CorpusRecord 195748

School Committee 2.6.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / HWCAM Educational Access Channel
Date
2025-02-07
Location
Essex County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,219 words · about 79 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e you e e e okay um good evening uh I'd like to uh call to order the uh public hearing this is public hearing number two for the Hamilton one Regional School District uh FY 26 budget um and uh Eric I just so is there anyone on Zoom besides Julia yeah there's a few people in the waiting room okay so I just want to make sure they can they're all good like they can hear or whatever we know that because I want to if they have a question that or yeah I just sent them a message that we're going into budget hearing okay all right Vinnie ready when you are you can it should switch over now yep for okay thank you all for joining us tonight and coming out during uh tonight's weather

002event we are here to uh present to you the superintendent's final FY 26 budget recommendation uh for the public hearing number two of the FY 26 budget process uh just so everyone knows uh in the full meeting later on tonight uh the school committee will vote on the budget so for the second presentation not going to go through the entirety of the presentation I'm really just going to advance to the motion slide and then uh start any discussions or any final comments uh unlike the last public hearing public hearing number one I presented the public hearing and then uh in the full uh school committee meeting I updated those numbers that's not the case this time the exact numbers in this public hearing are what we are going to vote on for the final budget

003um so for those who might be tuning in for the first time or haven't seen a lot of the budget presentations I'm just going to go over a list of things that we look at when we go to build our budget uh without a doubt the biggest thing is our collective bargaining agreements uh these are agreements uh and contracts that we've uh come to agreements with our five unions um Within These Collective bargain agreements we find our cost of living adjustments uh otherwise known as a cola adjustment in addition uh it signifies uh it stipulates any step increases uh so if a individual is in one of these unions uh at the end of a school year they might be eligible for a step increase as well as a cola adjustment uh so both those

004things are find are found within our collective bargaining agreements uh and for certain unions they also have the ability for any column or Lane changes uh this is if an individual uh goes back to school or takes inservice credits they can move uh horizontally along the salary schedule uh within those Collective baring agreements uh in addition to these documents uh big thing we look at is retirements uh at this point of time in the last few years we've seen an uptick in the number of retirements I think it has to do with the Baby Boomers coming to that retirement age V can I just interrupt you for one second I just are looks like people are you trying to see the screen and you can't see it I can we can are you sure I

005just want to make sure you can see that the because we all have it electronically too so yeah so yeah are you guys all good good okay um so the next thing we might look at is retirements uh historically when an individual retires they uh more seasoned and deeper within the salary schedule uh making uh more of a salary when there's a retirement we usually uh bring in an individual who's uh younger less seasoned and isn't as deep in the salary schedule and we realize uh savings through these retirements uh in the same note we also realize savings from staff turnover uh so when building the FY 26 budget we are uh six months ahead of when the actual fiscal year starts uh and eight months of ahead of when the school year starts so

006there might be an individual uh or a teacher who's employed right now uh making say uh $60,000 a year uh we incorporate that individual into our FY 26 budget uh but for whatever reason when the school year starts that individual is no longer with us whether they left on their own accord or whether they were not renewed um there's staff turnover and the individual that we might bring in uh now might be making say $50,000 so we would realize a $10,000 savings from staff turnover um this is one big area that we see savings or changes to the budget from one year to the next uh the next big ticket item is our health insurance enrollment changes or any premium rate increases uh health insurance I believe represents about a $3 million line item within

007our budget um and historically health insurance companies year-over-year uh apply an increase to their premium rates uh so an a 5% increase on our premium rate could be upwards of a $150,000 increase uh to our health insurance overall uh so depending on what that premium rate increase it could have a big effect on our budget from one year to the next uh same thing with Transportation contracts uh Transportation costs uh over the past few years have increased dramatically uh this is the result of increased gas prices as well as um increased costs uh increased salaries for the bus drivers for FY 26 we do not have a contract we have a three-year contract and the last year is fy2 uh so we will be going out to bid for FY 26 but transportation in itself

008uh can have changes within the budget uh this is both for General Ed transportation and special ed out of District transportation uh next thing is our AO District tuitions uh for our a District tuitions uh it's regulated by OSD the operational services division uh they set a rate increase uh every year for FY 26 I believe the increase is 3.6% uh a district tuitions again is a line item about $4 million so any change in um that rate again can have a drastic uh effect on our budget uh next is any requests from our building principles or Department department heads uh every year and throughout the year we're always meeting with our principles and the department heads and listening to um ideas they might have or kind of innovative projects that they want to um

009initiate in the classroom so we go over and try to help find funding for any of those requests if we have room in the budget uh next is the condition of our buildings and grounds uh if you look around most of our buildings were built sometime in the 50s so they are approaching a 70 years old uh so there is uh failing equipment most of our equipment is past its useful life uh so we always meet with Curtis our director of Maintenance uh facilities and operations and go through any requests that he might have uh to keep the buildings operation uh next is the district's enrollment shift our regional agreement uh dictates how we break out our budget uh to one Community to the other uh it's based on a rolling threeyear average of the

010make up of the population meaning how many students reside in Hamilton how many students reside in wedam whatever that percentage is is how we disperse uh the cost of the budget to the communities so any changes in the enrollment shift is something we look at uh while building the budget and last is just the general state of the communities uh what's going on in Hamilton what's going on in Wenham are they trying to put forth a major project during the annual town meeting and what is the among the community uh to support the School District budget we are always keeping this in the back of our minds when we go to build the budget so when we go to build it where do we start we always start with our enrollment shift uh presented here

011is just residents only there are also um pre prek tuition in students as well as school choice in students this does not represent our sto total student population uh but rather just the population that makes up um how the budget is split between the two communities so what happened in October 1st of 2024 uh we saw an increase of 13 students overall but if you look kind of at the bottom corner of the screen here you can see that all 13 students were from Venom uh Hamilton did not see an increase in their student population whatsoever year-over year uh so what this translates into Isom now makes up a bigger portion of the population which then means they make up a bigger portion of our budget uh for FY 26 but what was the result

012of that change uh so right now currently for fy2 uh we have a split of 66.2 n% Hamilton and 33.712183 7% uh going towards venam and away from Hamilton so if you apply this new percentage It ultimately means $130,000 is moving away from Hamilton and going towards wenam that means right out of the gate if we completely rolled our budget over from one year to the next took a complete snapshot didn't change anything in our revenues or our expenditures and only applied the enrollment shift it would result in in increase to Venom's budget of 1% and a decrease to Hamilton of a half a percent this is important because it's the first step in building the budget we really want to know what effect the enrollment shift has on the community before we start building

013expenses because as you can see here right out of the gate vom is going up 1% so if you think of prop two and a half we already ate up half of that increase just in the enrollment shift without anything else occurring um just for a point of reference if you look at our prior year budget the enrollment shift was about $24,000 uh so we're looking at nearly four or five times the amount it was last year uh so this is just the same uh information presented in a different format again step one in the process is the enrollment shift if we stopped there again it would be no increase for the Regional School District overall uh but an increase Toom of 1% and a decrease to Hamilton of a half per. the next thing

014we look at is our revenues because we really want to know if we have any Revenue growth or any Revenue shortfalls before we go and build our expenditures so we know what we're working with before we start building our expenditures for instance if we had a drastic change in our revenues going down we're going to approach our exp our expenses in a much different um format and really try to refra from changing anything however the opposite if we have a lot of Revenue growth uh we might try to think of different programs or different um things to initiate with this new uh Revenue funding source so what we have in front of you now is the changes in our offsets and revenues from fy2 to FY 26 uh this is all of our offsets and

015revenues except our assessments uh so all of this is all the funds we take in except for what Hamilton and qu uh covers so year ofe we are seeing an increase of 216,000 or roughly 2.3% uh to me this is really just okay it's not horrible and it's not great uh we really would like to see Revenue growth higher than two and a half perc uh it's just about right there so again uh to me it is just okay uh but one thing I do want to point out uh is our excess and efficiency the last um two or lines uh when you combine those two lines we are seeing a reduction in our revenues by about $210,000 and that's because excess and deficiency is such a wild card you really can't rely on it

016from one me to the next it is unpredictable uh there are too many moving Parts uh that could either increase or decrease your excess and deficiency so historically uh we try to move all of those uh to offsets and expenses that I will get you in a moment uh but when you look at all of our revenues again uh we have a $216,000 increase but when you remove our excess and deficiency it paints a much different picture uh we have strong Revenue growth of 43,000 or roughly 6.1% uh which looking at this if again we're moving end it's a much different picture uh it really shows that we're trying to do uh the best we can to increase our revenues year ofe so now layering layering in our enrollment shift and our changes to our

017um offsets and revenues that end result would be a decrease uh to the Regional School District's overall budget of a half percent uh and an increase to wenam of a half percent and a decrease to Hamilton of just about 1.1% um but we don't stop there the next step is our expenditures but this represents what would happen if we left everything the same and level funded our expenditures from one year to the next so the last step in the process is adding in any changes to our expenditures uh in front of you here is the summary by Desi category including all of our operating and our debt um based on Desi regulations a Regional School District must uh a Regional School District school committee must approve a budget uh broken down by Des category uh

