CorpusRecord 192755

Board of County Commissioners | Regular Meeting | February 3, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / UnionCountyNC
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Union County, KY
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,209 words · about 96 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e you okay I'd like to call the February 3rd 2025 regular meeting of the Union County Board of Commissioners to order at this time I will provide the invocation if you would like to join dearly father thank you very much for your provision your protection and your continued blessings over Union County North Carolina we are so thankful for what you do for the citizens of this County we pray for our Farmers law enforcement those that choose to teach in our schools work in our libraries our fire departments EMS we ask you to protect them bless them and dearly father I just want to praise you and ask you to give us guidance and wisdom to make decisions that are always in the very best interest of those that we serve and it's in

002your name that I pray amen if everyone would please stand I pledge alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with libery and justice for all that brings us to informal comment I believe we do have a couple of people that signed up online and let's see let's make it very formal here each speaker must address the board from the lect and begin their remarks by first giving their name stating whether they are residents of Union County and indicating the municipality within which they reside any each speaker will have three minutes to make remarks a tone may sound at the conclusion of your remarks a speaker may not yield any of his or her time to another speaker speakers may not

003discuss matters which are the subject of public hearings and they must be courteous in their language and presentation restatements or repetitive comments by the same speaker whether at the same or a separate meeting may be ruled out of order and terminated by the chair personal tax will not not be tolerated speakers may leave WR written comments and or supporting documents if any with our clerk to the board we will begin tonight with Meredith Mah good evening everyone hope you're doing well today my name is Meredith Mar I'm here with John Thomasson uh I live in Indian Trail and um John is also a member of Union County as well we're here to introduce trees Union which is a growing Grassroots organization founded in 2023 with members across Union County all dedicated to enhancing the area's

004tree canopy with the goal of improving residents lives health safety and quality of life we're fortunate to have the expertise of Union County's urban forestry program and establishing supporting our initiatives through this collaboration and other Partnerships we're addressing the critical challenge of tree canopy loss as our growing County continues to develop particularly in areas like waxa Indian Trail and Monroe Union County's planning department projects we will have around 400,000 residents by 2025 which is about a 60% increase our strongest partnership is with Union County Public Schools where we've already made significant impact working closely with UC CPS administrators and facility staff we planted 36 trees this last fall at local elementary schools creating Better Learning environments and safer playgrounds for generations of students we also planted some trees on the Monroe Greenway to add shade

005to a very sunny portion of the path combined with our three tree plantings that we did this fall we engaged over a hundred parent and student volunteers at Stallings elementary Union Elementary and the Monroe Greenway fostering environmental stewardship research showed the trees deliver crucial public health benefits Treeline streets have been shown to improve Traffic Safety while strategic tree placement um can reduce residential energy costs by up to 25% for our children trees trees around schools playgrounds and homes correlate with reduced ADHD symptoms lower asmin rates among many other benefits for fiscal year 2026 we're looking forward to expanding our impact through three key initiatives planting two 200 trees at Union County um Public Schools we're projecting we're uh we've got a goal of reaching about 25% tree canopy coverage around the playground areas um Distributing

006a thousand seedlings at community and Arbor Day events to engage the residents in the public and providing 10 200 trees to neighborhoods with below average canopy coverage we are you know brand new so we operate a lean ship we are able to dedicate over 97% of of our funding and donations directly to tree plantings and distribution and we do this through maintaining strong Partnerships with local organizations municipalities businesses and volunteers we're seeking your support to help create a Greener and healthier and more prosperous Union County that maintains a its natural character while accommodating growth thank you so much for your time I'm happy to answer any questions you may have I just to Lear you're welcome out of curiosity what SI of tree do you typically plant we go I'm sorry if you'd like some

007personal recommendations I'm in the tree business I'm just that's it full disclosure partner we're focusing on Native trees we want to diversify the tree canopy a lot of you know developments come in and they plant only one or two types of trees but it's really in our best interest to have a diverse base of trees going with seedlings or larger material are they like three gallon five gallon 10 gon so around the schools we're shooting for I think SE uh 15 gallons because yeah this the kids are a little rough on the trees if you plant if you plant the seven gallons it's most likely just to get snapped um but when we do our tree giveaways we're going to do seven gallon trees yeah and the seedlings are much smaller they're like you know

008tiny little things so so crep myrtles I don't think crepe myrtles are on the docket although they are lovely So when you say native yeah give us two or three uh Red Bud um you've got red Maples they are um domestic um you've got uh Lobby what is it loli all kinds of Oaks all kinds of Oaks Live Oaks um yeah just I name a couple um so my grandfather used to tell me that if you got a 15 gallon tree you got to have a 30- gallon hole um who digs the holes for these things so we've got great relationships with the urban forestry department and they have great relationships with the parks and re departments so most of the time for all of our plantings we're able to get um County Parks and

009wreck people to come out get an augur and dig the holes for us so when we do that I mean it literally we to 24 trees in an hour with you know a couple hundred volunteers and it was a piece of cake and everyone had a great time perfect thank you you're welcome it was nice to meet you thank you so much a nice thing to learn yes one more and I'll quit um do you have an approved species list that you work by I'm sorry do you have an approved species list that you work by I'm not sure I'm not I'm not sure we do John do you this is John Thomasson he works with uh he's our coordinator between the rotary clubs and Boy Scouts he helps kind of manage all our tree

010plantings and thankfully we have some very experienced people like our our PhD County arborist and it depends on the job so we try to get the right trees for the right job um so there's not a there are lists of of native trees there are lists of from the landscape Association there are lists of great to trees and name trees for the areas but we try to put in the right trees with the right job okay I'm good thanks well we look forward to you coming back and giving us an upate dat later love to look looking forward to thank you so so much our next speaker is Katie Ryan good evening Commissioners my name is Katie Ryan and I'm a proud president of Union County in the town of Stallings I'm also president of

011Spain North Carolina and the leader of change for Union County a volunteer group that works hand inand with Union County Animal Services our volunteers contribute over 3,000 hours to the local animal shelter tonight I here to bring attention to an issue that directly affects the quality of life of your constituents we recently conducted a survey and over 350 Union County residents shared their frustration about the state of Animal Welfare in our County their message was clear we need change we are advocating for common sense Solutions solutions that respect our Traditions as a rural community while also ensuring Public Safety and Animal Welfare we ask you to establish an animal services committee let's bring together the right people veterinarians nonprofit leaders business owners livestock owners to have a real conversation about the challenges our county is

012experiencing this would not be unprecedented the Commissioners already benefit from 19 other citizen advisory groups it's time to give Animal Services the same level of attention our Count's animal ordinances haven't been updated since 1997 and they no longer fit the reality of Union County our ordinances are outdated unclear and ineffective they do little to prevent animal cruelty and provide limited enforcement power to our Animal Control Officers the challenges extend beyond ordinances our Animal Control Officers are stretched too thin we need more of them Union County has grown by 40% in the last 20 years but our shelter has not grown with it in just the last four years shelter impoundments have increased 20% in 2024 very sadly for the first time healthy and adoptable animals were euthanized not due to illness but due to space

013an animal services committee can help us plan strategically to ensure our shelter meets the needs of a growing County we know that spaying and neutering reduces the number of unwanted animals uh this County's investment in in a shelter veterinarian was a great step and we all applaud you for that now let's take the next step we asked the county to award a community partner Grant to the Humane Society of Union County which operates the Monroe lowcost spay neuter clinic County funded affordable spay neuter would help seniors veterans and limited income families and drastically reduce the number of animals being abandoned and surrendered at the shelter animal services isn't often at the top of the County's agenda but it should be because it fects your constituents every single day tonight we're asking you just to take

014the first simple step and discuss forming an animal services committee with us we can bring the right people to the table we can work together with animal control to find solutions that make sense for both our rural traditions and the future of a growing Union County we can create a safer and healthier Community for both residents and animals alike thank youer she oh my goodness hello Commissioners thank you for having us here tonight my name's Laura S I live in wingit I have been and a Union County resident for 24 years now and just over 15 years of that has been as an animal welfare Advocate um so today I'm here to Second Katie's request that we talk about having an animal um Services committee and I would also like to highlight the critical issue

015of the urgent need for affordable spay and neuter Services um the rising cost uh Veterinary Care has made even lowcost spay neuter options inaccessible for many residents particularly seniors veterans and families with limited incomes every single day we receive pleas from people calling wanting to do the right thing and they don't have the money to do it and there's only so much that we can do ourselves to help um the lack of affordable Spain Services has far-reaching consequences increased animal abandonment including on the property of the Humane Society they get put over our fence and left in our parking lot frequently stray dogs roaming rural roads creating hazards for residents and drivers families overwhelmed by unexpected litters they cannot care for and over overcrowding at the animal shelter forcing healthy and adoptable animals to be

016euthanized when space Runs Out in desperation some residents have resorted have resorted to abandoning their pets in unsafe conditions endangering both the animals and the public we do thank the county for funding the veterinarian at the shelter to do the span neuter of the shelter animals we also want to thank you for a previous one-time gift to the Humane Society where we were able to take County money and alter 576 animals um with the money provided and that made a huge dent um since its Inception in 2011 the Monroe loow cost spay neuter clinic has performed over 44,50 spay neuter surgeries this has prevented thousands of unwanted litters and is helping to significantly reduce shelter intake between 2010 and 2020 however since 2020 the intake has gone back up approximately 20% or 19% excuse me

017by forming an animal services committee and supporting affordable spay spay neuter initiatives we can reduce stray and abandon animals ease the burden on an overcrowded shelter and create safer neighborhoods for residents with additional County funding we can expand these critical Services we provide to low-income pet owners preventing thousands more of unwanted animals from entering the shelter system this is a practical practical Common Sense solution and with immediate measurable benefits for our community the Humane Society is set my time's up thank you for for your for listening then thank you very um good evening Commissioners my name is April Thomasson and I am a resident of wingit North Carolina I'm a little bit nervous so okay um so I am here on the behalf of House of pearls we are a nonprofit located halfway in Wing

018the city of wing and halfway in Union County kind of on the on the edge there um we are a one-year nonprofit or one-year drug re abilitation program for women who struggle with addictions I actually here to back them up um I'm speaking tonight because Union County's outdated animal ordinances have had a direct and serious impact on our property a few months ago three female dogs were abandoned on our property and took up residence under our buildings we did what any responsible property owner would do and we called animal control for help but because these dogs were not considered dangerous they couldn't do anything about it so we were stuck with it the situation quickly escalated these female dogs gave birth and before we knew it we had 17 dogs and puppies on our property

019that we didn't even want still no one from Animal Control could help um and no one could find the owners because there wasn't any kind of law Union County doesn't have a leash law and our ordinances do not hold people accountable for letting their animals roam we wanted to do the right thing but the cost of Spain neutering and vaccinating 17 dogs was over $5,000 a financial burden we should never have to had to Bear thankfully the animal rescue Community stepped up to help us today we've kept all the adult dogs but this situation took months of work and should have never happened in the first place people should not be allowed to let their dogs wander and I I want to add to that I got I don't have long these dogs broke loose

