia County School Regular Session 12⧸10⧸2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Volusia County School Board
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Volusia County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
37,326 words · about 208 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e don't start over good evening and Welcome to our B County school board for December 10th 2024 I'd like to call to order this meeting we will start with the Pledge of Allegiance followed by the national anthem The Pledge will be by DeBry Elementary and our Anthem will be played live by Gregory Dukes our band director at Mainland High School and that'll be followed by a Moment of silence and reflection hi I'm Miss lavarius from Deber Elementary and this is Miss Donald's thirdd grade class I Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God inivisible with liy and justice for [Music] all for [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] you may be [Applause] seated I'd like to welcome

002everyone here tonight thank you for being here I'd also like to welcome all of our board members to my far left I have Miss Donna brasmer District four beside her I have Mr Ruben cologne representing District 5 beside him is Dr Gilbert Evans our Schoolboard attorney to my far right I have Mrs Celeste Gilmore our agency clerk beside her is Miss Christa Goodrich from District Two and next to her is Miss Jamie Haynes our vice chair representing district one and to my immediate right I have Dr Carmen J balabin our superintendent and I am Miss Jesse Thompson your chair representing District 3 items for approval on this agenda 1.03 2.02 5.01 7.02 19.01.2016 V board vote is called on that item and time will be provided at the end of the meeting for public comment

003for items of general interest pertaining to public education of Lucha County before items from the board superintendent or attorney for discussion announcement or approval our district vision statement to create lifelong Learners prepared for an everchanging Global society and now I would love to hear from our board members Mr cologne greetings everyone and again thank you all for being here today it feels like an eternity since we were here and so I do have a few things uh that I grateful for I'll try not to hit them all and save some for everyone shout out to our fine arts department and all of our art teachers uh they participated in the Dand Art Festival I had the honor and pleasure of being there with my daughter who loves the Arts and so we had a great

004time thank you to our Fine Arts team who is hiding somewhere in here somewhere um for uh and also our our each of our our teachers I believe this was isolated to the west side I think all the schools were from the west side at the festival so that was wonderful um I want to give a shout out to Morrison's healthc care so uh for the last two years uh Morrison's who uh happens to be the uh folks who provide food service at the hospital that I work at um for two years they have provided a thanks giving meal uh which we've had at at high Banks Learning Center and you know what makes this really special is that the guys who are the cooks whenever we ask them and I explain to them what

005the situation is of many of our students at high Banks they are so stoked about preparing an amazing meal for those students so much so that at 10 o'clock at night I'm writing to the uh to the counselor there saying hey we didn't think about dessert I'll grab some cookies and when I got went to pick up the food the guys were like like hey we noticed you didn't order dessert we threw in three sheet cakes for you and so they absolutely just love on our kids and uh also had the um honor of having a former Deltona commissioner who happens to be here today Miss uh former commissioner Dana mol uh came and also helped to serve the meals and so um shout out to uh Morrison's and uh later on I'll be asking

006to see if we could recognize him because like I said these guys just absolutely loved uh serving our students uh for Thanksgiving almost done I promise and so as we're going into the holiday season of course the Arts are big in all of our schools and um we basically have events every single night that we could arguably be at but I had the honor of uh being at the orchestra concert for Delona middle school and what made that really special is they usually do it on Tuesday nights like tonight and so for the last two years I haven't been able to attend there uh because it's always on a Schoolboard night and so um the amazing work Miss senko is doing at Delona Middle with Orchestra is uh amazing also want to give a shout

007out to uh Jenny Stevens as well as sudath Moving and Storage in Orlando uh they donated what looked like dozens if not 100 chairs to Timber Crest Elementary uh for Teacher chairs and so I wanted to say thank you to them for that it's been a while since we've been here and I'll let Miss Haynes talk about the Children's Home and so that is it for me thank you thank you Vice chair Haynes thank you um so a few other things that have um happened since the last board meeting is we had the great teaching that took place at a lot of our campuses and I think quite a few of us did attend that I um was originally going to be able to participate in the morning and then I had another commitment so

008I was able to participate in the afternoon at manate Cove Elementary and it's just amazing that when you go and talk to students and you give them the ability to ask questions um the questions that they'll come up with to ask you about you know like well how did you get to that point in the job that you do and everything but also um I have to give a big shout out to Dand high school I know all of our high schools prepare wonderful Thanksgiving meals for our students but dantai always reaches out and asks me if I will come and serve and it's a delight and an honor to serve um Chris cloudman the mayor of Delan was there with me serving and um the fire chief was there also this year and when

009they come in the line you know what's so nice is every child in valicia county has the opportunity to eat breakfast and lunch for free they don't have to pay for it okay so when they come in the line that day we loaded their plates down with turkey and stuffing and mashed potatoes and gravy and some people call it yam some call it sweet potatoes but they were candied and they thought that was great and green beans and cinnamon rolls to the point point that when you've got high school kids that have to use two hands to carry all of this and when they would come up to the line I said you don't have to make a choice today you can have everything that we are serving and they're like we get all of

010it and I said yes and um they'll be doing the same thing for Christmas but that's happening at all of our schools and it's it's so nice to know that our kids have that opportunity to the food and they they don't go hungry and some of them I even encouraged them to try something they hadn't tried before I was like try the candied yams they've got cinnamon sugar on them they if you don't like them you can come back and tell me well nobody came back to say they didn't like them but um Miss Thompson and I also attended the all count chorus where and that was held at dantai this year where all of our students come together from middle school and high school and they perform and they have guest um conductors that

011come in and perform with them and that it was beautiful to hear the music and hear the kids perform but we also also did some visits right before we went on Thanksgiving break for our five teacher of the year finalist and so those five people have been named and if you don't look on social media our Communications Department did a great job of putting out who the five finalists were this year and it's so exciting when you get to walk into a teacher's room and they have no clue that they're one of the five finalists and just to see their students react and Dr balaman does a great job of asking the the students if they want to say something about their teacher and some of them what they say it comes from their heart

012and it's just amazing what they share with you about their teacher things that we would never know but it's from their Viewpoint and then we also right before um I have to give a shout out to sheriff chipwood he brought the Dare program back to Valia County and mcginness Elementary did The Graduate uation for our first fifth grade group with the Dare program and we were up there and when I taught fifth grade years ago um we had the Dare program and my students got to participate in it but you know some of what our kids are facing now is different because they have to talk to them about the vaping piece and you're thinking why are we having to talk to fifth graders about vaping but they did but they all graduated from the

013Dare program and there were a couple of them had written their own essays and they got to get up and read their essays about what they learned and why they will make better choices so that they then don't get into drugs and vaping and things like that and so I thank the sheriff for bringing that program back we also were out handing out attendance Awards and Stark Elementary here in Dand got one of the attendance Awards along with a check for getting the kids in school and that's what it's all about you know and I thank Mr mcalli and all of what his team is doing to push out to parents about how important it is that our students are in school and then since he left it um for me Florida United Methodist Children's

014Home has changed their name and they're now called residing hope but they're still in the same place that they've always been and they've always that side has always been a place in my heart because 38 years ago I started my career at Enterprise Elementary and I taught the children that lived at the children home I even taught some of the children who their parents were house parents there so I cannot say that I have never missed a year because there were a few years when my own two were very little that I missed a Christmas program but he and I along with a lot of other people we were there last night for the Christmas program at the um children's home because you realize they don't have anybody to be in the audience to clap

015and cheer for them so next year if you just want to have an opportunity to go and listen to kids that are excited about Christmas and they put on a Christmas play and they sing Christmas carols reach out to one of us because we go every year and it'll just fill your heart with happiness to be able to go there and you can be in the audience and clap and cheer for those kids and join in with them on the Christmas carols because there's nothing better because that's why we're here we're here to make a difference for kids and to be positive and so I will end with that thank you thank you and Miss goodr did you all right so I want to give a shout out to Campbell Middle School they put on

016an amazing fact Fair um and the drum line from Mainland was there as well as uh the band from Campbell and the dancers and they were just phenomenal if you have not attended a fact fair and you can go to the one at Campbell because it is amazing so great job to them I want to give a shout out to multiple principles um first silver SS for having great attendance and the principal there is doing an amazing job I got to be principal of a day at Horizon and she's doing an incredible job there uh t t principal I just saw her back there she actually just shared with us that they need 120 mentors for the kids at ter T so if anyone um is available to Mentor know people that are available to

017Mentor or has friends that will Mentor being a mentor will change these children's lives it doesn't take that much time to make that big of a difference so I beg you to please consider that um Atlantic high school but before the election they actually had um all the candidates come in and meet with their seniors and talk about um why we're running and I thought that was very exceptional that the students asked for that because some of them were going to be 18 and could vote so shout out to them as as well and then congrats to RJ Long Street Elementary um for placing third place in the ponts inlet Christmas parade so I'm pretty new so that's all I have for now but I want to wish everyone a very happy holiday um I'm

018excited to be here I'm excited to work with all of you if I haven't been to your school or Met You Yet please reach out to me I want to um take some time to get to meet everyone so thanks thank you and miss brosmer this already on okay uh I am also very new this is my first board meeting and I'm going to be short and sweet because all of my appointments with my with my schools are after the holidays I decided to give us all a break because I'm the one who's learning right now uh my shout out is to the staff here who spent I don't know six or eight hours with me yesterday bombarding me with bureaucratic acronyms uh that I am still trying to learn but I thought my focus

019initially should be on the district so I'm extremely honored to be here I'm very happy to be here uh Merry Christmas to everybody and I will have much more to report next time thank you and uh Vice chair hes you covered everything so beautifully there were a lot of events that happened we haven't all been here together in a long time and I just wanted to add one more thing to that we had the EMB riddle game for our teacher of the year and so thank you to all the teachers who were out there for Embry Riddle for putting that all together and for all their families and the community members that came out to support them because I know that that was it's a really cool event when you get all of those teachers

020of the Year together so thank you for everyone who came to that all right moving on to item 1.03 we will have approval of the minutes approval of the minutes of the November 12th 2024 Workshop work session and regular session and the November 19th 2024 organizational session and leasing Corporation session do we have a motion to approve the presented minutes approve approve I move to approve thank you Miss good rich and there thank you Mr cologne any discussion all right all those in favor say I I any opposed all right it passes item 2.01 agenda changes superintendent balabin are there any agenda changes before the agenda is presented to the board for approval Ma Madam chair I would like to pull item 19.02 which is the adoption of proposed amendments to policy 801 we've just

021received notification that there have been some new legislation that our board attorney will need to review and and um make those adjustments so this will come back at a later board meeting all right thank you all right so approval of the agenda do we have a motion to approve the presented agenda including the change to remove 19 .02 for a later date now moved thank you Miss brosmer I'll second thank you Vice chair is there any further discussion see none all those in favor please say I I any opposed it passes all right item 3.01 announcements by Dr Carmen J Balin our superintendent thank you madam chair board members those of you in the audience such a beautiful audience here today thank you all for being here and those of you listening at home actually

022I hate to disappoint you today of all days but I don't have a video for you today I'll make up at the next board meeting however as we talked about the teacher of the year finalist we have five finalists in our district representing 70 of the schools that that receive nominations and we will be having our banquet on January the 11th and I look forward to that celebration um board members accompany me to these School schools and these are our five fi finalists Katie Evans um representing Citrus Grove Elementary we have Melissa C from Creekside Middle we have Shila Sharma from Galaxy middle and we have Jeremy Davis from Spruce Creek High and Kelly shahal from tamoka elementary now as we visited these teachers one of the things that that you will see a theme

023that correlates it's really it's about truly their passion and their dedication and what makes them so exceptional in this field right and although we only have five finalists I think they are representative of every single one of our teachers in our classrooms and the dedication that they show to our students on a daily basis so I'd like to congratulate all all 70 but a special congratulations to the five finalists that will we will be celebrating on January the 11th also we as you all know we always say that Safety and Security of our students staff is always our number one priority and our Department of Education the way they conduct audits now is that they will call our district like 10 minutes prior and they will say I will be at this school and that's

024it 10 minutes prior because they want to really see that what they're observing for is enacted those variables are enacted on a daily basis so all of these schools this year have received visits and I'm going to share it with you where they ended up but all the schools that received a comprehensive um safety audit this year are Beats Side Elementary Blue Lake Elementary Camp Bill middle Champion Elementary Coronado Elementary Creekside Middle the land High Delona High Freedom Elementary George Marx Elementary Orman Beach Elementary Orman Beach mid Palm Terrace Elementary Pearson Elementary Pine Trail Elementary RJ Long Street um dit Taylor Middle High to R elementary Westside and here's the beautiful thing about this every single one of these schools that have received these audits that were announced only five to 10 minutes before all

025of them have received a perfect score [Applause] [Music] I want to share this with you that that Doe they were so very impressed that they asked for a t-shirt that has the VCS logo for them so they can go back and brag about our district but I really want to thank Captain Smith I want to thank the entire Safety and Security team our executive level team and all of our principles and staff members for all always always prioritizing the Safety and Security of staff and students thank you so very much because your effort we can see it's it's they're buzzing about it at the state level um our High School showcase we know that this a very high demand event and it's a celebration really it's a celebration of all of the great things that

026are happening in our schools and we're finding more and more middle schools also joining these showcases so if you would please mark your Calendars our families I mean we love to see our families there they're invited to join us de um Thursday December the 12th from yes this Thursday from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. and it will be at the valua County fairgrounds and you if you have never been to one it's an experience you need to be there because we will have our academies we have our instructors there we have our students our families and it's a grand show but most importantly our students really get to Showcase really what their learning is like for these differenty so I invite families to go and peruse and shop and this way you'll be able to obtain

027firsthand information so you can make the the best decision when it comes to your children andies to choose from and last but not least some important dates uh December 9th through the 15th it's considered Computer Science Education week uh December 23rd is our winter break that it begins on December 23rd and this is when all of our families gets to keep their children home okay that's our gift to you January 6 we will resume with a teacher Duty day and student holiday and then January the 7th is when classes normal classes will resume and Madam chair that's it for me today well thank you very much I look forward to that meeting with the two videos next time two videos yes all right on to our recognitions item 4.01 our inspiring leaders Academy and if

028I'm correct this will be presented by uh Miss Workman and Miss hope yes uh and during the workshop today if you haven't um watched a workshop yet which I know you can't wait to um pull that video to watch a workshop but we talked about all of these different leadership pipelines so this is an opportunity for us us to celebrate um this recognition which will be presented by Miss Brandy hog our coordinator for leadership development along with Miss Stephanie Workman our executive director and this is the aspiring leaders Academy good evening chairwoman Thompson school board members superintendent balabin and members of the audience thank you for the opportunity to recognize the latest graduates of our aspiring leaders Academy the aspiring leaders Academy is a year-long professional development program designed for instructional Personnel who are certified

029in Ed leadership and are looking to pursue an administrative position within the next two years the academy focuses on cultivating leadership skills to better to prepare our participants for school leadership roles while also building a strong pipeline for Future Leaders we we launched the aspiring leaders Academy with our inaugural cohort in January of 2022 since then the feedback has been overwhelmingly positive and the demand for enrollment continues to grow the data also reflects the program success and supporting effective succession planning within our district the ala has proudly enrolled 68 participants across cohorts 1 2 and three I'm thrilled to share that 20 9 of these individuals have already advanced into leadership roles such as administrative Deans assistant principles and even District leaders and I'm confident that the others are on their way as well their

030achievement highlights their dedication in the program's profound impact in shaping the next generation of exceptional leaders in our district I'm both excited and inspired by the future of VCS knowing that these Tal talented individuals will play a vital role in shaping our schools and our community it is my privilege to soon to announce to you the graduates of cohort 3 from the aspiring leaders Academy but before we begin with their names I'd also like to take a moment to support you can see there's many principles in the room this evening um that support these aspiring leaders on a regular basis so if we can just ask them to stand for a second to be recognized don't be sh [Applause] and I know I mentioned the importance of leadership development is a team and a collaborative

031effort and you can see by the principles attending this evening that that indeed is um a fact so thank you principles for being here um participants when I call your name please come forward to receive your certificate from Mr Cash and Mrs Workman and will shake the board memb hands and we're going to ask that you stand along the wall and we'll take a group photograph um once all the names have been called all right I'm proud to announce our first participant is Maria Baker a teacher from River Springs Middle School [Applause] Joseph Brennan teacher at Deltona High [Applause] School Heather Cahill teacher on assignment Pride Elementary Julie cardo administrative Dean new Samara Beach High School Jessica Davis administrative Dean Stark Elementary Dean Marie deiz administrative Dean Cypress Creek Elementary Rebecca Gable administrative Dean Sunrise

032element [Applause] Johnson administrative Dean Deltona High [Applause] School Zer placement specialist at Deltona Lakes Elementary Maguire teacher on assignment South Daytona Elementary although she is not able to be with us this evening I do want to recog Rec iiz Katie Mullins who is a placement specialist for the ESC Department Shana Palmore intervention teacher at RJ Long Street [Applause] Elementary Magda Torres cologne specialist teaching leading and [Applause] learning Heather Turner ad administrative Dean Sugarmill [Applause] Elementary and last but certainly not least Sharice Webb Moore school counselor at Terry T small [Applause] Elementary congratulations to our cohort our newest cohort of the aspiring leaders Academy [Applause] okay so taller in the back shorter in the she's the coordinator you lovely ladies you get in the FR okay everybody come on you got fill in on both sides

