CorpusRecord 195450

Greenfield Planning Board Meeting 2 13 25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV)
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Franklin County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,615 words · about 54 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right call this meeting to the Greenfield planning board to order um Jeff saer Vice chair standing in for George Who chair but is out sick uh so if anyone is recording this please let me know thank you what else do we have to say at the front the beginning that's it the recorded message great let's um this is my first time as chair so screw all up let me go around across the board and to see who else here Jeff saler Vice chair Victor big michella Clark uh Tom bledo alternate ER Riz er er Riz alternate so when the lights are green they're on right that is correct okay and today you guys will both be voting if you want to okay we have three Gap three spots to fill so we have four

002voting members today so Mr chair you have officially ele ated the two alternates as voting members correct thank you all right the next order of business to approve the minutes of January 2nd don't move second any discussion no they looked like they were pretty accurate when I was reading them over I didn't see I'm not as good at the spelling and grammar piece of it but I think think the context was as I remember the meeting um I read the minutes but I feel like I should have St since I wasn't at the meeting and wasn't even on the planning board at the time fair enough I'm not sure if what the protocol is Eric meeting minutes it's the majority of those present of the Quorum so two can vote in me minutes that's good

003I would obain for the same reason okay was there a second though second to did you second that to what uh the motion to approve the minutes did he make a motion to yes I did yes second all in favor I I I abstain two abstain excellent okay number four discussion items first revised proposed amendments to section 256 accessory dwelling units of the zoning ordinance and does everybody have that handy I I have a question on that just one second here now there there are multiple versions in the packet I got so the one that I'm looking at is uh bolded in the top and the date is October 3 2024 December 18 2024 January 28 2025 and on the lower right corner it says one page is that that one we're all looking at

004correct it is okay good all right I'm ready okay so my understanding is the purpose primary purpose of these modifications is to bring the Adu um portion of the zoning ordinance into compliance with the affordable homes act uh which technically went into effect on the 5th of February and so the Eric you've made we've made changes that to our the best of our knowledge reflect the guidance from the state and we've gotten better and better guidance over time so we have pretty clear guidance at this point about what to do including official definitions for certain things clarification on U some of the the caveats like what a bus station is uh when parking rules can be adjusted in response to Transit proximity those sorts of things um so Eric what would you would you say

005at this point what we're looking at here reflects to the best of your knowledge an ordinance that's as compliant as it can be to the chairman is yes from based on the training that I have uh attended the final regulations put out by the state and the legal memos and briefs that I've read I believe that the proposed zoning amendments and our Adu ordinance will meet the new law the spirit and intent of the new law and that's my opinion too having gone through it and following along with I I agree I think it does exactly what we need to do I agree as well okay having read them great so Eric can you remind us we're endorsing this like I guess we're still in discussion do we discuss the two items and then we

006come back to action items or we do action on this one and then discuss the next one so yes I would say that you would want to kind of discuss the two together because they're kind of joined um there is one provision in the site plan regulations that is being amended that is not relative to adus and we can I I'll bring that out when we go over that but the rest of it is because of the the new law relative to adus so I would recommend discussion on that as well and then the process would be to take a vote if you agree with the language and the intent of what we're doing here uh to initi forward it to the city council to officially initiate the zoning amendment process that will result a

007joint public hearing with the economic development committee of the city council which we're hoping to do March 6 uh on your agenda on March 6 okay so again we're just going to make a comment a discussion comment on pages one through six correct um one action item is to look at one through sixou one through four four uh wait sorry yeah is one through six there is something that I I need to discuss with the board on the Adu portion um so we're still discussing that I believe yes so the very last page of the proposed amendment second last page basically the the new law has a new use called a protected use Adu the intent is clear municipalities do not try to stop adus protected use adus it's very clear but if there's a

008second you on a property or or in a district where it's not a single family home is allowed then you can regulate it you can RIT it in those districts or you could require a special permit for the second unit so what I wanted to discuss with the board is table of uses part of the Amendments um it would get rid of the definitions accessory unit within an accessory unit detached and uh detached it would just a protected accessory dwelling unit definition lowed by right in all districts that currently allow single family homes but I put a second use category in the table of uses called and this is where I need your guidance it's second accessory dwelling unit pursuant to the section and dwell accessory dwelling units but I didn't really like the the

009name second accessory dwelling unit I was thinking and I'll get the board's view on it that it could be called a nonprotected accessory unprotected that's what that's what it is one the first one is protected the second is unprotected I think being consistent with the terminology is fine there okay does the board agree with that language better than second excep unit y yes now can I have a clarification with that for example if you're in a on a two family dwelling lot and you're putting an accessory unit in one of those dwellings that would fall into the unprotected as an example because we have that are two family duplexes sorry I didn't mean to talk over you I'm sorry yeah so so your your question is if there's a two family dwelling existing two family

010dwelling dwelling and they want to add a third unit yeah for example within one of the one side of the two family for example they want to carve out an Adu would that fall under protected or unprotected unprotected unprotected okay and that unprotected would allow for those different scenarios in those pre-existing two family lots I believe so I believe it even would extend to a single family residence that wants to put an additional Adu you have a single family residence with a protected Adu already in existence and they decide they want to put a second Adu on there that now becomes an unprotected Adu and it would follow all the guidelines we put in place for unprotected adus is that correct Eric that is correct okay I know thank you Victor I I had a

011similar question along the same lines which was trying to understand the distinction between single family and two family since our code doesn't really distinguish between them um but I understand the the protected is for single family but it's really for in a single family District which is in our case includes two families so is this a choice to say that two family units can't have a protected Adu or is that what the state is telling us is that it's a choice it's a choice what these regulations that I put forth after the final regulations and hearing all the the trainings and legal briefs is is only on protected adus uh the initial amendments included two families and you know so a two family could come in and that would fall under the the protected use