020from a situation because they weren't being taken care of and they came to us and we couldn't turn them away had they been taken care of this wouldn't have happened um this this stuff should come with fines and consequences for the people who do this this is not just our story across the county dozens and dozens of residents are struggling with loose dogs abandoned animals and a lack of enforcement we need Common Sense updates to our ordinances to reflect the reality of Union County today not the way it was in 1997 we urge you to take the first steps by forming the animal services committee to evaluate our animal laws which need changing let's create clear enforceable policies and protect those both residents and animals thank you thank you thank you my name is Todd

021barber I live at a 2007 a story of drive at Indian Trail I appreciate the opportunity to speak uh I speak here today on my own accord not on behalf of the Town staff or the entire elected body first off congratulations to miss HS Mr side Mr balam on your hard fault successful November election um i' like to congratulate Miss Merill and Mr Helms on your appointment as chair and vice chair first off I'd like to thank the county and its park and rec team for the placement of ice skating ring in Indian Trail I'm sure the residents enjoyed it I'd like to thank Mr HS for coming to speak to our Council the other night about the resolution concerning SB 382 council member Ember I understand has placed it on the next agenda the

022I agree with the county and local municipality should be allowed to restrict high density residential zoning um matter of fact it's during the meeting I got a rare text from my wife asking who the real professional guy was that was speaking all I can say Mr HMS You Can't Hide handsome I was like of all the people you a man um uh the county and the town work together on putting a water line in over at Emerald Woods an Indian Trail and uh understand that's progressing and I we we appreciate that getting people off well water we have the same situation actually worse in the neighborhood in Indian Trail it's called moris Park Community I'd like to thank y'all understand y'all did the entire design for that and I told a resident some of them

023that I would come down here when it started pushing budget time to appeal to your good nature of maybe we can do the same thing uh you know I'm sure the residents would appreciate it I understand the county is second up setting up its own Economic Development commission I think it's a great idea and hopefully it will serve the municipalities in a bigger and better capacity our town does not have an economic development position on staff and we do not have an economic development board so I appeal to your good nature if the county be while setting this up consider Indian Trail having a presence in this new Endeavor that you're taking on I don't think we had a official capacity in the one before so uh that's just my thinking you may have different

024but I like to commend the bo this board for exercising patience physical constraint and common sense in regards to expanding sewer capacity I appreciate the county expanding 12 Mile Creek and other approved measures that will guarantee future business development in Indian Trail I understand not a single project in Indian Trail was denied sewer last year and we still have capacity no matter all we've heard the bottom line is is do you have it or you don't and nobody's been denied I appreciate that in regarding the possibilities I'm sorry can I I guess got a little bit more is that okay I appreciate that I don't hear well and I think you said keep going and I'm serious without a hearing the sisted device and I have hearing a and is I'm losing my hearing in

025reading the possibilities as Count's pursuing for the future I just want to say it was a clear sign you didn't just jump through decisions that will greatly raised sewer and water rates instead you acted as an elected official should act on behalf of the people and looking after their bottom line and my wife is just really tight you don't want to see that water bill bit go up Indian Trail is a unique community and the fact that we're kind of a suburb Community not a traditional CH so we get a lot of our service in conjunction with the county such as we contract the wonderful Sheriff's Department over here and they do a great job we contract with the fire actually Indian tra residents don't pay any extra for fire through their taxes we it's

026all done through the fire things we get EMS Water and Sewer through the county for example I appreciate any efforts the Commissioners can make to keep our taxers low with the re-evaluation coming and I know I'm going to get the same thing over an Indian Trail but none of you live in Indian Trail so you can't blame me so anyway I like like the county and the town and all of us to have a great relationship I think you got a good working board from what I can tell and I just want to come in here and say just a few thoughts and really the most part to say some of us really appreciate what you're doing and thank you and may God got you the wisdom to govern more thank you God bless you

027I I do want to comment um Mr Barber has been here several times over the past year year and a half um Mayor Cohen has been several times and I just want to I want to thank you for um being such a a good partner you know with the county so thank you again well thank you a little Jo just say to all y'all he he you know he was a poll greeter that concludes um our public comments the next item on the agenda is a public hearing concerning step for economic development incentive Grant in an amount not to exceed $2,350 th000 over a 5year period for a confidential company identified as project nickel I will open open the public hearing and recognize Ron May our economic development director for comments Madam chair Commissioners manager

028Matthews it is my pleasure to bring before you tonight an economic development incentive Grant requests for project nickel typically when we bring a project to you we identify the company by name tonight I'm referring to this opportunity by the confidential code name project nickel the reason we cannot of Al name tonight is that we are pursuing economic incentives through the state of North Carolina which means if awarded the company name will be announced first by the governor's office uh and we expect to hear from the state regarding those incentives uh over the next two weeks I am very proud to share with you details of this opportunity um that I am sure you will find very attractive our Economic Development Department started conversations with project Nichols in the summer of 2024 my assistant director Rachel

029Holzman first became aware of the opportunity while attending the farm Boro air show in England uh this past summer over the subsequent months we learned the following details project nickel is an existing Union County firm whose corporate headquarters is in another state the company produces very sophisticated products which are delivered to customers across the globe demand for its products has grown to a level where its current manufacturing capacity cannot keep up the parent Corporation operates another production facility in another state that produces the same products to meet the current and expected future demand it is necessary to construct a new 50,000 square foot processing facility and install the most sophisticated production equipment of its kind expected capital investment is $100 million again capital investment of $100 million in addition to the high level of investment

030the project is expected to create 65 new full-time jobs paying an approximate annual wage of $78,000 that's a little over $5 million each year in new wages to enhance the business case to the company's leadership to locate this project in Union County my office is requesting the following incentive project Nicholls $100 million capital investment qualifies it for a standard step four Economic Development incentive Grant in an amount not to exceed $2,350 th000 paid over a 5-year period beginning in fiscal year 2028 based on anticipated capital investment the company would pay estimated ADV valorum taxes of two 2 million excuse me $2,940 th000 over the same Grant period of course actual tax revenues to the county will be based on the current tax rate applied to the assessed value of the investment each year after depreciation

031therefore given the potential to secure this high level of capital investment and also secure the well-paying jobs the staff of the Union County Economic Development Department recommend the award of this step four Economic Development Grant to project Nickel in an amount not to exceed 2 million sorry I'm choke up when I say the size of the grant um to project nickle in an amount not to exceed $2,350 th000 to help secure this $100 million investment with that I'd be glad to answer any questions thank you does anyone have any questions thank you Ron thank you madam clerk has anyone signed up to speak at the public hearing okay we have no speaker signed up for the public hearing are there any speakers here tonight that wish to speak regarding this public hearing hi hello this

032is my name is Joel down as you guys already know I live in Wesley Chapel um I wasn't going to speak on this but obviously this is a great opportunity for the county I think that the county should pursue something like this um the one thing that I was thinking about while I was sitting here is that maybe put a contingency that is contingent on the state also approving it obviously it seems like the state would approve it as it is a great sounds like a great opportunity for the state and also the county uh but just possibly so that the covers the of the county and the taxpayers as ourselves so that's all I have to say thank you very much thank you Joel I will now close the public hearing next on theend

033agenda is item 25-15 I would like to recognize Lifesaver Award recipient and recognize Deputy County manager Patrick Nyon concerning this recognition thank you madam chair uh we're here to recognize one of our uh employees tonight I'd like to ask Ken Pinsky to come to the podium on October 3rd 2024 um Ken was running one of our senior nutrition H delivered uh meal routes and He Came Upon a house he noticed the door was a jar um he reached his head in and yelled out and he could hear Cries From help there was an elderly gentleman who had fallen in the bathroom and had been there for a period of time um I believe it was overnight yeah 24 hours um and who knows how long that gentleman would have survived in that situation but Ken

034was able to get inside get him stabilized call 911 coordinate with the supervisor and was able to get in touch with the family so um I don't think it's a stretch to say that without Ken's intervention that day that gentleman might not be with us today um Ken is a bit of a frequent flyer about a year prior um some of you might remember and we recognized Ken last year for a a similar life saving event to where there was a individual at a congregate site that he performed the HCK maneuver on and brought that individual back and I believe this is your fifth life saav sixth life saving not Awards but six times in my life that's happened this is his sixth time it started at 12 years old I was 12 for the

035first one that he has been able to save someone's life so it's it's pretty incredible um the life you've had in in in this and we we couldn't be more proud of Ken so please uh help me congratulate Ken on this award [Applause] um clone someone who who saves lives everywhere he goes the next item on the agenda is item 25-65 um introduction of Jason May director of budget and grants management I would like to recognize assistant County Manager Clayton buer concerning this matter thank you madam chair tonight is my pleasure to introduce you to Jason may he is our new director of budget and grants management and started with the county last week um has over 20 years of experience in local government most recently serving as the Director of budget and strategic planning

036for the City of Richmond Virginia uh where he managed the city's budget process Capital Improvement program and federal pandemic funding initiatives he also previously served and director and management roles in North Carolina local governments including Burke County and the City of Canapolis he has a bachelor's degree from UNCC Charlotte and an MPA degree from appalachin State University he has completed both the senior executive Institute at the Virginia Institute of government and the municipal and County Administration course at UNCC School of government he is also a certified local government budget and evaluation officer with the North Carolina local government budget Association so you'll be seeing more of Jason at your retreat next week and throughout the budget process and we look forward to his contributions here in Union County thank you for the opportunity to be

037here this even okay thank you feel underachieved I didn't save anybody's life done anything else there I'm trying to figure out where the money is well welcome um you you have two two pluses you're a 49er yes and a mountaineer yes so welcome thank you thank you we look forward to working with you thank thank you so much Madam chair just for the record Jason May is unrelated to Jason K except by and poem whatever emails I get for you I promise to provide immediately to you and vice versa [Laughter] yeah very good it is now time for the consideration of the agenda and the consent agenda uh Madam chair could I ask a question uh and maybe U the manager can help you what exactly is the process for setting up as been requested

038Animal Services advisory committee how what's the actual process we go through to set up an advisory committee it's really fair very simple the board would um honestly uh direct us to go out create a structure uh probably look for um some similar bylaws that already exist somewhere uh give you some advice on the number of individuals who should serve and then after that you advertise it for interested parties so it's relatively simple and uh relatively cost free that's really up to the board uh some of our boards committees are are unpaid those are usually ad hoc and don't last for any period of time others are uh have receive a stien like our our land use board uh some other boards do receive some stien um I would uh I would personally volunteer to serve

039as the commission representative on such an advisory uh committee um I guess I will need to discuss with my colleagues if there's interest in moving forward before we do anything formal thank you thank you for the information Adam chair yes I'd like to make a motion that we approve the agenda and consent agenda as published all those in favor say I I I we are now at the business portion of our agenda the first item for business is item 25-0 59 it it's just information only so that'll bring us straight to business um so first up is item consider a step for economic development incentive Grant in the amount not to exceed $2,350 th000 over a 5-year period for a confidential company identified as project nickel I will recognize Ron May economic development director concerning