018so this is that chart uh year ofe the FY 26 budget recommendation is an increase of 1.9 million or roughly 4.08% um so just quickly what does this mean for our final Town assessments we've now layered in our enrollment shift our changes to our revenues and now any changes to our expenditures the end result is an increase to Hamilton of 972 th000 under 4% uh and an increase to vom of 72,000 or roughly 5.7% uh for the Regional School District as a whole from FY 25 to FY 26 Our Town assessments combined are increasing by 1.7 million or roughly 4 and a half% this is that same chart prior but Broken Out by operating first debt for anyone who wants to see the difference between um the assessments based on operating in debt uh you

019can see again at the bottom it's that same increase year-over year of one 1.6 million or roughly 4.5% so now I'm going to go over um some difficulties that we faced during the budget process to to outline some of the difficulties that we had uh this is in no special order uh it really is just kind of how it falls within the budget process um the first thing one of the biggest not sorry not the biggest uh one of the difficulties we faced is the enrollment shift as we just talked about uh it caused an increase to wenom of 1% in that shift of $137,000 away from Hamilton and towards wam uh the next thing which is the biggest thing is our collective bargaining agreements uh for the for fy2 when we went to build

020the fy2 budget uh only one of our five contracts were settled uh that means we were estimating and assuming uh cost of living adjustments and step in Lane changes for fy2 we did not have that final data so when we built the fy2 budget we incorporated somewhere between three and 4% increase to salaries depending on um what bargaining unit you were in but when those Union contracts were settled and the fy2 actuals came in uh they were somewhere between 3 and 19% with an average overall just over 8% uh so this alone resulted in a 1.1 million increase to our annual budget because again we did not have that funding in fy2 uh for those salaries so those have to be incorporated into our FY 26 budget uh but we can't stop there because that

021only gets us to where 25 should have been then you have to apply all of our FY 26 contractual changes so all the FY 26 cost of living adjustments uh step Lane changes and anything else that uh came about in the new Union contract uh that FY 26 amount came out to another 1.3 million in increased salaries uh to the annual budget year of a year so combined when you take the the shortfall in fy2 and then the increase for FY 26 it means an increas of $2.4 million in salaries alone over the fy2 budget so if we left everything else the same the enrollment ship the same the our revenues were the same and all other expenditures were the same except for salaries it would have meant an increase to our overall annual budget

022of 5.4% increase to FY 26 uh because of those increases uh the next difficult decision revolv around our excess and defici deficiency usage uh so historically when you have excess and deficiency you really try to match those revenues with one-time Capital expenditures uh because end is considered a one-time Revenue source and is not reoccurring every year you really want to use that towards something that matches that something that's not going to reoccur every year salaries reoccur every single year um fixing a boiler or replacing Windows do not uh relatively speaking it should be another 20 years before you see an expense for that again um that's why you really try to use end for items like that uh but a difficult decision we had this year was in order to keep the budget um below

023certain thresholds we took the recommendation of the Capital Finance subcommittee and then the approval of the full committee and instead of using those one-time end funds towards one-time Capital expenditures we diverted a an additional $1.3 million of excess and efficiency towards that $2.1 million um I'm sorry towards our operating budget uh to lower the overall increase um that means in total for FY 26 uh the school district is contributing $2.1 million in end to offset our oper budget before this decision was made we already uh committed $773,000 to offset the assessment we added another 1.3 uh million to it for that combined 2.1 million uh now again for those who have listened to my presentations before this is something we're definitely going to have to deal with in FY 27 uh but we really don't

024know what the full impact of that is going to be until the next budget cycle uh there are a lot of moving parts to our budget we could have increased revenues in other areas that help close this $2.1 million gap uh we could end FY 25 with a surplus which would then go towards our end usage for FY 27 um so time will tell before we can truly realize what effect this will have on the budget process uh for next year but it is definitely going to have uh an impact and is definitely something we're going to have to deal with uh throughout the year and during the in the next budget cycle uh the next difficulty we faced revolved around a of District cost escalations uh now a district in total increased by 423,000

025year AE uh tuition's increased by approximately 181,000 and transportation by 242 um you can really see that transportation both on the General Ed side and on the special ed side really saw an uptick in the past year um next is our Essex County Retirement appropriation um ESS the appropriation continues to rise by double digigit percentages every single year for FY 26 uh we received an increase of 12.4% uh which translated into a $147,000 increase year of a year uh and this appropriation really is out of our hands we're told the number and we have to uh but double digit uh increases year-over-year uh make other uh put strain on other sides of our budget uh just to review some good things some accolades that we've uh incorporated into our FY 26 budget uh is that

026we've made a strong investment and a commitment to Student Success Through staff retention um so through those Union negotiations the school committee uh has made it a substantial investment of our employees of that $2.1 million uh we're hoping that this leads to a stronger candidacy pool uh and increases our staff retention ultimately leading to a Better Learning environment for our students uh the next item which I'm in particularly excited about is the investment in our stem program so the FY 26 budget does incorporate uh two new stem teachers at the elementary level uh these two teachers will be dispersed amongst the three elementary schools so it won't be a full uh 1.0 in each building it'll be more like a s at each of the three buildings uh Spread spread across um we're really excited

027about what Innovative programs uh and uh projects these stem teachers will come with and are excited to see what the next year brings uh for our stem program uh this investment across the three elementary schools is estimated to cost roughly 209,000 um next is the support for our Athletic program uh overall the FY 26 budget uh increases the district's contribution to the user fees for FY 25 the current year um the school committee matched the uh user fee offset by roughly 50% for FY 25 that has moved to 55% excuse me along with that increase in user fees we are an investment to maintain the new athletic complex uh so in total amongst the user fees and the additional investment to maintain the complex our athletic department overall is seeing an increase of $18,000 and

028represents a 16.14% increase uh for the athletic department over fy2 uh the next item revolves around our cyber security uh so with increased uh outside security breaches across the country and across the globe Our IT department uh has really stressed the importance of updating our security features um so the district is making a $55,000 investment to help uh increase our security posture uh next another item that I'm in particularly happy about is around our OPB this is our other post employment benefits uh this is the fifth year in a row that the district has met its uh commitment to increase our opep contribution by $50,000 per year uh the first year had an investment of $100,000 which five years later for FY 26 Meads a combined increase to opep of roughly $300,000 uh to me

029this really says that we're taking our OPB liability seriously and are really trying to fund uh these obligations I just want to thank the community in the school committee because over the past five years uh the district has has invested a large amount of money into our OPB I believe in FY 23 uh we used a lot of our excess and deficiency to help fund OPB uh so right now I believe our total OPB balance is upwards of $3 million which really if you look across uh to other Regional School Districts it really uh outpaces our our competition on the North Shore uh last but not least is the enhancement to our summer school program so the y 26 budget uh incorporates an additional $33,000 Investments which will make a profound impact on students uh

030summer school experience and help bring in additional staff uh to support the students needs uh so presented in front of you right now uh is a chart of all the major expense changes uh over or under $110,000 this is represented as a gross number before any um offsets and revenues and I am incorporating both the operating and the debt figures uh so you can see at the bottom corner hopefully it's not too small is that $1.9 million increase or roughly 4% uh next I've Incorporated a summary of all of our changes to Staffing uh right here you can see there is a lot of movement every year amongst buildings where we really try to uh keep the staff we have and redeploy them across the build across the district uh depending on what the needs

031are of the student population next year uh we really try to maintain our overall FTE or our overall Staffing level and you can see here from one year to the next we are trying to do that uh we've only increased or we're only requesting to increase Staffing uh by less than one person it's technically 0.88 um FTE uh this really can be attributed to that 1.0 additional special education ESP that was needed for a one toone um aid for a new student that moved into the district um so that concludes the overall presentation for the public hearing and I hope to see everyone at the annual town meeting on April 5th so I can take any questions or comments thank you Vinnie um so as a public hearing this is an opportunity for the public

032to ask questions or to make a comment um we'll start with in the room does anyone in the room have a question or a comment regarding the budget we are going to have an opportunity for Citizens comments during our general meeting if people have comments on something else but if anyone has a question or a comment specifically around the budget that Vinnie uh Leone just presented no um Mr Tracy is there anyone on Zoom that has a question or a comment regarding the budget I'm sending a message in there right now to the waiting room yeah we'll give them a moment anybody has a question in the waiting room just use to raise your hand feature and if that can you just also let them I don't know if they can hear me but just

033that they you know certainly if they have comments on something else they can talk about that yep just minutes send a message think we're good all right looks like no one on Zoom has a comment or question about the budget correct okay uh I'm just looking to the committee if everyone without objection I'll be moving towards closing the public hearing okay um thank you very much Vinnie for your work um at this point we will close the public hearing uh portion of the meeting um and uh maybe we'll just uh I don't know that we I think we can just move right into our meeting I um so the public hearing is closed um and before we get started on the regular meeting I'm just not quite sure who we have on Zoom for members