012but I'm like let's just make it let's just meet the law the law it means only single family so two families is another whole use category it's only single family homes that can have that protect right I was trying to understand that Eric because the but if you are two we could include two families but if you're but right now you're saying if someone is in a two family they could seek to put in an accessory dwelling unit it would be unprotected so they would need to go through the special permit process corre so SD do let's go I just I because I'm just thinking about there's there's two families and there's two families and I'm thinking about there's a lot of properties that you can't tell whether they're a single family or a two

013family it's just now it's been cut up into two nothing different about that property it used to be a single the grounds are all the same everything is the same he wouldn't know from the outside what it is and I'm trying to understand well why would it be that if the person that now owns it is it's now viewed as a two you know why are there kind of different rights on what they can do but I do understand that this is really about single family and that is now no longer a single family even though the structure you might not be able to tell the difference corre uh but in that case someone could go through a special permit process if they wanted to do it so the Avenue is still there it's just

014a nonprotected Avenue so I'm I'm good with that and within that unprotected as in as also with the protected it can be within without detached or connected correct that encompasses all those definitions y so you You' kept liation you've kept it to a single family as a as kind of a choice and anything beyond that is a permit process correct so sorry and the only thing it that separates the Adu from a regular family dwelling is the limitation of size 900 gr square feet has to be under 900 gr square feet so anything above that is considered a second dwelling and that would then you're getting into two family lots Etc the only other caveat is you yes I mean in Greenfield because we can do up to three family by right U isn't all

015that meaningful of a distinction except for detached because you can't have a detached other unit so only the detached technically would be held to that standard right you could just not call it an Adu and as far as most of the dep departments at the city are concerned they wouldn't carry the way it's still going to be subject to building code and all those other things the the protected adus still have to meet the um maximum lot coverage by requirements setback requirements Etc so we already have limitations based on Dimensions right and everything has to fall than that because I know there was a lot of concern about that but that has that is not changing even for a protected Adu you still have to meet those dimensional requirements can I ask one question on

016that point because I I had heard from someone that one of the distinctions is that for an existing structure it could be grandfathered in and then if you're then going to make that an Adu you're basically grandfathered in from the setbacks and all that stuff yes true so the new regulations and law clearly specifies that if there is an existing single family home on a non-conforming lot doesn't meet lot area Frontage setbacks whatever it is di menion requirement a protected Adu still has to be allowed on the on the property does it have to meet the setback requirements do you think Eric or I mean obviously if if there was a Structure there already I assume you're that's sort of grandfather in but if you're saying a non-conforming lot and you wanted to add Adu

017do you have to meet all of the otherwise or how does that work other things can be met you you have to meet them if they can't be met because of of the non-conformity of the single family lot then you still have to allow a protected Adu use I see and they would would they have to go through the variance process no that's whole point of they protected no special permits no variances no other permitting even if they right if they're but I think are you talking about putting an addition on an existing non-conforming structure dimensionally non-conforming structure I was just asking about that because I was told that one of the things the only difference in Greenfield because we can do a two family as of right the only difference besides the 900 units

018that 900 square feet limitation is that because of the grandfathering language that an Adu actually has some grandfathered rights that a two family if you were if you were in a single and you wanted to make it a two you wouldn't but have that same but I I'd like a clarification on that then Eric so you already have a nonconforming my understanding when you have a non-conforming structureal a lot you can't make it worse you can't make it more non-conforming so that Adu would theoretically have to be contained within the unit am I interpreting that correctly it can be detached so you're making your non-conforming let's say it's non-conforming as far as coverage and setbacks on both sides for example and you put on an Adu that's going to make it grossly non-conforming is that

019allowed that's what the new law is saying yes interesting okay yeah it seems the only area where given Greenfield law where an Adu actually would provide some structures more Le way but it's very narrow I mean it's very like the example I like to use to say a lot needs 10,000 sare F feet and has 9,000 sare F feet single family home on there and somebody wanted to do a duplex answer is no the building inspector would say no you don't meet the the coverage in the lot area but if the Adu somebody wanted to put a detached Adu on that same lot the answer is yes but only 900 but only 900 ft but only 900 yeah it's just a general Principle as long as you're making the specific non-conformity worse you can it's

020not an issue that even with setbacks even with setbacks well L wasn't cleared on the types of non-conformity it just said a non-conforming lot a single family lot must allow a protected Adu use okay is there does there I guess two comments one I feel like we should have a definition of unprotected ad exactly that was a second piece of the whole thing we besides changing this uh people of use the language we would need to add it definition of unprotected ad yeah just to make it clear because somewhere needs to say I mean basically it's an additional Adu that's the it's a sec yes a second Adu being put on a piece of property is essentially an unprotected Adu right and then one other thought is if if you were in a Sit how

021do you demonstrate how do you prove that you can't meet the setbacks and all those other things in the non-conforming situation like it seems like there could be language that you have to put it in the least disruptive side or something like that I mean how how can you just put it wherever you want because you you know you're GNA break the you're gonna have to you're going to infringe on some setback somewhere to get the protected use in there if it were a second unit you couldn't do it but if it's an ad it's a protected use you can do it but still you guys' link is broken again this meaning was tried to happen last week or two weeks ago whenever it was because I go to so many meetings but online you

022cannot log into your meeting again so there will be an open meeting law filed again on this if this meeting doesn't stop now because the public cannot ACC say where you try to log it from you have to go in through a back Channel that's the only reason why Stephanie's in find the password so if you go to the meeting calendar you can't you cannot get in from I'm trying to get in as we speak in my pocket what about like uh from the board agenda L you guys see me try to get into your meeting that I can't get into so if there's other people in town and this is well Eric Eric if I can speak the uh the notice you sent me with the agenda and the link on it the link

