CorpusRecord 19618

Special Meeting of the Governing Board - January 23, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Glendale Elementary School District
Date
2025-01-24
Location
Maricopa County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,144 words · about 46 min
Collected
2026-06-06

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening everybody wow it's really loud um good evening everybody Welcome to the January 23rd meeting for the Glendale Elementary School District governing board uh please let the minute show we have three out of five board members currently present Hector is stuck in traffic and Miss uh Wilson is out sick today so uh we do have a quorum to go and continue the meeting so with that being said are there any changes to the agenda this after or evening good evening president Martinez members of the board no there are not all right Miss Bartel uh it what is there a motion to adopt the agenda I would like to move that we adopt the agenda second all right Miss Bartell how do you vote I miss Pentel how do you vote I

002and the chair votes I thank you um see please join me in a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance please rise Mr scatter Jones yes president Martinez may I ask for a point of privilege yes ma'am thank you glendell elementary schools PR [Music] and GST GST is committed to providing a welcoming inclusive learning environment where all students can Thrive not only academically but also socially emotionally we embrac the diversity of our community and honored our families and trust us with their children's academic and social well-being every day we understand Public Schools face many challenges beyond our local control but will remain steadfast in our commitment to ensuring that every student feels welcome and supported while at school we will continue to make decisions that prioritize the best interest of both our students

003and Community ensuring that every child feels value respected and empowered to learn regardless of outside burdens placed on public education at GSD we are all in for all kids every day thank you thank you Mr G Jones Moving on in our agenda to our special recognition uh just because Awards Miss Jones yes govering board if we can please step down we will begin those [Music] recognitions good evening for those of you that are joining us for the first time we are going to begining our celebrations um the just because Awards and this is on behalf of goose our Educational Foundation so every month we randomly select a student and a staff member and we um just want to say thank you just because just because meaning that you are attending GSD as a student or

004you've chosen GSD to employee to be an employee here and we're proud that you uh UST in us uh to be your employer as well as that your children attend our schools every day so it is a random selection this is a unique one so every student every teacher is play or staff member not just teachers tonight it's it's a teacher are placed into um a data bank and we randomly select one person across the district as an employee and then one as a student so this time we have a teacher and our teacher is from Burton and Mariah if you'll come forward please Miss Dean will come forward you can bring your little one Ezekiel bring the baby he can come and we want to say thank you for choosing GSD um Gusto has

005awarded her with a $50 gift certificate already we're also going to award her with some chocolates a sign and um a plaque some kindness crayons some Mosaic Taffy this is a yard sign marah and so I know you're exhausted with having an 18-month y so if you could run outside about 9 when I can get to your house and both of you just stand there and I'll take a picture we'll be good you'll be on Instagram you'll be famous okay make sure you're fully dressed no chonies and we'll be good all right but Mariah thank you so much for choosing gstd and if we could come in and take a picture please aana and could the Burton Family please come forward [Music] great and you want to just get Mariah and the baby [Applause] thank

006you so much you're welcome I'm sure she's not going to give him the chocolate we should have got Puffs does he eat Puffs I need to get some Puffs all right so as I said earlier what was unique about this time we did the random drawing and it's never occurred before the student was Al actually also from Burton her name is Olivia but she's out ill today not only it was interesting that we uh a and I we did the the random we our teacher came out Maria comes out we do it again we have a student it's Burton it's Olivia and the thing about it was it was Olivia's first day of school that day so I call Kate Laser's our principal I said Kate Olivia she's like Olivia I can't Cindy I'm embarrassed

007I don't know who this student is and she she's worried about it she talks to Brian they're worried they don't know who the student is it's because they had just registered that morning so um so we went and visited Olivia in the cafeteria she was thrilled to death and very excited and so unfortunately she couldn't be here but Kate if you'll make sure she gets everything so um but again that had never happened so we were quite excited and surprised by that probably should have bought a lottery ticket so which I failed to do obviously I'm still here so we will go to the next award and our next award um but I want to give this to Mariah did somebody give her chocolate chocolate because she said that her mom had been babysitting all

008day so I think Grandma Nana needs some chocolate I'm pretty sure Nana needs chocolate there you go you're welcome being a nana I I understand that okay um so now we're going to go into our uh just because or we do just because we're going to go into the Kanas um student of the month and we have with us our great kananian Patrick Kaiser and Patrick if you will please do that honor for us thank you and it good to see you guys I haven't seen you in a little while so good evening my name is Patrick Kaiser I'm a member of the kuas club of Glendale and tonight I am here to recognize the kowas club of Glendale superintendent student of the month for the month of January 2025 the reason that this award

009is so special is that this student has been choose chosen by the superintendent for their hard work passion for helping others and helping to make our community a better place this month's winner is Alyssa Marin [Applause] Alissa congratulations now this is where we get to embarrass you a lot so be be prepared Alyssa why don't you come up here so we can all look at you and stare at you while you're embarrassed then we'll give you chocolate Alyssa is a fourth grade student at Herold W Smith Elementary School where she has attended since first grade Alyssa is dedicated to making the world a better place and is passionate about helping others she volunteers at her church by making sure the church is clean and welcoming Alyssa and her family also enjoy volunteering at Christmas time

