CorpusRecord 1925

Volusia County School Board - The Volusia County School Workshop⧸Work Session 02⧸11⧸2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Volusia County School Board
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Volusia County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,147 words · about 85 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e don't send anyone for me oh don't good afternoon welcome to the belush County School Board Workshop today is February the 11th 2025 the time now is 12:34 p.m. in just a moment I'm going to ask that you stand with me for the Pledge of Allegiance followed by a Moment of silence and reflection so at this time will you please stand I pledge alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you may be seated here today with me on my far left we have Mrs Donna brosmer representing District 4 Mrs Christa Goodridge representing District 2 Dr Gilbert Evans our Schoolboard attorney moving over to my far right we have Miss Celeste

002Gilmore our agency clerk Mrs Jesse Thompson representing District 3 Mr Ruben clone our vice chair representing District 5 Dr Carmen balabin our superintendent and I'm Jamie Haynes representing district one we have three items today on the agenda for the workshop the first item is item 2.01 exceptional student education Dr balabin thank you madam chair at this time I would like to ask Miss Jack whis copelan our executive director for exceptional student education and I think she's got some team members here couple things I wanted to share with with the board and those of you who are listening um or joining us as we all know that our district is successfully so far managing a doj settlement agreement so I have to give kudos to this team because not only are we managing a doj settlement

003agreement but in addition to that we are looking at our work that we're doing in es and we are working in putting that structure in place for a full Continuum of services so they will be sharing with you some of what that inner working is is all about as we are looking at that full Continuum of services and then the team will answer any questions that you may have Miss Copeland please introduce I think you have a few members from your team here yes I do good afternoon chair haes Schoolboard members and superintendent Dr balabin so here I have with me my assistant director Casey lamb and then in the audience I have all of my ESC coordinators so I'm going to introduce them one at a time so please stand we have Lita gillo

004who's a coordinator of Elementary Stephanie degia who is over our access and low incidence programs we have Sue Hopkins who is over secondary we have Kathy galotti who's over transition and Tom Allard who takes care of our VR Grant and behind Tom is Dr spidel Who is in charge of related service services and also reporting thank you I want to thank you all for this opportunity this afternoon to speak with you about an update on exceptional student education in valua County Schools our presentation supports policy 303 which governs special programs and procedures for exceptional students we will focus on guardrails 2 and three during this presentation today I will provide you with with an overview of ESC programs key initiatives compliance updates and our next steps in ensuring that every exceptional student in our district

005Rees the support they need to succeed we want to start off this afternoon by highlighting the annual ESC Family Conference that took place on Saturday February 1st we have a short video to highlight that conference for you this afternoon this event connects our families and district with Community Resources to help support their child's educational Journey we had over 400 registered attendees 45 Community agencies that attended and over 50 VCS employees that volunteered to support the family [Music] conference you know we want to make sure that not only are we setting those strong gos but we believe that we have to maximize the potential of each and every student we have to have people who have strength that they can trust we have mutual respect for the work and that we are doing this together because

006it's not the school alone it's not the families alone but it's us jointly working together to ensure the success of all students in [Music] Bal Jake is happy to find people that he knows from his adventures here um but it's been helpful and great to just talk to faces rather than [Music] online well to begin with this um type of resources that you offer is within the school system and where do do you have more opportunity to serve a family that within the school you have every one of the different agencies and the different um um providers then in this one [Music] place so thank you it was an amazing Saturday and we look forward to continuing this practice so as we get in the presentation today we're going to start with Ida the individuals

007with disabilities education act as a reminder our work in ESC is grounded in the individuals with disabilities Education Act it is a federal law that ensures all students with disabilities receive the services and supports necessary to access the general education curriculum idea stands on six key principles of free appropriate education appropriate evaluations individualized education plans leas restrictive environments parent and student participation in decision-making and procedural safeguards these principles ensure that we address the unique educational needs of every student and empowering them to engage in high levels of learning ex excuse me I'm sorry to interrupt I I have a lot of questions and and they tend to be kind of slid specific so I just want to know if I should ask them per slide or do you want me to wait until the end

008I think at the end the end okay thank you so this slide highlights our um Ida funding that valua County Schools receives and it's broken up into four categories Personnel professional learning community- based instruction and student supplies and so Personnel is our support prer support prer professionals bus assistants program Specialists ESC assistant principles are some of the Personnel that are covered through our Ida funding to support student needs our professional learning that we've taken place this year are non-violent crisis training bouncy dog which is a K2 separate class self-regulation training and managing the cycles of acting now community- based instruction is the Hands-On approach that we take with ESC students into to the community to practice life vocational and social skills in real world settings it helps our students develop life skills vocational skills social

009and communication skills and independent living skills student supplies include mobility and Equipment sensory items communication devices and applications as we continue to work we will continue to make sure that our resources maximize the impact on our student learning as Dr balabin mentioned at the beginning the district is under a Department of Justice settlement Bia County entered into the settlement agreement with the Department of Justice based on an ADA an American with Disabilities Act complaint that was filed in 2018 the settlement continues in through August of 2026 and there are key areas that we work to continue to grow strong in that is limiting the number of suspensions for our students with disabilities addressing Ada comp complaints promptly providing ongoing training for our staff in relation to ESC compliance reducing the number of law enforcement involvement

010with our students with disabilities and monitoring our classroom removals and behavior interventions by implementing these measures we have seen great Improvement in ensuring equality and also legal compliance with all of our ESC students education modified is a technology platform that we use in ESC and it has been a tremendous help so to enhance our compliance and streamline tracking of services provided to students we have implemented education modified it is a research-based educational technology platform last year in the 2324 school year we piloted across the district we have been able to provide ongoing professional learning to teachers this school year and we will continue to do so as we grow in the usage of this platform this platform enables teachers general education and ESC teachers to acknowledge IEPs within the system track student accommodations and goals

011as I as highlighted in their IEPs and it also allows our ESC separate class students to maintain lesson plans along with our support Prof support pair professionals keep their logs for daily work with students inside of the platform so I know there's a lot of numbers on this next slide but I just want to highlight a few things for you this shows our usage from inception until date and what this does is it highlights every single form that we use in the platform not every teacher uses every form but I did want to highlight the IEP acknowledgement form this is a form that is used at the beginning of the year when we acknowledge IEPs so you're going to see the trend of those numbers go down and we want them to go down because

012we only acknowledge IEPs again when there is a change in service I also would like for you to take note that we've at this current school year we've had almost three million submissions and we're very excited about the tracking of student accommodations the accommodation tracking form has a 1.5 million submissions this was an area of growth for us identified in the doj settlement and we have also received acknowledgement from the Department of Education in Florida of what a great new tool this is and how our documentation is a lot more clear and understandable as we present it to the state so the next FL few slides will take you through the usage by month so we have total submissions by month and we have accommodations tracking by month accommodations tracking is done by all teachers

