001e e e good evening everyone I call the February 18th 2025 regular meeting of the Union County Board of Commissioners to order at this time I would like to recognize commissioner Vice chair Brian HMS for the invocation thank you madam chair if you're so inclined please join me in prayer dear heavenly father Lord we just want to thank you Lord for all of your blessings all of your blessings on our County um our state and also our nation um Lord as we uh As We Gather here for this meeting tonight I pray that you provide our board um your uh wisdom and your guidance as we make the best decisions possible for the people of Union County for in Jesus name we do pray amen amen amen the United States of America stands nation godible
002withy and jusice for all the next item on the agenda is informal comments from the community Madame chair has anyone signed up to speak for informal comments the first person is Colette Roland good evening everybody uh my name is Colette Roland I am a resident of Union County and I live in waaw uh the reason I came tonight is that we have a nonprofit that I don't know if many of y'all know about that operates in Monroe North Carolina called The Connect Center through the connect Center we have the pass through store which is a free store for clothing and shoes for anybody that meets the 125% of the federal poverty guideline so as currently we've been serving for the last two years years uh almost 1100 residents in Union County and throughout North Carolina
003some even South Carolina and the other thing is we started a program called The Connect Scholars um in order to break that cycle of poverty we thought it was important to make sure we capture them to let them know they can go into higher education from high school so currently we're working with 13 students and we make sure that they have the tools they need to be able to go into that higher education we give them free tutoring uh we anything that they need we make sure we're there for them to be their Village the purpose of me coming out tonight is because this is the first year that we're actually applying for the uh Union County partnership Grant so we wanted just to make y'all aware of who we were what we do and
004that's basically it so thank you for the time thank you for being here tonight our next speaker is Amy Nicol hi actually um I have Jeff Mangum here as well we're kind of tag teaming this he's next on the list okay so you want to go first y thank you guys thank you guys I'm Jeff Mangum uh vice vice chair of food for families uh NC headquartered here in an Indian Trail we've been feeding families for the past 13 years I was a member always been a member of First Baptist Indian Trail and about 13 years ago we had a teacher came to us and said I've got some kids in my class that we've identified that aren't eating from the time they get free lunch on Friday till they get free lunch free breakfast
005on Monday so we took it upon ourselves to supply food for about 18 to 20 kids and started a backpack program that first night we said how in the world are we going to sustain this well fast forward 13 years we're supplying thousands of families each and every week and um Amy's got some numbers she's going to throw out but we're we're excited to be in this year's in this cycle of grant money and we have petitioned for $25,000 to help buy food with inflation we all know what the cost of food is and for us feeding so many families each and every week School children's we're supplying all the schools uh we're doing mobile distributions throughout the county again Amy will go into all that but I just want to make you guys aware
006that the need is astronomical and you know I've been a resident of Union County my entire life and one thing I never dreamed of is there would be kids living two doors down for me that are hungry and not necessarily at the poverty level but below and above the poverty level and our goal is that we that no child goes hungry and um with your help we can help meet that need all right thanks Jeff um so my name is Amy Nikolai and I'm the executive director at food for families um like Jeff St said we started back in 2012 um but in 2014 we actually became our own 501c3 nonprofit organization and um we also became a partnering agency with Second Harvest Food Bank at that time so we actually have five core programs
007now we've kind of expanded over the years um as a result of Co in 2020 we've expanded our programs not just the backpack weekend food programs um at that time we were averaging about 700 bags a week to students in Union and Anson county and now today we're averaging about 1,500 bags a week to students in um Union Anson and parts of mecklinburg County just for the backpack program um our second program which actually started um in 2020 was our home delivery program we partner with um the social workers and counselors in the school systems and they help identify families that need more than just the weekend food and this program allows us to um give families um more High nutritional food frozen meat uh fresh fruits and vegetables along with non- perishable items and
008um today we actually we had a record number of of Home deliveries in January actually we had 501 families that receive our weekly home deliveries um and just the packets the folders that he left for you guys have our 2024 impact numbers for all of our programs but um you know we went from uh you know zero in e e e those vehicles are no longer available as as a police package so we have moved more towards the pickup truck the SUV style because we have all of our equipment so essentially these deputies when we talk about those response times we want them in the zones we don't want them sitting at the office and having to drive to respond to those calls for service we want them in the community so essentially their vehicles
009is their office that is their mobile office they most of them rarely have to come to the office unless they they've made an arrest or they have to go before the magistrate or some administrative reason but primarily they stay out there in the field which is where we want them and this is just a snapshot of the interior and you'll see some of the equipment that they're issued and and the cage that they have if they're transporting a prisoner in the back uh and the rifles and things that they have issued to them we're very fortunate to have the equipment uh that we have to keep them prepared to do their job Sheriff's offices positions I want to think um and this sort of tracks that Trend moves along with the County's population if you
010see we're about 300 according to what I have 373 total uh funded position positions some of those are part-time positions but I think we're currently at 373 this is our organizational chart um and how it's broken down with the seven divisions Two Chief deputies the sheriff and all the various bureaus uh and and units that fall with within uh each of those divisions Our Town contracts just real quickly um these are our our special operations Bureau and how that's broken down we have um Weddington has just added two more deputies to their contract so they're up to five in Weddington Wesley Chapel still is sitting at one um I don't know why if of any of those small towns that need more they do and we've told them every year but they are comfortable with
011just one um even though they continue to grow and their retail footprint keeps growing Marvin has two Lake Park is is good with two um we have our safe unit which is primarily responsible for our alcohol or just drug impaired or alcohol impaired drivers um they've been around since the end of 2015 and that is primarily their job is out there looking for those dangerous and impaired drivers they do a wonderful job they're led by one sergeant and five deputies and then our Shield unit which used to be our Warrant Squad we've sort of repurposed that group one Sergeant five deputies one of those five is assigned as a full-time Task Force officer to the United States Marshall service we get the benefit of that because of the investigative resources they bring if we have
012a wanted person who's a dangerous wanted person that they've left Union County we dedicate the resources to finding that individual and and they vice versa come here as much as we need them help us helping us locate you know our wanted persons so we're very fortunate to have that relationship with them and this is um a snapshot of our overall Town contracts the largest obviously being Indian Trail they've grown to 36 total employees um led by a captain two lieutenants four sergeants 26 deputies and three civilians so they're also paying for one full-time Administrative Assistant one part-time admin assistant one full-time crime scene investigator two detectives and then third 33 deputies and that contract just continues to grow as Indian Trail continues to grow and this is sort of a breakdown of all municipalities um