033come on in [Laughter] theer that [Laughter] okay all right everybody than [Applause] anything was not smos I haven't had the cheesecake yet that's in there and I heard that's that's I heard that's like a $4,000 cheesecake oh you heard all right our next item on the agenda is 5.01 our administrative appointments Dr Balman thank you madam chair board members I have one recommendation today and that recommendation would be no other than Miss Melissa FR Miss Melissa FR can you join us I like to share it a little bit with you regarding Miss FR Miss FR has obtained her bachelor's degree from the University of Central Florida a master's degree from the UN University of Central Florida certifications in the following areas at leadership Elementary Ed English speakers of other languages reading she has been with

034valua County Public School since 1999 where she started as a teacher at pathway Elementary and then she went on to becoming a teacher at Holly Hill Middle and then tamoka Elementary then went into becoming a Reading Coach at seab Brees high school went to teach at tamoka elementary after that Cypress Creek Elementary became a Reading Coach at Creekside Middle a teacher on assignment and then a teacher um an assistant principal at University High moved to curriculum assistant uh principal at Mainland High School and then the principal of Sweetwater Elementary did I miss anything Miss FR as you can tell she's well versed in valua County Public Schools um graduated uh from the class the preparation class of 2023 and we know how important leadership is and one of the most important appointment that a superintendent

035can make is placing the right principle at a school so at the same time I like to thank the committee that sat into your interview um all those members i' like to thank them for volunteering their time but with your um blessing here tonight this evening I'm recommending that Miss Melissa FR becomes the new principal of Mainland High School and if approved by this board her effective date will be January 15 2024 we let you take a break and then come back you've heard the superintendent's recommendation for Melissa FR to be the principal at Mainland Tha do we have a motion I'd like to motion to approve and I'd like to make a second thank you Miss goodr and vice chair is there any further discussion so if you look at her career it's so

036well-rounded and you know and we even had you over here on the West side of the county for just a little while um but what I want to what I know in my heart is mainland has your heart and I really couldn't think of a better person even though it's hard cuz like you're doing great things at Sweet waterer but high schools are unique places and they take people that have a passion and a love for high school students to be there and I truly believe that you have that passion and love for there so um I am very thankful because I know at this time of the year that's a tough decision to put your name in because you've already fallen in love with one group of kids um but I'm so thankful that

037you put your name in and you stepped out there to be able to look at becoming the principal of Mainland so thank you so I would just like to say that I this is so bittersweet because I love her at Sweet Water you've done an amazing job and actually um surprised as you look around all of these beautiful little Winter Wonderland snowflakes are from your kids at Sweet Water um so but I know that you love Mainland and you're perfect for Mainland you really really are we have to have someone in our high schools who loves our kids and understands them and that absolutely is you so thank you so much did you ah Mr cologne and so you know this is a great example of uh something they say at Mainland something about uh

038Never Dies so uh congratulations I think you're going to do great things and uh thank you for your willingness to take on you all right is there any further discussion I just want to say congratulations we're really excited and I've heard just amazing things about you so very excited welcome thank you all right all those in favor say I I I any opposed it passes unanimously thank you so much ladies and gentlemen of the school board chairwoman Jesse Tom Thompson Vice chair Jamie Haynes Miss Donna brosmer Mr Ruben cologne Miss Christa Goodrich and superintendent Dr Balaban thank you so much I stand here before you deeply honored and grateful for the opportunity to serve as the next principal at Mainland High School with great enthusiasm and a heartfelt sense of responsibility I embrace this new

039chapter in my career committed to placing the education safety and the future of our students at the very center of everything that we do to serve as principal at my Amma moer is a privilege beyond words mland high school has shaped me into the person that I am today and I am so inspired to give back to that Community who has given so much to me I love Mainland for many many reasons my parents graduated from Mainland myself my husband my daughters and I have two granddaughters at Mainland now so that's four generations I graduated 40 years ago this year from Mainland High School and I've been a part of mainland in some way some aspect throughout all of these years I coach there and just recently I've served as the curriculum assistant principal and

040the data assistant principal the teachers the staff The Faculty the students and the community they've become my school family and have been for years and I care very deeply about that Community I've always felt that I would return to high school because that's where I feel I'm most needed and where I can make the most meaningful impact for the young people at such a pivotal stage in their journey tonight is both a dream K Drew and a Bittersweet moment and turning point for me I want to express how much my time at Sweetwater Elementary has meant to me Sweetwater is truly a very special place a vibrant nurturing environment that's created by the students the faculty and the families there that promotes growth and just pure Excellence uh serving there as principal has been one

041of the greatest honors of my career and I will always cherish the relationships the memories and the lessons that I've learned and gained there uh Sweetwater is truly a love Bubble that's what we like to call it the love Bubble and it's left a beautiful imprint on my heart that I'll forever carry with me this transition was not an an easy decision the timing is not what I had envisioned and leaving SWAT Sweetwater is one of the hardest choices that I've had to make however I want to acknowledge and I'm very grateful for the great care that the district is taking and the thoughtfulness and the transition to with Sweet Water I'm very confident that sweet water will continue to thrive I no doubt and I know they will continue to soar higher and higher

042I want to thank the following leaders who have shaped me and encouraged me throughout the years my forever Mentor Anita McDonald Mr persus who was the very first person when I was a teacher to see leadership potential in me Mr John Cash who allowed me to dive into leadership thank you Brandy hog our leader of all leaders who takes us under our wing and she just guides us with her example Dr Julian Jones who gave me so many opportunities at University to grow as a leader Miss frzy for all of her guidance and Mr Huth who I still call Coach Huth from when I was at Mainland but Mr Tim Hoth I hope to be half the leader that you are and Dr castelli for all the opportunities at Mainland High School I am it's

043a very heart I have a very heartful thank you to my husband Eric for all of his support I came home and asked about this and he was completely encouraging I deal he deals with my passion he knows where my heart is my dedication doesn't complain about the long hours and actually he joins me he's very involved my daughters Crystal Amanda Kindle Tatiana and Paige for all of their support and love and to my mom Doug Josie Amber and Annette for being my biggest fans lastly I want to express my utmost appreciation to Dr Balaban Dr VA Mr Cash Dr Drayton and the board for believing in me and entrusting me with this role and this responsibility I'm committed to exceeding your expectations and working tirelessly to drive our school forward to the staff and

044the students and the faculty at Mainland High School I am so eager to return home to serve you to lead you and to help shape the Bright Futures that lay ahead I am committed to embracing this RO with the same passion faith and dedication that have guided me throughout my career so thank you God bless and buck Pride Never Dies [Applause] Jesse you got to invite a [Laughter] for is that very nice to see you yes like the second one is that better okay Jesse SFL snowflakes [Laughter] forg did all right hello here I'm in the way is am [Laughter] [Applause] [Music] you of course you thank you m than you I love your shirt gold there [Applause] all right moving on to item 6.01 public participation cons concerning items on the consent agenda do

045we have any public comment cards on items specific to topics mentioned in the consent agenda no nope okay thank you all right item 7.01 removal of items from the consent agenda Dr Balman are there items requiring removal on the consent agenda Madam chair I have no changes thank you and board members are there any items on the consent agenda that you would like to remove for further discussion all right see none Board hearing no proposed changes to the consent agenda do we have a motion to approve motion to approve second thank you Mr cologne and Miss brosmer is there any further discussion all right hearing none all those in favor say I I I all those opposed it passes unanimously all right item 7.03 are there any board member comments on the adopted consent agenda

046no all right item 8.01 and we don't have any items that have been removed from consent so we won't do that all right 18 go to 18 all right so because it is still 5:19 that's a very long way or now 520 away from 6:00 pm we're going to continue moving on with the agenda and then when it comes to 6 o'cl we'll come back for public comment so moving forward to 18.01 we have our Florida school boards Association a presentation by our vice chair Miss Haynes thank you so what I want to share because we have two brand new board members is that we have a wonderful resource called the Florida School Board Association and it is a collective nonpartisan voice for all school board members so just as students come to school each

047day to learn and teachers have to go through professional learning as we saw tonight some of our leaders they go through all of our leaders go through professional learning in order to develop their craft and to become better at it we have the Florida Schoolboard Association which is available to each and every one of us and this past week a lot of you um got to experience the first um you know fads conference um since you've been elected and for those of us that have been members and so I just wanted to share some of the things tonight with you about that the Florida Schoolboard Association has actually been in existence since 1930 so soon it will be coming up on a hundred years of serving school boards in Valia County and so the mission

048though of the Florida School Board Association is no different than our own mission here in Valia County and that's to increase student achievement and so how do we do that as Schoolboard members we have to do that through our leadership and our advocacy for public education because what's the most important thing is ensuring that every child have access to a free public education and so some of the things that um as an association that we share um a mutual peace in and as I said it accepts every board member is it gives us representation it provides us with the professional learning it allows us to collaborate with Schoolboard members from districts that are like size surrounding us and even those that we can learn something from that may be smaller or larger it's very Innovative

049because it's all we're always looking forward to what can we do next and it's impactful and so who are they there are 65 districts currently in the Florida Schoolboard Association participating District as a full district there are over 340 school board members across the State of Florida that participate in fsba and then from those we have a board of directors and so we're very fortunate in valua County because each large to mediumsized District gets their own seat on the board of directors so we actually have our own seat on the board of directors then the smaller districts actually group together to select a board member from possibly three to five smaller districts to have a board member I want to say once again thank you to this board because I have the opportunity to sit

050on the board of directors for fsba and represent Valia County so that in all decisions that the board of directors are making we have a voice at that table and I want to thank Mr cologne this year for stepping up to be my alternate in the event something happens and I can't be present at a meeting he stepped in to move on so here are all of the counties across the state of Florida that are involved in fsba and this is what makes up the board so if you see counties ranging with Miami Dade being the largest down to valua we are the ones that have a single seat on that board of directors when you go from Cy's representing seats 14 to 27 that is how they have paired them and they rotate who

051so for this year if there's someone on the board of directors from Flagler then next year it may be someone from St John's and then putam because they take turns representing on the board of directors also what's really wonderful about this organization is there's a group of executive officers these ladies and gentlemen here that are executive officers they are current school board members serving in their counties and if you look back through the past history we've been fortunate in Valia County that we have had had before some of our own school board members that have served on the executive officer board Mrs Ider Wright served as a vice president Miss Candace lenford served as a president at one time when she was serving here but this is our current Florida Schoolboard Association executive officers and

052which county they represent they are actually elected by the general membership to serve in these positions and this year we are so fortunate because president Tim Bryant from from Okaloosa has a heart for kids and he does a great job of leading this group also we have an fsba staff these are the ladies that actually do the day-to-day work for the Florida School Board Association they are the ones that prepare all of the training prepare the weekly meetings the monthly check-ins put our conferences together but what I can honestly tell you is there's never a Time that I haven't picked up my phone and made a call and someone there always answers and they always answer whatever questions we might have or they send us out information we may need so this is our fsba

053staff and the positions that they are in this is also our committee group now the standing committees are also made up of current seated school board members from across the state and so you can actually join more than one committee if you so choose I currently sit on the finance committee the leadership committee and the policy committee I know miss brosme you have joined the advocacy committee I know Mr cologne has set on several different committees and this is the best way to get involved because when these are the people that are chairing it and vice chairing it and you do that for one year but when you participate in a committee you bring your voice to what that committee is talking about and it will then help build the platform that we when we

054go to meet with our legislators to be able to share with them the things that we see as important and ask them to make those priorities for Education not only here in Valia County but in other districts this is one group if you this is some of the others we have a long range planning committee that we've now put into place we have an equity committee also next and then the nominating committee I know at um last week's meeting during the um General membership we selected people to sit on this year's nominating committee and if you ever get the chance to sit on the nominating committee it's a wonderful experience because each year when people are applying that they'd like to be the Pres or the vice president or the secret AR or the treasurer

055and you sit on the nominating committee you get to read their resumés and you get to be part of the interviews and decide who is going to be on the executive slate of officers that is put up we've added some additional ad hoc committees those are fairly new but they're because of legislation that came out like the school and safety the you know the AI piece that's happening in in it and also the know and grow and so these are some of the conference and events that they offer to us so that we can earn points and also be up to dat on what the expectations are for us so I in October was at the board of directors and leadership development but that they also had the chairs and vice chairs there for all

056of the Committees you just most recently were um we had the new school board member training and the annual joint conference because our annual joint conference is also with our superintendent because the idea is that we work together as a team we have coming up um which all of us have the opportunity to be able to attend um the trainings in Tallahassee and do the days in legislation and what's so nice is they hand us like here's the platform you know here's the things you can advocate for we can add something on there that's like specific to valua County but what they've already done is they've collectively across the state looked at what do we need to do next in the field of education and when we go up there and say 300 of us

057show up at one time from across the state as school board members I will tell you they listen because we are a large group of people and we can move mountains at that time but along with that we'll have our annual summer conference now I will tell you that's always a little tricky we finished graduations and we head straight over to the annual summer conference and we're all kind of like okay take a deep breath we've just lived through how many days of graduations but we can get through this and so they also have a whole leadership development so just as we learned earlier today during the workshop about the leadership development plan that Brandy hog is doing with all of our aspiring leaders the people that we want to move into being assistant principles

058and principles what's nice is fsba has a leadership development I remember that it didn't take me very long to earn my emerging leader um piece but my real goal was to get that certified board member training and that takes 96 hours of attending the Workshops the trainings the monthly meetings things like that but it's not just attending it you got to do the homework and so I will tell you there's nothing better though than when you earn and you become a certified board member I was fortunate when I got on the board that Mrs Ida Wright was already here and she had her certified board member and Mrs cuthber had her certified board member and they took me under their wing and they're like you can do this Jamie and so I've held my certified

059board member training now for quite a while but it's just nice to know that you have it and once you have it then each year you just have to earn 15 credit hours to keep that certified board member training and it's not hard to do it and what I think it shows our community is that we're invested in learning and continuing to stay up on anything new that's coming out from the legislation so that we can best do our job Master board is something that we were finally able to achieve here in Valia County and it took quite a lot to do it and then um Mrs cuthber stepped down and left us and so we had to go back through and to because Miss Thompson had joined us and so we have held our

060Master board training now I think for four years but we're at a point right now since we have two new board members we have to redo this in order to earn back our Master board training so I would like all of you to look like go to the fsba website and look and have an understanding of what masterboard training is because it does take a commitment because we all have to work together to earn that but I'm hoping that you'll each look at it because I'd love for us to have the opportunity to earn that back because that says that we collectively together have taken the time to go through that training and learn how to work with each other so that we can best put the needs of our students first and then they

061also offer as I said customized board support and they offer a peer-to-peer program so that if you know you want to pair up and I will tell you that what happened during my first four years um I actually paired up with about 20 different school board members and to this day we support each other and there's only one from so there's 19 other counties that I know I can reach out to any one of those board members and say do you have a policy about this or you know what are you doing about that and we're able to unlike us we can't talk to each other except for in this room about things that we could possibly vote on I can talk to those board members from 19 other counties and they can share with

062me and so one of the things though that I would just want to make sure everybody is aware of we're at the end of the year and it's time to do your ethics training um for those of you that are listening in the audience or at home we're required each year as an elected officials to um take ethics training and what's nice is fad and fsba and fadss is the superintendent group they work together and they actually put together an Ethics training for us that everything is about the rules and laws that we have to follow and so because sometimes it's different for a County Council or a city council their rules are different than what ours are and so I went ahead and finished mine before Thanksgiving and I printed off my certificate and

063I gave Karen a copy so she has it in my file because when we go to file our form six real soon we have to check on there that we have completed our ethics training it takes about four hours to do but you can do it virtually and it's easy and they cover the topics that at times have gotten Schoolboard members sometimes in trouble because last year there was an hour long of the 4-Hour training was on social media you know and the dos and don'ts of social media and what happens and so I would encourage you to look at that and so the advocacy goals and like I said Miss brosme thank you so much for stepping up to serve on the advocacy committee because I think you attended the first meeting while you

064were there it's a lot and in that you will find a lot of what they're already looking at you know last year had a lot of deregulation pieces to some of the bills and they changed the base student allocation and the way the funding was done and all that but these are some of the these are our four legislative platforms that are priorities for us as members of fsba for this year and so I will just say to you membership really matters and the next couple slides um if you'll just slowly go through the next two slides these are the values that we gain from being members so I would like to just encourage those of you that have joined us to consider joining and being a part of this so take a moment at

065all the things they offer to us and then um if you'll move on this part I need to talk about for just a moment years ago the Florida School Board Association was part of the national Schoolboard Association but as I said about that board of directors the National School Board Association found themselves in some difficult situations Miss Cuthbert and Mrs Wright were on the board at that time and Miss Cuthbert and I were at the board of directors meeting and I will tell you politics doesn't matter when it comes to the board of directors we all come together about what is best and what's Best in our districts in Florida and what do we need and we are one of the founding members of Cosa because there were 16 states that started it we stepped