023itself actually took me to the January 2nd meeting but the meeting ID and the passcode brought me here so I had no trouble getting it on Zoom I just used the meeting ID and the passcode that was included with the with the agenda you sent out for this meeting the meeting link brought me to last month's meeting but the meeting ID and passcode brought me here that you were able to get in from the agenda yes which is not accessible to the public is it possible to open the January 2nd meeting that's the one that's linked just have the file me this I'm just just letting you guys know as a concerned citizen because I know there's probably plenty of people that are sitting here trying to do the same thing I'm this is a

024so you're aware of some people that were trying to get in and they can't yeah okay do you think we can is it possible how you guys want to continue with that I want all right thank you thank you very much see you're letting us know that again is it possible to open it is it's happening too except that goes to City Hall January that's the wrong jary second was that's the thing about hybrid meetings man cityil yeah that's what I mean the whole town voted on it they want to do it you guys just this is but no no they we're gon to meeting but this is the result of that hybrid vote oh it's the result of somebody not fixing account somebody not doing their job that's all right now so we discussed

025that so what are we doing now we're just going to make a recommendation to send a favorable view disc we should continue this meeting or now what do you guys think well we got a quarum have a quarum the meeting links appears to work I got it I got in from the agenda he's gonna file the thing anyways like he always does so the only people that wanted to speak just left I mean they were here so I don't I don't quite understand why they needed to leave they they had a choice to stay in the no they did that's what I'm saying so they they sort of I mean if they want to participate they could have but they just have left so but last time this happened George the chair chose to close

026the meeting down he did at that time the same last time they got in I guess through the same way that that Stephanie's in now and George determined that it's just too is is this a is this a thing that's happened a lot with meetings in town it's happened a few times um I think we close the meeting I mean people the hybrid thing there going to be technical glitches on occasion people have to get used to that a little bit but yeah I don't know it's up to the board you're the board decide to continue or close it down I think we continue got myself and you got Stephanie who were able to get in online so people can get online you had people in the audience who could have commented and have elected

027to leave that's their choice I don't think we not have the meeting why why should we not have the meeting okay I I would agree with that and it's also it's fairly straightforward matters here I mean okay I don't think there's a lot of controversy and and the people who left actually presented fairly in-depth testimony already which we can take but I I I would be inclined to continue s like the board has reached consensus to how do you feel yeah what do you think er um I mean if we're making a decision tonight that could be contested that would be contest the only thing that would so here's what we say you continue the meeting and you vote to put this to the city council to initiate the zoning amendment process a public hearing

028will be scheduled will be properly voted and the meeting link will be quadruply checked yeah and so the public will be notified to come in and comment on this same language so nothing's changing nothing's lost no opportunity is lost they can still come March 6 and this is recorded and this is recorded they can also look at the recording on a we'll put it on the website even just just so people can see it so this so today today there could have been comments on this but today is really not the main point for public comment on it that is the hearing that's coming up which if we take a vote today we could then move ahead and create the public comment the hearing there is no public meeting on our agenda tonight I think

029if there was a public hearing it'd be a lot easier decision we can't have a public hearing without without that but meeting and it's straightforward matters I believe the board has made a good decision to continue we're not really taking any action outside of initiating something that will generate a public hearing exactly yeah yeah and those people could have stayed I guess you're right so I don't know why they left we heard from those individuals we've heard from and we could hear from them again we would if they wanted to speak we would have let them speak that's I'm sure they'll speak I'm sure they'll comment a public hearing yeah so that's the time to do it anyway so okay all right it doesn't become law when we're we vote on it it becomes law

030when Council votes on it right so the next step is to what make a put forward a recommendation a positive or negative to council for this that gets done after the public hearing for right now the board just either if you agree on the language then someone makes a motion to initiate forward this to the city council to initiate the zoning Amendment and Eric is this just for a just for 256 or is this for 261 as well just the first one just see I think Eric was about to talk about the definition for we go ahead yeah for unprotected right right so what we need to do is finalize the definition of unprotected Adu and then move on to the site plan and how that relates to the adus and then if the board's

031in agreement with the language and and the logic behind it then you would take that vote forward at city council initia process so definition of unprotected Adu I thought agree is this a second Adu on a single family residence or any Adu on a multif family residence yeah two family or above right so unprotected Adu would be a second accessory dwelling unit on a single family property or any Adu on a multif family property would you say know two or three multi family property is four or more units all right two or two or three bed two or three family property if you add a fourth unit to a a three family then it's multif family still um it it's just really uh a single let me think now it's a two family basically adding

032a or a two family property so it's a second Adu on a single family property or an Adu on a two two family prop or any Adu on a two family property that's very clear yep thank you okay so that would that's something that you would add I would add that language cover that would be forwarded to the city council with the excluded language that we just discussed to initiate the process once we once the board votes on that so is everyone good with the accessory dwelling unit proposed amendments I would just make one more comment that I think so the because the purpose of this modification at this time is to bring the ordinance into compliance with the state legislation it makes sense to do that and nothing further it doesn't mean that in

033the future under different conversation we could add more opportunities to do adus but I've seen this blow up with the uh 3A the MBTA communities act if you guys have followed that one at all yes where a lot of cities and towns thought that their planning boards were bringing the zoning up to compliance and in reality the boards were kind of taking it further and that people weren't happy about that just because it was it was considered in bad faith given what their task was just to get it up to compliance so I think it's good and and it's kind of non-controversial that it needs to be compliant it becomes controversial if we go further than that well and and you're making a compliant and you're making some conservative calls on a couple of the

034issues where there's more flexibility yes which can be more liberalize later right yeah good summary the other thing the whole point of this Adu um legislation is to putting an Adu in existing house is is probably the most economical way to to add an extra dwelling unit when you get into over two families when you get into three families it changes with the building code sprinkler code I mean you name it there are all sorts of things that kick in and already fire separation with just between units is already there it's already pretty honorous depending what your configuration looks like but the whole point of the Adu is to keep it really simple and it's easy to tack on either detached or within a unit and well within a unit it's a little harder but