013their police budget their total number of employees and this is kind of what it looked like around 2024 and you can see on the on the right side is what these are the five Town contracts that the Sheriff's Office serves um and what the cost is to uh to those towns for that service and that's it so I will open it up to any questions that anyone may have any questions ma'am yes um thank you very much chief for the information Sheriff I do have one question off the top of my head considering the new administration's push on uh illegal immigration uh criminal elements can you just explain your relationship with the Marshall service Ice immigration what have you um on the apprehension and whatever happens to uh illegal criminal elements as far as anyone
014who is undocumented or here how you with ice yeah undocumented U gang members what have you criminal element how you work with ice or other Federal authorities and dealing with those we have Partnerships with virtually every Federal agency and we have for many many years um you know especially with with the Marshall service which we currently have one full-time you know Task Force officer assigned there as I mentioned earlier as far as ice the way that goes we haven't changed CH the way we operate at the sheriff's office with any sort of identification procedure essentially what happens is we do not as an agency go out and and look for individuals who may not be here legally we don't go out looking for those individuals we don't go with ice to look for those individuals
015how that H how that comes into play is when any person comes into the jail regardless of who they are they're fingerprinted and they are positively identified part of that identification procedure is determining what is their native country where were you born and we send that information once they're fingerprinted it goes to the SBI to the FBI and to ice for them to be identified and if they've had any type of Border Nexus if ice then responds to that that inquiry and they they say that they want a detainer put on that individual then we do that we will hold them what happens is that once that individual meets conditions of release for the underlying charge that they're in custody for ice has 48 hours to come and get them we're only allowed to hold
016them for up to but no more than 48 hours after they have met other conditions of release so that process really hasn't changed it hasn't impacted us um but we work with all federal agencies you know we've we've frequently been partners with Homeland Security with ATF we also have a task force officer on the on the ATF you know violent crimes task force um as well as we have in the past with the FBI so we we work with and partner with all law enforcement agencies but that's kind of kind of the way our process works thank thank you let me just say this I is not going in the churches searching the churches they're not going in the schools searching the schools put that to rest they just don't do that we're and we're
017not going to do that either if there's somebody that needs something they can contact our SRO we'll take care of it I is not going to do it I thought find this information very helpful I I would also like to ask uh staff I know we're in in the uh budget process but I would also like to welcome uh the sheriff's department back in part of the budget process to actually go through the the budget part for law enforcement I think that would also be very helpful since this is I know for me particularly since this is my first budget go around so I would like to have uh these good folks back thank you very much chair um Chief thank you for being here Sheriff thank you for being here as well um one
018thing I want to Circle back to and and first of all let me say this um as a parent with two small kids in ucps our sro's are fantastic they are fantastic and um and it's it's really it's great to see these kids they they'll they'll bond with these deputies um and those deputies really become a part of their school culture um I I wanted to just go back real quickly to the slide that you had on the uh instance by school type yes sir just so I understand correctly and just so you know we're we're getting that message out correctly to the public these aren't like prosecuted crimes these are just like reportable instance correct am I understanding that right if it if it is a crime that is alleged okay it doesn't mean
019it's it's it actually happened but if if a student is is alleging a crime an assault a a threat um and we get a lot of those threats we get a lot of assaults um if you see the weekly report that comes from our school uh Safety Division how many incidents are reported in a week's time you know it'd be it's amazing it takes 30 minutes to read it that's a weekly summary of the five school days but Mo the vast majority of those reports are not they're not actual crimes the ones that are prosecuted I mean the overwhelming majority are are under the age of 18 so they're reported to Department of Juvenile Justice for to seek a petition and and to see if they'll issue a petition against the student if it's Justified
020but the numbers I don't want the numbers to frighten you there's not that many actual crimes in the schools our our schools are very very safe but we are if we get a report I mean because kids are on social media and if we get the to see to say something app to see something say something appen we we get several a day that somebody reports something that they overheard a student you know saying they were going to bring violence to the school we immediately start that investigation we don't wait we immediately get to the source of that and if it means going to that students home that evening and making contact we do that but but that still goes down as a as an incident report right yes sir okay thank you it's just
021like a 911 call it's the same thing gotcha we document it it goes into those numbers but it not necessarily mean it's a crime it's charge thank you yes sir I have a question on this it says um is this is this data only for Union County Public Schools or would it be for Charter Schools private schools home school education South pedmont what all is this K12 it private Charter home school that's going to be K12 Union County Public Schools so this is only Union County Public Schools those will be the reports that are available to us through our report records management system so it it's it's not going to capture the charter schools because we don't have school resource officers in those schools right so I was wondering like if there was an incident
022would they not call 911 well they they would but for example I was thinking of Union Academy Monroe police is over there so that would go to they would go call 911 but Monroe police would handle that situ it goes to 911 it comes to us our Monroe or whatever whatever jurisdiction it is okay thank you yes ma'am are there any other questions I just want to thank you again for being here and thank you for the job that you do 247 thank you all thank you next on our agenda is item 25- z53 Wastewater Pump Station approval request Sanctuary at Southgate Phase 2 development I will recognize our County Manager Brian Matthews thank you madam chair let's see if I can find this here it up okay well the presentation is not on there
023so can we move to the next item and I'll bring it put it in there and get e e e agreement you for um additional funding for future years correct that is correct because every year the cost will change and it it'll take more dollars to maintain the same level we were providing for those eight this year um so if that it's worked into the budget great if not our our base level would have to be reduced and that could potentially affect the weight list and then Wesley Chapel would have a decision whether they want to fund the entirety of what the weight list is at that time or not and th those are just discussions and points we're going to have to work out in an inter local it it has the potential to