066away from the national Schoolboard Association and we are part of a founding member of the cosba organization and it has grown and I believe it has 27 States now as part of it that's what Mr cologne referenced earlier about the training that we went to and we learned what Tennessee was doing to be able to get their pair professionals and office Specialists into teaching positions and so we are a proud founding member of cosba and cosba we have people that serve on cosba and on the Committees for Cosa because we brought back the the National Organization that we helped found to what our real mission is which is to make sure our students are prepared to be productive citizens and so the other thing that has been added and Celeste is in here with us

067um and if you go to the next slide and Karen would be happy to answer any questions you have about this FS ba added a new part for all of our support staff and so all of our support staff now get training through Florida Schoolboard Association where they have the opportunity to meet with and talk to and develop relationships with secretaries and administrative assistants and agency clerks from across the state that are also working with Schoolboard members and they have also developed for them now where they can become certified and they will have their certification to work with Schoolboard members and I just remember when Karen started um participating and she pulled Celeste in she's like it's amazing the topics that they cover and she said I can reach out now and talk to somebody

068and ask them you know what they're doing and that's what it's about it's about networking it's about building relationships and I think all of our principles that are sitting out here right now would tell you the same thing no one should have to do their job alone you know you build a relationship and you network with other people and it makes your job so much easier so I just wanted to take a little bit of time tonight to share with you some of the benefits of the Florida School Board Association and at the same time I wanted our public and our teachers administrators staff no matter what job role you do to understand that just as you have responsibility to learn and grow and develop in what you're doing we have responsibilities to learn and

069grow and develop in what we're doing and so I'm hoping that we can move forward um being active members in the Florida Schoolboard Association and I'd love to see us earn our Master board training back here in vucha County so that we can have that seal of approval and people know that we've taken the time to work together to have masterboard so thank you thank you Vice chair Haynes is there any discussion Miss brosmer I just have one question uh given the fact that there is another election in two years for the board majority how does the board certification work uh will we just be getting it when we're we have to do it again because of any changes so actually they typically do it over they they look at our schedule and they try

070to do it in two to three months at Max um and so they come and they start and do a full day what they allowed us to do when um Miss Thompson joined us is we H we did a modified version because we were only adding one board member but once you're adding two or more board members during an election then that's when you need to go back through the whole thing because it changes the whole makeup so we actually the first time that we earned it Mr cologne and I were here and we did the full training um to get it and then Miss Thompson got to do the modified version when she joined us and so I asked that same question and so it's when you bring on two or more new board

071members because it changes the the Dynamics and um most districts do it even you know when they turn it over because they just we learned a lot kind of like about each other too and and just how to work together in here which is what's important you know that we're working together and that we have we can all have something different that we have a passion about or something you know like you know I'm championing this or whatever but it's just also to collectively know what each one of us what we're coming for and what we want to see a difference in thank you you're welcome and Miss Goodrich yeah I just wanted to say that um I attended and as a new member it was um I felt an exceptional program it was really

072nice because we can't talk to each other so once you're here there's you can't call and say hey I've never dealt with this before what do I do so it was really nice just to have other boards out there that I could talk to and say how do you handle this and what do you do in these situations because otherwise we're on an island alone so I I think it's a really valuable resource and I appreciated the time there and the training that I received thank you very much is there any further discussion on this all right we're gonna take a let's see it's almost we're GNA take about a let's say a 15 minute break and then we'll be back in here for a public comment thank you e e e sh thank you

073for that recess and welcome back everyone at this time we'll be doing public participation I currently in front of me have 20 five cards we are going to go through all of these there's a variety of topics and I would like to ask the rest of my board if you all are all right with going through these all together now I am you very much thank you each speaker will have a total of three minutes to speak when their time is up they will be asked to stop speakers are not permitted to make personal attacks on Schoolboard members or the superintendent I will call the first name and then the second one so that you can be ready to come up after the person in front of you the first person to speak is Sheriff

074Michael Chitwood followed by lordis Leon welcome good evening Madam chair honorable board members it's an honor to be here tonight and the sole purpose I am here is to support Dr B uh 37 years in policing in May I'll be here 19 and I can tell you I cannot think of a better Synergy that I'm seeing between Valia County schools and and law enforcement or the enthusiasm when I walk in the schools you know I walk in for reading events I walk in for feeding in the cafeteria uh Girls on the Run and there is a palpable enthusiasm when you walk in to our schools from the ad Administration to the teachers to the students and the big reason of supporting Dr B is our mission all of our mission is the Safety and Security

075of our students our teachers our administrators and our school staff and I just want to tell you what we've done together in a collaborative partnership and that's where this Synergy comes from we have reduced School threats by over 78% since week five and six in school uh when we were averaging over 300 in that period we're down into the teens now uh all of our srds at the assistants of the school district are trained and certified in ADA compliance we added when we saw the studies of having an SRO in middle school we added seven SRO to continue in that reduction of incidence in Middle Schools uh fucious integration I mean we all worked hard to integrate our Security Systems and Technology so that we all can get a bigger view of of the way

076things are going and and um representative H Haynes was there to watch our first D graduation over 15 years at mcginness uh Elementary it was phenomenal to see those young kids get up and read their essays Dr B was there the administration was there to read their essays about what they uh meant to them of course the implementation of House Bill 1473 uh that was just an outstanding collaboration and the Auditors noted that they noted in there that Valia county is exceptional when it comes to Safety and Security and they wished other schools were following the model that we put in place and and Ruben you were responsible for that you know we changed the mancher way back when Dr B got in we put embedded our staff in there uh with Captain uh Todd

077Smith and his entire staff so that everybody's on the same page Gaggle you know last week through that Gaggle search we saved a young man who was potentially suicidal that is so important that we're all on the same page and instantaneously we're able to deliver uh those resources so I'm here to support the doctor in in uh in getting her contract renewed you know we all been doing things a long time everything's not perfect but when you find something that works I think it's imperative that we stick to that so God bless you all and Merry Christmas good luck to you Doctor thank you thank you all right next we have lordis Leon followed by Dana mol hello and thank you for um to all the vs VCS board and Dr boving and the whole

078staff for giving me the opportunity to express my gratitude and grateful I'm grateful for the board's effort to elevate Hispanic culture and bring awareness to the growing Hispanic population in our community I am particularly impressed by the implementation of the Lu dual language program which provide our children with valuable opportunities and advantages in the job market as an Hispanic myself I understand the importance of being a bilingual in the workforce uh in fact my brother who is a marine received a higher salary because of his bilingual skills I'm very proud to be part of this community with such innovative ideas including the CTC program this the vola County Schools have done have gone above and beyond to create Pathways for Workforce Development and to ensure that our children succeed even when difficulties are arise I

079know that the board and its members and business partners work hard to resolve them in the best way possible on behalf of our board and those who are involved in our chamber thank you for your dedication to the well-being our children who are the future of our society thank you next we have Miss Dana mcol followed by Linda Cuthbert thank you madam superintendent uh board members thank you I'm here this evening to address remarks made about students and with that equally as important teachers in my city of Deltona our Deltona teachers work long hard hours spend an inordinate amount of both financial and emotional currency to support and Mentor our students and are there for their Community day in and day out Madam chair you've revealed yourself not professionally fit to carry their lunch our

080students work hard to move up and beyond their sometimes restrictive limitations they work hard to goal set they work hard to goal achieve they are engaging they are bright they are resilient you're not professionally fit to represent these beautiful hardworking Souls I'm also in sense that you would refer to one of the the hardest working board members here as a tan man this man has been in our schools with his sleeves rolled up tirelessly working for our kids since well before you became a political novelty as a former commissioner and a forever Community servant in the beautiful City of Deltona I'm appalled by comments made by the forn now chair of this board as someone who is no stranger to controversy even I am appalled by your lack of professionalism and Common Sense sense if

081my organizational understanding is correct part of the chair's responsibility is to be the guide and the responsible voice of the board as a whole this board and superintendent have worked hard over the last four years that I've been in office to bring bring pragmatic solutions to educational needs and that includes a lot of visits to these schools to provide positive feedback and encouragement with one ego driven TI raade you have sent the message that they are instead stupid shame on you I worked for the last six years with some of the members of this board and I can't imagine that any of them would be as ignorant as racist and as elitist to talk to any child about any child this way your disrespect for my community and disregard for the emotional Ware of the

082impact of your words on my community's children speaks volumes as to why you are unfit to continue to serve as chair of this board I'm calling for you to go to each and every school in my city to apologize face to face to our teachers and our students I'm also calling for this board to remove you as chair and censor you for your actions for you being an admitted liar for your appalling comments about the children and teachers in my city and for your complete lack of professionalism and understanding of your post politics and ego do not belong in education if Professional Standards apply to our staff and students and they must follow the code of conduct why did these same principles not apply to this board member as a side note I would encourage

083you if you in your own words are un bothered by your actions I would strongly encourage you to seek professional help if this is not behavior of a true leader please reconsider your own mental and professional Fitness for this public office thank you next will be Miss Linda cuthber followed by Daisy Grimes good evening Madam chair school board members Madame superintendent and the superintendent staff I am a resident of new smyna District 3 which which is our chis District I am a 26-year veteran of teaching in the Lush County schools and an eight-year veteran of being on the school board my principal Mr Merrick is in the audience as a longtime colleague as my evaluator and as my co-worker in our community long time ago teaching English at new SM Beach High School I learned

084the importance of telling stories I knew that you could could not just be a kindergarten teacher to tell a story it is across all disciplines all all levels of of of ability it's done in every single kind of classroom whether it's science chemistry zoology calculus and especially I my whole entire career of almost 30 years of total teaching has been based on telling of Stories the telling of stories is crucial to education why because it engages students it hooks kids into the purpose of the lesson into the relevance of why they are learning the lesson before them we have to make sure that we establish a reason for teaching a lesson each and every day it is Paramount that our teachers know that because otherwise our children are not going to respond Stephen Spielberg also

085knew this when he H happened to read a letter that I taught in class that Abraham Lincoln wrote I believe in 1864 to a Mrs Bixby who at the time thought that she had lost five Sons during the Civil War Mr uh Spielberg director knew that too because he created an entire story a film based on that small short two or three paragraph letter and it's called Saving Private Ryan when I talk that letter because I used it as teaching of tone I showed them a clip this of this story with the pardon me with the permission from my principal at the time Dr Caroline Kelly to me because it was rated not G but it was only a clip that showed the purpose of why those men went all the way in to save

086Private Ryan they didn't save Private Ryan they saved the mother and the same way I taught beloved to my AP English Lang students I read a story from children's literature about the love of a mother for her children when we have an anticipatory set which is using a very old uh educational term we use it to engage to make relevance and to make permanence in their minds because stories tell the unexplainable thank you thank you Miss cber next up is Miss Daisy Grimes followed by Ida Wright good evening um you know my name it has been stated and I am the chief executive officer for the valua county African-American Leadership Council which is a council that comprises 71 African-American organizations in vuia county and governed by a board of nine members Madame chair and members

087of the valua county School Board permit me to take this opportunity to thank those seated board members who have served our district and welcome our two new board members this evening I thank you for your leadership these this past two years I can say these four years we have faced many challenges Co the misund understanding of CRT our teaching of black history which is American history low achieving Schools rezoning teacher shortage budget restraints and we cannot leave out book banding so much more but through it all because of your excellent leadership and board Direction you continued providing an exceptional educational opportunity to all students it has not always been easy but you were elected to be able to make hard decisions if necessary I will tell our new board members that the people in your

088District who elected you to provide guidance and set policy for this school district they expect professionalism Integrity respect and commitment to ensure that every child receives an excellent education and is prepared to be the challenges of a global world as I have always said in these meetings and I will repeat it tonight you are not elected to run the school district the superintendent is given that charge to run the district administratively you were elected to set policy I am pleased to say we continue to have an excellent working relationship with our superintendent and her administrative staff it is not always easy and we have had our differences in the process but our goal has always been how do we work together to provide the best educational opportunities for the students in this District we have

089done this and today I say to you live and work the vision that you have established and we will EST continue achieving excellent in education thank you thank you next up is Miss Ida Wright followed by verell Spar good evening Madam chair board members it is a pleasure to be here this evening I'm here in support and her contract meeting her doing a very difficult time when we initially closed for Co and I remember saying to Dr Fritz Dr Fritz I'm really concerned about you at that time who had became he ill and Dr bagin taken over because both of them were kind of new at their roles but she proved to be Trooper she and she TR and she proved to work really hard as the former chair of Luchia County schools and a

090former a vice president for Florida School Board Association I've went through a whole lot during my 10 year on the school board because of Co um learned a lot faced a lot but she is a true leader if nothing else during this time we need stability in our district we need stability in valua county and I think you have a person at the helm who could see us through any challenges we should face moving forward and take us to the next level looking at our record and looking at where we were over the last three years and then looking at our school grade this year we are very close to becoming a district again and I believe if you serve on the board if it is not your desire to see our students or this

091District become to become an a district then maybe you you should really reconsider why you're a board member you're not a board member for you you're a board member for your children our children when I ran for the board at that time I was the only School Board member to have a child in the school then Ruben joined me we both had children in the school district and we ran because of other children I had the means to be able to put my son in private school I had the means if my son need a tutor but I ran because I know there were many children who needed the expertise not of just the board but the teachers in this District to make sure that their children were successful to be a voice for those

092children who were struggling who needed some extra assistance that we provided those that assistance to our children so school board members being a former chair it is up to you to do what's right for our children not for yourselves this is not a platform for you to stand and grandstand it is about our children and as someone who graduated from Valia County Schools I take that very seriously and if you are not here for our children I will get rid of you personally because these are my children this is my home and if you are not here to support and do what's best for our children and make sure we have stability in valua County gota you I'mma refrain from saying that but you'll be seeing me more often thank you forell Spar followed by

093shamine Shepard good evening um my name is vanel Spar I am a music teacher at TR T Spar Elementary and I have been there this is my 26th year at that school this past year year we have um well this year we got rezoned um as a school district we did not do our due diligence in making sure that those students and those families were able to come into that school area into our new school before time because the school was not ready and still is not ready um in order for them to understand the TR way and how we handle things how we do things and now we are at a point where we're having high turnover of teachers this school year and I know that right now maybe what I'm saying is not

094popular I'm not here for popularity never have been never will be I'm here for the children of that Community have been always will be I go to the parents home I walk those streets to go see those children and check on them going into the new area so that's what our school board should have done to make sure happened in my opinion to go into the community because yes we did have meetings the families didn't come to find out what was going on it was our responsibility in my opinion to go into those communities into those neighborhoods put a tent bring some hot dogs something to let them know that we care we know this is a challenge but we're here for you and yet again in my opinion and I have to continue to

095say that because these are my words not anyone else's Belia county is continuing to not give the support that the students in that Community truly needs I have heard it over and over and over and over again and it's not true you're you are not giving us what we need we don't look like tamoka we don't look like Spruce Creek they don't need what our children need because they're already coming behind give us the support we need so our children can be successful because you want your child to be successful you want other children to be successful at those other schools we want our children at that school to be successful and you know what they come in it's hard but guess what they're sending us the best that they got as a parent we

096have to be there and give them what they need and we're not doing it right now thank you thank you next shamine Shepard followed by Cynthia Slater chair Thompson school board members and superintendent Balaban my name is shamine Shepard and I am the executive director of Futures Foundation the education uh foundation for the school district in 2025 Futures will be celebrating our 40th year and tonight I am here to highlight two of our programs and the relationship that we have established with fuchia County Schools the first event is principal for a day and Dr baban I will say I'm disappointed there are no videos IID planned on refer referencing those tonight but that's okay um thank you all for your great comments and always positive feedback for futures um for those that are not familiar

097with principal for a day um it involves uh business partners pairing with each of the schools within the school districts many of our schools have already established relationships in the community but a if a business needed to be partnered um with a community or business partner Futures and fucha County Schools work together to make those connections happen for the school on the day of the big event the business partner shows up at the school and the principal puts them to work a morning with the principal looks different at every school however what takes place is real it's organic and it provides insight into what a principal truly experiences each day as the morning wrapped up business partners and principles headed to the sandborn Center for a debrief and a luncheon during the debrief several of

098our business partners shared their experience from the morning and it was impressive to hear their stories and know that at all 70 schools in the district had a similar experience that morning while the day may seem like just a fun event it's more than that we know that schools cannot function on just State funding by shadowing a principle business partners find unique ways they connect with the school this may be purchasing t-shirts for staff providing a piece of equipment for CTE program or perhaps getting Sheldon from The Tortugas to do a visit at each School the second event I would like to briefly talk about is Teacher of the Year again thank you all for your kind comments um I know I may be a little bit partial but I really think that valua County

099does an amazing job in celebrating our teacher of the year nominees finalists and the winner each year there is a nominee from each school and these nominees exemplify passion and teaching and they deserve to be celebrated as mentioned the celebration is coming up next month and um there will be a banquet in January with over 900 folks attending the winner will be named the 2026 teacher of the year they are going to be eligible to enter the state teacher of the year competition and for the 17th year in a row Daytona Kia will provide a car for the winner to drive for a year truly could not do this event without the partnership of the district so thank you for letting me highlight these programs and we look forward to our partnership for years to