010by passing out toys for those who need the extra support overall Alyssa is a great example to other students we asked her teachers to share a little more about Alyssa as part of the nomination process Mrs Mahia Alyssa's first grade teacher shared I remember Alyssa as being a student with such a kind and loving heart even now she still comes up to me every day after school and give me a goodbye hug I also recall very clearly her outstanding school spirit she never missed a chance to dress up for those schoolwide spirit days congratulations Alyssa you will certain you certainly deserve this award Alyssa's second grade teacher Mrs carmichel added Alyssa is such a hard worker and always on task and followed directions in class the one me memory I can think of is that

011every day at dismissal for the last couple of years if I can flip the page she always comes up to her old teachers and gives them a hug and that always meant so much to me Mrs Ingram alysa's third grade teacher admired Alyssa's helpfulness she said while in class Alyssa was always respectful help ful and responsible she always went above and beyond helping other students with their homework or the day's lessons this year Alyssa continues to make an impression on the Smith campus her fourth grade teacher Mrs Sanders States Alyssa is a leader in the classroom always willing to help others she helps our new students navigate the school and classrooms she also helps her second language peers learn and grow this is why she was asked to be one of our classroom ambassadors Alyssa

012is is a model of servant leadership at school home and inner Community which is why she is so deserving of the student of the month award congratulations Alysa we have a certificate to recognize your hard work and a $50 gift card to Walmart the kuas club of Glendale encourages you to keep up the good work for anyone who would like to learn more about the good work of the kuas club of Glenn you can go to our website at Kanas club glendale.com or follow us on Facebook or you can always join us for lunch every Wednesday at mws at 55th Avenue in Pur thank you can we have alysa's uh whole clan come on up everybody Smith family media family and friends come come on up everyone come on up there's a lot come on

013up okay so some chocolate for you some chocolate for you chocolate for you okay we're good all right everybody [Music] great can you just get the family okay a can we just get the family family Alyssa and then Alyssa there's one more thing you get to do also Mr beran Alissa also you get to choose something out of our treasure basket all right congratulations Alysa uh in in collaboration with the glendell elementary school district and the members of the Kanas Club of Glendale last year we developed a new award that recognizes the School in the district that demonstrates unwavering dedication to Servant leadership and provides significant service to the local Metro Regional and Global Community this award is called the commitment to service servant leadership award and each month the school in the district will

014be named the inspiring change School of the month the January 2025 winner of this award is Bicentennial South [Applause] that is your award with the Rob robust focus on Career and Technical education B Centennial South has worked to create Partnerships with many Community organizations that provide outstanding presentations on the first Friday of every month and help with interesting field trips that are aligned with each grade level's CTE focus of particular note with a focus on first responder training to Medical Sciences to hospitality and culinary arts Bicentennial South has worked to partner with industry leaders such as the Glendale police and fire departments Chase Building team EV innovators and others to make sure all students have had a diverse experiences and are ready to choose any path they desire during their high school years and Beyond

015Bicentennial South inspires change through these academic offerings one example of a culmination of their hard work has been their electronic go-kart Mosaic club which built a go-kart drove it in two parades and have now worked to disassemble that cart for future clubs these students as innovators show what purposeful dedication learning new Workforce skills and showcasing the outcomes can do for not only students engagement interest and celebration but overall Community Support the trophy that you received is a traveling trophy that will be proudly displayed at the winning school for the month and will move to the winning School the following month this will help build the solidarity of the GES community and recognize the hard work of developing our Future Leaders congratulations [Applause] do you have any more south family or is it just you just

016you great [Applause] okay okay moving on in our agenda are there any calls to the public this evening president Martinez no there are not okay uh next on the agenda is the consent agenda uh are there is there motion to adopt the consent agenda I'll move to approve the consent agenda second Miss Bartel how do you vote I miss Pentel how do you vote I Mr Haro how do you vote I and chair votes I thank you moving on to reports and information items uh the really fun stuff Capital lawsuit update now in its 30th year Miss seata Jones yes at this time I'll turn over to Mr Bean for formal introductions Mr Mr President members of the board superintendent sagata Jones um you have uh Danny Adelman here with the Arizona Center for Law

017and the public interest uh he took over as executive director I believe it was in 201 18 um but he also served on the board for about 20 years prior to becoming the executive director and you might remember that at the time Tim Hogan was the attorney leading the capital lawsuit um I let me just before Danny goes into his presentation the superintendent and I um and I think it was board member Martinez president Martinez also expressed I believe it was in November our appreciation to Mr Edelman on his per performance during the actual 60-day trial or however long that was um they were well prepared the entire team delivered I we were pleased with your performance the preparation and really your gentleness and Grace with some of the witnesses and some of the individuals

018in that room and I don't know that we could have asked for a better team to litigate that Capital lawsuit so with that I will turn it over to Mr Adelman um thanks anyway um actually the I've been asked to explain what is the capital lawsuit um although many of you already know about it I'll give you a little background and just tell you what's going on like right at this minute so the basic idea of the case is the state is not providing adequate funding to enable all of Arizona's school districts to meet their Capital needs and capital can be anything from the condition of your facilities do your air conditioners work is it watertight do your do you have buses um all those things plus um curriculum and technology and Equipment everything that