024get a little complicated as people come on and off so we're trying to come up with an agreement that's as uh easy to understand for them and us well I I'll Echo um chair Merl's comments and uh say thank you to Wesley Chapel um you know it makes it a lot easier you know for uh for this board and our County when we were able to have those Partnerships with our municipalities um and you know I've said this before but um but you know when we when we have those Partnerships we can do some great things and I think this is a um a good example of that so thank you for bringing this yes sir thank you thank you all think we go back to item 253 pum station approval request from Sanctuary at
025Southgate Phase 2 development I will recognize our County Manager Matthews to present that request sorry about that Brian thank you for your patience a little bit of technical difficulty there so what you have here tonight um Commissioners is a request for a pump station to be considered um back several years ago the Board of Commissioners approved the policy at which um new pump stations and improvements to pump stations would have to come to the board for decisions on whether to move forward with the construction of those often times development um cannot Flow by gravity or there's a difficulty in flow flowing by gravity to a a a wastewater treatment plan and so pump stations are sort of a necessary evil depending on the the circumstances what you have here tonight is a request for a
026pump station called Sanctuary at Southgate Phase 2 and I'll talk a little bit about that so this is just the policy that the board had adopted and it's part of our our policy requirements so this uh just shows you a map of the property there actually a there was a phase one of the property that that is actually in the Blue Area there that property the phase one has already been approved and is actually being constructed without a pump station so those uh developments are those properties that are within that and I believe it's all single family residential or mostly that actually is um is flowing by gravity to our system a pump station was not required for that however phase two which I'll show you some more information about that does require pump station
027for it to to actually be able to to work so to give you a breakdown of the actual development I'll try to show you here this is this lighter area is the phase one you can see that that's mostly sing single family there is some multif family in this area here but it's mostly a single family portion of the development this area in Gray is the uh request for the phase two which is the one that actually requires the pump station and you can see a breakdown of type of the development 75 single family homes 240 multifam um units a future fire station and then commercial or retail properties um that total a little over 149,000 Square ft so that that's everything that's sort of identified in this grayish area here there are a couple
028of ways to actually serve this property if a pump station were to be approved this actually doesn't have a gravity option and I'll talk about that in just a minute so alternative number one is where a pump station is actually constructed on the property and then it would actually pump the flow to an existing gravity line that actually then goes to our Poppin Pump Station Poppin is one of our largest pump station it's a regional Pump Station that ultimately flows all the way back to 12mile Creek um wastewater treatment plant where that's where the actual sewer is treated it could uh connect here and Flow by gravity to that pump station or it could connect at this location at pomac and flow there either way that's not really relevant that's just the options for that
029phase is pumping from the site directly to this gravity section it has a life cycle cost of about $2.1 million and and probably the reason for that you'll see the other one is higher is you have less line you're having to put in less less less of your actual sewer lines to put in to be able to make that um um make that work sure the alternative yes sir go ahead um go back show you that yes uh Brian ju just for clarification for everybody up here and out there when you say life cycle cost um can you expand on that about you know sure okay so uh we use 20 years as and John and and hung can step in here if I say something that's wrong but we use 20 years as as
030our gauge for life cycle for the the the actual Pump Station as well as the force man and any of the other components that go with it in a pump station there really a number of different uh years as far as the the life of a pump station there's the wet well there's the pumps themselves there's the electronics there's there's all kinds of components those all vary in the way they may last like a pump may only last 10 years but the electronics May last five or the wet well may last 30 years we use 20 as a total for everything we're going to replace some things in less than 20 years doesn't mean that we're going to wait 20 years and do work on it that's just how the cycle is actually developed did
031that help answer the question for it yes absolutely so um I think that that that kind of clarifies I think the point that um that everyone needs to understand is is that there is a maintenance cost here absolutely and and there there is a if approved then there will there will come a time where this pump will have to be uh either completely replaced or I mean there's going to be it's going to have to be maintained over the years absolutely and and I do want to point out that that 2.1 million does include The Upfront cost of building the pump station and everything so there is that they there is cost to that which the county does not pay that cost the developer pays the cost of actually building The Pump Station putting all
032the actual infrastructure in and then if approved by the board then it's accepted by the county we own it and maintain it so that 2.1 million is it's all in it's all of that do you know Brian do you know how much of that 2.1 million is the actual initial construction cost I do not know that off the top of my head no sir but but it is the County's responsibility once it's installed it is it is all ours we own it we maintain it if everything breaks we fix it so it's ours at that point in time yes ma'am exactly so alternative to uh is is a little bit different in that you actually Flow by gravity to an existing Pump Station so this is a gravity line that would have to be installed
033uh by the by the developer then connecting to an existing Pump Station which itself then pumps to this area here which is another gravity line that gravity line then flows to to another Pump Station which then ultimately pumps all the way back down to um your your Poppin and then goes to 12 M it's a roundabout way so it's not a true gravity solution you are ultimately still flowing it to a pump station the difference here is that this flow from this development actually requires improvements to this pump station which is the Porter Ridge Pump Station as well as improvements to the FI Stone Pump Station you actually are going to have to do some upgrades to those pump stations to accept that additional flow and all of that is baked into this life cycle
034cost of $3.6 million so while there's gravity and gravity as a whole is typically cheaper to build than a pump station and a force man you've got a long run of gravity and then you have the work you have to do on actually improving the pump stations which makes that life cycle cost a lot higher again that's over the 20-year time frame that we build that out to so when I said there really isn't a true gravity solution unfortunately for this piece of property there just isn't one gravity solution it's some form of a pump is what you need for that all right so whether or not to approve or or deny this is a utility based decision um you've got a couple of options here for the board and what your choices are you
035mean obviously the this particular Pump Station only serves that development so keeping in mind that the utility itself really looks for customers you're not expanding your customer base by having a single uh Pump Station that only serves that development um that is a negative obviously you on the positive obviously you are adding customers if you choose to approve this you are adding some customers to the system whether they're residential or commercial they are customers they ultimately do pay into the system but you're not able to spread those cost over more because you only serve that development as it is you do have your approval request there the development is ultimately served by the poplin Road Pump Station so it's an existing Pump Station um you're you're basically pumping from one pump to that ultimate Regional