100come thank you thank you next is Cynthia Slater followed by Joe Hearn good evening Madam chair board members again my name is Cynthia Slater and I serve as president of the Daytona Beach NAACP I've served in this capacity for over 20 years the National Association for the advancement of colored people the naacp's education program aims to improve the educational experience of all students especially those of color by working to eliminate discrimination and create a world without racism by working to ensure that all students have access to high quality learning experiences by providing support to students to help them develop the skills and education they need by working to end the schoolto prism pipeline by offering training on student student debt forgiveness programs developing Future Leaders the naacp's youth program aims to develop the next generation

101of civil rights and Community leaders and the naacp's aim aims to educate people about the contributions of the African diaspora and other people of color to civilization throughout my over 20 years of service the NAACP has worked closely and in partnership with the Valia County school system and its super attendance including the late Margaret Smith the late James Russell Ronald Scott Fritz and our current superintendent Dr Carmen balabin throughout the 20 plus years that the NAACP worked with the district leadership we have worked together on several initiatives and like any partner we have not always agreed however we agreed to disagree because in the end it was the quality of education for all children that mattered I recognize those super superintendents that came before Dr balabin for their commitment to education because I believe that

102they all had the students best interest at heart but I must say that it is Dr Carmen balabin that really brought the relationship between the NAACP and the district uh to the to a point of an honest respected and effective partnership our monthly meetings are open and straightforward that address our concerns this has resulted in increased Partnerships with educations of Higher Learning as Bon cookman University and Embry Riddle expanding CTE programs in our middle and high schools within our area providing tutoring and mentoring services to students at our most challenging schools this provides them with academic and mental support one of our middle schools that is cell middle school has two students taking dual enrollment classes this has never been done before and all of the middle schools has at least one student taken a

103dual enrollment class I think we need to clap with that as the president of the Dona Beach NAACP I'm here to say thank you to Dr balaman and to your outstanding services and if I had one more minute I'd say some more stuff thank you thank you next is Mr Joe Hearn followed by Karen weinrick right good evening educators and community of valua Madame chair school board members and welcome uh board member brosmer and board member uh Goodridge um we're excited to have you my name is Joe Hearn I'm very active in the community and many different levels involved with many different chambers um I get to do all the fun stuff and like celebrate teachers and Schools of Excellence and do a lot of great things to uplift our Educators and I'm really passionate

104about investing in our youth um along with the many organizations I work with I also chair the children and family Advisory board for bluch County and involved in many other social organizations that really help get the message out about how important education is in our community I just want to take a time to say thank you to the Schoolboard members who have served welcome to the new ones but I've had the pleasure of working directly with Jamie and Ruben and um our new Madam chair and actually being present in the schools with our amazing superintendent Dr Babin um I have seen such a change in belusa County since the time that Dr belab Dr Babin arrived um I call her superwoman I see so much connectivity in our community that I've never seen before she's

105present and I think that's half the job being a leader on many boards and many organizations you know you can't please everybody you all will soon find that out that you're not going to make everybody happy but as an outsider looking in and active in my community I see when impact happens I see when change happens and I see the difference that's being made with leadership of the current board and also with our superintendent we're all grateful for that I think you can see just by our sherff NAACP all these organizations that over the years I've seen have conflict with our school system you can see how bridging that Gap working together to make a difference for why we're here it's so easy sometimes especially I would never want to be a politician so I

106I don't walk in your shoes but you know sometimes it's about investing local we have to stick stay away from the federal politics you know they're important but we have to remember we're it's about Valia County one of the greatest joys for me since the time Dr balabin Has Come Aboard serving with all of you board members is I'm all over Central Florida I lot in simal county and recently was at an event a couple events and to hear them say boy y'all are really rides over in in gucha County your school system is really stepping up I felt so good about that I me I was born and raised in Winter Park I've been in vucha county for 30 years it was just extremely impressive to hear that and that's a testament to the

107amazing Educators in our school system our amazing students and our amazing leadership and that includes all of you I do believe uplifting Educators is critical and stability consistency and Leadership for our students is going to be most thank you next up is Karen weinrick followed by Eric FR good evening I'm here to once again talk about my favorite subject testing we the parents teachers and students have been asking for years for Less testing we were in fact told that there was less testing this school year but I'm here to tell you that is not the case we've added the I ready quick check this quick check is not in fact quick nor is it just a check it is the exact same diagnostic we gave two years ago this diagnostic is important because it places

108them at their correct level for the I ready program we did the quick check last week and it took most of my students between four to six days to complete sometimes eating up as much as an hour of instructional time a day this test given three times a year is not listed on the testing calendar in the next eight days my fourth grade students will take three major County mandated t tomorrow they will take the science VST this is the most reasonable test they will take it is 15 questions and most my students will be able to complete it in an hour or less it tests the standards we have taught for the last nine weeks or so my students enjoy the test as they love science and they like the challenge of the science

109questions but then on Thursday they will take the ELA VBA test at our PLC last week we learned that this test has 10 more questions than it did last year because Rea needed at least three questions per standard to be valid what is the result my nine and 10-year-old students will take a 35 question test that's about the same amount as secondary bbas that prints out at 23 Pages you heard that correctly 23 pages I read the VBA administrative guide which says that the test for students without accommodations is 90 minutes however in an email we received it states that students that are not finished after the 90-minute session should be given an alternative location and provide it with the time needed to complete the assessment now let me ask you how many nine and

11010 year olds will be able to read multiple passages and answer 35 questions in just 90 minutes I'll tell you not many there's no place in our school to hold all the students who are not done after 90 minutes there will simply be too many and we have three grade levels testing at once this is not a 90minut test and to claim so is disingenuous at best a week from today my students will then take the math VBA this test prints out in only 16 pages but it's also 35 questions reading the administration guide it couldn't find a suggested time but it again says students should be given sufficient time to complete all items once again it will take a long time for students to complete this especially as we have taught them to take

111their time show their work and check their answers what are we doing can we please stop these tests are not for our children therefore the Rea Department analyze and predict how they will join the fast test which let me remind you is only two and a half instructional weeks away we give it the second week in January you want us our students test scores to improve give us back the VBA days and let us teach it's not too late it doesn't start till Thursday there's still time to cancel it thank you thank you next Mr Eric FR followed by Dr Dean hot good evening esteemed members of the school board and superintendent balabin I stand before you today with a heart full of gratitude pride and excitement it is an honor to speak on behalf

112of Futures Foundation as the president and the business Community as we express our deepest thanks for your unwavering commitment to providing students with meaningful opportunities to grow learn and Thrive first and foremost I would like to extend our sincere thanks for the incredible support that he have shown to Career and Technical education or CTE programs within our district these programs are making a remarkable difference in the lives of countless students opening doors to Hands-On learning experiences and equipping them with essential skills that will serve them for years to come whether it's learning to design and build exploring the intricacies of Health Sciences diving into the world of electrical and information technology or preparing the for careers in business and culinary arts CTE provides students with Pathways to success both in higher education and in the

113workforce through C through CTE programs students not only develop technical proficiency but also gain confidence leadership and a deep sense of purpose we have empowered them to see that their dreams are attainable and that success is built on hard work dedication and the practical application of knowledge as a manager for a local electrical contractor I can vouch for our company and our industry that we are immensely grateful for the investment passion and dedication that the school board is committed to making these programs and students successful I also want to thank you for your continued support for the Futures Foundation programs in 1985 Futures foundation for Val County Schools was established to increase the business Community involvement in public schools and to provide programs and activities beyond the financial capabilities of the school district futes Foundation

114has played a pivotal role in enhancing educational opport unities for both teachers and students through generous funding from our Community Partners Futures is able to facilitate student programs such as takest and children which offers students College tuition scholarships and tomorrow leaders which is a leadership training program designed for high school juniors our teacher programs such as teacher of the year teacher classroom minig grants and principal for day which is one of my favorites where a business and Community partner gets the opportunity to experience a day in the life of a local principle in morning followed by a luncheon I can assure you from firsthand experience that being a school principal makes our jobs look like recess time these initiatives whether they come in the form of Hands-On internships with CTE program a student leadership event

115or a scholarship are directly aligned with our mission to promote and Achieve educational Excellence no matter their background or future aspirations your support for futures Foundation is not just an investment in today's students but is a long-term investment in the workforce of tomorrow as we look ahead into the future we are excited about the opportunities that continue to unfold for our students because of your dedication with CTE programs in the Futures Foundation you're not only helping to shape the lives of individual students but you're also helping to shape the future of our community or thank you Mr fr thank you Dr bam for your support next Dr Deana hot followed by Brett brancher or bradner I'm so sorry good evening um I'm Danna hot I teach at new samna Beach Middle School um while I

116do understand our districts need to comply with the state law requiring the doors and gates to be locked at our schools I find myself wondering if there is not a way to address the law in a more efficient and safer manner as a teacher at nerna Beach Middle School I have a key to my building I have a key to my classroom and because I work such crazy hours I was earned given a key to the back door of the media center so that I could have access to a restroom before school or after school um when I arrived at school if there was ever a case where we would have and I hate to bring this up but it's the reason I'm here an active shooter if there was an active shooter to be

117on campus and I found myself outside of my building with students I could find myself traveling with students over 200 yards to find safety of an indoor building um there is no way we can be aord Ed a m is there no way we can be afforded a master key to our buildings or possibly have an access code system set up in place I strongly believe I'd be willing to give my life to protect any of my students or any students but this current system would leave faculty staff and students In Harm's Way We do not even have access to our main office without our office specialist leaving their work area to open the door for one of us um although someone from the District was there measuring for a more automated system for the

118back doors to the office in August nothing has changed um I have taught at this district and worked in this district for going on 34 years and I think that I could be trusted with a key I'm trusted with children and I would protect the children but I would need to get the children out of Harm's Way so please if there's some way that we could revisit this and possibly give it some different consideration it'd be greatly appreciated thank you for your time thank you uh Mr Brett brander followed by Elizabeth Albert good evening uh Dr balabin School Board returning school board members that for better a worst probably know me too well uh new school board members welcome uh good luck God bless it's going to be a ride um I'm here tonight to

119speak in behalf of Dr balabin and encourage the school board to rehire ex extend her cont contract um wherever we are at this stage I was Dr Pierce called me last week and asked me if I would come speak on behalf of CT and the relationship we have with our superintendent now I've been at the land high school for a lot of years and if you flash back to my interview day with Mr Moyer I will never forget one thing he said now my teaching career started at a unit district in Illinois the school district with 600 students one school board one superintendent we knew everybody I asked Mr Moyer what about the superintendent he said if our superintendent knows you you've done something really really bad I F I I think of that quite

120often because the way the relationship we have now that I believe Dr balabin knows me she knows me quite well she knows my program she knows our students I am a lifetime agriculture teacher um I go back to be I'm a vocational teacher I go back before CTE um I have never seen a superintendent of a district this size be this Hands-On with her staff with her teachers with her students and that is a very very rare thing in today's world she is supportive of CTE this board has been very supportive of CTE 30 years ago we were the hot item we fell from The Graces of of this country we see the repercussions of it today a a few years ago we started realizing there is a need for what we offer the skills

121we teach our ability to keep students in school kids come to school for our classes there are not very many that come for the cores but they love their electives they love their Career Tech Ed the Arts the music Dr balamin and this school board have always recognized that fact and have been as supportive as possible for this I will speak to you know on a personal level um several years ago a year ago now I interviewed for CT director or director job for lack of better words and I didn't get it I should not have gotten it I was at the meeting where we seated Dr Pierce and I remember Dr Balman at the end walking up and asking me if I was okay my words were If you hired me over her it

122was the biggest mistake of your career and I do believe that um I it's the but she cared enough and knew me well enough to take two minutes and make that simple statement I've not been turned down for very many jobs in my care career the few I have no one bothered to ask me if I was okay when it was over members of the school board I strongly encourage you to extend Dr balam's contract she's been an outstanding leader and very deserving thank you thank you next is Elizabeth Albert followed by Kelly H Haskins uh yes ma'am of Jamie Menard all right good evening Madam chair members of the the board superintendent Dr balabin I am reading this for a colleague good evening school board members and Dr balabin I know it's a long

123shot but I hope you will reconsider taking Class Dojo away from teachers especially Elementary School this is my 19th year teaching and I started using Class Dojo when it came out 14 years ago it first came out when the dreaded clip charts were still in use this was a new initiative way to ditched the charts but then it became so much more every year there is something new and exciting add it and all of this it's free for teachers to use I know the district wants to block dojo and would prefer that we all use focused communication I did the focused training and have been using it but it's not that user friendly and parents prefer dojo and so do teachers again especially Elementary parents are not responding or engaged on Focus like they are

124on dojo it's so much easier and faster for them and us to communicate I always have 100% parent involvement with JoJo but have not had that with focus at all not even close but Dojo is so much more than communication there is class story where we can share things happening in the classroom post flyers and the new calendar feature students love to play Dojo Island during inside recess there are great seal videos and lessons for teachers to use but the most important is the PBIS aspect students have a Dojo monster that they get to create and take ownership in they earn dojo points for positive behavior students in my classroom get to cash in their points on Friday Dojo has a dojo is a great great tool that allows them to redeem only the points

125they want to and they can save the rest this is my entire behav management and I would be lost without it I understand the IT department has some Safety and Security issues but I've never had an issue in the 14 years of using it Dojo has so many things in place to ensure that it's safe also if teachers don't know how to use it safely they can be trained I am the dojo mentor and administrator for my school and was at my previous I would be happy to provide training during my free time no uh if the communication and connecting families is the concern and security risk I please ask you to consider letting us at least keep dojo for the PBIS pce we do not have to connect to a school or connect families

126we can still use Dojo without any student information other than a first name the only thing teachers provide is their own personal email address teachers would still be able to reward points and students could use Dojo during inside recess with a class code that teachers are given and it chains daily this would ensure there's no data or personal student parent information shared there are other great teacher tools on dojo that have no security risk as well I could go on for hours about how amazing it is I know Focus also has a PBIS feature and I worked over the summer with a wonderful person in the IT department thinking we would be able to use it right away unfortunately that didn't happen and we didn't get our teachers trained also it is not even close

127to being like Dojo so it is not something the students are at all interested in this makes it ineffective for our classrooms I'm sure it probably works great in middle and high schools but it's not for elementary thank you for listening I hope you make the right decision Jamie manard thank you next is Kelly H Haskins followed by Kim short good evening everyone my name is Kelly has Haskins hello and I am the vice president of marketing for launch Credit Union we are proud to have two student run launch credit union branches one at Spruce Creek High one at University High and they are run by the finance at both schools student run School branches would not be possible without the support of the CTE program and the support of your superintendent Dr B Goin

128thank you Dr B Goin has been an advocate for launch Credit Union and its efforts to Pro to provide valuable educational experiences for the students of alucha County Schools through our school branches at UHS and Spruce Creek we offer valous school valous school Finance Academy students real life Hands-On experiences to your high school students these aren't just typical classroom lessons these are experiences experiences that give students the chance to step into the real world of banking customer service and profession professional development all before they even graduate in addition your students are learning about responsibility communication interviewing and career skills that will stay with them for a lifetime this program enables them to gain invaluable work experience which ultimately helps them figure out their true calling whether that's going into the workforce right after high school

129or pursuing further education or building long-term careers Dr B Goin has seen the success our school branches have had within your high schools and she's led the way with adding a finance Academy at Pine Ridge High School allowing launch Credit Union to plan for opening its third High School Branch this means even more Valia schools or valua students will gain valuable skills to succeed well beyond their high school years speaking of success we congratulate valua schools and Dr B goin on the recent successful rise in assessment scores we know that when test scores soar so do the students when schools produce higher quality graduates then launch and other local businesses reap the benefits of higher quality a higher quality Workforce pool to hire from and we've hired many valua school graduates when valua Schools students

130win our local businesses win we would like to thank Dr B Goin and valua schools for your support of our school branches and for allowing launch to be a part of your success thank you next up is Miss Kim short followed by Dan Reed I hi I'm here to switch topic a little bit um I I was the uh the what was I the co-chair of the half-cent uh committee that that brought the half cent money to Valia County and I have some some concerns that uh I was sat on this committee for about five months and with our previous district attorney it was kind of reinvented what the purpose of this committee was and I would really like this board to go back to the table on this and and give what we promised

131our taxpayers so let me explain from the beginning this referendum came into effect in 2014 and we went out as a committee to the different cities and we solicited support from every single one I think only two of them didn't give us their their endorsement one of the things that we promised over and over and over again to our taxpayers was that we were going to have an oversight committee comprised of citizens that was going to be a voting body that would vote and then give the school board our recommendation it was an oversight it was a exactly what it sounds like it's an oversight committee and we were supposed to be doing that um while I was on the committee my very first month of being on it Mr penley our previous district attorney