019is capital which is almost everything that isn't a teacher or a salary so it's your stuff and under the Arizona Constitution our Supreme Court has held it is the state's obligation to adequately fund the capital needs of all public schools and uh this case follows up on a case that actually was decided 30 years years ago where the Supreme Court threw out the way Arizona funds the capital needs of public schools because it relied so heavily on whether your District could pass bonds and overrides and whether you had the capacity to pass enough bonds and overrides to really take care of your needs and in Arizona the property value between somewhere like Scottdale and somewhere like Glendale is enormous so even if you have the most supportive electorate in the world in Glendale you are

020limited in a way that Scottdale and Sedona and Paradise Valley aren't um limited by the Constitution so the Supreme Court threw out this system and said you can't rely so heavily on property values because it's just not fair to the residents if you don't happen to have a huge property value in your district and property value can be because you have great big Office Buildings in your District it's not just the value of residential property it's everything in the district so you might get lucky have a Nuclear Generating Station in your District you have a huge property value so just by raising the tax a penny or two you can raise a ton of money whereas if you're in a district without without that you can raise taxes by dollars and still not have enough

021to meet all your needs so the Supreme Court threw that out they said our constitution says it's the state's obligation to provide good Capital facilities in every school in Arizona if the local voters want to do something extra once the state has covered all the basics that's okay but State it's your obligation to cover all the basics so they threw it out they told the legislature to fix it the legislature didn't want to but eventually they fixed it and in 1998 they passed something called students first it gave all districts different sources of money that would cover all their Capital needs um it worked for a while um a lot of schools got built a lot of schools got got repaired a lot of new air conditioners new buses all that stuff was done um

022and then what happened well the legislature just started taking away that money and it first it was bit by bit and then by the time we got to the recession Arizona took away more school funding than any other state in the United States um other states also reduced funding but then they restored it in Arizona they didn't restore the funding after the recession it actually got worse and worse through about 2015 1617 and so ultimately we were right back to where we were if you lived in a community that had a ton of bonds you could do well if you lived in a community that struggled um you couldn't and so we sued again and we sued on behalf of four districts um including glendell and the Arizona school boards Association the Arizona educational Association

023and the Arizona School administrators so it actually had both labor the aea and management asba and the same case which just was an indication of how bad it had gotten in response to our case um they did do some good things um they restored one aspect of capital funding but they're a long long way from making the system good again so we sued um in 2017 it's been eight years um the work that has been done in this case not only by the legal team but by Cindy and Mike has been amazing and amazingly difficult um and ultimately after seven years of Discovery taking more than 80 depositions which is taking testimony from people we finally got to trial this last summer um and it wasn't a 60-day trial but it did last a whole

024month um it was very difficult every day over 110 degrees um but Witnesses came from from all over the State of Arizona experts from all over the country and they just talked about the inadequacy of capital funding in Arizona and how it creates vast disparities um between the facilities and creates this have have not system we have a provision in our Constitution that says school funding it's the state's responsibility to provide a general and uniform system whatever uniform means it doesn't mean that people in Sedona can raise taxes by a penny and have 60 times as much as you could raise with that same amount in a district without that wealth um so tons of Discovery tons of problems that came out that districts are dealing with um schools that have outlived their useful life

025um you know inability to replace buses uh all kinds of different things leaky roofs air conditioners that don't work we got to trial um the the state stopped defending the case but the legislature is trying to defend the case the state ultimately kind of threw up its hands and said we're not going to defend this anymore but the legislative leaders had different lawyers and Witnesses none of which ever worked in a school um to come and say everything's fine and stop complaining and everything is the district's fault and if you just use the system better it might take you 10 years to get your problem fixed but eventually it will be fixed our position is a child only gets one chance to be a third grader saying we're going to fix this problem in 10

026years is not okay every child deserves good facilities and we are super grateful um to Glendale to our other clients um to let us bring this case on behalf of every student in Arizona every teacher in Arizona and every District where we are right now so trial was this past summer um this is unlike a jury trial where last day of trial you find out if you won or lost this is a trial to a judge and so after the case after the trial is over we do what's called postt trial briefing so we submitted to the judge a closing argument back in October and what we said here's what we believe the evidence showed um it was close to 400 pages long 1,500 paragraphs of what we say the evidence showed um and then

027just before Christmas the the legislators turned in their closing arguments and what they think the evidence showed and now we have in 25 days on February 17th the last pleading that will be filed in this case it is our rebuttal to the legislative submission then the case will be in the hands of the judge typically a judge resolves a case like this any case in 60 days after all of these pleadings are done so if that happens we're looking at April the case the evidence in this case is massive literally millions of pages of documents so it will not surprise anyone if the judge says I need an extra month or two so somewhere between April May I don't think it would go past may we expect to get a ruling from the judge and

028he will decide whether he believes the system is unconstitutional for the same reasons they threw it out 30 years ago or if he accepts the arguments that the legislative leaders were making any questions any questions from the board I just have a comment it it just incenses me that somebody would actually say it may take you 10 years to fix a problem but that's okay you eventually will I don't know of any building that starts out with a small leak in the roof that magically repairs itself over 10 years it usually gets considerably worse and creates a lot more problems you know there is so much evidence in this case that confirms exactly what you said and there's all these State documents that say if we don't fix these things now if you don't fix