035detached to put a unit outside and create some another dwelling it's very economical and very attainable economically attainable for most homeowners and that was the whole point of that Adu which is it's happening around the country but it it's you know it's actually a good thing yep I mean your kids want to be independent stick them in the Adu you know they grow up whatever I mean there's so many sen it's not only seniors but there's so many situations um socially where it's nice to have that little extra without having to turn it into a whole big huge project that requires all sort well excuse me all sorts of approvals that really and this will require less now yeah next do you want to talk about the other one yes let me talk about OS

036amendments to section 20061 ecode numbers site plan review and approval the bring through zoning ordinance it's section 200 d8.4 under the numbers so the new law and especially the training and it was made clear in the training and the legal memo received from different organizations like Franklin Regional Council governments and others that have to treat a protected use Adu as you would a single family home so do we require site plan review for a single family home the answer answer is no we never have and we never will never say never but right now we never have in the past and we we're not doing it now so Adu protected Adu use has to be treated as a single family use so this removes site plan review for adus which is um second the very

037first section under B5 page one so that that would need to be stricken to meet the new law and the regulations yep that's really it other than one other change in the entire there have been uh citizens concerned citizens that have reached out to the board suggesting we look at other things like traffic studies and other requirements of site plan review but this is strictly two things mostly protected use Adu which is removing it from site plan review review and approval and the second thing that was discussed resulting from even zba meetings is that should a Butters be notified of a site plan review right now they're not notified it's not required under law and of course site plan review is not even in Mass general laws it's all case law so now you're talking

038about any site plan R viiew not just yeah site plan the entire common wealth of Massachusetts I mean under any circumstance in in Greenfield now we're not about adus anymore this this conversation now about site plan review correct in any case any case all site plan reviews this this is the topic that was discussed notifying a butters for all site plan reviews and putting two in the newspaper was this was this on the table already then to be considered you're saying independent of the adus or yes this is totally independent of the adus and since we're doing a proposed amendments I included this amendment requiring but of notification I see yeah so right now if you do a special perent application all the butters within 300 ft of the subject property get notified by mail

039but not for site plan and two legal ads in the green field recorder get put in one two weeks out one one week out required by law site plan review none of that gets done municipalities are allowed to go above and beyond the law and there are a few communities out there that do require a butter notification and legal ads for site plans but not many uh but this would be something that the board should consider giving the U the request from I guess I have a question about the word a Butters you me an a butter a typical lot has three AB Butters front I mean side side and back across the street it is not an a butter and 300 feet away is Property Owners so are we talking Property Owners or a

040Butters the official language is a Butters and some guy that's uh recently a couple months ago is like you and you know truly Define the word a butter the entire Commonwealth of Massachusetts is misusing the term a butter based on the actual definition but that's what the state uses the word of butter so that means if we say 300 feet by Butters anyone that has property within 300 feet that's what that means the true definition is what you're saying but like I said the whole Commonwealth's got it wrong it's the radius really yes and I've I've never seen 300 feet I've seen 200 feet I've never seen 300 feet 300 feet is is the requirement and has always been the requirement for in in here in Massachusetts okay yes has has this matter been discussed

041in public forums or hearings or has the zoning board of appeals discussed or have we discussed it Z boards has discussed it the issue came up before them and have they made a recommendation or it feels like a fairly significant matter since there's a fair amount of site plan reviews I would assume is a significant change you're very observant this is significant I've been here 18 years we never required a butter notification or legalized fory review um what it does is put a burden on staff yeah it just it feels like this might require some discussion and the owner because they have to pay for the two legal ads and they have to pay for the butter notification I can see the legal ads I can see the legal ads being a requirement because that

042covers everybody and you know and um but I don't think that we should have to send notifications to all the property owners within 300 fet I think that's honorous and capricious and just you know I don't think I could see the legal notices okay so you concur with the legal notices but not butter notification I think that's excessive that's a compromise so were you GNA say something it just it feels like we're just kind of making kind of random decision here you know because I I wouldn't be comfortable making this decision to require it now given how little discussion there's been and how much it impact you know so like to think it through more so and then well should we do a half decision well we really haven't really thought it through yet so

043I'm just wondering if we should just actually give this some there been a lot of discussion about site plan review we've been talking about it at almost every meeting that comes up all right I'm sorry just not privy to it so I I didn't know if you had talked about these notifications and whether or not to do them or not you know yes this this this topic goes back to one of our first meetings the there's a group of individuals that brings it up at every meeting site plan review they have a list of requirements I think and this is part of their stuff so we've we've heard this I've heard this for at least four months I see I think we're yeah it's been brought up we haven't had a chance to talk about

044it because we're more constrained than the people that comment at the meeting meetings right so this is the first time I think that it's officially been on an agenda of a meeting that we've been able to conduct and so okay the suggestion I think we're kind of stress testing it to some degree it wasn't there before it's not related to adus but because it's been discussed in parallel with adus we thought let's just have a discussion about it we have also talked separately about taking a bigger picture look at site plan review special permit buy right just having a clear understanding of the lines are what the purpose of each designation is and take a more holistic approach to what our role is with respect to those things so I think that to me if

045it's site plan review is a byright use that just needs to be designed in a careful way and needs a little bit of oversight on the design it's not a change of use it's not it's it's not a special permit or it would have been designated as such on the use table so it isn't the business of all people within 300 feet to dictate what you're going to do on your property right it's it's a burden to to issue the notifications to do the legal things I mean that that belongs in the special permit category not the special per and it's also and I've seen this in other communities it's a violation of privacy I've heard of people who in other communities you have to file your um in there's one place you have to