132came in and basically rad to us what the referendum said and made it very clear to our group that we were not a group of people that were going to be doing any kind of voting we were a group of people that were going to be do doing reporting and I will say to his credit when you go back and read it it does state that my issue is that for years it was 15 years before the referendum got put back into place by our voters and up until that point and this was in April of I'm gonna 23 I want to say um we were operating under that premise and one of the things that I think is is really also kind of important for you guys to know is that you know two

133of us um Miss Miss Bishop Sandy bishop and myself made it very clear at that meeting that this was not what we promised our taxpayers Mitch Aon also raised his concerns this is all noted in the notes from that meeting there's been no movement on it I I I really do truly believe it was because the past district attorney had no intention of revisiting it it was very cut and dry to him I have a lot of concerns with this as do a few other groups in town uh the league of women's voters I can I can very clearly state that our education committee um we're concerned with it as well this was something that we promised our taxpayers and I can tell you many of us are not going to feel comfortable when this

134needs to be you know come up for vote again supporting something without it so I'm I'm asking my board to please look at that thank you thank you next is Dan Reed followed by Mr Craig lungren is there Dan Reed in here he had to leave okay thank you Miss Albert all right then next is uh Mr Craig lungren followed by David Jimenez good evening everyone uh tonight I'm here to Advocate as well as praise our superintendent for all that she has done not just for myself but for my students um uh my name is Craig lunger I'm the director of ed uh agriculture education at cbes high school um three years ago I have been there for three years now three years ago the program was being demolished and shut down uh for it

135not to be there anymore uh by the help of our CTE and our County as well as some Schoolboard members um the program stayed alive uh I joined in with a new uh principal as well uh we started with roughly about 50 or 60 students in the program uh three years have passed we have 410 now um because of that it is not because of me it is not because of our Administration or that is it is because of the parents the students and The Advocates we have here that help our students on every single day um The Advocate that I mostly uh appreciate is our superintendent um our superintendent is coming to our school all the time she comes in she greets our Administration she greets our teachers but more importantly she greets our

136students and she greets them by name because she knows a great deal of them because she cares about each and every one of our students that we have not just at my school but at every school in belala County she is there she ask them questions what are you doing what are you learning where do you see yourself going with this and and at in Career Tech education our students are Hands-On learning skills they are getting ready to go to college trade school or open their own business and a lot of them are going to make a lot more money than any of us in this room um it is because of our superintendent and the dedication she has to our students they feel the care and they want to continue learning and educating themselves

137in our CTE programs um I would not be standing here today without the support of our superintendent um she has helped encourage me helped coach me through difficult times and it is because I heard that I stand in front of my students each and every day and tell them that they can do what they set out to do no matter who they are where they come from or what they're U represent they represent themselves and their future is in their hands and our superintendent believes in each and every one of our students and that's why she is one of our biggest Advocates and Madam cartton I am proud to sit next to you each and every day and take a photo with you because you are our biggest Advocate and I appreciate you thank you

138Mr David Jimenez followed by Clifton raldi um five and six I'll go back to that today and here's a one of 550,000 citizens my family has the bo system County since 1957 uh my father-in-law was a principal for 42 years my brother-in-law was my time in 1992 to p i remember uh coming to this building the real their role uh that we would post at the credit union that was my father-in-law also started time Joan kowal was the superintendent five and six my opinion the foundation the grounds the canas in which the school system rest is in his show uh to provide a solid a steady Foundation that brings stability to a five and six for direction and stability are needed to continue the aming progress that we have seen over the last cou program

139the progress have been clear tangible and measurable please providing an extension to the superintend about the progress to continue all have positions has different opinions but we had to go provide that stability that will uh that started a few years back finally we are here because a a common purpose uh most people probably won't be able to reide the vision statement I challenge you all to look it up but I tell you that you all are very clear about what is the common purpose and that's our children and that's what I have learned working who R I share and Dr Bing I never seen somebody and five and six that's the number of superintendence five that we have had in six years I care for teachers that that was my job in 1990 to assist

140and provide Aid and assistance guys know me here I know that don't work for the teachers and have them to see next is Clifton raldi followed by Eve Davies good evening Madam chair members of the board superintendent Dr B members of the audience my name is Clifton raldi and I'm the Lucha County High School admissions representative for Tulsa welding I've had the privilege to work with Dr Balaban um this year here in vucha County I'm proud to say that I grew up in Valia County uh attending elementary middle and high school right here in our County Dr bamman has uh been making some tremendous impacts in AA County School District I've had the privilege of participating in the first CTE partnership tour where I visited six high schools saw firsthand the incredible work that is

141being done under the leadership here are a few highlights of the wonderful things Dr balabin is doing Dr balabin is a champion for educational equality ensuring that every student in our district has access to high quality education regardless of their background she focuses on providing additional resources to the underfunded schools Bridging the Gap for students from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds and creating more inclusive and supportive learning environments Dr Bogman has introduced a variety of innovative programs designed to help the students Thrive today rapidly changing World whether it's expanding stem opportunities increasing access to advanced placement courses or launching Afterschool enrichment programs she has enriched students with the skills needed for success one of Dr balan's most notable achievements is her strong support of Career and Technical education she understands the importance of Hands-On learning and equi

142the students with practical skills for in demand careers Dr Ban's expanding CTE programs in fields like healthcare engineering and it while also placing a strong emphasis on the trades an area close to my heart as admissions from Tulsa welding schools programs she's also launched the CTE partnership tour providing students with direct exposure to Industry leaders creative opportunities for internships pre-apprenticeship and building connections with Educators the immersive experience Bridges the gap between education and employment giving students real world insight into shape their Futures Dr balaman is deeply committed to strengthening Community ties she's worked tirelessly to Foster strong connections between schools parents local businesses and other organizations her efforts have resulted in valuable Partnerships that benefit students both in out of the classroom in short Dr ban is making a significant and positive difference in our

143district her dedication to educational equality Innovative programs and expanding career opportunities through CTE and building strong Community connections while having a lasting impact for years to come very much you next is Eve Davies followed by Annie SWAT is Eve Davies here okay so sorry all right uh good evening chair Madame chairperson Schoolboard members V members and all our other valua County uh staff along with the public I was asked to come here and speak about the challenges the rezoning has brought to Orman Beach Middle School I am Mrs Davies I am a Career and Technical education teacher at Orman middle Middle School I'm a team teacher technology engineering Aerospace and Manufacturing and my specialties are robotics flight simulation and rocketry we build things we plan we design we test we fly we program we do

144all the stuff with our hands everything that is so wonderful to hear everybody talking about that is so important in our school I love being a CTE teacher and I've been CTE my whole life the resoning unfortunately has not improved our situation as Career and Technical and elective teachers at Orman Beach Middle School I teach grades six seven and eight the idal C classroom is about 20 to 25 students I have I have it easy I only have 187 students now and my largest class side is 38 our health teacher next door his class size is he is up to 44 in his class period 67 five six and seven so one of the things that the V asked me to talk about was support for the staff in the beginning of the year we

145knew we were told we were going to have large class sizes we didn't get any more tables we didn't get any more chairs the teachers had to find their own tables and chairs as custodial I'm still hustling tables and chairs for my students because it was so important that we felt each student was Welcome to our school that they had a seat and a table to sit at so it comes down to the planning the problem problem of large class sizes could have possibly been covered by an additional allocation for our school we did not get any additional allocations as far as I have heard we could have added a language arts all my students are so interested in Japanese when I ask them what interests them Japanese an additional Spanish unit something that would

146not take a lab like CTE does but instead we got seven class periods which was a switch from the six class periods and class sizes went up to 40 so for example my largest class my 38 student class is a robotics class I have 15 robots I still don't know how I get 38 students to program 15 robots and I have two robotics classes so the same 15 robots have to go to both classes so the other Middle School teachers we have begged borrowed possibly stolen robots from each other to try to get robotics someone says I got some extra kits we're all like driving to University to get the extra kits Okay so we've done everything we can to try to provide this valuable um education for our students because it's very important to

147us but some students are in our class the other additional problem is the behavior being just so difficult with the last class sizes and when I say behavior I'm saying I can't turn my back on the class because you don't know what's going to happen so I asked ask you to consider additional allocations to our school in order to alleviate our CTE and elective class size thank you thank you next is Annie swatti followed by Elizabeth Albert hi and I want to start by saying Merry Christmas I'm this is my fourth speech in two years and it's so nice to see some new faces I see some new faces in Jesse Thompson is chair gives me hope that I'm going to be heard and possibly inclusion can start being implemented um the best Christmas present

148you can give the best gift ever that you could start giving is to end the segregation of the special needs students in all of Lucha County Schools here's some facts to remind you about that I said in my other speech in 1954 the law was passed to end segregation for the black students and it took over 20 years to implement in 1976 Ada Section 504 was passed to end the segregation of students with disabilities and it's 2024 in still of Lua County Schools is still segregating them and separating them form the General Ed so for example if you put black kids in building 15 at CB's High School where they try to put my son at it would be called a racial segregation a racial War imagine that so then what would you call if

149he placed only students with disabilities in that same building 100 children in one building that are only disabled that's called discrimination and segregation that defines it to a te that's corrupt and this outdated system needs to end let valua County be schools be an example of how to implement inclusion because this whole nation is doing the same thing in state of Florida so let's start now so why is it still going on my my solution is money is the only logical reason the more kids they put in that building they claimed they they needed to add of the support by fraudulent documentation of students condition for example my son has 13 behaviors he never had ever in his whole entire school life to justify removing him from general education and placed him in a segregated

150building I have 13 I'm going to give you guys a copy 13 behaviors suddenly the more behaviors the more support needed equals more money for the school and how is that money being used per child I don't know okay so this needs to be investigated all right it's always about the money when my son was at Pathways Elementary when he was in elementary um which was then in a school they claimed if my son or other special needs kids were included into a gened class it would drop the score of the school which means they would get less money huh oh wow the score of the school is more important than the educational needs of a special needs student I recall my son once got all AIDS was on the honor rooll I was not

151happy to know they passed him on so easy when he barely was a C or D student in my eyes to pass on to special needs kids in this corrupt system is so cruel and sets them up for failure when they finally aged out at age 22 they are barely employable and introverted when they are never around this Jed thank you Miss swy okay so this's just stop robbing these children and robbing us taxpayers and give them what they deserve thank you thank you next up is Elizabeth Albert followed by Bev Johnson good evening again Madame chair members of the board superintendent Dr balabin and members of the audience so this time I'm speaking for myself but not really I'm speaking on behalf of the teachers and staff at CH T small Elementary and Campbell

152Middle School tonight in your audience we have representatives from both schools who have come across the district to be present and engage in the work of uh their Union and and this board I want to talk to you about the rezoning and the Ripple effects or the consequences of what has occurred uh based on the decision to move students so what we know and what was already shared with you in part is the fact that what might have looked really great on paper the reality of it is not working the way I think anyone on this board would have intended it to work out uh Eve and and Holly and obms has also had resoning Eve spoke earlier I apologize for not including her nonetheless uh what we know is there was limited if any

153proactive and intentional action taken to blend the groups of students that were merging onto any of these campuses and because of that the result has been catastrophic at Several of these schools there is educational impacts due to larger class sizes which result in behavioral problems there are violence and behavioral issues resulting in different groups of children from neighborhoods coming together that have not been integrated in a way that helps them understand how we behave on this campus I hope you're following what I'm saying and so what what has resulted is negative impacts not only to the students that show up every day who want to learn but to the instructional and support Personnel who work in these schools I have a doc a document here one for Terry T and one for Campbell that lists

154every employee in our bargaining unit teachers and support staff on each one of the campuses it's a tracking data I can tell you at Terry T small Elementary School 19 of these employ 19 of the employees at the school who started in August are no longer there of those 19 who have left because we want to talk about facts and data of those 19 who have left 11 were new hires at TT small when we look at Campbell Middle School I can tell you that 11 teachers who and staff who were there in August have left as of today and four of those were newly hired to the school so what I'm saying to you is this uh these schools TT small obms Campbell Middle School and some of the others who were rezoned and

155I know there's another round potentially coming this year there needs to be true proactive act actions taken to work to get in front of some of the issues and those actions need to include the voice of the teachers and the staff and the community members who live around these schools if not I think unfortunately we're going to continue to see negative impacts thank you thank you next up is Bev Johnson good evening Madam chair school board members and superintendent bgin it's nice to be here my name is Bev Johnson I'm the president and CE of Easter Seals Northeast Central Florida we have a longstanding relationship that we like to call a partnership with Luchia County Schools it's been more than 30 years that we've provided Services uh within the school system and when I say

156we are Partners um our relationship has always been positive and uh and we certainly have experienced challenges but we've we've experienced them together um specifically working with our kidss with special needs oftentimes funding is an issue it is across the country and um just to kind of give you the the the inside scoop of how we work together know we've in justest said sometimes gosh I'll bake the cookies for the bake sale right we understand we live in a world at Easter seales where funding is constantly challenged and and so we are appreciative of the fact that we share that challenge although we wish it didn't have to share it with anybody at Easter Seals we care about all children certainly but we have a very special place in our hearts for students with unique

157abilities and oftentimes we're working to find solutions that are not readily available or apparent and creating change takes time but I'm encouraged but I but by what I see and what we experience under your leadership Dr B in recent years under your leadership we've seen incredible support and positive change like I said before we've always had positive relationships but it's been very difficult at times to see us kind of move the needle and I know it's not always apparent to everyone involved um when things are happening and changing but in our world we've seen incredible positive change uh with our relationship and I want to say I appreciate that very much it's not just you either it's your leadership your staff is accessible they are open-minded and there's opportunities that are there and I believe

158it's because of your leadership so I want to thank you for that and I want to make sure that the school board understands and knows that that comes from the top and it's apparent across your entire cabinet I recently took a field trip with you the CTE field trip and it was phenomenal um it was great not just to go into the schools and have the kids be exposed to the professionals and the industries that were on the field trip but to have us exposed to the children and to what's happening within the school system at Easter Seals I and as a as a mom I am always advocating for our children with unique abilities and those that might fall through the cracks and I was very encouraged by what I saw through the CTE

159program to see how we could continue to strengthen and support that program and potentially expand that program to meet every child where they are and to help children realize dreams they didn't even know they maybe had and uh and I just want to say thank you so thank you for the work that you're doing um I feel the support for you in the room certainly I'm sure that the board feels the same so thank you very much and I hope you all have wonderful holidays thank you and then that is the end of public comment currently we are going to take a 10-minute recess and we will be back at 7:28 e e e all right everyone at this time we will be going to item probationary status of new employees Madam chair I would

160like to ask Mr John Cash our chief of staff along with Miss Stephanie Workman our executive director for human resources to come forward um they have a very short and brief and concise it all means the same set of information to share with you regarding for policy 429 so thank you welcome chair Thompson board member superintendent Balaban a special welcome to miss Goodrich and Miss brossmer nice to see you again uh we understood completely Dr bamman expeditious so with that being said Miss Workman well good evening um as you know one of the um policies that we have never had in place for all employees is a prob aary policy there were there was um probationary language in the instructional the support and the former appsme but we never had anything that addressed non-bargaining so

161when the askme contract went away uh back in January we felt like we needed to address a probationary policy for all employees that aren't governed by a bargaining unit so that is what brings us to the table tonight um I I have no um comment cards for this item is there a recommendation from the superintendent yes Madam chair I recommend that the adoption of policy 429 which is the probationary status for new employees do we have a motion to approve I make a motion to approve I'll second thank you Vice chair thank you Miss Goodrich is there any further discussion Mr cologne yes uh was this advertised for the required amount of time yes sir it was okay and did we receive any public comment on this policy during that advertisement to my knowledge no

162sir very good thank you is there any further discussion all right all those in favor say I I any opposed it passes unanimously 19.02 was pulled so we are moving on to 19.03 authorization to advertise proposed amendments to policy 320 media selection of print and non-print materials thank you madam chair I would like to ask Dr Desiree rabinsky um she is our coordinator for instructional materials and Media Services and she will share with you some revisions briefly revisions to policy 320 good evening chairwoman Thompson uh superintendent bin and Schoolboard members um policy 320 is an on the agenda with a request to advertise with revisions these changes aim to clarify some definitions update terminology and clarify procedures for selecting managing and um the challenging procedure for media materials in school libraries um we did add

163some definitions for clarity and um to update some of the ter terminology and the language from the Florida statute to make sure that was represented in all areas of um the policy all right and we have one person who is going to be speaking on this for public comment and that is Miss Jennifer Kelly good evening board and M superintendent um I just wanted to come up here and say thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you um just a little bit of a a timeline uh on this I reached you guys know I have been uh working on this for a couple years but I did Reach Out a couple months back to the superintendent to request this be put onto the um agenda to be addressed and she did get back

164to me same day so the communication and transparency this time through this have been much improved as well as the policy has been much improved um after reading it when it came out I um had about six no I had 18 questions and I reached out to Dr rabinsky and she very graciously called me back about an hour later and we went through all of them she took the time with me to go through all of them to make sure I had the understanding on it and I greatly appreciate that um it's not 100% but I don't expect everything to be 100% but this is something that I can definitely uh work with and move forward with the definitions put out here thank you it's very clear um consolidating everything that was repetitive in the