029a leaking roof now not only does the problem not get solved but it causes all this secondary damage and in some of these old facilities you know there's asbestos up there there's insulation there's all kinds of problems that can happen so yeah you're 100% right and the 10year thing like there are districts where they applied for air conditioning instead of swamp in 2009 it's still not done wow there's a district whose water was so toxic that not only could the children not um drink it they couldn't wash their hands in it they had to bring in boiled water and put them in cool ERS and put them outside the bathrooms for kids to wash their hands in it took more than 9 years for that to get fixed and meanwhile in during that nine years

030what else had to be sacrificed oh yeah um it it really is crazy um it's just crazy because it's the most inefficient thing that the state could do if you don't fix problems right away they get worse and then they're more expensive and just inflation from construction if you wait four years to fix a roof even if nothing changed it's going to cost a lot more four years from now and the disparity is great right like the kids if you've got sufficient bond funds to take care of it you fix it before its leaking you have it on a schedule and the state said back in 200 12 oh what we need to do is just put everything on a schedule and then we can fix it before it fails it'll save a ton of

031money didn't happen so and Danny I'd like to say you don't look a day older than 30 years ago I literally you aged well have I I found a document at the center that I signed in 1994 so 31 years I've been working on this so we appreciate as Mr Beren said we couldn't ask for better representation I know um you know we were in court for 30 days but you are still working you work prior to that you're working still with that it takes a toll on you mentally it takes a sacrifice from your family and we do we do admire the work that you've done and your team we are confident we're winning this and we could not do that without your counsel so again thank you Dany we appreciate it thank you

032any other comments from the board I would just like to say thank you I uh uh what a quagmire uh I wouldn't have even known where to start where to go um thank you also thank you for me since I've been in school I I'm the youngest one here on the board I've Been Told let me let me Flex that a little bit I've been told that I've never attended a fully funded public school and that matches the comments that teachers uh principles have made during the whole time I was in school like there was always things to be fixed and never enough money to do it so thank you um I just just have one thing to add and this probably a question best uh for Mr beran um the auditor general this past

033week came out with a risk analysis indicating two areas of high risk for Glenda Elementary School district one of them being the student count which we are quite aware of the other one is the reduction in our capital budget limit Reserve would you say that the what what would you say is the impact on the lack of the capital funding is on that budget limited Reserve Mr President members of the board if you look at when we first started notifying the board of some of those concerns you know I I think that's truly in alignment in other words their risk assessment um at least from our perspective validates everything that we've been saying when you lose students obviously funding decreases um and it creates challenges not only for glendel but for other school districts but

034that's why it was critical that we went to the voters in 2023 and asked for that District additional assistance override so that we could attempt to try to change their analysis um and not just because of their analysis but perhaps even more importantly to provide our students and staff and the various stakeholders with what they need to to operate to function and so I think it's our attempt I do believe you're going to see a little bit of that analysis change when they do the 25 um but that's an ongoing concern and again I think the presentations that we provided in the past align with those concerns but in the end um the state has a responsibility which as legal council has pointed out it's failed to meet that constitutional obligation had it been funding

035or should it be funding that perhaps there would be less of a need to be going to the V voters for those additional um Revenue sources uh Mr President members of the board I don't know if that answered the question but that's but that's uh the response I I just have the feeling that the state is withholding money with the right hand and then slapping us with the left hand because we don't have the money that they're withholding that's that's what it feels like to me um but again thank you for your presentation uh thank you for all the work that you put in of course thank you Mr beran for I know you've put in a lot of hours and Miss Jones you've both put in a lot of hours uh in up on

036the stand and doing uh depositions and all that stuff and giving up uh plenty of time outside of your normal school hours for that so thank you very much for your leadership on that okay moving into reports and information items B school replacement update Miss seata Jones yes we have Lynn Adams with us this evening and Mr Beren if you'll do formal introductions please yes uh Mr President members of the board superintendent seata Jones uh you will know at least Lynn Adams you will you might remember uh her um I just want to just point out what it says on Osborne malin's website about Lynn Adams a strategic a strategic advisor and Confidant to many Arizona Educators uh and we believe that wholeheartedly um Lynn perhaps a side note I met Lynn when I was

037about 19 years old um and I was working for the state and she was uh at the Attorney General's office and um truly valuable information both not only from a statutory perspective and constitutional perspective but also from a public policy perspective and so I always uh enjoy conversations with Lynn um and she does fantastic work so I'll let her provide you an update of where we are thank you uh it's hard to be going second I will be talking about I will call it the younger cousin of the lawsuit that you just heard about here and at the end of my presentation the superintendent is going to tell me that I have also aged very well so um Danny and I were just saying we've known each other for about 35 years it's and and