034I know we have Julia we have Julia Campbell okay all right okay so we have five members correct okay all everybody good Julia you good can you hear us yes okay can hear you okay um in that case um I will move on and I will call to order the meeting of the Hamilton one Regional school committee on Thursday February 6th 2025 at 7:04 p.m. and I will invite you to join us in the Pledge of Allegiance the United States of America to The Republic it stands na um I just want to remind everyone um that this meeting is um being recorded and live streamed on HW Camp um oh thank you Vinnie um so I see that there are some people in the room that I think probably want to offer a public comment

035um and I'm not sure whether there's anyone on Zoom but we'll um try to get to everyone um if uh you would like to offer a public comment I ask that when you do that you um provide your name and please spell your last name so that we can get it um correctly noted in the minutes um and I ask you to limit your comments to three minutes um if there's somebody in the room please go ahead and approach the podium um and maybe we need a little a little tweak of the podium there so that we can see you hold on let's make sure we can see you yeah we're just doing a little rearrange okay breaking anything there that's better all right hi I'm Bridget odonnell last name is o d o n

036n l l I live at 105 Main Street in Wenham I also am an employee of the district I work at winr elementary school and have worked there for 25 years I fully support the new elementary school project and urge the school committee to vote in favor of the new school so that it can be B brought to town meeting for decision I have worked at winthrip for the last 25 years and can confirm that we definitely need a new school every student and adult deserves to live excuse me not live learn and work in healthy classrooms and in a building that is safe students also deserve learning spaces that are suitable for optimal learning when elementary students need to receive small group or one-on-one instruction they could go in the new building to a

037breakout room right off their classroom and Le lose basically zero instructional time in the current situation they have to walk down the hall or like down around the building or maybe they have to go work on the stage in the cafeteria where there all there is is a curtain we've had literacy intervention happen up there and currently now we have speech and language happening up there because they tried to have three speech and language people in a tiny little room I mean hardly even a room like maybe enough for two desks and some children um I have also um been a part of this design project from the start um I was lucky enough and uh fortunate enough to be able to give suggestions and hear about it and get really excited um we also

038I've been to different forums that we've been to that that the town has held or Eric has held um and I don't know if people really understand the depth of need and our buildings um we have two or three adult bathrooms in our winrep winrep school um which can be kind of tough when you got to go like that fast um also um our cafeteria currently does not take into consideration the needs of children who get overstimulated um the new school design has taken that all into account in many different facets um actually every single decision that's been made about the new school has been thinking about how we know children learn best not like they did in 1950 but actually environments and situations where they will actually have the best learning for their brains

039and their bodies um and we also have a large problem with temperature control which also impacts learning when you're in a room when it's almost 80 degrees in the winter and we're opening Windows because it's so hot the kids faces get red or people feel sick that's not the best thing for our students or teachers or staff anybody that works there um so I do urge you to move forward with this vote and vote favorably to bring it to the people um at town meeting so that's it and I if I could I don't know if I'm allowed to Heidi civo who also works at winr couldn't make it tonight or make it on Zoom she's got something going on she just has a quick statement if I could read that um I'm going to

040ask that um we let the other people speak and then we'll see if we have okay thank you I want to make sure everyone gets an opportunity thank you hi I'm Katie O'Brien o r i n and I live at 114 Forest Street in Hamilton thank you I'm gonna just I'm gonna make sure you're that we have a timer would you be the our timer um I'm not great at the timing while I'm trying to so okay we'll let you know when you're getting close to your three minutes all right thank you um so I fully support the new elementary school project and I urge the school committee to do the same and vote to bring this to town meeting I was a student at the high school when the population was over 700 so

041this size of a school is not new to the district and it allows more opportunities for different groups of students to work together and collaborate in a more meaningful way than we're allowed to with the groups that we have across three different schools um as a teacher the design promotes small learning communities as well as appropriate learning spaces that I would be thrilled to be a part of moving forward thank you thank you hi uh I'm Linda mastriani I live at the mic a little closer 23 mle Street in Hamilton and I teach across all three elementary schools so I am in and out of BU Cutler and winrep every single week um as a taxpayer I urge the school committee to do the fiscally responsible thing and to vote in favor of the new

042school I want that msba money um I would rather have a brand new school that I am paying for as a taxpayer than to have three 70 or 75 year old schools that we're trying to hold together um as a teacher I'd like to thank the building committee for their work in planning for a new building that will be safe healthy and supportive of the educational needs of our students and as a grandparent I look forward to sending my two grandchildren to a new school in our district um where they will flourish um please allow the taxpayers to decide on this school at the Springtown meetings thank you thank you uh Mr Tracy do we have people on Zoom that would like to offer a public comment anyone on Zoom uh would like to offer

043a comment please use the raise your hand Fe okay oh well that's interesting know all right you can unmute yourself there we go somebody just fig there we okay go ahead Alicia thank you gosh it's been a while since I had to find that raised hand feature um my name is Alicia Anderson and I've been teaching in Hamilton Wenham for this is my 22nd year four of those years were at the winthrip school and the last 18 have been at Cutler and I'm uh just wanting to urge the school committee members to vote in favor of the new elementary school project so that it can be brought to the residents of Hamilton and Wenham to decide if the project moves forward um I have to acknowledge I'm not a taxpayer and either Hamilton or Wenham

044and I understand that those are the folks who will be shouldering the tax implications of this project um however the money being offered by the msba towards the project it it must be considered um it may not be there in the future which would leave the entire cost to the residents of the towns um should we choose to to pass on this project as it stands now uh our elementary builds are in tough shape um I think at the moment there's a dead animal Somewhere In My Room the odor is quite strong uh and we it just doesn't make fiscal sense to keep putting Band-Aids on our schools um to the detriment of students so again I urge the school committee members to vote in favor of moving this project forward to the towns for

045their consideration thank you thank you I unmuted is it I don't know hello can you hear me go ahead J go right go ahead yep okay hi I'm Sean Clark I was going to say I taught here for 20 years but I remember when we hired Alicia so I've been here longer than that um so uh I am also in support of new schools uh the new school build I know that I'm also I don't live in Hamilton whenham but um I have seen our schools go through a lot of repairs and um we have a lot of temperature controls and issues and um I feel like logistic wise with student supports and teacher supports and um building Community I feel like one school with a stronger community of Learners and teachers would benefit the

046town immensely thanks thank you thank you anyone else online would like to speak you can just unmute if you can't use the raise your hand feature looks like we're okay okay um so I know that there was someone in the room um it is we've made I'm going to look to the committee um whether we feel we feel like we have time whether we're willing to hear one more from the room if you're still interested in speaking sure yep hi I'm speaking for Heidi cciio c a cc i v i o who lives at 11 to excuse me 11 Hilltop Drive in wenam and she asked me to just say the following that she supports the building of a new elementary school and urge the school committee to vote in favor of the project thank

047you okay one more chance there on Zoom it looks like nobody else is on Zoom okay all right um at this point I will um close the citizens comments um portion and um know we have uh the zoom link will not close because we have a Committee Member on on Zoom um but I think in general it's uh we usually recommend to watch on HW cam um rather than on the zoom link um okay um next up uh is OD dear a review of the school committee protocols and our mission statement I didn't pass that out let's see who wants who who's excited to talk um all right I'll do I will do uh a portion of our committee protocols um as elected members of the Hamilton one Regional school committee we including the superintendent

048accept the high honor and trust that has been placed in us to ensure that the students of the district receive the best education possible to that end we hereby commit to the following in the conduct of our business business number nine all members will maintain the confidentiality of privileged information and will respect the open meeting law thank you uh next up am will read a portion of our mission statement the Hamilton wam Regional School District school committee's mission is to ensure our schools create graduates with a passion for lifelong learning together with the critical skills needed to maximize their potential the Hamilton wam Regional school committee will lead and inspire a district that is a source of civic pride and Municipal engagement to serve the community for generations to come thank you um next on

049our agenda is the consent agenda does anyone have any items that they would like to hold from the consent agenda Julia you're good she's good yep okay uh David uh I moov at the Hamilton one Regional school committee um vote to approve the consent agenda as presented in tonight's meeting agenda second second by Amy kumberg um we do need to do a roll call vote because we have a remote uh member uh Julia yes Trent yes uh Amy yes David yes uh d yes that is unanimous of the five members present and the motion passes five correct corre okay um next up um is uh the vote on the elementary school project Elementary School building Project funding um it the motion is is uh very formal and very long um do you want to read

050it first sure okay I don't have any more water I I moved at the Hamilton one Regional School District hereby appropriates the amount of 142 m266 34 for the purpose of paying costs for Designing constructing and equipping a new Cutler elementary school at 237 Asbury Street Hamilton Mass including the payment of all costs incidental or related there to the project which school fa uh which school facilities shall have an anticipated useful life as an educated educational facility for the instruction of school children of at least 50 years and for which the district may be eligible for a school construction Grant from the Massachusetts school building authority and SBA set am out to be expended at the direction of the Hamilton wam School building committee to meet this appropriation the district is authorized to borrow a