040this item Madam chair thank you again uh any questions that you have i' you would welcome those and uh try to answer the best I can yes M um not a question but I'll offer a motion that we um first award a step four Economic Development incentive Grant in the amount not to exceed 2, 350,000 uh dollar over a 5-year period and two authorize the county manager to negotiate and execute an agreement substantially consistent with this agenda item okay motion is on the floor any comments any feedback okay all those in favor of the motion say I I I okay thank you very much thank you next on our agenda is item 25-55 Union County Jail study update I want to recognize Chris Bo vo our facilities and Fleet Management director concerning this item well

041good evening Commissioners um we appreciate the opportunity to get in front of you and give you an update on the jail study that's currently underway um as you're aware the board gave Direction to the county manager and leadership team to begin a study uh that could begin to update the statistics and data and ultimately the bed count um estimates and projections uh for potential new jail last year um the update tonight um will include um uh discussions about the studies process um the process followed by our design team uh data collected and an anal Anis of that data um you'll see a focus on two projections the first um is where no changes are expected or planned for in the current justice system processes and a second that includes uh or anticipates an increase in

042future booking so those are two uh forecasts for you to consider um as you're reviewing the information um I'd also like to point out that uh this portion or this update the information in this update is only a portion of the total study um in order to move forward with the rest of the study we're going to need some direction in a future meeting uh with the board um and so you'll hear the design team talk about some of the next steps that they have in their processes I will also share some next steps for Union County specifically um kind of really focused on The Retreat on the 12th and some of the things we'll share on on uh in that Retreat um we're not asking the board to take any action tonight um just

043only to receive this information uh included any update um so I'd like to uh now um introduce Allan Richardson and Patrick jablonsky with Justice planners um they are subject matter experts uh in desen uh detention center and prison planning uh and they're going to lead the presentation tonight so I'll turn it over to them thank you good evening I'm Alan Richardson with Justice planners and I thank you for the opportunity to come and and speak uh with you uh this evening uh just a a quick overview of the team for the jail study here uh for this project is uh little Architects along with Hil Randall uh Architects are will be doing the design uh portion later uh in this project um Justice planners to tell you a little bit uh about about Justice planners

044I started um as a corrections officer over 35 years ago uh I worked uh pretty much every position in a County Jail up to facility Commander uh got the great opportunity to work on staff with the National Institute of Corrections in Colorado for a period of time uh before I started uh doing uh private Consulting uh just in the last um seven eight years I guess since 2018 uh justice planners has had the great opportunity to do now 30 uh such Detention Center needs assessments 19 detention and prison uh Master plans uh and so we we take our operational experience uh and and put it to work here and we we've just had the the great fortune and opportunity to be able to work across the country uh with this with me tonight I've got

045Dr Patrick jablonsky uh I'll let him introduce himself in in just a moment whenever he gets up and and dazzles you with the with the data analysis and information that he's that he's got for you the purpose of the needs assessment portion uh of this study is is quite simple take a look at the data from the local criminal justice system from the jail and to be able to synthesize that to determine what the future inmate population and bed space needs are going to be uh for Union County our process for this back in September we came on site for several days we interviewed a lot of the key stakeholders uh in the local Criminal Justice System uh we use this data and information again to do a deep dive on reconstructing forensically the the

046inmate population uh in facility use this information to come up with a a forecast for the future size of the population as well as uh an alternate uh or two to say uh one if nothing changes what are you looking at and two if if things do change like like Chris was mentioning if if bookings do go up then uh what's the what's the implication going to be of for Union County um any questions on that yes thank you madam chair um Allan first of all thank you for being here and presenting this uh information to us I I've got a quick question regarding the the stakeholders okay um listed here in bullet number one uh well sub bullet number one under the process um who exactly were the key stakeholders that your firm interviewed

047oh gosh uh we interviewed folks from the jail from the Sheriff's Office uh from local law enforcement the courts the prosecuting attorney defense attorneys um uh M local Magistrate I off the top of my head I I know there were a few others but it was it was a it was a pretty good list of individuals okay thank you um I think it's important to understand you know who who the key stakeholders that were uh interviewed and pulled you know with this study um I mean obviously you know our job as Commissioners is we have to represent the U well the most important stakeholder that we have and that's the taxpayers of Union County sure so so am I right to say that that your team your firm interviewed essentially um the Sheriff's Office jail

048courts judicial and magistrate is that kind of in a nutshell uh plus others I tell you while while Patrick is is presenting I can pull up and give you that exact list of great talk to thank you absolutely other questions at this point okay with that Patrick good evening Commissioners great to be here um without further Ado I'll try to Dazzle you with our data analysis thanks boss the uh uh I would have to say this a fairly complex study there's a lot of moving pieces anytime that you're looking at uh matters of the Criminal Justice System especially if you're looking out uh a quarter century and so uh one of the things that that we start with is we try to get a feel for the context of the community uh and and really

049right off the bat the the incredible growth of Union County uh over time and what's expected in the future dictates so much uh so much of the discussion that that we've uh seen already this evening as just really the incredible growth uh for for this County and that's very important to our uh projections however it's there's other pieces to the projections that uh go beyond the the growth and so we start with that context uh which is the projected population for uh the adult uh component of the community going to 2050 we downloaded data from the North Carolina State demographers office uh and and took it apart uh luckily this state does a good job of disaggregating the population data uh such that we're not just looking at an overall County growth picture uh if

050we were to look at the overall County growth picture at 64 4% across the next quarter uh Century however uh that includes children and senior citizens who are not necessarily coming to the jail operation and so we look at the adult population and actually when we built our uh projection scenarios we looked at at males uh as well because that's about 85% of the jail population you can see from the chart that uh growth is astronomical however you already knew that uh this does have an impact in our bookings for that we look at down the road uh and uh what we start with is if you look at the average daily population of the jail uh going back to January 2018 7 years ago you can see that it it is has periods of

051peaks in valleys you can see in 2020 the impact of of covid uh but then the population recovered very quickly from covid uh and it it drops again goes back up but really from 2022 forward the Jail's population in Union County is really artificially constrained because of a capacity problem there's many more individuals who uh ought to be coming to jail that aren't necessarily coming to Jail uh at least in the in the view of the the key stakeholders and when we uh dig into the numbers we we sort of see that as well uh when we break our data into uh monthly chunks uh we see that uh despite the capacity con constraint on the jail the number of individuals that the county is responsible for uh goes up and you'll see a spike

052at the end of our data essentially what's going on here is the number of individuals who have a violent felony charge have increased over time such that that that there's really no choice in terms of holding these individuals and so the sheriff's office is in the position of having to house these individuals but also house them in in other uh places as well and so the the uh type of in that's coming into the facility has changed qualitatively it's a much more serious population uh than it was uh 7 years ago there's two factors yes sir excuse me um let me stop you right here because I've got a couple of questions you can go back to the first slide regarding population yes thank you um so you know you're right I mean we've seen

053um tons of projections this board has I mean everybody that's you know involved in in uh County government you know has has personally experienced and witnessed the growth here in Union County and so of our residents um but what I question though is is that you said that you get your population data from the North Carolina State demographers office correct yes sir and where do they get their data from I I don't know okay um the reason why I asked this question is sorry typically that information comes from the the county as far as uh the past data and then they make estimates on their own so like we provide them with any population counts building U permits that level of information and then they do their own estimates okay thank you I appreciate that

054the reason why I POS the question is because lately we've seen lots of studies regarding population growth one of those was recently published by the Charlotte business Alliance you may have probably seen that study I know that some members of our board have seen it um but you know that particular organization had published that uh that it anticipates a 50% uh growth uh in the greater Charlotte Area um and I think it's important that we understand that organizations you know like the Charlotte business Alliance um as one is funded typically by other members that rely on growth for revenue and so um I think that we should kind of take this as face value here but understand that there's other intricacies involved with any kind of data or statistics that we get on growth um

055if you sorry if you could go forward also one slide please um I believe it was here you know you made the comment and I wanted to go back to this you made the comment essentially and I'm paraphrasing here but you said that uh that you were uh insinuating that we would be making more arrests if we had more bids is that correct yes sir okay and does that information that you got from your key stakeholders yes and who who would that be uh law enforcement agencies okay so to include uh the Sheriff's Office wingit what were the other law enforcement Monroe PD so we're talking about our local law enforcement is telling you that we can't that we're not arresting folks because we don't have bed space correct so we are allowing potentially violent

056offenders to be let go because we don't have bis commissioner I I didn't say that about violent offenders uh what I'm saying is there's uh what we're seeing is a shift in in arrest processes such that uh there's operations that the sheriff's office for instance uh conducted as a matter of course uh driver's license checks uh DUI checkpoints uh s years ago that they have to uh seriously reduce uh nowadays because they just don't have the bed space if I'm if I may jump in here if my memory is correct I think in um previous presentations we had been um told uh weekenders for example um criminals or whatever that are supposed to check themselves in on the weekend if we didn't have bed space they might would be sent home so maybe that's part

057of it the weekenders um but I believe we also um County Manager Matthews were we not also told that um that we had a contract I believe with cabar County or someone else that uh for a daily uh fee they would house some of our criminals for us not necessarily you know pass go right so we we have a loose agreement with cabis County that when we are are over um the jail population they will take some of our um our folks and they will um obviously keep them at a cost we pay that are we still doing that we we are yes and it really just depends and I I let the Sheriff's Office speak to it to more um you know details on it but it really depends on the circumstances of Are

058We above our count or not what's going on uh we do um if we're doing major repairs and we have to shift some of the inmates out to do repairs we would use it for that purpose as well okay so I just want to share that because we have had extensive conversations about those those type of people like the weekenders I remember that in particular that you know if if we were at capacity they might would have to go back home and not check themselves in for the weekend that's an excellent example so sorry I didn't know you finished go ahead give me just one second sure so okay so is your understanding then that we have a directive that well we've got to limit the arrest because we don't have jail space I'm not

059sure about the term directive but but what we heard fairly consistently from the stakeholders is there's a uh artificial suppression on the number of individuals who get booked into the facility uh due to the capacity situation and then on the flip side of that then um you're assumption is is that at if we had more uh best space available that we could uh make additional arrest and and we could essentially fill the bed space yes sir so with more bed space then we're able to arrest more yes sir and detain more yes okay okay all right that's that's all I have for right now okay yes um on Slide Five um do we have the completed data for the year to date for the ADP this goes through the end of September 2024 the year

060to date yes we got our tranch of data from the sheriff's office in early October we conducted the analysis in October okay but you don't have anything through the remaining of 2024 okay this is more of a general question your slide back if you could go back to Union County population slide you're projecting between 64% uh my question is in considering a new jail what is a reasonable expectation of the life of uh a new jail facility because I'm expecting it to be a lot more than 25 years to 2050 um I mean we build high schools for 50 and 60 years um so and I'm assuming the the growth projection is part of the formula you're using to project the needed bed size of a new facility is that that that's part of the

061function right yeah it's it's a piece of the forecast models it's not the the absolute best predictor of our models but it it has a a component in the math okay so I guess what I'm asking is if you're only projecting the population here out to 2050 how long is a reasonable expectation for a new jail for the numbers farther out than 2050 to be as far as an uh the ideal population because it's going to last X number of years so far as a life expectancy for a Detention Center there is no hard fast rule I I would say a rule of thumb is looking at potentially 30 years uh really just 30 years well keep in mind I guess it depends on how good you build it right depends on how good you