036station it is already designed to handle a significant flow because it is a regional Pump Station so that is a positive if you were to look at that from that side I'll be happy to answer any questions that you have I know the attorney for the developer uh Mr Bennett is here I believe he has some things he'd like to say to you uh he had requested that the board consider delaying uh action on this um I I my goal here was to present you the information you can decide if you want to delay taking action on this or not it had already been sent out in the notice in the agenda and so that's a decision you can make do you have any questions for me uh Brian in in phase two U I
037want to make sure I'm clear when you describe part of of phase two with multifam would that be apartments or could that potentially be say town homes or Condominiums of some good question and I will actually let Mr Bennett answer that question because I am not sure if it is apartments or town homes and and I think it'd be better to let Mr Bennett answer that question okay does anyone have any questions for the county manager okay okay thank you thank you Ste good evening my name is Steven Bennett and I am a resident of waaw and I am also the attorney of the owner of the property um and this is of course sanctuary at Southgate a couple brief comments and I I'll try to address some of the questions that have come up
038this is a 2013 project and that is shocking that it's it's still going but it is here it was approved by the town of Indian Trail 12 years ago they wanted the project then and they still want it now we've had numerous talks with the town um as Mr Matthews um told you already most of the residential is already underway construction is already underway the real point of the this is at this point in time it is essentially a commercial project there's 150,000 Square ft of commercial that can't function without the pump station there's supposed to be a a grocery store tenant out there and then another 95,000 square feet of um retail and shops around it that was the goal um I am here I do have a representative of the owner with us
039we also have our engineer here to help answer any questions you guys might have um I I remember you guys had asked a question about the life cycle cost The Upfront cost of the pump station is a million and that's something the developer is picking up um Mr sides I think you had a question and that was in reference to Apartments is that correct the the multifam specifically Apartments Town Homes condos which you could be more specific that's correct okay so the original approval back in 2013 so this was a conditional District um and so the original approval back then was for apartments at that time thank you mam chair yes I have a question for Mr Bennett U Mr Bennett uh you made the comment that this is primarily commercial uh but the majority
040of the sewer capacity that would be fed to this pump station was serviced residential correct when we talk about are we talking about phase one or phase two I mean there are certainly pH two what we're looking at tonight I think there are residential components sure that are that are flowing into there for lack of a better term um I'm not an engineer and I please don't ask me to put numbers on that but I do have our engineer if you would like to know okay good evening Matt sinkovitz um to answer your question yes the majority of the allocated flow would be residential compared to the commercial component thank you and um and just so we're we're also clear the the commercial project in question here uh the commercial space would be future commercial
041correct that's correct so residential would be built first uh as intended right now yes okay thank you is there a timeline like what do you have in the contract that do you have to have the commercial side done within five years or 10 years I can't speak to the actual development timeline or is it just future uh yes ma'am so U Michael Slavic uh I'm representative of Walton the owner of the property uh yes we are actively uh working through a contract right now with a commercial developer that will uh build this out ideally they would like to build uh the entire front Ed right there on Rocky River all is one it at one uh at one time yes and that would be um in conjunction with the single family and town homes that
042are being developed by a separate Builder so they would be um different but what's the timeline the timeline would be it would take I mean about 12 months from now because you to go get construction drawings and uh approval through the town of Indian Trail would take about 12 months for them to break ground for commercial or for residential uh for both at the same time okay you said town homes so the the existing project that's in phase one has 52 Town Homes as approved on the conditional District the 240 multif family units cannot be converted to town homes unless approved by Indian Trail which we've never uh gone back to change it to town homes as we were just intending to go forward with the original approval thank you madam chair yes um thank
043you madam chair I'll make the motion that we deny the application request uh concerning the sanctuary at Southgate Phase 2 development for a new Wastewater Pump Station as such pump uh solution is set forth in the application associated with this uh request in accordance with Section 34- 336b uh one of the Union county code and second to adopt the utility based rationale statement for denial are there any questions comments All favor motion say I next on the agenda we had a request from commissioner Gary sides to discussed um I believe a district court judge I will turn it over to commissioner sides um thank you madam chairman during our uh discussions uh on the jail we have talked about potential bottlenecks in the uh judicial system and judge uh hux was kind enough our lead
044district court judge was kind enough to reach out to me and give me an opportunity to learn more about our legal Community here in Union County since I am not an attorney and fortunately have not been involved in the legal process myself in um in from that discussion it is obvious that there's a need for an additional district court judge in Union County um judge hux U explained to me that there's something that determines the amount of judges in a district called the District Court workload formula but unfortunately the most recent she was able to obtain was from 2020 she was also um not able to determine or it's not available the actual formula that is used to determine uh that that formula so what we did was we basically went by population which seems
045to make sense and draw and the reason I'm asking uh the board to consider a resolution for additional Court judges in in the information I'll give you in surrounding counties of which Union County currently has five district court judges and if you break that down by roughly 260,000 population that's one judge per 51,2 190 residents cabis County which is slightly smaller in population than Union County at 240,000 has six district court judges that's one judge for every 40,000 residents Gaston County has seven district court judges with a population also less than Union County at some 237,000 that's one judge per 33,8 91 residents ell county is a little bit different there there are actually two counties involved in that District but that uh that's ell and Alexander but they have a total of six district
046court judges with approximate total population of 236,000 that is one judge per 39,380 63 residents now many of you may have been under the misconception as I was that your district court judges do not handle your major criminal cases you divorces child custody tickets what have you but they do are responsible for class H and I felonies which could involve potential time in our County jail for those accused of those crimes so that that in turn could impact the length of stay so I would like to with the uh without any disent from our U my colleagues I'd like to ask uh Jason to prepare a resolution to ask our general assembly delegation to fund allocate and fund an additional additional district court judge for Union County and if anyone has any questions I'll do