051set amount under and pursuant to chapter 71 section 16d of the general laws in the district agreement as amended in pursuant to any other uh enabling Authority the district acknowledges that the mba's grant program is a non on entitlement discretionary program based on need as determined by the msba and any project cost a district incurs in excess of the grant approved by and receive from the msba shall be the sole responsibility of the district provided further that any Grant the district may receive from the msba shall not exceed the lesser of uh 28% of eligible approved project costs as determined by the msba or to the total maximum Grant amount determined by the msba and that the amount of borrowing authorized pursuant to this vote shall be reduced by Any Grant amount set forth in

052the Project funding agreement that may be executed between the district and the msba further within seven days of the uh from the date which his vote is to be adopted the secretary be and by is instructed to notify the select Board of each of the member towns of the district as to the amount and general purpose of this debt herein authorized as required by sorry as required by the district agreement in by chapter 71 section 16d of the general laws do I have a second second second by Amy kumberg again um yeah yeah could you say that again um so I think um well I don't know Eric do you or or David I think someone should just clarify to the committee the what the actual mean I'm happy to do it but if you're

053happy to do it just sort of the meaning of what it is we're actually voting on here because that was long and complicated and it's actually quite simple what we're being asked the initial question was probably why 142 million dollar that's the total cost of the project um the total cost of the project is required by the msba to be voted upon even though they are committing approximately $50 million in reimbursement um they still make you vote for the entire cost of the project um the 51.2% is the mba's reimbursement amount plus some of the incentive points that we've received along the way for various leads like um Green Schools lead certification and U maintenance um consistency over over the time so really this allows the school committee to just say to the towns we

054are um authorizing this expenditure from the school committee level it's still if it passes here tonight you need five out of seven votes for it to move forward a super majority if it passes here tonight it moves forward to the both towns uh to be on the warrant also on this agenda are copy samples of the warrant articles as they would be presented with the Motions um for that project so essentially the town would receive a very similar lengthy motion uh for the warrant in warrant article and then also a ballot um the ballot language that is also required by the msba this statement and all the others is approved by the msba has been vetted by our attorneys and has Al uh been Ved by our bond Council who would ultimately be involved in

055the financing part if we got to that portion of the project that hope sure does anyone have any questions about what Eric just said um so I just I just to be the this it's a just like the budget later on this evening it this requires five um a super majority so requires five yes votes and the purpose of this is to move forward to ask the citizens of Hamilton and whenham whether or not this is or yes or no do they want this project okay and ultimately it would be four more votes so if the vote occurred in the affirmative tonight it would go to both Town meetings there would be a vote at each town meeting which would require two-thirds vote of the members the town meeting and if it passed at the

056town meeting in each Town it would also go to the ballot the following Thursday which it needs a majority vote because it's a um because it's an excess of prop two and a half be a Deb exclusion excuse me it be it would be a Deb exclusion so it needs a ballot vote sorry I believe that's a good question I believe at town meeting it's a simple it's 2third and then it's a simple majority at the ballot is that correct you are correct thank you um all right uh people have comments anyone want to offer anything um yes just some questions for Eric um so this is the these are the final numbers that we've been waiting on um so with these numbers then we will be able to some point in time between now

057and town meeting make everybody who is a resident know what their tax is going to be yes that's something that we've been talking about since I think November when are we going to do that so we got uh was it Thursday I think Thursday no wait today's Thursday sorry Tuesday we received the um the war the vom numbers so they gave us their numbers we're waiting on Hamilton to finalize theirs and as soon as we get those we'll start to push those out with the towns our OPM will work with the towns to get stuff on the website we'll have um calc on the website for people to go in and calculate their amount um wam actually did a nice job breaking it down by uh thousands so depending on how many you know if

058you're every under 100,000 is x% so it's it's a fairly simple calculation for people they made a nice chart if we can get uh Hamilton to match that it' be it'd be easier to present to the people to say this is this is how you can see exactly what it's going to cost you is there a reason that we're not sending it out to everybody like to every household this is what your household is yeah we could we could absolutely could I think I'd have to figure out how to do it for every single household like here's your value here's your value here's your value but I can certainly look into it I I think we can definitely look make the charts available for everybody but I just I think that the so much of

059what causes confusion in the town and what we do here is that not everybody is as involved as the people are here in the decisions that are made and that's where I think that you could put a chart up online and you might get 75% of people that don't know it's there because they other things are going on in the world and in their life right and so that's my concern is that we can be as transparent as we can possibly be and it can still be perceived as a lack of transparency um and I think the way around that is to you know just just radical transparency right we we've sent mailers out about this to everybody in the town already we could do the same thing in this regard y um so that

060it's it's ating people how much information they're getting on it which I think is important yeah I don't disagree I think just the complexity of it I'll have to figure out I don't I don't um can I say something I'd have to do it in two different ways go ahead Julia sorry yep Julia go ahead uh we could also potentially Trent like you're saying maybe work with the newspaper that goes out um I do I worry I mean I think it'd be very cost burdensome to send each individual taxpayer an individual mail of like this is what you individually will owe I don't know how much that will cost but um I think if we have the charts available online and then maybe offer them up to any kind of publication that would like to

061share them that goes out to all the households for free yeah I agree that making like a variable printing for every single household in the Two Towns might be expensive but I wonder if we could mail them to each person one General message and send them online and then maybe provide some sort of resource for people who don't have access to looking online I guess we could price out what varable printing would be for each household I think it's easy if we think about partnering with the town yeah because they do this four times a year they send everybody out like this is what your tax bill is this year I get it and every single time yeah I think we can do I think that's the way to do it have to just work

062with each of the towns to pull up I I totally get the idea that there's a short period of time and that the logistics are difficult and I will say I think that I just want to highlight that that's sort of what I was thinking what you just said about the the key is really partnering with the towns because it is a partnership determining that number and what is a joint responsibility that like when if this goes to town meeting that the point is that people have as much information as possible and it's a legitimate concern if a person felt like they didn't have enough information I I think that's a really valid point and I also think your point about it being a joint with the town is really important that especially where they're

063Two Towns the Two Towns might have different reasons for wanting to communicate in they might want to communicate differently that's possible um so you know David Frankle just joined the meeting online hi David can you hear us good evening yes I hear good your audio is not as good as Julia's um I'm sorry say that again that's because I'm on Zoom yeah the the audio is not quite Asar it's a bit echoey I think whatever miking Liv got there um is uh is leading to a more Hollow room sound makes a little tiny bit harder to understand I was having trouble hearing oh okay um is it tell me can you hear me or and not other people no I mean Eric Eric's booming voice comes through more more readily than than the others in

064terms of quality and the comprehensibility all right well please just let me know and I'll I'll be happy to repeat or have other people repeat if um if needed um so um just to get you up to speed David um David PLO read the motion which is we're under the Hamilton went home school Project funding David PLO read the motion the motion has been seconded and now we're having a discussion around um this motion um so that's where we are um do other people did other people have comments questions David no um Julia or David I think I could you just repeat that sorry sure um so the the sure I'm maybe I'll have maybe I'll have Eric say it but Bas but I'm trying to be loud I I'm not usually accused of being

065too quiet that's not been a big problem in my life um but um the motion before us is long and complicated but this is the language that is specifically needed for a school building project um but the gist of this is that if this were to be voted in the affirmative this evening then it would move the vote um to the town meetings and to the ballot to allow the people of Hamilton went them to vote on whether they would like to pursue this project and um the other thing which Trent just clarified um in a question is that these are in fact the final numbers that we have received um so the numbers listed here are the final numbers could you hear me yes thank you understand motion okay hang motion I think I

066think David pedo should read the motion again this time with this time perhaps with some interpretive dance or you know I also agree um David Frankle do you have a question or a comment only well you know we've had a little bit of back and forth by email today and just to dispose to the rest of the committee um I feel that my understanding is that this amount does not include sufficient to meet the ashray standard 241 and since we're building this building to last for the next 40 to 50 years um I think it's important to make it as pandemic proof as possible for public health reasons not just for the reasons of students and staff and uh so I'm not quite sure how to handle it turns out that for an extra $3

067to5 a square foot we could have had that in there I see no evidence that that was actually examined and um meaningfully discarded or included um Bas on just back and forth clearing Eric on what was done and why it was done I I I don't understand why it wasn't Incorporated it's it um it affects uh test scores it affects absenteeism it affects public health and uh it's you know like about a third of a percentage point of the total value of the project to Incorporated so um I don't know where you go with that um but I'm not personally I'm not willing to vote for something that that doesn't doesn't include it so maybe Eric you can clarify but it definitely doesn't include it wasn't that in the email today the email response was

068it's not part of um the state I'm actually looking up for reir the state requirement um you know so that everything that has been going in is actually meets all current state requirements excuse me um at the highest levels again it's you know lead lead silver certified um you know so we're we're at the top of um you know all the current requirements States so you know you're you're addressing something that you know could be in the future down the line and that we actually are um capable of upgrading to which again I think was in the response um you know even though it's not a requirement yet we do have the capabilities of of upgrading to the new requirements should it become mandated in the future um I'm concerned well I'm concerned that we're