046file your building plans like your permit application building permit application made public so people within 300 ft who didn't even know your name now see that you're doing something that might be kind of personal in your house they have a a floor plan of your house they know where all your rooms are and you get accosted at the grocery store now for doing something so it just it like politicized is something that you're allowed to do on your private property by right it just isn't the business of the the public if I just want to say that it's cost and time because you have to file several weeks before the hearing date you got to publish you got to notify and for a lot of people who are just trying to afford to stay in

047their houses which is again the whole point of this Adu and you know add on that that little apartment for whoever so they can afford to pay their taxes this just adds so much cost and and they're already allowed to do it by right and delays and delays but we're not yeah this is all brought out from public comments so this is this the only reason this is in here is there was such a public comment multiple times that it was stuck in I'm all for not having it at all I don't if I think of a site plan is not required it's not required but I be to make a compromise with the people who continually bring it up and going with the legal notices so I was just trying to make a reach

048a compromised position here that I thought might appease the constituency that brought this up and continues to bring it up yes Mr chairman I just want to that's great Point uh Victor because it's constituents that brought this up not the department of planning or the planning board yeah our would be against that if I if it was my vote um yeah I I prefer just to take the action needed on adus and leave this for another time because it just doesn't feel like it's a decision that we want to make now and it's not really relevant to everything else and I'm not even sure what the right answer is but it does if I think you're the point you're making Jeff about this is really different than a special permit is it feels very much

049on point that you know it's every doesn't get to look at this stuff it's not everybody's you know I'm having an AR architect to work on my house the I don't get to the whole neighborhood doesn't get to opine right well the neighborhood has already established what the zoning is they've already established what's by right if you're within that then they've already endorsed what you're doing exactly correct correct I would add the building code has all sorts of requirements like if you get too close to The Neighbor Next Door well now you've got to rate your walls and that's going to add to the cost so some of you might say well let's move it in a little little bit let's pull it away from the property line there are other kind of um safety

050measures or things in place through the building code that are going to limit and encourage you know a good solution yeah if my point if you do want to push the envelope and exceed zoning limits that's what special permits are for right but I I have one thing I'd like to bring up that I know has been a an economic hurdle for people trying to do s something like this in Greenfield if you have another dwelling that's detached you have to have a separate sewer M connection you can't tie into the existing you've got to have a whole new other connection into the street which is very costly and very a lot of times complicated because you're having to tear up the driveways or whatever it would be great if Greenfield could figure out a

051way to allow exceptions where it's feasible to just tack in on the back instead of having that extra connection but that's something for D but I know Public Works top because we're trying to encourage people to build these units to solve our housing crisis but that is a big hurdle for people sorry I talked also I talked to Jeff earlier and there is something in the new regulations that say and the DPW now has to revise its policy they did require a separate sewer connection for detach data use the new law says you cannot require a separate connection if ility if it's a ad it's a protected use ad so that is dealt with a okay thank you I miss I I didn't see that so if I hear the board I'm going to cross

052this proposed amendment off I'm going to include this as a whole package I'll retitle it to say the same thing requirements under the affordable homes act signed by the governor and that language will be here so that it's clear this is all related to one topic you say what what's all one topic we're not we're not rolling six we're not rolling 56 in with 61 right yes so there's two proposed there's two things happening Victor just to summarize real quick we got the Adu ordinance which we just finalized in the site plan review one thing in it relative to adus removing the requirement for site plan review that's it one sentence tricken yeah all one package for adus does that make sense yes yeah okay and just for the record the discussed notification idea it's

053not something we're removing from the code or suggesting be removed from the code it was never in the code it was never in the code I'm removing it from this what we're going what the board's going to vote I think next to initiate the zoning it just shouldn't be understood that we changed the notification rules we took no action on the notification rules they weren't it wasn't like that to begin with and it will remain not like that for the time being I agree we could okay just clarifying for audience is there a motion from the board move goad yeah go ahead I move that we move forward with a positive recommendation on the changes to our zoning law for the accessory dwelling units as we've amended it to comply with the new guidelines by

054the state of Massachusetts and do you want to include that you would forward that to the city council to initiate the zoning amendment process yes we forward that to the city council to initiate the public meeting or discussion whatever yes and this is for 256 and 261 y 56 and and 261 no we just had a discussion on 61 we couldn't come to agreement Victor there's one change in the site plan the one change I think where we just where you took out the Adu took out plan requirement for but that's a change to 61 which we're making that's correct I'll agree with that okay Jeff do you want a second you want someone else second B3 was that a change also any residential use of three or more units as opposed to two or

055more it's only other one that only strike through I see other oh yes yes yes that's just updating to reflect the way the adus yes yes work also there are two strik through than thank you very must point that okay but it's all relative to the 8 right second need disc or discussion all in favor I I in favor business do excellent okay thank you so the last thing we have to do and you guys can get used to these the approval not required for meetings are always this short it can be this one's pretty straightforward yeah no it's just because there's it's straightforward matters in front of us this time but kid we'll give you a longer one next time yeah so last item under action items approval not required plan endorsement for Lots

056at 169 old Albany Road cessor tax map R39 Lots one and two submitted by first gen construction just for the record we the only thing we can do on these is just make sure that nothing looks out of order but otherwise Eric will tell us if it passes all the checks and and then we we approve it we can't we can't be against it you have we have to approve it so just uh if I could give a quick summary of anr for the new board members so an anr it stands for approval not required and it means approve not required so you don't need subdivision approval to do certain things break up property this is the only state in the Union that does that and it's not a good thing it is a Massachusetts

057thing and it's currently still law that approval is not required because theoretically there's two criteria that needs to be met for an a &r plan in Massachusetts you must meet the frontage requirement in The District in which you're located you know the road Frontage you have a certain Road Frontage and you have to have practical access you must be able to get over that road Frontage to your lap it can't be a clipped or Wetland or something something preventing you from getting into the law if it meets those two criteria board has no choice but to endorse the plan so there's not much leeway for planning boards even though the anr handbook is a thick um so this plan here i' got it here in the addition the attacks map currently so you can see