047my best to answer so you're only asking for one yes ma'am okay commissioner HMS um so first of all let me um thank commissioner sides for you know looking into some of the discussion that we've had on the bottlenecks um so to through I should say through the through the chair sorry easy for me to say um through the chair to commissioner sides so did Judge hu um express some optimism then that should we add another District Court judge that she felt as though this would expedite the process about uh possibly um reducing the length of stay there for our jail definitely would have an impact on the judicial system moving moving it uh those involved faster through the system and as we learned in our orientation there's not only increase you have increase in
048in uh cases that cause those a waiting a trial to be in the jail it's also as the crimes are more severe their length of stay that they're actually staying in the jail is longer so you want to try and of course impact both would have uh would have a you know bias some more times more space or at least have an impact on the increase I also asked because I had originally mentioned Superior Court judge and uh again something I did not realize if you add a superior court judge that is for the entire district and may not have an impact actually on Union County because they would also be responsible for other counties where a district court judge would be responsible for uh this District which I believe is 30 which is just
049Union County so uh I also learned that adding a superior court judge may not have as much an impact as a district court judge potentially could m chair I have a question yes um this will be to staff do we know if we have room in the courthouse for another judge do we have a courtroom available for a full-time position they would they would schedule the court rooms we do have an office aail available for another district court judge so they they would have to schedule around an additional judge um but they they'd be able to manage that we we do have one additional office that we could put that position in she judge hux did did say that yes they could manage schedules to accommodate another one Madam chair um to to staff here
050Patrick uh I believe that one thing that that was said during our retreat was that and please correct me if I'm wrong for I misunderstood but we could get some more utilization out of the courtrooms that we currently have correct that they're not being used to their maybe I misunderstood what you said but U but there's some avail ability there with the courtrooms that we currently have yeah I think the question was around whether all courtrooms are being used and they are not all being used all the time but they are all being used so I I do think there is some available capacity within those courtrooms to accommodate another uh judge in that schedule okay thank you I have another question so this would be an elected position correct yes okay secondly if the
051general assembly approves it in the the next session how quick could that turnaround be would it be an off election cycle Jason may know this better than I um he's probably more familiar with it I I do not know the answer to that question that would depend largely on the way that they framed the legislation as to whether uh you could have somebody in that seat more quickly than the next general election uh it's conceivable they could uh appoint someone into or bring someone from another uh area of the Court structure in there are a lot of different options but that's in within the discretion of the general assembly just for Just for kicks and Giggles how quick could they turn that around when you say turn that around to to for the funds and
052to even if there's an appointment to that position how quick could that all of that transpire the legislature moves in mysterious ways but uh I would uh I I would think 6 months to a year would be a reasonable time frame to get some get some change but um there a lot of moving parts that we have no control over right Jason does does adding a judge is that considered local legislation that can sometimes move faster or is that uh it would it would be a public bill to add a number of judges to the district not not just local legislation wel thank you thank you madam chair commissioner sides um all right you said we're our current ratio would be is one judge per 51,000 citizens I think yes one judge per 51,2 190
053people which is the highest ratio of any surrounding counties all right so my question is if we added one more judge what would that make the ratio be well I didn't do that math but that Le get us in line with most of the other counties in our area Gaston has seven we have five they have less population so um and ell has has six so everybody else has at least six Gaston has seven so uh at least would get us on par now if you'd like me to revise um a resolution to ask for two I'm glad to do it but um I don't know the space requirements on that but I got the feeling that that one is of a dire need ask thank you thank you commissioner sides Madam chair yes so
054this question is probably the staff um not that long ago we approved an expansion with uh the judicial Center correct so if memory serves me um right we also approved two additional Das is that also were were were there not two District Attorneys added recently uh not recently but we do fund two assistant district attorney positions okay so that weren't added but we we we fund them was this was the possibility of an an additional district court judge was that anything that we looked at in the whole judicial study at all so my understanding is that you know the need for additional courtroom space was gauged on the fact that we do need some additional um judges to help with that um so I won't say that that was the the primary driving Factor but
055we were aware that we need an additional courtroom space in the future I I'll just maybe this will help some of your questions as well if we do move forward with an actual resolution I did ask judge hux if she could be present when we are entertaining that resolution to answer specific questions which I am not equipped to answer maybe that would help everyone with especially with the B issue and everything else how how district courts could potentially impact our uh length of stay at the jail did you have a question I've got yes through the chair um commissioner s are would you be willing to share this information with the other board members that you have the numbers oh certainly certainly I just have it in note form and I'll be glad to um
056share an email and she also provided some documentation and I apologize I just received it this morning so I didn't have a time to uh distribute it but I will be glad to get all this information out to everyone that would be very helpful um because we're sitting here without a lot of information and I just want to uh remind the board that one of our legislative priorities is to ask for a superior court judge so if there is a change or an addition to that legislative priorities list we'd probably want to add add this along with the resolution so I I want to go back to commissioner Brian HMS this point it was brought to us last year um the request to um renovate and upgrade and expand the judicial Center and I I
057do not recall um staff bringing this request to us so this seems at the time we did not receive a request so this is the first time you've heard of this request I'm not aware yeah generally we at a local level do not get involved in asking for judge positions this is something um in my tenure here this is the first time we've had any discussion I will say as part of the space needs analysis they did meet with the judicial uh officials and that was a need they knew the population was growing the case load was growing so they knew they were going to need another judge at some point and additional courtroom space Superior Court Judge uh district court judge but this this is this was part of a space need needs analysis
058that was done let's say about four or five years ago at this point but again we we have never taken a position to proactively uh pitch the legislator to add that generally it's been more reactive that when we uh like the public defender office that came in this last budget year we didn't we didn't know it was coming we didn't ask for it but we got it and then we you know had to scramble I will say a singular judge is a lot easier for space for than a office of 18 public defenders so I'd like to make a recommendation I think this has been a healthy discussion this is new information for at least four of us um so I would like to know I I think we need to do some more homework