038I still think of him as we're both young anyway so um so this is going to add to the tale of long lawsuits um something that we thought wasn't going to take very long or this one is not as old as the uh older cousin uh lawsuit that you just heard about but it has taken some twists and turns so um I'm going to give you some dates and some facts so this lawsuit is um a an appeal actually so unlike a lawsuit it's an administrative appeal from a decision made by the school facilities oversight board that's the board that dos out the funding that Dany was just talking about and it lets schools know whether they can replace they have money to replace or to repair so in December 2022 December 15 202 2

0392 the school facilities oversight board decided that glendell would not have funding to replace the buildings at the menend and um Jack campus it denied that funding to us so we filed an administrative appeal which is like a lawsuit but slightly different and here's how it's it's different um the appeal is heard by an administrative law judge um so a judge still but the judge is really acting on behalf of the school facilities oversight board so at the end of the day the judge hears testimony and then makes a recommendation back to the school facilities oversight board the board that's already denied us and has been arguing in front of the judge that they were right um so it's a sort of an odd process but that's where that's sort of the road that we're

040going down here is is again this administrative appeal so after we in March we filed our appeal notice for the next several months we tried to work to settle the matter we were trying to make some overtures to the school facilities oversight board you know let's see if we can do this they they shut us down um they did start they did launch some discussions about what they are calling end of useful life buildings buildings that can't be repaired that need to be replaced so that they started on their own some discussions about these these issues but we were never able to reach an agreement so um January 2024 rolls around so the decision was made in December 2022 we had some hearing dates again we tried to work things through January rolls around and

041we have a hearing coming up it's later in January and we issue a subpoena for Scott Thompson who is um who who works for the Mesa Public Schools he's also on the school facilities oversight board we want him to testify he faces these issues all the time and so we want his Insight he's been on the board for six years and we want his testimony the hearing uh doesn't go forward it had to be continued because of an illness of one of the lawyers um it's rescheduled to June um in March fast forward a little bit and this is relevant the suben is relevant um the school facilities oversight board moves to quash moves to vacate arpen to Scott Thompson um they claim that he since he's a decision maker that they we should not

042be able to get his testimony the judge rules in our favor we think we're going forward the state the school facilities oversight board moves for reconsideration on the reconsideration the judge modifi The subpoena a little bit and says you can't ask him about his thought process for making a decision but you can ask him about his work on behalf of Mesa he used to work for this Arizona Department of Education you can ask him all those um he manages facilities for again for Mesa for the biggest Public School in District in Arizona all these things are relevant and by the way Mesa now can't pass bonds so they're going to have to face some tough issues so you can ask him about all of that we continue to get ready um for hearing we're going

043to go for we're going to we have a hearing in June at this point our hearing set in June right before the hearing we were actually preparing your superintendent and Mr veran for their testimony we get notified that the school facilities oversight board is going to appeal the decision again from the from the judge so they file what's called a special action appeal which goes to the Superior Court um we um we we agree to to stay our hearing we want to we want to get this issue um figured out we agree to stay the hearing um the school facilities oversight board drags their feet again they've let us know in June they're going to file this July comes around nothing's been filed all of June nothing's been filed July comes around so in early

044August we asked the court to set the hearing dates we're like they said they were going to file this but they haven't um they finally file at the end of August the school facilities oversight board files something with the with the Superior Court we brief it fully and we win um so we were right um and November 8th the court rules in our favor and says the subpoena can move forward with the limitations that the court had already made it's good we also ask for our attorney fees and we get awarded our attorney's fees so we get awarded over $30,000 in our fees for their special action we're ready to move forward right now we have April hearing dates that we've been working on um so we are ready to move forward um we're going

045to push forward but um we ask the court are the judge in the lower court the appeal the administrative appeal um to move forward with these dates and the the um State argues that they should wait until we're done with all the appeals um so we could either agree to move forward with the hearing without any testimony from Scott Thompson or we could agree to move forward with the hearing take all the testimony wait and then see how the the how the decision turns out and then maybe months later take some testimony from Scott Thompson we decided we wanted to do neither of those we wanted to have all of the hearing testimony presented at the same time so that the judge could then quickly make a decision so we have we we decided to

046continue to stay the matter until because those were not good options for us so we stayed the matter last week the school facilities oversight board informed us that they're going to seek another appeal from the superior Court they're going to move to the court of appeals and ask for an appeal of this issue um so um we don't know how quickly that's going to move we continue to feel very strongly about um our our position and our decision to have Scott Thompson testify they're obviously um throwing up a lot of roadblocks to that um so we're going to continue to do that and again if we Prevail in this next appeal we'll ask them for some more attorneys fees with interest acre at 8% every month so we'll continue to try to seek that on

047your behalf um just I've I've indicated why we want Scott Thompson to testify um the state again says he's a decision maker you can't we don't want him to testify um we we believe that that the guard rails have been appro apprpriate so we don't have new dates for our hearing yet again we actually do right now have April dates they haven't been vacated but it's pretty clear it's not going to move forward in v in April um after the appeal to the court of appeals the next Avenue for the school facilities oversight board to continue to delay this because let's be honest that's appears to be what they're doing um is uh is a petition for review to the Arizona Supreme Court those are not great granted very often but it's hard to say