058exactly what's happening this lck is far question that is this part here this lot already exists and that's this lot and this is one LP right now as you can see right one lot it goes into shelburn there's this Top Line right here old Aly Road and the address is 169 old alurn old Greenfield you know their driveway comes off of shelburn into this so what they want to do is you can see right now it's one big lot they want to break this lot off from proper and and the frontage is still way over 200 feet on this road even though it's not in the green field so is not being impacted at all so it meets the frontage requirements and practical access so so what they're doing is they're taking a lot that

059says 13.55 that was originally those three lots and breaking it into a lot of eight a lot of 13 and a lot of seven a lot of Seven Acres already exists that exists it's the other two that we're talking so they're creating one lot additionally off this one overall larger parcel okay so they're taking a lot which is considerably the one that's 13 was originally 21 and they want to make it now a 13 and8 correct okay yep I did not have a chance to go and look at this how's the topography here can you reasonably access yeah if there's a house there and they got a does the new Frontage for the lot that's 8 Acres on Albany Road meet the requirements because it's just that little strip between that lot in the corner

060and the existing 13 acre lot so that's okay too that Frontage there is is fine yeah I mean right now the frontage is way over 200 fet not as small as it looks it's way longer than it looks so it's like 400 feet or more they have more than enough Frontage oh it's 200 yeah 217 feet on all road so this is 39444 for this Frontage but that but this is the lock that matters isn't it just this one no it's both you know if you're breaking it into two both have to still front right yep right okay all right I'm good with it that's quick explanation of anr yeah so the other thing we do with these is so we pretend like we're going to you know beat it up and comment on it

061just to understand it at least because in front of us what helps us understand zoning so yeah for sure um and then we vote to approve it and then I think is this the kind of thing where we vote to let the chair sign on behalf of everyone else too uh or the vice chair in these case v on you to sign you could sign it right then and there is the property owner here no typically we don't have the property owner show up for anr plans okay so if we did a site plan view or say approval we'd all have to sign it no sometimes they just show up anyway I didn't know if they were listening in on the audience if that was Stephanie or some else I'll make a motion go ahead

062Victor I make a motion that we approve the anr plan endorsement for Lots 169 all Aly all old Albany Road and that we empower the vice chair to sign on behalf of the board second any discussion I'll second okay all in favor I I I that was a a double motion to approve it and also so in this case I'll be the one who signs on behalf of the board so you guys don't have to do that so you just tell me when I should show up to do that right now oh or now that's why I figured you could do it right now and save you from trouble we sometimes not been able to do that virtual meetings we can't but uh inperson meetings we we can so A1 two copies I'll give you

063a pen thanks it says George going to cross him out well you can sign the okay can you just cross you need to Let's cross all it's doing is spelling out the name of the yeah 25 years in Jamaica plan 16 it's a long time in e mass and I finally got out a lot less while we're doing that can I give a small board report or a staff report yes let's move on to board and staff reports if anyone has any yeah I had been interesting I I went to the I went to the EDC meeting last night was last night night before virtually and I heard an interesting comment they were talking about the uh property we approved a while ago with the two storefronts and the old Jewelers with the apartments above

064and they had the same concern regarding the opaque window is and one of the guys there mentioned that we currently have a Clinic on Main Street which I'll have to go look at that has basically a a h shadow box front about three feet of space behind the window with the black wall behind it which is essentially a place for display you know like artwork or or landscaping or whatever and um I thought that was a really clever idea so I called the architect uh on that particular particular property and asked him if he had considered that or had addressed that perent perhaps with the owners um he said he hasn't and he the one actually told me about the other one down the street but he also mentioned a property called cat cattle pan

065katelan downtown I can't I may have it pronounced wrong and he kind of liked the artwork that was done on the window so I guess I'm just trying to report to the board is that um the architect is considering other options more attractive and more appealing to Street traffic than any sort of just an opaque window and I thought that was a positive move and I thought if we could get them to really go with the shadow box that could be really interesting that perhaps we could approach the Historical Society to furnish you know enlarged photos of yesty year and things like that to to put in these sorts of uh boxes for things to look at so I just want let the down the board know that I had heard that comment and that

066I approached the architect and that the architect was considering other options thank you Victor Victor is is um is the ground floor still considered is there a cannabis kind of application and that yeah they have that that application is going to be put forward they're going to try and get approved for the Cannabis uh retailer there so yes that is still uh one of the options on that ground floor space is that an option or is that what's going to happen well you know one of the things they're going to do on one side one one un is going to be that and I don't they didn't mention what the other one was but they were going to move forward with the cannabis dispensary on on that property okay disre information th they did receive

067zoning board of appeals approval for a marijuana Spenser there retail operation they did not move forward with that particular approval and went through S plan review for you've approved the planning board I mean and but they are thinking coming back possibly to do the marijuana R location and and the reason I brought that up is because I looked at the we we asked at our meeting for them to put some windows on Main Street and I see that we got the revised uh details showing the windows yes we got a revised plan showing um clear windows and the nonopaque and as well as the new windows okay just I was signing all those form so Victor you're saying they under if they were doing a dispensary they would keep the Clear Window but put something

068well they're thinking of options other than an opaque window so it may not be a clear window maybe well it may be a fritted window or it may be an art glassed window like I said they mention a property down the street and I know the name I think it's c a t a p n Kettle plan or something he he mentioned that property and like I said he also mentioned a clinic apparently there's a medical clinic in existence already that has the shadow box effect but unfortunately that's not being used that I walk by that building all the time anytime I go in downtown I walk by that building and I actually find it very offensive personally because I think a vibrant downtown has activity at the street level you see in you know