059I would like staff to speak with judge hux and for staff to get some more information and I would like for staff to come back back to us at a later date soon and let us know what that ratio would be for Union County if we are 1 to 51,000 um right now um I would like to know what that ratio would be if we added um a second district court judge just so we can have some hard numbers since we've heard what other Counties have I would I think it would be helpful for us to know what the ratio would be um a real number what it would be if we were able to petition um the general assembly you know with a possible resolution to um request a second second judge position I
060think we'll ask judge answer some questions that's just beyond you know our our scope and then I think some clarification on um who would make that appointment until an election process was held commissioner bcol no I think this is very interesting discussion and I I commend commissioner s for bringing this to light you know now Jason I don't know how good at math Jason is but we were sitting here hammering through this and and our our guess is one if we haded won that bring us down to like 42,000 one judge per 42,000 to 42,500 if we added two judges it would bring us around interesting in my discussion with judge hux is this the way she put it is whenever uh a county or a judge such as herself requests through the legislature additional
061judges they bring up this District Court workload formula but the latest she can get her hands on is basically 5 years old and they do not share the formula that they use so we basically came up with our own formula based on population and how many these other districts judges these Counties have so I'm really concerned that our lead District Court Judge can't find out from the state Authority that controls this exactly what formula they use and why she can't get an updated one and that's what our legislators uh or the legislature uses to determine how many we get that makes no sense so I I would I would encourage us to to dive into that further too and judge hux can elaborate further I'm sure yes sir okay thank you very much um next
062on our agenda is item 25- 095 jail discussion I will turn it over to County Manager Brian Matthews or Clayton buer no he's he's open it up for me I'm GNA sit here and talk so instead of going up there um so at at our Retreat and we had a very good discussion with the board about some upcoming capital projects in jail uh obviously was a very big part of that discussion and so you asked for some additional information we're bringing that back and then just you know if the board wishes to have some additional discussion and we we're available you know tonight to do that one of the the things that the Sheriff's Office had provided which the board was very uh pleased to see was the comparison of our population as far as
063total population and how we compare to other counties of somewhat similar size and where they stood with their jail bed capacity and their core then so that was provided but what you got at that time were actually um mostly the counties that were around our same size bunkham County was a little bit greater than than us and in population but then you basically had cabis and Johnston and d and um and Gaston which are all lower but they but they have bed sizes that that range from in the 500s to 600 range inmate size so the board ask well you know what does that look like for populations that are bigger but maybe closer to what our population is estimated to be in 2030 and 2040 and 2050 so what you have here is you've
064got a chart and it kind of breaks it down and so first it gives you in the blue that is the the D the population that our comp plan uses um which is really developed from the region so CPO which is is a regional trans transation agency they develop population projections and we're a a member of that and so we use those population projections in our in our comp plan and that's what you see in the blue what you see in the the yellow or gold are the population projections that come from the state demographer now they're different because one is a 2025 and then a 2035 and a 2045 whereas the other one's a 2030 a 2040 and a 2050 so they're off by you know 5 years but it give you an idea
065of what um each one of those different U sources has as far as population if you were to look at um the CPO data as what we compared ourselves to because that's what we used in our comp plan then the closest that would come to the county and 2035 as we as we expected to grow would be Durham and Cumberland um that they would be close to what we would be now that's today understand they're going to grow over that same time frame as well but today they would be the closest to what that population would be and they have respectively a 736 bed jail capacity and a 568 bed capacity now if you look at forye and Gilford way off I mean they're a lot bigger um they have extreme large um bed counts
066you know over a, and 1300 and and so I don't think those comparisons are really are are fair for us because they are so large and and the other thing to keep in mind is that you know for Durham understand a Durham has a larger City in it and so I think you would you that's a that's a different um that's a different Dynamic that we would have to take into consideration so for for us I think your best um compar are going to be with like bunam a cabis a Johnston Gaston those are going to be more similar to for us as far as growth in population and probably inmate size at some point in time again not saying that the board has to build a 600 bed jail we're just saying that for
067comparison purposes this is about the range you see for for populations that are somewhat similar to our size any questions questions for me on that you have at your um seats which is not I don't have that in presentation form some additional information that the Sheriff's Office had provided you um and that is again I think some good data that they have for you to look at and ultimately what we're going to be seeking from the board is some direction again that doesn't have to be tonight but some direction on how you wish the second phase of the jail study to be complet Ed and to do that the consultant really needs some parameters some bookends to say what size facility and is is are they going to look at to evaluate you know what
068does it take to build it how does it how do you operate it what is the Staffing those types of things that you really need to have a size in mind so that they can finish that part of it um again not saying you have to make that decision tonight but we are going to need some Direction from the board at some point in the very near future so that we can move forward with finishing that study any questions for me um I do not have any questions I just appreciate um getting this this information back based on our our request at The Retreat do you have some questions um thank you madam chair I you know I I think that as we look at this I I think first of all um great observations
069because as we look at some of these other counties here I don't know that that's a I mean it's a comparison but they're very different than Union um some of these are going to be very U they're going to have very large urban populations where Union County doesn't have that um and so you know looking at the numbers here I like the comparison with Johnston County um and I think that that sort of Falls in line with what we heard from our Sheriff at our retreat uh pretty close anyway um and so to to be clear what we're discussing at this moment right here is for the second part of the study this is not a final approval but what we were looking at is is essentially you know should we decide to press forward
070what are the parameters and then if I understand correctly and please correct me wrong if I'm wrong uh Mr County manager but uh but at that point the consultant would then bring back uh more concrete numbers to the board for final consideration and then we would deliberate on how you would go about paying for something like this that's correct so you would get some estimates and you would get some staffing data cuz obviously Staffing and operating it has a significant cost you get some estimates on that you get some estimates on on construction costs and then that would be factored into the board making a decision on do you move forward with constructing a jail and if so how do you fund that is that a general obligation bond with with a referendum is that