048whether it would be in this case or not looking because we don't have an order to look at to to see what would be appealed um so again it's unclear how long much longer this is going to take but it is clear that the school facilities oversight board is delaying um and doing what it can to delay our appeal here I just want to tell you a couple other things that we've tried we really have tried and by me um and we I really mean Mr Baran and your superintendent have worked really hard with us to try to to resolve this more quickly without the need for an appeal um one of the issues that we feel that we're facing is that we don't agree with the legal advice that the school facilities oversight board

049is getting about their um about the the statutes just not a not a secret obviously I'm telling you in public here um we don't agree with the way they've interpreted the statutes so we attempted to write a memo analyzing the statutes we submitted it to the Attorney General's office for review we thought if we could get Beyond this lawyer that's providing advice to the school facilities oversight board and have other lawyers in the Attorney General's office look at it that might move us forward because we had a pending appeal the Attorney General's office declined to do that but we provided our analysis and we provided it to the school facilities oversight board members too so that they could see that statutes did provide a way forward for what we were asking for we also arranged

050for the school facility oversight board's executive director toour the Jack and men's campus without legal counsel so she could take a look at the buildings um and and see for herself what needed to be replaced what needed to be changed why we were asking for funding to to build the new buildings um she did the tour we were supposed to have a settlement conference after and they cancelled the settlement conference after after so we were never able to move forward with that but we were able to at least do the tour but our idea was let's have them tour let's have them see it for themselves and then we can sit down and talk about some practical ways forward here um we have and will continue to provide comments to the school facilities oversight board

051whenever they're doing new policies we provide our input you know they know both me and Mike now um and we'll continue to do that and provide comments during public comment to try to again our our view is we really need to talk to the board members themselves um and to to express as clearly as we can why our position is an appropriate position if we have to go forward with the appeal we obviously will but in the interest of not only um saving money for the district on legal fees but really to try to move it forward to the to the issue we just talked about um about time is delay is not good delay is no one's friends especially especially students and teachers and staff so we've really been trying to think creatively about

052how we can deal with this issue without having to move forward with the appeal because after after this administrative appeal it can go back to court we can go through more appeals so um we're doing our best to resolve it but again we're we've really been faced with delay after delay after delay at every turn um and um we we'll continue to fight the good fight so do you have any good any questions for me any questions or comments from the board I guess at this point I'd like to know are you allowed to take them to court for stalling it like this over and over and over again unfortunately not but the thing we can do um we figured out a way to get attorney's fees like I said um I the attorney's fees

053have to come out of the agency's budget and so the more um we can make them have pain in some way for their delay I know that sounds horrible but that's you know we usually you don't get attorney's fees and we found a statute that allowed us to get attorney's fees um I'll tell you they even argued against the fact that we won they claimed that we did not win at the Superior Court the judge did not even just batted that down and said of course they won they got you did not get anything you asked for school facilities oversight board the district got everything they asked for which was keep things the same they won so you know I I was hoping that the threat of additional attorney fees which will be more expensive

054for them on a expanded appeal would um convince them not to not to further appeal but unfortunately that wasn't the case but we're trying to we're trying to think of ways to how can we get them not to delay um again we've tried to push them we've tried to push the the administrative law judge um to move forward with the hearing but in terms of you know our analysis we want the hearing testimony to come in all at the same time I think it's more it will be more impactful for the judge to hear everyone at the same time hear our Witnesses which are your superintendent and Mr baragan to hear them talk about the issues and the school and the needs than to have you know maybe a six-month Gap in hearing that and

055then hearing one witness at the end your memory just isn't the same and I think it loses that emotional impact thank you anybody else Mr G Jones yes presid yes president Martinez members of the board thank you ly uh very very much for that and you don't look a day over 30 so I oh my gosh I can't believe that came out of nowhere um because we continue to face with sfob the can delay after delay after delay we still in glendell elementary school district have buildings that do need do not meet minim minimum adequate um standards and guidelines we still have to do repairs we have repairs that sop will not fund because they've declared our buildings um have outlived their useful life I think that we need to be prepared with and ask

056for some specific strategies on how we move forward with sfob and I would not want that you know I'd like to do that in executive session um this evening please thank you moving on in our agenda we don't have any action items tonight uh so we will move into future meetings um that are coming up Miss Jones yes okay the next um we have our February board retreat and that will be on Saturday we did we determine a time on that 9 to 12 I think it I think it was 9: because nobody wanted to get up okay N 9 to 12 and we've the board has has submitted some topics um Mr Martinez I also we've talked about doing um Financial solvency and presentation just on um basic 101 Finance with as we see

057what's happening in surrounding areas that would be a good discussion for us and um also any other items you'd like to [Music] see yes I I'm looking forward to that uh one of the things you know with all the news that's been happening lately uh a question I asked myself is is there anything that the board could have done or is there anything that the board could have seen or or is there a point of view that that would that would have helped that would help a board avert financial crisis at a school district um so we as part of the as part of the board retreat we're going to have a little Financial liter literacy 101 uh for school Finance so that should be fun uh I know we have a couple other topics