069not at that level in in all of our schools now until 2028 and then after 2028 we still won't have them in the majority of of classrooms and if this project gets up um it only it only affects less than half of the world students in our school system so we we are lagging badly other schools but Boston public schools for example since 2020 has already gotten much closer to today although they they too are not yet at at uh 241 as 241 levels so um and I don't think it's just you know it's not just a school district decision it's because it's a public health issue because schools are such a great driver of of illness uh into the community um I think the boards of health will weigh in on this issue as

070well so if I if I may um I don't know if other people want to speak I don't want to step in but um I from my point of view this is me personally um we're really being asked I think this is I'm I actually think it's completely fine to bring up your concerns I think that's appropriate to bring up your concerns and and share those and at the same time um the question before us is not actually how we individually might choose to vote at town meeting the question before us is shall we we well I want to back up and say I'm going to back up and say a while ago we went to the public and we asked for funding to do a feasibility study and the citizens of Hamilton and wam

071funded that feasibility study and the deal with that is that we would do we as the district would do this work and come back to them with a project so that they could decide whether they want the project or not and we've done that and so when I'm looking at this I'm looking at this as this question is now let's let the people now decide on the project that we have ready to present um and I see that as being I personally am in support of the project I think it's a great project I'm excited about it but even if I weren't I'd like to say that I think the right thing is to bring it to the people and let them decide um so I I think it's absolutely fine for you to bring

072up any concerns you have about the project but I hope I guess I'm encouraging it's just me speaking personally like that I really would want the people to be able to vote on this can I jump in um yes Eric I just I just want to be clear with the whole committee the the reality of the standard of air quality hasn't even been met yet uh and it won't be until we get to the design stage which is after schematic schematic design is really just the shape of the building and what it looks like then we move into the deep design stage and and some of those things like ashray standard 41 is is not even um hasn't been adopted by Massachusetts at this time but in speaking with the contractors today I talked to

073our our um people who did our hbac stuff they gave me a lot of information about contingencies that are built into the project to be able to say okay at this time you have the ability to put in uh a UV a UV uh light that would you know take particles out of the air in your in your air systems you could you could add those things in along the way as you build um so so those these kind of growth things that Dave's talking about are not out of the question it's just it's not designed to that standard because it's not Massachusetts standard um it meets all International Mechanical codes the lead silver standard which we're trying to get to ASR 62.1 which is ventilation rate procedure ventilation requirements of high efficiency uh using

074MV 14 filters which is actually a higher level than we use now um and and it can grow continuing to grow this cost between three and $5 a square foot which which would add approximately 3 60 to $680,000 to the cost it does not necessarily need to be added to the top it may be part of the contingencies along the way um the tradeoffs that are made through the through the projects we've built so I think some of these things are worth further discussion but shouldn't hold up the the project because I I still think we can get to some of the places that I that Mr Frankle is talking about just to clarify Eric it doesn't take particle the UV lamps do not take particles out of the it destroys viruses um in the

075air and so there still but it's destroyed their effectiveness but um 62.1 has been ridiculed by Harvard as being completely obsolete it is a worse standard than than we had in 1905 um so and the Massachusetts school Building Association uh NBA has changed their because 62.1 used to be in the building code and probably still is in the building code but they the building code I am told by mrba now simply says the latest ashray standards that because things are changing so much they they wanted to get away from language that specified which ashray standards but the latest one is 241 so I I don't think it's it's entirely accurate to say that that it's not part of standard because they've stopped being specific about the as standard and simply refer to the fact that

076you should use the lightest ones and as I say ASR 241 is the latest can I say something Julia sure oh yeah I know David can see me um I think I mean I think we should bring this to the towns to see I mean I think that's our responsibility to bring this to the towns for them to vote on it like this is not set in stone what we vote on right now this is just saying we vote to bring it to the towns and then the towns can vote how they want to vote and we can vote as Citizens how we want to vote um yeah you know I think we're getting two into the weeds for this particular motion if the motion was just to bring it to the town and seems

077more longwinded than that but um I've got no I've got no OB to being brought to the to the town's vote and so long as it's not brought to the town's vote based on unanimous approval of it of of its content I'm sorry David can you say that again so long as it's not brought to the town I didn't hear the end of that as long as it doesn't imply that that the school committee unanimously supports in in its current form no okay that's a was kind of like Eric said a work a work in progress I mean it's there's still there's iterations of it there's schematics of it um design is but nothing has you know ground hasn't been broken yet because we don't even know what the towns are gonna say no I

078I think Julia I'm not sorry to just step on your toes I do think David I think that's a valid question or point that that by voting for this I I think that's an important and valid point doesn't mean we support it as it is exactly right I so and that's a great question and other people can speak to that I mean I do think the money is really important here that the money is the amount of money that we are saying this is the amount of money that the project is cannot exceed cannot exceed excuse me cannot exceed so in that sense yes we are saying this is the amount of money you look like you want to say something David no uh I was just saying that you know you're you're deling into

079this weed of you know one specific um you know point that that you know you tend to bring up quite often um and what has to be realized and and not sort of put aside is that we you know excuse me um you know we're we're currently designing you know as as part of the school building um committee you know we're currently working with the Architects and designers to make sure that everything is up to the minute to code on not only you know the point you're bringing up but probably about 10,000 other points simultaneously right um and what you know we're paying people very good money to do is to make sure not one of them is missed and not one of them um you know isn't the most upto-date and best choice for

080the children in our community excuse me that's you know not to say that your point isn't valid and you know your concern isn't real and that you have this expertise um in this field however you know it is one of very very very very very many little pieces of the watch that we're trying to build here um um and you know while again your concern is valid you know the the the main thing you know we can do is sort of assure you that you know we hear you and and I think this goes to everyone else who's ever sort of sat here and felt like they've said something in the audience and and they haven't been heard um we have heard you we have uh you know whether you want to believe it or

081not addressed every single concern um looked into um every you know sort of different view or uh Sid step or you know potential underground river that's have been been brought up and you know in in in in researched to make sure that we are in fact you know dotting every eye and Crossing every te in this very very very important project right it makes no sense to go through all this work to ask the public for a lot of money and a lot of trust right to then come up short in anyway it it it would be a complete waste of my time for the past going on six years at this point since the first time I've right um and and you know so I I definitely respect what you say and what everyone

082else you know has ever come in here to say um you know but you know at this point all I can do is ask you to to sort of trust that the process is to try and bring everything that we possibly can for the least amount of money to this town and to our students right and then that includes hearing what you're saying about you know these these codes possibly being updated and then making sure that you know the people we've hired to do this are looking into this you know every single day along the way to make sure that we're not opening um which has happened just about every with every building in this District have open and already been sort of behind the eightball and not enough so can I just ask a

083question who for for I've got a devil's advocate that I just can't let go who makes this decision that decision we who makes what decision who ultimately who will make the decision of which standard we are going to meet in the building is that the school building who building right has the you know has the authority to make the decision but we would you know be looking to our Architects and engineers and specifically in this case would be the HVAC Engineers that we have you know so then I just have one point and then I really want to get to a vote which is like this committee never gave guiding principles to the school building committee right um we never said these are the things that we think are most important and when I look

084at the school building project I think that it like the the values of the school building committee are well represented in there you can see where they wanted to they you um wanted to represent excellence right there are places where like we didn't go and take a building cookie cutter that are available right um and say we're going to install this we said we want something that is excellent in these particular ways and I I get the sense that um you know having been on this committee now for as long as I have that David doesn't see you know the the indoor environment particularly air quality as something that this commit represents in um in in investment uh by a reflection of its values right and so I think that that's if I had to

085to guess what why he's bringing it up right now David I can't really hear you when you talk so I'm just kind of putting words in your mouth um that that he's looking for some commitment from this committee because we aren't the group that's going to be making that decision um that we are going to value that that as a component of the way that the new school is moving forward knowing that it's not going to be this group's decision but we do have the ability to guide the way the decisions are made does that make sense we and the your point um Trent um because as members of the committee we you know we are in a way conflicted why don't we get a recognized expert on this subject um but it's less less

086a mechanic you HVAC Engineers are not necessarily experts on the consequences of their decisions they're much more mechanical in their in their expertise you know they working out the volumes and the deployment but um if if we could get a guest speaker to speak to this issue to the whole committee about why we should give a about which standard we we adhere to I think that would be very good for guiding guiding your decision making because you know David I just I I think that that claim to be a recognized expert on the subject Al I'm probably better read than most on the subject but not direct an expert and I think Trent is actually familiar with one of the most prominent experts in this field I I think I just I think that David

087we we've established that this group is not the one that's going to make those those detailed decisions um that is the school building committee and so all we can really do is give guidance to the school building committee yes from a procedural perspective yeah could could we not charge the superintendent to take since his chair that school committee to take this issue and um project project out views on the subject I I can assure you as two members of three members of the school building committee are sitting here right now that is very clear what your position is you know and I will definitely be hounding the next time I meet with the HVAC um on the project you know um but you know I again to sort of reiterate it and again it's not