071paying for that out of a you know a limited obligation bond which doesn't require a vote of the of the people those decisions would be made at a later time now I will you know we'll say you know we gave a number of recommendations for the board to consider at The Retreat we can provide you with that information again if you don't have that for your you to be able to look over while you're you deciding I I if the board is okay I will schedule this probably at one of your March meetings to get some direction on what do you want to do with this item unless you're ready to give us some direction tonight I will put it on probably your probably your first meeting in March to get some direction will we
072be hearing um from Christopher Boyd is he going to chime in at any point and give us a facilities perspective we've we've heard you know this information is is he going to come back I know he made a presentation to us last year um for all facilities or for a jail in particular talking about a Jil um I mean he can always come back with we weren't sure that the the board um Wanted additional information from Chris we're happy to have him come back and speak to to you about this um you tell us what additional information you need and we will be happy to have him come so I just want to go back we've received all this information the reason I bring that up is because he had done a presentation on a
073um I believe a 400 bed with a 500 core or a 500 with a 500 and a 600 with the 500 and um if if you can speak for him I assume y'all have spoken we um do you still stand by those numbers or do you not so that's why I bring it up and I'll be happy to uh we had I anticipated that at the time where the board's making a decision we would have that on the board so you can see that I didn't anticipate you'd make a decision tonight but I I did anticipate that when we brought it back we would show you those options again we would have some revised General estimates for those costs um and we'd show you okay if you chose a 400 and a 600 this is
074an estimated cost here's a 4800 here's a 600 and 800 we could give you those estimates and then have a you know a bigger discussion about that so it was my intention to have that whether it's Chris prent or or me or anyone else we were going to have that information well that's why I brought it up I didn't hear it so I wanted to ask you know if we would be hearing or you know circling back to that that information again or has that been thrown out the window no absolutely not and and my my mistake I I didn't think the board was ready to make a decision so that's why I didn't that's why I didn't put it I just asking if he would be coming back yes ma'am we will have that
075information for you okay thank you commiss hand that just tells me you like Chris and that's okay I'm all right with that Mr manager uh Chris is back there he looks like a cat ready to LEAP out of his seat yeah I know I'm not call up but it's okay we are now yeah I guess so um yeah I'm happy I you know I'm sitting back there going I I you know I want to get up um I'm happy to come back anytime discuss any numbers I think it may be important that uh report you saw I guess it was in last March is when we did that yeah um it started at you know really low numbers you know we had ranges from I think 250 you know to you know all the way
076up to I think 600 800 was the the top I don't do you want me to go back through those low numbers no the chart I'm specifically remembering was three lines and it was like a 400 600 core 500 600 core 6 600 600 because that was what you brought to us and then we were requested for I believe an 800 core or something and I just distinctly remember that was significantly higher than what the three options you brought to us yeah so no I I don't want to hear anything you know about like a 250 because obviously that's not where we need to be that's right so commissioner HMS thank you madam chair um yeah I remember the study or the chart that you're referring to and and yes it did have those three
077options I you know look I'm of the opinion that we don't need um 800 to 1200 beds um again I I like the comparison here with Johnston um and of course the board can deliberate that but I think that that chart that uh commissioner Merill was talking about um gets us some closer options to some of the relative comparisons that we see here yeah um so I I agree I I think that would be very helpful for us okay moiss SS um one of the questions I have for myself in determining this issue is how long the next jail we buil just the next one how long do we want it to to last in other words before we have to go in and start expanding the core and expanding the jail I think to
078me that is kind of the question that gets you to the capacity numbers now however we Finance it it's going to take 20 years to pay off I think to me and some of the projections the consultant did were 25 years out personally I'd like to build a facility at least to have the initial capacities to handle the 25-year projections so that future boards are not going in and expanding it before it's even paid for I I I I go back to the example of the judicial Center I don't believe it's paid off yet if if and we're already making arrangements to find other spacing now is that going to be the cheapest route well no but um I think the best value because we all know whatever future years it is that have to
079come out to expand either the core or the the sales thems that is going to be more expensive than today next month is going to be more expensive than today next year is going to be more expensive than today so I'm trying to I'm trying to project out 25 years which would be uh what would be sufficient to meet the needs in in that year and and just I'll I'll get the conversation going I I don't think we need anything less than an 800 core 600 bed jail that's that's just me analyzing the information so far and I hear what you're saying but if we're going to be around four so our average daily incarceration right now is let's just it's under 300 I struggle to ask the taxpayers to build an 800 bed jail
080if it's going to take if it's going to take 20 years or whatever to get to that number um but I appreciate you know your thoughts on that commissioner HMS well and to that point too I believe the consultant said that the jail is going to last 25 to maybe 30 years so we'll have a five plus year stent where it's not being paid for commissioner commissioner Brams thank you madam chair um and two I believe that through this study we we've learned a couple of things okay and one of the things that we learned that we didn't know before is that our core is well the core can be designed and built so that it's expandable okay and I think that that's key because um from if I understand it correctly you know we
081could look at at a smaller scale for the time being but design it in a manner in which we would have the option to expand that core at a later time and my our understand and so I think that that's something that we probably need to or maybe staff can with the consultant to get some clarification there but that's my understanding and and to commissioner sides um to his concern there I would argue that that's something that we should take to the consultant and say hey this is a concern of ours um and and I think that the onus then becomes on the designers uh on this project to say okay well we're going to start with a 600 core size or 500 core or whatever it may be uh but we're going to design
082this thing in a in a method so that it could be expandable in 30 years to 600 800 whatever it is and so I I think that you design it with options yeah I agree with that because I remember at The Retreat um Sheriff Kathy was real quick on his feet um and it was funny because I was you know doing it the oldfashioned way and trying to come up with the number my number matched his number um I think it was um we were going to be you know around 400 um inmates per day at at at 2030 year 2030 we were going to be in the neighborhood of maybe 400 um average daily population so again I think it's very you know the fact that we can um expand the core that it
083is expandable um is one reason I don't want to go all the way to 800 or 1200 um right off the bat um I think we need to do what we can afford and not overburden the taxpayers um with something that's you know all the way out to 20 250 plus so um I say you know we need to reconvene and um come up with the number where where to start to get us um to the completion where how many beds do we need at completion and and nothing less and then um you know give them parameters that it can be expandable whether it's the bed the number of beds or the core yes u i I certainly understand I guess I was just trying to my personal philosophy is the next jail we build