165last time we went through this very helpful um some of the issues that I had uh wished to be addressed were addressed um in a way that I think is going to be very beneficial to move forward with us so I just want to thank everyone involved thanks so much is there a recommendation from the superintendent yes Madam chair I recommend the authority be granted to advertise the proposed amendments to Schoolboard policy 320 which is Media selection of print and non-print materials do we have a motion to approve motion to approve second go ahead that's fine okay and mo Donna all right any further discussion Mr cologne uh my question is for Council is this compliant with is this policy compliant with current law yes thank you all right any further discussion all right all

166those in favor please say I I any opposed it passes unanimously thank you thank you 19.04 Transportation analysis and wage recommendation thank you madam chair um our chief of staff Mr Cash is here along with Miss Stephanie Warman who is our executive director for human resources they have a presentation for you about the transportation analysis and wages recommendation as you recall um I don't remember the exact date but this board at the at the request of this board including the two uh board members that are no longer here Mr pares and Miss Bernett you have requested that the team go and provide an a a a presentation to get a presentation ready for this board that will showcase what um a a recommendation pretty much for our transportation Division and they are ready to share

167that presentation with you and to obtain your input if needed thank you uh chair toson board members superintendent Balaban as you alluded to Dr Balaban I believe it was September 24th thank you um is when this was brought to us we were given the task to do an analysis and bring forward a potential wage increase for a critical shortage area which is our bus drivers and I will share that it has been a critical shortage area in transportation for quite some time in Valia County and it's been a challenge to recruit and retain our bus drivers which is really important to get our students to and from school before I have Miss Workman go through the uh PowerPoint and then answer any questions you may have just wanted you to be aware that our CFO

168Todd CE was very involved in this process on the team along with Patty Core Miss Workman myself and of course Dr olssen and transportation and his team who I believe are here to bring this presentation forward for your consideration so thank you with that I'll let Miss Workman go through the actual PowerPoint presentation sir um as you know this um all ties to guard rail one which is to recruit support develop and retain that high quality staff which is as Mr Cass mentioned um very difficult in this particular area so just to give you a little bit background of information as to how we got here um annually and this is just since I have been in HR we have had anywhere between 30 and 40 vacancies and when you think of vacancies you have

169to think of that as routes so that's 30 to 40 routes that we are missing both morning and evening um the hourly rate increase has not been Equitable to the rate increases by outside entities and when I say outside entities I'm talking about Private Industry like Votran and some of our bus um companies here in our area the which this has made our transportation department have to decrease the number of routes significantly to combat having fewer drivers if you ask any of our current um operators what they will tell you is that many of them do run two and three routes a day um if you really dive into the data you will find that we have been paying a tremendous amount of overtime simply because we haven't been able to fill these routes um

170lastly we have also had to use employees from other job roles we have had Paras who have jumped on board to assist we have had instructional staff jump on board as well as many of the individuals within the transportation Department who aren't officially assigned to an operator role just to give you an idea of where valua stands at this moment in terms of starting rates we are currently at 1762 and that does include the 3% raise that was given back in um the early Fall by this board however looking at the districts around us you can see that simol and Bard both which are very close in proximity start around $20 an hour so when we were looking at doing an analysis we we took all of this data into consideration as to how we

171can make ourselves competitive I mean we are just a little bit above Votran which is one of our competitors however um especially um I live here on the West side of the county it doesn't take very long to get to seminal and to make almost um $2 and a half dollars more an hour that that's a big deal so what what our proposed plan is is we would like to increase the hourly rate first for our bus assistance we would like to increase that by a dollar to make that competitive and then for our operators we would like to raise that by $3 an hour what this does is I'm going to jump back for just a second to this chart is not only does it put us above those two surrounding districts that are

172higher it allows us to hopefully get some of our people people who have jumped across the bridge as I like to say to come back because why would you want to drive the seminal when you can stay right here and and make more so so that's the reason we've looked at that $3 proposal one of the other reasons that in looking at the entire transportation department we want to also entice our bus assistants to come on board because one of the things our transportation department has been doing that has been working is they have been hiring those assistants and then working with them and training them to become CDL licensed to become drivers so if we can get them in as an attendant we put them through our training program within no time they have

173now jumped up to $20 an hour as well the second thing that we know we need to address is we need to address compression um I know it's been alluded to many times in conversations with the board that not only in the instructional world but as well well in our support world that moved to $115 an hour as quickly as it had to happen compressed many of our our staff that's been here 15 to 20 years all of a sudden someone new coming in is right where you were even though you've given that amount of time to the district so our goal is to um look at facilitating a salary schedule in the 25 26 school year that will help address that compression unfortunately um and I know uh Mr Cash mentioned um discussing with

174Mr CE you know we can only do things incrementally because of the way that our budget is set up so what we are proposing is the increases that I mentioned earlier and this gives you a breakdown of those individuals who would be impacted it's not just the assistants it's not just the operators it's those dispatchers it's those mechanics it's those technicians because believe it or not all of those 30 plus people that fall outside of those categories they are what have been saving us they are the ones with the CDL licenses that have been jumping off of their regular job to try to help get our kids to school so we felt like we didn't want to just address those two categories but we needed to look to look at Transportation as a whole so

175in doing so you can see that for one year this would be a 1.2 almost 1.3 uh million dollar investment and that would would be reoccurring however what we are proposing for this year is to start it in January on January 1st moving through the end of the fiscal year so for this one year it would be half of that so um at this point I feel like that is our presentation and if you have any questions we're happy to answer Miss brosmer thank you I'm very grateful to the district um the staff for taking this step uh I've personally kind of narrowed down our function as a as a district uh we have the job of getting the kids to school and then we have the job of making the classrooms a place where

176the teachers can teach and students can learn and this is half the battle they have they have a really difficult job and I didn't want us to continue to be the training ground for votan so thank you very much for doing this I won't belabor the point I'm just very grateful I made an issue of it um over the last year and a half and I am delighted to see this happen so thank you Vice chair Haynes I want to thank all of you because we did we um we asked that you analyze all of this and look at it and I had the um privilege of going out and speaking at the Deltona you know bus hub to I think about 80 of our employees out there and I actually asked them you know

177which would they prefer to start with and they um other than one individual they said we'd rather start with the dollars and I too am hoping that with this increase we're going to bring back some of those that have crossed the line into simal County and that they will come back to us and I'm also hoping because we are doing the whole CDL piece now to help them get their CDL that some of these bus assistants will want to step up and get their CDL licenses because then their salary can raise the only thing and um I talked to both of you ahead of time about this is I feel it's very important that tonight we also make a commitment that yes in when we start the new fiscal year that we go ahead and

178have ready to roll out a piece to address the compression because we have a piece in place right now to address the compression for the teachers we have the two supplements that actually count into their F FRS system that our teachers you know that have X number years of experience can earn those two supplements and I just would like like to see us commit tonight that yes we're going to do this salary adjustment so that we show them how much we appreciate them and we can bring people back but I just want to make sure that we are going to go ahead and start addressing the compression piece for all of these individuals starting in the next fiscal year to your point uh Miss Haynes the slide I put back on here so you can

179see it publicly that's the last bullet that we're committed to taking a look at that compression and we're stating here publicly there's work to be done to combat compression and it's not easy task but it's one that we are committed and we want the employees to hear that we absolutely are committed to address and I did share with them it can't be corrected in one year like we won't correct it next year but as long as we start the process and show them that we actually value and we realize that if you've been here 20 years you got into that compression piece but that we're going to work towards pulling you up but I want to thank you because I know this was a lot of work to collect all of this information and try

180to figure out where the funding was to be able to do this but I appreciate the job they're the first people that see our students every morning and they're the last group that tells them goodbye when they drop them off at home so thank you Mr cologne so I too want to Echo appreciation I know we discussed this earlier in the year and admittedly I haven't been extremely engaged in these conversations as our chair uh has been uh probably but I was very pleasantly surprised that we were that the proposal coming to the board was a 177% increase and not only is it a 17% increase on top of the 3% but it also takes us ahead of our surrounding counties which is extremely important and so I I I am grateful that you all

181worked your magic together with the CFO in that I don't don't think we've ever seen a 177% increase come before us for any uh any group and so uh I am grateful that um we are able to do this not only for our employees but also for our students as we recognize that you know our bus drivers are are are essential as our all of our employees so again thank you uh for putting our desire on I'd say on steroids because when I saw the final numbers that were being proposed it's like you know could it always be more absolutely and uh and I know our bus drivers are going to be grateful for it so thank you thank you now we do have one public comment on this item and that is Miss Elizabeth

182Albert good evening again Madam chair members of the board superintendent Dr balabin members of of the audience so to begin I would like to say um how wonderful this very long overdue increase is to the uh bus drivers and bus attendants I can only imagine that Carol Sawyer is somewhere turning a cartwheel at this point in time uh when she hears about this increase for her people uh so in the spirit of giving during this holiday season I want you to to remind you that every employee in this District contributes to the success of our students of course it all starts in the morning with Transportation but then let's not forget our schoolway Cafe professionals feed them our office staff make sure our schools and work sites are ready to go our Maintenance and Facilities

183folks they make sure that everything is functioning um our Paris support our students with disabilities our campus advisors are there to make sure things are clicking the way they're supposed to and everyone's behaving delivery Personnel make sure our schools and our uh cafeterias are stocked uh School Guardians also another l protection custodians keep our buildings and Facilities clean instructional uh Personnel do the work of educating administrators do the work of making sure their sites are run correctly every person in this District contributes to the overall success of our students and they are our number one priority and so uh there are many other folks that I didn't have on my list that I would like you to consider as we revisit looking at salaries in order order to provide for our employees and be competitive

184we know that there is $117 million currently in the fund balance we learned that when the AFR was completed in September and it was shared and so for full transparency we have met twice with Mr CE and Miss Workman to talk about what we can do since we have come up to uh such a great number in that fund balance Mr CE is very Savvy and smart and he has done some things that have created a great return on investment so what can can we do to to give back to those that give so much for all of us in this District um I just want to say that tonight's vote on this item is the very first step in a good direction and I encourage you to continue to take a look at this

185and do this work because what we know is in order to be competitive in today's hiring market and with surrounding districts as Mr cologne you have pointed out and as demonstrated on the slide that we saw that will take us to first place in this area we must make a adjustments for everybody in this district from Soup To Nuts who helps our children succeed thank you is there a recommendation from the superintendent yes I do I recommend approval of wage increase for student transportation services as follows bus attendance $1 per hour and bus operators transportation bus dispatcher vehicle Tech assistant mechan mechanic technician autov visual technician auto body and vehicle technician $3 per hour do we have a motion to approve I make the motion to approve second thank you Vice chair Haynes and miss

186brosmer all right any further discussion the none although in favor say I I I any opposed it passes unanimously thank you thank you guys very much thank you John and thank you Stephanie next we are moving on to item 19.05 Schoolboard member travel confirmation Karen Bishop admitted it got it there is no one from the public who wishes to speak on this item is there a recommendation from the superintendent um Madam chair I um oh sorry I wasn't recognized no uh Mr colog um in looking at this list I noticed that we included many of the outof state cosba events and so my initial thought is um that while it's good to have it on here it involves uh the potential of a summit which I don't know where that's going to be held we

187have our fsba events here there's a annual conference in Atlanta uh there is a federal advocacy to Washington DC um I I think it's important that we have the ability to uh participate in these events however um I I think that anything that's going to be outside of the State of Florida um we should have a board consensus for traveling so if any one of us wants to go to Washington DC let's say for that Federal advocacy I think it's important as the district will be uh picking up the cost that we uh at least majority approve that travel um to uh outside of the state um the other thing that's on here is travel to Tallahassee from January 14 to May second and so I also think that it's important that uh we have

188the ability to do that but when we go up to Tallahassee and the school district is covering the cost it should be uh with messaging from the board as you are there for the school district and it should be in collaboration with our lobbyists and so so I also again I'm very uh I I think that you know by law we have these on here because the legislation says if travel is going to exceed $500 we should have this voted on but I think that uh we should uh for the sake of controlling costs and and ensuring that the messaging is consistent in collaboration with the district that anything that's outside of the state travel uh we bring forth amongst ourselves to say you know if you want to go to there's a school safety

189conference so I may have a specific desire in collaboration with Chief and Dr B and say I'd really like to go to this so I would come to you all and say I'd like to go to this this is the cost is going to exceed 500 and then seek your approval to then be able to expend that otherwise we could arguably be you know which I don't think any of us have this desire but arguably we could travel to Tallahassee every week from now from January to May 2nd and basically be at a conference every month of the year at The District's expense so I propose that for these uh cosba uh events that we seek uh board consensus as well as any trips to Tallahassee that are uh representing the board uh in that

190travel so that's my uh recommendation that we edit this document uh to reflect that and I will make a motion as such second all right uh Miss goodr did you want to say anything else and then miss Haynes I was just gonna say I agree um I think the cosba events can be moved I mean or highlighted that they're available but I do think they should be Standalone items if someone wishes to travel outside of the state and I actually think that if you're going to travel to Tah outside of the fsba event that we know is structured and exactly what's happening that um it should also seek add um approval as a standalone item and miss brosmer that actually touches on my question I wondered procedurally what we would do to coordinate any um

191any uh conversation with legislators in Tallahassee um how how does that happen among the board members and and how do we approach the board for permission to to do that Mr colum so what brought this on the agenda was Mr persus who was our uh Advocate who worked I think we even ass he was our we assigned him to our advocacy chair and he went to Tallahassee a couple of times I think uh with uh League of cities and then I I believe he went up one other time and so he wanted the ability for us to be able to uh go to do these activities as denoted here um and the school district cover the cost of that travel if it exceeded you know that $500 which is the threshold that we're talking here

192so arguably if I wanted to go to a session listen you know we'll know what laws and sessions are coming up I would come before this body and say hey there's a session coming up regarding School member term limits and I'd like the ability to go there and speak on that on behalf of the board if there is consensus then yay we would say yes go for it and uh and and that would be that followup um things happen kind of on short notice in Tallahassee especially during committee weeks and things start to move quickly uh is there a process if we see something thing that we think needs to be addressed and we would want to weigh in is there a process for getting short um approval in a shorter term rather than waiting

193for another meeting to ask I would be in favor of amending this to say uh allowing the board chair to allow that decision before it comes before the next meeting in other words if something happens in Tallahassee and it gets hot and heavy and we need to have a voice there there I I understand what you're saying uh I think that I would be okay if the board chair in collaboration with the superintendent if that's happening then uh and it would then come to our next meeting uh for board approval okay I that um Miss Haynes I I was gonna add to it when I heard what you said you know exactly what Mr colog just said to um you know that we could go ahead and get it approved because it does happen quickly

194up there but all of the out all the ones that are outside of the state those are kind of already set and and my thought is you know if you want to go to one I think you just have to have a valid reason what you're going because everything we always look at is what's the return on investment you know so what is it that we're going to learn and how is that going to change the practice of what we're doing here for students Mr cologne we don't have any travel plan between now and the end of the year so my thought is uh that we bring this back with the proper language in uh unless there's a reason statuto which I don't think there is right now because we're not going anywhere uh and

195bring this back in January at the next meeting we'll table this so I I'll retract my motion and I retract I make a motion that we table this to the next board meeting and um I'm sure Karen is listening and then we can bring bring this back uh the next meeting and approve it then as we have proposed here at the table if that's okay with everyone so I'll retract my motion and I'll make a new motion to table this uh until the next meeting and do we have a second for the motion to table second thank you and is there any further discussion all right all those in favor say I I I any opposed it passes unanimously we will table this until our January meeting when will come back with all of the

196beautiful things you said wrapped in there Beau correct Dr Evans thank you Karen you all right now we are moving on to item 19.06.13 our then board chair Jamie Haynes and the superintendent um the contract is before you that has been proposed and the contract was created based upon a review of other school district superintendent contracts of like like sizes uh for as you know valua county is considered a large District I want the record to reflect that the past chair did ask for a compar uh between other districts so we looked at several other districts namely bravard Orange acola um seminol Deval we even looked at CER County um as well and Sarasota County looked at the size of the school district the number of students the number of Staff the length of the

197superintendent contract and the base salary along with other incentives that were given in those contract so after a review of those contracts um we negotiated or the superintendent and the then board chair negotiated a four-year contract for the superintendent uh uh 8% 8.7% salary increase for the superintendent a medical stien for medical expenses of $500 per month and also to give a car um which the superintendent always had a car but we negotiated to give her a car that she could park at her home instead of having to park at one of the schools um as do all the other administrators in the county um who have a company car so those are the material changes to the contract and this is the contract that we have proposing uh for your review and consideration on

198this this evening Mr cologne thank you so uh board I I'm a numbers person and I went through and looked at our school districts in the state or excuse me in the country and I went plus and minus 10,000 students and so this report nationally includes uh a lot of charter schools and so in this number I know as far as public schools we're probably closer to the uh 50th something largest District in the country however this report put us at 62 so starting with Milwaukee Public Schools at 67,000 students working my way down to Howard County Public Schools 57,000 students were're current at 63,000 students and so having looked at their superintendent salary and as you all are aware uh the it's not as clear-cut as a dollar amount some school districts have you