088that you're not being heard but excuse me throughout this process you know um we've had these Community forums and we've had um you know different opportunities to meet with teachers in public well I did I I did raise it right at the beginning of the school building committee and was told they're there wait it's that decision be made Downstream yeah so I'm going to just interrupt and say and it really hasn't been made actually because I don't think you guys debated the issue so so David I I hear you and I heard you say that you had the opportunity to raise this issue and I heard and I and I heard David Palo who's on school building committee say he's heard that opport that you've raised this issue so I I understand your frustration and

089at the same time I don't think the issue is that you haven't had the opportunity to raise the issue because it has been raised we've we have heard the issue Dana not to be argumented but um our school protocols call for complete debating of the issue and what what I my objection about this and on a couple of other issues is that there was never substantive debate as far as I can tell correct me I'm wrong Eric and David uh about whether to be or not to be on 241 you know did did the school building committee go that is one of the possibilities here's the evidence for here's the evidence against we've decided against it I couldn't find any trace of that but I may looking the wrong place I feel like at this

090point this is kind of out of the scope of the motion I don't know because I did ask the question right from the Geo of the committee and I just didn't get an answer um David I'm not sure if you could hear what Amy just said um so Amy is just saying that she feels like at this point we might be beyond the four corners of the motion um sure okay um I'm not trying to what was that I said I'm not trying to fill that to do that okay um does anyone else have any questions uh regarding this the specific Motion in front of us looks like maybe we're ready to vote I'm looking at the two people online yes Julie you guys vote y okay you guys ready to vote okay yes um

091all right is everyone and everyone is clear no one needs David to repeat the entire motion okay uh we're going to do a roll call vote um I'm gonna start with you David David pedo yes Amy yes uh Dana is a yes Trent yes Julia yes David Frankle no okay and so that is 5 to one and the motion passes correct y okay um uh the next item on the agenda is the superintendent um evidence um before we get just before we do that David Frank I don't know if there's any way for you to move your mic a little closer I'm I think we're all having a little trouble hearing in both directions but I can hear Julia just fine so I'm not quite sure what that's about but um testing one two three

092that's a little better that's actually better yep that's a little better thank you I'll let for a bit more okay sorry that's good all right um next up is uh the superintendent formative evidence thank you everyone uh this is the mid midcycle evaluation evidence mid year and it's really the first half so that you can begin to go through the evidence uh outline questions or uh start to track it for evaluation purposes at the end of the year uh as we get into May there'll be I'll continually add to this document I I the way it's designed I just continuously add to it um so it's it gives you an overview as to right now where I am with goals and objectives uh that I laid out at the beginning of the year uh that

093were voted upon by this committee it outlines everything from meetings to things that we're working on um through the district and opportunities that we have to uh look towards the future and um trying to finalize some of my goals as they relate to the district goals so this is just for you to take and begin to digest and put together formulate questions if you have them please reach out to me um with the understanding that there I'll continuously add to this document so that as we get into May you'll get a final document that'll be I don't know 25 or 30 pages long that will have um the entirety of the responses for my goals for this year so I just want to make sure everybody had it in a timely manner and um certainly

094if if you're going through it and you have a question please reach out to me um I just wanted to add to that um just exactly that that I do hope by having it you do have it in a timely manner we have plenty of time I um asked Janelle um to help I don't know if you have remembered but in the past that the actual form that we fill out for the superintendent evaluation is really just frustrating from a formatting sense point of view Janelle has done some real work on it and she's gotten the form already so we I my hope is to get those forms to you actually very soon so that if you um wanted to sort of do your evaluation as you go along you can do that um so

095I'll be getting those out to you you um and then I just want to reiterate what Eric said this is a lot of information and I hope that you'll reach out to him of course you can always ask a question in a meeting it's important um but also I hope that you'll ask him directly one of the things about being a school Committee Member is that you do have a direct line to the superintendent so in this document if you I know I glanced at it I had a couple questions I'm going to ask him directly um so that I'm clear um anybody else have any questions about the um process C or about sort of the general what's going on here this okay thank you thank you um next up uh I think is

096maybe Amy who's coming right along um is an update on the communications and branding conversation yes um thank you so I have been meeting with a member of the community Chris Ford who has um branding and design agencies pilot and yellow fly in Boston and I showed him all the work that we've done up until now around branding um and he has volunteered his designers to take on the next steps of the project so right now I'm waiting for him to update me with their timeline um but that is pretty much the update and as soon as I have that I'll share it with Mr Tracy great thank you for that thank you for doing that work and for having those conversations um does anybody have any questions can I add to that here go

097ahead sorry just a subset to that uh Mr Ford also reached it back out to me Circle back to me uh connected us up with some graphic design people to do our signage we we're responsible for all the signage the new um athletic facilities so he connected us to kind of a a group that does this specifically for companies like his without us having to go through a middleman to we should be able to save some money on that as well so we're looking forward to that meeting it should happen after vacation great um and is this um timing wise do we feel like we're going to be in an okay time frame to get the signage done we are we are in good shape great um anyone else have questions or comments on that

098thank you um next up um this item is titled procedures for addressing protocol concerns um a couple meetings back um I came to the committee and asked how the committee wanted um the myself or whoever is in the chair position um to address concerns regarding member Behavior and um I do appreciate I did get some feedback from Individual members um that um and I appreciate the feedback that that the um committee would like those concerns to be brought forth to the committee to trust the committee um to be transparent with the committee um and to try to address them um in that way um um and so I appreciate those that feedback um it if anyone has anything that they would like to address regarding um that at this that and that conversation um that

099would this would be the time for that yeah um can you hear me clearly yep yes um I don't want to address every one of the the uh allegations and imputations that you made at that meeting not not at this meeting it will take take too much time but I do wanted to um address one of them um and I'll just read from the minutes so that to refresh over his memory um you stated the D stated CH let say Cher stated that the following several months ago member David Frankle applied for a grant on behalf of the district without authorization to do so after having been specifically told that the district was not interested in obtaining the products offered by the Grant on that grand statement he made inaccurate and false statements on the

100application so my response to that is that I didn't reply I didn't apply for the grant I was merely making an inquiry as to the size and nature of that very New Foundations gr apart from everything else the MC's legal advice is that there is no need to get the prior approval about a grant but it was not my intent and and uh there was apart from the form that they had on their site to makeing queries um I had several fun conversations with the the person that was nearly had created this foundation and and uh was knowledgeable about the grant there was nothing to indicate how many how many of these boxes and I'll explain more what these boxes are in a minute um were available and uh eventually he said look I'm going

101to ask my board how many it's it's possible and came back and initially said uh 4,000 anyway I filled out what was characterized by the foundation was an information gathering form I had it I made it clear that any Grant offer would have to be accepted by the superintendent and the school committee I immediately notified the superintendent when that inquiry surprisingly turned into a grant offer he did not respond to me he referred the matter to ultimately after two emails from me to him he referred it to the to chaira implying I had done something improper um which I think was very unfair because I brought the the offer to him in two comprehensive emails immediately prior to the offsite um planning meeting where I was unable to attend because I was away on vacation

102um I written to Eric asked him to represent to the committee in that informal planning session where his goals were being discussed um the fine they said and this is to Eric on August 8 um glad we had the chance to chat this morning um I think we had a coffee and uh discussed the fact I wouldn't be there and that there would that I really wanted um some things brought up so I said the coy rosenal Foundation has approved inwriting a $4,000 Grant which could come to 66 Cy rosenell box kits um does everybody know what a Coy Rosen colar box is or should I just give a brief explanation of what it is I know what that is is that what you're asking yeah David is asking does everyone know what a Cory

103Rosenthal box is yes I do I do it's a it's a do-it-yourself air filter box that um uh is considered by far the best pric performance uh that you could that's out there in the world um uh I'm certainly able to show you one of these uh at the next meeting in person um the state of Connecticut for example just recently uh spent I think $11 million go one in every single School in every single classroom so this is not some kind of hair brain scheme that uh that that I've made up as a hobbyist far from it this is this is very mainstream and these are the units that will actually get used we've made several ourselves we use them around our home um I've shown to Eric that the sound level of these

104is is acceptable to work in a classroom which is not true of the metaphy boxes that we spent $70,000 to put one in every classroom couple of years ago and the teachers turn them down they when they're turned down from level four to level three they deliver about one not much more than one air change per hour uh in the room which renders them almost useless they need to be R running more like five air changes now which is what DAV David I'm just I'm gonna interrupt you but I will at the will of the committee if if people want you just let me know I don't want to it it feels like right now you're discussing the pros and cons of a particular air filtration system but I think you're not addressing the protocol

105concerns anymore that's what it feels like to me other people can tell me if they'd like to continue I really I gave you uh and the committee probably took half an hour to go through all all of my um misdirects and I really want to clarify what was said to Eric um uh in in two Communications basically the second time I followed up because he hadn't followed up and it turns out he didn't bring it up in the offsite meeting in spite of my request um at September 11 I wrote to him and basically said uh I'm just looking to understand would you like to discuss the grant oper I'm just looking to understand if you wish to accept this grant offer or reject it in either case I'd appreciate understanding your reasoning 3 days