084I would like to have it be sufficient in capacity so that future boards don't have to expand it until at least it's paid for now you all may decide you know that's that's not feas and and that that's fine I understand it but that's kind of the way I'm looking at trying to build backwards if you will will 20 years out what do we need a jail to last at least 20 years before it has to be expanded yes most definitely it should be designed to be expanded extensively hopefully with the right maintenance we can make this thing last 50 years or more but of the of the initial the next jail we're going to build I would hope we would build it of sufficient capacity that at least it wouldn't have to be expanded
085until the original is paid for so so 20 years so how big a jail do we need if we stepped in time 20 years from now is is kind of the way I'm coming for if that helps at all and you all may not feel that you know you might feel well if they have to come back in 10 or 15 years that's fine and and that's certainly your your right to do what I was just trying to offer some some uh Food For Thought on how to go about making a decision on the optimum size if if it helps commissioner BR HMS thank you madam chair um one other thing that I'd like to point out and maybe remind staff um maybe a request of Staff maybe that's a better way to put it
086is we did have some discussion at our Retreat about the current jail facility and whether or not any of that building could be salvaged repurposed re you know for whatever um but I mean obviously the County's got some some some needs and so I I would also like more information when we start discussing this again if possible about what we can use um the old facility for maybe it's an Annex maybe it's you know whatever but uh but I I think that that there has to be something that we can utilize that for may not be a prison or a jail it may be something else but uh but I like some options yeah I I think once the board uh you know decides on this is the the the the study parameters we would
087also approach the consultant and ask them to include in the scope evaluating the um existing facility and give us some options on what it can be used for how you know what is a good purpose for that facility obviously that would take a little more time CU that wasn't in the original scope but it would be our opinion we would add that cuz the board did bring that up at our Retreat so we would want to discuss that with the consultant and we have to keep in mind um that the existing jail does have is failing and um what and and we would want to hear from the consultant or whoever facilities whoever um if we did want to keep that as a functional um space what is that going to take to retrofit and
088make it usable um because it does have problems which has brought us to where we are today absolutely any other comments or questions commissioner I'm afraid my comments may be taking us backwards a little bit I think one of my greatest frustrations well I would like to say this first I believe we can work together and make our best educated guest and move to ball for and then determine how we're going to do this thing pay for it referendum how how we're going to do that but what really concerns me is oversight during the construction process so we don't end up building back on a a nonsolid footing yeah and so we I would argue that our jail would be may not be failing now word on a solid footing so that's that's my big
089concern any other comments or questions no okay okay we've added some things we ask a question of the chair if are we prepared to say that uh this will be on the the the first meeting in March agenda to to yes make it okay we will bring that at the first meeting in the March for the board at least give us some Direction get direction then it goes to the consultant for more pricing and specific information timeline Staffing Etc and then we would make a a final decision including financing is that yeah my guess is that the the board would have that information probably to plus months okay and then um you would we would put that on a meeting and let you discuss it and give us a final decision on what you want
090to do with that so I'm I'm thinking probably 60 plus days from some after the March meeting okay I will now turn it over to the county manager for manager comments the only thing I'd like to say is I thought we had a very good retreat with the board on on February 12th we did not finish all our items but I think that's actually not a bad thing because me there was a lot of discussion whole lot of interest in the information that we had and I I wanted to say thank you for your time that day we are going to swing back and and and hit those areas that we were not able to get to we're going to send you a calendar for Budget meetings so that we can get going on that
091but I did want to say thank you I thought that was a really good exercise for the board thank you commissioner Clancy welcome um the only thing I would say is I just appreciate the U attitudes and the way we work together as a board we we you know we don't always agree but I that we're very respectful to one another and I appreciate all the staff and all their efforts and the work they put into what we do and encourage everybody to be safe on the way home commissioner Christina HMS thank you um Madam chair um first of all I'd like to thank um the municipality of Wesley Chapel for being the first ones out of the gate to help our senior nutrition and especially the staff for reaching out to all the municipalities
092um hopefully they will come back soon um with some numbers that they can assist their um their seniors with um I'd also like the municipalities to consider um the house bill 382 um and I'm also going to call on um representative Mark Brody Dean ARP Todd Johnson and David Willis to um put into legislation a single item bill in lie of what we currently have um 382 was originally designed for relief in Western North Carolina for the flood damage and now we've got the density density issue with that so again I'm calling on our uh local legislation our Representatives excuse me to pass a single item bill for the state I agree with that commissioner HMS and I think the focus needs to be on Western North Carolina um instead of a broad stretch over
093all 18 100 counties and let's make sure we um focus on Western North Carolina commissioner Brian HS thank you madam chair um I I will Echo commissioner Christina Helm's comments thanking um Wesley Chapel um for uh their support with senior meals um I also want to thank uh Mineral Springs because Mineral Springs RS adopted a resolution um uh very similar to what Union County has adopted against SP 382 um and there may be other municipalities I'm just aware of Mineral Springs but uh I want to thank them uh think as normal thank all of our staff uh for for being here um I thought that the The Retreat that we had was was very productive um and kudos to staff for uh for all the effort that you guys put into uh making that success
094um we've got the threat of severe weather winter weather coming on coming up here U maybe in the morning or uh for that matter it might be Thursday from what I'm hearing it's kind of a moving Target but uh but what I'll say is I I I hope that everybody stays safe um and I certainly wish that uh that all the kids get a whole bunch of snow but uh but but more importantly uh stay safe out there thank you commissioner ODS I would uh also like to thank uh staff for the retreat I found the information invaluable um I know folks it seems like this jail issue has been before us for well it preceded me well before but I would hope you would be encouraged by noting that your County Commission uh this
095this board does not take decisions that involve um nine fig potentially nine figures of uh commitment from the taxpayers lightly and are looking at this from all different angles I feel very confident when it comes to make a decision we will be able to find a balance between what meets needs into the future but yet is cost effective for today's taxpayer and I hope you all will be stay safe in whatever weather we encounter and uh I wish you a good evening okay thank you everyone I'll um accept a motion to adjourn all those in favor say I hi good night for