069there's a sense of life in there and you feel like you're part of that either people on the inside looking out and seeing you engaging or vice versa and the Medical Clinic on Main Street I really do not like that solution that they did I know I know where what they were trying to do but I just feel like it's not really good for a vibrant downtown and an active livable Street I I don't I don't disagree with that I think just a frosted window would be fine you know you can see movement but unfortunately the Massachusetts law doesn't allow you to see into the into the dispensary so you have to somehow have it why are we putting a dispensary on Main Street then taking up valuable storefront Street Frontage that should be something

070else that really reinforces and supports our downtown an active downtown that's populated by people and not like this hidden shadowy thing that you have to go into and hide I mean we shouldn't even be putting that on on our main streets honestly I think see you see it down by the across from the transit center that it used to be a dance studio in there and they had these nice Windows showing the Tut and the leotards and then people dancing and now it's all boarded up and it's it's really hard I walk by these things because I take the bus all the time and it's really not nice it's not comfortable I don't I I just feel like it's not making our downtown nice and attractive that's a whole another discussion because it's a permitted

071use in our downtown and unless our and correct me if I'm wrong Eric unless we change some kind of zoning law that says you know marijuana dispensaries are not a permitted use in downtown they're going to be there no it can be in downtown it shouldn't be on our main commercial strip the access should be to the back there could be some other use in the front that's all I'm saying yes we would have to amend the regul to allow that right now they're just allowed outright in the CC District yeah it's it's an urban design issue but it really to me it really I mean it's to me it's it's blight are there other uses are there other uses that require kind of this opaque glass or is that the only one where the

072where law requires it well it must be only one I'm aware of is marijuana establishments must be opaque you cannot see in other you cannot see in or you cannot see clearly what's inside so again if it's like a a fritted frosted glass where you I don't know if that would meet the new the the law under the marijuana we'd have to check that out but probably not it probably has to be completely opaque with zero opportunity to look in so some history on that one when we when we approved the site plan we did so on the condition that there be clear glass on the ground floor yeah and the comment was made well at one point they wanted to put a dispensary in there and they don't allow clear glass and my response

073was well it needs to have clear glass so if you can't reconcile the rule with the use look somewhere else yeah so I don't know maybe maybe now it's not going to come to us and they've changed they've worked around that they obviously they go for approval to get that changed but is that a that's a power that the board has to require clear glass and that that can therefore limit yes the board can do that and the board did that but if this applicant goes before the zoning Board of appeals with a special permit application for a marijuana a retail establishment then the clear glass goes away if the board approves it because they're they Trump yes different different special permits go to different boards and that's one that goes to zoning like we

074would get it's all spelled out like which which is the granting Authority would be great if we had design guidelines for our main streets in our downtown yes and also I think appropo the site plan review conversation U if we had more authority to rule on Urban Design matters because at the moment we really can only rule on traffic circulation environmental things you know engineering type things and I don't think that's true I don't think that's true Jee I've read in a thing somewhere which one was I read one of these papers where it said that we could locations of buildings was one of the things that we had the right to do under site plan review so we could comment on the locations of buildings on a s plan but going back to your

075thing the other day when we had that you were talking about how that kind of Alleyway was actually become a street and we thought the properties would look better being pushed to that side as opposed to Railroad side as I read it we could have said that's what we want it's possible yeah I mean it's somewhat ambiguous and that so that's a a course control of you know where so we could Justified that like I think we Justified the clear glass on the basis of Public Safety we can control lighting and and landscaping for similar reasons but we could add more oversight for ourselves which we've discussed that'll be the bigger conversation we alluded to before so that we can weigh in more precisely on on Urban Design issues in a really sensitive environment Like

076a downtown where it's really easy to screw it up right well we did require what's what's the address where the Wilson's building we did allow housing on the ground floor but we said it had to be towards the back so I mean we could say the same thing a dispensary does not belong on on a downtown Main Street you can do it push it to the back have it have an entrance go into the back and in the front have two little storefronts some shops or even even you know some kind of public art thing on a rotational basis but to have um a I'm right there with you it's BL we're there with you believe me we're there with you we have no way to stop so so what as a concerned citizen what

077would I have to do to change that I mean like the downtown's getting destroyed by these dispensaries did get appr ridiculous did that get approved with the is that what Victor was saying um I'm not sure what Victor just said Victor did that design get approved to the opaque glass what what we got approved what I heard was was about the uh opaque glass and was brought up again at the EDC meeting but that may have been just information they were getting later in other words they may have seen our comments it was not it was not a discussion about that Clinic open that dispensary opening there was no mention that had gone forward and they were doing because when I spoke with the architect today they haven't gone forward with that okay no there's

078no there's no submission of any application for uh right marijuana retail at that location there is it just sounded like someone at the EDC had just seen that drawing and had seen that opaque class and was commenting on it but yes why would somebody pay for Prime real estate to just be you know they don't need to pay for that and pay for all that clouded glass or whatever they should just go back back alley somewhere I don't know it's like Northampton and other cities right down town all the retail some of them have have better EGS and more off to the size but think it's part I think it's part of this board to come up with those recommendations board want to board a recommendation to the city council that there being no you

079know streets side dispensaries on Main Street and we want to make that recommendation that the zoning law be changed to reflect that we do that right that's what we do yeah the issue to me is definely do that is the um you know the state requirement that you know these basically aren't commercial establishments that are you know in normal commercial District where you see inside and they're making them weird and dark and the cuz you know I don't I'm not interested in saying well we just don't want marijuana establish of Main Street the problem really is the design issue that that comes with them and they just create these sort of black holes on Main Street you know we all grew up with drugstores we're we're still alive we we were not all you know

080I mean there was all sorts of stuffs in those windows liquor stores liquor stores exactly I mean this is oh my gosh but still I mean in defense of our downtown Prime real estate commercial we're trying to develop this let's you know whatever we have to do I mean if we have to change the zoning or something but I don't mind taking this on but I really um this really breaks my heart that's why we that's why we voted down the by ride clinics we didn't want clinics all over downtown so we we we voted that down we said we it should not be by right we G try and put a medical clinic on our Main Street downtown it needs a special permit well there's nothing wrong with having a clinic downtown I mean