013in all settings for students the next slide shows you support facilitation logs and consultation log submission support facilitation logs are completed by ESC teachers that push into the general education classroom to support students consultation logs are completed by ESC teachers working with the general education teacher to support student learning this slide shows you all separate class lesson plan submissions and Paras support log submissions the separate class lesson plan submissions are completed by ESC teachers ser serving students in a separate class setting par professional logs are submitted weekly by our support prepare support par professionals by leveraging this technology we are approving efficiency and ensuring that every student's IEP is properly executed we have been able to reduce paperwork for ESC teachers we've also like I said before been able to receive positive accolades from doe

014the next couple slides will take you through our Valia County ESC quarterly audits this is a very proactive process that was started here in Valia County and we take this process to conduct quarterly internal audits on each school so our process is that we randomly select two students from each School each quarter schools are given the names of those students and they must submit all documentation related to IEP services that are being provided schools receive an ESC report card at the conclusion of the audit of giving a score of between one and 10 one being low 10 being great so with evaluating compliance each quarter miss Lamb and I meet with each principal and assistant principal to go over their ESC report card and see if there's any additional support that we can give them

015the next slide shows you an example of what a report card looks like so this is a perfect 10 report card that was given to a school this nine weeks each each school is scored in six different areas the first area at the top left is the state audit that is when we take a kid's IEP services and compare it to the docu documentation we receive for the school tracking those Services the next one is discipline we look at discipline in two different ways we look at the number of students that have been suspended for five or more days and schools must have IEP meetings or suspension review meetings in order to document that they are talking about the student make sure we have the right supports in place for that student so they gain

016points for making sure that their documentation and that their meetings have taken place the next part of discipline is the discipline comparison where we compare the total number of referrals to the number of referrals that are received by ESC students and so in that discipline comparison we want to make sure that we're not disproportionate and that we're continuing to reduce the number number of referrals received by ESC students related to their total School population number three is LR lease restrictive environment for lease restrictive environment we look at the students that are zoned for that school not students that schools receive because of program and or variances so we look at two areas we look at our regular class and we look at our separate class and we want to make sure that our regular class

017numbers continue to increase and that our separate class numbers continue to decrease and or stay the same that's how schools earn those points and then if you go back up to the top on the rightand side we always take a look at IEPs and EPS for our gifted students that are out of date so when we pull this report we're making sure that the meetings have taken place within the time frame and also that the event has been locked in focus and that qualifies it as an indate IEP or EP and so schools get credit for making sure that they keep timelines um ready for IEPs and EPs and the next one is teams feedback and monitoring that is when our program our district program Specialists go out to support schools so we need to

018keep that two-way communication going so we track that in Microsoft teams so the district program specialist goes out to support a school whether it's an ASD program or a ve mild program and they document not only what they've done but also give actionable steps for their work and the schools so it's the school's responsibility to go into that same Excel sheet and comment and let us know what they've done what they're working on what they still need support in so if that's kept up to date then the School receives points for that the last area that schools get points for is called transition and so this is when we're looking at our transition assessments for students as they matriculate we start at 12 years old so elementary students do receive the transition assessments where we

019talk talk about what you want to do when you grow up and things like that and so the one area that I do want you to note is legal that is not an area that's scored for a school that is a point of information we make sure all schools know and understand the students on their campus that are represented by legal counsel and or an advocate so when schools receive their score and additional comments like I said Miss lamb and I meet with each of them individually and we go over their report card whether they got a perfect 10 or not we want to make sure that we're supporting all schools in relation to compliance so these audits help us to identify strengths areas of improvement ensure compliance across the district our use of Education

020modified has helped schools to improve their scores with the ability to track and pull student data electronically I do want to point out that my collaboration with the elementary and secondary executive directors have been an intrical moving part of making sure this work continues to move forward the next slide highlights our current range of ESC Service delivery models from least restrictive to most restrictive environments ensuring that students receive the appropriate level of support the graphic here represents our current Continuum of services the general education options in golden yellow on the screen our regular class placement where students spend between 80 to 100% of their time time with their non-disabled peers the resource placement in yellow is where students spend 40 to 79% of their school week with their non-disabled peers support services offered at these

021levels is consultation support facilitation co- te and therapies including occupational physical speech and language our support facilitation model is where ESC teacher collaborates with a general education teacher to provide strategy accommodations and modifications to support the student in a general education classroom the ESC teacher not doesn't necessarily directly instruct a student but instead offers guidance and expertise to help the general education teacher meet the student needs consultation in this model an ESC teacher works with the general education teacher to provide advice resources strategies for supporting the student the ESD teacher may not directly interact with the student but offer suggestion on how to modify curriculum classroom environment or teaching strategies to meet the individual needs of that student the goal of this model is that the Jour education teacher has the support and tools necessary

022to effectively include the student in the classro next is cod teaching in this model the esa teacher and journal education teacher work together in the same classroom to instruct students including those with disabilities both teachers share the responsibility of planning teaching and assessing students co- teing allows for a differentiated instruction helping students to succeed in an inclusive setting the section in blue highlights our separate class options we have a separate class placement where students spend less than 40% of their school week with their non-disabled peers we off also offer therapy in this setting this may be in small group or individual our current separate class settings are our ASD autism spectrum disorder class our EBD emotional Behavior disability class our modified class for students with intellectual disabilities and I able our intensive academic Behavior learning

023environment we also have multivariant exceptionalities our multi and Mild varing exceptionalities mild ve our ASD class is designed for students with ASD who may have challenges with communication social interactions and behavior regulation this class provides a structured learning environment visual supports and social skills training our EBD class supports significant emotional and behavior challenges that impact a students abilities to succeed in the general education classroom their structured routines behavioral interventions and social skills learning the goal of this class is to help children learn to regulate their behavior avors to transition back into a least restrictive environment if possible next is our modified class this class is for students with intellectual disabilities designed for students who have significant cognitive impairments and need a regularly High structured environment the students need modified curriculum so that they can focus

024on functional academics life skills and adaptive Behavior also we have iable iable is our intensive academic behavioral learning environment this instruction is based on the students's IEP it's a smaller class size with intensive Behavior Support a structured learning environment social skills training and so the purpose of the iable classroom is to provide an intensive academic behavioral support for students who need a structured and therapeutic environment we have multi ve which is our multivariant exceptionalities and this students with multiple disabilities that affect their academic communication and adaptive functioning this class is highly specialized based on the combination of the students needs and students often have a blend of academic instruction therapy and assisted technology in this classroom and lastly in the blue section our separate class section is our mild ve mild varing exceptionalities this supports

025students with mild disabilities including learning language impairments or mild intellectual disabilities these students do follow our standard curriculum but need additional academic or behavioral support so the goal is to develop these student skills to be successfully integrated into the general education classroom and the last section is green are other separate environments and so this is Hospital homebound this is off campus instruction separate schools or residential placement for students who have more intense support who need more intense support outside of the Traditional School setting the next slide you will see is our enhanced ESC Service delivery models this is what we're looking to help support and increase and provide the support students need these delivery model enhancements will increase access to ESC Services across all schools our work in enhancing our service delivery models have been