199know a car allowance which I'll talk about in a second some school districts cover the mileage uh some school districts uh have bonuses you really can't I mean there's just to go through and figure out numbers wise but what I will tell you is that I used a single source which is a government website which you could go find all of the salaries of all the school districts all the public employees and right now Dr balamin uh according to this report and again the numbers can go up or down a little bit uh we're at $3.9 per student and when I took the mean of all of these districts which are about I have it on an Excel spreadsheet so I went from 55 to 71 the mean salary for and we're talking about just

200by virtue of District size the mean salary is $311,000 so if we look at districts in our country that are up and down plus or minus you know 10,000 students the mean salary is 311,000 the mean per student is $514 we're currently at $396 then I went and look at some folks that we know so our former deputy superintendent went up to troop County Georgia they have 12,000 students 12,200 students salary was $225,000 which is $18.44 per student now kudos to Georgia their base student allocation is about 12 thou it's about 7,000 $6,000 more than ours so kudos to Georgia our CFO or coo at the time uh Dr Mark shanoff went to Oola County they have 73,000 students and his salary is $280,000 so that's $3.80 per student uh prior to Dr balabin we

201did a superintendent search and the amazing Dr Moore uh who was our second place candidate and we did not hire him went to Indian River and by the way everyone he was superintendent of the year so Dr Moore and he knows I'm a fan he went to Indian River County that has 17,1 199 students just as a reminder we're right around 63,000 students and Dr Moore went to Indian River for a humble $189,000 that was three years three years ago he just renegotiated to $239,000 which is $13.90 per student when I did this math and I started to look at districts our size and mind you there's a lot of Vari ations uh even taking out some of the outliers in California that I'm not even going to share with Dr balabin how much these

202folks get paid because it yeah it's it's insane again it can vary it C it can no I'm not going to say it out loud everyone can do their own research and so what this led me to to realize is a few things number one we're getting a bargain which I'm not a fan of because I think that she has done everything we've asked for and more I don't need to I don't need to say much I think we heard it today I think that what she's asking for is fair as we know nothing is getting cheaper everything is getting more expensive and the truth is we get to lock her in for four years at that amount of money and she's going to get her for those who don't know she gets the same

203raise our non bargaining folks get so if our principles get 2% she gets 2% so in my opinion aside from how amazing the work that she has done she's done everything that we've asked her for I think this is a very fair proposal let's talk about the vehicle because that was uh brought up and the reality is that Mo a lot of school districts and by the way for those that don't know we're talking about a Ford Escape we're not talking about a an expedition we're not talking about a navigator we're talking about a Ford Escape and I uh had some vehicle issues went to a conference and they lent me the ability which by the way that the ability to drive a district car is actually a lot more than even running for Schoolboard

204and being a Schoolboard member okay and they gave me a Ford Escape and I can tell you it felt like and mind you I drive a Buick LaCrosse so I don't have anything that's huge to drive every day I got into this little truck I put it in reverse and the little window for the reverse camera is this big so we're not talking about a Mercedes we're not talking about arguably Dr balabin can say you know what I'm going to drive my personal vehicle and you all pay me the mileage she could say that and that would cost us a lot more than we pay for the Ford Escape I'm almost embarrassed to say that she drives a fort Escape but that's neither here nor there and so this request and she would never say

205this this request comes from this Dr balabin Lives not far away from seab breze high she can see the parking lot across the street however at 10:00 at night because of our current requirements she she has to drive to that school across the street from her house open up the fence because we know our fences are as we heard a challenge by herself whatever time of night it is to open that fence park the car and drive her car across the street now the job of superintendent office often requires them to be out at night in the community and I think there's no question that she does that if we go to Tampa to a conference and she wants to stop at her daughter's house in Winter Garden it's now Friday night she has to

206drive to Daytona because she can't have that vehicle at her daughter's house because our policy says that it can't do that that's what we're asking for she's not saying I'm going to go drive to Alaska and take a road trip and a fort Escape I I think that request is reasonable again it's not a luxury vehicle it's not even a vehicle I would probably purchase for myself because I'm a big guy and so I I think the request is reasonable uh it's definitely I can assure you it's cheaper than paying mileage uh and so I I think that request is extremely reasonable and so again the evaluation speak for themselves the numbers the the numbers the market all of that supports that this is probably an underfunded contract but I think Dr balabin also has

207sensitivity for the challenges our district has faced and for that reason I am extremely supportive of this I have done the math I have looked up other districts um a lot of folks will point out seino County and I can tell you that I had a great chat with board members from over there and they've also improved their number although I don't know exactly what it is different set of circumstances uh but again and and seino County was included in the numbers uh that Drew me to my mean so for that reason Dr balabin I want to thank you again I feel that you know it is definitely warranted I think that the work that has been done as evidenced by I mean we couldn't make this up and so uh I am fully supportive

208of this thank you thank you Miss brosmer I'm not a numbers person I'm a policy person and um I went and I'm this is my very first board meeting of so when um Mr Evans contacted me uh and if my voice shakes it's because I'm trying to keep my teeth from chattering so forgive me for that but um when Mr Evans contacted me to discuss this contract I had not seen it and I asked him for three documents um and I greatly appreciate that you sent them to to me right away um they were Dr balaban's evaluation which had not been posted on board docs on on the um on the agenda item and um her original contract as well as the the new draft it was my understanding that the reason this is on

209the agenda for today is because this is the last meeting in December and that her contract uh required notification by December 31st of whether we intended to to extend her contract but the date is not December 31st it's March 31st 2025 when this decision has to be made so I'm not exactly sure why we're doing this now um and with that in mind uh part of what has um been on mind my mind is that I mean clearly Dr baban is very easy to like um we could tell that from the fan club who was here tonight telling telling us how wonderful she is and her passion for the students and for the for the Bia County School District is indisputable um her personal warmth her um her Talent as a public speaker all of

210those things are are really excellent um but I think because we're just coming out of an election cycle and have two new board members who have not had an opportunity to know anything about the negotiation of this contract which I would have thought might be workshopped at least or we might have had some kind of of previous opportunity for input um my thought is that it would be more prudent for us to have that opportunity and um and I also noted in our in the existing contract that it calls for one-year extensions at the same rate as all of our one-year contract employees get uh that seems appropriate to me so we're not if if we don't make this decision tonight we still have a contract um we still have a contract for three more

211months and we have the opportunity to discuss what to do with it as a full board allowing two new board members to get better seated to have the opportunity to work more with Dr Balaban and learn the district a little bit better get ourselves a little bit better situated uh and um in the the only thing that I would um adjust in that period is that uh Dr balaban's evaluation is linked to the Strategic plan Dr balaman told me over coffee that uh the staff wrote the Strategic plan with input from the board that's nice work if you can get it but that's effectively writing your own evaluation document and so the proper way to do it is that the board writes the Strategic plan and so I I would think that we could use

212the next few months to come up with um with metrics that are appropriate for evaluation and then uh and then decide on extending the contract under the existing terms uh what ends up happening with the with uh four-year contracts and and the vucha County school board has been through this numerous times as we've already heard from the public in talking about the desire for stability and the fact that we've gone through so many uh superintendents in a very short time is that what ends up happening and we did this to Dr Fritz um he had already notified the board that he was not going to renew his contract and the board fired him anyway and we ended up doing a payout the one-year extensions um seemed prudent to me at least at this moment um

213I may change my mind in three months when when her contract is actually up but um at this moment the terms of the existing cont contract seem very prudent to me and very workable and and I I would personally like the opportunity to work with this contract and to work with Dr Balaban before I need to make a decision of this magnitude because deciding who our super intendent is going to be is probably the single most important thing we do she's the one who implements everything we want done in classrooms and we heard tonight how excellent she is in some areas but we also heard about deficiencies that need to be addressed so it's up to us as a board to make sure that we provide the framework to get those deficiencies addressed and and

214then have a a document that allows us to measure all of that so my my thought for tonight is that we lay this on the table and bring it back in at our second meeting in March during which time we can figure out what our metrics are and uh maybe Workshop the the entire concept I have no problem for instance with the issue of the car that makes perfect sense to me I can't imagine having to drop it off and and leave it here and go somewhere and get get in your own and go somewhere else so I think there there is room to work with this um but according to the current contract terms we don't have to do it tonight and I would like the opportunity to work on it a little bit

215more thank you Vice chair Haynes thank you so I um I have been here and worked under many superintendant and worked with a superintendent so when it was time to write her contract there were some things that we were very clear about we did not want an evergreen Clause we had already gone through through an evergreen Clause before which just meant it was an automatic renewal so we did not put an evergreen Clause into this we also did not want a golden parachute which we did not put into this we also said we did not want a bonus piece because I will tell you for years bonuses for superintendent have been an issue and she was here and did all of the work during covid stepped up and lived out at schools and in in

216this boardroom all the way up till 2:30 in the morning we did more meetings that summer than we typically do in a full year just in two months period of time well as soon as the superintendent who was out during that entire time of like nine months returned he immediately asked for his $10,000 bonus and because it was in the contract we had to give it to him so I asked originally no Evergreen claws no golden parachute no bonus we asked for a straightforward contract that gave her a base salary and she would earn the same salary increase as the other people in the non bargaining unit that she falls under what we also asked was for her to have her health insurance and then we asked that she have the ability to have access

217to a car we had former superintendents that not only had bonuses they had health insurance that covered their entire families including adult children they had nine7 to $900 a month that they were given for vehicles even during times when they weren't working for valua County they still got the that monthly vehicle allowance she didn't ask for any of those things but what happened was and Mr clone was chair at the time we didn't get the contract to even look at till we arrived in the boardroom because it was supposedly being worked on over the weekend and we got that contract as we arrived in the boardroom and even though I tried to scan it quickly looking to see were their discrepancies the things that I had said to not include in there we missed some

218things so I'll start with this in the contract that we approved for her to start for a threeyear period of time her health insurance was entirely left out of that contract and she had to pay her health insurance then we tried to amend that and the same firm that wrote the contract amended it with only paying the health piece but not the vision and dental so the current contract she has she's having to pay all of that and she's been having to pay it we've never had a superintendent have to pay those things the next piece that we discovered have to love somebody that puts little clawes in there um and by the way she didn't start off with long-term and short-term disability 30 days into her contract that was also in a previous contract

219but a clause was put in there and HR can speak to it that it said in the event though somebody in the group she was in was not getting this the 3% raise we gave everybody this year it didn't matter which category you're in everybody got 3% okay that if there was anybody not getting it then she didn't get it she didn't get the 3% raise this year either so the current contract we have has issues the current contract says we have to follow the policy where no matter what time of the night it is and and during Hurricane time time she may have to go out at 2:00 a.m. in the morning she has to park her vehicle at seab breze high unlock the gate go in park it switch whatever relock the gate

220I find that not to be a safe piece my biggest issue on that was safety for her now she could turn around as many of the districts do because as I said we analyzed all the pieces and parts and she could say okay then I want you guys to pay me $900 a month because there's a lot of superintendents that get paid that and the previous one got paid so that he didn't use our vehicle we had to pay him monthly for a vehicle so this is one of the most simplistic contracts and even with the errors that are in it that need to be corrected that we've ever had she's not getting things that other districts are getting there are a lot of districts that say if you look at it that their superintendent

221based on their evaluation will get five a 5% raise of what their current base salary is at that point so if we had to give her 5% every year and when Dr Smith was here there's people sitting in this audience that have been here as long as me we got 0% raises and she got a 6% raise Dr Smith did so she didn't take care of the employees because she had all those things built into her contract this is a simplistic contract it's very fair Dr Evans and I went through it line item by line item to try to find all the errors because there were so many errors in that contract that's why it's a rewrite and not to just renew the current contract because the current contract is not even fair to her

222with the health insurance issue with her not getting the same raises everyone else she took a she took a lower raise this year and what we're doing with her for the vehicle asking her to do all of these things but not providing for her and making sure that she is safe out at night now as far as the thing goes I did ask that it be a six-month piece in there because we've already gone through the part and there's former board members here that were on the board um we it takes six months when Mr Russell left the end of June it took us six months to find a superintend endent so we had to hire an interim superintendent in the meantime and so talk about changes that was a lot of changes for our

223district so as far as I know there's no way to realistically if you're going to do a process to do it in three months and you're asking to do it during one of the most hectic times of the year and so then let's talk about we went with three years because of what had already happened so ideally three years was not smart and if you look there are a few districts with three but most of them give out a contract for four five or six years because there's legislative laws that we have to follow the legislation determines what is cause and what is not cause so the legislation also determines that if you're going to let a superintendent go and it's without cause they get 20 weeks pay we have no choice in that matter

224but the reason why we put in this time is exactly because of where we're at right now when Dr Evans and I were working on it he was going to bring it forth to the board that was seated at that time to share with all of them and I said we already know that one of those board members is not going to be here Mr cologne and I arrived in 2018 to a board that the meeting before we were sworn in they extended the current superintendent's contract that wasn't even up wasn't even close to being up they added an additional two years onto his contract there and he already still had two years so they pushed his contract out to four years so that ideally one term and if we weren't here we'd never have

225a say in what happened there but four years allows the two of you that have currently been seated you will be able to do three complete evaluations on the superintendent so you should know who she is four years also would allow couple things if the three of us two years from now were to run again and all win well then we've already evaluated her at that point for six years um if not and any of us go the people coming in won't be faced with this just like you are right now they'll get at least a full year evaluation done and a half of a year before they would make a decision on whether or not they wanted to extend her contract at that time I will tell you and and U Mr clone you

226were correct on the salary for Oola but I can't remember the number most there is a large percentage of the schools though in Oola that are Charter so they don't fall under the superintendent there see we have very few charter schools in valua County but some of these Counties have at least a third of their um schools are Charter well guess what the school board and the superintendent don't govern Charter Schools but yet those superintendents are making more money than what she's making all we were trying to do in this and all I asked when we finished was that she have it looked at by her own outside Council to ensure that there were no more errors in it but I have to thank him Dr Evans has been a blessing since he walked in

227the door because he is thorough and he is careful and he matches everything to the law this is one of the most easily readable contracts it spells out everything he puts the he quotes the law piece in here if you know what the statute is and so I hear what you're saying but if we wait till March and all of a sudden you know for whatever reason you think you're not going to keep Dr Balaban I will tell you we won't be able to find somebody in three years and as far as the piece that goes with T I mean I mean in three months and as far as the thing goes with teachers I was under the part where teachers earn tenure 2011 we as Vish County didn't change the rules for teachers in

2282011 the legislature changed the law and they made all teachers annual contract other than those that were already tenured and then here's what they did oh well if you want to stay tenured you're going to get less money based on your scores so if you want more money you need to drop your tenure and the sad thing is and and Miss Albert will agree with me we watched a lot of teachers give up their tenure now if you're a great teacher you're going to be fine we're not cutting teachers at the end of the year the teachers that don't make it there is a reason why okay just as if she goes out and commits a felony we're going to release her but we're going to have a cause and we're going to follow what

229the law says so I'm here tonight because we've already been through this and unfortunately the contract you have in front of you that she's working under right now now has been detrimental because there's not a sing the money we're contributing to the insurance plan for every employee she's not been getting the salary we gave everybody else this past year I mean at the start of this school year she didn't get that salary increase because of that Clause that was in there and as I said I find it to be a Safety and Security issue that we would ask ask her to park to get out unlock a gate go in park one car get in another come back out and relock that gate at any given moment when she gets even if she gets a

230phone call in the middle of the night that she has to report somewhere so I'm actually in support of this contract I W I did all my dealings with Dr Evans and then Dr Evans met with her and then she took it to her own attorney because I was just like I don't want there to be any errors I've already lived through the errors and she's she's not asking for anything she's not asking for a she's not asking that she get a different raise than everybody else she's not asking for a bonus and as far as a strategic plan goes every school writes their school Improvement plan which is their strategic plan for the year and it is written by the Committees at the school that are made up of teachers and staff and parents

231and administrators and whether or not they meet those metrics is also towards their grading Point I've actually helped write School Improvement plans but quite frankly if you're going to ask me to write the Strategic plan for the district I don't I have qualifications right plans but I don't have the qualifications nor the access to the data that's why that plan is written by a large group of people and every one of us shared a PE like co-chaired a piece of it to do that so if you're asking me to write that strategic plan I'm your wrong person to ask even though I've written School Improvement plans but my thing tonight is we need to move forward on this we need to vote on this and she needs to know that she is can continue with

232the vision and the mission that we have and continue the work she's doing and our staff needs to know that we have stability here in valusa county and that's where I stand miss brosmer the Practical effect of of what you've just explained to me is that it doesn't matter what our contracts say because we can make up our own terms the contract says March 31st 2025 on or before I understand that but it's March 31st which means we are not compelled to do it tonight and to your point about how surprised you were to be handed a document that you had not seen we are in the same situation we had no input um this was negotiated knowing that there were going to be two new board members and a new board chair who would