058on there but uh but uh make sure you you take your Five Hour Energy before you show up because uh School Finance can be a very dull topic to sit through even though Mike absolutely loves it and probably has pajamas with dollar signs on it almost guaranteed um so I I'm looking forward to that and getting together and kind of going through everything with you guys and with that also we have then the next meeting would be the 13th and that's when we will do the administrative and Psych as contract renewals and then salary placement tables as well I I do have a agenda item request um I would like to see us update policy regarding law enforcement and potential like uh law enforcement agents coming into the schools and asking about status I just

059want to make sure that we remain a district that is inclusive and that our students staff and our families U know that we're keeping them safe in full accordance with the the law of course and uh yeah I think that's a a very timely topic um I know we we have a policy regarding law enforcement with some of the recent changes I I don't know whether it goes far enough but everything seems to change day by day depending on which news feed you read and who you believe and and what's going to happen um I'll just throw it out there trust no Newsfeed picks or it doesn't happen literally everybody has a cell phone there are millions of cameras out there that's why that's why no one's found Bigfoot yet and no one Bigfoot doesn't

060exist because we would have gotten a picture of them already so um we're going to I think it's a good idea to talk through the process and and I think uh we should will'll probably end up having to call um legal counsel and to give us some guidance and then I would also like to see if if uh policy services at asba um have anything in the works right now uh regarding updated policy guidance for school districts we've been working with all day today and continue to as as well as the other organizations and uh legal um has several legal um firms have been sending us information it is a very fluid topic right now you saw some of those orders Chang today so we will stay on top of that and then we can

061put that as a discussion item what we would probably do ahead of time is um send information to you in a board um up update and so that you can have that information then we can have that healthy discussion um at at the next board meeting if um if that's all right February 13th absolutely thank you all right if there's nothing else we're going to move on to the summary of current events I know it's only been two weeks since our last meeting but that's like 14 weeks in dog weeks um because this has been the longest year ever uh so mrata Jones if you can give us a little update uh yes I want to thank um the artwork in the back from Challenger and Sunset Vista it's always great to see student work

062uh we've had our two spelling bees have taken place we had our Spanish our first ever that I'm aware of Spanish spelling be took place today and so we were excited about that and congratulations to our winners February 7th will be we will host the regional spelling be here um district office so we are excited about that last night was or no last week sometime was Tech night Tech night was great it was over 360 some families attended it was incredible there are so many things thank you for teachers and staff and families for coming out for that I enjoyed that last night was gifted night uh again uh we had a lot of our families out thank you to teachers and staff a lot of things I snap pictures of things I'm going to

063do with my grandchildren to keep them busy it was really well attended and some just great great things going on and we thank the community basketball season is underway right now and that's always an exciting time for us uh we look forward to Champion uh ships and get to debut our new basketball with our logo so we're excited about that 100th day um celebration we have a video we're going to sh in a little bit about that that was yesterday um job fair is Saturday here at district office we're excited about that um so we'll HR is ready to go and we hope we get a lot of candidates with that and and we've been doing some Geo fencing in some areas where we think we might you know people might need jobs so we've

064been doing that as well um executive orders yes as I said earlier executive orders have have come out uh we've sent out statements you should you were receiving statements today I just you know we are trying we work with legal council uh we try to send out the most current information as it is in the moment and what best meets the needs of our community and so we will continue continue to do that as well and with that I'm going to turn it over to Adana and gladus has the 100th day video from yesterday [Music] w [Music] [Applause] those were the hundred days and uh Mar soul is she here did she leave I told her she should stay for the video um no she had to leave um yeah that was the best makeup

065ever she had I asked if she could I said how'd you do that she said make it and I said said can you make him go away you know and uh so because I wanted mine to go away but uh it was great it was great um to see I was out and thank you to Discovery for letting me I was some places interrupted classrooms at Discovery I think Horizon I Was A disruption there as well but it was nice to see kids and they were engaged in the 100 Day activities and it just makes kids and families feel good so we always look forward to the 100th day yes we do know it's a big day and Mr Baran had his dollar socks on I'm sure yesterday but um you know we always want

066to take you know the opportunity to celebrate the H 100th day it just makes kids feel old and happy and so um but 100 day smarter and as I said to others I'm a 100 days grayer I'm sure but you know it's all for our students and our community that we love so dearly so with that that concludes my [Music] report all right thank you busy couple weeks uh we'll start with the Govern board report um down at the endend Miss Bartel usually the person that starts doesn't get to say ditto to anything ahead of time but but I you know I was able to attend the tech night which was incredibly attended those kids and the parents were all just having a great time with the technology that we have available in our district

067was able to attend the gifted night last night and some just great projects that our kids and their families can work with um I think this was the first time ever that indirectly I was on a campus for the hundredth Day celebration so as a quani and reading to a classroom so it gave me an excuse to order 100 day of school t-shirt so I got to show that off yesterday and dress appropriately when I read to the classes um it's just always so exciting to see you know what our staffs are doing with our kids and and the interaction between everybody um so thank you all for everything that you guys do every day um just a reminder we have Market on the Move this Saturday over at the system of Care Center so