026collaborative with teachers administrators in vucha county and we've also worked with our neighboring districts as well there are four enhancements on this graphic that are highlighted in yellow that I would like to speak with you about today there's also one in blue the one in blue is our intensive class this is currently our multi classroom and so this one is just a language change so that we can match the language of the state the four hi highlighted in yellow first one is a Behavior Support teacher a Behavior Support teacher provides instruction and support to students in grades K12 who develop monly adverse behaviors that interfere with learning and need specially designed instruction in social skills and social communication these students participate in the general education classroom but need more support in social emotional learning to

027navigate and generalize these skills the next one is the ESC support class the ESC support class is a model 4K 12 that is that is needed for a small group classroom setting for SDI our specially designed instruction because they are at least two years below grade level standards for specific subjects such as math Ela science or social studies it could also include independent functioning social and organizational skills this class is for students that need adjustment to instruction to vary at the pace and depth of learning the ESC support class is not a self contained environment the next one is the ESC separate class this model supports for students in grades K12 with cognitive deficits resulting in global deficiencies in the following curriculum and learning social and emotional independent functioning and communication and there also may

028be a need for Health Care needs and lastly in the most restrictive environment would be the ASD indd intensive Behavior class this model is support for students in K12 with significant cognitive and Global deficits that have severe intensive behavioral needs resulting in severe physical aggression so as we have been taking a look at where we need to move forward we have been reviewing our current models we have been evaluating program placement for Effectiveness we have been looking at the geographical needs to reduce student travel we've also been aligning the IEP goals for individualized support the enhancements to our ESC Service delivery Continuum will be a phase in approach over the next couple of years we will continue to work with collaborative Partners within our district outside of our district and especially our VCS teachers administrators

029and parents as we move forward one exciting group is our ESC advisor committee our ESC advisory committee is truly the strength of our department we are committed to collaborating with families Educators and community members this group meets monthly to discuss ESC related concerns and improvements their perspective is very vital to our work this community includes parents Educators and Community stakeholders they provide recommendations for service enhancements they also play a crucial role in supporting our students because by working together we know that we can continue to enhance the educational outcomes for all students so as we move forward we continue to focus on expanding teacher training and professional learning strengthening parent engagement through workshops and resources continuing compliance monitoring to ensure quality ESC Service delivery in closing we remain committed to ensuring every exceptional student in

030Bia County receives the support they need to Thrive thank you for your time and I welcome any questions Andor discussion thank you Mrs brire would you like to go first okay uh it was good to hear the presentation first because it did answer some of my questions um so I appreciate that and it's nice to see you I I want you to know how much I enjoyed and appreciated the um the es Family Conference and event um it was really helpful because the this is a a new area for me it was really helpful to be able to speak to a lot of the service providers too um and and learn from them um so I'm G to kind of go through these slides and I had made notes of questions and I'll see what

031I still have left um on the my first one is on the idea um slide I I just wondered how we Define appropriate public education I I don't appropriate tends to be kind of a loose Loosely defined word so I just wondered how we structure it are you talking about fape um the first one I don't know what the slide number is it's it's the but the principles on it uh yes it's the the number one the of the six principles yes free appropriate public education I was just curious to know how I guess it's the government uh defines appropriate yes we and we have lots of guidelines and procedures that we follow through idea and part of the free appropriate education is making sure that we are using our IEP teams and data to

032guide our decisions that is not in isolation that is a collaborative effort okay um thank you um who is our behavioral consultant Dr Ben [Music] Springer I'm sorry Springer yes okay I was just curious to know who that is I don't think I've met him and what exactly does he do so Dr Brin spinger role was a part of the Department of Justice settlement so he meets actually in our last round of audits he met with all principles along with Casey and I to specifically go over their discipline data he also a principal can email questions concerns we do schedule visits with him to physically come to valua to help support certain schools or high need situations in terms of behavior okay thank you um what kind of what kind of feedback are you getting

033from teachers who are using the um education modified system I I recall that it's relatively new are are you getting good participation from that yes we are we are getting great participation from it and teachers have been very vocal we've been able to listen and we already have a list of changes for next year that is going to make their world even a little bit better so what we've been doing this year is making sure that as we've rolled out the full implementation across the district in every classroom with every teacher that we continue to listen because once it gets into the hands of our teachers the end user we want to make sure that we continue to listen so we can continue to make improvements and so just just to give you an idea

034of a simple Improvement right now when a teacher clicks for an accommodation there's a drop down box and so instead of having the drop- down box next year the um accommodation is just going to be there for them The Click so just that little quick instead of taking 10 seconds to click a drop down box they're right there in front of you and you can just click on the ones that the child has used for the day so those are the improvements that we're continueing to modify the program well that sounds that sounds useful um what is a compliance audit I think you touched on that um so the IEP is annual but the compliance audits are quarterly yes so this is a proactive measure that vucha county has taken to ensure that we meet

035our compliance standard and so at every quarter each school is given two names of students randomly they don't know who those kids are they don't know what program that they are being served in pop test it's a pop yep and so then what they're required to do is to provide the service logs for that student and the service logs for any related services such as speee otpt and then my team along with District placement Specialists um take a look at each school we have a calendar that we use and a very methodical way that we use to make sure that the IEP and the documentation match and so after that that's where I'm explaining the report card schools then receive an ESC report card which miss Lamb and I review with each team individually is

036the report card sort of a universal way to do this uh this kind of a random question just occurred to me um is this something that is unique to VCS or is it related to the doj settlement or um where does the report card fit in it is unique to VCS it is homegrown right here in Valia County and but it was based on the feedback that we received from not only the DJ settlement but also from State complaints okay um thank you I think my last questions are are all kind of inter related and they have to do with um the the what I realize is a very complex situation with violent students um we had a report last week of of a teacher who was having to deal with a a student with

03780 felonies um that uh that kind of um and and teachers who are being assaulted physically assaulted by their um by their students I'm curious to know how we handle ese students who behave that way compared to how we handle gened students who behave that way um because I understand the doj settlement requires fewer discipline referrals but there's a real risk especially when when maybe the the IEP is related to um they're gifted or you know they're they're high functioning but they're violent so how do we how do we accommodate both of those needs because the teachers need to feel safe too yes 100% And so one of the pieces of the IEP if we have a student that is demonstrating abnormal behaviors or aggressive behaviors it's called the behavior intervention plan and so that

038is a plan that is created within the school and the IEP team to identify what the behaviors are what are the root causes of the behaviors and what are the interventions we need to put in place for that student so that we can decrease those behaviors and so uh behavior intervention plans are reviewed by teams on a regular basis and sometimes they do change frequently depending on the level of behavior or the change in Behavior we also have crisis plans that are developed within the IEP if it's something that a behavior that we may not see often but it is an escalated behavior that we need to implement a crisis plan for uh two things um I'd like to know where High Banks and Riverview fit with any of these programs uh since they are

039alternative schools and um and what was my other question well let's start with that one because I forgot the other one for the for so in terms of high Banks and Riverview that is where our I able program is house so that's our most intensive Behavior program that has a therapeutic component to it that children receive at high Banks and Riverview okay and now I remember my other question between the academics and the behavior um reports or needs um you'll have to forgive me I I kind of mentally default back to The Miracle Worker where Annie Sullivan had to control Helen Keller's behaviors before she could teach her anything so I'm curious to know if there's a priority that's given to to those two when they may conflict um which one gets attention first well