233not have an opportunity to lead the discussion or to participate and have any input into it we just got it handed to us and while it satisfies the questions that you had and the concerns that you had we haven't had the same opportunity I'm just asking for even even if we don't put it off until the second meeting in March let's put it off until the first meeting in February but just allow us a little bit of time to have some input and and be able to discuss some of the terms that that we might question we have not been given that opportunity and when this was negotiated you knew we were coming and and so I I think it's fair to us as new board members to have a better sense of the overall

234process this is something that probably should be workshopped not discussed at in a board meeting with a vote hanging over us and that's why I would like to lay this on the table and bring and have another more in-depth conversation about this because the history that produced this document is something that you might know from one perspective but there are other perspectives that probably need to be included too and and so my position is still this is not ripe and we have time to cure it we have time to discuss it if if it is as solid and logical as you describe then wonderful but I don't think that we have had a full opportunity to find out Miss Goodrich um so I am in the same boat as Donna but I did spend the

235last several months um doing a tremendous amount of research on our superintendent and um the job she's done as we heard from the community um our Business Leaders our leaders in our schools Community leaders we have a rockstar amongst us and when you have a rockar if we have a chance to keep her you stole my thunder on the numbers um if we have a chance to keep her at what is a more than reasonable contract and keep her now we don't have to wait until March I don't there I've answered all my questions I've probably harassed Mr Cash way too much with a million and 10 questions as well as our attorney um I've spent hours upon hours the last couple weeks with all my questions I very um confident in the answer I

236think that Dr Balaban has significantly invested her time into this community and I think it's time our community lets her know that she doesn't have to look over her shoulder that we're behind her we see what she's done and we want to keep her we need someone in valisha county and we've needed someone in vucha county for years to unite all of us and to not have the Henry VII Schoolboard situation we have someone right now she's unifying so many different members of our community Community she's phenomenal and I think we would be highly remiss to not tell her we believe that and to do it as soon as we have the chance to Mr cologne so the other the other thing to consider is that currently there are other school districts not far from

237us that are looking for superintendence and so if we want to waste if we want to waste four months giving Dr balabin the chance to go rather than sealing this deal tonight at what is a very very fair it kills me to say that because it's extremely Fair uh amount um then uh we will uh possibly be looking for another superintendent and I wouldn't blame her so with that I'd like to make the motion to approve I'll second it um when we still have um no no we thank you um and miss goodr you still had something that you wanted to say but then we after that we do have six uh public comments thank you and while we're at fsba I had the chance to talk to other school boards and get their feedback

238about superintendence and in the State of Florida everyone is aware that we have a rockstar so I am certain that there are many school boards that would love to have her come join them and I think we need to keep her on ours all right and with that I'm going to call we have six public comments do we have any other cards that have been dropped off okay thank you all right so our first one is going to be Miss Kim short hi everybody I um I'm glad I'm the first one to speak but I will tell you I know there's some other people in this room who are excited to say some things as well I I think what's disappointed me tonight is just the amount of people who feel like somebody's gonna get

239fired who's doing a good job I I don't know where that came from I I wish that rumor wasn't out there um I would be very interested in hearing Dr be's comments because I don't think she intends on leaving and I don't know where anybody wanted to to to fire her came from so I wanted to say that to begin with but I'm a contract person and I'm a numbers person and when I look at this and when I look at the situation I've also been around watching Schoolboard meetings since uh 2012 we've had way too much turnover in this district and I don't think that that's a good thing at all um but while I think that I also want to just say that I don't think that we're setting a good precedent whenever

240we have board members that come into a boardroom and you're given a document and you're supposed to be making decisions on it not when you have some time I don't like that we have a review that wasn't put out there for the public to be able to see I feel like that wasn't transparent I also have never liked that there was no metrics attached to it from the business world that I come in come from um in order for you to get raises there are metrics attached to it I've never liked that I just like when you go around comparing districts or states there is no way to really compare I've done that exercise several times we have different Title One percentages from District to District we've had too much turnover in our district when

241it comes to superintendent or maybe what there's so many things that go into every single District our sizes our our size of of valua is the size of Rhode Island alone you can't you just can't compare but what I do want to say and make clear is that I agree with um Donna I think that what you said tonight was eloquent I do believe that the right thing to do is to wait so that we can understand a little bit more I think that you guys should be going through this contract a little bit more I am very concerned about Dr B's safety when it comes to the car thing personally I think that should be an addendum to a contract immediately that is not acceptable I had no idea I feel stupid that I

242didn't know that um but there's some other things in this contract there's there's a and I don't have it in front of me right now but there's something about you know making sure that you have conversations with with Dr balabin as a board outside you know the the boardroom before you have conversations the thing that concerns me about that is if you were to fire somebody with cause and you have that kind of a a piece in your contract when from the attorney that I spoke to that could actually be used against your terms for cause there's things like that that are in it and so I agree with you Donna I thank you so much for saying what you said next up is Miss Elizabeth Albert followed by Allison root good evening again Madame

243chair members of the board superintendent Dr balabin members of the audience so I want to start by thanking you miss Haynes for explanation answered some of the questions that I have U just a point of clarification if I can sure that I'm understanding exactly what you said I know we're not going to interact but you can nod whatever so just to clarify uh what you said earlier so in the prior contract that Dr balabin was working under and it shouldn't be a surprise that I'm coming to talk about contracts that's what we do right so there needs to be a clarification on the health insurance because if you are reading the solidarity report reports that I'm sending to you in the last three weeks I've written about it twice our every employee who takes our

244health insurance is struggling in this District so to clarify Dr Balaban did not receive any of the district contribution to the medical premium that the other employees received okay noing thank you for clarifying that that was an unknown so when we look at the health insurance offering that is in this contract very reasonable to expect that the board would pick up that cost that would be an expectation that we would have based on my um interactions with the health insurance committee uh the concerns that we have that we're already articulating and again for transparency purposes I requested a meeting and Dr balaman is working to set that up where she and I can talk about some of these concerns and how we get ahead of that for everybody that takes the district health insurance um

245I'm I'm just that $500 additional through me um we there's not a lot of information about what that is for you mentioned vision and dental I don't know if that is what it's for or not but um it was just something that caught my eye that if you're able to expand upon or if there's any way that the rest of the benefit eligible employees who are taking the health insurance could also get a little bit of an extra lift we would like to explore that conversation as well thank you Miss Allison root and then she will be reading for David root so it's been a hot minute since I've been here uh three kids busy schedule um but I think my greatest concern is the superintendent doing a great job that's amazing but if you

246don't have the money don't have the money you can't you can't turn I'm Not Jesus I can't turn wine water into wine f um so we were here in April May and June when we were displacing or maybe it started back in March I'm sure you guys remember we were displacing 200 and some teachers because we didn't have enough money to allocate to kids but now we have enough to allocate to this I mean you add all of these benefit packages up and you're looking at teacher salaries right there um so I'm not saying that she doesn't deserve it what I'm saying is can we afford it um I sat here and watched the presentation on the budget where Mr CE made it quite clear that we had to give money back to the state

247last year because so many students we had put in our budget we would have X amount of students we didn't have that many students enrolled therefore we had to give the money back so and he said that he had guesstimated in hopes that we would have this many students this year but he wasn't sure that would we would get it so if we're not getting the money to make the payment aren't we is going further into the red that we discussed and then my second question is I've been hearing tonight about the past four years since 2020 but it was made quite clear at that time that this was an inherited problem because our superintendent had only been an employee for about a year at that time so is this a one year that it's

248been going or is this a foure because if she was here acting as superintendent in 2020 then when we have when you look at the board meetings from the past it was the Esser funds that were misallocated and used for permanent funding were used and that wasn't her that was something she inherited because she had only been here a year as of April so an 8% increase on a struggling budget that we're in the red so deep with I just find that hard to justify so that's me um those of you that were here in um April May and June Christa and Donna you guys are new to this one um David was very passionate about the budget he actually met with Dr CE about it he came here and met with him and it's

249still you you just can't get it if you don't have it um so he asked because I know he emailed you guys but I don't I don't believe Mr cologne's gonna read it so I'm gonna read it on his behalf um this is on behalf of David my name is David root and I'm a student at Deltona High School so this will be my second one by the way um and I'm a student at Deltona High School if possible I would like sorry I don't have my readers if possible I would like if this email were read into public participation on my behalf I have not been able to attend any meetings since nearly 300 teachers were displaced due to my busy schedule but I have been trying my best to stay informed about what

250has been going on it has been a while since this summer when I spoke about how the displacements would affect me so I would like to update you all on how this year has gone so far every day I walk into my choir class and I feel as though I'm watching my aspirations to become a choir director crash and burn the current director just simply can't teach or Inspire any of the students in her class the plan to displace teachers and have teachers who are qualified to teach multiple classes teach different subjects seems like a great idea to save money in the budget however then we have teachers like my choir director who teaches and creates lessons plans for math which alone is a full-time job teaches choir which again is a full-time job assists

251in coaching girls weightlifting girls soccer and track and teach all the music for the school's play while also getting her Masters she does not have the means of teaching the chir leaving it to me to attempt to teach the and Inspire these kids every day I go to class and teach instead of learning in this time of my life where I should be learning I spend everyday teaching since I am the most knowledgeable and singing and music theory because our school cannot afford to pay a full-time choir director but I'm glad that in the renewal of the superintendent's contract she is getting pay raises and added benefits to anyone listening with the right to vote please take note of who votes for approval of this content as well as every other motion into consideration when

252deciding who makes the decisions for teachers and students thank you all right next up is Bob Fitz Simmons um I'll try to keep it real short I I just want to give a little bio on me I'm a blch County resident for 40 years I'm past president of the Belia building industry Association and I uh have four children who graduated from the land high and I currently have five grandchildren in the valou County School System so so I definitely have a stake here um I really have no comment Dr B about your performance uh you know about your salary because I haven't done the research I don't know um I've been on and off at front of this board over the years but I kind of got caught off guard I'm very much in line

253with what Mrs uh um what um what Mrs short said which is as a businessman as a contractor as somebody who reviews contracts on a regular basis to not have the opportunity as a board to go through that I think is a Justice to the board members who have just shown up so Mr Colin you know had a lot of good information I listened very you know intently but I need to look at that and I think I were one of the new board members or a board member that wasn't part of that I would want to see a all that data so that I could come to an educated decision on the matter so again I don't really see the harm uh or you know problem that postponing for 30 days or 60 days

254presents um I reviewed the contract as well uh yeah March is the date you usually look at it but this contract that Dr B is currently under is good until June 30 so anyway that's really all I have to say I don't want to eat up a bunch of time uh but I don't I I I guess the the thing that puzzled me is what is the compelling reason for jumping so far out in front and I haven't figured that out yet I've heard different stories but nothing makes sense to me yet to Jump Ahead like that and not give the full board the benefit of reviewing everything that uh you know Mr Colin did thank you and our last card is for VCS principles Alicia Douglas Shannon hay and Jessica aases good evening um

255Madam chair Madam Vice chair superintendent and board members my colleagues and I are here to support Dr Balman Jessica visis Stark Elementary Joy Boyd Walker T Elementary we have Shannon hay Orman Beach Elementary Jen Williams Citrus Grove Elementary I'm at manity Cove Elementary and we had Lee pro cop here from Beachside but her son was sick so she apologizes but she had to go home be a mom um throughout our time in Belia County Schools we've worked under many superintendents and we've grown together as a team many of us consider each other family Dr balgan has brought much needed stability to our group during challenging times such as covid the pandemic the implementation of higher academic expectations s and the effort to showcase our schools she has consistently supported us as leaders in every way

256possible Dr balaman Fosters an environment of openness with listen and learn sessions and is always receptive to Innovative strategies for supporting both students and staff Dr balaman leads a team of District level leaders who understand that their that her vision and philosophy are to work alongside of us as thought partners with an all Hands-On deck approach in a time when teacher retention is a nationwide challenge Dr balabin has made Recruitment and Retention a priority her focus on creating a supportive collaborative environment has been crucial in helping to retain dedicated Educators we are on our way to achieving an a rating and we recognize that the change of superintendence can be traumatic traumatic for all involved it takes time for a new leader to get to know our systems our policies our procedures and our staff

257belusa County Prides itself on teamwork and we work the Strategic plan with a clear understanding of our individual roles in empowering a culture of Excellence we look forward to Dr Balaban bringing a positive word and uplifting message during our monthly principal meeting we deeply appreciate her caring Spirit guidance and ongoing support both personally and professionally we believe her consistency wisdom and leadership are all essential for our continued success so we are here to support you Dr balabin we believe in you and thank you for what you do thank you so those are all the public comments do we have a motion to you have a motion in a second okay your is on the table all right and it was seconded I seconded okay is there any further discussion from the board all right all

258those in favor can I just address something yes you can yeah so I hear I hear the concern of it being so quick to the new board members and so I do want to address that I would normally say yeah let's take a little bit more time there's external issues um that exist that I think we've touched on tonight that I think we um would put ourselves in Jeopardy of not providing our children with the best possible superintendent we could have and so that's why I spent so much time researching and getting as much data as I could to make the best decision I could tonight and so for that reason that's why I feel like it's been a quick thing any further discussion all right all those in favor of approving our superintendent's contract

259say I I I I any opposed no all right it motion moves forward four to [Applause] one because we're still in this meeting moving on to 20.01 public participation do we have any more public comment cards on items of general interest pertaining to public education in vucha County no we do not all right and so now we are moving on to I just want to again commend you for the work you've done and I believe you're going to leave a legacy in valou County so let's keep the Train Running thank you thank you very much Mr cologne so we have an elephant in the room that I think we need to address and wish everybody else would have lit up the board before my name came up but it's it's the comments that were made

260from our chair and so I am interested to hear our board chair's thoughts on those comments if she's prepared to if not then uh and so I'll yield if you are prepared thank you Mr cologne and so I had thought about this um prior to this board meeting today um and I I do love what Dana mcol said and that was to go to all the different schools and I really do plan to do that I'm sorry for the words that I said because I chose those words poorly I do sincerely believe that all of our students deserve the best education every single one and so I am looking forward to working with our superintendent because I know she as well believes that our students are made for greatness and they can absolutely get there

261I am sorry to the board that I sit with that my words caused you sadness and anger and this was a growing moment for me and I know we've all gone through that and so thank you for bringing it up Mr cologne I know these words it's going to take time um but moving forward I think that we will be a stronger better board and I will always be focused on putting our students first and making sure that they get the best possible education because they really are the reason that I'm here so thank you Lord I think we you know one of the Privileges that we have is to elect our chair and that person speaks for all of us that person doesn't have any more power than any one of us our votes

262all count as one we come here with five different walks of life we come here with five different um [Music] perspectives as we saw a few minutes ago sometimes you win sometimes you don't but that's why there's five of us and um I I think that you know we we elect our chair and I made the motion very proudly very proudly and I think for the sake of our students for the sake of of our district for the sake of our stability for the sake even of yourself Miss Thompson and we had this discussion you know I I I think that we need to reconsider who is going to be the face of this board and I don't think any of us there's none of us here that were not affected by those words and

263I appreciate your acknowledgement and so um I want to make the motion that we reconsider agenda item from the organizational meeting and put that on the next agenda for discussion um that will give everybody time to think reconsider it'll give time for us to understand I I don't think that folks have shared you know how they truly feel I think there's still a lot of restraint I can tell you there's a lot of folks who I realizing that the superintendent contract was the most important thing on our agenda today I really had several folks uh who truly I I I kindly asked them guys let's not let's focus on what's important and I want to thank everyone who who heeded that because there was a lot of restraint and and and and and I believe

264the apology to be true I really truly do but again you know can this person rightfully be the voice of all of us when we're not there and and you know I've already shared with M Miss Thompson that those words were very hurtful not because of me we're big people we can handle it we're politicians people say whatever they want to say we're get used to that but when it when it affects our kids when when comments are made to disparage our children that crosses over into a different world and again I accept your apology sincerely um and so I think uh I I want to make the motion that we reconsider that agenda item uh that was in our organizational meeting being on the prevailing side I have the ability to do that and

265so um and that'll give us time to process and and figure out as a board how we want to move forward so that's my motion I'll second all right well then we will add this on to the next board meeting thank you Mr colon have to vote on it all those in favor say I I any opposed it's unanimous Dr balabin so before we conclude tonight I just want to extend my gratitude to this board thank you so very much for your belief your trust and uh to all of our community members to our building leaders to our district leaders to our students to our parents the work that we have accomplished in the past few years has been something truly amazing and it's not just because of my leadership but it's because of your

266dedication to our vision and if there's one thing I clearly know and the reason why I am committed to this District it's because I believe in its people I believe in our community members in our partners in our parents and our students and that is the reason why I have enlisted to work in this field because I'm one of those individuals that I'm truly committed I believe in what I do and I think that speaks for itself but I could not have done this job so far without each and every one of you you're your steadfast support for what we do on a daily basis so I want to thank you I want to thank you for again for this belief and I know that in the upcoming years you're absolutely right there's so much

267more to accomplish and our goal here is to ensure that valua County continues and remains one of the top in the nation so again thank you for your belief in me but most importantly thank you to each and every one of you because I couldn't have done this without you so thank you all right we will meet again on Tuesday January 14th for a workshop work session and regular session it is 9:09 p.m. and this meeting is adjourned and I'm going to

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.