068I'll be there pregn early all right thank you m Bortel Miss Pento I love the 100th day and uh I don't know that it was such a big celebration when my kids were in school but I remember it was important and sometimes when I talk to parents they don't realize the importance and and what it's all about so and I love seeing that and I want a Valentine's Day card with Mr baran's picture on it I love that picture so um we've seen that as him as Cupid not so much okay maybe maybe uh St Patrick's Day could do that one too maybe he can find us a pot of gold he's good at that um thank you for the updates on the lawsuit and the building that has been something that has it predates

069me actually being on the board and um I remember conversations at that time where are you sure you want to do this and I said absolutely every child deserves every single child deserves to be in a safe place in a safe building with things that are not taped together things that are not posters over holes and that is not we we're not pointing fingers at each other here we know where the fault lies and it's not anybody in this room and it's not anybody who was employed here it is the legislature so um I'm going to uh continue to do my part to urge them to do their jobs and give our students and all the students of Arizona what they deserve and lastly um it's an interesting climate right now and I'm talking to

070parents and talking and hearing from teachers who are relaying to me the fears of their families of their students and I would like to um reiterate that as a person as a parent as a community member I am here for every single person I am truly in Allin for all kids and that's our motto and and we are not going to step away from that so please know that as a as a board member and I can only speak for myself but I I feel good about the rest of everybody on this diet days we are happy to have your children here and your families and we're going to do everything we can to make sure that our community is educated all right thank you uh Mr Haram uh ditto uh I don't know how

071to follow up with that but yeah I wholeheartly agree with um board member Pimentel um when I volunteered to do this job um it was with the community in mind I had people reach out to me asking me to do this and took a took a month or two of convincing me but ultimately I said said yes because I care about the kids of my community I care about my neighbors I care about Educators and I want to make sure that we are inclusive we make sure our families feel safe our staff um because the second we stop letting them know that hey like we're not going to keep you safe that's that's when we're failing as a district so like Monica I believe and I I'm going to do everything in my power to

072make sure sure that we we keep it that way that we keep excelling and keep uh keep our kiddos uh happy and and um making sure that we also prevent The Bullying that is probably going to uh follow pretty soon with the rhetoric happening at the national level thank you all right thank you thank you no no hello all right um just want to say thank you to uh both our guests this evening for your legal advice uh you both have that Benjamin buttons disease so you look like you're aging backwards so I'm sure by the time these lawsuits are done you will be babies yes um he Hector maybe can we can borrow some car seats and stuff next time you're around in case we need to furry him to court and such like

073that so um thank you for for all the hard work um congratulations on everyone on getting through the 100th day it seems like it just kind of snuck up on us um I would like to personally apologize to all the Nanas and tatas that were stuck on the couch because their kids stole their cane and their Walker to take the school um it was only for a day and you guys weren't going anywhere anyway so just just just chill you're you're good um take your rest but uh uh as the last board meeting in board member appreciation month uh I would just like to again reiterate that my thanks uh for the board that I happen to sit up here with um Maran I hope you're feeling better soon Brenda Monica Hector uh thank you

074all uh we couldn't have done any of this without you um your support for the school district is absolutely unwavering and the diversity we have amongst the board because we all come from different backgrounds and we all know different things and we're able to bring that to the table we're able to bring that up here at the deas um thank you we are a better board because of it because of it uh and I appreciate and I look forward to finishing out the rest of the year serving with you guys who'll finish the puzzles Brenda the rest of you didn't do your puzzles yet yeah no cookies for you I did it on the way home at at that stoplight on Grand waiting for the train all right uh with that we will at this

075time the governing board will consider voting to recess the regular meeting in order to convene to Executive session for the following purposes in accordance with Arizona revised Statute 38- 43103 A3 and Arizona by Statute 38 43103 A4 for discussion and consultation with the attorneys of the public body to obtain legal advice and consider its position and instruct its attorneys regarding the public body's position related to pending litigation in CV 2017-6 n75 also in accordance with Arizona revised Statute 38 43103 A3 and Arizona revised Statute 38 43103 A4 for discussion consultation with the attorneys of the public body to obtain legal advice and consider its position and instruct its attorneys regarding the public body's position relating to pending litigation 23 f-0001 dadm and CV 2024 d231 also in accordance with Arizona revised statutes 38 43103 A5

076for the purpose of consultation or instruction to designate Representatives as to negotiation regarding salaries or compensation in the form of benefits for District employees is there a motion to to recess to Executive session I move that we go into executive session for the three items listed no only for two the first one we are not oh wait what what we have three B and C we will not go into executive session for Capital lawsuit we'll go into executive session for sfob and the meeting conver right so the very first one you can just amend the motion to not include that one okay I would like to amend my motion not to include item 98 is there a second second Miss Bartel how do you vote I miss Pentel how do you vote I Mr hadam

077how do you vote I and the chair votes I we are now an executive session sir Administration there is no action item coming out of EX executive session you are free to go thank you for your work how do I feel so old getting out of this chair yeah there's no action items when we come back I think we know we have to recv and let's just come out here let's I I I know what you're saying but let's just be transparent and we'll come out here e e e chair is even C is there a oh Jesus Christ u is there a motion to return to regular session I'll move to return to regular session second Miss Bartell how do you vote I miss Pentel how do you vote I Mr Haro how do

078you vote I okay and chair votes I is there a motion to adjourn move to adjourn second all those in favor I I thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.