062build it depends on how how well you maintain it if you drive your car day after day after day and never change the oil yeah uh in there it's not going to last as long uh if you defer maintenance on a Detention Facility it's not going to last as long right and typically in in in looking at a jail I I I can I can do the the math and and show you uh cool charts and stuff but typically a jail is going to age approximately three and a half times faster than a than a typical County building because of wear and tear because it operates 24 hours a day s days a week it it never closes and you you've got less than desirable clientele that do a lot of wear and tear on

063the place then when it gets crowded you start putting two offenders in a space designed for one it it's going to age that much faster okay uh with population projections not not to step on any of your the farther you get out when you start looking 20 30 30 years out into the future you're um it becomes a little less your reliability Factor starts to deteriorate uh a little it's hard to project that far out exactly and and with the jail facility and again if you do do if you don't defer your maintenance if you stay on top of it it's it's going to last much longer take care of what you got exactly okay also could you uh obviously 2008 the Great Recession did not have a long-term impact on our population growth or

064the pandemic are there any foreseeable events you could see between now and 2050 or the next 30 Years that might impact this this growth rate for uh commissioner there any number of things that can happen that uh would impact the the growth rate another pandemic uh massive public policy change uh there's there's a a ton of uncertainty 10 15 20 years out but the the events along those lines that we've seen in the past haven't had a long-term effect the the pandemic I mean we're back in 2008 which affected the real estate market among and all the financial markets it's recovered from that so it really hasn't had a longlasting effect on the trajectory trajectory of our growth is that fair to say not for the free world population growth no it hasn't uh in

065terms of a correctional population it's a little bit unique for Union County because you're constrained by capacity uh in about 90% of the projects uh in the communities that that we're lucky enough to work in uh what we've seen post pandemic is that the jail populations largely have not fully risen back to where they were on a pre-pandemic basis because typically uh the the individuals who have less serious matters uh and less less violence they they were released more uh during 2020 and 2021 and because they have capacity we've seen those populations uh you know lower than they were on a pre-pandemic basis it's not the case here because frankly candidly you were short of jail space well before the pandemic so we have an artificial bottleneck if you will in the system because of

066limited that's a Capac way that may skew the the numbers as we start to get to bump up to that ceiling okay all right thank you okay all right at basic level my job it looks to be relatively simple I only have to track two factors to predict a Jail's population uh it's the number of individuals coming to the jail bookings and how long those individuals stay it's the complexity within uh each of those two categories so briefly we'll look at bookings in average length of stay for Union County on a historical basis we start with average daily bookings the blue Trend here is bookings uh this these are monthly time points going to the end of September uh and the black line is the average average daily population I realize I'm hitting you with

067a rather complex chart right off the bat uh rest assured we had a much larger presentation for staff to review uh that kind of builds to this and you get hit with the F final product and so uh that fact is not lost on me to step you through it essentially if you pay attention to the dashed lines the little dotted lines that I plotted on the two Trends uh you can see that the the bookings uh Trend and uh the average daily population Trend March relatively well together for about a 5year period coming out of the pandemic certainly uh it really boils down to this the more people that you bring to a correctional facility in general the average daily population will go up uh we haven't talked about average length of the stay

068yet so uh to to be clear uh there's a a relatively healthy diversion uh process in a lot of communities uh and that there's uh people who aren't arrested they get diverted from custody here uh and a lot of that is driven by the capacity questions that the Sheriff's Office handles with the uh uh facility itself uh it is our contention indeed that uh the the bullet at the bottom right I think is is you know we stand by it that bookings will increase substantially uh if more beds come online uh because that's where really law enforcement is at at this point so that's the story with average daily bookings the other side of the population question is average length of stay uh you'll see the relationship between these two t uh two Trends is

069slightly different uh the red line is average length of stay plotted in in days against the scale on the right population is plotted against scale on the left and again it's a black line uh you'll see that there wasn't all that much relationship going uh between 2018 and 2021 uh and uh arguably not much relationship until frankly really the start of 2023 the population uptick that we see during 2024 is due mostly to an average length of stay increase uh and this really uh has its its roots in the type of individuals who are coming to the jail uh when you compare them to uh say 2018 is the the proportion of individuals who uh face a violent charge or a violent felony charge has risen significantly these are individuals that that law enforcement can't

070just ignore uh these are individuals to who in the interest of Public Safety have to come to the jail which then place is a burden really on trying to figure out uh what the nonviolent individuals uh do in terms of of housing or or what the detention question is for them uh a little bit of math here if the booking level of 2018 where uh the community had 17 individuals booked per day instead of the current roughly 15 the average daily population would be 36 higher uh uh with today's average length of stay so average length of stay is creeping up as time goes on a lot of that is just simply reflective of the fact that these individuals have more serious matters before them uh that that uh take longer for uh uh processing

071through the Judiciary I will also observe this the county uh criminal justice system is excellent uh compared to just about everywhere we've worked in terms of the front-end processing uh it's extremely efficient and I I commend the county uh uh funding positions to to work in the uh uh District Attorney's Office in particular to review cases is uh extremely smart strategically uh we were heartened to see that there's a lot of communities that we uh go to we end up recommending something like that and to see that you're already doing it uh is excellent and I I shudder to think what the population question would be if the county wasn't already doing that strategy uh the population would be even larger uh and you would uh be facing I think a lot more serious uh

072question so that's average length this day versus average daily population can I interrupt you I think you just answered my question but my concern was if there was any bottleneck that can be addressed in the judicial part of the process in other words you're saying there are more serious the the crimes serious seriousness is increasing is our local Judicial System IE do we have enough judges do we have everything in place to address that that's not creating an artificial uh bottleneck and that's why the average length of stay is increasing that something that can be addressed we need another Superior Court Judge do we need this that did you experience any of that or in in our conversations with uh stakeholders uh there there were indications of uh you know needing uh you know another

073uh another judge or or two at at that level um I would also have to observe uh sadly that we did not AC uh criminal court case processing data for this project uh we normally we we try to everywhere because this is in some ways the keys to the kingdom uh for a project we we finished a project in in Northern Florida uh in late 2000 late last year uh where we got all the criminal justice information and we were able to furnish that County with I think 21 recommendations is of what they could do better in terms of Criminal Justice case processing unfortunately we were not able to get that data out of the state for this project and we would happily uh have uh analyzed it and then said here are six bottlenecks

074that you consider now saying that um I I think I I feel good about where the criminal justice system is uh because a lot of questions are are being uh addressed we had a great visit with uh uh with the Judiciary uh where there's some good ideas that are taking shape there are changes to the the the uh software systems that just got implemented uh you know not long ago uh that I think helps uh and I I love seeing and hearing about the conversations among the stakeholders in the county there's a lot of good things the problem is that you're being swamped by an increasing load of people and uh a lot of the matters facing those individuals are much more serious than they were say a decade ago okay yes um repulsed here

075if you can go back one slide I think yeah thank you yes so I I I want to look at this graph because as I was studying over some of our materials this kind of jumped out at me so January 18th you know we're looking at an average daily booking of well over 300 oh I'm I'm sorry I should explain the the chart the the black line uh the Y AIS is on the left side and the average daily bookings I plotted on the the right side didn't mean to be tricky statistically with you and so if you look at the average daily uh uh bookings were instead of 300 it's it's well over uh 18 uh on that basis thank you for the clarification I was looking at this and I'm like wait a

076minute I should have said that right off the bat it's a double charart okay and and I appreciate your your clarification there I think uh commissioner SE and I probably had about the same question because you know one of the things that and I think it's on your next slide forward um there we go yeah so so you talk about the front end of of processing so the question I had was very similar so you know that almost insinuates that you know maybe we have a bottleneck on the back end of processing or you know maybe in the court system um so so you you from what your firm has found there may be some truth to that then is that what absolutely yeah and and from you know from where I'm standing today after

077having conducted the the study is I I don't know what I don't know about the the criminal court case processing issues uh that said though I I feel good about the the uh process here uh because you know there's conversations taking place there's concern for it it's just uh what I would love to see candidly is more managing to the data which uh I I suspect with what the state uh Judiciary provides that's what's going on and you couldn't get the data from the state no sir and that that can't be obtained locally we we tried um two or three different methods and and we got to the person uh and and asked and explained uh uh the nature of the project and we could not get it but is it a safe assumption then

078that if we had uh that criminal court case data that that would obviously be a Smoking Gun to identify potentially other bottlenecks in our city yes sir that sounds pretty serious to me it sounds like a pretty important piece of data to make sure not just the jail but the whole uh judicial process it possible improvements yeah there's now now to be clear there are General criminal justice case processing numbers that are publicly available uh in fact the response of the the state courts was well look at our website uh what I think sets us apart as a company is Justice planners looks at Raw data uh and so we were asking for every single criminal motion uh filed every criminal matter and allowing us to do big data if you will uh and and

079crunch the numbers rather than having them just say there were 500 cases filed in a given month that doesn't tell me how fast things move when hearings are how many continuances there are and some other things maybe I'm getting in the weeds but evidently did they say for for security purposes they couldn't give it to your privacy or they just don't have it where I can get to it okay I'm not from North Carolina so I feel safe in saying or all of the above well to answer your question essentially I don't think the uh staff involved at the state level wanted to set the precedent of releasing tranches of raw data to researchers for those purposes so the state attorney general who was Josh Stan who is now our governor did not want to

080release that information this was state courts this St and who controls that information we could get the woman's name for you I don't remember it but it doesn't go through the AG's office no I Madam chair um I I would like for the board to be privy to that if uh if you if your fir share us share with fact the conversations took place in early October and I I just honestly don't remember but I took good notes it's very convenient timing very convenient timing excellent thank you excellent and to to actually call back commissioner to previous question about uh the study ending in September is uh we worked very hard and in Union County staff did as well uh to try to secure that data and that's why we're seeing my study end essentially

081with the end of September uh we were working trying to get the court data so that we could finish the analysis at that point and so we worked through uh a chunk of September uh the whole month of October and as I recall into November before we were given the hard no thank you now uh I get a bunch of variables I have a ton of raw data and it's time to build a jail population forecast uh uh a little bit about my background I got my uh start in criminal justice work at Orange County Florida in Orlando uh I was a uh college professor at the University of Central Florida teaching statistics to uh large groups of individuals who did not want to be in my classroom and uh about the time that my

082wife told me I needed to get a real job uh the only place that would hire me was the county jail in Orange County Florida I thought I would do that for about 90 days till something better came along and uh I fell in love with uh with the subject matter and the people uh and I found that my mathematical modeling from Academia teaching mass communication research and public opinion was excellent at predicting jail populations now that said uh in 2004 uh I was living in Orlando and hurricane Jean was coming at us through the Caribbean and it turned North and everybody pulled the boards off the houses and then the storm does a U-turn and comes ashore which is the map that's there and everybody uh cuss the forecasters well now I am a