081there are many around the world that do it but the street front is is eye level ground floor Street Front is a certain type of activity and a certain articulation of that facade that creates a downtown or destroys a downtown and and we want the former we want to have a lively downtown not something that's destroyed by the articulation of that ground floor whatever you do above and be behind is a different thing but it's that ground floor Street eye level activity when you I when you say that I think of Boston City Hall you know what that looks like that would they just eliminated that ground floor and con street it's just nothing is there I it's almost the most EX stream version of just obliterating the ground and and as it is it's

082just a Barren always will be it's way to deal that one of the good ways to deal with it is design review that was mentioned that's a good way to deal with the issues that you're discussing and we've talked about design review since I've been here actually and that would be the adding design review to the site plan process or what would that be it would be your mic You' have design review guidelines that have to be followed by anybody coming so going to develop a site part of that is following our design guidelines it says it must be laid out this way I mean maybe we talk to Economic Development uh Department of Economic Development I mean there I think we should really make this part of uh this should happen in Greenfield however

083it happens and it doesn't have to be a separate design review board it could just be guidelines exact like North is a separate AR pial review board but we wouldn't have to have that we just have guidelines that need to be follow and most design review boards they they just make recommendations to the planning board they don't they oversee and they make a recommendation but they can be very effective I sat on the design review board in Amis for five years and we got a lot done the more quantifiable measurable you can make the rules the less I mean ideally it's something that it can be staff reviewed with confidence and it's not ambiguous and it is designed engineered to give us exactly what you're talking about and if a builder developer tenant knows what

084the rules are going in they're they're not going to complain about it yeah and it's to their it's to their advantage if they want a successful project it's in their interest to do it right I think I personally anyway would also make sure that the rules that we impose are worthwhile right some places will'll add a bunch of rules especially for residential that just make it more expensive to build so that it can be more but we're smart enough to avoid those things and just do the things that have that impact that we're looking for no the whole I mean design review boards they all want to see the business being successful and good design is win-win for everybody that's the bottom line so for businesses and the public yep agreed so that that'll show

085up on our agenda at some point and we'll figure that out Eric we can strategize on yes it should be something that we need to do that in a way that's organized and sometimes things come through in a peac meal way and all of a sudden they're in the process and now we're voting on this one it should be thought of it should have been been thought of holistically but now it's like parsed up into these oneoff rules so at least for this which is fully within our control we should do it in a thought way I I think we could we could do it okay agenda item for our next meeting or so I mean we should just put it on the calendar so we have the discussion and get there next meeting agenda

086is full and it's going to take more than one meeting yeah but we should at least all start thinking about it yeah and I don't know maybe I can reach out to different people and see what would be the best way to try and Implement something like that as part of the yeah there's lots of great models develop guidelines but it's it would be a win-win for Greenfield honestly and everybody would be clear and land owners would be more than happy to see their their spaces rented or their place is successful that you know their tenant staying Etc so maybe we could have a preliminary discussion at the next opportunity anyway to kind of make a game plan okay great there also I got I've got one other bit I can bring in from the

087EDC there was also a interesting discussion about um current landlords who have vacant spaces who are maintaining the space is vacant they're now they have no incentive to go ahead and fill them so there's some interesting discussion about vacancy a vacancy fine and uh so apparently that I didn't even know it was a issue downtown that there was property owned that their landlord is intentionally leaving vacant it's right off there ways to fight that too that was your discussion they were talking about like a a vacancy law for every linear foot of Frontage on the building you were going to get fined and x amount of dollars and that was going to continue and it was funny one of the audience people came back I think it was our um Business Development lady said they've

088got Deep Pockets they wouldn't care and I'm like wow I I just couldn't hear what I couldn't believe what I was hearing uh the only thing I broke thought came to my mind I think the Town open own the bank on Bank Street and wouldn't we get fined as well good question yeah that's a touchy one but there there are tools you just need the political will to impose them we can at least collect some money from some absentee landlords for a while I rather find carrots instead of sticks yeah there's those two can it svise them to put something in there Pittsfield is's a great example right in western Mass Pittsfield you know has been struggling economically but 2005 I was I was involved with an estat there and the downtown was really just

089dead nobody could rent anything but they gave all the storefronts to artists and artists would do these pop-up installations they'd get it for a month for free and they would do these great whatever they wanted sculptural painting whatever they would take over that and one big window each artist would have one and it became a real big thing and people would come to look at it and they'd be they would be on rotation and it was a great way to bring people downtown and activate those Street fronts that just empty boarded up and dead yeah you have to and so like we could be doing that here I think in that situation the either the business improvement district or the city took a Master Lease out on the thing the reason the landlord wouldn't want

090to do it is what artist has liability insurance and but if if you can cover those bases then the landlord gets rent revenue and and can be flexible about who's who's in there yeah yeah we're shutting down all right no more board and staff reports next meeting date is um March 6 right Eric it's March 6 which is hearing that's a joint hearing with the EDC to discuss the zoning ordinances and also that other one is that right the one that we weren't was not on our agenda but that is out in the public at this point there the third proposed zoning Amendment that's in our packet it was not on our agenda is going to be on the table then too okay yeah it's actually three separate ones being by councelor Garrett no oh

091Michael M how pronounce that was in the packet that was sent to us last page very last page three proposed amendments that he's moved board that will be part of the joint public hearing on March 6 mro tor toar Mastro Mastro too increasing the height Lim these are so these so these have some history too this another attempt at a few that weren't passed because they just needed some more consideration after we adjourn we still need I moved to a Jour second up oh favor I I thank you Victor I feel better thank you [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.