040we always want to make sure that we work with the child's Behavior because we know if they're not behaving appropriate or regulated then learning cannot take place so the behavior is the priority okay I'm I'm very glad to know that um and and just going back to one of my other questions um how how does how we handle the um ESC students who may be violent um compared to how we handle the Gen ed students and that may not even be a question you can answer because that might be a gen Ed question I don't know well just in terms of the differences we have to look at for the ESC student the exceptionality and we have to ensure that the behavior is not a manifestation of that exceptionality okay if you have if you

041have a high function um student whose IEP is not related to behavior but who whose IEP is not related to behavior but who is violent then what do you do that's a very general question and I know I'm sorry so that's not a question that I can answer without a specific situation but I'd be more than happy to speak with you about that if there's a specific situation if I if I come up with a specific I'll ask you thank you okay thanks for all of this thank you all right I'm moving on Mr cologne so thank you last week we had the opportunity to meet and go over many of my concerns first of all I want to congratulate you and your team on the work that you have done to support not only

042our ESC teachers but are all of our teachers who earlier in the year expressed or have for years uh lots of concerns especially as it relates to the documentation and I mean arguably I knock on wood it's been a minute since uh we've heard so obviously it's working because if it wasn't we would know um so again I want to thank you I I saw the numbers fored modified and and the use and it seems like we're finally getting into a groove of things and and and I'm grateful for that um I look forward to hearing more about the changes you're proposing as I discussed with you in our meeting and ensuring that we have the support that we need you know it's easy to put things on paper but you want to make sure

043we also have the people to uh roll these things out uh in a methodical way um and and what I shared with them was I'd rather move slower and do it completely than to roll it out poof and you know Big Bang and you don't really have enough folks to support that so um I think we've come along way and I'm uh feeling good and that we're headed in the right direction uh and I'm I'm also grateful Dr B of you and your team in recognizing that we need to expand the Continuum of services that we have here um you know kids are evolving and they younger and younger becoming more uh I'll just say it this way there's more opportunities and so uh by us being able to offer those Services here in Valia

044County rather than uh outside of Valia County which is the right thing to do for kids um that will also allow us to expand that so I look forward to seeing us do that as well because again that whole Continuum of services is important the one thing I I didn't hear you elaborate on was um and I think there'd be a benefit to everyone is the services that we offer at elementary that aren't offered in middle school that are not offered in high school that don't really match uh if you could at a high level expl because that was really fast uh what what is it that we're looking to do so that those Services go across the Spectrum and are offered all the way across and if you can also include uh if there's

045anything in the game plan with gifted I know gifted in elementary is gifted it's a it's a big deal Middle School it kind of you know becomes a little bit harder not quite as pronounced I guess I'll say that in high school I think it's all does it all just blend into AP and Ace and all of that or or how does that work or do are we looking at any changes for that so just that Continuum what will that look like yes so currently we have um a co- te model that is in the secondary level but not in elementary school and we have a modified model co- te co- te is when we have a general education teacher and an ESC teacher working together in the same classroom planning giving assessments together collectively

046so we have that in middle school but not in elementary that is correct is that in high school as well yes okay and then also our modified classroom is at the secondary level in middle and high school and those for our students that are intellectually um disabled but it is not in elementary school currently we are using ve mild and multi for those students so our ve mild self-contained classroom I got you are our varying exceptionality students with mild disabilities and then our multi are students who have multiple disabilities in the same room that have some cognitive Global deficits so we do not have a modified option right now for the access curriculum in elementary if you don't mind share a little bit in terms of moving to that full Continuum right I think a

047a big adjustment to the the program or the model is what we're looking into doing next year which is to separate cognitive from Behavior you want to expand a little bit on that yes ma'am so so one thing that miss brosme you brought up is the behavior versus the academic and one thing we've seen especially in elementary and our current V mild model is that we have cognitive and behavior in the same classroom and it's hard to meet the needs and so we really need to make sure we're being clear and succinct when we're placing students and so that we are giving them those supports and so that's why you heard me bring up the ESC um support class because that is a class that if you have cognitive issues you can go to for

048the issue say it's math that you're having but then be back in the general education classroom and then the uh Behavior Support teacher can support that student who may be having adverse behaviors in the general education classroom because our goal is least restrict least restrictive environment that LR but we have to make sure that we have the proper supports for students in any environment that they're in in valua so translation and correct me if I'm wrong so we've got at times and I've seen this where there is a class with several students of varying exceptionalities and one students behaviors are way over here and then there are students who are over here and these kids are not learning because we're chasing this kid around all day long to keep him safe I'm being proper here

049to keep him safe and so that detracts from the ones that have the ability some times that don't have the behaviors from them being able to learn to what you're saying is we're going to sort of figure that part out and separated so that we can focus on the learning of this one and not be distracted by the behaviors of correct so that that student who's having the behaviors can be in a supportive environment to support the behaviors and then get to the academics where we have other students as you described who just need that academic support gotcha thank you you're welcome Mrs goodr first of all thank you I'm very sorry that I missed it um the event on last Saturday I was out of town as you know and you know how important

050this is to me so thank you for all that you're doing thank you to all of you for all that you're doing and to all the ESC staff out there listening and students thanks for being exceptionally awesome um can you and I know we went over this already but can you just quickly give a synopsis of what graduation looks like for some of our exceptional students because I know it's a little bit different of a pathway and for some of the general ed students so just to let people know that maybe didn't hear the presentation last time yes and I'm actually going to bring up Kathy galotti if Dr balam if you don't mind to go over deferment absolutely good afternoon everybody I'm going to go over diment any student with an IEP has the

051option to defer receipt of their diploma that means that they can graduate march with the class but they can come back for services that we Supply here in valua County so we encourage all students who do not have a path meaning they're not going in the military they don't have employment they're not going to college to return as a valua County student um the diploma stays at the school once you receive your diploma you're not eligible for services in any public school but we encourage them to come back back and then we have very we have a lot of options that they could go through of course if they're working on dual enrollment they can continue that if they're working on Merit and Scholar they can continue to earn that certification we have employment advisers

052in valua County they have been working with me for probably 25 years they're excellent and they help the students individually gain employment out in the community they'll maintain status with them until they're secured on that job and then they slowly fade away so we have students working at Publix Stetson throughout our community um we also have our um they can come back for community-based vocational training where each school goes to a site out in the community to learn the skills that they need for employment um once they go through that they may end up going in one of our three project search programs that we have at Halifax Hospital that's for a student usually in their last year uh with valua County Schools we have a teacher of ESC teacher there and we have a

053employment advisor they have one hour of instruction in the morning vocational skills working on how to interview resumés how the social skills that kind of interaction and then they go through 10 nine week uh 10 week uh rotations there's three of them at the hospital so they're actually doing a job at the hospital they be may be a medical record Clerk they're working in dietary we have students working in the ER um throughout the hospital so they'll go through those rotations the three of them and at the end of the school year we place them into employment either at the hospital or out in the community so we have a lot of different opportunities for our students we encourage them all to come back because we don't want a student going through 12 years of