083forecaster 20 years later and essentially the story boils down to this the forecasters in 2004 with hurricane Jan didn't know what they didn't know they didn't have a crystal ball Allan and I are very good at what we do we do not possess a crystal ball uh so uh this calls back to I think our earlier conversation a few minutes ago commissioner that uh I don't know what public policies uh public policy changes three years 5 years 10 years from now will happen uh or you know if space aliens invade in 20 years or what that does to the criminal justice system of Union County so there's a number of things that could uh really hurt the effectiveness of of my forecast uh to put a fine point on this when I landed at Charlotte

084uh I got a text message about a project that I I did uh in a large city in Georgia and uh I had to smile and say they completely changed their Criminal Justice System 90 days after I released my forecast now I'm hoping that my forecast spurred that change if anything but it goes boils down to this a forecast is not a prediction uh it it is but it really isn't it's not a recipe for the future uh what the best way to predict the future is my boss often reminds me is to change the future or create the future and in the case when I landed at Charlotte this afternoon was the forecast that I released really was worthless uh within 90 days because of a profound change in that uh in that locality

085and so uh my underling uh comment on the left side of the screen that there's no unforeseen changes is is there intentionally uh that that one part of the story that we're going to show you uh is uh assuming that there are no changes that if you go along at the current clip here's what you're going to have and that would result in this forecast that we are calling our primary forecast again this assumes that there are no changes in the criminal justice system from where it was when we collected our data at the end of September 2024 this forecast is based on multiple projected simulations of bookings average length of stay and the prior history of the Jail's average daily population booking itself was modeled in part using the growth curve from the state

086demographers office uh we also looked at arrest patterns uh we tried to look at crime rate that's not a very good predictor anywhere thanks to uh some problems with crime data on a national level uh which has impacted uh our work uh and average length of stay we we ended up modeling independently it would have been nice to have the court data to impact our uh average length of stay forecast but we've already covered that so essentially we built uh I think this one was 15,000 simulations of the future for Union County we selected the one that was the best fit for the data uh at the end of the day uh over time it is uh our assumption if nothing changes bookings will double over time from 15 to about 30 per day the

087average length of stay will go from its current level of just over two weeks to about 22 days uh despite the efforts of everybody to control average length of inevitably we think uh those efforts will be subsumed by the growing seriousness of the charges that the individuals face the bottom line is by 2050 the average daily population is expected to be 657 uh individuals that Union County is responsible for now there's a big Aster risk with that you do not have the space for 657 individuals and so uh the pressure will be there to house 6 57 individuals if nothing changes in the system now that's just the body count that's the number of humans on an average daily basis uh we have to to move to the actual required size of a facility requires

088discussion of a couple factors there's two things that we have to take into account number one that graph that I just showed you is an average there are days of the week hours of the day and times of the year where the population pressure is larger uh upon the the the jail facility and so we have to take into account what we call a peaking factor that there are just some times of the year that are busier than others we went and modeled the data and we uh Supply two peaking factors for females it's 16.1% for males it's 88.6% we have to add that to the average that we have and my next slide will cover that um there's also this other Factor we call it an an operational factor or a classification factor it's

089the two subo on the slide is essentially the jail needs internal capacity to move people around keep different people separate from each other known enemies uh rival gang members code defendants uh individuals of wildly different classification levels you don't want a firsttime DUI offender housed in the same cell with somebody who's got a extremely violent past uh so to maintain Safety and Security you have to uh take into account these two factors the peaking factor and the classification factor to do that we have this table let's step through the table so that we make sure that that what I'm saying is is is sensical let's look at uh 2050 the bottom row of the table on the left side of the table engraves what we expect to happen with females if no changes happen uh

090in current arrest detention or processing practices we forecast an average daily population of 131 females by 2050 we add the peaking factor of 16.1% which is 21 that's 21 beds uh then the classification factor is 20 more beds and so to house safely and securely 131 females in a quarter Century you need 172 beds the same logic applies to the males our average daily population forecast says 526 we add the peaking the classification factor and we get a bed need of 650 at the end of the day uh the the bed need of 6 yeah 650 uh there the total average daily there uh is oh I'm adding the wrong the wrong column I have confused myself the total average daily population is 657 the bed need to house those individuals is 822 can I

091oh I'm sorry go ahead please okay um we've talked about the beds um that you are forecasting that were needed but you haven't touched on staff that is also required for this no which is an ongoing yearly cost um with that that many people possibly housed in Union County Jail how many officers do we currently have and how many will we need in the future I will call on alen Richardson who's probably the best person in the country to answer that question excellent question uh that's asked a little bit too early in in the process answer it later if you want to pause that and answer it later that that's fine too let's do that okay in in your U total beds needed and your average da daily population are you taking into account the

092inmates that are uh need medical services they're in the infirmary because that's another separate isolation that's built into those those numbers the actual that component of the population would be in a future step but yes okay Madam chair yes um to uh commissioner Helms so um previously when we looked at this item um we did have some modeling you know in regards to the number of officers that would be required so uh correctional officers uh for certain siiz facilities so our staff ran some modeling for that um not one this large I don't believe um as what we're discussing right now but no and I I'm sorry I didn't mean to interrupt you but no go go right ahead um the second phase of this project is once the board gives some direction on a

093total buildout uh there are some additional uh components that they'll be studying and part of that is staffing needs uh they'll give us some some better defined cost estimates some uh options on phasing uh a project and all of that really sort of comes at a second phase so you're you're not going to get that level of detail today they'll just need to know kind of what is your what Your parameters for them to look at sure but when we're doing a a overlay of this you know that does cost into we have to factor in that cost excuse me absolutely and you know if we decide to have this many beds you know my concern right now is the sheriff's office has a hiring you know they've got a challeng yeah thank you a

094challenge um I see I'm face quite often and you know our our Sheriff's Office is topnotch um but uh recruit those people in is going to be a challenge on to house this many people so it is a concern and um but it does need to be looked at and discussed sooner than later absolutely and I I would just add to I mean you know you're not talking about just Co cost you're talking about utility costs exactly service Medical Care yeah the the previous modeling that we've that we did I mean utility is going to be a huge Factor because you're talking about um I mean essentially I mean more than Dublin you know the size of what we've got so it's this is potentially four times the size so well it's outfitting each Deputy

095as well I mean it's their their uniform their weapons their vehicles everything that needs to be installed on the vehicles so it it becomes extensive per deputy yes so this is our primary forecast assuming that nothing changes in the current practices of the the present system let's look at the next uh slide is uh telling you exactly that uh what our visits with stakeholders our extensive conversations and and our past experiences and other jurisdictions that were in a similar boat we anticipate uh an immediate doubling of bookings when a new facility uh opened if I were to to wave a magic wand this evening and open a new facility it is my estimation that bookings would double very quickly uh in in Union County if we were to to open it tonight uh and so

096uh a lot of this is population growth but we're also seeing a more serious crime uh uh issue in terms of of what offenses are are being conducted Now versus say 25 years ago so that the world has gotten to be more serious and what's the matters facing individuals in Union County are also more serious so I'm going to show this table and I'm going to make you promise me not to peek at the right side of the table let's look only at the left side of the table if we can okay don't look at the right side the left side is the current policies and practices continuing this is my my forecast that you've already seen okay so bookings at 14.9 currently the average daily population 255 right now you need 319 beds according

097to our calculations with peaking and classification to operate a safe and secure uh facility and then you can see it goes up over time such that bookings double if everything just goes on its own at the current trajectory by 2050 if 30 bookings per day the average daily population of 657 and the 822 bed need now now it's time to look at the right side of the table the right side of the table is essentially I think very realistic portrayal of what could happen in terms of uh of reality is that if an expanded jail facility uh opened with our modeling for average length of stay uh in tow that bookings number uh is 30 which coincidentally is what we're saying happens in 2050 is essentially you get the future but you get it right

098away because you have more jail space and so with with the bed space available it say um if you build it they will come uh type situation that the space is available and uh there is the demand present already for 30 bookings per day now which gets the average daily population of 657 uh at the projected average length of stay the bed needs 822 you can see 30 years 25 years into the future at the bottom of the table uh bookings would grow from that point forward such that you're at 45.5 daily bookings uh in an average daily population getting close to 1,000 uh in the need well over uh 1,000 that's if everything currently in place uh goes to the uh future as as uh it's as it's going and a facility opens can

099I ask you you mentioned that uh the study you did for somewhere in Georgia then then something happened in the legal environment and it blew up your study what what exactly happened what did they do decriminalized marijuana or something in that in that situation uh there was a district attorney in place that that uh felt it absolutely in the community's interest to leave everybody pre-trial uh with a violent charge uh incarcerated as long as possible uh even beyond their their bond hearings and so the pre-trial average length of stay for that jurisdiction was significantly High uh about 3 months after we issued our report uh what the district attorney there did was uh put people out on electronic monitoring with an appearance Bond promise that took the jail population there down by 500 and about

100a 45-day period uh which completely destroyed my forecast and our conversations with that individual's office this was never mentioned to us as a possible change had that been isolated to us as a possible change we would have happily have modeled what the impact was and then said here's the size facility that your jurisdiction needs well is part of your study to make recommendations on potential changes that we could make that would affect the average daily population with a program such as that absolutely uh the one handicap with with all that commissioner is in this instance we don't have the criminal court case data that I can say change this part of the processing or change this part of the process I will also say that compared to that jurisdiction in Georgia uh Union County is

101is much more uh efficient and Progressive in terms of trying to manage its jail population and and doing things to divert and deflect individuals from custody okay in your in your uh expanded jail facility allowing for more bookings the daily bookings are you assuming they all end up in the jail and not released on bond or what have you or these individuals would be released uh as they are now the majority of individuals booked into the jail are released on on Bond the if you were to look at the the median average do you remember that from you know like eth grade where they taught us mean median mode I've never used it till I got into this and essentially median is the midpoint of of the data so if we look at everybody released

102during the month of January and we take that middle case we order that list by how long everybody had stayed in jail we take the middle case the median number uh for Union County is is extremely low I want to say it's less than two uh it's very low the front door processing is very quick it's the backdoor processing but that's not necessarily uh you know a a a backlog issue that is is easily solvable I don't know what I don't know again but keep in mind these uh longer cases are very serious criminal matters you know homicides aggravated assaults uh etc etc where the penalties facing the defendant SL inmate are significant and you know they're not in a hurry uh to take a plea they want their cases tried by and large and

103so that leads to longer stays in the jail so you're saying that if we removed the bottleneck of the of the limited jail capacity we have now our bookings would almost double overnight yes sir holy I have a question sir um with the new Administrations um stance stance thank you um do you foresee any changes in your projections I think so because when we built these uh projections I really wasn't certain what things were going to look like and as I stand here I'm not exactly certain what will happen with immigration enforcement certainly not in in Union County um my assumptions in our modeling here uh doesn't take that into account uh one of the things that that I I think uh that is is helpful on our part is that uh if we go