106ago uh into the new school year and my granddaughter Reena caught Co now has missed three days at school due to an infection that that had her temperature at almost 103 clearly there are other students and staff that have been exposed and a number infected it's also turned our household upside down because my wife is having a hip vable not not going to beat this to death here the CR box of course he RIS box it's the lowest and quite quiet setting has the a higher than the metap um mety 50 on the highest setting and the mid setting of the of the CR box is able to deliver an air chain per hour of five in a classic classroom versus met uh mety 50s 2.1 on its highest level setting and since the teachers

107turn it down or off um because it's unaccept unacceptably noisy the air changes for hour is 1.2 anyway my any point is this that we have an offer on the table for free of 140 units of this and I'm really not happy that that was turned into a smear I think the question is more based on a false premise okay based on a false premise that that I had done something irregular against a set of rules really were not made manifestly obvious and which are not Statewide rules and I'm still not convinced that it's part of any formal policy we have quite willing to treat it as if it is but I don't believe that there was a solid foundation for making the accusation in the first place but be that as it may um

108the question is we have an offer on the table and the consequence of using this uh this kind offer is that we would have an opportunity for um for an educational opportunity for uh a lot of students that that's what ASU now the largest university I gather in the country has done they have created a course uh for indoor air quality uh built around also a practical build it yourself air filter system um and then they've taken it to the schools uh around David can I just can I say something this is Julia you're talking about we're talking about the way you went about applying for the grant not the substance of the Grant in any way it was about how you went about applying for it the other thing is just you know having

109worked for a nonprofit for many years we we get offers for things that are free all the time and there is a huge resource of Manpower and and time um and other things that go into learning how something works and everything like that but I don't want to go into the substance of the grant because I think what we were talking about if I was correct was not the substance or the box or whatever it was for it was how it was it was about how um no I the process and the protocol I reject I reject that that uh that um characterization of what happened because what what I did is I saw that the grants are all of a sudden available and I made an inquiry as to what the grant what grants

110were possible and then I took that to Eric it wasn't an application would have been taken would have then been taken if he'd shown any willingness it would have been taken to the committee as a whole He instead you know implied that it wasn't really the committee's choice it was his I don't think that is proper either you know if this is a committee decision uh and to whether or not to assign Eric Eric this as a goal or not well I don't know I mean I feel like I have what if I had like 300 printers that I wanted to give it doesn't that doesn't have to go through the committee that would just have to go through Eric you know or what if I had some office supplies to give or if I

111had a rug or that's true God only knows I just I don't I guess that I think um yeah I think that it's in the eye of the beholder and that it's not even about the issue of the substance of what the grant was funding it's the the way that it was approached is what I understood the issue was and I completely understand you wanting to stick up for stick up for yourself um but to me I mean I I do trust Eric to make decisions about those kind those kinds of things that are not policies per se that are just things that are in the classroom um because I'm sure we get offers all the time I'm gonna I'm gonna interrupt I'm just going to interrupt the two of you just for a second

112just I'm going to interrupt it does look like did you want to speak does look we have someone here that in the room that want to speak and then I do want you know to keep Focus here so go ahead Trent um thank you I I just I think that it is Meaningful to separate the two things right the how this was gone about and the substance of what it is um when donations of substantive amounts of money come it comes to the committee to accept or not accept um the first time that I heard about this grant was in the last meeting we were talking about the protocols um and so I I do think that there's there is there should be a conversation that the committee has about what gets brought to the

113committee but I think that the the item that's on the agenda here is about the protocol um and I would just say that you know when you at the end of the meeting tonight ask for additional items um um for future meetings then I will put that on as a additional item for a future meeting is how the committee responds to things that are that potential donations that are coming in because I think we have a couple other things um but I just I think that that a that's an important discussion to have and B is not exactly what we're supposed to be addressing under what's on the agenda here today thank you um other people okay yeah I I would accept that um to place I'm sorry David can you get closer to the

114mic I can't hear you now sorry I I would accept that as as a a friendly suggestion put it on the agenda to be specifically debated at some future meeting at at the next meeting all right we ready to move on okay thank you you good um all right next up is Vinnie again um to the FY 26 final budget we still have Julia and and David correct okay yep just duplicating no just just making sure just so they can see what he's uh so as I mentioned during the public hearing I was not going to go through uh the entire presentation in the exhibit there is a uh 50 slide presentation that literally breaks out the movement of every single uh dollar throughout the budget between fy2 and FY 26 uh right here I

115have the final budget motion and I can answer uh any questions or any final comments or I can go over anything in particular somebody might want review again uh it's kind of your time to request any final questions or or comments that you have um or I can go through the whole thing anyone questions or comments for Vinnie Julia or David questions or comments for Vinnie um I will just say a big thank you for my the page that of course thank you um David do you want to read the motion for us sure excuse me I move the Hamilton one and Regional school committee approve the final FY 26 general fund expend general fund expenditures budget of 4,441 149 this includes general fund operation expenses after offsets in the amount of 43,4 193,00 242

116and general fund general fund Debt Service expenses in the amount of 1,947 N7 furthermore the gross operating expenses of the district before offsets have been allocated by the Desi defined chart of accounts according to the summary by Desi category chart included in the in this budget presentation as detailed in the exhibit do I have a second second second by Amy kumberg um there questions or discussion can't see the people anymore no no no no nothing all right it looks like we are ready to vote um it'll be a roll call vote um Trent yes uh Julia yes David Franco yes Dane as a yes Amy yes yes all right that is unanimous and of the six members present and the motion passes thank you guys thank you [Music] Vinnie um it's an after after all

117that um next up is um uh school committee budy budget and Capital Communication um discussion Eric I don't know if you want to say that or yeah we we um wanted to get this on the agenda earlier rather than later to be able to put together our one-page flyer that we have prepared for uh Town meetings just as we have in the past usually a one onepage visual flyer of kind of the budget highlights um also the school highlights um that anything that would go to town meeting we' put on this one page flyer we need to get it done um within a week of town meeting because it has to be approved by both moderators before I can actually bring it to the town meeting so just wanted to put that in everybody's front

118and center view because we have a short window to do it with vacation coming up around the corner thoughts comments graphic designers I would I volunteer to create it if you'd like that's okay with everybody to vote on that um have we before I second yes I think we have voted on that before I think you've done it before maybe and David's done it before I think um yes and I do think we have voted on that um I um yeah I think um if people are comfortable we could have a motion on that I moved that Hamilton one school committee um task gave meber would put together one pager for town meeting do we have a second second second by Trent been weird if few second um all right uh anyone have any questions

119or yeah I'm sorry I wasn't I didn't hear that very clearly so um Eric could you possibly sure they just tasked Amy with creating the onepage document for town meeting oh okay fine thank you it'll be a roll call vote um all right anybody have anything else all right looks like we're ready to vote uh David poo yes Amy yes Dan as a yes Trent yes Julia yes David Frankle yes and that is unanimous of um the six members present thank you very much Amy um all right and you can work with Eric and Vinnie on that and it'll be fun it will okay um committee reports uh Capital Finance uh we have our next meeting on this coming Monday we've met since the last okay update great uh policy we still need to meet

120um yes we're held up a little bit you sent me a message about Monday mornings right yeah and then I'm on break for the full week so maybe that would be a good week all right I'll reach back out having trouble getting everybody okay a time all right um I'm blanking on what it was but I had another question for policy but I can't remember what it was oh well yes I'll bring it up in another time I I have a question but yes um it was around remote meetings because it looks like the rules the laws may change so um negotiations nothing oh that's me nothing that's us Y no um uh secretary report oh geez you know what I never fall back up with now when you weren't here I had we were

121going back and forth and we just didn't solidify anything and now I can put on all right um we'll get on that in the future okay Eric uh thank you a couple of items uh exciting the 100th day of school celebrations are coming up next week always fun at the elementary school um also on the 12th which is Wednesday the annual hearts and flowers event if you have not been it's a a very nice little event that our Coral kids do at uh the high school level and it's only about an hour long they they have different groups that sing and um have food and and uh usually some type of or something available so hearts and flowers next Wednesday it usually starts around 6:30 uh don't forget we are going on break uh after

122next week from 17th to the 21st we will be on uh winter recess and then uh K right after that just before our next meeting the kindergarten information night will be on February 25th at 6:30 and that will take place this year at the winr and that is it anybody having questions for the superintendent I question um several um one what's the status of the electronic CL um Grant the status now is we are on hold I have uh been in contact with Seth Molton office and several of his people the uh as you know the the holds that were put on some of the government grants are have been impacted um we're still waiting for the idea of whether or not this grant will come forward or not nobody is sure nobody's come out

123and said that it is or isn't coming so we're just waiting for some help from DC right and that's am I right is that $5 million with Dr at St the amount was it's it's approximately $4.8 million so um very good and what what's the status of the btq um energy study I think I I believe Curtis has reached out I don't know at what state he's at but he will be here next meeting uh to talk about the water uh requests that were made last meeting so we can ask him then and I guess not to beat a dead horse here but I I'm getting the impression that there's um there's a lot of a lot of illness going around the school you know it's it's typical seasonal illness and I've seen direct evidence