054high school exiting and not having a plan to be successful so we have a lot of different options we do work with the schoolway cafe to employ students within Bia County Schools we work with the custodial staff to place them in custodial and we also um have the spot program where they work with the facilities in maintenance so instead of going to school again they go to one of the maintenance Hub they follow the crew out to each site and then at the end of that school year hopefully they're employed as as a valuch county um employee I was going to say student sorry and so is their curriculum to get them to graduate different than Jen Ed and are they being afforded the opportunities to get a lot of life skills well um any

055student can defer so you could be on the Gen Ed path and defer or you could be on the access path uh path where there is um a lot of the vocational training independent functioning training but our deferment is open for all of our students with an IEP okay and then my other question was well it's not really a question I was just GNA ask if I could be put on to the list um of the monthly meeting at The Advisory Group because I'd love to attend sometimes as well as I'd love to go see project search because I've heard fantastic things about it and I'd love to see it in action um and that's it for questions but I'm going to give a quick plug um on April 5th if anyone's looking to volunteer

056for the Special Olympics it will be at Mainland High School last year we were short um over a 100 volunteers so you can be unified partner in any athletic competition you want to be a partner and you do not have to be trained in it so anyone looking to come join us and hopefully we'll see some of the kids out there competing so thank you for all that you do thank you and I will umite for project search okay thank you thank you yep Mrs brosmer just one more comment I wanted to um expand on what Mr cologne said about having the disruptive students who take away time from the other students that applies in gen Ed too I just wanted to expand that a little bit that's all I'll go that's fine you go

057ahead are you sure okay um I want to thank you and I'll help clarify a few of the questions um that came up because I know there's so many terms and there's so many acronyms in ESC that it becomes confusing and it it's confusing even for parents you know when they come into a meeting I've watched their faces over the years because they don't understand sometimes what we're saying so we have to take a step back and we have to provide them explanations in language that's understandable but Mr cologne for secondary um I actually did the co talk classes at the secondary level and believe it or not they were supposed to be a 70 30% split which meant 70% of the students say in Algebra 1 were gened and 30% were ESC they had

058an IEP because math could be their learning disability area that they needed extra support in and I co-taught them with a wonderful um ESC teacher who has since retired but I taught them I it a new student came in one day and this is how a student said to them have a seat Miss Hayes is going to get up there and she's going to teach us all about what we need to know today for the math lesson but when she's finished Mrs best is going to come up behind her and she's going to break some of it down into simpler terms for us so if you didn't get it the first way you'll get it the second way but the thing is you've got two teachers here to help you and so that is very

059important because in elementary I also taught self-contained um classroom and I've watched the pendulum go from here to here and now we're coming back again um it used to be we didn't put all of our kids at elementary into varing exceptionalities classes we actually had programs that were designed exactly for the area that they were struggling with so I taught self-contained speech and language to three from from the age of three to um five turning six year olds and one of the years I taught it I had 13 little boys 13 little boys that you possibly couldn't even understand what they said okay some there was there was one all he did was mix up all of his pronouns okay others you had to try to work with them to identify what was that they

060were saying so they were it was a huge Spectrum but they were in there because every one of them that was their primary disability and at that same time we had classes specifically just for our children with a learning disability we had classes specifically for our children with behavioral issues that that's what we had to overcome that piece before we could move on and then all of a sudden we came along and we grouped them all together and that's when the pendulum swung so I am happy to see that we recognize taking children with multiple exceptionalities and putting them in one classroom is not necessarily the best thing for them I watched those children that when they got the services for their primary disability I watched them sore I watched them because the instruction was

061geared towards exact what they needed in that room and I'm not saying that because listen when you take 13 little three to six-year-old little boys at some point somebody's going to have a rough day and act out but none of them were in that room because Behavior was the issue they were all there because they were struggling with speaking and they needed to be able to learn how to communicate because communication is an important part then of being able to learn how to read and they got all of their academic instruction but they also got specialized speech therapy by our speech clinicians you know have master's degrees in what they needed and I'm happy to see that we're moving back but that's there is a difference between Elementary and secondary and people need to realize

062that what works necessarily in elementary we can't replicate in secondary because it's not going to work in secondary necessarily secondary is a different thing especially with our children with learning disabilities I had a young lady who actually was tested in first grade for gifted she came out that yes but she came out as a gifted learning disabled student and that's rare it's not something you hear all the time but here was the thing when they gave her the gifted test and then they tested her academics she was already as a six-year-old reading at a fifth to sixth grade level and I can attest to that because one day her mother was in pharmaceutical and blood sales and she brought in a book and wanted to read the book because it was her day to read

063to the class about blood and I had to convince her the rest of the six-year-olds weren't interested in this could we pick a different book to read but she could read that well guess what her math came out at second grade level so she still in my opinion was gifted in math but when you took her overall IQ and you looked at her academics she was labeled as a gifted LD child so she just needed we knew she was going to need some extra support in her math I mean brilliant young lady but six I mean so we have to take it now I know that Mr clone has shared he wants you to go really slow with this piece of looking at our schools I'm all for slow when needed but I also am

064aware that we have some situations out there and we have some schools that have 30% or more of their population on their campuses are are ESC students and we have placed a heavy load on the shoulders of the people at those schools in a lot of ways so I think we need to figure out a plan to move a little bit sooner than later we can't allow you know three more years to pass where we keep increasing the numbers at those schools because we're wearing people out and we and some of our school buildings because I've went out and walked them with facilities are not designed for the programs that we are hosting at those schools or they may be designed and they have a classroom a classroom that has a large enough bathroom you

065know to have a changing table in it and things like that because there's so many rules attached to that but if they have three units three different classroom units that need a changing table and the other two classrooms don't have bathrooms to put changing tables into then we're not meeting the best needs of those children and so I think and that's why I've even asked a couple years ago as we're moving forward and we're renovating schools or we're building new schools is we need to know ahead of time time what is our population going to be and you know I give credit um that it year ago we took a long look at mcginness elementary and discovered that all of the kids that were there in one of the programs they all lived in Pearson

066but we were busing them every day quite a distance to mcginness and we were able to move that program to Pearson and put them back in their Community they're closer If the parents need to go on campus for any reason and it made sense so I just want you to continue to look at where children live what is the program that will best meet their needs and I'm happy to hear that we're going to pull the behavior because we used to also have selfcontained classrooms that were strictly when Behavior was the primary it didn't mean that they didn't maybe have a secondary piece that they needed but when Behavior was the primary piece they were going into a room with smaller numbers and more support and it gave the behavioral specialist a place to be

067to work every day on those instead of a behavioral specialist now trying to hit six different rooms because we have them scattered throughout and so I appreciate um and I appreciate the time you took with me um prior to this so that you know I could ask some more questions and share things but I think we're on the right track because the pendulum is swinging back and here's the thing we don't need to be on either end we need to be here in the middle and we need to make the decisions here based on what's best for our kids and I appreciate both of you and all of you out there for what you're doing because I know it takes a lot of time and effort so thank you Mrs brosmer I you raised an