104down the road uh a period of time and that picture becomes less murky uh we are a phone call away to to happily uh do some arithmetic that if bookings increase over and above what we're seeing we can give you that bed need uh very very quickly uh just because that is a just an unforeseen thing uh and it's unfolding right now as as we speak okay I want to I'm going to go back to this sticker shock here yes sir um we're in 2025 I'm going to assume at the very least it's going to take a year to design if we decided tomorrow it would take a year to design and what four years to build depending on size roughly two to three you if you make a decision tonight what a probably years

105four years to have it open from the decision being made okay so you're into you're into 2030 pretty darn close so you're already looking at right at 33 bookings when the thing opens yes because I'm going over here to your chart on the right because now I've got the capacity yes sir so we have a field of dreams if you build it they will come yes okay yes yeah and keep in mind I think one of the things that that we often um when they build into this there are other law enforcement agencies in the county that we don't control who they decide to arrest or don't arrest um so we have the county but but you have five other jurisdictions that have their own law enforcement agencies when where I started in Orange County

106if you were to look at an aerial shot of the Orange County jail you'll see the first building and then the second building and the third and the fourth and the fifth and the sixth building going along the lake shore there uh is that they would open 256 and then 512 and then 1,24 beds and the the facilities got taller and taller and they continued to fill those facilities now uh there's a little bit of a happy ending uh they conducted a full criminal justice case processing study and Analysis over the course of a year they had a community review board uh that was made up largely of stakeholders and and interested members of the community the average length of stay for the jail was in my estimation cut uh responsibly and safely did not

107really compromise criminal justice uh safety in the community uh the growth trajectory when I was hired in uh the end of 2001 uh there were only 3,000 beds available uh but the uh inmate population was over 4,500 uh those reforms that were instituted I believe there were 23 criminal justice case processing changes that they made uh they have not built a new facility since 2006 because they built their last facility declared it to be the last and then uh they started managing to the data and managing average length of stay uh and it's a great example of responsible uh governance that they've been able to cap their uh facility the issue here like it was there is the county was growing at an incredible rate and that County growth has leveled off in the last

10810 to 15 years and so they were able to manage and weather the storm they have available capacity at their facility uh here you're growing but uh frankly candidly you got behind the eightball uh in terms of the size of the facility that you needed a larger facility uh some time ago and uh the demand is there for the product uh basically and so uh if you view jail beds as a as a good uh or service uh the demand is there uh currently it's it's pent up demand uh and when that Supply is placed there um demand will meet Supply do you have any information that you can provide to the board of um the detainees their age grouping if we have you know absolutely okay thank you plus the other thing that concerns

109me on your chart this is only 2050 that's a 25e projection of which it's going to take any bonds issue any debt issued to build this facility are going to take 20 years to pay off so we're going to have this thing paid off for five years and then turn around and build another one and now that I have cheered you all up we will move from the forecast uh and start talking about uh next steps for the actual analysis I will turn it back to Alan Richardson thanks so the next steps to to wrap up this study um you guys are going to need to talk amongst yourselves uh and to to make a decision for the total number of beds to be built out uh uh for this now that could come in

110phases uh and let's let's pick a round number and say a thousand beds I have I have no idea what you're going to come up with you you may not you may choose not to build all of those at one time you would build out the the backbone the core infrastructure your water your HVAC and everything like that for the full buildout but maybe approach it in phases so hopefully we can find some ways to tackle some issues and slow that growth so we won't need as many beds or at least not as not as quickly after we get the total number of beds that that we're looking at building out then we go into what we call program development uh and that's looking at how the sheriff's team wants to operate the facility to

111be as as efficient uh as possible and we want to determine the operations first and then come up with a design that will support those operations not not the other way around uh once we get those operational scenarios we talk about uh the narrative to describe all that for all the different building components from your Administration to your housing to your to your services uh there and then we'll develop uh space allocation tables we'll work with the team with the county and and with the sheriff to come up with the total square footage uh that would be needed that that's for every cell for every office for every broom closet uh in the facility to get a total order of magnitude as to how big a facility that we're looking at and we could also

112look at that in in the phases as well and then that brings us to preliminary Staffing um that is really going to depend upon the size of the facility how many housing units the capacity of the housing units the operational philosophy are we going to put an officer in every housing unit direct supervision or we're going to have an officer outside of the unit remote supervision all is going to Impact Staffing we'll come up some very high level Staffing estimates uh as as a part of this study but at every major step along the way staffing needs to be Revisited and be refined because we talked about 30-year life cycle what you're going to spend to construct a facility is going to pale in comparison is what you're going to spend to operate it over

113the course of 30 years rule of thumb your initial construction costs are going to be about 10% of what you're going to spend over time for this the other 85 90% is going to be operational cost of that 80% is going to be Staffing and so that's why it's so important to do this right and to do it efficient and efficiently doesn't always mean less staff means the right number of staff to be able able to safely operate this facility uh we'll come up with some comparative operational cost models for full capacity phase capacity and again at at this stage that's that's going to be very high level uh numbers and that's the next step for for our portion of the of the study that we're doing now any any questions on those next steps

114from us yes ma'am so um before tonight there was a lot of conversation about um wanting space to bring in federal inmates yes ma'am was that part was that factored in like when you were meeting with um with the sheriff office or whatever or any of your numbers so that um we could bring in federal inmates or is or or I see you shaking your head are the numbers just based on our growth or our growth to bring in also federal inmates federal inmates are not included in these projection numbers and the reason for that we want to let you know what your responsibility is for Union County responsible inmates and and offenders to house here should you choose to contract with the with the Marshall service or another Federal agency that's going be a

115policy decision that you're going to have to make will that will also include numbers and and and a quantity so let's say again you pick that round number of a th000 beds that you're going to look for then how many do you want to add on top of that to house whether it's for the feds for other counties or for what but we we exclude those intentionally because frankly that's going to be a policy decision on your part than absolutely I do want to follow back up you asked a question a long time a go about the stakeholders uh just to give you a list we we did speak with the sheriff with the chief Deputy with many of the jail staff uh the finance administrator uh services in the jail to include Food Service

116and Health Services um the lieutenant over investigations which is on the law enforcement side an assistant County Manager a district court judge the District Attorney's Office Human Resources I'm sorry Human Services administrator uh environmental health Superior Court Judge court security we don't often do court security but we talk to court security on on this one too uh for local law enforcement uh we talked to representatives from wax offw from Monroe and from wigit Deputy County Manager uh one of be your magistrates and the chief public defender and the clerk of court and the clerk of court thank you mam chair thank you I I appreciate that sir um you know I think that uh obviously the the stakeholders is pretty pretty important and um and I'm not saying that you guys didn't interview the right

117people um but I would say too that you know there's a lot more that we have to consider you know sitting in the seat besides just the just our our judicial staff and our law enforcement folks um and I I want to Circle back to something because this has been kind of kind of eating at me so uh when you were speaking you know I posed you a couple of questions regarding the arrest and the bookings and um and so I I think that we've covered this in detail tonight that obviously the study that you guys have done is based off of a number of assumptions and that's really all that you can provide us because as you mentioned we don't have you know that Court data that we'd like to have so so we're

118we're kind of handcuffed already and and I I understand that you guys are giving us the best data that you have but it's still based off of assumptions some of those assumptions are are large some of those um maybe not some so large but but U but it's still assumptions and I I think that you know I I think that we're to a point where if we're not arresting or detaining people because we don't have the bed space obviously that is a threat to the safety of our residents in my opinion um but the bigger question is is why in your key key stakeholder meetings why is it that we're not arresting and detaining people okay is it because we don't have the the bested space or because we don't want to send people to

119cabis County I mean and I know that maybe you guys can't answer that question but I think it's worth mentioning I I can answer the response that we got okay sure repeatedly was that there was there was no room at the end at cabis as well here okay but we also send prisoners to cabis County too and what's the cost per day for prisoners sent to cabis I think the sheriff is probably uh best suited to answer that I will say about okay thank you I will say about cabis too it is a little bit of a staffing issue for them too they have to have the staff available up there to handle our overflow and sometimes they don't have uh available staff we have worked with them to see if there's something we can

120arrange to send staff up there if they can overhire staff um but that is one of the concerns too that they may not have available staff to watch the prisoners that we do send up there okay but let's just look at it from cost perspective now I mean I I can understand that's a variable so it's $70 per day to send prisoners to other facilities like cabar how much is it to us as a cost here in Union County I believe it's about 65 right the last time we checked somewhere along that lines so we're talking about a difference of $5 per day and what's the the going rate for jails cost what's the cost if we build a thousand bed jail today thousand bed core what's the going rate for something like that the

121that varies depending part uh depending upon what part of the country uh you're in what we've seen lately is total project costs can range anywhere from $800 to $1,000 per square foot okay how many square feet youing yeah how many square feet are you looking at for a th beds I don't know until we get into the next steps of our so 300400 million no total build out to 240 okay but by the but by the time four years rolls around we're looking at 300 yeah that's that's and we're already $827 million in debt service and so um the other and and again I want to go back to the flip side because you you had a funny look you know whenever I mentioned this earlier and that is okay if we had more bed

122space space all right but if we had more bed space I asked the question so you're saying that we would arrest and detain more people and you're like well yeah okay all right so that's you know kind of implying that all right are we going to I mean are we going to be you know just trying to you know get the get the uh the breaks there and and trying to you know fill up uh fill up the in when we don't have to are we posing a unnecessary burden on the rate payers of I'm sorry the taxpayers of Union County um and and you know I I I certainly appreciate what you were saying where you were drawing references from other you know municipalities that you guys have worked with but I don't see

123that in the study I don't see a comparison in the state of North Carolina in the study so I don't see something in you know a different County in our state that's comparable to the size of Union County um I'd like to see some comparative information so you know again I I certainly appreciate you know you guys doing this study but I think that we all we all need to understand that this is not an exact science you know with the numbers that we're looking at um just my personal feeling on this is that you know hey do we need a new facility Well I think that you know you can look at our existing facility right now and make the case that structurally sure we need a new facility do we need additional bids

124probably um but I have a hard time believing that we need 822 thank you I think it was 1,200 yeah I think you're right okay Chris yes thank you very much yeah I just wanted to share a uh little bit of comment on commentary on next steps for Union County um so we we have a board retreat on the 12th and um what we plan to do there in addition to our general Capital um presentation is talk about some scenarios and present some scenarios those scenarios we're we're working through with a leadership team to try to develop what scenarios and that when I say scenarios means bed Count versus core size and so we'll present several scenarios and we're going to attach high level costs to them so that you can see uh what those

125mean um you know each of those scenarios um so we we'll come you know to you on the 12th with some of that information um now it's important to move to the next phase of this study for us to at least get to a decision on bed count core size um so that they can start the program and work so we can get a little our estimates can get get a little tighter you know at the endend of the study um and we could uh we think it's going to take 60 to 90 days once the board gives us Direction on bed count cor eyes to finish the study out which puts us sometime in June July to be able to bring a a full presentation complete uh report back to the board you Mr

126Helm's comments U are um kind of got me to thinking it can we draw any conclusions from the counties we usually identify with that are close in size to us perhaps some have somewhat of the growing pattern cabis County they have what a 600 bed jail we're sending them folks they're not quite as large heavily populated as Union County but they are growing and so they have a 600 bed jail and they obviously have room for our people that we're sending up there well but how far I mean how soon are they going to be capped out yeah if if um you weren't on the board at the time but I know the Sheriff's Office did some comparisons to Lo to other surrounding counties and like-sized counties and we can we can try to you