124of pressure to keep the kids in school have them tough it out when they're symptomatic which as far as I'm concern seems to me to um just accelerate the rate at which we infect each other in uh infect teachers infect each other in the schools and so forth so I'm just wondering what is your own personal policy what is your plan to mitigate to to reduce the amount of of disease communication that goes on in the school realistically we rely on our nurses our nurses make the decision on who stays in school and who goes home they work directly with kids and families uh every single day and also keep us in the loop as to what may or may not be happening within the schools I also notice I don't know if David can

125hear me so you might have to repeat this Eric but as a winther parent I see in Mrs shak's email every week There's a statement from the nurse with guidance about when to keep kids home yeah which I find really helpful as a benchmark so there's no particular policy um regarding you know students that are symptomatic about whether they that's person by person decision by the nurse is that what you're saying correct you think that's a good pxy given that that just accelerates the right of of Sprint the reality is is I trust our nurses wholeheartedly to make decisions on the ground level for our kids and our staff and are they given any instructions about the boxes they do have in the room to turn them on or turn them off or turn them

126down I you know I when they were originally distributed I didn't see much evidence of of explaining why they were there and what the consequences of of messing around with their their levels was but maybe that has changed has it I'm not sure what you're talk what what are you talking I'm I'm sorry can you say that again I don't know what you're the filter boxes that Eric acquired a couple of years ago I think it is now is it Eric um uh can be turned on they can be turned off the teachers can can do either of those they can turn them down and their effectiveness at reducing the spread of infection in the room is is affected by each of those decisions I'm just wondering how those decision what what education have those

127those teachers received about the consequences of taking those actions um and uh and where are we in in the cycle of of improvement because I noticed with with Nick's um email to all of us that they're very conscious of how sick their their own staff get from the schools and and they're looking forward to the new school hoping the new school will enable them to not get as sick and yet there's very things that we're I'm not sure what we're doing to to reduce the level of of um disease Communication in our room in our schools at this stage so I'm just asking so communication for Disease Control comes from our nurses our lead nurse uh sends out uh notices to staff across all of our buildings especially and things it could be anything the

128most recent one was around um lice so there there are fairly consistent Communications by our nurses to people in the facilities in the buildings uh they generally manage all of that there's no formal training on how to use a metaphy box to turn it on or off um some teachers keep them on the mid level some people teachers keep them on the low level some teachers keep them on the highest level um it just varies with each classroom some people don't use them at all they don't they don't uh there requirement to use them so some people choose not to use them yeah I think that's probably pretty accurate it's not very effective but it's it's probably an accurate characterization of that what is going on but but your point is you you delegate that

129entirely to the nurses correct okay thank you I'll take that to heart no more questions for me thank you okay uh anybody else have any questions for Eric I just had one we had a member of the Community Reach Out about the high school cell phone policy I then saw something come out from the high school about that is being considered by High School staff So eventually I imagine we'll hear what that ultimate consideration result is yep the it's about I think it was about two weeks ago when I when I first talked to Brian menoni about his uh wanting to change the cell phone policy at the high school level currently now they have a policy where kids put their phones in um their literally shoe bo shoe uh storage things that hang on

130the wall they drop they drop their cell phone in there you know I go into a class you probably see 10 or 12 or 14 cell phones in there so not all kids use it they're moving to something a little more strict uh at the request of parents parents and teachers so they started with the staff and faculty I think they had two forums last week open for staff and faculty to come in and and uh kind of let people know how they have there's a survey that if it hasn't gone out already it's gone out to families and then there is a survey going to kids I believe on Monday of next week and then they'll formulate some type of uh uh cell phone policy at the high school level that they'll add into

131the handbook and that'll eventually come here so they are in the process of updating it and we've given them um I was on the commissioner's call today for a little over an hour and a half and uh some of the things that they gave us were related to cell phones from the Attorney General's office so I sent all of that to the teachers that are running this committee um to to do that work so that it's it's a toolkit from the Attorney General's office with some related information that may help them in their policy development so that's that's that's what's happening right now thank you thank you anything else um okay I don't uh really have a chair report I do have a a little bit of a followup to the um procedures for addressing

132protocol concerns um I just want to make sure that everyone and I kind of really want everyone to respond that everyone is clear and everyone is an agreement that we as school committee members should not be contacting staff directly and and asking for information that in fact the chain of command is that we should ask from for information through the superintendent does anyone here have any questions about that or want to respond to that in any way who's the new football coach yeah do do parents do all do all the parents that make appointments with teachers have to go through Eric to get appointments so that's a great question David so if a parent is going to meet with a teacher regarding your specific child regarding you know report cards or a behavioral issue with

133your child then absolutely not then they don't need to go to Eric but if a school Committee Member were asking for general information from a staff member that is something that um so for example if a member of the public wanted information a report or data or statistics they might not realize that they shouldn't go directly to a staff member but if they went to that staff member they would be directed to the superintendent so that's how the information would be provided to a random member of the public members of the school committee need to remember that as a school committee member if you approach a member of the staff and ask for information directly about the school you know things about operations or statistics or data that you're in a position in which that

134staff member um may feel obligated to respond to you you're um so yes so that should so to answer your question no if you're talking about your own specific child and a like conference with the teacher of course not but um so yeah so good question I hope that answered it okay thank you anybody else have questions on that okay I don't have anything else I did hear um one topic for future meeting already I heard Trent asking about a topic of donation procedures is that correct yeah I've been thinking about how to word that request yeah and I do want to give a little information just before and before we get to the what because we do sort of already have a procedure and it is that if um and Julia actually used the

135example of well if I had 10 printers and things like that actually do happen people go to the superintendent and say I have these things and sometimes the superintendent says actually no we don't have a use for that um so if that's part of your question because then it actually wouldn't appear on our agenda like that that's actually does I mean Eric back I want to make sure that's true but that does happen sometimes people try to be generous and donate something that we the district doesn't actually want so that is part of the procedures we see the most is something like computer monitors people want to get rid of them so they're like hey school I'm gonna donate your my computer my seven computer monitors from 1993 you but we don't we just say

136no we we try to stay away from technology in general that's been used so right we stop that part of but it's a valid conversation um I mean it could just be called donation procedures if you want to dive more deeply into what those are I I think that you know given the concerns that were brought up around specifically uh the Grant and then I think that I think that we should have a conversation about about those because I think that if we need to talk about updating our protocols um then that's the time to do it if we need to talk about um um asking the the policy committee to you know develop policies and bring them back to the the full school committee I think that's the time to do it okay do

137you think it should just be called donation procedures well I I think it's a little bit more than that right because I think the the the issue here isn't necessarily the the donation itself other I think the issue at hand was um an individual member or you know the the the yeah that an know just individual member spoke on behalf of the school committee you know without the consent of the school committee or you know prior knowledge um um and you know it's sort of working around that you know and hearing what David was saying tonight you know um that he was inquiring and that was just sort of granted you know the um or given the grant even though he thought it was just only an inquiring or whatever you know the concern from

138the committee was that in fact he was speaking for the committee and you know I think we can OB need to clarify that language a little bit see I I would entirely agree with that I think that maybe this is a broader discussion around external communication yeah and I I was going to say I actually still have a note from you in general that we do want to have a conversation around committee members external communication and maybe that's the topic and whether it's around donation procedures or other yeah yeah I know it's so tough I mean you guys know you get it around how people ask you and you know you're not speaking in front in on behalf of the committee but you know they hear no matter what they know you're s on the

139school committee and so they sort of take it that way and and I mean in other words it I don't want to spend too much time on this because it is just a topic for future meeting but I I wrote down Committee Member committee members or external commun Communications maybe it's just called Committee Member external Communications or something like that um we can come up with something um and it may really just it may be around our voted and approved protocols that we discuss or it may be around just having a general discussion but I think there's a topic there so and you and I can talk if you want to have flesh that out more or if you feel like that's enough we can do that I I think it's adequately Broad and I'm

140adequately tired yes as we all okay broad um anybody else have a topic for future meeting no I just want to note that Julie C had to drop off oh okay um all right so yeah Julia had to leave just a couple minutes early around 8:40 Dana I have a Q2 update fy2 Q2 update and that's at the next meeting if that's okay if there enough room let's hope it'll be fun I can wait if not okay Eric uh we also have to read Title 9 okay roll back so if to it's been voted uh by this Comm the the polic the Biden era policy was voted but we need to now go back and roll back to the 2020 original Trump era policy so I'll have that together and ready for the next meeting

141only because we need it uh because we approve our handbook our high school handbook we need to have that updated fairly quickly so okay we just waiting for our attorneys to clear through everything all right um anybody have anything else okay looks like we are ready for a motion if anyone has one I move toj at 8:45 motion to adjourn sure second I'll propose I heard I heard both Davids will take that as a motion and a second wej I I thought we were GNA get a chair's report uh I didn't have anything on the chair's report had nothing to address other than what I wanted to say about this uh staff communication um okay so I heard a motion to adjourn 845 uh David and I heard a second of was a chorus of

142Davids and a second by Trent um David Frankle yeah Trent sorry yes Dan is a yes Amy yes uh David yes and we are adjourned at 8:45

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.