068interesting question that wouldn't have occurred to me on the geographic portion of this consideration how does zoning work with that so we work with them but I'll give an example in your area you have an elementary school in your area that already four years ago had a significant number of students on campus with IEPs with a large variety of primary pieces and someone decided to take a school and take the kids from that school and move them to your school making that school in your area even more overcrowded with and so it becomes a lot more work for administrators especially when behaviors are happening because if you have a lot of kids on campus that can be set off in a moment and they're running we don't have enough people on Elementary CL campuses to

069you know get them and get them back in and I'm happy to tell you like later which school school it is and which school they were moved from but you have a school in your area that has a substantial number of ESC programs on campus with because they closed down they they they moved the whole units out of another school so and bust them in in the in the resoning process uh are they are the number of ESC students being rezoned a factor in the resoning decisions I guess I'm still uncertain about that they they have access to where children are where they currently live and so do they live in a rezoning area but where are we currently busing them we're busing a lot of kids in valou County um I'll speak about the

070schools just in district one there are two elementary schools in district one that are heavily Ese and we had to turn gen ad rooms into ESC rooms and that's when I talk about the room not being set up or being able to have the right equipment in it to necessarily meet the needs of the students and both of those are 30% or higher of their entire population and yet they're coming from Schools they're most of those children are not zoned for that school but they're being busted there because that's where we put the programs okay thank you you can't and it and here's the difference between middle and high we're not typically in middle and high busting a child out of their Zone to another middle or high because in middle and high we meet

071those needs in a different way because we look at do they need to still be in a self-contained or like a separate classroom for that or are we now addressing it in a co-taught situation because they just need the extra support in math or do we have support facilitation coming in we look at that so for middle and high they get a SC schedule more designed for where they at now and which type of classroom do they need to learn in thank you you're welcome all right do you want to say I just want to say thank you to the entire to the team some of you are here um this group of individuals here have worked 247 and I I promise uh Miss Copeland that after her third year the job will get easier

072um there is a lot of um adjusting that needed to take place this past year as you guys know I also want to thank the board because you know that last year during our listen and learn ESC was one of those topics that came up to the point that I even said to a few of our teachers I'm well aware just give us the time I'm well aware so I want to thank you because this year it's so much better but not only evidence and seen by us here but also by every group that has been out here for for example we've had do doe here maybe seven times so far and which each visit we're seeing that they are seeing evidence that we are improving in the right ways also with our doj we

073meet with them monthly so I want to thank you guys for all of the work that you've been doing behind the scene and and clearly it's seeing we're seeing that that's permeating into the culture of our organization I visited a school Horizon um just last Friday and I walked into the front office and a teacher was there and it so happened that the teacher had all of the documentation for a different placement for our student but I talked to the teacher about the documentation and she was just raving and talking about Ed modify how much easier has made in terms of you know pulling those documentation reviewing and so forth and I remember year one with Ed modify right we went through some Growing Pains but that's all process when you're instituting changes but I

074want to thank you guys because For What It's Worth meeting the needs of every learner is starting to really permeate into the culture of our and fabric of our organization so thank you uh Miss Copeland you've got two more years and after that it gets easier um and to the entire team that's here thank you for all the work that you've been doing on and behind the scenes and I need to put in one plug since Kathy came up um for those of you that have not had a chance yet to attend a project search graduation I believe she probably already has the date May 28th okay but May 28th you have to go to Project search graduation Miss Thompson and I have attended and um bring bring some tissues with you I'll be honest

075with you because every year I tell myself it doesn't matter what story th that child tells I'm not going to cry and then you hear their story and all the things they overcame and I'll never forget the young man that said he his original goal was he wanted to work for Panera and he said and I'm already working and I've already gotten two paychecks and I mean it's just those are our children that what Halifax Hospital does along with fucha County Schools to prepare those children to have an opportunity to play productive part in society is just phenomenal and I did have one mother call me about the facilities piece because she said my husband and I just thought our son would live with us forever and we would take care of him forever and

076she said um she called me after he' worked one year with facilities and she said he's worked one full year now with facilities and Miss Haynes he gets up every morning excited to go to work and be on one of those facility teams and she said we see a future for him that we didn't see when he was growing up and that's what it's all about it's finding that future and finding a path so that every student has a plan and what they can and can do so thank you for everything you do and thank you Kathy because thank you all it's fabulous all right we are moving right along to item 3.01 House Bill 1473 our quarterly report Dr valkin yeah thank you madam chair I would like to ask Captain Smith um our

077director for Safety and Security he's going to share with you our quarterly update regarding 1473 and it will probably be the shortest presentation um that you would receive be shorter than last time probably good afternoon superintendent Madame chair and board members I'm captain Todd Smith the director of Safety and Security for valua County Schools today we will be discussing the quarterly safety report in accordance with Florida State statutes this presentation aligns with policy 511 safety of facilities this presentation also aligns with guard rail 2 providing conditions that enhance student learning in accordance with House Bill 1473 school districts are required to report four things each quarter the number and percentage of schools including Charter Schools inspected or reinspected during the quarter the number and percentage of schools with no school safety requirement deficiencies in the

078second quarter 21 schools were inspected or reinspected by the office of safe schools this represents 27.27% of the schools inspected or reinspected 19 schools had no school safety requirement deficiencies therefore 90.48% of schools had no school safety requirement deficiencies before I conclude this presentation I'd like to touch on something real quick there are hundreds of ways that a school can fail this audit if a single door is unlocked in the entire school they fail if a single gate is out of compliance they fail if there are missing a single document of the hundreds that are required they fail of the two schools with deficiencies Mainland High School had a single safe Zone identifier that was missing and it was immediately resolved and Henson Middle School had a door lock malfunction at the beginning of the

079school day the incident had been reported to staff prior to the audit that happened the same day day and before the lock could be fixed they got audited which obviously the doors found unlocked otherwise both schools would have had a perfect audit out of all the ways that they could have fil the principles and staff are taking these audits serious the results show that they care we have created a culture surrounding Safety and Security and we are working hard to ensure compliance and this concludes my presentation thank you any questions you did a great job I do thank you yeah sorry Rich um so I was at Atlantic high school this week and they were asking me and and I don't know if this is the right time to ask this question but I'm going

080to um for their Automotive class they can't use their cards to go outside to the automotive building um to access their tools and the things they need to to get to for that class without a teacher can we look into seeing if there's a way to do that safely yes thank you that's all okay thank you Captain so at this time we're going to take um a short break and let's be back in here at 2 pm for the third topic thank you e e e welcome back it is 2:1 pm and we are now moving on to item 3.02 potential prototype design for elementary schools Dr baman thank you madam chair board members as you know we had this discussion um at least two years ago when we start talking about um reviewing prototypes