127know get that back out in front of you if that makes sense before the retreat so I have a chance to study it I can do my best to do that sir yes sir I imagine it can I'm sure the sheriff's off's got it like that yeah I think that to me I I understand what we're trying to do with the study is we're trying to put math to it and project out but I think it would be helpful to see comparable counties in in North Carolina we're dealing with the same legal environment under the same having the same parallel growth in needs for their jail facility ities as well does that make sense yeah all right that's it thank you commissioner meil can I make a comment please yes um after reviewing this information

128um back before commissioner sides and I were on uh the DI here in October um the Union County Council on came before the board and asked for additional funds for Meals on Wheels they produced um numbers for the board that showed the population up to 2042 um can I staff to put slide four back up according to the numbers that the Council on Aging produced they projected approximately 380,000 people in 2042 to and according to this um we're going to be 225 is so I'm going to make a charge to the board that we we're we're already at 260 then how yeah these numbers are and I think they may be using they may be using the adult population they're not using even still you know if I take 76 out that's over 300,000 and

129this number is not correct so so um again so as a board we need to reflect on these numbers and maybe get some more information from people that are presenting to us because it seems like these numbers are not accurate from somebody and it's making me very concerned because simply we're going to be on taxpayers are going to be on the hook for multitude of things that these um that different organizations are coming to us asking us to provide for and if numbers are wrong that means what we pay is wrong sure so I I just want to make sure that us going forward are really generating correct numbers that are coming to us and I'm not saying who is right and who is wrong I'm just saying the numbers that we're presented to us

130are very off yes I would somebody I would recommend that we that we use our comp plan those are the numbers that were presented to you for population growth and I I would recommend those would be the numbers you FOC but you understand what I'm saying these numbers are presented by different organizations so if I may for 2032 was the year the according to uh State demographer uh total population everybody 314 562 and adults would be 193 868 and I think you were looking at 2042 not 20 2042 is what she was looking at so uh total population 379 556 adults 800 he seems pretty confident yeah exactly um but I think I don't know if everyone's understand understand what's going on here but we've presenting been presented data back in October that said one

131set of numbers and then tonight we've been presented new sets of data with conflicting numbers so you know especially as a new board member it or you know all of us um hopefully by the retreat you know we need hopefully all of our departments and agencies are have good factual numbers and I think the ones tonight are pretty solid yeah they but um but it is confusing because a prior presentation on a different topic um was different but it's population they were looking at a population correct and that's another reason that I asked for who is what demographics age-wise are coming to the jail 18 okay um are there any other questions regarding this um tonight I would like to um call for a 10minute recess um for um we'll be back let's just call

132it we'll be back at 8 8:30 so we'll have a recess e e e okay thank you everyone um much needed break um so I would move that we we get back on track here the next item of business is item -44 the 2055 Metropolitan Transportation plan candidate projects I want to recognize beon Hansen senior planner concerning this item even chairwoman Merill members of the board manager Matthews this is a presentation on candidate projects that can be submitted for consideration by the Charlotte Regional Transportation Planning organizations um long range plan so we are part of a three-step process we've already envisioned our projects now we're prioritizing and and then the ones that get prioritized move into implementation this is the universe of projects that we draw from this is the comprehensive Transportation plan in uh

133the CPO portions of uni County which is the um urbanized portions or areas projected to urbanize so all of these roads that are in black or blue or red have recommendations for improvements in the future and the last time we went through this process was about five years ago this plan was adopted four years ago and these are the projects that are funded you have the Providence Road Widing the railroad extension you have Monroe Road us us74 you have a series of intersection projects 601 up to the Monro Expressway and um these are all some stage of implementation they might be in design a Right of Way Monroe Road obviously they're they're clearing trees out of the way so projects do move ahead and we're in the process of updating the new list of projects

134going out to 2055 so cart post listing projects now through Valentine's Day next Friday they're going to evaluate these projects on a variety of perspectives congestion safety cost benefit uh impacts on the community they're going to evaluate them in March and April come back with a draft list in May and complete the work hopefully by July and then the documentation will occur and this whole process will be complete by next spring something to keep in mind is the money is already committed now through 2035 so we're talking about projects 10 20 or 30 years into the future so this this list of projects includes um background information information and it includes coordination with the adjacent mun or the affected municipalities for this specific project with Wesley Chapel it's NC 84 from the existing uh widening

135which ends at their Town Hall continues at East to Airport Road thought that was a logical Terminus it's about 2 and a half miles it's consistent with our comprehensive plans with our um transportation plan Wesley Chapel has endorsed this and the cross-section would be similar to what's already designed for c84 which should be four lanes with a median sidewalks or multi-purpose path on the shoulders any questions about this project um it if you're going all the way to Airport Road is that going to mess up the roundabout there sure [Laughter] okay I I I ass I assure you it will it will wreck that roundabout and someone will have to something will have to be rebuilt in this place so we get a two-lane roundabout I don't know what the design will be but that

136roundabout will have to be changed to long enough to see any of this stuff anyway so you all can figure it out we'll probably have flying cars by then anyway right maybe okay the next one is Old Charlotte Highway uh continuing on from the current widening which is essentially Sun Valley and continuing South to Rogers Road this was in coordination with Monroe and Indian Trail is about 1.5 miles it's also consistent with our comprehensive plan consistent with the comprehensive Transportation plan via similar cross-section multi-purpose path sidewalk median um some intersections would have revised um access so it might only be right in right out or directional crossovers but it would go to Rogers which is just North of the large grade separation project that we recently had funded at the railroad tracks at Old Charlotte

137Highway and Rocky River M chair um Bor sorry uh beorn real quick just for clarification um so Indian Trill Monroe they are in support of this particular project yes they are thank you sir could would you go back to your comment you made on Rocky River Old Charlotte Highway intersection yes could you reiterate that again that's a that's a railro project that's funded to take the intersection and revise it so it'll be so the roads will go over the railroad tracks which it crosses twice once at Rocky River and once at Old Charlotte Highway way and if I remember a conversation with Mr Jensen that that is from a different pot of money involving the rail roads no it's just a it's it's an it's an artificial different pot of money it's a funding category

138but it's all Transportation dollars is it a category that has funding yes it's funded it was one of 10 in the entire state that was funded this past spring it was funded this past spring when do you anticipate design and starting to move dir I don't I don't know probably five years oh okay well that's five years Marshville bypass this is an eastern part of the county this is also consistent with our comprehensive plan which identifies us74 as a future Interstate you need to upgrade us74 to get future Interstate designation this is potentially a toll project that tolling study is going to start any time now uh in light of the fact that the study is not going to be complete by next Friday we're requesting that an assumption of toll benefits be applied uh

139on a basis based off of the um percent of the Monroe Expressway was paid for by tols so that would be approximately 25% for this project uh be Lane controlled access similar to the Monroe Expressway and Marshville is in support of submitting this project as well so if the Turnpike Authority agrees to make it a toll would that expedite the construction yes it would so who do we ask do we ask or petition the Turnpike Authority to take it over as I mean make it a toll road how the first the first thing is submitting it tonight if it makes in the MTP then that allows it to then get in the queue for funding to design and Implement okay so they but when would the Turnpike Authority get involved as far as making it

140a toll road part as a part of the design and and potentially they could Jump Right In yes okay thank you and then this isn't a road widening it's really two intersections in downtown heni Bridge Ed wild milgrove and inel fair viiew um really they operate as one intersection because they're so close together there's a lot of s maneuvering of the traffic it's very unsafe it's congested it's also uh a frequently flooded area so there's a lot of benefits by improving these um we don't know what the design will be um but it's a it's a critical intersection from our process uh two years ago uh this is supported by heni bridge and by the town of Indian Trail and then the last one is is not a request for support it's actually a request

141to or recommendation to oppose which is the waaw parkway I I will note that waaw actually has some alternatives on what they what they're submitting there's a segment that just goes from nc16 to wax Onan Trail which is completely within the town that's their purview so we have no comments on that but the overall segment going to nc75 crosses through Mineral Springs crosses their own Incorporated Union County um the county has taken a position in the past and this would be consistent consistent with that to oppose that project and Mineral Springs is scheduled to take a similar action at their meeting next Thursday night you're mentioning Highway 16 is that in the earlier years planned widening of Highway 16 that's funded designs underway hopefully later this decade it's actually well under construction but yes that's

142a very near-term project 10 years being near-term as far as roads go sad to say but yes yeah Madam chair um be if I can stop you right here and and just provide the board a little bit of clarity so um in regards to waxall Parkway um correct Union County in Min Springs is opposed this um now crtp at this point um is kind of off the radar if you will I mean it's still there but no local points have been assigned to it um and there's been at least some reluctance ceed to take this issue up because the three stakeholders involved meaning Union County um uh Mineral Springs and of course waxall uh do not have any common agreement there so just to give you guys some context okay so the request tonight is

143to support the proposed applications the four that I listed and then the one for for opposition and um chair or I mean uh Vice chair hel would be your representative at CPO to express those votes when it comes to prioritization of and um and inclusion in the ultimate plan for projects like these Madam chair yes um I'll make the motion that we uh adopt the action requested tonight um and that is there with me one second here that we uh approve the candidate project recommendations um as presented um with the exception of the wax Hall Park Parkway my motion would include uh that we would continue to oppose the wax hall Parkway so uh to sum it up the requested action uh my m is to adopt the requested action as presented here on screen

144thank you board any comments questions okay we have a motion all those in favor of the motion say I I I okay thank you thank you than next on our agenda is item 254 47 Union County Land preservation and easement program update I want to recognize Alan Aldridge Union County Soil and Water Conservation District director concerning this item okay good evening Madam chair Commissioners manager Matthews on behalf of the Sol water board and the a Advisory board we're excited to provide you update and new business on the land preservation and easement program a couple of y'all have seen the next three slides but I think it's important to show them so uh Farm Lo loss in Union County North Car North Carolina ranked second in the United States for open space land loss with Union

145County ranking 13th um with a county that is the third largest a county in uh uh North Carolina I think uh this is alarming to a lot of people um and this slide first saw a legislative meeting with local state and federal Partners which extension hosted really started uh the Farmland uh preservation uh talks so previous commission action uh approved in 2023 November 6th um this board approved staff to apply for North Carolina Farmland preservation trust fund Grant uh approved the Union County Soil and Water District to hold conservation easements and adopted the budget amendment allowing us to take PV rollback money and put it in the land preservation program the 2023 funding was $969,000 and future PV rollback money and this as y'all know the PV rollback money is money a three-year back grab

146uh from back taxes with land coming out of a forestry Horticulture Wildlife so some staff actions since the program was approved um December 2023 we applied for the adfp uh Grant through uh the Department of Agriculture uh we interviewed with them in April of 24 um in may we applied for a facilitation Grant with work the working lands trust fund and the foundation of so and water in June we awarded that um July 24 we provided a template from the working lands trust fund for Union County Land preservation easement program um August of 2024 we were awarded $155,000 from adfp through the department of act for the development Grant okay uh so we developed a land preservation easement ordinance in uh partnership with Union County legal department we have worked with the so and Water

147Board of Supervisors and the Advisory Board to set priorities and develop a rank criteria for future easements and we are currently working with a rule land committee to set future priorities and ranking criteria and we have been engaging with a lot of land owners we have a long list of people to contact when this goes live so this is uh the first easement this is our pilot project easement 90 20251 this is a 104 Acre Farm off of Highway 200 Morgan Mill Road it is almost half and half uh AG land and Forest land it has over 60 Acres of sols of Statewide importance and Prime Farmland so that's over half of the property and it also has 3100 ft of river Frontage has a historic mill on the site it's a centy farm and

148it's also in the voluntary act District before I get to the next part I'm going to show you the map of the property um you can see it's on Rocky River and has a bunch of forest land and crop land so going back uh the uh fair market value the estimated fair market value is just a little over a million dollars uh the Pu value is 52,900 so the total conservation easement value is $962,000 we are looking at a 75% purchase of this easement which is a permanent easement and that's $721 575,000 this has a 25% donation value of $240,000 um so that is uh a per 75% purchase easement with a 25% donation any questions on this easement what's a sentury farm a farm that has been in the family for over 100 years

149Century mad yes just touch on donation um value there again just so I'm clear with that okay so we are purchasing $720,000 that's 75% of the easement value okay with the landowner donating 25% if he would go after other uh easement programs they pay up to 100% the state will pay 50 and the FEDS will pay 50 so we're looking at a 75% Max on our uh conservation easements any other questions regarding that no sir okay this is our second easement tonight easement 9020 25002 this is a 59 Acre Farm off of Walters Mill Road it has 35 acres in Crop Production 20 in Forest land and it has 25 acres of soils of Statewide importance it has three different ponds equaling around three acres but this is 100% donation um the estimated uh fair

150market value on this property is $45,881 after we look at state sales data we have to adjust that to the new value of $65 942 um so this is pre tax reval numbers and the uh median sales ratio value adjust that to $65,000 um with pu value of $54,000 the T the estimated total donated conservation easement value is $551,000 so we are not per purchase and dis easement we're getting it donated 100% all we have to pay for is transactional cost surveys Environ environmental assessments and legal fees associated with this any questions and here's a map on that property what are soils of Statewide importance very important St soils to agriculture in other words it's very fertile very fertile okay any any other questions on this SL Tell City so other opportunities uh that we

151have when we um move this program forward uh adfp which is through the department of a we can ask for uh matching opportunities we can work with them and pay for transactional costs which will help uh adfp applications rank higher um for other easements so we're not just looking at the Union County program we're looking at other opportunities to conserve land in Union County um with the uh adfp program there's the AL through nrcs so it's basically the same thing but with Federal monies um and we we're also working with eement par Partners Kataba lands working lands trust and three L Three Rivers Kataba lands actually brought us the donated easement um and again we worked with Kataba lands uh on that Grant so the actions that we were requesting tonight as a soul and

152water board and the ACT Advisory Board is to adopt the Union County Land preservation and easement ordinance as attached approve the allocation of funds from the budget that long number for the purchase of easements 90 20251 for the amount of $721,000 Z1 into the Union County Land preservation easement program except the donation of easement 92 90 20 25002 into the Union County Land preservation easement program and AD adopt budget amendment 22 appropriate in the Union County's general fund unassigned fund balance in the amount of $885,000 991 to be used for the purchase of conservation easements and Associated transactional cost and to make clear that is PV rollback money from 2024 for lands coming out of a forestry Hort and Wildlife so that was a big ask is there any questions regarding that or okay um

153Madam chair I've got questions um how much federal funds have we received to increase the dollar amount to add land into these preservations zero can we get funds from the federal uh going back uh a couple months ago when we first presented this one of the main reasons to have the Union County program is speed so if we apply for an adfp uh easement 3 to 5 years to get 50% once they get that then they have to apply for Al okay three more you're looking at a 3 to sevene process for that now if we have land owners are willing to wait yes we'd love to push them there it'll cost less for us and we'll get more land conserved because we'll just have to pay for the transactional cost but a lot of

154land owners when they're thinking about easements they're not they're either they've had a health scare they something's come up and they're thinking about you know the future of their land but no we will apply that is part of the program we again just got the uh uh where we could hold easements in 2023 okay um so what happens to the property after the land owner passes it transfers just like any other property would to the next landowner okay does it remain in the program at that point perpetuity forever okay okay um and who's responsible for the taxes once it's entered into the program the landowner okay they're still responsible for the taxes um is this considered a revocable or irrevocable trust I can't answer that question this generally falls into the realm of an irrevocable

155documentation it's not technically a trust it's more of an easement that's purchase so if you can think of it as a uh when you sell off an easement uh the purchaser of that easement has it for as long as they own it it's just theirs okay yeah the word trust was just used in it so I wanted to verify okay any other questions Madam chair if if I could I just want to talk sorry I can't figure it out either just on the uh the last bullet point if the board does want to do this and move forward with this program again this funding would come out of the County's available fund balance which you saw at the last board meeting in the audit so it would come out of that that dollar amount I

156just wanted you all to be aware of that not saying you should or shouldn't do I just want you to know that that would come out of available fund balance for your uh consideration as part of the budget I I have another question Madam CH how many other properties um have approach um have an interest in putting this into the easement we we have not pushed this out but right now just people watching these meetings we have 10 to 15 people coming the when we start talking about this we' get a lot of interest saying we'd really haven't even pushed it out okay in light of that that this is increasing in popularity uh should we not look at this as a regular budget item for next year rather than going out of the fund

157balance well go ahead if we anticipate this continuing to occur well in the way the program is set up that as land comes out of the voluntary act district there are three years worth of taxes that are clawed back and that's the funding that is being used to pay for the program so the board could put additional funding into it if you chose to but this is all land that has come out of the the voluntary act District so the cost is coming back around to us right and and the other thing is is from year to year that number changes right so right right harder to budge for got you got you long as the money's coming back if I'm not mistaken it was over 900,000 last time we talked about this right that

158was the 2023 amount this is the this is the 2024 request that number was 969 thank you I would like to hear I would like to um ask the county manager I mean in light of um this coming out of our fund balance I I would like to hear your comments on you know the the pros cons impact you I mean certainly it has an impact on our overall um budget but I think from our perspective we look at what is the benefit from the program and the program is actually uh geared at doing a couple of things the board has made it very clear that you have a desire to protect rural uh open space and the rural character of this community you're not going to do that unless you put your money where

159your mouth is and I think that's kind of what this is this is a a a way to help with that so yes it has an impact but I think honestly it's a good program okay um so that that's exactly what I wanted to hear did you have a question Mr H okay okay well then I would like to make a motion that we approve the action um coming for us for the soil and water um 25-47 Madam chair yes Ju Just a comment before we vote um first of all Alan thank you appreciate that um you know when we previously discussed this obviously I was a big proponent of this program and and I still land um I think that the comments from our County Manager uh were spond on um sometimes you have

160to put your money where your mouth is and this is something that this speaks to the fabric of Union County um you know agriculture is so important to us um and maintaining you know these you know permanent easements to make sure that these properties remain agriculturally based is um is is immensely important especially considering ing the um the uh the residential growth that we've seen in this area so I'll be supporting the motion thank you okay if I could just second his comments uh I mean good land like you have here they don't make it anymore and once it's turned into a shopping center or a residential neighborhood it doesn't go back to Farmland so U the numbers you provided about the loss of Farmland how Union County ranks in the nation that is that

161is very sobering figure it's not a number to be proud of yeah y absolutely yeah um I me I just made the comment that it's not a number to be proud of um thank you very much for coming forth for this information it's greatly appreciated um it's something that is very near and dear to my heart um along with a lot of the people out in our audience tonight that are farmers or have been Farmers um the 13th in the nation is not something to be proud of in the loss of land um so I I am very honored that I was able to present this tonight absolutely okay we have a motion on the floor U to approve this request all those in favor say I I I unanimous thank you so much thank

162you next on our agenda is item 25- 056 appointments to boards and committees there are three boards with vacancies for consideration this evening these vacancies have been advertised in accordance with the board's rules of procedure applications have been received and information regarding the vacant positions may be found in the background provided for this item first is the Consolidated Human Services Board there are nine total V vacancies on this board I will now entertain a motion for nominations commissioner HMS Madam chair thank you um I would like to make a motion that that we appoint uh Mr no herrian uh to fill the vacant engineer position um and I think we can probably do this all in one motion but I'd also make the motion that we approve or appoint uh Miss Lisa Kerner uh to

163fill the other person position at the Consolidated Human Services support okay any comments okay all those in favor say I I I the second board with a vacancy for consideration this evening is the Board of Equalization and review I will now entertain a motion for a nomination for this board Madam chair um I'll make the motion that we appoint um Mr Thomas J Smith to the Board of Equalization and review okay all those in favor say I I I Okay the third board with vacancies for consideration this evening is the library Board of Trustees there are three vacancies on this board I will now entertain a motion for nominations to the library Board of Trustees Madam chair yes I'll make the motion that we appoint uh the three applicants um I'm probably going to mess

164this name up but Valerie um Grom Lovitz Julie Thomas and also Charlene balkam to the library Board of Trustees thank you very much all those in favor say I I I okay that brings us to the end of our meeting um I will start um with the county manager's comments uh I just want to say thank you to the board I appreciate uh the opportunity to work for the board and wish you a good night and I'll remain at this end commissioner Gary sides no confidence man' commissioner HMS thank you madam chair um just real quick I I want to uh tell the the folks that took the time to come tonight and speak thank you um I really appreciated U the engagement from the public and and the participation um our first speaker um

165for gosh what was the what was the organization about the trees oh yeah I thought that was Meredith m yeah Miss Mah trees Union I yeah I thought that that was fantastic and certainly appreciated that um I appreciated also the um the input that we got from others that had concerned with uh animal well welfare um as always appreciate our staff tonight it's been a long night but we've had lots of good discussion I think and it's been uh it's been a good productive meeting so again thank you to all of our staff um thank you to my fellow board members and to uh everyone out there good night okay commissioner Cy bam yeah thank you thank you madam chair I thought you were coming on this way um truly the only comment is I'm

166I'm really happy to see the farm down at the river Morgan Mill Road and Rocky River going into this program I've often admired that farm would often would have liked to have bought that farm but this is the next best thing that it will remain in agriculture and I hope everybody has a good night thank you commissioner HMS no com thank you okay um I would be remiss if I didn't say commissioner um Jerry Simpson thank you for being um here tonight it's always great um to see you active and um out I know what yall do yeah yeah and you and you still show up and support us so just wanted to say hello and thank you for being here tonight we also had uh the chairman of un of Union County Public Schools

167um Board of Education we had Jimmy Benin here with us tonight um so that that yeah Jimmy was here and um and I just Joel it's always great to have your part participation so um thank you everyone for um being here tonight and with that I will make a motion to adjourn all those in favor say I I I good night everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.