081for elementary K8 and secondary so the team has been doing some research and they're here to share with you a prototype that's still in the works and this is in particular for elementary school we have with us here today miss Patty core who's our chief operating officer along with Mr Ron young our director and Tom Brown our coordinator and BJJ vus all right good afternoon thank you all for having us here today um yes this is in the works and it's as you see on the title it says potential prototype design for elementary schools and as the team goes through it you'll see why um this would be considered a good prototype for us to be able to expand and contract a site as necessary based on the physical plant or the land that we're

082building on and some other information you'll see um coming shortly this presentation conforms to our district policies number 63 and 605 603 uh outlines the design guidelines and educational specifications for Bou County Schools when we build and then the construction delivery method in 605 this also aligns to guard rail 3 of our strategic plan improve operational efficiency and maximize resources to support student learning learning good afternoon Miss core asked me to do a little bit of research on this so I dove into statutes dove into the internet I also spoke with our friends in Orange simal Amber vard county about prototype buildings that they're using right now um and so this uh presentation is laid out just to kind of give you an overview of the Prototype design concept which is basically a strategy to

083reduce capital expenditure create efficiencies save money um and do a few more things that'll help our students as we go through this it's basically building the same building over and over again with modifications to fit the site not only is it a good idea but it's actually mandated by Florida statute that if we have two Elementary two middle two high school buildings that are going to be happening within our five-year work plan it is mandated that we use those same construction designs and seek the efficiencies of a prototype type whenever and well not whenever possible but it's it's mandated to that we make it possible um trying to get ahead of that we did this research and looked into the concept of a school uh building prototype design and as I said before the number

084one reason most school districts most businesses look for a prototype is to save money let's face it one of the main ways we save money is on the front end the preconstruction the design cost some of the examples that were shared with me by other districts are up to a 5% savings which if we we had the example I gave if we had a $60 million construction project you'd look at saving maybe $3 million on the design the preconstruction not to mention efficiencies you could be created by buying the same materials over again multiple times and if you knew you had a couple projects coming down the road you could get ahead of that save money's there the other place where we save money is in the operation of the facility and in the maintenance

085of the facility and quite frankly you can even save time and time is money because if our um employees and even if we know what that school looks like before we get there it's quicker to get to wherever it is you're working if you've got 27 different designs you're not exactly sure always where you're going when you show up at a campus some of you may have had that experience as you visit the various schools um so money is important time is important but what really appealed to me as a former principal um is the fact that it supports student learning um it creates consistency it reduce risks and it it creates a sense of educational Equity across the district um and it also creates a consensus among stakeholders so as we're looking at developing

086new schools new projects we're sort of coming from the same place for all of our communities across the district um just kind of how a prototype design works and and what are the pieces of it that we need prototype schools are typically designed to be efficient flexible customizable it's primarily suitable for elementary schools that's where it really fits the best it's sort of difficult at the second level and it's really a challenge at a high school level because of the various programs Athletics the different things that are happening at those schools and the reality is we don't build as many of those high schools within the same time frame so in terms of taking a prototype and moving it it might be several years which means you've had a lot of changes in Building Technology

087Etc as as you look at high schools and secondary schools um the beautiful thing about a prototype school as I said before is the idea that it can be used again and again with slight modifications just to adjust to the sites as we build schools across the district um your team recommends that we look at the Edith I Stark Elementary School currently under construction as a prototype design we feel it meets the criteria in terms of being Compact and efficient it's easily expandable um it can be customized to meet School sites it is modern we know it's safe it's going to be secure and it's designed to accommodate about 650 students which is sort of our suweet spot in terms of building new schools um in doing the research I uh got the input of

088principles got some principal voices talked to some people out in the fields about things that they were looking for and sort of created this checklist and and the Stark prototype kind of marks all the boxes um I did want to call out because some spacious front office lobby since we've had security a lot of times our parents are crammed up front we want to have the ability to have a lobby area that's big enough for them and another piece is the office and Conference space space with itinerate workers with um the number of Assessments and services that we're providing to different students U we need to have some of those things that we don't have necessarily in the older school buildings in terms of conference space and the big piece that came and resonated from

089everybody was flexibility the ability to have a large cafeteria space it's flexible and rooms that can be flexed depending on the needs of the school depending on the time of the year because we know during testing and other times we have various needs and we feel like the Edith I Stark model supports that so to give you a little more information and tell you more about that I'm going to turn it over to Mr Brown and good afternoon so uh the next uh couple of slides are just the uh elevations uh of what uh Edith Stark is going to look like um it's a much simpler design um so it will fit pretty much within any uh neighborhood um and not look out of place this here is just a look at the bus drop

090off uh pickup area uh the back side of the campus now the next slide is the floor plan that is being constructed at Stark now um as Mr vogus had mentioned earlier with this being a proposed prototype um it is flexible and adaptable to pretty much any site uh that we would encounter uh currently uh this plan is designed for 650 student stations if you'll notice uh at the top right corner of this floor plan you'll see a little cutout area there uh that was intentionally done to reduce uh the number of student stations down for this particular uh building so there are six classrooms that could be added into that location there to expand uh the student capacity so by doing that you could increase capacity of this particular design to um 770 student

091stations and again if we get into a situation where you need a larger capacity Elementary School uh additional classrooms can be added onto the end of that building at the far right very easily and you can do a one-story or twostory addition onto that uh depending on how many student stations you would require so um one of the things I'd like to point out uh with this uh particular floor plan is that all of the square footage within this design is utilized to its maximum potential um some of our previous uh designs had uh large spaces that kind of didn't lend themselves very well uh for student use so we've addressed that and have now utilized the square foot as best as possible to accommodate the student education in these facilities also with this uh

092particular design the main corridors are situated to where they are very easy to supervise uh as students are traversing these corridors so you can stand uh kind of in a center location and see in all directions now these here are just a couple of Aerials from last month of the progress of Stark and again uh you'll notice uh in the areas where that uh six classrooms had been removed to get the student station countdown so that would be where you could add student station classrooms as well as on the end of the building and this is a linear building so it uh like I said lends itself to a lot of conditions that concludes our presentation if you guys have any questions we'd be happy to address them Mr clone and so I look forward

093to possibly approving this sometime in January or February of next year the reason I say that is every school that we've built has always been the newest latest greatest wonderful most innov inovative everything until we move in and we figure out this was working well this is not working well so while I appreciate the inside on the Stark Elementary not that we're not uh creating a high expectation uh I'd be curious to see once we start using it and abusing it to say to then be able to say okay this worked out really well this is because you know there are times you know my Delona middle school is beautiful I mean it's beautiful walk in and there's this beautiful huge foyer looks like the Amway arena same Architects you know and then in retrospect

094I'm thinking okay what do we do with the space well could it have been not quite so Grand and maybe we could have used that somewhere else could we have made the classrooms six Ines bigger this way and used that space and so I I I am all about having the Prototype I'm just I wait to hear back the feedback from the folks at the new Stark to tell us whether or not this is great or it's not you know I had the honor of going to the new ter te and there's opportunities there you know Deltona Middle there's opportunities to mocha I haven't heard anything but I'm sure my email will fill up now you know so again it's taking all of that feedback just as you said um and so um I'm all

095for having a prototype I just you know I I'd want I'd be curious to hear from the folks once they move in if it's good or not thank you that's part of the beauty of the Prototype is that ability to learn from experience and make the tweaks and adjustments as we go thank you good Rich um I agree with Mr clone let's see if it works before we use it as a prototype but I my question is my understanding is that in our elementary schools we don't break even financially until we're at about 750 students so if we have the opportunity to add on I understand that's there when I've been involved in construction doing it the first time is sign is a significant savings rather than building it and then later adding on so

096why wouldn't we build to the 750 start it's actually 550 and it's 90% of the 550 so it's it's not that you just have a school that has 550 seats you have to have it at least 90% capacity of a 550 seat school so at Stark uh the original design was for 800 but it just the de the the area uh the losos in the area just doesn't support an 800 seat school that's why we it was changed to 650 so you're saying 550 is where we break even yes so I'm getting different numbers you ask if you ask Todd he'll tell you Todd says 750 so maybe we need some clarification yeah maybe we need to get some clarification on that because I don't want to build schools that lose money right and if

097it doesn't fantastic I just want a better understanding of it okay but but let me ask a question and seriously this is for me to understand I'm hearing that we when we build we have to have a 90% capacity I mean to be able to fill 90% % that's so I think that's where some of it is coming from because you look at the areas that you're open to in terms of the the feeder pattern right and how many students you're going to be generating in schools that like for example your Stark right if you look at the feeder pattern for Stark it will tell you realistically how many students were that Stark is zoned for it so it might be another issue it might be like looking at the Zoning for the schools It's

098So Many Factors financially I I believe you're absolutely right it's about 650 something students that you have to have to just break even right but I think for building purposes we have to be able to look at the Zoning for those schools and be able to fill 90% of it okay so which will make it more of a look relooking at the zoning may I add something so they um there's going to be rezoning taking place for Stark because there's not the students that are zoned there right now can't support this school but we're overcrowded at the surrounding schools so the rezoning is going to take place to put more students into Stark into the brand new school building so are we busing them there no they'll be with most of them will be within

099the two mile radius the problem is we have so if you think about 1792 Woodland Boulevard in Dand we have three schools sitting on elementary schools sitting on the West Side they're all under two miles to each other and then on the other side we have three Schools elementary schools all sitting within less than two miles from each other so we have six elementary schools sitting in Dand and we have elementary schools that are overcrowded so we did a piece of resoning a year ago and that we only touched Woodward and Citrus Grove because the growth is happening further west going towards Lake County and but we told them at the time the parents that we did reone between those two they would not get rezoned a second time but then there are parts that

100we left on that side also immediately right across the boulevard that will be coming over because freedom is also way over capacity we're trying to not add additional buildings to those schools and take them up like DeBerry to a thousand or more kids because at that point it's not effective for elementary school a thousand is you need to stop you don't need to go over a thousand kids at an elementary school with so we just have not done the rezoning piece because we can't rezone them until the school is ready to put them in there miss do you have anything else miss good okay M brosmer to your point actually to a number of the points that have been made in in the last couple of minutes um in one of my past projects I

101had to uh evaluate I had to study and evaluate and and what have you on school concurrency and District size and economies of scale and for for elementary schools uh 650 is just about right so um that the Thousand is is just way too many um and I I like kind of aiming lower than the 650 and then we have room to to grow when we need to so I um I just wanted to toss that in because it was consistent with with the studies that I've done okay so um I already said this so I wasn't surprised other people came up with it I already told you guys I can't I can't go with this being the Prototype till after it's opened and everybody has moved in because if you know we did use

102a prototype um on some of our schools here in in valuch County at one point you know when we built vucha Pines and Forest Lake and DeBry all at the same time understanding that we put a second story on De Barry but vucha Pines and Forest Lake were built with the same prototype and then we use that prototype a few more times and I'm all for prototypes because seminal county has used prototypes for years they have for their elementary middle and high you know back when the growth hit them and they were building and it does save money and it's more consistent it's much easier to understand the layout you know it works for Captain Smith and his team if they have to go in for a Safety and Security issue all of that but

103I'm not sold yet that this is the Prototype because until I walk it and I see it because if we look at the new schools that have opened in the time period that Mr colone and I have been here on the board Pearson is absolutely beautiful but the classrooms are about this big and they have all these big learning areas that can't be used unless the teacher goes to the learning area with the children because you can't send five-year-olds out to a learning area unsupervised teachers could lose their teaching certificate so those learning areas are not typically used very much at that school which becomes the the classroom teachers could have had a bigger space than this and and everywhere I've gone with you guys you hear me say the space needs to be in

104the classroom so that they teachers can do the activities they need to do and especially for our primary Learners they need to be able to move to the floor and then move to a center or station they can't sit in a seat all day long that is not what is best that's not how they learn the best we look at pride pride Elementary beautiful two-story building but when you walk in it's it's like Deltona Middle it has this huge area that's just it's not used for anything I'll be honest with you probably the school you guys did the best job as a twostory and I'm not saying that it should be um but at the time when we finally started building twostory schools is actually DeBerry because DeBerry does not have a wasted space like

105Pride or an a space where you go to Citrus Grove and you still have to get through a set of double doors into the other doors and things like that but that was also built right before we went to class size Amendment so their classrooms are a nice size okay and those kids have the ability to move about and that is important in elementary school I'm not against learning lab areas but and and I I was happy to hear that there is a point where you can stand in the hallways and you can see all the way down because George Marks way those wings go off you know and we didn't open it but what three years was it three years ago you can't stand and see everything and you know when we have a

106principal and an assistant principal on campus if they can't stand somewhere to be able to see everything or they can't put a teacher there that's a safety issue too so I like what you said and you said some of the right words that spoke to me about this but until I actually see it and we move stuff into it I can't give you an approval I don't think there's any disagreement I think the reason that we brought the school today was to bring attention to it we think it could possibly be a prototype in the future so when we open it and you're touring it and you know pay particular attention about sight lines and that sort of thing there's a there's a fine line between enough space and wasted space right so I think

107the guys have done a really good job with song and Associates on this school of providing those sight lines doing away with some of was Ed space and uh I think it's a really on paper it's a really efficient use of space and we've said the same thing that um maybe this is a little premature but we did want to bring it to you because we want to walk it ourselves so and and I support a prototype I really do I support it for the cost savings and all that we just need to see I mean that that's part of why when we went to P County and we saw the K8 being built okay we went back once the kids were moved in and the teachers and the office Specialists and everybody were there

108to ask them is the space working and how is it working and is there anything they would have changed and I just I'm with you and so I it's fine that we bring it up now because this is the way we need to move we need to go to prototypes I mean Atlantic and pineridge were built off the same model only Atlantic was one less Wing at the time because it didn't have enough students you know to support that additional Wing but you know they were built but codes H codes change and the safety piece hit us hard all of us that safety piece is probably the the piece that nobody thought I mean we thought we had our kids safe but that brought a lot of challenges so any other questions all right thank

109you very much thank you and we're looking forward to seeing this school all right at this time it is 2:25 p.m. and this meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.